A short item observes that the prosecution's case so far in the Lizzie Borden murder trial has been weak. It predicts the chances now favor her acquittal.
The Butler Weekly Times · 15 June 1893 · page 8
Borden murder trial, baa presented a very weak case, and the chances now look favorable for her acquittal. Gus Bernbadt of Jefferson City is the happy dad of a fine boy, and
City Marshal Hilliard testified about his visits to the Borden house and Lizzie's statement that she was in the barn during the murders. Matron Hannah Reagan recounted overhearing a tense exchange between Lizzie and her sister Emma at the police station.
The Anaconda Standard · 15 June 1893 · page 1
LIZZIE BORDEN'S TRIAL. Progress Made In This Now Celebrated Case.
Mrs.Gilford, a dressmaker, testified^that, in speaking of Mrs. Bu-doii to lis*^^tie, she referred to her as the lattcr's^mother. Luiie said: lioti'tsay that, because she's a mean,^good-for-nothing thing and I don't have^much to do w ith her.^ Lu.ie further said^that she stayed in her room at homo and,^while eating at the same table, they never^look their meals together. AnnaBorden gave no material testi^^mony. Then came six w itnesses w ho were^in the neighborhood on the morning of the^murders, none of whom saw anyone enter^or leave the Borden house. Tbe cross-ex^^amination, however, allowed that such a^thing was possible without being observed.
Witnesses testified at Lizzie Borden's trial, including neighbors who saw no one enter or leave the house, and police matron Hannah Regan recounting a tense exchange between Lizzie and Emma in custody. The court also admitted testimony about Lizzie allegedly trying to buy prussic acid before the murders, and Bridget Sullivan identified a blood-stained handkerchief.
The Anaconda Standard · 15 June 1893 · page 1
LIZZIE BORDEN'S TRIAL.
HannahRegan, the police station^matron, testified that on August^24 while Liuie was in her charge^F.mma called. ^I went into the^toilet room and hearing loud talk looked^out and saw Litiio lying on her side and^F.mma bending over' her. I.lisle said:^'You havex^ivcui me away, Fmme, but I^don't earn, I won't gtre in an inch.' Em^^ma aaidt 'Oh, Liasie. I didn't.' They^stayod together nearly two hours but^didn't speak, and when Kiniu loft no^goodbye was exchanged, 9ncross-examination Mrs. Regan denied^that she had told a reporter that she would^sign a paper saying that the ^You gave^me away'1 story waa a lie.
See moreSee less
She had been^seen by Rev. Or. Buch. who asked her to^sign such a paper, but the marshal ordered^her not I* do it. BridgetSullivan was recalled and iden^^tified the blwsl-stained handkerchief^found beside Mrs. Borden's body, and^identified it us one which the latter used.
City Marshal Hilliard testified about searching the Borden premises and his conversations with Lizzie Borden, including the scene when she was first told she was a suspect. Mayor Coughlin recounted asking Lizzie where she was during the murders, to which she replied she was in the barn looking for sinkers.
Omaha Daily Bee · 15 June 1893 · page 2
LIZZIE BORDEN'S CHANCES - Testimony Given Yesterday in Her Trial for Murder - TRYING HARD TO SECURE A CONVICTION
NRW BnnrotiD.Juno 14. The old court house where Ltzzlo Bordon's life hangs In the bal ance was again thronged today , largely by women , who nro more persistent In demand ing admission than men. City Marshal lllllaid of Fall Hlvcr was the llrst witness today. Ho testified as to Ills search of the promises and of his con versations with the prisoner. The feature of the marshal's testimony was the description of the scene when Lizzie Borden was first told that she was suspected of the crime. Mayor Coughlln was present nt the tlmo.
See moreSee less
Ho told tlio family that they had bettor re main within tlio house for a few days as thcro wns great excitement on the streets. If they wcro annoyed by crowds of people gathering about the house they should no tify him or the city marshal and they would bo protected. Lizzie Borden then asked why that was locossary , and wanted to know if anybody .n the house wns suspected , Mayor Coughlln said ho was sorry to say itbuttho truth was , she herself was suspected. The mayor nskcd LUzIo where she was when the affair hapicuod , and sbo replied that she was in the Darn looking for load sinkers for her fish Inc. Emma spoke up and said : "Wo have tried to keep It from you as long as wo could.1' Lizzio said : "Well , I am ready to goat any tlmo. " Cross-examined , Marshal Illlllard ad mitted tlmt the search of the Borden house was thorough nnd that tlio defendant gave 111 in all articles asked for and spoke frankly of the suspicion against her. Mayor Coughlln of Fall Hlverwas the next witness. Mrs. Hannah H. GifTord , n dressmaker , testified that she had made dresses for tlio Bordens. Ono day Lizzie Borden , who had come to have a dross made , told her not to call Mrs. Borden her mother , because "she was n moan , good-for nothing thing. " Lizzie had said that she did not have much to do with her and did not oven cat at the same table with her unless absolutely necessary. Annie M. Borden , cousin of the prisoner , a gray-haired woman , was next called. She had gone to Europe with Lizzie in ISiUI. Upon returning to America Lizzie had said that she was sorry the Journey was over be cause she did not want to go homo where it was so unpleasant lor her. Hannah Uoagan , matron of the police sta tion at Fall Hlvor , testified she had tlio prisoner In charge at ono time. August 20
Mayor Coughlin testifies about informing Lizzie Borden she was a suspect and her account of her whereabouts; other witnesses, including a dressmaker and the police matron, describe Lizzie's hostile remarks about her stepmother and a tense exchange with her sister Emma in jail. Cross-examination challenges the matron's credibility regarding the alleged quarrel.
Testimony focuses on whether Rev. Mr. Buck pressured a witness to sign a paper denying a story of a quarrel, and separately on druggist Eli Bence's account that Lizzie Borden tried to buy prussic acid the day before the murders. The defense objected to the poison testimony as irrelevant and prejudicial, but the court ruled it admissible, visibly upsetting Lizzie Borden.
Omaha Daily Bee · 15 June 1893 · page 2
buying of the prussloacld Is an Innocent act. 1 hero Is nothing lo show tlm least tendency to malice toward Mr. nml Mrs. Borden. " I'lio court decided the ovldonco competent nnd would bo admitted , Lizzie Borden , leaning against the rail , pressing hoiface against her fan , flushed , when the decision of the court was made L known. fc\ Adjourned until morning. ft * *
A Fall River report describes Assistant Marshal Fleet's claim to have found an axe in the Borden house cellar, kept secret for ten months, which he says matches the weapon used in the murders. Many residents reportedly believe this is the actual murder weapon, causing a local sensation and concern among Lizzie Borden's friends.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Sioux County Journal · 15 June 1893 · page 2
For many weeks stories about the hatchet and axes have been published but during all the long ten mouths that have o apsed he has scrupul nisly kept the snret that tho weapon was found on the day the famous bat juries veere discovered. His description of ths weap on was so exact, so minute, his reputa tion for veracity and honorable deal ing in police and private matters is so well known here that two-thirds of tho population believe he has really found the weapon wiih wtich the deeds were l ommitted. ilany of Lizzie Borden's friends feel very much exercised over the testimony.
The article describes the prosecution's case against Lizzie Borden as weak and shifting, noting that detective work and police testimony have been inconsistent. It suggests she was accused mainly because police had no other suspect.
Goldsboro Weekly Argus · 15 June 1893 · page 3
The Stats Guard encampment of the lstard 3d Regiments will open at Carolina City, near Morehead, on July 13 and continue till July 22. The name of the grounds will be "Camp Bogart," in memory of Col. D. N, Bogart, who lost bis life in Newbern during the review of the Statetroops assembled there in April. The prosecutian in the case of Lizzie Borden, charged with the murder of har father and step mother, seem3 to be laboring. A great deal of detective work has been done in the case, and a great many theories have deen advanced to show that the young woman is guilty, but the line of the prose cution has been shifted several times and it is said will be changed again.
See moreSee less
Lizzie Borden appears to haye been seized upon because the police could get no ono else whom they could accuse of the -crime. The testimony of the police and the detectives have been terribly mixed, and so far little evidence against the prisoner has been bought out.
The report states that the trial of Lizzie Borden for the murder of her father and stepmother has begun at New Bedford, Massachusetts. It appears as a short item within a roundup of miscellaneous national news notes.
The Western Sentinel · 15 June 1893 · page 6
NEWS NOTES The Virginia populists will nomi nate a lull State ticket. The Republicans carried the day in the municipal t lection of Wilming ton, Dt-1. Thomas Nelson Page, the Virginia author, ami Mrs. Henry M. Field were married in Chicago. W7. E. Turnbrill and Miss Slaugh ter, of Petersburg, eloped to Wash ington, where they wre married. The trial of Miss Lizzie Borden for
At the New Bedford trial, the defense succeeded in getting Lizzie Borden's inquest testimony excluded, a novel legal point in Massachusetts. Police witness Michael Mulially gave confusing and contradictory testimony about the hatchets found in the cellar, including the handleless hatchet's condition and whether dust or blood was present.
The Monmouth Inquirer · 15 June 1893 · page 8
THE BORDEN TRIAL. UNRAVELING FALL RIVER'S FAMOUS MURDER MYSTERY.
^5ye at the inquest was taken up. It is the first time that the point has been raised in this state, and it was a novel one to the lawyers. It was brought up yesterday when Anna M. White, the official stenog rapher of the Fall River court, testified at there had been a conversation between r. Knowlton and Miss Borden there.
At the Borden trial in New Bedford, Dr. Dolan described finding the bodies, a bloody handkerchief, hair and possible blood on a hatchet, and detailed the wounds on Mrs. Borden's skull. The court also ruled that Lizzie Borden's inquest testimony from the prior August could not be used against her, and reports noted the trial was nearing its end with the defense yet to present its case.
The Monmouth Inquirer · 15 June 1893 · page 8
were described also. The doctor remove ! the skulls of both the murdered persons. “Would a hatchet be consistent with die v.-eur.ds yeti found on Mrs. Border:‘s he*wVrM " Yt.'." “Ir. ■, ,-ur opinion, cc aid tin wounds you found upon the head of Mrs. Bcrden have beer, iu I fir ted by a woman of rdinarv strengths” 'Yes." “How lone, in your opinion, was Vir~. Borden dend ltel'ore Mr. Borden?" “About an hour and a half or two hours.” Xew Bedford. Mass.. Juno 14.—Theend of the Borden trial i* in sight, though not the solution of the Borden mystery. Dis
A boy searching for a ball found an old hatchet with a hammer head on a neighboring barn near the Borden house, its rusty blade showing traces of gilt underneath. The same report covers day ten of the murder trial, including excluded testimony about prussic acid sales from a New Bedford druggist.
The Jersey City News · 15 June 1893 · page 1
NOW, A NEW HATCHET.
THE TRIAL. The tenth day of the murder trial opened hot, with a big crowd in attend ance. I.li9s Borden was Joverwhelmed with floral offerings this tnjtelng and appeared in excellent spirlt^Pi spite the
During cross-examination on prussic acid's uses, the court ruled that testimony about Lizzie Borden's alleged attempt to purchase prussic acid must be excluded because preliminary allegations had not been properly made by the prosecution. The prosecution then rested its case, and the defense began its opening statement, with attorney Jennings praising Lizzie's character and expressing emotion over the case.
The Jersey City News · 15 June 1893 · page 1
thought it would. RULED OUT. At 10:20 the Court ruled that the pre limioary allegations hud uot beeu made by the prosecution, and that therefore the testi mouy relating to the attempt of Lizzie Borden to purchase prussic acid must ne ruled out. Tula is the third and perhaps fatal blow to the Government’s case. The first was tbe exclusion of Lizzie Borden’s own teat tltnony. given at tbe Inquest, tbe second was tbe exclusion or ins testimony oi Anna Borden, tbe consio, and this Iasi seemed t<5 be tbe final setback. Mr. Kuowlton then «' o-e, and after Dot ting tbe various exhibits la evidence; created a sensation by announcing:— “The Government rests.” This was at 10:25. THE DEFENSE’S TURN.
Defense attorney Jennings begins his opening statement, praising Lizzie Borden's character and expressing emotion over the case given his personal connection to the family. The first defense witness, Martha Chagnon, testifies about hearing pounding noises near the Borden fence the night before the murders.
The Jersey City News · 15 June 1893 · page 1
been brought against her. KNOCKING ON TIIE FENCE. Martha Cbagnon, the pleasant little French girl, who testified for the prose cution, was the first witness for the de fence. She is a daughter of Dr. Chagoon, whose yard Is In the rear of the Borden yard. On the night preceding the Borden murder. Miss Cbagnon said, she heard a nolle At about eleven o’clock at night. "How did It sound?” Mr. Jennings asked. "It sounded like pounding on the fence,” was the answer. Mr, Knowlton had objected to this Inquiry, bnt It was allowed.
See moreSee less
“Row long did It continue?” "Four or five minutes.” “What did you do a* the result of hear ing the noise?” There was objection to this, and the question was excluded. “Did you do anything to investigate the cause of the noise?” "No, sir.” _
Dr. Dolan testifies at the New Bedford trial, describing with a mannikin's head how the fatal blows were delivered, while Prof. Wood addresses blood spot evidence and the handleless hatchet. Observers note a juror fell ill and that some lawyers have left convinced Lizzie Borden will be acquitted given the weak prosecution case.
Bridgeton Pioneer · 15 June 1893 · page 5
MISS BORDEN'S TRIAL
Lizzie Cannot Be Convicted. Court House, New Bedford, Mass., June 14.—If the Commonwealth of Massa chusetts, which the crier of the court here calls upon the Almighty to save at the opening and closing of the session each day, does not present any stronger evi dence as to why Lizzie Borden should be convicted of having hastened her step mother and father to death, she will never be convicted rf the awfnl crime of which she stands charged in the indictment. That fact has become so apparent that some of the lawyers (one of them came all the way from Georgia to attend the trial) who have been present from the first have gone home, thoroughly convinced that the jury will acquit the young woman now on trial for her life.
See moreSee less
What the prosecution can have in re serve with which to convince the jury of the guilt of Miss Borden, if it has anything at all, is a subject of speculation. The evi dence taken at the inquest, which fur nished the prosecution with wedges which could have been used to advantage when she went on the stand, having been ex cluded, the prosecution will have to get along with it as best it may. When the case was resumed Dr. Dolan took the stand agaiD, and Mr. Adams con tinued his cross-examination. A mani kin’s head was set up on n chair beside the jury box and the doctor described how the blows fell upon the head of Mr. Borden when he was murdered. tie described the position of tue bodies and the blood spots and Raid the blows came from left to right anc* were of moder ate force. The prisoner sat with closed eyes and a fan over her face. Continuing, Dr. Dolan said that, the blows were made by a sharp instrument, and some of them on Mrs. Borden by an assailant astride of the body. A juryman was taken sick and a recess of five minutes was taken. The prisoner was affected, and was led from the room. When the session was resumed. Dr. Do lan admitted testifying in preliminary hearing that Mrs. Borden’s death was an hour to an hour and a half before his ex amination of her, but now thought it was an hour to an hour and a half before Mr. Borden’s death. He could not safely judge priority within an hour from blood coagu
During the Borden murder trial, Dr. Dolan testified about the nature and timing of the fatal blows using a mannequin head, while Prof. Wood's analysis found no blood on the hatchets or axe and no poison in the stomachs. A juror's sudden illness briefly interrupted proceedings.
Harvard medical experts testified about the autopsy findings, including stomach contents showing deaths an hour and a half apart and no evidence of poison. Blood analysis of hatchets, axe, and clothing was presented, with claims about cleaning and non-human hair, followed by Dr. Draper's description of skull wounds.
Bridgeton Pioneer · 15 June 1893 · page 5
scribed the wounds in the skull of Mr. Borden. 3 DEAD, MANY HURT. New York “Sweaters” Flee for Life From a Fire. Wild Rush of the Men, Women and Children Employed In the Shops—Only
The report describes a visit by the Mayor, Mr. Morse, and the Borden sisters, in which the Mayor asks the family to stay indoors due to public excitement. When Lizzie demands to know the truth, the Mayor tells her she is suspected, and she recounts being in the barn for about twenty minutes to get lead for sinkers at the time her father was killed.
The Sun · 15 June 1893 · page 2
LIZZIE BORDEN'S WORST DAY. t Continued from nnlpage.) Rcrlbod thai xlslt which, with tho Mayor and tho prisoner ns central llguros.. pounds llko something out of u Fronch novol or n trench crlmlnnl trial: ... .,,,
Marshal Hilliard testifies at Lizzie Borden's trial about the police response on August 4th, describing his search of the barn and yard, and later searches of the house including bedrooms. He recounts taking away a dress and requesting the one Lizzie wore the day of the murders.
The Evening Herald · 15 June 1893 · page 2
MARSHAL HILLIARD ON THE STAND
BHti's Tiwtlmony of tho Tnlk llotween the Two Hlstors In the Police Station. Nxw nDfOM, Mnss., Juno 15. Lizzie Borden eatne Into the court room tills
Marshal Hilliard describes multiple visits to the Borden house, searching the barn and rooms, and obtaining a dress and skirt from Lizzie Borden via lawyer Jennings which he passed to Dr. Dolan. He also recounts a later visit where Dr. Coughlin advised the family to stay indoors for their safety amid public excitement.
The Evening Herald · 15 June 1893 · page 2
MARSHAL HILLIARD ON THE STAND
t looked Into the room of Mr. and M-- Borden, then Into IT.... L'.'.o'h room and then Intr. JIis Emma's room; there were other ollicers there Who were looking for anything they could And; I made no exnm nntlon of the drosses; I went again that fteruoon, and in a general way searched the house; thero were other oflleers tlieio: I spent, my time in examining closuts and the dressing cases. I took a dress away; I asked Mr. Jennings for the clres lio (Miss Borden) wore that day; I was then in Mrs.
See moreSee less
Borden's room, and ho went out, returning with this dress, whicli had been shown; I saw Miss Borden after wards In Emma's room; when the dress was handed to me I passed it to Dr. Dolan; I had no tnlk with Miss Borden while 1
This courtroom testimony recounts Mayor Coughlin and Marshal Hilliard's visit to the Borden house, where Lizzie was told she was suspected and asked about her whereabouts during the murders. Additional witnesses, a dressmaker and a cousin, testify about Lizzie's relationship with her stepmother and a European trip.
The Evening Herald · 15 June 1893 · page 2
oremises. He swore that the senrch of tho Borden house was thorough, and that tho defend ant gnvo him nil articles ha nsked for, ond poke earnestly ana irnnKiy in conversa tion about suspicion of her. Movor John W. Coughlln, Fall Itiver, was then called. lie descrilKHl his visit to the Borden house with Marshal Ililliard and corroborated tho marshal's testimony as to the conversation with tho defendant, The court excluded tho evidence as to demonstration against Mr. Morse, offered by government to show that the police later surrounded the house In good faith for nroteotion, not l r surveillance.
See moreSee less
Mrs Hannah H. Gilford, the dressmaker who lias made wearing apparel for the Hor ,tens for six or Haven years past, in describ ing her occupation, said slu made outside ladle garments. 'Mis Borden came to see me about a suit one day," she said. "Wl.ile she wns there I told her I was making a dress for Mrs. Borden, and when I snoko of Mrs. Borden I called her mother. " 'Don't say that, because she's a mean, ifood-for-nothing thing,' Lizsle said to me. 'I don't buve muoh to do witli her.' Lizzie told me. 'At home.' she said. 'I stay In my room.' I asked her if slio dldjuot oat with them. She said they ate at the same table, but that tl-i-y never took their meals toirether if tliev cmil help it." That lwa a! i.eiu was of that, and when it h.ul b.-.-u tol 1. Anna II. Borden, a cousin of tbf unsiner, was called. A tall, gray-hahed woman stepped Into the court room ami remove i uer veil, sue went to Europe with Llzsie when the lat er went to Europe. What tbe prosecution wanted to show by that witness was ttiat on tue way Dome to this country Llnle leinarked the nice time ther bad lust passed, and said she was sorrv she was going home, because her home was so unpleasant for her. The defence objected, a id tbe court de cided not to allow the matter to be testi fied to at tbe present time. Lucv Collet testified that she sat on Dr. t-'haixtiou's piazia in view of the Borden ferae fioin 10. -IS to 11.45 on the morning ,,f the nniruVr and saw no one. llios. Hp' I. a. u hustler, testified that he washed nr..un in Mn. Churchill's yard on the of the murder, and saw no one. I'atiick MoGowan testified that he win in the Crowe yard on the morning J the murder and saw no one in the Bor den vard. Tbe cross-examination of the last few witnesses tended to show a man might have yone out of tbe Borden yard without h1ntf imiin. Mr. Itescan. matron of the Fall Hirer lolioe station, testified to u sutoiuxl venution in the station on August 4 be tween the prisoner and Emma, in which i be prisoner said: "You have given me away, Kmma, and I will let you see I won't (the in one inob." Kuinia said.-"No, Lizzie, I didn't give you away." They then sat two boars without speaking, aud parted without speaking ym ifoumui denied that she told any re porters tint she would sign a paper saying that the "You gave me away" rtory was a lie. After conclusion of Mm. lCeagan'a tesu1 roeuy the government pllereu evmence Kbit the;, PiUoaer attempted to procure -"W Mill ViTSHIHIIKI I JUt. - - 1 -f 4.
A roundup of national and international news items for the week briefly mentions that evidence against Lizzie Borden was weak on the third day of her trial. The item is embedded among unrelated stories like a jaguar escape, Edwin Booth's funeral, and political conventions.
Freeland Tribune · 15 June 1893 · page 4
NEWS OF THE WEEK. Tliur*day, June 8. The Columbian Liberty boll was cast at Troy, N. Y. Tho evidence against Lizzie Borden on the third day of t lie trial was ; weak Animal Dealer Burns of New ;
Coverage of the Borden trial describes a day generally favorable to the defense, including restrictions on testimony about Lizzie's alleged attempt to buy prussic acid and admissions from Marshal Hilliard about an incomplete search. Matron Hannah Reagan testified about the 'gave me away' confrontation between Lizzie and her sister, while the prosecution pursued the theory of exclusive opportunity.
Pawtucket Tribune · 15 June 1893 · page 1
A DAY OF SURPRISES.
mony concerning a certain trunk at the Borden house, which the police could not open. The trunk proved to have a secret spring, which was not found until Lizzie disclosed 1t to the officers. Mayor Coughlin of Fall River followed, beir g cross-questioned with much close ness by Mr. Robinson conecerning the prisoner’s action when he (Coughlin) told her that she was suspected of the murder, end her earnest readiness to go with the authorities. if they so desired. At this point the unbroken line of ~tern wiinesses of the week was brokeu, and very agreea bly, by the Introduetion of the Dressmaker.
See moreSee less
Anna H. Gifford was her name—she who made outer garments oceasionally for the Borden family, not every year, us she testi fied, for that was hardly compatible with Andrew Borden's frugality, Mrs, Gifford suid she made w dolman for Lizzie in the spring of 1892, and had some conversation with the defendant at the time regarding her stepmot her, Ex-Governor Robinson objected to the fntroduetion of the conversation on the ground of indefinite ang remote time, but upon Mrs, Giff rd fixing it as during March, she was allowed to answer, Lizzie, ghe «aid, upon her referring to Abby Dur fee Borden as her mother, exclaimed: “Don’t call her my mother; she is a mean old thing, and I stay in my room most of the time.” The Prisoner's Face Flushed as this last sentence was spoken, but oth erwise she seemed (o listen with a certain fndifference, which suddenly disappeared as Anna H. Borden’'s name was read as tho next witness, Here was really the dramatic situation o/ ‘he day. Miss Anna Borden of Fall River is not a relative of the defendant, but the two young women were close friends for years and took a European trip together three years ago. Under such cir cumstances their relations grew intimate, and Lizzie more than once made admis pions to her friend concerning the unhap piness of her home life, expressing especial regret as their journey drew to a close and the necessity of returning forced ftself upon her, Barring the prisoner's tears of joy Mon day, there has been no more pathetic incident thus far in the trial than the grief-stricken way in which the quiet woman in black heard the name of she who so lntely had seemed a life-long friend. Lizzie Borden waited until she saw Anna Borden coldly advance to the wit ness stand aud then she covered her eyes with her fan as if the sight was
The defense cross-examined Marshal Hilliard and Mayor Coughlin, while matron Hannah Reagan recounted the 'Give Away' story about Lizzie accusing her sister. Dressmaker Anna Gifford testified Lizzie once called her stepmother 'a mean old thing,' and the session ended as Anna Borden was called as the next witness.
The report describes courtroom testimony in which witnesses recounted Lizzie Borden's complaints about her stepmother, before the judge ruled Anna Borden's testimony about Lizzie's remarks on an unhappy home life inadmissible as evidence of premeditation. It also notes a French maid's confused and tangled testimony that provided comic relief during the session.
Doctors testified at Lizzie Borden's trial that the handleless hatchet from the Borden home could have produced all the wounds on both victims. Dr. Cheever gave a dramatic courtroom demonstration of how the fatal blow to Mr. Borden's skull could have been struck.
The Austin Weekly Statesman · 15 June 1893 · page 8
PUBLIC INTEREST GROWING AS GIRL'S TRIAL PROGRESSES
Hatchet Belonging to Borden Home stead A Graphic Illuitration. New Bedford, June 13. -Again great crowd Jhrouged the court room where Lizzie Borden was being trieu n..,ii.li.r ti nrixoner eat with 1U1 Ul U I U V t f" .ir.QiH vna unci ft fan ovet her face Dr. Dolan testified that the blow were made by a sharp instrument and some on Mrs. Borden by her asiailau astride of her body. Dr. E. 8. Wood of Harvard Medical college was next called and described the examination of the stomachs. He found nothing to indicate disease in either stomach aud of the contents showed a difference an hour and a half In time of death There was no evidence of poison.
See moreSee less
Dr rtrar.oi. riaaprihail the wounds in the Kknil f Mr. Borden. He described the wounds and swore that the instru merit producing them was three and a half inches long, the exact length of the handleless hatchet. At the conclusion of Draper's ex ominfitimi Dr. (Jheever. surgical ex pert, was called. He tettilled that the handleless hatchet could make all the blows on the bodies; that one blow on Mrs. Borden was made by a person lacing her, aud on cross examination miri thn hinnrf would naturally fall nn thnasHailaut. There was a strife. ing and dramatlo lllmtratiou a little irr xhnn Mr. Adams asked him to Illustrate lust how the blow could mvA hnnn struck to produce the cut found in the skull of Mr. Borden. Adams stood before witness, who was tall and spare and vey deliberate in bis moveuien's. A new hatchet was hfilri aloft a second, incliued to the Inft. tlinn flashed through the air straight at. it seemed, the skull o Mr. AiinmH. When it seemed as if the crush of the bone could be heard, the hatchet stopped and remained steadv. The spectators gasped. A few minutes later court adjourned.
A hatchet was found on a neighbor's barn roof near the Borden property by a boy searching for a ball, and was reported to police and the defense counsel. The implement, rusted with traces of gilt, was being considered as possible evidence in the ongoing Lizzie Borden murder trial.
San Antonio Daily Light · 15 June 1893 · page 1
FOUND A HATCHET. Which May Figure as a Witness In The Lizzie Borden Case. Fall River, Mass., June 15— Last night, a son of C. C. Potter,
The first day of Lizzie Borden's trial featured testimony from Marshal Hilliard and Mayor Coughlin about their visit to the Borden house and conversations with the defendant. Dressmaker Mrs. Gifford testified that Lizzie had called Mrs. Borden hateful and said she hated her.
Richmond Dispatch · 15 June 1893 · page 1
LIZZIE BORDEN'S ORDEAL
Cacia, : ——n_. tizzie Borden's Orde (By telezraph to the Dispateh.] | NEW Beproed, Mass. June 14. lo the Borden trial the first witness called was t iny-Marshal Mithard, of Fall River, who des riba his Visi to tho Borden house and & nyorsation with the prisoner in which she was t Jd teal she Was sis | pected of the crime, The witness was Cross-ex. amucd by Governor {obinson, who attempted to show that Hilliard was net « pstructed In his search of toe prenuses and that the search of the roo ns was thorough.
See moreSee less
Huhara swore that the sesrcn of the Borden housy was thorousi | wid that the defendant gave up ail the articles he asked for and spoce earnesily and frankly tu | conversation about the suspicion restag upon her. | Mayor John Coughlin, of Fall River, described Cn visic to the Borden house with Hilliard and | et rroborsted the Marshal's testimony as 10 the | conversation with the defendant. I'ne Court excluded evidence as to the domon | stration against Morse offered hy the govern ment to sow that the polics later surrounded the house in good faith for protection and not for surveillance, Mrs, Giflord, dressmaker, testified that the prisoner (old her that Mrs. Borden was a * mean, Latefal odd toning”: thai she hated her, and ever ate with her when shis could help it. Ihe prisousr’s color rose As this LASLIIONY WAS Zivell. I's government offered to fiw that the pei gonear sail in November, 1880, that her home was anbappy. This was excludad on the ground that it did not necessarily refer to the murdered poarsons, Five or six witnesses testified to being within sigutof the Borden yard on tne morning ol the murder and sealing no person leave the yard, but upon cross-examination 1s appeared thal men inight have leit the yard without being seel. Hannah Peagan, matroa at the polles station, Fail Itiver, testified, defining hor duties. Wit ness sald the prisoner was in her charge at one ume, * She was in my room,” sbe said. * On J
Testimony continued regarding Lizzie Borden's relationship with her sister Emma and a disputed written statement about whether they had quarreled. The court also debated and ultimately admitted testimony from drug clerk Eli Bence that Lizzie allegedly tried to buy prussic acid the day before the murders, claiming it was to clean a sealskin cape.
Richmond Dispatch · 15 June 1893 · page 1
exprossed a willingness to sign the paper. Ell Benes, a drug clerk of Fall Kiver, was aworn, but the dafence objected to his testimony being admitted, It was intended to prove by him shat Lizzie Borden tried to purchase prussic acid the day befors the murder, saying she wanted to clean a seal-skin facque, also that that article is never used for such a purposas, After along argument, the justices consiltad half an hour and then decided to ad mit the drug clerk's testimony. The defence was not satisfied with the decision, and another argument followed which lasted until court ad 1ourned.
The report notes the trial of Lizzie Borden for the murder of her father and stepmother is drawing national attention due to its mystery. It states that no blood was found on her clothing despite the bloody crime scene, and that the prosecution's testimony so far has not strongly implicated her.
Clarke Courier · 15 June 1893 · page 2
The trial of Miss Lizzie Borden, of Mass., who is charged with the mur der of her father and step-mother, is attracting much attention all over the country because of the mystery about the crime. Miss Lizzie and Bridget Sullivan, a servant girl in the employ of the Borden family, were, it seems, the only persons in or near the house when the double murder was committed. The servant girl is not suspected, and the theory is that Miss Lizzie is the only person who could have committed the crime, though no motive is alleged.
See moreSee less
In less than a half hour after the murder of her father she sent for the family physician and other friends, and while the blood of the victims bespat tered everything near where their bodies were found, no blood was found on any of the garments worn at the time by the accused. The testimony thns far introduced by tbe State is not calculated to fasten the irime upon the young lady.
The Memphis Appeal-Avalanche offers an analysis arguing it would have been physically impossible for Lizzie Borden to have killed both her father and stepmother given the narrow time windows and lack of a change of bloody clothing. The piece reasons through the morning's timeline, concluding she could not have hidden evidence and appeared clean to Bridget Sullivan so quickly.
The Times · 15 June 1893 · page 4
£ demphis Appeal-Avalanche is of » Memphis Appeal-Avalanei "| pe einlon that it would have been im ose’le for Lizzie Borden to have killed he fathqr and step-mother. It reasons ( pt It she were guilty, she would have | ren obliged to have killed her step
A newspaper miscellany item states that Lizzie Borden belongs to the Central Congregational Church in Fall River, whose minister is Rev. W. Walker Jubb. It explicitly corrects an earlier report that had named Rev. E. A. Buck as her minister.
A recently Issued circular states that Philip Armour & Co. received .flOJ, 000,000 from "distribution sales" In the lest 12 months, made $12,000,000 worth of glue and paid 5,500,000 to their 11,000 em ployes. Tho plume of tho Prince of Wales, worn on state occasions, is sal J to be worth $50, 000. The feathers, nu English writer says, are pulled from the tall of tbo feriwah, one of the rarest and most beautiful birds of India. Tha porsonul belongings ot tho Blalues wero removed from Bar Harbor to Augusta last week, as Stnuwood has been rented.
See moreSee less
Mils Lizzie Borden is a member of tho Central Congregational church in Ftall River, of which Rev. W. Walker Jubb is mlnlstor, not, ns has been said, Rev, E. A. Buck, In vluunf whnt Hood's f-nrf p:irllla has dime for others, hjit not reasonable to believe that It will also be ot benefit to you 't
On the third day of Lizzie Borden's trial, witnesses described the construction and layout of the Borden house, including a closet large enough for a man to hide in. John V. Morse, brother of Borden's first wife, then testified about his visit to the house the day before the murders, detailing his movements, meals, and lack of any disturbance overnight.
Nkw Bmij'omi, Mao?., Juuc 7. At l-.o upeuins of tho third day of tbu Borden trurdur tlinl tliU lnortilsi; tlio nut bid curiosity of the feiuaiu portion a! tlu ooni tinnilty wa3 rataroit to mid nearly olid half of tha spectators in tlia court room were woman. Misj liorden caiuo into court looking 09 unconcerned anil fresh as any ono possibly could under filch trying clr cmnatimces. After bIiu took ltor sent lawyer Jennings had o ilvo minutes' conversation with her and sliu appeared very much in terested und nnlmutud, a smllo asserting Il licit occasionally a tbo tr.ll: proceeded.
