As the Papers Told It

Lizzie Borden · The full archive

June 1893, part 6

250 articles

The Portland Daily Press · Portland, Me.

District Attorney Knowlton delivers his closing argument, arguing Lizzie Borden murdered her mother first, then calmly killed her father upon his return before alerting Bridget. He dismisses defense claims about the peddler's testimony, the burned dress, and Lizzie's composure, framing her as a transformed murderess who met her father as Nemesis rather than as a daughter.

The Portland Daily Press · 21 June 1893 · page 1

BORDEN CASE.

Mr. Knowlton Resumed his summing up as soon as the court came to order this morning. The first point he touched upon was the point of motive. He said it was not necessary to find a motive in all cases to fix guilt. He claimed the motives of a crime were as inscrutable as the ways of divine providence. He claimed jeal ousy surrounded and threatened the daily life of Mrs. Borden and that it was not Lizzie Andrew Borden who greeted her father when he came in but a mur deress, whose hands were reeking with the blood of the dead woman up stairs.

See moreSee less

It was not the father she met but the husband of the woman she had just killed. The murder, he said, was not the result of careful plans but the out come of stern necessity. The speaker then described the last walk of Mr. Borden and his arrival at the house; how Bridget let him in, and the moves that were made up to the time he asserts Liz zie pounced upon him with uplifted axe. Mr. Knowlton said that the prisoner was possessed of a composure that had aston ished the world, but she was not under the influence of any drug when she first saw the officers of the law upon the day of the murders, and he claimed that the story of the barn was simply incredible. Instead of this she occupied the time be tween the departure of Bridget up stairs until she called her in, killing her father and destroying the evidence of the crime. The district attorney said no credence was to be placed upon stories of the peddler regarding seeing a woman go from the Borden barn to the house at 10.50. He said the man had finlrl a. f1n70n rliffownn-fctrini the time. He claimed the defense had failed to show what Lizzie was doing in the barn at the time she alleged she was there. Regarding Medley, he said the man was an old detective and his evi dence was of the most valuable variety. He said the nerve that Lizzie exhibited after the murder when every one was trembling with fear was evidence that she was capable of the crime. He then attacked the story offered by the defence regarding the burned di ess and in this connection said that even Mrs. Churchill said she did not know what dress Lizzie burned. A striking passage in the remarks of the district attorney was that in which he spoke of Lizzie’s meeting her father after the murder of Mrs. Borden. He said: I have called your attention to the way in which they lived under the same roof • it impressed me deeply, as I am sure it did you. The malice was all before the fact;

See the clipping

The Portland Daily Press · Portland, Me.

The editorial notes that the public had steadily predicted Lizzie Borden would not be convicted, and explains that under Massachusetts law a hung jury allows retrial but an acquittal is final. It then shifts to unrelated news, including a mysterious stabbing death in Lowell and the serious illness of Supreme Court Justice Blatchford.

The Portland Daily Press · 21 June 1893 · page 4

WEDNESDAY, JUNE 21. This seems to be one of the times when the “I told you so” contingent has been in the front rank from first to last. The public have been remarkably steadfast in the opinion that Lizzie Borden would not be convicted. Under the Massachusetts law capital cases must be tried again when the jury disagrees, unless the prosecuting officer, satisfied that he is on the wrong track, “nol prosses” [the case. Several noted criminals have been convicted on second trials. But if the jury acquits the ac cused can never again be brought to trial no matter what may happen. While the Borden trial has directed all

See the clipping

The Portland Daily Press · Portland, Me.

The report states Lizzie Borden has been found not guilty and is now legally free, protected from retrial even if new evidence of guilt emerged. It notes the verdict will likely be accepted as just, though the mystery of who committed the murders remains unsolved.

The Portland Daily Press · 21 June 1893 · page 4

Lizzie Andrew Borden is free; and can never be tried again for tho murder of Andrew J. Borden and his wife. Should evidence be discovered today showing beyond a doubt that Lizzie Borden is

See the clipping

Morris Tribune · Morris, Minn.

At the New Bedford courthouse, Governor Robinson delivered his argument for the defense, contending the murders were the work of a maniac and that Lizzie Borden could not have committed them. He finished at 3 o'clock, after which District Attorney Knowlton began his closing argument for the prosecution.

Morris Tribune · 21 June 1893 · page 1

PLEADING FOR A LIFE.

Governor Robinson Makes His Ad dress Ibr Lizzie Bor Ien. NEW BEDFORD, Mass., June 20.—The day of the arguments in the Borden case brought out a terrific jam at the courthouse. The jury was polled promptly on tho opening of court, and almost immediately Governor Robinson began his argument. Kc held that the fearful crime of which Lizzie Borden is accused was the work of a maniac, andit is impossible that she should have committed it. Governor Robinson finished at 3 and District Attorney KnowlO'clock ton began his address for the prosecu tion.

See the clipping

St. Paul Daily Globe · Saint Paul, Minn.

A New Bedford jury found Lizzie Borden not guilty of murdering her father and stepmother, prompting spectators to cheer loudly despite judicial decorum. Borden wept upon hearing the verdict, and her defense attorneys embraced in relief as the courtroom erupted in celebration.

St. Paul Daily Globe · 21 June 1893 · page 1

New Bedfohd. Mass., June 20.— Lizzie Borden was today declared by' the jury to be not guilty of the charge of murdering her father and step mother, and tonight is a free woman, and will sleep outside of prison walls tor the first time in months. It was just 4:30 o'clock when the spectators, who had kept their seats patiently during the retirement' of the jury, noticed a movement indicating their return. A moment later the twelve men filed into their seats and were polled. Miss Borden was asKed to stand up, and the foreman was asked to return the ver dic.whichhe announced— "Not guilty."

See moreSee less

Then all the dignity and decorum of the court room vanished. A cheer went up which might have been heard half a mile away through the open windows, and there was no attempt to check it. The stately justices looked straight ahead at the bare walls during the tremendons ex citement, which lasted fully a minute. -Miss Borden's head went down upon the rail in front of her, and tears came where they had refused to come for many a long day as . She Heard the Sweetest Words ever poured Into her willing ears. Mr. Jennings was almost crying, and his voice broke as he put his hand out to Mr. Adams, who sat next to him, and said "Thank God," while Mr. Adams returned the pressure of the hand and seemed incapable of speech. Gov. Robinson turned to the rapidly dissolving jury as they filed out of their seats and gleamed on them with a fatherly interest in his kindly eye, and stood up as Mr. Knowlton and Mr. Moody came over to shake hands with the counsel for the defense. As soon as possible the room was cleared, although it was a hard task, since everybody wanted to shake hands with Miss Borden. When the spec tators had finally gone she. was taken to. the room of the justices and allowed to recover her composure with only the eyes of friends upon her and the caress of devoted admirers. At the' expiration of .au hour she was placed in a carriage and driven to the station, where she took the train for Fall River, her home no longer, proba bly, but still the only objective point for the immediate present.

See the clipping

St. Paul Daily Globe · Saint Paul, Minn.

The jury returns a verdict of not guilty, prompting a sustained cheer in the courtroom and tears from Lizzie Borden. The report also covers the morning's closing arguments, the judge's charge to the jury, and Borden's brief statement maintaining her innocence before the verdict was announced.

St. Paul Daily Globe · 21 June 1893 · page 1

LIZZIE IS CLEARED.

the counsel for the defense. As soon as possible the room was cleared, although it was a hard task, since everybody wanted to shake hands with Miss Borden. When the spec tators had finally gone she. was taken to. the room of the justices and allowed to recover her composure with only the eyes of friends upon her and the caress of devoted admirers. At the' expiration of .au hour she was placed in a carriage and driven to the station, where she took the train for Fall River, her home no longer, proba bly, but still the only objective point for the immediate present.

See the clipping

St. Paul Daily Globe · Saint Paul, Minn.

The jury deliberated only one hour and twenty minutes before finding Lizzie Borden not guilty in the murder case at Fall River. The report reviews the prosecution's theory of motive and the brutal nature of the killings, noting the defense never offered an alternative suspect and simply argued the evidence was insufficient.

St. Paul Daily Globe · 21 June 1893 · page 4

LIZZIE BUI. I) EN. The jury in the Lizzie Borden mur der case at-FalLßlver.af ter a deliberate of one hour and twenty minutes.brought in a verdict of not guilty. The evi dence against Lizzie Borden* was ;

See the clipping

St. Paul Daily Globe · Saint Paul, Minn.

The report reviews the Borden trial, criticizing the Fall River police for shifting theories and contradictory testimony while praising ex-Gov. Robinson's defense for exposing these inconsistencies. It argues the prosecution's circumstantial case did not meet the reasonable doubt standard, justifying the jury's decision.

St. Paul Daily Globe · 21 June 1893 · page 4

amusing to the public. But for all the inconsistencies in the \ theory and presentations of the prose cution, which Robinson made to stand out boldly, there remained that unan swerable query, "If Lizzie Borden

See the clipping

Mower County Transcript · Lansing, Minn.

The jury in the Lizzie Borden murder case at Fall River returned a verdict of not guilty, announced the previous afternoon. The item is a brief one-line news note amid other unrelated items.

Mower County Transcript · 21 June 1893 · page 4

AUSTIN, WEDNESDAY^-JUNE 21,1893. THE jury in the Lizzie Borden mur der case at Fall River found a verdict of "not guilty" yesterday afternoon. CHIEF JUSTICE FULLER, who hails

See the clipping

Mower County Transcript · Lansing, Minn.

At the New Bedford courthouse, former Governor Robinson delivered his closing argument for the defense, arguing the murders were the work of a maniac and that Lizzie Borden could not have committed them. District Attorney Knowlton then began his address for the prosecution.

Mower County Transcript · 21 June 1893 · page 4

PLEADING FOR A LIFE. Governor Robinson Makes His Ad dress for Lizzie Borden. NEW BEDFORD, Mass., June 20.—The day of the arguments in the Borden

See the clipping

The Yellowstone Journal · Miles City, Mont.

The article reviews the circumstantial and disconnected evidence against Lizzie Borden, noting the lack of a clear motive led to her acquittal. It concludes that despite evidence placing her in the house during the murders, the case remains an unsolved mystery.

The Yellowstone Journal · 21 June 1893 · page 2

friends cannot satisfactorily determine With the acquittal of Lizzie Borden the ase is relegated to the catalogue o mysterious crimes, the secrets of whici -ae rarely, if ever disclosed.

See the clipping

The Helena Independent · Helena, Mont.

The report announces that Lizzie Borden was found not guilty by the jury after deliberating for an hour and twenty minutes, prompting cheers from spectators. It also recaps District Attorney Knowlton's closing argument, which emphasized her alleged motive, the implausibility of her barn alibi, and the burned dress as evidence of guilt.

The Helena Independent · 21 June 1893 · page 1

IIZLIE BORDEN IS FREE. The Jury Declare Her Not Guilty of the Murder of Her Father and Mother. Justice Dewey's Charge Is Very Favorable to the Accused Woman.

See the clipping

The Helena Independent · Helena, Mont.

The defense attorney made his closing argument, addressing the burned dress, the hatchet evidence, and Lizzie Borden's statement of innocence to the court. Judge Dewey then charged the jury, explaining the legal standards for murder, circumstantial evidence, and reasonable doubt they must apply in reaching a verdict.

The Helena Independent · 21 June 1893 · page 1

LIZZIE BORDEN. further charged the jury to weigh the evi dence to see whether defendant's perma nent state of mind showed any motive for the crime. Every material allegation in the indictment must be proved beyond a

See the clipping

The Helena Independent · Helena, Mont.

After the judge's charge to the jury, deliberations lasted an hour and twenty minutes before the jury returned a verdict of not guilty. The courtroom erupted in cheers, Lizzie Borden broke down in tears, and she was later taken by carriage to the train station to return to Fall River.

The Helena Independent · 21 June 1893 · page 1

LIZZIE BORDEN.

the jary was allowed to retire. It was just 4:40 o'eleck when the spectators, who kept their seats patiently for the hour and twenty mtintee after the retirement of the jury, aotleed a movement indleatiug their return. A moment later the twelve men filed into their seate and were polled. Miss lorden was asked to stand up and the fore man asked to return the verdict, which he announeed: "Not guilty." Then all the dignity and decorum of the court room vanished. A cheer went up whioh might have been heard half a mile away and there was no attemapt to cheek it.

See moreSee less

Miss Borden's head went down upon the rail in front of her and tears ceme. Lawrer Jnniegs wsee almost oeryin while Lawyer Adams seemed neeapable of speeh. As soon as poe sible the seem was eleared and when the peetatore had finally gone Miss Borden was taken to the room of the juetioe and allowed to recover her semposere with only the eyes of her friends ui on her and the caress of devoted ad mirers. At the expiration of an hour she was pieed an e earriage and driven to the statine, where she took the train for Fall iver, her home no lopger, probably, but still t only o jeetlve point fto the im

See the clipping

The Helena Independent · Helena, Mont.

This report announces the acquittal of Lizzie Borden for the murder of her parents, calling it the most remarkable criminal trial in recent years. The writer notes the verdict is accepted but the true murderer remains unknown, leaving the case open for detectives to solve.

The Helena Independent · 21 June 1893 · page 4

LIZZIE BOIRDEN ACQUITTED. The end of the most remarkable criminal trial in recent years was reached yesterday with the acquittal of Lizzie Borden for the murder of her parents. The result is not surprising I to those who have followed the case in the newspapers but unfortunately, whether guilty or innocent, circum stances will not remove suspicion from the woman in the minds of very many well meaning people until the author of the murder is discovered. The theory of the prosecution that the crime must have been committed by Lizzie Borden because suspicion could attach to no other person was very well for a starter, but it failed because it could not be shown that she had any connection whatever with the shocking affair.

See moreSee less

The public at large will be satisfied with the verdict since under the conditions no honest-minded man or woman desires the conviction and punishment of Liz zie Borden, unless the case is "proven beyond a scintilla of doubt," as Col. Nolan would say. The case now reverts to the original inquiry. Who murdered the Bordens? At the present time we accept the con clusion of the jury that it was not the daughter and tilhe greatest criminal mys tery of the age is left for the detectives to solve. It is surely a field to inspire the genius of iall followers of the great Sergeant Cuff, the hero of the search for the moonstone. In this connection we remember that the theft of that fa mous diamond was traced to a man whose character was as irreproachable as that of Lizzio Borden. However, the rmost striking feature of the Fall River murder is that it was not done for rob bery but for reasons as difficult to de termine as the identity of the authors, and the discovery of one probably mIlans the discovery of both.

See the clipping

The Columbus Journal · Columbus, Neb.

The report notes that Lizzie Borden's trial in New Bedford is proceeding slowly, with public sympathy leaning in her favor. It speculates that an acquittal would leave the murders as mysterious as Chicago's unsolved Snell case.

The Columbus Journal · 21 June 1893 · page 2

The trial of Lizzie Borden, at New Bedford, Mass., for the murder of her father and step-mother, is dragging along slowly, with the smpathy all in favor of Miss Borden. If she is ac quitted the murder will remain as much a mystery as the Snell case in Chicago.

See the clipping

Omaha Daily Bee · Omaha, Neb.

The report announces that Lizzie Borden was acquitted after the jury deliberated briefly, with the courtroom erupting in approval. It also recaps District Attorney Knowlton's closing argument from the final day of trial, detailing the prosecution's theory of motive and disputed evidence like the silk dress and hatchet.

Omaha Daily Bee · 21 June 1893 · page 1

f LIZZIE BORDEN ACQUITTED After Doing Out a Short Time the Jury domes to tin Agreement , LAST DAY OF 1I1E CELEBRATED TRIAL Noisy flotnonntmtlant of Approval AVhrn

See the clipping

Omaha Daily Bee · Omaha, Neb.

The prosecutor attacks Lizzie Borden's alibi about being in the barn loft, arguing it was implausible given the heat and lack of evidence of her presence there. He also highlights the burned dress, Mrs. Reagan's disputed statement, and the hatchet evidence, arguing the circumstantial case points to her guilt.

Omaha Daily Bee · 21 June 1893 · page 1

LAST DAY OF THE CELEBRATED TRIAL

ono ? That barn alibi will not stand. Wo como back and find her father dead and a story on her lips which has no vestige of truth In it. IIo then commented on the old and dusty condition of the barn and ol the tlrst kocn-oyod people who found nc tracks thcro. Ho also dismissed the state inent of two boys who jvcnt to the barn tc cat their dinner because it was cool. He referred to the visit to the cellar ns en evi tlcnco of Miss Borden's nerve.

See moreSee less

How she could have avoided getting blood on hei clothes the jury could answer , because thci were neither women nor murderers. There was somewhere In that house r Bedford cord dress stained with paint nnd c dress which , stained as it was , was good enough to wear for mourning dress , ant when the ofllcers came there on Friday II vrns a singular thing that this dress , aftci being kept all through these months , was burned on that Sabbath. Llzzlo had beer told on Saturday night tliat she was guilty and on Sunday she burns this dress.

See the clipping

Omaha Daily Bee · Omaha, Neb.

The jury returned a verdict of not guilty after brief deliberation, prompting a cheer in the courtroom and emotional reactions from Lizzie Borden and her defense team. She was later taken by carriage to the train station to return to Fall River.

Omaha Daily Bee · 21 June 1893 · page 1

lasted fully a minute. Miss Borden's head went down upon the rail in front of her and tears came where they had refused to como for many a long day as she heard the sweetest words over [ loured into her willing ears. Mr. Jennings was almost crying und his voice broke as lie put his hand out to Mr. Adams , who sat next to him , and said ' -Thank God , " while Mr. Adams retu.-ned the pressure of the hand and seemed incapable of speech. Gov ernor Robinson turned to the rapidly dissolvinT"1ury as they filed out of their scats and gleamed on them witn a fatherly in terest in his kindly eye and stood up as Mr.

See moreSee less

Knowllon nnd Mr. Moody came over to shako hands with counsel for the defense. Soon as possible the hall was cleared , which was a hard task , since everybody wanted to shako hands with Miss Borden. When the spectators had finally gone she was taken to the room of the justices and allowed to recover her composure with only the oycs of friends upon her and in the care of devoted admirers. TAt the expiration of an hour she was placed in n carriage and driven to the station , where she took the " train for Fall Hlver , her homo no longer , probably , but still her only objective point for the immediate present.

See the clipping

Omaha Daily Bee · Omaha, Neb.

The report summarizes the Lizzie Borden case, describing the double murder of her father and stepmother, the police investigation, and her arrest based on weak circumstantial evidence. It notes the trial was conducted before three judges and an intelligent jury, ending in her acquittal.

Omaha Daily Bee · 21 June 1893 · page 4

school system. hlXZIR UOHDKN ACQUITTED. Few criminal trials in this country have commanded a greater measure of public interest than that of Lizzie Borden at Fall River , Mass. , charged with having murdered her father and stepmother. There was nn ex traordinary mystery surrounding the double tragedy , and it Is not improbable that it may remain a mystery fororer. The murders took plaoo in the forenoon , and probably within ono or two hours of each other. Lizzie BDrdon and the sarvant girl were at homo , and during nearly all of the forenoon were In the house , each performing certain duties.

See moreSee less

While they were thus moving about the promises the murders were committed * ' mitted . As sojn as' discovered , which wa- * but a very short time after Mr. Borden don was killed , his wife having been murdered first , an alarm was given and the police called in. They made a most thorough search of the promises and found nothing to seriously implicate its occupants , nor were there any traces" ol an escaped murderer. 'It was a most perplexing and battling case , but it was necessary for the police to do something and they managed to got togothoi enough circumstantial evidence ol a very weak kind to warrant the arrest of Liz/io Borden

See the clipping

Asheville Daily Citizen · Asheville, N.C.

The jury returned a verdict of not guilty in the Borden case, prompting a loud cheer in the courtroom. Lizzie Borden wept with relief and left that afternoon by train for Fall River.

Asheville Daily Citizen · 21 June 1893 · page 1

LIZZIE BORDEN A FREE WOMAN

New Heufiikii, Mass., June 21. The jury returned a verdict ot not guilty in the Borden case. When the verdict was returned a cheer went up which might have lieen heard a half mile away, and there was no at tempt to check it. Miss Horden's head went down uiion the rail in front of her and tears came where they bad refused to come tor many a lone day, as she "heard the verdict. She left on the after' noon train for Kail River.

See the clipping

Paper unidentified

The report covers the final day of the Lizzie Borden murder trial in New Bedford, Massachusetts, including the District Attorney's closing argument about motive and malice. The jury ultimately returned a verdict of not guilty, acquitting Borden of the murders.

Paper unidentified · 21 June 1893 · page 1

NOT GUILTY THE VERDICT. LIZZIE BORDEN ACQUITTED BY THE JURY.

By Southern Associated Press. New Bedford, Mass , June 20. There was not so great a jam out side the court house this morning, although at the opening of the court there was as many people in the room as at any time during the Borden trial. Miss Borden entered the room at 8:55. The Court came in at 9 promptly, and tho District Attorney continued his argument. The District Attorney again re curred to his theory of motive for the murder as shown in the rela tion between Lizzie Borden and her

See the clipping

Paper unidentified

District Attorney Knowlton delivers his closing argument, portraying Lizzie Borden as a transformed murderess driven by jealousy and hatred of her stepmother, and methodically attacking the defense's alibi, the ironing story, the silk dress, and the hatchet evidence. He concludes his argument and the court takes a recess before Lizzie is given a chance to speak.

Paper unidentified · 21 June 1893 · page 1

Borden house during the short time between Andrew Borden’s ar rival at home and Lizzies’announce ment of the murder. The story of Lizzie ironing clothes he discredited

See the clipping

Paper unidentified

The report describes the judge's final charge to the jury, emphasizing that guilt must be proven and the defendant's silence should not count against her. The jury quickly returned a verdict of 'Not Guilty,' after which remaining charges were dropped and the court was adjourned.

Paper unidentified · 21 June 1893 · page 1

“Not Guilty.” After the verdic£ had been received the district at torney moved that the other cases against Miss Borden be nolle prossed and the order of the court was to that effect Chief Justice Mason then gracefully thanked the jurors in appreciation of their work and faithful aervice, and reminded them that the precautions taken with them which may have seemed irksome at the time were solely in the interest of justice, a fact which they undoubtedly realized now. The jury was then discharged and court was adjourned

See the clipping

Paper unidentified

The piece reports that the jury took only two hours to find Lizzie Borden not guilty, agreeing the verdict was justified by the evidence presented. It then speculates editorially about her possible guilty knowledge or involvement in a conspiracy, while hoping for her innocence.

Paper unidentified · 21 June 1893 · page 2

As we have indicated, the case made against Lizzie Borden was so slight that there could be no great expectation of her conviction. The jury took but two hours to consider

See the clipping

The State Chronicle · Raleigh, N.C.

After the judge's charge to the jury and closing arguments from the district attorney, the jury deliberated and returned a verdict of not guilty for Lizzie Borden. The courtroom was crowded as the foreman announced the verdict and Borden was discharged.

The State Chronicle · 21 June 1893 · page 1

LIZZIE BORDEN ACQUITTED BY THE JURY

There was not so great a iam out ouuuubu upeuuig oi ine court jury at 3:15. there was as many people in the room a3 at any time during the Borden trial. Miss Borden entered the room at 8:55. The Court came in at 9 promptly, and the District Attorney continued his argument. Ane District Attorney again rethe murder as shown in the rela tion between Lizzie Borden and her stepmother, from which he Eaid we can suspect even the malice existiner. i nave called your attention to the way in which they lived under the same roof. It impresses me deeply, as i am sure it did you. The mal ice was all before the fact. The wickedness, the ingratitude, had gene on under that roof for many

See the clipping

The State Chronicle · Raleigh, N.C.

A fragmentary report muses that jealousy or malice within the Borden household might explain the killings, cautioning that such suggestions could inflame public judgment against Lizzie Borden. The writer expresses hope that evidence shows she did not premeditate her father's death.

The State Chronicle · 21 June 1893 · page 1

- 1 J 1 1 mueo wuu uo kiiow are seated in death, we don't know but that some into unquenchable fire. There may be tnat in this case, which shows that Lizzie Borden did not plan to kill ber father, and I hope so. But it was not Lizzie Borden who

See the clipping

The State Chronicle · Raleigh, N.C.

Prosecutor Knowlton argued to the jury that the second murder was not planned but was a 'wicked and fearful necessity,' analyzing the timeline between Andrew Borden's arrival home and Lizzie's announcement of finding him dead. He discredited her story of ironing clothes and her alibi about visiting the barn, while crediting Officer Medley's testimony that no one had been in the barn.

The State Chronicle · 21 June 1893 · page 1

When she came down stairs it was her father she met, but it was also the husband of the stepmother she had hated. There was no escape wicked and fearful necessity; and I say this to relieve my mind of the dreadful feeling that there is a parricide in the world. Knowlton then analyzed the testi mony as to what went cn in the Borden house during the short tima between Andrew Borden's ar rival at home and Lizzies' announce ment of the murder. The atory of Lizzie ironing clothes he discredited and the visit to the barn alibi he said would not stand.

See moreSee less

Officer Medley's story which went to show that nobody had been in the barn Knowlton held to be cor rect. The prisoner watched Knowl ton fixedly during his argument

See the clipping

The State Chronicle · Raleigh, N.C.

The report discusses the verdict of not guilty in the Lizzie Borden trial, noting the jury deliberated only two hours. It speculates on her possible involvement in a plot with her uncle Morse, despite the acquittal, while acknowledging she may be entirely innocent.

The State Chronicle · 21 June 1893 · page 2

As we have indicated, the case made against Lizzie Borden was so slight that there could be no great expectation of her conviction. The jury took but two hours to consider the evidence, and run over the case together in their room. 'They could have spent but little time in delib eration, and in short order returned a verdict of not guilty. We think the verdict was war ranted by the evidence. Whether she was not a party to a plot to have her parents murdered is not so clear. The probability is that she knew that her step mother had been killed, and arranged matters for the murder of her father.

See moreSee less

Perhaps her uncle Morse managed the details and she contrived the opportunity, while some third person did the deeds. And again, it may be that she is entirely innocent, and that

See the clipping

Weekly Union · Manchester, N.H.

Judge Dewey finishes his charge to the jury, who retire and return after about ninety minutes with a verdict of 'Not Guilty.' The courtroom erupts in cheers, the sheriff is unable to restore order and is moved to tears, and Lizzie Borden bows her head in emotion.

Weekly Union · 21 June 1893 · page 2

“Not Guiity.” After the verdict had been received the district attorney moved that the other cases against Miss Borden be nol prossed and the order of the court was to that effect. Chiet Justice Mason then gracefully thanked the jurors in appreciation of their work and faithful service, and reminded them that the prezautions taken with them which may bave seemed irksome at the time were solely in the interest of justice, a fact which they undoubtedly realized now. The jury was then dismissed and the court was adjourned until Monday next, when the regular criminal session will be ovened.

See moreSee less

~ The closing scene in the Borden itrial - was In direct contrast to those which had preceded it. Heretofore, all had been de corous and in keeping with the dignity of ' the most digrified court in the country, but ' when the verdlet of “Not guilty” was re turred, a cheer went up which might have been heard half a mile away through the open windows, and there was no attempt to check it. The stately justices looked straight ahead at the bare walls. Sheriff Wright was powerless to wield the gavel which lies ready for his use, and not cnce during the tremendous excite ment which lasted fully a minute, did he make the slightest sign of having heard it. He rever saw the people rising in their seats and waving their handkerchiefs in unison with their voices because Hig Fyes Were Full of Toars, and were completely blinded for the time. Miss Borden’s head went down upon the rall in front of her and tears came where

See the clipping

Weekly Union · Manchester, N.H.

The jury delivers a verdict of not guilty, prompting tears and emotional handshakes among Lizzie Borden's defense team, followed by her being taken to recover before departing by train to Fall River. In Fall River, news of the acquittal sparks great surprise and excitement, with crowds gathering at the Borden homestead in anticipation of her arrival.

Weekly Union · 21 June 1893 · page 2

body wanted to shake hands with Miss Borden. Then she was taken to the room of the justices and aliowed to recover her composure with only the eyes of friends upon her and the caresses of devoted ad mirers. . At the expiration of an hour she was placed in a carriage and driven to the sta tion, where she took the train for Fall River, her home no longer, probably, but still the only objective point for the imme diate present.

See the clipping

Weekly Union · Manchester, N.H.

After news of Lizzie Borden's acquittal spread, crowds gathered at the Borden homestead awaiting her arrival, but she instead went to Charles J. Holmes' house on Pine Street. There she gave a brief interview declaring herself 'the happiest woman in the world,' while thousands remained outside her former home into the night.

Weekly Union · 21 June 1893 · page 2

LIZZIE BORDEN IN FALL RIVER.

i e Fepaiiadh S i was surging about the homestead on Sec ond street, a carrlagfi stopped at the resi dence of Charles J, Holmes, No. 65 Pine street. The first one to al;fiht from it was Mr. Holmes, and he was followed by Liz zle Borden. Then came Emma and Miss Annie Holmes.

See the clipping

Weekly Union · Manchester, N.H.

The report announces that Lizzie Borden was acquitted of murdering her father and stepmother, calling the verdict just given the slim circumstantial evidence presented by the prosecution. It also reproduces a Philadelphia Times editorial arguing the prosecutor had a duty to concede failure rather than press for conviction without adequate proof.

