This editorial comments on the trial of Lizzie Borden, asserting that her acquittal was a correct verdict given the weak evidence presented by the prosecution. It criticizes the Fall River police for building their case on theory and suspicion rather than solid facts, suggesting they distorted evidence to fit their preconceived notions of guilt.
Montgomery County Sentinel · 23 June 1893 · page 2
The prompt acquittal or Lizzie Borden by the Jury at New liedtord, Mass.,on Teuaday, ’ will receive the hearty indorsement of all who have followed the lealimony in a cane which In every aspatl is nueof the most ex
A small town correspondent notes that the failure of Fall River police to secure a conviction against Lizzie Borden has left them in an awkward position. The comment appears amid unrelated local news items about baseball, weather, and politics.
The Aegis & Intelligencer · 23 June 1893 · page 3
proved. Miss Bessie Sawyer, Mr. Howard Bevard and Miss Marion and Aleatha Bevard are at the World’s Fair, Chicago. Mr. Harry G. Price, w-no has been on a visit to ins parents, w ill start for his San Francisco home on Sunday next. On last Saturday week, A. Wychgram, merchant at. Edgewood, was arrested by Con stable Melhorn and taken before Justice Hardy, charged with selling intoxicating drinks and maintaining a nuisance at his place of business. After hearing evidence Justice Hardy dismissed the case. The thermometer reached nearly 100 in the shade this morning. The failure of the police officers of Fall River, Mass., to convict Lizzie Borden has placed them in a very unenviable position. Jeuome.
The Prince George's Enquirer and Southern Maryland Advertiser · Upper Marlborough, Md.
This editorial discusses the jury's verdict of not guilty in the Lizzie Borden murder trial, noting that while suspicion remains, no solid evidence was presented to prove her guilt. It praises the conduct of the trial itself while criticizing the Fall River police for their investigative shortcomings, leaving the case shrouded in mystery.
The Prince George's Enquirer and Southern Maryland Advertiser · 23 June 1893 · page 2
Tbe Acquittal of Lizzie Bordeu. The jury iu the trial of Lizzie Borden reached promptly the only conclusion possible I from the testiraoney, a verdict cf not guilty. ■ In the absence of any other plausible theory - the suspicion will remain that Lizxie Bordou I may have committed or have known of the commission of the double murder ; but not a a shred of evidence w’as produced to make 1 this any more than a suspicion. Theie wts
Lizzie Borden has been found not guilty of murdering her father and stepmother, in a case called one of the most remarkable in criminal history. Despite the acquittal, public opinion in Fall River reportedly still believes she committed the murders, though the report notes the prosecution's case was weak.
Little Falls Transcript · 23 June 1893 · page 2
Lizzie Borden has been declared not guilty of the murder of her father and stepmother. The ise is one of the most remarkable in criminal history. Public sentiment
The jury found Lizzie Borden not guilty of the murders of her father and stepmother after a brief deliberation. The courtroom erupted into loud cheers and disorder upon the verdict's announcement, breaking the court's usual decorum.
The Weekly Tribune · 23 June 1893 · page 1
NOT GUILTY.
W'ai AnlllOnilteil. NEw B...niwoil, June 20.-The jury has acquitted Lizzie Borden of the mur der of her father and stepmother, with which she had been accused. The court came in promptly at 1.45, every seat in the room being occupied as usual. The chief justice then addressed Miss Borden by name, telling her that she now had a voice and could say to the
A New York Sun reporter describes the dramatic courtroom scene as the jury delivers a not guilty verdict, detailing Lizzie Borden's physical collapse and reaction. The report also notes that the defense's closing argument may have been unnecessary, and criticizes the judge's charge for inventing a new theory favorable to the defendant regarding the note.
Asheville Daily Citizen · 23 June 1893 · page 2
HE'S GLAD HE WENT
OF LIZZIE BOKDBN. From the New York Sun. Every juryman stood at right-abont face, staring at the woman. There was such a gentle, kindly light beaming in every eye that no one questioned the verdict that was to be uttered. But God save every woman from the feelings that Lizzie Borden showed in the return
The report reveals that the defense's choice not to argue before the jury was itself sufficient for acquittal, and details Judge Dewey's charge where he floated a theory of a second assassin regarding the disputed note. It also describes the jury celebrating with drinks after their long sequestration, and the Borden sisters' plans to help find the real killer.
Asheville Daily Citizen · 23 June 1893 · page 2
NO NEED TO TALK.
WILL Ill-NT Ol'T TUB ML'RUKKERS. The Bordens have no kindly feeling toward the police, and yet mean to com bine with them in the near future in fcrretinir out the murderers of the old people. To that end the cirls will clevote their enerev hereafter. But instead of leaving the case solely with the police they will ask their lawyers to co-operate with the Government whenever clues arc found to work upon.
A short item reports that Lizzie Borden, tried for the murder of her father and stepmother in New Bedford, Massachusetts, was found not guilty by the jury on Tuesday. The item is one of many brief news notices in this issue's miscellany column.
The Charlotte Democrat · 23 June 1893 · page 3
I 1 T O 1 ... nesaay, J une -int. 1 1 1 1 It is stated that positions have been found for fourteen of the nineteen grad uates of the Agricultural and Mechanical College. m Lizzie Borden, on trial fortho murder lo hor farther and stepmother, at New Bedford, Mass., the jury, on Tuesday, ,1 returned a verdict "noj. guilty." nwThe North Carolina postmasters ap pointed: At Dorr, Lincoln county, Laura L. Ballard, James Mullen removed; Waco, Cleveland county, lloylo Elliott. . ... - - I An Kxo.hanra trulv savs: The average 1 J
The newspaper comments that the jury's verdict shows police were wrong in prosecuting Lizzie Borden, and argues police must now find the actual murderer. The piece treats the Borden case as one of several short editorial items on the page.
Paper unidentified · 23 June 1893 · page 2
FBI DAY. - - - JUNE~23, 1893 Pat Winston says that he didn’t do it. The question that remains unan swered is who killed the Bordens. The jury having found that the Police were in the wrong trial as to Lizzie Borden, it remains for the
The report covers the third day of Lizzie Borden's trial, including testimony from a civil engineer, photographer, her uncle John Morse, and timing witnesses. Bridget Sullivan's testimony placed Lizzie in the home at the time of the murders but also emphasized there had been no unkind words between Lizzie and her stepmother.
A short item states that Lizzie Borden has been acquitted and released because the State failed to make out a case against her. It adds that the jury's verdict was righteous and a credit to its judgment.
Fisherman & Farmer · 23 June 1893 · page 4
Lizzie Borden has been acquitted land released, as the State has failed o make oui a case against her. The verdict of the jury was a
The report states that the jury found the police had conducted the wrong trial regarding Lizzie Borden, implying her acquittal. It notes that the identity of the actual murderer of the Bordens remains unresolved, leaving police to continue their search.
The State Chronicle · 23 June 1893 · page 2
FRIDAY, - - - JUNE 23, 1893 do it. Tue question that remains unan swered i3 who killed the Bordens. The jury having found that the Police were in the wrong tiial as to Lizzie Borden, it remains for the
This item reports that the jury in the Lizzie Borden murder case returned a verdict of not guilty. It appears as a brief mention among other unrelated news items in an editorial notes column.
Be it loss or gain, let us stand up like men and honest citizens. No one has met w'tli a more dishearten ing loss than The Commonwealth, yet would we prefer to remain in ruins than purchase prosperity at the cost of our self-respect and man hood.
Lizzie Borden's home receives around 200 letters daily, drawing attention from local post office authorities. Many letters come from Christian Endeavor and W.C.T.U. society members nationwide, while the Borden sisters remain indoors receiving callers.
The Jersey City News · 23 June 1893 · page 1
LIZZIE HORDES’8~MAIL. Fall River, Mass., June 23, 1893.— Lizzie Borden’s daily mail ia s ome tbing extraordinary, and Is a revelation to the local post office authorities. At least 200 letters were taken in her home this morning by the Iodo man who resides iu the house, and he makes frequent visits to the postotfice during the (lay. A great many of the letters come from members of the Christian Endeavor ahd W. C. T. U. societies throughout the country, nearly all of the large c ities being represented. The girls have not stirred out sines their Jarrival home, but are kept very busy receiving callers.
Lizzie Borden returned to Fall River to a jubilant crowd of 2,000 who gathered at the Borden homestead playing music late into the night. The report notes she called herself the happiest woman in the world, while questioning how she could truly feel so until her parents' killer is found.
The Silver State · 23 June 1893 · page 3
I Lizzie Borden Happy. Lizzie Bordep received an ovation on her arrival at Fall River Mass., Wednesday evening. She intended to stop at the Borden homestead, hut on account of the crowd accepted the hospitality of Mr. Holmes, whose house was thronged with people eager to congratulate her upon her acquittal. The crowd at the Borden homestead numbered 2,000 and re mained until after midnight, the band playing “Auld Lang Syne,” which created intense excitement. Miss Borden says she is the‘‘happiest -wWotnan in the world.” We should think that Lzizie Borden could not possibly feel her self the happiest woman in the world until the person who committed the atrocious crime of murdering her lather and stepmother is appre hended.
See moreSee less
Many are in sympathy with Lizzie, hut at the same time she was accused <>f the crime, tried, and although she was acquitted, the stain still rests upon her, and if the mys tery is never cleared, she will always he looked upon with suspicion.
Lawyer Jennings admits he has no provable theory about who committed the Borden murders, but says Lizzie Borden and her sister intend to keep investigating to find the real culprits. The item appears amid a column of miscellaneous short news items.
Paper unidentified · 23 June 1893 · page 1
ELECTRIC FLASHES. Secretary Carlisle has directed the July interest on the 4 per cent bonds to be paid Monday. A suicide epidemic has broken out in Buda Pesth and other Hungarian towns. Sevelf cases of suicide were reported at Buda Peath yesterday. Cases of insan ity are increasing. The lunatic asylums are full. It has been decided that, owing to the large number of people who will attend the funeral of Senator Stanford the ser vices will be held at the quadrangle of the university. The funeral oration will be delivered by Dr.
See moreSee less
Stebbins. Lawyer Jennings has no theory which he can sustain with proof as to who did commit the Borden murder. Never theless be says Miss Lizzie Borden and her sister will leave no stone unturned to discover, if possible, who the murder ers are. The hunt is alreadv on aud will continue. A fearfully destructive cvclone passed through Williamstown, Kan., and the adjacent country half a mile wide and six miles long, accompanied by a down pour of rain and the darkness of mid night. Ten dead bodies are already discovered, and it is known that at least five more were killed.
This report covers the defense's opening at the Borden trial, including testimony that other persons were seen near the house the morning of the murder. Emma Borden testified about Lizzie's bank accounts and property, a ring given to their father, and the paint-stained dress that was burned.
Butler Citizen · 23 June 1893 · page 2
The Borden Case. The defense opened on Thursday, and proved that other persons were seen about the house the morning of the murder. Mure of the same kind of evidence fol lowed on Friday, and Kmma Borden, a sister of I.izzie testified as follows:
The editorial states that Lizzie Borden has been acquitted, as most sensible people expected, leaving the tragedy once again shrouded in mystery. It also criticizes commentators like Mrs. Mary Livermore and Joe Howard for their coverage of the case.
Pawtucket Tribune · 23 June 1893 · page 2
For years the smooth round face of exPostmaster-General Wanamaker has beamed in the onation’s eye. The oon viction has been forced upon him until he accepted it, that he Is omne of those whom not to know argues yourself un known. The shock therefore to his nerves whena brakeman on a Reading train insisted upon collecting a fair, be cause he could not convince him of his {dentity, must have been sovere. The trainman who demanded efther sight of the pass or the money does not know it the saintly dry goods merchant wrote down his name with the object of recom mending him for promotion or dismissal.
See moreSee less
1t would not be a sure thing to bet either way. Lizzie Borden has been acquitted as every sensible person In the counry be lieved she would be. The most startling tragedy In modern times is therefore shrouded, once more, In impenetrable mystery. Meanwhile Miss Borden should muzzle her fool friends. One of the most persistent and insufferable of the lot is Mrs. Mary A. Livermore. Joe Howard is a good second. This man’s dispatches to the New York Recorder were an insult to the decent sentiment of the State. The Globe wisely divested them of the sting of bigotry.—[Boston Republic. The Btate of Rhode Island, through its
A short satirical item notes that although the jury acquitted Lizzie Borden, the Fall River Globe newspaper still considers her guilty. It mocks the Globe for standing by its earlier assumptions despite the verdict.
The Providence News · 23 June 1893 · page 4
RIGHT TO THE POINT
The jury acquitted Lizzie Borden but the Fall River Globe does not, The Globe stands pto be counted-before—its—name has been called. $ 98 The wheat-raising farmer is not rising in his seat to call the Democratic party blessed, $ 3 Police Justice Tighe would look most be coming in plain eitizen’s clothing. $ ¢ The press of the entire land is teeming with full accounts of what the president doesn’'t think about the silver question. 2 58 Piscatorial exercise has not been recom mended as a method for reducing the presi dent's adipose surplus, $ ¢ With all their search the only candidate that the Democrats can find for 1808 is one Grover Cleveland.
The report states that after one of the most remarkable trials on record, the jury returned a verdict of not guilty for Lizzie Borden. It notes that every attempt to directly connect her to the crime failed, though some still believe she may know the murderer even if she didn't commit the crime herself.
The Camden Chronicle · 23 June 1893 · page 2
The jury in the Lizzie Borden m. . . . . I case, after ono of the most remarktempt to connect her directly with
The report states that Lizzie Borden, who was charged with murdering her mother and father, has been acquitted by a jury of twelve men. It is presented as a short news item alongside unrelated national and local news briefs.
The Bolivar Bulletin · 23 June 1893 · page 2
Fon foreigners to receive from the American people unstinted adoration and praise, it is only necessary for them to be connected with the no bility. If Corbctt has an eye to business he will endeavor to engage Lizzie Borden as one of his troun. Exhibitions of e the two would insure crowded houses. Complete official returns of the Chinese registration under the dreary act shows that of the 110,000 Chinese in the United States only 13,179 have registered. Headsmax Maxwkll an nounces that he has appoint ed 700 postmasters since his accession to office. lie is one of the true blues that does notirrow wearv in well doinjr. The twentv-sixth annual V-
A brief editorial aside notes that the Lizzie Borden trial is as sensational as the famous Parkman-Webster murder trial of decades earlier. It appears amid a list of miscellaneous political and social one-liners in the paper's opinion column.
San Antonio Daily Light · 23 June 1893 · page 2
undersigned. T. B. Johnson, Manager San Antonio Light. Dallas State Fair will hang up $27,000 in purses for the runners and trotters. That should draw. The Lizzie Borden trial is as
Lizzie Borden returned to her Second Street home with her sister after spending the night at Charles Holmes' residence, appearing cheerful at breakfast despite reportedly breaking down upon entering her old home. Public sentiment in Fall River has shifted favorably since the verdict, with lawyer Andrew Jennings receiving many congratulatory letters and telegrams for Borden.
The Roanoke Times · 23 June 1893 · page 3
Miss Horden at. I all River. Kali. RlVRlt, Mass., June 23. ? Lizzie Borden returned with her sister to her home on Second street, after having .-pent the night at Mr. Charles B, Holmes' resi? dence on Pine street. Miss Borden sjM'iil i. very pleasant night and was very cheer? ful at breakfastin the Holmes residence. A domestic in the family house on Second st reel is reported to have .-.aid l hat the two girls broke down completely when they bad entered their old home. Lawyer An? drew J. Jennings is receiving letters and telegrams of eongral ulal ions from all parts of t he country, and Miss I {onion's mail at (.inpnstolHce is very heavy.
See moreSee less
The tamper of the people of the city has been changed greatly by the verdict and there is a mani? fest respect, for the decision id' the jury.
This report summarizes the Lizzie Borden case for readers, describing the household at 92 Second Street, the discovery of Andrew and Abby Borden's hatchet murders on August 4, 1892, and the circumstantial nature of the evidence against Lizzie. It notes the legal standard required for a first-degree murder conviction based on circumstantial evidence.
Clinch Valley News · 23 June 1893 · page 4
THE LIZZIE BORDEN CASE.
fico as second plus3 matter. F1UDAY, JtpK K THE LIZZIE B01vDE>T OASE. From tlie evidence iiddoctid for nud against Miss Lizzie; B?rden ut New Bedford) Masa., Iii? 'public is able to iorm a judgment. No otio miw uor professed to see tho commis? sion of tbo crime. There were no confossious of guilt proved. The eviduueo has been purely eircuinsliwi tial. Iu order to justify a conviction of murder in the first degree upon circumstantial evidence facts should bo cloarly prov?d which tiro abaoluto ly inconsistent upon any theory with the defendant'^ iuuocence.
See moreSee less
At No. 92 Second street, in the heart of Fall River, Mass., a town of 80,000 inhabit an I :i. within a square or two of tl io city ?hall, lived Audruw J. Borden, Iii? wife, Abbey D. Hor? den, and two daughter", Emma Hor? den, the elder, and Jjizi-.io A. Borden, the defendant iu this ease, who is ft young woman Ibirty.-two yearn of age. The only'other itimalu in the house wns a norvant, Bridget Sulli? van. The mother of the two young women, who are the only children of Andrew J. Borden, died BOtne twen? ty years ago. Abbey Borden was tbeir Btepinolher. Andrew Borden
This report reconstructs the morning of the murders, describing Bridget Sullivan's activities, Andrew Borden's return home, and the discovery of his body by Lizzie. It details Lizzie's own account of her whereabouts, Bridget's inquest testimony about timing, and the subsequent discovery of Mrs. Borden's body upstairs, noting the autopsy finding that she was killed before her husband.
Clinch Valley News · 23 June 1893 · page 4
told Mr. nud Mrs. Churchill of the .murder of her father. Mrs. Churchill came to tho house at once aud asked for Mrs. Borden. Lizzie knew noth? ing of her whereabouts, but nailed to mind the fact that her stepmother had told her previously that. She had reeeived a note from a friend aud. in response, wns intending to call on that friend. However, Bridget was requested to look for the mistress. . but she objected to going alone, and SirsChurchill went with her. As tho two women approached the I top of tho Blairs lending to the sec ond floor they saw on the floor of the guest chamber the body of Mrs. Borden. It was learned that she,too, had been-murdered iu about tho same
The report reviews forensic evidence, including the lack of blood on Lizzie's clothing and the stomach-content analysis suggesting Mrs. Borden died before her husband, while noting inconsistencies in Lizzie's statements. It then describes the opening of her trial in New Bedford before Chief Justice Mason and associate justices, amid heavy press and public interest.
Clinch Valley News · 23 June 1893 · page 4
girl's mind at tho tiiuo. Tho medical experts in Boston! who oxarnincd the stoiunclis of tho murdered man and woman testified that in their opinion .Mrs. Borden was killed from an hour to an hour
The report announces that Lizzie Borden was found not guilty at her New Bedford trial for the murders of her father and stepmother, amid cheers from a packed courtroom. It notes the prosecution was aggressive but the evidence was considered trivial, with police having no other suspect for the brutal hatchet killings.
Shenandoah Herald · 23 June 1893 · page 2
cres of land to supply the wood pulp to |! pake the paper required for a single ( wue, That is to say, more than two ! honsand acres of timber are annually A onsumed to supply the paper ued by t be World —Ezx. q Miss Lizzie Borden, whose trial at New ; edford, Mass, forthe murder of her|, sther and ste -mother nearly a year ago |« t their home in the city of Fall River, |, as deeply interested the whole country |g yr the past two weeks, was declared not aiity on |uesday, amid the cheers and |;, yars of the hundreds who packed the p yart-room.
See moreSee less
The prosecution was an no- |, snally able and bitter one, althongh the ridence against the young lady was ri calensly trivial. Mr. and Mrs. Borden | . ere found in their home with their beads |, most backed to pieces with a hatchet or |
The article reports that Lizzie Borden was found not guilty at her New Bedford trial for the murders of her father and stepmother, amid cheers and tears in the packed courtroom. It criticizes the prosecution as bitter and the evidence as trivial, noting jurors were ready to acquit quickly.
Shenandoah Herald · 23 June 1893 · page 2
Miss Lizzie Borden, whose trial at New ; edford, Mass, forthe murder of her|, sther and ste -mother nearly a year ago |« t their home in the city of Fall River, |, as deeply interested the whole country |g yr the past two weeks, was declared not aiity on |uesday, amid the cheers and |;, yars of the hundreds who packed the p yart-room. The prosecution was an no- |, snally able and bitter one, althongh the ridence against the young lady was ri calensly trivial. Mr. and Mrs. Borden | . ere found in their home with their beads |, most backed to pieces with a hatchet or |
The report describes the conclusion of Lizzie Borden's trial for the murder of her father and stepmother, ending in a 'Not guilty' verdict delivered by the jury at 4:30 Tuesday afternoon. It details the closing arguments by Ex-Gov. Robinson for the defense and District Attorney Knowlton for the state, Lizzie's own brief statement of innocence, and Judge Dewey's charge to the jury emphasizing the need for proof beyond reasonable doubt.
Vermont Phœnix · 23 June 1893 · page 1
I.lrilf llol ilrli ,(iilllt il. The trial of Lizzie Borden at Now Bed ford, Mass., charged with thu murder of her father and step-mother, ended In a ver dict of "Not guilty," which was brought In by the jury at 4:!!0 Tuesday afternoon, Kx-Gov. Bobinson made the plea for the defence Monday, occupying the greater part of the day, and Dislilct Attorney Knowlton begun the argument for the state, finishing just before the noon adjourn ment Tuesday. The dhtrlct attorney, in his argument, made masterly and cffectlvo mc of all the evidence against the prisoner, and many who listened to him thought Its effect on the jury to be such that there would at least be a disagreement.
See moreSee less
When the court reassembled at 1:15 the chief justice addressed Miss Borden by name, telling
The report describes the emotional scene in the courtroom as Lizzie Borden is acquitted of murdering her father and stepmother, with spectators and officials alike moved to tears. It reflects on the verdict, noting that while no legal proof existed to convict her, mystery still surrounds the case, particularly regarding the burned dress and an unexplained note.
Vermont Phœnix · 23 June 1893 · page 1
team and were completely blinded for the time. Mts Ilimlen's head went down U"on the rail In front of hrrand tears came where they had not come for many a long day. Mr. Jennings wax al most crying and hit voice hroke ns he put hir, hand our to Mr Adams who sat u?t to him and said. 'Thank Cod." while Mr. Ailiims returned the pressure of the hand and M-emed Incapable of speech Ex tiov. Hobinson turned t' the rapidly dissolving Jury as they filed out of their seats and beamed on them with a fatherly Inteiest in his kiudly eyes As won a; powible the room was cleared, although it wan a hard task, since every lnly wanted to shake hands with Miss Borden.
See moreSee less
Then she was taken to the room of the jUhtlctB and allowed to recover ler composure with only the eye of friends ilium her and the caresses of devoted admirers. At the expiration of an hour she was placed In a carriage and driven to the sta tion where she took the train for Kali Hlvcr." To the public who had so closely follow ed the course of the trial the result was in no sense a surprise, for the verdict was the only one that seemed.yossible to be found on the evidence. The Borden murder is the most remarkable and mysterious of which this generation has had a knowl edge, and the result of the trial only deep ens the mystery which surrounds It. What ever individual opinion may be, there was absolutely no legal proof that Miss Borden was tho murderer. JTlie on'J' two directly incriminating features of the evidence were the burning of the dress, which was ex plained on a reasonable basis, and the sto ry of the note which Lizzie Borden said her stepmother received on the morning of the murder and no trace of which or its sender has ever been discovered. It Is far easier to believe, however, that the send ing of this note was the work of a secret or crazy assassin than that Miss Borden herself committed both these bloody crimes. It may be possible to imagine that, as the result of. sudden anger, or of long sup pressed hatred, she could have struck down her stepmother, but it is incredible that, after the lapse of an hour and a half, she should, with fiendish malignity, have also stricken down her unoffending father for whom she had always shown a daughter's love. The prosecu'ion made the mistake of as suming that Miss Borden was guilty and then going to work to make up a string of evidence to convict her, instead of looking for facts regardless of their theories. In tills way they laid their case open from the start to bo quickly riddled by the defeuce. A great crowd surrounded the Borden house at ran Kiver Tuesday night, In ex pectation of Miss Borden's arrival there. The crowd were disappointed, however, for she spent the night at the house of a friend and the next day went quietly to her old home, which of late has been occupied by her sister Emma and a domestic. The hatchet which two boys found last week on a barn near the Borden house in Fall River is held subject to tho command of the counsel of the Borden girls. It was not allowed to go into the hands of the po lice. In a quiet way, through their coun sel, the Misses Borden will use every means to discover the murderer of their parents. It is said that, before ex-Gov. Bobluson would accept a retainer for Lizzie Borden, he visited her at tho jail, spent two hours with her alone, and satisfied himself of her Innocence. An explosion In the chemical works lit Odessa, Russia, caused blazing benzine to be thrown over the workmen, 10 of whom were burned to death.
This editorial argues that Lizzie Borden's acquittal was a foregone conclusion given the weak evidence, since the prosecution's theory of exclusion—that no one else could have committed the murders—was never proven. It dismisses the significance of Borden's remarks calling her stepmother unkind as insufficient grounds for suspicion of murder.
The Bennington Banner · 23 June 1893 · page 8
8 LIZZIE BORDEN'S ACQTJITTAL. Tlio acquittal of Lizzlo Bordon, Tues day, ou tbo obarge of hayinj: murdored her father and stopmother must havo becn a forejjono conclusion in tbo ininds of all wno havo intolllKently studicd tbo eIdonco, ot lack of evUanco, in' tbo caso. Tbo prosecution had to ntand or f all on tbo theory of cxcluslon that is, tbo theorytbatno ono olse than Lizzie Borden bad an opportunity to commit tbo crimcs aud tbat tbcory tho govern mcnt utterly falled to establigh. It was ovidont to common senso that a murder crontorinR tbo bouse, whethor bo cn torod on that fatal morninfr or the nijjbt boforo, did not advortiso bis ontry, and it needs no argument to domonstrato L6w llttlo tbo avcrago man or woman knows of tbo goinj and coming at tboir neiKbbor's dwellings.