See moreSee less
Mr. Kilran, civil on;;l"ocr, who was on the stand yesterday, was in-colled for tho llrst witness. Ha returned bis testimony at to the nurrouniliURs of tho Borden prem ises, tha construction of tho house, measure ments and location ot rooms etc. Witness said ths closot in tho front ball of tho liorden house was large enough to allow a man to outer it. Tbo door could ba shut saslly. James A. Walsh, a Kali River pho tographer, was the next wltaes. IIo said lie hud taken photographs of the liorden premises nt tho request of tho government. 3'ho photographs wero put In ovldouoi and Identified by vltue". John V. JHiino limn Took tlio Stand. He testified that ho was 00 years of as0, and a brother ot Mr. Borden's llrst wife. Lizzie Borden is Oil years old, Emma 41. Witness visitod tha liordena' Wednesday, August !!; wont to .Swansea in tho after noon; returned ut NllO p. m. on tha same day; saw nobody but tho family in tho bous.', wont to bed at 10:!!0, saw or hnrd nobody dm In;; tho nir;lit; aroso at 0 the next morning, ate lirenktiist with Mr, and "Mrs. Bord-n ut 7 o'clock-. Witness left tha bouts at. S:10 n. m. ; saw Bridget (Sullivan In tho kitchen on his v?ny out; was in tho city on business until about 11 :-(J, then returned to tbo Bcrdou house and w as informed of the tragedy; haw tha bodies if Mr. and Mr.". Bordon." Witness never saw Lizzie Borden from the tlina ho
John V. Morse, brother of Mr. Borden's first wife, described his movements before and after the murders, including dining with the Bordens and finding no officers at the barn upon his return. His testimony, under cross-examination by ex-Gov. Robinson, raised questions about the front door lock and possible outside entry.
A witness described finding no officers near the barn upon returning, contradicting police claims about verifying Lizzie's alibi, and recalled seeing a man bagging axes days after the murder. Bridget Sullivan then testified about locking doors the night before the killings and about Mr. and Mrs. Borden being ill Wednesday morning, while bank officials confirmed seeing Andrew Borden that same morning.
since. At 11::!., court took a five minutes' ro cesw, during nhich tuuo Hits Borden con versed witb her counsel, while sho nervous ly lingered her bottlo of smelling salts. Abraham (J. Hart, treasurer of Union Savings bank of Kali Klver; John T. Bur rei;, cashier of Union National bank, and Kvcrett Id. Cook, cashier of tbo First Mo tional bank, testified to seuing Mr. Borden in their ro.pectivo banksbetween i):30 and 10 o'clock on the morning of the murders, llrldgol Sullivan's Tontlmoiiy, Bridget .Sullivan testified that sho camo to work lor tho Hordens nbout two years boforo tho time of tho murder; on tho Mon day preceding tho day ot tho tragedy wit ness washed tha clothei of the house bold in tho cellar.
See moreSee less
After washing alio locked tho cellar door by a bolt on tho inside; from that time after she bad no occasion to uo that door; never no ticed any chtr.gn in tha door from that time. Continuing, witness testified that Mr. and Mri. Borden wero both sick Wed nesday morning: had seen Mr. Morse nt tho houso Wednesday; witness was out Wed nesday night; got homo ubout 10:l."i; when bho weal out in tho cvuuiug the back door was lockoJ; It us tho sumo way when sho returned; af lor alio want into the house sho locked this door with double locks and u bolt; then wont direct to bej; heard no jioisa during tlo night, Witnoss told ol her nork oo tho morning ot tho murder. At this point court took a rccss from 1 to 2 : 1 ."5. On re-as6ombllng .Mies Borden tool: her seat for tho first time within tha bar en closure and near hor. counsel. I3he appeared to bo In good spirits nud toyed with a clus ter ot pansies which sue bold. Mrs. Kelley was called, wlnlo Bridge! Pulllvun rost"d. rihe is tho wife of Dr. Kolley and lives in the next houso south of the Ilordon bouse. Jibe unified to leaving ber house nt 2b' minutes of 11 by her kitchen clock, nblcti was not auacsurate tlinekisper ami Seeing !r. Itur l.m In III. Vnril, coming around to thu front of tbo house, Ho was putting the key iu to tho fiout door whan she ptueod. She did not remember my team coining by nt the time, though It Might have bsou so, lirldget Hulli 7aii, bilug re called, tostluVd to Mr. and Mrs. Borden and Mr, Morse living breukfnst tigothor. I.lzio camo !..io tlio klto!iu while wtnss was umhiui; I l.e dishes, blm mid sho didn't want much nt anything for breakfast but would tako 1'iiiie coltae and cookies. Wllncss than dos cnbed her propnrntlous for washing tli ilndons; the told Lizzie ttm she ueed'nt lock the door as sh would waut to come in for water. While alio was washing the windows from tho outside, Lizzio wont In and did nut lock tho door; witness went nrotlud tho house to tha barn several times for water and no one camo to the 1iouo that s.uv. Whllo she was washing tho Insldo of tho windows In tho sitting room she heard someone at the front door and went to unlock it. Hho was both ered with so many locks and bolts that sho tald "O, pshaw," and Lizzie, who was ot the head of ttio stirs or iu bor room, laughed nt hor. Witness then described her running for the doctor and for Miss Bussoll ot Miss Bur den's suggestion and boing told by Lizzio that sho thought ber mother had come in and go up stairs and so if die wa thoro; 1 li uu tlio finding of Mrs. Borden's body by Mrs. Churchill and lursolf. When she camo ilown stniM Lizzio told her that sho had found tho ecroon door opou
This editorial criticizes newspapers for sensationalizing the Lizzie Borden trial with lurid details like the murder weapon, bloody items, and courtroom swooning, illustrated with gruesome woodcuts. It argues reputable journals should report the trial's facts without such ghastly embellishments.
St. Johnsbury Caledonian · 15 June 1893 · page 4
LIVELY JOVRSALIS3I. Lovers of the sensational in jour nalism are now getting an abun dance of that sort of thing in the newspaper accounts of the trial of Lizzie Borden. The handleless hatchet with which it is supposed the deed was done, the dress which Miss Borden did not wear on the morning of the murder, the exact spots in the exact rooms where the murdered people were found, the bloody handkerchief, Miss Lizzie her self in the act of swooning in the court room when some piece of especially startling testimony is given these and other things are pictured in the newspaper columns and dressed out in such verbiage as only the sensational reporter can find use for.
See moreSee less
The trial in question is an im portant one, and many people out side of that immediate vicinity are interested in the outcome thereof. But it would seem possible to make the published accounts of it interesting and intelligible without laying so strong emphasis on these ghastly emblems of crime and calling upon the wood-cut aitist to show them up in all their hideousncss, Such details as these may well be omitted from the columns of would be icputable journals,
The report describes a week of testimony in the Borden trial at New Bedford, noting that evidence so far has favored the defense. It highlights the judge's ruling excluding Lizzie Borden's preliminary hearing testimony as a setback for the prosecution.
St. Johnsbury Caledonian · 15 June 1893 · page 4
THE HORDES TRIAL. Proceedings in the Borden trial nt New Bedford have been watched with intense interest during the past week, and it may be said that at this writing those who have looked upon Miss Borden as innocent of the terrible crime with which she is charged have had their hopes strengthened, and are more than ever convinced that she will be fully acquitted. Certainly the evidence thus far brought out is not partic ularly unfavorable to the prisoner. The attempt to have the testimony which Miss Borden gave at the
The report describes the ongoing trial of Lizzie Borden, noting that cross-examination by ex-Gov. Robinson has undermined much of the prosecution's testimony. It predicts the case will soon go to the jury and anticipates a likely acquittal.
Bellows Falls Times · 15 June 1893 · page 10
GUILTY OR NOT?
Fall Klver. ' The trial of Lizzie Borden, charged with the murder of her father and mother, is progressing slowly. So far the state has put in a large amount of testimony, some of an apparently dam aging nature to the defendant, but the rigid cross-examinations by ex-Gov. Rob inson nave changed the color oi the tes timony and show that much of it was manufactured. Witnesses dispute each otherand even refute their own testimony from day to day. Jt is generally con ceded that the state's case is being weakened by each additional witness.
See moreSee less
The testimony for the state is now about all in, and the case will probably go to the jury by Saturday. The testimony extracted by the coroner's jury from Miss Borden just after the murder, when she was nearly insane with grief and from the effects of drags, was excluded, as it should be. It is doubtful if the de fense puts in many witnesses, and whether Miss Borden goes on the stand. At present, it looks as though the jury will bring in a verdict of acquittal with out a wrangle.
At the Borden trial, Officer Fleet testified to finding additional hatchets in the cellar, while Officer Harrington undermined the defense's outsider theory by stating Lizzie told him the motive wasn't robbery since nothing in the house was disturbed. She also gave detailed timing about finding her father dead and her time in the barn.
Wood County Reporter · 15 June 1893 · page 6
ROBBERY NOT THE MOTIVELizzie Borden Told an Officer that Noth ing io the House Was D ■ nrb I. New Bedford, Mass., June —in the Borden trial to-day Officer fleet admitted that he found other hatchets in the cellar partly covered by ashes Officer Harrington made a hole in the defense's theory of murder by outsiders by testifying that Miss Borden tol t him immediately after tne tragedy that the motive was not robbery, as every thing about the house was undisturbed. She told wit ness she left her father reading a pa per and found him dead twenty min utes after. She was particular about the time she was in the barn, saying she was there fully twenty minutes.
The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · Wheeling, W. Va.
Mrs. Hannah Gifford, the Bordens' dressmaker, testified that Lizzie spoke bitterly of her stepmother, calling her 'mean' and saying she avoided eating with her when possible. The report also references a dramatic incident involving the police matron and an alleged confrontation in Lizzie's cell, which her friends denied occurred.
The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · 15 June 1893 · page 1
persistent and insistent than the wen. Tim sulfation of the day was tho ovidouce el Mrs. (ilfl'ord, a dross maker, .n.l thu matron of the Fall River polico I station. Mrs. Hannah H. Gifford, tho dross maker, wlio has mado wearing apparel (or tlio Dordensfor thoaiz voars past, la (Inscribing horoccupation,saidsho made "outsideladlos'garments, Miss llorden cams to mo about a suit ono day. Wliilo alio was thcro I told hor I was making a dross (or Mrs. Borden, and when I spoko of Mrs. Bordou, I called hor mother. 'Don't say that becaUBO ilio's u mean, good for nothing thing,' Liulo said to ine.
See moreSee less
was. '1 don't huvo much to do with her,' Lizzie told me. 'At homo' alio said, 'I nay in my room.' I asked her if she diil not oat with thorn. Kho said thoy uto ut tlio same table, but thoy never took thoir weals togethor if thoy could kelp it. Next came six wituosaos who wore in tlio llordon neighborhood tho morning of tho murder, uclthor of whom oaw
The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · Wheeling, W. Va.
Bridget Sullivan testifies about the bloodstained handkerchief, then a druggist's clerk is called to testify Lizzie Borden tried to buy prussic acid the day before the murders. After lengthy legal argument between prosecutor Moody and defense attorney Robinson, Chief Justice Mason rules the evidence admissible as showing the defendant's state of mind prior to the killings.
The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · 15 June 1893 · page 1
IN A MURDEROUS MOOD
IN A MUflUKROL'S 11U0U. Mr. Moody said that tho common woaith wanted to show by Butts tlml flomu time during August 3, tho day boforo tho tnurdor, Lizzie Borden wont to a drug storu and tried to purchaso ton coats worth of prussiu add. titio said ho wanted it in order to clean a seal' skill sucnue. "It is not usod for such u purpose, said Mr. Moody. ''Mrs. Hor don bad soon Dr. Bowea and told liim that she was afraid of boinu poisoned. Lizzie Uorden was in a murduroua mood at the timo."
See moreSee less
Tho assistant district attorney quoted from a number of authorities to main* tain his position. When Mr. Moody flnishod his arjjU' monk K*.(4nvnrnnr Unhiiiflnn hncrnn. Ho contended that im to anythiug pre1 vioua to Augaijt 3 there waa nothing in tho testimony oxcopt that given by Mrs. GitTord.
The report covers trial proceedings at New Bedford where the court ruled to admit evidence that Lizzie Borden tried to buy prussic acid the day before the murders, intended to show premeditation. City Marshal Hilliard testified about visiting the Borden house and informing Lizzie she was a suspect, with cross-examination by Governor Robinson.
Wheeling Register · 15 June 1893 · page 1
COURT WILL ADMIT EVIDENCE
Brought Out Yesterday. New Bedford, Mass., June 14.—The old court house, where Lizzie Borden’s life is in the balance, was again throng ed to-day—largely by woman who are more Insistent and persistent than the men. City Marsha! Hilliard, Fall River, was the first witness this morning, aud de scribed his visits to the Borden bouse, his conversation with the prisoner in which she was told that she was sus pected, and when she said she was in the barn when the murders were com mitted. The Marshal was cross exam ined by Governor Robiuson, who at tempted to show that the witness T$as not obstructed in his search of *he premises. A feature of the Marshal’s testimony was the first knowledge Lizzie Borden
Witnesses including Mayor Coughlin, Marshal Hilliard, a dressmaker, and police matron Hannah Reagan testify about the days surrounding Lizzie Borden's questioning and arrest. Testimony covers her alibi about being in the barn, her strained relationship with her stepmother, and the circumstances of police surveillance at the Borden house.
Wheeling Register · 15 June 1893 · page 1
COURT WILL ADMIT EVIDENCE
River, was next called. Ho described his visit to the Borden house with Mar shal Hilliard and corroborated the mar shal’s testimony as to the conversation with the defendant. The court ex cluded the evidence as to demonstration against Mr. Morse offered by the govern ment to show that the police later sur rounded the house in good faith for protection not for survei llauce. Mrs. Hannah H. Gifford, tbo dress maker who has made wearing apparel for the Bordens for the six years past, iu describing her occupation, said she made “outside ladies garments.” ‘ Miss Borden came to see me about a suit one day.” she said.
See moreSee less
“While sho was there I told her I was making a dress for Mrs. Barden and when I spoke of Mrs. Bor den, I called her mother. ‘Don’t say that because sho is a mean, good for notbing thing,’ Lizzie said to me. “ ‘I don’t have much to do with her,’ Lizzie said. ’At home, she said, T stay in my room.’ I asked her if sho did not eat with them. She said they ate at t.ho same table, but they never took their meals together if they could help it.” Next came six witnesses who were iu the Borden neighborhood the morning
Police matron Hannah Reagan testified at trial that she overheard Lizzie tell Emma 'you have given me away' during a tense exchange at the station, followed by a cold silence between the sisters. She also described a lighter incident involving a bet over breaking an egg, and discussed pressure from Rev. Mr. Buck to deny the quarrel story.
Wheeling Register · 15 June 1893 · page 1
Lizzie Borden leaned far forward her head over the shoulder of ^Ir. Robin son. Her face did not change in ex pression, except that it became flushed. At this point a recess was taken.
This item in a roundup of telegraphic briefs notes that the trial of Lizzie Borden for murdering her father and stepmother is in progress at New Bedford, Massachusetts. It adds that the trial is attracting great attention throughout New England.
The Saratoga Sun · 15 June 1893 · page 2
. fleers of the Carnegie company on account of the killing at Homestead, have been qua hed. i The trial of Lizzie Borden for murdering her father and step-mother is in progress at New Bedford, Massachusetts. The trial at tractgreat attention throughout New EngI land. A negro ravishcr was taken from the jail at Decatur. Illinois, by a mob the other night and lynched. The governor declares that the members of the mob shall be brought to trial for it. The Cleveland. Ohio. Free Trade club gave its annual banquet Wednesday night. Among the guest* of the club who responded to toasts w ere Henry George. Thomas G. Shear man, William Lloyd Garrison and Hon.
The report describes widespread local opinion that the prosecution's case against Lizzie Borden is weak, fueled by rumors that her defense team will reveal a dramatic new fact. It mentions hints that she purchased paint before the murder and that dress-burning was common in the household, alongside confusion over a police officer's conflicting testimony about a hatchet handle.
The Forrest City Times · 16 June 1893 · page 8
A VERY WEAK CASE.
plode a bomb-shell in the camp of the authorities. It is hinted that the de fense will show conclusively that Liz zie Borden purchased some paint a few days before the murder and that it was not an uncommon thing to burn dresses in the Borden household. Then
This report covers Wednesday and Thursday's proceedings in Lizzie Borden's trial at New Bedford, describing a packed courtroom and the defendant's demeanor. City Marshal Hilliard testified about arriving at the Borden house amid a large crowd and revealed the first knowledge that Lizzie had said she was suspected of the murder.
Paper unidentified · 16 June 1893 · page 1
LIZZIE BORDEN'S TRIAL.
A feature of the Marshall’s testi mony was the first knowledge that Liz zie Borden had said that she was sus pected of the murder. Mayor Cough
Witnesses testify at trial about the police visit to the Borden house, where Mayor Coughlin told Lizzie she was suspected, and about Lizzie's demeanor and statements to a dressmaker and the police matron. Marshal Hilliard corroborates that Lizzie cooperated with the search and spoke frankly about the suspicion against her.
Paper unidentified · 16 June 1893 · page 1
LIZZIE BORDEN'S TRIAL.
City Marshal Hilliard on being cross-examined swore that the search of the Borden bouse was thorough, and the defendant gave him all the ar ticles asked for and spoke earnestly aud frankly in conversation about the suspicion ot her. Mayor John W. Coughlin, of Fall River, was next called. He described the visit to the Borden house with Marshal Hilliard, and corroborated the Marshal's testimony as to the con versation, and a demonst ration against Mr. Morse was offered by tho Govern ment, to show that the police later, surrounded the house in good faith for protection, not for surveillance.
See moreSee less
Mrs. Hannah Clifford, a dressmaker who has made wearing apparel for the Bordens for six or seven years past, said: “Miss Borden came to see me about a suit one day. While there I told her I was making a dress for Mrs. Borden and when 1 spoke of Mrs. Borden I called her her mother.” “Don’t say that because she’s a mean, good-for-nothing thing,” Lizzie said to me. “1 dont have much to do with her,” Lizzie told me, “At home,” she said, “1 stay in my room.’’ “L asked her if she did not eat with them. She said tliey ate at tho same table, but they never took their meals together if they could help it.” Next came six witnesses who wore iu tho Borden neighborhood the murder, neither of whom saw any one enter or go away. Cross-examina tion, however, tended to show that a man might have gone out of the Bor den house without being seen. Hannah Regan, the matron at the police station in Fall River, testified that the prisoner was in her charge at one time. “She was in my room,” she said, “on the 21th of August. Emma came to see her. I was in the room cleaning up. She spoke with her sis ter aud I wont into tho toilet-room and hearing loud talk looked out and saw Lizzie lying on her side and Em ftnlg ItMM. said: ’You have given me away, LIZZIE BORDEN’S TRIAL. ABSURDLY TANGLED. Emma, but I don’t care; 1 won’t give The Ford Theatre Disaster Gets Bad Wednesday’s and Thursday’s Pro in one inch.’ Emma said: ‘Oil, Liz ly Mixed up in Court. ceedings in the Famous Mur zie, I did not,’ at the same time sit der Case. The Supreme court of the District ting down. They sat there until Mrse county taxes. The court room at New Bedford, of Columbia, on yeste’rday, dismissed Jenkins came, two hours after, but Mass., where Lizzie Borden’s chances Col. Ainsworth's petition for man Lizzie made no talk at all with her for life aud death are daily being damns, against the Deputy Coroner of sister after—never opened her mouth weighed in the legal balances, held the District, on two grounds, first to her. When 1 first heard the noise in the hands of the presiding justices holding that the Deputy Coroner is of loud talking I was about 4 feet aud members of the jury who are not a legal officer. This invalidates away in the closet. When Emma left sworn to try the case according to the inquest as far as held. Second, that morning there was nothing said the law and evidence, was crowded to that the right of a person to be pres by the other, aud no good-bye was its utmost capacity on both Wednesday ent at an inquest in person or by excharged.” and Thursday. At the hour of ad counsel is discretionary with the cor
Hannah Regan testified about overhearing Lizzie and Emma Borden arguing in the police station, with Lizzie accusing Emma of 'giving her away.' Druggists testified about Lizzie's alleged attempt to buy prussic acid, but the judges excluded this evidence as not meeting the prosecution's proffer.
Paper unidentified · 16 June 1893 · page 1
Bridget Sullivan was recalled. Mr. Moody took up the old blood-stained handkerchief found beside the body of Mrs. Borden aud held it up so Bridget conld see it. “Whose handkerchief was that?” asked the lawyer. “That,” answered Bridget, “is what Mrs. Borden need as a duster.”
The item mentions that Wednesday and Thursday's trial proceedings in the Lizzie Borden murder case are published in this issue, bringing readers up to date. It notes future issues will carry the previous day's proceedings.
Paper unidentified · 16 June 1893 · page 4
Borden murder case, as published in this issue of the Democrat, brings , the proceedings of this celebrated trial up to date, enabling us to give in each subsequent day’s issue the proceedings of the day previous. President M. P. Ilillyer, of the Tex arkana Water Company, arrived in the city yesterday from Kansas City, Mo. He has only recently returned from a visit to the World's Fair and speaks in terms of decided praise con cerning magnitude and excellence of the great Columbian Exposition.
The item reports that Lizzie Borden is currently on trial at New Bedford, Massachusetts, for the murder of her parents. It calls the case one of the most mysterious in years.
The Mountain Echo · 16 June 1893 · page 2
pills will cure them. (*, C. Poynter. j The city of Fargo, N. D., was j half wiped out by firu last week ( The loan wns a half million dollars, one w<*wd describes it "perfection.” we rej far to do witi’s witch Hazel salve, cures ob stinate sores, t^rus. skin deceases and is a ! Well known cure for piles. C. C. Poynter.; Three I uildings in !?t. Louis weio blown ul> last week hy gaso line. Sixteen persons were bad ly burned but no one was killed. / We could not improve the <piality ifpvtd «Wble tiro price.
See moreSee less
L»e win’s witch nazej Si t! ve is the bint S live that experience can produce, or that money can buy. C. C. Poyuter. ( Lizzie Borden is on trial at
Among a roundup of unrelated national and international news items, the report briefly states that Lizzie Borden's trial for murdering her father and step-mother is in progress at New Bedford, Massachusetts. It notes the trial is attracting great attention throughout New England.
crowd also went In to see her highness. The Spanish caravals, Santa Marla, Nina andPlnu, arc now off the southeastern coast of Nova Scotia, between Halifax and Caiiso. The Republicans of Ohio have re-nomlnated Major McKinley for governor by acclamation. The Duke of Vcragua attended the conven tion. For the first lime In San Francisco a Chinese woman Is appearing on tho stage and the Washington street Temple of Celestial Drama Is packed to the doors every night. The Indictments that were found by the grand Jury against 11. C. Frick and other of ficers of the Caruegle company on account of the killing at llomestend, have been quashed.
See moreSee less
The trial of Lizzie Borden for murdering her father nnd step-mother Is In progress at New Bedford, Masaaehusctls. The trial at tracts great attention throughout New Eng land. The New York Central’s report of gross earnings for May, shows that the road earned In May, 1802, 18,04.1,405, nnd In May, 1823, $4,001,818. This is a net gain for May of this year of $.'158,210 over May lust year. Riots have broken out In Comma, the capItol of the province of that name, In the ex treme northwest of Spain. The cause of the riots Is the indignation aroused among tho people against the taxation arising from the military reforms. The Cleveland, Ohio, Free Trade club gave IU annual banquet Wednesday night. Among the guests of the club who responded to toastswere Henry George, Thomas G. Shear man, William Lloyd Garrison aud lion. Thomas L. Johnson.
On June 15, the Borden murder trial's tenth day featured testimony on prussic acid purchases, which the court ultimately excluded, before the prosecution rested its case. The defense, led by Mr. Jennings, then began presenting its case, calling Mary Chagnon as the first witness.
Morning Journal and Courier · 16 June 1893 · page 3
the Borden Hoaae. 'Nrw Bbdvoho, U ass., Jane 15. The tenthday of the Borden murder trial opened with hot weather and a big orowd in attendance., Misa Jordan appeared in goodspirlts, notwithstanding yesterday's rather disheartening proceedings, which oloaed with the deolslon of the oourt to ad mit testimony relating to Lizzie Borden's attempt to purchase pruaslo sold. Charles P. Lawton, a druggist of New Bedford, Henry H. TUlaon, a farrier of the same town, and Nathaniel Hathawayran analytical chemist, also of this oity, testlfied regarding the keeping and tha effect of pnusie sold.
See moreSee less
Objections were made and the oourt after consultation deoided to ex clude the evidenoe of the attempted pur chases of that poison. The commonwealth then, after introduc ing exhibits, rested its ease and a reoesa for fifteen minates was taken, daring wbioh the prisoner talked earnestly with Mrs. Fessenden of Boston, the first woman who has spoken to her in the oourt room. The counsel for the defense then pre sented their side of the case, Mr. Jennings being the spokesman. After outlining the crime and the accusation attaint bis client. he said: "We shall show yon that this
After the prosecution rested, defense attorney Jennings opened for Lizzie Borden, asserting her spotless character. Witnesses testified about strange noises and an unidentified man seen near the Borden and Chagnon properties the night before the murders.
Morning Journal and Courier · 16 June 1893 · page 3
being the spokesman. After outlining the crime and the accusation attaint bis client. he said: "We shall show yon that this young woman had led a spotless life was interested in religious and ouaniaoie wore and yet for some reason the gOTeznment seems to have fastened the crime npon her " The prisoner sat with her face buried in her handkerchief during her counsel's slea. - ' When he had oloaed his address alary Cbtguon was called as the first witness for the defense. She testified that milo'ciock on the night before the murder shs heard a noise like the pounding or.
See moreSee less
wood in the dl reotion of the Borden fence, oontinued for five minutes. C roes-examined by Mr. Enowlton aha said that the noise seemed to oome from that direction, bnt the windows were oloaed and she made no investigation, Mrs. CJhsgnon confirmed her stepdaugh ter's testimony about the noise, and on be ing cross-examined, said that at first she thought it sounded like a dog. John w.urouard testified that he painted the Borden house in May, 1892, and he thought that the prisoner was in the vicin
Trial testimony recounts various witnesses who saw unidentified men near the Borden property before and after the murder, including a man sleeping on steps the night before and strangers in the yard and barn afterward. Other witnesses testify about the accessibility of doors and barn areas, suggesting alternative suspects or opportunities for others to have committed the crime.
Morning Journal and Courier · 16 June 1893 · page 3
was at the barn on the morning Andrew J. Borden was murdered; about 11 o clock I saw a carriage, an open box buggy, stand ing by a tree near the Borden house; there was a man in the carriage; I never saw the man or the carriage before; this was short ly before 11 o'olook or 10:50. Dr. uanay or cau iuver teetined to passing the Borden honse at 9 and 10:30 a. m. on the morning of the-marder; saw a medium-sized young man, very pale, walk ing slowly along.
See moreSee less
He was well dressed in a light suit; he was acting strangely; he seemed to be weak and had an intensely agitated expression on his face; witness thought he had seen the man before and had tried to find him, bat was unauooess fal. Delia MaMey, who Uvea on Second street, testified to seeing a young man dressed in light clothes standing in the Borden gateway about 9.40 a. m. on the morning of the murder; never saw htm before and noticed nothing about his ap pearance. Jerome T. Borden testified that be entered the Borden front door without diMculty the day after the murder. Walter if. Stevens, a local reporter, tes tified that he went into the Borden barn Bhortly after the murder; heard people walking in the loft; Medley was in the en try of the bouse, and witness did not see Fleet in the barn; made a thorough searoh of the yard without result;! before going to the barn tried tne cellar aoor and found it looked. Alfred Clarkson testified to seeing three men in the barn shortly after 11:30, but neither Medley nor Fleet was among them. Simon Roblnskt, ice cream peddler, testified that he kept bis horse on Second etreet, opposite the Borden house, and left the stable at 11:03 on the day of the murder. He saw a lady with a dark colored dress on coming from the barn; she had nothing on her head, and was walking slowly toward the house; had seen the ser vant a few weeks before and sold her toe oream; this was not the servant, uross examlsation failed to ohange the evidenoe. Charles D. Uardlner, stablekeeper, testi fied that Bobinski took his team out five or ten minutes past eleven that day; wit ness drove oat ten minutes later than Bo binski; did not know anything about the trouble at the Borden house and did not look toward it: saw Ra porter Manning run ning up the street. Charles B. Newhall of Worcester, who was in Gardiner's car riage corroborated Mr. uanuner. Kverett Brown testified to being at the Borden
A roundup of national and world news items for the week includes a brief note that the evidence against Lizzie Borden presented on the third day of her trial was weak. The item appears alongside unrelated news such as the Columbian Liberty bell casting and the Ohio Republican convention.
The Willimantic Journal · 16 June 1893 · page 8
NEWS OF THE WEEK, Thursday, Jane 8. The Columbian Liberty bell was cast at Troy, N. Y.-The evidence against Lizzie Borden on the third day of the trial was weak-Animal Dealer Bums of New
A newspaper commentary analyzes the murder trial, noting that testimony about Lizzie Borden's alleged attempt to buy prussic acid before the killings is the most damaging evidence yet presented by the prosecution. The piece argues that without this testimony the case against her would have been weak, but acknowledges the defense has not yet been heard.
The Morning Call · 16 June 1893 · page 6
DID LIZZIE BORDEN KILL HER FATHER? Tbe evidence of the drug clerk who tes tified that Lizzie Borden tried to buy prus sic acid ol him before the murder of her
The piece argues the Borden murders are uniquely baffling because the killer had only minutes to act in broad daylight, unlike other infamous cases such as Bierdell, Colt, and Webster-Parkman. It muses that if Lizzie is guilty she must be a rare phenomenon of self-control, and if a burglar did it, his clean escape is remarkable.
The Morning Call · 16 June 1893 · page 6
DID LIZZIE BORDEN KILL HER
In the Webster-Parkman murder, also, the crime was committed in the daytime, but it was done in the seclusion of a labor atory, which was kept securely locked, and in which hammering constantly took I place. It will be noted that these differ from the Borden case, in that the assassin had plenty of time to deal with the corpse after the deed, whereas the murderer of the Bordens had only a few minutes to prepare for discovery. If Lizzie Burden is a parricide, it must be assumed that she is one of those phe nomenal monsters whose nerves and muscles are under absolute control.
See moreSee less
She must have brooded over the prospect of being disinherited until her mind became ; unbalanced and her consciousness of right i and wrong destroyed. We are told that j she wus a devout church member; if she killed her father she must have become a religious enthusiast shaped in the type the cast-iron devotees of the old days who thought that the killing of a heretic would be grateful to God. If, on the other hand, the Bordens were killed by a wandering burglar who took life in order to capture ; property, the murderer's flight, without , leaving any trace, is oue of the most re markable escapes on record.
The Wilmington Daily Republican · Wilmington, Del.
A boy named Potter found a rusted hatchet in John Crowe's barn near the Borden property while looking for a ball. Traces of gilt under the rust suggested the hatchet may once have been an ornament rather than a weapon.
The Wilmington Daily Republican · 16 June 1893 · page 1
HATCHET FOUND.
The words of this article could not be separated from the rest of its page. Read it in the clipping.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
The Wilmington Daily Republican · Wilmington, Del.
On the tenth day of Lizzie Borden's murder trial, the court ruled testimony about an alleged attempted purchase of prussic acid inadmissible, ending that line of evidence. The defense then began its case, with attorney Jennings arguing for the presumption of innocence and warning jurors about the dangers of relying on circumstantial evidence.
The Wilmington Daily Republican · 16 June 1893 · page 1
ARGUMENT OF LAWYER JENNINGS.
tempted purchase of the poison on Miss Borden the court decided that the evi dence was incompetent. This ends the prussic acid incident. Then the defense began its case, with Mr. Jennings us spokesman. Ho said la part: ✓ "Wo shall show you that this young hail led a spotless life; Interested In religious and charitable work, and yet for
The Wilmington Daily Republican · Wilmington, Del.
Defense attorney Jennings argues the prosecution's case rests entirely on circumstantial evidence with no direct testimony linking Lizzie Borden to the crime, and questions the motive theory. He previews defense evidence about the burned dress, her presence in the barn, and lack of blood on her clothing, after which Dr. Benjamin Hardy begins testifying.
The Wilmington Daily Republican · 16 June 1893 · page 1
ARGUMENT OF LAWYER JENNINGS.
is not one particle of direct evidence against Lizzie Borden to connect her with this crime; it is wholly and absolutely circum stantial, and there is no class of evidenco known that, under certain circumstances, is as dangerous as evidence of this nature. "You will find that a motive j of the links in the chain of circumstantial evidence becomes of tremendous impor 6luce. The government's chain is that whoever killed one killed the other, and where they have assumed to show a tive for the killing of her stepmother, there is for tho killing of her o father. In measuring tho motive you have
The prosecution rested and Mr. Jennings began Lizzie Borden's defense, promising to prove her barn story and paint-stained dress account were true while discrediting police testimony. The correspondent notes the defense evidence held up well under cross-examination, suggesting growing confidence in her innocence.
New-York Tribune · 16 June 1893 · page 1
* ANOTHER BLOW FOR THE STATE (FROM ASTAFF CORR ESPONDEXT OF THE TRIBUNE,) New-Bedford, Miss, June 15.—The tenth day of Lizzie Borden's trial has ended, and has prob. ably brought her close to the day of vindication and liberty. The proseention rested this morning, and the | defence began promptly. Mr. Jennings opened with the startling statement that he intended to prove that Lizzie Borden's story abont going to ihe barn was true; that her story ahont the dress che burned having paint on it was true: and that lie intended to prove the falsity of a good deal of the evidence miven in behalf of the Common.