Weekly Union · 21 June 1893 · page 4

section ss It does of this in the followlng: ‘lt is the plain and imperative daty of the prosecuting officer so confess the fatiureof the state and permit Miss Borden to be ac qaitted witheut argument. The prosecutIng officer who presses for a convicsion ia a grave criminal case without evldence to warrant it, 1s himself a perjured ofiicer of the court. A lawyer may properly de fend a prisoner of whose guilt he has knowledge, and exhaust all means within the law to gain an acqulttal; but_the pros ecuting officer who demands a conviction for murder without evidence to justify such a verdict, must be false to justice and false to his oath of office.” e e e The Borden Verdict, There will be no general surprise at the result of the trial of Lizzie A.

See moreSee less

Borden on the charge of killing her father and step wother. “Not guilty” was the only answer that twelve good men and true could ren der after listening to such evidence as the presecution had to present, It is rarely, indeed, that a person is called so answer for a capital crime on so slender a chain of circumstances as the state in this case at tempted to forge around a most unfortu nate jyoung woman. She was in Or near . her home when her parexts were murdered. That was about the sum and substance of the evidence .on which the state kept Lizzie Borden in jail for nearly a year, and then asked that she be con victed of murder and hanged. In the Hght of the evidence, followed as it has been by a just verdict, it ils plain that a cruel wrong has been done. A young wo man has been deprived of her liberty for mary months, has bzen compelled to wit ness the repetition of horrors in the pre sentation of her father’s skull and all the terrible proof that a double murder had been committed—the only important fact established—and has been compelled to walt in dreary uncertalnty as to her fate, snd all this, as most people will belleve, because the police of Fall River jumped at a conclusion on the day of the murder and were determined their theory should be sustained, regardless of all reasonable con sideration ot the evidence. Lizzie Borden goes free at last, but she has been the vie um of an outrageous wrong, for which there is now no remedy. After liviag an upright and exemplary life -in one com munity for more than thirty years,she was rut on trial for her life on evidence such as few prosecuting officers would attempt to hold a common thief upon when accused of petty lareeny. It is little wonder that in acourt which has been remarkable for the orderly character of {ts proceedings, the pent-up feelings of the spectators found vent In loud applause without rebuke from ijuadge or sheriff. It would seem as if the counsel for the pro secutfon must have felt relief even in the midst of an overwhelming defeat.

See the clipping

Weekly Union · Manchester, N.H.

This editorial argues that Lizzie Borden was wrongly prosecuted on flimsy circumstantial evidence and praises the jury's verdict of acquittal as just. It criticizes Fall River police for jumping to conclusions and condemns the ordeal she endured over many months of imprisonment and trial.

Weekly Union · 21 June 1893 · page 4

The words of this article are printed with the report it shares its clipping with. Read them there or in the clipping.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

Weekly Union · Manchester, N.H.

A Philadelphia Record editorial reprinted in this paper contrasts the Lizzie Borden trial with the Salem witchcraft trials, calling it a sign of progress in Massachusetts jurisprudence. It praises the trial for its eminent fairness and freedom from legal technicalities and quibbling.

Weekly Union · 21 June 1893 · page 4

Risk Was Too Grest, Baston Home Journal. It Is becomivg evident day by day that Attoruey-Genersl Pillsbury showed great forethought in withdraw!nz from the con duct of the Borden case. The chances of victory were too slim to make it wise for him to risk his reputation of never having been defeated Ina murder trial.

See the clipping

The Jersey City News · Jersey City, N.J.

This editorial argues the not-guilty verdict was correct because the prosecution used improper, tyrannical methods, even though it acknowledges the evidence suggested a strong probability of her guilt. The writer praises the verdict as protecting common-law liberties for all citizens, while admitting it does not clear Borden's name in the public mind.

The Jersey City News · 21 June 1893 · page 2

WEDNESDAY'. JUNE 21, 1893 This paper is Democratic in principles and is independent in its views otf all local questions. The Borden Verdict. The verdict in the Borden case was just what was to be expected. It was, besides, just what it ought to be. There was something in this case be yond the mere ordinary “benefit of doubt” which called for such a ver dict. Lizzie Borden ought to have been acquitted not merely because she was not proven guilty, but still more be cause she was made the victim of il legal and tyrannical methods by the State, because if the methods used against her had won sanction from judges or jurors they might have passed into precedents subversive of the common law liberty which is our best personal heritage.

See moreSee less

No good citi zen should feel any sentiment but one of satisfaction at the verdict regis tered. It is a verdict in the interest of every man, woman and child in the community. But does this verdict clear the name and fame of Lizzie Borden from the

See the clipping

The Jersey City News · Jersey City, N.J.

The piece analyzes Knowlton's closing speech for the prosecution, arguing it was deeply persuasive even without absolute proof. It contrasts the prosecution's physical/circumstantial case with the defense's psychological argument that a respectable woman couldn't commit such a crime, leaning toward skepticism of the defense's premise.

The Jersey City News · 21 June 1893 · page 2

UUCUlUiU K/VU >• VVU Ul>Og ' ^Ibilities, the one mainly physical, the other mainly psychologic. The prose cation holds it impossible from the actual material circumstances of the case that anybody but Lizzie Borden should have done the killing in the old Fall River house last August. They tried but were not allowed to introduce some quasi-psychologic cor roboration in the proof of Lizzie Bor den’s mental state, the presence of motive and her embarrassment and her contradictions in trying to ac count for the various facts of the mur der. Out of all their material, they fabricated a terrible case of probabil ity. The defense set up the alleged psychologic impossibility of a re spectable young woman of Miss Borden’s general character and ante

See the clipping

The Jersey City News · Jersey City, N.J.

The article argues that skepticism about a woman's capacity for such violence is a weak defense, citing historical examples of female criminality. It concludes that despite the verdict, suspicion will likely always cling to Lizzie Borden unless another suspect is found.

The Jersey City News · 21 June 1893 · page 2

In a few days now, the Borden mystery will lapse into a conversa tional back number. But nothing, we believe, will ever clear Lizzie Bor don of the extremest suspicion save and except the discovery by God knows what accident, of the highly problematical somebody else who may have committed the crime.

See the clipping

Santa Fe Daily New Mexican · Santa Fe, N.M.

Lizzie Borden was acquitted yesterday in New Bedford of the murder of her father and step-mother. The report describes her being surrounded by cheering friends and notes the prosecution's evidence was weak and contradictory, with the community satisfied by the verdict.

Santa Fe Daily New Mexican · 21 June 1893 · page 1

Llzcie Goes Free. . New Bedfobd, June 20. Lizzie Borden was acquitted yesterday of the murder of her father and step-mother. Friends orowded around her, weeping and shower ing their congratulations upon her, and she walked Out of the court room not only a free woman, but a heroine. Thus closed one of the most remarkable trials of the age. The evidenoe for the prosecution was very weak and oontradiotery, and each colored his own to cast a rosy hue upon himself. The entire community is satisfied with the verdict.

See the clipping

The Sun · New York, N.Y.

The report describes the dramatic scene as Lizzie Borden is acquitted, collapsing in tears while the courtroom erupts in cheers and applause. It recounts her composed plea of innocence during the trial and the emotional aftermath of the jury's verdict, noting even judges were moved to tears.

The Sun · 21 June 1893 · page 1

VINDICATED, SHE BREAKS DOWN.

they began -asking ono another who killed jitrYSK LkH Mr. und Mrs. Borden. fe fc&iif H LU'zio Borden had cut a great figure In the j Ey'li ' M court room boluro her acqulttaL bho had a iifh vbi come In showing every bit of tho strain of tea j xfk? ; f

See the clipping

The Sun · New York, N.Y.

Lizzie Borden declares her innocence before the judge's charge to the jury, then the jury returns after deliberation. The courtroom tension builds as the foreman confirms a verdict has been reached, with Lizzie visibly strained as all eyes turn to her.

The Sun · 21 June 1893 · page 1

can Consul-General nt London, has hud a con ference with a number of shluowneisand rue Importers In regard to dm measuros to bo taken bv thom In ruevent Iho Intiodueilon of cholera to the Cnlied Mite. The ship owners and dealers prornlted that thoy would take every possible piernutlou ag.tlust the goods carried or shipped by them boluglutuctod with cholera germs. CalliotaH Kills, free from colorlog aad all Inert mailer, U, be uioiisgrctibie, JJt, , come back that tlio climax In tbs dreadful Vi 'yj! J I ,H role sho has been playing olectrlflod tlio poo- 'H S9,fi.

See moreSee less

r.r'"! lie. Tho twelve jurors tiled Into tholr box. Jtf IrMi j ;'H and this correspondent noticed tbatevery man . A jjFjH "H of thom sought out Lizzie Borden with his "' i ' SplSu eyes and looked at her steadily. Had they ' Fi iil"" H boon going to unnounco hor guilty they would K, rjfHI notbnvodonoso. She did not look at them. it fiMtil H Perhaps sho heard the exclamation of Mr. ' tj $'n Jennings: "Gosh, old man. we've got them.1 j ft -MA H Perhaps she was undor too much strain to K wfi'l benror rocognlzo anything. f R ' wljw bbH "Lizzie Andrew Borden." snld the Clerk of E ''Mf;i 1 the court, "stand up." Eho arose unstoadllr. p ffi H with a face as white an marble. K Effl" "Gentlemen, havo you agreed upon a vortf ''Tfj jH diet V" said tho Clerk to tho jury. ft livijtj ' It was so still In tho court that tho flutter o Pr H'hIt bkkI two fans mado u great nolso. f nM Jbb! " Wo have," said Foreman Btohards boldly. f ifpf 'a!! Tho prisoner was gripping tho rail In front J. M-fm of the dock as If her standing up.dopcudod J?: tHl -sibhI upon Its keeping its place. U''sKl B Llzzlo Androw Borden." said tho Clerk. j fihlljj jH "hold up your right hnnd." J' Ui-iti'j 'SbaI "JurorB, look upon tho prlsonor. Prisoner. I' rt xls IbbI look upon tho foieman." pvijlj Lvory juryman stood nt risht-about.face. fi' tvlB il SbhI staring at tho woman. There was such a genP ii ?miB bB tie, kindly light learning in overyoyo that no & irlif SbbI ono quostlonod tho verdict that was to be i (Im uttered. But God savo ovory woman from the F 1KW m bbI toolings that LIzz o Borden showed in the ikf ffi.ftl M

See the clipping

The Sun · New York, N.Y.

The jury foreman delivers a verdict of not guilty for Lizzie Andrew Borden, and she collapses against the dock rail, overcome with emotion. The clerk formally discharges her without bail, and her attorney Mr. Jennings struggles to comfort her as spectators react to the dramatic scene.

The Sun · 21 June 1893 · page 1

on amid tho tumult "that Llzzlo Andrew I'I. 'Sr'''flH Borden Is not guilty." ' j-j. !,;(-J " Wu do." said tho foreman. I'MfllsjB! " So say you, Mr. Foreman ?" f MuM " I do," said ho. j;lj tijrpH "So say you, gentlemen?" (wWiiiM. " Wo do." said they all. hImpTI bH " Llzrlo Andrew Bordon," eald tho clerk, look ' lllilr!

See the clipping

The Evening World · New York, N.Y.

Lizzie Borden and her sister returned to their Second Street home after spending the night at a friend's house, arriving by closed carriage with few spectators present. Both sisters reportedly broke down upon entering their old home, while Borden's attorney received many congratulatory letters and the public mood had shifted to respect the jury's verdict.

The Evening World · 21 June 1893 · page 3

LIZZIE BORDEN GOES HOME. She and Her Bister Much Affected oo ReacblDff the Old House. FALL RIVER, Mass., June 21. LlzsMe A. Borden returned with her winter this

See the clipping

The Evening World · New York, N.Y.

Lizzie Borden and her sister returned to their Second Street home after spending the night at a friend's house, arriving quietly by closed carriage with few spectators present. The public mood had shifted favorably, with Jennings receiving congratulatory letters and Borden's mail heavy at the post office.

The Evening World · 21 June 1893 · page 3

LIZZIE BORDEN GOES HOME. she and Her Sister Much Affected on Reaching" the Old Rouse. FALL RIVER. Mass., June 21. Lizzie A. Borden returned with her sister this

See the clipping

The Evening World · New York, N.Y.

Lizzie Borden and her sister returned to their Second Street home on the morning after her acquittal, having spent the previous night at a friend's house. Few spectators were present since the crowds from the night before didn't know when she would arrive, and the sisters avoided reporters on their counsel's advice.

The Evening World · 21 June 1893 · page 3

LIZZIE BORDEN GOES HOME. 6na and Her fi'.ster Much Affected on Reaching thn Old Houit. PALL RIVER. Minn, June 21. -Utile A. Borden returned with her sinter thin

See the clipping

The Evening World · New York, N.Y.

Lizzie Borden and her sister returned to their Second Street home after spending the night at a friend's house, both visibly affected upon entering. Jennings is receiving congratulatory letters nationwide, and the public mood in Fall River has shifted to respect the jury's verdict.

The Evening World · 21 June 1893 · page 3

LIZZIE BORDEN GOES HOME.

when they had entered their old home. To-day Andrew J, Jennings is receiv ing letters and telegrams of congratu lations from all par's of the country, and Miss Borden's mall at the Post i lffice Is very heavy. The temper of the people of the city has bet-ii changed greatly by the verdict. and there is a manifest respect for the decision of the Jury.

See the clipping

The Silver State · Unionville, Nev.

The jury in the Lizzie Borden case returned a verdict of acquittal yesterday afternoon. They deliberated for only a few minutes before reaching their decision.

The Silver State · 21 June 1893 · page 3

Lizzie Borden Acquitted.

NEWS NOTES. Miscellaneous Items Gathered From Vari ous Sources. Shirts embroidered by hand and ' costing $50 each came in fashion in the reign of Elizabeth. The prosecution in the Borden case

See the clipping

The Silver State · Unionville, Nev.

A New York World dispatch from Baltimore reports a boarding house keeper's story about a young man who called himself Felix Borden, claiming kinship to Lizzie Borden's uncle, who allegedly said "Oh, Lizzie did it" after the murders. The report suggests his description matched witness accounts of a stranger seen at the Borden gate the morning of the killings.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Silver State · 21 June 1893 · page 3

ABSOLUTELY PURE May Solve tlie Mysterv. The New York World'* Baltimore special says: Mrs. Ramsey, who keeps a hoarding house, relates a story that previous to the Borden murders a new England boy who represented himself as Felix Borden, the adopted son of Lizzie Borden’s uncle, boarded with her. He did not pay his board bill and left, saying he was going to his home in Massachu setts to get money to settle with. A few days after he left the Borden murders were committed. He re turned to Baltimore, and Mrs.

See moreSee less

Ram sey spoke about the murders. He replied, “Oh, Lizzie did it.” His description it is said tallies with j that given by witnesses who testified | that they saw a strange young man ; at the gate of the Borden house on the morning of the murder. Young! Borden left Baltimore last fall and has not lieen heard of since. — - The Work of an Incendiary. The business portion of the town of i Tillamook, Or. was destroyed by fire Monday morning. It started at 1 a. ' great medicine at this season.

See the clipping

Morning Appeal · Carson City, Nev.

A special dispatch reports that Lizzie Borden was acquitted of murder after the jury deliberated for one hour and twenty minutes. She reportedly made a speech thanking the jury, and the verdict was said to meet everyone's approval.

Morning Appeal · 21 June 1893 · page 3

Lizzie Borden Acquitted. A special dispatch to the Appeal, which was bulletined yesterday after noon says: "Lizzie Boaden was acquitted of the charge of murder, the jury being out one hour and twenty minutes. After the verdict she made a speech thanking the jury." The verdict meets the approval of everyone. .

See the clipping

Daily Independent · Elko, Nev.

District Attorney Knowlton makes his closing argument citing Lizzie's enmity toward her stepmother as motive, after which Lizzie addresses the court declaring her innocence. Following Justice Dewey's charge to the jury, they deliberate and return a verdict of not guilty.

Daily Independent · 21 June 1893 · page 3

> -- ? ? Lizzie Borden Acquitted. At the opening of the Bsrden trial at New Bedford, Mass., yesterday Dis trict Attorney Knowlton resumed bis argument in behf&f of the common

See the clipping

Paper unidentified

The report covers the final day of the Borden trial, including the prosecution's closing argument about motive and evidence, and Lizzie's brief statement declining to address the jury directly. The jury deliberated only an hour and twenty minutes before returning a verdict of acquittal.

Paper unidentified · 21 June 1893 · page 1

LIZZIE BORDEN FREE Jury Bring in a Verdict of acquittal ONLY AN HOUR AND TWENTY MINUTES

Itogan and afterward denied by ber, about a quarrel'between the Borden sis ters was true. Ho said tho production of tbo hatchet was no part of tbe gov

See the clipping

Paper unidentified

The judge concludes his charge to the jury, instructing them on standards of proof and how to weigh circumstantial evidence and Lizzie's statements. The jury deliberates for an hour and twenty minutes before acquitting Lizzie Borden of murder.

Paper unidentified · 21 June 1893 · page 1

The jury acquitted Lizzie Borden or murder. The jury was out an bour and twen ty minutes. j i i n mam Wanted. Girl for general bouse work. Must be capable of taking full charge. Enquire 243 Union street cor, Cottagt strtet,

See the clipping

Paper unidentified

The jury acquitted Lizzie Borden after deliberating for one hour and twenty minutes, following closing arguments from the prosecution about motive and evidence. Borden declined to address the jury at length, stating only that she was innocent and leaving her case in their hands.

Paper unidentified · 21 June 1893 · page 1

LIZZIE BORDEN FREE

Rogan and afterward denied by her, about a quarrel between the Borden sis ters was true. He said the productio of. the hatchet was no part of the go

See the clipping

Paper unidentified

The report covers the judge's final charge to the jury, emphasizing the burden of proof and the defendant's right not to testify. It concludes with the jury acquitting Lizzie Borden of murder after deliberating for one hour and twenty minutes.

Paper unidentified · 21 June 1893 · page 1

The jury lias acquitted Lizzie Borden of murder. The jury was out an hour and twenty minutes. BANK FAILURE AT KLLKNSBl'ltG, Statement Made Showing That the Resources Exceed the Liabilities.

See the clipping

The Daily Morning Astorian · Astoria, Oregon

After closing arguments and Justice Dewey's charge to the jury, Lizzie Borden was acquitted of murder following only an hour and twenty minutes of deliberation. The verdict sparked loud cheering in the courtroom, and Borden was later taken by carriage to the train station to return to Fall River.

The Daily Morning Astorian · 21 June 1893 · page 1

SENSATIONAL SCENE IN COURT

Jury acquitted Lizzie Borden of mur der. Vvt.on the verdict was announced, all the dignity and decorum of the court vanished. A cheer went, up which might have been heard half a mile away, and there was no attempt to check it. Miss Borden's head went down upon the roll in front of her and the tears came. Mr. Jennings was almost crying, while Mr. Adams eeemed Incapable of speech. As soon as possl ble the room was cleared, and when the spectators had finally gone. Miss Borden was taken to the room of the Justices and allowed to recover her composure with only the eyes of friends upon her, and the caresses of devoted admirers.

See moreSee less

At the expiration of nn hour ehe was placed in a carriage and driven to the station, where she took the train for Fall River, her home no longer, probably, but still the only ob. Jectlve point she has for the immediate present. ' ; .

See the clipping

The Forest Republican · Tionesta, Pa.

The item is a short editorial comment amid unrelated news, remarking that the ongoing Lizzie Borden trial will eventually conclude and reveal her guilt or innocence. It adds a skeptical 'Perhaps,' suggesting doubt about whether the verdict will truly settle the matter.

The Forest Republican · 21 June 1893 · page 2

Afteb while the Lizzie Borden trial will come to a close and then the people will kuow whether she's guilty or not. Perhaps.

See the clipping

The Star · Reynoldsville, Pa.

The report describes how, after the defense rested its case in the Lizzie Borden trial at New Bedford, public sentiment shifted dramatically in her favor. It states the prosecution's case relied on suppositions and innuendo, and predicts an acquittal with Lizzie becoming viewed as nearly a martyr.

The Star · 21 June 1893 · page 2

BELIEVE LIZZIE INNOCENT.

fendant, Whose Aequlttal Seems Certain. At New Bedford, Mass., the defence in the Lizzie Borden murder trial rested their case Friday afternoon and the trial was ad journed until Monday. The defence over threw all the important point made by the Qovtrnment The change In public sentiment during the past day in the case Is remarkable, and before court convenes again next Monday It is sale to say that Lizzie Borden will be come almost a saint and a martyr in the

See the clipping

In the story →

Pawtucket Tribune · Pawtucket, R.I.

The report describes the dramatic courtroom scene in New Bedford as the jury returned a not guilty verdict after barely an hour of deliberation. It recounts the tense atmosphere, the jury's return, and Lizzie Borden's composed demeanor as the clerk addressed her.

Pawtucket Tribune · 21 June 1893 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

LIZZIE BORDEN FREE.

Thrilling Scenes at the Verdict of Not Guilty.

See moreSee less

ONLY ONE BALLOT TAKEN.

The Defendant Bore up Bravely Under the Trying Ordeal.

NEW BEDFORD, Mass., June 21.—Lizzie Borden is a free woman. Along has swept the current of the great trial to acquittal.

Scarcely an hour was required for the 12 men, "good and true," to return the verdict of not guilty.

The ending was worthy of the greatest murder tribunal of the century.

So sudden a decision was entirely unexpected, and many who were off their guard and had temporarily left the court house lost it altogether.

Judge Dewey uttered the last words of his charge as the big clock indicated 3:12 o'clock, and in 12 minutes more the jury was given notice to retire.

The trusty 12 filed out at 3:25 o'clock, and everybody settled down for a long wait that might reach through the watches of the night.

An hour of insufferable heat passed by and the hands on the dial had begun a second revolution when, suddenly, there was a little stir, as if a misplaced breeze had strayed into the courtroom. Several people who had been in the lower rooms bobbed upstairs in an unconcerned sort of way and word was passed that the jury had struck a snag and was about to ask the court for instructions.

In a minute more the three judges were in their seats, and then followed the jury with a fixed look upon their faces. Every newspaper man was alert, for the reassembling had but one meaning.

MISS LIZZIE BORDEN

"Lizzie Andrew Borden, stand up," said the clerk; "raise your right hand."

The defendant obeyed without a tremor.

"Have you agreed upon a verdict, gentlemen?" said the man of records.

"We have," said the foreman.

"He shall speak for us," said the others.

"What say you, Mr. Foreman, is the prisoner at the bar guilty or not guilty?"

"Not Guilty."

Miss Borden dropped in her chair as the last word was uttered and buried her face in her arms, as they rested on the front railing of the prisoners' dock. She had not fainted as at first supposed and reported, but was in that precious state of mind where tears and silent joy struggle for supremacy.

No Voice Was Heard, but as she dropped in her chair came a great clapping of hands that almost made the old courthouse tremble.

The defendant, however, was lost to all that took place about her, and remained with her head upon her hands until friends about raised her up to listen to the words giving her formal release.

No tears stood in her eyes, but as she sat down she took her handkerchief and brushed away those just rising to the surface.

Even as she had fallen, Andrew Jenkins had reached out for one of her hands and stood wringing it as she lay with her head downward.

Then came Judge Mason's thanks to the jury, and a second after the trusty 12 stood in a line waiting to shake the ex-defendant's hand.

Ex-Governor Robinson stood on one side and Mr. Jennings on the other, supporting Miss Borden, and if ever hands were sincerely shaken it was by the woman who had received the gift of life when death lay so handily at their disposal.

Miss Borden's Face was very red, and by this time tears coursed down her cheeks, but she had words for everyone, despite joy's intoxication. Everybody wanted to shake hands with her and few started for the doors, although the deputy sheriffs to right, left and behind them shouted and thundered. When it was seen, however, that it was too much to be asked, the crowd made a break for the front and rear doors that it might give her hearty greeting on departure.

The birds of the air carry the news as well as the wires, and within ten minutes several hundred people stood about the courthouse. The greatest crowd gathered at the rear entrance to see Miss Borden make her final exit from the building where for twelve terrible days she had struggled for her life. A great flock of school girls clustered about the doorway, while several artists camped beneath a flowery syringa drew the crowd, leaving a vacant place at the door for the familiar form of she whose victory had been flashed across every sea to anxious millions.

The little one horse coach and colored driver that had 23 times carried her to the jail stood in waiting, but this time the curtains had not been drawn. Finally Deputy Kirby emerged and sprang into the vehicle, but he was alone.

"She's gone out the front way," cried one of the deputies, and the crowd started on the run, only to learn that it had been fooled, and was back again within a minute.

Meantime the crowd waited patiently for Miss Borden. Mr. Knowlton came down the rear steps very unconcernedly smoking, and some of the crowd had a word to say to him, to which he returned the reply, "That's all right."

Suddenly a gay equipage turned around the corner—a new hack, gold-mounted harnesses and lively steeds. "This is the team," said the keen observers, and later Deputy Kirby was seen shrinking back in the corner. During this time Sheriff Wright had been driven to the jail and secured Miss Borden's handbag, which he took to the livery stable, so that her small effects were within the hack.

In a minute the

Heroine of the Hour was in the carriage with her sister, while Mr. Holmes and Mr. Robinson stood beaming at the steps.

A great crowd gathered about the vehicle, and Miss Borden readily began shaking hands. There were tears, smiles and hearty good wishes sent over that gateway, as more than a hundred elbowed their way forward to extend their greeting.

Finally Mr. Holmes and Mr. Robinson decided to accompany the sisters and entered the deputy's hack, Mr. Kirby taking the driver's place on the box. The carriage started westward down the back street in the flood of sunlight of the June afternoon.

The way led to the jail, but they were not going thither, but to Fall River.

Lizzie Borden had begun a distinct existence; she was being rolled away into a new life. The whole world was watching that afternoon journey and was saying: "Probably never will the real truth of the Borden tragedy be known." The scenes about the courthouse were as striking as might have been expected.

Mr. Jennings Happy.

It's a question if Andrew J. Jennings wasn't happier than Lizzie Borden, and there was a glad light in ex-Governor Robinson's eyes. Miss Borden seemed yesterday to lean greatly upon Charles J. Holmes, who stood nearest her at the great climax when life and death hung on a single word

Miss Borden's Future Plans.

Nobody knows what Miss Borden's plans are, but it is supposed that she will eventually begin life over again in Fall River after seeking protracted rest in some quiet spot.

When the afternoon session opened the defendant was given an opportunity to take the stand. She promptly stood up and leaning toward the jury said: "I am innocent. I will leave it to my counsel to speak for me." Her face was somewhat flushed as she took her seat, but she was far from being disconcerted.

This had, in fact, been her strongest day. She scarcely shaded her eyes from start to finish, leaning her head upon the railing behind her and looking far away toward the ceiling, when her eyes were not riveted upon the man who was making his greatest professional effort to deprive her of life.

Mr. Knowlton's Argument was of a high order, his points generally well taken, his style dramatic and his earnestness rare. For more than five hours of broiling temperature he held close attention and few forlorn hopes were ever better led. His work in the case will do much to enhance his reputation, for he grappled with an unpleasant duty, and found law against him at nearly every point.

See the clipping

Pawtucket Tribune · Pawtucket, R.I.

The jury returns a verdict of not guilty for Lizzie Borden, who drops into her chair in emotional relief as spectators applaud loudly. The report also clarifies that she did not faint, correcting earlier assumptions, and describes well-wishers including her lawyers and jurors congratulating her.

Pawtucket Tribune · 21 June 1893 · page 1

The defendant obe‘ed without a tremor. “Have you agreed Yipon a verdict, gen tlemen?" sald the man of records. “We have,” sald the foreman. “He shall speak for us,” said the others. “What my' you, Mr. Foreman, is the prisoner at the bar guilty or not gnilty?” “Not Guilty,” Miss Borden dropped ir her chair as the last word was uttered and buried her face

See the clipping

Pawtucket Tribune · Pawtucket, R.I.

After the jury's verdict, Lizzie Borden is congratulated by jurors, her lawyers, and a gathering crowd outside the courthouse. She is described as emotional but gracious, eventually departing in a carriage with her sister amid cheers and handshakes.

Pawtucket Tribune · 21 June 1893 · page 1

and Mr. Jennings vn the other, supporting Miss Borden, and if ever hands were sin cerely shaken it was by the woman who had received the gift of life when death lay so bandily at their disposa). ¥ Miss Borden’s Face was very red, and by this time tears ooursed down ber cheeks, but she had words for everyone, despite joy's intoxica tion. Everybody wanted to shake hands with her and few started for the doors, although the deputy sheriffyto right, left and behind them shouted Abd thundered. When it was seen, howevaer, that it was too much to be asked, the crowd made a break for the front and rear doors that it might give her hearty greeting on de parture.

See moreSee less

The birds of the air carry tke news as well as the wires, and within ten minntes several hundred people stood about the courthouse. The greatest crowd gathered at the rear entrance to see Miss Borden make her final exit from the building where for ‘twelve terrible days she had struggled for ‘ber life. A great flock of school girls clustered about the doorway, while sey ‘eral artists camped beneath & flowery

See the clipping

Pawtucket Tribune · Pawtucket, R.I.

The article announces that Lizzie Borden has been found not guilty by a jury of her peers after a lengthy and closely watched trial. It praises the fairness of the proceedings on both sides and declares her fully innocent, free of all suspicion.

