As the Papers Told It

Lizzie Borden · The full archive

August 1892, part 1

250 articles

Waterbury Evening Democrat · Waterbury, Conn.

A day after the murders, Fall River police report no clue to the killer or weapon in the deaths of Andrew Borden and his wife. A Portuguese farmhand was investigated but cleared, while suspicion is shifting toward a brother-in-law.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

Waterbury Evening Democrat · 5 August 1892 · page 1

Fall River, Mass., Aug. 5. There is absolutely no clue to the murderer or murderers of Andrew J.Borden and his wife, who were found dead In their home on Second street yesterday, both fright fully mutilated about the head and face. No implements that could have been used in the commission of the crime have been found. Mr. Borden lay on a sofa in a room on the top floor of the house. His head had been cut, and gashes from four to six inches long were found on his face and neck.

See moreSee less

Mrs Borden was in her own chamber on the upper floor, and tha condition of her face and head was the same as that of her husband. She lay face down in the bed, which was a veritable pool of blood. The police were notified, and immediately an investigation was begun. The daughter of the unfortunate couple was the first to make the discovery. She went up stairs after finding the body of her father, and saw that of her mother. She thought her mother had fallen in a swoon, but finding that she, too, was murdered, the girl fled down stairs and fainted. The police have searched in vain for any clue to the murderer. They spent yebter day afternoon searching for a Portuguese who runs the Borden farm at Gardiner's Neck, and who, it was said, was in the house at 10:45 a. m., a few minutes be fore the bodies were discovered. To-day the police say there is nothing lnthe Portuguese story. It is reported that word was sent to Mrs. Borden in the morning that a sick friend desired to see her, but she did not go out. It is said that the servant, Brid get Sullivan, says she went into the room to make some inquiry of Mr. Borden five minutes before Lizzie Borden gave the alarm. He was then sitting on the sofa reading a newspaper. Mr. Borden was a wealthy real estate owner and mill man, and was seen on the street half an hour before he was found dead. Although the police have no clue, yet their suspicions rest upon persons who were in the family circle, particularly John M. Morse, brother-in-law of Mr. Borden by his first marriage; also on the daughter Lizzie, who first discovered the body of the father. John H. Morse is 55 years of age and came here from Hastings, la., two years ago. He became very in timate with Mr. Borden and the latter' s daughter, and spent a great portion of his time with them. He came from New Bed ford at noon Wednesday and spent the night at the Borden Homestead. He left there yesterday morning at 9 o'clock and was next seen on the premises about 20 minutes after the bodies were discovered. The police say the only motive for murder was gain, else one of the victims might have been spared. It has been decided to keep Morse under close surveillance until further develop ments. The murder has caused the great est sensation here since the Granite mill fire.

See the clipping

In the story →

Waterbury Evening Democrat · Waterbury, Conn.

The report describes the discovery of Andrew and Abby Borden's mutilated bodies and recounts conflicting details, including a dismissed rumor about a Portuguese farmhand and a mysterious 'sick friend' message. It names both John Morse, Borden's brother-in-law, and daughter Lizzie as under police suspicion.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

Waterbury Evening Democrat · 5 August 1892 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

THE BORDEN MURDER

No Clue to the Slayers of the Aged Couple.

See moreSee less

A BROTHER-IN-LAW SUSPECTED.

The Weapon With Which the Millionaire and His Wife Were Mutilated Cannot Be Found--Mr. Borden Was Seen Five Minutes Before the Crime.

FALL RIVER, Mass., Aug. 5.--There is absolutely no clue to the murderer or murderers of Andrew J. Borden and his wife, who were found dead in their home on Second street yesterday, both frightfully mutilated about the head and face.

No implements that could have been used in the commission of the crime have been found.

Mr. Borden lay on a sofa in a room on the top floor of the house. His head had been cut, and gashes from four to six inches long were found on his face and neck.

Mrs Borden was in her own chamber on the upper floor, and the condition of her face and head was the same as that of her husband. She lay face down in the bed, which was a veritable pool of blood. The police were notified, and immediately an investigation was begun.

The daughter of the unfortunate couple was the first to make the discovery. She went up stairs after finding the body of her father, and saw that of her mother. She thought her mother had fallen in a swoon, but finding that she, too, was murdered, the girl fled down stairs and fainted.

The police have searched in vain for any clue to the murderer. They spent yesterday afternoon searching for a Portuguese who runs the Borden farm at Gardiner's Neck, and who, it was said, was in the house at 10:45 a. m., a few minutes before the bodies were discovered.

To-day the police say there is nothing in the Portuguese story.

It is reported that word was sent to Mrs. Borden in the morning that a sick friend desired to see her, but she did not go out. It is said that the servant, Bridget Sullivan, says she went into the room to make some inquiry of Mr. Borden five minutes before Lizzie Borden gave the alarm. He was then sitting on the sofa reading a newspaper.

Mr. Borden was a wealthy real estate owner and mill man, and was seen on the street half an hour before he was found dead.

Although the police have no clue, yet their suspicions rest upon persons who were in the family circle, particularly John M. Morse, brother-in-law of Mr. Borden by his first marriage; also on the daughter Lizzie, who first discovered the body of the father. John M. Morse is 55 years of age and came here from Hastings, Ia., two years ago. He became very intimate with Mr. Borden and the latter's daughter, and spent a great portion of his time with them. He came from New Bedford at noon Wednesday and spent the night at the Borden Homestead. He left there yesterday morning at 9 o'clock and was next seen on the premises about 20 minutes after the bodies were discovered.

The police say the only motive for murder was gain, else one of the victims might have been spared.

It has been decided to keep Morse under close surveillance until further developments. The murder has caused the greatest sensation here since the Granite mill fire.

See the clipping

In the story →

Evening Journal · Wilmington, Del.

This earliest dispatch from Fall River describes Andrew and Abby Borden found brutally hacked to death with an axe in their home, discovered by their daughter and a servant. It speculates the killer hid in the house, attacking Mrs. Borden upstairs before killing Mr. Borden downstairs, and notes robbery was not the motive since nothing was missing.

Evening Journal · 5 August 1892 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

HUSBAND AND WIFE BUTCHERED.

Hacked to Death with an Ax by Some Unknown Assassin.

See moreSee less

Fall River, Mass., Aug. 5--Andrew J. Borden and wife, two of the oldest, wealthiest and most highly respected persons in the city, were brutally murdered with an ax in broad daylight in their home on Second street, within a few minutes' walk of the city hall and the central business section. The Borden family consisted of the father, mother, two daughters and a servant. The older daughter has been in Fairhaven, Conn., for some days. The rest of the family have been ill for three or four days, and Dr. Bowen, the attending physician, was suspecting an attempt at poisoning.

About 8 o'clock in the morning Mrs. Borden received a note asking her to go and visit a friend who was ill. She left the house and shortly afterward her husband walked to one of the banks. He returned about 10:30 o'clock and sat on the sofa. The servant, Bridget Sullivan, then went outside the house to wash windows. In the meantime Miss Lizzie Borden, a daughter, arose from bed and walked down stairs, seeing and speaking to her father as she passed through the room. She supposed her mother was out. She went into the yard and stepped into the barn.

While there, she heard a cry of distress coming apparently from the house and she ran in. She went directly to a sitting room leading from the main hallway in the house, and there saw her father lying back on a sofa covered with blood and lifeless.

She ran out again shrieking and her cries attracted the servant and a neighbor. They made a hasty search for the mother and found her up stairs in a spare bedroom lying dead, face downward, on the floor. Medical Examiner Dolan was summoned, and he found Mr. Borden's head hacked to pieces in a horrible manner, no less than seven long gashes being on his face and skull, some of them an inch and a half deep through flesh and bone. Mrs. Borden, too, had been frightfully butchered about the face and skull. It is supposed that the murderer was concealed about the house when Mr. Borden came in and went up stairs with the intention of murdering him. Before he could accomplish his purpose Mrs. Borden's attention was attracted.

The murderer probably followed her into a spare room and struck her from behind. After being sure of his work the murderer probably went down stairs, where Mr. Borden had fallen asleep on the sofa and there dealt him the awful blows that ended his life. Robbery was not the motive of the crime, as no valuables nor money was missing. Two or three suspects were arrested, but none of them is believed to know anything of the crime.

See the clipping

Evening Journal · Wilmington, Del.

The report describes Mr. Borden being bludgeoned while asleep on the sofa, with robbery ruled out as a motive and several suspects arrested but not believed guilty. It also claims Mrs. Borden left home that morning after receiving a note asking her to visit a sick friend, before her husband returned and was killed.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

Evening Journal · 5 August 1892 · page 2

'' '" n " Rnm «faulting andher cries U , a ' tL ' d tlle eeivuntand a. neighbor. They made a hasty search tor the mother and fonnd her up stairs in a mare bedroom , , "> »tans in a spare oearoom lying dead, race downward, on the floor. Medical Examiner Dolan was summoned, and he found Mr. Borden's heart hacked to pieces in a horrible manner, no less than leveu long gashes being on his face and skull, some of them an inch and « half deep 'through flesh ami bone.

See moreSee less

Mrs. Borden, too, uau boon frightfully butchered about tho ttl, d skull. It is supposed that tho murderer was concealed about the house when Mi. Beiden came in and went up bull's with the intention of murdering him. Before ho could accomplish his purpose Mrs. Bur* .en s attention was attracted. Ibe murderer probably followed her into 5 spare room and struck her from behind. After being sure of nis work the murderer probably went down stairs, where Mr, Bor

See the clipping

Daily Kennebec Journal · Augusta, Me.

A wire report from Fall River describes Andrew and Abby Borden found brutally murdered with an axe in their home, with no trace of the killer or weapon. It recounts daughter Lizzie's movements that morning and her discovery of her father's body, while assuming her mother was simply out of the house.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

Daily Kennebec Journal · 5 August 1892 · page 1

FOUL MURDER.

— Km Kiwi:. Mass.. August 4.—Andrew I .1. Borden and wife, two of the oldest, j wealthiest and most highly respected per- : sonin this city, were brutally murdered j with an axe at II o’clock this morning, at their home on Second street, within a min utes walk of City hail ami the central business section. Tlic circumstances arc most surprising, as no trace of the murderer or weapon can fa1 found. The Borden family consisted of father, mother, two daughters and a ser vant. The older daughter has been to Fairhaven, but has been sick sonic days, j l»r.

See moreSee less

Bowen, the attending physician, was, suspecting an attempt at poisoning. \bout s tins morning Mrs. Borden re- ] reived a note to visit a friend who was ill. , She left the house and shortly afterwards J her husband followed and walked down the j street to one of the banks. He returned j about 10.dO ami sat on the sofa. In answer to a question from the servant • he said he w as feeding very well. The ! servant. Bridget Sullivan, then went outside the house to wash the windows. In the meantime. Miss Lizzie Borden, the daughter, rose from her bed and walked down the -lairs, seeing and speaking to her father as -he passed through the room. She supposed 1 her mother was out. She went into the yard, stepped into the ' barn. While there she heard a cry of dis tress, coming apparently from the house, and she ran in. She went directly to the : sitting room leading from the main hallway j in the house, and there she saw her father ! lying hack on the sofa, covered with blood j and lifeless. She ran out. shrieking am! her cries at tracted the servant and neighbor. They j made a hasty search for her mother, and [ found her up stairs in a spare bedroom. \ Iving dead, fare dow nw ard on the floor. Tlu» women summoned Dr Bowen, who ! lives opposite, who found both victims lie- ! vond medical aid. officer Allen arrived |

See the clipping

Daily Kennebec Journal · Augusta, Me.

This report describes the discovery of Andrew and Abby Borden's bodies by Lizzie and a servant, detailing the gruesome wounds found by the medical examiner. It also offers speculative theories about an unknown intruder who allegedly killed Mrs. Borden first, then Mr. Borden, ruling out robbery as a motive.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

Daily Kennebec Journal · 5 August 1892 · page 1

FOUL MURDER.

Park. Roxbury. July 30, by striking him on Kickapoo Indian Oil the head with a hammer. Holland died yesterday from the injuries. kills pain instantly. 15 cents. toea-t lives opposite, who found both victims lie- ! vond medical aid. officer Allen arrived | early. but became so excited that he ran at i once with an incoherent story to the police I station. The policemen’s excursion occurred toj day, ami half the force was at Kocky Point w hen the murders occurred. A small posse of police surrounded the house ami in a ■ short time were busy keeping back the host; of business men and curiosity seekers w ho j thronged the street, attracted by the j tragedy.

See moreSee less

Medical Kxaminer Bulan was on the scene within a half hour. He found Mr. | Borden's head hacked to pieces in a terrible j manner, seven long gashes on the face and -kull, some an inch and a half deep through j the Hesh and bone. When Mrs. Borden was first seen, her ' daughter and others supfKised that she died from heart disease, to which -lie had been subject. The reporter tir-t noticed blood in her hair, and when the bed near w hich | -he was lying had been drawn away, it was seen that she hail been frightfully battered about the face and skull. All sorts of theories concerning the mur der are current. Those most generally ac cepted arc it is supposed the murderer was concealed about the house when Mr Borden came in and no one saw him enter. An soon ait became quiet he is thought to have gone up stairs with the intention of murdering Mr. Borden. Before he could accomplish hi* purpose, Mrs. Borden’s at trillion was probably attracted. In view of the fact that Mrs. Borden made no outcry, it is thought she mu-t have lieen killed first ( and instantly. The murderer probably followed tier into the spare room and struck her from In-hind. . I'.vcrv thing was in perfect order in the room and it gives rise to the belief that -lie «anot aware she was being followed. \fter being-lire of his work the murder* r probably went down stairs where Mr. Bor den had fallen asleep on the sofa and there I* alt him the awful blows that ended his life. Bobbery was not the motive of the crime. .1no valuableor money are missing. There arc no blood stainon the fnrniture covering or Hoots, and these facts show how quietly the work was done. Two or three suspects were arrested this afternoon hut none are believed to know anything of the crime. Andrew J. Borden was horn in this city j in IHe was in the furniture business :t:t years with William A lmy. under the 1 firm name of Borden & A lmy. and accumu lated a large amount of real estate, valued at lie owned two farms in Swansea, and at first it was thought that a disappointed farm hand was the murderer. I.ater the opinion has gained ground that a tenant, who was ill-appointed ami had a quarrel with Mr Borden, was the assailant. Mr. Borden was president of the I nion Saving hank, director of the B. M. Pur fee Safe Deposit and Trust Company, director of the Troy and Merchants mill and director of the (ilobe Street Railway Company. He was twice married, his second wife being Miss Abbie P. Cray. Mrs. Borden was years old. Medical Kxamincr Dolan held an autopsy this afternoon, on the 1kmlies of the victims. The stomachs of both will In* sent to Bos ton for analysis, with the view of determin ing whether milk poisoning was attempted. At this hour police suspicions rest on two persons in the family circle, particularly John W. Morse, brother-in-law of Mr. Bor den by his first marriage, and also on the daughter Lizzie, who first discovered the body of her father. John W. Morse is .*»."* years of age, and came here from Hastings. Iowa, two year ago. He lM-eame very intimate with Mr. Borden and the latter’s daughter, and spent a great portion of his time with them. He came from New Bedford at noon yes terday and spent the night at the Borden homestead. He left there this morning at :> o’clock and was not seen about the prem ises till about minutes after the bodies were discovered. After most careful searching it was de rided that neither of the victims engaged in any struggle both being struck down in stantly ami hacked to pieces afterward. The j*o I ice -ay the only motive for the mur der was gain, else one of the victims would have been spared.

See the clipping

Daily Kennebec Journal · Augusta, Me.

This report speculates that an unknown assailant hid in the house, killed Mrs. Borden first then Mr. Borden, with robbery ruled out since nothing was missing. It also notes suspicion falling on John Morse and daughter Lizzie, plus theories about a disgruntled farm hand or tenant.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

Daily Kennebec Journal · 5 August 1892 · page 1

The words of this article are printed with the report it shares its clipping with. Read them there or in the clipping.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

The Portland Daily Press · Portland, Me.

The article reports that Andrew J. Borden and his wife were brutally murdered with an axe at their Second Street home, with suspicion falling on their daughter and a male relative. It describes the morning's events, including a note supposedly summoning Mrs. Borden away and Lizzie Borden's movements before discovering the crime.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

The Portland Daily Press · 5 August 1892 · page 1

MURDER AND MYSTERY.

Fall River, Mass., August 4.—A. J. Borden and wife, two of the oldest, wealthiest and most highly respected persons in this city were brutally mur dered with an axe at 11 o’clock this morning at their home on Second street within a few minutes walk of the City Hall and central business section. The circumstances are most surprising and shocking. No trace of the murderer or the weapon can be found. The Borden family consisted of father, mother, two daughters and a servant. The | older daughter has been at Fairhaven for some days.

See moreSee less

Dr. Bowen, the attending phys ician, was suspecting an attempt at pois oning. About 8 this morning, Mrs. Bor den received a note asking her to visit a friend who was ill. She left the house and afterwards her husband followed and walked down the street to one of the banks. He returned at about 10.30 and sat on *the sofa. In answer to a question from the servant he said he was feeling very well. The ser vant, Bridget Sullivan, then went out Siut3 Lilts ilOUStS LU WOiSil LUO W1UUUWO, All the meantime, Miss Lizzie Borden, the daughter, rose from her bed and walked down stairs, seeing and speaking to her father as she passed through the room. She supposed her mother was out. She went into the yard and stepped into the barn. While there, she says, she Heard a Cry of Distress coming apparently from the house. She ran in. She went directly to the sitting room, leading from the main hallway in the house. There she saw her father lying back on the sofa covered with blood and lifeless. She ran out shriek ing and her cries attracted the servant and a neighbor. They made a hasty search for her mother and found her up stairs in the spare bedroom lying dead, face downward on the floor. The women summoned Dr. Bowen, who lives opposite. He found both victims beyond medical aid. Officer -Allen arrived early but became so excited that he ran at once with an incoherent story to the po lice station. The policemen’s excursion occurred today and half the force was at Rocky Point when the murders occurred. A small posse of police surrounded the house in a short time and were busy keeping back the host of business men and curiosity seekers who thronged Sec ond street, attracted by the tragedy. Medical Examiner Dolan was on the scene within half an hour. He found Mr. Bordfen’s head hacked to pieces in a horrible manner. Seven long gashes were on the face and skull, some an inch and a half deep through flesh and bone. When Mrs. Borden was first seen, her daughter and others supposed she died from heart disease, to which she has been subject. A reporter first noticed blood in her hair and, when the bed near which she was lying had been drawn away, it was seen that she had been Frightfully Battered About the Face. All sorts of theories concerning the murder are current. It is supposed by some that the murderer was concealed about the house when Mr. Borden came n and no one saw him enter. In view of the fact that Mrs. Borden made no outcry, it is thought she must have been killed first and instantly. The murderer propably followed her into the spare room and struck her from behind. Everything was in perfect order in the _... l +■ mirnn idon +-/V tUo lmUdf fVlof she was not aware that she was being followed. After being sure of his work the murderer probably went down stairs where Mr. Borden had fallen asleep on the sofa and dealt him an awful blow that ended his life. Robbery was not the motive of the crime as no valuables or money are missing. There are no blood stains on the furniture covering or floors and these facts show how quietly the work was done. Two or three suspeots were arrested this afternoon but none are believed to know anything of the crime. It was at first thought that a farm hand was the murderer. Later the opinion gained ground that a disappointed tenant was the assailant. Medical Examiner Dolan held an au topsy this afternoon on the bodies of the victims. The stomachs of both will be sent to Boston for analysis to see if milk poisoning had been attempted. At this hour, suspicions rest on Persons in the Family Circle, particularly John Morse, a brother-in law of Borden by his first marriage and also on the daughter, Lizzie, who first discovered the body of her father. John Morse is 55 years of age and came here from Hastings, Iowa, two years ago. He became very intimate with Mr. Borden and the latter’s daughter and spent a great portion of his time with them. He came from New Bedford at noon yester day and spent the night at the Borden homestead. He left there this morning at 9 o’clock. He was next seen on the premises about 20 minntes after the bodies were discovered. The familv have not felt well for sev eral days and suspected that their food was tampered with. Andrew J. Borden was born in this city in 1822 and was in the furniture business thirty-three years with William Almy. lie accumulated a large amount of real estate, valued at §050,000 and owned two farms in Swansea. He was president of the Union savings bank, director of B. M. C. Durfee Safe Deposit and Trust Company, director in the Troy and Merchants’ mills, and director of the Globe Street Railway Company. He was

See the clipping

The Portland Daily Press · Portland, Me.

This early report describes the discovery of Andrew and Abby Borden's bodies, the arrival of police and the medical examiner, and the brutal wounds found on both victims. It also recounts initial theories about an outside intruder, a farm hand, or a disappointed tenant as the killer, and mentions suspects arrested but not held.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

The Portland Daily Press · 5 August 1892 · page 1

The words of this article are printed with the report it shares its clipping with. Read them there or in the clipping.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

The Portland Daily Press · Portland, Me.

The report speculates on how the murderer attacked Andrew and Abby Borden, claims robbery was not the motive, and notes suspicion falling on John Morse and Lizzie Borden. It also details Andrew Borden's wealth and business background, and mentions an autopsy being performed with stomach contents sent for poison analysis.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

The Portland Daily Press · 5 August 1892 · page 1

The words of this article are printed with the report it shares its clipping with. Read them there or in the clipping.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

The Evening World · New York, N.Y.

Police reportedly obtained a key clue when a drug store clerk said Lizzie Borden had tried to buy poison shortly before the killings. He was brought to identify her at her lodgings, and the story notes a second family member is also suspected.

The Evening World · 5 August 1892 · page 1

POLICE HAVE A CLUE.

(ht iiioeurrn raria.1 Kill, UltIK, Aug. 0 Thi) Ktntng Glolr will say this ivuilii iliutammt Important clue to the Bortlen double murder Is In pes sesBlnn of the police. Irora Clerk );il Uence, at Ik Ik Smith's dn.tr store, they learned last night that Miss Mario Borden had been in the storp within thirty, six houis past aud had Inquired Kir a certnln poison. Iho clerk was asked to accompany tho om ccrs, and was closclv quest lonod as to Ike time, tha girl's condition mentiill), the amount nnd quality of tho poison Mio had called for.

See moreSee less

'iho ofllirrR then look tho drug clerk to a residence on Second street w hero Mls Llzrlo was stopplne tor iho time btlntr. He did Identify her nnd In her pn senco Informed tho officers that she wns In his plaeo ot business and mndc Inquiry foi a bottle of poison Miss Borden's toply to thU arrusntlDii is known only to the two policemen und busclf

See the clipping

In the story →

The Evening World · New York, N.Y.

An autopsy reveals extensive wounds to both victims' skulls, and their stomachs are sent to Boston to test for poisoning. Police suspicion centers on family members John Morse and daughter Lizzie, with Morse placed under surveillance due to his presence near the time of the murders.

The Evening World · 5 August 1892 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

TWO SUSPECTS IN THE FAMILY

POLICE HAVE A CLUE.

Fall River Double Murder Mystery May Be Solved.

See moreSee less

Drug Clerk Says Lizzie Borden Asked Him for Poison.

She's the Murdered Couple's D[au]ghter—Another Family Suspect.

[BY ASSOCIATED PRESS.] FALL RIVER, Aug. 5.—The Evening Globe will say this evening that a most important clue to the Borden double murder is in possession of the police.

From Clerk Eli Bence, at D. R. Smith's drug store, they learned last night that Miss Lizzie Borden had been in the store within thirty-six hours past and had inquired for a certain poison.

The clerk was asked to accompany the officers, and was closely questioned as to the time, the girl's condition mentally, the amount and quality of the poison she had called for.

The officers then took the drug clerk to a residence on Second street where Miss Lizzie was stopping for the time being. He did identify her and in her presence informed the officers that she was in his place of business and made inquiry for a bottle of poison.

Miss Borden's reply to this accusation is known only to the two policemen and herself.

TWO SUSPECTS IN THE FAMILY.

[BY ASSOCIATED PRESS.] FALL RIVER, Mass., Aug. 5.—The double murder of yesterday, in which Millionaire Andrew J. Borden and his wife were the victims has caused the greatest sensation known here since the Granite Mill fire. Far into last night great throngs of people surrounded the family residence.

Medical Examiner Dolan, assisted by other physicians, held an autopsy on the bodies of the victims of the tragedy. It was found that Borden sustained twelve cuts in the face and skull, varying in length from 4 to 8 inches, also suffered a fracture of the skull two by four inches and three inches deep. His wife's head and face were battered all out of shape.

The stomachs of both victims were removed and placed in alcohol to be sent to Boston to-day for analysis, with a view of determining whether or not milk poisoning was attempted.

Police suspicions rest upon persons who were in the family circle, particularly on John W. Morse, brother-in-law of Mr. Borden by his first marriage; also on the daughter Lizzie, who first discovered the body of the father.

John W. Morse is fifty-five years of age, and came here from Hastings, Ia., two years ago. He became very intimate with Mr. Borden and the latter's daughter, and spent a great portion of his time with them.

He came from New Bedford at noon Wednesday and spent the night at the Borden homestead. He left there yesterday morning at 9 o'clock and was next seen on the premises about twenty minutes after the bodies were discovered.

After the most careful searching it has been decided that neither of the victims engaged in a struggle, both being struck down instantly and hacked to pieces afterwards.

The police say the only motive for murder was gain to be eventually secured through the death of both parties. And the fact that so little ado was made by those who were most directly interested and so little attempt was made at first to discover the possible murderer is strengthening the police in the opinions they now hold.

At one time the police threatened to place Morse in custody, but it was decided to keep him under close surveillance until further developments.

Four policemen are on guard at the house to-day, and only a few very near relatives are allowed to enter. Those who went were a Mr. Morse, of New Bedford, a cousin of the suspected man, and another close friend, who gave his name as Fish.

These men can give no reason why Morse should be under suspicion other than the fact that he happened to be in this neighborhood at this time. He would not benefit by the death of either of the parties unless a will was made, which at this writing cannot be told.

Emma, the daughter who was visiting in the vicinity of New Bedford when the murder took place, is at home to-day and has charge of the house. Her sister Lizzie is not in a much better state than she was yesterday when she discovered her father dead.

NEW BEDFORD, Mass., Aug. 5.—John N. Morse, who is suspected of knowing something about the double murder at Fall River, made his home with Isaac C. Davis, at South Dartmouth. He belongs in Hastings, Ia., and has lived in Mr. Davis's family for about a year.

Members of the Davis family say Morse left South Dartmouth Thursday for Fall River for the purpose of purchasing cattle for Mr. Davis. He was expected home last night. They give him an excellent name, and do not believe that he is in any way connected with the affair.

See the clipping

The Evening Herald · Shenandoah, Pa.

Fall River police report finding no clue or weapon in the brutal slaying of Andrew Borden and his wife, both found mutilated in their home. A Portuguese farmhand was briefly suspected but cleared, while servant Bridget Sullivan's account of the morning is noted.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

The Evening Herald · 5 August 1892 · page 3

Fali, Riveh, Mass., Aug. 6. There is absolutely no clue to the murderer or murderers of Andrew u. Borden and his wife, who were found dead in their home on Second street yesterday, both fright fully mutilated about tho head aud face. No implements that could have beea used in the oommissiou ot the crime hare been found. Mr. Borden lay on a sofa in a room On the top floor of the house. His head had been cut, and gashes from four to six inches long were found on his face and neck.

See moreSee less

Mrs Borden was In her own chamberon the upper floor, and tho condition of her faco and head was the sameas that ot her husband. She lay faco down in the bed, which was a veritable pool of blood. Tho police wero notified, and immediately an Investigation wns begun. The daughter of the uufortunnto couple was tho ilrst to make the discovery. She went up stalls after finding tho body of her father, and saw that of her mother. She thought her mother had fallen in a swoon, but finding that she, too, was murdered, tho, girl fled down stairs und fainted. The police havo searched in vain for any clue to tho murderer. Thoy spent yebter day afternoon searching for a Portuguesu who runs tho Borden farm at Gardiner's Neck, aHd who, it was said, was in tho house at 10:45 a. m., a few minutes be fore the bodies werediscoveroil. To-day tho police say there is nothing in the Portuguese story. It is reported that word, was sent to Mrs. Borden in the morning that a sick friend desired to see her, but she did not go. out. It is said that the servant, Brid get Sullivan, says she went Into tho room to mako some inquiry of Mr. Borden live minutes beforo Lizzie Borden gavo the alarm. He was then sitting on the sofa, rending a newspaper. Mr. Bord.s i was a wealthy real estate owner a. .1 in '.' ,nui, and was seen on the street half au aour beforo ho was found dead. .Although the pollco have no clue, yet their suspicions rest upon persons who wero in the family circle, particularly John M. Morse, brother-in-law of Mr. Borden by his first marriage; also on tho daughter Lizzie, who first discovered the body ot the father. John M. Morse is 55 years of age and came herefrom Hastings, In., two years ago. Ho became very in timate with Mr. Borden and the hitter's daughter, and spent a great portion ot his time with them. He camo from New Bod ford at noon Wednesday and spent the night at the Borden Homestead. He left thero yesterday morning at 0 o'clook and was next seen on the premises about 20 minutes after the bodies Were discovered. Tiie police say the only motive for murder wits gain, else one of tho victims might have been spared. It has been decided to keep Morse under closo surveillance until further develop ments. The murder has caused the great est sensation here since the Qranlto mill fire.

See the clipping

The Evening Herald · Shenandoah, Pa.

The report describes the police investigation into the Borden murders, noting suspicion falls on John M. Morse, Mr. Borden's brother-in-law, and on daughter Lizzie, who discovered the body. It details Morse's movements, the servant Bridget Sullivan's account, and police surveillance of Morse pending further developments.

The Evening Herald · 5 August 1892 · page 3

wero in the family circle, particularly John M. Morse, brother-in-law of Mr. Borden by his first marriage; also on tho daughter Lizzie, who first discovered the body ot the father. John M. Morse is 55 years of age and came herefrom Hastings, In., two years ago. Ho became very in timate with Mr. Borden and the hitter's daughter, and spent a great portion ot his time with them. He camo from New Bod ford at noon Wednesday and spent the night at the Borden Homestead. He left thero yesterday morning at 0 o'clook and was next seen on the premises about 20 minutes after the bodies Were discovered.

See moreSee less

Tiie police say the only motive for murder wits gain, else one of tho victims might have been spared. It has been decided to keep Morse under closo surveillance until further develop ments. The murder has caused the great est sensation here since the Qranlto mill fire.

See the clipping

Pittsburg Dispatch · Pittsburg, Pa.

Andrew J. Borden and his wife were found brutally mutilated about the head and face with an ax, cleaver, or razor at their Fall River home. The report notes no weapon was found, that Borden had been seen in town shortly before his death, and that servant Bridget Sullivan had spoken with him minutes before Lizzie Borden raised the alarm.

Pittsburg Dispatch · 5 August 1892 · page 10

AN UNACCOUNTABLE TRAGEDY.

A Wealthy Con pie Murdered In Broad Day light In a Busy Ctty. Fall Biveb, Mass., Aug. 4. Andrew J. Borden and his wife were found dead at their home at 11 o'clock this morning. Both had been frightfully mutilated about the head and face with an ax, cleaver or razor. Mr. Borden lay on a sofa in a room on the lower floor of the house. His head had been cut and gashes from five to six inches long were found on his face and neck. Mrs.

See the clipping

Morning Journal and Courier · New Haven, Conn.

The report claims investigators have verified that Lizzie Borden attempted to purchase prussic acid before the murders, fueling suspicion against her. It describes her strange, detached demeanor and family tensions, and predicts an imminent arrest.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

Morning Journal and Courier · 6 August 1892 · page 3

Under Police Surveillance Poison Was Asked for at a Drug Store. Fall River, Mass., Aug. 5. To-night the mystery snrronnding the Borden mur ders csme very olose to a solution. Unless all signs fail there will be arrests to-mor row, if not earlier. The story of the at tempt of Miss Lizzie Borden to pnrobase

See the clipping

Waterbury Evening Democrat · Waterbury, Conn.

Police reveal a clue: drug clerk Eli Bence identified Lizzie Borden as the woman who recently inquired about buying a certain poison at his store. He was taken to confront her directly, and her response was not disclosed to the press.

Waterbury Evening Democrat · 6 August 1892 · page 2

FALL RIVER'S MYSTERY. ONE OF THE GIRLS BOUGHT POISON.

Remains at Fever Heat. Fall River, Mass., Aug. 6. It ia stated that an important clue to the mur derer of Andrew J. Borden and his wife is in the hands of the police. From Clerk Eli Bence, at P. R. Smith's drug store, they learned that Miss Lizzie Borden had been in the store within 36 hours past, and had inquired for a cer tain poison. The clerk was asked to ac company the officers, and they closely questioned him as to the time of the girl's call, her condition mentally and the amount and quality of the poison she had bouKht and called for.

See moreSee less

I he police then took the drug clerk to a house on Second street, where Miss Lizzie Borden was stopping for the time being. The clerk was not previously well ac quainted with the young woman, but he had told them that he could identify her at sight. He did identity her, and in the presence of the police informed them that Bhe was in his place of business and made inquiry for a bottle of poison. Miss Borden's reply to this accusation, as well as the exact langauge which was used at the time, is known only to the police. Suspicion fixed itself after the murder on members of the family who were in or about the house at the time when the tragedy took place, and the authorities placed a watch on Borden's daughter Liz zie, who gave the alarm, and John W.

See the clipping

The Record-Union · Sacramento, Calif.

Days after the murders, no definite trace of the killer has been found, and a $5,000 reward is offered for arrest and conviction. The report notes Borden's estate value and mentions Lizzie Borden was identified by a drug clerk regarding an inquiry about poison, though what happened between them is unclear.

The Record-Union · 6 August 1892 · page 1

Murder of Mr. and Mrs. Borden. Fai,l River (Mass.), Aug. s.—No posi tive trace has been found of tho murderer of Mr. and Mrs. Andrew J. Borden. Five thousand dollars reward is offered for the arrest ar.d conviction of the murderers. Borden's personal estato is estimated at between $175,000 and .5250.000. A Miss Lizzie Borden is said to have made in quiries at a drug store for a certain poison. This afternoon a drug clerk was taken before Miss Borden and he identified her. What transpired between them is not known.

See moreSee less

Hot Day In Kansas City* Kansas City, Aug. s.—This was the hottest day of the season. The ther mometer registered 78° at an early hour this morning. By noon it reached I)s°, and at 4 o'clock fc>°, all in the Govern ment signal station, on top of one of the highest buildings in the town. On the street the thermometers registered 102 Q to 104 in the shade. There were several prostrations, but no fatalities. There was a hot wind all day. There are grave fears for the safety of Kansas corn.

See the clipping

Evening Journal · Wilmington, Del.

Fall River police, unable to find outside clues, focus suspicion on the Borden household, effectively detaining Lizzie, her sister, Morse, and Bridget Sullivan. A drug clerk, Eli Bence, identifies Lizzie as the woman who inquired about buying poison shortly before the murders.

CorrectionThis set right 3 earlier articles: Daily Kennebec Journal, 5 August 1892, Daily Kennebec Journal, 5 August 1892, The Portland Daily Press, 5 August 1892.

Evening Journal · 6 August 1892 · page 5

THE HOUSEHOLD UNDER SUSPICION. Mil Borden'. Strange Action«, Coupled with the Fact That She Pnrchased Pul.on Shortly Itefore the Murder. Were Committed, Impress the Police. Fall Hiver, Mass,, Aug. 6.—The Borden murder mystery deepens and casts the shadow of suspicion on the surviving mem ber» of the household. The police were un able to find any clew outside the house and they turned their attention to the members of the family. They have made no arrests, but virtually have made prisoners of the two daughters of Mr. and Mrs. Borden, the nephew, John W.

See moreSee less

Morse, and the servant, Bridget bnUivau. A most important clew is in the posses sion of the police. From Clerk Eli Bence, at D. H. Smith's drug store, they learned that Miss Borden had been in the store within forty-eight hours past and bad in quired for a certain poison. The clerk was asked to accompany the o(deers, and they closely questioned him kb to the time of the girl's cull, her condition mentally, the amount and quality of the poison she bad bought or called for. The officers then took the drug clerk to a residence on Second street, where Mies 1 Lizzie Borden was stopping (or the time being. The clerk was not previously well ac quainted with the young woman, but he had told the officers that ho could identify her at sight. He did identify her, aud in the presence of the police officers informed them that she was in his place of business and made inquiry for a bottle of poison. Miss Bordeu's reply to this accusation, as well as the exact language hieb was used at the time, is known only U the police and herself. The demeanor of Miss Lizzie through the trying ordeal of being confronted with the man who says that she asked about poison was that of contempt and scorn. In fact her conduct, as observed by the police since the affair happened, has been strange, in asmuch as she stood the pointed question ing of all who interviewed her with the show of no other feeling than that of a dis interested party. It is generally known among the dose friends of the family that Lizzie has not been on the best of terr t with other mem bers of the household. I is alleged that for some time previous she did not sit at the table with the balance of the family, but that she bad her meals served at a separate table. The feeling of coolness between the mem bers of the family is not accounted (or by either the police or neighbors. The murder had hardly been discovered before she told the neighbors that she was very sorry, as she had arranged to go to Marion for a va cation. Làter it was learned that Miss Lizzie had inquired at a drug store for hy drocyanic aciil in a diluted form, saying that she wished to nse it for furs. Very Much a Mystery, The absence of any apparent motive for the crime has baffled the police in their in vestigation fully us much as the absence of clows in the immediate vicinity. They don't know which way to turn or where to look for evidence. It is certainly estab lished that the murderer did not attempt to leave the house until after the srlme was discovered. He must have been close st baud when Lizzie opened the sitting room door and saw her murdered father. Then, too, the murderer must have had blood stains on bands and clothing, for the autopsy revealed the fact that there were no lens than twelve deep cuts on each bead, the skull of each victim being laid open and horribly gashed, yet this daughter bore no criminating marks. If she bad committed the murder she must have hidden the ox or cleaver in tke house, but the police have searched every nook and cornel in the bouse and hum without finding the weapon. The absence of the weapon goes to prove the innocence of the members of the house hold more than anything else. It is nega tive evidence to be sure, but it is important. The argument used by the relativst is that the murderer was in the room with Mrs. Borden when the daughter's sersams announced her discovery of the first mur der. There was no time then for robbery. Flight was the only thing to be thought of. While it seems improbable that a man could have escaped under such circum stances without leaving a clew it is not im possible, as the many mysterious crimes of a similar nature have proved.

See the clipping

Evening Journal · Wilmington, Del.

The report describes police frustration over the absence of clues and the murder weapon, noting the killer must have been very close by and bloodstained given the extreme violence of the wounds. It presents the defense argument that the murderer had no time for robbery and must have simply fled, while acknowledging this seems improbable without leaving a trace.

CorrectionThis set right an article from the day before.

Evening Journal · 6 August 1892 · page 5

THE HOUSEHOLD UNDER SUSPICION.

The words of this article are printed with the report it shares its clipping with. Read them there or in the clipping.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

In the story →

The Morning News · Savannah, Ga.

The Bordens were found hacked to death at their Fall River home, with police investigating a theory that poison was used to stupefy the victims before the ax attack. Suspicion falls on brother-in-law John Morse and a nephew, though no arrests have been made as police await the funeral.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out. CorrectionThis set right 3 earlier articles: Waterbury Evening Democrat, 5 August 1892, Evening Journal, 5 August 1892, The Portland Daily Press, 5 August 1892.

The Morning News · 6 August 1892 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

WEALTHY COUPLE SLAIN

RELATIVES SUSPECTED OF KILLING THEM.

See moreSee less

Poison Probably Administered to Stupefy the Victims Before They Were Attacked With Knife and Ax. The Police Working on a Theory But No Arrest Made Yet.

FALL RIVER, MASS., Aug. 5.—Andrew J. Borden, a wealthy real estate owner and mill man, and his wife were found dead at their home, No. 92 Second street, about noon yesterday. Both had been mutilated about the head and face with an ax, cleaver or razor. Mr. Borden lay on a sofa in a room on the top floor of the house. His head had been cut, and gashes from four to six inches long were found on his face and neck. Mrs. Borden was in her own chamber on the upper floor, and the condition of her face and head was the same as that of her husband. She lay face downward in her bed, which, was a veritable pool of blood. After a most thorough and persistent search no trace has been found of the murderer. Four policemen are on guard at the house, and have been patrolling the neighborhood since the affair was made public. This morning State Detective Seaver and City Marshal Hilliard held a long consultation, and later on visited and interrogated Miss Lizzie, a daughter of Mr. and Mrs. Borden, at the house. The result of their investigation will not be known until an arrest of some kind has been made.

WATCHING A BROTHER-IN-LAW.

A strict watch that has been kept over John W. Morse, a brother-in-law of Mr. Borden by his first marriage, was even more strictly kept to-day than ever. It appears to be the desire of the police to make no arrests until after the funeral, unless it becomes known that the murderers actually entered the house and escaped within an hour, an idea that is scouted by the police at the present time.

The following advertisement appeared in to-night's local papers:

$5,000 REWARD.

The above reward will be paid to any one who may secure the arrest and conviction of the person or persons who occasioned the death of Andrew J. Borden and his wife.

EMMA J. BORDEN. LIZZIE J. BORDEN.

A NEPHEW SUSPECTED.

Late this afternoon it was reported at the police station that a young man said to be a nephew of Mr. Borden was suspected of the murders. It arose from the fact that some time ago Mr. and Mrs. Borden were overheard in angry talk with the young man over the division of some property. As the young man was parting from them at the front door he was heard to say: "By —— you have cheated me and I will make you suffer." The report was sifted and it was found that such a conversation had occurred, but it happened ten months ago and the young man had not been seen since. The police let go this clew readily and again turned their attention to the house.

LOOKING INTO MORSE'S HISTORY.

The antecedents of John W. Morse and his connections are being closely hunted and the girl Lizzie is again being subjected to a rigorous examination. Morse is 55 years of age and came here from Hastings, Ia., two years ago. He became very intimate with Mr. Borden and Lizzie Borden, spending a great deal of his time with them. He came from New Bedford at noon on the day before the murder and spent the night in the Borden house. He left there at 9 o'clock on the day of the crime and was next seen twenty minutes after the body was discovered.

POISONING SUSPECTED.

The police believe that there was either a previous attempt at killing by poison, or that poison was administered as a preparatory step for the crime. On the morning of their death both Mr. and Mrs. Borden arose from sleep feeling ill. They had drank milk before going to bed, and it is believed that if drugs were administered it was done then. It is here that the suspicion of a conspiracy coincides with the presence of the brother-in-law in the house. After Medical Examiner Dolan, assisted by other physicians, had completed his autopsy on the bodies the stomachs of both were placed in alcohol and sent to Boston for analysis, with a view to determining if poisoning had been attempted.

NO SIGNS OF A STRUGGLE.

The poison theory is borne out by the fact that the condition of the rooms in which the two bodies were found showed no signs of a struggle, not a piece of furniture being out of its place, while there was very little blood scattered about, although Mr. Borden sustained no less than twelve cuts on the face and skull, varying in length from four to eight inches, and a fracture of the skull two by four inches and three inches deep. Mrs. Borden's wounds were not of so wholesale a nature.

ESCAPE NOT EASY.

