As the Papers Told It

Lizzie Borden · The full archive

July 1893

119 articles

The Osceola Times · Osceola, Ark.

Reports that Lizzie Borden's daily mail is extraordinary, with over 100 letters delivered to her home in one morning, many from Christian Endeavor and W.C.T.U. society members. Marshal Hilliard and Mayor Coughlin are also receiving numerous vile and threatening letters related to the case.

The Osceola Times · 1 July 1893 · page 2

F*tj. Rivm Masis . June xi —Lizzie ; Borden's daily mail i* sccnething exJ traordinarr. at least .t-Xi letters being . taken into her home yesterday mom । ing by the lone man resident at the

See the clipping

The Washington Bee · Washington, D.C.

After her acquittal, Lizzie Borden has moved back into her Second Street home with her sister Emma, reportedly determined to identify the real murderer. Her lawyer says she may leave Fall River to rest, while jury foreman Charles Richards describes a lighthearted bet among jurors before their verdict was reached.

The Washington Bee · 1 July 1893 · page 1

HUNTING THE BORDEN MURDERER

ders. Nevertheless, he says, Miss Liz zie Borden and her sister will leave no stone unturned to discover, if pos sible, who the murderers are. The hunt is already on and will continue. Of Lizzie Borden's plans for the future he says he knows little, but thinks it probable that she may leave the city

See the clipping

The Washington Bee · Washington, D.C.

Jury foreman Richards recounts how the panel decided to vote on the first ballot, with one juror paying for drinks to speed agreement. He states the verdict was based on evidence, and that the prosecution failed to prove its case against Lizzie Borden.

The Washington Bee · 1 July 1893 · page 1

A Lizzie Borden Case. St. Louis, Mo., is to have a murder trial after the New Bedford pattern. Maud McKibben, eighteen, has been arrested for poisoning her father and sister, Mrs. Stewart. An autopsy showed that both had died from the effects of strychnine. Maud tried to purchase both arsenic and strychnine a few days before the meal was eaten

See the clipping

The Washington Bee · Washington, D.C.

Lizzie and Emma Borden have moved back into their old Fall River residence. They plan to pursue, with legal and detective help, the identification of their father and stepmother's true murderer.

The Washington Bee · 1 July 1893 · page 1

River Falls, Wis., just over the Min nesota line, lightning struck the centre-pole of the circus tent of Ringling Brothers. Seven people were killed instantly and quite a number injured, none of the latter fatally. Miss Lizzie Borden and her sister

See the clipping

The Washington Bee · Washington, D.C.

A roundup of brief news items includes a one-line note that Lizzie Borden is receiving numerous marriage proposals through the mail. The item appears amid unrelated briefs on flooding, politics, and society news.

The Washington Bee · 1 July 1893 · page 4

TELEGRAPHIC BRIEFS. i Lizzie Borden is receiving many of fers of marriage by mail. The crevasse at Rescue Break, near New Orleans, was enlarging at the lat est accounts, and had attained a width

See the clipping

The Pacific Commercial Advertiser · Honolulu, Hawaiian Islands

The report states that Lizzie Borden, accused of killing her father and stepmother with a hatchet, has been acquitted after a multi-week trial in which the prosecution failed to prove its charges. The jury, following the judge's instructions, found her not guilty, though the crime remains unsolved as to who committed it.

The Pacific Commercial Advertiser · 1 July 1893 · page 5

The words of this article could not be separated from the rest of its page. Read it in the clipping.

No page image survives for this article

Western Kansas World · Wakeeney, Kan.

A jury in New Bedford, Massachusetts returned a verdict of acquittal in the Lizzie Borden murder trial. The verdict was greeted with cheers in the courtroom, which were quickly suppressed.

Western Kansas World · 1 July 1893 · page 6

The Jury Says "Not Guilty." New Bedford, Mass., June 22. The jury returned a verdict of acquittal in the Lizzie Borden case. The verdict was received with cheers, which were quickly suppressed.

See the clipping

The Opelousas Courier · Opelousas, La.

The jury that heard testimony against Lizzie Borden, accused of murdering her father and stepmother in Fall River, Mass., declared her innocent of the double crime. The verdict states the evidence was insufficient to establish her guilt.

The Opelousas Courier · 1 July 1893 · page 4

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

See the clipping

The L'anse Sentinel · L'anse, L.S., Mich.

The report describes the jury's 'not guilty' verdict in the Lizzie Borden trial, with Borden breaking into tears upon hearing the decision. Spectators cheered, defense attorneys Jennings and Adams reacted emotionally, and Borden was eventually escorted away and given time to recover her composure before being placed in a carriage.

The L'anse Sentinel · 1 July 1893 · page 6

LIZZIE BORDEN FREE. The Jury I)raJrr Tliat Mi Is Nut (iuilly. JJew r?rrKonr, Mass., June C2. "Not guilty Miss Korden's head went down upon the rail in front of her and tears came

See the clipping

The L'anse Sentinel · L'anse, L.S., Mich.

After the judge's charge to the jury and Lizzie Borden's brief statement proclaiming her innocence, the courtroom proceedings concluded with her being freed. She was then taken to a private room before departing by carriage and train back to Fall River.

The L'anse Sentinel · 1 July 1893 · page 6

LIZZIE BORDEN FREE.

near approach of the end At the conclusion of the district at torney's address, the chief justice ad dressed Mis Borden by name, telling her that she now had a voice and could say to the jury what she choose to say. She arose, somewhat agitated, and said to the jury: "I am innocent, but I will leave my case in your hands and in the hands of my counsel." Judge Dewey charged the jury. He read his charge rapidly, and among other things embodied therein at as the caution to take a decision only upon the law and the evidence. The court defined the degrees of murderand said the degree was to be determined by the Jury.

See the clipping

The White Pine News · Treasure City, Nev.

The report states that the famous trial of Lizzie Borden at New Bedford, Massachusetts has concluded with her acquittal. It is mentioned briefly among a collection of other unrelated news items.

The White Pine News · 1 July 1893 · page 2

The famous trial of Lizzie Borden at New Bedford (Mass.) has termina ted in the acquittal of the defendant. The mints of India are to stop the coinage of silver. This is what is knocking down the white metal.

See the clipping

San Antonio Daily Light · San Antonio, Tex.

The Galveston Tribune is quoted suggesting the Lizzie Borden murder mystery may never be solved unless someone confesses, sarcastically noting police exhausted their efforts trying to convict her 'who happened to be innocent.' The comment reflects lingering public skepticism about the verdict even after her acquittal.

San Antonio Daily Light · 1 July 1893 · page 12

Mie Borden murder may never be 'Cleared up. The New Bedford po lice can not be expected to do any more. They exhausted all their energies trying to convict Lizzie Borden, who happened to be inno

See the clipping

Mineral Point Tribune · Mineral Point, Wis.

A brief news digest item reports that Lizzie Borden was declared not guilty of murdering her father and stepmother. The jury deliberated for only an hour and a half before reaching the verdict.

Mineral Point Tribune · 1 July 1893 · page 2

gone to Buzzard's Bay. Dr. J. I>. Bry ant, Die family physician, accompanied them to New York. Lizzie Borden was declared guiltless i of the murder of her father and step

See the clipping

Mineral Point Tribune · Mineral Point, Wis.

A filler quote from the Commercial Advertiser remarks sarcastically that prosecutors only managed to prove two elderly, respectable people were brutally murdered. It implies the case against Lizzie Borden lacked real evidence of her guilt.

Mineral Point Tribune · 1 July 1893 · page 7

Commercial Advertiser: All that Lizzie Borden's prosecutors have been able to prove Is that two elderly and worthy people were murdered in u shockingly brutal manner.

See the clipping

The New Dominion · Morgantown, W. Va.

A general commentary piece reflects on recent national events, including the World's Fair controversy and the conclusion of the Lizzie Borden trial. The mention is brief, grouped with other news of the moment like Eulalie's visit and the fair's Sunday opening.

The New Dominion · 1 July 1893 · page 2

Sunday the Lizzie Borden trial is over and Eulalie snubbed our snobs and returned home in glory the country ean sit down, fan itself and

See the clipping

St. Paul Daily Globe · Saint Paul, Minn.

The report reflects on former Governor Robinson's closing argument for Lizzie Borden's defense, noting his plain, conversational style rather than dramatic oratory. It argues this disappointed public expectation but convinced the jury, reflecting a broader decline of flamboyant courtroom eloquence.

St. Paul Daily Globe · 2 July 1893 · page 4

THE EFFECTIVE SPEAKER. The trial of Lizzie Borden attracted the attention of the nation by its mys tery. All the actors in it knew that the nation was gazing at them. The law yers in tlie case felt the value of the op portunity for fame it gave them. Ex jGoy.'■"; Robinson was of counsel tor the accused. He made the closing speech to the jury. Public expectation was on edge. It thought to be sated with a grand oratorical display, It was felt o be such an opportunity as Dough erty in his day or IXGEBSOU*.

See moreSee less

would' have made the greatest effort of their lives in. We may be sure that they would have utilized it to electrify.- and captivate and sweep away wijh them (he com t aud jury aud audience, all .

See the clipping

Richmond Dispatch · Richmond, Va.

A letter to the editor theorizes that the Borden murders were committed in daylight because the father was 'always present at night,' suggesting the father's killing was an afterthought. The writer moralizes on parental disobedience and professes confidence the State Attorney shares his view of the case.

Richmond Dispatch · 2 July 1893 · page 11

How an innocent, tender-hearted daugh ter conld voluntarily seek a night's repose in a house where she witnessod such sights as we read of in the Borden home I can't understand with my knowledge of the operations (especially) of a woman's brain, 1t 1s carious, physiologically, how vivid and lasting are some impressions upon this organ. I have a remarkable case in wy own experience too lengthy for recital, and 1 am not at all nervous. Law; ors wisely pay great attention to the (na. tural) behavior of criminals. Their con.

See moreSee less

duet after, as well as before, trial has always been interesting te me. Beecher's conduct after his trial satisfied | me of the character of the man. Nature 18 true to harself if carefully watched for atime. 1 have always been & great be. lever in * post-mortems,” ‘They teach us often more “at a glance” than the three wonths' consultations of a half dozen doc. tors. And we know the valne of what 1

See the clipping

The Roanoke Times · Roanoke, Va.

A brief item reports that Mrs. Mary A. Livermore expects Lizzie Borden to visit her as a guest at her home in Melrose, Massachusetts. The report is framed explicitly as unconfirmed rumor.

The Roanoke Times · 2 July 1893 · page 3

Humor About li//i< Horden. Boston. July 1.?It is said that Mrs. Maty A. Li vermore expects to receive Miss Lizzie Borden soon as her guest at her home in Melrose, Mass.

See the clipping

Illinois Staats-Zeitung · Chicago, Ill.

A satirical German-language commentary lists examples of criminals achieving fame and fortune, including Lizzie Borden being invited by the St. Louis Globe-Democrat to tour as a public reader. It claims she instead chose to travel incognito to Europe rather than cash in on her notoriety at home.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

Illinois Staats-Zeitung · 3 July 1893 · page 2

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

See the clipping

The Waco Evening News · Waco, Tex.

A brief filler note claims Lizzie Borden receives numerous marriage proposals through the mail, suggesting fortune-seeking suitors have learned of her inheritance. It is presented as a humorous aside rather than hard news.