Pawtucket Tribune · 21 June 1893 · page 2

PUBLIC PARK. Lyman Goff wants Hammond’s pond district for a public park. Certain Alder men had qoite a lengtby talk at the Gofts’ othee last week. Invitations have been sent out by these certaln Aldermen to other city officers for a supper at Havens'’s on Friday night. We await de: velopment. THE BORDEN CASE. One of the most ocelebrated trials of modern times has at length come to an end. It has been fraught with interest trom the beginning and there is hardly » bome throughout the length and hreadth of this land into which some knowledge of this trial ‘has not come. Lizzie Borden

See the clipping

Pawtucket Tribune · Pawtucket, R.I.

A sarcastic newspaper column remarks on Governor Robinson's success in securing Lizzie Borden's acquittal, suggesting she should now 'hunt down the real murderer.' It also notes that Massachusetts authorities still have work to do on the broader mysterious murder investigations, including the Dr. Chaput case.

Pawtucket Tribune · 21 June 1893 · page 2

Now that the Borden case is ended the Massachuasetts authorities have still some thing to do In the mysterious murder. line, in looking into the Dr. Chaput case of Lowell. Judge Stiness having returned from the World’s Fair we may soon expect to hear of the full bench being ready to listen to arguments on the political imbroglio.

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

The jury found Lizzie Borden not guilty after brief deliberation, and she was congratulated extensively in the courtroom before departing with former Governor Robinson. She returned triumphantly to a friend's home in Fall River, overwhelmed by public support.

The Providence News · 21 June 1893 · page 1

ECHOES OF THE TRIAL

SPECIAL TO THE NEWS. NEW BEDFORD, June 21. —Lizzie Borden, free from suspicion, free from anxiety, declared innocent by the scales of Massachusetts justice and by the voice of the people throughout the land, is

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

Following her acquittal, Lizzie Borden is cheered by crowds as she leaves the courthouse and travels by carriage back to Fall River with her sister and attorney. Her lawyer Mr. Jennings expresses great happiness, while reports suggest Lizzie and Emma will not remain in the old Borden home and plan to seek the real murderer.

The Providence News · 21 June 1893 · page 1

HAPPY MISS LIZZIE

BORDEN, ception until n la’e hour. Mr. Jennings was there, wreathel in smiles and with out doubt the happiest man in the world. Ever since the murder Mr. Jennings has devoted hims:lf heart and soul to the

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

The report describes Governor Robinson's confidence in Lizzie Borden before the trial and his personal meeting with her, then shifts to the newspaper's self-congratulatory account of being first to deliver the not-guilty verdict to Providence readers via special wire. It emphasizes the paper's speed and thoroughness compared to competitors.

The Providence News · 21 June 1893 · page 1

OUR COMPETITORS BEATEN.

,Rarely has such Intense interest been taken in a trial for murder as that which manifested itself in the Borden case. Healizing that the pnblicdesired to know above all other things the verdict of the jury, the News made preparations to furnish the public with the desired in-

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

The report describes the city's immediate reaction as news of Lizzie Borden's acquittal spread via newspaper extras and newsboys. It details the mixed public sentiment, with most expressing relief and little surprise, while a minority remained convinced of her guilt, and describes heated debates and betting on the verdict.

The Providence News · 21 June 1893 · page 3

AS IN A LOOKING GLASS.

seemed the general opinion, ot.hinfi but the one topic of the great trial coul be heard un({when. No our felt that a mistake had been made on the strength of the evidenc, which has faiied to prove that Lizzie Borden was guilty of the murder of her father and mother *‘beyoud a reasonable doubt,” but the suspeuss of waiting; tbe throb of sympathy which alike quickened the pulse ot the accused woman and that of the public; the strain of walting for the' judgment of the twelve men, good and true, who were Lo say as to the fate of Lizzie Borden, all intensified therelief at the news of her

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

The piazza groups' conversation last evening centered entirely on the acquittal of Lizzie Borden, and news spread quickly the next morning via milkmen and streetcar riders. The report notes the jury's verdict seemed to satisfy almost everyone.

The Providence News · 21 June 1893 · page 3

am bruised up badiy. I canunot biame Lbe men 1u charge of :Le car, aud as the hieyeles have no siga or number I do not know how to seek redress. I wish you would azitave this matter and see if some rules cannot be adopted for the protec tion of people. luis bad enouzh to bave Lo look out for bicycles without having them 1n rear of cars.” R Ry e The subject of conversation amopg all the pinzza groups las. evening was the acquittai of Lizzie Borden, This morn

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

This editorial column briefly references that a competing newspaper had to call in its staff overnight to produce a special edition about the Borden verdict. It offers wry sympathy for the rival's trouble, confirming the verdict had just been delivered.

The Providence News · 21 June 1893 · page 4

. The News offors its sympathy and oo to its contemporary that ‘was obliged last night to collect its force from their homes to get out its _ ptickful-extra on the Borden verdict, I is to be hoped Eulalia will not form her opinion of the size of the state and ‘the character of her people by the small it of the one and the small number of - the other she saw in the few hours stay -@t Newport yesterday, THE police seem determined to show -Mo mercy to the carriers of concealed weapons, This is well, The man with & pistol, dirk or razor in his pocket is a _ menace to the peace of the community ~and to the lives of the people.

See moreSee less

Tue Ohio democrats will be obliged -#0 lay in a liberal supply of fly paper if they expect to catch a candidate for

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

The New Bedford News congratulates itself for printing the best trial coverage and being first to announce Lizzie Borden's acquittal verdict ahead of all rival papers. It describes the rapid production of an extra edition, sold within minutes of the verdict being set in type.

The Providence News · 21 June 1893 · page 4

THE NEWS AND THE CASE, The News has the satisfaction today of the knowledge that it has printed the best report of the Borden trial that was sent to any newspaper from New Bedford ; that its editorial position from the time of the arrest of Miss Borden

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

The report states that the not guilty verdict matches the evidence as presented at trial, and argues there was insufficient justification at each stage—arrest, grand jury holding, and indictment—for pursuing the case against Lizzie Borden. It credits Massachusetts with treating her fairly throughout, while noting the murder mystery itself remains unsolved.

The Providence News · 21 June 1893 · page 4

NOT GUILTY.

All of these steps, except the action of the Fall River police, were taken with manifest reluctance, The theory that nobody had an opportunity to cominit the crime except Lizzie Borden evidently strongly inflnenced the offi. cers of justice, and had great weight with the grand jury, —Having been arrested and indieted; Miss Borden has po ground for just complaint agailust the state of Massa cliusetts. - Bhe has been troated with all the consideration and kindness com patible with the circumstances, and her trial was wholly devoid of grounds for criticisma or complaiut, Whether or not exact justice has been done by the verdict is a matter that, despite sentiment or sympathy, will still be regarded as a fit subject for argument until the vetl of mystery that hangs over the tragedy of last August may be lifted, At present the Borden murder takes its place as the greatest of the many mysteries of erime that have ever been speculated about by the Amwmerican peo ple.

See the clipping

Yorkville Enquirer · Yorkville, S.C.

The report briefly summarizes the August 1892 murders of Andrew and Abby Borden in Fall River and notes that the trial against daughter Lizzie Borden has been underway for about ten days in New Bedford. It describes how the bodies were found, the lack of a weapon, and the circumstantial evidence against Lizzie, including a small blood spot on her underskirt.

Yorkville Enquirer · 21 June 1893 · page 2

? One of the most remarkable criminal; trials of the present decade has been in progress at New Bedford, Mass.. during the past ten days. On the 4tli day of August, 1SS>2, Andrew J. Borden, a wealthy real estate and mill owner aud his wife, were found dead in their home at Fall River, Mass. The body of the husband was lying in a room down stairs and the wife up stairs. Both bodies had been brutally hacked with some sharp weapon, presumably a hatchet, and the room was bespattered with blood. Living

See the clipping

The Watchman and Southron · Sumter, S.C.

The report describes the start of the Borden murder trial at New Bedford, Massachusetts, with crowds gathering outside the courthouse. It details Lizzie Borden's entrance into the courtroom at 10:58, her attire, and the packed room of jurors and press.

The Watchman and Southron · 21 June 1893 · page 4

LIZZIE BORDEN ON TRIAL. The Court Room Thronged with Interj ested Spectators. The long-anticipated Borden murj der trial ??egan at New Bedford, Mass., ; Mondav evening. At on early hour ? . . every available shady spot on the conn try street near the court hons.- was preempted, and patiently thc sitters ' and standers waited until the bell on the courthouse tolled, signifying the opening of the court. Al precise- ! ly 10:58 Miss Lizzie A. Borden, I the prisoner, came slowly into the courtroom and was shown to her seat m the dock.

See moreSee less

She wns at tired in a very becoming cos- : tumo of black brocaded stuff and nore ' v pretty shad?: hal relieved by a touch : here and there of blue. Every'seat in the room was occupied by talesmen j ri 1111 newspaper men, no outsiders be- | ing admitted np to that time, and | w ithin the box inclosnre were a few of *he prominent men of the county, who but because it was fl Pessary to ob? serve extraordinary precautions to se? cure the safe transmission of the doc? ument to the United States the.treaty was not received at the department until a late day last week. The treaty was in. the French language and it was necessary to translate the docu? ment into English and make very care? ful comparisons between the transla? tion and the original This work was completed Monday and the 'president j saw it for the first time Tuesday when ! Secretary Gresham carried it to the cabinet meeting. All that remained to be done was to malle the official proclamation and that was done Tuesi chancery. day afternoon. The proclamation simply recited the provisions of the treaty and the announcement that it would go into effect twenty days from date-that is to say on June 24th. Appoint itt oui M Announced; The president Thursday made the following appointments : To be col? lectors Of internal revenue-James L. Dogget, of Texas, for the fourth dis? trict of'Texas; Frank P. Bond, of Tennessee, for the tenth district of Tennessee. Joseph Donnell, of Wis? consin, to be consul general oi the United States, at Nueve Laredo* Mexi? co. To be consul general of the Uni? ted States-Van Leer Polk, of Ten? $3-, 500, nessee? at Calcutta* ludia; J; Partelloj of the District of Columbia, atSonnes bery* Germany ; Marshall P-. Thatch? er, of Michigan) at Windsor* Ont-. ; AV. H. Seymour, of Alabama* at Paler? mo, Italy ; John Patton* of Michigan, at Amherstburg, Ont. ; Fredrick Opp, of Texas, at Preslau, Germany, Alex? ander Rosenthal, of New York, at Leg? horn, Italy; W. H. Jacks, of Indiana, at London, Ont. ; Claude Thomas, of newly ollicered. Kentucky* at Marseilles, France; Pulaski F-. Hyatt, of Pennsylvania, at Santiago de Cuba; Francis H. Under? wood, of Massachusetts, at Teck, Scot? land ; Newton Ashe, of Iowa,

See the clipping

The Abbeville Press and Banner · Abbeville, S.C.

The trial of Lizzie Borden for the murder of her father and stepmother began in New Bedford, Massachusetts, drawing national attention and crowds of strangers. The report describes the courtroom, Judge Blodgett presiding, District Attorney Moody for the prosecution, ex-Governor Robinson for the defense, and Lizzie's composed demeanor as she entered the dock.

The Abbeville Press and Banner · 21 June 1893 · page 2

LIZZIE BORDEN ON TRIAL.

the Supreme Bench, presides over the court. District Attorney Moody leads the array of part. counsel for the commonwealth, and exGovernor Robinson that of the defense. At 11 o'clock Miss A. Borden, the prisoner, came slowly into the room, preceded by Deputy Sheriff Klrby, and was shown to her

See the clipping

The Abbeville Press and Banner · Abbeville, S.C.

The report describes jury selection and the opening of the prosecution's case by Assistant District Attorney Moody, including evidence about the hatchet and skulls, and Lizzie Borden fainting when told a burned dress would be presented as evidence. It also covers the jury's visit to the crime scene and early witness testimony about timelines and the discovery of the bodies.

The Abbeville Press and Banner · 21 June 1893 · page 2

iccoran.'iny the jury. Uu uiii; iiuru day oi the triai Civil Engineer Kiornan w.is the first witness cximined. Ho testified as to the location ot the bodies when they were lound. James A. Walsh, a photographer, showed views of the Borden house. Surveyors' and photographers' evidence beinj; concluded, John V. Horse, unclc of the prisoner, took the stand. On cross-examination he swore that

See the clipping

Freie Presse Für Texas · San Antonio, Tex.

The report states that the sensational trial against Miss Lizzie Borden in Bedford, Massachusetts, who was accused of murdering her father and stepmother, ended with the acquittal of the defendant. It briefly notes the case's notoriety as part of a roundup of news items.

Freie Presse Für Texas · 21 June 1893 · page 1

Miß Lizzie Borden in Bedford, Mass» welche unter der Anklage stand, ihren Vater und ihre Stiefmutter ermordet zu haben, endete mit der Freisprechung der Angeklagtenl — Der Bundesanwalt Winston, Bundegmarshal Brown, Zollcollector » Wasson, Special-Agent Mulkey und sechs Specialllinspectoren, alle im

See the clipping

The Salt Lake Herald · Salt Lake City, Utah

A short filler item reports that Lizzie Borden has been acquitted, joking that this happened despite unflattering newspaper sketches of her. It notes that the other testimony favored her.

The Salt Lake Herald · 21 June 1893 · page 4

I sidered en regie to attend a funeral on a f IN SOME western towns it is not con j I bicycle 1 LIZZIE BORDEN has been acquitted in

See the clipping

The Salt Lake Herald · Salt Lake City, Utah

This editorial argues that Lizzie Borden's acquittal for the murders of her father and stepmother was the correct outcome given the lack of direct evidence. It acknowledges suspicious circumstances but concludes that convicting her would require believing an improbable sudden transformation into a murderer.

The Salt Lake Herald · 21 June 1893 · page 4

They are a sure sign that the g o p is I in a frightfully demoralized condition II I I A Proper Acquittal I The acquittal of LIZZIE BORDEN who was charged with the murder of her father and her stepmother will give satisfaction to nearly everybody who has paid close attention to the evidence ad duced at the inquest and at the trial Many sympathetic and sensitive people will breathe more freely on reading this morning the verdict of the jury That Mr and Mrs BORDEN were foully

See the clipping

The Salt Lake Herald · Salt Lake City, Utah

This editorial argues that it would be unprecedented for someone of previously exemplary character to suddenly commit such a crime, suggesting the prosecution's theory of Lizzie Borden's guilt was flawed from the start. It praises the acquittal as justified given insufficient evidence and commends both legal teams for conducting the trial with notable decorum, free of the theatrics common in other regions.

The Salt Lake Herald · 21 June 1893 · page 4

There are cases on record which appear on the surfaceto show that individuals of previous exemplary life have suddenly figured as violators of the law and devel oped traits never before perceived in their character But that is usually be cause their exact disposition and their whole course has not been accurately known Those who were closely inti mate with them have been aware of devi ations from the path of rectitude that have not appeared to the public eye It I is contrary to the course of nature for II I I criminality of alienious sort to crop out at once after a proper life up to the time of attaining majority There is some thing outof plumb in such people and it appears during their growth and earlier history There was an evident disposition to fasten the crime of killing the BORDENS upon the young woman who has been acquitted Her guilt was the theory of the officers and they did their utmost to prove it correct They have signally failed A fixedtheory of that kind is very dangerous to a suspected person Cir cumstances sometimes aid so strongly to support it that it is a most difficult thing to explain them away That LIZZIE BORDEN has escaped from the network

See the clipping

The Roanoke Times · Roanoke, Va.

The report announces that Lizzie Borden has been acquitted in the famous Borden murder case, with the jury finding she did not commit the crime. It summarizes Judge Dewey's charge to the jury, emphasizing standards of reasonable doubt, motive, and the weight of circumstantial evidence.

The Roanoke Times · 21 June 1893 · page 1

Not Commit the Murder. Nkw Bedford, Mass., June 20.?The famous Borden case iB at an end and Lizzie Borden is free. She and her sister

See the clipping

The Roanoke Times · Roanoke, Va.

The judge instructed the jury on standards of proof and circumstantial evidence, noting Lizzie's failure to testify should not count against her. The jury deliberated briefly and returned a verdict of not guilty, after which remaining charges against her were dropped.

The Roanoke Times · 21 June 1893 · page 1

LIZZIE BORDEN ACQUITTED

cluded bis charge to the jury at 3:15 p. m. The jury filed into their seats at 4:-'.0 and were polled Miss Borden was a-k?d to stand up, and the foreman was asked to return the verdict, upon which he announced "Not guilty.'- After the verdict had been received the district attorney moved that the other cases against Miss Korden be nolle prossed, anil the order of the court was to that effect. _ Mabel Paige at tlio Academy to-night. Prices IO, 80 und 30 cents.

See the clipping

Alexandria Gazette · Alexandria, D.C.

This editorial piece discusses Lizzie Borden's acquittal after a year's imprisonment, noting that no evidence was found to support the suspicion of parricide against her. It questions what reparation can be made to her for the suffering and shame she endured during the legal process.

Alexandria Gazette · 21 June 1893 · page 2

Miss Lizzie Borden, after a year's imprisonment, on mere suspicion of parricide, and untold misery and shame, has beim acquitted, as no evi? dence in support ofthat suspicion, nor

See the clipping

Alexandria Gazette · Alexandria, D.C.

The jury returned a verdict of not guilty in the trial of Lizzie Borden for the murders of her father and stepmother, prompting cheers in the courtroom. The District Attorney moved not to pursue further charges, and the judge thanked the jury for their service.

Alexandria Gazette · 21 June 1893 · page 2

Miss Borden Acquitted. At New Bedford, Mass., yesterday evening Miss Elizabeth A. Borden was acquitted for the murder of her father, Andrew S. Borden, and stepmother, Abbie Durfee Borden, August 4, 1892,

See the clipping

Alexandria Gazette · Alexandria, D.C.

The jury returns a verdict of not guilty, prompting an emotional outburst in the courtroom with cheering, tears, and handkerchief-waving. Lizzie Borden weeps at the verdict, her defense team is overcome with emotion, and she later departs by train with her sister Emma back to Fall River.

Alexandria Gazette · 21 June 1893 · page 2

The words of this article could not be separated from the rest of its page. Read it in the clipping.

No clean clipping could be cut from this page

The Times · Richmond, Va.

The jury found Lizzie Borden not guilty of murdering her parents, with the courtroom erupting in cheers as she wept. The report also recounts the prosecutor's final closing argument made just before the verdict was delivered.

The Times · 21 June 1893 · page 1

MISS BORDEN "NOT GUILTY."

. 8 ATA J «). nr x ide of /| : tl 1 at tle opening of the court there was as many people in the room as at any time during the Borden trial. Miss Borden en tered the room at 8.56. The Court came in at 9 promptly, and tho district attorney continued his argu guent, He again recurred to his theory of mo ftve for murder as shown in the relations between Lizzie Borden and her step mother. “From which,” he sald, “we can puspect even the malice existing. 1 have called vour attention to the way in which they lived under the same roof. It im presses me deeply, as 1 am sure it did ou. The malice was all before the fact;

See the clipping

The Times · Richmond, Va.

District Attorney Knowlton delivers his closing argument, theorizing that Lizzie killed her father to prevent him from learning she murdered her stepmother. He also reviews evidence including the burned dress, the hatchet, and witness testimony, arguing the defense's case 'amounted to nothing.'

The Times · 21 June 1893 · page 1

Mr. Knowlton then analyzed the testi nony as to what went on in the Borden house during the ghort time between Andrew Borden's arrival at home and Lizzie's cunouncement of the murder. The story of Lizzie ironing clothes he discredited, and the visit to the barn glibl, he “sald, would not stand. Officer Medley's story, which went to show that

See the clipping

The Times · Richmond, Va.

The judge's charge to the jury is summarized, emphasizing standards of proof for circumstantial evidence and the defendant's right not to testify. The jury deliberates briefly and returns a verdict of not guilty, prompting an emotional outburst in the courtroom.

The Times · 21 June 1893 · page 1

Judges Jooked straight ahead at the bare walls, Sheriff Yrignt was powerless to wield the gavel which lies ready for his use, and not once during the tremen dous exeitemert, which lasted fully a “minute, did he make the slightest sign of having heard it. He never saw the people rising in their seats and waving | their handkerchiefs in nnison with their | voices, because his eyes were full of tears, and were completely blinded for the time, Migs Borden's head went down upon the rail in front of her, and tears came where they had refused to come for many a long day, as she heard the sweet est words ever poured into her willing ears, the words “not guilty.” Mr.

See moreSee less

Jennings was almost crying, and his voice broke as he put his hand out to Mr. Adams, who sat next to him, and said, “Thank God,” while Mr. Adams re turned the pressure of the hand and | seemed incapable of speech. Governor Robinson turned to the rapidly dissolving jury as they filed out of their seats, and gleamed on them with a fatherly in terest in his Kindly eyes, and stood up as Mr. Knowlton and Mr. Moody came over to shake hands with the counsel for the defense, As soon as possible the room was cleared, When the spectators had finally gone Migs Borden was taken to the room of the justices and allowed to recover her composure with only the eyes of friends upon her and the caresses of devoted ad mi:ers, At the expiration of an hour she was placed In a carriage and driven to the station, where she took a train for Fall River, her home no longer, probably, but still the only objective point for the im mediate present.

See the clipping

The Times · Richmond, Va.

The judge instructed the jury on standards of proof and circumstantial evidence, noting Lizzie's failure to testify should not be held against her. The jury deliberated briefly and returned a verdict of not guilty, prompting emotional scenes in the courtroom including tears from Lizzie Borden and her attorney.

The Times · 21 June 1893 · page 1

The words of this article are printed with the report it shares its clipping with. Read them there or in the clipping.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

The Seattle Post-Intelligencer · Seattle, Wash. Terr. Wash.

The report announces that Lizzie Borden was acquitted on June 20 after being tried since June 5 for the murders of her father and stepmother. It recaps the prosecution's closing argument, which focused on motive, the inconsistent accounts of her burned dress, and the implausibility of her alibi in the barn.

The Seattle Post-Intelligencer · 21 June 1893 · page 1

SECURED THE VERDICT

New Beitokp, June 20.—Lizzie Borden, who has been on trial here siuce June 5, on the charge of hav.ng murdered fcer father, Andrew J. Borden, and his wife,

See the clipping

The Seattle Post-Intelligencer · Seattle, Wash. Terr. Wash.

The prosecutor argues Lizzie Borden had motive and opportunity, pointing to the contradictory stories about her burned dress, her claimed barn alibi, and the hatchet matching the skull wounds. After Lizzie declares her innocence, Justice Dewey instructs the jury on reasonable doubt, motive, and the weighing of circumstantial evidence.

The Seattle Post-Intelligencer · 21 June 1893 · page 1

LIZZIE BORDEN

MZZTB BOBDBM. nesMtoallwoM ana dusty condition o( the barn ud the fact that keen-eyed people found no trace* o! a parson baring bean there. How she could bar* avoided getting blood on bar clothea tba Jury could not answer, because they were neither woman nor murderer*. It was a aingu tar thing that thla dree*, after being kept so long, was burned on tbat particular Sunday. Utile Borden had been told on Saturday nlgbt that she would be accused of tba crime and tba next morning sbe burned the dress, lira Re gan never denied the "you-give-me-away" story uudar oath.

See moreSee less

Tba prosecution did not claim tbat they introduced the hatebet with which the murder was committed. It was shown that tba hatchet bad been wet and bad been robbed in ashes, and that the blade fitted almost miraculously into the boles in the skulls. He declared that the story of the quarrel between ,the Borden sister*, as told by Matron Regan and afterward denied by her, was true. He said tba

See the clipping

The Seattle Post-Intelligencer · Seattle, Wash. Terr. Wash.

The judge's charge to the jury emphasized the circumstantial nature of the case and reasonable doubt, after which the jury deliberated and returned a verdict of not guilty. The courtroom erupted in cheers, Lizzie Borden wept with relief, and she was later taken by carriage to the train for Fall River; the report closes with a summary recap of the original double murder.

The Seattle Post-Intelligencer · 21 June 1893 · page 1

today issued by the United States commis sioner for the arrest of Roberts, the Soulier who recently killed Private O Leary at i(. bherman. ___ _ . Try Aaoth JS.uc;s cr blood boildiag tonic retirement ot the jar* noticed a movement indicating their return. A moment later the twe.ve men tiled into their seat* and were polled. M.ss Borden was asked ta stand up an J the foreman asked to return the verdict, which he announced as "Not guilty." Then ail the dignity and decoT 'M rx 0i li»* cyurt room vanished.

See moreSee less

A cheer went up which might fcava been heard half a mile a war, and there was no at tempt to check »t. Miss Borden's head went down upon the rail in front of her and the tears came. Mr. Jennings was al most crying, while Mr. Adams seemed in capable of speech. As aoon as possiMa the room was cleared, and when tha spec tators ha I iinally gone, Miss Borden waa tak-n to the room of the justices and al lowed to recover her composure with only the eyes of frien is upon her and the ca resses of devoted admirers. At the as piration ft! an hour she was piaced in %

See the clipping

The Seattle Post-Intelligencer · Seattle, Wash. Terr. Wash.

The jury has acquitted Lizzie Borden of murdering her father and stepmother, a verdict the paper calls final though it suggests 'not proven' would have better matched public sentiment. The editorial claims most observers believe she was guilty despite the circumstantial evidence, and notes that women in particular have shown her no sympathy, viewing her as a cold, unsentimental murderess.

The Seattle Post-Intelligencer · 21 June 1893 · page 4

LIZZIK BOKDICN ACQI'ITTIO. The jury has finally acquitted LUxia Borden of the crime of murder. This ver dict is final and the accused can never again be tried for the murder of her fatk-er and step-mother. If the iury could have brought in a verdict of "not proven" It would have been more in accordance with the fatts and with the general drift of public opinion. There are few people who have followed carelu.lv this remarka ble ensj who have not come to the con elusion that I.issie I lord en must have commuted the crimes of which she was accused although the evidence against her purely circumstantial.

See moreSee less

A cm.'us feature ot this remarkable cassia that l.isx e Borden from the tirst •eents to have hud the feminine public opinion sol id against her. Theie have been timet during the trial when the ter iible strain to wh eh she has leeti

See the clipping

The Seattle Post-Intelligencer · Seattle, Wash. Terr. Wash.

The article contrasts Lizzie Borden's case with those of Carlyle Harris and Dr. Buchanan, noting that public sympathy was extended to handsome young male murderers but withheld entirely from Borden. It argues that women in particular condemned her as a cold, loveless, avaricious spinster who killed out of greed rather than passion, explaining the total absence of public compassion for her.

The Seattle Post-Intelligencer · 21 June 1893 · page 4

LIZZIE BORDEN ACQUITTED

st-mcj point she is nothing but a hard-faced. eo<d. -austere, soar "old maid" who, in heriting her father's avarice, beiiered that her parsimonious stepmother would ob tain i large amount of property that would otherwise go to herself and her sister. For this the woman folk be.ieve s>ha bitterly hated her stepmother and finally kille<} bar and killed her father to com plete'the crime, knowing that if he sur vived he would feel morally certain that his daughter was the murderess of his wife and ireat her in accordance with this con viction.

See moreSee less

Vowing L'rrie Borden from tha stand point of tha women folk who believe her guiltjr. their total withholding of all com pass on or sympathy for her during her trial lis entirely natural; tha woman did not fco wrong because of "love" lor any body! that took the curdled form of pas sionate resentment or revenge; she went wrotig purely because of relentless, cold blooded hate for her stepmother; a bata thatjwas not born out ol crossed lore, but out v>f disappointed avarice. This fairly explains why Uzxie Borden has not re ceived any flowers, fruit, or any sort of ovatjon during her trial. The wotuen all thot&ht bcr guilty, and finding no touch or *!>ior of the "grand passion" in her gulll have nothing but a fact of flint for

See the clipping

The Seattle Post-Intelligencer · Seattle, Wash. Terr. Wash.

This opinion piece argues Lizzie Borden's alleged crime stemmed from cold-blooded hate and disappointed avarice rather than passion, explaining the public's lack of sympathy for her during trial. It predicts that despite her acquittal, she faces lifelong social ostracism in America unless the true culprit is ever found.

The Seattle Post-Intelligencer · 21 June 1893 · page 4

her guilty, but believed her insane; the minority who believe her innofent take no very deep interest in her becajise she is no longer young, and was iievwr beautiful, or even handsome or pretty; she has always led a retired Ufa, neuter seeking social sympathy nor in viting it from others. Even now that sha has |>een acquitted her fate is a miserable one J the is doomed to social exile the lest of her days unless the author of the Borden murders la discovered; she ;cannot iive In Fall River; sha can jive no* here in America with any comfort until the executor of the Borden murllers is exposed to the light of day.

See moreSee less

Until that day the life of I.izxie Borden, if is sane, is a life of sociai ostracism and jnoral exile. If shs is really innocent she |i the most unfortunate of all women in tl~e world; if she is guilty and sane sha is thp mast repulsive; If she is guilty but insane, as seems probable, she is entitled to compassion as an insane woman held

See the clipping

Watertown Republican · Watertown, Wis.

At the Lizzie Borden trial, a dozen defense witnesses testified to refute the police matron's claim that Lizzie accused Emma of 'giving her away.' Emma Borden took the stand, denied the alleged quarrel, and insisted she and Lizzie had remained on good terms with their mother for years.

Watertown Republican · 21 June 1893 · page 2

Baron von Hollenden, German ambas sador at Washington, then responded to the greetings of Mr. Rubens in be half of the representatives of the Ger man Emperor, Next on the programme was the address of the day, which was delivered by Carl Scburz, of New York. THE MATRON’S STORY FALSE. Witnesses Deny That Lizzie and Borden Quarreled.