That the murders could have been committed by a stranger who escaped is very doubtful, as there were many persons about who would have seen him leaving the place after the deed.

Another suspicious circumstance is that the commission of the deed should have been timed for the exact period when the servant girl, Bridget Sullivan, was busy cleaning the outside of the windows and so out of the way. This girl heard no commotion or groan, while Miss Borden says that she heard a noise while she was in the barn, and hurried in to find the bodies of her dead parents. A remarkable thing is that Miss Borden, although, according to the servant's story, she supposed that her mother was out, did not give an alarm when she found her father's body, but went to her mother's room, and it was her shrieks from that place which attracted the servant and neighbors to the scene. It is believed by some that Mr. Borden and his wife, suffering from drowsiness produced by drugs or otherwise, were asleep when the assassin attacked them, and that sudden and swift blows quickly ended the bloody business.

MISS BORDEN AFTER POISON.

The Evening Globe says this evening that most important clew is in possession of the police. From Clerk Eli Bence, at D. R. Smith's drug store, they learned last night that Miss Borden had been in the store within three hours and had inquired for a certain poison. The clerk was asked to accompany the officers, who closely questioned him as to the facts relative to the time, the girl's condition mentally and the amount and quality of the poison she had bought or called for. The officers then took the drug clerk to the residence on Second street where Miss Lizzie was stopping for the time being. The young man was not well acquainted with the young woman, but he had told them that he could identify her at sight. He did identify her and in the presence of the officers informed them that she was in his place of business and made inquiries for a bottle of poison. Miss Borden's reply to this accusation, as well as the exact language which she used at the time, is known only to the policemen and herself.

See the clipping

The Morning News · Savannah, Ga.

Detectives questioned Lizzie Borden again and kept close watch on brother-in-law John Morse while investigating a tip about a nephew who had quarreled with the Bordens over property. Police also suspected the couple may have been drugged via milk before the killings, and a $5,000 reward was offered for the killer's arrest.

The Morning News · 6 August 1892 · page 1

A NEPHEW SUSPECTED.

LOOKt.VO INTO MORSE’S HISTORY. The antecedents of John W. Morse and his connections are being closely bunted and the girl Lizzie is again being subjected to a rigorous examination. Morse is 55 years of age and came here from Hastings, la., two > ears ago. He became very intimate with Mr. Borden and Lizzie Borden, spending a great deal of his time with them. He came from New Bedford at noon on the day be fore the murder ana spent the night in the Borden house. He left there at 9 o’clock on the day of the crime and was next seen twenty minutes after the body was discov ered.

See the clipping

The Morning News · Savannah, Ga.

Investigators theorize that Mr. and Mrs. Borden may have been drugged via milk before being killed, since neither room showed signs of struggle despite the violence. The report also notes a clue involving druggist Eli Bence and an inquiry Lizzie Borden allegedly made about poison.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

The Morning News · 6 August 1892 · page 1

attempted. NO BIONS|oN A STRUGGLE. The poison theory Is borne out by the faot that the condition of the rooms in which the two bodies wore found showed no signs of a struggle, not a piece of furniture being out of its place, while there was very little blood scattered about, although Mr. Borden sustained no less than twelve cuts on the (ace and skull, varying in length from four to eight inches, and a fracture of the skull to by four inches and three inches deep. Mrs. Borden’s wound* were not of so whole sale a nature.

See moreSee less

escape not easy. That the murders oould have been oom nutted by a stranger who escaped is very doubtful, as there were many persons about , 0 would have seen him leaving the place after the deed. Another suspicious circumitanoo is that tM commission of the deed should have been timed for the exact period when the eervant girl, Bridget Sullivan, was busy cleaning the outside of the windows and so out of the way. This girl heard no oom motion or groan, while Miss Borden says >nst nhe heard a noise while she was in the o&rn, and hurried in to And the bodies of her eaa parents. A remarkable thing is that da Borden, although, according to the story, she supposed that her other was out, did not give an alarm ink *“ e foun d her father’s body, but went room < end it was her shrieks T 1 '“at place which attracted the servant oa neighbors to the scene. It is believed . that Mr. Borden and his wife, uttering from drowsiness produced by ’ l *’®r otherwise, were asleep when tha ,„? s,ln , attacked them, and that sudden b * ows <l“tokly ended the bloody

See the clipping

Der Deutsche Correspondent · Baltimore, Md.

The report describes the Borden double murder in Fall River, noting police initially suspected a Portuguese farmhand working the Borden farm but found no evidence against him. It then states suspicion later turned to a dissatisfied tenant, John Morse (brother of Borden's first wife), and daughter Lizzie Borden, who had discovered the bodies.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day. CorrectionThis set right 3 earlier articles: Waterbury Evening Democrat, 5 August 1892, Daily Kennebec Journal, 5 August 1892, The Evening Herald, 5 August 1892.

Wrong

Der Deutsche Correspondent · 6 August 1892 · page 3

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

See the clipping

Der Deutsche Correspondent · Baltimore, Md.

Despite thorough investigation, no trace of the murderer of Andrew Borden and his wife has been found, with police guarding the house and increasing surveillance on John Morse. A pharmacy clerk reportedly told police that Lizzie Borden tried to buy poison 36 hours before the murders, and the sisters have offered a $5,000 reward for the killer's capture.

Der Deutsche Correspondent · 6 August 1892 · page 4

Das Mordgeheimniß in Fall-River

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

See the clipping

Der Deutsche Correspondent · Baltimore, Md.

The report describes a $5,000 reward offered by Emma and Lizzie Borden for the killer's capture, and details Andrew Borden's estate valuation. It also reports that police learned from drugstore clerk Eli Bence that Lizzie had sought poison 36 hours before the murders, and outlines police theories that the couple may have been poisoned via milk before being killed, possibly by conspirators rather than a stranger.

Der Deutsche Correspondent · 6 August 1892 · page 4

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

See the clipping

In the story →

The Portland Daily Press · Portland, Me.

A Fall River Globe report says drug clerk Eli Bence identified Lizzie Borden as the woman who inquired about buying poison at his store within 36 hours of the murders. The piece suggests this points to a family member wanting the parents out of the way, with arrests expected soon.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

The Portland Daily Press · 6 August 1892 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

SHE BOUGHT POISON.

Lizzie Borden Is the Subject of a Terrible Suspicion.

See moreSee less

EXCITEMENT IN FALL RIVER STILL AT FEVER HEAT.

Miss Borden's Purchase of the Poison Proved--Her Strange Conduct--Morse, the Suspected Man, Surrounded by a Crowd of Thousands on the Street--He Is Closely Watched by the Police--The Funeral Arrangements.

FALL RIVER, August 5.--Tonight the mystery surrounding the Borden murders came very close to solution. Unless all signs fail, there will be arrests tomorrow. The Fall River Globe tonight says that the police learned from Eli Beare, a drug clerk, last night that Miss Borden had been in the store within 36 hours previous and had inquired for a certain poison. There clerk was asked to accompany the officers and closely questioned as to the exact facts relative to the time, the girl's condition mentally, the amount and quality of the poison she had bought or called for. The officers then led the drug clerk to a residence on Second street, where Miss Lizzie was stopping for the time being. The young man was not previously well acquainted with the young woman, but he had told them that he could identify her at sight. He did identify her and in the presence of the police officers informed her that she was in his place of business and made

Inquiry For a Bottle of Poison.

The Globe's story has been verified by the highest authority. There now seems no doubt that some one in the family was anxious to have the father and mother out of the way. The demeanor of Miss Lizzie through the trying ordeal of being confronted with the man who says she asked about poison was of half contempt and scorn. Her conduct as observed by the police since the affair happened, had been strange inasmuch as she has stood the pointed questioning of all who have interviewed her with a show of no other feeling than that of a disinterested party. It is generally known among close friends of the family that Lizzie has not been upon the best of terms with the other members of the household. It is alleged that for some time previous she did not sit at the same table with the other folks, but had her meals served at a separate table. The feeling of coolness between the members of the family is unaccounted for by police or neighbors. The murder had hardly been discovered before she told a neighbor that she was very sorry as she had arranged to go to Marion on a vacation.

Tonight it was learned that Miss Lizzie had enquired at the drug store for hydrocyanic acid in diluted form, saying that she wished to use it on furs. Medical Examiner Dolan stated the acid would be of little use for such a purpose as it has no antiseptic qualities, but is an exceedingly injurious acid to the human system. There is not the slightest doubt that Miss Lizzie

Enquired for the Deadly Acid at Smith's drug store, but whether for herself or some other person remains to be proven. The police are acting slowly and carefully in the affair, giving way, no doubt, to a feeling of sentiment because of the high social standing of the parties involved. The strictest kind of a guard is being kept on the house and all the inmates, John Morse went out four times today on various errands, and each time was followed closely by a detective and patrolman. Tonight in company with the servant girl he walked to the post office. Before reaching it they were surrounded by a crowd of 2000 or more. Five policemen kept the crowd back while the parties were returning to the Borden homestead. The excitement is greater tonight if anything than last night. A crowd of 600 people are standing in front of the house but the police do not allow stragglers to hang over the fence or loiter on the sidewalk.

From all indications it would seem as if the funeral services tomorrow would have an official flavor. During the day the clothing worn by the deceased persons was buried near the house. Miss Lizzie kept her room all day and has been inaccessible to all callers. In police circles tonight it is being talked that the two murders occurred after the victims were rendered unconscious by drugs.

See the clipping

The Portland Daily Press · Portland, Me.

Reports emerge that Lizzie Borden had inquired at a drug store about obtaining diluted hydrocyanic acid, claiming it was for cleaning furs, though the medical examiner doubts this use. Meanwhile police maintain heavy surveillance on the Borden household amid large crowds, and speculation grows that the victims may have been drugged unconscious before being killed.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

The Portland Daily Press · 6 August 1892 · page 1

STILL AT FEVER HEAT

Fall River, August 6.—Tonight the mystery surrounding the Borden mur ders came very close to solution. Un less all signs fail, there -will be arrests to morrow. The Fall River Globe tonight says that the police learned from Eli Beare, a drug clerk, last night that Miss Borden had been in the store within 36 hours previous and had inquired for a certain poison. There clerk was asked to accompany the officers and closely questioned as to the exact facts relative to the time, the girl’s condition mental ly, the amount and quality of the poison she had bought or called for.

See moreSee less

The offi cers then led the drug clerk to a resi dence on Second street, where Miss Lizzie was stopping for the time being. The young man was not previously well acquainted with the young woman, but he had told them that he could identify her at sight. He did identify her and in the presence of the police officers in formed.her that she was in his place of business and made Inquiry For a Bottle of Poison. The Globe’s story has been verified by the highest authority. There now seems no doubt that some one in the family was anxious to have the father and mother out of the way. The demeanor of Miss Lizzie through the trying ordeal of being confronted with tfie man who says she asked about poison was of half uvutvui^>v UIUU wvn ivu wm served by the police since the affair hap pened, had been strange inasmuch as she has stood the pointed questioning of all who have interviewed her with a show of no other feeling than that of a disin terested party. It is generally known among close friends of the family that Lizzie has not been upon the best of terms with the other members of the household. It is alleged that for some time previous she did not sit at the same table with the other folks, but had her meals served at a separate table. The feeling of coolness between the members of the family is unaccounted for by police or neighbors. The murder had hardly been discovered before she told a neigh bor that she was very sorry as she had arranged to go to Marion on a vacation. Tonight it was learned that Miss Liz zie had enquired at the drug store for hydrocyanic acid in diluted form, saying that she wished to use it on furs. Medi cal Examiner Dolan stated the acid would be of little use for such a purpose as it has no antiseptic qualities, but is an exceedingly injurious acid to the hu man system. There is not the slightest doubt that Miss Lizzie Enquired for the Deadly Acid at Smith’s drug store, but whether for herself or some other person remains to be proven. The police are acting slowly and carefully in the affair, giving way,no doubt, to a feeling of sentiment because of the high social standing of the par ties involved. The strictest kind of a guard is being kept on the house and all the inmates, John Morse went out four times today on various errands, and each time was followed close ly by a detective and patrolman. Tonight in company with the servant girl he walked to the post office. Before reaching it they were surrounded by a crowd of 2000 or more. Five policemen kept the crowd back while the parties were returning to the Borden homestead. The excitement is greater tonight if any thing than last night. A crowd of 600 people are standing in front of the house but the police do not allow stragglers to hang over the fence or loiter on the side From all indications it would seem as if the funeral services tomorrow would have an official flavor. During the day the clothing worn by the deceased per sons was buried near the house. Miss Lizzie kept her room all day and has been inaccessible to all callers. In police circles tonight it is being talked that the two murders occurred after the victims were rendered uncon scious by drugs. Relating to Pinkertons. Washington, August 5.—As finally agreed upon by the conferees that sec tion of the sundry civil bill relating to the Pinkerton detective system reads: “No employe of the Pinkerton detec tive agency or similar agency shall be employed in any government service or by any officer in the District of Colum bia.” This language rids the amendment of the disturbing provision which was the prohibition of the employment of Pinkertons by any government contrac tor. _

See the clipping

St. Paul Daily Globe · Saint Paul, Minn.

A telegram informed W. B. Norse of Excelsior that his brother and sister-in-law, Andrew and Abby Borden, had been murdered in Fall River, prompting him to leave immediately. The report says both were killed around 11 a.m. Thursday with an ax, cleaver, or razor, and names John Morse, Lizzie Borden, and a servant girl as being watched, though Morse was now believed innocent.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

St. Paul Daily Globe · 6 August 1892 · page 3

THE FALL RIVER MURDER

MINNEAPOLIS. MINNEAPOLIS GLOBULES. Elizabeth Madden, the shoplifter arrested by Inspector Doyle, was sent to the workLouse yesterday tor sixty days. W. M. Ferris, who was drowned Thursday In the Straight river at Owntoima, was well known here. He was eleetrotyper for Mar oer, Luse & Co. Chief ot Police Henderson reports SG? ar rests during July, of which 14J were for state offenses. The.detectives made twenty -nine arrests and recovered property worth gJTO. An elevator, to cost about 515.00 Q. will be erected by the A. D. Mtilford Elevator comT>niiy just outside the city limits on the S>t.

See moreSee less

Louis toad. The elevator will hold about 300,000 bushels of grain. Marriage licenses were issued yesterday to Samuel B. 'ihompsoti and Defla C. Hall, EmilC. Brose and Uertha 11. Lange. Oust heckman <uid Annie Wiren, Samuel J. MoWat and Jennie Kinir. E. L. Carpenter has purchased the interest of Mr«. S. O. Hull in the Ball & Dueey Lum ber company. >lr. Carpenter retires fsoru the lirni of Carpenter IJros. it Co.. and is suc ceeded by his brother, E. J. Carpenter. An autopsy was held yesterday upon the remains of "French Lena,'" who died sud denly while making her toilet Thursday afternoon. The autopsy revealed that death was caused by an overdose of morphine. After touay the obnoxious target hhootitiß on me Fort Snelling reservation by the Third regiment soldiers will cease, and the resi dents of Richfield and Bloomingtou town ships may feel secure of flying builets here after. There will be a moonlight excursion at lliunetonka this evening for the beneiitof Trinity chapel, Epitco] al, :it Excelsior. The City of St. Louis will leave Excelsior al I:'M o'clock, and stop al Luke Park, MinnctonKa Beach and the hotel St. Louis. The board of education ln:s about $100,000 on band for the purpose of making new ini provemeuts, and it is now thought that a new twenty-room Bchoolbouse will be erected on the site of the present Douglas school m Dupoiit and Franklin avenues. Only two more performances of ■ The Gos soon." will te given !<t the Bijou. The en gagement will end with a matinee and eveu ing perforninnfie today. Tomorrow night "In Old Kentucky" will be presented for the first time. At tiio £emi-annual meeting of the Lucy Hayes union, held Thursday afternoon, the following officers were elected for the ensu ing term: President, Mis. Frances, Neal; secretory, Mrs. L. W. Demon; corresnond ins secretary, Mrs. YV. E. J. Demming; treasurer, Mis. W. L. Lawrence. The lease which gives to the T. J. I'reece Mercantile company the occupancy of the Kinsman building on First avenue north has been signed, sealed and delivered, and the new enterprise lias n borne. Ibe build ing is located at :U'J-(I4 First avenue north, adjoining the wholesale house of George K. Kewell & Co. The members of the Portland Avenue Christian church decided Thursday night to commence at once ifae erection ot ibeir new bouse of worship on the corner ot Portland avenue and bleveuih street. The stipulated 815.000 Juts been raised, and the foundation will be put iv this year. It is eveu post.il le that nine work may be. done on tiie walls. Tbe bouse will cost about $33,009. and tnc remainder of the money will be secured by mortgage. Exposition Treasure?, 11. J. Smith returned yesterday from his trip to New York. He has been busiiy engaged in looking after the in terests of the exposition art gallery, and does not return empty banded. Oik; of the unique features of the collection will lie 100 of the line original water colors and oil paiutines from whicn the illustrations for the Century magazine were made. There will also be 00 simi lar drawings made for the Cosmopolitan by the first illustrators of the country. Mr. Smith has secured :200 water colors by the bc'st artists, and some represent ative canvases in oil. The feature of the first week of the exposition will bu the exhibition of Muukacsy's famous painting, '"Lust Hours of Mozart," for which Gen. R. A. Aiger paid ?40,(i00. This great painting can only remain a week, as it must be back in the Alger residence early in September, wlien the general's daughter is tv be married. The painting will come on a special car by itself. In addition Mr. Smith has secured about so of the Guest canvases owned in Detroit, among them bci:ig several from the well-known Hopkins collection. The Fall River Murder. W. B. Norse, of Excelsior, has re ceived "a telegram announcing that his brother and sister, Mr. and Mrs. An drew I>. Borden, ot Fall River, Mass*, had been murdered at 11 o'clock Thurs day morning. Jle left for Fall River immediately upon receiving the tele pram. The Bordeus are well known at Aliunetonka, where they pass their summers. Mr. Morris' daughter, Anna, is visiting the Bordens, and it was from her the telegram e -me. Mr. and Mrs. Borden were murdered in the most brutal manner, both being horribly mutilated with ail ax, cleaver or razor. John N. Morse, brother of W. 13. Morse, •was at first suspected of being the mur derer, but is now regarded as innocent. Among those who are being watched, besides Morse, are Lizzie Borden, the murdered couple's daughter, and a ser vant girl. Anderson's Wooden Lejj. Alfred Anderson is a cripple and 6poi ts a wooden leg. This wooden leg is an exceedingly lively one, and sets Alfred in no end of trouble. He was locked up last winter on account of this leir, and last night he was again corralled by an officer and locked up in the ceutral station. Anderson went into Gordon's saloon on First ave nue south and demanded a drink, and, when refused, mew exceedingly wroth. He went out on the walk and, lifting up his wooden le^. began kick ing at the door. He kicked so hard that a pane of glass fell out and at tracted Officer Bacon's attention. He arrested the man with the wooden leg, and, after a light, managed, with the assistance of the patrol driver, to land him in the wagon and bring him to the station. Fumes of Gasoline. Dave Brindell, an employe of the dye works at 720 Hennepin avenue, was overcome by the fumes of gasoline yesterday afternoon and narrowly escaped death. He. was taken ill and vent into t tie closet in the basement, where he fell inio a state of uncon sciousness. When he was found some time later he was nearly dead. The patrol wagon was called and Brindell was taken to his home, at 1717 Second avenue south. Bowker and His Home. The Bowker Home for the Friendless will hereafter run without the official sanction of the board, if it runs at all. The directors have finally concluded their investigations and come to the conclusion that with Bowker and the elusive chicken house in the home, they will have nothing more to do with it. The association wiil continue to oner ale as heretofore, but Bowker will uot be "in it."

See the clipping

The Jersey City News · Jersey City, N.J.

Despite mounting evidence, police have not arrested Lizzie Borden or her uncle John Morse, instead maintaining heavy surveillance on the Borden home amid growing public excitement. The report notes the victims' clothes were buried and that police increasingly suspect the victims were drugged before being killed.

The Jersey City News · 6 August 1892 · page 1

fence or loiter ou the sidewalks. During the day the clothes worn by the deceased persons were buried in the rear of the house. Lizzie Borden kept her room all day and was inaccessible to callers, no matter who or what they were. |*The police put more and more faith in the theory that the victims were ren dered unconscious by drugs before the murder.

See the clipping

The Evening Herald · Shenandoah, Pa.

Police investigating the Borden murders learn that a drug store clerk, Eli Bence, claims Lizzie Borden tried to buy poison shortly before the killings. He is brought to identify her in person, and does so, though her response to the accusation is not disclosed.

The Evening Herald · 6 August 1892 · page 3

ONE OF THE GIRLS BOUGHT POISON.

Itecarillng the MurderThe Kxcltejneftt llemalns'at Ferer Heat. Falu Riveii, Mass., Aug. 0. It la stated that an Important clue to the mur derer of Andrew J. Borden and his wifo is In the hands otthe police. From Clerk Ell Bence, at P. K. Smith's drug store, they learned that Miss Llzzlo Borden had been in the store within 80 hours past, and had inquired for a cer tain poison. The clerk was asked to ac company tho olllcers, and they cloicly questioned him as to the tlmo of the girl's call, her condition mentally and the amount and quality of the poison sho had bought nnd called for.

See moreSee less

The police then took the drug clerk to a houso on Second street, where Miss Lizzie Borden was stopping for the tlmo being. The clerk was not proviously well ac quainted with the young woman, but he had told them that ho could identify her at sight. He did identity her, nnd in tho presence of tho police informed them that sho was in his place of business aud made inquiry for n bottle of poison. Miss Borden's reply to this accusation, as well as the exact lanzaugo which was used at the time, Is known only to tho police. Suspicion fixed itself after the murder on members of the family who were in or about the houso at tho tlmo when tho tragedy took place, and the authorities placed a watch on Borden's daughter Liz zie,. who gave the alarm, and John W.

See the clipping

In the story →

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

The Borden funeral took place under heavy police guard, with thousands gathered outside the home before burial at Oak Grove Cemetery. Meanwhile, rumors circulated that three suspects—including a prominent physician—would soon be arrested, and that Lizzie Borden reacted furiously when police sought to search her room.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

The Providence News · 6 August 1892 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

THREE SUSPECTS.

Their Arrest Expected This Afternoon.

See moreSee less

THE BORDENS BURIED.

Impressive Services Over the Bodies of the Murdered Pair.

A MOST SENSATIONAL STORY.

Lizzie Borden Is Said to Have Flown Into a Fury When the Officers Proposed Immediately After the Discovery of the Murder to Search Her Room.

[SPECIAL TO THE NEWS.]

FALL RIVER, Aug. 6.--The funeral of Andrew L. and Alice Borden, the murdered couple, took place at 11 o'clock this forenoon. Thousands of people blocked the streets in the vicinity of the stricken home, and tried in vain to get a peep at the proceedings.

A cordon of police kept all at a respectful distance; no one was allowed inside but the immediate relatives of the deceased. The services were brief but impressive. The Rev. Dr. Adams, pastor of the First Congregational Church, conducted the services, assisted by the Rev. E. A. Berek. The bodies were placed in black cloth-covered caskets, and were placed side by side.

Following the services the two caskets were borne to hearses in waiting by bearers representing the corporations with which Mr. Borden was connected. Down the street the funeral cortege made its way, the people falling back as it approached. Interment was in the Oak Grove cemetery.

The police had made no arrests up to noon. It is stated that the expected blow will fall this afternoon, after the funeral is over.

It is now stated that three arrests will be made, one as principal and two accessories.

One of the suspects is a prominent physican, whose name has not been connected with the crime. The utmost excitement prevails and the wildest rumors of important disclosures are afloat.

It was learned to-day for the first time that an hour or more after the murder was discovered two of the officers despatched to the scene undertook to make a search of the house. They looked over the first floor to some extent and then started up stairs. Lizzie Borden became aware of their efforts, and as they reached the door of her room she stepped boldly in front of the officers, exclaiming, "Where are you going?"

"We are going to search this house and your room," replied the officers.

"You are not going into that room" said Lizzie as she turned the key in the lock and stood determined in front of the door.

"We desire to search that bureau and the closet in your room.

"Don't you interfere. You have no right to enter my room, and I tell you you shall not; there is nothing there!"

"It will be better for you, Miss Borden, to let us make the search."

Lizzie thereat became furious and barred the officers' progress, repeating with fixed determination her declarations that they should not enter. Her boldness of front astonished the officers so that they did not really know whether they had the authority or not to prosecute the search.

Finally they became convinced that they had made an unauthorized move and they withdrew without attempting to conclude the search through the house.

CONTINUED ON PAGE 3.

LIZZIE BOUGHT ACID.

A Possible Solution of the Fall River Murder Mystery.

IS THE DAUGHTER GUILTY?

Her Strange Actions Arouse Police Suspicion--But it Isn't a Good Thing to be Too Quick to Jump on a Bereaved Woman.

CONTINUED FROM PAGE 1.

FALL RIVER, Mass., Aug. 6.--Last night the mystery surrounding the Borden murders came very close to a solution and unless all signs fail, there will be arrests today. The story of the attempt of Miss Lizzie Borden to purchase poison has been verified by the highest authorities.

There now seems no doubt that some one in the family was anxious to have the father and mother out of the way. The demeanor of Miss Lizzie through the trying ordeal of being confronted with the man who says that she asked about poison was half of contempt and scorn. In fact, her conduct as observed by the police since the affair happened, has been strange, inasmuch as she stood the pointed questioning of all who interviewed her with the show of no other feeling than that of a disinterested party.

It is generally known among the close friends of the family that Lizzie has not been upon the best of terms with the other members of the household. It is alleged that she for some time previous did not sit at the table with the other folks, but that she had her meals served on a separate table. The feeling of coolness between the members of the family is not accounted for by either the police or the neighbors. The murder had hardly been discovered before she told a neighbor that she was very sorry as she had arranged to go to Marion on a vacation.

Last night it was learned that Miss Lizzie had inquired at a drug store for hydrocyanic acid in a diluted form, saying she wished to use it on furs. Medical Examiner Dolan, who has been deeply interested in the case, stated that the acid would be of little use for such purpose, as it has no antiseptic qualities, but it is an exceedingly injurious acid to the human system. There is not the slightest doubt that Miss Lizzie inquired for the deadly acid at Smith's drug store, but whether for herself or some other person remains to be proven.

The police are acting slowly and carefully in the affair, giving way, no doubt to feelings of sentiment, because of the high social standing of the parties involved. The strictest kind of guard is being kept on the house and all the inmates.

John Morse went out of the house four times yesterday on various errands and each time he was followed closely by a detective patrolman. Last night, in company with the servant girl, he walked to the post office, but before reaching there they were surrounded by a crowd of 2000 people or more. Five policemen kept the crowds back, while the parties were returning to the Borden homestead. The excitement was greater last night, if anything, than it was Thursday night.

A crowd of 600 people stood in front of the house, but the police would not allow stragglers to hang over the fence or loiter on the sidewalks. From all indications it would seem as if the funeral services would have an official flavor.

The clothes worn by the deceased persons were buried near the house. Miss Lizzie kept her room all day and was inaccessable to callers, no matter who or what they were.

In police circles it is being talked that the two murders occurred after the victims had been rendered unconscious by drugs. If this surmise proves true, it will then be readily understood how an extraordinary tragedy could be enacted here on the principal street without attracting any public attention.

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

The Borden funeral took place with burial at Oak Grove cemetery, while rumors spread that police would soon arrest a principal and two accessories, including a prominent physician. The report also reveals that officers had earlier been blocked by Lizzie Borden from searching her room shortly after the murders were discovered.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

The Providence News · 6 August 1892 · page 1

ISPECIAL TO THRE NEWAI FALL RivER, Aug. 6.—The funeral of Andrew L. and Alice Borden, the mur dered couple, took place at 11 o’clock this forenoon. Thousands of people blocked the streets in the vicinity of the stricken home, and tried in vain to get a peep at the proceedings. A cordon of police kept all at a respect ful distance; no one was allowed inside but the immediate relatives of the de ceased. The services were brief but im pressive. The KRev. Dr. Adams, pastor of the First Congregational Church, con ducted the services, assisted by the Rev.

See moreSee less

E. A. Berek. The bodies were placed in black cloth-covered caskets, and were placed side by side. Following the services the two caskets were borne to hearses in waiting by bear ers representing the corporations with which Mr. Borden was connected. Down the street the funeral cortege made its way, the people falling back as it ap proached. Jloterment was in the Oak Grove cemetery. The police had made no arrests up to noon. It is stated that the expected blow will fall this afternoon, after the funeral is over. It is now stated that three arrests will be made, one as principal and two acces sories. One of the suspects is a prominent phy rican, whose name has not been connect ed with the crime. The utmost excite ment prevails and the wildest rumors of important disclosures are afloat. It was learned to-day for the first time that an hour or more after the murder was discovered two of the officers des patched to the scene undértook to make a search of the house, They looked over the first floor to some ex | tent and then started up stairs. Lizzie Borden became aware of their of forts, and as they reached the door of her room she stepped boldly in frount of the officers, exclaiming, ‘‘Where are you going "’ ‘““We are going to search this house and your room,” replied the officers. *“You are not going into that room” said Lizzie as she turned the key in the lock and stood determined in frout of the door. ** We desire to search that bureau and the closet in your room. “Don’t you interfere. You have no right to enter my room, and I tell you you shall not ; there is nothing there ! “It will be better for you, Miss Borden, to let us make the search.” Lizzie thereat became furious and barred the officers’ progress, repeating with fixed determination her declarations that they should pot enter. Her bolduess of front astonished the officers 8o that they did not really know whether they had the authority or not to prosecute the search, Finally they became convinced that they had made an unautborized move and they withdrew without attempting to conclude the search through the house.

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

The article claims investigators have verified that Lizzie Borden attempted to purchase prussic acid before the murders, suggesting she wanted her parents out of the way. It also describes her cold demeanor and strained relations with the family as further grounds for suspicion.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

The Providence News · 6 August 1892 · page 3

LIZZIE BOUGHT ACID

FROM PAGE 1. FALL RIVER, Mass,, Aug. 6.—Last night the mystery surrounding the Borden murders came very close to a solution and unless all signs fall, there will be ar rests today. The story of the attempt of Miss Lizzie Borden to purchase polsoa bhas been verified by the highest authoriLies. There now seems no doubt that some one in the family was anxious to have the father and mother out of the way. The demeanor of Miss Lizzie through the trying ordeal of being confronted with the man who says that she asked about

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

The report examines claims that Lizzie Borden sought hydrocyanic acid at a drug store, with the medical examiner noting it would be useless for cleaning furs but highly toxic to humans. It also describes heavy police surveillance of the Borden household, crowds gathering nightly, and rumors that the victims had been drugged unconscious before being killed.

The Providence News · 6 August 1892 · page 3

each time he was followed closely by a detective rtrolmll. Last night, in company with the servant filrl, he walked to the post office, but belore mcnlns there they were surrounded by a crow of 2000 people or more. Five policemen kept the crowds back, while the parties were returning to the Borden homestead. The excitement was greater last night, if

See the clipping

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

Fall River police are investigating a clue about a stranger seen calling at the Borden house the Monday before the murders, described as about 25 years old wearing distinctive laced baseball shoes. A witness saw the man enter the house, stay about ten minutes, then leave in a horse and buggy, and police are trying to trace his identity.

New-York Tribune · 7 August 1892 · page 1

SHOES WHO CALLED ON MR. BORDEN— FUNERAL OF THE VICTIMS, Fall River, Mass., Aug 6 —TLe following lew, to determine who were the recent callers at the Bor- | den homestead, is being traced to-day by the police. Last Monday morning, about 9 o'clock, a horse and bugzy turned 1ato Second-st. out of Spring, and stopped in front of the Borden house. A man who is employed near by sat in his buggy almost opposite, and facing south. [Ie had ample opportunity and time to take a careful look at the vehicle, anc the circumstance of the two strange men calling at the Borden house made an impression on hig mind which he remembered distinctly.

See moreSee less

One of the men | got out of the buggy and rang the door bell. As he stood there, the observer saw him plainly, and remembers that his description was that of a man about twenty-five years old, with sallow complexion, soft hat, dark trousers with a wide stripe of dark material down the leg, and russet, or * baseball” shoes, Ile wis about five feet nine inches high. The shoes in particular attracted attention, as they were of peculiar make and color, and were laced. Mr. Borden opened the door, and the man spoke a few words and was admitted. The man who remained in the team was not so closely scrutinized, and his description is not well remembered. The one NO

See the clipping

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

Police investigate reports of strange men near the Borden house, including a boy who saw a man scale the backyard fence and gave a description matching an earlier witness account. Investigators also pursue leads about Morse's horse-trading business and a Frenchman's account of driving a suspicious agitated stranger toward Westport.

New-York Tribune · 7 August 1892 · page 1

POLICE. A CLEW.

scription is not well remembered. The one NO who entered remained about ten minutes and then came out with his hat in his hand. The teamn wins driven off in the direction of Pleasant-st, This circumstance is considered of importance when the fact is known that the police have in their possession knowledge of the only person who tells of having seen a strange man at the Borden house at the time of the murders, A boy named Kirounck, about twelve years old, was passing the honse at about 11 o'clock, and saw a man scale the rear fence into the yard back of Dr.

See moreSee less

Chagnon’s houss. The hoy went to his home on Central-st. and told his father of the circumstance, The father was go impressed with the story that he informed Marshal Hilliard, who sent for the boy and heard what he had to say. A sig nificant thing in this connection is that the boy gave the same description of the man whom he had seen jump the fence as did the young man who saw the stranger standing on Mr. Borden's

See the clipping

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

Investigators pursue leads on traveling horse traders and a hatchet purchased in New Bedford, while police hold hatchets from the Borden cellar for microscopic testing. Meanwhile, the Borden funerals take place amid a large crowd, with Mr. Morse addressing reporters and describing Lizzie's demeanor.

New-York Tribune · 7 August 1892 · page 1

Borden cellar A microscopical examination will he made of them next Mooday. No traces of blood can be discoverca on them with the naked eye. The latest developments in the Borden murders have given way to discussion among the people to-day of the funerals, which took place this morning. As early the house was as 9 o'clock surrounded by a great crowd. Reporters, artists, photographers and policernen were active among them. Shortly after 10:30, Mr. Morse came from the house and talked freely with a group of reporter<, He said it was a terrible thing to be suspected and shadowed as he had been, but he courts the fullest investigation and is anxious and willing to do all that he can to trace the perpetrators of the great crimes.

See moreSee less

[He sald Miss Lizzie Borden's health was in about the same condition as it was last Thursday afternoon. She did not mingle with the family to any great exteut. When Mr. Fish, of Hartford, a nephew of Ler stepmother, appeared, she gave him a cool reception. About 11 o'clock preparations were begun for the funerals. People numbering between 3,000 and 4,000 appeared on Secondst., in front of the house, and nbout twenty policemen stood around and maintained a clear passageway. The Rev. Dr. Adams, of the First Congregational Church, sud City Missionary Buck arrived and entered the houss, The bodies were in two plain black cloth-covered coflins in the sitting-room where Mr. Borden was killed, An ivy wreath was placed on Mr. Border's bier, and a bouquet of

See the clipping

In the story →

St. Paul Daily Globe · Saint Paul, Minn.

Officers investigating the Borden murders attempted to search Lizzie's room but she stood in front of the door and refused entry, delaying the search for hours. A full search of the house was finally conducted that afternoon, but no clinching evidence was reported found.

CorrectionThis set right 2 earlier articles: Morning Journal and Courier, 6 August 1892, The Providence News, 6 August 1892.

St. Paul Daily Globe · 7 August 1892 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

LIZZIE WAS FURIOUS,

And Prevented the Officers From Entering Her Room.

See moreSee less

FALL RIVER, Mass., Aug. 6.—An important fact in connection with the Borden double murder was developed today. An hour or more after the murder was discovered, two of the officers despatched to the scene undertook to make a search of the house. They looked over the first floor to some extent and then started upstairs. Lizzie Borden became aware of their efforts, and, as they reached the door of her room, she stepped boldly in front of the officers, exclaiming:

"Where are you going?"

"We are going to search this house and your room," replied the officers.

"You are not going into that room," said Lizzie, as she turned the key in the lock and stood determinedly in front of the door.

"We want to search that bureau and the closet in your room; don't you interfere," replied the officer.

"You have no right to enter my room, and I tell you you shall not. There is nothing there."

"It will be better for you, Miss Borden, to let us make the search."

Lizzie then became furious and barred the officers' progress, repeating that they should not enter. They did not, and if any evidence of crime existed in that room there has been ample time to remove it. There are no other developments in the case and no arrests have been made.

The first thorough search of the Borden residence was made this afternoon while the trial was in progress. From 2 o'clock until 6:30 the most searching investigation was made of every detail discovered since the crime was perpetrated. The search through the house was expected to develop many things, but at 7 o'clock tonight it was stated officially that no clinching evidence was obtained, and it is now impossible to say what turn the investigation will take.

See the clipping

Omaha Daily Bee · Omaha, Neb.

On the day of Andrew and Abby Borden's funeral, Lizzie appeared visibly shaken while Emma remained composed. Investigators were pursuing a new lead involving gypsy horse traders camped nearby who matched witness descriptions of a man seen near the Borden house.

Omaha Daily Bee · 7 August 1892 · page 4

Itordfii Mimloi-n. FAU , UIVEII , Mass. , Aug. 0. Tbo latest development In the Borden murders relating particularly to thu theory of poisoning lias given way today to the tall ? of the funeral , which took place this morniag. Miss Lls-zio and Miss Emma Bordcn were , of. course , tbo principal mourners. Miss Lizzie wont out of tlio house first loaning on the undertSlior's arm. She wns self-conscious , but her nerves ware completely upstrung , us was shown by tbo great trembling ot her body and the manner in which she bore down on her sup porter.

See moreSee less

When she reached her cnrnugo , she fell back exhausted on tno cushion. Miss Emma , the other sister , was much calmer , and walked quickly and took her saat with out hardly glancing nt the crowds staring nt bar. Miss Lizzie Borden Is a very pretty woman and quite lloshv. Her faca showed traces of the Intense suffering she had borna for thrco days. The latest clew being followed Involves a cnmp of gypsy-looking horse traders , camped on ttio outskirts , ono of whom answers the descriptions given bv tlireo persons of a man soon near the Harden house before the mui dor.

See the clipping

The Sun · New York, N.Y.

The article reports a theory that Lizzie Borden first poisoned her father and stepmother with prussic acid before fatally attacking their bodies, allegedly to mislead police. It also revisits conflicting accounts of a drug clerk who either refused or secretly sold her poison, while noting the house's proximity to police and busy streets.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day. CorrectionThis set right 2 earlier articles: The Portland Daily Press, 6 August 1892, The Portland Daily Press, 6 August 1892.

Wrong

The Sun · 7 August 1892 · page 2

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

See the clipping

The Sun · New York, N.Y.

This report describes the discovery of Andrew and Abby Borden's bodies, with details of their wounds and positions. It also recounts the pursuit of leads involving a suspicious stranger seen near the house, corroborated by multiple witnesses including a boy and a Frenchman, as well as scrutiny of John Morse's recent horse dealings.

CorrectionThis set right 2 earlier articles: Der Deutsche Correspondent, 6 August 1892, St. Paul Daily Globe, 6 August 1892.

The Sun · 7 August 1892 · page 2

resldence. The boy wont to his home on Cen tral street and told his father of the circum stance. Tho father was so Impressed .Vfltn tho story that ho notlflod Marshal Millard, whp nenttothohoy and heard what he hadKoaay. A significant thine Is that the boy cave tho sumo description of the man he hid aeon jump the fence as did tho young man who sawthe stranger standing onMr. Borden's donrateo on Monday morning The boy was particular In tho description of tho shoes and tho hat. as thoy struck him as tho most glaring part of tho man's drcas.

See moreSee less

This was exactly tho expo rlonco of tho man on Monday. Klerouack was rigidly examined by the police, and ho told such a straightforward story that the Mnrshal was convlncod that his statement was true. On tho way to New Bedford yesterday a Frenchman was found who told the following story: "Betwoen 12 UO and 1 o clock on Tliurs day I wnsdrlvlug along with my wood wagon In .'ront of Merchant Mill. A strange man itooM wnriiK Mils. ronncN v vs rovmn. Ur n from photoi-apli. stopped me and cllmbod In. llo had the appearance of being ngltnted. and asked mo to drivn him toward Wostport. at tho same time thruMInc 54 Into, my hands. He took tho reins and drovo tho hoise hltnseir. I havo a wood) nrd on .Icneko strcot. and I told tho fellow that I must stop there and got an other hore. as tho one wo. hnd was tired fiom a morning's li.ud work. My wife was In tho yard, and sho did not liko tho nppturanco of tlm htrangor. . . ... . . tr. i "She posltloly refused to let mo go to ent portwllh tho man. ami I gave him bnck his money and told him that I would not assist Tlin doscrlptlon of the man given by tho Fiencliman tallies with that glien by tho boy at tho polleo station and that of the young man who saw tho strnngor on Monday morning. ., . ,, Keutchors for Information concerning Morse reM'iilod tho fact that ho has been recently dealing in horses, nnd'it Is nllegod that ho re ceived a car load from the Vest and disposed or thom through other paitlos In tho vicinity ofWestport. . ... , ,.,., At the heid of tho rior. In Westport. is a camp of Itlnernnt horie traders, who havo been operating ill that iclnlty for threo weeks or more. Thoy go In ami out of Now Bed ford continually, and Morse has been seen to hno business with theso people. They enmo from the West, and aro hand ling tho horses repnitml to hnvo boon brought by Morso. In Dartmouth It was learned that Morso hail lioen representing hlmsolf as a nealthy horse trader. Ho boarded In tho un pretentious cottago of a native within a mile of the Western liorso tradors' camp. The searchers in Westport yesterday found the horse traders' camp and most of Its occu pants. Among them was a man who tills pre cisely the description of the man soon by tho boy on Thursday at noon, the young man on Monday morning, and tho Frenchman on Thursday afternoon. This man appeared to be the principal of the traders, and would not converse on any subjects othorlthan those per taining to horse tradingTwo 'ow Bedford detectivoa worked this clue all day. and tboy found that tho gam? had dono more or less trading in this city. They found a hardware store where a hatchet was purchased on Wednesday by one of the men from Westport. He paid $1.12 for the weapon, and the ciork givea a description like that glvon by tho Fall Blver people. This clue is being worked up. and tho gang of borso traders will bo called on to tell whore they were on Thursday. There are many who think It strnngo that Miss Lizzie Borden callod to tho servant, who had cono to the attle to wash some wlndous. when she discovered her dead father. But Miss Borden says she has an explanation on that point. After Bridget Sullivan had reached tho sit ting room In responso to the daughter's call, and after the arrival of a neighbor. Mrs. Churchill, the daughter went upstairs to boo If her mother waB in Uie house, and found hur dead body. Mr. Morso was not in tho house when the polleo got thero. He was the first suspect on that account. He had just ranched 1'all Blver after an absence of two years in the West, and had been nt the Borden houe only one day. Ho slept at tho Borden houso on Wednesday night and tho family breakfasted about 7 o'clock. At a quarter before 0 o'clock he left the houso and called on relatives at 7 Weybosset street. The family of Mr. Daniel Lmery. Miss Lmory. and a cousin. Miss Morse, entertained him at that houso until after 11 o'clock. Mrs. Kmery says It wob 11 :'J0 o'clock, and fixes tho time by hor delay in starting the preparations for dinner, upon Mr. Morse's departure. Mrs. hmony went to the store as soon as she could get her hat on after Mr. Morso left, and saw by tho clock In tho etoro that it was 11 :W o clock. Mr. Morse's nleco confirms this story, and Mrs. Horace O. Klngsloy. who resides in the first floor apartment, says that she saw Mr. Morse come to the house early in the fore noon, and that sho heard the trouble he had at the door to get in und saw him as he was going away. Hhe was getting fher dinner nt the time and It was after 11 o'clock, though she did not notice the exact hour. All these witnesses aro of unimpeachable veracity, and tholr testi mony completely absolves Mr. Morse from

See the clipping

The Sun · New York, N.Y.

