As the Papers Told It

Lizzie Borden · The full archive

May 1893

175 articles

The Daily Herald · Brownsville, Tex.

At a Boston church, Rev. W. F. Hindman devoted his sermon to a plea for justice for Lizzie Borden, contrasting her lengthy imprisonment without trial to the lighter treatment of a convicted bank president. He argued the disparity suggested a breakdown of justice.

The Daily Herald · 1 May 1893 · page 1

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

The editorial comments on reports that Lizzie Borden's trial may occur next month, arguing that a speedy trial is both fair and desired by her supporters. It reflects on the principle that defendants should not be subjected to prolonged mental anguish awaiting trial.

The Providence News · 2 May 1893 · page 4

SmouLp it prove true, as reported, that Lizzie Borden will be tried next month, there will be rejoicing not only among the young woman's friends but also among those who believe that a person accused of committing a crime is entitled to a speedy as well as a fair and impartial trial. It is not the pur pose of the law to subject the accused to unnecessary mental torture, although, as in Miss Borden's case, it sometimes happens that months elapse between the indictment and the trial. Tue country must take a back seat.

See moreSee less

The scientists have provea that the cities are developing the finest type of woman that has existed, at least since the days of the Grreeks. The same may also be swid-of the men, though the im provement is not so pronounced as in the case of the women, for the reason that there was not quite the improve ment necessary, The cities are all right, and it is to be noted that the city people have improved much faster since they took to living so largely in the

See the clipping

New Ulm Review · New Ulm, Minn.

A roundup of the week's news items includes a brief note that Lizzie Borden's trial has been scheduled to begin in the term starting June 5. The item appears among many unrelated national and international news briefs.

New Ulm Review · 3 May 1893 · page 2

THE WEEK'S NEWS.

Lizzie Borden's trial has been fixed for the term beginning Jun 5. President Cleveland denies that the Russian treaty is a very bad document. The National Bank of Australasia at Melbourne fails, owing many millions of dollars r,ia*:33 vViman har. made an assign ment. His liabilities are estimated at Si.ooo.coo. .' -,-•*/ '-. .1 .* •!„. Repov*" ^a* been received from Brazil of atfotner bloody battle in Ri Grande do Sal which 800 were killed. Evans and Sontag. the California robbers, for the offiVers have been looking for some time, held up a stage

See the clipping

Morris Tribune · Morris, Minn. · and 1 other paper

This brief item from a weekly news roundup reports that Lizzie Borden's trial has been scheduled to begin on June 5. It appears amid a mix of unrelated national and international news items from late April and early May 1893.

Morris Tribune · 3 May 1893 · page 4

THE WEEK'S NEWS.

Monday, May 1. St. Paul capitalists are investing in I Black Hills mica mines. James B. Eustis, tho new French minister, has arrived at Paris. Lizzie Borden's trial has beeu fixed for the term beginning June 5. President Cleveland denies that the Russian treaty is a very bad document, The National Bank of Australasia at Melbourne fails, owing many millions of dollars. Erastus Wiinan has made an assign ment. His liabilities are estimated at $1,000,000. Report has been received from Brazil of another bloody battle in Rio Grande do Sul in which 800 were killed. Evans and Son tag, the California robbers, for whom the officers have been looking for some time, held up a stage

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • Oakes Weekly Republican · Oakes, N.D. · 5 May 1893

Mower County Transcript · Lansing, Minn.

A roundup of national and international news items includes a brief note that Lizzie Borden's trial has been fixed for the court term beginning June 5. The item appears amid unrelated stories on politics, finance, and other current events.

Mower County Transcript · 3 May 1893 · page 5

Monday, May 1. St. Paul capitalists are investing in Black Hills mica mines. James B. Eustis, the new French minister, has arrived at Paris. Lizzie Borden's trial has been fixed for the term beginning June 5. President Cleveland denies that the Russian treaty is a very bad document. The National Bank of Australasia at Melbourne fails, owing many millions of dollars. Erastus Wiman has made an assign ment. His liabilities are estimated at $1,000,000. Report has been received from Brazil of another bloody battle in Rio Grande do Sul in which 800 were killed. Evans and Sontag, the California robbers, for whom the officers have been looking for some time, held up a stage

See the clipping

Weekly Union · Manchester, N.H.

The Massachusetts superior court, after conference between counsel, has scheduled Lizzie Borden's trial to begin Monday, June 5, at New Bedford. The date is subject to change only if some reason arises to alter it.

Weekly Union · 3 May 1893 · page 1

Agsigned for Term Beginning June 5 at New Bedford. - “BosTON, May I.—The superlor court, upon conference and agreement of coun sel, has assigned the trial of Lizzie Borden for the term beginning Monday, Juue 5, at New Bedford, unless some reason hereaf ter appears to the contrary.

See the clipping

Connecticut Western News · Salisbury, Conn.

The report notes that Lizzie Borden has been held in jail for eight months awaiting trial, with public impatience growing over the state's delay. It contrasts her case with two other Massachusetts murder trials completed in the meantime, one acquittal and one execution.

Connecticut Western News · 4 May 1893 · page 1

A fair visitor. town came to see the visiting squadron. and all New York swelled the throng. Ex cursion steamers, packed on all decks with eager sightseers, cruised In and out among the cruisers, ironclads and battleships. One boat was capsized alongside the British ship Tartar, and two men were pulled out of the water by the sailors. The United States cruiser had a good many visitors, but nothing like the crowds that besieged the foreign vessels. The Santa Maria was black with visitors all day. Rear Admiral de Li bran entertained at dinner all of the other admirals, their staffs and the commander of the ships on the French flagship Arethuse. The Delay In the Borden Trial.

See the clipping

The Free Press · Poplarville, Miss.

A short item among news briefs states that the celebrated Lizzie Borden murder case will be tried at Fall River, Massachusetts, in June. No further details are given.

The Free Press · 4 May 1893 · page 2

The celebrated Lizzie Borden inutder case will he tried at Fad River, Mass., in June. A shipment of something over three carloads of strawberries was

See the clipping

The Monmouth Inquirer · Freehold, N.J.

The report notes public frustration at the slow pace of prosecuting Lizzie Borden, who had been jailed for eight months awaiting trial. It contrasts her case with two other Massachusetts murder trials completed in the meantime, one ending in acquittal and one in execution.

The Monmouth Inquirer · 4 May 1893 · page 8

The Delay In the Ilorden Trial. Boston, April 29.—Much impatience is ! being manifested by the public at the de i lay in trying Lizzie Borden, who has been i kept in jail for mouths awaiting the tardy j action of the law department of the com monwealth. Since she was imprisoned eight months ago, two persons in this state charged with murder have been tried, one of which was acquitted and the other suf fered the extreme penalty of the law.

See the clipping

The Sun · New York, N.Y.

Defense attorneys Robinson and Adams met with Jennings to discuss the upcoming trial, favoring Taunton over New Bedford for convenience. The prosecution prefers New Bedford, and no trial date has yet been set.

The Sun · 5 May 1893 · page 2

Bard Flchtlna at Long Islaael City Loci ISLAND Crrr May 4The trial bouts of the Empire City Clubs boxing tournament took place tonight in Puritan Hall Borden avenue Long Island City A large audience

See the clipping

The Washington Bee · Washington, D.C.

This item is a short news brief reporting that the trial of Lizzie Borden for the murder of her parents will probably begin in June at Fall River, Massachusetts. It appears among a list of unrelated telegraphic news briefs from around the world.

The Washington Bee · 6 May 1893 · page 4

TELEGRAPHIC BRIEFS.

The Ohio Republican State Convention will be held at Columbus on June 7 and 8, The old ticket will be renominated. It is probable that the trial of Lizzie Borden for the murder of her parents will begin in June, at Fall River, Mass. Senator Proctor, of Vermont, and two local capitalists will build at Kenville, Tenn., the largest marble mill in the world. The failure of the Union Loan and Trust Company, at Sioux City, Iowa, has carried down a number of business houses. The Canadian Pacific Railway officials have completed plans for a line of steamBhips between Vancouver and Sidney, Australia. For allowing Murderers Pallister and Roehl to escape from Sing Sing, Keepers Hulse, Murphy and Glynn have been t . dismissed.

See the clipping

The Neihart Herald · Neihart, Mont.

A roundup of weekly news items reports that Lizzie Borden's trial has been scheduled for the court term beginning June 5. The brief notice appears amid unrelated items on banking failures, strikes, and international affairs.

The Neihart Herald · 6 May 1893 · page 1

THE WEEK'S NEWS.

Monday, May 1. St. Paul capitalists are investing in Black Hills mica mines. James B. Eustis, the new French minister, has arrived at Paris. Lizzie Borden's trial has been fixed for the term beginning June 5. President Cleveland denies that the Russian treaty is a very bad document. The National Bank of Australasia at Melbourne fails, owing many millions of dollars. Erastus Wiman has made an assign ment. His liabilities are estimated at $1,000,000. Report has been received from Brazil of another bloody battle in Rio Grande do Sul in which 800 were killed. Evans and Sontag, the California robbers, for whom the officers have been looking for some time, held up a stage near Visalia Saturday.

See the clipping

The Carbon Advocate · Lehighton, Pa.

Amid a roundup of miscellaneous national and world news, the item reports that the trial of Lizzie Borden, called the alleged Fall River parricide, will begin on June 5. It appears as a single-line entry among unrelated stories like bank failures and storm damage.

The Carbon Advocate · 6 May 1893 · page 1

A WEEK'S NEWS CONDENSED

Sttturdar, April JED. The Second National bank of Columbia. Tenn., closed Its doors yesterday. It Is temporarily embarrassed. The Chinese land telegraph line has been Joined to the Russian system. Messages can now be sent to auy part of the world from any telegraph station In China, The Karalo Indians hare donned the war patnt. Eight settlers in the vicinity of their lands were killed by the Indians, and the government has sent troops to subdue the turbulent red men. Monday, May 1 The trial of Lizzie Borden, the alleged Fall Hirer parricide, will begin ou June 6.

See the clipping

The Times · Richmond, Va.

The report notes that Lizzie Borden's trial for the murder of her parents is scheduled to begin at Taunton, Mass., on June 6th, by which time she will have spent nearly a year in jail without bail. It criticizes the prosecution's delays as a flaw in the justice system, arguing she will have nearly served a murder sentence even if acquitted.

The Times · 6 May 1893 · page 4

The revolution in the Sandwich Islands is declared now to be a fixed fact, and there i8 no hope of a restoration of the monarchy. It is now left with the re public to decide whether there shall be annexation with the United States or not. The leaders of the Government now recog nize that if the islands become part of the territory of the United States, they must be governed according to their laws and constitution, and the questions of contract labor and native voting must both be settled. This will, in all likeli hood, prevent anything more than an nlliance, offensive and defensive, with this country being sought by the Ha wallan President. The trial of Lizzie Borden, accused of

See the clipping

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

A Boston dispatch reports Lizzie Borden's trial has been set for Monday, June 5, unless further delays arise. The editorial criticizes the nearly ten-month gap between the August murders and the upcoming trial, arguing justice demands a speedier process.

New-York Tribune · 8 May 1893 · page 6

“unless some reason lwreafter appears to the contrary.” At this distance it looks as if the burden of proof was upon the prosecuting authorities to how why there has been so mueh delay in bringing this case to trial. The Borden murders oecurred in August last, and the arrest of Lizzie Borden, and th action of the Coroner's jury in holding her for trial, followed afterward soon The inalienable right of every person accused of erime is a speedy trial, Such a trial would especially seem to be in order where a young woran is charged with the horrible crime of murdering her father and mother.

See moreSee less

There may be a wood eo planation tor the delay which has already Locenged, but surely nine or ten months ought to he ample time to ol tain all the evidence procurabie. In fact, halt that time would seem to he quite suflicient for the purpose. Strict regard for Justice requires that Lizzie Borden should be put on trial at the earliest day possible, and no further excise for delay shou!d be tolerated,

See the clipping

Waterbury Evening Democrat · Waterbury, Conn.

Lizzie Borden was secretly brought from Taunton Jail to New Bedford Superior Court and arraigned on three indictments for the murders of her father and stepmother. She pleaded not guilty and was described as composed, well-dressed, and showing little outward strain before being returned to jail.

Waterbury Evening Democrat · 9 May 1893 · page 1

LIZZIE BORDEN PLEADS NOT GUILTY TO THE CHARGE OF MURDER

She has been an inmate Of Taunton Jail ever sinoe August last, under Indictment for the murder, on Aug. 4, In Fall River, of her father, Andrew Jackson Borden, and her stepmother, Abble Durfee Borden. She was brought here to be arraigned in the Superior Court now in session in this city. The utmost secrecy was observed in bringing her here. - When Miss Borden was escorted rnp stairs to the court room she faltered, and leaned against the casing for a second, but immediately recovered her self possession and walked with a firm step along the Isle and took her place In the dock, uec.xace was flushed and her eyes turned, now to the right, then to the left and again to the celling or floor.

See moreSee less

However great may have been her men tal suffering during her Imprisonment she carries no outward sign ol It. - one is plump and has A good color, and her eyes are bright and. there are apparently no more lines than at the time of her arrest. She wore a dark, plainly made dress and a black double breasted sacque, small black hat, black vail and black gloves. Three indictments of two counts each were read to her. Two of them charged her with the murder of Andrew J. Bor den and Abble Durfee Borden separately, and the third charged her with the murder of both. At the end of each indictment the clerk asked: "Lizzie Andrew Borden, what say you to this indictment; are you guilty or not guilty!" and to each she replied clearly, calmly and steadily: ' 1 am not guilty." she did not seem to be stolid or stub born, but acted as if she was fully alive to the gravity of the situation. Andrew J. Jenkins , of Fall Rivef, who has been her faithful counsel all through, was present. Alter the arraignment was over. Mr. Jennings accompanied the sheriff, his wife and Miss Borden to the station, where the three took a train for Taunton, where Miss Borden will be again imprisoned un til her trial.

See the clipping

Waterbury Evening Democrat · Waterbury, Conn.

Lizzie Borden was secretly brought to Superior Court and arraigned on three indictments for the murders of her father and stepmother. She remained composed, pleading 'not guilty' to each charge before being returned to Taunton jail to await trial.

Waterbury Evening Democrat · 9 May 1893 · page 1

THE SUDDEN TRIP TO THE COURT

Three indictments of two counts each were read to her. Two of them charged her with the murder of Andrew J. Bor den and Abble Durfee Borden separately, and the third charged her with the murder of both. At the end of each indictment the clerk asked: "Lizzie Andrew Borden, what say you to this indictment; are you guilty or not guilty!" and to each she replied clearly, calmly and steadily: ' 1 am not guilty." she did not seem to be stolid or stub born, but acted as if she was fully alive to the gravity of the situation.

See moreSee less

Andrew J. Jenkins , of Fall Rivef, who has been her faithful counsel all through, was present. Alter the arraignment was over. Mr. Jennings accompanied the sheriff, his wife and Miss Borden to the station, where the three took a train for Taunton, where Miss Borden will be again imprisoned un til her trial.

See the clipping

The Herald · Los Angeles, Calif.

The piece discusses the heavy reliance on circumstantial evidence in several notable murder trials, including those of Mrs. Maybrick, Carlyle Harris, and Lizzie Borden. It notes that public sentiment regarding Borden's guilt has shifted and that her chances of conviction have lessened.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

The Herald · 9 May 1893 · page 4

Tnit execution of Oarlyle W. Harris calls attention to the great prominence of circumstantial evidence in murder cases. There have been a number of striking cases lately both in the United States and England as to which there hae been a very great division of senti ment. Amongst these was that of Mre. Maybrick, tried and convicted of poison ing her husband. Not less interesting was that of Lizzie Borden, in New Jersey, arraigned for having killed her aged father and step-mother with a hatchet. . Our own Bentley case also turned on purely circumstantial evidence.

See moreSee less

As to nil of these caßes there is grave reason ior doubting tho guilt of the accused. Millions of people on both sides of the A tlantic doubt the guilt of Mrs. May brick, yet phe was only prevented from being hanged by a reprieve which was wrung with great difficulty from Queen Victoria, who absolutely refused to par don her. Not even the fact that she was in wretched health would induce the queen to relent. In the Borden case

See the clipping

The Herald · Los Angeles, Calif.

Lizzie Borden was arraigned in New Bedford superior court on indictments for the murders of her father Andrew Borden and stepmother Abby Borden. She calmly pleaded not guilty to each count before being returned to Taunton jail to await trial.

The Herald · 9 May 1893 · page 6

She rieadg Not Guilty to the Indictments Againat Her. New Bedford, Mass., May B.—Lizzie Andrew Borden, who has been an in mate of Taunton jail ever since August laet, under indictment for the mnrder on AngUßt 4th, in Fall River, of her father! Andrew Jackson Borden, and step mother Abbie Lnrfee Borden, was ar raigned thie afternoon in the superior court of this city. The authorities sought to keep her arraignment quiet and preserve tne utmost secrecy. How ever great may have been her mental sufferings during ber imprisonment, sbe carried no outward sign of them.

See moreSee less

When the ripple of excite ment which marked her entrance into court had subsided tha district attorney moved tbat Mies Borden be arraigned, and the clerk of the conrt read slowly and solemnly the three indictments of two counts each. Two of them charged her with the murder of Andrew J. Bor den and Abbie LHtrfee Borden, separate ly, and the third charged her with the mnrder of botb. At the end of each in dictment sbe replied clearly, calmly and steadily, "I am not guilty." The conrt then adjourned, and Miss Borden was taken to faunton, where she will be im prisoned till ber trial.

See the clipping

In the story →

The Record-Union · Sacramento, Calif.

Lizzie Borden was arraigned in New Bedford Superior Court on three indictments related to the August 4th murders of her father Andrew Jackson Borden and stepmother Abbie Durfee Borden. She calmly pleaded not guilty to each charge before being returned to Taunton Jail to await trial.

The Record-Union · 9 May 1893 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

LIZZIE BORDEN ARRAIGNED

On Three Charges of Murder—She Pleads Not Guilty.

See moreSee less

NEW BEDFORD (Mass.), May 8.—Lizzie Andrew Borden, who has been an inmate of the Taunton Jail ever since August last, under indictment for the murder on August 4th, in Fall River, of her father, Andrew Jackson Borden, and her stepmother, Abbie Durfee Borden, was arraigned this afternoon in the Superior Court of this city. The authorities sought to keep the arraignment quiet, and preserved the utmost secrecy. However great has been her mental sufferings during her imprisonment, she carried no outward sign of them.

When the ripple of excitement which marked her entrance into court had subsided the District Attorney moved that Miss Borden be arraigned, and the Clerk of Court read slowly and solomnly three indictments of two counts each. Two of them charged her with the murder of Andrew J. Borden and Abbie Durfee Borden, separately, and the third charged her with the murder of both. At the end of each indictment she replied clearly, calmly and steadily: "I am not guilty." The court then adjourned and Miss Borden was taken back to Taunton, where she will be imprisoned till the trial.

See the clipping

The Wilmington Daily Republican · Wilmington, Del.

Lizzie Borden was arraigned in superior court in New Bedford on indictments for the murders of her father and stepmother, appearing composed despite months in jail. She stood as the charges were read and pleaded not guilty to the murders of Andrew and Abby Borden.

The Wilmington Daily Republican · 9 May 1893 · page 1

SHE FIRMLY PLEADS NOT GUILTY

! '' the time of her •rest. Wh tlie rippl».* of excitement which •krd her entrance had subsided the dis trict attorney moved that Miss Borden bo arraigned, and the clerk of the court said, "Lizzie Andrew Borden, stand up," and site did so, and looked steadily ut him, while he read slowly and solemnly three indictments of three counts each. T »1 them charged her with the murder of An drew J. Borden and Annie Durfee Bordeu, separately, and the third charged her with the murder of both. At the end of each in diet meat the clerk asked: "Lizzie Andrew Borden, what say you to this indictment— * you guilty or notguilty?"

See moreSee less

and to each she replied dearly, calmly aud steadily, .. . guilty." 1 The t was then adjourned, and after waiting a moment or two for tlie specta tors to disperse, Sheriff Wright, hi.-, wife and Miss Borden left the room and took the train and returned to Taunton. Till Broo . Miss., May 9.—The white

See the clipping

The Wilmington Daily Republican · Wilmington, Del.

