The Princeton Union · Princeton, Minn. · and 2 other papers
The long-anticipated Borden murder trial opened in New Bedford, Massachusetts, with crowds gathering outside the courthouse before the session began. Lizzie Borden entered the courtroom at 10:58, and after a prayer, jury selection commenced.
The Princeton Union · 8 June 1893 · page 3
LIZZIE BORDEN'S TRIAL. New Bedford, Mass., June 6.The loug^ anticipated Borden murder trial has be gun. At an early hour every available shady spot on County street near the
The Dickinson Press · Dickinson, N.D. · 10 June 1893
The Washburn Leader · Washburn, N.D. · 10 June 1893
The Washburn Leader · Washburn, N.D. · 17 June 1893
Paper unidentified
The item notes that one of the most interesting murder trials in years is currently in progress at 'Bedford, Mass.', where Lizzie Borden is being tried for the murder of her father and stepmother. It is a brief aside within a column covering various political and news items of the day.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Paper unidentified · 8 June 1893 · page 2
One of the most interesting and exciting murder trials that hns had public attention in many years is now in progress at Bedford Mass., whero Lizzie Borden is being tried for the murder of her father and stepmother.
On June 7, the Lizzie Borden trial continued with testimony from J.V. Morse, a guest at the Borden house at the time of the murders, and servant Bridget Sullivan. The main point established was that family relations were harmonious with no quarrels, and no new facts emerged before court adjourned.
Omaha Daily Bee · 8 June 1893 · page 1
Mzzle llorden'n Trial. NEW BEIIFOIID , Muss. , Juno 7 , The trial o Lizzie Borden continued today , J , V , Morse n guest at the liorJon house ut the time o the murders , and Bridget Sullivan , a ner vant , testified. The principal point brough out in the examination of Miss Sullivan wu that the family relatives were of ttio mos harmonious character , there never bavin , been any quarrels. Other testimony de veloped no new fuels. At the close of th cross-examination of Bridget Sullivan th court adjourned until tomorrow ut 0 o'clock
The report describes the start of Lizzie Borden's trial in New Bedford, including her arraignment, the packed courtroom, and the selection of the jury. It recounts her appearance in court and notes the intense public interest in the case.
The Monmouth Inquirer · 8 June 1893 · page 8
MURDER MYSTERY. ^Lizzie Borden, Accused of Braining Her Father and Stepmother With a Hatchet, Faces Her Judge—.She Fainted When the Skulls Were Mentioned* NEW Bedford, Mass., June 5.—Perhaps the most sensational trial New England lias had in half a century or more Is that which was begun here today, when Lizzie Borden was arraigned for the murder of her father and stepmother. It will be several days, though, from the time when Judge Mason took his seat this lorenoon until the trial begins in earnest. The quaint little courthouse was packed to the doors and probably will he every day that the trial goes on.
See moreSee less
The crowd of spec tators will be looking for some sensational developments each day, and they cannot be kept out. The Borden murder mystery has attract ed more public attention than any case of the kind in years. On Aug. 4, 1892, Mr. and Mrs. A ndrew J. Borden were hacked to death in their home in a thickly settled
The report describes the opening days of Lizzie Borden's trial in New Bedford, noting the quick empaneling of the jury and the start of prosecution testimony. It highlights witness Alice M. Russell's testimony about burned dresses and Lizzie's premonitions as especially significant evidence for the government.
The Monmouth Inquirer · 8 June 1893 · page 8
vided there are no setbacks. New Bedford. Mass., June 7.—The trip to Fall River by the jury somewhat inter rupted the Borden trial, but the prosecu tion Iregan again this forenoon presenting evidence. Up to this morning only one ■witness had been called. He was Thomas Kieran, a civil engineer from Fall River. The eminent counsel for the defense wore a serious look upon their faces this morn ing. It is to be a hard struggle, with plenty of close in-fighting. The government ap parently rests secure in the possession of its facts, and has added but one piece of re ally new testimony, for the new ax and the burned dress have already been hinted at long ago as having been presented to the grand jury.
See moreSee less
But -Miss Alice M. Russell is brought to the front witli even greater prominence than Bridget Sullivan. And Miss Russell was Lizzie Borden’s closest friend; so close that hers was t he first name that suggested itself to the stricken girl that fatal iporning when Bridget ivas sent out to summon help. Miss Russell occupies an anomalous and peculiarly singular position. It is her tes timony as to the burning of the dresses, and her evidence as to the expressed pre sentment of evil hanging over the Borden
During the trial, the jury was taken to Fall River to inspect the Borden house and nearby locations relevant to the case, accompanied by lawyers and deputies. Earlier in court, confusion arose over the display of skulls as evidence, which Lizzie and the sheriff briefly thought were about to be removed.
The Monmouth Inquirer · 8 June 1893 · page 8
the premises was in progress. Assistant District Attorney Moody and Lawyer Jen nings accompanied the party. Then the court took a recess and Miss Borden, after a chat with Mr. Adams, was conducted back to jail. The Jury at the House.
Prosecutor Moody opened the government's case against Lizzie Borden, emphasizing her alleged hatred of her stepmother and arguing no one else could have committed the murders; Borden fainted during his address. The next day, servant Bridget Sullivan testified that anyone could have entered the house unnoticed and that family relations were not unpleasant.
Gloucester County Democrat · 8 June 1893 · page 2
of the Russian government to raise the rank of its mission here to an embassy. the Borden Murder Trial. New Bedford, Mass., June 7.—The case of the government in the trial of lizzie Borden for the murder of her parents was formally opened yesterday by Mr. Moody. In a strong argument he reviewed the events leading to the tragedy, dwelt at length upon Miss Borden’s hatred of her stepmother, and asserted that no one else could possibly have committed the crime et that hour of the day. At the conclusion of Mr.
See moreSee less
Moody’s address Miss Borden fell hack in a faint. New Bedford, June 8.—In the Borden trial yesterday Bridget Sullivan, the ser vant girl, was the most important witness. According to her testimony anybody could have entered the house without her knowl edge, and she asserted that the family re lations were not unpleasant.
This report covers the New Bedford trial proceedings, describing crowds at the courthouse and testimony from witnesses including Dr. Bowen, the family physician, and references to Alice Russell's distress over Lizzie's destruction of a dress. Mrs. Churchill's observation that Lizzie seemed troubled and Bridget Sullivan's recollection of an old robbery are also mentioned as part of the day's testimony.
The Jersey City News · 8 June 1893 · page 1
"OH, WHY DID YOU LET ME!"
New Bedford, Mass., June 8, 1893.— The Court House was opened before the regular time this morning, and at the maiu entrance the inquisitive females who had swallowed their breakf ast hur riedly or dispensed with them entirely, made one of the prettiest rushes ever seeu outside of College premises. The two blue coated representatives of the local police were carried off their feoo and whirled along with the resistless pettlcoated surge from below until sev eral Depaty Sheriffs jumped down to their rescue and turned the tide. The re sult was that the pushers were kept out entirely, while those who acted iu a fairly deceuc manner were allowed the coveted privilege of fighting for seats in side.
See moreSee less
Miss Borden was in her seat fifteen minutes before the court came in and eagerly looked over the conteuts of a big, official looking envelope, which she afterwards passed to Governor Robinson. All her couusel was early on hand and the jury were in their seats before coun sel lor ihe prosecution showed up at all. Just as the Court came it and the crier was making his proclamation, Miss Bor den was passingfrom her seat iu the dock to a seat within the bar enclosure beside her counsel. She was obliged to stand almost beside Judge Blodgett, while the crier was talking.
The report describes courtroom scenes as Lizzie Borden's trial resumes, including crowd control issues and her passing an envelope to Governor Robinson. Dr. Bowen then testifies about being summoned to the Borden house and finding Andrew Borden's body on the sitting room sofa, his face severely cut.
The Jersey City News · 8 June 1893 · page 1
THE DAT’S WOKS. The first witness called for was Mrs. Churchill, the previous call forDr.Bowen having been rescinded, but she not being present, Dr. Bowen was put on. He said:— •‘I have lived at my present residence twenty-one years, which is diagonally opposite the Borden house. I have been tne family physician ueariy all that time. I recall the day of August 4, '92. I saw Mr. Borden the day before about six o’clock going dowu the street. 1 testified at the iuquest,but do not recall that 1 said then I saw him going up the street on !
See moreSee less
Wednesday (the notes show he did say so. but witness said it was a mistake). X thiult it was after eleven and. before lmlf nast eleveu tnat I returned to mv house iu the morning of Wednesday. Wheu I returned Mrs. Bowen spoke to me, and in consequeutce of that I went to the Borden house. I saw Miss Llfczje Borden and Mrs. Chnrcbill there: they were iD the side hall, just at the end of it, near the kitchen door. I said, ‘Lizzie, what’s the matter?’ She said, ’Father has been killed or stabbed.’ I asked, ‘Where is your father?’ She said, ‘In the sitting room.’ That was all that was said in that connection at that time. Iu consequence of what she said I went into the dining rocm and then into the sitting room. I saw the form of Air. Borden lying on the sofa at the left of the sittiug room door. 1 found upou inspec
A witness (the family physician) describes finding Andrew Borden's body on the sofa and later being shown upstairs to discover Abby Borden's body in the guest room, noting her head wound and that she was dead. He recounts Lizzie's statements about being in the barn and about Mrs. Borden receiving a note to visit a sick friend.
The Jersey City News · 8 June 1893 · page 1
THE DAY'S WORK
had trouble with some of his teuauis. Tuen I asked her to get sometbiug to cover Mr. Borden wltn, and Bridget brought me a sheet. The sheet was brought from Mr. Borden’s room aud the key taken from the mantle, X believe, where it was usually kept. After the sneet was used Lizzie asked me if i would telegraph to Kinma. aud iu consequence of that re quest 1 dia so. Up to that time nothiog had. been said of Mrs. Borden, but just before I weut to the telegraph otlice somebody asked where Mrs.
See moreSee less
Borden was, and Lizzie said she had received a note to visit a sick friend aud had gone out. As I was going I met Officer Alien. I know it was he, bat I can’t tell how long it was after I went there that X met him. On my return from the telegraph office I met in the kitchen hallway Mrs. Churchill, and she said they had found Mrs. Borden upstairs in the front room. She said I had better go up and see her. MRS. BORDEN’S BODY.
An editorial argues that Lizzie Borden's inquest interrogation, conducted without counsel or warning, violated core Common Law protections for the accused. It states the case looks bad for her but condemns the prosecutorial methods as a threat to criminal justice principles generally.
The Jersey City News · 8 June 1893 · page 2
■ is the protection which, in one case ft after another, we see lapsing into ■ neglect and disregard. When suspicion fell upon Lizzie I Borden, she was taken into a private
The trial opened in New Bedford with prosecutor Moody delivering his opening statement, describing the murders of the elderly couple and outlining the household's movements that morning. The jury had viewed the Borden home and premises the previous afternoon, and Lizzie Borden fainted as Moody concluded his address.
Bridgeton Pioneer · 8 June 1893 · page 4
First Witness Culled. New Bedford, Mass., June 7.—At 8:53 a. m. Miss Borden and the jury were In their seats, and counsel were on hand busily arranging their papers. The doors were opened to spectators about that time, and at least a third of those present were females. State Detectives Seaver and Shaw were close at hand to counsel for the prosecu cution as aides, and Detective Ducey, of Chelsea, who has been doing some quiet work on the sly for the defense, was handy to the call of counsel on that side. The jury heard the indictments against Miss Borden read as soon as Court was formally
During opening proceedings, Lizzie Borden fainted after prosecutor Moody's remarks and was revived with smelling salts and ice before court resumed. The jury traveled to Fall River to view the Borden premises, with Lizzie waiving her right to accompany them.
Bridgeton Pioneer · 8 June 1893 · page 4
Lizzie Borden Faints. Her eyes were closed and she appeared as if asleep. Not by any motion did she betray that she was conscious of what was going on about her. Just as Mr. Moody had ceased to speak and taken one step toward his seat, there was a noise where Miss Borden was sitting. She had fainted. The Rev. Mr. Jubb hurried over to her and placed a bottle of smelling salts to her nostrils. Deputy Sheriff Kirby and an other officer hurried after soms cracked ice. The woman’s face grew white.
See moreSee less
The offi cers returned with ice in a moment, and a couple of minutes later Miss Borden began to recover. The jury was allowed a recess of about five minutes, and when it had returned to the box she had recovered her usual man ner and bearing. When the jury returned the case was opened by the Government putting on its first witness in the person of Thomas Kiernan. Mr. Knowlton then asked the court to allow the jury to take a view of the Bor den premises. Gov. Robinson, who con sulted Miss Borden in regard to accom panying the jury to Fall River, announced that his client waived her rights in the matter and would not go with them. Messrs. Hodges, Brown, Nickerson and Arnold of the Deputy Sheriffs were desig nated by the Sheriff to look after the jury, and Messrs. Moody, for the commonwealth, and Mr. Jennings, for the defense, were designated as representing counsel. The Chief Justice instructed the jury as to what the view was to be taken for and then they were dismissed to report for duty this morning at 9 o’clock.
This report covers courtroom proceedings at the Borden murder trial in New Bedford, including crowds rushing for seats and Lizzie Borden's composed demeanor. Dr. Bowen takes the stand to testify, with mention of a dress burning incident and his prescribing a double morphine dose for Lizzie.
The Evening World · 8 June 1893 · page 1
BURNING THAT DRESS.
Double Morphine Dom for Lizzie. NEW BEDFORD, Maes., Juno 8. The Court-House was opened before the regular time for the Borden trial this , k morning, and at the main entrance the I Inquisitive females who had swallowed their breakfasts hurriedly or dispensed with them entirely made one of tho prettiest rushes ever seen outside of col lege premises. The two blue-coated representatives of the local pollco were carried off their feet and whirled along with the resist less pettlcoated surge from below until several deputy sheriffs Jumped down to their rescue snd turned the tlde.
See moreSee less
Tho result was that the pushers were 'kept out entirely, while those who acted In a fairly decent manner were allowed the coveted privilege of fighting for seats Inside. Miss Borden was In her seat fifteen minutes before tho Court came In, and 1 eagerly looked over the contents of a big, official-looking envelope which 'she afterwards passed to ex-Gov. Robinson. Just as tho Court came in and tho crier was making his proclamation, Miss ' Borden was passing from her seat In the I dock to a sent within the bar lnclosure beside her counsel. She was obliged to land almost beside Judge Blodgett while the crier was talking. Dlt. BOWEN TO THE STAND.
The report describes courtroom scenes as Lizzie Borden takes her seat and a crowd is controlled outside, then transitions to the testimony of Dr. Bowen, the family physician. Bowen recounts arriving at the Borden house after the murder, finding Andrew Borden's body on the sofa, and identifying a photograph of the victim for the jury while Lizzie avoided looking at it.
Dr. Bowen describes to the jury how he found Andrew Borden's body on the sofa and later discovered Abby Borden's body upstairs, recounting his examination of both and his exchanges with Lizzie about her whereabouts. A photograph of Andrew Borden is shown to the jury while Lizzie stares at the floor.
The Evening World · 8 June 1893 · page 1
DR. BOWEN TO THE STAND.
had gone out. I"As 1 was going I met Officer Allen, I know It was he, but I can't tell how long It was after I went there that I met him. On my return from the tele graph office I met in the kitchen hall way Mrs. Churchill, and she said they had found Mrs. Borden upstairs In the front room. She said I hud better go up and see her, "I went through the dining-room and Utlng-room, nnd up the front stairs, , stopping a moment at tho door of the I guest chamber At that point I looked over tho bed and saw the prottrate form of Mrs.
See moreSee less
Borden; then I was stand ing In the doorway. I went around at "A the. foot of the bed, placed my hand on flk-her head and found a wound In the Ylhead; then I felt, her pulse and found llhe was. dead. II "I never said to anyone that, she bad died of fright or in a faint, but I will say this. My first thought was that she had fainted. I went downstairs I and told the people Mrs. Borden was dead; that I thought she was killed by the same Instrument with which Mr. Borden was killed, nnd that I consid ered it fortunate that Lizzie was out of the way." Here a photograph of the position of Mrs. Borden was shown and witness said Mrs. Borden was lying nearer the bed when he saw her.. As this plcturre went the rounds and was commented upon Lizzie coverjd her eyes, but there woro no tears. Witness continued; "When I was in the house In the morning I saw that Lizzie had changed her dress, a pink wrapper, but did not notice the first dress worn as to color or material." The witness said that after he went downstairs first, after seeing Mrs. Bor den's body, Lizzie was In the kitchen. Mrs. Churchill, Miss Russell, witness's wife and Bridget were fanning her and working over her. She afterwards went into the dining-room, and witness told her she had better go to her room, where he afterwards saw her. MORPHINE FOR LIZZIE BORDEN.
This report describes the courtroom scene at the Borden trial in New Bedford, including the crowd rush to enter and Lizzie Borden's demeanor as she reviewed documents before court began. It also references testimony about Lizzie's burning of a dress on the Sunday after the murders and Dr. Bowen's account of prescribing double morphine doses to her.
The Evening World · 8 June 1893 · page 1
BURNING THAT DRESS.
V Doublo Morphine Dotes lor Lizzie. ' I NEW BEDFOHD, Mass., June 8. il The Court-llouso was opened before the B regular time for the Borden trial this morning, and at the main entrance the
The report describes the courtroom scene as Lizzie Borden takes her seat before Judge Blaisdell, then shifts to Dr. Bowen's testimony on the stand. Bowen recounts being summoned to the Borden house on August 4, 1892, finding Andrew Borden's body on the sitting-room sofa, and identifying a photograph of the corpse while Lizzie kept her eyes on the floor.
The Evening World · 8 June 1893 · page 1
BV the crier was talking. nil, 1IOWHN TO Till! STAND. BM Tli? first witness called for was Mrs. BJL Churchill, a previous call for Dr. l'owcn BjK having been rescinded, but she not beBJI lug present, Dr. Bowen was put on. 1 t Hi said: "1 have lived at my present HIT - residence twenty-one years. It Is dlas HlPiW onally opposite the Borden house. I BlIKj hiv" baen tl,e tnmi& physician 'nearly mwLi n" that ,lme1 reca" tne day ot Avjv 4, 1S'J2. I saw Mr. Borden the day beVJf fore, about 6 o'clock, going down the
A witness (evidently Dr. Bowen) testifies at the inquest about finding Andrew Borden's body on the sofa, showing the jury a photograph of the slain man while Lizzie stared at the floor. He recounts his exchanges with Lizzie about her whereabouts and Mrs. Borden's absence, then describes finding Abby Borden's body upstairs and confirming she was dead.
The Evening World · 8 June 1893 · page 1
A PICTURE OF THE MURDERED MAN
Br mil ot h,s lcnantaThen I asked her to HI sJli I et omet,llIl(! 10 covcr SIrBorden and ,1 DH K3l, Bridget brought me a sheet. ' vsPVssssbsT "The sheet was brought from Mr. BBVI Borden's room, and tho key was taken tlJfBYv from the mantel, I believe, where It was HIBll usually kept. After tho sheet was used UBlI Lizzie asked It I would telegraph to BjB ijM Emma, nnd I dlil so. I'p to that time Bj,X nothing had been said of Mrs. Borden, BBjtgJ but Just before I v.-imt to the telegraph BBLhI oftlce somebody asked where Mrs.
See moreSee less
liorBBt71 den was, and I.lzzle said she had re- ( BV II I celved a note to visit a sick friend, and . Bb M had gone out. Wfj "As I was going I met Officer Allen. liU I know It was he. but I ran't tell how j&vB long It was after I went there that I W met him. On lyy return from the televM f graph office I met In the kitchen hallm I way Mrs. Churchill, nnd she said they 1 I I had found Mrs. Borden upstairs In the ( I front room. She said I had better go up Jl and see her. Wi U "I went through the dining-room and U'iH Slttlng-ruom, and up the front stairs, JB stopping a moment at the door of tho juBJI guest chamber At that point I looked BBj over the bed nnd saw the prostrate IK) form ot Mrs Borden; then I was stand-' eAflK lng In the doorway, I went nround nt BP the foot ot tlie bed, placed my hand on OT' her head and found a wound In the -BT' I, head; then I felt her pulse and found she was dead. BJ "I never b:ild to anyone that she had ' died of fright or In a faint, but I will ' sny this. My first thought was that shu had fainted. I went downstairs ' and told the people Mrs. llorden vuib ! dead; that I thought she was killed by , the same Instrument with which Mr. ' llorden was killed, and that I consid ered It fortunate that I.lzzle was out ot tho way." ! Here a photograph of the position of Mrs. Borden was shown und witness said Mrs. llorden was lying nearer tho bed when he saw her.. As this ploturre j went the rounds and was commented upon Lizzie coverid her eyes, but there were no tears. Witness continued: "When I wns In the house ln the morning I saw that Lizzie had changed her dress, a pink wrapper, but did not notlre the first dress worn as to color or material." The witness said that after ho went downstairs first, utter seeing Mrs. Bor den's body, Lizzie was In the kitchen. Mrs. Churchill, Miss Russell, witness's wife and Bridget were fanning her and working over her. She afterwards went Into the dining-room, and witness told (her she hud better go to her room, whete ho nf terwards saw her. MORPHINE FOR LIZZIE BORDEN.
Coverage of the Borden trial at New Bedford describes Miss Russell's testimony about Lizzie Borden burning a dress on the Sunday after the murders, and Dr. Bowen's testimony about discovering the crime scene and treating Lizzie. Dr. Bowen recounts arriving at the Borden house and Lizzie telling him her father had been killed or stabbed.
The Evening World · 8 June 1893 · page 1
BURNING THAT DRESS.
DR. BOWEN TO THE STAND. The first witness called for was Mrs. Churchill, a previous call for Dr. Bowen having been rescinded, but Bhe not be ing present. Dr. Bowen was put on. He said: "I have lived at my present residence twenty-one yeacs. It Is diag onally opposite the Borden house. I have been the family physician nearly all that time. I recall the day of Aug. 4, 1802. I saw Mr. Borden the day be fore, about 6 o'clock, going down the street. "I think It was after 11 ai.d before 11.30 that I returned to my house In the morning of the murder.
See moreSee less
When I re turned Mrs. Bowen 'spoke to me, and In consequence of that I went to the Bor den house. I saw Miss Lizzie Borden and Mrs. Churchill there. They were In g , the Bide hall, Just at the end of It, near f A the kitchen door; I said, 'Lizzie, what's ft the materr Bhe said, 'Father has been killed, or'-aUbbed,"- -I aaked: 'Wb.er;t: your fatherr"She Baldr 'In the sitting; room.' '"That.was all that was said In that (I connection at that time. I went Into the
Family physician Dr. Bowen testifies at the trial about being called to the Borden house on August 4, 1892, finding Andrew Borden dead on the sitting-room sofa, and his exchanges with Lizzie Borden that morning. He recounts her claim of being in the barn, her request to telegraph her sister Emma, and her statement that Mrs. Borden had gone to visit a sick friend.
Dr. Bowen recounts at trial his discovery of Andrew and Abby Borden's bodies, describing Lizzie's reactions and statements immediately after the murders. He describes examining Mrs. Borden's wound, sending the telegram to Emma, and Lizzie changing her dress.
The Evening World · 8 June 1893 · page 1
A PICTURE OF THE MURDERED
some lion.' She said she was afraid I her father had had trouble with some of his tenantB. Then I asked her to get something to cover Mr. Borden and Bridget Drought me a sheet. By "The sheet was brought from Mr. ml Borden's room, and the key was taken ML from the mantel, I Melleve, where It was H usually kept. After CTTJheet was used ML Lizzie asked If I would telegraph to H Emma, and I did so. Up to thut time H nothing had been said of Mrs.
See moreSee less
Borden, H but Just before I went to the telegraph H office somebody asked wnere Mrs. BorH den was, and Lizzie said she had reH celved a note to visit a sick friend, and H had gone out. mm "As I was going I met Officer Allen. FT I know It was he, but I can't teU how ylong It was after I went there that I met him. On my return from the teleJ graph office I met In the kitchen hallry way Mrs. Churchill, and she said they had found Mrs. Borden upstairs In tho ID front room. She said I had better go up jf-, and see. her.
This compilation of general news briefs from early June 1893 includes a single line noting that Lizzie Borden is on trial at New Bedford, Massachusetts. It appears alongside unrelated items like Cleveland's fishing trip, mining disasters, and Edwin Booth's death.
Belmont Chronicle · 8 June 1893 · page 1
GENERAL NEWS NOTES.
Lizzie Borden is on trial at New Bed ford, Mass. Four people at Cincinnati were bitten by a mad dog Monday. I he jury found the railroad responsible for the Main circus wreck. President Cleveland says that an extra session will be called abont September 1. Charles W. Dayton, a Tammanyite, was appointed postmaster at New York. Rumors caused a great run on Chicago banks Monday, and the trouble extended . to many smaller towns, causing many failures. Secretary Carlisle began the disburse ment of the Choctaw and Chickasaw claim of 13,000,000 for the ceded land in the Cherokee strip.
See moreSee less
- , The first fall of rain in Meade. Kas since last. September, was Monday morning, after the operations of Jewell. the railroad rain-maker. Edwin Booth died Wednesday morn ing. The Russian extradition treaty was proclaimed and will go into effect June 24th. The annual convention of the Amal gamated Association of Iron and Steel
After a ten-month delay, Lizzie Borden's trial for the murder of her father and stepmother has commenced. The report notes the evidence against her is largely circumstantial—her presence in the house and inconsistent statements—while also citing public support for her innocence and a recent similar unsolved murder (Miss Manchester) that undermines the case against her.
The Evening Herald · 8 June 1893 · page 2
Miss Borden's character has always stood very high and the lias many strong believers in her innocence among those who have beon most Intimately acquainted with her, and a
The fourth day of the Lizzie Borden trial opened with Dr. Bowen on the stand, following testimony from civil engineer Thomas Kieran and photographer James Walsh regarding crime scene measurements and photographs. The report notes fewer women in attendance than the previous day and describes Lizzie Borden as appearing calm and engaged in conversation with her attorney.
The Evening Herald · 8 June 1893 · page 2
MIm Harden Hliows Only Casual Inter est In tlie Proceeding--Morse's Con trndlitlnn Tlie Servant's Story. New Hedpohd, Mnss., June 8. Tlie fourth day of the Borden trial lgnn this morning soon ntter 9 oclock, with Dr. Ilowen on tho stand. 1 he court room had n different aspect to-day in the fact that there were not so many women in attend nnce as yesterday. Yesterday Miss Borden entered looking its unconcerned and fresh as any one could under such circumstances. After she took her seat, Mr. Jennings hnd a flTo-mlnutea' conversation with her, aud she appeared very much Interested and animated, smile breaking out occasionally ns the talk proceeded.
See moreSee less
Thomas Kiemnn, the civil englnoer. who was called Tuesday just before adjourn ment, was recalled for cross-examination. lie pointed out tno line between tne Borden aud Kelly bouses, and said the line struck twelve Inches from the hinge or east side of the door. The point ot contact of that lino with tho east side of Second street ns to belnn tho point whore there is tho best observation, was a ques tion which came up for discussion between counsel and court. James J. Walsh, n photographer ot Fall River, was next called. lie was cnlled upon to testify as to the accuracy of the photographs taken by him to be used lu the trial. Tlie views of tn premises weio taken on Saturdny last. Hi' took other photographs just af tor the trag edy. 1'lctures of the bodies of both Mr. aud Mrs. Borden were taken at the same time. The name of John V. Morse was next called, and a big, raw-boned man, bronzed and wearing a gray beard, stepped forward aud leaned up against the dock, ns ho would upon n Uncs rail. He is an uncle of the prisoner, and brother of the first Mrs Borden. The first Mrs. Borden died in 1801, the witness told Mr. Moody. Mr. Borden married the second time about three years later. Morse said he visited the Bordon house on Aug. 8. He had seen Mls Lizzie prior to that for about four months. Miss Bor den was not there when he called on thr 3d. as least he did not see her while there. Ho left the houte about 3 or 4 o'clock and returned in the evening at about 8:30 He entered by the front door. Mrs. Bor den let him in. The door was shut after he stenned into the hall. He could not say If It wik locked. Mrs. Borden went to bed flrst that night. Bofore that he heard jome one enter the house and eo into Lizzie's room, He slept t-at nlubt In tho guest chamber, the room iu which Mrs. Borden was subsequently found dead As ho entered the guest chamber he no ticed that tho door of Miss Lizzie's room was closeJ. It was the same when he went down stairs the next morning. When he entered tho -sitting room on Thursday morning the door between the sitting room aud tho kitchen was closed. He breakfasted with Mr. and Mrs. Borden at about 7 o'clock. Mr. Borden was in the sitting room most of the time that Morse was there utter breakfast. Mrs. Borden was dusting the sitting room then. Morse left the bouse that morning at about 7t58. Mr. Borden went out with him They left by the screen door. He saw Briduet Sulllvuu there. The screen door was fastened on the inside with the ordinary hook and screw eye. When he returned to the house the dead bodies had been discovered. He saw the body of Mrs. Borden first. Ex-Gov. Uoblnson commenced cross-examining
At the Borden trial, a civil engineer and a photographer testified about measurements and photos of the crime scene. John V. Morse, Lizzie's uncle, then described his movements on the day before and morning of the murders, including details of the house's doors and locks.
Among many unrelated news items from June 5, this digest reports that Lizzie Borden's trial for the murder of her father and stepmother began at New Bedford. The item gives no further detail, simply noting the trial's commencement alongside other world and national news.
Freeland Tribune · 8 June 1893 · page 4
the death of Maggie Man zone. Monday, June If. The trial of Lizzie Borden, charged with the murder of her father and stepmother at Fall River, began at New Bedford The Rev. Dr. Lyman Abbott of Brooklyn up held tho views of I)r. Briggs and severely criticised the Presbyterian general assem bly which suspended him from the minis try Jose Carreiro. a Portuguese, is un der arrest In Fall River for the murder of Bertha Manchester, and the police believe they have sufficient evidence to convict him The ltev. Dr. James 11.
See moreSee less
Ecob of Al bany will withdraw from the Presby terian church ns a result of the de cision in the Briggs case Owing tc A storm less than 60,000 persons vis ited the World's fair, which was opened yesterday A speculator on thf Chicago board of trade hanged himsel! with the cord of his smoking jacket Tb< Kill of Colonel Logan 11. Roots of Little Rock, disposes of property worth *1,004,000 3 Mr. Coolidge, ex-minister to France, arrived at New York The Austrian truining ship Frundsberg arrived at New York, and the cadets on board will visit \ the World's fair The Infanta Eulalie ( left New York for Chicago——Five persons lost their lives at an early nit ruing fire in ; East Forty-third street, New York Mr.
Maid Bridget Sullivan testified that the Borden household was peaceful, with no quarrels or domestic trouble, undermining the prosecution's theory of family strife. Her account of calm relations, including Lizzie's pleasant exchange with her stepmother that morning, was seen as a significant boost to the defense.
Pawtucket Tribune · 8 June 1893 · page 1
THE DEFENSE AIDED
Bits of Evidence Which Are in Favor the Accused Woman. NEW BEDFORD, Mass., June 8, —Bridget Sullivan has told her story. Her evidence is complete. In less than four hours her testimeny was finished. Her very candor, hor evidence deftly drawn out by the per si-tent, smooth and adroit cross-examina tion has done more to help her accused former mistress than injure her, Governor Robinson has succeeded in dealing a pretty hard blow to the theory of the comnmonwealth that there was a quarrel in this faiily; that the relations between parents and daughters were strained; that they did not live happily together.
See moreSee less
Here is a girl who on her own evidence had lived in the close relation of the family domestic for two years and nine months in the Borden household. What does she say on this point? Why, that her relations with Miss Fmmi and Miss Lizzic Borden were so pleasant that they gave her a more pleasing pet name than her own and called her Maguie, and she liked it. “It was not nnpleasant,” was her reply to the governor. Mrs. Borden called her by her right name. They Never Had Any Trouble there; she did not sce any quarreling or conflict; the daughters did not usually come (o the breakliast table with Mr, and Mrs. Borden; they did not get up as early; they were there at dinner. There was no trouble that morning; Bridget heard Liz gle and her stepinother talking calwly to gether, the same as anybody would. Ivis Bridget Sullivan who says this on heroath, And is is of the first importance to the defense for its weight against the commonwealth’s theory of motive, Then Bridget leaves that sereen door open from 9 o'clock to 10:45 very nearly. And when she went out, as she says, at 9, it is perfectly clear, on all the evidence, that Mrs. Borden was alive.
Governor Robinson's closing argument stresses Bridget Sullivan's testimony that the Borden household was peaceful and that the screen door was left unhooked for nearly two hours, allowing anyone to enter unseen. He uses this to undercut the prosecution's theory of exclusive opportunity and motive against Lizzie Borden.
This report reviews Bridget Sullivan's trial testimony, highlighting contradictions about whether she hooked the screen door and discrepancies in Lizzie's clothing descriptions compared to the drugstore poisoning witness. It also notes confusion over the locked front door and the layout of the house regarding stairway access, concluding the testimony strengthened the defense's case.
Pawtucket Tribune · 8 June 1893 · page 1
And at Home Blok. There is the evidence as to the locks on the front door. Uncle John Morse settled the question of the ease with which the spring lock could be passed without a key. The material fact is that there is nothing to show that Mrs. Borden herself locked the door as she started to go up stairs. It would have been the most natural thing in the world for her to do, knowing that Bridget was out and that Lizzie was up stairs. At any rate there is nothing to connect Lizzie Borden with the positive locking of this door.
See moreSee less
Bridget had nothing to do with this door or the front entry or the rooms up stairs. Bridget Goes Plump Through Mr. Moody's solid wall which, hedeclared, existed up stairs, dividing the Borden house, Itisthe claim of the common
On June 6 in New Bedford, the indictment against Lizzie Borden was read and prosecutor Moody delivered the government's opening statement. Immediately afterward Borden fainted and the court adjourned until the next day so the jury could visit the crime scene.
The Austin Weekly Statesman · 8 June 1893 · page 8
Lizzie Borden Trial.
don Tit-Bits. hand this morning. The jury heard theindictruents against Miss Borden read as soon as court was formally opened. Attorney Moody then opened the government's case. To the end of the opening address Miss Borden never moved a muscle. Just as Moody ceased speakiDg there was a
At the New Bedford trial, John V. Morse (a house guest) and servant Bridget Sullivan testified that the Borden family relations were harmonious with no quarrels. The testimony contained no new facts, and court adjourned after Sullivan's cross-examination.
The Salt Lake Herald · 8 June 1893 · page 1
L1ZZLC BORDENS TRIAL Evidence Showing That tho Family Rein tions Ware Yer Pleasant NEW BEDFORD Mass June 7The trial of Lizzie Borden was continued to day Jjj V Morse a guest at tho Borden i house at the time of the murder and Brid get Sullivan servant testified The principal point brought out in the exam ination of Miss Sullivan was that the family relations were of the most har monious character there never having been any quarrels The testimony was devoid of new facts At the close of the crossexamination of Bridget Sullivan court adjourned till tomorrow Two Persons round Dead GRAND RAPIDs Mich June 7Walter Gray and Dora Velzey were found dead at noon in the formers room Each had a bullet hole in the head Jealousy on the part of one or the other is supposed to be the cause Indications point to the shooting hay ing been done by the woman She is un
At her murder trial in New Bedford, Assistant District Attorney Moody delivered an opening statement claiming he could prove Lizzie Borden tried to buy poison, burned the dress she wore the morning of the murders, and made contradictory statements. He announced he would call Alice Russell to testify she saw Borden burn the dress three days after the killings, a revelation that reportedly caused Borden to swoon in the dock.
The Roanoke Times · 8 June 1893 · page 1
Contradictory Statements. Nkw Bedford, Mass., June 7.?When Lizzie Borden was held at Kali River last August to await tho action of the grand jury it was hinted that the prosecution had barely sufficient testi? mony to effect the commitment of the prisoner, and that it bad deliberately beld in reservo tho essential evidence in which it relied to secured a capital verdict. That this was so was shown to-day when Assistant District Attorney Moody, In tbe presentation of the case for the government, exhibited tho weapon with which it is claimed tbe butchery of Andrew J. Borden and his wifo was committed, and declared that he would produce a witness in the person of Miss Alice M. Russell, Lizzie Borden's bosom friend, who would swear
District Attorney Moody opens the prosecution's case, outlining the murders of Andrew and Abby Borden and introducing evidence of family discord, Lizzie's alleged premonitions of disaster, and the timeline of Mrs. Borden's death around 9:30 a.m. He also reveals testimony that Lizzie burned a dress worn the morning of the murder, prompting her to faint in the dock.
The Roanoke Times · 8 June 1893 · page 1
which Liz/.ie coased to address her as "mother." That was about five years ago Since then, it is said, tho prisoner bad frequently spoken of Mrs. Borden in the most harsh terms. At this point Mr. Moody introduced a new and sig?
This report recounts District Attorney Moody's opening remarks at trial, detailing the prosecution's reconstructed timeline of the morning Mrs. Borden was killed, including Lizzie's alleged lie about a note and her changing contradictory stories to Bridget and Mrs. Churchill. It emphasizes Lizzie's calm demeanor, her summoning of Miss Russell instead of raising alarm, and her changing into a pink wrapper after the body was discovered.
The Roanoke Times · 8 June 1893 · page 1
note calling her away. "This," said Mr. Moody, "was a lie conceived and asked for the purpose of stifling any inquiry as to Mrs. Borden's where? abouts." Then Lizzie was traced to the kitchen, where she was asked whether she was
A Taunton newspaper had reported that Lizzie Borden's mind was giving way under the strain of imprisonment and the murder charge. Her physician, Dr. Paige, flatly denied this, stating her mind was never clearer, while separately it was reported that seventy witnesses would be called by the prosecution.
Clarke Courier · 8 June 1893 · page 4
A Taunton (Mass.) newspaper stated that Lizzie Borden’s mind is giving way under the terrible strain due to her imprisonment and the charge against her. Dr. Paige, her physician, says: “There is not a word of truth in the story. Miss Borden’s mind was never clearer than it is now.” It is said that seventy wit nesses will be called by the prosecu tion in the Borden case, and inspec tors have been busy at Fall Iiiver summoning them.
On June 7, the defense in Lizzie Borden's trial began questioning witnesses about whether the murderer could have been concealed in a closet. The report notes that the prosecution's evidence presented that day was not especially damaging.
Alexandria Gazette · 8 June 1893 · page 2
NEWS OF THE DAY. Wm. G. Grey, aged twenty-eight years, and ?jiss Dora Yetzey were found dead in a room in a lodging house in Grand Rapids, Mich., yester? day, both shot through the head.* In the trial of Lizzie Borden, at Fall River, Mass., yesterday, the line of de? fence was indicated by calling on wit? nesses to testify that the person who committed the murder might have been couc-aled iu a closet. The evidence agahut Lizzie Borden yesterday was not very damaging.
During the Borden murder trial, witness Alice Russell testified that she saw Lizzie burn a dress in the kitchen stove the Sunday after the murders. She described the dress as a cheap, light blue cotton Bedford cord with a small dark figure, which she had previously seen Lizzie wearing earlier that spring.