See the clipping

The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · Wheeling, W. Va.

The editorial calls the jury's verdict acquitting Lizzie Borden entirely righteous, arguing the prosecution had no real evidence against her beyond a prosecutor's dramatic but unsubstantiated reconstruction of the crime. It also defends defense attorney ex-Governor Robinson's understated closing argument, saying he rightly focused on the lack of evidence rather than theatrical oratory.

The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · 21 June 1893 · page 4

A JuMt Verdict. Thero never was u uioro righteous ver'dict thun that givon yesterday by tho jury ia the Lizzio Borden case. Thero was nothing beforo that jury to prove tho young woman's guilt The prosocutor pictured her savage

See the clipping

The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · Wheeling, W. Va.

A newspaper column remarks that the Borden case will likely never be solved, criticizing the police for focusing on Lizzie Borden while the real killer escaped. The item is part of a miscellany of unrelated news briefs.

The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · 21 June 1893 · page 4

that any work uudortRkon by that body tondvatico tho city's interest Invariably dsvolvn on few inou. To mu?ic, A drum corpsol fifty thousand! Evory ono a huatler. That will ba worth seeing. It would be interesting to know who did kill old man Borden sod his wifo. Tho probability ig that the mystery will not bo solved. Tho police have inudo a floe metis of the caso. While they were trying to convict Lizzie Borden

See the clipping

The World · Martinsburg, W. Va.

This editorial commends the jury's prompt acquittal of Lizzie Borden, arguing the state's evidence was far too weak to justify a conviction. It concludes that the true murderer will likely never be found, and the case will join history's unsolved criminal mysteries.

The World · 21 June 1893 · page 2

Lizzie Borden is clearly not the answer according to the testimony. The real criminal will probably never be discnv ered and the case will now pass into legal history to take its place by tin side of the famous criminal mysteries »i*ich human analysis and detective abi.itjr have bceu unable to unnivel.

See the clipping

Wheeling Register · Wheeling, W. Va.

The jury in the Borden murder trial acquitted Lizzie Borden, with spectators cheering loudly and Borden shedding tears of joy upon hearing the verdict. The report also recounts closing arguments made earlier that day, including the District Attorney's remarks on motive and family discord.

Wheeling Register · 21 June 1893 · page 1

SHE IS NOT GUILTY

From the Throng of Spectators in the Court Room—Miss Bor den Returns to Fall River. New Bedford. Mass., June 20. There was less of a Jam outside the courthouse this morning, although at the opening of court there were a» many people in the room as at any t.me during the session. Miss Borden en

See the clipping

Wheeling Register · Wheeling, W. Va.

The District Attorney continues his closing argument, dismissing the defense's claim about motive and describing a theory of how Lizzie Borden allegedly killed her stepmother first, then deceived and killed her father upon his return home. He paints her as transformed into a 'murderess' driven by hatred and necessity rather than premeditated planning.

Wheeling Register · 21 June 1893 · page 1

Borden did not plan to kill her father, and I hope so. But it was not Lizzie Andrew Borden who came down these stairs to meet

See the clipping

Wheeling Register · Wheeling, W. Va.

The prosecutor's closing argument mocks the barn alibi, questions the lack of blood on Lizzie's clothes, and argues the hatchet handle was deliberately broken to hide evidence. The court then allows Lizzie to address the jury, she declares her innocence, and Judge Dewey begins his charge to the jury.

Wheeling Register · 21 June 1893 · page 1

KVKW OX A COOLJCX* DAT. She told Officer Harrington that she could not hear anything, any noise, because she was up in the loft. This was the only place, and the hottest where she could get and not hear anything. In all your ob servation have you ever heard of an at tempt to create an alibi which was ^ore strange than the circumstances of this one. That barn alibi will not stand. We come back and And her father dead, and a story on bar lips which has no vestige of truth in It.

See moreSee less

He referred to the visit to the cellar as an evidence of Miss Borden's nerve. How she could have avoided getting blood on her clothes the jury caunot an swer because they are neither wemen nor murderers. The prosecution did not claim they had introduced the hatchet with which the murder was committed. We don't say this small hatchet did the business, but we do think the handle was broken off. not ac cidentally, but m order to make the least showing ef sp.inters. It has been shown that It had been wet and then rubbed in ashea, and it has been shown that the blade fits almost miraculously into the boles in i those skulls. We do not say it was the hatchet, but we do say it may well have been the hatchet.

See the clipping

Wheeling Register · Wheeling, W. Va.

The report states Lizzie Borden was acquitted not due to skilled defense lawyers but because the prosecution failed to provide solid legal proof of her guilt. It notes the quick jury verdict reflects the absence of concrete evidence, though moral suspicions may have favored conviction, and speculates the true murderer may someday be revealed.

Wheeling Register · 21 June 1893 · page 4

LIZZIE BORDEN Al'QriTTED. Lizzie Bobdsx has been acquitted, not through tbe ability of her lawyers, but because of the utter absence of any sort of proof of her guilt. The argu ments made In presenting her case to the jury were by oo means brilliant, while the prosecution very ably and strongly presented every paint against her. The almost immediate verdict by the jury acquitting the defendant, therefore, is further evidence that there was not one legal peg on which tho prosecution could hang its case. If surmises and moral conclusions were valid evidence lu a court of just ice, the prosecution might have bad the best of it and Lizzie Borden might not have been so easily cleared of tbe awful charge against her.

See moreSee less

if »mi>nl»r will nut." and the true BoRT»s>f murderer Is odo day brought to light and tells the tale, it will be the clearing up of one of the most remark able mysteries in the annals of crime.

See the clipping

The Weekly Register · Point Pleasant, Va. W. Va.

A short news blurb notes that Lizzie Borden, tried for killing her father and stepmother in Fall River, Massachusetts, was acquitted of the crime the previous day. The item appears amid a column of unrelated short news items on politics and current events.

The Weekly Register · 21 June 1893 · page 2

The latest turn in a flail |?Q O ? Julu suggests jBWWBP^iitodStates may j-et seek to annex itself to Hawaii. JId.w history does invert itself. Miss Lizzie Borden, who has been on trial for the killing of her father and step-mother, at Fall Kiver, Mass., a few months ago, was ac quitted of the crime yesterday.

See the clipping

The Cheyenne Daily Leader · Cheyenne, Wyo.

The report describes the final day of Lizzie Borden's trial in New Bedford, Massachusetts, including closing arguments, the judge's charge to the jury, and Borden's brief statement of innocence. The jury retired and returned after a short deliberation, delivering a verdict of not guilty.

The Cheyenne Daily Leader · 21 June 1893 · page 1

FOUND NOT GUILTY. Lizzie Borden Acquitted of the Charge of Double Murder. JURY OUT ONLY A LITTLE WHILE. Scene of Great Excitement in the Court Room Over the Announce

See the clipping

The Green Forest Tribune · Green Forest, Ark.

A filler column of odds-and-ends jokes and commentary remarks that twelve jurors are currently deciding Lizzie Borden's guilt or innocence. It also notes a charge that politics has entered the Borden case.

The Green Forest Tribune · 22 June 1893 · page 4

Great Scott! Whither are we drifting? It is now charged that there is politics in the Lizzie Borden case. The Chinese rule—a beheaded banker for every broken bank— may yet have to bo adopted in America. Wheat sold for 63 cents a bushel in Chicago the other day, and the anti-option bill didn’t become a law either. Strange, isn’t it, how many peo ple always know after an accident that it was going to happen? The thieves seem to be getting more out of the World’s Fair than any other class. Wf have received a copy of the Little Rock Tribune. It is well filled with news. The ultra economist in Congress can never hope to be popular in Washington.

See the clipping

The Russellville Democrat · Russellville, Ark.

A massive crowd, mostly women in holiday attire, mobbed the New Bedford courthouse for the day of closing arguments, with only a tenth finding seats. Lizzie Borden appeared composed holding a bunch of pinks as Governor Robinson began his defense argument after the jury was polled.

The Russellville Democrat · 22 June 1893 · page 1

Borden came in, a bunch of pinks in her hand and a contented smite on her face. The jury was polled promptly on the opening of court, and almost immediately Gov ernor Robinson began his argument.

See the clipping

The Press · Stafford Springs, Conn.

The piece argues Lizzie Borden's acquittal was a foregone conclusion given the weak case, and criticizes Fall River police for fixating on one theory while the real culprit remains free. It also recounts how ex-Governor Robinson was chosen as her defense attorney.

The Press · 22 June 1893 · page 2

A story is going the rounds about the way in which ex-Governor Robinson was retained to defend Lizzie Borden. Among the prisoner's many Fall River friends

See the clipping

The Press · Stafford Springs, Conn.

The Norwich Bulletin notes that Lizzie Borden's dressmaker testified she had called her stepmother 'a mean old thing' and once said 'I hate her.' The piece reflects on how such ordinary but unguarded remarks now loom large as evidence against her in court.

The Press · 22 June 1893 · page 2

Norwich Bulletin : The Borden trial has in it a hint of warning "for most fami lies. Lizzie Borden said in the hearing of her dressmaker that her step-mother

See the clipping

Connecticut Western News · Salisbury, Conn.

Reporting from the Borden trial in New Bedford, this dispatch notes that nearly all evidence has been presented and a verdict is expected early the following week, with growing belief that Lizzie Borden will be acquitted. It details testimony from witnesses including her sister Emma, who disputed quarrel stories and explained the burned dress as paint-stained, along with reporters denying a damaging quote attributed to the jail matron.

Connecticut Western News · 22 June 1893 · page 1

MISS BORDEN'S FATE. EVIDENCE IN THE FAMOUS TRIAL ALMOST ALL IN.

MOST ALL IN. The Probability Tt Llxzie Borden WUl Be Acquitted Growing Stronger Her Sister Denied the Quarrel, and Said the Burned Dress Was Covered With Paint, New Bedford, Mass., June 17. The evidence on which the Borden jury is to form its opinion of the prisoner's guilt or innocence is practically all in. A verdict will be reached early next week, and the impression is gaining ground that an acquittal will result. The last day's proceedings began when the court excluded the evidence offered by the defense as to the appearance at Steep Brook, twelve days after the murder, of a strangely acting man, with a bloody shirt and a hatchet.

See moreSee less

Charles F. Sawyer said he saw the prisoner in the Borden house just after the murders. People were fanning her and her clothes were not disarranged or bloody. John J. Manning and Thomas Hickey, reporters, testified that Matron Reagan told them there was nothing in the " you gave me away " story. Mary K. Holmes testified that defendant was a member of the church and Christian Endeavor society, and engaged in various religious and charitable enterprises, and that she attended church with Mrs. Borden. Emma L. Borden, defendant's sister, tes

See the clipping

Connecticut Western News · Salisbury, Conn.

Emma Borden is cross-examined about the dress-burning incident and denies making certain statements attributed to her by witnesses. The dressmaker testifies about the burned garment, after which the defense rests and the prosecution prepares its rebuttal.

Connecticut Western News · 22 June 1893 · page 1

MOST ALL IN

The examination of Emma Borden closed with that, and Mary A. Raymond, who made the, dress that was burned, was call ed. She then told of something that was peculiarly interesting, bbe said that when Miss Lizzie had the dress made she dis carded an old wrapper for it. "What did she do with the old wrapper?" "She cut some pieces out of it and said she would burn the dress. She went down stairs with it in her arms and came back without it." After a little more unimportant testi mony ex-Governor Robinson said: "The defense rests."

See moreSee less

Mr. Moody asked for 15 minutes in which to prepare the rebuttal, which the court granted. New Bedford, Mass., June 19. Today marks the beginning of the end of the famous Borden murder trial. Today comes the legal battle of the counsel for the pros ecution and defense. The work of preparation among the counsel in the Borden case bad been going on all the day before, despite the fact that it was Sunday. The work was considered one of the essentials of good work to come. Consultations and deliberations and active efforts in the line of blocking out the argu ments on an effective basis had been keep ing all parties in the city Interested exceed ingly busy, while the newspaper men have been interested lookers on lrom afar, sim ply because a nearer approach and an in sight into the actual work of the day and evening was an absolute impossibility.

See the clipping

Connecticut Western News · Salisbury, Conn.

The report describes final courtroom preparations as the Borden trial nears its end, with D.A. Knowlton and defense attorney Robinson delivering closing arguments before the judge's charge to the jury. It also relays an unverified Baltimore story about a young man calling himself 'Felix Borden' who allegedly told a landlady that 'Lizzie did it.'

Connecticut Western News · 22 June 1893 · page 1

Possible Clew. Baltimore, June 19. Mrs. Ramsey, who keeps a boarding house at 333 St. Paul street, says that previous to the Borden murders a boy came from New England and boarded with her. He told her tht t he was the adopted son of Lizzie Borden's uncle, and that his name was Felix Bor den. He said that his parents' name was Desroches. From all account! he did not live happily with the Bordens, aud as a re sult of a disagreement with them he left home suddenly. ' Felix told Mrs.

See moreSee less

Ramsey that his home was in New Bedford or Fall River. He spent his money freely. He did not pay his board bill and left, saying that he was going to his home in Massachusetts to get money to settle. A few days after Felix left, the Borden murders were committed. He returned to" Baltimore. On one occasion Mrs. Ramsey spoke to Felix about the murders. She says that he replied, "Oh, Lizzie did it." Asked to describe the young man, Mrs. Ramsey said he was a medium sized fellow, with dark hair, and when he left was 21 years old. His description, it is said, tal lies with that given by several witnesses on Thursday, who said they saw a strange young man at the Borden gate the morn ing of the murder. Young Borden left Baltimore last fall and has not been heard of here sine. New Bedford, Mass., June 20. In a few short hours Lizrie Borden expects to know whether she Is to be a free woman or a woman disgraced and condemned. The hours will be trying ones to her, and there is no knowing how many of them there are to be. nivu xMmdjMr tMetrlot Attornv Koowlton resumed his summing up. 1. hen came the charge to the jury. Lizzie Borden shows that the strain is beginning to tell upon her, and no wonder after such a day as she passed through yes terday. The summinc up of ex-Governor Robin son was somewhat disappointing. His friends had expected him to make a bril limit and stirring appeal to the jury, but even the most enthusiastic of them admit ted that it was rather commonplace, as whole. He spoke for four hours and a quarter, and during most of the time Miss Borden kept her face covered with her lan. As he was closing Lizziebegan to weep, : Her face was red and swollen when she re

See the clipping

Connecticut Western News · Salisbury, Conn.

The report announces that Lizzie Borden has been found 'not guilty' by the jury after an hour and a half of deliberation. It describes the courtroom erupting in cheers, waving hats and handkerchiefs, as the verdict was read, and states the collapse of the State's case left no other possible outcome.

CorrectionThis set right an article from the day before.

Connecticut Western News · 22 June 1893 · page 2

Lizzie Borden Vindicated.

THURSDAY, JUNE 22, 1893. Thus far Dr Dixon's series of sermons on "The Gates of Hell In Modern Bab ylon" have shown the dark side of the picture. The next sermon will present the bright side and will be entitled The Church Triumphant." It will be published June 29th and it will close this remarkable series. On July 6th the Njews will resume the publication of Dr Talmage's sermons. Lizzie Borden Vindicated, lizzie Borden is at last a free woman Alter deliberating an hour and a half the iurv rendered a verdict of "not ST w w guilty" on , Tuesday afternoon.

See moreSee less

The verdict was received with waving of hats and handkerchiefs and a mighty shout that made the old court house tremble. After the complete breaking down of the State's case no other ver diet should have been rendered. ,

See the clipping

Morning Journal and Courier · New Haven, Conn.

Lizzie Borden and her sister Emma returned to their Second Street home after Lizzie spent the night at a friend's residence following her acquittal. The report notes public sympathy had shifted in her favor, with congratulatory letters arriving for her attorney, and mentions plans for Lizzie, Emma, and Bridget Sullivan to travel to Europe.

Morning Journal and Courier · 22 June 1893 · page 3

LIZZIE BORDEN AT HOME.

or tne inry. It is stated by a relative of the Borden family that as soon as Mies Lizzie Borden and her sister Emma can make proper ar rangements they, with Bridget Sullivan, will sail for Europe for an extended trip, This la considered the best way to escape unpleasant recollections of the past year,

See the clipping

Freeland Tribune · Freeland, Pa. · and 1 other paper

This weekly news roundup reports that the prosecution rested and the defense began its case in the Lizzie Borden trial at New Bedford on Friday, June 10. It notes that Mr. Jennings delivered the opening speech for the defense.

Freeland Tribune · 22 June 1893 · page 4

NEWS OF THE WEEK.

the kindly feeling of Russia for Austria Friday, Juno 10. The prosecution rested and the defense began lu the trial of Lizzie Borden at New Bedford. Mr. Jennings made the opening speech for the prisoner Wealthy and aged Eliphalet Stratton of Brooklyn has been arrested on a charge of starving his Invalid young wife It is alleged that E. M. Field's insanity Is shammed and that he is practically free Royal Phelps Car roll's new yacht, the Navahoe, was dis abled by collision with n pilotboat Several persons were killed, and considerable damage to property was done by lightning in the west The heirs of Jay Gould will contest in court the payment of 1250,000 Inheritance tax in addition to the 1500,000 already paid The Rev.

See moreSee less

Charles B. McKenna, a priest of St.

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • The Willimantic Journal · Willimantic, Conn. · 23 June 1893

Freeland Tribune · Freeland, Pa. · and 1 other paper

This roundup of world and national news briefly reports that testimony in the Borden murder trial was finished on Saturday, June 17, with court adjourning until Monday. It notes that Emma Borden gave strong evidence in her sister Lizzie's favor.

Freeland Tribune · 22 June 1893 · page 4

NEWS OF THE WEEK.

alleges that he is insane. Saturday, Juno 17. The taking of testimony in the Borden murder trial was finished, and the court adjourned till Monday. Emma Borden gave strong evidence iu her sister's favor ——Bunker Hill day is being celebrated in

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • The Willimantic Journal · Willimantic, Conn. · 23 June 1893

Waterbury Evening Democrat · Waterbury, Conn.

An opinion piece argues that Marshal Hilliard fixed on a theory to avoid appearing incompetent, ignoring other clues, and that District Attorney Knowlton pursued the Borden prosecution partly to boost his own reputation against a formidable defense lawyer. It suggests Knowlton was not personally hostile to the Borden sisters but may have sought fame through their conviction.

Waterbury Evening Democrat · 22 June 1893 · page 2

The ambition of men affects human affairs and nowhere is it better shown than in the Borden case. The public demanded that Marshall Hilliard find the guilty party and lest he should be denounced as incompetent he fixed upon a theory and ignored clues that did not lead in its direction. The at torney general of Massachusetts refused to prosecute the marshall's case and District Attorney Knowlton took it up. Pitted against him was the strongest lawyer in criminal practice in the state. To beat him would be a great feather in the younger district attorney's cap.

See moreSee less

He appreciated that fact clearly and it is not strange that he forgot that he was a publio prosecutor only bound to get at the truth and became a zealous advocate working for his own glory even if at the hazard of sacrificing a life. It is said that the Borden sisters

See the clipping

Waterbury Evening Democrat · Waterbury, Conn.

After her acquittal, Lizzie Borden and her sister Emma returned to their Second Street home, accompanied by Bridget Sullivan, following a night spent at a friend's residence. A relative states the sisters plan to travel to Europe with Bridget Sullivan to escape painful memories of the past year.

Waterbury Evening Democrat · 22 June 1893 · page 2

PLANS OF THE BORDEN3 Will Go to Europe Boon, Accom They panled by Bridget Sullivan. Fall River. Mass., June 22. It is stated by a relative of the Borden family

See the clipping

Evening Journal · Wilmington, Del.

This editorial argues that police and District Attorney Knowlton were duty-bound to prosecute Lizzie Borden based on the suspicion against her, and that criticism of them is unfair since the trial judges allowed the case to proceed. It also quotes a Philadelphia Inquirer piece criticizing Knowlton for pursuing the case despite his legal skill.

Evening Journal · 22 June 1893 · page 2

We cannot thoroughly comprehend the assaults which are prevalent npon the police and upon District Attorney Know) ton on account of the prosecution of Lizzie Borden. In the first place, if the contention had any real basis It would include that admirable and learned bench of junges, of whom the admirable Judge Blodgett was the chief, in the blame that is attached to the prosecutor and the police. If the case were so despicable and disreputable that Just and honorable judge would not, could not have listened to it for two weeks.

See moreSee less

But in addition to that, the police and the prosecutor are bound by oath to act on their suspicions. They cannot try and acquit. Those.mur ders of the Bordens were committed and suspicion polnted'to Lizzie Borden as the murderer. After the suspicion has failed to be established as a fact, It is unwise and unjust to jdamo those officials who acted upon it. It was their duty to act. It would have been the duty of Judge Blodgett to dismiss the case and instruct the Jury to bring in a verdict of "not guilty" if the strictures of some of the newspapers were true. Homebody com mitted the murders; it is not yet proven that Lizzie Borden did not commit them, and it never will be proven till there is

See the clipping

Evening Journal · Wilmington, Del.

A short local notes item reports that public sympathy had consistently favored Lizzie Borden and that the not-guilty verdict was well received in the area. It appears amid miscellaneous town news about swimming complaints, baseball games, and personal items.

Evening Journal · 22 June 1893 · page 4

manager's address is T. 1) Wise, New Castle, Del. Inetileiil. of the Day. Rowing, sailing and swimming erenow lh e _favorlte evening pastimes for the young people. The steamer Thomas Clyde stopped here yesterday but received only a very limited patronage. Sympathy was from the first and all the time with Lizzie Borden and the ver diet of not guilty seems to give general satisfaction here.

See the clipping

Evening Journal · Wilmington, Del.

Lizzie Borden went back to her Second Street home in Fall River after staying overnight at Charles Holmes's residence. Her counsel stated that she and her sister would try to find the real killer of her father and stepmother.

Evening Journal · 22 June 1893 · page 4

SUMMARY OF EARLY KEÏÏS. Ml«* Durden Return« to Her Ileumanil Will Kmleuvor to Ferret Out the Beal Murderer of Her Father and Step Mother. Lizzie A. Borden returned with her slater to her home on Hecoud street, Fall River, after having spent the night at Charles B. Holmes's residence Her counsel said she and Lev sister would en deavorto ferret out the real murderer.

See the clipping

Delaware Gazette and State Journal · Wilmington, Del.

The report describes the jury's brief deliberation and the tumultuous applause that greeted Lizzie Borden's acquittal, with the prisoner collapsing as if shot upon hearing the verdict. It also recaps earlier trial testimony from witnesses about the Borden yard and a quarrel between Lizzie and her sister Emma.

Delaware Gazette and State Journal · 22 June 1893 · page 1

THE PRISONER FALLS AS IF SHOT

Patrick McGowan testified that he was in the<' e yard on the morning of the murder and t yard. Mrs. Kirby tostilieii that she w kitchen the morning of the murder f no «me in the Borden var«l. Joseph DesRosier and John Denny fled that they worked in ti all davon the day of the murder und saw : between that ami the ! no on«* go Hordni yard. The cross-exumin: witnesses tend'd to show that" man .nigh. ! ' the Borden her ; yard 1

See the clipping

Delaware Gazette and State Journal · Wilmington, Del.

Mrs. Reagan testifies at trial about overhearing a quarrel between Lizzie and Emma Borden the day before the murders, including Lizzie's statement 'you have given me away' and Emma's denial. Cross-examination challenges the witness's account, followed by the start of testimony from drug clerk Eli Bence regarding Lizzie's alleged attempt to purchase prussic acid.

Delaware Gazette and State Journal · 22 June 1893 · page 1

LIZZIE AND EMMA QUARRELED

again in the afternoon but I can't tell just when. Mr. Buck was tliore I am quite sure. Hecame every day. What time Miss E ill the ufternoon I can't tell. I know that. Mis* Borden looked \\ lien you left the fore. When I si*okc of the affair hetw the sisters, I spoke «>f it as a «jmirrH. This was before the first hearing. I don't know what «lay of the week the quarrel was 1 don't know whether the story ■ cjuarrel was published i-i the morning papers. 1 was asked about it by r«'P< that very afternoon, and al>oi ing.

See moreSee less

I never tol«i any reporte! lie, that there Mr. Buck spoke hut 1 never told him it wu? she diil be thi if i lie ' as all : 1 i of truth i • Then*

See the clipping

Delaware Gazette and State Journal · Wilmington, Del.

Court debates admissibility of testimony suggesting Lizzie Borden tried to buy prussic acid before the murders, with witnesses questioned about the poison's uses. A separate item reports a rusty hatchet found near the Borden property and describes Lizzie's demeanor amid flowers on the trial's tenth day.

Delaware Gazette and State Journal · 22 June 1893 · page 1

ATTEMPT TO

Fai.l River, M \s?., June 15.—Last night n I»«»v named Rotter. ?<»u of C\ C. R« clerk iu the Full River water works olfic«*. while looking for a ball, found a hatchet on the top of John Crowe's barn, which is located just in the rear of the Borden prop Mr. I'otter this morning reported his find to the police and also sought an inter view with the counsel f«>r defence, but was unable to find Mr. Jennings. He still has the hatchet in his posses sion, amt d«;seribes it as ordinary imple ment with a hammer head.

See moreSee less

The handle was weather-beaten ami the blade covered with rust. Some of the particles of rust being removed, a slight coloring of gilt was disci« »seil, which would either indicate that t lie hatchet was ew when lost ornament or was quite or discarded. LIZZIE BORDEN. FLOWERS

See the clipping

The National Tribune · Washington, D.C.

The report summarizes the background of the Borden murders in Fall River, describing the household, Andrew Borden's wealth, and the discovery of the bodies on August 4, 1892. It notes that only Lizzie Borden and servant Bridget Sullivan were known to be in the house at the time, and references medical testimony from the ongoing trial.

The National Tribune · 22 June 1893 · page 8

A GREAT CASE Close of the Trial of Lizzie A. Borden for a Double Murder

On the 4th day of Angnst, 1892, somo tirao between tho hours of 9 and 11:15 a. m., An drew Bordon and his wifo wore murdered in their homo. Their heads wore horribly hacked with a hatchet or somo similar weapon. Only two persons besides tho murdered man aud woman wore known to havo loon in the house during the timo within which tho murder must havo occurred. Theso wore Lizzie Borden and Bridgot Sullivan. John V. Morso, tho matornal nuclo of Emma and Lizzie, was a visitor at tho house, but left tho houso early in tho morning and did not return until after tho discovory of the crimo. Emma was absent on a visit to

See the clipping

The National Tribune · Washington, D.C.

This report reconstructs the morning of the murders, detailing the movements of Lizzie Borden, Bridget Sullivan, John Morse, and Andrew Borden, based on testimony given at the ongoing trial. It notes the unresolved mystery of the note Lizzie claimed summoned Mrs. Borden away, and the timeline suggesting Mrs. Borden was killed roughly 70-90 minutes before Andrew Borden's death.

The National Tribune · 22 June 1893 · page 8

Now Bedford. Andrew Borden went out abont 9. Ac cording to tho tostimony of the medical experts at the trial which is being hold, Mrs. Borden must havo been killed from an hour to an hour and a half bofore Mr. Bordon, which would place the timo of her murder at 9:30 o'clock or thereabouts, as Mr. Bordon camo back at 10:45. During all this time Bridgot Sullivan was, sho claimed at tho trial, washing windows. She passed to and fro down stairs and occasionally wont out into tho yard, and for a little whilo during this time sho stopped her work and ongaged in conversation with a servant girl across the fence. She said sho did not see any one come into or leave the houso, although

See the clipping

The National Tribune · Washington, D.C.

This report summarizes the discovery of Abby Borden's body, Lizzie's account of her father's death, and details of her clothing examination showing almost no blood. It also notes her arrest, imprisonment, and the opening of her trial on June 5 before Chief Justice Mason and associate justices.

The National Tribune · 22 June 1893 · page 8

tific examination by Mrs. Borden. experis, witn trie re suit that no blood, except one spot as large as a pin's head on her skirt, was found. A belief in the double guilt of Lizzio Borden

See the clipping

In the story →

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

This item compiles editorial reactions from several major newspapers (Albany Argus, Philadelphia Record, Washington Post, Baltimore Sun) following Lizzie Borden's acquittal. The papers largely agree the prosecution's case was weak, question the wisdom of her arrest and indictment, and marvel at her composure throughout the ordeal.

New-York Tribune · 22 June 1893 · page 7 · transcribed from the page image

THE ACQUITTAL OF LIZZIE BORDEN.

NO JUSTIFICATION FOR HER TREATMENT. From The Albany Argus.

See moreSee less

What is there in the case made out by the prosecution which should justify the State of Massachusetts in its treatment of Lizzie Borden since her arrest six days after the Fall River tragedy? If a New-England jury, after due deliberation for a little over two hours, returns a verdict of not guilty without any seeming disagreement, if they decide that there were not facts sufficient upon which to find an indictment for murder against the accused, is not their action in itself an Indictment of the intelligence and methods of the Fall River police and District-Attorney Knowlton?

THE INDICTMENT UNWARRANTED. From The Philadelphia Record.

The grievous delay in the trial of the accused, in the light of the disclosures of the trial, is now accounted for. There never was a case so clear as to warrant indictment. Lizzie Borden will go out of court, if she be innocent, the victim of circumstances, suspicions and persecutions for which she can obtain neither redress nor remittance unless the actual murderer shall at some future time be found out. In that hope she must live.