At her arraignment, Lizzie Borden stood calmly as the clerk read three indictments charging her with the murders of her father and stepmother, separately and jointly. She answered the charges and was then returned by train to Taunton with the sheriff and his wife.

The Wilmington Daily Republican · 9 May 1893 · page 1

.. . guilty." 1 The t was then adjourned, and after waiting a moment or two for tlie specta tors to disperse, Sheriff Wright, hi.-, wife and Miss Borden left the room and took the train and returned to Taunton. Till Broo . Miss., May 9.—The white caps pleaded guilty and were sentenced to rears iu tlie penitentiary. There st affecting scene iu the court. The

See the clipping

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

Lizzie Borden was arraigned in superior court at New Bedford on the indictment for murdering her father and stepmother, pleading not guilty. The report describes her composed demeanor and the crowd that gathered to see her.

Evening Star · 9 May 1893 · page 8

LIZZIE BORDEN ARRAIGNED. be Pleasde Net Guilty to the Indletanents for Murder. Lizzie Andrew Borden, who has been an in iate of Taunton, Maw., jail ever since August at under indictment for the murder, on April in Fall River, of her father, Andrew Jackson orden, and her stepmother, Abbie Durfee orden, was arraigned yesterday afternoon in te superior court, now in session at New Bed >rd, Mass News of the coming of Miss Borden had tached the city before her arrival, and quite a amber of people had gathered, who looked.

See moreSee less

iriously, and in many cases not unsympathetic ly, at the woman who stands charged with te murder of her father and mother. On arriving at the court house Miss Borden as conveyed at once through the rear door to te district attorney's room, and remained tere till 5:15 o'clock, the court being occupied ith the trial of a civil case. Miss Borden was escorted upstairs to the nrt room. Sheriff Wright entering first, his ife following. and then. framed in the door

See the clipping

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

Lizzie Borden was brought to the New Bedford court house and arraigned on indictments for the murders of her father and stepmother. She pleaded 'not guilty' to each of the three counts read by the clerk, maintaining her composure throughout the brief proceeding.

Evening Star · 9 May 1893 · page 8

When the ripple of excitement which marked er entrance had subsided. the district attorney ioyed that Miss Borden be arraigned, and the erk of the court said: "Lizzie Andrew Borden. stand up." and she id so, and looked steadily at him while he read owly and solemnly three indictments of two )untt each. Two of them charged her with Ce murder of Andrew J. Borden and Abbie urfee Borden, separately, and the third iarged her with the murder of both. At the ad of each indictment the clerk asked: "Lizzie Andrew Borden, what say you to this idictment; are you guilty or not guilty?"

See moreSee less

and each she replied clearly, calmly and steadily: I am not guilty." The court then adjourned, end. after waiting moipent or two for the spectators to disperse, heriff Wright, his wife and Miss Borden left ie room and took the train and returned to

See the clipping

Rock Island Daily Argus · Rock Island, Ill.

Lizzie Borden was secretly transported from Taunton jail to New Bedford, where she was arraigned in superior court and pleaded not guilty to the charges against her. Her sister Emma accompanied her, and the trial was set to begin in early June.

Rock Island Daily Argus · 9 May 1893 · page 4

Another Celebrated Case. TACXTON-, Mass., May 9. Lizzie Borden wns taken from Tannton jail, hurried to the railway station in a close carriage in charge of Sheriff Wright nnd then taken to New Bedford, where she was arraigned in the superior court and pleaded not guilty. The utmost secrecy was observed, the sheriff going to New Bedford at 1 o'clock as a "blind," then coming back to get the prisoner. Mips Borden was look ing well but pale. Her sister Kmma was with her. Th e party returned here. The trial will come early in June.

See the clipping

The Wichita Daily Eagle · Wichita, Kan.

A brief note states that Lizzie Borden was arraigned at New Bedford to plead to the charge of murdering her father and her stepmother. The item appears amid other unrelated news items, including the execution of Carlyle W. Harris.

The Wichita Daily Eagle · 9 May 1893 · page 1

Harris' Written Statsment "Withheld From the Public for the Present Lizzie Borden Arra'gned at New Bedford to Plead to the Charge of Mnrdefng Her Pather

See the clipping

The Wichita Daily Eagle · Wichita, Kan.

Lizzie Borden was brought from Taunton jail to New Bedford superior court and arraigned on three indictments for the murders of her father, her stepmother, and both together. She pleaded not guilty to each charge, appeared composed though briefly faltering, and was returned to Taunton jail to await trial.

The Wichita Daily Eagle · 9 May 1893 · page 1

LIZZIE BORDEN ARRAIGNED. New BhDJOKD. Mass., May 8 Liz.ie Andrew Borden, who stands charged with one of the foulest crimes on the caleudnr the murder of her father and stepmother

See the clipping

The Evening Bulletin · Maysville, Ky.

Lizzie Borden, jailed since August on charges of murdering her father Andrew and stepmother Abby, was arraigned in New Bedford superior court. She pleaded not guilty to both indictments.

The Evening Bulletin · 9 May 1893 · page 1

Lizzie IIordAn In Court. New Bedford, Mass., May 0. Lizzie Borden, who has been an inmato of tho jail ever since August last, under in dictment for tho murdor on Aug. 4 in

See the clipping

Daily Kennebec Journal · Augusta, Me.

Lizzie Borden was arraigned in superior court at New Bedford on three indictments for the murders of her father Andrew Borden and stepmother Abbie Borden. She pleaded not guilty in a clear, calm voice and was returned to Taunton jail.

Daily Kennebec Journal · 9 May 1893 · page 1

LIZZIE BORDEN Pleaded Not Guilty to Charge of the Murder Of Her Father and Mother— Arraigned at New Bedford On Three Indictments—She Was Self-possessed—Voice Calm and Steady.

rakin to Niw Bedford Whirl Shi Will be Arraigned This Walk. Taunton. Mass., May 8.—Lizzie Borden iras taken from Taunton jail this afternoon it 3.25. She was hurried to the railway station in i closed carriage and. in charge of Sheriff Wright, Started for New Bedford at 5.30 to >e arraigned in the superior court on her ir rival. The utmost secrecy was observed. Miss Borden was looking well, but pale. Her lister Kmina was w ith her all the after »oon.

See the clipping

The Portland Daily Press · Portland, Me.

Lizzie Borden was arraigned in Superior Court in New Bedford on three indictments relating to the murders of her father and stepmother. She pleaded not guilty to each charge in a calm, steady voice before being returned to Taunton jail.

The Portland Daily Press · 9 May 1893 · page 1

New Bedford, May 8.—Lizzie An* drew Borden, under indictment for the murder, on August 4th, in Fall Biver, of her father, Andrew Jackson Borden, and her stepmother, Ahbie Durfee Borden, was this afternoon arraigned in the Supe rior Court in this city. She was arraign ed on three indictments, of two counts. Two charged her with the murder of Andrew J. Borden and Abbie Durfee Borden. separately. and the third chare ed her with the murder of both. She pleaded not guilty to each indictment. Her voice was clear, calm and steady, but she apparently was fully alive to the gravity of the situation. She was re turned to Taunton jail, from which she had been brought to appear in court.

See the clipping

St. Paul Daily Globe · Saint Paul, Minn.

Lizzie Andrew Borden, held in Taunton jail since August, was arraigned on three indictments in superior court for the murders of her father Andrew Jackson Borden and stepmother Abbie Durfee Borden. She pleaded not guilty.

St. Paul Daily Globe · 9 May 1893 · page 1

Lizzie Borden Arraigned. New Bedford, Mass., May B.— Lizzie Andrew Borden, who has been an in mate of Taunton jail ever since August last, under indictment for the murder, on August 4, in Fall Hiver.ot her father, Andrew Jackson Borden, and her step mother, Abbie Durfee Borden, was ar raigned on three indictments this after noon in the superior court, now in ses sion in ths city. She pleaded not guilty. ___■_

See the clipping

The Helena Independent · Helena, Mont.

Lizzie Borden was arraigned in New Bedford superior court on three indictments for the murders of her father Andrew and stepmother Abbie Borden. She calmly pleaded not guilty to each count before being returned to Taunton jail to await trial.

The Helena Independent · 9 May 1893 · page 1

She Pleads not Guilty to Three ladlet ments Charaing Murder. New BEDFORD. Mass., May 8.-Lizzie An drew Borden, who has been an inmate of Taunton jail ever since August last, under indictment for the murder on Aug. 4, in Fall River, of her father, Andrew Jackson Borden, and her stepmother. Abbie Durfee Borden, was arraigned this afternoon in the superior court of this city. The au thorities sought to keep the arraignment quiet and preserved the utmost secrecy. However great may have been her mental sufferings during her imprisonment, she carried no outward sign of them.

See moreSee less

When the ripple of excitement which marked her entrance into court subsided, the district attorney moved that Miss Bor den be arraigned and the clerk of the court read slowly and solemnly three indictments of two counts each. Two of them charge her with the murder of Andrew Jackson Borden and Abbie Durfee Borden, sepa rotely, and the third charges her with the murder of both. At the end of each in dictment she replied clearly, calmly and steadily. "I am not guilty." The court then adjourned and Miss Borden was taken back to Taunton, where she will be im. prisoned till trial.

See the clipping

Pawtucket Tribune · Pawtucket, R.I.

Lizzie Borden was arraigned in New Bedford superior court on charges of murdering her father and stepmother. She appeared calm and composed, entering a plea of not guilty.

Pawtucket Tribune · 9 May 1893 · page 1

PLEADS NOT GUILTY.

Fall River, of her father, Andrew Jacks: Borden, and her stepmother, Abbie Du fee Borden, was arraigned yesterday afte: noon in the superior court now in session in this city. News of the coming of Miss Borden had reached this city before her arrival, aud quite & nuwmber of people had gather:l. who looked curiously and in many ensc: not unsympathetically at the woman wu. stands charged with one of the foulest crimes in history, Miss Borden was escorted upstairs to the courtroom at 5:15 o’clock. Sheriff Wright entered first, his wife followed and then appeared Miss Borden.

See moreSee less

For the space, per haps, of a second, she faltered and leaned against the casing, but she immediately re covered her self-possession and walked with a firm step along the aisle and Took Her Place In the Dock.

See the clipping

Pawtucket Tribune · Pawtucket, R.I.

Lizzie Borden was escorted into the courtroom and formally arraigned on three indictments for the murders of her father and stepmother. She calmly pleaded 'not guilty' to each charge, appearing composed and unchanged in appearance since her arrest.

Pawtucket Tribune · 9 May 1893 · page 1

APPEARANCE NOT CHANGED

MISB LIZZIE RORDEN. At the end of each indictment the clerk asked: ‘‘Lizzie Andrew Borden, what say you to this indictment; are you guilty or not guilty?” W Lt " To each she replied, clearly, calmly and steadly, I am not guilty.” She did not seem to be stolid or stub born, but acted as if she was fully alive to the gravity of the situation, Andrew J. Jennings of Fall River, who has been her faithful counsel all through, was present, having come over on an earlier train. After the arraignment was over and Miss Borden had taken her seat, Mr.

See moreSee less

Jennings stepped forward and asked Judge Hammond if he would assign Counsel For Miss Borden. The judge asked who had been acting, and Mr. Jennings said he had, together with George D. Robinson and M. O.

See the clipping

Pawtucket Tribune · Pawtucket, R.I.

Lizzie Borden was arraigned and calmly pleaded not guilty before Judge Hammond, with attorney Andrew Jennings confirming her legal team of himself, George Robinson, and M.O. Adams. After the hearing, she was escorted back to the jail in Taunton to await trial.

Pawtucket Tribune · 9 May 1893 · page 1

ative. Judge Hammond said there appeared to be no necessity for the assignment of counsel and told Mr. Jonn!ufl he could enter the appearance of himself and Messrs. Robinson and Adams, The court then adjourned. Mr, Jen nings accompanied the sheriff, his wife and Miss Borden to the station, where the three took the 5:50 p. m. train for Taun. ton, where, in the jail, Miss Borden will be again imprisoned till her trial.

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

An opinion piece compares four criminal cases—Carlyle Harris, T. Thatcher Graves, Lizzie Borden, and Dr. Buchanan—to argue that circumstantial evidence often unfairly convicts the accused. It notes that Lizzie Borden was arraigned the previous day for the murder of her father and stepmother, stating that no plausible circumstantial evidence has yet been revealed against her.

The Providence News · 9 May 1893 · page 4

FOUR CASES, Carlyle Harris has been killed by legal process in New York upon evi dence that was scarcely better than purely circnmstantial, T. Thatcher Graves has missed the gallows merely by a hair's breadth, brought into imminent peril of his life by circumstantial evidence solely. Lizzie Borden was yesterday arraigned

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

An opinion piece argues that the justice system often fails to establish guilt fairly, citing the cases of Harris, Dr. Graves, Lizzie Borden, and Dr. Buchanan as examples where evidence was insufficient or trials unjust. It states that no sufficient evidence of guilt has yet been shown against Borden, as far as the public knows.

The Providence News · 9 May 1893 · page 4

FOUR CASES

Sufficient evidence to warrant a sus picion that she is guilty has not yet been adduced against Lizzie Borden, so far as the public knows. Dr. Buchanan, though a person who does not appeal to the sympathies of anybody, may be in nocent of the awful crime he is charged with, for all the evidence shows to the contrary. Each of these persons has been taken by the law, kept in prison as long as the law officers desired, and put upon the rack of trial for his life. Every resource of the state has been in each case employed to bring thein to death. Neither of them had an impartial trial, The claim that they had is not capable of being proven.

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

Lizzie Borden was finally arraigned for the murder of her father and stepmother after a long imprisonment, though no trial date was yet set. The piece notes public sympathy for the delay she endured and expresses hope the case will soon be resolved.

The Providence News · 9 May 1893 · page 4

MISS BORDEN'S CASE, After months of weary waiting Lizzie Borden was taken from prison yester day and arraigned for the murder of her father and step -mother, No date

See the clipping

San Antonio Daily Light · San Antonio, Tex.

A short news item reports that Lizzie Borden was arraigned at Taunton, Massachusetts, on charges of murdering her parents. It appears amid a roundup of unrelated national and international news briefs.

San Antonio Daily Light · 9 May 1893 · page 3

Lizzie Borden is arranged at Taunton, Mass., for the murder of her parents. Dr. Eli McClellan, U. S. A„ nephew of Gen. George B. McClel

See the clipping

The Salt Lake Herald · Salt Lake City, Utah

Lizzie Borden was brought before the supreme court in New Bedford and arraigned on three indictments for the murders of her father Andrew and stepmother Abby Borden. She pleaded not guilty to each charge and was returned to Taunton jail to await trial.

The Salt Lake Herald · 9 May 1893 · page 1

quiet and preserved the utmost secresy However great may have been her men tal sufferings during her imprisonment she cried no outward sign of them When the ripple of excitement which marked her entrance into court subsided the district attorney moved that Miss Borden be arraigned and the clerk of the court read slowly and solemnly three in dictments of two counts each Two of them charged her with the mur der of Andrew J Borden and Able Durfee Borden separately and the third charged her with the murder of both At the end of each indictment she replied clearly calmly and steadily Am not guilty I Court then adjourned and Miss Borden was taken back to Taunton where she

See the clipping

Alexandria Gazette · Alexandria, D.C.

Lizzie Borden was arraigned in court at New Bedford, Massachusetts, on charges of murdering her father and stepmother. She entered a plea of not guilty to the indictment.

Alexandria Gazette · 9 May 1893 · page 2

NEWS OF THE DAY.

in 1820. Lizzie Borden was arraigned in court at New Bedford, Mass., yesterday, and plead not guilty to the indictment charging her with the murder of her father aud stepmother.

See the clipping

Wheeling Register · Wheeling, W. Va.

The report states that Lizzie Borden was arraigned on a charge of murder and pleaded guilty, after which she was remanded to jail. It further claims that her trial would begin immediately.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

Wheeling Register · 9 May 1893 · page 1

• hmlth to FI (lit Deropnoy. Boston, Md'., May 5.—Judge Newton, of the Coney Island Athletic Club, met Billy Smith at tbe office of Capt. A. W. Cook to-day, and as a result of the nego tiations Smith signed an agreement to box Dempsev twenty ronnds, or until a decision «, rendered by the referee, at the Coney island Athletic Club, under its rules, on the eveniog of J une 30th, the contest to oe under Marquis of Queensbury rules, with five-ounce gloves, and such referee and time-keepers as the club selects, for 15,000, riven by tbe club, 15.500 to tbe wlaner and ISOO to tbe loser.

See moreSee less

Tbe principal* are not to exceed 142 pounds, and tbe forfeit is *300. Portland, Or*., May*.—Jack Demptey has received *300 for expenses from the Coney Island Club, and has agreed to fight Smith for a purse of *5,000. Miss Lizzie Borden was arraigned on tbe charge of mnrder, and pleaded guilty. »be was remanded to jaiL Tbe trial will be gin at once. Tbe National banks have been called on h.nifah to the Treasury a st—fit of cate of the cause or Harris ueain, anu then drovo Into the prison grounds through the southeasterly gate. In his wagon was a highly polished oak casket which was carried into the death cham ber. where the body of Harris, dressed In a dark suit of prison made goods, re posed upon a table. The body was placed in the casket. The undertaker refused to disclose the plans for the disposition of the body. The silver plate upon the cover of the casket con tained this Inscription:

See the clipping

The Cheyenne Daily Leader · Cheyenne, Wyo.

Lizzie Borden, held in Taunton jail since August on charges of murdering her father and stepmother, was formally arraigned in New Bedford superior court. She pleaded not guilty and was returned to jail to await trial.

The Cheyenne Daily Leader · 9 May 1893 · page 1

Lizzie Borden on Trial. New Bedford, Mass., May 8. —Lizzie Andrew Borden, who has been an inmate of the Taunton jail ever since August last

See the clipping

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

A dispatch from New Bedford, Massachusetts confirms that Lizzie Borden's trial will be held there, beginning the first Monday in June. Chief Justice Mason will preside, with Judges Blodgett and Dewey likely serving as his associates.

New-York Tribune · 10 May 1893 · page 2

THE BORDEN TRIAL TO BEGIN JUNE b. New-Bedford, Mass., May 9 (8pecial).—It is definitely announced that the trial of Lizzie Borden will be held here. The trial will begin the first Monday in June.

See the clipping

The Indiana State Sentinel · Indianapolis

Lizzie Borden was arraigned in superior court in New Bedford on indictments for the murders of her father and stepmother. She calmly pleaded 'not guilty' to each of the three indictments despite efforts to keep the proceeding secret.

CorrectionThis set right 2 earlier articles: The Herald, 9 May 1893, Wheeling Register, 9 May 1893.

The Indiana State Sentinel · 10 May 1893 · page 1

SHE CALMLY PLEADED NOT GUILTY TO EACH OF THE COUNTS. Tim Authorities Sought to Keep Her Ar. rnlgumeiit in Court Oulet, Hut the Srrrct (iot Out mid Caused Ouite n Commotion Ileturneit to I'rlsou to Awult Trial. New r.F.Kroiu), Mans., May H. Lizzie Andrew Borden, who has been an inmate of the Taunton jail since August last, under indictment for the murder on Aug. 4, in Fall Kiver. of her father, Andrew Jackson Borden, ond her step mother, Abbie Durlee Borden, was ar raigned this afternoon in the superior court, now in session in this city.

See moreSee less

The authorities sought to keep the arrange ment quiet and preservo the utmost secrecy. News ot the coming of Miss Borden had, however, reached this city, and caused a commotion. On arrival at the coyrt bouse she was conducted to the district attorney's room and remained there till o:l" o'clock, tho court be.ng oc cupied. Miss llor len was then l-jcn rted upstairs to the court-room. The district attornov moved that Miss Korden lie ar raigned tud the clerk of the court said: "Lizzie Andrew Boideu, stand up," an i she did so, and looked steadily at him while he read slowly and solemnly three indictments of two counts each. Two of them chartred her with the inirder of An drew J. Borden and A blue Durfce Mor den, separately, and the third charged her with the murder of both. At the end oi each indictment the clerk aske I, "Lizzie Andrew Borden, what say you to this in dictment, are you guilty or not guilty'.'" and to each ehe replied clearly, calmly and steadily, "I am not guilty." Judge Hammond said there appeared to be no necessity for the assignment of counsel, and told Mr. Jennings l.e could enter tho apienrance of himt-elf and Messrs. George D. Kobinson and M. '. Adams, The court was then adjourned, and alter waiting a moment or two for the spectators to disperse, Sherill W tight, his wife and Miss Borden left the room, and in company with Mr. Jennings proce.-ded to the room of District-Attorney Knowi ton, where they stopped till it was time tog to the tram. Mr. Jennings accom panied tho sbeiid, his wife nnd Mis Borden to the station, whiro the three took tho ö:."0 p. m. train for Taunton, where .Miss Borden will be a'ain im prisoned until her trial.

