The piece notes the Borden trial resumes tomorrow but says the case is essentially closed, with no substantial evidence against Lizzie Borden beyond the failure to find another suspect. It predicts she will be acquitted, though the mystery of who committed the murders will remain unsolved.
Wheeling Sunday Register · 18 June 1893 · page 4
BBBEBIh'■■ B r4 -. ' ; 1 v r ; -■ a . - t ■ - - Bniy fun to be run down. TomoiIA»>w the Borden trial will be L resumed, but unless the unexpected ■
On the night before closing arguments, lawyers for both sides prepare their final statements while reporters wait outside. The piece speculates that defense attorney Robinson will give the effort of his life against prosecutor Knowlton, and predicts Lizzie Borden will likely be acquitted or the jury will deadlock.
Morning Journal and Courier · 19 June 1893 · page 3
le Believed That Lizzie Borden Will Be PromsUr Acquitted. . Nw Bidford, Mass. June 18. The night before the legal battle Is as ninal in most oonfllota a pretty qnietand nneyentf nl time. The work of preparation among the counsel In the Borden case has bean
The report speculates that Lizzie Borden will likely be acquitted or the jury will disagree, denying rumors of an actual disagreement among jurors. It also explains the earlier confusion over two arrest warrants, clarifying that Marshal Hilliard issued one before consulting District Attorney Knowlton, who then insisted on a properly tailored warrant.
Morning Journal and Courier · 19 June 1893 · page 3
BEFORE THE BIG BATTLE.
The concensus of opinion nere la that Miss Borden will be acquitted In short or. der or that the jury will disagree. In the former event it is understood there will be no jubilation, bnt she will retire quietly from the scene of so muoh unpleasantness as quickly as possible. In the latter event there may come a new trial or a case of nolle proa., she being allowed to go on her own recognizance, provided her counsel stand in the breach. The story about disagreement in the i ury is all bosh, and originated in the fertile mind of a euper-imaoinative person.
See moreSee less
While tbe surroundings are not particularly con ducive to harmony, still it is a fact that exceedingly pleasant relations have been maintained, and it would not be surprising if every Jane hereafter there should be a festive reunion of the Borden jury to com memorate this delightfully bright spot in their career. It has just come to the knowledge of the Associated Press that the true inwardness of the double warrant business is this: When Marshal Hilliard came to the con clusion that it was , necessary to closely watch Lizzie Borden he swore ont a war rant for her arrest, trying, however, to consult Mr. Enowlton about the matter. The latter was at his summer home -in Marion and oonld not be reached by tele phone. When he came up on the day of the Inquest Marshal millard had tbe war rant duly made ont and in his pocket. After tne inquest tne district attorney said: "Have a warrant made ont and ar rest her" or words to that effect, and the marshal replied that he had one already. But Mr. Knowlton said that this would not do, there must be a warrant made ont to fit the case, he under standing and appreciating, even at that time the very point whioh ex Gov ernor Robinson used so effectively in bar ring ont the testimony of Miss Borden at the inquest. It is fair to state that the first warrant was issued wholly without Mr. Enowlton's knowledge or aanotion, ac cording to Mr. Hilliard's statement, al though the latter tried to oonsult the law yer before he obtained it. The arguments will probably take all day Monday and the charge be given on Tuesday. It being Impossible for tne jury to leave the eourt room after receiving the charge it la considered as not fair to start them in on the last atage of the proceed ings at nightfall.
The report discusses courtroom procedural details about the arrest warrant and trial scheduling, then shifts to a Baltimore story about a young man named Felix Borden who claimed to be Lizzie Borden's uncle's adopted son and allegedly said 'Lizzie did it.' A landlady recounts his suspicious behavior and resemblance to witness descriptions from the trial.
Morning Journal and Courier · 19 June 1893 · page 3
IS THIS THE MURDERER?
' Strange manner His Description Tallies iritn That er Witnesses In vine Borden Trial. - Nxw Tosx, June 18 The World's spe cial from Baltimore ways: Mrs. Rsmsey, who keeps a boarding house at No. 338 St Paul street, says that previous to the Borden murder a boy oasje from New England and boarded with her. He told her that he was the adopted son of IJzzIs Borden's nnole, and tbat bis nam was Felix Borden. He said his parents namewas Deerosches." From all ac counts he did not. live happily with the.
See moreSee less
Borden s. - . . Felix told Urs. Bsmeey that bis horns was in New Bedford or Fall Elver. He spent his money freely. He did not pay his board bill and left, saving that he was going to his home in Massachusetts to gat money to settle. A few-days after Felix left the Boiden murders were committed. He returned to Baltimore. X)n one occasion Mrs. Ramsey spoke to Felix about the murders. She says tbat he replied: "Oh, -Lizzie did it." Asked if the young man was ever heard to make any threatening remarks about the Bordens of Massachusetts, Mrs. Ram sey said: "During the two years Felix lived here he spoke frequently of the Bor dens, and. judging from his remarks, I did not think he oared very muoh for them. He referred, I remember on one occasion, to some old woman np there, and did not speak in verr complimentary terms ox her." Mrs. Ramsey said the young man was a meaiom-slzea xeiiow, witn a ark nair, ana when he left was twenty-one years oio. His description, it la said, tallies with that given by several witnesses In the Borden trial on Thursday, who said that they saw a strange young man at the Borden gate the morning of the murders.
The courtroom was packed as ex-Governor Robinson opened the defense's closing argument, with District Attorney Knowlton to follow. The judge's charge to the jury was delayed until the next day per Massachusetts custom, so jurors would not have to deliberate overnight after a long day of arguments.
Waterbury Evening Democrat · 19 June 1893 · page 2
SUMMING UP TODAY
GOVERNMENT NOT LIKELY TO WIN Hard Work Done Yesterday By the Law yers Gov. Koblnson Feels tbe Gravity of His Position The Massachusetts Custom -A Story from the West. New Bedfokd, Mass., June 19. The court room was crowded to suffocation this morning before 9 o'clock. Lizzie Borden came in shortly before that time,
The report describes the tense final day of closing arguments between defense attorney Gov. Robinson and prosecutor Hosea Knowlton, noting the prosecution's advantage of speaking last to the jury. It also notes a general belief that Lizzie Borden will be acquitted or the jury will disagree, with no public celebration expected either way.
Waterbury Evening Democrat · 19 June 1893 · page 2
GOVERNMENT NOT LIKELY TO WIN
The concensus of opinion here is that Miss Borden will be acquitted in short order or that the jury will disagree. In the former event, it is understood that there will lie no jubilation, but she will retire quickly from the scene of so much unpleasantness as quickly as possible. In the latter event, there may come a new trial or a case of nolle prosequi later on she being allowed to go on her own rec ognizance provided her counsel stands in the breach. It may not be fair to assume that the jury has sampled publii opinion sufficient ly to diagauose its present condition, and yet, there is a strong feeling that this as sumption will be entirely correct.
With closing arguments set for Monday and the judge's charge for Tuesday, observers in New Bedford believe Lizzie Borden will be acquitted quickly or the jury will disagree. If acquitted, no celebration is expected as she quietly leaves; a disagreement could lead to a new trial or nolle prosequi with release on recognizance.
The Morning Call · 19 June 1893 · page 1
PROBABLY^AN^ ACQUITTAL. That Seems the Only Outcome for the Borden Case. New Bedford,'. Mass., June 18.— The work of preparation among the counsel in the Borden case has been going on all day.
A Baltimore landlady, Mrs. Ramsey, claims a young boarder calling himself Felix Borden, supposedly nephew of Lizzie's uncle, fled without paying before the murders and later told her 'Oh, Lizzie did it.' His description allegedly matches the stranger witnesses saw at the Borden gate that morning.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
The Morning Call · 19 June 1893 · page 1
AN IMPORTANT STATEMENT.
New York, June 18.— World's Baltimore special says: Mrs." Ramsey who keeps a boarding-house relates a story that previous to the Borden murders, a New England boy who represented him self as Felix Borden, the adopted son of Lizzie Borden's uncle, boarded with ber. He did not pay his board bill and left, say ing he was going to his home in Massa chusetts to get money to settle with. A few days after he left the Borden murders were committed. He returned to Balti more, and Mrs. Ramsey spoke about the murders.
See moreSee less
He replied, "Oh, Lizzie did It." His de scription it is said tallies with that given by witnesses who testified that they saw a strange young man at the gate of the Borden house on the morning of the mur der. Young Borden left ' Baltimore last fall and has not been heard of since.
As the Borden trial approaches its conclusion in New Bedford, legal observers predict Lizzie Borden will likely be acquitted or face a hung jury, with no public celebration expected either way. Separately, a Baltimore boarding house keeper claims a young man posing as a relative named Felix Borden told her 'Lizzie did it' before disappearing, with his description matching a stranger reportedly seen near the Borden home.
The Herald · 19 June 1893 · page 1
Opinion (taenia to Be That Lizzie Will Be Acquitted. Nbw Bedford, Mass., June IB. —The work of preparation among counsel in the Borden case waa going on all day. The concensus of opinion la that Miss Borden will be acquitted in short order or tbe jury will disagree. In tbe former event, it is understood, there will be no jubila tion but she will retire quietly from the scene of so much uupleassntness as quirikly as possible. In the Utter event i there may come a new trial or a case of i nolle prosequi later on, she being al lowed to (to on her own recognizance pro vided counsel stands in the breach.
See moreSee less
The arguments will probably take all day i Monday and tho charge will be given on Tuesday morning. New York, June 18.—The World's Baltimore special says: Mrs. Ramsey, who keeps a boarding house, relates the story that previous to the Borden mur I ders, a New England boy, who repre sented himself as Felix Borden, an adopted son of Lizzie Borden's uncle, boarded with her. He did not pay his board bill and left, saying he was gnu g to bis home in Massachusetts to get money to settle with. A few days af ter he left the Borden murders were committed. He retnrned to Baltimore, and Mrs. Ramsev spoke about the mur ders. He replied: - 'Oh, Lizzie did it." His discription, it is said, tallies with tbatgiven by witnesses wbo testified thoy saw a strange young man at tbe gate of the Borden house the morning of the murder. Young Borden left Baltimore last fall and bas not been heard of since.
A Baltimore boarding-house keeper claims a young man calling himself Felix Borden, nephew of Lizzie's uncle, fled without paying his bill just before the murders and later said 'Lizzie did it.' His description reportedly matched the strange man witnesses saw at the Borden gate on the morning of the killings.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
The Record-Union · 19 June 1893 · page 1
San Francisco, June 18.—Among the passengers on the steamer City of Peking, from China to-day, was Chen She Sum, said to bo an Embassador of the Chinese Government dispatched to the United States for the purpose of ascertaining the actual state of public opinion relating to Chinese residents here, and of tho inten tion of the Government in the enforce ment of the Geary Act. He will proceed to Chicago to attend the fair, aud then go to Washington in pursuance of his mission. When interviewed by a re porter Chen She Sum refused to niako any statoment as to his plans or the ob ject of his visit.
See moreSee less
» . _, THE BORDEN MYSTERY. Did the Strange Younnr Man at the Gate Commit the Crimes t New York, June 18.—A World's Bal timore special says that Mrs. Ramsey, who keeps a boarding-house, relates the story that previous to the Borden mur ders a New England boy who repre sented himself as Felix Borden, the adopted son of Lizzie Borden's uncle, boarded with her. He did not pay his board bill, and ieft saying that ho was go ing to his home in Massachusetts to get money to settle with. A few days after he loft the Borden murders were com mitted. He returned to Baltimore, and Mrs. Ramsey spoke about the murders. He replied: "Oh, Lizzie did it." His description, it is said, tallies with that given by witnesses who testified that they saw a strange young man at tho gate of the Borden house on the morning of the murders. Young Borden left Balti more last fall and has not been heard of since. will probably hi; acquitted. Nkw Bedfobd (Mass.), June 18.—The work of preparation among counsel In the Borden ease was going on all day. The concensus of opinion is that Miss Borden will be acquitted in short order or the jury will disagree. In the former event it is understood there will be no jubilation, but she will retire quietly from the scene of much unpleasantness, as quickly as possible, lv tho latter event may come a new trial or a nolle prosequi, later on she being allowed to go on her own recognizance, provided counsel stands in the breach. Tho argu ments will pro'uabiy take all day Mon day and the charge will be given on Tuesday morning. ♦
A brief editorial comment states that the case against Lizzie Borden should never have been started, buried among miscellaneous political and tariff commentary. No further detail or argument is given to support this claim.
Evening Journal · 19 June 1893 · page 2
MONDAY. JUNE 19. 180.1. It seems now that the case against Lizzie Borden should never have been begun. Fbatheks sprinkled through the salad is not an absolute proof that it is not made of veal.
A Tribune correspondent reports that closing arguments in the Lizzie Borden trial are set to begin, contrasting the deliberate pace of Massachusetts court procedure with the faster style of New York courts. The writer praises the Massachusetts system as more dignified and better suited to ensuring justice.
New-York Tribune · 19 June 1893 · page 1
READY FOR THE ARGUMENTS. THE SUMMING UP IN THE BORDEN CASE TO BEGIN TO-DAY
TO MAKE A GREAT SPEECH. (PROM A STAFF CORRESPONDENT OF THE TRIBUNE.) New-Bedford, June 1#.—If Lizzie Borden were being tried in New-York City tt would be pos.
A journalist describes the procedural decorum of the Lizzie Borden trial, noting the defense has raised only three objections and praising the judges' dignified, reserved conduct. The writer speculates, based on the judges' demeanor alone, that they privately believe the charge against Borden has not been proven.
New-York Tribune · 19 June 1893 · page 1
NO FRIVOLOUS ORJECTIONS MADE. No frivolous or technical objections have heen made in this case, The defence have taken just three exceptions to the rulings of the Court. Ordinarily the decisions of the Court as to the admissibility of evidence are delivered in a word or two—as, “the witness may answer:” or, “the question is excluded :” and there the matter ends, I think that the three judges presiding over this trial are of the opinion that the charge against Lizzie Borden has not been proved. But my opinion is predicted on nothing they have said or done during the trial.
See moreSee less
It is simply an assumption that men of their intelligence and judicial expe'rience and training must have arrived at that concinsion. On the bench they have heen silent, | reserved, not in the least austere, but thoroughly | dignified and serious. The Chief Justice does all | the talking that is done. When an objection is made he looks at his associates and they nod yes or no; or, he consults a moment privately
The report praises defense attorney Governor Robinson's oratorical skills and natural, sincere speaking manner, contrasting him with other famous orators. It argues the evidence against Lizzie Borden is weak and contradictory, with no clear motive established for the brutal ax murders of her father and stepmother.
New-York Tribune · 19 June 1893 · page 2
GOVERNOR ROBINSON'S OPPORTUNITY.
uses simple language, direct and little illustrated with metaphor. He is passionate, but the fire is that of nature: it is not a forced heat. He has a heart himself, feelings, impulses and eympathies, and he knows just how to reveal them go as to awaken a true response in the hearts of others. He has humor, but it js grim: wit, but it is deadly. His argumentative faculty moves in a manner so simple, and by processes 80 seeniingly necessary, one after another, as to efface the appearance of that adroitness which has controlled them from the first step to the last.
See moreSee less
Governor Robinson will make a great speech for Lizzie Borden. And what an opportunity: His client is a woman, young, and if not beautiful, at least not without looks and manners that engaz® attention and appeal warmly for respect. She is on trial for her life as the result of one of the most bewildering and horribly fascinating trazedies with which human feeling las ever heen
The report argues that no credible motive has been established against Lizzie Borden, noting Emma Borden's testimony that her mother had no enemies. It questions the prosecution's theory, pointing out the five-year gap since the $1,500 property dispute and the logical inconsistency of delayed revenge, while also noting the practical impossibility of an unknown killer escaping unseen.
New-York Tribune · 19 June 1893 · page 2
Borden last Friday. “None at all that I ever heard of,” was the prompt reply. “Not in all the world?” “No, I am sure she had no enemies.” Nor had he. There is not a touch of fact on which to base a motive against the prisoner at the bar excepting that five or six years ago her father gave her stepmother's half-sister a beggarly present of £1,500, and that his daughfers thougiit they ought to have as much. Well, he gave it to them, and there the matter ended. There were eighteen blows with a hatchet made in Mrs.
See moreSee less
Borden's head: ten in Mr. Borden's. If it was Lizzie who made them, and on account of a §7,500 transaction five vears ago, from which she issned satistied, why should she have waited #0 long? Revenge 1s a quick, not a slow, pasgion, and Lizzie Borden conld have had no other. Her father's money was, in the end, sure to be hers, and the end was close af hand But if it was not she, who was it? Who stole into the locked and bolted Louse, ascended to its second story, dashed in murderous fury upon that guiltless, inoffensive old woman, came down to the first floor without leaving a spot of blood to show his trail, and some tim», pregnmably as much as an hour later, selecting the one moment when it would have been possible to do it unobserved, killed the old man, equally harmless, and in the end escaped as successtully as if he had melted. This, to be sure, is not that jury's charze. It is no part of their business to discover who Killed Andrew Borden and his wife, It js theirs only to
The report describes Lizzie Borden's ordeal under public scrutiny and prosecution, then praises defense attorney Mr. Adams for his behind-the-scenes diligence despite being overshadowed by Governor Robinson in court. It credits Adams with researching law, identifying prosecution weaknesses, and supporting the defense team selflessly.
New-York Tribune · 19 June 1893 · page 2
EXCELLENT WORK OF MR. ADAMS.
The words of this article could not be separated from the rest of its page. Read it in the clipping.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
Evening Star · Washington, D.C. · and 1 other paper
Defense counsel ex-Governor Robinson systematically addresses the prosecution's evidence, offering alternative explanations for the blood spot, Lizzie's varying statements, the burned dress, and her demeanor after the murders. He argues each piece of circumstantial evidence is consistent with innocence rather than guilt.
Evening Star · 19 June 1893 · page 6
dence. ANALYZINO THS ZvIDZCEz. After eautioning the jury to disregard certain parts of the district attorney's opening as not proved by the evidence, the ex-governor pro ceeded to dispose of certain points of the prose cution's evidence in detail. The only connection between defendant and the crimes was the blood spot on the skirt,which was exotainable as men strual blood. The proposition that Lizzie must have seeu Mrs. Borden's body when upstairs was unsound, because the body could be seen from only one stair, and there she would not stop and look if she did not suspect wrong.
See moreSee less
Lizzie's statement that her mother had received a note and gone out was plain if Mrs. Borden told both Lizzie and Bridget about it, and that they could not believe Lizzie tied about it. Lizzie's varying statements that she was in the yard and the barn were reconcilable. The testimony of three men proved thai Rubinaki saw the defendant coming to the house from the barn, and there fore her statement of her u hereabouts at the time of the murders was true. When Lizzie
Ex-Gov. Robinson delivers the defense's closing argument, countering prosecution evidence point by point including the dress burning, Matron Reagan's testimony, and the murder weapon. He also suggests an outside assassin could have committed the crime, while a separate dispatch describes the packed courtroom scene.
Evening Star · 19 June 1893 · page 6
ANALYZING THE EVIDENCE
Scenes in the Court Roese. pectal Dispatch to The Eveninr Star. Naw BEDFORD. MaSS., Jue 19.-The great itrator be. we Brazil aud Argentine in the jes attle for Lizzie Borden's life is now going on I a the court room. Every inch of standing I
On the eve of closing arguments in New Bedford, defense counsel Governor Robinson and his team spent Sunday preparing their case, aware the prosecution's Hosea Knowlton would speak last to the jury. The report notes rumors to be raised, including a claim Lizzie was naked when she discovered her mother's body and a story about a missing foster-nephew.
The Indianapolis Journal · 19 June 1893 · page 4
IN BEHALF OF MISS BORDEN
About a Hissing Foster-3ebbew. New Bedford, Mas.. Jane IS. The night before the legal battle is. as is niual in most conflicts, a particularly quiet and uneventful time. ' The work of preparation among the counsel in the Borden case has
On the eve of closing arguments, former Governor Robinson is readying what is expected to be the greatest speech of his legal career, facing prosecutor Hosea Knowlton who will have the advantage of speaking last to the jury. Local opinion holds that Lizzie Borden will likely be acquitted or the jury will disagree, and reports of discord among jurors are dismissed as baseless rumor.
The Indianapolis Journal · 19 June 1893 · page 4
The government has the best end of the argument because it has the ears of the jury last, and it is barely possible that, provided the jury have not the most re tentive minds in the world, the words last spoken and heard may fall on most fertile ground. The consensus of opinion here is that Miss Borden will be acquitted in short
The report discusses the defense's expected arguments about the mysterious note Lizzie claimed her stepmother received, and the unresolved question of its existence. It also details a new lead from Baltimore, where a boarding house keeper claims a young man named Felix Borden, allegedly connected to the Borden family, told her 'Lizzie did it' and matched descriptions of a stranger seen near the Borden home on the murder morning.
The Indianapolis Journal · 19 June 1893 · page 4
A MUstnc Witness. New York, Jnne 1& The World's special frcm Baltimore says: Mrs. Ramsey, who keeps a boarding house at No. oo3 St. Paul street, says that previous to the Borden murders a boy came from New England and boarded with her. He told her that he was the adopted son of Lizzie Borden's uncle, and that his name was Felix Borden. He said that his parent's name was Dere chases. From all accounts he did not live happily with the Bordens, and as a result of a disagreement with them he left home suddenly.
See moreSee less
Felix told Mrs. Hamsey that his home was In New Bedford or Fall Kiver. He 6pent his money freely. He did not pay his board bill and left, saying that he was going to his home in Massachusetts to get iiiouey to settle. A few days after Felix loft the Borden murders were committed and be returned to Baltimore. On one oc casion Mrs. Kamftey spoke to Felix about the murders. She says that he replied: "Ob, Lizzie did it." Being asked if the young man was ever heard to make any threatening remarks about the Bordens, of 'Massachusetts, Mrs. Ramsey said: "During the two years Felix lived here bespoke frequently of the Bordens, and. judging from his remarks, I did not think he cared very much for them. He referred, 1 remember, on one occasion, to some old woman up there, and did not speak very complimentary of her. I judged from his remarks that he bad a quarrel with his peo ple before he cacio here, although ho never told me tho particulars.'' Asked to describe tho young man, Mrs. Ramsey said he was a medium-sized fellow with dark hair, and when he left wss twenty-one years old. His description, it is said, tallies with that given by several witnesses on Thursday, who ssid they saw a 6trantre young man at the Borden gate the niornidtr of the murder. Young Borden left Uultiinore last fall and has not been heard of hero since.
A German-American newspaper's daily commentary column remarks that the Lizzie Borden trial can now conclude, since public opinion has already acquitted her. It adds that it would be remarkable if the real murderer were still found.
Der Deutsche Correspondent · 19 June 1893 · page 2
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
The report briefly notes that in the murder trial against Lizzie Borden in New Bedford, Massachusetts, the lawyers will begin their closing arguments today. It is one short item among many unrelated news briefs in this column.
Der Deutsche Correspondent · 19 June 1893 · page 6
In dem Mordprozesse gegen Lizzie Borden zu New Bedsord, Mass., werden d>e Anwälie heute ihre Argumente beginnen. General A. Ballon Caldwell, der erste Generalanwalt von West-Virginien, und ei ner der Gründer des neuen Staates, ist ge stern Abend in Wheeling, W.-Va., plötzlich
A New York World special reports that a Baltimore boarding house keeper, Mrs. Ramsey, says a young man calling himself Felix Borden, claiming to be an adopted relative of Lizzie Borden's uncle, boarded with her before the murders and later said 'Oh, Lizzie did it' when asked about the case. The man reportedly left suddenly for Massachusetts just before the murders and returned to Baltimore afterward.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
Daily Kennebec Journal · 19 June 1893 · page 1
A Strange Young Man Appears in the Borden Case. I SItry him (tlliMrt That May Pouibl, Unravel the Mystery. New Y«>kk.June 1H.—A World* special from Baltimore says tliat .Mrs. Kamscv .* ho Kcci»s a boarding house at i».V* St. Paul greet, ssyt that previous to the Borden murders m boy came from Nee F.ngl.-tud uni boarded with her. He told her that he was the adopted sou »f Lizzie Borden s uncle and ins name wan Kelix Borden. He said that hi* patvi t* lame was Desroches. From all account* ie did not live happily with the Bunions, md as a result of a disagreement »ltli them , »e left home suddenly.
See moreSee less
Felix told Mrs. Kainsey that in* home »a* in New Bedford or Fall Kivcr. lie ipent money freely. He did not pay hi* •oard hill and left, saying he wa* going to , lie iioinc in Massachusetts to gel money to , fettle. , A few days after Felix left, the Borden . norder* were committed and he returned o Baltimore. On one occasion Mrs. Ham ( icy Hpoke to Felix shout the murders. Nln fays lie replied : “Oh, Lizzie did it.” Asked if the young man w as ever beared t o make any threatening remarks about tin , tordens of Massachusetts, Mrs. Itauisc) aid : "During the two years that Felix lived icre, he spoke frequently of the Bordens, md judging from his remurks, I did not (link he eared very much for them, lie , ef erred, 1 remember, on one occasion to 4 omc old woman up there and did iiots|a*ak n very complimentary terms of her. I udged front his remarks that he had a luarrel with his people Itefore he came here, | dthough he never told me the particulars.” Mr. Ramsey said the young man was a nediuni-si/.ed fellow, with dark hair, and rlion he left w as 21 years old. Hi* de cription, it is said, tallies with that given , >y several witnesses in the Borden trial. , I'hursday, who said they saw a strange oung man at the Borden gate on the morn- * ng of the murder. . Young Borden left Baltimore last fall and las not been heard of here.
A Baltimore boarding-house landlady recounts that a young lodger named Felix, who left town around the time of the Borden murders, once remarked 'Lizzie did it' when asked about the case. She also notes he spoke disparagingly of the Bordens and resembled a stranger witnesses saw at the Borden gate the morning of the murders.
Daily Kennebec Journal · 19 June 1893 · page 1
Unravel the Mystery. New Y«>kk.June 1H.—A World* special from Baltimore says tliat .Mrs. Kamscv .* ho Kcci»s a boarding house at i».V* St. Paul greet, ssyt that previous to the Borden murders m boy came from Nee F.ngl.-tud uni boarded with her. He told her that he was the adopted sou »f Lizzie Borden s uncle and ins name wan Kelix Borden. He said that hi* patvi t* lame was Desroches. From all account* ie did not live happily with the Bunions, md as a result of a disagreement »ltli them , »e left home suddenly.
See moreSee less
Felix told Mrs. Kainsey that in* home »a* in New Bedford or Fall Kivcr. lie ipent money freely. He did not pay hi* •oard hill and left, saying he wa* going to , lie iioinc in Massachusetts to gel money to , fettle. , A few days after Felix left, the Borden . norder* were committed and he returned o Baltimore. On one occasion Mrs. Ham ( icy Hpoke to Felix shout the murders. Nln fays lie replied : “Oh, Lizzie did it.” Asked if the young man w as ever beared t o make any threatening remarks about tin , tordens of Massachusetts, Mrs. Itauisc) aid : "During the two years that Felix lived icre, he spoke frequently of the Bordens, md judging from his remurks, I did not (link he eared very much for them, lie , ef erred, 1 remember, on one occasion to 4 omc old woman up there and did iiots|a*ak n very complimentary terms of her. I udged front his remarks that he had a luarrel with his people Itefore he came here, | dthough he never told me the particulars.” Mr. Ramsey said the young man was a nediuni-si/.ed fellow, with dark hair, and rlion he left w as 21 years old. Hi* de cription, it is said, tallies with that given , >y several witnesses in the Borden trial. , I'hursday, who said they saw a strange oung man at the Borden gate on the morn- * ng of the murder. . Young Borden left Baltimore last fall and las not been heard of here.
The report notes that Emma Borden gave a plausible explanation for the dress Lizzie burned after the murders. It also describes how the defense's attempt to introduce testimony about a bloodstained man with a hatchet seen in nearby woods was properly excluded by the court.
Daily Kennebec Journal · 19 June 1893 · page 2
Emma Borden's explanation about that dreas her sister Lizzie burned, was a »m plausible one. » J aJl means Boston should have a new music hail if the old one has got to go be fore tiie advance of rapid transit. The starch trust wasn’t stiff enough to stand under the wilting depression in “in dost rials." Trusts aren t to be trusted any
This editorial discusses defense evidence about a bloodstained man with a hatchet near Fall River that was excluded from the Borden trial, suggesting police should investigate further. It also critiques the lack of sympathy shown toward Lizzie Borden by women spectators during the trial, contrasting this with typical female solidarity.
Daily Kennebec Journal · 19 June 1893 · page 2
The Borden defense offered to prove that August 18th a man spotted with blood an*! carrying a hatchet was seen in the wood* four miles from Fall River and wa* hear! t«» exclaim “poor Mr*. Borden." This pro posed evidence was properly excluded hut the public would like to know about it. At least the poliee should have been informed of the evidence and if so the public would also like to know what they’ve done about it. — Woman need not take exceptions to a little criticism mingled with the many com pliment* bestowed on her from every source.
See moreSee less
The criticism arises from a con spicuous illustration of what has long been recognized as womans inhumanity to woman. The illustration wa* afforded by the Borden trial and consisted in tin’ fact that scarcely one kind word was spoken to Lizzie Borden during the trial by one of her own sex. and every |>oiiit gained by the defense only too apparently disappointed the women among the spectator*. Supposing Lizzie Borden guilty . Alim was known to be guilty of the crudest possible crime on one of their own sex and yet expression* of aym paihy from women were not altogether wanting. Harris, the wife murderer ex cite*I quite a degree of sympathy among tome women. Indeed woman is regarded aa a more sympathetic j being than man and one ualurally expert* a more lavish expression of it from her than from the sterner sex. Her fidelity to roan, brother or husband, often times sur passes the comprehension. But woman * fidelity to woman is markedly less than man’s fidelity to man. The most damaging testimony against I*izzie Borden come from one who waa her intimate friend and it was
A special dispatch from Portland to the Haverhill Gazette reports that ex-Governor Robie believes the government failed to prove its case against Lizzie Borden. He also praised ex-Governor Robinson's skill as a criminal defense lawyer.
Daily Kennebec Journal · 19 June 1893 · page 2
A special to the Haverhill Gazette from Portland i* as follow* : The talk of the city is about the Borden trial. Yesterday after noon ex-Governor Robie, who has followed the case with great interest, said that it seemed to him that the government had failed to prove its case, and that ex-Gorer nor Robinson had showed himself a great criminal lawyer. Rev. A. S. Ladd, of Bangor is on an ex tended trip into Washington county. Sunday he was to spend at Machias and East Machi as, the following at Calais ami Milltown and the first Sunday in July xt East port. He will address the Ministerial Association xt East Machias and visit Cooper, Alexan dria, Pembroke. Perrv, etc. He will reach home about July 7.
