As the Papers Told It

Lizzie Borden · The full archive

June 1893, part 1

250 articles

Daily Kennebec Journal · Augusta, Me.

The murder of Bertha Manchester, found bludgeoned in her farmhouse, is reported as eerily similar to the Borden killings, prompting speculation about a possible connection. The piece also notes that Attorney General Pillsbury is reportedly staying out of the Borden trial due to doubts about her guilt.

Daily Kennebec Journal · 1 June 1893 · page 2

FALL RIVER'S MURDER MYSTERY

Fall Hirer ha* mother murder mystery, the details of which in some respects re semble the famous Borden mystery. Itc tween the hours of r. h» A. M. and 'J l*. M.. Tuesda), a farm house in the suburbs. was entered ami Mis* Bertha Manchester, a young woman who was alone at the time, was murdered, the top of her skull being crushed to jelly. A neighbor living close by heard no noise during tlie day and saw j no one enter the house. Three large dogs about the house made no disturbance.

See moreSee less

The axe with which the deed was don.* was found in the woodpile. This terrible deed certainly recalls vividly the details of the 1 Borden murder*. The brutal hacking of the skull resembles the manner in which the Bordens were killed. Several articles of value were stolen from the Manchester house, while nothing was missed from the Borden house. This contrast, however, may indicate but little. The amount taken at the Manchester bouse was of no considerable value and a medical examination showed that aside from a desire to steal, to murder, or for re venge. there was no motive. The facts thus far known imply that there could have been no motive for revenge. There is a possibility that the murderer of the Man chester girl and of the Bordens is one and the same—some stealthy fiend with sn in sane desire for slaughter. It ie said that Attorney General Pillsbury does not appear in the trial of Lizzie Bor den because he hasn't confidence in her guilt. Possibly the circumstances of this fresh tragedy may shake the firm convic tions which District Attorney Knowlton en tertains of Lizzie Borden's guilt.

See the clipping

The Saratoga Sun · Saratoga, Wyo.

A one-line telegraphic brevity states that Lizzie Borden's mind is reportedly failing, amid a column of unrelated brief news items from around the world. No further detail or source is given for the claim.

The Saratoga Sun · 1 June 1893 · page 2

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

See the clipping

The Rawlins Republican · Rawlins, Wyo.

A brief dispatch claims that Lizzie Borden's mind is failing, amid a miscellany of telegraphic news items. No further detail or source is given for the claim.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

The Rawlins Republican · 1 June 1893 · page 6

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

See the clipping

Springfield Weekly Republican · Springfield, Mass.

A general news column touches on many topics, including a brief note that Massachusetts Attorney-General Pillsbury will not personally prosecute the Lizzie Borden trial since a law now shifts capital case duties to district attorneys. The rest of the passage covers unrelated political and social news items.

Springfield Weekly Republican · 2 June 1893 · page 1

inability to represent the state at the Lizzie Borden trial, it will be remembered that the Legislature has relieved the chief law officer of the state from the too great burden of personally conducting ali prosecutions in capital cases. This duty now falls to the

See the clipping

Springfield Weekly Republican · Springfield, Mass.

Investigators in Fall River are probing the murder of Bertha Manchester, noting the family dogs made no noise and medical examiners ruled out assault before death though an attempted assault seemed likely from her clothing. Police publicly dismissed suspicion of her father, who wept while doing chores and insisted his daughter was a hard worker who ran the farm in his absence.

Springfield Weekly Republican · 2 June 1893 · page 5

tiffs and a third is a Newfoundland. It • would seem that these dogs would make considerable noise under circumstances that would produce such a result. Be cause no such noise was noticed, the po lice are inclined to think that the deed was committed by some one familiar with the premises. The medical examiner has decided that the girl was not outraged be fore or after death, but it seems probable that a felonious attempt was made from the condition of her clothing when the girl was found. There was ample opportunity for the murderer to commit the deed un noticed, just as the Borden murders were committed last August, while the oppor

See the clipping

Springfield Weekly Republican · Springfield, Mass.

Police reportedly suspect a foreign farmhand who had quarreled with the family killed a servant named Bertha with an axe, in a crime eerily similar to the Borden murders. The report speculates this unidentified man might also be responsible for the Borden killings, suggesting Lizzie Borden could be wrongly imprisoned.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

Springfield Weekly Republican · 2 June 1893 · page 5

one of the many persistent questioners, he said: "My girl could work harder than two girls. She looked after 200 hens and fed and let out the cattle while I was on my route. Sho did all the chores if I was a little delayed. Why, she was better than any man, because a man would have used a boy to go after him to finish his work. They say her house was not very tidy, but it was because she was not able to do it. She had to be pretty busy, since there has not been anv man here,” ami the old man went about his chores with tears on his cheek.

See moreSee less

The police worked in the neighborhood of the house all day, obtaining all possible iuformatiop of the neighbors concerning past affairs nt the Manchester farm and tracing out the men who have been em ployed there. They have their attention directed toward a man who might have committed the deed, but they will not. give out the slightest clew as to who he is or where he has been stopping. Rumors in police circles say that the man is a for eigner who worked on the farm less than a week and left, after having quarreled openly with the daughter and her father. It does not seem possible to the police that any tramp or stranger could go into the house without being savagely attacked by the dogs that are loose about the place. The police believe the man was in the house before the girl entered. In going into the dining-room, where Bertha was pre paring to bake ginger-bread, she saw him coining. Fearing danger, she probably took up the ax from the wood-box back of the stove. This probably angered the man, who might have only been intent on rob bery. and a fierce struggle ensued. That the girl made a powerful attempt, to save her life is stated by all who know her disposition, and is also evidenced by vari ous blood smooches in spots in different parts of the small space where she was found. When asked it the wounds were like those inflicted on the Bordens, save that there were more of them, Dr Dolan exclaimed: “Please do not inflict me with parallelisms. This murder is a horrible affair, and will be handled by itself. I do not care to make any comparison.” “It will strike everybody,” says the Boston Journal, “as especially remark able that the similarity of the gory de tails in both cases should be so strikingly exact as to indicate that the blows with the death-dealing ax and the methods of the murderer in the case of each victim were almost, precisely alike. Find this murderer and is it not possible with him may also he found the man whose wild ap pearance so attracted Dr Handy’s atten tion as he passed him in front of the Bor den house? the man whose leap over the fence so startled pretty Marie Chagnon and her mother, the wretch, in fact, for whose’bloody work Lizzie Borden may be even now suffering?”

See the clipping

The Portland Daily Press · Portland, Me.

A newspaper editorial argues that Lizzie Borden's composure after the murders should not be taken as proof of guilt, citing a separate Fall River case where a father's even greater coolness after his daughter's murder failed to implicate him. The piece warns against over-relying on assumptions about how people 'should' behave in tragic circumstances.

The Portland Daily Press · 2 June 1893 · page 4

Perhaps more people have been led to believe in the guilt of Lizzie Borden by her remarkable coolness immediately after the discovery of the murder than by any other single circumstance. These people have argued that such cool ness was explicable only on the theory that she had committed the deed herself and had schooled herself to retain her self possession. But the develop ments of the second Fall Iiiver tragedy utterly confound this theory. It is ad mitted now by all the officers that the father of the dead girl had nothing to do with her murder.

See moreSee less

They suspected him somewhat at first, but they are now con vinced that he is entirely innocent. Yet this man acted with even greater coolness and unconcern than did Lizzie Borden, fallen informed of

See the clipping

Chariton Courier · Keytesville, Mo.

A news brief claims Lizzie Borden has become a physical and mental wreck after ten months in jail awaiting trial for the murders of her father and stepmother. It predicts she will be declared hopelessly insane at her upcoming trial and sent to an asylum rather than convicted.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

Chariton Courier · 2 June 1893 · page 7

Miss Lizzie Borden, of Fall River, Massachusetts, who has been con fined in jail at that place, for the last ten months for killing her father

See the clipping

The Olneyville Times · Olneyville Providence, R.I.

A newspaper miscellany column mentions that the Borden case, like the Graves case, is to be tried again before the judges. It treats the upcoming Lizzie Borden trial as a well-worn matter for renewed discussion.

The Olneyville Times · 2 June 1893 · page 2

The Graves case is to be tried again and Lizzie Borden is again before the judges. The well worn cases will again receive a thorough discussion.

See the clipping

The Bennington Banner · Bennington, Vt.

Mrs. Mary Livermore reports a jail interview with Lizzie Borden, who calmly but emotionally protests her innocence of the murders. Borden argues the crime's circumstances—broad daylight, servants and relatives nearby—make it illogical to believe she could have committed it undetected.

CorrectionThis set right an article from the day before.

The Bennington Banner · 2 June 1893 · page 6

LIZZIE BORDEN ON HER OWN OASE. Mrs. Mary A. Livermoro bad a long interviow witb tbo allegcd murdcrcss, Lizzio Borden, in Tauton jail recently. Mrs. Livermoro says bf that interviow: "Lizzio Bordcn talkcd to mo vo'ry frooly of tho wholo caso, but very calmly ana sadly. You c!n seo that tlio girl feols ber position keenly. I spoko of tbo commcnts on ber stolid indiffercnco. 'What would thoy havo me do?' sho askcd sadly., 'IIowl? Go into hystcr tcs? I am wrongly accuscd of two hor riblo ciifnes. I know it is usclcss to cry out in 'iudignatiou at tha outrago, so I am trying hard to keep calm and sclf controllcd uutiM shall bo provcd inuo cont.'

See moreSee less

'' 'Wbat hurts me most,' sho said again, 'is tho malignant fecling that has bcen sbown. I bave d'ono no hiirm to any ono. Is my character of thirty ycars to count for notliing "nothiiig bccauso I am accuscd bf somo tcriiblo crimc?' Then sho grew moro excitod, and spoko of tlio crimo itsolf. 'How can thoy tliink mo guilty?' sho oxclaimed. 'Whata fool must I bavo beeii if I committcd a crimo likq that iu broad dayligbt, with tho cer tajntly of dctcction, with peoplo going to'and fro on tbe street, with Bridgot washing windows and likely to come in at any nionient for water, witb my unclo vislting us and likely td bo back at any timo, with tho curtainsupand tho noigb bors astir. I know cvcry foot of tlit houso. I could havo walked all over it in tho dark, suro of my way. Why, if I eontemplated that crimo, sli'ould I nbc havo dono it at night? Two blows, as thoy lay a-dcop, no nolso,' no stir. I could havo oponed wido tlio street door, mado ovidenco of a strugglo in tho room and then with plenty of timo to removo from myself all traccs of tho blbod,' gono quiotly to my bed.-' But they say. that I committed botli crirucs at noonday, and romoved from'myself aU'ovidcnco'of the borriblo work. 'llow cau thoy beliovo that?' "Lizzio Borden has no thoiight of os cape. Sho has no thcory of tho, murdor, sho 'says'; it is to hor"a3"horriblo'a mys: tery as it is to us all.. In spito ,of the network of circiimstanti.il OTldcnco woven about lior, in spito of tho hatchets in Now Bedford seo tlio farco of it Lizzio Bordcn assorts hor inuocenco,,aud I beliovo' ber.'' i

See the clipping

The Bennington Banner · Bennington, Vt.

Lizzie Borden speaks emotionally about the accusation against her, arguing it would have been foolish to commit the murders in broad daylight with so many people nearby and likely to witness or interrupt her. She insists she has no theory about who committed the murders, calls it as much a mystery to her as to everyone else, and maintains her innocence despite the circumstantial evidence.

The Bennington Banner · 2 June 1893 · page 6

LIZZIE BORDEN ON HER OWN

that?' "Lizzio Borden has no thoiight of os cape. Sho has no thcory of tho, murdor, sho 'says'; it is to hor"a3"horriblo'a mys: tery as it is to us all.. In spito ,of the network of circiimstanti.il OTldcnco woven about lior, in spito of tho hatchets in Now Bedford seo tlio farco of it Lizzio Bordcn assorts hor inuocenco,,aud I beliovo' ber.'' i

See the clipping

The Meeker Herald · Meeker, Colo.

A one-line telegraphic brevity reports that Lizzie Borden's mind is said to be failing. It appears among a list of unrelated short news items from around the world.

The Meeker Herald · 3 June 1893 · page 2

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

See the clipping

Waterbury Evening Democrat · Waterbury, Conn.

Lizzie Borden left Taunton on the 10:31 train for New Bedford, where her trial will take place. The brief notice marks her transfer ahead of court proceedings.

Waterbury Evening Democrat · 3 June 1893 · page 4

Serious Accident In Bridgeport. Bridgeport, June 3. Albert Forn bad, a carpenter, fell from a scaffold ing, three stories, to-day, receiving in juries that may prove fatal. Uzsla Borden Goes to New Bedford.

See the clipping

The Jersey City News · Jersey City, N.J.

Sheriff Wright escorted Lizzie Borden from Taunton jail to New Bedford on the 10:30 train. She wore plain dress, carried pansies, and appeared in better health than at her arraignment.

CorrectionThis set right an article from the day before.

The Jersey City News · 3 June 1893 · page 2

HOMESTEAD PROSECUTIONS DROPPED. Pittsburg. Junq 3, 1893.—All of the charges of murder, etc., against H. C. Frick and others of the Carnegie steel Company officials, as well as the Pinkerton detectives, were dropped in court this morning. In turn, all ot the strikers who ti d been arrested and were as yet nutried.bnva been released on their own vecoguizauces. This virtually ends all of the Homestead cases in connection with tbe big strike of last year. LIZZIE BORDEN’S ORDEAL. 1'AUNTON, Mass.. June 3, 1893.—Sheriff Wright took Lizzie Bordeu from Taun ton jail to New Bedford on the 10.30 train this forenoou. Miss Bordeu was plainly dressed, curried a hunch of pau sies, and seemed In oetler health than when she weut over to be arraigned.

See the clipping

The Evening World · New York, N.Y.

This newspaper notice advertises an upcoming complete summary of the Lizzie Borden case, noting its enormous national interest. It frames the central question as whether she is a guilty murderess or an innocent victim with remarkable luck.

The Evening World · 3 June 1893 · page 8

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

See the clipping

The Evening World · New York, N.Y.

This is a promotional blurb advertising tomorrow's edition, which will feature a complete summary of the nationally followed Lizzie Borden case. It notes the public is divided on whether she is a guilty murderess or an innocent woman with remarkable composure.

The Evening World · 3 June 1893 · page 8

The words of this article could not be separated from the rest of its page. Read it in the clipping.

No clean clipping could be cut from this page

The Evening World · New York, N.Y.

This is a promotional teaser for the Sunday World newspaper, advertising an upcoming feature summarizing the Lizzie Borden case. It frames the public fascination with the case by noting she is seen as either a brutal murderess or an innocent woman with remarkable composure.

The Evening World · 3 June 1893 · page 8

I I Do We Pay Too Hitch for Gas ? Lizzie Borden. ' HE SAYS SHE IS BEING OUPEO. But Mrs. Vlasto Is Entisfiod with

See the clipping

The Evening World · New York, N.Y.

Sheriff Wright moved Lizzie Borden from Taunton Jail to New Bedford by train ahead of her trial. She appeared in good health, dressed in finery, and carried a bunch of pansies; the trial was set to begin the following Monday.

The Evening World · 3 June 1893 · page 2

LIZZIE BORDEN'S TRIAL

York Back In Kentucky. MAUION, Ky June 3. The long-lost Kentucky girl, Miss Halite J, Moore, who mysteriously disappeared from the Cornell residence In Now York, and was finally discovered, a mother, In the almshouse In Lancaster, Pa., re. turned here yesterday morning, with her baby. Immediately upon leaving the train she went to the Home of her brolher-ln-lnw, Cen. i:. Huston, anil Is in socluelon, refusing to see nny callers, nnd It Is Imposslblu to get nny statement from her. j LIZZIE BORDEN'S TRIAL.

See the clipping

The Evening World · New York, N.Y.

This is a promotional item from The World advertising its Sunday edition, listing a complete summary of the Lizzie Borden case as one of several featured stories. It describes the case as one of the most remarkable murders in history and notes public uncertainty over whether Borden is guilty or an innocent victim.

The Evening World · 3 June 1893 · page 8

Lizzie Borden.

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

See the clipping

In the story →

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

Lizzie Borden left Taunton quietly by train for New Bedford ahead of her upcoming murder trial, maintaining a calm, composed demeanor throughout the journey. The report notes her apparent nerve and describes her watching the countryside, while speculating whether she can endure the ordeal to come.

The Providence News · 3 June 1893 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

TO FACE HER ACCUSERS.

MISS LIZZIE BORDEN LEFT FOR NEW BEDFORD THIS MORNING.

See moreSee less

She Faces Her Coming Trial With the Composure of Innocence—Few Knew That She Was to Leave Taunton Today.

SPECIAL TO THE NEWS.

TAUNTON, Mass., June 3—Lizzie Borden left here for New Bedford on the 10:01 o'clock train this morning. The preparations for her departure had been very quietly made, and it was intended to keep the time of her departure a secret, but that was an impossibility. The tickets were bought early this morning, and the party drove to the station just in time to catch the train.

As she alighted from the carriage and walked to the train her step was firm and elastic, and she showed no signs of physical breaking down.

The ride to New Bedford was an uneventful one, and the prisoner maintained her usual calm demeanor, though she fully realized that at the end of her trip she was to undergo the trial on which possibly her life depends.

The thoughts that filled her breast found no expression in her face, and as the cars whirled along through the country, now beautiful in its early summer garb, she seemed absorbed in watching the beautiful landscape. She has apparently called into requisition all that wonderful nerve which upheld her during her preliminary trial, and of which she will so sorely stand in need in the days that are to come when she will stand before the bar charged with the awful crime which the state has worked so hard to fasten upon her. Whether she will be able to go through the trial without breaking down is a question that time alone can solve. Her friends, confident in her innocence, claim that she will be able to do so, notwithstanding the awful strain that will be placed upon her.

Arrived at New Bedford.

SPECIAL TO THE NEWS.

NEW BEDFORD, June 3.—Lizzie Borden's departure from Taunton had been kept so quiet and the run was so short that her arrival here was unheralded, and so there were only a few people at the depot when the train came in. Sheriff Wright conducted the prisoner immediately to the jail.

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

A Fall River businessman recounts seeing a wild, pale, ragged man near an abandoned building while driving with his wife ten days before the Borden murders. The story is presented as support for the theory that a lunatic roaming the woods near Fall River committed both the Borden and Manchester murders.

The Providence News · 3 June 1893 · page 2

" FALL RIVER, Mass,, June 8.-—The theory which has for some time existed in many minds that there is lurking some where in the woods about Fall River, a lunatic who perpetrated both the Borden and Manchester murders, has gained a certain degree of confirmation. A well-known Boston business man who has lived here and still continues to live part of the year in Fall River said yester day. “My story is not calculated to allay the feelings of anxiety and apprehension which now fill *he hearts of those who live in lonely farmhouses on the outskirts of Fall River, particularly in the direction of the new Boston roads, but 10 days previ ous to the Oommission of the Borden Murder T and my wife took a pleasure drive from ¥Fall River to Assonet and return., We oame back by the upper or Bell road, which finally leads to the New Boston road, whereon stands the Mauchester house.

See moreSee less

%It is a desolate and lonely way, houses are few and far between and the woods and swamps on either side are almost im penetrable. Passing one of these dilapi dated structures we were startled to see the figure of a man Attentively Regarding Us from around a corner. His face was pale and pinched, with a wolfish expression about the eyes. His clothing was in rags and apparently filthy. This uncanny ob

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

A witness recounts an unsettling encounter with a ragged, wild-looking man near an abandoned house, suggesting an insane vagrant could be responsible for the Manchester murder. Meanwhile, police investigate a Black suspect held on vagrancy charges, search for a suspicious tramp in Lowell, and comb the crime scene for evidence including bloodstained clothing.

The Providence News · 3 June 1893 · page 2

IS A LUNATIC RESPONSIBLE?

Attentively Regarding Us from around a corner. His face was pale and pinched, with a wolfish expression about the eyes. His clothing was in rags and apparently filthy. This uncanny ob mlooked at us steadfastly and then van within the ruins. “We did not stop to investigate, for it was growing dark, and as the place had an uncomfortable appearance I whipped the horses, with the object of getting to civil ization as soon as possible. The abandoned house is not far distant from the branch lane reaching to Dr. Durfee's charcoal and acid factory, and is less than two miles from the Manchester place.

See moreSee less

Ido not see why this theory of the insane man has not been thought of earlier in regard vo the Borden case.” Louis Quarry, the negro suspected of being implicated in the murder of Bertha M. Manchester, was arraigned yesterday on a charge of va grancy, and was held in bond of $5OO for his appearance on Tuesday. The so-called suspicious articles found on him have no connection with the Man chesters, but is held to give an opportunity for further investigation. Twenty policemen went yesterday after noon to the seene of the murder to search through the woods west of the farm and to investigate the matter of the piece of stained woolen underwear found hanging on a bush in the orchard back of the barn. It is stated that the girl's stomach has been removed for expert examination to determine whaut time the murder was com-

See the clipping

Waterbury Evening Democrat · Waterbury, Conn.

The trial of Lizzie Borden for the murder of her father and stepmother began today, with no spectators allowed in the courtroom. One hundred and fifty men were summoned for jury selection, with both defense and state given twenty-two peremptory challenges.

Waterbury Evening Democrat · 5 June 1893 · page 4

Lizzie Borden On Trial. New Bedford, June 5. The trial of Lizzie Borden for the murder of her fa ther and step mother was begun to day No spectators were allowed in the court room. One hundred and fifty men have been summoned from which to select jury. The defense and state have each twenty two peremptory challenges, and it is anticipated that many an hour will pass before twelve good and unbiased men are found.

See the clipping

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

The report describes final preparations in New Bedford for the Lizzie Borden murder trial, set to begin the next morning with Chief Justice Albert Mason presiding. It details jury selection procedures, courtroom seating for the press, and the legal teams: District Attorneys Knowlton and Moody for the prosecution, and ex-Governor Robinson and Andrew Jennings for the defense.

New-York Tribune · 5 June 1893 · page 2

1 ms net register, piv wor ee S00 Jos he Iris, ull probably worth between READY TO BEGIN THE BORDEN TRIAL TO-DAY. New-Bedford, Mass., June 4 (Special).—Preparations for the great Lizzie Borden murder {rial, which b>

See the clipping

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

The report announces that Lizzie Borden's trial for the murder of her father and stepmother begins today in New Bedford, exactly ten months after the crime. It notes intense public interest and anticipates difficulty in empaneling an impartial jury.

New-York Tribune · 5 June 1893 · page 6

A criminal trial of far more than ordinary interest will be begun in New-Bedford to-day— the trial of Lizzie Borden for the murder of her father and stepmother. The crime was an extraordinary one, and despite the long interval since it took place—exactly ten months—public interest in it has not lost its edge. So much publicity bas been attracted by the case that no little difficulty will be experienced in obtaining a jury. No one can envy the task of the men who will be called on to determine Miss Borden's guilt or innocence.

See the clipping

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

This article previews the upcoming trial of Lizzie Borden, noting it will be one of the most celebrated criminal cases in New England history. It recaps the basic facts: the double murder of Andrew and Abby Borden on August 4, 1892, in Fall River, and the household members present at the time, including Lizzie and her stepmother's stepdaughters.

Evening Star · 5 June 1893 · page 8

LIZZIE BORDEN'S CASE - THE TRIAL BEGINS THIS WEEK

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

See the clipping

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

The report describes John Morse's whereabouts during the murders, noting his testimony will only cover household movements that morning since he was away from the house. It then reconstructs Bridget Sullivan's detailed account of Andrew Borden's return home around 10:45, his brief trip upstairs, and Lizzie's appearance with an ironing board shortly before Bridget went to lie down.

Evening Star · 5 June 1893 · page 8

time she looked at theelkitw 1m . A few minutes after that Mr. Bsrde cons to the frost deer; the frost doer was always kp loobed be. msI within a year the BArds house had been ransacked In bread daylight by burg lars. When Brdet heard Mr. Borden at the door she went adlet him n-that was about ten minutes aftar she had looked at the clock to se if it was time to set about getting dinner in other words, it was 10: when Borden get beck to the hoome Bridget testies that he went into the anig room and sat down and took a key and went up stairs by the back way; that he remained there hut a mossent.

See moreSee less

returned, placed the key an a shelf and sat down in the ting room.

See the clipping

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

This report reconstructs Bridget Sullivan's testimony describing the morning of the murders, including Mr. Borden's return home, Lizzie's appearance with an ironing board, and Bridget's rest period before being summoned downstairs. It details the discovery of Mr. Borden's body, the confusion over whether Lizzie said her father was "dead" or "hurt," and the subsequent search for Mrs. Borden upstairs.

Evening Star · 5 June 1893 · page 8

DI Nar 821 Um. noanS. At the time Mr. Borden did this Bridget does not know in what room l.zzie was. The next he saw of Tizzie wo a few minates afterward whe Lii c=me through the sitting room into the dining room with an ironing board in her hands. It was than somewhere between 1:0 and 1:56, for about 10:56 o'clock Bridget say* Ae went stairs to le down. During this time. Bridget says, she does not know where Mrs. Borden was. Lizze bad told her that Mrs. Borden had gone out or was going out. Bridget bad net men her since be tween 9 and 10 'elock in the morning. when dhe (Mrs. Borden) bad told her to wah the windows.

See the clipping

Abendblatt Der Illinois Staats-Zeitung · Chicago, Ill.

The long-awaited trial of Lizzie Borden began today in New Bedford, Massachusetts, with crowds gathering early outside the courthouse. Borden entered the courtroom at 10:58 AM, tastefully dressed with a wide-brimmed summer hat, while seats were reserved for journalists and jurors.

Abendblatt Der Illinois Staats-Zeitung · 5 June 1893 · page 1

Der Prozeß der Lizzie Borden, Der angeblichen Mörderin, heute begonnen. Newßedford, Mass., 5. Juni. Der lang erwartete Prozeß Borden hat heute seinen Anfang genommen. In frü

See the clipping

Der Deutsche Correspondent · Baltimore, Md.

Lizzie Borden, accused of murdering her father and stepmother, was brought under Sheriff Wright's custody to New Bedford and placed in the correctional facility under warden Hunt. Her trial on the murder charges is set to begin the following Monday.

Der Deutsche Correspondent · 5 June 1893 · page 4

Li;;ie Borden's bevorstehender Prozeß. New - Bedford, Mass., 3. Juni. —Lizzie Borden, deren Prozeß aus die Anklagen, ihren Vater nnd ihre Stief mutter ermordet zn haben, am Montag

See the clipping

Daily Kennebec Journal · Augusta, Me.

Lizzie Borden arrived in New Bedford in the custody of Sheriff Wright and was taken to the county jail, where she will be held in one of the ordinary women's cells before possibly being moved to larger hospital cells. John V. Morse also arrived separately to consult with lawyer Jennings, and the trial is set to begin Monday.

Daily Kennebec Journal · 5 June 1893 · page 4

LIZZIE BORDEN Taken to New Bedford. Where Her Trial Will Commence Today. Nfcw Bkhi okii. June 3.— Lizzie A. Bor I den arrived in this city about noon today, j She left Taunton in the custody of Sherir

See the clipping

The Portland Daily Press · Portland, Me.

A Boston Daily Globe dispatch announces that Lizzie Borden's trial will begin Monday, June 5, at New Bedford, calling it one of the most famous trials in New England history. It promises a complete phonographic transcript of testimony and vivid courtroom sketches by reporter Joseph Howard, Jr.

The Portland Daily Press · 5 June 1893 · page 1

LIZZIE BORDEN'S TRIAL.

Howard, Jr. Boston, June 8.—The trial of Lizzi Borden of Fall River will be one of tli most famous in the annals of New Enj land. It will be begun on Monda;

See the clipping

The Portland Daily Press · Portland, Me.

The trial of Lizzie Borden for the murder of her father and stepmother is set to begin at New Bedford, with jury selection starting once the judges take their seats. Reporters from Boston, Providence and New York have flocked to the courthouse, complaining of limited seating, while Borden herself arrived from Taunton looking pale but recovered from illness.

The Portland Daily Press · 5 June 1893 · page 1

READY FOR THE GREAT TRIAL.

Bedford Today. New Bedford, Mass., June 4.—The. preparations for the trial of Lizzie An drews Borden, for the murder of her fa ther and stepmother, are all completed. Immediately after Chief Justice Mason and Judges Blodgett and Dewey take their places in the court room tomorrow, the work of empanelling the jurors will begin. Already the counsel for both sides are on the spot waiting for the hour of the opening of the court, which is set at 11. The trains today brought a large number of newspaper men from Boston, Providence and New York, and more are expected on the early trains in the morning.

See moreSee less

Dissatisfaction at the limited accommodations furnished the newspa per writers is very marked, and those who are not able to obtain seats in the court room are free in denunciation of the authorities. Since Lizzie Borden en tered the jail here yesterday, the officers have not vouchsafed any information as to how she has spent the time. The only thing they are willing to say is the pris oner is not coufined in any of the cells to which the reporters consigned her Satur day. Her trip from Taunton yesterday was uneventful. She was apparently fully recovered from her recent illness, excepting as to a pallor which marked the effect of the confinement.

See the clipping

The Portland Daily Press · Portland, Me.

The report announces that Lizzie Borden's trial for the murder of her father and stepmother begins today in New Bedford. It notes the unusually intense public interest in the case and observes that Massachusetts law, unlike some other jurisdictions, does not exclude jurors who have already formed opinions.

The Portland Daily Press · 5 June 1893 · page 4

question that will happily never be answered. Lewiston Sun. How many days ago was it, esteemec contemporary, that you rebuked thi Pbess for what you regarded as an at tempt to make political capital out of : business failure? How can you expect your rebukes to be effective if you; preaching and your practice are so differ ent? The trial of Lizzie Borden on the chargi of murdering her father and stepmothei is to begin at New Bedford today. It ii doubtful if there ever was a trial in the New England states in which there was so general a public interest as there wil be in this one.

See moreSee less

Luckily the Massachu setts law does not exclude from the juri box everybody who may have formed ai opinion in regard to the case, else i would be practically impossible to ge twelve men to try the case, for it liai been discussed so generally and so lonj that it is hardly possible that there ii any person of intelligence who has no; formed some idea m regard to it.

See the clipping

The Jersey City News · Jersey City, N.J.

The long-anticipated trial of Lizzie Borden began in New Bedford, with crowds gathering early outside the courthouse and deputies guarding the entrances. Borden entered the courtroom dressed in black brocade with a blue-trimmed hat, acknowledging defense counsel's bow with only a slight nod before taking her seat in the dock.

The Jersey City News · 5 June 1893 · page 1

LIZZIE BORDEN ON TRIAL

Trials Began Today. Special to TJie Jersey City News. New Bedford, Mass., Jvue 5, 1893.— Thh long anticipated Borden murder trial baa begun. At au early hour this

See the clipping

The Jersey City News · Jersey City, N.J.

The report describes the opening of Lizzie Borden's murder trial, detailing courtroom seating arrangements and the formal proceedings as Chief Justice Mason convened the court. The jury selection process begins with talesmen being questioned about their ability to render impartial judgment, including the first juror Ansel G. Baker.

The Jersey City News · 5 June 1893 · page 1

JUSTICE GETTING READY.

attorney, a short consultation was held. Meanwhile Messrs. Adams and Jennings their mustaches, anxious for a begin ning. Court came in at precisely tweDtv-sev en miuutes past eleven. Chief Justice Mason taking the centre seat, with the Rev. M. C. Julien of New Bedford, who had been selected to muke the regulation opening prayer, on his extreme left. As soon as they were seated Deputy Sheriff Thomas VV. Butman was instructed by Clerk Borden to make the usual procla mation to the talesmen, after_ which the clerk called them ia alphabetical ordeij Seven miuutes were thus taken ud.

See moreSee less

after which a briet yrayer was offered, Miss Boraeu tjtuuding. Then the District Attorney couveyed officially to the court what has been well known for a week or so, that the Attornoy General will not be here to attend to his duty, and that Mr. William H. Moody, District Attorney of Essex county, would acr. He gave to the court the addilioual Information iu a very formal manner, tnat Lizzie Andrew Borden had been indicted for the murder of her father and stepfather, aud he hud dUe-Uacor to move for the impaneling of a jury tor the trial of the cause. Chief Justice Mason then addressed the talesmen a body, stating that he should be obliged to put certain question to them as they came before the court relative to forming opiuions, their bias or prejudice, etc. He read a section of an opinion from the Chief Justice of the Court of last resort, bearing upon the matter of opinions, aud he cautioned them that all of their Janswers must be given under oath. MENTAL CAPABILITIES.

See the clipping

The Evening World · New York, N.Y.

The long-anticipated Borden murder trial opened in a sweltering New Bedford courtroom, with crowds gathering outside before dawn and jury selection beginning at 10 a.m. Lizzie Borden entered at 10:58, dressed in black, and kept her eyes downcast as she passed counsel and took her seat in the dock.

The Evening World · 5 June 1893 · page 1

With Kyes Downcast. NKW BRDFORD, Mass., June B.-Th long anticipated Borden murder trial has' At nn early hour this morning every available shady spot on County street, 1 H near the Courl-House, was pre-empted, '

See the clipping

The Evening World · New York, N.Y.

The trial opens with jury selection beginning, as District-Attorney Moody takes over prosecution duties and formally informs the court of Lizzie Borden's indictment for the murder of her father and stepmother. The first juror, George Potter of Westport, is sworn in despite having formed an opinion on the case.

The Evening World · 5 June 1893 · page 1

BORDEN TRIAL BEGINS

Justice Mason taking the centre seat. iffll Sheriff Thomas W. Butman made the ?Hb! usunl proclamation to the talesmen, ivMI after which the clerk called them In 'jflal . alphabetical order. cHI Prayer wns offered by Rev. Mr. Julian, '-Sal I Then the District-Attorney conveyed' sBsi I officially to the court what has been i well-known for n week or so. that the UH1 Attorney-Oenernl will not be here to nt tend to his duty, nnd that William H. Moody, District-Attorney of Essex Ba1 County, would act. He gave to the Court the additional Information In a 'VWH very formal manner that Lizzie Borden jSH had been Indicted for the murder of vBl her father nnd stepmother, and thnt &HH 1 he had the honor to move for the ImelHl panelling of a Jury for the trial of the ''fBI CM-f JuRt'c Mes-n then addressel tt"i ikMI talesmen as a body, aftee which Mlssv tjjMl Borden was asked to stand up, nnd waa liBI told of her right to challenge.

See moreSee less

-H George Potter, of Westport, who bad JbM formed nn opinion, but did not think.' -,H1 It was sufficient to prevent ft being, changed, was duly sworn and placed In the box nt 11. CI, ns the first juror ac-

See the clipping

The Evening World · New York, N.Y.

The report reconstructs the timeline of the murders using testimony about when Mr. and Mrs. Borden died and Lizzie's composed, unstained appearance shortly after each killing. It argues the tight timeframes make it nearly impossible for Lizzie to have committed both murders without leaving any trace of blood or disorder, criticizing police for focusing solely on her as a suspect.

The Evening World · 5 June 1893 · page 4

crime within half an hour. At 10.65 Bridget went upstairs to Ho down before getting dinner ready, as was her custom. At thnt time Mr. Bor den was alive and asleep on the par lor sofa. Fifteen or twenty minutes afterwards Lizzie Borden gave an alarm and called Bridget downstairs. Mr. Borden was then dead. Lizzie was dressed as before, was calm and with

See the clipping

The Evening World · New York, N.Y.

The report describes the start of Lizzie Borden's murder trial in a hot, crowded New Bedford courtroom, with crowds gathering outside and jury selection underway. It details Lizzie's arrival at 10:53 AM dressed in black, her composed demeanor, and the courtroom atmosphere including a brief wordless exchange with defense counsel Melvin Adams.

The Evening World · 5 June 1893 · page 1

County, would act. He gave to the jsVjS Court the additional Information In a . liH very formal manner that Lizzie Borden .wM I had been Indicted for the murder of raffP her father nnd stepmother, and that "i'jfc i he had the honor to move for the ImSfU panelling of a Jury' for the trial of the vi4J cause. "fSfl Chief Justlc Mason then addrnrsel the talesmen us a body, nfter which Miss Wlf Borden was asked to stand up, nnd was told of her right to challenge. MSI George Potter, of Westpnrt, who had Wll i formed nn opinion, but did not tblnk j&S It was sufficient to prevent it being iia changed, was duly sworn nnd placed In vlttB , the box nt 11.54, as the first juror -'iaf cepted.

See the clipping

The Evening World · New York, N.Y.

The Borden murder trial began with District-Attorney Moody announcing the indictment against Lizzie Borden for the murder of her father and stepmother, and requesting a jury be empanelled. The first juror, George Potter of Westport, was sworn in and seated at 11:54 after stating he could set aside any opinion he had formed.

The Evening World · 5 June 1893 · page 1

BORDEN TRIAL BEGINS

The words of this article are printed with the report it shares its clipping with. Read them there or in the clipping.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

Paper unidentified

The report announces that Lizzie Borden's trial for the murder of her father Andrew Jackson Borden and stepmother Abbie Borden began in New Bedford, Massachusetts. It briefly recaps the victims as a wealthy, respected couple killed on the morning of August 4, 1892.

Paper unidentified · 5 June 1893 · page 1

CRIMINAL NEWS.

Flay False. New Bedford, Mass., June 6. The trial of Lizzie Borden, of Fall River, on charge of murdering her father, An drew Jackson Borden, and .her step mother Abbio Borden,an aged,wealtby, and highly respeoted couple, on tbe morning of August 4. 1802, began here this morning.

See the clipping

Pawtucket Tribune · Pawtucket, R.I.

The superior court trial of Lizzie Borden for the murder of her father and stepmother began at 11 o'clock in New Bedford, with Justice Mason presiding. Her sister Emma Borden was present in the city, staying with friends, and press representatives were given special accommodations in the courtroom.

Pawtucket Tribune · 5 June 1893 · page 1

ON TRIAL FOR HER LIFE

John W. Nickerson. NEw Beororp, Mass., June s.—At 11 o'clock this morning the superior court assembled in the court house on County street, and the trial of Lizzie Borden, tharged with the murder of her father sud stepmother, was begun, Emma Borden, who, next to her sister, is the most notable figure in the trial, will stay with friends in this city during its progress, Mrs, Mary A. Livermore, the tried and true friend who manifested so great an interest in Miss Borden since she has rested under the shadow now hanging over her, will be present at the trial, it is expected. Justice Mason and his associates arrived in this city this forenoon. They went te

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

The trial of Lizzie Borden for the murders of her father Andrew and stepmother Abbie opened in New Bedford, with the first day devoted to jury selection and spectators barred to make room for talesmen. The report recaps the background of the Bordens' wealth and the August 1892 discovery of the murders by Lizzie and Bridget Sullivan.

The Providence News · 5 June 1893 · page 1

LIZZIE BORDEN ON TRIAL.

The criminal history of New England records no more awful tragedy than the cruel butchery of these two aged peo ple. Mr. Borden, a man of 65 years of age, was one of the wealthiest citizens of Fall River. His wealth was partly inberited but by far the larger portion of it was ac quired by frugal habits and shrewd Lusi ness methods, He was well and widely known as one to whom fortune brought no joy except in the possession. Mrs. Borden was his second wife and she seems also of unostentatious character. The murders occurred on Thurslay, Aug. 4, 1802, at some time between 10 and 11:30 a. m,

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

This report summarizes the background of the Borden murders, the initial investigation, and the weak circumstantial case built by prosecutors. It highlights contradictions in testimony and notes the trial's focus on witnesses like druggist Eli Bence.