See the clipping

The Indiana State Sentinel · Indianapolis

Lizzie Borden was brought before the court and arraigned on three indictments charging her with the murders of her father and stepmother, separately and jointly. To each count she clearly answered 'I am not guilty,' after which the court adjourned and she was escorted back to Taunton jail to await trial.

The Indiana State Sentinel · 10 May 1893 · page 1

TO EACH OF THE COUNTS

Ileturneit to I'rlsou to Awult Trial. New r.F.Kroiu), Mans., May H. Lizzie Andrew Borden, who has been an inmate of the Taunton jail since August last, under indictment for the murder on Aug. 4, in Fall Kiver. of her father, Andrew Jackson Borden, ond her step mother, Abbie Durlee Borden, was ar raigned this afternoon in the superior court, now in session in this city. The authorities sought to keep the arrange ment quiet and preservo the utmost secrecy. News ot the coming of Miss Borden had, however, reached this city, and caused a commotion.

See moreSee less

On arrival at the coyrt bouse she was conducted to the district attorney's room and remained there till o:l" o'clock, tho court be.ng oc cupied. Miss llor len was then l-jcn rted upstairs to the court-room. The district attornov moved that Miss Korden lie ar raigned tud the clerk of the court said: "Lizzie Andrew Boideu, stand up," an i she did so, and looked steadily at him while he read slowly and solemnly three indictments of two counts each. Two of them chartred her with the inirder of An drew J. Borden and A blue Durfce Mor den, separately, and the third charged her with the murder of both. At the end oi each indictment the clerk aske I, "Lizzie Andrew Borden, what say you to this in dictment, are you guilty or not guilty'.'" and to each ehe replied clearly, calmly and steadily, "I am not guilty." Judge Hammond said there appeared to be no necessity for the assignment of counsel, and told Mr. Jennings l.e could enter tho apienrance of himt-elf and

See the clipping

The Portland Daily Press · Portland, Me.

Reports indicate Lizzie Borden will be transferred to New Bedford several days before her June trial begins, to avoid crowds at the train stations in Taunton and New Bedford. She will stay in a cell at the women's prison, where Bridget Sullivan, a former servant in the Borden household, now works for the jail keeper.

The Portland Daily Press · 10 May 1893 · page 1

EARLY TO AVOID THE CROWD. Lizzie Borden Will Go to Fall River tc Await Her Trial. New Bedford, Mass., May 9.—It it said on good authority that Lizzie Bor

See the clipping

Morris Tribune · Morris, Minn.

Lizzie Borden was arraigned in New Bedford, Massachusetts, on charges of murdering her father and mother. She pleaded not guilty to the charges.

Morris Tribune · 10 May 1893 · page 1

It is rMQore* that Scott win™ of the Treasury Spaulding. Mr. Gladstone has appointed John I Buskin, tho art critic, poet laureate, to succeed the late Lord Tennyson. Lizzie Borden has been arraigned at I New Bedford, Mass., on the charge of murdering lier father and mother. She plead not guilty.

See the clipping

Mower County Transcript · Lansing, Minn.

The report notes that Lizzie Borden was arraigned in New Bedford, Massachusetts, on charges of murdering her father and mother. She entered a plea of not guilty.

Mower County Transcript · 10 May 1893 · page 3

Agent Plummer. It is ramorod that Sootfc Wilka of Illinois will succeed Assistant Secretary of the Treasury Spaulding. Mr. Gladstone has appointed John Ruskin, the art critic, poot laureate, to succeed the late Lord Tennyson. Lizzie Borden has been arraigned at New Bedford, Mass., on the charge of murdering her father and mother, She plead not guilty.

See the clipping

The Helena Independent · Helena, Mont.

A newspaper opinion column mentions that the next major murder trial will be that of Lizzie Borden, noting the case will rest entirely on circumstantial evidence. It adds a wry comment that juries currently favor such evidence.

The Helena Independent · 10 May 1893 · page 4

THE next great murder trial will be that of Lizzie Borden, the result of which will depend wholly on circum stantial evidence, which, by the way, seems in high favor with juries these

See the clipping

The North Platte Tribune · North Platte, Neb.

Lizzie Borden was arraigned in New Bedford superior court on three indictments for the murders of her father and stepmother. She calmly pleaded 'not guilty' to each count before being returned to Taunton jail to await trial.

The North Platte Tribune · 10 May 1893 · page 1

LIZZIE BORDEN ARRAIGNED. ofthttip-jj She Plead XCot Guilty to Each dictmentH. Kcw Bedford, Mass., May 9. Lizzie Andrew Borden, who ha3 been au in mate of Taunton jail ever since August last, under indictment for the murder, on Aug. 4, in Fall River, of her father, Andrew Jackson Borden, and her step mother, Abbie Durfee Borden, was ar raigned in the superior court of this city. Wben tho ripple of excitement which marked her entrance into the court had subsided the district attorney moved that Miss Borden be arraigned and the clerk of the court read slowly and solemnly the three indictments of two counts each.

See moreSee less

Two of them charged her with the mnrder of Andrew J. Bor den and Abbie Durfee Borden, separ ately, and the third charged her with the murder of both. At the end of each -indictment she re plied clearly, calmly and steadily. ''I am hot guilty." The court then adjourned and Miss Borden was taken back to Taunton, where she will be imprisoned till her trial.

See the clipping

Paper unidentified

The report notes that Lizzie Borden, charged with murdering her father and stepmother, was arraigned on Monday and pleaded not guilty. It highlights that she has been jailed since August but remains in good health, and notes no blood was found on her clothing and the murder weapon was never recovered.

Paper unidentified · 10 May 1893 · page 2

The trial of Lizzie Borden, who is charged with the murder of her father and of her step mother in Massachusetts, was arraigned on Monday, and plead not guilty. She

See the clipping

The State Chronicle · Raleigh, N.C.

The report states that Lizzie Borden was arraigned on Monday for the murders of her father and stepmother in Massachusetts and pleaded not guilty. It notes she has been jailed since the previous August, remains in good health, and that no blood was found on her clothing nor has the murder weapon been identified.

The State Chronicle · 10 May 1893 · page 2

now filling. a somewhat fuller acount of the subject in the Atlanta Constitution, from which it appears that the President does not propose to sus tain his old law partner BisRell in this particular matter. We are very glad to have this information. Else where will be found the extract from the Constitution. The trial of Lizzie Borden, who is charged with the murder of her

See the clipping

Weekly Union · Manchester, N.H.

Lizzie Borden was arraigned in New Bedford superior court on indictments for the murders of her father and stepmother. She pleaded 'not guilty' to each of three indictments read to her.

Weekly Union · 10 May 1893 · page 1

LIZZIE BORDEN. Her Arraignment at New Bedford, on the Charge of Murder.

«],izzle Andrew Borden, stand up,” and she did so, and looked steadlly at him while he read slowly and solemnl,\i‘ three indictments of two counts each. Two of them charged her with the murder of. An drew S. Borden and Abble Durfee Borden separately, and the third charged her with the murder of both. At the end of each indictment the clerk asked, ¢“Lizzle An drew Borden, what say you to this indict ment, are you guilty or not gutlty?”’ and to each she repiled clearly, calmly and steadily, S 5 _ “Y Am Not Guilty.” She did not seem to be stolld orstubborn but acted as If she was fullyalive to the gravity of the situatlon.

See moreSee less

Andrew J. Jennings of Fall River, wko has been her faithful counsel all through, was present, having come over on an earlier train. After the arralgnment was

See the clipping

Weekly Union · Manchester, N.H.

Lizzie Borden stood before Judge Hammond as three indictments for the murders of Andrew and Abby Borden were read, and she pleaded not guilty to each. Her attorney Andrew Jennings had his appearance, along with co-counsel Robinson and Adams, entered as acceptable, and Borden was then returned by train to Taunton jail to await trial.

Weekly Union · 10 May 1893 · page 1

VOLUME 4% NUMESa 15 and Mr. Jenninzé"‘s\‘* : he had to&ether with George D. Robinson and M. O. Adams, Judge Hammond asked {f this counsel was acceptable to Miss Borden and Mr. Jennings answered in the affirmative. Judge Hammond said there appears to be no necessity for the assignment of counsel and told Mr. Jennings he could enter the appearance of himself and Messrs. Robin son and Adams. The court was then adiourned and affer walting a moment or two for the spectators to disperse, Sheriff Wright, his wife and Miss Borden left the room and in company with Mr.

See moreSee less

Jennings proceeded to the room of District Attorney Knowlton, where they stopped tlll 1t was time to go to the train. Mr. Jennings accompanied the sheriff, his wife and Miss Borden to the station,

See the clipping

The Evening World · New York, N.Y.

The report confirms that Lizzie Borden's murder trial will be held in New Bedford, opening on the first Monday in June (June 5). It notes that Marshal Hilliard of Fall River met with District Attorney Knowlton to discuss the case, and that Chief Justice Mason will preside.

The Evening World · 10 May 1893 · page 6

LIZZIE BORDEN'S TRIAL.

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

See the clipping

Daily Independent · Elko, Nev.

The brief reports that Lizzie Borden, indicted for murdering her father and step-mother last August, was arraigned the previous afternoon. She entered a plea of not guilty.

Daily Independent · 10 May 1893 · page 3

Preceptor?Of course you want to I go to heaven, Willie? Willie?I I should say not. I ain't enough stuck j on pulling off grandpa's boots for I that. Lizzie Borden, the Massachusetts I girl indicted for murdering her father 1 and step-mother last August, was ar raigned yesterday afternoon and plead I not guilty. Boston Transcript:?The best ban-1 <iuet that man ever sat down to was never relished half so heartily as the core of his chum's apple away back in primary-school days.

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

The report announces that Lizzie Borden's murder trial will be held at the courthouse in New Bedford, Massachusetts, beginning the first Monday in June. Chief Justice Mason will preside, with Judges Blodgett and Dewey likely serving as associates, and arrangements are being made for press accommodations.

The Providence News · 10 May 1893 · page 7

FIRST MONDAY IN JUNE Is Assigned as the Date For the Trial of Lizzie Borden. NEwW BEDFORD, Mass., May 10 - All doubt as to the fact that the trial of Liz

See the clipping

San Antonio Daily Light · San Antonio, Tex.

A newspaper's miscellaneous editorial column notes that with the Harris case concluded, the Lizzie Borden case now demands public attention as equally sensational. It remarks that in neither case will the full facts be known until time reveals all secrets.

San Antonio Daily Light · 10 May 1893 · page 2

Ie Uncle Sam’s credit is not good enough in Europe to have his notes accepted at par Wall street cannot help him out. The people who do not want U. S. currency do not have to take it. It is in order to say, take it or quit trading. The Harris case having been eternally disposed of, the Lizzie Borden case now demands atten

See the clipping

The Roanoke Times · Roanoke, Va.

Lizzie Borden, jailed since August on charges of murdering her father and stepmother, was arraigned in New Bedford superior court. She calmly stated 'I am not guilty' before being returned to Taunton jail.

The Roanoke Times · 10 May 1893 · page 6

She Answers the Charge of Murder After Months In Jail. New BEDFORD, Mass., May 0.?Lizzie Andrew Horden, who has been an inmate of Taunton jail ever since August last, under indictment for tho murder, on Au? gust. 4, in Fall River, of her father, An? drew Jnekson Borden, and her step? mother, Abbie Dnrfeo Burden, 'was ur raigned in tbe superior court now in ses siou iu this city. On arriving at the court? house Miss Borden was conveyed at onco through the rear door to the district attor? ney's room.

See moreSee less

She was escorted upstairs to the court? room. Sheriff Wright entering first, his wife followed, and then, framed in a door? way, appeared Miss Borden. For the spuce perfiajw of a second she faltered nnd leaned against the casing, but she immediately re ?covered l>er -self-possession nnd walked with a firm -step along the aisle and took her place in the dock. When the excite? ment which marked her entrance had sub? sided the district attorney moved that Miss Borden be arraigned and the clerk of the ?court said: "Lizzie Andrew Borden stand tip.** and she did so, and looked steadily nt him, while lie read slowly and solemnly three indictments of two counts each. She replied clearly, calmly nnd steadily: "I am not guilty." The court adjourned ami Sheriff Wright, bis wife and Miss Borden took the train and returned to Taunton.

See the clipping

Alexandria Gazette · Alexandria, D.C.

A news digest reports that Lizzie Borden's trial for the murder of her father and stepmother will be held in New Bedford, Massachusetts. The trial is scheduled to begin on the first Monday in June.

Alexandria Gazette · 10 May 1893 · page 2

The trial of Lizzie Borden for the murder of her father and stepmother is to be held in New Bedford, Mass., be? ginning on the first Monday in June.

See the clipping

Wheeling Register · Wheeling, W. Va.

The newspaper notes that a typographical error in yesterday's edition made it appear Lizzie Borden pleaded guilty to murder. It clarifies that the plea was actually "not guilty."

Wheeling Register · 10 May 1893 · page 4

Sioux Iudians. Mb. Mahay thinks the bills his physicians sent lnforsavin? his life are loo big. Mahay ought to be a good judge of what his life is worth. The closing of the World’s lair on Sunday with the rest of wicked Chicago wide open presents a horridly correct illustration of the Sunday closing idea in practice. In the nows columns of yesterday’s Register, a typographical error caused Miss Lizzie Borden to plead guilty to the charge of murder. It should have read “not guilty.”

See the clipping

The Oskaloosa Herald · Oskaloosa, Iowa

Lizzie Borden, held in Taunton jail since August under indictment for murdering her parents, was arraigned before Judge Hammond in superior court. She pleaded not guilty and was remanded to jail to await trial set for early June.

The Oskaloosa Herald · 11 May 1893 · page 3

Lizzie Borden Arraigned. New Bedford, Mass., May 10. —Lizzie Borden, who has been confined in the Taunton jail ever since last August under indictment for the murder of her father and mother August 4, in Fall River, was on Monday afternoon ar raigned before Judge Hammond in the superior court. She pleaded not guilty, and was remanded to jail to await trial, which will take place early in June.

See the clipping

The Indianapolis Journal · Indianapolis, Ind.

A short wire-service item states that Lizzie Borden's trial will begin at New Bedford, Massachusetts, on June 4. It appears among a list of unrelated news brevities from around the country.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

The Indianapolis Journal · 11 May 1893 · page 2

TELEGRAPHIC BREVITIES. The trial of Lizzie Borden will begin at New Bedford, Mass., June 4. Three of the English war vessels and tho !' i lift

See the clipping

Ellsworth American · Ellsworth, Me.

This report mainly discusses a Governor Flower's clemency controversy for a convicted murderer named Harris in New York. It makes a brief comparison to Lizzie Borden, suggesting she languishes in jail without enough evidence to justify her committal.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

Ellsworth American · 11 May 1893 · page 2

Poor Lizzie Borden, languishing in a Massachusetts jrragainst whom all the legal wit of the old Commonwealth ha not been able to dig up testimony enough to justify committal, might thank her stars for one-twentieth part of the atten tion and kindness which have been so iavi-hlv bestowed upon New York's last convicted murderer Governor Flower yielded, and under a peculiar statute of the State, directed, not a legal, but a layman .- re-examination into the facts of the case, under which the same result that all the courts had arrived at was reached, and *hen the announce ment was made from the executive cham:*er that the law must hold its way.

See moreSee less

Justice hahail a hard time in getting itaeif done, but it is a relief to know that at last it has been done. Summoned to New and Broader Fields of Labor.

See the clipping

Ellsworth American · Ellsworth, Me.

A roundup of national news briefs includes a note that Lizzie Borden's defense team would prefer the trial be held in Taunton, Massachusetts. The item appears amid unrelated stories on financial panics, crimes, and deaths from around the country.

Ellsworth American · 11 May 1893 · page 2

There is little proability that Murderer Almy will commit suicide-Sudden death of Hon. James W. Patterson at Han over. N.H.-Death of JudgeN. W. Shores of Great Barrington, Mass.-The defense in the Borden case would prefer to have the trial take place in Taunton

See the clipping

Ellsworth American · Ellsworth, Me.

Lizzie A. Borden was arraigned in the superior court at New Bedford, Massachusetts, on charges of murder. She entered a plea of not guilty.

Ellsworth American · 11 May 1893 · page 2

other badly injured iu Philadelphia Lizzie A. Borden was arraigned iu the superior court at New Bedford. Mass., and I :• uled not guilty of murder-Ex-Presi dent <I» n/.ales <if Mexico is again reported dead-The libel against the Chilian steamer Itata haa been di.-missed by the l uited states circuit court of appeals at ban Francisco.

See the clipping

The Worthington Advance · Worthington, Minn.

The report states that the trial of Lizzie Borden for the murder of her parents began at New Bedford, Massachusetts. It gives only this brief notice without further detail.

The Worthington Advance · 11 May 1893 · page 2

ing the world's fair on Sundays and deV- LONDON, May 5.—The British steamer A manded that the grounds be thrown City of Khios, from Calcutta, April 8 open to the public on that day. for London, while off Beachy Head TH* trial of Lizzie Borden for the Wednesday night collided with an nn muttiet of her parents began at New known schooner whieh it is feared Bedfotd, Mass., the fttb. (. .* went down with all on board.: Thfe THE world's fair gronnds were iliumsteamer sustained damage forwardl" heated by electricity the night of the Failure la Chlca**. CHICAGO, May 6.'—The Consolidated Mtajr v.'—VUUBUlUl^bett A BOUT 700 horwahpers in Chicago Copy company, doing a picture frame wept on a strike tKe.Sth. business-at 156 West Van Buren street.

See the clipping

Paper unidentified

Lizzie Borden was arraigned in superior court in New Bedford on charges of murdering her father and stepmother in Fall River the previous August. She appeared calm and composed despite a brief falter upon entering, and authorities had tried to keep the proceeding quiet though a crowd still gathered.

Paper unidentified · 11 May 1893 · page 1

SHE PLEADS NOT GUILTY

TKe Grind Befftna. New Bedford, Mass., May 9.—Liszie Andrew Borden, who has been an inmate of Taunton jail ever since August last, under indictment for the murder on Aug. 4, in Fall River, of her father, Andrew Jackson Bordeu, and her stepmother, Abbie Durfee Borden, was arraigned this afternoon in the superior court. The au thorities sought to keep the arraignment quiet, and preserved the utmost secrecy. News of the coining of Miss Bordeu had, however, reached this city before the ar rival, and quite a number of people had gathered, who looked curiously and in many cases not unsynipathetieally at the woman who stands charged with one of the foulest crimes 011 the calendar.

See moreSee less

-On arrival at the court house Miss Borden was conveyed at once through the rear door to the district attorney's room, and remained there till 5:15 o'clock, the court being occupied with the trial of a civil case. Miss Borden was then escorted up stairs to the court room. For the space perhaps of a second she faltered, and leaned a&ainst the casing, but she imme diately regained her self possession, and walked with a firm step along the aisle and took her place iu the dock. However great may have been her mental suffer ings during her imprisonment, she carried no outward sign of them. When the rip ple of excitement which marked her eu tranee had subsided, the district attotney moved that Miss Borden be arraigned, and the clerk of the court, Simeon Bor deu, Esq., said "Lizzie Andrew Borden, stand up," and she did so, and looked steadily at him while he read slowly and solemnly three indictments of two counts each. Two of them charged her with the murder of Andrew J. Bordeu and Abbie Durfee Borden, separately, and the third charged her with the murder of both. At the end of each indictment the clerk asked: "Lizzie Andrew Borden, what say you to this indictment are you guilty or

See the clipping

Paper unidentified

Lizzie Borden was brought to court and arraigned on three indictments for the murders of Andrew and Abbie Borden, pleading 'not guilty' to each count in a calm, steady voice. Her counsel Andrew Jennings was present, and the court approved additional attorneys George D. Robinson and M. D. Adams before she was returned to Taunton jail to await trial.