See moreSee less
wealth by the police officers. Much of this promise was redeemed before the session closed. Mayterious as is the whole affair, including the prisoner's behavior, it begins to look as if she not only might be, but must be, innocent. It cannot be said that Mr. Jennings's evidence was precisely ronclusive, but its tendency to prove innocence was strong. It seemed trustworthy, and it stood solid and upright against a eross-examination admirably adapted ty break it to pieces had it been flimsy or fraudulent, MISS BORDEN MOVED TO TEARS,
The report describes Lizzie Borden's near-total isolation from other women at the trial, noting hostility especially after Professor Wood testified no blood was found on tested objects. It then describes three Fall River friends who finally greeted her warmly, alongside vivid scene-setting of the courthouse grounds and a note that prussic-acid evidence was ruled inadmissible.
New-York Tribune · 16 June 1893 · page 1
WELCOMING FALL RIVER WOMEN. To-day at noon three women came forward from the audience and spoke to” Miss Borden. Even they were not strangers, moved by a kind and generons impulse. They were friends who had "known her in Fall River. But they were mightily welcome, She talked with them long, and seemed | to draw keen enjoyment from their presence and from the consolatory looks they gave to her. On Monday she came into the courtroom with a little | tunel of white and red pinks, They were the | only flowers she has had since the trial began.
See moreSee less
| Everything was bright to-day around the hande some little building where the trial goes on. The sun moved brilliantly through a sloudless sky. Cool winds from the water blew over the town, tempering the heat and giving vivaeity and brizhtness to nature of every kind. They were cutting the grass on the courthouse lawn, and as
This roundup of the day's news briefly reports that the prosecution rested its case in the Lizzie Borden trial at New Bedford, and the defense began with an opening speech by Mr. Jennings. It also covers unrelated foreign and domestic news items from the same day.
New-York Tribune · 16 June 1893 · page 6
THE NEWS THIS MORNING.
Germany passed oft quietly: reballots will be necessary in many districts, === The oficial bulletin says President Carnot’s condition 13 slightly improved: it is believed in Paris that his illness is serious. Sir Lichard Webster continued his mgument before the Behring Sea Court. Domestic.—The attendance at the Fair yestoerday, German Day, exceeded that of any other fete day since the opening of the Bxposition; the German Building was dedicated with appropriate exercises, ———= Commencement exercises were held at Cornell University and other institutions, —== The prosecution rested and the defence began in the trial of Lizzie Borden, at New-Bedford ; Mr.
See moreSee less
Jennings made the opening speech for the prisoner. Royal Phelps Carroll's new vacht, the Navaloe, was towed into Boston Harbor disabled by collision with a pilot boat. === Several persons were killed and considerable damage to property was done by lightning in the West, === The leirs of Jay Gould will contest in court the payment of £250,000 inheritance tax iu addition to the £500,000 already paid.
The prosecution rested its case in the Borden trial and the defense began, with the editorial opining that the prosecution's case was weak. It also notes allegations that Fall River police may have conspired to prove Lizzie Borden guilty, suggesting this deserves investigation if she is acquitted.
New-York Tribune · 16 June 1893 · page 6
has a large German population, and the Fatherland is admirably well represent:d in every department of the big show henen it is not surprising that Germany “came out strong” on the day specially set apart in its honor. The crowds were immense, and all the exercises, in which the enthusiastic Germans took part with true Teutonic enthusiasm, were brilliantly succossful. There will be other great days at the Fair. but German Day will maintain a high yank among the festival cccasions which the Fair managers are bound to cncourage by every means in their power.
See moreSee less
——e The prosecution in the Borden trial closed its case vesterday and the defence was begun. No candid and raticnal person, whatever his former or present belief regarding the matter, can say that the prosecutions case is a strong one: and if the defence fulfils the pronises made in Mr. Jennings's opening address, the duty of the jury when they retire for deliberation will be quickly and casily performed. Tt is strongly intimat-d by our correspondent that a conspiracy was entered into by the Fall River police to prove Lizzie Borden guilty of the unnatural crimes of which she stands accused. If the tiial results in the way that now serm: altogether probable, it may be the duty either of the State or Deal” anthorities to make a searching investigation en this point. These police officers scem to have made up their minds at the outset, and then to have sought for facts that would support their view the case.
The passage notes that Massachusetts court custom requires witnesses in the Borden trial to stand while testifying, a practice the writer calls strange and even cruel. The editorial argues this rule, applied regardless of gender, serves no clear purpose and should be relaxed on humanitarian grounds.
New-York Tribune · 16 June 1893 · page 6
— One feature of the Borden trial cannot but impress all familiar with the prevailing custom in this State as strange and even cruel, namely, the requirement that witnesses Hust stand while testifying—a rule which seems to he enforced impartially in the cases of both men and women, though undoubtedly a relaxation of it would be granted hy the Court in case of feeble persons. It is hard to pes what can be gained by the course pursued, which must necessarily be exwearisome in cases where witnesses are cordingly kept under examination a long time.
See moreSee less
No lawyer in this State would say that the course of justices has ever been interfered with hy allowing wit. nesses to sit when in the witness-box. The Massachusetts practice has come down from Aan earlier generation. (Considerations of humanity would lead to a change, and the ends of justice would be equally well subserved.
The judge barred testimony about prussic acid, Lizzie's inquest statements, and a friend's account of her unhappy home, dealing three blows to the prosecution. Defense witnesses contradicted police officers Fleet and Mullaly over details of finding the hatchet handle, raising the specter of police perjury.
New-York Tribune · 16 June 1893 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
THREE SEVERE SETBACKS FOR THE STATE.
BEGINNING HER DEFENCE.
BORDEN PROSECUTION RESTS.
See moreSee less
MR. JENNINGS STATES THE CASE FOR HIS CLIENT.
PROMISING TO SHOW THAT HER STORY ABOUT VISITING THE BARN IS TRUE—STRONG EVIDENCE TO PROVE IT INTRODUCED—ANOTHER BLOW FOR THE STATE.
(FROM A STAFF CORRESPONDENT OF THE TRIBUNE.)
New-Bedford, Mass., June 15.—The tenth day of Lizzie Borden's trial has ended, and has probably brought her close to the day of vindication and liberty.
The prosecution rested this morning, and the defence began promptly. Mr. Jennings opened with the startling statement that he intended to prove that Lizzie Borden's story about going to the barn was true; that her story about the dress she burned having paint on it was true; and that he intended to prove the falsity of a good deal of the evidence given in behalf of the Commonwealth by the police officers. Much of this promise was redeemed before the session closed. Mysterious as is the whole affair, including the prisoner's behavior, it begins to look as if she not only might be, but must be, innocent. It cannot be said that Mr. Jennings's evidence was precisely conclusive, but its tendency to prove innocence was strong. It seemed trustworthy, and it stood solid and upright against a cross-examination admirably adapted to break it to pieces had it been flimsy or fraudulent.
MISS BORDEN MOVED TO TEARS.
Somehow or other, the prisoner at the bar has not seemed greatly moved by the feeling of hope and almost confidence which the results of the day might well have inspired. She yielded slowly to the heavy strain to which the prosecution's story, with its accompanying theatrical properties, its axes and hatchets, its skulls and plaster casts, and its long-drawn-out and dreadful details of blood and horror, subjected her. She revives as slowly as she yielded. Many amusing situations developed during the day, but they did not amuse the prisoner. She sat through everything, except the speech of her counsel, stolid and depressed. As he talked and told of his intimate relations with her father and with her; as he told of the home she had lived in, and of what she had been to it and in it; as he described her love for her father, her care for him in his old age, the interest she took in his affairs, and the aid she gave to him, and as he drew the utterly sad picture of the position she is now placed in, she buried her face in her handkerchief and cried heartily.
During the recess of the court at noon, for the first time in these long and terrible ten days, one of her own sex was seen to speak to her. It is difficult to account for the hostile attitude in which even yet the women who attend this trial stand toward the prisoner. If ever there were an object entitled to pity and commiseration, it is she. At no time has her guilt seemed inevitable; at no time have the presumptions of innocence proceeding from human nature and from her history as a woman and a daughter been overcome. Her homeliness is by no means that which a coarse or cruel nature would be apt to impart.
So far as outward appearances tell any story they show only a poor wretched woman, borne down with the weight of an accusation than which in all the record of crime there is none more horrible. They show a woman of refinement, whose manner and bearing from the moment she took her seat in the prisoners' dock until now have been most exemplary. There has not been a look or a gesture, a word or an attitude suggestive of the qualities which she must possess, not vaguely or in small measure, but developed in an abnormal and hideous degree, if she is the deplorable creature charged by the State. Her very grief and unhappiness, keen beyond comparison, and deep beyond sounding, have been expressed only because nature could not bear the burden this trial has imposed. They have been displayed despite a superhuman effort to hold them in subjection.
And yet, with all this in her favor, not a woman in New-Bedford has given so much as a kind look to her. Not one has offered to shake her hand or to speak in her ear a single word of consolation or hope. Her isolation has been complete. The feeling of her sex against her is so positive and manifest that women in the courtroom actually look disappointed when a witness says anything to her advantage. When Professor Wood concluded the statement of his examination of each of the objects sent to him to be tested for blood with the declaration that no trace of blood was to be found anywhere upon them, the women in the audience looked positively disgusted and angry. No doubt the most of them came away believing that Professor Wood was no such chemist as he has been cracked up to be.
WELCOMING FALL RIVER WOMEN.
To-day at noon three women came forward from the audience and spoke to Miss Borden. Even they were not strangers, moved by a kind and generous impulse. They were friends who had known her in Fall River. But they were mightily welcome. She talked with them long, and seemed to draw keen enjoyment from their presence and from the consolatory looks they gave to her. On Monday she came into the courtroom with a little bunch of white and red pinks. They were the only flowers she has had since the trial began.
Everything was bright to-day around the handsome little building where the trial goes on. The sun moved brilliantly through a cloudless sky. Cool winds from the water blew over the town, tempering the heat and giving vivacity and brightness to nature of every kind. They were cutting the grass on the courthouse lawn, and as the mower made its way along the wind caught up the little grass blades its knife had parted and sent them whirling all around. The sparrows from the capitals of the big Grecian columns that give so stately a front to the courthouse building came down and made little sheaves of grass, took them up to their nests above the capitals and made great sport with them there. Chasing one another in light-hearted frolic, they flew into the arching elms, they dashed into the flower plots, giving screams of fun and defiance as they went. It does not take many days of such sights and sounds as have been encountered in this indescribable trial to give one a feeling of fondness for these little birds and flowers and leaves and grasses.
PRUSSIC-ACID EVIDENCE RULED OUT.
The Court decided, after all, that it would not admit the evidence of the drug clerk as to Lizzie Borden's attempt to buy some prussic acid on the night before the tragedy. The judges expressed themselves as impressed with the claim of the defence that this drug was often used for household purposes of one kind or another, and they held that the prosecution were under the necessity of proving to the contrary before the evidence would be admissible. It was not enough, they said, to show that the prisoner had that night bought something with which murder might have been committed, especially in view of the fact that it was not committed with that or with anything like it. If prussic acid was such a poison as to render its purchase by an ordinary person of itself suspicious, they thought the evidence might be brought in. The Commonwealth started out this morning with an effort to produce proof of the kind thus called for, but did not succeed to the Court's satisfaction. Their expert witnesses said that they never heard of prussic acid being used for any household purpose, but when under cross-examination they were asked to declare the properties of the poison, and to say whether, with those properties, it might not produce such an effect when used in such a way, they said, Yes, it might. The Court listened to this sort of thing for some time, and then suggested to the District-Attorney that he would better abandon the attempt to work in the prussic-acid incident. The Court looked upon it with disfavor, anyhow, and could not be reconciled to its use unless the conditions made it evidently pertinent.
THREE SEVERE SETBACKS FOR THE STATE.
The State's case has been much weakened by the Court's refusal to admit this and other bits of evidence. Its case against the prisoner required everything it possessed in the way of suggestion and information. If all had been admitted, the issue would still be extremely doubtful. The State had no resource to spare; and in the decisions declining to receive the evidence given by Miss Borden at the Coroner's inquest, together with that of Miss Anna Borden, the friend with whom Lizzie went abroad in 1890, as to Lizzie's statement that her home was an unhappy one, and excluding this prussic-acid story, the prosecution has encountered three severe blows. Their main case, as it now stands, comes from the Fall River police department. This is most unfortunate for the State, not only because the police contradicted themselves so often and on such important points, but because it has all along been felt that the police were on trial as well as Lizzie Borden. If that was true before the defence opened, it was much more true at the close of this afternoon's session. If the evidence introduced by Mr. Jennings is true—and it had all the appearances of verity—Miss Borden is in that dock as the result of a deliberate police conspiracy. If what the defendant's witnesses have sworn to commands belief, Assistant Marshal Fleet and Officer Medley are perjurers; and if there is a particle of police perjury in the prosecution's case it tumbles to the ground in a heap. It is purely circumstantial, anyhow, and unless it can all be depended upon, no part of it is worth considering. The position of Officer Fleet and Officer Mullaly was particularly bad when they themselves had left the stand. They swore that they were together when Fleet found the hatchet-head. Fleet swore that the handle which had been broken off close to the iron was nowhere to be seen. Mullaly swore that it was there in the box with the head it belonged to; that he handled it, and Fleet handled it, and Fleet put it back in the box. Then before Fleet and Mullaly could communicate or anybody could tell Fleet what Mullaly had said, Fleet was brought back to the witness-stand and made to repeat his statement that the handle was not there; that he did not see it or touch it.
ALLEGING A POLICE CONSPIRACY.
Mistakes, of course, are always possible, but they ought not to be possible to police officers who are swearing away a human life. And now the defence comes forward with a story which makes other parts of Fleet's testimony impossible and which convicts Mullaly of having received the information, on the very day of the tragedy, that a witness had seen Lizzie Borden, at fifteen minutes past 11, coming from the barn, where she says she had been since 11 o'clock. This looks like bad faith on the part of the police, and taken in connection with their own contradictions, evasions and undoubted blunders, it points darkly at a conspiracy. The inquiry has arisen already in every rational mind whether these policemen, having failed to catch the real murderer, have not deliberately put away clews that they might have successfully followed and deliberately ignored facts which spoke for Miss Borden's innocence, and whether they have not done something even worse than this. If they have, there ought to be a day of reckoning for Mr. Fleet and Mr. Medley and Mr. Mullaly. If the promotions and increased salaries which all these fine detectives have secured since they put Lizzie Borden into prison are the fruit of perjury and of a league among themselves to hunt an innocent woman to her death, there is no punishment possible under the law too severe for them. The point is already reached where that jury has got to decide between witnesses who can have no possible motive for false swearing, and whose testimony is firm and reasonable, and in many respects corroborated, and the evidence given by these policemen. For what they said the policemen have a motive. It is the motive of hiding their own stupidity and of finding a victim for public clamor and a claim on their own part for public reward.
There should be a suspension of judgment, of course, until the case is closed; but the present situation justifies watchfulness and suspicion. Since it seems to be the habit in Fall River for persons in authority to carry around warrants in their pockets to be used in their discretion, it might be well for some competent person to get out a warrant for a few of these policemen. It might be well for Mayor Coughlin to advise them, as he took so much pains to advise Lizzie Borden, not to go out of their houses for the present. It might be well for him to place some trusty minions armed with these warrants all around their houses and to keep watch on them day and night. If that kind of thing was justifiable procedure against a girl suspected of murder, it is justifiable against men who are suspected of false swearing against her life.
The report highlights contradictory testimony from officers Fleet and Mullaly about whether a hatchet handle was found with the head at the Borden crime scene. It suggests the inconsistencies, combined with evidence that police suppressed information favorable to Lizzie Borden, point to a possible conspiracy to frame her while covering up their own investigative failures.
New-York Tribune · 16 June 1893 · page 2
ALLEGING A POLICE CONSPIRACY. Mistakes, of course, are always possible, but they ought not to be possible to police officers who are swearing away a human life. And now the “defence comes forward with a story which makes other parte of Fleet's testimony . impossible and which convicts Mnullaly of having received the information, on the very day of the tragedy, that 8 witness had seen Lizzie Borden, at fifteen minutes past 11, coming from the barn, where she gays she had been since 11 o'clock. This looks like bad faith on the part of the police, antl taken in connection with their own aontradietions, evasions and untoubted blunders, it pointa darkly at a conspiracy.
See moreSee less
The inquiry has arisen already in very rational mind whether these policemen, | having failed to catch the real murderer, have not deliberately put away clews that they might have successfully followed and deliberately ignored facts which spoke for Miss Borden’s innocence, and whether they have not done something even worse than this. If they have, there ought to be a day of reckoning for Mr, Fleet and Mr. Medley and Mr. Mullaly. If the promotions and increased salaries which all these fine detectives have secured since thev put Lizzie Borden into prison are the fruit of perjury and .of a league among themselves to hunt an innocent woman to her death, there is no punishment possible und r the law too severe for them. The point is already reached where that jury has got to decide between witnesses who can have no possible motive for false swearing, and whose testimony is iim and reasonable, and in many respects corroborated, end the evidence given by these policemen. For what they said the policemen have a motive. 1t is the motive of hiding their own stupidity and of finding a victim for public clamor and a claim
An editorial argues that if Lizzie Borden's prosecution rests on perjured police testimony, the officers deserve the same suspicion once directed at her. A separate dispatch reports the Commonwealth's case has closed, weakened by contested admission of drug-clerk testimony about an alleged prussic acid purchase.
New-York Tribune · 16 June 1893 · page 2
ALLEGING A POLICE CONSPIRACY
LAST EVIDENCE AND EXHIBITS INTRODUCED BY THE PROSECUTION’'S LAWYERS. New-Bedford, Mass.,, June 15.—The case of the Commonwealth ended, from the dramatic pint of view, unfortunately. It is a mistake for an attorney to reserve a piece of evidence the admissibility of which he himself has doubts of to the last of his case, because after having contended for it and being finally beaten, his statement that there hic case rosts has all the appearance of a collapse. The State's case has not collapsed, unless it turns out that its police witnesses have been engaged in a monstrous plot, Bat it was weakened by the occurrences of this morning.
See moreSee less
When court adjourned last night the judges bad decided to receive the drug clerk's evidence about Lizzie Borden's attempted purchase of prassic acld
A jury having been secured, the trial of Lizzie Borden for the murder of her father and stepmother began at New Bedford with the prosecution's opening statement. Court then adjourned so the jury could visit the scene of the killings in Fall River.
The Jasper Weekly Courier · 16 June 1893 · page 6
PERSONAL AND GENERAL.
Chicago savings banks, on the 6th, but none of the national banks were af fected. A j cry having been secured, the trial of Miss Lizzie Borden for the alleged
On the tenth day of the Lizzie Borden trial, defense witnesses testified to seeing a stranger near the Borden house and hearing persons in the barn loft, while druggists testified about prussic acid's uses. The justices ultimately excluded all prosecution evidence regarding Borden's alleged attempts to purchase prussic acid.
The Indianapolis Journal · 16 June 1893 · page 4
New Bedford, Mass., June 15. The tenth day of the Borden murder trial opened hot, with a big crowd in attend ance. Miss Borden was overwhelmed with
Defense counsel Jennings argues the prosecution has shown no direct evidence linking Lizzie Borden to the murders, only circumstantial evidence, and claims no motive existed for killing her father. He asserts others were present at the property during the murders and that the burned dress was stained with paint, not blood, unrelated to the crime.
The Indianapolis Journal · 16 June 1893 · page 4
1 want to say that there is not ono particle of di rect testimony ajralnst Lizzie Borden lo connect her with tbis crime; it is wholly aud absolutely
Defense attorney Jennings argues in his opening statement that the barn was accessible to others and that Lizzie's dress was stained with paint, not blood. Witnesses for the defense then testify about strange men seen near the Borden house before and on the day of the murders.
The Indianapolis Journal · 16 June 1893 · page 4
Martha Chagnon, a pleasant little French girl, was the first witness for the defense, tihe is a daughter of Dr. Chagnon, whose yurd is iu the rearof the Borden yard. On the night preceding tho Borden murder. (he eaid she heard a doiko at about 11 o'clock at night. It sounded like pounding ou the Borden fence, and lasted about live minutes. Martha's mother coniistned her daughter's evidence, but the purpose of their testimony was not discovered.
A roundup of short news items from around the country includes one line noting that Thursday's testimony in the Borden trial produced nothing startling. The rest of the item covers unrelated news such as accidents, drownings, strikes, and civic events.
The Goodland Republic · 16 June 1893 · page 1
BOILED DOWN.
Nothing of a startling nature was de veloped by the evidence in the Borden trial Thursday. The Traveling Men's Protective associa tion elected officers at Thursday's session. The Knight of Honor, in session at Mil waukee, elected their supreme officers by acclamation. William Myre, 12 years old, was drowned in a mill pond Friday night near Menom inee, Mich.
A short news digest item mentions that Lizzie Borden's friends feel confident of acquittal based on evidence presented so far at her murder trial in Massachusetts. The item is part of a roundup of miscellaneous national news briefs.
The Goodland Republic · 16 June 1893 · page 1
Monday, June 12. Princess Eulalia spent Monday at the t"r, going in the morning and remaining flttil late in the afternoon. president Cleveland granted pardons Monday to a number of lawbreakers. The friends of Lizzie Borden, who is now on trial for murder in Massachusetts, feel quite confident of acquittal on the evidence so far submitted. Mrs. E. F. Holmes, whose husband was killed in a collision between a Northwest ern train and an electric motor in Council Bluffs, has sued the street car company for $20,000 damages. The patriotic citizens of Alton, Ilia., Sunday, decorated the grave of the anti slave martyr, Owen Love joy.
See moreSee less
The Clevelands will propably summer Buzzard's Bay. Mrs. Cleveland is desirous of taking Ruth therebefore the heated term begins in Washington. Baron A. de Sickler's bay colt Ragotoky
On the tenth day of the trial, the prosecution rested its case after failing to introduce evidence that Lizzie Borden tried to buy prussic acid. The defense then opened, with attorney Jennings outlining plans to show her previous good character, lack of motive, and that others had access to the crime scene.
The Wichita Daily Eagle · 16 June 1893 · page 2
THE STATE RESTS ITS CASE AND THE DEFENSE OPENS
New Be. "i:i), Mass.. June 15. The - tenth day ol the UoidearrI.it opened with a big attendance. -Miss Borden was over whelmed this morning with floral offer ing and appeared in excellent spirits. The prosecution attempted lo introduce evidence that Lizzie Borden had attempt
Defense attorney Jennings argues the murder weapon was never tied to Lizzie, opportunity was not exclusive, and no motive existed for killing her father. Witnesses testify to noises, a buggy, and strange men seen near the Borden house around the time of the murders.
The Wichita Daily Eagle · 16 June 1893 · page 2
THE DEFENSE OPENS
taiurder. On the subJBct of circumstantial evi dence, Mr. Jennings addressed the jury thus: "You are not to say how this mys terious murder whs committed, but to say by whom. You are simply to answer as to tliis defendant to say you aie satisfied beyond a teasonable doubt that she is utnlty or innocent, and a reasonable doubt is a doubt for winch you cm furnish a good reason. There is not one particle of direct testimony against Lizzie Borden to connect her with this crime. It is wholly
Springfield Weekly Republican · Springfield, Mass.
At the New Bedford trial, counsel argued over whether Lizzie Borden's inquest testimony, given under suspicion but before arrest, should be admitted as evidence. The prosecution cited precedent for admitting voluntary statements, while the defense argued it was not truly voluntary since she lacked counsel and proper caution.
Springfield Weekly Republican · 16 June 1893 · page 4
THE DEVELOPMENTS THIS WEEK IN THE BORDEN MURDER TRIAL
InqurM Tealim««) Excluded The Court I>ecide« Akriunl It. Most of the morning in the Borden trial at New Bedford Monday was occupied with the argument of counsel ami the de
Springfield Weekly Republican · Springfield, Mass.
The court ruled that Lizzie Borden's earlier statements were made while effectively under arrest and thus inadmissible, a decision seen as weakening the prosecution's case. Medical examiners Dedrick and Dolan then testified about the autopsies, offering opinions on the sequence of the murders and undergoing cross-examination.
Springfield Weekly Republican · 16 June 1893 · page 4
Borden died first. Patrolman Hyde testi fied that while stationed outside the Bor den house the night after the murder he saw the prisoner and Miss Russell go down cellar to the water-closet and sink with a pail, and the prisoner go there again later alone. Cross-examination only brought out the fact that they carried a light and made no concealment of their actions. In the afternoon records were admitted showing the dates of the death of Mr Borden's first wife, his marriage to the second wife, and birth of the pris oner.
See moreSee less
Mr Knowlton then conducted the direct examination of Medical Examiner Dolan, who described the autopsies and examination of the blood spots, and gave his opinion that Mrs Borden died an hour to and hour and a half before her hus band. Mr Adams cross-examined the wit ness rigidly with reference to the Oak Grove cemetery autopsy. The cross-ex amination was not concluded when the court adjourned. Testimony of Wv Willinm A. Rolan, the Medical ExaminerDr William A. Dolan said he had been a practicing physician for 11 years;he was a medical examiner for Bristol county. I had been in the Borden house 10 or 15 minutes on the day of the murder when the city hall clock struck 12. I first saw Mr Sawyer, then Dr Bowen. Bridger Sul livan and Mr Morse, also Miss Russell and Mrs Churchill. Officers Allen. Mullaly and Doherty were there. 1 had a little talk with Lizzie Borden that morning; she was in her room. I asked her about that note and •,e said Mrs Borden hml re
Springfield Weekly Republican · Springfield, Mass.
A police witness testifies about arriving at the Borden house, finding Mr. Borden's body on the sofa still warm with oozing blood, and later finding Mrs. Borden's colder body upstairs with a bloody handkerchief nearby. He also describes collecting evidence including a carpet sample, milk for analysis, and discovering axes and hatchets in the cellar.
Springfield Weekly Republican · 16 June 1893 · page 4
of the body Continuing, he said: I got Mr Kieran to take some measurements for me, some time after: I noticed the blood was coagulated. Mrs Borden was lying more upon the left side of her face, so as to expose the rear of the right back of the head. There I found a handker chief (the same already shown!. It was an old one of silk and was bloody: it was near her head: I didn’t take the handker chief, but it was buried with the rest of the clothes.
See moreSee less
I was only there two or three minutes at that time. I had a thermom eter with me, but I did not use it. I found the temperature of Mr Borden to be very high. I learned this from the hands; at that time the blood was dripping in two places down the head of the sofa; there was no blood on top of the carpet, but it had soaked in; I saw no coagulated blood on Mr Borden. I touched the body of Mrs Borden and it was much colder than Mr Borden's. I afterward removed some of rhe carpet from under rhe sofa where Mr Borden lay. (Piece shown.) I recognized this piece of carpet (here shown) this was under Mrs Borden; (the piece was about 1(4 feet square and was black with blood). 1 made an examina tion of Mr Borden's wounds, and found there seemed to be from 8 to 10 wounds. I Here witness described the clothes of Mr Borden and also what valuables he had about him). In his pocket-book witness found $81.50 in money, the greater part of It bills; the odd cents in silver: watch and chain were in their usual place. There was a ring on his finger. Witness collected a sample of the morn ing's milk, in consequent of what was told him and afterward analyzed it. Continuing, he said: Then 1 went into the cellar and found some axes and hatchets. I saw one. a clawhammer, which appeared to have been scraped. It was | 12.30 or thereabouts that day when I first 1 saw those axes. I went away and went
Springfield Weekly Republican · Springfield, Mass.
A court ruling favored the prosecution on an evidence question, and testimony resumed with dressmaker Hannah Gifford recounting Lizzie's harsh words about her stepmother, and police matron Hannah Reagan describing a quarrel between Lizzie and her sister Emma in jail where Lizzie accused Emma of 'giving her away.' The defense also scored a point suggesting an outside assassin could have slipped past witnesses near the house on the murder day.
Springfield Weekly Republican · 16 June 1893 · page 5
Mias llorden mid Hrr Dreasninker. Mrs Hannah H. Gifford of Fall River waid: I live at 29 Franklin street, and am a manufacturer of ladies'outside garments, il have made cloaks for the Bordens. I Imade a sack for Lizzie Borden last spring, J had a talk with her about her stepmother. I think in March, 1892. (Lizzie here put tier fan over her face.) Gov Robinson ob jected to witness telling the conversation • because it was too remote, but the ques tion was put, exceptions being taken. I [Spoke, witness said, and called Mrs Bor fden "mother.’’ She said, “Don’t call her Another, she is only my stepmother, and [she is a mean, hateful old thing.” 1 said, r'Oh, Lizzie, don’t say that,” and then she eaid that she always kept apart from her land ate her meals alone.
See moreSee less
The eross-exam jination developed nothing of interest. Jlntrou Rt*ugau’» Story.
Springfield Weekly Republican · Springfield, Mass.
Mrs. Reagan describes the scene in Lizzie's room with Emma and Mr. Jennings, recounting the egg anecdote and denying she ever disavowed her story of a quarrel between the sisters. She is cross-examined about a statement prepared by Mr. Buck denying the quarrel occurred, which she refused to sign.
Springfield Weekly Republican · 16 June 1893 · page 5
'11:1111 were there or not. I<know that Miss Borden looked more excited when you left the room than she did before. 1" do re member something about an egg that [same afternoon; it was over the fact that ,1 said an egg could be broken one way
Springfield Weekly Republican · Springfield, Mass.
The preliminary hearing for Carreiro in the Manchester murder case has been delayed, with supporters raising funds and protesting his confinement in a drunkard's cell. The Portuguese consul intervened, securing lawyers and visiting the prisoner, while police defended their handling of suspects by referencing public criticism from the Borden case.
Springfield Weekly Republican · 16 June 1893 · page 5
THE MANCHESTER MURDER CASE. Carreiro’s Friends Indignant at His Treatment. The preliminary hearing in the Man chester case is set for this week, but it will probably be continued, neither side being ready for trial. The friends of Carreiro are actively working in his behalf, and subscription books to raise funds have been distributed in Fall River. New Bed ford and Taunton. Unfavorable comment is passed upon the manner in which Car reiro is imprisoned. He occupies an ordin ary drunkard’s cell in the central station, which practically has no accommodations for a long term of confinement.
See moreSee less
The police are much exercised over the criti cism, and say they made an especial de parture from the ordinary manner of using a suspect in the Borden ease on account of public sentiment and the general howl from the press of the country. In return they have been maligned and con demned. They say now they will treat Carreiro as a suspect should be treated. He shall have all the privileges within the requirements of the law, no more, no less. The prisoner's condition has been reported to Viscount Vaille de Costa. Portuguese consul at Boston, Carreiro being a sub ject of Portugal. Wednesday the consul arrived in Fall River and secured the ser vices of Lawyers Swift and Grimes. The consul, Mr Swift and Rev Mr Percal were granted permission to see the prisoner, and were closeted with Carreiro in his cell at the central station in the afternoon. The consul is said to have engaged a prominent 80-ton lawyer and Mr de Terra of New Bedford to conduct the prisoner's ease.
Springfield Weekly Republican · Springfield, Mass.
Rev John Schofield, who has known Lizzie Borden since childhood, tells a reporter he believes she is innocent. He criticizes the Fall River police, particularly Assistant Marshal Fleet, for contradictory testimony about the hatchet and accuses them of bias toward conviction.
Springfield Weekly Republican · 16 June 1893 · page 7
A Clergyman Who Firmly Believe* in Iler Innocence. Rev John Schofield of Braddocks, Pa., a former resident of Fall River, who has known Lizzie Borden ever since she was nine years old, stated Sunday to a re porter that he would as soon accuse his own daughter of the crime for which Lizzie Borden is now standing trial as believe Lizzie is guilty. Mr Schofield fur ther said: "The testimony in the case seems to benefit rather than injure Lizzie Borden’s case. When Fleet testified that he found that hatchet without the handle, and the officer who was with him at the time swore that the handle was in the hatchet at the time Fleet picked it up.
See moreSee less
and that Fleet took possession of it handle and all. the impression made upon the jury could not be otherwise than favorable to Lizzie’s cause. I also have some knowledge of persons living in Fall River, and know Assistant Marshal Fleet too well to have any confidence in any statement he would make. There are some other persons connected with the police department of Fall River who are no more truthful than Fleet. It is my opinion that the police were too hasty in forming a theory concerning the awful tragedy, but now that they have charged Lizzie Borden with the crime, they are working solely for her conviction, with out a single thought of justice.”
The report describes the ongoing Lizzie Borden murder trial in New Bedford, Massachusetts, as the most interesting murder case of the era, noting that circumstantial evidence has emerged against her. It states the prosecution's main argument remains that no one else could have committed the murders.
Der Deutsche Correspondent · 16 June 1893 · page 2
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
Defense counsel Jennings argues there is no direct evidence linking Lizzie Borden to the hatchet or the murders, calling it a purely circumstantial case. He cites a past wrongful conviction overturned by confession, and attacks the prosecution's shifting claims about the murder weapon.
The Portland Daily Press · 16 June 1893 · page 1
“It isn’t for you, gentlemen, to unrav el this mystery; it isn’t for you to find how this muraer was committed. It is for you to say, have they furnished the proof that Lizzie Andrew Borden com mitted this deed?” was the earnest ad juration Of the manifestly deeply stirred counsel. With cutting sarcasm Hr. Jennings dwelt on the faot of that claw hammer head hatchet which Dr. Dolan felt so sure did these murders, that he felt sure he found the imprint of that claw-head in the top of the old Mr.