The Providence News · 5 June 1893 · page 1

Lizzie's Awfal Discovery. The first intimation that the public rec-ived was the cry of the daughter, Lizzie, to Bridget Sullivan, who at once went for Dr. Bowen, the family physi cian. The authorities were notified, and in less than a half-bour the news was spread over the whole country. The police aud detectives began to hunt for clews. A careful search of the houss was made. The barn in the rear was examined. Clews pointing to red-handed men and supposed assassins were all foilowed diligently to their end. Mean while it was thought more because the pubjic demanded some result and some arrest thin because there wasany evidence .

See moreSee less

either direct or circumstantial the au thorities arrestea lizzie Borden. All the evidence they had at the time of the arrest was that no one else had been found upon whom the crime could be tixed. And during the entire prelimi nary hearing all the evidence produced was on'y to 'he effect that no one else hat been seen near the Borden house at that time, Wituess after witness was called by the prosecution to show that no one was secn near the house and the evidence was uot eveu clear as to that fact,

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

Professor Wood testified that microscopic and chemical analysis found no human blood on the hatchet, Lizzie's shoes, stockings, or dress, only a pinhead-sized spot on her underskirt. The defense argued this undermined the prosecution's case, while the report also recaps the earlier preliminary hearing and grand jury findings against her.

The Providence News · 5 June 1893 · page 1

MISS LIZZIE BORDEN

Two Tribunals Hela Her. Nevertheless Judge Blaisle!l, who has since resignel from his position because of allezed improper acts, found Lizzie probably guilty. The grand jury held its secret session and also found her probubly guilty, and today bas begun the trial which will set tle finallv whether a daughter could have deliberately hacked and mutilated her garents as the Bordens wer>2, or whether the government will fail to prove its case. New developments are expected, but the public will want much stronger evidence than any yet produced before it will pronounce the sentence of guilty on L'zzie Borden. In the months that bhave elapsed since Lizzie Borden was found probably guilty

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

The report describes Lizzie Borden's arrival at the courthouse under guard of Deputy Sheriff Kirby, noting her changed, sorrowful appearance compared to earlier times. It also details her attire and the presence of clergy and courtroom spectators.

The Providence News · 5 June 1893 · page 2

tenaed as she drew near the door. Her face was turned away fromn the crowd as if she would avoid their staring gaze. Then she turned, gave her hand to Sheriff Kirby, auppos lightly trom the carriage and emtered the doox where her trial for life or death was to, occur. It was not vhe Lizzie Borden wof a year ago., It was not the Lizzie ‘Borden of ten months ago. The formn was the same, the easy and graceful carriage was the same, but the tace had changed.

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

The report describes the opening of Lizzie Borden's murder trial, including the courtroom scene, the judges, attorneys, and the prayer given before proceedings began. It details the start of jury selection, noting the questioning of talesmen about bias and relation to the victims, and Lizzie's challenge of the second juror.

The Providence News · 5 June 1893 · page 2

District Attorney Kno witon Arose. District Attorney Kue wlion rose, ex plained that Attorney Gaeral Pittsb ury was ill, and asked that Mr. Moody be © assigued to assist him. 'l‘sln he said, ‘‘Lizzie Andrew Borden ——fsmow at the bar charged with two counts. One the murder of ber rather, Audrew Jennings Borden, and the otl er the murder of Abbie Horclen, I ask thue

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

An intimate friend of District-Attorney Moody claims little new evidence will be introduced at the Borden trial, except one unpublished detail: that days before the killings, Lizzie Borden allegedly told neighbors she had a premonition a murder would occur in her family. The item also reports ongoing jury selection, noting many New Bedford men were challenged and most jurors chosen came from rural areas.

The Providence News · 5 June 1893 · page 2

BUT LITTLE NEW TESTIMONY.

An Intimate l"rl.n-d_;f District-Attorney Moody Responsible for ‘1 his Statement. HAVERHILL, Mass., June b —Ex-Sena tor Benjamin F. Bracket:, an intimate friend of Mr. Moody, is authority for the statement that very little new evidence will be introduced into the Borden trial. The only important bit of testimcn: yet uop.blished which will ue offered will be to prove that a few days before the trugedy, Miss Borden in conversitio with some neighbors, said that she had a present centthat within a few da)s there wou!d be a murder fn uer fawily.

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

The report announces that Lizzie Borden's trial for the murder of her father and stepmother has begun in New Bedford. It criticizes the Fall River police's early handling of the case and suggests public skepticism that prosecutors can prove her guilt.

The Providence News · 5 June 1893 · page 4

THE GREAT MYSTERY;

toward finding proof of the guilt of Miss Borden will be revealed during the trial. The unaccountable laxity shown during the first two day after the crime was committed discredited the Fall River police to such an extent that the public has never felt that re. liance could be placed wupon their theories, There has been a singular hesitancy displayel by the prosecuting officers throughout, From the time of the murder to the present they have appar ently had but little faith in their case against Miss Borden. Responsibility has been avoided, and steps have been taken with signs of reluctantance.

See moreSee less

The avoidance of direct responsibile ity by the attorney gemeral of Massa chusetts, almost on the eve of the trial, when at an earlivr stage he had insisted upon taking the management of the case into his own hands, gives color te a suspicion that the government's case is not strong. Many circumstances have strengthened this belief. The public belief is that if Lizzie Borden is not innocent the prosecuting officers have an exceedingly difficult task to prove her guilty. This belief may be found to be utterly without foundation, but it has grown in strength and exfent since the unfortunate woman was arrested, The concern of the public in this trial is more that the efficacy of the officers of the law, and the processes by which the law assumes to protect human life, be vindicated, than that Lizzie Borden be exculpated or convicted, There is scarcely a shadow of possibility that she will not receive justice. A jury could not be erapanelled that would conviet her if the evidence did not fully war rant it,

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

This report questions the prosecution's resolve in the Lizzie Borden case, noting hesitancy and shifting responsibility among officials as the trial nears. It reflects public skepticism about whether the government can prove her guilt, while expressing confidence that justice will prevail regardless of outcome.

The Providence News · 5 June 1893 · page 4

THE GREAT MYSTERY;

The words of this article are printed with the report it shares its clipping with. Read them there or in the clipping.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

The Waco Evening News · Waco, Tex.

The report describes Lizzie Borden taking her seat in the prisoner's dock at the Massachusetts supreme court in New Bedford. It notes the beginning of a fierce legal contest between top criminal lawyers over her life and honor.

The Waco Evening News · 5 June 1893 · page 1

Mkw Bedford, Mass., Jane .". To-day Lizzie Borden took her seat in a prisoner's dock of the supreme oourt here, and a battle royal be tween most eminent criminal lawyers in the state with a woman's life aud honor at stake began.

See the clipping

San Antonio Daily Light · San Antonio, Tex.

Lizzie Borden took her seat in the prisoners' dock at the Superior Court in New Bedford, Massachusetts, as her murder trial began. The report notes a legal battle between the state's most eminent criminal lawyers, with Borden's life and reputation at stake.

San Antonio Daily Light · 5 June 1893 · page 1

The Lizzie Borden Case. New Bedford, Mass., June 5.— (Special.)—Today Lizzie Borden took her seat in the prisoners’ dock of the Superion court here and a battle between the most emi nent criminal lawyers in the state, with the woman’s life and honor at stake, began. Democrats “Get Together.”

See the clipping

San Antonio Daily Light · San Antonio, Tex.

The report previews the trial of Lizzie Borden, set to begin in New Bedford, describing the courtroom preparations, counsel for both sides, and public fascination with the case. It also recounts background on the Borden family and a suggested motive involving inheritance disputes between Lizzie and her stepmother.

San Antonio Daily Light · 5 June 1893 · page 1

Trying Lizzie Borden. New Bedford, Mass., June 5.— Perhaps the most sensational trial New England has ever had in half a century or more is that which

See the clipping

Alexandria Gazette · Alexandria, D.C.

A daily news roundup reports that the trial of Lizzie Borden for the murder of her father and stepmother began that day in New Bedford, Massachusetts. The item is one of many unrelated short news briefs from around the country.

Alexandria Gazette · 5 June 1893 · page 2

NEWS OF THE DAY. The attendance at the Chicago Fair yesterday was not large. Four persons were burned to death in a lire in a New York teucmeut early yesterday morning. The trial of Miss Lizzie Borden for the murder of her father and step?

See the clipping

Alexandria Gazette · Alexandria, D.C.

The long-anticipated trial of Lizzie Borden opened in New Bedford, Massachusetts, with crowds gathering outside the courthouse before dawn. Borden entered the courtroom at 10:58 a.m. wearing a black brocaded dress and blue-trimmed hat, taking her seat in the prisoner's dock.

Alexandria Gazette · 5 June 1893 · page 2

The Borilcn Trial. NEW Bedi-'ORD, Mass., June u.?Tho long anticipated Borden murder trial has begun. At an early hour this morning every available shady spot on County street near tho court house was preempted and patiently tho sit? ters and Standers waited until the bell on the court house was tolled, signify? ing the opening of court. At precisely 10:58 Miss Lizzie A. Borden, tho prison?

See the clipping

Morning Journal and Courier · New Haven, Conn.

The trial of Lizzie Borden began in New Bedford with jury selection, as crowds gathered outside the courthouse despite the heat. Lizzie Borden entered the courtroom in a black brocaded dress and blue-trimmed hat, acknowledging her defense counsel with only a slight nod before Chief Justice Mason opened court with a prayer.

Morning Journal and Courier · 6 June 1893 · page 3

Fall List ot the Jury The Trial Will Take Three Weeks. Niw Bedford, Jane 5. The long an ticipated Borden trial haa began. At an early bout this morning svery available shady spot on County street near the oonrt honse was pre cmpted, and patiently the sitters and Btanders waited until the bell on the eonrt honse' was tolled, elgalfyln; tbe opening of oonrt. Deputy sheriffs guarded the entranoe at the front and New Bedford policemen were at the rear. The talesmen began to file Into their plaoea at 10 o'clock and at 11.

See moreSee less

all were there and were checked off, gtven numbers by the clerk and waited the coming with becom ing fortitude. At precisely 10:58 Miss Lizzie Borden, the prisoner, came slowly into the room, preceded by Deputy Sheriff Kirby.and was shown to her seat in the dock. She was at tired in a very becoming ootnme of black brocaded stuff, and wore a pretty Bhade bat relieved by a touch here and there of blue. As she passed the bar enclosure Melvin O. Adams, counsel for the defense. tepped to the rail andbowed to her, bnt Lizzie, while acknowledging with a slight Inclination of the head-the salutatlooiever raised nei eyes to me and passed on slowly beyond to the dock. Court came in at precisely 11:27. Chief Justice Mason taking the center seat, with Bev. M. C. Julian of New Bedford, who had been selected to make the regulation opening prayer, on his extreme left. As soon as they were seated, Deputy snerlff. Thomas W. Batman was instructed by Clerk Borden to make the usual proclama tion to tne talesmen, atter whloh tne olerk then called them In alphabetical order. Seven minutes were thus taken up, after which a brief prayer was offered, Mlsa Borden standing. Chief jQstice Mason addressed the tales men as a body, stating that he should be obliged to put certain questions to them, as they o-ime before tbe court, relative to forming opiolons, their bias or prejudice, etc He read a section of an opinion from the chief justice of the court of last re sort, bearing upon the matter of opinions, and he cautioned them that all of their an swers must be given under oath. If any one of them was so mentally constituted that he could not believe any person would commit a crime panlshable with death, then that person would not do as a juror. Tne clerk was then directed to pro ceed with the impaneling of the jury. Miss Borden was BBked to stand up and told of her right to ohallenge. The first uror was Ansel U. Baker of New Bed ford, who said he did not think any evi dence whioh could be produoed wonld in duce him to change his mind, and he was told to step aside. The following jurors were aocepted:

See the clipping

Morning Journal and Courier · New Haven, Conn.

Lizzie Borden entered the New Bedford courtroom as jury selection began, with Chief Justice Mason presiding and questioning prospective jurors about bias and opinions on capital punishment. Twelve jurors were quickly selected and seated, including foreman Charles J. Richards, completing the panel from among the talesmen present.

Morning Journal and Courier · 6 June 1893 · page 3

BORDEN TRIAL BEGINS

Thomas W. Batman was instructed by Clerk Borden to make the usual proclama tion to tne talesmen, atter whloh tne olerk then called them In alphabetical order. Seven minutes were thus taken up, after which a brief prayer was offered, Mlsa Borden standing. Chief jQstice Mason addressed the tales men as a body, stating that he should be obliged to put certain questions to them, as they o-ime before tbe court, relative to forming opiolons, their bias or prejudice, etc He read a section of an opinion from the chief justice of the court of last re sort, bearing upon the matter of opinions, and he cautioned them that all of their an swers must be given under oath.

See moreSee less

If any one of them was so mentally constituted that he could not believe any person would commit a crime panlshable with death, then that person would not do as a juror. Tne clerk was then directed to pro ceed with the impaneling of the jury. Miss Borden was BBked to stand up and told of her right to ohallenge. The first uror was Ansel U. Baker of New Bed ford, who said he did not think any evi dence whioh could be produoed wonld in duce him to change his mind, and he was told to step aside. The following jurors were aocepted:

See the clipping

Waterbury Evening Democrat · Waterbury, Conn.

The report describes the second day of Lizzie Borden's murder trial in New Bedford, noting the surprisingly fast jury selection completed in a single day. It also details Lizzie Borden's entrance into the courtroom, her appearance, and the presence of defense counsel.

Waterbury Evening Democrat · 6 June 1893 · page 1

A JURY OBTAINED IN A SINGLE PAY Intense Interest Shown la the Proceed ing. The Lawyers Who Are Cond act ios; the Case The Trial Began With at Prayer The Accuse Woman Before the Bar. Nxw Bedford, Mass., Jane 6. At 9 o'clock this morning the twelve good men and true who compose the jury that is to decide Lizzie Borden's fate filed into the jury-box and answered to their names as the clerk called the roll. Soon the judges appeared and the second day of the long delayed trial of Lizzie Andrew Borden for the murder of her father and mother began.

See moreSee less

Nearly every one is surprised at the quickness with which the jury was secured. Yesterday when it was stated that this part of the trial might consume not more than two days the person who made the statement was laughed at. None were more surprised than the counsel themselves who were not prepared to so on with the case last eveuing and that part of the pro ceedings had to be left for this morning.

See the clipping

Waterbury Evening Democrat · Waterbury, Conn.

The report describes the opening of Lizzie Borden's trial, including procedural details on jury selection and consultations between counsel and the court. It also profiles her defense attorneys—Jennings, Adams, and ex-Governor Robinson—and notes Borden's frail health after a recent illness.

Waterbury Evening Democrat · 6 June 1893 · page 1

weeks. Miss Borden is still far from strong. Two weeks ago she had a severe attack of the grip, and was threatened with pneu monia. She practically got up from a sick bed to come and stand trial for her life.

See the clipping

Waterbury Evening Democrat · Waterbury, Conn.

The trial opens with Chief Justice Mason presiding and a prayer offered while Lizzie Borden stands; District Attorney Moody formally moves for jury empanelment after announcing Borden's indictment for the murders of her father and stepmother. The lengthy jury selection process continues through the day, with about sixty-five talesmen examined and several challenged by both the defense and prosecution before all twelve jurors are finally secured.

Waterbury Evening Democrat · 6 June 1893 · page 1

As soon as they were seated Deputy Sheriff Thomas W. Butman was instructed by Clerk Borden to make the usual proc lamation to the talesmen, after which the clerk called them in alphabetical order. Seven minutes were thus taken up, after which a brief prayer was offered, Miss Borden standing. ........... Then tbe District Attorney conveyed of ficially to tbe court what has been well known for a week oraoqhat the Attorney General will not be" her to attend to his duty and that Mr. Wm. H. Moody, District Attorney of Essex county, would act.

See moreSee less

rtm save, to the court the additional informa tion in a very formal manner, that Lizzie Andre Borden had been indicted for the murder of her father and step-mother, and that he had the honor to move for the Im panelling of a jury for the trial of the causa. Chief Justice Mason then addressed the talesmen as a body, stating that he should be obliged to put certain questions to them as they came before the court, rela tive to forming opinions, their bias or prejudice, eta Miss Borden was asked to stand up and told of her right to challenge. The first juror was Ansel G. Baker, of New B.-t ford, who sjild be did not think any evi dence which could be produced would in dues him to change bis mind, and he was prejudice, but was not acceptable to the defense. Miss Borden calling her challenge under direction of Mr. Jennings, in a clear voiox George Potter, of Westport, had formed an opinion, bnt did; not .think it wai suffi cient to prevent Vbeing changed. There was no challenge, and he was duly sworn and placed in the box. - V Mortimer be arias, jjew JUedlord, said he had formed and expressed opinions and hip judgment was so well set it would be hard work to change it. Five jurors had been secured at the close of the morning session. YY nan court opened in the afternoon tbe room was again packed. The whole after noon was taken in getting the seven other jurors. About sixty-five of the panel were examined and most ot them were excused for different reasons. Several of them were challenged by Miss Borden, and a few by the prosecution. Most of them were indlfierent. The sixth and seventh jurors were se cured easily, but it was some time before another was secured. Finally Augutus Swift, New Bedford, was Indifferent, and was accepted and sworn in as the eighth juror, and Frank E. Cole, Attleboro, was indifferent, and Chicago. acceptable, being sworn in as the ninth juror. John C. Finn, Taunton, was ac cepted as the tenth juror. Charles Jluchards, JNorth Attleboro, stood indifferent and was accepted and sworn In as the eleventh juror. Oliver . Ulfford, New Bedford, said he was related to the prisoner at the bar and was excused. As ha passed Lizzie so e looked at him in astonishment, and he smiled a cheerful "keep your courage up" to her. Then there was a long; interval before the twelfth man was found, twenty-on e other men having been excused for one reason or another. The last man chosen was Allen H. Wardell of Dartmouth.

See the clipping

Waterbury Evening Democrat · Waterbury, Conn.

During the opening address by Assistant District Attorney Moody at the Borden murder trial, Lizzie Borden fainted as he detailed accusations including the ax murders, a Prussic acid purchase, and an alleged dress burning witnessed by Bridget Sullivan. The court adjourned at noon so jurors could visit the crime scene.

Waterbury Evening Democrat · 6 June 1893 · page 4

LIZZIE BORDEN FAINTS IN COURT. When the Prosecuting Attorney Said She Visited Her Mother's Boom and Burn ed a Dress on the Day of the Murder.

See the clipping

The Morning Call · San Francisco, Calif.

The report announces the start of Lizzie Borden's trial in New Bedford for the murders of her father and stepmother in Fall River. It recaps the circumstantial case, including the household's occupants that morning, the discovery of the bodies, and Lizzie's later arrest due to discrepancies in her account.

The Morning Call · 6 June 1893 · page 2

Her Parents. New Bedford, Mass., Junes.— The trial of Lizzie Borden of Fall River on the charge of murdering her father, Andrew Jack3on Borden, and her .stepmother, Abby Durfee Borden, two aged wealthy and highly respected people, on the morn ing of August 4. 1592, began here this morning. The most eminent criminal lawyers in the State are employed and the trial promises to be most interesting and probably very sensational. The evidence is purely circumstantial. Un ihe day in question, as far as known, the only per sons in the house were the old couple, Lizzie and the maid servant, Bridget Sullivan, who was outside most of ihe morning, washing windows.

See moreSee less

The Bordens were out in the morning, returning be tween 10 and 11 o'clock, and it was only a short time afterward that Lizzie, after a short visit to the barn, called to the serv ant to run for a doctor, as her father had been murdered. Shortly afterward Mrs. Borden was missed and the search re vealed her body in an upper room, she having evidently been killed some time before hei* husband. In both cases death resulted from blows from some heavy, sharp instrument, probably an ax, but the instrument of death has never been dis covered. Certain discrepancies In Lizzie's stories and some other suspicious circum stances led to her arrest some weeks after the murder and her subsequent indict ment.

See the clipping

The Record-Union · Sacramento, Calif.

The report announces that Lizzie Borden's trial for the murders of her father and stepmother began in New Bedford, Massachusetts. It recaps the circumstantial evidence, including the discovery of the bodies and Lizzie's inconsistent statements, leading to her arrest and indictment.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

The Record-Union · 6 June 1893 · page 1

MET WITH INSTANT DEATH. i Terrible Full of an Aeronaut at ' Trenton, New Jersey. Trknton (X. J.l, June ">.—Charles Y. Richmond, an aeronaut, made a 3,000-foot ascension to-day and lost his life. Rich mond rose gracefully, sailing with the wind in a southeasterly direction. When ' ho cut loose from the balloon it was ! noticed by the spectators that tho paraj ! chute failed to work properly, and they j j were horrified to sco Richmond descend I ! with lightning rapidity, making revolu ! tions in the air as he camo dowu.

See moreSee less

Several i women fainted, and everybody in tho great throng were sickened by tho specI tacle. Richmond landed in a muddy lit tle stream, and if he was alive when he touched the surface he was drowned. Ho belonged in Springfield, 111. BORDEN* MURDERS. Trial of Lizzie Began at Fall River, Massachusetts. Nkw BEDFOBD iMass.,, June 5. —The trial of Lizzie llorden of Fall River on the charge of murdering her father, An drew Jackson Borden, and her step mother, Abby Durleo Borden, two aged, wealthy and highly respected people, on the morning of August 1, l""Jr2, began here I this inoruiug. The most eminent crimii nal lawyers in the State aro employed, and the trial promises to be most inter esting and probably very sensational. The evidence is purely circumstantial. On the daj* in question, as far as known, the only persons in the house were the ' old couple, Lizzie and the maid servant, Bridget Sullivan, who was outside most ' of the morning washiug windows. The ! Bordens were out in tho morning, re i turning between 10 and 11 o'clock, and it i I was only a short timo afterward that Lizzie, after a short visit to the barn, ! called to tho servant to run for a doctor, as her father had been murdored. Shortly afterward Mrs. Borden was missed, an.l the search revealed her body in an upper room, she having ovidontly been killed ! some time before her husband. In both j cases death resulted from blows from some heavy, sharp instrument, probably an ax, but the instrument of death has never been discovered. Certain dis crepancies in Lizzie's stories and some other suspicious circumstances led to her arrest some weeks after tho murdor aud her subsequent indictment. Had a CLOSE CALL. Impeached State Officials of Nebraska Reinstated. Omaha (Neb.), June 5.—A special to the (imaha Bee from Lincoln, Neb., says: The impeached oilicials have been rein stated, but they had a close call. The Supremo Court, by a vote of two to one, declared that Secretary of State Allen, Special to the Record-Union. Attorney-General Hastiugs and Com missioner of Public Lands and Buildings Humphrey woro innocent of the charges brought against them by the Legislature. visitors. Chief Justice Maxwell was the dissenter. He held that the three men were guilty of misdemeanors in oflice, and should bo forever debarred from holding positions of trust in the public service. But Hall. Judges Post and No vai, in their opinions, acquitted the accused of any intention of wrongdoing and thus rostored them to thoir oliice. Tho opinion is very lengthy. Judge Maxwell in his dissent finds that "The charges are woll taken, and should I.c sustained. I therefore vote guilty as charged. I find that the result of the de cision if adhered to will bo to open tho door to the grossest frauds in public in stitutions of tho State. A number of wit nesses for the Stato testifiod as if under constraint, and there seemed to be power ful influences affecting some of them, aside from immediate friends of the re spondents at work in their favor. The respondents aro, of course, not responsi ble i'or these influences, but it is my duty to montion them."

See the clipping

The Wilmington Daily Republican · Wilmington, Del.

The long-anticipated Borden murder trial began in New Bedford, with a jury of twelve seated by late afternoon under foreman Charles I. Richards. District Attorney Knowlton expects the trial to last about three weeks, and the report describes Lizzie Borden's appearance and reputation as the proceedings commence.

The Wilmington Daily Republican · 6 June 1893 · page 1

counsel began their opening addresses to the jury. District Attorney Knowlton is of the opinion that at least three weeks will ho required to finish up tho trial, provided there set backs. Tho Borden trial is going to bo of tho most memorable In the criminal annals of New England. Lizzie D. Borden is a young woman 31 years of age, who has heretofore led a respected life, who was identified with numerous religious movements, who, ding to the testimony of her friends, kind of heurt and thoughtful for tho comfort and feelings of others.

See moreSee less

Did this young woman split open her aged father's head with a lmtcliet as ho lay sleeping a sofa, and afterwards go back and so bat ter his f»tce d bead with the same weapon that the doctors who looked upon t he hideous sight could hurdly command their

See the clipping

The Wilmington Daily Republican · Wilmington, Del.

As Lizzie Borden's trial begins, this report recaps the brutal double murder of Andrew and Abby Borden with a hatchet, questioning how Lizzie could have committed the crimes without leaving blood or evidence. It also details Andrew Borden's considerable wealth and reputation as a shrewd, penurious businessman in Fall River.

The Wilmington Daily Republican · 6 June 1893 · page 1

QUICK WORK IN SECURING A JURY

with the deed left undisposed of? luwyers, arc going to decide whether Lizzie Borden did all these things. On Aug. 4, 1892, when Andrew J. Bor Borden, tho eldest daughter, was not at home. She •ay in New Bedford a visit, and hence i

See the clipping

The Wilmington Daily Republican · Wilmington, Del.

The report describes Andrew Borden as a shrewd, penny-pinching businessman worth $350,000 to $500,000, who owned significant property including a business block and bank stock, and had made enemies through his dealings. It also discusses the strained relationship between Lizzie and her stepmother versus the more affectionate, though reserved, relationship Lizzie had with her father.

The Wilmington Daily Republican · 6 June 1893 · page 1

stock, bavings hank. Borden household there is a conflict of Were not tion. Lizzie always addressed her ferred to her as Mrs. Borden, mev years hud hot words with her I cordial terms there is

See the clipping

In the story →

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

The long-anticipated Borden murder trial began in New Bedford, with a jury quickly secured amid large crowds outside the courthouse. Lizzie Borden appeared in court dressed in black, and officials including Judge Mason and prosecutors Knowlton and Moody were present as proceedings commenced.

New-York Tribune · 6 June 1893 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

LIZZIE BORDEN ON TRIAL.

A SATISFACTORY JURY QUICKLY SECURED.

See moreSee less

THE PROSECUTION WILL OPEN ITS CASE THIS MORNING—CROWDS ABOUT THE COURT-HOUSE IN FALL RIVER.

New-Bedford, Mass., June 5.—The long-anticipated Borden murder trial has begun. At an early hour this morning every available shady spot on County-st. near the courthouse was pre-empted, and patiently the spectators waited until the bell on the courthouse was tolled, signifying the opening of court. Deputy sheriffs guarded the entrance at the front and New-Bedford policemen were at the rear. The talesmen began to file into their places at 10 o'clock, and at 11 o'clock all were there. At 10:58 Miss Lizzie A. Borden, the prisoner, came slowly into the room, preceded by Deputy Sheriff Kirby, and was shown to her seat in the dock. She was attired in a becoming costume of black brocaded stuff, and wore a pretty shade hat, relieved by a touch here and there of blue. As she passed the bar inclosure Melvin O. Adams, of counsel for defence, stepped to

MISS LIZZIE BORDEN.

the rail and bowed to her, but Lizzie, while acknowledging with a slight inclination of the head the salutation, never raised her eyes to his, and passed on slowly beyond to the dock. Every seat in the room was occupied by talesmen and newspaper men, no outsiders being admitted up to that time, and within the box inclosure were a few of the prominent men of the county. District-Attorney Knowlton and Mr. Moody, his assistant, were on hand.

The court came in at 11:27 o'clock. Chief Justice Mason taking the centre seat, with the Rev. M. C. Julien, of New-Bedford, who had been selected to make the regulation opening prayer, on his left. As soon as they were seated Deputy Sheriff Thomas W. Butman was instructed by Clerk Borden to make the usual proclamation to the talesmen, after which the clerk called them in alphabetical order. Seven minutes were thus taken up, after which a brief prayer was offered, Miss Borden standing. Then the District-Attorney conveyed officially to the court what has been well known for a week or so, that the Attorney-General will not be here to attend to his duty, and that William H. Moody, District-Attorney of Essex County, would act. He gave to the court the additional information in a very formal manner that Lizzie Andrew Borden had been indicted for the murder of her father and step-mother, and he had the honor to move for the impanelling of a jury for the trial of the cause. Chief Justice Mason addressed the talesmen as a body, stating that he should be obliged to put certain questions to them as they came before the court relative to forming opinions, their bias or prejudice, etc. He read a section of an opinion from the Chief Justice of the court of last resort bearing upon the matter of opinions, and he cautioned them that all of their answers must be given under oath. If any of them was so mentally constituted that he could not believe any person would commit a crime punishable with death, then that person would not do as a juror. The clerk was then directed to proceed with the impanelling of the jury. Miss Borden was asked to stand up and told of her right to challenge.

George Potter, of Westport, had formed an opinion but did not think it was sufficient to prevent being changed. He had no bias or prejudice, and was in a condition to find a verdict of guilt if the evidence warranted. There was no challenge and he was duly sworn and placed in the box at 11:54, being the first juror chosen.

William F. Dean, of Taunton, had no bias or prejudice, and his opinions would not preclude him from acting fairly to all parties. He was accepted and was sworn.

John Wilbur, Somerset, had formed an opinion, but was unbiassed and stood fair to all, and was declared indifferent. The Government, however, asked through the court whether he was a client of either of the counsel in the case, and he replied: "No." He was made the third man on the jury.

Frederick C. Wilbur, Raynham, had no prejudice and was capable of acting fairly by both parties in interest. He took the fourth seat on the jury.

Lemuel K. Wilbur, Easton, stood indifferent and was sworn.

William Wescott, Seekonk, stood indifferent, and was accepted.

Lewis B. Hodges, of Taunton, was indifferent, and was sworn in as the seventh member of the jury, there being no challenges.

Augustus Swift, New-Bedford, was accepted and sworn in as the eighth juror.

Frank E. Cole, of Attleboro, was indifferent, and was accepted, being sworn in as the ninth juror.

John C. Finn, Taunton, was accepted as the tenth juror.

Charles I. Richards, of North Attleboro, stood indifferent, and was accepted and sworn in as the eleventh juror.

Oliver E. Gifford, New-Bedford, said he was related to the prisoner at the bar, and was excused.

As he passed Lizzie Borden she looked at him in astonishment, and he smiled a cheerful "Keep your courage up" to her.

Allen H. Wardwell, of Dartmouth, stood indifferent, was not challenged, and was sworn as the twelfth juror at 4:45 o'clock.

The quickness with which the jury was impanelled was a surprise to everybody, even the counsel, and they were somewhat unprepared. In all not more than threescore talesmen were examined. The hour was so late that it was not known whether it was best to go on with the opening for the prosecution, or to defer the matter until morning, and a consultation took place in regard to the matter between Messrs. Knowlton, Moody, Robinson and Jennings. Meanwhile, the jury was formally made up, and the court then dismissed them for half an hour at the most, during which time they could make arrangements for their coming seclusion. Deputy Sheriff Butman was given a dozen sheets of paper and a dozen envelopes, one set for each juryman, and they were taken to the jury-room for the use of the men. It was decided that there should be no opening to-night, and the court was adjourned until to-morrow morning, at 9 o'clock. District-Attorney Knowlton is of the opinion that at least three weeks will be required now to finish up the trial. Charles I. Richards, of North Attleboro, was appointed foreman of the jury.

See the clipping

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

Lizzie Borden entered the courtroom calmly dressed in black brocade for the start of jury selection in her murder trial. The court proceeded with the formal impaneling process, questioning potential jurors like George Potter about bias or preformed opinions regarding the case.

New-York Tribune · 6 June 1893 · page 3

MISS LIZZIE RONRDEN. the rall and howed to her, but Lizzie, while acknowl. edging with a siight inclination of the head the salutation, never ralsed her eves to his, and passed on slowly beyond to the dock. Every seat In the room was occupied by talesmen and newspaper men, no ontsiders being admitted up to that time, and within the box Inclosure were a few of the prominent men of the econnty. DistrietAttorney Knowlton and Mr. Moody, his assistant, were on hand, The court came In at 11:27 o'clock. Chief Justice Mason taking the centre seat, with the Rev, M, (, Julien, of New Redford, who had been selected to make the regulation opening praver, on his left, As soon as they were seated Deputy Sheriff Thomas W.

See moreSee less

Butmygn was Instructed Ly Clerk Borden to make the

See the clipping

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

A jury to try Lizzie Borden was selected with surprising ease despite expectations of difficulty, given the case's high profile. Jurors will face strict seclusion during the three to four week trial.

New-York Tribune · 6 June 1893 · page 6

lation that was imperatively demanded— whether it shonld provide for a scientific dealing with the subject or for slap-bang Tammany methods. Mr. Daly appears to have accomplished some good. We can all be glad of that, without indorsing the Daly plan of campaign unequivocally. A fp — Contrary to the general expectation, a jury to try Lizzie Borden was obtained yesterday

See the clipping

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

This item collects excerpts from multiple newspapers (Springfield Union, Baltimore American, Boston Journal, Troy Times) expressing sympathy for Lizzie Borden and skepticism that she could have committed the murders without leaving trace evidence. Several cite the 'Manchester case' as proof that an outside intruder could commit such a murder and escape undetected.

New-York Tribune · 6 June 1893 · page 7

A REMARKABLE WOMAN ON TRIAL, From The Baltimore American, Lizzie Borden's trial will, doubtless, be a remarkable one. The evidence will be largely, if not wholly, circumstantial, and it remains to be seen how far it will go toward conviction, Miss Borden has shown | perself to be a remarkable woman, she will be more so If she does not break down during the ordecl of cross-examination,

See the clipping

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

Multiple newspapers comment on the forthcoming trial of Lizzie Borden, noting the case's circumstantial nature, public sympathy for her, and intense national interest. A recent similar unsolved murder in Manchester is cited as potentially bolstering the defense's argument that an outsider could have committed the Borden killings undetected.

New-York Tribune · 6 June 1893 · page 7

THE DEFENDANT GETS MUCH SYMPATHY

SIGNIFICANCE OF THE MANCHESTER CASE. From The Troy Times, That a man ean enter n house in broad daylight in a thickly settled neighborhood, commit a murder without being seen and successfully escape is con. founding the enemies of Lizzie Borden, who is accused on the ground that such a murder by an outsider as has been committed at Farmer Manchester's house wins Impossible. Miss Borden fs to be tried next week, and this new and remariable murder 15 expected to have an important bearing on the result,

See the clipping

The Morning News · Savannah, Ga.

The long-anticipated trial of Lizzie Borden began in New Bedford, Massachusetts, with crowds gathering outside the courthouse and Borden appearing in a black costume. The jury was quickly impaneled by late afternoon, but opening statements were postponed until the next morning, with the prosecutor estimating the trial would last three weeks.

The Morning News · 6 June 1893 · page 1

LIZZIE BORDEN ON TRIAL. The Court House Packed With Tales men and Newspaper Men. Now Bedford, Mass., June s.—Tho long anticipated Borden murder trial has be gun. At an early hour this morning every uvailablo shady spot in County street, near the court house, was pre empted and patiently tho sitters and stnnders waited until the boll on the court house tolled, signifying the opening of tho court. Precisely at 10:58 o’clock Miss Lizzie A. Borden, the prisoner, came slowly into tho court room and was shown

See the clipping

The Indianapolis Journal · Indianapolis, Ind.

The trial of Lizzie Borden for the murder of her father and stepmother began in New Bedford, with Chief Justice Mason presiding and a jury selected by day's end. The report recaps the background of the case, noting the victims Andrew J. Borden and his wife, and the murders that occurred ten months earlier.

The Indianapolis Journal · 6 June 1893 · page 2

LIZZIE BORDEN IN COURT On Trial for the Murder of Her Father and Step-Mother Last August

New Bedford, Mass.. June 6. The trial of Lizzie liordan, for the murder of her father and stepmother, began hereto-day. The court room was crowded.' Chief Justice Mason presided, and his associates were Justices iilodgett and Dewey. It was just 11 o'clock when a closed carriage drew up at the rear of the courthouse. A deputy eheriH stepped out of it and held out bis hand to assist Lizzie Borden. The crowd pressed forward ina sort of a frenzy to catch a glimpse of the woman, but she slipped quietly into the building before they weru uble to do bo aud walked quietly to her place in tho prisoner' a dock.

See moreSee less

The oourt having been duly opened, the task of securing a jury was betfun. tho prisoner, as is the law of Massachusetts, challenging in person whenever prompted by her couueel. At 4:4") k M. tho jury was completed and the court adjourned until to-morrow. The crime for which Jdiss Borden ,1s on

See the clipping

The Indianapolis Journal · Indianapolis, Ind.

This report reviews the Borden family history, including the ages and relationships of the victims and the rumored debts and poison theories. It also recounts the servant Bridget Sullivan's actions and Lizzie's statements on the morning of the murders.

The Indianapolis Journal · 6 June 1893 · page 2

LIZZIE BORDEN IN COURT

On the morning of the day of the murder Mr. Borden had been on his busi ness rounds and came back. Mrs. itorden was dressing to go out. Isridget Sullivan,

See the clipping

Rock Island Daily Argus · Rock Island, Ill.

A short news item reports that the trial of Lizzie Borden for the murder of her father and stepmother, which occurred in August 1892, has commenced at New Bedford, Massachusetts. The item is a single sentence buried among other unrelated news briefs.

Rock Island Daily Argus · 6 June 1893 · page 4

$500,000. The trial of Lizzie Borden for the mur der of her father and stepmother in August, 18'J2, has been begun at New Bed ford, Mass..

See the clipping

The Wichita Daily Eagle · Wichita, Kan.

Amid a roundup of news items including an Arkansas bank robbery, the paper notes in a single line that the trial of Lizzie Borden for the murder of her father and stepmother has commenced at New Bedford, Massachusetts. No further details of the trial proceedings are given in this excerpt.

The Wichita Daily Eagle · 6 June 1893 · page 2

!he Trial of Lizzie Borden for the Murder of Her Patber and Stepmother Com menced at New Bedford, Mass, The Nebraska Impeachments Thrown Out by the Su preme Court The Carnegie Oases, General Notes,

See the clipping

The Wichita Daily Eagle · Wichita, Kan.

The report covers the opening of Lizzie Borden's trial in the Massachusetts superior court, recapping the background of the August 1892 murders of her father and stepmother. It recounts Lizzie's own account of her movements that morning, while noting that a post-mortem photograph contradicts her claim about removing her father's boots.

The Wichita Daily Eagle · 6 June 1893 · page 2

THE BORDEN MUEDEB. Lizzie Borden on Trial for Xilling Her Patber nd Stepmother. New Bedford, Mass., June .".Today Lizzie Boiden took a seat in the pris

See the clipping

The Wichita Daily Eagle · Wichita, Kan.

The report reviews Lizzie Borden's account of the day of the murders, noting a photograph contradicts her claim that she removed her father's boots. It also describes the discovery of Mrs. Borden's body and states that the Borden murder trial began today with jury selection completed.

The Wichita Daily Eagle · 6 June 1893 · page 2

ing the servant, sent her at once for Dr. Bowen, who lived near by. Then she sat down on the outside steps, and was thus seen by a neighbor, Mrs. Churchill, who asked what the matter was. Bizzio told her of the murder, and Mrs. Churchill asked for Mrs. Borden. Lizzie knew noth ing of tho latter's whereabouts, but called to mind that her stepmother had told her of a note asking her to call on a friend that morning, and lemembered that her step mother had told her she was going to nay a call.