The Waco Evening News · 3 July 1893 · page 2

It ia said tho mails carry to Miss Lizzie Borden quite a number of offers of marriage. Tho impecu noous wife hunters have learned tho sizo of hor pile. That extra session is a regular God-send to tho hotel pooplo in Washington.

See the clipping

The Hawaiian Gazette · Honolulu, Hawaii

The report announces that Lizzie Borden has been acquitted of the murder of her father and stepmother after a weeks-long trial. It notes the prosecution failed to prove its charges, and the crime remains unsolved despite extensive detective work, as it occurred in broad daylight with Borden nearby.

The Hawaiian Gazette · 4 July 1893 · page 3

Lizzie Borden Acquitted. The famous Borden murder case, in which Lizzie Borden, of Fall Eiver, Mass., was accused of slaying her father and stepmother with a hatchet, and which has occupied tho attention of the whole country for many months past, has finally been settled, so far as the guilt of the woman is concerned. The trial has been in progress several weeks, and it was expected that ihe State had a case which 'no defense could withstand ; but, when the evidence was all in, it was found that the government bad proved nothing of its charges, and the jury, in accordance with the instructions of the court, promptly acquitted tho defendant.

See moreSee less

The crime is one of the most mysterious in the annals of this country, and the best detective ability has been unable to unravel it or get a real cine, notwithstanding it was committed in broad daylight in a

See the clipping

St. Paul Daily Globe · Saint Paul, Minn.

The report notes that Lizzie Borden and her sister still live in the old Fall River homestead but are bothered by intrusive strangers and may seek another house. It denies published rumors that they intend to travel to Europe.

CorrectionThis set right an article from the day before.

St. Paul Daily Globe · 4 July 1893 · page 5

Lizzie Borden and her sister continue to live in the old homestead at Fall River, but they are so much annoyed by curious and impertinent strangers that they mean to secure another house

See the clipping

The Breckenridge News · Cloverport, Ky.

This article reports that Lizzie Borden was acquitted at her murder trial in New Bedford, Mass., after being charged with killing her father and step-mother. It discusses the prosecution's theory of a property-motivated murder and notes the evidence was largely gossip and petty remarks, insufficient to prove guilt.

The Breckenridge News · 5 July 1893 · page 2

LIZZIE BORDEN'S CASE, A Romarkabio Murder Trial That Now England Watchod With interest. A Chapter of Horrors the Police Attempted to Weave About Tho

See the clipping

The Silver State · Unionville, Nev.

A roundup of brief news items mentions that Lizzie Borden spent ten months in jail, alongside other trivia. It also sarcastically asks what becomes of Fall River policemen promoted for pinning the Borden murder on her, now that she has been acquitted.

The Silver State · 5 July 1893 · page 3

NEWS NOTES.

Several Fall River policemen were pmnoted last year, for efficient ser vice in fastening the Borden murder upon Lizzie Borden. What is to be come of them now? Five months ago a bail boy in Pittsburg jabbed an elephant’s trunk with a nail on the end of a stick. Recently the same boy visited the Zoo, and the elephant came near kill ing him. A sensation was created in a New York Catholic church by the priest denouncing a member of the con gregation from the pulpit for deceiv ing him by getting him to wed her to a Protestant.

See moreSee less

John A. Botzum, who has gone around the world from Akron, Ohio, walking whenever possible, wore out twentv-seven pairs of shoes in his 2-year jaunt, besides sandals, which i he used in the East. George Jones and “Rattlesnake Pete.” two contestants in the cow boy race, claim that Berry, Albright, Gillespie and Smith, the first four men in, rode in cars at night during the race and shipped their horses. ;

See the clipping

Pawtucket Tribune · Pawtucket, R.I.

Following her acquittal in the New Bedford trial, Lizzie Borden has returned to her Fall River home but finds herself besieged by curious onlookers and reporters. Mrs. Livermore, a supporter, describes the impossibility of arranging a private visit due to the intense public scrutiny surrounding Borden.

Pawtucket Tribune · 5 July 1893 · page 1

SHE SEEKS PRIVACY.

BosTON, July 5. —The tide of sympathy and fiiendliness toward Miss Lizzie Bor den is now ot its height. The heroine of the terrible ordeal of the New Bedford trial has now returned to quiet life and the round of household dutfes in her Fall River home, and desires nothing so strougly than that she may be forgotten by the new:papers and left in peace by the curions. : The proposed visit to Mrs. Livermore at Melrose some time dnring the summer has caused the descent of a horde of inter viewers upon Mprs.

See moreSee less

Livermore's doorstep to discover the details of the visit, a Post reporter among them, “I don’t suppose,”’ suid Mrs. Livermore, meditatively, “that I could smuggle Lizzie Borden in here at midnight without the reporters finding it out before the frout

See the clipping

Pawtucket Tribune · Pawtucket, R.I.

The report quotes a friend relaying Lizzie Borden's reflections after her acquittal, including letters of support and accusation she receives, and her ongoing sadness despite freedom. It also notes plans to sell the Borden homestead and move due to painful memories and public intrusion.

Pawtucket Tribune · 5 July 1893 · page 1

DAYS OF HAPPINESS GONE.

many sad cases, “Then lam still receiving letters abont the Borden ease—some blaming me for my fnterest in Miss Borden, some from people evidently morbid from dwelling on the horrors and mystery of the erime, those who have dreamed dreams and have theo rics, and many from people who have believed all along in her innocence and re*:-loe in her nequittal, ‘Oh! yes; Lizzie Borden is not without friends. She writes me that they have been so assiduous in their attentions, so kind and carcful of her in every way that she has had hardly time to herself for the routine of daily work, and Is just now be gnuing to tuke up the little household duties.

See moreSee less

Her health is better and she is be ginning to sleep naturally at night, but as she told me with a great deal of pathos: ‘I realize that I can never be light-hearted agiin’'” ThHe arrang-ments for the purchase of a new house in Fall River are not yet com pleted. The Borden homestead has natur ally many painful assocations for both sisters, and they are anxious to be gone from it and from vhe hostile neighbors and peeping sightseers who find a morbid in terest in visiting the cene of the world famous traged .

See the clipping

The Abbeville Press and Banner · Abbeville, S.C.

The jury at New Bedford quickly found Lizzie Borden not guilty after a thirteen-day trial for the murder of her father and stepmother. The courtroom erupted in applause as the verdict was read, and Borden returned to Fall River as the guest of a local banker.

The Abbeville Press and Banner · 5 July 1893 · page 2

LIZZIE BORDEN SET FREE. THE JURY SPEEDILY DECLARE HER NOT GUILTY.

Borden ra acquitted by the jury which tried her at New Bedford, Mass., on tho charge of murdering her father and stopmother. She was almost overcomo when the verdict wa3 read, and men and women cheered tho findins*. Miss Borden returned to Fall River, where she became the guest of Banker Irenes. It had been a fearful day in court, a day of keen suffering for everybody, for the heat was intense. For tho prisoner it was tho most trying of all her ordeals, for she was forced to sit and listen for more than three hours while Mr.

See moreSee less

Knowlton with all the power of his eloquence sought to forge tight upon her the rivets of the government's chaim of circumstantial evidence. Court came in promptly at 0 o'olock ; the jury was polled and the District Attorney picked up the thread of his argument where he had dropped it. He congratulated the jury upon the near approaoh of the end. The counsel .who opened the cause Jor the defence had said that motive was a part of

See the clipping

Connecticut Western News · Salisbury, Conn.

The report states that Emma and Lizzie Borden have purchased a new house in the most fashionable part of Fall River. It notes their old home was now too ghastly for them to continue living in after the murders.

Connecticut Western News · 6 July 1893 · page 3

Mrs Hammond of the W. R. C. The monument is 01 granite and is surmounted by the figure of a private soldier. The "square sides above the bases bear fitting inscription s and names of soldiers and sailors. It was a red letter day for' New Hart ford, the biggest time the town has ever seen. A prominent business man in New York state gives away four copies of the New Testament each day the cost of the four cigars he used to smoke per day. Mioses Emma and Lizzie Borden have bought a new house in the most fash ionable part of Fall River, their old home being too ghastly for them,

See the clipping

The Morning News · Savannah, Ga.

The report notes that Lizzie Borden has received a large photograph of the jury that acquitted her of murder charges, which she has placed in her parlor at Fall River. It speculates she may become the most popular and widely known young woman in Massachusetts.

The Morning News · 6 July 1893 · page 4

Miss Lizzie Borden has been presented with a large photograph of the jury that acquitted her of the charge of murder, it has been placed in her parlor at Fall Hiver. There is likelihood that Miss Lizzie will become the most popular as well as the most widely known young woman in Massachusetts.

See the clipping

The Oskaloosa Herald · Oskaloosa, Iowa

The article claims Lizzie Borden's family once lived in Glenwood, Iowa, where her father supposedly married the stepmother who became a murder victim. It further claims Lizzie herself worked as a schoolteacher in Iowa.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Oskaloosa Herald · 6 July 1893 · page 4

Guaranteed Cure For Rheumatism. The first bottle of Dr. Detchon’s “Mystic Cure’’ for rheumatism and neuralgia is guaranteed to benefit or money promptly refunded. You take no risk. Try it. It usually cures in 1 to 8 days, m cents. Sold and g uar anteed by Green & Bentley, druggists, Ossialoosa. 27w4mos. An lowan. —It is developed now that Lizzie Borden is from lowa, having lived with her parents at one time at Glenwood, and there her father was married to the step-mother whowwas a victim of the dual murder. Lizzie was an lowa school ma’am.

See moreSee less

To My Friends, As you are well aware that 1 would sot recommend that which 1 did not believe to be good, I derire to say to all who desire a good, reliable, family medicine, that I believe one bottle of Sulphur Bitters will do you more good than any other remedy 1 ever saw.—Rev. Cephas Socle. Lost Thunks.— Much trouble is be ing experienced by World’s Fair visi tors who take checked bagage. There Is an endless amount of luggage arriv ing daily and it is next to impossible to tlnd checks of corresponding num bers. Go in light marching order. Don’t check.

See the clipping

Audubon County Republican · Audubon, Iowa

The item claims Lizzie Borden and her family lived on a farm near Glenwood, Iowa from 1870 to 1883, and that Andrew Borden married Abby there despite Lizzie's objections. It states Lizzie spent much time away teaching school in nearby districts during this period.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

Audubon County Republican · 6 July 1893 · page 1

Borden, the young lady who was re cently tried amt acquitted on the charge of having murdered her father and step-mother. Mr. and Mrs. Andrew Borden, at Fall River, Mass., was at one time a resident of Glenwood, la. From 1870 to 188.1 Andrew Borden, to gether w ith other members of the fami ly, lived on a farm just outside the corporate limits of Glenwood. It was here that the father married the step mother, whom Lizzie was charged with having murdered. The marriage was against the wishes of the young girl, wao entered many a vigorous protest, but without avail. After the marriage, while the Bordens lived at Glenwood.

See the clipping

The Somerset Reporter · Skowhegan, Me.

After her acquittal in the New Bedford trial, Lizzie Borden has returned to quiet domestic life in Fall River but is besieged by public curiosity. A planned visit to Mrs. Livermore in Melrose has drawn swarms of reporters, with Mrs. Livermore describing how even she is watched and followed by the curious public.