See moreSee less
Borden’s head. And now “ that hatchet has disappeared from the case, disappeared, and a new hatchet is substituted. Yet that hatchet was not put in until after Prof. Wood had declared on that glorious morning in Fall Biver that there was neither blood nor human hair upon the hatchet head.” He strongly emphasized the fact that nobody saw old Andrew J. Borden go down the street that morning of the 4th
The defence counsel argues the burned dress was not the murder garment, disputes exclusive opportunity, and challenges the government's theory connecting Lizzie to both killings. Neighbor Martha Chagnon and her mother testify about hearing pounding or footstep sounds near the Borden fence the night before the murders, with Knowlton cross-examining them closely.
The Portland Daily Press · 16 June 1893 · page 1
Pretty Martha Charnon, the Bordens’ neighbor on the east, was the first wit ness. She is a charming young girl, wearing a becoming charming costume of blue, with pink cambric vest and sail or hat. Martha heard a sound as if some one pounding at about 11 o’clock. It came from the south in the direction of the Borden house, and it was the night before the murder. District Attorney Knowlton objected to Mr. Jennings asking what it sounded like, and the court sustained him. The pretty witness was confused—she could’t describe the noise, because she said “I couldn’t see it.’V But Mr, Knowl ton could not make her say that the noise came from the ice houses.
See moreSee less
It was not in that direction. Martha was sure it was not|the icemen pounding the ice. It came from the Borden fence. As she couldn’t tell what the noise sounded like Martha found herself at cross pur
Witnesses including the Chagnons, a painter, and others testified during Lizzie Borden's trial about noises heard the night before the murder, strange men seen near the Borden house, and unrelated matters like house painting. Defense attorneys used testimony to suggest an intruder or stranger may have been responsible for the murders.
The Portland Daily Press · 16 June 1893 · page 1
it was not|the icemen pounding the ice. It came from the Borden fence. As she couldn’t tell what the noise sounded like Martha found herself at cross pur foses with her counsel and retired. ast summer in Fall Biver she told the court it seemed like a man jumping over the fence. Marianne Chagnon, Martha’s mamma, remembered the noise that night before the murder; it was that of the step of a man on the Borden fence or walk. It came from the back yard. Lizzie, who gave way to tears during Mr.
See moreSee less
Jennings’s plea, brightened again as the Chagnons were called, and smiled when Mrs. Chagnon got decidedly mixed under District Attorney Knowlton’s sharply put questions. The attractive Frenchwoman, with her pleasing accent, was very prettily confused. She was not sure that the ash barrel had not made tne sound sne neara, Dut it was in a dif ferent direction. John G-rouard, a stout painter of gen erous build, testified to painting the house, and that Lizzie was around the bam where his tubs were. The material fact was brought out that old Mr. Borden told him that Lizzie was to select the color, and that he had better not mix the paint until the morning, as he wanted Lizzie to be by when it was done. Liz zie was round the next morning and tried the mixed color on the house. Mrs. Mary A. Durfee was put on-to testify to witnessing, a heated discussion between old Mr. Borden and a stranger on the Borden steps at some time near the Thanksgiving previous. Mrs. Dur fee was quite an attractive witness, in dark blue dress and velvet tocque. She placed the time finally as possibly on some date within two months prior to her sister’s death, which occurred Octo ber 27, 1892. She was going for medi oine for her. The Court ruled the evidence too re mote and excluded it, the defence saving an exception. Saw Strange Men."
This item compiles brief quotes from various newspapers around the country commenting on Lizzie Borden's trial, which had just begun after nearly ten months of her imprisonment. The quotes range from sympathetic remarks about her composure to observations about the slow pace of Massachusetts justice and the trial's extraordinary public interest.
St. Paul Daily Globe · 16 June 1893 · page 4
Saved From Drowning. James Barrows, a man who liveron the West Side flats, narrowly escaped drowning in the river yesterday through the overturning of his 3kiff. He was rowing in the middle of the current when his boat struck a snag and went over. He drifted for some distance down the river and was finally rescued by a neighbor who rowed out into the river after him. The only damage sus tained was a ducking in the muddy wat^r. THE BORDEN CASE.
On the tenth day of the Borden trial, prosecution testimony concluded after a judge excluded evidence regarding Lizzie's alleged attempt to purchase prussic acid. The defense then began calling witnesses, including some who contradicted state witnesses and reported seeing a man near the house.
St. Paul Daily Globe · 16 June 1893 · page 4
IN LIZZIE'S BEHALF,
New BEDFonD, Mass., June 15. — The tenth day of the Borden murder trial opened with a big crowd in attendance. Miss Borden was overwhelmed with
Defense lawyer Jennings argues the evidence is purely circumstantial, with no motive shown for killing her father and no weapon connected to her. He claims others were seen around the house and barn, that the burned dress was stained with paint not blood, and that she wore the same dress she described.
St. Paul Daily Globe · 16 June 1893 · page 4
IN LIZZIE'S BEHALF
ticalof direct testimony against Lizzie Andrew Borden to connect her with this crime; it is wholly and absolutely circumstantial. It is not for you to unravel the mystery of how
A brief editorial comment observes that if Lizzie Borden is guilty, she is the coldest-blooded fiend ever tried in America, but if innocent, she is enduring a torment worse than any punishment imaginable. The item is part of a miscellany column of short editorial quips on various topics.
The Helena Independent · 16 June 1893 · page 4
TWO THINGS are certain. If Lizzie Borden is guilty she is the coldest blooded fiend ever placed on trial in this country; if innocent, she is suffering an inquisition that will make punishment in another world seem like a June pic
The defense attempted to introduce testimony on Thursday that could help clear Lizzie Borden, but the prosecution objected. The court took the matter under advisement and adjourned before ruling.
The Beatrice Daily Express · 16 June 1893 · page 1
The Burden Trial. ! New Bedford, Mass., June 16.—The defense in the Borden trial attempted to introduce testimony Thursday which would go far toward clearing Lizzie ; Borden. Counsel for the prosecution i objected and the court took the matter j under advisement, adjourning court in | the meantime.
The report summarizes the prosecution's theory that Lizzie Borden had sole opportunity to kill both her father and stepmother, detailing an alleged timeline involving a change of dress, the murders, and disposal of the hatchet handle. It notes the defense has not yet been presented, giving only the state's circumstantial case.
Paper unidentified · 16 June 1893 · page 2
Boston Herald. Busy people don’t have time to read the detailed reports of the murder trial at New Bedford in which Miss Lizzie Borden is being defended against an accusation by the commonwealth of Massachusetts of having murdered her father and stepmother. This is how the case stood at the end of the trial. It is the State’s theory that Liz zie Borden had the opportunity to
The report details the State's full theory of how Lizzie Borden allegedly killed her stepmother and father, including disposing of the hatchet handle and burning her dress. It also presents Alice Russell's trial testimony about the dress-burning incident and her later warning to Lizzie.
Paper unidentified · 16 June 1893 · page 2
WEEK OF THE BORDEN TRIAL.
Mrs. Borden never left the house that forenoon. No one in the world has been found who saw her out side of it and no one has come for
The State Chronicle · Raleigh, N.C. · 16 June 1893
Paper unidentified
Alice Russell testifies that Lizzie Borden burned a paint-stained dress days after the murders and that she later questioned why Russell let her do it. Officers testify about a handle-less hatchet found in the cellar with fresh ash residue and a freshly broken handle, with conflicting accounts about a missing piece of the handle.
Paper unidentified · 16 June 1893 · page 2
WEEK OF THE BORDEN TRIAL.
After breakfest I left the lower part of the house and returned before noon. When I came back I went in the kitchen and saw Lizzie standing by the stove, Emma by the sink. Lizzie had a dress skirt, and I asked her what she was going to do with it, and Lizzie said she was going to burn it. It was all covered with paint. I said noth ing and went out. When I came in the room again Lizzie was tearing the dress. I said “I would not let anybody see me doing that,” and she stepped one step back.
See moreSee less
It was the waist she was tearing. Ido not remember about the skirt. There were no officers in the house at that time, though there were some about the premises. Bridget had left be fore that. I saw Mr. Hanscom and saw him at the Borden house on Monday and conversed with him in the parlor. In consequence of that talk I saw Lizzie and Emma in the dining room and I said “I’m afraid the worst thing you could have done was to burn that dress. I have been asked about your dresses,” and she said “Why did you let me do it?” Miss Russell’s testimony is still unsupported; but if Miss Emma Borden shall corroborate it the
The report describes the jury selection process for Lizzie Borden's trial and Assistant District Attorney Moody's opening statement, including hatchet measurements and testimony about family discord. It also recaps background details of the murders of Andrew and Abby Borden and family history.
Fisherman & Farmer · 16 June 1893 · page 3
Details of the Crime. The eldest victim of the Time was Andrew J. Borden, a capitalist of Fall River, Mass., who was seventy years old. The other vic
This report, reprinted from the Boston Herald, summarizes the evidence presented by the government during the first week of the Borden trial in New Bedford. It includes fragmentary courtroom testimony, including questioning about a handle piece matching other evidence.
The State Chronicle · 16 June 1893 · page 2
Boston Herald. read murder which Miss Lizzie Borden is being defended against an accusation by the commonwealth of Massachusetts of having murdered her father and stepmother. This is how the case stood at the end of the trial. It is the State's theory that Liz zie Borden had the opportunity to
This report lays out the State's full theory of how Lizzie Borden allegedly killed her stepmother and father, including the dress change, the hatchet handle burned in the stove, and the ash-smeared blade hidden in the cellar. It frames this as the prosecution's case against her, noting her barn-visit alibi was deemed a lie by the State.
The report covers a June 1893 session of the Borden trial, noting a smaller crowd and describing pre-trial legal arguments over admitting testimony about a man seen with a bloody hatchet. It also introduces witness Sarah R. Hart, who begins describing her knowledge of Andrew Borden and the neighborhood a decade earlier.
The Jersey City News · 16 June 1893 · page 1
A MAN IN THE GATE. The first wituess was Sarah R. Hart, Tivertoa, and she said:—“I lived in Fall River ten years ago, on or near Second street most of the time. I Knew Andrew J. Borden by sight and knew where he lived; I had a sister who lived in the Dr. Kelley house some fifteen years and I was In the habit of going there frequently. On the day of the murders I passed by Mr. Borden’s house with my sister-in law, Mrs. Manley; it was about ton miuJ utes to ten A.
See moreSee less
M.; we passed by the north gate and stopped there to spaak to my nephew who was there in a carriage, and went up to the back of his carriage. While I was there I saw a young man standing In the gateway; it was not Mr. Borden; he was resting his head on his left hand, his elbow beiug on the gate post; I was tnere five minutes and he was there when I went away; I went ;dowu to Main street and got there just in time to catch the ten o’clock car for the North; this car leaves City Hull for the North at just ten o’olock. (Here witness poiuted out ou photograph of the premises where she saw me man.) •‘The carriage, was a little|to the nortb'of the gate; I didnt notice the man as I passed by the gate, but only when I turned around.” Cross-examination:—“The carriage was between the Borden and Churchill bouses! the horse’s head was south; my nephew’s name is Ezra P. B. Manley, and 1 never noticed him as we wate walking along until he spoke to me. ThereWas nothing to obstruct my view him as I walked along, but I was busy talking with Mrs. Manley; I don’t mean to say that this man was uot standing in the gatewny before I turned, but 1 didn’t notice him. This man’s left elbow was on tbe south post, the one nearest the house. He didn’t change his Dosition that I noticed; he turned his head to look at me. I didn’t know the man.” NO BLOOD ON HE1{.
Court proceedings resume with a ruling excluding testimony about a Portuguese witness who claimed to see a man with a bloody hatchet. Witness Sarah R. Hart then testifies about seeing an unknown young man standing in the Borden's north gateway around the time of the murders.
Charles Sawyer testifies he stood guard at the Borden house and observed Lizzie Borden being tended to by Miss Russell, Mrs. Churchill, and Bridget Sullivan, noting no signs of blood on her head, hair, hands, or dress. He also describes the arrival sequence of various police officers and bystanders at the scene.
The Jersey City News · 16 June 1893 · page 1
NO BLOOD ON HE1{. Charles S. Sawyer, painter, Fall River —• i recau me uay or me cornea mur der, I was iu number 81 Second street. Air. Ricn’s shop, wheu I heard that a man had been stabbed, and 1 went out on to the street. Isaw Mr. Hall and Mis3 Russell; she was going up on tils other side ol the street aud I weut over to talk with her. I walked along with her Until 1 got to the gate of the Borden bouse when I turned around and walked nway; when I turned away I wet Officer Allen at Airs.
See moreSee less
Churchill’s gaic; I weut back with him and he pat me on guard at the side door after we had beeu iu tbe house. When 1 was in there Aliss Russel!, Mrs. Churchill, Miss Lizzie and Brigst Sullivan, were iu the kitchen; Miss Lizzie was sitting in a rock ing chair aud the others seemed to no working over her fanning her and, v»‘ biug her hands; I was close to her alrthe time. She appeared to be some what distressed. I saw no signs of blood on herhead, hair, bauds or dress: I cannot tell what, kind of a dress she had on. whether it was dark or light; after that 1 was back aud forward in the entry, aud when the
A brief dispatch from New Bedford reports that in the Lizzie Borden trial, the defense concluded presenting its case on the afternoon of June 10. No further details are given.
Paper unidentified · 16 June 1893 · page 1
The Murder Trial. New Bedford, Juno 10. In tho Lizzie Borden trial the defense rested its 'case this afternoon. War in Samoa. Washington, June 16. Secretary
The report announces the Borden murder trial concluded with a not-guilty verdict reached in under two hours. It then recaps background details of the case, including the murders of Mr. and Mrs. Borden, the suspicion against daughter Lizzie, and the timeline of her movements that morning.
The Athena Press · 16 June 1893 · page 2
THE MYSTIC BORDEN CASE
Borden. About Antf. Hit 4th, Wt, Mr. arid jrs. Borden were 'murdered in broad day light and in their own house. Theirskulls were dashed in and their heads pounded almost beyond human re semblance. Lizzie Borden, one of the daugh ters, was accused of the crime. She was of excellent social stand ing and prominent in church and charitable work; but was known not to be on very good terms with her stepmother, and it is supposed she knew of her father's intention to make a will leaving half of his property to his wife.
See moreSee less
This was supposed to have supplied the motive for the killing. Mrs. Bor den was killed, it is believed, about an hour before her husband. The time at which Mr. Borden was killed was established within a few minutes; and the only persons known to be about the house at tho time were Mr. and Mrs. Bor den, Lizzie and a servant girl The possibility of the servant's guilt was not admitted. Lizzie Borden's movements from 10:30 to 10:55 were known. Dur ing this time, her lather came home from down town.. From 10:55 to 11:10, or perhaps a few moments later, her movements were known only to herself. Dur ing that, her father was killed and his head beaten in such a way that the blood must have been snatterod all over the murderer; yet Lizzie had not a trace of blood upon her pei son when she called tho servant and told her of her fathers death As incredtable as it seems that the girl, in a period not to exceed twenty minutes, could have killed her father, havo removed all traces of the crime from her person, se creted the weapon with which the deed Was done, and exposed her self to face the world, she was sent to jail and kept there for eight months without trial, or attempt to try her, though the constitution of Massachussets provides that no person accused of crime can be con fined longer than six months, be fore trial. The excuses given for the out rageous detention were simply puerile. The state's attorney and police professed to have certain "clues" leading to confirmation of the charges that the accused young woman murdered her father and stepmother. These they said would require time for their work ing out, to definite and convincing proof. This was the pretense. Then wo were given to under stand that the judge who presided at the committing trial was con vinced that tho slate could prove the guilt of the accused; but for some reasons unexplained, and that admit no explanation, the state demanded her commitment without hearing this proof, and this was granted. Then it was said, as coming from the prosecuting attorney of fice, that if Miss Borden were held in jail long enough she would surely confess her guilt. finally we wcro told she was detained nearly a year, she and her counsel being kept in ignorance of the proof by which it was pro posed to show her a murderess, be cause the benevolent authorities "more than suspected tho woman's sanity" and were holding up for developments in that direction, If the officers had really any testimony of a convicting charac ter, thoy should have been told to produce it before tho committing magistrate, in order that the ac oused might then and there meet it or prepare to meet it on her trial. That they were not thus ordered shows the magistrate either a fool or a scoundrel. The proposal to terrify the wo rtnintn confession, by holding over her an implied threat of per petual immurement in jail, was an infamous proceeding. The ex cuse that she was "thought insane" was ridiculous, for the way to de velope that fact was to prove it on her trial for murder. : The withholding of the alleged convicting proof and her commit ment simply on the asnmntinn hat she was believed to bo euiltv by the neighbors, was such an outrage as wo believe would be im possible in any western state.
An opinion piece condemns the eight-month detention of Lizzie Borden without trial, arguing it violated Massachusetts law limiting pre-trial confinement to six months. It accuses prosecutors and the judge of using vague 'clues,' threats, and claims of insanity as pretexts to pressure a confession rather than presenting evidence at a hearing.
The Athena Press · 16 June 1893 · page 2
Then it was said, as coming from the prosecuting attorney of fice, that if Miss Borden were held in jail long enough she would surely confess her guilt.
The report describes a highly sensational murder trial underway in Fall River, Massachusetts against unmarried Lizzie Borden, noting the case's sensational nature due to both the mysterious circumstances and her relationship to the victims. It states her father, the wealthy merchant Borden, and her stepmother were murdered with a hatchet in bestial fashion, and that Lizzie persistently denies guilt while the evidence against her does not seem very strong.
Scranton Wochenblatt · 16 June 1893 · page 4
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
The report notes the Borden murder trial has just begun and is expected to last at least ten days, with no evidence given in this account. It states the prosecution appears to have a weak case, giving Lizzie and her supporters hope for acquittal.
Sullivan Republican · 16 June 1893 · page 3
The attornies in the Lizzie Borden murder trial, say that the ca9C has just begun and will continue for at least ten days from this date, hence we shall not give any evidence in the case. As the evidence appears, the prosecution has a very weak case and Lizzie and her friends are very hopeful of acquittal. The boom of city guests at the 'Mere so far, has not caused any alarm that cholera is raging in Philadelphia. Reduced fares to the World's Fair are assured, say a number of railway officials. The fight over the Dushore post office, is waxing warm.
The report notes that Lizzie Borden's trial for the murder of her father and stepmother is still proceeding in New Bedford, Massachusetts. It states that all indications point toward her acquittal, as the prosecution had failed to prove guilt beyond a reasonable doubt.
The Cambria Freeman · 16 June 1893 · page 2
The trial of Miss Lizzie Borden at New Bedford, Mass., for the murder of her father and step mother last fall at Fall River, is still KQi'ng on. All indi cations point to the acquittal of Miss Borden, the state having failed to make
The Olneyville Times · Olneyville Providence, R.I.
A newspaper miscellany mentions that the Lizzie Borden trial at New Bedford is capturing national attention. It notes the prosecution has presented a weak case so far, with public opinion leaning toward acquittal.
The Olneyville Times · 16 June 1893 · page 2
The trial of Lizzie Borden at New Bed ford is engrossing the attention of news paper readers throughout the country. Thus far the prosecution have put in a very weak case and the prevailing opinion seems to be that the prisoner will be acquitted. Tue Tives has received a circular this week from the peach growersof Delaware sayving that from present appearances the peach crop in Delaware and the Chesa peake Peninsular will be very large. It is only hoped the hopes of the Delaware grower and the Rhode Island consumer will not be blasted.
The Olneyville Times · Olneyville Providence, R.I.
A filler column of miscellaneous jokes and quips includes an anecdote about a Pawtucket newsboy yelling about 'Lizzie Borden's trials' while hawking papers. The item is part of a humor roundup with no direct reporting on case facts.
The Olneyville Times · 16 June 1893 · page 2
SMALL TALK. There are guantities of Fair minded people in Chicago. The boy who likes fractions is yet (o be born. It seems that Worth, the man milliner is only a dressmaker. “Do you think a porous plaster can cure him of stutteringi” “‘Yes; when he comes to take it off he will talk right along without stopping."—Exchange. The man who retains a lawyer ‘‘keeps his owp counsel" A Pawtucket newsboy hit it about right this morning when he went through the streets yelling, ‘‘All about Lizzie Borden's trials.”—Pawtucket Tribane. A walled city i
The report describes a new witness, Hyman Lubinsky, who testified seeing Lizzie Borden walking from the barn to the side doorstep around 11 a.m. on the day of the murders, corroborating her own account. It also discusses the trial's progress, noting the exclusion of the prussic acid testimony and other evidence, which dealt setbacks to the prosecution's case.
Pawtucket Tribune · 16 June 1893 · page 1
NEW WITNESS TURNS UP.
Goveinor Rob.nson’s eloguent argument, is 10 be fo!lowed by Attorney Knowlton's close tomorrow forenoen lut{ the chaige is expected to be by Mr. Justice Dewey. Mr, Jonuings is not us sanguine as Colonel Adams, however. He looks for one more day of evidence for the defense, and, it that be so, then the pleas are hardly likely to be made tomorrow, though they may be. Ti:e commonwealth is expested to work all its resources to secure rebutting testi mony. That is its last fighting chaunce. That the prosecution opened with great strength and power the clue of its evi dence in the way it did 1s a great surprise.
See moreSee less
Wiether the rulings of the court ou the three great premises—the exclusion of the inquust report; of the entire evidence of Miss Anoa Borden bearing upon the mo tive, and of the prussic acid story of Eil Bence nnd bis confreres, has pushed theiy feet from urd r tiem, certain it is that the qu ry last night was, what has become of thgovernment’s case, The rulings and decisions gave the prose cution a severe set-back, yet it is neverthe l'ss true that each one of them was founded upon good law and intrenched in its principles.
The report describes a courtroom day in which several evidentiary rulings favored the defense, surprising both sides and weakening the prosecution's case. Witnesses including the Chagnons, Simon Lubinsky, and two young boys gave testimony, with Lubinsky's account that Lizzie was seen coming from the barn seen as potentially crucial to the defense.
Pawtucket Tribune · 16 June 1893 · page 1
efforts. T e first witnesses—the Chagnons—were disappointing, because there was #o little that was positive in their testimony as to ti:e stranger who jumped the Borden rear fence at 11 o’clock the night before, but as the great trio develoztd their evidence they showed a strong hand and shrewdly manipalated their cards, The greatest eveut of the day was the square, straightforward testimony that Lizzie was seen com'ng from the barn, Lizzie Borden was not in the house as the government ‘@ ks to show, and the screen door was open, Simon Lubinsky’s glance over his shoulder may save Lizzie Boraen’s neck from the gallows noose. His story was very naturally told, The Boy Witnesses.
Testimony recounts two boys, Brownie and Tom Barlow, exploring the Borden barn loft the day of the murders, describing their movements and timing. Another witness, Joe Lemay, testifies about a stranger in the woods overheard saying 'poor Miss Borden,' with defense arguing its relevance to opportunity while prosecution objects.
Pawtucket Tribune · 16 June 1893 · page 1
with his grandmother. The boys stayed at the Borden house till b o’clock, and came back in the svening, hanging round till 12 «’clock on the night after the murder. Jim Barlow considored the barn loft, on the whole, cooler than it was out of doors that d .y, in spite of t. @ fact of its low roof and sloping sides. Then Joe Lemay was called to tell his startling story of the Wild Stranger his dog scented out in the woods west of the Wilson road on she Sunday after the murder—the man with the axe who says: “Too bad, poor Miss Borden; too bad, poor Miss Borden ' ~Attorney Knowlton ob jocted to the testimony.
See moreSee less
On such evidence as this Mr. Jennings srgued that the Steep Brook could not be
This report assesses Lizzie Borden's chances of conviction after the prosecution rested its case, concluding the government failed to prove its central theory of 'exclusive opportunity.' It notes the evidence was weaker than promised in the opening statement, though some circumstantial points remain against her.
The Providence News · 16 June 1893 · page 4
LIZZIE BORDEN’'S CHANCES. The completion of the government's case against Lizzie Borden makes it pos sible to estimate the chances for her conviction, as it is safe to assume that the defense will not augment them, if it materially changes them, Speaking broadly, it may be said that the government has failed in several im portant particulars to sustain the theo ries and the declarations advanced by Prosecutor Moody in his opening ad dress, The chief reliance of the prosecution was placed upon the theory of ‘“‘exclu sive opportunity,” that no other than Lizzie Borden could possibly have com .
See moreSee less
mitted the crime she is charged with and escape detection, This theory has been riddled by the testimony of the government's own witnesses until it presents such a tattered and dishelved appoarance as to be almost disreputa ble. It has not been sustained in any important particular. It is not neces sary to point out the defects in the evi dence brought forward to prove exclu sive opportunity, It simply did not prove it, More: It disproved it, Other affirmative evidence was weaker than even Miss Borden's friends feared and expected. It was decidedly weaker than the opening address alleged. What strength there seems to be left in it after the ordeal of cross examination will doubtless be materially weakened by the defense. It assuredly will if the promises of Counsel Jennings are ful filled, It is not to be denied that there are strong points of cirecnmstantial evidence against Lizzie Borden, She made as- ‘sertions that apparently cannot be sus tained, unless indeed the defense has some fremendous surprises in store. The note that she said had been sent to her stepmother has not been found, nor the friend who was alleged to have sent it. It has not been settled where Miss Borden was when the murders were committed. It appears that she told conflicting stories regarding that, and it was pretty conclusively shown that she was not in the barn, as she related, We note that it is assumed by some newspapers that the prosecution has shown that Miss Borden was up stairs after the killing of Mrs. Borden, and
A newspaper assesses the prosecution's case as tattered and unsustained, noting failures to prove exclusive opportunity, motive, the murder weapon, or bloodstained clothing. It acknowledges circumstantial evidence against Lizzie Borden, including her unverified claims about a note and conflicting accounts of her whereabouts, while noting the defense has not yet presented its case.
The report argues the government failed to establish motive, produce the murder weapon, or show any blood on Lizzie Borden's person or clothing. It concludes the trial so far has deepened rather than solved the mystery, with the outcome still uncertain.
The Providence News · 16 June 1893 · page 4
LIZZIE BORDEN'S CHANCES.
The trial thus far has simply deep. ened the awful mystery of the Borden murder, Its conclusion may clear it up, It may, but there appears to be but the slightest ground to expect that it will, After it is concluded will be time enough to examine into the causes of the failure to futhom the mystery by the Fall River police and the Massachsetts state anthorities—lif Lizzie Borden is not acquitted,
This Fall River dispatch reports that public opinion holds the prosecution's case against Lizzie Borden is weak, fueled by rumors that the defense will reveal she bought paint before the murders and that dress-burning was common in the household. It also notes confusion over an officer's inconsistent testimony about finding a hatchet handle.
The Bolivar Bulletin · 16 June 1893 · page 1
Hatchet Stories. Fall River, Mass., June lL--All day long talk has been plentiful on the subject of the Borden murders and there can be no denial that it is a gen eral opinion about town that the prose cution thus'far has a very weak case. This opinion is being strengthened by rumors current here to the effect that Lizzie Borden's counsel will shortly ex plode a bomb-shell in the camp of the authorities. It is hinted that the de fense will show conclusively that Liz zie Borden purchased some paint I a few days before the murder and that it was not an uncommon thing to burn dresses in the Borden household.
See moreSee less
Then the fact that the girl burned the dress in the daylight, wLlie 1 officers sur rounded the house, will also be cited to show there was not the slightest concealment.! ;The defendant's fclaw yers do not attempt to disguise their joyful feelings because of the present status of the case, and the girl's friends here are jubilant. The hatchet inci dent, with its accompanying denials, is also a source of much comfort. '" '"" But while the prisoner's . friends are buoyant the spirits of the police au thorities are by no means downcast. Officer Maulley's strange, unexpected statement about finding the handle, is, they say, in keeping with the general tone of the testimony given by hiin be fore in court. Bie has been known several times to take a position in less
The report assesses that Massachusetts has not made strong headway proving Lizzie Borden guilty, noting suspicious circumstances but insufficient certainty for a jury to convict on a capital charge. It describes the defense's strategy as not proving her innocence outright but undermining the prosecution's case built on the theory that she must be guilty since no other suspect exists.
Vermont Phœnix · 16 June 1893 · page 1
World's Fair. Up to this time tho state of Massachu setts has not made great headway toward proving that Lizzie Borden killed her father and step-mother. The Impression left, after reading the evidence, Is that the suspicious circumstances against her are very strong, but that no juryman would like to give his vote to hang her until more certain evidence than any yet has been produced. The trouble with the state's case appears to be that it was made up on the theory that Lizzie liorden must have done the killing because there was no one else to suspect, and this theory oxGov. ltoblnson Is steadily riddling with holes. On the oilier hand the wtrk of the defence goes, not to prove Miss llorden's In-
A boy found a weathered, rusty hatchet atop a barn behind the Borden house while searching for a ball, though its relevance to the murders was unclear. Meanwhile, the defense called an ice cream peddler who testified he saw a woman walking from the house to the barn just after 11 a.m. on August 4, corroborating Lizzie Borden's account of her whereabouts.
Vermont Phœnix · 16 June 1893 · page 1
Another llntcllet Found. Wednesday night a boy found a hatchet on top of a barn in the rear of the Borden house at Fall River, whllo looking for a ball. The hatchet was rusty and weather stained, Whether it has any significance in the murder case remains to be seen. The defence Introduced yesterday an Ice cream peddler, who saw a woman going from the Borden house to the barn just after 11 o'clock, Aug. 4. His evidence Is important as corroborating Miss Borden's statement that she was in tho barn when her father was killed.
See moreSee less
e I.es.eps at Liberty, The court of appeals at Paris has quashed tho sentences against Ferdinand de Les seps, Charles do Lesseps, M. Eiffel and others, convicted of fraud In connection with the Panama canal, on tho ground that the statute of limitations covered tho offences charged, and that the Indictment on which the prisoners were tried was Irreg ular. The prisoners aro at liberty. Mrs. Frank Leslie has been granted a divorce from her English husband, ''Wil lie" Wilde, brother of Oscar Wilde.
This report summarizes the prosecution's theory that Lizzie Borden killed her stepmother to prevent her father from diverting his fortune, then killed her father to complete the inheritance. It notes that no clear evidence yet supports this theory of motive, describing the case as one of the most bewildering homicides in criminal history.
Vermont Phœnix · 16 June 1893 · page 2
"With n Stinunurv of Kvhlciu'o gliowliio; lVlint In ( Imicil Against tlir I'rlstnifr, Wlint linn Uceit lretl nml What llefntril. I Abridged from the New York Tribune's excel-It-tit Biiiiimnry 1 In the history of crime there have heen few cases of homicide more bewildering than that now being tried In New Hedford, Mass. Whoever killed the aged Morden couple exposed even less of motive than of personality. It must have been a revenge ful crime, and yet nothing Is In sight to show that cither of the victims was hated by anybody to the extent that ordinarily prompts murder.
See moreSee less
The theory of the pros ecution Is that Lizzie had long hated Mrs. Borden; that she suspected her father of Intending to divert a considerable part of his fortune to her stepmother and possibly to some of her stepmother's relations; that she killed the stepmother to prevent this, and then killed her fatherto make the pre vention complete and to. acquire her Inher itance promptly. Hut so far there is no evidence to prove this. The woman with whom Lizzie Iloiden lived as her stepmother had been Mr. Dor den's wife for nearly the whole period of Lizzie's life. She can scarcely remember her own mother, and all she ever had of motherly care and affection came from Mrs. Ilorden. Her father was 70 years old. Her stepmother was 03, very stout, and not especially vigorous. Mr. Borden was worth f:).")0,000, and was a director in various financial concerns. The family lived In a snug way peculiar to themselves. There is nothing to show that Lizzie Bor den was greedy for money. She and her sister were both properly supplied with money, and had bank accounts of their own. The state has made up its case on the theory that Lizzie Borden must have com mitted the murders, because no one else had a chance to commit them. To prove this it got together a chain of evidence which was all right until ex-Gov. ltobln son got liold of it on cross-examination, when it has been riddled with holes. It is a curious circumstance that every witness for the prosecution has redeemed its assurance of what he would testify to, only to weaken, to become confused, to qualify himself, to make changes and ad missions before the ex-governor got through with him. The details that accuse Lizzie Borden lack consistency, lack probability, and might be true and still leave her Inno cent. She was the last person that saw her father and her stepmother alive. Nothing whatever in the circumstances of the case even suggest anybody else as their murderer.
The report lays out the theory that Lizzie killed her stepmother over inheritance fears and then her father, but notes no evidence proves this. It argues the state's case has been riddled with holes under ex-Gov. Robinson's cross-examination, with witnesses repeatedly weakening or contradicting themselves.
The report notes that Lizzie Borden's trial for the Fall River ax murders continues, with the defense seeming to prevail over the prosecution. It states the general public opinion is that she will be triumphantly acquitted.
The Londonderry Sifter · 16 June 1893 · page 1
Guitean issued a dragnet curse which included everyone who had anything to do with his conviction and man kind in general. Superstitious peo ple may connect the presence of Gui tenu's skull in the building in so re mysterious way with the terrible cat astrophe. The trial of the Fall Itiver i!iee conspiracy against 51iss Lizzie Borden continues. It is the general opinion that Miss Iiorilen is getting the liest of her iicrsectitors and will be triumph antly acquitted. - Every lwttle of Arnica and Oil Liniment I ild is warranted by the proprietors to give atisfaction or money will be refunded.
The report describes the start of Lizzie Borden's murder trial at New Bedford, noting the defense's early win in excluding her inquest testimony. It also summarizes the Tribune's reconstruction of how, if guilty, Borden could have killed both parents and changed clothes within the available time window.