See moreSee less

However, Bridget was lequested to look for Mrs. Uoruen. She refused to eo alone and Mrs. Churchill went with her. The two women found the body of Mr. Borden on the fioor of the guest chamber, hc also had been murdered atter the sumo mnnneriia Mr. Borden, with several blows from a heavy sharp mstru meut, probably a hatchet or au ax. It wa: determined at the autopsy that Mrs Borden was killed some time before her husband. It appears to have been shown that there was no lite auout tne uouse an tue morning, but membeis of the family were seen at intervals-, rvouotiy was seen to enter the house: no instrument has been discovered which fits the case, but the government claims and will attempt to prove that Lizzie Boiden committed th crime. The court room was picked with people when the trial begau today. At 4:45 o'clock the jury was completed and the court adjourned until tomorrow morniug

See the clipping

The Evening Bulletin · Maysville, Ky.

The trial of Lizzie Borden for the murder of her father and mother began at New Bedford, with crowds gathering outside the courthouse. Jury selection was completed by late afternoon, and court adjourned before the prosecution's opening statement could be given.

The Evening Bulletin · 6 June 1893 · page 1

LIZZIE BORDEN'S TRIAL. Beginning of a Great Criminal Case at New Bedford, Mass.

a dollar and a; half for eyery dollar do pbsiteu, but the greater part 6f the money (iu tied, up in securities. He, does ed in her death, riOtKn02.how.lonfl:Jhft bankcaiLfiajid and American delegates will make com parisons of the .methods adopted in their various countries in the fight against the liquor traffic and from this general interchange of experiences it is believed that considerable good can be accomplished. LIZZIE BORDEN'S TRIAL. UoslnnlnjE of a Great Criminal Case

See the clipping

Daily Kennebec Journal · Augusta, Me.

The trial of Lizzie Borden for the murder of her father and stepmother opened in New Bedford, with the entire day devoted to jury selection. The twelve-man jury was sworn in by 4:45 PM, and court adjourned until the next morning, with plans for the jury to visit the Borden homestead in Fall River.

Daily Kennebec Journal · 6 June 1893 · page 1

Taunton: Augustus Swift . New Bedford Frank G. Cole. Attleboro: John <’. Finn. Taunton; Allen H. WardelL Dart mouth. The last juror was sworn: at 4.45 P. M. The quickness with' which the jury was impanm lied was a sur prise to every one. The jury was formally matte up and dismissed for half an hour during which the counsel consulted regard ing an adjournment. It was finally de cided not to open the case tonight ami court adjourned until 0 A. M. tomorrow. Tomorrow, immediately after the district attorney makes the opening for the prosecu tion, the court will adjourn in order that the jury can visit Fall River and view the Borden homestead.

See moreSee less

A special car will be chartered for the train which leaves here at 12 55. A plan of the house, drawn by the < ity engineer of Fall River, will be submitted In'fore the ad journment. and he taken along by those m charge. Counsel for the prosecution and defense will he in the party.

See the clipping

Daily Kennebec Journal · Augusta, Me.

Jose Correiro, the Portuguese suspect in the Manchester murder, was arraigned and pleaded not guilty, with his case continued to June 15th. The continuance was granted because many witnesses were attending the Borden trial in New Bedford.

Daily Kennebec Journal · 6 June 1893 · page 1

And Held W tkout Bail—Pleaded Not Guilty Searching lor Clues. F\u. Ki\ f.r. Mas*.. June 5 —lose Cor n-in*. the Portuguese under arrest for th<* Manchester murder, was arraigned this morning and held without bail until June 15th. He pleaded not guilty, and nrnnonc*d himself ready for trial. The government a*ked for a continuance,a* many important witne«*e* were in New Bedford attending the Borden trial. Judge McDonough coti linued the case to the 15th. Manuel Sou c* i. principal witness for the government, wa* he 11 in 920OO bonds. This morni' g officer* searching in the vi cinitv of Corriefo’s boardine hou*e in Ro* enviPe, found the old pair of shoes »nui by him Memorial day.

See moreSee less

They were lying in a gravel pit near the railroad track, a con st lerablc distance fr< m the house. Jo«eph Lacroix, a sbn-3 deaI*»T. identified the shoes. The officer* state that the shoe* h *d evidently b»en soaked in water, but w «11 not *ay that there is blood on the sh )es.

See the clipping

Daily Kennebec Journal · Augusta, Me.

The long-anticipated Borden murder trial opened in New Bedford, with crowds gathering outside the courthouse and Lizzie Borden entering court in a black brocaded dress. Jury selection began, with the district attorney moving to impanel a jury and Chief Justice Mason questioning potential jurors about bias.

Daily Kennebec Journal · 6 June 1893 · page 1

Commenced at New oedlord -Five Jurors Se cured Before Adjournment. Nkw Ukofoki*, Mass.. .June 5.—The ! Inng-antieipattd Borden murder trial lias begun. At Mil early hour this morning ev ery available shady spot on County street near the court house » »s pre-empted by people awaiting the sound of the court house b«d| which would mark the opening of the great trial. Deputy sheriffs guarded the entrance to the front and New Bedford policemen the rear. The talesmen began to file into their places at 10 o'clock, and by 11 all bad ar rived. At precisely ill.5#, IJzzie Borden, the prisoner came slow|v into the room, pre

See the clipping

The Portland Daily Press · Portland, Me.

The report describes the opening day of the Lizzie Borden trial in New Bedford, where a jury was selected from 150 talesmen in just one day. It also details the crowds gathered outside the courthouse and Lizzie Borden's calm demeanor as she arrived dressed in black.

The Portland Daily Press · 6 June 1893 · page 1

WILL DECIDE HER FATE.

Lizzie was the object watched for, and there was no disappointment. The court house was encircled with an ever-grow ing crowd, among which the ladies held the majority. The sidewalk on Court street was choked with curious gazers, waiting patiently in the hot sun for a glimpse of the girl whose trial is attract ing the interest of the world, and is equalled only by that of Mrs. Maybrick, in London. Lizzie Borden arrived at 11 o’clock promptly, driving up in a close, handsome, single carriage with colored driver. Sheriff Wright accompanied her.

See moreSee less

Alloc Rnvrlfin TTTO C o-tfiv/vrl in rt black hernani dress, aqd wore a black spring hat of lace. There were no flow ers nor any attempt at external display. She seemed perfectly cool and deliberate Her face wore the hue of health. The girl was kindly assisted to alight by Sheriff Wright and Deputy Sheriff Kirby. A hush fell over the lounging crowd as the girl passed up the rear steps of the court house. A slight wave of color passed over her face. She pro ceeded quickly with her escort to the court room. Lizzie took her seat within the dock at the extreme right, Deputy Sheriff Kirby, her guardian, taking his place beside her. Within the bar Was her friend and

See the clipping

The Portland Daily Press · Portland, Me.

The report describes the scene as Lizzie Borden arrives at the New Bedford courthouse for the opening of her trial, detailing her composed demeanor and the arrangement of courtroom figures including judges, attorneys, clergy, and the court stenographer. It notes procedural formalities such as the crier's summons and the empaneling of the jury pool before District Attorney Knowlton begins addressing the court.

The Portland Daily Press · 6 June 1893 · page 1

TO BE A FAMOUS TRIAL.

front of them were Mrs. Holmes of Fall River, and chatting with him Judge Ed mund H. Bennett of the Boston Univer sity Law School. District Attorney W. H. Moody^of Essex, who will open for the prosecution was the first of the counsel to appear at 10.50. Following him came Col. Melvin O. Adams, his pleasant smile winning for him a cordial reception. Mr. Jen nings accompanied him. His manner betokened perfect confidence. Marshal Hilliard, clean-shaven and in a light spring suit, sat on the left in front, and with him was Mr.

See moreSee less

Simeon Borden, Jr., of Fall River, a distant connection of the prisoner. Miss Annie M. White, the court steno grapher, in whose hads may be so large a share of Lizzie’s fate, sat just in front of the dock rail. She wore a becoming suit of brown, with contrasting shades of cream. It is Miss White, who is to testify to the star chamber inquest re port on which District Attorney Knowl ton so strongly relies for Lizzie Borden’s undoing. Ex-Governor Robinson came in at 11.20 and walking over to the dock greeted Lizzie with his kind smile and shook her hand. They had a moment’s whispered conference. Then Hon. Chas. J.

See the clipping

The Portland Daily Press · Portland, Me.

The Superior Court trial of Lizzie Borden for the murders of her father Andrew Jackson Borden and stepmother Abby Durfee Borden formally began, with Chief Justice Mason addressing the venire on their responsibilities and the standards for impartiality. Jury selection proceeded with several candidates examined and either challenged, excused, or sworn in, including Ansel G. Baker, George Winslow, and George Potter.

The Portland Daily Press · 6 June 1893 · page 1

and walking over to the dock greeted Lizzie with his kind smile and shook her hand. They had a moment’s whispered conference. Then Hon. Chas. J. Holmes arose and came over to the dock. District Attorney Knowlton was all ready to proceed at 11.26, and the Court came in, Justice Mason gravely leading the way. The crier made the old-time proclamation with his thrice repeated Hear ye. Then the jury list was called. The crier summoned them with his quaint call: “Hear ye! Hear ye! Hear ye! good and lawful men, sum moned by venire to attend at this session of the Superior Court, appear and an swer to your names as they be called.” The responses received indicated that the 150 jurors,occupied all the rear seats.

See moreSee less

Joseph W. Hathaway was the first absen tee from the venire roll noted. Clerk Simeon B. Borden occupied the desk in front of Judge Mason. Rev. M. C. Julian of Trinitarian church, New Bedford, as the clerk’s voice ceased, offered an appeal, that jus tice be done, innocence revealed and guilt exposed at this sitting of the court.; As all were again seated District At torney Knowlton explained to the court that the Attorney General was unavoid ably absent because of his recent ill health, and that his physician had de cided, and as the attorney felt wisely, that it was best that the Attorney Gener al should not appear, at his suggestion he had invited Mr. Win. H. Moody of Haverhill, District Attorney for the east ern district, to assist him. Lizzie An drew Borden was now at the bar for trial upon an indictment in two counts charg ing her with the murder of Andrew Jack son Borden and Abby Durfec Borden, his wife, respectively.

See the clipping

St. Paul Daily Globe · Saint Paul, Minn.

The report describes the start of the long-anticipated Borden murder trial in New Bedford, Massachusetts, with Lizzie Borden brought into court and jury selection beginning. By the end of the day, the jury was completed after a recess, and the court adjourned until morning.

St. Paul Daily Globe · 6 June 1893 · page 3

Charged With Murder. New Bedfokd. Mass., Juns s.— The long-anticipated Borden murder trial has begun. At au early hour this morning every available shady spot on County street near the court house was pre empted, and patiently the sitters and slanders waited until the bell on the court house was tolled, signifying the opening of court. At precisely 10:53 Miss Lizzie A. Bordeu, the prisoner, was slowly into the court room and was shown to her seat In the dock. Every seat in the room was occupied by tales men and newspaper men, no out siders being admitted up to that time. Court opened at 11:25. Chief Justice Mason presided.

See the clipping

The Helena Independent · Helena, Mont.

The report announces that Lizzie Borden's trial for the murders of her father Andrew and stepmother Abby Borden has begun in New Bedford. It recaps the circumstantial case, including the household's occupants that morning, the discovery of the bodies, and her later arrest.

The Helena Independent · 6 June 1893 · page 1

LIZZIE BORDEN'S TRIAL. Begun at Fall River, Mas.-The Terrible Crime. NzW BEDFORD. Mass., June .--The trial of Lizzie Borden, of Fall River, charged with murdering her father, Andrap Jack son Borden, and her stepmother. Abby Dur fee i.orden, an aged and highly respected couple, on the morning of Aug. 4, 1892, began here this mornina. The most emi nent criminal lawyers in the state were em ployed and the trial promises to be moat interesting and probably sensational. The evidence is purely circumstantial, On the day in question, as far as known, the only persons in the house of the old counle were Lizzie and a maid-servant, Bridget Sullivan.

See moreSee less

who was outsi ie most of the morning, washing windows. Borden was out in the morning, returning be tween 10 and 11 o'clock, and it was only a short time afterwards that Lizzie, after a short visit to the bhrn, called the servant to run for a doctor, as her father had been murdered. Shortly afterward Mrs. Borden was missed and a search re vealed her body in the upper room, she having evidently been killed some time be fore her husband. In both oases death re suited from blows from some heavy sharp instrument, probably an axe, but the in strument of death has never been die covered. Certain discrepancy in Lizzie's stories and some other suspioious circumstanoes led to her arrest some weeks after the mur der, and subsequent indictment.

See the clipping

The Jersey City News · Jersey City, N.J.

The trial of Lizzie Borden for the murder of her father and stepmother began in New Bedford, with the courtroom packed and the jury and counsel in place. District Attorney Moody began his opening address after the indictment was read, during which Borden showed brief signs of emotion before returning to her composed demeanor.

The Jersey City News · 6 June 1893 · page 1

QUICKLY RECOVERS HER COMPOSURE

New Bedford, Mass., Mass., June 6 1S93—After well-nigh a year of anticipa tion, theorizing and speculation, the trial of Miss Lizzie Borden, charged with hav ing hacked the life out of her father and stepmother, was begun in earnest this morning. Every seat in the court room h ad been taken by nine o’clock, the hour set for opening the trial proper. The Jury, which had been iu the custody of two deputy sheriffs through the night under lock and key in one of the hotels here, was in its place.

See moreSee less

So were |all the connsel on both sides. The bell on the court rung out prompt ly at nine o’clock this morning, announc ing to all who cared to hear that the court was In session. Just before the crowd had been permitted to come in. In it were just nineteen women. No time was wasted iu preliminaries. When the crier h d opened the court Clerk Borden read the formal indictment, charging Miss Borden with the brutal murder of her parents. During the reading of the indictment Miss Borden, who had been brought in just before tne Justices ascended to their places, showed some signs of emotion. Twice ner lips twitched nervously, and once there was the shee^ot tears in her eyes. But it passed away la an instant, and again there was presented the pic ture or the coarse-featured stoical wo man, apparently Indifferent to her sur roundings. Sne might have been the least interested of auy of the spectators, so far as outward manifestations were concerned, during the greater portion of the time. V. MR. MOODY’S OPENING ADDRESS.

See the clipping

The Jersey City News · Jersey City, N.J.

At Lizzie Borden's trial, District Attorney Moody delivers his opening statement, describing her attempt to buy prussic acid the day before the murders and a suspicious conversation with Alice Russell the night before. He outlines the prosecution's theory involving family discord and strange explanations for the household's illness.

The Jersey City News · 6 June 1893 · page 1

the time. V. MR. MOODY’S OPENING ADDRESS. The cgud't room was completely hushed A aaiafnnr ntatHpf. AttnPMl-V W. H. Moody stepped over betore the jury and begau liis^krese, lu which there might be somej^Ki of sensations to follow. So ail ii^^Hm were on the qui vive, Mr. his opening with a brief s!I^Hnoe Borden family. He called atSntlou to the fact that Miss Lizzie Borden and her step-mother quar relled Decause of an act of her father’s, which was of beueflt to a relative of the second Mrs. Borden.

See the clipping

The Jersey City News · Jersey City, N.J.

Assistant District Attorney Moody describes the Borden house layout and the morning of the murders in his opening statement, noting the jury would later visit the scene. He highlights alleged discrepancies in Lizzie Borden's statements about her mother's whereabouts after Mrs. Borden was already dead.

The Jersey City News · 6 June 1893 · page 1

them Immediately after that. He described how Bridget Sullivan, the servant, had washed the windows. “Dur ing all the time she was doing that,” ha said, “she didn’t see Mrs. Borden or Lizzie.” Then she went down stairs and began to wash the windows on. the south side of the house. “While engagedthns she hoard Mr. Borden at the screen door. He went around the house and let himself iu at the front door. It was 10:40 o’clock when Mr. Borden started to reach his home. Ha was away from his home at the time, a distance wuloh he could have covered in a minute.

See moreSee less

As was not the custom iu that house, the door was locked and Doited. He made the noise a person would expecting to get in wuh a latch key. LIZZIE BORDER’S ALLEGED LIE.

See the clipping

Daily Independent · Elko, Nev.

The report states that Lizzie Borden's trial for the murder of her father and stepmother began in New Bedford. It notes the killings occurred on the morning of August 4, 1892, in Fall River, Massachusetts.

Daily Independent · 6 June 1893 · page 3

The trial of Lizzie Borden, of Fall River, Maw., on the obarge of mur ?daring her father and step mother<on the morniug of August 4,1892, began at New Bedford yesterday morning. At the close of a long prayer by a father who had prayed for a poor family, his son Said: ** Father, if I had as muoh wheat ta the bare ?a you have, t would answer that prayer inyself!" , Hugh Ross, the prosecuting wit- ,

See the clipping

Paper unidentified

The report announces that Lizzie Borden's trial for the murder of her father and stepmother began in New Bedford, Massachusetts. It recaps the circumstantial case, including the discovery of the bodies and the discrepancies in Lizzie's account that led to her arrest.

Paper unidentified · 6 June 1893 · page 1

LIZZIE BORDEN'S TRIAL A Sensational Murder Case Commenced Yesterday.

Last August. New Bedford, Mass., June 5. The trial of Lizzie Borden of Fall River, charged with murdering her father, An drew Jackson Borden, and her step mother, Abb'y Durfee Borden, an aged, wealthy and highly respected couple, on the morning of August 4th, 1833, began here this morning. The most eminent criminal lawyers of the state are em ployed, and the trial promises to be most interesting and probably sensa tional. The evidence is purely circum stantial. On the day in question, as far as is known, the only persons in the house were the old couple, Lizzie and a maid servant, Bridget Sullivan, who was outside most of the morning wash ing windows.

See moreSee less

Borden was out in the morning, returning between 10 and 11 o'clock, and it was only a short time afterward that Lizzie, after a short visit to the barn, called to the servant to run for the doctor as her father had been murdered. Shortly afterward Mrs. Borden was missed, and a search re vealed her body in an upper room, she having evidently been killed some time before her husband. In both cases death resulted from blows from some heavy, sharp instrument, probably an ax, but the instrument of death has never been discovered. A certain dis crepancy in Lizzie's stories and some other suspicious circumstances led to her arrest some weeks afterward and subsequent indictment.

See the clipping

The Daily Morning Astorian · Astoria, Oregon

The trial of Lizzie Borden of Fall River began in New Bedford on June 5, charging her with murdering her father Andrew Jackson Borden and stepmother Abby Durfee Borden. The elderly, wealthy couple had been killed on the morning of August 4, 1892.

The Daily Morning Astorian · 6 June 1893 · page 1

LIZZIE BORDEN ON TRIAL. " New Bedford, Mass., June G. Tfia trial of Lizzie Borden of Fall River, charged with murdering her father, Andrew Jackson Borden; and her Btep-mother, Abby Dufee Borden, a an aged wealthy aJid hlglily leKpected couple on the morning of Aug. 4, 1802, was begun herd this morning. I .

See the clipping

The Evening Herald · Shenandoah, Pa.

The trial of Lizzie Borden began with jury selection, and by the second day eleven of twelve jurymen had been secured. The report notes intense public interest in the proceedings and describes the trial opening with a prayer.

The Evening Herald · 6 June 1893 · page 2

ELEVEN MEN ALREADY IN THE DOX lntons Interest flliotrn In tho Proceed In it Tho lawyers Who Aro Comltict liiK thn Ohio Tho Trial Ili'Kiin Willi n Prayer TliaJ Aocusuil Woman lletnrr tli liar. New Hkdpomj, Mass., June 0. The long delayod trlnl ot Lizzie Borden which begun yesterday with the securing of a Jury Is be ing cootlnued this morning with au at tempt to secure the twelfth Juror.

See the clipping

The Evening Herald · Shenandoah, Pa.

Talesmen filed in and were checked off as Lizzie Borden entered the courtroom dressed in black brocaded fabric and a hat trimmed with blue. The report describes courtroom procedure for jury selection, noting Chief Justice Mason's estimate that empaneling a jury would take two to three days.

The Evening Herald · 6 June 1893 · page 2

At precisely 10.68 Miss Lizzie A. Borden, the prisoner, came slowly Into the room, preceded by Deputy Sheriff Klrby, and was shown to her seat In the dock

See the clipping

The Evening Herald · Shenandoah, Pa.

The trial opens with procedural discussion of jury selection methods, as Chief Justice Mason explains the process for questioning jurors. The passage also profiles Lizzie Borden's defense attorneys and notes her recent illness before describing the court's formal opening at 11:27.

The Evening Herald · 6 June 1893 · page 2

weeks. Miss Borden is still far from strong. Two weeks ago she had a severe attack of the grip, and was threatened with pneu monia She practically got up from a sick bed to come and stand trial for her life.

See the clipping

Pawtucket Tribune · Pawtucket, R.I.

A jury of twelve men has been chosen for Lizzie Borden's trial in New Bedford, Massachusetts. The report describes the courtroom layout and reflects on whether Borden, raised in a strict Puritan household, could be guilty or innocent of the murders.

Pawtucket Tribune · 6 June 1893 · page 1

DRAWING OF JURORS

Her Calm Demeanor. NEW BEDFORD, Mass,, June 6.—The fight for Lizzie Borden’s life is on. The 12 men who hold her fate in their keeping have been chosen. She has looked on thei faces, one by one, and they have looked on bers. *Juror, look upon the prisoner; prisoner, look upon the juror!” If Lizzie Borden is guilty she is th greatest psychological phenomenon of th day; born and bred in a strict,cold Puritan atmosphere, self-poised, virtuons, intelli gent, lacking quick impulse and ardent temperament, her conscience formed in the mould of the Sunday school and Christian Endcavor society for 30 years, until one day the Intent demon in her as serted itself in the mad, motiveless carnage of that Augnst morning.

See moreSee less

It Lizzie Boiden is innocent, she has borne hertelf with heroism and vindieated the sort of hard, staunch Puritan material she is made of. The Conrtroom _is a small, white-walled room, with the judge’s bench, over which were two bunches of pink and red carnations in glass receptables, under an arch in the ¢ iling, flanked with double wooden Corinthian pillars set into the wall, At either s'de of the judge’s bench are two doors, and ahove two chandeliers,

See the clipping

Pawtucket Tribune · Pawtucket, R.I.

This report describes the courtroom setting and Lizzie Borden's demeanor as her trial begins, noting her calm, composed appearance. It also details the start of jury selection, describing the vetting and swearing-in process of potential jurors.

Pawtucket Tribune · 6 June 1893 · page 1

A. J. JENNINGS, In front of the bench sit the counsel, for which two green-covered tables are pro vided. Behind them are the members of the bar. Next comes the dock, one por tion of which is divided off for the New York press, and at the left of the room is the jury box and the five shelves, with seating for 25 of the Boston and local re porters and artists, Lizzie Borden Is Calm, The newspuper men who saw Lizzie Borden last year remarked how much plumper and more prepossessing she ap peared than nine months ago.

See moreSee less

Certainly she looked in excellent health, and like auy one of a hundred well-dressed women one might weet on the street, She came forward looking straight ahead with a little air of determination, followed by a deputy sheriff, and both took scats in the dock: broad, cane-seated armchairs being provided, Miss Borden seated herself guietly, still looking straight ahead. She stood the

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

At the New Bedford trial, DA Moody delivers the prosecution's opening statement, detailing Andrew Borden's life, his second marriage, and tensions within the disunited family. Lizzie Borden sits alone in court, showing no reaction as she is formally indicted for the murders.

The Providence News · 6 June 1893 · page 1

MR. MOODY'S OPENING.

The Opening for the Government. He first detailed the position of Mr, Borden, his wealth and his early life. His marriage with his second wife, cc curred :lmost tweanty-eight years ago, He described the quiet taswes and habits

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

Prosecutor Moody tells the jury that Lizzie Borden attempted to buy prussic acid before the murders, and describes in detail the layout of the Borden house, including the locked doors between bedrooms. He also establishes the household's security routine on the night before the murders.

The Providence News · 6 June 1893 · page 1

JUDGE BLODGKETT. the north side of the house is the sitting room and from it open two doors, one to the hallway and another to the dining room. In this room Mr. Bor len's body was found, Upstairs over this room is Lizzie's room. In front of it is the spare room where Mrs, Borden was found. Between the two rooms is a dcor which is always kept locked and bolted on either side. The description of the chamber fol lowed, Mr. Borden's room was over the kitchen and had a little rcom opening out of it, Bridge 's rcom is on the third story, 00 Wednesday night Lizzie was the last person in the house by the froat door.

See moreSee less

That dcor countains three fastenings, the lock, the spring lock and tie balt. The prisoner fastened all these when she entered, The back door had already been closed. It is safe, therefore, to ray Npws.

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

The district attorney reconstructs the morning of the murders, describing the household's movements, the locked doors, and Mrs. Borden's death in the guest room before Mr. Borden returned home. He emphasizes Lizzie's presence and behavior throughout, including her laugh from the upstairs hallway after Bridget struggled to open the locked front door.

The Providence News · 6 June 1893 · page 1

The Last Seen of Mrs. Borden Alive. That was the last seen of Mrs. Borden. She never left that room alive and was undoubtedly killed within a few minutes of the time when she entered it, I say she never left that room alive, because no living person saw her else where afterwards. Here the district at torvey looked directly at Lizzie Borden, pausing impressively fora moment. He vhen continued, Meanwhile Bridget was preparing to wash the windows. Snhe had gone out of the back door and Lizale appeared at that door.

See moreSee less

. Bridget said to her: “You need not lock the door as I sball be bhere all the time; but you may if you wish, as I can got my water from the barn.”’ She got the water, as was afterwards shown, dnd I think we can prove that the door was not locked by Lizzie, Now Mr. Borden went down town and the time he was there was fixed by Mr. Clegg, who keeps a paper store, at 10:29 o’clock. Soon after he returned and tried to eunter the front door, but found it locked.

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

During the murder trial, prosecutor Moody delivered a dramatic closing appeal to the jury about blood evidence on the hatchet, after which defense attorney Jennings approached Lizzie Borden with a box of evidence. She failed to respond to her name and then suddenly fainted, prompting reporters to speculate whether this was nervous collapse, guilt, or the strain of the proceedings.

The Providence News · 6 June 1893 · page 2

~ prisoner and called her by name. *“‘Miss - Borden.” The fan remained unmoved. ':, L/ zzie showed no sigu of recoguition. ; “Miss Borden.” ~_ Btill no sign. Mr. Jennings laid the ~ box down and walked away. 7‘_ Suddenly the fan fell from her hand ~ without a momeunt’s warning, her head fell tack against the railing. :

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

On the opening day of her trial, Lizzie Borden nearly collapsed in court but recovered her composure after a brief moment of distress. The first witness, Thomas Kieran, testified about distances and sightlines around the Borden house, after which the jury was sent to view the premises in Fall River.

The Providence News · 6 June 1893 · page 2

First Witness Called. “Thomas Kieran,” said Mr. Moody. He came to the stand and describel the various distances from the Borden house to the police station and to the store of Clegg. He showed a plan of the Borden house and its immediate sur roundings, a plan of the house up stairs and down, During the examination of the plans ex-(ov, Robinson walked mnervously around, made trequent notes. When Mr. Jenning bezan to cross examine the witness the ract was biough t out that a person standing on Second wtreet and tooking from the eorner of the Kelley house diagonally ncross the lots, twelve Inches of the barn door in the Borden yard could be seen, * Jury Goes to Fall River, This was the last evidence of the day and under the direction of the court the jury were sent to Fall River 1o view the Berden house.

See moreSee less

The court stated that Miss Borden was entitled to go with the jury if she wished. After covsultation with her counsel, ex-Governor Robinson stated she di{ not feel well enough to undertake the journey, Mr. Jennings aud Mr, Moody were de!- egated to accompany the jury and the court adjourned until 9 a. ~ tomorrow,

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

The report describes the swift start of the Borden trial, noting quick jury selection and the prosecution's apparently limited new evidence. It also mentions a dramatic moment when Lizzie Borden fainted in court, while public opinion increasingly leans toward acquittal.

The Providence News · 6 June 1893 · page 4

THE BORDEN TRIAL. The trial of Lizzie Borden at New Bedford has certainly opened with the promise that it may not be stretched out to the disgraceful length that many of the murder trials that have attracted the attention of the country of late have been. The prompiness with which the jury was secured, and the other sigus of vigor that were made apparent yester duy, are hopeful. [The fact, if it proves to be 4 tact, that the prosecution has but little evidence that the public does not already know of to introduce also assures a speedy trial, The proceedings opened today with a dramatic Incident that may assure the world that Lizzie Borden is actually like other women, She fainted in court.

See moreSee less

There is of course no hint of the probable result of the trial, though tie impression that the accused woman cannot be convicted grows more firm in the public mind, The jury geems to be made up of men who will be naturally disposed to give would be infl-xible if the evidence warrants a conv ction, The interest in the trial is widespread —almost universnl—and nothing in the line of news has been so eagerly sought for since the Graves trial at Denver, and in many particulars this exceeds that,

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

The item notes sensational reports comparing the Bertha Manchester murder in Fall River to the Borden case, claiming the axe wounds were identical in style. It wryly observes that no one has suggested Lizzie Borden escaped her cell to commit this new crime, since the perpetrator in both cases seems agreed not to be her.

The Providence News · 6 June 1893 · page 4

ALTHOUGH BENBATIONAL REPORTS are furnished us of the late tragedy in which Bertha Manchester lost her life at Fall River and much is said to show that the blows that preduced death and the use of the axe were identical with those in the Borden murder, we are glad to notice that no correspondent has as yet suggested that Lizzie Borden escaped from her cell and committed the crime. If the hand that struck the blows in the different cases was the same it seems to be conceded that the hand was not Miss Borden's, THE SENATE COMMITTEE on {mmigra tion seems to be digging to some purpose

See the clipping

The Madison Daily Leader · Madison, S.D.

The report from New Bedford, Massachusetts states that jury selection has begun in the trial of Lizzie Borden, accused of murdering her father and stepmother. It notes the case has already attracted significant attention and that top legal talent is involved.

The Madison Daily Leader · 6 June 1893 · page 3

tion. i.iziic Borden on t^irial. NEW BEDFORD, Mass., June 6.—The work of selecting a jury in the case of the state against Lizzie Borden for the

See the clipping

San Antonio Daily Light · San Antonio, Tex.

This roundup of miscellaneous news items from around the world includes a brief line noting that the jury has been impaneled in the Lizzie Borden murder case. The rest of the passage covers unrelated events such as disasters, financial news, and political developments.

San Antonio Daily Light · 6 June 1893 · page 3

The jury has been impanneled in the Lizzie Borden murder case. Dynamite explosion at Lais, F rance, and dynamiter arrested. The region round about Yoakum

See the clipping

The Salt Lake Herald · Salt Lake City, Utah

The report describes the start of Lizzie Borden's trial in New Bedford for the murder of her father and stepmother, calling it one of New England's most sensational cases in decades. It recaps the circumstantial evidence, the household's movements on the day of the killings, and the discovery of the bodies.

The Salt Lake Herald · 6 June 1893 · page 1

4S S a day when Lizzie Borden was arraigned arraiged for the murder of her father and step mother The case is full of mysteries and J the public has been made thoroughly fa miliar with all the details of the terrible tragedy The story of the life of the rich mill owner Borden mil second mar of his

See the clipping

The Salt Lake Herald · Salt Lake City, Utah

The report details the career of Chief Justice Mason, who will preside over Lizzie Borden's trial, along with logistics such as press seating, jury selection, and defense/prosecution counsel. It also describes the courthouse and jail where Borden will be held during proceedings.

The Salt Lake Herald · 6 June 1893 · page 1

duties of his higher office Accommodations for fifty newspaper men have been prepared and an extra venire of jurymen has been drawn by the clerk of the court whose name singu larly enough is Simeon Borden jr He is in no way related to the defendant ExGovern George D Robinson who will act as senior counsel for Lizzie Bor den comes from Chicopee Melvin O Adams from Boston Mr Jennings from Fall River Attorney General Pillsbury has charge of the prosecution The gloomy old court house where Liz zie Borden is to be put on trial for her lifo is situated a little west from the center of the city fronting on Court street one of the principal residence streets and sur rounded by magnificent elm trees Run ning alongside on the north Is Court street on which but a square or two dis tant is the jail where Miss Borden will be confined during her trial

See the clipping

Richmond Dispatch · Richmond, Va.

The jury for Lizzie Borden's murder trial was unexpectedly and quickly empaneled by late afternoon, surprising even the attorneys, leading the court to adjourn opening statements until the next morning. Charles I. Richards of North Attleboro was named jury foreman, and the prosecution estimated the trial would take at least three weeks.

Richmond Dispatch · 6 June 1893 · page 5

MISS BORDEN'S TRIAL A JURY OBTAINED WITH UNEXPECTED QUICKNESS

anticipated Borden murder trial was be. gun at as early hour this morning. Every available shady spot on County street near aN WATE WT MNES wo --. ns bedi dnd dads Ne patiently the sitters and standers waited until the bell on the conrt-honse tollad, signifying the opening of court, At precisely 10:55 Miss Lizzie Borden, the prisoner, came slowly into the court room and was shown to her seat in the dock. She was attired 1n a very be. commng costume of black broeaded stuff and wore a pretty shade hat, relieved by a toucu here and there of blue, Every eat in the room was occupied by

See the clipping

Richmond Dispatch · Richmond, Va.

The report describes the rapid empanelling of the jury for the Lizzie Borden murder trial, noting the foreman's name and the judge's decision to postpone opening statements until the next day. It also recaps the background of the double murder of Andrew and Abby Borden on August 4, 1892, based on Bridget Sullivan's earlier testimony.

Richmond Dispatch · 6 June 1893 · page 5

STORY OF THE CRIME, Mr. Borden and his wife were murdaraed on the morning of August 4, 15802, in their honse, No. 2 Second street, Fall River. The crime was ‘ommittad, it ig supposed, betwean hail-past 10 | and a quarter-past 11 o'clock. There were that morning in the houde, which i8 in the heart of the city, five parsons--Mr. Borden and his wife, Lizzie sorden, the servant, Bridget sullivan, ana John V. Morse, Lizzie's uncle.

See the clipping

Richmond Dispatch · Richmond, Va.

Bridget Sullivan testifies about the timeline of events on the morning of the murders, detailing Mr. Borden's return home, Lizzie's movements, and the discovery of Mrs. Borden's body. She describes being sent for Dr. Bowen and Mrs. Russell after Lizzie alerted her that something had happened to her father.

Richmond Dispatch · 6 June 1893 · page 5

| BRIDGET SULLIVAN'S TESTIMONY. | She gatd that a fow minutes before Mr. Dor den's arrival sue iooked at the clock to sos if 1t was time to begin to prepare dinner. Very posi tively Bridget declared it was twenty ininutes after 10 when she looked at the cock. Mr. Borden was at the front door a few minutes after that. Ine front door waa kept locked because the Borden house had been ransacked in broad day light within a year. Bridget, when sho heard Mr. Borden #t the front door, went down and let Chim on.

See moreSee less

She eslculated that was about ten min utes after she looked at tho clock, | Mr Borden, according to Bridget's story, was in the honse at hali-past 10. He went to the dining-room, sat down, and 100k n key anil went uy-stairs by the back way. Hereturnedina few minutes, placed the key on the ghelf, and sat down in the sitting-room. Bridget says sho re mained down-gstairs until five minutes to 11 o'clock When she went ap-stairs to lis dowe. = iiridzot saw Lizzie Borden pass through the sitting-room into the dining-room, carrying an troning-board stew minutes atter Mr. Borden wont into the sitting-room. Bridget declares that all this time she did not know where Mrs, Borden was. Lizzie had toll her Mre. Borden had gone ont or was preparihia to go oui. The servant says she nad been lying down only ten or fifteen minutes when Lizzie called hor Lizzio's voles told her that gomething had hap pened, She sprang {ron the bed snd hurried down-stairs, she saye sho found Lizzie leaning with hor back against tho back-door. JAzzie, ac. cording to Bridget, seid her father was dead. There 18 considerable dispute as to whether Hrideat meant that lizz @ had said ber father wns hurt and not dead. Lizzie hurried Bridget after Dr. Bowen, who lives diagonally across the street. Dr. Bowen was away {rom home, and when the frighten garvant came back Lizzia sent her after Mrs, Russell, who lives on Bordea street. When

See the clipping

The Roanoke Times · Roanoke, Va.

The long-anticipated trial of Lizzie Borden opened in New Bedford, with the defendant arriving in court dressed in black brocaded stuff and a shaded hat. The jury was empanelled quickly by 4:45 p.m., surprising counsel, and court adjourned without opening statements until the next morning.

The Roanoke Times · 6 June 1893 · page 1

1.I//1K HOKUKN'S TRIAL. The Fall River Murder Mystery at Last In Court. Nkw Bkdford, Mass., Juno 5.?The long anticipated trial of Lizzie Borden has begun. At an early hour this morn?

See the clipping

Alexandria Gazette · Alexandria, D.C.

The report states that Lizzie Borden's trial for the murder of her father and stepmother began at New Bedford, with the indictments read to the jury. Prosecutor Mr. Moody then opened the government's case.

Alexandria Gazette · 6 June 1893 · page 2

The trial of Lizzie Borden for the murder of her father and step mother was commenced at New Bedford this morning. The jury heard the indict? ments against Miss Borden read as soon as court was formally opened, and Mr. Moody then stepped to the railing and opened the government's case.

See the clipping

The Times · Richmond, Va.

A short item from New Bedford, Mass., reports that the long-anticipated Borden murder trial has begun. No further details are given in this fragment.

The Times · 6 June 1893 · page 2

NEW BEDFORD, MASS, June 5.—The long-anticipated Borden murder trial has begun. At an early hour this morning every available shady spot on County street, near the court-house, was pre empted, and patiently the sitters and standers waited until the bell on the court-house tolled, signifying the open ing of the court. At precisely 10:58 Miss Lizzie Borden,

See the clipping

The Times · Richmond, Va.

The report describes the opening day of Lizzie Borden's murder trial in New Bedford, noting her appearance in court and the swift selection of a jury by late afternoon. It also recaps the earlier double murder of Andrew and Abby Borden, noting the household's occupants that morning.

The Times · 6 June 1893 · page 2

TRIAL OF MISS BORDEN. HEARING OF THE CELEBRATED CASE BEGUN AT NEW BEDFORD.

J. Borden were hacked to death in their home in a thickly settled portion of Fall River, Mass.,, by some person unknown. The crimes occurred between 9 and 1 o'clock In the morning. The only persns { obout the house that morning so far as known were the murdered couple, Lizzie Eorden and Bridz:t Sulivan, the servant. Brideet declares that she saw Mrs. 3or den for the last time at 9 o'clock and that later lizzie said her stepmother had gene out. Bridget was washing ‘vindows cutside the house between 9 and 10:29, while Lizzi» was inside ironing >r mov ing about different parts of the resiiz1e, |

See the clipping

The Times · Richmond, Va.

The report describes the opening day of Lizzie Borden's trial, noting the jury foreman was appointed and opening statements were postponed until the next morning. It also recaps the history of the murders of Andrew and Abby Borden, including testimony details from Bridget Sullivan and Lizzie's own account of her movements that morning.

The Times · 6 June 1893 · page 2

CASE BEGUN AT NEW BEDFORD.

The words of this article are printed with the report it shares its clipping with. Read them there or in the clipping.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

The Times · Richmond, Va.

The report reviews how Andrew and Abby Borden were killed with a hatchet or axe, noting the time-of-death estimates and Lizzie's account of her movements. It also summarizes the forensic findings—no blood found on the axes, hatchet, or Lizzie's clothing despite the bloody crime scene—and debates the alleged motive and her possible innocence.

The Times · 6 June 1893 · page 2

CASE BEGUN AT NEW BEDFORD

and presentation of Bible and ordination ciated in regard to the United States. prayer by Rev, F. H. James. Mr. Cole » rery tangible, 4 The alleged motive for the double crime charged against Lizzie Borden is that che and her stepmother were not on friendly terms. Lizzie says that she and her steo mother quarreled five years ago. Bafoce

See the clipping

Fairhaven Herald · Fairhaven, Wash.

