As the Papers Told It

Lizzie Borden · The full archive

August 1892, part 2

250 articles

The Portland Daily Press · Portland, Me.

The report states that suspicions against Lizzie Borden have culminated in her arrest for the murder of her father and stepmother. It notes the evidence is largely circumstantial, based on her and the servant girl being the only people with opportunity to commit the crime.

The Portland Daily Press · 13 August 1892 · page 4

Borden which have existed from the time the Fall River tragedy became known have culminated in her arrest on the charge of murdering her father and

See the clipping

St. Paul Daily Globe · Saint Paul, Minn.

Lizzie Borden was arraigned in district court before Judge Blaisdell, charged with killing her father and stepmother, and entered a plea of not guilty through her attorney. A dispute arose over whether the judge could hear the case after presiding at the inquest, and Borden was ultimately remanded to jail without bail.

St. Paul Daily Globe · 13 August 1892 · page 4

Pall Rivei:, Mass.. Aug. 12.— Lizzie C. Borden was arraigned in the Second district court before Judge J. C. Blais dell this morning, charged with the killing of her father and stepmother. The court room was crowded to suffoca tion. Miss Borden's friends at court were very few in number. Mr. Morse, Bridget Sullivan, Miss Emma 1-Sorden and City Missionary Buck were present. Miss Bordeu, the prisoner, was repre sented by Andrew J. Jennings. Miss Borden was dressed in a dark blue tailor-made gown and wore a black lace hat adorned with a few red berries. She looked in much bet ter condition than she was in last night just before her arrest. Miss Borden entered the court room

See the clipping

St. Paul Daily Globe · Saint Paul, Minn.

At her arraignment, Lizzie Borden's counsel objected to the same judge presiding over both inquest and trial, but the objection was overruled. She pleaded not guilty, the case was continued to August 22, and she was committed without bail into the custody of Matron Russell.

St. Paul Daily Globe · 13 August 1892 · page 4

MISS LIZZIE IN JAIL.

and justice. He, as attorney for Lizzie Borden, hart been refused permission to enter and guide his client while an in quiry was being made. It was not to be expected of human nature that the same judge could act at an inquest and n, trial

See the clipping

St. Paul Daily Globe · Saint Paul, Minn.

Lizzie Borden's demurrer was overruled at arraignment, and she was committed without bail to await a preliminary trial set for August 22; the Borden safe was opened and its contents deposited for safekeeping. Separately, police are reported to possess a peculiar claw-headed hatchet with a long handle believed to match the wounds in Mrs. Borden's head.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

St. Paul Daily Globe · 13 August 1892 · page 4

MISS LIZZIE IN JAIL.

very humorous letter, "which will be found below, he serves notice that he will be heard from in the near future. Of course this letter will spoil many columns of "hot stuff" on fusion which is stored up in several newspaper of fices, but the Sage evidently did not care much for that. The letter follows: To the Editor of the Globe. • Will you be kind enough to give me suffi cient space in which to deny certain enter taining fabrications of ihe public press con cerning myself? For a time I was simply -.amused by these inventions, but I find them repeated broadcast until they are obtaining general credence, and are annoying and distressing my friends: One newspaper, tbe other day.

See moreSee less

casually re marked—discussing the probabilities of the campaign— that I might resign my nomina tion for governor, and retire to my farm Anotner kindly suzgested that if I had any ,desire to withdraw. I could get my physician . to order me to do so on account of my health In tne hands of a third artist this grew into a statement th*t I was actually about to Rive up the eot^est, A fourth repeated this with a supplement— thai my doctor had ordered roe to resign. a fifth explained' that my sickness was due to overwork. And then a Dakota paper kindly remarked that I had been paid a handsome sum to get sick and withdraw. And thereupon a whole con course of state papers has Riven it out that I am very sick, and absolutely out of the field and that the People's party ticket has gone to pieces. You remember. Mr. Editor, the old story of the man who was said to have swallowed something "as black as a crow;" and the re port grew, by successive stages, until it ap peared that the unfertnnate individual had swallowed three black crows— alive at that: of .Mr. ilarkle. Really, if these inventive and romantic gen tlemen of the press are not stopped in their creative career. I shall expect to re.ad. in a few days, a full account of my last sickness and death, and all the details at my funeral together with the glowing obituary notices wi:h which the de!i"2h!ed newspapers will consign me to my lav. resting place. - And so I push, aside the marble slab of my "tnmo ami stick my bead oat long .enough to protest (however much •it ni-iy disappoint the world).- that I .-i.-a not sfes or (Tying or 'dead; ; that 1 have as i h;.> - :ciaiL,"anil cannot recollect ' that I ever Im<i . one: that I never was in better he::ii!i in my life: tiint I have not thought for one iusi4i:t:»tf ; withdrawing from the content for the gubernatorial chair;, that on Monday uext 1 Ij?/iu a series of sevI enty-rive speeches. i:i IL psu-.sof ill? state: I and that I prjpo-e to make the coming earn l>iiiif!i t!it> liveliest ever, seen: in Jlnrnesot-i.l It my excellent friends, Hou. Kuute .Kelson much today. until Monday, Aug. 22 % and it was grant ed. Mr. Morse and Bridget Sullivan were then held as witnesses in the sum of?sooeaeh. Miss Borden was asked to stand up, ana was committed with out bail. She left the court room lean ing on Mr. Buck's arm, and was closely followed by City Marshal llilliard, who again placed her In charge of Matron Russell. She will Drobably remain in charge of the local matron until a week from Monday. At that time it is ex pected that a preliminary trial will be commenced before Judge Blaisdell. The Borden safe was opened this morn ing after a Boston locksmith had been at work at it about eight hours. The contents will not be given for publica tion. They consist of a huge amouut of cash and some few papers. They were bundled and tied • with a strong cori, and, after Attorney Jenninzs and Offi csr Harringtou had affixed their signa tures on the outside, the bundle was taken to the Safe Deposit and Trust company and deposited. The guard has been taken from the neighborhood of the house, with the exception of one officer, a-nd John V. Morse is again at liberty. If Miss Borden is able to be removed she will be taken to Taunton jail. A Peculiar Hatcnet. This afternoon and evening there were the strongest rumors that the police have procured the hatchet with which the crime was committed. The police are in possession of a peculiar hatchet, and the rumor that this par ticular hatchet was used is greatly strengthened by the strong wording of City Marshal Hilliard's complaint pub lished today. Xo hatchet like the one in custody can be found in the local hardware stores. Its greatest pecul iarity is a claw on the side of the head nearest the handle. The han dle is about two and a half feef loun and the top of the head is about one and a half by four inches. It is said that the head of the hatchet fits into the murderous wounds in Mrs. Borden's head. The blade of the implement is represented as being very thin and very sharp, measuring about live and a hall' inches at the widest part, it is what is known amoug fanners as an old-fashioned thrashwood hatchet, ex cejrtfor the strange claw. A hardware mail says that such hatchets are proba uly used in laying heavy plankin<* where spikes are driven, the claw bein" used in Pollins Oat Spikes. When the police authorities were asked if such a hatchet was in their custody, they would neither admit nor deny it. The matter, with all other evi dence, is now in control of District At torney Knowlton. The condition of the hatchet with a bloody deed of some kind is almost beyond doubt, as spots of blood have been found on the blade and handle. Certain cloths covered with blow!, found in the cellar where the hatchet was found, are said to have an important bearing on this part of the ens*'. Tonight Marshal Hilliard said that there was a great deal yet to be proven before the crime could be finally fastened upon Miss Borden. Much had been learned, but for all that he could see the trial would be long and tedious. Medical Examiner Doiau says that a great deal will depend on the accuracy of the medical examination of the body and the analysis of the parts sent to Boston. Tonight affairs are more quiet in police circles than for many days. There is the report of an unsuccessful search made in the Chaee mill wood pond, which, according to the statement of a man named Ward, con tained evidences of the crime. Office rs Doherty ami Harrington found nothing suspicious there. XX TATJXTON JAIL.. Miss Borden Is Safely Behind the Bar*. Taunton, Mass., Aug. 12.— Miss Bor den entered a cell at Taunton jail at 4:25 o'clock this afternoon. Her entry iuto the city took the form of a public ceremony. Arriving at the central pas senger station, Miss Borden was con ducted to a curtained hack by Minister Buck and City Marshall Hilliard, De tective beaver acting as guard and clearing the way. The only sign of in terest she manifested was when Tauu ton was reached, when she aroused from her lethargy, for a second, then dropped her head on her hand and closed her eyes. Arriving at the jail she was at once placed in a cell, the minister conducting her to the door, and .Marshal Hilliard seeing that the door was properly secured. Mrs. Wright, wife of Sheriff Wrfgttt, an old friend of the Borden family, hurried to the cell with a glass of water, which the pris oner eagerly drank. When Miss Burden entered the jail her manner was com posed, and there was no sign of nerv ousness given. She passed towards the corridors, apparently seeing nothing and noticing nobody. The sheriff stood by the inner dcor. and he was affected almost to tears as he saw the daughter of his old friend pass into the apart meuts usually occupied by the most degraded females. Minister Buck emerged from the cell room white and asritated, and not disposed to talk.

See the clipping

Paper unidentified

Lizzie Borden was arraigned in Fall River, Massachusetts on charges of homicide for killing her father and step-mother. She pleaded not guilty, and the proceedings were continued until August 22.

Paper unidentified · 13 August 1892 · page 1

Fade River, Mass, Aug. 12. Lizzie C. Borden was arraigned this morning on charges of homicide, arising from the killing of her father and step-mother. She pleaded not guilty. The trial was continued till August 22.

See the clipping

Paper unidentified

After Andrew and Abby Borden's funeral, police conducted a thorough search of the Borden house but found no conclusive evidence. The report also notes that Lizzie Borden had earlier blocked officers from entering her room, and mentions a new suspect lead involving a group of horse traders.

Paper unidentified · 13 August 1892 · page 2

A MURDEll MYSTERY. Still No Clue to the Murderer at Ftll River, M»u FALL RIVER. Mass., Aug. 8.—'Ihe latest development in the Borden murders re lating particularly to the theory of poison ing. has given way to-day to the talk ol the funeral, wbicli took ]laco tIiis morning. Miss zzie and Miss Lmnia Borden were ot course the principal mourners. Tift latret clue being followed involves a camp of gyp-y-looking faorso traders camped on the outskirts, one of whom answers the de scriptions given by three persons of a man seen near the Borden house beiore the murder.

See moreSee less

An important fact in conncction with the murder was developed to-day. An hour or more a.ter the murder was discovered two «i the officers dispatched to the scene undertook to make a search of the house. They looked over the fir*t floor to some ex tent and then started up stair's. Lizzie Bor den became nware oi their efforts, and as they readied the door of her room she stepped boldly in front ot the officers and re.used to let them into her room. The first thorough search of the Borden resi dence was made this afternoon while the funeral was in progress. From 2 o'clock until 6:30 the most se irehing investigation was made of every detail discovered since the crime was peipirated. The search through the house was exjiccted to develop many things, but at 7 o'clock to-night it was stated officially that no clinchiu' evi dence was obtained, and it is now impos sible to say what turn the investigation wiiltake.

See the clipping

The Jamesburg Record · Jamesburg, N.J.

Lizzie Borden was arrested at the Central Police Station in Fall River after being brought in ostensibly as a witness to the inquest. She was charged with the murder of her father and stepmother, was lodged in jail with access denied even to her sister and lawyer, and showed little visible emotion beyond a flash of anger.

The Jamesburg Record · 13 August 1892 · page 1

LIZZIE BORDEN ARRESTED. She is Charged with the Murder of Her Father and Mother.

Father and VothM*. Fall River, Mass.. Aug. la.-Llzzte Borden, daughter of the murdered trier chant, is under arrest. She was made a pria-i oner in the inquest room of the Central p»|

See the clipping

The Sun · New York, N.Y.

Lizzie Borden spent the night in a room at police headquarters before being brought to a packed courtroom for her preliminary hearing. Her lawyer objected to the proceedings and she did not enter a guilty plea.

The Sun · 13 August 1892 · page 2

LIZZIE BORDEN IN PRISON

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

See the clipping

The Evening Herald · Shenandoah, Pa.

An axe/hatchet found in the Borden cellar is reported as the murder weapon, with blood and hair matching Mrs. Borden found under microscope examination. Lizzie Borden has been formally committed to a cell in Taunton and is reportedly showing no signs of breaking down.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

The Evening Herald · 13 August 1892 · page 3

Fall, IiivEn, Mass., Aug. 13. The ax wun wlilch Mrs. Borden was killed has been found. That is the sensation of tho day in the mysterious double murder case. The formal committment of Miss LIzzio ns the assassin of her father and stepmother ranks second in interest to tho discovery of the murderous weapon. It has just leaked out that ono of the four hatchets found in the cellar of the Borden homestead, soon after tho murder, was tho Instrument with which tho butch ery was committed. It has a handlo two and a bnlf feet long, and a steel blade keen as a razor.

See moreSee less

Its blade and head are peculiarly shaped. The latter is blunt at the end furthest from the handle, nnd has a claw for pull ing nails at the other end. Under tho microscope it shows many Bpots of human blood. That it was care fully washed thero is no doubt, for a buckot of water was found near it, and also three new towels, partially covered with blood. Tho water had been splashed over tho cellar floor. Lizzie Borden was asked at the time the ax was found about these towels, and she said that they had been used by a woman in Illness. Tho wounds in tho head of Mrs. Borden lit the blunt end of the hatchet head. Tho weapon also show ed some long hairs, which matched those in Mrs. Borden's head. The pollco are now satisfied that this instrument was used by the author of the crime.

See the clipping

Pittsburg Dispatch · Pittsburg, Pa.

The report describes Lizzie Borden's night in a small jail cell and her appearance before Judge Blaisdell the next morning, where she pleaded not guilty through her attorney Jennings. It also notes a new piece of evidence—an additional ax wound—as a fresh point against her, and mentions two important witnesses being held.

Pittsburg Dispatch · 13 August 1892 · page 9

rsrcctA. TitraHAM to t ihitjitctm Fall limsR, Aug. 12. Lizzie Borden pent last nigbt in a small room on the sec nd floor of police headquarters. She was estless in the early part of the night, but oward mominshe slept soundly. Judge Blaisdell opened court at 9:40 'clock. As he sat down Lizzie Borden ralked down the long corridor leading from ler room. She leaned on the arm of the Uv.E. J. Buck; Marshal Hilliard walked cside her. She wore a blue cloth dress, a lack hat trimmed with black lace and iolets.

See moreSee less

In her left hand she carried a pair f long, black gloves. She was silent while Lawyer Jennings rew up a motion he was going to present to he court. Her fingers twitched nervously, nd she picked the fingers of her gloves as f trying to tear the threads. Once or twice he closed her eyes, leaned back in her chair nd passed her right hand wearily over her orehead.

See the clipping

Pittsburg Dispatch · Pittsburg, Pa.

Lizzie Borden was brought before the court and entered a whispered then emphatic 'not guilty' plea to charges of murdering her father and stepmother. Her lawyer Jennings argued the proceedings were improper since the inquest was still open and the judge was hearing prejudicial evidence, while District Attorney Knowlton defended the process as standard procedure.

Pittsburg Dispatch · 13 August 1892 · page 9

Since the police began their Investigation t has been commonly reported and ad Tiitted that Miss Borden was suspected. She n as summoned summarily and forced to ap pear at the inquest, where she was not rep

See the clipping

Pittsburg Dispatch · Pittsburg, Pa.

District Attorney Knowlton's demurrer was sustained at the preliminary hearing, and the case was continued until August 22; Lizzie Borden was formally committed while Morse and Bridget Sullivan were held as witnesses on bond. The report also describes her transport to and entry into Taunton jail.

Pittsburg Dispatch · 13 August 1892 · page 9

tained, and Mr. Jennings filed an exception. He moved for a trial at once. District At torney Knowlton objected, on the giound lhat an inquest was still going on. He asked tor a continuance until Monday, Aucust 22, and it was granted. Mr. Morse and Bridcet Sullivan were then held as witnesses in jhe sum of SoOO each. Clerk Leonard told Lizzie Borden to stand up. She arose and he read the result of the day's proceedings. As he finished he aid: "And you are committed until the above date." The lips of the prisoner came together tight. Her hands clenched and her eyes flashed. Her lawyer led her

See the clipping

Pawtucket Tribune · Pawtucket, R.I.

Lizzie Borden was quietly escorted by City Marshal Hilliard from the police station to the train for Taunton, where she would be held in jail. Family and friends including her sister Emma, Rev. Buck, Dr. Bowen, and her lawyer Mr. Jennings bid her farewell before her departure.

Pawtucket Tribune · 13 August 1892 · page 1

TAKEN TO TAUNTON.

830 train, and the reporters were all At hand as the hour ugrroachod. Miss Emma L. Borden, with My. Jenuings and 15. Bowen, bade Miss Lizgle A. Borden an al fectionate good-bye. The parting between tho slgters wne o sad ome, but both ap peared buoyed up by a strong faith and great trush. Ligzie seemed brighter and stronger thag she had been in the morning, though she was cool enough then. Bhe had ex

See the clipping

Pawtucket Tribune · Pawtucket, R.I.

Lizzie Borden said an emotional goodbye to her sister Emma before being taken by train to Taunton, where a chaotic crowd mobbed the officers and carriage. She was processed into the jail, bathed, and placed in a small cell in the women's wing to await her hearing.

Pawtucket Tribune · 13 August 1892 · page 1

COMMITTED WITHOUT BAIL.

At Taunton there was a tumultuous and simply dis graceful crowd of morbidly curious peo g!lo awaiting the arrival of the train, oy raced after the officers as soon as they alighted, and jostled thelr prisonee and ber escort. Miss Borden was hup rled as fast as the marshal could hurry ber ous through the ladies’ room and fnto 8 hack. The mob fairly swarmed round the carriage and hemmed it in, many ner rowly escaplug being yun dowg when the ooach rattled off toward the jail. The reporters’ coaches were ready simul tauneously, and In the same order as before

See the clipping

Pawtucket Tribune · Pawtucket, R.I.

Lizzie Borden was placed in a jail cell described in detail, then arraigned before Judge Blaisdell on charges of murdering her father and stepmother, pleading not guilty in a firm voice. The court ordered her held without bail and continued the case to August 22, with Morse and Bridget Sullivan held as witnesses.

Pawtucket Tribune · 13 August 1892 · page 1

COMMITTED WITHOUT BAIL.

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

See the clipping

Pawtucket Tribune · Pawtucket, R.I.

The piece expresses disbelief that a woman could have committed such a brutal axe murder, questioning whether a woman would have the strength to wield the weapon. It notes Lizzie Borden's calm, unmoved demeanor has contributed to public belief in her guilt, while the writer hopes the suspicion proves unfounded.

Pawtucket Tribune · 13 August 1892 · page 2

THE BORDEN MURDER. It is terrible to comtemplate the pos sibility of a young woman’s committing such a revolting and brutal murder as the Fall River tragedy. It secws almost in credible that a woman should have chosen as the instrument for such a deed an axe which would require a strong man’s arm to wield with such sudden and fatal effect, For the sake of humanity it i to be hoped that the suspicion which seoms to fasten the guilt on the daughter, strong as it now appears to be, may prove unfounded, But Lizzie Borden is evidently a singular women, of iron nerves and determined will.

See moreSee less

Her sclf-restraint during the trying scenes since the murder has been remark ble, and her unmoved indifference perhaps as much as anything has tended to create a belief in hor gullt.

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

The report describes a new theory that the Borden murders were part of a long-plotted conspiracy against Lizzie Borden, with police holding her clothing except for undergarments and a will found in a safe deposit box. Despite suspicions and her arrest, many locals still refuse to believe Lizzie is guilty, while Morse remains under some suspicion despite an alibi.

The Providence News · 13 August 1892 · page 1

PLOTTED FOR YEARS.

but what it contains is not given out. There are still thousands of the best fiople here who refuse to believe that zzie Borden couid have murdered her father and sugmother. The police are blamed by unthinking pooglo for arrest

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

The report notes a will was found in a safe but its contents are undisclosed, while community opinion remains divided on Lizzie Borden's guilt though most support the arrest. It also describes the strong legal defense being gathered, the Borden family's wealth and influence, and speculation about possible confederates.

The Providence News · 13 August 1892 · page 1

fully confirmed, it is growing that Miss }l;tnie‘wu the strongest witness against erself. One fact is plain in all this discussion, namely, that there has been no ripple of sorrow for the loss of Andrew J, Borden

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

The report airs local gossip and an alderman's hints that Lizzie Borden conspired with a confederate to murder her father and stepmother, allegedly planning it since her 1890 European trip. It also notes that most of her former schoolmates defend her character despite the rumors.

The Providence News · 13 August 1892 · page 1

money overmuch. While no one may blame the old man, no one feels that he has lost anything by his death; and when such athing may be truthtullg said of any man, it matters not how honest he was, nor how regularly he atteuded church, he is shown not to have been a valuable citizen. The intimation from an official source that Miss Borden had confederates finds agreement in the thoughts of many more than those who utter such thoughts, doubtless. It would not be fair to site names in this connection; but it may be said that a well-k»swn public man of this town is among those who think that Miss Borden and some other person con nected with the family hired a man to do

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

A brief editorial comment states that the trust of her neighbors and her pastor is a strong point in Lizzie Borden's favor. This appears amid a column of miscellaneous short items and opinions from the Providence News.

The Providence News · 13 August 1892 · page 4

—THE PROVIDENCE NEWS. Tue trust of her neighbors and her pastor is a strong point in favor of Miss Lizzie Borden, Buzzarp's Bay bluefish don't bite, but Harrison caught sixty Adirondack trout in one inning. Tug proposition of Inspector Byrnes of New York, to flog Anarchists, might opon an excellent way to knock a good lot of tomfoolery out of those notoriety seeking gentry. $ Tue Iron Hall investigation is bring ing out just the sort of revelations any person of average common sense might have expected. When will people re fuse to trust promises of the impossible?

See moreSee less

DAVE, it seems, failed to call on Cleve because he was calling on *‘ Boss™ McLaughlin at the momert when the offing was most anxiously watched from Gray Gables. Mahomet might as well make up his mind to go to the mountain, The pension fraud is the greatest of the age—and Cleveland struck the beggars in the face. He should be g ven a chance to hit ‘em again.—

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

The piece notes that the Borden case is the talk of Providence, with many residents claiming personal connections to the Borden family, such as a clerk who supposedly attended school with Lizzie Borden. A man argues her good character and reputation over many years should count in her favor, reflecting public sentiment sympathetic to Lizzie amid ongoing proceedings.

The Providence News · 13 August 1892 · page 4

There is no question that the NEwWs has exactly hit the popular view of the Bor den case, It is the topic of universal con versation’ on the street, in the shops and in publie eonngmce& It's surprising, too, how many PROVIDENCE peox& Kknow something about the Bordens, man on a street car told me the other day that a clerk in his office had gone to scnool with Lizzie Borden, and remembered her as an extremely bright scholar. *‘ You can’t tell me,” said this gentleman, ‘‘that the

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

This dispatch from Fall River describes the modest character of Andrew Borden's house and grounds, correcting public misconceptions about the size of the barn where Lizzie Borden was said to be during the murders. It emphasizes the plain, unpretentious nature of the property despite Borden's wealth.

The Providence News · 13 August 1892 · page 7

THE NEWS SAYS A CONSPIRACY

in his night olotb.l ran to aneighbor’s Boys who want to make money by oanvassing for where a wake was in progress, and at the News apply to Mr. Bliss, the newsdealer, for tacked the guests. He was overpowered and taken Lo his home in a carriage, terms and sample coples. You can earn $6 easily. enough Lo be a lawn, is exception llli unattractive. There is no ;tumgz at flornl decoration ;it i« evident that t reflining influences nature bestows upon he’f .;l:vr?tm found ::d r icemion 'l)fiu h stable, wblo‘ & L.u 80 often mentioned 'he size o 8 cramped, e ns the place where Miss Borden was perdu during the interval while tne souls of her parents were taking flight from their batchered bodies, is scarcely of con

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

The report describes the modest, unadorned grounds and small stable at the Borden home, arguing the stable was too close to the house to have hidden Lizzie as some imagined. It then recounts her being taken by hack and train to Taunton for imprisonment, escorted by Marshal Hilliard and Rev. Mr. Buck, with little public commotion.

The Providence News · 13 August 1892 · page 7

in his night olotb.l ran to aneighbor’s Boys who want to make money by oanvassing for where a wake was in progress, and at the News apply to Mr. Bliss, the newsdealer, for tacked the guests. He was overpowered and taken Lo his home in a carriage, terms and sample coples. You can earn $6 easily. Lizzie Borden’s life has not been such that ahe should fudnully become depraved and reach a climax of sin at this age; sue has no nfpuunco of & guilty woman, or oneé trylug to brave out her natural emotions, On Friday afternoon four livery hacks drove up to the side entrance of the pulice station, There was a small, scattered crowd hov ering arouud these temms for it had been announced that at 3 o'clock Miss Borden would be tanken theuceto Taunton for

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

A reporter describes Lizzie Borden's composed, dignified appearance as she was escorted by a clergyman and officials from a carriage to a train bound for jail. The account emphasizes her genteel appearance and includes testimonials from poor townspeople who uniformly described her as a good, pleasant girl who they believe innocent.

The Providence News · 13 August 1892 · page 7

in his night olotb.l ran to aneighbor’s Boys who want to make money by oanvassing for where a wake was in progress, and at the News apply to Mr. Bliss, the newsdealer, for tacked the guests. He was overpowered and taken Lo his home in a carriage, terms and sample coples. You can earn $6 easily. aged missionary rlmout leaned on his young compuauion for support; the clergy man’s face was Snud gricf-stricken an | showed signs eep emotion. Miss Borden was rightl :ribed by the child on the box scat, She was esseutially a “pretry lady.” Her tigure seemed commanding in con trast with those around her; her face was in repose, her cheeks showing a steady, beautitul pink color; her eyes were do v u cast, but with no tremulous lids like the guilty ; her chief beauty was her abund

See the clipping

San Antonio Daily Light · San Antonio, Tex.