The Bennington Banner · 16 June 1893 · page 1
The trial of Lizzie Borden for tho kill ing of bor father and mother at Fall Rlv er, Ma8s., began last weok Monday at Now Bedford, Mass. Trobably no simi lar caso has arouscd tho intercst tbis ono has commandcd from tho day of tho dis covcry of tho dcad bodies of Mr. and Mrs. Borden in their handsomo residcnce,
The report quotes the Tribune's summary of the prosecution's theory of how Lizzie Borden could have committed both murders within a tight timeframe, questioning the feasibility of completing all the described actions in just fifteen minutes. It argues that no credible witness placed her near the barn during the critical window, suggesting this casts doubt on her guilt.
The Bennington Banner · 16 June 1893 · page 1
sholf in tho cellar, corered it with asbes and weut to tho attic stairs and called Bridgot That was a great deal of work to do in fifteen minutes. If thora woro n crediblo witness in existonco wbo conld say to that jury tbatat any timo after 11 o'ctack and bofore flfteon min utes past bo had seen Lizzlo Borden wlthin twenty feet of that barn door, it is safe to say sho would go free. Thero is not a singlo fact the Statn has proved which is not consistent witb hor inno cence, or which would cit a figuro if sho cuuld only traco hersolf somohow to tbat barn."
A short item reports that Lizzie Borden is on trial at New Bedford, Massachusetts for hacking her father and stepmother to death, both about sixty years old. It states the only suggested motive was her poor relationship with her stepmother and fear her father would leave his estate to his wife.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
Washington Standard · 16 June 1893 · page 2
CLT IN KATES OK TRANSPORTATION. — The (Jreat Northern lias cut passenger rates from Seattle to St. Paul, to fllo. This rate will probably be followed by eacli of the other lines, and was doubt less anticipated by them. The fact is, the attendance at the World's Fair so far has been disap]»ointing, and there is but one reason for it, the scarcely of money. The only alternative seems to be to adopt rates which will com mand the patronage of those who really want to see the big show. Chicago sees it in that light, hence the clamor of her leading newspapers for a universal cut in rates.
See moreSee less
AN UNNATURAL DKKD. —One of the most horrible deeds of criminal his tory is on trial and the sensation at New Bedford, Mass. Lizzie Borden is charged with chopping to pieces her father and step-mother, both of whom were about bo years of age. Borden was a retired undertaker, wealthy and influential. The only motive attribu'- « ) for the bloody deed is that Lizzie was on had terms with her step-mother and had grounds for belie! that her father iutended to make a will in favor of his wife. A SPECIAL session of Congress will probably be called early in September.
During the hearing on whether Lizzie Borden's inquest testimony should be admissible at trial, she became suddenly ill and had to leave the courtroom while District Attorney Moody was arguing for its admission. Ex-Governor Robinson then made a lengthy plea to suppress the testimony, arguing she had been harassed and tricked by police before the inquest.
Iowa County Democrat · 16 June 1893 · page 3
LIZZIE BORDEN TAKEN ILL
District Atlorucy Was Speaking. Nkw liKitpoitD. Mass.,June 13.—Dur ing District Attorney .Moody's remarks on the question of the admission of the prisoner's testimony at the inquest Miss Lorden was obliged to leave the court room through sudden indisposi tion. When Miss Borden came into court siie looked dragged and told ti'ov. Robinson that she had not slept Well. Mr. Moody spent three-quarters of an hour in maintaining the admissi bility of Miss Borden's evidence before
At the Borden murder trial, Officer Harrington testified that Lizzie told him right after the killings that nothing in the house was disturbed, undercutting the defense's outside-intruder theory. Another officer, Fleet, testified that additional hatchets were found in the cellar partly covered by ashes.
Iowa County Democrat · 16 June 1893 · page 6
ROBBERY NOT THE MOTIVELizzie Borden Told an Officer that Noth ing in tlie House Was D * urbe I. New Bedford, Mass., June s — ln the Borden trial to-day Oflicer fleet admitted that lie found other hatchets in the cellar partly covered by ashes. Officer Harrington made a hole in the defense's theory of ! murder by outsiders by testifying that M iss Borden told him immediately after tue tragedy that the motive was not robbery, as everything about the house was undisturbed. Bhe told wit ness she left her father reading a pa per and found him dead twenty min utes after. -She was particular about the time she was in the barn, saying she was there fully twenty minutes.
The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · Wheeling, W. Va.
On the tenth day of the Borden murder trial, witnesses testified about the uses of prussic acid, but after objections from the defense, the justices ruled the evidence insufficient and excluded all testimony about attempted purchases of the poison. The commonwealth then rested its case, and a brief recess was taken.
The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · 16 June 1893 · page 1
ARE CLEARING AWAY - The Clouds That Hung Dark Over Lizzie Borden's Head
New Uudvoud, Mabs., Juno IS.?XI tooth day of 'the Borden murder tri oponed with a big crowd la attoudnni | Miss Borden was overwhelmed wll
The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · Wheeling, W. Va.
The defense attorney outlines the case against the prosecution's circumstantial evidence, promising to show an unconnected stranger was seen near the Borden house and that the barn had other visitors contradicting police testimony. Witnesses including Walter Stephens, a reporter, testify to hearing people in the barn loft, challenging Officer Medley's claim of undisturbed dust on the floor.
The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · 16 June 1893 · page 1
THE FIRST WITNESS. During tko oponing Miaa Borden ct ered hor tearful oycs with hor linnkd ' cliiof. Charlos N. Gilford and Uriah Kir , both eworo to having soon a stran man on tho steps of the lattor's hou ' near the Bordon rosldouco at 11 o'cio ' tho night before the murder*. 1 f Benjamin Handy, of Fall Itiver, tostili that lie wont by tho Unrdcn houno 8 morning of tho murder nt fl and 10:! "X saw u medium sized young mu 1 very pale In complexion, with ills oj 3 fixed on tile siduwalit, passing slov towards tho south; ho was acti strangely; in coilsoquonco of his i poarance I turned in my carriago watch hint ns ho wont by; I have - faint idoa that I had soon him boiori
On the tenth day of the Borden trial, druggists and chemists testified about prussic acid's uses and dangers, but the justices ruled the evidence failed to meet the prosecution's own proffer and excluded all testimony about Lizzie's alleged attempt to buy the poison. The Commonwealth then rested its case.
Wheeling Register · 16 June 1893 · page 1
New Bedford, Mass., June 15.—The tenth day of the Borden murder trial opened with a big crowd in attendance. Miss Borden was overwhelmed with floral offerings this morning aud
Defense counsel argues the prosecution's circumstantial case fails to prove motive, weapon, or exclusive opportunity, insisting no direct evidence links Lizzie Borden to the murders. Early defense witnesses testify about a noise at the Borden fence the night before and a strange man seen nearby, aiming to show others were present around the property.
Wheeling Register · 16 June 1893 · page 1
AFTER THE RECESS
Chagnon, whose yard Is in the rear oi the Borden yard, On the night preced ing the Borden murder. Miss Chagnon said she heard a noise at about 11 o’clock at night. It sounded like pound ing on the Borden fence, and lasted about five minutes. Marion Chagnon, mother of Martha, confirmed her daugh ter, but the purpose of their testimony is not disclosed. Charles N. Gifford and Uriah Kirby both swore to bating seen a strange man on the steps of the latter’s bouse, near the Borden residence, at 11 o’clock the night before the murders.
See moreSee less
Dr. Benj. Handy, of Fall River, tes tilled that he went by the Border house on the morning of the murder, al 9 and 10:30 o’clock. “I saw a medium sized man, very pale in complexion with his eyes fixed on the sidewall walking toward the south; be was act Ing strangely. In consequence of hh iDpearance I turned in my carriage t< watch him as he went by. I have i ! faint idea that I had seen him before.’
Several witnesses, including Dr. Benjamin Handy, Mrs. Delia Maxley, and reporter Walter Stephens, testified at the trial about suspicious strangers seen near the Borden house before and after the murders. An ice cream peddler also described seeing a woman emerge from the barn area on the morning of the killings.
The report describes a June 16 adjournment of the Borden trial and notes growing public sentiment that Lizzie Borden could not have committed the murders if sane. It argues the prosecution's own timeline—requiring the murders be done in twelve minutes—makes her guilt seem physically implausible given her composed appearance afterward.
The World · 16 June 1893 · page 7
THE BORDEN TRIAL. Tti(' I VHIiik IIi kIuk to Grow Thitt tho /!<j* rutted tilrl In Innocent or liiHiine. New Bedford, Mans., June la—It whs :;:40 o’clock Friday aftcryyou when tl»c court decided to adjqu^i the Borden case until Saturday morning’. As the details in this remarkable oaaa, come out ‘lay by day the feeling is grow ing stronger Idr.zie Borden could1 not have Committed the crime if she had been a sane woman. The prosecu tion have cut down the time in which * the murder must have boon committed to twelve minutes.
See moreSee less
f It would seem to any common-sense person physlcially impossible for small woman like Lizzie Borden to com mit two murders in twelve minutes, de stroy all traces of 4.he crime and re appear with hair unruffled, with cloth ing smooth, without face even flushed. The very strongest points brought out by the prosecution day by day seem ingly prove the fallacy of these views.
At the New Bedford trial, the court excluded testimony from a Portuguese witness about a bloodied man muttering about 'poor Mrs. Borden,' and Matron Reagan denied hearing a quarrel between the Borden sisters. Emma Borden testified about family history and property, and firmly denied any 'you gave me away' exchange occurred between herself and Lizzie.
Paper unidentified · 17 June 1893 · page 1
LIZZIE BORDEN TRIAL
The Defense Continues Its Testimony with Sustained Interest. Court at New Bedford was called to order at the usual hour on yester day, Friday, morning. The crowd was not so large as on the preceding days of the week. But the intense in terest manifested throughout the trial showed no evident decrease. The prisoner appeared more than usually calm and self possessed. The decision relative to the admis sion of the evidence of the Portuguese who saw a man with a bloody hatchet and muttering about “poor Mrs. Bor den” was that the evidence could not be admitted.
See moreSee less
The morning’s evidence was devoted to prove in a general way that men were seen about the Borden house the day of the murder who could have committed the crime, and also to showing that Matron Reagan to the reporters denied hav ing heard any quarrel in the jail be tween the two Borden sisters in which the prisoner said, “You have given me away,” and would have signed a denial but for the refusal of the mar shal to let her. Emma, the sister of Lizzie Borden, testified that the family had lived in the house they now live in twenty-one years last May. At the time of the murder Lizzie was possessed of prop erty which Emma gave a list of. She said her father wore a ring on his fin ger given him by Lizzie. Emma de nied absolutely the “you gave me away” story, and swore that no quar rel took place between tho sisters in
Emma Borden testified about family history, property, and denied that any quarrel occurred between her and Lizzie in the matron's room, including the alleged 'you gave me away' statement. Marshal Hilliard was called in rebuttal regarding the same alleged quarrel, and court adjourned until Monday.
Paper unidentified · 17 June 1893 · page 1
Matron Ragan’s room. Cross-examined with reference to the family relations Emma testified to her father’s gift of the house to their stepmother, after which Lizzie ceased to call her mother and called her Mrs. Borden, but for two or three years before the murder the relations be tween Lizzie and Mrs. Borden were entirely cordial, and if she testified to the contrary at the preliminary hear ing that was untrue. Marshall Hilliard was the first wit ness called in rebuttal. He was asked about the quarrel between Emma and Lizzie in the matron’s room. He said Mrs. Reagan told her story partly to him and he said it she had any story to tell she had better tell it in court. Court adjourned until Monday morning.
The report states that the government's case against Lizzie Borden appears to rest only on circumstantial conjecture rather than solid evidence. It notes that after the prosecution closed its testimony, the chain of evidence remained a series of disconnected links, with conviction hopes resting mainly on damaging admissions during cross-examination of defense witnesses.
Arizona Republican · 17 June 1893 · page 4
The aovuit.NMENT appears to havo failed in tho lionlen enso and on the foundation upon which the scaffold of Lizzie Borden was to bo erected, to havo been ablo only to raiee a ghastly and unsolvable conjecture. At tho close of the prosecution's testimony nisht be fore last tho chain which was to be welded about her, consisted only of a lot of disconnected linkfi. The only an parent possibility of a conviction lies in tho ability of the government to ob tain damaging evidence from the de fendant's witnesses on cross-examination.
The report states that Lizzie Borden's trial for murdering her father and stepmother is in progress at New Bedford, Massachusetts, and is attracting great attention throughout New England. It is a brief mention among many unrelated news items of the day.
The Meeker Herald · 17 June 1893 · page 2
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
The Lizzie Borden murder trial is proceeding in New Bedford, with the prosecution's case not yet succeeding. A key development was the court's ruling to exclude Borden's inquest testimony, deemed coerced self-incrimination, a decision seen as favorable to the defense.
Paper unidentified · 17 June 1893 · page 4
Fuller of Vermont read k paper before the Professional Club of Attleboro recently in which he clearly established the claim that Samuel Morey of Fairlee, Vt., was the first man who invented, built and ran a steamboat. His experimental crafts were run on the Connecticut river at Fairlee, also between Hartford and New Haven, and from Bordentown, N. J. to Philadelphia. Robert
A brief telegraph news item reports that efforts are being made to weaken the government's case against Lizzie Borden during her ongoing murder trial. It appears amid a roundup of other unrelated wire stories, including foreign news and a New York dynamite incident.
Morning Journal and Courier · 17 June 1893 · page 3
From All Quarters. LIZZIE BORDEN'S TBIAL. Efforts Made to Weaken the Government's Case. JQSEPI JEFFEBSOSi SERHJUSY ILL Results of the Germantlec lion in Doubt. PRESIDENT C&RNOT JMPRQYED.
Coverage of the New Bedford trial reports another witness corroborating sightings of a strange man near the Borden house the morning of the murders, while the court excluded other defense evidence about a bloody-shirted man seen later. Reporters testified that Matron Reagan denied the alleged 'you gave me away' confession story, and witnesses described Lizzie Borden's calm demeanor and clothing after the murders.
Morning Journal and Courier · 17 June 1893 · page 3
Dynamite Cartridges Ex plode in New York. LIZZIE BABDEIPl TBUL, The Accused's Prospects Brighter Another Witness Saw the iriysteri n man In Front of the Borden House Sirs. Keagan's Btorr Dis credited. Naw Bkdfobd, Jane 16. At the Borden trial this morning the oonrt ezolnded the evidence offered yesterday by the defense as to the appearance at Steep brook twelve dais after the mnrdera ot a strangely act ing man with bloody shirt and a hatchet Sara Hart corroborated lira, llanley'a tes timony of yesterday about the yonng man standing at the Borden gate post the morn log of the mnrder and fixed the time at 9:50.
See moreSee less
Charles Sawyer saw the prisoner In the Borden honse joat after the murders, People were fanning her, and her clothes were not disarranged or bloody. He saw people aronnd the barn, Alfred Clarkson, the witness of yesterday, being among the first. J. J. Manning and Thomas Hlokey, re porters,. testified that Matron Beagan told them there was nothing in the "yon gave me away" story. Vanning went into the barn with others: saw Ularston, bat not Offioer Medley. He was cross examined as to the blood spots and the condition of the bed chamber, which ha said was dark. Mary K. Holmes testified that defendant was a member of ohnroh and Christian En deavor societies and engaged in various re ligions and charitable enterprises, and that she attended ohnrch with Mrs. Borden. Witness desorlbed the conversation be
Witnesses testify about Matron Reagan's disputed 'you gave me away' remark, which she reportedly wanted to retract but was forbidden by Marshal Hilliard to sign a denial. Emma Borden describes the thorough police search, the dresses in Lizzie's closet, and family relations, while the prosecution calls rebuttal witnesses to contest these accounts.
Morning Journal and Courier · 17 June 1893 · page 3
press orders." Mary E. Brlgham testified that Matron Beagan told her first story. it is all a lie from beginning to end. I was willing to sign the paper, but the mar shal wonld not let me." Etnma L Borden, defendant's Bister,, testifitd that Lizzie gave her father a ring which he constantly wore, and which was the only ornament he wore. She then said there were eighteen dresses in the oloset the day of the search; of whioh eight were bine dresses belonging to defendant. Mr. Dolan told witness the search was as thorough as oould be mad without taking the paper from the wall and the carpets from the floor, and Jennlng told her everything had been searched.
See moreSee less
Witness and defend ant assisted in the search. On cross examination she testified that her father's gift of a honse to their stepmother made, trouble between Lizzie and'her stepmother, bat that their relations had been entirely cordial for two or three years before the murders, although Lizzie had ceased to call Mrs. Borden "mother." In the after noon she said Lizzie wore the Bedford oord
The report covers the twelfth day of the Lizzie Borden trial, noting the defense's rapid progress and a recess until Monday. Emma Borden testified about the paint-stained dress and hatchet, denying a matron's account, while other witnesses corroborated her testimony.
Waterbury Evening Democrat · 17 June 1893 · page 3
GETTING NEAR THE END
EMMA TESTIFIES FOR HER SISTER She Tells About the Painty Dress and the Hatchet, and Denies the Story ol Matron Bjan-Oth,r 'Witnesses Con firm Ber Story Tha Court Decides to Take a Best. tf New Bedford, Mass., June 17. The twelfth day of the struggle between the two parties in the Borden trial will begin on
At Lizzie Borden's trial, witness Sarah Hart described seeing an unidentified young man resting at the Borden gate around the time of the murders, while court rejected related hatchet-witness evidence. Reporters Manning and Hickey testified about interviewing Mrs. Reagan, who reportedly denied the substance of her earlier published quarrel story.
Waterbury Evening Democrat · 17 June 1893 · page 3
Tiverton, and she said: "I lived in Fall River ten years ago, on or near Second street. I knew Andrew J. Borden by sight and knew where he lived; on the day of the murders I passed by Mr. Borden's house with my sister-in-law, Mrs. Mauley; it was about 9:50 a. m. ; we passed by the north gate and stopped there to speak to my nephew who was there in a carriage, and went up to the back of his carriage. While I was there I saw a young man standing in the gate-way; it was not Mr. Borden; he was resting his head on his left hand, his elbow being on the gate
Witnesses testify about the disputed 'you gave me away' story, with the matron allegedly wanting to deny it but being blocked by the marshal. Emma Borden testifies about family relations, household arrangements, the search for the note, and states she never saw the handleless hatchet.
Waterbury Evening Democrat · 17 June 1893 · page 3
Holmes testified that Matron Reagan told Mr. Buck that the denial of the "you gave me away" story was true, and that she would sign it if the marshal did not ob ject. John R. Caldwell, reporter, testified that Marshal Hilliard told Mrs. Reagan it she signed the denial of the "you gave me away story," it would be against his ex press orders. Mary E. Brigham testified that Matron Reagan said about the story: "It is all a lie from beginning to end. I was willing to Bign that paper, but the marshal would not let me."
See moreSee less
Emma Borden then took the stand. She testified that her father's gift of the house to her stepmother made trouble between Lizzie and her stepmother, and Lizzie ceased to call her mother and called her Mrs. Borden; but for two or three years before the murder the relations between Lizzie and Mrs. Borden were entirely cor dial. If she had testified to the contrary at the preliminary hearing that was un true. Emma denied absolutely the "You gave me away" story, ana swore no quar rel took place between the sisters in Matron Reagan's room. Mr. Knowlton cross-ex amined with reference to family relations. Emma Borden resumed on cross-exami
At the Borden trial, the court refused to admit testimony from a Frenchman named Lemain who claimed to have encountered a blood-covered stranger wielding an axe and muttering about 'Poor Mrs. Borden' near Fall River. Other witnesses testified about a young man seen at the Borden gate and about guarding Lizzie Borden after the murders, noting she showed no visible blood.
The Morning Call · 17 June 1893 · page 1
IT WAS NOT INVESTIGATED.
Special to The Morning Call. New Bedford, Mass., June 16.— Borden trial was resumed this morning. The court decided not to admit the evi dence as to the. man. seen with a bloody hatchet, muttering "Poor Mrs. Borden." This is the testimony given by a Frenchman named Lemain, who stated that he lives at Steep Brook, three miles from Fall River on the New Bedford road, and he is a woodchopper. Two weeks after the mur ders he said he was in the woods, when on the other side of a stone wall he heard a voice which kept repeating: "Poor Mrs.
See moreSee less
Borden! Poor Mrs. Borden!" He got over the wall, and approach ing the man, spoke to_ him. This man brandished an ax in a threatening manner, and the Frenchman raised his own ax. As the two stood there glaring at each other, the Frenchman noticed that the stranger's right sleeve and coat were covered with blood, and without a word lie stranger turned and went away. The Frenchman notified the police, who, in stead of searching for the blood-stained stranger began a ponderous investigation into his (the Frenchman's) private charac ter and antecedents. The man was seen again and the police were again notified, but nothing was done. Sarah B. Hart testified that shortly be fore 10 o'clock on the morning of the mur der she passed the Borden house and stopped at the north gate and saw a young man standing in the gateway. He was still standing there when witness drove away. Charles S. Sawyer, a painter of Fall River, testified that he was put on duty at the side door of the Borden house after the murder. He was close to Lizzie Borden all the time. She appeared distressed. Saw no signs of blood on her. A number of witnesses were then ex amined regarding the story published about the time of the murder, in which Police Matron Regan was quoted as saying she overheara a quarrel between the Bor den sisters which went far to fix the guilt of Lizzie. All testified that Mrs. Regan pronounced the publication false. Emma Borden, Lizzie's sister, denied that thero had been any quarrel between them, as reported. She said Lizzie was at outs with her stepmother at one time, but they had been good friends for three years before the murder. . /, \> PjA Emma Borden further testified that the dress with paint on it was stained In May when the painters were working in the house. She said that she asked Lizzie why she didn't destroy the dress and thought she did so. The witness knew of no enemy her stepmother had. Marshal Hilliard was the first witness called in rebuttal after the defense rested. He was asked as to the quarrel in the matron's room and said he told the matron not to sign a paper denying the give-away story. This ended the testimony except for one boy who will be heard for the defense on Monday.
Witnesses testified at the Borden trial about a bloodstained stranger near the house that police failed to properly investigate, and about a published story alleging a quarrel between Lizzie and Emma Borden overheard by the police matron, which was denied by multiple witnesses including Mrs. Regan herself. Emma Borden also testified about the paint-stained dress and the lack of known enemies of her stepmother.
An editorial argues Lizzie Borden nearly was wrongly convicted based on false testimony, particularly regarding the bloody hatchet evidence. It questions who had a motive to frame an innocent woman and calls for finding the true culprit.
The Morning Call · 17 June 1893 · page 6
FALSE TESTIMONY. From present indications Lizzie Borden came unpleasantly near being convicted of the murder of her father on false testi mony. The circumstantial evidence which
The report discusses surprise at how quickly a jury was impaneled in the Borden case, attributing it to Massachusetts court procedure where judges rather than attorneys examine jurors. It contrasts this efficient system with New York's lengthier jury selection process and California's experience with trial delays.
The Morning Call · 17 June 1893 · page 6
QUITE ASTONISHED.
York a case like the Borden one would re quire a week at least to get a jury, all ow ing to the "protracted personal catechism" there permitted. It would, however, be an improvement both on the Massachusetts and the New York svstera were a raajgriiy verdict acceptable. In San Francisco there has often been sad experience of inter minable delays in jury hunting, and the waste of time is all the more deplorable from the great certainty in all exciting trials that the jurors will not agree, and that the proceedings must be resumed de novo. Justice snatched at in this manner too often resembles a farce, but it is quite tragical in expenditure.
All evidence in the Lizzie Borden trial has been presented, with closing arguments to begin Monday and the case expected to reach the jury by Tuesday noon. The report characterizes the prosecution's case as weak, noting its reliance on 'exclusive opportunity' without establishing motive, and criticizes the defense for not investigating the mysterious note or pressing claims about other suspects seen near the house.
Evening Journal · 17 June 1893 · page 1
PROSECUTION'S WEAK CASE.
I carefuUy prepared circumstantial .'web I woven by the prosecution, backed by the cross -examining knife of the defendant's lawyers, and have heanl the testimony | offered by the defense to show that other p ersons were seen in the vicinity of the Borden house the day of the I murder. I While the prosecution surprised every bod y b y its the defense also caused some astonishmeut by not at temptl to prove that either of the I victims had incurred the hatred of -min' I person, thus furnishing a motive for the I crime.
See moreSee less
The prosecution rests on "ex I elusive opportunity;" and while failing I ( 0 prove, defies the defense to prove the I p risoner did not commit the crime, I Another feature of the case was the fail I , ire to investigate the circumstances con I uected with tlie note Lizzie Borden said I ber 8 tep mother received, calling her'out I 0 f the honse. Taking it altogether, the I trial has been a disappointment in many I ways, both to the friends of the accused | and to those who believe in her guilt, The series of crashes with which the I prosecution has come down since the I trial of Lizzie Borden began has been I almost as extraordinary as the crime I with which the woman stands charged, I District'Attorney Knowlton cannot be I blamed for having turned white in I the face and hurried and anxious in I b j a answer when another wave of I disaster rolled over him in the testi I mony of . Hyman Rubenskl, the ice I cream peddler, who said that on the I morning of the tragedy he saw Miss I B orde u walking from the barn to the | house.
The Wilmington Daily Republican · Wilmington, Del.
At the Borden murder trial in New Bedford, the court ruled on admissibility of evidence regarding a Portuguese man with a bloody hatchet, excluding it. Witness Mary Holmes described the search of the Borden house after the murders, and Emma Borden then took the stand.
The Wilmington Daily Republican · 17 June 1893 · page 1
LIZZIE BORDEN'S SISTER ON THE STAND AT NEW BEDFORD. MATRON REAGAN'S STORY DENIED.
'Would put in writing just what he in tended to show. Mrs. Mary R. Holmes, a neighbor and member of the church which Miss Borden attend cd, tho first important witness. She told of her visit, to the bouse when she Jie&rd of the murder and the arrival of Dr. Bowen and Officer Fleet. She proceeded: ••When Fleet came in he asked Lizzie some questions, and Lizzie said she wished he Would In* quick about it, f< she was very •Ireil, having great many quest i
The Wilmington Daily Republican · Wilmington, Del.
Emma Borden, Lizzie's sister, testified about the search of the house, an inventory of dresses, and the burning of a paint-stained Bedford cord dress days after the murders. She described Lizzie's explanation for burning it and Miss Russell's later remark that it had been destroyed.
The Wilmington Daily Republican · 17 June 1893 · page 1
Wntory of the clothes in the closet «flernoon it • week ago from my recollection. There Wwe eight but only others being Lizzie's and mine. I w there when t he search w •nd I both went to the Opening trunks; the •bed, made up about nineteen dresses there, belonged to Mrs. Borden, the going . Lizzi sist in ver made the slight
The Wilmington Daily Republican · Wilmington, Del.
Witnesses testify about Lizzie Borden burning a dress after the murders and a reported quarrel with her stepmother, which the defense disputes as mere ordinary conversation. Other witnesses, including a dressmaker and Dr. Bowen's wife, testify about the dress's history and the absence of blood on Lizzie's clothing shortly after the murders.
The Wilmington Daily Republican · 17 June 1893 · page 1
' 9t Fall Hiver, testlfle«i: "I have done dress «aaklng for Lizzie Borden at her home. I ■rent to the house the first week in May, s there three weeks. The Bed 1893, and ford cord dress I made first because Lizzie Hi it. The painters were painting the a • when Lizzie was wearing the dress, - ^ «ndnlie put it * l»«wI the dress after it * », JBOulli not get that drees it w done. I 'painted.' She under any other
A Tribune correspondent reports that all evidence in the Lizzie Borden trial has been presented after eleven days, with only closing arguments, the judge's charge, and the jury verdict remaining. The writer asserts that most courtroom observers now believe Borden is innocent and the victim of a police conspiracy, citing Emma Borden's testimony about paint on the burned dress and contradiction of damaging statements attributed to Lizzie.
New-York Tribune · 17 June 1893 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.
BRIGHT FOR LIZZIE BORDEN. HER SISTER EMMA'S EVIDENCE
PAINT ON THE BURNED DRESS POSITIVELY
See moreSee less
SWORN TO.
THE "YOU GAVE ME AWAY" STORY CONTRADICTED, AND LIZZIE'S LOVE FOR HER
FATHER SHOWN—THE TESTIMONY ALL IN.
[FROM A STAFF CORRESPONDENT OF THE TRIBUNE.]
New-Bedford, Mass., June 16.—At the end of the eleventh day of the trial the case of the Commonwealth of Massachusetts against Lizzie Andrew Borden is closed. The evidence on both sides is in. That part of the record is sealed, and nothing now remains but the arguments of counsel, the charge of the Court, and the verdict of the jury. Few people who have attended the trial doubt what the verdict will be, and if it is what they look for, there will still be a score to settle before Lizzie Borden and her extraordinary entanglement with the law may be permitted to drop out of sight. The belief in the prisoner's guilt is now confined to that class of people who are naturally suspicious, who have at least a tendency toward hard-heartedness, and who are also so narrow and prejudiced in their views that, having once obtained an impression, they can never allow themselves to part with it. All others, if a judgment can be formed without actually taking a full vote of the courthouse audience, believe that she is innocent, and of these a great majority are convinced that she has been the victim of a police conspiracy.
It is certainly difficult to understand the testimony in any other way. Every suspicious circumstance brought forward by the prosecution has been at least relieved of the necessity of regarding it as suspicious, and on most of such circumstances the defence have placed by trustworthy and corroborated evidence a natural interpretation that is plainly innocent. With the police the issue has been squarely joined, and Governor Robinson's policy in treating them in his cross-examination as not only hostile but malignant witnesses has been vindicated by the production of disinterested testimony which cannot be true unless they are perjurers, and which seems to be true. The prosecution's evidence in rebuttal was mostly confession. The Commonwealth has been in full retreat since the defence put its first witness on the stand, and toward the last of to-day's session the retreat became a disorderly and confused flight.
MISS BORDEN NOT PUT ON THE STAND.
Lizzie Borden did not go on the stand. Some persons will undoubtedly draw an inference from this fact to her disadvantage. This is the natural, almost the inevitable, thing to do. Her best friends here, and her friends are now beginning to multiply, to hold up their heads and to avow their friendship, however diffident they may be about opposing their judgment to that of her counsel, cannot avoid a feeling of regret that she was thought to be unable to stand the strain of such an ordeal. Nevertheless, the claim of her counsel is quite true, that they have proved substantially everything the evidence of which she can supply. Their case would be strengthened only in a moral sense by the mere fact of her taking the stand and subjecting herself to the batteries of the prosecution. On the other hand, it cannot be denied that there is danger of her breaking down. She is utterly tired, almost ill. The pressure and excitement under which she has been during the last two weeks, to say nothing of the last ten months, have left her nervous and in a mental condition anything but healthy. The awful loneliness of her position has weighed upon her, and it is not at all clear that conditions, physical and metaphysical, would not operate to render her, though innocent, an easy victim to the stern, merciless and artful methods of the District-Attorney. Her counsel says she stands in mortal terror of him, and she has good reason to do so.
She remembers how, after seven days of excitement following the murders; after being subjected to searches and questionings almost without number; after being examined by this policeman and then by that one, and by another and another, until it really seemed as if the entire force were set upon her in relays and reliefs; after awful scenes of blood; after the funeral; after being informed that she was under suspicion; after being required to give up her clothing; after actual illness and the constant medicinal application of morphine, she was brought before this District-Attorney, her counsel barred out, and put under a two days' examination in which torture exquisite and brutal was applied to her for hours at a time. She remembers how, after questions were asked plainly conveying his suspicion and his bulldog purpose to get something out of her, he inquired: Did she see her father lying on the sofa? Did she realize that he was dead? Did she see the blood spurting from his wounds? Did she see pools of it on the floor? Did she see the holes in his head? Did she see the wounds lying open? Did she see his eyeballs hanging down? Then she buried her face in her hands and begged for time to think.
EXPLANATIONS DUE FROM MR. KNOWLTON.
If the jury acquits Lizzie Borden, Mr. Knowlton will have some rather ugly things to explain. It appears that there is not a fact that has been told by the defendant's witnesses of which he was not informed before the Grand Jury indicted her. He probably thinks she is guilty. He is just the kind of man to think so. His figure is heavy and stout; his head is big; his face is fat; he has light, sandy hair, and a beard which, while growing all over his face, is heaviest on his chin. He has a round, snub nose, absurdly little for so big a head and so fat a face. His eyes are blue, uncomfortably small and deeply set under his forehead. He has a harsh voice, with a distinct snarl in it.
"Who is this District-Attorney Knowlton?" inquired a stranger to-day, leaning over toward the benches where the little group of New-York correspondents sit.
"He is a gentleman," replied one of them, looking up, "who came here in 1632, and has lived here ever since. He conducted the cases against the Salem witches, achieving his first distinction in that performance. He is probably without an equal in that kind of practice."
The remark was a little rough, perhaps, and yet it was an illustrative answer. The methods of the prosecution of Lizzie Borden, until it reached this court, are not to be defended; and even here Mr. Knowlton has presented evidence which, knowing the extent and character of the proof available to show its falsity, he should have been most cautious in using. That is a safe proposition, whatever the jury's verdict may be.
EMMA BORDEN'S EFFECTIVE TESTIMONY. Emma Borden, Lizzie's sister, was the main witness to-day. She gave the strongest possible testimony in favor of the prisoner, and gave it in the strongest possible way. She, too, is plainly a woman of education, character and refinement. She did not submit to be misunderstood or carried where she was not minded to go. Her answers to the District Attorney were given with precisely that manner and in just that tone which rendered them most effective. There was nothing resentful about her toward the prosecution, but there was everything loving and tender and true toward her sister. Not a note of defiance, not an accent of irritation, not a gesture of impatience escaped her. But the District Attorney could not make her say a syllable to the hurt of the prisoner. At times he pressed her hotly, with the evident intention of getting her confused. But she neither became confused nor angry, and the answers she gave were plainly the answers of a truthful, honest heart. They did not avail the State in its prosecution of Lizzie Borden, because the facts do not avail it. There was no motive for her to commit the crime alleged against her. If anything were lacking to prove that before Emma took the stand, it is not lacking now.