The trial of Lizzie Borden for the axe murders of her father and stepmother began in New Bedford, Massachusetts. The report recaps the circumstantial case, including Bridget Sullivan's presence, the discovery of the bodies, and discrepancies in Lizzie's account that led to her arrest and indictment.

Fairhaven Herald · 6 June 1893 · page 1

ARRAIGNED FOR MURDER

NEW BEbrorD, Mass., June 5-The trial of Lizzie Borden, of Fall River, charged with murdering her father, Aundrew Jackson Borden, and her step mother, Abby Durfee Borden, an aged, wealthy und highly respected couple, on the morning of August 4, 1802, be gan here this morning. The most eminent eriminal lawyers of the stuate were employed and the trial 0 mises to be most interesting ai.d probubly sensational. The evidence is purely circumstantial. On the day in ques tion, as far as known, the only persons in the house were the old couple, Lizzie and a maid servant, Bridget Sullivan, who was outside most of the morning washing windows., Borden was out in the morning, returning between 10 and 11 o’¢loek, aud it was only s short time afterwards that Lizzie, after a short visit to the barn, ealled to the servant to run for the doctor as her father had been murdered, Shortly afterwards Mrs.

See moreSee less

Borden was missed, and a search revealed her body in the upper room, she having evidently been killed some time before her husbaud. In both cases death resulted from blows from some

See the clipping

The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · Wheeling, W. Va.

The article summarizes the Borden case, describing the murders of Andrew and Abby Borden, noting Lizzie Borden and servant Bridget Sullivan were in the house, and citing motive and a blood spot as key prosecution evidence. It also mentions a daughter 'implicated' in the murder who was supposedly absent when it occurred.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · 6 June 1893 · page 4

drudges. Ho had a second wife wit wUoin his daughters wore not on goo terms. One of tho daughters is in n way implicated in tho murder, for sL was absent at the tlrno it was coumi tod. 0,ld man Borden and his wile wer murdered in their homo in broad da; light. The othor persons known to L in the house at the time were I.izzie lio don aud llridgot Bullivan, the servan Lizzie llorden gave the alarm, sayiu that her father was hurt or dead, It not certain which.

See moreSee less

Mrs. Borden ho beon murdered upstairs, the old uia downstairs. Lizzie Borden had a mi live for tho crime. The death of Ik father would bring hor a large inheri mice. The etopmothor being deai there would bo still more for tho duugl tors. The motive and an almost luipu ceptible spot of blood that may hav got ou her drese wbuu she went to tb side of her dead lather, are tho chit grounds for tho prosecution. ISofor the young woman can be convicte there will have to be much more coi vincing proof of her guilt. Tho case i full of mystery and the trial will bo fu of interest. The Hirlku Kt:vursod. Sevonty furniture manufacturers < Cincinnati, ull in tbo city excopt twi have closed thoir works and locked ou their workmen. This is; their rcupont to cortain domands of their employe: One of tho demands is that tho inuuu fuotnrers shall not sell goods to person employing non-union lubor. Two that sund meu are thrown out of employ incut by this action. The lock-out is tho employers' strike Against the union of the wage-earner it presents the solid front of tho unite manufacturers. Employershavoloamo tho lesson from employes. The strik is a kind of force. Bo is tho lock-oul Neither affords tho best way of gettin along in businoss. A better way than oithor is for boil sides to drop tho idea of wariaro an to treat their interests as business in torosts, aud when they cannot ugroo 01 the main question to agree to arbitral their differences. This is a more civil izod method than tho strike aud th lock-out. It is better for the interest immediately ivfolvod and bottmIp tho country. The itlglit of Exclusion. : It may be, as somo prodict, that othe governments will take advantage otkx position taken by our owu with rospoc to iho exclusion of aliens. If this righ should bo exercised asainst citizons a mo uuiiou oiaioa eojouriuut: 111 ioreig couutrioa wo could not complain. It i uq incident of sovereignty. t Any people bus a right to say wh shall not and who may rosido with! itu borders. The Chinese exclusion ac was passed to keop out of the countr certain aliens whoso presence in larg< numbers was thought to be undosirabl and hurtful. Those of that nationalit residing In the country were permitto to remain provided thoy would regie to so ua to be identified. If China sees fit to rota%to wit limilar action, or if it ahull say thu nil Americans shall got out of Chin ?nd stuy out, wo cannot complain China is an independent nation am may rogulato her domestic affairs t suit horself. Tho same rulo applies t jvery other nation, tho littlo onos a well as the big ones. On witli tin! UluriuuH Fourth ! It having boon found impossible t Bocuro tho necessary, number of guui antors for tho production of Tho Las Days Of Pompoii, the Columbian Fourtl of July celebration as originally de signod by tho chumbor of commorc will bo carriod out As a handsoino display of firework Is included in the I'oiupeiian spoctacle this part of tho Fourth of July pro gramma proper would have beon aban ilonod if Pompoii had boon produpod Since that is not to bo tho committooio tho chamber of commerco will ondoavo to have on tho night of tho Fourth o July such an exhibition of fireworks a lias never beon soon in this locality. Tha work of urrauglng for tho celo brntlon will now bo takon ud activcl; in all ita branches and pushed to ; liundsomo success. The historic spectacle proposod fo: Whoellug would havo been a groa ihing, but since wo cuunot havo tha ind can huvo tho "old-fashionod Fourth' m a liundsomo scale, lot everybody ;urn In to make that tho groutost one lay's succoss Wheeling has ever known Hurrah for Christopher Columbui lud Undo Bam I State buildings nt tho fair, if oponoc it all on Sunday, should nqt ho oponoc 'on tho sly." If thu fair Is open cor alnly any stfito building may bo opor or tho,accommodation of persons hav nn a special right to uao it. The Wes Virginia building will bo oponcd one o; thoeo days. Every Wort Virginian will bo glut hat tho rocolvorship for the groat Nor oik & Wostorn was bo short-lived Waal Virginia would rogrot upythlnj laving tho appoaranco of the sorloui imbarraiBinont of that important do /olo|>mont.

See the clipping

Wheeling Register · Wheeling, W. Va.

The report describes the first day of Lizzie Borden's trial at the Superior Court in New Bedford, framing it as a contest between top criminal lawyers with her life at stake. It recaps the background of the double murder of Andrew and Abby Borden in August 1892, including the household's movements that morning and Lizzie's own account of finding her father's body.

Wheeling Register · 6 June 1893 · page 1

LIZZIE BORDEN S CASE. The Trial Began Before the Superior Coart at New Bedford, Ma»»acha*eiM, Testerdag. New Bedford, Mass., June 5.—To day Lizzie Borden took her seat In the prisoners dock of the Superior Court bore, and a battle royal between the most eminent criminal lawyers in the State, with a womon’s life and honor at stake, began. On the fourth day of August, 1892, be tween 9:30 and 11:30 a. m., Andrew Jackson Borden and Abby Duffee Bor den were murdered at their home in Fall River. This much is known, and the horrible brutality of the affair has excited national interest, but Just when and by whom these deeds were com mitted, are questions which the court and jury and eminent counsels will try to solve and for which they assembled here to to-day.

See moreSee less

Briefly put, the case stands as follows: Lizzie Aberdeen, daughter of An drew Jackson Borden, a woman about thirty-three years old, her step-mother, Abby Durfee Borden, and Bridget Sul livan, a servant, were the only mem bers of the family about the house when Mr. Borden came home at about

See the clipping

Wheeling Register · Wheeling, W. Va.

The article reviews Lizzie Borden's account of the morning of the murders, noting a photograph contradicts her claim about her father's boots, and confirms Mrs. Borden was killed before her husband. It then describes the start of the trial, with Chief Justice Mason presiding and large crowds gathering as Lizzie arrives at the courthouse.

Wheeling Register · 6 June 1893 · page 1

LIZZIE BORDEN'S CASE.

Churchill came to the house at once, and asked for Mrs. Borden. Lizzie knew nothing of her whereabouts, but _it __; _ A . fan, (higher ak<»n mother had told her previously that she had received a note from a friend and In responie was intending to call on that friend. However, Bridget was requested to look for her mistress, but she objected to going alone and Mrs. Churchill went with her. As the two women approached the top of the stairs leading to the second floor they saw on the floor of the guest chamber the body of Mrs.

See moreSee less

Borden. It was soon learned that she too had been murdered In about the same manner as her husband had been, vlx: with heavy blows from a sharp instrument, probably an axe or a hatchet. It was definitely determined at an autopsy subsequently held that Mrs. Borden had been killed sometime before her husband. Sheriff Wright bad made all the pre parations he could to handle the crowd, which he knew would get about the court house aud struggle to get In. All the availablo policemen and doputy sheriffs were pressed into service Inside and outside the building. They had their hands full no matter where they happened to be stationed. During the present trial Chief Justice Mason will preside. His associate* will

See the clipping

Bill Barlow's Budget · Douglas, Wyo. · and 1 other paper

A compilation of brief national news items includes a one-line mention that the trial of Lizzie Borden began at New Bedford, Massachusetts, that Monday morning. The rest of the item covers unrelated stories, from murders and lawsuits to Edwin Booth's declining health.

Bill Barlow's Budget · 7 June 1893 · page 4

BRIEF ITEMS OF NEWS.

roads for the purpose of smuggling Chinese into the United States. The trial of Lizzie Borden began at New Bedford, Mass., this (Monday) morning. The indictments against H. C. Frick, the result of the Homestead strike have been quashed. It is believed the cases against the strikers will be dismissed. Mrs. Harrison, who would have shortly become queen of the Gypsies of North America, was buried in Green Mount cem etary, near Mascoutah, 111., Saturday.

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • The Beatrice Daily Express · Beatrice, Neb. · 5 June 1893

Paper unidentified

The report marks the start of Lizzie Borden's trial at New Bedford, recapping the case history including the double axe murder of Andrew and Abby Borden and the grand jury's true bill. It notes five jurors have been chosen so far as proceedings begin.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

Paper unidentified · 7 June 1893 · page 1

FIVE JURORS CHOSEN. Beginning of Lizzie Andre Borden’s Trial at New Bedford, Maes. The most sensational murder trial in the history of New England within the memory of the present generation is that which began at New Bedford Mass., Monday, in which a young and handsome woman, Miss Lizzie Borden, is arraigned for tlie peculiarly atrocious murder of her own father and his second wife. The case from the first has literally teemed with mys tery and has been surrounded by so many mysterious circumstances that grave doubts are entertained of its ever being fully unravelled to public view.

See moreSee less

The story of the murder has been read and related in even the most obscure portions of the United States and has been the subject of newspaper comment in every civilized land. The story of the life of the rich mill owner, Borden; of bis second marriage; of the discord between wife and daughter have all been gone over. The motive for the crime has been looked for in the fact that the mill owner was to leave all his wealth to his wife, leaving Lizzie and her sister dependent upon the step-mother. The day of the tragedy came, and Mrs. Borden was found dead on the upper floor, Mr. Borden having been killed on the first floor. The crime was committed with an axe or a hatchet, and the only other denizens of the house at the time of the murder were the Irish servant girl and Lizzie. The arrest of Brother-in-law Morse was followed quickly by his release, ho having proved an alibi. The coron er’s jury held Lizzie for the grand jury. That body, after long investi gation and repeated delays, found a true bill of murder in the first degree, and Lizzie has now boon confined in the Taunton jail for over a year. Chief Justice Albert Mason, one of the oldest and most distinguished members of the state judiciary, will act as presiding Judge at the trial. Accommodation for fifty newspaper men has been prepared, and an extra venire of Jurymen lias been drawn by the clerk of the court, whose name singularly enough, is Simeon Borden, jr. lie is in no way related to the de fendant. Ex-Gov. George D. Robinson, who will act as senior counsel for Lizzie Borden, comes from Chicopee; Melvin O. Adams from Boston; Mr. Jenning, from Fall River. Attorney-General Pillsbury has charge of the prosecu tion. The gloomy old court house where Lizzie Borden is to be put on trial for her life, is situated a little west from the center of the city,, fronting on County street, one of the prinepial residence streets, and surrounded by magnificent elm trees. Rumilng alongside on the nortli is Court street, on which, but a square or two distant, is the jail where Miss Borden will bo confined during her trial. At 11:27 a. m. Monday, (he prisoner was formally arraigned for trial. The work of empaneling the jury was then begun. At 12 o’clock, noon, on yesterday five jurors had been ob tained. The work of selecting the jury goes on today. That Indian Money. Latest advices from Washington confirm the fact that the money due the Choctaw and Chickasaw Indians for the Cheyenne and Arapahoe lands has not yet been paid over. The merchants and business men of the entire section are deeply interested in the outcome of the matter, as they have sold large amounts of goods on the strength of the early payment of this money. The statement that war rants have been drawn for the money has led many to believe that this meant the money would bo paid into the Choctaw treasury. Such is not necessarily the case. Warrants have to bo drawn for money for any pur pose before it can bo paid out. The drawing of tho warrants indicate, however, that tho money is to lie paid in some way and that in a short time. It cannot come too soon for the Choc taws are greatly in need of it and it will relieve them from much distress and actual want.

See the clipping

Paper unidentified

The report recaps the Borden case background and reviews the upcoming trial, including the judge, attorneys, and courthouse details. It notes that by Tuesday noon five jurors had been selected, with jury selection continuing.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

Paper unidentified · 7 June 1893 · page 1

FIVE JURORS CHOSEN.

The words of this article are printed with the report it shares its clipping with. Read them there or in the clipping.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

Morning Journal and Courier · New Haven, Conn.

A brief telegraph dispatch reports that Lizzie Borden fainted during a court proceeding but quickly regained consciousness. The report notes she soon returned to her usual calm demeanor.

Morning Journal and Courier · 7 June 1893 · page 3

Passes Away. LIZZIE BORDEN FAINTED Regained She Soon Usual Calmness. RUSSIAN TREATY IS PROCLAIMED. It Will Go Into Effect in Three Weeks. EDWIN BOOTH IB1D. AWAY. Her

See the clipping

Morning Journal and Courier · New Haven, Conn.

The headline announces that Lizzie Borden fainted, apparently during a courtroom proceeding in her murder trial, which was underway in June 1893. The body text that follows in the clipping is garbled by OCR/layout and actually corresponds to an unrelated story about a telegraphy tournament, so no further detail about the fainting incident is given.

Morning Journal and Courier · 7 June 1893 · page 3

LIZZIE BORDEN FAINTED. The Stoical Daughter of an Old New England Family at Last Breaks Down The Opening of the Famous murder Trial. Nkw Bedford, 'Mass., Jnne 6. Miss Lizzie Borden and the jury selected yester day to try her on the charge of murdering her father and stepmother were in their seats before 9 o'clock this morning. At least a third of the spectators present were women. The jury heard the lndlotment against the prisoner read as soon as oourt was opened. Mr. Moody of oonnsel for the state then opened the prossontlun's case, beginning with a story of the murder on August 4, 1893.

See moreSee less

The eourt room was completely hushed when Mr. Moody stepped over before the jnry and began his address, in whioh there might be some Inklings of sensations to follow. So all in the room were on the qui vlve. Mr. Moody made his opening with a brief sketch of the Borden family. He called attention to tbe faot that Miss Lizz'.e Borden and her step-mother qnarrelled because of an act of her father's which was of benefit to a relative of the second Mrs. Borden.

See the clipping

Morning Journal and Courier · New Haven, Conn.

At New Bedford, prosecutor Mr. Moody opens the state's case against Lizzie Borden, sketching her family history and the layout of the Borden house. The jury is told they will later visit the crime scene to see where the two victims were found.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day. CorrectionThis set right an article from the day before.

Wrong

Morning Journal and Courier · 7 June 1893 · page 3

LIZZIE BORDEN FAINTED. The Stoical Daughter of an Old New England Family at Last Breaks Down The Opening of the Famous murder Trial. Nkw Bedford, 'Mass., Jnne 6. Miss Lizzie Borden and the jury selected yester day to try her on the charge of murdering her father and stepmother were in their seats before 9 o'clock this morning. At least a third of the spectators present were women. The jury heard the lndlotment against the prisoner read as soon as oourt was opened. Mr. Moody of oonnsel for the state then opened the prossontlun's case, beginning with a story of the murder on August 4, 1893.

See moreSee less

The eourt room was completely hushed when Mr. Moody stepped over before the jnry and began his address, in whioh there might be some Inklings of sensations to follow. So all in the room were on the qui vlve. Mr. Moody made his opening with a brief sketch of the Borden family. He called attention to tbe faot that Miss Lizz'.e Borden and her step-mother qnarrelled because of an act of her father's which was of benefit to a relative of the second Mrs. Borden. Mr. Moody then carefully described the house In which the tragedy was enacted on August 4 last, lie drew particular atten tion to the fact that there was no entrance at the rear of the honse. He described carefully the position of tne different sleeping rooms in tne douse. The importance of the minute description of the house will become apparent as the case progresses. When he bad finished that, the assistant dlstrlot attorney in formed the jurors that later In the day they would have an opportunity to visit the house in whioh the murders were com mitted, and would have made dear to them the conditions in the building in Fall Biver when the two hacked bodies were fonnd. Up to this time Miss Borden regarded the speaker steadily, but no more so than every other speaker in the room. At times she fanned herself lazily, at otnera she kept the edge of her fan stuok iu her mouth. Mr. Moody then got down to the days of the murder, and followed the movements of each member of the household, nil of whioh have been fully told. The blows in tbe head of Mr. Borden were made with a weapon 31 inches Iong.no more fjed no less," said the speaker im pressively. "This part of a hatchet ia just that length." There were no evidences of a struggle anywhere in the bouse," he went on, "not an article anywhere in the house had been disturbed. The one who committed the murders was familiar with the premises." From the middle until the end of the opening address Miss Borden leaned back in her chair and never moved a muscle. She pat the fan up over her face, and holding her head forward, pressed It olose against her forehead and held it there. Her eyes were closed and ahe appeared as if asleep. Not by any motion did ahe betray that she was ooni olous of what was going on about her. Just as Mr. Moody had oeased to speak and taken one step toward his seat, there was a noise where Miss Borden was sitting. She bad fainted. The Rev. Mr. Jabb hurried over to her and placed a bottle of smelling salts to her nostrils. Depnty Sheriff Kirby and anoth er offioer hurried after cracked Ice. The woman's face crew white. The offi cers returned with ice in a moment and a oouple of minutes later Miss Borden began to recover. The jury was allowed a recess of about five minutes, and when it had returned to the box she had recovered her usnal man ner and bearing. At 11:30 the defendant refused to ac company tbe jury to the scene of tbe crime. The ohlef justice instructed the jury as to what the view was to be taken for, and then they were dismissed to report for dnty to-morrow morning at 9 o'clock.

See the clipping

Waterbury Evening Democrat · Waterbury, Conn.

The report describes courtroom testimony at Lizzie Borden's trial regarding sightlines within the Borden house, including the barn door, closet, and stairs, and whether the body could have been seen. It also notes Lizzie's restless night and speculation she may break down under the strain.

Waterbury Evening Democrat · 7 June 1893 · page 1

LIZZIE BORDEN'S TRIAL

Darn aoor trom second street. Judge Mason suggested that this point was clearly shown on the drawings and was seen dj tne jury yesterday. The evidence then turned to the closet in the lower front hall of the house. WirniwH testified that when the door of the closet was slightly ajar, a person might uo lusiue witnouc oeing seen Dy anyone in the front hall. Then the possibility of seeiDg the dead body of Mrs Borden in the front room on the floor, when the observer was standing on the stairs and lookinsr under'the bed.

See moreSee less

was taken up. It appeared that the body could be seen u me ooserver triea to see it. but the witness was not sure that in ordi nary passing up stairs the body would be noticed. The prosecution will claim that Lizzie stood at the head of the stairs when her father returned on the fatal morning, for the express purpose ui turning mm dsck it no attemptea to come up the front stairs. Witness stated that there were barbed wire fences around the yard except in front, uaines a. waisn, pnotograpber, was next called. He bad taken views of the body on the day of the tragedy. It is the general opinion that Lizzie Borden will not be able to endure the strain of a long trial. Yesterday's swoon.it is believed, ia the beginning 01 ner Dreaicing aown, and if the trial lasts a month it is not unlikely that, if guuey, sne win confess.

See the clipping

Waterbury Evening Democrat · Waterbury, Conn.

The New Bedford trial resumed with Thomas Kiernan as the first prosecution witness, after the jury heard the indictments read. Prosecutor Moody delivered an opening address describing the murders and highlighting discrepancies in Lizzie Borden's statements, after which Borden fainted.

CorrectionThis set right an article from the day before.

Waterbury Evening Democrat · 7 June 1893 · page 2

LIZZIE BORDEN'S TRIAL Examining the First Witness For the Prosecution. THOMAS KIERNAN ON THE STAND. The Jurors Returned from Fall River Early Last Evening. Mr. Moody's Opening Address for the Prosecution. Miss Borden Faints at Its Conclusion.

New Bedford, Mass., June 7. Tbt court house was aj;ain packed this mora ing when court opened. Miss Borden ami herattorneys were iu their places promptly at 9 e'elock, and shortly atrer that time. Thomas Kiernan, th first witness for the prosecution, began to give his testimony. "When court convened yesterday tht jury beard the Indictments against Miss Borden read as soon as Court was foruially opened, and were charged as "good meu and true, stand together and hearken to your evidence." Mr. Moody then stepped to the railing and opened the government's case.

See moreSee less

He said that on the fourth day of August lat an old man and an eld woman, without a known enemy in the world, were stricken down bv an unknown assassin. Ik th prisoner dock was a youag weman, a 1 daughter ot the murdered people, a young woman of goed social standing, charged with the crime of murdering thess people. It was his purpose to put the story of the crime in th easiest manner possible. Mr. Meody got down t th early morn ing of th day upon which th tragedy was enacted. He told at what hours the diner ent members of the household had arisen and what had passed between them imme diately after that. The speaker called attention to th dis crepancies teat existed in tne stories told by the prisoner. Iu brief, they were that she told on story. In wbicb sba said that while iu the barn she had heard a noise in the house, something in the nature of an aUrrn. She rushed into the house and discov ered the body of her father. Ihe other story was that she had been in the loft of th bars and had discovered th body of her father when she entered th house to get her hat. She bad told, too, tnat sne bad gone to the barn for th purpose of getting some lead from which to make sinkers. Another story was that she had gone there for a piece of iron with which to repair a screen. Mr. J'oody unrolled a bundle and dis closed the clothing Miss Borden had worn ou the morning her father and mother were killed. 11 held them up for inspect tlon by the jury. There was no trace of blood on any of the garments on except the front of the skirt, wher there was a minute particle of blood. Two axes and three hatchets were shown to the jury. "There was no evidence of a struggle anywhere in the house," Mr. Moody went on, "not an article anywhera in the house had been disturbed. The on who com mitted th murder was familiar with the premises. From the middle until the end of the onenins; address Miss Bordan leaned back in her chair and never moved a muscle. She put the fan up over her face, and holding her head forward, pressed it close agaiust her forehead and held it there. Her eyes were closed and she appeared as if asleep. Not by any motion did she betray that she was conscious of what was going on about her. Just as Mr. Moody had ceased to speak and taken one step toward his seat, there was a noise where Miss Borden was sitting. She had fainted. The Rev. Mr. Jubb hurried over to her and placed a bottle of smelling salts to her nostrils. Deputy Sheriff Kirby and an other officer hurried after some cracked ice. The woman's face grew white. The ofli - cers returned with ice in a moment, and a couple of minutes later Miss Borden began to recover. The jury was allowed a recess of about five minutes, and when it bad returned to the box she had recovered her usual man ner and bearing. When the jury returned the case was opened by the Government putting on its first witness in th person of Thomas Kiernan. Mr. Knowlton then asked the court to allow the jury to take a view of the Bor den premises. Gov. Robinson, who con suited Miss Borden In regard to accom panying the jury to Fall River, announced that h'is client waived her rights in the matter and would not go with them. Messrs. Hodges, Brown, Nickerson and Arnold of the Deputy Sheriffs were desig nated by th Sheriff to look after the jury, and Messrs. Moody, for the commonwealth, and Mr. Jennings, lor the detense, were designated as representing counsel.

See the clipping

Waterbury Evening Democrat · Waterbury, Conn.

During the trial, Lizzie Borden fainted and was revived with smelling salts and ice before the jury returned to hear the first witness, Thomas Kiernan. Later, the jury traveled to Fall River to view the Borden house and surrounding premises as part of the proceedings.

Waterbury Evening Democrat · 7 June 1893 · page 2

going on about her. Just as Mr. Moody had ceased to speak and taken one step toward his seat, there was a noise where Miss Borden was sitting. She had fainted. The Rev. Mr. Jubb hurried over to her and placed a bottle of smelling salts to her nostrils. Deputy Sheriff Kirby and an other officer hurried after some cracked ice. The woman's face grew white. The ofli - cers returned with ice in a moment, and a couple of minutes later Miss Borden began to recover. The jury was allowed a recess of about five minutes, and when it bad returned to the box she had recovered her usual man ner and bearing.

See moreSee less

When the jury returned the case was opened by the Government putting on its first witness in th person of Thomas Kiernan. Mr. Knowlton then asked the court to allow the jury to take a view of the Bor den premises. Gov. Robinson, who con suited Miss Borden In regard to accom panying the jury to Fall River, announced that h'is client waived her rights in the matter and would not go with them. Messrs. Hodges, Brown, Nickerson and Arnold of the Deputy Sheriffs were desig nated by th Sheriff to look after the jury, and Messrs. Moody, for the commonwealth, and Mr. Jennings, lor the detense, were designated as representing counsel.

See the clipping

The Morning Call · San Francisco, Calif.

The trial of Lizzie Borden for the murder of her father and stepmother began in New Bedford with Attorney Moody's opening statement detailing the crime and alleged ill will between Lizzie and her stepmother. Lizzie fainted after the statement, then the prosecution called its first witness, civil engineer Thomas Kiernan, before the court adjourned and the jury viewed the murder scene.

The Morning Call · 7 June 1893 · page 1

Then, After All. New Bedford, Mass., June 6.— The trial of Lizzie Borden for the murder of her fatlrer stud stepmother in Fall River begun this morning with a statement of the case on behalf of the commonwealth by Attorney Moo y, who rehearsed the de tails of the crime as already told in these dispatches, and related many instancss to show ill will had long existed between Lizzie and her stepmother. Though Miss Borden gave no sign of being affected by .he address she fainted just as <lie speaker concluded.

See moreSee less

When she revived the State put on as the first wit ness Thomas Kiernan, a civil engineer. He minutely described the Borden • house and surroundings. Adjourned till tor-mor row. After the adjournment of the court the jury went to Fall River and viewed the scene of the murder.

See the clipping

The Morning Call · San Francisco, Calif.

This report summarizes the August 1892 double murder of Andrew and Abby Borden in Fall River, describing how both were found hacked to death with a hatchet and how Lizzie Borden was the only person present besides a servant. It notes prosecutors believe Lizzie's motive was fear of being cut out of her father's will.

The Morning Call · 7 June 1893 · page 6

THE BORDEN MYSTERY. The trial of Lizzie Borden of Fall River, Mass., for the murder of her father and mother is one of those sensational cases which will attract attention all over the

See the clipping

The Morning Call · San Francisco, Calif.

The report lays out the prosecution's theory that Lizzie Borden cleared the house to be alone, then killed her mother and later her father with a hatchet. It also presents an alternative theory involving two strangers seen entering the yard the night before, suggesting burglars may have been responsible for the murders.

The Morning Call · 7 June 1893 · page 6

There is another which presents fewer difficulties. The Borden bouse stood in a lot at the rear of which was a barn used hy the family to store rubbish. The rear gate of the lot was unfastened. On the evening before the murder neighbors living in the back street saw two strangers at this gate, and think they saw them enter the yard. They did not observe them go ing out. It was possible for 'two house breakers to enter the yard, steal into the barn, and await events. Mr. Borden was known to be rich, and was suspected of keeping money and valuables in a safe which sloe din his bouse.

See moreSee less

Let us assume that two burglars did that night enter the barn intending to break into the house, and that they were foiled by the bolts with which doors and windows were fastened. They would return dis appointed to the barn. They might conclude to wait till the morning, wben the back door would be openea, and take the chances of a sudden rush. When morn ing came they would wait for an oppor tunity. When they thought it had come, one of tbem might have crept Into the house about a quarter past 10, ran upstairs, and, finding Mrs. Borden in her room felled her with a blow of the hatchet. Then finding that the safe, which *was his objective point, was not in the bedroom the murderer might have gone hastily down stairs and discovered what he was in search of in the parlor. Perhaps while he was studying how to open the safe Borneo, sleeping on the sofa, might have moved, whereupon the burglar, having gone so far, would not hesitate to finish him with his hatchet, and when the neighborhood was aroused would make his escape by the back door, without having attained his purpose. It will be observed that this theory fails to account for the burglar's time between the killing of Borden and bis escape— a period of several minutes. The accounts of the trial, which will be supplied by the dispatches, will shed further light on the tragedy, and may dis pose of both these theories. Others may take their place. The ablest members of the New England bar have been retained for prosecution and defense, and the chances are that the truth will come out. though, of course, the Borden mystery may be added to the long list of undiscov ered murders.

See the clipping

The Morning Call · San Francisco, Calif.

The article speculates about a theory that burglars broke into the Borden house seeking a safe, killing Mrs. Borden and then Mr. Borden when he stirred. It acknowledges gaps in the theory and notes that trial testimony may confirm or replace such speculation.

The Morning Call · 7 June 1893 · page 6

The words of this article are printed with the report it shares its clipping with. Read them there or in the clipping.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

The Record-Union · Sacramento, Calif.

The trial opened at New Bedford with Attorney Moody giving the prosecution's opening statement, detailing the crime and alleging long-standing ill-will between Lizzie and her stepmother. Lizzie fainted after the statement, and the first witness, civil engineer Thomas Kiernan, described the Borden house before adjournment.

The Record-Union · 7 June 1893 · page 1

LIZZIE BORDEN TRIAL. Opening Statement on Behalf of tho Commonwealth. New Bedford (Mass.), June G.—The trial of Lizzie Borden, for the murder of ! her father and stepmother in I'all Kiver, began this morning with a statement of the case on behalf of the commonwealth by Attorney Moody, who rehearsed the detail of tho crime as already told in these dispatches, and related many iustauces to show ill-will had long existed between I Lizzie and her stepmother. Though Miss Borden gave no sign of I being affected by the addiess, she fainted just as the speaker concluded. When i she revived the State put on as lirst wit ness Thomas Kiernan, a civil engineer. He minutely described the Borden houso and surroundings. Adjourned till to morrow.

See the clipping

Evening Journal · Wilmington, Del.

The trial of Lizzie Borden for the murder of her father and stepmother began in New Bedford, Massachusetts. The editorial calls the evidence meagre but strongly presumptive, urges readers to follow multiple newspapers for accurate information, and promises ongoing commentary as evidence unfolds.

Evening Journal · 7 June 1893 · page 2

The trial of Lizzie Borden for the mnrdar of her father and stepmother was begun In New Bedford, Maasachu setts, yesterday. This la an Intensely In teresting case. The evidence is meagre

See the clipping

The Wilmington Daily Republican · Wilmington, Del.

At the Lizzie Borden trial in New Bedford, prosecutor Mr. Moody opened the government's case, describing the Borden family background and the growing estrangement between Lizzie and her stepmother over property matters. He cited testimony that a family dressmaker heard Lizzie express hatred toward her stepmother, calling her a 'horrid, mean thing.'

The Wilmington Daily Republican · 7 June 1893 · page 1

THE ACCUSED WOMAN'S HATRED.

in the easiest manner possible. Mr. Borden was a man of considerahli property and of quiet, retiring ways, win bad saved his money as lie made it, bad maintained his family be termed a narrow scale. married for the second time, not long afte hat might Lizzie A. Bor of ago when her fat he: 8 ye

See the clipping

The Wilmington Daily Republican · Wilmington, Del.

District Attorney Moody opens the prosecution's case, describing Lizzie's resentment toward her stepmother and detailing the household's movements on the morning of the murders. He outlines evidence including a burned dress with apparent blood spatters and Lizzie's inconsistent statements to authorities.

The Wilmington Daily Republican · 7 June 1893 · page 1

THE ACCUSED WOMAN'S HATRED.

▼«sat ii ith Miss Alice Russell, thut Lizzie had rder in her heart, Mr. hloody then produced tho plans of the house of tho Bordens*and the locality, dkneribod them plainly to tho jury. C Hauing he said: "On tho morning of the tragedy Bridget Sulliv y safely ass tho proof tin •nly human beings in tho house that night were thornwe have mentioned. Bridget her fuel down stairs and built a fire, the milk al tho rear door ami locked it afl«r she brough' it in. There flow here, d this it w rhieh Bridge locked after she got the ilk. Lizzie c I tl. ■

See the clipping

The Wilmington Daily Republican · Wilmington, Del.

This report covers the prosecution's opening statement by Mr. Moody at the trial, describing the morning of the murders including Bridget Sullivan's activities, Lizzie's claim that Mrs. Borden received a note, and the discovery of the bodies. It details the hatchet evidence matching the wounds, the burned dress, and notes the jury's reaction before adjournment, with testimony from witness Thomas Kieran following.

The Wilmington Daily Republican · 7 June 1893 · page 1

talroduccd its fir witness, Thomas Kir nan. a civil engineer, •ho ifled in tho streets in tho nity of the I rden home. After this testimony the der eourt, adjourned in it tho Borden house tr*' to bo Keteascd. : Jhl I Paris, June 7.—The Eclair states that the court of cassation, to which Charles «1« Lesseps and his associates appealed from tho sentences passed upon them for ption in tho management of thc ■ffalrs of the Panama Canal company, will annul the sentenco and order the Iroae of the defendants. There Panama trials, und the above prospective nulment will only apply to the tencv.cs delivered ns result of tho secoud trial. Tnoreforo itc ouiy benefit Baihut I Fall

See the clipping

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

A news digest reports that Mr. Moody opened the government's case in the Borden trial at New Bedford, with one witness examined before adjournment. The jury then traveled to Fall River to view the scene of the double murder.

New-York Tribune · 7 June 1893 · page 6

THE NEWS THIS MORNING. Foreign.—Radical members of the House of Commons held a conference to consider means of expediting the passage of the Ilome Rule bill: two amendments to the bili were rejected in the Commons. =———-— Sir Richard Webster continued bis argument for the Dritish case before the Behring Sea Tribunal of Arbitration. =——=— The Valkyrie again defeated the Britannia, Satanita, Iverna and Calluna. -————== Suez Canal stockholders held a boisterous meeting in Paris; Ferdinand and Charles de Iesseps were re-elected members of the Board of Directors. Domestic.—The runs on Chicago savings banks wero continued without any failure resulting: many failures of banks and business firms were reported from various parts of the country.

See moreSee less

—— — Mr. Moody opened the Government's case in the Borden trial at New-Bedford: after one witness

See the clipping

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

The trial of Lizzie Borden began with the prosecution's opening address delivered by Mr. Moody, followed by examination of one witness. The jury was then taken to Fall River to inspect the Borden house and surrounding grounds.

New-York Tribune · 7 June 1893 · page 6

The trial of Lizzie Borden made some progress yesterday, the opening address for the prosecution being made and one witness being examined. The jury were then taken to Fall

See the clipping

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

The trial began with jury selection completed and Mr. Moody delivering the prosecution's opening address, describing the murders of an elderly couple and accusing Lizzie Borden, their daughter, of the crime. After one witness was examined, the court adjourned to allow the jury to visit the crime scene in Fall River.

New-York Tribune · 7 June 1893 · page 11

DOUBLE MURDER AT FALL RIVER. New Bedford, Mass, §June 6.—The trial of Lizzie Borden was fairly started here to-day, the jury having been complete) yesterday. Mr. Moody made an ai dress, opening Me Government's case, and one wWkiness for the prosecution was examined. Then an adfournment was taken to enable the jury to visit Fall River and view the scene of the tragedy. At 8:55 o'clock this morning Miss Lorden and the jury were in their seats In the courtroom, and counsel were on hand busily arranging thelr papers. The doors were opened to spectators about that time, and at least a third of those who entered were women, State Detectives Seaver and shaw sat near the connsel for the proseention and aids: and Detective Ducey, of Chelsea, who has been doing some quiet work for the defence, wis handy to the call of the counsel on that side.

See moreSee less

The jury heard the indictments against Miss Borden read as soon as the conrt was formally opened, and were charged. Then Mr. Moody stepped to the railing and opened the Government’s case. lle aid, among other things, that on August 4 an old man and ar old woman, without a known enemy in the world, were stricksn down bv an unknown assassin. In the prisoner's dock was a dangh ter of the murdered people, a young wonan of good social standing, charged with the crime of murdering these people. It was his purpose, added the speaker, to present the story of the crime in the easiest manner possible, Mr. Dorden was a man of considerable property, and of quiet, retiring wavs, who had saved his money as he bad made ft, and had maintained his family on what might be termed a narrow scale. Lizzie A. Borden was two or three vears old when her father married for the second time, not long after the death of lis fist wife, The marringe was over twenty-five years before the time of their death, and there had been no Issue. Abby Durfee Borden,

See the clipping

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

The report covers the opening day of the trial, describing the courtroom scene and detectives present before summarizing prosecutor Moody's opening statement. Moody outlined the Borden family history, the inheritance dispute, and alleged hostility between Lizzie and her stepmother, including a quoted remark calling her 'a mean, spiteful thing.'

New-York Tribune · 7 June 1893 · page 11

The words of this article are printed with the report it shares its clipping with. Read them there or in the clipping.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

Prosecutor Moody outlines evidence of family discord between Lizzie and her stepmother, including the prussic acid purchase attempt and Lizzie's foreboding conversation with Alice Russell the night before the murders. He also presents house plans to the jury.

New-York Tribune · 7 June 1893 · page 11

Upon the dav preceding the homicide John V. Morse came to the Bordens to visit them. He «l'pt ther Wednesday night, Om Tuesday night an lness o curred in the household, Mr. and Mrs. Borden and

See the clipping

The Morning News · Savannah, Ga.

The trial of Lizzie Borden opened in a packed New Bedford courtroom despite intense heat, with District Attorney Moody giving a powerful hour-long opening statement after the indictment was read. Only one witness was heard before court adjourned early so the jury could travel to Fall River to inspect the Borden premises.

The Morning News · 7 June 1893 · page 1

LIZZIE BORDEN IN THE DOCK. The Court Adjourns Early to Let the Jurors Inspect the Premises. New Bedford, Mass., Juno o.—Not withstanding tho excessively hot weather,

See the clipping

The Morning News · Savannah, Ga.

The report announces the start of Lizzie Borden's trial for the ax murders of her father and stepmother, noting the evidence is purely circumstantial. It recaps the discovery of the bodies, the presence of only Lizzie and a servant in the house, and speculation about a motive involving her father's will.

The Morning News · 7 June 1893 · page 4

The Borden Murder Case. What promises to be a remarkable murder trial was begun yesterday. It is that of Lizzie Borden at Fall River, Mass. The accused is a woman of about 32 years of age. She is accused of having m urdered her father and step-mother with an ax. The murder was committed Aug. 4,1892. The evidence against Miss Borden is wholly circumstantial, and it is not very convincing. The dead body of Mr. Borden was found in the sitting room of his home and that of Mrs. Borden in a room up stairs.