See moreSee less
Doubtlcss if tbo noighbors of tho Bordon houschold had known in advanco that something ex traordinary was to occur in tbat fated dwclling thoy would haTO postcd tbom fiolvcs at stoop and window, and havo boon ablo to furnisb proof of somo con scquenco for or against tho oxcluslon arguraont. As it was thoy went about their bomo dutics as usual, and, sbort of an occasional and casual glance in tho direction of tho Borden proniises, tbey probably know notbing Whatever of tbo situatlon. Exclusion out of tho way, tboro vras praotically notbing to tho caso. It sooms that Lizzio Borden had, on ono occasion, said tbat hor stepmother was "a mean old thing;" but if such a ro mark implies murderouB dosign, then potontial assasslns must bo alarmingly cbramon. Sho bad also, for aomo timo, callod her stopmother "Mrs. Bordon." instead of 'mother;" but as the eldorly stcpmpther was a trim and well-pro-servcd woman, and Lizzie Bordon is not a very'young woman, it is quite possiblo tbat Mrs. Borden was well enough satis fl'ed to bo addressed by a term that did tiot imply tbo maternal relation to hor stopdaughtcrs. At loast tbis point is as good'as mostof tbo arguraents for tho m'ay havo bcon an entiroly innocent act on tho part of Lizzio Bordon, conscious of tho suspiclons against her, and fear f ul that oven a paint stained dress might, Tri tbo bands of a governmcnt analyst, bo transformcd into a blood staiued gar ment. Lizzio Bordcn's statomcnt that sho went to tho barn to gotlead forsink crs, wbcn sho might havo bought tho sinkers for a fow pennies, is perfeutly crediblo. The Bordens wero not a ponny wasting f amily. To a mind not mado up in advanco all tbo circumstances mentioncd seom pcr fectly compatible with the presuraption of Lizzio Borden's innocence, and it only injuerJ tho govornment's caso for the prosccution to attompt to distort the inost natural and coramonplaco incidents into proof of deep and dovillish designs. District Attorney Kuowlton's arguraont was not raercly strong it was altogother too strong. Mr. Knowlton no doubt bo lieved conscientiously. in his theory of Lizzio Borden's guilt. But bo ovcr stepped tho bounds of judiclous rcason ing when lie summoncd imaginatlon to tho aid of evidenco, and argued what Lizzio Borden might bavo dono or what
This commentary argues that the case against Lizzie Borden was weak, noting that minor remarks and her story about buying lead sinkers were innocent and consistent with her innocence. It criticizes District Attorney Knowlton for overstepping by speculating beyond the evidence and undervaluing her good character.
The Bennington Banner · 23 June 1893 · page 8
LIZZIE BORDEN'S ACQUITTAL
L6w llttlo tbo avcrago man or woman knows of tbo goinj and coming at tboir neiKbbor's dwellings. Doubtlcss if tbo noighbors of tho Bordon houschold had known in advanco that something ex traordinary was to occur in tbat fated dwclling thoy would haTO postcd tbom fiolvcs at stoop and window, and havo boon ablo to furnisb proof of somo con scquenco for or against tho oxcluslon arguraont. As it was thoy went about their bomo dutics as usual, and, sbort of an occasional and casual glance in tho direction of tho Borden proniises, tbey probably know notbing Whatever of tbo situatlon.
See moreSee less
Exclusion out of tho way, tboro vras praotically notbing to tho caso. It sooms that Lizzio Borden had, on ono occasion, said tbat hor stepmother was "a mean old thing;" but if such a ro mark implies murderouB dosign, then potontial assasslns must bo alarmingly cbramon. Sho bad also, for aomo timo, callod her stopmother "Mrs. Bordon." instead of 'mother;" but as the eldorly stcpmpther was a trim and well-pro-servcd woman, and Lizzie Bordon is not a very'young woman, it is quite possiblo tbat Mrs. Borden was well enough satis fl'ed to bo addressed by a term that did tiot imply tbo maternal relation to hor stopdaughtcrs. At loast tbis point is as good'as mostof tbo arguraents for tho m'ay havo bcon an entiroly innocent act on tho part of Lizzio Bordon, conscious of tho suspiclons against her, and fear f ul that oven a paint stained dress might, Tri tbo bands of a governmcnt analyst, bo transformcd into a blood staiued gar ment. Lizzio Bordcn's statomcnt that sho went to tho barn to gotlead forsink crs, wbcn sho might havo bought tho sinkers for a fow pennies, is perfeutly crediblo. The Bordens wero not a ponny wasting f amily. To a mind not mado up in advanco all tbo circumstances mentioncd seom pcr fectly compatible with the presuraption of Lizzio Borden's innocence, and it only injuerJ tho govornment's caso for the prosccution to attompt to distort the inost natural and coramonplaco incidents into proof of deep and dovillish designs. District Attorney Kuowlton's arguraont was not raercly strong it was altogother too strong. Mr. Knowlton no doubt bo lieved conscientiously. in his theory of Lizzio Borden's guilt. But bo ovcr stepped tho bounds of judiclous rcason ing when lie summoncd imaginatlon to tho aid of evidenco, and argued what Lizzio Borden might bavo dono or what
This editorial from the N.Y. Press commends the defense lawyers—ex-Governor Robinson, Melvin Adams, and Mr. Jennings—for their skillful handling of Lizzie Borden's case, contrasting their approach with the prosecution's efforts. It declares the verdict final and in line with enlightened public opinion, while noting the murder remains an unsolved mystery.
The Bennington Banner · 23 June 1893 · page 8
mucli botter than somo of his critics. IIo addressed his argumcnts to their common sunso; ho treated tliera as mcn of understauding, like hiraself; ho pre scnted the facts in their plain, everyaay, homely, intelligent mcamng, stripped of tbo hideous garnituro with which tho prosccution had endcavorcd to disflguro every petty iiicidcnt ia Lizzio Borden's coucfuct; and the result bas proved tbat ex-Govcrnor Robinson had graspad tho caso and handled it with an ability tbat nbt only deservcd but commauded suo ccss. Mr. Jennings, too, tbo Borden family lawyer, faitbful to the daughter as to tho fatbcr, morits no small sbaro of commendation for tho signal victory wbich crowncd the defcuso of Lizzio Borden.
See moreSee less
Tho caso takes its placo among the unraveled mysteries of cilrao. Tbo law has decidcd Lizzio Borden innocent of tho dced aud all who rcspccttho law will accepf-ifs decision as final. It was no busincss of Lizzio Borden's defenders to suggest wbo the murdorer might be. The'future may develop the trutb or it may only dcppcn tho raystery. The ver dlct of ycsterday bas brought to a ter miriation one of tho most famous trialg of the prcscnt or any othcr age, and it is sufDcient to kuow that tho jury's decis ion is in accordanco with calm, unprej udiccd ana cnlightened public opinion. TJ; Y. Prcss.
Lawyer Jennings states he has no proven theory on who committed the Borden murders. He says Lizzie Borden and her sister will spare no effort to discover the true murderer, and the search continues.
Fairhaven Herald · 23 June 1893 · page 1
Who Did the Murder? - NEw York, June 22—-The World’s Fall River, Mass,, special says: Lawyer Jennings has no theory which he can sustain with proof as to who did com ‘mit the Borden murders. Nevertheless
Lizzie Borden returned to Fall River with her sister Emma, reportedly breaking down emotionally upon entering their home. Public sentiment has shifted in her favor, with congratulations pouring in and most now viewing the verdict as just.
Wisconsin Vorwärts · 23 June 1893 · page 1
Erst verwünscht, jetzt verhimmelt
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
A short wire filler claims Lizzie Borden's case is said to be strengthening and that her counsel will soon 'explode a bomb' beneath the opposition. The item offers no further detail on what this new evidence might be.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Iowa County Democrat · 23 June 1893 · page 2
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
Shepherdstown Register · Shepherdstown, Va. W. Va.
A brief item reports that Lizzie Borden of Fall River, tried for the murder of her father and stepmother, was promptly acquitted by the jury on Tuesday. The notice is short, embedded among unrelated local items and advertisements.
Shepherdstown Register · 23 June 1893 · page 2
| may be the uieaus of saving your eon j t ot* husban^. ? j fc : Miss Lizzie Borden, of Fall River, who has been on trial at New'B-d ' ford, Afass., for tlje inqnjer gf faer ( j father and step mother, was prompt-1 fit I ly acquitted by the jury on Tuesday, ' *t 4
The piece reports that Lizzie Borden has been acquitted of the murder charge, calling the charge one that never should have been brought. It reflects on how acquittal cannot restore her reputation or erase the suspicion and ten months she spent in Taunton Jail.
The World · 23 June 1893 · page 2
The words of this article could not be separated from the rest of its page. Read it in the clipping.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
The World · Martinsburg, W. Va.
The report describes the tense courtroom scene in New Bedford as the jury returned its verdict in the Borden murder trial. The foreman pronounced Lizzie Borden not guilty, prompting cheers, after which the judge discharged her from custody.
The World · 23 June 1893 · page 8
LIZZIE ANDREW BORDEN A FREE WOMAN AGAIN
New Beiifokii, Mass., .lnni: 21.— There was a whirl of excitement in the courtin-.ise here Tuesday while await ing the verdict of the jury it, the i!«>r den case. Amid uppressed hut iri- | tense excitement the jurors tii,-'l inti I the room. Then ttie clerk, as is the custom, called upon the prisoner to look upon the jury and raise her head. Lizzie Borden arose, trembling, to her feet, and it was with difficulty that she trained her feet, hut when once standing she appeared as firm as a rock.
See moreSee less
Her white face was turned calm ly toward the men who held her fate in their keeping. “(ientlemen, look upon the prisoner,” said tile judge “< ientlemen, have you agreed upon a verdict, what say you Mr. Foreman?" liefore the judge hud finished speaking, the foreman of the jury quickly.replied "not.guilty." Cheer after cheer broke out upon the stillness of a midsummer afternoon like the report of distant artillery. The court studiously refrained from ail at tempt at suppression of this demonstra tion. and it was some minutes before all became again silenced and still. When order was again restored the formal question was asked: ‘You say, Mr. Foreman, not guilty, so you say, so you all say.” "Lizzie Andrew Borden," said the judge, “the jury lias judged you not guilty of the crime of which you were charged. Y'ou are hereby discharged from custody,” Then District Attorney Know)ton arose and said: ‘‘There uro two more indictments charging tin same crime upon Lizzie Borden. These
The jury foreman announced a verdict of not guilty, prompting cheers in the courtroom that the judge did not suppress. District Attorney Knowlton entered a nolle prosequi on two remaining indictments, and the judge thanked the jury before discharging Lizzie Borden from custody.
The World · 23 June 1893 · page 8
"Lizzie Andrew Borden," said the judge, “the jury lias judged you not guilty of the crime of which you were charged. Y'ou are hereby discharged from custody,” Then District Attorney Know)ton arose and said: ‘‘There uro two more indictments charging tin same crime upon Lizzie Borden. These
The report describes Lizzie Borden's emotional reaction upon hearing the not guilty verdict, including her fainting spell and the courtroom's response. It also details a reception afterward where jurors, attorneys, and even former accusers shook her hand before she departed for Fall River.
The World · 23 June 1893 · page 8
Kev. Mr. Buck, her pastor, could onlj weep. Miss Borden was led into the judge’s room and a reception was given her which was participated in by the citizens of her own home at Fall River, as well as by the people of New Bed ford. Newspaper men. judges, court offi cers, the men who had been her jailers and even the men who had been her accuser*, gathered around her to shake hands with her. Miss Borden left New Bedford in a carriage at 5:21 to return to her Fall River home.
Baxter Springs News · Baxter Springs, Kan. · and 2 other papers
After deliberating just over an hour, the jury returned a verdict of not guilty in the Lizzie Borden murder trial. Judge Dewey had charged the jury to decide based only on law and evidence, and when the verdict was announced the courtroom erupted in cheers.
LIZZIE ACQUITTED. The .Tory Declares Miss Borden Not (ioiltv of the Murder of Her Father and Step mother. New Bedford, Mass, June 21. The Lizzie Borden case was given to the jury yesterday afternoon, und after be ing out u little more than an hour a verdict of not guilty was returned. When court convened in the after noon the chief justice addressed Miss Borden by name, telling her that she now had a voice und could say to the jury what she chose to say. She arose somewhat agitated, and said to the jury: "I am innocent but I will leave my case in your hands and in the hands of my counsel."
See moreSee less
Judge Dewey then charged the jury. He read his charge rapidly, and among other things embodied therein was tho caution to make a decision only upon the law and the evidence given. The court defined the degrees of murder and said the degree is to be determined by the jury. At the conclusion of the charge, the attorneys consulted a few moments The jury was allowed to retire and counsel agreed upon what exhibits were to be put into the case, after which they were brought in again, the oath administered by the clerk of tho court, and the jury took the case.' It was just 4:510 o'clock when the spectators who had kept their seats patiently during the retirement of the jury, noticed a movement indicating their return. A moment later the twelve men filed into their seats and were polled. Miss Borden was asked to stand np and the foreman was asked to return the verdict which he announced "Not guilty." Then all the dignity and decorum of the court room vanished. A cheer went up which might have been heard half a mile away through the open windows and there was no attempt to check it
The Kinsley Graphic · Kinsley, Kan. · 23 June 1893
People's Voice · Wellington, Kansas · 30 June 1893
Arizona Weekly Citizen · Tucson, Ariz
The item wryly notes that Lizzie Borden has been found innocent and is now a free woman. It jokingly suggests she be matched romantically with a satirical figure called the Arizona Kicker.
Arizona Weekly Citizen · 24 June 1893 · page 2
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
The trial's argument phase opened in New Bedford with an overflow crowd, most of whom could not gain admission to the courthouse. Defense attorney Governor Robinson began his argument, asserting Borden was physically incapable of committing the crime and that only a maniac or devil could have done it.
Arizona Weekly Citizen · 24 June 1893 · page 2
TELEGRAPHIC. New Bedford, Mass., June 19. The day of arguments in th9 Lizzie Borden trial opened with a great crowd in the court house. Scarcely one-tenth of them could gain admission. A large proportion of those in attend ance were in fashionable holiday attire. The defendant appeared fresh and smil
A telegraphic brevity notes that Lizzie Borden was acquitted of murdering her father and stepmother. The item is one of many short news briefs from around the country.
The Bessemer Indicator · 24 June 1893 · page 2
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
Amid local Meeker, Colorado news items, a single terse line reports that Lizzie Borden was acquitted. No further detail or context is given.
The Meeker Herald · 24 June 1893 · page 4
Ed. Archer was Meekering Tuesday. Fourth of July Dance. In accordance with the time-honored custom, a public dance will be given in Ihe court house hall on the evening of July 4th. Good mnsic will he had, and ; a general good time is promised. By order of < Committee. Lizzie Borden was acquitted. Dr. Milton, of Denver, a dentist of high repute in his profession, and ex v ice-president of the Colorado Dental association, is now at the Miller House prepared to operate for all who may desire his service#.
See moreSee less
liis prices will be very reasonable ami his work the best. He makes a specialty of gold crowns on roots and bridge wmk. lie will re main one week. All persons interested should call early. For Sale, I will sell (or trade for cattle) my en tire bunch of brood mares, with stallion, colts. Allies, etc. For Jurther particu lars address, 5. Witter, tf .Meeker, Colo. Strayed. I will pay £5 a bead for information that will lead to tile recovery of two l‘- \ ear-old iron gray colts, both have star on forehead and white hind feet, and are branded P on left shoulder,
A humor column includes a joke advertisement for an optician, riffing on public uncertainty about who committed the Borden murders if not Lizzie. It uses the unresolved mystery as a punchline to promote eyeglass fittings.
Paper unidentified · 24 June 1893 · page 8
BUSINESS AND PLEASURE COMBINED. Please Mention “The Home” When yon Pat ronise the Advertisers* He—“ Well, what have you there?” She—“ Two of your old letters, my dear.” He—“Umph! What’s the first one—the forty-pager?” She—“ One you sent me when I had a slight cold before we were married. This half-page is the one you wrote last winter whet I was nearly dead with the grip.”— Truth. Some folks don’t see who could have done that crime if Lizzie Borden didn’t, but all who have their eyes examined and fitted by Stevens the optician, at his Allyn House store will see clearly in every respect.
See moreSee less
* “Boys,” said the teacher, “we must all work in this world. Did any of you ever get something for nothing?” “Yes,” replied every boy in the room. “What?” asked the teacher, in surprise. “A lickin’,” was the reply. See! See! Fuller stock of furniture than can be found elsewhere! Yes, C. C. Fuller has it, at 14 and 16 Ford street. It’s a positive pleasure to inspect his spacious well-stocked warehouse. After a girl becomes excited over ice cream it takes a great deal to keep her
A newspaper filler column mixing advertisements and jokes includes a quip that 'Lizzie Borden, they say, isn't guilty' to pitch a gingham sale at Sage Allen's. It reflects the acquittal already being common public knowledge, used humorously to sell dry goods.
Paper unidentified · 24 June 1893 · page 8
BUSINESS AND PLEASURE COMBINED.
Bros., Pratt street. He Had—“ Have you ever taken any pains to collect this bill against Old Meddergrass?” inquired the head of the firm. “Pains?” exclaimed the bill col lector. “Pains, did you say? Great Scott! I have climbed a dozen barbed wire fences, been chased by a bull dog, and picked half a pint of birdshot out of my legs. By George, sir, I have?” Lizzie Borden, they say, Isn’t guilty but if you don’t attend the great reduc tion sale of French and Scotch Zephyr ginghams at Sage & Allen’s you will be guilty of injustice to yourself. The man who never advertises always has plenty of time to balance up his
The report declares Lizzie Borden's acquittal unsurprising, asserting that public opinion agreed with the jury's verdict and that the prosecution's evidence was far too weak to justify her prolonged detention. It laments the suffering she endured during her ten months in custody and notes that the true killer remains unidentified and at large.
Middletown Transcript · 24 June 1893 · page 2
The acquittal of Lizzie Borden was not unexpected. The verdict of that greater jury—public rentiment, which sets upon every case, whether in court or out of it, is in perfect accord with that of the twelve sturdy men of New England. The case is one of the most remarkable on record, and h s at tracted universal interest and sym pathy. The prosecution had not suffi cient evidence to hang an Indian dog, and the marvel is that this innoeent woman was ever held for trial on such flimsy evidence. No light has been tbiown on the case, and the question as to who committed tbe crime remains a mystery.
See moreSee less
While the police have been seeking in vain for incriminating evi dence against her, the real murderer of old Mr, and Mrs. Borden has had ample time to find a place of safety bayond the reach of justice. JTiss Borden is found innocent of the crime witli which she was charged, but she will never bs free from the cruel sus picion of some prejudiced miuds, and until the guilty one is found, life for lter must be a burden. A (refined, cul tnred, Christian lady, confined in a prisoner's cell for ten weary months, a victim of tbe "theories" of the polio and detectives. What she has suffered in body and mind no human being can
The item notes that the Lizzie Borden murder trial became a major national topic, with the New York Herald soliciting opinions from lawyers, judges, and citizens on her guilt or innocence before the jury's verdict. It praises this as an example of enterprising modern journalism.
The Freeman · 24 June 1893 · page 4
The Lizzie Borden murder trial be came almost a national issue. The New York Herald sent out feelers all over the Union in advance of the
The report states that Lizzie Borden was found not guilty by the jury in the New Bedford criminal court on Tuesday, given the weak evidence presented by the prosecution for the charge of parricide. It notes the courtroom erupted in applause at the verdict, and that Lizzie was quietly taken to the train station afterward to return to Fall River, though she likely would not stay there long.
Washington Journal · 24 June 1893 · page 4
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
The report announces that the murder trial against Lizzie Borden has begun before the jury court in New Bedford, Mass., drawing nationwide attention. It recaps the background: in August of the previous year, Andrew Borden and his second wife were found gruesomely murdered in their home in Fall River, with public opinion quickly pointing to his daughter from his first marriage as the perpetrator.
Washington Journal · 24 June 1893 · page 8
Lizzie Borden.
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
Lizzie Borden was freed after the jury deliberated only briefly before returning a verdict of acquittal. The crowd greeted the outcome, which was widely expected, with great enthusiasm and gave her an ovation.
The Atchison Blade · 24 June 1893 · page 2
LIZZIE BORDEN ACQUITTED. End of the Sensational Now England Murder Trial. New Bedford, Mass., June 21.— Lizzie Borden is free at last after ten months’ imprisonment. Yesterday afternoon the famous mur
A short item reports that Lizzie Borden, accused of murdering her father, step-mother, and banker J. H. Borden, has been acquitted after the jury deliberated for one hour and twenty minutes. It notes the case had been before the public for nearly a year.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Atchison Blade · 24 June 1893 · page 4
moulders in the foundry bnt is not allow ed to ’ work at his trade, he is a colored man. Some of the employes have beeu working at the foundry for 15 years.. All colored men used to have the yard work but gradually dropped off. The rousta bouts are those who carry the ladles of hot iron though it iser, to a strange,hot as haydes the boys seem to “sweat and work on” occasionally striking up a melody. The foundry boys are a jolly good lot of fallows and are not afraid to spend their money most all of them take The Blade and pay for It.
See moreSee less
We will tell you who the moulders, core makers, offbearers etc. are in our next wiite up. Hagan, the jeweier, wishes to draw the attention of the colored people of Atehl son so he has put into force his special sale of silver ware. You can buy knives, forks, spoons etc at his place to-day and all next week at lower* prices than any place In town give him a call. Corner of 6th and Commercial street This is what Governor Tillman of South Carolina recently said “There is one county in the state of North Carolina where the Negroes have political control and where they outnumber the whites ten to one—that is, Beauford—and there we have very little crime. I believe that county has less proportional representa tion In the penitentiary than any other in the State.l can not explain or speculate, but these are the plain blunt facts.” How can you stand the heat ? just this way; go to the Fair and get a good suit of Gentleman’s underware, only 58cents The home of B. F. Hudson in south Atchison was almost entirely destroyed by Hie Monday night. It is supposed it was set on fire by envious persons. Lizzie Borden who was accused of mur dering her father, step-mother and bank er J. H. Borden has been acquitted. The jury was out just one hour and twenty minutes. The famous Borden case has been before the public for nearly a year. A “Black Button Scamp’’ of Atchison says: “I went to Lawrence and took the Journal and found a Record of the World, returning to Atchison and being a Patriot took The Blade and became the Champion of the Globe. Horrible! Look here: summer shirts from 25 cents up at the Fair. Church Notes: Rev J. W. Wilson re turned from Lincoln last week.... Festival at Shiloh church to-night, a grand concert will be given next Friday night.... Mt. Olive church has done good work since they have been in their present location having reduced a debt of $l7O to SBS In a very short while; Rev. Taylor is certainly a worker... .Ebenezer church had a rally last Sunday and succeeded in raising $350, 96, including entertainments of Boone and Literary. The Wheatley literary raised $127.56 of i<self, the net clearings of the rally were about $250; Grand Sunday School picnic to-morrow at Forest Park. Rev. P. D. Yochum of the A. M. E. church extends a cordial invitation to the members and friends of the other church, es of the city to come over and assist him in his effort to pay off the mortgage debt on his ehurch; he desires to raise SBOO. Rev. A. Grant of Grand Junction, Col, Will assist Rev. Yochum Sunday. Rev. Sylvia Cuflman, a lady divine of Topeka, Kansas will be here Sunday to preach for him also. , Prcd P. Barrett keeps tho best Baking Powder in the city, 15centi a can, try it.
The report recaps how the prosecution's case was weakened under cross-examination by ex-Governor Robinson, leaving only Lizzie Borden's inconsistent statements, the note story, and the burned dress as notable points. It then details the defense's testimony, including witnesses describing a mysterious stranger near the Borden house and evidence about undisturbed dust in the barn loft contradicting Lizzie's account.
The Washington Bee · 24 June 1893 · page 4
LIZZIE BORDEN'S DEFENSE. Close of the Trial at New Bedford, Massachusetts.
that it was left by the skillful cross-examining of ex-Governor Robinson. The only points of the case for the prosecu tion left practically in good shape after cross-examination were the inconsistant explanations of Lizzie Borden as to her whereabouts and actions on the morning of the murder, the story told by her in regard to a note received on the morning of the murder by Mrs. Borden from a sick friend, and the facts in relation to burning a dress three days after the murder. The testimony for the defence was all completed by Saturday last. It was directed principally to proving that the prosecution proved nothing. Several witnesses testified to seeing a strange
The defense presented witnesses including an ice cream dealer who saw a woman leaving the barn, boys who found undisturbed dust in the loft, and testimony about a strange man near the Borden house. Emma Borden testified about family harmony and the burned dress, while the prison matron's damaging account was discredited.
The Washington Bee · 24 June 1893 · page 4
LIZZIE BORDEN'S DEFENSE.
Lizzie said aloud ; "You have given me away," was entirely discredited. Evi dence was brought to prove that Lizzie Borden had soiled a dress with paint while the Borden house was being painted some months previously, and that this dress was the one she burned
Fall River reports that Lizzie Borden is receiving hundreds of letters daily, many from Christian Endeavor and W.C.T.U. members nationwide. The sisters stay home but receive callers, while Marshal Hilliard and Mayor Coughlin get hostile letters, and rumors circulate of a lucrative museum appearance offer for Lizzie.
New-York Tribune · 24 June 1893 · page 11
LIZZIE BORDEN RECEIVING MANY LETTERS. Fall River, Mass, June 08. —LizzA¢ Borden's dally mall 1s something extraordinary. Al least 200 letters were received by her this morning. A great many of the letters came from members of the Christtan En deavop and W. C. T. U. societtes throughont the coun try, nearly all of the large cities belnz represented, The girls have not stirred out stnee thelr arrival home, but are kept busy receiving callers. Marshal Hilliard and Mayor Coughlin are recetving some astonishing letters, most of them being of a most vilifving char acter.
See moreSee less
Among the enrlositles Marshal Hilliard Las received Is a large leather medal from New-York state, It is reported to-day that Miss Borden has received an offer to appear in a nuisennm at a very heavy salary. This oifer probably came in ler all, just as the ofler cameo Captain Philip Marrington to accept a place Ina millinery establishment at the rate of #0,000 a year.
Lizzie Borden received over 200 letters in a single day's mail, many from Christian Endeavor and W.C.T.U. societies, since returning home. She has not left the house but receives many callers, while Marshal Hilliard and the mayor also get letters, mostly abusive.
Paper unidentified · 24 June 1893 · page 1
LETTERS FOR LIZZIE BORDEN. Fall River, Maw., June2s.—Lizzie Borden’s daily mail is extraordinary. Over 200 letters were taken to her this morning by the carrier. Many are
A satirical news digest notes that Lizzie Borden spent ten months in jail before her release, joking that Massachusetts will spare her a 'board bill' for her stay. The item is a brief aside among other miscellaneous news quips rather than a full report.
Evening Star · 24 June 1893 · page 4
Lizzie Borden was in jail ten months. It is understood that the commonwealth of Mma-n husetts will, In its emagna=nimity, refrain from ,rescnting a beard bill. It is doubtiess renssuring to the President to think on the quantities of advice that will have las to a-cumulate before he gets hack froma ray Gables. -It is a scientlle fact that Chinam=an are re tlnes that postpoues the operation af the
Amid a garbled roundup of miscellaneous news items (Chinese immigration, a naval disaster, political notes), the item briefly states that the Borden case has come to an end, with Lizzie Borden being acquitted of the charge of murder. The notice is terse, offering no detail on the verdict or trial proceedings.
Evening Star · 24 June 1893 · page 4
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
The report states that Lizzie Borden, accused of killing her father and step-mother in Fall River, Massachusetts, was acquitted. It adds that she received a grand ovation upon returning home.
Elmore Bulletin · 24 June 1893 · page 2
Falls. The next session of the grand the lodge will lie held at Pocatello, beginning on the second Tuesday in June, IHtM. Lizzie Borden, accused of killing her father and *tep-niother at r all* ]„ River, Mas«., wu acquitted on the ! i; | ^ ' She received a grand ovation
The report states that Lizzie Borden of Fall River, Massachusetts, charged with the murder of her father and stepmother, was acquitted by the jury after just fifty minutes of deliberation. It notes the case was one of the most remarkable in New England criminal history.