This report describes the ongoing police investigation into the Borden murders, noting the absence of bloodstains or burned cloth despite the brutal nature of the killings. It also details the discovery of a sharpened hatchet in the cellar with a gray hair on its handle, which police sent to a chemist for blood analysis, while also noting no robbery occurred since valuables remained untouched.

CorrectionThis set right 2 earlier articles: The Morning News, 6 August 1892, The Providence News, 6 August 1892.

The Sun · 7 August 1892 · page 2

,W front n photograph takea three years ate 'fc aB' When the police reached tho house they g' K found tho old man Iving on tho lounge in tho ;jg Hx Kitting room, his head restingon a blood It? op soaked sofa pillow. Ills body wns yot warm, ( JnJund the blood was oven thon oozlnc from tho k '' wounds. IS s I'p stairs t liny found Mrs. Bordon lying nt fi '&' full length on tho tloor. hor face in a pool of .1 MjF, i blood. Her body waB also warm, but the blood t rag?

See moreSee less

' was coagulated nioro than that other hnsi TgE band. The wounds hud boen made by the j ;JEt same weapon, and It must bate boon dripping . ft with blood after each murder. Yetthorels not I & tin. tlnlett drop of blood on the caroets or w W n.ilrs between the two bodies. It follows, J ' therefore, that tho weapon must have been .'; M ulped off before being used on the second & W Malm. But no bloodstained cloth has been 6 - found, and noun was burned that day at the Ift ;S. 'Borden house, for tho aHhes have been care- & gfr fully Inspected, and no remnants of cloth were 5 j& found. Noltlier has any aeor hatchet been 1 W found which bears evldenco of having been Jj t used in the work. Vff The llrt thing tho police did was to hunt for f ft tho murderer and the weapon in the house. In W$?t tho celler tliey found an axe and two hatchets.

See the clipping

Pittsburg Dispatch · Pittsburg, Pa.

The Borden sisters' funeral took place amid continued investigation into the double murder, with Lizzie described as composed but strained. Police attempting to search the house reportedly were blocked by Lizzie at her bedroom door, while investigators also pursued a lead involving a band of itinerant horse traders seen near the house before the killings.

CorrectionThis set right an article from the day before.

Pittsburg Dispatch · 7 August 1892 · page 7

FALL RIVER'S MYSTERY.

acres tne Senate bill admitting certxin ves sels ot trans-Atlantic lines to American got no tanner. registry. JSone of these have become laws except rft self-conscious, but her nerves were com pletely unstrung. Miss Emma, the other sister, was much calmer. Lizzie is pretty aud quite fleshv. Her face showed traces of the intense suffering she had borne for three dav. The latest clew being followed involves a camp of itinerant and gipsy-looking horse traders camped ou the outskirts of town, one of whom answers to description given by three persons of a man seen near the Borden house before the murder.

See moreSee less

An hour or more after the murder was discovered, two of the officers dispatched to the scene undertook to make a search of the house. They looked over the first floor to some extent, and then started up stairs. Lizzie Borden became aware of their efforts, and 'as they reached the door ot her room, she stepped boldly in front of the officers, exclaiming: ' "Where are yon going?" "We are going to search this house and your room," replied the officer.

See the clipping

Pittsburg Dispatch · Pittsburg, Pa.

Investigators pursue a lead involving itinerant horse traders near Fall River after witnesses described a man resembling one seen near the Borden house. The report also describes Lizzie Borden initially blocking officers from searching her room, followed by a thorough search conducted during the funeral that yielded no clinching evidence.

Pittsburg Dispatch · 7 August 1892 · page 7

FALL RIVER'S MYSTERY.

declarations that they should not enter. They did not at that time, and if any evi dence of crime existed in that room there has been ample time to remove it. There arc no other developments in the c.ise, and no arrests have been made. The first thorouch search of the Borden residence was made this afternoon while the funeral was in progress. From 2 o'clock until 6:30 the most searching investigation was madeof every detail discovered sine'e the crime was perpetrated. The search through the house was expected to develop many thing", but at 7 o'clock to-night it

See the clipping

The Wilmington Daily Republican · Wilmington, Del.

Police in Fall River have not yet identified the murderer(s) of Andrew and Abby Borden, though various theories exist. John Morse, Emma Borden, and especially Lizzie Borden are under heavy suspicion, with hard feelings against Borden noted but no clear motive established.

The Wilmington Daily Republican · 8 August 1892 · page 1

Fall River's Murder Mystorj. Fall River, Mass., Aug. 8.—There theories in ubundance, but the police have not yet discovered the murderer or murderers of Andrew J. Borden, the wealthy hanker, and his wife Abby. John V. Morse, the dead man's brother in-law; Emma Borden and Lizzie Bor den, his daughters, are practically del arrest, particularly Lizzie Borden. The police have found fitting motive for the crime. Cause for hard feeling ugaii.st Borden there undoubtedly was, but its not such r'ould give rise source to the fiendish hatred evident in th« work of Thu reday.

See the clipping

Daily Kennebec Journal · Augusta, Me.

Investigators continue searching the Borden home for clues and have had two stains on a cellar axe tested, with experts confirming blood on one. Police have also established a timeline placing Andrew Borden's murder between 10:30 and 11:00 a.m., based on witness sightings and the servant's account of admitting him home.

Daily Kennebec Journal · 8 August 1892 · page 1

Fu.i Kiv»k. lug. n The Borden mys tery still remains unexplained. Hie par ticular business winch the detective* had on hand today was the careful searching of tin house for anything which tni*fbt furnish them w ith a dew to the murdere r. Medical cxjwrts tonight pronounced two stains found upon one of the axes taken from the Borden cellar to he Mood. I iwler a powerful microsco|*e one s|**i had the appearance of having lwen partially wiped off. and its original form and dej*th were partially affected. The other was more distinct and fur nished w hat is said to be satisfactory proof as to its composition.

See moreSee less

The police have fixed with certainty the time that Mr. Borden was murdered us be tween I0..10 and 11 .Od o'clock in the fore noon. and they assume that Mrs. Borden was killed just N forc that time. They arrive at their decision regarding the old gentleman by the following facts; It is known that Mr. Borden was talking to Mr. ( has. M. Horton at 10..’to o'clock, as they were seen together hv jhtsous on the Chace Mill car. that leaves City hall for Bedford and Quarry streets at 10.20. Tin car was standing in front of the building. After leaving Mr. Horton. Mr. Borden walked up South Maui street, stopping for a minute or two at his block, ami thc-n go ing through Borden street to Second to his home. The servant. Bridge t Sullivan, is

See the clipping

Daily Kennebec Journal · Augusta, Me.

The report pieces together Andrew Borden's movements before his death, including testimony from Bridget Sullivan about when she let him in and the timing of the alarm being raised. It also offers character sketches of Emma and Lizzie Borden, describing their social standing and personalities.

Daily Kennebec Journal · 8 August 1892 · page 1

STILL MYSTERY.

that he can recall clearly . The eloek at Hr. Bowen’s had struc k just before tin daughter Lizzie came to the door for doctor and Dr. Bowen, who was out when the rail was made, reached Mr. Borden's house at II. du. The murder was rejmrted within L*» min utes from the time that Mr. Borden i kuown to have been alive. In the more exclusive society of the city the Misses Kmina and Lizzie Borden a re

See the clipping

Daily Kennebec Journal · Augusta, Me.

The report describes Lizzie Borden's reputation as intelligent but haughty, and her family's social standing with sympathetic elite friends. It also details the physical layout of the Borden property and neighbors' accounts of seeing no one enter or leave the house before the murders were discovered.

Daily Kennebec Journal · 8 August 1892 · page 1

STILL MYSTERY.

tial friends desert them. Not a scream or a groan was beard com ing from Mr. Borden's mansion Thursday morning: neither did tinfamily living in the house north of tinBorden* sec anybody connout of the house at any time during th«- morning In-fore the murder hut Mr Borden himself. Mr. Borden left his holm-, alias been stated, about ** o'clock. Mr-. Churchill, who lives with her mother. Mr* I I*. Buf fington. across tinyard, watched Mr. Borden out of the yard. There i* a fence between the two houses, and Mrs.

See moreSee less

Buffington's kitclu-n windows lock over the fence into the yard, directly oppo site the side door, and not 2s feet from the Borden home. The barn is hut 20 feet be hind tinhome, and the distance from tin cast end of the house to the cast end of the barn is not more that *»o feet. Behind the barn is a fence e ight feet high, protected by a Imrbed wire* fence. This fence divides the Borden estate from that of Dr-d. B. Chagnon. whose home fronts on Third street, tin the re ar front of |)r. ( hagnon's place are half a dozen apple and peer tree* that -tand up against the fence that partitions the Borden estate from that of ('hagnon's. (in the south side of the Borden house is Dr. Kelly's residence. A low fe-nee-stands between. The Buffiugtcui house is on the north side. Miss Addie fheetliam lives with her mother ami Mrs Churchill with Mrs. Buf fington. All «f these person* were about their own houses all of Thursday morning. Miss Cheetham sat w riting a letter at H* o’clock nod at five minutes of II went to the postofBcc. She saw no one come out of tinBorden house during thetime shesat near the window fronting oti theBorden lawn. She eon Id hear the* si-le door bang if it ope ned at all. hut it did not. she says. Mr*. Churchill was about the house until III. 1 .*» A. M., when shewe-nt te» market. All agree that if there were any scream from inside the Borden house it would certainly Jm* heard by them. But they agreethat

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

As of August 8, no arrests had been made in the Borden murders, with reports that more organs and hair samples were sent to Boston for forensic analysis to compare with a white hair found on an axe. The article notes that many acquaintances defend Lizzie Borden's character and doubt she could have committed the murders, while also describing a failed attempt to photograph Mr. Morse at the funeral.

CorrectionThis set right an article from the day before.

The Providence News · 8 August 1892 · page 7

FALL RIVER'S MURDER MYSTERY. NO ARRESTS UP TO NOON. The Suspicions of Miss Lizzie Very Spongy.

music was indulged 10, the quartet, con tb:&:fln the Home. The public are sisting of Patrick MeGrath, bass, Lieuten o y lovited, . arge. maniacal, althongh it puzzles such theo rists to account for Par accustomed wan ner after the homicides. Miss Borden has, according to medical statements, been out of her mind at times, when otherwise well, but there does not seem as yet, to be enough sus

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

The report discusses theories about whether Lizzie Borden could have committed the murders while maniacal, noting medical statements that she had been out of her mind at times but insufficient suspicion to accuse her. It also describes an unsuccessful attempt to photograph Mr. Morse at the funeral, the bodies being placed in a receiving vault pending the poisoning theory, and a church sermon urging charity amid the accusations.

The Providence News · 8 August 1892 · page 7

The bodies lie in the rmlvlnf vault, whither they were cirried directly after the ceremonies, to await developments in regrd to the poisoning theory. iss Lizzie Borden is & member of the

See the clipping

In the story →

Waterbury Evening Democrat · Waterbury, Conn.

Police dug up the buried clothing of the Borden murder victims and spread it out for Medical Examiner Dolan to inspect, who removed hair samples before having it reburied. Despite searching the chimney and barn floor, officers found no new clues, and Dr. Dolan is expected to request an inquest during the week.

Waterbury Evening Democrat · 9 August 1892 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

FALL RIVER'S MYSTERY

Clews Followed Only to Come to Naught.

See moreSee less

THE HOUSE AGAIN SEARCHED.

An Inquest Will Probably be Held This Week—Emma and Lizzie Borden Prostrated—The Clothing of the Victims Dug Up and Examined.

FALL RIVER, Mass., Aug. 9.—The daughters of the murdered Mr. and Mrs. Borden are beginning to realize the awfulness of the suspicion resting upon Miss Lizzie and cannot control their feelings. The inmates of the house are all suffering from nervous prostration. The police are no nearer to a solution of the crime than they were last week. It seems as if this were one of those mysterious murders destined never to be cleared up.

The clothes worn by the victims, and which were buried in the yard, were dug up yesterday afternoon and spread out on the grass for the inspection of Medical Examiner Dolan. He picked from several parts of the clothes a quantity of hair from Mrs. Borden's head, which he placed in two lots and took it with him to his carriage.

He would say nothing as to the cause of resurrecting the clothing, but after making his examination he ordered it to be placed in a shoe case and buried four feet below the surface of the lot.

Yesterday's prolonged search did not result in any clews, nor did the officers at the conclusion feel that there was any cause for expecting more developments.

Portions of the chimney were dug away by a mason and the barn floor was torn up. Marshal Hilliard said the search was of value, in showing that whoever the assassin was his tracks were completely covered from view.

To-day the police have been at fever heat and have succeeded in running down seven out of nine clews.

Dr. Dolan will probably ask for an inquest during the week, as soon as he has an opportunity to formulate a complaint. The theory that the murder was committed by a man who was seen sitting on the garden fence half an hour before the murder was discovered has been exploded.

See the clipping

Evening Journal · Wilmington, Del.

Medical Examiner Dolan inspected clothing worn by the Borden victims that had been buried in the yard, removing hair samples from Mrs. Borden's garments before reburying the items. Police continued searching the house and barn without finding significant new evidence, though Marshal Hilliard noted the assassin's tracks appeared thoroughly concealed, and an inquest was expected soon.

Evening Journal · 9 August 1892 · page 2

SEARCHING FOR CLEWS

of Nervous Prostration—IIair Said to Have Ileen Found on One of the Axes. Fall River, Mas«., Aug. 9.—The ^ hes worn by the victims of the Horden nuiider Mid which wore b uric it in the yard were ting up and spread out on tho grass for the inspection of Medical Examiner Dolan. He picked from several parts of the clothes a quantity of hair from Mrs. Borden's head, which he placed in two lots and took with

See the clipping

Evening Journal · Wilmington, Del.

Investigators in the Borden case ruled out a man seen on the garden fence, identifying him as a mason's helper named Patrick McGowan who had an innocent reason for being there. Detectives also reported finding hairs on one of the hatchets discovered in the cellar, as the search of the property and barn continued.

Evening Journal · 9 August 1892 · page 2

NO NEARER A SOLUTION THAN EVER

complaint. One Theory Exploded. The theory that tho murder was commit ted by a man who was seen sitting on the garden fence half an hour before the mur ders were discovered has been exploded. The man seen by Mm. Nathan Chase pick ing peurs 1ms come to light. His name is Patrick McGowan, and he is n mason's helper employed by John Crowe. Mr. Crowe occupies a barn on Third street, in the rear of Dr. ICelly's house, which is tho u»xl one south of Borden's. The yard into which the man dropped when Mrs.

See moreSee less

Chase shook her garment at him is used by Mr. Crowe for the stornge of old lumber. State Detective Beaver and Detective Henry, of Providence, were looking for this man and found him. One of Mr. Crowe's men was engaged until 12 o'clock Thurs day dressing stone in this yard. He was Buuth of the barn, out of sight of the Bor den house, but no one could have jumped the fence into Crowe's yard and escaped his notice, though one could have escaped through tho Chognon yard. A secoml man was splitting wood at a woodpile nearer the Borden bouse, and from the place where he was working he

See the clipping

Evening Journal · Wilmington, Del.

Police reveal that hairs were found on one of the hatchets discovered in the Borden cellar under microscopic examination, while the household members show signs of nervous strain under suspicion. Bridget Sullivan and John Morse are shadowed by police, and a relative publicly speculates that Lizzie Borden and Morse conspired to hire the murder.

Evening Journal · 9 August 1892 · page 2

Illume. Linie Horden nnd Morse. HautvoI'.o, Aug. 9.—George B. Fish, of this city, whose wife is the sister of tho murdered Mr». Borden, of Fall River, in a published interview says that ho believes Lizzie Borden and J. V. Morse concocted the deed and biroi^ some one to do it. Lizzie and Emma Borden are stepdaughters of the murdered woman, and have never been on good terms with her, owing to troublo over the division of a small prop erty left by tbe girls' mother to Mr. Bor den, who gave it to the Becond wife iustead of the girls._

See the clipping

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

Medical Examiner Dolan examines the Borden victims' clothing, dug up from the yard, removing hair samples before reburying them. Police report that seven of nine clues have been disproven, including the suspicion of a man seen on the fence, now identified as a local mason's helper.

New-York Tribune · 9 August 1892 · page 4

THE FALL RIVER MURDERS. NO LIGHT YET SHED ON THE MYSTERY, MANY CLEWS PROVE WORTHLESS WHEN FOLLOWED UP BY THE POLICE.

MANY CLEWS PROVE WORTHLESS WHEN FOL. LOWED UP BY THE POLICE. Fall River, Mass., Aug. 8.—~The clothes worn by the victims of the Borden murder, and which were buried In the yard, were dug up this afternoon and spread out on the grass for the Inspection of Medical Examiner Dolan. He picked from several parts of the clothes a quantity of hair from Mrs. Borden’s head

See the clipping

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

Police dug through the barn and chimney in search of evidence, while detectives tracked down and cleared a man seen on the fence near the Borden property. A hatchet from the cellar was found to have two hairs on it under magnification, and Dr. Dolan is expected to request a formal inquest soon.

New-York Tribune · 9 August 1892 · page 4

FOLLOWED UP BY THE POLICE

Borden house, The yard into which the man dropped when Mrs. Chase shook her garment at him, 1s used by Mr. Crowe for the storage of old lumber. state Detective beaver and Detective Mcllenry, of Providence, were looking for this man and found him. McGowan says that while on the fence he saw no one in the Borden yard. Detective Seaver strates that one of the two batchets found In the cellar was examined under a powerful glass, and two hairs were found adhering to it. The inmates of the louse are all suffering from nervous prostration, Miss Idzzie and the servant girl particularly.

See moreSee less

The servant girl, Bridget Sullivan, spent most of yesterday with some friends, and also slept at thelr house. She returned this morning. In all her travels she was watched closely by a police. man. This afternoon Mr. #orse went down Secondst. Among the callers at the house was the Rev. J. walker Jubb, of the Central Congregational Chureh, who yesterday preached a sermon bearlug on the affalr, He made a pastor's call only.

See the clipping

Der Deutsche Correspondent · Baltimore, Md.

Fall River police again search the Borden home, checking chimneys and cellar but finding no new clues, while the axe found inside is sent to Boston for chemical analysis of stains on its handle. A relative, George B. Fish, voices his belief that Lizzie Borden and John V. Morse conspired to hire someone to commit the murders.

Der Deutsche Correspondent · 9 August 1892 · page 3

Der Doppelmord zu Fall-River

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

See the clipping

Daily Kennebec Journal · Augusta, Me.

Medical examiner Dolan had Mrs. Borden's buried clothing dug up and found hair samples, while searchers tore up the barn floor and chimney without finding new clues. Police also disproved the earlier theory that a man seen sitting on the fence was the killer, identifying him as a mason's helper named Patrick Mulowney (or similar) with a verified alibi.

Daily Kennebec Journal · 9 August 1892 · page 1

NO CLUE YET

in the yard. He was out of sight of the Borden house, and no oue could have jumped the fence into Crowe’s yard and escaped his notice. The man was splitting wood at a pile nearer the Borden house, and from the place where he w as working he could *ee the dividing fence. He remained in the yard until noon and saw no one jump the fence. Mid low an came to the yard between 11 and IV o’clock and waited a few minutes until sent out on a new job.

See moreSee less

While wait ing he went to the fence, and climbing upon some old fsatues, w as picking pears w hen Mr*. Chace saw him. When he dropped he disappeared from Mrs. Chace'* sight, but did not go between Mr. Crowe's barn and the chagnoi) fence, lie walked around the south of the barn, ami w as at once sent off on a new job. While on the fence he saw no one in the Borden yard. Detective Heaver state* that one of tin two hatchets found in the cellar was ex amined under a powerful glass, and two hairs found adhering to it. The inmate* of the house are all suffering from nervous prostration. Mis* Lizzie and the servant girl particularly. Late this afternoon Medical Kxamincr Dolan submitted the official report of the murder to Judge Hlaisdell. The latter took the paper*, promising to rea l them at the earliest moment, and set a date when the inquest can lie held.

See the clipping

Daily Kennebec Journal · Augusta, Me.

A witness's account of pear-picking near the Borden property is detailed to establish the layout and visibility around the yard, while police report finding no new evidence despite a thorough search of the house. A hatchet with hairs on it is sent for forensic examination, and a relative publicly speculates that Lizzie Borden conspired with John Morse to hire a killer.

Daily Kennebec Journal · 9 August 1892 · page 1

NO CLUE YET

Is In Existence. Fvi.i. Hiv 11:. Mas*.. August *. The |Nilice today went through the Borden house with great minuteness of investigation but found no trace of any evidence that would j lead to the detection of the author of the terrible tragedy. A guard is still kept about the house, hut ; the inmates are not interfered with in their j movements about the city. If. however, any attempt is made by them to leave; the city, arrest* will follow. If has been decided to send the suspicion* , axe to Boston for examination as to the character of the spot* on the handle.

See moreSee less

The date of the inquest has not yet In-en fixed. So far as the attorney and heirs of the Andrew .1. Borden estate kdow, there i* no j will in existence which dispose* of the de ceased* possessions. tieorge B. Fish of Hartford. Ct., whose ! wife is a -»i*t*-r of the murdered Mrs. Bor den of Fall River, in a published interview today . *ay* that he believe* Lizzie Borden and J. V. Morse concerted tiw* deed and hired some one to do it. Lizzie and Kinnm Borden are -fcj>dulighter* of the murdered woman and have never been on good terms , with Iter, owing to trouble over a division of a small property left by the girl * mother to Mr. Borden, who gave it to the second wife instead of the girl*.

See the clipping

Daily Kennebec Journal · Augusta, Me.

Despite thorough investigation, no evidence has been found to identify the murderer, though a guard remains at the house and the suspicious axe will be sent to Boston for analysis of spots on its handle. A relative by marriage publicly speculates that Lizzie Borden and John V. Morse conspired to hire someone to commit the murders, citing family tension over property.

Daily Kennebec Journal · 9 August 1892 · page 1

WHO DID IT?

The words of this article are printed with the report it shares its clipping with. Read them there or in the clipping.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

The Evening World · New York, N.Y.

The report describes Bridget Sullivan, the Borden family's servant, being summoned to the police station for questioning about the murders, appearing worried and pale. It notes that District Attorney Knowlton, Medical Examiner Dolan, Judge Blaisdell and detectives are handling the case, with Lizzie Borden expected to testify later that afternoon.

The Evening World · 9 August 1892 · page 1

WILL MURDER OUT?

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

See the clipping

The Sun · New York, N.Y.

Marshal Hilliard brought evidence including a bloodstained dress and an axe to a conference with District Attorney Knowlton, going through various theories before focusing on Lizzie Borden. No arrest was made that night, as officials decided to wait for testimony at the next day's inquest before deciding whether to charge anyone.

The Sun · 9 August 1892 · page 1

OF THE BORDEN HOUSEHOLD

took tho book diroctly to Chief Hilllard. Jl . The conforonoo was opened by Chlof of ro ll .'' "e0 Billiard. lto began with tho most tin 1 ' probable olue. lie went over It thoroughly, Mr ' and proved that it was valueless to tho sntlsfaction of Dlstrlot Attornoy Knowlton. It was "'- learnod that aluo nf ler cluo was taken up and H In turn tracod through to tho end. H Chief Hilllard reserved tho Lizzie Borden MM thoory until tho close. Ills purposo was to H ' disnrovo all othor theories and then suggest MM to tho District Attorney that tho Mzzie llorden

See the clipping

The Sun · New York, N.Y.

The report reveals that the mysterious stranger seen by Mrs. Chace and a French boy was merely a stone mason stealing pears, undermining an alternative suspect theory. Police argue that witnesses surrounding the house on all sides make it unlikely anyone could have entered or left unseen, strengthening suspicion against Lizzie Borden; the piece also notes a Pinkerton detective's visit amid rumors the family sought to prevent her arrest.

The Sun · 9 August 1892 · page 1

t the French boy in the street surI roundod the Borden house. No ono could 1 buvo entored the house by the rear , I door In the basement for the stone mason .xf stood within ten feet, nnd aside from that

See the clipping

The Sun · New York, N.Y.

The report describes tensions between police and the Borden family's hired Pinkerton detective, O.M. Hanscom, including a rumor that his presence was meant to prevent arrests. Police Chief Hilliard confirms an order temporarily barring Hanscom from the house was issued and then revoked, while defending the police investigation against the perceived interference of private detectives.

The Sun · 9 August 1892 · page 1

nttempt was mado to deny It, but this after noon tlio police ndmltled that It was true. Tho order was revoked this morning, and Mr. Hnnscom was allowed to etitor tho house. Chlof Hilllard. when seen this alter noon, tnid. "I did not give tho order, though 1 knew (he matter was bolng consid ered by tho elty authorities last night. In nny event, I see no reason why such orders aro not pioper at this time. Idonot believe there is nny reason why Mr. Hanscom, who Is nn ex pert detootlvp.

See moreSee less

and In the family's employ. Bhould havo access to the Borden house any more than tho reporters. The reporters nro working nshnrd to get nt the bottom of this case as lie Is. and no class nf unotllclnl Investi gators should bo discriminated against. hat ronson had the Borden clrls to on gngo detectives ? Are they nfruld that we will overstep the bounds of law In our Investiga tion of tho crime? If so why did thoy not com to us and show whote our acts nilulit soem nr may no inconsistent? 1 believe that the course pursued hits been taken to protoct the living. 1 hero lias been much labor and gi ent effort within tho past twenty four hours to create sympathy In that direc tion. In tho performance of my duty I do not forgot that there Is something due to the dead. Our purpose Is to bring the murdorer of Mr. nnd Mrs. Borden to justice, nnd our olTorts Will be rewarded." The police say thoy believe that Mr. Hans come's efforts will retard thoirwork. While It Is doubtful If tho police fear this yet It is n sig nificant fact that ns fast as the polico Hiiggest suspicious circumstances which might con nect Lizzie Bordon. just so fast nre thcsoelr cumstnnoos answered by Mr. Hanscom. Hlnco Mr. Hanscom has soen and talked with Llzzlo Borden her story has changed materi ally In several Important points, lor Instance, In her story, ns she first told It. she snld that sho wns In the barn not moro thnn twenty mlnutosMr. Hanscom now llxes It at half an hour. But why did Lizzie Bordon remain there thirty mlnutus ? Mr. Hanseom answers this by saying that the was hunting for tomo thing. But Mr. Hanscom adds thnt she was so weak nnd rambling in hor talk thnt he could not ask her about such points ns why she did not no tice her dand stepmother as she passed the door of tho room In which Mrs. Borden lay dead. If Lizzie Borden Is po weak and so rambling In hor mind thut she cannot nnswer perplexing questions llko thnt. bow Is It. nk the police, that she can explnln so minutely hor trip to the barn, and be so clear ubout cer tain other simple points? 1'eople hnv been commenting freolr to-day on tho work of the police. On Thursday, the day of the murder, there wns only n partial and Incomplete search of the Borden houso and premisos. There was no well organized hunt for any traces ot the murderer or tho in Rtiumcnt Friday passed and the polico made no effort to examine the houBe. Finally.on Saturday.a search Was made. The lawyer for tho Bordon girls, Mr. Jennings, nccorapanlod tho police about the place. On this search an axe was found in tho cellar which, tho police to-ttay said, had stains on it that were probably blood stains. This ne will bo sent to experts to examine. It wns said on good authority that a dross bolongiug to Llrzlo Borden was also found with n drop ut blood on it. But even Saturday's search was

See the clipping

Pittsburg Dispatch · Pittsburg, Pa.

This report describes the baffling nature of the Borden murders, noting no motive has been found since nothing was robbed or disturbed. It details the medical examiner's finding that Mrs. Borden was killed about an hour before her husband, and raises theories of drugging given the lack of any heard struggle.

Pittsburg Dispatch · 9 August 1892 · page 1

Drugged Possible Arrests. t6rrCIAL TZXEQalH TO TOT DISPATCH! Fami River, Mass., Aug. a The assassination of Millionaire Borden and his wife promises to become one of the most noted of modern murder mysteries. The discoveries and developments of each passing honr, instead of revealing the secret of the tragedy, only add to its weird and puzzling nature. No motive for the crime has yet been ascertained, Mr. Borden not being robbed, and nothing in the house being disturbed. There is still more to this. Neither the servant girl nor the people in the adjacent houses heard an outcry nor a sound of a struggle. Tet Mr. Borden was in fair

See the clipping

Pittsburg Dispatch · Pittsburg, Pa.

The report describes how neither the servant nor neighbors heard any struggle, and that medical evidence suggested Mrs. Borden was killed about an hour before her husband. It also details the discovery of the bodies and a secretive meeting among the District Attorney, police, and medical examiner.

Pittsburg Dispatch · 9 August 1892 · page 1

SPECIAL TELEGRAM TO THE DISPATCH

More remarkable than this even, the re sults of the investigation satisfied Medical Examiner Dolan that Mrs. Borden was killed at least an hour before her husband. This appears from the statement of Dr. Bowen, that when he arrived Mr. Borden's body was warm and the blood was flowing, but Mrs. Borden's body was cold and stiff During the hour that elapsed where was the murderer? He must have been concealed somewhere about the house. The murderer mu't, therefore, have stayed npoa the very scene of his first crime, not knowing what moment it might be discovered and he with it, though immediately after bis second murder be disappeared so amazingly that no one can guess bow he went. Remarkable sad Mysterious restores.

See the clipping

Pittsburg Dispatch · Pittsburg, Pa.

District Attorney Knowlton arrived in Fall River and met for five hours with police officials to review all evidence in the Borden murders. Investigators discussed Lizzie Borden's dress, a bloodstained ax, and a poison purchase register, concluding suspicion rested on Lizzie Borden but evidence was not yet sufficient for an arrest.

Pittsburg Dispatch · 9 August 1892 · page 1

SPECIAL TELEGRAM TO THE DISPATCH

A Judge Produces Some Papers. Judge Blaisdell, who presides over the court of this district, dropped in for a few minutes' talk with a big bulky envelope, and when be came out he had no envelope or papers with him. Dr. Dolan drove to a private entrance to Marshal Hilliard's office about 5 o'clock. He had with him a box covered with a lap robe. As he lifted the box from his carriage a bundle fell out It was Lizzie Borden's dress on which the police think there is a drop of blood. In the box among the other things was the ax

See the clipping

Pittsburg Dispatch · Pittsburg, Pa.

A belated search of the Borden premises uncovered an axe in the cellar with possible bloodstains, and reportedly a dress belonging to Lizzie Borden with a blood spot. Delays in examining the house and summoning the district attorney, as well as questions about why Lizzie remained free despite suspicion, are also noted.

Pittsburg Dispatch · 9 August 1892 · page 7

Borden house and premises. There was no well organized hunt for any traces of ths murderer or the instrument Friday passed and the police made no effort to ex amine the house. Finally, on Saturday, a search was mode. The lawyer for the Borden girls, Mr. Jennings, accompanied the police about the place. On this search an axe was found in the cellar which, the police to-day sold, had stains on it that were probably blood stains. This axe will be sent to experts to examine. It was said on good authority that a dress belonging to Lizzie Borden was also found

See the clipping

Pittsburg Dispatch · Pittsburg, Pa.

Police returned to the Borden house to search chimneys and fireplaces for evidence but found nothing, while critics questioned delays in contacting the district attorney and why Lizzie Borden had not been arrested despite suspicion. The report also examines the house's layout, arguing it would have been nearly impossible for an outside murderer to escape unseen given witnesses at nearby windows and the busy street.

Pittsburg Dispatch · 9 August 1892 · page 7

Wondering Why Llrxle Is Free. People also ask why, if it Is true, as tha police, say there is little or nothing in the clews apart from those connecting Lizzie Borden, she has not been arrested. The po

See the clipping

Pawtucket Tribune · Pawtucket, R.I.

Officials in Fall River held an overnight conference deciding to arrest Lizzie Borden if she tried to leave the house, with a warrant already drawn up. Bridget Sullivan would likely be held only as a witness, while orders for John Morse remained unchanged.

Pawtucket Tribune · 9 August 1892 · page 1

NEARING A CLIMAX

tances, Besides Willlam H. Grimes of this city she had several other sons, of whom Thomas and Joseph Grimes of Providence are well and favorably known throughout the State. Her funeral will take place Thursday morning from Bt. Charles’ Church, Woon socket, where a requiem high mass will be cclebrated, and interment will take place in Woouasocket also. bouse, he '; to 7 allowed to do ot.bn he was not go far away, and I at temmw leave town, he was to be placed fo tion house at once. The orders regarding Morse were the same as have been svanding since the murder; those in regaxd to the women were given out last night.

See moreSee less

For Lizzle Borden a warrant has heen made oat. The eervant girl, Bridget Sul fivan, will probably be only as a witness, It cabnpt be learned whether a document like shat made out for Lizzle has or has not been Issued for Morse,but it probably has not. A oonference at the Mellen House, a continuation A the session commenced under exciting ausplces at ¢ o'clock yes terday afternoon, was in session up to

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

A man claiming to be a detective arrested two young men in Providence for the Borden tragedy, but police grew suspicious and investigated. He was found to be insane, believing he had divine authority to track the Borden family, and was taken away by relatives.

The Providence News · 9 August 1892 · page 1

TO SOLVE THE BORDEN MYSTERY

ries of the youn« men, He was informed as to the causes lead ing to the arrest, and then after a conver sation with the man claiming to be a de tective, came to the copnclusion that he was an impostor. The man gave his name as Guunson, and said that he was emrloyod on the New York police force. He was locked up and a shoet sime later Dr. Palmer examined him as to his sanity., IThe physician came to the con clusion that tne man was incurably in sane. He labored under a delusion that he had been delegated by divine authority to trace out the members of the Borden family in Fall River. Eveatually he was held iu confinement. The young men

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

The official inquest into the Fall River murders began, with Judge Blaisdell presiding and District Attorney Knowlton present. Bridget Sullivan was the first witness, giving a straightforward account of her whereabouts the day of the murders.

The Providence News · 9 August 1892 · page 1

the court stenograpber. Bridget Sullivan :u the first witness examined, The girl bore up well under the trying ordeal. She was minutely and carefully exam ined as to her whereabouts on tue fatal Thursday, and when she last saw Mr. Borden. To all the questions she gave straightforward replies. At times she seemed syvercome with emotion, but after & short delay was able

See the clipping

Alexandria Gazette · Alexandria, D.C.

John V. Morse, uncle of the Borden sisters, refused to comment on a Hartford man's theory that he and Lizzie Borden conspired to hire someone to kill the elder Bordens, calling it absurd. Meanwhile, servant Bridget Sullivan was brought in for intensive questioning by police about events before and after the murders.

Alexandria Gazette · 9 August 1892 · page 2

Fish, of Hartford, that he (Fish) be? lieved that Miss Lizzie Borden and Mr. Morse concocted the murder of the old couple and hired some one to do it, said that his counsel had advised him to havo nothing to say for publication. He added, however, "You know as well as I do what grounds there are for such an absurd charge as that. It is en? tirely unreasonable. That is all I will say," This morniug Bridget Sullivan, the servant girl in the Borden family, was summoned to the central police station.

See moreSee less

Miss Sullivan was brought before the men to undergo a thorough examination as to the facts before and after the murders as far as she knew them. While the servant Avas in the court room locked up with the authori? ties Mr. J. V. Morse was walking along through Main street and down to the hanks closely followed by an officer.

See the clipping

Morning Journal and Courier · New Haven, Conn.

The inquest into the Borden murders continued before Judge Blaisdell, with District Attorney Knowlton separately questioning Bridget Sullivan and Lizzie Borden, though neither examination was completed. Attorney General Pillsbury arrived during proceedings, and rumors circulated of a bloody axe being found, while tensions grew between the servant and the daughters.

Morning Journal and Courier · 10 August 1892 · page 3

THE INQUEST HELD.

Found The Family Are Saylns Hard Thing. About tbe Two Cilrla. Fall KivKR.Maas'., Aug. 9. Tbe follovflng was to-nlgtt given pat by State Die teotlve Sewer: The irj'neat Into the Borden murder be fore Judge Blaisdell began at 10 o'clock a. m. District Attorney Knowlton oondnoted the examination. Bridget Sullivan and ias Lizzie Borden were questioned sep arately. The examination of neither was concluded. This inquest adjourned until 10 a. m. Wednesday. Nothing was de veloped for publication. The meagre re port was all that was given out officially regarding the four days' proceedings of the inquiry.

See moreSee less

After adjournment Bridget Sul livan was taken from the Central station. She was accompanied by Officer Doherty and went to No. 80 Division street, where she has refatives. She has hardly eaten or slept at the Borden house since the tragedy. District Attorney Knowlton told her that he regarded her as the most important wit ness in the case and promised to allow her to go on her own recognizance nntil the trial, if one takes place,provided she wonld not go away without first acqnainting the city marshal. While the principal parties at the inquest were at dinner Bridget, or Maceie as sbe was caiieacat nome, was placed in charge of Matron Russell, whose fins are sealed. The girl told the whole of her story to Mrs. Russell, often saying she could not tell all before, as there were so many men about. At 2 o'clock while Bridget was walking upstairs to the court room she was crying bitterly. Mies Borden was not examined very

See the clipping

Morning Journal and Courier · New Haven, Conn.

Authorities including Attorney-General Pillsbury, Marshal Hilliard, and chemists met in secret consultation at the Mellen house as stomach analysis continued, with officials admitting doubt over whom to arrest. The report also covers a rumored bloody axe find, family tensions over funeral arrangements, and a suggestive hint from Dr. Handy about a mysterious man seen near the Borden house.

Morning Journal and Courier · 10 August 1892 · page 3

THE INQUEST HELD

Professor ood, the Harvard chemist, Dr. Mackenize of this city and Dr. Dolan joined the other officials at the Mellon house. Attorney-General Pillsbury started for Boston on the 4:50 train. Before going he declined to say anything about the murder case. After his departure there was more seorecy than ever among the authorities. The analysis of the stomachs has not been completed yet and probably will not be for some days longer. It is said Dr. Wood was called here to assist, if possible, in giving some information whioh would justify the officials iu serving warrants.

See moreSee less

At the pres ent time the officers are in (rreat donbt about how to proceed. An officer who is very close to the head of the department said, he had no doubt of the ultimate arrest of some tine in the family, but which one he would not or oonld not say. After ad journment of the inquest Miss Borden was taken in a carriage to her home on Seoond street, accompanied by Mrs, Bingham and City Marshal' Hilliard. The servant girl will not be required to sleep in the Borden house again. . Her nerves are greatly shattered. To-night at 7:30 a rumor gained credence at the station that a bloody axe had been found at South Somerset in a house ocoupied by some Portuguese farm hands. Policemen were sent to investigate the case and have not returned. . The members or tne family are saying hard things concerning relations between the Misses Borden and their step mother. One woman has found much fault because the casket in which Mrs. Borden's body was encased was so plain ; also because one of the young women wore flowers in her hat at the funeral. Hiram Harrington, Mr. Borden's brother-in-law, whoBe strong state ments recently pnbllBnea were about as surprising as those sent out from Hartford, denied to-night to the Associated Press reporter that be bad any bard reel ing against the two girls. At various times, he says, he befriended them and he naa never in any way qnarreiea witn tnem. He and Mr. Borden had frequent differ ences of opinion and latterly they had not been on speaking terms, un tne nignt pre ceding the funeral he and Miss Lizzie had short conversation, which was not friendly on the young woman's part.

See the clipping

Morning Journal and Courier · New Haven, Conn.

A doctor reported seeing a ghastly-looking, agitated man with a black mustache near the Borden house on the morning of the murders, prompting police interest. Officers traced a suspect, tailor Thomas P. Walker who had a grudge over rent, but found he had a solid work alibi and could not have committed the crime.

Morning Journal and Courier · 10 August 1892 · page 3

BIS FACE LOOKED GHASTLY. To-night's News says: "Dr. Handy fur nishes a very suggestive hint as to the probable murderer of Mr. and Mrs. Bor den. He says that about 10 a. m. on Thurs day he saw a man standing on Second street, a little south of the Borden resi dence, the man having such, a terribly unusual - appearance as to attract bis attention: The stranger was ghastly white and seemed very much agitated. His eyes were particularly wild. He wore a Bmall black moustache. The doctor could certainly identify the man he observed, as he was so struck by his des perate looking character that he tnrned around his carriage and gazed at him for a considerable time.

See moreSee less

Late this evening the polioe began to put some credence in this rumor, as it was said that a man answering this description was seen' by U nicer Hyde about tne same time, ur ficers Doherty and Harrington ran down the "Getfant story. It appears that one' Thomas - P. Walker, a tailor working f or . ;, John Carey, - owed ; Mr. Borden a months rent .tor a house on Fourth street. When, asked Jto pay Walker used threatening language On the day of the murder Walker worked steadily from 7 in the morning until 13 and could not possibly have been near the Borden home stead." At a meeting of the board of aldermen to-night this order was passed: Inasmuch as terrible crime has been committed in our city, requiring an in creased number of men to do polioe duty, it is bereby ordered that tbe city marshal be and he is hereby directed to employ such constables as he may deem necessary for the detection of the criminals.

See the clipping

Waterbury Evening Democrat · Waterbury, Conn.

The inquest into the Borden murders began before Judge Blaisdell with District Attorney Knowlton conducting questioning of Bridget Sullivan and Lizzie Borden separately, though neither examination was concluded. Officials released only a brief bulletin stating nothing was developed for publication, while the report notes speculation that an arrest of a family member is expected.

Waterbury Evening Democrat · 10 August 1892 · page 2

Fall River, Mass., Aug. 10. The f ol lowing bulletin was last night given out by State Detective Seaver: The inquest into the Borden murder began before Judge Blaisdell at 10 a m., District-Attorney Knowlton conducting the investigation. Bridget Sullivan and Lizzie Borden were questioned separately, The examination of neither was conclnd ed. The inquest adjourned until 10 a. m. Wednesday. Nothing was developed for publication." This meagre report is all that is given out officially regarding the first day's pro ceedings of the inquiry. First Bridget Sullivan, the servant girl in the Borden family, was summoned to the Central Police station, bhe walked down in company with an officer and talked quite freely on the way.

See moreSee less

She looked very much worried and was quite pale as compared with her appear ance last Thursday morning, when seen first by a reporter. She told the omcer that it was very hard to be watched so closely and to have one's private affairs torn to pieces. She was willing, however, to have the police or any one else examine her every action since the time she arose Thursday until she was asked to go to the Police Station with the officer. She did not care to talt very mucn about the details of the family relations. She said that she wanted to leave two or I three times but she was urged to remain by Mrs. Borden, of whom she spoke very kindlv.