A Baltimore boarding house keeper, Mrs. Ramsay, claims a young man calling himself Felix Borden, who said he was adopted into the Borden family, spoke disparagingly of the Bordens and once remarked 'Oh, Lizzie did it!' when asked about the murders. A sailor is also mentioned as separately claiming to have committed the murder himself.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
The Portland Daily Press · 19 June 1893 · page 1
TWO MORE MURDERERS.
New Yobk, June 18.—The World’* special from Baltimore says that Mrs. Bamsay, who keeps a boarding house at 333 St. Paul street, says that previous to the Borden murders a boy came from New England and boarded with her. He told her he was the adopted son of Lizzie Borden’s uncle. His name was Felix Borden. He said his parsnta’ name was Desroches. From all acoounts he did not live happily with the Bordens and as a result of a disagreement with them he left home suddenly. Felix told Mrs. Bamsay that his home was in New Bed ford or Fall Biver.
See moreSee less
He spent money freely but did not pay his board hill and left, saying he was going to his home in Mas sachusetts to get the money to settle. A few days after Felix left the Borden mur ders were committed. He returned to Baltimore and on one occasion sion Mrs. Bamsay spoke to him about the murders. She says he replied: “Oh, Lizzie did it!’’ Asked if the young naan was ever heard to make any threatening remarks about the Bordens of Massachu setts, Mrs. Bamsay said: “During the two years Felix lived here, he spoke fre quently of (the Bordens and, judging trom his remarks, l dia not think he cared very much for them. He referred, I remember, on one occasion, to some old woman up there and did not speak in very complimeutary terms of her. I judged from his remarks that he had quarreled with his people before he came here, although he never told me the par ticulars.” Mrs. Ramsay said the young man was a medium sized fellow with dark hair. When he left he was 21 years old. His description, it is said, tallies with that given by several witnesses in the Borden trial Thursday, who said they saw a strange young man at the Borden gate en the morning of the murder. Yeung Bor den left Baltimore last fall and has not been heard of there since.
A Baltimore landlady recalls a boarder named Felix who left for Massachusetts just before the murders and later jokingly blamed Lizzie; his description allegedly matches a stranger seen at the Borden gate. A separate account from Ohio describes a sailor who confessed to murdering the Bordens for revenge before disappearing.
The Portland Daily Press · 19 June 1893 · page 1
Murderer Was a Sailor. Springfield, O., June 17.—Charles H. ■ Berry, a well known real estate man and politician, is likely to play an important part in solving the mystery which hangs over the great Borden murder at New Bedford. Last Octobera stranger came to this city and sought Berry, who then ran an employment agency, for work. Berry’s kind treatment gained the fel low’s confidence and he confided to him that he had murdered the Bordens for revenge, also that he was a sailor. This sustains the theory that the murder was committed by a sailor for some wrong inflicted on his father by Borden many years ago.
See moreSee less
The fellow wanted to give himself up, but finally disappeared. Berry had forgotten the incident until he saw an account of the mysterious in dividual who related a similar story to a barber in New Jersey, and the descrip tion given tallies with the man who called on Berry.
A reader wrote to the Hartford Courant objecting to newspapers using the familiar name 'Lizzie' Borden instead of 'Elizabeth,' calling it a tasteless outrage. The editor replied that since she was indicted under the name 'Lizzie Borden,' the press has little choice but to use that name.
The Portland Daily Press · 19 June 1893 · page 4
Miss Borden as “Lizzie” Borden. The correspondent declares that her name is “Elizabeth,” and that it is not only bad taste but a positive outrage to call her by any other name. In reply the editor of the Courant points out that the woman has been indicted as “Lizzie Borden,” and therefore that the newspapers can do nothing else but call her by that name. In England the newspapers would speak of her simply as “Borden,” no distinc
The report describes the quiet but intense preparations made by defense counsel Gov. Robinson and the prosecution before the final day of arguments in the Lizzie Borden trial. It notes public expectation leans toward a disagreement or acquittal, and highlights the rhetorical duel expected between Robinson and prosecutor Hosea Knowlton.
St. Paul Daily Globe · 19 June 1893 · page 4
THE BORDEN BATTLE. It Will Be Fiercely Fought Today by the Legal Fraternity. Gov. Robinson Amply Prepared to Make the Effort of His Life. A Disagreement or Acquittal Generally Expected by the Public.
Nkw Bedfoiu. Mass., June IS.— The night before the legal battle is, as is usual in most conflicts, a particularly quiet and uneventful time. The work of preparation among .the counsel In the Borden case has been going on all
On the eve of closing arguments, the report describes Gov. Robinson preparing his defense summation against prosecutor Hosea Knowlton, with speculation that Borden will be acquitted or the jury will disagree. It also dismisses as false a rumor of disagreement among jurors, claiming relations among them have been pleasant.
St. Paul Daily Globe · 19 June 1893 · page 4
THE BORDEN BATTLE.
Justice and Truth of the cause he has undertaken, and will devote his best energies to making an impression upon the twelve good men and true, such as cannot be readily overcome and entirely obliterated by the fierce, invective and fetching elo quence of Hosea M. Knowlton, his op ponent in this legal tilt. The govern ment has the best end of the argument, because it has the ears of the jury last, and it is barely possible that, provided the jury have not tho most retentive minds in the world, the words last spoken and heard may fall upon most fertile ground. The consensus of opin ion here is that Miss Borden will be
The report describes anticipated crowds for closing arguments, denies rumors of jury disagreement, and clarifies the sequence behind the controversial double warrant issued for Lizzie Borden's arrest. It also relays courthouse gossip that the prosecution will argue Lizzie was nude during one murder and wore a dress she later burned during the other.
St. Paul Daily Globe · 19 June 1893 · page 4
» Pleasant Relations have been maintained, and it will not be a surprising thing if every Juno hereafter there should be a festive re union of the Borden jury to commem orate this delightfully bright spot in their career. It has just come to the knowledge of the Associated Press that the true inwardness of the double warrant business is this: When Marshal Billiard came to the con clusion that it was necessary to closely watch Lizzie Borden, he swore out a war-rant for her arrest, trying, however, to consult Mr.
See moreSee less
Knowlton about the matter. The latter was at his sum mer home in Marion, and could not be reached by telephone. When he came up on the day of the inquest, Marshal Hilliard had the warrant duly made out and in his pocket. After the inquest the district attorney said: "Have a warrant made out and arrest her," or words to that effect, and the marshal replied that he had one already. But Mr. Knowlton said that this would not do; there must be a warrant made out to fit the case, he understanding and appreciating, even at that time, the very point which Gov. Robinson used so effectively in barring out the testimony of Miss Borden at the inquest. it is fair to state that the first warrant was issued wholly without Mr.Knowlton's knowl edge or sanction, according to Mr. Hill lard's statement, although the latter tried to consult the lawyer before he obtained it. The arguments will prob ably take all day Monday, and the charge will be given on Tuesday morn ing. It being impossible for the jury to leave the court room after receiving the charge, it is considered as not quite fair to start them in on the last stage of the proceedings at nightfall. Sensation Promised.
A filler item reports that most women in Fall River believe Lizzie Borden is guilty, while men tend to support her innocence. It reflects the gendered divide in public opinion during her ongoing murder trial.
St. Paul Daily Globe · 19 June 1893 · page 5
Mr. High will now have to get out a new and revised editiou ot "High on Injunctions." Chief Justice FULLER has matte some modifications necessary. « It is reported that a large portion of the female population of Fall River be lieves Lizzie Borden to be guilty. It is
This editorial, published the day before the verdict, predicts that Lizzie Borden will be acquitted due to lack of proof, though it argues public opinion may never fully exonerate her. It reflects on the mystery surrounding the Borden murders and suggests the truth may never be known.
The Jersey City News · 19 June 1893 · page 2
MONDAY, JUNE 19. 1893. This paper is Democratic in principles and is independent tn its views on all local questiojis. The Borden Mystery. To all intents and purposes, the tale of the Borden murders will reach its last page today or tomorrow. The verdict of “not guilty,” which the jury to a certainty will bring in, will stand as the word “Finis” to as strange a history as can be found in the an nals of crime. There is not the least reason to hope that in the future any thing will shed any new light upon tne mystery oi tuose two uiu people » death, and until the whole affair dies out of memory with the contem porary generations, it will always re main doubtful whether Lizzie Borden
An opinion piece faults the Fall River police for amateurish handling of the Borden murder scene, contrasting them with trained European detectives who would have preserved evidence and made careful records before theorizing. It argues for a state-maintained corps of skilled detectives to avoid such gross errors in future cases.
The Jersey City News · 19 June 1893 · page 2
Porce not only did their own work ill, but they allowed all sorts of out siders to overrun the house and prem ises of the Bordens, affording endless opportunity for dispersion of evidence , of the crime, and introducing Dew Is marks and traces eminently calculated to baffle and mislead. It ought really be the duty of every State to main * tain a small but thoroughly equipped corps of detectives for emergencies of this kind, and to make their employ ment depend, not on invariable suc cess, of course, in detecting criminals, v. but upon the invariable avoidance of 1 gross errors and blunders..
At the New Bedford courthouse, crowds packed in as ex-Gov. Robinson began his closing argument for the defense, describing the Borden murders as a dastardly crime that shocked everyone. He emphasized the need to find the true culprit while noting his client Lizzie Borden appeared calm, holding pinks, with no complaint of persecution.
The Evening World · 19 June 1893 · page 1
Knll R'ver Detoctlve Work. NEW nEDFORD. Mass., Juno 19. Th day of the argumen tB In the Borden case brought out a terrific Jam at the court house, and over an hour before the
Ex-Governor Robinson opens his closing argument for the defense, calling the murders a dastardly crime likely committed by a maniac rather than a careless amateur. He criticizes the prosecution's investigation as one-sided and urges the jury to disregard inferences from the preliminary hearing.
The Evening World · 19 June 1893 · page 1
EX-GOV. ROBINSON SUMS UP. "May It please Your Honors, Mr. Foreman and Gentlemen: One of the most dastardly and diabolical crimes ever committed la Massachusetts was perpetrated In August, 1892, In Fall River. The enormity of It startled everybody; every man feels that the wrong should be righted and the wick ed brought to Justice. Here was a crime with all Its horrors, and ''Who ' could have done such an act?' says everybody. In the quiet of a home, In tho broad daylight, on the streets of a populous city, who could have done It?
See moreSee less
"Inspection showed Mrs. Borden had been slain by the uso of some sharp Instrument, and below stairs was Mr. Borden's mutilated body. The terrors of those scenes no language can por trny, and we are challenged at the out set to find who was equal to that enor mlty. whose whole heart is blackened with crime. A maniac, not a man of sense and heart, a lunatic, a devil. They were well directed blows which caused those deaths, not directed by a blunderer, none going amiss. Surely we can say at the .outset this was not tho careless, untrained' doing of one unfa miliar with such work. "Now, suspicion begins to fall here ond everywhere. They surround this and that one, and follow out clues everywhere. No decent man complains of Investigation, and everything ought to be done, but we say evorythlng was not done and the proper methods not taken."
Lizzie Borden's defense counsel addresses the jury, urging them to weigh evidence carefully and avoid being swayed by police bias or public opinion. He reminds jurors that the law permits no inference of guilt from the defendant's choice not to testify.
The Evening World · 19 June 1893 · page 1
NO COMPLAINT OF PERSECUTION.
committed the deed upon which he Is I at work. j "The witness-stand brings out their weakness when they knock their own heads together, but after all they show themselves to be only men with human weakness. So I say to you, this de fendant comes before you perfectly sat isfied that the Jury Is tho most refresh ing aspect that the eye of human beings ever feasted hpon. You aro men, Bris tol County men, with hearts, heads, souls and right minds, and you come here In obedience to the laws, because In answer to their demands you must render this great service.
See moreSee less
You are loyal to the State and to common humanity. Bring your hearts, your homes and your Intellect here and let us talk to you as men. "Lizzie A. Borden has been In your charge from the day we opened this
At New Bedford, ex-Governor Robinson delivers his closing argument for the defense of Lizzie Borden, describing the brutal nature of the murders and arguing the crime was committed by a maniac. The courtroom was packed with spectators, mostly women, and Lizzie Borden appeared composed, holding a bunch of pinks.
The Evening World · 19 June 1893 · page 1
CLOSING THE CASE.
In? cx-Uov. Jtoblnson began his argu Mcnt. He said: EX-GOV. IIOBINSON SUMS UP. "May it please Your Honors, Mr. Foreman and Gentlemen: One of the most dasUrdly and diabolical crimes i ever committed In Massachusetts was perpetrated In August, lk'J2, In Fall Itlver. Tho enormity of It startled everybody; every man feels that the wrong should be righted and the wlck eJ brought to Justice. "Inspection showed .Mrs. Borden had been slain by ' the use of some Bharp instrument, and below stairs was Mr. Borden's mutilated body. The terrors of those 'scenes no language can por tray, and we are challenged at the out let to find who was equal to that enor mity, whose whole heart Is blackened with crime.
See moreSee less
A maniac, not a man of sense and heart, n lunatic, a devil. They were well directed blows which (.lused those deaths,, not directed by a blunderer, none going amiss. Surely wo an say at the outset this was not the tarelcss, untrained doing of one unfa miliar with such work.
Defense counsel urges jurors to judge Lizzie Borden solely on proven facts, insisting the prosecution is not motivated by malice but simply presenting the case given to them by Fall River police. He stresses that guilt must be established to a moral and mathematical certainty before conviction, asking jurors to use common sense rather than be swayed by outside opinion.
The Evening World · 19 June 1893 · page 1
NO COMPLAINT OF PERSECUTION.
cover up what Is inside. The officer Is 1 always magnifying this and minimizing that, and looking for the one who committed the deed upon which he Is at work. "I.l72le A. Borden has been In your charge from tho day we opened this case, and that was your oath, and now comes the time when not alone are her lawyers to speak for her nnd the Jus tices to speak, but you twelve men take hir In charge. She Isn't the property of anybody, but a free. Intelligent, In
The defense attorney argues in closing that no bloodstains were found on Lizzie except one tiny speck, and mocks the prosecution's theory about burned paper possibly concealing a hatchet handle. He also defends her laughter on the stairs and her account of her whereabouts, arguing innocent explanations exist for all the circumstantial evidence.
The Evening World · 19 June 1893 · page 1
CHASE UP THAT HATCHET, HANDLE
DLE. "Wo thought that the Government was going to claim that the hatchet handle was In that paper nnd that the wood had nil burned out and left the envelope, and we worried about this until Mullaly and Fleet got here to gether; now we know the orphan han dle is still flying In the alr.For heaven's sake get the 12J policemen of Fall River to chase It up and put It where It be longs. "Now you are to conceive of tho mur derer standing over the woman on the floor, and you are to consider how Mr.
See moreSee less
Borden was slain. Now, what reason (s there to consider this defendunt guilty? Whnt right have they to say she is? Well, first they say she was In the house. Well, that may bo tho wrong place for her to be because It Is her own home; perhaps It might be bet ter for her to be travelling the streets, but I don't think so. "She was In her room when they say Mrs. Borden's body wns lying on the floor, and that she must have seen the body. But you have been shown that you enn't stand on that landing and look Into the guest chamber. And then they sav that when she went down stairs sho could have seen the body, nnd therefore ought to have seen It. But people don't go about their own houses playing the detective, and If she had done thnt thing he Commonwealth would have said she knew of It and wns the murderer. The testlmonv of three men was cited to prove that lliiblnsky saw the defend ant coming to the house from the barn, and, therefore, her statement of her whereabouts at the time of the murders
Ex-Governor Robinson delivers his closing argument defending Lizzie Borden, describing the murders as dastardly and diabolical crimes committed by a maniac or devil. He references the brutal nature of the killings and critiques the Fall River detective work.
The Evening World · 19 June 1893 · page 1
CLOSING THE CASE.
EX-GOV. ROBINSON SUMS UP. "May It please Your Honors, Mr. Foreman and Gentlemen: Una of the mest dastardly and diabolical crimes ewr committed In Massachusetts was po.polrutcd In August, 1S1C. In Fall luver. Tho enormity of It startled everybody; every man feels that the vtuiig should be righted and the wick ed brought to Justice. "Inspection showed Mrs. Borden had been slain by the use of some sharp Instrument, and below stairs was Mr. lJurden'H mutilated body. The terrors of those scenes no language can por tray, and we are challenged at the oiltV set to Und" who was ejual to that cnorr.t ty, whose whole heart Is blackened with crime.
See moreSee less
A maniac, not a man of Et-use and heart. a lunatic, a dcyU. 'lliey were well directed blows which l i-sed those deaths, not directed by n bWnderer, none going umlss. Surely we can sai at the outset thts was not the drcliss, untrained doing of one unfa miliar with such work.
Ex-Gov. Robinson begins his closing argument in Lizzie Borden's defense before a packed New Bedford courtroom, calling the Borden murders a dastardly and diabolical crime. He describes the gruesome discovery of Mrs. Borden's body and Mr. Borden's mutilated corpse, suggesting the killer was a maniac rather than a sane person.
The Evening World · 19 June 1893 · page 1
CLOSING THE CASE
Foreman and Gentlemen: One of the -)M most dastardly and diabolical crimes) JI ever committed In Massachusetts was :3M perpetrated In August, 1832, ln Fall .1t River. The enormity ot it startled . everybody; every man feels that the !" wrong should be righted and the wick- . ed brought to Justice. 'W "Inspection showed Mrs. Borden had' .;- been slain by the use of some sharp ' Instrument, and below stairs was Mr. U Borden's mutlUtaaV-body. The terrors JJM of those scenes no language can por- .JB tray, and we are challenged at the out3fl set to find who was equal to that enor- '?
See moreSee less
mlty, whose whole heart Is blackened ': with crime. A maniac, not a man of sense and heart, a lunatic, a devU. ; They were well directed blows which " caused those deaths, not directed by av1 '-jM blunderer, none going amlaa. Surely we a!M can say at the outset this was not the ifB careless, untrained doing of one unfa- &9 miliar with such work. ,SM
A defense attorney addresses the jury, insisting the prosecution is not motivated by persecution but is simply presenting the case given to it by Fall River police. He urges jurors to judge Lizzie Borden solely on proven facts, calling her a free and innocent woman whose life is in their hands.
The Evening World · 19 June 1893 · page 1
NO COMPLAINT OF PERSECUTION.
the part of the commonwealth, only a .JB Kresentatlon of what has been proved .& ero and only that" tm Here the speaker referred to the iM klnd(y manner ln which the Sheriff had ?) used Miss Borden, and said: i zm "She came Into thlB court, presided r.f over by our ablest Justices, who want ,J1J the commonwealth's case tried fairly. ftM and now you are only to deal with the 5 fucts. I sntd the case was Drought here ( by the Fall River police. I" haven't itM time to go into sarcasm and denunclaCw tlon.
See moreSee less
The blue coat nnd brass buttons iJJl cover up what Is Inside. The officer Is -& always magnifying this and mlulmlxlnar ; that, and looking for the one who fiW committed the deed upon which be Is at work. tMJ "Lizzie A. Borden has been In your 11BJ charge from the day we opened this -"caW
This report covers a defense attorney's closing argument in the Borden trial, addressing the burned paper found by Harrington, the handleless hatchet, and the claim that Lizzie should have seen her stepmother's body. The lawyer argues the prosecution's inferences about her whereabouts and behavior, including her laughter on the stairs, do not prove guilt.
The Evening World · 19 June 1893 · page 2
K, Insinuations floatln..- around that Dr. H Bowcn knew something about Jt. iaKCHA8U UP THAT HATOHI3T HANkmmWt "We thought that the Government fe was BOlnk to claim that the .hatchet r handle was In that paper nnd that the K; wood had all burned out and left tie LjilMtrr envelope, and we worried about this K' until Mullaly and Fleet Kot here tok ' gether; now we know the orphan hanp 3le Is still flying In the 1'r.For heaven's mWBake Bet the 125 policemen of Fall HWcr f" to chase It up and put It where it beLasanEr longs.
See moreSee less
l iBE- "Now you are to conceive of the murSf' dercr standing over the woman on the floor, and you are to consider how Mr. UlllHr Borden was slain. Now, what reason r 1 Is there to consider this, defendant jrullty7 What right have they to lety F' she ls7 Well, first they say she was In B' the house. Well, that may be the K wrong place for her to be because It Is mmmmfJ her own home, perhaps It might be betmmKU ter for her to be travelling the streets, but I don't think sa. BmWtit "She was In her room when they say M Mrs. Borden's body was lying on the H'2. . floor, and that she must have seen the kfx body. Out you have been shown that Ki you can't stand on that landing and k.k.Bt-1 look Into the guest chamber. And then H they sav that when she went downK- stairs she could have seen tho body, K? and therefore ought to have seen It Kl But people don't go about their own mmW houses playing the dotecttve, and If she mWMffa had done that thing the Commonwealth my would have said she knew of It and il was the murderer." SbSbBT The testimony of three men was cited H1111B3 to prove that Rubinsk? Saw the defendK ant coming to the house from the barn, r' and. therefore, her statement of her HM 'Whereabouts at the time ot the murders
Former Governor Robinson, defending Lizzie Borden, argues she had no financial motive since she already had property and lacked for nothing. He dismisses testimony about strained relations with her stepmother and highlights that her father wore a ring given by Lizzie, buried with him, as evidence of family affection.
The Evening World · 19 June 1893 · page 2
LIZZIE HAD NO MOTIVE
V few years Lizzie did' not call Mrs. DorB' den mother. Mrs. Borden uas her stepHB; mother, and Lizzie had become a woman ZKi thirty years or so of age. The relation BHM of 'mother' is very tender, and there Is bbkbh-' nnthini, nniKtiinl in the fact that there Hfw' are times when nobody else can stand H; Where 'mother' does. HB" "DON'T HAY MOTHER TO ME."
Defense counsel argues points raised by the prosecution, including the ring buried with Andrew Borden, the locked doors, Lizzie's discovery of the body, her emotional reaction, and the burning of the dress. He contends these details support innocence rather than guilt.
The Evening World · 19 June 1893 · page 2
THIS WAS LIZZIE'S RING
BvK' Jiere hail been a burglary thei. . and Mr H-K Borden did not want any more chance Kt'flt for this work, fK' DISCOVERING THE CRIME. BH "They ay Lizzie rushed in and dls BjKtB sovcreel the homicide. 1'rom wlui', BjHH iiiIcbs she wus ouUldu, could Khe ruiii
A roundup column of short news items includes a note that Lizzie Borden will probably be acquitted, and a separate claim that suspicion now points to the adopted son of her uncle, who has not been seen since the murder. The item appears amid unrelated snippets on politics, Chinese registration, and German elections.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
Paper unidentified · 19 June 1893 · page 1
ELECTRIC FLASHES. Chief Justice Fuller h as I decidedjinan open fair, whicbsettles thelong contro versy. Returns show that out of 110,000 Chinese in the United States 13,139 reg istered. The German elections showthat tHO will vote for the army bill and 114 against. Lizzie Borden will probablv be ac quitted. Suspicion now points to the adopted son of Lizzie Borden's uncle, who has not been heard of since the murder. It Should Be in Every House J. B. Wilson, 371 Clay St., Sharpsburg, Pa., says he will not be without Dr.
See moreSee less
King's New Discovery for consump tion, coughs and colds, that it cured his wife who was threatened with pneumonia after an attack Of "la grippe," when various other remedies and several phy sicians had done her no good. Robert Barber, of Cooksport, Pa., claims Dr. King's New Discovery has done him more good than anything he ' ever used for lung trouble. Nothing like it. Try it. Free trial bottles at Snipes & Kinersly's. Large bottles, 50c. and1.00. I will f urn ish ice to any and all patrons at 25 cents per 100 pounds. Leave' or ders at C. F. Lauer's, or on the wagon. C. E. Allison. Wanted. in private Situation private fami v. to do Address Chronicle housework. office. 5.3t
A dispatch from New Bedford reports the trial nearing its close, noting the defense benefited from the exclusion of several key prosecution points, including inquest testimony, prussic acid purchase attempts, and witness statements about unpleasant home life. The report characterizes the government's case as weaker than the defense's at this stage.
Pawtucket Tribune · 19 June 1893 · page 1
DRAWING TO A CLOSE
Had the defense suffered in anything like such degree, the prosecution could have been consolbd, but as it was, the only witnesses on the other side whose testi mony was rejected were Joseph LeMay, who had seen a wild man in the woods, and Mrs. Mary A. Durfee, who saw a stranger sngrllg disputing with Andrew Borden fully 10 months betore the mur ders., Even if this had been admitted, it would have been somewhat difficult to ex plain how it was that a man who hade quarrelled with the husband sheuld kill the wife first. [+t us see what the prosecution at
This report summarizes the prosecution's case as argued by Mr. Moody, covering motive (friction with stepmother, prussic acid purchase, foreboding statements), the mysterious note, the bloody hatchet, and the burned dress, while noting which defense witnesses were excluded. It also highlights unresolved issues like the timing of Mrs. Borden's death relative to her husband's and the unverified note.
Pawtucket Tribune · 19 June 1893 · page 1
SUMMING UP THE EVIDENCE
Thas Puzzling Note. But the defeuse was even willing to & n cede that Mrs. Borden died an hour before her husband, for the assertion that Lizzie must have seen the body of her stepmother as she stood at the head of the stairs when her father entered the house, wgs an
This report summarizes defense testimony at the Borden trial, covering disputed points like stomach contents and time of death, the mysterious note, a possibly missing ring, and conflicting accounts of a sisters' quarrel. It highlights peddler Hyman Lubinsky's corroborated testimony that the woman he saw in the yard was not Bridget Sullivan, along with disputes over dust in the barn loft and blood evidence.
Pawtucket Tribune · 19 June 1893 · page 1
SUMMING UP THE EVIDENCE
Thas Puzzling Note. But the defeuse was even willing to & n cede that Mrs. Borden died an hour before her husband, for the assertion that Lizzie must have seen the body of her stepmother as she stood at the head of the stairs when her father entered the house, wgs an swered in another way—by the oxpeymeut tried by Uncle John and Mrs. Brigham. As to the note, althogh the Writer and Messenger were advertised for vainly, barring such of the other points, the evidence on which was not excluded, all were met either by absolute denjal of several witnesses or their equally absolute affirmation of facts which Mr.
See moreSee less
Jennings promised in his open ng argument to profe. The defense ex peoted to show by Uundertaker Renwick’s story that u ring which had been on Mr, Borden’s floger bad disappeared, but Mr, Renwick could remember nothing about it, The story of the quarrel between the sisters, and Lizzie’'s charge that Emma had “peached,” which Mrs. Reagan had insisted upon so firmly, was met with such an avalanche of denial that it was re solved to call the police matron’s testi mony in rebuttal, and she was driven in a carriage from Fall River in great haste, only to find on her arrival that there had been a change of opinion as to the wisdom of the action. It was shwn by more than half a dozen people thn 8 eral strangers, and possibly
The courtroom in New Bedford is packed with spectators eager to hear closing arguments in the Borden trial. Former Governor Robinson rises to deliver a passionate defense plea, urging the jury to acquit unless positive evidence connects Lizzie Borden to the crime.
The Providence News · 19 June 1893 · page 1
Rhode Island, and Edwin C. Pearce. Sucdenly Lizzie Borden nppeare I A hush faiis upon the room, aud as the clerk calls court, crler at last prevails, The tin e is at haund. Governor Robinson’s Plea, The great «x-governor arises, *“ May it ylease your honors: The enormity and outrage of this awfal crime set every member of society to investigating the cause of this crime and its author. Well may those who first lookel at the vie tlms sicken at heart and feel that the ties of nature had failed to keep men within the contines of eiviliz wion, “Trink of these awful blows. Eigh teen of them on the defenseless hem{‘or
A crowd of a thousand gathered outside the courthouse hoping for one of only 150 seats as Lizzie Borden's trial began. Ex-Governor George Robinson delivered the defense's opening argument, urging jurors to set aside prejudice and judge the case solely on evidence presented by the Fall River police.
Former Governor George D. Robinson, defending Lizzie Borden, tells the jury the police—not the prosecutor—built the case, and urges jurors to judge dispassionately whether she is guilty, warning against convicting on insufficient evidence just to satisfy public appetite for blood. He reminds them they have her fate in their charge and must decide only the simple question of guilt.
The Providence News · 19 June 1893 · page 1
EX-GOV. GEORGE D. ROBINSON.
He Scores the Police. “The policemen are human , made out of men and vothing elss, and the blae coat and the brass buttons ouly cover the kind of a mau that is inside, and you do not get the greatest ability in the world ins side a policeman’s coat,. “You may p.rhaps get what you want and what i< suflicient, but you must only ¢l upoa uim for such services as he can render.”’ Turping to the jury he said: *‘Lizzie Andrelv Borden fron the days when we opened the trial until this hour, has been in your eharge gentlemen.
See moreSee less
“That is the oath you took. “Aud not alone with vou, Mr. Fore man, or any one of vou, but with esch and ull of you. You have her in charge. Talks to the Jary. “Now has come the sime when not alone her lawyers are to speak for her, not alone the judges are to watch for pro tection, not alone is the learned at:ior ney of t .e commonwealth to ask no more thad he ought to have, but the twealve men who sit here to try this question, take the woman in their charge, and the comr'nonwult.h says, ‘We entrust he. to you, ; “You come bere without vrejudice or bias, I take it. You said you diu, I believed you. “I believe you now,
This report covers the defense attorney's closing argument in the Lizzie Borden trial, instructing jurors to decide only on evidence presented in court. He summarizes the timeline of Andrew Borden's movements and death, estimating Mrs. Borden died between 9:45-10:15 and Mr. Borden between 10:55-11:10, while arguing motive is irrelevant if guilt is proven.
The Providence News · 19 June 1893 · page 2
and find out what is right. “This defendant wants vothing but fustice and she des res to erovo it in the prorer administration of she law, “Things that are uot in dispute I hope I shall not contest, Resume of the Crime. “Mr. Andrew J. Borden left his house and went down street that morning,
Defense counsel argues no motive need be proven if guilt is established, but insists there is no direct evidence tying Lizzie Borden to the murders. He emphasizes the absence of blood on her person or clothing, save a tiny speck, arguing this is inconsistent with her having committed the bloody axe murders.
The Providence News · 19 June 1893 · page 2
“Then, too ugon ‘he best testimony or the experts an Erob&bly in your own commoun ~ense, who ever commiute | that murder of Mrs, Borden stood astride ber
The report describes defense attorney Robinson's closing argument, detailing his critique of the prosecution's theory about sightlines on the staircase and his methodical dismantling of the government's case. It also notes Justice Dewey's selection to deliver the jury charge and describes the intense public debate over witness credibility and police competence during the trial.
The Providence News · 19 June 1893 · page 2
COMPLIMENT TO GOV. ROBINSON
and down. : “You remember the experience you had looking, and, therefore, they say that al hough Miss Lizzi, wheu she was at bher door us she entered to pass down, ct;d HOL see Mrs. Borden over there beuind the bed, that it sue weut down stairs she could have seen Mr. Bordou lying there b-hiud the bed, and therefore, tLat Sue mMUst uwave BOUVL hero “Now if we had maeched youup a d down the stuirs and told you wothing vt what we wanjel you to look i, thers is not vne of you that would bave squint ¢d under that bed on that parc.cuiar trend of the stairs.
