A New York Recorder opinion piece by Joe Howard argues that accused persons like Lizzie Borden, who has been jailed since her parents' murder last August, are being treated as if already convicted despite the law presuming innocence. The writer calls for reformed detention conditions that preserve more personal liberty for the accused while awaiting trial.
The Indianapolis Journal · 12 June 1893 · page 4
A Vie tor Unconvicted Prisoners. Joe Howard, In New York Ilecoriler. Why should individuals charged with crime be treated as if they were convictef Take Lizzie Borden, for instance. Her father and stepmother were killed by some body last August. he was arrested and has been kept in jail ever since. The law Assumes her to be iunocent. bat the au thorities treat her as if she had been con victed of tbe homicide. Common sense suggest that accusation and conviction are not synonymous terms, yet the one neces sitates treatment precisely like that which follows the other.
See moreSee less
There should be some mode of confinement in capital cases where bail is not allowed which would not imply disgrace. Surely it is possible to have houses of detention whore the free dom of the party accused, outing alone ex enpted, can be allowed. He should have liberty to eat, drink, sleep, write and transact business as he may desire. Any other treatment is a traverse of individual rights, and should not be tolerated.
Townspeople in Fall River believe the prosecution's case against Lizzie Borden is weak, with rumors that her defense will reveal a paint purchase and testimony that burning dresses was common in the household. The report also describes conflicting police testimony over a hatchet handle, with one officer's account disputed by several colleagues.
The Indianapolis Journal · 12 June 1893 · page 5
Fall Kiveh. Mass., Juno 11. All day long talk has been plentiful on the subject of the Borden murders, and there can be no denial that it is a general opinion about town that the prosecution has thus far a very weak case. tThts opinion is being strengthened by rumors current here to tbe eilect that Lizzie Borden's counsel will shortly explodo a bombshell into the camp of the authorities. It is hinted that tho defense will enow conclusively that Lizzie Borden purchased some paint a low day a before tbe murder, and that it was not an uncommon thiug to burn dresses in the Borden house
The report discusses contradictions in police testimony about the hatchet handling by officers Medley and Desmond, suggesting the defense may exploit these inconsistencies. It also previews the court's upcoming decision on whether to admit Lizzie Borden's inquest testimony, which could force her to take the stand at trial.
The Indianapolis Journal · 12 June 1893 · page 5
WEAK CASE AGAINST LIZZIE
Lizzie Mny Have a Chance to Speak. New Bedford, Mass., June 11. By the events of to-morrow it will be decided whether the proseootlon will go sailing along with free sheets, or pull up close hauled for a long and tedious trip. If tbe court decides to admit the notes of the stenographer's reports in Lizzie Borden's
At the New Bedford trial, witness testimony focused on the discovery of the hatchet used in the murders and conflicting accounts about a missing wooden handle. Police officers Mullaly and Fleet gave contradictory statements, and Inspector Medley testified about finding the broken hatchet in the cellar and the absence of footprints in the dusty barn loft where Lizzie claimed to have been.
Der Deutsche Correspondent · 12 June 1893 · page 6
Lizzie Bordens Prozeß. Belastungszeugen im Kreuzverhör. Widersprechende Aussagen.
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
German-language American newspaper reports trial testimony from Inspector Medley, officer DeSmond, and state police officer Seaver regarding the handleless hatchet found in the cellar and examination of Lizzie Borden's clothing for blood stains. The witnesses gave conflicting accounts of who wrapped the hatchet and whether a blue dress was among the clothing examined.
Der Deutsche Correspondent · 12 June 1893 · page 6
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
At the New Bedford murder trial, Lieut. F. L. Edson testified about searching the Borden cellar for a hatchet handle, describing how officers found an axes and a headless hatchet but no matching handle. He noted Emma Borden had refused police entry on one occasion and detailed another search in August when Officer Medley found a hatchet head.
Daily Kennebec Journal · 12 June 1893 · page 1
New Bedfuko, Mass-, Jane 11.—The weather Saturday morning was warm and muggy ami as a consequence there was less of a rush for seats at the Borden murder trial than any previous day of the cele brated case. Miss Borden t»*ok her seat at I v<>5 within the har. She looked quite fresh j and appeared more interested in her «ur ! rounding* than heretofore. She held her smelling bottle in her hand and toyed with the little glass stopper somewhat nervously as she furtively glanced about under the brim of her black lace hat.
See moreSee less
The first witness was l.ieut. F. L. Edson of the Fall liiver police. He testified to having called w ith Officer Mahoney at the Borden house Friday night to search for llte hatchet handle spoken of by t tfficer Mullaley. Friday, but that he was refused admittance by Kmma Borden. He descrilted thoroughly the search of the cellar the day after the murder ami said he saw no loose hatchet handle. He took three axes amt a hatchet to the cen tral |>olice station and hail hail nothing to do with them since. August #th another search of the Borden cellar was made. Officer Medley that day
Witnesses including Capt. Desmond, Officer Medley, and Detective Seaver testified at the trial about the broken-handled hatchet found in the cellar, describing dust patterns and the apparent freshness of the break. Medley also recounted his initial search of the house and barn on the day of the murder.
Daily Kennebec Journal · 12 June 1893 · page 1
year lie was a patrolman, lie went to the Borden house at 11.40 on the day of the murder. He looked around the house and found the cellar door locked. Lizzie said to the witness that she was in the ham when the murder w as committed.
Witnesses Desmond and Seaver testified about the hatchet found with a broken handle covered in ashes, with defense attorney Robinson challenging the timing and searches. A separate agreement was reported detailing the circumstances of Lizzie Borden's inquest testimony, including that she was not allowed counsel and was arrested afterward.
Daily Kennebec Journal · 12 June 1893 · page 1
The Admissibility ot Her Evidence ta be Argued by Counsel Today. New Bkhforu, June II.—An agree ment relative to the admissibility of Mi-* Borden's evidence at the inquest has been signed by her and hr her attorney an I the matter will be argued at length on .Mon
Reports from Fall River describe the defense counsel's optimism as the prosecution's case appears weak, with rumors of a damaging revelation about burned dresses and paint purchases. The article also notes conflicting police testimony regarding the hatchet handle, undermining confidence in prosecution witnesses.
The Portland Daily Press · 12 June 1893 · page 1
HER COUNSEL JUBILANT.
Police—The State’s Attorneys Cha grined, B ut the Police Are Not Dis turbed—The Trial Has Just Begun. Fall Riveb, Mass., June 11.—It is the general opiuion about town that the prosecution in the Borden trial thus far has a very weak c ase. This opinion is being strengthened by rumors current here to the effect that Lizzie Borden’s counsel will shortly explode a bomb shell in the camp of the authorities. It is hinted that the defense will show con clusively that Lizzie Borden purchased same paint a few days before the mur der, andit was not an uncommon thing to bum dresses in the Borden household.
The passage reports contradictions among Fall River police officers' trial testimony, especially Officer Mullally's disputed account of finding a hatchet handle, with several other witnesses contradicting him. It also discusses legal arguments over whether Lizzie Borden's inquest testimony will be admitted as evidence, and predicts the trial will last two more weeks.
The Portland Daily Press · 12 June 1893 · page 1
mit the stenographic report in the Lizzie Borden testimony at the inquest, the government will‘,feel superlatively happy. It is believed, with reason, that upon this testimony the government largely relies, while in the event of its being al lowed, Lizzie must neoessarily take the
Trial testimony from Fall River police officers including Edson, Maloney, Medley, and state detective Severin covered the discovery and handling of hatchets, with contradictions about how evidence was transported to the station. Severin detailed finding forty blood spots in the sitting room and examining the barn loft stairs and hatchet handle in the cellar, noting dust and possible blood or rust stains.
The Portland Daily Press · 12 June 1893 · page 1
The Fall River Police Keep On Con* tradicting Each Other. New Bedford, Mass., June 10.—Much of the excitement attendant upon the trial of Lizzie Borden waned after the testimony of yesterday and a crowd much smaller in proportion than those gathering on the previous days gathered at the court house. Lizzie Borden ap peared calm and composed. Francis L. Edson of the Fall River po lice was first called. He testified in re gard to the hatchets and created a sen cnVi on T\v-v oVnl-Snrr 4-VielVia VVl Am Va the station open handed.
See moreSee less
It had been previously stated that th ey were taken in a bag. The basket and box contain ing scraps of iron from the Borden barn was brought into the court room. Benj. F. Malonv, a police officer, was ! next called, and was followed by Wm. Medley, another officer. Mr. Medley stated that he wrapped up the hatchet with his own hands and explained how he did it. This caused general laugh ter. George F. Severn, state detective, was next announced. He thought there were both dust and ashes on the hatchet blade. He searched the upper front hall closet but found no light dress like the one burned. The testimony then turned to blood spots in the sitting room. He found forty blood spots. The highest was six inches from the floor and two feet from the dining room door and all covered an area of twelve feet by six. Mr. Severn stated that he visited the Borden house at about 11.40 on the day of the murder. He went into the barn and examined the stairs care fully to see if any one had gone into the loft! He found them covered with dust which he brushed off with his hands. They bore no evidence of having been walked upon. He was present when the handle of the hatchet was found in the cellar. He said it was covered with dust and ashes which when brushed away showed dark stains that might have been either blood or rust* Cross-examined by ex-Governor Robin son, he stated tnat the hatchet was found on top of a box and was oovered PORTLAND DAILY PRESS.
The report describes rumors that Lizzie Borden's defense will reveal she purchased paint before the murders and that dress-burning was common in the Borden household, aiming to undercut suspicion. It also notes that police officers, including Officer O'Malley, are giving inconsistent testimony, boosting the defense's confidence.
St. Paul Daily Globe · 12 June 1893 · page 1
SHE PURCHASED PAINT
Fael Kivek, Mass., June 11.— All day long talk has been plentiful on the subject of the Borden murders, and there can be no denial that it is a gen eral opinion about town that the prose cution has thus far a very weak case. This opinion is being strengthened by rumors current here to the effect that Lizzie Borden's counsel will shortly ex plode a bombshell into the camp of the 'authorities, lt is hinted that the de fense will show conclusively that Lizzie Borden purchased some paint a few .days before the murder, and that it was not au uncommon thing to burn dresses in the Borden household.
See moreSee less
The fact that the girl burned the suspicious dress In the day light, when officers surrounded the house, will also be related to show there .was not the slightest attempt at cou cealment. The defendant's lawyers do not attempt to disguise their joyful feel ings because of the the present status of the case, and the girl's friends here are jubilant.
The report discusses conflicting police testimony about Officer Medley's hatchet discovery and whether his account will be undermined by the defense. It also previews the trial's key legal question of whether Lizzie Borden's inquest statements will be admitted as evidence, which both sides see as pivotal.
St. Paul Daily Globe · 12 June 1893 · page 1
notes of the stenographic reports in Lizzie Borden's testimony at the in qu<**sr, the government will feel su premely happy, It is believed, and 'with reason, that upon this testimony the government largely relies, and while, in the event of its being allowed,
A news bulletin roundup lists brief headlines from around the country, including one noting 'Complications in Borden trial.' No further detail is given about the nature of these complications.
St. Paul Daily Globe · 12 June 1893 · page 1
THE GLOBE BULLETIN
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
A newspaper miscellany column remarks that Lizzie Borden's defense attorneys, in choosing jurors, broke from the usual practice of picking unintelligent, criminal-sympathizing men. It claims reports indicate the empaneled jury is made up of able men.
St. Paul Daily Globe · 12 June 1893 · page 4
GENEIIAI. OBSERVATIONS
"Where is lowa's Gov. McKixley— it man who towers Nation waid and is a born leader of men?" asks tiie Dcs Moines Register. Mr. Clabkson would like to answer the question; but it would not answer to do so in his own paper. The attorneys who are defending Lizzie Borden, in selecting the jury, seem to have departed from the Ameri can custom of accepting men of little intelligence and who sympathize with criminals, lt is reported that the jury is composed of able men. The whisky trust, which was sup posed to be on the brink of death, turns out to bo full of spirit, lt has just sold $8,000,000 of new bonds, and proposes to cut down the production of liquor aud raise the price.
See moreSee less
Here is Attorney Gen eral OiNEv's opportunity. Harriet Bkechkb Stowe is enjoy ing her second childhood. She whiles away the time cutting out paper dolls and singing the songs she learned in her first childhood, with the innocence and freedom from care of a four-year-old child. Nature is very kind to permit the dear old woman to go down to her grave so happily. _»
A brief news item reports that Lizzie Borden is currently on trial for murder in Massachusetts. Her friends reportedly feel confident she will be acquitted based on the evidence presented so far.
The Beatrice Daily Express · 12 June 1893 · page 3
BRIEF NEWS ITEMS. The friends of Lizzie Borden, who la I now on triul for murder in Massachusetts, feel quite confident of acquittal on the evidence so far submitted. Mrs. E. F. Holmes, whose husband was killed in a collision between a Northwest ern train and an electric motor in Council Bluffs, has sued the street car company for #20,000 damages. The patriotic citizens of Alton, Uln, Sunday, decorated the grave of the anti slave martyr, Owen Lovejoy. The Clevelands will propably summer Buzzard’s Bay. Mrs. Cleveland Is desirous of taking Ruth there before the heated term begins in Washington. Baron A. do Sickler’s bay colt Ragotoky won the Grand Prix at Paris Sunday.
Defense lawyers argued successfully that Lizzie Borden's coroner's inquest testimony was involuntary and should be excluded from the murder trial. Reports also note rumors that the defense will reveal she bought paint before the murder and that dress-burning was common in the household, countering suspicion about a burned dress.
Asheville Daily Citizen · 12 June 1893 · page 1
That Paint Hpullered Ureas. New Bkdi'okd. Mass., June 12. The lawyers in the Borden case are spending the day arguing as to the admissability in the prcseut trial of Lizzie Borden's evidence before the coroner's inquest a ear or so ago. During the argument the prisoner was affected with a sudden indisposition and led away from the room by the sheriff. Governor Robinson, lor the defense. rgued eloquently that the facts showed that the defendant's (Lizzie Bordeu's) eclarations were not voluntary before the coroner's jury, and then discussed the authorities which, he claimed, admitted testimony only when the facts were differ ent from those in the case.
See moreSee less
The prisoner's wnuest testimony was hen excluded a great victory for the defense. This opinion is being strengthend by rumors current hereto the effect that Lizzie Borden's counsel will shortly ex plode a bomb shell in the camp of the uthonties. It is hinted tnattne aeiense will show conclusively that Lizzie Bor den purchased some paint a few days before the murder and that it was not an uncommon thing to burn dresses in the Borden household. The fact that the eirl burned a dress in the daylight when the officers surrounded the house, will also be related to snow that there was not the slightest attempt at concealment.
The trial court ruled to exclude Lizzie Borden's earlier inquest testimony from being used against her, with defense attorney Robinson delivering a passionate speech on public liberty. The jury was sent out during legal arguments over the admission of this testimony, and Borden appeared more at ease than in previous days.
The Jersey City News · 12 June 1893 · page 1
SAVED FROM HERSELF
Sudden Sickness. Special to The Jersey City News. New Bedford, Mass.. June 12, 1893.— With the heat maklug th6 court room where Lizzie Borden was on trial the
The jury was sent out of the courtroom while prosecutor Moody argued for admitting Lizzie Borden's inquest testimony as evidence, citing New York legal precedents. The report also notes Lizzie's improved demeanor and describes the jury's Sunday activities, including a ride about town after failing to agree on a church to attend.
The Jersey City News · 12 June 1893 · page 1
TX1E JURY SENT OUT. Wheu the court opoued Chief Justice Mason informed the jury that it migut retire. Tuat was done because of the ar gument which was abont.io be begun for aud against the admission of evidence given by Lizzie Borden when the in quest was held in Fall River last sum mer. The point to be decided meant every thing to the defendant. She listened at tentively to every word that was said by Assistant District Attorney Moody, wno begun the argument from the standpoint of the proseculiou. MISS BORDEN’S EVIDENCE.
Ex-Governor Robinson, for the defense, argues that Lizzie Borden was effectively under arrest and constant police surveillance during the inquest, and was never cautioned about her right to refuse self-incriminating testimony. He contends the inquest was not a genuine inquiry but an attempt to trap her, countering prosecutor Moody's citation of a precedent case.
The Jersey City News · 12 June 1893 · page 1
EX-GOVERNOR ROBINSON REPLIES
to wtiioh she was entitled. Lizzie Borden's counsel urged that at che time ot the inquest the proceedings had already beeu instituted against her, because the warrant had been sworn to. She had not been informed ot her right
The report describes New Bedford's beauty on a Sunday and contrasts it with Lizzie Borden's confined life in her prison quarters, where she is reported in good health and reading a novel. It notes she has had no visitors except her lawyers, but has received flowers and letters from supporters.
The Sun · 12 June 1893 · page 1
PLANS IN THE BORDEN CASE. NOT SETTLED WHETHER DEFENDANT WILL BE A WITNESS.
aaaaaav.' I aaaaaaaa New England. The heart of its residence dis trict Is a park of grand elms, gorgeous gar dens, and greon lawns. To-day tho tlowors wore open to their fullost splendor, the arch ing elms met In Gothlo lines over the shaded streets, and the robins, knowing It was Sunday, preOmptod tho lawns before tho great mansions of tho retired whaler tolc None ot theso alluring beauties wore for the most talked of woman In the town, for that woman Is Miss Lizzie Borden. She was in her prison quarters scenting the
The report describes courtroom arrangements during Lizzie Borden's trial, including restrictions on her sister Emma's visits and the Commonwealth's list of nearly ninety potential witnesses. It also previews upcoming expert medical testimony on the wounds and blood evidence, while noting uncertainty over whether Lizzie herself will testify.
The Sun · 12 June 1893 · page 1
LIZZIE WILL BE A WITNESS
The words of this article could not be separated from the rest of its page. Read it in the clipping.
The report describes the intense vetting both legal sides conducted on the 150-man jury panel, seeking middle-aged men with grown daughters and firm but fair reputations. It also captures courthouse officials' bemusement at the public spectacle, including the Sheriff's shifting and contradictory policies on admitting out-of-town reporters.
The Sun · 12 June 1893 · page 1
both side, the reader may be sure. A for what verdict they will rench.lt Is not within the scope of tbe writer's guessing ap paratus even to conjecture. He only knows that after studying tho testimony and talking to tlin lawyers on bothsides.he is convinced that tbe Bordens were brutally slain, but could not bavo been murdered by tho prisoner nor yet by any one els than the prisoner. As this effect of a week's suturallon with even tlio mlnuto detail nf the case may seem
On the second week of the Borden trial, lawyers argued over whether the stenographic notes of Lizzie Borden's inquest testimony should be admitted as evidence. Borden herself appeared tired and later became ill, prompting her to leave court during the proceedings.
The Evening World · 12 June 1893 · page 1
A POINT FOR LIZZIE.
NEW BEDFORD, Mass, June 12. Over ons.halt of the spectators In court this morning were women, and the sec ond week of the Borden trial opens with the appearance of Increased In terest ar the uncertainties of the case ore unfolded. The Indications of a se vere struggle over the admission of the stenographic notes of Miss Borden's testimony at the Inquest were plentiful this morning In the piles of books con taining authorities to be cited pro and con. A few moments before court opened counsel on both sides were summoned Into the private room of the presiding Justices for consultation.
See moreSee less
Miss Borden came Into court at 8 50 and took her seat within the bar, looking somewhat draggled, and In answer to an Inquiry from cx-Gov. Itoblnson as to her rest last night her words and manner Indi cated that she did not pass a pleasant t.'ght. The consultation lasted twenty min utes. After court was opened nnd the "ury polled the officers were directed by the Court to retire the Jury until they were sent for, pending the argu ments to follow. ,!xale's Testlmonr at the Inquest. Mr. Moody then addressed the Court, saying he understood the discussion now to be opened was that of the admissi bility of Miss Borden's evidence. He
Prosecution and defense attorneys debate whether Lizzie Borden's prior statements to police, given before her arrest, can be used as evidence against her. The defense argues she was effectively under suspicion and surveillance without caution, while prosecution cites precedents where such unwarned statements were admitted.
The Evening World · 12 June 1893 · page 1
A POINT FOR LIZZIE.
the State ot New York the evidence would be admissible. flllss Hordes Taken III. At this point Miss Borden was obliged to leave the room because of sudden In disposition. Mr. Moody held that where tht defend ant tfc the subject of the prosecution,
Defense attorney Robinson argues that the inquest was improperly used to extract incriminating testimony from Lizzie Borden without informing her of her rights, calling it a prosecutor's trick rather than a genuine inquiry. The Court ultimately rules in favor of the defense, deciding that her inquest testimony will be excluded from the trial.
The Evening World · 12 June 1893 · page 1
THE INQUEST A PROSECUTOR'S TRICK. Tho Inquest was not to discover whether a crime was committed or not, but Its use and power were devoted to extorting from this defendant something which could be made useful. The Government knew these murders had been committed by somebody, possi bly by some one else. Was the District Attorney to determine by whom? Yes, but not by dragging from her facts In such a manner. She was not examined to find out whether she had done these murders, because they had already sworn she had done It.
See moreSee less
They put that warrant In their pocket and say, "It we get anything out of her, we'll put It away." That was worse than burning a dress. Said Mr. Robinson: "Lizzie Borden stands on the Constitution of this com monwealth, and when the bill of rights says no person shall testify against htm-' self, she stands on that. The shield of the State and the shield of the nation are her protection In this hour." In this case. Miss Borden was In charge, she had been proceeded against nnd the warrant Issued, and the City Marshal was "delreted," not "per mitted," to arrest her. There was very II le au horlty for the proceedings egilnst this woman. Had she been told what she ought to hne heen told she would I
Defense attorney Robinson argues that Lizzie Borden's inquest testimony was coerced and unconstitutional, given without counsel and under improper pressure from the District Attorney. The court ultimately rules in favor of the defense, excluding her inquest testimony from the trial.
The Evening World · 12 June 1893 · page 1
THE INQUEST A PROSECUTOR'S TRICK
She was not examined to find out whether she had done these murders, I because they had already sworn she had ' done It. They put that warrant In their pocket and Boy, "If we get anything out of her, we'll put It away." That was worse than burning a dress. Hald Mr. Robinson. "Lizzie Borden stands on the Constitution of this com-, monwealth, and when the bill of rights says no person shall testify against him. self, she stands on that. The shield of the State and the shield of the nation are her protection In this hour."
See moreSee less
In this case, Miss Dbrden wsb In charge, she hod been proceeded against and the warrant Issued, and tho City Marshal was "delrcted," not "per mitted," to arrest her. Thero was very Il'le au horlty for the proceedings against this woman. Had she been told what she ought to have been told she would not have testified. Mr. Moody, replying, characterized Mr. Robinson's arguments as "mag nificent, but not lnw." THE DEFENSE SUSTAINED.
During cross-examination at the New Bedford trial, ex-Gov. Robinson exposed contradictions among police witnesses about the alleged missing hatchet handle, revealing that it had actually been found with the blade and carried away by one of the same officers who swore it was missing. This collapse of testimony undermined the prosecution's theory that Lizzie had burned the bloody handle to hide evidence.
The Evening World · 12 June 1893 · page 4
THAT HOODOO HATCHET.
BIl Uon. Insists 'that with that weapon LizWFl -1 Borden murdered -first her stepmiM mother j.nd, next Jier.'father. The theory WSt f the .irovernmtnt Is that after the B -murder the bloodBtatns on the hlade had
A newspaper editorial column briefly notes that the Borden case will this week move into the hands of chemical and medical experts. It predicts public sympathy will largely stay with the jury during the technical, analytical testimony.
The Evening World · 12 June 1893 · page 4
This week the Borden case falli Into the hands of the chemical and medical experts. Popular sympathy will rest to a considerable degree with the jury during most of the analytical proceedings.
This report from the Lizzie Borden trial describes how the hatchet exhibit continues to cause problems for the prosecution's case, with witnesses becoming confused during testimony. Ex-Gov. Robinson is portrayed as effectively challenging the Commonwealth's evidence, with the writer using extended metaphor to suggest the prosecution's case is unraveling rather than illuminating the truth.
Pawtucket Tribune · 12 June 1893 · page 1
CASE OF DEFENSE BRIGHTER
NeEw Beprorp, Mass., June 12.—The handi les; hotel e, cow cvnirally known as “‘the hoodou hatehet,” continuned its demonish pranks in the trial of Lizaie Borden for heo life Saturday. It chopped another great hol: in the case of which it s the most important feature. Since the ouly theory of the murder that has been advanced is that Lizzie Borden butchered both her parents at the end of 82 years of an upright life, whatever dam ages that theory simply increases the mys tery that shrouds the murders, It s as if the cause were a deep and pitch dark well, and the commonwenlth had said: “We will rig up a Siemens searchlight and throw its ;lare into rhe well and light up the bottom of it.”” They took 10 months to build the lunp, and on the first day in court set it up with a great flourish in New Bedford.
See moreSee less
They turned on the blaze, and it seemed very powerful, but the light only deepens the darkness, The Commonwenlith’s Lawyers pretend to point out objects in the inky space, but these vanish like phantoms at
The report describes how the prosecution's hatchet evidence backfired, with witnesses and testimony undermining their case rather than supporting it. It also recounts a dispute between prosecution and defense lawyers over retrieving a box containing the alleged murder weapon, noting the handle was missing when defense counsel finally obtained it.
Pawtucket Tribune · 12 June 1893 · page 1
EX GOVERNOR ROBINSON. The conumonwenlth’s lawyers had been fiudlng it as they would guard Aladdin’s 1p if they could get hold of it, but after it had sent their witnesses all away, and shivered their testimony so it could be seen through, these lawyers tossed the un holy thing on the table at which Lizzie Borden’s lawyers always sit, and there they left it lying, as if they wished to dis own it, There was another exciting contest out sgide the courtroom between the two sets of lawyers. 'The district attorney, Mr, Knowlton, sent two officers to the Borden home to get the box in which The Blade Was Found, and the handle if it was in it.
See moreSee less
Miss Bor den’s sister Emma lives in that house, and her lawyers saw toit that their antagonists were kept ont. That was what happened, Miss Lizzie's chief counsellor, A. J. Jen nings, had better luck, He got the box, but lo! the highly important handle was missing,. Who took it ean only be guessed at. Had it been found, it would have played hob with the theory that Miss Borden burned it. However, the police man who saw it proves as good a witness for Miss Borden as the handle itself. In Favor of Miss Borden, These reports during the last few days have seemed to take the part of the im prisoned woman. The reason why the re ports have seemed to favor Miss Borden is very interesting. It is that the case made out against her by the government has been luo;flv melting like a cake of ice in the
The report describes how defense attorney ex-Governor Robinson's skilled cross-examination caused police witnesses to contradict each other regarding the hatchet handle and how it was wrapped and carried away. It also notes damaging testimony about the dust-covered barn loft floor showing no footprints, undermining Lizzie Borden's claim of having been there the morning of the murder.
Pawtucket Tribune · 12 June 1893 · page 1
EX-GOVERNOR ROBINSON
that master cross-exuminer, Robinson, This has brought to light the positive reiterated proof that Lizzie Borden did hinder the searching of her room, and that she did not burn up the handle of the hatchet. Worse still, for the commonwealth, that handle has been at last traced to the place, and they must account for its disappear anoe or suffer the consequences by resting under the fairly grounded suspicion that it was hidden or destroyed for a purpose fovolving & human life, Saturday the hatchet laid out more po leoemen. First one of them told when he found it he showed it to his captain, and then wrapped it up ina piece of brown and took it to the city marshal mlh captain took the stand.
See moreSee less
all ne. WITNESSES CONFUSED The Hatchet the Cause of
The piece reflects on the first week of Lizzie Borden's trial, praising defense attorney Gov. Robinson's cross-examination skills for weakening the prosecution's case. It concludes the government's case rests mainly on suspicion rather than solid proof, leaving reasonable doubt as the second week begins.
Pawtucket Tribune · 12 June 1893 · page 2
LIZZIE BORDEN
Mayor Brown Is confldently expected to yeto the electric light contract on next Wednesday evening and transmit the same to the Commen Council which holds its regular monthly meeting at that time. In this connection it may be stated that the Joint special g )fmTttee on the Gudltion of establishing a municipal lighting plant is expected to report on that evening, and, as a consequence, he will have an array of figures to back hls veto that cannot be successtully contro verted. LIZZIE BORDEN. The first week of the trial of Miss Bor den has passed and the average mind is still uncertaln and we presume always will be In regard to who actually com mitted the foul and atrocious murder.
See moreSee less
We are certain of one thing and that is that she could not kave abler counsel, and it legal acumen will do anything to set her free It will be done. Gov. Robinson has again shown himself to be the wnaster of eriminal defence and a cross-exami ner without a peer. The case of the gov ernment has been shaken and withered under his powerful and searching inqul sitlon. It certainly is a remarkable array of facts that the government has put torward and ingeniously woven together, but the result is uncertain and doubtful. The only thing that is said is if Lizzie Borden didn’t commit the murder she knows something about it. That may be true, but it doesn’t prove a case against her for murder. It has been on such a theory as thils that the govern ment has worked because it had no other theory. The second week of the trial begins to day and we shall watch developments with interest. A better case than thus far set up must be forthcoming to pro duce conviction for a multitune of reason able doubts fill the mind.
Court proceedings focus on whether Lizzie Borden's inquest testimony can be admitted, with arguments consuming the day's session. The report also speculates that witness Mr. Sawyer may testify that others entered the barn before Inspector Medley, undermining the prosecution's footprint theory.
The Providence News · 12 June 1893 · page 2
LATEST INADMISSABLE
CONTINUED FROM PAGE 1, Borden was supposed to have fallen. Not asound dl('l, the attorney general hear. ‘l'he prosecution at onecs dropped the theory, It ma 'e no more noise than the faliing policeman, It is perhaps un
At the New Bedford trial, attorney Mr. Moody argued for admitting Lizzie Borden's inquest testimony, citing Massachusetts statutes on inquest procedure and precedent cases distinguishing voluntary statements from compelled confessions. The report also notes a hotel proprietor's telegram inviting Borden to stay at his resorts for free, presuming her acquittal.
The Providence News · 12 June 1893 · page 2
DAY SPENT IN ARGUMENTS
SPECIAL TO THE NEWS. Court House, New BEDFORD, Mass., June 12.-—Mi-s Borden appeared again this morning without flowers, but her lawyers have received in her behalt an invitation that is unique. A proprietor of two prominent hotels at two shore re sorts of note has telegraphed congratu lations on the outcome of the trial, He already presses the acquittal of the prisoner, and he has invited her to visit his Lotels for as long & time as she may see fit with such attendauts as she may bring, entirely free of char ¢ It is not yet known whether this gentle man is actuated a spirit of advertising philauthropy or of philanthropic adver tising.
See moreSee less
At the opeaing of the eourt this morn ing the jury were requested to retire and Mr. Moody ur os? to argue the ques tion of the admissability of the evideuce of Lizzie Borden made at the trial,
At the trial, witnesses gave conflicting accounts about whether a handle was found with the hatchet blade in the box, with Assistant Marshal Fleet and Policeman Mullaly directly contradicting each other. The report frames this as damaging to the prosecution's case, alongside testimony about Lizzie and Miss Russell carrying items to the cellar on the night after the murders.
The Providence News · 12 June 1893 · page 2
LIZZIE 1S FAVORED By ‘@ Lontradictory Evidence of Policemen, New BeEprorp, Mass,, June 12 —That small, broken handled hatchet which the district attomeys have introduced as the implement with which Lizzie Borden
This editorial notes the Borden trial is entering its second and likely final week, expressing relief that the public ordeal will soon end regardless of verdict. It also remarks that the prosecution's evidence during the first week did not appear particularly damning against Lizzie Borden.
The Providence News · 12 June 1893 · page 4
- Tur Borden trial enters upon its second and probably last week today. When it is over the public will be greatly relieved, whatever the verdict may be, . FroM novto the end of the first week _ in July, the flittings to the seashore ~ and mountains will be constant and - rapid. The News will follow all who _ leave their addresses at the business . office, No. 7 Weybosset street.
The News boasts that its trial reports, along with Julian Ralph's dispatches to the New York Sun, are the best available, praised for being concise and readable compared to papers that print full testimony verbatim. It explains that its reporter must transmit copy live during proceedings, unlike Ralph who can write after the day's session ends.
The Providence News · 12 June 1893 · page 4
OUR BORDEN TRIAL REPURT. The News has thus far printed the best report of the Borden trial avail able to Rhode Island, Connecticut or Massachusetts people,.
This item compiles short commentary from various New England newspapers on the ongoing Borden murder trial, including opinions on the fairness of coverage, the strength of evidence, and the performance of both prosecution and defense. Papers note the case's perplexing nature, with circumstances pointing both to guilt and innocence, and some express confidence in an acquittal.