Alexandria Gazette · 8 June 1893 · page 2
The Horden Monier Trial. New Bedford, Mass. Junes.?In the Borden murder trial to-day Alice Rus? sell described Lizzie's burning the dross Sunday after the murder. The dress, witness said, was a cheap, light blue cotton Bedford cord, with small dark figure, which witness had once noticed Lizzie wearing in the spring, when new.
On the third day of the Lizzie Borden murder trial, servant Bridget Sullivan testified that Lizzie and her stepmother lived congenially and peacefully together. The courtroom was crowded with curious spectators, mostly women, as Lizzie Borden appeared calm and even smiled while conferring with her attorney Jennings; testimony also covered a civil engineer's demonstration of hiding in a hallway closet.
The Times · 8 June 1893 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
HEARING OF WITNESSES.
BRIDGET SULLIVAN, THE BORDEN'S SERVANT, TESTIFIES.
See moreSee less
She Says Lizzie and Her Step-Mother Lived Congenially and Peacefully. Mr. Morse's Testimony.
NEW BEDFORD, MASS., June 7.--At the opening of the third day of the Borden murder trial this morning the morbid curiosity of the female portion of the community was catered to, and nearly one-half of the spectators were women. Their necks were craned one way as Miss Borden entered the room, looking as unconcerned and fresh as any one possibly could under such trying circumstances.
After she took her seat Jennings had five minutes' conversation with her and she appeared very much interested and animated, a smile breaking out occasionally as the talk proceeded.
Kiennan, the civil engineer, who was on yesterday, was recalled for first witness.
When the witness was making the measurements of the lower floor of the Borden house his attention was called to a closet in the front hall. He was asked if his attention was called to the fact that one could go in there and be hidden with the door completely shut. He described it by saying a man went in and he shut the door on him. There was no difficulty in closing the door. While the man was in there the door was left ajar, and the man in the closet could not have been seen by witness. Witness was eight or ten feet from the closet door at the time and about the same distance from the front of the house. When the witness was near the parlor door his attention was called to the man, but before he had time to verify whether he could see him or not, he moved to the door of the closet and then he did see him. Witness had made experiments as to what could be seen of objects on the floor of guest's room from the stairs. His assistant had lain down on the floor between the bureau and bed; then he (witness) went down stairs and came up in the ordinary way. Said witness: "I saw a man stretched on the floor from the stairs, and the point from which I first saw him was the centre of one of the stairs, which brought my eye just on a level with the floor. A short distance above I could not see him."
The surveyors' and photographers' evidence being concluded John V. Morse took the stand. At first the prisoner watched him carefully with apparent anxiety, then she looked on with the same indifference as heretofore.
At 10:30, on motion of the defense, all the witnesses, except Reporters Manning, Stevens and Caldwell, Messrs. Buck, Jubb and Holmes and those summoned for expert evidence, were ordered to be excluded from the room.
Morse testified that he was a brother of Mrs. Borden, the first. He was cross-examined by ex-Governor Robinson. As bearing on the possibility of an outsider being in the house, the fact was brought out that during the evening before the murder there was no light in the sitting-room, and that, unless the front door was shut hard, the spring-lock would not catch and turning the knob outside would open the door. Morse swore that on reaching the Borden house after the murder he saw no officers in the yard, that the barn door was closed and he heard no one inside. This contradicts the Government's claims that officers, by immediate examination of the barn, ascertained that the prisoner could not have been there at the time of the murder.
The witnesses called after Mr. Morse's examination fixed the time when Mr. Borden was last seen. Cross examination developed nothing but slight confusion and uncertainty as to the exact time. Miss Borden yawned and looked on listlessly.
A buzz of excitement went around the room at 12:30, when Mr. Moody called "Bridget" Sullivan.
She was a servant in the Borden family at the time of the murder. She leaned to the left side against the rail, looked straight at Mr. Moody and spoke so low that he had to tell her to speak louder. The prisoner remained leaning back in the seat, but changed posture so as to see the witness plainly, and watch Bridget steadily with large eyes wide open. All the judges watched Bridget carefully while she testified to bolting the cellar on the inside two days before the murder, to hooking the screen door, to the sickness of the Bordens Wednesday, and to her own conduct, and the locked condition of the doors on Wednesday night and Thursday morning before the murder.
She detailed at length the movements of the various members of the Borden household during the morning of the day of the crime, and described again the scenes when the murders were discovered. As bearing upon the alleged ill-feeling existing between Lizzie Borden and her stepmother, Bridget testified upon cross-examination:
I never had any trouble in the family, and liked the place; I never saw or heard anything out of the way in the family relations, and during my nearly three years of service everything was pleasant. Lizzie and her mother always spoke to each other; I heard them all talking in the sitting-room that morning, and Mrs. Borden asked Lizzie some questions and she answered them civilly and properly. So far as I could see they lived congenially and pleasantly.
Court testimony covers experiments on sightlines in the Borden house, John V. Morse's account of the barn and house security on the night before the murder, and the start of Bridget Sullivan's testimony about her household duties. Morse's testimony conflicts with the prosecution's claim that officers quickly verified the defendant could not have been in the barn.
The Times · 8 June 1893 · page 1
NEW BEDFORD, MASS. June 7.—At
Morse testified that he was a brother of Mrs. Borden, the first, He was cross examined by ex-Governor Robinson, As bearing on the possibility of an outsider being in the house, the fact was brought out that during the evening before the murder there was no light in the gitting room, and that, unless the front door was shut hard, the spring-lock would not catch and turring the knob ontside would open the door. Morse swore that on reaching the Borden house after the murder he saw no officers In the vari, that the barn door was closed and he heard no one inside.
See moreSee less
This contradicts the Government's claims that officers, by Immediate examination of the barn, ascertained that the prisoner could not have been there at the time of the mur der! The witnesses called after Mr. Morse's examination fixed the time when Mr. Borden was last seen. Cross examination developed nothing but slight confusion and uncertainty as to the exact time. Miss Borden yawned and looked on list lessly, A buzz of excitement went around the room at 12:30, when Mr. Moody called “Bridget” Sullivan, She was a servant in the Borden family at the time of the murder. She leaned to the left side against the rail, looked straight at Mr. Moody and spoke so low that he had to tell her to speak louder. The prisoner remained leaning back in the seat, but changed posture so as to see the witness plainly, and watch Bridget steadily with large eyes wide open. All he judges watched Bridget carefully while she testified to bolting the cellar n the inside two days hefore the mur ler, to hooking the screen door, to the sickness of the Bordens Wednesday, and 0 her own conduct, and the locked con lition of the doors on Wednesday night uid Thursday morning before the murder. She detailed at length the movements if the various members of the Borden wousehold during the morning of the day if the crime, and described again the cenes when the murders were discovered, \s bearing upon the alleged ill-feeling ex sting between Lizzie Borden and her tepmother, Bridget testified upon crogs xamination: I never had any trouble in the family, |], nd liked the place; I never saw or ieard anything out of the way in the amily relations, and during my nearly hree years of service everything was
At the Borden murder trial, servant Bridget Sullivan testified about locking doors and windows before the murders and described the family's movements that morning. On cross-examination she stated she never witnessed any discord between Lizzie and her stepmother, describing relations as civil and pleasant.
The long-anticipated trial of Lizzie Borden opened in New Bedford amid large crowds, with jury selection beginning at 10 a.m. Five jurors were chosen by the time of adjournment at 2:53 p.m., with proceedings to continue.
TWELVE MEN WHO WILL PASS UPON LIZZIE BORDEN'S GUILT
Ni.v IiKDFonn, Sines., Juno ti. The on? anticipated Borden murder trial has begun. At ca early hour this morning eory available shady spot on County street near tho court house wns preempted
The report describes the completion of jury selection in the Borden trial, naming the twelve jurors chosen. It then details District Attorney Moody's opening statement, in which he outlined the murders, family tensions, Lizzie's reported premonitions, the alleged prussic acid purchase, and house layout diagrams.
Jecided not to open tho cane to-night, and !ho com t adjourned until t) a. m. to-mor-:ow l.'ZZ E UORDtN SINKS I!oi o ittl IMstrlct ' Alturnnr Mood) 'a Opening Argument, New IltDKoiin, Moss , Juno G. Miss Borden and the jury weio in their feats and :ounsel wero cn hand bunly arranging their piipars. Thedoais wero opaned to specta tors about that time and nt least a third ot those pre-ont wero females. Tho weather was very warm. Tho jury listened to tne t-aJin of the Indictments ngninst Miss Horden ns soon as court was formally open s.i find tliey vera charged by the presiding judge u "good men and trus, st.iud togeth er and liearken to your evidence " District Attorney -Moody then stepped to ,uo railing oud opened the government's Suae.
See moreSee less
He roviowod tho facta of tho murder Oi An ire w Rordtn and wifo cu tho 4th of .ii, duo t npou tho relations that ex isted between L zzie Borden nud l.i r stepmother and the unkindly tee m that tho decision of tho properly "ausad between thtm. Mr. Moody desorib id tuo sudden iliiiojs of Androw Borden, ii wife a id Lizzie on tho Tuesday night pi-' ceain ' tho fatal Thursday while Bridget Su.uvun, the sirvant, was not affected in any way. Ho cited tae atntumout of Miss Borden male to a friend oj the eveuiiiK lie 'ire the murdera committed, to tho effect .hat she (iliss Bordon) felt greatly deprossod Ellll
Prosecutor Moody describes to the jury the household's movements on the morning of the murders, Lizzie's odd behavior, and the locked doors. He also notes Lizzie's prior depression and an alleged attempt to purchase prussic acid before the killings.
Feared Something was Going to Happen. Ite alto aaid there n no iloubt that the person who failed at the drug store on tho lay before tho murders and uuod for prus no acid niuMiss Borden. Mr. ilondy then producod plans of tho LTden house and the locality nud described thorn minutely to the jury. Ho described tho location of the rooms occupied by ilr. and Mrs. Borden, by l.i-zm and by Hmnia, her sister. Mr. Horse stopped ut tho Borden hoiwa on the niht preceding tho truedy. It is important, .Mr.
See moreSee less
Moody raid, to show who uecum-nl the house that night. Ue smd it would be proven that on the night precddmg tho murder tho trout door, back door and cular door wero all irrpiny iastened and that when tae only ircupau's ol th3 housj on that niht, Mr. and lire. Borden, l.izzio, Emma, Bridot Pi illvan and Mr. Morse, had retired, every ox crior approach was closed, He dotailed tho movement" of those in tho Bordon househulJ on tho following morning. Mrs. lio-den about !l o'clock had spokon to liridg t about cionuius somo windows. Mrs. Borusn theu went upstairs to put sorao pd'on cases on the bed la tha spare room, file Noyor I. oil, Ilor Kuoiu Ali Acalri, for no living persou saw her alive aain ox rjpt the aiaspln. When preparing to wash '.ho windows Bridget went to the back door and saw that the prisoner tliero wonc Into ha hou o, la washing tho windows Bridget law neither Mrs, Bordon nor tho prleoner Jurlng ull the tune she was at work. While at work sho heard Mr. Borden nt the front door! it was about 10.15, She wont to the door mid found it locked uud boltd, con trary to custom in that house, bho came io and made n remark about the door, ivhereupon tho prisoner from tho hall above inado some laughing exclamation. At that limo Mrs. Borden's body lay above, dead piobably more than nn hour. The prisoner s ked lior father for the mall, saying at tho id me tuno Mrs. Borden hud ono ou t. Bhe hadano'a and lias (jone lu answer to a rju 'lu That was a iie to stiHj inquiry. Tli pri' oner got her Ironlus board aud went to work and then told Bridget, who was (ibnlu washing windows, the faliohooi about tho no.o, ,S!:o told Hri:lc.ot to be orelul about the doors, as she might r;o jut. Bridget later went up stilrs and thoro Win .Nntliluc Muio Until thu Alarm, The prisoner was tho last pariouleft with W father ulivo. Mr. Moody dtscrlbad
The trial of Lizzie Borden for the murder of her parents began at New Bedford, with sensational courtroom developments on Tuesday involving the burned dress and axe head, and Lizzie showing signs of breaking down. The report notes her friends hope for acquittal while prosecutors express confidence in conviction.
St. Johnsbury Caledonian · 8 June 1893 · page 4
The trial of Lizzie Borden for the murder of her parents, which was begun at New Bedford on Monday, will attract a good deal of attention. There were one or two sensational developments in the court room on Tuesday, in connection with counsel s remarks about the burned dress and the axe head with which the deed was done, and the prisoner showed signs of breaking down. Oppor tunity will now be given for the fulfillment of the hope which Miss Borden's friends cherish the hope
A miscellany column surveys the week's news, noting an 'epidemic of horrors' including murders at Fall River, Natick, and Clarenceville and a revival of public interest in the Borden tragedy. It lumps this in with unrelated items like a women's suffrage bill in Michigan and plans for a world's fair in Belgium.
St. Johnsbury Caledonian · 8 June 1893 · page 4
Arrangements are now being made for exhibits covering all departments of agriculture, arts and commerce, and the classification of articles in cludes 66 groups. There has been a veritable epidemic of horrors the past week. What with the murders at Fall River. Natick, and Clarenceville, P. Q., and the revival of public interest in the ghastly Borden tragedy, the chapter is a strikingly black one. The removal of Jeff Davis' body to Richmond has given the papers con siderable to talk about the past week. Most people had an idea he was finally disposed of a good while ago.
A roundup of the week's national and international news notes that the Lizzie Borden trial began Monday at New Bedford. It also reports she nearly fainted during District Attorney Moody's opening statement on Tuesday.
St. Johnsbury Caledonian · 8 June 1893 · page 8
RECORD OF THE WEEK.
The trial ot Lizzie Borden was begun at New Bedford Two trains were wrecked near Leeper Station, Mo., involving the loss ot a hundred head of valuable live stock, the in-
The Seattle Post-Intelligencer · Seattle, Wash. Terr. Wash.
The report covers the continuation of Lizzie Borden's murder trial in New Bedford, noting testimony from house guest J.V. Morse and servant Bridget Sullivan. Both witnesses emphasized that the Borden family relations were harmonious, with no prior quarrels reported.
The Seattle Post-Intelligencer · 8 June 1893 · page 2
SIOO,OOO. The Bordea Harder Trial. NEW BEDFORD, Mass., June 7.— The trial of Lizzie Borden was continued today. J. V. Morse, a guest at Borden's at the time ot the murder, and Bridget Sullivan, the servant, testified. The principal point brought out in the examination of Miss Sullivan was that the family relations were of the most harmonious character, and there never had been any quarrels. The testimony was devoid of any new facta.
The report covers the third day of Lizzie Borden's murder trial, focusing on housekeeper Bridget Sullivan's testimony, which seemed favorable to the defendant since Miss Borden's dress reportedly had no blood on it that morning. John V. Morse also testified about his movements on the morning of the murders, describing breakfasting with the Bordens and leaving via the screen door.
Wheeling Register · 8 June 1893 · page 1
Miss Borden. Mr. Kiernan, tho civil engineer who was on yesterday, was re-called and measurements of tho Borden premises and surroundings occupied the jury’s attention. The surveyor’s and photo grapher’s evidence being concluded, John V. Morsetook the stand. At first the prisoner watched him carefully witbapparent anxiety, then looking on with the same iudifference as hereto fore. At 10:30, on motion of defense, all witnesses, except reporters and tho#o summoned for expert evidence, were or dered excluded from tho room. Morse testified that he parsed the night in the guest harnber, where Mrs.
See moreSee less
Borden was subsequently found dead; he breakfasted with the Bordens and loft the house by the screen door, Mr. Bordon golug out with him. When ne . _J .... V. Ar*,*A Kn/^inu icvui ugu nu vlikj **v u.ju *mv --- bad been discovered. He saw the body of Mrs. Borden first. “I went up stairs,” he said, "and un under the bed in which 1 had been sleeping, I found Mrs. Borden. There was blood on her face. 1 saw Miss Liz zie Borden when I returned.” That was the first time he had seen her since his arrival the day before. Cross-examined by ex-Governor Rob inson, he said it was about 11:40 that he returned to the Borden house on the morning of the murder. He approached the house from the rear. The street is' a busy one. He saw no policemen in the yar;d. The barn door was closed, and he heard no one Inside. This con tradicts the commonwealth’s allegaI tion that the police, by Immediate ex- ! aminatiou of the barn, ascertained that the prisoner could not have been in the barn at the time of the murder. Morse tola how the police had searched the house, and he had helped them. They found some axes, but he could not identify them now. At this point a recess of five minutes was taken. While the witness was testifying Miss Borden regarded him with hardly a casual iuterest. She chewed on the ring on the end of her fan. During the recess Miss Borden chat ted with M. O. Adams, one of her coun sel. During the course of her conver sation with him she laughed, and at that time appeared to bo In a cheerful frame of mind. The young woman was telling her counsel of a mistake made by Mor«e in bis statement of tho time her mother died. When that had been put straight on the record Morse was excused. Miss Borden also conversed earnestly with ex-Governor Robinson, while she nervously fingered her smelling salts. A buzz of excitement went around the room when Mr. Moody called "Bridget Sullivan.” She was dressed fashionably, and leaned to the left side of the rail, j looked straight at Moody, and spoke so 1 low that he had to tell her to speak | louder. All the Judges watched BrldI get carefully while she testified to 1 bolting the cellar door on the inside two days before the murder, to hooking the , screen door, to the sickness of the Bor deds Wednesday and to her own con duct, and to the locked condition of the doors on Wednesday night and Thurs day morning before the murder. Mr. Moody asked the witness to de scribe the dress worn by Miss Borden on the morning of the murder. She thought it was of light blue material with a dark blue sprig on it. "The dress maker who made ft is the same one that made Miss Lizzie s dresses
John V. Morse testified at trial about discovering Mrs. Borden's body under the bed in the guest chamber and described his movements that morning, including returning to the house around 11:40. His testimony that he saw no police near the barn and heard no one inside contradicted the prosecution's claim about the barn being searched immediately.
Bridget Sullivan, the Borden household maid, testified about locked doors, the household's illness, and Lizzie's dress on the morning of the murders. She described discovering Mrs. Borden's body upstairs after being sent to fetch help following Mr. Borden's murder.
The Daily Herald · Brownsville, Tex. · and 2 other papers
The report reconstructs Lizzie Borden's account of her movements the morning of the murders, noting she claimed to remove her father's boots though a photograph showed he still had them on. It details the discovery of Mrs. Borden's body upstairs and notes the autopsy showed she died well before Mr. Borden, with no weapon yet found.
The Daily Herald · 9 June 1893 · page 2
LIZZIE BORDEN'S TRIAL
Mrs Borden Lizzie knew nothing of her whereabouts but called to mind the taeUhat her stepmothei had told her previously that she had received a note irom a friend aud in response was intending to call ou that friend However Bridget was requested to look for her mistress but she objected to going alone aud Mrs Churchill went with her Ab the two women approached the top ot the stairs leading to the second floor they saw on the floor of the guest chamber the body ot Mrs Borden It was soon learned that bhe too had been murdered in about the same manner as her husband viz With severalblows from some htavy sharp instrument probably an axe or a hatchet It was definitely determined at nn autopsy subsequently held that Mr3 Bo den had been killed some time before her husband It ap pears to have been shown that liere was uu one about thehousc T53WPM 5pv STP n r < tu iNO 29 v all the morning but members of familv at intervals It is claimed aide to do so aud walked quietly that about the time Mrs Burden to her place in the prisoners dock z met her death in the guest chain The conrt having been duly open ber on the north side of the house ed the task of securing a jury bo the servant was washing ou the gan the prisoner as is the law of doors on the south side of the Massachusetts challenging in per house It has been demonstrated son whenever prompted by her conclusively that the death of Mrs counsel m Borden occurred in a very short At 445 the jury wascompletcd time after he entered the house and the court adjourned until and if Lizzies story ie correct morning someone did it while she was in Cut This Out the barn while Bridget was in the Afclinta Constitution yard and while Mrs Bordens life The veteran editor of the New less body was laying in the room York Journal of Commerce pays above her husband Nobody was editorial tribute to tho medical seen to enter the house No in strument has been discovered which prescription which has come to be tits the case but the government kuuwu as the Sun cholera mixture claim and will attempt to prove and the Constitution desires to join that circumstantial evidence points iis esteemed contemporary in mak to Lizzie A Borden as the mur ingthe remedy known deress and that the evidence is Mr Stone says that the remedy suflieiently strong to convict was given to the pTblie by the Snu Miss Burden wag arrested two more than twenty years ago but weeks after the minder and has this is a slip of the penor the types It was given the public more than since been hold in the Tannton jail except a few days during the forty years ago and since that timo preliminary hearing before Judge it has done a world ot good not only in cholera epidemics but in Blaisdell at the close of which she all derangement that possess the was held for the action of the cholera symptoms n cases of grand jury cholera morbus aud in dangerous On Tuesday November 15 the attacks ot diarrheal grand jury met at Tunutun and a The prescription was drawn up largo number of witnesses wore by a numberof eminent physicians examined On the lSth he jury went to ot New York published in the Suns editorial columns This face Fall River and viewed the pre Jias given the rcincdv the name of mises and was dismissed the fol Sun cholera mixture Tiie ditur of lowing Monday to ait again De the Journal of Commerce lias seen cember 1 it in constant use fur nearly two On Friday December 2 indict sjore years and found it to be the ments were found against Miss boat remedy for bowel troubles Borden charging her with the mnr yet demised To this he addc Nu deis an indictment was also found one who has this by hjui and takes against others who were charged it in time will ever have the with conspiracy to defeat the ends cholera of justice This latter indictment The writer of this has seen this was drawn up by a Taunton law remedy employed for more than yer and also by Assistant District Attorney liurd ofBoston tVenty years and it has never On the 8th of May Miss Borden failed case of bowel trouble when was brought to Now Bedford and taken promptly He has Been it and arraigned pleading not guilty give Almost instant relief in the to the indictments She was iak discasealmost as violent as genuine cholera wind ensues when the on back to tho Taunton jail where she became seriously ill because of deviled crab and the milk punch a cold caught while going to aud meet in the bosom of the areles3 from New Bedford and for a time epicure It is a remedy that ought to be in everyiiousehoid whether was in a dangerous condition Ou Saturday last she was again there is danger from cholera or not brought here to be in readuess for This is the prescription her trial Take equal parts of tincture of Sheriff Wright made all the pre cayenne pepper tincture oiopium tincture ot rhubarb essense of pep parationB he could to handle tho permintand spirits of camphor crowds he knew would beabout the Mix will Dose iifteen to thirty court house aud struggle to get fn drops in a cold water according to All available policemen were press age and violence of symptoms re ed into service inside and ontsido peated every fifteen or twenty the building They had their minutes until relief is obtained hands full It will do no harm if hi equal Duriug tho present Chief part of fine brandy is added to tlie Justice Mason will preside Vest in violet cases of cholera m or His associates will be Justice Blod bus or genuine cholera it is best tb l gett and Dewey prepare two doses so that if til s1 It was just li oclock when a first is thrown off the stomach the closed carriage drew up at the rear second can be given immediately of the court house A deputy There need be no fear of collapse sheriff stepped out of it and hand when this raedieiue is ed out hishand to assist Lizzie Bor given promptly den The crowd pressed foi ward in a sort of frenzy to catch a glimpse of Subscribe tor The Heuald the woman but she slipped quietly
The Russellville Democrat · Russellville, Ark. · 8 June 1893
The Green Forest Tribune · Green Forest, Ark. · 15 June 1893
The Willimantic Journal · Willimantic, Conn. · and 1 other paper
Prosecutor Moody began the government's case against Lizzie Borden at the New Bedford trial. After one witness testified, court adjourned and the jury traveled to Fall River to view the scene of the double murder.
The Willimantic Journal · 9 June 1893 · page 8
Borden trial at New Bedford. After one witness had been examined the court ad journed. and the Jury went to Fall River, where they viewed the scene of the double
Griggs Courier · Cooperstown, Dak. N.D. · and 3 other papers
The trial of Lizzie Borden for the murder of her father and mother began at New Bedford, Massachusetts, on the 5th. The report is a brief item within a roundup of national news.
The Worthington Advance · Worthington, Minn. · 8 June 1893
Warren Sheaf · Warren, Minn. · 8 June 1893
River Falls Journal · River Falls, Wis. · 8 June 1893
Paper unidentified
The report describes courtroom proceedings at New Bedford, noting Lizzie Borden's haggard appearance as the trial resumed. Witnesses Thomas Kiernan testified about sightlines to Mrs. Borden's body from the staircase, and John V. Morse described Lizzie's movements the night before the murders.
Paper unidentified · 9 June 1893 · page 1
What Happened in the Borden Home Before the Murder. The famous Borden mnrder trial was resumed immediately after the opening of the Criminal court at New Bedford, Maas., yesterday morning. The appearance of the prisoner, only one short year ago a bright handsome girl, now a pale, haggard and care worn looking woman, was the signal for a general movement on the part of the curiosity seekers among the au dience, who moved hastily forward to catch a glimpse of the famous pris oner. Miss Borden’s personal appearance on entering the court room told more clearly than words could have done of the terrible strain of the previous day.
See moreSee less
She was pale, listless and evidently nervous. Taking a seat she glanced swiftly over the court room, taking in rapidly the various objects which met her gaze. Thomas Kiernan was the first wit ness. He made the measurements of the house and the room where the bodies were discovered. He testified to the view of Mrs. Borden’s body from the top of the stairway, saying it could be seen from that point. This was to show that the prisoner could not have failed to see the body from the place where she stood on the morning of the tragedy and called her father, as he 'was entering, that her mother had gone out. Mr. Kier nan said the body could not be seen from Miss Borden’s room. John V. Morse was the next wit ness. He is an uncle of the prisoner and brother of the first Mrs. Borden. He was a guest of the Bordens the night preceding the tragedy* That night Lizzie went out somewhere, and he heard some one come in and go to her room. He slept that night in the room where Mrs. Borden’s body was found. As be entered the cham ber he noticed that Lizzie’s was closed. It was closed when he went down the next morning, lie ate breakfast with the family and left at 8.58 with Mr. Borden. When he re turned later both the Bordens were dead. Cross-examined by the defense the witness declared he did not know who the mysterious person was who en tered the house the night before the murder and went to Miss Borden’s room. The person did not speak, but he presumed it was Lizzie. When the witness was testifying Miss Borden regarded him with only a casual interest. She chatted with one of her counsel and laughed softly to herself. The defense grabbed eagerly at the suggestion that a stranger might have entered the Borden residence and hid until the next day. In support of this theory counsel brought out the fact that the front door latched with difficulty, and might have been unintentionally left open that night. Morse also helped tho defense by saying that he saw no officers in the yard after he came back the morning of the murders, and that the barn was closed. This contradicted the government’s claim that officers, by immediate ex amination of the barn, ascertained that the prisoner could not have been there at the time of the murder. Bridget Sullivan, the servant of the Borden household, was the next im portant witness. She said the night before the murder she returned home from a visit at 10:15 and thought all the doors were securely locked. She drank some milk and in the morning was sick. She heard nothing during the night. The doors were not open when she went down stairs and noth ing seemed to have been disturbed. A recess was then taken.
Witnesses testified about house measurements and sightlines, with Thomas Kiernan stating Mrs. Borden's body was visible from the stairway. John Morse and Bridget Sullivan gave accounts of the night before and morning of the murders, with the defense highlighting a mysterious nighttime visitor and an unlocked door to suggest an intruder theory.
At the Lizzie Borden trial in New Bedford, witnesses John V. Morse and servant Bridget Sullivan testified, with Sullivan's testimony emphasizing that the Borden family relations were harmonious and free of quarrels. The report notes no significant new facts emerged before court adjourned for the day.
Arizona Republican · 9 June 1893 · page 1
THEIR RELATIONS PLEASANT. Lizzie Borden and Her Family Had No Trouble. New Hkdfoiii), Maps., June 8. Asso ciated Press. The trial of Lizzie Bor den was continued today. J. V. Morse,
The report describes a police officer's long-kept secret about an axe found in the Borden house on the day of the murders, believed to be the weapon used. His detailed, credible description has convinced many that the true murder weapon has finally been identified, unsettling some of Lizzie Borden's supporters.
Morning Journal and Courier · 9 June 1893 · page 3
COVERED WITH ASHES
regarding the axe found la the) Borden bouse, supposed to have been toed in the murder. For many weeks stories about the faatohet and axes have been published, bat daring all the long ten months that have passed he baa scrupulously kept the secret that the probable weapon was found the daj the famous butchery was dlaooTeresL ... Hla description of the weapon was so exaos, so minute, nis reputation lor vera city and honorable dealing In police and private elrolee la sach, that the people be lieve he has found the weapon with which the deeda were committed. Many of Mine Borden' friends feel-much eiereleed oyer the testimony.
This is a furniture and carpet advertisement for P.J. Kelly & Co. that uses the headline 'LIZZIE BORDEN'S TRIAL' purely as an attention-grabbing hook, unrelated to actual trial content. The ad copy that follows discusses carpets, furniture, and home furnishings with no connection to the Borden case.
Morning Journal and Courier · 9 June 1893 · page 3
The report describes a day at Lizzie Borden's trial in New Bedford, including a chaotic rush for courtroom seats and Dr. Bowen's testimony denying he ever said Mrs. Borden died from fright. Cross-examination revealed Bowen had prescribed morphine to Lizzie Borden in increasing doses before and after her arrest.
Morning Journal and Courier · 9 June 1893 · page 3
Ansoaa; miea Borden's Friends I Fall River. jr. Nsw -'BiDyoBD, Mass., "June 8: 4he courthouse was opened for the trial of Lizzie Borden before tbe regular time this morning," and at the main entranoe the women who had swallowed their breakfasts hurriedly or dispensed with them entirely made suoh a rush to secure places that the two blue-coated local policemen were car ried oS their feet and whirled along with the orowd notil several deputy sheriffs jumped down to their rescue and turned the tide. The result was that the pushers were kept oat entirely, while those who acted in a fairly decent manner were al lowed the privilege of struggling for seats inside.
See moreSee less
Miss Borden was in her seat fifteen minutes before the court came in and ea gerly looted over the oontenta of a big, official-looking envelope whioh she after wards passed to Governor Robinson. All her counsel were early on hand, and the jurymen were In their seats before counsel Ior the prosecution appeared. The Brat witness called for to-day was Ifrs-Chnrohill, the previous call for Dr. Bowen haying been rescinded, bnt as she was not present, Br. Bowen was pat on. He stated nothing new in the dlreot ex amination except to deny that he had ever said that Mrs. Borden died from fright or in a faint. Cross examination by Mr.
A roundup of national and world news items for June 8, 1893, includes a brief mention that Lizzie Borden's trial for the murder of her father and stepmother began at New Bedford. The item is one line among many unrelated news briefs from that day.
The Willimantic Journal · 9 June 1893 · page 8
Monday, June 8. The trial of Lizzie Borden, charged with the murder of her father and stepmother at Fall River, began at New Bedford-The Rev. Dr. Lyman Abbott of Brooklyn up held the views of Dr. BriggB and severely criticised the Presbyterian general assem bly which suspended him from the minis try-Jose Carreiro, a Portuguese, is un der arrest in Fall River for the murder of Bertha Manchester, and the police believe they have sufficient evidence to convict him-The Rev. Dr. James H. Ecob of Al bany will withdraw from the Presby terian church as a result of the de cision in the Briggs case-Owing to a storm less than 60,000 persons vis ited the World’s fair, which was opened yesterday-A speculator on the Chicago board of trade hanged himself with the cord of his smoking jacket-The
The report covers the fifth day of the Lizzie Borden trial in New Bedford, focusing on Dr. Bowen's testimony that he prescribed morphine to Lizzie before and after her arrest, which could affect memory and cause hallucination. Bridget Sullivan was recalled and cross-examined again, denying she saw Lizzie in tears after being called downstairs.
Waterbury Evening Democrat · 9 June 1893 · page 1
LIZZIE BORDEN'S TRIAL. Another Interesting Day in the Famous Case.
a place of advantage in the line. The proceedings of ihe day give promise of being as interesting as those of yes terday. Yesterday the first witness called for was Mrs. Churchill, the previous call for Dr. Bowen having been rescinded, but she not being present, Dr. Bowen was put on. Dr. Bowen stated nothing new in the direct examination, except to deny that ha had evet said Mrs. Borden died of fright or in a faint. Cross-exaratnat on by Adams
Witnesses testify about the dress Lizzie allegedly burned, with police noting confusion over its whereabouts when they searched the house. Officer Allen and reporter Cunningham describe examining the Borden property, including locked doors, lack of footprints, and a bloody handkerchief near Mrs. Borden's body.
Waterbury Evening Democrat · 9 June 1893 · page 1
seeiDg Officer Alien going towards the Borden house. He went up afterwards with Walter P. Stevens, ef the Fall River News, and John Manning, of the Globe, and examined the grass in the Borden yard for footprints. They tried the cellar door and found it was locked. This is consid ered Important for the prosecution, as showing that there was no way to get into the house by the oellar. W itness said that when he and the re porters went to the house they jumped over the fence, and then peered about for footprints, they saw none, not even by the pear trees, in all the yard.
See moreSee less
Officer ueorge W. Allen, of the Fall River police force, said he was sent to the Borden house at 11:13 on the morning of the 4th. He described the manner in which he went, and about enlisting Mr. Sawyer for an outside guard, lie saw Lizzie at the table in the kitchen, and he also saw the body of Mr. Borden. He saw that the front door was locked with a night-lock and a bolt. Witness saw a clothes-press in the kitchen and looked into it. When he went to the station and reported to the marshal, ha had not heard of Mrs. Borden's death. He detailed his coming again and his searches through the house and his finding the cellar door locked on the inside, or bolted. Witness said that when he saw the body of Mrs. Borden there was a small
Witnesses testify about discovering Mrs. Borden's body, including a locked cellar door, a bloody handkerchief found on the guest room floor, and the condition of blood near both victims. A deputy sheriff describes arriving at the scene and comparing the wounds and blood state on both Mr. and Mrs. Borden, declining to offer an opinion on which died first.
Waterbury Evening Democrat · 9 June 1893 · page 1
seeiDg Officer Alien going towards the Borden house. He went up afterwards with Walter P. Stevens, ef the Fall River News, and John Manning, of the Globe, and examined the grass in the Borden yard for footprints. They tried the cellar door and found it was locked. This is consid ered Important for the prosecution, as showing that there was no way to get into the house by the oellar. W itness said that when he and the re porters went to the house they jumped over the fence, and then peered about for footprints, they saw none, not even by the pear trees, in all the yard.
See moreSee less
Officer ueorge W. Allen, of the Fall River police force, said he was sent to the Borden house at 11:13 on the morning of the 4th. He described the manner in which he went, and about enlisting Mr. Sawyer for an outside guard, lie saw Lizzie at the table in the kitchen, and he also saw the body of Mr. Borden. He saw that the front door was locked with a night-lock and a bolt. Witness saw a clothes-press in the kitchen and looked into it. When he went to the station and reported to the marshal, ha had not heard of Mrs. Borden's death. He detailed his coming again and his searches through the house and his finding the cellar door locked on the inside, or bolted. Witness said that when he saw the body of Mrs. Borden there was a small stand upon which were two books and a small oil lamp, about three feet away, but there was no marks of blood on the books or the stand. He noticed a bloody hand kerchief on the guest chamber floor, lying about midway between the body and the wall. Cross-examination failed to bring out anything of importance. Francis H. Wixon, deputy sheriff of Bristol county, said he was at the Central police station, arriving there about 11:01, He heard the city bell ringing when he was eighty feet away from the police station. When he had been there ten or fifteen mia utes the city marshal was called to the telephone; then he went by witness and gave some orders to somebody. Then Officer Allen cam in and told the marshal something. After learning what the trouble witness went to the Borden houe and thought he got there about 11:45. He looked at Ms. Borden and saw wouuds ou his fac ; they were many, aud the blood w is brihs colored suit lresli. , He saw Mr. . liorUen abd said the blood w is dark and coagulated Witness said he - had no opinion as' -to which ef the two had btea 10114 fire! At wm et aa eiMrt.
At the New Bedford trial, witnesses including Dr. Bowen, Bridget Sullivan, Mrs. Churchill, and Alice Russell testified, and prosecutors introduced a dark, blood-covered handkerchief found near Mrs. Borden's body that appeared partially burned. The defense countered by noting no bloodstains had been found on any of Lizzie's dresses as the prosecution claimed.
The Morning Call · 9 June 1893 · page 1
TIGHTENING THE COILS. The First Great Blow Dealt to Lizzie Borden. New , Bedfoki>, Mass., June B.— An im mense crowd was present at the IJorden
The item observes that the New York Herald portrayed trial evidence as damaging to Lizzie Borden, while the New York Sun characterized the same evidence as favorable to her and harmful to the prosecution. It notes both papers are providing extensive trial coverage, appealing to public interest in criminal cases.
Evening Journal · 9 June 1893 · page 2
The newspaper debate on the events of the trial of Lizzie Borden has already begun. The New York Herald corres pondent reported the Inoidentn and evi dence of the trial as damaging to
The Wilmington Daily Republican · Wilmington, Del.
Reporters describe a chaotic scene of women crowding for courtroom seats as the Borden trial continues, with testimony from Dr. Bowen, Bridget Sullivan, Mrs. Churchill, and Alice Russell. Officers testify about searching the premises, finding the cellar door locked, and producing the handleless hatchet as evidence.
The Wilmington Daily Republican · 9 June 1893 · page 1
THE CELLAR DOOR WAS LOCKED
II lot or Paint. New Bedford, Mass., June 9.—When the court house opeuod yesterday the in quisitive females made of the prettiest rushes outsido of college prem ises, The two blue coated representatives ft of police wero carried offjtheir feet local whirled along with the resistless pot ticoeted surge from below until several deputy sheriffs jumped down to their and turned the tide. The result was that the pushers were kept out entirely, while those who acted in a fairly decent allowed the coveted privilege manner of fighting for seats iusidc. Dr. Bowen the stand. He put stated nothing in tho direct examinn tion>xoept to deny that he had Mrs, Borden died of fright ln a faint. Crois examination by Mr. Adams brought
The Wilmington Daily Republican · Wilmington, Del.
Assistant Marshal Fleet testified at trial about finding the handleless hatchet and searching the Borden house, including locked doors and blood spots found in the guest room. He also described obtaining keys from Lizzie and Maggie to search Mr. and Mrs. Borden's rooms.
The Wilmington Daily Republican · 9 June 1893 · page 1
it, mid we went in and searched tho "III the guest's chamber I noticed there blood on the dressing case and some the pillows. There was another door leading from ber room, which was locked, but Lizzie got a key and let us in. We searched tho room. When we asked to get into Mr. Borden's room and shctold to get the koy from Maggie, I went down d got the key from Maggie and she showed us in there. I asked Lizzie when she had seen her stepmother last, and she said when she was in her room making Ibe bed.
See moreSee less
She told me also about the which she had received." Officer Fleet, in his cross-examination, said that he thought he could have blood on the clothes he examined if any hnd been there. If there had been any paint there he believed he could not have it unless he looked closely. Fall Rivku, June 9.—The sensation in
This report details witness testimony given at Lizzie Borden's trial reconstructing the morning of August 4, 1892, including Morse's breakfast with the Bordens and his departure, Lizzie's solitary breakfast, and Bridget Sullivan's movements. It describes Andrew Borden's return home, Lizzie's claim that Mrs. Borden had left to visit a sick friend, and Bridget going upstairs to rest as the town clock struck eleven.