See moreSee less

The only other occupants of the house were Lizzie Borden and a servant girl. Lizzie Borden discovered tho bodies, or pretended to discover them, and gave the alarm. The servant girl who was in the house all the morning heard no unusual noise in the rooms in which the murdered man and woman were found. The case is surrounded with mystery. Many believe Lizzie Borden is innocent.

See the clipping

The Indianapolis Journal · Indianapolis, Ind.

The trial began with jury selection the prior day, and Prosecutor Moody opened for the state by recounting details of the double murder and tensions within the Borden household. Lizzie Borden appeared overcome and fainted near the end of his address, requiring smelling salts and ice before she recovered; the state then called its first witness.

The Indianapolis Journal · 7 June 1893 · page 1

LIZZIE BORDEN PAINTED.

Prosecutor's Recital of the Crime. New Bedford, Mass., June 6. The trial of Miss Lizzie Iorden began in earnest this morning. Yesterday the jury was selected. To-day, after the indiotments had been read to the twelve men, Prosecutor Moody opened for the State. , lie said that it was bis purpose to pat the story of the crime before the jury in thet simples! possible manner. He then briefly" ran over the do tails of tho doublemurder, dwelling upon the narrow life of the inmates of tho Borden family, and relating many inci dents tending to show that ill feeling had existed for yeaia between the prisoner and her stepmother.

See moreSee less

From the middle until tho end of the address Miss Borden leaned baok in her. chair and never moved a muscle. She put the fan up over her lace and, holding her head forward, pressed it close against her forehead and held it there. Her eyes were closed and stie appeared as if asleep. Not by auy means did she betray that she was conscious of what waa going on about her. Just as Mr. Moody had 'ceased to speak and taken one step forward toward his eeat there was a noise where Miss Borden was sit tin a. She bad fainted. The Kev. Mr. Jubb hurried over to her and placed a bottle of smelling salts to her nostrils. Deputy bherilf Kirby and another ollicer hurried after cracked ice. The woman's face grew white. The otlicers re turned with ice in a moment and a couple of minutes: later Miss Borden began to re cover. The case was opened by the gov ernment putting on its first witness in the

See the clipping

The Indianapolis Journal · Indianapolis, Ind.

During the prosecution's opening statement detailing family discord, Lizzie Borden fainted and had to be revived with smelling salts and ice. The trial then began with testimony from civil engineer Thomas Kiernan, followed by a jury visit to the Borden house and other crime scene locations.

The Indianapolis Journal · 7 June 1893 · page 1

LIZZIE BORDEN FAINTED.

Ferson ot Thomas Kiernan. civil engineer, lo minutely described the Borden house and its surroundings. Court was then ad journed until to-morrow in order that the jury might visit the scene of the crime. When the jurymen arrived at Fall River. They were taken at once to the Borden house. Plans of the premises and surroundings were taken along. After carefully examining the Inner part of the house a survey of the outside was made afterwards. Dr. Bowen's Jbouse and other points figuring on the trial were shown and looked over.

See moreSee less

Passing to Third street, considerable time was spent in urowe's tetone yards, where masons wcro at work at the time the murder is al leged to have been committed, and the position and distance of the porch in Dr. Chagnon s bouse, where the Doctor's daughter was seated at the time of thu murder, was also noted. Every place men tioned in the story of the crime, including me union nanic, was visiieu.

See the clipping

The Indianapolis Journal · Indianapolis, Ind.

A literary commentary piece on Mary Wilkins's fiction uses the Lizzie Borden case as a real-life example of repressive, frugal New England family life. It notes her trial has just begun and speculates that monotony and poor diet might explain a 'sudden development of ferocity,' while stating there is no proof she committed the murder.

The Indianapolis Journal · 7 June 1893 · page 4

Puritanic hardness which haa not been eliminated by time, makes possible those peculiar happenings on which the stories mentioned aro based, and also accounts for the remarkable conditions brought to public notice by the tragedies of real life. Such events prove that the narrow lives described by the writers mentioned are not confined to rural districts only, but are found ia the larger towns. The case of Lizzie Borden, whose trial for the murder of her parents has just begun, is & case in point. Miss Dorden's father waa a rich man.

See moreSee less

a retired undertaker, with numerous investments in mill properties, street railways and other enterprises paying good dividends. Ills only interest in life, apparently, was in piling up dollars, and to this end he and his family lived without the enjoyment of any of the luxuries and pleasures that money would buy. Their daily faro, as described by the' servant girl, was of a sort that the poorest day laborer in this part of the country would be inclined to reject. In the cupboard on the morning of the .murder were mutton soup and cold mutton. "Warm them over," said Mrs. Horde n to the cook, "warm them over, but bo nuro to save enough for dinner." Tho Borden girls wero over thirty years old, and had none of the privileges

See the clipping

The Wichita Daily Eagle · Wichita, Kan.

Prosecutor Moody opens the case against Lizzie Borden, arguing she killed her parents due to strained family relations, causing her to faint in court. The first witness, civil engineer Thomas Kernan, describes the Borden house before court adjourns for a jury visit to the crime scene.

The Wichita Daily Eagle · 7 June 1893 · page 1

THE BORDEN TRKL. NewBedfokd, Mass., June C At the opening of Lizzie Borden's trial today the space allotted 10 spectators was occupied almost exclusively by women. Intense in terest is manifested in every detail of the c.ise. The jury were in their seats at S:55 o'ciock, Court was opened at 9 o'clock, and after the jury was charged Attorney Moody, for the prosecution, opened the case, lie said that the state .proposed to show that Lizzie Borden committeed the crime, and that the motive was a desire to get rid of her parents, with whom her re lations had been unpleasant and disagree able From the middle to the end of the open ins address Miss Borden leaned back in her chair and never moved a muscle.

See moreSee less

Just ns Mr. Moody had ceased to speak there was a noise where Miss Borden was hit ting. She had fainted. Jtev. Mr. Jndd hurried to her and placed a bottle of smel ling: salts to her nostrils and a couple of moments later Miss Borden began to recover. The first witness for the government was Thomas Kernan, a civil engineer. He minutely described the Borden house and its surroundings. Court then adjourned until tomorrow, in order that the jury might visit the scene of the crime.

See the clipping

The Evening Bulletin · Maysville, Ky.

At New Bedford, the jury was sworn and the indictments read against Lizzie Borden as the trial began. Prosecutor Moody opened the government's case, describing the double murder and alleging long-standing ill feeling between Borden and her stepmother.

The Evening Bulletin · 7 June 1893 · page 4

LIZZIE BORDEN'S TRIAL. The Jury Sworn In unit Government's ' Case Opened. New Bedford, Mass., Juno C Early in the morning Miss Lizzie Bor den and the jury were in their seats,

See the clipping

Der Deutsche Correspondent · Baltimore, Md.

The report describes the start of Lizzie Borden's long-awaited murder trial in New Bedford, with jury selection taking until 5 PM. It also recaps the August 4 double murder of Andrew and Abby Borden, naming the household members present that day, including Bridget Sullivan, Emma Borden, and John V. Morse.

Der Deutsche Correspondent · 7 June 1893 · page 1

Lizzie Borden's Prozeß. Der berühmte Rechtsfall. Interessante Rekapitulation der mit der Ermordung des Ehepaares Borden verknüpften Umstände.

Wie seinerieiis ausführlich birichtel, wurde am 4. August v. I. in Fall-River im Hause de wohlhabenden Kaufmannes und Gruud eigenthümers Andrew I. Borden ein scheuß licher Doppelmord verübt. Borden selbst und seine Gattin zweiter Ehe, Abbey D. Borden, wurden am Vormittag des genann ten Tages mit zerschmetterten Schädeln in verschiedenen Zimmern als Leichen aufge funden. Zur Zeil des Mordes befanden sich im genannten Hause außer den Ermor deien selbst, die zweite Tochter Borden'S au erster Ehe, die nunmehr 32 Jahre alte L-zzie D. Borden und das Dienstmädchen Bridget Sullivan. Die ältere Tochter Bor den'S, Emma L.

See moreSee less

Borden, befand sich zur Zeit in New-Bedford und auch der zur Zeit im Borden'schen Hause zum Besuch weilende Schwager Borven's, John V. Morse, war im Lause oes Vormittags von Hause abwe send. Gegen 10 Uhr Vormittags verließ, soweit bisher festgestellt wurde, Andrew I. Borden das Haus, um, wie gewöhnlich, einen Ge schäftsgang zu unternehmen, vom dem er nach Aussagen der Sullivan, die ihm die Thüre öffneie, um 10 Uhr 20 Minnlen nach Hause zurücklehne. Bolden begab sich di rekt nach dem Wohnzimmer, wahrend das genannte Tienstmädchen, wie sie behauptet, nach ihrem im oberen Stockwerke des Hau ses belegenen Zimmer ging, um sich einen Augenblick auszuruhen. Wo Lizzie und Frau Borden sich zur Zeit im Hause befan den, kann die Sullivan nicht angeben., Etwa nach Ablauf einer halben Stunde wurde die Sullivan angeblich durch den Ruf Lizzie's aufgeschreckt, dli ihr Mli erregter Stimme von unien herauf zurief, >hr Barer sei ermordet. Tie Sullivan eilte nun her unter und fand die Leiche Anorew I. Bor den'S mit zerschmettertem Schädel auf einem Sopha des Wohnzimmers liegend, wäh rend die Umgebung der Leiche mit Blut be spritzt war. Auf die Bitte Lizzie's lief die Sullivan nun nach dem in der Nähe wohnenden Tr. Bowen, den sie nicht zu Hause fand, der sich aber bald darauf einstellte. Als man nun nach Frau Borden suchie, fand man dieselbe ebenfalls mir zerschmettertem Schä del auf dem Fußboden ihres Schlafzim mers im oberen Stockwerke als Leiche lie gen. Im ersten Augenblicke war man natürlich geneigt, sich an die Theorie eines Raub mordes zu klammern, doch !prach gegen einen solchen der Umstand, daß nach dem Morde keinerlei Wertsachen vermißl wur den, ja selbst d>e werlhvolle Uhr und eine nichl unbedeutende Geldsumme, die Andrew Z.Borden zur Zeit bei sich trug, wurden bei seiner Leiche unberührt gefunden. Der dringende Verdacht richtete sich iiunmchr gegen Lizzie Borden, die einzige Person außer der -sitllivan, die zur Zxn des Mor des im Hause anwesend war, denn die Mög lichkeit, baß eine fremde Person in das HauS eingedrungen wäre und den Doppelmord in den verschiedenen Stockwerken des Hause verüben konnte, ohne daß Lizzie sowohl, wie das Dienstmädchen darauf ausmertiam wur den, schien von vornherein ausgeschlossen zu sein. Am 4. September v. I. wurde Lizzie Bor den von einer Jury dem Prozeßverfahren überwiesen, nachdem Richter Blaisdell in seiner Jnstrultiou an die derzeitigen Ge schworenen erklärt hatte, er fände, daß Llz zie Borden des ihr zur Last gelegieu Ber brecheus wahrscheinlich schuldig sei. Seil ihrer nach Entdeckung des Mordes erfolgten Verkostung befindet sich die Angellagte in Haft.

See the clipping

Der Deutsche Correspondent · Baltimore, Md.

This German-language report recounts the discovery of Andrew and Abby Borden's bodies with crushed skulls, describing the household's occupants and Bridget Sullivan's account of the morning. It notes that no valuables were missing, ruling out robbery, and that suspicion fell on Lizzie Borden as the only person besides Sullivan in the house at the time.

Der Deutsche Correspondent · 7 June 1893 · page 1

The words of this article are printed with the report it shares its clipping with. Read them there or in the clipping.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

Der Deutsche Correspondent · Baltimore, Md.

The article reviews how robbery was ruled out in the Borden murders since valuables were untouched, focusing suspicion on Lizzie Borden as the only person present besides the maid. It notes she was bound over for trial in September after the judge found her probably guilty, then shifts to an unrelated case: the interrogation of Portuguese suspect Jose Correiro in the Bertha Manchester murder.

Der Deutsche Correspondent · 7 June 1893 · page 1

The words of this article are printed with the report it shares its clipping with. Read them there or in the clipping.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

Daily Kennebec Journal · Augusta, Me.

At the New Bedford trial, government prosecutor Mr. Moody opened the case against Lizzie Borden by reviewing the murders of Andrew and Abby Borden, the strained relations between Lizzie and her stepmother, and the family's mysterious illness two nights before the killings. He also asserted that Lizzie was the person who tried to buy prussic acid from a drugstore the day before the murders, and presented house plans to the jury.

Daily Kennebec Journal · 7 June 1893 · page 1

New Bkoioki*. Mass.. June »».—At # 55 Miss Borden and the jury were in their seats and the counsel were on band, bn»ilv arranging their paper*. Doors were opened to spectators at about that time ami at least a third of those that entered were females. The jury heard the indictments against Mis* Borden read a* soon a* court wa* for mally Opened arid were charged as "Good men and true, stand together and hearken to the evidence." Mr. Moody then stepped to the railing and opened tbe government’s case. He reviewed the facts of the murder of Andrew Borden and his wife on the fourth of August last, dwelt upon the relation* that existed between Lizzie Borden and her Htcpmotlier.

See moreSee less

and the unkindly feei ng that the division of property caused between them. Moody described the sudden illness of Andrew Borden, his wife and Lizzie on the Tuesday night preceding tin* fatal Thurs day, while Bridget Sullivan, servant, was not affected in any way. { 11 He cited the statement of Miss Borden made to a friend on the evening before the murders were committed, to the effect that she. Miss Burden, felt greatly depressed and feared something was going to happen. He also said that there »»* no doubt that the person who called at tin drug store on the day before the murders ami asked for prussic a«-i*l was Miss Bor den. Moody then produced the plans of the Borden house ami the Ideality and de scribed them minutely to the jury. He described tinlocation of the room* occupied bv Mr. ami Mrs. Borden, by Liz zie and by Kmma, her sister. Mr. Morse stopped at the Borden house one night pre ceding the tragedy. It is important. Moody said, to show who occupied the house that night He said it would be proved that on the night preced ing the murder, the front door, back door and cellar door were all profwrly fastened, and that when the only occupant* of the house that night. Mr. and Mr*. Borden. Lizzie, Kmma. Bridget Sullivan ami Mr Morse bad retired, every exterior approach wa* closed. lie detailed the movement of those in the Borden household on the following morn ing. Mrs. Borden, about 1> o'clock, had spoken to Bridget about cleaning sonic win dows. Mrs. Borden then went upstairs to put some pillow cases on the bed in the spare room. She never left lo-r room alive again, for no living person saw her alive again, except the assassin. When prepar ing to wash the windows, Bridget went to the back door and saw the prisoner there. The prisoner went into the house. In w ashing the windows, Bridget saw neither Mrs. Borden nor the prisoner during all the time she wa* at work. While at work sin heard Mrs Borden at the front door. It was about 10.45. She went to the door anil found it locked and bolted contrary to custom in thai house. She came in and made the remark about the door, whereupon the prisoner from the ball above made some laughing exclamation. At that time Mrs. Borden's body lay above, dead, probably, more than an hour. The prisoner asked her fatln-r for the mail, saying at the same time : "Mrs. Borden i gone out; she had a note and lias gone in answer to it.” , That was a He to stifle inquiry. Tin prisoner got an Ironing board and went t« work, and then told Bridget, who was again washing the windows, the falsehood about tin note. She told Bridget to be careful about the doors a* she might g*. out. Bridg -t later went upstairs and there wa not'-ii • more until the alarm. The p'is oner «as the last jn-rson left with her father alive Moody here described Lizzie’* move ment* and statements when Mr. ami Mrs. Borden's bodies were discovered. She went to her own room without one* going to look at the murdered woman ami changed her dress. She told different stories as to her finding of the body of her father. No blood was found on the elotliing said t > lie worn by-the prisoner that morning, except one minute spot on the skirt. The dress worn when Mrs. Churchill arrived at the house was not the one the prisoner had on early that morning. An officer, it will be proven, soon after the alarm, saw Dr. Bowen doing something at the stove. The officer looked in and *aw what appeared to be a large roll of burned paper. Dr. Bowen. Mr. Moody said, had expressed the belief at the time that Mrs. Borden had died of fright. On Sunday morning Lizzie burned a dress in the stove which she said was all covered w ith paint. Next day Kmma said to Lizzie : “I’m afraid the burning of that ilrers was the worst thing you could h ive done," and Lizzie replied. “Oh why did yon let me do it." Moody alluded to the hatchets held by the government, the blade of one of wbi -h was 3 I-2 inches wide, the exact measure ment of either of the wounds of Andrew Borden. Tbe court ha* adjourned until tomorrow to allow the jury to go to Kail Kiver ami view the scene of the tragedy. At the close of the opening argument Mi** Borden had fallen back in her seat completely exhausted. Her counsel. Mr. Jennings, and one of her clerical friend*, administered relief in the form of smelling salts ami water.

See the clipping

Daily Kennebec Journal · Augusta, Me.

Prosecutor Moody outlines the government's case, citing family tensions, the mysterious prior illness of the household, and Lizzie's alleged attempt to buy prussic acid. He details the household's movements on the morning of the murders, including Bridget Sullivan's discovery of Mrs. Borden's locked door and Lizzie's claim that Mrs. Borden had left to answer a note.

Daily Kennebec Journal · 7 June 1893 · page 1

THE BORDEN TRIAL

The words of this article are printed with the report it shares its clipping with. Read them there or in the clipping.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

Daily Kennebec Journal · Augusta, Me.

This report covers prosecutor Moody's opening statement at trial, detailing Bridget Sullivan's testimony, Lizzie's inconsistent statements, the locked door, and the burned dress. It also describes physical evidence including a hatchet matching the wound dimensions and notes the jury's visit to the crime scene.

Daily Kennebec Journal · 7 June 1893 · page 1

THE BORDEN TRIAL

The words of this article are printed with the report it shares its clipping with. Read them there or in the clipping.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

The Portland Daily Press · Portland, Me.

The report describes the second day of the Lizzie Borden murder trial, including the reading of the indictment and jury roll call. It mentions District Attorney Moody's opening statements, testimony about a burned dress, and the skulls of the victims being brought into court though not displayed.

The Portland Daily Press · 7 June 1893 · page 1

BRING THE SKULLS.

Fall River. New Beeford Court House, June 6.— Lizzie Borden was promptly in her seat this morning a full five minutes before the coming of the court, and the ringing of the bell anounced the opening of the second day of the great trial. The jurors followed immediately upon her advent. They appeared to have passed a comfort able night in spite of the heat, and were not at all haggard. The jladies put in an appearance this morning quite early, among them the little veiled lady of Fall River police court room’s cherished memory.

See moreSee less

Mrs. Charles E. Barnes was the only lady within the bar, the remaining fair ones filling the left witness box as the fore noon progressed with a maze of bright contrasting colors in the pretty array of smart summer gowns. The court was received with proper honors. Clerk Simeon Borden called the roll of the jury. Ascertaining that no juror had dropped out of the panel during the night or melted away in the perspiring temperature, he proceeded to read with great solemnity the bill of indictment returned by the grand inquest. His closing injunction was impressive. “To each of the counts in this indictment, gentlemen, Lizzie Andrew Borden, the prisoner at the bar, has heretofore

See the clipping

The Portland Daily Press · Portland, Me.

District Attorney Moody opened the case for the Commonwealth, outlining evidence including family tensions over property, the household's mysterious illness before the murders, and testimony that Lizzie Borden sought to buy prussic acid the day before. He also described the locked house and movements of household members on the morning of the killings.

The Portland Daily Press · 7 June 1893 · page 1

He reviewed the facts of the murder of Andrew Borden and wife on the 4th of August, dwelt upon the relations that existed between Lizzie Borden and her stepmother, and the unkindly feeling that the division of the property caused between them. Mr. Moody described the sudden illness of Andrew Borden, his wife and Lizzie on the Tuesday night preceding the fatal Thursday, while Bridget Sullivan, the servant,” was not affected in any way. He cited the state ment of Miss Borden, made to a friend on the evening before the murders were committed, to the effect that she, Miss Borden, felt greatly depressed and feared something was going to happen.

See moreSee less

He also said there was no doubt that the person who called at the drug store on the day before the murders and asked for prussic acid was Miss Borden. Mr. Moody then produced the plans of the Borden house and locality, and de scribed them minutely to the jury. He described the location of the rooms occupied by Mr. and Mrs. Borden, by Lizzie and by Emma, her sister. Mr. Morse stopped at the Borden house on the night preceding the tragedy. It is important, Mr. Moody said, to show who occupied the house that night. He said it would be proven that on the nig lit preceding the murder, the front door, back door and cellar door were all prop erly fastened and that when the only oc pnnflntc rtf fVio Iiaiico An nirrlit Mr and Mrs. Borden, Lizzie, Emnja, Bridget Sullivan and Mr. Morse had retired, every exterior approach was closed. He detailed the movements of those in the Borden household on following morning. Mrs. Borden about 9 o’clock spoke to Bridget about cleaning some windows. Mrs. Borden then went up stairs to put some pillow cases on the bed in the spare room. She never left that room alive again, and no living person saw her alive again, except the assassin. When pre paring to wash windows Bridget went to the back door and saw the prisoner there. The prisoner went into the house. In washing the windows Bridget saw neither Mrs. Borden nor the prisoner during all that time she |was at work. While at work she heard Mr. Borden at the front door. It was about 10.45. She went to the door and found it locked and bolted contrary to custom in that house. He came in and made a remark about the door. Whereupon the prisoner from the hall above made some laughing exclama tion. At that time Mrs. Borden’s body lay above dead, probably more than an hour. The prisoner asked her father for the mail, saying at the same time, “Mrs. Borden is gone out. She had a note and has gone in answer to it.” That was a lie to stifle inquiry. The prisoner got the ironing board and went to work and then told Bridget, who was again washing the windows the falsehood about the note. She told Bridget to be careful about the doors as she might go out. Bridget later went up stairs and there was nothing more until the alarm. The prisoner was the cnlv person left with her father alive. Mr. Moody described Lizzie’s move ments and statements when Mr. and Mrs. Borden’s bodies were discovered. She went to her own room without once go ing to look at the murdered woman and changed her dress. She has told differ ent stories as to her reason for going in to the barn and as to her finding the body of her father. No blood was found on the clothing. 6aid to have been worn by the prisoner that morning, except one minute spot on the skirt. The dress she wore when Mrs. Churohill arrived at the house was not the one the prisoner had on early that morning. An officer, it will be proven, soon after tho alarm, saw Dr. Bowen do

See the clipping

The Portland Daily Press · Portland, Me.

District Attorney Moody outlined to the jury the movements of the Borden household on the morning of the murders, emphasizing Lizzie's opportunity and suspicious behavior. He detailed her false claim about a note summoning Mrs. Borden, inconsistent stories about finding her father's body, and the lack of blood on her clothing except one small spot.

The Portland Daily Press · 7 June 1893 · page 1

The words of this article are printed with the report it shares its clipping with. Read them there or in the clipping.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

New Ulm Review · New Ulm, Minn.

The report states that jury selection has begun in the trial of Lizzie Borden, accused by the state of murdering her father and stepmother. It notes the case is already famous and that top legal talent has been engaged.

New Ulm Review · 7 June 1893 · page 2

N E W E O Mass., 6.—The of selecting a in the case of the state against Lizzie Borden for the of her father a stepmother has begun. Th case is already famous and promises to become even more so. he best legal talent of the state is en gaged in the case S to E is E, la. 6.—The corner stone of the Catholic church of La motte IS miles from Dubuque was laid by Archbisho Hennessey. a Tolton of Chicago, he only colored Catholic priest in the country delivered* an address. Fined he is

See the clipping

Morris Tribune · Morris, Minn.

This fragment consists of the headline 'Lizzie Borden on Trial' alongside a New Bedford dateline, indicating the trial proceedings were underway. No further substantive details are included in this portion of the clipping.

Morris Tribune · 7 June 1893 · page 4

Word Comes From Minister Baker to the Mate Department. "WASHINGTON, June 2.—A dispatch has been received at the state department from Minister Baker dated Messaya, June 1, stating that peace is restored at Nicaragua and the new government has gone into operation. Lizzie Borden on Trial.

See the clipping

Morris Tribune · Morris, Minn.

The report states that jury selection has begun in the trial of Lizzie Borden for the murder of her father and stepmother. It notes the case has already become famous and that top legal talent in Massachusetts is involved.

Morris Tribune · 7 June 1893 · page 4

Lizzie Borden on Trial. NEW BEDFORD, Mass., June 6.—The work of selecting a jury in the case of the state against Lizzie Borden for the murder of her father and stepmother has begun. The case is already famous, and promises to become even more so. Tho best legal talent of the state is en gaged in the case.

See the clipping

Mower County Transcript · Lansing, Minn.

The report announces that jury selection has started in New Bedford, Massachusetts, for the trial of Lizzie Borden, accused of murdering her father and stepmother. It notes the case's growing fame and the prominent legal talent involved.

Mower County Transcript · 7 June 1893 · page 6

Lizzie Borden on Trial. NEW BEDFORD, Mass., June 6.—The work of selecting a jury in the case of the state against Lizzie Borden for the murder of her father and stepmother has begun. The case is already famous, and promises to become even more so. The best legal talent of the state is en gaged in the case.

See the clipping

The Helena Independent · Helena, Mont.

A sarcastic editorial note remarks that Lizzie Borden's refusal to plead insanity will please critics of circumstantial evidence and detectives. The comment is part of a broader satirical roundup of current events and political jabs.

The Helena Independent · 7 June 1893 · page 4

temperature. Helena. Jun 6. 185s. BY giving the run to newly arrived criminals, the .police department and Sheriff Curtis are daily earning new laurels. Now that the impeached officials of Nebraska have been acquitted, we rise ask whether Editor Rosewater knows where he is at. LET's get down to hard work on the Montana exhibit for the World's fair in 1993. Let us then have fewer salaries and more Montana. IF Messrs. Gay and Gross will come to Helena, we will promise a reception that will remind their friends of old times in Alder gulob.

See moreSee less

THE refusal of Lizzie Borden to plead insanity will be greeted with much joy by those manufacturers of circumstan tial evidence, commonly called detec tives. In his search for a summer resort, we desire to remind the president that Montana has the best fishing, the beset air and the smallest number of office seekers. THAT investment of $50,000 for the Briggs trial is already followed by ru mors of uneasiness and lack of confi dence in one of the oldest institutions of the religious world. WITH a plentiful supply of cracked ice and palm leaf fans near the editorial desk we think the Inter Mountain will be able to last through the hot weather end of the capital fight. THE reciprocity convention at St. Paul affords a good excuse for a social gathering, but its objects will be looked after when a democratic congress gets to work on tariff reform.

See the clipping

The Beatrice Daily Express · Beatrice, Neb.

The trial of Lizzie Borden, charged with murdering her father and stepmother, began at New Bedford, Massachusetts on the previous Monday. The report notes the case's deep mystery and anticipates the prosecution will need to explain the nine-month delay in bringing the accused to trial.

The Beatrice Daily Express · 7 June 1893 · page 2

The trial of Lizzie Borden, who is charged with the murder of her father and stepmother, was commenced at New Bedford, Mass., Monday last. No

See the clipping

The North Platte Tribune · North Platte, Neb.

The trial of Lizzie Borden for the murder of her father and stepmother opened in New Bedford with Attorney Moody's statement for the prosecution. He detailed the crime and cited evidence of long-standing ill-will between Lizzie and her stepmother.

The North Platte Tribune · 7 June 1893 · page 1

For the Prosecution. New Bedford, Mass., June G. The trial of Lizzie Borden for the murder of her father .and stepmother in Fall River began with the statement of the .case on behalf of the commonwealth by Attorney Moody, who rehearsed the details of the crime as already told in these dispatches. He related manv instances to show that ill-will had long existed between Lizzio and her stepmother.

See the clipping

Paper unidentified

The editorial comments that the Lizzie Borden trial is now underway, calling the alleged murders of her father and stepmother among the most horrible crimes in the nation's history. It states the evidence is not convincing of her guilt, and notes that no one else has yet been publicly connected to the murders.

Paper unidentified · 7 June 1893 · page 2

WEDNESDAY, JUNE 7, 1893. Tiie Lizzie Borden trial is now on. The crime of which she is accused— the murder of her father and of her step mother, is one of the most hor rible, if committed by her, in the annals of this country. The evi dence is by no means convincing that she is guilty, and yet so far no one else ha 3 been connected in the public mind with the murder.

See the clipping

Weekly Union · Manchester, N.H.

The article reports that jury selection has begun for Lizzie Borden's trial, noting the difficulty of finding impartial jurors given the case's notoriety. It argues the evidence presented at the preliminary hearing was too weak to justify conviction, suggesting a possible wrongful accusation.

Weekly Union · 7 June 1893 · page 4

The Borden Trial. ~ The work of getting a jury for the trial of Lizzie Borden has begun. I seems rext to impossible that twelve fntelligent men can be found within the limits of any county in Massachusetts who have not - formed some opinion with reference to the guilt or Innocence of the accused. It 13

See the clipping

Weekly Union · Manchester, N.H.

Following a new murder in Fall River so soon after the Borden killings, this report examines whether Fall River has an unusually high homicide rate compared to other Massachusetts cities. Citing Bristol County indictment statistics from 1871-1892, it argues Fall River's share of murder indictments far exceeds its share of the county's population.

Weekly Union · 7 June 1893 · page 4

krows it and laughs at you.” AR S SR Homicidal Tendencies. The latest shocking murder 1n Fall River, Mass., following so closely upon the Borden butchery has aroused the pec ple of New Enpgland to serious thought.

See the clipping

Weekly Union · Manchester, N.H.

This opinion column mocks Massachusetts detectives for habitually accusing family members of murder victims before investigating further, citing the Borden case as an example. It notes wryly that Fall River police faced a new murder case before public perception of their bungling in the Borden investigation could improve.

Weekly Union · 7 June 1893 · page 4

It was unfortunate that the Fall Rlver police should have another terrible mur der case on their hands before they could be shown how bungling thelr work was in the Borden case. It is understood that tbhe curtaln has been finally drawn on the Barnaby-Graves tragedy. The doctor is out on ball, and the leport is that there will be no farther trial. Gladstone’s assallant has been adjudzed insane. Now fix the whole tory party la the same way and have no more disgrace iul sensations in the home rule agitattoa. ——— et BB e Dr. Briggs’ peculiar style of heresy must be worse than murder, since he was tried these cond time after belsg acquiited. e ——— Touching Memory of Lafayette, Philadelphia Telegram.

See the clipping

The Jersey City News · Jersey City, N.J.

The report describes the opening of the Borden murder trial, noting the large female audience and Lizzie Borden's calm demeanor. Surveyor Mr. Kieran's cross-examination focused on sightlines between the Borden and Kelly houses, including whether the barn and guest chamber could be observed from certain points.

The Jersey City News · 7 June 1893 · page 1

LIZZIE IS TRANQUIL

The Body Not Visible From the Guest Chamber. New Bedford, Mass., June 7, 1893.—At tlie opening of the Borden murder trial this morning the morbid curiosity of the female portion of the community was catered to. and nearly one half of the spectators were women. Their necks were craned one way as Miss Bordea entered the room, looking unconcerned and fresh as any one possibly coaid under suen trying circum stances. After she took her seat Mr. Jennings had a five minutes’ conversa tion with her, and she apoeared very much interested, a smile breaking out occasionally as the talk proceeded.

See moreSee less

CouD9el changed locations this morn ing so that the defense could be nearer Miss Borden. Mr. Kieran, the civil engineer who was on yesterday, was recalled the first wit ness. The cross-examination was re sumed by his pointing out the line oe tween the Borden and Kelly houses and the said line strucktwelve inches from the binge or east side of the door. The point of contact of that line with the east side of Second street as to being the point where there is the best observation, was a question which came ud for discussion between counsel and Court, Couusel for fln#«noA AAntanilsil Hint I bawa woo nr. nocrT of going into tbis with the witness, as the jury had seen the place, but the question was allowed, and the auswer was that witness thought it was. POINTS OF VIEW.

See the clipping

The Jersey City News · Jersey City, N.J.

A surveyor described measurements of lines of sight between the Borden and Kelly houses, including obstructions like a clinging plant, fences, and a shed near the barn. He also testified about a closet in the front hall that could completely conceal a person when closed, demonstrating this by having a man hide inside.

The Jersey City News · 7 June 1893 · page 1

POINTS OF VIEW. He had made observations at other points in the vicinity of the line referred to. To lose sight of the barn door he had oaly to go south of the line. By going nert.h a few inches sight would also be lost. At the point of contact, nt the southeast corner of the Bordeu honse, there is a clinging plant which obstructs the view from any point in the vicinity of Second street. There is a fence at the front of toe Kelly yard, but witness did not thiDk that obstructed the view.

See moreSee less

Tpere is a par tition fence between the Kelly and Borden yarns, which nt the 'rout, near Second street, is four feet ten inches high. It is a picket fence. Next east is a shed, anti beyoud that to the enst a high board feoce, six feet high. aud that forms the boundary between the Borden yard and a yard which is part of Dr. Kelley’s property. Mr. Ciowe occupies the premises, but witness could not sny whether it was sometimes called Crowe’s yard or not. On the east side of the Bor den premises there is a six feet board fence; on the north side, beglunlug at the street there is a low board fence runuing back about as far as the east side of ths Buffington house, to a well house, which stands dose to the Borden Darn. There ic a frout doer on tne Borden barn (not on plan). Witness was asked to give dimen sions, but the court slated -that it was unnecessary. The door was on the soutn end of the wsst side of the bam. A plau of the cellar of the Bordeu house was next shown. A LURKING PLACE.

See the clipping

The Jersey City News · Jersey City, N.J.

A witness detailed precise measurements of the bed, bureau, sofa, and blood spot locations at the Borden house, testifying that a body on the floor could not be seen from the stairs. A photographer then testified about photographs taken of the premises and the victims' bodies, submitted as evidence.

The Jersey City News · 7 June 1893 · page 1

COULD THE BODY BE SEEN.

stayed. The iront door of the Borden house was noticed by witness, but could notBav how it was hUDg. The fences between the Borden and Crowe lots have barbed wire on the title, all of the back fences have barbed wire ou them at the top. Did not notice auy atthe bottom. Witness said he took tue location of wnat were shown him as blood spots by Dr. Dolan ou August 16. There were some ou the kitebeu door, 8 feet and 6 inches from the spot where Mr. Borden's head was said to have lain.

See moreSee less

It was on tne side of the door; it Whs on the architrave ot the door, or the side casing; there was one ou the dining room door, also ou the casing, 12>4 inches from the floor, the other U]4 There was none poiuted out to him ou the ceiling of tbe sluing room. PHOTOGRAPHS IN EVIDENCE.

See the clipping

In the story →

The Sun · New York, N.Y.

During the trial's opening statements, Lizzie Borden fainted in the courtroom without anyone initially noticing. The district attorney's opening speech revealed two surprises: that Lizzie Borden had burned a dress after the murders, and that a handleless hatchet matching the victims' skull wounds had been found on the property.

The Sun · 7 June 1893 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

LIZZIE BORDEN SWOONED. SHE FAINTED BEHIND HER FAN, AND IT WAS UNOBSERVED.

It was at a Critical Time in the Arraignment of Her as a Murderess—The Court Officer and Others Thought She Had Dropped Off to Sleep—When Her Arm was Shaken it was Seen that She was Unconscious—Two Surprises Disclosed in the Opening Speech of the District Attorney—Lizzie Borden Burned a Certain Dress After the Murder, and a Hatchet Without a Handle Has Been Found on the Place Which Fits the Skulls of the Victims. NEW BEDFORD, June 6.—Miss Lizzie Bordon fainted in court to-day, and thus brought into clearer view the singular and awful misery of her position. There she sat and is to sit for weeks, alone in the open middle of the court room, as nearly like a pilloried criminal as it is possible for a woman to be, now that there are no actual pillories. Whatever she may have done she is a woman, a being who for thirty-two of the thirty-three years of her life pursued the quiet and sheltered routine of a maiden of good family and comfortable circumstances in a little town. She was wholly respectable all her life, with respectable surroundings, family, and friends, and with the gentle but invulnerable guardianship that comes to such a daughter in such circumstances. Her rounds are even narrower and quieter than those of most girls of her degree. If she is guilty, she must now be suffering the torture of dreadful anxiety, as well as remorse, for remorse is certainly the portion of such a creature. If she is innocent, fancy the horror of her plight, seated there as the most public and notorious character in New England, and listening to the minutest details and the most complete description of the crime that she was the first to discover and that bereft her of her father.

See moreSee less

The strain which her situation produces on intelligent minds is felt by all who are connected with the court. They admit it. They talk of Hester Prynne and Jeannie Deans and of other women whose fearful experiences are suggested by this girl's misery.

But though Miss Borden fainted to-day her nerve is questioned by no one. Of a phlegmatic nature she sits like a graven image by the hour, except for the motion of the hand which plies her fan. In two days she has not been seen to alter the position she has first assumed when taking her chair each day. Occasionally she rests her head upon the rail above the back of the chair, but in the main it is only her eyes that she moves.

These reveal her intelligence and the activity of her mind. With them she sees every person and movement around her, and with them she shows how intently she is listening to all that is said. There came a time to-day, when the horrors of the butcheries of her people were being described, when she would put her fan before her face. She kept it there a long time. It seemed that she had fallen asleep, for her eyes were closed. It was found that she was unconscious. She had fainted, but with no theatricalism. With the same undemonstrativeness that is her peculiarity she had yielded to more than she could endure. One thing is certain, she has no art. Another is that her conduct is as consistent with innocence as with guilt.

The court room was not above two-thirds full and yet the imitation New York policeman at the gate seemed to have no crowd to battle with. The community is evidently used to this practical, business-like court, which refuses to recognize the wishes or even the existence of those not concerned in the trial. "The people must read the papers," says the Sheriff, and down in the town the people resignedly echo the remark and say: "We will have to read the papers." Thus it came that the tiny little court room only sheltered 120 persons this morning. The same dark red and light pink carnations were on the desk. The three grim and grizzled Judges sat behind them. The blue cloth and brass buttons of the swallow-tail coats of the sheriffs were again conspicuous, and the two groups of lawyers reassembled around their separate tables. Miss Lizzie Borden took her accustomed seat in the middle of the room, where fifty-eight persons could look into her face and sixty others could only see her hat and her glossy black hair. She wore the same black dress in which she appeared on the first day of the trial. Her heavy plain face, distinctly maidenly and younger than her years warrant, was lighted by a brighter sparkle in her eyes than on the first day.

The proceedings took on a funereal tone from the first and kept it to the end. Three men did nearly all the talking, and all adopted subdued, sad voices. The first lugubrious tones were those of Mr. Borden, the aged Clerk of the court, who arose to put Miss Borden to the bar in technical language and to read the bill of her indictment for the crimes with which she is charged. It was a solemn and old-fashioned document, that kept on saying to Miss Borden that she "feloniously, wilfully, and with malice aforethought did do murder." It ended by the Clerk addressing to the jury this statement: "She has before pleaded not guilty, and put herself upon her country, which country you are."

Then William H. Moody, the Essex county District Attorney, who is assisting the local attorney, arose to open the case for the Commonwealth. He walked over to the railing close in front of the jurors, and addressed them in a low and confidential manner, and a melancholy tone. In most other States he would have sought to have impressed the court room audience, but in Massachusetts the people are little considered. They must read the newspapers. Mr. Moody did not cover himself with forensic glory. He seemed very much constrained and ill at ease. He attempted to explain the complicated arrangement of the Borden house, and was very clumsy and confusing. He made no pretence of eloquence, but talked as one man might to another. Perhaps it was that he was sensitive to the delicacy of his task and did not want to be cruel or too plain with respect to the prisoner. For that he deserved great credit. He was most considerate. He ascribed all the villainy of the murder to the person he always called "the assailant." At the very end he said that the Government believes Miss Borden to be that assailant.