The Providence News · 12 June 1893 · page 4
New Bedfor! Jouraal. Th; real jury of her peers which is try ing Lizzie Bordeu, is the job lot of fe nininivy whiea fillthe jurv box on the south side of the New HBediord court house every day.—Fall River G obe, There is no doubt that the Borden murder 18 the most {mpénetrable of mysteries if L'zzie Borden us a tactor in it is eliminated, 7There has not b.en the shado v of a clew to any other criminal ity in connection with It.—Boston Herald. But this is the most perplexinz feature of the case.
See moreSee less
Nearly everv circumstauce is possible of two explanatiovs, oue of which points to the young woman’s kuilt and the o'ber of which poiuts to her inuocence. —Brooklyn Eale. The axe with which Mr, and Mrs Borden were killed has been found, but this will be of little conseq ience if the ove who usel the deally weapon is not more clearly determined than by the evi dence already in.—Newport Ne ws, +» The case is being well tried by both sides, nud the defenes has been quite uc cessful in the cross-cxa ninatiou.—Lo well Courier, It is ineredible that if Lizzie Borden were cunning enough to plan and execute the crime for which she is being tried that she would burn a tell-tale, blood stained dress In tue presence of two wit nesses, Woonsocket Riporcer.
A short news item reports that the trial of Lizzie Borden for the murder of her father and mother commenced in New Bedford, Massachusetts, the previous Monday. It appears amid a roundup of unrelated state and national news items.
Orleans County Monitor · 12 June 1893 · page 8
General News Items. The trial of Lizzie Borden,' for the murder of her father and mother, was begun at New Bedford Mass., last Monday. Edwin Booth died June X, at 1:17
A sarcastic newspaper comment suggests Fall River police might blame Lizzie Borden for a new axe murder in the city, mocking their earlier handling of her case. It implies the evidence against her in the new crime would be as flimsy as in the original accusation.
Orleans County Monitor · 12 June 1893 · page 8
While the police of Fall River are about it, it would be quite in keeping with their conduct of a year ago to accuse Lizzie Borden of this latest horrible murder with an axe that has been disclosed in that city. There is quite as much evidence against her this time as before. Concord States man.
The Seattle Post-Intelligencer · Seattle, Wash. Terr. Wash.
A Fall River report describes talk around town suggesting the prosecution has presented a weak case against Lizzie Borden. It notes rumors that her defense will soon reveal a major surprise, with her lawyers and supporters appearing confident despite the 'hatchet incident' controversy.
The Seattle Post-Intelligencer · 12 June 1893 · page 1
The Borden Murder Trial. FALI. KlT**, Mass., June 11.—All day lon* talk has been plentitui on the subject of the Borden murders and there is no de nying that it ia the general opinion that the prosecution has thus far presented a weak case. This opinion is strenrthened by the rumors current here to the effect that Lizzie Borden's counsel will shortly explode a bombshell in the camp of the authorities. The defendant's lawyers do not attempt to disguise their joyful feel tnps because of the present status of the case, and the woman's friends here are jubilant. The hatchet incident with ac companying denials is a source of much comfort, but while the prisoner's friends are buoyant in spirit, the police authorities are by no means downcast.
The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · Wheeling, W. Va.
The article reports town gossip that the prosecution's case against Lizzie Borden is weak, with rumors that her defense will reveal she bought paint before the murders and that dress-burning was common in the household. It also notes conflicting police testimony, particularly Officer Mullally's disputed statement about finding a hatchet handle.
The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · 12 June 1893 · page 1
the llurclun Trial. Fau. Hiveu, Mass., Juno 11.?All duj lout,' tulk has boon plentiful on the sub' joct of the llordon murders and there can bo no denial that it in a goneral opinion about town that tbo proseculion baa thus fur a very wouk case. This rumor is being strengthened by rumors here to tho effect that Lizzie Borden's counsel will shortly explode ti bombshell into the camp of tho author itios. It is hintod that the defense will show conclusively that Lizzie llordon
The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · Wheeling, W. Va.
Conflicting testimony emerges over a missing hatchet handle, with police disputing whether it was found, while other witnesses debate dust marks in the barn loft that contradict Lizzie's account of being there. Defense attorney Jennings also highlights that officers investigating the case were later promoted, and a state detective grows confused under cross-examination.
The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · 12 June 1893 · page 6
proves as Kood a witness for Misa 1 den as the biiudlo itself. liut thoro were other strong bit ovideuco, and one, that allowed th woro no signs that Lizzie Borden I boon in tlio barn, na alio said alio ? UU kUIJ U1UIII1I1? U1 I.IIO IIJUIUUl, '
A report from Fall River describes widespread local opinion that the prosecution's case against Lizzie Borden is weak, fueled by rumors that the defense will present evidence about a paint purchase and routine dress-burning in the household. It also notes confusion over Officer Mullally's testimony about finding a hatchet handle, which contradicted other officers' accounts.
Wheeling Register · 12 June 1893 · page 1
THE BORDEN MURDER.
I a Very Weak. Rivkr Falls, Mass., June 11.—All day long talk has been plentiful on the subject of the Bordeu murders, and there can be no denial that it is a general opinion about town that the prosecution has thus far a very TOo&k ease. This nnlnion is being strengthened by rumors here to the effect that Lizzie Berdon's counsel will shortly explode a bombshell into the camp of tho authorities. It i9 hinted that the defense will show conclusively that Lizzie Borden purchased some paint a few days be fore the murder, and that It was not an uncommon thing to burn dresses In the Borden household. The fact that
At the New Bedford trial, prosecutor Moody argued for 45 minutes that Lizzie Borden's statements at the inquest should be admissible as evidence, while the defense sought their exclusion. Lizzie appeared more cheerful than the previous day, having apparently been encouraged by how proceedings had gone in her favor.
Waterbury Evening Democrat · 13 June 1893 · page 2
LIZZIE MORE CHEERFUL HER INQUEST EVIDENCE EXCLUDED
Vrry Little Attention to the Testimony. New Bkdfoud, Mass., June 13. As on yesterday, the court room was filled long before the opening of the trial this morn mg, ad again tne majority oi tue specta tors were women. Lizzie Borden looked much more cl:eer ful when she came into the court-roou . Evidently, the way things had turned in her favor during yesterday's proceedings had so affected her that she had spent a better night than she had for some time. The case was taken up where it was stopped last evening, with Dr. Dolan en during cross-examination. Shortly before court opened yesterday counsel on hoth sides were summoned into the private room of the presiding justices for consultation. Miss Borden came into
The court ruled to exclude Lizzie Borden's inquest testimony, visibly affecting her. Witnesses including Dr. Dolan and Officer Hyde then testified about the crime scene, autopsy findings, and the hatchet evidence.
Waterbury Evening Democrat · 13 June 1893 · page 2
HER INQUEST EVIDENCE EXCLUDED
to 2:15. The cross-examination of Officer Hyd developed nothing. The Kail River city records were then read to show the mar ringe of Mr. and ill's. .Borden and the age of the prisoner. Medical Examiner Dolan was called at 2:35 and examined by Pis trict Attorney Knowlton as to his exam in ation nt the Borden house on the day of the murder and the conversation with the prisoner. Doctor Dolan identified the carpet taken from the floor under Mr. Borden's head described the condition of the blood found with each body, that of Mr. Borden being warm aud dripping and that of Mrs Borden coagulated. Witness examined milk used by the Bordens, August 3 and 4, and identified the hatchets shown him
At the Lizzie Borden trial, the court excluded the stenographic notes of her inquest testimony after argument. Dr. Dolan testified the wounds could have been inflicted by a woman of ordinary strength and that Mrs. Borden died an hour and a half to two hours before Mr. Borden.
The Morning Call · 13 June 1893 · page 1
COULD HAVE DONE IT. The Doctor Tells How the Bordens Were Killed. New Bedford, Mas*., 12. —At the opening of the second week of the Lizzie
On the second day of the second week of the Lizzie Borden trial, the court excluded stenographic notes of Lizzie's inquest testimony after lengthy argument. Dr. Dedrick and Dr. Dolan testified about the bodies, concluding Mrs. Borden died well before Mr. Borden and that the wounds could have been inflicted by a woman of ordinary strength, while a policeman described Lizzie's movements in the cellar the night before the murders.
The Herald · 13 June 1893 · page 1
Preliminary Testimony by the Defendant Not Admitted. New Bedford, Mass., Jane 12.—At the opening of the second week of the Lizzie Borden trial this morning, over half the spectators were women. After the conrt was formally opened, the jury was directed to retire, and what pro mises te he a protracted argument over the admissability of stenographic notes of Miss Borden's testimony at the in quest began. After the arguments were concluded, the court retired for consultation ana returning decided to exclude the testi mony. Dr. Dedrick was then placed on the stand and testified that from his exami nation of the bodies he believed Mrs.
See moreSee less
Borden died first. Policeman Hyde testified that he saw Miss Borden and her friend Miss Rus sell go down into the cellar ehortly before 9 o'clock on tbe night of the mur der with a pail to the water closet and sink. Tbe prisoner made another descent later alone. They had a light, but Miss Russell looked nervous. After recess Dr. Dolan testified regard ing the finding of tbe bodies. A cast of Mr. Borden's head was introdu:ed, and the doctor explained how the wounds were located. . Mis* Borden covered her eyes with a fan while the doctor was making the demonstrations. He ex pressed the opinion that the wounds could bave been inflicted by a woman of ordinary strength, and believes Mrs. Borden was dead an hour and a half to two hours before Mr. Borden.
On the second week of the Lizzie Borden trial, the court excluded the stenographic notes of her inquest testimony after argument. Doctors Kedrick and Dolan testified about the victims' wounds, concluding Mrs. Borden died one to two hours before Mr. Borden and that a woman could have inflicted the wounds.
The Record-Union · 13 June 1893 · page 1
BORDES MURDER TRIAL. Eurly Testimony of Liezle Excluded by the Court. New Bkdkobd (Mass.), June 12.—At the opening of the second week of the Lizzie Borden trial this morning over half the spectators were women. After the court was formally opened, the jury was directed to retire, and what promised to be a protracted argument over the ad missibility of the stenographic note 9of Miss LSorden's testimony at the inquest began. After the arguments were concluded tho court retired for consultation, and on returning it decided to exclude the testi mony.
See moreSee less
I'r. Kedrick was then placed on the stand and testified that from the exam ination of the bodies ho believed Mrs. Bordou died first. Policeman Hyde testified he saw Miss Borden and her friend, Miss Kussell, go down into the cellar tho night after tho murder with a pail to the water-Qloset and sink. The prisoner made anothor descent later, alone. They had a light, but Miss Russell looked nervous. After recess Dr. Dolan teatili«d regard ing tho finding of the bodies. A cast of Mr. Borden's head was introduced and tho doctor explained how the wounds were located. Miss Burden covered her eyes with a fan while tho doctor was making his demonstration. lie expressed the opiuion that tho wouuds could have been indicted by a woman of ordinary strength, and believes that Mrs. Borden was dead an hour and a hall or two hours
Dr. Dolan continued testimony describing the positions of the bodies, blood spots, and wound characteristics, including that blows came from left to right with considerable force. He admitted inconsistency in his earlier preliminary hearing testimony regarding the time of Mrs. Borden's death relative to Mr. Borden's.
Evening Journal · 13 June 1893 · page 1
SHE SAT WITH CLOSED EYES, LIZZIE BORDEN HID HER FACE AS SHE HEARD THE GRUESOME DETAILS. Another Big Crowd Occupied All the Scats In the Court Bourn This Morning Before Court Opened —Tho Prisoner
The report notes that Lizzie Borden, despite her reputation as an undemonstrative Yankee woman, wept when the trial judges ruled to exclude her contradictory statements made before the coroner's jury. This brief item is embedded among miscellaneous editorial commentary on unrelated topics.
Evening Journal · 13 June 1893 · page 2
TUESDAY. JUNK 13. 1893. TnE summer girl is said to be most in tense In the moonlight. The sun tanned face that is fashion able and costly, now, is vulgar later on. Vegetarians are no stronger than any other fools ; they are no less tiresome. however. The ultra end ofthe-century girl de signs her own bodices and makes up to fit them;so we understand from the fashion papers. There has not been any unanimous approval of the anti-hat crusade of the Fullmer Chorus. The women are wait lug to learn what other women intend to do.
See moreSee less
I Î Lizzie Borden Is not an emotional I S; Tankee maid of uncertain age, but she wept when tbe judges decided to exclude j her contradictory evidence before the j * coroner s jury. Mrs. Potter Palmer denies that 1/ Eulalia was in her house less than five minutes, and says the gentle and EI gracious princess was there "more than I tire minutes." [ %, It will not be of any groat service to the quick or the dead to try to determine who is guilty of the carelessness of per mitting the nse of the Ford's Theatre J building. Congress is guilty, hut we cannot hang Congress. j It Is onr businessor duty to say things. ! j It is foolish aud absurd to maintain that a newspaper is an engine of silence, a ! I scheme for suppressing things. The
At the Borden trial in New Bedford, the court ruled that Lizzie Borden's contradictory and incriminating testimony before the coroner's inquest could not be admitted as evidence. The report calls this the most important decision yet, one that severely weakens the prosecution's case.
Evening Journal · 13 June 1893 · page 4
Another Victory for Miss Horden. In the Borden trial at New Bedford, Mass., the most important decision in the case, one that, goes far to break down the prosecution, was made. The Court degreed that Lizzie Borden'* testimony, which was very contradictory and incriminating, given before the coroner's inquest at Fall river,could not be admitted.
On the seventh day of her trial, Lizzie Borden's lawyers won a major victory when her coroner's inquest testimony was ruled inadmissible. The court also saw plaster casts of her father's and stepmother's skulls as a medical witness described the brutal details of the murders.
New-York Tribune · 13 June 1893 · page 1
HER MOST TORTURING DAY
MOTHER PUT IN EVIDENCE. 3 (FROM A STAFF CORRESPONDENT OF THE TRIBUNE.) New-Bedford, Mass., June 12.—The seventh day of Lizzie Borden’s trial has ended, the first of ' the second week, and in some respects the most thrilling and painfully sensational day of all. She achieved a notable victory, and she passed through a terrible ordeal. Guilty or innocent, when the plaster casts showing the features of her father and stepmother and the position they were in as they lay cold in death, and the horrible red marks drawn across their faces and heads, were brought into court and the story of the butchery was told by a medical witness in all its shocking details, Lizzie Borden experienced
A journalist describes a beautiful June day outside the courthouse before detailing Judge Mason's ruling excluding Lizzie Borden's coroner's inquest testimony as evidence. After the favorable ruling was read, Borden wept quietly for several minutes, a rare emotional display noted by observers who had criticized her stoic demeanor.
New-York Tribune · 13 June 1893 · page 1
ng. MISS BORDEN WEEPS AT LAST. ' The women who have been so much annoyed bo. canse Lizzie Borden does not ery, possibly felt better when at the close of the reading of Judge Ma son's decision pronouncing in her favor on the question of the admissibility of certain evidence given by her at the coroner's inquest, she bowed her head to the back of ex-Governor Robinson's chair and wept. And yet it was not the kind of weeping that would probably satisfy the kind of women who have heen criticising her firm and ale most stolid demeanor.
See moreSee less
There were no sohs, no wild gestures. Probably, indeed, only those who were ¢lose to her and who were watching her intently knew that she was crying. But they, if they looked closely, saw that her face was hid and that it remained low-hent against the back of the chair for as many as ten minutes; that hep handkerchief was at her eyes, and that when she lifted her face again her eyes were very red. Her lawyers had won a great victory: one thas
The report discusses legal arguments over whether Lizzie Borden's testimony given before the Coroner last August should be admissible at trial, comparing it to a precedent case involving Jacob Sharp. After initial disagreement, prosecution and defense attorneys negotiated a stipulation agreeable to both sides, including Lizzie herself, avoiding a separate hearing on the circumstances of the testimony.
New-York Tribune · 13 June 1893 · page 1
ought to fail, The purpose of District-Attorney Knowlton and his able and high-minded assistant, Mr. Moody, to undertake to get in the testimony Lizzie Borden had given before the Coroner at Fall River last
During the trial, Governor Robinson delivered a passionate argument for excluding Lizzie Borden's inquest testimony, made outside the jury's knowledge. The court later ruled in the defense's favor, excluding the evidence, prompting visible relief in the courtroom and tears from Borden herself.
New-York Tribune · 13 June 1893 · page 2
Court, the jury being all the while ignorant that any such matter was so mich as talked of. Governor Robinson's speech was not made, therefore, in the desire to produce any hut a legitimate eect Nevertheless, it was full of fire and spirit. and when he talked of the rights of Lizzie Borden it somehow seemed that he was waking a plea for the rights of all mankind.
At the New Bedford trial, the court ruled that Lizzie Borden's testimony given at the Fall River coroner's inquest would not be admitted as evidence, a decision that visibly moved her to tears. The prosecution then moved on to present medical testimony, with the defense's strategy regarding whether Borden would testify still undecided.
New-York Tribune · 13 June 1893 · page 2
RIVER RULED CUT BY THE COURT— THE LAWYFERS' ARGUMENTS. Yow Bedford, Mass, June 12.- Having fai'ed In Its eftort to place the testimony Lizzie Borden gave last Angust at the Coroner's inquest before this jury, the prosecution proceeded to the final stare of its case. This was the offering of the medical testimony. It is said by the District Attorney that he wll require two more days in which to finish bis cage. How much {ime the defence will occups depends on whether they place Lizzie Borden on the stand or not.
See moreSee less
1¢ they decide not to do so, their other witnesses can be examined easily In two days. 1f she takes the stand, she must expect to ctrnggle for all of that time against the District-Attorney. If Lizzie Borden is innocent, she ought to go on the stand. The law save that the fact of a defendant s refusal to take the witness stand in his own behalf must not be construed to his disadvantage. It 1s all well enough for the law to say that, put human inferences are not a thing that can be regulated by statute. Like the wind, they come and go as they list, It alwass has been inferred, when a person accused of an infamous crime falls to stand up and defend himself with nll the resources in his power, and especially with his personal declaration of where he was and what he was doing at tg time when the offence alleged against him was committed, that he is gullty. That inference Is natural and inevitable, The newspaper men hereabouts who have followed this case from the beginning unite in saying that it was not always conducted by the State with that fair and decent spirit which has been so distinguishing a feature of ts presentation here. Lizzie Borden was under suspicion within an hour after the murders were discoverad. Police Officer Medley, when on the stand last week, testified that he was one of the first poMeemen to reach the scene of the tragedy. He sald Le was there at half past eleven. Mr. Borden could pot then have been dead more than twenty minutes, He ask lizzie where she was when the thing happened, and she told him * out in the barn.” One would suppose that Medley's first impulse would have been to take a look about the house, to see If per chance the murderer were not somewhere concealed. But that did not seem to strike Medley. With a mental prescience and penetration truly astonishing, he dashed at once for the barn to see if he could discover Lizzie's footprints in the sediment of dust on its floor. Already, then, it seems, she was under suspicion. 1 had my doubts of Medley's story, but it Is unquestionably true that the police arrived quickly at the conviction that Lizzie was the guilty party. So did DistrietAttorney Knowlton, from the particular second of time when Medley and Fleet arrived at the Borden house until Lizzie's arrest
This editorial-style report, appearing during the trial, reflects on how quickly Lizzie Borden fell under police suspicion—within an hour of the murders being discovered—and criticizes the state's conduct of the case as not always fair. It recounts Officer Medley's testimony about questioning Lizzie and immediately checking the barn for her footprints, suggesting suspicion formed almost instantly.
The item observes that Lizzie Borden has shown little emotion during her ordeal, attributing her stoic self-control to her upbringing and temperament. It notes that she wept quietly, though not dramatically, when the court issued a ruling favorable to her case.
New-York Tribune · 13 June 1893 · page 6
and ineffective. Home Rule can easily survive such assaults upon it. n— —— Come people have found fault with Lizzie Borden because of the I'ttle emotion displayed
This report discusses the trial argument over whether Lizzie Borden's inquest testimony should be admissible, noting the Court ruled to exclude it as improperly coerced. It criticizes the police and magistrate for pressuring the drugged, distraught defendant into self-contradictory statements, and praises Ex-Governor Robinson's impassioned defense of her rights.
New-York Tribune · 13 June 1893 · page 6
A POINT FOR LIZZIE BORDEN. The argument in the Borden murder trial respecting the admissibility of the prisoner's testimony before the inquest tended to create
An editorial, written during Lizzie Borden's trial, condemns the police and prosecution for sloppy investigative work, citing discrepancies over locks, hatchets, and the delayed discovery of a blood-spotted dress. It argues that police coercive and inquisitorial tactics toward Borden violated her right to be presumed innocent until proven guilty.
New-York Tribune · 13 June 1893 · page 6
NEW-YORK DAILY TRIBUNE, TUESDAY, and broken handles; there would have been no suspicious amplification of the prisoner's explanations as previously reported by the same witnesses : and the light bine dress with its paint or blood spots would have heen distovered on the first day instead of being loft where it could be destroyed at leisure. The marshals and police seen to have been convinesd from the first day that Lizzie Borden alone could have murdered her st pmother and father. They devoted their energies to the business of making out a case against her, but apparently did not know how to go about it.
See moreSee less
They waited for her to give them cues, and even then failed to discover her in the act of burning the gown. In their desperation they had recourse to processes at once inquisitorial and coercive. It was at that point that they clearly and unwarrantably placed thamselves outside the limits of justice and law. It was their duty to discover the murderer, but they had no right to drag facts out of the helpless, half-crazed woman, whom they had under their eyes and against whom they had sworn out a warrant. In<crutable as was the murder mystery, Lizzie Borden had the supreme right to be accounted innocent until her guilt could be proved, and the attempt to compel her to incriminate herself was a wanton outrage upon law and morals. Whatever may be the final result of the trial, one moral may be drawn at one and sharply emphasized. The police in their zeal to make out a case when confronted with public clamor and criticism must never converd the legitimate processes of espionage and detective skill into measures of persecution and injustice. The law is not a rack for torturing and incriminating those accused of crime. It is a shield for the protection of innocence as well as a sword for punishing guilt.
The trial's second week opened with the court ruling to exclude Lizzie Borden's stenographic inquest testimony, a decision seen as favorable to the defense. Medical Examiner Dolan later testified about the hatchet and blood evidence, and the blue dress with a small bloodstain was presented in court.
Paper unidentified · 13 June 1893 · page 1
ONE FOR LIZZIE BORDEN. The Court Decides to Exclude the Accused's Statement at the Inquest.
New Belford, Mass., June 13. — Over one half the spectators in court this morning were women, and the second week of the Borden trial opened with th« appearance of increased inter* est as the uncertainties of the case are unfolded. Mies Borden came into court prompt ly at 9 o’clock looking somewhat worn and in answer to an inquiry as to her rest last night, she replied that she did not pass a pleasant night. The con sultation lasted twenty minutes. After a long argument of counsel the court decided to exclude the steno graphic notes of Miss Borden’s testi mony at the inquest when under sus picion and before her arrest.
See moreSee less
Thia was an important point in her favor. During the argument the prisoner was affected by an indisposition and was led from the room. It is the general belief here that the prosecution has made a very weak case so far, and it is said that the burned dress theory of the state will be knocked out by the defense, which will show that Lizzie Borden bought and used paint a few days before the murder and that it was not an uncommon thing to burn dresses in the Borden household. In the afternoon Medical Examiner Dolan took the stand and identified the hatchet taken from the floor under Mr. Borden’s head, describing the blood found with each body, that of Mr. Borden’s being warm and that of Mrs. Borden coagulated. The blue dress that figured in the case before, was brought into court. On the waist was one spot of blood, a spot about the size of a pin head. A cast of Borden’s head was intro duced and handed to the doctor so that he might explain how the wounds were located. One of the wounds was four inches long. Another was a half inch longer than that The doc" tor took one of the hatchets and with it stood against the cast and illustrated how the hatchet had struck the old man's skull. “In your oppinion, could the wounds you found upon the head of Borden have been inflicted by a ’woman of ordinary strength?” “Yes,” replied the doctor. “How long, in your opinion, was Mrs. Borden dead before Borden?” “About an hour and a half or two hours.”
The prosecution's case is reported as weak, with the defense expected to refute the burned-dress theory by showing Lizzie bought paint and that dress-burning was common in the household. Medical Examiner Dolan then testified about the hatchet, blood evidence, and wound measurements, estimating Mrs. Borden died one and a half to two hours before her husband.
The second week of the Borden trial opens with debate over whether the stenographic notes of her inquest testimony should be admitted as evidence. Prosecutor Moody argues at length for admissibility, claiming her conduct and declarations showing consciousness of guilt should be allowed even if a confession is not claimed.
The Morning News · 13 June 1893 · page 1
Bickering Over Admitting a Steno graphic Report of Her Evidence. New Bedford, Mass., June 12.—Over one-half of the spectators in court this morning were women. Tiie second week of the Borden trial opens with tho appear ance of Increased interest as the uncer tainties of the case are unfolded. Indi cations of a severe struggle over the ad mission of the stenographic notes of Miss Borden's testimony at the Inquest were plentiful this morning iu tho piles of books containing authorities to be cited pro and con. A few moments before the court opened the counsel on both sides were summoned into the pri vate room of the presiding Justices for consultation.
See moreSee less
Miss Bolden earno into court at 8:50 o’clock aud took her seat within tho bar, looking somewhat dragged, and in answer to an inquiry from Gov. Hobmsou as to her rest last night, her words and maimer indicated tlmt she did not pass a pleasant night. The consultation lasted twenty minutes. After the court was opened the jury was polled, and the officers were directed by the court to retire the Jury until sent for. (tending arguments to follow. Mr. Moody then addressed the court, saying he understood that tiie discussion now to be opened was that of tiie admissi bility of Miss Borden's evidence. Ho spent three quarters of an hour maintain
After lengthy legal arguments between Gov. Robinson and Mr. Moody over whether Lizzie Borden's earlier testimony was voluntary, the justices ruled to exclude it from evidence, visibly affecting the prisoner. The afternoon session then turned to Dr. Albert Dedrick's medical testimony describing the wounds on the two victims' bodies.
The Morning News · 13 June 1893 · page 1
TRIAL OF LIZZIE BORDEN.
Tho jury returned and at 12:42 o’clock Dr. Albert C. Dedrick wus called. Ho testified to an examination of the bodies ou the afternoon of the murder. In his opinion Mrs. Borden died first. The greater part of the afternoon ses sion was devoted to a technical descrip tion of the wounds on the two bodies.
A newspaper opinion column remarks sarcastically that the officials who brought the Borden case to trial seem to be more on trial than Lizzie Borden herself. It is one of several brief political and social commentary items in this editorial roundup.
The Indianapolis Journal · 13 June 1893 · page 4
T. LOUIS Union ewi Co., Union Depot. WASHINGTON, D. C.-Riggs Ilouse and Ebbitt Hon we. ' It begins tolookas if the officials who bavo instituted tho Borden suit con
The item notes that syndicated newspaper photos purporting to show ex-Governor Robinson, a defense attorney in the Borden case, inaccurately depict him with a mustache and clean-shaven face. In reality, he shaves his upper lip and grows a beard on his face, looking more like a rural preacher than the tough figure shown in the images.
The Indianapolis Journal · 13 June 1893 · page 4
Tnn special events of tho week In the world's fair gronnds are as follows: To day the Spanish government headquarters opens with reception to tho Princess Eulalia; to-morrow France celebrates; Thursday is German day and the Indiana building will be dedicated; Friday, Illinois press day; Saturday, Bunker 11 til day and dedication ot Massachusetts building. In addition to these principal events there will be many minor ones. The pictures which some syndicate is sending to newspapers as tho likeness of ex-Governor Robinson, of the Borden case, represent him as wearing a mustache with a olean shaven face.
See moreSee less
As a matter ot fact, the distinguished gentleman shaves his npperlipand lets the beard grow on his face. Becides, be would sooner be taken for an old-fashioned New 'England rural preacher than the semi-tough which these pictures indicate. ' Mr. Cleveland is recognizing his obli
At the Borden murder trial, justices considered and ultimately excluded the defendant's inquest declarations made while under suspicion before arrest. Prosecutor Moody argued for their admissibility, but the court barred them, and Lizzie Borden suffered sudden indisposition during the proceedings.
The Indianapolis Journal · 13 June 1893 · page 4
EXCLUDED BY THE JUSTICES
Higbt Have Inflicted the Fatal Blows. New Br.nroHn, Mass., Juno 12. Th courtroom where the ilorden murder trial is being held was again crowded this morn ing, one half of the people present being women. A lew minutes beforo court opened counsel on both sides were summoned intOa the private room of the presiding justices for consultation. Miss Borden came iuto
The second week of Lizzie Borden's murder trial began with arguments over admitting her inquest testimony, which the court excluded. Witnesses described finding her near the cellar after the murders, and medical examiner Dolan testified about the hatchet, bloodstains, and wounds shown on a cast of Mrs. Borden's skull.
The Wichita Daily Eagle · 13 June 1893 · page 1
THE BORDEN TRIAL. New hhVroi'.U, Mass , Juue 12. Tha second wtiekf if Lizzie Borden's trial for the murder of her father and stepmother opened this morning. The courtroom wjl crowded aud interest In the case inorx.x-js
Dr. Dolan took the stand and identified the hatchet found under Mr. Borden's head, describing the differing blood conditions at each crime scene. He used a plaster cast of Mr. Borden's skull to illustrate the wounds, estimating they could have been inflicted by a woman of ordinary strength and that Mr. Borden had been dead about an hour or two.
The Wichita Daily Eagle · 13 June 1893 · page 1
THE BORDEN TRIAL.
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
The report from Fall River describes the ongoing Borden murder trial, noting that public opinion views the prosecution's case as weak and that the defense plans to show Lizzie bought paint and that clothing-burning was common in the household. It also reports that Lizzie fell ill during argument over admissibility of her inquest testimony, which the court ultimately excluded from evidence.
Der Deutsche Correspondent · 13 June 1893 · page 4
Lizzie Borden's Prozesz
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
A rural correspondent's column lists local events of the week, noting that news ranges 'from the Lizzie Borden trial down to the every day life of the common laborer.' The rest of the item consists of unrelated local items about farming, injuries, and community happenings in Maine towns.
Oxford Democrat · 13 June 1893 · page 3
WESTS ETHEL. Another week has pasted with crowd ing events from the Lizzie Borden trial down to the every day life of the corn* mon laborer, and from them all It Is sometimes difficult to select the most
On the second week of the Borden trial, prosecution and defense attorneys argued before the judges whether Lizzie Borden's testimony given at the inquest, before her arrest, should be admissible as evidence. Borden appeared drugged and distressed in court, at one point being led out due to sudden indisposition during the arguments.
Daily Kennebec Journal · 13 June 1893 · page 1
A POINT GAINED.
PlMud at Oecisios. New Bkiookp. Mms.. June 12 — Over half the spectators today were women, ami the second week of the Borden trial opens with the appearance of increased interest, as the uncertainties of the case are un folded. Miss Borden came into court at B.50 ami took her seat within the bar. look ing somewhat drugged, and in answer to an inquiry from cx-Gov. Kobinson as to her rest last uight. her words and manner in dicated site did not pass a pleasant night. After court was opened and tlie jury polled, the officers wen* directed by the court to retire the jury until they were tent for, (lending the arguments to follow.
See moreSee less
The question of the admissibility of Miss Borden's evidence at the inquest when un der suspicion before arrest, was then ar
The court ruled that since Lizzie Borden was effectively under arrest during the inquest, her statements there were not voluntary and could not be admitted as evidence at trial. The ruling visibly affected Lizzie emotionally, and the trial proceeded with testimony from Dr. Dedrick on the autopsy and Officer Hyde on Lizzie's cellar visits the night after the murders.
Daily Kennebec Journal · 13 June 1893 · page 1
A POINT GAINED.
aw. He claimed Kobinson had utterly i 'ailed to show anything which would justify i lie exclusion of this testimony. He denied hat Miss Borden's rights had been trains , fressed in any way. The court retired for ronsideration at 11.15. i
During the Borden trial, prosecutor Moody argued for admitting Lizzie's statements from the coroner's inquest, citing legal precedents from several jurisdictions. The court ultimately ruled that her inquest testimony could not be used against her, a significant victory for the defense.
The Portland Daily Press · 13 June 1893 · page 1
GREAT POINT GAINED FOR MISS LIZZIE BORDEN
LIZZIE BORDEN. Che Court Says that Her Evidence at the Coroner’s Inqnest Cannot Be Used Against Her—Gov. Robinson Hade an Eloquent Appeal for His Client and Denounced the Course of the Prosecu tion in Stinging Terms. New Bedfobd, Mass., Juno 12.—In ;he Borden trial this morning the jury were sent from the court room and Mr. Woody began for the Commonwealth his irgument for the admission of Lizzie Borden’s statement at the now famous ‘star chamber” hearing, regarded as so rital to the Commonwealth’s case. Mr. Woody’s manner was very earnest, and in lis favorite [attitude, a slightly leaning posture over the table in front of him, iis left hand thrust under its correspond ng coat tail, the finger and thumb of die right hand repeatedly striking I lorcra V\i 1 a fvrnnnTvif't'nn Jnn/1 n Eront of him.