See moreSee less
“You v ouid uot have thought of it.” Mr. Robinson went ou de ailing the corcumsiauces as tuey bave beeu preseat ed by the evidonee auu fluishe db, wigu ment at 3 J'vlock, He made no rhetrical flights, he dealth with toe cold U ord tucts poinckug out the weakness of the goverunweul's case, He was very lin re-sive wihen ne bauded he ¢cuse 10 the rurv for the delense.
This editorial argues the Borden trial has revealed police incompetence rather than a credible motive for the murders, claiming the prosecution's theories have repeatedly collapsed under its own witnesses. It predicts Lizzie Borden's conviction is highly unlikely given the weak and inconsistent case built by Fall River authorities.
The Providence News · 19 June 1893 · page 4
THE REAL MOTIVE.
E.—" police, But this carlessness is not the ~ 'worst feature of their work. - The conclusion that they deliberately - decided to labor to make out a case . sgainst Lizzie Borden cannot be ~ avoided. It is utterly impossible to ~attribute all the amazing blunders and ~ the uniform failure to sustain the al- - legations against the prisoner by _credible evidence to mere incompetency, i.‘; although that is the most charitabie
This editorial criticizes the Fall River police and prosecution for manufacturing a case against Lizzie Borden through suppression, distortion, and sensationalism rather than straightforward evidence. It also notes the suspicious secrecy around a confession in the unrelated Manchester murder case, questioning how little blood was found despite a violent axe attack.
The Providence News · 19 June 1893 · page 4
CORREIRQO’S CONFESSION, It is difficult to understand the action of the Fall River pelice in attempting to conceal the fact that Correiro has made a full confession of the murder of Miss Mauchester. Such secrecy can serve no good purposs, nor will it tend to establish public confidence in a force which the Borden trial has so clearly shown to be strangely inefficient. One of the curious matters brought to light by this confession is that although the murderer used an axe in his frightful work and inflicted more than a score of blows on his unforiu nate victim but a single spot of blood has yet been found on his clothing.
See moreSee less
This is all the more remarkable when it is remembered that Miss Manchester struggled with her assassin nntil the brute rendered her unconscious by re peated blows, . Some persons will no doubt regard this as an indication that Miss Borden may have killed her father and step mother and escaped being spattered with the blood of her victims; but it seek to influence the jury now sitting in the case at New Bedford by any deduc tions from the condition of Correiro’s clothing, 4
A newspaper's daily column of short satirical one-liners includes two remarks about the Lizzie Borden case: one notes the jury has been quiet but will be 'right to the point' when it speaks, and another jokes that the Massachusetts government's evidence unwittingly helped her defense. The rest of the column covers unrelated political and social quips.
The Providence News · 19 June 1893 · page 4
Lizzie Borden, 28 8 Republican postmasters who have served four years are told to get out. We admire the grace with which Mr. Birsell eats his own words, ' $ %3 During the next four weeks no one will doubt the patriotism of the average small boy. $ ¢ Mr. Blount acts like a man who knows his mind, but is afraid to speak it. $ %3 The New York Reform club appears 10 have dropped out of existence as a maker of politi cians and an unmaker of politics. $ ¢ ¢ Kate Field is out gunning after the public school system.
See moreSee less
Why didn't Kate finish the politicai question first? $ %3 Heretics are loose in Canada. DProfessor Goldwin Smith says that Canada should ap ply for a divorce from Eungland. Let the stake be driven and the fagots piled.
A small-town newspaper mentions local interest in the ongoing Borden murder trial in New Bedford, quoting the New York Tribune's assessment that the prosecution hasn't proven Lizzie committed the crime but no one can imagine who else could have. The item is embedded among unrelated local news about watering troughs, a wedding, a burglary, and runaway horses.
Orleans County Monitor · 19 June 1893 · page 4
Considerable interest has been felt here in the Borden trial, which is be ing held in New Bedford, Mass., where Lizzie Borden is being tried for the
A New York World dispatch from Baltimore reports a landlady's claim that a young boarder calling himself Felix Borden, supposedly connected to the Borden family, once said "Oh, Lizzie did it" when asked about the murders. The story describes him as having quarreled with the Bordens, left suddenly owing rent, and later returned to Baltimore after the killings.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
Wheeling Register · 19 June 1893 · page 1
STRANGER AT THE BORDEN GATE
Nkw York, June 13.—The TTorZd’* special from Baltimore says: Mrs. Ram sey, who keeps a boarding house at No. 333 St. Paul street, says that previous to the Borden murders a boy came from New England and boarded with her. He told her that he was the adopted son of Lizzie Borden’s uncle, and that his name was Felix Borden. He said that his parents name was Desroches. From all ac counts he did nut live happily with th<? Bordens, and as a result of a disagree rneut with them he left home suddenly.
See moreSee less
Felix told Mrs. Ramsay that his home was In New Bedford or Fall River. He spent his money freely. lie d:d not pay bis board bill and left, saying that 1 he was going to his home in Massachu setts to get money to settle. A few days after Felix left the Borden mur ders wera committed, lie returned to Baltimore. On one occasion Mrs. Ram say spoke to Felix about the murders. 8he says that he replied: “Oh, Lizzie did It.”
Mrs. Ramsay recounts that a young man named Felix, who had stayed in Baltimore and had unspecified grievances against the Bordens, once remarked 'Oh, Lizzie did it' when asked about the murders. His description reportedly matches witnesses who saw a strange man at the Borden gate the morning of the killings.
Wheeling Register · 19 June 1893 · page 1
HAS HAD A QUARREL
TEE LEGAL BATTLE Id the Borden Um« to be Fought To-day —Acquittal Probable. New Bkofokp, Mass., JuuelS.—The night before the legal battle is as usual In most conflicts, a particularly quiet and uneventful time. The work of F preparation, among the counsel in the Borden case, has been going on all day, despite the fact that it was Sunday. The work was considered one of the esentiais of good work to come. Consultations and ideliberations and active efforts in the lineof blocking out the arguments on an effective basis have been keeping all parties direct.y interested exceedingly busy, while the newspaper men have been interested lookers-oa from afar, simply because a nearer approach and an Insight into the ' actual work of the day and evening was an absolute impossibility.
See moreSee less
The concensus of opinion h°re is that Mi*s Borden wilt be acquitted in short
A newspaper commentary piece analyzes the ongoing Borden murder trial, suggesting that the skillful defense work by lawyers like ex-Governor Robinson has weakened the circumstantial evidence enough that acquittal seems probable, though a hung jury remains possible. The writer notes the case's enduring mystery, as it seems impossible either that an outside murderer committed the crimes undetected or that Lizzie Borden could have done so without leaving traces of blood.
Waterbury Evening Democrat · 20 June 1893 · page 2
THE BOBDEN CASK. So far as one may judge from a care. ful reading of the newspaper reports of the trial, it is scarcely possible that Lizzie Borden will bo convicted of hav
Former Governor Robinson opened the defense's closing arguments, contending Lizzie Borden was physically incapable of committing the murders and that no direct evidence, weapon, or bloodstains connected her to the crime. He walked the jury through the case chronologically, emphasizing the lack of evidence and urging them to use their hearts and intellects in reaching a verdict.
The Morning Call · 20 June 1893 · page 1
THE BORDEN CASE. The Lawyers Begin Their Arguments. ROBINSON FOR THE ACCUSED.
case. Governor Robinson then rehearsed chronologically the events connected with the crime. He saw no reason to connect the defendant with it. There was no direct evidence against Miss Borden, he said. No weapon whatever and no knowledge of the use of one bad been shown. The evidence shows that the defendant did not know where the alleged weapon was kept. There was no spot on her from her head to her feet, with the exception of one as big as a pin head on the skirt. Lizzie Borden was at home the morning the murders were committed, and if she had gone upstairs and looked under the bed she might have seen the body of her stepmother.
See moreSee less
Both Lizzie and Bridget tell about the note which called Mrs. Borden out, and both were told about it by Mrs. Borden. Lizzie said she had been in the bam 20 minutes. An ice-cream peddler, who knew Bridget, went by anil saw a woman, but not Bridget, walking to the house from the barn. Five minutes' recess was here taken, and Governor Robinson's address was dis cussed freely by the spectators, much dis appointment being expressed about it. Bridget, said the Governor after the recess, when she heard that Borden was dead said she would go to Mrs. White head's and tell Mrs. Borden, if she was there. Bridget Sullivan, who for two years had been closer to the family than any one else, never heard a quarrel be
Former Governor Robinson delivers the defense's closing argument, arguing there was no direct evidence, no weapon found, and no blood on Lizzie Borden except a pinhead spot. He challenges the prosecution's timeline and exclusive-opportunity theory, suggesting an outside intruder could have committed the murders.
The Morning Call · 20 June 1893 · page 1
ROBINSON FOR THE ACCUSED.
Bridget, said the Governor after the recess, when she heard that Borden was dead said she would go to Mrs. White head's and tell Mrs. Borden, if she was there. Bridget Sullivan, who for two years had been closer to the family than any one else, never heard a quarrel be tween Lizzie and Mrs. Borden. The speaker then related the fact of the alini.j-_ blt.i,<\stsii-;Qt\ dre&a. and - ttie burn- - I ing i\[ it. lr Lizzie Borden killed her stepI
This report covers the conclusion of ex-Governor Robinson's defense summation, arguing the exclusive opportunity theory was flawed and an outside intruder could have committed the murder. It then details District Attorney Knowlton's opening remarks for the prosecution's closing argument, which laid out the case against Lizzie Borden including the disputed note story.
The Morning Call · 20 June 1893 · page 1
ROBINSON FOR THE ACCUSED
"He came in end she said to him, 'Mother received a note and has gone out,'' but there was no note; there never was any one sick, and the note story originated with Lizzie Borden. Bridget Sullivau said that the first she heard of it was what Lizzie said." The court adjourned with Knowlton's argument not finished. Judge Justin Dewey, who is presiding nt th« trial in the Borden case, was born in Great Harrington, Mass., in a house that stands close to the border line of that town and tlie town of Alford.
See moreSee less
He studied law in the office of Increase Sumner, father Of C. A. Sumner of San Francisco, and after his admission to the bar was for five or six years a partner in practice with his venerable preceptor and uniil the latter was commissioned Judge of the Southern District of Berkshire County. He contin ued to practice law in Great Barring' on until his own elevation to the bench. He was noted from boyhood for his stu dious habits, being of a very sober and almost ascetic cast of mind. He very lareV laughs. His occasional smile seems to be one that breaks out on his face against his will. Yet he is of a very kind and generous disposition and is uot devoid of a grim sense of humor. Judge Dewey married a Miss Jane Stan ley, a remarkably brilliant pianist and otherwise highly accomplished, lie 'was reared in the faith and membership of the Congregational churchHe left that church in 1883, and for several years there after was in the communion of the Epis copal church, but resumed his connection with the church of his fathers, being of original Puritan stock. Felix Borden has been located here. Young Borden says he knew Lizzie and her father only by sight and reputation, and that if he told Mrs. Ramsey at Balti more that Lizzie committed the murders his opinion was formed on newspaper re ports and not from any knowledge of Liz zie's character. He could not remember, cither, just where he was at the time of the murders, because he was then in the circus business and it kept him traveling most of the time, but he had an idea he was ln Providence. BTnS
Former Governor Robinson opens closing arguments for the defense, arguing Lizzie was physically unable to commit the crime and that no weapon or blood evidence linked her to it. The report notes large crowds at the courthouse and previews that the District Attorney will argue for conviction.
The Herald · 20 June 1893 · page 2
DID LIZZIE KILL HER PARENTS?
By the Asaoelated Press. Nk« BIOPOBDi Maas., .Tone li.*-Th« day of arguments in the Llttlß Borden trial opened with a great crowd at the court hon.ee, Bcarcely one-tenth of whom
Governor Robinson delivers the defense's closing argument, arguing Lizzie was physically incapable of the crime and that no direct evidence, weapon, or blood evidence connects her to it. He challenges the prosecution's theory of exclusive opportunity and points to an unidentified man seen near the house as a possible culprit.
The Herald · 20 June 1893 · page 2
DID LIZZIE KILL HER PARENTS?
her step-mother. Both Lizzie and Bridget tell about the note which called Mrs. Borden out, and both were told of it by Mra. Borden, Lizzie said she had been in the barn M minutes. An ice-cream peddler, wbo knew Brid get, went by and saw a woman, but not Bridget, walking to the house from tbe barn." A five minutes' recess was here taken, and the address waa discussed freely by the Bpectators, much disappointment being expressed about it. "Bridget," said thn governor after re cess, "when she heard that Mr.
See moreSee less
Borden was dead, said ehe would go to Mrs. Whitehead's and tell Mrß. Borden, if fhe was there. That corroborates the theory that Brigdet Sullivan, who for two years hail been cloaer to the family I than any one else, never beard a quarrel between Lizzie and Mrß. Borden." The speaker then related the facts of tin-alleged blood-etained dress and the burning of it, and continued : "H Lizzie Borden killed her Btepmother at 11:45, r! A she come down and greet her father 11 her blood-stained drees? She must have .-bunged her clothing, nnd changed ii SH • n .liter the second slaughter. Lit rtn'l try to get Bridget out of tbe h ii. • Don't you think ahe would have :• oa some errand ?" •torney pointed out that the IttreM as to what had been ■ hill the Bordens, and touched '•> claw-beaded hatchet and tbe
The defense attorney argues no murder weapon was found and that an outside intruder could have entered and left unnoticed, suggesting more than one person was involved. District Attorney Knowlton then begins his closing argument, contending Lizzie was alone with her stepmother, invented the story of a note, and had motive rooted in hatred.
The Herald · 20 June 1893 · page 2
DID LIZZIE KILL HER PARENTS?
began to sum up for the prosecution. Knowlton said: "However we may differ we can agree that this is a moat heart-rending caee. Tbe woman we are trying is a Christian. It ia hard to con sider a woman guilty of such a crime, but the greatest criminals of the world have been women, and we must face this case ac men. No one wbo haa told of it saw Lizzie Borden burn that dress. While Mr. Borden waß down at the bank tbat morning the assassin met Mrs. Borden and killed
Defense attorney Governor Robinson argued Lizzie Borden was physically incapable of committing the murders and that no direct evidence, weapon, or bloodstains linked her to the crime. District Attorney Knowlton countered for the prosecution, asserting hatred motivated Lizzie to kill her stepmother and then her father to cover up the crime.
The Record-Union · 20 June 1893 · page 1
Cover TJp Her Crime. Special to the ni.coi.u-UxioN. New Bedford, June 19.—Tbe day for tho argument in the Lizzie Borden trial opened with a great crowd at tho Court house, scarcely one-tenth of whom could gam admission. A large proportion of thoso in attendance were in fashionable holiday attire. The defendant appeared fresh and smiling. Governor Robinson opened tho pro*-cod ings with his argument for the defense. He began by declaring the defendant physically unable to commit tho crimein tho manner in which it was committed; and, as for that, it was only possible for a maniac, a devil, to do it.
See moreSee less
He asked the jury to bring their homes, hearts and in tellects into their decision iv the case. Governor Robinsou then rehearsed chronologically the events connected with the crime. He saw no reason lo connect confederates of the defendant with it. There was no direct evidence against Miss Borden, he said. No weapon
This report covers the defense attorney's closing argument at Lizzie Borden's trial, highlighting lack of direct evidence, no weapon found, no bloodstains on her person, and alternate theories about intruders or accomplices. It ends with District Attorney Knowlton beginning the prosecution's closing summation.
The Record-Union · 20 June 1893 · page 1
COMMIT THE CRIME.
"Bridget," said the Governor, after recess, "when she heard Bordon was dead said she would go to Mrs. White head's and tell Mrs. Borden, if she was there, and that e-orroborates the theory that Bridget Sullivan, who, for two years, has been closer to tho family than any one else, never heard aejuarrel between Lizzie and Mrs. Borden." The speaker then related the fact of tho alleged blood-stained dress and the burn ing of it. -'If Lizzie Borden killed hor stepmother at !•:I.i, did she come down and greet her father in a biood-stained dres.v.'
See moreSee less
Sho must have changed her cloth ing, and changed it again after the second slaughter. Lizzie didn't try to get Bridget out of the house. Don't you think sho would have sent hor on some errand?" The attorney pointed out that doctors disagreed as to what had been used to kill the Bordens, aud touchod upon the
Defense counsel (the Governor) argues an outsider could have entered the house and committed the murders, and that Lizzie's hair would have shown blood if present during the act. District Attorney Knowlton then begins his closing argument, asserting Lizzie had sole opportunity, fabricated the story of a note summoning her mother, and that no such note ever existed.
The Record-Union · 20 June 1893 · page 1
COMMIT THE CRIME.
Knowlton said: "However we may differ, we can agree that this is a most heartrending ease. The woman we aro trying is a Christian. It is hard to con sider the woman guilty of such a crimo, but tho greatest criminals of the world have been women, and we must face this case as men. No one who has told ol \t saw Lizzio Borden burn that dress.
The district attorney continued his closing argument at the Borden trial, dismissing the defense's claim that motive was central to the case while suggesting family malice existed. The report also notes a small handleless hatchet mailed anonymously to Governor Robinson during the session.
Evening Journal · 20 June 1893 · page 1
SIXTH YEAR. SCORED LIZZIE BORDEN. Prosecuting Attorney's Mer ciless Arraignment. MET HEB FATHER WITH JUDAS' KISS Why Did she Stop Ironing W'hen She Had Hut a Few Handkerchiefs to Iron?
Evening Journal · Wilmington, Del. · and 1 other paper
This report covers the prosecution's closing argument at trial, which constructs a narrative of family malice and portrays Lizzie Borden as transformed into a murderess who killed her father to silence him after he discovered her stepmother's body. The speech dramatizes Andrew Borden's final walk and his daughter's deception upon his return home.
Evening Journal · 20 June 1893 · page 1
MET HER FATHER WITH JUDAS' KISS
able fire. A Murderess Came Down the Stairs. There may be that in this case which shows that Lizzie Andrew Borden did not plan to kill her father and I hope so. But it was not Lizzie Andrew Borden, who came dowu those stairs to meet her father, but a murderess, transformed from the ties of affection to the most consummate cruelty ever known, Mie came down to meet that stern old man who loved his daughter, but who also loved his wife aud the one man above all who would know who had killed his wife, aud when she came down stall's she came to meet Nemesis.
A defense attorney argues in closing that Lizzie Borden's account of being away from the house was consistently given to Dr. Bowen, Mrs. Churchill, Miss Russell, and officer Fleet, countering suggestions she lied due to being drugged. He notes Rev. Mr. Buck witnessed the Fleet interview and no inconsistency was reported at the time.
Evening Journal · 20 June 1893 · page 1
The words of this article could not be separated from the rest of its page. Read it in the clipping.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
Evening Journal · Wilmington, Del.
A newspaper editorial criticizes the prosecuting attorney's theory that Lizzie Borden committed the murders naked to avoid bloodstains, calling it no more reasonable than any other imagined explanation. The piece is part of a broader column of sarcastic commentary on various current events.
Evening Journal · 20 June 1893 · page 2
The proposal of the prosecuting attor ney to picture Lizzie Borden as a naked murderess, on the evidence furnished by a vivid imagination, Is not a morn reasonable explanation of the mystery of
The Wilmington Daily Republican · Wilmington, Del.
Defense attorney ex-Governor Robinson delivers his closing argument, defending Lizzie Borden's character and pushing back against perceived persecution by the prosecution. The report describes a packed courtroom and previews District Attorney Knowlton's forthcoming counter-argument focused on circumstantial evidence.
The Wilmington Daily Republican · 20 June 1893 · page 1
the District Attorney Point« to the Same lu a Plea for Justice. U*w Bedford, Maas., June 20.—The day of the arguments in tho Borden brought out a terrific jam at the court bous a, and over honr before the time of opeuing the doors Were besieged by people, tly ladle» in holiday attire, all hoping ts. But there were too few seats for for
The Wilmington Daily Republican · Wilmington, Del.
Prosecutor Knowlton addresses the jury, defending the police investigation and arguing the murders of Mr. and Mrs. Borden did not occur simultaneously. He portrays discord within the Borden household, referencing a quarrel over property and a telling remark made to Mrs. Gifford, to suggest motive and family tension behind the killings.
The Wilmington Daily Republican · 20 June 1893 · page 1
THE PROSECUTOR'S ARGUMENT
"Men will not tell tho truth always. Circumstances will tell the truth. They ot under oath. What impresses a.? the distinguishing feature of the case is the fact that these two people did not meet their death at the same time. It has been proved conclusively that this tv "It was the malice against. Mrs. Borden «1er. It was the act that inspired thi n who spent tho forenoon in that 6f a pers d this fact bears on this house, it from beginning to end. I shall have to ask is
The Wilmington Daily Republican · Wilmington, Del.
District Attorney Knowlton argues to the jury that no note ever came for Mrs. Borden, disputing the defense's claim, and that Lizzie Borden invented the story herself. He lays out the timeline of the morning, arguing no outsider could have entered unnoticed and that Lizzie's own movements implicate her.
The Wilmington Daily Republican · 20 June 1893 · page 1
"Then Brblget goes out washing win dows. Mrs. Borden goes into the guest's chamber ami Lizzie and she are above s.taii-8. Lizzie then goes out doors too . I if Bridget is fairly at. her work, ami then . I the time the murder was doue there w room for the assassin to come in. When
On the twelfth day of the trial, defense attorney ex-Governor Robinson spoke for nearly six hours in his closing argument, with the prosecution expected to respond the next day. The courtroom was packed beyond capacity as the case neared its conclusion.
New-York Tribune · 20 June 1893 · page 1
ALMOST READY FOR THE JURY ARGUMENT FOR THE DEFENCE IN THE BORDEN CASE
EXPECTATION. (FROM A STAFF CORRESPONDENT OF THE TRIBUNE) Now-Bedford, Mass., June 19.—The twelfth day of Lizzie Borden's trial has ended. There will he a thirteenth, and it looks now as if the trial itself would end on that day. It the close to which it comes is disastrous to the d~fen lint some people will be quick to peint out the une lucky number. Reason other than any drawn from the testimony will be neeccssary to account for such a result. To-day was occupied with the addresses of the counsel on both sides im
Defense attorney ex-Governor Robinson spoke for five hours in closing arguments, with the District Attorney expected to continue the next day before the case goes to the jury. The courtroom was overcrowded with spectators, including Emma Borden and supporters, while Lizzie Borden was moved back to the prisoner's dock alone.
New-York Tribune · 20 June 1893 · page 1
The courtroom here, though large, was packed to the full of its capacity. Hitherto only that number of people has bean adilited for which seats could be found in the chairs and benches ordinarily allotted to spectators, The aisles and anterooms have been kept open, but the ¢ 3 that besieged the Migh Sheriff and his €3%% 8, to-day was simply irresistible, and despr =” the barricades ‘of wood and flesh that were erected acninst it in all sorts of places leading to the doors of the courtroom, in the end it was tris umphant, and no inch of space in the room was loft unoceapied except in the prisoners’ dock.
See moreSee less
Miss Borden, who had been sitting beside hep counsel, was to-day removed back to the dock which she and the deputy who guards her held alone.
This report analyzes and criticizes the closing speech given by Lizzie Borden's defense attorney, ex-Governor Robinson, calling it tedious and poorly strategized despite his otherwise skillful handling of the trial. The writer argues Robinson should have projected confidence that acquittal was assured rather than painstakingly rebutting every piece of evidence, which betrayed anxiety about the case's strength.
New-York Tribune · 20 June 1893 · page 1
THE ADDRESS TO THE JURY.
The best that can be said for it is that it was a goog! though tedious analysis of the evidence. But it wa¥-planned on a wrong theory and was not skilfully judged. There is nothing much in this case against Lizzie Borden for which some kind
A commentary piece critiques both prosecution and defense strategies as the Borden trial draws to a close, noting the prosecution's timidity and inconsistent witness handling, and the defense's weak closing despite strong cross-examinations. It also reflects on Lizzie Borden's emotional state as she awaits the verdict after ten months of imprisonment.
New-York Tribune · 20 June 1893 · page 2
800 io defence, on the other hand, masterful in spect of ex-tiovernor Robinson's cross examinations, was feeble in direct examination. Every one of its witnesses especially Emma Borden and Rubinsky, the peddler, could have told more, an all better, than they did if they had been well questioned. And now, at the finish, the defence sume up weakly, and the District-Attorney sucin making the impression that he really has got a good deal to talk about. LIZZIE. BORDEN'S TRYING POSITION.
The report describes Lizzie Borden's reaction during prosecutor Knowlton's closing argument detailing the murders, then covers defense attorney ex-Governor Robinson's closing address calling for acquittal. Robinson reviews the gruesome evidence—eighteen blows to Mrs. Borden and ten to Mr. Borden—while arguing the crime required a depraved fiend, not the defendant.
New-York Tribune · 20 June 1893 · page 2
EX-GOVERNOR ROBINSON'S ADDRESS
BORDEN-HIS REVIEW OF THE LVIDENCE AND HIS ‘THEORY OF THE CRIME. New Bedford, Mass. June 19.—Ex-Governor Robin gon addressed himself without delay, at the opening of court, to the last duty he will have to perform fn this trial. He drew a vid picture of the crime, to the Government's. solution of which the jury was gheing its att ntion. #MWho could have done such an act?” he sald. “In the quiet of the home, in the broad davlight of an August day, on a street of a populons city, with notises within a stone's throw away, almost within toueh, who conld have done it?
See moreSee less
An inspection of the victims disclosed that Mrs. Borden had been slain by the use of some sharp and terrible fustrament {nftieting upon her head elghteen blows, thirteen of them erushing through the skull. And below stalrs, lying upon the sofa, was Mr. Borden's dead and
This report covers defense attorney Robinson's closing argument, describing Lizzie Borden's composed demeanor in court and reminding jurors of their oath to render a true verdict. He argues the prosecution has failed to establish a credible motive, dismissing testimony about family discord and disputing Matron Reagan's account of an alleged quarrel statement.
New-York Tribune · 20 June 1893 · page 2
THE OATH THE JURYMEN TOOK.
thelr low police origin. This wis # good point. Everything that has taken place since the murders were discovered has shown Lizzie Borden to be in possession of the instincts of
Final arguments commenced in the Lizzie Borden murder trial in New Bedford, Massachusetts, with the case set to go to the jury afterward. Observers predicted an acquittal or hung jury, criticizing Fall River officers for allegedly ignoring other leads in their push to convict Borden.
Paper unidentified · 20 June 1893 · page 1
Borden Case Now On. New Bedford, Mass., Juae2o.-~To. day the final arguments in the fa mous Lizzie Bosdeu murder case were begun. At their close the case will go to the jury. It is the general o pinion that the accused woman will be acquitted or that the jury will be hung. No one expects a vernict of conviction and it is agreea that the best the state cm hope for is a hung jury. The officers of Fall river are o penly criticised for neglecting good clues in other directions in their mad eagerness to convict Lizzie Borden;
After Governor Robinson finished his defense plea, District Attorney Knowlton began his closing argument, calling the case heartrending and the crime seemingly incredible yet undeniably committed. He emphasized the difficulty of believing a Christian woman of good standing could be charged with such a brutal murder, while urging the jury to avoid prejudice.
Evening Star · 20 June 1893 · page 2
The Eeynmb or the NanSrote Atterneys Argument to the Berden Case. It was 3 o'clock when Governor Robinson celeed his plea for the defense in the Borden ewe yesterday afternoon and District Attorney Enowlton toek up his work. Be said: "This is
This passage records the prosecution's closing speech at Lizzie Borden's trial, arguing that Abby Borden was killed first and did not hear the city hall clock strike, and defending the thoroughness and honesty of the police investigation. The speech also touches on family relationships, including a dispute over property between Lizzie and her stepmother's side, to establish motive.
Evening Star · 20 June 1893 · page 2
Cmesmericnas Tu& T= Tav. Nsn will ot tell the truth always; treum tans wil tel the truth; they are not unds eth. What impresmse ase' the distieguish Ing i.mue of the me is the fort that these twc did net meet their death at the asa It has been proved cnclelively the thewsoem. Mrs. Andrew J. Borden v never heard the city hel clock strike boo,
District Attorney Knowlton argues in his closing statement that no note ever came for Mrs. Borden, pointing out that Bridget Sullivan heard no messenger, saw no note, and that the doorbell never rang that morning. He contends the note story originated solely with Lizzie Borden and uses the tight timeline of the morning to argue she alone had opportunity to commit the murder.
Evening Star · 20 June 1893 · page 2
"Nother has had a note and has gone on When Bridget got through her work Lizzie t< her that she was going to lock the screen do as Mrs. Borden had gone out and she might eat, too. Counsel on the other side maidt eteteament was not a he. But there was unac there never was anybody sick. and the a erigmatcd with Lizzie Borden. Bridget Su van said she never heard anybody come witl note: she never smu any not. and the firsti hard of it was whet Lizzie said.
See moreSee less
Brid knew no note came when she was go outside and inside It did not come to the door, because. the door was locked most of time. And the frost door bell never rang I meraln I repeat there never was a note. Mr. knowlton had not concluded his ari mont when ceart adjourned for the day.
Former Governor Robinson delivered the opening argument for Lizzie Borden's defense, arguing that the blood spot on the stairs was menstrual blood rather than evidence of the crime. He emphasized that if she had committed the murders, she would not have raised the alarm so quickly, and noted that burning old clothes was a common household practice.
The Morning News · 20 June 1893 · page 1
Gov. Robinson Makes the Opening Ar gument Before the jury. Had the Defondant Committed the Crime She Would Not Have Given the Alarm so Soon—The Burning of Old Clothes Declared a Common Oc currence in Many Families. New Bedford, Mass., Juno 19.—Thoday of tho arguments in tho Borden trial brought a terrific Jam to the court houso and over an hour before tho time of open ing the door was besieged by people, mostly ladios, hoping for seats. There was not enough seats for a tenth part of the claimants. When court was ready for opening many ladies were standing in the aisles, but they were quietly ushered to tho ante rooms and corridors.
See moreSee less
The bar inclosuro was packed with legal lights. Tho Jurymen took their seats at 8:55 o'clock, lookingquite refreshed after their two days’ rest, and a few minutes later Miss Borden came in with a bunch of pinks in her hand and a contented smile on her face. Almost immediately Gov. Robinson began ills argument.
Defense attorney Gov. Robinson delivers a detailed closing argument rebutting the prosecution's evidence point by point, addressing the blood spot, Lizzie's varying statements, the burned dress, and her demeanor after the murders. He argues none of these points prove guilt and offers innocent explanations for each.