Blackfoot News · 24 June 1893 · page 8
World's Fair. Mike Leitcb, of Pullman, Washing ton, a debtor to the Moscow National bank, attempted to shoot R. S. Browne the president, Monday. Tbe ball made a slight wound on Browne's neck. Brown is a nephew of Governor Mc Connell. Lizzie Borden, of Falls River, Mass achusetts, charged with tbe malicious murder of her father and stepmother, was acquitted in fifty minutes after the case was given to the jury. In In many respects, this was one of the j most remarkable cases known in the j of ' criminal history of New England. ' One hundred and eighty miners are ; out on a 8triltc again at Gem in the
The jury deliberated for an hour and twenty minutes before returning a verdict of not guilty in the Lizzie Borden murder trial. She was greeted with cheers in New Bedford and later by 2,000 well-wishers at her home in Fall River.
The Ketchum Keystone · 24 June 1893 · page 3
Lizzie Borden Acquitted. The curtain has fallen upon the celebrated Borden murder trial. The final scene was the acquittal of Lizzie Borden of the terrible crime for which she was charged. For many months this poor girl has been under the stigma of an awful accusation, and suffering imprison ment in the gloomy walls of a cell. The jury were out an hour and twenty minutes and reached the conclusion of a "verdict of not guilty." Her acquittal was received with tremendous cheers by the peo ple. Miss Borden, affected to tears, was taken to a carriage and driven to the depot where she took the train for her home at Fall River.
See moreSee less
When she reached that city there were 2,000 people waiting at the old homestead to extend their con gratulations for her acquittal. The Borden murder trial at New Bedford, Mass., has excited a vast amount of attention in the state. The evidence has all been taken and arguments begun for the pros ecution and defense. The evidence seems insufficient to justify the con viction of Lizzie Borden for the heinous crime for which she is charged. The Borden murder will doubtless be added to the long rec ord of crimes that have never been solved. _ From the Ketchum Keystone we learn that the next meeting of the Idaho Press Association will be held at Ketchum on August 11. There is an opportunity for a press asso ciation to be a great benefit to the newspapers of the state. As far as we can recollect the principal busi ness thus far that has been accom plished has been the election of
A brief item notes that no one has sent Lizzie Borden flowers and no women have called on her, with not even a kindness shown to her in the courtroom. It appears amid miscellaneous news filler items from June 1893.
The Citizen · 24 June 1893 · page 2
A sweet damsel of Baltimore is about to be married to a minister. She con fided to the Other One that her wedding dress was “a dream”—satin at $7 a yard and $500 worth of duchess lace. “Only fancy,” observed the Other One reflect ively to me, “only fancy that gown—of course I mean a girl wearing such a gown—married to an everyday common preacher. Of course it isn’t as if hewere a bishop or anything like that, but an unheard of person living in an unfash ionable part of the city.
See moreSee less
Really, it is very inharmonious.” “Then why are you going to the wedding?” “Why'? Be cause I am a student of human nature, and such odd cases are an interesting study.”—Detroit Free Press. No one has sent Lizzie Borden any flow
On the tenth day of the Borden trial, Lizzie appeared in good spirits amid floral tributes from supporters. The prosecution's attempt to introduce evidence of her alleged attempt to buy prussic acid was blocked by the defense, and the commonwealth then rested its case.
Western Kansas World · 24 June 1893 · page 6
The X.izz!e Borden Trial. New Bedfobd, Mass., June 17. The tenth day of the Borden trial opened hot with a big attendance. Miss Borden was over whelmed with floral offerings and appeared in excellent spirits. The prosecution attempted to introduce evidence that Lizzie Borden had attempted to buy prussic acid, but the defense success fully combatted the attempt and the state was not allowed to introduce it. After the introduction of exhibits, the commonwealth rested its case and a recess was taken.
The New Bedford courtroom erupted in cheers as the jury foreman announced a verdict of not guilty for Lizzie Borden. The judge formally discharged her from custody, though the district attorney noted two additional indictments for the same crime still existed in another form.
The Middlesborough News · 24 June 1893 · page 4
LIZZIE BORDEN FREE
“Liaie Andrew Borden’’ Mid the Judge ‘the ury haa Judged you nut guilty of the crime of which you were charged You rs hereby dlarbargcd from custody” Then Iiatr!ct Attorn ey Kno Iton aroae and Mid : There are two more indict menta charging the name crime upon Lixile Borden Tlicae indlctmenta are of another form but refer to the name offence In view of the verdiet Jurt entered I dartre w en ter a nolle proacqui” District Attorney Knowlton then turned to I ha eounael for tlie defence and looking atraight at es-Governor
The jury delivers a verdict of not guilty, and Lizzie Borden reacts with visible shock before breaking down in tears of relief. She is then warmly received by supporters, including jurors, newspapermen, and even former accusers, before departing New Bedford by carriage amid cheers from the crowd.
The Middlesborough News · 24 June 1893 · page 4
Jury expressed a deal re to take the lainl of MIm Borden and tlie eyea of aoiur who were prraent euffuaed with inulat u re Governor Boblnaon waa the tint to congratulate her and even he the trained atlorney eould not repreat Ida emotion Xev Bunk her wtor could only weep MIm Borden waa led Into the Judgeto room and a raroption waa given bur which waa participated in liy the ritlaeue of her own home Fall Hir er aa well ' aa by the people of New Bedford Neaapaper men Judges court oflhwre the men who had Leen her Jailor and even the men win bad
The report describes Lizzie Borden's emotional departure by carriage after her acquittal, with crowds cheering, shaking her hand, and kissing her hand. It then details her evening arrival in Fall River, where she was met by large celebratory crowds who gathered at the Borden homestead and at Mr. Holmes's house, singing Auld Lang Syne, with Lizzie declaring herself the happiest woman in the world.
The Middlesborough News · 24 June 1893 · page 4
been her aecnacra gat lined around her to ahake liauda with her ' Miaa Borden left New Bedford In cirrlngo nt Dull In return to her Fall Klvcr home livable II in Borden there were in the party her friend M Holme tier unde John II Murjc her ilnter Kmma and her attorney Gov ernor Itobinaon Llxaio wm tlie first to ili-Mend I ho atalra to Ilia carriage Her face waa ttuibcd alth rxcltement Her mouth waa twitching ncrvoualy and aim appeared mure excited titan at any time aineo lier arreat Uovernor Koldnwin tiKk a aeat tiealdo Ida client oci'tipy lug tlie back aeat of ‘the carriage oppoaita tliem aat Mill Kmma Mr llolmea and Mr Ilonc It wai finally arranged to that all who wished tu do ao passed by tha car riage and aliook lianda with MIm Bure don and many eren went hi far a to kia her hand There were three cheer for MIm Borden which were given with a will and a tlie carriage disap peared from alght the duller of a little while handkerchief wa seen the part ing mIiiIc or the three women to the people who rejoiced at her releane llala Kenton IlnllN Fail Kivbh Mac June 3ft— fleaie Burden received an ovation on her ar rival hire thi evening She Intended to atop at the Harden Imim-stesd to night but on account of the crowd ac cepted the hospitality of Mr Holme whore house wa throng d with people
A short news item reports that Lizzie Borden, accused of murdering her father and stepmother in Fall River, Massachusetts, has been acquitted. The item appears amid a column of unrelated local notices and advertisements.
St. Landry Democrat · 24 June 1893 · page 1
Summer hat6 at J. K. Sandoz Bro s. The D emocrat o tuouths lor 50 cents. Fou S ale .—A rood second hand top : bupjry. Apply at t lâ in ofticc. Mr. J. N. Iîobiu has been appointed! poetuiaeter at Léon vi lie. Dr. Kendall's treatise on the horse can bo had at this office for 25 cents. cotton sold in New Orleans Middiin last Wednesday at 7 lljlG and rough rice | «t $1.25 to $2.50 per sack. -Miss Lizzie Borden, accused of mur j lieriug her father and stepmother at j Fall lliver, Mass., has been acquitted, j j Walter Chacheié repairs sewing ma chines aud guarantees satisfaction.!
See moreSee less
Give him a trial. U. S. Senator Leland Stanford, of California, died suddenly at his resi dence at Palo Alto, Cal., on Tuesday aright. She sang a song entitled "I'm in love with the man in the moon" and when asked why, she answered "Because he gets his clothing at Bloch's." J. B. Sandoz has an extensive assort ment of buggies, carriages, &.c., and his prices are probably a little lower than the lowest. Better see him about it.
The item reports that Lizzie Borden, tried in New Bedford, Massachusetts for the murder of her father and stepmother, has been acquitted. This is a brief mention embedded within unrelated local political and levee system news.
St. Landry Clarion · 24 June 1893 · page 2
Miiss Lizzie Borden, just tried at New Bedford, Mass., on the charge of -mur-i fring her father and step-nother, has been acuitted POLITICA L CA TECHISM. Question.-What kind of a Demo crat is he, who would approve of a De mocratic Governor retaining in office an appointee who had voted for the Harrison electors? Answer.-He is the kind who never votes a Democratic ticket, and is bent upon its disintegration and disruption. Question.-H-avewe any such in St. Landry? Answer.-Yes; the same old set who habitually kick out of the traces when fairly beaten in the party organization.
See moreSee less
Question.-What sort of a Democrat is that, who wanted President Cleve land to turn out a Republican post master in Opelousas and give the office to him. and who at the same time con demns Goy. Foster for turning out Du pre and Guidry to make way for two Democrats? Answer.-Let the Editor of the St.
A single terse line among miscellaneous news items states that Lizzie Borden has been acquitted. No further details or context are given.
The Colfax Chronicle · 24 June 1893 · page 1
Lizzie Borden has been acquitted. Every teacher in Grant should attend the Peabody Institute at Montgomery next week. IF YOUR JACK ATIXE Or 7';. are all worn out, really gac l for nothing it is general debility. '.y
The jury in the Lizzie Borden case of Fall River, Massachusetts, returned a verdict of not guilty on Tuesday. She had been charged with the murder of her father and mother.
The Democratic Advocate · 24 June 1893 · page 2
and many injured. Daniel Lord, .Ir., aged 22, of New York, ! I walked in his sleep on Tuesday at Chicago, j ’ | and, falling from a fourth-story window, busj j tained fatal injuries. At New York, on Monday, Frank Davis, ; . I the burglar, who robbed many houses in that : city, was sentenced to imprisonment for 24 { 1 i years and 0 months. In Montana and Idaho the mercury fell to i 4° above the freezing point Monday. Whib*-' east of the Rocky Mountains the temperature'! ranged from 84 to 98 degrees. The jury in the case of Lizzie Borden, of Fall River, Mass., charged with the murder !
Published days after the verdict, this editorial praises Lizzie Borden's acquittal as the only just outcome, calling the case 'remarkable' and criticizing Massachusetts authorities for allegedly manufacturing evidence against her. It accuses the prosecution of reversing the presumption of innocence and relying on police theories that fell apart under scrutiny.
The Cecil Whig · 24 June 1893 · page 2
LKTON. JUNE 24, 1893. IE BORDEN TRIAL. [rial ol Miss Lizzie Borden murder of her father and step , and which from the begin is enveloped in the profound itery, has resulted as every fnt reader of the evidence iit would, in her prompt il. Passing into history as [he most temarkable criminal hat has ever attracted the n of the country, the history ’. -Sphe prosecution is no less remark ■f we than disgraceful in the attempt wlhe public authorities ot Massa
This editorial, published days after Lizzie Borden's acquittal, harshly criticizes the police and prosecution for allegedly fabricating evidence against her during the nine months she was jailed. It concludes that the Commonwealth never had sufficient evidence or a credible motive to justify her conviction, calling the case one of unsupported suspicion at best.
The Cecil Whig · 24 June 1893 · page 2
| 1 the Commonwealth, but of that f [ sort of circumstantial evidence which it is apparently sc easy, if time and r opportunity be allowed, to collect or [ fabricate and wind about, as a death 1 coil, a person accused of crime. It is •Liuidteiy just to Lizzie Borden to say that from first to last the State ■ 1 had not a scintilla of evidence against her w hich would have justified her conviction; as it has proved, the evidence presented by the State K when weighed in the scales - with the truth scarcely, if at all, justified even a reasonable suspicion of her guilt. Certainly it was not sufficiently strong to keep her a prisoner for
The report states that Lizzie Borden was acquitted of murdering her father and stepmother in Fall River. It describes the jury deliberating only briefly before rendering the verdict, which was met with a spontaneous cheer in the courtroom.
The Irish Standard · 24 June 1893 · page 2
Lizzie Borden Acquitted. H, NEW BEDFORD, Mass., June 31.—Liz ^le Borden was acquitted yesterday of the charge of murdering her father and stepmother at Fall. River on, August 1893. Thejury was only out a short time, and when the verdict wtfs ren dered a cheer wexit up which mighjb have been heard half a mije away through the open windows aftd there was no attempt to check it. Indiana Bank Resumes.
This item compiles editorial reactions from papers across the country to Lizzie Borden's acquittal, including the Pittsburg Dispatch, Toledo Blade, Toledo Bee, Milwaukee Wisconsin, Wheeling Register, Nashville American, and Grand Rapids Democrat. The consensus view expressed is that the verdict was justified given the lack of evidence against her.
St. Paul Daily Globe · 24 June 1893 · page 4
LIZZIE BORDEN. Miss Lizzie Borden is not guilty. And the district attorney will find it a hard matter to explain why she was subjected to prosecution very like persecution and the taxpayers to the expense of the trial, if he cares to make the attempt.—Pitts burg Dispatch. Now she has been acquitted, because there was no evidence to convict her, and in the eye of the law she stands in nocent today. It would seem that time alone would tell the story, and even time sometimes forgets to telJ.— Toledo Blade.
See moreSee less
The verdict will receive the unani mous indorsement of every fair-minded person who has followed the testimony presented. There was not a scintilla of evidence to show that she was guilty ot the crime. -^Toledo Bee. She has bad a sore trial of twelve months' imprisonment iv the county jail, solely on suspicion. On thl3 ac count public sympathy has gone out to her.— Milwaukee Wisconsin.
At the New Bedford courthouse, former Governor Robinson delivered the defense's closing argument, contending the brutal nature of the crime made it impossible for Lizzie Borden to have committed it. District Attorney Knowlton then began his closing address for the prosecution.
The New North-West · 24 June 1893 · page 1
PLEADING FOR A LIFE
PL'EADING FOiR A LIFOE. Governor Robinson tlakes H-Is Ad. dress lbor Lizzie Borden. NEW BEeDFORDo, Mass., June 20.-The day of the arguments in the Borden case brought out a terrific jam at the courthouse. The jury wais polled promptly on the opening of court. and almost immediately Governor Robinson beganhis argument. He held that the fearful crime of which Lizzie Borden is accused was the nork of a lallnietc, and it is impossible that she should have committed it. Governor Robinson fnished at 3 o'tic ck and District Attorney Knowl ton began eis address for the prosecu tion. Railtoasdi:ls letatliate. LiTcocrx, Neb., June 20.-The rail
The trial of Lizzie Borden for the murder of her father and mother concluded at New Bedford, Massachusetts, with a jury verdict of not guilty. The courtroom erupted in cheers upon the announcement, and Borden, overcome with emotion, was later taken to recover privately before departing by train for Fall River.
The New North-West · 24 June 1893 · page 2
TrsE trial of Lizzie Borden for the murder of her father and mother, which has attracted so much attention through out the country for the past few dacys, was brought to a close at New Bedford, Mass., Tuesday, by the jury bringing in a ver dict of not guilty. The dispatches say that when the verdict was announced "all the dignity and decorum of the court room vanished. A cheer went up which might have been heard half a mile away and there was no attempt to check it. Miss Borden's head went down upon the rail in front of her and the tears came.
See moreSee less
Mr. Jennings was almost crying, while Mr. Adams seemed incapable of speech. As soon as possible the room was cleared, and when the spectators had finally gone, Miss Borden was taken to the room of the justices and allowed to recover her
Passaic City Record · Passaic City, N.J. · and 3 other papers
The jury returns a not guilty verdict after brief deliberation, and Lizzie Borden reacts with prayerful relief as the courtroom erupts in applause. She is later escorted to the train station amid cheering crowds and departs for Fall River to stay with a family friend.
Passaic City Record · 24 June 1893 · page 2
“Lizzie Andrew Borden, hold up your right hand and look upon the foreman. Foreman, look upon the prisoner. What is your ver dict?” “Not guilty.” At the words Lizzie Borden fell forward in an attitude of prayer and tho assemblage broke out into tumultous applause. The District Attorney rose and, after moving for the discharge of the indictment, said : “I now congratulato the defendant and her counsel.” As soon as practicable Miss Borden was re moved to the Judge’s room, where she was embraced by her sister and many of the friends who have steadfastly stood by her.
See moreSee less
When congratulated on her acquittal she smiled, and in reply to inquiries about her future plans referrod all to ex-Goxernor Robinson, who said that Miss Borden had made no plans, and only desired to escape as completely as possible from the public no tice. After the greater part of the crowd had dis persed, Miss Borden, accompanied by her sister and several friends, entered a carriage and was driven to the depot, where she took the train for Fall River, wh^re she became the guest of Banker C. J. Holmes. On the way she was repeatedly recognized and loudly cheered. Members of the jury say that an agreement was practically reached at the close oi the defence, and that it wac only at the suggestion of the foreman that they went through the form of retiring.
The Abbeville Press and Banner · Abbeville, S.C. · 5 July 1893
The Dickinson Press · Dickinson, N.D.
The jury in the Lizzie Borden murder trial returned a verdict of not guilty after deliberating for an hour and twenty minutes, and she was discharged from custody. The report details the prosecutor's closing argument, Lizzie's brief statement maintaining her innocence, and Judge Dewey's charge to the jury outlining the standards for reasonable doubt and circumstantial evidence.
The Dickinson Press · 24 June 1893 · page 1
LIZZIE IS AGAIN FREE
Her Stepmother. New Bedford. Mass., June 21. Tho jury iu the Lizzie Borden murder trial hns returned a verdict of not guilty, ami she was discharged from custody. The
After a thirteen-day trial, the jury acquitted Lizzie Borden of murdering her father and stepmother, prompting cheers in the courtroom. She returned to Fall River as a guest of Banker Holmes, while the report also recounts District Attorney Knowlton's closing argument.
Passaic City Record · 24 June 1893 · page 2
THE JURY SPEEDILY DECLARE HER NOT GUILTY
Weeps for Toy—Her Future. After an ordeal lasting thirteen days Lizzie I Borden was acquitted by the jnry which tried j tier at New Bedford, Mass., on the charge of i -aordering her father and stepmother. She ! was almost overcome when the verdict was ! read, and men and women cheered the flnd | ing. Miss Borden returned to Fall River, where she txacapie the guest of Banker
Following her acquittal, Lizzie Borden reportedly received about 200 letters in a single day, many from Christian Endeavor and W.C.T.U. members nationwide. She also allegedly received an offer to appear in a museum for a high salary, paralleling a similar offer made to Captain Philip Harrington.
The Sun · 24 June 1893 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
LIZZIE BORDEN'S LARGE MAIL. Marshal Hilliard Not Forgotten, Either—A Leather Medal Sent to Him. FALL RIVER, June 23.—Lizzie Borden's daily mail is. something extraordinary. At least 200 letters were taken to her home this morning by the man who resides in the house. He makes frequent visits to the Post Office during the day. Many of the letters come from members of the Christian Endeavor and W. C. T. U. societies throughout the country. nearly all of the large cities being represented. The girls have not stirred out since their arrival home.
See moreSee less
but are kept very busy receiving callers. Marshal Hilliard and Mayor Coughlin are receiving some astonishing letters. Among the curiosities the Marshal has received is a large leather medal. It is reported to-day that Miss Borden has received an offer to appear in a museum at a very heavy salary. This offer came in her mail. just as the offer came to Capt. Philip Harrington to accept a place in a millinery establishment at the rate of $5.000 per year.
The report claims that no woman in Fall River showed Lizzie Borden any sympathy during her trial, with none bringing flowers or comfort. It argues women spectators instead watched coldly, even smiling as testimony against her unfolded, contrasting this with how a man on trial would have been treated.
Morning Appeal · 24 June 1893 · page 2
PITILESS WOMEX. Not a single woman in all Fall River extended a single word of sympathy to Lizzie Borden during her trial. Not a spray of green or a single flower to gladden her, when aha came in, day after day, from her cold call to face tho scorn of the mob or the pitiless cress questioning of the attorneys. Instead was an array of har own sex who were there to see her writhe under the torture of the judicial pro ceedings, and who smiled and nudged each other every time the lash of testimony fell across her.
See moreSee less
Were it a man being tried, those same women would have covered his table with lower and filled his cell with them, A jury of petticoat9d sympathisers would have been turn ing heaven and earth to save him. Of all the cold, steel-hearted crea tures in the range of the animal kingdom, a woman stands at the head, when her own sex is the under doer.
A one-line item in a miscellany column reports that the jury has acquitted Lizzie Borden of the murder of her father and stepmother. No further detail is given.
The Wadsworth Dispatch · 24 June 1893 · page 3
The steam wagon is now running between Sierra Valley and Verdi. Refrigerators of all sizes for household purposes at Lang & Smith’s, Reno. * Mrs. J. W. Smith came in from Hot Springs Wednesday on a flying visit. Trout are taking a fly in the Truckee river. Now is the time to go fishing. Henry Esden is thinking of starting some kind of a business at Wadsworth. The California orchards and vineyards needs all the labor there is in that State. Preserve your fruit in natural state by using antiformentine sold by E.
See moreSee less
Gris wold. * The jury has acquitted Lizzie Borden of the murder of her father and step mother. A man with a board in the seat of his pants was hired by Foreman McKinney this week. Brooks McClane is the only man in town who keeps two bit cigars. The Reception. Wadsworth with its hundreds of green trees and pretty cottages is a lovely little town. We understand that the Wadsworth School Board elected teachers for the ensuing term but were unable to get the naraeB before going to press.
A Boston newspaper's reader poll to award an all-expenses vacation tour currently has Lizzie Borden, on trial for murdering her father and stepmother, in the lead. The item notes this as an ironic example of fame.
The White Pine News · 24 June 1893 · page 2
Such is fame. A Boston paper some time ago started a popular ballot for j the selection of a person who is to i have a vacation tour among the prom- | inent watering places at its expense. Up to date Lizzie Borden, who is on trial for the murder of her father and step-mother, heads the ballot.
The jury in the Lizzie Borden case acquitted her of murdering her father and mother after deliberating a little over an hour. The verdict was expected given the circumstantial evidence, and press reports indicate it met general public satisfaction.
Lyon County Times · 24 June 1893 · page 2
The jury in the Lizzie Borden case acquitted her of the murder of her father and mother after being out a little more than an hour. The evidence against her was all circumstantial, and the verdict, as rendered, was expected. It seems to have given general satisfaction, also, according to press reports. It will now be a fine piece of detect ive work to find out who is was that committed the fiendish mur ders. _ Six banks closed their doors in Los Angeles this week. Maybe the depositors therein, who lost by the failures, will be willing to give sil ver a show when they learn that the shortage of money and cause of suspension was owing to the failure of the government to pro duce enough money to carry on the business of the country.
The item reports that the murder trial of Lizzie Borden in New Bedford, Massachusetts, which had held the public in suspense, concluded with a verdict of 'Not Guilty.' This is a brief aside within a larger political news column.
The Ohio Democrat · 24 June 1893 · page 4
Every republican paper is de manding the repeal of the Sher man Silver law, yet Sherman is tho financial giant of the g. o. p. The great trial of Lizzie Borden for Murder, which has occupied tho court and held in suspense the
The report announces that Lizzie Borden's trial for the murders of her father and stepmother has concluded with a jury verdict of "not guilty." It recaps the gruesome axe murders, the household context, and the circumstantial motives presented—her strained relationship with her stepmother and knowledge of the will.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Dalles Times-Mountaineer · 24 June 1893 · page 2
THE LIZZIE BORDEN TRIAL. Tbe trial of Miss Lizzie Borden for the murder of her father and step mother, which has heen in progress for some days at New Bedford, Mass., and which has been a subject of great in terest in all portions of the country, came to an end yesterday by the jury rendering a verdict of "not guilty." This case has elicited considerable at tention because of the social standing of the accused and the atrocious man ner in which the crime was committed. Miss Borden is a young lady of educa tion, a member of the Congregational church, and highly esteemed by those with whom she associates The wea pon used in the commission of tbe crime was an axe or hatchet, and the bodies were hacked and bruised beyond recognition, presentins a most sickening sight to all 0 w wbo beheld them.
See moreSee less
Bridget Sullivan, a servant employed in the family? and the young lady were the only persons known to have been at the house at the time. It was near the hour of 11 o'clock, August 4, 1892, when the step-mother was killed, and the father was murdered about an hour after wards, on his return from Fall River. Miss Borden gave the alarm, and the circumstances surrounding the homi cide were such that she was held for the murder. It was proved that sh was not on very friendly terms with Mrs. Borden; but nothing was intro duced in evidence to infer that she was in any way at variance with her father. She knew that her father had willed half of his property to his wife, and this with her dislike towards Mrs. Borden were considered sufficient mo tives for the double murder. Not a half hour elapsed from the time Bor den was killed before she gave tbe alarm, and there was no evidence in her demeanor .that she had perpe trated such a terrible tragpdy. There were no traces of blood on her clothing, and the act could not have been done without tbe garments of the murderer showing some stains. Daring all. tbe time since her arrest she has not given the least sign 'Of guilt; but has apDeared Derfectlv composed up to the hour when the vevdict was rendered. It may have been possible that Miss Bord n could have committed the deed, removed all evidences of the crime trom ner person, ana oy me exertions of almost superhuman will power assumed an expression of inno . i i cence; but toe moral ana pnysicni probability of such being the facts is I verT remote. The acuteness . and ingenuity in destroying all traces of guilt are found only in hardened criminals, and have never been known to exist in persons whoseenvironment have been the church, Sunday school and the peaceful bonis. Dick Turpin or Johnathan Wilde mieht plan a mur der or a robbery with all the cunning possible; but it is hardly presumable that a young lady, who has led a spot less life, should display the same dia bolical art in covering the usual traces of an atrocious act Circumstantial evidence is very con vincing when the chain is complete; but there must be no other reasonable supposition to account for the tacts proved than the guilt of the prisoner. This is the way the law is laid down in the authorities; bnt frequently at torneys for the state attempt to - sup ply tbe deficiency by deluding the jury's minds into the belief that every link in the chain is connected, and the verdict is more often the result of the successful argument of the lawyer than an honest conviction of guilt In the Lizzie Borden trial the links in the chain of evidence were far from being connected, and there were many rea sonable suppositions for the - circum stances other than that she killed her atenmother because she did not like . , her, or was the murderer of her father for the reason that he left half of his valuable property to bis wife. The verdict will be approved by all fair-minded men, and it is to be hoped that other, juries will hereafter exer cise their .'own judgment, from the testimony produced, in rendering their verdicts, and not be influenced by popular prejudice or by the sophistries of hired attorneys. The dispatches contain accounts of
This editorial argues that the circumstantial evidence chain in the Lizzie Borden case was incomplete and did not meet the legal standard for conviction. It praises the verdict as correct and criticizes prosecutors and the public for being swayed by prejudice rather than sound legal reasoning.