See moreSee less
Mr. Moody turned half round facing Lizzie Borden, but her eyes were not upon him. They had the far tway look of one absorbed in thought profound. Lizzie buried her face in her Ean for some moments. Then she grew ralm and attentively listened to Mr. Moody’s opening sentences. It was but for a short time, however. Then Mr. Jennings came across to her and the girl gave him a small bottle or phial, wrapped in tissue covering which he put in his pocket. Governor Robinson spoke a few words to Sheriff Kirby, and that kind officer conducted Miss Borden out of the court room.
At trial, prosecution and defense attorneys debate whether Lizzie Borden's statements at the inquest should be admissible, citing precedents from other states and Massachusetts cases. Gov. Robinson argues forcefully that she was effectively in custody and under suspicion when questioned, making her inquest testimony inadmissible under her constitutional rights.
The Portland Daily Press · 13 June 1893 · page 1
Gov. Robinson Replies. All eyes were turned on Gov. Robinson is he slowly arose, and amid the most mpressive silence began his answer. He placed Lizzie Borden squarely upon the
A defense attorney (referred to as the Governor) delivers a passionate argument criticizing the prosecution for withholding Lizzie Borden's arrest warrant while questioning her at the inquest, calling this a violation of her rights worse than the dress-burning incident. The judges then rule to exclude her inquest testimony as evidence, with Chief Justice Mason explaining the legal reasoning behind this decision.
The Portland Daily Press · 13 June 1893 · page 1
and the directors of the People’s Prohib itory League of Maine, after a full exam ination of the books and accounts of the missing secretary, John W, Mitchell, who has not been seen since Wednesday has made the following statement to the Kennebec Journal: “From all indica tions, and on examination of the books and accounts of Mr. John W. Mitchell, secretary of the People’s Prohibitory Enforcement League of Maine, and from all appearances and evidence be fore the board of directors in relation to his disappearance, I am authorized by the board to say that It is the unanimous opinion of the directors that Mr.
See moreSee less
Mit chell was accidentally drowned while bathing in the Kennebec river. All his accounts are straight and he had no money of the organization unaccounted for in his hands at the time of his dis appearance. “John C. Stewabt, President.” away”—of covering her at every minute, of surrounding her at every movement, was condemned in most sarcastic tones. “If that is freedom, God save the Com monwealth of Massachusetts,” said the Governor, thrilling his audience with the intensity of his utterance. , He desired that it be not lost sight of I as the great fact in this case that Lizzie Borden had been charged with the com
The report discusses the judge's ruling to exclude Lizzie Borden's inquest testimony from her murder trial, noting this benefits the defense since she had been questioned without counsel shortly after her arrest. It speculates that this ruling significantly reduces the prosecution's chances of securing a conviction.
The Portland Daily Press · 13 June 1893 · page 4
The exclusion of Miss Lizzie Borden’s testimony at the inquest from the pres ent trial seems to be another point gained for the defence. It has been be
Dr. Dolan testifies about the wounds inflicted on Andrew Borden using a mannequin head, with cross-examination continuing on forensic details like time of death based on digestion and blood coagulation. The report notes observers believe the prosecution's case is weak and predicts acquittal, as crucial inquest testimony was excluded from trial.
The Jersey City News · 13 June 1893 · page 1
A GRUESOME DAY
New Bedford. Mass., June 13,1S93.—If the Commonwealth of Massachusetts, which thecrier of the court calls upon the Almighty to save at the opening and closing of the session eacn day, does not present any stronger evidence as to why Lizzie Borden should be convicted of hav ing hastened her stepmother and father to death, she will never he convicted of the awful crime of which she stands charged in the indictment. That fact has become so apparent that some of the law yers (one of them came all the way from Georgia to attend the trial) who have been present from the first have gone home, thoroughly convinced that the jury will acquit the young woman now on trial for ■ her life.
See moreSee less
What the prosecution can have in re serve with which to convince the jury of the guilt of Miss Borden, if it has any thing at all. is a subject of speculation. Ibe evidence taken at the inquest, which furnished the prosecution with wedges which could have been used to advantage wiien she weut ob the stand, having been excluded, the prosecution wilt have to get along without It ns best it may. DU. DOLAN'S EVIDENCE.
Dr. Dolan testified under cross-examination about the nature of the blows that killed Andrew and Abby Borden, stating they were struck by a left-handed person using a hatchet with ordinary strength. He also discussed blood spatter patterns, the cut hair, and disputed whether a wainscoting stain was blood.
The Jersey City News · 13 June 1893 · page 1
DU. DOLAN'S EVIDENCE. When the case was resumtu this morn • lug Dr. itolau took the stand again, aud Mr. Adams continued his cross-examina tion: Amauikin’s head was set no ou a chair beside the jqry box and the doctor described how the blows tell upoo the head of Mr. Borden when he was mur dered. The doctor told how high some ef the biood s pots had appeared outhedlulng ioom wall. Then he was ashed aoout the piece of wainscoting which was in troduced in evidence yesterday. The doctor said he did not believe that the stain ou the piece of wainscoting was.
See moreSee less
biood. He had been so informed, he said, by the experts who examined the spots to determine whether they were or Were not blood. “Have yon an opinion as to where the assailant rf Mr. Borden stood?” “1 have.” “Where?” “At the head of the sofa and in front of the sitting-room door.” THE MURDERER LEFT-HANDED.
Dr. Dolan testifies that Mrs. Borden's thick hair may have cushioned some blows, that the fatal blows required only ordinary strength, and that the killer likely stood astride the body facing east. Under cross-examination he reveals blood was found on the soles of shoes given to him by the Borden family, while a juror faints from the courtroom heat.
The Jersey City News · 13 June 1893 · page 1
ordinary strength.” ASTRIDE THE BODT. Dr. Dolan said that the assailant struck some of the blows on Mrs. Borden astride the body. , Mr. Adams got to asking auostions »about tbe pillow sbgtma aud bedspread, a'rd made some.of *Hjf .hiemners of the jutw nervous. fo '^t wheu hs took the'pidbw shan* pread and laid iboiu across tfite s. ^ t ic of the jurors while asking aOou?; th They did not appear to be overload . . having tne ar ticles spread out over theV Tbe person who klllecr Mrs. Borden.
See moreSee less
Dr Dolan thought, must have stood fac tug the east wall of the room in which tne dead body was discovered. During the course of the examination Miss Borden betrayed some emotion. She cried almost steadily forseTeral minutes. Occasionally sue removed the haudker cuief from her eyes and gazed witn some degree of Interest at a bunch of flowers which the Rev. Jubbs offered her when he came into court this morning, A JUROR FAINTS.
This editorial commentary celebrates the court's decision to exclude Lizzie Borden's inquisitorial examination from being used as evidence in her murder trial. The writer argues this ruling, regardless of her guilt, is a vital safeguard for future generations' legal rights against prosecutorial overreach.
The Jersey City News · 13 June 1893 · page 4
Board of Freeholders. The Borden Inquisition. The exclusion of the inquisitorial examination of Lizzie Borden from use in her trial for the murder of her
On the seventh day of the Borden trial in New Bedford, defense attorney Robinson successfully argued that Lizzie's inquest testimony should be excluded because she was effectively a prisoner at the time, making her statements involuntary. All three judges upheld this contention, and the courtroom also featured gruesome exhibits including the hatchet, bloody garments, and the sofa on which Andrew Borden died.
The Sun · 13 June 1893 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.
A POINT FOR LIZZIE BORDEN.
HER TESTIMONY AT THE INQUEST EXCLUDED AT THE TRIAL.
See moreSee less
Gov. Robinson's Contention that at the Time of the Inquest Miss Borden Was in Effect a Prisoner, and that Her Testimony Was in No Sense Voluntary, is Sustained by All Three of the Judges—The Prisoner Bursts Into Tears and Her Body Shakes with Suppressed Emotion as the Decision is Announced—Gruesome Exhibits in the Case—The Hatchet.
NEW BEDFORD, June 12.—The seventh day of the Borden trial did not discredit the reputation the cause has earned as unique and crowded with sensations. Gore and hatchets, axes, plaster casts that might have been borrowed from a Bowery chamber of horrors, bloody garments, bits of bloody carpet and blood-spattered furniture and house fittings—these were the stage properties in this legal drama that is winding itself out to the length of a Chinese play. The talk of the witnesses and lawyers went further and dealt with autopsies, and even with things that, though not unfit for publication, are yet much better out of print than in it. In the hallway just outside the court room was the bloody sofa on which poor old Mr. Borden died so horribly. It was covered all over with gunny sacking, but whoever did not know what it was had it pointed out, so that all were prepared on the very threshold for the legal saturnalia that was to go on within.
Miss Borden is not well, and her face and manner showed it. She is utterly at fault with the reputation she first set up as a human barometer that showed each morning what the state of her cause would be during the day. Her illness is trifling, but it served to bring her before to-day's crowd of spectators with all her old heaviness of features and absence of facial mobility. At the jail it is explained that it was the grip that she had in Taunton, and, though she had it lightly, she is far from well of it. Those who are superstitious have given her up as a guide to each day's developments, and now depend upon a study of the flowers that deck the bench before the three grizzled Judges. They repaid the glances that were bestowed upon them, for where the blue heliotropes had been on Saturday there stood a vase of white carnations—snow-white ones—between the guilty red ones and the uncertain pallid pinks. Much the most important event of the day was the argument for and against the admissibility of the testimony Miss Borden gave at the inquest, when District-Attorney Knowlton questioned her and she made contradictory replies to questions as to her whereabouts at the time her father must have been butchered. It will be remembered that this battle for and against the admission of this testimony raises a new point in law in the old Bay State. But that is important outside of this cause. What was important here was how the Court would decide it, for all who are pledged to convict Miss Borden if they can were most anxious to get in the testimony, while her friends were as intensely desirous of keeping it out. The Government would have liked to have read what she said on that occasion for the edification of this jury; and then, again, if it was admitted they could cross-examine her upon it all over again in case she should be put on the stand. Miss Borden's lawyers were opposed to this course because they say she was under the influence of morphine, and because she was without guidance by counsel and was in the hands of Mr. Knowlton, whose manner toward her, as well as his persistence in construing every act and word of her's against her, has led her to fear him and to shrink ward from him as, perhaps, any woman so placed would fear a powerful man whom she regarded as her enemy and persecutor. Out of court, in the hotel, and the streets it has been popularly believed that it would be a bad day for the prisoner when this testimony, given in her befogged condition during a day of badgering, should be read to this jury. Some wanted her to have the worst that could befall her. Others wanted her to have a fresh bill of health with which to meet this ordeal. Thus is society here rent in twain upon the question of her guilt or innocence. As to the new point in law, the facts are these: Plenty of persons in Massachusetts have borne witness at inquests and inquiries and then been accused and confronted with their own previous testimony, but in every such case the first testimony has been given voluntarily. The point raised in this cause was that Miss Borden did not give voluntary testimony at the inquest after the murders in her home. Her lawyers hold that she was not formally arrested, but that she was to all intents a prisoner and accused of committing the crimes. A warrant was indeed out for her, she was surrounded and watched by the police, she was told by the Government that she had got to answer its questions "if she stood on the stand all day." The benefit of counsel was denied to her and she stood alone, a helpless woman who had never been in a court before, surrounded by this band of police and Government officials that now again gather at the Court House door and is seen to be the source of nine-tenths of the evidence in the case against her. This morning was set apart for the hearing of this argument. The court room was crowded. Even on the sidewalk the lawyers had to struggle to get through the perpetual and now swollen crowd of women idlers. Great was the curiosity to hear the master lawyer, ex-Gov. Robinson, as a speech maker. District Attorney Moody, assistant to the local District Attorney, made the argument for the admission of the woman's previous testimony, and addressed himself solely to the Court and to the legal precedents for what he demanded. It was to be presumed that Gov. Robinson would follow the same course, but he had his client's cause too deeply at heart, and he departed so far from a merely legal argument that the audience enjoyed a sample of the eloquence and art that makes him so strong before a jury. Miss Borden got leave to retire during the argument, and the jury was excluded from the room. After two hours of talking pro and con, the three dignified Judges left the room to consult and reach their decision. They were gone a little more than an hour. When they filed back into the room and the High Sheriff, with his suit of blue and brass, commanded all to rise until the Court was seated, the strain upon the people in the room was such that at the end an explosion of suppressed sounds marked the relief that had come to all.
The Judges found that Miss Borden had been to all intents and purposes a prisoner charged with two murders, and her testimony at the inquest was not voluntary. The feeling of both sides in the controversy over her guilt was that this was a grand piece of good fortune for her. When the decision was reached by the Chief Justice there was a man in front of and a man behind the correspondent of THE SUN. Both spoke to him, and almost simultaneously. "That is logic and good law," said one, "the Commonwealth would have been disgraced [by] any other decision." "Great God!" said the other, "it is a crying shame that justice should be defeated and a murderer protected because of so slight a point as that decision is based upon." Miss Borden had come into the room and was sitting behind Mr. Robinson. She burst into tears, hiding her face in her handkerchief, while her body shook with the force of her emotion. It was then that all who had felt the strain of the uncertainty as to the decision of the Court first realized what that strain must have been in the case of the prisoner. She wore a new dress and it was one that was many times more expensive than the old one which had grown so very familiar. This new one was a black silk covered with fine black lace. The lace fell over her shoulders and was treated with artistic taste in the decoration of the front of the basque. Her hat was the same one she had worn before. It has been said in these reports that this young woman has no art. That is a mistake. She has shown little weaknesses and her own conceptions of what she ought and ought not to do under given circumstances. These are seen in trifling ways, and accurate knowledge of her develops very slowly, for she is extraordinarily phlegmatic and undemonstrative, yet she is no more ingenuous than the rest of us. Whenever the lawyers who oppose her come to the subject of bloodstains, and the discussion of the gory details of the murders, she hides her face in her hands, but when her own lawyers take up the same subjects of inquiry she keeps her head up and her eyes bright, and tries not to miss a word of what is said. At first it was thought she could not endure the horrible topic, but enough time has passed to show that it depends upon who discusses it. Of course, this is very natural, and quite feminine, and amounts to nothing one way or the other, yet a great many things that are not important are watched just as if they were. Miss Borden's womanhood was fully established when she burst into tears at hearing the decision of the lawyers, and with womanhood there must be at least a modicum of the arts and ways of femininity.
Seldom can any person have seen quite such another woman as this prisoner. Her face is part of the time like that of a graven image, and at other times it is as responsive to one emotion as the face of an actor. That one emotion is her sense of the ridiculous. She has been seen to weep but once, and that was to-day. Her father never even once gave relief to his sorrow or joy in tears. She has laughed many times thus far in court. Mr. Robinson made her laugh more than once today. In repose hers is a dull and lifeless looking face. When she smiles or laughs it is a bright and sensitive countenance, but her evidences of pleasure and humor are very evanescent. Always in a minute she casts off all traces of what stirred her, and her face becomes once again a dull and heavy mask.
The occasion for the exhibition of all the Government's ghastly trophies was the appearance on the witness stand of Dr. Dolan, the medical examiner of Fall River, custodian of the skulls of the dead couple, performer of the autopsy, measurer of the blood spots in the house, and analyst of the contents of the stomachs of the deceased couple. The Doctor in private life may be a pleasant man for a lady's tea party, but on the witness stand he shows himself competent to add new horrors to the most bloody murder case in New England's history.
The proceedings opened with the withdrawal of the jurors and the hearing of the arguments on the admissibility of Miss Borden's testimony at the inquest. The argument took practically all the morning. Mr. Moody, District Attorney for Essex, argued for the admission of the testimony, and ex-Gov. Robinson argued against it for Miss Borden. Mr. Moody argued; Gov. Robinson made a speech. By permission of the Court Miss Borden left the room while the arguments were made and went down stairs and sat in a room by herself.
After quoting or citing one case after another, mainly causes tried in other States, Mr. Moody said:
"It becomes evident that what a person says at the inquest becomes competent if that person is afterward charged with the crime."
He repeated this in this form: "On an inquiry as to the death of a person, if one who is under suspicion is informed that he is under suspicion, and responds to the call of the State and voluntarily gives testimony, what he has said at the inquiry is admissible against him. It is a matter within the knowledge of your Honors and of the counsel for the prosecution that hardly a term of this court passes without the admission of precisely this [a]gainst kind of testimony which is sought to be introduced in this case."
He told of a woman charged with burning a building who was first tried for arson and then put to the bar for perjury on her testimony at the fire inquest. Mr. Moody reminded the Court that the Government could take no exception if the testimony was ruled out, whereas if it were admitted the defence could appeal to the Supreme Court.
When he concluded, Mr. Robinson spoke for the prisoner. "Your Honors are to inquire if these have been departures from the established view of the law, and if they have been rightly taken. This court is not to take chances. We stand to-day on the right of this defendant, at this hour, no matter what the variations have been. Whatever has been done it shall have no effect unless it receives the sanction of the highest judicial tribunal in the Commonwealth."
The ex-Governor produced several copies in typewriting of points he had jotted down and meant to enlarge upon in his argument. He received permission to hand these copies to the Judges and the lawyers for the Commonwealth. Taking a copy of his own in his hand he used it as a guide. The first point in the list was that the medical examiner is shown by the evidence to have taken charge of the bodies upon which the inquest was to have been held. Second, Miss Borden testified on Aug. 9, 10, and 11. From the second day after the crimes the woman was kept under the constant observation of the police, all the time until the conclusion of her testimony. Her house was surrounded by the police, there was no time, day or night, when the eye of the police was not on her house and all the inmates of it. So far as any effect on the defendant was concerned she knew the police were around her and she was under uninterrupted surveillance. Before testifying the defendant made a request for counsel. This was denied, and no counsel was allowed to her, she stood alone, a woman, for three days, unguarded by counsel, confronted by the District Attorney, watched by the City Marshal, and at all times surrounded by the police.
The next point made by the shrewd and earnest ex-Governor was that Miss Borden was not properly cautioned.
"The complaint had been made against her and the warrant for her arrest was issued. That mandate was held by the Marshal when he escorted that woman to the inquest. Can any one say she had not been proceeded against? She had not been formally arrested, nay, but the Commonwealth had asserted its power and the City Marshal stood ready at any moment to make her his prisoner. We must assume in common sense that that was at the direction of the District Attorney. It was not at random that that was done. Some one in authority asked it. She was, in fact, a prisoner, never free. Then, later, she was arrested on another warrant. Perhaps this was done in order to say she was arrested subsequent to her testimony; so that, perhaps, without its being intended, it was, in fact, an evasion of the law. It may appear, it might appear, to deprive this defendant of the rights guaranteed to her by the laws.
"She was a woman, she couldn't run, with the hand ever on her shoulder, under those circumstances she was taken to the inquest to testify, with no one authorized to tell her or who was bound to tell her that she had any rights at all. She stood alone. a defenceless woman. in that attitude. If that is freedom. God save the Commonwealth of Massachusetts. If anything that is done by a woman under such circumstances is voluntary, then compulsory must hereafter be known as voluntary.
"The crimes had been committed. and knowledge of the fact was in the possession of the law. That inquiry was only used to extort from this woman something to be used against her in her trial.
"It is not to be lost sight of," the Governor continued, "that at the time she was examined she had been formally charged with the commission of the murders. She was not summoned in order to find who had done the deed, for the Government had already sworn that she did it. Instead of serving that warrant they hid it away and said to themselves that perhaps they could get something out of her before they served it. Then they issued another warrant, and said that they would consider her testimony as previous to that warrant. I hope I have not said more than I ought to. If I do so I hope the court will consider that it is the defendant who is speaking to you out of her knowledge of her experience in Fall River and out of a jealous regard for her rights, into which she was born.
"It makes no difference that our statutes say a defendant so placed may testify, if he or she so desires, for they say, further, that no inference is to be drawn against her from the fact that he or she refuses to testify. We hear the constitution of Massachusetts read, and it passes glibly over the tongue, in and out, and that until some one plants his feet upon it and fails to recognize its declarations. Miss Borden stands on that ancient document to-day. It says that no person shall be forced to testify against herself. It was written when Massachusetts was born. It was the instinct of that hour. It has been the bulwark of our liberties ever since. When the Constitution of the United States was drawn it said in simple phrase: 'No person shall be compelled in any criminal cause to be a witness against himself. The shield of the State and the shield of the nation are her protection in this hour.'"
Leaving his notes and turning to the consideration of the precedents offered by the Commonwealth, the ex-Governor said a number of things which, taken at random, show the drift of his argument, the drift being all that there is room to report here. For instance, he said that it was true that the unserved warrant was in the Marshal's pocket. But that pocket did not belong to Marshal Hilliard; it was the pocket of the Commonwealth.
"The Commonwealth was bound to say to a woman in her position. We ask you nothing. We don't want to put you on the rack or fail to caution you or exclude your counsel. We won't do that because we have charged you with the crime. We have accused you in court and put a warrant for your arrest in the City Marshal's hands, and we will not ask you a question. That is what old Massachusetts wanted to speak in the ear of that woman that day, but the Commonwealth did not have that voice."
Mr. Robinson having finished his argument, Mr. Moody arose to reply for the Government. "I could not help," said he, "when hearing what my learned friend was pleased to call his argument, recalling the remark made by a French officer upon hearing of the charge of the Light Brigade--slightly changed to suit this case--it is magnificent, but it is not law. This delivery is surrounded by many vocal gymnastics and fireworks, but it is not law. I had hesitated to say that there is no precedent for the position taken by the defence, but now that the other side has finished its argument, we can safely assume that there is not any case or precedent to justify the exclusion of this testimony in this case. All this wasted rhetoric is due to misunderstanding of the law. It was the duty of the Court to make inquiry beyond the mere finding that a crime had been committed.
In explanation of this assertion Mr. Moody said that there were but two persons in the house when the murders were committed, and added: "Does any one say that it is not competent to examine them as to this crime?" Again he asserted stoutly that "Miss Borden was represented by counsel who was also her friend, though that does not appear in the evidence, and before she appeared under examination we certainly can presume that he cautioned her on her rights, and gave her full counsel, and she knew her rights when she went into the court room. She testified as a voluntary witness in every sense of the word, legal or otherwise. It was not a case of failure to caution, but a case where she was cautioned, a case of the exercise of caution in the most considerate way that could have been chosen. Mr. Moody denied that the District Attorney knew of the issue of the first warrant, gotten out before Miss Borden testified and never used. "It is not proven that the District Attorney knew of it," said Mr. Moody "and any assumption on the part of our learned friends that the District Attorney knew of it is entirely unwarranted. Later he said: "No case has been cited over the length and breadth of this land or England to warrant the exclusion of this testimony." At the conclusion he mentioned the very important fact that has been already explained when he said: "Even if you admit this testimony the rights of the defendant will still be protected." It was half past 11 o'clock when, with customary formality and dignity, the three Judges withdrew to consider the arguments. It was twenty minutes to 1 o'clock when they returned. Chief Justice Mason always shows a sad and almost melancholy face, but this appearance was exaggerated strangely when he came back into court on this occasion. He looked so sad as to all but draw tears, if not to shed them. It was as if he was going to sentence Miss Borden to death, and yet in fact he was really the messenger who brought to her the best news she has heard since her arrest. He sat in impressive silence for a full minute, looking the whole court room over, and then he picked up a pair of spectacles, adjusted them slowly and carefully before his eyes, and read the decision he and his associates had reached. It was as follows: The propriety of examining the prisoner and of all that occurred in connection therewith is entirely distinct from the question of the admissibility of her statements at that examination. It is with the latter question that this Court has to deal. The common law regards this species of evidence with distrust; statements made by one accused of crime are admissible against him only when it is affirmatively established that they were voluntarily made. It has been held that statements of the accused as a witness under oath at an inquest before he had been arrested or charged with the crime under investigation may be voluntary and admissible against him in his subsequent trial, and the mere fact that at the time of his testimony at the inquest he was suspected of the crime does not make them otherwise. But we are of the opinion, upon principle and authority, that if the accused was at the time under arrest charged with the crime in question, the statements so made are not voluntary and are inadmissible at the trial.
The common law regards substance more than form. The principle involved cannot be evaded by avoiding the form of arrest. If the witness at the time of such testimony is practically in custody—from the agreed facts and the facts otherwise in evidence, the prisoner at the time of her testimony was, so far as relates to this question, as effectually in custody as if a formal precept had been served, and without dwelling on other circumstances which distinguish the facts in this case from other cases on which the Government rely—we are all of the opinion that this consideration is decisive, and the evidence is excluded.
Miss Borden, in her chair in front of the dock and close behind the line of chairs in which her lawyers sat, leaned forward and drank in every word of the decision. For a moment after the reading and during the veritable gush of relief that sounded in the court, she still sat thus stoical and heavy faced. Then, like lightning, a purple cast spread all over her face, her hand sought her handkerchief, and almost too quickly for her to get it to her face the tears shot into her eyes. A strange, strong convulsion racked her body at the same moment. She pressed the handkerchief almost into her eyes, and again and again her body shook with the sobbing form that her overstrained emo- [...]sion Packe[t?] tion took. She was soon able to control her- self, but when she showed her face again it was blue. She then had recourse to her smell-
ing bottle.
Albert C. Dedrick, a doctor, was put on the stand to show that Mrs. Borden died first—a fact that the defence admitted when the trial began. Joseph Hyde followed with a sort of a bugaboo story about how he saw Miss Bor- den go down cellar on the night of the day of the murder with a lamp and followed by Miss Russell. She had a slop pail and she emptied it in the water closet.
Miss Russell was dreadfully frightened—she shook with fright. By and by, while the wit- ness, who is a Fall River policeman, was watching the cellar window, down came Miss Borden again with a lamp and was seen to stoop over the sink within five or six feet of the tub full of bloody clothing that had been taken from the bodies of the murdered couple.
That was all he had to say, but ex-Gov. Rob- inson made him say it all over again with great elaboration, as if to show how utterly without significance it was. That is, it was without significance, as it seemed that the prisoner's second visit to the cellar had to do with a certain pailful of towels that was in the cellar and which both sides have agreed not to discuss during this trial.
"How long was she there in the cellar?" the Governor asked. "Not a minute," said the witness. "You know the pail that was in the cellar; was it right there?" indicating on the dia- gram of the cellar. "Pretty near there," said the Fall River po- liceman. "Yes, I thought so," said the ex-Governor, triumphantly.
Dr. William A. Dolan, the medical examiner, was the next witness called. District Attorney Knowlton made his first appearance as an examiner in handling this trump witness for the Commonwealth. District Attorney Moody has done all the examining of the Government witnesses up to this point, but he has worked too hard and is very tired. Dr. Dolan told Mr. Knowlton that when he saw Miss Lizzie Borden soon after the discovery of the murders, she told him that Mrs. Borden had got a note from some one who was sick and had gone out earlier in the morning. Asked where the note was, she said she did not know; she thought probably that Mrs. Borden had burned it in the kitchen stove. The Doctor told how he saw Mr. Borden's body, freshly murdered, with bright blood oozing from it.
The prisoner covered her face with her great black fan. She kept it covered while the Doctor told of seeing Mrs. Borden's dead body all covered and with the blood dried and powdery in her matted hair.
Mr. Knowlton, heavy voiced, big bodied, and with the appearance of a redoubtable Roundhead of Cromwell's time, waved the blood-saturated handkerchief that was found beside Mrs. Borden at the witness and asked him what he knew about it. Witness Dolan knew that it was buried with the rest of the things found on the murdered couple. These things were dug up by the Commonwealth and certain articles were recovered. Then the handkerchief was buried again, and again it was dug up and preserved. The sturdy Roundhead produced a yard of light carpet horribly stained with Mr. Borden's blood and a smaller piece of dark carpet still like leather with the blood of Mrs. Borden.
The witness identified both, and they were put in as exhibits, while Miss Borden pressed the edge of her fan against her eyes. Then the medical examiner went on to say that Mr. Borden wore a Cardigan jacket, and that he (Dr. Dolan) found $81.65 and a silver watch and chain on the old man's person.
The medical examiner got Bridget Sullivan to give him samples of that day's milk and of the milk delivered on the morning before. The prussic acid theory was rampant soon afterward, and possibly the witness was expecting to find some of that poison in the milk. Nothing was found in it, by the way. But this is aside from his testimony. He next identified the clanking hatchets and axes, and said he took out the stomachs of the victims, put them in jars, sealed the jars, and sent them to Prof. Wood of Harvard.
At this point half the people in court were looking at Miss Borden and believed she was going to swoon again. It was another hot day, like the one a week ago to-day when she did faint. Two deputy sheriffs jumped in opposite directions to get water for her, and after a deep draught from the glass that came to her first she appeared to recover. She had made no demonstration except that her face had become blue and she had been resting heavily on the rail beside her.
The medical man next examined the counterpane from the bed in the room where Mrs. Borden died, and as it was held up a solitary spot of blood was found on it. Next, an apparently spotless slab of marble from the washstand in the same room was brought in and identified. After that, pieces of door jambs and great hunks of wainscotting were paraded be[f]ore the witness and the jury identified, and piled up on the table before the jury box. The witness ventured the remark that he also had the shoes and stockings of the victims which had been sent to Prof. Woods. There was a feeling of relief when District Attorney Knowlton said he was not going to produce the clothing taken from the dead bodies. He added that if anybody wanted he would send and get it. He did not address the prisoner's counsel, but looked around the court room as if he thought the reporters or the women on the back benches were going to express a wish to have the mortuary relics sent to their home addresses at once. The witness got in a great bother in trying to get the hang of one of Miss Lizzie Borden's white petticoats. It was the skirt she wore on the morning of the murder, and it had a stain of blood down by the hem in the front of the garment. Whether the blood is to figure as important in the trial has not yet been developed. The clumsy witness tried to get the pesky garment straightened out so as to show where the stain was, and in the course of five minutes he gave it up. Mr. Knowlton next sent for and got a plaster bust or cast of a man's head and chest at the top of a plaster pedestal. It was one of those casts that Italian modellers peddle around New York, and was the identical one that they sometimes sell as the head of Tasso and at other times as that of Julius Caesar. In the language of the school children, he played it was the head of the murdered Mr. Borden. He steadied it on the rail before the jury and began to mark it all over with blue strokes to show where the blows were rained by the murderer upon the old man's face and head. There were ten of these blows, one cut one eye in half, another split the mouth and chin. Six of the blows sunk into the brain. The Doctor gave the measurements of the wounds. He said that one was four inches long, another was three and a half inches long, and another was only two inches in length. This was important, because when Mr. Moody introduced the hoodoo hatchet he said it was three inches and a half in length on the edge of the blade, and that was the precise length of the principal wounds it made.
Mr. Knowlton got the witness to say he had the skulls, and then asked him to explain the process by which they were cleaned and prepared. To his credit be it said that he did not pursue that branch of the inquiry and the witness did not answer him. Mr. Borden's was comparatively a thin skull, the witness said. He next went into a dissertation upon the contents of the stomachs of the murdered man and woman, the purpose being to show that in the woman the morning meal was not digested, while in the man it was nearly all digested.