The Morning News · 20 June 1893 · page 1
A. CAREFUL DISCUSSION. Gov. Robinson made a careful, logical discussion of the crime and its discovery as they appear from tho evidence.. Tho prisoner sat in the dock with her face covered with a fan while ho analyzed tho evidence. After cautioning tho jury to disregard certain parts of the district at torney’s opening as not proved by the evi dence, the ex-governor proceeded to dispose of certain points of the prosecution's evi dence in detail. The only connection be tween the defendant and the crimes was a blood spot on the stair, which was explainable as menstrual blood.
See moreSee less
The proposition that Lizzie must, have seen Mrs. Borden’s body when up stairs was unsound, because the body could be seen from only one stair, and there she would not stop and look if she did not suspect something wrong. Liz zie’s statement that her mother had re ceived a note aud gone out was plain, if Mrs. Borden told both Lizzie and Bridget about it, and that they could not believe that Lizzie had lied about it. lizzie’s varying statements that she was in tho yard and in the barn were recon cilable. The testimony of three men proved that Rubinsky saw the defendant coming to the house from the barn, and therefore her statement of her whore abouts at the time of the murders was true. When Lizzie spoke of going upstairs for Mrs. Borden she meant tho front stairs, because all kuew she could not be up tho b:*'k stairs, a sheet had boon ob tained from there, Lizzie’s laughter on the stairs was immaterial, unless guilt was assumed. The ring buried with Mr. Borden shows her affection for him. The custom of locking doors was not to look the daughters from her parent, but for protection.
Defense attorney Robinson closes his argument, addressing the burnt dress, timeline of the murders, and the matron's testimony, and urging the jury toward acquittal. The report also describes disorderly crowd scenes outside the courthouse and notes that District Attorney Knowlton began his rebuttal before adjournment.
The Morning News · 20 June 1893 · page 1
DtSOItACEFCL SCENES. The scenes about tho court, houso this afternoon were disgraceful. There was no system about the method of seating the people and ladles were tossed about the walks, in the corridors and on the stairs in a most reckless and careless manner. When Miss Borden came in sho
The report recounts unverified gossip that police officers tried to blackmail Lizzie Borden for a share of her inheritance, and that she refused, calling them villains. It also relays a separate rumor from Baltimore about a young man named Felix Borden who went to Fall River for money around the time of the murders and later vanished.
The Morning News · 20 June 1893 · page 4
During the trial the chief evidence against her was given by the police; and it was also brought out that they had sup pressed certain facts that were in her favor. There may be nothing in tlie story of attempted blackmail, but the facts mentioned would appear to give it color, vvhJ'n taken in connection with tlie fur ther fact that suits for perjury are likely to be brought against certaiu of the police witnesses in case the vgjrdict is in favor of Miss Borden. Another story bearing on the comes front Baltimore, to the effect that a wHd.ypung man named Felix Borden, the adopted spti of Lizzie Borden's uncle, left Baltimore five days before the murders to go' to Fall . River “to get
A short item buried among many unrelated news briefs reports that witnesses for the prosecution in the Lizzie Borden trial are contradicting each other. It speculates that the prisoner will likely be acquitted as a result.
The Hawaiian Star · 20 June 1893 · page 2
TELEGRAPHIC NOTES.
In the Lizzie Borden trial import ant witnesses for the prosecution contradict each other and it is thought the prisoner will be ac quitted. A fight occurred between a mob of
A brief item among miscellaneous news notes that the trial of Lizzie Borden at Fall River, Mass., for the murder of her father and mother has begun. It notes that the evidence against her is wholly circumstantial.
The Hawaiian Gazette · 20 June 1893 · page 7
uirecuuu ui uie xuuiuu icrriiury. The trial of Lizzie Borden at Fall River, Mass., for the murder of her father and mother, has begun. The evidence is wholly circumstantial. Mrs. Frank Leslie has applied for a ' divorce from Willie Wilde, brother of Oscar Wilde, and, it is said will undoubtedly get it. The .Russian extradition treaty has been formally proclaimed. Political offenses are not included. The manufacture of the rille for the United States army, to supplant the Springfield, will shortly begin at the Springfield armory and arsenal. A senate consisting of Senator Hill and others, is expected to airive on the coast soon, to study and report on the Chinese evil.
Among many unrelated news items, the report notes that the trial of Lizzie Borden is still underway in New Bedford, Massachusetts. It adds that the courtroom is largely attended by women.
The Daily Bulletin · 20 June 1893 · page 2
LATEST ITEMS OF NEWS.
United States Supremo Court in Oc tober. The entire 12,000,000 subscrip tions to tho Northern Pacific col lateral trust notes havo been mado up by a syndicate. Tho trial of Lizzie Borden is still on at Now Bodford, Mass. It is largely attended by women. "Rev." A. R. Roams, who eloped from Morcod, Cal., with his protty organist, Lucy Ruckor, deserting a wife and four children and taking a son of 13 along, has been captured
A defense attorney's closing argument argues no blood was found on Lizzie Borden despite the brutal crime, and mocks the prosecution's theory about a burned hatchet handle. He also disputes the significance of a note Mrs. Borden supposedly received, suggesting Bridget's account is more complete than Lizzie's.
The Indianapolis Journal · 20 June 1893 · page 2
THE 3I183INO HATCHET HANDLE. Then there was a bundle of burnt paper which Mr. Phillip Harrington found. Then there were mean assertions made that Dr. Bow-en was doing something. We thought they had the handle tiere, wrapped up In the newspaper, and that the handle had been burnt up entirely, and that the newspaper, which lives forever, only re mained. What a funny lire. That handle is ltlil flying through the air somewhere. A poor Drpban handle without its hatchet. For heavens lake get the 125 iollcemen of Fall River and thase It.
See moreSee less
Let them catch It and reunite it to its hatchet. Llzzlo Borden was at home that day. There was nothing strange in that. It was better for Lcr to be at home m her room than out In the streets. If MLas Uorden had gono upstairs that jnornlng and looked under the bed she might
The report summarizes ex-Governor Robinson's defense closing argument, which questioned the prosecution's claims about the mysterious note Mrs. Borden received and challenged testimony about Lizzie's trip to the barn. He suggested Bridget, not Lizzie, originated the note story and that the note's destruction was Miss Russell's idea, not an admission of guilt.
The Indianapolis Journal · 20 June 1893 · page 2
Lizzie and Bridget tell about the note, and both were told of it by Mrs. Borden. Bridget said Mrs. Borden wan ducting the sittiuif room just before she went away. The district attorney says Lizzie lied about the note. Now, Bridget tells the most complete story about the note. The speaker drew the inference that it "V?aa Bridget who told Lizzie abont the note. He Contended that the burning of the note was the suggestion of Miss Rus sell and not a statement made by Lizzie. Continuing, the ex-Governor said: "A per on may say 'where ia tbe coteF We can not rind it. The note run j be part of the scheme, of Mrs. Borden. There ar people
Ex-Governor Robinson delivers his closing argument for the defense, addressing witness testimony about a woman seen near the barn, Lizzie's reaction upon finding her father dead, and the prosecution's theory of motive. Reporters note the summation disappointed lawyers who expected a stronger performance from Robinson.
The Indianapolis Journal · 20 June 1893 · page 2
horse had corroborated him as to the time. tnd so had Newball. the man from Provi dence. NOT UP TO EXPECTATIONS. A recess for live minntea was taken at this point. The summingnoof ex-Governor Jtobinson, so far as it had gone, was dis cussed freely. Much disappointment was expressed about it. The ex-Governor's effort had not been so great as had been ex pected of him. The lawyers said tho facts in the oaa? had not been handled as they bad been led to believe they would. After recess the ex-Governor said: Bridget, when she heard Mr.
See moreSee less
Borden was dead, laid she would go to Mrs. Whitehead's and tell Ir. Borden, if she was there. That corrobo rated the theory of that note. If, you presume that tho detoudant U guilty, the' suggestion of lue prosecution would be that Miss Borden told Mrs. Churchill and Bridget to go upntalrs by the front way and hud Mrs. Borden. She thought Mrs. Borden had come In. . 1'erhaps It wan the slamming of the door, perhaps the moving about of some one In the bouse that sho heard. Now, they say, she showed no feeling. That whju her stepmother lay dead la the spare room tho stood at the head of tho stairs aud laughed. Well, if you are down stairs in your own house and some one craoks a joke you laugh at It. But suppoHO your son drops dead in a room upstairs, then you, who do not know he is dead, are a hard hearted wretch because you laughed at the joke. The way the Borden'a lived, how the houe was furnished or what they had to eat each day has nothing to do with the ease. The old fashioned tilnuer Is Just as good as the fancy things wo get at the hotel Mr. Kobinson then took up the question of motive, saying: Now, what sort of combination are you trying to make of this woman, r-be kills her stepmother because she did not like her, and killed her father whom she did like, because she wanted hU money I Miss Lizzie said Mrs. Borden was her stepmother and not her mother. The emphatic policeman. Fleet, told that. She had said to Mrs. I; Word, tho dressmaker, that her stepmother wat a mean old thing and that they did not have much to do with each other. But Bridget Sulli van, who for two year had been oloser to the family than any one elae, had never heard a Quarrel between them. I aree with you that Lizzie Borden Is not a saint. Counsel ventured the assertion that the members of the jury were not saints, lie told the jury that thero were other men as L-andsomo as they, i he girls didn't come down to breakfast with the others in the family. They remained up late. 'Here iras a man," be continued, "with no orna ment of any kind except one a ring on one of his tinkers. When be was buried it was put into the gruve with him. A simple old man wearluir that evidence of ailectlon for Lis little girl."
The piece questions why an adopted son who allegedly left the Borden family under a cloud before the murder has not been investigated. It accuses detectives and police of focusing entirely on building a case against Lizzie Borden while ignoring other leads.
The Indianapolis Journal · 20 June 1893 · page 4
Borden family who left under a cloud Borne time beforo tho murder was com mitted, why has he not been hunted up and accounted for? It looks very much as if the detectives nnd police had con lined thtir t Hurts entirely to trying to lix the crime on Lizzie Borden. Having
Defense attorney ex-Governor Robinson delivers his closing argument, calling the murders a physical and moral impossibility for his client to have committed. The prosecution then begins pointing out inconsistencies in the defense's theory, including the improbability of an assassin remaining in the house for over an hour awaiting a second victim.
The Wichita Daily Eagle · 20 June 1893 · page 1
Second Vic tim, Xew Bedford, Mass., June 19. The day of arguments in the Bordeu case brought out a terrific jam at the court house. The crowd was chiefly composed of women. The bar euclosure was tightly packed with legal lights from all oTer the county. The jury took their seats at S:33 o'clock, looking quite refreshed after the two days' rest. A few minutes later Miss Borden came in with a buuch of pinks in her band uud a contented smile on her face. Immediately Governor Robinson began his argument.
See moreSee less
Ho said: "May it please your honor, Mr. Foreman and gentlemen of the jury One of tho most dastardly aud diabolical crimes ever committed in Massachusetts was perpe trated in August, lS'J--', in Fall River. The enormity of it startled everybody. Every man feels that the wrong should be right ed aud the wicked brought to justice. The blows that caused tho death of Mr. and Mrs. Borden wero well directed not directed by a blunderer, none go
This passage records the defense attorney's closing argument, urging jurors to decide guilt solely on courtroom evidence and ignore rumors or unproven prosecution claims. He argues no weapon, blood, or direct evidence ties Lizzie Borden to the murders, and questions the barn visit testimony and Bridget's account.
The Wichita Daily Eagle · 20 June 1893 · page 1
"Ibere is no direct evidence against Mis3 Borden. No weapon whatever, and no knowledge of the Use of one has been shown. Not a spot on her from her hair to her feet on her dres, or anyxvhere else! Tbmk of it. Yes, there was one pot on her dres, as big the point of a run. that wa3 not where you expected u to be if she had done it in an out-of-theen there was a bundle of j wav nlace. Then there which Puilin Harrington burnt papers fn.,nfi Then there were mean assertions
Former governor, defending Lizzie Borden, argues she could not have committed the murders, questioning the blood evidence, the burned dress, and the lack of a credible motive. He suggests an unknown male assailant was responsible and praises Lizzie's character, prompting her to weep for the first time during the trial.
The Wichita Daily Eagle · 20 June 1893 · page 1
bers of thi jurj saints. "They say that Mtss Lizz'o burned her dress. A common way to get rid of old things is to burn them. The pniut-be-spattered dress which the prosecution produced was fouud by Emma iu a clothes press. WTieu Dr. Dolan came across it, he thought that it was blood stained. When they searched the house it was only a farce. They did not really care to secure auy more, thinking thoy had tho garment which would convict her of the crime. If Lizzie Borden killed her stepmother at 9.43 o'clock, did she como down aud greet her father in that blood stained dre.-s?
See moreSee less
She must have stood astride hc-r stepmother aud smashed the hatchet into her head; she unut have walked iuto a sea of blood, scattered it all over herself, changed her clothing, aud changed it after the second slaughter. Sho did not try to get Bridget out of the house. Don't you think she would have sent her out on some errand? A man could have gono to the house for the purpose of killing Mr. Bordeu, aud, happening to meet Mrs. Borden, struck her dowu. Then he waited for Mr. Borden to come homo and killed him. It would have been
The report claims a man calling himself Felix Borden, an adopted son of the Borden family, had lived in Baltimore boarding houses before the murders and then vanished. It suggests investigators are now looking into whether this unidentified man seen near the house on the day of the murders could be the actual killer.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Der Deutsche Correspondent · 20 June 1893 · page 4
War der Borden-Mörder in Baltimore?
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
A German-language report describes a man calling himself Felix Borden who told a boarding-house keeper that 'Lizzie was the murderess,' then later denied having real knowledge, claiming it was just a newspaper-derived opinion. He gives contradictory accounts of his identity and whereabouts, including conflicting stories about his adoptive family and alibi.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Der Deutsche Correspondent · 20 June 1893 · page 4
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
This is a front-page table of contents for the Portland Daily Press listing the day's articles. Among the items mentioned is a piece on 'Opinions of Portland gentlemen as to Lizzie Borden's case,' indicating public commentary during her ongoing trial.
The Portland Daily Press · 20 June 1893 · page 1
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
At the New Bedford trial, former Governor Robinson delivered a closing argument defending Lizzie Borden, addressing the Fall River police's handling of the case, the mystery of the note, and Lizzie's visit to the barn. The courtroom was packed with spectators, mostly women, as District Attorney Knowlton prepared to begin the prosecution's closing remarks.
The Portland Daily Press · 20 June 1893 · page 1
PLEADING FOR A LIFE.
WHICH ARE IMPORTANT. Comment on the Performance of the Fall River Police—How Lizzie Failed to Sec Mrs. Borden’s Body—The Story of the Note and the Visit to the Barn—Dis trict Attorney Knowlton Begins His Remarks.
A huge crowd packed the courthouse as Lizzie Borden's trial resumed, with Sheriff Wright controlling access to the courtroom. Defense attorney George D. Robinson began his closing argument, recounting the brutal nature of the murders of Andrew and Abby Borden.
The Portland Daily Press · 20 June 1893 · page 1
were at a premium. Miss Lizzie Borden came in at 8.55 an<i sat in her old chair within the dock. A magnificent bouquet of carnations waf given her as she took her seat. Thi court was very prompt. Sharply on the stroke of 9 Hon. Geo D. Robinson arose, and straigtening him self to his full height amid impressivi ailenpe, begAn,,his argument.
The Boston Journal interviewed lawyers, police officials, and women across New England about the Borden case, finding general belief that the evidence is insufficient to convict Lizzie Borden. The report notes suspicious circumstances, like the unverified note claimed to have summoned her mother, but says no sufficient chain of evidence has been found to prove guilt.
The Portland Daily Press · 20 June 1893 · page 4
New England on the Borden case. The results show a general belief that the evidence is not sufficient to convict Liz zie Borden. A few express the fixed opinion that she is innocent; but among the lawyers and others who have had ex perience in criminal matters the idea is quite generally expressed that the gov ernment evidence establishes a proba bility of guilt. It„would|not be surpris ing if the jury who have heard the case nhnnlil tolrn 9 nioir *>sv4_l II ■-miuwivuu xxum those who have merely read about it, and either bring in a verdict of acquittal or disagree.
See moreSee less
There are some circum stances in the conduct of Lizzie Borden on the day of the murder that are suspi cious; as fpr instance, her statement that her mother had received a note and had gone out in consequence of it. The note was not found among the Bor den possessions, and no person has ever come forward to acknowl edge the writing of such a note. A cir7 cumstance like this casts suspicion on Lizzie Borden, but it does not prove her guilty. It might contribute if enough circumstances could be found to |go with it. Such do not seem to have been found however. Another feature will weigh in the public mind. The' fundamental law guarantees that no person accused as Lizzie Borden is, shall bo compelled to
The Boston Journal surveyed police authorities and lawyers across New England cities for their opinions on Lizzie Borden's guilt or innocence. Portland officials, including City Marshal Henry Trickey and jurist Josiah Drummond, both predicted she would be acquitted, with Trickey asserting her actual innocence.
The Portland Daily Press · 20 June 1893 · page 5
Guilt or Innocence. The Boston Journal has been inter viewing police authorities and lawyers in the various cities of New England as to their opinions of Lizzie Borden’s guilt or innocence. This is what the Journal gets from Portland: City Marshal Henry S. Trickev savs that in his opinion Lizzie Borden will be acquitted, not only because she cannot be justly condemned on the evidence presented but because she isguiltless of the crime. The marshal has been con fined to his house by illness for a week and has had opportunitv to study the case.
See moreSee less
Hon. Josiah H. Drummond, one of Maine's leading jurists, says that in his opinion Lizzie Borden will be cleaied and that no testimony has thus far been adduced that a jury can conscientiously receive as proof of any crime on her part. Regarding her innocence, Mr. Drummond was not prepared to state an opinion. He said that reading the testi mony offered at a trial can scarcely afford all the light that presence in the court room can.
A packed crowd at New Bedford court house fought for seats as closing arguments began in the Borden case, with Gov. Robinson delivering the defense's summation. Lizzie Borden arrived carrying pink flowers, and disorderly scenes marked the afternoon as spectators, mostly women, were jostled outside the courtroom.
St. Paul Daily Globe · 20 June 1893 · page 4
Scenes in the Afternoon Were Dis graceful, Ladies Being Pushed and Tossed About. New Bedford, Mass., June li). —The day of arguments in the Borden case brought a terrific jjm at the court house, and over an hour before the time of opening the doors were beslegeu by people, mostly ladies in holiday at tire, all hoping for seats. But there were not enough seats for the accommodation of a tenth of the claimants, and there was much grumb ling in consequence. When the court was ready for opening there were many ladies standing in tha aisles, but they were quickly ushered to the ante-rooms and corridors and obliged to sniff the battle from afar.
See moreSee less
The bar enclosure was packed with legal lights. The jury took their seats at 8:55 looking quite refreshed after two days' rest, and a few minutes later Miss Borden came in, a bunch of pinks in her hand and a contented smile on her face. Al most immediately Gov. Robinson began his argument. The scenes about the court house this afternoon were dis graceful. There was no system about the method of seating people, and ladies were tossed about the walks, the corri dors and on the stairs in the most reckless and careless manner. When Miss Borden appeared she was pushed and crowded about just as every one else was. and there was some as perity in her manner as she entered the court room and faced the buzzing crowd. Gov. Robinson continued his address. lie reviewed the whole case, and said that it was dangerous to take the view that if Miss Borden did not do the deeds they could not see who did them. He said: "If you are satisfied she is not guilty, then you will so report. What is there to prove to you absolutely that she is guilty?" It was 3 o'clock when Gov. Robinson closed his plea and a recess of live minutes was allowed before District At torney Knowlton took up his work. Mr. Knowlton had not concluded his argu ment when the court adjourned for the day. A Baltimore dispatch sent out last night has caused some sensational in quiries as to the whereabouts of a young man named Felix Borden, who was there some months ago and ex pressed his opinions about Lizzie Borden. A Standard reporter learned that Felix was in this city and" working at the Whitcomb house cafe. He states that be is the adoo'.ed son of the late Charles T. Borden, a Mansfield druggist, who was distantly related to Andrew Borden. For some time he has been traveling as advance agent for a circus company, which was stranded in Provincetown. lie then came here and went to the Whitcomb house. Young Borden says he knew Lizzie and her father only by sight, and if he told Mrs. Ramsey, of Baltimore, that Lizzie committed the murders, iiis opinions were formed ou the newspaper* reports and not from auy knowledge of Lizzie's character. He could not remember, "either, just where he was at the time of the mur ders, because the show business kept him traveling most of the time, but he had an idea that he was in Providence.
Governor Robinson delivered his closing argument for the defense, questioning what proof existed of Lizzie Borden's guilt, before District Attorney Knowlton began the prosecution's rebuttal. The report also covers courtroom seating chaos and investigates a Baltimore rumor about a man named Felix Borden who had speculated about Lizzie's guilt.
Ex-Gov. Robinson opened the defense in the Lizzie Borden trial before a packed courtroom, arguing she was physically incapable of committing the crime and that no direct evidence linked her to it. He walked the jury through the timeline of events, noting no proof she knew where the weapon was kept and highlighting testimony about the note that called Mrs. Borden out.
The Helena Independent · 20 June 1893 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
PLEADING FOR HER LIFE.
Ex-Gov. Robinson Opens for the Defense in the Borden Murder Trial.
See moreSee less
His Argument Was Something of a Disappointment to the Spectators.
Court Adjourns Before the Prosecuting Officer Is Through Presenting His Side of the Case.
NEW BEDFORD, Mass., June 19.—The day of argument in the Lizzie Borden trial opened with a great crowd at the court house, scarcely one-tenth of whom could gain admission. A large proportion of those in attendance were fashionable ladies in holiday attire. The defendant appeared fresh and smiling. Ex-Gov. Robinson opened the proceedings with an argument for the defense. He began by declaring the defendant physically unable to commit the crime in the manner it was done. He claimed that aside from that it was only possible for a maniac or devil to do it. He asked the jury to bring their homes, their hearts and their intellects into the decision of the case. Gov. Robinson then rehearsed chronologically the events connected with the crime. He saw no reason to connect a confederate of the defendant with it. There was no direct evidence whatever against Miss Borden, he said, and no knowledge of the use of the weapon had been shown. The evidence showed that the defendant did not know where the alleged weapon was kept. Lizzie Borden was at home the morning the murders were committed, and if she had gone upstairs and looked under the bed she might have seen the body of her stepmother. Both Lizzie and Bridget tell about the note which called Mrs. Borden out, and both were told of it by Mrs. Borden. Lizzie said she had been in the barn twenty minutes. An ice cream peddler who knew Bridget went by and saw the woman, but not Bridget, walking to the house from the barn.
A five minutes' recess was here taken and the address was discussed freely by the spectators, much disappointment being expressed about it. Bridget, said the ex-governor after the recess, when she heard Borden was dead, said she would go to Mrs. Whitehead's and tell Mrs. Borden, if she was there. That corroborates the note theory. Bridget Sullivan, who for two years had been closer to the family than any one else, never heard a quarrel between Lizzie and Mrs. Borden. The speaker then related the fact of the alleged bloodstained dress and the burning of it. "If Lizzie Borden killed her stepmother at 9:45," he said, "did she come down and greet her father in the bloodstained dress? She must have changed her clothing and changed it again after the second slaughter. Lizzie did not try to get Bridget out of the house. Don't you think she would have sent her on some errand?" The attorney pointed out that the doctors disagreed as to what had been used to kill the Bordens and touched upon the claw-headed hatchet and the hatchet without a handle. If those were not the implements with which the murder was committed, where are they? The exclusive opportunity theory was simply an anticipation that would be realized. Anybody could have gotten into the house by simply avoiding Bridget on the outside and Lizzie on the inside. The lawyer held that the young man seen in the vicinity was an outside spy for the person committing the deed, and that the job was not done by one person. A dinner recess was taken and the ex-governor resumed when court reassembled. If there had been any blood on the defendants' hair, he said, those who were bathing her face would have discovered it.
It was three o'clock when the ex-governor closed and District Attorney Knowlton began to sum up for the prosecution. Knowlton said: "However we may differ, we can agree that this is a most heartrending case. The woman we are trying is a Christian. It is hard to consider this woman guilty of such a crime, but the greatest criminals of the world have been women and we must face this case as men. No one who has told of it saw Lizzie Borden burn that dress. While Borden was down at the bank that morning the assassin met Mrs. Borden and killed her. It was against her the hate was directed. There was one woman in the world who believed the old woman stood between her father and herself. There was nothing in these blows but hatred, and a great strong man with one blow only, would have made an end of it." The speaker reviewed the movements of the family on the morning of the tragedy and said up to the time the murder was committed there was no opportunity for the assassin to come in. When that 200-pound woman fell it must have been heard by whoever was in the house. If Lizzie was down stairs she was in the passageway of the murderer; if she was up stairs she could not have helped hearing. She was alone in the house with the murdered woman and knew that by and by there was coming into the house a stern, just man, who would have noticed the absence of his beloved wife. He came in and she said to him: "Mother has received a note and has gone out." But there was no note; there never was any one sick and the note story originated with Lizzie Borden. Bridget Sullivan said she first heard of it from what Lizzie said.
Court adjourned with Knowlton's arguments not finished.
Felix Borden has been located here. Young Borden says he knew Lizzie's father only by sight and reputation and if he told Mrs. Ramsey at Baltimore that Lizzie committed the murders his opinion was formed on newspaper reports and not from any knowledge of Lizzie's character. He could not remember either just where he was at the time of the murders, because he was then in the circus business and it kept him traveling most of the time, but he had an idea that he was in Providence.
Ex-Governor Robinson delivers his closing argument for the defense, reviewing the evidence and arguing there is no direct proof against Lizzie Borden, no known weapon connection, and no bloodstains found despite the alleged timeline. He suggests an outside intruder aided by a lookout could have committed the murders, and District Attorney Knowlton then begins the prosecution's closing argument.
The Helena Independent · 20 June 1893 · page 1
PLEADING FOR HER LIFE
Nzw BnDaonD, Mass., June 19.-The day of argument in the Lizzie Borden trial opened with a great crowd at the court honuse, searcely one-tenth of whom could gain admission. A large proportion of those in attendance were fashionable ladies in holiday attire. The defendant appeared fresh and smillin. Ex-Gov. Robinson opened the proeaedings with an argument for the defense. He began by declarine the defendant physically unable to commit the crime Ln the manner it was done. He claimed that aside from that it was only poselble for a manias or devil to do it.
See moreSee less
He asked the jury to bring their homes, their hearts and their intellects into the doiselon of the oase. Gor. Robinson then re hearsed chronologioally the events con nected with the crime. He saw no reason to eenneot a confederate of the de fendant with it. There was na di eot evi dense whatever against Mis Borden, he said, and no knowledge of the use of the weapoh had been shewn. The evidenee showed that the defendant did not know where the alleged weapon was kept. Lizzie lBorden was at home the morning the mur dere were committed, and if she had gone upstairs and looked under the bed she might have seen the body of her step mother. Both Lizzie and Bridget tell about the note which eailed Mrs. Borden out, and both were told of it by Mrs. Borden. Liz zie said she had been in the barn twenty minutes. An ice cream peddler who knew Bridget went by and saw the woman, but not Bridget, walking to the house from the barn. A five minutes' recess was here taken and the address was discussed fritly by the spectators, mndh disappointment being expressed about it. Bridget, said the ex governor after the reeess, when she heard Borden was dead, said she would go to Mes. Whitehead's and tell Mrs. Borden, if she was there. That corroborates the note theery. Bridget Sullivan. who for two years bhad been eloser to the family than sny one else, never heard a quarrel between Lizzie and Mrs. Borden. The speaker then related the faet of the alleged bloodstained -ress and the burning of it. "If Lizzie Borden killed her stepmother at 9:46." he said. "did she come down and greet her father in the bloodstained dress? She must have changed her clothing and changed it again after the second slaughter. Lizzie did not try to get Bridest out of the house. Don't you think she would have sent her on some errand?" The atto ney pointej out that the doctors disa greed as to what had been used to kill the Bordens and teouhed upon the claw-headed hatchet and the hatchet without a handle.
Defense attorney Robinson argues anyone could have entered the house and that no blood was found on Lizzie's hair, while District Attorney Knowlton begins his prosecution summation claiming Lizzie fabricated the note story about her stepmother and had motive rooted in hatred. The session closes with Knowlton's argument unfinished, and reports mention a Felix Borden located elsewhere, unrelated to the defendant's family, who disclaims special knowledge of the case.
The Helena Independent · 20 June 1893 · page 1
PLEADING FOR HER LIFE
The woman we are trying is a Christian. It is hard to cepaider this woman guilty of seah a erime, but the greatest eriminals of the world have been women and we must face this case as men. No one who has told of it saw Lizzie Borden burn that dress. While Borden was down at the hank that morning the assassin met Mrs. Borden and killed her. It was against her the hate was
Ex-Governor Robinson opened closing arguments for the defense, arguing Lizzie was physically unable to commit the crime and that only a 'maniac-devil' could have done it. He walked the jury through the evidence, emphasizing there was no direct evidence, no weapon found, and no proof Lizzie had ever used such an implement.
Omaha Daily Bee · 20 June 1893 · page 1
FIGHTING HARD FOR A LIFE
Nmv BEnFonn , Mass. , Juno 10. The day of arguments In the Lizzie Borden trial opened with n great crowd at the court house ,
Lizzie Borden's lawyer argues the prosecution's evidence is weak, noting the absence of blood on her clothing and uncertainty about the spare room door being open. He challenges claims about Lizzie's movements and the note Mrs. Borden allegedly received, suggesting Bridget's account is more detailed and credible.
Omaha Daily Bee · 20 June 1893 · page 1
EARNEST PLEA OF LIZZIE'S LAWYER
them catch It nnd reunite it to its hatchet. "Li/.zio Borden was at homo that day. There was nothing strange in that. It was hotter for hrr to bo at homo in her room than out in the streets. " The speaker said that if Miss Borden had gene up stairs that morning and looked under the bed she might hav , ! seen the body of her stepmother. "There is no evidence to show that the door of that spare room was wide open. The prosecution assumes that the door was open.
See moreSee less
The door may have been only ajar. It may have been closed. Miss Lizzie had no occasion to go into that room. Slio would not bo likely to do so , judging from the evidence intro duced as to the family relations. It is true that she went up stairs nnd saw her step mother making the bed In the spare room.
A defense lawyer's closing argument at trial dissects the prosecution's case, focusing on the mysterious note Mrs. Borden reportedly received, questioning whether Bridget or Lizzie first described it, and suggesting it may never be found because the sender doesn't know about the trial. The speaker also reviews Lizzie's account of visiting the barn, her varying statements about time spent there, and testimony from an ice cream peddler who saw a woman walking from the barn to the house.