The general opinion here is that Mr. Moody made a stronger case against Miss Borden than the public had any knowledge of. He brought out some notable new points. He promised to prove that Miss Borden did not wear the dress at the time the neighbors arrived that she is said to have had on at the time of the murder, and he told a dramatic story of an occasion two or three days after the murder when Miss Borden tore up and put in the stove one of her best dresses. She said it was covered with paint and when her friend, Miss Russell, told her that she wouldn't tear up the dress where people might see her Miss Borden only moved back a little way out of sight from the door.

Then, again, Mr. Moody promised to prove that no person outside the family could have entered the Borden house between the night before the murder and its occurrence. Not even Mr. Borden could get into it when he came there to his death, and when his wife was already butchered up stairs.

There was a little dramatic quality to the scene when the axes and hatchets were brought in and rattled together and shown to the jury. They were the old, historic implements of the case, and, being exhibited, were set aside as of no importance. Then Mr. Moody brought out another one, the mere blade of a hatchet without a handle, and sought to impress the jury that with this the bloody deed was done.

For more than half an hour Miss Borden listened to the theories of the Government without taking her eyes off Mr. Moody, and yet without looking at him in any marked way. Her attitude and manner were those of a person at a lecture or a sermon. For a still longer time she sat with the edge of a Japanese fan in her mouth, looking now at the floor and again at the speaker. She was experiencing emotions which were not revealed in her face, for her third position was taken by putting her fan against her face and leaving it there during that part of his address in which he described the bloody deeds and drove the crime home to her. It was after he had finished that she fainted.

On the table in front of Mr. Moody was a strange collection of exhibits in the case. There were two blue dresses, a white petticoat, a valise, some parcels, a pile of large photographs, and a number of diagrams, and plans of houses and streets drawn on oiled paper, and printed in white on blue backgrounds. Mr. Moody began by saying that before the jury to-day a woman of good society, possessing a heretofore unquestioned good character, a member of a Christian church, and the own daughter of one of the victims was at that bar accused of murder. He said that Mr. Andrew Jackson Bordon, the father, was worth somewhere between $250,000 and $300,000. He had been retired from business for a number of years. He had got his property by earning and saving, and he retained the habit of saving to the close of his life. His home establishment was on what might be called a narrow scale. By his first wife he had two daughters. She died, and he married again twenty-five years before his death. Of this second marriage there was no issue. He was seventy and the second wife was about six years younger. He was a spare, thin man, somewhat tall, and Mrs. Borden was fat and short, weighing in the neighborhood of 200 pounds.

"The house in which these homicides occurred," said Mr. Moody, "had been occupied by the family for some twenty years. There came between the prisoner and her stepmother an unkindly feeling. Those who know most about that feeling, except the prisoner at the bar, are dead, and it is only possible to get glimpses of the cause and extent of that feeling. Mr. Borden had seen fit to do some benefaction for a relative of Mrs. Borden, and in consequence the daughters thought something should be done for them as an offset. The details are unimportant.

"It is significant that enough feeling arose to cause a change of feeling between the prisoner and Mrs. Borden. Up to that time she had addressed her as 'mother.' After that she ceased to do so. We shall show that some time before the murder a cloak maker at work for the family spoke of Mrs. Borden to the prisoner as her mother. 'Don't call her my mother,' said the prisoner. 'She is a mean thing, and we hate her.'

"'Don't you go to meals with her?' she was asked.

"'Yes, but we have as little to do with her as possible and stay in our own rooms as much as possible.'"

Mr. Moody said that he knew nothing more significant than another little incident. When one of the officers spoke to the prisoner while her father and mother lay where they had been felled by the blows of an assassin, the officer asked:

"When did you last see your mother?"

"She isn't my mother," said the prisoner, "she is my stepmother—my mother is dead."

Mr. Moody thought the jury would be impressed with the method of living in the Borden household. "It will appear," he said, "that though the family occupied the same house there was built up between certain members by locks, bolts, and bars almost an impassable wall. In the early part of the autumn, the elder sister was away at Fair Haven. The household that was left consisted of Mr. and Mrs. Borden and a servant who had been in the service of the family for nearly three years, Bridget Sullivan, and the prisoner. On Tuesday night an illness occurred in the household. Mr. and Mrs. Borden were taken suddenly ill with a violent retching and vomiting illness, and to a less degree the prisoner was affected. Bridget, the servant, was not. On Wednesday morning Mr. and Mrs. Borden arose feeling as they might after such an illness, and Mrs. Borden consulted a physician. On the morning of Wednesday, the day before the homicides, the prisoner went to a drug store and asked the clerk for 10 cents worth of prussic acid for the purpose of cleaning a seal skin cape. She was told that it could not be sold without a prescription, and after some little talk she went away.

"I think you will be satisfied," said Mr. Moody, "that the person who made application for this deadly poison was the prisoner. Three persons recognized her. Two of them knew her by sight, and the third recognized her at once when he saw her. On the evening of Wednesday the prisoner made a call on a friend, Miss Alice E. Russell, and we shall commend to your careful attention what occurred that evening. The prisoner had been intending to spend her vacation with a party of friends at Marion. The talk between the two started on that topic. The prisoner said that she had made up her mind to go to Marion, and had written that day that she would go. 'But,' she said, 'I can't help feeling depressed. I can't help thinking that something is going to happen. I can't shake it off. Last night we were all sick. Mr. and Mrs. Borden were quite sick and vomiting, and we were afraid we had been poisoned. The girl did not eat baker's bread, and we did, and we think it might be that.' 'No,' said Miss Russell, 'if it had been that other people would have been sick.' 'Well,' said the prisoner, 'it might have been the milk.' 'What time do you get the milk?' 'Four o'clock in the morning,' said the prisoner. 'It is light then,' said Miss Russell, 'and no one would dare to touch it.' 'Well, that's so.' said the prisoner, 'but father has been having so much trouble with the people he deals with, I am afraid something is going to happen. I expect nothing but that the house will be burned over our heads. The barn has been broken into twice.' 'Well, that was the boys after the pigeons,' said Miss Russell. 'Well,' said the prisoner, 'the house has been broken into when only Maggie (the Bordens called Bridget Sullivan Maggie) and Emma and I were there. The other day I saw a man lurking around the house and when he saw me he ran away. Father had trouble with a man about a store the other day, and they had words and father turned him out.'"

Mr. Moody seemed to be very much impressed with this story, and tried to make it as impressive as possible. Then he said he had come to the most difficult duty he had to perform. It was to describe the Borden house. It was a double tenement, intended for two families. The Bordens have occupied it all. It was on Second street, Fall River, one of the most frequented streets in the city, a street of shops and homes, and the Borden house was but a short distance from the City Hall. There was a rear yard, with a barn in it; and back of that was a high board fence, with a barbed wire stretched across the top. There were three entrances, a front door, a side door on the north side facing Mrs. Churchill's house and leading by a small entry to the kitchen, and a third door exactly in the rear leading to the cellar. The front door hall has doors out of it into the parlor and the sitting room back of the parlor. In the hall is a stairway leading up stairs. From the upper hall open three doors. The first leads to a large closet for dresses, almost large enough for a bedroom. Another leads to the guest chamber, over the parlor. In that chamber Mrs. Borden was murdered. "It is a matter to be carefully considered," said Mr. Moody, "that as you turn upon the stairs going to the second story and as you begin to face into the hall you can look into the door of the guest chamber. The third door leads into the bedroom that was occupied by the prisoner.

"When you have got into this part of the house," said Mr. Moody, "you cannot go anywhere except into the clothes closet, into the guest chamber, or into the room occupied by the prisoner. All access to the other part of the house is closed—not by the natural construction of the house, but by the way in which the house was kept."

To make Mr. Moody's long story very short: Miss Lizzie slept over the sitting room, in which her father was murdered. Miss Emma had to go through Miss Lizzie's room to get to her room. The room in which Mr. and Mrs. Borden slept also adjoined Miss Lizzie's room. There was a door between the two, but Miss Lizzie hooked it on one side and her stepmother bolted it on the other. The room of the old couple was over the kitchen, and they had to go through the kitchen and up the back stairs to get to it. The daughters went up the front stairs.

Thus what was practically a wall separated the two generations. The bolts and bars and hooks were fastened always, before, during, and after the murders. Both the old people were murdered in the front of the house, he in the sitting room, under Lizzie's bedroom, and she in the guest chamber, in front of Lizzie's bedroom.

"Who occupied the house on the night before the murder?" Mr. Moody asked. "The person who came in last was the prisoner, and she locked the front door. There are three fastenings on that door. These three fastenings were drawn by the last person in the night before. The door leading to the cellar had been closed by Mrs. Borden, and by the evidence it will be shown that that door was locked during the day of the murder. Bridget came in by the back door and locked it. So when the prisoner and Bridget came in every exit was closed. Now, in the front part of the house that night the prisoner slept in her own room. Mr. Morse, a passing visitor, slept in the guest chamber. Mr. and Mrs. Borden slept in their own room. Bridget slept in her own room in the third story. In the morning Bridget was up first. She went down stairs and into the cellar to get her fuel for building a fire. Then she went to the door and took in the milk. The rear door, I may explain, was a double door, the inside or screen door being kept fastened, while the outside door was open. When opened by Bridget the outside door was opened for the day.

Then Mr. Borden came down stairs. He went out into the yard to empty some slops and then went to the barn. Bridget saw him do that. Bridget did not see Morse until after Mr. and Mrs. Borden had taken breakfast. After breakfast Mr. Morse was first to depart. He went out at 7:45 o'clock, and Mr. Borden let him out and bolted the door behind him. Soon after Morse went away the prisoner came down stairs and began eating what passed for her breakfast in the kitchen. While she was there Mrs. Borden went up stairs, and while up stairs Bridget went out into the yard because she was sick. When she came back Mr. Borden had apparently gone down town. Mrs. Borden was dusting the dining room, while the prisoner was in the kitchen. There was some conversation, we believe, between Mrs. Borden and Bridget about washing windows, and Bridget received her directions. Mrs. Borden disappeared at about that time. It will appear that she thought the prisoner had made the bed in the spare room. She was going up to put two pillow cases on two pillows up there. On the evidence you will be satisfied she never left the room alive, and was killed a few minutes after she went up.

"No living person saw her from that time till her death except the assailant. Bridget had to go to the barn and down cellar. At the screen door, as she was about to go out, the prisoner appeared, and Bridget said she need not lock the door, 'as I am coming in to get water to wash the windows.' She got the water in the barn, but it will be shown that the door was not locked at that time. Bridget went to the dining and sitting room to close the windows and there was no one there. Bridget washed windows on three sides of the house and saw neither Mrs. Borden nor the prisoner in the lower part of the house. She was at work when she heard some one at the front door. It was Mr. Borden. He had left the house at about between 9 and half past 9 o'clock, and

(according to Mr. Moody's complicated calculation) returned at a quarter to 11 o'clock, contrary to the usual custom. He found the front door locked and bolted, as well as fastened by the spring lock. He tried to get in with his latch key, and Bridget let him in. The prisoner, from the hall, made some laugh or exclamation, and at that moment Mrs. Borden lay dead within plain view of any one who stood in just the position the prisoner stood at that time, and had been dead for more than an hour. Mr. Borden went first to the dining room, and the prisoner came in and asked if there was any mail, and said Mrs. Borden had gone out. She had got a note from somebody who was sick.

"That, gentlemen, we put to you was a lie intended for no purpose except to stifle inquiry as to where Mrs. Borden was. Mr. Borden went up his own back stairs. All that occurred after he went upstairs occurred in less time than it takes to tell it. Nothing occurred afterward except the alarm which was given. Bridget came down and was sent diagonally across the street to get Dr. Bowen, at the prisoner's request. She came back quickly and was sent to go and get Miss Russell, at some distance. Almost instinctively there leaped to the lips of every one the question that was put to the prisoner, 'Where were you?' before a thought of suspicion crossed any mind. She had been the last person left with her father alive. The first question Bridget asked was 'Where were you?' 'I was out in the back yard. I heard a groan, came in, found the door open, and found father dead.' Bridget went to the doctor's, came back, and found the prisoner standing by the screen door. There had been no screams, no alarm; simply an attempt to secure Dr. Bowen. Mrs. Churchill, the next door neighbor, saw her standing at the door. Something in her appearance attracted her and she called to her. Bridget was told by the prisoner to go down to Miss Russell, whom you will remember as being the very person to whom Lizzie had predicted that disaster was about to occur. Mrs. Churchill asks the question: 'Where were you?' and receives the reply: 'I was out in the barn to get a piece of iron.' Bridget came in and asked if she should not go for Mrs. Borden. 'No,' said the prisoner 'and in telling this Mr. Moody made his voice as impressive as possible. 'I am almost sure I heard her come in.' Up to that time there was no effort to find Mrs. Borden. 'I wish you would look and see if you can't find Mrs. Borden,' said the prisoner. Mrs. Churchill went up with Bridget, and as her head reached the level of the floor she saw the dead body on the floor."

Mr. Moody thought it regrettable that Dr. Bowen was the family physician and was so naturally affected with horror and sympathy that his trained powers of observation failed when he thought Mrs. Borden had died of fright. Miss Borden went through the sitting room, where her father was lying, went up to her room, changed her dress, put on a loose wrapper, and lay down. She told Dr. Bowen she had gone out to get a piece of iron. She told Miss Russell she went to get iron or wire. She told Officer Medley she heard a peculiar noise, something like a scraping noise, and came in and found her father dead. She told Mrs. Churchill she heard a distressing noise.

"As inquiries began to multiply as to her whereabouts, another story comes into view. It is that she went out to the barn and into the loft of the barn to get lead to make sinkers. When she tells one person that she went into the barn to get the lead and to another person she says she came back and looked at the stove to see if the fire was hot enough for her to iron, and then put down her hat and accidentally discovered the homicide, gentlemen, it isn't a difference of words. In one case she tells that she discovers the murders while about her regular duties, and in another case that she heard groans. We will ask you to remember that the 4th of August was one of the hottest days of the last summer in this locality and that the loft of the barn was stifling. Officer Medley was among the first to enter the barn after the tragedy. He had heard the story and went up stairs to the loft. He found when he had touched the floor with his hands that it was thickly covered with dust. Afterward he walked there and found that every footprint was plainly to be seen.

"It is our duty to offer proof to you that Mrs. Borden died before her husband. We have evidence that when Lizzie discovered Mr. Borden's body it showed freshly running blood, and was warm. The blood of Mrs. Borden was coagulated, and the body was stiffened in death. The judgment of professional men who examined the bodies will be presented to you. The stomachs were sent to Prof. Wood and examined and prepared with exactness. Mrs. Borden's stomach contained eleven ounces of food in the process of digestion, one-fifth of which was water and four-fifths solid matter, partly digested. Mr. Borden's stomach contained six ounces, nine-tenths water and one-tenth of solids. The upper intestines of Mrs. Borden contained partly digested food, while Mr. Borden's were empty. Mrs. Borden's lower intestines were empty, while those of Mr. Borden's contained the matter which had been digested long before noon. Upon these facts the experts have determined that Mrs. Borden died at least an hour before her husband."

When Mr. Moody reached this point the impassive prisoner, who had been holding the edge of a fan between her lips for half an hour, motioned for a glass of water. It was brought to her by a deputy sheriff, and she lowered the fan and drank lightly.

"There was blood spattered in every direction," said Mr. Moody, "and it is probable spatters would be impressed on the clothing of the assassin. The clothing has been produced for the inspection of the Commonwealth. It was produced a great many days after the homicides. The clothing said to have been worn by the prisoner on the morning of the murder, shoes, stockings, dress, and skirt, was subjected to the most rigid examination, and it failed to disclose any marks of blood on the dress, but on the skirt that examination revealed one spot of blood which I don't think it worth while to call your attention to at the present time. You have in mind that an interval elapsed while Mr. Borden was up stairs. She says the reason she left the house was that she found the fire low, and she put a stick of wood on the fire and went out to the barn to wait until it ignited. When she came back the stick was there and the fire had all gone out. It will appear, and it was by a pure accident that this observation was made soon after the alarm, that Officer Tate, attracted by something Dr. Bowen was doing to the fire—I don't mean to suggest anything, gentlemen—looked in the stove and found a large roll of what appeared to be burnt paper. Dr. Bowen will say the prisoner had on a cheap calico dress, a sort of drab-colored dress. Mrs. Churchill says Lizzie had on in the morning a dress with a light blue ground and a fixed figure in navy blue without a white spot in it at all, and on being shown that dress (the one Dr. Bowen saw) she will say it was not that dress which the prisoner wore on the morning of the homicide.

"You will recall that soon after the homicide Miss Russell and the prisoner went to the bedroom. While they were there the prisoner said: 'I think I had better have Winwood for an undertaker;' and Miss Russell went away on an errand, forbidding Dr. Bowen to attend about the undertaker. When she came back she found the prisoner with a pink wrapper on; an officer informed the prisoner that she was under suspicion, and on that night Bridget Sullivan left the house, Alice Russell staying with the prisoner. Miss Emma was then at home. On the morning of Sunday Miss Russell came into the kitchen. The officers were about, but none was in the house, and there Miss Russell saw the prisoner with the skirt of a dress on her arm and what appeared to be its waist on a shelf near her side."

At this point all in the court room listened with new interest. It was suspected that Miss Borden's close friend had been assisting the Government against her, but no one was prepared for the startling information she had given the law officers. Miss Borden seemed unmindful of the importance of the news. She looked on as calmly and imperturbably as before.

"It was a cotton dress and not a silk dress," said Mr. Moody, to distinguish it from the silk the family doctor thinks she wore. "It was a light blue dress, with fixed navy blue spots in it. You will recall Mrs. Churchill's description of it. As she saw the prisoner standing by the stove Miss Emma turned and said: 'What are you going to do?' 'I'm going to burn this dress. It is all covered with paint.' Miss Russell turned away.

"She came again into the room and found the prisoner standing with the waist of the dress, and apparently tearing it apart. She said: 'Lizzie, I would not do that where people can see me.' The only consequence of that was that the prisoner stepped a little back and went on tearing her dress."

This was brand-new evidence, and apparently much the most damaging to the prisoner of all that has been brought forward. It fell upon the ears of the people in court like a lightning flash. "On another day," said Mr. Moody, "Miss Russell said: 'Lizzie, I am afraid that burning that dress was the worst thing you could have done.' 'Oh, why did you let me do it?' the prisoner replied. A considerable search was made by the officers for weapons, and they say no clothing unconcealed and covered with paint could have escaped observation."

From that point the District Attorney took up the subject of the weapons, and announced that the Government meant to lay open all the evidence it possessed at that time. An attendant brought in two axes and two hatchets and they were shown to the jury and disposed of with an explanation showing that they could not have been the weapons with which the bloody deeds were committed. Then Mr. Moody produced his second sensational disclosure. He began by saying: "On the day of the homicide another weapon or part of a weapon was found and attracted little attention."

As he spoke the young attorney held up the handleless blade of a little hatchet of precisely the sort that is kept in almost every dwelling for chopping kindling wood. "It was covered with an adhesion of dust—not the fine but the coarse dust of ashes. This adhered to all sides of it more or less. Both sides were rusty."

It was at this point that the prisoner ceased fanning herself and put her fan to her face, hiding it from nearly all in the room. Behind her fan she closed her eyes as if she was wearied with so much monotony which she found in the proceedings. "Prof. Wood will say," the young lawyer went on, "that while the fragments of the wood of the newly broken handle would render traces of blood, that on a smooth weapon blood could be easily and effectually and completely removed." Just then Mr. Jennings, of counsel of the accused, got up, and, taking the hatchet blade in his hands, examined it carefully. "The fact," continued Mr. Moody, "unquestionably as told by the skulls of the victims is, that the weapons were sharp. Another fact is unmistakably told by Mr. Borden's skull. It is that the weapon was just exactly three and a half inches on the blade—no more and no less. That is exactly the measure of that weapon. The Government does not insist that the homicide was done with this handleless weapon. It may have been. It may well have been.

The bloody weapon was not found on or beside the victims. "You will consider whether these were the acts of a bloody villian fleeing through the streets at noonday or of an inmate of the house, familiar with its means of obliteration and concealment. Nothing was disturbed, no property was taken, no drawers were ransacked.

"Mr. Borden had on his person a considerable sum of money, as well as a watch and chain. There was nothing to indicate an assault on the woman for lustful purposes. There was not a sign of a struggle. The assailant had been able to approach each victim by daylight, and, without struggle or outcry, to lay them low. Mrs. Borden was prostrate, her face on the floor and her head hacked to pieces. Some of the blows were delivered with great force, some with vacillating weakness. Mr. Borden was reclining on a sofa in the sitting room. Apparently he passed away from life into death without a struggle, and his head, too, bore the same marks."

In his peroration Mr. Moody went hastily over the main points in his argument, and then said: "There was no other human being there except the prisoner. The acts were those of a human being, the acts of a person who must have had a familiar knowledge of the premises and whereabouts and habits of those persons in occupation of the house at that time. I ask if any other reasonable hypothesis except that of the guilt of this prisoner can account for these murders on that morning"

It was 11 o'clock when he ended his presentation of the Commonwealth's case. The black figure of the prisoner had not attracted attention during the preceding half hour.

She had been sitting with the great Japanese fan close against her face. Only the correspondent of THE SUN and the deputy sheriff beside her could see behind the fan.

Therefore the rest of the people had ceased to look at her. Behind her fan her eyes were seen to be closed. But she was not asleep, she was listening. The young lawyer had built the fine meshes of his web all around her, and had seemed to shut her up in the heart of it, alone and helpless in the presence of the bloody pictures with which he filled his discourse.

Certain movements that she made with her feet and her hands and the fact that she kept the fan before her face showed that she was awake and listening. The speech ended, the jury went out, and three of the lawyers stood up close to the Judge's bench and talked with the Chief Justice. The court had been declared adjourned, and what was going on was informal.

Two or three minutes passed and the fan and the arm that held it up dropped upon the prisoner's lap. Her head was back against the rail, her eyes were shut, her mouth was open, and her breast heaved with very long breaths.

"Lizzie Borden's asleep," was the whisper that galloped through the court room. Deputy Sheriff Kirby, who sat beside her, took friendly alarm at such disrespectful behavior, and tried to awaken her before the Court should see her. He shook her arm. He might as well have shaken a pump handle. Her head rolled over so that her cheek rested on the rail at right angles to the line of her body. A purple cast came over her face. Kindly Mr. Kirby looked alarmed and helpless. City Missionary Jubb of Fall River was sitting near by, and sprang to his feet and began to fan her.

A Deputy Sheriff came quickly with a glass of water. After a little she regained partial consciousness. Mr. Jubb ordered her somewhat sharply to find her smelling salts. Her hand went into her pocket mechanically and came out with a little cut glass bottle in it.

Then she put both hands on the arms of the chair and fell back against the railing, not half over her faint. Mr. Jubb was applying the smelling salts, and was so much in earnest that her breath went from her, and she put up her hand to push the bottle away. In another minute her eyes opened, and she heard Mr. Jubb advising her to drink some water, which she did. Sheriff Wright, in the mean time, began rapping on his desk for order. The people crept back into their seats, and the episode ended with Miss Borden leaning her head against the rail, with her eyes shut, while every one wondered whether she was going to faint again.

This was at 7 minutes past 11. The jury came back, and Mr. Moody called the first witness. He was a young Fall River civil engineer named Thomas Kieran. He was questioned about the distances between various points in Fall River, as, for instance, how far it was from the Borden house to the city hall and to the police station, and from that station to another.

It turned out that he had drawn the diagrams and house plans which were to be entered as exhibits in the case. His work now was to verify and swear to them. He was the servant of the Commonwealth, but Miss Borden's lawyers took a great deal of interest in his testimony.

When he left the stand District Attorney Knowlton moved that the jury be directed to go to Fall River and take a view, not only of the interior and exterior of the Borden house, but of such other points as it might be of value for them to see.

Gov. Robinson arose and said something to the Court about its being the right and privilege of Miss Borden to accompany the jury to Fall River. He walked over to where the prisoner sat, and talked to her for a minute.

Then he said out loud that while she was, of course, entitled to accompany the jury, she did not desire to do so. She did not feel able, and would waive all her rights. "I state this in her presence," said the ex-Governor.

"If the defendant desires to participate in the view," said the Chief Justice, "she will be permitted to do so."

He ordered the Sheriff to designate four officers to go with the jury. The Sheriff stood up in his little box and named four men with good old Yankee names.

These four, in their blue shad-bellied coats, formed a line before the jury box and held up their hands in the way that an oath is administered in Massachusetts where the Bible is not used in court. Clerk Borden swore them upon the oath that they were to allow no persons except Mr. Moody for the Commonwealth and Mr. Jennings for the defence to speak to them while they were away.

They were going to trot out with the twelve jurors when the Chief Justice made them pause.

"I desire to say," said he, "that this view is not at all for the purpose of taking testimony. You will only observe the physical objects of the view. Counsel will only direct your attention to such objects. It will not be proper for you to ask questions, or for the counsel to make any statements. You are to keep all together, and all are to see what any of you see."

The last words of the proceedings in the second day of the trial were added by the

Chief Justice: "The officers will now suffer the jury to partake of luncheon." Suffering the poor chaps to eat was a new way to put it.

Miss Borden was taken back to the jail, and there sat and chatted with the Master of the House of Correction while the noonday change of guards was being made.

Mr. Josiah Hunt, the Master, is a notable man in this place, and deserves to be for he is a true gentleman, dignified, courteous, kindly, and able. He had no idea Lizzie had swooned, and nothing in her behavior suggested it. She chose for a topic in their talk to-day the fact that she was fond of books. He offered to lend her some, but she said she had plenty and was then engaged in reading one of Charles Dickens's novels. She is very fond of Dickens, she said. She spoke heartily, and there seemed nothing the matter with her. Mr. Hunt finds her an every-day, sensible woman, not gay or lively, but calm and yet of good spirits.

No one has sent her any flowers, he says, and no women have called on her. That suggests a mention of the fact that it is said here that most of the women consider her guilty

Certainly not one has shown her a kindness in the court room, not one has sat by her or spoken to her, and to-day, when she swooned, though there were twenty-one women in the room, not one went to her or showed any concern or sympathy during the excitement.

FALL RIVER, Mass., June 6.—About 1:30 o'clock the Borden jury walked to the Borden house and were admitted with the four men who had charge of them. Also accompanying them into the house were District Attorneys Knowlton and Moody, Gov. Robinson, and Mr. Jennings.

Assistant Marshal Fleet and Lieut. Edson controlled a posse of men who had been about the house since the morning keeping back the crowds of curiosity seekers.

After the jury had examined carefully the inner part of the Borden house, a survey of the outside adjoining yard was made, the distance from the house to the fence, and the location of the lumber pile were noted, and the barn loft was visited.

The jury filed out from the yard and walked up Second street to Dr. Bowen's house and other points figuring in the trial were shown and looked over. Passing to Third street considerable time was spent in Crowe's stone yard, where masons were at work at the time the murder is alleged to have been committed, and the position and distance of the porch in Dr. Chagnon's house, where the Doctor's daughter was seated at the time of the murder, was also noted. Every place mentioned in the story of the crime, including the Union Bank, were visited. The tour was finished at 4 P. M., and the jury went to a hotel here for the night.

See the clipping

The Sun · New York, N.Y.

This report describes Lizzie Borden's stoic, nearly motionless demeanor during courtroom proceedings, noting she sits like a statue except for moving her eyes and fanning herself. It recounts that she fainted today while graphic details of the murders were being described, though observers note she shows no theatrical behavior and her reaction is consistent with either guilt or innocence.

The Sun · 7 June 1893 · page 3

suggested by this girl's misery. But though Miss Borden fainted to-day her nerve is questioned by no one. Of a phleg matic nature sho sits like a graven Image by the hour, except for the motion ot the hand

See the clipping

The Sun · New York, N.Y.

The Lizzie Borden trial resumes with a small crowd in the courtroom, and the clerk formally reads the indictment charging her with murder. District Attorney Moody then opens for the prosecution, describing the Borden house layout and referring to the unnamed killer as 'the assailant,' concluding that the government believes Lizzie Borden to be that person.

The Sun · 7 June 1893 · page 3

tones were those of Mr. Borden, the aged Clerk ot the court who arose to put Miss Bor den to the bar in technical language and to read the bill ot her Indlotment forthecrlmes with which she Is charged. It was a solemn and old-fashioned document, that kept on sav ing to Miss Borden that she feloniously, wil fully, and with malloo aforethought did do murder." It ended br tbe Clerk addressing to the jury this statement: "She has before pleaded not guilty, and put herself upon her country, which country you are." Then William II. Moody, the Essex county District Attornoy. who Is assisting the local

See the clipping

The Evening World · New York, N.Y.

The report describes the opening of the third day of Lizzie Borden's murder trial, noting courtroom details like the composition of spectators and Lizzie's demeanor. Thomas Kiernan, a civil engineer, is recalled for cross-examination regarding sight-lines between the Borden and Kelly houses.

The Evening World · 7 June 1893 · page 1

MORSE ON THE STAND, Lizzie Borden's Uncle Called by the Prosecution.

Her Counsel TbU MornlDg. NEW BEDFORD, Mass., June 7. At the opening of the third day of the Borden murder trial, this mornlnc, the morbid curiosity of the female portion of the community was catered to, and nearly one-half of the spectators were it omen. Miss Dorden entered the room look ing as unconcerned nnd fresh an any one could under such circumstances. After she took her scat, Mr. Jennings had a nvc-mlnutcs' conversation with her, and she appeared very much In terested and animated, a smile break ing out occasionally as the talk pro ofed cd.

See moreSee less

Counsel changed locations this morn ing, so that the defens. could be nciier .Miss Borden. ! Thomas Klernan, the civil engineer, who was called yesterday Just, before adjournment, was recalled for crons-ex-amtnatlon. He pointed out the line between the Borden and Kelly houses, nnd said the linn struck twelve Inches from the hinge

See the clipping

The Evening World · New York, N.Y.

Thomas Kieran, a civil engineer, was recalled for cross-examination about his survey of the Borden and Kelly properties, including sightlines, fences, and the barn door. He also testified about the front hall closet, noting that a man could fully close its door while hidden inside.

The Evening World · 7 June 1893 · page 1

thought It was. Me had made observations at other points in the vicinity of the line referred to. To lose sight of the barn-door he had only to go south of the line. By going north a few Inches slsht would nl'o be lost. At the point of contact at the southeast corner of the Borden house there Is a climbing plant which obstructs the view from any point In the vicinity of Second street. There Is a fence at the front of the Kelly yard, but witness did not think that obstructed the view.

See moreSee less

There Is a partition fence between the Kelly and Borden yards, which nt the front near Second street Is four feet ten Inches high. It is a picket fence. Next east Is a shed, and behind that to the east a high board fence, trtx feet high, and that forms the boundary be twcea the Borden yard and a yard which Is part of Dr, Kelly's property. Mr. Crowe occupies the premises, bnt wit ness could not say whether It was sometimes called Crowe's yard or not. On the east side of the BorJen prem ises there Is a six feet board fence; on the north side, beginning nt the street, there la a law board fence running back about as far ai the east side of the Bufflngton house, to a well-house which stands close to the Borden barn. There l a front door on the Borden barn (not on plan). Witness was asked to give dimensions, but the Court stated that It wib unnecessary. The door was on the south end of the west side of the bam. A plan of the cellar of the Borden house was next shown, marked "3," the previous one being "8."' When wttnesi was making measure rnints of the lower floor, his atten tion was called to the closet In the front hall of the Borden house. He was asked If his attention ws called to the fact that one could go In there and be hidden with the door completely i hut. He described It by saying a man went In and he shut the door on him. 1 There was no difficulty In closing the door. While the man was In there the door ws left ajar, and the man In the closet could not be Been by witness. Witness was eight or ten feet from the closet

See the clipping

The Evening World · New York, N.Y.

Witnesses testify about measurements of the sitting-room sofa and blood spot locations in the Borden house, and photographer James A. Walsh describes photographs taken at the crime scene. John V. Morse takes the stand and is cross-examined by Ex-Gov. Robinson about the front door's spring lock, suggesting an outsider could have entered.

The Evening World · 7 June 1893 · page 1

Illver, the next witness, said he had taken 'photographs ot the llcrdcn premises at the request of tho Government, which photo graphs were put In evidence and Identified by him. There were five of them. The views j were taken onbt-rdy last. I The witness also touk some on tho day after the homlcldo at the request of Dr. Dolan. I The one of Mrs. Borden's position was takon about 3.30 In tbe afternoon. Tho surveyor's and photographers evt. I dene being concluded at 10.10, John V. i Horse, took (be stand.

See moreSee less

At first the prisoner 1 watched him carefully with apparent anxiety, tben looked on with the same lnajSerence as heretofore. " At 10.30, on motion of the defense, all wit nesses except lieporters Manning,! stovens and Caldwell, Meesrs. Buck, Jubb and Holmes 1 and those summoned for expert evidence,

See the clipping

The Evening World · New York, N.Y.

The report describes the third day of the Lizzie Borden murder trial in New Bedford, noting the courtroom atmosphere and Lizzie's demeanor as she conversed with her attorney. It details testimony from civil engineer Thomas Kieran about sightlines between the Borden and Kelly houses, with Bridget Sullivan, the family servant, called to testify.

The Evening World · 7 June 1893 · page 1

BRIDGET IS CALLED.

NEW BEDFORD, Mass., June 7. At the opening of the third day of the Borden murder trial, this morning, the morbid curiosity of tho female portion of the community was catered to, and nearly one-half of the spectators were women. Miss Borden entered the room look ing as unconcerned and fresh as any ..ne could under such circumstances. After she took her seat, Mr. Jennings had a five-minutes' conversation with her. and she appeared very much In terested and animated, a smile break ing out occasionally as the talk pro ceeded.

See moreSee less

! t-ounsel changed locations this morn Ine. so that tho defense could be nearer Miss Borden. Thomas Kleman, the civil engineer, who was called yesterday Just before adjournment, was recalled for cross-examlnatlon. He pointed out the line between the Borden and Kelly houses, and said the line struck twelve Inches from the hinge

See the clipping

The Evening World · New York, N.Y.

Civil engineer Thomas Kieran was cross-examined about measurements and sightlines between the Borden and Kelly houses, describing fences, obstructions like a climbing plant, and the barn door's visibility. He also discussed the front hall closet, noting a person could be hidden inside with the door shut.

The Evening World · 7 June 1893 · page 1

thought it was. Ha had made observations at other points In the vicinity of the line referred to To lose sight of the barn-door he had only to go south of the line. By going north a few Inches sight would also be lott. At the point of contact at the southeast corner of the Borden house there Is a climbing plant which obstructs the vtew from any point In the vicinity of Second street. There Is d. fenco at the front of the Kelly yard, but witness did not think that obstructed the view.

See moreSee less

There Is a partition fence between the Kelly and aorden yards, which at the front near Second street la four feet ter. Inches high. It Is a picket fence. .Next east Is a shed, and behind that to the east a high board fence, six feet high, and that forms the boundary be tween the Borden yard and a yard which Is part of Dr. Kelly's property. Mr. Crowe occupies the premises, but wlt i.is cou,d not say whether it waa fometlmes called Crowe's yard or not. On the east side of the Borden prem Ifes there is a six feet board fence; on the north side, beginning at the street, there Is a low board fence running back shout as far as the east side of the Utimngton house, to a well-house which Hands close to the Borden barn. There Is a front toor on the Borden barn (not on plan). Witness was asked to give dimensions, but the Court stated that It trns iinnip.sArv. The door was on the south end of the west side of the barn. I A plan of the cellar of tho Borden house waa next shown, marked "G," the previous one being "8." When witness was making measure ments of the lower floor, his atten tion waa called to the closet In the front hall of the Borden house. Ho was asked If his attention was called

See the clipping

The Evening World · New York, N.Y.

A witness detailed measurements taken at the Borden house and of the sitting-room sofa, along with blood spot locations pointed out by Dr. Dolan. A photographer also testified about photographs taken of the premises both the day after the murders and more recently, which were entered into evidence.

The Evening World · 7 June 1893 · page 1

by l be door one-half Inch. I It was Mr. Phillips, Mr. Jennings's aasoj elate, who went into the closet to males the experiments, but witness could not tar how long bo tared. The front door ot the Borden house was noticed by witness, but could not say how It was bung. The fences between the Borden and the crone lots have barbed wire on the sides; all ot the back tenors bare barbed wire on them at tbe lop. Did not notice any . at tbe bottom. Witness said be took tbe location ot what were shown him as blood spots by 'Dr.

See moreSee less

Dolan on Aug. 18. There were some on tbe kitchen door, eight feet and six inches irom tbe spo; wbere Mr. Borden's bead was said to bare lain. It was on the side of the door; It was on the architrave of the door, or the side casing; there was a spot on tbe dining-room door, also on tbe casing, Inches from the floor, and other There was Bono polntrd out to him on the celling of the sitting-room. James A. Walsh, photographer, ot Fall Ktvcr, the next witness, said be had taken photographs oi tbe Borden premises at the request of the. Government, which photo, graphs wero put In evidence and Identified

See the clipping

The Evening World · New York, N.Y.

On the third day of the Lizzie Borden murder trial, courtroom attention turns to testimony from servant Bridget Sullivan, with Lizzie watching intently. Civil engineer Thomas Kiernan is recalled for cross-examination regarding property lines and sightlines between the Borden and Kelly houses.

The Evening World · 7 June 1893 · page 1

BRIDGET IS CALLED.

I NEW BEDFORD, Mass., June 7. At I the opening of the third day of the I Borden murder trial, this morning, tho I morbid curiosity of the female portion I of the community was catered to, and I nearly one-half of the spectators were I women, I Miss Borden entered the room look I lng as unconcerned and fresh as any I one could under such circumstances. I After she tool; her seat, Mr. Jennings I had a five-minutes' conversation with I her, and she appeared very much In I terested and animated, a smile brenk- , I lng out occasionally as the talk pro I ceeded, I Counsel changed locations this morn I lng, so that tho defense could be nearer I Miss Borden.

See moreSee less

I Thomas Klcrnan, the civil engineer, I who was called yesterday jUBt before I adjournment, wns recalled for cross-ex-I amlnatlon. I He pointed out the line between the I Borden and Kelly houses, and said the I line struck twelve inches from the hinge i

See the clipping

The Evening World · New York, N.Y.

Civil engineer Thomas Kieran, recalled for cross-examination, described the boundary lines, fences, and sightlines between the Borden and Kelly properties, including obstructions like a climbing plant and various fences. He also discussed a cellar plan and a hall closet in the Borden house that could conceal a person.

The Evening World · 7 June 1893 · page 1

I also bo lost. At the point of contact I at the southeast corner of the Borden I house thero Is a climbing plant which I obstructs the view from any point In I the vicinity of Second street. There Is I a fence at the front of the Kelly yard, I but witness did not think that obstructed I the view. I There la a partition fence between the I Kelly and Borden yards, which at the I front near Second street Is four feet I ten Inches high. It Is a picket fence.

See moreSee less

I Next east is a shed, and behind that to I the east a high board fence, six feet I high, and that forms the boundary be I tween the Borden yard and a yard which I Is part of Dr. Kelly's property. Mr. I Crowe occupies the premises, but wlt , I nesi could not say whether It was I sometimes called Crowe's yard or not. I On the east side of the Borden premI tses there is a six feet board fence; on I the north aide, beginning at the street, I there Is a low board fence running back I about as far as the east side of the I BuRlngton house, to a well-house which I stands close to the Borden barn. There I Is a front door on the Borden barn (not on plan). Witness was asked to give I dimensions, but the Courtatated that It I was unnecessary. The door was on the I south end of the west side of the barn. I A plan of the cellar of the Borden I house was next shown, marked "G," I the previous one being "8." I When witness was making measureI ments of the lower floor, his atten .1 tlon was called to the closet In the 1 front hall of the Borden house. He I was asked If his attention was called

See the clipping

The Evening World · New York, N.Y.