There was one great gash upon Mrs. Borden that was not on her head. It was on her back at the base of the neck and top of the spine. The witness put down the plaster cast representing Mr. Borden and took up one no longer than a clothespin and no bigger than a woman's fist, offered by Mr. Knowlton as a model for describing Mrs. Borden's wounds. It looked like the head that the Italians offer as that of the good Saint Anthony. The witness, in [l]ist, describing these wounds, said that a space of Mrs. Borden's skull four or five inches long and an inch wide was crushed in. Two dramatic questions, or one that was put twice with a slight change the second time, were then put by the District Attorney. "In your opinion, were the wounds found on the head of Mr. Borden such as could have been inflicted with a hatchet by a woman of ordinary strength?" "Yes." "In your opinion, were the wounds found on the head of Mrs. Borden such as could have been inflicted with a hatchet by a woman of ordinary strength?" "Yes." Finally the witness said that Mrs. Borden appeared to have died first. The afternoon wore along and time did not cause Miss Lizzie Borden to change her position or cease to conceal her face. She had brought into court a bunch of pansies, and these she left lying in her lap. Ophelia's words, "There is pansies, that's for thought" leaped to the mind. What thoughts were these delicate flowers dedicated to upon this occasion? If to the prisoner's, who would dare to say what was their nature? Were they guiltless as those of the poor mad girl in the play, or deep and damned like Lady Macbeth's? Mr. Melville O. Adams of Boston took the witness in hand for cross-examination. The elastic and accommodating character of Fall River testimony has become proverbial, but the depth and extent of its peculiarities had not yet been measured, it seems. When Dr. Dolan came into the hands of Mr. Adams the hoodoo hatchet began its pranks again, and it again began to play its demonish havoc. It was not brought out, it is true; it was not even directly referred to, but Dr. Dolan is one of its sponsors and has been its guardian. That is enough for this bewitched destroyer of firewood and Fall River officials. Mr. Adams took up the claw-hammer hatchet, which the police first thought to be the murderer's weapon, because it looked as if it had been scraped and cleaned. It measures four and a half inches on the edge of its blade, and therefore is longer than the longest wound in either of the victims. Everything was made to conform to the theory that this was the guilty weapon, when the previous examination in the case was made in court. After that the handleless or hoodoo hatchet was suspected of being the murderous weapon and the Fall River officials came into new conclusions. "Do you remember having testified that this claw-hammer hatchet was adequate to cause the wounds on the skulls of the victims?" Mr. Adams asked. "Yes, sir." "Do you care to change that opinion now?" "I do." "Why?" "Because that hatchet is four and a half inches long," said the Doctor. The reader will remember that the later and pet hatchet, called the hoodoo, is but three and a half inches long on the blade. "Do you remember at a former trial I gave you a china doll's head, and you marked it to show a certain wound on Mrs. Borden's head?" "Yes." "The skull was crushed in?" "Yes." "And did you not call attention to the claw head of this hatchet and say, it was made by that?" "Yes." "Do you desire to change that answer?" "Yes." "Why?" "Because I don't think it was done with that instrument." "Why?" "I had not then prepared the skulls." "What? Did you not have the skulls at that time?" "I would not say so. At least they were not prepared" "Did you not say they were?" "I don't remember; but I certainly had not examined them." "You described the hatchet that made the wounds as one with a cutting edge of about five inches, if not more?" "Yes, sir." "Did you notify the daughters, or either of them, or any one of the family, that you was about to take the heads and skulls?" "No, sir." "When you had done it did you notify these daughters, or either of them, that you had done so?" "No." "Did you notify them that the interment occurred under such circumstances as that?" "No, sir." These questions and answers fell upon the court room air with theatrical force, and nearly all eyes were turned upon the lonely girl in deep black as she sat listening with her calm face. A new bond of sympathy was created for her in every sympathetic heart. heart, and for her sister also, who had not been told what dismemberment followed the mutilation of the bodies of their father and stepmother.
The witness said that not counting the contusions or the wounds on Mrs. Borden's back the woman was butchered with eighteen strokes of an axe.
"Did you swear there was blood on one of the hatchets?" Mr. Adams asked, meaning the claw-hammer one which was the basis of the earliest Fall River findings.
"No, sir; only the appearances of it," said the witness.
"Did you say there was hair on that one?" "Yes, sir."
And so there was, the hair of a cow, it will be remembered.
Then, after the crier had cried "Hear ye!" once for every Judge on the bench and had asked God to save the Commonwealth of Massachusetts, the day's proceedings ended.
During the trial, lawyers argued over whether Lizzie Borden's contradictory inquest testimony about her whereabouts should be admitted as evidence. Her defense claimed she was under morphine's influence and unrepresented by counsel when questioned by District Attorney Knowlton, while the prosecution sought to use her statements against her.
The Sun · 13 June 1893 · page 1
concluded Sir. O'llonrke. The Winder building, now occupied by the Second Auditor's oflice. will bo Inspected by Mr. O'ltourke to-morrow, sailed on Saturday last Callaayn I. Itllla, a Weleom Tonlo at U aal ol aliua oar's wsikxi. tho inquest when District-Attorney Knowlton ,'Jpf ij questioned hor nnd she mado contradictory ietsll&l replies to questions ns tn her whereabouts at J"ii' tho timo her father must havo been butchored. "'-vSul It will bo remembered that this battle for and "iff against the admission ot thtstoBtimony raises Stjt a new point In law in tho old Hay State.
See moreSee less
But &$. that Is Important outsido of this cause. What 'j was important hero was liow tho Court would ISi decide It, for nil who aro pledged to convict jtSr Miss Borden if they can woro most anxious to WW.
At the Borden murder trial in New Bedford, Dr. Dolan was cross-examined about his examination of Andrew Borden's body and the position of the head wounds. The court staged a realistic demonstration using a plaster cast of the victim's head placed on coats in a chair to illustrate how Mr. Borden's body lay on the sofa.
The Evening World · 13 June 1893 · page 1
A JUROR TAKEN SICK.
In the court-room were occupied some time before the court opened. Miss Borim den made her appearance ten minutes ?m before tho Justices took their seats. jl Counsel held a short consultation with Sm. t the Justices In their room prior to the i session. " Dr. Dolan was called to resume his J, testimony In cros-examlnatlon, Mr. - Adams conducting. He said: "The J marks on the plaster casts were marked x by Dr. Draper. I think, last Friday, here jS In New Bedford. , " The second time I Baw Mr. Borden's body I made a more thorough examlnaZ tlon than I did at Arst. I think the ef- -i
A witness describes the pattern of bloodstains on the parlor door and furniture, concluding the assailant stood between the parlor door and the head of the lounge. He also demonstrates with a cast of Mrs. Borden's head how her body was found, noting some blows were struck by an assailant straddling the body.
The Evening World · 13 June 1893 · page 1
Witness here arranged the cast of i C Mrs Borden's head In the chair to h show the relative position of the body v , when found, and continuing he said: ,' I, "As she la) all the cuts on her head '1 were seen, the bruises were not. I can1 Jj not tell )Ott what part of her head had 1 i. the thickest hall on it, but she had quite ' J a full head of hair." T The witness said some blows on Mrs. ? 1 Borden were m ido by an asiallant ji f astride of the body.
See moreSee less
1 I A Juryman was taken alek, and a re1 cess of Ave minutes was taken at 1015. 'I The prisoner was affected, and was led idlB from the room. ,
The New Bedford Court ruled against admitting Lizzie Borden's inquest testimony from August 8th, given five days after the murder, despite prosecution arguments that she was not under arrest at the time. The report details how she was effectively in custody, denied counsel, and questioned without caution while under severe physical and emotional strain, with a warrant already issued though unknown to her.
The Evening World · 13 June 1893 · page 4
ANOTHER FOR LIZZIE BORDEN
- 'K Ijlstlngly for the admission of the tustlI Bf nony, arguing that wlien It was given 9 ,BJi Hiss Borden was not under arrest. L Ipif But the fact was shown that oxcept that i K fbe had not been token to Jail sho iw iiImlfA practically as much under unest us 'i Wti he V to"3ay' and "lat complaint had
The court unanimously ruled to exclude Lizzie Borden's inquest testimony, finding she had effectively been a prisoner at the time without counsel or warning. Borden wept upon hearing the judges' decision, a rare moment of sympathy after being portrayed as an unnatural monster by prosecutors.
The Evening World · 13 June 1893 · page 4
ANOTHER FOR LIZZIE BORDEN
finger of suspicion waa designedly directed townrds her, and while her nervous system was so completely shattered that her doctor was com-, polled to treat her with constant doses of morphine to enable her to benr up at nil. The unworthy trick of forcing a jnting woman to make statements lit such n time, to bo used against her subsequently, without ullowlng her any legal support, advlco or protection, was of a piece with all the police conduct of this extraordinary prosecution. The Justices were unanimous In Ih decision excluding the testimony, and hald that from the fncts agreed to by both sides Miss Borden was as much a prisoner at the time of the Inquest ns hc has ever been since.
See moreSee less
Tho Intro duction of the testimony was only In tended ns n means of annoyance nnd lr rlt.'tlon. It coulJ hne done no real harm to the prisoner, yet lis exclusion In nnotfier triumph for the able counsel for the defense. The scene In the court-room yesterday was most affecting.. The words of the Judges as they made their decision were the first kind utterances the poor girl ut the bar had hoard from those en 1 gaged In the goernmcnt's rase, and ' she broke down under them. This young
A brief newspaper commentary remarks that, so far, the defense has scored more points than the prosecution in the ongoing Lizzie Borden trial. It offers no new facts, just an opinion on the trial's progress.
The Evening World · 13 June 1893 · page 4
I These Government clerks gave Col. Alnsworth a bad quarter of an hour at the Ford'B Theatre Inquest. i It is undeniably true that thus far the defonso has made the more points out of the Borden prosecution. June plays a queer medley on the ' weather strings.
The New Bedford court ruled against admitting Lizzie Borden's inquest testimony from the previous August, despite prosecution arguments that she was not under arrest when she gave it. The report details how a warrant had secretly been obtained against her before the inquest, and she was questioned without counsel or caution while under emotional distress and medication.
The Evening World · 13 June 1893 · page 4
U SCORE AKOTHER TOB LIZZIE BORDEN. K The Kow Bedford Court yesterday Uectded against admitting In the Uorduit , A murder trial the testimony given by H the accused, Lizzie liorden, at the InVsH luel on lost Aug. th, five days after the GfHF murder. The prosecution pressed InP"'" sistlngly for the admission of the u-stl. ! roony, arguing that when It was given it Ulaa Borden wu not under arrent. K But the fact was shown that except thut
A dispatch from Fall River describes the general opinion that the prosecution has presented a weak case against Lizzie Borden. Rumors suggest her defense counsel will soon deliver a dramatic blow to the prosecution's case, with her lawyers and supporters appearing confident.
The Silver State · 13 June 1893 · page 3
.J. II. N. W. Lizzie Borden's Trial. A dispatch from Fall River, Mass., says that there can Ire no denial that it is the general opinion that the prosecution thus far has presented a | very weak case against Lizzie Borden. The opinion is strengthened by ru mors current to the effect that Lizzie Borden’s counsel w ill shortly explode a bombshell into the camp of the authorities. Defendant’s lawyers do not attempt to disguise their joyful feelings because <»f the present status of the case, and the girl’s friends are jubilant. — --
The stenographic notes of Lizzie Borden's inquest testimony were ruled inadmissible after lengthy argument. Dr. Dedrick testified Mrs. Borden died before Mr. Borden, and Policeman Hyde described seeing Lizzie and Miss Russell carrying a pail to the cellar sink the night after the murders.
Paper unidentified · 13 June 1893 · page 1
Trial Excluded. . New Bedford, Mass., June 12. At the opening of the second week of the Lizzie Borden trial this morning over half the spectators were women. After the court formally opened the jury were directed to retire, and what promises to be a protracted argument over the ad missibility of the stenographic notes of Miss Borden's testimony at the inquest began. After the arguments were concluded, the court retired for consultation. Re turing, they stated that they had de cided to exclude the testimony. Dr. Dedrick was then placed on the stand.
See moreSee less
He testified that from an examination of the bodies he believed Mrs. Borden died first. Policeman Hyde testified that he saw Miss Borden and her friend, Miss Russell, go down into the cellar shortly before 9 o'clock on the night after the murder with a pail to the closet and sink. The prisoner made another descent later alone. They had a light, but Miss Russell looked nervous.
At the Bristol county courthouse, tension builds as the court reconvenes after deliberation on a crucial evidentiary question. The judges rule to exclude Lizzie Borden's earlier inquest testimony, a decision seen as favorable to the defense, bringing her to tears.
Pawtucket Tribune · 13 June 1893 · page 1
TURNING OF THE TIDE
New Broronp, Mass,, June 13.—What a day of excitement it has been! Who that sat in the quaint old Bristol county court room can forget the picture ef its crowded benches, its deeply attentive bar; the hush that fell as the last elogquent word fell from the lips of the learned counsel and the dignified justices, arbiters of Lizzie Borden’s fate, retired. What a tense moment it was!
The Massachusetts superior court ruled that Lizzie Borden's statements at the inquest were inadmissible at trial, a major victory for the defense. The ruling affirmed the constitutional right against self-incrimination and visibly shook the prosecution, while a separate note mentions the mysterious bloodstain on the door jamb has not been addressed in the current trial.
Pawtucket Tribune · 13 June 1893 · page 1
HER TESTIMONY EXCLUDED.
Lizzie Borden Burst Into Tears, and the gyes of many a falr lady in the spectators’ seats glistened, too, in ready sympathy. It was the snpreme moment in the case; in that it marked the turning of the tide. “You may say,” said a distinguished Boston lawyer watching the case, ‘“‘that you have lived to see the grandest re affirmance of the sound old Massachusetts doctrine of the constitutional right of every free man to protection agajnst com pulsion to force him to give testimony which may criminate himself that was ever known.” It may not go into the Massachusetts reports, which contain only the decisions of the full bench of the supreme tribunal, but it establishes a precedent in criminal procednre for the guidance of prosecuting officers in future capital cases.
See moreSee less
Commonwealth officials will be siow hereafter to resort to such attempts to ob tain evidence as were practised against L/ zzie Borden at Fall River.
The report reveals that the prominent blood spot on the dining room door jamb, long central to the prosecution's theory of how Lizzie Borden avoided being spattered with blood, may actually be tobacco juice rather than blood. This undermines the original theory of how she positioned herself to kill her father without staining her clothes.
Pawtucket Tribune · 13 June 1893 · page 1
A New Sensation
I rom the Old Man's Brain. T'bis spot couid have been made in no other way, according Lo expert testimony, With this spot now deMared to be not blood a: all, and that it might be tobacco juice, there is an end of the theory as to how Lizzie Borden kept hersell so clean from the spattering effusion of blood from the old man’s wounds. The original idea of the prosecution was that Lizzie killed Mrs. Borden first, destroyed the wrapper sghe wore at thas tiiwe, then came down stairs, arranged her father conveniently to sirike him from the dining room door and then kept her clothes clean by striking him from that pointof concealment.
See moreSee less
This great, big spot on the door jamb ex plained this satisfactorily, if it was blood. If it isn’t blood, as is @ow stated, all this pretty allegory is swept away as if it were a spider’s web, Then, if Lizzie did not have the sheiter of the diufgpg room wall to cover her from the gory shower she must have been out in the middle room, If she was there she would have taken
During cross-examination at the trial, Dr. Dolan testified he could not pinpoint time of death within half an hour using blood coagulation or digestion, relying only on body temperature; a juror and Lizzie Borden both became faint during the proceedings. Professor Edward Wood then testified about his examination of the Bordens' stomach contents, finding no irritants and normal digestion patterns.
The Providence News · 13 June 1893 · page 2
DR. DOLAN EXPLAINING THE CUTS.
the jury room where he at once swooned, Mr. Hodges is 66 years of age and of not a very vicorous physique. Scarcely had t e jury left the room when lL.zzle appeared faint. She bad been sobbing quietly for some time. Last night sue was il As she walked slowly from the room her weakness was apparent, She swaved from side to side, and it was with difficuley that she was helped to the judges room. The scene was ex c.ting. Suppose the juryman should be come suddeniy ill, Aunother jury would need to be impan elled and the case would have to be retvried.
See moreSee less
What Would be the Result, Miss Borden was certainly quite ill A joiryman had fainted. Complications were possible which might delay the The return of the jury afier a few minutes, and not long after the return of Miss Borde, dispelled temporarily the feeling of suspense. But there still remained the fact tha t neither of these who uad been ill bad en tirely recovered. 2 ¥ L i
Professor Edward Wood testified about examining the Bordens' stomach contents to estimate time of death, finding no evidence of poison in either stomach or the milk samples. He also described testing the hatchet, axes, and clothing for blood, finding only one tiny blood spot on the hatchet consistent with human blood.
The Providence News · 13 June 1893 · page 2
Professor Wood Called. Professor Kdward S, Wood was next called vo testify, He receiv ed the bottles containing the samples of milk and the stomachs of Mr. and Mrs, Borden. He carefully ex amined the stomachs of both,
Expert witnesses testified about the hatchet found at the Borden house, with Professor Wood finding no blood traces despite visible spots, and explaining how cleaning could have occurred before the handle broke. The day's dramatic climax came when Chief Justice Mason ruled that Lizzie Borden's inquest testimony would be excluded from the trial.
The Providence News · 13 June 1893 · page 2
SPECIAL TO THE NEWS, NEW BEDFORD, June 13.—Officer nyde’s testimony late yesterday afteruoon was wholly relating to having seen lLizzie Borden and Miss Russell go down into the cellar on the evening after the murders. He said Miss Russell appeared to be de cidedly nervous, and that, as he saw her from a cellar window, she shook. Mr, Robinson tried several times to get wit ness to look and act nervous as he said Miss Borden did, but nov with very satis tactory results, 4 Hyde said Miss Russell carried a lamp, but that her shaking did not jar the chimney off.
See moreSee less
Ten or 15 minutes later he said the prisoner came down stairs again alone and went to the sink fora few sec onds; he could not tell what she did. The examivation of Medical Examiner William A. Dolan in the afternoon was not at all interesting, barring the half lozen hatchets and numerous integral parts of the Borden house introduced, un til Lawyer Adams took a hand for the woss-questioning, which was cut short by sdjournment, R Mr, Adams arraigned Dolan sharply for not notifying the Borden ygirls when a second examination was held at Oak Grove cemetery and new facts ascertained. He also sought to tangle the doctor on cer tain admissions made before the district iourt at Fall River to the effect that one of the claw hatchets found would have been adequate to accomplish all the dreadful work of the flend now so ruthlessly pur sued.
The report discusses the exclusion of Lizzie Borden's inquest testimony from her murder trial, calling it a severe blow to the prosecution's case. It argues the testimony was properly excluded because she was under morphine's influence and under threat of arrest when she gave it, making her statements unreliable.
The Providence News · 13 June 1893 · page 4
A VITAL POINT. The exclusion of the testimony that Lizzie Borden gave at the inquest into the death of her father and stepmother from the trial of herself for doing the deed must prove to be a very severe blow to the government’s case. Yet it is not easy to understand what’ the prosecution expected to gain by its introduction, The necessity of the prosecution is direct evidence, and it is not claimed, we believe, that Miss Bor den’s testimony at the inquest was of this nature, So far as appears now the sole hope of the prosecation is based upon what Miss Borden cannot prove, viz., that she did not commit the murders, and upon the fact that she was confused and contradictory in her stautements after the murders and at the inquest, In fairness to the prisoner, being tried for her life, the court could dono less than refuse to allow the introduction of testimony wrung from her when she was under the shadow of immediate arrest, and was under the influence of morphine to such an extent as to be substantially irresponsible for her acts.
This item compiles short opinions from various newspapers about the ongoing Borden murder trial, noting the defense's effective cross-examination and the case's nationwide fascination. One excerpt quips about the difficulty of recalling a woman's clothing, referencing testimony confusion.
The Providence News · 13 June 1893 · page 4
THE BORI"EN TRIAL, The defense in tue Borden murder trial is weakening the government’s wit nesses by its cross-examination. ExGovernor Ro inson is kiudly and cour teous in his examinatvious, but his ques tionings are made with a firmness and determination that sifts the evidence of all uncertainty., The government has
This report, published during Lizzie Borden's trial in New Bedford, summarizes the August 4, 1892 murders of Andrew and Abby Borden at their Fall River home. It recounts who was in the house that morning and relays servant Bridget Sullivan's account of Mr. Borden's movements and Lizzie carrying an ironing board shortly before the killings.
The Laurens Advertiser · 13 June 1893 · page 4
STRANGE MURDER CASE
I which is in the heart of tho city, five Cm-sous?Mr. Borden and his wife, izzie Borden, the servant, Bridget Sullivan, and John V. Morse, Lizzie's uncle. Morse, who was tho guest of the Mm dens, left the house early and did not return until after the murders were discovered. Emma Borden, Lizzie's sister, was away on a visit to Now Bedford. Thus it is known that at tho tlmo the murder was committed thero wero four pcsons in the house. Lizzie Borden and Bridget Sullivan aro the only survivors, tho other two having been Mr. Borden and his wife. THE 8EKVANT GIRL'S STORY.
Bridget Sullivan testifies about finding Lizzie at the door saying her father was dead or hurt, then discovering Mrs. Borden's body upstairs with Mrs. Churchill. Lizzie Borden's own testimony describes tending her ill father, then going to the barn for sinkers and eating pears before returning to find him murdered.
The Laurens Advertiser · 13 June 1893 · page 4
THE SERVANT GIRL'S STORY
They rushed downstairs, and Mrs. Churchill told Dr. Bowen that Mrs. Borden had been murdered. According to Bridget's testimony, when sho wont up stairs to He down Mr. Bowdon was In tho sitting room alivo and well. From fifteen to twenty minutes later, that is, at from live minutes before eleven to flftoon minutes after olovon, he was lying dead, with about a dozen cuts, mado by an axe or hatchet, on his head and face. THE ACCUSED GIRL'S STORY.
The report recounts Lizzie Borden's explanation for being in the barn—retrieving sinkers for a fishing trip—before discovering her father's body. It also details the forensic puzzle of the crime: the brutal, blood-spattering nature of the murders versus the near-total absence of blood on Lizzie's clothing, and theories (stripping, a rubber garment) proposed to explain this discrepancy.
The Laurens Advertiser · 13 June 1893 · page 4
THE ACCUSED GIRL'S STORY.
Tho heads and faces of Mr. and Mrs. Borden wero so chopped and hacked that they wero beaten almost out of human rosomblance. If Lizzio is guilty sho must have killod her father within twenty minutos and then appoarod bo fore hor neighbors without a spot of blood on hor clothing and without any sign that sho had hastily adjusted hor dross. In that time also sho must have concealed so effectively that it has never been found tho bloody weapon with which the deed was committed, and sho also disposed of every scrap of direct evidence that would connect her with tho crime.
See moreSee less
Lizzie Borden wore a blue dross when the neighbors entered tho house and found hor father and her stepmother murdered. Sho wore a blue dress about tho house in tho morning. In two rooms blood from the murdorod ones had sputtered and spurted over everything for many feet around tho dead bodies. l/i tho minds of the authorities there trever was doubt that tho murderer of Mr. and Mrs. Borden was smeared and splashed with blond. With tho excep tion of a single drop of blood the size of a pin head on her white underskirt, not a speck of blood was found on the clothing Lizzie woro before or after tho murder.
At the start of the trial's second week, the court ruled Lizzie Borden's stenographic inquest testimony inadmissible after lengthy argument. Medical witnesses Dr. Dedrick and Dr. Dolan then testified on the order of the deaths and the nature of the wounds, while a policeman described Lizzie Borden's movements in the cellar the night after the murders.
The Salt Lake Herald · 13 June 1893 · page 1
THE BORDEN TRIAL Stenographic Notes of Miss Bordens Ev deuce Excluded NEW BEDFORD Mass June 12At the opening of the second week at the Lizzie Borden trial this morning over half the spectators were women After
This Fall River report describes growing public sentiment that the prosecution's case against Lizzie Borden is weak, with defense counsel reportedly jubilant. It mentions rumors of a coming defense bombshell about paint purchases and dress-burning, plus discrepancies in a policeman's testimony about a hatchet handle.
The Roanoke Times · 13 June 1893 · page 1
MAKING A WEAK CASE
COUNSEL FOE DEFENSE JUBILANT i>oo]ile Ar? lieglniiini; to Think That the Progecution Im Very Much I.Ike Persecu? tion?Queer Discrepancies In TeNtlmony uf Kcci'iilly l'romote<l I'olicemnn. FALL Kivf.R, Mass., .Inno 12.?All day Jong talk has been plentiful on tho subject of the Borden murderers, and there can be no denial that It is a gcnerul opinion about town thut the prosecution thus far has n very weak case. This opinion is l>eing strengthened by rumors current here to tho effect that Linste Burden's counsel will shortly explode a bombshell in the camp of the authorities.
See moreSee less
It is hinted that the defense will show conclusively that Li/./.ie Borden purchased pome paint a few days before the. murder and that it was not an uncommon thing to burn dresses in the Borden household. Tho fact, that the girl burned the dress in
The second week of the Borden trial opened with disputes over discrepancies in police witness testimony about the hatchet, and a major legal argument over whether Lizzie Borden's inquest testimony could be admitted as evidence. Prosecutor Moody argued for admissibility while defense attorney Robinson countered that her statements were not voluntary, as Lizzie herself appeared exhausted and had to be led from the room during proceedings.
The Roanoke Times · 13 June 1893 · page 1
COUNSEL FOR DEFENSE JUBILANT
uncer aintios of tho case were unfolded. I ndications of a severe struggle over the admission of the stenographic notes of Miss Borden's testimony at the in? quest we*e plentiful this morniug In the piles of books containing the authorities to be cited pro and con. A few minutes before the court opened courselfor both sides were summoned into the private room of the presiding justices for consultation. Miss Borden came into court at 8:30 and took a seat within tho bar, looking somewhat drag? ged, and in answer to inquiry from Gov?
See moreSee less
ernor Robinson as to her rest last nigh t. her words and manner indicated she did not pass a pleasant night. The consul? tation lasted twenty minutes. After tho court was opened tho jury was polled and tho officers were directed to retire tho Jury till sent for, pending the arguments to follow. Mr. Moody then addressed the court, saying he un? derstood the discussion now to be opened was that of tho admifsibility of Miss Borden's ovidonce. lie spent three quarters of an hour maintaining ttie i?d
On the second week of the Borden trial, prosecutor Moody argued for nearly an hour that Lizzie Borden's inquest testimony should be admissible as evidence. Lizzie appeared tired after a poor night's rest while judges and counsel conferred privately before the jury was sent out for arguments on the matter.
The Times · 13 June 1893 · page 1
TESTIMONY EXCLUDED. LIZZIE BORDEN'S STATEMENTS WILL NOT BE ADMITTED
NEW BEDFORD, MASS, June 12.—-Over half the spectators in the court this morning were women, The second week of the Borden trial opens with an ap pearance of increased interest as the uncertainties of the case are unfolded. Indications of a severe struggle over the admission of the stenographic notes of Miss Borden's testimony at the inquest were plentiful this morning in the piles of books containing authorities to be cited pro and con, A few moments before the court opened counsel for both sides summoned into a private room the presiding justices for consultation.
See moreSee less
Miss Borden came into the court at 8:50 and took a seat within the bar, look ing somewhat dragged, and in answer to an inquiry from Governor Robinson, as to her rest last night, her words and marner indicated she dil not pass a pleasant night. The consultation lasted twenty minutes. After the court opened the jury was polled and the officers divected by the court to retire the jury until sent for, pending the arguments to follow. Mr. Moody then addressed the court, saying that he understood the discus efon now to be opened was that of the admissibility of Miss Borden's evidence.
The court ruled to exclude Lizzie Borden's alleged statements after arguments from Governor Robinson and Mr. Moody, visibly upsetting the defendant before testimony resumed on the medical examination of the bodies. Separately, a racial controversy arose when a Black woman was denied courtroom admission and a Black man who gave up his seat for her was then excluded, prompting a lawsuit over discrimination.
The Times · 13 June 1893 · page 1
Albert C. Dedrick was called. He tes titled ta an examination of the bodies or the afternoon of the murder. In his opinion Mrs. Borden died first, The greater part of the afternoon ses sion was devoted to technical descriptions of the wounds on the two bodies, The color line has been drawn in the Borden trial, and a law sult threatens A colored woman named Jackson was not afimitted to the trial to-day. After wards eight white ladies were admitted A well-known colored man named King gave up his seat to the Jackson woman, and was then excluded from the court. room because there was no seat for him and he was not permitted to stand, He
The Seattle Post-Intelligencer · Seattle, Wash. Terr. Wash.
On the second day of the trial's second week, the court excluded Lizzie Borden's inquest testimony after argument, then heard medical testimony. Dr. Dedrick and Dr. Dolan described the victims' wounds using a cast of Andrew Borden's head, with Dolan opining a woman of ordinary strength could have inflicted them and that Mrs. Borden died well before her husband.
The Seattle Post-Intelligencer · 13 June 1893 · page 1
She Hides Her Fee* Whlls Dnetor De scribes Wounds on Her Father's Head. J*ew Bepfobd, Mass., June 12.—At the opening of tbe second week of the Lizzie Borden trial this morning over half of the spectators were women. After the court was formally opened the jury was directed to retire, and argument over the admissi bility of stenographic notes of Miss Bor den's testimony at the Inquest betran. After the arguments were concluded the court retired for consultation, and return ing, decided to exclude the testimony. Dr. Dedrick was then placed on the stand and testified that from the examination of the bodies be believed Mrs.
See moreSee less
Borden died first. Policeman Hyde testified that he saw Miss Borden and her friend. Miss Russell, gj down into tbe cellsr shortly before 9 o'clock on the night after the murder with • pail to the water closet and sink. The prisoner made another descent later alone. They had • light, but Miss Russell looked nervous. After recess Dr. Dolan testified regard ing the finding of the bodies. A cast ot Mr. Borden's bead was introduced and the doctor explained how the wounds were located. Miss Borden covered her eyes with a fan while the doctor was making the demonstrations. He expressed the opinion that the wounds couid have been inflicted by a woman of ordinary strength, and believes that Mrs. Borden was dead an hour and a half to two hours before Mr. Borden.
The trial resumes with a large female audience as lawyers argue over admitting Lizzie Borden's inquest testimony. Prosecutor Moody spends 45 minutes arguing her statements, made while under suspicion but before arrest, should be admissible.
Wheeling Register · 13 June 1893 · page 1
Skull. New Bedford, Mass., June 12.—. Over half the spectators in court this morning were women, and the second week of the Borden trial opens with the appearance of increased interest as the uncertainties of the case are unfolded. The indications of a severe struggle over the admission of the stenogrophic notes of Miss Borden’s testimony at the inquert were plentiful this morning in the pile of books containing authorities to be cited pro and con. A few moments before court opened counsel on both sides were summoned into the private room of the presiding justices for consultation. Miss Borden came into court at 8:30 and took her
The court ruled that Lizzie Borden's inquest testimony was not voluntary and excluded it from evidence, visibly affecting the prisoner. Subsequent witnesses included Dr. Dedrick, who believed Mrs. Borden died first, Officer Hyde describing Lizzie's cellar visits, and Dr. Dolan detailing the crime scene, blood evidence, and a bloodstain found on Lizzie's skirt.
Wheeling Register · 13 June 1893 · page 1
THE TRIAL OF LIZZIE BORDEN.
The Jury returned and at 12:42 Dr. Al bert C. Dedrick was called, lie testi fied to an examination of the Borden house the afternoon of tho murder. In his opinion Mrs. Borden died first. Patrolman Joseph Hydo was then called and described seeing tho prisoner with Miss Russoll, go down in the cellar with a pail to the sink at 8:45 on the night aftor the murder. The prisoner made a second visit to tho cellar alone a lew III uiuucs i a> hoi • -- tion, be said they had a light, but Miss Russell looked nervous.
See moreSee less
The Court took a recess at 12 o’olock to 2:15. The cross-examination of Ollicer Hyde developed nothing. Fall River city records were read to show the marriage of Mr. aud Mrs. Borden and tho age of prisoner. Medical examiner Dolan was then called. Dr. Dolan ldentifled the carpet taken from the floor under Mr. Borden’s head, described the condition of tho blood found with each body, that of Mr. Borden being warm and dripping, and that of Mrs. Burden coagu^ted. Wit ness examined the milk used by the Bordens August 3 and 4, and Identified ti»e hatchets shown him on the day of the murder. He described tho position of both bodies when found and the con dition of the rooms where found. The blue dress that has figured In the case before was brought into court. Dr. Dolan said Mr. Jennings had given him the blue dress and waist and tho white skirt. On the white* skirt was one spot of blood, a spot about the size of a pin head. A cast of Mr. Borden’s head was in troduced and handed to the doctor so that he might explain how the wounds were located. One of the wounds was four Inches long, auotber was half an Inch longer than that. Miss Borden when the cast of ber father’s head was brought in covered her eyes with her fan. She did not remove it even when addressedby lawyer Adams. The doctor took one of the hatchets, and with its blade against the cast, illustrated how the hatchet had struck the old man’s skull. /Tn your opinion, could the wounds on the head of Mrs. Borden have been Inflicted by a woman of ordinary strength?” “Yes.” “How long. In your opinion, was Mrs. Borden dead before Mr. Brden?” *'tAbout an hour aud a half or two hours.’’ , - r Adjourned dntil to-jnorrv-*,
Dr. Dolan described the condition of the bodies, identified the hatchets and blue dress, and explained blood evidence found on clothing. He testified that a woman of ordinary strength could have inflicted Mrs. Borden's wounds and that she died about 1.5-2 hours before Mr. Borden.
A brief telegraph dispatch reports that Lizzie Borden was emotionally affected by testimony during her trial proceedings and left the courtroom. The item is part of a wire news roundup covering multiple unrelated stories.
Morning Journal and Courier · 14 June 1893 · page 3
LEFT THE COURT ROOM
Many Persons Were Killed and Injured. WAS 1HICH AFFECTED. Lizzie Borden Was Obliged to Leave the Court Boom In Order Not to Lis ten to Some or tne Testimony and Not to See tbe Skulls of Her Parents When They Were Brought Into the Court Mr. - Borden Was Struck From Behind, and Mrs. Borden's Assailant Stood Over Her.
Dr. Dolan continued cross-examination about the nature of wounds on Mr. and Mrs. Borden, demonstrating with plaster casts how Mr. Borden's body was positioned on the sofa. Lizzie Borden left the courtroom to avoid hearing testimony and seeing her parents' skulls presented as evidence.