The brief news item reports that Lizzie Borden has been charged with killing her parents as a result of the inquest held in Fall River, Massachusetts. It appears amid a miscellany of unrelated national and international news items.

San Antonio Daily Light · 13 August 1892 · page 1

Miss Lizzie Borden, as tbe result of the Fall River, Mass., inquest, is charged wun the killing of her pa rents. Iron Hall Benevolent society books

See the clipping

Martinsburg Independent · Martinsburg, W. Va.

The report describes the initial discovery of Andrew and Abby Borden's mutilated bodies, with suspicion falling on daughter Lizzie and brother-in-law John Morse. A follow-up details police searching the house again three days later, finding no new clues, and notes Lizzie's evasive behavior compared to her sister Emma's.

Martinsburg Independent · 13 August 1892 · page 2

NO CLEW TO THE PERPETRATORS

daughter Lizzie and his brothdr-in-law, John W. Morse, are implicated. Fall River, Mass., Aug. 9.—The po lice are very active in the Borden mur der cases. Yesterday Captain Desmond, accompanied by a sergeant and two offi cers, went to the house and instituted another search. Places in the old fash ioned chimney were opened in a vain search for clews. The officers also pnlled over everything in the cellar, but with out obtaining any tangible results, while the search was going on Misses Emma and Lizzie Borden were even more gracious to the officers than they were on Saturday after the funeral.

See moreSee less

One of the searching party who came from the house states that, in conversa tion, Miss Emma Borden looked a per son in the eye, but Miss Lizzie invaria bly turned her head when questioned closely. The guard is still kept on the house, but the officers are under instructions not to molest the inmates nor interfere with their freedom in going about the city. If any attempts are made to leave the city, however, arrests will follow. Hartford, Aug. 9.—George B. Fish,

See the clipping

In the story →

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

The Lynn Item had suggested Andrew Borden's damning testimony against mutineers of the schooner Jefferson Borden gave convicts a revenge motive for his murder, but prison officials confirm the two convicted mutineers remain incarcerated in Maine. The report also notes the sheriff has not arranged any special treatment for Lizzie Borden or her visiting sister Emma at the jail.

New-York Tribune · 14 August 1892 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

A THEORY THAT FAILED.

REVENGE OF CONVICTED MEN AS A MOTIVE FOR THE BORDEN MURDER.

See moreSee less

BUT THE CONVICTS ARE STILL IN A MAINE PRISON--MISS BORDEN'S LIFE IN JAIL.

Lynn, Mass., Aug. 13.--"The Lynn Item" to-day published a story stating that Andrew J. Borden, of Fall River, gave the principal testimony that convicted the ringleaders in the mutiny on the schooner Jefferson Borden, while on a voyage from a foreign port to this country; that he and his wife were on the vessel; that his testimony in the courts was declared by the sailors to be false and exaggerated, and that the men who suffered by it vowed vengeance against him. The ringleaders of the mutiny, five in number, were overpowered and placed in irons, and when the vessel arrived in port they were brought before the courts for trial. Two of them were Americans, two were British subjects and one a Portuguese, who claimed to be a subject of Queen Victoria. By the aid of the English Government the three foreigners were either released or escaped with light terms of imprisonment. The two Americans were declared guilty by the courts and sentenced to death, but later President Cleveland commuted their sentences to imprisonment for life in the State Prison at Thomaston, Me. The principal testimony which the courts took under consideration and acted upon was given by Andrew J. Borden.

Thomaston, Me., Aug. 13.--George Miller and William Clark, the Jefferson Borden mutineers, were sent to the Maine State Prison on October 4, 1875, and have never been pardoned. They were sentenced for life.

Taunton, Mass., Aug. 13.--Sheriff Wright declined to ask or have Lizzie A. Borden asked, or her sister Emma, who is visiting her at the jail, whether their parents were on the schooner Jefferson Borden, or whether either of them knew anything about "The Lynn Item's" story. He declares that no questions are to be asked of people in jail, whether visitors or not.

Miss Borden passed a comfortable night, and this morning was cheerful to an unusal degree, brought about perhaps by the prospect of a visit from her sister. Mr. Jennings and Miss Emma Borden came up this morning, and the former, after a brief conversation, went away, leaving Emma in the cell with her sister. The two conversed in low tones for some time. During part of the time, Lizzie was occupied with some sewing which she had brought with her. It is understood that under no circumstances will she open her mouth, and Mr. Jennings, her counsel, will do all the talking necessary.

Fall River, Mass., Aug. 13.--The reaction in the Borden cases has set in, and to-day the popular feeling is noticeably quiet. There is now but one policeman at the Borden homestead, and he is doing patrol duty in the street to prevent curious people from annoying the family. The police have resumed their regular patrol duty, and only three men are hunting up further evidence of the murder.

The City Marshal said this morning that he was confident that the evidence to be submitted at the hearing, on August 22, would be strong enough to warrant the holding of Miss Borden for the Grand Jury. That body will not convene until November, and the time of the special session of the Superior Court that must be held, will be decided on afterward. While direct police surveillance has been removed from Mr. Morse and Miss Sullivan, yet their whole connection with the case will be gone over by the police again within the next few days, and they will not be far away should the police need them. There will not be many witnesses summoned for the preliminary hearing, unless the present plans are changed. The proceedings will be open to reporters. The marshal again denies the statements in many papers to the effect that no search was made until after the funeral. A search was made three times during the afternoon of the day of the murders, and Miss Lizzie's room was searched as thoroughly as other portions of the building. Police inquiry is being made again into the details of a mysterious robbery, which took place at the Borden homestead about a year ago. A lady's watch and several articles of jewelry were taken from a dressing case in one of the upper rooms, and to this day the police have been unable to trace the thief.

The most noticeable feature in the Borden case to-day was an expression made by Bridget Sullivan during an interview this afternoon. She remarked: "Well, I don't wonder that they arrested Lizzie Borden." As the Sullivan woman is the most important Government witness, her statement has startled the friends of the imprisoned girl. It is reported that the prosecution will present but little of its case at the preliminary hearing, keeping back, if possible, the most important evidence.

To-night's "News" says: "Mrs. Holmes has been one of the most intimate friends of the family. She admits that the family relations have not been as pleasant as they are in many families; that in years past they were decidedly unpleasant, at times, but she pronounces foolish all talk of an open rupture between Lizzie and her father and stepmother. She says that, as a matter of fact, Lizzie had been on much more friendly terms with her father and Mrs. Borden during the last year or two than she had been for a long time previously--probably since her father's second marriage."

See the clipping

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

The report recounts the 1875 Jefferson Borden mutiny case as background amid rumors linking it to the Bordens, while describing Lizzie Borden's calm demeanor in jail during a visit from her sister Emma. It also notes reduced police presence in Fall River and confidence that evidence will support holding Borden for the Grand Jury at the August 22 hearing.

New-York Tribune · 14 August 1892 · page 1

PRISON--MISS BORDEN'S LIFE IN JAIL.

e and his wife were on | port to this country; that h the vessel; that his testimony in the courts was declared by. the sailors to be false and exaggerated, and that the men who suffered by it vowed vengeance nim. The ringleaders of the mutiny, five i agalnst in number, were overpowered and placed in irons, and when the vessel arrived in port they were brought before the courts for trial. Two of them were Ameri cans, two were British subjects and one a Portuguese, who claimed to be a subject of Queen Victoria.

See moreSee less

By the aid of the English Government the three foreigners were either released or escaped with light terms of imprisonment. The two Americans were declared guilty by tha courts and sentenced to death, but later President Cleveland commuted thelr sentences to imprisonment for life in the State Prison at Thomaston, Me. The principal testimony which the courts took under concidertion and acted upon was given by Andrew J. Bnrden, . Thomaston, Me., Aug. 13.—George Miller and WiIfam Clark, the Jefferson Borden mutineers, were sent {0 the Maine State Prison on October 4, 1875, and havo never been pardoned. They ware sentenced for life.

See the clipping

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

The report previews the August 22 preliminary hearing, noting the Grand Jury won't convene until November and that few witnesses will be called. It also covers the marshal's denial that no search occurred before the funeral, renewed police inquiry into an earlier jewelry robbery, and Bridget Sullivan's startling remark that she isn't surprised Lizzie was arrested.

CorrectionThis set right 2 earlier articles: The Record-Union, 13 August 1892, New-York Tribune, 13 August 1892.

New-York Tribune · 14 August 1892 · page 1

will do all the talking necessary. Fall River, Mass., Aug. 13.—The reaction in the Borden eases has set in, and to-day the popular feeling 1s noticeably quiet, There 1s now but one policeman at the Borden homestead, and he is doing patrol duty in the street to prevent Turfous people from annosing the family. The police have resumed thelr regular patrol duty, and only three men are hunting np further evidence of the murder. The (ity Marshal said this mornng that he was confident that the evidence to be submitted at the hearing, on August 22, would be strong enough to warrant the holding of Miss Borden for the Grand Jury.

See moreSee less

That body will not convene until November, and the time of the special session of the superior Court that must be held, will be decided on afterward. While direct pollce surveillance has been removed from Mr. Morse and Miss sulllvan, vet ther whole connection with the case will be gone over by the police again within the next tow days, and they will not be far away should the police need them, There will not be many witnesses summoned for the pre hearing, unless the present plans are liminary changed. The proceedings will be open to reporters. The marshal again denies the statements in many papers to the effect that no search was made until after the funeral, A search was made thres times searched as thoronghly as Miss Lizzie s room was other portlons of the building. Police inquiry 1s being made aguin into the detalls of a mysterions robbery, which took place at the Borden homestead about n year ago. A lady’s watch and several articles of jewelry were taken from « dressing case in one of the upper rooms, and to this day the police have been unable to trace the thief, The most noticeable feature in the Borden case today was an expression made by Bridget sullivan durin an interview this afternoon. She remarked: © Well, don't wonder that they arrested Lizzie Borden.” As the Sullivan woman is the most fmportant Government, witness, her statement has startled the friends of the fmpriconsd girl. It 1s reported that the prosecution will present but little of Its case at the preliminary

See the clipping

The Morning News · Savannah, Ga.

The report summarizes the Fall River murder case, noting the evidence against Lizzie Borden is circumstantial and that she will have top legal defense. It recounts her discovery of her father's body, the earlier finding of Mrs. Borden's body upstairs, and the family's wealth and relationships.

CorrectionThis set right 2 earlier articles: Evening Journal, 13 August 1892, The Evening Herald, 13 August 1892.

The Morning News · 14 August 1892 · page 4

The Character of the Camoalgrn. The democratio campaign in thi§ state this year should be earuest and thorough. It should be kept free from personalities and oouduc'.ed on a high plane. The aim of the democratic press and speakers should be to show the people that it is to their in tereits that the Democratio party shall be victorious. The campaign oommittee will meet on next Wednesday to arrange the details of the campaign work. The chairman of that oommittee is well qualified for the duties which devolve upon him, and his associates will render him every assistance in their [lower.

See moreSee less

The oommittee understands the importance of calling into the field all of the democratio forces and of conducting the political battle so that evory voter will be reached in one way and another. Two things should be Kept in view from the beginning of the campaign until the end of it. One is the ueoessity for getting every democrat to cast his vote, and the other to make as many converts as possible from among those who are not now in accord with the Democratic party. Thera are thousands of democrats throughout the state who have become indifferent as to whether they vote or not. The Democratic party has been so largoiy in the majority for so many years that they have felt that their votes were not needed to secure its success. They cannot afford to feel that way this year. The democracy has an aotive and aggressive opponent in tho third party, and that party is to be as-isted by the Republican party. It has beau announced that the Republican party proposes to do all it can for the success of the third party. It is well understood what its object is. It is to defeat the Democratio party. The Republican party has no love for the third party and is not goiug to assist it because It wants to see it In power. It believes that if it can bring about the over throw of the Democratio party by helping the third party in this campaign the way for it to get into power will be open. It is apparent, therefore, that no democrat can afford to Le iuactive in this year’s con test. While we belive that the Democratio party will carry the state easily the majority at the state election in October should be made as large as possi ble for its moral effeot upon the election in November. An old-time democratio ma jority in October will so dishear eu the re publicans and the third party people that they will feel like letting the November election go by default. W bat is wanted is a democratio campaign club in every militia district. These clubs sbould have able and enthusiastic leaders who will see to it that every olub member is active in making converts and In stirring indifferent democrats to activity. Such clubs would be worth more thau campaign speakers or any amount of oampalgn litera ture. They would make dem cratio prin ciples the subject of discussion in every household, and discussion would insure democratic success. Of course these must be political meetings in every town, in every county, and at every cross roads, if possible, and these meetings should be addressed by well-informed speakers. These speakers, together with the democratio newspapers, will furnish the democratic clubs with the arguments with which to make converts. No doubt Chairman Atkinson has in mind all these things to which we call attention, and that he will make use of them. He is going into this contest to win, aud be will win. The Borden Murder Case. The Borden murder case, at Fall River, has some extremely sensational features. It promises to be a famous case in the criminal history of Massachusetts, because the testi mony against the young woman who is ac cused of the murder wholly circumstan tial. and she will have the best lawyers that money can procure to defend her. The dispatches in the Morning News have given the leading facts in the case from the time the crime was discovered until the criminal was arrested. Lizzie Borden, the woman who is accused of murdering her father and her step mother, is not more than 30 years of age and, although not remai kable for ami ability, has always had plenty of friends in Fall River. Her father, the murdered man, was one of the rich men of the city, being worth at least $500,000. As far as the publlo knows there was never anything but the kindest feeling between father and daughter. But it Is asserted that the daughter and step-mother did not gel along harmoniously. The murders wore committed very soon after breakfast. The body of Mrs. Borden was found in her room upstairs and that of Mr. Borden in the sitting room downstairs. Upon each there were many wounds that bad been made apparently with a hatchet or some such instrument. Lizzie Borden discovered the body of her father on her return from the barn, where the had been ostensibly on an errand of some sort. Bhe called the servant girl and they gave notice of the crime. It was some little time after the finding of the body of Mr. Borden before that of Mrs. Borden was found. The theory of the state is that Lizzie Borden administered poison to both Mr. and Mrs. Borden in s me wav, and that when they became helpless she killed them with a hatchet or ax, rather than let the poison do its work, in order to create the impression that they were the victims of some man who had broken into the house. The basis of this theory is the testimony of a drug olerk, who states that Mias Borden attempted to buy. poison from him a day or two before the murders were committed. There are other circumstances which seem to justify the action that has beeu taken by the state authorities. If Miss Borden committed the crimes what was her motive! There has, as yet, been no satisfactory answer to this question. Something has been said to the effect that Mr, Borden was about to make a wiil that would not have been very favorable to Mise Borden, but it has yet to be determined whether or not this statement has much, if any, foundation. Miss Borden bad agood home and was supplied with every comfort. If, therefore, she killed her father and step mother she Is a very remarkable criminal. The most rapid young in an of bis age who has come into public notice lately is Ed ward R. Decker, of Harlem, N. Y. Hois just 15 years old, but he is already a married mau, and has forged a check for SI,OOO. The name he forged, however, was that of a lenieut uncle, who agreed that the boy should not be indicted it be would go into the navy, wbloh he said he would do. The day before this 15-year-old forger was un masked, a 0-vear-old burglar was arrested by the New York police, which would seem to indicate that au epidemic of ariuie among uilauta is prevalent in Gotham. Progress of tho South. In the current number of tho Forum Richard H. Edmouds has an interesting and valuable article on the '‘Unparalleled Industrial Progress of the South.” While editor of the Manufacture r*’ Record Mr. EJm >nds made a thorough study of the resources of the south, and he is, therefore, well qualified to speak of the south’s mate rial development. He begins bis article with the following well-known quotation: "The development of the south means the enrichment of the nation*” whioh, he says, was the doctrine of the late Hon. William

See the clipping

The Morning News · Savannah, Ga.

This report describes the Borden murders, noting Mr. Borden's wealth, the discovery of the bodies, and tension between Lizzie and her stepmother. It outlines the state's theory that Lizzie first poisoned her parents before killing them with a hatchet to disguise the crime as an intruder's work.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day. CorrectionThis set right an article from the day before.

Wrong

The Morning News · 14 August 1892 · page 4

The words of this article are printed with the report it shares its clipping with. Read them there or in the clipping.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

The Indianapolis Journal · Indianapolis, Ind.

A newspaper reports a theory that the Borden murders may have been committed by sailors seeking revenge against Andrew Borden, who had given testimony convicting mutineers from the ship Jefferson Borden years earlier. The report notes many Fall River residents now believe Lizzie is innocent, though servant Bridget Sullivan's statements may still aid the prosecution.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

The Indianapolis Journal · 14 August 1892 · page 1

MEN WHO MURDERED THE BORDENS

Lynn, Mass., Aug. 13. Tho Lynn Item, to-day, publishes a story stating that An drew J. Borden, of Fall Kiver, gave the principal testimony that convicted ring leaders in themntmy on tho schooner Kich ard J. Borden while on the voyage from a foreign port to this country, that ho and his wife were on the vessel; that his testi mony in the courts was declared by sailors to be false and exaggerated, and that the men who suffered by it owjed vengeance against him. Most, if not all of them, have been released, and it is submitted that sev eral of them were in Fall Kiver at the time of th j murder.

See moreSee less

Less than a dozen years ago the ship Jefferson Borden, bound from n foreign port to this country, was seized by muti neers, who claimed to have been cruelly treated by, tbo oflicers, and in tho general struggle and confusion the captain was struck with a marlin spike and killed. The ringleaders of the mutiny, five in number, were overpowcrod and placed in irons, and when the vessel arrived in port they were brought bofore the courts for trial. Two of them . were Ameri cans, two were British subjects and one a Portuguese, who claimed to be a subject - of Queen Victoria. In tho courts the men told a fearful and pit iablo story of inhuman treatment that forced them to the wildest desperation, until tbey organized a mutiny and at tempted to get control of tho ship. Every man swore that in the general fight which occurred it was absolutely impossible to have located the murderer. By the aid of the English government tho three foreign ers were either released or escaped with light terms of imprisonment. Not so with tne Americans. They were declared nuilty by the courts and sentenced to death, but later President Cleveland commuted their sentences to imprisonment for life in the state prison at Thomaston, Me. The principal testimony which the courts took under. consideration, and acted upon, was given by a gentleman who was on board with his wife at the time, and who was principal owner of the ship. Against this man the prisoners long ago sworo they would have revenge. That man was An drew J. Borden, of Fall Kiver.who.with bis wife, has gone down to death by an assas sin's hand. The daughter's story of the two strangers about the houso on the day of the murder seems to have no weight with the police, although it may have later on if it should be learned that tbey were two of the five men who were engaged in the mutiny. Up to a year ago a most strenuous eflort was made by a man named Sullivan, prominent in tbo At lantic Coast Seamen's Union, to secure the release of the two men confined in Thomas ton prison. Petitions tor a pardon were signed by all the trado and labor organiza tions of the country and presented to Pres ident Harrison, and it is believed the men were pardoned about eight months aito. If these men were released, and the fact can be established that they, or any of their comrades in the mutiny, were in or about Fall Kiver the day of the, murder it may mean the release of Lizzie A. Korden, the victim of circumstantial evidence. ' . A dispatch from Taunton says: "Sheriff Wright declined to ask Lizzie A. Borden or her sister, who is visiting her at the jail, whether their parents were on thescbooner Jellerson Borden, or whether either of them knew anything about the Lynn story. He lays this down as law: No qu'tions to no asked of persons in jail, whether visitors or not. Miss Borden passed a comfortablo night, and this morning was cheerful. Mr. Jennings and Miss Kmma Borden came up this morning, and the former, after a brief conversation, went away, leaving Emma in the cell with her sister. The two conversed in low tones for some timo, but there were no tears, no complainings, and the whole affair had the appearance of a simple, ordi nary every-day visit between friends. Dur ing part of the iime Lizzie was occupied with some sewing which she had brought with her. It is understood that under no circumstances will she open her mouth, and Mr. Jennings, her counsel, will do all the talking necessary." A dispatch from Boston says: "Mr. Wal ter, of Walter. Friend & Co., ship brokers of this oity. says in relation to the trial of the Jefferson-Borden mutineers: 'Ves, I remember the trial. It was away back in 1876. Captain Patterson bad killed two of his sailors, and the rest of the crew were up for an attempt to murder. Two were discharged, and the others got .life sen tences, und are still in jail at Thomaston. Their friends tried to have them released some time ago, but Captain Patterson got up a petition to keep them in, 'and they were kept in. But you'd hotter see Mr. Kinnnian. around on Doune street.1 "Mr. Kinsman, commission merchant, naid: 'Ves, I do know all about the matter. Captain Patterson claimed that tho men rose against hiui. and murdered tho second mate and a sailor, and tried to kill him, his vifo and the steward. Androw J. Borden was not on the vessel at all. Tho only peo ple in her cabin wero Captain Patterson and his wife, two mates and the steward. Those sailors are all in Thomaston jail. None was discharged after trial.' " .

See the clipping

The Indianapolis Journal · Indianapolis, Ind.

The report recounts a mutiny aboard a ship owned by Andrew Borden, where convicted sailors swore revenge against him for his testimony. It speculates that escaped or pardoned mutineers might be the real killers, possibly tying into Lizzie Borden's account of strangers near the house.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

The Indianapolis Journal · 14 August 1892 · page 1

THE BORDEN MURDER CASE

The words of this article are printed with the report it shares its clipping with. Read them there or in the clipping.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

The Indianapolis Journal · Indianapolis, Ind.

The report describes a quiet jail visit between Lizzie and her sister Emma, with Lizzie sewing and remaining silent per her lawyer's advice. It also debunks a rumor linking Andrew Borden to the 1876 Jefferson Borden mutiny case, and notes that public sentiment in Fall River is turning more sympathetic toward Lizzie.

The Indianapolis Journal · 14 August 1892 · page 1

SENTIMENT AT FALL RIVER

Wright declined to ask Lizzie A. Borden or her sister, who is visiting her at the jail, whether their parents were on thescbooner Jellerson Borden, or whether either of them knew anything about the Lynn story. He lays this down as law: No qu'tions to no asked of persons in jail, whether visitors or not. Miss Borden passed a comfortablo night, and this morning was cheerful. Mr. Jennings and Miss Kmma Borden came up this morning, and the former, after a brief conversation, went away, leaving Emma in the cell with her sister.

See moreSee less

The two conversed in low tones for some timo, but there were no tears, no complainings, and the whole affair had the appearance of a simple, ordi nary every-day visit between friends. Dur ing part of the iime Lizzie was occupied with some sewing which she had brought with her. It is understood that under no circumstances will she open her mouth, and Mr. Jennings, her counsel, will do all the talking necessary." A dispatch from Boston says: "Mr. Wal ter, of Walter. Friend & Co., ship brokers of this oity. says in relation to the trial of the Jefferson-Borden mutineers: 'Ves, I remember the trial. It was away back in 1876. Captain Patterson bad killed two of his sailors, and the rest of the crew were up for an attempt to murder. Two were discharged, and the others got .life sen tences, und are still in jail at Thomaston. Their friends tried to have them released some time ago, but Captain Patterson got up a petition to keep them in, 'and they were kept in. But you'd hotter see Mr. Kinnnian. around on Doune street.1 "Mr. Kinsman, commission merchant, naid: 'Ves, I do know all about the matter. Captain Patterson claimed that tho men rose against hiui. and murdered tho second mate and a sailor, and tried to kill him, his vifo and the steward. Androw J. Borden was not on the vessel at all. Tho only peo ple in her cabin wero Captain Patterson and his wife, two mates and the steward. Those sailors are all in Thomaston jail. None was discharged after trial.' " .

See the clipping

The Indianapolis Journal · Indianapolis, Ind.

This editorial criticizes Fall River authorities for arresting Lizzie Borden without publicly offering solid proof, suggesting they acted out of desperation rather than genuine evidence. It argues that the alleged motive—family disagreements over money—is weak and that her character makes the brutal murders seem implausible.

The Indianapolis Journal · 14 August 1892 · page 12

FALL RIVER'S MYSTERIOUS CRIME

FALL BIVIE'3 MYSTE&IQOS CRIME. It the authorities of Fall River, Mass., have any good reason for the arrest of Miss Lizzie Borden for the murder of her father and step-mother, no harm could be done to the cause of justice by mak ing it public, and they would themselves' appear in a much better light. As it is, the unnecessary and owlish silence ob served by most of the legal function aries, and the entirely inadequate theo ries, not proofs, that others offer as to the guilt of the young woman give rise to a belief that these local Dogberries havo arrested Miss Borden, not because they have any proof of her participation in or knowledge of the crime, but be causo they cannot find any one else who might have done the deed, and in order to show that they are doing something to earn their salaries.

See moreSee less

Not a shadow of a motive for tho commission of the murder has been offered save the gossip of a servant and certain neigh bors as to family disagreements grow ing out of the wealthy father's, lack of generosity in money matters with his daughters stories that are disputed by equally good authority. Even if tho tales are true, it is most improbable, it is incredible, that a woman of the re pute and character of Miss Borden would resort to such brutality by way of revenge. Such an act on her part could only be accounted for on the ground that she was seized with a fit of maniacal rage, and this has not been suggested, nor was there, apparently, any sign of it before or after the dis covery of the murder. Miss Borden, who is of mature years, is described as a woman of sedate manner and retiring nature, active in church work und well liked by her acquaintances. Assuming" that she had deliber ately decided upon the "removal" of her parents it is beyond belief that she would adopt so horrible a method and perpetrate the act at a time when the servant was in the house and with in hearing, and when visitors were likely to cbme to the door at any mo ment. Murderers, it has been said, are sure, in spite of precautions, to leave somo clew to their identity, but in this caso Miss Borden, if guilty, escaped being caught in tho act merely by chance, and not through her own fore sight. As matters stand now it looks very much as if an outrage had been committed upon an innocent woman by incompetent police authorities.