New-York Tribune · 9 June 1893 · page 2
? fn the Borden house; that the night passed without incident; that the next morning at about ‘6 o'clock Morse arose, dressed and came down stairs into the sitting-room, where toward 7 o'clock he was joined by Mr. and Mrs. Borden. Bridget meanwhile had been busying herself in the kitchen, and shortly after 7 o'clock Morse and Mr. and Mrs. Borden took breakfast together. Just before 9 o'clock Morse went down town, and after that time he never again saw Mr. and Mrs. Borden alive. Just after Morse went out Lizzie made her appearance, got her own breakfast, and ate it.
See moreSee less
Mr. Borden st a quarter past 9 went down town, leeving Mrs. Borden dusting in the sittingroom, Lizzie eating in the dining-room, and Bridget outside of the house washing windows. From this time Mrs. Borden disappears from sight. Bridget saw her last when she (Bridget) left the sitting-room to go for the water wherewith to wash fhe windows. From time to time Bridget saw Lizzie moving about, apparently engazéd in the performance of household duties. At a quarter to 11 Mr. Borden reached his home. He was let in by Bridget, Lizzie being then upstairs, where Bridget heard her laughing. She came down, met her father, and told him that Mrs. Borden had gone out, having received a note from a sick friend. Mr. Borden took a seat in the sitting-toom near the window. Lizzie went into the dining-room and began to iron some handkerchiefs. Bridget, who was feeling ill, having finished her work on the windows, went upstairs to her own room in the attic, where she lay down on her bed, hearing, as she did so, the town clock strike 11. Fifteen minutes later Bridget heard Lizzie’s voice calling to her to come down stairs quickly, as somebody had hurt her father. Bridget came down, and saw Mr. Borden lying on the sofa in the sittingroom, the Iflood running from great gashes in his head. Bridget ran out, at Lizzie's comwand, to find a doctor. When she returned the doctor was already there, together with several neighbors. Bridget says that Lizzie told her that she (Lizzie) was out in the barn when the murder occurred. Lizzie also said to Bridget and others that she thought she had heard Mrs. Borden come in and go u stairs, Thereupon Bridgét and Mrs. Churchill, a neighbor, went upstairs and found Mrs. Borden's dead body in the guest-chamber, which Morse had occupied the night before. This was the case of the prosecution when the court assembled to-day.
The report recounts the prosecution's narrative of events on the morning of the murders, based on Bridget Sullivan's account, including Lizzie's movements and the discovery of the bodies. It also profiles the defense team, praising ex-Governor Robinson and the fairness of the trial proceedings.
New-York Tribune · 9 June 1893 · page 2
A BRILLIANT ARRAY OF COUNSEL. The gratifying fact about this trial is ite fairmess. ‘Tha Court has practically had nothing to do. Not the faintest dust-fleck has fallen from the bench upon the jury to the advantage or disadvantage of State or prisoner. Miss Borden's lawyers are deserving of the highest eredit for their conduct of her cause. Their methods ara honorable and high-minded, and it cannot b»
This report describes the opening days of Lizzie Borden's trial, highlighting the fairness of the court and the skill of her defense team led by ex-Governor Robinson. It also assesses prosecutor Moody's tactics and praises the intelligence of the witnesses called so far.
New-York Tribune · 9 June 1893 · page 2
A BRILLIANT ARRAY OF COUNSEL.
Not the faintest dust-fleck has fallen from the bench upon the jury to the advantage or disadvantage of State or prisoner. Miss Borden's lawyers are deserving of the highest eredit for their conduct of her cause. Their methods ara honorable and high-minded, and it cannot b» doubted that they have Produced a favorable fmpression of the cause w ich admits of them. Her leading attorney is one of the ablest lawyers in New-England. Ex-Governor Rebinson has heen three times Chief of the Commonwealth ‘of Massachusetts, and is distinguished in a State where eminence has to be earned, and where many are born capable of earning it, for his eloquence, lus keen intellect and his ready wit.
See moreSee less
He has two colleagues, one of whom i a young Boston lawyer, Mr. Adams, who has rapidly grown popular and has achieved notable successes. Mr. Jennings, who is associated with them, has Jong becn the family attorney of the Bordens, and gives to (Lizzie's case a measure
This roundup of domestic and foreign news briefly notes that prosecution testimony continued in the Lizzie Borden murder trial at New Bedford, Mass. It is listed among many other unrelated news items of the day, including the Home Rule bill debate and a Fargo fire.
New-York Tribune · 9 June 1893 · page 6
THE NEWS THIS MORNING.
Eulalie paid her first visit to the World's Far going to the grounds in the afternoon and again in the evening. State Senator Charles E. — Walker, of Corning, is dead. === Testimony for the prosecution was continued in the trial of Lizzie Borden for murder at New-Bedford, Mase.
The report reflects on the Borden murder trial's remarkable features: its rapid procedural pace, the horrific and inexplicable nature of the crime, and the prosecution's reliance on a method of exclusion rather than direct evidence. It notes that circumstantial evidence is minimal and could be challenged by the defense.
New-York Tribune · 9 June 1893 · page 6
THE BORDEN MURDER TRIAL. The Borden murder trial is remarkable from soveral points of view. [It is conspionons for rapidity of procedure, the jury having heen obtained withont difficulty and the Witnesses having told their stories in quick Secession, There is a busine slike directness in the court proceedings that is highly creditable to the Then the case | Massachusetts bench and bar. is unique in its horror and mystery, Lizzie Borden is charged with the unnatural and in-
This editorial analyzes the prosecution's case against Lizzie Borden, noting it relies on circumstantial evidence and a process of elimination rather than direct evidence. It compares this method to medical diagnosis by exclusion and criticizes it as a weak basis for criminal conviction, arguing the law typically disfavors theories of exclusive opportunity.
New-York Tribune · 9 June 1893 · page 6
THE BORDEN MURDER TRIAL.
This is a method frequently employed by physicians in diagnosing diseases. They exclude one cause after another until only one explanation remains. That also is the process adopted by Henry George in the most widdly circulated of his books, a large number of posible causes of poverty being argued down and the land question being tinally aceeptod as the only theory that 8 tenable. [It is hy this process of exclusion that the jury will be asked to believe that Lizzie Borden murdered her stepmother, changed her gown, went on with her ironing, killed her father and put on a third dress before calling the servant and sending for the doctor and the neighbors, The prosecution has begun by bolting and locking all the outside doors of the Borden house in order to prove that no murderer could have got in from the street or yard.
See moreSee less
Then it has demonstrated that Lizzie Borden was the last
The report describes the fourth day of Lizzie Borden's trial, noting that evidence presented by the prosecution increasingly points toward her guilt, though still tentatively. It also describes her demeanor as brighter and more cheerful despite the damaging testimony, and begins to recount her background as an unmarried 33-year-old woman accused of hacking her family.
New-York Tribune · 9 June 1893 · page 1
SCENES IN THE COURTROOM. [BY TELEGRAPR TO THE TRIBUNE.) New-Bedtord, Mass., June 8.—~The fourth day of Lizzie Borden’s trial has ended, and from the vaghe and unshagrely mass of evidence produced ' by the prosecution, the finger of accusation points still more directly at the prisoner. But it still points timidly, as if it were not sure of itself and us if it did not wholly like the responsibility it takes in asking a verdict against her. The day has been sool and heantiful. The grass om the little lawn in front of the courthouse and the fine old elms that arch the pathway leading | to its Corinthian portico were deliciously fresh and green.
See moreSee less
Perhaps it is a glance of their glad humor that has brightened Lizzie Borden. I$ must have been some other influence than any that the evidence could have given birth te, Innocent or guilty, it was painful enough, Ine nocent, she must still have thought it had an ugly sound. Guilty, her conscience must have { imparted to its suggestive details a meaning even more terrible than they conveyed to other minds than fers. But wherever it came from, or whatever it is, something made Lizzie Borden lrighter and stronger to-day than she has been at any time since she was first confronted with ® jury.
A journalist describes Lizzie Borden's demeanor and appearance during the trial, noting her calm, mostly impassive composure in court. The reporter analyzes her facial features in detail, finding her upper face delicate and womanly but her jaw, mouth, and chin coarse and almost masculine, suggesting capability for the crime.
New-York Tribune · 9 June 1893 · page 1
A SOMEWHAT UNWOMANLY FACE
Her countenance is naturally heavy. At the brow it starts well. Her forehead is Jow bu$ shapely, and her eyes are large and clear. She has pretty ears, small and delicate and held closely to her head. Her nose is straight, and if i might be dissociated from the heavy jaws, the wide mouth and the thick, long and somewhat protrude ing lips beneath it, it could be called sensitive. That which makes Lizzie Borden's a coarse facd
The report opens with a vivid description of courtroom procedure and ceremony as the Borden trial proceeds. It then recaps Wednesday's testimony, noting that prosecution witnesses John V. Morse and Bridget Sullivan had recounted the known facts of the murders of August 3, 1892, as far as anyone besides Lizzie herself knew them.
New-York Tribune · 9 June 1893 · page 1
WHAT WEDNESDAY’S EVIDENCE SHOWED. Four important witnesses were examined to. day. During yesterday's session the prosecution, principally by means of Lizzie’s uncle, John V, Morse, and Bridget Sullivan, the cook, had recited the story of the murder so far as it is known te anybody except Lizale herself. The evidenocs proved or tended to prove that on_.the night of August 3, 1892, Mr. and Mrs. Borden, Mr. Morse,
At the New Bedford trial, witnesses including John Cunningham, Officer Allen, and Deputy Sheriff Wixom testified about searching the Borden premises after the murders, confirming the cellar door was locked. Assistant Marshal Fleet then described finding a handleless hatchet in a cellar box, noting a fresh break on the handle fragment and ash covering the iron head.
Evening Star · 9 June 1893 · page 11
THE BORDEN MURDER CASE
Bowen. Miss Russell and Miss Sullivan pamin =.: up 2d street, and remembered seeing Office SAllen going toward the Borden house. H went up afterward with Walter P. Stevens c the Fall River Nees afid John Manning of th Globe and examined the grass in the Bord.i
Officer Fleet describes searching the Borden house on the day of the murders, including questioning Lizzie about her time in the barn and finding blood in the guest room. He also recounts finding a hatchet head covered in ashes in a box in the cellar, which was produced in court.
Evening Star · 9 June 1893 · page 11
THE BORDEN MURDER CASE
L door between Miss Borden's room and Mrs e Borden's locked. Up against the room doo1 leading into Mrs. Borden's out of Lizzie's was i
Testimony describes discovery of a hatchet head in a box in the cellar, covered with fine white ash-like dust, which the witness identified as the item recovered. The report notes this was the long-rumored weapon, kept secret by Assistant Marshal Fleet for months, and that many believe it to be the murder weapon.
Evening Star · 9 June 1893 · page 11
upon both sides, and, in fact. all over it; tin , dust was of ashes, very fine; other tools in thi a box had dust on them, but not the same as o this hatchet. Officer Fleet, in his cross-examination, maI that he thought he could have seen blood ot the clothes he examined if any had been there If there had been any paint there he believe< he could not have seen - it unlees he looked g closely. Court here adjourned until today. Last night's sensation at Fall River was As sistant Marshall Fleet's story regarding the ai e found in the Borden house.
See moreSee less
supposed to hav Ik e Was limed. a been used in the Borden murders. For man weqks stories about the hatchet and axes havy a been published. but during all the long te months that have elap ed he has scrupulously 5 in Judge Miller's court teday, one of them,Wm kept tho secret that the probable weapon wai found the day the famous butcheries were dim covered. His description of the weapon was so exact so minute, his reputation for veracity and hon orable dealing in police and private matters I so well known here, that two-thirds of thi t population believe he has really found the weapon with which the deeds were committed Many of Lizzie Borden's friends feel very mil exercised over the testimony.
The New Bedford trial resumes with Dr. Bowen testifying about prescribing morphine to Lizzie Borden that could affect memory and cause hallucinations. Bridget Sullivan is recalled and denies earlier statements about seeing Lizzie in tears, while the prosecution prepares to use the burned dress as evidence of guilt.
The Morning News · 9 June 1893 · page 1
LIZZIE BURNED A DRESS.
Bloody Work Was Dono. New Bedford, Mass., Juno 8. —The court house opened before the regular time this morning, and at the main entrance inquis itive females who hod swallowed their breakfasts hurriedly or dispensed with them entirely mode one of tho prettiest rushes ever seen outside of a college cam pus, Two blue-coated representatives ot the local police were carried off their foot and whirled along with the resistless pot ticoated surge from below until several deputy sheriff's jumped down to their rescue and turned the tide. Tlio result was that the pushers wore kept out en tirely, while those who acted in a fairly decent manner were allowed tho coveted privilege of fighting for the scats inside.
See moreSee less
Miss Borden was in her scat fifteen minutes before tlio court camo in and eagerly looked over the contents of a big, official-looking envelope, which she after ward passed to Gov. Robinson. All her counsel wore early on band and the jurors wero in their seats before tho counsel for tlio prosecution showed up at all. Just as the court come in and tho crier was making his proclamation Miss Borden was passing from a scat in the dock to a seat within the bar inolosure beside her counsel. She was obliged to stand al most beside Judge Blodgott while tho crier was talking. Dr. Bowen was put on tho stand. He stated nothing new tn his direct examina tion except to deny that lie had ever said Mrs. Borden died of fright or iu a faint. The cross-examination by Mr. Adams
The report notes that at the opening of Lizzie Borden's murder trial in Fall River, Mass., a local pastor offered a prayer asking that innocence be revealed and guilt exposed. This was described as a noteworthy feature of the trial's start.
The Morning News · 9 June 1893 · page 4
The words of this article could not be separated from the rest of its page. Read it in the clipping.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
The Indianapolis Journal · Indianapolis, Ind.
At the New Bedford trial, witnesses including Bridget Sullivan, Mrs. Churchill, and Alice Russell testified about Lizzie Borden's pale, excited appearance after the murders and about her burning a dress days later. Dr. Bowen denied ever claiming Mrs. Borden died of fright.
The Indianapolis Journal · 9 June 1893 · page 5
CAUSED HER TO TURN PALE
That Was Found by a Policeman Produced by the Prosecutor A Blue Dress Burned. . Nkw Bedford, Mass., June 8. The court house was opened before the regular timo this morning, and at the main entrance the crowd of curious females who had swal lowed their breakfast hurriedly or dis pensed with it entirely made one of the prettiest rushes ever seen outside of a col lege campus. The local police were carried oil' their feet and whirled along with the resistless potticoated surge from below, until several deputy shonlls jumped down to their rescue and turned the tide.
See moreSee less
Miss Borden was iu her seat fifteen minutes be fore the court came in, and eagerly looked over the contents of a big official-looking envelope, which she afterwards passed to Governor Robinson. All her counsel were early on hand. Dr. Bowen, the first witness, stated noth ing new in tho direot examination, except to deny that he had ever said Mrs. Borden
A witness described Lizzie Borden burning a paint-stained dress days after the murder, including her alarmed reaction when warned about it. Later, policeman George Allen testified he found a blood-covered handkerchief near Mrs. Borden's feet, visibly shaking the defendant.
The Indianapolis Journal · 9 June 1893 · page 5
CAUSED HER TO TURN PALE
After recess John Cunningham was cross examined, and then George Allen, a pale policeman of Fall River, was called. On tho morning of the tragedy a message came to the station house, where he was, telling of the murder. He went up to the Borden house on the run, and picked np another policeman on the way. When he reached the sitting room Mrs. Churchill ' and Mies Russell were there, bo was Dr. Bowen. The sheet had not yet been placed over the body of tho dead man. He happened to pasa the door, and he thonght he might as well examine the lock while he was there.
See moreSee less
Ho found a night lock and a bolt on the door. The door was both looked and bolted when he made the examination. When he saw Lizzie Borden that morning she was
Officer Allen testified about finding a blood-covered handkerchief near Mrs. Borden's feet, and officer Fleet described discovering the handleless hatchet in the cellar with a freshly broken handle disguised with ashes. The courtroom reacted visibly to the handkerchief testimony before court adjourned for the day.
The Indianapolis Journal · 9 June 1893 · page 5
Borden's feet; betweeu her feet and tho window." "Were there any marks on it!" Then came the answer that caused the prisoner to look as if she was about to collapse. Yes," were Allen's words. It was covered with blood." "That's all," said the district attorney, quietly, as if it were an every day matter to produce a bit of evidence lik9 that. Dunne the time that the handkerchief was talked about the prisoner picked at the tips of one glove with the other hand. sWhen ex-Governor Robinson cross-examined Allen he did not ask a question about the bloody handkerchief.
See moreSee less
Officer Allen, together with Sheriff Wixon, then testified to their search of the Borden premises after the murder. Then orhcor Fleet was put on the stand. After corroborating the testimony of the two previous witnesses, he described his finding tho h&ndleless hatchet produced by Mr. Moody in opening. This hatchet was found on the day of the murder in the box next tho chimney in tho cellar. A frag ment of the handle showed a fresh break, and the iron was covered with ashes. The manner in which tbeasbesordust Appeared in tho cut indicated that an effort had been made to havo the break appear like an old one. He saw no paint ahout the house. The court hero adjourned for the day.
A roundup of national news items reports that the trial of Lizzie Borden began at New Bedford, Massachusetts, on Monday morning. It is listed alongside unrelated stories such as a Chicago drowning, a Pennsylvania murder-suicide, and the Homestead strike indictments being quashed.
The Goodland Republic · 9 June 1893 · page 1
The trial of Lizzie Borden began. at New Bedford, Mass., this (Monday) morning. The indictments against H. C. Frick, the result of the Homestead strike have Vipn ntiashed. It is believed the cases against the strikers will be dismissed. Mrs. Harrison, who would have shortly become queen of the Gypsies of North America, was buried in Green Mount cemetary, near Mascoutah, 111.
Testimony at the Borden trial revealed that Lizzie Borden burned a dress she claimed was paint-stained, which the prosecution argued was actually blood-stained. A searcher named Allen also testified to finding a handkerchief near Mrs. Borden's feet that was covered in blood and appeared partially burned.
The Wichita Daily Eagle · 9 June 1893 · page 2
THE BORDEN TRIAL. New Bedford, Mass., June S. In the Borden trial today tho testimony showed hat Lizzie Borden, had, after the trgedy and after the search by the police, burned what .she said was a paiut-staiued dress,
Springfield Weekly Republican · Springfield, Mass.
Bridget Sullivan, the Borden family servant, and John V. Morse, Lizzie's uncle, testified at the trial, though Sullivan offered no new facts beyond her earlier hearings. Lizzie remained composed during the testimony, and ex-Gov. Robinson's cross-examination of Sullivan did not appear to shake her account.
Springfield Weekly Republican · 9 June 1893 · page 4
SOME IMPORTANT WITNESSES EXAMINED IN THE BORDEN CASE
Bridget Nwllivon <4ive« No New Forts Vivid Stories of the Tragedy. । When it was made known Wednesday ; that J. V. .Morse, uncle of Lizzie Borden, J and Bridget Sullivan, servant of the Bor den family, were to testify, the general im
Springfield Weekly Republican · Springfield, Mass.
John Vinnicum Morse testifies with no new facts, showing emotion when recalling the discovery of the bodies before composing himself under cross-examination. A civil engineer is recalled to discuss property lines and demonstrates how a person could hide in the front hall closet with the door shut.
Springfield Weekly Republican · 9 June 1893 · page 4
UNCLE AND SERVANT BOTH TESTIFY.
break down the court will not be held Saturday, or will make a temporary ad journment for n day, or will have to short en the daily sessions. The reason of the absence from court of Emma Borden, Lizzie's sister, and several other women, is that they are government witnesses and have been impounded. Mr K ciman,the civil engineer, who was on Tuesday, was recalled for the first wit ness. The cross-examination was resumed by his pointing out the line between the Borden and Kelley houses. He said the line struck 12 inches from the hinge or east side of the door.
See moreSee less
The point of contact of that line with Jhe east side of Second street as to being the point where there is the best observation, was a question which came up for discussion between counsel and court. Counsel for defense contended that there was no need of going into this with the witness as the jury had seen the place, but the question was al lowed, and the answer was that witness thought it was. He had made observa tions at other points in the vicinity of the line referred to. A plan of the cel lar of the Borden house was next shown, marked “G,” the previous one being "8.”
Springfield Weekly Republican · Springfield, Mass.
A surveyor described a demonstration showing a man could hide in the front hall closet with the door shut. John V. Morse, brother-in-law of the elder Mrs. Borden, testified about his visit to the Borden house on August 3-4, including arrival times, meals, and the household's movements that night and morning.
Springfield Weekly Republican · 9 June 1893 · page 4
The next witness was John V. Morse, who sajd he was now living at South Dart mouth. He is 60 years old. He has lived th->re nearly a year. He came East three years ago last April. He was a brother of the first Mrs Borden. The family rela tions having been established, witness was asked when Mr Borden was first mar ried and said it was about 47 years ago. There were three children. Onb is dead. Mrs Borden died in 1861. The child which died was younger than the others.
See moreSee less
Mr Borden’s second marriage he could not remember. He said Lizzie was 33 and Emma 41 years old. On Wednesday, Au gust 3 last, he wont to the Borden house. He had been a visitor there several weeks before. The last time he saw Lizzie be fore that visit he could not place. He ar rived at the Borden house at 1.30 on Wednesday. He did not see anybody that day but Mr and Mrs Borden and Bridget. He ate dinner there that day, but ate it alone. He went away that day between 3 and 4 p. m., and went to Swansea, com ing back on Wednesday, arriving about 8.30. That time he entered the front door, having been let in by Mrs Borden. He rang the bell. The door was shut af ter he went in. He saw nobody there but the family. He went first into the sitting room and went to bed about 10.30. Mrs Borden went to bed first, going out of the rear door to the back stairs. While we were sitting there somebody entered the front door and went tip stairs to Lizzie's room. Mr Borden and I went to bed at the same time, I going into the guest room. The prisoner’s room door was closed when I went into the room, but did not know whether it was locked. Saw or heard no person that night. Arose at about 6 o’clock and went down stairs; left the room door open; did not go back to the room; prisoner's room door was closed when I went down; went into the sitting room when I went down stairs on Thurs day morning; the day was pretty warm. There was no one in the room when I w«it there; the kitchen door was closed. I think; the first person I saw was Mr Bordem who came into the sitting-room, and then came Mrs Borden.
The report notes that in the murder trial against Lizzie Borden at New Bedford, Massachusetts, the examination of witnesses for the prosecution continued the previous day. It is a short item buried among unrelated European and American news briefs.
Der Deutsche Correspondent · 9 June 1893 · page 1
The words of this article could not be separated from the rest of its page. Read it in the clipping.
The report covers the ongoing murder trial of Lizzie Borden in New Bedford, Massachusetts, describing testimony from civil engineer Kiernan about the house's layout, Mrs. Borden's brother Mr. Morse, and maid Bridget Sullivan who repeated her earlier inquest statements. It notes Lizzie Borden appeared bored and yawned during the proceedings, and that the morning session brought nothing new to light.
Der Deutsche Correspondent · 9 June 1893 · page 1
Lizzie Borden's Prozeß.
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
The Prince George's Enquirer and Southern Maryland Advertiser · Upper Marlborough, Md.
A short news item reports that the trial of Lizzie Borden for the murder of her father and stepmother began on Monday at New Bedford, Massachusetts. It appears amid a list of unrelated national and international news briefs.
The Prince George's Enquirer and Southern Maryland Advertiser · 9 June 1893 · page 3
XEWS ITEMS. Why let your hair turn gray when Hall's Hair Reuewer will prevent it? General William Mahone lias been confined to bis home in Petersburg for sometime by sickness. Miss Belle H. Richardson, a native of War ren county, died in Washington, ou Thursday last. The attendance at the Chicago Fair Mon day was not very large. Four persons were burned lo death in a tire in a Xew York tenement early Monday morn ing. The trial of Miss Lizzie Borden for the murder of her father aud step-mother began Monday at Xew Bedford, Mass.
Dr. Bowen, the Borden family physician, testified about arriving at the house after the murders, finding Mr. Borden's body and later Mrs. Borden's, and his conversations with Lizzie that morning. Bridget Sullivan also reportedly contradicted some of her earlier testimony as the trial continued in New Bedford.
Daily Kennebec Journal · 9 June 1893 · page 1
•t LIqm ElfNn. Ntw Bm»oki>, Junes.—The court room waa crowded today. l>r. Bowen was the first witness. He said he had been the family physician of the Bordens 21 years. He went to the Borden house after II.JO on the day of the murder. He saw Lizzie and Mrs. t'hurehill there and asked what waa the trouble, ami Lizzie replies, "Father has been killed or stabbed." He saw Mr. Borden lying on the sofa in the sitting room with his head terribly cut. hut nolnvd tliat nothing about the room was disturbed.
See moreSee less
A photograph was here shown and iden tified. During the show ing of the photo graph the prisouer kept her eyes riveted on the tloor, never once glancing up. The witness continued, saying that he asked Lizzie if she had seen anyone alxvut the place and she said no. lie then asked her where she had been and she mu I, “In the barn to get some iron." She said she was afraid her father had had trouble with some of his tenants. He went upstairs and saw Mrs. Borden. He found the wound in her head an 1 never sai 1 to anyone that she had died of fright or was in a faint, but the first thought that the witness hud w its that she had fainted. Here a photograph of Mrs. Borden was submitted and as the picture went the rounds and was eommeuted upon. The prisoner covered her eyes hut there were no tears. "Continuing, the witness said that when he was in the house in the morning he saw that Lizziehad changed her dress, u pink wrapjter, but didn’t notiee the first dress worn as to color ami material. When the witness came down stairs after seeing Mrs. Borden’s body, several women were work ing over Lizzie in the kitchen fanning her. He prescribed bromo-caffeine for her that afternoon to allay her nervousness and ordered morphine for her Friday. Saturday and Sunday. Friday the witness gave Lizzie an eighth grain of morphine, he doubled it Saturday ami continued this treatment all the time up to her arrest and while she was in the sta tion. "Morphine," he said, "affects the mind by changing ami altering a (arson's views, and causes a hallucination." Bridget Sullivan was recalled. She snid that n robbery had occurred in the Borden house w hile she was working there, about
A doctor testifies about treating Lizzie with morphine and bromo-caffeine after the murders, noting the drug's effects on perception. Bridget Sullivan and neighbor Mrs. Churchill give conflicting accounts of Lizzie's emotional state and the discovery of the bodies.
Mrs. Churchill recounts Lizzie's claim of finding the body after returning from the barn, denying blood on her dress, and dismissing suspicion of a Swedish worker. Alice Russell testifies that Lizzie burned a paint-stained dress days after the murders, reacting with regret when told how it looked.
Daily Kennebec Journal · 9 June 1893 · page 1
had been any blood there. Witness continued : "Bridget sai l to me after I got there, ‘Mrs. Borden hail a note, and she hurried off; the was dusting tfie si'ting room, and she did not tell me where she was going, as she generally does.' "While at the house some policemen spoke ahout a Swede who worked for Mr. Borden; Lizzie said he wasn't ever in Fall River and that she would not suspect him.
At the New Bedford trial, prosecution evidence suggested the axe found in the Borden cellar on the day of the murders was likely the weapon used. Testimony also covered Miss Russell's account of burning a dress and contradictions in Bridget Sullivan's statements.
The Portland Daily Press · 9 June 1893 · page 1
IT KILLED THE BORDENS
Miss Borden was in her seat 15 min utes before the court came in, and ea gerly looked over the contents of a big, official-looking envelope, which she af terward passed to Gov. Robinson. All her counsel were early on band, and the jury were in their seats before counsel for the prosecution showed up at all. Just as the Court came in and the Crier was making his proclamation Miss Bor den was passing from her seat in the dock to a seat within the bar enclosure hp.r nnnncAl Sim woo stand almost beside Judge Blodgett wEile the crier was talking, and stood the ordeal well.
See moreSee less
Today’s sensation was Assistant Mar shal Fleet’s story regarding the axe found in the Borden home and supposed to have been used in the Borden mur der. During all the long ten months that have passed he has scrupulously kept the secret that the weapon was found the day the famous butcheries were discovered. His description of the weapon is so exact and his reputation for veracity and honorable dealing so well known here that two-thirds of the population believe he really found the weapon with which the deeds were com mitted. ' Many of Lizzie Borden’s friends feel very much exercised over the testi mony. The story is not yet finished and when it is there will be surprise for the defense because it will indicate collusion in favor of the defense not of a gratifying nature.
The report describes the crowded courtroom scene at the New Bedford trial and Assistant Marshal Fleet's long-withheld testimony about the axe found in the Borden home on the day of the murders. It then begins recounting Dr. Bowen's testimony about his movements and observations on the morning of August 4, 1892.
Dr. Bowen recounts being summoned by his wife to the Borden house, where Lizzie told him her father had been killed, and describes finding Andrew Borden dead on the sitting room sofa with a badly cut face. He also recalls Lizzie's statements about being in the barn and fears of trouble with tenants, and the arrangement for covering the body with a sheet.
The Portland Daily Press · 9 June 1893 · page 1
THE TRIAL AT NEW BEDFORD.
Dr. Bowen’s Story. The first witness called for was Mrs. Churchill, the previous call for Dr. Bowen having been rescinded, but she not being present, Dr. Bowen was put on. He said: “I have lived at my present residence 21 years, which is diagonally opposite the Borden house. I have been the family physician nearly all that time. I recall the day August 4,1892. I saw Mr. Borden the day before, about 6 o’clock, going down the street. I testified at the inquest, but do not recall that I said then I saw him going up the street on Wednesday.
See moreSee less
(The notes showed he did say so,but witness said it was a mistake.) I think it was after 11 and before 11.30 that I returned to my house in the fore noon of Wednesday: when I returned Mrs. Bowen spoke to me, and in con sequence of that I went to the Borden house; I saw Miss Lizzie Borden and Mrs. Churchill there; they were in the side hall just at the end of it, near the kitchen door; I said ‘Lizzie, what’s the matter?’ She said, ‘Father has been killed or stabbed.’ I asked, ‘Where is your father?’ She said, ‘In the sitting room.’ That was all that was said in that connection at that time. In con sequence of what she said I went into the dining room and then to the sit ting room; I saw the form of Mr. Borden
The report notes that the trial of Lizzie Borden, accused in the murder of her father and mother at Fall River, has begun. It remarks that Massachusetts courts do not move quickly, as the murders occurred about a year earlier.
Little Falls Transcript · 9 June 1893 · page 2
Call for advertised letters and give dale. W. M. FULLER, M. V. Ti trial of Lizzie Borden about whom so much has been said in connection with the murder of her father and mother at Fall River, has begun. Bay state courts do not give very speedy trials to alleged criminals as the muder occurred about a year ago. P. H. Neuman, has just received a number of heavy draught horses. Parties desiring to purchase will do well to give him acall. [tf&w] Ladies. Try a bottle of the Ideal Face Wash removes tan, freckles, and pimples. Leaves the skin soft and white. For sale at Mrs. K. E.
The Lizzie Borden trial continued with testimony from house guest J.V. Morse and servant Bridget Sullivan. Sullivan's testimony emphasized that the Borden family relations were harmonious with no quarrels, and no new facts emerged before the court adjourned.
The Anaconda Standard · 9 June 1893 · page 7
TheNew Liberty Hell. Philadelphia,June 7.^Interesting^ceremonies preliminary to the casting of^tho new liberty bell at Troy, X. V., were^bold in Independence hall to-day. The^gathering was mado up of ladies and gen^^tlemen from all parts of the United^States, constituting thu liberty bell com^^mittee. Colonel McCiuro delivered an^addres* of welcome, the response coming^from William U. McDowell, of Xowark,^K.J. It was agrooil to meet in Chicago^July 4, next when the bell will he rung lor^tbo first tiiuo w lib great ceremony. Theliortlen Trial. NewHKDi-otti), Mass., June 7.^The^trial of Lizzie Borden was cuntiniiod to^^day. J. V.
See moreSee less
Morse, a guest at tho Borden^house at the time of tho murder, and^Bridget Sullivan, a servant, tcstitled. Tho^principal point brought out in the exam^^ination of Miss Sullivan was that the fam^^ily relations were of a most harmonious^character, there never having been any^quarrel*. Tho testimony was devoid of^new facts. After a close croat-examiiia-^tion of Uridget Sullirau the court ad^^journed till to-morrow.
The report states that the trial of Lizzie Borden for the murder of her father and stepmother began at New Bedford on the previous Monday. It is a short, factual notice embedded among unrelated local news items.
The Charlotte Democrat · 9 June 1893 · page 2
Tbere are many grown people who don't know half of these things, all because they spent their time at school learning about something in some remote part of the earth that never was and never will be of any benefit to them. It is well enough, perhaps, to know about these tbings but its .better to know about home affairs first. Statesville Landmark. The trial of Miss Lizzie Borden for the murder of her father and step mother began at New Bedford, on Mon day last.
The trial of Lizzie Borden for the murder of her father and stepmother began on June 5, with a jury selected after nine hours and Borden pleading not guilty. The report recaps the August 1892 killings, noting no robbery motive and suspicion falling on Lizzie due to inconsistent statements.
The Hope Pioneer · 9 June 1893 · page 2
FOR HER LIFE. Miss Lizzie Borden Placed on Trial—She Is Charged with the Murder of Her leather and Stepmother. NEW BEDFORD, Mass., June G.—The trial of Miss Lizzie A. Borden, charged with the murder of her father and step mother, August 4, 1S92, was begun at 11 a. m. Monday. After nine hours of rigid examination a jury was secured. The defendant was arraigned and pleaded not guilty. She manifested a coolness that approached indifference to the proceedings. I The double murder of Andrew ,!. Borden and his wife took place in this city shortly before noon ou August 4, 181)2.
See moreSee less
The body of the old entlcnuui wus found on a sofa in the parlor of the house and tluit of Mrs. Borden In a bed chamber on the second floor. Death in both cases hint been caused by repeat ed blows of some heavy, sharp in strument on the face, ncek and head. Although Mr. Uorcten was worth half a million dollars, there is no evidence to indicate that robber* had been the motive of the crime. No plate or money or any of the valuables of the mansion were messing, nor had a singlo thin been re moved from the bodies. There were, so far as is yet known, but two persons besides llorden and his wife on the premises when the murder was committed. These were Bridget Sullivan, a domestic, and I.izi-.ie Uorden. the younger of Mr. Borden's two daughters, 'i'he first alarm was given by Lizzie, who ran out into the yard and called for help. She was sus pected chiefly because of certain discrepancies between herstatements to the police as to the circumstances under which the bodies were found. A brother-in-law of Borden named Harrington also testified that for ten years there had been almost constant disputes between the daughters and Mr. aud Mis. Uorden. They had been allowed KU0 a year each, and had been "given property worth in the aggregate about HI,000. They were dissatislled with this, Harrington said, and thought they ought to have more. Miss Uorden moved in the best society, and wanted money to "hold her end up," as Har rington expressed it. The theory of the prosecution Is that it was the purpose of Lizzie Borden, by killing Borden aud his wire, to inherit one-half of tho estate. Bearing on this pointinformation was furnished the police to the effect that Mr. Borden was about to make a wilL The po lice consider tho information reliable. No will has been found since his death aud he is believed to have died intes tate. It is said that Lizzie Borden knew he was about to make a will. Before the tragedy Lizzie Borden lived the humdrum life of a small place. She once taught a Sunday school class and was bright but sedate. She made an extended tour of Kurope two or three years ago. 1
The report notes no valuables were missing and recounts testimony from brother-in-law Harrington about long-standing financial disputes between the Borden daughters and their father and stepmother. It outlines the prosecution's theory that Lizzie killed her parents to inherit the estate before her father could finalize a new will, and includes brief biographical background on Lizzie's quiet pre-murder life.
This report describes a damaging day of testimony in the Lizzie Borden trial, focusing on the burning of her dress and the discovery of a hatchet hidden in a tool box that had been freshly rubbed with ashes. The defense, led by ex-Gov. Robinson, worked to undermine the prosecution's evidence, noting that Borden burned the dress openly and that witnesses saw no blood on it.
The Sun · 9 June 1893 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.
DARK FOR LIZZIE BORDEN. THE BURNING OF HER DRESS AND THE DISCOVERY OF THE HATCHET.
Strong Testimony Against the Defendant, but Her Counsel, ex-Gov. Robinson, Succeeds in Tearing Some of It Into Tatters—Two Persons Say the Dress Was the One She Wore at the Time of the Murder—Still They Saw no Blood on It—The Hatchet Was Hidden in a Tool Box, and Had Been Freshly Rubbed With Ashes—A Bloody Handkerchief that Also Appears Mysteriously in the Case.
See moreSee less
NEW BEDFORD, June 8.—It was a bad day for Lizzie Borden—a day full of suggestion of her guilt. As usual her physical condition seemed to foreshadow what was to come. She was all but motionless most of the day. All of her stoicism seemed to have returned to her. It is the general belief that the Government brought out its worst to-day and reached the summit of its little hillock of circumstantial evidence against the unhappy woman. And yet, after all, the principal testimony was as to the burning of her dress, which had been foreshadowed by the Government. That and the facts connected with her singular action made up the measure of the injury done to her case.
Queer and unaccountable as it was for a young woman so placed to burn a dress, especially in so frugal a New England household, it was yet an easy thing for her counsel to show much that was in her favor with regard to it. For instance, she made no effort to hide her act. She did it in broad daylight, in the presence of her sister and a friend, when policemen were just outside the unlocked door. All day the Government kept bringing out its most important and, as it thought, its most damaging points, and just as steadily ex-Gov. Robinson, on behalf of Miss Borden, either riddled them or tried to do so.
In this most expeditious court a swollen tide of witnesses seems ever pouring in the court-room door. Swearing them, ridding them of their testimony, and sending them away again goes on as a lot of cooks might squeeze a basketful of lemons. To-day, as nearly all of the witnesses were very important, the tone and temper of the proceedings were feverish and strained most of the time. The witnesses and the counsel on both sides were, like pugilists, steadily sparring each to get advantage of the other.
The operation could almost be likened to a pigeon-shooting match, in which District Attorney Moody kept flinging up the birds and defying his antagonist to hit them, while the ex-Governor as constantly fired, and often, but by no means always, wounded or brought them down.
Ex-Gov. Robinson is certainly without an equal in New York city as a cross-examiner. Hamlet, in the play, is no more necessary or conspicuous than this gifted lawyer is in this case.
He has not yet found a Government witness whom he has not been able to turn more or less to his own account. His ability is very like that of an actor. He changes his mood to suit his own purposes. He is very courtly and winning to a woman witness until he lands her where he wants her, and then, if it suits him, he becomes as stern as a pirate. He is as confidential and chatty as a gossip, and his witness becomes very desirous of pleasing him and is easily led into a trap. Then his manner changes, and he makes short work of letting the witness know he has him captive.
To-day he seemed determined to anger one of the witnesses. Then he showed his consummate art by simulating irritability, sternness, and impatience. That witness was a police officer named Fleet, and was the coolest, clearest-headed, shrewdest man the wily lawyer has yet had to deal with. In the other duels the ex-Governor has matched his big brains against far smaller ones, but John Fleet's brains were as good in their way as the lawyer's.