See the clipping

Waterbury Evening Democrat · Waterbury, Conn. · and 1 other paper

Servant Bridget Sullivan was brought before officials including the District Attorney and Medical Examiner for examination about events before and after the murders, while Lizzie Borden was served a subpoena and taken to the Central Police Station amid large crowds. The stomach analysis results were not yet complete, and officials remained uncertain about issuing warrants.

Waterbury Evening Democrat · 10 August 1892 · page 2

THE PROCEEDINGS KEPT SECRET.

lowed by an officer. Miss Lizzie Borden was brought to the Central Police station in the afternoon in a hack containing Marshal Billiard, Offi cer Harrington aud Mrs. James W. Bing ham." Miss Borden was served with a subpoe na summoning her to attend at an in quiry at the Second District Uourt, to de termine the cause of the death of her father and mother. Mrs. Bingiinm was visiting Miss Borden and consented to accompany her at the request and consent of Marshal Bil liard. The stopping of the carriage at the Bor den homestead was followed by the gath ering of a great crowd.

See moreSee less

As Miss Borden stepped 111 the people surged forward and caused lively work for the policeman lu keeping them back. The drive to the station was very rapid and was through crowds of people on both sidewalks. At the police station this crowd was greatly augmented and the police court alley was filled with curious business men and loiterers. Miss Bordon was conducted through the guard room oil the second floor where the court sits, fche wns dressed in a well-litting suit of black covered with lace. Site paid no attention to the persons around her. Her face looked worn and worried. Miss Borden was not examined very closely at yesterday s proceedings. The analysis of the stomachs has not been completed yet, and probably will not be for several days longer. Xt is said that Dr. Wood was called here to assist. if possible, in giving some information which would justify the officials in serv ing warrants. At the present time the officers are in great doubt about how to proceed. An officer, who is very close to the head of the department, said this morning, that he had no doubt of the ultimate arrest of some one in the family, but which one he would not or could not say. After the adjournment of the investiga tion Miss Borden was taken in a carriage to her home on Second street, accom panied by Mrs. Bingham and City Mar shal Hilliard. The servant girl will not be returned to sleep in the Borden house again. Her nerves are completely shat tered.

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • The Evening Herald · Shenandoah, Pa. · 10 August 1892

Waterbury Evening Democrat · Waterbury, Conn.

Lizzie Borden was brought to the police court for continued inquest proceedings, dressed in black lace, appearing worn and worried. Officials remain uncertain how to proceed, awaiting stomach analysis results, though one officer predicts an arrest within the family will eventually occur.

Waterbury Evening Democrat · 10 August 1892 · page 2

father and mother. Mrs. Bingiinm was visiting Miss Borden and consented to accompany her at the request and consent of Marshal Bil liard. The stopping of the carriage at the Bor den homestead was followed by the gath ering of a great crowd. As Miss Borden stepped 111 the people surged forward and caused lively work for the policeman lu keeping them back. The drive to the station was very rapid and was through crowds of people on both sidewalks. At the police station this crowd was greatly augmented and the police court alley was filled with curious business men and loiterers.

See moreSee less

Miss Bordon was conducted through the guard room oil the second floor where the court sits, fche wns dressed in a well-litting suit of black covered with lace. Site paid no attention to the persons around her. Her face looked worn and worried. Miss Borden was not examined very closely at yesterday s proceedings. The analysis of the stomachs has not been completed yet, and probably will not be for several days longer. Xt is said that Dr. Wood was called here to assist. if possible, in giving some information which would justify the officials in serv ing warrants. At the present time the officers are in great doubt about how to proceed. An officer, who is very close to the head of the department, said this morning, that he had no doubt of the ultimate arrest of some one in the family, but which one he would not or could not say. After the adjournment of the investiga tion Miss Borden was taken in a carriage to her home on Second street, accom panied by Mrs. Bingham and City Mar shal Hilliard. The servant girl will not be returned to sleep in the Borden house again. Her nerves are completely shat tered.

See the clipping

The Morning Call · San Francisco, Calif.

Lizzie Borden is placed under police surveillance and briefly held before being released on condition she not leave the city; the inquest begins, with her and servant Bridget Sullivan questioned separately but not concluded. A local doctor also reports seeing a ghastly, agitated stranger near the Borden house on the morning of the murders.

The Morning Call · 10 August 1892 · page 1

THE FALL RIVER MYSTERY

Murdered Couple. Fall Kiver, Mass., Aug. 9.— Miss Lizzie Borden, who is looked upon with suspicion in reference to the Borden murder case. is under strict surveillance by the police. This afternoon she was taken to the police station, but later tho District Attorney told her that she might go if site promised not to leave the city without first acquainting the City Marshal. The inquest began this afternoon. Bridget Sullivan, a domestic, and Lizzie Borden wero questioned separ ably. Tne examination of neither was con cluded and the inquest adjourned until to morrow.

See moreSee less

Bridget Sullivan was. placed in charge of Matron Bussell. Dr. Handy says regarding the probable murderer of Mr. and Mrs. Borden that on Thursday morning lie saw a man near the Borden residence of unusual appearance, being ghastly white aud very agitatedThe police are now investigating.

See the clipping

The Record-Union · Sacramento, Calif.

Lizzie Borden, suspected in the Fall River murder case, was taken to the police station but released on promising not to leave the city without notice. The inquest began, with Bridget Sullivan and Borden questioned separately before adjourning until the next day.

The Record-Union · 10 August 1892 · page 1

BORDEN* MURDER MYSTERY. Lizzie Borden Under Strict Surveil lance by the Police. Fall River (Muss.), Aug. 9.—Miss Lizzies Itorden, who is looked upon with suspicion in reference to the Borden mur der case, is under strict surveillance by | the police. This afternoon she was taken to the police station, but later the District j Attorney told her that she might go if j she promised not to leave the city with j out first acquainting the City Marshal. The inquest began this afternoon. Bridget i Sullivan, a domestic, and Lizzie Borden ! were questioned separately. The ex | animation of neither was concluded, and i the inquest adjourned until to-morrow. Bridget Sullivan was placed in charge of 1 Matron Russell. THE RECORD-UNION.

See the clipping

In the story →

Evening Journal · Wilmington, Del.

More than a hundred hours after the murders, police officials subject Lizzie Borden and servant Bridget Sullivan to intense questioning, having apparently failed to solve the case through other detective work. Officials including Marshal Hilliard, District Attorney Knowlton, state detectives, and the medical examiner confer in secret about the investigation's progress.

Evening Journal · 10 August 1892 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

MISS BORDEN'S ORDEAL

She Is Rigidly Examined at the Coroner's Investigation.

See moreSee less

THE SERVANT ALSO ON THE RACK.

Secrecy Maintained by the Officials as to the Result of the Investigation—Some Glaring Discrepancies in the Stories Told by the Daughter of the Victims.

FALL RIVER, Mass., Aug. 10.—Here—more than one hundred hours after the ax did its awful execution—there is no one bold enough to place his hand on man or woman and say: "I arrest you on suspicion of having murdered Andrew J. Borden and Abby Borden, his wife, on Aug. 4. You must come with me."

After several days of seeming lethargy the police officials have at length begun active steps toward the unraveling of the mystery that surrounds the murder, and they subjected to an inquisitorial examination Lizzie Borden and Bridget Sullivan, the servant. What it all means no one can tell with certainty, but it looks very much as though Marshal Hilliard and his aids were trying the effects of a bulldozing process, known in New York city police circles as "working the third degree." It is quite certain that finding the mystery surrounding the terrible crime beyond their detective ability, they have determined to make the suspected people themselves furnish the testimony which they have failed to gather.

The decided step taken was the outcome of a conference. Marshal Hilliard, District Attorney Knowlton, State Detectives Rhodes and Levear and Medical Examiner Dolan were closeted for some time in the marshal's office, and adjourned to meet later in a parlor of the Mellon House, where they remained behind locked doors until an early hour in the morning.

MRS. BORDEN.

During that protracted session every minute scrap of evidence that had been accumulated by the police was carefully examined, and a close comparison was made of the statements of different persons.

Miss Borden Contradicted.

Lizzie Borden's claim that she had discovered the dead body of her father after her visit to the barn, where she had gone for the purpose of making some sinkers to be used in a fishing excursion, was contradicted by a policeman, who declares that he carefully examined the barn loft on the day after the murder, and that he distinctly remembers that the thick dust on the floor was undisturbed by any footprints but his own.

The apparent inconsistency on the part of the young woman may be explained by the

MISS LIZZIE BORDEN.

fact that in the excitement following the discovery of the murders she had forgotten where she had gone for the lead.

A point that is not so satisfactorily settled is the disposition of the letter which Lizzie says was received by Mrs. Borden that morning, calling her to the bedside of a sick friend. The most careful search has failed to reveal any traces of that important epistle. Scraps and shreds of paper have been carefully gathered and pieced, but to no avail.

Miss Borden has on different occasions given the time of her absence from the house in the barn as 10:20 and 10:30 a. m., and the police look upon the discrepancy as serious. The police still believe that she tried to buy prussic acid at Smith's drug store, which she still positively denies.

An important piece of evidence submitted to the district attorney by the marshal was the distances between the scene of the tragedy and the adjoining houses, showing that the noise of any violent struggle must have been heard by the neighbors, as well as by Lizzie and the servant.

During the search conducted on Sunday a piece of lead pipe was found in the yard about five feet from the barn. Whether or not this is the metal from which Lizzie was going to make the sinkers has not yet been proved.

Rigidly Questioned.

When Marshal Hilliard drove up later to the Borden residence and told Miss Lizzie that she was wanted she displayed not the least sign of emotion, but asked only that a friend and old schoolmate, Mrs. George Brigham, who was in the house at the time, be permitted to go with her. The marshal assented and the women were driven to headquarters, followed by a curious crowd of men and boys. As they stepped from the carriage Lizzie looked around at the crowd without displaying the least sign of discomposure.

For four hours she was subjected to a rigid questioning. Professor Wood, to whom had been subjected for analysis the viscera of the murdered couple, and Attorney General Pillsbury were present, but did not remain long and drove off together. It was not until 6 o'clock that Miss Borden's ordeal was ended for the day and she was taken to her home, and Marshal Hilliard's double guard was put on the house to prevent the escape of any of the suspected people. Bridget Sullivan, who had not been permitted to see her mistress, was taken to the home of a friend, Mrs. Patrick Harrington, of 95 Division street.

Professor Wood, before leaving the city, was seen by a reporter, to whom he admitted to the best of his belief the stains on the rags gathered from the cellar of the Borden house during the search on Sunday were human blood. These rags were found under an upturned pail. That they were remnants of a garment has not, however, yet been settled.

See the clipping

Evening Journal · Wilmington, Del.

More than four days after the murders, Fall River police are pressuring suspects for testimony after admitting they lack strong evidence. Officials highlight contradictions in Lizzie Borden's story, including disputed footprints in the barn loft, an untraceable letter, inconsistent timing of her absence, and her denial of trying to buy prussic acid.

Evening Journal · 10 August 1892 · page 2

cal Examiner Do ^ ? lan were closeted for some time iu the niarsiml's of. y r flee, nnd ut j. mied to meet later in a parlor of the Mel 3^x Ion House, where •fij ^ they remained be ■Vvy ' f hind locked doors mv •* uutil an early hour in tho morning. MUS BORDEN. During that protracted session every mimito scrap of evidence that hud been accumu lated by the police was carefully examined, and a close comiisrison wns made of the statements of different persons. Contradicted. Ml,, l!ord< Lizzie Borden'R claim that she had dis covered the demi body of her father after her visit to the burn, where she lmd gone for the purpose of making some sinkers to be used in a Halting excursion, was contra dicted by a policeman, who declares that lie carefully examined tbo barn loft on the day after the murder, and thnt he distinctly remembers that the thick dust on the floor was undisturbed by utiy footprints but hiB own.

See moreSee less

The apparent Inconsistency on the part of the young woman tuny ho explained by ths 1

See the clipping

Evening Journal · Wilmington, Del.

Police investigate discrepancies in Lizzie Borden's account of her time in the barn and continue to suspect she tried to buy prussic acid, which she denies. A lead pipe and blood-stained rags are found during searches, and Lizzie undergoes a four-hour interrogation at police headquarters before returning home under guard.

Evening Journal · 10 August 1892 · page 2

ltlgidly Guest toned. When Marshal Hilliard drove up later to the Borden residence and told Miss Lizzie that she was wanted she displayed not tho least sign of emotion, but asked only that a friend and old schoolmate, Mrs. George Brigham, who was ln the house at the time, be permitted to go with her,' The marahai assented and the women were driven to headquarters, followed by a curious crowd of men and boys. As they stepped from the carriage Lizzie looked around at the Wtrwd without displaying the least sign of jiacompœure.

See moreSee less

For four hours she Was subjected to a rigid questioning. Professor Wood, to whom bad beeu subjected for analysis the viscera of the murdered couple, and Attorney Gen era! PiUsbury were present, but did not ro main long and drove off together. It was pot until 6 o'clock that Miss Borden's or deal was ended for the day and she was taken to her home, and Marshal Hilliard's double guard was put on the bouse to pre vent the escape of any of the suspected people. Bridget Sullivan, who had 1 • I • T been permitted to see her mistress, was

See the clipping

The Wilmington Daily Republican · Wilmington, Del.

Bridget Sullivan, the Borden family's servant, was examined by police and officials about facts before and after the murders. Lizzie Borden was then served a subpoena and brought to the police station amid large crowds to attend the inquest into her parents' deaths.

The Wilmington Daily Republican · 10 August 1892 · page 1

Blaiadell at tne suggestion of District Attorney Knowlton. A few hours later Miss Lizzie Borden was brought to the central police station in a hack containing Marshal in Hilliard, Officer Harrington and Mrs. Jathes W. Bingham. Miss Borden was served with a

See the clipping

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

The Fall River inquest into the Borden murders began, with servant Bridget Sullivan questioned closely by police and prosecutors about the household's movements before and after the killings. Lizzie Borden was later served a subpoena and brought to the police station by Marshal Hilliard and others to testify as well.

New-York Tribune · 10 August 1892 · page 5

THE FALL RIVER TRAGEDY. INQUEST IN THE BORDEN MURDERS BEGUN.

Qultivan, the servant girl in the Borden family, was summoned to the Central Police Station. She walked down In company with an officer and talked quite freely on the way. She looked much worried and was quite pale. She told the officer that it was hard te be watched so closely and to have one's private affairs torn In pieces. She was willing, however, to have the police know just what her movements were nce the time :zhe arose on Thursday until she was asked to go to the police station with the officer, She did not care to talk much about the details of the family relations.

See moreSee less

She said that she wanted to leave two Or three times, but she was urged to remain by Mrs. Borden, of whom she spoke kindly, She was taken ab once into the Clty Marshal's presence, and also ioto and the presence of Distrct-Awtorndgy Kuowlton Medical Examiner Dolan. Miss Sullivan WARS brought before the men to undergo a thorough examination as to the facts before and While after the murders as far as she knew them. the servant was In the court room locked up with the authorities, J. V. Morse was walking along through Main-st. and down to the banks, closely followed by an officer. Miss Lizzie Borden was brought to the Central Police station this afternoon in a hack edntaining Marshal Hilliard, Officer Harrington and Mrs, James W. Bingham. Miss Borden was served with a sub poena summoning her to attend at an inquiry at the second District Court, to determine the cause of the death of her father and mother, Mrs. Bingham was visiting Miss Borden at the time, and she consented to accompany her, For the first time since the murders occurred, the Marshal appeared in full uniform. The stopping of the carriage at the Borden homestead was followed by the gathering of a great crowd. As Miss Borden stepped tn the people surged forward and caused lively work for the policeman in Kkeepiug them back. The drive to the station was rapid and was through erowds of people on both sidewalks, Miss Borden and her companton were conducted through the guard-room on the second floor where the court sits, and ghe passed through a gaping crowd of policemen. she dressed In a well fitting sult of black, was covered with lace. She pald no attention to the per sons around her: her face looked worp and worrled, The private Inquiry in the second District was an tnquest ordered by Judge Blalsdell, at the suggestion of District-Attorney Knowlton, as a result of a midnight conference of the authorities, scarch is being made for the prescription which Dr. Bowen gave to the family when the members were il & week ago toduy. Attorney-Genemd Pillsbury has arrived In town, presumably on business in connection with the Borden CAses, The following bulletin was given out to-night bY rtate Detective seaver!: The inquest into the Barden murder began 'befors Judge Blaisdell at 10 a. m., District-Atiorney Knowlton conduct.

See the clipping

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

Lizzie Borden and Bridget Sullivan were brought separately before District Attorney Knowlton for a secret inquest ordered by Judge Blaisdell into the deaths of Andrew and Abby Borden. The examination of neither witness was completed, and the inquest was adjourned until the next morning with no details released to the press.

New-York Tribune · 10 August 1892 · page 5

EXAMINATION NOT FINISHED.

The words of this article are printed with the report it shares its clipping with. Read them there or in the clipping.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

The inquest into the Borden murders began before Judge Blaisdell with District Attorney Knowlton questioning Bridget Sullivan and Lizzie Borden separately, though neither examination was completed before adjournment until Wednesday. Attorney General Pillsbury arrived in town and conferred with officials including Harvard analyst Professor Wood, amid secrecy over stomach analysis results and uncertainty about whether to issue arrest warrants.

New-York Tribune · 10 August 1892 · page 5

EXAMINATION NOT FINISHED

Blaisdell at 10 a. m., District-Atiorney Knowlton conduct. ing the investigation, Bridget Sulltvan sod Lizzle Borden were questioned separately. The examination of neither was concluded. The Inquest adjourned updl 10 a. In. Wednesday. Nothing was developed for publication. This meagre report was all that was glven out officially regarding the frst day's procesdings of he tnquiry. After adjournment Bridget Sullivan was taken from the Central Station, She was accompanied by Officer Doherty, and went to No. =0 Division-st., where has relatives. She hardly enden oF she has slept at the Boren house since the tragedy.

See moreSee less

DistrictAttorney Knowlton told her that he regarded her as | the most Important withess In the case, and promisod to allow her to go on her own recognizance until the she Would not go ial, if one takes place, provided away without first acqualnting the City Marshal. Miss Borden was not examined closely, owing to

See the clipping

The Indianapolis Journal · Indianapolis, Ind.

Bridget Sullivan, the Borden family's servant, was questioned by police about her actions and the family's affairs, and later Lizzie Borden was brought to the police station amid a gathering crowd. The private inquiry was revealed to be an inquest ordered by Judge Blaisdell at the district attorney's request.

The Indianapolis Journal · 10 August 1892 · page 1

Fall River, Mass., Aug. 9. This morn ing Bridget Sullivan, the servant girl in the Borden family, was summoned to the Central police station to tell what she knew about tho murder. She told the officers that she was willing to have the po lice or any one else examine her every action since the time she arose Thursday until she was asked to go to the police sta tion. She did not care to talk very mneh about the details of the family relations. She said that she wanted to leave two or three times, but she was urged to stay by Mrs.

See moreSee less

Borden, of whom she spoke very kindly. While the servant was in the co urt-rooin locked np with the authorities Mr. J. V. Morse was walking along through Main street and down to the bauk, closely followed by an ofticcr. The private inquiry that is going on is in reality an inquest ordered by Judge Blaisdel at the suggestion of District At torney Knowlton. as a result of the mid night conference of the authorities. Miss Lizzie Borden was brought to the Central .police statiou this afternoon in a hack containing Marshal Milliard, omcer Har

See the clipping

The Indianapolis Journal · Indianapolis, Ind.

Lizzie Borden was brought to the Central police station and examined separately from Bridget Sullivan before Judge Blaisdell in a private inquest led by District Attorney Knowlton. The session was inconclusive and adjourned until Wednesday, while J.V. Morse denied a relative's suggestion that he and Lizzie had conspired in the murders.

The Indianapolis Journal · 10 August 1892 · page 1

THE BORDEN MURDER MYSTERY.

The words of this article are printed with the report it shares its clipping with. Read them there or in the clipping.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

Der Deutsche Correspondent · Baltimore, Md.

A German-American newspaper reports that John V. Morse, uncle of the Borden sisters, was confronted with an accusation by George B. Fish of Hartford claiming Morse and Lizzie Borden conspired to murder the couple. Morse called the charge absurd and declined further comment, while both Bridget Sullivan and Lizzie Borden underwent police interrogation that day.

Der Deutsche Correspondent · 10 August 1892 · page 1

Der Doppelmord in Fall-River

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

See the clipping

Daily Kennebec Journal · Augusta, Me.

An inquest before Judge Blaisdell began in Fall River, with District Attorney Knowlton questioning Lizzie Borden and Bridget Sullivan separately under strict secrecy. Neither examination was completed, the inquest adjourned until the next morning, and Bridget Sullivan was released on her own recognizance pending further proceedings.

Daily Kennebec Journal · 10 August 1892 · page 1

Km.i Kivm Mjws.. Aug.. 0.—This has : been a day of intense excitement in Fall Kiver. \n inquest was held today, and the ; utmost seereey baa been observed. Bridget ; Sullivan and Mis* Lizzie Borden were ex amined and cross-examined by the shrewd ; judge and sharp lawyers. of this inquest, the following bulletin j was tonight given out by State Detective i Seav r The inquest began In-fore .Fudge I Itl.iisdell at »«' A M District Attorney Knowlton conducting the investigation. I Bridget Sullivan and Lizzie Borden were questioned separately.

See moreSee less

The examination of neither whs concluded. 1 Ininquest ad journed until lo A. M. Wednesday. Noth-j mg developed for publication. This meagre report was all that was ; given out officially, regarding tinfirst day's j proceedings of the inquiry. After adjourn- | nu-nt Bridget Sullivan w as taken up from I the central station. She was accompanied j f»\ officer Doherty and went to No. so | Division street, where she lias relatives, j She has hardly eaten or slept at tin Borden i house since the tragedy.

See the clipping

Daily Kennebec Journal · Augusta, Me.

After the first day of the inquest, Bridget Sullivan was escorted to relatives' home and told by the district attorney she could remain free on her own recognizance until trial. Lizzie Borden was questioned further following the unexpected arrival of the Attorney-General, while officers remained uncertain how to proceed and chased down an unconfirmed rumor about a bloody axe found at a farm.

Daily Kennebec Journal · 10 August 1892 · page 1

THE BORDEN MURDER.

house since the tragedy. District Attorney Knowlton told her that j he regarded her as the most important w itj ness in the eastand promised to allow her to go on her ow n recognizance until the trial, if one takes place, provided that -he, would not go away without tir-t acquainting ; the city marshal. While the principal parties at the inquest were at dinner. Bridget, or ‘ Maggie" as -he whs called at home, was placed in charge of Matron Bussell, whose lips are sealed. The girl told the whole of her story to Mrs.

See moreSee less

Bussell, often say ing that she could not tell all before, us there were so many men about. M if'clock while Bridget was walking up stairs to the court room, she was crying bit terly. Mi— Borden was next examined very closely, owing to two new causes. First

See the clipping

The Portland Daily Press · Portland, Me.

The Borden murder inquest in Fall River proceeds with little public information, as officials decline comment while hinting action may come soon. Servant Bridget Sullivan is brought to police headquarters for thorough questioning about events before and after the murders.

The Portland Daily Press · 10 August 1892 · page 1

THE BAD BORDEN BUSINESS

Thursday morning, when first seen by a reporter. She told the officer that it was very hard to be watched so closely and to have one’s affairs torn to pieces. She was willing, however, to have the police or any one else examine her every action since the time she arose Thursday until she was asked to go to the police station with the officer. She* did not care to talk very much about the details of the family relations. She allowed she want ed to leave two or three times, but was urged to remain by Mrs. Borden, of whom she spoke very kindly. She was

See the clipping

The Portland Daily Press · Portland, Me.

The report describes the secret inquest held before Judge Blaisdell, with District Attorney Knowlton questioning Bridget Sullivan and Lizzie Borden about the murders. It also notes a Hartford relative, Fred Fish, distancing his family from his grandfather's theory that Lizzie and John Morse conspired in the killings.

The Portland Daily Press · 10 August 1892 · page 1

DISTANT RELATIVES

called within a very short time. Miss Lizzie Borden was brought to the central police station in a hack this afternoon. She had been served with a subpsena summoning her to attend at an inquiry at the second district court to determine the cause of the death of her father and mother. The drive from the Borden house to the station was very rapid and was through crowds of people on both sidewalks. At the police sta tion this crowd was greatly augmented and the police court alley was filled with business men and loiterers. The inquiry was conducted behind doors guarded by policemen.

See the clipping

The Portland Daily Press · Portland, Me.

The inquest before Judge Blaisdell opened in Fall River with District Attorney Knowlton questioning Bridget Sullivan and Lizzie Borden separately, though neither examination was completed and little was released publicly. The report also notes a relative's account of family disagreement over George B. Fish's theory that Lizzie and John Morse conspired in the murder.

The Portland Daily Press · 10 August 1892 · page 1

DISTANT RELATIVES

Hartford, Ct., August 9.—Fred S. Fish, grandson of Mrs. George B. Fish, who is a sister of the murdered Mrs. Borden of Fall River, has just returned from the funeral of Mr. and Mrs. Borden which he attended. He says members of his family do not agree with his grandfather, George B. Fish, that Lizzie Borden and J. Y. Morse concocted the murder of Mrs. Borden The other members of the Fish family disagree from George B. Fish, but have no theory to advance. Search is being made for the prescrip tion which Dr.

See moreSee less

Bowen gave to the family when its members were ill a week ago today. Fall River, Mass., August 9.—This has been a day of intense excitement in Fall River. The inquest was held today and the utmost secrecy has been ob served. Bridget Sullivan and Miss Liz zie Borden were examined and cross-ex amined by a shrewd judge and sharp lawyer. The following bulletin was tonight given out bv State Detective Seaver: "The inquest began before Judge Blais dell at 10 a. m.. District Attorney Knowl ton conducting the investigation. Bridget Sullivan and Lizzie Borden were ques tioned separately. The examination of neither was concluded. The inquest ad journed until 10 a. m. Wednesday. Nothing developed for publication.” This meagre report was all that was given out officially regarding the first day’s proceedings of the inquiry. After adjournment Bridget Sullivan was taken from the Central Station. She was ac companied by Officer Doherty and went to No. 80 Division street, where she has relatives. She has hardly eaten or slept at the Borden house since the tragedy. District Attorney Knowlton told her he regarded her as a most important witness in the case and promised to allow her to go on her recognizance until trial, if one takes place, provided she would not go away without first acquainting the city marshal. While the principal parties at the in quest were at dinner, Bridget, of “Mag gie” as she was called at home, was placed in charge of Matron Bussell, whose lips are sealed. The girl told the whole of her story to Mrs. Bussell, often saying she could not tell all before as there were so many men about. While Bridget was walking up stairs to the court room she was crying bitterly. Miss Borden was not examined very

See the clipping

The Jersey City News · Jersey City, N.J.

Fall River police investigate a report from Dr. Handy of a wild-eyed, ghastly pale stranger seen near the Borden house on the morning of the murders, a sighting also corroborated by an officer. They also check out tailor Thomas P. Walker, who owed Borden rent and had used threatening language, but confirm he was working elsewhere all morning and could not have committed the crime.

The Jersey City News · 10 August 1892 · page 1

NEW FALL RIVER CLUE.

House—Lizzie Under Duress. Fall Paver, Mass., Aug. 10, 1893.— X,ast night’s News says:—“Dr. Handy furnishes a very suggestive hint as to the probable murderer of Mr, and Mrs. Borden. He says that about ten A. M. on Thursday he saw a man standing on Second street a little south of the Borden residence the man having such a terrible unusual appeaiauce as to atiruct his attention. “The stra'uger was ghastly white and seemed very much agitated. His eyes were particularly wild. He wore a small black mustache. The doctor could certainly identify the man he observed, as he was so struck by his desperate looking charccter that he turned around his catriage and gazed at him for ~ wine, Laie last evening the police began to put some credence in this report, as it was said that a man answering this de scription was seen by Officer Hyde about the same time.

See moreSee less

Policemen Doherty and Harrington ran aown the tenaut siory. It appears that lhomas P. Walker, a tailor working for John Carey, owed Mr. Borden one month’s rent for a house ou Fourth street. When asked to pay Walker used threatening language. On the day of the murder Walker worked steadily from seven o’clock in the morning until twelve, and could not possibly have been near the Borden homestead. At a meeting of the Board of Alder men last night the following order was passed:— Inasmuch as a terrible crime has been com mitted in our city, requiring an increased num ber of men to do police duty, it is hereby ordered that the City Marshal be and he is here by directed to employ such constables as he may deem necessary for the detection of the criminals. t In spite of her air of bravado, or per haos partly because of her air of bravado, the general opinion in Fall River this morning was that Lizzie Borden would figure as the principal accused. Miss Bordeu spent the night at her own home, but she was as much a prisoner as if she had been in jail. Bridget Sullivau, the servant, was kept last night at the house of Mrs. Harrington, on Division street.

See the clipping

The Jersey City News · Jersey City, N.J.

Police investigated a tip about Thomas P. Walker, a tailor who owed rent to Mr. Borden and had used threatening language, but his alibi of working from 7 a.m. to noon cleared him. Meanwhile, Lizzie Borden was effectively held under guard at her home, suspected by public opinion as the likely accused, while servant Bridget Sullivan was kept separately to prevent coaching.

The Jersey City News · 10 August 1892 · page 1

NEW FALL RIVER CLUE

The words of this article are printed with the report it shares its clipping with. Read them there or in the clipping.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

The Evening World · New York, N.Y.

Lizzie Borden is reported under intense questioning during the inquest, while her blood-stained clothing is sent to Boston for chemical testing. Police investigate Dr. Handy's account of a wild-eyed stranger near the Borden house and check out tenant Thomas Walker as a suspect, but clear him with a solid alibi.

The Evening World · 10 August 1892 · page 3

ON THE RACK TO-DAY.

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

See the clipping

The Evening World · New York, N.Y.

The report describes growing police reliance on blood and poison analysis, Bridget Sullivan's improved emotional state, and friction between Inspector Hanscom and lawyer Jennings. It notes Lizzie Borden is expected to face intense questioning that day, with District-Attorney Knowlton coordinating with the Attorney-General on possible charges.

The Evening World · 10 August 1892 · page 3

ceeding the murdcis. Miss I.lzle Borden will bo put on the rack to-day and sensational statements arc looked for. Yesterday she was not pressed hard, according to a statement from onklnl quar ters made thU morning. The police have asnln become active In the starch alter evi dence, and oiu or two details In regard to tho missing letter said to have been received by Mra. Borden aro again being fought by tho officials. District-Attorney Knowl'.on Is working undor tho direction ot Allorne) -General i PUlshury, and It Is said that the form of com-

See the clipping

The Sun · New York, N.Y.

Bridget Sullivan is grilled by police and the District Attorney about the murders, breaks down weeping, and is placed in Matron Russell's care as the morning session adjourns. District Attorney Knowlton then sends Chief Hilliard to summon Lizzie Borden, who calmly agrees to accompany him to the inquiry with a companion.

The Sun · 10 August 1892 · page 2

THE CONFERENCE ADJOURNS.

& jf f nuarters sho was taken at onco before .Tudgo I A DlaUdcll. tho District Altornoy. and Chlof of f 1 Question nftor auotion was fired at her. i AH the suspicions ontnrtninnd against Llzrlo H K llorden worn repeated 10 her. Hlie was made $ -A ' to tell and re-tell her story. Ih The girl stood It ns long ns sho could. Thon V, tj f. ho broke down. Mlietoldhorexaminers.it iy 2 '- "s said, that she did not believe Mr.zlo Borden 19; left thohousoatall. She was nsked why s 10 35 lii thought Miss llorden hnd npt cone out.

See moreSee less

Bhe S? " answered with sobs. The DJstrlot Attorney ) f pressed on. and nbked how It was that she had g f 9Br,l no sounds of a struggle or of blows. ff $ h 'The girl did not answer, but sat weeping. IS ,1' Bhe had stood it ns long as she had been i W t questioned solely In regard to hor story as she H h fa 1 ad repeated it to Mr. llnnscom. andlas he had f ftf ' probably f0Pefttort u Mto hortytt wnon

See the clipping

The Sun · New York, N.Y.

District Attorney Knowlton questioned Lizzie Borden for nearly four hours at the inquest, with police checking her new statements against known facts. Professor Wood reported the cellar rags showed human blood and suggested poison indications in the stomach analysis, while Bridget Sullivan was sent to a private home in police custody.

The Sun · 10 August 1892 · page 2

;?J i . told hor story just as she had talked it over to W If ' Mr. llnnscom and Lawyer Jennings. 2 (1 1, 11 could not bo learned positively to-night y "5 f v what new details or points had been given g,i J, s by Miss llorden. From time to time during K S3 1 hor oMiiiInatlon Chlof or 1'ollcellllliurd would WV rt' f appear down stairs and hurriedly give whls- !?'- IK,; pered Instructions to homo of his mon. These W 'j detectims would disappear and return later ffi I?

See moreSee less

'3f and report to tho Chief. It was learned that to & many new points madn by Miss llorden wero it )T either alllnned or disproved at onco by the IK. 5 f police. Itwussald that many of them wero jrac .t v disproved. M !? '' Tho examination of Miss Borden lasted al- "Ac h ? most four hours. Twice during that time g i L District ttorny Knowlton hurried out or the ST i , building nnd down town. Once he wont to tho S i First National Hank. About 4:'J0 o'clock l'rof. f II k Wood ot Harvard went up stairs. He told the K 5. oxamlners that tho blood on the rags round in 1 tlio cellar was human blood. Ho said that In w jv . regard to tho roport on tho stomachs he would 3. v , not be able to give a xatisfactory analysis for J fij , at least four dnts. f6 8k ' It Is said that tho Indications so far noticeIt B Labla on thn vlscein pointed to tho presence of Kt: poleon. l'rof. Wood left tho court room at a E '. ' o'clock and want to the Mellen House, m 5 f whero he conferred with Attornoy-Qeneral W. B t l'lllsbtiry, The result of this conferonco was J J I v evidently satlstnctory, for tho Attorney-OonIP ' eralreturnod to Boston on the 5 o'clock train.

See the clipping

The Sun · New York, N.Y.

After a grueling four-hour inquest session, Lizzie Borden emerged composed and showed no nervousness, while her lawyer objected to her being questioned without his presence. Police detailed three theories of the murders—implicating John Morse, Lizzie Borden alone, or Borden and Bridget Sullivan together—and investigated Sullivan's unexplained movements on the night before the killings.

The Sun · 10 August 1892 · page 2

END OF THE ORDEAL

which Implicates both Llzzlo Borden and Bridget Sullivan. . . . . Thoy wero the onlytwo persons In thonouso when Mrs. Borden was murdered, and tho Sullivan girl was in the house whon Sir. Bor den wua lulled. Llrr.ie Borden, according to her own story, was at least on the premises. The (lovelnnmonts of to-day hayo strength ened this theory. wiiF.m: was nmmiKT om saturdat jiinriT? The authorities have realized that Llzzlo Borden and Bridget Bulllvnn should he kept apart. The actions or the Sullivan girl havo been carerully gone. over.

See moreSee less

On Saturday night she left the Borden houso nt 7 o'clock, Bho had a bundle with her, and manngod to etude the police. Whore she was between 7 and 8 o'clock on that night Is not known. Mrs. Patrick Harrington met her at H o'clock nt tho corner of Second and Morgan strcots, about five blocks from the Borden house. Tho two women went to .Mrs. Harrington' home. Bridget stayed there, until yesterday morning, when she roturned to the liordon housn with Mrs. Harrington, but without hor

See the clipping

The Evening Herald · Shenandoah, Pa.

The inquest into the Borden murders has begun, with Lizzie Borden and servant Bridget Sullivan being questioned by authorities. Details of their testimony are not elaborated in this brief notice.

The Evening Herald · 10 August 1892 · page 3

HE ,IN,QUEST BEGUN Lizzie Borden and Bridget Sul livan Questioned. THE PROCEEDINGS KEPT 8ECRET. KoTinuhe ltilt tlmt Nntne One of the I'amily Will lie Ar'rvitcil for the Murder--31

See the clipping

The Evening Herald · Shenandoah, Pa.

The inquest into the Borden murder began before Judge Blaisdell, with District Attorney Knowlton questioning Bridget Sullivan and Lizzie Borden separately; neither examination was concluded and the hearing adjourned until Wednesday. Officials declined to comment, though rumors suggested an arrest of a family member might be imminent.

The Evening Herald · 10 August 1892 · page 3

THE PROCEEDINGS KEPT SECRET.

Vm,. Rivfti, Muss., Aug. 10. Tho f oluwiiiK Imlletm was Inst night given out by Stats IJetectlro Seaver: The iiitmest into the Harden murder )efiu before Judge lilnlsdell at 10 n ra., District-Attorney Knowlton conducting the investigation. Bridget Sullivan nnd lizzie Borden were questioned separately. The examination of neither was concludd. llie inquest adjourned until 10 a. mi. Wednesday. Nothing was developed for publication." This meagre report Is nil that Is given out officially regarding the first day's pro ceedings of tho inquiry. First Bridget bullivnn, the servant girl in the Borden family, was summoned to tlie Central Police Station.

See moreSee less

She walked down in compaiiy with nn officer nnd talked quite freply on tho way. She looked very much worried and was quite pale as compared with her appear ance last lliursuny luormug, wuen seen ti . i. ... 1 Sho told the officer that it was very hard to be watched so closely and to have one s private nITairs torn to pieces, oho was willing, however, to have the police or any one else examine her every action since the time she arose Thursday until she was asked to go to tho Police Station with the officer. She did not care to talk very much about the details of tho family relations. Sho said that sho wanted to leave two or three' times but she was urged to remain by Mrs. Borden, of whom she spoke very kindly.

See the clipping

Pittsburg Dispatch · Pittsburg, Pa.

The Fall River inquest into the Borden murders intensifies as Attorney General Pillsbury and Professor Wood of Harvard join District Attorney Knowlton to question Lizzie Borden, who has reportedly given three different stories. Bridget Sullivan, under police care, has also allegedly broken down and changed her account, while police work to pin down the exact timeline of the murders.

Pittsburg Dispatch · 10 August 1892 · page 1

MURDER WILL OUT

some of Mr. Gladstone's remarks with anx Coplons Showers Fall on the These rags were concealed nnder a bucket Parched not anticipate who would govern when the iety. He felt bound to warn the Liberals turned upside down. They were smeared Fields In the Far West. that some questions "required Immediate present administration was displaced. It with blood as though an ax had been wiped , Kansas City, Ma, Aug. 9. Bain fell attention. He regretted Mr. Gladstone's on them. Dr. Dolan took these rags and was not possible for a Liberal Government all over Kansas to-night.

See moreSee less

Reports to the scant dismissal ot the case of evicted sent them to Prof. Wood of Boston. to say what measures they would submit to Associated Press from points as far west as tenants. They had borne the brunt of the He also sent a strip-of carpet dyed with the Parliament six months hence. battle and had' made the greatest sacrifices the Colorado line to the Indian Territorv blood of Mrs. Borden. for their class. He did not think their ease fre'and's Claim inih Forefront. and north to Nebraska State line say that Prof, wood to-day said that the blood presented an insuperable difficulty. Again, on the rags, as well as that on the carpet, In regard to the suggested holding of a bounteous showers watered the' parched if the amnesty question is neglected, It was human blood beyond all doubt. With session in Nqveniber.he conld only say that earth. Nearly every point reporting states would cause a fresh agitation and fresh this evidence before tbem, the District any Government taking that course would hats ufHcIent rain fell to save the corn crop, trouble. If the Liberal party is wise it Attorney and Chief Police Hllllard sent show an inadequate sense of the magnitude while a few state that 'the winds had done will give specific pledges to satisfy Ireland Sergeant Dougherty to the-Borden house anil variety of the subjects it had to deal fo much damage as to place' corn beyond pn these matters. , this mernlnf at-10 o'cleok.wJth.a summons with. Attempts had been made to contrast Lieutenant Colonel Edward JamM rajiet . . 'ij-ir- '. ,-, ii . j-,. . - -. . ..... ' ,.. , . . i&i,.i. ... y..."!LMiiL-'i&-' .1; - jferriTHKMsv ..? SsssssMsslssls-Sr I 1 - IM il 1 TT1 TTT'nil"? ir WT tl -l. '"-n 1 11 TiHssli IT "&E?iX V wveaBte2ESic?QBw-weaSPlBfi9ezeBBH0-' .i ii,n,ri-w .-,iii.-fiti. ' mi iapgBirin -mTBpgaBa. ifcr o'clock to-dny. They at once jolped Dis trict Attorney Knowlton at an inquiry which is now being held and which corres ponds to an inquest and at which Lizzie Borden was heard. Bridget Sullivan is at Mrs. Harrington's house in the care of a detective and Lizzie Borden is at her home under police surveillance. ' The police conference yesterday lasted far into the morning. The time of the murder

See the clipping

Pittsburg Dispatch · Pittsburg, Pa.

The report details the police conference fixing the time of Andrew Borden's murder between 10:50 and 11:15 a.m., based on witness testimony and Dr. Bowen's statements. It also describes discrepancies in Lizzie Borden's account of her whereabouts, including a detective's discovery that undisturbed dust in the barn loft contradicted her claim of searching there.

Pittsburg Dispatch · 10 August 1892 · page 1

some of Mr. Gladstone's remarks with anx Coplons Showers Fall on the These rags were concealed nnder a bucket Parched not anticipate who would govern when the iety. He felt bound to warn the Liberals turned upside down. They were smeared Fields In the Far West. that some questions "required Immediate present administration was displaced. It with blood as though an ax had been wiped , Kansas City, Ma, Aug. 9. Bain fell attention. He regretted Mr. Gladstone's on them. Dr. Dolan took these rags and was not possible for a Liberal Government all over Kansas to-night.

See moreSee less

Reports to the scant dismissal ot the case of evicted sent them to Prof. Wood of Boston. to say what measures they would submit to Associated Press from points as far west as tenants. They had borne the brunt of the He also sent a strip-of carpet dyed with the Parliament six months hence. battle and had' made the greatest sacrifices the Colorado line to the Indian Territorv blood of Mrs. Borden. for their class. He did not think their ease fre'and's Claim inih Forefront. and north to Nebraska State line say that Prof, wood to-day said that the blood presented an insuperable difficulty. Again, on the rags, as well as that on the carpet, In regard to the suggested holding of a bounteous showers watered the' parched if the amnesty question is neglected, It was human blood beyond all doubt. With session in Nqveniber.he conld only say that earth. Nearly every point reporting states would cause a fresh agitation and fresh this evidence before tbem, the District any Government taking that course would hats ufHcIent rain fell to save the corn crop, trouble. If the Liberal party is wise it Attorney and Chief Police Hllllard sent show an inadequate sense of the magnitude while a few state that 'the winds had done will give specific pledges to satisfy Ireland Sergeant Dougherty to the-Borden house anil variety of the subjects it had to deal fo much damage as to place' corn beyond pn these matters. , this mernlnf at-10 o'cleok.wJth.a summons with. Attempts had been made to contrast Lieutenant Colonel Edward JamM rajiet . . 'ij-ir- '. ,-, ii . j-,. . - -. . ..... ' ,.. , . . i&i,.i. ... y..."!LMiiL-'i&-' .1; - jferriTHKMsv ..? SsssssMsslssls-Sr I 1 - IM il 1 TT1 TTT'nil"? ir WT tl -l. '"-n 1 11 TiHssli IT "&E?iX V wveaBte2ESic?QBw-weaSPlBfi9ezeBBH0-' .i ii,n,ri-w .-,iii.-fiti. ' mi iapgBirin -mTBpgaBa. ifcr fixing the time of the murder at the confer ence the District 'Attorney took up the story of Lizzie Borden, who is the last per son known to hare seen her father alive. Lizzie Borden told three stories.