Paper unidentified · 11 May 1893 · page 1

ARRAIGNED.

The words of this article are printed with the report it shares its clipping with. Read them there or in the clipping.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

St. Paul Daily Globe · Saint Paul, Minn.

A dispatch from New Bedford, Massachusetts announces that the Lizzie Borden murder trial will be called the first Monday in June at the local courthouse. Chief Justice Mason is named as the presiding judge.

St. Paul Daily Globe · 11 May 1893 · page 6

L/fzzie Korden's Trial. Nrcw Bedford. Mass., May 10.— The Lizzie Borden murder case will be called tho first Monday in June at the court house In this city. Chief Justice MasoD will preside at the trial.

See the clipping

Bridgeton Pioneer · Bridgeton, N.J.

Lizzie Borden was arraigned on charges of murdering her parents and pleaded not guilty. She was returned to Taunton jail afterward.

Bridgeton Pioneer · 11 May 1893 · page 5

Lizzie Borden Pleads Not Guilty

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

See the clipping

The Sun · New York, N.Y.

The report announces that Lizzie Borden's trial will be held in New Bedford, Massachusetts, beginning the first Monday in June, with Chief Justice Mason presiding. It also notes an unconfirmed rumor that another hatchet, possibly linked to a different case, has been found in Fall River.

The Sun · 11 May 1893 · page 7

and at the conclusion of tho business of the Superior Court on Saturday Judge Hammond will flue the order assigning the date and place of the trial This order will bl served on Lizzie Borden at Taunton jaiL Marshal Hllllard of Fall Itlver who Is In charge of the police work on the Borden visited Now Bedford case Tiliod yester

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

This brief, sarcastic newspaper item jokes that Providence should supply more hatchets to the prosecutors of Lizzie Borden, mocking the number of hatchets that have been claimed as murder weapons. It reflects public skepticism about the physical evidence being gathered ahead of her trial.

The Providence News · 11 May 1893 · page 4

RIGHT TO THE POINT

BN ;A The emperor of Germany has rolled up his sleeves and molstened his hands, and ne says the German people bave got to have that military bill. Such threats have been made before, and by better men than Wilhelm, and have comne to nought. g R S Sl It the prosecutors of Lizzie Borden want more hatchets we invite them t» come to Providence for their next lot, This city feels that 1t has been neg lvcted in the matter of the finding of Borden hatchets.

See the clipping

Burlington Weekly Free Press · Burlington, Vt.

Lizzie Borden was secretly transported from Taunton jail to New Bedford for her formal arraignment in Superior Court on charges of murdering her father and stepmother. She pleaded not guilty to the indictments before being returned to her cell.

Burlington Weekly Free Press · 11 May 1893 · page 2

"I AM NOT GUILTY" THE REPLY OF LIZZIE BORDEN ON FORMAL ARRAIGNMENT. fiber (T Wright Tnloi Her yuletly Trom Tituntoii Jul! tn Now lleilford, Whoro

See the clipping

Burlington Weekly Free Press · Burlington, Vt.

Lizzie Borden arrived by train and was escorted under guard to the New Bedford court house, where she waited in the district attorney's office until called. She was formally arraigned on three indictments for the murders of Andrew and Abby Borden, pleading 'not guilty' clearly to each.

Burlington Weekly Free Press · 11 May 1893 · page 2

FORMAL ARRAIGNMENT.

to come off. Miss Borden was escorted upstairs to the court room at 0:15 o'clock. Bberill Wright entered first, his wife followed, and thun framed in the doorway appeared Miss Bor

See the clipping

Burlington Weekly Free Press · Burlington, Vt.

Lizzie Borden was formally arraigned before Judge Hammond on three indictments related to the murders of Andrew and Abbie Borden, pleading 'not guilty' calmly to each count. After the proceeding, she was escorted by the sheriff and her counsel Jennings to the train for Taunton, where she would be held until trial, which her defense team hopes to expedite.

Burlington Weekly Free Press · 11 May 1893 · page 2

FORMAL ARRAIGNMENT.

veil and black glovos. When tbe ripple of excitement which marked her entrance had subsided, the dis trlct attorney moved that Mils Borden be arraigned and tbe clerk of the court, BLnieon Borden, 06q,, said: '"Lizzie Andrew JJor den, stand up," and she did so, and looked steadily nt him while ho read blowly and solemnly three indictments of two counts each. Two of them charged her with the murder of Andrew J, Borden and Ahbie Durfeo Borden separately and tho third oharged her with the murder of both. At the end of each indictment tbe clerk aBked, "Lizzio Androw Borden, what say you to this indictment, ore you guilty or not guilty r" And to onchshe replied clearly, calmly and steadily, "I am not guilty.'

See moreSee less

Bhe did not seem to be stolid or stubborn but acted nt if tho was fully allvo to tbe gravity of tbe situation. Andrew J. Jen nings of Fall River, whoihas been her faith f ul counsel all through, was proseut, hav ing come over on an earlier train. Aftor tho arraignment was over and Miss Borden had taken hert seat, Mr. Jennings stepped forward and asked Judge Hammond if he would assign counsel for Miss Borden. Tho judge asked who had been acting and Mr. Jenningn said he had, together with George 1). Koblnsou and M. (J. Adams. Judge Hammond asked if this counsed was accept able to Miss Borden and Mr. Jennings nnswereJ in tbe affirmative. Judge Ham inond said there appearo to bo no nocessity r tbo assignment of counsel and told Mr, Jennings ho could enter tho appearance of himself and Mr. ltobinson und Mr. Adams. t Tbo court wan then adjourned, and nfter waiting a moment or two for tiho spectators to disperse, Sheriff Wright, his wife and Miss Borden left the room und in company with Mr, Jennings proceeded to the room of District Attornoy Knowlton. Here tbey utopped till it was time tc go to the train. Mr. Jennings accompanied the sheriff, his wife and Miss Borden to tbo station, where the threu took the 15:50 p. in. train for Taunton, where in tbe jail Miss Borden will be again imprisonod till her trial. Miss Jlorden and Her Couusel Want It Held nt Tauntou.

See the clipping

St. Johnsbury Caledonian · St. Johnsbury, Vt.

This roundup of the week's events reports that Lizzie Borden was formally arraigned at New Bedford on the charge of murder and pleaded not guilty. It is one item among many unrelated news briefs, including a Sing Sing execution and various disasters.

St. Johnsbury Caledonian · 11 May 1893 · page 8

RECORD OF THE WEEK.

Monday. Carlyle W. Harris was electrocuted in Sing Sing prison for the murder of his wife, Helen Potts, in 1891 ; the execution was successful, death be ing instantaneous; Harris died pro testing his innocence. Lizzie Borden

See the clipping

Wood County Reporter · Wisconsin Rapids, Wis.

Lizzie Borden was arraigned in superior court in New Bedford on three indictments for the murders of her father and stepmother. She calmly pleaded 'not guilty' to each charge before being returned to Taunton jail to await trial.

Wood County Reporter · 11 May 1893 · page 2

LIZZIE BORDEN ARRAIGNED. She Pleads “Not Guilty” to Three Charges of Murder Read. New Bedford, Mass., May B.—Lizzie Borden, who has been an inmate of

See the clipping

Grant County Herald · Lancaster, Wis.

Lizzie Borden, jailed since last August on charges of murdering her parents in Fall River, was arraigned before Judge Hammond in superior court. She pleaded not guilty and was remanded to jail to await trial, set for early June.

Grant County Herald · 11 May 1893 · page 1

Lizzie Borden Arraigned

Minister Lincoln Sails for Home. London, May 8. —Hon. Robert '!’. Lin coln. the late American minister, traveled on the “Eagle train" to South ampton. oit-nmpanied by all the mem bers of American legation, flen. Wil liams Falbe and dozens of Americans and others, who hade him farewell a he sailed -home on the American line steamship New York. The new Amer ican consul general, Hon. Patrick A. Uollins, began the duties of that 1 ti,< e at iinev. I.Uzie Borden Arraigned.

See the clipping

Griggs Courier · Cooperstown, Dak. N.D. · and 1 other paper

A roundup of news items reports that the trial of Lizzie Borden for the murder of her parents began at New Bedford, Massachusetts, on the 8th. The notice is brief, listed among other unrelated news items of the day.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day. CorrectionThis set right an article from the day before.

Wrong

Griggs Courier · 12 May 1893 · page 2

THE trial of Lizzie Borden for the murder of her parents began at New Bedford, Mass., the 8th. THE world's fair grounds were Illum inated by electricity the night of the 8th. ABOUT 700 horseshoers in Chicago went on a strike the 8th. THE Ott & Brewer Pottery company, of Trenton, N. J., was placed in the hands of a receiver the 8th. Liabili ties $137,0001.

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • River Falls Journal · River Falls, Wis. · 11 May 1893

The Forrest City Times · Forrest City, Ark.

Among a list of brief national news items, one line reports that Lizzie Borden, charged with murdering her parents, was arraigned at New Bedford, Massachusetts. She entered a plea of not guilty.

The Forrest City Times · 12 May 1893 · page 4

CONDENSED TELEGRAMS. Tilt: British fleet in New York waters has Ion* over seventy men t>y desertion since the ships reached that port. Warner, the patent medicine man of Roches ter. N. Y., has failed, with liabilities reaching tI.006.tW0. The Columbus caravels will leave New York to-day •<Wednesday) for the World's fair via the St. Lawrence and the lakes. St. Ix>uis hunkers have placed a iar»re amount of (fold at the service of Secretary Carlisle. Three men were drowned at Dixon. 111., as the result of the capsizing of a tiatboat. Lizzie Borden, churned with the murder of

See the clipping

Springfield Weekly Republican · Springfield, Mass.

Officials announce preparations for the Borden trial, including an extra venire, the assigned judges (Mason, Blodgett, Dewey), and press seating arrangements at New Bedford. A rumor also surfaces that a second hatchet has been found in Fall River, though officials will not confirm or deny it.

Springfield Weekly Republican · 12 May 1893 · page 5

READY FOR THE~BURITeN~CASE. The Government Officials Confer ■— Another llnlthet. The chief justice of the superior Court has given instructions tc the clerk of the court at. New Bedford to issue an extra venire, and at the conclusion of the busi ness of court Saturday Judge Hammond will issue the order assigning the date aud place of the trial. This order will be served on Lizzie Borden at Taunton jail. Marshal Hilliard of Fall River, who is in charge of the police work on the Bor den case, visited New Bedford Wednes day and wont at once to District Attor ney Knowlton's oilice, where the two officials were in close conference for a ong time.

See moreSee less

They kept the subject of their talk to themselves. Chief Justice Mason will preside at the trial, and his associates will probably be Judges Blodgett aud Dewey. Clerk Bor den has conferred with the chief justice concerning accoinmodations for the news paper reporters, and it has been decided to give up the witness-boxes to their use. Even this space will not accommodate more than 20 or 30 newspaper men. and they will be greatly crowded at that. The Now Bedford Evening Standard claims^ “It .is reported, on what is con sidered good authority, that another hatchet, which will be brought forward in the Borden ease, has been found in Fall River. Officials in this city refuse to deny or affirm the story.”

See the clipping

Springfield Weekly Republican · Springfield, Mass.

This general Massachusetts news digest covers various legal and civic matters, including a note that ex-Gov Robinson's involvement in the Borden trial in June, along with hot summer weather, led judges to postpone the Maverick bank case trials until September. The Borden case itself is mentioned only in passing as a scheduling consideration for unrelated proceedings.

Springfield Weekly Republican · 12 May 1893 · page 5

EASTERN MASSACHUSETTS

ability, will be that against ex-Cashier J. W. Work. The engagement of ex-Gov Robinson in the Borden trial in June and the hot sum mer Weather were the reasons why an earlier day for the trial ot these cases was not fixed* THE SPRINGFIELD WEEKLY REPUBLICAN: FRIDAY, MAY 12, 1893.—TWELVE PAGES. A BOLD ROBBERY IN CHICOPEE. destruction of the old Ijombard house, The com ma nd cry nf Massachusetts, order of the Loyul Legion. ha« elected which has stood on Main street for over these officers: Commander* Col Albert A. CASH TAKEN FROM A SA VINOS BANK n century.

See moreSee less

Only two of the large family I’ojw: senior vice-comuian*lor, Gen Hazard of Justin Lombard were married, and so Htetons: junior vice-commander* Comdr there are not many grandchildren to grieve Ry Mn-uugert Who Entieed the Treasurer Henry Wadleigh of United States navy: over the removal of Ihe residence so Iqng Out and Henrrbed the Money Drtwerrecorder, Col Arnold A. Rand: registrar. Asiuxdntcd with one family. It was just A Mmnll Haul mudt. Col Charlea E. Hapgood; treasnrer, Maj HH) years from the birth of tbe first of As daring a robbery ns Chicopee ever William P. Shreve: chancellor, Maj An Justin Lombard's children in the old knew was perpetrated Wednesday morning drew M. Benson; chaplain. Rev Edward mansion until the deatli of the hist iu the Everett Hale; council, Maj Homer G. when the cash-box of the Chicopee Falls line of 12, and during that long interval Gilmore, Ensign John C. Pegram, (’ant the place was occupied by the same fam savings bank was rifled just before noon George N. (‘arrientf^r, Lieut James N. ily. The house was built in 1787 by Justin in broad daylight and with people con North, and Gen Georg'* H. Nye. Lombard nnd bis aged father, Daniel occu stantly passing. Fortunately the amount pied it with him, passing much of the The legality of the contract of the Brook declining years of a memorable life on Ihe line gas company with tbe city of Boston taken was only $125 in cash besides two old doorslep, where his figure was familiar came up in the supreme court at Boston this checks amounting to $35. There was SB2 to the children of the day. And the. older week before Judge Holmes. George C. more in the box in silver, checks and bills, residents remember Justin Ixmrtmnl, who Jeffries is the complainant in the case, and 'which was not taken, and S3OO or S4OO reared his family in the house and culti the Brookline gas company and the city of vated tbe garden and orclvard in his old Boston are the defendants. J. Edward Ad locked in the safe, but the larger part of dicks also asks to be joined as a plaintiff in age until his death in 1841. the bank's money was as usual deposited the suit, being a stockholder in the com in this city. The man who undoubtedly pany. THE KAISER~MEANS BUSINESS.

See the clipping

The Times · Owosso, Mich.

Lizzie Borden was arraigned in superior court at New Bedford, Massachusetts, for the alleged murder of her father and stepmother in Fall River on August 4 of the previous year. She pleaded not guilty.

The Times · 12 May 1893 · page 6

000. A locomotive and four freight cars loaded with laborers broke through a bridge near Abrens, Cuba, and twenty men were killed. Gen. Manuel Gonzales, ex-president of Mexico and governor of the state of Guanajuato, died in the City of Mexico. He was born near Matamoras in 1820. Robert Downey, Richard Hoban and Watson Major were swept over a dam at Dixon, III., and drowned. Lizzie Borden was arraigned in the superior court at New Bedford, Mass., for the alleged murder of her father and stepmother in Fall River August 4 last and pleaded not guilt?.

See the clipping

Little Falls Transcript · Little Falls, Minn.

A feature article argues that circumstantial evidence is often more reliable than direct testimony, citing the pending Lizzie Borden case alongside others like Carlyle Harris and the historic Parkman murder. It contends wrongful convictions from direct evidence vastly outnumber those from circumstantial evidence.

Little Falls Transcript · 12 May 1893 · page 1

CIRCUMSTANCES CONVICTED THEM

©umstancos Sometimes Favor the Guilty. LL those impetu­ ous people who in­ veigh against cir­ cumstantial evi­ dence are at it again. The cases of Carlyle Harris, Lizzie Borden, Dr. Graves and many

See the clipping

The Weekly Tribune · Great Falls, Mont.

Lizzie Borden, held at Taunton jail since August, was arraigned in superior court on indictments for the murders of her father Andrew Jackson Borden and stepmother Abbie Durfee Borden. She calmly pleaded not guilty to each count before being returned to jail to await trial.

CorrectionThis set right an article from the day before.

The Weekly Tribune · 12 May 1893 · page 8

.ii.jj lh...t iti, * Agi n ..Iii iotitl. ( tar. si Ne.w Il.,,ini . Ma ... Mlay S. Lizzie Borden, who, ,ieu been an inmate of Taunton jail over since August last, un tier indictment for the :ur lr ,o .\A ugust 1. in Fall River. of her father. Andrew

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

Ex-Governor Robinson visited Taunton jail and held a two-hour conference with Lizzie Borden regarding her case. The brief item gives no further details about the content of their discussion.

The Providence News · 12 May 1893 · page 7

Robinson was here yuurdx and visited Taunton j.il, where he had a two hours’ conference with Lizzie Borden in relation to her case, Journalist Moore Dead.

See the clipping

The Daily Herald · Brownsville, Tex.

Lizzie Borden was arraigned in New Bedford superior court on three indictments related to the murders of her father Andrew Borden and stepmother Abbie Borden. She calmly pleaded not guilty to each charge before being returned to Taunton jail to await trial.

The Daily Herald · 12 May 1893 · page 1

LIZZIE BORDEN ARRAIGNED Charged with two Murders

NO 269 Hzzie Barren Germany Chars ed iwitu two JUunlcro Now Bedford Mass May 8 Lizzio Borden was arraigned this afternoon iu the superior court in this city Authorities sought to keep tho arraignment quiet and preserved the utmost secrecy How ever qm tc a number of people gath ercd When the ripio of exciio mont which mirked her entranoa anbsidod the district attoraoy mov ed that Miaa B > rdcn be arraigned and thecleric of tho court said Lizzie Borden slsnd up She did so and hwed steadily at him while ho road siowlj and solemnly throe indictments of two counts each Two charged her with tiie murder of Andrew J Bor den and Abbie Dnrfee Bordon scp eratoly and third charged with tho murder of both At tho end oT each indictment the clerk said Lizzie Borden what say yon to

See the clipping

Iowa County Democrat · Mineral Point, Wis.

Lizzie Borden, held in Taunton jail since August on charges of murdering her father and stepmother, was arraigned in New Bedford superior court. She calmly pleaded 'not guilty' to three indictments before being returned to jail to await trial.

Iowa County Democrat · 12 May 1893 · page 3

Charges of Murder Read. New’ Bedford, Mass., May 8. —Lizzie Borden, who has been an inmate of Taunton jail ever since August last under indictment for the murder of her father and step-mother, was ar raigned this afternoon in the superior court in this city. She carried no outward sign of suf fering. When the trouble and excite ment which marked her entrance into the court had subsided, the district at torney moved that Miss Borden be ar raigned and the clerk of the court read slowdy and solemnly three indictments of two counts each.

See moreSee less

Two of them charged her with the murder of her father and mother separately and the third charged her with the murder of both. At the end of each indictment she replied clearly, calmly and steadily, “I am not guilty.” The court then adjourned and Miss Borden was taken back to Taunton where she will be imprisoned until her trial. ,

See the clipping

Paper unidentified

Lizzie Borden was arraigned in the Superior Court at New Bedford and pleaded not guilty to the charge of murdering her parents last August. She was then returned to Taunton jail to await trial.

Paper unidentified · 13 May 1893 · page 4

Lizzie Borden has been arraigned in the Superior Court at New Bedford and returned to Taunton jail to await trial. She pleaded ‘not guilty” to the charge of murdering her ‘parents last August. The body of Frank W. Rohle, who with Thomas Fallister, escaped from the death house in Sing Sing prison April 20, has been found in the Hudson river, directly across from Sing Sing.

See the clipping

Waterbury Evening Democrat · Waterbury, Conn.

Ex-Governor Robinson, part of Lizzie Borden's defense counsel, visited Taunton jail and held a two-hour conference with her regarding her case. The visit was reported as routine legal preparation ahead of trial.

Waterbury Evening Democrat · 13 May 1893 · page 2

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

See the clipping

The Washington Bee · Washington, D.C.

A short news item states that the delay in bringing Lizzie Borden to trial is attracting significant public attention. No further details are given in this brief mention.

CorrectionThis set right an article from the day before.