Fleet is assistant marshal in Fall River, and is evidently a believer in Lizzie Borden's guilt. Like a typical policeman having some one in custody, he finds it simpler to construe all the evidence against that one than to take up a new clue and hunt out another prisoner. He gave a great deal of testimony which the Government evidently thinks is very hurtful to Miss Borden, and some of it the Government had not outlined. Then, again, Fleet is the man who found the handleless hatchet, which they are going to show to have borne traces of blood. Mr. Robinson set out to discredit all this testimony, and his plan was to get the witness angry and rattled. He succeeded in five minutes, and had the policeman glaring at him and answering him impudently. He also made the witness contradict himself, and in a measure disparage his own evidence. But just then it was time to close the court, so the wonderful wizard of a lawyer will have to work the witness up all over again to-morrow.
The Government kept on weaving its web all day, and the woman's counsel kept breaking through it at every vulnerable point, so that, while the web was there at the close of the day, it was all tatters. The steady effort that the Government made was to show that the doors of the Borden house were all locked on the morning of the murders, that many men and two women went through the house soon after the murder, that the officers saw workmen calmly at work on the other side of the fences around the Borden place, and that it was next to impossible that any one except an inmate committed the crimes. Then, too, they showed that other policemen were quickly sent to scour the woods and watch the depots. Testimony of this sort was incessant. How cleverly Mr. Robinson dealt with all of it will be seen in what follows.
Miss Lizzie Borden attracted general attention all day, of course, but she did nothing to deserve it. She might be said to have done nothing at all but sit still, well back in her chair, and leaning her chin on one hand, her right hand in the morning and her left one in the afternoon. Once she attracted adverse attention. It was when the first blood in this terribly bloody case was shown in the form of a saturated handkerchief carried about like a British flag by District Attorney Moody. She turned her head as she had never done before so that her chin was over her shoulder and she cast her eyes down. And yet any woman might have done the same thing.
That last reflection brings to mind the fact that unless the Government has got more than it has shown, the Borden case will pass into history as one of the most mysterious of the celebrated cases of the century. Most fairminded persons here are of the opinion, that there has been nothing yet brought forward that does not tend to prove the woman innocent quite as much as to suggest her guilty.
The Commonwealth to-day continued its efforts to exactly fix the time of the murder of Mr. Borden. It has at least narrowed things down so that if Lizzie Borden is the murderess she could have had only from 8 to 13 minutes in which to conceal all traces of the murder of her father after she did the bloody deed. In that period of from 8 to 13 minutes she must have either changed her dress or put another one over it, she must have broken the hickory handle of a hatchet, and she must have taken the bloody blade of the weapon down into the cellar and rubbed it a long while and thoroughly with ashes to remove the blood. Of course, she had to wash her face and hands and to attend to her hair and clean her shoes all in the little space of time which Bridget Sullivan says she spent up stairs, and which accords with the testimony of other witnesses.
The first witness of the day was Seabury W. Bowen, the family physician of the Bordens, who was the first person summoned by Miss Borden after the murder. He is also the first person to testify that nothing in the rooms where the murdered persons were found was disturbed by the murderer. "I asked Lizzie several times," he said, "'Have you seen anybody?' and her reply was, 'I have not.'"
"Where have you been?" the doctor asked. She said, "I have been to the barn looking for iron." She then said she was afraid her father had had trouble with his tenants, as she had overheard unfriendly conversations with them several times.
The doctor was another person to whom Lizzie said that Mrs. Borden had got a note asking her to call and see a sick person. The doctor went up and saw Mrs. Borden's body, and noted that she had been killed, probably by the same instrument that despatched Mr. Borden. When he came down he told Lizzie it was fortunate she was out of the way at the time. He denied that he had ever said that Miss Lizzie had on a drab dress at that time. All that he could say now was that the color of the dress was indefinite. Shown the blue dress which the Government keeps on the table in court, the Doctor said he did not call it drab, and that he could not tell whether that was the dress she had on or not.
Returning to his visit to the house, he told of seeing Lizzie in the kitchen, with the others leaning over her and fanning her. He told her to go to her room, and he prescribed something for her.
Mr. Melvin O. Adams took Mr. Robinson's place as crossexaminer of this witness. He had sufficient success to have satisfied even his brilliant colleague. He brought out from the Doctor the fact that Miss Borden was under the influence of morphine for several days after the murder.
On the day of the murder he gave her bromo caffeine. For Friday and Saturday he prescribed morphine. On Friday he gave her an eighth of a grain and on Saturday double as much. She had it again on Sunday and Monday
"How long did she take it?" said Mr. Adams.
"She had it all the time she was at the police station."
"Up to the time of her arrest and when she was at the station?" Mr. Adams asked.
"Yes, sir."
"After her arrest, when she was at the station, had she taken this double dose of morphine daily for several days?"
"Yes, sir."
"I suppose physicians understand that when morphine is given it affects the memory, changes the views of things, and gives people hallucinations?"
"Yes, sir."
"There is no doubt about it, is there?"
"No, sir." Of course the reader will understand the very great importance of this testimony for the prisoner. She has been accused of many contradictions in her stories, of peculiar behavior after the murder in her home and when under examination. The defence can now ascribe to the morphine as much of this as it pleases.
Bridget Sullivan was put on the stand again for ex-Gov. Robinson to ply with questions in the continuation of his cross-examination of her. He made her describe the dress she had on during the morning of the day of the murders, and as it proved to be a blue dress, it was clear that he means to argue that hers was the dress that Mrs. Churchill saw and afterward thought was worn by Miss Borden. However, the dress was little like the one Mrs. Churchill describes. The ex-Governor next took up the subject of the robberies of the Borden house and barn prior to the murders. His questions were objected to.
The Governor paused and contemplated the Judges reflectively. Then he said: "I do not want to state anything before the jury which I ought not to, but I want to bring out the fact that some time, not long before the murders, the house was entered by burglars in broad day while this witness and the prisoner were in the house."
"I think it is not competent," said the Chief Justice. "It was too long before the commission of the crime about which she is to testify."
Then ex-Gov. Robinson said he would like to bring out the fact that there had been a robbery of the barn also. He asked her when that was, and she said it was four or five months before the murders. The burglary of the residence was twelve months prior to the murders. The whole line of testimony was excluded—a loss to the prisoner's side, for her lawyers want to show that there was a good reason for the alleged anxiety of the prisoner to keep her home bolted and barred. The house had been robbed in broad daylight, and the barn behind it was pillaged twice. This the defence will argue—if they can get the evidence—was sufficient to render the Bordens very nervous, and more than commonly careful to keep the doors to the house well secured.
Mrs. Adelaide Churchill, the next-door neighbor of the Bordens to the northward, was the next witness. She is the neighbor who was the first person not of the household who entered the Borden house after the commission of the crime. She is a middle-aged matron of comfortable build and genteel, placid face. She told of seeing Andrew Jackson Borden as he started from his house on that round of business calls from which he came back to be killed. She went down town, and, in an uncertain measure of time, came back. She saw Bridget coming back from Dr. Bowen's rapidly. From her house she saw Miss Lizzie leaning against her kitchen door. The prisoner looked excited or agitated and the witness stepped to the window and said: "Lizzie, what's the matter?"
"Oh, Mrs. Churchill," said the prisoner, "do come over; some one has killed father."
The witness went over to the Borden house. As soon as she reached the door she stepped in, and there was Miss Lizzie sitting on the second stair to the right of the door. The witness put her right hand on the prisoner's arm and said:
"Oh, Lizzie, where is your father?"
"He is in the sitting room."
Then the witness asked: "Where were you when it happened?"
The prisoner replied: "I went to the barn to get a piece of iron."
The witness then asked where Mrs. Borden was. The prisoner said: "I don't know. She got a note and went out. I sent for Dr. Bowen. I must have a doctor. Father must have an enemy, for we have all been sick. I think it must be the milk. I think we were poisoned."
The witness ran over into the street, and, seeing a man, said that a doctor must be had. Soon Bridget came and Dr. Bowen. Some one told the Doctor Mr. Borden was in the sitting room. Bridget, Lizzie, and witness followed the Doctor as far as the dining room door. The Doctor then came out and said: "Come in and see him." "Oh, no," said the witness, "I don't want to see him. I saw him this morning."
The Doctor wanted a sheet to cover up the body. Bridget got the key to the bedroom of the old couple, and she and Mrs. Churchill went up. Bridget found the door locked, went in, and got the sheet. Miss Lizzie asked the Doctor if he would send a telegram to Emma, her sister. "Tell it to her as gently as you can," said the prisoner, "for there is an old person there." Miss Russell (the prisoner's closest friend and companion) soon came. After that Miss Lizzie asked would some one try to find Mrs. Borden, for she thought she heard her come in. The witness and Bridget went up the front stairs. They went up so that witness's eyes were on a level with the front hall, and saw across the hall and the spare room on the far side of the bed what looked like the form of a person. The witness went back and Miss Russell asked: "Is there another?" The witness said, "Yes, she is up there." Miss Lizzie said she should have to go to the cemetery, but the witness told her the undertaker would attend to everything.
"Was her excitement manifested by tears?"
"No, sir."
"Did you suggest any change of dress?"
"No."
"Did any one suggest it in your hearing?"
"No."
Asked what dress the prisoner wore, she said it looked like a light blue with white groundwork. It was of calico or cambric, with a dark navy blue diamond pattern printed on it. This, of course, is the dress that the Government will seek to prove was burned by the prisoner two or three days afterward. District Attorney Moody took from his table a dark blue dress and asked:
"Is that the dress?"
"No, sir. Oh, no, sir," said the witness quite emphatically.
Then it was that ex-Gov. Robinson took the witness in his charge on behalf of the prisoner, and gave another exhibition of his marvellous power as a cross-examiner. He got from the witness the fact that there was no peculiarity about Miss Lizzie's dress that attracted her to call across the yards and ask what was the matter. It was the prisoner's looks, not her acts. "Of course," said this magic-like juggler with words and vocal tones, "you did not examine that dress? You were too much excited?"
"Yes, sir."
"Of course you did not talk about dresses, then, when you heard about the murder?"
"No, sir."
"You did not notice Bridget's dress?"
"No."
"If we were to make particular inquiry, you couldn't tell?"
"No, sir."
"Mrs. Bowen came that morning. What sort of a dress did she have on?"
"I think she had on a whitish dress."
"Do you know what you had on?"
"Yes, sir."
"But beyond that you can't tell much about dresses?"
"No, sir."
"What dress did Miss Russell have on?"
"I don't remember."
Having thus weakened the Government theory about the missing dress worn during the perpetration of the murders, the ex-Governor took up another branch of the same subject in a most ingenious way. He asked the witness such questions as to produce testimony that Mrs. Churchill fancied Lizzie Borden had had a newspaper. Afterward, Miss Russell fanned Lizzie. Some one gave her something to drink, and the witness thought Miss Russell cooled the prisoner's face and hands with water. "You remained with her all the time up to noon?" the ex-Governor asked. "Did you see any blood on her dress?"
The witness did not.
"On a dress as light as that, if there had been blood you would have seen it?"
"I should think so. If it had been on the front of it I'd have seen it."
"Well," said the Governor, "you were right over her, in front of her, bathing her, fanning her?"
The witness replied that she was.
"And," said the Governor, "at no time did you see a particle of blood on her hands or her dress?"
"No."
"You saw nothing about her hair or her shoes?"
"No."
"When she lay on the lounge her feet and shoes were right up on the lounge?"
"Yes, sir."
This witness told of a conversation she overheard between a policeman and the prisoner. The officer was asking about some farm hand of her father's who had had a quarrel with the old man. The policeman suggested that, perhaps, the man was a Portuguese. The prisoner said: "He was not a Portuguese, he was a Swede." She added that she would not suspect him of doing such a thing. With a buzz from the surprised and expectant audience the name of Miss Russell was called by District Attorney Moody. This famous friend proved to be an old maid of 40, but far from fat and fair. In fact, she is a slender, prim woman of precise manners, of spare figure and sallow face. She was obliged to stand up in full length view of all the crowd, of course. She never once looked at the prisoner, who had once been her chum. On the contrary, she turned her left shoulder toward the prisoner, and kept that position for an hour and a half. If ever there was a woman who was and is superior to the frivolities of life, that woman is Miss Alice M. Russell. She testified that Miss Borden was a friend who frequently called upon her. She did so on the Wednesday night before the murder. The prisoner said:
"I feel depressed. I feel as if something was hanging over me. I can't throw it off. The other day the girls laughed in the dining room, and this feeling came over me, and they asked, 'What's the matter? Why don't you laugh?' Mr. and Mrs. Borden were awfully sick last night. We were all sick but Maggie." Lizzie thought maybe it was the baker's bread, which all ate except Maggie. Miss Russell thought if that were so others in town would be ill. Then the prisoner guessed maybe it was the milk, but Miss Russell, in her intensely practical way, showed that that could not well be the case.
"I feel afraid sometimes that father's got an enemy," the prisoner said. "He had so much trouble with men that came to see him." A man came to the house only a few days before, and she heard her father say to him: "I don't care to let my property for such a purpose." The man said: "I should not think such a man as you would care what you let it for." and her father was angry and showed him out of the house. She spoke of some one having robbed the barn, and the matter-of-fact witness said that was only some one after the pigeons. Miss Lizzie did not heed these calming statements, but said: "I feel as if I want to sleep with one eye half open. I feel that they'll burn the house down some time. I am afraid somebody'll do something to father some time; he's so discourteous to people."
When the witness went to the Borden house on the summons of the prisoner on the morning of the double murder, Lizzie said she had been to the barn to get some tin or iron to fix a screen. When she came into the house she saw her father and that he was killed. The witness started to loosen Lizzie's dress, but the prisoner said: "I won't faint." The point in bringing this out was that perhaps she had on another gown under the outer one, and to open her clothing would have disclosed the fact.
"Are you able to give a description of the dress she had on?" Miss Russell was asked.
"None whatever," she replied. Witness went to Lizzie's bedroom with her before the prisoner changed her dress. Asked in what way it was suggested that she leave the room, she answered that the prisoner remarked that when it was necessary for her to have an undertaker she should want Winwood. Witness then went down to tell this to the family physician, Dr. Bowen, and, after waiting some time, went up stairs again. The prisoner was coming out of her sister Emma's room tying the ribbon of a wrapper which she had put on.
Then came the thunderclap of the alleged proof against the wretched prisoner—the chief stroke of the Government. The witness had been led up to Sunday morning, the day following the funeral and the third day after the murder. She had gone down into the kitchen. Miss Lizzie was at the stove and held a skirt of a dress in her hand. Her sister Emma said: "What are you going to do?"
"I am going to burn the old thing up," said Lizzie. "It's all covered with paint."
The witness turned and left the room. She spoke to neither sister. She came back into the kitchen and saw Miss Lizzie, who stood by the cupboard, and was either ripping something or tearing something apart in the garment. "I said to her," the witness went on, "'I wouldn't let any one see me do that, Lizzie.' She did not make any answer. She stepped one step further back. I don't know that it was the waist, but I saw the portion of the dress on the cupboard shelf. No officers were then in the house, but there were officers about the premises."
Witness afterward talked with officer Hanscom, and later saw Miss Lizzie. She said to her: "I am afraid, Lizzie, that the worst thing you could have done was to burn that dress. They have been talking to me about it." Lizzie said: "Oh, why did you let me do it? Why didn't you tell me?"
District Attorney Moody paused a moment and then said: "Miss Russell, you testified at the inquest, at the preliminary examination, and before the Grand Jury. At any of those hearings did you say anything about that incident?"
"No, sir," said the witness.
"Stop one moment," said the magical cross-examiner for the defence, and he so strenuously objected to that question and answer that both were excluded. The witness finished for the Commonwealth by saying that the dress in question was a light blue dress with a small dark blue figure in it—a dress the prisoner had bought no longer ago than the early spring. This tallied with the description Mrs. Churchill gave of the dress the prisoner wore on the morning of the murder, a dress unlike any now in the possession of the Government.
The ex-Governor then took the witness, but it was not his purpose to make her seem of much account. He got her to tell how she had urged the prisoner to sit down, and had found her at the time of the discovery of the murders.
"Did she seem to have on more than one dress?"
"I did not notice," the witness replied.
"Did you see any blood upon her?"
"No, not a particle," said Miss Russell.
"Didn't see any on her dress or hair or hands or shoes?"
"No," said the witness.
"Everything looked all right?"
"Yes, sir."
As the witness recalled the first search of the house, the officers went into the room of the old couple, then into the parlor. In the afternoon they went to Miss Lizzie's room by bursting open the door between it and the room of the old couple. Later she saw Miss Lizzie screw the screw-eye into the door frame again. When the officers were there they searched Miss Lizzie's room. Miss Borden's counsel, with all his ability, could not make the witness say that the search was very thorough, but he found it a good point to make her swear that the room so generally supposed to have been kept free from inspection, was searched, after all.
Mrs. Churchill had said that Miss Lizzie wore a calico or cambric dress. Miss Russell told him the dress Lizzie burned up was of Bedford cord. She was certain she knew the difference between calico or cambric and Bedford cord: these were very different materials. The Governor could not get Miss Russell to say that any woman would know the difference, but she knew it.
"Now," said the Governor, "this tearing up of the dress was in bright daylight?"
"Yes, sir."
"Did you see any blood on that dress?"
"No."
"Not a drop?"
"She held it with the edge of it toward me," said the witness, "and I could see that the edge of it was soiled."
Here it occurred to the Chief Justice that the jury needed to stretch its legs, and so he ordered a recess for five minutes.
When ex-Gov. Robinson again began to direct his fusillade of keen and subtle questions at the chief witness of the commonwealth he asked her if there was not a thorough search on the day of the funeral, Saturday, two days after the twofold murder, Miss Russell said:
"No, they did not search everywhere."
"Did they go to Miss Lizzie's room?"
"Yes."
"What did you see them do up there?"
"After they took up all the things on the bureau and opened one or two drawers they did not do any more." They opened what was called the toilet room. They went into Emma's room, and she saw them pressing against a spare pillow in a closet, and the bed was next taken to pieces. There was no objection or resistance. The public had full sway, and this was the case with regard to all the searchers.
"I never heard of any resistance," the Governor got Miss Russell to say.
To all appearances the prisoner was much less interested in the testimony than the most unconcerned among the persons in the court. She spent her time in examining her fan and putting the handle of it in her mouth and out again mechanically. District Attorney Moody, for the Government, had the witness returned to him, and after a little contention and strong objection on the part of the prisoner's lawyers, he got Miss Russell to say that Bedford cord is a cloth made of cotton and that it is a cheap material. That confirmed Mrs. Churchill's statement that when she reached the Borden house on the day of the murders the prisoner wore a cheap cotton dress.
"You saw no paint upon it?"
"No, sir."
"Couldn't it have been soiled with other things without your seeing it?"
"It could," said the witness.
The Government lays stress on the point that Lizzie Borden told a deliberate lie when she told several persons on the day of the crimes that her step-mother had received a note and gone out in consequence. The Government holds that she invented this lie to prevent an early discovery of the murder of the step-mother. Miss Russell had a story to tell about that. She testified that on the day of the murders Dr. Bowen made a search for that note, and declared to her and Miss Lizzie that he could not find it.
"May be she burned it," the witness suggested.
"Yes," said Miss Lizzie, "she must have."
"Now, then," said the District Attorney, "for what was that closet used, the cupboard in which part of Lizzie's dress lay, while she tore up the other part?"
"It was a closet for coal and wood," said the witness, "and I remember seeing some flatirons there."
That was the strongest part of the Government's case. It showed the full extent of the backbone of the theory that makes her the murderess of the old people.
John Cunningham, a Fall River newsdealer, who was the first man to whom Mrs. Churchill gave the alarm on the street, was next sworn. He was called by the commonwealth to swear that he and two reporters examined the grass and soil around the Borden house to see if they could discover the footprints of the assassin. He saw no tracks or footprints anywhere. This was part of the Government's proof that no one but an inmate of the house could have committed the crime.
Ex-Gov. Robinson turned that witness into a cipher by making him swear that he did not even see the footprints made by Mr. Borden that morning when he went under the pear tree and picked up half a dozen pears, nor did he see the tracks of Bridget where she had gone over the grass to the Kelly fence, where she had stood while chatting with the Kelly servant.
George W. Allen, a Fall River policeman, who was the first officer at the scene of the crime, testified to the fact that Miss Lizzie was not crying, and did not show a sign of tears. Up stairs he saw no person except Mrs. Borden—that is to say, no living person, for she was murdered. He went in the cellar also. He was led to say that only three feet away from where Mrs. Borden lay dead there stood a table bearing two books. There was no blood on it or the books. It will be remembered that there was other testimony yesterday showing that in other directions the man's blood had spattered more than eight feet away. The assumption is this testimony will be asked to show that the murderer need not have been bloody because this table was not. The Government holds that line of argument in check.
This witness was the means of bringing into the room the most horrible of exhibits yet seen. It is believed the progress of the case is to be punctuated with ghastly and horrible relics of the crime. The axes and hatchets shown on the first day were modest and commonplace beside this exhibit of to-day. It was a blood saturated handkerchief found near Mrs. Borden's body. It is believed to have been worn by Mrs. Borden on her head while at her housework and when she was murdered. The old policeman went through the house and noticed that the front door was doubly or trebly locked. Up stairs in the guest chamber he saw a handkerchief close to Mrs. Borden's body. It lay near her feet and reaching out toward the door.
District Attorney Moody took up a paper parcel and opened it before the witness. Out of the paper he took a large bandana handkerchief that was all but cut or torn in shreds, and that was all but stiff and wholly discolored with dried blood. In carrying this exhibit about the Essex District Attorney held it widely opened so that it hung like a scarlet banner before the general gaze. Then it was that the prisoner turned her head directly away from the horrible object. She cast her eyes down to the floor.
Francis H. Wickson, a deputy sheriff, who has been in the army and seen dead bodies on the battlefields, also saw the corpses of the murdered Bordens. It was his observation that the wounds on Mr. Borden on the morning of the murder were fresh. The blood was light colored, and he saw none of it coagulated. On Mrs. Borden's body the blood was coagulated and of a dark maroon color. The intent of this testimony was to prove that Mrs. Borden was killed before Mr. Borden had met his death. The manner of the distribution of the old man's wealth depends upon which died first, by the way. If Mrs. Borden died last the property would go to her heirs, but if Mr. Borden was killed last, as is apparently the case, the two daughters would inherit all the property. This defines the motive Lizzie Borden had in killing the couple in the theory of the Government.
Officer Wickson testified to looking over the fences around the Borden yard right after the discovery of the crime. He saw one man sawing wood on the other side of one fence and two men at work in working clothes in another direction. They asked him what was the matter. This was part of the Government's effort to prove that no one but an inmate of the house committed the murders, that no one got away afterward, and that no one could have gotten away. What ex-Gov. Robinson did to weaken the force of that testimony was to make the witness admit that he did not go to the barn, or see any one else go to it, suggesting, of course, that the murderer might have been hidden in there.
A very important witness was John Fleet, the Assistant Marshal of Fall River, who made ex-Gov. Robinson very wroth at him by his apparent assumption that Miss Borden is guilty. He is a handsome and very shrewd man, but a typical dyed-in-the-wool policeman. On the day of the murder, to give his testimony, he saw Miss Lizzie and asked her if she knew anything about the murder. She said she did not. All she knew was that her father came home at about half past 10 or quarter to 11 o'clock, went to the sitting room, sat down, took out some papers and was looking at them. She was ironing some hankerchiefs in the dining room. She saw that her father was feeble, and went in to him, and advised and assisted him to lie down on the sofa. Then she went back to her ironing, and presently she went into the yard and up in the barn. She said she remained up in the barn about half an hour. She was up stairs over the first floor of the barn. She came down and went in the house, and found her father on the lounge in the position she had left him, but killed--or dead. Asked what she did, she said she went to the back stairs and called the servant girl. She was asked if Mr. Morse did the murders. She said she thought not, as he was away since early morning. Asked if the servant did it, she said no; that Bridget had gone up stairs before her father lay down and had not come down till after the murder. Asked if she had any idea who could kill her father and mother she replied: "She was not my mother, sir; she was my stepmother. My mother died when I was a child." She told the marshal about Mr. Clegg's calls upon her father about renting a store, and about her father's quarrel with a man who wanted to rent one of his houses for an improper purpose.
The hatchets and axes were brought in at this point. They were accompanied by the clanking and dashing that seems inseparable from being handled and that sounds terrible to those who sympathize with the prisoner and try to put themselves in her place. Miss Borden had been inattentive and drowsy up to that time, but now she raised her head and looked at the weapons with some show of interest. The other day she lowered her eyes when they were in the room. The assistant marshal went on to describe how, as soon as he could do so, he sent men to cover the roads and to visit the depots so as to intercept any fleeing criminal if possible. After that he went up to search Lizzie's room. Dr. Bowen was in there with the prisoner. The door was shut and locked. The marshal knocked, and Dr. Bowen opened the door. He was told that the officers wished to search the room. The Doctor closed the door and locked it, then opened it again and said Miss Borden wished to know if it was absolutely necessary to search that room at that time. The marshal replied that it was. The Doctor closed the door, said something to the prisoner, and then opened the door and let in the officers.
The search then began. The witness asked Miss Lizzie if she had said she was in the barn half an hour. She replied she had said twenty minutes to half an hour. When asked what was the last time she saw her stepmother she replied, "At about 9 o'clock." Mrs. Borden was then in the room where she was found dead, and was making the bed.
At this point the prisoner leaned over to her counsel, Mr. Adams, and whispered to him. "She then said," continued the witness, "that some one had brought a letter or note to Mrs. Borden, and she thought she had gone out. She had not noticed her return. She said she hoped we would get through with this search quick, that it was making her tired, and we told her we would get through as soon as we could. We did not make a thorough search.
Then came what was meant to be sensational testimony about the finding of the hatchet with which the Government argues that the crime was committed. The two axes and the two perfect hatchets which are thrown aside as innocent by the Government were first found by the marshal's men, and it was not till later in the day that he came upon the handleless one in a box on a jog in the chimney. It was in the box with several tools. It was covered with a heavy layer of thick ashes while the other objects in the box were coated very differently with fine dust. Moreover, the handleless hatchet was covered with ashes on all sides; all over. The marshal did not notice all this at the time or think much of it. He put it back in the box, but afterward he went and got it, and the Government made it the star exhibit in the cause. District Attorney Moody led the marshal back to the dresses of Miss Lizzie, after he had examined the little hatchet blade and had testified that the handle was newly broken off from within the blade. On Saturday the marshal and his men searched the Borden house again.
"Did you see any dress with paint on it?"
"No, sir."
"How critically did you examine the dresses?"
"Very closely."
A hum ran through the court as the minds of the people grasped the fact that if he did not see the paint-soiled dress it must have been because it was skilfully hidden. Miss Lizzie Borden leaned over to Mr. Adams of her counsel and whispered to him again.
"Did you see any blood on any garment?" Mr. Moody asked.
"No, sir," said the assistant marshal. When ex-Gov. Robinson took hold of Assistant Marshal Fleet he did so as a terrier takes hold of a rat. He flew at him at least as if he meant to shake him. Fleet was cool and not easily angered, yet such was the manner of the formerly oily lawyer that Job himself could not have endured his tone and words with patience. The ex-Governor was short, stern, and sharp.
"You've testified before several times in this case. This time you have added to your former testimony. Don't you know you have? Don't you know how you have done it? Do you mean to deny it?"
Thus he tried to rustle the witness all over. He first charged that the witness did not name the same persons as being at the Borden house on the morning of the murder as he had named before. But that was not what the lawyer was after. He was angry at the man for introducing testimony against his client to the effect that she actually led her father to the lounge on which he was battered out of human semblance. The talk to and fro is not important enough to report, but it was hot. Finally the ex-Governor got the assistant marshal to admit that he had not made a very thorough search of Lizzie's room. "Not as thorough as it should have been," said the marshal. He asked the witness to characterize Dr. Bowen's manner of holding Lizzie's door when he went there to search the room.
"He seemed to be holding the fort," said the witness.
Then the Governor was, indeed, angry.
"Do you call that a proper way to answer my question?" he shouted. "It's the proper way to reply to your way of doing business," said the witness.
"You asked him to characterize it," said District Attorney Knowlton. The Chief Justice seemed by his manner to think that witness was not beyond his province and the battle went on. Next the Governor began to succeed in his purpose of muddling the officer. The witness had described his examination of Lizzie's dresses, and had said in the closet they hung behind a long white curtain, a covering like a sheet. Now he could not recall whether there was such a covering or not. He thought there was no such covering. Ex-Gov. Robinson made the most of this contradiction and uncertainty, because it tended to show that a man who was so uncertain about a chief fixture in the room could not be trusted as to whether or not he had examined the dresses carefully or had seen a paint-stained dress or not. Unfortunately for the plans of the vastly clever lawyer, it was then time for the night's adjournment, and the witness had to go away and cool down so that he will have to be brushed the wrong way all over again to-morrow. The white-haired jury keepers were summoned and sworn and charged to take the jury to a convenient place for the night. Then the old crier rose in his box and shouted: "Hear ye! hear ye! hear ye!" and told all persons having business with the court to depart and give their attendance at place at 9 o'clock next day. "God bless the Commonwealth of Massachusetts!" said the old man in conclusion.
The report describes defense attorney ex-Governor Robinson's courtroom tactics against police officer John Fleet, who found the hatchet and gave testimony damaging to Lizzie Borden. It details the prosecution's effort to establish the house was secured and locked, while the defense sought to undermine witness credibility through provoking anger and contradictions.
The Sun · 9 June 1893 · page 1
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
The prosecution's case at trial has narrowed the window for the murder to 8-13 minutes, during which Lizzie would have had to change clothes, break the hatchet handle, and clean the blade and herself. Dr. Bowen, the family physician and first person summoned after the murder, testifies that Lizzie told him she had been in the barn looking for metal and suspected her father's tenants of trouble.
The Sun · 9 June 1893 · page 1
nuurti to exactly fix the time ot tho murder of ($ Mr. Borden. It bus nt least narrowed thing vS down so Hint if Lizzie Borden Is the murderess ire she could have hud only from H to 13 minutes IM in whloh to conceal ull traces of tho murder of "tSi. her father after shoilldthebloodydeed.lDtblt 'ijil period of from H to 13 minutes sho must have 'if"jI either changed her dress or put another on vM over It.slie must havo broken tha lilckoryhandl H1 of u hatchet, anil ehe must have taken the KMt bloody blade of the weapon down Into thclM lar and rubbed lt a long whllo und thoroughly vU with ashes to remove th blood.
See moreSee less
Ot course, ', iesi shu had tow ash her fuee and hands and to &! attend to her hair mid clean her shoes all In '1'isssi the little space of time which Bridget Sullivan TH says she spout up stairs, and which accord i!P with the testimony of other witnesses, 'W?i The first witness ot thu day VTUBHeabury W. I Bovren. trie family physician ot the Borden, km who wns tha first person summoned by Mils rW Botdeuuftor the murder. Un is also tha first " Si j.ersun to testify that nothing In tha room ,ii' whero tho murdered porsons were found was Hdlstnrbed by tlio murderer. " I asked Lizzie i sovural times," he said, "'Have you seen it' anybody Y and her reply was. ' I have not"' i "Where havo you been V" the doctor askd. IK She said, "1 have been to the bnru looking for A rori." hhe then said she iwas afraid Tier fathor Ja had had trouble with his tenants, as she bad jM overboard unfriendly conversation with them M several times. 'S The doctor, was another person to whom ljbbbI Llrzle said that Mrs. Borden had cot a not '!- asking her to call and see a sick person. Tha f'iSM doctor went up and saw Mrs. Borden' ,iiMm
This editorial discusses the ongoing Fall River murder trial, reflecting on the moral implications if Lizzie Borden were guilty of killing her father and stepmother for money. It summarizes the defense's argument about physical impossibility and the prosecution's case based on locked doors and alleged motive.
The Evening World · 9 June 1893 · page 4
THE GREAT MURDER TRIAL
n the New Hedford Court-House. They I I fight not alone for n human life, but to decide whether humanity Is worse than the most debased Imnglnatloni. have ever painted It; whether natural ties are mere Illusions; whether the teaching" of education, religion and morality are valueless, and whrthcr the Influence of a decoious and quiet' If not a very happy family circle, dur ln ti long lifetime, counts for nothing beforo the promptings of sclllshnirs and cupidity. If Lizzie Borden, a young woman brought up In a New England home, attentive to her religious duties, play ing her pat.
See moreSee less
In life without scandal or reproof until she had reached her ' thirty-second year, would brutally mur der her father and her stepmother, for no other possible reason than because she coveted the moro speedy possession of their means than she would other ' wise secure, then al the teaching of humanity are reversed, and the girl who had been jespected all her life was a living lie, a monster without u single redeeming quality. The Falls River murder case U a peculiar 'one, and the Interest In It Increase! as the trial proposes. There are such distinct iheorles and Issues g Involved that It does not seem to be an
During the Lizzie Borden murder trial, testimony revealed that she burned a dress she claimed was paint-stained. The prosecution argued the dress was actually stained with blood.
Morning Appeal · 9 June 1893 · page 3
A. Lizzie Borden's Trial. New Bedford, Mass., June 8 In the Lizzie Borden murder trial it was shown that after the tragedy she had burned what she said was a paint stained dress. The prosecution seeks to Bhow that it was blood-stained.
The item reports that Lizzie Borden of near New Bedford, Mass., is on trial for the murder of her father and stepmother. It notes the jury was selected Monday, evidence is being presented, public opinion is divided, and promises a fuller account of the evidence in the next issue.
Sullivan Republican · 9 June 1893 · page 3
Miss Lizzie Borden of near New Bedford, Mass., is on trial for the murder of her father and her step mother. The jury was selected on Monday and the evidence in the case is now being taken. This case is quite famous, the sentiment of the people being about equally di vided. We will give a brief sketch of the evidence in our next issue. Daniel Keeler, S. Mead and Isaac T. Low auditors of Laporte twp., assisted by their clerk, Lee R. Gavitt, were looking up and audit ing the financial standing of the La porte twp., school fund, on Monday. The statement will be published in the REPUBLICAN in due time.
The piece announces that the trial of Lizzie Borden for the ax murders of her father and stepmother began Monday in New Bedford, Mass. It recaps the case background, noting the killings occurred near noon on August 4, that only Lizzie and the servant were home, and that police eventually arrested Lizzie after weeks of investigation.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Butler Citizen · 9 June 1893 · page 2
AT New Bedford, Mass., Monday, the trial of a celebrated criminal case was begun. It is the case of the Common wealth vs Miss Lizzie Borden, accused of the murder of her father and step-mother. The ol|dcouple were killed with an ax near noon of August 4th last; no other member of the family except Lizzie and the hired girl were at home at the time; the hired girl took sick during the morn ing and went to bed; Lizzie was seen in the parlor reading and shortly after she announced the murder to the girl.
See moreSee less
No body was seen entering or leaving the house, and the police, after waiting for weeks came to the conclusion that Lizzie was the gnilty party, and had her arretted. Her lather was wealthy, and both he and his wife were misers.
During the murder trial in New Bedford, Lizzie Borden fainted after the prosecutor concluded his opening address to the jury. Court adjourned to allow the jury to visit the Borden homestead in Fall River where the killings occurred.
The Columbian · 9 June 1893 · page 2
Lluie Borden Fainted. Ntw ErcroRD. Mass.. Juae 7 1 tiie Lizzie Borden marv!(r trial vest-rrdiiT vrbrr the prosecutor had closed hi oj-eiuf ad dress to tee jury in tbe cejt trui cun. Miss Borden Liinte-l and irm;u ia ax unconsrious condition for several Eiirvt When aha was restored to her cai.urJ stAte court adjourned to allow tie ry ic go to Fall Kiver to iaa:. tie Ecriti homestead where the tra-!iy for eris alls Borden is being tried occurred.
Dr. Bowen testified he prescribed increasing doses of morphine to Lizzie Borden after the murders and her arrest. Witnesses described the dress Lizzie wore and later burned, and an officer testified to finding a bloody handkerchief near Mrs. Borden's body, while the mysterious note summoning Mrs. Borden was noted as never found.
Pawtucket Tribune · 9 June 1893 · page 1
POINTS OF INTEREST AT THE FOURTH DAY OF THE BORDEN TRIAL
NEw BeEDprorp, Mass.,, June 9.—The fourt day of the trial of Lizzie Borden was opened With the testimony of Dr, Bowen. H: swore that he had prescribed morphine for I, zzie in increasing doses to allay mental distress from the time of the tragedy yntil and after her arrest for the crime. Mrs. Churchill testified that Miss Bor den wore a light blue and white navy blue diamond figured dress that fateful morn g, and that she saw no blood upon it. Miss Alice Russ:ll testified that she saw [Azzie Borden on Sunday morning after the crime with a dress that sbhe told her She Intended to Burn, as it was paint covered.
See moreSee less
The dress was of light blue Bedford cord, and at the time of th: conversation Miss Borden was stand ing tetween the closet door and stove in the kitchen, tearing up the waist; and the skirt was soiied on that portion which Miss Russ )i saw, A most important point brought out was
The report covers trial testimony about Lizzie Borden's blue dress that she said she intended to burn, a bloody handkerchief found near Mrs. Borden's body, and the mysterious note Lizzie claimed summoned Mrs. Borden away, which was never found or traced. It also details cross-examination of Dr. Bowen regarding morphine's effects on mental state, which the defense hoped would explain inconsistencies in Lizzie's initial statements to police.
Pawtucket Tribune · 9 June 1893 · page 1
Miss Russ )i saw, A most important point brought out was ltn th; testimony of Oflicer Allen that he 'oun In a Pool of Blood at Mrs. Borden's feet a handkerchief, which Mr, Moody exhibited in court. This handkerchief, it is understood, the government will endeavor to counect with Lizzie Borden, and if it succeeds in this it is evident that another very strong cir cumstantial point has been secured. The matter of the note which Lizzie Borden said Mrs. Borden received sum moning her to the house of a sick friend seems to be coming to the front., It is remembered that the note itself has never been found; and, unless the defense is keeping back the fact, neither the woman who wrote it nor the woman who was sick nor the messenger who carried it to the Borden house has ever come for ward or even been traced in any way.
See moreSee less
It is noted, ulso, that Dr. Bowen said that just before he went out to telegraph to Emma Borden, lLizzie told him Mrs, Borden bhad received the unote and gone out, Mrs. Churchill, however, testified that immediately after that Lizzie asked her to go up stairs and look for Mrs. Borden, as she thcught «he had heard her come in, Neither Dr. Bowen nor Mrs, Churchill,nor Bridget Sullivan nor Miss Russell, how ever, seem to have heard her come in, although they had all been there with Lizzie. In regard to Dr. Bowen and his Morphine Treatment 9 it at once became evident that the defense was going to rely on this to rebut Lizzie's ptory at the star chamber hearing in the police station. MAdams was very slick in delucing this choice point when he asked the doctor if doctors did not know the effect mor phine had upon a person, then adding: *'lt gives them mental irresponsibility and hallucinations, does it not ?”’ “Tt does if they are not used to it, and M ss Borden had never taken any to my knowledge,” replied the doctor, with a smile of satlsfaction at saying something to hurt the prosecution.
The report describes confusion arising from courtroom testimony about whether police immediately searched the barn after the murders were discovered. It notes the prosecution's claims now appear uncertain, and raises the possibility that a stranger had been lurking near the property.