Omaha Daily Bee · 20 June 1893 · page 1
Mrs. Borden was alive then. They say she stayed up there without offering any evi 1dence on that point. 10 "Thoro is the note. Bridget says that she said the stepmother got n note from some ono who was sick and that she hud gene out. Bridget says , 'she did not tell mo where she was going. She generally docs. She hurried off. Lizzlo did not say anything about her hurrying off.1 "Now both Liz/.io and Bridget'tell about , the note and both were told of It by Mrs. Borden.
See moreSee less
Bridget said that Airs. Borden was dusting the sitting room just before she went away. The district attorney savs that Lizzie lied nbout this noto. Now , Bridget tolls the most complete story about the note. " The speaker drew the Inference that It was Bridget who told Lizzie aoout the note. She contended that the burning of the note ; | was at the suggestion of Miss Russell and
A special dispatch from New Bedford, Massachusetts reports that the jury in the Lizzie Borden case returned a verdict of Not Guilty on the evening of June 20, 1893. The courtroom was crowded and erupted in cheers that drowned out the judge's voice.
The Durham Daily Globe · 20 June 1893 · page 1
SHE WAS ACQUITTED.
New Bedford, Mas?, June 20. Special. The jury in the Lizzie Borden case returned a verdict this evening of Not Guilty. The court room was crowded, and the cheers that rent the air, drowned the voice of the judge.
At New Bedford, District Attorney Knowlton resumed his closing argument against Lizzie Borden, addressing the role of motive and the family's living conditions. The defense had argued motive was central to the prosecution's case, which Knowlton disputed while still noting its relevance to understanding the facts.
The Jersey City News · 20 June 1893 · page 1
New Bedford, June 20. 1893.— There was less of a jam outside tlie Court Hou sa this morning; although at the ope ning of court there were as many people iu the room as at aay time during the session. Among the peculiarities of the morning was the receipt of a box by Governor Rcb nsou sent from Pennsylvania, In which was a small handieles3 hatchet. The ti^ie inwarduess of the gift was not aDpareut, aud the box was not removed trorn the jinitor’s room. Miss Borden entered the roo n at five minutes to nine
This account describes a closing argument asserting that Lizzie Borden killed her father deliberately to prevent him from learning she had murdered her stepmother. It characterizes her as transformed by jealousy and malice into a 'consummate' murderess who met her father as 'Nemesis' upon his return home.
The Jersey City News · 20 June 1893 · page 1
many months. SCATHING DENUNCIATION. "Because the lips of thoss who do know are sealed in death we don’t know out that some new phase had come up in the family life adiliuetotha feeling ot mulice and jealousy existiug in this woman. IS'o suggestion could be iniula by that poor man as tiu favor of his wire but would fan the flames into unquench able lire. Tnere may be that in miscrne which shows that Lizzie Andrew Bor deu did not kill her father, and I hope so. But It was Tiot Lizzie Borden who came down those stairs to meet her father, but a
An editorial harshly criticizes ex-Governor Robinson's closing argument for Lizzie Borden, calling it weak, timid, and inconsecutive, as if made by someone who believed his client guilty. The writer predicts the verdict will likely favor Borden despite the poor speech, but warns the speech's tone of defeat could be blamed if the verdict goes against her.
The Jersey City News · 20 June 1893 · page 2
^ With it would bo severly disciplined, and 'the bench would be made a very uncomfortable seat for the Dogberry who aidecl in the outrage. The speech of ex-Governor Robin son in behalf of Lizzie Borden is a dost extraordinary failure. It was weak, timid, frivolous and inconsecu tive, where it should have been vig orous, aggressive, commanding and irresistible. It was the speech of a man who believed his client guilty. It was such a speech as might have been made if the State had triumph antly proved every point in its case, and the defense had to rely on loop hole" and technicalities to escape a conviction.
See moreSee less
It is hardly to be thought, in view of the evidence, that the vferdict can be adverse to Miss Borden; but if it should be, this speech would be responsible through the infectious tone of defeat and ^ .dread which pervaded it. The appointment of Mr. Matthies ■ sen to the post of United States Min ■ ister to Sweden is, like all President ■ Cleveland’s nominations, a splendid
District Attorney Knowlton continues his closing argument in the Borden trial, contending that motive, while not legally required, helps explain the case. He suggests Lizzie killed her father because he would eventually learn who killed her mother, citing long-standing family discord.
The Evening World · 20 June 1893 · page 1
NEW BEDFORD, Mass , June 20. There was less of a Jam outside the Court-House this morning, although at the opening of the Borden case there were as many people In the room as at any time, during the session. Among the peculiarities of the morn ing was the receipt of a box by cx-Gov. Robinson, "sent from Pennsylvania, In which was a small handleless hatchet. Miss Borden entered the room at 8 55 and ex-Gov. Robinson took a seat beside her and tho two engaged In conversa tion until court opened, when District Attorney Knowlton picked up the thread of his argument where he dropped it last night. MR. KNOWLTON ON THE MOTIVE.
A New York commentary piece briefly notes criticism that ex-Governor Robinson's closing speech defending Lizzie Borden was weaker than expected. The writer suggests this reflects poorly on the prosecution's case rather than the defense's effort.
The Evening World · 20 June 1893 · page 4
., . Justly arrested Vlklnts In Urookl)n vad exactly In line with the Intelligent treatment of those quarantined sufferers t In Prospect Mrert. - i Jlr, Haggert) iticrca-.l the number of !k Brooklyn llrldge Jum r b one As hi ' Ttas Number 13, and dldn t get huit a !, little bit, who's to complain of the lutk '. of that number after this ' r H Somebody declares that ex-Gov. )tob. 'J ' Inson'u closing speech In defense of Lizzie Borden was not so strong as It was expected to be, Hut Isn't It the fault with the prosecution, which failed Is to make points enough for un Insplra- :J Hon 7 It takes an assault to glw a de ', fenso a good working show 7 : There 1 a good deal to think of In that ', remark of a lawyer who waa a witness 1 yesterday tp Police Sergeant McCarton's yit.
At the New Bedford trial, District Attorney Knowlton continued his closing argument, contending that Lizzie had to kill her father because he would eventually learn who killed her mother. He described long-standing family tension and malice as context for the killings.
The Evening World · 20 June 1893 · page 1
NEW BEDFORD, Mass., June 20. There was less of a jum outside the Court-House this morning, although at tho opening of the Borden case there were ns many people ln the room ns at nny time during the sesHlon, Among the peculiarities of the morn Imr was the receipt of a box by cx-Oov. Robinson, sent from Pennsylvania, in which wns a small hnndlelcsn hatchet. Miss Honlen entered the room at S 5C and ex-Gov. Hoblnsin took a sent besldo her nnd the two engaged In conversa tion until court opened, when District Attorney Knowlton picked up the thread of his argument where he dropped It last night. MR. KNOWLTON ON THE MOTIVE.
The jury found Lizzie Borden not guilty of murdering her father and stepmother. The report also recounts District Attorney Knowlton's closing argument theorizing about family malice and motive before the verdict was announced.
The Evening World · 20 June 1893 · page 1
Know His Wife's Slayer. NEW DEDFOnD, June 20. Tho Jury finds Lizzie Borden not guilty of tho murder of her father and stepmother, Mlsa Borden entered tho room at !.5." anoax-Gov. Roblnaon took a seat beside
A miscellany of odd news items notes that a Boston paper's popular vote for a free vacation tour is currently led by Lizzie Borden, whose trial is expected to be decided by the end of the week. The item is otherwise unrelated trivia about bank deposits, royal slippers, and Arctic stoves.
The Silver State · 20 June 1893 · page 3
NEWS NOTES.
V Boston paper some time ago started a popular ballot for the selec tion of a person who is to have a va cation tour among the prominent watering places at its expense. Up to date Lizzie. Borden, whose trial will !m> decided the last of this week, leads the list. liongstride, an Irish hunter, the property of the Monmouth County Hunt, recently made the second greatest leap on record, a clear 34 foot leap from hank to hank, across the pond at Hollywood, N. .T., built in the center of the grounds of the
The piece notes that in the Lizzie Borden trial, the judge will charge the jury today, and praises the case as conducted with marked ability and fairness. It adds that if the jury disagrees, the prosecution will likely be abandoned.
The Daily Morning Astorian · 20 June 1893 · page 2
In tho Lizzie. Borden trial, the Judge will charge the Jury today. Tho case has been conducted with marked abil ity and fairness, recalling the best tra
At the close of her murder trial in New Bedford, Lizzie Borden stood and told the court "Gentlemen, I am innocent. I leave my case in the hands of my counsel." Judge Dewey then began his charge to the jury, with the case expected to go to them by about 4:30 that afternoon.
Pawtucket Tribune · 20 June 1893 · page 1
"I AM INNOCENT."
Special of the Tribune. NEwW &EDrFORD, June 20, 12 o’clock.— The court came in on time thls morning as usual. Although the heat was almost unbearable, still it being considered like ly to bethe last day, all who could get into the courtroom crowded in. There were a large number of out of town people from New York, Boston and Phlladelphia present both today and yes terday afternoon to see the close of this remarkable trial, District Attorney Knowlton took up the thread of his address where he left off yesterday afternoon at 5 o’clock and made a remarkably good argument with what he had to back it up with.
See moreSee less
Mr. Knowlton’s argument has upset the almost universal idea of acquittal of Miss Borden, and there are very many now who look for a disagreement, while not a few expect conviction.?
The report describes the dramatic courtroom scene as Lizzie Borden listens to the prosecution's case being woven against her, followed by Governor Robinson beginning his defense argument. Crowds packed the courthouse all day, forcing even the judge to call for order amid the chaos.
Pawtucket Tribune · 20 June 1893 · page 1
'I AM INNOCENT.'
80 professed to be vold of guilt, you find yourself seated in the dock of the highest criminal court, the synosure for the con centrated gaze of hundreds of pairs of eyes of your own sex, 100 el upon as the most astonishing creature of the genus homo this age has yet produced. Loveliest roses, rarest pansies, most exquisite pinks are showered upon you in profusion by both friend and total stranger. At once you find {oumlt an object of repulsion, of plety, of kindliest regard. “But there you sit, facing a man who, with all the genius and eloquence with which he is gifted, is endeavoring to con vince the 12 men sitting before him that you have killed your father and mother in cold blobd.
See moreSee less
It is you—you that he is accusing and around whom he weaves his web of hideous circumstances.” If one’s imagination might carry him thus far, he might possil.ly form some poor econception of the Inner Consciousness of the Prisoner at the bar in this great Borden trial, as she sat absorbed in the startling presenta tion of such an array of evidence as to things that secined so small and now are made to mean so much. Miss Borden sat with eyes riveted upon her accuser as he went in with his build ing of circumstance and incident in fate ful epvironment about her. It was the most intensely interesting day of the trial. Frow early morning till late afternoon the people hung about the court house wuiting in vain hope for a chance to get in. The ladies were in force everywhere und crowded, squeezed and pushed with far more persistency than the men. The reporters were compelled to perform acrobatic feats of remarkable agility to regunin their seats after the dinner recess, in most instances swinging hand over hand over the banisters, The crush on the rear steps were some thing trememdous in the graud seramble wJfl in, and Lizzle Borden’s attendants bad to fairly force a passage through for bher %o obtain entrance to the corridor. For the first time in many years’ experi ence in court attendance the stern tones of the chief justice himself were heard in a demand from the bench that the crowds in the alsles and benches be seated, that proper decorum be observed. The First Grand Plea of the Day was Governor Robinson's argument for the defense. In its general trend o pur supd very closcly the line of evidence pre sented by the prosecution. 534 Assuming an easy posture, squarely fac ing the panel, Mr. Robinson :‘novd both
Defense attorney (former Governor) George Robinson delivers his closing argument to the jury, discrediting prosecution witnesses like Officer Mullaly and Mrs. Reagan while emphasizing reasonable doubt. He uses vivid rhetorical imagery and highlights contradictions in the prosecution's case.
Pawtucket Tribune · 20 June 1893 · page 1
called by the defense, Mr, Mullaly said Laabinsky told him that it was 10:30 when he passed the Borden house that morning of the murder. Lubinsky was supported by his stable keeper, however, as to the time. Now, as to Mullaly fixing the tii e &
District Attorney Knowlton delivered a dramatic and declamatory closing argument for the prosecution, arguing that being a Christian woman was no defense against guilt. Following his plea, Associate Justice Dewey delivered the judge's charge to the jury, explaining points of law and instructing them on how to weigh the evidence before deliberations began.
The Providence News · 20 June 1893 · page 1
IAM It was declamatory; it was dramatic. There was not the calm presentation of the case that one naturally expects from the publis prosecator. His every effort was to impress upon the jury, not the story as told by the evidence, but the story as the prosecution outlined it from the very ptart, Starting with a theory that Liz zie Borden was guilty the government proposes, if possible, to prove her guilty. He touched upon the erime and its aw fulness, reiterated with rhetorieal effort the pain it caused him to do his duty and then posed for dramatic effect.
See moreSee less
He said that the prisoner at the bar was a woman—a Christian woman ~yet that was no argumeont in her favor. Christian women had committed crimes before this one. He valued Chris tian character highly, but he instanced many cases where religion w.s simply a cloak covering a mass of wickedness. He had sympathy forfthe woman, but also sympatuy for the slain—for these cut down in the noonday of life, when they should have been left to enjoy the fruits o, their labors. He called attention to the nature of the evidence. Everyone who
District Attorney Knowlton delivers his closing argument, explaining the legal distinction between direct and circumstantial evidence using Robinson Crusoe's footprints as an example. He argues the motive was malice toward Mrs. Borden, citing family discord and dismissing the mysterious note as a fabricated lie.
The Providence News · 20 June 1893 · page 1
this case bears on her. Then he brought in the *‘skeleton in the Dorden family,” drawing as his con clusion that because Lizzie ceased call lur Mrs. Borden mother she hated her with such an inteusity as to lead her to kill both Mrs, Borden and her own father, The evideuces of ill-will rested in the facts that there had long previ ously beeu a quarrel over some property and thav the girls. did vot eat their meals always with Mrs. Borden. He then detailed at some leugth the history of the morning of the murders, laying special stress ou the fact thkat no one ever showed up who sent or took the note to Mrs.
See moreSee less
Borden. This statement he conaracterized as a lie, “Gentlemen, incredulity can somepimes be dismissed by evideunce, but I am not
This report covers District Attorney Knowlton's closing argument in the Borden murder trial, in which he argues that motive need not be proven and describes a climate of family tension and jealousy. He dramatically declares that the woman who came downstairs that morning was not Andrew Borden's daughter but a murderess.
The Providence News · 20 June 1893 · page 1
cblivion that it would bring. “Wedon't know what plans this man mn'y bhave had for his daughters or his wile, “We cannot tell what his testamen tary purposes may have been, but we do know of the existence of a jenlousy that constancly threatenei him and sur rounded his daily lile, like a barrier to all family happigess, “We left last night the dead body of Mrs. Borden lyiug dead in that upper room. “We again turn to that most awful wo:d in the language—matricide. “Iv was not Lizzie Audrew Borden who eame down stairs that morning when Andrew J. Borden came in, “It was not the daughter of Andrew J. Borden, "It Was & Murdesess.” “Her heart was changed.
The report praises defense attorney Robinson's closing argument as a masterful piece of advocacy, while noting the contributions of fellow defense counsel Jennings and Adams. It also describes District Attorney Knowlton's closing argument as fair and eloquent despite the difficulties posed by weak prosecution evidence, and commends the overall conduct of the trial by Massachusetts officials.
The Providence News · 20 June 1893 · page 4
THE PLEAS. The pleas of the counsel in the Bor den case were worthy of the occasion, That of Mr. Robinson for the defense will take its place among the great ef forts of great lawyers for great occa sions, It was a very subtle work of art, with the art so skillfully disguised as to make it appear to be but the honest and feeling outpouring of a heart filled with anxiety that the truth be known and appreciated by the twelve good men and tgne to whom it was addresed, and an acute intelligence laboring to transfer its knowledge and convic tions, Mr. Robinson’s closing argument for Lizzie Borden was an altogether fitting
Defense attorney Governor Robinson opens closing arguments, claiming Lizzie Borden was physically unable to commit the murders and that only a maniac could have done it. He reviews the chronology of events, noting no direct evidence ties her to the crime and no proof she knew where the weapon was kept.
The Salt Lake Herald · 20 June 1893 · page 1
SUMMING UP THE CASE
ings with an argument for the defense He began by declaring that the defendant was physically unable to commit the crime in the manner committed that aside from that it was only possible for a maniac or devil to do it He asked the jury to bring their homes hearts and in tellects into the decision of the case Then he rehearsed chronolgically the events connected with the crime He saw no reason to connect defendant with it There was no direct evidence against Miss Borden whatever he said and no know ledge of the use of the weapon had been shown The evidence shows that the defendant did not know where the alleged weapon was kept Lizzie Borden was at home the morning the murders were com
Former Governor Robinson delivers closing argument for Lizzie Borden's defense, arguing lack of direct evidence, no proven weapon, and inconsistencies in the prosecution's timeline. He contends anyone could have entered the house unseen and questions how Lizzie could have avoided bloodstains if guilty.
The Salt Lake Herald · 20 June 1893 · page 1
ARGUMENTS ARE BEGUN
never heard a quarrel between Lizzie and Mrs Borden The speaker then related the fact of the alleged blood stained dress and the burning of it I Lizzie Borden killed her stepmother at 945 did she come down and greet her father in a blood stained dress She must have changed I thingand changed it again after the second slaughter Lizzie didnt try to getBridget out of the house Dont you think she would have sent her on some errand The attorney pointed out that the doctors disagreed as to what was used to kill the Bordens and touched upun the clawheaded hatchet and hatchet without
Ex-Governor Robinson concludes the defense's closing argument, arguing anyone could have entered the house and that no blood was found on Lizzie's head. District Attorney Knowlton then begins the prosecution's summation, emphasizing the lack of opportunity for an outside assassin and disputing Lizzie's story about a note received by Mrs. Borden.
The Salt Lake Herald · 20 June 1893 · page 1
ARGUMENTS ARE BEGUN
to formulatc i possible some plan of union amongclaaring houses Faurth There will be a conference of of days J Knowlton Degan to sum up for the defense However we may differ we can agree that this is the most heart I rending case The woman we are trying tryng is a Christian and i is i hard to consider a woman guilty 01 sucn a crime out inc greatest criminals of the world have been women and we must face this case as men No one who has told of it saw Lizzie Bor den burn that dress While Mr Bor den was down at the hank that morning the assasin met Mrs Borden and killed her It was against her that hate was II directed There was one woman in the
The editorial reports that editors widely expect Lizzie Borden to be acquitted, arguing the prosecution's strongest evidence was excluded by the court. It cites the exclusion of testimony about her alleged hatred of home, an attempted prussic acid purchase, and her inquest statements as critical blows to the Commonwealth's case.
Richmond Dispatch · 20 June 1893 · page 2
TUESDAY...... +.....JUNE 20, 1803, The Lizzie Borden Trial Many editors feel so certain that Lizzre Bonney will be acquitted that they have begun to denounce the police and magis
The New York Herald discusses the legal reasoning behind the defense's decision not to put Lizzie Borden on the witness stand. It explains that an accused person has the right to decline testifying without the jury drawing unfavorable inferences, and notes that cross-examination could have seriously damaged her case.
Richmond Dispatch · 20 June 1893 · page 4
Especially in murder cases where the proot of guilt is circumstantial 1t would be risky and might frove disastrous to ex pose to & searching cross.examinsation even an \nnocent accused person. It bas been said with no little force that Dr. Buchanan simply convicted himself by appearing a6 a witness in his own behalf ou his recent trial in this city. Lazzie Borden could not have helped her case by taking the stand. ‘The chances sre that she would have damaged it very seriously.
This report covers the defence attorney Robinson's closing plea to the jury in the Lizzie Borden trial, reviewing the circumstances of the crime. It describes the courtroom scene and Robinson's rhetorical appeal about the horrific nature of the Borden murders.
Richmond Dispatch · 20 June 1893 · page 1
Ihe (eo Crime Reviewed, eoraph to the Dispatch.) «,, June 19, ~The day Af as Borden trial breught a + the court-house, and over an time of opening the doors « i by people, mostly ladies, +5. There were not enough .r. for a tenth part of the 1 when the court was ready ; many ladies standing in the cotiv ushered into the ante. rridlors. The bar enclosure : with legal hights. The jury <0 looking quite refreshed . «rest, aud a few minutes : «len came in, a bunch of 1 and a contented smile \ <t immediately Governor , his argument,
Governor Robinson concludes his defense argument for Lizzie Borden, challenging the prosecution's evidence including the burned dress, hatchet, and Matron Hilliard's testimony. The report also describes unruly, disorganized crowds pushing and jostling attendees, including Lizzie Borden herself, outside the courthouse.
Richmond Dispatch · 20 June 1893 · page 1
DISGRACEFUL ECENES, The scenes about the court-house this afternoon were disgraceful, There wasno gystemn about the method of seating peo ple, and ladies were tossed about the walks, in the corridors, and on the stairs in the most reckless and careless manner. When Miss Borden came in she was pushed and crowded abont just as everybody else was, and there was justa touch of asperity in her manner as she entered the court. roow and faced the buzzing erowd.
Defense attorney Robinson addresses the jury, calling the Borden murders one of the most diabolical crimes ever committed and describing the horrific wounds inflicted on the victims. He argues the investigation was poorly conducted, with no proper clues followed and no formal inquest testimony from the accused.
Richmond Dispatch · 20 June 1893 · page 1
: eS R (bolheal erimes ever com. ccachusetts was Feposiuted Con ball Kaver, The enormi. oL evervhody, Every man s «hould be righted and cht to justice. Here was t« horrors, and who could an acts asks everybody. of a home in that broad : «treets of a populous ety, vo dome 1t7 Inspection «. borden had been slain ae sharp instrument, and «wo. Mr. Borden's mutilated : r« of those scenes no lan. vw. and we are challenged + nud who was equal to that ‘ « whole beart 15 blackened come, not a man of senses , lunatic, & devil, Directed blows which
A defense lawyer delivers an impassioned closing speech to the jury, invoking the presumption of innocence and urging jurors not to be swayed by public clamor or the desire to find a culprit. He argues the jury's only question is whether Lizzie Borden herself committed the murders, not who did, and warns against convicting an innocent woman to satisfy public demand for a victim.
Richmond Dispatch · 20 June 1893 · page 1
\. borden has been in your ‘Le day we opened this case, < tue time when not alone r« tospoeak for her and the jus.
Defense attorney ex-Governor Robinson systematically goes through the prosecution's evidence in his opening statement, offering alternative explanations for the blood spots, Lizzie's varying statements, the burned dress, and other key points. He argues these details are consistent with innocence rather than guilt.
Richmond Dispatch · 20 June 1893 · page 1
ANALYZING THE EVIDENCE
dencein detail, The only connection be. tween defendant and the crimes was the blood spo on the skirt, which was ex plainable as menstrual blood. The pro. position that lazzie must have seen Mrs. Borden’s body when up-stairs was unsound, because the body conld be geon from oniy one stair, and here she would not stop and look it she did not suspect wrong. lazzie's statement that her mother had received a note and gone out was pla af Mrs Borden told both Iazzie and Bridget about it, and that they could not believe lazzie hed about it.
See moreSee less
Lizzie's varying statements that she was in the yard and the barn wero reconcilable, Ibe testimony of three men proved that Rubinsk: saw the defendant conung to the house from the barn, and therefore ber statement of her wnereabouts at the time of the murders was true, When Liz zie spoke about going up-stairs for Mrs, Borden she meant thetfront stairs, because all knew she could not be up the back stairs, as a sheet had been obtained from there, lazzie's laughter on the stairs was immaterial unless guilt was assumed, The ring buried with Mr. Borden shows ber affection for ham. The custom of
This item appears solely as a headline, 'The Lizzie Borden Trial,' but the text that follows is entirely about the Hawaiian annexation crisis and the Nicaragua Canal, evidently due to a page layout or scanning error. No actual trial content is present in this passage.
A brief note states that the day of closing arguments in the Lizzie Borden trial drew an overflow crowd, causing a terrific jam at the courthouse. The item is embedded amid unrelated news about forest fires, pension fraud, and a publishing company's collapse.
The Times · 20 June 1893 · page 1
The district attorney had not concluded his argument when the court adjourned for the day. He devoted himself to weav ing a web of clreumstantial evidence against Lizzie Borden. Touching upon her good character, he called the jury's at tention to the case in Fall River, where 1 few years ago some prominent church members went wrong, saying that they were rotten to the core, and it was de monstrated that those who stand close to he sanctuary are not free from the taint sf sin. He argued that it was malice wgainst Mrs.
See moreSee less
Borden that inspired the murder. It was the act of a person who cpent the forenoon in that house, and his fact bears on this case from begin ning to end. : He spoke of the skeleton in the Borden wousehold and Lizzie's refusal to call her stepmother “mother.” Here the speaker eviewed the movements of the family on he morning of the tragedy from the {me of their arising in the morning, hrough the time when Mr. and Mrs. Bor len and Morse took breakfast together, he time of Morse going away and Mr. jorden locking the screen door after him; hen Mr. Borden goes down town; then irideget goes out washing windows, Mrs. Jorden goes into the guests’ chamber, and Lizzie and she are above stairs. Lizale hen goes outdoors to see If Bridget Is
Governor Robinson began his closing argument for the defense, walking the jury through the prosecution's evidence point by point. He argued the bloodstain on the stairs was menstrual blood, disputed that Lizzie must have seen her stepmother's body, and explained her account of a note her mother supposedly received.
The Times · 20 June 1893 · page 1
GOVERNOR ROBINSON'S APPEAL FOR LIZZIE BORDEN
When the court was ready for opening many ladies were standing in the alsles, but they were quietly ushered to the ante-rooms and corridors. The bar en closure was picked with legal lights. The jury took thelr seats at 8:55, look Ang quite refreshed after two days’ rest, and a few minutes later Miss Borden came in with a bunch of pinks in her hand and a contented smile on her face, and almost immediately Governor Robin son began his argument. Governor Robinson made a careful, 1dglcal discussion of the crime and its discovery, as they appear from the evi dence.
See moreSee less
The prisoner sat in the dock with her face covered with a fan, while | he analyzed the evidence. After cautioning the jury ‘o disregard certaln parts of the district attorney's opening, as not proved by the evidence, the ex-Governor proceeded to dispose of cartain points of the prosoeution’'s evi dence In detail. The only eonnection he tween defendant and the erimes was the blood spot on the stalr, which was ex plainable as menstrual blood. The propo sition that Lizzle must have seen Mrs. Borden's body when upstairs was un sgund, because the body could be seen from only one stair, and there she would not stop and look, if she did not suspect wrong. lYdzzie's statement that her mother had received a note and had gone out was plain, if Mrs. Borden told both Lizzie and Bridget about it, and that they could not believe Lizzie lied about it. Lizzie's varying statements that she was in the yard and the barn were recon cllable. The testimony of three men proved that Rubinsky saw the defendant coming to the house from the barn, and therefore her statement of her wherea bouts at the time was true. When Liz zle spoke about going upstairs for Mrs. Borden, she meant the front stairs, be cause all knew she could not be up the back stair, as a sheet had been obtained from there, Lizzie's laughter on the stairs was immaterial, unless gullt was assumed, The ring buried with Mr. Borden shows
Ex-Governor Robinson, defending Lizzie Borden, systematically countered the prosecution's evidence, explaining the blood spot, varying statements, dress burning, and locked doors as innocent. He argued exclusive opportunity was unproven and suggested an outside assassin could have committed the crime.
The Times · 20 June 1893 · page 1
Borden's body when upstairs was un sgund, because the body could be seen from only one stair, and there she would not stop and look, if she did not suspect wrong. lYdzzie's statement that her mother had received a note and had gone out was plain, if Mrs. Borden told both Lizzie and Bridget about it, and that they could not believe Lizzie lied about it. Lizzie's varying statements that she was in the yard and the barn were recon cllable. The testimony of three men proved that Rubinsky saw the defendant coming to the house from the barn, and therefore her statement of her wherea bouts at the time was true.
See moreSee less
When Liz zle spoke about going upstairs for Mrs. Borden, she meant the front stairs, be cause all knew she could not be up the back stair, as a sheet had been obtained from there, Lizzie's laughter on the stairs was immaterial, unless gullt was assumed, The ring buried with Mr. Borden shows
Governor Robinson concludes the defense's closing argument, urging the jury to acquit Lizzie Borden for lack of proof. District Attorney Knowlton begins the prosecution's closing, building a circumstantial case by reviewing the household's movements on the morning of the murder and suggesting motive tied to family discord.
The Seattle Post-Intelligencer · Seattle, Wash. Terr. Wash.
The report covers the opening of closing arguments in the Lizzie Borden trial at New Bedford, with defense attorney Gov. Robinson delivering his summation. He argued Lizzie was physically incapable of the crime, lacked blood evidence, had no known connection to the weapon, and reviewed the timeline of events including Bridget's and the ice cream peddler's testimony.
The Seattle Post-Intelligencer · 20 June 1893 · page 1
STRONG PLEA FOR ACCUSED.
New BXPFORD, Man., June 19.— Tha day of argument in tne Lizzie Borden trial opened with a great crowd at tha court ■house, scarcely one-tenth of whom could get admission. A large proportion of those in attendance were fashionable ladies in holiday attire. The defendant appeared fresh and smiling. GOT. Robinson optfifedl the proceedings with an argument for the defense. He be gan by deciaring tbe defendant physically unable to commit the crime in the manner in which it was committed; that aside from that, it was only possible for a maniac devil to do it.
See moreSee less
He asked the jury to bring their homes, hearta and intellects into their decision in the case. Ha then re hearsed chronologically tha events con nected with the crime, and continued: Ho saw no reason to connect a confederate of defendant with it Them was BO direct evi dence against Miss Borden, he said, whatever, and no knowledge of the use ot the weapon had been shown. The evidence shows that aefenl aut did not know where the alleged weapon was kept. There was not a spot of blood on her from her head to her fset with the except! jn of one as bix as api ahead on her skirt. Lizzie Bor den waa home on tbe aormng the murder was committed, and it ska bad gone up stairs and looked under tbo bod she might have aesn the body of her stepmother. Both Lizzie aad Bridget tell about tbe noia which called Mrs. Borden oat, and both were told of tt by Mrs. Borden. Lizzie aaid abo had been in the barn twenty mlnutea. An lee cream peddler who knjw Bridget went by and saw a woman, bat not Bridget, walking to tha boose from the barn. Five minutee recess was here taken and the address discussed freely by spectator*, much disappointment being expressed •bout it Gov. Robinson after the recess continued: When Bridget baud that Mr. Bordea was dead she said aba weald go to Mrs. Whitehead's and tail Mrs. Borden, I(she was there. That corroborates the note theory. Bridget Sullivan. who lor two years has been closer to the family than any one elae, never heard a quarrel between Uneand Mrs. Borden. Thespeeker then related the fact of the alleged b.oodslalued dree* sad the horning of It If lassie Borden hilled her step-mother at 9:45 du •become down and greet her father in her bloodstained drees? Shi must bees changed her elotbing and change! It again after the sec ond slaughter. loss* did not try to get Bridget out of the bona* Don't you think ahe would bare sent her en soma errand? The doctors had disagreed a*£o what had been used to kill the Borden* Be touched upon the claw headed batehet an&ttiafcitebet without a handle. If thoae were not tha tea pie men ts with which the murder was committed where are they? The exclusive opportunity theory wee sim ply anticipation, which might be realised. Any bjdy could have gotten into the house by simply avoiding Bridget on the outside and Liuie on the in*id& IJe held that the joung man aeea in the vicinity was an outside spy for the person committing the deed and that the job was not done by one person. If there bad been any blood on defendant's hair, he said, those who were bathing her face would have discovered it It was 3 o'clock when the ex-governor closed and District Attorney Knowlton be gan to sum up for the prosecution. Prosecutor Knowiton said:
The Seattle Post-Intelligencer · Seattle, Wash. Terr. Wash.