The Somerset Reporter · 6 July 1893 · page 8

SHE SEEKS PRIVACY

meditatively, “that I could smuggle Lizzie Borden in here at midnight without the reporters finding it out In-fore the front door was finally shut on her. Sunday my husband and 1 went out riding with a third person People in carriages drove by us rapidly and then slowed their horses and Pr«r«*«l Out Into Our furring* we cam»‘ by. as if they expected to see Lizzie Bonh n in tlir back neat. You nee how impossible it would lie t«» have her here at present,,,r to make any date for her visit while this curiosity is so aggres sive.

See moreSee less

“The poor girl fools herself under sur veil lance even now. She cannot look out of the window ..r stop out of doors but that shu is stared at, ami about the Borden house people peer over the fences anti from

See the clipping

The Somerset Reporter · Skowhegan, Me.

A friend of Lizzie Borden describes her reaction to acquittal, the flood of letters she receives from prisoners and sympathizers, and her improving health. The Borden sisters are planning to buy a new house in Fall River to escape hostile neighbors and sightseers at the old homestead.

The Somerset Reporter · 6 July 1893 · page 8

the Burden case—some blaming me for my Interest in Miss Borden, some from people evidently morbid from dwelling on the horrors and mystery of the crime, tin a; who have dreamed dreams and have theo ries, and m ly from people who have believed all along in her innocence and rejoice in her acquittal. “Oh! yes; Lizzie Borden is not without friends. She writes me that they have been so assiduous in their attentions, so kind and car ful of her in every way that Bhe has had hardly time to herself for the routine of daily work, and is just now be ginning to 'ake up the little household duties.

See moreSee less

Her health is better and she is be ginning to sleep naturally at night, but as Bhe told me with a great deal of pathos: 'I realize that I can never be light-hearted again,’ " The arrang ments for the purchase of n new house in Fail River are not yet com pleted. The Borden homestead lias natur ally many painful associations for both sisters, and they are anxious to be gone from it and from the hostile neighbors and peeping sightseers who find a morbid in terest in visiting the scene of the world famous tragedy.

See the clipping

The Redwood Gazette · Redwood Falls, Minn.

A brief, truncated telegraph item begins to reference 'the trial of Lizzie Borden' before being cut off by unrelated news fragments. No details of the proceedings or outcome are given in the surviving text.

The Redwood Gazette · 6 July 1893 · page 8

Telegraph Notes. Io., was THE postoffice at Lyons, The safe robbed the night of the 5th, was blown open e money and valuables taken. THE president said the evening of the 5th, in reply to a direct question by a representative of the Associated Press, tV.at he intended to call an extra ses sion of congress not earlier than the 1st nor later than the 15th of Septem ber, unless unexpected contingencies should necessitate a meeting at an earlier date. THE trial of Lizzie Borden, for the I ®T

See the clipping

Der Fortschritt · New Ulm, Minn.

The report announces that the sensational Borden trial in New Bedford, Massachusetts ended with Lizzie Borden's acquittal on charges of murdering her father and stepmother. It notes the jury's verdict was met with great jubilation in the courtroom, and states the prosecution's case relied only on a circumstantial theory constructed by police.

Der Fortschritt · 6 July 1893 · page 2

York aus angetreten, und zwar wird f^d die Leiche Andrew I. Borden's er feinen Weg über Pittsburg, Joliet,! mit zerschmettertem Schädel auf einem den Uellow Stone Park nach San-1 Sopha des Mohnzimmers liegend, Francisco nehmen, sich von dort nach während die Umgebung 'der Leiche mit Japan einschiffen, Asien durchkreuzen Blut bespritzt war. und durch Palästina und Aegypten bis Auf die Bitte Lizzie's lief die Sulli

See the clipping

Der Fortschritt · New Ulm, Minn.

This German-American newspaper article summarizes the mysterious double murder case, recounting how on the morning of August 4, 1892, wealthy merchant Andrew J. Borden and his wife Abby were found dead with crushed skulls in different rooms of their Fall River home. It lists who was present in the house at the time, including daughter Lizzie Borden, the maid Bridget Sullivan, and notes that Lizzie's sister Emma was away and Uncle John Morse had left that morning.

Der Fortschritt · 6 July 1893 · page 2

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

See the clipping

Der Fortschritt · New Ulm, Minn.

The report narrates how the bodies of Andrew and Abby Borden were discovered with crushed skulls, with money found untouched on Andrew's body, ruling out robbery as a motive. Suspicion immediately turned to Lizzie Borden as the only person besides the maid Bridget Sullivan present in the house at the time of the murders.

Der Fortschritt · 6 July 1893 · page 2

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

Goldsboro Weekly Argus · Goldsboro, N.C.

This editorial comments on the conclusion of the Borden murder trial, noting that Lizzie Borden was found not guilty due to the prosecution's weak circumstantial case. It argues that society's duty to protect individual rights outweighed the need for conviction absent solid evidence, affirming the presumption of innocence.

Goldsboro Weekly Argus · 6 July 1893 · page 4

SOCIETY AND LAW

Borden and his wife were mur dered by somebody. The prosecution relied wholly upon circumstantial evidence to prove that Lizzie Borden was the culprit. It failed signally to sus tain its allegation, and the jury very properly returned a verdict cf acquittal. It is lnonueiy oeuer mat any number of guilty persons should escape than that one innocent should be punished on dubious evidence. Society has two equally serious duties m such cases to itself, and to the individual. For the protection of the first it must eeek out for punishment any of fender against life or propeity.

See moreSee less

For the second, it must defend the rights of its humblest member from every injustice. Under the evidence submitted to the court, society, instead of aveng ing a crime against itself, would have committed a new one against the individual in making Izz!e Borden responsible for the death of her lather and step-mother. It is not right to say, in the absence of a scintilla of direct evidence to the contrary, that the presumption of guilt was again Bt her. Thepresumption of innocence is in favor of anybody, especially a wo man, accused of such a monstrous and unnatural ciime. The re sumption of circumstantial evi dence was against her, and a cares ful investigation has shown that the presumption was unfounded. "Law is, or should be, as rigid as mathematics in its propositions. and when the propositions fail of de monstration, the negative result is an affirmative answer beyond diepnte. Miss Borden goes forth accquit.

See the clipping

Goldsboro Weekly Argus · Goldsboro, N.C.

This editorial argues that society must protect individuals from injustice as much as it punishes crime, and that the presumption of innocence rightly prevailed when circumstantial evidence against Lizzie Borden failed under scrutiny. It concludes that acquitting a possibly guilty person is preferable to wrongly convicting an innocent one.

Goldsboro Weekly Argus · 6 July 1893 · page 4

SOCIETY AND LAW

Borden responsible for the death of her lather and step-mother. It is not right to say, in the absence of a scintilla of direct evidence to the contrary, that the presumption of guilt was again Bt her. Thepresumption of innocence is in favor of anybody, especially a wo man, accused of such a monstrous and unnatural ciime. The re sumption of circumstantial evi dence was against her, and a cares ful investigation has shown that the presumption was unfounded. "Law is, or should be, as rigid as mathematics in its propositions. and when the propositions fail of de monstration, the negative result is an affirmative answer beyond diepnte. Miss Borden goes forth accquit.

See the clipping

Bridgeton Pioneer · Bridgeton, N.J.

This opinion piece uses the Lizzie Borden trial to muse on how neighbors obsessively watch and gossip about each other's affairs, citing testimony about witnesses observing the house and Lizzie burning a dress. It moralizes that such curiosity is a mark of low breeding compared to more refined interests.

Bridgeton Pioneer · 6 July 1893 · page 4

The Evidence of Neighbors, Every famous legal case that comes before the public shows renewed evi dence of the interest neighbors take in one another’s affairs. In the Lizzie Bop den trial the neighbors were very sur« that nobody could have come in or gone out of the house of the ill fated couple on the morning of the murder without the neighbors seeing it, not on that morn ing or any other morning. When Miss Borden innocently attempted to bum up

See the clipping

Democratic Northwest · Napoleon, Ohio

A column of miscellaneous witty one-liners includes a quip suggesting that if Lizzie Borden lectures, her topic should be 'The hatchet as foundation for police theories,' mocking the prosecution's reliance on circumstantial evidence. The rest of the passage is unrelated filler content including an advertisement and other jokes about current events.

Democratic Northwest · 6 July 1893 · page 2

Thb modern battle-sbip bas proven tta efficiency m a killer of its own crew. No slates will be used in South Caro lina's state barrooms. It's cash or no trlpple. TAe administration has only to stand by its promises and purge the pension roll; the people will do the rest. "Jubilee" Isn't an appropriate name for a racing yacht, unless she is certain to always win. If Lizzie Borden lectures she should

See the clipping

Süd Dakota Nachrichten · Mitchell, Süd=dakota

This report announces the conclusion of the sensational Borden trial in New Bedford, noting the jury's verdict caused great jubilation among those in the courtroom. It then recaps the known facts of the double murder of Andrew and Abby Borden on August 4, 1892, including who was present in the house at the time.

Süd Dakota Nachrichten · 6 July 1893 · page 2

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

See the clipping

Süd Dakota Nachrichten · Mitchell, Süd=dakota

This German-American newspaper article recounts the discovery of Andrew and Abby Borden's bodies on August 4, 1892, detailing who was in the house and the sequence of events that morning. It notes that nothing of value was taken, ruling out robbery, and that suspicion fell on Lizzie Borden as the only other person present besides the maid Bridget Sullivan.

Süd Dakota Nachrichten · 6 July 1893 · page 2

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

Süd Dakota Nachrichten · Mitchell, Süd=dakota

The report describes finding Mrs. Borden's body with a crushed skull in the upstairs sitting room, and notes that robbery was ruled out since valuables, including Andrew Borden's watch and money, were untouched. It details the troubled Borden household and explains why suspicion fell on Lizzie as the only person besides servant Bridget Sullivan present in the house.

Süd Dakota Nachrichten · 6 July 1893 · page 2

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

The Valley Virginian · Staunton, Va.

A newspaper commentary piece disputes a minister's claim that alcohol figures in nearly every murder trial, citing Lizzie Borden as a sober defendant. The item appears amid unrelated news items including a Confederate memorial society meeting and anarchist pardons.

The Valley Virginian · 6 July 1893 · page 2

Rev. Thomas Dixon said in an address the other day that there is scarcely a murder trial in which drink does not figure in the evidence—a sentiment oft en expressed by temperance orators. But there was Lizzie Borden, who never took

See the clipping

Grant County Herald · Lancaster, Wis.

Following her acquittal on murder charges, Lizzie Borden and her sister Emma have returned to their social and church life in Fall River, living in the family home. The Borden estate, valued at about $300,000, passes to the sisters as sole heirs, while Lizzie's defense reportedly cost $50,000.

Grant County Herald · 6 July 1893 · page 5

Lizzie Borden, recently acquitted of the charge of murdering her parents, and her sister E uma have fully resumed their residence and their church and social relations in Fall River, Mass., occupying the old homestead. The Borden estate is about §300,000, and

See the clipping

Idaho Semi-Weekly World · Idaho City, Idaho Territory

Rev. Dr. Charles H. Parkhurst, a prominent New York preacher, states his firm conviction that it would have been a 'moral impossibility' for Lizzie Borden to have committed the murders with which she was charged. The item appears amid unrelated miscellaneous news briefs.