Morning Journal and Courier · 14 June 1893 · page 3
WAS MUCH AFFECTED
From Behind, and Mrs. Borden's Assailant Stood Over Her. NkwBxdfobtj, Mass , Jane 13. On the resumption of the trial of Lizzie Borden this morning, Dr. Dolan, the Fall Elver medloal examiner whose testimony about the nature of the wounds inflicted npon Mr. and Mrs. Borden oonsnmed nearly all jesterday afternoon's session, was called to resume his testimony in croei-examtnatlon, Mr. Adams oondnotins. He said: Tne marks on the plaster oasts were made by Dr. Draper, I think, last Friday here in Hew riedlord. The second time 1 saw Mr. Borden's body I made a more thorough examination than I did at first.
See moreSee less
I think tbe effect of repeated blows on the head wonld be to make it sink more, and the head might have been higher when first laid down. Perhaps I disturbed it slightly when I examined it. I don't know what the height of the sofa was; I didn't measure it." Here an arm chair was placed against the wall to be nsed as an Illustration of how the head of the sofa was when Mr. Borden lay on It last, the door of the court room leading to the anterooms standing as tbe door of the dining room relative to the head of the sofa. The witness then placed two coats in the chair and upon these pnt the plaster oast of Mr. Borden in the posi tion in which the body is alleged to have
Dr. Dolan and Dr. Draper testified at trial about the blood spatter and the precise nature and location of the axe wounds on Andrew and Abby Borden. Lizzie Borden was visibly distressed during the testimony, causing a recess, while Draper estimated an hour's gap between the two deaths.
Morning Journal and Courier · 14 June 1893 · page 3
WAS MUCH AFFECTED.
he was called to Fall River by Dr. Dolan. He assisted at tne autopsy; ne examined the wounds on the head of Mr. Borden, and made the mark a on the plaster oasts. Here the doctor described the wounds.as
Newspapers nationwide express the opinion that the government has failed to prove its case against Lizzie Borden, deepening the mystery of the murders. The report notes that Governor Robinson has effectively countered the evidence presented by prosecutor Moody at each turn.
Waterbury Evening Democrat · 14 June 1893 · page 2
ThK general opinion as expressed in the papers throughout the country is that the government has failed thus far to make out a case against Lizzie Bor den. This leaves the Borden murder
Dr. Dolan continued testimony at the Borden murder trial, describing the wounds inflicted on Andrew and Abby Borden using a mannequin head and skulls, and revised his estimate of the time between the two deaths. Lizzie Borden appeared visibly distressed during the medical testimony and had to be led from the courtroom.
Waterbury Evening Democrat · 14 June 1893 · page 2
MISS BORDEN AFFECTED - She Would Not Listen to Dr. Draper's Testimony - SKULLS PRODUCED IN COURT
Length of the Handleless Hatchet. New Bedford, Mass., June 14. Long before the appointed time the court room was crowded. Lizzie Borden came in a few minutes btfore 9 o'clock, and shortly after that time the proceedings of the ninth day began. When court opened yesterday Dr. Dolan took the stand again, and Mr. Adams con tinued his crocs-examination. A mani kin's head was set up on a chair beside the jury box and the doctor described how the blows fell upon the head of Mr. Borden when he was murdered.
See moreSee less
He described the position of the b dies and the blood spots and said the blows came from left to right and were of moder ate force. The prisoner sat with closed eyes aud a fan over her face. Continuing, Dr. Dolan said that, the blows were made by a sharp instrument, and some of them on Mrs. Borden by an assailant astride of the body. A juryman was taken sick and a recess of five minutes was taken. The prisoner was affected and was led from the room. When the session was resumed. Dr. Do lan admitted testifying in preliminary hearing that Mrs. Borden's death was an hour to an hour and a half before his ex amination of her, but now thought it was an hour to an hour and a halt before Mr. Borden's death. He could not safely judge
Prof. Wood testified the stomachs showed no poison and a 90-minute gap between the victims' deaths, and that the handleless hatchet showed no blood but could have been cleaned before its handle broke. Dr. Draper described the skull wounds on both victims and used a new hatchet to test wound dimensions, concluding assailants would have been spattered with blood depending on which hand struck.
Waterbury Evening Democrat · 14 June 1893 · page 2
SKULLS PRODUCED IN COURT
Borden. Cross-examined by Mr. Adams Witness said the heaviest blow given Mr. Borden was the one which cut his eye, and theu he was obliged to give a detailed statement of the character of the eye and its position and surroundings in the head. He thought the blood spots on the wall near the sofa were caused by spattering rather than from arteries. The assailant of Mr. Borden, pro vided a short-handled hatchet was used, would necessarily stand close to his head, and would receive some spatters on the clothes, if the right hand was used then the upper right part of the body would be spattered; it the left hand was used then the spatters would be on the upper left hand side.
See moreSee less
(Here counsel produced a new hatchet which he asked Dr. Draper to see if it would fit the wounds; this was attempted, but would not fit because it had not been sharpened and was blunt, it was 3 3-8 inches wide on the cutting edge.) On Mrs. Borden's body the witness found 22 wounds, IU of the cuts iu the head, 1 in the back, and 3 contusions on the face The wound in the back may have been caused while she was standing, or it may have been caused when she was lying on the floor. It proceeded from below up ward. He saw nothing about tho cut ting of the hair on Mrs. Borden's h end to indicate that a sharp instrument like a razor had been used. Ou Mrs. Borden's head there appeared to be blows which were beveled in both ways; taking the injuries on Mrs. Borden's head altogether, he thought they had all been given in one direction, from right to left. The assailant of Mrs. Bor den must have been more or less spattered with blood in front, although some of the blood might have gone in the air and come down behind, and that the face and hair might reasonably have received some blood spatters. On conclusion of Dr. Draper's testimony the court adjourned at 0 o clock. If the Commonwealth ot Massa chusetts, which the crier of the court here calls upon the Almighty to save at the opening and closing oi the session each day, does not present any stronger evi dence as to why Lizzie Borden should be convicted of having hastened her step mother and father to death, she will never be convicted of the awful crime of which she stands charged in the indictment. That fact has become so apparent that some ot the lawyers (one of them came all the way from Georgia to attend the trial) who have been present from the first have gone home, thoroughly convinced that the jury will acquit the young woman now on trial for her life. What the prosecution can have in re serve with which to convince the jury of the guilt of Miss Borden, if it has anything at all, is a subject of speculation. The evi dence taken at the inquest, which fur nished the prosecution' with wedges which could have been used to advantage when she went on the stand, having been ex eluded, the prosecution will have to get along with It as best it may.
At the Borden trial in New Bedford, Marshal Hilliard and Mayor Coughlin testified about conversations with Lizzie Borden and identified weapons and clothing shown during the trial. A hostler and another witness stated they saw no one enter the yard on the morning of the murder.
Waterbury Evening Democrat · 14 June 1893 · page 4
STILL A MYSTERY. Witnesses Testify That They Saw No One In the Yard on the Day of the Borden Murder. New Bedford, June 14. Marshal Rufus B. Hilliard was the first witness
A Newark barber claimed a bearded stranger once wrote a letter confessing to killing Mrs. Borden out of revenge, though police suspect he was merely a crank. The same report also notes continued cross-examination of medical experts Dr. Dolan and Dr. Wood in the ongoing Borden trial at New Bedford.
The Morning Call · 14 June 1893 · page 1
TOLD BY A BARBER.
Newark, N. J., June 13.— Another Bor den story was evolved here to-day, when a local b.irber told a yarn to the effect that last fall a larzo man with a heavy black beard came into his sliod aud got a clean shave and close haircut. The man then borrowed some writing-paper ana wrote three or four letters, two of which lie threw on the floor as unsatisfactory. On? of lb.es* was picked up by the barber after (he man had gone, and he found it was ad dressed to Mayor Coughlin of Fall River, and stated that the writer bud murdered Mrs.
See moreSee less
Bnrden out of revenge, The barber did not explain why he kept this quiet so long, anil the police think the raysterloas man was a crank. New Bedford, Mass., June 13,— 0n re sumption of the Lizzie Borden trial this rooming the cross-examination of Dr. Dilan was continued. Nothing of special interest was brnueht out and he gave way to Dr. E. 8. Wood of Harvard Medical College. He testified that there wai no eTirt"no • i *H. •-tot«!n?>!!! of M.\ arid Mrs. Borden that they bad been poisoned. H<* found no blood or anything connected with the case, either instruments or cloth ing, except a small spot of blood on a white skirt, which was human blood and i-nbably came from the outside. The liatchet might have been cleaned. Dr. Draper also testified as an expert touching wounds, the cundition of the stomachs aud the blood, aud declared, from an examination of Hie skulls, that the instrument which producea the wounds was tnree and a half inches long, the exact length of the hatchet. The testimony of the day closed with the examination of a surgical expert, Dr. Cheever.
At the New Bedford trial, Dr. E. S. Wood testified no poison was found in the stomachs and only one small human bloodstain was found, on a skirt, possibly from an outside source. Dr. Draper testified the fatal wounds matched the length of the handleless hatchet, and Dr. Cheever gave a closing surgical report.
The Record-Union · 14 June 1893 · page 1
LIZZIE BORDEN TRIAL. Xothint; of Special Interest ISroutjht Out In the Testimony. New Bkdfobd (Mass.), June I*.—On resumption of the Lizzie ttorden trial this morning the cross-examination of
An editorial discusses the court's ruling to exclude Lizzie Borden's testimony before the coroner's jury, arguing this likely thwarts a legal maneuver by the prosecution. It argues the state's case is presumptively strong but not conclusively proven, suggesting suspicion falls on Borden mainly because no other suspect exists.
Evening Journal · 14 June 1893 · page 2
The decision of the court 1o exclude the testimony of Lizzie Borden before tbe coroner's jury, likely prevents the success of a trick of the lawyers for the
At the Lizzie Borden trial in New Bedford, doctors Wood and Draper disagreed about the nature of the wounds, and testimony suggested the person striking the fatal blows was left-handed. A juryman fainted during the proceedings as the prosecution continued trying to prove only the prisoner could have committed the crime.
Evening Journal · 14 June 1893 · page 4
PRINCESS EULALIA AT THE FAIR She Koama About the Ground« on Her I-a*t Day, and In the Evening Give« a Reception at Her Roodii-T he Viking fthlp'a Progress. In the trial of Lizzie Borden at New Bedford. Mass , more hope for the pris
The report observes that the Lizzie Borden murder case has drawn immense public interest, more than any trial in recent memory. It describes the evidence as entirely circumstantial and, based on newspaper accounts, not strong enough to secure a conviction.
Smyrna Times · 14 June 1893 · page 2
Th* «rîm* »a» a Li a j . il *" lae t road day light. The prisoner is a little upwards of thirty years old, and mov(d in the best society circles in the Bay State. Whatever may be the be lief in regard to the guilt of Lizzie Borden, it doss not look as if there woall be tbs evidence to convict her.
This general news summary from the New-York Tribune briefly notes that several medical experts called by the prosecution testified in the trial of Lizzie Borden at New-Bedford. It appears as one item among many unrelated news items of the day, including foreign affairs, sports, and local New York news.
New-York Tribune · 14 June 1893 · page 6
physician's advice . Domestic.—Colonel Ainsworth applied to the court for a mandamus compelling the coroner to allow him to appear by counsel at the inquest into the ~ause of the Fords Theatre disaster: the inquest was continned. ==== Several medical experts culled by the prosecution testitied in the trial of Lizzie Borden at New-Bedford, ===
The report criticizes Dr. Dolan, the coroner, for incompetent and overzealous forensic conclusions in the Borden case, including his failed attempts to link a hatchet and clothing stains to the murders. Professor Wood of Harvard, though called by the prosecution, contradicted nearly all of Dolan's blood identifications and found no poison or blood traces on the weapons examined.
New-York Tribune · 14 June 1893 · page 6
CROWNLER'S QUEST LAW, The prosecution in the Borden trial haz not strengthened its case by the introduction of expert testimony. The vagaries of Dr. Dolan,
The report states that medical experts called by the prosecution in the Lizzie Borden trial have inadvertently helped the defense, noting that no traces of blood were found on key evidence. It suggests the state's case is weakening and a verdict may be reached within the week.
New-York Tribune · 14 June 1893 · page 1
IN LIZZIE BORDEN'S FAVOR THE STATE'S CASE DWINDLING
bail was forfeited, and Mr. Buxton refunded himnade a statement as follows to a T ribune reporter: oo On the 24th of April last Charles M. Preston, superine eolf out of the cash of the bank. went by the block « of grants - « 0 mystery If is th v Jargest 1 one téndent of the banks of the State of New-York, began me lf een cal structure. Then Mr. Pra ly andj o Ton ml To ey Hints A FECat nt i : : su” ctamitation othe: Iiving Savings Juetitscion.
See moreSee less
Ro. DETROIT ELECTRIC WORKS SOLD his adviser, Marcus Otterhourgh, took of the soundest institutions of the kind jn the ->-— Lizzie Borden, it simply amounts to this: That wife. So far as their testimony bears against alleged, advised the purchase of the Colt tract. rev into a symimetri-
A staff correspondent reports from New Bedford that the eighth day of Lizzie Borden's trial has concluded. The report suggests a verdict may be reached within the week.
New-York Tribune · 14 June 1893 · page 1
IN THE COURTROOM—A VERDICT MAY BE REACHED THIS WEEK
At trial, Professor Wood testified after extensive forensic testing that no trace of blood was found on the hatchet-head or its handle fragment. This contradicted earlier assurances from prosecutor Moody that the weapon's use in the murders could be proven.
New-York Tribune · 14 June 1893 · page 1
BE REACHED THIS WEEK. prosecution does not bring its case to a close pretty soon there will not be enough of it left to go to the jury on. We have all been led to suppose from the way the hatchet-head has been talked about by the State’s attorneys that there was on it or about it something in the nature of tangible proof that it liad been used in the murder of Mr. and Mrs. Borden. Mr. Moody has said, far more boldly than he had any right to gay it, that he ~ould prove its use, The least that could be expected after such positive and direct assurances was that he would be ably te find traces of human blood on it. Everyhody
The report criticizes inconsistencies in testimony about which hatchet matched the wounds, contrasting a prosecution witness's shifting claims with Professor Wood's credible chemical analysis. It explains the prosecution's weak forensic case linking Lizzie Borden to the murder weapon, and notes upcoming testimony from Professors Draper and Cheever.
New-York Tribune · 14 June 1893 · page 2
AN EXPERT WITH BRAINS AND HONESTY. Professor Wood, the eminent chemist, brought some brains with him, together with a larze and well-formed bump of honesty, when he took the witness stand. The Professor is a man, as well as a professor. Ile las all kinds of sense, not merely that which enables a man to see well through a microscope, ard read the story of @ changing litmus paper. If the Professor was caught in the neighborhvod of the New-York Stock Exchange he would be taken for a broker who had been having a good time selling industrials short.
See moreSee less
When the character of lois testimony 1s considered, people not familiar with the history of the Borden case will wonder why on earth the prosecution ever called him. They d to: there wis no possible way of connecting Lizzie Borden with those murders unless some-
The report contrasts the testimony of Dr. Draper, a medical examiner with detective instincts who seemed to testify with Lizzie Borden specifically in mind as the killer, against Dr. Cheever's more neutral scientific testimony. It notes the day established only that the hatchet could possibly have been the murder weapon and that a woman could have struck the blows under certain conditions, while a pinhead-sized bloodstain on Lizzie's skirt was deemed insignificant.
Why not clothes? Why fit the exposed costume to a woman?’ Thera wis a tone or a flavor ali through Dr. Draper's testimony which suggested that he thought the pergon whose Flows he was describing was Lizzie Borden. Dr. Cheever did not give sox or identity to the assailant Le had in wind.
At trial, defense attorney Adams skillfully cross-examined medical examiners Dolan and Draper about plaster casts and wound evidence, including testimony about eighty-six blood spots near Mr. Borden's head. Dr. Dolan repeatedly contradicted his earlier statements, having retracted claims about blood marks that turned out to be paint or rust, and reversed his opinion on the assailant's position relative to Mrs. Borden's body.
New-York Tribune · 14 June 1893 · page 2
THE TWO MURDERS.
the eye. The witness said it was a clean cut, indicat. ing the use of a tool with a sharp edge, but he thought it might have been done with a hatchet, notwithstanding that the blow was a glancing blow and so well accofaplished that Jt had shaved ofl a piece of the eyeball. The witness testified that on the wall-paper near the head of Mr. Borden there were no less than elghty-six blood spots within a radius of a foot—testimony of value in considering how remote was the possibility of Miss Eorden being the murderer and escaping, no matter how wll she disposed of her clothing, witliout bloody evidences of guilt where they were exposed and not easily washed out.
At the Lizzie Borden murder trial, Dr. Dolan continued testimony on the positions of the bodies and blood spots, prompting Lizzie to be led from the room in distress. Dr. E. S. Wood of Harvard testified about stomach contents showing a time-of-death difference of about 90 minutes, and noted the hatchet could have been cleaned before its handle broke.
Paper unidentified · 14 June 1893 · page 1
DOCTORS ON THE STAND.
Up Again. New Bedford, Mass., June 14. Again to-day a great crowd thronged the courtroom where Lizzie Borden it being tried for murder. Mr. Adams continued the cross ex amination of Dr. Dolan, who described the position of the bodies and the blood spots. At this point a juryman wat taken sick and recess was taken. Ih( prisoner was affected by the gruesnmt exhibits and was led from the ropm Dr. E. S. Wood of Harvard medica college and described the examination of the stomachs. The handeless hat chet had dust like ashes on the blad< tightly adhered.
See moreSee less
Under defendant’i objection and exception, Professoi Wood testified that the hatchet migh’ have been cleaned of blood before the handle was broken off. Witness found nothing to indicate disease or irritatior in either stomach and the contenti show a difference of an hour and fl half in the time of death.
The report describes Lizzie Borden entering the courtroom smiling and composed after the previous day's ordeal, wearing an elaborate lace dress. It details the courtroom's grim atmosphere, with bloody evidence and plaster casts of the victims being handled during testimony.
Evening Star · 14 June 1893 · page 6
Special Dispatch to The Evemint Star. Naw BaDroaD. Mass., June 14.-Everybody was interested this morning to we how Lizzie Borden had borne the ordeal of yesterday un der a test of nerves such as no woman of culture
The report describes courtroom testimony detailing the ten blows that killed Andrew Borden and the hatchet evidence, while Lizzie Borden sat in an ante-room overhearing it. It also notes the hostile female spectators and Marshal Hilliard's testimony about her arrest and custody of evidence.
Evening Star · 14 June 1893 · page 6
than is manifested at this trial. It is certain that the wo ..en who scorn Lis sie Borden are here in-suflcient numberA to al most create an atmosphere of hostility in this connection. Tax Bn's representative notes a marked difference between the attendance of women spectators at this and the Almy trial. In that case there was a man who admitted that he killed utterly without provocation a pure and innocent girl whose only ofiense was that her Yankee sense had pierced the mask of the hired man and saw beneath it the features of the ex-convict.
See moreSee less
Today the doubt which must protect an so cused prisoner until every shred of it nas been torn away by the evidence against her still cioake Lizzie Borden. Her own sex among the spectators look beyond the evidence. and tear
City Marshal Hilliard testified at the trial about his repeated searches of the Borden house, collecting a dress and skirt from Lizzie's room, and about Mayor Coughlin informing Lizzie she was a suspect, to which she calmly replied she was ready to go. He also described police struggling to open a locked trunk found in the attic.
Evening Star · 14 June 1893 · page 6
LIZZIE BORDEN*S TRIAL. Marshal Euiliard and May.r Conghlin 0. en the Stand. Naw BSpron, Mass.. June 14.-The Borden trial was opened promptly at 9 o'clock, every
The trial of Lizzie Borden for the murder of her parents at Fall River has begun in New Bedford. She remained composed during the prosecuting attorney's opening address but fainted at its conclusion.
The Daily Bulletin · 14 June 1893 · page 1
Webster of Now Mexico. Julius Balke, one of tho founders of tho Bruuswick-Balko-Collonder Company, manufacturing billiard tables, iu which business ho waB ono of tho American pioneers, is dead at tho ago of (53. Lizzie Borden's tri.il at Now Bed ford for the murder of her parents at Fall River has bcinin. She was composed during tho prosecuting
Prosecutor Moody opens the government's case by outlining the murders and alleged bad feeling between Lizzie Borden and her stepmother, after which Lizzie faints in the courtroom. Witnesses including Bridget Sullivan and Miss Russell testify, with Russell describing a burned dress Lizzie claimed had paint stains.
The Indiana State Sentinel · 14 June 1893 · page 2
DEFENDANT GREW PALE.
New Bedford, Mass., Jnns 6. At 8:53 clock Miel Borden and the jury f ere in their seats and counsel wer on hand busily arranging their papers. The doors vera opened to epectators about that time and st least a third of those present tvera femslea. The rreather opens very arm and another scorching day is in prospect. State Petectires Seaver and thaw ars elose at hand to counsel for the prosecution as aid?, and Detective Ducey of Chelsea, who has been doing some quiet work on the sly for the defense, is handy to the call of the counsel on that side, air.
See moreSee less
Moody opened the government's, case. He eai4 that it was his purpose to put the etory of the crime before the jury in the simplest possible manner. He then brisiiy ran over the details ol the double murder, dwelling upon the narrow life of tha inmate of the Borden family and relating ineny incidents tending to show that iii feeling had existed for years between the prisoner and her etepruother. From the middle until the end of the address Miss Borden leaned back in her chair and never moved a muscle. Mio put the fan orer her face, and holding her head forward pre-ed it close a-tinet her forehead and held it there. Her eyes rere closed'and she appeared as if asleep. Not by any mean did she betray that sbo tvas conscious of what was going on about lier. Just as Mr. Moody bad ceased to speak and taken cno step forward toward L:s seat there was a noise where Miss Bor den was sitting, he Lad fainted. The !ev. Mr. Jubb hurried over to her an l placed a bottla of smelling salts to her nostrils. Deputy Sheritf Kirby, another ollicer. hurried after cracked ice. The woman's face ?rew white. The olficers returned with ico in a moment and a couple of minutes later Miss Borden be pau to recover. The case was opened by the government putting on its first wit ness in tho person of Thomas Kiernan, civil engineer. He minutely described the lkrden hou? an i its eurroundings. Court waa then adjourned until tomorrow in order that the jury mijjLt visit the scene of the crime.
Prosecutor Moody opens the case against Lizzie Borden, recounting the murders and alleged ill feeling between her and her stepmother; Lizzie faints during the address and is revived with smelling salts and ice. The jury then tours the Borden house and surrounding sites in Fall River before the trial resumes with the first witness.
The Indiana State Sentinel · 14 June 1893 · page 2
The jury toured locations connected to the Borden murders, including Dr. Chagnon's house and Crowe's lumber yard, before the trial resumed. Witness John Morse testified about finding Mrs. Borden's body and described the morning of the murders, with cross-examination raising doubts about police claims regarding the barn.
The Indiana State Sentinel · 14 June 1893 · page 2
Cf eningof the third day of the Borden murder trial this morning i:ccks were craued as Mi-a Borden entered the room, looking &s uunconcerned and Irtfch as possible under the trying circumstances. After fhe took her est Mr. Jennings had a five minutes' con versation with her, and she appeared very much interested and animated, a smile breaking out occasionally ns tiio talk pro ceeded. Cuasl change 1 location this morning bo that the defence could be nearer Miss Borden.
Testimony continues in the Borden trial, including details about a broken hatchet handle covered in ashes and Officer Harrington's account of Lizzie Borden's demeanor and statements on the day of the murder. Cross-examination reveals contradictions in Harrington's testimony, and the prisoner is reported laughing during his detailed description of her dress.
The Indiana State Sentinel · 14 June 1893 · page 5
THE BORDEN TRIAL Concluded from Second It. terday's testimony that tho broken part of the hatcbet handle was cov ered with ashes like the blade lie also said he put the bandle'.es hatcbet back where he found it, that it was not produced at tbe preliminary bear ing and that he did not testify about it at that time because he did not think it was used for the murder. He faid he reached the Borden house at 1:4S ou the day of
Officers Harrington, Doherty and Mullaly testified about the Borden crime scene, Lizzie's demeanor, and the hatchets found, with some contradictions between witnesses. A sensation erupted when Mullaly mentioned a broken hatchet handle piece that Fleet denied seeing and the prosecution claimed no knowledge of.
The Indiana State Sentinel · 14 June 1893 · page 5
THE BORDEN TRIAL
Ollicer Doherty was put on at noon, and described his experience at the Bordens on tbe day of the murder. OiScer Mul laty took the stand next. His direct tes timony as to the condition of the premises on the day of tbe murder developed noth ing new except a corroboration of Fleet's testimony as to finding the handlesa hatchet. Tbe broken handle was clean, but the blade was covered with ashes.
Officer Fleet's testimony about a broken hatchet handle piece surprised the court, leading District-Attorney Knowlton to admit he had no knowledge of such evidence and request verification from the Borden house. Meanwhile, Fall River gossip suggests the prosecution's case is weak, with rumors that the defense will explain Lizzie's dress-burning and paint purchase as innocent, unrelated to the murder.
The Indiana State Sentinel · 14 June 1893 · page 5
THE BORDEN TRIAL
"Well, you have not any objection to our sending an officer over there to eee about it, have you?" aeked Mr. Knowl ton. "Xo such question lies arisen yet," paid Governor Kobinson, "and we will pass it cow unless the court rules against it." The court decided it was not necessary to proceed any further now. Falk Kivrr Mas.-., June 11. All day long talk has born plentiful on the subject of tbe Borden murdc-rd and there can be no denial that it is a general opinion about town 1 1: a t the prosecution has thus far a very weak case.
See moreSee less
This opinion is being etrenrhencd by rumors current to tho elfect that Lizzie Borden's counsel will shortly explode a bombshell in the camp of tbe authorities. It is hinted that the defence will show conclusively that Lizia Borden purchased eome paint a few days before the u.urder and that it was not an uncommon thing to burn dree sea in tho Borden household.
At the New Bedford trial, Dr. Dolan testified about the victims' wounds, blood spatter patterns, and revised his estimate of the timing between the two deaths. Dr. Wood of Harvard then described his examination of the stomach contents and the hatchet, including ash-like residue on the blade.
The Indianapolis Journal · 14 June 1893 · page 4
EVIDENCE OF THE EXPERTS
Murderer of Mrs. Bardea. Nr.w Bedford, Mass., Jure 13. Again to day people crowded the court room whcrsi Lizzie Borden is being tried for murder. Mr. Adams continued the crossexamina tion of Dr. Dolan, who described the posi tion of the bodies and the blood spots, and said they came from left to right, and were of moderate force. The prisoner sat with closed eyes and held a fan over her face. Continuing. Dr. Dolan said that the blowg were made by a sharp instrument and by an assailant astride tbe body.
See moreSee less
A jurymaa was taken sick aud a recess was taken The prisoner was affected by the gruesome exhibits anil details, and was led from the room. The session being resumed. Dr. DoUa admitted testifying in the preliminary hearing that Mrs. Borden's death occurred, an hour to an hour and a half before Iks examination, but he now thought it vvas an hour to an hour and a half beioro Mr Borden's death. He could not safely judge
Dr. Draper and Dr. Cheever testified at trial about the skull wounds, concluding the handleless hatchet matched the fatal injuries; Cheever dramatically demonstrated the blow's angle in court. A separate dispatch reports a Newark barber's tale of a suspicious bearded man who had his hair shaved off and wrote disguised letters.
The Indianapolis Journal · 14 June 1893 · page 4
EVIDENCE OF THE EXPERTS
Dr. Cheever. urrioaI expert, was next called. He tostitied that the haudlelesf hatchet could make all tbe blows ou the bodies, and that one blow on Mrs. Border was made by a person fscing her. On cross-examination he said blood would nat urally fall on the aesailatit. There was striking and dramatic illustration, a little later, wheu Mr. Adams asked him to illus trate just how the blow would have to be struck in order to produce the cnt found ia the skull of Mr. Borden. Mr. Adams stool before tbe witness, who is tall, spare and very deliberate in all his movements.
See moreSee less
X new hatchet was held aloft lor a second. inclined to tbe ielt and then dashed through tbo air, straight, as It eeemed. for the skull of Mr. Adams. It seemed as if tbe crash of bone must be beard. The hatchet, however, stopped and remained steady. The spectators gasped. A fow minutes later court adjourned.
A barber describes a mysterious man who visited his shop last fall, asked to have his hair and beard shaved off, and left behind discarded letters—one addressed to Fall River's mayor claiming 'I murdered Mrs. Borden' and warning he was now too disguised to be caught. The article notes police suspect the letter writer may simply have been a crank.
The Indianapolis Journal · 14 June 1893 · page 4
You would not know me, would youl' I told him 'No; I would not.' 1 noticed two sheets of paper on the door that be had left behind. They were spoiled sheets that be bad m written. One of them was addressed to Mayor Coughlin. of Fall Kiver. It read: 'I murdered Mrs. Borden. I did it out of revenge. It is no use trying to catch me, because 1 am so disguised you would not know me.'" The police don't know what to make of it. It is possible the man who wrote tho letters was a crank.
At the Borden trial in New Bedford, surgical expert Dr. Cheever testified that a hatchet could have made all the wounds and that one blow on Mrs. Borden came from someone facing her, with a court recess due to a sick juror. Separately, a Newark barber recounted a stranger who shaved off his hair and beard last fall and left behind a letter confessing to murdering Mrs. Borden out of revenge, though police were uncertain what to make of it.
The Wichita Daily Eagle · 14 June 1893 · page 2
THE BORDEN TRIAL. New Bedford, Mass., June 13. Lizzie Borden's tiial proceeded this morning be fore a great crowd, composed chiefly of women. Expert testimony was presented regarding the character of the wounds ad ministered by the inutderer of Mr. and lrs. Borden. One of the jurors was taken sick and a Secebs was taken. Dr. Chcever, a sureical expert, was call ed, lie testified that the hatchet could make all the blows on the bodies, and that one blow on Mrs. Borden was made by a person facing her. On cross-examination tie said that blood would naturally fall on the assailant. An illustration wus given of the-blow described. Adjourned. Newark, N. J., Juno 13. A barber
The report notes intense public interest in the Lizzie Borden murder trial in New Bedford, Mass., but states that testimony so far has not established even a probability of her guilt. It concludes the outcome remains uncertain at this stage of proceedings.
The Wichita Daily Eagle · 14 June 1893 · page 4
The trial of the Borden case at New Bedford, Mass., in which so much in terest has been manifested, doesn't seem to elucidate the mystery of the murder. The testimony So far published does not seem to establish so much as a proba bility of the guilt of Lizzie Borden, the accused. Still, the outcome of the case is hardly guessable at this stage of the trial.
At the New Bedford trial, Dr. Dolan testified about examining the bodies of Mr. and Mrs. Borden, noting differences in body temperature and blood coagulation suggesting a time gap between the murders. He described finding bloodstained carpet pieces, axes and a claw-hammer in the cellar, and two hairs discovered on the hammer with a magnifying glass, which he turned over to Professor Wood.
Der Deutsche Correspondent · 14 June 1893 · page 4
Lizzie Borden's Prozeß. N e w-B edfor d.'Maff., 13. Juni. In dem Prozesse gegen Lizzie Borden sagte Dr. Dölau ans, er-sei zuerst am Montag um 11.45 Vormittags in dem Borden'schen Hause gewesen und habe gefunden, daß Hrn. Borden's Leiche noch warm war; das Blut sei aus den Wunden gesickert. Als er dann in Frau Borden'S Zimmer hinauf ge gangen wäre uiid ihre Leiche befühll habe,
Doctors Dolan, Wood, Draper, and Cheever testify about the hatchet, blood stains, a hole in the dress, wounds on the victims, and stomach contents showing no poison. Separately, a Newark barber reports finding a discarded letter claiming to confess to Mrs. Borden's murder, which police suspect came from a 'crank'.
Der Deutsche Correspondent · 14 June 1893 · page 4
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
At the New Bedford courtroom, Dr. Dolan testified about the angle of the fatal blows, suggesting a left-handed assailant, and about a suspected bloodstain near a door jamb that he now believed was not blood after all. Miniature figures and the actual sofa on which Andrew Borden died were used in court to reenact the murder scene, while Lizzie Borden appeared composed, shielding her face with a fan.
The Portland Daily Press · 14 June 1893 · page 1
EXPERTS RE-ENACT THE TRAGEDY AT FALL RIVER.
State—A Juror’* Illness. New Bedford, Mass., June 13.—Miss Lizzie Borden came into the court room some fifteen minutes before the ringing of the bell today. She wore lie same dress as yesterday, and carried a cluster of delicate pink and white rose peony blossoms. In general appearance she was much brighter than yesterday. It tiio oocvuu wn«ua m cum os, miss Borden sat with her face bowed into her open fan, its soft raffle covering her eyes, and shutting out the grewseme, uncanny looking little miniature busts used to impersonate her murdered parents.