See the clipping

Pittsburg Dispatch · Pittsburg, Pa.

District Attorney finds discrepancies in Lizzie Borden's accounts of her whereabouts, with a detective disproving her loft story via undisturbed dust. Medical examiner states Mrs. Borden died about an hour before her husband, and bloodstained rags are found hidden in the cellar, confirmed as human blood.

Pittsburg Dispatch · 10 August 1892 · page 1

clews were worthless. Medical Examiner Dolar) then explained how Mrs. Borden must have been dead at least one hour be fore the murder of Mr. Borden. Dr. Dolan said that in his opinion Mrs, Borden was dead as early as 9 o'clock in the morning. This settles at least the fact that Miss Borden, who says' she was not away from the hopse the entire morning prior to the murder, must have been in the house with her stepmother and the assassin when the first murder took place. And with Bridget Sullivan up stairs and with Lizzie Borden wandering abont the house, how does it happen that they did not meet the assassin or hear the necessary noise of the murder?

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

The Borden murder inquest resumed in Fall River, with Lizzie Borden questioned for 90 minutes before being led out exhausted, followed by John Morse's testimony under strict secrecy. Meanwhile police and a carpenter searched the Borden house again, while conflicting and unconfirmed rumors circulated about Bridget Sullivan's testimony.

The Providence News · 10 August 1892 · page 1

WHAT DID BRIDGET TESTIFY?

fore prevailed. Mrs. George Brl%bam. a friend of the family, came to the station house this afternoon, and tried to cheer and interest tne unfortunate Miss Borden. In the meantime—~while Mr. Morse was undergoing his inquisition ana Miss Bor den was conversing with her friend a sig nificant scene was being enacted at the Borden house. VW

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

Police and a carpenter searched the Borden house again and emerged with large wrapped bundles and a piece of zinc or lead, fueling speculation tied to Lizzie's inquest testimony. Meanwhile, the inquest opened before Judge Blaisdell with District Attorney Knowlton questioning Bridget Sullivan and Lizzie Borden, though the day yielded no clear new developments.

The Providence News · 10 August 1892 · page 1

ISPECIAL TO THE NEWS.] FALL RIVER, Aug. 10.—The man who, between two chairs, found himself sud denly sitting on the ground, was not a more disappointed and embarassed indi vidual than be who yesterday had hopes that between a certain occurrence and a certain discovery alleged to have been made during the day in connection with the Borden murders, he would have something to stand on in next treating of those murders to the public. The day was utterly fruitless, Its chief event was the inquest, which began about 10 o’clock in the district court room before Judge Josiah C islais dell.

See moreSee less

District Attorney Hosea M. Knowl ton, who arrived Monday evening, con ducted the examination of witnesses, only two of whom had been heard at the hour of adjournment-—Bridget Sullivan, the servant of the Bordens, and Miss Elizabeth A. DBorden the suspected daughter. ’ ; There was not much excitement when Miss Sullivan was conducted to the court room, but the passage of Miss Borden was asexciting, if not so widely looked

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

Lizzie Borden was taken by hack to the inquest, appearing agitated but composed, and reportedly answered the district attorney's questions firmly without contradiction. A new witness, a Russian Jew passing by, claimed to have seen an unidentified woman move from the barn to the side door around the time of the murders, fueling public theories about Lizzie's possible guilt or complicity with John V. Morse.

The Providence News · 10 August 1892 · page 1

Thursday, and so cannot ug.how satis factorily her presence at or absence from the house at that time was mluinod. A Russian Jew who pa the house at 10:80 that morning, within a quarverof an hour of the time that old Mr, Borden returned home and within fifteen or

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

A newspaper roundup criticizes a local paper for having falsely bulletined Lizzie Borden's 'arrest,' just as it once falsely announced Queen Victoria's death to boost circulation. The item mocks such sensationalism, comparing it to Napoleonic-era false war bulletins.

The Providence News · 10 August 1892 · page 4

TrE local paper which a while ago bulletined the death of Queen Victoria to bolster up its failing circulation has lately posted in like manner the ‘“‘ar rest” of Dalton and of Lizzie Borden.

See the clipping

The Salt Lake Herald · Salt Lake City, Utah

The inquest into the Borden murders began in Fall River, with Lizzie Borden and domestic servant Bridget Sullivan questioned separately by authorities, though neither examination was completed. Lizzie was briefly detained by police but allowed to go after promising not to leave the city, while Dr. Handy described seeing a strange, agitated white-faced man near the Borden home on the morning of the murders.

The Salt Lake Herald · 10 August 1892 · page 1

TBE BORDEN MURDER Inquest NoW Pclng Held at Fall Rver Mass Lizzie Borden suspectd FALL RIVER Mass Aug 9Miss Lizzie Borden who is looked upon with suspicion in reference to the Borden murder case is under strict surveillance1 by the police This afternoon she was taken to the police station Later the district attorney told her that she might go if she promised not to leave the city without first acquainting

See the clipping

The Times · Richmond, Va.

A relative of the murdered Mrs. Borden reports that family members disagree with George B. Fish's theory that Lizzie Borden and J.V. Morse conspired in the murders. Lizzie Borden was taken to the Central police station and served with a subpoena to testify at the inquest into her father's death.

The Times · 10 August 1892 · page 1

The Roarden Murder Mystery. Hastrorp, Coxy., August %—Fred ©. Vish. the grandson of Mrs. Geo. B, Fish, who is the sister of the murdered Mrs. Bor don. of Fall River, has just returned from tho funeral of Mr. and Mrs. Borden, which he attended with his randmother, He pays that the members ” hts family do not agree with his grandfather, (eo. D. Fish, that Lizzie Borden and J. V. Morse con cocted the murder of Mr, and Mra. Borden, The other members of the family disagree

See the clipping

The Seattle Post-Intelligencer · Seattle, Wash. Terr. Wash.

Lizzie Borden was taken to the police station and held under surveillance, then released after the district attorney required her to stay in the city. The inquest began with separate questioning of Borden and servant Bridget Sullivan, while Dr. Handy reported seeing a ghastly, agitated stranger near the Borden house.

The Seattle Post-Intelligencer · 10 August 1892 · page 8

Lizzie Borden Under SnrTeillauce. FALL RIVER, Mass., Aug. 9.—Miss Lizzie Borden, who is looked upon with suspicion in reference to the Borden murder case, is under strict surveillance by the police This afternoon she was taken to the police station, then later the district attorney told her that she might go if she promised not to leave the city without first acquaint ing the city marshal. The inquest begai:} this afternoon. Bridget Sullivan, a do mestic, and Lizzie Borden were questioned separately. The examination of neither was concluded, and the inquest was ad journed till tomorrow.

See moreSee less

Bridget Sullivan was placed in charge of Matron Russell, Dr. Handy says, regarding the probable murderer of Mr. and Mrs. Borden, that on Thursday morning he saw a man near the Borden residence, of unusual appearance, being ghastly white and very agitated. The police are now investigating.

See the clipping

The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · Wheeling, W. Va.

The inquest into the Borden murders began before Judge Blaisdell, with District Attorney Knowlton leading questioning of Bridget Sullivan and then Lizzie Borden separately. Officials revealed nothing for publication, and the inquest was adjourned until the next morning.

The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · 10 August 1892 · page 1

BRIDGET SULLIVAN EXAMINED.

) time she arose Thursday until she ) asked to go to the police station h an officer. She did not care to talk y much about details of family relays. Sho said that she wanted to leave > or three times, but sho was urged remain by Mrs. Borden, of whom she .1.. ...... 1-1 11 CU. ...a 4.Un k?_ >uu vol/ &iuu4jr* ouo noa HWOU WW 0 tbo city marshal, District'Attorney

See the clipping

The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · Wheeling, W. Va.

District Attorney Knowlton conducted the inquest, examining Bridget Sullivan and Lizzie Borden separately, with proceedings adjourned until Wednesday and nothing released for publication. Afterward, Knowlton called Bridget the most important witness and allowed her to remain free pending trial if she agreed to notify the city marshal before leaving.

The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · 10 August 1892 · page 1

BRIDGET SULLIVAN EXAMINED

Morn: Dunles lllo Charge, all Riveu, Mass., August (S.?J. V. rso, tho undo oi the Borden girls, :n shown a statement by George B. b, of Hartford, a brothor-in-law of murdored Mrs. Borden, that he ih) bolloves that lllas Liztio Boiden . Air. Morse concocted tho murder of oldcouplo and hired somebody to t, said that his counsel h%d advised

See the clipping

Morning Journal and Courier · New Haven, Conn.

This brief wire-service headline, bundled among national news items, asserts that public opinion was turning toward Lizzie Borden's innocence. No further details or supporting text accompany the headline in this excerpt, which is dominated by unrelated Knights Templar conclave coverage.

Morning Journal and Courier · 11 August 1892 · page 3

Governor Buchanan Burned in Effigy. LIZZIE BORDEN THOUGHT INNOCENT. Resume of the Homestead Situation. THE PLUMED KNIGHTS. New England Men on Committees A New Bltual Adopted St. John's Commandery of Providence The

See the clipping

Morning Journal and Courier · New Haven, Conn.

The Fall River police admit they have no substantial evidence against anyone in the Borden murders, despite many theories. The inquest resumed with testimony from Lizzie Borden, Emma Borden, John Morse, Dr. Bowen, and others, with Lizzie's demeanor noticeably changed afterward and public opinion largely favoring her innocence.

Morning Journal and Courier · 11 August 1892 · page 3

Is Calnlne Ground A Hypothetical Case The Bodies Will be Exbnnsed. Fall River, Ang. 10 It cannot be said that the polioe have any substantial olne to the murderers of the Bordens. Theories are plentiful, bnt reliable evi dence la wanting. At S o'clock this after noon State Deteotlve Seaver banded the following bulletin to the reporters: The Inquest was continued at 10 o'clock. The witnesses ware Miss Lizzie Borden, John Y. Morse, Miss Emma L. Borden, Dr. S. W. Bo wen, Adelaide B. Churchill and Hiram C. Harrington. Adjourned until Thursday.

See moreSee less

Nothing developed for publication. This was all that was given ont after examinations lasting four and a half hours. The principal witness to-day was Miss Lizzie Borden. The change in Miss Bor den's appearanoe after her examination was the ohief topio of conversation at the polioe station to-night. Whatever the police may think of the strength of their clnes it is certain that the opinions of Miss Borden's many friends are entirely in favor of ber innocence. This feeling is gaining more adherents every hour. When Mr. Morse came from his examination to-day he calm and oolleoted, as he has been since suspicion has been directed toward him. Miss Emma Borden's manner was less dis turbed than any of the witnesses. Dr. Bowen told a straightforward storv. cover ing thai time since he' was called to the Borden house a few days before the murder. He incidentally save some evi dence which startled the authorities. The nature of this wonld not be given for publication, but it was learned that to morrow another examination of the bodies will be made at Oak Grove cemetery. Hiram Harrington could offer very little testimony regarding the circumstances sur rounding the murder, as he said he was not in the city. raken altogether tne police have pre sentea very insnmclent and meagre evidence against any member of the family ana the evidence that they have presented is such that it would be dangerous to pro ceea upon. The Daily Mews published the following in a late edition to-nieht: A physician who has figured as promt nent in the investigation of the Borden mystery as anyone that can be mentioned cited a hypothetical case this morning wnion would indicate that he has been undergoing a change of sentiment. From the first he has made no secret of his per sonal opinion that Miss Lizzie Borden was probably guilty of murder. This morning

See the clipping

Morning Journal and Courier · New Haven, Conn.

The report describes inquest testimony from Morse, Emma Borden, Dr. Bowen, and Hiram Harrington, noting police evidence against family members remains thin. It also details a physician's hypothetical scenario suggesting the prussic acid theory against Lizzie may be losing credibility, while speculating she might have taken poison herself rather than face arrest.

Morning Journal and Courier · 11 August 1892 · page 3

The words of this article are printed with the report it shares its clipping with. Read them there or in the clipping.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

Waterbury Evening Democrat · Waterbury, Conn.

The Fall River inquest into the Borden murders resumed, with Lizzie Borden, Emma Borden, Dr. Bowen, Adelaide Churchill, Hiram Harrington and John Morse examined over four and a half hours. Police report no clew made public, but note a trunk of bloody clothing was removed after analyst Prof. Wood met with the medical examiner.

Waterbury Evening Democrat · 11 August 1892 · page 2

SEEKING FOR A MOTIVE

Faix. Kivbr, Mass., Aug. 11. This morning it cannot be said that the police have any substantial clew to the mur ders of Mr. and Mrs. Andrew J. Borden. Theories are plentiful, but reliable evi dence is wanting. Last evening State Detective Seaver handed the following bulletin to the representatives: "The inquest was con tinued at 10 o'clock to-day. The wit nesses examined were Miss Lizzie Borden, John Y. Worse, Miss Emma L. Borden, Dr. S. W. Bowen, Adelaide B. Churchill and Hiram C. Harrington. Adjourned until 10 a. m. Thursday.

See moreSee less

Nothing devel oped for publication." This was all that was given out after examinations lasting four and a half hours. The principal witness was Miss Lizzie Borden. The change in Miss Bor den's appearance, after her examination, is the chief topic of conversation at the police station. Whatever the police may think of the strength of their clews, it is certain that Miss Borden's many friends believe her innocent. Prof. W ood, the analyst, appeared at the station early, in company with Medi cal Examiner Dolan. Shortly after the inquest was resumed the two men were admitted and were behind closed doors about tweuty minutes. When they reap peared they were followed by a couple of policemen carrying a trunk contain ing bloody clothing and other evidences of the crime. When Mr. Morse came from his exam ination he was as calm and collected as he has been since suspicion has been di rected toward him. Miss Emma Borden's manner has been less disturbed than any of the witnesses. Dr. Bowen told a straightforward story, covering the time since he was called to the Borden house, a few days before the murder. He incidentally gave some tes

See the clipping

Waterbury Evening Democrat · Waterbury, Conn.

At the inquest, Lizzie Borden, John Morse, Emma Borden, Dr. Bowen, Adelaide Churchill and Hiram Harrington were examined for four and a half hours, with little released publicly. Analyst Prof. Wood and Medical Examiner Dolan were seen with a trunk of bloody clothing, and tension grew between police and the family's counsel over competing theories.

Waterbury Evening Democrat · 11 August 1892 · page 2

LIZZIE BORDEN AGAIN EXAMINED.

The words of this article are printed with the report it shares its clipping with. Read them there or in the clipping.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

Waterbury Evening Democrat · Waterbury, Conn.

The report describes growing police reliance on blood analysis evidence while noting internal friction between police and Inspector Hanscom and attorney Jennings. It also covers Bridget Sullivan's improved emotional state and Lizzie Borden's distressing police questioning, after which she appeared visibly shaken.

Waterbury Evening Democrat · 11 August 1892 · page 2

LIZZIE BORDEN AGAIN EXAMINED.

murders. The police have again become active iu the search after evidence and one or two details in regard to the missing letter said to have been received by Mrs. Borden are again being sought by the omcials. District-Attorney Knowltou is working under the direction of Attorney-Oeneral Pillsbury and it is said that the form of complaint and possibly all warrants will be submitted to him. Much credit is being given in police circles to the work of Dr. Dolan, who has practically neglected a remunerative bisi ness since he was called 011 to act ofti dally.

See moreSee less

The only complaint against him is that his tongue will not wag to other than official inquisitors. Miss Borden was asked some nervoshaking questions and when she came from the police station her face was tear stained and she was very much upset. There was a great difference between her appearance before and after the examination. The servant girl is kept under the eye of a policeman at her brother-in-law's house aud she was not allowed to go free as was intimated last night by Detective Seaver.

See the clipping

Evening Journal · Wilmington, Del.

The inquest into the murders of Andrew and Abby Borden continued with testimony from Lizzie Borden, John V. Morse, Emma Borden, Dr. Bowen, Adelaide Churchill, and Hiram Harrington, but officials released no details to the press. The report describes the case as one of the era's great unsolved murder mysteries, noting the crime's strange circumstances and the lack of any arrest after a week.

Evening Journal · 11 August 1892 · page 2

ficient—The Tragedy One of the Most Peculiar Crimes of ltcccnt Years. Fall River, Mas*., Aug. 11.—People of Fall River can talk or tbmk of nothiug but the murder of Mr. and Mrs. Andrew J. Borden until some one is arrested or tried, or the crime becomes, liko many another murder, an old and unfathomable mystery. Tho town seems to have susiiemicd busi ness to stand on the street corners and dis miss the tragedy. That an old and respected merchant, with an ample fortune and a famous name, living in a closely settled neighborhood, could be butchered in his own house nt higli noon, and his wife slain in another room near by at the same time, and the bodies be discovered while the blood was still warm upon them, and that no truce of the ■ssassiu should be found nflor a week's search, seems incredible.

See moreSee less

All this makes the Fall River murders one of tho great murder mysteries of the epoch. Th« Inqumt.

See the clipping

Evening Journal · Wilmington, Del.

The Fall River murder inquest resumed with witnesses including Lizzie Borden, John Morse, Emma Borden, Dr. Bowen, Adelaide Churchill, and Hiram Harrington examined for over four hours, though officials released almost no details. Reports note Lizzie's altered appearance afterward, public sentiment favoring her innocence, and a physician reportedly softening his earlier suspicion of her guilt.

Evening Journal · 11 August 1892 · page 2

J. V. KORBE. den. The change iu Miss Borden's appear anco after her examination whs the chief topic of conversation at the polire station. Whatever the police may thiuk of the strength of their clews. It is certain that the opinions of Miss Borden's tunny friends arc entirely of her innocence. This feeling it gaining more udhereuts every hour. When Mr. Morse came from his examina tion he was us calm and collected ns he lias been since suspicion bas been directed to ward him. MiAs Emma Horden'» in aimer was less dlstijrbed than any of the witness e s.

See moreSee less

Dr. Bowen/told a straightforward story, covuriug tjrfo time since he was called to the Borden Rouse, a few days before the mur der. . HA incidentally gave some evidence Which startled the authorities. Thu uiituro of this would not be given for publication, but it was learned thut today another ex amination of the dead hudien will probably be made at Oak Grove cemetery. Hiram Hnrriugtou could offer very little testimony regarding the circumstances sur rounding the murder, us he said ho was not In the vicinity when it occurred. Taken altogether iu connection with un authorita tivo statement volunteered tho police lmvo presented very insufficient and monger evi dence against any member of tho family, and the evidence that they have presented is such that it would be dangerous to pro ceed upon it. A Doctor's Change of Views.

See the clipping

Evening Journal · Wilmington, Del.

A physician who earlier supported the poison theory poses a hypothetical about whether a guilty woman who used prussic acid might use it again, including on herself, rather than face arrest. The article notes this hypothetical suggests the prussic acid theory was losing credibility among investigators.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

Evening Journal · 11 August 1892 · page 2

J. V. KORBE. den. The change iu Miss Borden's appear anco after her examination whs the chief topic of conversation at the polire station. Whatever the police may thiuk of the strength of their clews. It is certain that the opinions of Miss Borden's tunny friends arc entirely of her innocence. This feeling it gaining more udhereuts every hour. When Mr. Morse came from his examina tion he was us calm and collected ns he lias been since suspicion bas been directed to ward him. MiAs Emma Horden'» in aimer was less dlstijrbed than any of the witness e s.

See moreSee less

Dr. Bowen/told a straightforward story, covuriug tjrfo time since he was called to the Borden Rouse, a few days before the mur der. . HA incidentally gave some evidence Which startled the authorities. Thu uiituro of this would not be given for publication, but it was learned thut today another ex amination of the dead hudien will probably be made at Oak Grove cemetery. Hiram Hnrriugtou could offer very little testimony regarding the circumstances sur rounding the murder, us he said ho was not In the vicinity when it occurred. Taken altogether iu connection with un authorita tivo statement volunteered tho police lmvo presented very insufficient and monger evi dence against any member of tho family, and the evidence that they have presented is such that it would be dangerous to pro ceed upon it. A Doctor's Change of Views. The Daily News publishes the following. "A physician who figures as prominently in the investigation of the Borden mystery as any one that cau be mentioned cited n hypothetical case, which would indicate that he has been undergoing a change of sentiment. From tho first he made "ijii secret of his personal opinion that Mi«» Lizzie Borden was probably guilty of mur der. This morning he wus asked if thero had been any development on the line of the prussic ucid idea, and his opinion con cerning it was rendered, instead of answer ing directly he cited liis hypothetical case as follows: " 'Givon a strong minded, resolute wom an, with nervo enough to havo committed thene two murder«, one ufter another—if tli)» woman had ohtuiuod prussic arid and used it, would »be not use it nguiu t Sup posing this woman committed thu murders, then learned that »he wo» suRpocted of the crime and thut there was iu evidence con tradictory Htatements of family difference and possibly even stronger evidence against her of which »he knuw nothing, would »he submit to being locked up iu a colli Would Bbe take chauces of being arrestuü and con fined m a cel If The doctor« hypothetical case looked us though tho prussic ucid story j was being discredited. V 'Miss Lixzie Borden knew thnt she was ... - . .... ., . . ■ suspected aud had an idea evidence would be used to convict. evidence was that she had trad to pur"

See the clipping

The Wilmington Daily Republican · Wilmington, Del.

A Fall River police official admits there is no clear suspect, though suspicion lingers on a member of the Borden family. Dr. Handy reports seeing a strange, agitated man near the Borden house before the murders, while Lizzie Borden's closed-door inquest questioning reportedly left her visibly shaken.

The Wilmington Daily Republican · 11 August 1892 · page 1

FALL RIVER'S MT STERT. FALL RIVER'S MT STERT. 61:111 No Clew to the Murderer of Mr. and Mn. Borden. Fall River, Mass., Aug. 11.—An officer who is very close to the head of the department, says that he has doubt of the nltimate arrest of some one of the Borden family, but which one he would not could not say. Dr. Handy furnishes a very sngges tlve hint to the probable murder of Mr. and Mrs. Borden. He says that about 10 a. pi. on Thursday last he saw a man standing ou Second street, a little •oath of the Borden residence, tn e mau having mich q terribly uunsual appear ance an to attract his attention.

See moreSee less

The atranger was ghastly white, and seemed ▼ery much agitated. The doctor could certainly identify the man lie observed, as he was so struck by his di*sperate|look ing character that he turned around his carnage and gazed at him for a consid erable time. The police begin to put some credence in this rumor, it was said that a u answering this descrip tion by Officer Hyde about the I I same time.

See the clipping

Delaware Gazette and State Journal · Wilmington, Del.

State detectives and a federal marshal questioned Lizzie Borden after an extensive but inconclusive search for her parents' killer. A $5,000 reward was offered and authorities planned to delay any arrest until after the funeral, held privately with the bodies lying in the drawing-room.

Delaware Gazette and State Journal · 11 August 1892 · page 3

most thorough and persistent search, clue Jins been found of the murderer of Mr. and Mrs. Andrew J. Borden. F policemen are guard at lling the have • been pi made public. since the affaii orning State Detective S. Eaver This and United States Marshal Hill held a the lit ûghborhood

See the clipping

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

The private inquest into the Borden murders continued in Fall River, with Lizzie Borden brought to the police station and analyst Professor Wood delivering a trunk of bloody clothing and evidence to Boston for testing. John V. Morse was also brought in but reportedly not examined, and the group later returned to the Borden home.

New-York Tribune · 11 August 1892 · page 1

MEMBERS OF THE BORDEN PAMILY EXALL AMINED AT THE PRIVATE INQUEST. Fall River, Mass., Aug. 10.—To-day the interest In the Borden murder cases centred around the Central the inquest was continued, Police station, where Miss Lizzie Borden was driven to the station this

See the clipping

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

The inquest resumed with Professor Wood and Medical Examiner Dolan removing a trunk of bloody clothing as evidence, later sent to Boston for analysis. Lizzie Borden, John Morse, Emma Borden, and others were examined for over four hours, with Lizzie appearing visibly shaken afterward, though police revealed no substantial leads.

New-York Tribune · 11 August 1892 · page 1

EXAMINED AT THE PRIVATE INQUEST.

checked for the same plice. There was an intermission in the proceadings at the Inquest at 11:15 0% lock, A few moments later viarshal Hilliard drove to the Borden homestead and returned with John V. Morse, Miss Lizzie Borden was taken into the matron’s room. Mr. Morse was taken into the courtroom, but it is sald that he was not subjected to an examination. At 12:30 o'clock Miss Borden, Mrs, Brigham, Mr. Morse and the city marshal were driven back to the house In a close carriage. Miss Borden was asked some nerve shaking questions, and when she came from the matron's room her face wis tear-stainsd.

See moreSee less

There was a great difference betwean her appearance before and after the examination. A carpenter was at work In the Borden house about an hour this afternoon, shortly before 2 o'clock Marshal Hillard, Detective Seaver and Officer Harrington arrived at the police station carrying three boxes, Two were wrapped up and one was open. The open one contained sheet lead and was taken from the barn where oiss [Azzie said she had gone to look for lead for sinkers. In the afternoon Dr. Bowen, the family physician, and Miss mma Borden, the daughter who was In Newpedford at the time of the marders, were brought to the Central Station to be examined. Tonight it cannot be sald that the police have any substantial clew to the murderers of Mr. and Mrs. Andrew J. Borden. At 5 o'clock this afternoon state Dotectivo Seaver handed the following bulletin to the reporters: The inquest was continued at 10 o'clock to-day. Tho witnesses examined were Miss Lizzie Borden, John V. Morse, Miss Fmma L. Borden, Dr. S. W. Bowen, Ade. laido R. Churchill and Hiram (, Harrington. Adjourned until 10 a. m. Thursday. Nothing developed for publication, This was all that was given out after examinations lasting more than four and a half hours. The principal witness to-day was Miss Lizzie Borden. The change lin Miss Borden's appearance after her examination was the chief tople of conversation in the police station to-night. Whatever the police may think of the strength of thelr clews, it is certain that the opinions of Miss Borden's many friends are entirely In favor of her Innocence. This feeling is gaining more adherents every hour. When Mr, Morse came from his examination to-day he was as calm and collected as lle lias been since suspicion has been directed toward him. Miss Emma Lorden’s manner was less dis turbed than any of the witnesses. Dr. Bowen told a straightforward story covering the time since he was called to the Dorden house, a few days before the murder. He Incidentally gave sume evidence which ~tartied the authorities. The nature of tiuis will not be given for publication, but it was learned that to-morrow another examination of the dead bodies will be made at Oak Grove Cemetery.

See the clipping

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

The private inquest into the Borden murders continued, with Lizzie Borden, John Morse, Emma Borden, Dr. Bowen, Adelaide Churchill, and Hiram Harrington examined over four and a half hours. No details were released, but Lizzie's changed appearance afterward drew attention, while friends remained convinced of her innocence.

New-York Tribune · 11 August 1892 · page 1

EXAMINED AT THE PRIVATE INQUEST.

The words of this article are printed with the report it shares its clipping with. Read them there or in the clipping.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

The Oskaloosa Herald · Oskaloosa, Iowa

This early Fall River dispatch describes the brutal hacking deaths of Andrew and Abby Borden at their Second Street home, found just before noon on Thursday. It also recounts family suspicions that their food had been poisoned in the days before the killings, and refers to an unknown intruder as the presumed murderer.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

The Oskaloosa Herald · 11 August 1892 · page 4

DEED OF A FIEND.

A TERRIBLE TRAGEDY. Fall River, Mass., Aug. 6.—Andrew J. Borden, a respected business man 6S years of age, and his wife, a most es timable lady of advanced years, were literally hacked to pieces m their quiet home at 92 Second street just previous to the noon hour Thursday. It was a most brutal and shock ing murder, and no crime in the annals of Massachusetts compares with it in fiendishness. The house is a two and one-half story structure, surrounded by a well-kept yard with a burn, aud is located in a thickly-set tled neighborhood.

See moreSee less

The family con sisted of Mr. and Mrs. Borden, an un married daughter -Lizzie and a servant named Bridget Sullivan. Another un married daughter is aw ay on a visit to relatives. Poison la tha Food. For some days past Mr. and Mrs. Borden and Miss Lizzie had been feel ing poorly, aud Wednesday or the day before they suspected their food was being tampered with and that they were suffering from poisoning. They had determined upon an analysis, ac cording to the servant, but as far as can be ascertained were not in possession of any definite information which would confirm their suspicious. Wednesday afternoon Mr. Borden was so unwell that he did not attend a meeting of the Massasoit bank di rectors, as was his custom, and his friends inquired concerning his health. Thursday morning he felt better, and between 10 and 11 o’clock went down town and transacted some business in the First national bank. Thence he walked up North Main street and at 10:30 was seen standing on the corner of Anawan street, where he owns a handsome brick block. He gave orders to certain workmen and then crossed the street and walked di rectly home. When he entered his house the servant was in the kitchen and Miss Lizzie Borden was sleeping in her room upstairs. Father and Mother Killed. At 11:13 Miss Borden awoke and descended the stairs. She passed into the front sitting-room on the first floor and there, lying on a lounge, with his face toward the ceiling, was the body of her father. The head was covered with wounds from half an inch to 6 inches in length and the wall of the skull had been crushed in. One gaping cut ex tended from the forehead diagonally across the face to the shoulder blade and had evidently been inflicted by a butcher's cleaver or broad-ax. The unfortunate man’s blood had flowed on to his shirt front and stained the pillow. Mrs. Churchill, a neighbor, came in at this time to see Miss Borden, who retained remarkable self control. The two went to the mother's room in the northwest corner on the second floor, where, stretched in a sickening pool of blood, was the wife and moth er. The body lay between the bed and a dressing case, and the skull had been battered in apparently by the same weapon which had been used on Mr. Borden, although the nature of the wounds suggested that the murderer had dealt his blows w’ith the blunt edge. Miss Borden swooned and Mrs. Churchill and the servant at once raised an alarm. A few moments later the most intense excitement prevailed, when it became known that Andrew J. Borden had been murdered, though it was fully an hour before the details of the awful tragedy reached the pub lic. I.ittle Knouru of the Crime. Business in the center of the city was practically suspended and men in all walks of life flocked to the scene. City Marshal Hilliard sent several officers to the house and they are working on the case at present, while all quarters of the town are being scoured. Dr. Bowen, who resides near the murdered man, was the first to enter the house after the crime was committed. He learned the following facts: When Mr. Borden returned from the bank he removed his coat, put on a thinner garment and sat down on the sofa to read a paper. The servant, Bridget Sullivan, passed through the room on her way upstains to wash the windows. Observing Mr. Borden and remembering that he was not as well as usual she asked him how he was feeling. "No better or worse than yesterday,” was the reply. Bridget passed Miss Bor lea on the stairs. The latter went out through the room in which her father was sitting, and entered the barn to get a piece of iron, with which she intended to mend a flower pot. She thinks she was not absent from the house more than five minutes. She, too. noticed that her father was oc cupied with a newspaper, and merely nodded to him. When she returned the frightful scene which has been de scribed met her gaze. Dr. Bowen is positive that Mrs. Borden must have entered the room where Mr. Borden sat just as the murderer finished his bloody work, and that the fiend chased her upstairs to her room, where he struck her down, as the blows were in flicted by a person who stood beside her. No Cl#w. There is as yet no clew to the mur derer of Mr. and Mrs. Andrew J. Bor den. John N. Morse, who was sus j»ected of the crime, is now regarded by the police as innocent. The servant girl ia being watched. Five thousand dollars reward has been offered by the relatives for the discovery of the crim inal. Wealthy and Popular. Mr. Borden was a courteous gentle man who amassed a fortune when a member of the firm of Borden & Aiiuy, undertaker* He retired from busi ness many years ago and invested largely in real estate. He was presi dent of the Union savings bank, a director In the B. M C. Durfee Safe Deposit and Trust Company and was interested in several manufacturing concerns oi the city.

See the clipping

The Oskaloosa Herald · Oskaloosa, Iowa

This report describes the discovery of Andrew and Abby Borden's bodies on August 4, detailing the suspected prior poisoning of the family and the gruesome wounds found on both victims. It recounts Lizzie Borden's movements that morning and the spreading alarm through Fall River as news of the murders broke.

The Oskaloosa Herald · 11 August 1892 · page 4

Their Declining Years. A TERRIBLE TRAGEDY. Fall River, Mass., Aug. 6.—Andrew J. Borden, a respected business man 6S years of age, and his wife, a most es timable lady of advanced years, were literally hacked to pieces m their quiet home at 92 Second street just previous to the noon hour Thursday. It was a most brutal and shock ing murder, and no crime in the annals of Massachusetts compares with it in fiendishness. The house is a two and one-half story structure, surrounded by a well-kept yard with a burn, aud is located in a thickly-set tled neighborhood.

See moreSee less

The family con sisted of Mr. and Mrs. Borden, an un married daughter -Lizzie and a servant named Bridget Sullivan. Another un married daughter is aw ay on a visit to relatives. Poison la tha Food. For some days past Mr. and Mrs. Borden and Miss Lizzie had been feel ing poorly, aud Wednesday or the day before they suspected their food was being tampered with and that they were suffering from poisoning. They had determined upon an analysis, ac cording to the servant, but as far as can be ascertained were not in possession of any definite information which would confirm their suspicious. Wednesday afternoon Mr. Borden was so unwell that he did not attend a meeting of the Massasoit bank di rectors, as was his custom, and his friends inquired concerning his health. Thursday morning he felt better, and between 10 and 11 o’clock went down town and transacted some business in the First national bank. Thence he walked up North Main street and at 10:30 was seen standing on the corner of Anawan street, where he owns a handsome brick block. He gave orders to certain workmen and then crossed the street and walked di rectly home. When he entered his house the servant was in the kitchen and Miss Lizzie Borden was sleeping in her room upstairs. Father and Mother Killed.

See the clipping

The Oskaloosa Herald · Oskaloosa, Iowa

This report describes finding Mrs. Borden's battered body upstairs and recounts Dr. Bowen's theory that she was killed immediately after her husband, with the murderer chasing her upstairs. It also notes the lack of clues, suspicion shifting away from John Morse, and a $5,000 reward offered.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

The Oskaloosa Herald · 11 August 1892 · page 4

A TERRIBLE TRAGEDY.

The words of this article are printed with the report it shares its clipping with. Read them there or in the clipping.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

The Indianapolis Journal · Indianapolis, Ind.

The secret inquest into the Borden murders resumed, with Lizzie Borden appearing calmer and less followed by crowds. Analysts took bloody clothing evidence to Boston for testing, but police admitted they still lacked solid clues to the killer's identity.

The Indianapolis Journal · 11 August 1892 · page 1

THE MYSTERY STILL UNRAVELED.

The police have again become aotive in the search after evidence, and one or two details in regard to the missing letter said to have been received by Mrs. Borden, are being eonght by the otlicials. To-night it cannot be said that the police have anv substantial clew to the murder

See the clipping

The Indianapolis Journal · Indianapolis, Ind.

Bloody clothing evidence was sent to Boston for analysis as police hope forensic testing will yield clues, while the inquest continued with testimony from Lizzie Borden, John Morse, Emma Borden, Dr. Bowen, and others. Despite rumors and theories, officials admit they have no substantial evidence against any family member, and most of Lizzie's friends believe her innocent.

The Indianapolis Journal · 11 August 1892 · page 1

THE MYSTERY STILL UNRAVELED.

To-night it cannot be said that the police have anv substantial clew to the murder ers of Mr. and Mrs. Andrew J. Borden. Theories are plentiful, bat reliable evi dence is wanting. At 5 o'clock this after noon State Detective Seaver handed the following bulletin to the reporters: "The inquest was continued to 10 o'clock to-day. The witnesses examined were Miss -Lizzie Borden, John V. Morse, Miss Liu ma L. Bor den, Dr. S. . Bowen, Adelaide B. Church ill and Hiram C. Harrington. Nothing de veloped for publication." This was all it-At was given out after examinations last inc more than four hours and a half.

See moreSee less

' Whatever the police may think of the strength of their clews, it is certain that the opinions of Miss Borden's many friends are entirely in favor of her innocence. Dr. Bowen told a straightforward story, cov ering the time since he was called to tho Borden house a few days before the mur der. He incidentally gave some evidence which startled tho authorities, lhe naturo of this will not be given for pnblication. but it was learned that to-morrow another examination of the dead bodies will be made at Oak Grove Cemetery. Taken all together, in connection with an authori tative statement volunteered to-uisht, the police have presented very msuflicient and meager evidence against any member of the family, and the evidence that has been presented is such that it would be danger ous to proceed upon it. The Daily News published the following In a late edition to-night: "A physician who has figured as prominent in the ip vestisatiou of the Borden mystery as any one that can be mentioned, cited a hypo thetical case this morning, whioh would indicate that he has been undergoing a change of sentiment. From the first he has made no secret of bis personal opinion that Miss Lizzio Borden was probably

See the clipping

The Indianapolis Journal · Indianapolis, Ind.

A doctor investigating the Borden case poses a hypothetical about a resolute woman using poison twice, seemingly casting doubt on the prussic acid theory. Police also bring boxes of sheet lead from the Borden barn to the station, tied to Lizzie's account of searching there for sinkers.

The Indianapolis Journal · 11 August 1892 · page 1

A carpenter was at work in the Borden bouse about an hour this afternoon. Short ly before 2 o'clock Marshal Milliard, de tective Beaver and officer Harrington ar rived at the police-station carrying three boxes. Two were wrapped up, but the open one contained sheet lead, and was taken from the barn where Miss Lizzie said she had gone to look for lead for sinkers.

See the clipping

Daily Kennebec Journal · Augusta, Me.

The inquest into the Borden murders continued, with Lizzie Borden, John Morse, Emma Borden, Dr. Bowen, and others examined for over four hours. Dr. Bowen reportedly gave startling evidence, and another examination of the bodies was expected the next day.

Daily Kennebec Journal · 11 August 1892 · page 1

And John W. Morse Testified ar Borden Inquest. Dr. jBowen Gave } Testimony That Greatly Startled Authorities And Will Lead to the Farther I lamination ot

See the clipping

The Helena Independent · Helena, Mont.

The Fall River inquest into the Borden murders continued with testimony from Lizzie Borden, John Morse, Emma Borden, Dr. Bowen, and others, but officials released nothing substantive to the press. Police privately admit they lack sufficient evidence to charge any family member, though Dr. Bowen reportedly gave startling testimony and another body examination is planned.

The Helena Independent · 11 August 1892 · page 1

THE BORDEN MURDER. Nothing Given Out From the Inquestto Shed Light on It. FALL Riven, Mass., Aug. 10.-To-night ii cannot be said that the police have any Mrs. Borden, Theories are plentiful. but substantial clue to the murderer of Mr. and reliable evidence is wanting. State Detect

See the clipping

Gloucester County Democrat · Woodbury, N.J.

The report describes a follow-up police search of the Borden house in Fall Rise, Mass., with officers examining the chimney and cellar without finding tangible evidence. It notes suspicion falling on daughter Lizzie Borden, whose demeanor during questioning was seen as evasive compared to her sister Emma's.

Gloucester County Democrat · 11 August 1892 · page 2

NO CLEW TO THE PERPETRATORS

John W. Morse, are implicated. Fall River, Mass., Aug. ‘J.—1The po lice are very active in tiie Borden mur der cases. Yesterday Captain Desmond, accompanied by a sergeant and two offi cers, went to the house and fustituted another search. Places in the old fash ioned chimney were opened in a vain search for clews. The officers also pulled over everything in the cellar, but with out obtaining any tangible results, while the search was going on Misses Emma and Lizzie Borden were even more gracious to the officer* than they were on Saturday after the funeral.

See moreSee less

One of the searching party who came from the house states that, in conversa tion, Miss Emma Borden looked a per son in the eye, but Miss Lizzie in varia bly turned her head when questioned closely. The guard is still kept on the house, but the officers are under instructions not to molest the inmates nor interfere with their freedom in going about tlie city. If any attempts are made to leave the city, however, arrests will follow.

See the clipping

In the story →

The Evening World · New York, N.Y.

At the resumed Borden inquest, witnesses Charles Sawyer and officer George Allen testified about discovering the bodies and the scene after the murders. Marshal Hilliard said three outside clues were being pursued, none implicating a family member, after two earlier suspects were cleared.

The Evening World · 11 August 1892 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

MAY CLEAR LIZZIE BORDEN.

Three Outside Clues to the Fall River Murders Being Traced.

See moreSee less

Close Medical Examinations to Be a Feature of the Case.

'BY ASSOCIATED PRESS.' FALL RIVER, Mass., Aug. 11.—The Borden inquest was resumed this morning. Charles Sawyer, who guarded the door of the house while Officer Allen ran to the Central Station, was the first witness. He testified that he ran to the house when he saw Mrs. Russell running, and that he was with Officer Doherty and an Associated Press reporter when Dr. Bowen discovered that Mrs. Borden did not die of heart disease.

Officer George Allen was called, and he testified to having seen Mr. Borden lying on the sofa, stabbed, as he supposed. His story added no new light to the crime.

Mrs. Perry Gifford was being examined at 12 o'clock.

Last night Officer Harrington went to Boston to identify a suspect answering a description of a "wild-looking man," seen last Thursday morning by the doctor as he was driving by the Borden House. The suspect was not the man.

The police have also run down a suspect, who boarded the New Bedford train at Mount Pleasant and rode into the city. He proved an alibi easily.

Marshal Hillard this morning submitted to another interview. In answer to questions as to whether or not the police had given up all hopes of locating a murderer outside the Borden family, he said the question was nonsensical, but he would answer by saying that three clues were already being run down, and none of them would in any way implicate a member of the household.

He was willing to say that close medical examinations and their results would be a feature of the case, and that it might turn out that suspicion would be directed from the Borden family.

It has been proved that the suspected poisonous milk drank by the Borden family was all right when it was taken from the Borden farm and brought to this city. Members of the family in charge of the farm drank it, and they were effected in no noticeable way.

Last night Officers Hargraves and Horace guarded the tomb which received the bodies of Mr. and Mrs. Borden. Just what this means can only be conjectured as the police are silent.

It has become public that the order passed by the Aldermen asking for an increase in the police force, was inspired by District-Attarney Knowlton.

There was a witness at yesterday's inquest whose name was not given out by the police when the usual bulletin was issued. It was Mrs. Egan, who was seen to enter the Borden yard before the murders, mistaking it for Dr. Kelly's property, adjoining.

See the clipping

The Evening World · New York, N.Y.

The Borden inquest resumed with testimony from witnesses who responded to the crime scene, adding little new information. Police report tracking down suspects, including a 'wild-looking man' and a train passenger, both cleared, while Marshal Hilliard claims three outside clues are being pursued that would not implicate the Borden household.

The Evening World · 11 August 1892 · page 2

MAY CLEAR LIZZIE BORDEN. i Three Outside Cluoa to tho Fall River Murders Being Traced. i Close Merilcnl Kxamliiutlons lo lie n Kenture of the ('use. UT AiaoctATvb raraa t Fall Hitch, Mass., Aug. 1!, The nornen

See the clipping

The Evening World · New York, N.Y.