The Washington Bee · 13 May 1893 · page 1

cp'-llx8rortlsnd,Jsa the consular question. A very revolu tionary spirit prevails in Norway, and the press is agitating the disolution ot the union between Sweden and Norway. Minister Stevens Coining' Home. Private information has been ru';oiveii at Washington, that Minister Stevens, with his wife aud daughter, will !ear? Honolulu ou May 24. Mr. Stevens had made arrangements to depart ou thai day before he knew that Mr. Blount wag going to the island. The delay in bringing Lizzie Borden to trial is exciting much attention. The noted Freuch billiardist, A. P. Rudolphe, has died in Paris, aged 58.

See the clipping

Perrysburg Journal · Perrysburg, Ohio · and 1 other paper

Lizzie Borden was arraigned in superior court at New Bedford, Massachusetts, for the alleged murder of her father and stepmother in Fall River on August 4 of the previous year. She entered a plea of not guilty.

Perrysburg Journal · 13 May 1893 · page 2

73,OOS,000 bushels; corn, 9.853,000 bush els; oats, 3,291,000 bushels; rye, 002,000 bushels; barley, 585,000 bushels. Six more of the men scalded by the bursting of the flue of the steamer Ohio near Cairo, 111., have died, making a total of thirteen victims. John J. Shea, of Lima, O., was paid the sum of $10,920 for the loss of an arm while in the employ of the Lake Erie fc Western road as yard conductor. Lizzie Borden was arraigned in the superior court at New Bedford, Mass., for the alleged murder of her father and stepmother In Fall River August 4 last and pleaded not guilty.

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • The Kanabec County Times · Mora, MN · 18 May 1893

The Weekly Intelligencer · Lexington, Mo.

A brief news item among many others reports that Lizzie Borden, charged with murdering her father and stepmother in Fall River, Mass., was arraigned and pleaded not guilty. The item is part of a national wire roundup of miscellaneous short news stories.

The Weekly Intelligencer · 13 May 1893 · page 1

NEWS IN BRIEF

Nodaway, Mo. .. . Major Watson, contractor; and two workmen were drowned at Dixon, 111., by the capsizing of a ' flatboat, witli which they were repairing the danv , ' The Joliet rolling mill, a branch - the Illinois steel company, is closed la all departments, throwing out of work 2,500 men. Lizzie Borden, charged - with tho ' murder of her father and step-mother at Fall River, Mass., was arraigned and pleaded not guilty. - Miss Mary Chambers is in jail at Clayton, Ala., for contempt of court in refusing to surrender $1,480 which sho claims is her own. Dr. Ely McClellan, V. 8. A;, at tached to General Miles' headquarters at Chicago, is dead; He was a nephew of General George B. McClellan.

See the clipping

The Neihart Herald · Neihart, Mont.

Lizzie Borden was arraigned in New Bedford, Massachusetts on charges of murdering her father and mother. She entered a plea of not guilty.

The Neihart Herald · 13 May 1893 · page 1

thority that the Navajoes have killed Agent Plummer. It is rumore« 1 ih»* Scott Wilke o! Illinois will succeed Assistant Secretary of the Treasury Spaulding. Mr. Gladstone has appointed John Ruskin, the art critic, poet laureate, to succeed the late Lord Tennyson. Lizzie Borden has been arraigned at Now Bedford, Mass., on the charge ol murdering her father and mother. She plead not guilty.

See the clipping

The Dickinson Press · Dickinson, N.D.

Lizzie Borden was arraigned in New Bedford superior court on charges of murdering her father and stepmother. She appeared calm, briefly faltering upon entering the courtroom before regaining composure to hear the charges read.

The Dickinson Press · 13 May 1893 · page 1

SHE PLEADS NOT GUILTY

The Grind Begins. Xew Bedford. Mass., May 9.—Lizzie Andrew Borden, who has Iven an inmate Tauutou jail ever since August last, uuder indictment tor the murder on Aug. 4, in Fall Uiver, of her father. Andrew Jackson Borden, and her stepmother. Abbie lhirtec Borden, was arraigiusl this afteruoou iu the superior court. The au thorities sought to keep the arraignment quiet, and preserved the utmot secrecy. News of the coming of Mis Borden had. howewr. reached this city K'fore the ar rival, and quite a number of i»eoplo had gathered, who hoked curiously and in tuauy cases not uusympathetically at the woman who Mauds charged with one of the foulest crimes on the calendar.

See moreSee less

On arrival at the court house Miss Borden was eonveyetl at om-e through the rear door to the district attorney's room, aud remained there till 5:15 o'clock, the court being occupied with the trial of a civil case. Miss Borden was then escorted up stairs to the court room. For the space perhaps of a second she faltered, and leaned against the casing, but she imme diately regained her self possession, and walked with a firm step along the aisle and took her place in the dock. However pvat may have been her mental suffer ings during her imprisonment, she carried no outward sigu of them. When the rip ple of excitement which marked her en trance had subsided, the district attorney moved that Miss Borden IN* arraigned, and the clerk of the court, Simeon Bor den, Ksq.. said: "Lizzie Andrew Borden, staud up.' aud she did so, and looked steadily at him while he read slowly and solemnly three indictments of two counts each. Two of them charged her with the murder of Andrew J. Borden and Abbie Uurfee Borden, separately, and the third charged her with the murder of both. At the end of each indictment the clerk asked "Lizzie Andrew Borden, what say you to this indictment are you guilty or not guilty V" and to each she replied clear ly, calmly and steadily, "1 aui not guilty." She did not seem to be stolid or stubborn, but acted as though she was fully alive to the gravity of the situation. Andrew J. Jennings of Fall Uiver, who has been licr faithful counsel all through, was present. Judge Hammond said there appeared to be no necessity for the as signment of counsel, ami tdd Mr. Jen mugs he could enter the appearance of hiuiself ami Messrs (Jeorgc f. Kobinson and M. Q. Adams. The court was then adjourned, and after waiting a moment or two for the spectators to disperse, Sheriff Wright, his wife and Miss Borden left the room, and in company with Air. Jennings proceeded to the room of Iis trict Attorney Knowlton. where they stopped until it was time to go to the train. Mr. Jennings accompanied the sheriff, his wife and Miss Borden to the station, where the three took the train for Taunton, where Miss Borden will be again imprisoned until her trial.

See the clipping

The Dickinson Press · Dickinson, N.D.

Lizzie Borden was brought to the court house and formally arraigned on three indictments for the murders of Andrew and Abbie Borden, pleading "not guilty" to each count. She remained composed throughout, briefly faltering upon entering the courtroom, and was afterward escorted back to Taunton to await trial.

The Dickinson Press · 13 May 1893 · page 1

ARRAIGNED

The words of this article are printed with the report it shares its clipping with. Read them there or in the clipping.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

Narragansett Herald · Narragansett Pier, R.I.

Lizzie Borden was transported from Taunton jail to New Bedford, arraigned in superior court on three murder indictments, and pleaded not guilty before being returned to Taunton. The report describes her calm demeanor, her reunion with her sister Emma, and notes the trial is set to open June 5.

Narragansett Herald · 13 May 1893 · page 8

Wright, his wife and Miss Borden, entered it and were driuen to the Central station just in time to catch the 3.30 train for this city.

See the clipping

Mineral Point Tribune · Mineral Point, Wis.

Lizzie Borden, held at Taunton jail since August, was arraigned in New Bedford superior court on three indictments for the murders of her father and stepmother. She calmly pleaded not guilty to each charge before being returned to Taunton jail to await trial.

Mineral Point Tribune · 13 May 1893 · page 2

New Bedford, Mass,, May 8. Lizzie Borden, who has been tin inmate of , Taunton jail ever since August last i under indictment for the murder of j her father and step-mother, was ar raigned this afternoon in the superior court in tins city. [ She carried no outward sign of suf j tering. When the trouble and excite ment which marked her entrance into the court had subsided, the district at torney moved that Miss Borden be ar raigned and the clerk of the court read slowly and solemnly three indictments of two counts each.

See moreSee less

Two of them charged her with the murder of bet father and mother separately and the third charged her with the murder of both. At the end of each indictment she replied clearly, calmly and steadily ”1 am not guilty." The court then adjourned and Mi* Borden was taken back to Taunton where she will be imprisoned until le ■ trial.

See the clipping

Martinsburg Independent · Martinsburg, W. Va.

Lizzie Andrew Borden, held in Taunton jail since August on indictment for the murders of her father Andrew Jackson Borden and stepmother Abbie Durfee Borden, was arraigned in Superior Court in New Bedford. She answered 'I am not guilty' in a firm voice to each of the three indictments read against her.

Martinsburg Independent · 13 May 1893 · page 2

Lizzie Borden Arraigned. New Bedford, Mass., May 8.— Lizzie Andrew Borden, who h‘>» been an inmate of Taunton jail ever sino> August last, un-ier indictment lor the murder on August 4, iu Fall River, of her fathei, Andrew Jack son Borden, and her stepmother. Abbie Durfee Borden, was arraign ed this afternoon in the Superior Court, now in session in this city. The accused, upon the reading of each of the three indictments, an swered in a firm voice, “I am not guilty.”

See the clipping

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

The report claims the grand jury recess was due to Attorney-General Pillsbury wanting insanity experts to examine Lizzie Borden, believing she may be mentally unbalanced rather than innocent. Defense attorney Jennings refused such an examination, insisting his client is not insane, and the matter was left for trial, with prosecutors expected to rely on key witnesses Bridget Sullivan and Mrs. Churchill.

New-York Tribune · 14 May 1893 · page 13

LIZZIE BORDEN'S MENTAL CONDITION. WHAT ATTORNEY-GENERAL PILLSBURY THINKS ABOUT IT-THE COMING TRIAL. Taunton, Mass, May 13.—It is asserted now that the true reason for the recess of the grand jury in the

See the clipping

The Wichita Daily Eagle · Wichita, Kan.

A report from Taunton claims the grand jury's recess in the Lizzie Borden case was due to Attorney General Pillsbury wanting psychiatric experts to assess her mental state. It states Pillsbury believed she was mentally unbalanced rather than innocent, and wanted her given every chance to show diminished responsibility if guilty.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Wichita Daily Eagle · 14 May 1893 · page 2

LIZZIE BORDEN.

EPILEPSY OR FITS. Can this dLseaso be cured? Mott pbyicUn mj No "say, Yes; allformx and the worst cam-. Af ter 30 years study and uxiiriment I have found th remedy. Epilepsy w cured by it; cnrtii, not sub dued by opiates tbe old, troachcronj, quack trea ment. Do not 1 f pair. Forget tat lmixwiuVrau on rour purso, past outrages ou your confidence, pa.i failures. Look forward, not lckinrl. My remedy h of li-&xy. Valuable work on the nabjeet, nrl largo Imtilo of tbe remedy sent free for tru.. Mention I'ost-OfScr uUxprea ivMreii.

See moreSee less

I'xof. W. II. I'iiEKl. p.p., 4 Cedar St., 3 Jiew Yoik. LIZZIE BORDEN. TAUNTON", Mas.. Mny 13. It U asscrtel now that the true inwardness of the re cess of the grand jury iu the. Lizzie liorde.-i case was because of Attorney General Pillsbury'a desire that a consultation of ins. may experts should he hIl to deter mine the mental coudition of Misa Bor hm, he firmly believing, not Inher Innocence, its bus beeu stattxl, but that she Ik men tally unbalanced. He wishes that every chance iu the world should be given her to show that if she is guilty It was been us o of bur mental condition.

See the clipping

Weekly Independent · Elko, Nev.

A brief news item reports that Lizzie Borden, indicted for the murder of her father and stepmother the previous August, was arraigned in court and entered a plea of not guilty. The item appears amid a miscellany column of local news briefs.

Weekly Independent · 14 May 1893 · page 3

Fort ilallock. Sprucouiont, Clover and Star Y'dloys. Tho festival of tho Presbyterian cknrch which was to take pinco Fri day evening, May 1*2, 189.1, is post poned until Friday, May 19. Preceptor? Of course you want to go lo heaven, Wiltio? Willie ? I should say not. I ain't enough stuck on pulliug oil grandpa's boots for that. Lizzie Borden, tho Mns3nchu3otts girl indicted for murdering bar father nnd bt?p mother last August, was ar raigned yesterday afternoon and plead not guilty. Boston Transcript: ? Tho best ban quet that man ever sat down to was I nover relished half ho heartily as the core of his chum's apple away back in primary-school days.

See the clipping

Waterbury Evening Democrat · Waterbury, Conn.

Lizzie Borden, held at Taunton jail, has come down with tonsillitis and is being treated by a physician for the first time since her incarceration. She caught cold on the day of her arraignment and has been unwell since, though her illness is not considered alarming.

Waterbury Evening Democrat · 15 May 1893 · page 3

Uzzl Borden Sick in Jail. Taunton, Mass. , May 15. For the first time since tha incarceration of Lizzie Borden at Taunton jail, she is under the care of a physician. She has a alight at tack oi tonsilltls, and it Is thought that no more alarming symptoms will appear. She caught cold on the day of arraignment and has been ailing ever since. Should anything more serious result she will be removed from her cell to the keepers house and will continue to receive the best of care.

See the clipping

The Jersey City News · Jersey City, N.J.

Dr. Page, the jail physician, states that Lizzie Borden's illness is bronchial and began after her arraignment in New Bedford, followed by a sudden chill. She has been moved to the keeper's house for quiet and is expected to be in fair condition by the time of her trial.

The Jersey City News · 15 May 1893 · page 1

LIZZIE BORDEN’S ILLN ESS. Taunton, Mass. May 15, 1893.—Dr Page, juil physician, says that Miss Bor den’s illness Is of a bronchial nature, and came on after her return from the arraignment at Now Bedford. The

See the clipping

Pawtucket Tribune · Pawtucket, R.I.

The Taunton jail reports that Lizzie Borden has come under a physician's care for the first time since her incarceration, suffering a slight case of tonsilitis after catching cold on the day of her arraignment. Officials say she is not expected to develop more serious symptoms, but if her condition worsens she will be moved to the keeper's house for better care.

Pawtucket Tribune · 15 May 1893 · page 3

Lizzie Borden Suffering From Tonsilitis. TAUNTON, Mass., May 15.—For the first time since the incarceration of Lizzie Borden at Taunton jail, she is under the care of a physician. She has a slight at

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

The report states that Lizzie Borden, held at Taunton jail, has come under a physician's care for the first time since her incarceration. She is suffering from a mild case of tonsillitis, and no serious complications are expected.

The Providence News · 15 May 1893 · page 6

Lizeie Borden Is Sick. TAUNTON, Mass., May 15.—For the first time since the incarceration of Lizzie Borden at Taunton jail, she is under the care of a phys'cian. She has a slight at

See the clipping

Waterbury Evening Democrat · Waterbury, Conn.

This editorial piece notes that Lizzie Borden's trial for the murder of her father and stepmother will attract major public interest, comparable to other famous cases. It observes she has been jailed nearly a year awaiting trial, and muses that the long imprisonment and circumstantial evidence may have swayed public sympathy in her favor.

Waterbury Evening Democrat · 16 May 1893 · page 2

The trial of Lizzie Borden for the murder of., her father and stepmother will create as much interest as the liar fis and Buchanan cases. The prisoner

See the clipping

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

Dr. Page, the jail physician, states that Lizzie Borden's illness is bronchial in nature and began after her arraignment at New Bedford. She was moved to the keeper's house due to noise in the women's quarters and is expected to be in fair condition by the time of her trial.

New-York Tribune · 16 May 1893 · page 1

Jamped overboard as the boat was passing Newurg last night and was drowned. His home was at No. 833 Evergiecn-ave., Brooklyn. LIZZIE BORDEN'S ILLNESS NOI SERIOUS. Taunton, Mass., Muy 10.—Dr. Page, the jail physiclan, says that Miss Borden's illness is of a bronchial nature and came on after her return from the arralgnment at New-Bedford. The following day she experienced a sudden chill and has since been under bis care. Owing to noise In the women’s quarter she bas been taken into the keeper's house, where it is she will undoubtedly be In fair condition at ule,

See the clipping

Waterbury Evening Democrat · Waterbury, Conn.

A report from Taunton, Mass. states that Lizzie Borden's condition has improved, with her doctor noting reduced fever and easier breathing. Dr. Paige predicts she will fully recover within a week.

Waterbury Evening Democrat · 17 May 1893 · page 3

Barneg-at Hotel Deoislon. Trenton, N. J., May 17. Vice Chan cellor Bird has rendered a decision in the Barnegat Park hotel litigation holding that the Farrow and Downing s deed for the Barnegate hotel property is a forgery and a fraud upon the court, iho deed is therefore set aside as invalid. Lizzie Borden Better.

See the clipping

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

The item discusses whether Attorney-General Pillsbury's role as prosecutor in the upcoming Lizzie Borden trial could hurt his chances if he runs for Governor. It notes that voters who believe Borden innocent might be numerous enough to defeat him.

New-York Tribune · 17 May 1893 · page 6

THE TALK OF THE DAY. The possible political bearings of the Bonen case are being canvassed by the Massachusetts papers, If Attorney-General Pillsbury should be a candidate for Governor, the fact that he is to be the prosecutor in the coming trial of Lizzie Borden, it is sald, would cost him the votes of those who belleve her to be innocent, and it is thought that there are enough of those so believing to defeat him should he run,

See the clipping

The Daily Bulletin · Honolulu, Hawaii

Lizzie Borden was arraigned at New Bedford on May 8th for the murder of her parents at Fall River on August 4th. She responded to every indictment clearly and calmly with "I am not guilty."

The Daily Bulletin · 17 May 1893 · page 3

of Appeals has denied the applica tion of tho Government for foifeit uro of tho steamship Itata, conse quently sho escapes scot free. Thieo test cases have boon broutrht against Chinese under tho Geary leitrictioii act. The attorneys of tho Southern Pacific Railroad havo been engaged as counsel for tho Chinese. Liabilities of tho Union Loan and Trust Company, Iowa, aro stated to bo .?8,(KK),00(). One Now York bank and its St. Louis correspondent hold 100,000 of tho paper. Lizzie Borden was arraigned at New Bedford, on tllo 8lh mst., for the murder of hei parents nt Pall

See the clipping

Watertown Republican · Watertown, Wis.

The brief news item reports that Lizzie Borden, accused of murdering her father and mother, was arraigned in court at New Bedford, Massachusetts. She entered a plea of not guilty to the charges.

Watertown Republican · 17 May 1893 · page 2

New York & Susquehanna road. The Russian government will convene a commission of Jewish rabbis in Sep tember to settle the Jewish question. David Stain brook, living near New castle, Wyo., was killed by Ins 12-year old boy. The latter has been arrested. The Philadelphia, Honesdale & Al bany and the Philadelphia, Honesdale Albany railroads have been consoli dated. Lizzie Borden, charged with murder ing her father and mother, pleaded not guilty when arraigned at New Bedford, Alass. Lieut. W. AI. Williams, Nineteenth Calvary, will be tried at Ft. Wayne, Ind., by court-martial, for failing to pay his debts.

See moreSee less

The city of Pueblo, Col., proposes to save SIOO,OOO a year by discharging hall the numbers of the fire and police de partments, George Rose, of Liberty, Ind., quit chewing tobacco and used paper as a substitute. He died from poison in printing ink. An old feud between drainage canal workmen resulted in Charles Smallwood shooting Robert Tolliver dead near Jwockport, 111. Henry Feadlek, a restaurant keeper at Seymour, Ind., was shot dead by Leopold Trenck, who had assaulted the NEWS PARAGRAPHS. The men who robbed the Alobile A Ohio train near Cairo, 111., have been located and will be arrested.

See the clipping

The Green Forest Tribune · Green Forest, Ark.

A news brief reports that Lizzie Borden, charged with murdering her father and step-mother in Fall River, Mass., will be placed on trial June 5. The item appears among a roundup of short unrelated news paragraphs.

The Green Forest Tribune · 18 May 1893 · page 1

Lizzie Borden, charged with the murder of her father and step-mother at Fall lilver, Mass., will he placed on trial June 5. The death is announced of Colonel Yard H. Lainon, private secretary to President Aincolu, and one of his most trusted friends. The Republican League of' Clubs in convention at Louisville elected William W.