See moreSee less
The sofa on which Mr. Borden was found lying dead was also in court. Rev. Mr. Jubb came up smiling, bring iug with him a bunch of gaily-variegated bachelor’s buttons and a folded note which he passed with the flowers to Miss Borden. Col. Adams opened his inter
A medical witness describes the wounds on the victim's head, noting they were clean, sharp, left-to-right cuts made with moderate force, and offers an opinion on the assailant's position during the attack. He also discusses blood evidence found on clothing and shoes, and clarifies earlier testimony about the estimated time difference between the two deaths.
The Portland Daily Press · 14 June 1893 · page 1
Jennings; I don’t know where he got it. “When I looked at a pocket in the dress there tvas a spot on the pocket which resembled blood, but as I look at it now I don’t think it was bloctd. I had the shoes and stockings brought to ms that same day and thoaght there wa« blood on the so}e of one of the shoes. I found none oA the stockings; I found a pin-heAd spot On the Wklte skirt. I do not know what I said at the time about the time of death of Mrs.
See moreSee less
Borden, as compared with the tfcme of death of Mr. Borden.” Continuing, he said: “I don’t know whether I said she had died 11-2 hours before I saw her or before Mr. Borden dkl. (The minutes of the first hearing showed that he had said then she died from an hour to an hour and a half before he saw hnr.) I have •not the impression that f. said that, but 1 now say the difference between the deaths was from one to one and a half hours. If both died at the same time
Dr. E.S. Wood of Harvard testified no poison was found in the stomachs and only a small spot of human blood was found, possibly from an outside source. He stated the murder weapon was likely the handleless hatchet, matching the 3.5-inch wound length, while a separate item describes a crank's false confession letter found in Newark.
The Helena Independent · 14 June 1893 · page 1
THE BORDEN TRIAL. Was the Mysterious Work Done With the Handlolese eatobet. Nuw BnrDoaD, Mase., June 18.-On the resumption of the Lizzle Borden trial this morning the eross-ezamination of Dr.
The report recounts the August 4 murders of Andrew and Abby Borden and notes that circumstantial evidence led to Lizzie Borden's arraignment and commitment to Taunton jail on the 12th to await trial. It describes her as calm and dignified despite suspicion, and notes her known friction with her stepmother but no clear motive for the killings.
The Helena Independent · 14 June 1893 · page 1
LIZZIE BORDEN.
n the oity of F4ll River, Massachasetts. Sines that time the affair has oeapied a eonapiounoa place is the newspaper press, the criminal oourt, and the public mlnd; but up to the present writing, the mystery eurrounding it may be said to have deep ened rather than dispelled. A strong chain of ciroumstantial evidence, however, has been tiahtenian about the remarkable young woman whose portrait is given to our readers on this page-Miss Lizzie Borden, daughter of the murdered man, and stp. daughter of the wife who perished with him. Miss Borden and a domestic named Bridget Sullivan were about the house when the aged couple were savagely stricken down with a hatchet at midday.
See moreSee less
It was the daugh ter who gave the alarm that brought in the neighbors and police, who failed to discover the slightest trace of the murderer outside of the dwelling. After a searching examin. ation, Miss Borden was arraigned, and, on the 12th inst., committed to the Taunton
On the third day of the Borden murder trial in New Bedford, court observers noted the prosecution's case appeared weakened by its own witnesses, and Lizzie Borden's testimony from the inquest was ruled inadmissible. The report also describes Lizzie's calm, composed demeanor in the dock, her attire, and her apparent lack of visible anxiety despite the gravity of the proceedings.
Weekly Union · 14 June 1893 · page 1
Inquest Ruled Out. NEw BEDFORD, MAsSS., Juae 7.—At the opening of the third day of the Borden murder trial this morning the morbid curiosity of the female portion of the com munity was catered to, and nearly one half of the spectators in the court room were women. While they were finding places the jary came in, under the charge of Deputy Sherlff John Nickerson, and two minutes later Deputy Sheriff Kirby escorted Lizzle Bor den to her seat in the dock. The sharp-toned bell pealed out its an ncuncement of courl time at 9 o’clock, but tbe judges were late, not comling in until five minutes after that hour.
See moreSee less
While walting, Lizzle Borden sas in her station as calm and immovable as ever, ap perently nene the worse for her lapse of firmoness yesterday afiernoon. She was attired in the same black gown and black hiat, with blue rosestes that she has worn since Monday, and she walked firmly, with a ponchalant air. Lizzle Borden does rot act as a prisoner generally does whose very life rests on the words which drop from the lips of those whe talk on the witness stand., Shels more than stocial, half the time she does not even seem to be listening to what is being sald by the witnesses. She never leans forward and pays mas ked attention, but sometimes she wilil lock straight into the eyves of the person and gathers every word. But that is gen erally when very important testimony is belng given. ; She appeared well today, and her at tendants report a good appstite and plenty «f sleep, all that she can hope for until the jury is ready to report. The testimony of the forenoon up to the 1 ¢’clock noon recess presented
Robinson's cross-examination of Officer Fleet exposed contradictions about the handleless hatchet and revealed sisters were seen using the back stairs, weakening the prosecution's locked-door theory. Other officers testified about the crime scene and Lizzie's demeanor and dress on the day of the murders.
Weekly Union · 14 June 1893 · page 1
ROASTING THE WITNESSES, Ex-Governor Robinson Continues to Riddle the Government Case.
¥xGoverncr Robinson Continues to Eiddle the Government Case. NEw BEDFORD, MAss., June 9.—The cross-examination of Officer Fleet by exGovernor Robinson for the defense was resumed this morning, and lasted about an beur and a half, The witness testified that in the box in the cellar rcom where tre bandleless hatcbet of which the gov ernment s making so much was_found two other batchets were also found, and that there was a pile of ashes in the same roome. Considerable time was spent in showing tbut the search which the oflicers made of the Borden house on the day of the mur cer was uot a very thorough one.
See moreSee less
Counsel succeeded in involving wltness in a coniradicticn of his previous testi weny as to whether the handleless hatehet Lied ashes on the brokean part, He also acmitted that in the prellminary hearing e falled to testify about the handieless hatchet, although asked all about what he fuund in tke cellar. ; Cfiicer Philip Barrington was the next witness and testified as to what he saw in the Borden house the day of the murder, relating his conversation with the prison er, in which she sald her father sat down snd read the paper and she went out in the barn and that the motive could not have been robbery for everything was right, even to the watch and ring on his finger. §he showed no emotion and was very
The report defends the judges' ruling barring Lizzie Borden's inquest testimony from being used as evidence at her murder trial, calling it simple justice given she had no counsel and was questioned as a virtual prisoner. It argues the prosecution must prove its case with other evidence, noting the extraordinary nature of the crime if guilt is established.
Weekly Union · 14 June 1893 · page 4
A Righteous Decision.
The words of this article could not be separated from the rest of its page. Read it in the clipping.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
Weekly Union · Manchester, N.H.
This brief item references the Brooklyn Eagle's assessment that the state's witnesses are hurting its own case in the Lizzie Borden trial, describing it as more a hunt for the murderer than proof of guilt. It also sarcastically mocks prosecutors for making a spectacle over a hatchet with no handle as evidence.
Weekly Union · 14 June 1893 · page 4
Borden are making fools of themselves over. Nicaragua has a new president, and the people cheer “the United States minister lustlly on every appearance. That country is all right. 3
During the trial, the prosecution's own expert admitted an earlier claim that the blood spot was on the front of Lizzie Borden's skirt was mistaken, clarifying it was on the back, below the opening and six inches above the hem. The rest of the day's testimony moved into speculative conjecture about skulls and blood evidence, while reporters also described the courtroom atmosphere and Lizzie's demeanor.
The Sun · 14 June 1893 · page 3
spirits. There were no other notable flower In the court room, but the puro white carna tions wero still In tho centra ol the Judge's desk. A newcomer among the women spectators had Miss Llzzlo Borden pointed out to her. and at the first stance exclaimed, "Why. ba
The report describes Lizzie Borden's appearance and the hostile, judgmental crowd of women watching her trial. It also details two days of graphic medical examiner testimony using plaster dummies to reenact the murder scene, including the positioning of Abby Borden's body and her wounds.
The Sun · 14 June 1893 · page 3
LIZZIE'S TRIAL.
xmtured as no many fallow deer, but when any 2 no speaks to thorn ot tho trial thoy say: Oh. do hopo they will hang her." Why God has mado lovely women so unjust toward her own sex and so prono to think ill ot any person in petticoats. He alone can tell. Certainly tha women hero abandon reason In their scorn of Llzzlo Borden, and aro In sufficient numbers to greato a hostllo atmosphere In the court room. In that cruel environment tho prisoner sits every day without a woman near her. becausa
The report describes graphic courtroom testimony at Lizzie Borden's trial, including the medical examiner's use of a screen image and staged recreation of the father's battered head wound, prompting a juror to faint. It also covers Professor Wood of Harvard testifying as a chemistry expert about blood and stomach contents, with commentary on Lizzie's composed but attentive demeanor throughout.
The Sun · 14 June 1893 · page 3
Placed in such a position 7 Guilty ae Judas, or spotless as Cornelia, whnt torturo must shn have suffered I Macbeth seter o,unilod beneath worso epoctrea than must have Hulked across tho stage of men tality. Ut course, alio exhibited nearly all of ner wonderful nerve. The Borden have hoen Americans for two hundred and nfjjr years,
A Newark barber claimed that last fall a bearded man got a shave and haircut, then wrote several letters, one addressed to Fall River's mayor confessing to murdering Mrs. Borden out of revenge. Police believe the mysterious man was merely a crank, and the barber offered no explanation for his long silence.
The Daily Morning Astorian · 14 June 1893 · page 1
13 LIZZIE BORDEN GUILTY?
A RAP AT THE TRUSTS. Chicago, June 13. Judge MeConnell this afternooni hit the trusts a hard rap, particularly the preservers' trust. It was In a suit against It by a recalci trant member, Andrew D. Bishop. In overrulllng the demurrer by the asso ciation Judge McConnell said In part: "No court of record should lend its legal operations to further tho inter ests and carry out the purposes of the trust. To my mind the corporation known as the American Fruit Pre serves' Association Is but an agent of the trust, and as such the same Ille gally attaches to Is as to tho principal. The association now has three days in which to reply to Bishop. 13 LIZZIE BORDEN GUILTY?
On the ninth day of the Lizzie Borden trial, Dr. Dolan testified using a mannequin's head to show how the fatal blows were struck, describing wound positions and blood spatter. Testimony focused on matching the wound size to the three-and-a-half-inch blade of the handleless hatchet found in the Borden home.
The Evening Herald · 14 June 1893 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
MISS BORDEN AFFECTED
She Would Not Listen to Dr. Draper's Testimony.
See moreSee less
SKULLS PRODUCED IN COURT
Evidence to Show That the Instrument Which Made the Wounds Was Three and One-Half Inches Long, the Exact Length of the Handleless Hatchet.
NEW BEDFORD, Mass., June 14.—Long before the appointed time the court room was crowded. Lizzie Borden came in a few minutes before 9 o'clock, and shortly after that time the proceedings of the ninth day began.
When court opened yesterday Dr. Dolan took the stand again, and Mr. Adams continued his cross-examination. A manikin's head was set up on a chair beside the jury box and the doctor described how the blows fell upon the head of Mr. Borden when he was murdered.
He described the position of the b dies and the blood spots and said the blows came from left to right and were of moderate force. The prisoner sat with closed eyes and a fan over her face.
Continuing, Dr. Dolan said that the blows were made by a sharp instrument, and some of them on Mrs. Borden by an assailant astride of the body. A juryman was taken sick and a recess of five minutes was taken. The prisoner was affected, and was led from the room.
When the session was resumed, Dr. Dolan admitted testifying in preliminary hearing that Mrs. Borden's death was an hour to an hour and a half before his examination of her, but now thought it was an hour to an hour and a half before Mr. Borden's death. He could not safely judge priority within an hour from blood coagulation alone or from digestion alone, if they had been sick.
On re-cross examination Dr. Dolan said the length of the wound would not determine the length of the edge of the instrument.
Dr. E. S. Wood, of Harvard Medical College, was then called and described the examination of the stomachs.
Prof. Wood found nothing to indicate disease or irritation in either stomach, and their contents showed a difference of an hour and a half in the time of death. There was no evidence of poison in the stomachs or in the milk used by the family on Aug. 3 and 4. Examination showed no blood on the claw-hammered hatchet or axe or on the blue dress. The hair found on this hatchet was not human.
Prof. Wood said the blood spot on the white skirt probably came from outside and was human blood. The shoes and stockings and dining-room door casing had no blood spots. The handleless hatchet had no blood. The break in its handle contained no dust.
The handleless hatchet had dust like ashes on the blade tightly adhering. Under defendant's objection and exception, Prof. Wood testified that the handleless hatchet might have been cleaned of blood before the handle was broken off.
Dr. Draper then took the stand and described the wounds in the skull of Mr. Borden.
Cross-examined by Mr. Adams—Witness said the heaviest blow given Mr. Borden was the one which cut his eye, and then he was obliged to give a detailed statement of the character of the eye and its position and surroundings in the head. He thought the blood spots on the wall near the sofa were caused by spattering rather than from arteries. The assailant of Mr. Borden, provided a short-handled hatchet was used, would necessarily stand close to his head, and would receive some spatters on the clothes, if the right hand was used then the upper right part of the body would be spattered; if the left hand was used then the spatters would be on the upper left hand side.
(Here counsel produced a new hatchet which he asked Dr. Draper to see if it would fit the wounds; this was attempted, but would not fit because it had not been sharpened and was blunt, it was 3 3-8 inches wide on the cutting edge.)
On Mrs. Borden's body the witness found 22 wounds, 18 of the cuts in the head, 1 in the back, and 3 contusions on the face. The wound in the back may have been caused while she was standing, or it may have been caused when she was lying on the floor. It proceeded from below upward. He saw nothing about the cutting of the hair on Mrs. Borden's head to indicate that a sharp instrument like a razor had been used.
On Mrs. Borden's head there appeared to be blows which were beveled in both ways; taking the injuries on Mrs. Borden's head altogether, he thought they had all been given in one direction, from right to left. The assailant of Mrs. Borden must have been more or less spattered with blood in front, although some of the blood might have gone in the air and come down behind, and that the face and hair might reasonably have received some blood spatters.
On conclusion of Dr. Draper's testimony the court adjourned at 5 o'clock.
If the Commonwealth of Massachusetts, which the crier of the court here calls upon the Almighty to save at the opening and closing of the session each day, does not present any stronger evidence as to why Lizzie Borden should be convicted of having hastened her stepmother and father to death, she will never be convicted of the awful crime of which she stands charged in the indictment. That fact has become so apparent that some of the lawyers (one of them came all the way from Georgia to attend the trial) who have been present from the first have gone home, thoroughly convinced that the jury will acquit the young woman now on trial for her life.
What the prosecution can have in reserve with which to convince the jury of the guilt of Miss Borden, if it has anything at all, is a subject of speculation. The evidence taken at the inquest, which furnished the prosecution with wedges which could have been used to advantage when she went on the stand, having been excluded, the prosecution will have to get along with it as best it may.
At the ninth day of the Borden trial, Dr. Dolan and Dr. Wood testified about the nature and timing of the fatal wounds using a mannequin head, while also addressing forensic evidence from the hatchets, clothing, and stomach contents. Dr. Dolan revised his earlier inquest testimony about which victim died first, and experts found no definitive blood evidence linking any specific weapon to the murders.
The Evening Herald · 14 June 1893 · page 2
SKULLS PRODUCED IN COURT
When tlie session was resumed, Dr. Do Ian admitted testifying in preliminary hearing that Mrs. Borden's dentil was an hour to an hour and a half Ijeforo Ills ex amination of licr, but now thought It was an hour to nn hour and n half before Mr.
The trial of Lizzie Borden for the murder of her father and stepmother has been occupying the Court at New Bedford for the past week, with at least three more weeks of testimony expected. The report claims all evidence submitted so far has favored the defendant.
The Somerset Herald · 14 June 1893 · page 2
The trial of Lizzie Borden for the murder of ber father and stepmother bas been oc cupying tbe attention of tbe Court at New Bedford, Mas., tbe past week. It will take
Harvard's Professor E.S. Wood testified that chemical tests on the victims' stomachs and milk samples showed no traces of poison. He also found no conclusive blood evidence on Lizzie's clothing, shoes, or the axes and hatchet, and a hair found on one hatchet proved to be from an animal, not human.
Pawtucket Tribune · 14 June 1893 · page 1
EXPERTS TESTIMONY In the Borden Case in Favor of the Defense
NEW BEDFORD, sy, June 14, --Lizzie Borden wis out of the room all yesterdae afternoon, aone of the skulls was con stantly before the jury, Wuouen she eame
Professor Edward Wood testified about finding no blood on Lizzie Borden's clothing except a tiny spot on her skirt, and that a hair on one hatchet was animal, not human. Medical examiners Draper and Cheever gave technical testimony on the skull wounds, agreeing a woman could have committed the murders.
Pawtucket Tribune · 14 June 1893 · page 1
LIZZIE'S MIND RELIEVED.
timony was along the same line as that of Dr. Draper. Upon being cross-ex mined he said that, in his opiuion, the assailant was taller than Mrs. Borden, Both ad mitted that a woman of average strength could have committed b oth murders with hatchets such as those shown, Professor Edward 8. Wood, the expert, is not a man who would be picked out us u physiolo zical el mist. He has a red face and might be taken for a policeman il he did not wear a white tie. When he be an to talk bis replies came with admirable directuess, Mss Borden
This report describes trial proceedings including expert testimony about a hatchet that showed no blood traces and debate over whether the murderer would have been bloodstained. It also notes the prisoner's absence from court, Andrew Borden's skull being displayed, and speculation among supporters about an acquittal celebration.
Pawtucket Tribune · 14 June 1893 · page 1
Absent From the Courtroom. It is doubtful if the prisoner was in the courtroom two hours all day. Even the production of Andrew Borden’s skull in the afternoon failed to arouse the languor, although it was placed on a high pile of books in a way that would ordinarily have eaused women to shudder, A chief effort of the defense was to have the experts b ing out the fact that the murderer must have been profusely spat tered in committing the crime, e-pecially the upper balf of the body, and in this they were partially successful. There not being enough hatchets in stock, A new one was brought into court, and the lawyer<’ enclosure would now pass for a hardware store.
A barber in Newark, New Jersey claims a disguised, opium-using stranger confessed in writing to murdering Mrs. Borden before vanishing. Police are skeptical and unsure what to make of the story.
The Providence News · 14 June 1893 · page 2
A STARTLING CLAILM A MAN AT NEWARK, N. J.,, SAYS HE KILLED THE BORDENS, The Story Told by a Barber Who Shaved the Self-Accused Murderer—The Po
Miss Gifford testifies that Lizzie refused to call Mrs. Borden 'mother' and said the family had as little to do with her as possible. Prosecutor Moody seeks to introduce testimony from Hannah Borden about a conversation suggesting hostility between Lizzie and her stepmother, which the defense argues is too remote to be admissible.
The Providence News · 14 June 1893 · page 2
TRIAL HASTENS ON
Hannah Borden. Miss Hannah H, Borden was called. Miss Dorden is the most intimate friend of Lizzie. She bad had a conversation with Lizzie on the return of both from a summer trip abroad in 1500. Mr. Robin sou took exception to the evideuce as be 1L LOO remote. I'he jury were asked to retire and the question was argued before the judges M. Moody said that heintendel to show by this couversation a fixed hostile feel
This report covers courtroom testimony from several witnesses, including Lucy Collette, who revised her timeline of when she began watching the Borden yard for anyone fleeing over the back fence. Other witnesses like Thomas Bowles, Patrick McGowan, and Aruba Kirby testified about not seeing anyone pass through nearby yards or lanes that morning.
The Providence News · 14 June 1893 · page 2
Lucy Collette's Testimony. Luey Collette next testified. She first thought she went vo Dr. Chagnouns house at 1115 o’clock, but she afterward cor rected hersell and decided that she went there about 10:45 o’cleck. % Inasmmuch as the prosecution had called ler to prove that no one had escaped from the Borden yard over the back lence, the time was important, She was sitting on the piazza of the
This miscellany column criticizes newspapers for publishing ghastly illustrations of skull wounds in Borden trial coverage, calling it disgusting sensationalism. It also opines that trial testimony is strengthening public doubt in the prosecution's case and increasing sympathy for Lizzie Borden, comparing her ordeal to New England's witch-craft persecutions.
The Providence News · 14 June 1893 · page 4
~ .BoME of the newspapers seem to be ' doing their best to disgust the public " with the Borden trial. The ghastly ¢ pictures of cloven skulls are enough to -make decent people forswear papers - that make a specialty of illustrating { very disgusting thing they are called _ mpon to chronicle. . TuE points brought out in the Borden - trial continue to strengthen the public b in the weakness of the prosecu tion's case, as well as to augment the - public’s sympathy for the young woman - whois being subjected to the most terri " ble ordeal any woman has been called . upon to pass through in New England . #ince the days of witch-craft,persecutions M would be an act of manifest justice
The Massachusetts Supreme Court ruled to exclude testimony Lizzie Borden gave at the inquest, given when her arrest had been deferred to compel her testimony. The editorial praises this decision as a check on coercive prosecutorial tactics against suspects.
The Providence News · 14 June 1893 · page 4
Tur decision of the Massachusetts supreme court to exclude the testimony of Miss Borden given at the inquest when her arrest was only deferred to force her to testify will have a very salutary effect npon the method of handling suspected persons by prose enting officers. The News has referred to the inguisition methods allowed by courts and the growing lack of fairness toward prisoners, Perhaps this decis ion of the Massachusetts court will tend to inspire officials that it is necessary to show that gceused persons are guilty rather than that they cannot conclu sively prove their innocence,
A column of miscellaneous editorial one-liners touches briefly on the Borden case, stating that the 'inoffensive cow' repeatedly mentioned by a Globe columnist has no connection to the Borden case. The rest of the item covers unrelated political and social quips of the day.
The Providence News · 14 June 1893 · page 4
RIGHT TO THE POINT.
The public is hereby apprised ot the fact that the inoftensive cow continually men tioned by Joe Howard in the Globe has no connection with the Borden case.
At the Lizzie Borden trial, Dr. E. S. Wood of Harvard testified that no poison was found in the Bordens' stomachs and that no blood was found except a small human blood spot on a skirt, possibly from an outside source. Dr. Draper testified that skull wounds measured three and a half inches, matching the length of the handleless hatchet.
The Salt Lake Herald · 14 June 1893 · page 1
ANOTHER BORDEN STORT A Newark Barber Has a Letter Wherein the Murder Is Confessed NEWARK N J June 13 Another Borden story was evolved here today when a local barber told a story to the effect that last fall a large man with a heavy black beard came into his shop got a clean shave and close hair cut bor rowed some writing paper and wrote three or four letters two of which he threw on the floor as unsatisfactory One of these the barber picked up after the man was gone and found that it was addressed to Mayor Coughlin of Fall River and stated that the writer had murdered Mrs Borden ont of revenge The barber did not explain why ho kept this quiet so long The police think the mysterious man was a crank
A dispatch from New Bedford reports that medical experts testified about the death wounds of Andrew and Abby Borden, displaying their skulls and fitting weapons into the wound patterns. Lizzie Borden wept and left the courtroom, a juror became ill, and some lawyers predicted she would be acquitted given the weak evidence presented.
Alexandria Gazette · 14 June 1893 · page 2
Tin: BoRDEN Cask.?A dispatch from New Bedford. Mass.. says : "If the com? monwealth of Massachusetts does not present any stronger evidence as to why Lizzie Borden should he convicted of having hastened her stepmother and father to death, she will never be con? victed of the awful crime of which she stands charged in the indictment. That fact has become so apparent that some of the lawyers who have been present from the first have gone home, thor? oughly convinced that the jury will acquit the young woman now on trial i for her life.
See moreSee less
Yesterday was the most grewsome day of the trial. All wit ! nesses were doctors, and all the testi? mony related to the death wounds of the old couple, whose skulls were ex? hibited, and the supposed weapons were fitted into the chinks left by the murderer. Miss Borden wept and re?
At the New Bedford trial, Mayor Coughlin corroborated the marshal's account of a conversation with the defendant, while a dressmaker testified Lizzie called Mrs. Borden 'mean, hateful' and said she hated her. A police matron also recounted a tense exchange between Lizzie and her sister Emma at the station house.
Alexandria Gazette · 14 June 1893 · page 2
TO-DAY'S TELEGRAPHIC NEWS Thf Borden Trial. , New Bedford, June 14.?In the Barden murder trial to-day Mayor John \Y. Coughlin, of Fall River, was next called. He described ihe vi>it to the Borden house with Marshal Milliard and corroborated the marshal's testi? mony as to the conversation with the defendant. The court excluded the evidence as to the demonstration against Mr. Morse, olieied by the gov? ernment to show that the police later surrounded the house in good faith for protection and not for surveillance. Mrs. Gilford, a dressmaker, eesliCed to-day against the defendant.
See moreSee less
The prisoner told her that Mrs. Korden was :i mean, hateful, old thing, that she hated her. and never ate with li> rwben she could help it. The prisoner's color rose as the testimony was given. Mrs. Reagan, matron, of the Fall River police station, testified to an exj cited conversation at the station house ! August 4 between the prisoner and her sister Emma in which the prisoner said: "Youhave given me away, Em? ma, and I will let you see I wont give in one inch." They parted wihout speaking.
A newspaper opinion piece remarks that women of New Bedford are turning against Lizzie Borden even though no evidence has yet convicted her of murdering her father and stepmother. The writer uses this to moralize about women's lack of sympathy for their own sex in trouble.
The Times · 14 June 1893 · page 4
It is reported that the women of New Bedford are all down on Lizzie Borden, although, as yet, nothing has been found to convict her of the murder of her father and step-mother. This proves the old saying that when a woman {is in trouble none offer her less sympathy than her own sex. How different would be the conduct of the New Bedford women if the accused were a negro man. Then not only sym pathy but even affection would not be wanting. | Jt Is rencrted that W. 8. Gilbert, the composer of comic opera, says that scarf has no word to rhyme with it. If Mr. Gil bert lived in Virgiaia ne would have no difficulty in using laugh as a proper rhyme for it.
The Seattle Post-Intelligencer · Seattle, Wash. Terr. Wash.
A New Jersey barber claimed a bearded stranger wrote a confession letter to Fall River's mayor last fall, though police suspect a crank. Meanwhile at the actual trial, medical experts Dr. Wood and Dr. Draper testified about the absence of poison, minimal blood evidence, and that wound dimensions matched the handleless hatchet.
The Seattle Post-Intelligencer · 14 June 1893 · page 3
THE BORDEN MURDER CASE
A New Jersey Barber's Qaoer Story— Exports Testify at Xrial. NEWARK. N. J., Jane 13.—Another Bor den story wss evolved today when a local barber told a story to the effect that last fall a large man with a heavy bta;k beard came into his ahop, got a clean shave and close hair cut, borrowed soma writing paper and wrote three or four letters. two of which be threw on the door as unsatisfactory. One of these the barber picked up after tbe man bad gone out and found it was addressed to Msyor Coughlin, of Fall River, snd atated that the writer had mur dered Mrs.
See moreSee less
Borden out of revenge. The barber did not explain why he kept this quiet ao long. The police think the mya terious man was a crank. New BxDrosp. Mass., June IX— On the resumption of the Lizzie Borden trial this morning the cross-examination of Dr. Dolan was continued, but nothing of spe cial interest was oroueht out and he gave way to Dr. E. S. Wood, of the Har vard Medical college. He testified that there was no evidence in the stom achs of Mr. and Mrs. Borden that they had been poisoned. He found no blood on anything connected with the case, either on instruments or clothing, except a small spot of blood on a white skirt, which was human blood, and prob ably came from the outside, but the handle less hatcaet might have been cleaned. Dr. Draper also testified as an expert, touching the wounds?the condition of the stomachs and tbe blood, and declared from an examination of the skulla that the instrument which had produced the wounds was three and a half inches long, the exact length of the handleless hatchet. The testimony of the day closed with an examination by the surgical expert Dr. t'heever.
The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · Wheeling, W. Va.
The piece argues that Massachusetts authorities never had sufficient grounds to arrest Lizzie Borden for the murders of her father and stepmother. It predicts her imminent acquittal and asks what reparation the state owes her after a year's imprisonment awaiting trial.
The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · 14 June 1893 · page 4
The itnproaeion ia growing on tho ublic mind that the authorities of lassachuaetts never had any grounds >r arresting Lizzie Borden for the murer of her father and stepmother, or, il i\av had, they huve failed thus far to
At the New Bedford trial, Dr. Dolan continued cross-examination describing the bodies' wounds, blood spots, and revised his estimate of the time gap between the two deaths. Prof. Edward Wood of Harvard then testified about stomach contents and the hatchet blade, finding no evidence of poison.
Wheeling Register · 14 June 1893 · page 2
Story From N'ewar*. New Bedford, Mass., June 13.— Again a great crowd thronged the court room where Lizzie Borden is being tried for murder. Mr. Adams continued the cross-exam ination of Dr. Dolan, who described the position of the bodies and the blood spots, and said the blows came from left to right and wore of moderate force. The prisoner sal with closed eyes and a fan over her face. Continuing, Dr. Do lan said the wounds were made by a sharp instrument and some were made by an assailant astride the body.
See moreSee less
A juryman was taken sick and a recess was taken. The prisoner was affected by the gruesome exhibits and details and was led front the room. The session being resumed, Dr. Dolau admitted testifying in prliminary bearing that Mrs. Borden’s death was an hour to an hour aud a half before his examination of her, but be now thought it was an hour to an hour and a half before Mr. Borden’s death. lie
Medical experts testified that no blood was found on the hatchet, ax, or blue dress, though a blood spot on the white skirt was identified as human. Dr. Draper and Dr. Cheever gave detailed testimony about the skull wounds, concluding the handleless hatchet matched the wound dimensions and could have produced all the injuries.
Wheeling Register · 14 June 1893 · page 2
THE BORDEN MURDER CASE
Mrs. Borden was made by a person facing her, and on cross-examination that blood would naturally fall on the assailant. There was a striking and dramatic Illustration a llttlo later when Mr. Adams asked him to illustrato just how tho blow would have to be struck in order to produce the cut found In the skull of Mr. Borden, Mr. Adams stood before tho witness who is tall, spare, and very deliberate in all his movements. A new hatchet was held aloft for a second Inclined to the left and then flashed through the air, straight as It seemed with tho skull of Mr.
See moreSee less
Adams. When ft seemed as If the crash of bone must be heard the hatchet stopped and remained steady. The spectators gasped. A few minutes later tho court ad journed.
A barber claims a strange bearded man asked him to shave off his hair and beard last fall, then wrote and rewrote several letters before leaving, including one addressed to the mayor confessing to murdering Mrs. Borden out of revenge. Police are uncertain what to make of the story, suggesting the letter-writer may have been a crank.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
Wheeling Register · 14 June 1893 · page 2
HE MAY BE THE MURDERER
Newark, N. J., Juno 13.—\Vm. H. Devere, who keeps a barber shop here, has added his contribution to the many stories about the Borden murder. The story as told to the police is as follows: “One afternoon last fall—I do not recollect the precise date—a man en tered my shop. Ho was about five feet six inches tall, aud weighed about 150 pounds. He wore a heavy black beard and mustache. His hair was black; he was about 45 years of age. His clothes were neat aud tidy. He wore a brown derby hat aud no cpat.
See moreSee less
He said he wanted me to shave eff his hair, beard and mustache. I did so. “While I was shaving the man he asked me if I would take a chew of opiumI refused. When I finish ed shaving the man he asked for some writing paper. lie wrote three letters and they did not seem to suit him, so he re-wrote them. He wrote a fine hand and appeared to be trying to dis guise Ills handwriting. Ho acted so strangely that I felt alarmed. “Before the man went away he look ed at himself in the glass and said to me, ‘You would not know me would you?’ “I told him ‘no, I would not.’ I noticed two sheets of paper on tbe floor that he had left behind. They were spoiled sheets that he had re written. One of them was addressed to Mayor Coughliu, of Fall River. It read: “ *1 murdered Mrs. Borden. I did it out of revenge. It is of no use trying to catch me, because I am so disguised you would not know me.” ’ The police dou't kuuw what to make of It. It Is possible the man who wrote thu ieliars was a crank. A Pretty Wedding at Martlnsburg. Specie l 'Iwltgram to thi RiOi*’*? Martixsburg, W. Ya. June 18.—A very pretty wedding wa9 solemnized in tbe Presbyterian Church in this city to-day at 11 a. * m. The contracting partes were Mis9 Mamie Spillman and Mr. Geo. W. Poke. Miss Spillman, sister of the bride, was maid of honor, and Mr. C. A. Young best man. The ushers were Messrs A. C. >,adenbuuscb, K. T. Snodgrass. Wm. and Fred Spillman. Rev. Dr. F. M. Woods performed the ceremony. The happy couple left on a tour of the Eastern cities. Splendid Condition of the State Treasury. Spicial ItUoram to thi Rtoiit'r. Charleston,W.Va., June 13.—The State Treasury is in good condition. From the statement of State Treasurer Rowan to day it apoears there is to the credit of the School Fund $286,718.58: to the credit of the General School Fund 325.40 and to the credit of the State Fund #62,793.18, I making a total of $646,887.16. Oat of One Scrape into Another. Specie - Ttitgram to th« Riauitr. Columbus, O., June 13.—Gov. McKinley to-day honored the requisition of the Gov ernor of Pennsylvania for Daniel Dona hue, alias Billy Kelly, wanted in Beaver eountv. Pa., for robbery. He will be re leased from the State Prison to-morrow, J after serving a three years'sentence from Mahoning county for burglary and larceny. -♦ I
A short news brief mentions that Lizzie Borden is currently on trial for murder in Massachusetts. It notes that her friends feel confident of an acquittal based on the evidence presented so far.