Idaho Semi-Weekly World · 7 July 1893 · page 2

viction that it would have been a "moral impossibility" for Lizzie Borden to commit the murders with which »lie to charged. is

See the clipping

Fisherman & Farmer · Edenton, N.C.

A brief humorous item claims Lizzie Borden is besieged by admirers seeking her hand in marriage, noting her $100,000 fortune as the attraction. The item is placed among miscellaneous short news and joke items.

Fisherman & Farmer · 7 July 1893 · page 1

Nebraska State Journal. Miss Lizzie Borden is now disturbed bv hosts of admirers anxiously seek ing her hand. There are $100,000 or more in it.

See the clipping

The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · Wheeling, W. Va.

A column of miscellaneous personal news items reports that Mrs. Mary A. Livermore expects to host Miss Lizzie Borden as a guest soon at her home in Melrose, Massachusetts. The item appears amid unrelated trivia about public figures and advertisements.

The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · 7 July 1893 · page 4

PERSONAL POINTS

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

See the clipping

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

A letter to the editor agrees with The Tribune's criticism of District-Attorney Knowlton's conduct in prosecuting Lizzie Borden, calling him sincere but partisan and overly dogmatic in pressing every inference against her. The writer argues this reflects a systemic flaw where the same official investigates and prosecutes, citing other recent trials as further evidence of this tendency.

New-York Tribune · 8 July 1893 · page 2

PARTISANSHIP OF PROSECUTORS, To the Editor of The Tribune. Sir: The Tribune this morning so appropriately characterizes the eonduct of the prosecution of Lizzie Borden by District-Attorney Knowlton that 1 wish It

See the clipping

The Ketchum Keystone · Ketchum, Idaho

The report states that Lizzie Borden and her sister purchased a fashionable new residence in Fall River, moving away from the old house due to its grim associations. It speculates that a lecture tour might be her next move.

The Ketchum Keystone · 8 July 1893 · page 2

The words of this article could not be separated from the rest of its page. Read it in the clipping.

No clean clipping could be cut from this page

Eureka Weekly Sentinel · Eureka, Nev.

A legal commentary piece discusses the defense's decision not to put Lizzie Borden on the stand, explaining that defendants have the right not to testify without the jury drawing negative inferences. It notes the risks of cross-examination, citing Dr. Buchanan's self-damaging testimony in another trial, and concludes Borden likely helped her case by staying silent.

Eureka Weekly Sentinel · 8 July 1893 · page 3

It has been said, with no little force, that Dr. Buchanan simply convicted himself by appearing as a witness in his own behalf on his recent trial in this city. Lizzie Borden could not have helped her case by taking the stand. The chances are that she would have damaged it very seriously.—N.

See the clipping

In the story →

Eureka Weekly Sentinel · Eureka, Nev.

A dispatch reports that three prominent members of Fall River's Central Church say they will refuse to fraternize with Lizzie Borden until the murders of her father and stepmother are solved or explained. It also notes that police protection may be needed to shield her from threatened insults should she attend church.

Eureka Weekly Sentinel · 8 July 1893 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

Will Not Fraternize With Lizzie. A dispatch from Fall River, Massachusetts, to the Salt Lake Tribune says: "Three of the most prominent members of the Central Church declare that they will not fraternize with Miss Lizzie Borden until the murderers of her father and stepmother are avenged, or at least explained. It is said that police protection will be required to guard Miss Lizzie Borden from threatened insults if she attempts to attend church."

See the clipping

Ameryka · Toledo, Ohio

The report states that Lizzie Borden is now receiving 200 congratulatory letters daily. It adds that she and her sister are planning an extended trip to Europe.

Ameryka · 8 July 1893 · page 7

WIADOMOŚCI Z RÓŻNYCH STRON.

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

See the clipping

Narragansett Herald · Narragansett Pier, R.I.

A fire in Fall River caused $2,000 in damage to a building owned by the heirs of Andrew J. Borden, one of whom is Lizzie Borden. The item is a brief filler note among various unrelated news items.

Narragansett Herald · 8 July 1893 · page 8

Andrew J. Borden, one of whom is Lizzie Borden. . At Wilburton, I. T., there is considerable excitement over the action Governor Jones may take in the matter of commuting the death sentence imposed upon the seven Choe taws now awaiting execution in that place. The governor has received a message from the authorities at Washington asking if there is any authority whereby the chief magistrate

See the clipping

The Morning News · Savannah, Ga.

A self-described detective reporter claims he always believed Lizzie Borden had guilty knowledge of the murders, dismissing the idea that an outsider could have committed them unseen. He proposes an unproven theory that she secretly met a man abroad who wanted to marry her for her money, and that her father's refusal to allow the match precipitated a crisis just before the killings.

The Morning News · 9 July 1893 · page 10

A Theory That She Had One Who Was Unscrupulous—After Her Fortune. From the Pittsburg Dispatch. New York, July I.—“ There never was a doubt in my mind,” said a famous de tective reporter to-day, "as to whether T.izzic Borde.n committed the murders of which she was accused. I was detailed on the ease when the preliminary trial was on. My remark made at the time the tide of public opinion was turning steadily against her, was to the effect that in order to make her guilty of com mitting the murders the prosecution must endow her with the powers of perform ing a miracle.

See moreSee less

"From the way the case has developed it now s. ems that it was nil easy matter for any one to have got into the house and murder and Mr. and Mrs. Borden unob served. provided they were there just at the right minute. The one unaccountable point lies in the direction of the motive for committing the murders. An impres sion will always remain thut Lizzie Bor den kuevv something about the affair, if she were not actually associated with the ghastly butchery, and I have yet to see a theory advanced which will dovetail in all around as the one I suggest. “It was to the effect that by some means or other, possibly while she was abroad, Lizzie Borden had become ac quainted with some unscrupulous person who wished to marry her for the sake of her money. Thut site had met this man clandestinely from time to time and that her father had refused to countenance the. match. Jflst before the murders u crisis was precipitated by the man insisting upon her marrying him or else endure the alternative of an exposure. Intending to commit suicide to escape her troubles. Lizzie Borden had bought the prussic acid, of which fact the man was aware. Incensed at the thought of losing her money, the man went to the house on tig morning of the murders, or possibly had been secreted there since the previous night, perhaps with no definite purpose, and with or without Lizzie Borden’s knowledge. The sight of the axes might have roused a demoniacal impulse, and upon failing to meet with any encourage ment. for It is hopes, from either Mr. or Mrs. Borden, he killed them. • Lizzie Borden may have been in the barn when he did it. Speechless with hot for site may have watched him com mit the inhuman butcheries. She may have let him out of the front door after it was over and then in a dazed way have gone to call the servant girl. But it seems almost impossible that she should not know who the murderer was, and that she should not have denounced him if there had not been love between them. Here seems to he a theory with a motive which explains many strange points about the case otherwise utterly inex plicable.”

See the clipping

The Morning News · Savannah, Ga.

An unnamed commentator proposes a theory that Lizzie Borden had a secret suitor whose exposure of a clandestine romance or desire for her money led him to murder her parents while she watched helplessly. The writer admits this is speculation meant to explain otherwise inexplicable aspects of the case.

The Morning News · 9 July 1893 · page 10

LIZZIE BORDEN'S LOVER

The words of this article are printed with the report it shares its clipping with. Read them there or in the clipping.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

The report states there is no reason to attach importance to the latest story about the Borden case involving a man named Carpenter, a former bookkeeper for Mr. Borden's firm who had been a suspect but proved an alibi. His wife explained the letter found in Rome, N.Y., and his reluctance to return to Fall River, leading the paper to conclude there is no clue worth pursuing further.

New-York Tribune · 10 July 1893 · page 6

No reason is apparent for attaching importance to the latest story told in connection with the Borden mystery. The man Carpenter. formerly a bookkeeper for Mr. Borden's

See the clipping

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

A brief filler item quotes Mrs. Livermore saying Lizzie Borden is not without friends, who have been attentive and kind to her. It notes her health is improving and she is resuming small household duties, though she says she can never be light-hearted again.

New-York Tribune · 10 July 1893 · page 6

job done? he expected to have hig} Frnthiul James (son of contractor)—Well, 1 neard him tell mother that if he got a certain job he's look. ing after he'd have yours finished by to-night, but if not. he guessed he'd make this job last out anothef week. —( Yankee Blade, “ Lizzie Borden is not without friends,” says Mrs. Livermore. * she writes me that they have been 80 assiduous in their attentions, so kind and careful of her in every way, that she has had hardly thine (0 her<clf for the routine of daily work, and is just now beginning tv) take up the little household duties.

See moreSee less

Her health is better and she is beginning to sleep naturally night, but as she told me with a great deal of ut

See the clipping

The Portland Daily Press · Portland, Me.

A letter connected to the Fall River murder investigation was mistakenly reported as addressed to 'Lawrence Carpenter,' but is actually addressed to Joseph Wilmuth Carpenter, Jr., a traveling salesman from Albany. Lizzie Borden's attorney, Andrew Jennings, telegraphed to verify the reports and request the letter's text.

The Portland Daily Press · 10 July 1893 · page 1

Rome, N. Y.,July 8.—The letter which Dr. Lloyd has in his possession and which bears on the murder at Fall River, is addressed to Joseph Wilmnth Carpen ter, Jr., and not to Lawrence Carpentef as has been stated. J. W. Carpenter, Jr., is a commercial traveller of Albany, formerly of Fall River, Mass. He fre quently visits Rome and was registered at the Arlington Hotel June 21. He left with a horse and wagon to visit thaisur rounding villages and is not here now. The letter and postal card await him at the Arlington.

See moreSee less

Dr. Lloyed this afternoon received a telegram from Lawyer Jennings of Fall River, counsel for Lizzie Borden, in quirine as to the truth of the reports concerning the finding of the letter and requesting him to telegraph its text.

See the clipping

Pawtucket Tribune · Pawtucket, R.I.

The report examines a suspicious letter linked to Joseph W. Carpenter Jr., a former employee of Andrew Borden's furniture firm, investigated in connection with the Borden murders. It concludes the lead 'amounts to nothing,' noting Carpenter's wife explained his absence and quoted her letter saying Lizzie Borden had already been acquitted.

Pawtucket Tribune · 10 July 1893 · page 1

Some Sagarore mill stock was trans lerred to sutisfy the claim, but later tu« mill becume involved and t.'bo stook proved valueless. Buil followed, but, when both parties were ready for trial, Carpenter threatened some things which several of the parties did not ecare to face, and the proceedings were quashed, Mrs. Joseph Car; nter last night said she wrote a letter to her husband some days ago, in which she begged him tocome home as soon as he could. She sald, in substance, that nobody could cause him any more annoyance here on aoccount of the murders, inasmnch as Lizzie Borden was acquitted and the feeling in the mat ter had quicted down.

See moreSee less

She wrote in this strain because her husband had been diffident about coming to Fall River on sccount of having once been shadowed snd bis name mixed ap in the affair. She said that her hushand has not been bere sinee Decoration day, 1892, and that “is wherealwpts after that date had been fully explained to the satisfaction of the police, She ennnot explain how her letter was lost. She wrote to her busband

See the clipping

Orleans County Monitor · Barton, Vt.

The article is a biographical sketch of former Massachusetts Governor George D. Robinson, who served as defense counsel for Lizzie Borden. It details his modest farm upbringing, his education at Harvard, and his early career as a schoolmaster before becoming a prominent lawyer and politician.