PHENOMENAL FORTITUDE. From The Washington Post.

Assume what theory we may, the fact remains that no woman is of record who ever demeaned herself under similarly trying circumstances with such phenomenal impassibility and unnerved fortitude. Was it a high-born, heroic consciousness of innocence or a stoicism steeled to the menace of fate?

NO JURY COULD HAVE CONVICTED HER. From The Baltimore Sun.

No jury composed of men entitled to be at large could possibly have convicted her on the evidence presented at the trial without being false to their oaths and to their intellects. The case made out by the State was not strong enough to hang a dog on, and the wonder is, not that she was acquitted, but that she should have been subjected to a long imprisonment and a bitter prosecution on the testimony produced before the jury.

A FAIR TRIAL. From The Utica Herald.

Never was a trial conducted more fairly than that of Lizzie Borden. Neither prosecution nor defence omitted any effort to secure the truth, and the trial and its result are satisfactory.

THE EVIDENCE FELL FAR SHORT. From The Boston Herald.

People—and there are a good many of them—who have believed from the first that she was not clear of grave suspicion have been compelled to recognize that the evidence as brought out at the trial fell far short of fixing the crime upon her. The charge of Judge Dewey was practically and logically an instruction to acquit.

LET HER FIND A SOLUTION. From The Providence Journal.

There is no reason now for Miss Borden's silence. Let her speak. And let her also, as we have said, spare no effort to bring this horrible case to a more satisfactory conclusion than it has now reached, after months of investigation by the Government, and floods of eloquence from the defence; with so much evidence barred out by the Court, and the presumption of innocence most strenuously insisted upon by the learned judge who delivered the charge.

AN EXCELLENT JUDICIAL SYSTEM. From The Boston Globe.

There may well be congratulations also for Massachusetts and her people upon the possession of so excellent and so impartial a judicial system as that under which, without delay as without haste, one of the most celebrated cases of the time has been heard and definitely decided.

See the clipping

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

This item compiles reactions from several papers (Washington Post, Baltimore Sun, Utica Herald, Boston Herald, Providence Journal, Boston Globe) to Lizzie Borden's acquittal. Most praise the trial's fairness and argue the evidence was too weak to convict, while one paper urges Borden to now speak publicly to resolve lingering suspicion.

New-York Tribune · 22 June 1893 · page 7

LET HER FIND A SOLUTION, From The Providence Journal, There 1s no reason now for Miss Borden's silence, Let her speak, And let her also, we have said, HE)

See the clipping

Paper unidentified

A jury returned a verdict of acquittal in the Lizzie Borden case in New Bedford, Massachusetts. The news was received with cheers in the courtroom, which were quickly suppressed.

Paper unidentified · 22 June 1893 · page 3

More Seat* for the People. Chicago. June 22.—Comfi-rtable settee® with a total -eating caj<acity of about 40,- 000 have teen plac*«i conveniently about ir. the world’s fair. This will enable visitor to sit during the daily concerts and watch the pyrotechnic and e.ectnc displays in the evening. —— - —* Th* Jury Myi “Not Guilty."* New Bedford. .Mu*., June 22.—The jury returned a verdict of acquittal in the Lizzie Borden case. The ww» received with cheers, which were-quickly -irpj rv>*j.

See the clipping

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

Following Lizzie Borden's acquittal by a jury of twelve men, this report argues the crime investigation must start anew since the accused has been cleared. It speculates on how an unknown assassin could have entered the Borden house and escaped undetected.

Evening Star · 22 June 1893 · page 8

WHO IS THE ASSASSIN?

houses. Three women. Annie Timmin.. Han nah Vanarcher and Mary Fitzpatrick. jumped froma the rear windowe of the fourth story, They wore taken to the New York hoepitet, the two former being "shook" patienta and the latte having a leg broken. The total lose by fire i, 0100,000. The Plateau Valley sheep war near Dubuque, Col. Is probably over, the cheep men having been forced to vacate. aiixteen-year-old Wileon Haye., a colored boy was drowned in the Chrietiana creek, Wining Ltoo. Del., yesterday. sms been pointing In one direction for ten e* lting months must be discarded.

See moreSee less

l.LowIo Tum XUnban. Vra a legal Standpoint, If from no other, a plain that some monster did just what it hi en clhimed no monster could do. He sent ote to Mrs. Borden on the morning of Augu i and stole into the house on 2d street. He es

See the clipping

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

This piece sarcastically dismantles the theory of a mysterious outside killer, noting the absurdity of an unseen intruder lurking for over an hour, murdering twice, and vanishing without a trace or description. It concludes that despite Lizzie Borden's acquittal, the true killer remains utterly unidentified and the case unsolved.

Evening Star · 22 June 1893 · page 8

WHO IS THE ASSASSIN?

Uc Ande that his note has not aoomplished h marpose, and being diseovered strikes dow ras. Borden. AN OLD rTonY wIr A NZW CeAnAcTSn. It is the old story, but a new character

See the clipping

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

This report muses on the mysterious, unidentified individual who killed Mr. and Mrs. Borden, arguing that no clear profile—farmhand, sailor, tramp, or businessman—fits the perpetrator. It notes that despite the lack of a working theory, Lizzie Borden and her sister intend to pursue the search for the true murderer.

Evening Star · 22 June 1893 · page 8

A DIFFICULT TRAIL TO FOLLOW.

MR a=ne wIrL LAVE No STONE VNTUnXKs The New York World's Fall River, Mas peelal says: 1Awyer Jennings has no theor rhich he can sustain with proof as to who di ommit the Borden murders. Nevertheless, b mys, Miss Borden and her sister will leave n tone unturned to discover, if possible, who th sarderers are. The hunt is already on an rill continue. ceod preferred and common stock. The com uittee recommends that the niumbe LIGHTNING IM A CIRCUS.

See the clipping

The Morning News · Savannah, Ga.

Lizzie Borden and her sister returned to their Second Street home after spending the night at a friend's house, avoiding reporters on counsel's advice. The report notes public sentiment had shifted favorably after the verdict, with congratulatory telegrams and mail arriving for Borden and her lawyer.

The Morning News · 22 June 1893 · page 1

LIZZIE BORDEN RETURNS HOME. The Sisters Said to Have Broken Down Completely on Entering. Fall River, Mass., June 21.—Lizzie Bor den returned with her sister this morn

See the clipping

The Pacific Commercial Advertiser · Honolulu, Hawaiian Islands

A brief telegraphic dispatch reports that the defense in the Lizzie Borden trial has raised a legal objection to the use of her earlier testimony against her. The point is expected to be argued the following Monday and could significantly affect her defense.

The Pacific Commercial Advertiser · 22 June 1893 · page 1

TELEGRAPHIC NEWS. Latest by the' Arrival of the S. G. Wilder. Two trains collided near Sabana Grande, Nicaragua, June 8th, and a number of passengers were killed. It is announced that the new Nicaraguan Government will make no change in the canal concession, but will demand that the work be more rigidly prosecuted. The defense in the Lizzie Borden trial has raised an objection to the use of Miss Borden'd testimony in her trial, and the legal point aris ing therefrom is expected to have considerable weight in her defense. The matter will be argued Monday next. The Princess Eulalia yesterday

See the clipping

The Oskaloosa Herald · Oskaloosa, Iowa

The item is a column of miscellaneous short items, one of which comments on the Borden case, noting that unlike male murder defendants who might receive sympathy from women, Lizzie Borden receives none from New England women, who treat her as already condemned. The item speaks of her as presently 'on trial.'

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

The Oskaloosa Herald · 22 June 1893 · page 1

—Had a man been the center of at traction in the Borden trial, under all its strange conditions, the fellow* would have received much sweet and dowered sympathy from tiie women of that section. It has always been so before. But there is a woman on trial —Lizzie Borden. But she don’t get the dowers.

See the clipping

Audubon County Republican · Audubon, Iowa

The jury in the Lizzie Borden murder trial at New Bedford, Mass., deliberated for only an hour and a half before returning a verdict of not guilty. Borden had been charged with the murder of her father and mother at Fall River.

Audubon County Republican · 22 June 1893 · page 1

DURING THE WEEK.

Unit ad Slates supreme court hxs been stricken with paralysis and lie* at the point of death at Ins cottage at New port, It I. The coroner’s jury, in the case oi the catastrophe at the Ford Theatre build ing, Washington, decided to hold Col. F. C. Ainsworth, in charge of the building, to the grand jury. In the case of Lizzie Borden, whose

See the clipping

Audubon County Republican · Audubon, Iowa

The report states Lizzie Borden was acquitted on Tuesday of murdering her father and mother, with the jury reaching a verdict quickly. It characterizes the prosecution's case as weak and purely circumstantial, suggesting she was tried only because no other suspect could be found.

Audubon County Republican · 22 June 1893 · page 2

The cow boy lace from Chadron, Nebr., to Chicago is one of the most in teresting of current events. The dis tance is about 900 miles and they are jogging along at about sixty miles per day. Two have dropped out, with seven remaining, and Joe Gillespie and “Rattle Snake Pete” arc in the lead, with horses in good condition. The horses are a cross between thorough bred and bronchos, fine specimens of strength and endurance. The real con test will be in the finish when they ex pect to go at the rate of 100 miles per day. Lizzie Borden was acquitted on

See the clipping

The Weiser Signal · Weiser, Idaho

A humorous article about Idaho's exhibit at a fair jokingly lists celebrities, including Lizzie Borden, as being amazed by it. It is satire, not a factual report on the Borden case itself.

The Weiser Signal · 22 June 1893 · page 2

home rule bill. Lizzie Borden actu ally went into ecstacies and half ex pressed an intention of coming here to live when circumstances would permit. Count de Lesseps said he longed to be at peace in Idaho. Jim

See the clipping

The Weiser Signal · Weiser, Idaho

A miscellaneous newspaper filler column of jokes and short items includes a single sarcastic line suggesting that determining Lizzie Borden's innocence or guilt should involve abandoning 'all other methods.' The rest of the passage is unrelated commentary on politics, agriculture, and society.

The Weiser Signal · 22 June 1893 · page 2

I As twelve men are now engaged lit determining whether Lizzie Borden is innocent or guilty we would respect fully suggest the abandonnent of all other methods. ■ j '~ 1 _.. ■ i — _! 1 A man with money to invest needs to keep his eyes open, but that need j not keep newspaper men from get ting all the sleep they want. | It is an almighty hard task, breth ern, to make the lender and the bor rower take the same view of the : money question. • Wheat sold for t)3 cents a bushel t in Chicago the other day,and the anti- ; I j option bill didn't become a law,either.

See the clipping

Canton Weekly Register · Canton, Ill.

After closing arguments, Judge Dewey charged the jury on weighing evidence of motive and the standard of proof beyond reasonable doubt. The jury deliberated briefly and returned a verdict of not guilty.

Canton Weekly Register · 22 June 1893 · page 6

LIZZIE BORDEN ACQUITTED. Close of the Celebrated Trial at New Bed ford, .Mass. Xkw Bedford, June ‘Jl,—The lawyers in the Borden case—in which Lizzie Borden was accused of murdering her father and stepmother—concluded their arguments and Judge Dewey charged the jury to weigh the evidence so as to see whether defendant’s permanent state of mind showed motive for the crime. Every material allegation in the indictment must be proved beyond reasonable doubt, that is, to a moral certainty. He com pared direct and circumstantial evidence, and said that failure to prove an essential fact would be fatal, but failure to prove u helpful fact might not be.

See moreSee less

Lizzie’s state ments about the note were discussed at length, and he said they must be satisfied they were false. The judge concluded his charge at 3:<K>, and the jury retired, and returned shortly with a verdict of not guilty. __

See the clipping

Barton County Democrat · Great Bend, Kan.

A brief item reports that Lizzie Borden, tried for murdering her father and mother in New Bedford, Mass., was acquitted by the jury on Tuesday. The note appears amid unrelated local items about farming, taxes, and town news.

Barton County Democrat · 22 June 1893 · page 5

Jack Morrison and wife returned from Pueblo, Col., last Friday, and will probably remain here perma nently. Some farmers will hit the water line in this county, on corn, as planting began April 1st and will continue up to July 1st. Quite a number of our good citizens were in town the first of the weak, paying taxes before the penalty went on, June 20th. It Barton county gets one bushel to the acre sown last fall to wheat she will go beyond the expectations of the wise city farmers. Lizzie Borden, who was tried for murdering her father and mother at New Bedford, Mass., was, on Tuesday acquitted by the jury.

See moreSee less

Democratic county committee meet ing Saturday, the 24th. If you are a member of the committee it is im portant that you be present. C. L. Jones was in from the Chey enne, Wednesday. He says that the hot days are putting some unwelcome curlycues on the growing corn. E. C. Davis, of the south side, is one of Barton's farmers who will have wheat to cut this season. He was in town Tuesday ordering a header. The probate judge on Tuesday said the words which yoked together "for better or for worse," Geo. W. Rouner of Wallace, and Miss Alice Tabler of

See the clipping

The Wichita Daily Eagle · Wichita, Kan.

The newspaper reports that public sentiment overwhelmingly supports the 'not guilty' verdict returned in the Lizzie Borden trial at New Bedford. It criticizes the prosecution for lacking direct or circumstantial evidence and for seemingly pursuing conviction regardless of proof.

The Wichita Daily Eagle · 22 June 1893 · page 4

Never, perhaps, has the verdict of a trial jury in a criminal prosecution been inoie heartily and unanimously endorsed 13' the reading public than will be the return of "not guilty"' m tho caso of Lizzie Borden at New Bedford, Mass., Tuesday, Public s'inpathy has been with the accused ever since it became appaiunt that the prosecution gave it out, by acts, that it was bent upon fast ening, the guilt of the terrible crime upon Lizzie Borden, the daughter ol the mur dered man and his wife, whether or no.

See moreSee less

It was a forced put on the part of the state to maintain its action from tho beginning, and tho absence of a tingle pojnt of direct evidence, and of circum Mantial cvideccu of even a probable character, supplemented by tho 1111 naturalness and want of motive, made tho prosecution appear as a crimo against the accused. Tho common opin ion is that a righteous verdict was ren

See the clipping

The Bossier Banner · Bellevue, La.

A short item reports that Lizzie Borden of Fall River, Mass., who had been on trial for the murder of her father and stepmother, has been acquitted. The item is a single sentence amid a miscellany of unrelated news briefs.

The Bossier Banner · 22 June 1893 · page 2

The words of this article could not be separated from the rest of its page. Read it in the clipping.

No clean clipping could be cut from this page

Saint Mary's Beacon · Leonard Town, Md.

The report states that closing arguments in the Lizzie Borden murder trial have concluded, with Knowlton's prosecution speech called effective and Robinson's defense called weak. It notes the case has gone to the jury and that public opinion expects a 'not guilty' verdict.

Saint Mary's Beacon · 22 June 1893 · page 2

Friday, June lb, 1893. The Prince George’s County Fair Association is greatly improving its grounds at Upper Marlboro’. The contest has begun fn Mont gomery between the independents and regulars in advance of the democratic primaries. Albert Spadds is in jail at Ches tertown, charged with shooting his father-in-law, James Lewis, wound ing him slightly. Capt. J. Frank Cooper, of the pungy James V. Daiger, of Cris lield. was killed at Deal’s Island aud the body thrown overboard. The State rested and the defense began offering testimony in the trial of Miss Lizzie Borden for the mur der of her father arid stepmother

See the clipping

The Republican · Oakland, Md.

This editorial applauds the swift acquittal of Lizzie Borden by the New Bedford jury, calling the case one of the most extraordinary in criminal history. It criticizes the prosecution's evidence as weak and theory-driven, accusing the Fall River police of building a case on suspicion and conjecture rather than solid proof.

The Republican · 22 June 1893 · page 4

Lizzie Borden Acquitted.

Mass., Tuesday, will receive the heartv indorsement of all who have followed the testimony in a case which in every respect is one of the most extraordinary known tQ crimi nal history. No jury composed of men entitled to be at large could possibly have convicted her on the evidence presented at the trial with out bring false to their oaths and to their intellects. The case made out by the State was not strong enough to hang a dog on. and the wonder is, not that she was ac quitted, but that she should have been subjected to a long imprison ment and a bitter prosecution on the testimony produced before the jury.

See moreSee less

The case was largely a police case from the beginning to the end, and was built on theories, supposi tions and more or less vague sus picions. Two murders were com mitted for which the police could find no other perpetrator. There fore, it followed, according to de tective logic, that Lizzie Borden

See the clipping

Daily Kennebec Journal · Augusta, Me.

A relative of the Borden family says Lizzie and Emma Borden, along with Bridget Sullivan, plan to sail for Europe once arrangements can be made. The trip is described as the best way to escape unpleasant memories of the past year following the trial.

Daily Kennebec Journal · 22 June 1893 · page 1

GOING ABROAD.

Kali. Kivkr, June SI.— It is stated by a relative of the Borden family that a* soon as Mt«s Lizzie Borden and her sister Kturns can make proper arrangements they, with Bridget Sullivan, will aail for Europe for an extended trip. This is considered the best way to esc a pi’ the unpleasant recollections of the past year.

See the clipping

Daily Kennebec Journal · Augusta, Me.

This editorial piece criticizes Fall River citizens who hastily condemned Lizzie Borden before her trial and now struggle to reconcile their judgments with the court's not-guilty verdict. It also references her reward offer for finding the real killer, expressing hope she will now pursue justice.

Daily Kennebec Journal · 22 June 1893 · page 2

Borden and exceedingly free in eipressin their opinions, are finding it decidedly diffl cult to square themselves with the vcfdi* Of the court It is never safe to condem a person until the evidence is all in. When Lizzie Borden joined her sist*

See the clipping

The Somerset Reporter · Skowhegan, Me.

The trial of Lizzie Borden for murder concluded Tuesday afternoon with a prompt acquittal by the jury after about an hour of deliberation. Closing arguments from Governor Robinson and the District Attorney preceded Justice Dewey's charge to the jury, and the verdict of 'not guilty' was met with public satisfaction.

The Somerset Reporter · 22 June 1893 · page 1

ENTERED as SECOND CLASS MAIL MATTER. Not Guilty. The trial of Lizzie Borden of Fall giver. Mas?., for murder came to an end Tuesday afternoon and resulted in

See the clipping

The Somerset Reporter · Skowhegan, Me.

The jury delivers a verdict of not guilty in the Lizzie Borden murder trial at New Bedford, which the report frames as a full vindication of her innocence rather than mere acquittal. The passage also recaps trial proceedings including testimony about prussic acid purchase, a dressmaker's account of Lizzie's remarks about her stepmother, Officer Medley's testimony about footprints, and closing arguments by defense lawyer Jennings.

The Somerset Reporter · 22 June 1893 · page 1

LIZZIE NOT GUILTY.

Lizzie's Turn. Xkxv Bf.I'K »tii•. Mas-., June *.•'■—F--r an hour Laxvyer .Jennings ple.eh-d Lizzie Borden’s case yesterday and she had her second good cry before the public Wit nesses for the defense xvere hurried along with his or her little story A pedlar snxv a woman coming from the barn on the fatal morning. Two boys testified t* l>eing in the barn loft la-fore the arrival of Officer Medley, who sxvore that he failed i find footprints in the dust. The Defense Iti'ils

See the clipping

The Somerset Reporter · Skowhegan, Me.

This report covers the final days of Lizzie Borden's trial, including defense witnesses, closing arguments by Jennings, Robinson, and Prosecutor Knowlton, and testimony disputing Matron Reagan's 'you gave me away' story. The passage ends with the court's verdict: Lizzie Borden is discharged and acquitted.

The Somerset Reporter · 22 June 1893 · page 1

MISS LIZZIE BORDEN.

The Defense Iti'ils Xf.xv Hi dkord, Mass . June 17 -All tht evidence is now la-fore the jury in the Borden case. Matron Bengali's you have given me away story" xvas totally demol ished by several xvitms*e>. Mi— Bi.s-ed said she told of the paint-grimed dm-'i— oqly wiien begged to by the Borden -de ters. Arguments will In* made Monday.

See the clipping

The Portland Daily Press · Portland, Me.

Following Lizzie Borden's acquittal, she and sister Emma returned to their Second Street home, with a relative suggesting the pair plus servant Bridget Sullivan may travel to Europe. The town remains divided on the verdict, and police appear dejected, showing no enthusiasm for pursuing further suspects.

The Portland Daily Press · 22 June 1893 · page 1

Fall Eiveb, Mass., June 21.—It is stated by a relative of the Borden family that as soon as Miss Lizzie Borden and her sister Emma, can make proper ar

See the clipping

The Sauk Centre Herald · Sauk Centre, Minn.

A brief item notes that Lizzie Borden's brother once lived on a farm at Fairy Lake in the town of Kandota, purchased by their father, the man later murdered in Fall River. The note situates the famous case within local Minnesota history.

The Sauk Centre Herald · 22 June 1893 · page 3

—The brother of Lizzie Borden, the de fendant in the famous Fall River murder trial, was formerly aresident of the town of Kandota, living on a farm at Fairy Lake for some time. The murdered father purchased a farm there, upon which his son lived, some fifteen years ago. —Roadmaster P. J. Clarity has just completed an immense fill at Mora on the Hinckley branch. A tressle there has been removed and a fill of 133 rods has been made. It has an average height of 36 feet. This plan is being adopted all along the Hinckley branch and a solid roadbed is being constructed.

See the clipping

The Sauk Centre Herald · Sauk Centre, Minn.

A short item reports that Lizzie Borden, charged with murdering her father and stepmother in Fall River, Mass., has been acquitted. The jury deliberated for an hour and a half before returning a not guilty verdict, which the report says met with general approval.

The Sauk Centre Herald · 22 June 1893 · page 3

T. D. Davidson, has been in the city dur ing the past week, on business connected with the Central Minnesota Roller Mill. Mr. and Mrs. Nash of Hudson, Wis., have been visiting friends in this vicinity during the past week. Mrs. Nash is a daughter of Rev. M. H. Smith, who formerly lived on a farm just north of the city. Mrs. Frank Dewey, accompanied by by her husband’s sister, Miss Clara Dewey, arrive 1 in the city on Friday from Syracuse, N. Y., and are the guests of Mrs. Dewey’s parents, S.

See moreSee less

Pendergast and wife. Sam Lowenstein, the genial cigar manufacturer, and political hustler of St. Paul, was in the city on business on Saturday. He sold several fine bills of goods, and he will make this city one of his regular visiting places in the future. Lizzie Borden, the woman charged with the murder of her father and step mother, at Fall River, Mass., has been acquitted. The jury was absentanhour and a half and returned a verdict of not guilty. The verdict meets with general approval.

See the clipping

The Prison Mirror · Stillwater, Minn.

Among a miscellany of national and international news briefs, this digest reports that on June 20 the jury found Lizzie Borden guiltless. The item is a compressed weekly news summary covering many unrelated stories, with the Borden verdict given only a single line.

The Prison Mirror · 22 June 1893 · page 2

NEWS OF A WEEK

Ashland, Wis. President Cleveland will take a course of treat ment to cure his obesity. A special ambassador arrives from China to feel the public pulse on the Exclusion act. The yacht Onawa designed and built by Arthur Dyer of Minetonka shown to be a marvel of speed. June 20. The jury found Lizzie Borden guiltless. A New York railroad kills nine and wounds one hundred. June wheat struck OP4 cents in Chicago—the lowest price on record. The Pope holds that to send a child to a secu lar school is not an offense against religion.

See moreSee less

Ten customs inspectors in the Puget Sound district lose their places for conniving at frauds* Col. Ainsworth, Supt. Covert, Sasse the engi neer, and Dant the contractor found guilty by the coroner’s jury inquiring into the Ford thea tre disaster have been bound over to the crimi nal court.

See the clipping

Mexico Weekly Ledger · Mexico, Mo.

A short item reports that the jury in New Bedford, Massachusetts, deliberated for one hour and twenty minutes before finding Lizzie Borden not guilty of murdering her father and stepmother. It appears as one of several unrelated short news briefs under a general roundup headline.

Mexico Weekly Ledger · 22 June 1893 · page 2

The jury at New Bedford, Mass after being out an hour and 20 min utes, found Lizzie Borden not guilty of the murder of her father and stepmother. Samuel A. Wilson, the lone train robber, will be taken to Union for trial the latter part of the week. He is now arranging to put his photo graph on the market. Colonel Ains worth and the others included in the Coroner's jury's verdict of responsibility for the Ford Theater disaster at Washington ap peared in court voluntarily and gave $10,000 bond for their appearance in court.

See the clipping

The Butler Weekly Times · Butler, Mo.

Lizzie Borden, tried for the murder of her father and stepmother in Bedford, Mass., was acquitted after the jury deliberated for only an hour and a half. The report notes the state's case was weak and that police witnesses seemed eager to fix guilt on her, with the verdict met by approval.

The Butler Weekly Times · 22 June 1893 · page 4

Lizzie Borden, the young lady tried for ner life at Bedford Mass., for the murder of her father and step mother, was acquitted. The case was given to the jury Tuesday

See the clipping

Omaha Daily Bee · Omaha, Neb.

In a column of local anecdotes, a citizen reminisces about Lizzie Borden's murdered father as a respected neighbor, then confuses him with a different man—an absconding ticket agent named Andy Borden—calling him Lizzie's first cousin. The item appears amid unrelated local news items like fires, runaway horses, and petty theft arrests.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

Omaha Daily Bee · 22 June 1893 · page 2

In spoakitK of the verdict in the Lizzie Borden murder case last c\cning n well known citizen slid : " 1 ll\cd as neighbor to Ciptaln Bordcn tor i oars and ho was ono of Iho best nnd most lespeotcd citizens of the

See the clipping

Omaha Daily Bee · Omaha, Neb.

A gossip and trivia column makes a brief, exaggerated claim that six people died violent deaths at the Borden home. It also notes that Lizzie Borden's lead counsel, ex-Governor Robinson, was being floated as a presidential candidate.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

Omaha Daily Bee · 22 June 1893 · page 4

PEOPLE AND THINGS

I'KOVLK .t.W ) TJIISUS. Dana Cleveland is the name of a man in Coldwater , Mich. The Borden homestead is a hunian slaugh ter house , blx persons mot violent deaths there. Ex-Governor Hobmson , chief counsel for Lizzie Borden , mignt proporlv pray to be saved from his political friends. They are boomir.ir him for the presidency. A Philadelphia burglar hold 100 armed men at bay for ton hours at Chester , Pa. And yet the envious assert that Quaker citizens are too humble to resent the bill of a Jersey mosquito.

See moreSee less

Thomas Edison ventures the opinion that Chicago is destined to bo the London of America nnd New York will bo its Liverpool. The General Electric company has a few favors to ask of Chicago Mr. Bailey of Texas will glvo way to Mr. Settle of North Carolina ns the youngest member of congress when the statesmen tackle the Sherman bill next September. Mr. Settle is 23 years old. Miss Sallie Pierson , n compositor , has been appointed state organizer of the Fed eration of Labor for Indiana. She has sup ported herself and mother by typesetting since she was 10 yo.irs of ago. It is not generally known that a brother survives Edwin Booth , Ho is Dr. Joseph A. Booth , who was bom in Baltimore and studied mcdlclno nt tlio South Carolina Med ical college at Charleston. Ho is at present practicing his profession nnd lecturing on surgery in Now York. Mount Auburn , the cemetery whcro Edwin Booth is bjuriod , is celebrated for its beauty. It is in Old Cambridge , about one milo from Harvard college , und half that distance from the residence of the late poet , Longfel low. Edwin Booth'n brother , Junius Brutus , Charles Sunnier , the late Vlco President Henry Wilson , Husjoll Lowell , and many other famous dead , sleep there. Edward M. Field , the degenerate son o ! Cyrus Field , who ruined his father and hastened his demise , was sent to the asyluir at Buffalo to await determination whothoi ho was insane or merely shamming. Ho has boon as a quasi Inmate of the institution foi nearly , a year , nnd the reports show that In is not confined ut all , but allowed to roan about the streets of UufTalo without ttu formality of an attendant ovon. JUIK'WFVI , O rKttIUttiH. Washington Star : You may think thai tin youiiK man who Is dellvurlni ; the valodlutorj looks ratluirplousedand proud ; bulyououxli tO bee lllS mother. I'uck : "Did you MID that shocking straw hai Do Mips In wearing" "Yes ; another I'anaina scandal. " Philadelphia Uocord : "No , Maud , dear , i resident of 1'nrls Is notu parasite. " - Blftlnss : Here today and Kdnn tomorrowthu nmu who borrowed u llvu-dollar bill froi you , 1'hlladolphla Times ; There Is u Mowers. Hence , perhaps , thu way tlio blow ubout June , Detroit Krco Press ; The tlmo Is at han when the vonotiirlaii must coininuno with hi Inner elf as to how ho stands on the cucuni bur question. lluffulo Courier : Perhaps BOIIHI expert I n color etroutH can uxiilaln how It U that a ma often looks bluent wlion bo Is In u brown itud ; n Indianapolis Journal : Ilunury I no Wbataru von thlnkln' about KO hardV

See the clipping

The Beatrice Daily Express · Beatrice, Neb.

The report states that Lizzie Borden's acquittal in the killing of her stepmother and father was not surprising given the trial testimony. It notes the prosecution's theory of hatred-driven murder versus the defense's claim of an unknown intruder, and suggests police fixation on Borden may have obscured the truth.