Robinson's closing argument for the defense argues there is no direct evidence against Lizzie Borden, no blood on her clothing except a small spot, and no proof she knew where the weapon was kept. He raises alternative theories, including an unidentified outsider and conflicting medical testimony about the murder weapon, before District Attorney Knowlton begins the prosecution's summation.
The Seattle Post-Intelligencer · 20 June 1893 · page 1
The Seattle Post-Intelligencer · Seattle, Wash. Terr. Wash.
Defense attorney (ex-Governor Robinson) argues about the murder weapon and suggests an outside intruder exploited gaps in supervision, while District Attorney Knowlton begins the prosecution's closing, arguing Lizzie had motive, opportunity, and fabricated the note story. The report also notes a located witness, Felix Borden, clarifying his earlier reported comments about Lizzie were based on newspaper accounts, not personal knowledge.
The Seattle Post-Intelligencer · 20 June 1893 · page 1
STRONG PLEA FOR ACCUSED.
Prosecutor Knowiton said: However we may differ, we can agree that this is a most heartrending case. The woman we are trviog is a Christian. It Is hatd to con sider a woman guilty of such a crime, but the greatest criminals of the world have been women, and we mutt faro this case as men. No oae who has told of U aaw Lime Borden burn that dres* While Mr. Borden was down at the bank that morning theaaamwin met Mrs. Borden and killed ber. It was against her that Llizic's
The Seattle Post-Intelligencer · Seattle, Wash. Terr. Wash.
This report announces that Lizzie Borden's trial for the murder of her father and stepmother began on June 5th in New Bedford and is expected to conclude soon, noting intense national interest. It recaps the crime itself, describing how Andrew and Abby Borden were found hacked to death with a hatchet, with no robbery and no suspicion falling on the servant Bridget Sullivan.
The Seattle Post-Intelligencer · 20 June 1893 · page 4
THE RORDC!) TRIAL. T?!* trial of Lizzie Borden, charged with lt.iv murder of l:er father and •tepmotbcr, began at New Itedford, Mass.. on M ts»e sth Inst., probably closes tflrf. This trial, which haa lasted two has excited the deepest interest thr -iifhout the whole country. No mnr d«" trial bat been so <u'ly reporter! by the les'ing newspapers of the East since Prof. Jchti W. Webster, of Harvard college, was tru I 'or the murder of !>r. i'arkman at it-oti »i in !•«». Andrew Borden, of Fail K'»--r, Mas*., and hi» wife were found m in their dwelling house last *«'i=n er; the murderer killed them w.th • haii-bet, splitting their heads open with rejTV.ed blow*.
See moreSee less
The dead body of the wtJ iian was found lying in an upper cham ber, where she had been struck down wl J!«» she «at work. Mr. Borden was kii I while lying on the sofa in the sit ting toom about 11 o'clock in tbe fore lte< n. The condition of his wife's body prove 1 thai she had l»een kdled ahout two bouii before, or shortly after 9 o'clock, when the went up stairs to dust the cham ber'. Mr. Borden's wateh and money
The Seattle Post-Intelligencer · Seattle, Wash. Terr. Wash.
The report reviews trial testimony, noting the timing of Mrs. Borden's death, that no robbery occurred, and that suspicion fell on Lizzie Borden due to her account of a mysterious note her stepmother supposedly received. It summarizes the prosecution's 'exclusive opportunity' theory versus the defense's argument that an intruder could have hidden in the house and escaped through an unlocked door.
The Seattle Post-Intelligencer · 20 June 1893 · page 4
THE BORDEN TRIAL
•he u»ld she did not know; she thought probably that Mrs. Borden had burned It in tbe kitchen ttove. This Delias not been found; nor has any
The Seattle Post-Intelligencer · Seattle, Wash. Terr. Wash.
The report argues the prosecution's case collapsed after key inquest testimony was excluded because Lizzie had effectively been a prisoner when she gave it. It predicts a disagreement or acquittal is likely, while speculating she may still be guilty and possibly insane, comparing her to Guiteau, and describing her mixed emotional reactions in court.
The Seattle Post-Intelligencer · 20 June 1893 · page 4
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
The trial's argument phase opens in New Bedford with a packed courtroom, Lizzie Borden appearing fresh and smiling. Governor Robinson, for the defense, argues she was physically unable to commit the murders and that only a 'maniac devil' could have done it.
Fairhaven Herald · 20 June 1893 · page 1
NEw BEprorn, Mass., June 19—The day of argument in the Lizzie Borden trial opened with a great crowd at the court house, scarcely one-tenth of whom could get admission. A large proportion of those in attendance were fashionable ladies in holiday attire. The ‘defendant appeared fresh and smiling. Governor Robinson opened the pro ceedings with the argument for the defense. He began by declaring the defendant physically unable to commit the erime in the manner committed; that aside from that it was only pos-| gible for a maniac devil to do it. He asked the jury to bring their homes, their hearts and intellects into a decision of the case, Denver Political Difficulties
The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · Wheeling, W. Va.
At the New Bedford courthouse, defense attorney ex-Governor Robinson began his closing argument, claiming the state had not produced a particle of evidence proving Lizzie Borden committed the murders. He argued it was physically and morally impossible for her to have done it, and criticized the Fall River police investigation.
The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · 20 June 1893 · page 1
everybody was obliged to sit down. Tbo jury took their seats at 8:55, looking quito fresh after two days' rest, and a few minutos lator Miss Borden cuino in, a bunch of pinks in hor land and a contented smile on her face. The jury was pollod promptly on tho oponing of courtAlmost Immediately Governor Hobinaon began his argument. He said:
The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · Wheeling, W. Va.
Former Governor Robinson begins his closing argument for Lizzie Borden's defense, describing the murders as horrific and dastardly while arguing such acts are morally impossible for the defendant. He emphasizes that the preliminary hearing proceedings should not influence the jury and praises the district attorney for conducting the prosecution fairly without seeking undue fame.
The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · 20 June 1893 · page 1
COUNSEL ROBINSON BEGINS
populous city, who could have dono it? Inspection showed Mrs. Borden had boon slain by the use of some sharp instrument,* and below stairs was Mr. Borden's mutilated body. The terrors of those scenes no language can portray, and wo aro challenged at tlio outset
The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · Wheeling, W. Va.
Defense counsel Robinson addresses the jury, urging them to consider only proven facts and not to infer guilt from preliminary hearings or police suspicion. He argues Lizzie Borden is innocent, criticizes the Fall River police for bias, and calls on jurors to judge carefully as free men responsible for her fate.
The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · 20 June 1893 · page 1
COUNSEL ROBINSON BEGINS
hearings. "Wo come hero to seek freodom and through you gontloinon. As you bogiu lo contomplato this crime you must say such actn are physically and morally iinpossiblo for this young woman. It is u wreck of human morals to say this of hor. Tho defense complains of no parsocutiou on the part qf tho district attorney. Ho has only one duty to do, and with bis well oarned fam'o at tho bar he has no need to soarch for fame, and bo will bo the last man to attempt such.
See moreSee less
He stands abovo such things, and says, 'all I have is tho case as it Is, una m u was urouu'iu uiu uy uiu punne of Fall Kivor.' Ho ib not lioro (or blood, noltbor is ho helped for that purpose by our friend from Essex county. So you seo no small play, no mean tactics on the part of the commonwealth, only a presentation of what lias boon proved hero and only that. tui: I'olice sconm Iloro the upoakor referred to the kindly manner in which the sherifl bad used Miss Borden and said: "Sbo como In. camo in this court, prosidod ovor by
The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · Wheeling, W. Va.
The report quotes ex-Governor Robinson's opening remarks for the defense, arguing Lizzie Borden should not be convicted simply because no other suspect has been found. The editorial contends the prosecution has failed to prove guilt beyond reasonable doubt and that she deserves acquittal.
The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · 20 June 1893 · page 4
The Borden Case.
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · Wheeling, W. Va.
A newspaper comment suggests that if people keep sending flowers to Lizzie Borden, others may come to believe she is guilty, noting sarcastically that only the guilty receive such abundant floral tributes. The remark reflects public commentary circulating during her murder trial.
The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · 20 June 1893 · page 4
Ip people continuo to send liowora to izzio Borden other pooplo will begin i fear she is guilty. Tho guilty got the iwors in riotous abundance.
At the New Bedford courthouse, crowds packed in for the start of closing arguments in the Borden trial. Ex-Governor Robinson began his defense argument, addressing the jury about the shocking nature of the crime and urging them to rely only on evidence.
Wheeling Register · 20 June 1893 · page 1
B ants, and there was much grumbling iu rag consequence. H .... __ OL..ia tu.uk. In tVlA V1 U*JU ^uunu » 'F* -* aisles ware cleared lu a second, and everybody was obliged to sit down. The jury took their seals at S:55, look ing quite refreshed after two days rest, and a few minutes later Miss Borden came in, a bunch of pinks in her hand and a contented smile on her face. The Jury was polled promptly on the opening of court, and almost Immedi ately Gov. Robinson began his argu ment.
See moreSee less
lie said: gov. Robinson’s argument. May it please your honors, Mr. Fore man and gentlemen:—One of the most das tardly and diabolical crimes ever commit ted in Massachusetts was perpetrated in August, It-** in Fall River. The enormity of It startled everybody. Every man feels that the wrong should be righted and the wicked brought to justice. Here was a crime with all its horrors and "who could have done such an act!” says everybody. In the quiet of a home, in the broad day light, on the streets of a populous city, who could havedouoit* Inspection showed Mrs. Borden had been slain by the use of some sharp instrumfeut and below stairs was Mr. Borden’s mutilated body. The
Governor Robinson opens his closing argument for the defense, calling the murders a diabolical crime that must have been committed by a maniac, not the defendant. He argues the preliminary hearings should not influence the jury and praises the prosecutor's fairness while insisting Lizzie Borden is innocent.
Wheeling Register · 20 June 1893 · page 1
THE CELEBRATED BORDEN CASE.
Mrs. Borden had been slain by the use of some sharp instrumfeut and below stairs was Mr. Borden’s mutilated body. The terrors of those sc mes no language can
A defense attorney delivers closing arguments to the jury, urging them to see Lizzie Borden as an innocent, free woman in their charge rather than property of the court. He criticizes the Fall River police for building the case against her while praising the district attorney for conducting the prosecution fairly without seeking undue fame or persecution.
Wheeling Register · 20 June 1893 · page 1
A WORD ABOL T THX POLICE. Here tne speaser reierreu iu me muui> manner in which the sheriff had used Miss Borden, and said: She came in this court,
Ex-Governor Robinson gave a four-and-a-half-hour closing address for Lizzie Borden's defense before a large audience of fashionable ladies. The district attorney then followed with the state's summation.
The Cheyenne Daily Leader · 20 June 1893 · page 1
icated yesterday. Ex-Governor Robinson before an immense audience composed largely of fashionable ladies delivered a four and one-half hours closing address in behalf of Lizzie Borden. The dis trict attorney then summed up for the state.
The jury in the Borden murder trial has declared Lizzie Borden not guilty. The report also recounts the final day of closing arguments, including the prosecution's dismissal of motive and skepticism about her alibi in the barn loft.
Paper unidentified · 21 June 1893 · page 1
LIZZIE BORDEN CLEAR. The Jury in the Bordan Case Declare that Lizzie is Innocent of Murder. The crowd which usually thronged the corridors of the court building in New Bedford, Mass, where the trial of Lizzie Borden for murder has been in progress for the past several weeks, was not so large yesterday as on the previous days. However, at the open ing of the court there were as many people in the room as any time du ring the session. Miss Borden enter ed the room at 8:55 and Gov. Robin
The defense attorney closes his argument by attacking the prosecution's theory, including the barn alibi and dress evidence, before the judge instructs the jury on reasonable doubt and burden of proof. The jury retires and returns with its verdict, with Lizzie Borden standing as the foreman is polled.
Paper unidentified · 21 June 1893 · page 1
LIZZIE BORDEN CLEAR.
Continuing the speaker thoroughly reviewed the important evidence ad duced at the trial, on both sides of the case, and grappled in an able manner with every opposing fact which tend ed to destroy the theory of the prose cution as to Miss Borden’s guilt.
The report notes that the Lizzie Borden trial has reached its tenth day, with the prisoner reportedly in good spirits despite damaging testimony. It states evidence was presented that she had attempted to purchase prussic acid on the day her parents were murdered.
Arizona Weekly Journal-Miner · 21 June 1893 · page 1
Visaua, California, Juno 15. Chris Evans sustained tho ampu tatiou of his left hand j-edterdayin jail. The conditition or John Sou tag, tho other wounded bandit, has in a slight measure improved, aud there is now behoved to be a possi bility for his recovery. Tho out laws will 1m taken to Freano for rial as soon as thoir condition will permit. ?ew JiEDFORD, June in. inis IS the tenth day of the Lizzie Borden trial, aud the prisoner seems in good spirits. Sho has leon over whelmed with iloral offeringss, uot withstandinir the charactorof the ovidenco against her yesterday, in which it was proved that tno ue fotiflnnt had attemnted to purchase prussic acid on the day that her parents wero murdered. Fx. Gtinx. I.T.. June 15. Henry
A Newark barber named William H. Devere told police of a mysterious customer who had him shave off his hair and beard, then wrote and rewrote several letters, one addressed to the Mayor of Fall River. The story is presented as a dubious lead, likely the work of a crank rather than evidence of the real Borden assassin.
Tell-Tale Letters. A Confession to tho Mayor of Fall River That Ha Was the Slayer of the Bordens, New Yokk, Juno 20. William II, Devere has kept a barber shop at No
The report recounts Governor Robinson's defense summation questioning the prosecution's evidence, including the bloodstained dress, missing weapon, and opportunity for an outside intruder. It announces that Lizzie Borden was acquitted of the double murder after brief jury deliberation.
Arizona Republican · 21 June 1893 · page 1
NOT GUILTY. Acquitted of the Horrible Double Butchery. The Verdict Arrived at Yesterday Afternoon After a Very Brief Deliberation.
Nkw Redford, Moes., June 20. As sociated Press. Governor Robinson tuis ttfternooD rehearsed chronological events connected with tho Borden mur der. There is no doubt in the evidence against Mies Borden, he said. The evi dence Bhows the defendant did not know whero the alleged weapon was kept. Lizzie Borden was at Inmo on tlio morning the murders were com mitted, and if she had geno upstairs and looked under tho bed sho might have seen the body of her step-mother. Bridget Sullivan, who for two years had hr-pn n.ser to tho family than anyone else, never heard a quarrel between Lizzie nnd Mre. Borden.
The editorial comments on Lizzie Borden's acquittal, noting she is free from jail and the murder charge, crediting her lawyer's skillful defense. It acknowledges the murders remain unsolved, with Lizzie having been the only plausible suspect, and suggests the mystery may never be resolved.
Morning Journal and Courier · 21 June 1893 · page 1
One Dollar Per Year (in advance). Single Copies 5 cents. NOT GUILTY. Lizzie Borden may not be happy this morning, bnt she is probably a good deal more comfortable than she has been for
The jury deliberated only forty minutes before returning a verdict of not guilty in the Borden murder trial, prompting wild cheering from spectators that the sheriff made no attempt to stop. Lizzie Borden wept for the first time during the proceedings and declared herself the happiest woman in the world.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Morning Journal and Courier · 21 June 1893 · page 3
THE JURY IN THE BORDEN TRIAL FIND THAT THE ACCUSED IS INNOCENT OF THE MURDER OF HER FATHER AND MOTHER. THEY WERE OUT ONLY FORTY MINUTES. WHEN THE VERDICT WAS ANNOUNCED THE SPECTATORS IN THE COURT ROOM WENT WILD WITH JOY AND CHEERED FOR SEVERAL MOMENTS. LIZZIE BOWED HER HEAD AND CRIED FOR THE FIRST TIME SINCE HER TRIAL. SHE IS SOON TO GO HOME AND SHE SAYS THAT SHE IS THE HAPPIEST WOMAN IN THE WORLD.
New Bedford, Jane 20. The closing scene In the Borden trial was in direot con trast to those which had preceded H. Heretofore all had been decorum and In keeping with the dignity of the moat dig nified eonrt in the oonntry, but when the verdiot of "not tcalltj" was returned obeer went np which might have been heard half a mile away through the open windows, and there was no attempt to oheok it. The stately justices looked straight ahead at the bare walls. Sheriff Wright was powerless to wield the gavel which lay ready for his nse, and not once daring, the tremendous ezoltement which lasted fully a minntedidhe make the slight est sign of haying heard it.
See moreSee less
Ha never saw the people rising in their seats and waving their handkerchiefs in unison with their voloes, because his eyes were full of tears and were blinded for the time. ' lfiss Borden's head went down upon the rail in front of her1 and tears came where they bad not come for many a long day, as she heard the sweetest words ever poured Into her willing ears, the words "not guilty." Mr. Jennings was almost orying and his voice broke as he pat his hand out to Mr. Adams, who sat next to him, and said: "Thank God," while Mr. Adams returned the pressure of the hand and seemed in capable, of speech. Governor Robinson turned to tbe rapidly dissolving jury as they filed out of their seats and beamed on them with a fatherly Interest In his kindly eyes and stood np as Mr. Knowlton and Mr. Moody came over to shake hands with the counsel foi the defense. As soon as possible the room was cleared, although it was a hard task, sinoe every body wanted to shake hands with Miss Borden. Then she was taken to the room of the just ices and allowed to recover her oompoeure with only the eyes of friends upon, ber and the caresses of devoted ad mirers. ' At the expiration of an hont she was placed in a oarriase and driven to the station, where she took the train for Fall Elver her home no longer, probably, bat still tne only oDieouve point lor tne imme diate present. wnen tne court opened tnis morning District Attorney Knowlton pioked up the thread of hie closing argument. He said that counsel for the defense had said, that motive was a part of the government's case, bat the speaker said this was not so, although tbe consideration of motive has weight In elucidating the facts In the case. Motives, however, were neither adequate nor even tolerable when considered in con nection with a orime. The motives of mankind are as inscrutable as are the ways of Divine Providence, though it does af ford satisfaction to our reasoning to have discovered that there were unfortunate conditions in that family from which we can suspect even the malice existing. - He said that msy be Lizzie Borden did not plan to kill her father. Bat it was not Lizzie Borden who came down the stairs, but a murderess. He knew too muoh of the family relations for her to let him live. The second murder was not planned, bnt was done as a wioked and fearful neces sity. Bridget was doing her work when the old man was taking the last walk of his life. He stopped at various places, and finally turned into the yard of the honse t where his wife lay dead. He went around to the side door and found it locked; went to the front door and tried to use his key, but couldn't, and was let In by Bridg et. He came into the honse, sat down, and then came Lizzie from the very place that his wife lay dead and told him a false hood about where his wife was. Where was that stepmother! She knew that would keep the old man silent for a time, but not for long. Then Bridget came into the dining roam to wash the windows there, and the old man, after paying visit to his room, came into the sitting room again, and Lizzie, with the spirit of Judas kissing his master, suggested that he lie down to get a rest. She tells Bridget thai if she goes down town to look up the door, as she might go out herself. 'Then Bridget goes upstairs to get her rest and Lizzie goes on ironing, alone with her viotim. In less than twenty minutes she calls her servant down and tells her that her father is killed. She had a good fir to iron her clothes with, and I have the evidence to prove it, for Officer Har rington tells us that at 12;30 there were living embers in the stove, and we know if there was fire there then there was a better one earlier in the day. And when ahe was Ironing, why did she stop! There were only a few handkerchiefs to iron, but for all the time she was at work there were but few of them ready to lay away for use. 1 : I want to speak about a matter which necessitates reternn g acaln to tne note. Mr. Morse saw Mrs. borden disappear up stairs, presumably to make the bed. Liz zie comes down ana rets ner oreauast. Lassie finishes' her breakfast; Lizzie goes upstairs again. Mrs. Borden comes down stairs asaln and elves Bridcret Instructions aa to washing windows, and goes on dust ing. Bridget gets her water, cornea in the house to sbut down tne windows, ana Mrs. Berden has gone again. - - She was upstairs and was dead then. Then Lizzie comes down stairs. Nobody has come to either door bnt her father. Lizzie tells Bridget that Mrs. Borden has gone out and if she (Bridget) goes out she must look the door, because ahe (Lizzie) may go out. Then she tells about the note, but that note, if there was a note, was not the note of the assassin. Bhe had Just told Bridget and her father that hat step-mother had gone out, but she suggested to Mrs. Churchill, "She had a note to go out, but don't know but she is zuiea too. for think I heard her oome in." The counsel on the other side says the fall deceived her. Great heavens, has he forgotten that the fail had occurred long before ahe told Bridget ahe had son out: and when her father's body was found she never thought to call upon toe step-mower, one night up, but called to the servant, two flights no. What's the defenoel Nothins. nothing. I say again, nothing.; Some dust thrown in our faoea. . Some absurd stories about drunken men of pale and irresolute men walking the street in broad daylight and of fiehtins doosv Our case ia proven: we can't measure faota, we can't put a yard stick to them, but do they lead ua to the truth! If they do they have done mil can expect of themGive the prisoner every benefit, and ask yourselves are you satisfied! I submit all the facta In tha case to you with the oonfideno that you are man of sense; not to ask yon to avenge these deaths or to work for tha credit of the commonwealth, but I put it on a higher around than this. ies mercy be t care of; it ia not strange In this common wealth of Massachusetts, sot aa yon would like to think of having acted when -you stand before the Great White Throne. - Broeaa wea taken until 1:45 for the charge. The court came in, promptly at 1:40, every seat in na room oeing occupied xne onie? osaoe wen aoaxeasea Miss Borden by name, telling her that shenow had a voice and oouia say to tne jury what ahe ohosa to Bay. She arose a what aoitated and said to the jury: "1 "am innoeent, but I will leave my case in your hands and in the hands of ay counsel.'! -v.---- :: - . Judge Dewey then charged tha jury. Ha caotlomd them to.tke a decision only upon the law and the evldenoe and not to be lnBum .. flaeneed hv anvthina in tbe) prior proceed ings, and that no aetlon of tha prisoner since her arrest can be taken into con sideration. The -character and previous life of the defendant must always be taken into consideration. Taking aUthe faota into consideration is It a f act that mere was anv motive for Lizzie Borden to make away with her parents! There must be no magnifyingor belittling to make anything fit in wham it aeemlns'l v oueht to. The government claims that the acta oome under the head of murder in the first degree. The law claims that in order to nrove this evervthlntr claimed must be nroven bevond a reasonable doubt. There must be meat nantion in handling clrcum stantial evidence. The jury must bear in mind that failure to prove an eesentall fact would be fatal to the government's case: the government claimed that an essential fact was embraced In the note matter; that the defendant had made statements which she knew were false when she made them. The jury must be satisfied that they were raise. -JSvery tact proved must do con sistent with ornilt. The irovemment need not show that no one else bad the oppor tunity to commit the orime, bat mast prove that . the defendant committed it. The jury must reason as to the effect of the defendant's eonduct and statements. They were not to conclude by expert testimony, bnt were to apply it to a reason able judgment. They might oonviot if they were satisfied that the act was com mitted bv another person bnt that de fendant was present, aiding and abetting, for in the eyes of the law on ia equally Kutlty - with the other. The jury was cautioned against noticing in any way the fact that defendant did not take tne stand, The harden of proof is on the government and the defendant is not obliged to eiguta. shoulder say of it. The defence was not to deal with the evidence In a captious spirit. If not legally guilty the jury must ssyso. At the conclusion 01 the charge at 3:10 the jury retired. At 4:SU o'clook it was announced that they had reached a verdiot ana tney mea into the oonrt room and were polled. Mis Borden waa asked to stand up, and the foreman waa asked to return the -verdict, upon whioh he nounced "Not guilty." After tbe verdiot had been received the Uolumbia oarsmen. district attorney moved that the other cases against Miss Borden be nolle pros'd, and tbe order of the court was to that effect. Chief Justloe Mason then srabefully thanked the jury in appreciation of their work and faithful service, and reminded them that the precautions taken with them, whioh may have Beamed irksome at tbe time solely in the interest of justice, a fact which they undoubtedly realized now. The jury waa then dismissed and tbe court was adjourned until Monday next, when the regular criminal session will be opened. 8HS IB HAPPY.
The jury returns a verdict of not guilty, prompting tears and emotional reactions from Lizzie Borden and her counsel as the courtroom erupts in applause. The report also recaps District Attorney Knowlton's closing argument from earlier that morning, in which he argued Lizzie had reason to kill her parents despite the absence of a premeditated motive.
Morning Journal and Courier · 21 June 1893 · page 3
Borden. Then she was taken to the room of the just ices and allowed to recover her oompoeure with only the eyes of friends upon, ber and the caresses of devoted ad mirers. ' At the expiration of an hont she
A prosecution attorney reconstructs the morning timeline, arguing Lizzie had opportunity and motive to kill her parents and discrediting the defense's theories about mysterious strangers. He insists the evidence of a warm stove, inconsistent statements about the note, and her failure to check on her stepmother all prove her guilt.
Morning Journal and Courier · 21 June 1893 · page 3
necessitates reternn g acaln to tne note. Mr. Morse saw Mrs. borden disappear up stairs, presumably to make the bed. Liz zie comes down ana rets ner oreauast. Lassie finishes' her breakfast; Lizzie goes upstairs again. Mrs. Borden comes down stairs asaln and elves Bridcret Instructions aa to washing windows, and goes on dust ing. Bridget gets her water, cornea in the house to sbut down tne windows, ana Mrs. Berden has gone again. - - She was upstairs and was dead then. Then Lizzie comes down stairs. Nobody has come to either door bnt her father. Lizzie tells Bridget that Mrs. Borden has gone out and if she
This editorial argues Lizzie Borden's acquittal was expected since the prosecution proved little beyond her presence in the house. It criticizes the Fall River police for fixating on one theory, allowing the true killer to escape.
Waterbury Evening Democrat · 21 June 1893 · page 2
Borden was no surprise; it was only what was expected. The prosecution oroved absolutely nothing, except that proved aoao Ithe accused was in the house on the day
The report describes Lizzie Borden's acquittal in the murder trial, noting the jury took only an hour and a quarter to reach a not guilty verdict after Judge Dewey's charge favored her. It recaps the prosecution's closing argument about motive and the family's troubled living situation.
Waterbury Evening Democrat · 21 June 1893 · page 2
Received the Verdict. New Bedford, Mass., June 21. The loan agony is over, and Lizzie Borden to day ia a free woman. After the charge of Judge Dewey, no one expected 'any other verdict than that of "not guilty," which was rendered by the jury in an hour and a quarter after the judge had finished his charge. L.zzie Borden, the outcast of a year, is to day a heroine. But until the mystery of the murders is solved, the finger of sus picion will always be pointed at her. Court came in at v o clock yesterday. the jury was polled, and the District At torney picked up the thread of bis argu-
Knowlton continues his closing argument, addressing motive, the family's domestic discord, and Lizzie's inconsistent explanations. He reviews evidence including the burned dress, the handleless hatchet fitting the wounds, and testimony from witnesses like Mrs. Reagan and Medley to argue for her guilt.
Waterbury Evening Democrat · 21 June 1893 · page 2
many months. Mr. Kuowlton then proceeded to discuss the murder of Mr. Borden, which he argued might have been induced by the fact that he was the only person who would know Lizzie killed Mrs. Borden. He detailed Mr. Borden's action on the morning of the murder till he was left alone with the prisoner and emphasized the fact that she left her ironing unfin ished when the crime was committed. Reading her varying explanations of her conduct at the time of the crime, he argued that they were incredible. Rubinski's story was indefinite, and Medley's story refuted defendant a alibi, lhe pris oner watched Mr.
See moreSee less
Knowlton fixedly durin, his argument. Mr. Knowlton argued that the silk dress produced by the defendant was not the dress worn at the time of the murder as
The article announces that the jury acquitted Lizzie Borden, while also recapping District Attorney Knowlton's closing argument theorizing her motive for killing both stepmother and father. It notes the mystery of who committed the murders remains unsolved despite the verdict.
The Morning Call · 21 June 1893 · page 2
FREE FROM GUILT.
IFj«eUI ■■. Tar UoKMtxe fs-__. New Bedfoed, .Mass.. Jane 20. —At the opening of the Borden tri»l this norn ing, : District Attorney Knowlton resumed his j argument ln behalf cf tbe Commonwealth. I If* addressed .-. Mil to tte motive fori
The judge's charge to the jury emphasized the need for proof beyond reasonable doubt and noted weaknesses in the circumstantial case. The jury deliberated briefly and returned a verdict of not guilty, prompting cheers in the courtroom and emotional reactions from Lizzie Borden and her attorneys.
The Morning Call · 21 June 1893 · page 2
THE CRIME AND ITS MYSTERY. If Lizzie Borden Did Not Commit the Murder, Who Did? Altboagh the trial is endef and a jury bas declared Unto Borden not zuilty of, tbe atrocious double crime with which she stood chareef, titers is about UM case yet a mystery tbat has never boon unraveled, try the most tola analytical minis to un ravel it as 'bey may, aod that i: now seems will never bo solved. If Lizzie Borden did ' no: kill her parents, who did? Andrew" D. Borden, a man whose wealth wasestl \ mated at from $a>V£« to $500,000, was found murdered and with hU sad almost cot to ; sees on the lounge in the sitting room of bis b< ise, on second street, Fail R.v*r, st 11 :C5 o'clock on the morning of
After Lizzie Borden's acquittal, this report revisits the case, noting that the double murder of Andrew and Abby Borden remains unexplained if she is innocent. It recounts the murders, the suspicion that fell on Lizzie and servant Bridget Sullivan, and the inconsistencies in Lizzie's inquest testimony about the note and her whereabouts.