Orleans County Monitor · 10 July 1893 · page 3

A MASSACHUSETTS LAWYER.

I In the Old IJay State. Governor George D. Robinson, ;r counsel for Lizzie Borden, is of tcellent type of true American man and has fairly won his way to

See the clipping

The Beatrice Daily Express · Beatrice, Neb.

This piece reflects on Lizzie Borden's life after being acquitted by a unanimous jury verdict, suggesting her Puritan ancestry gave her the strength to endure the trial. It predicts the ordeal will haunt her for the rest of her days despite the not-guilty verdict.

The Beatrice Daily Express · 11 July 1893 · page 2

The lot of Lizzie Borden for the rest of her life cannot be an enviable one. The recollection of the fiery ordeal through which she has passed will try the iron self control yt even this woman *Kk the blood of ten generations of

See the clipping

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

Fall River reports say the Misses Borden have purchased the Charles N. Allen property on French Street, located in one of the city's finest areas. The brief item notes only that this purchase has been reported, without further detail.

New-York Tribune · 12 July 1893 · page 7

-> LIZZIE BORDEN BUYING A NEW HOME. ! Fall River, Mass., July 11.—It is reported that the Misses Borden have bought the Charles N. Allen prope erty, in French-st,, in the finest part of the city. ->

See the clipping

The Indianapolis Journal · Indianapolis, Ind.

Mrs. Livermore shares a letter from Lizzie Borden describing the kindness of her friends and her slow return to normal household routines. Borden is quoted saying she can never be light-hearted again, though her health and sleep are improving.

The Indianapolis Journal · 12 July 1893 · page 4

ABOUT PEOPLE AND THINGS.

"Lizzie Borden is not without friends." says Mrs. Livermore. "She writes me that they have been so assiduous in their atten tions, so kind and careful of her in every way, that she has had hardly time to her self for the routine of daily work, and is just now beginning to take up tho little household duties. Her health is better aud she in beginning to sleep naturally at night, bnt as bhe told mo with a great deal of pathos. 'I realize that 1 can never be light-hearted again.' "

See the clipping

Walker Lake Bulletin · Hawthorne, Nev.

A short filler item in a column of miscellaneous news notes states that Lizzie Borden was in jail for ten months. This brief mention appears shortly after her acquittal and release from custody.

Walker Lake Bulletin · 12 July 1893 · page 3

SAMPLES. Lizzie Borden was in jail ten months. Arthur George is back from the Bay city. Very few foreign tourist* are visit -1 ing the fair. About 20,009 people visited Reno! on the Fourth. The Board of Pardons ha in session to day in Carson. The Peary exploring party is ready for its long journey. Judge Crocker returned from San

See the clipping

The Record-Visitor · Pawtucket, R.I.

A syndicated women's column questions why women shower convicted male murderers with flowers and gifts while offering no sympathy to Lizzie Borden, who sat through her trial seemingly friendless. The writer argues this reveals a troubling double standard in how society treats accused women versus condemned men.

The Record-Visitor · 12 July 1893 · page 8

want to know if it is true, as Mrs, Ca hoon thinks, that lovely woman has only sympathy with men murderers, even to the extent of not bestowing any on a woman who is unjustly charged with wurder. Ladies, what do you think of this: “The members of my sex, as they *end and withhold their sympathies in he case of the fallen, downtrodden and ppressed, present a curious and inter sting study? The case in point is that of Lizzie Borden, than whomn no prisoner

See the clipping

Eagle River Review · Eagle River, Wis. · and 1 other paper

This feature piece, published during the Borden trial, reflects on the dangers of circumstantial evidence by recounting historical parricide cases. It describes a case where a son was convicted and hanged for killing his father, only for his sister to confess years later that she committed the crime and framed him.

Eagle River Review · 13 July 1893 · page 7

CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE. Cases in Which the Innocent Have Paid the Penalty for the Guilty. The case of Lizzie Borden, depending upon circumstantial evidence, evokes fresh interest in that ever-fascinating

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • Watertown Republican · Watertown, Wis. · 12 July 1893

Connecticut Western News · Salisbury, Conn.

A roundup of brief national and world news items includes mention that a letter found in Utica, N.Y. (later said to be Rome, N.Y.) is regarded as a clue to the Borden murder and is being investigated. The item appears amid unrelated snippets on floods, royalty, and crime stories of the day.

Connecticut Western News · 13 July 1893 · page 4

BOILED DOWN.

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

See the clipping

Connecticut Western News · Salisbury, Conn.

The article profiles ex-Governor George D. Robinson, senior counsel for Lizzie Borden, describing his upbringing on a Massachusetts farm and his education at Harvard. It details his family background, character, and early career as a schoolmaster before his rise as a lawyer and statesman.

Connecticut Western News · 13 July 1893 · page 4

A MASSACHUSETTS LAWYER.

In the Old Hay State. Ex-Governor George D. Robinson, senior counsel for Lizzie Borden, is of an excellent type of true American man hood and has fairly won his way to

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

A brief local item reports that Miss Lizzie Borden is visiting at the residence of Mr. Charles Morse on the main road from Bristol to Warren. It is a short social notice with no further detail.

The Providence News · 13 July 1893 · page 1

There was a panic l-omo-u, for traces of poisoning. % who ran in terror in every st.‘n'r'nbon. vompany. The damage was slizht, pchocner Wasp, bound to Bristol Ferry with a cargo oi lime from Roekland, Me., arrived ye-t.erd.{y. Mr. Whitby of Brooklyn, N, Y., is the guest of Captain R. R. Magee, Miss Lizzie Borden is visiting at the residence of Mr. Charies Morse on the waiu road from Bristol o Warren.

See the clipping

The Portland Daily Press · Portland, Me.

The report says Emma and Lizzie Borden have purchased a new home on French Street in Fall River's affluent 'Hill' section, after apparently abandoning an earlier option on the Butterworth estate. It notes local gossip and mixed community sentiment toward Lizzie, with one citizen defending her as legally cleared of guilt.

The Portland Daily Press · 14 July 1893 · page 1

THE BORDENS' NEW HOME.

Concerning It. Boston, July 13.—A Fall River de spatch to the Journal says: Emma and Lizzie Borden have purchased a now homo on the north side of French

See the clipping

The Sun · New York, N.Y.

Emma and Lizzie Borden have purchased a new home on French Street in Fall River's most fashionable neighborhood, known as 'The Hill.' This surprised locals who had assumed the sisters would instead acquire the Butterworth property, on which they held an option.

The Sun · 14 July 1893 · page 3

TEE BOEDEX GIRLS II A YE A XEWllOHE. "The ITIII," the Arlstoernclle (Section or Fall River, to Have Them tor Residents, Fvli, IlrvEr, July 13. Emma nnd Lizzie Borden havo purchased n now homo on tho north side of French street in Pall Itlvcr, in tho most aristocratic section of tho city.

See the clipping

The Oregon Mist · St. Helens, Or.

A brief news item states that Lizzie Borden has been invited by the Globe-Democrat to give a lecture. No further details are provided about the terms or her response.

The Oregon Mist · 14 July 1893 · page 1

Will be Much Below the Av erage Corn Crop. Lizzie Borden ha, lieen invited by the Globe-Democrat to lecture. Thu work of overhauling the halls of

See the clipping

Sullivan Republican · Laporte, Pa.

A dentist in Rome, N.Y. found a misdirected letter addressed to Lawrence Carpenter, postmarked Fall River the day after Lizzie Borden's acquittal, urging him to come home and asking if he could prove his whereabouts the morning of the murder. The letter sparked scrutiny of Joseph W. Carpenter Jr., a former Borden & Almy employee with a past financial dispute with Andrew Borden.

Sullivan Republican · 14 July 1893 · page 3

CLUE TO THE BORDEN MURDER

THE I.OST LETTER AROUSES SUSPICION. FALL RIVER, July 9. —Joseph W. Carpenter, jr., about whom much is now being printed in connection with the Borden murders, because of a suspicious letter supposed to have been addressed to him i» New York, formerly worked for the IJordcn & Almy firm of furniture dealers, of which Andrew J. Borden was the senior member. It w#3 al leged against Carpenter, at one time, that he falsified the firm's books. Some Sagamore mill stock was transferred to satisfy the claim, but later the mill became involved and the stock proved valueless.

See moreSee less

Suit followed, but when both parties were ready for trial, Carpenter threatened something, which several of the parties did not dare to face, and the proceedings were quashed. Andrew Borden was most severe with Carpenter, but the latter never had serious trouble with him. Carpenter left the city shortly after ward, and became a drummer for ink, pens and stationery. He has traveled the most of the time in New York state, and generally makes his headquarters iu Albany. He married a daughter of Captain Barney, of this city aud was here last iu May, 1892. When the Bordon tragedies were heralded about the country last August, every man who might have had formerly any differences with Mr. Borden was hunted down. Among the unforuriate suspects was Carpenter. District Attorne}- Knowlton felt .satisfied from his talk with Mrs. Carpenter, aud her little girl, here, that ' I ""band had not been in the vieinitj the time of the tragedy, noi some time before it. Nevertheless, at the suggestion of Marshal II il liard, who was urged ou by Mr. Sennings, Harrington was sont out to run down Carpenter and to ob tain positive information of his whereabouts during the latter days of July and the early days of Au gust, 1892. Carpenter proved an alibiti by hotel clerks and registers. Ono fact iu connection with the Carpenter matter, caused Miss Borden's

See the clipping

Sullivan Republican · Laporte, Pa.

This report revisits the investigation of Joseph W. Carpenter, a former employee with past business disputes with Andrew Borden, who was investigated as a suspect after the murders. It details his alibi, a since-discredited barber's claim placing him in Fall River before the killings, and his wife's account of his whereabouts, confirming he was cleared.

Sullivan Republican · 14 July 1893 · page 3

THE LOST LETTER AROUSES SUSPICION

The words of this article are printed with the report it shares its clipping with. Read them there or in the clipping.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

The Londonderry Sifter · South Londonderry, Vt.

This report is a biographical sketch of Ex-Governor George D. Robinson, senior counsel for Lizzie Borden, describing his upbringing on a Lexington, Massachusetts farm and his education at Harvard. It details his family background, physical appearance as a young man, and early career as a schoolmaster before his rise as a lawyer and statesman.

The Londonderry Sifter · 14 July 1893 · page 2

How a Famous Lawyer raesed Ills Tenth In Ihe Old Day Stale. Ex-Governor George D, Robinson, senior counsel for Lizzie Borden, is of an excellent type of true American man. hood and has fairly won his way to

See the clipping

The Morning News · Savannah, Ga.

A personal-items column reports that Lizzie Borden's friends have been attentive and helpful since her trial ended, and that her health is improving as she resumes small household duties. Mrs. Livermore is quoted relaying Borden's own words that she can never be lighthearted again.

The Morning News · 15 July 1893 · page 4

PERSONAL.

In alluding to the good offices performed by some of Lizzie Borden s friends since the conclusion of th© famous trial. Mrs. Liver more says: she writes me that they have been so assiduous in their attentions so kind and careful in every way. that she has had hardly time to herself for the routine of daily work, and is just now beginning to take up the little household duties. Her health is better and she is r*eginning to sl *ep naturally at night. b.t as she told me witn a great deal of puthos. I realize that I can never be light hearted again.' ”

See the clipping

Paper unidentified

This short item states that Lizzie Borden has been invited by the Globe-Democrat to lecture. It appears amid a miscellany of unrelated news briefs from around the country.