See the clipping

Connecticut Western News · Salisbury, Conn. · and 1 other paper

This roundup of the week's news items briefly notes that the trial of Lizzie Borden has been scheduled for June 5. It also covers unrelated stories like immigration law changes, deaths, and labor unrest.

Connecticut Western News · 18 May 1893 · page 3

BOILED DOWN.

Oolamna to Unas. Thursday, May 11. . f The new immigration law went into foroe at Ellis island. The wife of Mysterious Billy Smith, the pugilist, died in Lynn, Mass., of blood poi soning. John K. Tall man, a well known resident of Albany, Is dead. The rajah of Keunihar, India, is besieged in his capital by 10,000 insurgents. Mary McCann, the servant girl who has been unoonscious for 28 days in a hospital at Orange, N. J., as the result of a fall from a trolley car, has recovered conscious ness.

See moreSee less

The appeal of Colonel Hayes, now in Sing Sing, was argued before the general term and decision reserved. The trial of Lizzie Borden has been fixed for June 5. The treasurer of Putnam county, O., is said to be $25,000 short in his accounts. The failure of the Australian bank added to the uneasiness of Wall street

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • The Monmouth Inquirer · Freehold, N.J. · 18 May 1893

The National Tribune · Washington, D.C.

The report states that Lizzie Borden's trial for the murder of her parents in August 1892 will begin in New Bedford, Massachusetts, on the first Monday in June. Chief Justice Mason is noted to preside over the proceedings.

The National Tribune · 18 May 1893 · page 8

To bo Tried at New Bedford. It has hcon settled that the trial of Lizzie Borden for tho murder of her aged parents in August, 1892, will begin in New Bedford, Mass., on tho first Monday in June. Chief Justice Mason will preside.

See the clipping

The Monmouth Inquirer · Freehold, N.J.

The defense in the Borden case announced it will present the skulls of the murdered couple as evidence, countering the state's use of them. Lawyer Jennings reportedly plans to argue that none of the hatchets held by the prosecution could have caused the fatal wounds.

The Monmouth Inquirer · 18 May 1893 · page 8

The Borden Skulls as Evidence. Fall River, Mass., May 17.—The de fense in the Borden case will have some thing to say about the skulls of the mur dered couple. The ghastly relics are to be in court for the use of the state, but Law yer Jennings has notified the government that he also wants to put them in evidence. This action of the defense settles apparent ly the question of the hatchet which it is alleged was used to murder the Bordens, for it is believed the defense will under take to show that none of the hatchets in p hands of the government could have ■Aided the fatal wounds. May Detain Minister Risley,

See the clipping

The Monmouth Inquirer · Freehold, N.J.

A brief dispatch from Taunton, Massachusetts reports that Lizzie Borden's condition is much improved. Dr. Paige is quoted saying he expects her to fully recover within a week.

The Monmouth Inquirer · 18 May 1893 · page 8

Twenty Killed In an Explosion. Paris, May 16.—A boiler exploded in a cloth factory in Sedan. Twenty are said to have been killed. Many more were in jured. _■ Lizzie Borden’s Health Improving. Taunton, Mass., May 17.—Miss Borden’s condition is much Improved. Dr. Paige says he thinks in a week she will have en tirely recovered.

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

A newspaper comment piece notes progress in the proceedings against Lizzie Borden and argues she deserves a speedy trial. It states that keeping her confined merely on suspicion denies her justice, regardless of guilt or innocence.

The Providence News · 18 May 1893 · page 8

NOTE AND COMMENT. THE INDICATIONS of progress in the pro ceedings against Lizzie Borden wili be re ceived everywhere with expressions of ap proval. That young woman is entitled to

See the clipping

Burlington Weekly Free Press · Burlington, Vt.

Among a roundup of miscellaneous news items, a brief notice states that Lizzie Borden is ill while being held in the Taunton, Massachusetts jail. No further details are given about her condition or the circumstances.

Burlington Weekly Free Press · 18 May 1893 · page 7

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

See the clipping

Wood County Reporter · Wisconsin Rapids, Wis.

A brief news item among other condensed items reports that the trial of Lizzie Borden for the murder of her parents has been scheduled for the first Monday in June in New Bedford, Massachusetts. No further details about the case are given.

Wood County Reporter · 18 May 1893 · page 2

The trial of Lizzie Borden, for the murder of her parents, has been set for the first Monday in June, at New Bed ford, Mass.

See the clipping

The Kinsley Graphic · Kinsley, Kan.

The report states that doubts about the trial location have been resolved, confirming New Bedford, Massachusetts as the site. It specifies the trial will begin on the first Monday in June at the New Bedford courthouse.

The Kinsley Graphic · 19 May 1893 · page 1

, IHK EAST. All doubt as to the fact that the trial of Lizzie, Borden is to take place f 1n New Bedford, Mass., is at last dis "pellcd, and it is now known for a ccr-

See the clipping

The Iola Register · Iola, Kansas

The report states that the location of Lizzie Borden's murder trial has been settled as New Bedford, Massachusetts. It specifies the trial will begin on the first Monday in June at the New Bedford courthouse.

The Iola Register · 19 May 1893 · page 2

his own escape. All doubt as to the fact that the trial of Lizzie Borden is to take place in New Bedford, Mass., is at last dis pelled, and it is now known, for a cer tainty that the famous murder case

See the clipping

The Mankato Free Press · Mankato, Minn.

A newspaper editorial claims Lizzie Borden is being held in jail merely to give Massachusetts authorities time to strengthen a weak case against her. It notes two other murders occurred in the district since her arrest, and suggests officials hoped she would break down mentally while they searched for more evidence.

The Mankato Free Press · 19 May 1893 · page 1

They have a queer way of doing things in Massachusetts. It is claimed that Lizzie Borden, who is charged with killing her father and step-mother, at Fall River, is being detained in prison simply to give the authorities time to work up a case against her. Since her arrest two murders have been committed in the same district, for which one person has been tried and acquitted and another convicted and executed. It is alleged by some of the papers of that locality that the case against Miss Borden is too weak to hold, and that the delay has been made in the hope that some evidence might be found to strengthen it.

See moreSee less

Another pa per suggests that she has been held in hopes that she would ‘"go insane in her cell, or that Providence or the evil one would < “>jne to their help.” The feeling there is more intense because it is the general impression that the evidence upon which she was held for trial was not sufficient, and that she has been deprived of her liberty while the authorities have been endeavor ing to strengthen it. The charge of murder is a most serious one, and when ft is made there ought to be ev idence enough to warrant the holding of the person charged. The course that has been pursued by the Massa chusetts officials in the Lizzie Borden

See the clipping

The Sun · New York, N.Y.

Mrs. Mary A. Livermore recounts a jail interview with Lizzie Borden, who calmly insists she is innocent and criticizes being called indifferent. Borden argues it would have been foolish to commit the murders in broad daylight with people nearby, suggesting she could have done it more safely at night if guilty.

The Sun · 19 May 1893 · page 5

LIZZIE BORDEN ON HER OWN CASE She Clearly Points Out the Weak Point In the Prosecution Theory

She Csitmly Point Out the Week Point In the Proncciillon Tlirnrjr BOSTON May la Mrs Mary A llvormore had a long Interview with the nllcged murder ess Lizzie Borden In Tniinton jnll recently Mrs Livermore says of that interview

See the clipping

The Bennington Banner · Bennington, Vt.

An Associated Press dispatch from Taunton reports rumors that the grand jury recess was due to Attorney General Pillsbury wanting insanity experts to examine Lizzie Borden, believing she might be mentally unbalanced rather than innocent. Borden's counsel Jennings reportedly refused any such examination, insisting his client was not insane, leaving the matter to be settled at trial.

The Bennington Banner · 19 May 1893 · page 1

IS LIZZIE BORDEN INSANE? Tho Associatod Press agont at Taunton, Hass., undcr date of tho 13th, con tributes tho following: "It is assorted that tho true iuwardness of tho reccss of tho grand jury in tho Lizzio Bordon caso was becauso of Attoruoy Genoial I'ills bury's desiro tliat a consultation of in samty experts should be hcld to dotor mino tho mcntal condition of Jliss lior den, ho firmly believing, not iu her in noccnce, as has bcou atatod, but that sho was mentally unbalanced. "llo wisned tliat overy ciianco snouid bo givcn hor to show that, if sho was guilty, it was bccause of hor niontal con dition.

See moreSee less

But Mr. Jonnings. counsel for Miss Borden, assorted iu his argumcnt at Fall River, 'My client is not insaue.' IIo could not, thereforo, assont to any such oxamination as was suggestcd hy tuo attorney generai, and was lorccu to await tho developments of tho trial. It is not tho intention of tho governincn'tto wasto any tiruo iu iho oxamination of witncsscs who havo had visions, who have scen wild-oyed mcn, or who havo becorao possosscd of thcorics. It will be sufflcicut, it is claimed. for tho proso cuting attoruoys to bring out tho ovi denco of the rcal witncsscs in tho caso. Tho two most importautones aro Brldgot Sullivan and Mrs. Churchill. If thero is no groat delay in gotting tho jury, tho caso, tho government oftlcials say, cau bo cloared up in thrco wcoks." By tho way how does it como about tliat Lizzio Borden-is so prosccutod. and Bridget Sullivan oscapcs any suspicion of knowledgo whatsoover? According to tho publibhcd details sho was within hcaring at tho timo of Mr. Bordpn's mur dor. If sho saw or heard anything why is it not told? And if shois ontircly ig norant of what was going on within a fow fect of hor whilo washing windows, how comes it that tho Polico of Fali Rivor think sho knows so much of tho whercabouts of tho accuscd, wheu tho barn was around tho houso and at somo distanco from whcro it is tcstiflcd sho stood at tho timo of tho raurdcr? Thcso aro legitimato qucstions if tho publishcd ovidenco amouuts to anything. Miss Borden's trial becins at New Bedford, Juno 1st. Wo hopo tho pro siding judgowill bo somo ono who is impartial. Iler oxamination was con fcssedly ono-sidod and partizan.

See the clipping

The Bennington Banner · Bennington, Vt.

The report questions why Lizzie Borden alone faces prosecution while Bridget Sullivan, who was near the crime scene, escapes suspicion despite police believing she knows Lizzie's whereabouts. It also notes the trial begins June 1st in New Bedford and hopes for an impartial judge, criticizing the earlier inquest examination as one-sided and partisan.

The Bennington Banner · 19 May 1893 · page 1

The words of this article are printed with the report it shares its clipping with. Read them there or in the clipping.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

The Grenada Sentinel · Grenada, Miss.

The report states that all doubt has been dispelled regarding the location of Lizzie Borden's murder trial, confirming it will take place in New Bedford, Massachusetts. The trial is scheduled to begin on the first Monday in June at the courthouse there.

The Grenada Sentinel · 20 May 1893 · page 2

THE KANT. The stockholders of Madison squarp garden, New York, have decided to sell their property. It is not profitable an investment. The supposed dead body of Roehle, the convicted murderer who, with I'al lister, escaped from Sing Sing, has been found in the river, and it is supposed that Pallister killed him to facilitate his own escape. All doubt as to the fact that the trial of Lizzie Borden is to take place in New Bedford, Mass., is at last dis

See the clipping

The Washburn Leader · Washburn, N.D.

A brief news item reports that Lizzie Borden, charged with murdering her father and mother, was arraigned in New Bedford, Massachusetts, and entered a plea of not guilty. The item appears amid a roundup of other crime stories under the heading 'Sinful Doings.'

The Washburn Leader · 20 May 1893 · page 2

counterfeiting. lizzie Borden, charged with murdering her father and mother, pleaded not guilty when arraigned at New Bedford, Mass. Will Batherick is on trial at Pontine, Mich., charged with the murder of his father. A conflict occurred between union and non-union sailors at Redondo, which resulted in the death of two men. In Henry Lederer's printing office at New York 3,000 counterfeit union cigar labels were seised. Lederer is awaiting trial. David Stainbrook, living near New castle, Wyo., was killed by his twelve year-old boy. Tbe latter has been ar rested. William Matthews, tbe king aad last

See the clipping

Narragansett Herald · Narragansett Pier, R.I.

The report describes preparations for Lizzie Borden's upcoming trial, noting over 150 jury venires have been issued to the sheriff. It reveals that Attorney General Pillsbury had sought an insanity evaluation of Borden during the grand jury recess, a request her attorney Jennings refused, insisting she was not insane; the piece also names Bridget Sullivan and Mrs. Churchill as the prosecution's key witnesses.

Narragansett Herald · 20 May 1893 · page 8

TRIAL OF LIZZIE BORDEN

---No Visionary Testimony. Bridget Sallivan and Mrs. Chuarchill the Most Important Witnesses—Ovex 150 Venires in the Hands of the Sherifi. Now that the Borden case may be said tc be practically on, matters which have Leen whispered and hinted at for the past few months in connection with various phases of the case are coming to the surface. It is asserted now that the true inwardness of the recess of the grand jhry was because of Atty.-Gen. Pillsbury’s desire that a con sultation of insanity ex: erts should be held to determine the mental condition of Miss Borden, he firmly believing, not in her inno

See the clipping

Waterbury Evening Democrat · Waterbury, Conn.

A Taunton report claims Lizzie Borden's mind is giving way under the strain of awaiting trial for the murders of her father and stepmother. It states she is too ill to be moved to New Bedford for trial.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

Waterbury Evening Democrat · 22 May 1893 · page 4

LIZZIE BORDEN'S CONDITION.

Everything was quiet at the prison Yesterday. Chamberlain was absent rojn the institution. He had gone to his farm in Massachusetts and is not ex pected back until Tuesday afternoon, when the investigating committee meets again. it is expected mat uenerai uaven will ask the investigating committee to allow Mr Atwood, the former prison chaplain, to take the position again. A number of the prisoners who cannot read or write are missing the night school which they used to attend, and over which the chaplain presided. LIZZIE BORDEN'S CONDITION. The Unfortunate Woman's Hind Giving: way unaer mo ure mnin.

See moreSee less

Taunton, Mass, May aa. it was stated to-day that Lizzie Borden, under iuukiuwuii xui uuus u iuu stepmother, is becoming insane. Her mind is giving way under tne great strain and she is too illto be taken to New Bedford for trial. The "Now York" 1 a Flyer. Rockport, Mass, May 22. The cruiser "New York" completed her trial trip at 1:43, making the run in four hours and eighteen minutes, developing an unomciai record or twenty-one miles an hour. Buchanan's Sentence Deferred. Niw York, May 22. Dr Robert W, Buchanan, the wife murderer, will not be sentenced until two weens from todav. owinsr to a misunderstanding be tween the district attorney and Recorder Smythe. President McLeod May Retire New York, May 22. It was rumored in wan street to-day that important charges were about to take place in the management of the JNew England road including the retirement of President UcLieod within a wees. Big Fire in Kensington, New Britain, May 22. Kensington was visited by a sia.uuu nre eariv yesterday morning and had it not been for the summoning of tbe nre depart ment from here promptly the entire village would have probably been wiped out. Aa it was wooding Brothers fac tory, H. W. Wood's house, Baldwin Fingle's barn and two unoccupied iron foundries went up in smoke. Student Dwlght'a Disgrace James Snyder Dwight of Poughkeepsie, N. Y., a member of the senior clase of Yale, was arrested Saturday night by Sergeant Cowles, charged with the theft of diamonds, clothing and othei articles of value from Stuart McKnigh Bi-riniM nr va ma rrnm Kmart hi r. k mohi or other vehicle ill.' . . uisiiutoii.Cuiu lockup for several hours, but was sub sequently released under bonds cf $500 furnished by ur-J. U. f oster. Wanderings of an Aged Man, Meriden, May 22. Reubin Johnson aged seventy, formerly a well known bat manufacturer in Danbury. who re tired from business some years ago, and has since been living with his son in Fair Haven, a suburb of New Haven was found insane and almost exhausted wandering about near Yalesville last night. He strayed from his home yesterday morning and was seen near East Rock park in New Haven about noon. He walked all the afternoon and shortly before 8 o'clock last night arrived at the house of J. J. Ives in Tracy. He ate nothing since morning and was almost fainting. having walked ntteen miles, tie was unable to tell much about himself ex cept that he lived in New Haven and tbe police of that city were at once no tified. It happened that Mr Johnson son was at police headquarters at the time to notify the police of the disap pearance of his father and he at once made arrangements to bring him back He has been afflicted with fits of in sanity for some time, the result of kick by a horse some years ago. and

See the clipping

The Portland Daily Press · Portland, Me.

Reformer Mary A. Livermore visited Lizzie Borden and described her as a quiet, sensible woman, contradicting the sensational portrayals in newspapers. The brief item appears embedded within an unrelated editorial on lynching.

The Portland Daily Press · 22 May 1893 · page 1

Mrs. Mary A. Livermore has called on Lizzie Borden and found her a quiet, sensible woman, far different from the person described hy the newspapers.

See the clipping

The Evening Herald · Shenandoah, Pa.

A short dispatch from Fall River reports that Chief Justice Mason and Judges Blodgett and Dewey have been definitely chosen to preside at Lizzie Borden's upcoming trial in New Bedford. The trial is scheduled for the following month.

The Evening Herald · 22 May 1893 · page 3

To l'roalde at Mute Itorden's Trial. Fall Kiver, May 22. It has been de finitely decided that Chief Justice Mason and Judgos Blodgett and Deway are to preside at the trial of Lizzie Borden at imw Ueiltord next mouth.

See the clipping

Pawtucket Tribune · Pawtucket, R.I.

The report confirms the Borden trial will begin June 5 in New Bedford despite rumors of delay, and notes both prosecution and defense had preferred Taunton as the venue. It also previews expected evidence, including the burned dress, the safe robbery, and Bridget Sullivan's testimony.

Pawtucket Tribune · 22 May 1893 · page 1

THE BORDEN CASE Trial Will Begin June 5 and Last Two Weeks. NO NEW DEVELOPMENTS. Unusual Secrecy Maintained About Matters Pertaining to the Case.

Matters Pertaining to the Case. NEW BEDFORD, Mass., May 22 —Despite renorts that the conunsel in the Borden case would not find it convenient to be here on Monday, Jime 5, and that the trial would not be opened until the day following, i$ may be stated as a fact that it will be be gun on the day set, It #s understood that neither the govern ment nor the attorneys for the defense wished to Have the Trial Held Here, but that both would have preferred Taune ton: bm the court settled It, and that ended it.

See moreSee less

Undoubtedly Taunton would have been the choice of Lizzie Borden, a sO, had «he been consulted, for she has bocome accus.omed to her quarters there, and she would be likely to undergo the nervous strain of the trial more easily there than here amid entirely new sure roundings. It is stated that not very much new evie dence of any great importance is likely to be introduced, and that the preliminary hearing really afforded the public a very good iden of the case on both sides, The relations of the varions members of the Borden family to each other, it is said, may be brou _ht out more fully; the al leged buraiug of a dress by Lizzie Borden on the Day Following the Murders may be emphasized, and the mysterious robbing of Mr Borden’s safe some months

See the clipping

Pawtucket Tribune · Pawtucket, R.I.

Rumors swirl about whether witness Bridget Sullivan will add new testimony, but officials maintain strict secrecy about case developments since the preliminary hearing. It is confirmed that Chief Justice Mason and Judges Blodgett and Dewey will preside over Lizzie Borden's trial next month in New Bedford, expected to last about two weeks.

Pawtucket Tribune · 22 May 1893 · page 1

Dewey are to preside at the trial of Lizzie Borden at New Bedford next month. SERIOUS RAILROAD ACCIDENT. A Train Puns Wild Causing a Property Loss of $25.000 But No Lives Lost. BARRE, Vi, May 22.—<The first big ao eident in the history of the Barre railroad

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

The report describes Lizzie Borden's partial recovery from a cold she had since May 8, but notes that loss of sleep and health troubles are affecting her mind. It questions whether she will be well enough to be present when her case is called for trial.

The Providence News · 22 May 1893 · page 1

LIZZIE BORDEN'S CASE

The words of this article could not be separated from the rest of its page. Read it in the clipping.

No clean clipping could be cut from this page

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

This column is a multi-story New England news roundup, covering a serious train wreck in Barre, Vermont and naval trials off Gloucester, Massachusetts. The headline teases a note about 'The Judges in the Lizzie Borden Case,' but no actual Borden content appears in the surviving text.