The Dalles Times-Mountaineer · 24 June 1893 · page 2
Lizzie Borden trial the links in the chain of evidence were far from being connected, and there were many rea sonable suppositions for the - circum stances other than that she killed her atenmother because she did not like . , her, or was the murderer of her father for the reason that he left half of his valuable property to bis wife. The verdict will be approved by all fair-minded men, and it is to be hoped that other, juries will hereafter exer cise their .'own judgment, from the testimony produced, in rendering their verdicts, and not be influenced by popular prejudice or by the sophistries of hired attorneys. The dispatches contain accounts of
District Attorney Knowlton concluded his closing argument, asserting Lizzie Borden's motive was hatred of her stepmother and the need to also kill her father to avoid detection, while dismissing her silk dress explanation. Lizzie declared her innocence before Justice Dewey charged the jury on degrees of murder and the weight of evidence.
The Dalles Times-Mountaineer · 24 June 1893 · page 2
Lizzie Borden Free
tween the acts. , The speaker continued, arguing tha: the Bilk dress produced by tbe deiendaot was not tbe a'ess worn at the time of be murder. The two version of tbe burn ing of defendant's dress were irrecoucil iable. He discussed defendant's conduct since the murder He declared the story of tbe quarrel, told by Matron Rogan and afterward denied by ber, about a quarrel between tbe Borden Sisters was true. He
After closing arguments and the judge's charge, the jury deliberated and returned a verdict of not guilty in the Lizzie Borden murder trial. The courtroom reacted with strong emotion, and the district attorney moved to drop remaining charges against her.
The Carbon Advocate · 24 June 1893 · page 1
LIZZIE BORDEN
LIZZIB BORDElf. der became necessary In order to hide the staying of her stepmother, Mr, Know! ton oonoluded with a critical review of the evidence. After a recess the defendant was given an opportunity to speak. She said: "lam Innocent, but I will leave my case In your hands and with my counsel." Justice Dewey, In charging the Jury, stated the presumption, which was In creased by the defendant's character, and aid that guilt must lie proved to a moral eertalnty to warrant a conviction. The Justice concluded his charge to the Jury at 8:15, and they at once retired, while a breathless silence fell over the orowded court room, which was unbroken until the return of the twelve men who held Lizzie Borden't life In their hands.
See moreSee less
The Jurors filed Into their seats at 4:80, and were polled. Miss Bordeu was asked to stand up, ajjd the foreman was asked to return the verdict, upon, whloh he an nounced 'not guilty." After the verdict had been received the district attorney moved that the other cases against Miss Borden be nolle prosit! . and the order of the court was to that ef fect. Justice Mason then gracefully thanked the Jurors In appreciation of their work and faithful service. The jury was then dis missed and court was adjourned until Monday next, when the regular criminal session will be opened. Miss Borden's head went down upon the rati In front of hr and tears vame where
After Justice Dewey's charge emphasizing the presumption of innocence and need for moral certainty, the jury deliberated and returned a verdict of not guilty. The announcement produced an emotional scene, with Lizzie Borden in tears, her lawyers overcome, and a loud cheer from spectators that the sheriff made no attempt to suppress.
The Carbon Advocate · 24 June 1893 · page 1
district attorney moved that the other cases against Miss Borden be nolle prosit! . and the order of the court was to that ef fect. Justice Mason then gracefully thanked the Jurors In appreciation of their work and faithful service. The jury was then dis missed and court was adjourned until Monday next, when the regular criminal session will be opened. Miss Borden's head went down upon the rati In front of hr and tears vame where
The report describes the large volume of mail — around 200 letters in one day — arriving at Lizzie Borden's home after her acquittal, many from Christian Endeavor and W.C.T.U. society members nationwide. It notes that Borden and her sister have not left the house but are kept busy receiving callers.
The Providence News · 24 June 1893 · page 6
. Trying to Save Correlre’s Neck. ~ FawL RIvER, Mass,, June 24.—A good ~ many people here wonder why the counsel - for Correiro did not waive examination at - the start, Thursday, instead of taking a " whole morning to make up their mind . that the prisoner has no case. It turns . out to be a shrewd move of Lawyer Swift ~ and for a fixed purpose. He could not ~ hope to free the accused after all he bas ~ said about the case. Ie did plan to ~ lighten the charge, however.
See moreSee less
He will in ~ mist that the crimze was not one of murder ~inthe first degree, but of manslaughter, . and if he succeeds in doing this he may - pave the neck of the prisoner. Lizzie Borden's Sympathizers.
The report describes the tense courtroom atmosphere in New Bedford as the jury returned after 40 minutes of deliberation to announce its verdict. It details the silence, the spectators' anticipation, and Lizzie Borden's visible nervousness as the clerk began polling the jury.
Narragansett Herald · 24 June 1893 · page 1
HER INNOCENCE DECLARED.
Slowly the jurors filed to their box, and l:“t:b-ej the seats they had vacated when g. -+Then Clerk Borden broke the silence with the poll of the jury, followed by the customary question: “Mr. Foreman and geutlemen of the jury, have you agreed upon a verdict "’ Calmly and clearly came the reply from Foreman Richards:
The jury deliberated and foreman Richards announced a verdict of not guilty, causing Lizzie Borden to faint from the strain before being congratulated by her counsel. The report also recaps the original crime: Andrew and Abbie Borden found hacked to death with a hatchet at their Fall River home the previous August.
Narragansett Herald · 24 June 1893 · page 1
“Gentlemen of the j'ury. now, what say you, is the prisoner guiity or not guilty 7"’ “Not guihy ! Foreman Richards had spoken. The decision of twelve good men and true had been mae. The resait of the terrible two weeks’ ordeal toid upon Lizzie Borden, and she fainted. But it was only for a moment. Friends gathered around and offered their congratulations. Governor Robinson was by her side, and the rest of her counsel were in the group about her. It was a pleasant scene. Though the result had been a'most expected, there was almost enough uncer tainty about it to make the rejoicing hearty. Slowly the throug left the stuffy court reom, and the great criminal tria! was a thing - = The Crime.
This report reviews the investigation and police conduct following the murders of Andrew and Abby Borden, describing how suspicion narrowed to Lizzie Borden and servant Bridget Sullivan. It outlines the prosecution's theory of motive, opportunity, and premeditation as presented by District Attorneys Knowlton and Moody, naming defense counsel George D. Robinson.
Narragansett Herald · 24 June 1893 · page 1
Borden, the elder of the sisters, was out of town at tha time, it was evident she bhad nothing to do with it. As Mr. Morse, nncle of the young ladies, conld establish au ahbi from early in the merning until after the murder, it was equally clear that he had nothing to do with it, so the matter narrowed itseif down to Miss Lizzie Borden and Bridget Sullivan, the servant. For reasons satisfactory to themse!ves, the police selected Miss Borden as their game and from that moment to the present time have done nothing but seek to fasten the
The report describes the dramatic scene at the New Bedford trial as the jury delivered a verdict of not guilty, prompting cheers and emotional reactions from Lizzie Borden and her defense team. It details the courtroom atmosphere, including the judges' demeanor and the rush of spectators to congratulate Borden afterward.
The Kimball Graphic · 24 June 1893 · page 1
LIZZIE BORDEN ACQUITTED. A Dramatic Soene-The Defendant Break* Down When the Strain Is Over. NKW BEDFOKD, Mass., Juno 22.—The faradns ]Jordcn trial is ended and the
A newspaper's miscellaneous commentary column criticizes the New Bedford police for bringing Lizzie Borden to trial, asserting there was no real evidence against her. The remark appears amid a string of unrelated regional and political one-liners.
San Antonio Daily Light · 24 June 1893 · page 2
Southeast Texas would like it to keep dry until the cotton is freed from the weeds, but in this section the fields are as clean as a new baby on inspection. The New Bedford police are responsible for the fool trial that has just taken place. There was not one jot of evidence against Lizzie Borden.
A miscellany column needles the Fort Worth Gazette for boasting it had predicted Lizzie Borden's acquittal. The writer dismisses this as obvious, arguing the original evidence showed nothing more than a police blunder.
San Antonio Daily Light · 24 June 1893 · page 2
The Gazette, of Fort Worth, claims a scoop because it prophe sed that Lizzie Borden would be acquitted. A wooden headed Punchinello could have done that. There was nothing in the evidence on her original examination to in dicate that there was anything in the case but a big police blunder. In his argument for Great Brit ain before the Behring Sea com mission, Sir Richard Webster inti mated that Great Britain might not abide by the decision rendered. This brought the president of the Arbitration board to his feet with a jerk, and he the turn on Sir Richard so sharply that his English brain fairly whirled.
See moreSee less
President deCourca Informed Web ster that his language could not be tolerated, and that “neither coun try a party to this arbitration can break its word and reject the award made by this tribunal.” This would indicate that Great Britain is getting the worst of the argu meht, and is trying to crawfish, bi 1 she can’t do know.
The jury deliberated only briefly before returning a verdict of not guilty in the Lizzie Borden murder trial. Spectators cheered, Borden wept with relief, and she was later taken by carriage to the train station bound for Fall River.
Mineral Point Tribune · 24 June 1893 · page 6
IT IS OUT BUT A VERY FEW MINUTES
New Bi-dford, July 20.-in tie Lizzie Borden murder case this after noon the last arguments were made and then the judge gave a clmrg .lUit favorable to the defense. At the con eittsion of the charge the attorneys consulted afew moments and then (In jury was allowed to retire. It was just 4:30 o’clock when the spectators who had kept their s--;its patiently dur ing the retirement of the Jury, no ticed a movement indicating its iviunt. A monnnt later tintwelve ineu tiled into their settts and were (wiled. Miss Borden was asked to stand up.
See moreSee less
and the foreman was asked to return his verdict. "Not guilty,” was his reply. Then all the dignity and decorum of the court room vanished. A cheer went up which might have been heart half a mile away and there was no at tempt to check it. Miss Borden's head went down upon the rail in front of her and the tears came. Mr. Jennings almost cried, while Mr. Adams seemed incapable of speech. As soon as possible the room was cleared and when the spectators laid finally gone Miss Borden was taken t-- the room of the justices and allowed to recover her composure with only the eyes of friends upon her and du cat-ess of devoted admirers. At the expiration of an hour she was placed in a carriage and driven to the station, where she took a train for Fall Hirer. h--r home no longer probably, but sdll the only objective point for the present. Tin-1 A KLIMENTS.
The jury's verdict of "Not guilty" triggers cheers and emotional reactions in the courtroom, after which Lizzie Borden is escorted away and eventually returns toward Fall River. The report also recaps District Attorney Knowlton's closing argument detailing the prosecution's theory of motive and sequence of events leading to the murders.
Mineral Point Tribune · 24 June 1893 · page 6
the only objective point for the present. Tin-1 A KLIMENTS. New Bedford, Mass., June 30.—The great Borden trn.i is ended and as tills news slicing tamed over the wires the jurv are considering what they will r gistiT in court late to-night or to-morrow morning. There were as many people in the court room to hear the argument of the Borden trial as at any time during the session Among the peculiarities of the morning was the receipt of a box by Cov. Robinson, sent from Pennsylvania, in which was a small handleless hatchet The true inwardness of the gift was notap parent and the box was not removed from the janitor’s room.
See moreSee less
Miss Borden entered the room at 8:55, and Governor Robinson took a seat beside her and the two engaged in conversation until court opened Court came in at 9 o'clock promptly and District Attorney Knowlton picked up the thread of his argument where he dropped it last night. He spoke at length of the motive of the crime, saying the malice was all be* fore the fact. The wickedness of in gratitude had gone on under that roof for many months. Mr. Knowlton discussed the mur der of Mr. Borden, which he argued might have been induced by the fact that he was the only one who would know Lizzie, killed Mrs. bur den. Mr. Borden s movements on the morning of the tragedy were detailed up to the time lie was left alone with the prisoner. T e pri oner’s ironing was left unfinished wiien the crime was committed. Her varying explana tions of her conduct at the time of the crime were incredible. Medleys story of the visit to the barn refuted the defendant’s alibi, Reverting to the motive for killing Mr. Borden, he said that Mr. Borden knew too mu'h of the family relations, and Lizzie did not dure to let him live. There was no escape from the crime but to com plete the bloody work. The second murder was not planned, bat was done as a wicked and fearful ae essityMr. Knowlton reviewed at length the ev iden e as to the handleless hatchet, dwelling on the significance of its fitting the wounds and being broken short as if by design. He again returned to the evidence about the note, ;i ml then, powerfully summari ■ ing his entire argument, closed at 1 2:05 with an elegant appeal to the jury to decide as their consciences should di rect. EULALIE SOON GOES.
A rural newspaper's local gossip column mentions amid other community news that Lizzie Borden has been acquitted. The item criticizes lawyers and detectives who work for money and fame rather than justice.
Martinsburg Herald · 24 June 1893 · page 2
Lizzie Borden has been acquit ted. Those lawyers and detec tives who work so hard for mon ey, name and fame, and not for justice,—just as soon convict an innocent person as to clear the guilty,—should hang themselves. J - -— — “To Err is Human, to Forgive teaching, that he even seems like a disciple of Christianity itself. Divine." From the very accuracy and A citizen of this place who steadiness of his logical powers visited Mr. James H. Pine at the he is able to see what sentiments Moundsville penitentiary recent are consistent in those who hold ly, reports that the unfortunate any religious doctrines at all, man has so aged and changed in and he appears to others to feel appearance during his brief con and hold a whole circle of theo finement as to be hardly recog logical truths, which exist in his nizable.
See moreSee less
The prisoner stated mind not otherwise than as a that he hadn't a single relative number of deductions.” in the world. In talking over ern cities. his trouble he broke down and Jones Spring News.
The newspaper's editorial column congratulates former Governor Robinson on his defense of Lizzie Borden and congratulates the jury for their decision based on the evidence. It remarks that Borden seems to be a 'womanly woman' with much kindness in her nature.
Martinsburg Independent · 24 June 1893 · page 2
Flower, of New York and Gover nor thereof has renominated himself and has also reuominated Mr. Cleve land for President. The next thing to do will be to adjust the finances so as to stop so much destruction. If you please, discontinue the pres ent program. We congratulate ex Gov. Robin son on his Bplendid defence of Miss Borden, and we congratulate the ju ry on their action under the evi dence. As Mr. Robinson expresses it, Miss Borden seems to “be a wo manly woman.’’ If so, there must be a quantity of kindness in her na ture.
The report announces that Lizzie Borden was found not guilty, ending the trial with a verdict that satisfied public opinion, which had favored her from the start. It also describes courtroom scenes, including a mysterious hatchet sent to Governor Robinson and the closing arguments addressing the question of motive.
Martinsburg Independent · 24 June 1893 · page 2
W. II. H. Fuck, P. M. Miss Borden Not Guilty. New Bedford, Mass., June 2(1.— Mies Lizzie Borden is a free woman. The great trial ended this afternoon in a verdict of ‘ not guilty.” No ef fort was made to check the wild out burst of enthusiasm over the jury’s decision. Her friends never doubt ed her innocence. Public opinion has been in her favor from '.he first and eoerybody seem3 satisfied. Among the peculiarities of tbs morning was the receipt of a box by Gov. Robinson, sent from Pennsyl vania in which was a small handle less hatchet. The true inwardness of the gift was not apparent, and the box was not removed from the jani tor’s room. Miss Borden entered
This is a general newspaper filler column mixing local business directory ads with satirical one-liners on politics. One aside jokes that the hatchet doesn't mean the same thing in the Lizzie Borden case as in the George Washington cherry-tree anecdote.
The New Dominion · 24 June 1893 · page 1
VOLUME XXVII. There is a very heavy growth of moss all over the Ohio republican platform. The hatchet doesn't stand for the same thing in the Lizzie Borden case that-it does in the anecdote of
This miscellaneous editorial column discusses a suggestion that Lizzie Borden go on the lecture stage, arguing it would be unwise since she currently has public sympathy. It notes ex-Gov. Robinson, her defense attorney, called her one of the most refined and sensible women he ever met.
The Morning News · 25 June 1893 · page 4
Paternalism In Washington state over stepped itself in the passage of the anti cigarette hill, which our dispatches say has been pronounced unconstitutional by the Federal circuit court in so far as it interfere* with the trade of importers. Under the ruling all that is necessary for a > igarette dealer to do is to buy his stock outside the state, and go ahead and sell One of these days the states inclined to paternalism and the prohibition of luxu ries may find that In carrying out such a policy they are standing in their own light.
See moreSee less
The suggestion that Lizzie Borden go ijion the lecture stage is not good. She las the public sympathy now. but if she rere to attempt to turn her waking night tare of experience into money by talking bout it upon the rostrum, the publiemind wild revolt. However, there is little keiihood of Miss Borden doing anything
Amid a column of political commentary on Kansas Populists and Democrats, the writer inserts a brief remark about Lizzie Borden, suggesting that if she refrains from capitalizing on her notoriety through a book or lecture circuit, it would confirm the public sympathy she has received. The rest of the passage covers unrelated political and economic topics of the day.
The Wichita Daily Eagle · 25 June 1893 · page 4
Dick Morris had the. longest pole and now holds the revenue collector persim mon. And John 3Iartin and the stal warts are all looking askance not a risible anywhere visible. The man without a country is anob ject of general commiseration, but when 00.000 Democrats in Kansas find them selves without a party they should ask the prayers of the balance of the count'. If Lizzie Borden will exercise the
This editorial pushes back on the Lawrence Record's claim that Lizzie Borden was acquitted due to her sex rather than lack of proof. It argues the law presumes innocence until guilt is proven, criticizing the Record for reversing that principle.
The Wichita Daily Eagle · 25 June 1893 · page 4
Record makes the lemarkable statement that "Miss Borden owes her escape from the death penalty more to the fact of Jer sex than to any pi oof of her inno cence.'' It has been tho general belief that the prosecution of Miss Borden was instituted aud organized to convict her, "snd it may bo this to which the Record refers, otherwise its statement is an enigma. The presumption of the law is that a person is innocent until proven guilty. The Record would reverse the rule, and require the accused to first es tablish her innocence. The Register claims ;! -at 24.000 people live in Washington eounty. There is fer tility enough in the soil of thut coeuty to mstaiu 100,000 people.
District Attorney Knowlton argued Lizzie Borden's enmity toward her stepmother and fear of her father's reaction gave her motive for both murders. After Justice Dewey's charge to the jury on degrees of murder and the presumption of innocence, the jury deliberated and returned a verdict of not guilty.
Lizzie Borden Acquit ted. At the opening of the B?rdon trinl at New Hedford, Mass., yesterday Dis trict Attorney Knowlton resumed his argument in liehnlf of the common
This filler item jokes that the phrase 'Lizzie Borden hatchet' is becoming a popular cliché for short filler paragraphs, comparing it to 'Maxwell's ax.' It reflects how the case had already entered popular culture and journalistic slang by mid-1893.
The Salt Lake Herald · 25 June 1893 · page 4
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
Following Lizzie Borden's acquittal by a jury of twelve, the report argues the crime is thrown back to square one, with no family member responsible for the murders. It declares nearly a year of investigation and evidence worthless, insisting police must find an unknown assassin who entered the Borden house despite locked doors.
Richmond Dispatch · 25 June 1893 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
WHERE IS THE ASSASSIN?
There Is Mystifying Work Ahead for the Fall River Police.
See moreSee less
Now that it has been proved to the satisfaction of twelve men that a mistake was committed and that Miss Lizzie Borden did not butcher her father and stepmother, as alleged, says a Fall River special to the Providence Journal, the crime is thrown back to the afternoon of August 4, 1892, when the police were scouring the country for the murderer. Nothing remains except the fact that Mr. and Mrs. Borden were slain in cold blood, and the community is still saddled with a tragedy that remains unexplained. Opinions, whether changed or unchanged by the decision reached, no longer count. The accused has been removed from consideration.
It is now necessary to pursue an entirely new line. No member of the family took the lives of the aged couple, and an assassin must be found, or it must be said of Fall River that a fiend can kill there as he pleases and escape punishment. The work of the authorities has just begun. The investigation which has been pursued and the mass of evidence which has been collected are worthless. Every clue which has been pointing in one direction for ten exciting months must be discarded.
FOLLOWING THE MURDER.
From a legal standpoint, if from no other, it is plain that some monster did just what it has been claimed no monster could do. He sent a note to Mrs. Borden on the morning of August 4th and stole into the house on Second street. He entered by the front door, which was double locked, or through the side door, which was hooked, or by means of the chimney. It matters not how he entered so long as it has been demonstrated that he got in and accomplished his unholy undertaking. He concealed himself somewhere on the premises. The world knows that he was not seen there and that he has not been seen since. Perhaps he secreted himself in the cellar or in a clothes-press on the second floor, or in the attic; it doesn't matter where. He finds that his note has not accomplished his purpose, and, being discovered, strikes down Mrs. Borden.
AN OLD STORY WITH A NEW CHARACTER.
It is the old story, but a new character is playing the part of the villain, and circumstances must be made to fit his convenience. He is not detected, and he waits an hour or an hour and a half until Mr. Borden arrives. It is fair to presume that he does not go to the stable. He follows Miss Lizzie Borden down-stairs if he is hiding in that part of the house, or he waits until she disappears if he is in the basement or on the first floor, and then wields the axe again. He takes himself off noiselessly north, south, east, or west, with the axe and the note in his possession. His motive cannot be imagined. If it were robbery, he lost the nerve which enabled him to endure the strain after the first crime, and fled without helping himself to plunder. If it were revenge, he surely had it.
A DIFFICULT TRAIL TO FOLLOW.
To track him will be difficult. He has nearly a year's start. He has no name and no description of him can be furnished. Nothing short of a miracle will ever reveal his identity. But this is an age of miracles and he may be overtaken. At all events, the above is a shadowy picture of the individual who drove a blade into the skulls of Mr. and Mrs. Borden, and who has never been suspected except for a few hours after the discovery of the frightful deed.
It seems inconceivable that with three people about the premises there could have been more than one such individual. It isn't necessary to double the difficulties of the unsolved problem. But there is no denying that as this perplexing slaughter stands to-night some scoundrel who answers this meagre picture is still at large, and if he keeps his own counsel he is likely to remain at large. It is safe to assert that he cannot be painted in stronger colors. He is a phantom so far as the most brilliant imagination goes. Nobody can set him down as a farm hand, as a sailor, as a tramp, or as a businessman. Who and what he was cannot be determined. Nevertheless, he must be substituted at this late hour in this marvellous case and the interest which once centred elsewhere must henceforth centre in him.
THE SISTERS WILL LEAVE NO STONE UNTURNED.
The New York World's Fall River (Mass.) special says: Lawyer Jennings has no theory which he can sustain with proof as to who did commit the Borden murders. Nevertheless, he says, Miss Borden and her sister will leave no stone unturned to discover, if possible, who the murderers are. The hunt is already on and will continue.
Writing after the trial, the author sarcastically reconstructs how an unidentified 'monster' could have entered the Borden house, hidden, and killed both victims without being seen. The piece mocks the lack of evidence or motive for this mystery intruder, concluding the case remains unsolved.
Richmond Dispatch · 25 June 1893 · page 2
FOLLOWING THE MURDER
AN OLD STORY WITH A NEW CHARACTER, It is the old story, but a new character is playing the part of the villain, and cir. cumstances must be made to fit his conve. nience. He is not detected, and he waits an hour or an hour and a half until Mr. Borden arrives, It is {air to presume that he does not go to the stable, He follows Miss Lizzie Borden down.stairs if he 18 hiding in that part of the house, or he waits until she disappears if he is in the basement or on the first floor, and then wields tho axe again, He takes himself off noisolesely north, south, east, or wast, with the axe and the note in his possession.
See moreSee less
His motive cannot be imagiued. [If it wera robbery, he lost the nerve which enabled him to endure the strain after the first ering, and fled without helping himself to plunder, If it were revenge, he surely had it.
Following Lizzie Borden's acquittal by a jury of twelve men, the report states that the crime must now be reinvestigated from scratch, as all prior evidence and theories pointing to her are worthless. It notes that her lawyer Jennings has no proven theory, but the family will pursue every lead to find the true murderer, who remains an unidentified phantom.
Richmond Dispatch · 25 June 1893 · page 2
THE SISTERS WILL LEAVE NO STONE UNTURNED
There Is Mystifying Work Ahead for the ull River Police. | Now that it has been proved to the satis. faction of twelve men that a mistake was comuutted and that Miss Lizzie Borden did not butcher her father and step. | | mother, as alleged, says a Fall Hiver { soeecinl to the Providence Jowrnal, the erime 1s thrown back to the afternoon | of Augnst 4, 1892, when the police were scouring the country tor the murderer, Nothing remains except the fact that Mr, and Mrs. Borden were slain in cold blood, and the commuaity 1s still saddled with a tragedy that remains unexplained, Opin.
See moreSee less
ous, whether changed or unchanged by the decigion reached, no longer connt. ‘I he accused bas been removed from cone s:deration, It is DOW necessary to pursne an entirely new line. No member of the family took the lives of the aged couple, and an assas gin must be found, or it wust be said of all River that a fiend ean kill there as he pleaser and escape punishment. The | work of the authorities has just begun, The investigation which has been pursued and the mass of evidence which has been collected are worthless, Every clue which lias been pointing in ene direction for ten exciting months must be discarded,
The report describes the murderer as a complete unknown—no clear profile as farm hand, sailor, tramp, or businessman—who remains at large if he stays silent. It also notes that lawyer Jennings has no provable theory, but that Lizzie Borden and her sister are determined to leave no stone unturned in finding the killer.
Richmond Dispatch · 25 June 1893 · page 2
THE BISTEKS WILL LEAVE NO STONE UNTURNED, The New York World's Fall River (Mass,) gpocial says: Lawyer .Jennings has no theory which he can sustain with proof as to who did commit the Borden murders, Nevertheless, he rays, Miss Borden and her sister will leave no stone unturned to discover, if possible, who the murderers
Marshal Hilliard is flooded with anonymous letters, some confessing to the murders and others threatening him for prosecuting Lizzie Borden. Lizzie herself receives hundreds of letters daily, mostly supportive from temperance groups, while facing social ostracism and needing police protection to attend church.
The Roanoke Times · 25 June 1893 · page 4
York. The noighbors say that they have not yet seen Miss Lizzie l'orden about the yard, although they have no'.ieed her moving from room to room. She is gradually recovering from the nervous strain of tho past months and is again feeling quite at home. Her sleep is much better than it has been for many a night, and she does not complain of physical illness. Miss Borden receives several hundred letters daily. The most of her letters arc of a congratula? tory character and come from members of tho Woman's Christian Temperance Union and Christian Endeavor Soci?
See moreSee less
eties. Judge Itlaisdoll is in receipt of a com? munication from a crank which is post? marked Amesbury. The writer censures the judge for his connection with the Korden case and advises him to go back to shoemaklng. Throo of the most prominent members of the Central Church declare that 'boy will not fra? ternize with Miss Borden until the mur? ders of her father and mother are avenged, or at least explained. It is said that police protection will be required to guard Miss Lizzie Borden from in? sults If she attempts to attend church within a few days.
Marshal Hilliard and Judge Blaisdell receive threatening and crank letters following Lizzie Borden's trial, while Lizzie herself gets hundreds of supportive letters and is slowly recovering at home. Some Central Church members refuse to associate with her until the murders are explained.
The Morning News · 26 June 1893 · page 1
ECHO OF THE BORDEN CASE. Marshal Hilliard Receiving Confess ing and Threatening Letters. Fall River, Juno 2ft.—Marshal Hilliard has received hundreds of anonymous let ters from cranks, confessing tho murder of Mr. and Mrs. Borden, ami from others who threatened him for persecuting an innocent woman. It is suggested by one correspondent that the friends of Miss Borden should organize and behead tho marshal in public. Another suggests that the marshal beware, as White Caps may overtake him. Among the articles re ceived by the marshal is a big leather medal from Now York.