Bill Barlow's Budget · 14 June 1893 · page 4
BRIEF NEWS ITEMS. The friends of Lizzie Borden, who is now on trial for murder in Massachusetts, feel quite confident of acquittal on the evidence so far submitted. Mrs. E. F. Holmes, whose husband was killed in a collision between a Northwest ern train and an electric motor in Council Bluffs, has sued the street car company for $20,000 damages. The patriotic citizens of Alton, Ills., Sunday, decorated the grave of the anti slave martyr, Owen Lovejoy. The Clevelands will propably summer Buzzard’s Bay. Mrs. Cleveland is desirous of taking Ruth there before the heated term begins in Washington. Baron A. de Sickler’s bay colt Ragotoky won the Grand Prix at Paris Sunday.
At the New Bedford trial, Dr. Dolan testified in detail about the nature of the fatal blows to Andrew Borden, describing them as left-handed, one-handed strikes of moderate force delivered from a position at the head of the sofa. The gruesome testimony visibly distressed Lizzie Borden, who wept and hid her face during the proceedings.
Paper unidentified · 15 June 1893 · page 1
LIZZIE BORDEN SICKENS.
Resuming his testimony, he said that the blows that killed Mr. Borden must have been delivered by a left handed person, as they were deliver ed from left to right. The blows were of moderate force. The blows were, in his opinion, one-handed ones, the hatchet not being held in both hands at any tune. The person who struck the blows stood at the head of the sofa, and in front of the sitting room door. The blows were of such a character that the blood spurted all over, particularly upward.
See moreSee less
The hair was cut clean and sharp as though by a very sharp instrument. During the recital of these ghastly details, Miss Borden hid her face in her handkerchief, and seemed much agitated. When she removed her handkerchief, it was seen she had been weeping. Mr. Adams gathered together all the bloody pillow shams and sheets and spread them over the laps of the jurors in the front row. Juror Hodge fainted at the sight, bnt was soon revived. A new feature brought out in the testimony of the Doctor was that the murderer struck some of the blows on Mrs. Borden astride the body. Either of the two hatchets directly in evi dence could have been used. The 2) inch cuts might have been made by a3) meh hatchet. The wit ness admitted it was a matter of specu lation about the time that passed be tween the murders. He believed Mrs. Borden was killed fully an hour and a half before Mr Borden. The bloody tale was too much for Miss Borden, and during a brief re cess she was led from the room. Prof. Wood, of Harvard College, teal died to the analysis of the stomachs of the Bordens. He found no traces of prussic acid in them. He tested the miik with the same result. Testa of the spots on the claw-headed hatch et failed to develop the presence of blood on the axes. The hair on the hatchet was probably a cow’s hair. The spot of blood on Lizzie’s skirt came from the outside. Witness said the crime was probably committed with the headless hatchet. The per son who killed the Bordens would certainly have been spattered with blood. At the conclusion of Prof. Wood's examination Dr. Cheever, surgical ex pert was called. He testified that the handlelees hatchet could make all the wouuds, that one blow on Mrs. Borden was made by a person facing her, and on cross-examination said that the blood would naturally fall on the assailant. Then came a striking and dramatic illustration when Mr. Adams asked him to illustrate just how the blow would have to bo struck iu order to produce the cut found in the skull of Mr. Borden. Mr. Adams stood be fore the witness, who is tall, spare and very deliberate in all his movements, A new hatchet was held aloft for a second, inclined to the left, and then Hashed through the air, straight, as it seemed, with the skull of Mr. Adams. When it seemed as if the crash of bone i. ust be heard, the hatchet stop ped and remained steady. The spec tators gasped. A few minutes later the court adjourned for the day.
Expert witnesses testified about the nature of the fatal blows, suggesting a left-handed assailant using one-handed strikes, with Mrs. Borden killed about 90 minutes before Mr. Borden. Lizzie Borden wept and was eventually led from the courtroom as bloody evidence was displayed to jurors.
A brief news item reports that late developments in the Borden case show evidence strongly favoring the defendant. The trial is expected to last two weeks.
The Green Forest Tribune · 15 June 1893 · page 1
Late developments in the Borden case show evidence strongly in favor of the de l'endent. The trial is calendered to last two weeks. The World’s Vegetarian Congress
This report summarizes the Lizzie Borden case as her trial proceeds in New Bedford, recounting the discovery of her father and stepmother's bodies and her account of the morning's events. It notes a photograph contradicts her claim that she removed her father's boots, since the boots were found on his feet.
The Green Forest Tribune · 15 June 1893 · page 1
THE BORDEN CASE, Brief History of a Notorious Murder Case Now Being Investigated.
Case Now Being Investigated. The trial of Lizzie Borden, who is charged with hacking her aged father and step-mother to death on August 4, 1892, was begun at New Bedford, Mass., on Monday of last week. Excepting that of Carlyle W. Harris, this case has probably excited deeper interest throughout the country than any since the famous Ward-Mitchell case at Memphis. The trial is progressing slowly and much damairing evidence to the defendent has been introduced. Briefly put, the case stands as follows: Lizzie A. Borden, daughter of Andrew Jackson Borden, a woman about 33 years old; her step-mother, Abby Dur fee Borden, and Bridget Sulivan, a ser vant, were the only member of the fam ily about the house when Mr. Borden
On the second day of the trial's second week, courtroom interest remains high with many women spectators present. Prosecutor Moody argues at length that Lizzie Borden's statements at the inquest should be admissible as evidence, even though made before her arrest.
The Russellville Democrat · 15 June 1893 · page 1
LIZZIE BORDEN. Her Life Still in the Balance and lutereftt Unabated. New Bedford, Mass , June 12. — Over one half the spectators in court this morning were women, and
The St. Johns Herald · St. Johns, Arizona Territory Ariz.
A roundup of national news items reports that the trial of Lizzie Borden, accused of murdering her father and stepmother in Fall River, began at New Bedford, Massachusetts on the 6th. No further detail is given.
The St. Johns Herald · 15 June 1893 · page 1
-The trial of Lizzie Borden, for tho murder of her father and step mother in-Fall River, began at New Bedford, Mass., on the 6th inst.
This report assesses the ongoing Borden trial, noting that the prosecution's case appears flimsy and contradictory, especially regarding the hatchet handle and dress-burning evidence. It highlights the lack of motive, the defendant's good character, and praises ex-Gov. Robinson's defense as building his reputation as a lawyer.
The Press · 15 June 1893 · page 2
No one is now looking for the convic tion of Lizzie Borden. The question "is whether th? jury will agree in her entire acquittal. The boasted net-work of tes
The Hartford Courant observes that the nation is fixated on the Borden trial, with Boston papers devoting pages daily to the case. The piece wryly contrasts this intense coverage with public indifference to other unsolved deaths, such as over twenty people killed in Washington the same week.
The Press · 15 June 1893 · page 2
Hartford Courant : The whole country is watching with interest the great Borden trial. The Boston papers give to it not columns but pages daily, and editors else where, though they chop out with blue pencil cords of immaterial details, still give to the case a daily prominence. And what is the cause of all this interest? Simply that two people have been killed and nobody knows who did it. Prav look at Washington, where more than twenty persons were killed last Friday. Nobody knows who killed them, but somebody is just as surely responsible for those' deaths as for the deaths of the two Bordens.
This report covers early days of Lizzie Borden's trial in New Bedford, noting that Bridget Sullivan's testimony was less damaging than expected and that defense counsel ex-Governor Robinson signaled an aggressive strategy. It also describes prosecutor Moody's questioning of witness Mr. Allen about a handkerchief found upstairs in the Borden house.
Connecticut Western News · 15 June 1893 · page 1
MURDER MYSTERY. The Proieeutloa's Witnesses Get Tang-led Up Lizzie Borden's Counsel Score a Point In Having the Inquest Testimony Excluded. New Bedford, Mass., June 8. Up to the time that Dr. Bowen took the stand this morning the prosecution of Lizzie Bor den had developed but little new evidence and none that was startling. ' The testi mony of Bridget Sullivan was not so dam aging to the prisoner as had been expected. The reason of the absence from court of Emma Borden, Lizzie's sister, and several other ladies, is that they are government witnesses and have been impounded.
See moreSee less
New Bedford, Mass., June 9. There ars conflicting opinions as to the value of the last testimony in the Borden trial. It is certain that the defense awoke to the ex igencies of the occasion for the first time, and ex-Governor Robinson gave the first hints of the part he intends to play in the drama now on the boards at the New Bed ford courthouse. He is going to make the most bitter fight against the common wealth he ever engaged in, and every move ment of the enemy will be met as far as possible with counter efforts of the most, brilliant nature. The careless way in which Assistant At torney Moody brought the handkerchief into the case was Interesting in itself. He seemed to be about to sit down, having finished with the witness to all appear ances. - Then he walked back to the table. Q. Mr. Allen, did you find anything while you were up stairs? A. Yes, I did.
At the Borden murder trial, witness Allen testified he found a blood-covered handkerchief near Mrs. Borden's feet, visibly shaking the defendant. Separately, conflicting police testimony about the hatchet's broken handle deepened confusion over that piece of evidence.
Connecticut Western News · 15 June 1893 · page 1
WILLIAM H. MOODY. When ex-Governor Robinson cross exam ined Allen he did not ask a question about the bloody handkerchief. New Bedford, Mass., June 10. When court opened this morning the question raised by the defense as to the propriety of idmitting the evidence that Lizzie Borden o;ave at the inquest was taken up. It is the first time that the point has been raised In this state, and it was a novel one to the lawyers. It was brought up yesterday when Anna M. White, the official stenog rapher of the Fall River court, testified that there had been a conversation between Mr. Knowlton and Miss Borden there.
Connecticut Western News · Salisbury, Conn. · and 1 other paper
At the New Bedford trial, a prosecution witness denied knowledge of a missing hatchet handle, contradicting earlier testimony by Mullally, causing confusion in court. The judges then ruled that Lizzie Borden's inquest testimony, given under duress, could not be used against her, and Dr. Dolan described finding the bodies and evidence including a bloody handkerchief and the claw-head hatchet.
Connecticut Western News · 15 June 1893 · page 1
Borden's testimony at the inquest, the gov ernment will feel superlatively happy. . New Bedford, Mass., June 13. It is now definitely stated that ex-Governor
The Monmouth Inquirer · Freehold, N.J. · 15 June 1893
Morning Journal and Courier · New Haven, Conn.
City Marshal Hilliard and Mayor Coughlin testified about the night Lizzie Borden was told she was suspected, with Hilliard recounting her saying she was ready to go if suspected. Dressmaker Mrs. Gifford also testified that Lizzie had called her stepmother a 'mean, hateful old thing' and said she hated her.
Morning Journal and Courier · 15 June 1893 · page 3
TRIAL OF LIZZIE BOBDEN Hannah Reagan Testifies that Lizzie Accused Her Slater of Giving; Her Away Question of Admittance of a Drug Clerk's Testimony Argued at Length. Nbw Bedford, Mass., June 14. The first witness called in the trial of Lizzie Borden this morning was City Marshal Hilliard of Fall River. He told about his visits to the Borden house, and of his care
This report covers trial testimony from Mayor Coughlin, Mrs. Gifford, and matron Hannah Reagan, among others. Reagan's account of a heated exchange between Lizzie and Emma Borden in the police station, including Lizzie's statement 'you have given me away, Emma,' caused a sensation in the courtroom.
Morning Journal and Courier · 15 June 1893 · page 3
TRIAL OF LIZZIE BORDEN
dence as to the demonstration against Mr. Morse, offered by the government to show that the police later surrounded the house in good faith for protection, not for sur veillance. Mrs. Oifford, a dressmaker, tsstiied, against the defendant's objection. The prisoner, she said, told her that Mrs. Bor den was "a mean, hateful old thing"; that she hated her, and never ate with her when she -could help it. The prisoner's oolor rose when this testimony was given. The government offered to show that the prisoner said in November, 1890, that her home was anhappy.
See moreSee less
This was excluded on the ground that It did not necessarily refer to the muraerea persons. Mrs. Kirby was oalled and testified that she was in her kitchen on the morning of the mnrder and saw no one In the Borden
A witness describes a tense exchange between Lizzie and Emma Borden, with Lizzie declaring she would not give in. Testimony then turns to a drug clerk's account of Lizzie allegedly seeking prussic acid before the murders, sparking a legal argument over admissibility.
Morning Journal and Courier · 15 June 1893 · page 3
TRIAL OF LIZZIE BORDEN
there was nothing said by either and no "good bye" was exohanged. Decided sen sation. Cross examined by Mr. Jennings: Emma remained there in that room until yon came and when you came you said to Emma: "Have you told her alii" And Kami said she had told her all she had to tell. Emma came again in the afternoon, but I can't tell just when; Mr. Buok was there I am quite cure. He came every day. Beoess until 2:15 p. m. was taken and af ter it Dr. Dolan was recalled: The plaster removed from the guest ohamber was shown him and identified.
See moreSee less
Bridget Sulli van was recalled and identified the bloody handkerchief found in the room with Mrs. Borden's body as one used by Mrs. Borden as a duster; witness said that when she
Freeland Tribune · Freeland, Pa. · and 1 other paper
A roundup of national and world news items for the week notes that testimony for the prosecution continued in the murder trial of Lizzie Borden at New Bedford, Massachusetts. The item is one line among many unrelated news briefs.
Freeland Tribune · 15 June 1893 · page 4
NEWS OF THE WEEK.
a Canadian lawyer, followed him. Friday, June 9. The funeral services of Edwin Booth were held at the Little Church Around the Comer, New York, and the remains taken to Boston for burial Testimony for the prosecution was continued in the trial of Lizzie Borden for murder at New Bedford, Mass. The loss by lire at Fargo, ND .
The Willimantic Journal · Willimantic, Conn. · 16 June 1893
Freeland Tribune · Freeland, Pa. · and 1 other paper
A roundup of national news items mentions that prosecution witnesses were cross-examined by ex-Governor Robinson during the Lizzie Borden trial at New Bedford. The item is one of many brief news notes from June 10 covering unrelated events nationwide.
Freeland Tribune · 15 June 1893 · page 4
shows u defalcation of $3,000. Saturday, June 10. Ford's theater In Washington, the scene of the assassination of Lincoln in 1865, col lapsed while nearly 400 government clerks were at work inside. Twenty-four persons were killed and nearly 50 injured Wit nesses for the prosecution were cross ex amined by ex-Governor Robinson in the trial of Lizzie Borden at New Bedford One hundred and fifty homeless
The Willimantic Journal · Willimantic, Conn. · 16 June 1893
Waterbury Evening Democrat · Waterbury, Conn.
The report covers trial proceedings in New Bedford, noting the judges admitted evidence regarding prussic acid purchase. Marshal Hilliard testified about his officers' search of the Borden house and barn on the day of the murders and afterward.
Waterbury Evening Democrat · 15 June 1893 · page 2
LIZZIE BORDEN'S TRIAL The Judges Admit the Prussic Acid Evidence. MARSHAL HILLIARD ON THE STAND
Thm government Had Some Advantage In toe Straggle of Yesterday Mr. Rea gan's Teatlmony of the Talk Between the Two Slaters In the Police Station. Nkw Bedford, Mass., June 15. Lizzie Borden came into the court room this morning shortly before 9 o'clock looking a little more worn than the baa for some time. She, however, tried to appear as unconcerned as usual aud spoke quite ani matedly with Counsel Robinson. After a short preliminary tilt between tbe oppot-lng lawyers Marshall HUliard again took the stand. "On the 4th ot August, last year, my attention was called to the trouble at the Borden house by John Cunninebam, news dealer; I sent officer George W, Allen at once to the house.
See moreSee less
I did not : notice tbe time accurately; I first went to the house about 3 o'clock; first I sent Allen, then Doherty, Mullaly, Modley, Gillon, Wilson and Fleet When I got thers I looked araund the yard and searched the barn; the side door ot the barn wai open, the door on the left was closed, but I am not positive whether the window in the west end was closed or not; I think the east window wan closed. It was extremely warm in the barn; I only looked at one or two of the rooms in the house that day. The next time I went in the house was on Saturday afternoon, after the funeral; I Looked Into the room of Mr. and Mrs. Borden, then into Miss Lizzie's room and then into Miss Emma's room; there were other officers there who were looking for anything they could find; I made no exam ination of the dresses; I went again that afternoon, and in a general way searched the house; there were other officers there; I spent my time in examining closets and the dressing cases. I took a dress away; I asked Mr. Jennings for the dress she (Miss Borden) wore that day; I was then lu Mrs. Borden's room, and he went out, returning with this dress, which had been shown; I saw Miss Borden after wards in Emma's room; when the dress waa banded to me I passed it to Dr. Dolan; I had no talk with Miss Borden while I
Marshal Hilliard describes his repeated visits to the Borden house, searching the barn and bedrooms, and collecting a dress, skirt, and lounge cover from Jennings to pass to Dr. Dolan. He also recounts a later visit with Dr. Coughlin where the family was advised to stay indoors due to crowds, and Lizzie questioned if anyone in the house was suspected.
Waterbury Evening Democrat · 15 June 1893 · page 2
Waterbury Evening Democrat · Waterbury, Conn. · and 1 other paper
Testimony describes Mayor Coughlin and Marshal Hilliard visiting the Borden house to inform Lizzie she was suspected, with Lizzie and Emma's reactions recounted. Dressmaker Hannah Gifford also testifies about Lizzie's hostile remarks regarding her stepmother Mrs. Borden.
Waterbury Evening Democrat · 15 June 1893 · page 2
tion about suspicion of her. Mayor John W. Coughlin, Fall River. was theu called. He described his visit to tbe Borden house with Marshal Hilliard and corroborated the marahal'a testimony as to the conversation with the defendant. The court excluded the evidence as to demonstration against Mr. Morse, offered by government to show that the police later surrounded the house in good faith for protection, not for surveillance. Mrs. Hannah H. Gifford, the dressmaker who has made wearing apparel (or the Bor dens for six or seven years past, in describ ing her occupation, said aht made outside ladies' garmeuts.
See moreSee less
"Miss Borden came to see me about a suit on day," she said. "While she was there I told her I was makiug a dress for Mrs. Borden, and when I spoke of Mrs. Bocden I called bar mother. " 'Don't say that, because she's a mean, good-for-nothing thing,' Lizzie said to me.
The Indianapolis Journal · Indianapolis, Ind. · 15 June 1893
The Morning Call · San Francisco, Calif.
Coverage of the Borden trial's June 14 session includes City Marshal Hilliard's account of questioning Lizzie, Mrs. Gifford's testimony about Lizzie's harsh words for her stepmother, and neighborhood witnesses who saw no one enter or leave the house. Police matron Hannah Regan also testified about overhearing a tense exchange between Lizzie and her sister Emma in the jail toilet-room.
The Morning Call · 15 June 1893 · page 2
ONE AGAINST HER
Special to The Mobxinq Call. Ne \v Bedford, Mass., June 14.— Women were In a majority at the Borden trial again ?o-day. City Marshal Hilliard of Fall River was the first witness. He described his visit to the Borden house, and his con versation with the prisoner, in which she was told she was suspected, when she told Hilliard that she was in the barn when th* murders were committed. The cross examination developed nothing new. Mrs. Gifford, a dressmaker, testified that in speaking of Mrs. Borden to Lizzie she referred to her as the latter's mother.
See moreSee less
Upon that Lizzie said: "Don't say that, because she's a mean, good-for-nothing thing, and I don't have much to do with her." Lizzie further said she stayed in her room at home, and, while eating at the same table, the family never took meals together. Anna H. Borden gave no material testi
Police matron Hannah Regan testified about overhearing a tense exchange between Lizzie and Emma Borden in jail, including Lizzie's remark 'You have given me away, Emma.' The court also ruled admissible the testimony of druggist Eli Bence regarding Lizzie's alleged attempt to buy prussic acid before the murders.
The Morning Call · 15 June 1893 · page 2
QUARREL OF THE SISTERS.
Bridget Sullivan was recalled and iden tified the blond-stained handkerchief found beside Mrs. Borden's body as a duster the latter used. -p J£li Belts, the drug clerk who was to tes tify that Lizzie tried to purchase prussic acid from him on the day befure the mur der, was next called, but an objection was raised by the defense and after considera ble argument the court retired for con sultation regarding the admission of his testimony. They returned with a decision that the evidence would be admitted. Lizzie flushed visibly, but an adjournment was immediately taken until to-morrow.
Witnesses at the New Bedford trial testified no one was seen near the Borden house the morning of the murders, and that Lizzie had said she hated her stepmother and accused her sister of betraying her while in jail. The court also ruled to admit testimony from a drug clerk about Lizzie's attempt to buy prussic acid the day before the killings.
Evening Journal · 15 June 1893 · page 4
Keck» of Fourth ChirtR Poet ma» tern. Trlncci Kulalla Leaven Chicago anti Will Go to Niagara MUa A hell Wuntn ■ * .* 0,000 for a Broken Heart. In the matter of the petition of Colonel Ainsworth with regard to his right to attend the deputy coroner's in quest into the disaster in Ford's Theatre the Supreme Court of the District of Columbia dismissed the petition. It de cided the deputy coroner could not con duct tbe inquest, and that a coroner bad discretion over persons who might |[be admitted to the bearing.
See moreSee less
A new inquest will lie lieid and be conducted by tbe coroner himself. Misa Korden Hated Her .Stepmother, Tim testimony in the murder trial of Lizzie Borden at New Bedford, Mass., was to the effect that no one was seen near or about tbe Borden house on the morning on which the murders occurred ; that Lizzie told outsiders that she hated her step mother, and that while she was in jail site bad accused her Bister of "giving her away." The prosecution also scored a point in that the court de cided to admit, the testimony of the drug clerk from whom Lizzie tried to buy prussic acid on the day before the murders.
The Wilmington Daily Republican · Wilmington, Del.
The New York Recorder convened a panel of eminent citizens as a volunteer jury to independently judge the evidence in the Lizzie Borden case, aiming to test whether an ordinary jury could handle such a complex capital case. The panel, including figures like Rev. Edward Everett Hale and Lucy Stone, would deliver their own verdict of 'proven' or 'not proven' for comparison with the official trial outcome.
The Wilmington Daily Republican · 15 June 1893 · page 2
Ti-.f «r .'I i, rkci Trlnl-. ^ M Tho New ^ork llocorder has iustitu ted a novel but feasible mode by which decisions of juries in capital cases aro Vu . _. «. ,, . to be tested, and tho Lizzie Borden ease has bee lectod os tho test case. Actuated it says, by tho desire to sup ply a good answer to the widely de bated «luestlon, "Is tho average jury drawn to try a capital caso equal to tfee task?" it has aecured tho co-op «•atlon of a special jury to give a vol nnteer verdict upon tho cam.
See moreSee less
Twelve eminent citizens have boon selected, who have consented to servo, to read. to weigh and to givo a verdict on the evidence given and to decide In two .orma, -Proven-or -Not proven. lhe special Jill y consiste ol Hev. Idwurd Everett Hale, ex Governor y Ameo, Hon. John F. Andrew. Hon.
Delaware Gazette and State Journal · Wilmington, Del.
At the trial, housemaid Bridget Sullivan described her movements and chores on the morning of the murders, including washing windows and fetching water. She testified she saw no one enter the house and did not see Lizzie during much of that time.
Delaware Gazette and State Journal · 15 June 1893 · page 2
IL Proves Rather Favorable to Lizzie Borden. THE CONDITION OF THE HOUSE ! Man Might Hate Cl opt in j and Committed the Crime. , The XVitno* Atlmitted at This Might Have Don«* Without the Intrude Koblitsou's C ■•examination. Hit lïEïmmn. M ap,.. June 7.—The «.*. « hire of ,.„|»v-»pr..ciim.- ill tho >, ! niorder trial war tli.Mfrtiioc.nv ,.f liniloei i Sullivan, the housemaid in the « niplov «»f j the Horden» at tile time of the crime and the chief Witness for tin* prosccniiou. Sin- : detailed at length thu movements at the ; •tubers of MuR d.n 1.
See moreSee less
during the morning of the duv of the ! crime. After breakfast Mrs. Burden aske.l her to wash the win.lmvs. That was about 9 o'clock. Continuing, witness said ■ "Aft»-r I receive»! tin* instructions ! went I into the kitchen, then into the dining and I •itting-rooins and shut the window- ■*«.» the ! luside shatters were open. 1 nover touched 1 them. Did not see Lizzie then. I went rood en pail, «ame up ' down cellar, got a stairs, got ater, Lizzi«- asked n vhat I was going • ' I ! ! :
Delaware Gazette and State Journal · Wilmington, Del.
This report covers courtroom testimony recounting Lizzie Borden's burning of a dress shortly after the murders, witnessed by Alice Russell and Mrs. Churchill. It also includes inquest-related testimony about police searching Lizzie's room and questioning her locked doors and movements.
Delaware Gazette and State Journal · 15 June 1893 · page 2
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
Delaware Gazette and State Journal · Wilmington, Del.
Police witnesses describe searching the Borden house after the murders, noting blood on a dressing case and pillows, and recount Officer Fleet's earlier claim about discovering the probable murder weapon. The report also covers a bank cashier's letter correcting Lizzie Borden's testimony about an account balance.
Delaware Gazette and State Journal · 15 June 1893 · page 2
The court, adjourned until to-morrow. Fai.l litv kr, M«.**.. June 8.—To-night's sensation in this city is Assistant Marshal Fleet's story regarding the axe fourni the Horden house, supposed to have been used in the Borden murders. For many d weeks stories about the hatchet and uxes been published, but during all ti»«- j I months that have passed lie has scrupulously kept the secret that the pr» as fourni the day the I able weapon famous butcheries .. ies were discovered. His description of the weapon was : Ute. las reputation f oruhlo donling lu well km . RIVKR. ) i j I His | , .-o veracity and | »I private I here, tin !
This report offers background on Andrew Borden's frugal household and his daughter Lizzie, describing her as unremarkable in appearance and manner. It recounts how she alerted neighbors to find her father and stepmother hacked to death in their locked home, with no signs of robbery or forced entry.
The National Tribune · 15 June 1893 · page 4
THE LIZZIE BORDEN CASE
talions on the North Atlantic Squadron. gold. house. The amazed people found her step mother dead in ono room, having been killed by repeated blows by a hatchet or ax, and her father similarly slain in auother. There was no sign of robbery, everything about the house being undisturbed; there was no in dication thata strolling criminal had made liis way into the house, and no motive appeared for committing the deed. All the doors of the house were carefully fastened, for it was the motto of tho Borden house hold: "Safe hind, safe find."
See moreSee less
An outsider could not have entered the house in any way without attracting the attention of Lizzie Borden or the servant girl, who were the other inmates besidea the murdered people. In fact, an nncle of Lizzie, who was visiting the family at the time, returned to the house shortly after the tragedy, and could not get in until he was admitted. The servant girl was not suspected of tho crime, and the State authorities finally decided that Lizzie was the guilty one, and have put her on trial. The points against her are that the murder was committed, and all the presumptions are that it must have been done by some one in the house. A strong attempt has been made to show that she and her stepmother were on very bad terms, and the theory is that the
The article reviews the case against Lizzie Borden, noting that no outsider could have entered the house unnoticed and that authorities settled on her as the suspect now on trial. It also raises doubts about the prosecution's theory, pointing to her previously unremarkable character, lack of evident outbursts with her stepmother, the implausibility of the timeline, and the absence of definitive physical evidence.
The National Tribune · 15 June 1893 · page 4
talions on the North Atlantic Squadron. gold. and these so -wrought upon a solitary, self ish, shnt-in nature, that she formed the resolution to kill both her father and aiep mother. Against this must be said that there has been nothing in Lizzie Borden's previous life that would suggest a deed of infinitely less desperation than the one of which she is accused. There is no testimony that there
This compiles reactions from several newspapers (Boston Post, Providence Journal, Utica Herald, Springfield Union, Albany Journal) arguing that the prosecution's case against Lizzie Borden is weak and falling apart. They cite the exclusion of her inquest testimony and the thinness of physical evidence, such as a single pinhead-sized bloodstain.
New-York Tribune · 15 June 1893 · page 7
———— AP — THE CASE AGAINST MISS BORDEN. THE PROSECUTION WEAKENING, I'rom Th» Boston Post, It Is very evident to any clear headed observer that the ease of the prosecution In the Dorden trial
Newspapers report that the exclusion of Lizzie Borden's inquest testimony removes the prosecution's best chance of convicting her. Editorials argue the evidence is insufficient for a jury to convict, suggesting officials themselves seem to be on trial.
New-York Tribune · 15 June 1893 · page 7
SATISFA{TORY EVIDENCE YIOT. hot 8 From The Philadelphia inguiver, Idzzhe Borden may he gulity, Lat so fur there has been no evidences npon which no Jury conld convied conselentionsiy, Every one of those Jurvimen may believe that the young woman killed her father and stepmother, but hellef is not cvldence, and of evidence the proseentlon fs sadly heling
A Tribune correspondent reports the ninth day of Lizzie Borden's trial consisted of fragmented testimony interrupted by lengthy legal arguments over admissibility, preventing the prosecution from closing as planned. The report notes Borden appeared pale and ill but attentive, visibly distressed by evidence like bloody carpets and skulls, though these had been removed from view.
New-York Tribune · 15 June 1893 · page 1
THE STATE'S CASE CLOSING. POINTS AGAINST MISS BORDEN
A POLICE MATRON'S STORY. (FROM A STAFF CORRESPONDENT OF TIE TRIBUNE.) New-Bedford, Mass.,, June 14.—The ninth 44p of Lizzie Borden's trial has ended. The proceeds ings have consisted of scraps and pieces, the fage ends of the prosecution's case. The giving of the testimony was interrupted twice by long argue ments from the lawyers on tho iimissibility of certain portions of it. These arguments occupied fo much time that the prosecution did not finish. Mr. Knowlton and Mr. Moody had stated tha$ they expected to elose to-day. Undoubtedly they would have succeeded in doing so if the rate at which testimony has hitherto been given had becn maintained.
See moreSee less
Whatever they may now bring forward, it is pretty safe to say that the hour of surprises and startling new developments has passed, It is most unlikely that anything will now be brought forward the material facts of which are not already known. MISS BORDEN'S APT SUGGESTIONS.
The report describes Lizzie Borden's alert courtroom behavior and sharp suggestions to her counsel during cross-examination. It also summarizes Marshal Hilliard's testimony about her anxious questions and the fruitless police searches of the Borden house after the murders.
New-York Tribune · 15 June 1893 · page 1
MORE. VAGUE AND INCONCLUSIVE TESTIMONY. A dozen witnesses took the stand to-day. Each had among many words one little point to make, and, like all the rest of the State's evidence, it was significant, but vague and inconclusive, It may have meant something, but it did not need to. There is, in fact, nothing that has been told of her conduct whieh might not be true and yet leave her guiltless of the crime she is charged with. Its force is derived solely from the circumstances that there seems to be no other way in accounting for the deaths of Mr.
See moreSee less
and Mrs. Borden unless they came by the hand of Lizzie. Marshal Hilliard, who is at the head of the Fall River police force, told of his visit to the Borden house after the killing, and of the things
The report describes testimony from Fall River's Mayor and Marshal about Lizzie Borden's composed reaction upon learning she was a suspect, followed by the court's exclusion of testimony about remarks she allegedly made regarding her stepmother. It also covers witnesses who saw no one entering or leaving the Borden property around the time of the murders.
New-York Tribune · 15 June 1893 · page 1
MORE EVIDENCE FOR THE STATE EXCLUDED. Then a woman was put on the stand who had been a eloakmaker for the Borden family during a series of years, Her point was that some timo in March of last year she had had a talk with the prisoner, who said that her stepmother was a wean old thing,” with whom she did not have much to do. The prosecution undertook to follow up this line of evidence hy the testimony of a wite ness who had been Lizzie's companion in 1890 on a trip abroad, and who was prepared to say that witile they were on the returning steamer Lizzie anid she was sorry to be coming back, because she was returning to such an unhappy home. It ap-
This is a general news summary page listing items from around the world, including a brief mention that the Borden murder trial continued at New Bedford with prosecution evidence ongoing. Other items include foreign affairs, domestic news, sports results, and weather.