The Providence News · 22 May 1893 · page 3

A YALE STUDENT'S MISDOING. The Haverhill Police Kept Busy—Great Barrington Suffering ¥From the Work of Incendiaries—The Judges in the Lizzle Borden Case. BARRE, Vt., May 2¢.—The first big ac

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

The report states that Chief Justice Mason and Judges Blodgett and Dewey have been chosen to preside over Lizzie Borden's upcoming trial. The trial is scheduled to take place in New Bedford the following month.

The Providence News · 22 May 1893 · page 3

Lizzie Borden's Trial. BosToN, May 23.—1 t has been definitely decided that Chief Justice Mason and Judges Blodgett and Dewey are to preside at the trial of Lizzie Borden at New Bed ford, next month.

See the clipping

The Hawaiian Gazette · Honolulu, Hawaii · and 1 other paper

Lizzie Borden of Massachusetts, accused of murdering her father and mother, was arraigned on three indictments and pleaded not guilty before returning to jail. Her trial was scheduled for June.

The Hawaiian Gazette · 23 May 1893 · page 5

partment. They feel absolute confidence in the administration to handle the question without alarm to the country or detriment to the public credit. Secretary Carlisle is quoted as saying that the situation was entirely satisfactory; that he had assurances that the New York banks would aiu the department if the necessity arose, but that he did not believe such would be necessary. The St. Louis banks have come to the aid of the United States trpasurv, and tomorrow over 2,000,000 in gold will be handed to the sub-treasury in exchange for treasury aud national bank notes. Lizzie Borden of Massachusetts, the alleged murderess of her father and

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • The Pacific Commercial Advertiser · Honolulu, Hawaiian Islands · 18 May 1893

Morning Journal and Courier · New Haven, Conn.

A newspaper brief reports that Lizzie Borden's physician has stated her mind is not failing, countering circulating rumors about her mental state. The item appears amid other short wire dispatches shortly before her trial.

CorrectionThis set right an article from the day before.

Morning Journal and Courier · 23 May 1893 · page 3

LIZZIE BORDEN'S MIND ALL RIGHT.

Wonderful Time Made by the New York. LIZZIE BORDEN'S KIKD AIL BIGHT.

See the clipping

Morning Journal and Courier · New Haven, Conn.

A report claims Lizzie Borden's mind is failing under the strain of confinement and the approaching trial, suggesting the trial could be delayed. Her jail physician, Dr. Paige, flatly denies this, stating her mind has never been clearer as she recovers from illness.

Morning Journal and Courier · 23 May 1893 · page 3

LIZZIE BORDEN'S CONDITION. It Is Alleged That Her Mind la Fall. lnar, But Her Jail Physician De nies it. Taumtoh, Mass., May 22. The Gazette to-night aays: "Taunton jail is almost a deaf and dumb institution, but enough has been gathered from it to indicate that the long confinement and approaching trial are rapidly unnerving Llszle Borden. If she continues in the grade down whioh she is travelling the trial will not take place on June 5, perhaps at all in the way marked out by the authorities and defense. The jury may be a commission of physicians In spite of the protestations of her counsel at the preliminary hearing in Fall Biver."

See moreSee less

Dr. Paige, who is Llule Borden's Dbvslol&n at the jail, was asked this afternoon as to tbe truth of the statement, intimat ing that Miss Borden's mind is failing. Without hesitation he said, there was no truth whatever in the statement. In fact, he said that Miss Borden's mind bad never been dearer than it was now, as she is con valescing from her illness. The dootor says that Miss Borden is so far recovered that she is able to be about the house at Sheriff Wright's, although she is not al lowed much freedom, of oonrse. Dr. false was asked if Miss Borden wonld be ordered baok to her cell before the time of taking her to New Bedford. and he spoke as though it is doubtful. The greatest care will be taken to guard against a reiapse.

See the clipping

Waterbury Evening Democrat · Waterbury, Conn.

Dr. Naimus Paige, Lizzie Borden's physician at the Taunton jail, denies rumors that her mental state is deteriorating. He states her mind has never been clearer than at present.

Waterbury Evening Democrat · 23 May 1893 · page 1

Lizzie Borden's Mind Not Failing. Taunton, Mass., May 23. Dr. Naimus Paige, Lizzie A. Borden's physician at the Taunton jail, says there is no truth in the statement that Miss Borden's mind is fail

See the clipping

The Portland Daily Press · Portland, Me.

A brief item reports that rumors from Taunton claiming Lizzie Borden is in danger of mental collapse are being denied. No further detail is given on the source of the original rumor.

The Portland Daily Press · 23 May 1893 · page 1

BRIEFLY TOLd! Reports'from Taunton that Miss Lizzie Borden is in danger of mental collapse are denied. There are fears in San Francisco of an outbreak among the Highbinders on ac count of the Geary law. Professor Robinson of Bowdoin has analyzed a lot of Uno beer at the request of Lewiston offioers, and declared it to be an intoxicant within the meaning of the law. Several packages of the beer have been seized in Lewiston. The Boston Globe has an interview with John L. Sullivan, in which John is quoted as saying that tie may yet sue Lawyer Lizotte for obtaining money un der false pretences.

See moreSee less

As John is made to speak of Lizotte as using “both his hands” there is soqoe doubt as to the au thenticity of tha ihterview.

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

This brief item states that rumors claiming Lizzie Borden is insane have been authoritatively denied. It offers no further detail on the origin of the rumor or the source of the denial.

The Providence News · 23 May 1893 · page 2

RUMOR DENIED, By High Authority

P * A ‘3! 'Ji \ The Rumor That Lizzie Borden Is Tnsane Authoritatively Denied A Burning Steamior -Sad Drowning Aceident st New Haven My, Nickerson's Will, KEENE, N. H., Mmay 24.~0ne of the. big boilers at the Beaver wills in this city ex

See the clipping

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

As Lizzie Borden's murder trial is about to begin, Mrs. Mary Livermore reports having interviewed the accused and states her belief in Borden's innocence despite the circumstantial evidence against her. The writer notes the trial will draw great public interest due to the perplexing nature of the case.

New-York Tribune · 24 May 1893 · page 6

Now that the trial of Lizzie Borden for the murder of her parents is about to begin, Mrs. Mary Livermore comes to the front and asserts her belief in her innocence. Mrs. Livermore has been interviewing the accused, and, after hearing what

See the clipping

Pawtucket Tribune · Pawtucket, R.I.

This report outlines the six main points the government plans to emphasize at Lizzie Borden's upcoming trial, including the burned dress, the safe robbery, family tension, the hatchet, and lack of alternative suspects. It also previews the defense's likely counterarguments, particularly regarding the dress-burning and the safe robbery.

Pawtucket Tribune · 24 May 1893 · page 1

Defenee Say, Can Easily Be Met. NEW BEDFORD, Mass., May 24 -Is s understood that the government will bring into prominence six leading features in the coming trial of Lizzie A. Borden, These are (1) the alleged burning of a dress by the defendant on the day follow ing the murdsrs; (2) the mysterious rob bery of Andrew Borden's safe some months before his death; (3) the alleged strained relations between Lizzie Borden and her father and stepmother; (4) the finding of the hatchet with which the murders are alleged to have been eom mitted; (5) the failure of all other clues except that leading to Lizzie Borden to offer any explanation of the crimes; (6) the lack of opportunity for any other persom to have committed the deed.

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

With nearly 50 jurors drawn for the upcoming trial, this report outlines six main points the prosecution plans to raise against Lizzie Borden, including the burned dress, the safe robbery, and the murder weapon. It also predicts the defense's strategy will expose inconsistencies strong enough to likely secure an acquittal.

The Providence News · 24 May 1893 · page 2

THE SIX KNOTTY POINTS,

Borden’s Acquittal, it is Clalmed. NEw BeEpronn, Mass,, May 24 —Consid erable excitement was caused here yester day afternoon by the drawing of nearly 50 jurors for the Borden murder case, It is understood that the government will bring into prominence six leading features in the coming trial of Lizzie A. Borden, These are (1) the alleged burning of a dress by the defendant on the day follow fng the murders; (2) the mysterious rob bery of Andrew Borden's safe some months before his death; (3) the alleged strained relations between Lizzie Borden and her father and stepmother; (4) the finding of the hatchet with which the mur ders are alleged to have been committed; (5) the failure of all other clues except that leading to Lizzie Borden to offer any ex planation of the crimes: (6) the lack of op portunity for any other person to have committed the deed.

See moreSee less

Regarding the alleged burning of a dress, it is said that the defense will prob ably not offer a denial, but will put in an explanation felt to be Sufficlent to Destroy the Weight of the government’s contention, It re mains to be seen how satisfactory the ex planation may be. This is an important point, The robbery of Mr. Borden's safe, while undoubtedly mysterious and possibly, when unexplained, tending to throw sus picion upon some member of the family, it is said can easily be met by the defense, in so far as removing any conclusive rea son for laying it at Lizzie's door. This whole episode will probably be treated as a hearsay exaggeration, It is a very serious question, however, whether the government can put in this evidence, for it is held that it is inadmis sible, unless possibly it might be intro duced as tending to show the relations ex isting between the defendant and her father. Even upon this claim, however,

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

This report previews likely courtroom arguments, noting the defense will stress reasonable doubt and the possibility of another intruder, including Dr. Handy's mysterious "wild-eyed man." It also states the government will rely solely on the hatchet from the preliminary hearing, dismissing rumors of additional hatchets as unfounded.

The Providence News · 24 May 1893 · page 2

THE ARGUMENT OF THE DEFENSE

e Evidence Abont the Robbery. While it is generally understood that the family relations were not altogether pleasant five years ago, the defense will set out to show that more recently the family relations had been altogether pleas ant and harmonious. As to the hatchet, there is no probability that the government will put in any hatchet other than the one shown at the preliminary hearing; and all talk of the recent finding of other hatchets is abso lutely without foundation, In all probability the defense will not put forth with any insistence any explana tion of the erimes, devoting itself chiefly to the defense of lizzie Borden to the charge against her: but it is extremely likely that the presence of other persons in the neighborhood of the house, Dr, Handy's *“wild-eyed man” and other similar polnts brought out at the pre liminary heaving, Will Again Be Emphasized, The state, of course, will again Insist upon the theory advauced previously, that it shows by the process of exclusion that no other person than Lizzie Borden had the opportunity to commit the erimes, and that no other person has been found upen whom any suspicion can rest, that she must have done it.

See moreSee less

The defense, however, will insist that this theory is not consistent with the ei dence of the state, which it will undoubt« edly argae allows abundant opportunity for some other person to have entered the house, committed the murder and escaped without detection,

See the clipping

Connecticut Western News · Salisbury, Conn. · and 1 other paper

Dr. Nainus Paige, Lizzie Borden's physician at the Taunton jail, denied rumors that her mind was failing. He stated she had recovered enough to move about Sheriff Wright's house, though with restricted freedom.

Connecticut Western News · 25 May 1893 · page 1

Lizzie Borden's Condition. Taunton, Mass., May 23. Dr. Nainus Paige, who is Lizzie A. .Borden's physician at the Taunton jail, was asked as to the truth of the statement intimating that Miss Borden's mind is failing. He said that there was no t ruth in the statement. The doctor says that Miss Borden is so far recovered that she is able to be about the house at Sheriff Wright's, although she is not allowed much freedom of course.

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • The Monmouth Inquirer · Freehold, N.J. · 25 May 1893

Santa Fe Daily New Mexican · Santa Fe, N.M.

Amid a roundup of brief national and territorial news items, one line reports that Lizzie Borden, under indictment for the Taunton, Mass. murders of her father and mother, is losing her mind. No further detail or source is given.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

Santa Fe Daily New Mexican · 25 May 1893 · page 1

CONDENSED NEWS. Two mud dogs bit over twenty people in Chioago yesterday. At Louisville, Ky., the wind destroyed $300,000 worth of property. The coal miners' strike is spreading in Kansas, and 18,000 men will soon be out. Lizzie Borden, under indictment for killing her father and mother at Taunton, Mass., is losing her mind. ' E. E. Towner, supposedly of Denver, a middle aged, handsome and well dressed man, blew out his brains in tho Hollen-. den, at Cleveland, Ohio. Wind storms in Minnesota, Wisconsin and Iowa have done a great amount of damage.

See moreSee less

At St. Paul one man was killed and in Wisconsin two. Many buildings were blown down at Sioux City. Jimmy Carroll, of New York, has signed articles for Johnny Griffin to fight Solly Smith before the Columbian Athletic olub of Chicago for a purse of $6,000. The fight is to take place the first week in July.

See the clipping

The Times · Richmond, Va.

The report states Lizzie Borden has been held in jail for nearly a year awaiting trial on only vague circumstantial evidence, and is reputedly losing her mind. It reflects sympathetically on the psychological toll of her prolonged imprisonment, whether she is guilty or innocent.

The Times · 25 May 1893 · page 4

Charged with a terrible crime, of which there is only vagae circumstantial evi dence against her, end kept in jail for nearly a vear without being brought 10 trial, Lizzie Borden, it is reputed, is

See the clipping

Burlington Weekly Free Press · Burlington, Vt.

A Fall River dispatch reports that prolonged confinement and the approaching trial are rapidly unnerving Lizzie Borden. It speculates that if her decline continues, the trial may not occur on June 8 as planned, or might proceed before a different kind of jury.

Burlington Weekly Free Press · 25 May 1893 · page 3

LZZ.B BORDEN UNNERVED. ler Itniilth ltrd tttliiL; llmili Llltlrr Con. lhiHtilPilt and tlio C'ollllni; Trial. Tai .-., Mnsj., May 2J. Tho Go ?etlu this afternoon : Long con iin uieri and t jo approaching trial are rapidly unnerving Lizzie Hordcu. If tilt ci.t i.ue on tho gir.de down which tho is now travelling Lit r tiinl will uot take pluco June 8, perhaps not at all in tho way marked out by the authoritioi and tho dt 'cti,". 'iho jury may bo a commission of , j b ;, j cans.

See the clipping

Burlington Weekly Free Press · Burlington, Vt.

Mrs. Mary Livermore recounts a jailhouse interview with Lizzie Borden, who speaks calmly but sadly about being falsely accused of the murders. Borden argues the crime's circumstances—broad daylight, visible windows, nearby servants and an expected uncle—make her guilt implausible.

Burlington Weekly Free Press · 25 May 1893 · page 3

lizzie borden's defence. Sho 1VIU .linrr I.lvrrllloro Atiout the I'roseciitlnn'n ttenU 'I'lmorj. MniTdN, May 10. Mm. Mary A. I.lrer nioro hud a long Interview with tho alleged

See the clipping

St. Johnsbury Caledonian · St. Johnsbury, Vt.

A compilation of the week's national news items reports that Lizzie Borden is said to be breaking down under the severe strain of her protracted confinement in jail. The roundup otherwise covers fires, strikes, storms, bank closures, and other unrelated events.

St. Johnsbury Caledonian · 25 May 1893 · page 8

RECORD OF THE WEEK.

Lizzie Borden is said to be break ing down under the severe strain to which she has been subjected and the protracted confinement in jail. By

See the clipping

Morning Journal and Courier · New Haven, Conn.

A brief news item states that Lizzie Borden will be tried next month. No further details are given in this short telegraph dispatch.

Morning Journal and Courier · 26 May 1893 · page 3

THERE WILL BC MO POSTPONEMENT. Lizzie Borden Will Be Tried Next Month. INFAXTA EOUUE IN NEW YORK. Greeted by Salutes From the War Vessels. WILL OPEN ON SUNDAY.

See the clipping

Morning Journal and Courier · New Haven, Conn.

The Boston press reports that Attorney General Pillsbury will not personally try the Borden case due to health concerns, with District Attorney Knowlton and District Attorney Moody of Essex handling the prosecution instead. There is no application for postponement, and the trial is expected to proceed as scheduled at New Bedford on June 5.

Morning Journal and Courier · 26 May 1893 · page 3

Attorney General Plllsbury Will Not Try it No Application ror Postponement. Boston, Hay 25. The City Frees is authority for the statement that Attorney General Pillsbnry will not try the Borden oase. Tbe City Press ia authorized to state that the trial will be conducted on the part of the government by District Attorney Knowlton, assisted by Dlstrlot Attorney Moody of the Essex district. Booh recent tests as Mr. Plllsbury has made of his strength to show that while steadily gaining he is not yet able to under take the protracted strain and labor ot a capital trial without risks, which his phy sician will not allow him to incur.

See moreSee less

There has been no application for or suggestion of postponement and there ia scarcely any donbt that the trial will proceed at New Bedford on Jnne 5, as assigned.

See the clipping

The Morning News · Savannah, Ga.

The report notes that the trial of Lizzie Borden, accused of murdering her father and stepmother in Fall River, Massachusetts, will start in a few days. It highlights the strong circumstantial case against her but notes she has influential supporters, including reformer Mary A. Livermore, who plans to speak out during the trial.

The Morning News · 26 May 1893 · page 4

The trial of Lizzie Borden, the Fall River (Mass.) woman, who is accused of murdering both her father and step mother, will be begun In a few days. The case is a peculiarly interesting’ one, and a seemingly complete network of circum stantial evidence has lioen drawn around the accused. Notwithstanding this, Miss Borden has many influential friends who refuse to believe her guilty. Among those friends is Mrs. Mary A. Livermore, the noted Boston reformer, who proposes to bo beard from during tho trial. The Appeal to Statistics.—l am told, dear, that Jack Uattlepate spoilt most of his Easter vacation in your hack parlor.

See moreSee less

Aren i you giving him rather a dangerous amount of en couragementl' "Why, no, dearest, he Is merely a boy. To bo sure he Is u year older than 1. hut I shall Ist out next winter. whlh Jack has two years more in college, and It will Isnix yearn after I hat before he can earu much of anything So, practically, he Is nix years younger Ilian 1, and that makes him 12. It l abeurd to talk snout encouraging a boy no young as that." Burlier s Bazar.

See the clipping

Springfield Weekly Republican · Springfield, Mass.

A brief news item reports that Chief Justice Mason and Judges Blodgett and Dewey have been definitively selected to preside over Lizzie Borden's upcoming trial in New Bedford. The item appears within a roundup of short Massachusetts news items.

Springfield Weekly Republican · 26 May 1893 · page 5

EASTERN MASSACHUSETTS.

works will be rebuilt at once .probably. Walter Paine, 3d, surrendered to the au thorities at Boston Sunday and was ad mitted to bail in the sum of SIO,OOO, his son, Sydney B. Paine of Providence, R, 1.. and his son-in-law, Ray Greene Haling of New Bedford, being the bondsmen. Paine was agent and treasurer of the American linen company, and it was charged against him that he falsified the books of the corpo ration to cover up illegal transactions. His offense was committed about the date of the Chace-Hathaway defalcations, and shortly after it became known he made his escape to Montreal, where he has since been inter ested in a cotton mill.

See moreSee less

It has been sus pected for some time that he was anxious to settle the case against him. It has been definitely decided that Chief Justice Mason and judges Blodgett and Dewey are to preside at the trial of Lizzie Borden at New’ Bedford next month.

See the clipping

Springfield Weekly Republican · Springfield, Mass.

The report notes that Judge Dewey, presiding over the upcoming Lizzie Borden trial, has refused requests from Boston newspapers for his photograph, having not had one taken in years. It jokes that reporters will have to sketch him or catch him by surprise when the trial begins.

Springfield Weekly Republican · 26 May 1893 · page 8

Judge Dewey is a stumbling-block in the way of the Boston newspa)*'rs. apropos of the trial of Lizzie Borden. Requests have been pairing in upon the judge for his picture, but he is like Mr Olney when

See the clipping

Springfield Weekly Republican · Springfield, Mass.

Dr. Caleb (Danforth) Paige, Lizzie Borden's physician at the Taunton jail, denied rumors that her mind was failing, saying it had never been clearer. He noted she was recovering well enough to move about Sheriff Wright's house, though under restricted freedom ahead of her transfer to New Bedford.

CorrectionThis set right an article from the day before.

Springfield Weekly Republican · 26 May 1893 · page 8

MISS BORDEN'S MIND ALL RIGHT.