The Morning Call · 21 June 1893 · page 2
THE CRIME AND ITS MYSTERY. If Lizzie Borden Did Not Commit the Murder, Who Did? Altboagh the trial is endef and a jury bas declared Unto Borden not zuilty of, tbe atrocious double crime with which she stood chareef, titers is about UM case yet a mystery tbat has never boon unraveled, try the most tola analytical minis to un ravel it as 'bey may, aod that i: now seems will never bo solved. If Lizzie Borden did ' no: kill her parents, who did? Andrew" D. Borden, a man whose wealth wasestl \ mated at from $a>V£« to $500,000, was found murdered and with hU sad almost cot to ; sees on the lounge in the sitting room of bis b< ise, on second street, Fail R.v*r, st 11 :C5 o'clock on the morning of Thursday, August 4, ÜB2.
See moreSee less
When tbe a'artied friends and neighbors regained ; their senses sufficiently to Intend to ac quaint bis wife with tbe occurrence they found ber murdered in an almost exactly similar manner, on the floor of the second : story "spare XL," whither she had gone to prepare it for 'he reception of a guest. It appeared, ttcuzh this point was never folly Investigated by the police. that only two people were ii st about th» . boose at the time, namely, Lbs Borden, the dead man's danzhter, and Bridget Sol livan, a servant. Owing to the facts that superior int^llizence was requisite for the concealment of the crime and that the danzhter had not warmly loved, though it could not be shown tbat sbe even disliked her stepmother, and also tba: sbe had teen
The report announces that Lizzie Borden has been acquitted, with the jury deliberating only twenty minutes, as no direct evidence linked her to the murders beyond a theory of 'exclusive opportunity.' The article argues the prosecution's timeline for the killing was implausibly fast and suggests her unsociable reputation unfairly fueled suspicion.
The Morning Call · 21 June 1893 · page 6
THE , LIZZIE BORDEN CASE. Lizzie Borden Is free. It took the jury but twenty minutes to come to the de cision. No evidence was adduced cennecting the woman with the murder, and the prosecution has been compelled to rely upon the theory of "exclusive oppor tunity." If Lizzie had been convicted the verdict would have rested on the unstable ground that no one but herself had an opportunity of committing the crime. On such grounds in times past human life ha* been sacrificed to passing prejudice and passion. The theory of the prosecution is that in a period of time varying from eight to thirteen minutes Lizzie Borden hacked her father's head with an ax.
See moreSee less
broke the handle of the ax. cleaned the blade with ashes and placed it in a tool-chest, then changed her clothes and shoes, which were spat tered with blood, washed her hands and face and gave the alarm. The whole annals of crime contain no example of ; such swift work. An expert assassin, i used to wielding the ax as an instrument of murder and familiar with the. work of effacing blood stains, would have been embarrassed to do so much ln so few min utes; to assume that a cirl whose first essay in crime this was could have done so is straining credibility. The readiness of the authorities, the police and part of the people of Fall I.iver to suspect Lizzie Borden may in j
This editorial argues that circumstantial 'exclusive opportunity' reasoning used by prosecutors is risky, since the true field of suspects may be wider than assumed. It suggests an unknown intruder could have killed the Bordens and that it is better to entertain this possibility than convict a potentially innocent woman.
The Morning Call · 21 June 1893 · page 6
THE LIZZIE BORDEN CASE.
I may have killed Mr. and Mr*. Borden and ; have made his en-ape in the confusion | which followed L,z/ii,'s shrieks. The , hypothesis Involve* difficulties, but they ; are not insurmountable. Murderers some j times defy pursuit iv daylight and In busy | streets when the weapon they used is in their hand and their clothes are still be j spattered with the blood of their victim. I It is better to assume that the Bordens died by the hand of a dexterous assassin I than hang a woman who may lie innocent.
District Attorney Knowlton gave his closing argument, citing Lizzie's enmity toward her stepmother and inconsistencies in her dress-burning story and alibi as evidence of guilt. Despite this, the jury returned a not guilty verdict after deliberating for only twenty minutes.
The Herald · 21 June 1893 · page 1
the acte. The speaker continued, arguing that the silk dress produced by Jie defend ant was not the dress worn at the time of the murder. The two versions of the burning of the defendant's dress were irreconcilable. Ho discussed the de fendant's conduct since the murder, and declared the story told by Matron Regan and afterward denied by her, about a quarrel between the Borden sisters, was true.
The judge concludes his charge to the jury, emphasizing the circumstantial nature of the evidence and the possibility of an unknown assassin. The jury quickly returns a verdict of not guilty, prompting cheers in the courtroom and a jubilant celebration with crowds and a band at Borden's home in Fall River.
The Herald · 21 June 1893 · page 1
THE DEFENDANT ACQUITTED
THE VERDICT APFLAUDED. Then all the dignity and decorum of the court room vanished. A cheer went up which might have been heard half a mile away, and there was no attempt to check it. Miss Borden's head went down upon the rail in front of her and the tears came. Mr. Jennings was al most crying, while Dr. Adams seemed incapable of speech. As soon as possible the room was cleared, and when the spectators were finally gone, Miss Borden was taken to the room of the justices and allowed to recover her composure, with only tbe eyes of friends upon her and the caress of devoted admirers.
See moreSee less
At the expiration of an hour she was placed in a carriage and driven to the station, where she took a train for Fall River, her home no longer probably, but still the only ob jective point for the immediate present. Fall River, Mass., June 20. —Lizzie
The New Bedford trial of Lizzie Borden, accused of murdering her father and stepmother, ended with a not guilty verdict reached after only twenty minutes of deliberation. The report details Judge Dewey's charge to the jury regarding standards of proof and circumstantial evidence.
The Record-Union · 21 June 1893 · page 1
LIZZIE BORDEN ACQUITTED. A CELEBRATED MURDER TRIAL BROUGHT TO A CLOSE. Tho Jury Brings in a Verdict of Not Guilty—Accused Released From Prison. Special to the Record-Union.
After the judge's charge to the jury concerning circumstantial evidence and reasonable doubt, the jury deliberated and returned a verdict of 'not guilty.' The courtroom erupted in cheers, Lizzie Borden wept, and she was later taken by carriage to the train for Fall River.
The Record-Union · 21 June 1893 · page 1
BROUGHT TO A CLOSE.
A moment later the twelve men filed into their seats ami were polled. Miss Borden was asked to stand up, and the foreman was asked to return a verdict, which he announced, "not guilty." Then all the dignity and decorum of the courtroom vanished. A cheer went un which might have been heard a milo away, and there was no attempt to check it. Miss l.e.r deu's head went down upon the rail in front of her and tears came. Mr. Jen nings was almost crying, while Dr. Ad ams seemed incapable of speech.
See moreSee less
As soon as possible, the Toom was cleared, and when tho spectators had finally gone Miss Borden was taken to the room of the Justices, and allowed to recover her composure with only tho eyss of friends upon her and the caress of devoted ad mirers. At the expiration of an hour she was placed in a carriage and driven to the station, where she took tho train for Fail River, hor home no longer, proba bly, but still the only objective point for the immediate present.
The Record-Union states it withheld comment during the trial but now declares the jury wisely found Borden innocent. It blames police for assuming her guilt from the start and building their case around that theory instead of seeking the truth.
The Record-Union · 21 June 1893 · page 2
The words of this article could not be separated from the rest of its page. Read it in the clipping.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
Evening Journal · Wilmington, Del.
The New Bedford court discharged Lizzie Borden after the jury returned a verdict of not guilty, ending her ten months in custody. The report describes her composed demeanor, her declaration of innocence, and the tense atmosphere as the verdict was read.
Evening Journal · 21 June 1893 · page 1
ACQUITTED OF MURDER
SHE DROPPED LIKE AN OX, IN COURT, Nighty Shout Went Up From the Specta tors When the Jury Brought In Its Verdict of "Not Guilty**- Miss Borden Besieged By Hundreds of Friends and Well-Wishers-Governor Robinson Put Ills Arm Around Her# New Bedford, June 21.—"The court orders that you be discharged and go." That is tiie summary of the last words the old state of Massachusetts said to Liz zie Borden yesterday afternoon. Lizzie Borden had cut a great figure in the court room before her acquittal. She had come in showing every bit of the strain of ten months in the custody of the witch burners.
See moreSee less
As she rose from the chair every one noticed that she added to her extraordinary gracefulness a surpassing dignity. Erect, with her head held bravely up and with eyes that looked tenderly and yet firmly into the faces of her lawyers, she spoke a few words in a clear tone. "Gentlemen, I am innocent," said she. "I leave my counsel to speak for me." Then she resumed her seat, aud the read ing of the remarkable charge of the judges to the jury was the next proceed ing. Then the jury retired. "Lizzie Andrew Borden," said the clerk of the court, "stand up." She arose unsteadily with a face as white as marble. "Gentlemen, have yon agreed upon a verdict?" said the clerk 1o the jury. It was so still in the court that the flutter of two fans made a great noise. "We have," said Foreman Richards boldly. The prisoner was gripping the rail in front of the dock as it her standing up depended upon Its keeping its place. "L!zzie"Audrew [Borden," said the clerk, "hold upyour right hand." "Jurors, look upou the prisoner. Prisoner, look upon the foreman. " Every juryman stood at right about face, staring at the woman. There was such a gentle, kindly light beaming in every eye that no one questioned the verdict that was to be uttered. But God save every woman from the feelings that Lizzie Borden showed in the return look she cast upon that jury. It was what is
The jury returns a verdict of not guilty for Lizzie Borden, who collapses against the dock rail upon hearing the words. The court formally discharges her without bail, and the prosecutor enters a nolle prosequi on the remaining indictments.
The report describes the scene after Lizzie Borden's acquittal, including ex-Governor Robinson's emotional embrace of her and the judge's thanks to the jury. It then describes the surprised reaction in Fall River and Lizzie's arrival at the Holmes residence, where she gave a brief interview declaring herself 'the happiest woman in the world.'
Evening Journal · 21 June 1893 · page 1
Lizzie Burden Loaves Prison. Fall River, Mass. June 21.—The news of Lizzie Borden's acquittal was received with tiie greatest surprise in in this city. Even her warmest 'fri ends and most ardeut supporters dared not hope anything better than a disagree meut after reading the district attorney's argument in behalf of the government. Wlieu it was flashed over the wires that the prisoner had been acquitted, great excitement prevailed. Upon the streets the chief topic of of conversation was the unlooked-for dis charge of Lizzie Borden JSS It bad been said that Lizzie would ride over from New Bedford in a carriage, and as the hour of coming was uncertain, a crowd of of morbid, curious ones assembled early at tbo Borden homestead to get a glimpse of the woman who, durlug the past ten months has gained such a world wide reputation.
See moreSee less
Meanwhile, at 8 13 p. m., while the crowd was surging about the home
This opinion piece discusses the Fall River police's handling of the Lizzie Borden case, arguing that while their evidence was flawed or unfair and failed to convict her, they likely acted out of duty rather than bad motives. It concludes that suspicion of exclusive opportunity will remain on Borden until the true murderer is identified.
Evening Journal · 21 June 1893 · page 2
Tub presumptive evidence of exclu sive opportunity against Lizzie Borden was very strung. It showed that there was no opportunity for any one else to commit the murders with wbicli she was
The Wilmington Daily Republican · Wilmington, Del.
The jury quickly returned a verdict of not guilty, prompting such emotional outbursts of applause that the sheriff made no attempt to stop them. The report also recounts District Attorney Knowlton's closing argument accusing Lizzie of a calculated double murder driven by hatred of her stepmother, followed by Justice Dewey's charge to the jury on the presumption of innocence.
The Wilmington Daily Republican · 21 June 1893 · page 1
EMOTIONAL SCENES IN COURT.
r • LIZZIE BORDEN. No suggestion could bo made by s in fav of his wife but poor would fan the flames into unquenchable fire. There tpay be that in this case which ■hows that Lizzie Audrew Borden did not plan to kill her father, and I hope so. "But it not Lizzie Andrew Borden who came dowu those moot lier father, but a murderess, transformed from t&e ties of affection to the com sum mate cruelty ever k •n. She came dowu to meet that stern old who loved his Aeuglitur, but who also loved his wife, and above all who would know who had killed his dfe, ami when she Mme down stairs she came to eet Nome »I« lie knew much of the family re * lotions, and she did not dare to let him live.
See moreSee less
When she came down stai her father she ; but it s also the husband of a stepmother, whom she hated. There escape fr tin« erimo but to complete tho bloody work. The second murder planned, but a wioked and fearful issity. And 1 say this to relieve my mind of tho
The Wilmington Daily Republican · Wilmington, Del.
Prosecutor Knowlton concludes his closing argument suggesting Lizzie killed her father to prevent discovery after killing her stepmother. Judge Dewey charges the jury on reasonable doubt and circumstantial evidence, after which the jury deliberates and returns a verdict of not guilty.
The Wilmington Daily Republican · 21 June 1893 · page 1
reasonable judgment. They If satisfied the act l and abetting. The fact that defe did not testify should a breathless silence fell , which of tho twelve Borden'l life in their hands. The jurors filed into their ■r tho e s unbroken u
The Wilmington Daily Republican · Wilmington, Del.
The judge's charge to the jury concluded, and after deliberation the jury returned a verdict of 'not guilty' for Lizzie Borden. The courtroom erupted in cheers and emotion, with her lawyers overcome and spectators waving handkerchiefs, while Borden herself was overwhelmed with relief.
The Wilmington Daily Republican · 21 June 1893 · page 1
»esslon will be opened. Miss Borden's head \ rail in front of her and they hud refused Any red into her willing c: guilty." Mr. Jennings w voice broke
The Wilmington Daily Republican · Wilmington, Del.
The jury has found Lizzie Borden not guilty of murdering her father and stepmother, a verdict the writer says the evidence clearly supported. The report notes this leaves the murders unsolved and predicts public doubt will persist until the actual killer is found.
The Wilmington Daily Republican · 21 June 1893 · page 2
Not Guilty. generally expected Iiizz * 0 ■'« As Borden Iras been declared not guilty ! , c ol lb. murder or her lather quit qtep-, mother by the jury that tried her. No at fault ba found with the verdict of the quality of the evidence at tiie jury, park park Y Y J.
District Attorney Knowlton delivered a scathing closing argument, abandoning his earlier courteous demeanor toward the defendant. He portrayed Lizzie Borden as a frenzied murderess driven by hatred, describing her delicate hands as claw-like and her movements as panther-like stealth.
New-York Tribune · 21 June 1893 · page 2
THE DISTRICT ATTORNEY'S ATTITUDL. Yesterday there hud been a certain timidity in Lis manner and a sort of courtesy in his bearing toward the lady-like prisoner he was trying to send to the zallows. But timidity and courtesy disappeared together from his argument this morning. He pictured the Borden houschold as
This report describes prosecutor Knowlton's harsh characterization of Lizzie Borden during closing arguments, comparing her to a predatory animal and calling her a murderess. It also covers Judge Dewey's charge to the jury, including his dismissal of a financial dispute as a credible motive for the murders.
New-York Tribune · 21 June 1893 · page 2
THE DISTRICT ATTORNEY'S ATTITUDE
| far as the prosecution's evidence was concerne | that was absolutely the only suggestion in it of a condition of ill-feeling between Lizzie Borden and her stepmother. In the cross-examination of Ll'mma Borden, who appearad as a witness Yor the defence, there was an admission that six vears ago both she and Lizzie were irritated at then stepmother concerning u transiction involving £1,500, which her father had given as a prsent to their stepmother's stepsister. But Lmwa had said that Lizzie had not at the time felt deeply about the matter, and soon forgot it altogether.
See moreSee less
Well might Judge Dewey ask the jury to consider whether the remark Mrs Gifford had testified to supplied any motive for such crimes as Lizzie Jorden was charged with. “Look at that re mark,” he said, “in the light of the fact that the person who made it was a young woman, not a philosopher, nor a jurist, who made the agcurate use of words a study.”
At the close of testimony, Chief Justice Mason invited Lizzie Borden to address the jury, and she rose to simply state, "I am innocent. I did not do it. I have committed my case to my counsel, and what they say is true. They have spoken for me." The report also describes Judge Dewey, noted for his resemblance to James Blaine, preparing to deliver his charge to the jury, emphasizing fact over speculation rather than mercy.
New-York Tribune · 21 June 1893 · page 2
JUDGE DEWEY'S KINDLY WORDS.
“ Lizzie Andrew Borden, it is yonr privileze at this time to say to the 1iry in person any word you may desire to add to what has been said already by your counsel” He spoke mildly, and it seemed as if che did not clearly understand that it was she to whom his remarks were directed. She had only just taken her seat when he leaned forward to address her, and had settlad baek in one of ber characteristic attitudes with ler lan against her chin. She started as she heard her name pronounced, and looked first at the judge, then at the deputy sheriff who sat beside her, and in reply to his motion she again fastened her eves on the Court.
See moreSee less
Judge Mason saw the look, first of bewilderment and then of inguiry, and Le added, * Speak now if you will.”
The jury delivers a verdict of not guilty, ending Lizzie Borden's long and sensational trial. The report describes her emotional return to Fall River and casts her as a victim of a conspiracy by vulgar accusers.
New-York Tribune · 21 June 1893 · page 1
TO FALL RIVER. [FROM A STAFF CORRESPONDENT OF THE TRIBUNE.) New-Badford, June 20.—<Lizzie Borden is & woman, She has returned to-night to the free place where her great She is te trial began. know no more of jails and matrons and marshals and special doteetives and sheriils; no more of coroners and police magistrates, and no more of witch-buraning district-attorneys. She has drunk the cup of all that experience to the very dregs, and It 18 not extravagant to say that a bitterep was never placed to human lips. Not guilty!
See moreSee less
Not guilty! Not guilty! It woilld be a pleasure to repeat the words a hune dred times. For ten months this woman, by ine stinst, birth and cultivation a lady, used to all that was gentle and refined; torn from a home that had been otf all things else quiet and come tortable; broken by the shock of a monstrous
This sympathetic account describes Lizzie Borden's triumphant vindication in court after enduring months of what the writer calls lies, manipulation, and public condemnation by police and press. It recounts her arrest on August 6 and the subsequent ordeal, defending her character against the vulgar crowds who judged her without understanding.
New-York Tribune · 21 June 1893 · page 1
CIRCUMSTANCES AGAINST HER
It is not remarkable that Lizzie Borden came into the courtroom that How witnessed hep lias triumphant vindication with the lines of prond despair traced deeply in her face. She had small reason for hope. From that Saturday might, the 6th of August, when, in the room from whieh the murdered bodies of her tather and stepmother had heen only a few hours removed, she received the Mavor of the city of Fall River and his Marshal of Police, and listened to them say: “It is yon, Miss Borden, who are under suspleion—"from that moment until the day sho was first brought inte this conrtroom her experience with the lnw—the law that presumed all wen innocent until they are proved guilty, the law that throws a shield around those who ive it their trae alleziance— worded, was a long chapter of unrelieved Liorrors, hunted, deliberately lied about, made to say ine criminating words had never thonght, pice she tured in incriminating scenes that existed only in the vindietive inmcination of ber jailers, she had small reason to think that the last chapter of hoe | a!
See moreSee less
would not what who had etions he those ¥ brought her to it weant it should be, the record of her doom.
This is a news summary column listing the day's top stories, including a brief item stating that Lizzie Borden was acquitted at New Bedford of murdering her father and stepmother. The rest of the passage covers unrelated foreign and domestic news items.
New-York Tribune · 21 June 1893 · page 6
THE NEWS THIS MORNING. Foreign.—I'he president of the Behring Sea Tribunal sharply rebuked Sir Richard Webster, of counpel for Great Britain, =——— There were reports of a revolutionary outbreak in Barcelona, === The Liberal convention in Ottawa was begun, == Jeavy storms were reported from Paris, Berlin and Lisbon. Domestic.—lizzie Borden was acquitted at New-
The New Bedford jury acquitted Lizzie Borden after deliberation, despite a strong closing argument from the prosecution. The editorial argues the verdict was just, as the State failed to connect her to the murders or establish a credible motive.
New-York Tribune · 21 June 1893 · page 6
France and America. ACQUITTAL or LIZZIE BORDEN. The New-Liedford jury have done what they could to restore Lizzie Borden to her rightful place in a world of hope and happiness. They
This editorial argues that the verdict acquitting Lizzie Borden was correct, since the prosecution failed to connect her to the murders or establish a credible motive, relying only on flimsy circumstantial evidence. It warns that a conviction based on such weak proof would have set a dangerous legal precedent, while acknowledging that suspicion will likely follow her for life despite her legal innocence.
New-York Tribune · 21 June 1893 · page 6
ACQUITTAL OF LIZZIE BORDEN.
We have no hesitation in pronouncing this a righteous verdict. Mysterious as were the murders in the Borden house, the State failed absolutely in connecting her with them, or in supplying any intelligible motive for them, A succassfal application of the theory of exclusive opportunity to a case in which direct proof was lacking, and in which the circumstantial evidence was of the flimsiest nature, would have given a wrong and dangerous trend to criminal practice. Tt would have done violence to the best traditions of the science of law and have stimulated loose thinking and pernicious activ.
See moreSee less
ity among police officials and public prosecutors. The verdict in the Borden case empha- <izos the fact that guilt must be proved, and not lightly assumed because there is only one person suspected and the police have no othar theory. The security of human lifo would not have been promoted by a conviction of Lizzie Borden upon such evidence as was brought into court. Such a conviction would have been a most vicious precedent for stupid, overzealous police officers and heartless prosecutors. The judgment of the Borden jury will bo in-
Following her acquittal, Lizzie Borden was driven to a banker's home in Fall River for a celebratory reception with family and supporters. Witnesses described her as joyful and animated, showing no signs of the ordeal she had just endured, while Governor Robinson commented that the verdict was unsurprising given the lack of proven evidence.
Evening Star · 21 June 1893 · page 6
LIZZIE BORDEN A NEW WOMAN
was whizzing down the street toward Fal River. In it were Mr. C. J. Holumes. his daugh ter, Miss Anna C. Holmes, and Mismes Lizi and Emma Borden. They drove to the cozy little house of tb well-known banker on Pins street in this city who had been oae of the most emphatic he liovers in the prisase' innoae-c*. The rid by carriage occupied an hour. A reception In honor of the return of thm once accused but now vindicated young woa ws held. A call at the house ,was made during th evening sod Liii expreesed herself as lb happiest woman in the world.
See moreSee less
She was dresea in the black silk and black nst she has worn a the trial, reclined easily in a chair and was evi deutly telling some kind of a story when fir. s1eeun. Her right hand wan uplifted, andeasth point of the narrative was reahed everybod; laughed. Dr. Bowen came in a few momsenta later, an then the whols party passed io the dinint room for refresumenuta. As Miss Borden passe through the beflway she was laughinig gail with the rest of the party, an there was no trace of whet she ha just pained through, no indication I her sprightly movement that told of worry an Iphysical collapse. Her eyes sprldwith asi pmetion, her face lighted up wit the pleasure the occasion, and an she disappeared Into lt dining room she remarked to nomebody: "Wetl you ought to let me do just as I please." Nt ens who had eeen Lizze Borden just before th jury came in would have recognized her. The result of the trial gave universal satisfac tion in Boeton. Gov. Robinnonsaid: "I am ne surprised. No other verdict could have bee rendered by the jury on evidence not prover I think that it isalso in accord with the publi opinion. No matter what the muspicione me have been. if not proven In law, of coorne the do not hold." There ia probably less rejoicing among II rank and lse in this city of Fall River abot the acquittal than In any other place In th country. Here the distinctions of race,e social positioc, of religion, have placed a nume; ical majority against Lizzie Borden. Yet bert tou, are her very atrongest friends. Her fir
The report describes Lizzie Borden's cheerful, relieved demeanor just after the jury's not-guilty verdict, contrasting it with her earlier distress during the trial. It also covers public reaction in Boston and Fall River, including Governor Robinson's comments and a crowd gathering near her home, which dispersed without seeing her.
The jury deliberated briefly before returning a verdict acquitting Lizzie Borden of murdering her parents. The courtroom was tense and silent as the verdict was announced at 4:36 PM, with Borden struggling to conceal her nervousness.
Evening Star · 21 June 1893 · page 7
ACQUITTAL OF LIZZIE BORDEN
CeOsonAuATAS TJE ACC9VE -TAKNN BACK TO ALL 31,3n. As anneunced ins a psteript edition of TR, STAR yesterday afternoon, L=i=zi Borden was acquitted at 4M o'eloek of the murder of her parents, with which she had been charged. Dinsgresmsmt had been the expectation of almost every one, and very few expected even that before today. At its very close the do fhme developed a surprising weakness and the governmnent developed a surprising strength. This rather ansettled the understanding of the Smost scus. After the jury went out at 3:15
The jury returns after deliberation and foreman Richards announces a verdict of "not guilty," prompting cheers from the packed courtroom. Lizzie Borden faints from the strain and is revived by Dr. Bowen before regaining partial consciousness.
Evening Star · 21 June 1893 · page 7
WAITING FOR THE VERDICT
quiet reigned. "oT OurL.Tr." Slowly the jurors filed to their box and re sumed the seats they had vacated when retiring. Then Clerk Borden broke the silence with the 1oll of the jury. folowed by the customary question: "Mr. Foreman and gentlemntn of the jury. have yon agree.t upon a verdict?" Calmly and clearly csme the reply from Foreman Richards: "We have." Then followed a few seconds of shrful *ue ese, while the assemblage leaned forward and listened to the next question. "Gentlemen of the jur., now what say you, is the prisoner guilty or not gnilty?" "Not guilty!" Foreman Richrds had spoken: the decision of twelve good men and true had been made. LIZzIE BOUDEN FAINT.
The jury's foreman delivered a not guilty verdict, and Lizzie Borden fainted from exhaustion as the courtroom and waiting crowds erupted in celebration. After being revived by Dr. Bowen, she was declared free by the judges and traveled home to Fall River accompanied by family and clergy.
Evening Star · 21 June 1893 · page 7
been made. LIZzIE BOUDEN FAINT. The pen Is almost powerless to describe the scene which followed. For sixty seconds there was not a sound. Then the crowd or a theusand men and women broke into a cry of joy aint approval that rang far outside and told the waiting thousands about the court honse that Lizzie Borden was a free woman. Lizzie had stood while the foreman spoke. When he had finished she started. stepped for ward. put out her arms as it she would throw them about the neck of Mr.
See moreSee less
Richards. and then saunk to the door an Inanimate mass of over strung. eihauated humanity. swPr 1n TUE ROOM. The bombastic sheriff made no attempt to restrain the shouts and hurrahs of the crowds: the reporters vanished from sight; only the three dignified judges were calm. The multitude ewept from the room In s minnte and there were left only the judges. the jury. the lawyers, Lizzie Borden. her sistet Emma end uce, John V. Mforse. Dr. Bowot was there and he at once applied restorativee ic the unconscious woman. In ten minutes she was conscious. but apparently oblivious to any of her surroundings. Ibi, condition continued half an hour, dunring which the three judgee patiently sat in their places and waited. Then Dr. Bowen said the prisoner was cape. ble of taking pert in the formalIties neessary. The judges nodded briefly and in three amin nice Miss Borden was free. Then Chief Jut tiee Mason stePred down from the bench, and, reaching out both his hands toward Lizzie Bor den. he grasped her righit hand and said: "Mist Borden, your trial was a fair oneryour aceiutta a just verdict. Let me congratulate you.' cnvins 1o3 MIas nonna.. in ten minutes it seemed every man, womau -and child in New Bedford knew that Miss Bor den had been found not guilty, and a littli later, when her carriage was driving to the rail road statione though the curtains were drawn it was known that rhe wam e:'ide. and the wild est enthusisam greeted her all along the way Six months ago people believed her guilty; to dav they know she is not, because a jury ha said so umpon the hoot evidence the state ooulu produce.
The jury deliberated only about an hour before finding Lizzie Borden not guilty, and the remaining charges were dropped by the district attorney. The report also recounts the prosecutor's closing argument asserting her guilt and theorizing about family tensions as motive.
The Morning News · 21 June 1893 · page 1
Reaching a Verdict The Other Cases Against the Accused Nolle Pressed on Motion of the Dta trlct Attorney—The Latter’s Speech to the Jury a Strong Argument As serting the Guilt of the Accused. Now Bedford, Mass.,June 20—There wag not so great a Jam outside the Court House this morning, although at the opening of court there was us many people in the room as at any time during the Borden trial. Miss Borden entered the room at 8.5S o’clock tho Court came in at 9 and the dig* triet Attorney continued his argument.
See moreSee less
The district attorney again recurred to his theory of tho motive for the murder as shown in the rotations between Li/.zia Borden and her stepmother, from which lie said, “Wo can suspect even the malico existing. I have called your atten tion to the way in whichthey lived under tho same roof. Ths malico was all before the fact. Tho wickedness, the ingratitude, had gone on under that roof for many, muny We don’t know but that some new phaso had i-omo up in tho family life. There may ho that in this case which shows that Lizzie Andrew Borden did not pluu to kill tier fattier and I hope so. But it was not Lizzie Andrew Borden who came down those stairs to meet her father, but a murdross, transformed frong the tics of affection to the most consum mate cruelty ever known. Bhe came down to meet that stern old. man who loved his daughter, but who also loved his wifo, aud the one man who would know who killed his wife. Ho knew too much of tho family relations and she did not dare to let him live. Thero was no escape from tho crime but to com-, pi etc tho bloody work. The second mur der was not, planned hut wns done as a wicked and fearful necessity.” “Mr. Kuowlton then analyzed tlie testi mony as to what went on in the Borden house during the Riiort tlmo between An drew Borden’s arrival at home and Liz zie's announcement of the murder. Tho Story of Lizzie ironiug clothes he discred ited, and her visit to the barn alibi, ho suid, would not stund. Officer Medley's story which wont to show that nobody had been in the barn Mr. Kuowlton hold to bo correct. He declared that the sillt dress produced by the defondaut was not the dress worn at the time of the murder, as shown by Mrs. Churchill, Doherty and Dr. Bowen. Ths search the day of the murder was Insufficient, but put the de feudaut ou her guard, and Saturday’s thorough search failed to disclose tha dress, therefore he claimed it was con cealed. Mr. Knowtton reviewed tho evidence as to tlie handloss hatchet, dealing on the stgulflanoo of its fitting tho wounds, and
Prosecutor Knowlton delivers closing argument accusing Lizzie Borden of murdering her father to prevent him learning she killed her stepmother, dismissing her alibi evidence. The jury deliberates briefly and returns a verdict of not guilty, after which remaining charges against her are dropped.
The jury returns a verdict of not guilty for Lizzie Borden, prompting a loud cheer in the courtroom and tears from Borden, her attorneys, and even the sheriff. She is later taken to a private room to recover before departing by train for Fall River.
The Morning News · 21 June 1893 · page 1
RECEIVED WITH A CHEER
Telegraph from Irwintou, Wilkinson county, says that on Sunday afternoon a young lady, daughter of a farmer in that section, was decoyed from her home by a negro and taken away into a dense swamp and there held captive till this afternoon, when a searching party found her more dead than alive and suffering from brutal treatment at the hands of tlie negro. It is supposed that other negroes were con cerned in the outrage. A posse of citi zens is hot on the trail and if captured tho negro will be lynched.