New-York Tribune · 15 June 1893 · page 6
THE NEWS THIS MORNING
——— The Borden murder trial went on at NewBedford, evidence for the prosecution being continned, Ex-President Harrison was among co =3 the visitors at the World's Fair. == Chief Jus-
This piece analyzes the prosecution's claimed motive for Lizzie Borden killing her parents, noting that while an unhappy home life and property disputes with her stepmother were alleged, no clear motive was established for killing her father. The writer argues that if the stepmother was removed, the father's death would naturally benefit both daughters equally, making a premeditated motive to kill him harder to explain.
New-York Tribune · 15 June 1893 · page 6
4 STUDY OF MOTIVE. One of the many inexplicable things which the prosecution in the Borden cise has failed to unravel is the prisoner's motive for killing
This op-ed argues the state failed to establish a credible motive for Lizzie Borden to kill her father, since her stepmother's death had already removed the main source of family discord. It contends the second murder actually increased her danger and difficulty rather than protecting her, making the prosecution's theory unconvincing.
New-York Tribune · 15 June 1893 · page 6
A STUDY OF MOTIVE
Borden se. While something vaguely regembling a mative can he supplied for the commission of the first crime, the second murder is absolutely inexplicable on the theory of the state. Phe slaughter of the helpless old man was not required for the protection of the murderer. It igercased immeasurably the murderet’s difficulty and danger. As a crime committed by Lizzie Borden it is utterly wnintelligible.
Lawyers argued whether testimony that Lizzie Borden tried to buy prussic acid the night before the murders should be admitted as evidence of murderous intent. The court, split 2-1, ruled to admit it for the limited purpose the prosecution specified, despite defense objections that no irritant was found in the victims' stomachs.
New-York Tribune · 15 June 1893 · page 2
THE ALLEGED ATTEMPT TO BUY POISON. The session ended with a long discussion by counsel of the admissibility of the testimony of the drug clerk by whom the State proposes to prove that the poisoner ‘on the evening of August 3, the night before the murders, attempted to buy some prussic acid. The State's claim is that this attempt tends to prove the existence in her mind of a murderous purpose; that it goea to show that she meant harm to somebody. The defence replies that, even if it does, there js no proof that it meant harm to Mr.
See moreSee less
and Mrs. Borden. If it meant harm to anybody else, it is certainly not admissible; and the evidence of Professor Wood that the stomachs of the murdered people were absolutely free from the presence of an irritant takes from the proseeution all chance of showing that any suco
The report describes a courtroom dispute over admitting controversial testimony, with judges divided and the jury carefully shielded from the issue until resolved. It then transitions into a detailed review of the Commonwealth's evidence against Lizzie Borden as her trial nears its midpoint, summarizing her background and the prosecution's theory of events.
New-York Tribune · 15 June 1893 · page 2
WHAT THE PROSECUTION HAS TRIED TO PROVE THAT LIZZIE BORDEN DID ON AUGUST 4, 1892
THAT LIZZIE BORDEN DID ON AUGUST 4, 1802, New-Bedford, Mass, June 14.—It Is no easy task within reasonable Iimits of space to give a correct flea of the cose against Lizzie Borden. This is a fair point at which to review it, for the Commonwealth's evidence is practically in. Barring the unexpected, the record contains the complete story of the Borden tragedy as the Listrict-Attorney understands it. The reason y it is so difiicult a case 10 review in a few connected sentences is that fit consists of so many hundred loose, vague, shapeless facts, to ap preciate the Learing of which it is aJmost necessary to see the witness who narrates them; to underst nl what he is and what are his relations to the affair, and to note the manner lu which he tells Lis story and the degree and character of the resistance Le offers to the cross-examination of the defence.
See moreSee less
All is, to be sure, in some measure applies to every account of a grest trial; but it applies here in all that especial measure due to the circumstances that have lent to the case of Lizzie Borden so wonderful an interest. It is almost incredible, nest to impossible, that she should be guilty; and yet, timid as an honest man must be about prououncing her gullty, Le is uitely perplexed to find the grounds on which Le can declare himsell satistied of her innocence. As told by the prosecution, and as quallfied by the admissions and explenations of its wit nesses on cross-exmmination, the facts of the case seem to be these:
This report summarizes prosecution evidence presented at trial regarding Lizzie Borden's life and family dynamics, noting some tension between her and her stepmother Mrs. Borden. It cites witness testimony from Bridget Sullivan describing apparently friendly relations, contrasted with Lizzie's own statement to police distancing herself from her stepmother.
New-York Tribune · 15 June 1893 · page 2
HER LFIE AND FAMILY RELATIONS. Lizzie Borden, thirty-thres years old, well-educated, well brouzht up, Laving Uved a useful and refined fife, acuve in tae practical relief work of a Christian Chu~¢h, whs, until the morning of Augnst 4, 1802, by ail wha know her, regarded as a good woman. Mer father, worth about $30),00), was seven'ly years old. His wite was her stepmother, bat had been married to her father for twenty-seven years, During all that time Lizzie, her older sister Emma, and Mr. and Mrs. Borden lad lived together day and
During the Borden murder trial in New Bedford, defense attorney Jennings cross-examines the station house matron about visits from Emma Borden and others on the day Lizzie was upset. The matron recalls Lizzie was more excited after her visitors left, and discusses a reported quarrel between the sisters that she confirmed to a reporter as true.
Evening Star · 15 June 1893 · page 8
POISON EMTZDNCZ ADMIItaD. The Freseuttss Owlne a Pwat in the mee den ese. The trial of i3zs Borden at New Bedford for the murder of her father was resumed at
During Lizzie Borden's murder trial, witnesses testified about a blood-spotted piece of plaster and a bloodied handkerchief found near Mrs. Borden's body, as well as a locked screen door. A drug clerk's testimony about Lizzie allegedly trying to buy prussic acid the day before the murders was then challenged by the defense as inadmissible.
Evening Star · 15 June 1893 · page 8
TED 3L00D-PoTTED PLAsT. Dr. Dolan was recalled and testilled to a blood-spotted elece of plaster taken from the wall in the rem where Mrs. Borden was found. Bridget Sullivan was recalled and identilled the bloodt handkerehlef found near the body of Mrs. Borden as one used as a dusting cloth. The witness msad that when she went out to wash the windows she found the screen door locked, and she left it unlocked after her.
The report describes courtroom arguments over admitting evidence that Lizzie Borden tried to buy poison before the murders, which prosecutor Moody argued showed premeditation. It also recounts an anecdote of a New York society hostess defending her old friend Lizzie Borden's character at a tea party, insisting she could not have committed the murders.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Evening Star · 15 June 1893 · page 8
LIZZIE DEFENDED BY A FRIEND.
LIUsIE DEFENDED ST A WnIEND. Miss Lizzie Borden's guilt or Innocence is discussed in every circle of society. At an afternoon tea in an elegant West End avenue mns=ion in New York the other day the ladles eaely debated the vexed question. Tehostess hestened intently to the expres sions of her guests, and after things had quieted down a bit maid: "Ladies, I have something to tell you which will doubtless sar pise you all very much-but bef ore I begin I want your opinions on a photograph which I have hers."
See moreSee less
The picture, that of a sweet-faced young woman, was shown, and all agreed that the person whom it represented must be lovely. Ruch a sweet expression, such lovely eyes, and so modest, sucn were the different oinions given. "lNone of you see anything vicious or wicked in that face, do you?" asked the hostess "Oh, no," was the general answer. "Well," continued the hostess, "that is a photograph of Lissie Borden, whose supposed crime you have been canvassing. She gave it to me about six years ago. "Lizzie Borden is one of my beat friends. I was born and brought up in the same town with her. I have known her intimately for twenty-five years, and I tell you It is Impossible that she could ever have committed the awful crime for which she is being tried for her life. I wish It were possible for mbe to tell you what an awful shock It was to me the morning I took up the per and read that Lizzie Borden, my old sceolmte and friend, was suspected of having killed her father and mother. "I cannot understand how such a mistaken impression regarding the character of Lizsie Borden has gotten possssin of people. Instead of the oarse, stolid ceature she Is represented, she is a reined, cultured woman. Strong in character, loyal to her frends, kind hearted and charitable, capable of great self-restraint and repression. It is not true that her father was mean and parsimonious. He was a typical New Englander. frugal In all his ways, and no POISON EMTZDNCZ ADMIItaD. The Freseuttss Owlne a Pwat in the mee den ese. The trial of i3zs Borden at New Bedford for the murder of her father was resumed at 2:15 pm. with Station House Matron peagan under eroe-szamanation by Mr. Jennings. Mr. Jennings asked with reference to Emma Bor den's visit to her siser sftr .the latter's ar rest: "Did Miss Emma come again in the after noon?" "I think she did." "Can you tell as what tine?" "No, sir; I canet." "Was there anybody else there in th after noon excepting Mr. Back?" "I do not remember." "Was Mrs. Holmes there that afternoon?" "I do not remember." "Is there anything in connection with the day that you do remember excepting this trouble?" . street northwest. "No, r; exepting that Mins Lizzie was more excited after her visitors left than before they "ame." e asked her about some afternoon when Mrs. Bohmes. Mrs. Brighton and Miss Emma were in the matron's room, when they tried some experiments with an egg, but she said that it was not the afternoon of the trouble. Mr. Jennings then asked: "Did you not say that there was a quarrel between the sisters?' ag Star. "Yes. I called it that." JOHN J. WILMARTH. '"What day of the weak was it on?" "I don't know." Was not the story of the guarrel published in the next morning's papers?' "I don't know; I did not see it." "Were on asked about it by reporters?' "I was. "Did you tell them about it?" "I told one reporter that it was true." "Did You ever tell any reporter that it was not true?" "I never did, sir." "Did Mr. Back ask you about It in the court room?' "Mr. Back did not ask me about it in the court room." "Did von ever tell him that It was not true?" "I did not." "Did Mr. Buck bring you a paper which he wished you to sign?" "Was not it a denial that any quarrel had taken place between Lizzie and Emm.W" "I do not know." "Does this sound like It?" and Mr. ennings read a typewritten statement which wasa denial of the quarrel. Witness said: "It does." "Did you tell Mr. Buck that you would sign if Marshal Hilliard would let you?' "I did not, sir." "Didn't say anything of the kind?" "No, sir." STREET NORTHWEST.
At the New Bedford trial, City Marshal Hilliard and Mayor Coughlin testified about their visits to the Borden house and conversations with Lizzie after she was told she was suspected. A dressmaker testified Lizzie called her stepmother 'mean, hateful,' and several witnesses said they saw no one leave the yard the morning of the murders.
The Morning News · 15 June 1893 · page 1
LIZZIE AND HER SISTER.
A Police Matron Springs a Sensation in Coart. The Witness Testifies That She Heard tho Prisoner Accuse Her Sister Emma of GivingHer Away Other Witnesses Testify That They Saw No Man Leave the Premises on the Morning of tho Murder. Now Bedford Mass., June 14.—1n the Borden trial to-day the first witness called was City Marshal Hilliard of Fall River, who described his visits to the Borden the conversation with tlie pris oner, in which she was told that she was suspected of tho crime. The witness was cross-examined by Gov.
See moreSee less
Robinson, who attempted to show that City Marshal Hilliard was not obstructed in bis search of the premises and that his search of the rooms was thorough. City Marshal Hil liard swore that the search of the Borden house was thorough and the defendant gave him all tho arMcles ho usked for. He spoke earnestly and frankly in conversa tion about the suspicion of her. Muyor John Coughlin of Fall River de scribed Ills visit to the Borden house with Marshal Hilliard and corroborated the marshal's testimony as to his conversa tion with tho defendant. The court excluded evidence as to a demonstration against, Morse, offered by the government, to show that the police later surrounded tlie house in good faith for protection, and not for surveillance. Mrs. Gifford, a dressmaker, testified that the prisoner had told her that Mrs. Borden was a mean, hateful old thing; that she hated her, and never ate with her when sbo could help it. Tho prison er's color rose as this testimony Was given. Tho government offered to show that tho prisoner said in November. 1890, that her homo was unhappy. This was ex cluded on the ground that it did not necessarily refer to tho murdered persons. Fivo or six witnesses testified to being within sight of tho Borden yurd on till morning of the murdor and sow no person leave the yard, but on cross-examination it appeared that men might havo left tho .yard without being seen.
A matron testifies about tension between Lizzie and her sister Emma after the murders, including a disputed statement about whether they quarreled. The court also debates and ultimately admits testimony from drug clerk Eli Bence that Lizzie tried to buy prussic acid the day before the murders.
The Morning News · 15 June 1893 · page 1
THE CROSS-EXAMINATION
paper. Eli Bence, a drug clerk of Fall River, was sworn, but the defense objected to ills testimony being admitted, it was in tended to prove by lihn that Lizzie Borden tried to purchase prussic acid the day be fore the murder, saying she wanted to clean a sealskin sack; also thut the arti cle is never used for such a purpose. After a lona argument tlio Justices con sulted half an hour and then decided to admit the drug clerk’s testimony. The defense was not satisfied with the de cision and another argument followed, which lasted until court adjo timed.
The New York Tribune observes that the trial evidence suggests Lizzie Borden couldn't have committed the murders, yet no one else could have either. It expresses sympathy for the jury's difficult position in reaching a verdict.
The Morning News · 15 June 1893 · page 4
The Lizzie Borden Puzzle. From the New York Tribune (Rep.). The logic of the evidence in tho New Bed ford trial seems to be that Lizzie Borden cottldn t have done it. but nobody else could have done it. The jury ’deserve the sympa thies of every one in tho noble old common wealth.
The Pacific Commercial Advertiser · Honolulu, Hawaiian Islands
The report states that the trial of Lizzie Borden for the murder of her father and mother has begun at Fall River, Massachusetts. It notes that the evidence against her is wholly circumstantial.
The Pacific Commercial Advertiser · 15 June 1893 · page 5
The tria! of Lizzie Borden at Fall River, Mass., for the murder of her father and mother, has begun. The evidence is wholly circumstantial. Mrs. Frank Leslie has applied for a
At the Borden trial, witnesses testified about finding a blood-covered, partially burned handkerchief near Mrs. Borden's body and a handleless hatchet in the cellar with a freshly broken handle disguised with ashes. Dr. Bowen denied ever saying Mrs. Borden died of fright, and officer Fleet found no bloodstains on examined dresses.
The Oskaloosa Herald · 15 June 1893 · page 1
STAINED WITH BLOOD.
Evidence. New Bedford, Mhss., June 10.—Dr. Bowen was the first witness in the Borden trial Thursday. He stated noth ing in the direct examination except to deny that he had ever said that Mrs. Borden died of fright or in a faint. George Allen, a policeman of Fall River, was then called. On the morning of the tragedy he went up to the Bor den house. When he reached the sit ting room Mrs. Churchill and Miss Rus sell were there. So was Dr. Bowen. The sheet had not yet been placed over the body of the dead man.
See moreSee less
When he saw Lizzie Borden that morning she was cool and self possessed. Then came another surprise from the prosecution, and one that caused the heavy, dull features of the defendant to grow ashy white. It was a handker chief, dark and dirty and half de stroyed. It looked as if an attempt had been made to burn it. Allen swore that he found the handkerchief near the body of Mrs. Borden, it was cov ered with blood. Officer Fleet described his finding of a handless hatchet while searching the premises for clews. This hatchet was found on the day of the murders in the box next the chimney down cellar. A fragment of the handle showed a fresh break and the iron was covered with ashes. The manner in which the ashes or dust appeared in the cut indicated that an effort had been made to have the break appear like ?n old one. Cross-examined, Fleet said he examined a number of dresses carefully, but found no bloodstains.
During the trial, Lizzie Borden was forced to leave the courtroom due to sudden illness while District Attorney Moody argued for admitting her inquest testimony. Ex-Governor Robinson countered with a plea that her inquest statements were coerced, given without caution and amid police surveillance.
Audubon County Republican · 15 June 1893 · page 1
New Bedford, Mass.,June 14. —Dur ing District Attorney Moody's remark! on the question of the admission of the prisoner's testimony at the inquest Miss Borden was obliged to leave the court room through sudden indisposi tion. When Miss Borden came into court she looked drugged and told Gov. Robinson that she had not slept well. Mr. Moody spent three-quarters of an hour in maintaining the admissi bility of Miss Borden's evidence before
The report covers testimony from Lizzie Borden's murder trial, including City Marshal Hilliard's account of visiting the Borden home and informing the family of police suspicions, plus Police Matron Hannah Reagan's testimony about a tense exchange between Lizzie and her sister at the station. The report notes testimony caused Lizzie's face to flush and previews forthcoming evidence about a dressmaker and a prussic acid purchase story.
The Indianapolis Journal · 15 June 1893 · page 4
TRYING DAY FOR MISS BORDEN
Prussia Acid Story to Be Admitted. New Bedford, Mass.. June 14 The old courthouse where Lizzie Borden's life is in the balance was again thronged to-day,
A dressmaker recounts Lizzie Borden's hostile remarks about her stepmother, while other witnesses testify about the crime scene and a confrontation between Lizzie and her sister Emma witnessed by police matron Hannah Reagan. The matron describes Lizzie accusing Emma of 'giving her away' during a heated exchange at the police station.
The Indianapolis Journal · 15 June 1893 · page 4
THK DKESSMAKKR's 8TOKY. Mrs. Hannah II. Cliti'ord, the dressmaker who has made wearing apparel for the Bor dens for six or seven years past, took the stand nest. In describing her occupation Bbe said she made "outside ladies' gar ments." "Miss Borden came to see me about a suit one day," she said. "While she was there I told her I was making a dress for Mrs.. Borden, aud when 1 spoke of Mrs. Borden I called her mother. 'Don't say that, because she's a mean, good-for-nothing thing Lizzi e said to me.
See moreSee less
'I don't have mach to do with her,' Lizzie told me. 'At home.' she said, 'I stay iu my room I asked her if she did not eat with them. She said they ate At the same table, but that they never took their meals together if they could help it." Then Anna 11. Borden, a cousin of the prisoner, was called. A tall, gray-haired woman stepped into the court room and re moved her veil. She went to Europe with Lizzie when tbe latter went abroad in 1890. What the prosecution wanted to show by this witness was that on tbe way home to this country Lizzie remarked about the nice time they had just passed, and said she was sorry she was going home, because her home was so unpleasant for her. Tbe defense objected, and the conrt decided not to allow tbe mutter. Next came six witnesses, who were in tbe Borden neighborhood the morning of the murder, neither of whom saw any one enter or go away. The cross-examination, however, tended to show, a man might have gone ont of the Borden yard
City Marshal Hilliard testified about searching the Borden premises and recounted the moment Mayor Coughlin told Lizzie she was suspected of the murders, to which she replied she had been in the barn. The court also admitted evidence that the defendant had tried to purchase prussic acid before the killings.
The Wichita Daily Eagle · 15 June 1893 · page 1
THE BORDEN TRIAL. THE PROSECUTION SCORES A POINT DURING THE DAY.
New BEDFOnD, Mass., June 14. The old court house where Lizzie Borden's lifo hangs in the balance was again thronged today, largely by womeu, who aro per sistent in demanding ndwisiiou. City Marshal Milliard of Fall River was the first witness today, lie testified as to his search of the premises and as to con versations with tho prisoner. Tho feiituro of tho marshal's testimony was the description of the scene wheu Liuu Borden was first told that she was sus pected of the crime. Major Coughjin wis prcseut at the time, lie told tha I&mlly that they had better remain iu tho house for a few days, as there was much.
See moreSee less
excite ment ou tho streots. Ic they wore an noyed by crowds of people gathering about thu house, they should notify hiui.or tha city marshal, anil they would beprotected. Ltzziy Borden then asked why that was necessary, aud wanted to know if anybody
Trial testimony recounts the mayor telling Lizzie she was suspected, her sister Emma's remark overheard by matron Hannah Reagan, and dressmaker and cousin testimony about Lizzie's harsh comments on her stepmother. A drug clerk begins to testify that Lizzie tried to buy prussic acid before the defense objects.
The Wichita Daily Eagle · 15 June 1893 · page 1
THE PROSECUTION SCORES A POINT
testified that, she had mado dresses tor tha Bordou-. Oar day Llzxio Borden, who had come to have a dress made, told her not to cull Mrx. Borden, her mother, be cause sho was i mean, good-for-nothing thing." She also said ttiut she did uot
A newspaper's editorial column of miscellaneous short items briefly mentions that Lizzie Borden is now satisfying public morbid curiosity that had been fed by the Charley Harris execution. The rest of the passage covers unrelated topics like Kansas banks, editors' quarrels, and corn crops.
The Wichita Daily Eagle · 15 June 1893 · page 4
The ouly run on them apprehended by Kansas is fioni the safe crackers from enviioning territory; particularly from "Missouri. Lizzie Borden is now supplying the aching void experienced by the victims of moi bid curiosity since the execution
The report describes courtroom testimony from a doctor detailing the wounds found on Abby and Andrew Borden, estimating the murder weapon's blade length and victim's gender-neutral capability to inflict the blows. Cross-examination addressed how much blood would have spattered on the killer and how quickly it would dry on a hatchet in August heat.
Der Deutsche Correspondent · 15 June 1893 · page 4
Lizzie Borden's Prozeß
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
German-language account of the Borden trial describes medical testimony on how the fatal blows were struck, plus testimony from Fall River officials and a dressmaker who heard Lizzie call Abby Borden hateful. Other witnesses meant to prove no stranger could have entered unseen were undermined on cross-examination, and police matron Hannah Reagan recounted a heated jail dispute between Lizzie and her sister Emma.
Der Deutsche Correspondent · 15 June 1893 · page 4
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
A roundup of miscellaneous news items mentions that New Bedford has its own sensational story—a jealousy-driven shooting death of Jose Maria Carmento—comparing its public interest to that of the ongoing Borden trial. The Borden case itself is only referenced in passing as a point of comparison, with no details given.
The Republican Journal · 15 June 1893 · page 1
before . lie temperance congress at < hica^o were- ■ •< Mu;lit women to vote concerning the 1 i<{11 >i trallii ami legislation." by Mrs. Mary \. Livermore. "Duty of elmrcli member^ in social reform." by Rev. Joseph r,.ok. ami ‘ • Nat ionali/.in^ the Impior Tratlie." by Fa 1 ward Bellamy.... ‘dimlaur and Ilosmcr won tin-double scull race at Vustin. Texas. Friday: I lanlon and Teem • : second . McLean ami Ten F.vek last. New Bedford has a sensation to rival pub la inti-rest in the Borden trial. Saturday lose \'aria ( armento.
See moreSee less
J'< years old. shot •1 a 1 y das ( ailuas t hiou.u'li the ln-aiI on the streets. Tluuit! died immediately. Jeal '•usy wastlie cause... .Mrs Frank Leslie has been hi\.>tved from W in. t . I.. Wilde and Inperuiossh >u : = • marry a.^ain-The »•:«!!!. -: Y M Issa.'iiiis. Its w a' benched i: t in- < i i •. i j -- ,i l < i "at ,,1'da \ . 1 i !s t x peet
A small-town correspondent's miscellaneous notes include a brief remark that Lizzie Borden draws a large audience of listeners at local stores each day, amid reports on a drowning death and local crop conditions. The item is mostly unrelated local news, with the Borden reference only indicating ongoing public obsession during her trial.
The Republican Journal · 15 June 1893 · page 1
Lii;ki:t\ Shcn.Ian Sullivan yet lives .. The itih ers of the Ladie’s Meii.-f t orps anto he installed to-day, Thursday Miss Kva I’.-aliodv is at home from Rhode rsland .... Lizzie Borden has a la-hearing at
Marshal Hilliard testified about his visits to the Borden house, describing the dress Lizzie wore and recounting her exchange with Mayor Coughlin about being suspected. The court also heard of evidence from Police Matron Hannah Reagan, though some testimony was excluded by the judges.
Daily Kennebec Journal · 15 June 1893 · page 1
UNHAPPY LIZZIE.
Is Gained ty DaNacs. New Beukoru. June 14.—The Borden trial was resumed promptly this morning and at 9 o'clock every seat in the court room was tilled. City Marshal Hilliard of Fall Kiver was the first witness, lie described his visits to the Horden house ou the day of the murder and the following Saturday. He identified the dress shown in the case as that worn by Lizzie Borden on the day of the murder. He then told of his visit to the barn.
Witnesses at trial describe Mayor Coughlin and Marshal Hilliard's visit to the Borden house, recounting Lizzie's calm response upon learning she was suspected and her account of being in the barn during the murders. A dressmaker also testifies that Lizzie once called her stepmother 'a mean, hateful thing' and said she ate meals apart from her.
Daily Kennebec Journal · 15 June 1893 · page 1
UNHAPPY LIZZIE.
a bench. The witness told of getting the hatchets, clothing of victims, shoes and stockings and other articles from the Borden house. He said he ha«l, made efforts, through his offi cers only, to find out about a note which was said to have been sent to the Borden house on the day of the murder. It appearing that the witness had done nothing personally about the matter, he was not allowed to state the results. In the cross-examination by Robinson Hillard said the search of the Borden house bv the police officers was thorough and that the memliers of the Horden family assisted the officers willingly during the search.
See moreSee less
Lizzie's conversation about her being sus pected was open, earnest and frank. Mayor John W. Coughlin of Kail Kiver was the next witness. He described his visit to the Borden house with Marshal Hilliard and corroborated his testimony as
Witnesses testified they saw no one in or around the Borden yard on the morning of the murder, and legal arguments were made over admissibility of certain statements. Matron Hannah Reagan recounted overhearing Lizzie tell her sister Emma, "You have given me away, Emma, but I don't care, I won't give in one inch."
Daily Kennebec Journal · 15 June 1893 · page 1
family beside her stepmother. Lucy Collet of Fall River testified that she sat on Dr. Ohagnon’s piazza in view of the Borden house from 10.46 to 11.45 on the morning of the murder and saw no man about the premises. Thomas Bolles of Fall River, hostler, said he washed carriages in Mrs. Churchill's yard on the morning of the murder and saw no one in the Borden yard. He could see only a very little of the ya*d; he admit ted that in fact, lie could not see any of it.
See moreSee less
1’atrick McGowan testified that he was in Mr. Crowe's yard from about 10 to 10.30 the morning of the murder. He was em ployed by Mr. Crowe. He saw nobody in the Borden yard. Joseph Des Rosier and John Denoey, who were at work in Crowe's yard on the morning of the murder, testi fied that they saw no one go through the Borden yard that morning. Hannah Reagan, matron of the police
At the New Bedford trial, officials Hilliard, Coughlin, and Fleet testified about searching the Borden house and telling Lizzie she was a suspect, with conflicting accounts of how thorough the search was. The defense failed to exclude testimony about the prussic acid purchase attempt, strengthening the prosecution's case, though they succeeded in showing an intruder could have entered the house.
The Portland Daily Press · 15 June 1893 · page 1
HONORS EVEN.
PRUSSIC ACID STORY. Evidence That Strengthens the Govern ment’s Case—Miss Borden’s Counsel Failed to Exclude Testimony as to the Pofson—They Bid Shut Out Testimony as to Bomestio Troubles and Showed / an Assassin Might Have Entered the House. New Bedfoeo, Mass., June 14.—This morning, at the Borden trial, City Mar shal Hilliard and Mayor Coughlin of Fall River described their visits to the Borden house after the murders, and
At trial, Marshal Hilliard testified under cross-examination that the search of the Borden house was not very thorough and that there was no running water on the second floor, undermining theories Lizzie could have cleaned blood from herself. He also admitted uncertainty over who showed police how to open a locked trunk in the attic, and recounted Lizzie's exchange with the Mayor about being suspected.
The Portland Daily Press · 15 June 1893 · page 1
looking for it. Again, with regard to the trunk in the attic, the Marshal was more frank than his officers. He testified that this trunk opened with a spring, which none of those present could find. Miss Emma and MiSs Lizzie Borden came up stairs, and though he would not be positive, he thought it was Lizzie who showed him how to open that trunk. All the way along both Captain Desmond and John Fleet had dodged this query. They remembered Miss Emma, but their mem ory failed utterly as to Miss Lizzie.
See moreSee less
The Marshal’s face was wreathed in smiles as he denied making a request to Mr. Jennings that he ask Lizzie to come in where they were and pick up some thing. “No, sir,” he remembered nothing of the kind. “Didn’t try to experiment with her?” “Not at all.” “And it is not in your memory at all?” asked the Governor. Andrew Jennings’s face was a study. His eyes were riveted upon the Marshal with a burning gaze, while the Marshal grew more rosy. He remembered noth ing or the kina. Again he went over that* tableaux after tea in the Borden house that Saturday evening. “Is anybody suspected in this house?” was the answer of the witness, quoting Lizzie Borden’s query. “Mr. Morse may answer that,” said the Mayor. “I want to know the truth,” -*Jd the girl, and then His Honor told ' er she was suspected. “She spoke freely, frankly, earnestly,” said the Governor, and both the Marshal and the Mayor she did. Marshal Hilliard, in spite of District Attorney Knowlton’s objections, was allowed to answer Governor Robin son that while he had not told Mr. Jen nings that he suspected the witness be fore this call to apprise Lizzie Borden of the feeling concerning her, he had told Mr. Jennings that some one else did. The Dressmaker's Story of Hard Feeling, Then came the dressmaker, Mrs. Han nah Gifford. She had been making a cloak for Mrs. Borden in March, 1892, and when speaking of it to Lizzie the latter said, referring to Mrs. Borden, that she was “a mean, good for nothing thing.” Gov. Robinson objected, and was saved an exception. The governor con sidered that this was too remote from the period of the crime. It was allowed to go in, however, and Lizzie’s cheek hushed slightly as*she watched the wit ness. ... Mrs. Gifford went on to say that' slie said, “Oh, Lizzie, you don’t mean that,” and went on to state that the girl re plied that, though she came down to her meals, she didn’t eat with Mrs. Borden if she could help it. This is the only wit ness as yet that the government has to offset Bridget Sullivan’s testimony that she never saw a quarrel or any ill feeling in the Borden family during her stay of nearly three years. The defence has now reserved two ex ceptions.
The passage covers courtroom testimony including Marshal Hilliard's inconsistent statements about telling Lizzie she was suspected, and dressmaker Hannah Gifford's account of Lizzie's harsh words about her stepmother. It also introduces witness Anna Borden, Lizzie's close friend from their 1890 European trip.
The Portland Daily Press · 15 June 1893 · page 1
Morse may answer that,” said the Mayor. “I want to know the truth,” -*Jd the girl, and then His Honor told ' er she was suspected. “She spoke freely, frankly, earnestly,” said the Governor, and both the Marshal and the Mayor she did. Marshal Hilliard, in spite of District Attorney Knowlton’s objections, was allowed to answer Governor Robin son that while he had not told Mr. Jen nings that he suspected the witness be fore this call to apprise Lizzie Borden of the feeling concerning her, he had told Mr. Jennings that some one else did.
See moreSee less
The Dressmaker's Story of Hard Feeling, Then came the dressmaker, Mrs. Han nah Gifford. She had been making a cloak for Mrs. Borden in March, 1892, and when speaking of it to Lizzie the latter said, referring to Mrs. Borden, that she was “a mean, good for nothing thing.” Gov. Robinson objected, and was saved an exception. The governor con sidered that this was too remote from the period of the crime. It was allowed to go in, however, and Lizzie’s cheek hushed slightly as*she watched the wit ness. ... Mrs. Gifford went on to say that' slie said, “Oh, Lizzie, you don’t mean that,” and went on to state that the girl re plied that, though she came down to her meals, she didn’t eat with Mrs. Borden if she could help it. This is the only wit ness as yet that the government has to offset Bridget Sullivan’s testimony that she never saw a quarrel or any ill feeling in the Borden family during her stay of nearly three years. The defence has now reserved two ex ceptions.
The report describes the opening of Lizzie Borden's trial for the murders of her father and stepmother, noting that a jury was secured and the prosecution's opening statement was delivered. After the opening speech, court adjourned so jurors could visit the scene of the killings in Fall River.
Iron County Register · 15 June 1893 · page 2
A Summary of Important Events. PERSONAL AND GENERAL. A JtTHT having been secured, the trial of Miss Lizzie Borden for the alleged murder of her father and step-mother
The report describes the ongoing trial of Lizzie Borden in Bedford, Massachusetts, for the murder of her father and stepmother, calling it the most sensational trial of the day. It notes that the defense won a key victory when the court refused to admit her earlier inquest testimony, which had been given under great mental excitement and was considered very damaging to her case.
The Butler Weekly Times · 15 June 1893 · page 8
The trial of Miss Lizzie Borden at Bedford, Mass, for the murder of her father and stepmother is the most sensational trial of the day.