See the clipping

The Indianapolis Journal · Indianapolis, Ind.

The piece argues it is incredible that a respected, church-going woman like Lizzie Borden could have committed such a brutal act, citing disputed stories about her father's stinginess as insufficient motive. It suggests that if she is innocent, the police authorities have outrageously accused her without proper grounds.

The Indianapolis Journal · 14 August 1892 · page 12

FALL RIVER'S MYSTERIOUS CRIME

The words of this article are printed with the report it shares its clipping with. Read them there or in the clipping.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

The Wichita Daily Eagle · Wichita, Kan.

The report cites a Lynn Item story suggesting Andrew Borden's testimony against mutineers decades earlier may have motivated revenge killers, possibly exonerating Lizzie Borden. It also notes servant Bridget Sullivan's comment that she isn't surprised by Lizzie's arrest, and mentions defense counsel Jennings has been denied access to inquest testimony ahead of the preliminary hearing.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

The Wichita Daily Eagle · 14 August 1892 · page 7

THE BORDEN MURDER

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

See the clipping

St. Paul Daily Globe · Saint Paul, Minn.

Bridget Sullivan, the chief prosecution witness, remarked she wasn't surprised by Lizzie Borden's arrest, startling the defense camp. Meanwhile public opinion in Fall River is cooling after initial fervor for conviction, and a new theory about the murder's motive is emerging.

St. Paul Daily Globe · 14 August 1892 · page 6

MISS SULLIVAN, THE MAIN WITNESS AGAINST LIZZIE BORDEN, DROPS A SIGNIFICANT REMARK TOUCHING THE LATTER'S ARREST. A REACTION BEGINS TO SET IN AMONG MANY PEOPLE IN FALL RIVER. A NEW THEORY ADVANCED AS TO THE MOTIVE FOR THE CRIME.

ernment should have acquainted Mr. J Jennings with its side of the cas?. The j district attorney would not talk on the ! case, beyond dropping an occasional hint as to its legal aspect. It is known thiit the government is indifferent as to -the opinions of people regarding the justice of the arrest of Miss Borden. It is reported that the prosecution will present but little of its case at the pre liminary hearing, keeping back, if pos sible, the most important evidence.

See the clipping

St. Paul Daily Globe · Saint Paul, Minn.

The report describes a lull in public hostility toward Lizzie Borden, with some influential people now believing a trial will prove her innocent. It also notes limited police presence at the Borden home, continued but less visible scrutiny of Morse and Sullivan, and the marshal's denial that searches were delayed until after the funeral.

St. Paul Daily Globe · 14 August 1892 · page 6

A ltesK-tion Setting; In. The reaction in the Borden case has set in, and today the popular feeling is noticeably quiet. There is very little violent discussion going on. Three days ago it was the popular cry that Miss Lizzie was a criminal, and should be placed behind prison bars. Today, although the district attorney and judges have passed their opinions on the evidence, there are many thoughtful and influential men who believe a trial will substantiate SIiFS Borden's protestations of inno cence. There is now but one police man at the Borden homestead, and he

See the clipping

St. Paul Daily Globe · Saint Paul, Minn.

Police renewed inquiry into a mysterious jewelry robbery at the Borden home about a year earlier, while Lizzie's cell visit with her sister Emma was described as calm and ordinary. Separately, the Lynn Item reported a theory that Andrew Borden's damaging testimony in an old shipboard mutiny trial may have provoked vengeance from released sailors possibly in Fall River at the time of the murders.

St. Paul Daily Globe · 14 August 1892 · page 6

THEORY OF REVENGE

building. Police inquiry is beiug mad again inlo'tlie de'aild'of" a ipystenou? robbery which took place at the Borden homestead about a year ago. '■■■ A lady's watch and several articles of jewelry were taken from a dressing-case in one of tiie upper rooms, and to this day the police have .been unable, to ■■trace tlir> thief, ' y h «raYy^*> Miss Borden passed a comforhible nieht and this morning was cheerful. Mr. Jennings and Miss Emma Berden came up this morning and the former, after a brief conversation, went away, leaving Emma in the cell with her sis ter.

See moreSee less

The two conversed in low tones for some time, but there were no tears, no complain ings, and the wholeaffair had the appearance of a simple, ordinary every-day visit between friends." Dur ing part of the time Lizzie was occu pied with some sewing which she had brought with her. It is understood that under no circumstances will she open "her mouth, and Mr. Jennings will do all the talking necessary.

See the clipping

The Sun · New York, N.Y.

A hackman named Donnelly and a man named Cook claim they were first to enter the barn before police and found evidence someone had slept in the hay the night before the murders. This revives a previously dismissed clue about a suspicious man seen by Officer Hyde and Dr. Handy, suggesting the police prematurely dismissed leads pointing away from Lizzie Borden.

The Sun · 14 August 1892 · page 2

IN LIZZIE BORDEN'S FAVOR

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

See the clipping

The Sun · New York, N.Y.

A hackman and a telephone man claim they found evidence someone slept in the Borden barn loft the night before the murders, contradicting police claims that this lead was investigated and found worthless. Their account also conflicts with Officer Medley's later testimony that no footprints were found in the dusty barn chamber.

The Sun · 14 August 1892 · page 2

IN LIZZIE BORDEN'S FAVOR.

WUl: Donnelly lives on Fourth street, two blooks H'' oast of tho l!o: don liouso. Ho telephoned up Ht.' to MoDcrmotl UrolJiers. tho undertakers, and Wi , thoy told him thnt it was trua that Mr. and .If, Mrs. Borden hud boon klllod. m& Ashnhnd noiiunlntaiioo with Mr. Borden, mVf- ; Donnelly wont directly ovor to the house. He III' - was thoro nt half past 11 o'clock, he is very Kit i 'sure. Tho police had not not thoro. for he l'". ' looked round to see if he could find one.

See moreSee less

KtlK ' There was a crowd around the honaeund ' j pooplo on tho street. Mr. Kouthnrrt Miller from K. is. across tho way railed to him and said: "' ' Why don't you mako a search. John?" 1 ' Mr. Donnelly replied:

See the clipping

The Sun · New York, N.Y.

The report notes conflicting evidence about footprints in the barn loft and disputes over who told Bridget Sullivan to wash windows, suggesting it was Mrs. Borden, not Lizzie. It also describes a growing public reaction favoring Lizzie's innocence, reduced police surveillance, and plans for the upcoming preliminary hearing.

The Sun · 14 August 1892 · page 2

IN LIZZIE BORDEN'S FAVOR.

& 3 denae. there are many thoughtful andlnflu & ' entlal men who believe a trial will substantialt ate Miss Borden's plea of not guilty. ;,; i There Is now only one policeman at the ?i i- ' Borden homestead, and be U doing patrol !'' duty on the street to prevent curious people f: i' from annoying the family. W iWhile direct polloo surveillance has been re fit Jmoved from Mr. Morse and Miss Bolllvan. ret ?k ? ; their whole connection with the ease will he

See the clipping

Pittsburg Dispatch · Pittsburg, Pa.

A report suggests Andrew Borden's damaging testimony against mutineers on the ship Jefferson Borden years earlier may have motivated his murder, as the convicted sailors reportedly swore revenge. Meanwhile, Lizzie Borden is described as calm in her cell, visited by her sister Emma and Miss Jennings, remaining silent while her lawyer speaks for her.

Pittsburg Dispatch · 14 August 1892 · page 7

BORDEN IN A MUTINY

During part of the time Lizzie was occu pied with some sewing which she had brought with her. It is understood that un der no circumstances will she open her mouth, and Mr. Jennings, her counsel, will do all the talking necessary. The Lynn Item to-day publishes a story stating that Andrew J. Borden, ot Fall River, gave the principal testimony that convicted the ring leaders in the mutiny on the schooner Richard J. Borden, while on the voyage from a foreign port to this coun try; that he and his wife were on the vessel;

See the clipping

Pittsburg Dispatch · Pittsburg, Pa.

The report recounts a shipboard mutiny in which Andrew J. Borden's testimony sent two Americans to prison, and speculates that paroled mutineers sought revenge by killing him and his wife. It also notes the sheriff's refusal to let anyone question Lizzie or Emma Borden about the ship or the mutiny story.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

Pittsburg Dispatch · 14 August 1892 · page 7

the C. E. Gehrlnp Brewlnc Company. Cleve magazine here!caUe,d The BumanUaHan,vhlch land, and the Schlathcr Brewlncr.nmn ,nlo not dsl,ln "pitenflti nam, with anyCl-flaiid. " " t'hv'.p'm !vr guilty by the courts and sentenced to death, but later President Cleveland com muted their sentences to imprisonment tor life in the State prison at Thomaston, Me. Revenge Sworn .calnst Mr. Borden. The principal testimony which the courts took under consideration and acted upon was given by a geutleman who was on board with his wife at the time, and who was the principal owner ot tne ship.

See moreSee less

Against this man the prisoners long ago swore they would have revenge. That man was Andrew J. Borden, of Fall River, who, with his wife, has gone down to death by an assassin's hand. The daughter's story of tbe two strangers about the house on the day ot the murder seems to have no weight with the police, although it may have later on if it should be learned that they were two ot the five men who were engaged in the mutiny. Up to a year ago a most strennous effort

See the clipping

Pittsburg Dispatch · Pittsburg, Pa.

The report explores an unproven theory linking Lizzie Borden's case to pardoned Jefferson Borden mutineers possibly in Fall River, while noting the Sheriff bars questions to the sisters about it. It also highlights servant Bridget Sullivan's comment that she isn't surprised Lizzie was arrested, and notes the prosecution plans to withhold key evidence at the preliminary hearing.

Pittsburg Dispatch · 14 August 1892 · page 7

The "Sheriff Allow No Qaestlnns. Sheriff "Wright declined to ask or have Lizzie A. Borden asked, or her sister Emma, who is visiting her at the jail, whether their parents were on the schooner Jefferson Borden, or whether either of them knew about the Lvnn story. He lays down the

See the clipping

Wheeling Sunday Register · Wheeling, W. Va.

The Lynn Item reports that Andrew Borden's testimony once convicted mutineers from the ship Jefferson Borden, some of whom allegedly vowed vengeance and may have been in Fall River at the time of the murders. The story suggests former mutineers as possible suspects in the Borden killings.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

Wheeling Sunday Register · 14 August 1892 · page 1

ANOTHER CLUE

Lynn. Mass., August 13.—The Lynn Item will to-day publish a story stating that Andrew J. Bordon, of Fall River, save the principal testimony that con victed the ringleaders in the mutiny on | the schooner Richard J. Borden, j while on the voyage from a foreign port to this country; that he and his wife were on the vessel; that his testimony in the courts was declared by the sailors to be false and exaggerated, and that the men who suffered by it vowed ven geance against him. Most if not all of them have been released, and It Is sub mitted that several of them were in F*H River at the time of the murder.

See moreSee less

Less than u dozen years ago, the ship ’ Jefferson Borden bound from a foreign port to this country was seized by the mutineers who claimed to have been | cruelly treated by the officers, and In i the general struggle and confusion the Captain was struck with a marlin spike and killed. The ringleaders of the mutiny, five In j number, were overpowered and placed ! in irons, aud when the vessel arrived In I port they were brought before the } courts for trial. Every man swore that 1 in the general fight that occucred it | was absolutely impossible to have lo i rated the murderer. By the aid of the | English Government, three of them who were foreigners, were either released or I escaped with light terms of Imprison I meat. Not so with the two Americans in the crowd. They were declared | guilty by the coart# and sentenced to ' death, but later President Cleveland commuted their sentence to imprison ment for life In the State prison at i Thomaston, Me. The principal testimony which the i courts took under consideration and acted upon, was given by a gentleman who was on board with his wife at the time, and who was the principal owner of the ship. Against this man the prisouers long ago swore they would have revenge. That man was Andrew J. Borden, of Fall River, who with his wife has gone down to death by assas sin's hand. Petitions for a pardon were signed by all trade and labor organizations of the country and presented to President Harrison, and It is believed that the men at Thoraaston were pardoned about eight months ago. If these men were releasee and the fact can be established ; that they, or any of their comrades in the mutiny, were in and about Fall ! River the day of the murder, It may

See the clipping

Wheeling Sunday Register · Wheeling, W. Va.

The report recounts a theory that Andrew Borden was murdered in revenge by former mutineers he had testified against, speculating this could exonerate Lizzie. It also notes Bridget Sullivan's comment implying she isn't surprised by Lizzie's arrest, alongside reports of growing public sympathy for Lizzie's innocence.

Wheeling Sunday Register · 14 August 1892 · page 1

ANOTHER CLUE

| guilty by the coart# and sentenced to ' death, but later President Cleveland commuted their sentence to imprison ment for life In the State prison at i Thomaston, Me. The principal testimony which the i courts took under consideration and acted upon, was given by a gentleman who was on board with his wife at the time, and who was the principal owner of the ship. Against this man the prisouers long ago swore they would have revenge. That man was Andrew J. Borden, of Fall River, who with his wife has gone down to death by assas sin's hand.

See moreSee less

Petitions for a pardon were signed by all trade and labor organizations of the country and presented to President Harrison, and It is believed that the men at Thoraaston were pardoned about eight months ago. If these men were releasee and the fact can be established ; that they, or any of their comrades in the mutiny, were in and about Fall ! River the day of the murder, It may j mean the release of Lizzie A. Borden, the victim of circumstantial evidence.

See the clipping

Wheeling Sunday Register · Wheeling, W. Va.

Three days after suspicion peaked, Fall River residents are now more skeptical of Lizzie Borden's guilt, with some believing a trial will prove her innocence. Meanwhile, her lawyer has been denied access to inquest testimony, and jail officials strictly limit what visitors may discuss with her.

Wheeling Sunday Register · 14 August 1892 · page 1

REACTION SETTING IN. Many Now Believe the Borden Girl Inno cent of the Crime for \\ hlch She ii Imprisoned. Fall River, Mass., August 13.— The reaction in the Borden cae has set in and to-day the popular feeling is quiet. There is very little violent discussion going on In the street, and what few cases seen were the outgrowth of hard expreisions against the imprisoned girl. Three days ago the popular cry was that Miss Lizzie was a crimtnai and should be placed behind the prison bars. To-day, although the District Attorney and Judges have passed their oplnioas on the evidence, there are many thoughtful and influen tial men who believe a trial will sub stantiate Miss Borden’s protestations of innocence.

See moreSee less

There is now but one po liceman at the Borden homestead, and he is doing patrol duty on the street to prevent curious people from auuoying the family. There will not be a great many wit nesses summoned for the preliminary | hearing unless the present plans are changed.

See the clipping

Waterbury Evening Democrat · Waterbury, Conn.

Authorities are awaiting Prof. Wood's analysis of blood and stomach contents while investigating leads and letters sent to police. Government officials reportedly believe Lizzie Borden may have been insane if she committed the murders, and public sympathy is shifting in her favor as an earlier theory about revengeful sailors has been discredited.

Waterbury Evening Democrat · 15 August 1892 · page 2

THINK SHE WAS INSANE.

the spots of blood on the axe and carpet. They say if there is any truth in the re ports that. Wood has discovered that the blood upon the axe and carpets is the same, it is very strange he has not heard it officially. The police to-day have been engaged in chasing down a suspect and te-rting state ments made in many letters sent to tho Marshal. It, is I.i..ie Borden's side of the story that is now attracting the attention ot the police. Officers Harrington and Dougherty have searched Rhode Island unsuccessfully for the man who drove tlu suspect to Newport.

See moreSee less

It is an open secret in police circles that the government officers believe that Miss Borden was insane at tho time of time of the murders, if sho committed them. Some evidence relating to tho pri vate life of Miss Borden, now in the hands of the police, bears directly on this side of the case and strengthens the opinion of the high police authorities who have sanl that .Miss liorUen was not conscious of her deeds, if she was implicated. Reports from the jail are to the effect that Miss llorden is almost prostrated her nerves are shattered and she is com pletely broken down from the terrible strain on her mind. She has all alum.' fully realized her position, and her re markable determination served her well for the time, hut now that she is openly accuscil ot tho nwltil crime the strain has proved too much for her. lhe tide ol public sympathy is turnin strongly now in favor of Miss Borden. lhe story about the revengeful sailors changed t he opinion of hundreds who be lie veil l.i.zie Borden guilty of the crime

See the clipping

Waterbury Evening Democrat · Waterbury, Conn.

The report notes that sentiment has begun shifting, with many now sympathetic to Lizzie Borden despite earlier near-universal belief in her guilt. It describes the case against her as largely circumstantial and negative in nature, resting on the question of who else could have done it rather than direct evidence.

Waterbury Evening Democrat · 15 August 1892 · page 2

woman. The clinic and the circumstances fol lowing stand unparalleled in tho history of crime in America. It was murder in cold blood, planned with nicety of arrani'.einent and consummated with uiilaitering nerve, ferocious iu'design, in human in every detail of its accomplish ment. I lit-, it is alleged, was done by J woman, mature in years, serious in tent peranieul ,t religious and dutiful in daily life. lhe mv-tcry is yet only partially solved. ii Mill presents grave doubts and i o it 1 ci cms. The discrepancy be tween ill.- ciiai'iiL'',er of the crime aud tho character of the accused between tho motive neccessarv and the motive estab lished is notable.

See moreSee less

The basis of the charge against Lizzie Borden is essential Iv of n neg.-it ive character. If she didn't do it, who did' they ask. Who else could have dune it .' The corroborative evident' the direct testimony against, her, is dis connected and far from conclusive. It not impossible, if improbable, that furl her developments will weaken instead of strengthen the charge against her.

See the clipping

Evening Journal · Wilmington, Del.

Fall River police reportedly believe Lizzie Borden is demented and are searching for a possible accessory after the fact, maintaining a guard on the receiving tomb at Oak Grove cemetery. The report also debunks a widely circulated claim that blood was confirmed microscopically on the ax handle, noting Professor Wood has made no such report and Medical Examiner Dolan denies hearing of one.

CorrectionThis set right an article from the day before.

Evening Journal · 15 August 1892 · page 2

THEORY OF INSANITY.

Pall River, Mass., Aug. 15.—The state ment that the police are looking for an ac cessory after the fact in tho Borden murder is partially confirmed by the fact that the receiving tomb at Oak Grove cemetery is still guarded night and day. The day after the mock burial, with which the police de ceived the Women who attended it in the role of chief mourners and chief suspect, they detailed men to guard the receiving tomb in which tho bodies wet« placed to await the second autopsy. Since the second visit of the surgeon the vigilance has never been relaxed for nu instant.

See moreSee less

Ono man still guards the house itself, though there is no ono beneath its roof except John W. Morse, who is under $500 bail, and Emma Borden, whose testimony U not considered of im portance. A statement given wide publicity was thB Bnb8tn,lco fonnd on tho bnndl ° of an ax taken from the Borden cellar liai proved under a microscope to be blood, and that It was identical in composition with that which stained the lounge and carpet whore Andrew Borden's body lay. This is merely conjecture. Professor Wood has made no report on the subject of stains. Medical Examiner Dolan positively denies Hint he has heard a word from Professor Wood ou the subject. To him tho report would come if it had come at all. A Great Legal Fight. For that reason the medical examiner says the stories to the effect that this damaging evidence has been completely established are purely imaginary. The reiterated state ment that the weapon found had been fitted into the wounds in Mm. Borden's skull is equally foolish. The defense would be strong enough In any case, but if it could be established that the ux which is now so slightly marked by blood had been placed in the wounds ils value as evidence would 1m gone iu u twinkling. There is half »million of money In Andrew Borden's mime. The others of the family connections are worth from t lOÜ.Oüü to KUX), «0U. What money cun dole save the name of the family and the life of one of its members will be done, AndrewD.Johnson.thopriaoner'scoun sel.wasueverknowutowaiveuncxaininn tion. He will fight from tho start. Tho inquiry will be resumed on Tuesday. The chief w itnesses yet to lie heard are Pro fessor Wood, who Is the atate analyst und microscopist in the present case, and Medi cal Examiner Dolan, whose testimony will supplement that of Professor Wood iu fix ing the time of death and tho interval elapsing between Mrs. Burden's death and that of her husband. A Double Bold un Lizzie. The inquest, after one or two sessions, will be adjourned from day to day until the date of the prisoner's examination. By pro ceeding this way the slate will be able to take an advantage of any new evidence which develops in the interval. Tho wording of the warrant on which Lizzie Borden was arrested shows the keen ness of the district attorney, as it is a ooa stitutionnl provision Hint the life of no per son shall be placed iu jeopardy for the .nine offense. Here whs a doable murder. Tije warrant served mentions the killing of An drew J. Borden alone. It does not even take cognizance of Mrs. Borden's death. By that omission the state secured a second hold npou the prisoner. It provides for oil emergencies. It is possible that the evi dence in hand, circumstantial in nature as it is. might not warrant the court in hold ing Miss Borden for the grand jury. She might escape through tho legal technicality loophole. In cither case she would be rear rested and charged with the murder of her stepmother. Tho warrant on which she is now held was based on tho murder of the old man, because most ut the evidence bore more directly upon that crime. The facts that Mrs. Borden was killed an hour before her husband, that Bridget Sullivan was in a position to have seen any stranger hud he approached or left the house during that time, and that Lizzie was then alone in the house with her stepmother, afford ground j for strong suspicion, but for little else. Consulting In Secret, The door of the guest chamber was closed, and did nut disclose its secret until after the father's body hfifi been found iu j the sitting room below. If there was any | noticeable noise during the tragedy it must have been more pronounced in the case of Mrs. Borden's death, for she, tho surgeons believe, was standing before the north win dow when the assassin strack the first blow. No one heard her fall, though she weighed | more than 200 pounds. Tho circumstantial

See the clipping

Evening Journal · Wilmington, Del.

The report denies widely publicized claims that blood found on an axe handle was microscopically matched to stains from Andrew Borden's body, with Medical Examiner Dolan stating he has heard nothing from Professor Wood on the subject. It also details the legal strategy behind Lizzie Borden's arrest warrant, which named only Andrew's murder to preserve a second prosecution option regarding Abby Borden's death.

CorrectionThis set right 2 earlier articles: The Morning News, 14 August 1892, The Wichita Daily Eagle, 14 August 1892.

Evening Journal · 15 August 1892 · page 2

The words of this article are printed with the report it shares its clipping with. Read them there or in the clipping.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

Evening Journal · Wilmington, Del.

The report explains that the arrest warrant against Lizzie Borden only charges her with her father's murder, not her stepmother's, as a legal strategy to allow re-arrest on a second charge if needed due to double jeopardy protections. It also notes the circumstantial evidence is considered stronger regarding Andrew Borden's death than Abby Borden's.

Evening Journal · 15 August 1892 · page 2

that of her husband. A Double Bold un Lizzie. The inquest, after one or two sessions, will be adjourned from day to day until the date of the prisoner's examination. By pro ceeding this way the slate will be able to take an advantage of any new evidence which develops in the interval. Tho wording of the warrant on which Lizzie Borden was arrested shows the keen ness of the district attorney, as it is a ooa stitutionnl provision Hint the life of no per son shall be placed iu jeopardy for the .nine offense.

See moreSee less

Here whs a doable murder. Tije warrant served mentions the killing of An drew J. Borden alone. It does not even take cognizance of Mrs. Borden's death. By that omission the state secured a second hold npou the prisoner. It provides for oil emergencies. It is possible that the evi dence in hand, circumstantial in nature as it is. might not warrant the court in hold ing Miss Borden for the grand jury. She might escape through tho legal technicality loophole. In cither case she would be rear rested and charged with the murder of her stepmother. Tho warrant on which she is now held was based on tho murder of the old man, because most ut the evidence bore more directly upon that crime. The facts that Mrs. Borden was killed an hour before her husband, that Bridget Sullivan was in a position to have seen any stranger hud he approached or left the house during that time, and that Lizzie was then alone in the house with her stepmother, afford ground j for strong suspicion, but for little else. Consulting In Secret, The door of the guest chamber was closed, and did nut disclose its secret until after the father's body hfifi been found iu j the sitting room below. If there was any | noticeable noise during the tragedy it must have been more pronounced in the case of Mrs. Borden's death, for she, tho surgeons believe, was standing before the north win dow when the assassin strack the first blow. No one heard her fall, though she weighed | more than 200 pounds. Tho circumstantial

See the clipping

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

This report describes the wounds on both victims, noting the surprising absence of blood and that the attacks appeared sudden and unexpected. It also relates the story given to police by the household: Mrs. Borden's morning errand, Mr. Borden's bank visit and nap, and Lizzie's discovery of her father's body after searching the barn.

Evening Star · 15 August 1892 · page 3

i= awhen the murders were committed. T'as. euivan. a domeatic, and Liegie Borden, the younger of the two daugtan.Theeider daughter was dibiag in Ama wan.Mre.iig. rs sosauwe' esta. The bet aam was gives by lasse Borden,

See the clipping

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

The report recounts Lizzie Borden's version of events—finding her father dead and sending for Bridget, then discovering her mother's body upstairs—while noting the household had recently fallen ill, possibly from poisoning. It also describes the police's initial theory of a lurking intruder, later abandoned in favor of suspicion that the crime was a family matter, as the inquest proceeded.

Evening Star · 15 August 1892 · page 3

low. According to Lizzie Borden ahe elep late that aorning and did sot t until Mrs. Bor den had gone ot, akse thogt, in reepome to the note from the neighbor. On going, down stairs Littie pased through the parlor and mw and spoke to her father. Bupposing her mother was out, she went Into the ysrd and entered the barn in search of a piece of lead, from which to cut "sabere" for a 44ing ex cursion she expected soon to oake to Marion to join soae Bandav school friends who were already soJo there.