The report describes the ongoing inquest in Fall River, with witnesses Charles Gifford and officer Allen testifying about finding Mrs. Borden's body and disputing that Mr. Borden died of heart disease, while a suspicious man was pursued but not found. Marshal Hilliard addresses questions about three outside clues being investigated beyond the Borden household.

The Evening World · 11 August 1892 · page 2

MAY BE LIZZIE BORDEN

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

See the clipping

Der Westbote · Columbus, Ohio

The report describes the discovery of Andrew J. Borden's body with a crushed skull on a sofa downstairs, while his wife was found murdered in an upstairs bedroom. It also mentions the $5,300 reward offered by daughters Emma and Lizzie, and a pharmacy clerk's claim that Lizzie had tried to buy poison the day before the murders.

Der Westbote · 11 August 1892 · page 3

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

See the clipping

The Evening Herald · Shenandoah, Pa.

The inquest into the murders of Andrew and Abby Borden resumed, with Lizzie Borden, John Morse, Emma Borden, and others examined for over four hours. Police reveal little, but note a marked change in Lizzie Borden's demeanor afterward, while public sentiment appears to be shifting in her favor.

The Evening Herald · 11 August 1892 · page 3

SEEKING FOR A MOTIVE

1 :ivi nny Rubstnutlnl clow to the tnur tlcia of Jlr. nnd Mrs. Andrew J. Uordeu. Theories nre plentiful, but reliable evi dence is wnnting. Lnst evening State Dctcctlvo Seaver hnnded the following bulletin to the representatives: "Tho inquest wm con tinued nt 10 o'clock to-dny. Tho wit nesses exnmined were Miss Lizzie Borden, John Y-1Ioi-m), Miss Emma L. Uorden, Dr. S. W. liowen, Adelaide B. Churchill nnd Hirnra C. Hnrrington. Adjourned until 10 a. m. Thursday. Nothing devel oped for publication." This was nil that was given out after examinations lasting four and a half hours.

See moreSee less

The principal witness was Miss Lizzio Borden. Tho chango In Miss Bor den's appearance, after her examination, Is the chief topic of conversation at the polico station. Whatever the police may think of the strength of their clews, It Is certain that Miss Borden's many friends believe her innocent. Prof. W ood, the analyst, appeared nt thestatlon early, In company with Medi cal Examiner l5olan. Shortly after the inquest was resumed the two men were admitted and were behind closed doors about twenty minutes. When they reap peared they were followed by a couple of policemen carrying a trunk contain ing bloody clothing and other evidences of the crime. When Mr. Morse came from his exam ination he was as calm and collected as he has been slnco suspicion has been di rected toward him. Miss Emma Borden's manner has been less disturbed than any of the witnesses. Dr. Bowen told a straightforward story, covering the time since ho was called to the Borden house, a fow days before the murder. Ho incidentally gavo some tes

See the clipping

The Evening Herald · Shenandoah, Pa.

Lizzie Borden, her sister Emma, Dr. Bowen, and others were examined for hours at the inquest, with Lizzie's changed appearance afterward drawing notice. Police tensions emerged with the defense attorney, and chemical analysis of bloody clothing became a central focus of the investigation.

The Evening Herald · 11 August 1892 · page 3

LIZZIE BORDEN AGAIN EXAMINED.

The words of this article are printed with the report it shares its clipping with. Read them there or in the clipping.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

The Evening Herald · Shenandoah, Pa.

Police are increasingly focused on blood analysis evidence while renewing interest in a missing letter supposedly sent to Mrs. Borden. Tensions emerge between police and Inspector Hanscom and family attorney Jennings, while Lizzie Borden is reported visibly shaken after another round of questioning at the police station.

The Evening Herald · 11 August 1892 · page 3

LIZZIE BORDEN AGAIN EXAMINED.

murders. The polico have again become active In the search nf ter evidence nnd ono or two detaik in regard to the missing letter said to have been received by Mrs. Borden are again being sought by the officials. District-Attorney Knowltou is working under the direction ot Attornoy-GenernI Pillsbury nnd It Is said that the form of complaint and possibly all warrants will ba submitted to him. Much credit Is being given In polico circles to the work ot Dr. Dolan, who has practically neglected nrenumerntlve busi ness since he was called on to ac offi cially.

See moreSee less

The only complant against him is that his tonguo will not wug to other than official inquisitors. Miss Borden was asked some nerve bllnkimr questions and when she camo from the police station her face was tear stained nnd she was very much upset. There was a great dlirerenco betweon her apponrance before and after tho examination. The servant girl is kept under the eye of n policeman at her brother-in-law's houso and she was not allowed to go free as was Intimated last night by Detective Seaver.

See the clipping

Pittsburg Dispatch · Pittsburg, Pa.

The Fall River inquest into the Borden murders continued, with Lizzie Borden again brought to the station and authorities expecting formal arrests the next day. Analyst Prof. Wood took bloody clothing and other evidence to Boston for testing, with much hope placed on the results.

Pittsburg Dispatch · 11 August 1892 · page 7

Borden murder mystery, it is now confi dently expected that formal arrests will be made to-morrow. To-day the interest cen tered around the police headquarters, where the inquest was proceeding. Miss Borden was driven to the station this morn ing in a closed carriage, accompanied by

See the clipping

Pittsburg Dispatch · Pittsburg, Pa.

The report describes the ongoing inquest into Andrea Borden's murder, noting that Lizzie Borden was questioned intensely and left the matron's room visibly shaken. It also mentions blood evidence being analyzed, tension between police and Inspector Hanscom, and Bridget Sullivan being kept under police guard.

Pittsburg Dispatch · 11 August 1892 · page 7

BRIDGET SULLIVAN IS UNDER GUARD

ceding and succeeding the murder. Miss Borden was put on the rack to-day and sensational facts are looked for. Yes terday she was not pressed hard, according to a statement from official quarters made this morning. Mrs. Borden's Missing Letter. The police have again become active in the search after evidence, and one or two details in regard to the missing letter said to have been received by Mrs. Borden are again being sought by the officials. District Attorney Knowlton is. working under the direction of Attorney General Pillsbury, and it is said that the form of complaint, and possibly all warrants, will be submitted to him.

See the clipping

Pittsburg Dispatch · Pittsburg, Pa.

The inquest into the Borden murders resumed with Lizzie Borden, Emma Borden, Dr. Bowen, and others examined for hours, though police released little new information. A physician described a wild-eyed, pale stranger seen near the Borden house the morning of the murders, a lead police were pursuing alongside evidence like lead sinkers taken from the barn.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

Pittsburg Dispatch · 11 August 1892 · page 7

seemed as though this Government were de thuMar s terrific and the fluhintr of termined to avoid all investigation. No heajMhiv fireworks was something wondersooner were the Congressionalists in power iul this country. behold. The President speitt a quiet than Ej&n flopped with the agility of that aaJfKS o one called at the cottage. iteLfr-MZM wmm house about an hour this afternoon. Short ly before 2 o'clock Marshal Hilliard, De tective Seaver and Officer Harrington ar rived at the police station carrying three boxes. Two were wrapped up and one was open.

See moreSee less

The open one contained sheet lead and was taken from the barn where Miss Lizzie said she had gone to look for lead for sinkers. The inquest was resumed at 2:30 o'clock. Dr. Bowen, the family physician, and Miss Emma Borden, the daughter, who was in Bedford at the time of the murders, were

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

The Fall River inquest into Andrew and Abby Borden's murders continued with testimony from Mrs. Perry Gifford and Charles Sawyer, while police pursued various leads including a false clue in New Bedford. Officials expect the inquest to conclude soon, with speculation that Lizzie Borden may be arrested that night or the police guard removed from the Borden house.

The Providence News · 11 August 1892 · page 1

THE END IS NEAR.

attorney. Since Saturday no T’::stlons have been asked any of the members of the Borden household outside of the inquest except relating to certain business relations which Andrew Borden was said to have had with a man. It was found that he had never had any such dealings. The marshal denies that,

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

The report describes ongoing police investigation around the Borden house, including a false lead on a New Bedford man and dismissed business-dealings theory. It notes the inquest is expected to conclude today, with speculation that an arrest could follow depending on evidence and local sentiment.

The Providence News · 11 August 1892 · page 1

A DAY OF EXPECTATION, Before To-night, It Is Thought, Arrests May Be Made, FALL RIVER, Mass.,, Aug. 11.—To-day will probably tell whether the dark Borden mystery is to ever have an ade quate solution, Nearly all the witnesses whocan by any possibility know anything about the murders have been examined. The thing can’t be drawn out much

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

The police chief insists the department is pursuing leads nationwide, not just locally, while dismissing most tips from cranks and psychics as worthless. It's revealed that women posing as family friends—actually police detectives—have guarded Lizzie Borden every night since the murders, and the inquest is expected to conclude today with possible arrests.

The Providence News · 11 August 1892 · page 1

A DAY OF EXPECTATION,

out the country. He called the newspaper re‘Prosenutlves into his office and announced that he de sired it wunderstood that the depart ment was not confloing all its labors to the following of clues and theories in this city, and the residents of the city were not receiv ing the undivided attention of the officers and detectives. Every clue of every sort haus been investigated and will be {uveo tlfintod. 'he police are constantly receiving let ters from people, mostly cranks, in all parts of the country, offering suggestions and giving clues.

See moreSee less

Some of the writers have seen the murderer, others have found the bloody axe and others proffer their services in unravelling the mystery for n consideration, SoE Clairvoyants aud dream-book experts have written scores of letters, and there are at least a dozen from seventh daugh ters of seventh daughters. No attention whatever is paid to these communica tions, and though there are some ratner ingenious hints made by avonymous let ter writers, these, too, are discarded, It is an odd little faet that Mrs, Brig ham, who accompanied Lizzie Borden to

See the clipping

The Salt Lake Herald · Salt Lake City, Utah

The Fall River inquest into the Borden murders continued for a fourth day, with witnesses including Lizzie Borden, Emma Borden, John Morse, Dr. Bowen, Adelaide Churchill, and Hiram Harrington examined for over four hours. Police report no substantial clue to the killer, though Dr. Bowen's testimony reportedly startled authorities, and another autopsy is planned for the next day.

The Salt Lake Herald · 11 August 1892 · page 1

THE BORDEN MURDER

child died Monday Last evening Mrs Kester took another child aged 2 year und after trying unsuccessfully to drown him in a barrel of water carried him a mile and a half to a well and tossod him In drowning him Mrs Kester who de clared she was glad she killed them tried to drown herself but was placed undor ar rest vent suicide and is closely watched in jail to pre THE BORDEN MURDER

See the clipping

The Times · Richmond, Va.

During the ongoing inquest, Professor Wood and Medical Examiner Dolan examined evidence before a trunk of blood-stained clothing was sent to Boston for analysis. Lizzie Borden appeared at the station looking brighter, while servant Bridget Sullivan remained with friends in a calmer state of mind.

The Times · 11 August 1892 · page 1

EXPERTS CALLED IN,

Biood.Stained Garments Figure in the Bor. den Murder Mystery. Faris Rives, Mass,, August 10,—The in terest in the Borden murder cases is centre 10g around the Central police station, where the inquest is still going on. Miss Borden

See the clipping

The Times · Richmond, Va.

Professor Wood takes trunks of bloodstained clothing to Boston for chemical analysis as police increasingly focus on blood evidence over earlier poison theories. Meanwhile the inquest resumes with Lizzie Borden undergoing harsh questioning that visibly shakes her, while Bridget Sullivan remains under police watch.

The Times · 11 August 1892 · page 1

EXPERTS CALLED IN.

Jennings, counsel for the family. It is al leged that the former is endeavoring to build back fires to destroy the theories of the police, Miss Borden will be put on the rack to day, and sensational statements are looked for. Yesterday she was not pressed hard, according to a statement from official gnar tere. District Attorney Krpowlton is work ing under the direction of Attorney-General Villsbary, and it i8 said that the form of complaint, and possibly all warrants will be submitted to him. There was an intermission in the pro ceedings at the inquest at 11:15 o'clock, A few moments later Marshal Hilliard drove to the Borden homestead and returned with

See the clipping

The Seattle Post-Intelligencer · Seattle, Wash. Terr. Wash.

This digest-style report covers unrelated crime news, including Tennessee's commutation of a death sentence and a New York murderer's escape. It notes in passing that the Borden murder case remains 'as profound as ever,' with no new details provided.

The Seattle Post-Intelligencer · 11 August 1892 · page 2

A NEW YORK MURDERER ESCAPES No Hope for Murderer McNulty—The Borden Murder Mystery as Fro found as Iver, MEMPHIS, Tenn., Aug. Id—The city was thrown into a state of intense excitement when

See the clipping

The Seattle Post-Intelligencer · Seattle, Wash. Terr. Wash.

The Fall River police report no substantial clue to the murderer of Mr. and Mrs. Borden after a fourth day of inquest testimony from Lizzie Borden, John Morse, Emma Borden, Dr. Bowen, and others. Dr. Bowen reportedly gave startling testimony not yet disclosed, and another examination of the bodies is planned for the next day.

The Seattle Post-Intelligencer · 11 August 1892 · page 2

THK BORDEN MURDER MTSTERT. Fall River Police Refuse to Give Infor mation Concerning Investigations* FALL RIVEB, Mass., Aug. 10.— Tonight it can not be said that the police have any substantial clue to the murderer of Mr. and Mrs. Borden.

See the clipping

The Cheyenne Daily Leader · Cheyenne, Wyo.

The inquest into the Borden murders continued for a fourth day, with witnesses including Lizzie Borden, Emma Borden, John Morse, Dr. Bowen, Adelaide Churchill, and Hiram Harrington examined. Police admit they have no substantial evidence pointing to a suspect despite numerous theories.

The Cheyenne Daily Leader · 11 August 1892 · page 1

The Borden Murder Case. Fall River, Mass., Aug. 10.—To night it cannot be said the police have any substantial clue to the murderers of Mr. and Mrs. Borden. Theories are

See the clipping

Morning Journal and Courier · New Haven, Conn.

Lizzie Borden was arrested on August 11 and charged with murdering her father and stepmother, following a third day of inquest testimony that left her physically and mentally exhausted. The warrant reading was waived, she was searched by a matron, and officials including the district attorney and marshal conferred with the family's attorney before the arrest was made.

CorrectionThis set right 2 earlier articles: The Oskaloosa Herald, 11 August 1892, Pittsburg Dispatch, 11 August 1892.

Morning Journal and Courier · 12 August 1892 · page 3

No ConfldenceVote in the House of Commons. AN ARREST fflADE. ITIIss .Lizzie Borden Acensed of tbe Awful Traeedy She Takes Her Ar rest Calmly Her Examination Has Been a Terrible Strain Excitement Over tbe Arrest. Fall Eivkb, Ang. 11. Miss Lizzie Borden is utider arrest, charged with murdering her father and stepmother last Thursday morning at their home on Second street. Miss Borden was brought to the Second district conrt about 3 o'olock this afternoon, presumably to give far ther evidence at the inquest. Mas Borden was accompanied by her sister and lira.

See moreSee less

Brigham. As was the case yesterday, all proceedings were made behind locked doors. No offi cial announcement was made that wonld lead to any definite knowledge of the de tails. When Hiss Lizzie returned from the third inquiry she was a physical and mental wreck. She was conducted to the matron's room. The inqnest was ad journed about 4 o'clock, when Distiict At torney - Enowlton and other offi cials went down stairs to the marshal's office, where they were oloeeted for two hoars. Shortly after 6 o'clock City Marshal Hllltard and District Attorney Knowlton drove to the home of Andrew Jenkins, attorney for the Borden family for years. They returned about 7 o'clock and went upstairs into the matron's room, where Miss Borden was placed under arrest. The reading of the warrant was waived. Miss Borden took her arrest with surprising calmness, the two women with her being more affected. The excitement was great after the arrest, although some hoars pre vious it was generally understood Miss Borden would soon be arrested. She was searohed by Mrs. Russell shortly after abe was formally placed in custody, uther witnesses who were examined at the in vestigation are Ell Bence, the druggist, who is supposed to hare refused to sell poi son to the prisoner; also his assistant, Fred Hart, and Frank Kllroy, who was in the store when Miss Borden is alleged to have made the request. Their testimony is said to have olinohed the suspicions held by the police. The prisoner will be arraigned In the district court to morrow morning. She will in all probability be bound over to the speoial session of the superior conrt.

See the clipping

Morning Journal and Courier · New Haven, Conn.

The inquest into the Borden murders was adjourned, after which officials conferred and then arrested Lizzie Borden at the matron's room, where she took the news calmly. Witnesses including druggist Eli Bence and his assistants testified about an alleged attempt by Borden to buy poison, testimony said to have solidified police suspicions.

Morning Journal and Courier · 12 August 1892 · page 3

Over tbe Arrest. Fall Eivkb, Ang. 11. Miss Lizzie Borden is utider arrest, charged with murdering her father and stepmother last Thursday morning at their home on Second street. Miss Borden was brought to the Second district conrt about 3 o'olock this afternoon, presumably to give far ther evidence at the inquest. Mas Borden was accompanied by her sister and lira. Brigham. As was the case yesterday, all proceedings were made behind locked doors. No offi cial announcement was made that wonld lead to any definite knowledge of the de tails.

See moreSee less

When Hiss Lizzie returned from the third inquiry she was a physical and mental wreck. She was conducted to the matron's room. The inqnest was ad journed about 4 o'clock, when Distiict At torney - Enowlton and other offi cials went down stairs to the marshal's office, where they were oloeeted for two hoars. Shortly after 6 o'clock City Marshal Hllltard and District Attorney Knowlton drove to the home of Andrew Jenkins, attorney for the Borden family for years. They returned about 7 o'clock and went upstairs into the matron's room, where Miss Borden was placed under arrest. The reading of the warrant was waived. Miss Borden took her arrest with surprising calmness, the two women with her being more affected. The excitement was great after the arrest, although some hoars pre vious it was generally understood Miss Borden would soon be arrested. She was searohed by Mrs. Russell shortly after abe was formally placed in custody, uther witnesses who were examined at the in vestigation are Ell Bence, the druggist, who is supposed to hare refused to sell poi son to the prisoner; also his assistant, Fred Hart, and Frank Kllroy, who was in the store when Miss Borden is alleged to have made the request. Their testimony is said to have olinohed the suspicions held by the police. The prisoner will be arraigned In the district court to morrow morning. She will in all probability be bound over to the speoial session of the superior conrt.

See the clipping

Waterbury Evening Democrat · Waterbury, Conn.

Lizzie Borden was arrested and charged with the murder of her father and stepmother during an inquest session at the Central Police station, reacting with anger but no visible fear or surprise. Her sister Emma wept while Lizzie remained composed, and authorities arranged for her to be held in more comfortable quarters than the usual jail cells.

Waterbury Evening Democrat · 12 August 1892 · page 1

SHE TAKES IT COOLLY

I'ubllo Feellus Running High. Fall River, Mass., Ai 13. While the arrest of Lizzie Borden, daughter of tho murdered merchant,had been expected all along, yet when the announcement

See the clipping

Waterbury Evening Democrat · Waterbury, Conn. · and 1 other paper

The Borden inquest heard testimony from relatives and neighbors about family relations, while a second autopsy revealed a new bruise on Mrs. Borden's body shaped like an axe head. Drug clerks Eli Bense and Frank Kilroy testified that Lizzie Borden attempted to buy and possibly did purchase poison before the murders.

CorrectionThis set right 2 earlier articles: Evening Journal, 11 August 1892, The Oskaloosa Herald, 11 August 1892.

Waterbury Evening Democrat · 12 August 1892 · page 1

LIZZIE BORDEN

I.1ZZIK. HOR11EN. of the pro. ress of the case, which in the main uuavailin Mrs. George Whitehead, a step sister of the deceased woman, Mrs. Tripp, a neigh bor and Miss Kussell, who was placed in charge of the household, were examined at the inquest as to the relations of the family. The deposition of Mrs. Hiram C. Harrington was also taken. A second autopsy was held In the ladies waiting room at link Cirove Cemetery during the morning. Mrs. Borden's body was examined first. The new fact dis covered was a bruise on the back near the left shoulder about tho width of an axo and shaped like the head of an axe.

See moreSee less

It gives another clew to the exact posi tion held by Mrs. Borden when the deed was committed. Tho afternoon session began at 2:30 o'clock. The first witness called was Kli Bense, the clerk in Dr. Smith's drug store, who told the police several days ago that Lizzie Borden had tried to purchase poison at Mr. Smith's drug store. Benso swore to this statement, and it is said gave further information which materially strengthens that part, of the evidence against Li..ie Borden, which re lates to the poisoning. After the testimony ot Bense hud been taken, a drug clerk named Frank Kilroy was called. It was learned that Kilroy Is one of the witnesses by whom the Dis trict Attorney is going to prove that Liz rie Borden not only tried to purchase, but actually did buy poison. When Kilroy was through. Cashier Fred Hart of the Union Savings Bank, in which Mr. Borden is said to have kept his stocks and bonds, went up stairs to the court room. Mr. Hart was asked in regard to Mr. Borden's financial affairs. Threats of Lynching Marie. Salem, N. J., Aug. 12. Edward Har ris, colored, aged 20 years, was arrested yesterday on the charge of outraging Martha, the 12-year-old daughter of Thomas Lawrence, a well-known farmer, who resides near this city. The girl's parents left the house In charge of the daughterand Harris, who was employed on the farm, went there and assaulted her. Harris denies the charge, but Dr. Sperron, who made nn examination, says the crime was committed. There is great indignation and threats of lynching arc being made. Sullivan Identified. New York, Aug. 13. Daniel D. Sulli van, the alleged murderer of Anthony Haswell, who was killed after being en ticed away from home iu East Providence, li. 1., on the night of July 19 last, has 1 ccti fully identified in the Tombs Police .'..urt by the wife of the murdered man uiid a tenant. Reported Itattlo In Afghanistan. London, Aug. 12. Advices from Sim la state that another collision between Russians and Afghans has taken place. The battle was fought near Nerahasht Krnor ax reported killtd on both aid.

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • The Evening Herald · Shenandoah, Pa. · 12 August 1892

Waterbury Evening Democrat · Waterbury, Conn.

Lizzie Borden, charged with the murder of her father and stepmother, had a hearing and was remanded to New Bedford jail without bail. Bridget Sullivan, the housekeeper, was held on $1,500 bail to appear as a witness.

Waterbury Evening Democrat · 12 August 1892 · page 4

Remanded to New Bedford Jail. Fall River. Mass. August 12. Miss Lizzie Borden, charged with the murder of her father and stepmother, was given a hearing this morning. She was re manded to New Bedford jail without bail. Bridget Sullivan, the housekeeper. was neiu in tne sum ot s;j,uuu to appear as a witness.

See the clipping

The Morning Call · San Francisco, Calif.

The report announces that Lizzie Borden has been arrested in Fall River, Massachusetts, charged with murdering her father and stepmother the previous Thursday. It notes that the inquiry was conducted behind closed doors all day, with no details released to the public, and that she will be arraigned in District Court the next morning.

The Morning Call · 12 August 1892 · page 1

LIZZIE BORDEN ARRESTED. The Daughter of the Murdered Couple Charged With the Crime. Fall River, Mass.. Aug. 11.— Mits Liz zie Borden is under arrest charged with mur

See the clipping

The Record-Union · Sacramento, Calif.

Lizzie Borden was arrested in Fall River on the night of August 11, charged with murdering her father and stepmother the previous Thursday. The inquiry into the crime had been conducted all day behind closed doors, with no details released to the public; she is to be arraigned the next morning.

The Record-Union · 12 August 1892 · page 1

Miss Borden Placed Under Arrest. Fall River (Mass.), Aug. IL—Miss Lizzie Borden is under arrest, charged with murdering her father and step mother last Thursday. The inquiry into the crime has been conducted all day with closed doors, and none ofthe details have been given to the public. Miss Bor den was arrested to-night, some time after the adjournment of the inquiry. The prisoner will be arraigned in the District Court to-morrow morning.

See the clipping

Evening Journal · Wilmington, Del.

Lizzie Borden was taken into custody at the Fall River police station inquest room, ostensibly as a witness, and formally charged with murdering her father and stepmother. She showed no fear, only anger, and was denied access to visitors including her sister and lawyer.

Evening Journal · 12 August 1892 · page 2

LIZZIE BORDEN IN JAIL. She Is Charged with Murdering Her Father and Mother.

Dociles of the Victim. Again Examined. Fall River, Mass., Aug. 12.—Lizzie Borden, daughter of the murdered nier chant, is under arrest. She'was made a pris oner in the inquest room of the Central p<> lice station, whore gha was taken ostcuzibly us n witness. Even though the community has been iu some measure prepared for this terrible out come of the pending iuquost, Lizzie Bor don's arrest caused an immense sensation. .She was lodged in jail and access to her wo» denied everybody, even her sister Emms and her counsel coming under the ban.

See moreSee less

When driven through tho streets her fact was veiled, but when she lifted the veil at tho wurduu's residence her almost mascu lino couutouauce betrayed no emotion. I, wore the same tense, set expression which has been noticeable since tho tragedy. It is believed that her arrest would not have boon ventured upon unless some posi tive evidence hud resulted from the con tinued session of tho inquest. She Took It Coolly.

See the clipping

Evening Journal · Wilmington, Del.

Lizzie Borden shows no fear after her arrest while her sister weeps; police remain tight-lipped but a drug clerk witness suggests she purchased prussic acid before the murders. Medical examiners re-inspect Mrs. Borden's body finding a previously unnoticed wound, while a safe-cracker works to open Mr. Borden's safe for possible evidence.

Evening Journal · 12 August 1892 · page 2

THE OFFICIALS STILL RETICENT

iu waiting at the door. It wns evident all day that part of the mystery of the Burden murder was sup plied by the police. Marshal Hilliard and his associates are close mouthed. Not one wonl of official information was given to the public except Marshal Hilliard's brief announcement of Lizzie Borden's arrest. He even refused to tell the reporters who tho witnesses at the inquest were. The most important of these witnesses, so far ns Lizzie Borden's arrest is concerned, was Levi Bence, a drug clerk. It is presumed that he identified her us the purchaser of the prussic acid a few days before the murder; Tlie Hodies Again Examined.

See the clipping

Evening Journal · Wilmington, Del.

The bodies of Mr. and Mrs. Borden were exhumed for further examination but revealed no new evidence about the murder weapon. A safe expert from Boston eventually broke open Mr. Borden's safe with a sledgehammer after failing to find the combination, and police alone know its contents.

Evening Journal · 12 August 1892 · page 2

ton and he was sent immediately to tho Borden house and began work on the safe door. It has not been opened since the murder, for Mr. Borden alone knew the combination. Possibly the safe contains papers which will bo of value at the in quest, and it is surmised that it bides some evidence which will assist in determining tho motive for the murder. The expert worked for two hours at the combination and failed. Then be sent out for a sledge hummer and crowbar, and with a muscular assistant began to pound on the mass of iron and steel.

See moreSee less

For three hours the work went on, and finally, after nearly half a day's work, the safe opened and yielded up its contents. The police were on hand to take charge of the contents, and to them alone is tho nature of the matter known. To say that tho arrest of Miss Borden is beyond the comprehension of a great many people is not too much to say, for there are thousands in this city who do not now and perhaps never will bo made to lielieve that she was capable of the awful crime.

See the clipping

In the story →

The Wilmington Daily Republican · Wilmington, Del.

The inquest into the Borden murders resumed behind closed doors, after which Lizzie Borden was arrested and jailed, apparently as an accessory before the fact. A second autopsy on Mrs. Borden revealed a new bruise on her shoulder, offering a clue to her position when killed.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

The Wilmington Daily Republican · 12 August 1892 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

LIZZIE BORDEN ARRESTED. Held as an Accessory in the Murder of Her Parents.

Fall River, Mass., Aug. 12.—The inquest in the Borden murder case was resumed yesterday behind closed doors. Just what was developed at the hearing it is impossible to learn at present, but from the fact that Miss Lizzie Borden has been placed under arrest it is evident that facts have been developed which point to her as at least an accessory before the fact in the murder of her father and stepmother. Miss Borden was taken to jail at once.

See moreSee less

A second autopsy was held in the ladies' waiting room at the Oak Grove cemetery. Mrs. Borden's body was exhumed first. The new fact discovered was a bruise on the back, near the left shoulder, about the width of an ax and shaped like the head of an ax. It gives another clew to the exact position held by Mrs. Borden when the deed was committed.

See the clipping

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

A news digest reports that Lizzie Borden was arrested at Fall River, charged with complicity in the murder of her father and his wife. The item appears as a brief line among other domestic news summaries.

New-York Tribune · 12 August 1892 · page 6

THE NEWS THIS MORNING. Foreign.—The House of Commons divided on # motion of “ No Confidence” in the Conservative Government; and the motion was carried by a vote of 330 to 310. Alarming rumors about es f— Mr. Gladstone’s health were contradicted by his son, Herbert. France has taken possession of an island near Madagascar. Several persons were killed in a cholera riot in Asia Minor. Domestic.— Dispatches from Minister Kgan said that Chili had agreed to the establishment of a Claims Commission, to meet in Washington for the settlement of claims against her.

See moreSee less

t=—= Miss Lizzie Borden was arrested at Fall River charged with cowplicity in the murder of her father and his wife. Hal Pointer defeated Direct in the match race at Grand Rapids. Appeals for aid in the rescue work among the young girls in India were made by missionaries at Northfield, Mass. ——— President Schurman, of Cornell University, spoke on the relations of capital and labor at Chautauqua. Hugh McCurdy, of Michigan, way elected Grand Master

See the clipping

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

The report states that the arrest of Mr. Borden's younger daughter, following the mysterious murder of him and his wife last Thursday in Fall River, has been anticipated for several days based on police investigations. It notes detectives have built a web of suspicious circumstances around her, though a clear motive remains puzzling and previously worked in her favor.

New-York Tribune · 12 August 1892 · page 6

rag-tag and bobtail of Falstaff's army. To one feature of the debate in which a man up a tree might have espied a glimmer of humor the discredited party in power seemed insensible. Futile students of history may find it diverting that the Goverament, in debating the speech from the throne, should have twitted the Opposition with net having brought forward a pelicy. ——————————— That the arrest of the younger daughter of Mr. Borden, who with his wife was murdered under mysterious circumstances last Thursday at Fall River, would follow as the outcome of the investigations of the police has been plain for several days.

See moreSee less

Shocking as is the thought that the two aged people should have come to their death at the hands of a member of the family, it must be said that the detectives have woven a web of suspicious circumstances areund the young woman which calls for judicial irivestigation. The case has been lifted out of the ordinary criminal category, and will be studied henceforth with especial interest by those who concern themselves with what may be called the psychology of crime. The absence, or at least inadequacy, of all motive for the murder, so far as has been discovered, is one of its most puzzling features, and one which hitherto has acted powerfully in the accused woman's favor.

See the clipping

The Morning News · Savannah, Ga.

Lizzie Borden was arrested in Fall River after a third day of inquest testimony, charged with murdering her father and stepmother. She appeared composed as the warrant was read in the matron's room following closed-door proceedings involving the district attorney and city marshal.

The Morning News · 12 August 1892 · page 1

the Savsniuh Mobninij News and the Atlanta Ccns/ituiioa nave also exaggerated the affair at Jesup. The howling mob did not break through the militia and attack my bailiffs, neither did Bailiff Williams brain any one into insensibility with a rifle. I am sorry the dispatches In the papers were so exagger ated, as some inay think I was the anther of them. I saw two reporters in Brunswick tans night for a few moments only, and the dis patches ia to day's paters have been exagger ated from what I told them. I saw no mob at any time. John Ellis, Jb. LIZZIE BORDEN ARRESTED. She is Charged with Murdering Her

See the clipping

The Indianapolis Journal · Indianapolis, Ind.

Lizzie Borden was brought before the Second District Court for further inquest testimony and was later formally arrested and charged with murdering her father and stepmother. Witnesses including a druggist and his assistants testified about an alleged attempt by Borden to purchase poison before the killings.

The Indianapolis Journal · 12 August 1892 · page 2

LIZZIE BORDEN ARRESTED, Charged with Murdering Her Father and Step-Mother, and Placed in Jail.

They returned about 7 o'clock and went into the matron's room, where Miss Borden waa lying on a sola. The reading of the warrant was waived. The girl took the nnouncement with surprising calmness. Tho two women with her were much more visibly aflected. Miss Borden was searched by Mrs. Russell shortly after she was formally placed in custody. Other witnesses examined at the inquest this afternoon, were Eli Hence, who is sup posed to have refused to sell poison to the prisoner; his assistant, Fred. Hart, and Frank Kilroy, who was in the store when it is alleged Miss Borden made the request.

See moreSee less

Their testimony is said to have clinched the suspicions of the police, but it is believed in no way to have aflected the previous statements made by them. The city marshal's guard will be kept around the house for ., booth time longer. Miss Sullivan is .still with her relatives. The prisoner will be arraigned in the District Court room to morrow. In all probability she will be bound over to the special session of the Superior Court. , All the afternoon machinists were at work on the safe at the Borden homestead, but up to this hour they have not been able to open it. A second autopsy was held to-day in the ladies' waiting-room at the Oak Grove Cemetery. Mrs. Borden's body was exhumed first. The new fact discovered was a bruise on the shoulder the width of an ax and shaped Jjke the head of an ax. It gives a clew to the exact position held by Mrs. Borden when the deed was committed. The physicians also examined Mr. Borden's body.

See the clipping

The Indianapolis Journal · Indianapolis, Ind.

Lizzie Borden was formally arrested and searched, with inquest testimony from the drugstore clerk and witnesses regarding the alleged poison request. A second autopsy on the exhumed bodies revealed a bruise on Mrs. Borden's shoulder matching the shape of an ax head.

The Indianapolis Journal · 12 August 1892 · page 2

LIZZIE BORDEN ARRESTED

The words of this article are printed with the report it shares its clipping with. Read them there or in the clipping.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

Springfield Weekly Republican · Springfield, Mass.

The report describes the discovery of Andrew and Abby Borden's bodies at their Fall River home, noting the lack of a clear motive since robbery was ruled out. It recounts Lizzie Borden's account of the morning, the illness in the household, and the suspicion beginning to fall on family members.

Springfield Weekly Republican · 12 August 1892 · page 4

for the Deed Hard to Itungine— <Ucr| Fxeiirment nt Full River. Another peculiarly atrocious murder was added to the list of New England crimes last week Thursday when Mr and Mrs Andrew J. Borden were brutally killed Ht Fall River, the crime being committed in the home of the un fortunate victims in the full glare of dayJighL The entire absence of any clew rs to who the assassin was and the difficulty of imagining any motive, especially since it has been discovered that robbery did not in cite the deed, adds mystery to the horrors surrounding the crime.

See moreSee less

Andrew J. Borden and bis wife were two of the oldest, wealthiest and most highly respected per sons in the city, living on Second street, within a minute’s walk of city hall and the central business section. The Borden family consisted of the father, mother, two daughters and a servant. The older daughter has been in Fairhaven for some days. The rest of the family have been ill for three or four days, ana Dr Buwen, the attending physician, was suspect ing an attempt at poisoning. About 8 o’clock Thursday morning Mrs Borden received a note asking her to go and visit a friend who was ill. She left the house and shortly afterward her husband followed and walked down street to one of the banks. He re turned about 10.30 o’clock and sat on the sofa. In answer to a question from the servant he said he was very well. The servant, Bridget Sullivan, then went outside the house to wash windows. In the mean time Miss Lizzie Borden, a

See the clipping

Springfield Weekly Republican · Springfield, Mass.

An autopsy revealed extensive wounds on both victims, with no evidence of a struggle, and organs were sent for poison analysis. Police investigation turned toward John Morse and Lizzie Borden, especially after a drugstore clerk identified her as having inquired about poison shortly before the murders.

Springfield Weekly Republican · 12 August 1892 · page 4

MR AND MRS A. J. BORDEN VICTIMS

the body of the father. Morse is 55 years old and went to Fall River from Hastings, la., two years ago. He became very intimate with Mr Borden and the latter’s daughter, and spent a great part of his time with them. He went irom New Bedford at noon Wednesday and spent the night at the Borden house. He left there Thursday morniug at 9 o’clock and was next “eeu on the premises about 21) minutes alter the bodies were discovered. After the most careful searching it has been decided that neither of the victims engaged in a struggle, both being struck down in stantly and hacked to pieces afterward.

See moreSee less

The most important development iu the Borden murder case at Fall River Friday was the report that the police discovered late Thunda.y night that Miss Lizzie Borden had been in D. R. Smith’s drug store within 36 hours and inquired for a certain kind of poison. This information was obtained from Eli Bence, a clerk in the store. He did not know at the time who the young woman was, but on being taken to the' house where Miss Borden is staying, positively identified her as the one. Mr Bence was closely questioned by the police as to the exact time us Miss Borden’s visit, her apparent mental condi tion and the amount and kind of the poison called for. Miss Borden was also questioned by the police in regard to the visit. What she said, as well as the information obtained from Mr Bence, the police will not disclose to any extent. The demeanor of Miss Borden throughout the ordeal of being confronted with Mr Bence

See the clipping

Springfield Weekly Republican · Springfield, Mass.

The report describes Lizzie Borden being questioned by police about her drugstore visit to buy hydrocyanic acid, and details the funeral of Andrew and Abby Borden. It also announces that the inquest before Judge Blaisdell has begun, with Bridget Sullivan and Lizzie Borden questioned separately, though little was disclosed publicly.

Springfield Weekly Republican · 12 August 1892 · page 4

IMPORTANT WITNESSES EXAMINED

JSOOU Reward—The above reward will be paid to any one who may secure the arrest and convic tion of the person or persons who occasioned the death of Andrew J. Borden and his wife. . Emma J. Borden, Lizzie A. Burden.

See the clipping

Daily Kennebec Journal · Augusta, Me.

The report announces that Lizzie Borden has been placed under arrest, charged with the murder of her father and stepmother at their Second Street home. It describes her returning from inquest questioning as a 'physical and mental wreck,' and officials meeting privately with marshal and district attorney, including a visit to family attorney Andrew Jennings.

Daily Kennebec Journal · 12 August 1892 · page 1

ACCUSED.

Km Kivik. Aug. II. Mis* Lizzie Bor- : len is under arrest, charged with murdering H r father and step-mother last Thursday 1 Homing, at their home on Second street i Miss Borden was brought to Second di*

See the clipping

Daily Kennebec Journal · Augusta, Me.

After a closed-door inquest, Lizzie Borden emerged exhausted and was later formally arrested at the matron's room, with her attorney Andrew Jennings breaking the news beforehand. Her sister and Mrs. Brigham were visibly distraught, while Lizzie remained calm; a safe at the Borden home was being examined for a possible will.

Daily Kennebec Journal · 12 August 1892 · page 1

ACCUSED

Ksq., who had been the attorney for the Borden family for some years, lie r« turned about 7 o'clock, and went up stairs into the matron's room, where Mis» Borden was lying on tinsofa. City Marshal Hilliard had previously notified Mr. .lennings that he proposed to j arrest his client, and Mr .lennings broke the new s to her before the officer ap|*earcd ! The reading of the warrant was waived. Miss Borden took her arrest with stir prising calmness, the two women with her being much more visibly affected than she Her sister was greatly cast down, anil Mr*.

See moreSee less

Brigham -died tears. I.mma Borden and Mrs. Hrigliain were driven home. The excitement on the street »ie very great just after the arrest. Mi»» Borden was searched by Mrs. Bussell shortly after she was formally placed in custody. All the afternoon, machinists have been at work on the safe in the Borden home stead, hut up to this writing they have not been able to open it. It is surmised that the safe contains some important papers | possibly a will.

See the clipping

The Portland Daily Press · Portland, Me.

Lizzie Borden was arrested in Fall River for the murder of her father and stepmother, following an inquest conducted behind locked doors. She appeared exhausted after extended questioning, and officials including the district attorney and city marshal met privately before visiting the family's attorney.

The Portland Daily Press · 12 August 1892 · page 1

LAST WEEK. A Case of Circumstantial Evidence—It Needs Much Strengthening—Flimsy Nature of the Testimony—Charactei and Condition of the Alleged Parri cide. Fall River, Mass., August 11.—Miss Lizzie Borden is under arrest charged with murdering her father and step mother last Thursday morning at their home on Second street. Miss Borden was brought to the second district court room about three o’clock this afternoon, presumably to give further evidence at the inquest. Bridget Sullivan, the servant girl, had been summoned shortly before. Miss Borden was accompanied by her sister and Mrs, Brigham, who remained with her loyally during the hard scenes of the funeral and inquest as was the case yes terday.

See moreSee less

All the proceedings were con ducted behind locked doors. No official announcement was made that would lead to any definite knowledge of the details of the inquest. When Miss Lizzie returned from the third inquiry and cross-examination, she was a physical and mental wreck. She was conducted to the matron’s room leaning heavily on Mrs. Brigham’s arm. The inquest was adjourned about foiu o’clock, when District Attorney Knowl ton and other officials went down stairs to the marshal’s private office, where they remained Closeted for two hours. Shortly after 6 o’clock, City Marshal Hilliard and District Attorney Knowl ton drove to the home of Andrew Jen nings, EsqJ, who has been the attorney for the Borden family for some years. He returned about 7 o’olook and went up stairs into the matron’s room, where Miss Borden was lying on a sofa. City Marshal Hilliard had previously notified Mr. Jennings that he proposed to arrest his client, and Mr. Jennings broke the news to her before the officer appeared. The reading of the warrant was waived and Miss Borden took her arrest with surprising calmness, two women with her being much more visibly affec ted than she. Her sister was greatly cast down and Mrs. Brigham shed tears. Emma Borden and Mrs. Brigham were driven home. The excitement on the street was very great just after the ar rest. Miss Borden was searched by Mrs. Russell shortly after she was formally placed in custody. All the aftornoon machinists have been at work on the safe in the Borden homestead, but up tc this writing they have not been able tc open it. It is surmised that the safe contained some important papers.

See the clipping

The Portland Daily Press · Portland, Me.

After a grueling third round of inquest questioning, Lizzie Borden was arrested at the police station with her attorney Andrew Jennings present; she took the news calmly while her sister and Mrs. Brigham were visibly distraught. The case against her rests heavily on Bridget Sullivan's testimony about unaccounted time alone with her stepmother and father, plus pending stomach-content analysis to determine time of death.

The Portland Daily Press · 12 August 1892 · page 1

Shortly after 6 o’clock, City Marshal Hilliard and District Attorney Knowl ton drove to the home of Andrew Jen nings, EsqJ, who has been the attorney for the Borden family for some years. He returned about 7 o’olook and went up stairs into the matron’s room, where Miss Borden was lying on a sofa. City Marshal Hilliard had previously notified Mr. Jennings that he proposed to arrest his client, and Mr. Jennings broke the news to her before the officer appeared. The reading of the warrant was waived and Miss Borden took her arrest with surprising calmness, two women with her being much more visibly affec ted than she.

See moreSee less

Her sister was greatly cast down and Mrs. Brigham shed tears. Emma Borden and Mrs. Brigham were driven home. The excitement on the street was very great just after the ar rest. Miss Borden was searched by Mrs. Russell shortly after she was formally placed in custody. All the aftornoon machinists have been at work on the safe in the Borden homestead, but up tc this writing they have not been able tc open it. It is surmised that the safe contained some important papers.