Pawtucket Tribune · 9 June 1893 · page 2
seocond class matter. | THE BORDEN MYSTERY. ‘ The unfolding of the Borden murder drama continues the sensation of the hour in Massachusetts. The smallest symptom of trepidation on Lizzie Borden’s part is already construed by the public as evi dence of guilt. It s pretty clear that the roasses believe her culpable. Yesterday’s testimony tends to confuse, rather than to clear, the situation., The prosecution is now hazyas to some of its claims, notably as to its assertion that the local police had at once searched [the barn when summoned to the scene of the crime. It now appears possible that a stranger may have been lurking about the place.
A filler item quotes the New London Telegraph joking that newspaper engravings of the attorneys and of Lizzie Borden herself all make them look like murderers. This brief aside reflects the intense press caricature coverage during her trial.
Pawtucket Tribune · 9 June 1893 · page 2
The Telegraph of New London says: “The newspaper cuts of the attorneys for and against Miss Borden and Miss Borden herself make them all look llke murder ers.” The Cumberland Democrats didn’t ap pear to be “in it at all "yesterday. Evi dently they got frightened too soon. The Aldermanic meetings will be liveller than ever when Mr. Adams gets back with his fish stories. The Attleboro people are now clamor ing for §1.50 gas.
The report describes how the Lizzie Borden trial has captured unprecedented public interest in New England, with people closely following the evidence and arguments from both prosecution and defense. It notes this interest stems from genuine hope that Borden will be proven innocent, distinguishing it from mere sensationalism.
The Providence News · 9 June 1893 · page 3
Mr. James O'Connell of Boston is vis lu:g Mr. and Mrs, £ Schreier at New po PR e Mrs, J. J. Post of New York has ar rived at her cottage in Newport for the season. 7 Probably there has never been a mur der trial in New England that absorbed such a large proportiou of the interest of everybody who reads newspapers as does the Borden trial. Almost every person one meets about towu is fully posted re
This compiles editorial reactions from papers across the country debating the strength of the circumstantial case against Lizzie Borden, including doubts about motive and the hatchet evidence. It also notes a setback for the prosecution after testimony revealed the side door was left unfastened during the crime window.
The Providence News · 9 June 1893 · page 3
Lizzie Borden is charged without the strongest possible motive. But in this case no motive whatever isshown, and the fact that none was claimed to exist indicates * hat may prove the weakest point in the entire case, Springfield Union. Interest in the Borden trial is not con fined to New E gland. luws details oe cupy the first pluce in the newspapers all over the coun'ry. It is a real cause celebre, ard its outcome is awaited with a wider apxiety than has marked the progress of any murder trial for a quar ter of a eentury.—Boston Herald.
See moreSee less
It already begins to look as if the pros ecution in the Borde: case might as well supply the jury with tiles of last year's newspapers and rest the case for the stute. They could thus give an intelli: gent verdict on a!l the evidence without the bother of listening to twice-told tales, Boston Post.
This item collects commentary from various papers about the ongoing Borden trial in New Bedford, including criticism of public curiosity and the trial's location. It notes that Bridget Sullivan's testimony about the unlocked side door punched a hole in the prosecution's case.
The Providence News · 9 June 1893 · page 3
acame of ball by two picked nines from ot the city chuiches will be rune for of the demise of the queen. the club, The wagons will leave from fifte un m 1 utes at 2o'clock as a welcome Carroll Street nall at 9 o’clock a. m. to the visitors and as a voiifieation to tue : 3 : citiz:ns of the citisens of their arrival, Coomudore E. D. Morgin will meet the It is not the intention of Kt., Pev. officers nnd crew at the New York Yacht Bishop Clark and his colleagues on the clubhouse, atter which they will be pre committee appointed to urze the mayor sented to the eity committee’ The whole and city and town councils to take ineqs party will steu be taven for a drive ures to prevent the desecration of Sun around the eity, Duriug the afternoon day during the summer seaso: to int r % b nd concert will be given in Touro fere with Su.
See moreSee less
day exvursions. W ha! they park and the visitors will be giveu a are almicg at are the opeu bars, Suunday sold there stute. They could thus give an intelli: gent verdict on a!l the evidence without the bother of listening to twice-told tales, Boston Post. Womanly curiosity in its worst form is daily manifested at the trial in New Bedford. Housewives whose home duties engnuge nearly all of their ttention are puzzied to know how e morbidly curi ous who are wasinz valuabie hours in a court room manag: to get the time in whicnh to do is.—~F il River Herald, A considerable hle was punched in the governinent’s case 1n the Borden trial by the testimony of the Sullivan girl that the side door was unfastened during a considerable period while she was wash ing windows out of sight of the door,— Lowell Courier.
The report from New Bedford, Mass. states that jury selection has begun in the case against Lizzie Borden for the murder of her father and stepmother. It notes the case is already famous and is expected to attract further attention, with top legal talent involved.
The Mitchell Capital · 9 June 1893 · page 7
Lizzie Borden on Trial
Died of His Injuries. RED WING, Minn., June 6.—J. S. Allen, local agent of the United States Express company, died at 6 a. m. as the result of injuries inflicted upon his head April 28 by some unknown person. He did not fully recover from the delirium which affected him soon after his injury. No. traceof the person who committed the assault has been found. liizzie Bordeu oil Trial. feS NEW BEDFORD, Mass., June 0.—The I work of selecting a jury in the case of I the state against Lizzie Borden for the murder of her father and stepmother has begun. The case is already famous, and promises to become even more so. The best legal talent of the state is en eased in th" case.
A short item notes the Lizzie Borden case is on trial in the Superior court of New Bedford, Massachusetts. It states she is charged with killing her father and stepmother at Fall River in August 1892.
The Bolivar Bulletin · 9 June 1893 · page 2
The famous Lizzie Borden case is on trial in the Supe rior court of New Bedford, Mass. Defendant is charged with killinc her father and step-mother at Falls River, August, 1892. David A. Nunn, collector of internal revenue for the nth district, of Tennessee.
Lizzie Borden's trial begins in New Bedford, with a recap of the case: her account of helping her father onto the lounge, removing his boots, and later finding him murdered after a stint in the yard and barn. The report notes a contradiction, as a photograph of the body showed Andrew Borden's boots were still on his feet, conflicting with Lizzie's story.
The Daily Herald · 9 June 1893 · page 2
1ZZ1B BORB9EW8 TRIAL The SFanous Murder Case Be fore the 1itbllc New BoJlord Mass Jane 5 Tod y Lizzie Borden took her seat in tiie prisoners docket of the snpe rior court here and a battle royal between the moat eminent criminal lawyers in this slate with a wo mans life and iionor at stake be fiip Briefly put the case stands as f Jul low Lizzio A Burden daughter of Andrew Jackson Borden a woman about 33 years old her stepmoth er Abby Durfee Bonier and Brio get Sullivan a servant were the oniy members of the family about the house when Mr Burden came homo atahont 20 45 onthe morn inir of the 4h of Au nst1892 on wlrch day Mr Borden and his wife
The report reviews the murder details, autopsy findings, and the timeline of Lizzie Borden's arrest, inquest, grand jury indictment, and arraignment leading up to her trial. It describes preparations at the courthouse in New Bedford as the trial begins before Chief Justice Mason and associate justices.
The Daily Herald · 9 June 1893 · page 2
T53WPM 5pv STP n r < all the morning but members of familv at intervals It is claimed that about the time Mrs Burden met her death in the guest chain ber on the north side of the house the servant was washing ou the doors on the south side of the house It has been demonstrated conclusively that the death of Mrs Borden occurred in a very short time after he entered the house and if Lizzies story ie correct someone did it while she was in the barn while Bridget was in the yard and while Mrs Bordens life less body was laying in the room above her husband Nobody was seen to enter the house No in strument has been discovered which tits the case but the government claim and will attempt to prove that circumstantial evidence points to Lizzie A Borden as the mur deress and that the evidence is suflieiently strong to convict Miss Burden wag arrested two weeks after the minder and has since been hold in the Tannton jail except a few days during the preliminary hearing before Judge Blaisdell at the close of which she was held for the action of the grand jury On Tuesday November 15 the grand jury met at Tunutun and a largo number of witnesses wore examined On the lSth he jury went to Fall River and viewed the pre mises and was dismissed the fol lowing Monday to ait again De cember 1 On Friday December 2 indict ments were found against Miss Borden charging her with the mnr deis an indictment was also found against others who were charged with conspiracy to defeat the ends of justice This latter indictment was drawn up by a Taunton law yer and also by Assistant District Attorney liurd ofBoston On the 8th of May Miss Borden
A digest of miscellaneous late telegrams covers topics from the Chicago World's Fair to cholera and crop reports. Among the items is a brief note that the Lizzie Borden trial continues, with testimony described as not material.
San Antonio Daily Light · 9 June 1893 · page 3
LATE TELEGRAMS BOILED DOWN FROM PRIVATE SPECIAL AND OTHER SOURCES
SOURCES. Medina votes no license, 54 to 17. The treasury situation remains unchanged. Modocs of St. Louis beat Galves ton crew at Houston. Half the business of Fargo was burned up and 3,000 are homeless. The Lizzie Borden trial contin ues, testimony not material. The new Guatemalan minister presents his credentials. There will be no Pond issue un less authorized by congress. Cholera is rapidly spreading to the Mediterranean trade ports. The Chicago Fair remains open pending an appeal. . Eulalie is astounded at the mag nificent Columbian exposition. There were 200,000 people at the Chicago Fair grounds last night.
See moreSee less
The fire-piece representing Eula lie[at Chicago was 60 by 80 feet. , | i Hawaii is confident of an Ameri can protectorate. Wheat breaks down to 63 cents Chicago. World’s.' temperance congress
At the New Bedford trial, witnesses including Dr. Bowen, Bridget Sullivan, and Alice Russell were examined, and prosecutors unexpectedly produced a blood-stained, partially burned handkerchief said to have been found near Mrs. Borden's body, shaking Lizzie Borden visibly. The defense countered by noting no blood stains were found on the dresses as the prosecution had claimed.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Salt Lake Herald · 9 June 1893 · page 1
TRYING LIZZIE BORDEN
r1o Brother of tho Duku of Veragu Stricken Down at Columbus COLUMBUS 0 June SA sensational Fvent marked the close of the school chil drens parade today in honor of the Duke of Varagun The dukes brother was stricken with angina pectoris and fell i prostrate on the grand stand He suffered frightful agony and the attack seemed likely to result fatally owing to the ter rilie crowd of spectators and the inabilty r of the authorities to1 force back the people 1 to give the nobleman air 4 tt Bishop Waltersoo stood rSady to admiii black and dirty and half destroyed and looked as i an attempt had been made to burn it The examination of the officer developed the fact that the handkerchief was found lying a little away from Mrs Bordens body and that it was covered with blood When this fact was brought out the
The courthouse was packed as the trial resumed, with Lizzie Borden seated near her counsel before court began. Dr. Bowen testified, denying he had ever claimed Mrs. Borden died of fright or in a faint, with cross-examination beginning.
Richmond Dispatch · 9 June 1893 · page 1
side of college premises, | | The two bluescoated representatives of the local police were carried off their reet and whirled along with the resistiess petticoated surge from balow until several deputy sheriffs jumped down to their rescue ana turned the tide. The result was that the pushers wore kept out | entirely, while those who actad in a fairly decent | manner ware allowed the covetod privilege of fighting for seats inside. Miss Borden was in her aeat fifteen minutes befor the Court came in, and eagerly looked | over tha contents of a big, ofleial-looking en | volope, which sha afterward passed to Governor Robinson.
See moreSee less
All her counsel were early on hand, { and the jury were in their seats befors counsel | | | for the prosecution showed up at all, | Just as the Court came in and the crier was i making his proclamation Miss Borden was pass. | ing from her geat fu the dock toa seat within the par enclosure heat te her counsel. She was ob. | Nigel to stand almost beside Judge Blodgett { whila the crier was talking.
A witness testifies about Lizzie Borden's cheap light-blue cotton dress, with cross-examination by Governor Robinson failing to shake her account. The prosecution produces a handleless hatchet found in the cellar covered in dust and ashes, theorizing it was the murder weapon, while an officer testifies about searching Lizzie's room and clothing for blood.
Richmond Dispatch · 9 June 1893 · page 1
VERY IMPORTANT TESTIMONY
that Lizzio committed the murdors with this | bLatchet. A fragment of tho handle showed a frosh break. Ane outside cellar-door was locked, and part of tho prosecution’s theory is that the hateuet mast have been placed in tho cellar by some ons fnsite the house, Oficor Fleet, wuo teastited to finding the hatchet hoad, also teasing to searching Lizzie Borden's root on the day the marder was dis. | covered. In Lis cross-oxamination he sald tbat he theueht ho could have seen blood on the
At the Borden trial, Dr. Bowen testified he never said Mrs. Borden died of fright, and cross-examination revealed he had prescribed increasing doses of morphine to Lizzie before and after her arrest. Bridget Sullivan was recalled and denied earlier testimony that she saw Lizzie in tears, with Mrs. Churchill's testimony following and Alice Russell's account of the dress burning next.
A witness testified about Lizzie Borden's alleged statement regarding burning a dress, and about a cheap light-blue cotton dress she had worn in spring. The prosecution produced a handleless hatchet found in the cellar covered in dust and ashes, with Officer Fleet testifying about searching her room and seeing no blood on her clothes.
This report covers the opening of Lizzie Borden's murder trial in New Bedford, describing the prosecution's statement of the case and early testimony. Maid Bridget Sullivan details her movements washing windows and interactions with Lizzie on the morning of the murders.
The Roanoke Times · 9 June 1893 · page 1
New BEDFORD, Mass., June 7 ?The trial of Miss Lizzie Borden for the mur? der of her father and Mrs. Borden, her stepmother, on the 4th of last August, is one of absorbing interest. The prosecution made a detailed statement of the crime and what they proposed to prove, and now court and jury are trying to unravel one of tbe greatest mysteries of modern jurisprudence. Bridget Sullivan detailed at length the movements of the various members of the Borden household during the morning of the day of the crime. After breakfast Mrs Borden asked her to wash the windows. That was about U
Bridget Sullivan recounts her movements washing windows inside and outside the house, describing interactions with Andrew and Lizzie Borden before the murder was discovered. She details timing, including hearing the city hall clock strike eleven, and being called downstairs by Lizzie's cry that her father was dead.
The Roanoke Times · 9 June 1893 · page 1
any boll ring. "Wben 1 left Mr. Borden in he did not speak to me; he had a parcel in his hand; when he went into the dining room he sat in a chair at the head of the lounge and I went on washing my windows: Miss Lizzie came down stairs about five minutes after and went into i the dining room: I heard her ask her father if he had any mail, and she told him tbat Mrs. Borden had received a note and had gone out. "Then Mr.
See moreSee less
Borden took the key of his bedroom and went up the back stairs. Woen he came down soon after he tcok a rocking chair in the sitting room and \ 1 went on washing my windows, this i 1 time in the dining room. While I was : doing this Lizzie came into the dining room, took an ironing board from the j kitchen and placed it in position. She asked me if I was ecing out tbis after j noon and 1 said I did not think I was. I She says: "Well, if you do be sure and ' lock the doors, for Mrs. Bordenhasgone out. on a sick CS.11, and 1 may go out my ' self. I "Thon I went up to my room and laid i down. The first notice I took of any time was when I beard the city hall clock striko 11. I think I had been there three or four minutes; don*t think I went to sleep; heard no noise, am able to hear the opening and closing of the screen door if it is done by a careless
Bridget Sullivan testifies about hearing Lizzie call her downstairs after finding Andrew Borden dead, and the subsequent discovery of Abby Borden's body upstairs. Alice Russell then testifies that she saw Lizzie Borden burning a light blue dress days after the murders, claiming it was paint-stained.
The Roanoke Times · 9 June 1893 · page 1
"I did not, and she told me to go for Dr. Bowen. I did not find Dr. Bowen. Tuen 1 went to the corner of Second and Borden streets for Miss Russell, and she was not there; then 1 found where she did live and told ber what Lizzie wanted. I guess 1 ran to Dr. Howen's but I don't know. When I same back I found Mrs. Cburchiil. "I sa'd when I came br.ck that if I knew where Mrs. Whitehead lived I woujd go and tell Mrs. Horden, if she was there, that Mr.Borden was very sick, and Lizzie Baid/Oh, Maggie,I am ala ost sure I beard her come in; go up Ptairs and see if she is there.'
See moreSee less
I said, 'I will not go upstairs alone,' and Mrs. Church? ill went up with me. When I got high enough on the stairs to see into tbe ? room 1 saw the body on tbe Moor and ran in and stood by the foot of the bed: tbe door was wide open; 1 did not make any examination of Mrs. Borden's body." Alice Russell testified to seeing Lizzie Borden burn the light blue dress which the prosecution maintain she wore the morning of the murders. Sne burned it tbe Sunday after the murders, saying it was stained with paint. Witness went i out and came in again and saw Li v. >? standing nea* the cupboard door uliI tearing or ric;!.ng a small portion of the dross The sKirt was lying on tbe si elf. WitnesB said: 'I would not let anybody see you do that," to wbicb 1 Lizzie said nothing, but moved back one step towa*d the cupbourJ door. Afterwards witness sa d, '1 a'i' afr&: ?
The item reports that the trial of Miss Lizzie Borden for the murder of her father and stepmother began Monday at New Bedford, Massachusetts. It is one of several short news items in a weekly roundup column.
Shenandoah Herald · 9 June 1893 · page 2
Memorial Day at Wicchester. The Virginia populist convention to n-winate a full State ticket is to be held in Lynchburg, Aogust 3rd. The trial of Miss Lizzie Borden for the marder of her father and step-mother
The report announces that Lizzie Borden's murder trial began in New Bedford, Massachusetts, with a jury panel of twelve men selected on the first day. It then recaps the background of the case, describing the household, the discovery of Andrew Borden's body, and Lizzie's account of finding him after returning from the yard.
Vermont Phœnix · 9 June 1893 · page 7
HISTORY OF THE CASE. A JURY QUICKLY IMPANELED. OUTLINE OF THE GOVERNMENT'S CASE AND THE EVIDENCE.
Hi'ler History or the Case. The horrible murders for which Miss Borden Is charged were committed at the Borden homestead In Fall Illver between tho hours of 0:30 and Il::t0 a. m. Aug. 4, 1802. Tho inmates of the household were Mr. and Mrs. Borden, Lizzie Borden, and Bridget Sullivan, the domestic. Ill feeling existed between Miss Borden and her father and stepmother on account of trouble over the division of some property. There Is an older sister, Emma, not living at home. On the morning of the murder Mr. Borden went out soon after breakfast.
See moreSee less
Bridget -was engaged outdoor washing windows and Lizzie was engaged with va rious matters outdoor and in. When her father came home toward noon she made him comfortable on the lounge, and then went Into the yard, gathering and eating some pears, being gone 10 or 15 minutes. On her return she found that her father had been murdered and called the servant, sending her at once for Dr. Bowcn, who lived near by. Then she sat down on the outside steps and was thus seen by Mrs. Addle Churchill, a neighbor, and asked what the matter was. She told Mrs. Churchill of the murder of her father. Mrs. Churchill came to the house at once and asked for Mrs. Borden. Lizzie an swered that she thought her stepmother was not In, as she had received a message that morning from a friend on whom she thought she had gone to call. Bridget was requested to look for her mistress, but she objected to going alone and Mrs. Churchill went with her. As the two women ap proached the top of tho stairs leading to the second lloor, they saw, on the floor of the guest chamber, the body of Mrs. Bor den. It was soon learned that she, too, had been murdered In about the same man ner her husband had been, viz. : with sever al blows from some heavy, sharp Instru ment, probably an axo or a hatchet. The bodies were horribly hacked and gashed. Miss Borden was arrested two weeks aft er the murder, and has since been held in Taunton jail, excepting a few days during the preliminary hearing before Judge Blalsdell, at the close of which she was held for the action of tho grand jury. Public opinion has been sharply divided as to Miss Borden's guilt. Those who have maintained her innocence declare that, for lack of any other solution of the crime, the officials have entered into a conspiracy to convict her. Others who have studied the case closely believe that it is impo$ible for any other person to have committed the murders. The theory is, of course, that In the absence of her father, she at tacked and killed her stepmother, and that after her father's return she killed him while he was lying on the lounge. Throughout these 10 months she has re gained a remarkable composure.
The report recaps the discovery of the murders and the theory that Lizzie killed her stepmother first, then her father upon his return. It then describes District Attorney Moody's opening statement at trial, including the sensational claim that Lizzie burned a dress, and the jury's visit to the Borden house.
District Attorney Moody opened the state's case against Lizzie Borden, alleging she burned a dress and detailing the murder theory, which visibly distressed her. Witnesses John Morse and Bridget Sullivan testified, with Sullivan's cross-examination by ex-Gov. Robinson actually helping the defense by describing normal family relations.
Vermont Phœnix · 9 June 1893 · page 7
The Trial. At Tuesday morning's session of the court District Attorney Moody outlined the case for the state. He gave In detail the reasons for believing Lizzie Borden guilty, and produced a sensaton by saying that the state would prove that Lizzie Bor den burned the dress which she had on the morning of the murder, giving as a reason to Mrs. Churchill that It was covered with paint. Afterward, while the detectives were at work on the case, her sister Emma said: "Lizzie, that burning of the other dress was a big mistake.
See moreSee less
You ought not to have done it." This visibly affected Miss Borden, and she nearly fainted as Mr. Moody closed. In the afternoon the jury were taken to Fall Biver to examine the Borden house and premises. .The Kvldelice. The most Important witnesses examined on Wednesday were John V. Morse, an un cle of Lizzie Borden, and Bridget Sulli van, the Irish domestic. Mr. Morse Is a man (50 years old, a plain, blunt Iowa fanner, who has lived in Massachusetts for three years past. He was a visitor at the Borden's on the day and night tieiore tne murder. He left in the morning, but re turned toward noon and was in the yard when the murders were discovered. But the main point of his testimony was that after he went to his own room the night before ho heard some one come p the stairs and enter Lizzie's room. This was before Lizzie had retired. A leading question raised by the defence is its to whether any other person than Lizzie Borden had an opportunity to com mit tho crime. In this connection the back screen door plays an important part, the question being whether it was kept fastened so that no stranger could have en tered from the outside. Mr. Morse testi fied that he came and went by that door and the lock was defective, so that It did not catch unless tho door was slammed. Anyone could open it by turning the knob sharply. Bridget Sullivan's evidence had been ex pected to make a great sensation and to be very damaging to Miss Borden. B7 ex Gov. Bobinson's skilful handling of her cross-examination, however, her evidence helped Miss Borden lather than other wise. She could not say that the Borden family had not lived happily together. She had known of no trouble and no augry talk. Lizzie Borden and her stepmoth er had talked together In the usual way on the morning of Aug. 4. Mrs. Borden sent Bridget after breakfast to wash the windows. She was not suro that the screen door was fastened alter ner, ana sho spent some minutes talking to a neigh bor's domestic with her back turned to the house, so U t there was ample chance for anyone to have entered the house tinner celved. She becamo tll.before her outdoor work was done and went upstairs and lay down. She heard the clock strike 11 and very soon after Lizzie called cut to her to come down tor her tamer was tiean. Bridget's examination occupied much less time than was anticipated. The other half-dozen witnesses of the day testified on unimportant points, as to having seen Mr. Borden on the morning of the murder, etc. It was proved that Lizzie Borden was at home the night before, when It had been claimed that she was out trying to buy prussic acid. Some evldenco was also given, bearing on the burned dress and to show what dress Lizzie wore on the morn ing of the murder.
The trial of Lizzie Borden began Monday at New Bedford, with the first day spent selecting a jury. The jury then viewed the Borden premises in Fall River, and testimony began Wednesday, with the trial expected to last several weeks amid intense public interest.
The Londonderry Sifter · 9 June 1893 · page 1
The trial of Miss Lizzie Borden commenced at New Bedfordj Mass., on Monday. The first day was con sumed in getting a jury. Tuesday the jury was takcu to i' nll River to view the Borden premises, and on Wednesday the real work, the tak ing of testimony was begun. The trial may last seveial weeks and will be watched with intense interest by thousands who believe (hat Miss Bor den is innocent and that site has been shamefully abused by the common wealth of Massachusetts. The general financial situation is growing serious.
See moreSee less
Failures by the dozen are reported daily, principally in the West. Gold is' rapidly leaving us crowded out by the white metal and we'll soon be left with only the big white dollar with its "Iu God we trust." - '
At the New Bedford trial, Dr. Bowen denied claiming Mrs. Borden died of fright and admitted giving Lizzie morphine that could cause memory loss or hallucination. Bridget Sullivan and Mrs. Churchill were cross-examined about Lizzie's appearance and demeanor after the murders, with Alice Russell called next.
Wheeling Register · 9 June 1893 · page 1
Most Important Thus Far. New Bedford, Mass., June 8.—The court house was rrowded to repletlou again to-day, a majority of the specta tors being females. Dr. Bowen, the first witness, stated nothing new In the direct examination, except to deny that be had ever said Mrs. Borden died of fright or in & faint. Cross-examined by Adams the fact came out that the witness had provided morphine for the prisoner to allay ner vous excitement, first In ordinary doses; afterwards in double doses, continued to the time of her arrest and afterwards in the station house and before the ex amination at the inquest, and that mor phine so described had a tendency to affect the memory and produce hallu cination.
See moreSee less
The examination lasted a lit tle over an hour. Bridget Sullivan was recalled for re cross-examlDation. She testified that she saw Lizzie In tears when she called her down stairs just after the murder, and denied she bad ever stated so, as shown by her testimony in the prelimi nary hearing. Mrs. Churchill was called next.
Witnesses Alice Russell and Officer Allen testify about Lizzie burning a dress after the murder and a bloodstained handkerchief found near Mrs. Borden's body. Officer Fleet also testifies about searching the barn and dresses for blood evidence.
Wheeling Register · 9 June 1893 · page 1
VERY ODD WAY TO INTRODUCE IT
Mrs. Borden’s feet—between her feet aDd the window,” “Were there any marks on it?” Then came the answer that caused the prisoner to look as If she was about to collapse. "Yes,” were Allen’s words. “It was covered with blood.” “That’s all,” said the District Attor ney, as if It was an every day matter to produce a bit of evidence like that. During the time that the handker chief was talked about the prisoner picked at the tips of one glove with the other hand. When ex-Oovernor Robin son cross-examloed Alien, he did not ask a question about the bloody hand kerchief.
See moreSee less
Then Officer Fleet was put on the stand and told of his search in the barn. “Did you notice anything particular about the hay when you went up there the first time?”
Testimony at the Borden trial revealed that Lizzie Borden burned a dress after the murders and after police had searched the house, a dress they had not found. She claimed it was paint-stained, but the prosecution argued it was stained with blood.
The Cheyenne Daily Leader · 9 June 1893 · page 1
The Borden Trial. New Bedford, Mass., June 8. —In the Borden trial the testimony showed Lizzie Borden had after the tragedy aud after the search by the police burnt what she said was a paint stained dress and which the searchers had not found. The prosecution seeks to show it was blood stained dress.
The report describes a packed New Bedford courtroom during Lizzie Borden's murder trial, with crowds of spectators jostling for seats. It details servant Bridget Sullivan's testimony about locked doors and household conditions before the murders, and the start of cross-examination by ex-Gov. Robinson.
Paper unidentified · 10 June 1893 · page 1
BLOOD-STAINED GOWN.
It Figured Largely in the Trial of the Borden Murder Mystery Yesterday. At no time before since the trial of Lizzie Borden for the murder of her father and step-mother begun before the Superior Criminal court of New Bedford, Mass., has the attendance of curious spectators been anything like so great or the attendant rush for seats within the court room so deter mined and resistless. For a time the police found themselves utterly unable to check the mad rush of the horde of curious women who forced themselves forward to places of prominence just iu front of the prisoner’s stand.
See moreSee less
Indeed the officers were swept bodily aside by the irate females, but a posse of depu ty sheriffs appeared aud the fair curi osity seekers ejected iu large num bers. Court adjourned Thursday with Bridget Sullivan, the servant in the Borden household at the time of the tragedy, in the witness chair. She was dressed fashionably aud leaued to the left side against the rail, looked straight at Prosecutor Moody, aud spoke so low that be had to tell her to speak louder. The prisoner re mained leaning back in the seat, but changed posture so as to see the wit ness plainly and watched Bridget steadily with large eyes wide open. All the Judges watched Bridget carefully while she testified to bolting the cellar door on the inside two days before the murder, to hooking the screen door, to the sickness of the Bordens Wednesday and to her own conduct, and to the locked condition of the doors ou Wednesday night and Thursday morning before the murder. When ex-G ov. Robinson began to cross-examine he tried to show by the witness that the most pleasant rela tions existed in the family. Bridget said that the daughters did not come to the table with their parents. When Mrs. Borden spoke to them they spoke to her. She amended that in part subse quently by saying that the members of the family conversed together very often and that she had never heard them quarreling. “Now, did you say that Second street was a quiet street?”' was asked. “I don’t know,” Bridget answered. “I never heard any quarreling there.” The questioner then came down to the time after the murder. “Y'ou did not see any blood on her, did you?” he asked, referring to Miss Borden. “No, sir.” “Was her hair ruffled,'or any of her clothing disarranged?” “No, sir.” Bridget said she never heard a cross word in the house between Lizzie and Mrs. Borden. Robinson got her to admit she did not know whether she booked the screen door on the morn ing of the murder. Dr. Bowen, the physician first called after the murders, was the first wit ness yesterday. He told about how Lizzie met him aud informed him of the murders. He asked her if she bad seen any one about it, and she said she had not. When asked where she had been, Lizzie told tho witnesses she had been in the barn for a piece of iron. In ex planation of the murders she declared she was afraid her father had had trouble with some of the tenants. Nothing up to that time had been said about Mrs. Borden. The Doctor suddenly asked the girl about her mother, and she replied that she had received a note which bad called her from the house. When ho saw Lizzie that morning she had on a pink wrapper, a cheap one, but ho wasn’t prepared to des cribe it, except to say it was an ordi nary every-day dress. Ou cross examination, the Doctor said Miss Borden was very nervous for several (jays after the tragedy, and lie prescribed morphine, which might have affected her mind. Bridget Sullivan was recalled, and said tho house had been robbed a year before the murder. This evidence was stricken out. She denied that sfio had said at the inquest that she saw Lizzie crying after tho murder. Mrs. Adelaide Churchill, a neighbor of the Bordens, swore that Lizzie de clared her mother had gone out In response to a uote. She afterwards said she heard her mother go up stairs. The dress Liz zie had on that morning was a light blue one. Miss Allee Russell was tho most im portant witness of the day. She de tailed Miss Borden’s visit to her the ulght preceding the murder, tolling how Miss Borden had expressed her fears of something dreadful about to happen. Lizzie told her site felt as though she ought to sleep with one eye open, as her father had bad trouble with his men. The witness then des cribed the burning of a dress by Liz zie. Witness and Lizzie’s sister were present, Lizzie put the dress in the stove, saying it had paint on it. She seemed greatly frightened when her sister told her the police had questioned her about the dress. She said she was sorry she had burned it. Witness did not see any blood on the dress. Court then adjourned until the usual hour on the following day.
Bridget Sullivan testified about locked doors, the family's quiet relations, and seeing no blood or disarray on Lizzie after the murders. Dr. Bowen described being summoned by Lizzie, her explanation about being in the barn and a note calling her mother away, and her pink wrapper dress.
BLOOD-STAINED GOWN. It Figured Largely in the Trial of the Borden Murder Mystery Yesterday. At no time before since the trial of Lizzie Borden for the murder of her father and step-mother begun before the Superior Criminal court of New Bedford, Mass., has the attendance of curious spectators been anything like so great or the attendant rush for seats within the court room so deter mined and resistless. For a time the police found themselves utterly unable to check the mad rush of the horde of curious women who forced themselves forward to places of prominence just iu front of the prisoner’s stand.
See moreSee less
Indeed the officers were swept bodily aside by the irate females, but a posse of depu ty sheriffs appeared aud the fair curi osity seekers ejected iu large num bers. Court adjourned Thursday with Bridget Sullivan, the servant in the Borden household at the time of the tragedy, in the witness chair. She was dressed fashionably aud leaued to the left side against the rail, looked straight at Prosecutor Moody, aud spoke so low that be had to tell her to speak louder. The prisoner re mained leaning back in the seat, but changed posture so as to see the wit ness plainly and watched Bridget steadily with large eyes wide open. All the Judges watched Bridget carefully while she testified to bolting the cellar door on the inside two days before the murder, to hooking the screen door, to the sickness of the Bordens Wednesday and to her own conduct, and to the locked condition of the doors ou Wednesday night and Thursday morning before the murder. When ex-G ov. Robinson began to cross-examine he tried to show by the witness that the most pleasant rela tions existed in the family. Bridget said that the daughters did not come to the table with their parents. When Mrs. Borden spoke to them they spoke to her. She amended that in part subse quently by saying that the members of the family conversed together very often and that she had never heard them quarreling. “Now, did you say that Second street was a quiet street?”' was asked. “I don’t know,” Bridget answered. “I never heard any quarreling there.” The questioner then came down to the time after the murder. “Y'ou did not see any blood on her, did you?” he asked, referring to Miss Borden. “No, sir.” “Was her hair ruffled,'or any of her clothing disarranged?” “No, sir.” Bridget said she never heard a cross word in the house between Lizzie and Mrs. Borden. Robinson got her to admit she did not know whether she booked the screen door on the morn ing of the murder. Dr. Bowen, the physician first called after the murders, was the first wit ness yesterday. He told about how Lizzie met him aud informed him of the murders. He asked her if she bad seen any one about it, and she said she had not. When asked where she had been, Lizzie told tho witnesses she had been in the barn for a piece of iron. In ex planation of the murders she declared she was afraid her father had had trouble with some of the tenants. Nothing up to that time had been said about Mrs. Borden. The Doctor suddenly asked the girl about her mother, and she replied that she had received a note which bad called her from the house. When ho saw Lizzie that morning she had on a pink wrapper, a cheap one, but ho wasn’t prepared to des cribe it, except to say it was an ordi nary every-day dress. Ou cross examination, the Doctor said Miss Borden was very nervous for several (jays after the tragedy, and lie prescribed morphine, which might have affected her mind. Bridget Sullivan was recalled, and said tho house had been robbed a year before the murder. This evidence was stricken out. She denied that sfio had said at the inquest that she saw Lizzie crying after tho murder. Mrs. Adelaide Churchill, a neighbor of the Bordens, swore that Lizzie de clared her mother had gone out In response to a uote. She afterwards said she heard her mother go up stairs. The dress Liz zie had on that morning was a light blue one. Miss Allee Russell was tho most im portant witness of the day. She de tailed Miss Borden’s visit to her the ulght preceding the murder, tolling how Miss Borden had expressed her fears of something dreadful about to happen. Lizzie told her site felt as though she ought to sleep with one eye open, as her father had bad trouble with his men. The witness then des cribed the burning of a dress by Liz zie. Witness and Lizzie’s sister were present, Lizzie put the dress in the stove, saying it had paint on it. She seemed greatly frightened when her sister told her the police had questioned her about the dress. She said she was sorry she had burned it. Witness did not see any blood on the dress. Court then adjourned until the usual hour on the following day.
Witnesses at Lizzie Borden's trial testify about her behavior after the murders, including Dr. Bowen's account of her composure and explanations, and neighbor Mrs. Churchill's recollection of the note story. Alice Russell gives key testimony about Lizzie's premonitions the night before and her burning of a dress with alleged paint stains.
The trial of Lizzie Borden for the murder of her father and stepmother began in New Bedford, Mass., with Attorney Moody presenting the Commonwealth's case. He detailed the crime and cited instances suggesting long-standing ill will between Lizzie and her stepmother.
Honolclc, May 30. AfTa'ra political have quieted down during the past five days. Claus Spreckles created a sensation by demanding immediate payment of 195,000 owed him by the government. Tbe provisional government claim they will have no trouble meeting the demand and annexationists say they are dissatisfied with the protectorate and believe Blount's report favors this measure. Royolists say on the con'rary that the claim they made all along that there will be no annexation is verified and that tha queen will be reinst'.ted; also that the provisional government has been considering instructions to ha sent to Minister Thurston about the treaty of annexation, asking among other th'ngs that control of the government lands be left to the Hawaiian government, to be disposed of under a law similar to the United States laws, and also that United States take up ?900,000, Hawaiian silver coinage, and recoin it into American money.
See moreSee less
alarming rcmor. Among the alarming rumors floating about Honolulu is one to the effect the royalists are secretly arming and on June 11, Kamebemesa'a birthday, which is celebrated here as a national holiday, will attempt a coup de etat, and restore the queen to her throne. Although a few timid people profes3 to believe it the most of the annexation ists look upon it as a hoax and are paying no attention to it New Bedford, Mass., June G The trial of Lizzie Borden for the murder of her father and 6tep-mother in Fall River, began this morning, with the statement -f the case on behalf of the commonwea.th by Attorney Moouy, who rehearsed ths details of the crime and relattd many instances to show thai ill will long existed between Liz zie and her step-mother. New York. June 6. Booth's son said this afternoon Booth is rapialy sinking and will probably die before nightfall.
A short news item reports that conflicting testimony has been given during the trial of Lizzie Borden. No further details of the specific testimony are provided in this fragment.
Morning Journal and Courier · 10 June 1893 · page 3
CONFLICTING TESTIMONY GIVEN.
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
Assistant Marshal Fleet testified about finding hatchets near the chimney in the cellar and placing a claw-headed hatchet under the stairs. Ex-Governor Robinson's cross-examination revealed inconsistencies, including contradictions about ashes on the broken hatchet handle and admission that the initial search was not thorough.
Morning Journal and Courier · 10 June 1893 · page 3
LIZZIE BORDEN'S TRIAL
TeaUaaany. HiwBnrou, Mean., June 9. About cms-half of Che spectators In the oourt house at the trial of IixxU Borden this morning were women. The first witness oalled was Assistant Marahal Fleet, and his cross examination was resumed by Gover nor Robinson. He told about his visit to the Borden house, and that ha found O fl eers MuTlaly and Devine In th. cellar. He said: "I was told by MulleTy afterwards that the hatchets were taken from the middle cellar on the south aide. Those hatchets were found near the chimney In the me box where the broken-handled hatchet was found.
See moreSee less
In the middle room there was a five foot pile of ashes, near the chimney and near the box where the hatchets were found. I pat the claw-headed hatchet In the cellar room nnder the stairs; behind these were some boxes and a keg; that waa
Officers Fleet, Harrington, and Doherty testified about the condition of the bodies and the house after the murders, including Lizzie's account of finding her father and her composure at the time. Doherty described searching the house, finding a hatchet in the cellar, and a later conversation between Lizzie and Bridget about the cellar door.
Morning Journal and Courier · 10 June 1893 · page 3
LIZZIE BORDEN'S TRIAL
den houae and his wandering about It. "Mrs. Borden, when I saw her," said he, "waa lying face down. I lifted the head and looked at it. The farniture In the room waa not disturbed, that I remember. On the floor was a bunoh of hair as big as my net, wbion appeared to nave been cut off. Daring the afternoon I saw Miss Bor den in the kitchen. I asked her where ahe wae when thia waa done. She said It must have been while s be was In the barn; abs heard no outcries or screams, bat she heard a noise like aoraplrg.