WORCESTER COUNTY. James J. B arren, president of the J. J. Warren company, manufacturers of leather goods, died at Worcester Sunday, aged 71. The corporation has branch offices in Boston, New York, Denver and San Fran cisco. He was a native of Brimfield and his body will be taken there for burial. Mr and Mrs John E. Russell of Leices ter are now in Paris, on their way to Eu gland, after a successful three months’ tour of Snain. MISS BORDER'S miniEallright. Dr JSanamua Paige of Taunton, who is Liz zie Borden’s physician at the Taunton jai' was asked the other afternoon as to the truth of the statement intimating that Miss Bor den’s mind is failing.

See moreSee less

Without hesitating ho said that there was no truth what ever in the statement. In fact, he said that Miss Borden's mind had never bten clear er than it was while she is cou valescing from her recent illness. The doctor says that Miss Borden is so far recovered that she is able to be about the house at Sheriff Wright’s, although she is notallowed much freedom of course. Dr I’aige was asked if Miss Borden would be ordered back to her’ cell before the time ot taking her to New Bedford, and he spoke as though it is doubtful. The greatest care will be taken to guard against a relapse. Things Worth Remembering. When you feel a kind of goneness about the stomach it is a sign that your mod does not sit well and that you are about to have a fit of indigestion. When you begin to feel nervous and are unable to sit still comfortably; when your clothes sudden ly seem to lose their nt and become too tight in places the lit of indigestion is surely upon you. W heu this fit of indigestion is repeated from day to day it finally resolves itself Into dyspepsia. Remember that three to ten of Bbandreth'S Pills will cure the worst case of indigestion or dyspepsia, or both, and that a regular course of them, say two every night for a week or ten days, will act as a preventive of either complaint. Found—the reason for the great popularity of Hood’s Sarsaparilla—simply this; Hoort's Cukes. Be sure to get Hood’s. If ever a man feels like “a poor worm of tha dust,” it is when he suffers from that tired feel ing. Ayer’s Sarsaparilla removes this discourag ing physical condition and imparts the thrill of new life »nd energy to every nerve, tissue, muscle, and fiber of the whole body.

See the clipping

Springfield Weekly Republican · Springfield, Mass.

A political column discussing Massachusetts gubernatorial prospects mentions that Attorney-General Pillsbury's participation in the Lizzie Borden murder trial might hurt his political standing. The writer dismisses this concern, insisting Pillsbury will do his duty regardless of political consequences.

Springfield Weekly Republican · 26 May 1893 · page 9

Lizzie Borden murder trial by AttorneyGeneral I’illsbury might damage his polit ical prospects. However that may be, the attorney-general will do his whole duty to the commonwealth whose law ntiicer he

See the clipping

In the story →

Springfield Weekly Republican · Springfield, Mass.

Mrs Mary A. Livermore, who knew Lizzie Borden from Sunday school, recounts her visit to the prisoner in Taunton jail, describing her appearance and demeanor to a Boston Post reporter. She describes Lizzie as pale, coughing, emotionally affected despite reports of stolidity, and physically different from newspaper caricatures.

Springfield Weekly Republican · 26 May 1893 · page 11 · transcribed from the page image

A TALK WITH LIZZIE BORDEN.

Mrs Mary A. Livermore Visits Her In Taunton Jail.

See moreSee less

Mrs Mary A. Livermore, who knew Lizzie Borden as a girl in Sunday-school at Fall River years ago, and who has corresponded with the prisoner regularly of late, recently visited her in Taunton jail. She told the story of her call to a reporter of the Boston Post, and here it is: "I found Lizzie in the matron's room, which is pleasant and prettily furnished, and where she is as comforable as she can be under the circumstances. Lizzie is of larger build than her sister, with blue eyes and lighter hair. All the pictures I have seen have been caricatures of her. She has really a refined and intelligent face, though she is not pretty and probably about 30. Her sister must be about a dozen years older. Emma looks like the Bordens, but Lizzie neither looks like her father or mother. She talked to me freely of the whole case, but very calmly and sadly. The comments on her stolidity are absurd. You can see that the girl feels her position keenly. She has changed little since her imprisonment. She has not grown thin, but is pale from the long confinement within doors. Her cough troubles her a great deal and she is quite hoarse. She begged me to stay longer, but I felt that it was taxing her strength too much to talk with her more.

"When I saw the girl and talked with her, face to face, it seemed incredible that she could be the Lizzie Borden of the newspapers. I have corresponded with her all through these months of waiting for the trial, but this was my first sight of her since early youth. 'Do you know,' I said to her, 'I want to go down stairs into some cell to find the woman charged with the murder of her parents, because I cannot believe it is you?' 'Unfortunately I am that woman!' she replied sadly. Then I spoke of the comments on her stolid indifference. 'What would they have me do?' she asked, sadly. 'Howl? Go into hysterics? I am wrongly accused of two horrible crimes. I know it is useless to cry out in indignation at the outrage, and so I am trying hard to keep calm and self-controled until I shall be proved innocent.

"'What hurts me most,' she said again, 'is the malignant feeling that has been shown. I have done no harm to any one. Is my character of 30 years to count for nothing—nothing—because I am accused of so terrible a crime?' Lizzie spoke of her step-mother throughout as 'mother.' 'She was the best step-mother I ever heard of,' she told me; 'she never spoke or acted unkindly to either of us in all the years. She married my father when I was three years old, and she always seemed like my own mother.'

"She admitted that the Borden family was 'close' when I referred to some incidents between her Aunt Abby and her father, but not that her father was hard. 'He was never hard to me. He was close in money matters, but I never asked him for anything that I wanted very much that I didn't get it, though sometimes I had to ask two or three times. And then if I wanted anything that I didn't care to ask of father, I would go to mother, and she would always see that he humored me.'

"In reference to the crime, she told me of her discovery of her father: 'I had covered him up and fixed his pillow and cared for him but half an hour before, and when I opened the door of the sitting-room the first that I saw was the blood pouring down the side of his head as he lay. I do not know what I thought first—that he was dead, that some one had killed my father. I did not think of my mother at all.' Then she grew more excited and spoke of the crime itself. 'How can they think me guilty? What a fool must I have been if I committed a crime like that in broad daylight, with the certainty of detection, with people going to and fro on the street, with Bridget washing windows and likely to come in for water at any minute; with my uncle visiting us and likely to be back at any time, with the curtains up and the neighbors astir? I knew every foot of that house. I could have walked all over it in the dark, sure of my way. Why, if I contemplated that crime, should I not have done it at night? Two blows as they lay asleep, no noise, no stir; I could have opened wide the street door, made evidence of a struggle in the room, and then with plenty of time to remove from myself all traces of the blood, gone quietly to bed. But they say that I committed both crimes at noonday and removed from myself all evidence of the horrible work. How can they believe that?'"

See the clipping

Springfield Weekly Republican · Springfield, Mass.

A reporter recounts a personal conversation with Lizzie Borden in her cell, in which she defends her composure and character, describes her affection for her stepmother, and recounts discovering her father's body. She also argues it would have been illogical for her to commit the murders in broad daylight given the risk of detection.

Springfield Weekly Republican · 26 May 1893 · page 11

A TALK WITH LIZZIE BORDEN

seemed like my own mother.’ “She admitted that the Borden family was ‘close’ when I referred to some inci dents between her Aunt Abby and her father, but not that her father was hard. 'He was never hard to me. He was close

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

The report announces that District Attorneys Knowlton and Moody, not Attorney General Pillsbury, will prosecute the Borden case due to Pillsbury's health. It also details an 1891 burglary at the Borden home, involving a stolen writing desk, money, and Mrs. Borden's watch, which may be introduced as evidence at the upcoming trial.

The Providence News · 26 May 1893 · page 3

THE COMING BORDEN TRIAL

BosToN, May 26.—Attorney Genera) Pillsbury will not try the Borden case. District Attorney Knowlton of Bristol county, assisted by District Attorney Moody of Essex county, will represent

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

The report recounts the 1891 theft of money, street car tickets, and Mrs. Borden's gold watch from a writing desk at the Borden home, which Andrew Borden asked authorities to keep secret. It notes the case was eventually dropped by Borden himself and may become relevant evidence in the upcoming murder trial.

The Providence News · 26 May 1893 · page 3

THE STORY OF HOUSE ROBBERY

80 on to the end of the ctu‘{)ur. The fact is that on June 24, 1891, An drew J. Borden discovered that a large old-fashioned writing desk at his home had been opened and money, street car tickets and a gold watch belonging to Mrs. Borden abstracted. The latter was particularly prized because of its as sociations, although not otherwise valu able. Mr. Borden immediately reported the affair to the authorities, with the request that it be kept a profound secret. It was kept quiet for over a year, aud had it not been for the terrible developments in the family last August the robbery would almost have been forgotten.

See moreSee less

In any event, it never would have reached the public prints. It is understood that the fasten ings on the desk had been tampered with, although the final entrance may have been effected with a key which fitted the lock, either by accident or intention, It is a coincidence that an oflicer was put upon the case who knew the Borden family thoroughly. In fact, it may be said that he had in a sense grown up with the daughters, There had been a series of robberies in Fall River just preceding this, and a young man was finally tripped up with a lot of different sized keys in his possession; but there seems to have been something dis tinctive about this thefu that

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

The article revisits a prior theft of street railway tickets and cash from the Borden home, noting Mr. Borden abruptly halted the police investigation despite tickets being traceable. It outlines how both prosecution and defense plan to use this old robbery as circumstantial evidence regarding Lizzie Borden's possible involvement or innocence in the murders.

The Providence News · 26 May 1893 · page 3

THE STORY OF HOUSE ROBBERY

Did Not Indicate an Expert. Mr. Borden was a director in the street railway company, and the tickets stolen were those issued only to directors. Con sequently, being of such limited issue, it was comparatively easy to trace the thief the minute the tickets were presented. The amount of money takén was not large. A watch was kept on the street cars for peveral weeks, but just what the detec tive’s work disclosed will not be known before the trial, for, suddenly, Mr. Borden told the officers to drop the case.

See moreSee less

It is said, however, that the tickets were traced to some person. It does not appear that anything elsc was taken from the house at this time, nor were any other of the houses in that neighborhood robbed. The state will argue that the ordinary thief must have known that the use of the street car tickets would have led to early detection and that the watch was of small value. The robbery, it is said, was committed at a time when some of the family must have been about the house. Mr. Borden had a safe in his house at the time, which was filled with waluable papers; yet its contents remained unharmed, seemingly indicating that the robbery was not the work of an accomplished cracksman., On the other hand it is said that the de fense will urge that there is not, and never was, any evidence whatever connecting Lizzie Borden with the robbery, that the suppositious theory is Created Solely by the Suspicion cast upon her by her arrest for the mur ders, and shat the very fact that the rob bery was committed during the presence in the house of members of the family only serves to prove the possibility of some one also having entered the house from outside and committed the murders. Itis hinted also that it may not be im possible to show that Mr. Borden's only reason for discontinuing the police investi gation was that the thief had returned the watch and in return had been promised immunity from prosectition. It is also said that there has never been a general opinion among the authorities that any evidence was secured upon which the police would have dared to make an arrest. The question of whether the evidence on this subject will be admitted is a serious one, but it is understood that the government will fight hard to get it in as apart of its chain of circumstantial evi dence.

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

The report states that Attorney General Pillsbury will not actively participate in prosecuting Lizzie Borden due to poor health, leaving the case to District Attorney Knowlton. The writer questions why Borden was kept in jail for months awaiting trial if the attorney general was not going to lead the prosecution after all.

The Providence News · 26 May 1893 · page 4

WHAT DOES IT MEAN? It is now authoritatively announced that Attorney Goneral Pillsbury will not participate actively in the prosecu tion of Lizzie Borden, on the ground that his health will not permit him to undertake so arduous a task, This is a tacit admission that the government regards her conviction a difficult matter, In view of the fact that Lizzie Borden hus been kept in jail for many months, untried, in order that the case might be conducted by the attorney general instead of the district attorney, a 8 is customary—thissudden recognifion of Mr.

See moreSee less

Knowlton’s ability to try the case must be very flattering to that gentleman, but how it compensates Miss Borden for the injustice done to her by this prolonged and unnecessary delay is a mystery. Can it be that the truth can more easily be obtained from witnesses mouths after the crime was committed than while it was still fresh in their minds? There certainly must be some reason for this long delay.

See the clipping

The Bessemer Indicator · Bessemer, Colo.

A short telegraphic brevity item claims that Lizzie Borden's mental state is deteriorating as her trial approaches. No source or detail is given, consistent with the many unverified rumors circulating about her before the trial began.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 4 days later.

Wrong

The Bessemer Indicator · 27 May 1893 · page 2

Telegraphic Brevities. It U stated that Lizzie Borden'a mind U falling. Locust* are ravaging the province of Sara to.T. Russia. The Sit Companies still advise Chinese not to register. The Italian ministry Is likely to reslgu as a result of au adverse vote. The two months' drought In France has caused an enormous loss Is crops. Violent windstorms swept over the North west on the 22nd and did much damage. A congress of coal miners opened at Brus sels on the 22ud. Recent floods have devastated large districts In Routnauia. NY hole villages have been sub merged.

See moreSee less

The National Editorial Association elected Walter Williams of Columbia, Missouri, aa president. James Cordon Bennett says that he Intends | to lake ali his employes on the JleraUl Into partnership. The Infanta Kulalle made a ceremonious I call on the I'rrtldcnt, Saturday, and It was j returned by Mrs. Cleveland. Tho congress <>f newspaper men met at j Chicago on the 22nd. Delegates were present ! front a.l parts of America uud Europe. Secretary Gresham says that there Is no danger of the Chinese government retaliating on the United States for the tieary law. The Starr gang tried to hold tip a Santa Fc I

See the clipping

Paper unidentified

A news digest item states that Chief Justice Mason and Judges Blodgett and Dewey will preside over Lizzie Borden's trial at New Bedford next month. The item appears among a roundup of unrelated national news briefs.

Paper unidentified · 27 May 1893 · page 4

Justice Mason and Judges Blodgett and Dewey are to preside at the trial of Lizzie Borden at New Bedford next month. Harry Holcomb and Alfred Holt, young men of New Haven, were drowned in the har bor, Monday. Their companion Clarence Webb was rescued. The National Bank of Deposit has closed its doors. This is the first New York City bank to suspend on account of the tight money markets. The Standard Oil Company has bought the Tide Water Company of New York, its great est competitor, for $7,000,000. The Domestic Sewing Machine Company of New York has been attached by the Astor

See the clipping

The Washington Bee · Washington, D.C.

The report states that Massachusetts Attorney General Pillsbury's poor health has forced him to send a substitute to conduct the prosecution in the Lizzie Borden case. This brief note appears among a list of miscellaneous national and international news items.

The Washington Bee · 27 May 1893 · page 5

York, representing $7,000,000, has been swallowed up by the Standard Oil Com pany. Ill health compels Attorney General Pillsbury, of Massachusetts, to send a substitute to conduct the Lizzie Borden prosecution. It is reported at Stanley Falls that Emin Pasha, the noted African explorer, was killed by an Arab chief, Said Bin Abed, near TJnyoro. The Queen of England, who was 74 years old last week, is still stout and healthy, aud gives promise of reigning yet for years.

See the clipping

Narragansett Herald · Narragansett Pier, R.I.

A brief news item reports that Chief Justice Mason and Judges Blodgett and Dewey have been definitely chosen to preside over Lizzie Borden's trial. The trial is set to take place at New Bedford the following month.

Narragansett Herald · 27 May 1893 · page 8

National Bank the other day, and has re ported that it is sound, and will not be zffect ed by the failure of the Vermont Investment and Guarantee Company. The farm buildings of Wilbur F. Brann in the suburbs of Bangor were destroyed by fire. together with six cows,a horse and other farm stock. Loss, 82500; insured for £l5OO. The origin of the fire is unknown. A yvoung !lad named King was badly in jured in his hand and hip by the explosion of a cartridze between two stones, a few days ago at Gorham.

See moreSee less

It has been definitely decided that Chief Justice Mason and Judges Blodgett and Dewey are to preside at the trial of Lizzie Borden at New Bedford next month. Alfred Marceau of Springfield, whose wife attempted to elope with a nezgroa few days since, has been granted the custody of his two children. Chief of Police Voilmer of South Norwalk, Ct., is undergoing treatment at the Pasteur Institute, New York, for a wildeat bite re ceived recently. Henry Glysman,while attempting to board a train at the union station, Springfield. was struck by another train and badly cut about the head. The Hon. E. J. Ormsbee of Brandon, Vt., has been appointed receiver of the Vermont

See the clipping

The Portland Daily Press · Portland, Me.

The Portland Press runs an editorial noting reports that Attorney General Pillsbury doubts Lizzie Borden's guilt, in contrast to District Attorney Knowlton's confidence in her guilt. The piece speculates that such disagreement between the two prosecutors bodes poorly for securing a unanimous jury verdict.

The Portland Daily Press · 31 May 1893 · page 4

WEDNESDAY, MAY 81.. Dr. Graves escapes not because his in nocence has been established, but simply because the State of Colorado refuses to spend the money necessary to establish his guilt. Ex-Consul A. E. Webb who professes to be a convert to Mohammedanism, is going to try and start an emigration from India to this country. The flood of emi gration to this country is quite big enough now.' There Is no {occasion for anybody’s trying to increase it. Mr. Webb can spend his time and talent more profitably and more agreeably to the people of this country.

See moreSee less

The Boston Advertiser hints strongly that ill health is not the only reason why Attorney General Pillsbury does not appear in the Borden case. It declares without any reservation that since the preliminary hearing Mr,-’ Pillsbury has not hkd any great confidence in Lizzie Borden’s . guilt. District Attorney

See the clipping

In the story →

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

The report describes the murder of Bertha Manchester, a milkman's daughter, found hacked to death in her home while her father and brother were away. It draws a parallel to the still-unresolved Borden case, suggesting that prosecutorial delays may embolden criminals.

The Providence News · 31 May 1893 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image

FALL RIVER'S LATEST CRIME.

The law's delay in the Borden case seems to have been provocative to some extent at least of another brutal murder. Yesterday afternoon while the district attorney was in consultation over details in the prosecution of Lizzie Borden, the news came to him that another crime was awaiting his attention. The crime of yesterday was the murder of Miss Bertha Manchester, daughter of a milkman living on a lonely road in the suburbs of Fall River. The girl had been left alone in the house while her father and brother were attending to the duties of their occupation. On their return she was found lying murdered upon the floor. Curiously enough, a hatchet, as in the Borden case, was used to commit the crime.

See moreSee less

At the present writing no clue seems to have been left behind by the murderer, and if the same loose methods of police examination are employed that characterized the Borden case the affair will remain shrouded in mystery.

The long delay in the Borden case in bringing the perpetrator of that crime to punishment has had its effect by leading to the supposition that criminals in that county, more than elsewhere in the state, have better chances for doing their evil work in safety.

The law to be effective as a preventive to crime must be enforced promptly. Punishment must follow crime or the fear of would-be criminals of its terrors is so far lessened as to become nil.

Within a fortnight a report has come from Fall River that efforts are being made to induce the nol prossing of cases against a man who fourteen years ago embezzled a large amount from one of the mills there, on the ground that he has spent years in "exile" in Canada and is now an old man. His guilt is admitted, his crime was a most serious one, for he was a man who stood high in the community, whose social connections were of the best, and who, because of his high standing was all the more trusted.

Under such circumstances, is it any wonder that a general belief exists that under certain conditions the laws may be violated with impunity? There is something lacking in the administration of justice in Fall River, and to an unprejudiced person that something appears to be either competency or a willingness to enforce the laws.

It may be a matter only of coincidence that such circumstances exist in Fall River, but if so the coincidence is most unfortunate for Fall River.

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

A newspaper digest of opinions from other papers includes a note from the Attleboro Sun sympathizing with Lizzie Borden's declining health, blaming the state for not trying her sooner. The rest of the column covers unrelated political and social commentary.

CorrectionThis set right an article from 4 days earlier.

The Providence News · 31 May 1893 · page 4

WHAT OTHERS ARE SAYING.

Chinamen continue to carry a stiff upper g‘p. They are a starchy lot.—[Fall River ews, It is a lamentable fact that there are 86,000 more saloons than there are sehools in the United States. Such a keeping of the law of supply and demand is to be re gretted. —|Haverhill Bulletin, It is no wonder that Lizzie Borden's

See the clipping