See moreSee less
The neighbors say that they have not yet seen Miss Lizzie Borden about the yard, although they have noticed Iter moving from room to room. She is grad ually recovering from the nervous strain of the pa3t months and is again feeling quite at home. Her sloop is much better than it has been for many a night, and she docs not complain of physical illness. Miss Borden receive* several hundred let ters daily. Tho moat of her letters are of a congratulatory character, and come from members of the Woman's Christian Temperance Union and Christian En deavor societies. Judge Blaisdell is in receipt of a rom muni.'atinn from n crank which is post marked Amesbury. The writer censures the judge for his connection with the Borden case and advises him to go back to shoemaking. Three of tho most prom inent members of the Central church declare that they will not fraternize with Miss Borden until the murders of her father and mother aro avenged, or at least oxplaiued. It is said that police protection will be required to guard Miss Borden from insults if she attempts to attend church within a few days.
This filler piece jokes about the skillful legal maneuvering in the Lizzie Borden case by comparing it to an old anecdote about a Southern Ohio lawyer's absurd cross-examination tactics. The anecdote describes a lawyer badgering a witness with irrelevant questions to discredit her testimony about seeing a murder suspect.
The Morning News · 26 June 1893 · page 4
Getting at the Facts. The shrewdness in working up and pro senting the remarkable case against Lizzie Borden suggests to the Cleveland Plain Deal er the effort of a southern Ohio lawyer some ~ ;irs ago in adducing the "fullness of testi
A short notice states that Lizzie Borden of New Bedford, Mass., was acquitted after a lengthy trial on charges of murdering her father and stepmother. It appears as a brief item amid other unrelated crime reports.
Illinois Staats-Zeitung · 26 June 1893 · page 1
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
The editorial criticizes suffragist Mary A. Livermore for writing favorably about the Borden case while refusing to read the prosecutor's arguments. It accuses her of being biased and calls her one of Lizzie Borden's 'fool friends' who harm her cause through one-sided advocacy.
Pawtucket Tribune · 26 June 1893 · page 2
MARY A. LIVERMORE. The Telegram sces some good In Mrs. Mary A. Livermore. We don’t. It is con ceded that she s one of the most promi pent of oar female suffrage idvoocates and belleves the entrance of women to per tect equality relations would bea grand thing for everybody. Bhe has written a good deal on the Borden case, und, like her ideas on religious matters, she is afraid to examine more than one side. She liked Governor Robinson’s plea and she read it the second time, but she could not trust herself to read District Attorney Knowlton’s argument because she was afraid she would read something she would not like, or, possibly, could not refute.
See moreSee less
She 18 somewhat of the “American Me chanlc” stripe, as was evidenced by her foolish diatribes against the lamented Boyle O'R illy whom almost everybody loved. As the Boston Republic has sald, she is one of Lizzie Borden’s ‘“fool friends” who do her harm by their bigoted writings.
A newspaper item quotes an excitable Martha's Vineyard editor named Strahan celebrating Lizzie Borden's acquittal with exaggerated joy. He curses the witnesses he considers perjurers and praises God for the verdict freeing an innocent woman.
Pawtucket Tribune · 26 June 1893 · page 2
There’s a crazy man down at Martha’s Vineyard, His name is Strahan and he is \ editor of the Herald, Here him: “Lizzie Borden 1s acquitted! We shout glory, we
The report notes the Borden jury was unanimous in finding her innocent from the start of deliberations. An editorial argues it is unjust for distant newspapers to condemn Lizzie Borden as guilty when the trial produced no direct evidence against her and her acquittal was clear and decisive.
San Antonio Daily Light · 26 June 1893 · page 2
THE BORDEN VERDICT. It is as ungenerous as it is un just to declarethat Lizzie Borden was guilty of murder, in the face of the testimony adduced at the trial.
This editorial argues that Lizzie Borden was emphatically and decisively acquitted by a jury with full knowledge of the facts, and that distant newspapers should not second-guess the verdict. It calls for compassion toward her, noting she must live with the burden of having been tried despite her clean record and acquittal.
San Antonio Daily Light · 26 June 1893 · page 2
The condemnation of crime is well, but when the acquittal of all crim inal act is as clear and decisive as it was in the case of Miss Borden it is not in the interest of law, good order, decency, common humany or fair dealing to reiterate the guilt of the acquitted and call down the condemnation of the community upon them. This is particularly so in the case of a modest, cultivated young lady against whose character there was no ground of accusation in all her past. The charity that covers a multltute of sins, and the manli ness that screens a woman from all unnecessary trial and hardship alike demand that no attempt be made to reverse the verdict of the Borden jury, or weaken the force of the judicial declaration in her favor.
The report discusses the New Bedford jury's acquittal of Lizzie Borden despite District-Attorney Knowlton's powerful closing argument, calling it a righteous verdict. It argues the state failed to connect her to the murders or establish a motive, praising the jury's judgment.
Orleans County Monitor · 26 June 1893 · page 8
ACQUITTAL OF LIZZIE BORDEN
who went to Jackson Park did not hurry in that direction. The crowd was of about the same character as on previous Sundays. Although the managers have been successful in the legal proceedings ended on Saturday, they are threatened with further liti gation on the same subject. Inde pendent of this, however, they should, as honorable men, regard it as their duty to pay back the money which they took from the Government on terms which they will henceforth make no attempt to fulfill. Tribune. ACQUITTAL OF LIZZIE BORDEN .
This editorial argues that the jury's verdict in the Borden case was correct, given how flimsy the circumstantial evidence was, and warns that a conviction would have set a dangerous precedent for prosecutors and police. It insists that acquittal under the law means innocence is established, rejecting cynical comparisons to Scotland's 'not proven' verdict.
Orleans County Monitor · 26 June 1893 · page 8
"Guilty, but not proven." The law assumes innocence until guilt is prov ed. When acquittal follows a trial, in which all the resources of the police and the State have been employed in order to secure conviction, innocence is established, if .Lizzie Borden un der a merciful law has had the right for ten months to be considered in nocent, so she has now the inestima ble privilege of returning to her home, holding up her head proudly, and pro claiming to a world that has been deeply touched by the pathos of her lot: "I am not guilty, twelve just men being my witnesses."
See moreSee less
Tribune. The annual meeting of the trustees of the Vermont Methodist Seminary was held Wednesday afternoon, Hon. W. P. Dillingham, the president, in the chair. There were twenty-three trustees present, including Senator Proctor and Hon. J. B. Brooks of Syriuse, N. Y. The following officers were elected for the vear ensuinsr: President, W. P. Dillingham; secre tary, Rev. W. R. Davenport; treasurer,Thomas Marvin; executive com mittee, W. P. Dillingham, Thomas Marvin, G. W. Parmenter, W. E. Bar
The Wilmington Daily Republican · Wilmington, Del.
Fall River, Mass. reports that Lizzie Borden daily receives letters including marriage proposals and suggestions about her parents' murderer. Her adviser Henry Homes states she will not continue living in the Borden homestead and will never again employ Bridget Sullivan as her servant.
The Wilmington Daily Republican · 27 June 1893 · page 4
•t lier parents s murderer. He share ol' the estate In worth »200,000. Henry Homes, Lizzie Borden's nd viser, says slio T won't continue to reside in the Bor «leu homestead on Second street an« will nover agate have Bridget Sullivaj hcr servant. A ( Ik hi AmIciim. r si®, June26.—The Crum Croc! Iron and Steel Works, with a oapita Block of »50, 000,assigned on Saturday Tlie liabilities 5I2Ü.000, while th. assets will not amount lo over »50,001 if if forced a sale. The Delawar«
Idaho Semi-Weekly World · Idaho City, Idaho Territory
A short item among local notices reports that Lizzie Borden, tried in Massachusetts for the murder of her father and stepmother, was acquitted a few days earlier. The item offers no further detail on the trial or verdict.
Idaho Semi-Weekly World · 27 June 1893 · page 1
Miss Lizzie Borden, who has been on trial a long time in Massachusetts, charged with the murder of her fath er and stepmother, was acquitted a a few days ago.
A sarcastic newspaper aside asks whether Fall River police, having failed to convict Lizzie Borden, will now give up or find another innocent person to pursue. It reflects public skepticism toward the prosecution's conduct after the case's resolution.
St. Paul Daily Globe · 27 June 1893 · page 5
P. F. Lyons, Local Forecast Official. Silver-plated bedsteads are now a fad of fashion. This will increase the market for the white metal; somewhat. ■»■ — . A New Jersey man is prosecuting his wife on the charge of beating him. lt is dangerous to let the weaker sex grow too strong. An inventor comes to the front with an aerial electric railway, the cars of which be proposes to operate at 500 miles an hour. That would be fast enough even for Chicago. fi: .2 ...,-. ; y " -■----**- — •""' '^ — Will the police of .-Fall River who tried rso desperately toconvict Lizzie Borden give it up now. or tin d some
District Attorney Knowlton delivered his closing argument, arguing Lizzie Borden hid a bloodstained dress, broke the hatchet handle, and used burnt paper to protect her clothing during the murders. After Lizzie declared her innocence to the court, Justice Dewey began charging the jury on the degrees of murder, though the verdict had not yet been reached when this report was filed.
The Sedalia Weekly Bazoo · 27 June 1893 · page 2
New Bedford, Mass., June 20. lhere was less of a jam outride the court bouse tins iuornm when the Borden case was called, but the court room held fully as mauy people as on any previous day. District Attorney Knolton resumed his argument. Liz zie Borden occupied a seat beside her attorney, Uovernor .Kobinson, and conversed with him in au apparently cheerful manner. Kuowltou argued that the silk dress produced by defense was not the dress worn at the time of the murder. The police search of the house on the first day was insufficient but it nut Lizzie Borden on guard aud before subse
Prosecutor Knowlton argues Lizzie used the handleless hatchet and burned bloodstained paper, then Justice Dewey charges the jury on reasonable doubt and motive. The jury deliberates and returns a verdict of not guilty, prompting cheers in the courtroom and tears from Lizzie Borden.
The Sedalia Weekly Bazoo · 27 June 1893 · page 2
LIZZIE IS ACQUITTED.
New Bedford. Mass., June 21. It was just 4:30 o'clock yesterday when the spectators, who had kept their seats patiently during the re tirement of the jury' in the Borden case noticed a movement indicating their retuiu. A moment later the 12 men filed into their seats and were polled. Miss Borden was asked to stand up and the foreman was asked to return the verdict, which he announced "Not guilty." Then all" the dignity aud docorum of the court room vanished. A cheer went up which might have been heard half a, mile away through the open windows and there was no attempt to check it.
See moreSee less
The stately justices looked straight ahead at the bare walls dur ing the tremendous excitement, which lasted fully a minute. Miss Borden's head went down upon the rail in front of her and tears came where they had refused to come for many a long day as she heard "the sweetest words ever poured into her willing cars. Mr." Jennings was almost cry-ins; aud his voice broke as he put his hand out to Mr. Adams, who sat next to him, and said : "Thank God ! " while Mr. Adams returned the pressure of the baud aud seemed incapable of speech. Governor Kobinson turned to the rapidly dissolving jury as they filed out ot their seats and gleamed on them with a fatherly interest in his kindly eye, and stood up as Mr. Knowlton and Mr. Moody came over to shake hands with the counsel for the defense. As soon as possible the room was cleared, although it was a hard task, since everybody waited to shake hands with Miss Borden. When the spectators had finally gone, she was taken to the room of the justices and allowed to recover her composure with only the eyes of friends upon her and the caress of devoted admir ers. At the expiration of an hour she was placed in a carriage and driv en to the station, where she took the train for Fall River, her home no longer probably, but still the only ob jective ioint lor the immediate present.
The report describes the emotional scene as the jury's not guilty verdict is announced, with cheering spectators, Lizzie Borden breaking into tears, and her lawyers overcome with relief. It also includes a physical description of Borden published for public interest following the trial.
The Sedalia Weekly Bazoo · 27 June 1893 · page 2
NOT GUILTY.
LIZZIE HORDES". Here is a woman's pen picture of Lizzie Borden, whose recent trial for the murder of her father and step mother had claimed public interest to such a great extent : This New England woman who was legally accused of the most bruta; murders of the nineteenth century, is o leet 6 inches in height, and weighs about 130 pounds. Even those who were most anxious to see her handed admit that she is a "lady," and that her manner, under these very trying circumstances, was one not ot indiffer ence or bravado, but of quiet dignity which was impressive. Lizzie Borden has a very plain face.
The report states that Lizzie Borden, tried for the murder of her father and stepmother, was acquitted. It is a short factual notice among other miscellaneous news items.
Mississippi Leader · 27 June 1893 · page 2
Lizzie Borden, the young Massachu i setts woman who was tried for the j murder of her father and step-mother. was acquitted. ___ The Peabody Normal Institute at Ox
The jury in the Borden case returned a verdict of 'not guilty' at half-past 4 o'clock, prompting cheers from the crowd and tears from Lizzie Borden. She returned to Fall River that night to an enthusiastic reception, declaring herself the happiest woman in the world.
The Progressive Farmer · 27 June 1893 · page 3
LIZZIE BORDEN ACQUITTED. New Bedford, Maes., June 2L At half -past 4 o'clock ye&terday afternoon the jury in the Borden case returned a verdict of "not guilty." When the verdict was delivered by the foreman, with Viss Borden standing in front of him, a loud cheer went up from the crowd, and Miss Borden herself wept profusely. As the room was being cleared after the adjournment of court, the crowd pressed about Lizzie to shape her hand. She seemed overjoyed and declared herself "the happiest woman in the world." Miss Borden returned last night to her home -in Fall river, where she was given an enthusiastic reception. The verdict seems to meet with the general approval of the people.
The report states Lizzie Borden, accused of murdering her father and stepmother, was acquitted last week at New Bedford, Mass. It adds that the acquittal was widely expected since there was no substantial evidence linking her to the crime.
The Mount Holly News · 27 June 1893 · page 2
TUESDAY, JUNE 27,1893. Lizzie Borden, accused of the murder of her father and stepmother, was ac quitted at New Bedford Mass., last week. This action was generally anticipated, as
The report states that Lizzie Borden's trial for the murder of her father and stepmother concluded in New Bedford with a verdict of acquittal. It notes the jury deliberated about an hour, found no real evidence against her, and that the murder remains a mystery.
Paper unidentified · 27 June 1893 · page 2
The trial of Lizzie Borelen for the murdei of her father and step mother was eoncludeel at New Bedford, Mass., last Tuesday anel resulted in a verdict of acquittal. The authorities, after a fruitless effort to discover the slightest clue to the murelerer, conclutled to arrest Lizzie Borden in order to satisfy the deunat el of tho public that some one lo ariested for tho murder. There wns no evidence that she committed tho murder and the jury, after having Leen out nlK)ut an hour, returned a verdict of not guilty and now the Borden murder is as much a mys tery as ever.
See moreSee less
lxs Linas hns a democratic postmaster and he is theonly elem ocratic oflie ial in Valencia ceiunty. There is erne advantage in being a democrat in Valencia county, and flint is that there is no room for purty disseiihion, hut on the other hand, democrats up thero must feel mighty lonesome.
Lizzie Borden has been found not guilty of murdering her father and mother, a verdict the report says was fully justified by the evidence. Former Governor Robinson, her defense attorney, recounts his long-held belief in her innocence and describes the outpouring of public support she received during the trial, including daily letters and flowers.
Smyrna Times · 28 June 1893 · page 1
Lizzie Borden Not Guilty. As was generally expected Lizzie l>ordeu has* bisen declared not guilty of the murder of her father ami mother by I lie Jury that tried her. fault can be toirtid with the verdict of the jury, as the quality of the evidence submitted would not admit of other result, But all this does not clear up the iii cry. Ex Governor Robi iisoii in a conver sation upon that subject said : "During the trial I received about fifty letters from cranks confessing the Borden murder. I Iiave had hut , . one opinion step No any
An account describes the jury's quick decision to acquit Lizzie Borden, noting they had essentially decided before formally retiring. It also describes the outpouring of public support during the trial, including daily letters and flowers, and crowds showing goodwill toward her afterward.
Smyrna Times · 28 June 1893 · page 1
"Miss Lizzie has said to me that the Borden murders were ns much of a mystery to her as to any one else. I can only account for the widespread difference of opinion among the people of the country as to her innocence or guilt in this way ; Before the trial there were all sorts of conclusions formed, based on anything but the evi dence in the case. [
A humorous filler item in a newspaper miscellany column jokes that Lizzie Borden might seek revenge by becoming a stage performer or lecturer. It appears amid other unrelated quips and advertisements.
Smyrna Times · 28 June 1893 · page 4
• Dignity, like a ''hand-me-down" coat, does not act well upon every indivi* dual who trit-8 to wear it. • • • Miss Lizzie Borden may get her re venge by going upon (he «luge or Hie lecture platform. Don't you know lo have perfect health you must have riuae blood, and tbe best way lo have pure blood is to take Hood's Sarsaparilla, the best blood purifier and strength builder. Hood's Pills may be had by mail for 25 cents of C. I. Hood & Go., Lowell, Mass. re Hie and to best for
The Wilmington Daily Republican · Wilmington, Del.
In the murder trial of Julia Force for killing her sisters, Judge Clarke told jurors the crime had no parallel except possibly the Borden murder case, if committed by Lizzie Borden. The jury quickly returned a verdict of insanity for Force.
The Wilmington Daily Republican · 28 June 1893 · page 1
Julia Foi Atlanta, Juno 28. Jury iu the trial of Julia Fv.rce for the murder of her sisters Judge Clarko re ferred to the enormity of the crime. He said the crime w parallel unless it be that, of the Borden murder case, if that cri by Lizzie Borden. The jury remained only a few minutes, and brought in a v diet of ot guilty. About Miss Force' insanity there seems to bo little doubt. Nut Guilty. In charging the probably without a mitted
This report covers the trial and acquittal of Julia Force for murder in Georgia, where the judge, in his charge to the jury, called the crime possibly without parallel except in the Borden murder case, speculating it exceeded Borden's in horror. The jury returned a not guilty verdict after brief deliberation, and Force was ordered to the state insane asylum.
The Morning News · 28 June 1893 · page 1
JULIA FORCE NOT GUILTY.
fendant was affected and sobbed softly. After the dinner recess Judge Clarke charged the Jury. During thodelivery of his remarks Miss Foreo sat immovable before the Jury with her face buried in her bunds. In his charge Judge Clarke referred to the enormity of the crime and said the Jury should consider the prior life of tho prisoner. He said the crime was probably without parallel, unless 16 be lu the Borden murder caso, if that crime was committed by Lizzie Borden. The Force murder was nveiiimorcjliomblo thun that. As the judge was charging tho Jury the prisoner broke down, sobbing convulsively.
See moreSee less
The jury remained out only a few minutes and at 8 o'clock brought in a verdict of not guilty. It will bo remembered that Miss Force was tried shortly aftor the murder occurred, on a writ of lun: cy, and was promptly Judged insane. Solicitor General Hill held that the proceeding WM irregular, as tho case should have gone first before the criminal court, where the prisoner had the privilege iff enter ing a plea of insanity aud establishing It to tho satisfaction of the Jury. This lias been done, and about Miss Force’s in sanity there seeni3 to be little doubt. She will lie sent ut once to the state luna tic usylum at Milledgevilie.
A general interest dispatch from Tampa, Florida describes civic improvements and local news, mentioning in passing that the Lizzie Borden murder trial verdict of acquittal was almost universally approved there. It claims no similar trial generated such widespread personal interest and sympathy among Americans.
The Morning News · 28 June 1893 · page 5
TAMPA GOSSIP
Mousing News, the people are in close touch with the outside world. Every bodv in Florida seems to have been read ing the daily reports of the Lizzie Borden
Julia Force was acquitted by reason of insanity for murdering her two sisters, with the judge comparing the crime's enormity to the Borden case, 'if that crime was committed by Lizzie Borden.' She will be committed to the state lunatic asylum.
The Indianapolis Journal · 28 June 1893 · page 3
Mill Be Sent to a Mad llouse. Atlanta, Ga., June 27. Miss Julia Force was put on trial yesterday for the murder of her two sisters last February. She had kept a diary for a year or more, and all through it appeared her intention of some time killing her sisters. The prisoner en tered the court room to-day with the widow of ex-Governor Conley. 8he was defended by Smith, Glenn & Smith, Seoretary Hoke Smith's law firm, and John Harde man, a eousin. Miss Force's mother and two brothers were in court.
See moreSee less
In his charge to the jury, this afternoon. Judge Clarke referred to the enormity of the crime, and said the jury should con sider the prior life of the prisoner. He said the ericae was probably without a parallel, unless it be that of the llorden murder case, if that crime was committed by Lizzie Borden. The force murder was even more horrible than that. As the Judge was charging the jury the prisoner broke down, sobbing convulsive ly. The jury remained out only a few minutes, and at 3 o'clock brought in a ver dict of not guilty. It will be remembered Miss Forc6 was tried shortly after the mur der occurred on a writ of lunacy, and was promptly judged insane. Solicitor-general Hill held that the proceeding was irregu lar, as the case should have gone first. be fore the criminal courts, where the pris oner had the privilege of entering a plea of insanity and establishing to the satisfac tion of the jury. This has been done, and about Miss Korea's insanity thsre seems to be little doubt. She will be Bent at once to the State lunatio asylum.
The report states that Lizzie Borden, accused of murdering her father and stepmother, has been acquitted by the jury. It notes the case drew national attention and that newspapers largely agree the verdict was correct.
Fergus Falls Ugeblad · 28 June 1893 · page 1
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
Morris Tribune · Morris, Minn. · and 1 other paper
The jury in the Borden murder trial returned a verdict of not guilty after deliberating a little over an hour, prompting cheers in the courtroom. Lizzie Borden was later taken by carriage to the station and departed by train for Fall River.
Morris Tribune · 28 June 1893 · page 1
These Are the Dead: When order had been somewhat re stored it was found that istretched on the ground were four men and three boys, all dead. They were: O. A. Dean boomer, married, Kennikinnick town ship Eugene Reynolds, unmarried, a carpenter 14-year-old son of Curtis Aldridge J. A. Glendenning, married, town clerk of Oak Grove Clark Mapes, married, a farmer of Clinton township a 12-year-old son of Wallace Smith, and a 12-year-old son of J. A. Glendenniu Mrs. Glendenning and another son are seriously injured. Patrick Collins, a farmer, unmarried, seriously injured, and now at Gladstone hotel, and two strangers, supposed to ba railroad grad «ra, are also at the hotel badly injured. LIZZIE BORDEN FREE. Jnry In the Famous Murder Case Declares Defeudant Not Guilty,
Mower County Transcript · Lansing, Minn. · 28 June 1893
The Columbus Journal · Columbus, Neb.
The report states that the Lizzie Borden murder trial in New Bedford concluded on June 23, with the jury returning a verdict of not guilty. It notes the courtroom erupted in applause upon the verdict being announced.
The Columbus Journal · 28 June 1893 · page 2
The British battle ship Victoria was ran into off .Tripoli by the Camperdown, a sister war vessel, causing it to sink in very deep water and drowning 400 of her officers and crew, among them Vice Ad miral Tryon. The Tremont house at Fort Scott, Kan., suddenly collapsed at 930 Monday morning, burying seventy-five people in the debris, twenty of whom are supposed to have been killed outright. There were several store rooms on the ground floor. On the 23d the sensational trial of Lizzie Borden, at New Bedford, Mass., charged with the murder of her father and step-mother, came to an end, the jury rendering a verdict of not guilty. The verdict of the jury was received with rounds of applause that fairly shook the court house.
Julia Force was acquitted of murdering her two sisters after a Georgia jury deliberated only minutes; the judge's charge noted the crime's severity, comparing it to the Borden murders "if the crime was committed by Lizzie Borden." Force was ruled insane and sent to the state asylum at Milledgeville.
Omaha Daily Bee · 28 June 1893 · page 2
Mil I'd or. ATMNTA , Juno 27 , Miss Julia Force was put on trial yesterday for the murder of her two sisters last February. She had kept a dairy for a year or moro and all through It ap peared her Intention to some time kill her sisters. Miss Force's mother nnd two brothers were In court. The arguments wore completed today. After the dinner recess Judge Clarke charged the Jury. During Iho delivery of his remarks Miss Force sat Immovable before the Jury with her face buried in her bunds.
See moreSee less
In his charge Judge Clarke referred to the enormity of the crime , and said tlio ury should consider Iho prior life of iho prisoner. Ho said Iho crlmo was probably without a parallel unless it be that of the Borden mur der case , if the crime was committed by Lizzie Borden , The Force murder was even more horrible than thai. As Iho judge was charging the Jury , the prisoner broke down. sobbing convulsively. The jury remained out only a few minutes ami at 3 o'clock brought In a verdict of not guilty. Miss Force was tried shortly after the murder occurred on a writ of lunacy and wa ; promptly adjudged insane. Solicitor Genera Hill held lhat the proceeding was irregular as the case should have cone first before the criminal courts , where the prisoner had tin privilege of entering a plea of insanity ant establishing it to the satisfaction of the jury. This has been done and about Mlsa Force's insanity there seems to bo little doubt. She will bo sent at once tc tbo stale lunatic asylum at Mlllodgoville. Chicago
This report describes how a Missouri Pacific railroad ticket clerk, inspired by the Lizzie Borden case to play amateur detective, helped capture a gang of train robbers by tricking a suspect into confessing. The article credits the clerk's investigative efforts, undertaken in emulation of sleuthing fascination sparked by the Borden murder case, as key to the arrests.
Omaha Daily Bee · 28 June 1893 · page 5
of the amateur dotectlvo over since Lizzie Borden was accused of murder and ho has longed to show his Bradshaw training In some such case ns that of last night. When Bennlngton , the man who squalod on his pals , went into the Missouri Pacific office last Thursday ho asked for the general manager. Mr. Bames Informed him that the general manager was out , but that ho looked after his business. Imagining that ho was talking to ono of the great rail road men of iho country Bonntngton pro ceeded to glvo his "pals" the "brace , " and Billy Barnes , clover ami astute , wormed out of Mr.
See moreSee less
Train Hobbcr the whole story. And it Is to this quiet , unassuming young man that the whole credit of the capture of last night should be given.
A humor column quips that an exchange paper called Lizzie Borden 'a lucky woman,' mocking the odd choice of words. The item offers no real news, just a snide aside amid other miscellaneous jokes and notes.
The Beatrice Daily Express · 28 June 1893 · page 2
Western money does not seem to be flowing east very rapidly. A western horse captured that $30,000 hung up by the Washington Park Club. An exchange says "Lizzie Borden is a
A newspaper commentary argues the Borden trial was largely unnecessary because the prosecution failed to properly investigate or disclose evidence before indicting Lizzie Borden. It notes that testimony about undisturbed dust in the barn loft was contradicted by witnesses, undermining the state's case against her alibi.
Asheville Daily Citizen · 28 June 1893 · page 2
A 1 KATIH1-. OK TM1-; HUBIIliN TKUU A lat urc ot the Borden case that we have not. vet seen commented on is that I he trial was all but uiineccss.ii v if the State's alt'Tnev had done his whole duty. By whole duty, we mean taking the view that the State's attornevs were concerned, not so much in securing a convicti hi of somebody, as in arriving at the truth. Lizzie Borden was kept in jail 10 months, a speedy trial being denieil her, and in that time it must be comeded that the prosecution had full opportunity to investigate every point against her mil decide whether it was worth while t bring her to trial.