The Beatrice Daily Express · 22 June 1893 · page 2

The acquittal of Lizzie Borden charged with killing her stepmother and father, is not matter of surprise to people who have followed the testimony adduced at the trial just closed. The prosecution held that the stepmother was killed through hatred and the father was soon after struck down to prevent discovery of the crime. The defense held that the murders were committed by some secret enemy who mauuged to escape tiupcrceived. The belief prevails that hut for the deter mination from the first, of the police to fasten the murders upon the daugh ter, the mystery attending (he crimes might have been cleared up long ago. The state military hoard met Iasi week and decided that the state here after will not pay for horses ami forage

See the clipping

Paper unidentified

A newspaper commentary piece notes that press coverage of the Borden trial commended the court's conduct, highlighting that the proceedings were free of sensationalism and that the judge was dignified and impartial. The piece suggests this trial should serve as a model for New York courts.

Paper unidentified · 22 June 1893 · page 2

The press in its comments on the Borden trial pays a merited compli ment to the court on the conduct of the case. So far as the trial was con cerned, it was devoid of sensational features and the lawyers treated each other with courtesy, and the judge was dignified, fair and impar tial. The conduct of the case is commended to the attention of the New York courts as one worthy of being studied as an example to be followed. This part of the moral vineyard was visited by an earthquake Tues day night.

See moreSee less

It was noticed at New Berne, at Charlotte and at Raleigh. But it was an infantile amusement on the part of Dame Nature, tftid did not shock anyone. It was more pronounced, however, at Savannah and Charleston, being accompanied by a rumbling noise, and shaking houses there.

See the clipping

Paper unidentified

The New York Herald explains the legal reasoning behind Lizzie Borden's defense team choosing not to put her on the stand. It notes that an accused person has the right to decline testifying, and neither prosecution nor jury may hold this against them.

Paper unidentified · 22 June 1893 · page 2

Why Lizzie Borden Did Not Testify. New York Herald. The failure of the defence to put Lizzie Borden on the stand has given rise to no little speculation. But it will not surprise any lawyer versed in criminal procedure. Every accused person has the right to testify in his own behalf or not as he chooses. If he does not see fit to do so the prosecution is not permitted to comment on the fact nor the jury to draw any unfa vorable inference from it. While the prosecution cannot call the prisoner as a witness, it may cross-examine him if put on the

See the clipping

Paper unidentified

The report discusses legal strategy, noting that cross-examination often deters defense counsel from putting their client on the stand, especially in circumstantial murder cases. It argues Lizzie Borden would not help her case and might seriously damage it by testifying.

Paper unidentified · 22 June 1893 · page 2

The words of this article could not be separated from the rest of its page. Read it in the clipping.

No clean clipping could be cut from this page

The Western Sentinel · Winston-Salem, N.C.

A miscellany column notes that readers following the Lizzie Borden murder trial in Fall River might also enjoy the novel 'The Leavenworth Case' by Anna Katherine Green. The mention is brief, grouped among unrelated local and national items.

The Western Sentinel · 22 June 1893 · page 2

Interior Department. Those who have read the trial of Lizzie Borden charged, with the murder of her father and step-mother at Fall River, Mass., would become interested in that remarkably clever novel, "The Leavenworth Case," by

See the clipping

The Caucasian · Clinton, N.C.

The report states that Lizzie Borden, who was on trial for her life for murdering her father and stepmother, has been acquitted. It suggests there was little evidence, even circumstantial, against her, and implies she was prosecuted mainly because police had no other suspect.

The Caucasian · 22 June 1893 · page 3

Lizzie Borden who has been on trial for her life in Massachusetts, charged with the crime of murdering her father and stepmother, has been acquited. There seems to haye been but little evidence, even cir cumstantial, that she committed the ."vviiureuuatm;; mat sne was prosecuted because the" police could find no clue pointing to any one else. So long as the Democrats will not use their chance to redeem their pledges, it may be said of Sanctimo nious Joe, the "Honest Joe" Daniels of other days, occupying a fat office in Washington) "Daniels in tne lyin's den, but not hurt by the Iyin's."

See the clipping

The State Chronicle · Raleigh, N.C.

The report explains that a defendant has the right to testify or not, and that the defense's failure to put Lizzie Borden on the stand should not be seen as the prosecution could not comment on it nor the jury draw unfavorable inference. It frames this as an unsurprising legal strategy familiar to any lawyer.

The State Chronicle · 22 June 1893 · page 2

T. Why Lizzie Borden Did Not Testify. cross-examination even an innocent accused person. It has been said with no little force that Dr. Bu chanan convicted himself by ap

See the clipping

The State Chronicle · Raleigh, N.C.

The piece argues that cross-examination can damage even an innocent accused person, citing Dr. Buchanan's self-damaging testimony. It concludes Lizzie Borden could not have helped her case by taking the stand and likely would have hurt it.

The State Chronicle · 22 June 1893 · page 2

Why Lizzie Borden Did Not Testify. cross-examination even an innocent accused person. It has been said with no little force that Dr. Bu chanan convicted himself by ap pearing as a witness in his own be half on his recent trial in this city. Lizzie Borden could not have helped her case by taking the stand. The chances are that she would have damaged it very seriously.

See the clipping

The Monmouth Inquirer · Freehold, N.J.

The report describes Lizzie Borden's acquittal and return to her Fall River home, noting the surprise reaction of the public and crowds gathering outside the Borden homestead. It details the scene of Bridget Sullivan preparing the house for Lizzie's homecoming amid heavy police presence.

The Monmouth Inquirer · 22 June 1893 · page 8

MISS BORDEN IS FREE. SHE IS AT HER OLD HOME SURROUNDED BY HER FRIENDS.

Eren her warmest friends and most ardent ^ft^orters dared not hope anythingjbetter <Kfln a disagreement after reading the dis ict attorney’s forcible argument in be llf of the government. When it was •shed over the wires that the prisoner id been acquitted, the greatest excite §nt prevailed. Upon the streets the sole ipic of conversation was the unlooked for ^charge of Lizzie Borden. It had been stated that Lizzie would ride •dyer from New Bedford in a carriage, and the hour of coming was uncertain, a CTqtfd of morbid, curious ones assembled

See the clipping

The Monmouth Inquirer · Freehold, N.J.

After news of Lizzie Borden's acquittal spread, crowds gathered at the Borden homestead awaiting her arrival, but she instead went to Charles J. Holmes' residence. A reporter interviewed her there, where she expressed happiness and declined to discuss the trial, while a huge crowd lingered at her home into the night.

The Monmouth Inquirer · 22 June 1893 · page 8

, Jpside the house a light was brightly ■ ■buttling in the kitchen, where Bridget Sulj who, it is said, has resumed her rattler position, was preparing tor the j coping of Lizzie and her friends. While j tJjS crowd was surging about the home- ■ |tead on Second street a carriage stopped at the residence of Charles J. Holmes, 67 Bias street. The first one to alight from &was Mr. Holmes, and he was followed j ny Lizzie Borden. Then came Emma and ; Miss Annie Holmes. Lizzie did not wait for Mr. Holmes’ escort, but bounded up the ;

See the clipping

The Monmouth Inquirer · Freehold, N.J.

The report describes Lizzie Borden's joyful reaction and plans following her acquittal, including crowds gathering at the Borden homestead and her statement of happiness. It also recounts the closing scene of the trial, including her sole courtroom statement and the judge's dismissal of the jury.

The Monmouth Inquirer · 22 June 1893 · page 8

Miss Borden Is Happy. Lizzie said: “I am the happiest woman the world.” She did not care to dwell j Upon the subject of the trial and said that the whole party had agreed not to discuss that subject. She said that she would probably spend the night at Mr. Holmes’ j •house. She intended to go home, but her friends advised her not to, on account of j the great number of people who were as- \ Bdmbled there. Lizzie is looking better than ever before, j Shfe was dressed in a black silk dress and was smiling pleasantly while convers ing; with everybody.

See moreSee less

She said she had a pleasant journey from New Bedford, being oft the road a little over an hour. Mr. Holmes’ house was thrown open, and many visitors were received, but few were al lowed to talk with Lizzie, i At the Borden homestead the crowd kept increasing until there were over 2,000 peo ple there. A traveling band stopped in front of the house and played “Auld Lang Syne,” creating the greatest excitement. At midnight there was still a fair gather ing. No plans have been made for the future, but it is very probable that Miss Borden ■will remain in Fall River, although it has been said that she intended to go abroad. Andrew J. Jennings, counsel for the de fense, was too happy and too much occu pied to be interviewed. He says the case •cathe out just as he expected; that the jury Auld not do otherwise. The police officials refuse to talk.

See the clipping

Gloucester County Democrat · Woodbury, N.J.

After District Attorney Knowlton's closing argument accusing Lizzie Borden of killing her stepmother to hide the motive for murdering her father, and Justice Dewey's charge to the jury, the jury deliberated briefly and returned a verdict of not guilty. The courtroom erupted in applause, and Borden broke down in tears as the district attorney moved to drop remaining charges against her.

Gloucester County Democrat · 22 June 1893 · page 2

EMOTIONAL SCENES IN COURT

LTZZIE BORDEN. der became necessary in order to hide the slaying of her stepmother. Mr. Knowlton | concluded with a critical review of the evidence. After a recess the defendant was given an opportunity to speak. She said: “I am innocent, but I will leave my case in your hands and with my counsel.” Justice Dewey, in charging the jury, g'atefi the presumption, which was in creased by the defendant’s character, and said that guilt must be proved to a moral certainty to warrant a conviction. The justice concluded his charge to the jury at 3:15, and they at once retired, while a breathless silence fell over the crowded court room, which was unbroken until the return of the twelve men who held Lizzie Borden’t life in their hands.

See moreSee less

The jurors tiled iuto their seats at 4:30, and were polled. Miss Borden was asked to stand up, and the foreman was asked to return the verdict, upon which he an nounced “not guilty.” After the verdict had been received the district attorney moved that the other cases against Miss Borden be nolle prossed, and the order of the court was to that ef fect. Justice Mason then gracefully thanked the jurors in appreciation of their work and faithful service. The jury was then dis missed and court was adjourned until Monday next, when the regular criminal session will be opened. Miss Borden’s head went down upon the rail iu front of her and tears oame where

See the clipping

Gloucester County Democrat · Woodbury, N.J.

The report describes the dramatic scene when the jury returned a verdict of not guilty, prompting a sustained cheer from spectators that the sheriff could not control. Afterward, Borden was allowed to compose herself privately before being driven to a train bound for Fall River.

Gloucester County Democrat · 22 June 1893 · page 2

When the spectators had finally gone Miss Borden was taken to the room of the justices and allowed to recover her com posure with only the eyes of friends upon her and the caresses of detoted admirers. At the expiration of an hour she was placed in a carriage and driven to the sta tion, where she took a tr^n for Fall River, her home no longer probably, but still the only objective point for the immediate present._

See the clipping

Paper unidentified

The report describes a New York Recorder scheme to empanel twelve prominent citizens as an unofficial jury to render their own verdict on the Borden case, independent of the court. It then notes that press dispatches confirm the legal jury has acquitted Lizzie Borden, with the private jury's verdict still awaited.

Paper unidentified · 22 June 1893 · page 1

The Borden trial, in the attempt to solve a great murder mystery is attracting wide-spread interest. As a great many people form their opinions regardless of the finding of the jury Selected, the New York Recorder has instituted a novel proceeding. They have selected a jury of twelve prominent citi zensmany of whose names are household words all over the coun try who will consider the Borden case as individuals. A stenograph ic copy of all the proceedings will be furnished each distinguished juror, who gives his verdict on the case. The plan is an interesting one, and, though it will not neces sarily demonstrate the guilt or in nocence of Lizzie Borden, yet the

See the clipping

Santa Fe Daily New Mexican · Santa Fe, N.M.

A sarcastic editorial comment notes that Lizzie Borden has been acquitted, as most people outside the New Bedford police expected. It predicts Massachusetts will now settle into complacency, clipping stock coupons and worshipping her as a heroine.

Santa Fe Daily New Mexican · 22 June 1893 · page 2

West. THURSDAY, JTJSE 22. Eyiby day the eastern banks fail and the west stands firm. Gold is beginning to f el 11 western attraction. What will the effete east do nowf Thb German war appropriations will pRsa tho roichstag. What is the matter with the young war lord of Germany at tending some of the World's fair con gresses? He woold learn something. Now that Lizzie Borden is acquitted, as everybody outsido of the New Bed ford police thought she would be, Massa chusetts will probably settle down to a long season of clipping coupons from western stocks and woislupping the fair heroine of this tragio affair.

See the clipping

The Stark County Democrat · Canton, Ohio

The jury returns a verdict of 'Not guilty' for Lizzie Borden, prompting spectators to cheer loudly and wave handkerchiefs despite courtroom decorum. The sheriff is too overcome with emotion to restore order, and Borden breaks down in tears as her lawyers react with relief and gratitude.

The Stark County Democrat · 22 June 1893 · page 1

SPECTATORS GO WILD.

MISS LIZZIK BORDEN. tup which might hnvo boen heard half a " mile away through tlve opon windows, tond thoro was uo attempt mado ta check it.

See the clipping

The Stark County Democrat · Canton, Ohio

The report describes the emotional reaction in the courtroom as the verdict of 'not guilty' is read, with Lizzie Borden breaking down in tears and her lawyers overcome with emotion. Afterward, she is taken to recover privately before being escorted to a train bound for Fall River, while remaining cases against her are dropped.

The Stark County Democrat · 22 June 1893 · page 1

moved that tho other cases against Miss Borden be nolle prossod, and tho ordor of tho court was to that effect. A Kutlonal GunrlnmnJn Trnulilo. HAnmsBuna, Juno 21. Captain John D. Badger, lato commander of company

See the clipping

Democratic Northwest · Napoleon, Ohio

A newspaper miscellany/joke column makes a quip contrasting the hatchet's role in the Lizzie Borden case with an old anecdote, amid other political one-liners. It is not a news report but a humorous aside referencing the ongoing case.

Democratic Northwest · 22 June 1893 · page 2

Therb is a very h avy grovAh of moss all over the Ohio Republican f platform. ' Uncus 8am is going to buy Miss Columbia a new bow-wow, and it's to beeither silver or cold. Which shall it be? ' ; The batchet dosen't stand for the same thing In the Lizzie Borden case

See the clipping

The Evening Herald · Shenandoah, Pa.

The item lists notable happenings on the year's longest and hottest day, including Lizzie Borden's acquittal of murder charges. It also mentions an earthquake in Georgia and deaths from heat and a railroad accident.

The Evening Herald · 22 June 1893 · page 2

Wednesday was tho longest day of tho year, as it was the hottest, and the hottest Juno day for twenty-two years; Lizzie Borden was acquitted of

See the clipping

The Evening Herald · Shenandoah, Pa.

The writer argues that Lizzie Borden's acquittal was a foregone conclusion given the lack of direct or circumstantial evidence connecting her to the murders of her father and stepmother. The piece criticizes the open hostility and spiteful animus shown by witnesses and police toward Borden, calling her wrongfully accused.

The Evening Herald · 22 June 1893 · page 2

To all who have anything like a proper conception of what convincing evidence In a murder trial is, the ac quittal of Lizzie Borden was a fore gone conclusion. Apart from the hor rible unnaturalness of the crime charged against her, the absolute Im possibility that a women could, In broad daylight, in a house on a public street, with a servant in the house, murder in the most cruel manner two persons and they her father and step mother and there was no discovery on her clothing or eloewhmt the slightest evidence of her having com milted the dreadfnl deed, there watno evidence of either a direct or cir cumstantial 'character that oould possibly connect her with tho foul

See the clipping

Freeland Tribune · Freeland, Pa.

A roundup of the week's news briefly reports that the Borden murder trial continued in New Bedford with prosecution evidence, and notes the prosecution rested on Friday, June 16. The item is surrounded by many unrelated national and international news briefs from the same week.

Freeland Tribune · 22 June 1893 · page 4

NEWS OF TIIE WEEK. Thurtnlay, June 15. The Borden murder trial went on at New Bedford, evidence for the prosecution being continued Ex-President Harrison was among the visitors at the World's fair

See the clipping

Pawtucket Tribune · Pawtucket, R.I.

The report describes editorial reactions nationwide to Lizzie Borden's acquittal, noting a shift in public opinion compared to a year earlier. It also mentions plans for Lizzie and her sister Emma, along with Bridget Sullivan, to travel to Europe, and describes well-wishers greeting her at the Borden home.

Pawtucket Tribune · 22 June 1893 · page 1

VOICE OF THE PRESS Concerning the Verdict in the Borden Case.

Faru River, Mass, June 22 It is stated by a velative of the Borden family that a 8 soon as Miss Lizzie Borden and her sister, Kima, can make proper ar rangements they, with Bridget Suallivan, will sail for Europe for an extended trip. This is cousidered the better way to escape unpleasant recollections of the past year, The first day of Mise Lizzie Borden's new life was filled to the brim with con gratulations. They began early in the morning when the sisters returned to the old home on Second street and lasted until bedtime, keeping Harriet, Bridget Sulli van’s successor, on & constant trot to the front door, Thedoors were tightly locked, and Harriet opened them only just anough to serve as a sort of inside guard, so that

See the clipping

Pawtucket Tribune · Pawtucket, R.I.

The report collects editorial comments from various Boston papers reacting to Lizzie Borden's acquittal, showing a shift in public opinion compared to a year earlier. Most editorials express approval of the verdict while noting the murder remains unsolved.

Pawtucket Tribune · 22 June 1893 · page 1

THE GENERAL SENTIMENT.

The first day of Mise Lizzie Borden's new life was filled to the brim with con gratulations. They began early in the morning when the sisters returned to the old home on Second street and lasted until bedtime, keeping Harriet, Bridget Sulli van’s successor, on & constant trot to the front door, Thedoors were tightly locked, and Harriet opened them only just anough to serve as a sort of inside guard, so that l.l‘)“t:nltfi friends might pass the counterEditorial eomm-nts, as showing the trend of pubiic opinion {n the final out come of the trial of Lizzie Borden, prove instructive and interesting reading.

See moreSee less

They form a marked contrast to the positions held by mauy of these same papers 10 or 12 months ago. b Boston Opinions, The verdict of the jury saves from deadly peril and vindicates from ecruel suspicion a true, modest and upright woman., The justness of the verdict will be approved by the almost unbroken sentiment of the community.—Journal, The verdict of acquittal which was given yesterday by the “‘twelve good men and true” at New Bedford will find, from that larger jury, the public, general acquies cence and approval. —Globe, People—and there are a good many of them—who have believed from the first that Lizzle Borden was not clear of grave suspicion have been compelled to recog nize that the evidence as brought out at the trial fell far short of fixing the crime upon her.—Herald, The verdictof *‘not guilty’’ was generally and with ample reason expected. Kven before the trial began it was the prevail ing opinion that no econviction was possi ble.—Advertiser. The trial of the case is distinctly honor able to Massachusetts justice. But iu the preliminaries of the trial it has been far different. From the very beginning, to the time when Lizzie Borden was brought before the court and the jury, the course of the officers of the law has been that of persecution rather than of justice, —Post. The verdict can surprise only those who had expected®disagreement of the jur;. Without regard to the justice of the verdict, this case bids fair to be celebrated in tne criminal annals of the United States, a terrible chapter in the mysteries of murder. The jury find that Miss Borden did not murder her father and her step mother, but they do not say who did the crime, for that is not within their prov ince. To determine w o did the deed shouid be as much a public duty with the authorities as it ever has been, —~Trans script. ST AR AT R Outside the Hub, Lizzie Borden is legally innoeent. A person is presumed to be guiltless until guilt is proved, and in ber case guilt was very far from beiug proved. But this un fortunate woman stands in a terrible posi tion, because so long as the assassin of her father and stepmother remains undis covered and unpunished there will be many people who will still believe her guilty.—Springfield Republican, The speedy verdict of not guilty in the

See the clipping

Pawtucket Tribune · Pawtucket, R.I.

This item compiles editorial reactions from numerous papers—Boston, Springfield, Worcester, Lowell, New York—to the jury's not-guilty verdict in the Borden murder trial. Most express approval of the acquittal based on insufficient evidence, while noting that public suspicion of Lizzie Borden will likely persist regardless of the legal outcome.

Pawtucket Tribune · 22 June 1893 · page 1

THE GENERAL SENTIMENT.

The first day of Mise Lizzie Borden's new life was filled to the brim with con gratulations. They began early in the morning when the sisters returned to the old home on Second street and lasted until bedtime, keeping Harriet, Bridget Sulli van’s successor, on & constant trot to the front door, Thedoors were tightly locked, and Harriet opened them only just anough to serve as a sort of inside guard, so that l.l‘)“t:nltfi friends might pass the counterEditorial eomm-nts, as showing the trend of pubiic opinion {n the final out come of the trial of Lizzie Borden, prove instructive and interesting reading.

See moreSee less

They form a marked contrast to the positions held by mauy of these same papers 10 or 12 months ago. b Boston Opinions, The verdict of the jury saves from deadly peril and vindicates from ecruel suspicion a true, modest and upright woman., The justness of the verdict will be approved by the almost unbroken sentiment of the community.—Journal, The verdict of acquittal which was given yesterday by the “‘twelve good men and true” at New Bedford will find, from that larger jury, the public, general acquies cence and approval. —Globe, People—and there are a good many of them—who have believed from the first that Lizzle Borden was not clear of grave suspicion have been compelled to recog nize that the evidence as brought out at the trial fell far short of fixing the crime upon her.—Herald, The verdictof *‘not guilty’’ was generally and with ample reason expected. Kven before the trial began it was the prevail ing opinion that no econviction was possi ble.—Advertiser. The trial of the case is distinctly honor able to Massachusetts justice. But iu the preliminaries of the trial it has been far different. From the very beginning, to the time when Lizzie Borden was brought before the court and the jury, the course of the officers of the law has been that of persecution rather than of justice, —Post. The verdict can surprise only those who had expected®disagreement of the jur;. Without regard to the justice of the verdict, this case bids fair to be celebrated in tne criminal annals of the United States, a terrible chapter in the mysteries of murder. The jury find that Miss Borden did not murder her father and her step mother, but they do not say who did the crime, for that is not within their prov ince. To determine w o did the deed shouid be as much a public duty with the authorities as it ever has been, —~Trans script. ST AR AT R Outside the Hub, Lizzie Borden is legally innoeent. A person is presumed to be guiltless until guilt is proved, and in ber case guilt was very far from beiug proved. But this un fortunate woman stands in a terrible posi tion, because so long as the assassin of her father and stepmother remains undis covered and unpunished there will be many people who will still believe her guilty.—Springfield Republican, The speedy verdict of not guilty in the Borden case moets popular approval, and no one doubts that from the evidence pre sented justice is done, The male residents of this city consider the verdict insuffcient because it did ot order the entire police force of Fall River to be hanged or im prisoned for lif ». —~Worcester Telegram, There is canss for public congratulation in the verdiet thut acquits Miss Borden of the charge of owrder. It is a salutary circnmstinee that the 12 men, chosen partly b cause they were fathers, to decide her fiste, were all so thoroughly convinced. Her unanimous requittal will not wholly spire Miss Borden from suspicion even now.—Worcester Spy. The verdict of ascquittal of the jury in the Dorden case was not unexpected to those who heve followed the evidence. It is true that there are still very many per sons who believe that ILizzie Borden is guility. Under the circumstances it will be a bard tas < for Lizzie Borden to live down the prejudice there is against her,— Lowell Mail.

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

The article compiles newspaper commentary from across the country reacting to the jury's verdict acquitting Lizzie Borden. Most outlets commend the verdict as expected given the evidence, though some note lingering public suspicion and suggest she should help fund the search for the real killer.

The Providence News · 22 June 1893 · page 3

WHAT NEWSPAPERS SAY.

No criminal trial in this or any other country attracted greater attention than that ¢f Miss Lizzie Borden, and non e re- ‘celvod greater attention from the press of the country. It is of value, there

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

This item collects editorial commentary from various papers (Boston Globe, Newport Herald, New York Herald, Boston Herald, Newport Observer) reacting to Lizzie Borden's acquittal. Most express that while the jury's verdict should be respected as final, public suspicion of her guilt or knowledge of the crime remains widespread, and the case will go down as an unsolved mystery.

The Providence News · 22 June 1893 · page 3

IT IS GENERALLY COMMENDED.

Evidence of Gullt Wanting. The acquittal of Lizzie Borden cannot have been a surprise to the publie, for the tendency of the trial in its later stages was distinetly against a verdict ef guilty. People—and they are a good

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

This item compiles editorial reactions from various newspapers (New York Press, Springfield Union) praising the jury's acquittal of Lizzie Borden and Judge Dewey's conduct of the trial as fair and impartial. The commentary notes the murders remain unsolved and a mystery, though public opinion is largely satisfied that justice was served regarding the only person ever accused of the crime.

The Providence News · 22 June 1893 · page 3

iatitude as was consistent with fairness, Judge Dewey’s charge was a wodel of clearness and impartiality, No man on the Mussachusetts bench has a broader xnnwlodu;o of the law, and he has the splendid faculty of speaking not only as a judge, but as a man, » foculty which a jury never fails to take ncte of. His charge favorad the prisoner (9r the rea son taat the facts favoreld her. The trial is over und the Borden murders remain as much a mystery as ever, but the pub lic is m the main satisfied that justice has been done the ouly person who has ever been accused of thecrime,—Spring field Union, Colonel ¥.

See moreSee less

F, Olney went out to Crans ton and looked the Sockanosset school over yesterday to familarize himself

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

Jury foreman Charles Richards, interviewed at his North Attleboro home, denies reports of discord among jurors and says their relations were harmonious throughout the 16-day trial. He explains the jury took an informal ballot followed by a formal one, concluding the government failed to prove its case against Lizzie Borden.

The Providence News · 22 June 1893 · page 6

NEVER ANY ROW AMONG THE JURY

Case—Bordens Golng to Europe. NorTH ATTLEBORO, Mass.,, June 22. Charles Richapds, foreman of the jury which declared Lizzie Borden to be not guilty of the murder of her father and

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

A juror named Richards describes the jury's quick deliberation process and the dramatic moment Lizzie Borden reacted to the not-guilty verdict. The report also notes that Lizzie and her sister Emma, along with Bridget Sullivan, plan to travel to Europe.

The Providence News · 22 June 1893 · page 6

NEVER ANY ROW AMONG THE JURY

The Bordens to Visit Europe. FaLL River, Mass.,, June 22.-It is stated by a relative of the Borden family that as soon as Miss Lizzie Dorden and her sister Emma, can make proper ar rangements, they, with Bridget Sullivan, will sail for Europe for an extended trip,

See the clipping

Edgefield Advertiser · Edgefield, S.C.

This article, printed as Lizzie Borden's trial begins in New Bedford, recaps the August 4, 1892 murders of Andrew and Abby Borden and lists who was in the house that morning. It details servant Bridget Sullivan's account of Andrew Borden's movements and Lizzie's actions shortly before the bodies were found.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

Edgefield Advertiser · 22 June 1893 · page 1

THOS. J. ADAMS, PROPRIETOR. STRANGE MURDER CASE. Story of the Crime for Which al Yoong: Lady is Now on Trial. The trial of Lizzie Borden for the mnrder of bsr father and step mother, now in progress in New Bedford, Mass., is one of the most remarkable of the age. Mr. Borden and his Wife wer murdered on the morning of Au gust 4.1892, in their house, No. 92 Second street, Fall River. The crime was committed, it is sup posed, between half-past ten and a quarter-past eleven o'clock. There were that morning in the house, which is m the heatt of the city, five persone-Mr.

See moreSee less

Borden and hil wife, Lizzie Borden, the servant, j Bridget Sullivan, and John V. Morse, Lizzie's uncle. Mor?e, who was the guest of the Bordens, left the h*>use early and did not return until after the mur ders were discovered. Emma Bor den, Lizzie's sister, was away on a visit to New Bedford. Thus it is known that at the time the mur der wa* committed there were four persons in the house. Lizzie Bor den and Bridget Sullivan are the only-survivors, the other two hav ing been Mr. Borden and his wife. Bridget. with the crime. bodies.

See the clipping

Edgefield Advertiser · Edgefield, S.C.

This report details Bridget Sullivan's testimony about the morning of the murders, including Mr. Borden's movements, Lizzie's actions, and the discovery of Mrs. Borden's body by Mrs. Churchill and Bridget. It also begins to introduce Lizzie's own conflicting account of her father being ill and lying on the sofa.

Edgefield Advertiser · 22 June 1893 · page 1

THE SERVANT GIRL'S STORY

Hives in Borden street. When Bridget came hack with Mrs. Bus ?ell, Dr. Bowen and Mrs. Churchill were in the house. ?Mrs. Churchill and Bridget went upoftairs to look for Mrs. Borden, who they believed had come in while they were down stairs. On Jthe floor of the bedroom, between the bed and the bureau, they found ?MTS. Borden's body. They rushed dtownsiairs, and Mrs. Churchill told l>r. Bowen. that Mrs. Borden had been murdered. According to Bridgets testi mony, when she went up stairs to lie down Mr. Borden was in the sitting room alive and well..

See moreSee less

Fro m ?fifteen to twenty minutes later, Chatis, at from, five minutes be? fore eleven to fifteen minutes after eleven, he was lying dead, with about a dozen cuts, made by an axe or hatchet, on his head and and face.

See the clipping

Edgefield Advertiser · Edgefield, S.C.