See moreSee less

While in the barn she heard a cr== distress coming appaetly from the house. Bashing i, she foundh father deed on the sa. he called Bridget and they gave as alarm. 'le. they arehed upestairs for Mrs. Borden and found bar as d secribed. The door of the spre room, the trle. were told, was closed. Scwathe stern as related IS 1W OW m T3 Unlore and Yt evnsdi amr.a no elanes which to werk. sanoata o Ta oca. he Iret theory of the pollee wae tht a mur derer ta...m., with the plas ed concealed hhaelf tai the heams and had teken demperas ebenoee for the itander that might be at hand. rhis tiew waso re leqihed whes itewa found that nohn e4esae.Teplc net taard..e were a famil .atter *.ndgrows half ntheil e a of , segg At the cutest there were aeveral fanse elm. e arrembdo ma p be, u e one amnibi.

See the clipping

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

The report describes the ongoing investigation into the Borden murders, including Bridget Sullivan's account to police of her movements on the morning of the killings and John Morse's alibi. It also details the search for the murder weapon, noting several hatchets and axes found on the property, one with possible bloodstains, with evidence sent to Boston for chemical analysis.

Evening Star · 15 August 1892 · page 3

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

See the clipping

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

Fall River police are shown chasing down and dismissing numerous false tips, including a sighting of a mysterious 'wild-eyed man' and a claim of hearing cries from the Borden house, both proven untrue. Meanwhile, results from Professor Wood's analysis of blood on the axe and stomach contents remain unreported, and public attention is shifting toward Lizzie Borden's own account of events.

CorrectionThis set right 3 earlier articles: The Indianapolis Journal, 14 August 1892, Pittsburg Dispatch, 14 August 1892, Wheeling Sunday Register, 14 August 1892.

New-York Tribune · 15 August 1892 · page 1

LATEST PHASE OF THT FALL RIVER MYSTF RY POLICE STILL PM LIOWING UP OLEWS. Fal River, Mass, Anz. 14.=The Borden murders are the great tople here yet. Neither Medical Exam iner Dolan nor City Mar<hal Hillard have heard anything from Professor Wood, who Is analyzing the stom: achs of the victims and comparing the spots of blood on the axe and carpat. They say If there is any truth in the reports that Wood has diccovered that the blood upon the axe and carpets Is the same, it Is strange they have not heard it officially.

See moreSee less

The police to-day have heen engaged in chosing down dews aud toast! ig statements made in many letters sant to the Masshal. It Is Lizzie Borden's side of the ease that 1s pow at trecting the whole attention of the police. The report that Gideon Manchester, drawdender at Etone Drdee, had seen Dr. Handy's “wild-eyed man” being driven toward Newport by his brother has been proved to be niteue. Manchestee’s brother has been dead three years. Officers Harrington and Dougherty liave been all evar Rhode 153and Ln an unsnocesstul search to find who drove the snspect to Newport. The story Almer Coggeshall trdd the police about hls having thew cries tom the Borden household the moming of the murder amounts to nothing. His son was at work at Fors Hili, two miles from the scene, all day Thureday, Augnst 4. The police Lave spent some time running down the statement made azin that susplelons char acters were seen toward New Ledford, bul without sue ces. The City Martha! shows a strange collection of letters from all parté of the country suggesting ways and means to ocute the criminal, It is not thought now that the preliminary hearing sot down lor August 22 will ba of long duration It hus been the policy of DistrictAttorney Knowlton in handing caplial crines to give out as little svidence as possible until the trial takes place. Mr, Jennings, the atto ney who belleves in the innocence of Miss Norden, will do everyting tu his power to have a full examina ton al the earllesl date. 11s sturdy work at the time of the erralgmment Las done much to change public opinion ooncerntng the girl Although Miss Borden Is under arrest charged with perhaps the most heinous crime committe d In recent vears, there is lttle talk about the punishment that should te meted out to her. she l= finding sup porters ahd friends In the most unexpected places, The talk Is almost entirely regarding her chances of provifig her Innocence. This fact gives the police anthorities reason to think that much of the strongest evidence will have to be given before Mr. Jenkins will consent to an order for holding his client until November. Tt 1s an open secret In police circles that the Government offeers belleve that Miss Borden wis Insane wt the time of the murders, if she com mitted them. It 1s well known In this city that Judee Blaisdell and District Attorney Kuowlton were preju eed In Miss Borden's favor, and they most have had the strongest possible reasons for ordering her arrest, sone evidetice relating to the private life of Miss Borden, now in the hands of the police, bears direc ly on this side of the case and stiengthens the opinion of the high pollce authorities who have said that Miss Boden was not conscious of her deeds, if she was implicated. PP. i

See the clipping

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

Police report following up on various tips, including a false lead from Almer Coggeshall and unsubstantiated sightings near New Bedford, while receiving many crank letters suggesting how to catch the criminal. The piece also claims it is an 'open secret' that officials believe Lizzie Borden may have been insane if she committed the murders, and notes growing public sympathy for her innocence.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

New-York Tribune · 15 August 1892 · page 1

POLICE STILL FOLLOWING UP CLUES

The words of this article are printed with the report it shares its clipping with. Read them there or in the clipping.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

In the story →

The Indianapolis Journal · Indianapolis, Ind.

Police officials and Robert Pinkerton suggest that if Lizzie Borden committed the murders, she must have been mentally unbalanced. Meanwhile, investigators await forensic results on blood evidence and continue chasing leads ahead of the preliminary hearing.

The Indianapolis Journal · 15 August 1892 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

IF GUILTY SHE WAS INSANE

Opinion of Leading Police Officials and Friends of Miss Lizzie Borden.

See moreSee less

Evidence Relating to Her Private Life Said to Furnish a Basis for the Belief that Her Mind Was Unbalanced.

Robert Pinkerton Also Thinks the Perpetrator of the Crime Was a Lunatic.

Madman Kills His Companion and Throws Himself in Front of a Locomotive—Deadly Free Fight Follows a Dog Fight.

WAS MISS BORDEN INSANE?

Opinion Gaining Ground that She Was Ill She Committed the Double Crime.

FALL RIVER, Mass., Aug. 14.—The Borden murders are the great topic here yet. At the Central Congregation Church, of which the Borden family were members, union services were held to-day, attended by the members of the First and Central Churches.

City Marshal Hilliard has heard nothing from Prof. Wood, who is analyzing the stomach of the victims and comparing the spots of blood on the axe and carpet. He says if there is any truth in the reports that Wood has discovered that the blood upon the axe and carpet is the same it is very strange he has not heard it officially. The police to-day have been engaged in chasing down clews and testing statements made in many letters sent to the marshal.

It is Lizzie Borden's side of the case that is now attracting the whole attention of the police. It is not thought that the preliminary hearing set down for the 22d inst. will be of long duration. It has been the policy of District Attorney Knowlton in handling capital crimes to give as little evidence as possible until the trial takes place. Attorney Jennings, who beyond question believes in the innocence of Miss Borden, will do everything in his power to have a full examination at the earliest date. His work at the time of the arraignment has done much to change public opinion concerning the girl; more particularly that position referring to a fair trial by an impartial judge. Although Miss Borden is under arrest charged with perhaps the most heinious crime committed here in recent years, there is little talk about the punishment that should be meted out to her. She is finding supporters and friends in unexpected places. The talk is almost entirely regarding her chances of proving her innocence. This fact gives the police authorities reason to think that much of the strongest evidence will have to be given before attorney Jennings will consent to an order for holding his client until November. It is an open secret in police circles that the leading officers of the State believe that Miss Borden was insane at the time of the murders, if she committed them. It is well known in this city that Judge Blaisdell and District Attorney Knowlton were prejudiced in Miss Borden's favor, and they must have had the strongest possible reasons for ordering her arrest. Some evidence relating to the private life of Miss Borden, now in the hands of the police, bear directly on this side of the case, and strengthens the opinion of the high police authorities who have said that Miss Borden was not conscious of her deeds if she was implicated.

Views of Robert Pinkerton.

NEW YORK, Aug. 14.—Robert Pinkerton gave his views on the Borden murders to a reporter to-day. He said he had not studied the case from a detective's stand-point, but only through the newspapers. He said, in reply to a question whether Lizzie Borden's arrest was justified by the facts, that he thought it was, but that such an action did not necessarily imply that she was guilty. It would be quite possible for a person to enter the house by stealth and commit the crime without being seen, and to prove the point Mr. Pinkerton mentioned several cases where large sums of money had been stolen by expert thieves in broad daylight. When asked if he thought the murderer an insane perso[n], he said: "Judging from what I have read about the case it seems to me that the person who killed Mr. and Mrs. Borden must have been insane, but I would not care to be quoted as advancing an insanity theory." Continuing, he said: "It seems strange that there are no more conclusive clews to be followed, if the reports of blood-stained walls and ceiling are true. If they were in such a condition the murderer must have gone away with blood stains on his clothing. Now where are these bloody clothes? The mere fact that Miss Borden has told conflicting stories is more in her favor than if she had unhesitatingly stuck to the same tale, as an innocent person is more likely to make conflicting statements than a guilty one."

Concerning the Pinkerton detective who was placed on the case and who was severely criticised by the Fall River authorities, he said: "The authorities seemed to have thought that our detective was brought into the case for the purpose of protecting Lizzie Borden. Such was not the case. He was wired by the family to follow any clews that might lead to the detection of the criminal. He has been removed from the case at my suggestion, as I thought it unwise to have a private detective on the case until the authorities had reached some decision." The lawyer who has charge of Miss Borden's interests Mr. Pinkerton considers a very clever man, and thinks her interests will not suffer while under his care.

See the clipping

The Indianapolis Journal · Indianapolis, Ind.

Police are chasing down clues and testing letters sent to the marshal while analyzing blood evidence on the axe and carpet. Officials reportedly believe privately that Lizzie Borden may have been insane if she committed the murders, and public opinion is shifting toward sympathy for her.

The Indianapolis Journal · 15 August 1892 · page 1

WAS MISS BORDEN INSANE?

She Committed the Doable Crime. Fall. River. Mass., Aug. 14. The Borden murders are the great topio here yet. At the Central Congregation Church, of which the Borden family were members, union services were held to-day, attended by the members ot the First and Central Churches. City Marshal Hilliard has heard nothing from Prof. Wood, who is analyzing the stomaoh of the victims and comparing tho spots of blood on the axe and carpet. Ha . says if there is any truth in the reports that WTood has discovered that the blood upon the axe and carpet is the same it is very strange he has not beard it officially.

See moreSee less

The police to-day have been engaged in chasing down clews and testing statements made in many letters sent to the marshal. It is Lizzie Borden's side of the case that is now attracting the whole attention of the police. It is not thought that the pre liminary hearing set down for the 22dinst, will be of long duration. It has been tho policy of District Attorney Knowlton in handling capital crimes to give as little evidence as possible until the trial takes place. Attorney Jennings, who beyond question believes in the innocence of Miss Borden, will do everything in his power to have a full examination at the earliest date. His work at the time of the arraignment has done much to change pnblio opinion concerning the girl; more particularly that position referring to a fair trial by an im partial judge. Althougu Miss Borden is under arrest charged with perhaps the most beinions crime committed here in re cent years, there it little talk about the punishment that sbonld be meted out to her. She is finding supporters and friends in unexpected places, i he talk is almost entirely regarding her chances of proving her innocence. 1 his fact .gives the police authorities reason to think that much of the strongest evidence will have to be given before attorney Jennings will con sent to an order for holding his client until November. It is an open secret is police circles that the leaning othcers of the State believe that Miss Borden was insane at the time of the murders, if she commit ted them. It is well known in this city that Jndge Blaisdell and District Attorney Knowlton were prejudiced in Miss Borden1! favor, and they must have had the strong est possible reasons for ordering her ar rest. Some evidence relating; to the pri vate life of Miss Borden, now in tho hands of the police, bear directly on this side of the case, and strengthens the opinion of the high police authorities who have said that Miss Borden was not conscious of her deeds if she was implicated.

See the clipping

The Indianapolis Journal · Indianapolis, Ind.

Robert Pinkerton discusses the Borden murders, suggesting the killer may have been insane and noting that Lizzie's conflicting stories could indicate innocence rather than guilt. He also clarifies that the Pinkerton detective assigned to the case was hired by the family to find the real criminal, not to protect Lizzie Borden.

The Indianapolis Journal · 15 August 1892 · page 1

WAS MISS BORDEN INSANE?

Views of Robert Pinkerton. Nkw York, Aug. 14. Robert Pinkerton gave his views on the Borden murders To a reporter to-day. He said he had not stud ied the case from a detective's stand-point, but only through the newspapers. He said, in reply to a question whether Lizzie Bor den's arrest was justified by the facts, that he thought it was, but that such an action did not necessarily imply that she was guilty. It would be quite possible for a person to enter the house by stealth and commit the crime without being seen, and to prove the point Mr.

See moreSee less

Pinkerton mentioned several cases where large sums of money had been stolen by expert thieves in broad daylight. When asked if he thought the murderer an insane perse, bo said: "Judg ing from what 1 have read abont the caso it seems to me that the person who killed Mr. and Mrs. Borden must have been insane, but 1 would not care to be quoted as ad vancing an insanity theory." Continuing, he said: "It seems strange that there are no more conclusive clews to be followed, if the reports of blood-stainod walls and ceiling are true. If they were in such a condition tho murderer must have gone away with blood stains on his clothing. Now where aro these bloody clothcsT T be mere fact that Miss Borden has told conflicting stones Is more in her favor than If she had unhesi tatingly stuck to the 6ame tale, as an in nocent person is more likely to make con flicting statements than a guilty one." Concerning the Pinkerton detective who wa9 placed on the case and who was se verely criticised by the Fall River autbori- . ties, he said: "The authorities seemed to have tnought that our detective was brought into the case for tho purpose of protecting Lizzie Borden. Such was not the cane. Ho was wired by the family to follow any clows that might lead to the de tection of the criminal. He has been re moved from the case at my suggestion, aa 1 thought it unwise to have a private de tective on the -case nntil the authorities had reached some decision' The lawyer who has charge of Miss Borden's Interests Mr. Pinkerton considers a very clever man, and thinks her interests will not sutler while under his care.

See the clipping

Der Deutsche Correspondent · Baltimore, Md.

The Lynn, Mass. newspaper 'Item' suggests Andrew Borden may have been murdered in revenge by persons linked to a mutiny aboard the schooner 'Richard L. Borden,' against whom he had testified. Meanwhile, Lizzie Borden spent a sleepless night in jail and felt unwell, while police also reexamined an unsolved burglary at the Borden house from a year earlier.

Der Deutsche Correspondent · 15 August 1892 · page 1

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

See the clipping

Daily Kennebec Journal · Augusta, Me.

Prof. Wood's analysis reportedly found no evidence of poison in the victims' viscera, undercutting the theory that the Bordens' illness before the murders was due to poisoning. The blood on the hatchet, carpet, and sofa coverings was said to be scientifically consistent with human blood, and some lawyers doubted the state had enough evidence for an indictment.

Daily Kennebec Journal · 15 August 1892 · page 1

prior to the murder was caused as a result • f poisoning, and thu* the attempted pur chase of prussic acid by Mis* Borden on Wednesday will, even if true, fail in value a supplementary piece of evidence show ing criminal deliberation and planning on her part. There are many sound lawyers and pro fessional men in this city tonight, who, basing their opinion* on the case as it ha* developed to date, believe that insuMieicnt evidence is |M>**e*sed by the State to justify finding of an indictment by the gran t jury.

See moreSee less

On t’n*- contrary, the officer* in the case are positive that the prisoner will he held for trial, hut on the fart* in their possesion now tin v do licit themselves believe a eon- ; v ietioti I - pos-'de. I hey reason that from now on evidence will he gathered without difficulty. however, and that a strong case ' will be made out ultimately.

See the clipping

Daily Kennebec Journal · Augusta, Me.

The report discusses conflicting legal opinions on whether the State has enough evidence for an indictment, while poison evidence undercuts an earlier theory about the Bordens being poisoned before the murders. It also details a new theory suggesting former mutineers from the schooner Jefferson Borden, against whom Andrew Borden once testified, may have sought revenge.

Daily Kennebec Journal · 15 August 1892 · page 1

IT MAY BE A CLUE.

M.i > \ug. Id. Thel.yim Item t*>.I;iv published a *lory stating that Andrew .1 Borden of Fall liiv. r gave the principal testimony that connected the ring leader* in the mutiny on the schooner Jefferson Borden, while on a voyage from a foreign port to this country, that lie and hi w-fc were on th1 vessel, that the testimony ill the courts was declared by the -ailors to he false and exaggerated and that the men who suffered by it vowed vengeme agam-t him. Most, if not all of them, have been released and it isubmitted that several of them were in Fall Kiverat the time of the murder.

See moreSee less

* Bess than a do/.en years ago the schooner .1. tiers* m Borden, hound from a foreign port to tin-country, was seized hy muti .

See the clipping

Daily Kennebec Journal · Augusta, Me.

Marshal Hillard responds to criticism of the police handling of the Borden case, saying he cannot yet reveal inquest details. The report also notes lawyer Jennings' denial of knowing about a will, and previews the defense's argument that the total absence of blood on Lizzie's garments suggests innocence given Bridget Sullivan's constant presence in the house.

Daily Kennebec Journal · 15 August 1892 · page 1

ment. and « specially Mar-lmll Hillard, has Ik-en subjected to severe eritu Um in regard to the handling of the Borden ease. Marshal Hillard was interviewed this evening in relation t<> the criticism. 1 don't feel that I have been lax in my duty he -aid. because I think that I un der-land the situation better than most who have seen tit to criticise my aetion-. I am not at liberty yet to tell all that I could. In-eau-e I should have to relate eer tain matters which rame out at the inquest, and which must be kept bark for the pres ent.

See moreSee less

Mr. Jennings has stated several times that he had not heard of any intention to make a will, and thinkin the face of the ehtim <>f the poliep that they have evidence to prove that a will was fortheoming. that if it were true he. a* Mr. Borden's lawyer, would have heard it asoon as any one. The entire absence of blood on Miss Bor den's garments i* something the defence will argue in favor **f her innocence. If ■he killed her mother, it was done with Bri Fret Sullivan on the premises, and she must not only do the deed, hut conceal all evidences of the crime at the risk of being discovered at any stage by this servant who was running all about the house that morn ing. tir*t in the kitchen after water, then out to wa-h tho windows on the first floor, which commanded, one after another, every room on that floor: and, on occasion, out into the front hall to admit Mr. Borden.

See the clipping

St. Paul Daily Globe · Saint Paul, Minn.

Robert Pinkerton tells a reporter he believes Lizzie Borden's arrest was justified by the facts, though not proof of guilt, and suggests the killer may have been insane given the bloody crime scene. He also notes her conflicting statements could indicate innocence rather than guilt, and comments on criticism of the Pinkerton detective assigned to the case.

St. Paul Daily Globe · 15 August 1892 · page 8

He Thinks the Person Who Killed the Bordens Insane. New York, •Aug. 14.— The Herald says: Robert Pinkerton gave his views on the Borden murders to a reporter yesterday. He said he had not studied the case from a detective's standpoint, but only through the newspapers. He said, in reply to a question whether Lizzie Borden's arrest was justified by the facts, that he thought it was, but that such action did not necessarily im ply she was guilty. , It would be quite possible for a person to enter the house by stealth and commit the crime with out being seen, and, to prove the point, Mr.

See moreSee less

Pinkerton mentioned several cases where large sums of money had been stolen by experts in broad daylight. When asked if he thought the mur derer an insane person, he said: "Judging from what I have read about the case, it seems to me that the person who killed Mr. and Mrs. Borden must have been insane, but 1 would not care to be quoted as advancing an in sanity theory.". Continuing, he said: "It seems strange that there are no more conclusive clues to be followed if the reports of blood stained walls and ceiling are true. If they were in such a condition, the mur derer must have gone away with blood stains on his clothing. .Now, where are these bloody clothes? "The mere fact that Miss Borden has told conflicting stories is more in her favor than if she had unhesitatingly stuck to the same tale, as an innocent person is more likely to make conflict ing statements than is a guilty one." Concerning the Pinkerton detective who was placed on " the case, and who was severely criticised by the Fall River authorities, he said: "The authorities seemed to have thought that our detective was brought into the case for the purpose of protect ing Lizzie Borden from them. Such was not the case. He was hired by the fam ily to follow: any clues that might lead to the detection of the criminal. -He has been removed from the case at my suggestion, as 1 thought it unwise to have a private detective on the case until the authorities had reached some decision." The lawyer who has charge of Miss Borden's interests Mr. Pinkerton con siders a very clever man, and thinks her interests will not suffer while under his care.

See the clipping

St. Paul Daily Globe · Saint Paul, Minn.

A Pinkerton official discusses whether the Borden killer was insane, noting the puzzle of missing bloodstained clothing despite reports of blood on walls. He also defends hiring a private detective for the family and explains removing him pending authorities' decision.

St. Paul Daily Globe · 15 August 1892 · page 8

PINKERTON PUMPED.

The words of this article are printed with the report it shares its clipping with. Read them there or in the clipping.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

Omaha Daily Bee · Omaha, Neb.

Bridget Sullivan, a key witness, said she wasn't surprised Lizzie Borden was arrested, alarming the defense. Lizzie's lawyer Jennings still has no access to inquest testimony, and the prosecution plans to reveal little evidence at the preliminary hearing.

Omaha Daily Bee · 15 August 1892 · page 2

No New Developments In the Borden Murder Case

No Now DcAclojnuciitH In the Tfolilcn Mur der Oaso. FAU. RiviiiMns9.Aug.l4. : The noticeable feature lu tbo Harden case yesterday was an expression made by Brldgot Sullivan during an interview She remarked : "SVoll , I don't wonder that they arrested Lizzie Borden. " As Miss Sullivan Is the most Important government witness her statement has startled tbo friends of the impilsonod woman. A. J. Jonnlng.4. counsel for Miss Lizzlo , has been able to got no inkling of the testi mony elicited ut tha inquest. A great many people fool that the government should have acquainted Mr.

See moreSee less

Jennings wltn its side of the case. Tbo district attorney will not tulle on tbo case , beyond dropping an occasional hint as to Its legal aspect. It Is known that the government Is indifferent as to the opinions of people regarding the justice of the arrest of Miss Borden. It Is reported that the prosecution will present but llltlo of its case nt tbo preliminary hearing , keeping back , if possible , the most important evidence.

See the clipping

The Evening Herald · Shenandoah, Pa.

Investigators are analyzing blood evidence and stomach contents while pursuing leads on Lizzie Borden's side of the story, including a suspect driven to Newport. Government officials reportedly believe she may have been insane and unconscious of her actions if she committed the murders, as public sympathy shifts in her favor after a story about revengeful sailors was debunked.

The Evening Herald · 15 August 1892 · page 2

THINK SHE WAS INSANE. Theory of Government Ofllcers In Llzxls llonlen's Case. Fall River, Mass., Aug. 15. Tho Bor den murders nnd the arrest o Lizzie Bor den are still tho great toplo of discussion. Neither Medical Exnmlner Dolan or City Marshal Billiard have heard anything from Prof. Wood, who is analyzing tho stomachs of the victims and comparing the spots of blood on the axe and carpet. They say if thcro is any truth in the re ports that Wood has discovered that the blood upon tho nxe and carpets is the same, it is very strange ho has not hoard it officially.

See moreSee less

Tho polico to-dny havo been engaged In chasing down a suspect and testing state ments made in many letters sent to tho Marshal. It is Lizzie Borden's side of tho story that is now attracting tho attention of the police. Officers Harrington and Dougherty havo searched Rhode Island unsuccessfully for the man who drove tho suspect to Newport. It Is an open secret in polico circles that the government officers believe that Miss Borden was insane at the timo of time of the murders, if she committed them. Somo evidence relating to tho pri vate lifo of Miss Borden, now in tho hands of the police, bears directly on this side of the caso and strengthens tho opinion of tho high police authorities who havo eaid that Miss Borden was not conscious of her deeds, if she was implicated. Reports from the jail aro to tho effect that Miss Borden is almost prostrated, her nerves are shattered and she is com pletely broken down from tho terrible strain on her mind. Sho has all along fully realized her position, and her re markable determination served her well for tho time, but now that she is openly accused of the awfuT crime tho strain bus proved too much for her. The tide of public sympathy is turning strongly now In favor of Mies Borden. Tho fctory about tho revengeful sailors changed tho opinion of hundreds who bo liovcd Lizzie Borden guilty of the crime

See the clipping

The Evening Herald · Shenandoah, Pa.

The report notes that the theory of revengeful sailors committing the murders has been debunked, yet sympathy for Lizzie Borden is growing as suspicion turns toward her accusers. It argues the evidence against her is largely circumstantial and inconclusive, built mainly on the absence of another suspect rather than direct proof.

The Evening Herald · 15 August 1892 · page 2

woman. The crime and the circumstances fol lowing stand unparalleled in the history of crime in America. It was murder in cold blood, planned with nicety of nr rangement and consummated with unfalleiing narve, ferocious In design, in human in yry detail of its Hcoompllsh meat. This, it is nlleged, was doneby a woman, mature In years, .erious in tern perament,treliKtous and dutiful in daily life. The mystery is yet only partially solved. It still presents gravo doubts and contradictions. The discrepancy ba tween the cun,r,tifcT of the crime and tho character of t4baccused between the motive neccossa and the motive estab lished is notable.

See moreSee less

The basts of the charge against Lizzie Borden Is essential ly of a negative character. If she didn't do it, who didt they ask. Who else could have dona It? The corroborative evidence, the direct testimony against her, Is dis connected and far from conclusive. It is not impossible, If Improbable, that further developments will weaken Instead of strengthen the charge against her.

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

Friends of Lizzie Borden are considering prominent criminal attorneys like Gen. Roger Pryor, Solomon Lucas, and John Andrew Taylor to lead her defense if she is held for trial. Meanwhile, more observers are criticizing the closed-door inquest, arguing a public hearing would have prevented press errors and unfair speculation.