See moreSee less
cation. When the verdict of “not guilty” was returned, a cheer went up which might! havo been heard half a mile away, antjj there was no attempt to check it. Tho; statoly judges looked straight ahead* at tho bare walls. Sheriff Wright was powerless to weilij the gavel which lies ready for his use, and not onco during tho tremendous ex citement, which lasted fully a minute,' did he make tlie slightest sign of having heard it. He never saw the people rising: in their seats and waving theij handker chiefs in unison with their voices, bo-j cause his eyes were full of tears and were: completely blinded for tho timo.i Miss Borden’s head went down; upon tho rail in front of her and tears came where they had refused to come toe
The piece argues the jury's not-guilty verdict was justified given the evidence presented by the prosecution, even though the murder mystery remains unsolved. It notes the jury's task was only to determine Lizzie Borden's guilt, not identify the true killer, and claims public opinion had already reached the same conclusion.
The Morning News · 21 June 1893 · page 4
The verdict in the Lizzie Borden case was precisely what the evidence presented by the prosecution warranted. No other verdict, according to the evidence, could have been returned. The mystery of the murder is now, indeed, greater than ever before. But the jury’s business was not to say who committed the murder. What it had to do, and had only to do, was to say whether Lizzie Borden is or is not the
The Cheyenne Daily Leader · Cheyenne, Wyo. · and 1 other paper
After the judge's charge, the jury deliberated briefly and returned a verdict of not guilty, prompting cheers in the courtroom. Lizzie Borden wept with relief, her counsel reacted emotionally, and she was later taken by carriage to the train station bound for Fall River.
The Cheyenne Daily Leader · 21 June 1893 · page 1
JURY OUT ONLY A LITTLE WHILE.
his kindly eye. He stood up as Mr. Knowlton and Mr. Moody came over to shake hands with the counsel for the defense. As soon as possible the room was cleared, although it was a hard task, since everybody wanted to shake hands with Miss Borden. When the spectators had finally gone she was taken to the room of the jus tices and allowed to recover her com posure, with only the eyes of friends upon her and the caresses of devoted admirers. At the expiration of an hour she was placed in a carriage and driven to the station, where she took the train for Fall River, her home no longer probably, but still the only objective point she now has.
The Oskaloosa Herald · Oskaloosa, Iowa · 29 June 1893
The Indiana State Sentinel · Indianapolis
Governor Robinson delivered a four-hour closing argument for the defense that reportedly fell short of expectations, after which prosecutor Knowlton began his speech for the state. The courtroom was packed with spectators, mostly women, scrambling for seats to witness the proceedings.
The Indiana State Sentinel · 21 June 1893 · page 1
GIVEN TO THE JURY
Ntw P,eifokp, Mas., JuDe 10. The day of tho nramenfs in the Borden case brought cut a terriue jam at the court house, and over an Lour before the time
A defense speaker at trial dissects the prosecution's theories, questioning assumptions about the open door, the mysterious note Mrs. Borden received, and Lizzie's account of her barn visit. He suggests Bridget's testimony may be the true source of details attributed to Lizzie, and casts doubt on the prosecution's narrative of the note's burning.
The Indiana State Sentinel · 21 June 1893 · page 1
Horden had gone up-staira that morning and looked under the bed ahe might have seen the body of her step-mother. There is no evidence to show that the door of that room was wide open. The prosecution as sumes that the door was wide open. The door may have been only ajar. It may have been closed. Miss Lizzie bad no occasion to go into that room. She would not be likely to do so judging from the evidence introduced as to the family relations. It is true that she went up stairs and saw her stepmother making the bed in the spare room.
See moreSee less
It makes no Uilisrei.es how many times she went up and down stairs that day. Grant that she did go up stairs at about U o'clock, Mrs. Borden was alive then. They say she stayed up there without oSeriug any evidence on that poiat. There is the note. Bridget says shs caw the stepmother gat a note from some one who was sick, and that she bad gone out. Bridget says "the did not tell me where she was going; she generally does. She hurried oQ." Lizzie did not say anything about her hurrying oft. Now, both Lizzie and Bridget tell about the note and both were told of it by Mrs. Borden. Bridget said Mrs. Borden was dusting the sitting-room just before she went away. The dia tnet attorney says Lizzie lied about the note. Now, Bridget tells the most complete story about the note. The speaker drew the infer ence that it was Bridget who told Lizzie about the note. He contended that the burning of the note was the suggestion of Miss Bussed and not a statement made by Lizzie. A person may say "where is the note?" we cannot hnd it. The note may be part of the scheme of Mrs. Borden. There are people around here nuw
The report covers ex-Governor Robinson's closing argument for the defense, addressing witness testimony about a mysterious woman seen in the yard and Bridget's actions after discovering Mr. Borden's death. Robinson also challenges the prosecution's characterization of Lizzie's demeanor and alleged motive, arguing the household details and her relationship with her stepmother don't prove guilt.
The Indiana State Sentinel · 21 June 1893 · page 1
Ilobtnson n Disappointment. The summing up of ex-Governor Rob inson, so far as it had gone, was dUcussed freely. Much disappointment was ex pressed about it. The governor's effort had not been eo great as had been ex pected of him. The lawyers eaid the facts in the case had not been handled as they bad been led to believe they would. Bridget, the ex-governor said, after reotss, when she heard Mr. Borden was dead, said she would go to Mrs. Whitsheads and tell Mrs. Borden if she was there. That was corrobo rated on the story of the note If you presume that the deteudaut is guilty, the suggestion of the prosequi on would be that Miss Borden told Mrs.
See moreSee less
Churchill and Bridget to go up stairs by the front way and find Mrs. Borden. She t.iouglit Mrs. Borden had come in. l'erhaps it
At the Borden trial, Dr. Dolan was cross-examined about the wounds, blood spatter, and timing of the deaths, revising his earlier inquest testimony on the sequence of death. Defense witnesses testified to seeing a stranger near the Borden house and a man asleep on the step the night of the murders, while the defense outlined what it intended to prove.
The Indiana State Sentinel · 21 June 1893 · page 6
THE BORDEN TRIAL. Lawyer Jennings' Statement to the Jury. Outlining What His Side Expects to Prove. FLOWERS FOR DEFENDANT. Witnesses Testify to Having Seen a Stranger About the Borden House the Day of the Murder. The Fact Sworn to by Another Witness That a Character Was Found Asleep on the Step of the Defendant's Home at 11 O'Clock at Night. Another Hatchet Discovery.
Another Hatchet Discovery. New Bedford, Mass., Juns 13. Again today people crowded the court room where Lizzie Borden la being tried for murder. Mr. Adams continued the cross examination of Dr. Do an, who described the position of the bodies and the blood spots, and eaid they came from left to right and were of moderate force. The prisoner sat with closed eyes and a fan over her face. Continuing, Dr. Dolan said ths blows were made by a sharp in strument and an assailant astride the body. A juryman was taken sick and a recess was taken.
See moreSee less
The prisoner was af fected by the gruesome exhibits and the details and was led from the room. The session being resumed. Dr. Dolan admit ted testifying in the preliminary hearing that Mrs. Borden's death was an hour to an hour and a half before his examina tion of bar, but he now thought it was an hour to an hour and a half before Mr. Borden's death. He could not safely
Prof. Wood and Dr. Draper gave detailed testimony about the stomach contents, wounds, and absence of blood on most weapons except a small human blood spot on the white skirt. Dr. Cheever dramatically demonstrated how the fatal blow could have been struck, while Lizzie Borden left the courtroom during the medical testimony.
The Indiana State Sentinel · 21 June 1893 · page 6
Borden. The prisoner left the court room. not wishing to hear tbs medical testimony or see ths skulls, which were produced by j the government. Dr. Draper described j the wounds and condition ot the stomach and blood to determine the priority of death. At the conclusion of Dr. Draper's exam ination Dr. Cheevar. surzical exDert. waa ..it. J II. J .1... t Ji.l I isiivu, jib it-oiiuuu .uaii iu, uauuieieBH hatchet could make all the blows on the bodies, that one blow on Mrs. Borden was made by a person facing her.
See moreSee less
and on cross examination, that the blood would nat uraily fall on the assailant. There was a striking and dramatic il lustration s little later, when Mr. Adams asked him to illustrate just how the blow would have to be struck in order to pro duce the cut found in the skull of Mr. Bor den. Mr. Adams stood before the wit ness, who is tail, spare aud very deliberate in all his movements. A new hatchet was held aloft for a second, inclined to the left and then flashed through the air, straight, as it seemed, for ths skull of Mr. Adams. It seemed aa if the crash of bone must be heard, the hatchet stopped and remained steady. The spectators gasped. A few minutes later the court adjourned.
Testimony describes Mayor Coughlin and Marshal Hilliard informing Lizzie Borden she was suspected, with Lizzie and Emma responding; Lizzie claimed she was in the barn for twenty minutes during the murders. A dressmaker also testified about Lizzie's hostile remarks toward her stepmother Abby Borden.
The Indiana State Sentinel · 21 June 1893 · page 6
City Marshal Hiiliard, cross-examined, swore that the search of the Borden house was thorough snd that the defendant gave him all articles hs asked for and spoke earnestly and franxly in conversa tion about the suspicion of herelf. Mayor John W. Coughlin of Fall River was next called. He described his visit to the Borden house with Marshal Hiil iard. and corroborated the marshal's testi mony as to the conversation with the de fendant. The court excluded the evidence as to the demonstration against Mr. Morse oli'ered by government to show that tho police later surrounded the houee in good faith for protection, not for surveillance,
The Borden trial resumed with lighter attendance, and the court ruled inadmissible testimony from a Portuguese witness who claimed to have seen a man with a bloody hatchet. Witness Sarah Hart testified to seeing an unfamiliar young man standing at the Borden gate around 9:50 a.m. on the day of the murders.
The Indiana State Sentinel · 21 June 1893 · page 7
rast belnjt removed, a nllghl colorinz of the silt was disclosed, which would either indicate that tne hatchet was at one time used as an ornment or was quite new when loet or discarded. New Bedford. Maes., Jane 10. There was lees of a crowd at the court house this morning at the resumption of the Borden trial than there has beeu at any
Reporters testify at the Borden trial about Fall River Police Matron Reagan's disputed account of a jailhouse exchange between Lizzie and Emma Borden, with Reagan denying any quarrel occurred. Other witnesses describe the chaotic scene at the Borden house after the murders, including Lizzie being tended to in the kitchen and a failed search of the barn.
The Indiana State Sentinel · 21 June 1893 · page 7
By th's witness it was proven that many people were swarming about the Borden lionsand in the barn where Lizzie is said to have been (hiring the murder, but where OiKcer MoKelley afterwards subse quently went, but could find no trace of Miss Borden or any one else. John J. Manning, reporter. Fall Kiver He first beard of the Borden murder eoiL.e time before 1 1 and examined the bouse and premises, finding the cellar door closed. Saul the witness: "1 remember the puh'icntion of Police Matron Began's story of the 'give away' interview between the Bisters and 1 had an interview with her. 1 think it was the same night of the ublication. In answer to question
Reporters and others testify at the preliminary hearing about a published story alleging a quarrel between Lizzie and Emma Borden, which Mrs. Reagan denied and later had printed as a retraction. Witnesses describe her statements that the story was false and her willingness to sign a denial with the marshal's approval.
The Indiana State Sentinel · 21 June 1893 · page 7
A Kf itortrr'a Story. Thomas F. Ilickey, another reporter of Fall Kiver, next testified. "In my ca pacity as reporter I saw Mrs. Keagau on Friday about tho etory referred to above. 1 eaid, I tee you're getting yourself in the paper, Mrs. Beagan.' She eaid : 'Yes. tat they have got to take tuet all back.' I aekfl her about thn alleged quarrel be tween Lizzie and Froma anl she paid there bad been no quarrel. I asked her If ehe bad repeated any words of the sis ters. Aftked ber if there waa any truth in the report and ehe eaid absolutely none.',' Mrs.
See moreSee less
Mary IL Holmes. Fall Liver, wife oi Charles J. Holme "I know Mis Bor den and have known who she was from childhood. vhe is a member of the church I attend. I first heard cf the Borden murder at 11:4". I went to the house about 1 and sat down in the kitchen, come oce told me soon after that Lizzie would like to sea me. I remained in the honse with Lizzie until K:;M p. m. I remember the publication of Mrs. Beagan's quar rel story. After it was published I had a talk with Mrs. Beagan about it. She spoke to me about it. she said: 'Mrs. Holmes you know it is not to, for that was the time we were talking about the egs.' Subsequently I beard Mrs. Beagan say that she would eigne certain paper if Marshal liilliard were willing. At this time I was in the ma tron's room, and Fbe made no statement as she returned after having talked with some men who called."
The jury in New Bedford quickly returned a verdict of not guilty, prompting cheers from the crowded courtroom. Lizzie Borden was overcome with emotion upon hearing the verdict, and the report notes the murder mystery remains unsolved.
The Indianapolis Journal · 21 June 1893 · page 1
LIZZIE BORDEN NOT GUILTY
NOT GUILTV." Then the silence was broken. All the dignity and decorum of the court room van ished. A cheer went up which might have been heard half a mile away through the open windows, and there was no attempt to check it. The stately justices looked straight ahead at the bare walls during tho tremendous excitement, which lasted fully a minute. Miss Borden's head went down upon the rail in front of her and tears came where they had refused to come for. many a long day as she heard the sweetest words over pourod into her willing ears.
See moreSee less
Mr. Jennings was almost crying and his voice broke as he put his hand out to Mr. Adams, who sat next to him and said, "Thank God," while Mr. Adams returned the pressure of the hand and seemed incapable of speech. Ex-Governor Kobinson turned to the rapidly dissolving jury as they filed out of their seats and gleamed on them with a fatherly interest in his kindly eye. He stood up as Mr. Knowlton and Mr. Moody came over to shake hands with the counsel for the de fense. As soon as possible the room was cleared, although it was a hard task, since everybody wanted to shake hands with Miss Borden. When the spectators had finally gone she was taken to the justices' room and allowed to recover her composure with only the eyes of friends upon her. At the expiration of an hour she was placed in a carriage and driven to the station, where she took the train for Fall River, her home zt l?u;er. probably, but utill the only ob jective point for the immediate present
The courtroom breaks into cheers as Lizzie Borden is found not guilty, with her attorneys visibly moved with emotion. The report also recounts District Attorney Knowlton's closing argument from the trial, addressing the question of motive.
Knowlton argues that while motive need not be fully understood, the household's long-simmering malice and ingratitude explain the crime. He reconstructs Andrew Borden's return home and Lizzie's false statement about her stepmother's whereabouts, arguing she killed her father to prevent him from learning she had killed his wife.
The Indianapolis Journal · 21 June 1893 · page 1
KNOWLTON'S ARGUMENT.
The words of this article could not be separated from the rest of its page. Read it in the clipping.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
The Indianapolis Journal · Indianapolis, Ind.
A newspaper opinion piece argues that Lizzie Borden calling her stepmother 'a mean, hateful thing' should not be treated as proof of murder. It jokes that such a standard would make many stepchildren nervous.
The Indianapolis Journal · 21 June 1893 · page 2
So It Would. itw York Moruiog Advertiser It is to be boped that Massachusetts will not deem Lizzie Borden's characterization of her stepmother m 'a mean, hateful thing'' conelusive evidence that the girl is a murderer. Such a precedent would mako a great many stepchildren everywhere Very uncomfortable.
This editorial discusses the jury's quick acquittal of Lizzie Borden, arguing the prosecution failed to prove guilt beyond reasonable doubt despite deepening the mystery. It criticizes the police and prosecutor for apparently delaying trial to bolster a weak case, and suggests Borden deserves legal compensation for her ordeal, while noting the murders remain unsolved.
The Indianapolis Journal · 21 June 1893 · page 4
throws no light on tho mystery of the double murder,- but justice requires that she should be regarded as innocent. As an innocent person she has suffered an outrage in being con fined in jail nearly a year without op portunity for trial. Tho conduct of tho marshal, police and prosecutor led the public to believe that they had unques tionable proof of her guilt, but the flimsy evidence brought out in court at last indicated, rather, that the delay had been for the purpose' of bolstering up a weak case.
See moreSee less
Mies Borden will prob ably not wish to have anything nioro to do with courts, but there should certainly bo some legal compensation ob tainable for the injury done her. It is said that the police, after adopting tho theory that she committed tho deed, neglected all other clews, and the length of time that has elapsed provents taking them up sgain. The question still re mains: Who committed the murders?
This editorial commends the Lizzie Borden trial as a model of judicial conduct, noting the dignified courtroom atmosphere despite its plain, old-fashioned setting. It praises the judges, sheriff, and opposing lawyers for their mutual courtesy, lack of wrangling, and minimal technical objections during proceedings.
The Indianapolis Journal · 21 June 1893 · page 4
1 LESSON OF THE LIZZIE BORDEN TBIAL. Aside from the intense interest excited, by the Lizzie Borden trial on account of the sensational features surrounding
The report states that the trial against Lizzie Borden, accused of murdering her parents, concluded in New Bedford, Mass. Witness testimony and circumstantial evidence showed her innocence, and the jury's verdict reflected this, prompting an enthusiastic, sympathetic response from the public.
Dziennik Chicagoski · 21 June 1893 · page 1
Zakończenie procesu Borden.
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
The trial of Lizzie Borden concluded with a jury verdict of not guilty, delivered after an hour and a half of deliberation. The courtroom erupted in cheers as Borden, who had remained composed throughout the trial, was declared a free woman.
Rock Island Daily Argus · 21 June 1893 · page 4
The Verdict of the Jury. It wasat 3 p. m. that the jurors retired to their room to deliberate on their decision. At 4:) they filed into the room and the si lence was intense. The jury was polled. Miss Borden wasusked to stand up, and the foreman was asked to state the verdict, up on which he announced: "Not guilty." After the verdict had been r'-ceived the district attorney moved that the other cases against Miss Borden !e nolle prossed, and the order of the court was to that effect.
See moreSee less
The closing scenes of t),e trial were in di elirett contrast with 'hose that had pre ceded Theretofore all had Seen de corous and in keeping with the dignity of the most iigiliel court in the state. But whea t::r verdict ot not guilty was re turned a e-ln -er went up which might hav been heard half mil? away through t open windows, and there was no attemj i to check it The stately judge looked straight alu:i! at the bare walls. SlieritT Wright was powerless tf wield the gave: which lies reedy for his use. and not once during the Tremendous excitement which lasted fully minute did he make the slightest sign of having heard it
The jury foreman announces a verdict of not guilty, prompting cheers in the courtroom and emotional reactions from Lizzie Borden and her defense team. The report closes by noting the murder remains an unsolved mystery, with no alternative suspect identified.
Following her acquittal, Lizzie Borden is taken from the courtroom to recover before departing by train for Fall River. The report then reviews the unsolved case, recounting Lizzie's own account of her movements the morning her father and stepmother were killed, noting no witnesses existed besides the murderer.
Rock Island Daily Argus · 21 June 1893 · page 4
AN UN.cOLVABL MYSTERY. That Is Vh:- the Itorden Murder Look Like Now If Iizzie Borden did not murder her father and stepmother who did? That tn the question -sked by the prosecution dur ing the trial and it was on the theory that there was no one else to suspect that the prosecution largely arrested, ana that is the question still unanswered. On the 4th day of August, 1892, between the hours of 9:30 and 11:30 a. m. Andrew Jackson Borden and Abby Durfee Borden were murdered at their home in Fall Rive.
See moreSee less
This is all that is known. For legally, and, many believe, morally, Lizzie Borden is guiltless. Lizzie A. Borden, daughter of Andrew Jackson Borden, a woman now about 33 years old; her stepmother, Abby Durfee Borden, and Bridget Sullivan, a sen-ant, were the only memlwrs of the family about the house. When Mr. Borden came home at about 10:45 that morning Bridget left him at the frontdoor and in a few mo ments went to her room up-statrs. She had Ixcen encaged a good part of the morn ing ont of doors washing windows. There was absolutely no witness to the murders except the murderer. Lizzie Borden's own account of the acts
Abendblatt Der Illinois Staats-Zeitung · Chicago, Ill.
The report states that the trial of Lizzie Borden, accused of murder, concluded in New Bedford, Massachusetts. After deliberating for about ninety minutes, the jury returned a verdict of not guilty at 4:35 PM.
Abendblatt Der Illinois Staats-Zeitung · 21 June 1893 · page 1
Lizzie Borden keine Mörderin, So lautet der Wahrspruch der Geschworenen.
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
Abendblatt Der Illinois Staats-Zeitung · Chicago, Ill.
The Illinois Staats-Zeitung reports that the sensational Borden murder trial in New Bedford has ended with Lizzie Borden's acquittal on charges of murdering her father and stepmother. The paper calls the prosecution's case flimsy and criticizes District Attorney Knowlton for insulting the defendant even as his case collapsed.
Abendblatt Der Illinois Staats-Zeitung · 21 June 1893 · page 2
Per Nummer 1 Cent. Per Woche 6 Cents. Die Freisprechung -er Lizzie Borden. Der sensationelle Mordprozeß Borden, welcher sich in den letzten Wochen vor dem Kriminalgericht in New Bedford, Mass., abspiclte, hat mit der Freisprechung der Lizzie Borden, welche des Mordes an ihrem
Abendblatt Der Illinois Staats-Zeitung · Chicago, Ill.
The report announces Lizzie Borden's acquittal, calling it a just verdict that cannot compensate for the suffering she endured from baseless suspicion. It harshly criticizes District Attorney Knowlton as foolish and brutal, and mocks the fickle public opinion that condemned her before trial and cheered her after.
Abendblatt Der Illinois Staats-Zeitung · 21 June 1893 · page 2
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
The report describes the final day of the Borden trial, including District Attorney Knowlton's closing argument accusing Lizzie of hiding a blood-stained dress and using a hatchet with a broken handle. It concludes with Lizzie's acquittal, courtroom celebration, and her return home to Fall River.
The Wichita Daily Eagle · 21 June 1893 · page 2
LIZZIE BORDEN ACQUITTED. IS'EW Bedford, Mass., June 20. There was less of a jam outside the court house 'this morning when the Borden case was called, but the court room held 1 ally as jimmy people as on any previous day, when 'District Attorney Kuowlton rammed his argument. Lizzie Borden occupied a seat beside her attorney, Governor Robinson, fnnd conversed with him in an apparently icheerful manner. Mr. Kuowlton argued that tho silk dress .produced by the defense was not tho dress worn at the time of tho murder. The po 'lice .search of the house the first day was liuMifticient. but it put Lizzie Borden on l&uard, and when further seaich was made
Prosecutor Knowlton concludes his closing argument, Lizzie Borden briefly addresses the court proclaiming innocence, and Justice Dewey charges the jury. The jury deliberates and returns a not guilty verdict, prompting a massive cheer in the courtroom before Borden departs for Fall River.
The Wichita Daily Eagle · 21 June 1893 · page 2
LIZZIE BORDEN ACQUITTED.
ii movement indicating its return, A 3nomeut later the twelve men tiled into i heir seats and Were polled. Mi&s Borden "was asked to stand up and the foieman "was aslud to return the verdict, which he announced "Not guilty."
Defense attorney ex-Governor Robinson argues the evidence is insufficient and that the brutal crime must have been committed by a strong, determined person, not a weak woman like Lizzie Borden, suggesting an outside intruder. District Attorney Knowlton counters that Lizzie must have known who committed the murders even if she didn't do them herself, since her father and 200-pound stepmother could not have been killed without her noticing while she was in the house.
Der Deutsche Correspondent · 21 June 1893 · page 1
Lizzie Borden's Prozeß
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
District Attorney Knowlton concludes his argument, theorizing Lizzie killed her stepmother in a rage then killed her father to avoid exposure, though he stops short of claiming premeditation. Judge Dewey then instructs the jury on degrees of murder and the presumption of innocence before deliberations, with the headline already announcing her acquittal.
Der Deutsche Correspondent · 21 June 1893 · page 5
Lizzie Borden freigesprochen.
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
The jury deliberated for just over an hour before returning a verdict of 'not guilty' for Lizzie Borden. The courtroom erupted in cheers, and Lizzie wept for the first time in a long while before departing for Fall River with friends.
Der Deutsche Correspondent · 21 June 1893 · page 5
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
The jury in the Lizzie Borden murder trial returned a verdict of not guilty after deliberating only one hour. The report also describes the final morning of trial, including closing arguments, Lizzie's brief statement of innocence, and Judge Dewey's charge to the jury.
Daily Kennebec Journal · 21 June 1893 · page 1
NOT GUILTY!
* It Jury—Tlw Vardict. New Bei»eomi>, Maas., June 20.—The court room was packed thia morning at the resumption of the Borden case. Miss Borden come into court at A.53 and Mr. Kobituon took hia scat beside her and the two engaged in cooveraation until court opened. Immediately upon the opening of the court District Attorney Kuowiton resumed iiis argument, speaking at length ami reviewing the evidence carefully aud thoroughly. At the close a recess was taken. Court reconvened at 1.4.*>. every seat be ing occupied. The chief justice told Miss Borden that she could say to the jury what •he chose.
See moreSee less
She arose, somewhat agitated, and said : "I am innocent, but 1 will leave my case in your hands and in the hands of my counsel." Judge Dewey charged the jury. He cautioned them to make a de ision only upon the law and evidence given, not to be influenced by anything in the prk>r pro ceedings; that no action of the prisoner since arrest can betaken into consideration. Character add previous life, of the defend ant must always bo taken into considera tion. Taking all the facts into consideration, is it a fact there was any motive for Lizzie Borden to make way with her parents: There must be no magnifying or belittling
The judge's charge concluded, exhibits were formally entered, and the jury deliberated before returning a verdict of not guilty. The courtroom erupted in cheers, Lizzie Borden wept with relief, and her defense attorneys expressed emotional gratitude as the case concluded.
Daily Kennebec Journal · 21 June 1893 · page 1
be discharged, and it was so ordered. After verdict was received at 4.30, the district attorney moved that the other case* against Miss Borden be noi prossed, and the order of the court was to that effect Chief Justice Mason thanked the juror* for their work and faithful service. The jury was dismissed and court adjourned until Monday next when the regular crimi nal session will be opened. The closing scene in the Borden trial was in direct contrast to those which preceded it. Heretofore, all was decorous and in i keeping with the most dignified court in the country.
See moreSee less
When the verdict of "Not guilty” was re turned a cheer went up which might have been heard half a mile away through the open windows, and there was no attempt to check it. The stately justices looked straight ahead at the bare walls, winking ami blinking just like ordinary men; the hand of doughty Sheriff Wright waa powerless to wield the gavel, and not once daring the tremendous excitement did he make the slightest sign of haring heard it. The people rose in their seats and waved handkerchiefs in unison with their voices. Miss Borden’s head went down apon the rail in front of her, ami tears came as she heard the words "not guilty.” Mr. Jennings was almost crying and hi* voice broke as be put his hand out to Mr. Adams, who sat next to him and said "Thank God.” Mr. Adams returned the presure of bis hand, but seemed incapable of speech. Governor Robertson to turned the rapidly dissolving jnry as they filed out of their seats ami gleamed on them with fatherly interest in his kindly eyes, ami stood up a* Mr. Kuowiton and Mr. Moody come over to shake hands with the counsel for the de fense. As soon as possible the room was cleared, {everybody wanted to shake hands with Miss Borden. She was taken to the room of the justices and allowed to recover her composure with only her friends with her. At the expiration of an hour she was placed in a carriage and driven to the «u tion, where she took the train for Fail River.
The report describes the emotional courtroom scene as the jury delivers a not-guilty verdict, with Lizzie Borden breaking down and her lawyers shaking hands in relief. It then follows her journey home to Fall River, where crowds gathered outside her house awaiting her arrival.
Daily Kennebec Journal · 21 June 1893 · page 1
BACK TO HER HOME. Lizzie Borden, a Free Woman, Once More With Friends.
The report calls the jury's acquittal of Lizzie Borden the only reasonable verdict given the evidence presented at trial. It criticizes the Fall River police for incompetence and questions why Borden was held in prison so long before trial, while noting the crime remains unsolved.
Daily Kennebec Journal · 21 June 1893 · page 2
The Borden Verdict. The verdict which has been rendered in j the Borden trial, was the only one, which, in view of the testimony submitted,an intelj ligent jury could possibly have returned, j The Jmi hnai lias never ladieved in the* guilt of Lizzie Borden, and early urged its
The jury deliberated for an hour and a quarter before returning a verdict of not guilty in the trial of Lizzie Borden for the murder of her father and stepmother. The courtroom broke into cheers and emotional scenes as Borden and her defense team reacted with relief.
The Portland Daily Press · 21 June 1893 · page 1
NOT GUILTY THE VERDICT IN THE BORDEN CASE
chiefs in unison with their voices. Miss Borden’s head went down upon the rail in front of her and tears came as she heard the words “Not urum,y. iur. oenmngs was almost cry ing and his voice broke as he put his hand out to Mr. Adams, who sat next him, and said “Thank God.” Mr. Adams returned the pressure of the hand but seemed incapable of speech. Gov. Rob inson turned to the rapidly dissolving jury as they filed out of their seats and gleamed on them with fatherly interest in his kindly eyes.
See moreSee less
He stood up as Mr. Knowlton and Mr. Moody came over to shake hands with the counsel for the de fense. As soon as possible the room was cleared. Everybody wanted to shake hands with Miss Borden, She was taken to the room of the justices and allowed to recover her composure with only the friends who were with her. At the ex piration of an hour she was helped to a carriage and driven to the station where she took the train for Fall River. Mr. Knowlton Resumed his summing up as soon as the court came to order this morning. The first point he touched upon was the point of motive. He said it was not necessary to find a motive in all cases to fix guilt. He claimed the motives of a crime were as inscrutable as the ways of divine providence. He claimed jeal ousy surrounded and threatened the daily life of Mrs. Borden and that it was not Lizzie Andrew Borden who greeted her father when he came in but a mur deress, whose hands were reeking with the blood of the dead woman up stairs. It was not the father she met but the husband of the woman she had just killed. The murder, he said, was not the result of careful plans but the out come of stern necessity. The speaker then described the last walk of Mr. Borden and his arrival at the house; how Bridget let him in, and the moves that were made up to the time he asserts Liz zie pounced upon him with uplifted axe. Mr. Knowlton said that the prisoner was possessed of a composure that had aston ished the world, but she was not under the influence of any drug when she first saw the officers of the law upon the day of the murders, and he claimed that the story of the barn was simply incredible. Instead of this she occupied the time be tween the departure of Bridget up stairs until she called her in, killing her father and destroying the evidence of the crime. The district attorney said no credence was to be placed upon stories of the peddler regarding seeing a woman go from the Borden barn to the house at 10.50. He said the man had
The jury's not guilty verdict triggers wild cheering and tears in the courtroom, with Lizzie Borden overcome with emotion as her lawyers embrace. The report also recaps prosecutor Knowlton's closing argument from the prior day, in which he argued jealousy was the motive and dismissed Lizzie's barn alibi as incredible.