The report describes Lizzie Borden's account of her movements on the morning of the murders, including going to the barn for sinkers and eating pears, before discovering her father's body. It also discusses the near-total absence of blood on her clothing and speculative theories—such as a rubber covering—proposed to explain this discrepancy.

Edgefield Advertiser · 22 June 1893 · page 1

THE ACCUSED GIRL'S STORY

When she got there she found her father murdered and summoned Bridget. The heads and faces of Mr. and Mrs. Borden were so chopped and hacked that they were beaten almost out of human resemblance. If Lizzie is guilty she must have killed her father within tweiity minutes and then appeared before her neighbors without a spot of blood on her clothing and without any sign that she had hastily ad justed her dress/ In that time also she must have concealed so effect ively that it has never been found the bloody weapon with which the deed was committed, and she also disposed of every scrap of direct evidence that would connect her with the crime.

See moreSee less

Lizzie Borden wore a blue dress when the neighbors entered the house and found her father and stepmother murdered. She wore a. blue dress about the house in the morning. In two rooms blood from the murdered ones had spat tered and spurted over everything for many feet around the dead bodies. In the minds of the authorities there never was doubt that the murderer of Mr. and Mrs. Borden was smeared and splashed with blood. With the exception of a single drop of blood the size of a pin head on her white underskirt, not a speck of blood was found on the clothing Lizzie worn before or after the murder.

See the clipping

Turner County Herald · Hurley, S.D.

A brief news item reports that the jury in the Lizzie Borden murder trial at New Bedford, Massachusetts returned a verdict of 'not guilty.' The item is embedded within unrelated local news about a Chicago World's Fair parade and postal service policy.

Turner County Herald · 22 June 1893 · page 4

The words of this article could not be separated from the rest of its page. Read it in the clipping.

No clean clipping could be cut from this page

The Madison Daily Leader · Madison, S.D.

The report describes the New Bedford courtroom scene as the jury returned a verdict of not guilty after deliberating a little over an hour, prompting a loud cheer and visible emotion from both the judge and Lizzie Borden. It also notes that remaining charges against her were dropped at the district attorney's request.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

The Madison Daily Leader · 22 June 1893 · page 2

ml Case-IV alcu Foil!iil Gtiiltv Sentenced. NEW BEDFORD, Mas#.. June 23.—Tha jury in the Borden case, after being out a little ovur an hour, returned a verdict of not guilty. the verdict had been received the district attorney moved that the other nees against Miss Borden be nolle proved, and the order of the court was to that effect. Chief Justice Mason gracefully thanked the jurors in appreciation of their work and faith L'nl service and reminded them that the precs^u'ions taken-with them which may have seemed irrelevant at the time were solely iu the interests of justice, a fact which they undoubtedly realized now.

See moreSee less

The scenes at the close of the trial were in contrast with those that preceeded it. Heretofore everything had lieen decorous and in keeping with the most dignified court in the country. But when the verdict of "not guilty" was returned A Cheer Went Up which might have been heard half a mile away through the open windowe and there was no attempt to check it. The stern judge looked straight ahead at the bare walls. He was pow erless to wield the gavel which lies ready tor his use and not once during the tremendous excitement, which lasted fully a minute, did he make the slightest sign of having heard it. He never saw the people rising in their ser.ts and waving their handkerchiefs in unison with their voices because his eyes were fnll of tears and were com pletely blinded for the time. Miss" Borden heard the verdict stand ing at the bar and tears came where they had not been tor many a day. When the (spectators had finally gone Miss Borden was taken to the room of the justices and allowed to recover her composure. At the expiration of an hour she was placed in a carriage and driven to the station, where she took a train for Fall River. Received an Oration. FALL RIVER. Mass., June 22.—Lizzie Borden received an ovation on Jier ar rival here. She intended to stop at the Boi-den homestead, but on account of the crowd accepted the hosj.itality of Mr. Holme*, whose house was thronged with people eager to congratulate her upon her acquittal. The crowd at the Borden homestead numbered 2,0u0, and remained until after midnight, a band playing "Auld Lang Syne." which created intense excitement. Lizzie says she is' the happiest woQian iu the world.

See the clipping

The Madison Daily Leader · Madison, S.D.

The jury returns a verdict of not guilty, prompting a loud cheer in the courtroom that the judge, moved to tears, does not attempt to silence. Lizzie Borden returns to Fall River to an enthusiastic crowd of supporters celebrating her acquittal.

The Madison Daily Leader · 22 June 1893 · page 2

Miss" Borden heard the verdict stand ing at the bar and tears came where they had not been tor many a day. When the (spectators had finally gone Miss Borden was taken to the room of the justices and allowed to recover her composure. At the expiration of an hour she was placed in a carriage and driven to the station, where she took a train for Fall River. Received an Oration.

See the clipping

Reporter and Farmer · Webster, S.D.

A brief item reports that Lizzie Borden was acquitted of the charge of murdering her father and stepmother at Fall River, Massachusetts. It notes the public watched the trial closely and was relieved by the verdict, given that most evidence was circumstantial.

Reporter and Farmer · 22 June 1893 · page 1

Falls Press. The railroads running throughh Nebraska are curtailing their tram service in retaliation for the hostile legislation in that state last winter. Those who are howling for anti rail road legation in this suite might not relish riding along on mixed trains, or if they do they should take a trip over the Bristol and Madison line. The glamour which enveloped Eulalia on her first arrival in this country is rapidly dissolvingShe turns out to be a rather ordinary woman, with a bad temper and some bad habitsShe 'drew people to the faia, however Tho Chicag oans made her pay.—Mpls Journal.

See moreSee less

Lizzie Borden was acquitted of the charge of murdering her father and stepmother at Fall River,Mass. The public at large has watched the trial with great interest and are relieved by the verdict, as near ly all the evidence was of the cir cumstantial kind.

See the clipping

Herald and Tribune · Jonesborough, Tenn.

The report states that the famous Lizzie Borden murder case has concluded with the acquittal of the accused. It is a short, single-sentence mention embedded within an unrelated local news column.

Herald and Tribune · 22 June 1893 · page 3

The famous Lizzie Borden murdor oase terminated in the acquittal of the accused. When Baby Ml lck, we gave hor 0torla. When ibe wa a Child, he cried for Cantoris.

See the clipping

San Antonio Daily Light · San Antonio, Tex.

This is a general editorial about race relations and the African American experience, defending the race against being blamed collectively for crimes of individuals. It mentions Lizzie Borden only in passing, describing her as currently standing charged with murdering her stepmother and father, used as an example of notable crime news alongside train robberies and London murders.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

San Antonio Daily Light · 22 June 1893 · page 6

The words of this article could not be separated from the rest of its page. Read it in the clipping.

No clean clipping could be cut from this page

The Salt Lake Herald · Salt Lake City, Utah

A brief editorial comment observes that the Lizzie Borden trial only confirmed that two elderly people were brutally killed. It states the proceedings shed no reliable light on who actually committed the murders.

The Salt Lake Herald · 22 June 1893 · page 4

THE NATVAB of Eampur has been to the Yosemite valley and will soon make a over one of the northern railroads He will therefore give Salt Lake the goby THE LIZZIE BORDEN trial developed J only the wellknown fact that two i worthy and aged people were brutally killed but threw absolutely no reliable

See the clipping

Richmond Dispatch · Richmond, Va.

Lizzie Borden and her sister returned to their Second Street home after spending the night at a friend's house, reportedly breaking down upon entering. Andrew Jennings is receiving congratulatory letters, and public sentiment in Fall River has shifted to respect the jury's verdict.

Richmond Dispatch · 22 June 1893 · page 3

MISS BORDEN AT HOME AGAIN

Mr. Charles B. Holmes's residence, on Pine street. They drove up to the gate in a closed carriage, and their entrance was most juintal to witness. There were few spectators, for the crowds of last night knew nothing of the hour when the long-imprisoned girl would return. They denied themselves to all newspaper-men, in accordance with the suggestions of their coun sel. Tue sofa on which Mr. Borden lay when he was murdered is at the Central Police Station and will not be removed for a day or two. Miss Liz zie spent a very ploasant night and was very chesrful at breakiast in the Holmes residence this morning. A domesiic mm the family house on Second street is reported to have sald that

See the clipping

The Valley Virginian · Staunton, Va.

A short item reports that Lizzie Borden, charged with murdering her father and step-mother, was acquitted on Tuesday. It misstates the location of the crime as New Jersey rather than Massachusetts.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

The Valley Virginian · 22 June 1893 · page 2

Richmond from IVarm Springs. The total number of American news papers has grown from 5,319 to 20,000 during the past twenty-live years. The lower Shenandoah Valley is great ly in need of rain, and the corn will not si»viye the drouth many days longer. Lizzie Borden, charged with the mur

See the clipping

The Valley Virginian · Staunton, Va.

A newspaper editorial argues that Lizzie Borden's acquittal was justified because the prosecution failed to prove its case beyond reasonable doubt. It notes that while legal doubt remains about who committed the murders, the trial undermined the theory that Lizzie had exclusive opportunity to do so.

The Valley Virginian · 22 June 1893 · page 3

It was a case full of mystery, and none cf that mystery has been solved by Liz zie Borden’s trial if we except the fact, all important to Lizzie, that it is now no longer generally believed that she had the “exclusive opportunity” to do the killing. Certainly it has been shown that some other person might have sneaked into the house and done it, and that person's daring would have been no greater than the boldness and bad ness attributed to Lizzie. The verdict will be generally approved. It was the right thing and the expected thing.—Richmond Dispatch.

See the clipping

In the story →

The Times · Richmond, Va.

Lizzie Borden and her sister Emma returned to their Second Street home after Lizzie spent the night at a family friend's house following her acquittal. The report notes the town's changed mood of respect for the verdict and the flood of congratulatory letters her lawyer is receiving.

The Times · 22 June 1893 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

LIZZIE BORDEN AT HOME.

With Her Sister Emma, She Returns to the Blighted Hearthstone.

See moreSee less

FALL RIVER, MASS., June 21.—Lizzie Borden returned with her sister this morning to her home on Second street, after having spent the night at Mr. Chas. B. Holmes' residence, on Pine street. They drove up to the gate in a closed carriage, and their entrance was most painful to witness. There were very few spectators, for the crowds of last night knew nothing of the hour when the long imprisoned girl would return. They denied themselves to all newspaper men, in accordance with the suggestions of their counsel. The sofa on which Mr. Borden laid when he was murdered, is at the Central police-station, and will not be removed for a day or two. Miss Lizzie spent a very pleasant night, and was very cheerful at breakfast in the Holmes' residence.

This morning a domestic in the family house, on Second street, is reported to have said that the two girls broke down completely when they had entered their old home. To-day Andrew J. Jennings is receiving letters and telegrams of congratulation from all parts of the country, and Miss Borden's mail at the postoffice is very heavy. The temper of the people of the city has changed greatly by the verdict, and there is a manifest respect for the decision of the jury.

See the clipping

The Times · Richmond, Va.

The piece notes Lizzie Borden was acquitted by the jury after nearly a year in jail, and argues she deserves damages given the prosecution's harsh closing characterization of her as a 'blocdy murderess.' It also includes a dramatized narrative asserting she met her father and stepmother's husband on the stairs and had 'no escape from the crime but to complete the bloody work.'

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

The Times · 22 June 1893 · page 4

tere Home, 1. O. G. T., Soldiers’ ome, St. Patrick's Beneficial and Social So clety, Twenty-sixth and Grace. Stuart Horse Guards, Snyder bullding. Miss Lizzie Bord n certainly should re ceive damages from somebody, Not only | | was she, an innocent person, kept ‘n jail nearly a year without being brought to trial, but the counsel for the State in Fis last fpeech declared that she was a vile and bloody murderess, He said posi tively, and without reservation, that “jt was not Lizzie Andeew Borden who came down those stairs to meet her father, but a murderess transformed from the ties of affection to the most coasun mate cruelty ever known,” * % & % » When she came down stales it was her father she met, but it was also the hus band of the stepmother she had hated.

See moreSee less

There was no escape from the crime but to complete the bloody work. The se cond murder was not planned, but it was done as a wicked and fearful necessity.” Now the jury have said that Lizzie Borden is not guilty, It is generally supposed that the great cowboy race of 700 :niles from Nebraska to Chicago will be attended with cruelty to the horses, but the Chicago Herald says that is not true. That paper states that by the terms of the cowboy race each horse comes all the way through, and must be in good condition at the cuteome. The sum of $800 is offered for the wh ning horse at the end of *h> race. The terms insure good treatm nt of ihe horses, and the msa will be as well off, at least, as the bicyelers who are making races from Springfisld to the capitals of the various surrounding States. General Alger, who is such a good Republican that his nomination for Presi dent was once talked about, declares that there is no foundation for the charge that the present administration is op posed to the pensioning of Federal vete rans, who deserve pensions. The General Pimself is in favor (f purging the p~n elon rolls 80 that they can be mads rolls of honor. And this should be done, and the General is certainly right for once, but the Republican party will never nominate him fer the presidency ro long a8 he holds such views, The Vikings who came to the United States to take part In the Columbian Exposition, were, 4 day or two ago, .lub bed by the police of Brooklyn, aed iock=d Wp In a station-house It appears that they committeq no offences except that of trying to defend themselves from an assault by Brooklyn toughs, It is such conduct as this that makes for:igners return to their homes and represent the

See the clipping

The Times · Richmond, Va.

This opinion piece argues that Lizzie Borden deserves compensation for being jailed nearly a year before trial and then branded a 'vile and bloody murderess' by the prosecution. It notes that despite the prosecutor's graphic closing argument, the jury found her not guilty.

The Times · 22 June 1893 · page 4

Stuart Horse Guards, Snyder bullding. Miss Lizzie Bord n certainly should re ceive damages from somebody, Not only | | was she, an innocent person, kept ‘n jail nearly a year without being brought to trial, but the counsel for the State in Fis last fpeech declared that she was a vile and bloody murderess, He said posi tively, and without reservation, that “jt was not Lizzie Andeew Borden who came down those stairs to meet her father, but a murderess transformed from the ties of affection to the most coasun mate cruelty ever known,” * % & % » When she came down stales it was her father she met, but it was also the hus band of the stepmother she had hated.

See moreSee less

There was no escape from the crime but to complete the bloody work. The se cond murder was not planned, but it was done as a wicked and fearful necessity.” Now the jury have said that Lizzie Borden is not guilty,

See the clipping

Burlington Weekly Free Press · Burlington, Vt.

A one-line news brief reports that expert testimony at the Borden trial in New Bedford, Mass., showed no trace of blood on clothing or hatchets examined. It appears amid a miscellany of unrelated news items from around the country.

Burlington Weekly Free Press · 22 June 1893 · page 7

thu HOttth canal ut Lawrence. .Mass. Tho wife of n Salmon Falls (N. H.) man nnd a man suid to be a mesmerist wero ar rested nt Lowell, Mass. Augustus H. Farmer was probably fatally assaulted at How, N. II., by Jnmes and Albert .Tame ton Steamer Winthrop was burned at Kastport, JIc. A motion was mado for the ilischargo of Dr. Graves Heavy defalcations wero discovered in tho Irving Savings institution, New York city Herbert Heals was htrttck by lightning nt Yarmouth Island, Me., and instantly killed About one-quarter of tho .spin ners who struck at thu tho Everett mills at' Lawrence, Mass., Inst week havo re turned to work Expert testimony at.

See moreSee less

the Borden trial nt New Hedford, Mass., shows no trace of blood on clotlilng or hatchets Evans and Sontng, the Cali fornia outlaws, wero captured after being severely wounded Tho viking ship has arrived at New London, Conn.

See the clipping

Burlington Weekly Free Press · Burlington, Vt.

The report notes that the Lizzie Borden trial in New Bedford is nearly finished, with defense attorney Jennings delivering an hour-long plea for her case. It also mentions a peddler who claimed to have seen a woman leaving the barn on the morning of the murders, supposedly supporting Lizzie's alibi.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

Burlington Weekly Free Press · 22 June 1893 · page 7

tho good roads bill The trial at New Bedford, Mass., of Lizzie Borden is prac tically nt an end, and for au hour yester day Lawyer .lenuius pleaded her case. A Jewish pedlar turned up who said he saw a woman coming from the barn on the fatal morning, thus proving Lizzie's alini The Sons of Veterans nt Nuw Bedford, Mass., elected ollicers yesterday for the en suing year Dr. II. A. Cliaput of Low ell, Mass., was stabbed in live places in his looms at BW Merriinae street, aud is now at St.

See moreSee less

John's hospital under thu iullueuco ut ether. His assailant was arrested. Sntlllduy, .limn 17, Manchester, N, II., celebrated Hunker Hill day A )oung woman bather was drowned at Shelter Heights, L. 1 John Morrough, an aiiti-Pariiellite, is to retiio from parliament Inhuman cruelties havo been practised un thoso suspected of Hiding Brazilian rebels Thomas T.

See the clipping

Burlington Weekly Free Press · Burlington, Vt.

This brief news item reports that all evidence in the Lizzie Borden case has been presented and the case is now being handed to the jury for deliberation. It appears amid a roundup of unrelated national news items.

Burlington Weekly Free Press · 22 June 1893 · page 7

Was nominated justice of tho Lebanon police court Tho Massachusetts build ing was dedicated at the World's fair grounds Evidence in tho Borden caso is all in and it now goes to the jury Hunker Hill day was celebrated on an un usually grand scnlo at Charlostown (Bos ton), although wet weather somewhat In terfered with the pleasures ot the day,

See the clipping

St. Johnsbury Caledonian · St. Johnsbury, Vt.

The jury found Lizzie Borden not guilty after only an hour's deliberation, with the prosecution's case deemed weak and defense attorney Ex-Gov. Robinson praised for his skill. The report notes the murders of Mr. and Mrs. Borden remain unsolved, calling it one of the era's great mysteries.

St. Johnsbury Caledonian · 22 June 1893 · page 4

lizzie borden free. Those who had read the evidence in the Borden trial at New Bedford were not surprised that the jury brought in a verdict of "Not Guilty" after only an hour's deliberation. The government's side of the case proved unexpectedly weak and the powerful arguments of the district attorney had no effect upon the jury. Ex-Gov. Robinson proved a perfect tower of strength as a criminal law yer, and has gained a national rep utation by his conduct of this case. But the great mystery is still un solved. The world has not yet found out who murdered Mr. and Mrs. Borden of Pall River. This double murder bids fair to become one of the greatest mysteries of the period.

See the clipping

St. Johnsbury Caledonian · St. Johnsbury, Vt.

A Boston newspaper is reported to have interviewed people nationwide for their opinions on whether Lizzie Borden is guilty or innocent. The item criticizes this as improper journalism since the jury has not yet rendered its verdict.

St. Johnsbury Caledonian · 22 June 1893 · page 4

A Boston paper has interviewed people in different parts of the coun try to get opinions on the guilt or innocence of Lizzie Borden. This is journalism with a vengeance; and, taking into consideration the fact that the jury has not yet given its opinion, the publication of these in terviews is somewhat outside of the province of legitimate jour

See the clipping

St. Johnsbury Caledonian · St. Johnsbury, Vt.

This item is part of a weekly news round-up listing miscellaneous events from around the world. Among the Friday entries, it briefly notes that all the evidence in the Borden trial had been presented in court.

St. Johnsbury Caledonian · 22 June 1893 · page 8

The returns irom the general elec tions in Germany show a majority against the government. The evi dence in the fa mous Borden trial was

See the clipping

St. Johnsbury Caledonian · St. Johnsbury, Vt.

A roundup of miscellaneous news items from the week includes a brief line stating that Lizzie Borden was acquitted of murder charges at New Bedford, Mass. The item appears amid unrelated stories about fires, drownings, deaths, and accidents nationwide.

St. Johnsbury Caledonian · 22 June 1893 · page 8

Lizzie Borden acquitted of the charge of murder at New Bedlord, Mass. Henniker. N. II., was visited bv a disastrous fire. Robert E. Phillips and Arthur Meade, of the Boston Chamber ot Commerce, were drowned while canoeing. A train on a Long Island road, carrying nearly a thousand persons, was derailed in a tunnel, resulting in the death of several persons and the injury of 100 others. Wednesday. Death of Editor Crane of the Lud low Tribune. Senator Stanford of California died of apoplexy. He was worth probably $100,000,000. in vested in railroads, mines, real es tates, vineyards and horses.

See moreSee less

Xew steamship company formed in New Jersey to control the American line of trans-Atlantic steamers. Dyna mite bomb exploded at midnight in Madrid, Spain at the house of Ex Picmier Castillo. Theatre shattered.

See the clipping

Herald and News · West Randolph, Vt.

The report announces that Lizzie Borden's trial ended in a verdict of "Not Guilty," as expected by those following the evidence. It suggests the Fall River police, having failed to find the real murderer, tried to pin the crime on Borden to protect their reputations.

Herald and News · 22 June 1893 · page 1

"Not Guilty." The trial of Miss Lizzie liorden ended, as all who have followed the evidence believed it would end, in a verdict of "Not Guilty." At thii distance, it looks very much as thcugh the Fall River police, failing completely to discover the real ' mur derer, endeavored to fasten the crime onto Miss Borden to save their rep

See the clipping

Herald and News · West Randolph, Vt.

The piece notes that the Lizzie Borden trial for the murder of her father and stepmother is underway and attracting great public interest due to its unprecedented nature. It observes that the case against her rests entirely on circumstantial evidence, and that good moral character seems powerless against such facts.

Herald and News · 22 June 1893 · page 1

Lizzie Borden for,the murder of her fa ther and stepmother. The case has aroused grea' interest everywhere from its unprecedented character. The whole case against Miss Borden is founded wholly ou circumstantial evi dence. There is nothing to prevent any one of us from having to undergo just such a trial as Miss Borden is now passing through, as good moral charac ter and life seem to have no weight against a sad array ot lacts. They have accused Miss Borden be

See the clipping

The Yakima Herald · North Yakima, Wash.

The report announces that the Borden trial has concluded with a verdict of not guilty, freeing the accused daughter of the murdered parents. It summarizes the defense's arguments, including lack of motive, her respectable upbringing, and the physical improbability that she could have committed the brutal killings.

The Yakima Herald · 22 June 1893 · page 2

Toe celebrated Borden trial is ended and the accused daughter of murdered parents is a free woman with • verdict ol not guilty. The case has been character

See the clipping

Aberdeen Herald · Aberdeen, W.T.

This opinion piece compares the recent acquittal of Lizzie Borden to the ongoing Seattle trial of Ursula Jaunita Unfug, accused of murdering Thomas Henderson Boyd. It argues that Borden, despite weak evidence, received sympathy only because of her respectable life, while Unfug, despite stronger evidence of guilt, is winning undeserved sympathy due to her youth and beauty.

Aberdeen Herald · 22 June 1893 · page 2

# MAUDILIN SENTIMENT. The recent acquittal of Lizzie Borden, charged with murdering her father and stepmother, irresistablv suggests the trial of Ursula Jaunita Unfug, now going on in Seattle, with a difference. The Post-Intelligencer has said of Miss Borden that she is a homely "old maid," who before her acquittal, got no flowers and little sympathy. Miss Borden's pre

See the clipping

Aberdeen Herald · Aberdeen, W.T.

A brief news item reports that Lizzie Borden, tried in New Bedford, Massachusetts for the murder of her father and stepmother, was acquitted. The report notes that no direct evidence was introduced to incriminate her.

Aberdeen Herald · 22 June 1893 · page 3

B. Crammatte and Elizabeth Kelman. Lizzie Borden, who was on trial in New Bedford, Mass., for the murder of her father and step mother was acquitted. No direct evidence was introduced incul pating her. An extensive conspiracy to smuggle opium and Chinese into this country lias been reported to the treasury department from the Sound, and is said to involve many of the ex-federal officials up ttiere. Aberdeen has been crowded this week with ladies from all points in the county, who have made the trip here for the pur pose of attending the big discount sale of

See the clipping

The Manitowoc Pilot · Manitowoc, Wis.

A short news item reports that Lizzie Borden was acquitted by the jury trying her for the murder of her father and stepmother. It notes the evidence was purely circumstantial and that all household members were present with no trace of an intruder found.

The Manitowoc Pilot · 22 June 1893 · page 2

GENERAL NEWS.

Lizzie Borden was acquitted by the jury before whom she was tried for the murder of her father and step-mother. The evidence against her was purely cir cumstantial and that of not a crimina, ting nature. The two murdered peopleLizzie, their daughter, an I the servant lived together. All were in the house when the murders were committed and no traces of any other person could be found sbout the house.

See the clipping

West Virginia Argus · Kingwood, W. Va.

The report briefly mentions that the Borden murder case, tried in New Bedford, Massachusetts, concluded this week with Lizzie Borden's acquittal by the jury. It notes the case remains a mystery despite the verdict.

West Virginia Argus · 22 June 1893 · page 2

Robinson and W. A. PefTer, Jr. The latter is a son of U. S. Senator PefTer, of Kansas, and the paper is to be published in the interest of the Populists of this State. The first number is newsy and well edi ted. The Borden murder case on trial in the Criminal Court at New Bed ford, Mass., has excited a great deal of interest all ovor the country and the papers have been full of it for some time. Tho prisoner, Miss Lizzie Borden, on trial for the

See the clipping

The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · Wheeling, W. Va.

This editorial criticizes prosecutor Knowlton for pursuing conviction despite lacking evidence against Lizzie Borden, arguing his closing speech was dramatic but baseless. It also condemns the state of Massachusetts for holding her ten months in prison without justification, now proven by the acquittal.

The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · 22 June 1893 · page 4

Ton Months ol'Wrong. . Fomosrly ton months tho commonwealth of Massachusetts kopt Lizzie Borden in prison, all tho time looking for evidonce asainst bur and finding none, yot doterminod to convict hor if possiblo without ovldonco. Civilized society should bo clad to mako what amends it can for so great a wrong at this, Tho vordict of tho |ury is formal and ofHcial declaration of tho wrong. For every day and ovory hour of tlioso months Lizzie Borden Is now shown to

See the clipping

Wheeling Register · Wheeling, W. Va.

Despite her acquittal, reports claim a general belief in Fall River holds Lizzie Borden guilty, with some fearing mob violence if she returns home. The article laments her social ostracism and expresses sympathy for her situation.

Wheeling Register · 22 June 1893 · page 4

MIT SATISFIED. Lizzie Borden seem cot to be with out honor save at her own home. In Fall Kiver according to reports there a general belief In her guilt, notwith standing her acquittal and the utter lack of evidence against her. This feeling ruus so high that she has been advised not to retarn there. It is said that seventy-five people out . • a_ a i— n.n Di..». kAliA«tn Oi every uuuumtu iu »- *•“ her guilty and that even mob vio lence is feared should she return. Is this unfortunate woman—acquitted by the law, though not by the Judg ment of her home people and neigh bors—to be still further hounded and worried by the petty though incessant annoyances that accompany social octraclsm until the true murderer of her parents is found?

See moreSee less

If so It is a sad outlook for Lizzie Borden's peace of mind, should she determine to continue her residence at her old home. She is to be sincerely pitied.

See the clipping

The Rawlins Republican · Rawlins, Wyo.

A roundup of national and international news notes that Lizzie Borden's murder trial is in progress at New Bedford, Massachusetts. It adds that the trial is attracting great attention throughout New England.

The Rawlins Republican · 22 June 1893 · page 6

crowd also went in to see her highness. Tbe Spanish caravals, Santa Maria, Nina and Pinta, are now off the southeastern coast of Nova Scotia, between Halifax and Canso. The Republicans of Ohio have re-nominated Major McKinley for governor by acclamation. The Duke of Veragua attended the conven tion. The Swedish government has established on tbe coast nine stations for medical oi>ser vation. The object of this measure is to pro tect the country from cholera. The McCague savings bank and the Amer ican national bank of Omaha have closed their doors.

See moreSee less

The banks are not in very bad condition, but could not stand a run. The Vatican has sent three letters te Car dinal Gibbons, Arjbbisbop Ireland and tbe American archbishops generally, copiously explaining the pope’s scholastic pollq*. Ibe trial of Lizzie Borden for murdering her father and step-mother is In progress at

See the clipping

Fisherman & Farmer · Edenton, N.C. · and 1 other paper

On the fourth day of Lizzie Borden's trial, witnesses including Bridget Sullivan, Dr. Bowen, Mrs. Churchill, and Alice Russell testified, with Sullivan placing Lizzie in the house at the time of the murders while denying any animosity between her and her stepmother. Alice Russell described witnessing Lizzie tearing up and burning a dress days after the murders, testimony that withstood cross-examination by defense attorney Robinson.

CorrectionThis set right 2 earlier articles: Edgefield Advertiser, 22 June 1893, Burlington Weekly Free Press, 22 June 1893.

Fisherman & Farmer · 23 June 1893 · page 3

AT NEW BEDFORD.

?hers' evidence hem concluded, John V. lorse, uncle of the prisoner, took the stand. On cross-examination he swore that on reaching the liorden house after the mur der h saw no officers in th yard : that the barn door was c!osel and he heard no one Inside. Phis contradicted the Government's claims that officers. y immediate exam ination of th barn, ascertained that the pris oner could not have been there at the time of the murder. A. G. Hart. Joseph Short lieve and Jam? Mather, witnesses, called after five minutes' recess fixed the time when Mr.