See moreSee less
Tli.it they did not make such investi gation or. if they did, that they sup pressed the evidence so secured is tasily apparent from the comparison of wlnit the prosecution promised to prove with what it really did prove. For instance, it promised to prove that Lizzie Borden was lying when she said she was in the Borden barn at about the moment, and lor some moments after, when her father was killed, u police officer swearing that the dust in the barn lott was not dis turbed. But the evidenceot the prosecu tion tell away to nothing at this point , in the face of the testimony of several who were in the burn lott and saw that the dust had In-en disturbed therein, and in the face o I the direct test iin mv ol a credible witness to tineffect that he saw woman coming from the Borden barn at about the moment that Lizzie Borden said she came, and that that -.vom.-iii was not Bridget Sullivan, the only other woman about the premises and whom witness knew well by sight, anil then fore must, in all probability, have Ix-rn Lizzie Borneo Now was the State hound in its search alter the truth, hound in all fairness to ward a woman susiected of murder, to hunt out such testimony, at its call in Fall River as readily as at the call of the defense, and give it due onsiderai i n ? If it had done so with relation to all the strong points against Lizzie Borden well as in relation to the one we have mentioned, there would not have been a trial at all; Lizstie Borden would have been set free mouths ago. We know this liecausc the State Iniled to convict Lizzie Borden, and the reason for its fail
This piece argues that the prosecution failed to adequately investigate evidence favorable to Lizzie Borden, such as testimony about disturbed dust in the barn loft and a witness who saw a woman emerge from the barn who was not Bridget Sullivan. The author contends that had the state pursued such exculpatory evidence as diligently as the defense did, Borden would have been cleared months before trial.
Lizzie Borden and her sister returned to the Second Street home the morning after the verdict, arriving quietly by closed carriage and avoiding reporters. Public sentiment in Fall River had shifted to general acceptance of the jury's decision, with Lawyer Jennings receiving congratulatory letters from around the country.
Weekly Union · 28 June 1893 · page 1
IN THE OLD HOUSE.
VERDICT IR THE BORDEN CASE Just What Was Expected by Newspapers and Eminent Lawyers. The belief in Lizzie Borden’s innocence bas been steady in" its growth in the public mwind, and it bas now taken deep root, and
This report compiles reactions from multiple major newspapers (Post, New York Herald, Times, Recorder, Worcester Telegram) to Lizzie Borden's acquittal, nearly all praising the verdict as just and criticizing the prosecution's handling of the case. The consensus view expressed is that the government's case was weak from the start and that the swift not-guilty verdict reflected both the strength of the defense and public sentiment that Borden was wrongly persecuted.
Weekly Union · 28 June 1893 · page 1
VERDICT IN THE BORDEN CASE
eral Wyman of the marine hospital service, referring yesterday to the outlook for chol era in the United States during the present summer,sald : “We have an even chance of escaping cholera altogether this year. Should it arrive it will certainly not be come epidemic., Its non-appearance thus far proves that no germs have lived over winter in this country, as it was feared might happen. The prospect now Is much better than I ex pected it would be at this time. 1f cholera should geta foothold in this country Dr.
See moreSee less
Wyman thinks it would be guickly stamped out. Thirty-seven of the states have boards of heaith. All of them sre on the alert and would take active measures to prevent the disease from gpreading. : firpek by a Train and Kilied GARDINFR, Mnr, Juune 25.—Thomas Waters, aged 50 jears, employed in -Brad strect’s mill at South Gardiner, was walk ing ob ke track one mile east of South Gzrdiner depot this afternoon, when he was s'ruck avd lostantly killed by train No.ll. Waurerswas very deaf. He wasa pative of Bt. Stephen, N. 8., where he leuves a wife and two children. 113 where a jury of her own countrymen cuuld, after havin%the worst and utmost | tnat might legally be presented against her, proncunce the accused to be ¢Not guilty.” | Post—The trial of the case lis distinctly ‘ honorable to Massachusetts justice. The dignity and fairness with which it was con* ducted, the manifest purpose to get at the truth, the striet impartiality with which the rights of the accused were guarded,have extorted expressions of admiration from critics all over the land. But in the pre liminarles of the trial it has been far differ ent. ¥rom the very beginning, to the time when Lizzle Borden was brought before the court axd the jury, the course of the
Newspapers and prominent Massachusetts men react to the acquittal of Lizzie Borden, with many expressing that the prosecution failed to prove its case. Quotes from Governor Russell, George Fred Williams, and various judges and officials largely support the verdict as justified by weak evidence.
Weekly Union · 28 June 1893 · page 1
pose that she was gullty. Recorder—No other verdict was possi ble, in view of the utter destruction of the thecry, not at one point but at many, and all points that were vital on which Dis trict Attorney Kupowlton sought to con vict Miss Borden. There Is, we belleve, a very general feeling of Isdignation over the methods of the prosecuting authorities in this case. From first to last it was not a prosecution in the interest of soclety, but a prosecution in the interest of police counspiracy to fit facts to preconceived theory and convict an innocent woman by fair means or foul.
See moreSee less
- Worcester Telegram—The speedy ver dict of not guilty in the Borden case meets popular approval, and noone doubts that frcm the evidence presented justice {s done. It isseldom that a case is discussed with such temper at so great a distance from the scene of the tragedy as this case has been considered here in streets and everywhere that men gather. The male resicents of this eity by a large majority coneider the verdict insufficlent because it did not order the entire police force of Fall River to be hanged or imprisoned for Life, while the government prosecutors are dewovnced In fiery language. The following additional opinions on the verdict in the Borden case by prominent Massachusetts men are Interesting: Governor Russell—“l am not surprised. No other verdiet could have been rendered by toe jury on evidence not proven. I think that it 1s also in accord with the pub lic opinfon. No matter what the suspic ions may have been, if nct' provem ia law, of course, they do not hold.” Hon. George Fred Willlams thinks the acquital was eminently juss, and further, taking into consideration the evidence pre sented by the government, that the verdict not only acquits Miss Boréen of the legal
A short item reports that Lizzie Borden, charged with murdering her father and mother in Fall River, Massachusetts, last fall, was acquitted by a jury last week. The item appears amid a column of miscellaneous regional news briefs.
Walker Lake Bulletin · 28 June 1893 · page 3
Lizzie Borden, charged with the murder of her father and mother at Fall River, Mass,, last fall, was acquitted by a jury last week. There seems to be no doubt among the officers that John Marshall, the notorious stage robber, killed Mess enger Tovey on the lone stage. Dana Brown and family left Carson Monday night for Napa, California where they will remain until a per manent location is decided upon. Happy and content is a home with “The Ro chester,” a lamp with the light of the morning.
A brief item remarks that no woman in Fall River showed any sympathy for Lizzie Borden during her trial. It appears as a single-line aside amid a column of miscellaneous local notes.
The Wadsworth Dispatch · 28 June 1893 · page 2
BREVITIES
extended a single word of sympathy to Lizzie Borden during her trial. Clean the combustible trash out of your yards before the Fourth of July or you may repent your laziness. The Mason Valley round up reached the Mason ranch yesterday. Cattle are
Lizzie Borden's home received about 200 letters in a single day, many from Christian Endeavor and W.C.T.U. society members. Local officials also received letters, some vile in nature, along with unusual items like a leather medal from New York.
The Enterprise · 28 June 1893 · page 6
Lltsle Bordan's Letters. Fall Bivkr, Mass., June 84. Lizzie Borden's dally mail ia something extra ordinary, at least 200 letters being taken into her home yesterday. A great many of the letters come from mem bers of the Christian Endeavor and W. C. T. U. societies throughout the coun try. The girls have not been out since their arrival home, but are kept very busy receiving callers. Marshal 1111 liard and Mayor Coughlln are receiving some astonishing letters, most of them being of the dirtiest and most villlfying character. Among the curiosities he has received Is a Targe Icother medal from Jsew k'ork statu.
The report announces that Lizzie Borden was acquitted of murder, with the mystery of the killings left unsolved. It recounts the district attorney's closing argument emphasizing family tension and motive, followed by the defense's rebuttal and the judge's charge before the jury's quick verdict.
The Enterprise · 28 June 1893 · page 6
Lizzie Borden did not plan to kill her father, and I hope so. But it was not Lizzie Borden who came down those stairs to meet her father, but a mur deress, transformed from the ties of
Judge Dewey charged the jury on the standards for murder and reasonable doubt, noting the defendant's silence should not count against her. The jury deliberated and returned a verdict of not guilty, prompting cheers in the courtroom and tears from Lizzie Borden.
The Enterprise · 28 June 1893 · page 6
The jury filed into their seats at 4:30 and were polled, Miss Borden was asked to stand up and the foreman was asked to return the verdict, upon which he announced: "Not guilty." After the verdict had been received the district attorney moved that the other cases against Miss Borden be nolle prossed, and the order of the court was to that effect Chief Justice Mason then gracefully thanked the jurors in appreciation of their work and faithful service. The closing scenes in the trial were in direct contrast with those which had proceeded it Heretofore all had been decorum and in keeping with the dig nity of the most dignified court in the country, but when the verdict of "Not guilty" was returned, a cheer went up which might have been heard half a mile away through the open windows, and there was no attempt to check it The stately judges looked straight ahead at the bare walla Miss Borden's head went down upon the rail in front of her and tears came where they had refused to come for many a long day, as she heard the sweetest words ever poured into her willing ears the words "not guilty.'
See moreSee less
At the expiration of an hour ahe was placed in a oarriage and driven to the station, where she took a train for Fall River, her home no longer probably, but still the only objective point for the immediate present
The report states that Lizzie Borden's acquittal was no surprise to the public, as it was widely expected. It criticizes the prosecution's case, claiming police witnesses seemed rehearsed and fell apart under cross-examination, and concludes the murder will likely remain unsolved absent a confession.
The Forest Republican · 28 June 1893 · page 2
Tionesta boro. John R. Osgood. The acquittal of Lizzie Borden is no surprise to the public at large. It was expected. The prosecution re prejudiced policemen who all had
This report describes the emotional scene in the New Bedford courtroom when the jury's 'Not guilty' verdict was announced, including the cheering crowd, the weeping sheriff, and Lizzie Borden's own tears of relief. Her lawyers Jennings and Adams are shown overcome with emotion as the verdict is read.
The Somerset Herald · 28 June 1893 · page 2
PEOPLE WENT WILD. Spectators Happy Over the Acquit tal of Lizzie Borden. New Bedford, Mass., June 21. The clos ing scenes lu the trial of Lizzie iorden,
The jury in the Borden murder trial at New Bedford, Mass., returned a verdict of not guilty. Lizzie Borden reacted with visible emotion as cheers broke out in the courtroom following the announcement.
The Star · 28 June 1893 · page 2
LIZZIE BORDEN NOT GUILTY. A CELEBRATED CASE ENDS.
LIZZIE A. HORPltS. raise her hnnd. Lizzie Borden arose tremb ling and tottering, and it was with difficul ty the cnlmd her feet, but when once stand
The jury delivers a verdict of "Not guilty," and Lizzie Borden reacts with visible emotion before being congratulated by jurors, her attorney, and supporters. The report also recaps details of the crime, including the murders of Andrew Borden and his wife Abby in August 1892.
The Star · 28 June 1893 · page 2
A CELEBRATED CASE ENDS
expressed a desire to take the hand of Lizzie Borden and Governor Kobinson was the first to congratulate her, and even he, the trnined attorney, could not repress his emotion. The Bey. Mr. Buck, her pastor, could only weep. Lizzie was led into the Judge's room and reception was given her by citizens of Fall Itiver and New Bedford, who cordially shook her hand and congrnt Dialed her. At 8 o'clock he returned to her Fall River home In a carriage, accompanied bv her friend, Mrs. Holmes; her uncle, John V.
See moreSee less
Morse; her sister Emma, and ex-Governor Kobinson, Lizzie was the first to descend the court house stairs to the carriage. Her face was flushed, her Hps were trembling nervously and ahe appeare I more excited than at any time since her arrest. All who wished passed by the carriage and shook hands with Lizzie, and many kissed her hand. There were three cheer for the uc-
This retrospective account summarizes the Borden family relationships, the disputed poison theory, and the sequence of events on the morning of the murders as later reconstructed. It notes that no poison was found in the victims' bodies and that reports of Lizzie buying prussic acid were a case of mistaken identity.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
The Star · 28 June 1893 · page 2
hand. There were three cheer for the uc- ?uitted girl and as the carriage disappeared rom s'ghtthe flutter of a little white hand kerchief was seen a a parting salute from her. Details or the Crime. The eldest victim of the crime was Andrew 3. Borden, a capitalist of Fall Kiver. Mns., who was seventy years old. The other vic tim was his second wife, stepmother to the prisoner. She was eoimldernlily voting! than hnr husbnnd, who married hiir whou Wis Lizzie was nbout four years old. She waa a Inrm.
See moreSee less
fleshy woman. There were two daughter. Lizzie and F.mma, Emma was out of town ou the day of th, murder, which took place on Auirust 4, 1892. Emma called her stepmother "AIiIiIb," but Lizzie did not call bor anything to her face or speak to her at all. She qiutrmllod with her live year ago because her stepmother induced tier father to clear a piece of prop erty of UI and give it to his wife' sister. Miss Lizzie was born In 1RR0. Hhe and her sister hail 5000 in cash or In mill share or in each form. This their hither had given to them. At the time of the murder all the momhers of the family were ill, ami this led to thu theory that they hud all been poisoned. A drug elerk was snid to have sold prussie acid to .Miss Lizzie, but It was a cane ol mistaken identity. No ioiaon wa found in the bodiea of the victims. On the morning of the day of the murder Mr. Borden had been on hia business round and bad come back. Mrs. Borden w dressing to go out. Bridget Sullivan waa up stair washing window. The old man went to sleep on a lounge in the sitting room. The wife continued dressing, It she wa Hot already dead, and Lizzie Borden, ac cording to her own story, went out to th barn in the yard and stayed there thirty minute. She passed her father in going out, and stopped to ctroke his heud. All this wa between half past ten o'clock and ten minute past eleven o'clock in the morning, in a disagreeable aide atreot, a soml-tene-ment neighborhood with small shop in it. It waa in the heart of the elty, in its business part. The wife had sent the (srvant to wash the down stairs dlDiiig-room windows. At four or five minute before It the servant wont up to her room to lie down. She bad been lying there ten or fifteen minute when Mia Lizzie called to her from down stairs in a volea suggesting alarm or terror. She i reported to nave eu Ajizzie in ine Kitnuen, wno said either "Father' dead i go for doctor" or 'Father' hurti go for the doctor." The servant will elear up thi eoufuaion as to wnni waa said. The mrvaut. Bridget Sullivan, wentandcame book and wa sent out to get a Mrs. Busaell, When she returned airaln Dr. Bouren wu there and had been preceded by Mr. Church ill, a neighbor, whose windows looked oloso upon the Borden bouaa. Those visitors saw the father's body. Mrs. Churchill said aomo oua should notify Mr. Bardon. aod Uuuexas marked that she t non gnt ne fieftrd her motnOr eome In. The neighbor nnd servant went up and discovered the d-a-i woman. Both vic tim had been brutnlly chopped nhout the head and face. Llzr.l'i'ltor den was suspected and plneed under surveillance l;oin the mo ment the crl'iio was discovered. Finally, the District Atto-nnv wen' h'ort!i nr.ini Jurv and declared tnst he had sufficient evidentto convict her. So she was indicted.arreted, and has been confined In jail ever since, nntll Tuesday, when she wns acquitted of all charges against ber, and i now a fret wo i.an again.
The report states that Lizzie Borden's trial for the murder of her father and stepmother ended in New Bedford with a verdict of not guilty, as the state could not produce solid evidence beyond a theorized motive of mutual hatred. It notes public skepticism, suggesting many believed her probably guilty despite the acquittal.
Yorkville Enquirer · 28 June 1893 · page 2
? The trial of Lizzie Borden, at New Bei ford, Mass., for the murder of her father ar stepmother, at Fall River, came to an er on Tuesday of last week, resulting in a ve diet of not guilty. The State was unable 1 develop any evidence against the accuse^ and the whole case was based on the possib motive of the murders. It was shown thi for vears nast a fierce hatred existed betwe< Miss Borden and her stepmother, and the th ory of the State was that Miss Borden mu
The report covers the fourth day of Lizzie Borden's trial at New Bedford, with Dr. Bowen, Mrs. Churchill, and Alice Russell testifying about the crime scene, Lizzie's demeanor, and her burning a dress days after the murders. Police witnesses also described physical evidence found at the Borden house, including an unbloodied table and a bloodstained handkerchief.
The Abbeville Press and Banner · 28 June 1893 · page 2
CONTINUATION OF THE TRIAL AT NEW BEDFORD.
ATRTjE BETWEEN AQTMUA. : Roslin mines, Kittias County, Washing- : r ; ton. I was brought out of a slope 1070 ; th* <rentre and circumference of the ciroula j : feet loug with a dip of 18 degrees. I am : winy, with a passageway between. Thesi tanks aro fitted up with such representation: 3 . not unuirauiiu ;i iMuswKUk-<jiLuimiiuua iii . a ; character. My State has a coal ar^a of : of the vasty deep and the mountain pool9 a i : 1.000,000 acres. Boat mo if you can : are appropriate.
See moreSee less
The picturesque part is, ii : and you are entitled to tho broom. l?ot, exceedingly attractive, and seems to con lHtJ7 ; it is valued at 16500. tent the inmates, who appear to /eei at home, he testified that he had prescribed morphine for Miss Borden to allay nervous excitement. The doses were increased to double strength and had a tendency to affect the memory. Mrs. Churchill, who lived in part of the Bordea house, testified to occurrences just before the murder. She said that Miss Borden was so pale and excited after the murder as to attract considerable attention. Miss Alice Russell was then C3lled. She described Miss Borden's burninor the dress Sunday after the murder. Witness want out and
Witnesses at the Borden trial, including police officers Fleet, Harrington, Doherty, Edson, Mahoney, Medley, Desmond, and Detective Seaver, gave testimony about the handleless hatchet found in the cellar and its condition when discovered. Cross-examination by ex-Governor Robinson revealed multiple contradictions among the officers regarding where the hatchet was found, whether it had ash or dust on it, and who handled the evidence.
The Abbeville Press and Banner · 28 June 1893 · page 2
at the Borden house. There was less of a rush of spectators to the Borden murder trial on the 3ixth day than usual, the day opening warm and muggy. The first witness callod was Lieutenant F. L. Edson, of the Fall River Police. He testified to an ineffectual attempt to search the Borden cellar for the hatchet at-Aon fA kyr TLfnlloIv On IWUilliC onuiu IW %JJ iuuuwkj! WM W. VW. examination ho dascribed the thorough search of the cellar after the murder, and said he saw no loosa hatchot handle. Robinson brought out the fact that nearly all the Fall River police prominent in this case have been promoted since the murder except Mullaly, who contradicted Fleet.
See moreSee less
Officer Benjamin F. Mahoney was oalled and corroborated ' Edson. William H. Medley, inspector of Police, Fall River, described finding the barn door fastened, and on entering seeing dust up stairs which had not been disturbed. The barn windows and door upstairs wera closed. His examination was made within ten minutes after ' reaching the house.
The report describes the emotional scene as Lizzie Borden hears the verdict of not guilty, with spectators cheering and her attorneys overcome with emotion. It captures the immediate reaction in the courtroom following her acquittal.
The Maryville Times · 28 June 1893 · page 8
Lizzie Borden ever heard, came to her willing ears, and tears flowed where Ithey had refused to for many a day. j, Showred with cares
The report describes the closing arguments and verdict in the trial of Julia Force, who was found not guilty of killing her two sisters and ordered sent to a state asylum. The presiding judge, in his charge to the jury, compared the brutality of the crime to the Borden murder case in Massachusetts.
Richmond Dispatch · 28 June 1893 · page 1
JULIA FORCE TRIAL.
| prior lifa of the prisoner. Is said the crime was otably without a parallel, unless it be in the Borden murder case, if that crime was cotu nutted by Lizzie Borden. The Force murder | was avan more horrible than that As the Judge
During the Julia Force murder trial in Atlanta, the judge referenced the Lizzie Borden case as a possible parallel for an exceptionally horrific crime, noting uncertainty about whether Borden committed it. The jury found Force not guilty by reason of insanity after brief deliberation.
The Roanoke Times · 28 June 1893 · page 1
consider the prior life of the prisoner. He said the crime was probably without a parallel unless It bo in the Borden murder case if that crime was com? mitted by Lizzie Borden. The Poice murder was even more hor? rible than that. Ab the judge was charg? ing the jury the prisoner broke down, Bobbing convulsively. The jury re? mained out only a few minutes and at 3 a'clcck brought in a verdict of not guilty. It will be remembered that Miss Force was tried shortly after tho mur? der occurred on a writ of lunacy and was promptly judged insane.
See moreSee less
Solicitor General Hill hold that the proceeding was irregular as tho case should have gone first before the criminal courts, where the prisoner had the privilege of entering a plea of insanity and estab? lishing it to the satisfaction of the jury. This has been done and about Miss Force's insanity there seems to be little doubt Shu will be sent at once to the State lunatic asylum at Milledgevllle.
This editorial, published after Lizzie Borden's acquittal, criticizes the Borden sisters for not working with police to find the real murderers in the nearly year since the crime. It argues their delayed promise to assist investigators now casts suspicion on Lizzie rather than vindicating her.
The Vermont Watchman · 28 June 1893 · page 4
A Remarkable Case
A Kcmarkalilc C'ase. " Tho Bordens have no kiudly fecling toward tho police, and yet they mcan to combiue with thcm in the near future in ferrctiug out thc murdorcrs of tho old people. To that cud tho girls will devote their oncrgy hereafter." So says tho Boston IleruhVs corrcspondent at thc sccne of tho lato trial. AVhen it is cousidered that tho most cffectivo way of vindicating tho iunocenco of Lizzie Borden was the pro
Julia Force was tried in Atlanta for murdering her two sisters, with the judge calling the crime possibly unparalleled except for the Borden case if Lizzie Borden committed it. The jury found Force not guilty by reason of insanity, and she was ordered sent to the state asylum at Milledgeville.
Wheeling Register · 28 June 1893 · page 1
MISS FORCE DECLARED INSANE.
Borden murder case if that crime was com mitted hv Lizzie Borden. The Force murder was even more horri ble than that. As the judge was charging tho jury, the prisoner broke down sobhiug convulsively. The jury remained out only a few minutes, and at 3 o'clock brought in a verdict of not guilty. It will be remembered Miss Force was tried shortly after the murder occurred on a writ of lunacy and was promptly judged insane. Solicitor General Hill held that the pro ceedings were irregular as the case should have gone tirst before the criminal courts where the prisoner had the privilege of en tering a plea of insanity and establishing it to the satisfaction of the jury.
See moreSee less
This has been done aud about Miss Force's iDsanitv there seems to be little doubt. She will be sent at once to the state lunatic asylum at Milledgeville.
A New Bedford correspondent describes the twelve Borden jurors marching in lockstep straight from the courthouse to a hotel bar after their discharge, ignoring cheering crowds and well-wishers along the way. The piece wryly notes the jurors had earned their right to drink after sixteen days of trial.
The Weekly Register · 28 June 1893 · page 2
?v Lizzie Borden Jury. cw Bedford correspondent itee: "The twolve men of tho Borden jury, still koeping lock step after leaving tho court room when
A jury in New Bedford, Massachusetts delivered a verdict of not guilty in the Lizzie Borden murder trial, prompting cheers in the courtroom. The report describes the tense courtroom scene as the verdict was read and Borden was formally discharged from custody.
Ceredo Advance · 28 June 1893 · page 2
NOT GUILTY.
New Hrnronn. Mass.. June 21.— There was a whirl of excitement in the courthouse here Tuesday while await ing the verdict of the jury in the Bor den ease. Aiuid Suppressed but in tense excitement the jurors tiled into the room. Then the clerk, as is the custom, called upon the prisoner to look upon the jury and raise her head. Lizzie Borden arose, trembling, to her feet, and it was with difficulty that she gained her feet, but when once standing she appeared as tirm as a ri»ck. Her white face was turned calm ly toward the men who held her fate in their keeping.
See moreSee less
‘aientlemen. look upon the prisoner." said the judge, "tientlemen, have you ugreed upon » verdict, what say you Mr. Foreman?" Before the judge had finished speaking, ‘the foreman of the jury quickly replied "not guilty.” Cheer after cheer broke out upon the stillness of a midsummer afternoon like the report of distant artillery. The court studiously refrained from all at tempt at suppression of this demonstra tion. and it was some minutes before all became ugain silenced and still. t\ hen order was again restored tue formal question was asked: "You say, Mr. Foreman, not guilty, so you say, so von all sav." \ uu au say. “Lizzie Andrew Borden," said the
Lizzie Borden's face went pale then flushed as the jury's 'not guilty' verdict was announced, and she wept with her head bowed on the rail before the judge discharged her. A reception followed in the judge's chambers with well-wishers, jurors, and even her former jailers shaking her hand before she departed by carriage for Fall River.
Ceredo Advance · 28 June 1893 · page 2
Immediately upon adjournment the jury expressed a desire to take the hand of Miss Borden, and the eyes of sunn who were present suffused'with moist ure. * iov. Robinson was the first U ron grata late her. and even he, thi trained attorney, could not repress hi*, j .-motion. Rev. Mr. Buck, her pastor, could onh •veep. Miss Borden was led into the | judge * room and a reception was giver ber which was participated in by tin citizens of her own home at Kail River ts well as by the people of New Bed 'ord.
See moreSee less
Newspaper men. judges, court offi -ers. the men who had been her jailers :ind even the men who had Wen hrt «eens»-rs. gathered around her to shnkr hands with her. Mis* Borden left N.-vv Bedford in a carriage at 5:21 to return to her Kail River home.
A relative reports that Lizzie and Emma Borden, along with housekeeper Bridget Sullivan, plan to sail for Europe once arrangements can be made. The sisters had just returned to their Second Street home after spending the night at Charles Holmes' residence following the trial.
Ceredo Advance · 28 June 1893 · page 2
THE BORDEN SISTERS. They. Together With Bridget Sulllvitn, " *11 S (|| for Kurope. 1 A 1.1, ItlVKK. Mass., June 22. — It is said by n relative of the Borden family -hat as soon as Mi** Lizzie and her sis
A short item reports that Lizzie Borden, accused of killing her father and stepmother in Fall River, Massachusetts, was tried and acquitted. The case is noted as having attracted significant national attention.
Ceredo Advance · 28 June 1893 · page 4
Miss Lizzie Borden, whose trial attracted so much attention throughout the country, and who was accused of killing her father and step-mother, at Fall Kiv$r,
The Rawlins Republican · Rawlins, Wyo. · and 1 other paper
A brief item quotes the New York Herald predicting the Lizzie Borden trial will surpass any US criminal trial in public interest since Guiteau's. The piece notes the intense national attention the case is drawing, especially in New England.