See the clipping

The Portland Daily Press · Portland, Me.

The report details the police theory against Lizzie Borden, focusing on two windows of opportunity when she was alone with each victim, and explains how stomach-content analysis by Professor Wood may establish the time gap between the two killings. It also reconstructs Bridget Sullivan's movements washing windows and the discovery of lead in the barn.

The Portland Daily Press · 12 August 1892 · page 1

The Case Against Her. The presentment of the police against Miss Lizzie A. Borden now is founded almost solely on Bridget Sullivan’s evi dence, with the other corroborative tes timony on the case. From this, the offi cers require Lizzie to account for her time for one hour, from 9.30 to 10.30, or thereabouts, when she was entirely alone in the house with her stepmother, Mrs. Borden, she having sent Bridget out of doors to wash the windows, and also for nine minutes, from about five minutes of eleven to three or four min utes past, when she was likewise alone down stairs in the sitting room with her father.

See moreSee less

The theory of the government all depends on Professor Wood’s analy sis of the contents of the stomachs and the difference in time which may be shown in the arrest of their functions and digestion of the food later that morning at breakfast. The Mayor, Dr. Coughlan, believes Mrs. Bordp.n was .killed firstif so the post mortem digestion ought to indicate the fact. Her body was said to be com paratively cold when found, while Mr. Borden’s was warm and without symp toms of rigor mortis. The analysis oi Mr. Borden’s stomach will prove whether or not digestion ceased after it had terminated in Mrs. Borden. Uncle John V. Morse started out at about quarter of pine; Mr. Borden went down town at 9.15; Bridget Sullivan was sent out to wash the windows all round the house, by Miss Lizzie, at about 9.30. It took her nearly an hour. There were eleven windows. She began on the north side and worked along round by the back end of the house to the south side. In doing this she commanded a view oi the side of the door and steps and saw that nobody entered there during thai time. When she got round the south side of the house working toward the street she was out of sight of the yard. She was also out of hearing or any heavy sound of a fall in the spare chamber in the extreme northwest front of the house. As she came out to the street she came in view of the front door, she saw old Mr. Borden coming up the street, and ran round to the front door to let him in. This was about 10.40, and all the time Lizzie Borden was also in the house with Mrs. Borden. Bridget went up to her room at about five minutes of 11. She left Lizzie smooth ing the pillows for her father’s nap or the lounge. She threw herself on hei bed after attending to little things, bu1 in less than five minutes Lizzie called her. She descended to find Mr. Border dead. Officer Medley found the lead in the barn that Lizzie was after to make sink ers. There was about 20 pounds of leal lead in a little jug to the left of the dooi at which she entered, and, and two feet six inches from it there was a lot of pipe lead in plain sight four feet, eight inclief from the door. There was no lead in the barn chamber, and Lizzie says she wat out there 20 minutes. That, in brief out line, is the government’s theory against Lizzie A. Borden, and the points she will have to meot, if called upon. List of Witnesses The witnesses examined this morning were: Mrs. George W. Whitehead ol 30 Second street; Charles Sawyer, the painter, from 78 Second street; Miss Lil lian Russell, Miss Tripp, who keeps a restaurant on Second street, and Mrs,

See the clipping

St. Paul Daily Globe · Saint Paul, Minn.

Lizzie Borden was arrested at 6 p.m. on charges of murdering her father and mother, causing intense excitement in Fall River. She was jailed and denied visitors, including her sister and counsel, with her arrest reportedly prompted by evidence from the ongoing inquest.

St. Paul Daily Globe · 12 August 1892 · page 1

MISS BORDEN ARRESTED. Her Incarceration Causes Intense Incitement at Fall River, Fall Kivek, Mass., Aug. 11.— The arrest of Mtss Lizzie Bordeu, charged with the murder of her father and

See the clipping

The Beatrice Daily Express · Beatrice, Neb.

Fall River authorities arrested Lizzie Borden on charges of murdering her father and mother following the ongoing inquest. She was jailed immediately, barred from seeing even her lawyer, and showed no emotion when her veil was lifted in public.

The Beatrice Daily Express · 12 August 1892 · page 1

I.lxzle Borden Arrtuted. Fall River, Mass., Aug 13.—The arrest of Miss Lizzie Borden, charged with the murder of her father and mother, was brought al>ont at »> o'clock p. m. Even though the community lias been in some measure prepared for this terrible outcome' by the pending inquest, Lizzie Borden's arrest caused an immense sensation. Bho was bulged in jail, and access was denied to her by everybody, even her counsel coming under the ban. When driven through the streets her face was veiled. When she lifted her veil at the warden's resi dence it betrayed no emotion. It is lielieved that her arrest would not have been ventured ujioti unless some positive evidence had resulted from the con tinued session of t lie inquest yesterday.

See the clipping

Paper unidentified

Lizzie Borden was arrested at 1 p.m. on charges of murdering her father and mother, sending shock through the Fall River community despite being prepared by the pending inquest. She was taken to jail with her face veiled, denied access to everyone including her counsel, and showed no emotion when the veil was lifted at the warden's residence.

Paper unidentified · 12 August 1892 · page 5

I.lrtle llnrden Arrlsted. Faix Rivkii, Mass., Aug 12. The arrest of Miss Liexie Borden, charged with the murder of her father and mother, was brought about at I o'clock p. m. Even though the community lias lHen in some messnre prepared for this terrible outcome by the pending inquest, Lizzie Borden's arrest caused an immense sensation. She was lodged in jail, and access was denied to her by everybody, even her counsel coming tinder the ban. When driven through tho streets her face waa veiled. When the lifted her veil at the warden's resi dence it tot rayed no emotion. It is believed that her arrest would not have been ventured upon unless some positive evidence had resulted from tne con tinued session of the inquost yesterday,

See the clipping

The Durham Daily Globe · Durham, N.C.

The Borden inquest resumed in Fall River with testimony pointing toward a family member as the killer. A second autopsy found a new axe-shaped bruise on Mrs. Borden's body, and Lizzie Borden was placed under arrest while a locksmith attempted to open Mr. Borden's safe.

The Durham Daily Globe · 12 August 1892 · page 3

The Iiorden inquest was resumed yes terday morning at Fall River, Mass. Sev eral witnesses were examined and the evidence thus far points to a member of the family as the perpetrator of the hor rible crime. A second autopsy was held in the ladies' waiting room at Oak Grove cemetery this morning. Mrs. Borden's bod' was examined first. The new fact discovered was a bruise on the back near the left si ouhler about the width of an axe and shaped like the head of an axe It gives another clue to the exact posi tion held bv Mrs.

See moreSee less

Borden when the deed was committed. Misses Emms and Lizz'e Borden, Mrs Brigam and Miss Sullivan were brought to the police station this afternoon A locksmith is at work try ing to open Mr. Borden's safe at the house to determine whether or not a will was made. Miss Lizzie Borden is now under

See the clipping

The State Chronicle · Raleigh, N.C.

The Borden inquest continued with a second autopsy revealing a bruise on Mrs. Borden's back matching the shape of an axe head. Lizzie Borden, her sister Emma, and two servants were brought to the police station, and Lizzie was placed under arrest.

The State Chronicle · 12 August 1892 · page 1

IS MISS BORDEN GUILTY? Did She .Murder Father and Mother to Marry the .Man of Her Choicer By Telegraph to the state Chronicle. Fall River, Mass., August 11. The Borden inquest was resumed this morn ing. Several witnesses were examined and the evidence thus far points to a member of the family as the perpetrator of the horrible crime. A second autopsy was held in the ladies waiting room at Oak Grove cemetery thi9 morning. Mrs. Borden's body was examined first, The new fact discovered was a bruise on the back near the left 6houlder about the width of an axe and shaped like the head of an axe.

See moreSee less

It gives another clue to the exact position held by Mrs. Borden when the deed was committed. Misses Emma and Lizzie Borden, Mrs. Brigam and Miss Sullivan were brought to tbe police sta tion this afternoon. A locksmith is at work trying to open Mr. Borden's safe at the house to determine whether or not a will was made. Miss Lizzie Borden is now under arrest. Wholesale Exodus or Knights Tem

See the clipping

Griggs Courier · Cooperstown, Dak. N.D.

This dispatch from Fall River describes Andrew J. Borden and his wife as found brutally murdered in their home, calling it the most shocking crime in Massachusetts history. It further reports that daughter Lizzie Borden is under close detective surveillance and suspected of the killings, with an arrest expected soon.

Griggs Courier · 12 August 1892 · page 2

BRUTALLY SLAIN.

pected of Having Committed the Terrible Crime. AN AWFUL TBAGEDY. FALL RIVEB, Mass., Aug. 6.—Andrew J. Borden, a respected business man 08 years of age, and his wife, a most es timable lady of advanced years, were literally hacked to pieces in their quiet home at 92 Second street just previous to the noon hour Thursday. It was a most brutal and shock ing murder, and no crime in the annals of Massachusetts compares with it in fiendishness. The house is a two and one-half story structure, surrounded by a well-kept yard with a barn, and is located in a thickly-set tled -neighborhood.

See moreSee less

The family con sisted of Mr. and Mrs. Borden, an un married daughter Lizzie and a servant' named Bridget Sullivan. Another un married daughter is away on a visit to relatives. Mr. Borden was a. courteous gentle man who amassed a fortune when a member of the firm of Borden Aimy, undertakers. He retired from busi ness many years ago and invested, largely in real estate. He was presi dent of the Union savings bank, a director in the B. M. Durfee Safe Deposit and Trust Company and was interested in4' several manufacturing concerns o£. the city. ?.

See the clipping

Griggs Courier · Cooperstown, Dak. N.D.

The report states Lizzie Borden is under close watch by four detectives on suspicion of murdering her father and stepmother. It cites her alleged purchase of prussic acid before the deaths, an unsuccessful search for the murder weapon, and a financial motive involving a $500,000 inheritance.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

Griggs Courier · 12 August 1892 · page 2

FALI. RIVEB, Mass., Aug. 6.—Miss Lizzie Borden is practically under ar rest on suspicion of the murder of her father and stepmother.* She is under the close surveillance of four de tectives. The detectives engaged-' on the case feel confident' that their suspicions will be suf ficiently confirmed by further evidence' to-day to warrant the woman placed in, jail. Friday it was discovered that within thirty-six hours prior to the murder Miss Lizzie purchased four ounces of prussic acid at D. R. Smith's drug store, and an investigation is be ing made to discover if that was the poison which caused the sick-' ness of the old people.

See moreSee less

Eli Hence, the clerk who sold the poison, identified Miss Borden, She made no: denial of the purchase and claimed she' intended to use the prussic acid to kill' moths. Every effort has been made to find the ax, for such doubtless was the instrument with which the heads of Millionaire Borden and his wife were crushed in. Thus far they have been: unsuccessful For a motive the authorities say that Miss Borden would have cotne into po session of $500,000 by the death of the old folk and thatshe had been kept' down on amiserly allowance insufficient to dress and do as she desired.

See the clipping

The Evening World · New York, N.Y.

Lizzie Borden has been arrested on charges of murdering her father and mother at their Second Street home, and will be arraigned in District Court. The report notes she appeared calm despite the charges, that her uncle and the servant girl remain under surveillance, and that the inquest left her physically and mentally exhausted.

The Evening World · 12 August 1892 · page 1

UNMOVED BY ARREST.

District court room about .1 o'clock ycsler- ,t hU i da) afternoon, presumably to give further XB evidence at the Inquest, sho was nccom- ,' ; panlid by her sister and Mrs. Drlgham. AU .' ;m tho proceedings were carried on behind j, , locked doors. y When Miss I.ilo returned from the third (i 'fl Inqulr) she vt as a ph) steal ani mental wrecle' K .' and was conducted to tinmatron's room. p .; The inquest w as adjourned about 4 o'clock. f, m District-Attorney Knowlton and other of.

See moreSee less

"- rial then went to the Marshal's private; i ; ! office, w hero they remained closetod for two j nI hours. j . shortlyaftertlo'cIock.LllyllarshalllUllard r $W l and District-Attorney Knowlton. drove to tna, ' v homo ot Audrew Jennings, who had been the I 'fl family's attorney for some years. They re-.' i, -fl turned at about 7 o'clock and went lntp the M matron's room, where Miss Borden was lying )B nu a sofa. -H 1 he reading or tho warrant was waived. ifl -Mlssllorden took thu announcement of her 'JM arret with surprising calmness. Two women , fl who wero with her wero much moro visibly ' ' affected. ;H Tho ezclletucnt on tho street was very lH great when the news of the arrest became -E Mt known, although some hours previous it was! fl generall) uiiacrstoud that Miss Borden was I il sunn to bu made a prisoner. W "fl Miss Ilorden wis searched by Mrs. ltussell ll'l shortl) after she was formal) placed In cusfl ' fl

See the clipping

The Evening World · New York, N.Y.

The report describes Lizzie Borden's third day of inquest testimony, after which she was formally arrested at the Marshal's office with the warrant reading waived. It also notes she remained calm despite the arrest, while witnesses including the drugstore clerk Eli Bence testified about her alleged attempt to purchase poison.

The Evening World · 12 August 1892 · page 1

UNMOVED BY ARREST.

The words of this article are printed with the report it shares its clipping with. Read them there or in the clipping.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

The Sun · New York, N.Y.

Fall River police arrested Lizzie Borden at 7:10 p.m. on charges of murdering her parents, after a week of investigation convinced them they had enough evidence. She remained composed and silent as Chief Hilliard read the warrant, with her lawyer, sister Emma, and others present.

The Sun · 12 August 1892 · page 1

LIZZIE BORDEN ARRESTED. SHE LISTENS TO THE CHARGE OF MURDER WITH COMPOSURE.

Her Iron tVIII Stands Her In Oood Stead and Hho tValvea tha Reading of tha IV arrant-Her Sister at Mar Bide When Hhe wee Charged IVIIh Ilir Pareats1 Murder The Declelon Arrived at After m I.obk Coaanltatlen by tha Authorities. Fall BtvKit. Aug. 11. The Borden murder mystery, according to tho bollot of tho poltco ot Tall Blvor. la solved. At 7:10 o'clock to night Lir.zlo Borden was arrostod by Chief ot Police HUllard and nocusod ot homlolde. For ono wook tho pollco nnd othor proper author ltios have labored unremittingly to faston tho crtmoupon tho guilty person. Thoy bolieve to-night that thoy havo dono It Thoy aro sat lBflod that more than moro ctroumstantlal ovldonce justifies and domandod the arrest of Lizzie Bordon.

See the clipping

The Sun · New York, N.Y.

Lizzie Borden waives the formal reading of her arrest warrant before Marshal Hilliard, showing brief emotion before being placed in custody of Matron Russell. The inquest resumes with testimony from Mrs. Josephine Tripp, who describes Lizzie's strained relations with her parents, and from C. L. Sawyer, an early arrival at the murder scene.

The Sun · 12 August 1892 · page 1

SHE LISTENS TO THE CHARGE OF

morning with a conforenco botween Chief ot Police Hilliard. District Attorney Enowlton. and Medical Examiner Dolan. This consulta tion lasted until after 10 o'clock. Then Dr. Dolan hurriedly drove away. The inquest began at 11 o'clock. Tho first witness called was Mrs. Josonhine Tripp from West port She has known Lizzie Borden from n small child.

See the clipping

The Sun · New York, N.Y.

Witnesses at the inquest, including a sister of Mrs. Borden, drug clerks, and a bank cashier, gave testimony about Lizzie Borden's alleged hatred of her parents and her attempts to buy poison. Officials also confirmed the milk from the Borden farm was safe and found no will in Mr. Borden's safe.

The Sun · 12 August 1892 · page 1

TESTIMONY REGARDING POISONS

TESTIMONY nFUUDlNO FAnKONB. After Mrs. Whitehead had testified further in rogard to less important matters, tho wit nesses wero sont home, and the District At torney and the Chief ot Pollco hold another consultation, At Its closo both men went to dinnor. It was decided dollnltoly, however, at this conferonce to summon Lizzie Borden before Judge Blals doll at tho afternoon session, and, unless something unexpected prevented, place her under arrest at tho close of the session. Tho afternoon session began at 2:30 o'olock. The first witness called was Eli Benso, the clerk in Dr.

See moreSee less

Smith's drug storo, who told tho pollco several days ago that Lizzie Bordan had tried to purohase poison at Mr. Smith's drug store. Benco swore to this statement and It Is said guva fuithar information which materially i I ",fy,t,n I TfU-4 Jt&Km! Set' Itui'SiSia I :-

See the clipping

The Evening Herald · Shenandoah, Pa.

The report notes Lizzie Borden was not surprised by her arrest in connection with the Borden murders. It also mentions that the bodies were examined again as part of the ongoing investigation.

The Evening Herald · 12 August 1892 · page 3

The words of this article could not be separated from the rest of its page. Read it in the clipping.

No clean clipping could be cut from this page

The Evening Herald · Shenandoah, Pa.

The report describes Lizzie Borden being formally charged with the murder of her father and stepmother while ostensibly in the inquest room as a witness. She showed little emotion while her sister Emma wept, and public excitement in Fall River was described as intense.

The Evening Herald · 12 August 1892 · page 3

Continuation of the Inquest. The Decision to Arrest Lizzie Arrived at After Long Consultation by the Authorities. Public Feeling Running High.

The words of this article could not be separated from the rest of its page. Read it in the clipping.

Clipping to come

Pittsburg Dispatch · Pittsburg, Pa.

After a week-long investigation, Fall River police arrested Lizzie Borden on August 11 for the murder of her parents. She displayed remarkable composure, waiving the formal reading of the warrant through her attorney.

Pittsburg Dispatch · 12 August 1892 · page 1

Lizzie Borden Arrested for the Murder of Her Rich Father and Mother

The Iron nerve 'and wonderful self-control of the accused womac was never mora clearly manifested than when the warrant charging her with the murder of her parents was read to her this evening: This same woman, who yesterday seemed about to give away to her emotion, stood silent and motionless, without a tremor, when Chief of Police Hilliard entered the Borden mansion to serve the warrant upon her. Chief Hilliard

See the clipping

Pittsburg Dispatch · Pittsburg, Pa.

Chief Hilliard serves Lizzie Borden a warrant charging her with the murder of her parents, and she remains composed while waiving its reading. The same day, an inquest opens with witnesses testifying to friction between Lizzie and her parents and establishing the timeline after the bodies were discovered.

Pittsburg Dispatch · 12 August 1892 · page 1

SPECIAL TELEGRAM TO THE DISPATCH.

Knowlton and Medical Examiner Dolan. This consultation lasted until after 10 'o'clock. Then Dr. Dolan hurriedly drove away. The inquest began at 11 o'clock. The first witness called was Mrs. Josephine Tripp, from Westport She has known Lizzie Borden from childhood. It is said she confirmed the testimony already given by

See the clipping

Pittsburg Dispatch · Pittsburg, Pa.

Witnesses at the inquest testify about longstanding hostility between Lizzie Borden and her parents, including a dispute over property given to her aunt. Drug clerks also testify that Lizzie attempted to purchase poison before the murders, leading officials to decide to have her arrested after the afternoon session.

Pittsburg Dispatch · 12 August 1892 · page 1

SPECIAL TELEGRAM TO THE DISPATCH.

Whitehead quoted specific instances where the alleged hatred of Lizzie Borden for her parents cropped out Mrs. Whitehead explained, among other things, that she formerly owned a house in conjunction with another person. The other person mortgaged her intetest and the mort gage was foreclosed. 'Mr. Borden bought it and gave it to Mrs. Whitehead, and established her title to the property. It was learned further that Lizzie Borden is said to have objected strongly to this, and to have blamed her stepmother for persuading Mr. Borden to part with some of his money. Attempts to Purchase Poison.

See the clipping

Pittsburg Dispatch · Pittsburg, Pa.

A Boston visitor to New York discusses public sentiment in Boston, where many believe Lizzie Borden is innocent or acted insanely, citing her youth and lack of motive. He also praises the integrity of Massachusetts courts and judicial appointments.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

Pittsburg Dispatch · 12 August 1892 · page 6

BOSTON PEOPLE EXCITED Over the Murder Mystery at Fall River - No Apparent Motive to Lead Lizzie Borden to Commit the Deed - Massachusetts Proud of Her Judiciary

Seventh Avenue Hotel yesterday, and dis cussed the Borden mystery at Fall Hirer, Mass. He said the people of Boston were much exercised over the crime, as Mr. Borden was well known in the city in manufacturing and financial circles. "The general belief there," he went on, "is that Lizzie Borden is guilt

See the clipping

Pittsburg Dispatch · Pittsburg, Pa.

The piece praises Massachusetts's justice system for keeping details private during investigations, crediting this policy with low crime rates and few unsolved mysteries. It calls the Borden case highly mysterious, noting disbelief that a young woman, especially a daughter, could have committed such a brutal act.

Pittsburg Dispatch · 12 August 1892 · page 6

The History oi tne state is compara tively free from mysteries of a criminal na ture and the action ot tne authorities in withholding important information is large ly due to this. The police are discreet and seldom say anything that will interfere with the performance of their duty and as a consequence the escape of a murderer is a rare exception. This, of course, meets with the hearty approval of the public although they are fully as curious as people in other States. "The Borden case is certainly most mys terious. The brutality of the person who

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

Lizzie Borden was arraigned in Fall River police court before Judge Blaisdell, charged with the murder of her father and stepmother, and pleaded not guilty. Her lawyer Andrew Jennings protested that the inquest questioning had prejudiced her case since she lacked counsel during the earlier inquest.

The Providence News · 12 August 1892 · page 1

ISPECIAL TO THE NEWS.) FALL RIVER, Aug. 12.—This morning in the police court before Judge Blaisdell, another chapter was added to the awful murder tragedy. Miss Lizzie Borden was arraigned, charged with the murder of her father and step-mother. She pleaded not guilty. The accused girl entered the court room at 9 o'clock, leaning upon the arm of the Rev. Mr. Buck, the city missionary. She was attired in a dress of blue serge cut in prevailing fashion of summer outing suits, with high puffed sleeves and long train, the skirt was entirely plain and the bodice was relieved by a lighter row of ruching in the neck.

See moreSee less

She wore a black straw hat trimmed with black lace and four red rose buds. She walked with a firm step and with head erect, but plainly showed the effects of the ordeal she passed through last night. Her eyes were bloodshot and her face was flushed. The government was represented by

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

Defense attorney Jennings argued that Judge Blaisdell was prejudiced by improper questions asked of Lizzie Borden before she had counsel, while prosecutor Knowlton defended his conduct. The hearing was continued to August 22, and the report also describes Lizzie's transfer to jail and introduces family physician Dr. Bowen.

The Providence News · 12 August 1892 · page 1

than force, about seventy advances have been obtained during the year 1890, Tenements on the average consisting of three rooms (one living room amd two bedrooms) would rent for about ss. to @s. per month si.B2 to $1.44). The eheapest with doors facing a court or CONTINUED ON PAGE 2. robable cause why Miss lizzie should be Eeld for the grand jury. If the judge de cides that there 1s not probable cause Lizzie Borden will go without delay and canuot again be put in jeopardy. Miss Borden will remain at the station without bail, She will have no opportu nity, if, in fact she desires it, to take any prussic acid.

See moreSee less

The change of prisons, for the house 92 Second street, was virtually a nrison, miust be a very great relief, Toe blood-stained, gory prison at 92 Second street was a house of detention

See the clipping

In the story →

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

This report introduces the main people connected to the Borden case, including Dr. Bowen, neighbor Adelaide Churchill, and relative Hiram Harrington, along with gossip about Lizzie's rumored engagement and a past family tragedy. It also reveals that police officers reportedly decided on Lizzie's guilt within twenty minutes of arriving, citing undisturbed grass, lack of blood trails, and an axe found with blood stains.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

The Providence News · 12 August 1892 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

THE DRAMATIS PERSONAE. Some of the People Who Figure in the Great Borden Tragedy. FALL RIVER, Aug. 12--Dr. Seabury W. Bowen is the Borden family physician, and lives opposite their house. He is a gray, churchly looking gentleman, tall and dignified, and has always had a good name and been connected with the First Baptist church. His standing as a physician is good and he is liked by the public. Insinuations against him early in this case were promptly and properly frowned down. It was he who, in company with Officer Doherty, first discovered Mrs.

See moreSee less

Borden lying dead in her room. The doctor proceeding to the upper floor to try to find Mrs. Borden, saw her lying on the floor and exclaimed, "Why, she's fainted at the sight of Mr. Borden!" When a step nearer showed him what had actually befallen her. Adelaide Churchill is the widow of Charles H. Churchill and next door neighbor of the Borden family. She is a light-complexioned, fleshy lady of about 50 years; has long been a singer in the First Congregational Church and has a high personal reputation. Hiram P. Harrington is a brother-in-law of Andrew J. Borden, an old resident and a well-meaning man, who says he had business differences with the old man. The older citizens everywhere recall the murder, many years ago, by a Borden related to this very family, of her three children and her own suicide in a well, on the premises adjoining those of the late Andrew J. Borden. Lizzie Borden is said to have been very friendly with, if not engaged to, a worthy young man of Westport. MISS LIZZIE BORDEN.

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

The piece criticizes newspapers for gleefully reporting Lizzie Borden's arrest as though her guilt were settled, noting she has not yet been tried. It points out that reporters, excluded from the official examination, are spreading guesswork and prejudiced verdicts before the public.

The Providence News · 12 August 1892 · page 4

T :flty displayed toward the “At Last” in the morning pa . to indicate the pleasure of ; ot the arrest of Miss Lizzie ;“_ .In point of fact, whether the uilty or not of the murder or parcats, Miss Borden has not . the present time received X from the newspapers. ) arrested on the finding of umn of guess work and surmises have not been admitted to a single session of pound. the official examination, and, whatever knowledge may be in the possession of the police, the reporters have abso lutely no justification for trying her case beforehand, and spreading their prejudiced verdict before the eyes of millions, Hands off | Fair play, breth ren of the quill!

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

The report announces Lizzie Borden's arrest for the murder of her father and stepmother, calling it the climax of the case's first stage. It urges the public to treat her charitably given the weak circumstantial evidence revealed so far by police.

The Providence News · 12 August 1892 · page 4

“‘enterprise” upon the case permitted, it appears that the police authorities have given the circumstantial evidence that they have considered all the weight it can possibly be credited with, and that in arresting Miss Borden and formally

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

This item criticizes newspapers for rushing to judgment on the Fall River murders based on surmise and guesswork rather than facts. It argues Lizzie Borden and her family deserve the benefit of the doubt until guilt is clearly proven, while mocking sensationalist 'newspaper lawyers' filling columns with baseless speculation.

The Providence News · 12 August 1892 · page 4

JALL We are norrH the Call should advise giving the family to the doubt when of course it means that that the benefit of the doubt should be given to the fam ily. Aside from the grammatical slip the substance of doctrine is excellent, Lizzie Borden has been tried daily for the past week by newspaper lawyers who know nothing about the matter and who are writing their apologies, for brains out thin to fill the number of columns they think the jaded public will stand, X

See the clipping

The Salt Lake Herald · Salt Lake City, Utah

Fall River authorities report Lizzie Borden has been arrested and charged with murdering her father and stepmother last Thursday. A closed-door inquiry was conducted all day, with no details released to the public before her arrest that evening.

The Salt Lake Herald · 12 August 1892 · page 1

THE BORDEN MURDER CASE I Lizzie Borden Placed Undir Arrest for Doing the Died FALL RIVER Mass Aug SLizzie Bor den is under arrest charged with murder murer

See the clipping

Alexandria Gazette · Alexandria, D.C.

Lizzie Borden was arrested at Fall River, Massachusetts last night, accused of murdering her father and mother. Police express confidence they have the right suspect, noting suspicion had pointed to her almost from the start.

Alexandria Gazette · 12 August 1892 · page 2

Clinton W. Clapp, trustee of the Bap? tist Church of Wappinger's Falls, N. V., has been arrested for sending ob? scene letters to Mrs. Elizabeth Smith and other widows ofthat village. Secretary Meakin predicts that there will be 50,000 members of the business men's democratic organization enrolled in New York independently of the 10.000 dry goods men permanently organized. A fatal accident occurred in a coal pit at Besseoes. department of Gard,France, yesterday. While S miners were as? cending the shaft in a cage the cable at? tached to the cage broke and all were dashed to the bottom and killed.

See moreSee less

Lizzie Borden was arrested at Fall River, Mass., last night, accused of the murder of her father and mother. The police are confident that they have the perpetrator of the terrible crime. Sus? picion has been directed toward her al? most from the first. In the British House of Commons yesterday Mr. J. W. Lowther, parlia? mentary secretary of the Foreign Of? fice, in response to a question, said that the government had made no rep? resentations or remonstrances to the United States government concerning the McKinley tarilf bill. Heavy storms arc sweeping over Spain, and are doing an immense amount of damage. The rain is falling in torrents, and is destroying; the grape and olive crops. Much damage has been done by the rivers overflowing their banks, and in some places the low country adjacent to the rivers resembles huge lakes. -.??

See the clipping

Alexandria Gazette · Alexandria, D.C.

Lizzie Borden was arraigned before Judge Blaisdell on homicide charges for the deaths of her father and stepmother, pleading not guilty through her attorney's instruction that she speak herself. The case was continued to August 22, with Morse and Bridget Sullivan held as witnesses on $500 bonds while Borden was committed without bail.

Alexandria Gazette · 12 August 1892 · page 2

Miss Horden Committed. Fall River, Mass.. Aug. 12?Lizzie C. Borden was arraigned before Judge J. C. BlaLsdell this morning on charges of homicide arising from the killing of her' father and step-mother. The court room was crowded by a motley crowd of curious people. Mr. Norse, Bridget Sullivan, Miss Emma Borden and City Missionary Back were present. Mr. Jennings, the prisoner's counsel, said he would.enter a plea of not guilty. District Attorney Knowl ton, who was conducting tho govern? ment's case, insisted that Miss Borden plead herself, and she did so.

See moreSee less

Tho case was continued until Monday, August 22. Mr. Morse and Bridget Sullivan were then held as witnesses in the sums of $500 each. Miss Borden was committed without bail. Tiie Borden safe was opened this morning. The contents will not be given for publication.

See the clipping

The Times · Richmond, Va.

The resumed Borden inquest in Fall River produced testimony implicating a family member, and a second autopsy revealed a new axe-shaped bruise on Mrs. Borden's shoulder. Lizzie and Emma Borden, along with Mrs. Brigham and Miss Sullivan, were taken to the police station while a locksmith worked to open Mr. Borden's safe.

The Times · 12 August 1892 · page 1

DAUGHTER CHARGED WITH CRIME

crime, A second hutopey was held in the ladies’ waiting room at Uak Grove cemetery this morning. Mrs. Borden's body was examined first. ‘I he new fact discovered was a bruise on the back near the left shoulder about the width of an axe and shaped like the head of an axe, It gives another clue to the exact position held by Mrs, Borden when the deed was committed. Misses Emma and Lizzie Borden, Mrs, Brigham and Miss Sullivan were brought to the police-station this afternoon. A lock smith is at work trying to open Mr. Bor den's safe at the house to determine whether or not a will was mada,

See the clipping

Vermont Phœnix · Brattleboro, Vt.

The Vermont Phoenix reports that Andrew and Abby Borden were found killed with an ax in their Fall River home, with daughter Lizzie Borden saying she discovered her father's body after hearing a cry. It also mentions a mysterious note calling Mrs. Borden away and earlier suspicions of poisoning in the household.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

Vermont Phœnix · 12 August 1892 · page 7

MUEDERED IN THEIR HOME, A Wealthy Itesiilcnt or Full Ittver, Muss., mid Ills Wire Killed with an Ax, Ami HitMimWinXtil Hi i n .n , ( i ,l ;i ( l,l Slj.tn ji,,t n. (', ,.. A llnllglitnt'liilriSll.pli inn. Another atrocious and mysterious mur der lias attracted the attention of all Xew England for a week past. Mr. and Mrs. Andrew .1. Borden were killed In their home at Fall 1 liver, Mass., on Tliuisdav. The crime was committed in the day time under very mysterious circumstances. Mr. and Mrs. Ilonlcn were two of the oldest, wealthiest and most highly respected per sons in the city, living on Second street, within a minute's walk of city hall ami the central business section.

See moreSee less

The Borden fam ily consisted of the father, mother, two daughters and a servant. The older daughter has been in Falrhaven for some lays. Tho rest of the family have been 111 for three or four days, and Dr. Bowen, tho attending physician, was suspecting an at tempt at poisoning. About eight o'clock Thursday morning Mrs. Borden receUeil a note asking her to go to visit a friend who was 111. She left the house and shortly afterward her husband followed and walk ed down street to one of the banks. He returned about 10::10 o'clock and sat on the sofa, in answer to n question from the servant lie said he was very well. The servant, Bridget Sullivan, then went out side the house to wash windows. In the mean time Miss Lizzie Borden, a daughter, according to her own story, arose from bed and walked down stairs, seeing and speaking to her father as she passed through the room. She supposed her mother was out. She went Into the yard and stepped into the bain. While there she heard a cry of distress coming apparently from the house and ran in. She went directly to a sitting-room leading from the main hallway in the house and there saw her father lying back on a sofa covered with blood and lifeless. She ran out again, shrieking, and her cries attract ed the servant and a neighbor. They made a hasty search for the mother and found her upstairs in a spare bedroom, lying dead, face downward on the llnor. Tlie women ran downstairs terrified and .summoned Dr. Bowun, who lives opposite, who found both of the ietims bejond medical assistance, and could do nothing but notify the police. Mr. Borden's head had been hacked to pieces, evidently with an ax, and Mrs. Borden's face and" skull were frightfully battered. The crime has caused great excitement in Fall lliver, and the members of the Borilen family, as well as a Mr. Shaw, a son of Mrs. Borden by her first marriage, have been under -the surveillance of oflicers. The morbid curiosity of the people has been so great that a force of police has been stationed in front of the house to keep the crowds from collecting. A search of the house revealed no definite clue. The instrument with which the murder was committed cannot be found. The daughter, Miss Lizzie, is under suspicion, and it is known that she attempted to buy poison at a drug store three days before the murder. The oflicers hae not divulged what they have learned. Mr. ilonlcn was .0 years old and his wife (17. He amassed a fortune in the furniture business, and his estate is Valued at not less than $.-'..10,000. The daughters have offered $.1000 for the apprehension of the murderer. Nobody was seen to le.ie the house, or enter it. The parade of the Knights Temnlar at Denver, Colo., on Tuesday was an impres sive pageant. Fifty thousand men were in the parade, which was levlewed by Grand Master Gobln, the governor of Colorado and other ollicials. Frederick Kayser, a Dayton, Ohio, mi ser, worth f.i0O,(KX), hanged himself hecause his only daughter, a cultured "ill who returned recently after a live vear.s' absence in Sweden, where she was studying music, urged him to stop gathering slop's and rubbish. Before Judge Eben Hutchinson of Chel sea, Mass., absconded, he prepared and eft with Ids law partner, Col. T. W. i'or er, a document virtually acknowledging many of the most serious charges pre ferred against him. This document show s that Judge Hutchinson used his hsch nosition to defraud not only a high class of justness men. but a large number of nciipie in the humbler walks of life. The toal amount which he stole is $170,000. . B. liobins, attorney and conveyancer. Philadelphia, lias disappeared, ami it is alen mat the discrepancies n which h Is uvolved aggregate $1.10,000. In the latter part of June it became known that liobins, as accounting warden of St. Mark's church, was several thousand dollars short n his accounts with tho vestrv. it is said that the deticit was made good by an offer of security. Ills family were left without a penny for their support and are now beug cared tor by a relative. A sudden llood at St. Paul. Minn., on Thursday night of last week caused the loss of three lives, and the wounding of many people. A gully on Page street which had been the natural outlet for the the waters from the country above was built over into a small culvert. The cul vert became dammed, anil tho water set back, forming a pond two acres in extent and many feet deep. The earthwork snd. denly gave way In the night and the water swept down on the low land below. Men, women and children were fished out of the debris for nearly a mile. A How Of l't in Is Olistcnlng tlu-oUKli coral lips Is certainly a pleas ing object, but a row of discolored. liesH'cled teeth in any mouth at all is a grevious drawback: add to this, that such a set or te. th i i,un,. ..' Cuinpanied by impure brcathundnnecan scarcely the great imriller of the breath nil, I iliiteii..inf the teeth, oJiviutes this state of the mouth comi.ieici.v, n-sciiiiig iih ueniai occupants Hum de structlon.and counteracting the Inlluence upon tli enamel of acid secretions In the mouth. tint kli it's Arnirn Salve. The best salve In the world for cuts, biulses sores, ulcers, salt rheum, feier lores, tetter chapped hands, chilblains, corns and all skin eruptions, and positively cures piles or no lay require! It Is guaranteed to gle p rfect satls foctlon or money refunded, l'ifce 2J cents ier box. Kor side by F. II. Holden Co Failed, jaded, tlrod, overworked women weak nervous, delicate and sulrcriug ones. iuc&o iiro tuo no-

See the clipping

Vermont Phœnix · Brattleboro, Vt.

The report describes Bridget Sullivan and Lizzie Borden's actions on the morning of the murders, culminating in the discovery of Andrew and Abby Borden's bodies. It notes the ongoing police surveillance, suspicion falling on Lizzie, and an unconfirmed rumor that she tried to buy poison days earlier.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

Vermont Phœnix · 12 August 1892 · page 7

MURDERED IN THEIR HOME

The words of this article are printed with the report it shares its clipping with. Read them there or in the clipping.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

The United Opinion · Bradford, Vt.

This dispatch from Fall River describes the brutal killing of Andrew Borden and his wife Abby, both struck repeatedly with an axe-like weapon in their home. It states no motive or suspect has been identified and that the killer vanished without taking money or papers.

The United Opinion · 12 August 1892 · page 1

AN AWFUL TRAGEDY.

Second street, shortly after 11 o'clock yes terday. Mr. Borden was reclining upon a sofa in the sitting room of his residence. Some one armed with an axe or a weapon of similar character came into the room and deliberately struck him on the head with the blade. To make his work complete he chopped away with fiendish fury until the

See the clipping

The United Opinion · Bradford, Vt.

This report describes the brutal hatchet killings of Andrew and Abby Borden, claiming Andrew was struck first downstairs and Mrs. Borden killed afterward upstairs with thirteen blows. It also recounts an alleged prior poisoning attempt on the household and describes Lizzie Borden's discovery of her father's body after returning from the barn.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

The United Opinion · 12 August 1892 · page 1

HACKED TO PIECES.

Fall River, Mass., Aug. 5. A double murder, with the perpetrator undiscov ered, Is the sensation in this city. Noth ing equaling this crime has ever created so much excitement in Fall River. Andrew J. Borden, who was one of the prominent, wealthy and most respected citizens of Fall River, with his wife, Abby Borden, were butcherefl in their home, 93 Second street, shortly after 11 o'clock yes terday. Mr. Borden was reclining upon a sofa in the sitting room of his residence. Some one armed with an axe or a weapon of similar character came into the room and deliberately struck him on the head with the blade.

See moreSee less

To make his work complete he chopped away with fiendish fury until the Head Waa Cut Almost In Twain. The first blow killed the old man. The murderer, it would seem, was inspired with intense hatred or was wonderfully cool, judging from the way he hacked at the defenseless old man. Not satisfied with that, the murderer went up stairs, found Mrs. Borden, and kiittd her the same way. Ere 'sunk the blade of bis hatchet or axe deep into her skull no less than thirteen times. A person could not have killed a dog in a more brutal fashion. After com mitting these fearful crimes, and without stopping to' secure money or papers, the murderer disappeared as mysteriously as he came. The whole thing was Done in Fifteen or Twenty Minute. From the testimony of those who knew the old people, it would appear that a pre vious attempt had been made upon their lives the day before by the use of poison. Everybody in the house, save one man, was taken violently sick after eating or drinking, and it does not appear whether the man in question, drank of the milk or ate the food. . . There is no doubt but what an attempt to kill the Bordens was first made by the use of poison; that not being successful, the murderer, who must have been a perk'ou of enlaauUlLy (ieawnniaad cbwneter, concluded to do the job in a fashion that would not admit of failure. The Dlsoovery of the Remain of Andrew J. Borden and his wife was rather a dramatic one. It was made by the daughter Lizzie, who was the younger sister and the special pet of the old folks. The woman is in a state almost verging upon insanity. She is confined to her room in the upper part of the house, but has the company of her sister, who arrived here late yesterday afternoon from Fair Haven, in answer to a telegram from Dr. Bowen, the family physician. ' Lizzie bad been ironing out in the kitchen. The servant girl, Bridget Sulli van, was up stairs washing windows. As nearly as can be ascertained, the time was close on to 11 o'clock. There was no one iu the house beside those mentioned, ex cept her father, Mr. Borden and her step mother. Lizzie stopped work to go to the bjrn, which is just iu the rear and very close to the house unusually near, on account of the limited extent of the yard. She was gone, as she says, not over fifteen or twenty minutes. Lizzie went into the sit ting room, where here father always spent his time when iu the house. She was al most petrified by the sight which lay be fore her eyes. There lay the body ot her beloved father with the left side of his face chopped in. It was like lightning from a clear sky to her. How such a thing could occur in such a short time was incomprehensible. W ith a scream the daughter summoned the servant girl, Bridget, and told her to run across the street to Dr. Bowen and have him come at once. Bridget did as she was told. Lizzie staggered upstairs in a dazed, be wildered way, trying to find her room. Then she Thought of II er Stepmother, and sought her with the idea of breaking the news to her. She received another terrible shock when she discovered the re mains of Mrs. Borden lying on the floor of the guest's chamber. This was the cli max, and she sank to the floor uncon scious, and did not revive until Dr. Bowen arrived. Marshal Hilliard and State Detective Seavey tried hard to get some information from the daughter, but she was iu a state where it was impossible to do sa All they could learn was that she knows nothing and could think of nothing. About John Morae. John Morse, a middle-aged man a via. itor in the family, who had slept the night before in this spare room where Mrs. Bor den's body was fonnd, stepped to the side door of the house shortly after the mur der, and was admitted, and has since fig ured in the incidents about the house and the story of the day. Inquest Has Re-gun Fall River, Mass., Aug. 10. Lizzie A. Borden rested last night in the old bouse at 82 Second street, her home. Bridget Sullivan reposed in the house at 65 Divi sion street, the residence of her relatives. Both were guarded by officers, the same same as in the past, one policeman keep ing watch over Bridget Sullivau.two look ing after the Borden girls and John Morse. Liziie Borden will probably be sum moned to the district court today to con tinue the testimony she began at the in quest yesterday. From the fact tbat she was in attendance a a witness, the prob ability of an immediate arrest has greatly diminished. The day was one of intense interest from its start The aopearance of BRADFORD, VERMONT, AUGUST 12, 1892. Lizzie Borden at headquarters, the incep WILL BE DESPERATE, tion of an official inquiry, the arrival of

See the clipping

The United Opinion · Bradford, Vt.

The report retells how Lizzie Borden found her father's body with his face chopped in, then discovered her stepmother's body in the guest room, fainting until Dr. Bowen arrived. It also notes the inquest resuming in Fall River, with Lizzie expected back in district court and officials like the Attorney General and Professor Wood arriving.

The United Opinion · 12 August 1892 · page 1

HACKED TO PIECES.