See moreSee less

Borden was last seen. Crosa-eximina-tion developed nothing but slight confusion and uncertainty as to the exact time. Miss Borden yawned and looked on listlessly. Mr. Moody then called Bridget Sul livan to the stand. Bridget Sulli van was the stronst witness of the day, but while he' testimony placed Liz zie Borden, the accused, in the home at the hour of the murders, the effect of it was weakened by the statement, re iterated with emphasis, that between the accused and her stepmother, there had never been, to witness's knowledge, an un kind word. When the cross-examination of Bridget had been concluded the court ad , iourned. The line of defence was indicated by calling on witnesses to testify that the person who committed the murder misrht nave been concealed in a closet. When the fourth day of Lizzie Borden's trial had ended, from the vajjue and un shapely mass of evidence produced by the prosecution, the finger of accusation seemed to the spectators to point still mors directly at the prisoner. The first witness was Doc tor Bowen. the physician who was sum moned to the Borden residence after the bodies had been discovered. He told the situation of the bodies, and said that apparently nothing had been disturbed in the rooms. On cross-examination he testified that he had prescribed mor phine for Miss Borden to allay nervous excitement. The doses were increased to double strength and had a ten dency to affect the memory. Mrs. Churchill, who lived in part of the Borden house, trstified to occurrences just before the murder. She said that Miss Bor den was so pale and excited aftei the murder as to attract considerable attention. Miss Alice Russell was then called. She described Miss Borden's burning the dress Sunday after the murder. Witness went out and came in again and saw Miss Borden stand ing near the cupboard door and tearing or ripping small portions of the dress. Rob inson's cross-examination failed to shake Miss Russell's direct testimony. On re-direct she testified, against objection by defense, that the cupboard in which witnesssaw a part of tho dress at the time of the burn ing was used only for kitchen utensils. Then there came a string ot officers. Two points were made off George Washington Allen, policeman. One was that a table, un Fpattered with blood, was foxind within three feet of the front of the sofa where Andrew Borden was found dead. The other was the production of a bloodstained and tat tered handkerchief of the bandanna variety, found on the floor, and not hereto fore produced. Both these things are

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • The Press · Belleville, N.J. · 17 June 1893

Fisherman & Farmer · Edenton, N.C. · and 2 other papers

Alice Russell testified about Lizzie Borden burning a dress days after the murders, and police witnesses described bloodstains, a locked cellar door, and hatchets found in the house. Assistant Marshal Fleet's testimony about the hatchet handle was challenged under cross-examination by ex-Governor Robinson.

Fisherman & Farmer · 23 June 1893 · page 3

AT NEW BEDFORD.

The words of this article are printed with the report it shares its clipping with. Read them there or in the clipping.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

Also printed in 2 papers
  • The Press · Belleville, N.J. · 17 June 1893
  • The Abbeville Press and Banner · Abbeville, S.C. · 28 June 1893

The Forrest City Times · Forrest City, Ark.

This column quotes other newspapers' reactions to Lizzie Borden's acquittal, with one calling her a 'she devil' who escaped justice and another criticizing her unjust imprisonment before trial. The piece reflects divided public opinion even after the verdict was rendered.

The Forrest City Times · 23 June 1893 · page 6

TIM" A M» THAT The trial of Lizzie Borden is over,’ and she has la>en acquitted. Public opinion had anticipated this verdict, as all people who have closely followed the c».-e have been satisfied that there, « as, under the evidence, a substantial doubt of the prisoner's guilt; yet, as «e have often said, not all the evidence I for the defense tior all the ingenuity ;

See the clipping

Paper unidentified

The piece explains that Lizzie Borden's refusal to take the stand was a legal right, not evidence of guilt, since prosecutors cannot comment on such silence nor can juries draw unfavorable inferences from it. It criticizes the public for treating her silence as damning despite established legal principle.

Paper unidentified · 23 June 1893 · page 2

The failure of the defense to put Lizzie Borden on the stand, which has been used by self constituted juries as a damning proof of her

See the clipping

Arkansas Echo · Little Rock, Ark.

The report states the Borden case was decided this week: Lizzie Borden had been accused of murdering her father and stepmother, but only circumstantial evidence existed. The jury found her not guilty.

CorrectionThis set right 6 earlier articles: The Oskaloosa Herald, 22 June 1893, Omaha Daily Bee, 22 June 1893, Omaha Daily Bee, 22 June 1893, The Madison Daily Leader, 22 June 1893, San Antonio Daily Light, 22 June 1893, The Times, 22 June 1893.

Arkansas Echo · 23 June 1893 · page 8

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

See the clipping

The State Herald · Holyoke, Colo.

This filler item quotes the New York Herald predicting the Lizzie Borden trial will surpass any US criminal trial in public interest since Guiteau's. It notes the case is drawing intense attention not just in New England but across the whole country.

The State Herald · 23 June 1893 · page 2

••The trial of Lizzie Borden,” sit)'* tho New York lierald, “bids fair to purpass in general interest any crim inal trial in this country since that of Guiteau.” Not only in Now Eng

See the clipping

The Willimantic Journal · Willimantic, Conn.

This roundup of national and international news briefly mentions that the Borden murder trial continued at New Bedford with prosecution evidence, and that the prosecution rested on June 16. It also covers unrelated events like the World's Fair, labor strikes, and British parliamentary proceedings.

The Willimantic Journal · 23 June 1893 · page 8

NEWS OF THE WEEK

Friday, Jane 16. The prosecution rested and the defense began in the trial of Lizzie Borden at New Bedford. Mr. Jennings made the opening speech for the prisoner-Wealthy and aged Eliphalet Stratton of Brooklyn has been arrested on a charge of starving his invalid young wife-It is alleged that E. M. Field’s insanity is shammed and that he is practically free-Royal Phelps Car roll’s new yacht, the Navahoe, was dis abled by collision with a pilotboat -Several persons were killed, and considerable damage to property was done by lightning in the west-The heirs of Jay Gould will contest in court the payment of #250.000 inheritance tax in addition to the #500,000 already paid-The

See the clipping

Milford Chronicle · Milford, Del.

This editorial celebrates the jury's not-guilty verdict delivered Tuesday in the Lizzie Borden murder trial at New Bedford, arguing the prosecution failed to establish motive, find the murder weapon, or locate blood evidence on the accused. The writer declares Borden innocent and a victim of circumstances, praising her prior character as a church and charity leader.

CorrectionThis set right an article from the day before.

Milford Chronicle · 23 June 1893 · page 2

■in--' V 4 ygPr&T That was the ver cred on Tuesday by the mil my in the Lizzie Borden murder trial at New Bedford, Mass. That a is also the verdict of the people everywhere who have followe«! this celebrated case and who have road and analyzed every particle of the evidence produced by the govern ment and by the defence. Leaving out the defence entirely there was not anything in the evidence pro duced by the government that an . honest and intelligent jury could have convicted upon. The govern ment did not make out a case against the accused aud had the verdict been different the court would have been justified insetting it aside and order ing a new trial.

See moreSee less

The government signally failed in proving anything. It failed to establish a motive. It failed to produce the instrument of death. It failed to find a drop of blood on the clothing of the accused, when such a crime could not possi bly have been committed without be spattering almost from head to foot the perpetrator of the horrible deed. Lizzie Borden's character was al ways,previous to this double murder, " beyondTrepronch. She was a leader in church matters and all charitable work of her city. She has been legally tried and pro nounced innocent after the ease of the government was brilliantly con ducted. No one of Intelligence can say they believe her guilty. She victim of circumstances and was a if ever a jury brought in an intelli gent and just verdict it is the verdict of the twelve true men in the cele brated Lizzie Borden case. The mys tery involved in this case has not a parallel in the criminal annals of the Lizale Borden is inno universe. The guilty one is safe if the cent. old adage of "murder will out" does not prove true in the Borden case. The United States'engineers have at last satisfied themselves that the Chronicle was strictly correct in saying a new mouth to the Mispill ion could not be made in the man ner in which the work was being 4 attempted. On Wednesday, after a month's labor lost orders came from if Washington to cease operations the experiment About two upon thousand dollars of the twelve thous * aud available lias been expended and the river's mouth is not any and ■k don't believe as belter, and we 'an before. The dredg '7 good as it was ing machine has been ordered to the mouth of the Murderkill river, at ii Bowers Beach, where she will begin mouth. operations upon that river 's At tais mouth tbe work ft* prq

See the clipping

Milford Chronicle · Milford, Del.

This editorial argues the prosecution failed to prove motive, produce the murder weapon, or find blood on Lizzie Borden's clothing. It declares her innocent, praises the jury's verdict as just, and laments that the true killer remains unidentified.

Milford Chronicle · 23 June 1893 · page 2

the perpetrator of the horrible deed. Lizzie Borden's character was al ways,previous to this double murder, " beyondTrepronch. She was a leader in church matters and all charitable work of her city. She has been legally tried and pro nounced innocent after the ease of the government was brilliantly con ducted. No one of Intelligence can say they believe her guilty. She victim of circumstances and was a if ever a jury brought in an intelli gent and just verdict it is the verdict of the twelve true men in the cele brated Lizzie Borden case.

See moreSee less

The mys tery involved in this case has not a parallel in the criminal annals of the Lizale Borden is inno universe. The guilty one is safe if the cent. old adage of "murder will out" does not prove true in the Borden case.

See the clipping

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

Office workers reading a Tribune correspondent's colorful dispatches from the Lizzie Borden trial fall into a dispute over what region the phrase 'Down East' properly covers. The argument reveals no consensus among New Englanders, with opinions varying by state and perspective.

New-York Tribune · 23 June 1893 · page 2

WHAT IS MEANT BY "DOWN EAST"? NEW-ENGLANDERS UNABLE TO AGREE IN LOCATING IT—IT DEPENDS ON THE POINT OF VIEW.

NEW-ENGLANDERS UNABLE TO AGREE IN LOCATING IT=IT DEPENDS ON THE POINT OF VIF. <sme men In a downthwn office the other day were reading and commenting on The Tribune correspondent’s pletiresque descriptions (tf scones and incidents of the Lizzie Borden trial, when one tebk exception to

See the clipping

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

A newspaper commentary argues that Lizzie Borden's acquittal was earned through a strong case, not legal trickery or favorable treatment. It notes the prosecution was earnest and public sentiment was against her, yet she was still found innocent.

New-York Tribune · 23 June 1893 · page 6

well, but dre unwilling to encourage him to tho extent of getting damp during the days which they have dedicated to painting things red. —— en —_ One thing can certainly be said about Lizzie Borden's vindication. It was not obtained by

See the clipping

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

The report notes that Lizzie Borden was held in jail for nearly ten months before her trial, which it argues was far too long. It observes that although she was acquitted, there is no way to compensate her for the prolonged suffering and suspense she endured.

New-York Tribune · 23 June 1893 · page 6

Lizzie Borden was kept in jail fully ten months before being put on trial. That was at least eigirt months too long. She is declared innocent,

See the clipping

Idaho Semi-Weekly World · Idaho City, Idaho Territory

The item reports that Lizzie Borden, tried in Massachusetts for the murder of her father and stepmother, was acquitted a few days prior. It appears as a short filler item among local mining and town news.

Idaho Semi-Weekly World · 23 June 1893 · page 1

John Gorman's big St. Bernard dog, Celt, was put on the scales the other day, and he weighed just 170 pounds. Celt is ts good natured and intelligent as he is big. He is a full blooded St. Bernard. John Oomens came in last Tues day from Banner. John says some good ore is coming out of the Wol verine mine, but the main pay chute has not yet been reached on the 600 foot level. A rumor is going tbe rounds of the Wood River country that the Union Pacific will soon run bat three trains a week to Hailey, and that the mail service will be reduced to a tri-week ___ __ Ed.

See moreSee less

Harrison bas leased Win. Lib by's Lucky Boy mine, in Gambrinus district, and went up last Tuesday to begin work. Miss Lizzie Borden, who has been on trial a long time in Massachusetts, charged with the murder of her fath er and stepmother, was acquitted i few days ago.

See the clipping

The Indianapolis Journal · Indianapolis, Ind.

A humorous filler item speculates that Lizzie Borden will receive marriage proposals from strangers now that she has been acquitted. It jokes that she would have received even more had the jury left doubt about her innocence.

The Indianapolis Journal · 23 June 1893 · page 4

"Hob" Ingersoll has not made any unnres sion on the heart of that eminent paean. However, another London importation, the Salvation Army, is doing good work among tbe class that constitutes tho ma jority of the Colouel'a co-irreligionists. How many proposals of marriage will Lizzie Borden receive from ntrangers this summer! While she will not receive so many as she woula bad tbe jury disagreed and left some doubt as to her innocence, it is almost a certainty that from two to a dozen men whom she never beard of will each usk to be the oak to her clinging ivy. As engaged conple in Bluefield. V. Va., ran a foot race, the man was beaten, and tbe young woman discarded him, saying

See the clipping

The Indianapolis Journal · Indianapolis, Ind.

The New York Sun reports that former Governor George Robinson, before accepting Lizzie Borden's defense retainer, insisted on speaking with her alone and emerged convinced of her innocence. The piece describes his subsequent close relationship with her during the trial, including his practice of sharing damaging testimony with her to gauge her reactions.

The Indianapolis Journal · 23 June 1893 · page 4

New York Sun. Bofore Governor Robinson would apcept a retainer in her case he said he would have to talk with her, and hear her voice, aud look into her eye. Mr. Adam and Mr. Jen nings accompanied him to Tauutou jail a month or more ago. and all sat down to gether. Mr. Kobiusou then asked tho oth ers to withdraw. Said he: "1 have heard your accounts of this case, all 1 want to. Now 1 want to hear what Miss Borden has

See the clipping

The Kinsley Graphic · Kinsley, Kan.

The report states that the Lizzie Borden case was given to the jury on June 20th. In just over an hour, the jury returned a verdict of acquittal.

The Kinsley Graphic · 23 June 1893 · page 1

4JDITIONAI. DISPATCHES . A KUmber of United States customs officials in the staite of Washington have been dismissed from the. service on the charge of collusion with, parties who smuggled Chinese intotheountry, Striking miners in a district, of Bo hemia attacked the governor, out were driven off by the police witfli-loss of life. ; . The Suburban handicap at Coney Isl and furnished a great surprise. Low lander winning at long odds in the bet ting. ; The Lizzie Borden case was given to the jury on the 20th and in a little more

See the clipping

Semi-Weekly Interior Journal · Stanford, Ky.

A roundup of short news items reports that Lizzie Borden, charged with murdering her parents in New Bedford, Massachusetts, was acquitted. It notes the case drew great public interest.

Semi-Weekly Interior Journal · 23 June 1893 · page 2

NEWSY NOTES.

Lizzie Borden, charced with the murder of her parents at New Bedford, Masd., was acquitted. The case created great interest. The World's Fair officials have designated

See the clipping

The Hartford Republican · Hartford, Ky.

The report states that after a long and exciting trial, Lizzie Borden was found 'not guilty' by the jury, freeing her from the charge of murdering her parents. It characterizes her as an innocent, much-abused girl whose acquittal will be met with widespread approval across the nation.

The Hartford Republican · 23 June 1893 · page 3

Tin: Hon. John W. Lewis, ol Springfield, has accepted an invitation to attend the Itciitiioti hero on the Fourth. Ho is the peer of any man in Kentucky and those who delight in patriotic eloquence should be on hand to hear the grcut orator. Mr. Lewis has many fiicnds in tho county nnd will receive n warm welcome. Akti:k a long nnd exciting trial, Lizzie Borden litis been declared "not guilty" by the jury in tho case, and thus an innocent but much abused girl goes tree of tho crimo of tho murder of her parents, with which she was charged. The name of Lizzie Borden is known in every home from

See the clipping

Springfield Weekly Republican · Springfield, Mass.

The report notes that Lizzie Borden has returned to Fall River to resume her former life of church and philanthropic work after the ordeal of her trial. It states that townspeople are supportive of her wish to retreat from the publicity surrounding the case.

Springfield Weekly Republican · 23 June 1893 · page 1

EDITORIAL NOTE AND COMMENT. Miss Lizzie Borden has gone to Fall River to stay. She proposes to resume her church and philanthropic work, and to take up the

See the clipping

Springfield Weekly Republican · Springfield, Mass.

This report discusses Lizzie Borden's acquittal, noting she cannot be tried again for the murders of her father and stepmother. It reflects on the case as a mystery that remains unsolved despite a thorough trial and police investigation.

Springfield Weekly Republican · 23 June 1893 · page 2

The extraordinary feature of this case, as it appears to-uay, is that after the searching scrutiny of atrial of which the prosecution was conducted by able and vigilant lawyers, supported by a merciless police, it remains even more an impenetrable mystery than ever. Andrew J. Borden and his wife were butchered in the most demoniacal fashion in their own home in the heart of a populous city while the sun was high and all the neighbors were awake. The alarm came within a few minutes after the second tragedy, and the police began at once their hunt for the assassin.

See moreSee less

They searched high and low for traces of the fiend. Nearly a year has passed, and the state ot MassachuKt*t confesses to the whole world that it knows nothing of the perpetrator of those fearful crimes. Tea, it admits that it is pos sible for a person to do these things w ithin one of its cities and escape discovery. Lizzie Borden is legally innocent. A person is presumed to be guiltless until guiit is proved, and in her ease guilt was very far from being proved. But this unfor tunate woman, even now that she has been acquitted, stands in a terrible position, because so long as the assassin of her father and stepmother remains undiscovered and unpunished there will be many people who will still believe her guilty. Casting aside speculations as to the woman’s sanity,—and these murders were truly maniacioal—the result of this trial leaves no one with any intellectual justification for affirming that Miss Borden is guilty: it leaves every mind suspended in an atmosphere of doubt, and all who fairly consider the problem must now become agnostics as to the identity of the guilty one. But the human mind is not con tent with negations, and thus in its groping for affirmations a cruel injustice may be done the acquitted person. It is to be sincerely hoped that Miss Borden will not he wronged in this manner. But who killed Abby and Andrew Borden'? AVe cannot help seeking the solution of the mystery which is now back in the hands of a baffled police, deep and dark as ever.

See the clipping

Springfield Weekly Republican · Springfield, Mass.

This editorial published just after Lizzie Borden's acquittal reflects on the lingering mystery of who killed Andrew and Abby Borden. It argues that while she is legally innocent, public doubt will persist since the true killer remains unidentified.

Springfield Weekly Republican · 23 June 1893 · page 2

The words of this article are printed with the report it shares its clipping with. Read them there or in the clipping.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

Springfield Weekly Republican · Springfield, Mass.

A Baltimore landlady, Mrs. Ramsey, recounts a young boarder who claimed to be an adopted relative of the Bordens and allegedly said 'Lizzie did it.' The young man, calling himself Felix Borden, left suddenly for Massachusetts shortly before the murders and later returned to Baltimore.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

Springfield Weekly Republican · 23 June 1893 · page 5

-4 STORY ERUM~BALTIAiORE About a Vonns Mnn Who Talked About the Bordens a tSood Beal. A New York XX'orld dispatch from Bal timore, Md., says: Mrs Ramsey, who keeps a boarding-house at 333 St Raul street, says that previous to the Borden murders a boy came from New England and boarded with her. He told her that Im was the adopted son of Lizzie Borden’s unde and that his name was Felix Bor den. He said that his parents' name was Desroches. From all accounts he did not live happily with the Bordens, and as a result of a disagreement with them he left home suddenly.

See moreSee less

Felix told Mrs Ramsey that his home war. in New Bedford or Fall River. He spent his money freely. He did not pay his board bill and left, saying that he was going to his home in Massachusetts to get money to settle. phy, two; bachelor of civil engineering, three; bachelor of electrical engineering, eight; bachelor of divinity, three: master of arts, six; civil engineer, one. At the eon elusion of the exercises dinner was served in the gymnasium. Bowdoin class day was observed Tues day afternoon with these exercises: Open ing address, F. M. Shaw; history. B. F. Barker; prophecy, M. S. Clifford; class sta tistics, A. M. Jones; paring address, A. S. 1 Liggett; smoking pipe of pence, sing ing the ode and cheering the halls. The clnss-iiay hop was held in the evening. Class officers: President, C. 11. Savage; marshal, E. 11. Carlton; committee, .1. S. May, A. R. Jenks ami XX’. Lambert.

See the clipping

Springfield Weekly Republican · Springfield, Mass.

A Baltimore landlady, Mrs. Ramsey, recounts that a young boarder named Felix, who left town just before the Borden murders, later said 'Oh, Lizzie did it' when asked about the case. She also notes his unflattering remarks about the Bordens and that his description matched a mysterious young man reportedly seen at the Borden gate the morning of the murders.

Springfield Weekly Republican · 23 June 1893 · page 5

A STORY FROM BALTIMORE

A few days after Felix left, the Borden murders wencommitted. He returned to Baltimore. On one ocresion Mrs Ramsey spoke to Felix about the murders. She says that he replied: "Oh, Lizzie did it." Asked if the young man was ever heard to make any thrcnienlng remarks about the Bordens of Massachusetts, Mrs Ram sey said: "During the two years Felix lived here he sisike frequently of the Bor dens, and, judging from his remarks, I didn't think be cured very much for them. He referred, I remember, on one occasion to some old woman up there and did not speak in very complimentary terms of her.

See moreSee less

I judged from his remarks that lie had had a quarrel with his people before he canm hero, although he never told me the particulars.” Mrs Ramsey said the young man was a medium-sized fellow with dark hair and when he left was 21 years old. Ills description, it is said, tallies with that given by several witnesses in file Burden trial last week, who said they saw a strange young man at the Borden gate the morning of the murders. Young Bor den left Baltimore last autumn, and has not been heard of there since.

See the clipping

Springfield Weekly Republican · Springfield, Mass.

The trial at New Bedford concluded Tuesday afternoon with the jury delivering a verdict of not guilty after Judge Dewey's charge. District Attorney Knowlton moved to drop other pending charges, and Chief Justice Mason thanked the jurors for their service.

Springfield Weekly Republican · 23 June 1893 · page 6

JUDGE DEWEY'S CHARGE TO THE JURY. Hr l.onn« Mronslv Toward the nrfruic The Close of niMrict Attorney Knool ton*>* Argument Exciting Ncwi in llir Court-room. The Borden trial ended Tuesday after noon at New Bedford, the jury bringing in a verdict of “not. guilty." This result has been generally expected, although a disagreement of the jury would have caused little surprise. District Attorney Knowlton finished his presentation of the state’s ease in the morning and rhe first thing in the afternoon, after Miss Borden had said to the jury, when privilege was given her to speak.

See moreSee less

“I am innocent, but 1 will leave my case in your hands and in the hands of my counsel," was Judge Dewey’s charge to the jury. District At torney Knowlton’s closing and the charge are given below. At the conclusion of the charge at 3.10 p. m., the jury retired. At 4.30 it was announced that they had reached a ver dict ami they tiled into the court-room and were polled. Mis< Borden was asked to stand up and the foreman was asked to return the verdict, unon which he an nounced “not guilty." After the verdict had been received, the district attorney moved that the other eases against Miss Borden be mol pressed, and the order of the court was to that effect. * Chief Justice Mason then gracefully thanked the jurors in appreciation of their work and faithful service and reminded them that the pre cautions taken with them which may have se-mol irks nue at the time, were solely in rhe interest of justice, a fact which they undoubtedly realized now. Ine jurj’ was then dismissed ami the court was adjoi:r::el until Monday next when the regular criminal session will be opened. The closing scene in the Borden trial

See the clipping

Springfield Weekly Republican · Springfield, Mass.

After Judge Dewey's charge, the jury deliberated about 80 minutes before returning a verdict of 'not guilty' for Lizzie Borden. The courtroom broke into prolonged cheering despite the court's dignity, with Borden, her attorneys, and spectators all moved to tears or celebration.

Springfield Weekly Republican · 23 June 1893 · page 6

The words of this article are printed with the report it shares its clipping with. Read them there or in the clipping.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

Springfield Weekly Republican · Springfield, Mass.

The jury returns a verdict of 'Not guilty,' prompting tears and emotional celebration from Lizzie Borden and her defense team, including Jennings and Robinson. The report also recounts part of ex-Governor Robinson's closing argument to the jury emphasizing the presumption of innocence.

Springfield Weekly Republican · 23 June 1893 · page 6

eyes, and stood up as Mr Knowlton *<nd Mr Moody came over to shake hands with the counsel for the defense. As soon as jiossible the room was cleared, although it was a hard task since everybody wante i to shake hands w ; *t> Miss Borden. Th* : she was taken to the room of the justice ami allov tsi to recover her composure with only the eyes of friends upon her and the caresses of devoted admirers. At the ex piration of an hour she was placed in a carriage ;.nd driven to the station where she took the train for Fall River, her home no longer, probably. bu r still the only objective point for the immediate present.

See the clipping

Springfield Weekly Republican · Springfield, Mass.

Lizzie Borden and her sister returned to their Second Street home in Fall River after spending the night at Charles J. Holmes's residence, arriving by closed carriage to few spectators. The report notes her cheerful mood, the public's changed temper toward the verdict, letters of congratulation, and plans for a European trip.

Springfield Weekly Republican · 23 June 1893 · page 8

they had entered their old home. Andrew J. Jennings received letters and telegrams of congratulation from all parts of the country, and Miss Borden’s mail at the post-office is very heavy. The temper of the people of the city has been changed greatly by the verdict, and there is a manifest respect for the decision of the jury. It is stated by a relative of the Bordens that as soon as Lizzie Borden and her sister Emma can make proper arrange ment, they, with Bridget Sullivan, will sail for Europe for an extended trip. This is considered the best way to escape un pleasant recollections of the past year.

See the clipping

Springfield Weekly Republican · Springfield, Mass.

The report reviews the prosecution resting its case and defense attorney Jennings' opening statement, which promised to show Lizzie's good character, lack of motive, and problems with the prosecution's evidence including the barn loft testimony and burned dress. It also notes the paper's own assessment that the government's case weakened during the second week, including the court excluding Lizzie's inquest testimony.

Springfield Weekly Republican · 23 June 1893 · page 12

THE BORDEN MURDER CASE. THE TESTIMONY OF LAST WEEK; A Careful Review of the Evidence in the Case and the Points Brought Out.

bad to worse. First, the court ruled out Lizzie Borden’s testimony given at the cor oner’s inquest uihui which the district at torney had placed considerable dependence because of tin* alleged contradictions into which Miss Lizzie had been trapped. Then the testimony of the government’s witnes ses coneeruing the prisoner's alleged at tempt to buy prussic arid on the day be fore the murders, was also excluded, and so another of rhe district attorney’s \ *av iest guns was silenced. Finally, Miss Em ma Borden reached the stand and gave testimony which completely demolished the fabric of ugly suspicion raised about her sister by the testimony of Miss Alice Russell concerning the famous burned dress.

See moreSee less

Said Miss Russell on the stand:— When I came bark I went In the kitchen and saw Lizzie standing by the stove. Bnnua by the sink. Lizzie had a dress skirt, and I asked her what she was going to do with it. and Lizzie said she was going to burn it. It was all covered with mint. I said nothing and went out. Wh('ii I came in the room again Lizzie was tearing the dress. I said. ‘T would not let anybody see me doing that.” and she stepped one step back. It was the waist she was tearing. Eight days later Miss Emma Borden reached The stand. Mr Jennings conduct

See the clipping

Springfield Weekly Republican · Springfield, Mass.

This report reviews the second week of the Borden trial, noting the court excluded Lizzie's inquest testimony and evidence about an alleged prussic acid purchase. It also details Emma Borden's testimony explaining the paint stains on the burned bedford cord dress, countering Alice Russell's earlier account.

Springfield Weekly Republican · 23 June 1893 · page 12

THE TESTIMONY ON LAST WEEK

The words of this article are printed with the report it shares its clipping with. Read them there or in the clipping.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

Springfield Weekly Republican · Springfield, Mass.

The passage recounts testimony about a dress with paint or stain that faded over time, then pivots to a commentary arguing the prosecution has failed to prove its case. It questions the state's claims about exclusive opportunity, the murder weapon, and motive, highlighting contradictions in witness testimony about the hatchet handle.

Springfield Weekly Republican · 23 June 1893 · page 12

Fleet of the handle. On what grounds now can the district attorm'y, speaking for the commonwealth of Massachusetts, ask the jury to believe that Miss Lizzie Borden, as charged in the indictment, kilhsl her father and her step mother with "a sharp instrument?” (’an he say that she had an "exclusive oppor tunity”? (’an he ronm'et her in any direct way with any phase of the crime? Can he show that she has been involved in a single contradiction in her own story of her movements on that fatal August day?

See moreSee less

Finally, can he assign an adequate motive for the double butchery by the person he has bt'en pursuing? The state did not .suc ceed in showing that Miss Borden had an “exclusive opportunity.” ""Several wit nesses testified as to the uncertain condi tion of the .snap lock on the front door, and it is uncontradicted that the clothes press in tin* upper front hall afforded ample room for a person to hide in. Fur thermore, several witnesses have testified io seeing in front of ihe Borden residence that forenoon an unknown man who acted queerly. The state has not connected the defend ant in any direct way with rhe crime in such a convincing muaner that the jury must believe. It has not produced the weaixm the murderer used and shown that Lizzie Borden used it in such a role. Upon none of the hatchets brought into

See the clipping

Der Deutsche Correspondent · Baltimore, Md.

Lizzie Borden and her sister Emma moved back into their former residence on Second Street in Fall River, the scene of the notorious double murder, after spending the previous night at Mr. Chas. R. Holmes's home. Upon entering the house, both women were overcome with emotion and wept for some time.

Der Deutsche Correspondent · 23 June 1893 · page 1

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

See the clipping