The Rawlins Republican · 29 June 1893 · page 2
‘•The trial of Lizzie Borden,” says . the New York Herald, "bids fair to surpass in general interest any crim inal trial in this country .since that of Guiteau.” Not only in New Eng
The Bessemer Indicator · Bessemer, Colo. · 24 June 1893
The Green Forest Tribune · Green Forest, Ark.
Lizzie Borden, now an heiress to her father's estate, returned home to Fall River after being acquitted by a New Bedford jury of murdering her father and stepmother. The jury deliberated only one hour and twenty minutes before delivering the verdict.
The Green Forest Tribune · 29 June 1893 · page 1
The Democratic J udicial Convention at Little Rock nominated Judge Carroll I). Wood as Associate Justice. Sixty-one ballots were taken. Th e strike of the lumber shovers of Tonawanda, N. Y., which caused the calling out of militia, has beeu compromised by a commit tee of citizens. The monument in commemoration of the Fort Dearborn Indian massacre, the gift of George M. Pull in..u to Chicago was formally un veiled Thursday. Charley Borden, aged 10, shot and
The jury at New Bedford deliberated for one hour twenty minutes before returning a verdict of not guilty for Lizzie Borden on charges of murdering her father and stepmother. She returned to her Fall River home the night after the verdict, greeted by cheers from spectators in the courtroom.
The Green Forest Tribune · 29 June 1893 · page 1
Lizzie Burden Acquitted. Fall River, Mass., June 21.— Lizzie Borden, now one of the full heiresses of the estate of her father, Andrew J. Bor den. banker and capitalist, returned quietly to her home here last night and for the first time in ten months slept the sleep of a free woman. The verdict of the jury at New Bed ford, which acquitted Miss Borden of the terrible charge of willfully murder ing her father and stepmother, was ren dered yesterday after a deliberation lasting one hour and twenty minutes. It was just 4:80 o’clock when the spectators, who had kept their seats during the retirement of thejury, notic ed a movement indicating their return.
See moreSee less
A moment later the twelve men filed in to their seats and were polled. Miss Borden was asked to stand up and the foreman was asked to return the verdict, which he announced—“Not guilty.” Then a cheer went up which might have been heard half a mil9 away through the open windows and there was no attempt to check it. The jus tices looked straight ahead at the bare wallB. As soon as possible the room was cleared, although it waR a hard task, since everybody waited to shake hands with Miss Borden. About an hour af terward she was placed in a carriage and driven to the station, where she took the train for this city.
The newspaper expresses hope that journalists will now allow Lizzie Borden to return to obscurity following the killing of her parents. It notes her burden is already heavy without continued media attention.
Waterbury Evening Democrat · 29 June 1893 · page 2
To-moebow will close the present fls-1 I oal year and Instead of the eight or ten million deficiency which was estimated by Raam there will remain unexpended more than one million of the pension ap propriation. It is to be hoped that the newspapers will hereafter allow Lizzie Borden to
The report confirms Lizzie Borden's acquittal on murder charges and describes her return home to Fall River, noting she has received thousands of supportive letters from women's temperance and Christian groups. It also details the vicious, insulting letters received by prosecutors Marshal Hilliard, Mayor Coughlin, and Judge Blaisdell for their roles in the case.
The National Tribune · 29 June 1893 · page 8
Judgo Blaisdell is in receipt of a communica tion from a crank which i3 postmarked Ames bury. Tho writer censures the Judge for his connection with tho Borden case, and advises him to go back to shoomaking.
The report describes the final day of the trial, including Lizzie Borden's statement of innocence and Judge Dewey's charge to the jury. It recounts the jury's brief deliberation and their return with a verdict of acquittal, which was met with loud cheers in the packed courtroom.
The Oskaloosa Herald · 29 June 1893 · page 1
Miss Borden Is Acquitted of the Charge of Murder.
LIZZIE BORDEN. tered the room at 8:55. Ex-Gov. Rob inson took a seat beside her and the two engaged in conversation until court opened at 9 o’clock. The jury was polled and the district attorney con cluded his argument. The chief justice then addressed Miss Borden by name, telling her that she now hail a voiee and could say to the jury what she choose to say. She arose, somewhat agitated, and said to the jury: “I am innocent, but 1 will leave my case in your hands and in the hands of my counsel.” Given to the Jury.
See moreSee less
Judge Dewey then charged the jury. At the conclusion of the charge, at 3:15, the attorneys consulted a few moments. The jury was allowed to retire and counsel agreed upon what exhibits were to be put in the case, after which they were brought in again, the oath administered by the clerk of the court and the jury took the case. The Verdict Caused a Cheer.
The jury returned a verdict of not guilty in the Lizzie Borden trial, prompting a cheer in the courtroom. Lizzie Borden was freed and returned home afterward.
The Oskaloosa Herald · 29 June 1893 · page 1
NOT GUILTY. SHE IS FREE.
Lizzie Returns Home. Fall River, Mass., June 22. —Lizzie Borden returned to her home Wednes day in company with her sister Emma. A domestic in the house said the two girls broke down when they entered their old home. Lizzie spent a pleasant night at the Holmes residence and was very cheerful at breakfast. She declined to be inter viewed. Her mail to-day is enormous, congratulations being showered on her from all points. The temper of the peo ple has been changed greatly by the verdict, for which there is now general respect.
Iron County Register · Ironton, Mo. · and 1 other paper
Following her acquittal, Lizzie Borden is reported to be receiving around 200 letters daily, many from Christian Endeavor and W.C.T.U. society members expressing support. Meanwhile, local officials Marshal Hilliard and Mayor Coughlin receive vile, abusive letters criticizing the verdict.
Iron County Register · 29 June 1893 · page 2
LIZZIE BORDEN'S MAIL. Ittera Being Received from the Chris tian Endeavor and W. C. T. C. Socie ties. Faix Riteb, Mass., June 24. Lizzie Borden's daily mail is something ex
The Jasper Weekly Courier · Jasper, Ind. · 30 June 1893
The Indianapolis Journal · Indianapolis, Ind.
An exchange notes that Lizzie Borden will continue to face reminders of the crime due to New England's intolerant attitudes. However, since she is wealthy, the piece suggests she need not fear serious social ostracism.
The Indianapolis Journal · 29 June 1893 · page 4
Democrat. He refused to be sworn in, and started back to Washington with the avowed purpose of making things warm for Secretary Iloko Smith. The executive committee of the encamp ment are making no mistake in having the barracks located as near the center of the city as possible. At one or two previous encampments the barracks were nearly ueeless because located four or five miles from the heart of the city, to which locations transportation was limited and uncomfortable. The president of the Niedringbaus roll ing mills, of St. Louis, positively refuses to sign a scale of wages with bia employes.
See moreSee less
Tariff legislation, he says, threatens to cheapen tbe product of his mills dnripg the ensuing year, and, as the wages of his men would have to be reduced according ly, he will not sign the scale they have presented. An exchange says that Lizzie Borden will continue to be reminded of the crime with which she was charged by the narrow and intolerant spirit of New England. As Miss Borden is more than "well fixed," no one
The Kanabec County Times · Mora, MN · and 1 other paper
Lizzie Borden was acquitted at New Bedford of murdering her father and stepmother at Fall River, Mass. The killings had occurred on August 4, 1892.
The Kanabec County Times · 29 June 1893 · page 2
Lizzie Borden was acquitted at New Bedford of the charge of murdering her father and stepmother at Fall River, Mass., on August 4, 1892. By the terms of Edwin Booth’s will
Griggs Courier · Cooperstown, Dak. N.D. · 30 June 1893
The Worthington Advance · Worthington, Minn.
The report notes that Lizzie Borden, recently acquitted of murdering her parents, and her sister Emma have resumed their residence, church, and social life in Fall River, Massachusetts. It also mentions the Borden estate, valued around $300,000 with the sisters as sole heirs, and states the cost of Lizzie's defense was about $50,000.
The Worthington Advance · 29 June 1893 · page 2
LIZZIE BORDEN, recently acquitted of the charge of murdering her parents, and her sister Emma have fully re sumed their residence and their church and social relations in Fail River, Mass., occupying the old homestead. The Borden estate is about and the 1300,000, yound ladies are sole heirs. The cost of Miss Lizzie's defense is put at 950,000.
This general news roundup reports that a New Bedford jury deliberated only an hour and twenty minutes before finding Lizzie Borden not guilty of murdering her father and stepmother. It also notes an earlier moment where Borden and her sister wept upon returning to their old home.
The Farmers' Union · 29 June 1893 · page 6
Eight firemen were more or less injured by an explosion of naphtha in a building in New York, where a lire was in prog ress. Edwin Booth's will divided an estate worth 695,009 among friends and rela tives, with a liberal bequest to the chari table institutions. The jury at New Bedford, Mass., after being out an hour and twenty minutes, found Lizzie Borden not guilty of the murder of her father and stepmother. There is trouble in the Ohio Republican camp . Four towns in the Northwest were wiped out by lire.
See moreSee less
At Oenton, Ivy., Hoi Osborn shot and killed two men. New Rochelie, N. Y., is reported prac tically bankrupt. Samuel Adler, a prominent New York Jew, committed suicide. Walter Besant, the English novelist, has arrived at New York. Fire destroyed a six-story building at Chicago, entailing 390,090 loss. Chairman Bland is out in reply to Sec retary Carlisle on the silver question. O. H. Jamison, a furniture dealerof To ledo, O.. has failed and left the place. E. G. Eames and his wife were killed in a railway accident near Carbon Bluff,
A roundup of brief national news items states that after deliberation of a few minutes, Lizzie Borden was found not guilty of murdering her father and stepmother. The item appears amid a jumble of unrelated news briefs and even references the trial's state testimony as still ongoing elsewhere in the same roundup.
The Farmers' Union · 29 June 1893 · page 6
Brocklyn Bridge. A young Mexican of Chiapas named Vicente Beoaiandro killed his sweetheart and committed suicide. The State in the Borden murder case has closed after 10 days and the defense has begun. The Supreme Court of Illinois has affirmed the death sentence of Wm. J Jamison and set August IS as the date of execution .
This digest-style news roundup mentions that in the case of Lizzie Borden, on trial at New Bedford for the murder of her father and stepmother at Fall River, the jury returned a verdict of 'not guilty' on the 20th. The item is one of many brief news items covering unrelated events from around the same period.
Iron County Register · 29 June 1893 · page 6
21st, on the steamship Columbia. It consisted of $900,000, and was imported by Baring, Magoun &. Co. The official investigation into the bomb explosion at the residence of Senor Canoras del Castillo, in Madrid has led to the discovery of a plot that embraces anarchists in several Euro pean countries. The advisability of having a twenty five cent admission day at the World's fair was discussed by members of the council of administration, on the 23d, and the chances are that the half-rate -will be tried Sunday, July 2. Secretart Carlisle, on the 22d, directed Treasurer Mergan to antici pate the payment of the July interest on the 4 per cent.
See moreSee less
United States bonds and on the Pacific railroad bonds to relieve the financial pressure. In the caseot Miss Lizzie Borden, on trial at New Bedford, Mass., for the alleged murder of her father and step-mother at Fall River, Mass., last August, the jury, on the 20th, re turned a verdict of "not guilty." 1 ' Ax attempt to hold up and rob the Atlantic & Pacific passenger train near Coolidge, N. M-, on the -"id, was frus trated by the coolness and daring of the engineer in pulling oat after the train had been stopped by the robbers.
Following her recent acquittal on charges of killing her father and stepmother, Lizzie Borden of Fall River, Mass. is receiving an enormous volume of mail. Many letters come from Christian Endeavor and W.C.T.U. societies across the country.
Iron County Register · 29 June 1893 · page 6
Miss Lizzie Borden, of Fall River, Mass., who was recently acquitted of the charge of killing her father and step-mother, is daily in receipt of an
A roundup of general news items from around the country notes briefly that Lizzie Borden has been acquitted of the murder of her father and stepmother. The item is one line among many unrelated news snippets about disasters, deaths, and curiosities.
Iuka Reporter · 29 June 1893 · page 2
GENERAL NEWS.
In point of disasters the year 18 6eems to be a notable one. Much of Louisiaua’s best sugar land has been inundated the past three weeks. A man has been found on the pen sion rolls, (he cause for which is the loss of hair. Lizzie Borden has been acquitted of
The Associated Press reports that a jury in New Bedford has found Lizzie Borden not guilty of murdering her father and stepmother. The report describes the courtroom scene, including Judge Dewey's charge to the jury, Borden's statement of innocence, and the cheering that erupted when the verdict was announced.
Fergus County Argus · 29 June 1893 · page 1
NOT GUILTY
"IOT oGUITY." ash Wua the Verdict Rendered in the lamose Linie Borden Murder Trial. An Associated Press dispatch from New Bedford says: The jury has ac quitted Lizzie Borden of the murder of her father and stepmother, with wT-hL she L. bim r.ctraw. The court came in promptly at 1:45, every seat in the room being occupied as usual. The chief justice then ad dressed Miss Borden by name, telling her that she now had a voice and , could say to the jury what she chose to say. She arose somewhat agitated and said to the jury: "I am inno cent, but I will leave my case in your hands and in the hands of my coun sel."
See moreSee less
Judge Dewey then chalted the jury. He read his charIe rapidly and j among other things emtbodied thlerein was the caution to nmltke their de
The jury's not guilty verdict is announced, prompting a minute-long cheer from the courtroom despite attempts to maintain decorum. Lizzie Borden breaks down in tears as her defense team, including Jennings and Adams, react with emotion before she is taken to recover privately and then driven to the train station.
Fergus County Argus · 29 June 1893 · page 1
NOT GUILTY
Miss Borden. When the spectators had finally gone she was taken to the room of the justices and allowed to l recover her composurewith only the eyes of friends upon her and thecaress
The report states that Lizzie Borden was tried in Massachusetts for the murder of her father and stepmother and was acquitted. It notes the case attracted great attention and that many believed she committed the crime but there was insufficient proof to convict.
Watauga Democrat · 29 June 1893 · page 2
The trial of Lizzie Borden for the murder of her father and step-mother, resulted in her acquittal. This trial was in the state of Mass., a h r! has attracted more attention thon any 'such case of 'recent date. It is generally belieV' ed that Lizzie Borden did the! inhuman act, out no proof could.be had sufficient to coa vict her 'iy-VV-. ','' : Many of the surplus clerks in tbe various departments of the government atWash ington will soon be dismissed from their service as t h e r e seems to .
See moreSee less
be no earthly use for thero. Agenerul clean ing trp cf hrrrrs on i3 rii- !1 ; ' c, ra trv rpeose to the government will bat suspended. Th1e was a be savedi It hi high time to great surprise in financial cir begin to economize, the way clea, as it was thought to be things are financially. on a Bound basis and was considered a substantial af As we intimated in our last issue, It. B Glenn, of Wins fair. ion, ha been appointed Dis On the 23rd inst., n roost trict Attorney and Kope Eli terrible calamity befell the as Collector of Internal Reve British battle ship Victoria, nue for the Western District. a flag ship of of theMediter Now for the many applicants ranean squadron. This ship to obtaiu the Deputy Collec flew the flag of Vice Admiral tor's place. Also clerks, store Sir George Tryon, wus run keeper, gangers all come un into off the coast of Tripoli, der Air. Elias. by the British battle ship BOONE. Camperdown of the same Editor Democrnt: squadron, under the com It seems to me thatt h e mand ofCapt.Chas. Johnson. town of Boone lias more fea The Victoria had an enor tures of notice thaivany town mous hole made in her side, of ike dimensions in t n e through which the vate r mountain counliesof .North poured in 'floods and from Carolina. She makes no pre which she soon sank carrying tentions whatever to be a four hundred of the six hun city and is not envious of dred passenger on board, with lipvhithebnt.tnm. Somesuch an honor.-.. But of h e r population he has ever boas of the officei s managed to get ted. It is too well known to out of the suction caused by again repeat, that the Boone the sinking of the ;esel and people have more morenobb were saved. Vice Admiral Try traits than almost any peo on was among the lost. The ple living. The troubles ara Victoria was a twin screw bat so fuw that occur within her tie ship, 10,470 tons and orders that we might say 14,000 horse power. there are really none. The North Curolina 8tato Mr. Editor, your town is Weather Service for the week kind and generous. The peoending the 19th inst. states ile will always do their part that in sections of the State of benevolent work. - Watau the crops have been injured ga should ever be proud of by the excess of ruin fall, her town, for that means to though on a general average e proud of herself. I don't it states that the crops are nieun to say thut Boone is n fairly good. In the western great, flourishing, booming, part of the State a great deal thriving town of several thou of rain has fallen and farm sand inhabitants, but think work has been greatly "retar for a moment. Did jrou know ded. In Watauga we have that Boone, has,, a better had a vast amount of rain court house and jail t h u n thus far this month and some any county touching her and hink that wheat and rye will that the financial condition not fill welk Corn is rather of the county coaUTbe no bet smaller than it usually is at tei ? The Bryan and Coffey this time of year, but oats Hotels are the best in tn e and grass are extra fine. country, and are th only'hb
The jury in the Lizzie Borden murder trial returned a verdict of 'Not Guilty' at 4:30 PM, prompting a cheer that shook the courtroom. The district attorney then moved to drop the remaining charges against her, which the court granted.
The Western Sentinel · 29 June 1893 · page 1
Eight Deaths at Parkville. New Bedford, Mass., June 21. Tne Lizzie Borden murder case, which has attracted widespread at tention and interest, was concluded yesterday. At 3: 15 o'clock the Judge concluded his charge to the jury, who at 4:30 Hied into their seats and were polled. Miss Borden was asked to stand up, and the foreman was asked to return the verdict, upon which he announced "Not guilty." After the verdict had been received the district attorney moved that the other cases against Miss Borden be. nolle prosequied, and the order of the court was to that effect. When the verdict was returned a deep silence prevailed in the court room, broken in a few seconds by a cheer that literally made the building shake.
A short news brevity reports that the jury has acquitted Lizzie Borden of the murder of her father and stepmother. It appears amid other unrelated local and national news items.
The Central Nevadan · 29 June 1893 · page 3
J U L\. I'lic California orchards and vine yards needs ail the labor there is in that State. 1 he jury I),-.- acquitted Lizzie Borden of the murder of her father
A Georgia judge, in charging a jury in an unrelated murder case, suggested the Borden case was only paralleled in enormity 'if that murder was committed by Lizzie Borden.' The editorial blasts him for seemingly forgetting or ignoring that Borden was acquitted, calling his remark 'bad form, and judicial bad form, at that.'
Pawtucket Tribune · 29 June 1893 · page 2
Julian Force at Atlanta, Ga.. of the charge of marder Judge Clark said: ““This crime, committed by a Christian woman, is enormous, the only parallel to it being the Borden murder, if that murder was committed by Lizzie Borden.” Perhaps his Honor, with the exsy somnolence of the South, does not know that the Fall River woman was acquitted, and that his statement is worse than immoral and inde cent; it !¢ bad form, and judiclal baa form, at that. ; e e Says John Most to the pardoned Anar chists of Chieago: “Welecome!
See moreSee less
We greet them as soldiers returning to our ranks ready to unsheathe the sword against all that is wrong—Church, State and Capital, and in aid of all good things good—Anar ohy, Communism and the Soclal Revola tion.” There is nothing uncertain about this, By their friends ye shall know them, and such are the friends of Uov. Altgeld of Illinols, and the temporarily repentent Fielden, Schwab and Neebe. ' - c No better evidence of the decay of the Garfield Club and 001. Tiepke’s following
The report describes the emotional scene in the New Bedford courtroom as the jury returned a verdict of 'Not Guilty' for Lizzie Borden. It details the cheering crowd, the weeping judges, and Borden's own tears upon hearing the verdict.
Edgefield Advertiser · 29 June 1893 · page 1
THE JUSTICES WEPT. THE JURY RENDERED A VERDICT OF "NOT GUILTY"
Columbia Journal. NEW BEDFORD, Mass., June 21 . A nid the waving of handkerchiefs and tumultuous cheering yester day afternoon Lizzie Borden re joiced that she was to go free. The dark cloud that had been hovering over her waa dispelled. Tears fell from the eyes of the stern justices, and the sc^a was such as has never been known in this country. The justices made no effort to stop the demonstration. Their hearts wei* . wi th the people, and for a few mo ments they forgot law and deco rum. The jory filed into their seats at i :30 p. m., and were polled. Miss ' Borden was asked to stand up, and
The jury delivers a verdict of 'Not Guilty' for Lizzie Borden, prompting a tremendous cheer in the courtroom and tears from the judge, her lawyers, and herself. The other case against her is dismissed, and after resting at the justices' room she is taken home to Fall River, briefly staying at a friend's house first.
Edgefield Advertiser · 29 June 1893 · page 1
VERDICT OF NOT GUILTY
Miss Borden's head went down upon the rail in front of her, and tears came where they had refused to come for many long days as she heard the sweetest words ever poured in to-her willing ears, the words "Not GnUty." Mr. Jennings was almost crying, and his voice brok?) as he put his hand ont to Mr. Adams, who sat next to him, and said, "Thank God!" while Adams returned the' pressure of the hand and seemed incapable of speech. After the verdict had been re ceived the district attorney moved that the other case against Miss Borden be nolle prossed, and the oider of the court was to that effect Chief Justice Mason then grace fully thanked the jurois, in appre ciation of their work and faithful service, and reminded them that the precautions taken with them, which may have seemed irksome at the time, were solely in the in terest of justice-a fact which they undoubtedly realized now.
See moreSee less
The jury was then dismissed. Governor Robinson turned to f he rapidly dissolving jury as they id out of their seats and beamed riwith fatherly interest in indly Ayes, and stood up as M. .owltoii and Mr. Moody came ?, +o shake hands with the counsel for tue defence. As soon as possible the room was cleared. When the spectators had finally gone Miss Borden was taken to the room of the justices and allowed to recover her com posure, with only the eyes of friends upon her and the caresses of devoted admirers. At the expiration of an hour she was placed in a carriage and driven to the station, where abe took the train for Fall River, her home no longer probably, Lut still the only objective point for the immediate present.
After her acquittal, Lizzie Borden returned by carriage to her Second Street home in Fall River, having spent the previous night at a friend's house. The report describes the quiet, emotional homecoming, the public's shifted sentiment favoring the verdict, and the flood of congratulatory letters reaching her lawyer.
Edgefield Advertiser · 29 June 1893 · page 1
LIZZIE BORDEN RETURNS HOME.
Borden lay when be waa mur de ie at the central police station s will not be removed for a day two. Lizzie spent a very pleas; night and was very cheerful breakfast in the Holmes reside] this morning. A domestic in 1 family house on Second street reported to have said that the t girl s broke down completely wb they entered their old home. 1 rV.y Andrew J. Jennings is rece ing letters and telegrams of cc gratulationi from all parts of t country and Miss Borden's mail very heavy. The sentiment of t people of this city has be changed greatly by the verdict ? there is manifest respect for t decision of tbs jury.
The report states that Lizzie Borden of Fall River, Mass., was declared innocent by the jury in her trial for the murder of her father and stepmother. It notes that the mystery of the double murder in broad daylight remains unsolved.
Edgefield Advertiser · 29 June 1893 · page 2
=== rHOS. J. ADAMS,.EDITOR v - , THURSDAY, JUNE 29,1893. Senator Stanford, of California, died a few days ago, of paralysis of the heart. He left a fortune of . $35,000,000. . ' The famous "Blarney Stone," which for centuries occupied a place in the walls of the historic Blarney castle, in Ireland, has ar rived at the World's Fair. An explosion of dynamite in Madrid last week resulted in the death of two of the Spanish no bility, and the injury of many other persons. Anarchists are at j the bottom of it, and great excite ment prevails.
See moreSee less
Lizzie Borden, of Fall River, Mass,, whose trial for the murder of her father and stepmother has . excited such wide-spread interest, has been declared innocent by the jury, and the mystery of the I double murder in broad daylight remains unsolved. The British battle ships Vic toria and Camperdown collided in the Mediterranean sea on Friday. The Victoria sank' in fifteen; fathoms of water. Over four hun dred lives were lost, including Ad miral Sir George Tryon, who was? in charge of the squadron. Kansas and Missouri were visited j by a fearful cyclone last week, in which there was great loss ot life j and destruction of property. In Georgia, also, there was a wind- [ storm }f unusual severity, which damaged crops, buildings, otc, and gave the people a big scare. Lieut. T. Q. Donaldson, of the U. S. A., who has been filling the
The report announces Lizzie Borden has been acquitted of the Fall River murders of her father and stepmother. It criticizes the prosecution for pursuing a theory of guilt without real evidence and suggests officers should have faced consequences for malicious prosecution.
Pierre Weekly Free Press · 29 June 1893 · page 4
President Cleveland once got within a 1 few miles of South Dakota, and his then he has forgotten that there arc other portions of the state and is giving his official favors to the faithful of that reminders. Hassler of Washington ('ity but credited to Forest City, ami liurke of some southern state and credited to Aberdeen, are the other state appoint ments. We are not complaining but wuuld suggest that there area whole lot of hungry democrats in other parts of who are anxious to be taken ,,f lre Lizzie Horden, the alleged parricide of Fall River, has been triumph Mass., antly acquitted after one of the most determined efforts at conviction ever attempted by officers of the law.
See moreSee less
There was absolutely no evidence to connect Lizzie Borden with the murder of her
The jury returns a verdict of not guilty for Lizzie Borden, prompting an emotional outburst in the courtroom with cheering and tears. Her defense attorneys react with relief and gratitude as the verdict is announced.
The Comet · 29 June 1893 · page 3
Miss Borden's head went down on the rail in front of her and tears came in where they had refused to come for many a long day, as 6he heard the sweetest words ever poured into her willing ears, the words: "Not guilty." Jennings was almost crying and his voice broke as he put out his hand to Adams who sat next to him and said, "Thank God," while Adams returned the pressure of the hand and seemed incapable of speech. Gov. RobinsoH turned to the rapidly dissolving jury as they filed out of their seats and gleamed on them with fatherly interest in his kindly eyes and stood up as Knowlton and Moody came over to shake hands with the counsel for the defense.
See moreSee less
As soon as possible tho room was cleared. When the spectators had finally gone Miss Borden was taken to the room of the justico and allowed to recover her composure, with only the eyes of friends upon her and the ca res3es of devoted admirers. At the ex piration of an hour she was placed in carriage and driven to the station. where Bhe took the train for Fall Riv er, her home no longer probably, but still the only objective point for her immediate presence.
The jury delivers a verdict of 'Not guilty' for Lizzie Borden, prompting an emotional scene in the courtroom with cheering spectators and tears from Borden and her defense team. She is later taken by carriage to the train station to return to Fall River.
The Comet · 29 June 1893 · page 3
...BORDEN EVER HEARD.
As soon as possible tho room was cleared. When the spectators had finally gone Miss Borden was taken to the room of the justico and allowed to recover her composure, with only the eyes of friends upon her and the ca res3es of devoted admirers. At the ex piration of an hour she was placed in carriage and driven to the station. where Bhe took the train for Fall Riv er, her home no longer probably, but still the only objective point for her immediate presence.
This editorial reports that Lizzie Borden's murder trial ended in acquittal, which it says came as no surprise. It blames incompetent and dishonest detectives for building a weak case against her to cover their own failures.