See moreSee less
Then I had some talk with Bridget and Mr. MuUaly and I went about the honae and looked it over thor oughly, going into the rooms we fonnd open, and then we went down oellar where Mullaly found a hatchet. I think it waa tbe claw beaded one; then 1 went ont in tbe yard and then to the offioe. I saw Mlas Borden in her room that day before I went away. I went to her room and she
On the sixth day of the trial, Governor Robinson's cross-examination of Officer Fleet revealed contradictions about the handleless hatchet and ashes found near it. Fleet admitted the search of the house was not thorough and that he hadn't mentioned the hatchet at the preliminary hearing because he didn't think it was the murder weapon.
Waterbury Evening Democrat · 10 June 1893 · page 2
LIZZIE BORDEN'S TRIAL
MORE NEW WITNESSES EXAMINED Officer Fleet Blake Several Contradic tion In HI Croas-Examlnatlon Har rington Description of a Dress Cauea Merriment. New Bedford, Mass., June 10. When the doors of the Court House opened this morning for the sixth day of the Borden trial, a great crowd of women shoved their way into the building and occupied the seats which they have held for the past two days. Miss Borden was iu her seat at 8 :5, and
Defense attorney Robinson highlighted contradictions in witness testimony about the barn door and window conditions. A dispute arose over a broken hatchet handle piece that officer Mulloly said was found and replaced, which witness Fleet denied ever seeing, causing a sensation in court; additional witnesses testified about the police search and the inquest before court adjourned.
Waterbury Evening Democrat · 10 June 1893 · page 2
MORE NEW WITNESSES EXAMINED
Other witnesses called were Charles H. Wilson, a police officer, who described the search of the house, Annie M. White, tin stenographer who told what took place at the inquest and George A. Pettee, who tolii what he saw about the Borden premises ou the morning ot the tragedy. Xhen after Mrs. Churchill had been recalled andques tioned more about the burned up dres court adjourned because the government had no more witnesses at hand.
The report notes that Lizzie Borden, accused of murdering her father and stepmother in Fall River last August, is being arraigned for trial this week. It observes that there is no direct evidence against her and predicts the trial will last several weeks.
Middletown Transcript · 10 June 1893 · page 2
Lizzie Borden, charged with kill ing her father and step-mother at Fall River, Mass., last August, is arraigned for trial this week. The case is one of of great interest, there being no direct The The evidence against the accused, trial will be of several weeks duration.
The German-language report notes that Lizzie Borden's trial began Tuesday in New Bedford, Massachusetts, where she stands accused of killing her stepmother and father with an axe. It describes how she nearly fainted when the hacked skulls of the victims and the matching axe were displayed in court.
Washington Journal · 10 June 1893 · page 4
— In New Bedford, Mass., hat am Dienstag der Prozeß gegen Lizzie Borden, die feinerzogene Farmerstochter von Fall River begonnen, welche beschuldigt wird, ibre Stiefmutter und ihren Vater mit
The report announces the start of the sensational Fall River murder trial of Lizzie Borden, accused of killing her father and stepmother with a hatchet. It recounts her account of discovering the bodies after returning from the barn, including the timeline of her father's bank visit and death.
The Washington Bee · 10 June 1893 · page 4
LIZZIE BORDEN ON TRIAL FALL RIVER'S SENSATIONAL MURDER CASE NOW ON
Monday at Fall River, Mass. Lizzie Bor den, a young woman of 27 years, is held to answer for the murder of her father, Andrew J. Borden, 68 years of age, and her step-mother, Mrs. Abbie Borden, herjathers second wife. The tragedy was inexpressibly fiendish and bloody. Both victims were killed by blows of a hatchet or axe, and were terriblymutilated by repeated blows. JThe bodies of both Borden and his wife were discovered by Lizzie Borden, who with the servant, Bridget Sullivan,
The article recaps the discovery of Andrew and Abby Borden's mutilated bodies and the bloody crime scene, noting no weapon was conclusively identified despite two axes being found. It reviews why suspicion fell on Lizzie Borden, including the theory of a motive involving her father's intention to alter his will in favor of her stepmother, as her trial begins.
The Washington Bee · 10 June 1893 · page 4
MURDER CASE NOW ON
They found the walls, carpets and wainn coting of the rooms in which the mur ders were committed spattered with blood. It was almost an impossibility that the 'assassin could have escaped without having the clothing and person blackmail. smeared. An ax was evidently the deadly weapon, but although two were found in the house, neither had any blood stains on tliem. Suspicion settled, after several arrests, tendencies. on Lizzie Borden, because no attempt at been seen to leave the house by half a dozen or more neighbors, who would The examination into the murders re- ' since the war.
The piece reflects on the reliability of witness memory before describing Officer Fleet, a prosecution witness believed to think Lizzie Borden guilty, and his calm demeanor resembling Superintendent Byrnes. It then profiles defense attorney Governor Robinson's sharp, expressive cross-examination style and physical presence in court.
New-York Tribune · 10 June 1893 · page 2
EXAMINATION
Borden murdered her father and stepmother. In that sense he is plaivly a hostile witness. And yet there was nothing in his appearance or anguage whieh hinted at malevolence or vindictiveness. lle does not look unlike Superfatendent Byrnes, except that he is much youngr and more slender. He has the same quiet, dark eves, the sama oval face and swarthy complexion, the same dark, broad, drooping mustache and the same calm, half-interested demeanor. Tle spoke with the same deliberation and with that upward reflective look at the ceiling which seems so much to assist Mr. Lyrnes's memory.
At the New Bedford trial, defense attorney Robinson aggressively cross-examines Marshal Fleet, catching him in contradictions between his trial testimony and earlier statements at the inquest and Fall River hearing. Testimony also reveals the police search of the Borden house was conducted carelessly, with closets and trunks only glanced at.
New-York Tribune · 10 June 1893 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.
HATCHETS IN EVIDENCE. STATE WITNESSES CONTRADICT EACH OTHER.
CONFLICTING STORIES ABOUT THE WEAPON WITH WHICH THE MURDERS ARE ALLEGED TO HAVE BEEN COMMITTED-LIZZIE BORDEN LIKELY TO TESTIFY.
See moreSee less
[BY TELEGRAPH TO THE TRIBUNE.]
New-Bedford, Mass., June 9.—It was made plain to-day that Marshal Fleet and his assistants had searched the Borden house on that Thursday afternoon with anything but thoroughness. They looked into the clothes closet, where the women of the family kept their dresses. They glanced at the dresses, and felt of them, but did not examine them carefully. They paid little attention to the contents of the numerous trunks. The visit to the cellar, where the hatchet-head was found, was inquired into with especial scrutiny.
"Who was in the cellar when you went down there?" asked Governor Robinson.
The witness said that Officer Mullaly, Officer Devine and Dr. Dolan were there.
Q.—What were they doing? A.—Looking around.
Q.—Did you see the axes and hatchets then? A.—I did.
Q.—Where? A.—They were on the cellar floor.
Governor Robinson picked up the axes and hatchets and inquired if they were the ones he saw. Fleet said they were. "Did you see anything else of this character?" Fleet said he did not.
Q.—Then what did you do? A.—Stayed there a little while, looked around and talked.
Q.—This was the occasion of your second visit to the cellar? A.—Yes, sir.
Q.—Well, what then did you do? A.—I went out into the yard.
Q.—What, again? A.—Yes, sir.
Q.—What for? A.—To hear reports from my men.
Q.—After that did you go into the cellar again? A.—Yes, sir.
Q.—Who went with you? A.—Nobody.
Q.—Who was there? A.—Some officers were there, but I don't know who.
Q.—Was this the occasion on which you found something else in the way of a hatchet? A.—No, sir.
Q.—Wasn't it? A.—No, sir.
Governor Robinson looked sharply at the witness, and, turning to the table, picked up the hatchet-head, and held it high in view.
"When did you find this, Mr. Fleet?" he asked.
"On the occasion of my second visit," said Fleet.
Governor Robinson paused and looked sharply at him again. "Why didn't you say so when you were describing what you did on that occasion?"
"You did not ask me."
"Yes, I did."
"I did not so understand it."
"Do you understand me now? When did you find this hatchet-head?"
"On the occasion of my second visit." A DRAMATIC EPISODE.
The questions and answers following, which are a verbatim report of the proceedings will be found especially interesting and important as a prelude to one of the most dramatic and sensational situations that have ever occurred in a criminal trial.
Q.—When you saw this hatchet-head, where was it?
A.—In a box.
Q.—In with those hatchets over there, and those axes?
A.—No. They were found at one time and in one place. This I found at a later time and in another place.
Q.—But you say it was in a box. A.—Yes, sir.
Q.—And with other tools, you said? A.—Yes, sir.
Q.-And all covered with dust? A.—Yes, sir.
Q.—The room was an ashy, dusty room, wasn't it? A.—There were ashes there, but they were confined to a space of four or five feet.
Q.—Weren't the brickwork and box and everything else covered with ashes? A.—Yes, sir.
Q.—It was an ashy old place, wasn't it? A.—Perhaps so.
Q.—It isn't strange, Mr. Fleet, is it, that everything should be covered with ashes when ashes were constantly dumped there? A.—No.
Q.—Who took it out of the box? A.-I did.
Q.—Was anybody else there? A.—Mullaly was there, but I don't know whether he saw me or not.
It is to be noted here that the piece of wood which, when the hatchet-head was found, was fastened into it, being that end of the handle which was held in the iron, has since been taken out, presumably by the State, and for the purpose of chemical and other examinations. The head and this small piece of handle were now on Mr. Robinson's desk, and were constantly being picked up by him and held for the witness's inspection during his further examination.
Q.—When you found it this piece of handle was in the blade, wasn't it? A.—Yes, sir.
Q.—Who took it out? A.—I don't know.
Q.—Did you? A.—No.
Q.—This was all you found? A.—Yes, sir. Q.—Just th[i]s blade, and this little piece of handle? A.—Yes, sir.
Q.—And the iron on both sides was covered with ashy dust? A.—Yes, sir.
Q.—Was there any dust on the broken wood of the handle here where the break is? A.—It was a new break. I don't think there were ashes on it.
Q.—What did you do with it after you had looked at it? A.—I put it back in the box.
Q.—The box you found it in? A.—Yes, sir.
Q.—Did Mullaly see you do it? A.—I dare say he did.
Q.—Did you go off and leave it there? A.—Yes, sir.
Q.—You didn't do anything with it at all? A.—No, sir.
WAS IT THE ASSASSIN'S WEAPON?
The relation of this hatchet-head to the crime up to this point in the trial is simply that the length of the blade is identical with the length of the wounds on the bodies of Mr. and Mrs. Borden, though as that fact is only asserted, not proved, presumably the State will hereafter introduce the evidence of Professor Woods, of Harvard, to prove that fresh blood had been on it before it was covered with ashes. The reader of this dispatch will, however, when he has read it through, know as much about this hatchet as the jury yet does.
Two other hatchets, one with a long blade and claw-head, the other ordinary in size and shape, and both supplied with handles, and two axes, have been exhibited in the case. Thus far absolutely nothing has been said to show that the axes and the hatchet of ordinary size and shape had anything to do with the case. The claw-headed, long-bladed hatchet, however, when found by the officers was seen to have a red mark on the handle and a large rusty spot on one side of the blade. To these facts Fleet testified yesterday. Laying down the hatchet-head, and picking up the claw-headed hatchet, Mr. Robinson inquired:
Q.—Do you now see the red spot on the handle of this which you said was there when you found it? A.—No, sir; it isn't here now.
Q.—Who took it off? A.—I don't know.
Q.—Who has had possession of it since you found it? A.—I don't know.
Q.—Well, Lizzie Borden hasn't anyhow, has she? A.—No, sir.
Q.—You'll swear to that? A.—Yes, sir.
Q.—Was it a large or small spot? A.—It was a good-sized spot.
Q.—Dirt and blood? A.—I couldn't say.
Q.—Or paint? A.—It might have been blood or paint.
Q.—You saw a rusty spot on the blade too, didn't you? A.—Yes, sir.
Q.—Look at the blade now. Is it still there? A.—It does not seem to be there.
Q.—You were able to find it then? A.—Yes, sir.
Q.—But you can't find it now? A.—No, sir.
Q.—Who took it off? A.—I don't know.
Q.—Did you? A.—I did not.
Q.—And neither did Lizzie Borden, did she? A.—I think not.
Q.—She couldn't have done it, could she? A.—No, sir.
Q.—What did you do with all these four axes and hatchets when you found them? A.—I put back the two axes and this hatchet (indicating the hatchet of ordinary size and shape with a handle) where I found them. This hatchet (indicating the claw-headed one, on the blade of which there had been a rusty spot, and on the handle of which there had been a red mark) I laid aside.
This evidently was the point Mr. Robinson had been desirous of bringing out. He put down the claw-headed hatchet and again took up the hatchet-head and the little piece of wood belonging to it.
Q.—This hatchet-head was all covered with dust when you found it? A.—Yes, sir.
Q.—Both sides? A.—Yes, sir.
Q.—And there was dust also on the broken wood, wasn't there—in the break, I mean. A.—No, sir.
Q.—How's that? A.—There was no dust in the break. It looked like a new break.
Q.—But didn't you testify yesterday that there was dust in the break? A.—I think not.
Q.—If you did, was it true? A.—It looked like a new break.
Q.—I didn't ask you that. Listen, and I will read the stenographer's report of what you said yesterday. (Reading.) "There were ashes all over the hatchet, or, may be, dust, but it looked like fine ashes, and there was dust or ashes on the wood in the break." Did you say that? A.—I may have.
FLEET CONTRADICTS HIMSELF.
Q.—Well, what is the truth about it? Did you tell the truth then, or do you tell it now? A.—Well, I think—— (pausing).
Q.—Come, now, take your pick; have it either way; but make a choice. A.—There was no ashes on the break.
Q.—That's your answer, is it? A.—There wasn't much there anyhow.
Q.—Oh, you want to change again, do you? A.—I am answering the best I know.
Q.—Why have you told two different stories about the ashes in this break? A.—I don't know.
Q.—Are both true? A.—They can't be.
Q.—Now, try again. Did you see any ashes on this wood in the break? A.—I don't remember about it.
Q.—You put the hatchet-head back in the box? A.—Yes, sir.
Q.—When did you next see it? A.—In Taunton.
Q.—Mr. Fleet, you testified at the preliminary examination in this case, didn't you? A.—Yes, sir.
Q.—In your testimony then, did you say a word about this handleless hatchet? A.—No, sir.
Q.—Not a word? A.—No, sir.
Q.—Did anybody tell you not to? A.—No, sir.
Q.—You told about finding the two axes and the two hatchets with handles, didn't you? A.—Yes, sir.
Q.—And when you were asked if you found anything else, you said you didn't. Isn't that correct? A.—I said I failed to find anything.
Q.—But you had found this hatchet-head, hadn't you? A.—Yes, sir. Q.—Why didn't you tell them so? A.—Well, I hadn't taken it away.
Q.—Why didn't you take it away? A.—Because I didn't think it important.
Q.—The thing you thought important was the claw-headed hatchet with the rust on the blade and the red mark on the handle, wasn't it? A.—Yes, sir.
Q.—And this poor little thing you didn't consider of any account, did you? A.—No, sir.
This completed the examination of Marshal Fleet. It had not ended well for the prosecution. The defence had shown that he had a bad memory; that his search of the house after the murders had been extremely superficial, and that it had not been adequately guarded. They had shown, too, that he was testifying to several things, all extremely important, which in his earlier testimony he had not mentioned. But the incident most destructive of the value of Fleet's evidence was yet to come. It was a complete surprise to Court and counsel.
A SURPRISE TO COURT AND COUNSEL.
Officer Harrington succeeded the marshal on the stand. Harrington is now a captain of the Fall River police. He has been promoted since the Borden murders. So has Fleet, and so have two or three others of the policemen who were engaged in "ferreting out" the Borden mystery. It might have been better, perhaps, had the promoting power awaited the result of this trial before distributing its favors so generously. Officer Harrington was a somewhat la-de-dah young man for a policeman.
He has an exceedingly glib tongue and a truly marvellous facility for describing feminine costumes.
When he was asked what Lizzie Borden had on, here is what he said. Said it quick, as if he had it by heart; said it, too, without a blush:
LIZZIE BORDEN'S DRESS DESCRIBED.
"She was dressed in a house dress, pink, with a pink and light brown stripe alternating. On the light stripe was a diamond figure. The dress fitted close to the form, almost a tailor-made fit, and was shirred at the neck."
The audience began to titter. Governor Robinson stared through his spectacles at the witness; then glanced anxiously at the Court; then drew his hand over his forehead, as if to see if he couldn't get it in, and then said:
"Dear me, dear me. What's that you say?"
"Why, shirred," said Policeman Harrington, with an expression of pained surprise that he did not seem to be understood. "Shirred, you know,—ah, gathered at the neck, that is," and Mr. Harrington, police captain, guardian of our liberties and lives, put up his hand to his throat and made a gesture as if gathering himself in at that point.
Governor Robinson did his best to follow the witness.
"Ah, yes," he said, "I see," and the Governor put up his hand to his throat, and tried to gather himself in as Mr. Harrington had illustrated. "Is that all?" he asked. "It had a number of bows," said Mr. Harrington, "and on either side was a red ribbon about an inch wide, which was brought around and tied in a bow at the front. It was cut en train, or what is called bell skirt."
HARRINGTON'S PROBABLE INSPIRATION.
They say that over Mr. Harrington's desk in his office at Fall River he has a beautifully embroidered perfumed sachet. Maybe it was out of this that he drew the inspiration which enabled him to give so fine a description of a dress which Lizzie Borden did not wear at that time, and has never either worn or possessed. As a description coming from a police officer, it was a wonderful description, and if such a dress had ever been in existence, it would probably have been a wonderful dress. The dress that Lizzie Borden really wore on that occasion was thus described yesterday by her next door neighbor, Mrs. Churchill:
WHAT SHE REALLY WORE.
"It was a light-blue and white ground, with a dark navy-blue diamond spot in it."
Mrs. Churchill had often seen the dress, and in reply to other questions she said that the skirt and the waist were alike; that it was a blouse waist; that the colors in the groundwork were blended, and that the diamond figure was large and conspicuous. When Harrington had done with his shirrs, his stripes, his en traines and his bell skirts, Governor Robinson quietly inquired: Q.—What was your business before you went on the police force? A.—I was a painter.
Q.—And before that? A.—I was in the boot business.
Q.—Were you ever a dressmaker? A.—No, sir.
Q.—Ever in the dry goods business? A.—No, sir.
Q.—Did you ever have anything to do with colors except when you were in the paint business? A.—No, sir, except to admire them.
The Governor threw a native-born Yankee twang into the tones of his voice, and a queer little squint into his eyes, as he asked:
"And do you admire a red ribbon on a pink waist?"
Except for his description of the dress, Officer Harrington's testimony was not notably different from what was said by the rest. There were, how- ever, some points in the evidence which are worth consideration. He says, for instance, that when he asked Lizzie if she had any idea who could have had a motive to kill her father, she said she didn't know of any, and when he asked if robbery might have been the cause, she said: "No, everything is all right, even to his watch and the ring on his finger." THE EVIDENCE ALL INDEFINITE. This is a case in which all the evidence is circum- stantial, all indirect, all scrappy, and indefinite. No one thing signifies much, and 500 things must be taken and put together in order to make a case of any kind. It is worth while to pause, therefore, on this remark of Lizzie's. It showed that the ring on his finger and the watch in his pocket had been in her mind. If innocent, because when she found her father dead she herself looked around for signs of a robbery. If guilty, with the thought of them in her mind, she had utterly neglected to undertake to throw suspicion away from herself by making the mock marks of a robbery. According to the State, the house was in her possession. Except for Bridget in the attic, Lizzie was the only live person there. She herself set the time limit on the affair, for it was she who called Bridget from the attic and Mrs. Churchill from over the fence. If she was so close as she must have been to commit these murders; anyhow, if the watch and the ring were in her mind, as they were when she spoke to Officer Harrington, why might she not have tossed things around, destroyed or concealed or lost in the well a few valuables from the persons of her victims, and then instead of calling Bridget and Mrs. Churchill have quietly walked downtown and paid a visit to a friend? If she was capable of doing the thing as the State says she did it, she was equally capable of doing it thus. If she was as incredibly provident as the State alleges, by the concealment of every trace of how the crime was done, her providence would have been equal to the making of the plan of going downtown and of letting the world do the discovering.
AN UNEXPLAINED INCIDENT.
The witness, in answer to the question what he saw when he went into the kitchen, replied as follows, introducing an incident of which nothing had formerly been said and which is still unexplained:
I saw Dr. Bowen with some scraps of note paper in his hand, standing to the west of the door leading to the rear hall. I asked him what they were, and he said he guessed they had nothing to do with this case. He started to arrange them in some order, as though to read them, and I noticed in the upper left-hand corner of one sheet the word "Emma." The rest was written in lead-pencil. I asked him again what they were, and he said they were from his daughter; then he lifted the lid of the stove and put them in.
Did you notice anything?
I noticed in the south end of the fire box there was a small fire; I should think a coal fire. Some paper had been burned there before, and it had been charred, but still held a cylindrical form. It was about a foot long, two inches in diameter.
Lizzie's unwillingness to allow suspicion to attach to anybody on account of anything she might say was further shown in the talk Mr. Harrington had with her:
I asked her if she had any reason to suspect any one. No matter how insignificant it might appear to her, it might have some bearing on the case. She said: "No, I haven't any. A few weeks ago father had some angry words with a man, but about what I don't know."
I asked her if she heard it. She said: "No, I was in another room." I asked her if her father had said anything about it. She said: "No. About three weeks later he came again, and they had some more angry words, when father went away, and he said to the man if he came in town again to call on him and he might tell him something more definite about the store."
I suggested that she might not be in a frame of mind to give a clear statement of the facts on account of it being so soon after the murder, and perhaps to-morrow might be a better time to talk with her, and that she might give me the name of the man who wanted the store. She answered: "No; I can tell all I know about it now just as well as at any other time."
OFFICER MULLALY'S STORY.
It was late in the afternoon when the dramatic incident occurred to which the testimony of Marshal Fleet about the hatchet head and the little piece of broken wood in it was the prelude. Officer Mullaly was on the stand. He is the man who was in Fleet's company down in the cellar when Fleet found the hatchet and examined it. Fleet testified that Mullaly was there. In his main examination Mullaly's testimony was merely corroborative of what had already been testified to by other policemen. But under the cross-examination of Governor Robinson, he was required to be extremely definite and particular. His story of the discovery of the various hatchets was as follows:
Q.--Who went to the cellar with you the first time? A.--Officer Dougherty and Bridget Sullivan.
Q.--What did Bridget do? A.--She went to show us where the hatchets were.
Q.--What made her do this? A.--Miss Borden said she would show us where the hatchets were.
Q.--Did she call Bridget, or did you ask her? A.--When we got through the attic we went to the cellar direct.
Q.--You had told Bridget what you wanted? A.--Yes.
Q.--And she led the way to the little room on the south side of the house? A.--Yes.
Q.--What did she do? A.--She went where the hatchets were and took them out of the box.
Q.--Did she look around the room? A.--I don't know about looking around. She didn't step around.
Q.--They were in the box? A.--Yes.
Q.--Describe it. A.--It was from 14 to 16 inches long. Q.—Did it have a cover? A.—None that I saw.
Q.—Were things pretty well covered with ashes and dust? A.—The axe handles were pretty well covered.
Q.—How many things did she take out? A.—Two hatchets.
Q.—Did she hand them to you? A.—She did.
Q.—Was one larger than the other? A.—Yes.
Q.—Did they look about the same as now? A.—There was a rust spot on one of them which I don't see now (looking at one which he held in his hand).
Q.—You said that the handle of this hatchet was covered with ashes? A.—I don't say it of that.
Q.—Was there any dust or ashes on the other? (Showing it.) A.—I think this one looked about the same as now.
Q.—Then they were not at that time covered with dust or ashes? A.—No; the axes had their handles covered with dust.
Q.—Did you find them? A.—I won't say if I did or Bridget handed them to me.
Q.—You discovered nothing else on them? A.—I believe the handle of the big hatchet was cleaner than the other.
At this point Mr. Robinson took in his hand the hatchet-head which Fleet had discovered, and asked Mullaly when he first saw it. Mullaly said he saw it when Mr. Fleet called his attention to it.
Q.—How did the metal look? A.—Then as compared with now, it looked different.
Q.—How different? A.—It was covered with ashes.
Q.—It was found in a box, wasn't it? A.—Yes, sir.
Q.—Do you know what became of the box? A.—No, sir.
Q.—What was taken out of it while you were there? A.—Nothing but the hatchet and a piece of freshly broken handle.
FLEET'S TESTIMONY CONTRADICTED.
Governor Robinson looked sharply at the witness and then turned around to consult his colleague. Fleet had said time and time again that there was no other piece of handle anywhere discovered except the little bit of wood broken off in the hatchet's eye.
Q.—What do you mean by a piece of freshly broken handle? A.—There was a piece of handle there.
Q.—Detached from the blade? A.—Yes.
Q.—Where is it? A.—I'm sure I don't know.
Q.—Did you ever see it after that? A.—Never.
Q.—Who took it out? A.—Mr. Fleet.
Q.—How long was it? A.—Somewhat shorter than the handles of those hatchets there on the table.
Q.—You say you saw Mr. Fleet take that piece of handle out of the box? A.—Yes, sir; I saw him.
Q.—And did you see him put it back? A.—Yes, sir. I saw him put it back.
Governor Robinson paused again. His colleague, Mr. Adams, keenly alive to the importance of this disclosure, had sent out an officer of the court to find Marshal Fleet and to see to it that no one had a chance to talk with him until he was brought back to the court-room. This was a wise precaution. Turning once more to the witness, Mr. Robinson said:
"You are perfectly sure of the facts which you are now testifying to, are you, Mr. Mullaly?" Mr. Mullally said he was, and seemed surprised that there was so much fuss about it.
District-Attorney Moody seemed anxious to take a hand in the proceedings; in fact, to take control of them. Addressing the court, he said:
"Your Honors, nothing was said on the direct examination about this piece of wood. I submit that I ought to be allowed to inquire about it before the defence proceeds with its cross-examination."
The court put their heads together and held a short but animated conversation. Then the Chief Justice quietly observed: "Mr. Robinson will proceed with his cross-examination." Whereupon Mr. Moody dropped back into his seat.
"Did you ever tell this to any one before?" asked Mr. Robinson.
The witness said he never did.
Q.--Do you know where Mr. Fleet is now? A.--I don't know, sir.
Q.--Is he below? A.--I don't know.
Governor Robinson--You will remain where you are, sir, and we will await the result of the effort we are making to find Mr. Fleet.
FLEET BROUGHT BACK TO COURT.
Officers were moving in all directions upon this quest. It appeared also that one of Fleet's Fall River police, who had been hanging around and had observed the extraordinary contradiction between his and Mullaly's evidence, had also started on the hunt for him. This man approached Fleet just as he was seized by one of the officers of the court. He endeavored to engage Fleet in conversation, but the court officer interfered, and hustled him away. Fleet was brought into the courtroom without having received any intimation of the situation. He looked surprised, and of course he realized that something was the matter. He took his place on the witness-stand, however, and awaited developments.
Meanwhile an interesting altercation had taken place between counsel. Governor Robinson made a formal demand on District Attorney Knowlton for the production of that piece of handle, but the District-Attorney, who was evidently as much surprised as anybody else at the turn the evidence had taken, insisted that he had never heard of it before.
When Fleet appeared Mr. Moody again insisted on his right of questioning the officer in direct examination before the defence was permitted to get at him. Mr. Moody, indeed, started to do so, and perhaps to give Fleet an intimation of what the matter was. But Governor Robinson sternly checked the District-Attorney, and the court quickly intervened, directing the defence to go ahead. Then came these questions and answers:
Q.—Recalling to your mind, Mr. Fleet, the box which you found in the cellar, in which you said you found this hatchet here, please state what was in that box and all what was there? A.—There were some other tools, and some scraps of iron. I don't know just what they were.
Q.—Who was with you when you examined the box? A.—Mr. Mullaly.
Q.—Anybody else? A.—No, sir.
Governor Robinson held up the hatchet-head and the little piece of wood that had been fastened in its eye.
Q.—You found these there, didn't you? A.—Yes, sir.
Q.—This small piece of wood was then in the eye of the hatchet—so, wasn't it? A.—Yes, sir.
Q.—Was there any other wood in the box? A.—No.
Q.—Now, Mr. Fleet, answer me this: Did you find in that box any other part of this hatchet than this blade and this little piece of the handle? A.—No, sir.
Q.—You found no other part of the handle? A.—No, sir.
Q.—You're sure of that? A.—No.
FLEET GREATLY PERPLEXED.
Mr. Fleet was evidently much perplexed and troubled. His swarthy face was quite red, and he was slow to answer. Finally, however, he said: I found, no other part of the handle. Q.—Are you positively sure of that? A.—Yes, sir.
Q.—As sure as you are of anything else to which you have testified? A.—Yes, sir.
Governor Robinson looked keenly and fixedly at Fleet. Then he turned and looked at the jury. Every man of them was turned full toward the witness, and had watched his every motion and had heard his every word. The court, too, had drawn forward, and had kept sharp and critical watch upon the scene. The great crowd in the courtroom was absolutely still. Every eye was fixed upon the witness. Governor Robinson turned from the jury to the court; from the court he looked full and hard into the faces of the prosecuting officers. Then he dropped into his seat. "That will do," he said.
It was a most extraordinary scene, the fitting close of an extraordinary day in the trial of one of the most confused, strange, unnatural, improbable and altogether mysterious cases of homicide known in the history of crime. The further testimony of the day was unimportant. There was little of it.
Just before the adjournment the prosecution offered in evidence the testimony of Lizzie Borden given at the Coroner's inquest just after she was arrested, after she had been taking morphine daily for over a week, upon her physician's prescription, and at hearings where she was produced by subpoena and compelled to testify without the presence or assistance of couns[e]l. In New-York this evidence would be clearly inadmissible. There is a statue existing protecting accused persons and enabling them to decline to testify without pleading their statutory privilege, and forbidding the use upon their trial of any involuntary statement. This law was elucidated by the Court of Appeals when it decided that Judge Barrett had erred in admitting upon the trial of Jacob Sharp the evidence he had given before the Senate Committee. In Massachusetts, however, there is no statute bearing on this matter.
The defence objected to Mr. Moody's motion on the common law principle that no one can be compelled to testify against himself. Neither side seemed ready to argue the issue at once, and the argument was deferred until Monday. Later the attorneys on both sides met in conference and to-night it is announced that they have agreed on a statement of facts to be presented. If the evidence is admitted the defence will of course explain the numerous contradictions by saying that Lizzie was under the influence of morphine.
MISS BORDEN LIKELY TO TESTIFY.
It is almost certain that in any event she will herself go on the stand. The prosecution will have an opportunity to cross-examine her on any changes there may be in the story she tells now from that she told at the inquest.
Every day adds to the improbability that Lizzie Borden committed these murders. Every day brings out developments that seem to render such a thing incredible. It is an incomparable case.
Defense attorney Robinson cross-examines a witness about the hatchets and axes found at the Borden house, pressing him on a red spot and rusty mark seen on one claw-headed hatchet that had since disappeared. The questioning also probes inconsistencies about dust in the broken handle, suggesting the break was recent.
New-York Tribune · 10 June 1893 · page 2
WAS IT THIS ASSASSIN'S WEAPON?
A.—1 don’t Know. Q.—~Well, Lizzie Borden hasn't anyhow, has she) No, sir. Q.~You'll swear to that? Q.—Was it a large or small pot? A.— A. Yes, sir. A.—~It was » good.
On the fifth day of Lizzie Borden's trial, defense attorneys sharply cross-examined police officers, forcing contradictions and suggesting the Borden house was poorly guarded. Ex-Governor Robinson's questioning reportedly devastated Marshal Fleet's testimony, leaving the prosecution's case weaker than before.
New-York Tribune · 10 June 1893 · page 1
BETTER FOR LIZZIE BORDEN
NARY TRIAL. [BY TELEGRAPH TO THE TRIBUNE.] New-Bedford, Mass, June 9.—The fifth dag of Lizzie Borden's trial has ended. The prosecne tion's work is atill incomplete, and, although dozens of the court stenographers’ notehooks were filled with the record of the day’s proceedings, little wili be found in them that adds to the probability of the prisoner's guilt.
The defense scored points by exposing contradictions among police officers about how well the Borden house was guarded after the murders. The report also describes the courtroom atmosphere and Lizzie Borden's calm, dignified demeanor as she closely follows testimony and assists her counsel.
New-York Tribune · 10 June 1893 · page 1
POINTS MADE BY THE DEFENCE.
MISS BORDEN CALM AND DIGNIFLIED. Lizzie Borden maintains the more cheerful sppearance which came to her with yesterday's sunshine. She prompted her counsel considerably to-day, and her suggestions were evidently good, for he gave close attention, and almost immediately asked a question or went into a line of examination fruitful of advantage to thle deNothing that was said by any witness fenie, intelligent and ready observation. escaped her deportment is precisely what it Her general should be. She is wholly unconcerned in the crowd around her. She takes no notice of the seratshing correspondents or the sketching newspaper artists.
See moreSee less
They move quietly here and there, catching her first in this position and then in that, but she could not be less conscious of them or more entirely heedful of the awful hasiness that brings her here if she and the judges, the jury and the lawyers were the only
Assistant Marshal John Fleet testified about searching the Borden cellar and finding axes, hatchets, and a handleless hatchet head covered in dust, believed by prosecutors to be the murder weapon. Fleet also recounted Lizzie Borden telling him she advised her father to rest on the sofa, testimony that differed slightly from her statements to other witnesses.
New-York Tribune · 10 June 1893 · page 1
MISS BORDEN CALM AND DIGNIFIED
On the direct examination he had testified abou his having gone to the Borden house on August 1, 1802, whieh was a Thursday, just after the murders had been discovered. He told of a conversation he had with Lizzie Borden, of his search
At the New Bedford trial, Officer Harrington described Lizzie Borden's composed, tearless behavior and her account of finding her father dead after twenty minutes. He also detailed her dress that day, and under cross-examination briefly contradicted then reaffirmed his earlier testimony.
The Morning News · 10 June 1893 · page 2
LIZZIE BORDEN 8 TRIAL A Policeman Testifies to Her Appear ance After the Murder. New Bedford, Maas . June 1* In the | Borden trial this morning! 'fib er Harring ton war railed to the stand at 10:45 o'clock. (hiring his testimony ns to the j condit ion of the liodies the prisoner looked I down nervously and lingered her black I fan. He testified that the prisoner said j she left her father reading a pa|x-r. and, aft, r twenty minutes, found him dead. [ and that she said the motive was not rob bery.
See moreSee less
as everything was right about the house. Officer Harrington testified that the prisoner was not in tears during the interview on the day of the murder, and that she was very positive as to the exact time she was in the barn. He de scribed very fully the prisoner’s dress at that time, causing laughter among the ladies, who constituted fully half of the spectators. The cross-examination com menced at 11:35 o’clock.
During the Borden trial, officers Fleet and Mullaly gave contradictory testimony about a broken hatchet handle found near the chimney, raising questions about the thoroughness of the police search. Separately, bank cashier Everett Cook sent a letter correcting his earlier testimony, admitting Lizzie Borden did have an account with a $172 balance.
The Morning News · 10 June 1893 · page 2
A CASHIER CORRECTS HIMSELF. At the opening of the court to-day the district attorney said he had received a letter from Everett M. Cook, the Fall River bank cashier, in which he stated that one of his answers to a question when he was on the stand was incorrect, and he begged to he allowed to change it. On the stand he said Miss Borden had no ac count in the Durfee Bank, in the letter he corrected it and said she h!ld and that the balance on Aug. 4 was $172.
See moreSee less
The cor rection was allowed to stand. The only matter of importance brought out at the afternoon session was the fact that the broken part of the handle of a small hatchet which was missing was seen by Officer Mullaly and the govern ment professed ignorance of the piece. Officer Mullaly said that Officer Fleet found it and put it back with the hatchet. During Officer Fleet’s testimony he never referred to the matter and considerable surprise was felt and expressed. Officer Fleet was re called and examined, although the govern ment objected. He said he never saw anything there in the nature of a piece of handle with a fresh break in it. There was a decided sensation as Officer Fleet stepped from the stand.
The report reflects on how women have shown little sympathy toward Lizzie Borden despite her previous respectability, noting no woman visited or sent comfort during her imprisonment. It also mentions that one of the key witnesses against her was once her closest friend, and references her fainting during the district attorney's courtroom arraignment.
The Morning News · 10 June 1893 · page 4
Few male murderers who achieve no toriety through the atrocity of thoir 1 crimes escape the adoration of more or less morbid-minded women; yet women are very slow to sympathize with crim inals, or even accused persons, of their own sex. Carlyle Harris, the wife pois oner, received innumerable bouquets and Xnany scented notes of sympathy from women after his conviction. If reports be true, he even made a proposal of mar riage, after condemnation, and was ac cepted. Nearer home, in Atlanta, during the recent past, a number of women have sent flowers anil other marks of esteem to mi nin jail accused of crime, tin the other lnnd, w< h ive on illustration of the fact that women have litile sympathy for women in the Lizzie Borden case.
The process of selecting a jury has begun in the trial of Lizzie Borden, charged with the murder of her father and stepmother. The report notes the case has already become famous and that top legal talent is involved on both sides.
The Kootenai Herald · 10 June 1893 · page 1
Lizzie Borden on Trial. New Bedford, Mass., J#ie 6.—The work of selecting a jury in the case of the 6tate against Lizzie Borden for the murder of her father and stepmother has begun. The case is already famous, and promises to become even more so. The best legal talent of the state is en gaged in the case.
At the New Bedford trial, ex-Governor Robinson's cross-examination revealed that multiple hatchets were found near the cellar chimney and that the search of the house on the day of the murder was not thorough. Witnesses Fleet and Harrington testified about the handleless hatchet's discovery and the condition of the victims' bodies, with Lizzie Borden reportedly remaining composed but nervous during testimony.
The Indianapolis Journal · 10 June 1893 · page 3
New Bedford, Mass., June 9. About one-half of tho spectators in the court house this morning were women. So per sistent have they become in their attempts to itet into the room where the Borden mnrder trial is being held that tte crier has built at tbe entrance an obstruction so tbat only one person may pass in at a time. Miss Borden evidently appreciates the sit
Officers Harrington, Doherty, Mullaly, and Fleet testified about the crime scene and Lizzie Borden's demeanor, with several contradicting earlier testimony. A dispute arose over a missing piece of hatchet handle that Mullaly said Fleet found, but Fleet denied seeing it, prompting the prosecution to request it be located at the Borden house.
The Indianapolis Journal · 10 June 1893 · page 3
Borden's on tbe day of the murder. Officer Mullaly took the stnnd next. His direct testimony as to the condition of the premises on the day of the murder de
During the Borden trial, a recalled witness denied seeing a piece of handle with a fresh break, prompting District Attorney Knowlton to admit he had never heard of this item and request it be verified at the Borden home. Further testimony from court stenographer Annie White about inquest conversations was postponed pending legal argument, and the court adjourned after cautioning jurors to withhold judgment until all evidence was presented.