The Providence News · 15 August 1892 · page 1

THAT STAR CHAMBER INQUEST.

About the Fall River Mystery. ISPECIAL TO THE NEWS.) FALL RIVER, Aug. 15.—The immediate friends of Lizzie A. Borden are planning for bher defence wheu the case against her comes to trial, should the preliminary examination on the 221 result in a finding of probably guilty. The namesof several leading attorneys of the country are being considered in the course of selecting a suitable senior to Mr. Jennings in the trial. Among distinguisbed criminal counsel who have been recommended are Gen. Roger A. Pryor of New York, Solo

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

The report discusses public debate over whether the Borden inquest should have been open rather than private, arguing a public inquest might have prevented newspaper errors. It also relates anecdotes about Andrew Borden's stinginess and domineering control over his daughters, including a business negotiation and restrictions on gifts and suitors.

The Providence News · 15 August 1892 · page 1

THAT STAR CHAMBER INQUEST.

waus a member of a committee appointed I‘)I the Knights of Pythias to confer with Mr. Bordeu about leuinf the lot on which the A. J. Borden Block on South Main and Anawam streets now stands. During the conference Mr. Borden Kro posed to lease the lot for twenty or fifty years, on a sliding scale of its assessed valuation, and requiring but 6 per c:nt. on that amount, upon condition that the Pythiaos erect a building on the spot, to cost at ‘least §50,000, the building, at the end of the lease, to belong to the estate.

See moreSee less

“That,” said the committeeman, after remarking at the previous stages of the proposition how favorable it was—'‘ that knocked the whole thing. We wanted bim to provide for the sale to the estate at a figure to be fixed by judges, but he would not listen to that.” : A neighbor who konew the family for years said last evening that he could see no motive on Lizzie's part for desiriug to kill er stepmotner, for it was always by ti.e stepmother’s intercession that she kot anything which her 'ather was not

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

A Fall River neighbor describes Andrew Borden's extreme penny-pinching toward his daughters Emma and Lizzie, including control over money and discouragement of suitors. The report also covers a church sermon for Lizzie and unconfirmed rumors that Professor Wood's analysis found blood and poison, while police continue chasing down clues.

The Providence News · 15 August 1892 · page 1

Rumors of Finding Blood and Poison

Were Premature. FALL RIVER, Aug. 15.—~The Borden murders are yet the great topic of conversation in this city. At the Cen tral Congregational Church, of which the Borden family were members, union ser vices were held, attended by members of the first and central churches. The pul. pit was filed by R:v. Dr. Mason, Bowdoin College, Brunswick, Me. He spoke on the words “Our Fatber,” In opening his sermon he spoke tenderly of the young girl of his flock who was stricken down with misery. He prayed that the Lord might grant her strength to bear up un. der tho terrible opprossion now her lot. Continuing he said: “A great cloud bas settled upon one of the familles of

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

A newspaper editorial questions the propriety of Judge Blaisdell presiding over both the inquest and the preliminary hearing in the Fall River murder case. It suggests that while this may have been technically legal, it violates the public's sense of moral justice.

The Providence News · 15 August 1892 · page 4

—THE PROVIDENCE NEWS. Exrorts are still increasing in quan tity and value, That horrid McKinley bill ! YESTERDAY was a perfect summer Sun day and as far removed fzom a dogday as possible, Ir Lizzie Borden turns out to be inno cent how awfully * cheap” those Fall River slenths will feel. You could buy a job lot of 'em for 10 cents. WHrrsey undertook the biggest job of his life when he engaged to heal the Hatfield-McCoy fend between William

See the clipping

San Antonio Daily Light · San Antonio, Tex.

A brief news digest item states that Lizzie Borden is not generally believed to be guilty of murdering her parents. This reflects the uncertain public opinion during the ongoing investigation into the Borden murders.

San Antonio Daily Light · 15 August 1892 · page 1

Miss Lizzie Borden is not generally believed guilty of the murder of her parents. Serious caving of river banks in Al giers, La., carries several buildings into tbe stream. Kansas is excited over the arrival of Russian emigrants from tbe cholera districts. Murderous aftrays are reported at Nashville, Tenn.; Liberty Hill, Corri gan and Aria, in Texas. Carpenter shop of Huntington, Pa., reformatory burned, and south wing of reformatory. Houston is full of strangers. Hogg’s headquarters at the Capitol, Clark's at tbe Hutchins House. Caperton arrested at Texarkana by hie new father-in-law. The second marriage was a runaway affair. Heavy freight train collision on tbe Southern Pacific near Beaumont, no one hurt; loss $60,00). Will Ashe arrested for the assassi nation of his father, ex-commissioner

See the clipping

Alexandria Gazette · Alexandria, D.C.

An editorial argues that if Lizzie Borden committed the Fall River murders, she was fully conscious, not in some trance-like state. It mocks the idea that a sane person could temporarily go 'crazy' just long enough to commit and conceal a crime.

Alexandria Gazette · 15 August 1892 · page 2

Ax attempt is now be'tig made to induce the belief thai Miss Borden com? mitted the recent horrible crime at Fall River, but that she did so while iu an unconscious condition. She may be guilty, though it is hardly probable; but if she is. that she was perfectly con? scious at the time is as plain as the nose on her face. The commission of crime and well devised etl'orts to avoid detec? tion are ineampitable with loss of con? sciousness. No sane man believes that another oue goes crazy just long euough to commit a crime, and those who say he does render themselves ridiculous.

See moreSee less

The farmers' alliance in some of the counties of theState are surrendering their charters and disbanding, because politics have been introduced in them und attempts made to transform them into third party organizations. All of them should do sr. The alliance was organized to help fanners, nol to help the republican party. which is the only conceivable effect the third party cau produce iu Virginia,

See the clipping

Alexandria Gazette · Alexandria, D.C.

The report claims it is an open secret among Fall River police that officials believe Lizzie Borden was insane at the time of the murders of her father and stepmother, if she committed them. This appears amid a roundup of unrelated national and international news items.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

Alexandria Gazette · 15 August 1892 · page 2

committee. It is an open secret in police circles at Fall River, Mass., that the State of licei"S believe that Miss Borden was in? sane at the time of the murders of her

See the clipping

The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · Wheeling, W. Va.

Fall River police continue analyzing evidence, including stomach contents and bloodstains, while following up leads from letters sent to the marshal. Public sentiment is growing in support of Lizzie Borden's innocence ahead of her preliminary hearing.

The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · 15 August 1892 · page 1

THE BORDEN MYSTERY. Lizzie Borden Has Many Friends Who Believe Her Innocent.

in his handling capital crimes, to Hive as little ovidenoe as possible until tbe trial takes placo. Attorney Jennings, who, beyond question, believes in the innocence of Mies Borden, tfill do everything in his power to have a full oxaminauon at tbo earliest date.

See the clipping

Wheeling Register · Wheeling, W. Va.

Fall River police are still testing evidence, including lab analysis of stomach contents and bloodstains, while Lizzie Borden remains in jail. Public sentiment increasingly leans toward her innocence or insanity, and officials expect the district attorney to withhold evidence until trial.

Wheeling Register · 15 August 1892 · page 1

A GENERAL FEELING THAT SHE IS EITHER INNOCENT, OR WAS INSANE AT THE TIME THE MURDERS WERE COMMITTED — THE STATE WILL LIKELY BE COMPELLED TO SHOW ALL ITS EVIDENCE TO HAVE HER HELD FOR TRIAL

Held for Trial. Fall River, Ma^., August 14.—The Borden murders are the groat topic here yet. City Marshal Hilliard has heard nothing from l’rof. Wood, who is ana lyzing the stomachs of the victims and comparing the spots of blood on the ate and carpet. The police to-day have been engaged in chasing down clues and testing state ments in m»ny letters sent to the Mar sha!. It is Lizzie Harden's side of the case that is now attracting the whole attention of the i*olice. It is not thought uow that the prelimi nary hearing set down for the ‘.’Vnd lust., will be of long duration.

See moreSee less

It ha* been the policy of District Attorney Knowlton, in his handling of capital crimes, to Hive as little evidence as pos sible until tb** trial takes place. Attor ney .lonnings, win. beyond question be lieves in the Innocence of Miss Borden, will do everything in his power to bars* a full examination at the earliest date. Although Miss Itorden is under arrest, charged with perhaps the most heinous crime committed iu lecent years, there is little talk about the punishment that, should he meted out to her. She it finding supporters and friends iu uio»t unexpected places. '1 he talk Is almost entirely regarding her chances of prov ing her innocence. This fact gives the police authorities reason to think that much of the strongest evidence will have to he given before Attorney Jen nings will consent to an order for hold ing his client until Novembar. it is an open secret in police circles that the government ollicers believe that Miss Borden was insane at the time of the murders, if she committed them.

See the clipping

Morning Journal and Courier · New Haven, Conn.

Fall River residents and lawyers debate whether Judge Blaisdell should preside over Lizzie Borden's preliminary hearing, since he already issued the arrest warrant based on the prosecution's case. Supporters of Borden argue she should welcome full scrutiny so that an acquittal would be unquestionable.

Morning Journal and Courier · 16 August 1892 · page 3

miSS BORDEN'S TRIAL. Shall the Preliminary Hearing ha Before Judge Blaladellt Doubt About the Young Woman's Cullt She Receives Kind Treatment In Jail Letters of Consolation Fre quently Received. Fall Rivib, Aug. 15. The most im portant subject to-night is that relating to the proepeoU for securing aa impartial preliminary hearing for Miss Lizzie Borden next Monday. The point raised by

See the clipping

Morning Journal and Courier · New Haven, Conn.

The report discusses the upcoming preliminary trial, noting fair treatment expected in New Bedford and low bail for witnesses Bridget Sullivan and Mr. Morse. It details anticipated prosecution evidence based on Sullivan's testimony about Lizzie's behavior, plus kind treatment of Lizzie in jail and a sympathy letter from her Christian Endeavor society.

Morning Journal and Courier · 16 August 1892 · page 3

MARSHAL HILLIABD'S STATEMENT. Marshal Hilliard's statement concerning the published opinions of the various news papers of the country haa given rue to much speculation as to the character of the evidence that the prosecution can sub mit at the trial. It will be of a positive nature, will be based on statements made by Bridget Sullivan relating partially to Miss Lizzie's manner before and after the crime, her inetruotlons to wash windows in remote parts of the house; also her con duo t toward her stepmother the past six months. KIND TREATMENT TO MISS Ufth his Miss Emma Borden, who wene relief I.-

See the clipping

The Morning Call · San Francisco, Calif.

Fall River's City Marshal Hilliard defends his handling of the Borden case, saying the press lacked the facts revealed at the inquest and that Lizzie Borden's arrest was not hasty. A senior Borden family member denies rumors that family money will be used to hinder the investigation, insisting no Borden will impede the police.

The Morning Call · 16 August 1892 · page 1

IHE FALL. BITKR MYSTERY. The Borden Fanr.ly Say Th<-y Will Not Obstruct the Investigation Fai.i. RIVER, Mass., Aug. lo.— City Mar shal Hiliiard *aii this morning regarding the criticisms of tl.e press concerning bis conduct of the Borden case that the news papers did not have the facts disclosed at the inquest, and that tho case depended en tirely on circumstantial <videi.ee. Lizzie Borden had not been Imprisoned in haste or without a full understanding of the circumstances. The most important member of the Bor den family said this morning: "The honor of the Burdens is not to be articled by po lice suspicion, perhaps resting lastly, on Lizzie Borden.

See moreSee less

No true Borden ever placed a stumbling block in the way of the law and no member of my family will, In any way, hamper the police In their investigation. The statement that 515. 000,000 of Borden money is to be used in balking the authori ties is untrue and ill-advised."

See the clipping

Los Angeles Herald · Los Angeles, Calif.

City Marshal Hilliard defends his conduct in the Borden case, saying newspapers lack the facts from the inquest and that Lizzie Borden's arrest was not hasty. A family member states the Bordens will not hinder the investigation despite rumors that family money would be used to obstruct authorities.

Los Angeles Herald · 16 August 1892 · page 2

A Member or the Family Says Investi gation Will Not Be Hindered. Fall River, Masa., Aug. 15.—City Marshal Hilliard said thia morning, re garding the criticisms by the press of hia conduct in the Borden caae, that the newspapers did not have the facts dis closed at the inqueat, and that tbe case depended entirely on circumstantial evidence. Lizzie Borden has not been imprisoned in haete, or without a full understanding of the circumstances. A moat important member of tbe Bor den family said thia morning: "The honor of the Bordens will not be affected by the police suspicion, perhaps resting justly on Lizzie Borden.

See moreSee less

No true Bor den ever placed a stumbling block in tbe way of the law, and no member of my family will in any way hamper the police in their investigation. The atate ment that $15,000,000 of Borden money will be used in balking the authorities, is untrue and ill-advised.

See the clipping

The Record-Union · Sacramento, Calif.

City Marshal Hilliard responds to press criticism of the Borden case, saying newspapers lacked facts from the inquest and that the case rests on circumstantial evidence. A Borden family member denies rumors that family wealth would be used to obstruct the investigation.

The Record-Union · 16 August 1892 · page 1

TIIK BORDEN CASE. Marshal Billiard Talks Conecininir the Criticisms of tho Press* Pall Bivkk (Mass.), Aug. 15.—City Marshal Billiard said this morning re garding the criticisms by the press of the conduct, of the I'or len case, that the newspapers did not have the facta dis closed at the inquest, and tne case de pended entirely on circumstantial evi dence. Lizzie Borden had not been im prisoned iv haste, or Without a full un ending of the circumstances. The most important member of the Borden tamily suid this morning: "The honor of the Bordens wus not to be af fected by police suspicion, perhaps rest ing justly on Lizzie Borden.

See moreSee less

No true Borden ever placed a stumbling-block in the way ofthe law, and no mem ber of my family will in any way hamper the police iv the investigation. The statement that fifteen millions of Bord* n money will ne used in balking the authorities is untrue and ill-advised."

See the clipping

Evening Journal · Wilmington, Del.

Fall River Marshal Hilliard responds to critical editorials, insisting the arrest of Lizzie Borden was justified by ample evidence gathered after chasing down over a hundred leads. He states the case will rest on circumstantial evidence and that the public has not yet seen the full facts disclosed at the inquest.

Evening Journal · 16 August 1892 · page 2

THE ACT WAS CALMLY DETERMINED She Was Not I prisoned In llusie Nor With. it a Full IlndrrstramliiiK *>f What Her Incurrerath Mt+snt — inpHt hy fur the Accused. l AU . r IV rk, Mass., Aug. 10 -City Mar slml Hilliard was shown about fifty edit» rials clipped from various punert» published I« New England during tho lust few day*, Most of them reflect a belief in Miss L ; zzie Borden's entire innocenco of the crime charged against her, mid assail the Full River police for prolonged delay in the case n pd for directing their efforts wholly to vva| .|i proving Miss Borden guilty.

See moreSee less

Mar „j m i u i U i,n-,t n ad most of the editorials , ,, , „ , , carofull - v - 1111,1 UIICe or twin» when his actions were criticised pointedly. He spoke warmly, and said it was about time ont of town people suspended judgment on Lizzie Borden and her arrest by tho Full River police.

See the clipping

Evening Journal · Wilmington, Del.

The district attorney and police defend their decision to arrest Lizzie Borden, stating they have ample cause based on inquest evidence not fully reported by newspapers. The report also notes the Borden family does not blame authorities for the arrest and dismisses rumors that family wealth would be used to obstruct the investigation.

Evening Journal · 16 August 1892 · page 2

derstanding of what her arrest means, Th« Korden l-uiully Honor. A great deal bus been said iu out c f town papers about the cruelty of detaining a finely bred nnd sensitive woman, as Miss Borden is. One of the greatest complaints that has been made against the adminis trator of police affairs has been that he was too easily moved by his feelings, too senti mental to be a polio*- officer. That he ha il very kind heart and a courteous mannet is acknowledged by all the members of the Borden family, and they do not blame the authorities for the harshness of the arrest.

See moreSee less

A great deal of nonsense is being published in connection with the case about tho Bor den family honor. On this point the most important member of the Borden family said for publication; "The honor of the Bordens, whoso Harms are so closely allied with the prosperity of the town, is not tc be affected by a police suspicion, perhnp» resting Justly, on Miss Lizzie Borden. Nt

See the clipping

Evening Journal · Wilmington, Del.

A newspaper editorial argues the public should suspend judgment on Lizzie Borden's guilt or innocence until the government presents its case in court, criticizing hasty conclusions based on incomplete information. It also reports that a Christian Endeavor youth group sent a message of sympathy to Borden in jail, and notes preliminary hearing testimony about a servant washing windows and Borden's relationship with her stepmother.

Evening Journal · 16 August 1892 · page 2

Jai , tbw mori , mg! i I W e. th. members of the Young People's So clety of Christian Endeavor, desire to extent I '° our fellow member. Ml«s Lizzie A Borden our sincere sympathy with her in herpree. nl hour of trial, aud onr confident belief that six will soon he restored to her place of usefulness aimmg ua Tbe u . los ' important subject of talk in tow " is tbr ' relating to the pro»|wts foi

See the clipping

The Wilmington Daily Republican · Wilmington, Del.

City Marshal Hilliard reviews dozens of New England newspaper editorials sympathetic to Lizzie Borden and critical of police for her arrest. He defends his investigation, saying he pursued over a hundred leads and that the public doesn't know the full inquest evidence justifying her detention.

The Wilmington Daily Republican · 16 August 1892 · page 1

THE BORDEN MURDER / City Marshal Hilliard Sustains His Action / SYMPATHY FOR THE PRISONER

Man's Daughter—Sympathy of tho Young People'« Society. Fall River, Mass., Aug. 16.— City Marshall Hilliard was yesterday morn ing shown about fifty editorials clippedv from varions papers published in New England during the past few days. Most of them reflect a belief in Miss Lizzie Borden's entire innoceuce of the id assail tue crime charged against her Fall River police for prolonged delay in aud for directing their efforts il. wholly toward proving Miss Borden guilty. Marshal Hilliard read most of the

See the clipping

In the story →

The Wilmington Daily Republican · Wilmington, Del.

The police marshal defends Lizzie Borden's arrest, insisting the public has not been told the full inquest evidence and that authorities had ample cause. A Christian Endeavor Society sends her sympathy, and a Taunton reporter reveals Bridget Sullivan now says she lay down due to nausea and vomiting, not fatigue, raising the possibility the victims were poisoned.

The Wilmington Daily Republican · 16 August 1892 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

THE BORDEN MURDER

City Marshall Hilliard Sustains His Action.

See moreSee less

SYMPATHY FOR THE PRISONER.

A Large Number of New England Newspapers Assail the Authorities for Imprisoning the Murdered Man's Daughter—Sympathy of the Young People's Society.

FALL RIVER, Mass., Aug. 16.—City Marshall Hilliard was yesterday morning shown about fifty editorials clipped from various papers published in New England during the past few days. Most of them reflect a belief in Miss Lizzie Borden's entire innocence of the crime charged against her and assail the Fall River police for prolonged delay in the case and for directing their efforts wholly toward proving Miss Borden guilty.

Marshal Hilliard read most of the editorials carefully and flushed once or twice when his actions were criticised pointedly. He spoke warmly and said it was about time out of town people suspended judgment on Lizzie Borden and her arrest by the Fall River police. "I started," he said, "on an outside clew within a half hour of the discovery of the tragedy on information furnished by members of the family. I have chased down more than a hundred outside clews within ten days. You and every other citizen must remember that the newspapers have not given anything near the facts disclosed at the inquest. You and the public may rest assured of this fact. The district attorney and myself are satisfied that the public authorities have ample cause for holding this girl, and she has not been imprisoned in haste nor without a full understanding of what her arrest means."

A great deal has been said in and out of town papers about the cruelty of detaining a finely bred and sensitive woman as Miss Borden is. One of the greatest complaints that has been made against the administrator of police affairs has been that he was too easily moved by his feelings, too sentimental to be a police officer. That he has a very kind heart and a courteous manner is acknowledged by all the members of the Borden family, and they do not blame the authorities for the harshness of the arrest. A great deal of nonsense is being published in connection with the case about the Borden family honor. On this point the most important member of the Borden said for publication yesterday morning:

"The honor of the Bordens, whose names are so closely allied with the prosperity of the town, is not to be affected by a police suspicion perhaps resting justly on Miss Lizzie Borden. No true Borden has ever placed a stumbling block in the way of the law, and no member of my family will in any way hamper the police in their investigation. The statement that $15,000,000 of Borden money will be used in balking the authorities, is untrue and ill advised."

FALL RIVER, Mass., Aug. 16.—The following was sent to Taunton jail yesterday morning: "We, the members of the Young People's Society of Christian Endeavor, desire to extend to our fellow member, Miss Lizzie A. Borden, our sincere sympathy with her in her present hour of trial and our confident belief that she will soon be returned to her place of usefulness among us."

TAUNTON, Mass., Aug. 16.—A Taunton Gazette reporter learned from Bridget Sullivan on Sunday that the reason she lay down on the day of the Borden murders was because she was troubled with naseau that morning and vomited several times while washing windows. Previous statements from the police have been to the effect that she laid down because she was tired with the work. It is probable that this statement was held back if made known at the inquest, as bearing upon the theory that the victims may have been dosed with poison.

See the clipping

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

Fall River City Marshal Hilliard responds to critical newspaper editorials suggesting Lizzie Borden's innocence and police overreach, defending the thoroughness of the investigation. He states police pursued over 100 outside leads before acting and insists ample evidence from the inquest justifies holding her.

New-York Tribune · 16 August 1892 · page 1

CITY MARSHAL HILLIARD SAYS SHE WAS x08 ARRFSTED WITH UNDUE HASTE. : : Fall River, Mass., Aug. 15.—City Marshal Hillard this morning saw about fifty editorials clipped from various papers published In New-England during the last few days. Most of them reflect a bellef in Miss Lizzie Borden’s entire innocence of the orime charge against her, and assail the Fall River police for prolonged delay In the case and for directing thelr efforts wholly toward proving Miss Borden guilty. Marshal Hilllard read most of the editorials carefully and flushed once or twice when his actions were pointedly. He spoke warmly and sald it was about time people suspended judgment on Lizzie Borden and

See the clipping

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

The Fall River police marshal defends Lizzie Borden's arrest, citing extensive investigation of over 100 leads and insisting the case rests on undisclosed inquest evidence. A Borden family member defends the family's honor, while critics question Judge Blaisdell's propriety in presiding over both the inquest and the upcoming preliminary trial.

New-York Tribune · 16 August 1892 · page 1

The words of this article could not be separated from the rest of its page. Read it in the clipping.

No clean clipping could be cut from this page

The Indianapolis Journal · Indianapolis, Ind.

Fall River Marshal Hilliard responds to editorials criticizing police for focusing solely on proving Lizzie Borden guilty, insisting the newspapers haven't reported the full facts from the inquest. He states authorities have ample cause for holding her, and a Borden family member defends the family's honor despite the suspicion.

The Indianapolis Journal · 16 August 1892 · page 2

MUST HAVE STRONG EVIDENCE

Reason for arresting Lizzie Borden. Fall River, Mass., Aug. 15. City Mar ihal Milliard was to-day shown about fifty editorials clipped from various papers pub lished in New England during the past few days. Most of them reflect a belief in Miss Lizzie Borden's entire innocence of the crime charged against her, and assail the Tall Kiver police for prolonged delay in the case and for directing their etlorts wholly toward proving Miss Borden guilty. Mar shal Hilliard read most of tho editorials carefully and ssid: "You and every other citizen must remember that the news papers have not given anything near tho facts disclosed at the inquest.

See moreSee less

This caso will depend on circumstantial evidence wholly, and the people's interests cannot be subserved by throwing the evidence into the hands of the defense until a hear ing of the trial takes place. You and the public may rest assured of this fact. Tho district attorney and myself are satis tied that the public authorities have ample cause for holding this girl, and she has not been imprisoned in haste, nor withont a full un derstanding of what has been published in oonnection with the case about tho Borden family honor." On the last point the most important member of the Borden family said for pub lication this morning: "The honor of the Borders, whose name are so closely allied with the prosperity of the town, is not to be affected by a police suspicion, perhaps resting jnstly on Miss Lizzie Borden. So true Borden has ever placed a stumbling block in the way of the law and no mem ber of my family will in any way hamper the police in the investigation. The state inent that fifteen millions of Borden money will be used In balking the authorities is nntrue and ill-advised." The following was sent to the Taunton fail this morning: "Wo, the members of tho Young People's Society of Christian En deavor, tie aire to extend toourfellow mem ber. Miss Lizzie Borden, our sincere sym pathy with her in her present hourof trial, and nor confident belief that she will soon bo restored to her place of usefulness among us."

See the clipping

The Indianapolis Journal · Indianapolis, Ind.

A district attorney official insists authorities have ample cause to hold Lizzie Borden and that evidence is being withheld from the defense until trial. Family and a Christian Endeavor society also issue statements supporting her and denying rumors of Borden money being used to obstruct justice.

The Indianapolis Journal · 16 August 1892 · page 2

MUST HAVE STRONG EVIDENCE.

The words of this article are printed with the report it shares its clipping with. Read them there or in the clipping.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

Dziennik Chicagoski · Chicago, Ill.

The report states that Lizzie Borden, arrested in Fall River for the murder of her father and stepmother, is probably innocent according to most of the New England press. Police officials counter that the press is unaware of the strong circumstantial evidence that made her arrest necessary.

Dziennik Chicagoski · 16 August 1892 · page 1

W sprawie morderstwa małżonków Borden.

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

See the clipping

The Wichita Daily Eagle · Wichita, Kan.

Fall River's City Marshal Hilliard reviewed about fifty newspaper editorials, most sympathetic to Lizzie Borden and critical of police delay and tactics. He defended the decision to hold her, citing strong circumstantial evidence and denying rumors that Borden family money would be used to bribe authorities.