Paper unidentified · 15 July 1893 · page 2

Lizzie Borden has been invited by the | Globe-IVmocrat to lecture. The work oi overhauling the halls ot' Congress is being pushed rapidly. Toronto is wrestling w ith the question of running street cars on Sunday. . Leadville. Col., is tilling up with id men, owing to the shutting down oi the

See the clipping

The New Dominion · Morgantown, W. Va.

A humorous filler item mocks the police's reliance on the hatchet as evidence, suggesting that if Lizzie Borden ever lectures, her topic should be 'The hatchet as a foundation for police theories.' It appears among a list of miscellaneous newspaper quips and jokes.

The New Dominion · 15 July 1893 · page 1

VOLUME XXVII. The McKinley bill must be re pealed. The Sherman law must go. The modern battle-ship has prov ed its efficiency as a killer-of its own crew. If Lizzie Borden lectures she

See the clipping

Idaho Semi-Weekly World · Idaho City, Idaho Territory

A one-line item in a miscellany column notes that Lizzie Borden has been invited by the Globe-Democrat to lecture. No further context or detail is given.

Idaho Semi-Weekly World · 18 July 1893 · page 2

Lizzie Borden has been invited by the Globe-Democrat to lecture. The work of overhauling the halls of Congress is being pushed rapidly. Toronto is wrestling with the question of running street cars on Sunday.

See the clipping

The Portland Daily Press · Portland, Me.

This report is a biographical sketch of ex-Governor George D. Robinson, senior counsel for Lizzie Borden, describing his upbringing on a Lexington farm and his early years as a Harvard student. It highlights his family background, character, and path to becoming a prominent lawyer and statesman.

The Portland Daily Press · 20 July 1893 · page 6

A MASSACHUSETTS LAWYER.

In the Old Bay State. Ex-Governor George D. Robinson, senior counsel for Lizzie Borden, is of an excellent type of true American man flood and has fairly won his way to

See the clipping

Semi-Weekly Interior Journal · Stanford, Ky.

A syndicated women's column reprints commentary from the New York Recorder questioning why women shower sympathy on male murderers but show none for Lizzie Borden, a woman merely accused of murder. The piece uses her case as a springboard for broader musings about female psychology and solidarity.

Semi-Weekly Interior Journal · 21 July 1893 · page 3

WOMAN'S WORLD IN PARAGRAPHS.

From tho latter column I clip the following extract about the gushing and tender hearted members of our bex who send flowers to murderers and criminals. I want to know if it is true, as Mrs. Ca-boon thinks, that lovely woman has only sympathy with men murderers, oven to tho extent of not Iwatowiug any on it woman who is unjustly charged with murder Ladies, what do you think of this: "Tho members of my sox, as they lend and withhold their sympathies in tho t'itso of the fallen, downtrodden and oppressed, present curious and study? Tho case in oint is that of Lizzie Borden, than whom no prisoner

See the clipping

Springfield Weekly Republican · Springfield, Mass.

The item is a roundup of political news, mentioning that District Attorney Moody, who assisted Knowlton in prosecuting Lizzie Borden, will not seek the attorney-generalship. Moody says he cannot afford the office and believes Knowlton has earned the nomination through his work on the case.

Springfield Weekly Republican · 21 July 1893 · page 1

Knowlton's associate in the trial of Miss Lizzie Borden, will not try for the attor ney-generalship—he cannot afford to take the office, ami besides thinks that Hosea M. Knowlton "by his past work has earned the right to the nomination.”

See the clipping

The Silver State · Unionville, Nev.

A brief item explains that Massachusetts' new jury selection law, allowing judges to pick jurors with peremptory challenges by lawyers, was first tested in the Lizzie Borden case. It claims the jury was selected in three days, intended to save time and cut legal costs.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 4 days later.

Wrong

The Silver State · 21 July 1893 · page 3

NEWS NOTES

The words of this article could not be separated from the rest of its page. Read it in the clipping.

No clean clipping could be cut from this page

The Lebanon Express · Lebanon, Or.

A miscellaneous news digest reports that Lizzie Borden has been invited by the Globe-Democrat to lecture. The item appears amid unrelated brief news snippets about crops, mining, and politics.

The Lebanon Express · 21 July 1893 · page 6

Lizzie Borden has been invited by the Globe-Democrat to lecture. The work of overhauling the halts of Congress is being pushed rapidly. Toronto is wreBtling with the question of running street can on Sunday.

See the clipping

In the story →

The Indianapolis Journal · Indianapolis, Ind.

Around the time of the Lizzie Borden trial, a Boston paper surveyed Massachusetts women on whether women should serve on juries trying female defendants, since all-male juries deny a woman's right to a jury of peers. Writers Abby Morton Diaz and Ednah D. Cheney argued for female jury representation, though the article pushes back, doubting juries are ever biased against women.

The Indianapolis Journal · 23 July 1893 · page 12 · transcribed from the page image

WOMEN AS JURORS.

About the time of the Lizzie Borden trial a Boston paper made a canvass among Massachusetts women as to the justice of trying women charged with crime before juries composed of men. The point was made that this was a practical denial of a woman's right to be tried by a jury of her peers. Some of the Massachusetts women have caught at the idea. Mrs. Abby Morton Diaz, a writer of some note, favors the representation of women on the jury when a woman is to be tried, and Mrs. Ednah D. Cheney, also known in literary circles, says:

See moreSee less

No woman is tried for a criminal offense by "her peers" if men alone sit upon a jury, and in all cases of divorce or inheritance, and many others, the jury may well be supposed to be prejudiced by their peculiar relation to their own interests if they represent only one-half of the community. Nor does the exclusion of women from the jury always work for the injury of women alone. It sometimes defeats the purposes of justice by the sympathy excited for one, however guilty, who has not a fair chance to defend herself, and even in a civil suit the feeling is so strong that a woman is generally the party wronged that a jury of men often decide rather by their chivalrous feeling than by the evidence.

There is something of assumption in this. We doubt if there is a case on record of a jury of men being unduly influenced against a woman on account of her sex. It is a common opinion that women are apt to judge their own sex more harshly than men do. In divorce cases, especially, we think most lawyers would say that men's sympathies are generally with the woman.

In saying that "no woman is tried by a jury of her peers if men alone sit on the jury," Mrs. Cheney seems to rest under a misconception as to the meaning of the word "peers." Its legal sense is "an equal." Under our system a juror must be a citizen, voter and freeholder, and it can hardly be claimed that a man who fills these requirements is not in a legal sense the peer of a woman. Of course, the term "peer" does not refer to mental endowments or moral qualities.

There is no reason for placing women on juries in cases where women are to be tried that does not apply with equal force to cases where men are to be tried. If they are to be admitted to partial jury service they should be admitted to all and placed on an equality with men. In their natural capacity and equipment for jury service women are like men. Some would make good jurors while others would not. Many women are as capable of weighing evidence and reaching just conclusions as is any man, and many men are as apt to be swayed by prejudice or sympathy as is any woman.

See the clipping

Morning Appeal · Carson City, Nev.

The report describes a new Massachusetts jury selection law that allows judges to pick jurors with peremptory challenges from each lawyer. It notes this law was first tested in the Lizzie Borden case, resulting in a jury being selected within three days.

Morning Appeal · 23 July 1893 · page 3

Massachusetts has a new jury law that works like a charm. The judge selects the jury, bur, each lawyer can exercise a perepmtory challenge. The first time the law was tested was in the Lizzie Borden case, and a jury was selected iu three days. The ob ject is to cut down law expenses and save time. Hold a monster in:?--i inceMnsj in Cooper institute or I'niun sjnnre, New York, while the silver delegates are at Washington. Let the West ern delegates flood New York, Bos ton and Philadelphia with orators while congress is in session. The labor organizations would make the necessary arrangements and a silver cyclone would sweep over the far East. t

See the clipping

The Portland Daily Press · Portland, Me.

A roundup of minor local news items from a Maine paper includes a note that the schooner Samuel Borden, arriving in port, is named for an uncle of Lizzie Borden. The rest of the column covers unrelated local happenings like arrests, fires, and club meetings.

The Portland Daily Press · 24 July 1893 · page 8

BRIEF JOTTINGS.

M. O. B., Peaks Island. The hat finishers’ annual picnic took place Saturday at Long Island and was greatly enjoyed by all who attended. Jack Brunze complained at the police station Saturday night that he had been assaulted by Eli Feeney and Tom Gor ham. The schooner Samuel Borden, which is coming to this port consigned to Carle ton Brothers, is named for an uncle of

See the clipping

The Jersey City News · Jersey City, N.J.

Lizzie Borden attended Sunday service at Central Congregational Church in Fall River, her first appearance there since the killings the previous August. She was escorted by Dr. Bowen and Charles J. Holmes, surprising much of the congregation, while the sermon was delivered by a family friend, Rev. Burnham of Springfield.

The Jersey City News · 24 July 1893 · page 1

LIZZIE BORDEN AT CHCRCU. Fall River, Mass., July 24, 1893.— [here was o wild sensation at the morn ug service at the Central Congregational llhurch yesterday, created by the first ap pearance there of Miss Lizzie Boarden, iince the tragic event at her house last August. She was escorted to her pew by Dr. 3owen and Charles J. Holmes. Outside )f a limited circle, her purpose to attead ifprice was not known, -and her appear tnce ivas a surprise to most of the congre gation. The pulpit was filled by the Rev. 3urnham of Springfield, a former minister ind friend of the Borden family.

See the clipping

In the story →

The Evening World · New York, N.Y.

Lizzie Borden attended morning service at Central Congregational Church in Fall River, marking her first appearance there since the murders at her home the previous August. She was escorted by Dr. Rowten and Charles J. Holmes, and her appearance surprised much of the congregation.

The Evening World · 24 July 1893 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

LIZZIE BORDEN GOES TO CHURCH.

Her First Appearance Makes a Mild Fall River Sensation.

See moreSee less

FALL RIVER, Mass., July 24.—There was a mild sensation at the morning service at the Central Congregational Church yesterday, created by the first appearance there of Miss Lizzie Borden since the tragic event at her home last August.

She was escorted to her pew by Dr. Bowen and Charles J. Holmes. Her appearance was a surprise to most of the congregation.

The pulpit was filled by Rev. Mr. Burnham, of Springfield, a former minister and friend of the Borden family.

See the clipping

The Evening World · New York, N.Y.

The report describes Lizzie Borden's first appearance at the Central Congregational Church in Fall River since the murders of her parents the previous August, which caused a stir among the congregation. She was escorted to her pew by Dr. Bowen and Charles J. Holmes, and her presence surprised most attendees.

The Evening World · 24 July 1893 · page 2

LIZZIE BORDEN GOES TO CHURCH. Bar Flrat Appaaronca fidukea ft allld Kail Klvar Banafttlon. PALL RIVER, Mau., July 2 -There was a in I Id vM)Hatlon at the morning service at the Central 'otiKregatlonal

See the clipping

The Evening World · New York, N.Y.

Lizzie Borden attended Sunday service at Central Congregational Church in Fall River for the first time since the murders last August, escorted by Dr. Bowen and Charles J. Holmes. Her appearance surprised much of the congregation, with Rev. Mr. Burnham of Springfield, a family friend, giving the sermon.