A surveyor described measurements of the bed, sofa, closet, and fences at the Borden house, along with locations of bloodstains noted by Dr. Dolan. A photographer then testified about photographs taken of the premises both the day after the murders and more recently, before John V. Morse took the stand.

The Evening World · 7 June 1893 · page 1

the sofa In the sitting room at the request of Doctor Dolan, and said the length w as 7 feet I 1 Inch over nil ; tbo width a feet 3 Inches ; at ! each end was a pillow or arm which was ot i cylindrical form.and between those two arms was 4 feet 11 Inches. I The sofa was against tho nail and projected by the door one-half Inch. It was .Mr. I'bllllps, Mr. Jennings's asso ciate, who went Into tho closet to make the experiments, but wltnosa could not say how long bo Hayed.

See moreSee less

The from door ot the Borden houso was noticed by witness, but could not say how It was bung. The fences tetween the Borden andtbe Crone lots have barbed wire on the sides; all ot the back fences baro barbed wire on them at the top. Bid not notlco any at the bottom. Witness said he took the location of what were shown him as Mood spots by Sr. Dolan : on Aug. 10. There were Borne on the kitchen door, eight leet and six Inches from the spot whero Mr. Cordon's head was Bald to havo lain. It was on tbo Bldo of the door; it was on the architrave of tho door, or tbe sldo casing; thcro was a spot on tho dining-room door, also on the casing, 1SJ inches from the floor, and other 14. There was none pointed out to him on the celling of tbo sitting-room. James A. Walsh, photographer, of Fall Jilrer, tbo next witness, said he had taken photographs ot the Borden premises at tho request ot the Government, whloh photo, graphs were put In cTldence and Identified by him. There were five ot them. Tbe views were taken on Saturday last. Tho witness also touk some on the day alter tbo homicide at tbe request of Dr. Dolan. The one of lira. Borden's position was taken about 3.30 In the afternoon. Tho surveyor's and photographers evl. dence being concluded at 10.10, John V. Morse took the stand. At first, the prisoner watched blm carefully with apparent anxiety, then looked on with tbe same Indifference as heretofore. At 10.30, on motion ot the defense, all wit nesses except Reporters Manning,! Stevens and Caldwell, Messrs. Buck, Jubb and Holmes and those summoned tor expert evidence, were ordered excluded from tne room. Morse said ho was now living at South Dartmouth ; had lived there nearly a year ; ho came East three years ago last April ; he was a brother of Mrs. Bor den, the first. Asked when Mr. Borden wns first mar ried, he said It was about forty-seven years ago : there were three children ; one Is dead. ; Mrs. Borden died In 1801 the child which died was younger than the others : Mr. Borden's second mar rlap he could not remember. lie said Lizzie was thirty-three and Emma forty-one years old. On Wednes day, Aug. 3, last, he went to the Bor den house. He had been a visitor thero several weeks before. The last time he saw Lizzie before that visit he could not place. He arrived at the Borden house at 1.30 on Wednesday. He did not see anybody that day but Mr. and Mrs. Borden and Bridget. He ate dinner there that day, but ate It alone. He went away be tween 8 and 4 P. M and went to Swansea, coming back on Wednesday, arriving about 8.30. That time he en tered the front door, having been let in by Mrs. Borden.

See the clipping

The Evening World · New York, N.Y.

On the third day of the Lizzie Borden murder trial, civil engineer Thomas Kiernan was recalled for cross-examination regarding the property line between the Borden and Kelly houses. The report also notes courtroom atmosphere, with many female spectators and Lizzie Borden appearing calm while conferring with her attorney Mr. Jennings.

The Evening World · 7 June 1893 · page 1

BRIDGET IS CALLED

women. IMlss Borden entered the room look ing as unconcerned and fresh aa any I one could under such circumstances. I After ahe took her scat, Mr. Jennlnrjs had a five-minutes' conversation with her, and she appeared very much Interested and animated, a smile break ing out occasionally as the talk proceeded. Counsel changed locations this mornIng, so that the defense could be nearer 1 lllss Borden. - Thomas Klernan, the civil engineer. who was called yesterday just before 3 adjournment, was recalled for cross-examlnatlon. 2 He pointed out the line between the Borden and Kelly houses, and said the line struck twelve Inches from the hinge

See the clipping

The Evening World · New York, N.Y.

Surveyor and photographer witnesses give detailed measurements of the Borden house, closet, sofa, and blood spot locations, with photographic evidence entered. John V. Morse, brother-in-law of Mrs. Borden, then takes the stand to discuss family history.

The Evening World · 7 June 1893 · page 1

at tbs bcttom. Ulincss Bald he took the location ot what wereSQona him as olool spots by Dr. Dolan on Aug. 10. there were tome on tho kitchen door, elcbt feet and six Inches irom the spo; where ilr. Borden's head was said to have lain. It was on the side of the door; it was on tho nrciiltravo or the door, or the bide casing; there nan a spot on the dining-room door, also on the caslnr, l-'H Inches from th door, and other Uli. There u na none, pointed out to him on the celling or tho sitting-room.

See moreSee less

James A. Walsh, photographer, of rail ltlver, the next llncss. said he had taken photographs oi the lloriicn premises at thu request of the Government, which photo grarhs were put in evidence and Identified by hltn. There wero five of them. The views were taken on cat r Jay last. Tbo witness also took come on tho day after tbo hcmUlde at tho request of Dr. Dolan. 1 no one ot Mrs. Borden's position was taken ab:.ut 3.30 In the alterpoon. Tbo surveyor's and photographers evi dence icing concluded at 10.10, Juhn V. Worse tcolc tho stand. At first the prisoner watched him carefully with apparent anxiety, then looked on with the same Indifference as heretofore. At 10.30, on motion of the defense, all wit. nesses except Hcporteis Manning,! Stevens and Caldwell, Messrs. Duck. Jubb and Holmes and those summoned lor expert evidence, were ordered excluded from toe room. Morso said ho was now living at South , Dartmouth ; .had lived there nearly a year ; he came East three years ago last April-; he waa a brother-of Mrs. Bor den, the first. Asked when Mr. Borden waa first mar ried, he said It was about forty-seven years ago ; there were three children ; one Is dead. ; Mrs. Borden died In 1861 tho child which died was younger than the others : Mr. Borden's second mar rlug he could not remember. He said Lizzie was thirty-three and Bmma forty-one years old. On Wednes day, Aug. 3, last, he.weiit to the Bor den house. He hnd wen a visitor there , several weeks before. The last time he , saw Llztle before that visit he could not place. He arrived at the Borden house at 1.30 on Wednesday. He did not see anybody i that day but Mr. and Mrs. Borden and I Bridget. He ate dinner there that day, but ate It alone. He went away be-1 tween 3 and 1 P. M., and went to Swansea, coming back on Wednesday, arriving about 8.30. That time he en tered the front door, having been let In by Mrs. Borden.

See the clipping

Pawtucket Tribune · Pawtucket, R.I.

District Attorney Moody opens the government's case against Lizzie Borden, describing the murders of her father and stepmother and emphasizing her conflicting statements to Dr. Bowen and Miss Russell about her whereabouts. The report notes Lizzie fainted during proceedings and the jury was to visit the Borden house.

Pawtucket Tribune · 7 June 1893 · page 1

THE BORDEN HORROR. The Government Case Opened by Mr. Moody. LIZZIE'S STORIES CONFLICT, The Prisoner Faints and the Jury Go to Visit the Borden Premises.

The Prisoner Faints and the Jury Go to Visit the Borden Premises. NEw Benronrp, Mass,, June 7.—At 855 yesterday morning Miss Bor 'en and the Jury were in their seats, and counsel were on hand busily arrangiug their papers. The doors were opened to spectators about that time, and at least a third of those present were females The jury heard the indictments against Miss Borden read as

See the clipping

Pawtucket Tribune · Pawtucket, R.I.

The district attorney's opening at trial outlines Lizzie Borden's contradictory statements about her whereabouts and actions before discovering her father's body, including differing explanations to Miss Russell and Officer Mullaley. The prosecution argues no other person could have committed the murders given the timeline and familiarity with the household.

Pawtucket Tribune · 7 June 1893 · page 1

DISTRICT ATTORNEY KNOWLTON detailed account she said she went up there to open the window, ate some pears, came back to the house, looked at the fire, found it was low, went to her room to wait for the fire to come up, eame down and discovered her futher, This day was one of the hottest days of that summer; the loft of the barn was stifling in its heat. Mullaley went into the barn when he came to the scene, looked at the floor and saw that the dust lay thick on the floor.

See moreSee less

He stepned in it and saw plainly every footstep he made, The Government Will Prove that there was an unkindly feeling be tween the prisoner and her step-mother; that she was dwelling on murder and pre dicting disaster and cataloguing defenses; tha ] from the time when Mrs, Borden went up stairs to the time when the prisoner came down an hour later, there was no other human being there but this prisoner at the bar; that these acts were of & human being; of one who must have had a familiar knowledge of the interior of the premises and of the habits of the occu pants; that she made contradictory state ments as to how she found the bodies; and the jury will be asked to say whether any other reasonable hypothesis exists than that the prisoner at the bar knows more about this case than she has thus far dis closed. Addresses the Juary.

See the clipping

Pawtucket Tribune · Pawtucket, R.I.

District Attorney Knowlton concludes his opening remarks to the jury, urging them to follow law and evidence and reach a verdict of guilt only if irresistibly convinced. Lizzie Borden appeared exhausted afterward, and the jury was granted a recess before being taken to view the Borden premises, which Lizzie declined to attend.

Pawtucket Tribune · 7 June 1893 · page 1

DISTRICT ATTORNEY KNOWLTON

Miss Borden Exhausted. Mr. Moody finished his opening at 10:55 and the jury was given a brief recess, At the close of the opening Miss Borden had fallen back in her seat completely ex bausted, and her counscl, Mr. Jennings, and one of her clerical friends adminis tered relief in the form of smelling salts and cold water,

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

Bridget Sullivan's inquest testimony covers the dinner Mrs. Borden brought her, questions about door fastenings and lights in the house, and instructions to wash windows. She also describes finding Mrs. Borden's body under the bed with blood on her face.

The Providence News · 7 June 1893 · page 2

LATEST BRIDGET ON THE STAND.

not, He found Dr, Bowen, some officers and possibly Mrs. Churehill in the hoase lWheu Le re.urned om Thursday mora -0“. Cross-Examined. Cross-Ex amined. Ex-Governor Robinsou cross examined the witness, “Do you know who provided the dio ner for you on Wednesday?’ “‘Mrs, Borden brousht it in.” *“Were Mr. or Mrs, Dorden sick. that night ?”7 **No, sir.” “Was Lizzie sick?” ‘“Mrs. Borden told me so.” “Wait a moment,” said Mr. Knowl ton. The question was afterward ruled out, “Was there a light in the sitting room ?"” “J don’t think there was any.”’ ** Was the door open into the hall #”

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

The report describes courtroom proceedings including Lizzie Borden's demeanor, Morse's testimony about hatchets being removed from the house, and stipulations about Andrew Borden's estate being worth $250,000-$300,000 with no will. It concludes with Bridget Sullivan being called to testify, noting the courtroom's anticipation of her account.

The Providence News · 7 June 1893 · page 2

Savings bank, was called. His testi mony, as well as that of John G. Bur rill, Everett G, Cork, Mr. Clegg, Joseph sShortdeeve and James Mather, simply proved that Mr, Borde: was down town at various ¥lacn between 10:30 and 10:45 o'clock on Thursday morning,. At this poi t, ex Governor Robinson rose and stated that for the purpose of this trial, it was conceded by both sides that Mr, Borden made no will, the de fendant knowines of none, it was accept ed that Mr. Borden had died intestate. It is further conceded that Mr., Borden

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

Maid Bridget Sullivan describes her duties and the household routine, including locking doors and her movements on the morning of the murders. She also recounts noticing Lizzie's sick condition and the events of the days leading up to the killings.

The Providence News · 7 June 1893 · page 2

states that it was on the side tow.ards Mrs. Keliey’s house. She uad known Mr Morse for quite a while. She had nothing to do witn the parior, She saw Mr. Morse tor the first time on Wenunesday ncon after dinoer. Mrs. Borden got hisx dinner for him, Witness did not go out that day. She was driving until 4 or 4:80 p. m, Tre washiug was donve on Monday in the wash roow in the celar. The cellar door was opan while she was down there, She locked the door with a bolt on Tues day after she hung out the clothes.

See moreSee less

She had no oceaston © ofn or out thé dour again belore Mr. Borden was Kkilled. Witness testified tLa. Secoud street WHS 4 main street, “Did you noties Lizzie’s condition on Wednesday moring?’ *“Yes, sir.”’ ' What was it?" “Siek.” i

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

The newspaper comments that District Attorney Moody presented a strong case against Lizzie Borden in his opening remarks at the New Bedford trial. However, it notes the evidence is entirely circumstantial and will need to be backed up by credible witness testimony.

The Providence News · 7 June 1893 · page 4

. the country President Cleveland got a _ good many votes last November. How - wrill it be for his successor on the ticket . §n 18967 2 It cannot be denied that District At - forney Moody outlined a strong case C pgainst Lizzie Borden in his opening at ~ the New Bedford court yesterday, But ~ all his evidence seems to be strictly . eircumstantial, and has also to be sub - ptantiated by the testimony of reliable witnesses, fjj GOVERNOR FLOWER has already nom -3‘ fonated Grover Cleveland for a fourth . gsrial at the presidency, A few brief

See the clipping

The Roanoke Times · Roanoke, Va.

The jury to hear the Lizzie Borden case was quickly completed, surprising even the attorneys who were unprepared for the speed. District Attorney Knowlton estimated the trial would take at least three weeks, with Charles L. Richards of North Attleboro appointed foreman.

The Roanoke Times · 7 June 1893 · page 3

dy nnd had evidently been out all night. There is gootl grounds for believing that these men committed the triple murder at Reach Ridge. The l.lzxle Horden Trial. New Beuforr, Mass., June6.?The jury to hear the Lizzie Borden case has been completed. The quickness with which the jury was impanelled was a surprise to everybody, even the counsel, and they were somewhat unprepared. District At? torney Knowlton is of the opinion that at lea>'t three weeks will be required now to linish up the trial, provided there are no setbacks. Charles L. Richards of North Attleboro was appointed foreman of the jury. _

See the clipping

Alexandria Gazette · Alexandria, D.C.

At her murder trial in New Bedford, Lizzie Borden fainted after Assistant District Attorney Moody stated in his opening speech that she burned a dress three days after the killings. Prosecutors produced the hatchet believed to be the murder weapon in court.

Alexandria Gazette · 7 June 1893 · page 2

trouble. Yours very truly. Meow Bow Wow. Lizzie Borden fainted in the court? room at New Bedford, Mass., yesterday after Assistant District Attorney Moody had declared in his opening speech that it would be proved that she burned a dress three days after the murder of her father and stepmother and had pro? duced in court the hatchet with which it is supposed the, crimes were com? mitted.

See the clipping

Alexandria Gazette · Alexandria, D.C.

A brief dispatch notes that on the third day of the Borden murder trial in New Bedford, Miss Borden appeared calm and composed in court. The report states that the taking of evidence was then resumed.

Alexandria Gazette · 7 June 1893 · page 2

Siansbury J. Willey, of Wilmington. Del., supreme master of the exchequi r of the Knights of Pythias, is to be ex? pelled from the order and proceedings, are to be begun against htm. The or? der has lost $$0,000 through his opera? tions. At the opening of the third day of the norden murder trial at New Bedford, Masr. this morning, .Miss Borden entered the room looking as unconcerned and fresh as anyone possibly could under such trying circun - slam e . Tho taking of evidence was then re? sumed. A destructive cyclone visited Bristol, Va., late Monday night, doing considerable damage to property and injuring II. Clint wood and J. P. (Coder, prominent citizens. The damage to property is estimated at from ?75,000 to S11M >,( M M).

See the clipping

Wisconsin Vorwärts · Milwaukee, Wis.

The report briefly notes that in New Bedford, Massachusetts, the trial began against Lizzie Borden, who is accused of murdering her parents on August 4. It gives no further details of the proceedings.

Wisconsin Vorwärts · 7 June 1893 · page 1

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

See the clipping

Wheeling Register · Wheeling, W. Va.

The report describes the opening day of Lizzie Borden's murder trial in New Bedford, including the reading of the indictment and the prosecution's opening statement by Mr. Moody detailing the family's strained relations. After the address, Borden fainted in the courtroom and was revived with smelling salts and ice.

Wheeling Register · 7 June 1893 · page 1

LIZZIE BORDEN’S TRIAL BEGUN. The Opening Artdreaa Made and the .fury OMT to View the FremUea—Alisa Mordeu Faints. New Bedford, Mass., June 6.—At 8:53 Miss Borden and the jury were Id their seats and counsel were on hand busily arranging their paper. The doors were opened to spectators about that time and at least a third of those present were females. The Jury heard the indictments agalnat Miss Borden read as soon as tho court was finally opened and charged as “good and true, stand together and harken to your evidence.” Mr.

See moreSee less

Moody then stepped to the rail ing and opened the government case. Ae said It was his purpose to put tho story of the crime before the Jury In the simplest possible manner. lie then briefly ran over the details of the double murder, dwelling upon the nar row life of the Inmates of the Borden family, and relating many Incidents tending to show that Ill-feeling had ex isted for years between the prisoner and her step-mother. From the middle until the end of the opening address, Miss Borden leaned back in her chair and never moved a muscle. She put the fan up over her face and holding her head forward, pressed It close against her forehead aud held It there. Just as Mr. Moody had ceased to speak and taken one step to wards his seat, there was & noise where Miss Borden was sitting. She had fainted. The Ilev. Mr. Judd hur ried over to her and placed a bottle of smelling salts to her nostrils Deputy Sheriff Kirby aud another officer hurried after crack ed ice. The woman’s face grew white. Ths officers returned with Ice In a mo ment and a couple of minutes later Miss Barren tn FArDVAf 'I'htt C Alfl was opened by the government putting on its first witness in the person of Thomas Kleraan, civil engineer. He minutely described the Borden house and its surroundings. Court was then adjourned until to-morrow In order that tbo jury might visit the scene of the crlmo.

See the clipping

Wheeling Register · Wheeling, W. Va.

The prosecutor Mr. Moody opened the trial by reviewing the murders and the strained family relations between Lizzie and her stepmother, after which Lizzie fainted and had to be revived with smelling salts and ice. The court then heard its first witness, civil engineer Thomas Kieran, who described the Borden house, before adjourning so the jury could visit the crime scene.

Wheeling Register · 7 June 1893 · page 1

LIZZIE BORDEN'S TRIAL BEGUN.

The words of this article are printed with the report it shares its clipping with. Read them there or in the clipping.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

Bridgeton Pioneer · Bridgeton, N.J. · and 1 other paper

Prosecutor Moody outlined the prosecution's case, highlighting contradictions in Lizzie Borden's accounts of her whereabouts and reasons for being in the barn. Her blood-stained skirt and the murder weapons were shown to the jury, and Lizzie fainted after the opening address concluded.

Bridgeton Pioneer · 8 June 1893 · page 4

Lizzie Borden’s Clothes in Court. Mr. Wood unrolled a bundle and dis closed the clothing Miss Borden had w orn on the morning her father and mother were killed. He held them up for inspect tlon by the jury. There wasno trace of blood on any of the garments on except the front of the skirt, where there was a minute particle of blood. Two axes and three hatchets were shown to the jury. “There was no evidence of a struggle anywhere in the house,” Mr. Moody went on, “not an article anywhere in the house had been disturbed.

See moreSee less

The one who com mitted the murder was familiar with the premises. From the middle until the end of the opening address Miss Borden leaned back in her chair and never moved a muscle. She put the fan up over her face, and holding her head forward, pressed it close against her forehead and held it there. Lizzie Borden Faints. Her eyes were closed and she appeared as if asleep. Not by any motion did she betray that she was conscious of what was going on about her. Just as Mr. Moody had ceased to speak and taken one step toward his seat, there was a noise where Miss Borden was sitting. She had fainted. The Rev. Mr. Jubb hurried over to her and placed a bottle of smelling salts to her nostrils. Deputy Sheriff Kirby and an other officer hurried after soms cracked ice. The woman’s face grew white. The offi cers returned with ice in a moment, and a couple of minutes later Miss Borden began to recover. The jury was allowed a recess of about five minutes, and when it had returned to the box she had recovered her usual man ner and bearing. When the jury returned the case was opened by the Government putting on its first witness in the person of Thomas Kiernan. Mr. Knowlton then asked the court to allow the jury to take a view of the Bor den premises. Gov. Robinson, who con sulted Miss Borden in regard to accom panying the jury to Fall River, announced that his client waived her rights in the matter and would not go with them. Messrs. Hodges, Brown, Nickerson and Arnold of the Deputy Sheriffs were desig nated by the Sheriff to look after the jury, and Messrs. Moody, for the commonwealth, and Mr. Jennings, for the defense, were designated as representing counsel. The Chief Justice instructed the jury as to what the view was to be taken for and then they were dismissed to report for duty this morning at 9 o’clock.

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • Waterbury Evening Democrat · Waterbury, Conn. · 7 June 1893

Paper unidentified

At the start of the trial's second day, Prosecutor Moody delivered the opening statement for the State, describing the double murder and outlining Lizzie Borden's strained relationship with her stepmother. He cited witness accounts of her hostile remarks about her stepmother as part of the prosecution's case.

Paper unidentified · 8 June 1893 · page 1

FAINTED AWAY.

Mr. Moody went at length into the family history of the Bordens. There was, he said, an unkindly feeling between the prisoner and her step-mother. The daughters thought

See the clipping

Paper unidentified

At trial, prosecutor Moody outlined the case against Lizzie Borden, describing family tensions, her alleged attempt to buy prussic acid, the household's illness before the murders, and her suspicious statements to Alice Russell. He also detailed the home's layout and Lizzie's false claim that her stepmother had left the house after receiving a note.

Paper unidentified · 8 June 1893 · page 1

Upon Tuesday night Mr. and Mrs. Borden were taken ill with retching and vomiting, aud the prisoner suffer ed the same way. Bridget Sullivan, the servant, was not affected.

See the clipping

Paper unidentified

During his opening address at trial, prosecutor Moody accused Lizzie Borden of lying about her stepmother's whereabouts and giving contradictory accounts of her own movements that morning, including a disputed claim she went to the barn loft. Lizzie fainted during the address, and the trial adjourned so the jury could view the Borden house in Fall River.

Paper unidentified · 8 June 1893 · page 1

MISS BORDEN FAINTS AWAY

Moody’s address and the jury went to Fall River to view the scene of the tragedy. Miss Borden refused to ac company them. The first witness called at Fall River was Thomas Kieran, a civil engineer at that place. He merely testified to the topography of the country around the Borden house and to the correct ness of the drawings handed to him

See the clipping

The Green Forest Tribune · Green Forest, Ark.

A brief news item reports that the trial of Lizzie Borden, accused of murdering her father and stepmother, began in Fall River, Massachusetts, on Monday. It notes the proceedings are being followed with intense public interest.

The Green Forest Tribune · 8 June 1893 · page 1

- ' jjNapierville, 111., who died in Brockville, Onta rio, two years ago. was receutly sold for $2. It contained gas stock worth $107,000. Dr. Graves, convicted of the murder of Mrs. Barnaby, by sending her at Denver a | bottle of poisoned whisky, has been granted a I new trial and released on $:>0,000 bail. \ The White County Bank at Beebe * » was placed in the hands of a receiver, Wcdues , dsy of last week. The liabilities are $20,000, with scarcely any assets to meet them. The trial of Lizzie Borden, accused of the murder of her father and step-mother, was begun at Pall Uivcr, Mass., Monday.

See moreSee less

The pro ceedings are being noted with all-absorbing in . tenst. our Mormon elders have mysteri. ^disappeared in St. Clair county, Ala , and jjeliovnd that they were murdered by citi i$f the county who objected to their mision iljork lx Presbyterian Assemhley has, by ^ majority, decided in favor of the appeals jroseentors of Dr. Briggs from the finding esbytery of New York, thus finding the Ignilty of heresy. *■ WIND AND FLOOD, Life and Property Destroyed in How ard County.

See the clipping

The Russellville Democrat · Russellville, Ark.

The report describes the start of Lizzie Borden's trial in the superior court at New Bedford, outlining the case against her for the murders of her father Andrew and stepmother Abbie Borden on August 4, 1892. It recounts Lizzie's own account of the morning, including her father's return home and her assisting him before she later discovered his body.

CorrectionThis set right 2 earlier articles: Paper unidentified, 7 June 1893, Morning Journal and Courier, 7 June 1893.

The Russellville Democrat · 8 June 1893 · page 1

New Bedford, Mass , June 5.— To-day Lizzie Borden took her seat in the prisoners’ dock of the superior court here and a battle royal be tween the most eminent criminal lawyers in the state, with a woman’s life and honor at stake, began. On tho fourth day of August, 1882, between the hours of 9:30 and 11:30 a.rn., Andrew Jackson Borden and Abbie Durfee Borden were murdered at their home, in Fall Iiiver. This much is known and the horrible brutality of the affair excited national interest, but just when and by whom these deeds were committed are questions which tho court and jury and eminent counsel will try to solve, and for which they are assembled here to day.

See moreSee less

Briefly put the case stands as follows: T .17710 A Fenian <lannr Andrew Jackson Borden, a woman about 33 years old, her step-monther, Abbie Durlee Borden, and Bridget Sullivan, a servant, were the only members of the family about the house when Mr. Borden came home, about 10 :45 that morning. Bridget let him in at the front door and in a few moments went to her room upstairs. She had been engaged a good part of the morning out doors washing windows. In the absence of proof to the contrary Lizzie’s story must be accepted as to the acts of herself and father until she discov ered his dead body. After he came in she assisted him to get in a com fortable position on a lounge in the sitting room, she says, taking off his boots and putting on his slippers (a photograph of the body taken after discovery shows this statement to be incorrect—the boots were on his feet), then she went into the yard, stopped a few moments to gather and eat some pears, passed on into the barn and spent ten or fifteen minutes hunting for lead to make fishing line sinkers. Goiug into the house, she found her father had been murdered, and called the servant, sending her at once for Dr. Bowen, who lived near, then she sat down on the outside steps and was thus seen by Mrs. Addie Churchill, a neighbor, and asked what the matter was. She told Mrs. Churchill of the murder of her father. Mrs. Churchill came to tho house at once and asked for Mrs. Borden. Lizzie knew nothing of her whereabouts, but sailed to mind the fact that her step mother told her previously she had received a note from a friend, and, in response, was intending to call on that friend. However, Bridget was requested to look for her mis tress, but she objected to going alone, and Mrs. Churchill went with her. As the two women ap proached the top stairs leading to the second floor they saw on the floor of the guest chamber the body of Mrs. Borden. It was learned she, too, had been mutderedjn about the samo manner her husband had been, viz: With several blows from some heavy sharp instrument, probably an axe or hatchet. It was definite ly determined at the autopsy sub sequently held that Mrs. Borden had been killed some time before her husband. It appears to have been shown there was no one about I II iL _:_1_L lhA IUU UUUOv ail Uiu luviuiugi wuv members of the family at intervals. It is claimed about the time Mrs. Borden met her death in the guest chamber on the north side of the house the servant was washing win dows out djors on the south side of the house. It has been demonstrated conclusively that the death of Mr. Bordeu occurred within a very short time after he entered the house, and if Lizzie’s stoiy is correct some one did it while she was in the barn, while Bridget was in the attic and while Mrs. Bordeu’s lifeless body was lying in the room above her husband. Nobody was seen to enter the house, ho instrument bad been discovered which fits the case, but the government claims and will attempt to prove circumstantial evidence points to Lizzie A. Borden as the murderess and evidenco suf ficiently strong tc convict. Miss Borden was arrested two weeks after the murder and and has since been held in the Taun ton jail, excepting a few days during the preliminary hearing before Judge Blaisdell, at the close of which she was held for action by the grand jury. On November 15, the grand jury met at Taunton and a large number of witnesses were examined. On the 18th the jury went to Fall Hiver and viewed the premises, and wero dismissed the following Mon day to sit again December 1. On Friday, December 2, indictments were found against Miss Borden, charging her with the murders, and an indictment was also found against others who are charged with con spiracy to defeat the ends of justice. This latter indictment was drawn up by a Taunton lawyer and also by Assistant District Attorney Uurd. On the 8th of May Miss Borden was I brought to New Bedford and formally j arraigned. She plead not guilty to i the indictments. She was taken

See the clipping

The Russellville Democrat · Russellville, Ark.

This report summarizes the autopsy findings showing Mrs. Borden was killed before her husband, and reviews the investigation, arrest, grand jury indictment, and arraignment leading up to trial. It notes the circumstantial case the prosecution plans to present against Lizzie Borden.

The Russellville Democrat · 8 June 1893 · page 1

Churchill of the murder of her father. Mrs. Churchill came to tho house at once and asked for Mrs. Borden. Lizzie knew nothing of her whereabouts, but sailed to mind the fact that her step mother told her previously she had received a note from a friend, and, in response, was intending to call on that friend. However, Bridget was requested to look for her mis tress, but she objected to going alone, and Mrs. Churchill went with her. As the two women ap proached the top stairs leading to the second floor they saw on the floor of the guest chamber the body of Mrs.

See moreSee less

Borden. It was learned she, too, had been mutderedjn about the samo manner her husband had been, viz: With several blows from some heavy sharp instrument, probably an axe or hatchet. It was definite ly determined at the autopsy sub sequently held that Mrs. Borden had been killed some time before her husband. It appears to have been shown there was no one about I II iL _:_1_L lhA IUU UUUOv ail Uiu luviuiugi wuv members of the family at intervals. It is claimed about the time Mrs. Borden met her death in the guest chamber on the north side of the house the servant was washing win dows out djors on the south side of the house. It has been demonstrated conclusively that the death of Mr. Bordeu occurred within a very short time after he entered the house, and if Lizzie’s stoiy is correct some one did it while she was in the barn, while Bridget was in the attic and while Mrs. Bordeu’s lifeless body was lying in the room above her husband. Nobody was seen to enter the house, ho instrument bad been discovered which fits the case, but the government claims and will attempt to prove circumstantial evidence points to Lizzie A. Borden as the murderess and evidenco suf ficiently strong tc convict. Miss Borden was arrested two weeks after the murder and and has since been held in the Taun ton jail, excepting a few days during the preliminary hearing before Judge Blaisdell, at the close of which she was held for action by the grand jury. On November 15, the grand jury met at Taunton and a large number of witnesses were examined. On the 18th the jury went to Fall Hiver and viewed the premises, and wero dismissed the following Mon day to sit again December 1. On

See the clipping

The Press · Stafford Springs, Conn.

A single sentence notes that Lizzie Borden is currently being tried for the murder of her father and step-mother in Fall River, Massachusetts, last summer. The item is embedded in a miscellany column alongside unrelated news about Hawaii, a flag anniversary, and a drowning death.

The Press · 8 June 1893 · page 2

Lizzie Borden is now being tried for the murder of her father and step-mother at Fall River, Mass. , last summer. The lately passed anti-pool law is now

See the clipping

Connecticut Western News · Salisbury, Conn.

The report describes the start of Lizzie Borden's trial for the murder of her father and stepmother, noting the packed courthouse and anticipation of sensational testimony. It recaps the crime, describing the hatchet killings of Andrew and Abby Borden and the movements of Lizzie and servant Bridget Sullivan that morning.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

Connecticut Western News · 8 June 1893 · page 1

THE BORDEN TRIAL. UNRAVELING FALL RIVER'S FAMOUS MURDER MYSTERY.

New BEDFORP, Mass., June 5. Perhaps the most sensational trial New England has had In half a century or more is that which was tagun here tielay, when Lltzle Borden was arraigned for the murder of her father and stepmother. It will be several days, thouRh, from the time when Judge Mason took his seat this forenoon until the trial legins in earnest. The quaint little courthouse was packed to the doors and probably will be every day that the trial goes ou. The crowd of spec tators will be looking for some sensational developments each day, and they cannot be kept out.

See moreSee less

Story of the Crime. The Borden murder mystery has attract ed more public attention than any oaae of the kind in years. On Aug. 4, 1883, Mr. and Mrs. Andrew J. Borden were hacked to death in their home in a thickly settled portion of .Fall River, Mass., by some per son unknown. The crimes occurred between "9 and 11 o'clock in the morning. The only persona about the house that morning so far aa known were the murdered couple, Liirie Borden and Bridget Sullivan, the servant. Bridget declares that she saw Mrs. Borden for the last t ime at 9 o'clock and that later Liir.le said her stepmother had gone out. Bridget was washing windows outside the house between 9 and 10:30, while Llr.ile was inside ironing or moving about different parts of the residence. There seems to be every indication that Mrs. uoraen, who was up stairs in the spare bedroom, was murdered between 9 and 10 o'clock. About 10 Mr. Borden returned to the house and was let in by Bridget. Lizzie was up stairs at the time, and Bridget says Lizzie laughed because she (Bridget) had trouble in opening the door. Mr. Borden sat down in the sitting room. Lizzie began Ironing in the kitchen, ana Bridget went up to her room on the second floor at about 5 minutes of 11 o'clock. Mr. Borden was alive then. Fifteen minutes later Bridget says Lizzie called to her to go for a doctor, as Mr. Borden was dead. Shortly after the. discovery of Mr. Borden's body that of his wife was found in the guest chamber up stairs. Mr. Borden had evidently leen murdered with -a hatchet or an ax as he lay asleep on the sitting room sofa. His wife had been struck down from behind as she stood on the floor of the guest chamber. The bodies were examined about 11:45, and their" general appearance and the contents of the stomachs indicated that Mrs. Borden had been dead at least two hours and Mr. Borden about one-half or three-quarters of an hour. Lizzie Borden states that she last saw her stepmother alive about 9 o'clock, and that Mrs. Borden told her she was going out. Lizzie says that after her lather cam home she went out in the yard and bam

See the clipping

Connecticut Western News · Salisbury, Conn.

As Lizzie Borden's trial began, this report summarized the August 1892 killings of Andrew and Abby Borden, detailing the timeline given by Bridget Sullivan and Lizzie herself. It notes no weapon was found near the bodies, though axes and a hatchet were discovered in the cellar.

Connecticut Western News · 8 June 1893 · page 1

MURDER MYSTERY. IJssle Ilordeu. Accused of llralnlnf Her Father and Stepmother With a Hatchet, Faces Her Judge The Ktory of the Crimes. New BEDFORP, Mass., June 5. Perhaps the most sensational trial New England has had In half a century or more is that which was tagun here tielay, when Lltzle Borden was arraigned for the murder of her father and stepmother. It will be several days, thouRh, from the time when Judge Mason took his seat this forenoon until the trial legins in earnest. The quaint little courthouse was packed to the doors and probably will be every day that the trial goes ou.

See moreSee less

The crowd of spec tators will be looking for some sensational developments each day, and they cannot be kept out. Story of the Crime. The Borden murder mystery has attract ed more public attention than any oaae of the kind in years. On Aug. 4, 1883, Mr. and Mrs. Andrew J. Borden were hacked to death in their home in a thickly settled portion of .Fall River, Mass., by some per son unknown. The crimes occurred between "9 and 11 o'clock in the morning. The only persona about the house that morning so far aa known were the murdered couple, Liirie Borden and Bridget Sullivan, the servant. Bridget declares that she saw Mrs. Borden for the last t ime at 9 o'clock and that later Liir.le said her stepmother had gone out. Bridget was washing windows outside the house between 9 and 10:30, while Llr.ile was inside ironing or moving about different parts of the residence. There seems to be every indication that Mrs. uoraen, who was up stairs in the spare bedroom, was murdered between 9 and 10 o'clock. About 10 Mr. Borden returned to the house and was let in by Bridget. Lizzie was up stairs at the time, and Bridget says Lizzie laughed because she (Bridget) had trouble in opening the door. Mr. Borden sat down in the sitting room. Lizzie began Ironing in the kitchen, ana Bridget went up to her room on the second floor at about 5 minutes of 11 o'clock. Mr. Borden was alive then. Fifteen minutes later Bridget says Lizzie called to her to go for a doctor, as Mr. Borden was dead. Shortly after the. discovery of Mr. Borden's body that of his wife was found in the guest chamber up stairs. Mr. Borden had evidently leen murdered with -a hatchet or an ax as he lay asleep on the sitting room sofa. His wife had been struck down from behind as she stood on the floor of the guest chamber. The bodies were examined about 11:45, and their" general appearance and the contents of the stomachs indicated that Mrs. Borden had been dead at least two hours and Mr. Borden about one-half or three-quarters of an hour. Lizzie Borden states that she last saw her stepmother alive about 9 o'clock, and that Mrs. Borden told her she was going out. Lizzie says that after her lather cam home she went out in the yard and bam

See the clipping

Connecticut Western News · Salisbury, Conn.

The report reviews the original crime scene findings, including the murder weapons, blood evidence, and timeline of the Borden killings, before describing the start of Lizzie Borden's trial in New Bedford with a swiftly empaneled jury. It notes Professor Wood's testimony that no blood was found on the axes, hatchet, or Lizzie's clothing.

Connecticut Western News · 8 June 1893 · page 1

3;a found on the clothing of Lizzie Bor en. At first thought the conclusion is irresistible that either Lizzie Borden or Bridget Sullivan must have killed Mr. and Mrs. Borden, for although there is some evidence that an unknown man was seen to jump the Borden fence during the morninn this evidence is not very tangible. The aliened motive for the double crime charged against Lizzie Borden is that she and her stepmother were not on friendly terms. Lizzie says that she and her step mother ouarreled five years ago. Before the quarrel Lizzie called her "mot her."

See moreSee less

New liKPKoitD, Mass., June With the jury 1kx all filled the trial of Lizzie Borden was commenced in , earnest this morning, and before today's session is over will be well under way. The prisoner appmred in court at the usual time today attired In the same cos tume of black. She wore the same hat that came down over her loreVead and was trimmed with black lace, old blue velvet and a few feathers. She took her seat and glanced inquiringly at the Jury box, where aat the 12 men who are to find her guilty or innocent of those awful crimes. The quickness which the Jury was em paneled was a surprise to everybody, even the counsel, and they were somewhat un prepared. District-Attorney Knowltonla of the opinion that at least three weeks will be required now to finish up the trial, pro vided there are no set backs.

See the clipping

Morning Journal and Courier · New Haven, Conn.

Report covers the third day of Lizzie Borden's murder trial, noting Bridget Sullivan gave damaging testimony while Lizzie watched closely. John Morse also testified about his movements on the day before the murders, including arriving at the Borden house and being let in by Mrs. Borden.

Morning Journal and Courier · 8 June 1893 · page 3

BRIDGET SULLIVAN TESTIFIES

Btefenae on His Crone Examination. Niw Bidtosd, Haas., Jane 7. At the opening of the third day of the trial of Llzrle Borden for murder ' this morning nearly one-half of the spectators were wo men. Hiss Borden entered the room look lng as unconcerned and fresh as anyone ooald nndex the olreamstanoes.' After she took her seat Mr. Jennings had five min utes' conversation with her, and ahe ap peared very much Interested and animated, a smile breaking out occasionally as the talk proceeded. Civil Engineer Kiernan, who was on the stand yesterday, was recalled for cross examination.