The Wichita Daily Eagle · 16 August 1892 · page 2

THE BORDEN CASE. Fall River. Mass., Aug. 15. City Marshal Hilliard was yesterday shown about fifty editorials, clipped from var ious New England papers. Most of them reflect a belief in Miss Lizzie Borden's in

See the clipping

Semi-Weekly Interior Journal · Stanford, Ky.

A short news item reports that Lizzie Borden has been arrested at Fall River, Massachusetts, and charged with the murder of her father and stepmother. It appears as one line among many unrelated regional news briefs.

Semi-Weekly Interior Journal · 16 August 1892 · page 2

NEWSY NOTES. There are but thrco Chinamen in Louisville. Lizzie Borden is under arrest at Fall River, Mass., charged with the murder of her father nnd step-mother.

See the clipping

Daily Kennebec Journal · Augusta, Me.

The Women's Christian Temperance Union and Young Women's Union held a special meeting and passed resolutions expressing sympathy to Lizzie Borden over her parents' deaths. They also declared their unshaken faith in her innocence, noting she served as the Young Women's Union's treasurer.

Daily Kennebec Journal · 16 August 1892 · page 1

-- I THEIR SYMPATHY An Unshaken Faith in miss Lizzie Borden Expressed by the Union Ladies. K VI i Hum. Aug. 2 V—The Women's Christian Temperance I'nixm ail.l The Young Women's I nion hi'i.l a s|»‘i'ial

See the clipping

Daily Kennebec Journal · Augusta, Me.

The report reviews the lack of blood evidence against Lizzie Borden, the freshly cut lead supporting her barn story, and undisturbed dust questioned by a detective. It also notes that stomach analysis of the victims reportedly showed no trace of poison, discrediting earlier poisoning theories.

Daily Kennebec Journal · 16 August 1892 · page 2

| being used. and the output of the carbtiild | mg companies will be increased over any previous year. This shows the prosj*erity of the country outside of the line* of agri- ^ , culture. shipbuilding and general meebani-■ • ai and building operations which are most i prominent at the Kast, and indicates the; presence of a national policy favorable to these operation* which it is desirable should W continued. The Borden Myttery. As tune goes on public sentiment is com ing vt-rv rapidIv to the belief that Miss l.izzie Horden is entirely innocent of any complicity in the murder of her father and stepmother.

See moreSee less

If there is a vestige of evi-, i lenoe to ptove anything of the kind it has vet to he made public. So far as this i use ha* developed, everything goe s to substan tiate her claim of innocence. It is scarcely possible that she could have committed these terrible crimes and still not have a single . drop of blood anywhere upon her clothing. In the short time at her disposal it would certainly seem an impossibility to so com pletely remove all traces of such :» hutch-1 cry. Again a search of the barn substan dated tier story by showing the lead which she claimed to have been after, with a por

See the clipping

Daily Kennebec Journal · Augusta, Me.

The report defends Lizzie Borden's account of visiting the barn before the murders, arguing undisturbed dust proves nothing given how quickly dust resettles. It notes that stomach analysis of the victims reportedly showed no trace of poison, undercutting druggists' testimony that she tried to buy some.

Daily Kennebec Journal · 16 August 1892 · page 2

(lined, to show that Miss Horde n was guilty of falsehood in claiming to have been there at tintime she stated. The an alysis of tin* stomachs of tinvictims of this horrible crime did not. it is reported, show anv trace of js»is«*n. This will tend to di* credit the testimony of the druggists who were so positive ill their identification of Lizzie Borden as a would-be purchaser of |M>ison. It is of course, among the pos sibilities that Lizzie Borden committed this crime but in view .*f the evidence thus far adduced we arc frank to confess that we do not consider it among the probabilities.

See the clipping

The Portland Daily Press · Portland, Me.

The Society of Christian Endeavor, Women's Christian Temperance Union, and Young Women's Association sent messages of sympathy and support to Lizzie Borden in Taunton jail, expressing confidence in her innocence. City Marshal Hilliard cautioned the public to withhold judgment until more facts are known, while a medium claimed to have received a message from Andrew Borden's ghost.

The Portland Daily Press · 16 August 1892 · page 1

The {Society of Christian Endeavor Be lieve Lizzie Innocent. Farr River, Mass., August 15.—The following was sent to Taunton jail this morning: “We, the members of the Young Peo ■t < n * i_ _ t? m_• -A?_iji_J_ J. yiO O kjuvivLJ Vi vuiiouuu xmuvuiui) vv sire to extend to our fellow member, Miss Lizzie A. Borden, our sincere sym pathy with her in her present hour of trial and our confident belief that she will soon be restored to her place of use fulness among us.” City Marshal Hilliard advises those peoplewho are declaring that Lizzie Borden is arrested without just cause to suspend judgment until they know more of the facts.

See moreSee less

A medium has appeared upon the scene with a long letter pretending to solve the mystery through a communica tion from Andrew J. Borden’s ghost. The Women’s Christian Temperance Union and the Young Women’s Associa tion held a meeting tonight and passed resolutions offering profound sympathy to Miss Lizzie A. Borden in the bereave ment that has befallen her by the tragic death of her parents, and expressing un shaken faith in her. Miss Borden is treasurer of the Young Women’s Associ ation, and has been prominent in union worln _

See the clipping

St. Paul Daily Globe · Saint Paul, Minn.

Fall River Marshal Hilliard defends keeping inquest evidence from the defense until trial, dismissing newspaper editorials sympathetic to Lizzie Borden's innocence. A Borden family member states the family will not interfere with justice despite suspicion resting on Lizzie.

St. Paul Daily Globe · 16 August 1892 · page 1

HIDING THEIR HAND

in connection with the case." About the Borden family honor,, the most important member of the Borden fumily said for publication this morn ing: "The honor of the Burdens, whose names are so closely, allied with the prosperity of the town.* is not to be affected by a police suspicion, perhaps resting justly on Miss Lixzie Borden. No true Borden has ever placed a stumbling block-in the way of the law, and no member of my family will in any way hamper the police in their in vestigation. The statement that fifteen millions of Borden money will be used in balking the authorities is untrue and ill-advised.'

See moreSee less

- The following was sent to the Taun ton jail this morning: We. the Young People's Society of Chris tian Endeavor, desire to extend to our fellow member. Miss Lizzie A. Borden, our sincere sympathy with her in her present hour of trial, and our confident belief that she will soon be restored to her place of usefulness among us.

See the clipping

St. Paul Daily Globe · Saint Paul, Minn.

The state's attorney explains that evidence from the inquest is being withheld from the defense until trial, defending Lizzie Borden's continued imprisonment. A reporter also reveals Bridget Sullivan said she lay down due to nausea and vomiting, not fatigue as police first claimed, fueling poisoning theories.

St. Paul Daily Globe · 16 August 1892 · page 1

HIDING THEIR HAND.

The words of this article are printed with the report it shares its clipping with. Read them there or in the clipping.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

The Helena Independent · Helena, Mont.

Fall River City Marshal Hilliard responds to press criticism of his handling of the Borden case, stating Lizzie Borden's arrest was not hasty and was based on circumstantial evidence from the inquest. A Borden family member denies rumors that the family's wealth will be used to obstruct the investigation.

The Helena Independent · 16 August 1892 · page 1

Will not Obstruct the Law. FALL BRIva, Mass., Aug. 15.-COty Mar shal Hilliard said this morning, regarding uriticisme by the press of his conduct of the Borden case, that the newspapers did not have the facts disclosed at the inquest. and that the case depended entirely on cir oumstantial evidence. Lizale Borden had not been imprisoned in haste or without a full understanding of the eircumstances most important. A member of the Borden family selid this morning that the honor of the Burdens was not to be nfiect by police suspicion, perhaps justly on Lizzie Borden.

See moreSee less

"It is not true that a Borden ever placed a stumbling blook in the way of the law, and no member of the family will in any way hamper police investigation. The state ment that fifteen millions of Borden money will be used in balking the authorities is astre and Ill.adysed."

See the clipping

Pittsburg Dispatch · Pittsburg, Pa.

New England newspapers published editorials criticizing the Fall River police for delays and for focusing solely on proving Lizzie Borden's guilt, with many expressing belief in her innocence. Marshal Hilliard defended the police's actions as justified by evidence not yet public, while a Christian Endeavor Society sent Borden a note of sympathy during her imprisonment.

Pittsburg Dispatch · 16 August 1892 · page 12

BELIEVE LIZZIE INNOCENT. .The Fal) Itlvrr Police Assailed by New England Papers Christian Endeavor Boclety People Send a Note of Sympathy to the Accrued Girl. Fall Bivee, Mas&, Aug. 15. City Marshal Hilliard was this morning shown about 50 editorials clipped from various papers published in New England during the past few days. Most of them reflect a 'belief in Miss Lizzie Borden's entire inno cence of the crime charged against her, and

See the clipping

Pawtucket Tribune · Pawtucket, R.I.

This editorial argues public opinion is turning against the authorities for acting too hastily in charging Lizzie Borden, criticizing the secrecy of the inquest proceedings. It notes she was denied counsel during hours of grueling examination, while still expressing hope that the true culprit, whoever it may be, is caught and punished.

Pawtucket Tribune · 16 August 1892 · page 2

THE BORDEN CASE.

OF ILLINOIS. A CITY WELL SERVED. The municipal management of Boston under Democratic administration com pares more than favorably with the for mer administrations controlled by Mayor Hart. The tax rato for this year Is §12.%0 per $l,OOO which 18 a lower rate than this city enjoys under the wasteful extrava gance Indulged in by a Republican City Council which controls appropriations. In this city the rato Is §13.831-3 per $l,OOO. THE BORDEN CASE. The reaction has set In in the Lizzie Borden case and the opinlon is fast growIng general that the authorities have act ed too hastily.

See moreSee less

And they have, unless they are in posession of more evidence than has been given to the publie. The proceedings seem 1o have about them too much secrecy and mystery to suit the American mind, At the Inquest Miss Borden was denied the privilege ot coun sel and was put through hours ot exami nation which must kave been torture to her, notwithstanding her great nerve and fron will. It is to be hogroed that the daughter may be found innocent of the horrible and unnatural crime with which she 18 charged. At the same time, it is most desirable that the gullty person should be detected and punished, oven it the criminal should be the person now under susplolon of the double murder,

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

The report describes Lizzie Borden's composed demeanor at Taunton jail, visits from clergy and her sister, and tokens of sympathy sent by her church community. It notes the police have revealed no details of evidence against her, and mentions the family physician's claim that she had previously been mentally unwell.

The Providence News · 16 August 1892 · page 1

AT THE TAUNTON JAIL

Congnfittonal church of this city, of which Miss Borden has been secretary, expressive of the sympathy of the mem bers with _her and their belief that she v;]nl soon be restored to usefulness among them, This is one of many tokens of confidence and tenderness which would be sent to Miss Borden if those who desire to be re membered to her felt free to send them. Miss Borden is in food physical condi tion, and seems likely to withstand the wear and tear of the accusation without

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

The report describes public sympathy for Lizzie Borden, including a resolution from women's temperance groups, and notes the police have revealed no evidence against her. It also details the Borden house's unusual layout and surfaces rumors of past insanity in the Borden family, including a claim by an old physician that Lizzie had been 'insane.'

The Providence News · 16 August 1892 · page 1

This was said without the faintest hint of seeking an excuse for the arrest of Liz zie A. Borden, The Rev. W, F. Fisher, who ?renchod in the Brondwa({ Congrega tional Church, Taunton, Sunday, against the action of the police was referreu to by Marshal Hilliard with a smile, and the remark that ‘‘you’d better go and inter view him, if you want some items.” The construction of the Borden house has never been counsidered in any ac counts of the murders. The house was constructed forty or fifty years ago, and was built expressly for a murder, as Ben jamin Cook says.

See moreSee less

It is impossible to go from the front of the second floor to the rear of the second floor by a direct courss ; to reach the back of the house, inside, one must pass over the first floor. There is a partition unbroksn between the rooms on the east and those on the west side of the house. It is readily seen that a murderer who committed his first act on the second floor would have every

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

An unnamed source claims insanity runs in the Borden family, suggesting it's hard to find a 'perfectly sane Borden.' Meanwhile, two Fall River women's organizations pass resolutions expressing sympathy and support for Lizzie Borden following her parents' deaths.

The Providence News · 16 August 1892 · page 1

‘““We offer our profound uym:.hy to Miss Lizzie A. Sorden in the sad and painful be reavement which has befallen hoer the re cent tn'ie death of her parents. e would also declare our unshaken faith in her, as a fellow worker and sister tenderly bo‘ond. and would assure her of our constant earnest prayers that she may be supported under the unprecedented trials and sorrows now resting upon her.” Miss Borden is treasurer of the Young Women's Union and has been prominent in union work.

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

Fall River townspeople debate whether Judge Blaisdell can impartially preside over Lizzie Borden's preliminary hearing, since he has already heard the prosecution's case. Some argue a different judge should hear it to ensure a fair, thorough airing of evidence that would fully vindicate her if innocent.

The Providence News · 16 August 1892 · page 6

LIZZIE BORDEN'S TRIAL. Prospects for an Impartial Preliminary Hearing.

cused prob.bl{ guilty. The case may have the fuilest exposure and venttiating before the court has fiwor to take juris diction should guiilt established. One of the strongest believers in Miss Borden’s innocence raised this point to day. Miss Lizzie and her truest friends should court the fullest investigation. When she is acquitted, her innocence should be 8o fully established that not a shadow ef suspicion can remain against her, It was urged, however, that the prisoner had the right to bave sufficient government evidence exposed to indicate what line of action was to be pursued; to show what line of defence she must pre pare to meet it.

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

The report discusses confidence in Judge Blaisdell's impartiality and prosecutor Knowlton's judgment in ordering Lizzie Borden's arrest. It also notes the low bail for witnesses Bridget Sullivan and John Morse and speculates that their testimony about Lizzie's demeanor will be central to the prosecution's case.

The Providence News · 16 August 1892 · page 6

ments. It has been noticeable here for several days that intelligent persons have ceased giving positive opinions on the merits of the case. Temperate minded people will not talk at longth about facts, but will arcwy that no fairer trial can be secured than may be bad in this city. There has never been any intense anger here against Miss Borden, despite the weight of the charge made against her, The most prominent lawyers in the city have changed their opinions on the mer its of the case since District Attorney Knowlton ordered thearrest. They have great confildence in Mr. Knowlton’s sense of justioe in ordering the city marshal to lock Miss Borden in a felon’s cell.

See the clipping

The Salt Lake Herald · Salt Lake City, Utah

City Marshal Hilliard defends his handling of the case, saying newspapers lacked facts disclosed at the inquest and that the case against Lizzie Borden rests on circumstantial evidence. A senior Borden family member denies rumors that the family would obstruct the investigation or use a fortune to bribe authorities.

The Salt Lake Herald · 16 August 1892 · page 1

BORDEN MDBDlia CASE Reports Penietl By the City llarahil anti e Member of tie Borden Family FALL RIVER Mass Aug 15City Mar shal HHliard said this morning regarding lag the criticisms by the press of his con duct in the Borden case that the newspa pers di3 not have the facts that vera dis closed at the inquest and that the case de pended entirely on circumstantial evidence Lizzie Borden had not beau imprisoned in haste or without a full understanding of the circumstances The most important member of the Bor den family said this morning that the honor of the Bordens was not to be affected by police suspicion perhaps resting justly on Lizzie Borden It was not true that a Borden ever placed a stumbling block in the wav of the law and no member of the family will in any way hamper police in vestigation The statement that fifteen millions of Borden money will be used In

See the clipping

The Seattle Post-Intelligencer · Seattle, Wash. Terr. Wash.

City Marshal Hilliard says newspapers lack full inquest facts and that Lizzie Borden's imprisonment was not hasty but based on circumstantial evidence. A Borden family member denies rumors that family honor or money would be used to obstruct the investigation.

The Seattle Post-Intelligencer · 16 August 1892 · page 3

The Borden Murder Mystery. FALI. RIVER, Mass., Aug. 15.— City Mar shal Hilliard said this morning, regarding the criticism by the press of the condition of the Borden case, that the newspapers did not have the facts disclosed at the in quest, and that the case depended entirely on circumstantial evidence; that Lizzie Borden had not been imprisoned in haste or without a full understanding of the cir cumstances. An important member of the Borden family said this morning that the honor of the Bordens was not to be af fected by the police suspicion, perhaps resting justly on Lizzie Borden.

See moreSee less

It was not true that the Bordens had ever placed a stumbliug block in the way of the law, and no member of the family would in any way hamper tbe police investigation. The statement that fifteen millions of Borden money would be used in balking the au thorities was untrue and ill-advised.

See the clipping

The Cheyenne Daily Leader · Cheyenne, Wyo.

Fall River's City Marshal Hilliard defended the handling of the Lizzie Borden case, saying the press lacked full details from the inquest and that the case rests on circumstantial evidence. A Borden family member denied rumors that $15,000,000 of family money would be used to obstruct the investigation.

The Cheyenne Daily Leader · 16 August 1892 · page 1

Marshal Hilliard said this morning re garding the criticisms by the press of the conduct of the Borden case, that news papers did not have the facts disclosed at the inquest and that the case depended entirely on circumstantial evidence. Liz zie Borden has not been imprisoned in haste or without a full understanding of the circumstances. An important mem ber of the Borden family said this morn ing that the honor of the Bordens was not to he affected by police suspicion, perhaps resting justlj’ on Lizzie Borden. No true Borden ever placed a stumbling block in the way of the law, and no mem ber of my family will in anv waj’ hamper the police in their investigation The statement that $15,000,000 of Borden money will bo used in balking the authori ties is untrue and illadvised.

See the clipping

Waterbury Evening Democrat · Waterbury, Conn.

Rev. J. Walter Jubb, pastor of Lizzie Borden's church, calls Judge Blaisdell's decision to preside at the inquest while also sitting as judge 'indecent' and 'outrageous,' vowing to push for a different judge at the preliminary hearing. Women's groups in Fall River also pass resolutions expressing sympathy and continued faith in Borden.

Waterbury Evening Democrat · 17 August 1892 · page 1

JUDGE BLAISDELL CRITICIZED. Lizzie Borden's Pastor Scores Him For Hie Action In the Case. Fall River, Mass. , Aug. 17. Bev. J. Walter Jubb, pastor of the Central Con

See the clipping

Smyrna Times · Smyrna, Del.

Lizzie Borden pleaded not guilty at Fall River, Massachusetts, to an indictment charging her with the murder of her father and step-mother. The brief item appears amid a roundup of miscellaneous national news.

Smyrna Times · 17 August 1892 · page 2

Miss Lizzie Borden pleaded not guilty at rail River, Mass., to au indictment charging her with the murder of her father and step-mother. The enforcement of the auti-lottery law has reduced the revenue of tho New OriosiiH postolfioe $103,000 and a reduction of salaries has been ordered. Reoent rains have insured an abund ant corn crop in Texas and Northern £ he Kood cr °P in Mexico will leave Texas without a market. At Boise, Judge Betty sentenced 8 of the miners' Union rioters, He de olared that labor organizations were to be judged by their acts, not their laws.

See moreSee less

Henry Ooltlieb, a well-known New York lawyer, was held in $4000 bail for court on charge of forgery. The police have over fifty cases of forgery and swindling against him, all of which have been committed within six months.

See the clipping

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

The Borden murder inquest was postponed after the District Attorney failed to appear, while police detailed a timeline of the murder discovery and sought a mysterious man seen near the Borden house. A local pastor publicly denounced Judge Blaisdell for both presiding over the inquest and sitting as judge, calling it indecent and outrageous.

New-York Tribune · 17 August 1892 · page 9

THE CASE STILL A MYSTERY JUDGE BLALS DELL'S ACTION DENOUNCED. Fall River, Mass., Aug. 16.—The Inquest nto the Borden murders was not resumed this afternoen, con: trary to expectations. The District-Attorney did not put in an appearance, and Marshal Hilliard went to Boston this morning. The police have decided that thirteen minutes elaps-d from the time Bridget sullivan asked Mr. Borlen how | he was until she was called downstairs by Miss Lizzie to give an alarm about the murder of her father. I'he sofa upon which Mr. Borden was murdered was vrought to the Central Police Station this morning, and will be kept there until after the trial.

See moreSee less

The police are looking for a man, of whom the fol lowing description is given: Height, 5 feed 2 inches: complexion, very white: wore light-gray hissiness suit, brown derby bat, Jawn-tennis shoes, short red musuiclie. He was seen twice in the neighborhood of the Borden house, Augnst 1 and August 4 The Rev. J. Walter Jubb, pastor of the Central Congregational Church, of which Miss Lizzie Borden is a member, characterizes Judee Llajsdell’s action in sitting on the bench as well as presiding at the Inquest as indecent, outrageous and not 10 be tolerated In any civilized community. He proposes to use every means

See the clipping

The Wichita Daily Eagle · Wichita, Kan.

The Woman's Christian Temperance Union and the Young Woman's Union of Fall River passed resolutions expressing sympathy for Lizzie Borden and belief in her innocence. Borden, under arrest for the murder of her father and stepmother, served as treasurer of the Young Woman's Union.

The Wichita Daily Eagle · 17 August 1892 · page 2

MISS BORDEN'S FRIENDS. FALL River, Mass., Aug. 16, The Woman's Christian Temperance union aud the Young Woman's union took ac tion yesterday encouraging to Miss Lizzie Borden, under arrest on tho charge of murdering her father and stepmother. Both unions adopted rnsolutious express ive of sympathy with Miss Borden in her affliction, declaring unbounded belief in her innoconse. Miss Borden is treasurer of the Young Woman's union aud h is been for a long lime prominent in their work.

See the clipping

Der Deutsche Correspondent · Baltimore, Md.

Pastor Walter Judd of Lizzie Borden's church condemns Judge Blaisdell for presiding over both the coroner's inquest and the court hearing, calling it improper and disgraceful. Judd vows to use all legal means to have a different judge preside over the hearing.

Der Deutsche Correspondent · 17 August 1892 · page 5

Ter Toppelmord in Hall-River. Fall-River, Mass.. 16. August. Pastor Walter ludd, von der Een tral-Congregalionalistcnkirchc, zu deren Mitgliedern Frl. Lizzie Borden gehört, charaklerisirt daS Vorgehen deS RlchterS

See the clipping

The Portland Daily Press · Portland, Me.

A brief news item reports that the inquest in the Borden murder case was postponed. It also notes a local pastor's criticism of Judge Blaisdell's conduct during the inquest.

The Portland Daily Press · 17 August 1892 · page 1

BRIEFLY TOLD. The inquest in the Borden murder case was postponed yesterday. Charles H. Pickett of Portsmouth, 29 years old* clerk at the general store of the Kittery navy yard, (lied of heart dis ease yesterday. Mills & Everett of Hew York, whole sale dealers in foreign fruits, assigned yesterday. Liabilities $75,000 to $85,000, itBOUlS piuu«*uxty dUUUt XGOO. Body of Luger Conehong, who was drowned Sunday at Brunswick, was found last night within a few feet of where he fell into the river. Six persons were killed and 15 others terribly injured by the collision of a con struction train with empty cars near Coschecton, Ohio, yesterday.

See moreSee less

An open switch caused the accident. Richard Taylor, a stage driver of North Hampton, has been arrested for the lar ceny of a pocketbook and diamond pin from J. Delano of St. Louis, a guest at

See the clipping

Grand Rapids Herald · Grand Rapids, Mich.

The Woman's Christian Temperance Union and Young Women's Union of Fall River held a special meeting expressing sympathy for and unshaken faith in Lizzie A. Borden. Borden, treasurer of the Young Women's Union, was noted as prominent in union work.

Grand Rapids Herald · 17 August 1892 · page 4

Faith in Lizzie Borden. Fm.i. BOOBS, Mass., Aug. 16. The Woman's C hristian Temperance union and the Young Women's union held a special meeting lt night st which

See the clipping

The Butler Weekly Times · Butler, Mo.

The report announces Lizzie Borden's arrest for the murders of her father and stepmother, following a third day of closed-door inquest proceedings in Fall River. It details the suspected motive, citing long-standing tension between Lizzie and her stepmother over money and her father's refusal to let her entertain lavishly.

The Butler Weekly Times · 17 August 1892 · page 2

The reason for tirst suspecting Lizzie of the crime is that she and her step mother have not been on good terms for several years, in fact, it is said that sin; refused to eat at the same table with Mrs. Borden or speak to her.

See the clipping

Weekly Union · Manchester, N.H.

After a day of inquest testimony that left her exhausted, Lizzie Borden was arrested on charges of murdering her father and stepmother. Her attorney Andrew Jennings was informed in advance and broke the news to her before officers formally read the warrant, which she took with calm composure.

Weekly Union · 17 August 1892 · page 1

ANOTHER MOVE.

FAauLL RIVER, Mass., Aug. 11.—Miss Lizzie Dorden is under arrest charged with murdering her father and step-mother last Thursduy morning at their home on Sec ond stieet. Miss Borden was brought to .the second district court room about 8 o’clock this af ternocn. presumably to give further evi dence nt the inquest. Bridget Sullivan, the servant girl, had been summoned shortly before. Miss Borden was accom pavied by her sister and Mrs. Brigham, who has remained with her loyally during tre hard scenes of the funeral and inquest. When Miss Lizzie returned from the third icquiry and cross-examination she was @ physical and mental wreck.

See moreSee less

She was conducted to the matron’s room, lean ing heavily on Mrs. Brighawm’s arm. The inquest was adjourned about 4 o’clock, when Distriet Attorney Knowlton and other cfiicials went down stairs to the marshal’s private office, where they re mained closeted for two hours. Shortiy after 6 o’clock City Marshal Hil liard and District Attorney Knowlton drove to the home of Andrew Jennings, who has heen attornev for the Borden fam ily tor some years. They returned about 7 o’clock. and went up stairs Into the mat ron’s room, where Miss Borden was lying on a sofu, City Marshall Hilliard had previously notified Mr. Jennings that belproposed to arrest his client, and Mr. Jennings broke the rews to her before the officers ap peared. The reading of the warrant was waived. DMiss Borden took her arrest with surpgising calmness, the two women with her being much more visibly affected than she. Her sister was greatly cast down and Mrs. Brizham shed tears. Shortly after ward Miss Emma Borden and Murs.