The Evening World · 24 July 1893 · page 2

LIZZIE BORDEN GOES TO CHURCH. Ber First Appearanoe Makes a Mid Fall River Sensation. FALL RIVER, Mass., July 24. There was a mild sensation at the morning service at the Central Congregational

See the clipping

Alexandria Gazette · Alexandria, D.C.

Miss Lizzie Borden made her first appearance at Sunday service at the Central Congregational Church in Fall River since the murders occurred at her home the previous August. Her presence created a mild sensation among the congregation.

Alexandria Gazette · 24 July 1893 · page 2

TELEGRAPHIC BREVITIES.

A fire broke out among the stables of deeming it lunacy, and be should stoo the District Reform school in Washing? the purchase. Respectfully, ton yesterday, resulting in the burning Georgb B. Tyler. morning service at the Central Congre? gational Church, at Fall River, Mass., yesterday created by the first appear pearance there of Miss Lizzie Borden since the tragic event at her home last August. Rev. O. D. Taylor, pastor of the Bap? tist church at Dalles, Oregon, was horsewhipped yesterday by Mis3 Hol comb, one of the teachers of Vwisco seminary of which Taylor is president. The cause is said to be Taylor's refusal to pay a balance due Miss Holcomb. The provincial council at South

See the clipping

The Indianapolis Journal · Indianapolis, Ind.

This miscellany column of odd facts and anecdotes includes a brief note that Lizzie Borden received nearly 100,000 votes in a Boston Journal world's fair coupon contest, but declined to make the trip to Chicago, so the runner-up would go instead. The item is one of several short curiosities about public figures and strange events.

The Indianapolis Journal · 25 July 1893 · page 4

ABOUT PEOPLE AND THINGS

1B0CT PEOPLE AND TllINGS. Hon. George S. Bot twell, when elect ed Governor of Massachusetts, was the youngest person ever elected to that olliee. Now be is tbe senior ex-Governor of tbe Stato as well as tbe oldest in years." Lizzie Borden polled nearly one hun

See the clipping

Daily Independent · Elko, Nev.

The item notes that Massachusetts' new jury selection law, which lets the judge pick jurors while each side retains a peremptory challenge, was first tested in the Lizzie Borden trial. It reports that a jury was selected in three days under this new process.

CorrectionThis set right an article from 4 days earlier.

Daily Independent · 25 July 1893 · page 3

The words of this article could not be separated from the rest of its page. Read it in the clipping.

No clean clipping could be cut from this page

Connecticut Western News · Salisbury, Conn.

The report notes that Lizzie Borden attended her old church for the first time since the murder occurred. This brief item appears within a roundup of miscellaneous news items from late July 1893.

Connecticut Western News · 27 July 1893 · page 4

Tuesday, July 85. The grand jury indicted Chief Ains worth. contractor: Superintendent Covert lud Engineer Sasse for the Ford's theater disaster. The Duke of Veragua says he is willing that a fund for bis assistance should be started. Lizzie Borden attended her old church for the first time since the murder. Joseph Jefferson denied that he was se riously affected with a cancer in the throat. Mrs. Eliza Luther died at Berkeley, Mass., at the age of 10G years 10 months and 26 days. McBride Brothers, owners of the steam yacht Yankee Doodle, announce that they will match their craft against any yacht in the world for $1,000 a side.

See moreSee less

A revolution has broken out in the state of Catharina, which borders Rio Grande do Sul. The issue of standard silver dollars from the mints and treasury office during the week ended July 22, 1893, was $351,834. Benjamin Richardson dropped dead while eating breakfast at Atlantic City.

See the clipping

In the story →

Waterbury Evening Democrat · Waterbury, Conn.

A Boston dispatch relays an unconfirmed Taunton rumor that Lizzie Borden confessed to killing her father and mother and is now jailed in Taunton. The report notes the story is unverified, adding only that the Borden sisters visited the Taunton jail that day.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

Waterbury Evening Democrat · 27 July 1893 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image

BORDEN CASE REVIVED.

A Story From Taunton That Lizzie Borden Has Confessed to the Murders.

See moreSee less

BOSTON, July 27.—A special from Taunton says that Lizzie Borden has confessed to the murder of her father and mother, and is now locked up in Taunton jail.

The story has not been confirmed. All that is known is that the Borden sisters were in Taunton to-day and visited the jail.

See the clipping

The Monmouth Inquirer · Freehold, N.J.

A brief news item notes that Lizzie Borden attended her old church for the first time since the murder occurred. This marks her return to public life following her trial.

The Monmouth Inquirer · 27 July 1893 · page 8

Tuesday, July 25. The grand jury indicted Chief Ains worth. Contractor Dant, Superintendent Covert and Engineer Sasse for the Ford’s theater disaster. The Duke of Veragua says he is willing that a fund for his assistance should be started. Lizzie Borden attended her old church for the first time since the murder. Joseph Jefferson denied that he was se riously affected with a cancer in the throat. Mrs. Eliza Luther died at Berkeley, Mass., at the age of IOC years 10 months and 25 days. McBride Brothers, owners of the steam yacht Yankee Doodle, announce that they will match their craft against any yacht in the world for *1,000 aside.

See moreSee less

A revolution lias broken out in the state of Catbarina, which borders Rio Grande do Sul. The issue of standard silver dollars from the mints and treasury office during the week ended July 22, was *351,834. Benjamin Richardson dropped dead while fating breakfast at Atlantic City.

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

A wild report claimed Lizzie Borden confessed and surrendered to Sheriff Wright in Taunton, but the story was disbelieved in Fall River where she was seen calmly on the streets. The report notes she had just offered a $5,000 reward for finding the real killer, and that she could not be retried anyway since she had already been acquitted.

The Providence News · 27 July 1893 · page 1

NO TRUTH IN IT

Not Believed in Fall River. SPECIAL TO THE NEWS. FarL RiIVER, July 27.—The report reached this city from Doston that Lizzie Borden has confessed to the murder that

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

A sensational rumor claimed Lizzie Borden surrendered to Sheriff Wright in Taunton and confessed to the murders. The report investigates and finds this false—she was merely visiting the Sheriff's family, having been seen walking freely in Fall River that same morning.

The Providence News · 27 July 1893 · page 1

GONE ON A VISIT

(SPECIAL TO THE NEWS.) BosTtoN, M.ss, July 21.—A special from Taunton states that L'zzie Borden surrendered her selt to Sheriff Wright this forenoon, She confesses to the murder of ner father and mother and is now an inmate of Taunton jail,

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

A wire service report falsely claimed Lizzie Borden had confessed, provoking outrage in Fall River where residents called it a cruel and unjustifiable fabrication. The piece notes sympathy for the Borden sisters and anger that their suffering was being dredged up again.

The Providence News · 27 July 1893 · page 2

INDIGNATION IN FALL RIVER.

nllcgod coniession of Lizzie Borden, The cruel story was uncalled lo¢ aud is m?ult.lfl.blo. tisonu par with the otler persecu tions that have attended this woman since that fatal Auvgust day. The slightest investigation would bave proved lis falsity. P ople here are very indignant over the eruel rumor, and the perpetrator would suffer badly were his identity known, Much sympathy i= expiescel over this digeing up afeesh of tie sorrows of the Borden girls. It was beartless in the cXireme.

See the clipping

The Herald · Los Angeles, Calif.

An evening paper had reported that Lizzie Borden surrendered herself to the sheriff and was jailed in Taunton. This report calls that claim entirely untrue, stating she merely came to visit friends.

The Herald · 28 July 1893 · page 6

A LiKzle Borden Ktiuior. Taunton, Mass.. July 27.—An evening paper published a report that Lizzie Borden had surrendered herself to tba sheriff and wae locked up in jail here. The report, is entirely untrne. Bna

See the clipping

Evening Journal · Wilmington, Del.

Lizzie Borden, already acquitted of murdering her father and stepmother, visited the Taunton jail. Her visit mistakenly led to an unfounded rumor that she had surrendered to authorities and confessed guilt.

CorrectionThis set right an article from the day before.

Evening Journal · 28 July 1893 · page 4

THAT AWFUL 80^IE AT AUBUEN Lizzie Borden's Visit to Taunton, Mas« , Yesterday, Gave Bise to uu Unfounded Rumor That She Bad Surrendered to the Authorities— Bloody Riot on the Floor of the Bouse of Commons. The court martial at Valetta acquitted Captain Bourke and alt the survivors of the Victoria disaster of all blame. The presideut of the court expressed regret that Markham had not disobeyed Tryou's order. No Foreign Interferenre Permitted. France gave notice of a blockade of Siamese ports on Saturday. lend Hose bery announced that England ouly gave Siam advice when asked and did not in tend to aid.

See moreSee less

Russia announced li-r neutrality, but ordered the Pacific rquadrou to hasten forward. France announced that uu foreign interference would be permitted. Lizzie Borden Visits Taunton .Val). Miss Lizzie Borden, who was recently acquitted of the charge of murdering her father and stepmother, Visited the jail at Taunton, Mass , yesterday. Her presence there gave rise to an unfounded rumor that she had surrendered herself and presumably confessed her guilt. Jewelry Makers Close Their Shops. Jew. iry manufacturers iu Plalnville. North Attleboro', Attleboro' Falls, and Attleboro, Mask , have beeu compelled to close their shops owing to lack of orders A majority of the inhabit unis depend on the jewelry shops for a livelihood. Violence In the Bouse of Commons. During the closing discussion of the Home Rule bill a remark by Mr. Cham berlain provoked T. P O'Connor to shout "Judas," kud thereupon a bloody riot occurred on the floor of the House of Commons Awful Klvctrocutlon of William Taylor. William Taylor was t lectrocuted at Auburn. The chair broke and Taylor regained life after the first application of the current. The dynamo tailed to work, and the city plant was used to complete Hie execution an hour after the first shock. The details of the first fail tire appeared iu Evening Journal's late edition. West Point Cadets at the Fair. For the first time iu the history of the West Point Military Academy the cadets will he taken ou a long journey, to the World's Fair in Chicago. Work of the Pension llnrena. It is expected that (he pension bureau will average over two hundred cases daily of suspended pensions. B.ay Refuse Oders of Bullion. If the price of silver should continue t-> go up iu London without any apparent cause the Treasury Department may refuse to accept offers of bulliou witbnui making counter offers, on the ground hat the quotations are the result of a ■ preconceived plan to force the prices up artificially. To the Victors Belong the Spoils. Civil Service Commissioner Roosevelt says that of the 4,000 clerks now In the departmental service of the United States, about three fourths are Republi cans. Tl>« Ladlis. The pleasant effect and perfect safety with which ladies may use the Caiifui uia liquid laxative Syrup of Figs, under ail conditions, makes it th«dr favorite remedy. To get the true and geiiulu» article, look for the name of the Cali foruia Fig Syrup Co , printed near the bottom of the package The Next Warren "Snlol^er. ,, The next Warren Athletic Club "smoker" will be given on August 17. Owing to many of the members going away on vacations it was decided to have no others until that date. Salnnlay, July 3!) V, T e will give to all purchasers of 1 pound Baking Powder a beautiful palace berr> set consisting of seven pieces Grand Union Tea Company, No. 609 King street

See the clipping

Springfield Weekly Republican · Springfield, Mass.