The Indianapolis Journal · 10 June 1893 · page 3
Fall Kiver, to the Bordens. to eee if this piece of wood, referred to above, was in tho box: all he wanted was justice. "That's all we want," said ex-Governor Kobinson. "Well, you have not any objeotion to our sending an officer over there to see about it, have you?" asked Mr. Knowlton. "No such question has arisen yet." said x-Govenror Kobinson, "and we will pass It now unless the court rules against it" The court decided it was not necessary to proceed any farther just now. Annie M. White, the court stenographer in Bristol county, was called to tell her story of what took place at tbe inquest in Fall Kiver. Asked if there was some con versation between ths distriot attorney and Miss Borden, Ex-Governor Kobinson
At the Borden trial in New Bedford, Lizzie Borden's attorney cross-examined Officer Fleet at length, revealing that other hatchets besides the handleless one were found in a box near the chimney. Fleet admitted the handleless hatchet was found on a second visit to the cellar and that the initial search of the house was not thorough.
The Wichita Daily Eagle · 10 June 1893 · page 2
THE BORDEN TRIAL. New Bedford. Alass , June 9. Lizzie Borden this morning u at died the testi mony very carefully. Her attorney gave Ollicer, Fleet a long cro-examiuntion, and disclosed the fact that other hatchets
A Salina Republican piece notes that after ten months in jail, Lizzie Borden of Fall River will finally face a jury, with testimony that could reveal whether she is a murderess or a wrongly accused victim. It notes the trial began Monday at New Bedford and calls it one of the great mysteries of the time.
The Wichita Daily Eagle · 10 June 1893 · page 4
A &Io3t Iiemarkable Trial. From tlie.S.ilina I.cimblic.in. After ten months of waiting in jail Miss Lizzie Borden of Fall River, Mass.. is to face a jury and hear the evidence that seeks to make her one of che most lemarkable criminals in history. The tiial which began at Now Bedford Mon day will be a most interestion one, not only because it seeks to unravel one of tlie gieatest mysteries of time, but be cause it promises to show whether Liz zie Boiden is a murderess or one of the most unfoitunate victims of law that has ever stood in the criminal dock.
The report notes that Lizzie Borden, accused of murdering her father and stepmother in Fall River the previous August, began trial on the preceding Monday in New Bedford. It adds that she is about 33 years old and that circumstances appear unfavorable to her.
St. Landry Democrat · 10 June 1893 · page 4
Miss Lizzie Borden, accused of the murder of her father and step-mother, at Fall River, Mass., on the 4th of Au gust last, was put on trial last Monday at New Bedford. She is about 33 years
A brief news roundup notes that Lizzie Borden's trial for the murder of her father and stepmother began on Tuesday in New Bedford, Massachusetts. It is described as one of the most terrible crimes ever committed in that state.
The Democratic Advocate · 10 June 1893 · page 2
amounts to $19,204,000. The trial of Lizzie Borden for the murder of her father and stepmother was begun in New Bedford, Massachusetts, on Tuesday. It was one of ihe most terrible crimes ever committed in that State.
At the Lizzie Borden murder trial in New Bedford, Officer George Allen testified as the first policeman to enter the Borden house, and the prosecutor dramatically produced a blood-stained, partly burned handkerchief found near Mrs. Borden's body. Other officers testified about the search of the house, the finding of axes, and the condition of the bodies, while Lizzie appeared nervous and hid her face behind a fan.
Der Deutsche Correspondent · 10 June 1893 · page 5
Lizzie Borden's Prozefj. New-Bedford, Mass., 9. Juni. In dem Mordproze>,e gegen L.zzie Borden wurde Polizist George Allen von Fall River als Zeuge vernommen. Derselbe war der erste Polizeibeanite, welcher das Borden'sche
At the Lizzie Borden trial, Assistant Marshal Fleet was cross-examined by ex-Gov. Robinson about the discovery of axes and hatchets in the Borden cellar, including the hatchet with a broken handle. The report notes government testimony appeared to contradict itself and was losing credibility with the public.
Daily Kennebec Journal · 10 June 1893 · page 1
GROWING WEAK.
Government Testimony in Lizzie Borden Trial Contradicts Itself and Loses Weight at Least With Public. Otto* FI* MM ip to Nit ttory ¥ tot Natotots.
Witnesses Harrington, Doherty, and Mullaley testified about the crime scene, with Harrington contradicting his earlier testimony about questioning Lizzie and the barn door's condition. Mullaley caused a sensation by claiming Officer Fleet had found and then lost the handle belonging to the headless hatchet.
Daily Kennebec Journal · 10 June 1893 · page 1
The w itness described the dreaa worn by Lizzie llorden at the time lie saw her aa a plain house w rap of (link anil light stripea, with diamond Agure on atripes. Witneaa said Mr Borden had on lace shoes when lie saw the body on the lounge. A pho tograph of the Borden room was here pre sented show ing that he had on congress shoes. on cross-examination Harrington contra dicted his former testimony as to an In quiry of Lizzie, hut afterwards admitted that the former testimony was correctHe repeated a detailed description of the pris oner's drera, which causes amusement, and the prisoner twice put her head on her arm and laughed heartily, for the Aral time in the trial.
See moreSee less
• Kx-Oovernor Kobinson also involved the witness in a contradiction of his former testimony as to the condition of the barn door and window. The witneaa contra dicted Fleet ns to the place where one hatchet was found. Officer Doherty was put on at noon and described Ins experience at the Bordens’on the «lay of the murder.
During the trial, Officer Fleet directly contradicted earlier testimony about an axe handle with ashes on it, undermining the prosecution's case. Separately, officers seeking the missing axe handle were refused entry to the Borden house unless authorized by the defense lawyer.
Daily Kennebec Journal · 10 June 1893 · page 1
j gued. Searching for the Milting Ixe Hiatfle. i Fai i. Kr* ki:, June SL—In response to a ‘ message from New Bedford, today, j officers w,-rit to the Borden house to search ' for the missing ax«* handle, hut were r*
The report notes that housekeeper Bridget Sullivan's testimony at the trial generally favored Lizzie Borden. It states that the evidence showed someone could have entered and left the Borden house to commit the murders without Bridget noticing.
Daily Kennebec Journal · 10 June 1893 · page 2
Thr farmers are trying to get encourage m*nt from the old saying, “A dry seed time makes a plentiful harvest.' The general trend of Bridget Sullivan « testimony was in Lizzie Borden * favor. Ii
During the Borden trial, Officer Fleet's testimony about finding a hatchet in the cellar was contradicted by another witness regarding whether a handle was found. Defense attorney Robinson's cross-examination exposed inconsistencies and suggested the police search of the house had been careless.
The Portland Daily Press · 10 June 1893 · page 1
FACE TO FACE. Two Government Witnesses Flatly Contradict Each Other. FLEET'S LITTLE HATCHET STORY ROBBED OF ITS FORCE.
Fleet On tlie Back. Assistant Marshal Fleet again faced Gov. Robinson from the witness stand. The officer eyed his sharp inquisitor warily, and made haste to say that if he made certain statements, as reported by the stenographer at the preliminary hear ing, they were pretty nearly correct. The Governor drew from the witness the sig nificant fact that there was a pile of ashes in the mid-cellar where the Borden hatch ets were found. Gov. Robinson struck an interesting pose as he thrust his left hand behind his coat tail and raised aloft the original cow’s-hair broadaxe, which was so ignominiously abandoned after Prof.
See moreSee less
Woods’s testimony. The number of individuals on the Borden premises, when Mr. Fleet arrived, was quite ma terially increased as the witness’s mem ory returned. He did remember seeing John Donnelly, the hackman, round the Borden house, though he refused to spe cify the time. The important bearing of this lies in the fact that it is Donnelly who will swear that he went up into the Borden barn chamber at the desire of Mr. Southard Miller, and went all through it before Officer Medley had gone up at all, and yet the officer testified that there was no indication of anybody having been round the chamber that morning. Very neatly and adroitly Governor Rob inson drew from his unwilling witness the facts of the search iup stairs, which Mr. Fleet and his two associates made in the Borden house that Thursday after
Defense attorney Robinson's cross-examination of Officer Fleet exposes gaps in the police search of the Borden house, including failure to check Bridget's dresses for blood or open a trunk. Robinson also attacks the credibility of the hatchet found in the cellar, highlighting the filthy condition of where it was discovered.
Defense attorney Governor Robinson cross-examines Assistant Marshal Fleet, exposing inconsistencies about the hatchet's discovery and custody chain. Captain Harrington then testifies about Lizzie Borden's clothing and burned paper found in the kitchen stove.
The Portland Daily Press · 10 June 1893 · page 1
Handsome Captain Harrington. Captain Phil Harrington, who followed, has received his stripes since the arrest of Lizzie Borden, jumping from a patrol man to the charge of a station. The captain is quite the Beau Brummell of the Fall River force in the extreme nice ty of his attire. With his faultles s white tie and curling blonde moustache, he at tracted the interest of the ladies at once. Nobody but the captain could so accurately describe a lady’s dress as did he the entire costume of Miss Lizzie Borden that morning, to the cherry red ribbon at the throat, the shirred front
In New Bedford, Massachusetts, the process of selecting a jury has begun in the case of the state against Lizzie Borden for the murder of her father and stepmother. The report notes the case is already famous and that top legal talent is engaged on both sides.
The Neihart Herald · 10 June 1893 · page 1
Lizzie Itordeu on Trial. New Bedford , Mass., June 0.—The work of selecting a jury in the case of the state against Lizzie Borden for the murder of her father and stepmother has begun. The case is already famous, and promises to become even more so. The best legal talent of the state is en gaged in the case.
The New York Recorder plans to have twelve distinguished citizens from Massachusetts and New York review a verbatim transcript of the Lizzie Borden trial and render sealed verdicts of proven or not proven. The piece notes this jury won't have the benefit of deliberation like the actual trial jury, though its members may be better trained.
Paper unidentified · 10 June 1893 · page 2
Lizzie Borden case, and give a sealed verdict, separately, of whether the charge against her be proven or not proven. The jurors in the trial have the benefit of consultation among themselves, which the Re corder’s jury will not have; but the latter is clou btless composed of bet ter trained persons. It will be in teresting to observe how the juries agree in their findings. Col. Waddell’s address on Social ism is a timely discussion of a very important movement among the people of this country, and there are few speakers more capable of presenting it in a proper light than the eloquent Wilmingtonian. We would be glad if an arrangement could be made for him to deliver his address at every court house in
The report states two new facts introduced at the Lizzie Borden trial: that she burned a dress the Sunday after the murder, claiming it had paint on it, and that a man found a hatchet head in a cellar box covered with ashes on both sides, unlike other tools in the box. The report suggests this evidence makes the outlook worse for the accused.
Paper unidentified · 10 June 1893 · page 2
In the Lizzie Borden case two new facts have been brought out in evi idence. The Sunday after the mur der Lizzie Borden burnt up & drees, saying that it had paint on it And a man of excellent character pro duces the head of a hatchet which he says he found In a box in the cellar the day of the murder, cov ered with ashes, both sides. There were other tools m the box that had dust on them, but not ashes. That is supposed to be the weapon used. The outlook is worse for the accused.
At the Borden trial, Officer Harrington testified about his interview with Lizzie Borden on the day of the murders, including her account of finding her father dead and her assertion that nothing was missing. He also described her composed demeanor and attire, which drew laughter from spectators.
Paper unidentified · 10 June 1893 · page 2
The Burden Trial. By Southern Associated Press. Newbeifcrd, Maes., June 9. —ln the Borden trial officer Harrington was called at 1045. During his testi mony as to the condition of the bodies, the prisoner looked down, and nervously fingered her black fan. He testified that the prisoner said she left her father reading a paper and after twenty minutes found him dead, and that she said that the motive was not robbery as everything was right about the house. Officer Harrington testified that the prisoner was not in tears during the interview on the day of the murder, and that she wa?
See moreSee less
very positive as to the exact tim i she was in the barn. He described very fully the prisoners dress at the time, causing laughter among the ladies who constituted fully half the spec tators. The cross examination com menced at 11;35.
Passaic City Record · Passaic City, N.J. · and 1 other paper
The report describes the start of Lizzie Borden's trial at New Bedford for the murder of her father and step-mother, noting the national attention and crowded courtroom. It details the courtroom setting, the presiding judge and attorneys, and Lizzie's composed appearance and attire as she entered the dock.
Passaic City Record · 10 June 1893 · page 1
LIZZIE BORDEN ON TRIAL. A MURDER CASE THAT EXCITES NATIONAL INTEREST.
* 1 i W LIZZIE A. BORDEN. ventilated building of the type of fifty years ago. Judge Blodgett, the ablest member of the Supreme Bench, presides over the court. District Attorney Moody leads the array of counsel for the commonwealth, and ex Governor Robinson that of the defense. At 11 o’clock Miss A. Borden, the prisoner, same slowly into the room, preceded by Deputy SherifT Kirby, and was shown to her seat in the dock. She was attired in a be coming costume of black brocaded stuff and wore a pretty shade hat relieved by a touch here and there of blue.
See moreSee less
As she passed the bar inclosure, Melvin O. Adams, of counsel for the defense, stepped to the rail and bowed to her. But Lizzie, while ac knowledging it with a slight inclination of the head, sat down, without raising her eyes to his and passed on slowly to the dock. Every seat in the room was occupied by tales men and newspaper men, no outsiders being admitted, and within the bos enclosure were
Passaic City Record · Passaic City, N.J. · and 2 other papers
The report describes the start of Lizzie Borden's murder trial, including jury selection presided over by Judge Blodgett with District Attorney Moody for the prosecution and ex-Governor Robinson for the defense. It also covers the prosecution's opening statement detailing the discovery of the bodies and the measurements of the murder weapon.
The Abbeville Press and Banner · Abbeville, S.C. · 21 June 1893
The State Chronicle · Raleigh, N.C.
The report describes two pieces of evidence introduced during the Lizzie Borden trial: her burning of a dress the Sunday after the murder, claimed to have paint on it, and a hatchet head found in a cellar box covered with ashes, which is suggested as the possible murder weapon. The account notes these developments make the outlook worse for the accused.
The State Chronicle · 10 June 1893 · page 2
In ihe Lizzie Borden case two new facts have been brought out in eviidence. The Sunday after the mur der Lizzie Borden burnt up a dreep, saying that it had paint on it. And a man of excellent character Pro duces the head of a hatchet which he says he found in a box in the cellar the day of the murder, cov erea witn ashes, both sides. There were other tools in the box thai. dust on them, but not ashes. That is supposed to be the weapon used aiib ouuook is worse for the accused
At the Borden trial in New Bedford, Officer Harrington testified about the condition of the bodies and recounted Lizzie Borden's statements that she found her father dead after a short absence and that robbery was not a motive. He also described her composed demeanor and attire during the interview on the day of the murder.
The State Chronicle · 10 June 1893 · page 2
The Borden Trial. By Southern Associated Press. Newbkifokd, Mss., June In the Borden trial officer Harrington was called at 1045. During his testi mony as to the condition cf the bodies, the prisoner looked down, and nervously fingered her black fan. He testified that the prisoner said she left her father reading a pajjci .'ma aucr twenty minutes found him dead, and that she said that the motive was not robbery as everything was right about the house. Officer Harrington testified that the prisoner was not in tears during the interview on the day of the murder, and that she wac very positive as to the exact tirr j she was in the barn.
See moreSee less
He described very fully the prisoners dresa at the time, causing laughter among the ladies who constituted fully half the spec tators. The cross examination com menced at 11;35.
The report describes jury selection for the Borden trial and District Attorney Moody's opening statement, including hatchet measurements matching Andrew Borden's wounds and claims Lizzie burned a dress after the murders. It also covers early witness testimony, including John Morse's account that contradicted the prosecution's claims about the barn.
Passaic City Record · 10 June 1893 · page 1
untehnt irw 3!^ inch°s; the instrument which fits into the death-wounds of An drew J. Borden wag just 3K inches wide. Lizzie Borden fainted after Mr. Moody had declared that it would be proved that she burned a dress three days after the murder of her father and stepmother and had pro duced in court the hatchet with which it is supposed the crimes were committed. She remained unconscious for several minutes. After District Attorney Moody had outlined the State's case the jury, accompanied by counsel for both sides, visited Fall River to examine the premises where the crime was committed and all other places in the locality which were to be used as landmarks in the trial of this case.
See moreSee less
The prisoner refused to accompany the jury. On the third day of the trial Civil En gineer Kieman was the first witness ex amined. He testified os to the location of the bodies when they were iound. James A. Walsh, a photographer, showed views of the Borden house. Surveyors’ and photogra phers' evidence being concluded, John V. Morse, uncle of the prisoner, took the stand. On cross-examination ne swore that on reaching the Borden house after the mur der he saw no officers in the yard ; that the bam door was closed and he heard no one Inside. This contradicted the Government’s claims that officers, by immediate exam ination of the bam, ascertained that the pris oner could not have been there at the time of the murder. A. G. Hart, Joseph Short lieve and James Mather, witnesses, called after five minutes' recess fixed the time when Mr. Borden was last seen. Cross-examina tion developed nothing but slight confusion and uncertainty as to the exact time. Miss Borden yawned and looked on listlessly. Mr. Moody then called Bridget Sul livan to the stand. Bridget Sulli van was the strongest witness of the day, but while her testimony placed Liz zie Borden, the accused, ia the home at the hour of the murders, the effect of it was weakened by the statement, re iterated with emphasis that between tb« shapely mass of evidence produced by the prosecution, the finger of accusation seemed to the spectators to point still more directly at the prisoner. The first witness was Doc tor Bowen, the physician who was sum moned to the Borden residence after the bodies had been discovered. He told the situation of the bodies, and said that apparently nothing had been disturbed in the rooms. On cross-examina tion he testified that he had prescribed mor phine for Miss Borden to allay nervotu excitement. The doses were increased to double strength and had a ten dency to affect the memory. Mrs. Churchill, who lived in part of the Borden house, testified to occurrences just before the murder. She said that Miss Bor den was so pale and excited after the murder as to attract considerable attention. Miss Alice Bussell was theD called. She described Miss Borden’s burning the dress Sunday after the murder. Witness went out and came in again and saw Miss Borden stand ing near the cupboard door and tearing or ripping small portions of the dress. Rob inson’s cross-examination failed to shake Miss Russell’s direct testimony. On re-direct she testified, against objection by defense, that the cupboard in which witness saw a part of the dress at the time of the twrn ing was used only for kitchen utensils. Then there came a string ot officers. Two points were made off George Washington Allen, policeman. One was that a table, un spattered with blood, was found within three feet of the front of the sofa where Andrew Borden was found dead. The . other was the production of a bloodstained and tat tered handkerchief of the bandanna variety, found on the floor, and not hereto fore produced. Both these things are pretty sure to mean something eventually. Deputy Sheriff Francis H. Wixom swore, from his recollection of army wounds, that Mrs. Borden's blood was coagulated when he saw it, while Mr. Borden’s was not. Tnis helped out the prosecution theory that Lizzie Borden killed her stepmother before break fast, and then, after a long chat with Bridget and a perusal of an old magazine, killed her father. The clanking of the hatchets and axes began with the examination of John Fleet, Assistant City Marshal, of Fall River. He told the old original story of how he had cross examined Miss Borden right after the murders, and she had said : “She wasn’t my mother—she was my step-mother. My mother died when I was a little girl.” He identified the two hatchets and two axes, already known in the case, and the new hatchet head. He had found it, he said, in a box on the cellar shelf on the Sat urday afterthe murders. Officer Cunningham testified that immediately after the murders he found the cellar door locked. This was considered a strong point for the prosecu tion.
The piece notes that Dr. Parkhurst believes Lizzie Borden is innocent while Helen Watterson disagrees, with other commentators joining the debate. It wryly suggests public opinion may settle the matter regardless of the jury's verdict.
The Evening World · 10 June 1893 · page 8
The words of this article could not be separated from the rest of its page. Read it in the clipping.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
The Evening World · New York, N.Y.
The report describes the New Bedford courtroom on a warm day, noting Lizzie Borden's calm demeanor as she toyed with her smelling-bottle. It also mentions a policeman being denied entry to the Borden house while searching again for a hatchet handle, and that officers on the case have been promoted.
The Evening World · 10 June 1893 · page 1
IN THE BORDEN CASE.
1 Hullnly Haye Dsen Promoted. I NfcW BEDFORD, Mass., June 10. a There was less of a rush this morning H than there has been yet for the Bor I den trial, the morning opening warm I and muggy, and the uncomfortable con I dltton of the court-room being too lltttle I attractive. In view of past experiences, to offset the drawing powers of com fl monplace evidence. Miss Borden took her seat at 8.55 1 within the bar, and looked quite fresh I and rosy, and more interested In her surroundings than has been apparent heretofore.
See moreSee less
Yesterday she Angered her fan and used It as expressing her thoughts and feelings, twirling It about as a baton to Indicate satisfaction or disappointment; this morning her smelling-bottle had the prominent place withIn the grasp of her fingers, and she , toyed with the little glass stopper some what nervously as she furtively glanced ' about under the brim of her black lace ,
Lieutenant F. L. Edson of the Fall River police testified at the Borden trial about taking axes and a hatchet from the Borden house the morning after the murders, and about being refused entry the night before. He also described a later search of the premises on August 8th with other officers, detailing where he searched in the cellar.
The Evening World · 10 June 1893 · page 1
room of the Justices. I A POMCK LIEUTENANT'S STORY. I The first witness was Lieut. F. L. Edson, of the Fall River police force, who testified as follows: "At tho time of the Borden tragedy I was acting Ser geant of "Police. At 8.40 last night I went to the Borden house In conse quence of Instructions, but was refused admission, the servant only appearing at the door. I sent word to Miss Emma Borden -requesting to be admitted, but was refused, Officer Mahoney was with me. "On the morning of Aug. 5 Inst I took j two wood-axes, a hand-axe and a small j shingle hatchet from the Borden house. ' The axe and hatchet were taken to
Officers Edson, Mahoney, and Medley testify about the search of the Borden cellar and barn, describing the discovery of a handleless hatchet covered in dust. Testimony highlights contradictions among police witnesses, including Mullaly's claim of a handle that others did not see, and notes promotions given to most officers involved except Mullaly.
The Evening World · 10 June 1893 · page 1
Officer Edson's testimony was valu able only as showing an Ineffectual at tempt last night to search the Borden cellar for the hatchet handle sworn to by Mullaly, which Marshal Fieet said he did not see, and as a description of the thorough search of the cellar after the murder, when he saw no loose hatchet handle. His statement that Btate Detective McIIenry was at the barn during the search brought out an Inquiry as to the tatter's connection with the Fall River police. Mr. Robinson also brought out the fact that nearly all the Fall River police prominent in this case, have been promoted since the murder, except Mullaly, who yesterday contra dicted fleet.
The item previews a debate feature asking 'Is Lizzie Borden Innocent?' with Dr. Parkhurst affirming her innocence and Helen Watterson disputing it. It notes the public may settle the matter in opinion regardless of the jury's verdict, implying the trial has already concluded.
The Evening World · 10 June 1893 · page 8
The words of this article could not be separated from the rest of its page. Read it in the clipping.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
The Evening World · New York, N.Y.
At the New Bedford trial, Lieut. V. L. Edson of the Fall River police testified that he went to the Borden house the night of the murders but was refused admission by the servant. The report also notes Lizzie Borden's demeanor in court and mentions a policeman returning to search again for a hatchet handle.
The Evening World · 10 June 1893 · page 5
hat. H Before court opened counsel on both sides held a consultation In the private jflj room of the Justices. H A POLICE LIEUTENANT'S STORY. ' H The first witness was Lieut. V. L. Edson, of the Fall Biver police force. who testified as follows: "At tho time of H the Borden tragedy I was acting Rergeant of Police. At 8.40 last night I H went to the Borden house in conse H quencc of Instructions, but was refused H admission, the servant only appearing H at the door. I sent word to Miss Emma Borden requesting to be admitted, but H was refused.
See moreSee less
Officer Mahoney was with I me. "On the morning of Aug. S last I took I two wood-axes, a hand-axe and a small H shingle hatchet from the Borden house. H The axes and hatchet were taken to H theCentral police station, and I haven't 1 had anything to do villi them since. N Whn I was at the house in the morning of the 6th, I was talking with Emma, and m Lizzie come In and asked Bridget I whether she was sure the back cellar H door was locked, and the answer was: 'Yes.' " I "I took part In a search of the premIses on the 8th. Desmond, Connors, I Quigley, Medley nnd an outsider, Mr.
Lt. V.L. Edson of the Fall River police testified at trial about being refused entry to the Borden house, collecting the axes and hatchets, and overhearing Lizzie ask Bridget if the cellar door was locked. He also described a later search of the premises on August 8 with other officers, finding nothing notable in the cinder boxes or elsewhere.
This item advertises an upcoming Sunday World feature in which Dr. Parkhurst argues Lizzie Borden is innocent while Helen Watterson argues she is not, each giving reasons for their view. It notes the public debate will proceed regardless of the jury's eventual verdict.
The Evening World · 10 June 1893 · page 8
The words of this article could not be separated from the rest of its page. Read it in the clipping.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
The Evening World · New York, N.Y.
The report describes the New Bedford courtroom on a warm day, noting Lizzie Borden's calmer, more composed appearance compared to previous days. It also mentions a policeman being denied entry to the Borden house in Fall River while attempting another search for a hatchet handle.
The Evening World · 10 June 1893 · page 1
IN THE BORDEN CASE
Mullaly II live Uecn Promoted. I Ni:W BEDFORD, Mass., June 10. There was less of a rush this morning . than thero hua been yet fur the Bor den tr l:i.l, the morning opening warm nml muggy, and the uncomfortable con dition of the court-room being too lltttle attractive. In view of past experiences, to offset tho drawing powers of com monplace evidence. MIhs Borden took her Beat at 8."i within tho bar, and looked ipdte fresh and rosy, and more interested in her surroundings than has been apparent heretofore. Yesterday she fingered her fan and used It as expressing; her thoughts and feelings, twirling It about j as a baton to Indicate satisfaction or disappointment; this morning her bmell-lng-bottle hud the prominent place with in the grnsp of her fingers, and she toyed with the little glass stopper some-.
See moreSee less
what nervously as she furtively glanced about under the brim of her black lace , hat. I
The piece notes that commentators like Dr. Parkhurst and Helen Watterson are publicly disagreeing on whether Lizzie Borden is innocent or guilty. It suggests the public will form its own verdict regardless of what the jury ultimately decides.
The Evening World · 10 June 1893 · page 8
The words of this article could not be separated from the rest of its page. Read it in the clipping.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
Eureka Weekly Sentinel · Eureka, Nev.
Among miscellaneous local news items, a short line notes that Lizzie Borden, charged with murdering her father and stepmother, is currently on trial in New Bedford, Massachusetts. The mention is brief, sandwiched between unrelated local notices about mining, travel, and town events.
Eureka Weekly Sentinel · 10 June 1893 · page 3
granted $100,000 in gold (or t trip to the World's Fair. Miaa Jotio Itobinson, who haa been at tending -the Hiatt University. returned homo Thursday. Frank MoAnllffe, who waa killed lut week at Leadville bad just inherited an es tate of $12,000. drover Cleveland says that the number of men In this oounlry who haven't got an ofBoo is appalling. Lizzie Borden, charged with the murder of hor father and stepmother, ia on trial at New Bedford, Matt.
The report announces that Lizzie Borden's trial for the murder of her father and stepmother began on June 10, 1893, with a jury selected after nine hours of examination and her pleading not guilty. It recaps the August 1892 killings, the lack of robbery motive, and the suspicious circumstances pointing to Lizzie, including family disputes testified to by a brother-in-law.
Perrysburg Journal · 10 June 1893 · page 3
FOR HER LIFE.
strument on tho face, neck and head. Although Mr. norden was worth' half a million dollars, there Is no evidence to Indicate that robbery had been the. moth cot the crime. Noplatoor money or any of thoaluablcs of the mansion wero mesilng, nor had a slnglo thing been re moved from the bodies. There were, so far as is yet known, but two persons besides Horden and his wlfo on tho premises when tho murder was committed. These were Urlrtget Sullivan, a domestic, and Lizzie Borden, tho younger of Mr. llorden's two daughters. Tho first alarm was given by Lizzie, who ran out Into
The report reviews the murder case against Lizzie Borden, noting no robbery occurred and detailing the prosecution's theory that she killed her father and stepmother to inherit his estate before he could make a will. It also includes testimony from a brother-in-law about years of family disputes over money and background on Lizzie Borden's quiet life and European trip.
Perrysburg Journal · 10 June 1893 · page 3
FOR HER LIFE
One Was Killed. they could not get money to go ahead CnAiu.KSTOJf, 111., June 5. George with their business und could not sell Walters and his daughter Nelllo jumped their stone. The government owes from a trestle near here to got out of them $85,000, which they cannot get, tho way of a Clover Leaf train. The and with tho banks pressing them fo girl was killed and Walters seriously money they wero forced to surrender. Injured. court ball. These were Urlrtget Sullivan, a domestic, and Lizzie Borden, tho younger of Mr.
See moreSee less
llorden's two daughters. Tho first alarm was given by Lizzie, who ran out Into tho yard and called for help. She was sus pected chiefly becauso of certain discrepancies between her statements to the police as to the clrcumstancos under which the bodies wero found. A brother-in-law of Horden named Harrington also testified that for ten years there had been almost constant disputes between the daughters and Mr. and Mrs. Borden. They had been allowed 5200 a year each, and had been given property worth In the aggregate about 88,000. They were dissatisfied with this, Harrington said, and thought they ought to have more. Miss Borden moved In tho best society, nnd
At the Borden trial in New Bedford, testimony revealed that Lizzie Borden burned a dress she claimed was paint-stained after the murders and police search. Prosecutors argued the dress was actually stained with blood, not paint.
Paper unidentified · 10 June 1893 · page 4
The Borden Trial. New Bedford, Mass., June 8. In the Lizzie Borden trial today the testimony was lhat the accused, after the tragedy, and after a search by the police, burned
At the Borden trial, Officer Mullaly testified that the missing piece of the hatchet handle had been removed from the cellar box by Assistant Marshal Fleet, examined, and then put back. Ex-Governor Robinson then cross-examined Fleet intensely about the police search of the Borden house.
Pawtucket Tribune · 10 June 1893 · page 1
STORY OF MULLALY
Questioning of Goy. Robinson. NEw BEpForDp, Mass,, June 10.—" Ju stice is all we want,” was the emphatic declaration of ex-Governor Robiuson at the Borden trial yesterday afternoon. The
Witnesses testified about a handleless hatchet found covered in ashes, with contradictions emerging about whether ashes were also on the handle. Police officers also described Lizzie Borden's clothing and recounted her statements about a man who argued with her father, with inconsistencies noted between trial and earlier hearing testimony.
Pawtucket Tribune · 10 June 1893 · page 1
THE MISSING AXE HANDLE.
ness. While describing the dress that Lizzie Borden had on when he saw her on the fatal morning of August 4, he spoke so authoritatively of plaits, shirred fronts, s mi-trains, bell skirts, ete., that Judge Dewey grinned from ear to ear, and the spectators were not slow in following his example. His accurate description caused Attorney Rolloson to ask, in the cross examlination, if he had ever been in the dressmaking or dry goods business. Wit~ ness sald he had not, Relating the conversation which he had with Lizzie Borden concerning the tragedy, he stated that she stated to him that her fatber had bad angry words with a man about something which she was ig norant of three weeks previously., She didn’t know who the man was.
See moreSee less
He came again to the house a week later, and an other animated conversation ensued. She heard her father say that he wouldn’t let his store anyway for such business, The witness insisted, In the cross-exami nation, that Miss Borden had not spoken to him about a farm hand, whereupon Attorney Robinson turned to his evidence at the preliminary hearing, where the witness testified that the defendant
This report covers courtroom testimony from Captain Harrington, Captain Doherty, and Officer Mullaly regarding their interactions with Lizzie Borden after the murders, including discrepancies between her inquest and trial statements. Witnesses described the crime scene, the condition of the bodies, and Lizzie's responses to questions about potential suspects and the location of weapons.
Pawtucket Tribune · 10 June 1893 · page 1
Had Made Such a Reference. Captain Harrington said that if he had made such a statement at the time of the hearing, it was the truth. There were other differences of minor importance be tween the witness’ testimony at the hear ing and the trial. Captain Patrick H. Doherty is another Fall River police official who has been pro moted to a captaincy since the Borden murder., He described particularly the position of Mrs. Borden's body in the up per chamber, and the lock of hair that was found on the bed in the immediate vicin fty.
See moreSee less
The hair appeared to have been sev ered from the head. In his conversation with Lizzie Borden, she told him that she was in the bv h when har father was killed, and her attention was attracted by a scraping noise. The
This report argues that despite presenting its strongest evidence, the prosecution has failed to produce any direct evidence against Lizzie Borden. It criticizes the government's theory that she committed the murders and cleaned up all traces within an implausibly short 8-13 minute window.
The Providence News · 10 June 1893 · page 4
~ est mysteries of the times, if not of the ‘ ~ century, r Fair-minded people who have con ~ scientiously followed the testimony of .~ fered by the government have not been able to discover that Lizzis Borden has - been incriminated yet. There has not ~ been the faintest scrap of direct evi ~ dence, and the circumstantial evidence ~ that seemed extremely damaging as it Wws presented in the government’s open ~ Ing has lost a great deal of its signifi cance at the hands of the government's own witnesses, The prosecution has succeeded, in ~ pursuit of its theory of “exclusive op portunity” in narrowing the time down to eight to thirteen minutes in which - Lizzie Borden must have committed - the terrible deed and concealed all ~ traces that connected her with ft, ‘ In this very brief space of time, ac
This editorial argues the prosecution's theory that Lizzie Borden committed the murders and cleaned up evidence in thirteen minutes is absurd, and that the government's case is becoming tangled. It praises defense attorney George D. Robinson's cross-examinations as masterful and suggests the trial's first week gives no indication of a likely conviction.
The Providence News · 10 June 1893 · page 4
174 Weybosset street, Providence. ful legal fights ever seen in this coun try, There is probably not a law yer in this country who has ever equalled the wonderful work being done by ex-Governor George D. Robinson for the life of Lizzie Borden. His cross examination of the government wit nesses has thus far been a finished ex hibition of the best conceivable work of a great and subtle lawyer and one of the most splendid exhibitions of the actor’s art ever presented to the public on any stage, The first week of the trial has re sulted in nothing that need be taken as even probable indication that the mystery of the Borden murders will be solved by this trial, or that this daughter will be convicted of the horrible crime of killing her father and his wife,
The report describes the Borden trial as now fully underway in New Bedford, with the defence holding strong. It profiles witness Bridget Sullivan, detailing her custody since the murders, her loyalty to Lizzie Borden, and her cautious demeanor on the witness stand.
Narragansett Herald · 10 June 1893 · page 8
UNDER WAY.
interests the civilized world. - As is always the case, the chief igterest in these celebrated cases attaches itseif to the personalities involved—some as accessories, >thers as witnesses The reading public throughout the land are as familiar with the name Bridget Sullivan as with that of Lizzie Borden. Save to a very ‘ew, her disappearance from the Borden premises :wo days after the tragedy, and her where ibouts since that day, nave been a mystery. she was seen at the inquest, but her resi donce and occupation have been a closed book to the general public.
See moreSee less
As a matter of fact, she was hrought to New Bedford and turned over to the castody of the local jailer, in whose family she has teen detained asa witness for the common wealth. She isa woman of strong charac teristics. Enamored as she was of Lizzie Borden, and pleased with her place in the
The report describes Bridget Sullivan, the Borden family's servant, giving lengthy testimony during the third day of Lizzie Borden's trial, noting her cautious demeanor and apparent reluctance to harm Lizzie's defense. It also describes Lizzie's attentive courtroom behavior and notes that both prosecution and defense had gathered measurements, diagrams, and photographs soon after the murders.
Narragansett Herald · 10 June 1893 · page 8
UNDER WAY
She was dressed as she had been since the beginning of the trial, and after recess car ried a small bornch of pansies in addition to the other articles mentioned. She mani fested intense interest in every disclosure of the day,and during Bridget Sullivan’s examination changed h-r seat so that she could look the witness full in the face, ex erting, it was thought, a more or less mag aetic influence upon the woman who, although sustaining the relation of servant in the Borden household for three years, was so much of a friend to the accused that
The report describes courtroom testimony from John Morse, who recounts breakfasting with the Bordens before discovering the murders, noting he saw Mrs. Borden's body under the bed where he had slept. Defense attorney Robinson's cross-examination undermines prosecution claims of household miserliness by eliciting that breakfast was ample and pleasant.
Narragansett Herald · 10 June 1893 · page 8
The appearance of uncle Morse, a tall, far mer looking individual, 60 years of age, full bearded, but without moustache, excited some interest. lHe, it wili be remembered, is a brother of the first Mrs. Borden, and therefore own uncle to the Borden girls. He slept in the guest chamber the night before the murder, and it was under his bed that the hacked and bloody body of his sister's successor was discovered.
At the New Bedford trial, prosecutor Mr. Moody delivered the government's opening address, after which Lizzie Borden collapsed from exhaustion and was revived with smelling salts. The first witness, civil engineer Tom Kiernan, testified about the streets near the Borden house, and the jury was granted permission to view the premises.
The Kimball Graphic · 10 June 1893 · page 1
The Defendant Exhausted at tha Closa of the Opining Address. NEW BEDFORD, Mass., June ti.—At 8:55 Miss Borden and.the jury were in their seats and the counsel were on hand busily arranging their papers. The doors were opened to spectators about that time and at least a third of tlioBe present were females. The jury heard the indictments against Miss Borden read as soon as the court was formally opened. Mr. Moody t)ien opened the government's case. Mr. Moody finished his opening ad dress at 10:55 and the jury was given a brief recess.
See moreSee less
At the close of the ad dress Miss Borden had fallen back in her seat, completely exhausted, and her counsel, Mr. Jennings, and one of tho clerical friends administered rcliof in the form of smelling salts and cold water. When the jury returned the case was opened by the government putting on its first witness in the person of Tom Kirnnn. Kirnan is a civil engineer, and testified in regard to the streets in the vicinity of the lloden house At tho conclusion of his examination the court granted permission for the jury to go to Fail River and view of tho Borden premises. Miss Borden declined to go with them. The jury was then dis missed to report for duty tomorrow morning at 9 o'clock.
The report describes the third day of the Lizzie Borden murder trial in New Bedford, noting the large female audience and Lizzie Borden's composed demeanor. Witnesses including a civil engineer and John V. Moore gave testimony about the house's layout and other details.
The Kimball Graphic · 10 June 1893 · page 1
Creatly Intsrosted. NEW BEDFORD, Mass., June 8.—At tho opening of the third day of the Borden murder trial tho mor bid curiosity of the female portion of tho community was catered to and nearly one-half of the spectators were women. Miss Borden entered the
The trial of Lizzie Borden resumed in New Bedford, with the jury seated and indictments read before a packed courtroom. Prosecutor Moody opened the government's case, outlining the discovery of the bodies, family tensions between Lizzie and her stepmother, and alleged evidence including an attempt to buy prussic acid and statements of foreboding before the murders.