See the clipping

Weekly Union · Manchester, N.H.

Following exhausting inquest testimony, Lizzie Borden was formally arrested at the matron's room after her attorney Andrew Jennings was notified in advance by City Marshal Hilliard. The report also describes the post-mortem examination revealing an additional wound on Mrs. Borden's body and notes ongoing investigation into a locked safe at the Borden home.

Weekly Union · 17 August 1892 · page 1

ANOTHER MOVE.

The words of this article are printed with the report it shares its clipping with. Read them there or in the clipping.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

Weekly Union · Manchester, N.H.

Lizzie Borden was transported to the Bristol county jail in Taunton and placed in cell No. 3, cared for by the sheriff and his wife who had known her family. The report also notes a new wound found on Mrs. Borden's body during autopsy, details of the arrest warrant process, and continued public support for Lizzie among her friends.

Weekly Union · 17 August 1892 · page 1

LOCKED IN CELL 3.

CLING TO ORIGINAL VIEWS, Consensus of Opinion Among Miss Lizzie Borden’s Defenders. FALL RIVER, Aug. 12.—The friends of the prisoner calmly review the situation this morning, and the causes -wich had led up to ILizzie Borden’s arrest. They are

See the clipping

The Evening Herald · Shenandoah, Pa.

Rev. J. Walter Jubb criticizes Judge Blaisdell for presiding at the inquest from the bench, calling it indecent and outrageous, and vows to seek a different judge for the preliminary hearing. A local women's union also passed a resolution of support and faith in Lizzie Borden.

The Evening Herald · 17 August 1892 · page 4

JUDGE BLAISDELL CRITICIZED.

poso3 to use every means to havo another Ju,,8 " tlle bench nt tlle preliminary The Woman's Christian Temperance Un ion nnd the Young Women's Union, nt a special moetlng, passed a resolution of aympathy for an unshaken faith in Miss Lizzie A. Borden, who is treasurer of the Young Women's Union and has been prominent in union work.

See the clipping

Pittsburg Dispatch · Pittsburg, Pa.

This item compiles editorial reactions from papers across the country—Chicago, Kansas City, New York, Boston, Buffalo, Philadelphia—on Lizzie Borden's arrest for her parents' murder. The opinions sharply conflict, with some assuming her guilt and others insisting the case against her is weak and circumstantial.

Pittsburg Dispatch · 17 August 1892 · page 4

THE FALL RIVER TRAGEDY.

on the ground tbat she is a poor orphan. Kansas cxy Tim-s. Miss Lizzie Boeder, being .now behind prison bar", may thank her stars on having lonnd a sanctuary from the sleuth hounds of the pi ess. New York Telegram. y It Is Just as true now as it ever was tbat murder will out. Both the innocent and the guilty can tely on that fact. Tbe Fall River tragedy is likely to prove no exception to the rule. Boston Herald. The arrest of Hiss Lizzie Borden doesnot appear to have been based npon good grounds.

See moreSee less

The State undertakes a big Job when it attempts to prove tbat no one else could have committed the murder. Buffalo Enquirer. It may be pretty certain that the Fall Blver police have bitten off more than they

See the clipping

Yorkville Enquirer · Yorkville, S.C.

A short news digest reports that Lizzie Borden of Fall River, Mass., was arrested the previous Thursday for the murder of her father and stepmother. It speculates that she committed the killings to gain control of her father's fortune.

Yorkville Enquirer · 17 August 1892 · page 2

to stand fifteen Republicans to six Democrats. In West Virginia, too, the Re from the cholera infected districts of Russia, show that 2,177 people died from the disease on Sunday of last week. The governor of Tennessee has commuted the sentence of King, the murder of Boston, from death to life imprisonment. The people of Memphis were so indignant at the action of the governor, that they burned him in effigy. The Georgia Democrats have renominated their present State officers as punrlidfites for re-election. The Third party people have also put out a ticket, but the Republicans have decided not to do so. There seems to be no doubt whatever of Democratic success. Lizzie Borden, a

See the clipping

Richmond Dispatch · Richmond, Va.

This report reprints a Washington Evening Star analysis questioning motive in the Borden murders and explaining why suspicion fell on Lizzie Borden. It also redescribes the discovery of the bodies, including Andrew Borden's hacked body on the parlor sofa and Abby Borden's body found face-down in the guest room.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

Richmond Dispatch · 17 August 1892 · page 4

THE BORDEN MURDER: SOME OF THE PECULIARITIES OF THE FALL RIVER TRAGEDY

DISCOVERY OF THE BODIES, The body of Borden was found on a vel.

See the clipping

Richmond Dispatch · Richmond, Va.

The report describes finding Mrs. Borden's body with multiple wounds to the head, noting the lack of blood as a clue and the peaceful positioning of both victims suggesting surprise attacks. It also recounts Lizzie Borden's story to police about a note summoning her stepmother away and her father's return and nap before the murders.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

Richmond Dispatch · 17 August 1892 · page 4

DISCOVERY OF THE BODIES

committed unexpectedly so far as the vic tims were concerned, Borden's body was reclining on the lounge, the legs were resting easily on the floor, the left arm iay on the Lip, the right was folded across the breast, the eyes were closed, and the features were unmarked by any expression of surprise or apprehension. The attitude was one of repose. The features of Mrs, Borden were not drawn, and there was absolutely no evidence of a struggle. There were, so far as yet known, but two persons other than Borden and his wife on the premises when the murderg were com witted. These were Bridget Sullivan, a domestic, and Lazzie Bordeu, the younger of the two daughters. I'he older dauglter was visiting in another town.

See the clipping

Richmond Dispatch · Richmond, Va.

This syndicated piece reflects on the baffling nature of the Borden murders, noting Andrew Borden's wealth and lack of known enemies as it discusses possible motives like jealousy, revenge, or insanity. It recounts the discovery of the bodies, describing Andrew Borden's wounds on the parlor sofa and locating Mrs. Borden's body upstairs.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

Richmond Dispatch · 17 August 1892 · page 4

THE BORDEN MURDER SOME OF THE PECULIARITIES OF THE FALL RIVER TRAGEDY

The words of this article are printed with the report it shares its clipping with. Read them there or in the clipping.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

Richmond Dispatch · Richmond, Va.

This report describes finding Andrew Borden's hacked body on the parlor sofa and Abby Borden's body upstairs, noting the lack of blood and absence of any sign of struggle. It also notes that only Bridget Sullivan and Lizzie Borden were in the house, with Lizzie raising the first alarm.

Richmond Dispatch · 17 August 1892 · page 4

DISCOVERY OF THE BODIES

closed the fact that death bad been caused, | as 10 the case of the husband, by repeated blows of some heavy sharp instrument on the face, neck, and head. In the case of both there was found a deep cut into the brain. A circumstance, which was not at once observed, but which was afterward no ticed and put down as a clue, was the re markable absence of blood from the pu merous wounds on both bodies. It was as if the lite-current had been retarded and partly congealed from other causes before the murderous blows were struck.

See moreSee less

A shght survey served to make it equally plain tbat the murders were both committed unexpectedly so far as the vic tims were concerned, Borden's body was reclining on the lounge, the legs were resting easily on the floor, the left arm iay on the Lip, the right was folded across the breast, the eyes were closed, and the features were unmarked by any expression of surprise or apprehension. The attitude was one of repose. The features of Mrs, Borden were not drawn, and there was absolutely no evidence of a struggle. There were, so far as yet known, but two persons other than Borden and his wife on the premises when the murderg were com witted. These were Bridget Sullivan, a domestic, and Lazzie Bordeu, the younger of the two daughters. I'he older dauglter was visiting in another town.

See the clipping

The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · Wheeling, W. Va.

A brief editorial comment remarks that the Borden murder case has reached a point where authorities feel they must convict Lizzie Borden or else be perpetually criticized. It is embedded among unrelated political and miscellaneous commentary of the day.

The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · 17 August 1892 · page 4

furnished local papers by the New York World as to Protection and .Reciprocity. Thi Borden murdor case seems to have been brought down to this, that theauthoritles must convict Lizzie Borden or ever after be unhappy.

See the clipping

Iron County Register · Ironton, Mo. · and 2 other papers

The report states that Lizzie Borden was arrested in Fall River, Massachusetts, on the evening of the 11th for the murder of her father and mother. It claims the victims were found butchered with an axe or hatchet after having previously been poisoned.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

Iron County Register · 18 August 1892 · page 2

Island & Pacific Railway Co., and ex president of the corporation, died at his residence in Chicago, on the night of the 10th, of heart disease. He was exactly 70 years of age. having been born August 11, 1822, at Bedford, N. Y. Edward Parker Deacon has been offered a pardon from prison if he will leave France and not prosecute his wife for divorce, and has declined the offer. Miss Lizzie Borden was arrested at

See the clipping

Also printed in 2 papers
  • The Bolivar Bulletin · Bolivar, Tenn. · 19 August 1892
  • The Osceola Times · Osceola, Ark. · 20 August 1892

Connecticut Western News · Salisbury, Conn.

The report claims the murder weapon—a blood- and hair-stained hatchet—has been found in the Borden cellar, alongside bloody towels and a water bucket. It also describes Lizzie Borden's composed appearance in court as her lawyer moves to dismiss the complaint due to judicial bias.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

Connecticut Western News · 18 August 1892 · page 1

NO. 1). LIZZIE BORDEN ARRESTED. Is Charged with the Murder of Her Bh Father and Mother. Fall River, Maas., Aug. IS. The ax with which Mrs. Borden was killed has been found. That is the sensation of the day in the mysterious double murder case. The formal commitment of Miss Lizzie as the assaasin of her father and stepmother ranks second in interest to the discovery of the murderous weapon. It did not leak out till now that one of the four hatchets found in the cellar of the Bor den homestead soon after the murder was the instrument with which the butchery was committed.

See moreSee less

Under the microscope it shows many spots of human blood. That it waa carefully washed there is no doubt, for a bucket of water waa found near it, and also three new towels, partially covered with blood. The water had been splashed over the cellar floor. The weapoa also showed some long baira, which matched those in Mrs. Borden head. Wheu court was opened Lizzie Borden came in on the arm of Rev. A. E. Buck, the white haired missionary of Central church. She wore a tailor made gown of dark blue and a black hat trimmed with black polka dot crape. She had no veil. She waa more self possessed than at any previous time, and her steellike and almost painful sever ity of countenance betrayed no emotion. She was careless and indifferent to her sur roundings and whispered leisurely to her counsel, A. J. Jennings. The latter filed a motion to dismiss the complaint upon the grounds that the judge, being the same per son who presided at the iuqnest, was not competent to paas an unbiased opinion at the preliminary trial; further, that the in quest was still in session. District Attorney Kuowlton offered a de murrer, which ww f u st.-vi r."d, nud t'.i ".i he asked that the prisoner be called upon to make lu r plea to the complaint. Her law yer offered a plea of not guilty, but the judge would uot accept it, and oid-rd the clerk to proceed with the nnual ctu-toin of the court. The clerk asked LUzielostand up and answer to the churgo of n.ur.UT. She did so iu a firm tone of voice aud with stress upou the "not." Then Lizzie Borden was ordered to be committed without bond to aws.it the trial. She ai-v.-e, and with ever fuiihful Minister Buck k km d out r.i di'r police i;um1. A cloaca carriage com ej cd Ler nnd her sLter Emma to the depot, where a ti.au was boarded for Taunton.

See the clipping

Freeland Tribune · Freeland, Pa. · and 1 other paper

At her preliminary hearing, Lizzie Borden's lawyer unsuccessfully challenged the judge's impartiality since he had also presided at the inquest. She entered a plea of not guilty and was ordered committed without bond to await trial, then transported by train to Taunton.

Freeland Tribune · 18 August 1892 · page 4

LIZZIE BORDEN ARRESTED.

quest was still in session. I District Attorney Knowltou offered a de murrer, which was sustained, and then he asked that the prisoner bo called upon to j make her plea to the complaint. Her law { yer offered a plea of not guilty, but the I judge would not accept it, and ordered tho I clerk to proceed with the usual custom of j tho court. The clerk asked Lizzie to stand | up and answer to tho charge of murdor. j Sho did so in a firm toueof voice and with Btress upon tho "not."

See moreSee less

Then Lizzie Borden was ordered to be j committod without bond to await the trial. I Sho arose, and with ever faithful Minister I Buck passed out under police guard. A | closed carriage conveyod her and her sister Emma to the depot, where a traiu was

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • Connecticut Western News · Salisbury, Conn. · 18 August 1892

Connecticut Western News · Salisbury, Conn.

A Taunton clergyman has concluded Lizzie Borden, accused of murdering her parents, is innocent, and preached this view in a sermon. He is now actively campaigning to sway public opinion in her favor, which the paper condemns as intolerable.

Connecticut Western News · 18 August 1892 · page 2

Trial by Pulpit. A clergyman in Taunton, M&bb., has satisfied himself that Lizzie Borden, ac- - oused of the murder of her parents, is innocent. Last Sunday he maintained this view in a sermon and now he is en gaged in working up public opinion in Jfiss Borden's favor. It seems to us that suoh conduct on the part of a clergyman is intolerable.

See the clipping

Waterbury Evening Democrat · Waterbury, Conn.

A man named Charles H. Pinkham walked into Fall River police headquarters and claimed he murdered Mr. and Mrs. Borden, saying he could not bear to see Lizzie Borden suffer. Police suspected he was merely a crank and locked him up.

Waterbury Evening Democrat · 18 August 1892 · page 4

Savs He Murdered the Bordens. Fall River, Mass, Aug 18. This morning a man giving the name of Charles H, Pinkham entered the police headquarters and said he was the mur derer of Mr and Mrs Borden. He stated

See the clipping

Delaware Gazette and State Journal · Wilmington, Del.

The Fall River inquest resumed with testimony from Lizzie Borden, John V. Morse, Dr. Bowen, and others, but authorities released no details for publication. Despite theories being plentiful, police reportedly lack substantial evidence against any family member, and Lizzie's friends remain convinced of her innocence.

Delaware Gazette and State Journal · 18 August 1892 · page 6

THE FALL RIVER MURDER.

Seaver handed the following bulletin to the reporters : "The inquest was continued at 10 o'clock to-day. The witnesses examined were Mis; fizzle Borden, John V. Morse, Miss K a li. Burden, Dr. 8. W. Bowen, Adelaide B. Churchill and Hiram C. Harrington. Adjourned until . Thursday. Nothing developed 10 u. for publication." This was all that was given out after examinations lasting more than lour and -liolf It Whatever the police may think of the strength of their elites, it is certain that the opinions of Miss Borden's many friends ,'o entirely in favor of her inno ccnce.

See the clipping

Delaware Gazette and State Journal · Wilmington, Del.

The report covers continued inquest examinations of witnesses including Dr. Bowen, Officer Allen, and others, with police officials stating evidence against the Borden family is insufficient to proceed. Marshal Hillyard discusses ongoing clue investigations, including a suspicious milk sample and pursuit of an outside suspect, while maintaining no family member is implicated.

Delaware Gazette and State Journal · 18 August 1892 · page 6

Fall'River, Mass., Aug. 11.—The Borden inquest was resumed this morn ing. Charles Sawyer, who guarded the door of the house while Officer Allen ran to the station, He testified that he rt when he s that he was with Officer Doherty and s the first wit in the house i Mrs. Bussell running, und

See the clipping

Delaware Gazette and State Journal · Wilmington, Del.

The report describes police investigating and dismissing several suspects, including a 'wild-looking' man and a theory of poisoned milk, finding no evidence pointing outside the Borden household. It then recounts Lizzie Borden's arrest, including the dramatic scene of her waiving the reading of the warrant before Marshal Hilliard.

CorrectionThis set right an article from the day before.

Delaware Gazette and State Journal · 18 August 1892 · page 6

THE FALL RIVER MURDER. No Clue to the Murclerors of »VI r. and Mrs. Borden. Tlir Latent Duvclopmetit of the Tragic Double Murdur in I-all Hiver— Jetions, to Ih* Hem lug Ovnrrult-d. Fai.i, Hiver, Aug. 11.—To-day it not be said that the police have any substantial duo to the murderers of Mr. and Mrs. Andrew ,J. Borden, who we found butchered in their home, in this city, last Thursday. Theories plen tiful, hut reliable evidence is waiting. At 5 o'clock last evening State Detective Seaver handed the following bulletin to the reporters : "The inquest was continued at 10 o'clock to-day.

See moreSee less

The witnesses examined were Mis; fizzle Borden, John V. Morse, Miss K a li. Burden, Dr. 8. W. Bowen, Adelaide B. Churchill and Hiram C. Harrington. Adjourned until . Thursday. Nothing developed 10 u. for publication." This was all that was given out after examinations lasting more than lour and -liolf It Whatever the police may think of the strength of their elites, it is certain that the opinions of Miss Borden's many friends ,'o entirely in favor of her inno ccnce. Dr. Bowen told a straightforward story covering the time si called to the Borden house few days before the murdt r. 1!-' incidentally gave some evidence which startled the authorities. The nature of this will not be given for publication, but it was learned that probably to-day another examination of the dead bodies will be made at Oak Grove remoterv. Take altogether, iu connection with authoritative statement volunteered to-night, the police have presented very insufficient and meagre evidence against any member of the family, and the evi dence that they have presented is such that it would be dangerous to proceed upon it. Fall'River, Mass., Aug. 11.—The Borden inquest was resumed this morn ing. Charles Sawyer, who guarded the door of the house while Officer Allen ran to the station, s the first wit in He testified that he rt the house when he s i Mrs. Bussell running, und that he was with Officer Doherty and an Associated Press reporter when Dr. D. Howen discovered that Mrs. Borden did net die of heart disease. Officer George Allen testified to hav ing seen Mr. Borden lying the sofa, stabbed as ho supposed. Ills story added no new light to the crime. Mrs. Perry Gifford was being ex amined at 12 o'clock. Last night Officer Harrington went Bos to identify a suspect answering description of a "wild-looking nu last Thursday »ruing by th doctor as he was driving o the Borde house. Thos •t the man. spet The police have also run d< pect, who boarded the New Bedford train at Mt. Pleasant .1 rode into the citv. He proved ; alibi easily. Marshal Hillvard this morning sub mitted to another interview. In answer to questions as to whether tin police had given up all hopes of locating a murderer outside of the Borden family, he said the question was nonsensical, hut he would answer it by saying that three clues were being down, and that none of them would in any way plicate a member of the household. He said he had not been stinted iu mono men by the city government bee se of political complications. I hunt ing clues personally, beca» se the district attorney required his pr euco at the inquest, but the detective -«irked most of the night and :ported t<> him, l he was willing to say that a close alicul examination of Mieir results would be a feature of the amt that ight t urn out that suspic would bed!reeled from the Borden family. It has been proved that the suspected poisonous milk drank by the Burden family was all right, when it was taken from the Borden farm and brought to this city. Members of th© family in charge of the farm drank it and they were effected in no way. .1. UtVKi:. Mass.. Aur. 12.--Lizzie !' Burden was arrested last night, accused of the murder of her father and With her arrest the beginning of tl of the great murder mystery is The police are. confident they have the perpetrator of the •rl ibl© cr

See the clipping

Barton County Democrat · Great Bend, Kan.

A short news item reports that Lizzie Borden has been arrested at Fall River, Massachusetts, for the murder of her father and stepmother. It notes the crime has shocked eastern society due to the prominence of those involved.

Barton County Democrat · 18 August 1892 · page 2

West, Fla. There was a fire at the state deaf and dumb asylum, Council Bluffs, la Loss, 10,000. Miss Lizzie Borden has been arrest el at Fall River, Mass., for the murder of her father and stepmother, a crime which has startled eastern society, all parties being prominent. Judge Wallace, in the United States court at Utica, N. Y., allowed the har row tooth trust the' right to sue, not withstanding the plea that it was an illegal combination. The Brotherhood of Locomotive En gineers will engage in no boycott against Carnegie materials. The Pittsburgh Post publishes a story of anarchists again plotting against the life of II. C. Frick.

See the clipping

Barton County Democrat · Great Bend, Kan.

Lizzie Borden was arraigned before Judge Blaisdell in Fall River on charges of killing her father and stepmother, and was committed without bail after a crowded hearing. Police reportedly possess a peculiar claw-hatchet with blood on blade and handle believed to match the wounds, though authorities would not confirm this.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

Barton County Democrat · 18 August 1892 · page 2

THE DAUGHTER ARRESTED. Banker Borden's Daughter Arrestedt Charged "With the M order or Her lather -od Stepmother. . Fall Hivek, Mass., Aug. IS. Lizzie -Borden was arraigned in the Second district court before Judge J. CL Blais deU, charged with the killing "of her' father and stepmother. The courV room was crowded to suffocation, al though Miss Borden's, friends at court - were very few in number. - After argument Miss Borden was com mitted without"baTL ' " The police are in possession of a pe culiar hatchet, and the rumor that this particular hatchet was used is greatly strengthened by the strong wording of City Marshal Hill- -iard's complaint.

See moreSee less

No hatchet like the -one in custody can be found in the local hardware stores. Its greatest peculiarity is a ciaw on tne siae oi tne head nearest the handle. The handle is about two and a half feet long and . the top of the head is about one and a half by four inches. It is said that the--head of the hatchet fits into the mur derous wounds in Mrs. Borden's head. The blade of the implement is repre sented as being very thin and very sharp, measuring about five and a half " inches in the widest part. It is what is known among farmers as an old fashioned thrash wood hatchet except for the strange claw. When the police authorities were asked if such a hatchet was in their custody they would neither admit nor deny it. The matter, with all' other 1 evidence, is now in control of District Attorney Knowlton. The . connec tion of the hatchet with a bloody deed of some kind is almost beyond doubt, as spots of blood have been found the blade and handle. Certain cloths covered with blood found in the cellar where the hatchet was found are said . to have an important bearing on this, part of the case. Last night Marshal Ililliard said that there was a great deal yet to be proven, before the crime could be finally fast ened upon Miss Borden. Much hacl been learned, but for all that he could, see the trial would be long and tedious Medical Examiner Dolan says that a great deal will depend upon the accu racy of the medical examination of the body and the analysis of the parts sect to Boston. Although the authorities refuse to make public their discoveries they are believed to have secured damaging evi dence against the woman under arrest She has told two or three different stories, one of which is to the effect that at a few minutes past 11 o'clock cn the morning of the murders she went to the barn and climbed into the loft to fret a piece of lead from a coil of lead pipe-, for a sinker. A detective, who climbed into the loft, found the floor covered with dust which retained impression of his feet. Tihere were no other footprints on the floor. Moreover the coil of lead pipe was found between the house and the barn and a mechanic w;o e-mined it declared that it had not becil cut for two months. Medical Examiner Dolan says that Mrs. Borden was killed an hour before her husband, a fact whish shows that the murderer must have remained in the house for some time. It happens also that at the time Mr. Borden was killed the house was surrounded by per sons on all sides. Patrick .McGowan was in the rear picking pears. Mrs. Chase was on the south side and" saw McGowan, who in turn saw her. A young French boy was in the street, and Mrs. Buffinton was on the north side of the house, where is the entrance alleged to have been used by the murderer, John Dinnie, a laborer, was at work in the yard adjoining th Borden property and was within thirty feet of McGowan. None of these per sons saw anybody either enter or leave the house. . When Lizzie Borden found the body of her father she called Bridget Sulli van, the domestic, instead of her step mother. She explained afterward that the reason she did not call the latter was because she had been summoned by a note to the bedside of asiek friend earlier in the morning, and she sup posed her still absent No such note has been found, nor has the boy whom Lizzie Borden said delivered 'it made himself known. Moreover, none of the murdered woman's friends was sick. When Bridget Sullivan was examined she broke down so completely that the investigation had to be adjourned until she could compose herself. She said tc the. officer who accompanied her to the police headquarters: The murderer ought to clear me" When she was. asked later what she meant she brok down and was unable to go on. A motive for the crime was furnished by an official of one of the Fall River banks, who says that he knows that Mr. Borden was preparing tp make a will and apportion his estate. He had gone so far, says this official, as to ike a number of shares of stock in the Bar fee Safe Deposit Co. a-nd in the Union National bank and prepare to divide it between his wife and daughters on the ratio of twenty shares for his wife and cne for each of his daughters. - " Hart at a rjiieer Tlonr. NonTiiriELTJ, Minn., Aug. 13. Burt Rivier and Charles Lfemont, young men living at Dundee, three miles from here, are both in love with Miss Lcn;.rr, cf their town. They made an azrcem jnt to settle the matter , by a fight ia the presence of the young woman. Miss Lonkey wss watchir.g the encounter - kj-x a. uuj; v i. oil nie iiutm; ioj i fright and ran away, throwing her cut It is thought she is fatally hurtfewi&s Honor appeased. -Beexe, Aug. 13. All the facts in con nection with the arrest at Bay Ridge, Maryland, of Dr. George, attache of the Swiss legation at "Washington, who was charged with appropriating the -purser of a Mrs. Horde of Baltimore, have been laid before the government. The re port of Gov. Brown of Maryland, regretting the incident as a blunder on the part of the deputy sheriff who made the arrest and stating that he had been dismissed from his position, has alsc been telegraphed here. The report is very generally approved, and the chief executive authority of Switzerland re gards the incident as closed. Anarchy on the Cooja. BarssELS, Aug. 13. The Independ ent Beige says that twenty agents of the Katanga company have been killed or captured by Arabs on the Upper Congo river.' The steamer Eeernart, river, was seized and the - facto ries closed. The Arabs -northwest of Nyangwe have gone '.own the Lualaba river and captured the station at Ribariba, killing the white employed there. The stations cn the upper Lomassi have also been, destroyed. The Arabs at Stanley Falls and Isangi, who have hitherto been loyal, are showing hostility.