The Austin Weekly Statesman · 29 June 1893 · page 2
Union upon the very principles that the South baa labored and fought for since the adoption of the federal con stitution. DETECTIVE PERSECUTION OF LIZ ZIE BORDEN. The sensational trial of Lizzie Borden jpon the charge of havlug committed the most heartless double murder of modern times, hai terminated In her acquittal. To those who have follow ed the incidents of the trial from day to day the result comes as no surprise. Even before the prosecution had rested Us case, it became appareut that the young woman was being sacrificed to a theory conceived by blundering de tectives to cover their own incompe tency.
See moreSee less
That a brutal double murder could be perpetrated in broad open day in the front rooms of a houte oc cupying the central position of the most densely populated quarter of a populous town, and the murderer es cape without leaving a trace of his flight behind him, was an acheive meiit charged with too much signifi
Lizzie Borden returned with her sister to their Second Street home in a closed carriage, with few spectators present. They refused to speak to reporters, and a domestic reportedly said the sisters broke down upon entering the house.
The Austin Weekly Statesman · 29 June 1893 · page 3
Lizzie Borden Returns Home. Fall, River. Mass.. June 21. Lizzie Borden returned with her sister this morning to her home on Second street. They drove to the
A small-town Virginia newspaper's miscellany column remarks that the Lizzie Borden case is a 'squeezed lemon' and that Americans are glad to drop it. The comment appears among unrelated weather, politics, and local news items rather than as a dedicated news report.
The Valley Virginian · 29 June 1893 · page 2
The camp meeting and the summer shower season are at hand. The man who prophesied a cool sum mer has taken to the woods. The summer thermometer hasresum ed business at. the old stand. An effort is being made to organize an artillery company at Charlottesville. The gold stream has turned this way again. America can stand a tulal-wave oi that sort. The Lizzie Borden case is a squeezed
The report states that Lizzie Borden was acquitted of murdering her stepmother and father. It notes surprise that the case went to trial given weak evidence, and that she had been jailed since the previous August.
Clarke Courier · 29 June 1893 · page 2
Miss Lizzie Borden was acquitted of the charge of murdering her step mother and father. The evidence against her was so weak that much surprise is expressed that the case was taken into court and that she should have been held in jail ever since last August to undergo such an issue. Iu a sermon delivered before the Methodist ministers of Tarrytowu,
Following her acquittal, Lizzie Borden returned home with her sister Emma, receiving hundreds of letters of support from across the country, including from Christian Endeavor and W.C.T.U. societies. The report notes the public mood has shifted toward respect for the jury's verdict, and mentions rumors of a planned European trip and offers for Lizzie to appear in a museum exhibit.
LIZZIE BORDEN'S MAIL. OrutuMfhim I With Loiters, from All l'(i!nt (if tlia Comji.is. Kai.Ij KlVKK, Mass., June 2IJ. Lizzie Iiorden's mall is something extraordinary. At least 200 letters weru taken to her home this morning by the lono man who, resides in tho house, nnd he makes frequent visits to the poitolllcj during tho day. A groat many of tho lottors coma from members ot Christian Kndeavor nu l W, C. T. U. so cieties throughout tho country. The girls havo not slopped out once since their arrival home, but aro kept very busy receiving callers. Marshal Ullliard and Mayor Coughlin nie receiving some astonishing letters, most ot them being of the dirtiest and most vlllllyinz churactcr. Among othcr'thlugs he received a big leather modul Irom New York iStnto.
The report states that Lizzie Borden was declared not guilty of murdering her father and stepmother. The jury deliberated for only an hour and a half before reaching its verdict.
Wood County Reporter · 29 June 1893 · page 2
Lizzie Borden was declared guiltless of the murder of her father and stepD'Other. The jury was out but an hour and a half. A steady improvement in the condi tion of labor is shown by the report of a subcommittee of the senate commit tee on finance on prices and wages fox fifty years. The duke of Yeragua has sent a let ter to Secretary Gresham thanking the government for the manner in which he was entertained while in the United States. Rainmaker Melbourne has made a contract with Senator Warren and other citizens of Laramie county, Wyo., to produce one-half inch of rain within the next live clays Miss Nettie Wetzel swallowed several grains of strychnine at Peoria, 111., and died a few hours later.
See moreSee less
She was 1G years old and Inis been insane on the subject of suicide for over a year. After many days of sifting of panels, a jury was finally completed in court
Wood County Reporter · Wisconsin Rapids, Wis. · and 1 other paper
Following the end of the Borden trial, Fall River police have begun a new search for the murderer, prompted by public demand after ex-Governor Robinson's defense remarks. They question a minister about a suspected former Borden clerk, while a previously discredited story about two men at the Borden house is reprinted, and Lizzie Borden remains secluded at home.
Wood County Reporter · 29 June 1893 · page 3
POLICE WAKE UP. Fall River, Mass., June 26.—The po nce of this city have untangled thorn s', Ives from the snarl ex-Goveruor Robinson got them into at Xew Bed ford during the Borden trial and in re sponse to a public demand have formal ly begun to look for the person who murdered Andrew J. Borden and his wife. The first thing they did was to call on Parson Jubb. who startled a Xew York correspondent Tuesday by telling him that the counsel for the de fense had a pretty strong opinion that they knew who did the murders, and had the jury returned any other verdict the man's arrest would have been or dered immediately.
See moreSee less
Furthermore, the minister said this suspected party was well known in Fall River, When ques tioned about this Mr. Jennings smiled and said that Mr. Juhb had put the matter too positively. The person referred to ■was a former clerk of Andrew Borden who left his employ some years ago under a cloud and has lived out of the city over since. A Boston paper to-day printed a long story telling again ihe exploded tale of two men in a wagon on the day of the murder, one of whom went to the door of the house and held a short conversation with Andrew Borden. The girls have again offered a reward for the arrest and conviction of the murderer. Lizzie Borden still keeps close within doors. Some of her intimate friends have called upon her and her mail is still enormous. The plant of the Northern Manufact uring company, at Ashland, was de droved by fire. Three residences in the immediate vicinity were badly scorched. Hie loss on the plant will be about $15,000: insurance 54.000.
Iowa County Democrat · Mineral Point, Wis. · 30 June 1893
The Saratoga Sun · Saratoga, Wyo.
Among a list of telegraphic brevities, the report states that Lizzie Borden was acquitted of murdering her father and stepmother. It is presented as a short factual news brief alongside other unrelated news items.
The Saratoga Sun · 29 June 1893 · page 2
Telegraphic Brevities Edwin Booth wu woith $600,000 when he died. European countries are suffering from heat and drought. Lizzie Borden was acquitted of murdering her father and stepmother. I Vice President Ezeta of Salvador has marI tied Miss Ida Dent Wright of New Yoik.
A one-line item in a roundup of telegraphic news briefs states that Lizzie Borden was acquitted of murdering her father and stepmother. It appears among other unrelated short news items from the period.
The Rawlins Republican · 29 June 1893 · page 2
Telegraphic Brevities. Edwin Booth was worth $600,000 when he died. European countries arc suffering from heat and drought. Lizzie Borden was acquitted of murdering her father and stepmother. The Gladstonlans have lost a seat in the Commons by a recent election. W. H. Prescott has been re-elected presi dent of the Typographical Union. Ex-President Harrison will spend two months at bls Cape May summer home. Vice President Ezeta of Salvador has mar ried Miss Ida Dent Wright of New Yoik.
This editorial argues that despite Lizzie Borden's acquittal, the prosecuting attorney was right to bring the case to trial given the circumstantial evidence pointing in one direction. It criticizes the press, especially the Denver News, for excessive sentimental backlash against prosecutors and police following the verdict.
The Buffalo Bulletin · 29 June 1893 · page 2
| to warrant n conviction, it was never | theless entirely in one direction, and ‘ there being nothing to set against it, I but previous good character, and ab ! s«*nee of motive, it would have been a ' gross neglect on the part of the prose cuting alterney not to have allowed the case to go to trial. Had he not done so, it is a certainty, that unless the actual murderer hnd been found and convicted on the clearest evidence, Miss Borden would have gone to the grave : with the burden of doubt upon her char ncter. That the release from the strain । caused by the long and harrussing sus-
Fisherman & Farmer · Edenton, N.C. · and 1 other paper
After a thirteen-day trial, the jury quickly found Lizzie Borden not guilty of murdering her father and stepmother, prompting cheers and applause in the courtroom. She wept with joy and returned to Fall River to stay with Banker Holmes.
Fisherman & Farmer · 30 June 1893 · page 3
Weeps for Joy--Her Future. After an ordeal lasting thirteen days Lizzie Borden was acquitted by the jury which tried her at New Bedford, Mass.. on the charge of murdering her Lather and stepmother She was almost overcome when the verdict was read, and men and women cheered the find ing. Miss Borden returned to Fall River,
Fisherman & Farmer · Edenton, N.C. · and 3 other papers
District Attorney Knowlton delivers a lengthy closing argument building the circumstantial case against Lizzie Borden, after which she briefly addresses the court declaring her innocence. Justice Dewey then begins his charge to the jury, outlining standards of proof for circumstantial evidence and motive.
Fisherman & Farmer · 30 June 1893 · page 3
DECLARE HER NOT GUILTY
When he had finished the Bordens and their friends looked gloomy and ex-Governor Robinson tried to cheer them up. Lizzie cried a little just before court took a recess. When court reconvened at a quarter to 2 o'clock Chief Justice Mason said, solemnly . 'Lizzie Andrew Borden, although you have
Passaic City Record · Passaic City, N.J. · 24 June 1893
The Press · Belleville, N.J. · 24 June 1893
The Abbeville Press and Banner · Abbeville, S.C. · 5 July 1893
The State Herald · Holyoke, Colo.
A one-line item in a roundup of national news briefs states that Lizzie Borden was acquitted of murdering her father and stepmother. No further details are given.
The State Herald · 30 June 1893 · page 2
Telegraphic) Brevities. Edwin Booth wai worth 1600,000 when he Hod. European countries arc suffering from heat tnd drought* 8. It. il. Clark, president of the Union Paclilo, la quite sick; Lizzie Borden was acquitted of murdering her father und stepmothor. Vico President Ezota of Salvndor has mar ried Miss Ida Dent Wright of New Yotk.
Among a long list of miscellaneous telegraphic news items, one line states that Lizzie Borden has been acquitted of the New Bedford homicide. No further detail is given.
The Hawaiian Star · 30 June 1893 · page 2
TELEGRAPHIC NOTES.
Niagara Falls. Walter Besant, the English novelist, is in Mew York. The cholera scourge is slowly work ing towards Paris. The Princess Eulalia sailed for Europe on the 24th. Embezzler Flood at San Francisco has been found guilty. President Cleveland and family have gone to Buzzard s Bay. Ex Prfsident Sacaza of Nicaragua is going to San Francisco. The British ship Royal Arthur has arrived at Santa Barbara. Lizzie Borden has been ar.quitttd of the New Bedfotd homicide.
Idaho County Free Press · Grangeville, Idaho Territory
This item summarizes the Lizzie Borden murder case for readers, explaining the brutal killings of Andrew and Abby Borden and the circumstances surrounding Lizzie's arrest. It notes the family tensions, a possible inheritance motive, and the timeline of who saw the victims shortly before their deaths.
Idaho County Free Press · 30 June 1893 · page 3
'SL *3* sm ! ïu* tmIal 6k Lizzie morden. The Borden niuVdbr case now on trial is one of the most extraordinary in the annals of crime. Lizzie Borden is charged with the murder of her father and step mother. The circumstances connected with the killing were particularly atro cious. The victims were not only killed by the dashing in of their skulls, but their heads were pounded out of sem blance to humanity almost. The sight was so terrible that it is said the phy sicians were almost sickened by it.
See moreSee less
Mrs. Borden had not been seen by any one for some time, perhaps an hour, before her body was found in her room. Mr, Borden was seen by the servant alive and well not more than twenty minutes before Lizzie called to the servant that he had been killed. A few particulars may be of service to help readers understand the case as the story is told by the dispatches from dey to day. The .Bordens were wealthy peo ple and the Moused girl, who is one of
Idaho County Free Press · Grangeville, Idaho Territory
This piece reviews the Borden case to help readers follow the daily dispatches, outlining the household's occupants and the narrow twenty-minute window in which Lizzie could have killed her father. It notes the puzzle that no blood was found on her despite the brutal nature of the killing, while also mentioning a rumored inheritance motive.
Idaho County Free Press · 30 June 1893 · page 3
he had been killed. A few particulars may be of service to help readers understand the case as the story is told by the dispatches from dey to day. The .Bordens were wealthy peo ple and the Moused girl, who is one of two daughters, was of excellent social standing, aud pi eminent in church and charitable work. She waa known not to be on very good .terms with her step mother and there is reason to believe that she knew of hsr father's intention to make a will learning half of hie prop erty to hie wife.
See moreSee less
This is supposed to have supplied the motive for the killing, but on the other band it ia pointed out that the relatione between the iaZher and daughter, though not marked by any ex travagant display of affection, were thoroughly friendly. The other daughter was away from home at the time the murder waa committed. A male relative was visiting the family, but he went out shortly iiefore the deed was committed, and hie movements duriug the time when the killing waa done are well settled. He cannot be connected with the crime in any way. The inmates of the houee on the morning of the murder, in addition to the man just mentioned, were Mr. and Mrs. Borden, Lizzie and the eervant girl. Unless tome one un known was concealed upon the premises and committed the crime, the oulv pel - eons who could have done it are Lizzie and the servant. The possibility of the servant's guilt ie not admitted and so far the case against Lizzie is baaed more upon the negative inference that there waa no other person who could have committed the deed than upon anything else. In order to establish her guilt cer tain facte consistent only with her inno cence must be overcome. The time at which Mr. Borden waß killed ie established within a few rain utes. Lizzie Borden's movements from
Idaho County Free Press · Grangeville, Idaho Territory
The piece lays out the narrow timeframe in which Lizzie Borden could have killed her father and earlier her stepmother, questioning how she could have avoided getting blood on herself. It speculates on how she might have hidden evidence and composed herself before raising the alarm, presenting this as the prosecution's probable theory of the crime.
Idaho County Free Press · 30 June 1893 · page 3
the time of the killing. Mrs. Borden was killed before her hus band, how long before is, of course, un known. Physicians who testified at the inquest said that the appearance of the stomach indicated that she was killed at least an hour sooner, but it is possible that the fact that Mr. Borden had bees down town would make some difference in the condition of the contents of the stomach. If Lizzie Borden committed the mur der, and it ie probable she did, ehe killed
The report notes that Lizzie Borden, recently acquitted of murdering her father and stepmother, is receiving a large volume of mail. Many letters come from Christian Endeavor and W.C.T.U. societies across the country.
The Jasper Weekly Courier · 30 June 1893 · page 6
LATE NEWS ITEMS.
Tryon, K. C. B. Two MEMRKits of the geological sur vey of Canada left Quebec, on the 23d, on the longest, most important and most perilous exploratory survey ever undertaken into what is now generally supposed to be the wild uninhabitable territory far north of Eastern Canada, known as the Labrador peninsula. Incensed at the result of the second ballot for members of the reiclistag, the socialists of Lubreek, Germany, on the 23d, made a demonstration that soon degenerated into a riot, during the progress of which u number of shop fronts were wrecked with stoues and clubs.
See moreSee less
Miss Lizzie Borden, of Fall River, Mass., who was recently acquitted of the charge of killing her father and step-mother, is daily in receipt of an j enormous mail, a number of the letters leing from the Christian Endeavor and W. C. T. U. societies throughout the country. Friedman it Friedman, wholesale clothing dealers of Chicago, confessed
The case was given to the jury on the 20th, and in just over an hour they returned a verdict of acquittal. This brief appears amid a list of other unrelated news items from around the country.
The Iola Register · 30 June 1893 · page 2
stantly killed. A train on the Long Island railroad was wrecked near Parkville. L. I. Nine persons were killed alnd about 100 in jured. The Lizzie Borden case was given to the jury on the 20th and in a little more than an hour a verdict of acquittal was returned. Henry Sheldon & Co., tea and coffee merchants, New York, have failed. Rev. Dr. Samuel Hart, professor of Trinity college, was elected bishop of the Episcopal church of Vermont Switchman McGeary has been held by a Gravesend justice for the killing ot ine nine people by the wrecking of the Sheepshcad Bay race train. A fifteen million dollar ocean steam ship combination has been formed at Jersey City.
Springfield Weekly Republican · Springfield, Mass.
The article discusses speculation that Attorney-General Pillsbury will be the Republican nominee for governor, but notes that public feeling over his decision not to personally prosecute Lizzie Borden may hurt his chances. The paper dismisses this criticism as unfair, defending Pillsbury's decision given his illness and the demands of his office.
Springfield Weekly Republican · 30 June 1893 · page 9
Pa<?es 9 to 12. CURRENT BAT STATE QUESTIONS. । Speculation about the republican candi date for governor generally settles upon Attorney-General Pillsbury as the man : who is likely to receive the indorsement of ■the September convention, though there g are those who think otherwise. Among them is the political observer of the Bos s ton Transcript, who believes that “the ‘acquittal of Miss Borden is very general ly regarded as eliminating Mr Pillsbury ; ‘from the problem. People are more prone ! ‘to be ruled by prejudice than by common ‘sense, anil it cannot be brushed out of 'sight that there is quite a feeling against i ‘Mr Pillsbury, however undeserved, and it ‘extends to those who have thought Lizzie ‘Borden guilty, as well as to those who ‘have from the first asserted her innoVence.
See moreSee less
The former blame him for not ‘taking charge of the trial, instead of dele ‘gating that duty to another, while the ‘latter persist in regarding the attorney ‘gendral as responsible for what they call ‘the persecution of the accused.'’ This is sail stuff, even for the hot season, and While such nonsense may be talked in the lobbies of Boston hotels, it will not. com mand any general degree of respect. Mr Pillsbury's serious illness, from which his recovery has been slow, enough for his determination not to con duct the prosecution of Miss Borden. The wisdom of that decision has been evident to all who have read the reports of the exciting proceedings at Now Bedford, con ducted in the midst of intolerable heat. Finally it will be remembered that Mr Pillsbury has protested ever since he has been in office that it was clearly too much to ask the attorney-general, with the other business of his office, to attend all the murder trials, every year becoming more irequent. To assert that the law was (changed this year expressly to permit Mr Pillsbury to escape the Borden trial is to
The jury deliberated only ninety minutes before returning a verdict of not guilty in the Lizzie Borden murder trial at New Bedford. The courtroom erupted in cheers as Borden wept upon hearing the verdict, after Judge Dewey's careful charge urging jurors to give her every reasonable doubt.
Weekly Expositor · 30 June 1893 · page 2
Miss Borden was asked to stand up, and the foreman was asked to return the verdict, which he announced not uuilty." Then all the dignity und decorum of the court-room van ished. A cheer went up which might have been heard half a mile avuy through the open windows and there was no attempt to check it. The stately justices looked straight ahead ac the bare walls during the tremend ous excitement, which lasted fully a minute. Miss Borden's head went clown upon tho rail in front of her, and tears came where they had refused to come for many a long day as sho heard the sweetest words ever poured into her willing ears.
The Londonderry Sifter · South Londonderry, Vt. · and 2 other papers
This editorial piece reflects on Lizzie Borden's unanimous acquittal, suggesting the ordeal will haunt her for the rest of her life despite her Puritan stoicism. It expresses hope that no one will ever again mention the accusation to her, treating the matter as settled by the jury's verdict.
The Londonderry Sifter · 30 June 1893 · page 2
The lot of Lizzie Borden for the rest of her. life cannot be an enviable one. The recollection of the fiery ordeal through which she has passed will try the iron
Little Falls Transcript · Little Falls, Minn. · 7 July 1893
The Southern Herald · Liberty, Miss.
The report states that Miss Borden, held in jail since last August for allegedly murdering her father and stepmother, has been acquitted by the jury. It adds a sarcastic comment that there was no evidence against her except the police officers' testimony.
The Southern Herald · 30 June 1893 · page 2
Miss Borden, who has been con fined in jail since last August on a charge of murdering her father and stepmother, has been promptly ac quitted by the jury. There was nothing against her but the officers.
Former Massachusetts Governor Robinson, defense counsel for Lizzie Borden, states he is convinced of her innocence and that the Borden murders remain a mystery. He notes that during the trial he received letters from fifty different cranks confessing to the murders.
The Southern Herald · 30 June 1893 · page 2
Walworth? Clarion-Ledger. Ex-Gov. Robinson, of Massa. chuseltt, counsel for Lizzie Borden, tayi he is convinced of his client's innocence, and that the Borden murders are at much a mystery to bar at to any one, arid that during tbe trial he received letter from fifty different cranks confessing to the murderi.' ".,' Ttfkes lie as. Natural gas has fceea d.sve.-d st Iron City, f tr.a.
The report notes that following the jury's verdict clearing Lizzie Borden, the question of who actually killed the Bordens remains unanswered. It suggests that since police pursued the wrong suspect, it now falls to detectives to find the real murderer.
Fisherman & Farmer · 30 June 1893 · page 5
Elizabeth City, N.C. The question that reuiaius unan swered is who killed the Bordens, The jurv having IbuLd tht thepo;ict were in the wrong trail as t Lizzie Borden it remains for the hlue ooaied gentry to hunt tip the real murderer.
The piece comments that after the jury's verdict, most people agree Lizzie Borden should have been acquitted. It suggests the prosecution's evidence was so weak that many now question why she was ever arrested.
Bismarck Weekly Tribune · 30 June 1893 · page 4
Lizzie Borden ought to have been ac quitted, and some wonder much that Lizzie should have been arrested at all or Buch flimsy evidence aa put forth by the prosecution. SUPERINTENDENT PERKINS, superin tendent of the Tenth division of the railway mail service, has been sus pended—pending investigation of some charges against him—but it is said a relative of Mike Doran wants the place —and BO it goes. THE cowboy race is over. Berry got
The Boston Journal reports that Mrs. Mary A. Livermore expects to host Miss Lizzie A. Borden soon as a guest at her home in Melrose, Massachusetts. The brief item offers no further detail on timing or reason for the visit.
The Jersey City News · 30 June 1893 · page 1
TO ENTERTAIN LIZZIE BORDEN. Boston. June 30, 1893.—The Journal sav» that Mrs. Mary A. Livermore ex pects to receive Miss Lizzie A. Borden soon as a guest at her home iu Melrose, Mass. _
A German-language newspaper reports that the Borden murder trial has begun in New Bedford, Massachusetts, drawing national attention. It recounts the August 1892 murders of Andrew Borden and his second wife in Fall River, and notes that public opinion has pointed to Lizzie Borden, the daughter from his first marriage, though she denies the crime and conviction is not yet certain.
Scranton Wochenblatt · 30 June 1893 · page 5
Lizzie Borden
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
This report describes the acquittal of Julia Force for murder, with the judge noting the crime's enormity was unmatched except possibly by the Borden case, 'if that crime was committed by Lizzie Borden.' It also notes Force had previously been judged insane and would be sent to a state asylum.
The Columbia Herald · 30 June 1893 · page 4
Mi-s Force. Afier i he dinner recefs Judge Clarke charged the jury. Durii g the deliv ery of his remarks Miss Force sat lui movsblo before the jury with her face buried in her bauds. Iu his charge Judge Clarke referred to the euoi uiiiy ol the crime, and said the jury should consider the prior life ol the prisoner. He said the crime was probably without a parallel unless it be that of the Borden murder case, if that crime was committed by Lizzie Borden. Tne Force murder was even more honiole than that.
See moreSee less
As the Judge was charging the jury the prisiouer broke down, sobbing con vulsively. The jury remained out only a le minutes, aud at 3 o'clock brought in a verdict of not miilty. It will be remembered that Mis Force was tried snortiy ater the murder ociiiTidou awiitt'f lunacy and was promptly adjudged insane. Stales Attorney General Hill l.tid that the pniceeuiiig were irregularis toe Case should ij,v. gone lii'nt be o-h tne Criuiinii! t'i'Uii, where tin' prisoner had tile pi iviieire ol mi-i h,ga pleu of insanity and estHlrixhinir the I act to the sitiisl'ai'Lioii of ilujury. This hat lit.-ti d me, and about Mis Force's in-.'t' ity t;i-.-re seems to Le little doubt. Sli will Ik' s-nt at once lo the State lunatic asylum at MiileU.c
This editorial comment notes that the court of public opinion in Massachusetts agrees with the jury's verdict in the Lizzie Borden case. It is a brief aside amid a list of political and tariff commentary.
San Antonio Daily Light · 30 June 1893 · page 2
FRIDAY, JUNE 30, 1893 The verdict of Massachusetts as to Lizzie Borden’s guilt follows that of the jury. The patronage worm is like the horse-leech's daughter, continually
Lizzie Borden and her sister returned by closed carriage to their Second Street home, with few spectators present and the sisters refusing all reporters. A household domestic reportedly said both sisters broke down completely upon entering the house.
San Saba County News · 30 June 1893 · page 2
Lizzie Borden at Home Fall River Mass Juno 22 Lizzie A Borden returned with her sister yesterday morning to their home on Second street They drove to tho gate In a closed carriage and
After closing arguments, Lizzie Borden declared her innocence to the jury before they retired to deliberate. The jury returned a not guilty verdict, prompting cheers in the courtroom and tears from Borden as she then departed by train for Fall River.
San Saba County News · 30 June 1893 · page 2
LIZZIE BORDEN IS FREE
Yesterday evening the attorneys hav ing concluded their arguments the chief justice asked Miss Borden if she had anything to say to the jury She arose and said I am innocent but will leave my case in j our hands and In tho bands of toy Counsel The jury was then charged and retired At 430 oclock tho jury returned and were polled Miss Borden was asked to stand up and the foreman asked to return the verdict which he announced Not guilty Then all the dignity and decorum of the court room vanished A cheer went up which might haw been heard half a mllo away and there was no at tempt to check It The stately justice looked straight ahead at the baro walls during the excitement which lasted fully a minute Miss Bordens head went down upon the rail in front of her and tears came where they had refused to come for many a long day as sho heard tho sweetest words ever poured into willing ears Mr Jennings almost crying put his hand out to Mr Adams who sat next to him and said Thank God Miss Borden took tho train for Fall River
A newspaper opinion column remarks that Lizzie Borden is receiving a bushel of letters a day, reflecting public sympathy and criticism of state officials for holding a woman in jail for ten months without proof of guilt. The item is part of a miscellany of satirical and political commentary rather than direct news reporting.
The Londonderry Sifter · 30 June 1893 · page 1
Miss Lizzie Borden is receiving bushel of letters a day, which shows that the sense of fairness is strong with the American people, and that it is a losiug business with state offi cials to keep a woman locked up for ten months without any evidence of guilt. How an American editor can work himself into a fever over the question of whether Mataufa or Malietoa ought to be king of Samoa is more than we can understand, but lots of 'em are doing it.
A whimsical opinion column riffs on human curiosity, citing the Lizzie Borden trial as proof that neighbors watch each other closely. It notes testimony that neighbors claimed no one could enter or leave the Borden house unseen, and recounts an anecdote about a neighbor questioning Lizzie for burning a paint-stained dress.
The Londonderry Sifter · 30 June 1893 · page 2
Tho Evidence of Neighbor, Every famous legal case that comes before the publio shows renewed evi dence of the interest neighbors take in one another's affairs. In the Lizzie Bor den trial the neighbors were very sure that nobody could have come In or gone out of the house of the 111 fated couple on the morning of the tnurder without the neighbors seeing it, not on that morn ing or any other morning. When Mibs Borden Innocently attempted to burn up