Inquest Has Re-gun Fall River, Mass., Aug. 10. Lizzie A. Borden rested last night in the old bouse at 82 Second street, her home. Bridget Sullivan reposed in the house at 65 Divi sion street, the residence of her relatives. Both were guarded by officers, the same same as in the past, one policeman keep ing watch over Bridget Sullivau.two look ing after the Borden girls and John Morse. Liziie Borden will probably be sum moned to the district court today to con tinue the testimony she began at the in quest yesterday.

See moreSee less

From the fact tbat she was in attendance a a witness, the prob ability of an immediate arrest has greatly diminished. The day was one of intense interest from its start The aopearance of BRADFORD, VERMONT, AUGUST 12, 1892. Lizzie Borden at headquarters, the incep WILL BE DESPERATE, tion of an official inquiry, the arrival of

See the clipping

The Seattle Post-Intelligencer · Seattle, Wash. Terr. Wash.

Lizzie Borden has been arrested, charged with murdering her father and stepmother last Thursday. The inquest into the crime was conducted all day behind closed doors, with no details released to the public, and she will be arraigned in district court the next morning.

The Seattle Post-Intelligencer · 12 August 1892 · page 3

Lissle Kunies Arrested. FALL RIVER, Mass., AUG? 11.— Lizzie Borden is •tt.ier arres.t, charged murdering her tsuier and stepmother last Thunwlay. luquiry feito the crime has been conducted all day with <fosed doors, and none of fche details have been given to the public. -M is»;Borden was arrested ♦sncht. some time after ournment of the in-

See the clipping

Iowa County Democrat · Mineral Point, Wis.

Lizzie Borden, suspected in her parents' murder, was briefly held by police before being released on condition she not leave the city. The inquest began the same day, with Borden and servant Bridget Sullivan questioned separately but their testimony unfinished.

Iowa County Democrat · 12 August 1892 · page 3

3 THE BORDEN MURDER CASE. Miss Lizzie Looked Upon With Suspicion —lnquest Begins. Fail River, Mass., Aug. 9. —Miss L'.zzle Borden, who was looked upon with sus picion in reference to the Berden murder case, is under strict surveillance by che police. This afternoon she was taken to the police station, bat later the district attorney told her that she might go if she promised not to leave the city without first acquainting the city marshal. The irquest began this afternoon. Bridget Sullivan, a domestic, and Lizzie Borden were questioned separately. The examination of neither was concluded and the inquest adjourned until tomorrow.

See the clipping

The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · Wheeling, W. Va.

The report describes Lizzie Borden's arrest on August 11 for the murder of her father and stepmother, following a third day of secret inquest proceedings. She reportedly received the warrant with calm composure, and officials noted the arrest, while not a direct result of the inquest, was justified by it.

The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · 12 August 1892 · page 1

LIZZIE BORDEN ARRESTED - She Takes it With Surprising Coolness - Result of the Inquest

LIZZIE BORDEN ARRESTED. 1 Hht TAltai it Willi surprising CoolnaM XUiult of the luqu*?t. " ? ? -? * i ?? ?n 1 ALL KtVliR, A1ASS., AUgUSl 11.?JU.I11 Lizzie Bordon i> under arrest, charged

See the clipping

The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · Wheeling, W. Va.

Lizzie Borden was arrested and taken to the matron's room, where she received the warrant with notable calm; crowds on the street grew excited once news spread, though an arrest had been rumored for hours. Police continued guarding the house and watching Bridget Sullivan and John Morse, while a city official clarified the arrest was justified by, but not a direct result of, the inquest.

The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · 12 August 1892 · page 1

" night and roported to him, and he was 1 willing to say that close medical exara? Inatlons ana thoir results would be a' _ featuro of tho case, and that It might turn out that suspicion would Da airoct-, 1 ed from tho Bordon family. It lias boon ,r proved that tho suspoctod poisonous !; milk drunk by tho Bordeu'family was, ; all light when it was taken from tho ; Borden (arm and brought to this city. J Members of the family drank it and 1 wero affected in no noticeable way.

See the clipping

Martinsburg Independent · Martinsburg, W. Va. · and 1 other paper

Police conduct another fruitless search of the Borden house, finding no clues despite examining the chimney and cellar. Lizzie Borden undergoes a private, emotionally difficult examination, while rumors swirl including a relative's theory that she and John Morse hired someone to commit the murders.

Martinsburg Independent · 13 August 1892 · page 2

NO CLEW TO THE PERPETRATORS

daughter Lizzie and his brothdr-in-law, John W. Morse, are implicated. Fall River, Mass., Aug. 9.—The po lice are very active in the Borden mur der cases. Yesterday Captain Desmond, accompanied by a sergeant and two offi cers, went to the house and instituted another search. Places in the old fash ioned chimney were opened in a vain search for clews. The officers also pnlled over everything in the cellar, but with out obtaining any tangible results, while the search was going on Misses Emma and Lizzie Borden were even more gracious to the officers than they were on Saturday after the funeral.

See moreSee less

One of the searching party who came from the house states that, in conversa tion, Miss Emma Borden looked a per son in the eye, but Miss Lizzie invaria bly turned her head when questioned closely. The guard is still kept on the house, but the officers are under instructions not to molest the inmates nor interfere with their freedom in going about the city. If any attempts are made to leave the city, however, arrests will follow. Hartford, Aug. 9.—George B. Fish, of this city, whose wife is the sister of the murdered Mrs. Borden, of Fall River, in a pnblished interview says that he believes Lizzie Borden and John V. Morse concocted the deed and hired some one to do it. Lizzie and Emma Borden are stepdaughters of the mur dered woman and have never been on good terms with her, owing to trouble over the division of a small property left by the girls' mother to Mr. Borden, who gave it to the second wife instead of to the girls. Fall River, Mass., Aug. 11.—An officer who is very close to the head of the department, says that he has no doubt of the ultimate arrest of some one of the Borden family, but which one he would not or could not say. Dr. Handy furnishes a very sugges tive hint as to the probable murder of Mr. and Mrs. Borden. He says that about 10 a. m. on Thursday last he saw a iqjin standing on Second street, a little south of the Borden residence, the man having such a terribly aunsual appear ance as to attract his attention. The stranger was gliastly white, and seemed very much agitated. The doctor coaid certainly identify the man he observed, as he was so struck by his desperate look ing character that he turned around his carriage and gazed at him for a consid erable time. The police begin to put some credence in this rumor, as it was said that a man answering this descrip tion was seen by Officer Hyde about the same time. The examination of Lizzie Borden was resnmed yesterday behind closed doors. It is said that Miss Borden was asked some nerve shaking questions, and when she came from the matron’s room her face was tear stained, and she was very mnch upset. There was a great difference between her appearance before and after the examination.

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • Gloucester County Democrat · Woodbury, N.J. · 11 August 1892

Waterbury Evening Democrat · Waterbury, Conn.

Reports claim a hatchet with a two-and-a-half foot handle and blunt claw head was found in the Borden cellar, showing blood spots and hairs matching Mrs. Borden's. Police believe this weapon, found near a bucket of water and bloodied towels, is the murder instrument.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out. CorrectionThis set right an article from the day before.

Waterbury Evening Democrat · 13 August 1892 · page 1

EACH CLAIMS IT KILLED THE BORDENS

Fau, River, Mass., Aug. 13. The as with which Mrs. Borden was killed has been found. That is the sensation of the day in the mysterious double murder case. The formal committment of Miss Lizzie as the assassin of her father and stepmother ranks second in interest to the discovery of the murderous weapon. It has just leaked out that one of the four hatchets found in the cellar of the Borden homestead, soon after the murder, was the instrument with which the butch ery was committed. It has a handle two and a half feet long, and a steel blade keen as a razor.

See moreSee less

Its blade and head are peculiarly shaped. The latter is blunt at the end furthest from the handle, and has a claw for pull ing nails at the other end. Under the microscope it shows many spots of human blood. That it was care fully washed there Is no doubt, for a bucket of water was found near it, and also three new towels, partially covered with blood. The water had been splashed over the cellar floor. Lizzie Borden was asked at the time the ax was found about these towels, and she said that they had been used by a woman in illness. The wounds in the head of Mrs. Borden fit the blunt end of the hatchet head. The weapon also show ed some long hairs, which matched those in Mrs. Borden's head. The police are now satisfied that this instrument was used by the author of the crime.

See the clipping

The Evening Herald · Shenandoah, Pa. · and 1 other paper

The report describes a long-handled axe-like weapon found in the Borden cellar, with bloodstains, hair matching Abby Borden, and bloody towels nearby, which police believed was the murder weapon. It also describes Lizzie Borden's calm, unemotional demeanor as she was taken to her jail cell in Taunton after her arraignment.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Evening Herald · 13 August 1892 · page 3

Taunton, Mass., Aug. 13. Miss Lizzie Borden, who pleaded not guilty to the charge of murdering her father and step mother at Fall River, and who was com mitted to tho jail here without ball, takes her confinement in a cell with remarkable composure. She shows not the slightest sign of wenV(-....,g, but bears herself with the samo firu.aess that has characterized her during the trying days of tho past week. Her entry into the city took the form of a public ceremonial. Excitement was high. Arriving at the Central passonger stntion.Wiss Borden was conducted to a curtained, hack by Hev.

See moreSee less

Mr. Buck and City Marslial Hllliard, Detective Seaver acting ns guard and clearing tho way. Arriving at the jail she was at ouco put in a cell, tho minister conducting her to tlie door nnd Marshal Hilllard seeing that tho door was properly secured. Mrs. Wright, wife of Sheriff Wright, an old friend of the Borden family hur ried to tho cell with a' glass of water, which the prisoner eagerly drank. When Miss Burden entered the jail office her face was composed and there was no sign of consciousness given ns she passed towards the corridor, apparently seeing nothing and noticing no one. The sheriff stood by the inner door, and lie was affected almost to tears, as ho saw the daughter of his old friend passing to apartments usually occupied by the most degraded females. Minister Buck emerged from the cell room white and ugitated, but not disposed-to talk. Swimming Contests at Asbury Park. AsBuity Tauk, N. J., Aug. 13. The ocean swimming contests attracted 20,000 people to tlie beach. Thero were 40 en tries in the match for men. The course was from the wave power pier in Ocean Grove to tho fishing pier in Asbury Park, a distance of 700 leet. The prizes were a gold medal -and a diamond scarf pin. The match was won by Charles MoUtuley of Brooklyn, Ealph D. Paine, of the Yalo football tenm, being second. The ladies' niatch brought out four entries, and wus won by Mrs. II. I McLean of New York city. Miss Bessie Smith of Asbury Park was second. A Mysterious IHsuiiiieuronce. Midmjetow.y, Conn., Aug . 13. Great excitemeut prevails at Middle-field over the disappearance of Capt. Henry Miller, very wealthy and influential citizen. He was seeu last Thursday evening by his nephew, Henry Ives, but now cannot be found. Searching parties have scoured the country and drawn off ponds here abouts, but no trace of Mr, Miller has been diseoveiod. He was about bO yuars of age, uumairied and eccentric. He wore long, white hair. Stone Cullers' btrlke On. NEWARK, N. J., Aug. 18. A commit tee of stone cutters have waited ou the bosses and notified the Utter that the men had declartnl the strike olf. This means that the men go back on worse terms and work 48 hours Instead of 44 per week. Nou-uulon men will not be discharged to make places for the strik ers. The year Is to begin March 1. llutl Four Seta ot Twins. Boov, Mioh., Aug. 13. Ten years ago Mrs. W. M. Smith made her husband hup py by giving birth tp twlus. Eight yours ago she repeated the operation, and three years ago again astonished him by bear ing two mare, lusty babies. But tho groat surprise came yesterday, when sho gave birth to her fourth twins. The eight children are all healthy uud well.

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • Waterbury Evening Democrat · Waterbury, Conn. · 13 August 1892

The Record-Union · Sacramento, Calif.

Lizzie Borden was arraigned in Fall River district court, pleaded not guilty to killing her father and stepmother, and was committed without bail with trial set for August 22. Police reportedly possess a peculiar claw-hatchet believed to match the wounds, though the marshal cautioned much remained to be proven.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day. CorrectionThis set right an article from the day before.

Wrong

The Record-Union · 13 August 1892 · page 1

Fall River, Aug. 12.—Lizzie Borden was arraigned m the Second District Court this morning, charged with killing 1" r fiather and Btepmother. Tho prisoner pleaded not guilty to tho charge, and Monday, August __d, was set for the trial. .Miss Borden was committed with out bail. The prisoner was taken to Tauuton this evening and lock< d up. There arc strong rumors this evening that the police have procured the hatchet With Which the crime was committed. The police are in possession of a peculiar hatchet, and the rumor that this particu lar hatchet was used is greatly strength ened by the strong wording of City Mar shal Hilliard's complaint, published to day.

See moreSee less

No hatchet liko the one in custody can be found in the local hardware stores, its greatest peculiarity is a claw on tho side nearest the handle. It is said the hatchet fits into tho murderous wounds in Mrs. Borden's head. To-night Marshal Billiard said thero was a great thai yet to be proven before the crime could be finally fastened apon Miss Borden. Much had been learned, but for all that he could see that tho trial would be long and tedious.

See the clipping

Evening Journal · Wilmington, Del.

The report claims the murder weapon has been found among hatchets in the Borden cellar, with human blood and hair matching Mrs. Borden under microscope examination, plus evidence of washing. It also notes Lizzie Borden pleaded not guilty and was committed to Taunton jail without bail.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

Evening Journal · 13 August 1892 · page 2

LIGHT ON THE MYSTERY.

LIZZIE BORDEN PLEADS NOT GUILTY. She Is Khii iHii$le$l for Tritt! Without Hall ami Taken to Taunton and Li Up In 11 Cell—The Accused W( Prs* serves Her Air of 1 mil (Terence. Fall River, Mass, Aug, 18,—The ax with which Mrs. Borden was killed has lieen found. That is the sensation of the day iu the mysterious double murder case. The formal commitment of Miss Lizzie us the nuassin of her father and stepmother ranks second iu interest to the discovery of the murderous weapon. It did not leak out till now that one of the four hatchets found in the cellar of the Bor den homestead soon after the mui der was the instrument with which tho butchery was committed.

See moreSee less

Under the microscope it shows many spots of human blood. That it was carefully washed there ia uo doubt, for a bucket of water was found near it, mid also three new towels, partially covered With blood. The water had been splashed over tho cellar floor. The weapon also showed some long hairs, which matched those in Mrs. Bolden's head. No hatchet like the one in custody can be found iu the local hard warn stores, its great est peculiarity is tbe claw on the side of the head nearest the handle. The handle Is about 2feet long and lbs top of tho head Is about l Ü by 4 inches. It Fits li thn < nil. It it said that the head of the hatchet fits Into tho murdi-Kitis wounds in Mr. Burden's head. The blade of the implement is rep resented as being very thin and very sharp, measuring about ô'îi loches in the widest part. It is what is kuowu among farmers us an oldfusliioned tlirushwood hatchet, except for the strong» claw. A hardware man says that suca hatchets are probably used in trimming heavy planking where spike» are driven, tho claw being u»ud iu pulling out spikes. When the jiolice authorities were asked i! such u hatchet was in their custody they would neither admit nor deny it. The mut ter with all other evidence is now iu con trol of District Attorney Kuowltun. Certain clothes covered with blood, found iu the cellar where the hatchet was found, are said to have uu important bearing on this part of the case. Marshal Hilliard said there was a great deal yet to bo proven before the crime could bo dually fastened upon Miss Borden. Much hud been learned, but for all that ho could see the trial would ho long and tedi ous. Medical Examiner Dolan says that a great deal will depend upon the accuracy of the medical examination of the bloody body and the analysis of the parts sent to Boston. Affairs îro more quiet iu police circles than for many hours. There is the report of an unsuccessful search made in tho Chace bill woods ponds, whirh, accord lag to the statement of a man named Ward, contained evidence of the crime, Officers Doherty and Harrington found nothing suspicious there, Llxslu Horden Arraigned. When court was opened Lizzie Borden came in on the arm of Rev. A. E. Buck, the white haired missionary of Central church. She were a tailor made gown of dark blue and a black hat trimmed with black polka <lot crape. She had no veil. She was more self possessed than ut any previous time, and her steellike aud almost painful sever ity of countenance betrayed no emotion. Hlio was careless and indifferent to lior sur roundings and whispered leisurely to her counsel, A. J. Jennings, Tho latter filed a motion to dismiss the complaint ujioii the grounds that the judge, being tho sumo per son who presided at tho inquest, was not competent to pass an unbiased opinion at the preliminary trial; further, that tho in quest waa «till in Beiaicm. Strict Attorney Knowlton offered a de murrer, which was sustained, and then he asked t hat tho prisoner be called upon lo make her plea to the complaint. Her law yer offered a pica of not guilty, but the judge would not accept it, and ordered the clerk to proceed with tho usual custom of the court. Tho clerk asked Lizsiu to stand ( up and answer to the charge of murder. «lie I'leads Not Guilty. j She did so in a firm tone of voice and with stress upon the "not." Mr. Jennings ar raigued tho police for conducting the in ( l u *' t in piiT,tB ttnd for denying him the I r, ght to attend nud protect herfromuse le«* question». A wordy war between the | two lawyers lasted fur half an hour. Jen I "in«* announced that his cliMt was ready un«i anxiou* to proceed to trial at once. Tbe ! state asked for a continuance until Aug. 22, which was granted. The district attorney Informed the court tU,,t 1,H wi!,ll - d Joh, ' V , '" <1 Bridge, ' SullivH11 P I#c « d under bonds to secure their attendance at the trial, us he looked upon thuln H!i valuable wit liesses. They wore ör derod to give security iu #600 okeb, which they did, with Almy & Milne, proprietors of The Daily News, us their bondsmen. Thou Lizzie Borden was ordered to be committed without bund to await the trial. She arose, und with ever faithful Minister , ,, . ! auc * £ passed out under police guard, A î, l>M "' d v*™ 1 *** conveyed her aud hersistor

See the clipping

In the story →

Evening Journal · Wilmington, Del.

The report describes a hatchet believed to match the wounds in Andrew Borden's head, along with bloody clothes found in the cellar, as key evidence now with the District Attorney. It also recounts Lizzie Borden's courtroom arraignment, where her plea of not guilty was refused by the judge pending further proceedings.

CorrectionThis set right 2 earlier articles: Vermont Phœnix, 12 August 1892, The United Opinion, 12 August 1892.

Evening Journal · 13 August 1892 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

LIGHT ON THE MYSTERY.

The Bloody Ax That Killed the Bordens Has Been Found.

See moreSee less

LIZZIE BORDEN PLEADS NOT GUILTY.

She Is Remanded for Trial Without Bail and Taken to Taunton and Locked Up in a Cell—The Accused Woman Preserves Her Air of Indifference.

FALL RIVER, Mass., Aug. 13.—The ax with which Mrs. Borden was killed has been found. That is the sensation of the day in the mysterious double murder case. The formal commitment of Miss Lizzie as the assassin of her father and stepmother ranks second in interest to the discovery of the murderous weapon.

It did not leak out till now that one of the four hatchets found in the cellar of the Borden homestead soon after the murder was the instrument with which the butchery was committed. Under the microscope it shows many spots of human blood. That it was carefully washed there is no doubt, for a bucket of water was found near it, and also three new towels, partially covered with blood. The water had been splashed over the cellar floor. The weapon also showed some long hairs, which matched those in Mrs. Borden's head.

No hatchet like the one in custody can be found in the local hardware stores, its greatest peculiarity is the claw on the side of the head nearest the handle. The handle is about 2½ feet long and the top of the head is about 1¼ by 4 inches.

It Fits Into the Cuts.

It is said that the head of the hatchet fits into the murderous wounds in Mr. Borden's head. The blade of the implement is represented as being very thin and very sharp, measuring about 5½ inches in the widest part. It is what is known among farmers as an oldfashioned thrashwood hatchet, except for the strange claw. A hardware man says that such hatchets are probably used in trimming heavy planking where spikes are driven, the claw being used in pulling out spikes.

When the police authorities were asked if such a hatchet was in their custody they would neither admit nor deny it. The matter with all other evidence is now in control of District Attorney Knowlton.

Certain clothes covered with blood, found in the cellar where the hatchet was found, are said to have an important bearing on this part of the case.

Marshal Hilliard said there was a great deal yet to be proven before the crime could be finally fastened upon Miss Borden. Much had been learned, but for all that he could see the trial would be long and tedious. Medical Examiner Dolan says that a great deal will depend upon the accuracy of the medical examination of the bloody body and the analysis of the parts sent to Boston. Affairs are more quiet in police circles than for many hours. There is the report of an unsuccessful search made in the Chace hill woods ponds, which, according to the statement of a man named Ward, contained evidence of the crime. Officers Doherty and Harrington found nothing suspicious there.

Lizzie Borden Arraigned.

When court was opened Lizzie Borden came in on the arm of Rev. A. E. Buck, the white haired missionary of Central church. She wore a tailor made gown of dark blue and a black hat trimmed with black polka dot crape. She had no veil. She was more self possessed than at any previous time, and her steellike and almost painful severity of countenance betrayed no emotion. She was careless and indifferent to her surroundings and whispered leisurely to her counsel, A. J. Jennings. The latter filed a motion to dismiss the complaint upon the grounds that the judge, being the same person who presided at the inquest, was not competent to pass an unbiased opinion at the preliminary trial; further, that the inquest was still in session.

District Attorney Knowlton offered a demurrer, which was sustained, and then he asked that the prisoner be called upon to make her plea to the complaint. Her lawyer offered a plea of not guilty, but the judge would not accept it, and ordered the clerk to proceed with the usual custom of the court. The clerk asked Lizzie to stand up and answer to the charge of murder.

She Pleads Not Guilty.

She did so in a firm tone of voice and with stress upon the "not." Mr. Jennings arraigned the police for conducting the inquest in private and for denying him the right to attend and protect her from useless questions. A wordy war between the two lawyers lasted for half an hour. Jennings announced that his client was ready and anxious to proceed to trial at once. The state asked for a continuance until Aug. 22, which was granted.

The district attorney informed the court that he wished John V. Morse and Bridget Sullivan placed under bonds to secure their attendance at the trial, as he looked upon them as valuable witnesses. They were ordered to give security in $500 each, which they did, with Almy & Milne, proprietors of The Daily News, as their bondsmen.

Then Lizzie Borden was ordered to be committed without bond to await the trial. She arose, and with ever faithful Minister Buck passed out under police guard. A closed carriage conveyed her and her sister Emma to the depot, where a train was boarded for Taunton. She was in custody of the chief of police. This closed the first legal act in this stirring tragedy.

In Jail at Taunton.

TAUNTON, Mass., Aug. 13.—Miss Lizzie Borden's entry into the city took the form of a public ceremonial. The excitement was high. Arriving at the Central Passenger station, Miss Borden was conducted to a curtained hack by Mr. Buck and City Marshal Hilliard, Detective Seaver acting as guard and clearing the way. The only sign of interest she manifested on the trip from Fall River was when Taunton was reached, when she aroused from her lethargy for a second, then dropped her head on her hand and closed her eyes.

Arriving at the jail, she was at once placed in a cell, the minister conducting her to the door and Marshal Hilliard seeing that the door was properly secured.

Mrs. Wright, wife of Sheriff Wright, an old friend of the Borden family, hurried to the cell with a glass of water, which the prisoner eagerly drank. When Miss Borden entered the jail office her face was composed and there was no sign of consciousness given as she passed toward the corridor, apparently seeing nothing and noticing no one.

The sheriff stood by the inner door, and he was affected almost to tears as he saw the daughter of his old friend passing to apartments usually occupied by the most degraded females. Minister Buck emerged from the cellroom white and agitated and not disposed to talk.

See the clipping

Evening Journal · Wilmington, Del.

At her arraignment, Lizzie Borden's lawyer entered a plea of not guilty despite the judge's reluctance, and after a dispute between counsel over inquest conduct, the court granted the prosecution's request for a continuance until August 22. Borden was then committed without bail and transported under police guard to the jail in Taunton, where she was received with great public interest and placed in a cell by Sheriff Wright's staff.

Evening Journal · 13 August 1892 · page 2

of The Daily News, us their bondsmen. Thou Lizzie Borden was ordered to be committed without bund to await the trial. She arose, und with ever faithful Minister , ,, . ! auc * £ passed out under police guard, A î, l>M "' d v*™ 1 *** conveyed her aud hersistor

See the clipping

The Wilmington Daily Republican · Wilmington, Del.

Lizzie Borden was arraigned in Fall River district court before Judge Blaisdell on homicide charges for the killing of her father and stepmother. After her lawyer's attempt to enter a plea for her was rejected by the District Attorney, she personally stated 'Not guilty' and was held without bail.

The Wilmington Daily Republican · 13 August 1892 · page 1

LIZZIE BORDEN IN JAIL

The words of this article could not be separated from the rest of its page. Read it in the clipping.

No clean clipping could be cut from this page

The Wilmington Daily Republican · Wilmington, Del.

Lizzie Borden, represented by attorney Jennings, entered a plea of not guilty at her arraignment before being ordered held without bail. She was then transported by train to Taunton jail, arriving under guard amid public excitement, and placed in the custody of Matron Russell.

The Wilmington Daily Republican · 13 August 1892 · page 1

LIZZIE BORDEN IN JAIL.

for for the reading o f the complaint, The reading w waived nings said he would enter a plea of not guilty. District Attorney Kuowlton in sisted that Miss Borden plead herself. She She then asked to plead to charges of homicide, of d did s voice, at first saying, "Not guilty." The clerk did not hear her and she raised her voice d said, iu qnito a loud voice, * 'Not guilty," putting strong the first word. emphasi Miss Borden s asked to stand up ami oommitted without bail. Sho ami wa left left tho court room leaning on Mr.

See moreSee less

and was closely followed by Bucks City Marshal Hilliard, who again plaeed£hor in enarge of Matron Russell. Taunton, Mass., Aug. 13.—Miss Lizzie Borden entered cell at Taunton jail at 4:25 yesterday afternoon. Her entry into t lie citjtook the form of a public ceremonial. Tho excitement Arriving at tho Central Passenger sta tion, Miss Borden was conducted to a curtained hack by Mr. Buck and City Marshal Hilliard, Detective Seaver act guard and clearing the way. The y sign of interest she manifested w when Taunton was reached, when she aroused from her lethargy for a second, then dropped her hand und closed her .1 Mr. Jen very weak > high.

See the clipping

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

Lizzie Borden was arraigned before Judge Blaisdell on charges of killing her father and stepmother, with her attorney entering a plea of not guilty on her behalf before she confirmed it herself. After the hearing, she was taken to Taunton Jail.

New-York Tribune · 13 August 1892 · page 1

J. C. Blaisdell this morning, charged with killing her father and stepmother. The court-room was crewded to suffocation by a motley crowd of curious people, and Miss Lorden’s friends at court were od in num» Miss Borden, the prisoner, was represented by

See the clipping

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

At her arraignment, Lizzie Borden's attorney objected to being tried before the same judge presiding at the inquest, but the objection was overruled. She pleaded not guilty, was committed without bail, and the case was continued until August 22, while her father's safe was also opened and its contents secured.

New-York Tribune · 13 August 1892 · page 1

WAS TAKEN TO TAUNTON JAIL.

Borden, had heen refused permission to enter and guide ‘Bis client while an Inquiry was being made. It whs not to be expected of human nature that the same judge could aet at an injuest and a trial and decide fairly In both cases. The proceeding Whe wholly unprecedented. Distiict-Attorney Knowlton opposed the plea. He sald ho knew more than twenty cases in his careel where similar pioceedings failed to attract attention, because the crimes were not atiended by such extra crdinary circumstances as those which preceded this arraignment. The matters of an Inquest and the mat ters of a trial were entirely distinct, and it was nof complimentary to His Honor’s judgment to say that he could not act fairly In both cases, The State’s position was finally sustained, and Mr Jennings filed an exception.

See moreSee less

Ie moved for a trial at once. District-Attorney Knowlton objected, on the ground that an Inquest was still going on. He asked

See the clipping

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

Lizzie Borden was transported to Taunton jail amid great public excitement, while in Fall River police opened the Borden safe and removed most of the guard from the house. Strong rumors circulated that police had found the murder hatchet, described as having a distinctive claw near the handle and blood on blade and handle, with bloody cloths also found nearby.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

New-York Tribune · 13 August 1892 · page 1

Particular ateh t, was used is greatly strep v yw the strong wording of Clty Marshal Hi , . plaint published to-an No hatohet Aun ph question can be found In the local hanlware stores. It's greatest pecnllant vy 1s a claw on the side of th head nearest the handle, It ts said that the head the hatchet fits Into the murderous wounds in Mrs, Borden's head, Spots of blood have been found on the blade and handle, Certain cloths covered with blood found in the cellar where the hatchet was ure said to have an Important bearing on this af the case, Taunton, Mass., Aung.

See moreSee less

12.—Miss Lizzle Borden entered a cell at Taunton jall at 4:25 this afternoon, Her entry Into the city caused great excitement. Arriving at the Central passenger station, Miss Bonde

See the clipping

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

A daily news summary reports that Lizzie Borden, accused of murdering her father and stepmother in Fall River, Massachusetts, was arraigned and pleaded not guilty. The item appears as one brief item among many unrelated domestic and foreign news items.

New-York Tribune · 13 August 1892 · page 6

Edison, N. J. == Miss Jane Meade Welsh lectured oy Columbus at Chantauqua; the games of the annual field-day were held. == Miss Lizzie Borden, who was arrested on the charge of killing her father and step mother in Fall River, Mass, was arraigned and pleaded not guilty. The Executive Board of the Feleration of Labor decided not to place a boycott on the Carnegie products. - The Rev. F. B. Meyer, of London, spcke on “The Holy

See the clipping

The Indianapolis Journal · Indianapolis, Ind.

Lizzie Borden appeared before Judge Blaisdell in Fall River district court, charged with killing her father and stepmother, and entered a not guilty plea through counsel Andrew Jennings. The courtroom was crowded; her sister Emma, Mr. Morse, Bridget Sullivan and a city missionary were present in support.

The Indianapolis Journal · 13 August 1892 · page 4

Murder of Her Father and Step-Mother. Fall River, Mass., Aug. 12. Lizzie C. Borden was arraigned in the Second Dis trict Court before Judge J. C. Blaisdell this morning charged with the killing of her father and step-mother. The court room was crowded to suffocation. Miss Borden's friends at coort were very few in number. Mr. Morse, Bridget Sullivan, Miss Emma Borden and City Missionary Buck were present. Miss Borden, the prisoner, was represented by Andrew J. Jennings. She was dressed in a dark-blue tailor-made gown and wore a black lace bat adorned with a'few red berries.

See moreSee less

She looked in much better condition than she was last night just before her arrest. Miss Borden entered the court-room lean ing on Miss Mary Hack's arm. one was somewhat nervous, but did not show feel ing by either tears or trembling. She was given a seat beside her counsel and her sister Emma and Missionary Buck, who sat in front of the prisoner's dock. The trial was commenced by the entering of a plea signed and sworn to by the prisoner. It re cited that the prisoner objected to the opening of a trial before a justice who was already sitting at an inquest held to de termine who committee: the crime charged agaiust her. This plea was overruled for the time being, aud the judge asked for the reading of the complaint. Tbo reading was waived, and Mr. Jennings said he would enter a plea of not guilty. District Attorney Knowlton, who was eonducting the prosecution, insisted that Miss Borden plead herself. f Augustus B. Leonard, clerk of the court, asked her to stand up, which she did lirnily and without assistance. She was then asked to plead to charges of homicide, and did so in a very weak voice, at tirst saying "Not guilty." The clerk did not hear her and she raised her voice and said in quite a loud voice, ".Not guilty," putting strong emphasis on the tirst word. Mr. Jennincs then began to argue for the acceptance of bispleatbat bis clientshould not be examined at the inquest. The pro ceeding was contrary to all law and jus tice. He, as attorney for Lizzie Borden,

See the clipping

The Indianapolis Journal · Indianapolis, Ind.

Lizzie Borden appeared in court represented by attorney Andrew Jennings, who first argued unsuccessfully that the same judge should not preside over both the inquest and trial. She then pleaded not guilty in a firm voice after the judge overruled her counsel's objection.

The Indianapolis Journal · 13 August 1892 · page 4

SHE PLEADS NOT GUILTY

The words of this article are printed with the report it shares its clipping with. Read them there or in the clipping.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

The Indianapolis Journal · Indianapolis, Ind.

At a court hearing, Lizzie Borden's counsel argued the judge who presided at the inquest should not also judge the trial, but the demurrer favoring separation was overruled and the case continued to August 22. Borden was committed without bail, while police reportedly obtained a peculiar claw-hatchet suspected as the murder weapon, and the Borden safe was opened and its contents secured.

The Indianapolis Journal · 13 August 1892 · page 4

PLEADS NOT GUILTY.

Miss Borden was asked to stand np, and was committed without bail. She loft the court-room leaning on Mr. Buck's arm, and was closely followed by City Marshal Hil liard, who again placed her in charge of Matron Russell. She will probably remain incbarge of the local matron until a week from Monday. At that time it is expected that a preliminary trial will be commenced

See the clipping

Dziennik Chicagoski · Chicago, Ill.

The report describes the murder of Mr. and Mrs. Borden in Fall River, Mass., committed with an axe, and states that daughter Lizzie A. Borden has been arrested as a suspect after a week-long investigation. It notes nothing was stolen, that Lizzie was known to be at odds with her stepmother, and that she denies guilt while some still doubt her capability of such a crime.

Dziennik Chicagoski · 13 August 1892 · page 1

Morderstwo.

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

See the clipping

Rock Island Daily Argus · Rock Island, Ill.

The report states that Mr. and Mrs. Borden were mysteriously murdered at Fall River, Massachusetts, a week earlier. It notes that their daughter Lizzie Borden has been arrested and charged with the murders.

Rock Island Daily Argus · 13 August 1892 · page 1

Nebraska, W. M. Dock, Ind.; Sixth Ne braska, James Whitehead, Kep. Mr. and Mrs. Borden, an aged couple, were mysteriously murdered at Fall River, Mass., a week ago. Lizzie Borden,

See the clipping

The Wichita Daily Eagle · Wichita, Kan.

Lizzie Borden was arraigned in court on charges of killing her father and stepmother, with her attorney first objecting to the judge's dual role in the inquest and this proceeding. She personally entered a plea of not guilty, and arguments continued over whether she could be compelled to testify at the inquest.

The Wichita Daily Eagle · 13 August 1892 · page 1

THE BORDEN CASE. PALI, Kiyeb, Mass., Aug. 13. Lizzie Borden waa arraigned before Judge Blais dell this morning, charged with killing her father and stepmother. The court room was crowded to suffocation. Miss Borden was represented by Andrew J. Jennings. Miss Borden entered the court room leaning on Missionary Buck's arm. She was somewhat nervous, but did not show feeling by either tears or trembling. The trial commenced by the entering of the plea signed and sworn to by the prisoner. It recited that the prisoner ob jected to trial before a justice who was al ready sitting at the inquest held to de termine who committed the crime charged against her.

See moreSee less

This plea was overruled, and the judge asked for the reading of the complaint. The reading was waived and Mr. Jennings said that he would enter a plea of not guilty. District Attorney Knowlton insisted that Miss Borden plead herself. The clerk of the court asked her

See the clipping

The Wichita Daily Eagle · Wichita, Kan.

At her arraignment, Lizzie Borden personally entered a plea of 'Not guilty' in a firm voice after her lawyer's attempt to plead for her was rejected; the case was continued to August 22 pending the ongoing inquest, and she was committed without bail and taken to the Taunton jail. The report also notes unconfirmed rumors that police had found a blood-covered hatchet and clothing in the cellar.

The Wichita Daily Eagle · 13 August 1892 · page 1

the sum of $500 each. Mits Borden was asked to stand up and was committed without bail She left the court room leaning on Mr. Buck's arm, and was again placed in charge of Matron Russell. She will probably re uiaiu in charge of the local matron until a week from Monday. At that time it is expected that the preliminary trial will be commenced. This afternoon Miss Borden was taken to Taunton, Mass., aud locked up iu a cell in the jail there. When Miss Borden en tered the jail her manner wan composed, and there was no sign of nervousness giyen.

See moreSee less

She passed through the corridors apparently seeing nothing and noticing nobody. This afternoon and evening there are the strongest rumors that the oolice have at last procured the hatchet with which the crime was committed. When the police were asked if the hatchet was in their possession they would neither affirm nor deny it. It is said that the hatchet was found in the cellar, with certain clothes, covered with blood.

See the clipping

Der Deutsche Correspondent · Baltimore, Md.

The report states that Lizzie Borden, daughter of the murdered couple, has been arrested in Fall River on general suspicion, though authorities apparently lack solid evidence to prosecute her. It notes her calm demeanor leads many to believe in her innocence, and criticizes local police for the poor progress of the investigation.

Der Deutsche Correspondent · 13 August 1892 · page 3

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

See the clipping

Der Deutsche Correspondent · Baltimore, Md.

Lizzie Borden was brought before Judge Blaisdell on charges of murdering her father and stepmother, pleading not guilty before a packed courtroom. She was denied bail and remanded to custody, while a locksmith opened the Borden family safe, which was sealed and deposited at a trust company.

Der Deutsche Correspondent · 13 August 1892 · page 4

Der Doppelmord in Fall-River

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

See the clipping

Der Deutsche Correspondent · Baltimore, Md.

Lizzie Borden was arraigned and entered a plea of not guilty; the court denied a defense request for delay and ordered her held without bail while witnesses Morse and Bridget Sullivan were released on $500 bail. The Borden family safe was opened by a locksmith and its contents sealed, and Lizzie was later transported under guard to Taunton jail amid a large crowd of onlookers.

Der Deutsche Correspondent · 13 August 1892 · page 4

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

Daily Kennebec Journal · Augusta, Me.

Lizzie Borden was arraigned in Second District Court before Judge Blaisdell on charges of killing her father and stepmother, pleading not guilty while represented by lawyer Andrew Jennings. She was held without bail and the case continued to August 22, with Morse and Bridget Sullivan held as witnesses in $500 each; a separate note describes a bloody hatchet found that may be the murder weapon.

Daily Kennebec Journal · 13 August 1892 · page 1

"NOT GUILTY"

^ BLOODY HATCHET Found Which Is Thought to be the Weapon that killed the Bordens Tins afternoon and evening there were rumor* that the police have procured the hatchet with which the Borden murders

See the clipping

Daily Kennebec Journal · Augusta, Me.

The report describes a claw-headed hatchet found with bloodstains, said to match Mrs. Borden's wounds, now in the district attorney's hands, along with bloody clothes found in the cellar. It also reports a second medical examination revealing an additional deep wound in Mrs. Borden's back, and describes Lizzie Borden's transfer to Taunton jail amid public excitement.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

Daily Kennebec Journal · 13 August 1892 · page 1

BODIES AGAIN EXAMINED The Bodies of the Murdered Persons Were Again Examined Thursday Mrs. Borden-' body was the first exam ined. Vu important feature of the examin ation wan the discovery of another frightful wound, two and one-half inclu s long and iwn inches deep, in the woman - hack, just below her neck. ^ \ hatchet or axe inu-t ha»e descended w ith powerful force to inflict sm h a terrible ga'h. hut this wound was lost sight of wliei; the examination of the woman's head was continued. The wound in Mrs.

See moreSee less

Borden's hack cer tainly showed that she was struck from behind, and it was the first inflic ted, fol lowed by tinothers. Taken to Jail. |M Mass.. August 11*. Miss Lizzie Borden entered the cell at Taunton jail, at I.L'o this afternoon. Her entry to the c ity took the form of a public ceremonial and the exc itement was high. Arriving at the Central passe nge r station. Miss Borden was conducted to a curtained hac k. Arriving at the jail, she* was at once plac ed in a cell, the ministe r conducting her to the door and Marshal Hilliard seeing that the door w as properly secured. Win n MhBorden e ntered tin* jail of fi<v her fare was composed and there «e no sign of solf-eonse-ion-ness manifested a 'h<* passed tow ards the corridor, apparently seeing nothing and notic ing nobody .

See the clipping

The Portland Daily Press · Portland, Me.

Lizzie Borden was arraigned in Fall River's Second District Court on homicide charges for killing her father and stepmother, pleading not guilty before Judge Blaisdell. She was committed without bail to await grand jury action, while the Borden safe was opened revealing cash and papers, which were sealed and deposited at a trust company.

The Portland Daily Press · 13 August 1892 · page 1

Axe Brought Into the Case. Fall Riveb, August 12.—Lizzie Bor den was arraigned this morning in the Second District court, Judge J. C. Blais dell, on a charge of homicide, in killing her father and stepmother. The court room was packed. The prisoner was represented by Andrew J. Jennings. She was quite calm and pleaded not guilty. Her counsel objected to her examina tion before the same justice who sat at the inquest. The objection was over ruled and Mr. Jennings filed exceptions. The case was continued to August 22. The prisoner was committed without bail.

See moreSee less

Morse and Bridget Sullivan were held in $500 each as witnesses. The Borden Safe. The Borden safe was opened this morning after John A. Marer of Boston, had been at work on it about eight hours. The contents will not be given for publication. They consisted of a large amount of cash and some few papers. They were bundled and tied with strong cord, and after Attorney Jennings and Officer Har rington had affixed their signatures on the outside the bundle was taken to the Safe Deposit and Trust Co., and de posited. rl'U . -3 1.1-.,,.... 3 +3w. neighborhood of the house with the ex ception of one officer and John V. Morse is again at liberty. If Miss Bor den be able to be removed she will be taken to Taunton jail this afternoon. Review of the Evidence. A review of the testimony upon which Lizzie Borden was arrested for murder,

See the clipping

The Portland Daily Press · Portland, Me.

The report details testimony from the inquest showing discrepancies between Lizzie's statements and other evidence, including Bridget Sullivan's testimony about the barn loft, a mysterious note, and a denied attempt to buy prussic acid. The district attorney concluded Lizzie had made three demonstrable errors, suggesting she may not have been in the barn and had no real reason to avoid finding her stepmother.

The Portland Daily Press · 13 August 1892 · page 1

body was discovered. Until then she supposed Mrs. Borden was in the house. Lizzie on the stand admitted receiving the note from the boy who delivered it, but she gave a very unsatisfactory de scription of the lad. x lieu, no Luu uuiv xuirv/u kw Ir x search of the house, she assumed at once that it was put in the stove and burned by Mrs. Borden. On this note rested the truth of Liz

See the clipping

The Portland Daily Press · Portland, Me.

The district attorney concluded that Lizzie Borden's inconsistent statements proved she was in the house during both murders and ordered her taken into custody. Police reportedly found a blood-stained hatchet matching the wounds, along with bloody clothes in the cellar, as Lizzie was committed to Taunton jail.

The Portland Daily Press · 13 August 1892 · page 1

she was also in the dwelling wlieu Mrs. Borden was murdered, and in the kitch en could hardly have failed to hear the heavy fall; that she had some reason for not trying to find her mother other than she gave, because there was no note delivered to make her think Mrs. Borden had gone out. • With the evidence that these state ments of Lizzie are incorrect came the thought that others of her stories might suffer from a lack of reliability, coupled with the other peculiar circumstances, and the district attorney made up his mind that the woman should be formal ly taken into custody.

See the clipping