Ex-Governor Robinson, who served as defense attorney in the Lizzie Borden case, received a group photograph of the jury that sat in her trial. He plans to keep it as a treasured memento of the significant case.

Springfield Weekly Republican · 28 July 1893 · page 8

SFRINUFIF.LD AND VICINITY. The assessors find that there are 0307 tnen in [lie city liable to draft in case of war. A divorce absolute has been granted Abraham 1.. Gilbert from Sarah M. Gil bert of Berlin, t't., for desertion. ExGov Robinson has received from the jury who sat in the trial of Lizzie Borden a line picture of the jury taken together,

See the clipping

Daily Kennebec Journal · Augusta, Me.

Taunton, Mass. was excited by a report that Lizzie Borden had surrendered herself to authorities. The report proved false; she had merely made a brief visit to the jail.

Daily Kennebec Journal · 28 July 1893 · page 1

NEWS NUGGETS.

W ednesday. Daniel Sherburne of Xorthwood. N. II . sged took pans green Wednesday, and vomited the same, then shot himself in the head. He is not expected to live. Clarence M Overman, ex-president and director of tinCitizen's National Bank, Hillsboro, Ohio, was arrested Wednesday, charged with embezzling $.>o,(X*0 of the bank’s funds. Powell Crossley, attorney, Cincinnati, made an assignment Wednesday. His as sets are $2t*0.000, and his liabilities are unknown. Crossley has been speculating in land in Ohio and Indiana. Taunton. Mass., was thrown into a state of excitement Thursday by the report that Lizzie Borden had delivered herself up. It proved later, however, that she had merely

See the clipping

The Portland Daily Press · Portland, Me.

A false dispatch claimed Lizzie Borden voluntarily surrendered herself to the sheriff at Taunton jail, which was picked up by newspapers nationwide. The report clarifies she merely paid a friendly visit to the sheriff's wife, who had been kind to her during her earlier imprisonment.

The Portland Daily Press · 28 July 1893 · page 1

A T.ie About Miss Borden. Boston, July 27.—The following des patch has been received by the Asso ciated Press: Taunton, Mass., July 27.—Lizzie Borden is in 1 aunton jail, where she came and voluntarily

See the clipping

The Sun · New York, N.Y.

A Taunton dispatch refutes an evening paper's claim that Lizzie Borden had surrendered to Sheriff Wright, confessed, and was being held in Taunton jail. The report clarifies she merely paid a friendly visit to the Warden there.

The Sun · 28 July 1893 · page 5

I.I ralr llordra Isa'i In Tunatoa Jnll. Taunton. July 27, A report In an evening paper to the effect that Lizzie Borden had sur rendered herself to Kherlff Wright, mado a confession, snd was in the Taunton jail. Is without foundation. Hhe merely made a friendly call upon the Warden here to-day.

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

The item mocks people who spread a rumor that Lizzie Borden had confessed to the murders, calling such believers foolish. It argues that someone who endured her ordeal with such composure would not suddenly become careless enough to confess.

The Providence News · 28 July 1893 · page 4

Prorre who circulated the ramor that Lizzie Bordon had confessed must be great believers in the tendeney of human beings toward idiocy. The person who could go through the terrible orlcal Lizzie Borden endured, as she went

See the clipping

The Herald-Advance · Milbank, S.D.

Lizzie Borden made her first appearance at Sunday service at Central Congregational Church since the murders at her home last August. She was escorted by Dr. Bowen and Charles J. Holmes, and her presence surprised the congregation as her plans had not been widely known.

The Herald-Advance · 28 July 1893 · page 6

LIZZIE AT CHURCH. Fall River, Mass., July 25.—'There was a mild sensation at the Sunday morning service at the Central Congregational church, created by the apiwuranee there of Miss Lizzie Borden, the first time sine the tragic event at her home last August. She was escorted to her pew

See the clipping

The Salt Lake Herald · Salt Lake City, Utah

A Taunton dispatch reports that an evening paper's story claiming Lizzie Borden had surrendered to the sheriff and was jailed was false. She had actually come to Taunton merely to visit friends.

The Salt Lake Herald · 28 July 1893 · page 1

An Unfounded Story

paper published a report that Lizzie Borden had surrendered herself to the sheriff and was locked up in jail here The report is entirely untrue as she merely came here to visit friends

See the clipping

Vermont Phœnix · Brattleboro, Vt.

An Associated Press dispatch claimed Lizzie Borden had voluntarily surrendered herself to the Taunton jail sheriff, causing a stir in newspaper circles. The story was revealed to be entirely false; she had merely visited the jailer's wife who had treated her kindly during her earlier imprisonment.

Vermont Phœnix · 28 July 1893 · page 8

A I'nke Ilimlen Story. There was a shock In newspaper circles yesterday afternoon when an Associated Press despatch was sent out from Taunton, Mass., saying that Miss Lizzie Borden was In Taunton jail, having voluntarily sur rendered herself to Sheriff Wright. The story proved to be a fire-class fake. Miss Borden merely came to the jail to make a visit on the wife of tho jailer who treated her so kindly during her long Imprison

See the clipping

Wisconsin Vorwärts · Milwaukee, Wis.

The report initially claims Lizzie Borden surrendered voluntarily to the sheriff in Taunton following accusations of murdering her father and stepmother. A follow-up note immediately corrects this, stating she only visited Taunton and that the rest of the story was idle invention.

Wisconsin Vorwärts · 28 July 1893 · page 1

Warum?

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

See the clipping

Huntsville Gazette · Huntsville, Ala.

The report claims Lizzie Borden voluntarily surrendered to Sheriff Wright in Taunton jail and may have confessed to murdering her father and stepmother. It then recaps her earlier trial and acquittal at New Bedford, noting she had been quietly settling her father's estate since being freed.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 4 days later.

Wrong

Huntsville Gazette · 29 July 1893 · page 2

Has Lizzie Borden Confessed to Killing Her Parents?

WF&* LIZZIB BOKOES. No criminal case in the history of this or a- - other country excited so much attention as the one tried recently in the quaint little town of New Bedford, Massacmisetts. A young girl was charged with the most hs lious of crimes committed in the n oa revolting matter. The stepmother, it was proved was killed first. To have been killed by Lizzie without leaving any trace, the act must have been done by the young girl in a perfectiy neud state. This was also true of her own father, who.

See moreSee less

it was proven, was killed while asleep on the sofa one hour after the murder of his wife. After a most remarkable and search ing trial Lizzie Borden was acquitted. The case was tried before learned jurists, intelligent jurymen and law yers of national reputation. The trial lasted many days, everydetail of which is familiar to the public. Since Lizzie Borden’s acquittal she has been quietly at her home attending to the settling of her father's estate, which amounted to and over $100,000. She has been the recipient of many letters from crowds—both male and fe male—including several offers of mar riage. Her manner has been morose and melancholy to an unusual degree. This, however, was considered perfect ly natural. It is not knowij what statement she has made and anything like definite in formation is hard to get, but it is un derstood that she has admitted that she was the murderer of her father and his wife. __

See the clipping

The Morning News · Savannah, Ga.

A report from Taunton, Mass. falsely claimed Lizzie Borden had confessed to the murders of her father and stepmother and surrendered to the sheriff. The item clarifies this was a fabricated story, as she had only traveled there on business, and notes a confession could not legally endanger her again.

The Morning News · 29 July 1893 · page 4

Borden had only gone to Taunton on busi ness. The fresh correspondent who sent out the story was probably unaware that even a confession could not again place Lizzie Borden's life in jeopardy.

See the clipping

The Weekly Messenger · St. Martinville, La.

The Boston Globe polled prominent Boston women on whether Lizzie Borden had been tried by a jury of her peers, given no women served on the panel. Most interviewed favored allowing women on juries, citing fairness and examples from Wyoming and Washington.

The Weekly Messenger · 29 July 1893 · page 2

Woman As Jurors.

Apropos of the late Lizzie Borsc den case, the Boston Globe has ea interviewed a number of the leadVe1 ing women of Boston and vicinity of r on the question of women on ju0 ries, asking whether they thought that Lizzie Borden had been tried Jn

See the clipping

The White Pine News · Treasure City, Nev.

A newspaper miscellany mentions a new Massachusetts jury law, under which the judge selects jurors while each lawyer retains one peremptory challenge. It notes the law was first tested in the Lizzie Borden case, claiming a jury was chosen in three days.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 4 days later.

Wrong

The White Pine News · 29 July 1893 · page 1

GENERAL NEWS

Lizzie Borden case, and a jury was selected in three days. The object is to cut down law expenses and save time. A young lady who had been mar ried a little over a year, wrote to her matter-of-fact father, saying: “We have the dearest little cottage in the world, ornamented with the most charming little creepers you ever saw.” The old man read the letter and exclaimed, “Twins, by thunder!” It is just a little discouraging to a man to carry a yelling, squalling baby around for half the night and then sit down and reflect that of such is the [ kingdom of heaven.

See the clipping

The Morning Call · San Francisco, Calif.

An acquaintance of Andrew Borden, now living in San Francisco, recounts family lore including the Borden ancestry in Fall River and the famous 'skeleton in armor' discovery. He also comments on Andrew's frugality and estimates the inheritance for his daughters at $500,000.

The Morning Call · 30 July 1893 · page 20

STILL A MYSTERY.

An old-time school-fellow andJife-time friend of Andrew Borden. whosa myste rious death last summer threw the entire country into a ferment of excitement, is a resident of San Francisco and had much to say last night anent the murdered man and his family. Algernon M. Cook cast in his lot with California twenty-eight years ago, but previous to that time his life from child hood up was passed at Fall River, Mas«. Last summer he returned on a visit to his native town, and a very few days after his arrival Andrew linrdsn was murdered.

See moreSee less

Uoon being asked to say something anent the personality of his inuruered friend Mr. Cook said: "Andrew and I were second cousins, and from my boyhood up I saw him al most every day. Fall River ought really to have been called Bordentown, for it j was hi» ancestors who first settled on the ■itfl of the present town in 1635. "It was Andrew's aunt, too," continued Mr. Cook, "who discovered the skeleton in armor which stimulated Longfellow to write the appropriate verses. I saw it many a lime in my young days in the Atheneum building, but a big tire in 1843 wiped building and skeleton both out of existence. "As he grew up Andrew was said to op very close in money matters, but of that I don't know anything personally. Anyway, he was successful in his business ventures, and his two girls will have quite $500,000 to divide between them. "Lizzie Borden I personally did not know, for when 1 left Fall River she was a

See the clipping

The Morning News · Savannah, Ga.

A New York Herald humor piece describes how deeply the Borden murder trial captivated public attention, especially among women. It recounts a man's story of his wife's obsessive daily reading of trial coverage and her unwavering conviction that Lizzie Borden was guilty, dismissing the defense and the jury's reasoning.

The Morning News · 30 July 1893 · page 10

Women and Murders. From the New York Herald. “It is astonishing,” said my friend, “what an amount of public-interest is ex cited by a mysterious murder case. Ev ery man you meet could tell all about the Borden ease, and the opinions, of learned lawyers were picked ’up everywhere throughout the country. "As for the women—well, you know how women dearly love a mystery. I think if that trial had lasted much longer my wife would have been a fit sub ject for a lunatic asylum. M.v wife made up her mind at the time of the tragedy that Lizzie Borden was guilty of the crime, and in this opiniou she was

See the clipping