Mineral Point Tribune · 10 June 1893 · page 3
\i'W Hmlford. Mass.. June ti. Before ;•) o'clock this morning Lizzie Borden was in her seat in the court house, and the trial was resumed shortly after. The public were admitted for the (irst I lime and the rush to seeur. seats was tremendous. More than one-third of those who fought for places were women. Tinjury was secured ln-rore adjournment yesterday. As soon as court was formally opened jhe indictments against Miss Burden wenread. Mr. Moody then opened the government's ease. He told (he story of the finding of the lushes of lizzies father and sUfpinolher and went at length into tho family history of the Bordens,
The report states that the trial of Lizzie Borden, accused of killing her father and stepmother in Fall River, began at New Bedford, Massachusetts. A jury was selected and testimony had started, with a large crowd in attendance.
Martinsburg Independent · 10 June 1893 · page 2
The trial of Lizzie Borden, charged with killing her father and step mother at Fall River, was begun at New Bedford, Mass. A jury was selected and the taking of testimony has been begun. A great crowd was present.
A short dispatch from New Bedford, Mass. reports that the day's evidence in the Lizzie Borden trial was mainly corroborative of earlier testimony and not particularly significant to either side.
The Morning Call · 11 June 1893 · page 1
Lizzie Borden's Trial. New Bedford. 'Mass., June 10.— Tin* evidence in Hie Bordeu. trial to-dar whs chiefly corroborative .of prior testimony and not of great value to either side.
The report covers the sixth day of Lizzie Borden's trial, noting testimony from Fall River policemen about the handleless hatchet and the allegedly blood-stained dress. It notes the prosecution's case is nearly complete, pending expert chemical testimony and arguments over admitting Borden's inquest statements.
New-York Tribune · 11 June 1893 · page 3
LIZZIE BORDEN'S BRAVE FIGHT. SIXTH DAY OF HER TRIAL. FALL RIVER POLICEMEN ON THE STAND. MORE TESTIMONY ABOUT THE HANDLELESS HATCHET AND THE ALLEGED BLOOD-STAINED DRESS—NOTHING NEW OR STARTLING BROUGHT OUT—AN AGREEMENT ON THE DEFENDANT'S EVIDENCE.
ON THE DEFENDANT'S EVIDENCE. [BY TELEGRAPH TO THE TRIBUNE.) New-Bedford, Mass., Jun” 10.—The sixth day of Lizzie Borden's (rial has ended, and with it has come
A journalist describes the pleasant summer scene outside the courthouse contrasted with Lizzie Borden's fight for her life inside, portraying her as keenly perceptive and actively directing her defense. The day's session was brief, adjourning until Monday, with the prosecution's evidence described as fragmentary and difficult to summarize.
New-York Tribune · 11 June 1893 · page 3
A DAUNTLESS, DESPERATE BATTLE. And she is fighting, fighting dauntlessly, fighting desperately. She is takiig no chances and losing no advantage. She, petzonally, Lizle Borden, the accused woman, is no small part of the force engaged In this strange conflict. Her perceptions are Keon, her store of resources rich aid readlly drawn upon. She sees the signlijcance of every word that falls from the witnesses’ lips. She sees low accusation can be denied and insinuation blunted. When the police officers brag of the thoroughuess of the search they made, she pours in promptings upon per counsel, and compels the witnesses to say that they did not see this, did not see that and gave no heed to the other.
See moreSee less
When they tell of their conversations with her on the afternoon of the murder and on the several days that followed, and when they fepeat something tiat secs suggestivey of guilt, she whispers into her lawyer's ear, and he at once wants to know if she did not also say something else as plainly indicative of innocence. Lizzie Borden 1s not a coward, and she does not look like a devil. She has more than ordinary self-command, whatever that may signify. All her faculties and all her strength are being employed to rescue ler from the awful fate impending. She seems to ha conscious of nothing but the peril she Is in, and she stands before it, pot weakly nor doubtfully, but facing wherever It most hardly threatens, and not often facing In vain. Only one session of the court was held to-dav, and adjournment was taken until Monday. It was an {nteresting session, but {ts significant features are extremely difficult to describe. This is due to the fact, so often mentioned, that the fneiminating evidence in this case is all scrappy. There is no connected line of circumstances, no orderly occurrence of events, pointing to Lizzie Borden's guilt, or throwing any light whatever on the death of those two old people. But there is a little fact here which seems to mean something, and then a little fact there and another yonder, and each is an incident of some gubordinate feature of the day on which the murders were committed—the feature as a whole meaning nothing in particular. These little incriminating points are numerous, but before they are found to make a serious case they have to be connected and “arranged. Each, however, requires for {its demonstration by the State, and then for its destruction by the defence, a great mass of minor evidence. In this sense it is hard to tell the story of to-day’s testimony, and even when told it amounts to little, except when taken in close connection with all the other little incidents that have been brought out before. :
The report describes Lizzie Borden's calm, determined demeanor during trial testimony, as she quietly corrects her lawyer on points of evidence. It also covers a day of police testimony establishing that the Borden house was thoroughly secured and searched, undermining the theory that an intruder could have escaped undetected.
This general news roundup briefly mentions that several Fall River policemen testified for the prosecution in the ongoing trial of Lizzie Borden. The item is one line among many unrelated national and international news summaries.
New-York Tribune · 11 June 1893 · page 6
Several Fall Liver policemen testified for the prosecution in the trial of Lizzie Borden at Fall River. The gunboat Machias reached NoewLondon, having averaged 15.17 knots on her trial trip, the required speed being thirteen knots. =————= The Duke of Veragua and party arrived at
This report discusses how law journals criticized the committing magistrate's conduct at Lizzie Borden's preliminary examination. It also compares Massachusetts and New York jury examination procedures, citing a Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court decision by Judge Holmes on the discretion of trial judges in questioning jurors.
New-York Tribune · 11 June 1893 · page 22
The trial of Mis Lizzie Borden has not only ex clted great phils interest, but much speclal curls Iiy among lawn he law Journals almost withont
Police officers testified at the New Bedford trial about searching the Borden cellar and barn, describing the discovery of a handleless hatchet covered in ash dust. Testimony revealed discrepancies among officers, including contradictions about a hatchet handle and promotions given to officers involved in the case except one.
The Morning News · 11 June 1893 · page 1
Handleless Hatchet. New Bedford, Mass,, June 10.—There was less pf a rusli at the Borden trial to day. the excessive host and discomfort of the court room proving too much for a majority of tho attendants. Mias Borden took her seat at 8:55 o’clock within tho bar. aud looked quite fros h and rosy and more interested in heir surroundings than has been apparent heretofore. Tho first witness was Lieut. F. L. Edson of Fall River, who at the time of the Borden tragedy was acting sergeant of jiolice. Lieut. Edson testified to an ineffectual attempt that night to search the Borden collar for tho lmtchet hundle, sworn to by Mullaly, On cross-ox am illa
The report predicts Lizzie Borden will likely be acquitted due to insufficient direct evidence, even though circumstantial evidence raises suspicion. It highlights testimony from her friend Miss Russell about Borden's premonitions of trouble and her burning of a paint-stained dress as the most damaging evidence against her.
The Morning News · 11 June 1893 · page 4
Wilt It B*matn • Hrilrrif The Impresslr.B thst in gathered from ] tin report* of ihe trial of IJiik Borden, j the voting women w ho is charged with the ' murder of her father and s!<*|*-mothrr at Fail River, Mass . is. that she will not lie I'OTivieted But if the verdict should bo in her favor It would not be because of ;t belief in her innocence, but because of the lack of evidence sufficient to remove all doubt of her guilt. There is no direct evidomieof her guilt and the circumstan tial evidence is not strong, but it is strong enough to make those who road it doubt ful of her innocence.
See moreSee less
The evident c of her friend. Miss Rus sell, has done more to strengthen the sus picion against her than any other that the state has produced. If this evidence is t rue Miss Borden, the day before the murders were committed, said that she was in a depressed condition of mind, and was haunted by a fear tiiat something terrible was about to happen in her home. There was no reason why she should have apprehended trouble. The inference, of course, is that having decided to commit the terrible crimes for which she is now being tried, she could not help making some indirect reference to her purpose in her talk with her confidential friend. Another thing in Miss Russell's evi dence that is damaging to the accused, is the statement that she saw her put an old skirt in the kitchen stove, where it was burned. The reason Miss Borden gave for burning it was that it was ruined by paint spots, and hence was of no fur ther use. Miss Russell says she told her at the time that she was making a great mistake in burning the dress, because the fact that she had burned it might cause her to be suspected of the murder. But, notwithstanding Miss Russell’s evidence, it will be impossible for the jury to get rid of a doubt of Miss Borden’s guilt. The jury will hesitate about find ing a verdict against her upon Miss Rus sell’s evidence, or upon any other that is not stronger. There being no direct evidence and very little that is circumstantial, the state is trying to show that no other person than Miss Borden could have committed the crimes. It has not yet succeeded in show ing the impossibility of any other person having committed the crimes. In fact, in the cross-examination, it was made quite evident that a man could easily have hidden in a closet that is in the room in which Miss Borden’s father was murdered. It cannot be predicted, of course, with any degree of certainty what the outcome of the trial will ba, but, as already stated, the chances are that Miss Borden will be acquitted, because of the lack of evidence, but if she is people will be so uncertain as to whether she is guilty or innocent that they will avoid her. The case is a remarkable one—one of the most remarkable in the history of crimes in this country. The murderer’s identity, unless it is revealed in a confes sion, will, In all probability, forever re main a mystery.
The report discusses testimony from Miss Russell about Lizzie Borden's apparent anxiety before the murders and her burning of a paint-stained dress, which Russell found suspicious. The writer argues the evidence is largely circumstantial and predicts Borden will likely be acquitted due to insufficient proof.
A miscellany of personal items notes that a Boston paper's vacation-tour popularity ballot is currently headed by Lizzie Borden, described as on trial for the murder of her father and stepmother. The item appears amid unrelated trivia about other public figures.
The Morning News · 11 June 1893 · page 4
PERSONAL
TER SON AL. \ cIV r, ATuVer t of Itrnwiß ha* excluded Unde Tom'sQtLiß”fn .fli Mir theaters of that coußlrySamuel J Iln*a rt*nf the I/oxlmrtnn trader, I an<l president of the Kentucky Dress Assorts i Hon i editor of the only republican newsI*airr in the state. A leading Boston paper some time ago started a popular ballot for the selection of a person who is to have a vacation tour among the prominent watering places at its expense I’p to date Lizzie Borden, who is on trial for the murder of her father and step mother,
This report describes New Bedford, Massachusetts, the site of the Lizzie Borden murder trial, noting its history as a whaling center and current atmosphere. It details the formal courtroom procedures of the Massachusetts Superior Court, including the high sheriff's ceremonial announcements and the positioning of judges and the prisoner.
The Indianapolis Journal · 11 June 1893 · page 12
THE LIZZIE B0BDE5 CASE. Tho old city of New Bedford, Mass., is a center of interest at present on uc coutjt of tho Lizzie Borden murder trial
The report describes the formal courtroom procedures of the Massachusetts Superior Court trial, including the ceremonial opening by the high sheriff and the three presiding justices. It also gives a detailed physical description of Lizzie Borden, age thirty-three, accused of killing her father and stepmother with a hatchet.
The Indianapolis Journal · 11 June 1893 · page 12
Lizzie Borden, thirty-three years old and unmarried, is accused of having killed her father and stepmother, with whom sho had lived from her infancy. The theory of tho probecution is that
The passage gives a detailed physical description of Lizzie Borden's face, dress, hair, and hands as she appears at the start of her trial, noting a contrast between her ladylike appearance and the prosecution's charge that those same hands wielded the hatchet. It also notes the defense and prosecution counsel and predicts a long, stubbornly contested trial.
The Indianapolis Journal · 11 June 1893 · page 12
LIZZIE BORDEN CASE
The words of this article could not be separated from the rest of its page. Read it in the clipping.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
The Sun · New York, N.Y.
During Lizzie Borden's trial, witnesses for the prosecution gave conflicting accounts of how the handleless hatchet was wrapped and discovered, undermining the murder weapon theory. The report portrays the inconsistencies as a major setback for the Commonwealth's case.
The Sun · 11 June 1893 · page 1
Nrw BrDFonti. Juno 10. The hsndloless hatohet-now generally known as "Hie hoo doo hatchet" continued Its demonlsh pranks) In tho trial of Llzzto Bordsn for her life to-dy. It chopped another grout hole In the case, ot which it Is tho most Important feature), alnca the only theory of the murder that hat beta advanced Is that Llezlo Borden butoher ed both her parents at th-s end of thirty-two years of an upright life. Whatever damages thnt theoiy almptr Increases tho mystery that shrouds tha murdors. It Is as If ths causo was A deep and pitch-dark well, and tho Common wealth had said: "We will rig up a tearoh light and throw its glare In the welt and light up the very bottom of It" They took tea months to build the lamp, and on the llrst dar In court set It up with a great flourish In New Bedford.
See moreSee less
'J hoy turned on ths Llar.o, and It seemed very powerlul. but the light onlr deepens th darkness. The Commonwealth's lawyers pretend to) point out objects In tho Inky space, but those vanish like phantoms at a seoond glance. They fMiod up tho hoodoo hatchet with
This report describes courtroom chaos in the Borden trial when a policeman's testimony about a missing hatchet handle contradicted the official prosecution account. Conflicting statements from officers, and the defense's blocking of prosecutors from retrieving evidence, left the handle's whereabouts unresolved and damaged the Commonwealth's case.
The Sun · 11 June 1893 · page 1
UPON THE PROSECUTION
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
A New Bedford correspondent describes courtroom details during Lizzie Borden's trial, including the handle-less hatchet box exhibit and symbolic arrangements of carnations. It also offers gossipy color about Lizzie's appearance and mood, and Bridget Sullivan's remarks about her weight gain in jail.
The Sun · 11 June 1893 · page 1
on th tai le boforo the jury this morning. A new glass of flowers was before tho Judges a bunch of hcllotropct alone with the classes of carnations thut have lasted all the week. It stood between the doep red carna tions that typify bloody guilt and tho gontlo pink ones tlmt stand for maidenly suffering. A chsngo in the carnations wns noticed. The guilty onus wore drooping and their heads hung dowa around their vase. Tho others, emblematic of distressed maidenhood, were erect Miss Lizzie Borden has beon likened to a be romttiir, becauso heretofore her spirits tee e.trly morning have corresponded with wbeft the day was to bring forth for or against hor.
See moreSee less
It was not so to-day. bho wns limp and inert this morning. Sho siemed depressed. To be sure the evont of tho dar ttlmulated her so that she left the court room a bright and vigorous woman, hut that does not mend tha luct that her spirits belied her ood fortune earlier in the duy. By tho way. the strangers who are here bogln' to notice that Lizzie Borden's face is of a type Quite common here In Now Bedford. They met Lizzie Bnrdens ovtry day and every where aoout towa. Some havt even como In the court room. Some are fairer, tome are younger, some are courier, but all havo tho same general cast of foaturts hoavr In the lower face, high In the cheekbones, wldeat the oes, and with heavy lips and ft deep lloa on each side of the mouth. It will b Interesting to the ladles to know tlmt all the reporters, even tho one who writes this, have been mistaken about tho material of which Is mado lhe dress which she wears In court every dar. It is simply black vripe. It will Interest both sexes to hear that Bridget htilllvan, as sno visits htr friends in tho kitchens on the Hill. Is lond of saving that slut scarcely knew Lizzie Borden when she mw her Incouit the first day, she has grown to fat. Evidently, as th Dlstilct Attorney would sny, prlnon fare Is better than tho routine of mutton, cold soup, cookies, and 1: re en 1 ens sho used to gel 111 hed cheerless home In 1 all htter. Tho 1 sports to Tux Hfsthe last few days
The report argues that the prosecution's main point—that Lizzie Borden burned a dress she claimed was paint-stained—is not particularly damaging evidence. It notes she expressed regret when warned the dress could be used against her, and argues she would unlikely burn evidence in front of witnesses if guilty.
The Times · 11 June 1893 · page 4
He was indicted for destroying certain statements received by him, as a public officer, from manufacturers in New York, and his counsel entered a demurrer to the charge, claiming that the statements were not public documents, and that he was not, therefore, guilty of a criminal offense. The case has finally reached the court of appeals, which decides that Peck must be tried. The way of the trans gressor is hard sometimes, as Peck will find out. He not only di4 not defeat Mr. Cleveland, but may have to undergo punishment for trying to do so by crooked means. The only point which the Government has made vet against Miss Lizzie Borden
The report describes the ongoing Lizzie Borden murder trial in New Bedford, noting the large, curious crowds—especially women—eager to witness the proceedings. It also details Lizzie Borden's appearance and a lighthearted remark she made to a deputy sheriff while observing the courtroom crowd.
Paper unidentified · 12 June 1893 · page 1
BORDEN MURDER TRIAL
days. The prisoner, Miss Lizzie Borden, entered the court room under tlie usual escort of officers, looking some what less pale and distraught than upon the previous day. She was
Governor Robinson's cross-examination of Assistant Marshal Fleet exposed inconsistencies regarding the handleless hatchet and ash conditions in the cellar. Officers Harrington, Doherty, and Mullaly also testified about the crime scene, with Harrington contradicted on prior testimony about the barn door and Lizzie's demeanor.
Paper unidentified · 12 June 1893 · page 1
He also said he put the handless hatch et back where he found it, that it was not produced at the preliminary hear ing, and that he did not testify about it at that time because he did not think it was used tor the murder; lie said he reached the Borden house
Officer Mullaly's testimony revealed a broken piece of hatchet handle that Fleet allegedly found but failed to mention in his own testimony, causing courtroom confusion. District Attorney Knowlton claimed ignorance of the piece and offered to send someone to check the evidence box in Fall River, while other witnesses including Mrs. Churchill gave additional testimony about Bridget's dress.
Paper unidentified · 12 June 1893 · page 1
that is true to name. For instance, all the shirts that they sell as Wilson Bros.’, have Wilson Bros.’ name on Semi or call for prices before purchasing elsewhere. them. ble surprise was felt and expressed. Fleet was recalled and examined, al though the state objected. He said he never saw anything there in the na ture of a piece of handle with a fresh break in it. A sensation was caused by this testimony. District Attorney Knowlton, on be ing asked for the extra piece of han dle, said he did not have it and this was the first time he had ever heard of it.
See moreSee less
Mr. Knowlton said he desirt d to have somebody sent to Fall River to the Borden house to see if the piece of wood referred to above was in the
A telegraph dispatch claims Lizzie Borden's defense counsel is preparing a dramatic surprise or revelation to be unveiled during the trial. No specifics are given about the nature of this 'bomb.'
Morning Journal and Courier · 12 June 1893 · page 3
A BOMB IS IN READINESS, It Will Be Exploded By Lizzie Borden's Counsel.
It Will Be Exploded By Liz zie Borden's Counsel. MANY VALUABLE LACES MISSING. They Belonged to the Queen of Italy. TOM ROE Will RACE ASAINST TIME,
Fall River gossip holds that the prosecution's case against Lizzie Borden is weak, with rumors that the defense will reveal she bought paint before the murders and that dress-burning was routine in the household. Police remain confident despite an officer's inconsistent testimony about finding a hatchet handle.
Morning Journal and Courier · 12 June 1893 · page 3
Bicycle Trip. Long wili. sfbinc a Bonn. Tbe Counsel and Friends of Lizzie Borden Are Jubilant at tbe Weak' nesa of tbe Prosecution. FaixBtvsb, Uass., Jnne 11. All day long talk has been plentiful on the subject of the Borden murders, and there oan be no denial that it is f general opinion about town that the prosecution thus far has a very weak case. This opinion Is strength ened by rumors onrrent here to the effect that Lizzie Borden's eonnsel will shortly explode a bomb shell In the camp of the authorities. It is hinted that the defense will show oonolaeively that Lizzie Borden purchased some paint a few days before the murder, and that it was not an nnoommon thing to burn dresses in tbe Borden house
Rev. John Schofield, who has known Lizzie Borden since childhood, tells a reporter he does not believe she is guilty and criticizes the credibility of Fall River police, particularly Assistant Marshal Fleet. He cites contradictory testimony about the hatchet handle as evidence favorable to Lizzie's defense, and accuses police of working solely for conviction rather than justice.
Morning Journal and Courier · 12 June 1893 · page 3
Believe That tbe Members or tbe Fall River Police Tell tbe Troth in tbe Borden Cue. Pittsburg, Pa., Jane. 11. The Bev. John Schofield of Braddooks, a former resident of Fall Elver, Mass., who has known Lizzie Borden ever since she was nlng years old stated to day to a reporter that he would as soon accuse his own daughter of the crime for whloh Lizzie Borden is now standing trial as believe that Lizzie is guilty. Mr. Sohofleld further said: "The testimony in the oase seems to ben. efit, rather than injure, Lizzie Borden's case. When Fleet testified that he found
After an hour of deliberation, the judge ruled that Lizzie Borden's testimony given at the inquest could not be admitted as evidence, deeming it potentially coerced rather than voluntary. The defense hailed this as a major victory, and a hotel owner even telegraphed congratulations, predicting her acquittal.
Waterbury Evening Democrat · 12 June 1893 · page 1
THE BORDEN CASE. The Prisoner Receives a Unique Invita tion From the Owner of a Summer Hotel. New Bedford, June 12 Lizzie Bor den's lawyers have received in her be half an invitation that is unique. A proprietor of two prominent hotels at two shore resorts has telegraphed con gratulations on the outcome of the trial. He already presages acquittal of the prisoner and invites her to visit his hotels for as long a time as she may see (It, with such attendants as she may bring, entirely free of charge.
See moreSee less
At the opening of court this morning the jury were requested to retire and Mr 5loody arose to argue the question of the admissibility of the evidence of Lizzie Borden made at the inquest. The point under discussion in the case is as to whether the testimony is such 88 to take it out of the realms ot a confession rent' ere d under compu'sion. The law states that no declaration obtained by compulsion from a defendant can be ad mitted in evidence, but all declarations that are voluntary are admissible. After deliberating for one hour and ten minutes the justice decided not to admit the evidence given by the prisoner at the inquest. This is a great victory for the defense, and Miss Borden and her counsel are jubilant.
On the seventh day of the New Bedford trial, lawyers argued over whether Lizzie Borden's inquest testimony could be admitted as evidence. The report notes growing inconsistencies in testimony about the hatchet handle, dust, and the color and fate of Borden's dress.
Waterbury Evening Democrat · 12 June 1893 · page 2
LEGAL LUMINARIES WRANGLING Arguments in Regard to the AdmlsslbllIty of tbe Report of Miss Borden's Testi mony at the Inquest No Abatement of Interest In the Proceedings Review of tbe Case Is There a Conspiracy ? New Bedford, June 12. Promptly at 9 o'clock this morning the judges, the op posing counsel and the prisoner were in their places, and the seventh day of the Borden trial commenced. The court room was packed as usual, a large proportion of the spectators being women. Argument at once began with regard to the admissibility of the report of the pris oner's testimony at the inquest.
See moreSee less
It is becoming more evident every day that the Commonwealth is gradual!; knocking the underpinning from the struc ture it be Kan to erect, be it prison or gib bet, with such skill and celerity in the trial of Lizzie Borden, and, what is more astonishing still, this work of demolition is beinii accomplished by the very me chanics who helped lay the foundation. Ibe conflicting testimony regarding tne handle of tbe hatchet with which it is said the murders were committed; the quality and quantity of the dust with which the handle was covered: the color and style of the dress Miss Borden wore on the morning of the murder; the alternately
The report says the case has become a muddle over the burned waist evidence, suggesting the prosecution may have trouble convincing the jury, and raises the possibility of a police conspiracy against Lizzie Borden. It then lays out the government's theory of guilt in detail, including motive, suspicious statements to a friend, and the alleged manner of the killings.
Waterbury Evening Democrat · 12 June 1893 · page 2
that ox the defense, may be of interest. The Government's case, as it stands, is that Miss Lizzie Borden is guilty because of the following facts: She lived a dull routine in an uncongenial household where
The report lays out a detailed theory of how Lizzie Borden allegedly killed her mother and father, including methods used to avoid bloodstains and lies told afterward. It also speculates on her motive, framing the stepmother's property dealings as the reason for the killings.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
Waterbury Evening Democrat · 12 June 1893 · page 2
New Bedford, June 12. Promptly at 9 o'clock this morning the judges, the op posing counsel and the prisoner were in their places, and the seventh day of the Borden trial commenced. The court room was packed as usual, a large proportion of the spectators being women. Argument at once began with regard to the admissibility of the report of the pris oner's testimony at the inquest. It is becoming more evident every day that the Commonwealth is gradual!; knocking the underpinning from the struc ture it be Kan to erect, be it prison or gib bet, with such skill and celerity in the trial of Lizzie Borden, and, what is more astonishing still, this work of demolition is beinii accomplished by the very me chanics who helped lay the foundation.
See moreSee less
Ibe conflicting testimony regarding tne handle of tbe hatchet with which it is said the murders were committed; the quality and quantity of the dust with which the handle was covered: the color and style of the dress Miss Borden wore on the morning of the murder; the alternately proven and denied identity of the dress with one she is said to have burned or the one now m posse-sion of the btate all this is becoming more of a muddle as tbe case progresses. If Miss liorden, or some one for her, can satisfactorily explain the alleged burning of the waist, it is dimcult to see, unless it some much better cards in reserve than a ny so far played, how the prosecu tion can convince the jury or the commun ity that this young woman is guilty of the atrocious crime with which she Is charged. In fact, the prosecution is gradually and materially giving tangibility to the belief which has existed in many minds that the prisoner is the victim, incredible as this may seem, of a conspiracy on tne part of the Fall River ponce, who, it is hinted, beiii'' baffled at every turn, felt that they bad to distort facts in order to make a case and, it is further intimated, earn the pro motion with which, as was disclosed, they nave since been rewarded. A review of the case, viewed from the standpoint of the prosecution, then from that ox the defense, may be of interest. The Government's case, as it stands, is that Miss Lizzie Borden is guilty because of the following facts: She lived a dull routine in an uncongenial household where life was monotonous, the fare was wretched, her father was a parsimonious man, and she hated her stepmother. So odious to right-minded persons was the manner of living that the old people kept their bedroom door locked, and bolted the doors that led from their end of the house to that occupied by the daughters. On the day before the murder she tried to buy prussic acid, and on that night she went to visit her closest friend. Miss Rus sell, and talked to her of her strange feel ing that something dreadful was going to bappeD. She talked of poison, saying that all her people had been sick, and she feared that the food was poisoned. She feared for her father because of his quar relsomeness; in fact, she said she expected nothing less than her home would be burned over her head. She said she had been oppressed by this feeling for some days, and while her sister and the servant were merry, she was depressed. She chose for a time for the murder a period when her sister was oS on a visit, and the only person at home besides Her victims was the servant. She meant at first to poison her people with prussic acid but could not While the servant was out of doors at work at the lower windows and her mother was upstairs at the chamber work she murdered her. An hour or two after ward her father came in and she induced him to lie down and sleep on a sofa where bis head would be near a doorway, in which she stood while she chopped his head, the wall protecting her from the ny lng blood. During all the bloody forenoon she saw to it that the house was locked on all sides against intrusion. How she pro tected herself from blood stains while murdering her mother is not yet outlined. She miL-ht have been naked, though. As she burned one of her dresses afterward. it is possible that that was what she woro. It will be admitted that during the second killing she need not bave got any blood upon her. When all was over she called the servant down. She did not scream or shriek, nor did she weep at any time that anyone can testify to. She in vented a lie to the effect that Mrs. Borden had got a note and gone out, and to this she adhered all day, until at the last he said, "She thought she heard her come in." well knowing that the only door at which the old lady could have come in was that of the kitchen, and yet to do so she must have passed the neighbors who were then around her. 1 bat lie was told to keep the people from looking for the old lady and discovering her body. No note was discovered, as it would be likely to be on the woman's body or about the house. She lied with still less system about her own movements. To no two per sous did she describe them alike. To every one she said she was in the yard or barn, but beyond that no two of her stories agreed. Upon the very discovery of the murders, when a police officer happened to ask a question about her mother, she turned upon him sharply and said: "She's not my mother; my mother died when I was a child. " At the same time she showed by a remark she made that she had picked out the undertaker she meant to employ. On the day of the funeral this Yankee girl, brought up iu a house where every penny was squeezed till it was dented committed the astonishing act of burning up a dress because it had a little paint on It a good dress made new that spring. As for the motive that prompted the crime, It seems many-sided. The stepmother had led the father to give property to her rela tives. The murderer hated her, and said so. bhe wanted money, ease and luxury. Had she killed her father first, theestat would have benefited his wife's people. Therefore, the mother was killed first and the father afterward. The Common wealth argues that only au inmate of the house, familiar with the habits of the oth era, could have committed the murders. Miss Borden a defenders assert that the angry stats of affairs in the Borden house Is exaggerated that they will prove that in two years aud nine months iu that house Bridget Sullivan never heard quarrel or a cross word there, tbat her talk about forebodings to Miss Russell was such as women often indulge in, thatit is mere coincidence that the murders hap Bened next day. Ihey assert that uiis
Fall River gossip holds that the prosecution has presented a weak case against Lizzie Borden, with rumors that her defense will soon spring a surprise. Her lawyers and friends appear confident and joyful, while police remain undeterred.
The Morning Call · 12 June 1893 · page 1
Her Acquittal. Fall River, Mass., June 11.— All day long taik has been plentiful on the subject of the Borden murders, and there can be no denial that it is the general opinion that the prosecution thus far has presented a very weak case. The opinion Is strength ened by rumors current here to the effect that Lizzie LSorden's counsel will shortly ex plode a bombshell into the enmp of the authorities. Defendant's lawyers do not attempt to disguise their joyful feelings because of ihe present status of the case, and the girl's friends here are jubilant. The hatchet incident with accompaying denials is a source of much comfort. But while the prisoner's friends have buoyant spirits the poPce authorities are by no means downcast.
The Wilmington Daily Republican · Wilmington, Del.
A Fall River report describes widespread opinion that the prosecution's case against Lizzie Borden is weak, citing contradictory police testimony about a hatchet handle. It notes the defense's confidence, including plans to explain Lizzie's paint purchase and her burning a dress in daylight as innocent, while police dismiss an officer's inconsistent testimony.
The Wilmington Daily Republican · 12 June 1893 · page 1
the snbjoct of the Borden plentiful murders, aud there denial that !>e It is a geueral opinion eboftt town that the prosecution thus far has a very weak This opinion is being strengthened by ru currcnt heroTo the effect that Lizzie Borden's counsel will shortly explode a bombshell into the camp of the authori ties. It is hinted that the defense will
The Wilmington Daily Republican · Wilmington, Del.
Trial coverage details conflicting police testimony, particularly Officer Mullally's disputed statement contradicted by five other witnesses, and the handling of the hatchet by Officers Medley and Desmond. The report also notes that most Fall River police involved in the case have received promotions except Mullally, and comments on the defense's cross-examination strategy and police department criticism.
The Wilmington Daily Republican · 12 June 1893 · page 1
REWARDING THE PROSECUTORS. rollco Officers Made Prominent In the Case Have Deen Pr d. Nk. Bedford, Mass., June 12.—The tes timony in the Borden trial Saturday was essentially of a police nature. First camo Lieutenant Euson, then Inspector Medley and Captain Desmond. They told of Hie pai ls that they took iu the investi gation of the Borden murders. Ex-Gov
The report notes that the Borden trial has run a full week, and despite extensive state testimony, the mystery of the Fall River double murder remains unsolved. It states that while some circumstances cast suspicion on Lizzie Borden, her defense has successfully confused witnesses, leaving no clear verdict in sight.
New-York Tribune · 12 June 1893 · page 6
place. The existing situation is extremely significant, and future development will be awaited with decp interest. Of course, if Tammany Hall thinks it has got as much as can serve it from the Manhattan concern, it will cast it overboard with as little concern as a squeezed lemon. — per The Borden trial has been in progress a full week. but in spite of the array of testimony presented in behalf of the State, which is weil summed up by our staff correspondent in the letter printed to-day, the mystery surrounding the double murder at Fall River last August is as dense as ever.
See moreSee less
A number of circumstances disclosed which, takén together, | have heen put Lizzie Borden in a somewhat bad light before the jury, but the prisoner's *connsel have been remarkably snccessful in tangling up the witnesses and inducing them to contradict themselves. No positive inference can be drawn trom the evidence thus far as to the guilt of Miss Borden: nor, despite the expedition displayed by court and lawyers, can anything definite he said regarding the time which the trial will eccupy. pow p———— o— E——
A descriptive feature portrays the judges, lawyers, and 'Down East' jurymen in the Borden trial, dwelling on their rustic New England character. It also offers a detailed physical description of Lizzie Borden herself, contrasting her unyielding facial features with the graceful, dignified bearing observed from behind as she awaits the verdict.
New-York Tribune · 12 June 1893 · page 2
21zZ1¥, BORDEN'S APPEARANCE. There 1s no question of deportment with the prisoner. She has no mind for anything except the dreadful business that brought and holds her here. While her face is not agreeable, it furnishes by ho means the only clew to her character. Habits of mind impress themselves upon the human body everywhere, Attitude is expressive: movement is expressive. The way one sits and walks and holds one’s hands tells a story of character and disposition almost as eloquent and clear ae the expression of: 's eyes or the lines about one's mouth.
See moreSee less
Iza x Borden's face is not a soft face. It 1s not gentle it does not indicate quick or tender emotigns. tilt is all right till the mouth, lips and’, jawd art peached. The mouth is strong and firm, and the l{ps move but slightly when she speaks. The cheeks are full and the jaw square and heavy. The chin
A commentator argues the prosecution's circumstantial case against Lizzie Borden lacks consistency and probability, suggesting reasonable doubt should favor acquittal. The report details testimony that Lizzie told Miss Russell the night before the murders that she felt something bad would happen and described household illness and her father's quarrel with a tenant.
New-York Tribune · 12 June 1893 · page 2
WHAT THE PROSECUTION HAS PROVED. Tho doctrine of “reasonable doubt” prevails in Massachusetts as in other civilized places. Without assuming to take the place of a jury which has fwpressed me as honest and competent, | should think that this doctrine of ‘ reasonable doubt” would avail to save Lizzie Borden from the gallows, unless the State makes its case muh stronger than it has yet done. An opinion on the case can properly be expressed because the jury is coufined, all the time, and is not allowed to see newspapers or to speak with any one. A gircumstantial case to be convincing must be very oircrmstantiol. ‘ihe details that, accuse ‘Lizzie Borden lack consistency, lgck pwbability,
New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y. · and 1 other paper
This report details Lizzie Borden's premonitions of danger and her father's quarrel over a lease, along with the household illness she attributed to bad milk or bread. It then lays out the prosecution's proven timeline of the morning of the murders, including Bridget's windows-washing, Mr. Borden's departure, and Mrs. Borden's disappearance from sight before her death.
New-York Tribune · 12 June 1893 · page 2
WHAT THE PROSECUTION HAS PROVED.
The State has proved that that Wednesday night found no one occupying or'in the Borden house except Mr. and Mrs. Borden, Mrs. More, lizale's uncle, the brother of Mr. Rorden's first ‘wife; Lizzie herself, and Bridget, the comk, No suspicion can attach to Morse. He arbse the next morning early, had his breakfast at 7:50 with Mr. and Mrs. Borden, left the house at = :45, went downtown, and accounts for his movements clearly until 11:30, when he returned to the house. Both Mr. and Mrs. Borden were then dead. Lizzie appeared that morning after Morse went downtown, and at about 9 o'clock She got her own breakfast.
See moreSee less
While she was eating ft Mrs. Borden was dusting in the sitting-room, whieh adjoined the dining-room, and Bridget was washing the windows of the kitchen, and had been instructed to wash all the windows on the first floor. At 9:15 Dridget saw Mr Borden ‘go downtown. From that time or thereabouts Mrs. Borden drops out of sight. Nobody saw her after that alive. At what particular moment she was killed is entirely unknown Bridget, not seeing her, at one time, along about 10 o'clock asked Lizzie where she was, and Lizzie replisa that she had received a note from a sick friend and had gone out. While Bridget wae washing the windows Lizzie ocenpied herself apparently with household duties, and Bridget saw her from time to time going about here ——— - _—
The report claims public opinion in Fall River favors Lizzie Borden, citing rumors that her defense will reveal she bought paint before the murder and that dress-burning was routine in the household. It also notes conflicting police testimony about the hatchet handle, undermining prosecution credibility.
Evening Star · 12 June 1893 · page 7
LIZZIE BORDEN'S FRIENDS CONFIDENT
Very Weak Case. It is the general opinion at Fall River that the prosecution in the Borden murder trial has a very weak case. This opinion is being strengthened by rumors current to the effect that Lizzie Borden's counsel will shortly ex plode a bombshell Into the camp of the au thorities. It is hinted that the defense will show conclusively that Lizzie Borden pur chased some paint a few days before the mur der, and that it was not an uncommon thing to burn dresses t the Borden household.
Conflicting testimony from officers Mullaly, Medley, and Desmond about finding and wrapping the hatchet is examined, with suggestions the defense may exploit these inconsistencies. The court is also awaiting a ruling on whether Lizzie Borden's inquest testimony will be admissible, with both prosecution and defense confident of prevailing.
Evening Star · 12 June 1893 · page 7
LIZZIE BORDEN'S FRIENDS CONFIDENT
inally submitted. In conversation with Mr. Moody last evening he showed that he was firmly persuaded that the argument of the prosecution for the admis sion of the testimony of Lizzie Borden at the iqnest would prevail, the other hand, counsel for the defense was equally eonfldent that the testimony wilt be ezeinded. In this case Lizzie will not go cn the stand unless some more damaging evi dance comaes up against her than has yet been shown. Chief Justice Mason and Justice Blodget came down from Boston last evening. and were met at the train by Distriot Attorney Knowlton.
See moreSee less
It was understood that they had been consuli lng authorities prior to being called upon to vase judgment one way or the other, relative to the phase of the case to be presented today. It was authoritatively stated last night that the case is but just begun, and that the medi cal espert testimony will take up quite a long timse. The trial may last two weeks. There Is no mistaking the symptoms of disappointment on the part of the government.
Fall River gossip claims the prosecution's case against Lizzie Borden is weak, with rumors that her defense will reveal she bought paint before the murders and that dress-burning was common in the household. The piece also notes an officer's contradictory testimony about finding a hatchet handle, which is boosting the defense's confidence.
The Morning News · 12 June 1893 · page 1
Made Out a Very Weak Case. Fall River Ma*s.. June 11. —All day long talk has been plentiful on tho sub ject of tho Borden murders, and there can be no deniul that tho general opinion about town is that the 'prosecution thus far has a very weak case. This opinion is being strengthened by rumors current here to the effect that Lizzie Bo''den's counsel will shortly explodo a bombshell in the camp of tho authorities. It is hinted that the defense will show con clusively that Lizzie Borden purchased some paint a few days before the murder and that it was not an uncommon thing to burn dresses in the Borden household.
See moreSee less
The fact that the girl burned the dress in tho daylight, when officers surrouuded the house, will also he related to show there was not the slightest attempt at concealment. The defendant’s lawyers do not attempt to disguise their joyful feelings because of the present status of the case and the girl’s friends here are jubilant.