"I was the one," she said, "who felt resentfully toward Mrs. Borden. It was not Lizzie. Their relations were always cordial until that matter of property came up. Six years ago Lizzie did not feel nearly so strongly about that as I did, and the last three years of their lives together were the pleasantest of all. They were on terms of absolute and constant cordiality."
She turned to the jury as she concluded that statement, and said slowly and with a solemnity that I dare not emphazise lest I give some touch of the affectation from which it was so perfectly free:
"What I have said is just the truth."
Every man in the box, I think, believed her.
THE STORY OF THE BURNED DRESS.
Then she told about the burned dress. She was away, it will be remembered, visiting at Marion, when the tragedy occurred. She was summoned home by telegram. The women of the Borden family kept their dresses in a clothes-press in a large window-lighted closet on the second floor of the house. Saturday morning (the murder occurred on Thursday) when Emma went to the closet to hang up her dresses, every hook was occupied, and she saw on one of them Lizzie's old Bedford-cord dress, which, since the preceding May, had been all covered with paint. The paint, Emma says, was all down its front and on many places on each side and along the bottom of the skirt. She says she told Lizzie that that old dress was in the way and ought to be destroyed, and that the burning of it the next morning was the result of her suggestion. That dress, Miss Borden on her oath declared, was in that closet in the full glare of the open window, with the paint all over it, and observable at a glance. When the police officers on Saturday afternoon searched the house they went through that closet in squads and platoons. She says she saw it there. Officer Fleet says he handled every dress and did not see it at all. Two or three officers, I forget their names, told the same story. None of them saw it. Which shall be believed?
CONFIRMED BY THE DRESSMAKER'S EVIDENCE.
Miss Borden is not alone in her statement that the dress was thus covered with paint. Mrs. Raymond, the dressmaker, who made it, says it was, too. She was in the house making dresses when Lizzie got the paint on it, and she remembers all about it. So as to the paint there is the evidence of the painter himself, who, acting under Lizzie's instructions, was painting the house. He does not know that she got any paint on her clothes, but he knows that she stood around while the work was going on, constantly giving instructions. There is the testimony of Mrs. Raymond and of Emma Borden, and there is nothing against it but the evidence of a knot of policemen who say they did not see it.
She burned it in broad daylight. It was a foolish thing to do, but why should she have been thinking about what not to do lest she, the dead man's own and loving daughter, be accused of murdering him?
MISS RUSSELL CONTRADICTED.
Miss Russell, in whose testimony for the prosecution the dress incident was first brought out, appears to be the sort of young woman of whom householders in Fall River may well beware. When she told the story she said that as Lizzie entered the kitchen with the dress on her arm, and started toward the stove, Emma looked up and said:
"What are you going to do with that dress?"
Emma says she didn't say it. Emma says she knew just exactly what Lizzie was going to do with the dress, because she herself had suggested the doing of it. Miss Russell testified that when Lizzie, replying to Emma's alleged question, said: "I'm going to burn it; it is all over paint," she (Miss Russell) quickly remarked: "I wouldn't do that if I were you, Lizzie, where anybody could see me," and that Lizzie thereupon stepped back a pace or two from the window. Emma testified to-day that she was in the room all the time: that she didn't hear anything of that kind said, and she doesn't believe it was said. The burning was done as a matter of course, without thought of consequences. There were consequences in Miss Russell's mind, there is no doubt of that, and her thoughts quickly took expression. Monday morning--this is Emma's testimony-- "Miss Russell came from the dining-room and said that Mr. Hanscom had asked her if all the dresses were there that were there on the day of the tragedy, and she had told him yes, and that she had told him a falsehood. It was decided by my sister and myself that she should go and tell him that a dress had been burned."
Mr. Hanscom was a private detective, the chief of the Pinkerton bureau, employed by the Borden sisters. Miss Russell went to him as agreed and told him of her falsehood. It may have been a kindly, well-meant lie, but it was as little appreciated by the Borden sisters as the apparently unkind and ill-meant truth she has since been telling.
No candid person can listen to the evidence which the defence has produced to-day without a tremendous feeling of indignation. It is directed chiefly against the Fall River police, but the District-Attorney deserves a share of it. At the close of yesterday's session it seemed clear that at least three policemen had committed perjury, and that the whole crowd of them had been contriving to convict Lizzie Borden on evidence either entirely false or false in color. That is, it seemed as if they had taken a number of little incidents and added to them, or subtracted from them, clearly producing the effect of suspicious circumstances, which, truthfully represented, they were not. Let it be remembered that it is on these little circumstances, scores of them and all strung together and brought to bear on the one great fact that Lizzie was present in or about the house when these murders were done, and that she only was there throughout that time, so far as is known—it is on these circumstances that the Commonwealth asks the forfeit of her life.
MANY PEOPLE AT THE BARN.
One of these is her tale about being in the barn from about 11 o'clock until fifteen minutes after, that being the time when her father at least was killed. Officer Medley seemed to make it sure that she must have told a falsehood. He said he reached the Borden house on the day of the murders about 12:20, and before any one else was there except two other officers and Lizzie's friends—Dr. Bowen, Mrs. Churchill and Miss Russell; that, hearing Lizzie's account of herself, he straightway went to the barn and searched it upstairs and down; that, finding nothing suspicious, he was about to come away, when it occurred to him to put his eyes on a level with the floor, and, doing so (the barn was not in use as such, nor for any other purpose than as a storehouse), he noticed the footprints he had made showed in the sediment of dust there, but could not see any smaller footprints. This was damaging evidence, but now it turns out that nearly a dozen people had been to the barn and all over it before Medley had so much as reached the Borden house. The proof of this is overwhelming. It comes from persons of every degree, some of whom saw one another, and none of whom saw Medley until after they had come out of the barn and returned to the house; and the best and clearest of these witnesses, Mr. Stevens, the Fall River reporter, having thus visited the barn, actually saw Medley turning in from the street to go into the house at the very time which Medley gives as the time of his first arrival.
The witnesses who have demonstrated the valuelessness of Medley's fancy sketch are all
Fall River people, all acquaintances of the police officers, and they all at that time freely told of their visit to the barn. The police must have known that Medley's story could be impeached. If they didn't, they were grossly incompetent detectives. If they did, they give occasion to doubt their integrity. The first of these infer- ences might be accepted but for the fact that throughout this trial the stories of the police-
men have been so often self-contradictory, and are now by the defendant's witnesses so often and so positively denied. From the time Gov-
ernor Robinson worked the fact out of Officer
Mullaly that the handle of the hatchet to which police suspicion finally attached was found by Officer Fleet in the same box where he found the head, Fleet having previously sworn that the handle was not there at all, and had never been discovered—from that time the police testimony has been breaking to pieces. Perhaps the worst example of this is the last—the story of Mrs.
Reagan, the matron of the Fall River police station. She swore that on the 26th of August,
Lizzie being then confined as a prisoner in the matron's room, Emma visited her and the two sisters had a quarrel. She said she was in the room all the time, and yet the only part of the quarrel she heard was Lizzie's charge, "Emma, you gave me away"; Emma's reply, "Lizzie, I
did not give you away," and Lizzie's retorting declaration, "Yes, you did give me away, but I
shall not give in an inch." Then Mrs. Reagan polished up her story by telling how Lizzie, who was lying on the sofa, turned over and refused to have anything further to do with her sister, and how they parted without saying goodby.
THE POLICE MATRON'S EVIDENCE DISPOSED OF.
Mrs. Reagan told this story boldly. The cross-examination was directed to discover whether she had not, when that story got out, declared that it was wholly false, and that she was not a witness to any such quarrel or to any quarrel. She was asked whether she had not offered to sign a paper containing this denial and had not been restrained from doing so by the positive interposition of Marshal Hilliard. All this was positively denied by Mrs. Reagan. She insisted that she had overheard the quarrel; that it occurred precisely as she had testified; that she never denied having overheard it, and never offered to sign the paper. To-day Miss Emma Borden solemnly assured the jury that no such quarrel ever occurred; that Lizzie never said anything of the kind to her nor she to Lizzie; that when the story first came out in the newspapers, she went to Mrs.
Reagan about it, and Mrs. Reagan did deny it and offer to sign the paper.
It is not hard to find out who is the perjurer here. The defence produced half a dozen witnesses to whom Mrs. Reagan did deny it. They put the correspondent of "The New-York Herald"
on the stand. He said that he was present when in Marshal Hilliard's presence she offered to sign the paper, and the Marshal forbade her doing anything of the kind. The prosecutor called Marshal Hilliard in rebuttal, but oddly enough, he didn't rebut at all. He said that Mrs. Reagan came to his office with a Mr. Buck. Mr. Buck handed a paper to him and said that Mrs. Reagan was willing to sign it if he said so. He glanced at it, and told her that she must not sign it, but must go to her room and attend to her business.
Now, what was the use of the prosecution bringing forward such testimony as that of the Reagan woman? They must have known that she had been lying at some time, either when she told of the quarrel or when she expressed her willingness to deny it. It is the simple truth that you cannot touch the police testimony at any point without evoking a hollow sound, and if Lizzie Borden is acquitted somebody ought to be made to pay dearly for the unconscionable wrong that has been inflicted upon her. All these policemen have been promoted since the Borden tragedy. Where then they were special officers and patrolmen, they are now captains, inspectors and assistant marshals. Their salaries have been increased. What are these rewards for? It looks as if that were a question for the Grand Jury of Bristol County to find the answer to, and it is to be hoped that District-Attorney Knowlton will be no less active and serviceable in assisting the Grand Jury in solving that question than he has been in driving Lizzie Borden to her peril.
A correspondent reports that courtroom opinion is swinging toward Lizzie Borden's innocence, with defense witnesses undermining police testimony and suggesting a conspiracy. Borden did not take the stand, reportedly due to exhaustion and nervous strain rather than any admission of guilt.
New-York Tribune · 17 June 1893 · page 1
MISS BORDEN NOT PUT ON THE STAND. Lizzie Borden dil not go on the stand. Some persone will undoubtedly draw an inference from this fact to her disadvantage, This is the natural,
The report describes District Attorney Knowlton's harsh two-day inquest examination of Lizzie Borden, detailing graphic questions about her father's wounds that reduced her to despair, and criticizes Knowlton's prosecutorial methods and appearance. It also notes that Emma Borden's trial testimony was effective for the defense.
New-York Tribune · 17 June 1893 · page 1
EXPLANATIONS DUE FROM MR. ENOWLTON. If the jury acquits Lizzie Borden, Mr. Knowle ton will have some rather ugly things to explain, It appears that there is not a fact that hae
This news digest reports that testimony in the Lizzie Borden murder trial at New Bedford, Mass., was finished, with the court adjourning until Monday. It notes that Emma Borden gave strong evidence in her sister's favor.
New-York Tribune · 17 June 1893 · page 6
to be only indigestion. =——= The taking of testi. mony in the Borden murder trial at New-De ford, Masa.,, was finished, and the court adjourn 4 till Monday; Emma Borden gave strong evidence in her sister's favor. Harvard authorities decided upon new requirements for admission t. the law school. ——=: The wilitia was ordered to be in readiness to repress a threatened outbreak among the striking lumber shovers at Tonawanda. City and Suburban.—The Infanta Eulalie arrived in the city and went to the house of J. AL Ceballos, which has been placed at her disposal, The meeting of the Southern Railway and Steamship Association came to an end. === Winpers at Morris Park: St. Florian, Sunbeam colt,
The report states that the Borden trial has essentially concluded, with all evidence presented and the case to be summed up for the jury on Monday. It notes the defense's evidence, particularly from Lizzie's sister, was strong and that Lizzie herself did not testify, attributed to the strain of the ordeal rather than guilt.
New-York Tribune · 17 June 1893 · page 6
cep The Borden trial is practically closed. Al the evidence has been taken, and the court has adjourned until Monday, when the case will be cummed up and given to the jury. The last day's testimony showed still more conclusively ho weakness of the prosecution's case, and was sirongly favorable to the prisoner. Her sisters evidence was particularly clear and streng, especially in refirence to the paint-stained gown and the story told by the prison matron, and on eross-examination she did not swerve a Fars breadth, Interesting and important evidence in corroboration of several of the prisoner's previous statements was also given.
See moreSee less
Lizzie Borden herself was not put on the stand ; a circumstance which the prosecution will doubtless dwell on impressively in summing ap. It must be remembered, however, that this unfortunate woman has been subjected to a tremendous strain for nearly a year, and that do—with reas n—s ands in almost merial dread of Di trict-Att ney Knonlion. At all events. there can be hardly a shadow of doubt that her counsel hive made out their cis» without compoling her to face the terible batteries of the prosecution on eross-examination.
Emma Borden testified at trial that Lizzie had no motive and that their relationship was cordial, especially in recent years. She also described finding Lizzie's paint-stained Bedford-cord dress in the closet two days after the murder.
New-York Tribune · 17 June 1893 · page 2
? hurt of the prisoner. At times Le pressed her fiotly, with the evident intention of getting her confused, Dut &he neither became confused nor angry, and the answers ehe gave were plainly the answers of a truthful, honest heart, They did not avail the State in its prosecution of Lizzie Borden, because the fucts do not avail it. There was no motive for her to commit the crime alleged against her, If anything were lacking to prove that before Emma took the stand, it is not lacking now, “1 was the one,” she said, * who felt resentinlly toward Mrs.
See moreSee less
Borden. It was not Lizzie. Their relations were alwavs cordial until that matter of property came up. Six years ago Lizzie aid not feel nearly so strongly about that as I did, and the last three vears of their lives together were the pleasantest of all. They were on terms of absoInte and constant ecr jality.” She turned to the jury ae she concluded that statement, and said clowly and with a solemnity that I dare not emphazise lest I give some touch of the affectation from which it was ro perfectly (ree: “What I have said is just the truth.” Every man in the box, I think, believed her.
The report covers Lizzie Borden's courtroom testimony about burning a paint-stained dress, with her sister Emma and the dressmaker corroborating that the dress was covered in paint. It notes the stark contradiction with police officers who testified they searched the closet and never saw any such dress.
New-York Tribune · 17 June 1893 · page 2
CONFIRMED BY THE DRESSMAKER'S EVIDENCE. Miss Borden is not alone in Ler statement that the dress was thus covered with paint. Mrs. Raymond, the dressmaker, who made it, says it waa, too, She was in the house making dresses when Lizzio got the paint on it, and she remembers all about it. So as to the paint there is the evidence of the painter himself, who, acting under Lizzie's instructions, was painting the house. Ile does not knew that she got any paint on her clothes, but he kuows that che | stood around while the work was going oa, con- | stuntly giving instructions.
See moreSee less
There is the tostimony of Mrs. Raymond and of Emma Borden, and there is nothing against it but the evidence of a knot of policemen who say they did not gee it. She burned it in brogd daylight. It was a foolish thing to do, but why should she have been thinking about what not to do lest she, the dead man’s own and loving daughtef, be accused of murdering him?
Emma Borden testified that she was present and did not hear Alice Russell warn Lizzie about being seen burning the dress, contradicting Russell's account. The defense also presented evidence suggesting Fall River police had given false or exaggerated testimony about suspicious circumstances.
New-York Tribune · 17 June 1893 · page 2
Mr. Hanscom was a private detective, the chief of the Pinkerton bureau, employed by the Dorden sisters. Miss Russell went to him as agreed and told Lim of her falsehood. It may have been a kindly, well-eant lie, but it was as little appreciated by the Borden sisters as the apparently unkind and ill-meant truth she has since been telling. No candid person can listen to the evidence which the defence has produced to-day without a tremendons feeling of indignation. It is directed chiefly against the Fall River police, but the.
See moreSee less
District-Attorney deserves a share of it. At the 2loso of yesterday's session it seemed clear that at least three policemen had committed perjury, and that the whole crowd of them had been contriving to convict Lizzie Borden on evidence either entirely false or false in color That is, it seemed as if they had taken a number of little incidents and added to thew, or subtracted from them, <learly producing the eflect of suis picious circumstances, which, truthfully repregented, they were not. Let it be remembered that it is on these little circumstances, scores of them and all strung together and brought to bear on the one great fact that Lizzie was present in or about the house when these murders were done, and that she only was there throughout that time, so far es is known—it is on these <2ircumstances that the Commonwealth asis the forfeit of her life,
Emma Borden was expected to testify for the defense despite being listed as a prosecution witness, explaining the dress-burning as unrelated to the murder. Other witnesses denied reports of a quarrel between Lizzie and Emma and disputed the 'you gave me away' story involving Matron Reagan.
The Morning News · 17 June 1893 · page 1
STANDS BY HER SISTER.
MRS. REAGAN’S STORY DENIED. After several unimportant witnesses had testified, Mrs. Mary R. Holmes, a neighbor and memberof tho church which Miss Bprden attended, was called to tho stand. She was present when the officers searched Lizzie Borden's room, and con sidered the search to bo very thorough. She remembered tho publication of tho story of a quarrel between tho Bordeu sisters. Mrs. Reagan hud told her that there was no truth in tho story. She heard Mrs. Reagan say she would sign a denial if Marshal Hilliard was willing. Charles J.
See moreSee less
Holmes testified that Matron Reagan told Buck that the denial of the “you gave ,me away" story was true and that she would sign it if the marshal did not object. John R. Caldwell, a reporter, testified that Marshal Hilliard told Mrs. Reagan if she signed a denial of the. “you gave mo away” story it would bo against ills ex press orders. Mary E. Brigham testified that Matron Reagan said about the story: “It is ail a lie from beginning to end. I was willing to sign that paper hut the marshal would not let me.” Miss Emma Borden was next called. She denied absolutely tho “you-gavo-me away” story, and swore that no quarrel took placo between tho sisters in Matron Reagan’s room. Mr. Kuowlton cross examined with reference to family rela tions. Emma testified that her lather s gift of a house to her step-mother mudo trouble betwoen Lizzie and her step mother, and Lizzie ceased to call her mother and called her Mrs. Borden: hut for two or three years before tho murder ttie relations between Lizzie and Mrs. Borden was entirely cordial, and if she had testified to the contrary ut tho pre liminary hearing that was untrue. THE DRESS THAT WAS BURNED.
Witnesses testified that Matron Reagan denied the published story of a quarrel between Lizzie and Emma Borden, saying she would have signed a denial but Marshal Hilliard forbade it. Emma Borden testified about family relations and described in detail the paint-stained dress Lizzie burned, which Emma herself had suggested destroying.
The Morning News · 17 June 1893 · page 1
not let me.” Miss Emma Borden was next called. She denied absolutely tho “you-gavo-me away” story, and swore that no quarrel took placo between tho sisters in Matron Reagan’s room. Mr. Kuowlton cross examined with reference to family rela tions. Emma testified that her lather s gift of a house to her step-mother mudo trouble betwoen Lizzie and her step mother, and Lizzie ceased to call her mother and called her Mrs. Borden: hut for two or three years before tho murder ttie relations between Lizzie and Mrs. Borden was entirely cordial, and if she had testified to the contrary ut tho pre liminary hearing that was untrue. THE DRESS THAT WAS BURNED.
The Morning News · Savannah, Ga. · and 1 other paper
Emma Borden, cross-examined at trial, denies knowledge of a handleless hatchet and denies any quarrel with Lizzie, calling newspaper reports of a rift false. Marshal Hilliard then testifies in rebuttal about Mrs. Reagan's retraction of her quarrel story, after which the defense rests.
The Morning News · 17 June 1893 · page 1
THE DRESS THAT WAS BURNED.
THE HANDLE LESS HATCHET. After the recess Emma Borden resumed the stand on cross-examination: “I never have seen the handleless hatehot and I don’t know anything about it. I don’t re member ever seeing but one hatchet ami I
The defense concluded its testimony in the Lizzie Borden murder trial, with closing arguments and the judge's charge to follow. Emma Borden testified about the burned dress and a police station interview, and witness Sarah Hart described seeing a young man at the Borden gate on the morning of the murders.
The Indianapolis Journal · 17 June 1893 · page 1
NEARLY READY FOR THE JURY
Interview at th Police Station. New Bedi oiid, Mass., June Id The most sensational and mysterious murder case New England has known will foon be given to the jury. This alternoon. at S:13 o'clock, the defense in tho Borden trial rested its case. There was less of a crowd at the court house this morning, at the resumption ot the trial, than there has been at any timo slnco it was commenced. Among the early visitors was Miss Emma Borden, who, it was understood, was to be called by the defense, although she was down as a gov ernment witness.
See moreSee less
Miss Lizzie Borden told ex-Governor Kobinson, as he greeted her, this morning, that she had not passed n very restful night, and tho intimation came with a cheering smile that she would feel better by and by. The decision rela tive to the admission of the evidence oi the Portuguese who saw tho man with thf bloody hatchet talking to himself about "poor Mrs. Borden," was, in order, the first thing, and when tho jury had beet polled counsel entered into a consults tion with the justices upon some point! which the latter desired more clearly. Fol lowing this the court said it was clear that tbe evidence could not be admitted. The first witness to-day was Sarah IL Hart, fche testified to having passed the Borden house on tho morning of the day ot the murders. "About th50 a. M.. on the day of the murders," said she, T passed by Mr Borden's house with my sister-in-law, Mrs. Manley. We passed by the north gate, and stopped there to speak to my nephew, whe was in a carriage. While I was there I saw a young man standing in the gateway. It was not Mr. Borden. He was resting his
Witnesses testify about a stranger seen at the Borden gate and about the chaotic scene at the house after the murders, with reporters denying any factual basis to Mrs. Reagan's rumored 'give-away' interview about a quarrel between Lizzie and Emma. The testimony undercuts earlier sensational reports of a jailhouse confession-like exchange between the sisters.
The Indianapolis Journal · 17 June 1893 · page 1
NEARLY READY FOR THE JURY
I was close to her all the timo. She ap peared to be somewhat distressed. 1 saw no signs of blood on her head, hair, hands or dress." By this witness it was proven that many people were swarming about the Borden house and in the barn where Lizzie is said to have been during tbe murders, and where officer Medley after wards subsequently went and could find no trace of Miss Borden or anyone else. the "give-away" story untrue. John J. Manning, a Fall River newsoapei reporter, was next called. He said Lo first heard of tbe Borden murder some time be
Reporters and witnesses testify at the trial about Mrs. Reagan's alleged story of a quarrel between Lizzie and Emma Borden, which she denied and sought to retract. A written denial was prepared but Mrs. Reagan was not allowed to sign it because the marshal refused permission.
The Indianapolis Journal · 17 June 1893 · page 1
Borden and have known who she was from childhood. She is a member of the church I attend. I first heard of the Borden murder at 11:45 a. m. I went to the
Emma Borden testifies about Lizzie burning a paint-stained dress and denies newspaper reports of a quarrel between them, insisting relations with their stepmother were cordial. The dressmaker who made the dress and other witnesses, including Mrs. Bowman, also give testimony about the dress, Lizzie's appearance, and the murder scene.
The Indianapolis Journal · 17 June 1893 · page 2
DID NOT QUAllKEL WITH HER SISTER. "I remember tbe story about tbe quarrel between sister and myself. I never bad any such conversation witb my sister as was reported. Tbere was never any troublo or quarrel in the matron's room between ua while she was there, or anything that could be construed into a quarrel. Lizzie never did put up ber finger and say any thing about giving in.'7 Witness contend ed that the relations between Lizzie and Mrs. Borden were entirely cordial. Wit
A Herald survey of criminal lawyers across the country found near-unanimous opinion that the Commonwealth's case against Lizzie Borden was weak, lacking proven motive and strong incriminating evidence. Even the state's 'exclusive opportunity' theory was seen by most as undermined.
The Indianapolis Journal · 17 June 1893 · page 2
VIEWS OF CRIMINAL LAWYERS.
Hvldence la Insufficient to Convict. New Yoiik. June 16. Instructions were lent by telegraph yesterday to the Herald correspondents in many ot tho large cities of the country to interview leading crim inal lawyers on the evidence presented by Commonwealth of Massachusetts in Its caso against Lizzie Borden, accused of the murder of her father and stepmother. The correspondents were particularly In structed to get expressions of opinion as to the suinViency of the evidence introduced
A newspaper opinion piece observes that Lizzie Borden's lack of emotional outbursts during her trial has led some to believe she is guilty, since she doesn't employ typical sympathy-inducing tactics used by female defendants. It notes growing sentiment toward her innocence among correspondents, but speculates public opinion might differ if she were considered pretty and more visibly distressed.
The Indianapolis Journal · 17 June 1893 · page 3
If Sh Were Only Pretty. New York Commercial Advertiser. Lizzie Borden's eondnot dnring the trial has proved her to be a most unsenti mental woman. Doubtless this faet has inclined people to beliove in her guilt, though her freedom from tricks to which female prisoners often resort to work on the sympathies of jurors should count in her favor. The correspondents report a growing sentiment approving the theory of her innocence, hut there is a suspicious lack of contingent of champions who are positively, persistently, indignantly sure that she is innocent. Hovr different it would all be if the defendant were pretty, tcarfnl and frivolous.
The report analyzes the Lizzie Borden trial, noting it is ending sooner than expected because some testimony was ruled out and the prosecution declined to examine many subpoenaed witnesses. It argues the State's theory of 'exclusive opportunity' was undermined by cross-examination showing doors were unlocked and others had access to the house.
The Indianapolis Journal · 17 June 1893 · page 4
THE LIZZIE BQBDEN CASE. It is evident that the Lizzie Borden trial will end much sooner than was ex pected when it began. This is partly due to the fact that some of the testi mony, which the State expected to in trodnce was ruled out, and partly to its Voluntary action in declining to ex amine quite a number of witnesses who had been subpoenaed. No lens than ninety witnesses were summoned by the prosecution, only about half of whom were examined. If the State bad mado a clear case, the failuio to examine all tho witnesses summoned might be taken as evidence that it was not deemed necessary, but it has fallen much abort of making a clear case.
See moreSee less
Under the circumstances, the resting of its case with half of its aubpeenaed wit nesses unexamined looks liko a retreat. The theory of tho prosecution has been exclusive opportunity. It has sought to prove that Lizzie Borden
This commentary argues the prosecution's case against Lizzie Borden is weak, lacking direct evidence, a clear motive for her father's murder, and physical evidence like blood on her clothing. It predicts the jury will either acquit her or fail to reach a verdict.
The Indianapolis Journal · 17 June 1893 · page 4
THE LIZZIE BORDEN CASE.
There is some evidence that she dis liked her stepmother, but none what ever that this feeling extended to her father. Their relations were entirely friendly, if not affectionate. It is con ceded on all hands that the same per son committed both murders. Admit ting that Lizzio Borden, in the heat of passion or in the outbreak of a long smoldering hatred, murdered her step mother, why shonld she havo deliber ately lain in wait to murder a father whom she loved? The prosecution must prove a motive in both cases.
See moreSee less
It has shown a partial, possible one in the case of the stepmother, but none whatever in the case of the father. The entire absence of blood on any of the garments worn by the defendant on the morning of the murder or found in tho house afterward has been a stumbling-block to the prosecution. It would seem impossible for any person to havo hacked two persons to death with a hatchot without being spattered with blood. Yet Lizzie Borden's garments
At the New Bedford trial, Mr. Adams continued cross-examining Dr. Dolan, who described the position of the bodies and stated the blows came from left to right with moderate force. Lizzie Borden sat with closed eyes, holding a fan over her face.
The Citizen · 17 June 1893 · page 3
The Lizzie Borden Trial. New Bedford, Mass., June 18.—Anoth er large crowd was present before the court opened. Miss Borden made her ap pearance ten minutes before the justices took their seats. Mr. Adams continued the cross-examination of Dr. Dolan, who described the position of the bodies and said the blows came from left to right and were of moderate force. The prisoner sat with closed eyes and a fan over her face.
A dispatch from Fall River reports widespread opinion that the prosecution's case against Lizzie Borden is weak. It cites a mocking account of the state's theory that she stripped naked twice to avoid getting blood on her dress while committing the murders.
The Citizen · 17 June 1893 · page 3
The Case Against Lizzie Borden. Fall River, Mass., June 12.—Therecan be no denial that it is a general opinion about town that tha prosecution in the Lizzie Borden case thus far has a very weak case. The prosecution seems to think so itself, for the latest theory credit ed to the state is that Lizzie Borden stripped herself naked twice in one morning and in that condition committed the mur ders in order to keep blood from getting on her dress.
Trial coverage reports defense testimony nearing completion, with witnesses describing the crime scene and a stranger seen near the Borden gate. The report also notes that Police Matron Reagan's account of a conversation between Lizzie and Emma was apparently disproved.
The Wichita Daily Eagle · 17 June 1893 · page 2
THE TESTIMONY FOR THE DEFENSE ABOUT CONCLUDED.
New Bedford, Mass., June 1C There vss less of a crowd at the Borden trial this morning than at any time since the famous case was called. A decision relative to the admission of the evidence of the Portu guese who saw the man with a bloody hatchet maundering about "poor Mrs. Bor den" was the first thing in order. The court decided not to admit th.it evidence. The first witness was Sarah Hart. On the day of the murder, she testified, she passed by the Borden house with her sister at 9:50 o'clock a.
See moreSee less
in. They stopped at the north gato of the Borden grounds to talk with a nephew who was there in a car riage. They saw a young man standing in the gateway. It was not Mr. Borden, lie was resting his head on his left hand, with his elbow resting on the gate. Mrs. Hart was there five miuutes and the man did not change his position except to look at her. She did not know the man. Charles S. Sawyer, a painter, said that he was put on guard at'.he Borden door on the day of the murder. Befoie lie was yiit on guard he was in the houe with Mrs. ChurchillMrs. Russell. .Lizzie Bor den ajid Bridget Sullivan. Lizzie Borden was sitting in a chair and.the others were fauniug her and rubbing her hands. She appeared much distressed. t There were no signs of blood ou any part'of her clothes orperson. People were swarming about the house and barn, whero Lizzie Borden is said to have been during the murder, hut where Officer Medley subsequently went and said that he found no traces of Lizzie or of any one else. John F. Mauning, the Fall river reporter for the Associated Press, said that he had interviewed Police Matron Reagan as to the story she was credited with telling re carding the interview between Emma Borden and the prisoner, in which the lat ter accused her sister of giving her awa Mrs. Kengau told him that there was nothing in the story. Thomas F. Hickey, another reporter, testified that Mrs. Keagan told him that the story was false. Mrs. 5lary Holmes, aclose friend of Liz zie Borden's, said that she taw Mr?, ltea gau and asked her about the story that bhe had overheard Lizzie accuse Emma Borden of having given her away. Mrs. Keagan said that it was not true, and Mrs.
Witnesses at the trial testified about the circulated story that Lizzie Borden had accused her sister Emma of 'giving her away,' allegedly overheard by police matron Mrs. Reagan. Multiple witnesses, including Emma Borden herself, said Mrs. Reagan denied the story and would have signed a paper refuting it, but Marshal Hilliard would not permit her to do so.
Emma Borden denied Lizzie had given hostile testimony about family relations at the preliminary hearing, stating the family was cordial despite Lizzie once refusing to call her stepmother "mother." The defense rested its case at 3:15 p.m., followed by brief rebuttal witnesses and Justice Mason's instruction to the jury not to form an opinion before hearing everything.
The Wichita Daily Eagle · 17 June 1893 · page 2
ABOUT CONCLUDED
her. Emma Borden denied tho story in toto She said that Mr. Borden had given Lizzie considerable property stock in several banks, manufacturing concerns and trust companies. Mr. Borden wore a ring ou his finger given him by Lizzie. The "fam ily relations between the various members ot the family, iucluumg Lizzie and their stepmother, were entirely cordial. If she li.ul testified to the coiitiary at the prelim inary hearing it was untrue. When Mr. Bordou gave Mrs. Borden the house Lizzie declined to address Mrs. Borden as moth er, aud called her Mrs.
See moreSee less
Burden. That was three years ago, however, and their rela tions had beeu resumed long before the murder. 'iho defense rested their case at 3:15 o'clock p. m. A few witnesses were then called in re buttal by Mr. Moody, but nothing impor tant was elicited. One other witness will be called by tue defense on Monday. After a consultation of the counsel Jus tice Mason addressed the jury, telling them iiol to form an opiuion till they had beard the whole case. Adjourned till Monday morning.
The report notes that Lizzie Borden, accused of murdering her father and stepmother, is on trial at New Bedford, Massachusetts. It describes her as remaining composed despite the pressure, with the writer asserting that the evidence against her is strong.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
St. Landry Clarion · 17 June 1893 · page 2
Miss Lizzie Borden, accused of the murder af her father and step-mother at Fall River, Mass., is on trial at New Bedford, that State. She holds up well under the mental strain naturally con nected with the knowledge that she is being tried for her life. Though the proofs of her guilt are strong, she does not break down and cry, and thus give evidence of her guilt. Paul B. Jumel, son of Allen Jumel, and E. D. Leche, fought with pistols at St. Gabriel on the 8th inst., on ac count of an old family feud.
See moreSee less
Jumel was killed and Leche dangerousiy wonnded. At a municipal election at Lake Charles a few days ago, the ticket headed by Pat. Crowley was elected over the one headed by 8, O. Shattuck.
The report notes that Lizzie Borden, on trial at New Bedford for the murder of her father and stepmother, received little sympathy from women observers. It contrasts this with how female sympathy would typically manifest for a male defendant, suggesting the brutality of the crime overrides typical gendered reactions.