See moreSee less

He gave the results of measnrementa taken by him of various parts of the hoHee and the articles of f nmlture. He was followed by James A. Walsh, a Fall Elver photographer, whose photographs of the Borden premises were pnt in evidence and Identified by him. jonn v. Morse was men oauea to tne stand and for a few momenta was watched olosely by the prisoner. On motion of the defense all witnesses except the reporters, Mannlng.Stevena and Caldwell, and Messrs.

See the clipping

Morning Journal and Courier · New Haven, Conn.

John Morse recounts his visit to the Borden house the day before and morning of the murders, describing his movements and the household routine. Under cross-examination by ex-Governor Robinson, he addresses the possibility of an outsider entering through an unlatched front door.

Morning Journal and Courier · 8 June 1893 · page 3

defense all witnesses except the reporters, Mannlng.Stevena and Caldwell, and Messrs. Book, Jubb and Holmes, and those sum moned for expert evidence, were excluded from the room. The witness said he went to the Borden house on Wednesday. Aug ust 3 last. He only saw Hr. and Mrs. Bor den and Bridget Sullivan, the servant, lie ate dinner alone, tie went to Swansea about 4 o'clock and returned about 8:30 and was let In by Mrs. Borden. He went to bed at 10:30. While he and lira Bor den were in the fritting room, Mr.

See moreSee less

Borden having gone to bed, somebody entered the front door and went up to Lizzie's room. The wltneas went to the guest's room. The prisoner's door was closed, but he did net know whether it was looked. The witness saw or heard no person that night. He arose at about 6 o'olook and went down stairs; left the room door open; did not go back eo the room; prisoner's room door was closed when he went down; went into the sitting room; there was no one in the room then. The kitchen door was olosed; the first person he saw was Mr. Borden, who oame into the sitting room, and then oame Mrs. Borden. He remain ed there until breakfast time and then went to the dining-room. Only these two were present. The witness left the house at aoout o:W, passingvout the rear door; Mr.- Borden went to the door; saw Bridget in tne citonen. When they got to the door Hr. Bor den hooked it by a small book inside. The witness was in tne olty all tne time until ns oame back, going first to the postoffioe, then to see sis nephew ana niece, ue leit there about 11:20 and went baok to the Borden house, travelling back on the horse oar. lie nrst went into tne baok yard ana picked np two or three pears and ate part of one; then went Into the house and waa informed that something had happened. The first viotlm he-saw was Mr. uoraen; then he went up the stairs and looked un der the door and saw Mrs. Borden lying there. When he saw her he was just be low the floor. He had been told ehe waa there. He did not see Lizzie Borden from the time he -arrived on Wednesday noon until he arrived back from his nleoe's. Ex-Governor Bobinson began cross ex amining Morse at 10:45 o'clock. As bear ing on the possibility of an onteider being in the house, he brought mt the fact that during the eveniDg before the marder there was no light in the Bitting room, ana that unless the front door waa shut hard the spring lock would not catch, and turn ing the knob ontaide wonld open the door. Mr. Morse aeoiarea mat on reacning tne Borden house after the murder he saw no officers -In the yard; that the barn door was olosed and he heard no one inside. This oontradiots the government's claim that officers, by immediate examination of the barn, ascertained that tne prisoner could not have been there at the time of the murder. At 11:35 o'olockthe court took a n veminutes' recess, during which time the prisoner talked earnestly with Jubb. Kobinson and Adams. After the recess witnesses were called to fix the time when Mr. Borden was last

See the clipping

Morning Journal and Courier · New Haven, Conn.

At the preliminary hearing, ex-Governor Robinson cross-examines John Morse about the house's locks, lighting, and the barn on the night of and after the murders, raising doubts about the government's timeline. Bridget Sullivan then testifies about her duties, living quarters, and knowledge of the household and barn.

Morning Journal and Courier · 8 June 1893 · page 3

The words of this article are printed with the report it shares its clipping with. Read them there or in the clipping.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

Freeland Tribune · Freeland, Pa. · and 1 other paper

This general news roundup from June 8, 1893 briefly mentions that a jury was selected in the trial of Lizzie A. Borden in New Bedford, Massachusetts, who was charged with double murder. The item appears as one line among dozens of unrelated national and international news briefs.

Freeland Tribune · 8 June 1893 · page 4

progress tbis week. Tuesday, June 0. Mrs. Frank Leslie filed affidavits in her suit for divorce from Willie Wilde—- There was almost a financial panic in Chi cago. Crowds filled 10 of the banks, from which thousands of dollars were with drawn. All were able to meet the demands upon them except the Meadowcroft Bros.' bank, which made an assignment In the trial of Lizzie A. Borden in New Bed ford, Mass., charged with double murder,

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • The Willimantic Journal · Willimantic, Conn. · 9 June 1893

Waterbury Evening Democrat · Waterbury, Conn.

At the New Bedford hearing, Dr. Seabury Brown described Lizzie Borden's composure and statements on the day of the murder, including her claim about her stepmother's note. Bridget Sullivan, recalled to the stand, denied Lizzie was crying on the stairs that morning, but stenographic notes from the inquest showed she had earlier said the opposite.

Waterbury Evening Democrat · 8 June 1893 · page 1

THE BORDEN MURDER TRIAL.

Made by Her at tbe Inquest. New Bedford, June 8. The appear ance of Lizzie Borden as she entered the court room to-day was that on her part at least there was on prospect of further , breaking down. She was somewhat cool er than usual and walked firmly to tbe prisoners' box. Dr Seabury Brown was the first witness called. He testified to going to tbe Borden house after Mr Borden had

See the clipping

Waterbury Evening Democrat · Waterbury, Conn.

A doctor testifies he prescribed bromo caffeine and morphine to Lizzie Borden after the murders. Bridget Sullivan denies saying Lizzie was crying on the stairs, contradicting her own inquest testimony, while Mrs Churchill describes finding Lizzie and seeing Mrs Borden's body.

Waterbury Evening Democrat · 8 June 1893 · page 1

produced strange ideas in people's minds Bridget Sullivan was recalled and questioned in regard to her visit to the cello r with the officers to search for weapons. She said that L-'zzie Borden was not crying when she met her on the stairs on the morning of the murder. The stenographic notes were then pro duced showing that at the inquest the witness had said that Lizzie was crying when she met her on the stairs. Mies Sullivan at this point became angry and declared that the notes were false; that she had never said that L'zzie was cry ing.

See moreSee less

Mrs Adelaide B. Churchill said she had found Lizzie on the stairs on the morning of the murder. She told wit ness that she had been to the barn and that her mother had gone out, but thought she had returned and wished some one would find her. Witness saw the body of Mrs Borden lying on the floor from the stairway. Said Lizzie wore a drrss of light blue cambric or calico. Mr Moody produced a dress and asked witness if it was the one Lizzie wore. "I did not see her have that dress on that morning," was the reply.

See the clipping

The Morning Call · San Francisco, Calif.

The report covers the continuation of Lizzie Borden's trial in New Bedford, noting testimony from guest J.V. Moise and servant Bridget Sullivan. Sullivan testified that the Borden family had always been harmonious, with no quarrels, though no new facts emerged.

The Morning Call · 8 June 1893 · page 1

HAD NO QUARRELS. The Family Relations of the Bordens Were Always Harmonious. New Bedfokd, Mas*., June 7.— The trial of Lizzie Borden was continued to

See the clipping

The Herald · Los Angeles, Calif.

The report describes the ongoing trial of Lizzie Borden, noting testimony from house guest J.V. Morse and servant Bridget Sullivan. It states the family relations were harmonious with no quarrels, and that no new facts emerged before court adjourned.

The Herald · 8 June 1893 · page 1

LIZ/IK BORDEN'S TRIAL. The Testimony Given Thns Far Devoid of Mew Facts. New Bedford, Mass., Jane 7.—The trial of Lizzie Borden was continued to day. J. V. Morse, a guest at the Borden

See the clipping

The Record-Union · Sacramento, Calif.

The trial of Lizzie Borden continued with testimony from J.V. Morse, a guest at the Borden house, and servant Bridget Sullivan. Sullivan's testimony emphasized that family relations were harmonious with no quarrels, and the court adjourned after her cross-examination.

The Record-Union · 8 June 1893 · page 1

Trial of Lizzie Borden. Nkw Bedford Mass.i, June 7.—The rtial of Lizze Borden was continued, to day. J. V. Morse, a guest at the Bcrden

See the clipping

Delaware Gazette and State Journal · Wilmington, Del.

The long-anticipated trial opened in New Bedford with Lizzie Borden appearing calm, dressed in black brocade, as crowds gathered outside the courthouse. District Attorney Moody opened for the prosecution, outlining the case and emphasizing family discord following her father's second marriage.

Delaware Gazette and State Journal · 8 June 1893 · page 5

THE GREAT TRIAL UNDER WAY.

New Rm ikord. Mass., June5.—Tho long anticipated Borden murder trial has be gun. At an early hour this morning every available shady spot County street near tho court house crowded, 1 patiently the sitters and Standers wailed until the hell on the court houie was tolled, signifying the opening of court. •At precisely IO.'.h o'clock Miss Lizzie A. Borden, the prisoner, came slowly iut«» tho court room and was show the dock. She was att ired i coming costume of black brocaded stuff. wore a pretty shade hat, relieved by u :h here and there <»f blue, Ev he room was occupied by talesmen and newspaper sillers being admitted up to thut time, ami within the box enclosure were a few of the prominent men of the county, who accorded seats bv courtesy.

See moreSee less

hud ne« New Bedford, Mass., June d. At *.5ô o'clock this morning Miss Borden and the

See the clipping

Delaware Gazette and State Journal · Wilmington, Del.

District Attorney Moody opens for the prosecution, emphasizing Lizzie Borden's estrangement from her stepmother and a quarrel over property division. A civil engineer, Mr. Kieran, testifies about measurements and visibility tests in the Borden house, including the hall closet and guest room.

Delaware Gazette and State Journal · 8 June 1893 · page 5

THE GREAT TRIAL UNDER WAY.

accorded seats bv courtesy. hud ne« New Bedford, Mass., June d. At *.5ô o'clock this morning Miss Borden and the jury wore in their seats, ami counsel were hand busily arranging their papers. The «I. spectators about that time ami third of those present were females. The weather opens very warm and another sc .. prospect. The jury heard the indictments against Miss Borden read as as formally opened, and ; true, "stand togethe evidence. I li««i District Attorney Moody of Essex, wh attorney-general, o «1 represent.* o for the commonwealth.

See moreSee less

tho address to the jury he recited the > r of the c *, and luid particular stress upon the fact Mr. Borden bail married a senind time, from which I that Lizzie and her sister had quarreled with their parents regarding a division of the property; that the girls had ceased to addre-s their step mother as "mother." He instanced the scene when an officer, seeking information from the prisoner right in sight of the woman who hud sunken under the assassin's blow, had asked : "When did you last mother?" The reply «: "She is not my mother; my mother died when I was an infant." New Bedford, Mass . June 7.—At the opening of the third day of the Borden murder trial, this morning, the morbid curiosity of the female portion of the com munity was cutered to and nearly one-half of ihe spectator:» were women. Their necks Miss Borden entered the room, looking as unconcerned and fresh as any one possibly could under such trying circumstances. After she took tier seat Mr. Jennings had a live minutes' conversation with her. and she appeared h interested und animated, a smile breaking out occasionally ns the talk proceeded. Mr. Kiermtn, the civil engineer who was yesterday?was recalled for the first wit s. When the witness was making measurements of the lower Hour of the Borden house, his attention was called to the closet in the front hall. He was asked if his attention was called to the fact that

See the clipping

Delaware Gazette and State Journal · Wilmington, Del.

A witness testifies about experiments concerning what could be seen through a closet door and from the stairs, including a demonstration with an assistant lying on the floor. John V. Morse then takes the stand, with Lizzie Borden watching him closely before reverting to apparent indifference.

Delaware Gazette and State Journal · 8 June 1893 · page 5

THE GREAT TRIAL UNDER WAY.

The words of this article are printed with the report it shares its clipping with. Read them there or in the clipping.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

A news summary column reports that John V. Morse, Bridget Sullivan, and others gave testimony in the Borden murder trial underway in New-Bedford, Mass. The item is one of several brief domestic news notices in the day's roundup.

New-York Tribune · 8 June 1893 · page 6

— THE NEWS THIS MORNING. a— Forecign.—A Conservative amendment to the Home Rule bill, relating to immigration and aliens, was accepted by the Government and carried in the Commons, 328 to 159: the Irish members and many Liberals voting against jt. == Sir Richard Webster finishel his address in behalf of the Rritish case before the Behring Sea Court] C. Robinson, a Canadian lawyer, followed him, Count Kalnoky's speech, intimating the pose sibility of an Austro-Russian allianes, has caused much irritation in Germany. Domestic—John V. Morse, Bridget Sullivan and others ave testimony in the Borden murder

See the clipping

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

The piece reports that prosecution testimony from Lizzie Borden's uncle John V. Morse and a household servant revealed the state's strategy: proving guilt not directly but by process of elimination, showing she was the only person present at the time. The author notes this approach would likely leave reasonable doubt in many minds.

New-York Tribune · 8 June 1893 · page 6

As was foreshadowed in Tur TRISUNE scne time ago, the Aqueduct Commissioners have decided to acquire Jerome Park as the site for the reservoir which they declare to be necessary north of the Harlem River. The proposed reservoir will cetainly be a costly undertaking, and Tammany Hall will mturally do all in its power to prom te the enterprise, in the hope of direct and indirect profits from it. The work, however, will, we take it, be under the control of the Aqueduct Commissimers, in whom the community has good reason to feel confidence.

See moreSee less

‘ ———n c—— Rapid progress is being made in the Borden trial. The theory of the prosecution was disclosed by the testimony given yesterday by Miss Borden's uncle, John V. Mose, and the servant in the Borden household. The prosecution evidently do not expect to prove that Miss Borden committed the fiendish crimes of which she is accused, except by a process of exclusion showing that she must have done so because she was the only person in the house at the time. An unbroken chain of testimony on this point would still leava at least a doubt in many minds.

See the clipping

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

The piece discusses how Lizzie Borden fainted in court after the prosecution opened with new testimony from her close friend, suggesting this may have prejudiced the jury. It cautions against inferring guilt from her loss of composure, noting the stress of being confronted with a friend's betrayal could explain it.

New-York Tribune · 8 June 1893 · page 6

——pe— Lizzie Borden's fainting fit was unfortunately timed, since it tended to create prejudice against her on the part of the jury. The counsel for the State in openirg the case disclosed new testimony, whizh would be used against her, including that of her most intimate friend. It was an awkward moment for the prisoner to turn pale and lose consciousness. It would be hardly safe, however, to infer guilt from this dramatic incident in court. Lizzie Borden, even if inno-

See the clipping

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

The report describes the third day of Lizzie Borden's trial in New Bedford, noting that the prosecution aims to show no one else could reasonably be suspected rather than directly proving she committed the murders. Witnesses John V. Morse and Bridget Sullivan testified as the state built a circumstantial case, with the court moving at a fast pace and the defense offering little resistance so far.

New-York Tribune · 8 June 1893 · page 1

OF CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE. (BY TELEGRAPH TO TPE TRIBUNE.) New-Bedford, Mass, June 7.-It is plain that the State does not expect to prove that Lizzie Borden killed her father and stepmother. The moat it hopes to prove is that nobody else can be reasonably sus pected of the crime; that she may be so suspected, and, therefore, that she must be guilty. Judged by its effect In carrying this conviction, the evidence thus far submitted is undeniably strong. It has been presented in much the same way that scraps of a torn paper might, when all collected, be put together.

See moreSee less

Gradually the writing Is shown in something like the original form, with most of the letters In place, the torn edges fitting. Whoever straek the blows that ended the lives of those two old people broke up a queer houseliold and drew the curtain down upon a drama of domestic life strange and disagreeable. They go to work early down here, Everybody is up and at it long before the sun is supposed to rise in New-York. Court assembles at 9 o'clock, and 1t doesn’t adjourn until 5, It works, too, all the while, The judges and lawyers are trying Lizzie Borden at &

See the clipping

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

This report covers the third day of Lizzie Borden's murder trial, describing the courtroom atmosphere and the prisoner's demeanor. It outlines District Attorney Moody's theory of the crime and summarizes testimony from witnesses John Morse and Bridget Sullivan.

New-York Tribune · 8 June 1893 · page 1

TILE STATE'S THEORY OF THE CRIME. District Attorney Moody allezes that the murder of Mr. and Mrs, Borden was committed on Thursdap morning, August 4, at some time after half-past 9 o'clock and be.ors 11, He asserts tiat during that peilod of tte the two victims of the tragedy with Bridget Sullivan and Lizzie Borden were the only persons im the Borden house. ~ He claims that the extraordinary habit which the Bordens had of locking and double locking the doors of their premises, which habit oa that day was in full force, prevented the ready Ingress of an assailant.

See moreSee less

Bearing these points in mind, the testimony of Morse, the uncle, and Bridget, the cook, 1s In many respects important, but whether it convicts Miss Borden or adds to the natural improbe ability of a danghter’s killing her father, Is a question which every person must answer for himself. Morse Is an elderly man, pot hand-ome to look upon, but with the general appearance of an honest, fairs minded, Now-England farmer. He answered thg ques. tions put to him deliberately, carefully, as though he wished to obey the oath he haa taken to speak the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth, as nearly as wus humanly possible, He 1s the brother of Lizziv's mother, old Mr. Borden's first wife, who died In 18¢€1, The second wife, by thé way, who was sixty-three years old when she was killed, was married to Borden in 1864, so that if, as the prose cutlon asserts, she was the oblect of Lizzie's pro= found and bitter hatred, it fcllows that the prisoner had put np with her for a long while,

See the clipping

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

The report covers John Morse's testimony about his stay at the Borden house the night before and morning of the murder, establishing that he had breakfast with Andrew and Abby Borden while Lizzie and Emma slept in. It notes the locked-door habits of the household and questions whether Morse's and Bridget's testimony helps or hurts the prosecution's case against Lizzie.

New-York Tribune · 8 June 1893 · page 1

THE STATE'S THEORY OF THE CRIME

The words of this article are printed with the report it shares its clipping with. Read them there or in the clipping.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

Witnesses including Morse and Bridget Sullivan detail Andrew Borden's movements on the morning of the murders, describing the household routine and door-locking habits. Police are reported searching the premises for evidence while investigators work to establish a timeline before Borden's death.

New-York Tribune · 8 June 1893 · page 2

3 «rime. £0 far as he observed, {here was nothing I got, home, ay x ner X the back door wns ISED, ‘ : 3 of blood on her clothes or person, nor any evidence I think Mr. Borden had a key to this door. ad MA U A E 4 about Lizzie that indicated agitation, nor any marks M | jocked. When 1 came back It was the, sme uy. EE IR i WRN Tima No

See the clipping

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

Bridget Sullivan testifies about the household routine on the morning of the murders, including Mr. Morse's departure and return, and Mrs. Borden's dusting in the parlor. Civil engineer Mr. Kiernan is recalled to the stand after a court recess to give further testimony.

New-York Tribune · 8 June 1893 · page 2

; was in the ng-room: she gav 0 . ' LY lim when, shortly after Morse went out, he ; ' Sens There Wig not more than five minutes’ differthree years, the last being that of New-Orleans In : 3 § started upstairs. Just before thik fAzzie had come Prepared only by POND'S EXTRACT Co., ence between the time of Mr. and Mrs. Borden's 1800, and are of great interest to all the members of . y downstairs to get her breakfast. While Lizale was NEW YORK AND LONDON. coming down.

See moreSee less

When he came down he put his key that music loving people. The first saengerfest was . . ONOVER & 0., - § very 1 1 label on the mantel, took out his slop pail ant passsd that at Cincinnati In 1840, when the Saengerbund : A

See the clipping

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

Courtroom testimony covers Bridget Sullivan's window-washing duties and the timing of Mrs. Borden's death, along with civil engineer Kiernan's measurements of the hall closet where a man could reportedly hide. Mrs. Caroline Kelley also testified about seeing Mr. Borden in his yard with a key in hand.

New-York Tribune · 8 June 1893 · page 2

MISS BORDEN IN GOOD HUMOR

- § very 1 1 label on the mantel, took out his slop pail ant passsd that at Cincinnati In 1840, when the Saengerbund : A : thus occupled Mrs. Borden was in the parlor, dustSee our name on every wrapper anda [abel through the side door. When he wag outdoors he Jretimpam— . “40, when the Saengerbun : 2 ing. Earlier in the morning she had instructed | === com me ees. | (cont into the large door of the barn.” was founded. Five socletics were represented len, 28 AND 30 WEST 23D ST.

See moreSee less

3 Bridget to wash the dining and sitting room windows, | . wr ae MISS PORDEN IN GOOD HUMOR. —— stm | three In Cincinnati and one each from Madison, Ind, vA and while Lizzie was still eating and Mrs. Borden | gives sharp contradiction to the revelation of another. i d mn “TT - » + and Louisville, Ky. Since then the Bund has grown Factory and Foundry, I \ ahit that 1s thrown upon it brings into view ML »Oh : y I stil dusting, and at about fifteen minutes past 9, Mr. Kiernan, the civil engineer who was on the At this point the court {00K a recess from 1 10 2:13 k LEECED BY TAMMANY HALL. steadily, until about 100 socletles in ull parts of the Y ; ' oR tata v . alle . “|p. mo On reassembling Mlss Borden took her seat " 536-338-330 West 23th 8¢., N. X, 8 : stand yesterday, was recalled this morning for the —_ Central West ave Ned in It d the 110 : Bridget set about that business. She Never Saw | gg jipecs, le testified to varlons measurements j for the first time within the bar inclosure and near ’ TAXPAYERS ROBBED OF LARGE | of the first fest WM ¢ Ea iY Mrs. Borden alive from that hour. She was occu- | made by lim at the Borden place, and about the | nop counsel. She appeared to be in good spirits and RURAL TAAL: “ A Lu of the first fest will doubtless be Increased to 3,000 ‘es pled cleaning the windows most of the morning. closet in the front hall of the house, He wis nsied : Arvetig anaiad Whith “she . SUM at the coming one, Other German singing socleNes : : , ; £ it nis attention wae called to the fact that ene could fondled a small cluster of pansies, which seem to be SUM. " 3 Ehe does not remember at just what hour, but along | in there and be hidden with the iy completely her favorite fioWers. — besides those In the Bund are expected to be present, | pn y a — —_— (onan noon she heard somebody trying to get into | Suc” ie described it by saying that a man went dn | GEC Ar witness called in the afternoon was Mrs. | | org pELONGING TO THE STATE SOLD TO and it Is anticipated that representatives of not less | : ; the front door with a Intchkey. As he seemed to be | and he shut the door on him. There was no diffi Caroline Kelley. he Saw Mr. Jorden in bis yard LANDS . BLLUNGES 4 than 150 vocal socletles will participate In the seven THE DEAD TRAGE DIAN, 4 having difficulty, she Went into the house and throngh | id I ins hii SOO Mle ue a The ou front door, passing inside of the fence; Be stooped NEW-YORK CITY FOR LESS THAN HALF great concerts to be given. — ee

See the clipping

The Morning News · Savannah, Ga.

On the third day of the Lizzie Borden murder trial, the courtroom was packed with curious women as Lizzie entered looking calm and fresh. Civil engineer Kiernan testified about measurements of the Borden house, including a front hall closet where a man could hide undetected with the door shut.

The Morning News · 8 June 1893 · page 1

Testimony as to His Measurements. Bridget O’Sullivan Put on the Stand. New Bedford, Mass., June 7. —At the Opening of the third day of tho Borden murder trial this morning the morbid curiosity of the female portion of the community was catered to and nearly one half of the spectators were women. Their necks were craned one w§y as Miss Bor den entered the room looking as uncon cerned and fresh as any one possibly could under such trying circumstances. After she took her seat Mr. Jenuings had a live, minutes’ conversation with her and she appeared very much interested and animated, a smile breaking out occasion ally as the talk proceeded!

See moreSee less

raeman, the civil engineer who was on the stand yesterday, was called as the first witness. When tho witness was making measurements of the lower floor of the Borden house his attention was called to a closet in the front hall. He

See the clipping

The Morning News · Savannah, Ga.

A surveyor described an experiment testing visibility of a body from the stairs, followed by John V. Morse's testimony suggesting an outsider could have entered through an unlatched door. The session closed with servant Bridget Sullivan beginning her testimony about household routines before the murders.

The Morning News · 8 June 1893 · page 1

THE CHANCE FOR AN OUTSIDER. Morse testified that ho was a brother of Mrs. Borden tho first. He was cross examined by ex-Gov. Robinson, as bear ing on the possibility of an outsider being in the house. The fact was brought out that during the evening before the mur der there was no light in the sitting room, and that unless the front door was shut hard the springlock would not catch and turning tho knob outside would open the door. Morse swore that on reaching the Borden house after tho murder he saw no officers in the yard, that the barn door was closed and that he heard no one inside.

See moreSee less

This contradicts the state's claim that officers by immediate exami nation of the barn ascertained that the prisoner could not have been there at the time of the murder. Witnesses called after Morse’s examina tion fixed the time When Mr. Borden was Jast seen. The cross-examination de veloped nothing but slight confusion and uncertainty as to the exact time. Miss Borden yawned and looked on listlessly. an important witness. * A buzz of excitement ran around the room at 12:30 o’clock when Mr. Moody called Bridget Sullivan. She was a servant in the Borden family at the time of the murder. She leaned to tlie left sido against the rail, looked straight at Mr. Moody and spoke so low that lie had to tell her to speak louder. The prisoner remained leaning back in her seat, but changed posture so as to see the witness plainly and watch Bridget steadily with her large eyes wide open. All the judges watched Bridget carefully while she.tes tified to bolting the cellar door on the In side two days before tho murder, to hook ing the screen door, to the sickness of tho Bordens Wednesday and to her own con duct, and tho looked condition of the doors on Wednesday night and Thursday morning before the” murder. She detailed at length the movements of the various members of tho Borden household during tho morning of the day of the crime and described again tho Scenes when tlie murders were discov ered. As bearing upon tho alleged ill feeling existing between Lizzie Borden and her step-mother Bridget testified U|xm cross-examination: “I never had any trouble in the family and liked the place. I never saw or heard anything out of the way in the family relations, and during my nearly three years of serv ice everything was pleasant. Lizzie and her mother always spoke to each other. I heard them all talking in the sitting room that morning and Mrs. Borden asked Liz zie sonic questions and shennswered them civilly and properly. So far as I could soe they livod congenially and pleas antly.” .

See the clipping

The Morning News · Savannah, Ga.

At the trial, witness Bridget Sullivan, the Borden family's servant, testified in detail about household routines, locked doors, and the discovery of the murders. Under cross-examination she stated she never witnessed discord between Lizzie and her stepmother, describing their relations as civil and pleasant.

The Morning News · 8 June 1893 · page 1

The words of this article are printed with the report it shares its clipping with. Read them there or in the clipping.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

The Indianapolis Journal · Indianapolis, Ind.

John V. Morse testifies that he stayed overnight in the guest room where Mrs. Borden's body was later found, and had breakfasted with the Bordens before leaving. He recounts returning to the house around 11:40 a.m. to find the bodies already discovered.

The Indianapolis Journal · 8 June 1893 · page 5

TRIAL OF LIZZIE BORDEN

Pen Picture of tte Prisoner. New Bedford, Mass., Jan 7. At th opening of the third day of the Uorden murder trial this morning necks were craned as 3Iit Horden entered the zoom, looking at unconcerned and fresh as possi ble under anch trying circumstances. After she took her seat Mr. Je unings bad a live minutes' conversation with her ami she ap peared very much interested and animated, a sinile breaking ont occasionally as the talk proceeded. When John V. Morse took the stand the prisoner at first watched him carefully with apparent anxiety, and tben looked on with the same inditfcrence as heretofore.

See moreSee less

Mr. Morse testified that he passed the night In the gnest chamber where Mrs. Borden was subse quently found dead; he breakfasted with the Bordena and left the House by the screen door. Mr. Borden going out with him. When he returned to tho house the dead bodies had been discovered. He saw the body of Mrs. Borden first. "I went up stairs," he said, and under the bed 1 had been sleeping on I found Mrs. Borden. There was blood on her face. I saw Miss 1 Lizzie Borden when 1 returned." That was tne brut time he bud seen her since his ar rival the day before. Cross-examined by rx-Governor Robin son, be said it was About 11:40 that be re turned to the Borden house on the morning of the murder, lie approached the house from tne rear. Tne street on whioh it is situated is t busy one. lie saw no police men in tho yard; the barn door was closed and he heard do one inside. This contra dicts the Commonwealth's allegation that the police, by immediate examination of the barn, ascertained that the nrisoner coald not have been in the barn at the time of the murder. Mr. Morse told how the police had searched the honse and he had helped tbein. They found some axes, but be could not identify them now. At this point a recess of live minutes was taken. While the witness was testifying Miss Borden regarded him with hardly a casual interest. She chewed on the ring in tho nd of her fau. During the recess Miss Borden chatted with Melvin Adams, one of tier counsel. During the course of her con versation with him sbe laughed and ap peared to be in a cheerful frame of mind. Theyoung woman was telling hercounselof a mistake made by Mr. Morse m his state ment of the time her mother died. When That had been straightened on the record Mr. Morse was excused.- Miss Borden also conversed earnestly with ex-Governor Rob inson, while she nervously fingered her smelling salts.

See the clipping

The Indianapolis Journal · Indianapolis, Ind.

John Morse testifies about discovering Mrs. Borden's body and his movements the morning of the murder, with cross-examination challenging the prosecution's timeline regarding the barn. Bridget Sullivan then takes the stand, describing household security details and Lizzie's dress on the morning of the killings.

The Indianapolis Journal · 8 June 1893 · page 5

TRIAL OF LIZZIE BORDEN

The words of this article are printed with the report it shares its clipping with. Read them there or in the clipping.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

The Indianapolis Journal · Indianapolis, Ind.

Bridget Sullivan testifies at the trial about household routines, the dress Lizzie wore, and her own actions after hearing Lizzie's outcry, including the discovery of Mrs. Borden's body. Under cross-examination by ex-Governor Robinson, she states Lizzie had no blood on her and her hair and clothing were not disarranged.

The Indianapolis Journal · 8 June 1893 · page 5

BRIDGET SULLIVAN'S TESTIMONY

Bridget carofnlly while sbe testified to bolting the cellar door on the inside two days before the murder, to hooking the screen door, to sickness of the Bor dens Wednesday and to her own con duct, and to the locked condition of the floors on Wednesday night and Thursday inorning before the murder. Mr. Moody asked tho witness to describe the dress worn by Miss Borden on the morning of the murder. She thought it was of light blue material, with a dark blue sprig on it. The dressmaker who hud made it was the sam one that made Miss Lizzie's dresses ever since she had been in the house.

See moreSee less

Shewas hot sure about the color of the dress. "1 heard an outcry' she said, coming down to the tragedy itself. T called down stairs aud found Mies Lizzie standing by the screen tioor, which was open. 1 did not notice her dress then. She sent me lor the doctor. She asked if I knew where Miss liuftselljived. 1 said 1 did, and she told me to go aud get her, as she could not stay alone. 1 could not find Miss Russell. I wcot back to the honse and entered by the screen door. Mrs. Churchill and Ir. Bowen were there. Dr. Bowen said Mr. Borden had been murdered. 1 said. 'Liziie, if 1 kuew that Mrs. Borden was at Mfs. Whitehead's 1 would go there and tell here that Mr. Borden wae very sick.' She said to me, 'Mangle, I think I heard her comu in and go np stairs. Go up and sen if she's there.' i said i'd not go alono. Mrs. 1'itnrohill and I went up stairs, and there we found Mrs. Borden' dead." "How fardidyou go into the room!" Bridget was asked. . "1 went far enough to see the body, any how." was the answer. Bridget bad heard nothing about a note to Mrs. Borden before Lizzie had told her of it. Neither had she heard of any sick person. Dil you ever see a hatchet about the bouse that had the handle broken ofll" she was asked. ?so. sir, I did not. The wood was cut by man on the farmthe driver," she said. That ooncluded the direct examination. When ex-Governor Robinson began" to cross-examine he tried fo show by the wit ness that the most pleasant relations exist ed in the family. Hridget said that the daughters did not come to the table with their parents. When Mrs. Borden spoke to them they spoke to her. She amended that In part, subsequently, by saying that the members of the family conversed together very often, and sbe had never heard them quarreling. "Now, did you say that Second street was a quiet street!" was asked. "1 don't know," Bridget answered, "I sever beard any quarreling there." The questioner then came down to the time alter the murder. "Von did not see any blood on her, did you!" ho asked, re ferring to Mies Borden. "No, sir." "Was her hair ruffled or any of her cloth tag disarranged!" "No. sir." Bridget said she never heard across word in the house between Lizzie and Mrs. Bor den. Robinson got her to admit that she did not know whether she hooked the screen door on the morning of the murder. At the close of her cross-examination the court adjourned until to-morrow morning. Dr. Bowen will be tho next witness.

See the clipping

Der Deutsche Correspondent · Baltimore, Md.

The trial against Lizzie Borden resumed in New Bedford despite oppressive heat, with a large curious crowd in attendance. Prosecutor Moody delivered the opening statement, a civil engineer testified about the Borden house's layout, and the jury was granted permission to visit the scene in Fall River, though Miss Borden declined to join them.

Der Deutsche Correspondent · 8 June 1893 · page 1

Lizzie Borden's Prozeß.

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

See the clipping

Daily Kennebec Journal · Augusta, Me.

On the third day of Lizzie Borden's trial in New Bedford, witnesses including a civil engineer, a photographer, and John V. Morse testified about the Borden house layout and family details. Morse, brother of Borden's first wife, described his visit to the Borden home on August 3rd.

Daily Kennebec Journal · 8 June 1893 · page 1

j talk proceeded. Mr. Kiran, the civil engineer who was on j the stand yesterday, was recalled for the first witness. He resumed his testimony as I to the surrounding of the Borden premises, j cunstiuction of house, measurements and location of rooms, etc. He said the closet in the front hall of the Borden house was large enough to allow easily a man to enter ; it. The door could be shut easily . James A. Walsh of Kail River, photog rapher, was the next witness. He said he had taken photographs of the Burden prem ises at the request of the government.

See moreSee less

The photograph* were put in evidence and iden tified by the witness. John V . Morse then took the stand. He testified that he was 60 years of age, was a brother of Mr. Borden's first wife, and said that Lizzie Borden is 33 and that Kmma is 41. The witness visited the Bordens Wednesday. Aug. 3, went to Swansea in

See the clipping

Daily Kennebec Journal · Augusta, Me.

A civil engineer finished describing the Borden house layout and a closet large enough for a man to hide in, followed by a photographer identifying crime scene photos. John Morse then testified about his visit to the Bordens before the murders, his movements that morning, and details about the house's locks and lighting.

Daily Kennebec Journal · 8 June 1893 · page 1

THE BORDEN TRIAL

The words of this article are printed with the report it shares its clipping with. Read them there or in the clipping.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

Daily Kennebec Journal · Augusta, Me.

A defense witness testifies about activity at the Borden house after the murders, including a man seen bagging hatchets days later and contradicting police claims about the barn. Bridget Sullivan then takes the stand and describes locking doors and the Bordens' illness the day before the murders.

Daily Kennebec Journal · 8 June 1893 · page 1

the m#n since. At 11.25 the court took five minutes re cess. (luring which Miss Borden conversed with tier counsel while she nervously fin gered (her bottle of smelling salt*. Thq witnesses were called and five min

See the clipping

Daily Kennebec Journal · Augusta, Me.

The report covers testimony at Lizzie Borden's trial, including a witness describing finding Mrs. Borden's body and details about household routines. It notes that testimony from John Morse and Bridget Sullivan, expected to reveal new information, instead offered little new to the case, disappointing onlookers.

Daily Kennebec Journal · 8 June 1893 · page 4

Bowen Coates Neat. New Bel»oki>, Juue 7.—When it was made known today that John V. Morse, uncle of Lizzie Borden and Bridget Sulli van, servant of the Borden family at the time of the murder, were to testify the

See the clipping

Daily Kennebec Journal · Augusta, Me.

Ex-Governor Robinson cross-examined Bridget Sullivan without shaking her testimony, while Lizzie watched intently as John Morse testified, becoming emotional when describing finding the bodies. The court granted Lizzie a comfortable chair and discussed accommodations for her possible exhaustion during the proceedings.

Daily Kennebec Journal · 8 June 1893 · page 4

"UNCLE JOHN" AND BRIDGET

The reason for the absence from court of Emma Borden. Lizzie’s sister, and several other ladies, is that the) are government witnesses arid have been impounded. FAIRFIELD RACES. June 14 and 15. Will Have a Splendid Field

See the clipping

The Portland Daily Press · Portland, Me.

At the New Bedford trial, John V. Morse and Bridget Sullivan testified but offered little new information beyond what was already known from preliminary hearings. Lizzie Borden reacted visibly to both witnesses, and defense counsel's cross-examination of Sullivan failed to shake her testimony.

The Portland Daily Press · 8 June 1893 · page 1

UNCLE JOHN'S STORY

TRIAL AT NEW BEDFORD. The Two Witnesses Told Little That Was Not Already Known—The Prisoner Receives Some Consideration—Why Her Sister Is Not By Her Side—The “Star Chamber” Examination a Point at Issue. New Bedford, Mass., June 7.—When it was made known today that John V. Morse, uncle of Lizzie Borden, and

See the clipping

The Portland Daily Press · Portland, Me.

The report covers the cross-examination of servant Bridget Sullivan, who was not shaken by defense questioning, and the testimony of John Morse, who became emotional recalling the bodies and contradicted police claims about the barn search. It also notes courtroom accommodations for Lizzie and the defense's effort to exclude her earlier inquest statements.

The Portland Daily Press · 8 June 1893 · page 1

TRIAL AT NEW BEDFORD.

wiped his eyes. He answered Governor Robinson’s questions promptly. On the cross-examination, his testimony contra dicted the government’s claim that the officers searched the Borden barn imme diately after the murders. The court granted the prisoner the right to sit in a comfortable arm chair by Mr. Jennings’s side this afternoon. It is the intention of the court to hold long sessions each day but the prisoner will be given relief if necessary at any time. In case Lizzie should break down, the court will not be held Saturday or will make a temporary adjournment for a day or shorten the daily session.

See moreSee less

The reasoh for thajabsence from .the court of Emma Borden, Lizzie’s sister, and several oth er ladies is that they are government witnesses and have been impounded It is understood that the defence will endeavor to exclude the report of the •‘star chamber” examination to which Lizzie was subjected shortly after the murder. It is claimed that aslshe is here to testify, the statements she made then when not represented by counsel, should not be admitted.

See the clipping

The Portland Daily Press · Portland, Me.

John Morse, Lizzie Borden's uncle, testified about his visit to the Borden house on August 3-4, 1893, detailing his movements, sleeping arrangements, and the household routine the morning of the murders. He described the family relationships and the events of breakfast that Thursday morning.

The Portland Daily Press · 8 June 1893 · page 1

TRIAL AT NEW BEDFORD.

Uncle John’s Story. Morse testified in the forenoon. He said he was now living at South Dartmouth; he is 60 years old; he has lived there nearly a year; he came east three years ago last April; he was a brother of Mrs. Borden the first. The family relations having been estab lished, witness was asked when Mr. Bor den was first married, and said it was about 47 years ago; there were three children; one is dead; Mrs. Borden died in 1861; the child which died was younger than the others.

See moreSee less

Mr. Borden’s second marriage he could not remember. He said Lizzie was 33 and Emma 41 years old. On Wednesday, Aug. 3d last, he went to the Borden house; he had been a visitor there several weeks before; the last time saw Lizzie before that visit he could not place. He arrived at the Borden house at 1.30 on Wednesday.

See the clipping