The Democratic Advocate · 17 June 1893 · page 2
Treasurer and a County Surveyor. Postmaster-General Bissell a few weeks ago announced that fourth-ciaas postmasters would not be removed except for cause, although they bud served four years. This ruling necessitated the tiling of charges of “offensive partisanship” against those holding on, and so much time was required to examine the charges, the order has been revoked. No charges are neces sary, when a fourth-class postmaster has served lour years, and he will be replaced when a proper Democrat is certified as his successor. All others might as well resign, as a clean sweep is to be made.
See moreSee less
They can save themselves from removal by resigning. The verdict last November was for a com plete change, and was the third successive one. Lizzie Borden, on trial at New Bedford, Massachusetts, for the murder of her father and step-mother, receives no femi nine sympathy. Very few women attend the sessions of the court, and when she fainted no female went to her assistance. If a man were on trial female sympathy would show itself by crowds of women at the trial and showers of flowers to the ac cused. And it seems the more shocking the murder, the deeper is female sympathy —a sympathy that partakes of affection and transforms the criminal into a hero. Journalistic. Our highly esteemed contemporary, the Port Tobacco Times, closed last week the fiftieth year of its existence. The Tinges has always stood well among Maryland county journals, and under the present management is in the front rank. i Willi the commencement of its fifteenth
At the Lizzie Borden trial in New Bedford, defense witnesses Dr. Handy and Mrs. Delia Manley testified to seeing a pale, agitated young stranger near the Borden property around the time of the murders. Plumber George T. Borden also testified about finding the front door unlocked when he visited the house the day after the killings.
Der Deutsche Correspondent · 17 June 1893 · page 4
Der Prozeß
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
Multiple defense witnesses testified, including a reporter who heard footsteps in the barn loft and an ice cream vendor who saw a woman leaving the barn around 11 a.m. Other witnesses, including Emma Borden, disputed police matron Reagan's account of an alleged quarrel between the sisters.
Der Deutsche Correspondent · 17 June 1893 · page 4
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
A roundup of short news items states that the indications in the Borden trial point strongly toward an acquittal. It also mentions another hatchet found in Fall River, questioning whether it has any real connection to the murder weapon evidence already produced in court.
Daily Kennebec Journal · 17 June 1893 · page 2
River. Unless it is *bown to have closer connection with the Borden murder than the hatchet* produced in court, the finder of it will not he entitled to much fame. The German Socialist* have made the greatest political gains ont of the German'
The report argues the prosecution has appeared weak during the trial, lacking strong material and having its key points undermined by cross-examination from ex-Governor Robinson. It also notes that Lizzie Borden had been under morphine's influence during her earlier inquest testimony, which was excluded from the current trial.
Daily Kennebec Journal · 17 June 1893 · page 2
A Weak Prosecution. The efforts of the prosecution in the Bor den murder case for the pas) ten days have left those moat firmly convinced of Lizzie Borden's guilt in doubt. The prosecution ha* appeared very weak. Thi* does not appear to be the fault of those conducting the prosecution. They have lacked mate rial. Their witnesses have not said a* much as was generally ex pected they would aay. Their strong-1 eat statement* when exposed to the keen ' cross questioning of ex-Governor Robinson lost nearly all the significance originally at-' tributed to them. The jury will not know what Litxie's testimony was before the star1 chamber court, the decision of which con- ■
This report discusses the trial's circumstantial evidence, noting Lizzie Borden was under morphine influence during earlier testimony and that no clear motive was established. It highlights contradictory testimony from police witnesses, particularly Matron Reagan's disputed account of an overheard statement between Lizzie and her sister.
Daily Kennebec Journal · 17 June 1893 · page 2
diseases, is proceeding ia a manner the best physicians like to avoid. This theory of variation need* strong support and in the case of Lizzie Borden doesn't appear to have had it. Indeed no clear motive has been shown why she should have commit' ted the deed. All are too familiar with dif ficulties incident to a household to believe that any enmities in the Borden household afforded a reasonable motive to drive a girl, long known in the communi ty as a very respectable person, to such
At the Borden trial, witnesses including Sarah Hart, Charles Sawyer, and reporter John Manning testified about the morning of the murders, while others denied the matron Mrs. Reagan's claim of a quarrel between the sisters. The court excluded defense evidence about a mysterious bloody-shirted man seen near Steep Brook.
The Portland Daily Press · 17 June 1893 · page 1
THE TALE IS TOLD
FATE OF LIZZIE BORDEN. Closing Evidence for the Defence—The Sister of the Accnsed the Principal Wit ness of the Day.—She and Others Deny Mrs. Beagan’s Story of the Quarrel —More About the Paint Covered Dress. New Bedford, .Tune 12.—At the Bor den trial this morning the court exclud ed the evidence offered yesterday by the defence, as to the appearance at Steep Brook, 12 days after the murders, of a strangely acting man with a bloody shirt and hatchet. Sarah Hart corroborated Mrs. Man ley’s testimony yesterday about a young man standing at the Borden gate post Jin the morning of the murders and fixed the time at 9.50.
See moreSee less
Charles F. Sawyer saw the prisoner in the Borden house just after the murders. People were fanning her, and her clothes were not disarranged or bloody. He saw people around the barnAlfred Clark son, a witness of yesterday being among them.
Defense witness Mrs. Holmes described Lizzie's relationship with the victim and testified that Lizzie wept over the caskets before the funeral. She also recounted Dr. Bowen's caution about admitting visitors and an incident involving Mrs. Reagan's denial of the 'You gave me away, Emma' story.
The Portland Daily Press · 17 June 1893 · page 1
she called a pretty thorough search in Lizzie’s and Miss Emma’s rooms. District Attorney Knowlton objected strenuously to Mrs. Holmes making any statement as to Lizzie’s manifestations in the presence of the dead at the funeral of her father and Mrs. Borden. The court allowed the preliminary questions, and Mrs. Holmes testified that Lizzie weut down into the room where both the bodios lay prepared for burial. This was before the funeral. Both bod ies were in one room. “What did Lizzie do?” caused an im mediate check and a long whispered con sultation between judges and counsel at the bench. Mrs. Holmes was given a chair. Lizzie Borden burled her face in
Emma Borden testified at the inquest/trial about Lizzie's bank accounts and property, totaling over $4800, and about an inventory of dresses found in the house. She also described the blue Bedford cord dress, stating it was made in May and worn the next morning, contradicting earlier testimony that placed its creation in March.
The Portland Daily Press · 17 June 1893 · page 1
deposit Fall River Five Cent Savings i Bank, $541: certificate Fall River Ha- . tional Bank; four Shares of Merchants’ , Manufacturing Company’s stock, dated . April 3, 1883, and five shares of the same . stock, dated 1851 (the par of Merchants’ mill stock is $100), and this would make the total of Lizzie’s possessions $4811. Emma presented an inventory of the dresses in the clothes closet upstairs, i There were 18 there belonging to her sis er andjherself and one belonging to Mrs. Borden. She said that Dr. Dolan gave her his positive assurance that the search of the house had been as thorough as it could be without the paper was torn from the walls or the carpets ripped up from the floors.
See moreSee less
Miss Borden’s eye frequently strayed 1 to Lizzie’s chair, where the younger sis
The defense's case in the Lizzie Borden trial is nearly complete, with Emma Borden testifying about the family home and relations. Earlier testimony about a Portuguese witness and bloody hatchet was ruled inadmissible, and a neighbor testified Lizzie wept while viewing her father's body.
St. Paul Daily Globe · 17 June 1893 · page 1
THE DEFENSE RESTS.
Nptw Bedfokd. Mass-, June 16.— There was less of a crowd at the court house this morning at the resumption of the Borden trial than at any time since the beginning of the trial. The decision relative to the admission of the evidence of the Portuguese who saw the man with the bloody hatchet was in order the first thing this morning, and after the jury had been polled counsel en tered into a consultation with the jus tices upon some points which the latter desired to hear. Following this the court said it was clear that tha evi dence offered on the head above referred to could not be admitted.
See moreSee less
Mrs. Mary R. Holmes, a neighbor and member of the church which Miss Borden attended, was then called to the stand. Witness was asked whether Lizzie went down to look at her father's body before the funeral, was objected to, but the court, assuming the question to be preliminary, allowed it to be answered, witness answering in tho affirmative. Witness was asked what Lizzie did when she went down into the room, and this was objected to; thereupon the chief just ice called counsel to the desk for consultation, the result of which was thai the question was changed to "At this time when she was viewing her father did she shed tears?" The answer was yea. Miss Emma Borden was called. Sue 'estitied as follows:
Emma Borden testifies about Lizzie burning a dress and a disputed account of a falsehood told to detective Hanscom, denying reports of a quarrel between the sisters and describing Lizzie's relations with Mrs. Borden as cordial. A dressmaker describes the paint-stained dress Lizzie wore, arguing it could not have concealed blood, while other witnesses recount Lizzie's condition and an experiment on visibility in the murder room.
St. Paul Daily Globe · 17 June 1893 · page 1
Had Told a Falsehood. My sister said at the time: "Why didn't you tell him about it? Why did you let me do it?" 1 remember the story about the quarrel between my sister and I. I never had any such conversation with my sister as was reported; there was never any trouble or quarrel in the matron's nufitQ between us while she was tl:ere, or anything that could be con strued into a quarrel: Lizzie never did put up her hngcr and say anything about giving in. Witness contended that the relations between Lizzie and Mrs. Borden were entirely cordial. Witness said that the breach caused by
A single-line news bulletin reports that the defense has finished presenting its case in the Lizzie Borden trial. No further details are given in this item.
St. Paul Daily Globe · 17 June 1893 · page 1
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
A Fall River correspondent reports widespread local opinion that the prosecution has a weak case against Lizzie Borden, fueled by rumors that the defense will reveal she bought paint before the murders and that dress-burning was common in the household. The report also recounts conflicting police testimony about the hatchet handle and how officers Medley and Desmond handled wrapping the hatchet as evidence.
The Cape Girardeau Democrat · 17 June 1893 · page 1
day long tiik has been plentiful on the? Subject of the Horden murders, and there cart be an denial that it is a gen eral opinion about town that the prose cution thus far has a very weak case. This opinion is being strengthened by rumors current here to the effect that Lizzie Borden's counsel will shortly ex plode a bomb-shell in the camp of the authorities. It is hinted that the de fense will show conclusively that Mx zie Borden purchased some paint a few days In fore the murder and that it was not an nn common thing to burn dresses in the Borden household. Then
Fall River townspeople believe the prosecution has a very weak case against Lizzie Borden, with rumors that her defense will soon reveal a 'bomb-shell' explaining the dress-burning and paint purchase. The report also notes conflicting testimony from Officer Manley about finding a hatchet handle, with police remaining confident despite public opinion favoring the defense.
Macon Beacon · 17 June 1893 · page 1
A VERY WEAK CASE. The Loral Comment on tho Borden Mur. der Trlal-Tho Defense Provided witn a Itomb Which They will Shortly Eiplodo ln the Camp of the Authorltles-Tho Dress-Burning Incident Eiplalned-Tho Hntchot stories. Fall River. Mass., June 11. All day long talk has been plentiful on the subject of the Borden murders, and there can be no denial Wat it is a gen eral opinion about town that the prose cution thus far has a very weak case. This opinion is being strengthened by rumors current here to the effect that Lizzie Borden's counsel will shortly ex plode a bomb-shell in the camp of the authorities.
See moreSee less
It is hinted that the de fense will show conclusively that Liz lie Borden purchased some paint a few davs before the murder and tnat it was not an uncommon thing to burn dresses ln the Borden household. Then
During the Borden trial, defense witnesses testified that reports of a quarrel between Lizzie and her stepmother, and of a quarrel overheard by Matron Hogan, were false. Emma Borden testified she and Lizzie had been on good terms for three years and explained that the paint stains on Lizzie's dress came from house painting done in May.
The Helena Independent · 17 June 1893 · page 1
THERE WAS NO QUARREL,
Nzw BErDoan, Mass., June 10.-When the Borden trial was resumed thie morning. court deioded not to admit the evidence as to the man seen with a bloody hatchet, muttering, "Poor Mrs. Borden." Sarah R. Hart testified that shortly before 10 o'elock, on the morning of the murders, she passed the Borden house and stopped at the north gate. She saw a young man standing iu the gateway. He was still standing there when witness drove away. Chas. S. Saw yer, a painter, of Fall River, testified that he was put on duty at the side door of the Borden house after the murders.
See moreSee less
He was close to Lizzie Borden all the time. She appeated distressed. He saw no signs of blood on her. A number of witnesses were then examined in regard to the story pub. liehed about the time of the murder, in which Police Matron iRogan was quoted as eaying she overheard a quarrel between the Borden stators which went far to fix the guilt on Lizzie. All testified that Mrs. logan pronounced the publication false. Emma Borden. Lizzie's sister, denied that there had been any quarrel between them,
The report describes the ongoing Lizzie Borden trial and a parallel experiment by the New York Recorder, which assembled a twelve-person 'jury' of notable figures including Edward Everett Hale, Samuel Gompers, and Lucy Stone to render an independent verdict based on a stenographic trial transcript. It notes this shadow jury's verdict would carry moral weight even though it has no legal standing, and discusses the lack of apparent motive as a point favoring Borden's innocence.
The Woman's Tribune · 17 June 1893 · page 1
[ methods of the courts and the bias of j counsel influence a decision different I from what persons of soundest judgment and keenest mind would reach unfettered by the machiuery of law. There is one thing to be said in favor of the Recorder's jury, it contains one woman and is thus much of a concession to a woman of the right, that has always been denied to her although held most sacred by man, the right to be tried by a jury of peers. The absence of sufficient motive for the deed has been considered a strong point in favor of Miss Borden, but the annals of crime now record the most in explicable lapses from moral rectitude as if under the influence of some tempo rary obsession or mania, or perhaps they are the sudden breaking through of the thin crust of morality which by the tenacity of custom has lasted long after the depths below were a seething fire of evil thoughts and purpose, that motive often lies beyond human ken.
See moreSee less
That which staggers the public is to believe that any human ingenuity could so suc cessfully and with such lightning rapidity cover up the evidences of crime. The prosecution are attempting to prove that with the hired woman busy around the house, Miss Borden killed her step mother with eighteen blows of a hatchet, removed all traces of blood from her person and of agitation from her man ner and went on ironing until her father came in; that then in a space of time not exceeding thirteen minutes, she 'hacked. head with many blows of the hatchet, took this to the cel lar, broke the handle, scoured the blade and put it away, removed from herself all traces of blood and all within thir teen minutes, the only time she was not under the observation of others between the time of her father’s return and death. If they succeed they will demonstrate a degree of cunning and skill that is not suggested by any of the facts of Miss Borden’s life or of her characteristics. The Tee-To-Tum Club is being found to be a very effective antagonist to the saloon as it fights it with its own weapons: brightness, music and companionship. There are six of these in London and one recently established in New York City, by Calvary church. The origina tor of the idea was Mr. P. R. Buchanan whose thought was to furnish the work ingmen of London a Cafe and Club. The features of clubs organized on this plan are a restaurant where a than can get a aeal for ten cents, a department for the sale of tea and club-rooms with games, books and opportunities for social intercourse.
The article discusses the Recorder's jury's inclusion of a woman and debates whether sufficient motive exists for Lizzie Borden to have committed the murders. It details the prosecution's theory that she killed both victims within a narrow timeframe, cleaned herself and the weapon, and questions whether such cunning matches her known character.
The newspaper opines that the prosecution's case against Lizzie Borden is weak, noting only that circumstances show she had opportunity but she has not been directly connected to the act. It mentions the defense will argue others also had opportunity, and references an extract from the defense's opening statement published elsewhere.
Paper unidentified · 17 June 1893 · page 2
The State having closed its case again:! Lizzie Borden, the general impression s9eins to be that the case made is a very weak one. She has
On the third day of the trial, surveyors and photographers presented evidence on the crime scene, followed by John V. Morse's testimony contradicting the prosecution's barn timeline claim. Bridget Sullivan was the day's key witness, placing Lizzie in the house at the time of the murders but also testifying she never knew of unkind words between Lizzie and her stepmother.
The Press · 17 June 1893 · page 7
AT NEW BEDFORD. |X>aily Progress of the Attempt to Prove That the Daughter, Lizzie, Killed Her Father and Step Mother at Fall River—Her Testi mony at the Inquest Excluded. On the third day of the Borden trial Civil Engineer Kieman was the first witness ex amined. He testified as to the location o£ the bodies when they were found. James A. "Walsh, a photographer, showed views of the [Borden house. Surveyors’ and photogra phers’ evidence being concluded, John V. (Morse, uncle of the prisoner, took the stand. |On cross-examination he swore that (On reaching the Borden house after the mur der he saw no officers in the yard ; that the pm door was closed and he heard no one [Inside.
See moreSee less
This contradicted the Government’s claims that officers, by immediate exam ination of the bam, ascertained that the pris oner could not have been there at the time jof the murder. A. G. Hart, Joseph Short |leve and James Mather, witnesses, called After live minutes’ recess fixed the time when Mr. Borden was last seen. Cross-examina Ition developed nothing but slight confusion And uncertainty as to the exact time. Mis3 [Borden yawned and looked on listlessly. [Mr. Moody then called Bridget Sul livan to the stand. Bridget Sulli fvan was the strongest witness of the day, but while her testimony placed Liz zie Borden, the accused, in the home at the hour of the murdere, the effect of jit was weakened by the statement, re iterated with emphasis, that between the Accused and her stepmother, there had jpever been, to witness's knowledge, an un ikind word. When the cross-examination of [Bridget had been concluded the court ad journed. The line of defence was indicated joy calling on witnesses to testify that the person who committed the murder might lhave been concealed in a closet. • vvnen we ionrtn uay oi uizzie jjoraens trial had ended, from the vague and un ehapely mass of evidence produced by the prosecution, the finger of accusation seemed jto the spectators to point still more directly 1st the prisoner. The first witness was Doc tor Bowen, the physician who was sum moned to the Borden residence after the bodies had been discovered. tie told |the situation of the bodies, and said (that apparently nothing had been (disturbed in the rooms. On cross-examina tion he testified that he had prescribed mor jphiue for Miss Borden to allay nervous (excitement. The doses were increased to double strength and had a ten dency to affect the memory. Mrs. Churchill, who lived in part of the Borden house, testified to occurrences just before the murder. She sab^that Miss Bor den was so pale and excited after the murder aa to attract considerable attention. Miss Alice Russell was then called. She described Mies Borden’s burning the dress Sunday after the murder. Witness went out and came in again and saw Miss Borden stand ing near • the cupboard door and tearing or rippir.g small portions of the dress. Rob inson’s cross-examination failed to shake Miss Russell’s direct testimony. On re-direct ehe testified, against objection by defense, that the cupboard in which witness saw a part of the dress at the time of the burn ing was used only for kitchen utensils. Then there came a string ot officers. Two points were made off George Washington Allan, policeman. One was that a table, un •pattered with blood, was found within three leet of the front of the sofa where Andrew Borden was found dead. The other was the production of a bloodstained and tat tered handkerchief of the bandanna variety, found on the floor, and not hereto ’fore produced. Both these things are
This is a promotional listing for the Sunday World newspaper advertising upcoming feature articles, including one titled 'The Real Lizzie Borden' by Mrs. Elizabeth G. Jordan. It promises an exhaustive, accurate character study of Borden as a 'strange type of the New England woman,' alongside unrelated items on Sandow the strongman and Brooklyn Bridge.
The Evening World · 17 June 1893 · page 6
I j THE REAL LIZZIE BORDEN. 1 HcALLISTER AND TEALL. j K 6 n wenr situation jy ts raurmy. THE WORLD; SATURDAY I. OUR THEATRES NEXT WEEK, BARNETT-DIXON GO TO-HIGHT well as ever at the American Theatre, two weeks, and she will be missed. The and those who thought that Manager new cooling apparlatnf, at this house has French showed IkJ of Judgment In given complete satisfaction putting on such an expensive produc Vanderllp and AdiUr have been entlon before the beginning of the regular
This item is a column of miscellaneous daily commentary and witty asides on various news topics, including a brief remark that the strength of the Borden defense rested on the weakness of the prosecution's case. It also notes the evidence show a reasonable doubt looms large in the Borden case.
The Evening World · 17 June 1893 · page 4
'$ This was to have been Farmer Dunn'r ft alzxard day. The prjphct of the Equly tableBulldlng has played us false. ft ,l. "Cholera spreading In France." It Ir 3 the prime business of other nations tc, ? keep It from spreading out of France. it 5. On the face of the evlt'ence, the marked if characteristic of the Borden case Is thf overshadowlngness of "a rcasonnblt A doubt." 'U
The defense's evidence in the Borden case concluded, with the verdict expected the following Tuesday after closing arguments. The report claims the defense testimony destroyed the prosecution's case and predicts Lizzie Borden will be acquitted, while criticizing the prosecution's conduct.
The Evening World · 17 June 1893 · page 4
NEARING THE END
on the momlng and, as near as can j be judged, lit the time of the murder I of Mr. Borden; that Mrs. Ileagan's Improbable story of a quarrel between the sisters was untrue; that the dress burned by the prisoner was actually i stained by paint and was worthless; that several persons had been In the f barn loft before the Imaginative omcer who could find no footprints In the dust, nnd that a stranger had been seen by two or three witnesses loitering near the Borden house on the morning of tne murders. It is confidently believed that Lizzie Borden will be promptly acquitted. In
A promotional blurb for the Sunday World advertises an upcoming article by Elizabeth G. Jordan billed as 'a striking pen picture' of Lizzie Borden. It promises 'the first exhaustive and accurate presentment of a strange type of the New England woman.'
The Evening World · 17 June 1893 · page 6
THE REAL LIZZIE BORDEN
The words of this article could not be separated from the rest of its page. Read it in the clipping.
This is a promotional blurb from The Sunday World advertising an upcoming feature article by Elizabeth G. Jordan, billed as an exhaustive and accurate character study of Lizzie Borden. It appears alongside other unrelated teasers for stories on Sandow the strongman and Brooklyn Bridge.
The Evening World · 17 June 1893 · page 6
THE REAL LIZZIE BORDEN
The words of this article could not be separated from the rest of its page. Read it in the clipping.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
The Evening World · New York, N.Y.
The defence rested its case, with closing arguments set for Monday and a verdict expected Tuesday. The editorial argues the defence testimony destroyed the prosecution's case, predicting Lizzie Borden's acquittal and criticizing police and prosecutors for alleged misconduct.
The Evening World · 17 June 1893 · page 4
NEARING THE END
NEABINU TBI! i!NU The evidence for the defence In the llorden case was closed yrsterduy and the verdict of the Jury into be ex pected on Tuesday nut. an adjourn ment having been agreed upon until Monday, which day tslll to taken up by the addresses of counsel. The testi mony yesterday seems to have destroy ed every point made by the over-anx-lous prosecution. It proved that Lizzie Borden had actually been In the burn on the morning and, us near as can be Judged, ut the time of the murder of Mr.
See moreSee less
Borden: that Mrs. lleagan's Im probable story of a quarrel between the sisters was untrue; that the dress burned by the prisoner was actually stained by paint and was worthless; that several persons had been In tho burn loft before the Imaginative officer who could find no footprints In the dust, and that a stranger had been seen by two or three witnesses loitering near the Borden house on the morning ot the murders. It Is confidently believed that I.lzzle Borden will be promptly acquitted. In deed, the prosecution has fallen to
This is a promotional listing in The World for its upcoming Sunday edition, teasing various feature articles including one titled 'The Real Lizzie Borden' by Elizabeth G. Jordan. The ad promises 'a striking pen picture' and calls it 'the first exhaustive and accurate presentment of a strange type of the New England woman.'
The Evening World · 17 June 1893 · page 6
J THE REAL LIZZIE BORDEN. ' HcALLISTER AND TEALL. I i I 6 l Ww1' Sltnttui Day it TfcTaJty, i OUR THEATRES NEKT WEEK. two weeks, and she will be missed. The new cooling apparlatus at this house haa given complete satisfaction. Vanderllp and Adair have been en-
The report describes the tenth day of the Lizzie Borden trial, noting druggists testified about her purchase of prussic acid, which the defense contested as unsuitable for cleaning furs. The court excluded all testimony regarding the acid, and the prosecution rested its case, with the writer noting prevailing public opinion favored her innocence.
The Silver State · 17 June 1893 · page 3
; vigorously contested every point of j the prosecution’s testimony, which went to show that the acid was not used for other than medicinal pur I poses, and was unsuitable for clean ing furs, the purpose for which Mias ■ Borden said that she wanted it. Fi , nally the court excluded all testi j mony in regard to prussic acid. The I commonwealth rested its ease. The prevailing opinion is that Miss Borden did not commit the terrible crime of which she is accused. Some of the evidence is strongly against her but at the same time she ; is believed to be innocent by many who are under the impression that the real murderer might be found if mure attention was paid to the wit nesses who are striving to have her convicted.
A brief item observes that the Lizzie Borden trial has not generated the sensational horror expected. It notes the general opinion that the prosecution has so far presented a weak case against her.
Eureka Weekly Sentinel · 17 June 1893 · page 2
The Lizzie Borden trial has not sup plied the amount of horror necessary for it to become a high sensation of the day. It is the general opinion that the prosecution thus far has presented a very weak case against her.
The report describes the ongoing Borden trial in New Bedford, noting the court adjourned until Saturday after a Friday session. It highlights that prosecution testimony has narrowed the murder window to twelve minutes, fueling public skepticism that Lizzie Borden, appearing composed and unruffled afterward, could have physically committed the crime in that time.
The Ohio Democrat · 17 June 1893 · page 3
As the details in this rcmarkablo case come out day by duy the feeling Is grow ing stronger that Lizzio Borden could not have committed tho crime if sho
On June 16 at the Borden murder trial, the court excluded testimony about a mysterious young man seen with a bloody hatchet. Witnesses including Emma Borden denied published reports of a quarrel between Lizzie and her stepmother, with Matron Rogan's alleged account called false.
Paper unidentified · 17 June 1893 · page 1
HER LIFE IN JEOPARDY
New Bedford, Mass.. June 16. The Borden trial was resumed this morning. The court decided not to admit evidence as to the man seen with a bloody hatchet, muttering, "Poor Mrs. Borden." Sarah R. Hart testified that shortly before 10 o'clock on the morning of the murder she passed the Borden house and stopped at the north gate and saw a yoang man standing in the gateway. He was stand ing there when the witness drove away. Charles S. Sawyer, a painter of Fall River, testified that he was put on duty at the side door of the Borden house after the murder.
See moreSee less
He was close to Lizzie Borden all the time. She appeared dis tressed. He saw no signs of blood on her. . A number of witnesses were then ex amined in regard to the story published about the time of the murder, in which Police Matron Rogan was quoted as say ing she had overheard a quarrel between the Borden sisters, which went far to fix the guilt on Lizzie. All testified that Mrs. Rogan pronounced the publication false. Emma Borden, Lizzie's sister, denied that there had been any quarrel between them, as reported. She said Lizzie was at outs with her stepmother at one time, but they had been good friends three years before the murder. ps art's Expedition. The Arctic Explorer Soon to Start on His Voyage.
The report describes the twelfth day of Lizzie Borden's trial, noting rapid progress by the defense and a court recess until Monday. Emma Borden testified in her sister's defense regarding a dress and hatchet, denying an account by Hiram Hengan, while other witnesses corroborated her testimony; the judge also ruled inadmissible testimony about a Portuguese man seen with a bloody hatchet.
The Evening Herald · 17 June 1893 · page 2
GETTING NEAR THE END
EMMA TESTIFIES FOR HER BISTER Hlie Tll About tho Painty Drm anil tlm llRlrlmt, nml Denies tho Story of 1 ill run Ilengnn-Other Witnesses Con firm llrr Mory-Ttie Court Decides to Take n ltest. Nbw Dbdkoud, Mass., Juno 17. The ttvoltth day of the struggle between the two parties In the Borden trial will begin on Monday next The oase has made sucu
Witnesses including Mrs. Holmes, Charles Holmes, John Caldwell, and Mary Brigham testify about Matron Reagan's denial of an alleged quarrel story and the marshal's refusal to let her sign a denial. Emma Borden takes the stand, discussing family tensions over the house gift, denying the sisters quarreled, and answering cross-examination about household routines and an unseen hatchet.
The Evening Herald · 17 June 1893 · page 2
marshal would not let mo." Emma Borden then took the stand. She testified that her father's gift of the house to her stepmother made trouble between Lizzie and her stepmother, and Lizzie ceased to call her mother and called her Mrs. Borden; but for two or three years before the murder tho relations between Lizzie nnd Mrs. Borden were entirely cor dial. If alio had testified to the contrary at the preliminary hearing that was un true. Emma denied absolutely the "You gave mo away" story, and Bwore no quar rel took place between the sisters In Matron Reagan's room. ur. juiowiton cross-examined with reference to family relations. Emma Borden resumed on cross-exami
Emma Borden is cross-examined about household arrangements, the note Lizzie received, waterproofs owned by family members, and the hiring of a detective. She denies key details claimed by Mrs. Reagan and Miss Russell about Lizzie's behavior with the dress.
The Evening Herald · 17 June 1893 · page 2
Fall River for the messenger or the writer. We have made no other search. Mr. Hans oom was a detective employed by my sis ter and I, and w blm first on Sunday after the murders. He wua at our house some. I don't think I can tell bow long he was employed by us, but I think two or three weeks. I never have seen the hand lelet.s hatchet, and I don't know any thing about it I don't remember ever i-ieing but one hatcbet, and I onn't describe it to you; all our family had wa terproofs; Mrj, Borden bad a dark one, It mu kept In the little closet; Llzsie had one
The defense concluded its case at the Lizzie Borden trial, successfully challenging testimony about her alleged stoic demeanor, a burned paint-stained dress, and matron Mrs. Reagan's claim that Lizzie said 'you have given me away' to her sister. Witnesses also testified that Lizzie wept upon seeing her father's mutilated remains.
Pawtucket Tribune · 17 June 1893 · page 1
ORI, / The Tople Treated was the alleged stolidity of the prisoner at the time the murder was discovered, the story of the paint stained dress that she burned up and the veracity of Mrs. Reagan, the police matron, who says she heard Lizzie Borden say to her sister: “You have given me away.” The defeuse enjoyed a perfect and over whelmning success in disposing of all these matters. Too much time was spent over Mrs, Reagan’s tale of the quarrel of the sisters. It was utterly demolished by Lizzie Brigham, yet other women, reporters and citizens generally were called to bury the story deeper than Kidd's treasure is hidden, As to the paint-grimed dress, there was equally ample proof of it, and proof, too, that Miss Russell, the close friend of Liz zie Borden, had told the police of it only when begged to do so by the Borden sisters.
See moreSee less
Finally, there was evidence that Lizzle Borden wept in the presence of the mu tilated remains of her father. Her lawyers
Emma Borden took the stand and gave detailed testimony about Lizzie's finances, her father's ring, and the search of the house. She also explained that the burned dress was a paint-stained, faded garment unfit for reuse, contradicting Alice Russell's earlier account, and described Lizzie weeping over her father's body.
Pawtucket Tribune · 17 June 1893 · page 1
company, 8 £ e She said that the gold ring on Borden's finger was given to him by Lizzie 10 or 15 years ago, she having wora it a long time, and that he prized it highly and always kept it on his little finger, where it was when he was buried. She produced an inventory of 18 or 1§ dresses hanging in their clothes press, and swore,in response to Marshal Fleet's as sertion that the search didn’t amount to much, that Dr, Dolan told her they had sdlirched from attic to cellar, Bridget taking the paper from the walls and the carpets from the floor.
See moreSee less
Her repors as to The Burning of the Dress was interesting by itself and forceful as a distinct challenge of the story told by ‘their former friend, old lady Rusself of Fall River. :
Emma Borden testified about the burning of the dress, Alice Russell's confession of falsehood to Hanscom, and denied Officer Reagan's account of a quarrel between herself and Lizzie. Under Knowlton's cross-examination she maintained her composure and firmly contradicted claims of family discord and the matron's quarrel story.
Pawtucket Tribune · 17 June 1893 · page 1
sbout the quarrel between Lizzie and herJelf. Sentence by sentence she denied the truth of every word, deliberately and em phatically umnz at rest, o far as she was concerned, the whole fabrication. 3 Mr Knowlton’s ingenious cross-examina tion endeavored to prove a condition of ill feeling in the Borden household, but suo ceeded only so far as the witness herseli was concerned. She said that some years ago her fathe: gave Mrs. Borden, her stepmotbher, one half of & house, of which the other half was owned by her sister, the price being about $1500; that this angered Lizzie and herself; in consequence of this their father gave them what is known as their grand father's house, and that after this the cor dial feelings between Mrs.
See moreSee less
Borden and Lizzie Borden were restored, but that such was not the case as between Mrs Borden and the witness. She could not recall but one hatchet as belonging in the house, redenied the ma tron’s story of the quarrel, told agaic sbout the burning of she dress and the falsehood of Miss Russell, described the
The report describes testimony revealing details of the Borden household, including Andrew Borden's finances and his daughters' independence, as well as John Morse's comments on the family's table. It also highlights contradictions in police testimony, particularly Inspector Medley's brief and possibly unreliable examination of the barn loft floor for footprints.
Narragansett Herald · 17 June 1893 · page 1
Prove to be Saving Testimony. There have been interesting glimpses o the home life of the Bordens of Fall River brought out in the testimony on the witness sun‘:fi Andrew DBorden was not mean and stingy. He was *“‘forehanded,” as they say down this way, but when a man ecame tc hire his store for a purpose the old man did not approve of, how quickly he refused to let it go into that tenant's hand. His two daughters were well provided for. The dresses in their close closet upstairs have been too numerous for the officers on the stand to remember.
See moreSee less
Both Lizzie and Emma had bank accounts of their own. They went where they pleased. If not, it was their own fault, not their father’s. Unecle John Morse spoke with gusto of the fact of the abundance of the table. After that it was not so necessary to forgive the warmed over breakfast. 1t 1s these unimportant details that go so far toward strengthening a theory, and when
The court ruled that Lizzie Borden's inquest statements were inadmissible because she was effectively under arrest when questioned, a decision that visibly moved her to tears. Later testimony from medical experts established that Mrs. Borden died one to two hours before her husband and that the murder weapon could have been wielded by a woman of ordinary strength.
Narragansett Herald · 17 June 1893 · page 1
Eighth Day. The State has made substantial progress today, for the first time since the sitting of the court began, in proving its indictment against Lizzie Borden. From the testimony of Prof. Wood of Ilarvard University, physiological chemist, and Drs. Draper and Cheever of Boston, medical and surgical experts, it proved beyond peradventure that Mrs. Borden died from one to two hours before her husband. It was also proven that either the handleless hatchet or one like it was used in the commission of the crimes, and that a woman of ordinary strength might have delivered the death blows upon the heads of each vic im.
See moreSee less
The agreement of testimony on the priori ty of death is of gresater significance in the case than the proof in the other two points because it demonstrates that at the moment when the prisoner was standing at the head of the stairs while Rridget Sallivan was ad mitting Mr. Borden through the front door Mrs. Borden lay dead in the guest’'s room with the door into the hall ajar. The only circumstance that prevents this being absolute proof of guilt is the fact of
On the eighth day of trial, medical experts testified that Mrs. Borden died one to two hours before her husband, and that the handleless hatchet could have caused the wounds and been wielded by a woman of ordinary strength. The defense countered by showing no blood was found on the hatchet or on Lizzie's garments except a small spot explainable by natural causes.
The trial opened in New Bedford with every seat in the courtroom filled. City Marshal Hilliard testified about visiting the Borden house and telling Lizzie she was a suspect, and was cross-examined by Governor Robinson about the thoroughness of the police search.
The Kimball Graphic · 17 June 1893 · page 1
BORDEN MURDER TRIAL. Every Seat in the Court Room Filled Willi the Curious. XKW Hmivoiti), Mass., June M.—Tho liordeu trial was opened promptly at 0 o'clock this morning, every scat being cocupied. Tlie first witness called was City Marshal Billiard, of Kail River, who told of his visit to the Horden house and the conversation with tho prisoner in which she. was told that she was suspected of the crime. The witness was cross-examined by Governor Itobinson who attempted to show that Ilillard was not obstructed in his search of the premises, and that the search of the rooms was thorough.
See moreSee less
Ilillard swore that the search of the Horden house was thorough, and that the defendant gave him all the articles bo asked for, and spoke earnestly and frankly in conversation about the suspicion that she was the murderer.
At the New Bedford trial, prosecutor Moody argued for nearly an hour that Lizzie Borden's inquest statements and conduct showing consciousness of guilt should be admitted as evidence. During his remarks Miss Borden was forced to leave the courtroom due to sudden illness, after which Governor Robinson argued for the defense that her declarations had not been voluntary.
The Kimball Graphic · 17 June 1893 · page 1
LIZZIE BORDEN OVERCOME Forced to Leave the Court Room Through Sudden Indisposition. XKW UEDFOKD, Mass.,.lune 13.—Half the spectators in the court Monday were women and the work of the
At the New Bedford courtroom, a large crowd gathered to hear continued testimony in the Lizzie Borden trial. Defense attorney Adams cross-examined Dr. Dolan, who described the position of the bodies and stated the fatal blows came from left to right and were of moderate force, while Lizzie Borden sat with closed eyes and a fan over her face.
The Kimball Graphic · 17 June 1893 · page 1
The Lizzie Borden Caso. NKW Binmmt), Mass., June 14.—An other largo tyowd was present Tuesday eager to hear the testimony in the Lizzie Horden caso before court opened, Mr.Adams continued the cross
A New York Herald correspondent in Richmond quotes several legal figures, including judges and attorneys, who believe the published evidence against Lizzie Borden is not strong enough to convict her. The item is part of a general roundup of local Richmond news.
Richmond Dispatch · 17 June 1893 · page 3
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
The court excluded testimony about Lizzie Borden's alleged attempt to purchase prussic acid, dealing a third blow to the prosecution's case after earlier exclusions of her inquest testimony and her cousin Anna Borden's testimony. District Attorney Moody then announced the government rested its case, surprising the courtroom, and defense attorney Mr. Jennings began his opening statement.
The Roanoke Times · 17 June 1893 · page 1
Lizzie Borden's Lawyers Now Presenting the Defense
Very Much In Favor of the Defendant. NKV BEDFORD, Muss., June 10.?Tlio court ruled that tlu> preliminary allega? tions had not been made out by the prose? cution, and that, therefore, the testimo? nies relating to the attempt of Lizzie Bor? den to purchase prussic acid must be ruled out. This i.s the third and perhaps fatal blow to the government case. Tu? first was the exclusion of Lizzie Borden's own testimony given at the inquest; the second was the exclusion of the testimony of Anna Borden, the cousin, and this last seemed to be the Hunt set back.
See moreSee less
The greatest surprise in the Borden case came when District Attorney Moody rose, and in his quiet tone announced that tho government rested its case. The announce? ment was shock enough to cause somo per? sons to catch their breath; it caused looks of wonderment on face after face: it made whisperers silent and those who had been silent talk. Lizzie's fan went tip to her face and hid her eyes and countenance: her lawyers looked pleased, and ex-Inspector Ducey of Cambridge, who has been working for the defense for the past throe months, actually smiled. But thiwe were glum looks on the faces of other oflicers?expressions of disap? pointment when the looks of wonder had disappeared. The judges were calm: so wore the jurors as far as appearances went. Witnesses For Hie Defense.
The defense attorney outlines the case for Lizzie Borden's innocence, disputing claims about the barn and the burned dress, and noting no blood was found on her. Witnesses including Martha Chagnon, Charles Clifford, Mark Chase, and Dr. Benjamin Hardy testify about suspicious strangers seen near the Borden house around the time of the murder.
The Roanoke Times · 17 June 1893 · page 1
ask you to see in view of the presumption of Innocence whnl law says you shall con? sider, that no blood was found upon her, and to consider t ho relations liotwoon fat her and daughter." first Willies* Tor Defense. Martha t'hagtion, the little Kreuch ?irl who testified for the prosecution, was the lirst witness for the defense. She i.s a daughter of Dr. ChilgllOU, whose yard is in tho roar of the Borden yard. On the night
Witnesses including a reporter, a relative, and an ice cream peddler testified for the defense, describing a strange man near the Borden house, unlocked doors, sounds in the barn loft, and a woman seen leaving the barn after 11 a.m. Their accounts contradicted earlier police testimony about footprints and timing.
The Roanoke Times · 17 June 1893 · page 1
LNOKE, VA., SATURD the Dell." Walter P. Stevens, who nt the timo of the tragedy was n reporter for one of the Ksill Rlyer dailies, was culled to the stund by IVJr. Jennings. His testimony was the most important for the defense that hud come out up to tili? time. He went to the Borden house on the morning of the trag' edy in the regular course of business. He
At the Lizzie Borden trial in New Bedford, Mass., the defense concluded its testimony, with Emma Borden as the day's principal witness. The judge told the jury all evidence was in but adjourned proceedings until Monday to allow counsel time to prepare closing arguments; general opinion favored acquittal.
Alexandria Gazette · 17 June 1893 · page 2
In the Lizzie Borden trial at Xew Bedford, Mass., the defense concluded its testimony yesterday, Miss Emma Borden being tho principal witness of tho day. The chief justice then ad?
At the Borden trial, witnesses testified about a rumored denial by Matron Reagan regarding a supposed quarrel between the Borden sisters, with Marshal Hilliard reportedly blocking her from signing a denial. Emma Borden took the stand and denied any such quarrel ever occurred.
The Times · 17 June 1893 · page 1
NEW BEDFORD, MASS, June 16.—~ There was less of a crowd at the court house this morning than at any time since the beginning of the Borden trial. Among the early visitors was Emma Bor den, who, it was understood, was to be called for the defense, although down as a Government witness, 2 The Court decided that the evidence of the Portuguese, who saw the man with the bloody hatchet, could not be ad mitted, and Mr. Jennings desired the ex ceptions noted, at the same time stating that he would put in writing just what he intended to show.
See moreSee less
After several unimportant witnesses had testified, Mrs. Mary R. Holn's, a peighbor and member of the zhurch waich Miss Bord:n atten}ed, was called to the vtand. She was present when the officers searched Lizzie Borden's room and considered tha searcn to be lhoriugh. She remembered the publication of the story of a quarrel between ‘he Borden sisters. Mrs. Reagan had told her there was no truth in the story. She heard Mrs. Reagan say she would sign a denial if Marsha! Hilliard was willing. Charles J. Holmes testified that Ma‘ron Reagan told Mr. Buck that the deaial of the “you gave me away’ story was rue, and that she would sign if the marshal did not object, : John R. Caldwell, a reporter, testified that Marshal Hilliard told Mrs. Reagan if she signed the denial of the “you gave me away” story it would be against hiz express orders, Mary E. Brigham testified that Matron Reagan said this about the story: “It is all a le from beginning to end. 1 was willing to sign that paper, but the Mar shal would not let me.” Miss Emma Borden was next ealled. She denied absolutely the “you gave me away” story, and swore no quarrel took place between the sisters in Matron Hea gan's room. Mr. Knowlton crossexam ined her with reference to family rela tions. Emma testified that her father's gift of the house to her step-mother made trouble between Lizzie and the step mother, and Lizzie ceased to call her mother and called her Mrs. Borden, but for two or three years before the murder the relations between Lizzie and Mrs. Borden were entirely cordial, and if she
Witnesses testified about Matron Reagan's willingness to deny the 'you gave me away' quarrel story, blocked by Marshal Hilliard's orders. Emma Borden testified denying any quarrel occurred, described the burned Bedford cord dress as paint-stained, and recounted Alice Russell's admission of lying to investigators about the dresses.
The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · Wheeling, W. Va.
The report covers trial testimony showing the defense calling witnesses to refute claims of a quarrel between Lizzie Borden and her sister, and to deny the 'give me away' story. Witness Sarah B. Hart also testified about passing the Borden house around the time of the murders.
The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · 17 June 1893 · page 1
THE DEFENSE RESTS.
Miss Lizzie told Governor Robinson us be greeted her this morning that sho bail not paused a very restful night, and tho intimation cuuio with u chaoriui; smile that sho felt better. Tho decision relative to tho udmission of tho evidence of tho Portuguose who saw tho men with tho bloody hatchot and uiuuudenng about "poor Mrs. Borden",
The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · Wheeling, W. Va.
Witnesses testify at Lizzie Borden's trial, including a woman who saw an unknown young man at the gate and a painter who saw no blood on Lizzie despite close proximity. Court also rules inadmissible testimony about Portuguese men seen with a bloody hatchet.
The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · 17 June 1893 · page 1
WERE ALL IN DEFENDANT'S FAVOR
Miss Lizzie was sitting in a rocking choir and tlip others seemed to be working over liur. fanning her and rubbing licr hands; I was closo to hor all tho tiiuo. Mho appeared to be somowhat diltrojacd. 1 saw no signs of blood on bor head, hair, bunds, or dross." Ily this wituobg it was proven thnt many pooplo woro swarming about tho llordou houso and in tho barn whero Lizzie is said to have boon during tho murders, but where Officer Modlov afterwards subeoquontly wont and coulil find no traces of Miss Borden, or auy oue else. John B. Manning, reporter, of Fall Kivor: Ho lirat heard of tho Borden
The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · Wheeling, W. Va.
Witnesses testify about Mrs. Reagan's willingness to sign a denial of the alleged jail quarrel story, and about Lizzie Borden burning an old Bedford dress after the murders. Mary Brigham recounts conversations about the dress and a prior falsehood told to investigator Hanscom.
The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · 17 June 1893 · page 1
WAS READY TO SIGN A DENIAL
Mra. Mary ?. Brighatn.of Fall Hi' I know Liziio Borden and have kn< her all my life. We were life-1 friends. 1 visited hor qiiito froquon Mrs. liougan told me ono duy u court, when wo were in tho matr< room, about a quarrel between tho tors. I aaw Mr. Buck with a pupoi his hand which ho road to her. X both went out and shocaunrback u Sho said sho was willing to sign paper, but that tho murshal would let her; that she would rather it nor piace inun to may wnero euo boon lioilabout; thut it was all u i it i 11 i uuu tuuro uuu uoeii no quui rci. l.lzzm'u BISTBIi TU1TIKII3.
The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · Wheeling, W. Va.
A brief editorial comment during the trial questions why Lizzie Borden was ever indicted, stating no case had been made against her. It implies skepticism about the strength of the evidence used to hold and charge her.
The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · 17 June 1893 · page 4
Two Sundays in succession there , have boon open gates and tho attendance is fltoadily incroasing day by day. No case has boon made against Lizzie Borden. Tho wonder is, why was sho ovor hold, and what Bort of ovidonco was alio indictod on? Ci.ka.v tho stroots.
Coverage of the Borden trial reports a lighter courtroom mood, with testimony undermining claims of a quarrel between the sisters and a witness describing an unknown young man at the Borden gate near the time of the murders. The court also ruled inadmissible testimony from Portuguese witnesses regarding men with a bloody hatchet.
Wheeling Register · 17 June 1893 · page 1
Things Look Very Much Brighter for Lizzie Borden. MISS EMMA DENIES THE QUARREL
*■ of the Borden trial than there has beilp i at any time since the beginning of tie trial. Among the early visitors wis j Mis» Emma Borden, who, it is under-1 Stood, is to bo called by the defense, al though she was down as a government —(Witness. Miss Lizzie told Gov. Robin -- / son as he greeted her this morniDg that she had not passed a very restful night,
Court excludes testimony from a Portuguese witness about men with a bloody hatchet. Several witnesses testify about the morning of the murders, people near the Borden house, Lizzie's appearance after the discovery, and a reporter's interview with Matron Reagan about the alleged sisters' 'give away' story.
Wheeling Register · 17 June 1893 · page 1
In a rocking cha r, aud the others seemed to b«* working over her, faunin* her and rubbing her hands; 1 was close to her all tue time. She appeared to be somewhat distressed. I saw no signs tof blood on her head, hair, hands or dress.” By this witness it was proven that many people were swarming about the Borden house and in the barn, " where Llzxle is said to have been during the murders, but where Officer Medley subsequently went, and could tiud no trace^of Miss Borden, or auv one else. John B. Manning, reporter, fall Rtver, said he first heard of the Borden murder some tiino before
Reporters and other witnesses testify at trial that Mrs. Reagan denied any quarrel between Lizzie and Emma Borden, calling the earlier published story false. A written retraction was prepared and read to her, which she reportedly agreed was true and offered to sign.
Wheeling Register · 17 June 1893 · page 1
ANOTHER NEWSPAPER MAN a was with me for the same purpose, and BUC ftUt " ^ v iwyw. WV.1M Thomas F. Hlckgy. another reporter of Fall River, next testified. "In ray ospactty as reporter, 1 saw Mrs. Reagan on Friday about the story referred to • above. I said, T see your’e getting your seif in the paper, Mrs. Reagan.’ She said, ‘Yes, but they have got to take that all back.’’ I asked her about the alleged quarrel between Lizzie and Emma and she said that there had been no quarrel.
See moreSee less
I asked her if she had re peated any words of the sisters and if there was any truth In the report, and r she said absolutely uoue.” Mrs. Mary R. Holme*, of Fall River, wife of Cbas. J. Holmes Said: *‘I know Miss Borden, and have known who she was from chiidhood. She is a member of the church I attend. I first beard of the Borden murder at 11:45. I went to j the house about 1 o'cloek and sat down.
The newspaper argues that the prosecution's case against Lizzie Borden collapsed under rebuttal testimony, noting her sister Emma's explanation of the burned dress and claims of family harmony. The piece concludes Borden was unfairly targeted by police who lacked evidence and built their case on prejudice.
The Herald · 18 June 1893 · page 4
"burn up the old thing." None of tbe testimony the police relied on ior a con viction held together. The police theory seems to have been built up on the fact that they had failed to find any other murderer, and selected Lizzie be cause they thought she might have done the deed. As far as one can judge from all the testimony published, and from the failure of the state to bring out any evidence inculpating the ac cused, Lizzie Borden has been a victim
This commentary piece argues that the prosecution's case against Lizzie Borden has collapsed, citing lack of blood evidence, an unidentified weapon, no established motive, and corroboration of her alibi. It predicts that conviction would be inexplicable and that acquittal is the likely outcome.
New-York Tribune · 18 June 1893 · page 6
THE GREAT MURDER CASE. The conviction of Lizzie Borden of murder upon the evidence now hefore the jury would be a more inexplicable mystery than the death of her stepmother and father. Jwies have been known to do strange, incomprehensible things: but the condemnation of the prisoner after the complete eollapse of the proseention would bear all those signs of mental disorder which have characterized the crimes in the Borden household. A disagreement of the jury is a contingeney which the counsel for the defence must fice, but it is more probabl: that they will secure the release of their client.
See moreSee less
The verdict out of court, whatever may be the result of the jury's deliberations, will inevitably be, that mysterious as the two murders remain. there is no evidence in justification of the prisoner's conviction. The case against her bas been reduced to a police conspiracy against a helpless woman, who was never allhwed fair play until her ease was brought into the present court. Every attempt to connect Lizzie Borden di-
This editorial contends that the fifteen-minute window allowed for the father's murder is too short for the killer to have committed the crime, cleaned up, and changed clothes without detection, suggesting reasonable doubt. It also criticizes the District Attorney for following police theories and presenting what it calls fabricated evidence that collapsed under scrutiny.
New-York Tribune · 18 June 1893 · page 6
THE GREAT MURDER CASE.
Lizzie Borden. He must have known that there was testimony at hand for enroborating her statement that she visited the barn, and he could not have heen unfamiliar with the gross blunders of the police. He allowed himself become the agent and abettor of police officials ager for promotion and bent upon distorting and manufacturing evidence» against the woman, whom they had prejudgel from the first hour. : He adopted their theories with amazing credulity, and after a wanton attempt to compel a distracted woman to incriminate herself produced in court after protracted delay an anomalons mass of perinred testimony, which fell to picces as soon as it was touched.
This brief item speculates that if Lizzie Borden is acquitted, it will be an extraordinary addition to criminal records given the case's lack of precedent. It suggests some witnesses may have committed perjury and questions whether the District Attorney will face consequences for holding Borden as a close prisoner for over ten months.
This report reviews the evidence presented at Lizzie Borden's trial for the murder of her father and stepmother, concluding that the state has failed to prove its case. It highlights unproven claims about blood on the ax and dress, and disputes the alleged incriminating remark to her sister.
Why Crtac Rrfuaod to Answer. The N> York Tim< sls disposed lo j criticise Oongrvf-sman Crisp rather harshly because be refused to say. in is stems,' tea telegram from that pa|*er in quiring whelher or not he favors the re ! pea i of tile silver purchase act, what his ; position in respect to that act is. The Times sent a similar dispatch to each of the senators and representatives and re ceived a reply from its senators and is', representatives. Of thesenators 27 favor rejieal, 7 oppose it and 4 have not yet made up their minds.
See moreSee less
Of the representa tives 145 favor repeal. 25 an' against r,- |wnl and 17 arc, in doubt as to the course they will pursue. Judge Crisp, in response to the inquiry of the Times, said: "No answer to your telegram.” The Times expresses the opinion that being a candidate for re election to the speakership he doesn't want to make known his principles• for fear of arousing opposition to his can didacy. It is inclined to the view that he has not the courage to express his con victions. When the time comes for Judge Crisp fo show whether he is for or against the repeal of the silver purchase act he will not be backward in expressing them. The true reason he refused to answer the tele gram of the Times is, doubtless, that being a candidate for re-election to the speaker ship. and having egery reason to think that he will be successful, he feels that it would not be proper for him to disclose his view’s in respect to the proposed repeal of the silver,purchase act. If re-elected speaker he will have to name the com mittee that will have an immense influ ence in shaping silver legislation. If he should announce his views in respect to the silver purchase act he would be handi capped in making up that committee. He would encounter all sorts of difficulties and annoyances. Why, then, simply to help along an undertaking started by a news paper, should he put himself in a position that would, to say the leastof it, be rather trying. Judge Crisp adopted a wise course in declining at this time to com mit himself for or against the silver pur chase act. The Lizzie Borden Case. Those who have followed the evidence in the case of Lizzie Borden, who is being tried on the. charge of having murdered her father and step-mother in their home in Fall River, Mass., can hardly have reached any other conclusion than that the state has failed to make out a case against her. The evidence for the state and the defense is now in, and the argu ment will bo begun to-morrow. Even if the defense had called no wit nesses It is doubtful if any unprejudiced person, who is familiar with the evidence introduced by the state, would feel jus tified in saying Miss Borden is guilty. There is no direct evidence against her, and the circumstantial evidence is not of a convincing character. The strongest points in the circum stantial evidence are that an ax with alleged blood spots on it was found in the cellar; that Miss Borden burned a dress a day or two after the crimes were com mitted, on which it is be lieved there were blood spots; that she charged her sister at the police station, while under arrest, with having “given her away,” that she was on had terms with her step-mother and that no persons were seen entering or leaving the Borden premises on the morning on which tho murder was committed. But it was not shown that the spots on the dress that was burned were blood spots, nor that tho spots on the ax found in the cellar were blood spots. Neither was it satisfactorily shown that Miss Borden made any' such remark to her sister as that attributed to her, nor that a person could not have entered and left the Bor den premises on the morning of the mur der without being seen by persons in tho vicinity. The testimony for the defense quite satisfactorily disposed of the points made by the state. Miss Borden's sister testi fied that the accused did not. charge her with having “given her away” and the testimony was that the dress that was destroyed had paint Spots on it and that it was burned openly. There was 1 also expert testimony to the effect that the ax found in the cellar did not have human blood spots upon it, and that per sons could have entered and left the Bor den home on the day the murders were committed without attracting attention. Judging from the testimony there is no doubt that Miss Borden will be acquitted for want of evidence sufficient to convict her. In that event the tragedy that was committed in the Borden home will re main as great a mystery as ever. Outcome of the Panama Scandal. None of the parties who wrecked the Panama Canal Company by reckless waste and extravagance, nor any of those who filled thoir pockets from the company’s treasury by blackmailing and other ille gitimate means are to be punished. The parties who were convicted in the trial court have been sot at liberty by the high est court of France on the ground that there were defects in the indictments and that the statute of limitations barred prosecution for the offenses with which they were charged. This practically end s one of the most remarkable financial scandals in the world’s history. Only a srnaii amount of the many mil lions of dollars that were paid for the stock of the Panama Canal Company was used in the work on tho canal. The money was recklessly thrown away. Millions of it went into tho pockets of those who contributed nothing whatever toward the building of the canal, and many millions more’ware paid for. work that amounted to nothing and for machin ery that was utterly useless for the pur poses for which it was intended. The ]tourer people of France contributed most of the money that was sunk in the Panama undertaking. They put their small savings into the stock of the com pany because they had confidence in M. de iA-sseps, and because they were led to believe they would get extraordinary dividends on their investment. At first there may have been a purpose to deal honestly with them, but, later on, those on tho inside had every reason to believe that the canal would boa failure. Indeed, from the present point of view, there never was a time when there was a fair prosi>ect that the canal would be a success. Still, the poor people of France were told by the subsidized newspai>ers that every thing was going on swimmingly, and that if they were wise they would put every ' dollar they could get into the enterprise. Surely, the dufH investors had a right to expect that somebody would bo held accountable for robbing them, and they I are justified in feeling bitterly toward the ! government, which gave the company much of its credit, for allowing those who virtually robbed them to escape punish ment, A Troublesome Question Settled. The question as to whether the fair shall he opened Sundays may be regarded as settled. The United States court of ap |x als yesterday held that the locaUlireet orsof the fair art; in full control of it, and the government, notwithstanding its gift of $2,500,000 in souvenir half dollars. has no voice what ever in the matter The unanimous decision of the court. Chief Justice Ful ler being one of the judges. Justifies the conclusion that an appeal will notbe taken to the Uinted States supreme court. If an appeal should be taken the decision, in all probabilty, would be affirmed. And, besides, the appeal could not be heard much, if any, before the close of the fair, unless the court should consent to make
The report reviews the prosecution's circumstantial evidence—the ax, the burned dress, an alleged accusation against her sister, and no one seen at the premises—and notes the defense's rebuttals to each point. It concludes that Lizzie Borden will likely be acquitted for lack of sufficient evidence, leaving the murders unsolved.
The Morning News · 18 June 1893 · page 4
The Lizzie Borden Case. Those who have followed the evidence in the case of Lizzie Borden, who is being tried on the. charge of having murdered her father and step-mother in their home in Fall River, Mass., can hardly have reached any other conclusion than that the state has failed to make out a case against her. The evidence for the state and the defense is now in, and the argu ment will bo begun to-morrow. Even if the defense had called no wit nesses It is doubtful if any unprejudiced person, who is familiar with the evidence introduced by the state, would feel jus tified in saying Miss Borden is guilty.
See moreSee less
There is no direct evidence against her, and the circumstantial evidence is not of a convincing character. The strongest points in the circum stantial evidence are that an ax with alleged blood spots on it was found in the cellar; that Miss Borden burned a dress a day or two after the crimes were com mitted, on which it is be lieved there were blood spots; that she charged her sister at the police station, while under arrest, with having “given her away,” that she was on had terms with her step-mother and that no persons were seen entering or leaving the Borden premises on the morning on which tho murder was committed. But it was not shown that the spots on the dress that was burned were blood spots, nor that tho spots on the ax found in the cellar were blood spots. Neither was it satisfactorily shown that Miss Borden made any' such remark to her sister as that attributed to her, nor that a person could not have entered and left the Bor den premises on the morning of the mur der without being seen by persons in tho vicinity. The testimony for the defense quite satisfactorily disposed of the points made by the state. Miss Borden's sister testi fied that the accused did not. charge her with having “given her away” and the testimony was that the dress that was destroyed had paint Spots on it and that it was burned openly. There was 1 also expert testimony to the effect that the ax found in the cellar did not have human blood spots upon it, and that per sons could have entered and left the Bor den home on the day the murders were committed without attracting attention. Judging from the testimony there is no doubt that Miss Borden will be acquitted for want of evidence sufficient to convict her. In that event the tragedy that was committed in the Borden home will re main as great a mystery as ever.
This is a column of brief editorial commentary on various topics, including a passing remark that the Lizzie Borden trial has 'compensating incidents' and jokes about Fall River police detective work. It is not a dedicated news report on the case but a miscellany column touching many subjects.
The Wichita Daily Eagle · 18 June 1893 · page 4
Mr. Morton was a. little slow in getting the run of the weather machine, but he is running out straight summer grist just now. The Lizzie Borden trial is not without
A newspaper commentary piece argues the prosecution has failed to establish a strong case connecting Lizzie Borden to her parents' murder, despite lingering suspicions from her strained relationship with them and her presence at the scene. The writer predicts she will likely be acquitted unless new evidence emerges, noting her calm demeanor has unsettled the lawyers and detectives who expected a breakdown.
The Helena Independent · 18 June 1893 · page 4
establish such a case against Lizzie Borden as was expected. They fail to show that she had any actual connec tion with the murder of her parents, though of course they have not removed the suspicions attached by reason of her unpleasant relations with them, her prdsence near the place at the time of the murder and the fact that under the conditions, suspicion could revert to no one else. During the trial, her ccnduct has been of an innocent woman, though more importance is always given tp the demeanor of an accused person than is deserved.
See moreSee less
Even if innocent, we would naturally expect some signs of emotion from a woman placed in her terrible po sition. Thus far, she has been calm and collected, and in this way has rattled the lawyers and detectives who expected her to collapse. Unless new evidence is introduced by the prosecution we may look for the acquittal of Miss Borden,
Mrs. Mary R. Holmes, a neighbor and fellow churchgoer, testified about seeing Lizzie Borden on the day of the murder and at her father's funeral viewing. She described Lizzie's clothing and confirmed Lizzie shed tears while viewing her father's body, with some testimony excluded after prosecution objections.
Paper unidentified · 18 June 1893 · page 3
Lizzie Borden’s Trial. After several unimportant wit nesses had testified Mrs. Mary R. Holmes, a neighbor and member of the church which Miss Borden at tended, was called to the stand. She testified: “I know Miss Borden and have known who she was from child hood; I have seen Miss Lizzie and her stepmother at church together; I first heard of the Borden murder
Witnesses testified about a disputed conversation in which Matron Reagan allegedly said Lizzie accused her of "giving her away," with conflicting accounts of whether Reagan wanted to sign a denial. Emma Borden testified denying any quarrel with Lizzie, described the sisters' relations with their stepmother, and recounted the burning of Lizzie's paint-stained dress after the murders.
Paper unidentified · 18 June 1893 · page 3
EMMA BORDEN DENIES THE CONVERSATION. Miss Emma P *den was next called. She der . absolutely the “You-gave me-' story, and swore that nc uarrel took place be tween the si era in Matron Reag an’s room. Mr. Krxjwlton cross-examined her with reference to family relations. Emma testified that her father’s gift of the house to her stepmother made trouble between Lizzie and the stepmother and Lizzie ceased to call her “mother” and called her Airs. Borden, but for two or three years before the murder the rela tions between Lizzie and Mrs. Bor den were entirely cordial. And if she had testified to the contrary at the preliminary hearing that was untrue.
Emma testified about the relationship between Lizzie and Mrs. Borden, noting Lizzie once called her 'mother' but stopped doing so two or three years before the murder. The report also references the burned dress incident from the preliminary hearing testimony.
The State Chronicle · 18 June 1893 · page 2
THE BURNED DRESS INCIDENT
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
At Lizzie Borden's trial, neighbor Mrs. Mary R. Holmes testified that she knew the Borden family and attended the same church as Lizzie. She recounted hearing of the murders around 11:45, arriving at the house by 1 o'clock, and being asked to see Lizzie in her room where men were present.
The State Chronicle · 18 June 1893 · page 2
James A Weston. Hickory, N. C, June 16, 1893. mm 9 mm Lizzie Borden's Trial. After several unimportant wit nesses had testified Mrs. Mary R. Holmes, a neighbor and member of the church which Miss Borden at tended, was called to the stand. She testified: "I know Miss Borden and have known who Bhe was from child hood; I have seen Miss Lizzie and her stepmother at church together; I first heard of the Borden murder at 11:45; I went to the house about 1 o'clock and sat down in the kitch en; some one told me soon after that Lizzie would like to see me; she was in her room and some men
This editorial comments on the Lizzie Borden trial as it nears a conclusion that can already be foretold, comparing it to the Beecher adultery trial as among the most closely followed cases in American newspapers. It praises The Sun's own reporter for giving readers a clearer understanding of the evidence and the defendant's character than courtroom spectators themselves could gain.
The Sun · 18 June 1893 · page 6
A Tho Lizzie Borden Case. If Tt 1b In a How England town or small VW city, perhaps, that a great murder trial rlsoa to tho highest dogrco of dramatlo m tntOTCat. Tho simplicity ot tho procoaa and j the surroundings, tho comparatively uni eventful character of ordinary life In tho
This editorial argues that the prosecution's case against Lizzie Borden, as presented in testimony, fails because while a motive of financial grievance and discontent might (unconvincingly) explain the stepmother's murder, no motive at all exists for killing her father afterward. The author contends the prosecution's theory requires Lizzie to be both calculating and brutal, yet the second murder contradicts the logic of eliminating her stepmother for financial gain since it only increased the risk of detection.
The Sun · 18 June 1893 · page 6
stepmother and hor father to death; de spatching the stepmother first. In order that tho entire fortune of hor father might pass directly to hor sister and herself, and no part bo diverted to Mrs. Adby Bobden's rolatlvos. Tho lack of cordial rolatlous In tho family was not 6hown with sufficient distinctness to warrant a decree In a suit for marital separation for Incompatibility of temper, much loss to afford ground for assuming a murderous intent, Tho testi mony to that offect consistod of gossip and the repetition ot pettish remarks mado at times by Miss Boiiden about hor stepmother.
See moreSee less
Indicating an attitude on hor part toward Mrs. Borden precisely llko that which is hold by thousands aud ton3 of thousands of grown-up daughters In Now England or olsewhoro, toward tho womon their fathors havo married. But oven it tho Government had proved
This editorial discusses race prejudice in America, citing a lawsuit by a Black man who was removed from his seat at the Borden trial courthouse after giving it to a Black woman. It uses the incident to argue that racial prejudice is universal and cannot be legislated away, drawing parallels to a Massachusetts barber bill.
Richmond Dispatch · 18 June 1893 · page 4
Raco Prejudices and the Borden Trial Wherever there are any considerable number of negroes and Caucasians living fn the same community race prejudices show themselves, ‘These prejudices are
The report argues the prosecution has failed to show a motive for killing the father, since any enmity was toward the stepmother. It also suggests Bridget was not suspected and that an unknown intruder could have entered while Lizzie was in the barn.
Richmond Dispatch · 18 June 1893 · page 4
The Trial of Lizzie Borden.
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
The report describes courtroom atmosphere as the Borden trial nears its end, noting Lizzie's improved demeanor after prejudicial testimony was excluded. It also notes most newspapermen covering the trial believe the prosecution failed to prove its case, with closing arguments to begin the next day.
Richmond Dispatch · 18 June 1893 · page 4
The Trial of Lizzie Borden
The words of this article could not be separated from the rest of its page. Read it in the clipping.