See the clipping

Barton County Democrat · Great Bend, Kan.

Lizzie Borden has been arrested in Fall River, Massachusetts, charged with murdering her father and stepmother the previous Thursday week. The report describes her appearance at a third inquest session behind closed doors, her reported ill will toward her stepmother over money matters, and background on her character and social standing.

Barton County Democrat · 18 August 1892 · page 6

I with Mrs. Borden or speak to her. j Money matters are said to have caused I the trouble. j Lizzie and her father had several j heated discussions on these matters,

See the clipping

The Republican Journal · Belfast, Me.

A short news item reports that Lizzie Borden of Fall River, Massachusetts, has been arrested on charges of murdering her father and stepmother. The item appears amid a roundup of unrelated national and international news briefs.

The Republican Journal · 18 August 1892 · page 1

Boston Thursday afternoon. She was christened the Marblehead by Mrs. C. F. Allen, of Salem, who broke the customary bottle of wine over the ship’s prow as she plunged into the water.Miss Lizzie Borden, of Fall River, Mass., has been

See the clipping

The Somerset Reporter · Skowhegan, Me.

Lizzie Borden was quietly removed from Fall River police headquarters to Taunton jail, amid a chaotic crowd of curious onlookers at the train station. She said an emotional goodbye to her sister Emma and supporters before being taken inside the jail by City Marshal Hilliard.

The Somerset Reporter · 18 August 1892 · page 8

LIZZIE A. BORDEN'S PRESENT HOME IS IN JAIL

band as the hour approached Miss Emma L. Borden, with Mr Jennings and Dr. Kowen, bade Miss Lizzie A. Borden an af fectionate got id bye. The parting between the sisters w as a -ad one, hut bot h ap peared bin.yed up by a strong faith uud great trust. \ I I nuuioii there was a tumultuous and simply dis graceful crowd of morbidly curious peo ple awaiting the ariivai ot the train. They raced after the officers as soon as they alighted, arid jostled their prisoner and her escort.

See moreSee less

Miss Borden was hur ried as fast as the marshal could hurry her out through the ladie-’ room and into a hack. The rnob fairly swarmed round the carriage and hemmed it in, many nar rowly escaping lieing run dov.n when the coach rattled off toward the jail. Tin* reporters' coaches were ready simul taneously, and in the same order as before the three backs rattled off f >r the jail. The carriage conveying Lizzie Borden en i cred t he grounds and drew up on t he west ern side. She quickly alighted, and, with Bev. Mr Buck, preceded the marshal and District Officer Denver into the building. In Jail.

See the clipping

The Somerset Reporter · Skowhegan, Me.

Amid a jostling crowd, Lizzie Borden was escorted to the jail and processed before being placed in a cell. She was then arraigned before Judge Blaisdell on homicide charges, pleading 'not guilty' in a firm voice after initial objections from her counsel were overruled.

The Somerset Reporter · 18 August 1892 · page 8

In Jail. Lizzie Borden was taken inside the iron rail separating the woman's wirm from tin* central vestibule. She was followed by Bv Mr. Buck who t bus had an oppor tunity for a last, chat with her, while City Marshal Hilliard signed the initimus on which she was committed to jail. The papers being found correct, Miss Borden was turned over to the matron, Mrs. Wright, the wife of the sheriff. The prisoner was conducted ilrst to the bath, and afterward was removed to the fourth cell on the southeast side of the womau's wing. In Court.

See the clipping

The Somerset Reporter · Skowhegan, Me.

Lizzie Borden stood and firmly pleaded 'Not guilty' to homicide charges at her arraignment, after initially speaking too softly to be heard. The court granted a continuance until August 22 due to an ongoing inquest, held witnesses Morse and Bridget Sullivan on bail, and committed Borden without bail.

The Somerset Reporter · 18 August 1892 · page 8

|.VHj each. Miss Borden was asked to stand lip and was committed wit hoiit bail._ MYSTERIOUS DISAPPEARANCE. I>r. A Newton'* Absence I.ends to n’ (suspicion of Milrlib.

See the clipping

The Portland Daily Press · Portland, Me.

The report notes that the inquest testimony against Lizzie Borden remains secret, known only to law officers, making outside opinions on her guilt premature. It also describes public controversy over Judge Blaisdell, who presided at the inquest and issued the arrest warrant, now sitting at the preliminary hearing despite claims he cannot be impartial.

The Portland Daily Press · 18 August 1892 · page 4

Miss Borden. They may be wrong, but nobody can say that they are before they know the evidence on which they acted. All Fall River is fiercely discussing the propriety of Judge Blaisdell’s sitting at the preliminary hearing in the case of Lizzie Borden. Judge Blaisdell presided at the Inquest, and issued the warrant arrest, and Rift-claimed by these who are opposed to his sitting at the hearing next Monday to determine whether Miss Borden shall be committed for trial, that he lias formed ah opinion, and therefore cannot hear the evidence : impartially.

See moreSee less

The Judge, however, is de termined to sit. There seems to be ’ something in the point, and under the circumstances it is a little strange that the Judge, even if he is confident that he can hold the scales of justice evenly, l does not voluntarily withdraw in defer ; ence to the strong public opinion which ■ apparently exists. The Argus has over and over again declared that the tariff was always a tax and invariably increased the price to the consumer by just its amount. A day or two ago, discussing the wool tariff, the Argus alleged that it s effect had been to cut down the price of wool, so that the American wool raiser got less for his product. This was its exact language: “Those who framed the McKinley tariff told the farmer that it would raise the price of his wool, and at the same time would decrease the imports of foreign wool. The reverse in both cases has been the result.” Now how does the Argus reconcile the two statements? If is heir. the tariff is a tax and invariably raises the price to the consumer how does it happen that the American farmer has been getting less for his wool since the McKinley duty was .put on, as the Argus alleges has been the case? We should like to have our esteemed contemporary explain this phenomenon. The claim that the opponents of pro hibition in the city of Portland will sub mit to that form of restraint with any better grace provided it is demonstrated under a local option law that a majority of the people of the city are in favor of it is an utter delusion. If a poll tomorrow should show a hundred or five hundred majority in favor of prohibition in this city the opponents would kick just as hard against its enforcement as they do now. They would claim, and with just as good reason as they do now, that it was an unwarrantable interference with the personal rights of the individual They would claim also, just as they do now, that it was not calculated to pro mote temperance, and they would bring just as much influence to bear upon the officers to slight the enforcement of the Ac. law as they do now. The idea that pro hibition secured under a local option law would be better enforced or more palatable is humbug.; and if the men who advocate local option should be come convinced that it would result in prohibition in the cities they would op pose it as strongly as they do the present condition. They have seized upon local option simply because they have an idea that it would result in free rum or license in the cities. The spokesmen of the Buffalo strikers aver that the arson and violence attend ant upon the strike of the switchmen is $1.35. the work of outsiders, and that the strik worth 75 c. ers are not responsible for them. This is the plea which is always put in in the case of strikes accompanied with vio lence. There is probably a certain amount of truth in it. That is to say, the Unions do not directly recommend violence, and when it has taken place they usually frown upon ii by resolu cost. tions. But this is not enough to acquit them of all responsibility for it. If they would rid themselves completely less of cost. of that, they must not only resolve against violence, but when it is in augurated they must step in and assist in putting it down. It taxes one’s cre dulity too much to believe that, if, as the strikers say, the acts of violence at worth 37 1-Sc. Buffalo were committed by outsiders, the strikers were powerless to prevent SI.50 and $3. it it if they had so desired. Giving the benefit of all the defence they make to the strikers, thev fall verv much short of acquitting themselves of all responsibil mer price lc5. ity for the incendiarism and other crimes which have been committed at Buffalo. mer price 35c. But we must confess to a great deal of incredulity in regard to the truthfulness reduced prices. of their defence. The only persons that had any motive for burning cars and throwing trains off the track were the low prices. strikers themselves. They were the only people that could possibly profit by such proceedings. It is hardly conceivable that the cars were set on fire from mere wantonness or that trains were derailed in the same spirit. The violent acts were committed with some definite ob ject in view, and there is no great doubt that that object was to compel the company to accede to the demands of the switchmen. It may be possible that eofte outsiders so strongly sympathized with the cause of the switchmen that they were ready to commit penal offences to aid them, but it is not probable.

See the clipping

The Redwood Gazette · Redwood Falls, Minn.

A brief news item reports that Lizzie Borden was placed under arrest in Fall River, Massachusetts, charged with murdering her father and stepmother. It appears amid a roundup of unrelated regional news items.

The Redwood Gazette · 18 August 1892 · page 1

were fatally burned. JOHN EDWARDS' daughter and grand child and Harvey Edwards, a relative, were killed by lightning during a storm at Beaver Dam, N. J. AT Fall River, Mass., ]\Iiss Lizzie Borden was placed under arrest, charged with the murder of her father and stepmother.

See the clipping

The Redwood Gazette · Redwood Falls, Minn.

Lizzie Borden was arraigned before Judge Blaisdell in Fall River district court, charged with murdering her father and stepmother, with few supporters present besides her sister Emma, Mr. Morse, Bridget Sullivan, and Rev. Buck. Her counsel's objection to the proceeding was overruled, and she entered a plea of not guilty through her attorney before being asked to plead herself.

The Redwood Gazette · 18 August 1892 · page 1

WITHOUT BAIL. Borden Held to Answer the Charge of Murdering Her Father and Step mother. FALL RIVER, Mass., Aug. 13.—Lizzie C. Borden was arraigned in the second district court before Judge J. C. Blais dell Friday morning charged with the killing of her father and stepmother. The courtroom was crowded to suffoca tion. Miss Borden's friends at court were very few in number. Mr. Morse, Bridget Suliivan, Miss Emma Borden and City Missionary Buck were present. Miss Borden, the prisoner, was represented

See the clipping

Warren Sheaf · Warren, Minn. · and 2 other papers

A brief news roundup item reports that Miss Lizzie Borden of Fall River, Massachusetts, was placed under arrest. She was charged with the murder of her father and stepmother.

Warren Sheaf · 18 August 1892 · page 2

JOHN EDWARDS' daughter and grand child and Harvey Edwards, a relative, were killed by lightning during a storm at Beaver Dam, N. J. A Fall River, Mass., Miss Lizzie Borden was placed under arrest, charged with the murder of her father and stepmother.

See the clipping

Also printed in 2 papers
  • The Worthington Advance · Worthington, Minn. · 18 August 1892
  • The Cape Girardeau Democrat · Cape Girardeau, Mo. · 20 August 1892

The Worthington Advance · Worthington, Minn.

Lizzie Borden was arraigned before Judge Blaisdell on charges of murdering her father and stepmother, entering a plea of not guilty through counsel Andrew Jennings. The proceeding included a contested motion over the judge's dual role in the inquest, which was overruled before the plea was formally taken.

The Worthington Advance · 18 August 1892 · page 2

WITHOUT 'BAIL. iA 14ul« Bwtfra Held to Answer the Charge of Murdering Her Father and Step­ mother. FALL RIVER, Mass., Lizgite C. Borden was arraigned iivthe iiirnnd district court before Mdgal?. C. Blaiir dell Friday morning charged Tpiih killing of her father and stepmother.' The courtroom was crowded to Mflbe# tion. Miss Borden's friends at court were very few in number. Mr. Morse, Bridget Sullivan, Miss Emma Borden and City Missionary Buck were present Miss Borden, the prisoner was represented

See the clipping

Gloucester County Democrat · Woodbury, N.J.

The bodies of Mr. and Mrs. Andrew J. Borden, victims of the recent tragedy, were buried by order of Medical Examiner Dolan, with cemetery employees placing them in the family lot. No family members were present at the burial, and Dolan stated that all bloody clothing had been sent to Boston with no timeline for its return.

Gloucester County Democrat · 18 August 1892 · page 2

The Bordens Buried.

Philadelphia. Aug. 18.—Late yester day afternoon Judge Biddle appointed Edward H. Clapp and Benjamin F. Dennisson appraisors of the assigned es tate of the Mutual Banking, Surety, Trust aud Safe Deposit Company. The application was made on the petit ion of A. E. Stockwell. assignee of the banking company. The petition simply set out the fact that the assignment was made, and asked that the appraisers be appointed. An inventory has not yet been filed. The Bordens Burled. Fall River, Mass., Aug. 18.—The bodies of Mr. and Mrs. Andrew J. Bor den.

See moreSee less

the victims of the recent tragedy, were buried yesterday by order of Medical Examiner Dolan. They were placed in the family lot by employes of the cemetery, and no members of the family were present. Medical Exami ner Dolan states that all of the bloody clothing has been sent to Boston, but he cannot tell when a return will be ! made. ISx-Prosident Bogran Killed. New Orleans, Aug. 18.—Notwith standing the fact that a dispatch from San Francisco Monday reported (nat ex President Bogvan, of Honduras, was in that city on his way to Europe, the steamship Breakwater, wfyich reached here yesterday from Livingston, brought a report that he was killed in tgie ncimty of Puerto Cortez, when the rebels occupied the place. Bograu’s hiding place was disclosed by an old peon. Murderous Highwaymen Lynched. Portland, Ore., Aug. 18.—A dispatch from Tacoma, Wash., says three high waymen held up and beheaded a man near Ellensburg, Wash., yesterday. Vijfilantspursued the bignwaymen, and captufing them hanged them to a tree. Plait's Parly Loyalty. Pittsburg. Aug. 18.—Hon. Whitelaw Iieid, Republican candidate for vice ppresident, accompanied by his wife, passed through Pittsburg last night on their way to Chicago on the New York limited. Congressman Burrows also accompanied Mr. Reid. In answer to a question Mr. Reid said: “It is well known that Mr. Platt was not so well suited with the nominations as he might have been, but he is a Republican and is with his pifty. His wannest friend, Mr. Fassett, who represented him at Albany, is at work for the ticket, and so are all the adherents of both these gen tlemen.” _ __ A Buckwheat Trust. Trenton, N, J,, Aug. 18.—A buck wheat trust has been formed, with a capital stock of $5,000,000. The incor porators, according to the papers filed in the office of the secretary of state, are David Dows and Joseph A. Knox of New York, William Nash ofj Brooklyn and Charles W. McCutchen of Plain field. Three millions of the stock is preferred and is to be entitled to 8 per cent, dividends before the declaration of anything on the common stock. Bonds to the amouut of $3,500,000 will also be issued Drove Off the Robbers. Denver, Colo., Aug. 18.—As the Den ver and Cheyeue passenger train on the Union Pacific stopped at the coal chutes at La Salle, two masked men entered one of the cars and ordered the passen gers to hold up their hands. Hands in profusion went up instantly, and the fellows were on the point of collecting toll when one of. the passengers opened fire from liis gun on the robbers. The latter returned the fire, but one of them getting hit they both jumped from the car and fled. Miss Borden Held l'or Murder. Fall River, Mass., Aug. 18.—Miss Lizzie Borden was given u hearing be fore Judge Blaisdell yesterday morning. The prosecution forced her to plead not guilty personally, which she did in a distinct voice, placing emphasis on the word -‘not.” Bhe was then remanded to prison without bail. Miss Borden arrived at the jail in Taunton in the afternoon,

See the clipping

Gloucester County Democrat · Woodbury, N.J.

Lizzie Borden appeared before Judge Blaisdell and was compelled to personally enter a plea of not guilty, which she did with emphasis. She was remanded without bail and transported to the jail in Taunton that afternoon.

Gloucester County Democrat · 18 August 1892 · page 2

Miss Borden Held l'or Murder. Fall River, Mass., Aug. 18.—Miss Lizzie Borden was given u hearing be fore Judge Blaisdell yesterday morning. The prosecution forced her to plead not

See the clipping

The Jersey City News · Jersey City, N.J.

Charles H. Peckham of Westport walked into Fall River police headquarters and confessed to murdering Andrew and Abby Borden, claiming Lizzie was innocent. Police were skeptical, suspecting his story was the product of a disordered mind rather than truth.

The Jersey City News · 18 August 1892 · page 1

DID HE KILL THE BORDENS?

Hurrah for the Fishing Hanks. The large ocean tug Theresa Verdon will leave Morris st., dock at ~.a0 A. M., sharp, every Sun dav rain or shine, continuing until October 2nd. Eaifer5c. Pilot and Manager Wm. Conners. self into custody for The murder of Mr. and Mrs. Andrew J. Borden. Deputy Marshal ’’’leet was sitting be hind his desk when the stranger entered. He asked for Marshal Hilliard, and upon being told that lie was out, inquired if Mr. Fleet was next in charge. The latter replied in the affirmative and inquired wunt the visitor wanted.

See moreSee less

* * XT noma TO Uoob-Vl r> 1V1 J> nni J 1. . «.T came from Westport, and I cannot bear to see Lizzie Borden suffer auy more. I am the one who murdered her father and

See the clipping

The Sun · New York, N.Y.

An unnamed official claims the case against Lizzie Borden rests on what Bridget Sullivan saw, not heard—specifically a hatchet she allegedly spotted half-hidden in the sitting room. The report also notes Medical Examiner Dolan found no spurting blood from the wounds and that the Borden parents were quietly buried that morning.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

The Sun · 18 August 1892 · page 7

STORY OF BRIDGET SULLIVAN

saw tho hatchet when she came Inside to get BODe water to complotn her work The police can show thoy say that Lizzie Borden was < < lthor the principal In tho mur der or nn accessory before the fact Medical Examiner Iolan Is satisfied and so nro the police that there was absolutely no spurting of blood from the wounds While perhaps one or two drops may bo found on time dress Lizzie wore tho police do not con sider them necessary to establish tholr case This morning the bodies nf Mr and Mrs Borden were burled Medical Examiner Dolan paid that thoro wus no further need of defer ring time burial Only the cemetery workmen warts present TIILIfl ITIHES cur < ouv The New Jersey 1OBlnl Sending Their AlrBftasCfi by Telephone from Orunfte BRICK CHURCH X J Aug 17Time cutting of the wires of time New Jersey Postal Tele graph Company by the Western Union Com pany on Monday again loaves the Postal with no connection by teleptrnph from Orange with thom outside world The Postals wires were originally strung from the poles of the Amen can Ilnpld Company Tho Western Union nc quircd by purchase tho franchises of tho American llnnld Litigation followed the pur chase The result was that thocourts decided that the Western Inion was not entitled to thoAmcrican Itaplds polos and wires but only th franchises The Western Union was ordered to restore tho American Itaplds lines to their original condition In iloiiic thin thin Vt estorn Union cut the wires of tim iostal Then tho 1obtals superintendent got permission to oroct poles in West nmmrigu A hue was then strung to Plcnsantdnle several miles over time Orange Mountains and in nn outofthowny place Here time company again hunc their wires on the Western Union Companys poles and for weeks operated successfully with the outside world Thu Wostorn Inion Company heard of the trick und onco more limo 1ostal Is out in the cold Mesai i are now sent to the com pnnys office In Nnwnrk by telephone and thence to their destination

See the clipping

The Evening World · New York, N.Y.

Charles H. Peckham of Westport walked into Fall River police headquarters and confessed to murdering Andrew and Abby Borden, claiming Lizzie was innocent. Deputy Marshal Fleet took him into custody but suspected his mind was disordered.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

The Evening World · 18 August 1892 · page 1

TirrriAi. to thk fvfuixo wobld.1 -piU Vai L Kivek, Mass., Aug. 18. At 10.05 this .'S morning Charles II. rcckham, ot Westport, 4fl walked Into Pollco Headquarters and gave uH himself Into custody for tbe murder of llr. fl and Mrs. Andrew J. Borden. jB Deputy Marshal Fleet was sitting behind 'n-H his aesk when tbo stranger entered. ijM lie asked for Mnrshal llllllard, and upon beTB Ing told that he was out, inquired If Mr. Fleet 'JM was tbe next In charge. v'9 The latter replied in tbe affirmative and "i'H Inquired what the visitor wanted.

See moreSee less

$19 llo sold: "My namo is Peckham. I rams ;vB from Westport, and I cannot bear to sea 'S9 Ltule Borden suffer any more. aJB "I am the one who murdered her father, H and mother, and she Is Innocent of the ', crime." 'tu The speech was delivered In a clear voice V?fl and vv ithaut any apparent excitement on the 'yB part of the v Isltor. ',fl Mr. Fleet could not believe his own ears, S lie Inquired of tbe man the time that he com- '.-SH mltted the crlme.and Peckham aSsWered thai j9 he did It two w eeks ago tc-day, about noon. 4,'S He said he had a good reason for doing It, 'JH which he did not state. '; lie bald he jumped I he fence tn tbe rear ol 'U tho house, entered tho side door Into tha 'WU kitchen, proceeded to kill Mrs. Borden ana "fl atterwards her husband. it Peckham has been locked up. ijfl He ankwers questions cherently, but , JB Deputy l'Hol Inclines to the opinion that lit S , story Is ihe product of a disordered ffltnO, '.ViH I affected by sympathy for LLule Borden. "sH I Peckham Is sixty-two years of age, about 5 'KU , feet H Inches tall and has a thin, gray bear'i ?iB Ho hj)b ho leases a farm from Edmund 'rifl ' Davis, at Westport, no ir New Bedford. .C Mayor Klrby, ot New Bedlord, was tele. H ' phoned to, and confirmed tbe farm part ol JjB tho story. Tho Mayor said he knew PeokM49 hum well, and that lie was tn some ways an eccentric person, but was never thought to t-H be Insane. .jfl Mr. Fleet also communicated by telephone "Jfl with Andrew .1. Jennings, attorney for Miss Burden, who replied that be would come luv .H mediately to tho station to see tho prisoner. "fl i Bai

See the clipping

The Evening World · New York, N.Y.

A 62-year-old farmer named Peckham from Westport walked into the police station and confessed to murdering Andrew and Abby Borden, claiming Lizzie Borden is innocent. Police, including Deputy Fleet, suspect the confession is the product of a disordered mind influenced by sympathy for Lizzie, though Peckham answered questions coherently and gave detailed, plausible-sounding testimony about his method of entry.

The Evening World · 18 August 1892 · page 1

'm TirrriAi. to thk fvfuixo wobld.1 -piU Vai L Kivek, Mass., Aug. 18. At 10.05 this .'S morning Charles II. rcckham, ot Westport, 4fl walked Into Pollco Headquarters and gave uH himself Into custody for tbe murder of llr. fl and Mrs. Andrew J. Borden. jB Deputy Marshal Fleet was sitting behind 'n-H his aesk when tbo stranger entered. ijM lie asked for Mnrshal llllllard, and upon beTB Ing told that he was out, inquired If Mr. Fleet 'JM was tbe next In charge. v'9 The latter replied in tbe affirmative and "i'H Inquired what the visitor wanted.

See moreSee less

$19 llo sold: "My namo is Peckham. I rams ;vB from Westport, and I cannot bear to sea 'S9 Ltule Borden suffer any more. aJB "I am the one who murdered her father, H and mother, and she Is Innocent of the ', crime." 'tu The speech was delivered In a clear voice V?fl and vv ithaut any apparent excitement on the 'yB part of the v Isltor. ',fl Mr. Fleet could not believe his own ears, S lie Inquired of tbe man the time that he com- '.-SH mltted the crlme.and Peckham aSsWered thai j9 he did It two w eeks ago tc-day, about noon. 4,'S He said he had a good reason for doing It, 'JH which he did not state. '; lie bald he jumped I he fence tn tbe rear ol 'U tho house, entered tho side door Into tha 'WU kitchen, proceeded to kill Mrs. Borden ana "fl atterwards her husband. it Peckham has been locked up. ijfl He ankwers questions cherently, but , JB Deputy l'Hol Inclines to the opinion that lit S , story Is ihe product of a disordered ffltnO, '.ViH I affected by sympathy for LLule Borden. "sH I Peckham Is sixty-two years of age, about 5 'KU , feet H Inches tall and has a thin, gray bear'i ?iB Ho hj)b ho leases a farm from Edmund 'rifl ' Davis, at Westport, no ir New Bedford. .C Mayor Klrby, ot New Bedlord, was tele. H ' phoned to, and confirmed tbe farm part ol JjB tho story. Tho Mayor said he knew PeokM49 hum well, and that lie was tn some ways an eccentric person, but was never thought to t-H be Insane. .jfl Mr. Fleet also communicated by telephone "Jfl with Andrew .1. Jennings, attorney for Miss Burden, who replied that be would come luv .H mediately to tho station to see tho prisoner. "fl i Bai

See the clipping

The Evening World · New York, N.Y.

Charles Peckham walked into Fall River police headquarters and confessed to murdering Andrew and Abby Borden, insisting Lizzie Borden was innocent. He gave officers a detailed account of climbing a fence and entering the house to kill the couple, and was taken into custody.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

The Evening World · 18 August 1892 · page 1

CONFESSES MURDER

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

See the clipping

The Evening World · New York, N.Y.

A 62-year-old farmer named Peckham from Westport walked into the police station and confessed to murdering Mr. and Mrs. Borden, claiming Lizzie was innocent. Deputy Fleet was skeptical, suspecting the man's story stemmed from a disordered mind sympathetic to Lizzie Borden, though Mayor Kirby confirmed Peckham's identity as a known but eccentric local farmer.

The Evening World · 18 August 1892 · page 1

CONFESSES THE MURDER

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

The Evening World · New York, N.Y.

Charles Peckham of Westport walked into Fall River police headquarters and confessed to murdering Andrew and Abby Borden, claiming Lizzie Borden was innocent. Deputy Marshal Fleet, skeptical of the calm confession's details, suspected Peckham's mind was disordered by sympathy for Lizzie rather than genuine guilt.

The Evening World · 18 August 1892 · page 1

CONFESSES MURDER.

Charles Pecklnm Says Fo Kil'od tho Bordcns at Fall Eivor. Comes from Weslport lo Got Lizzie Borden Out of Jail. Deputy Marshal Klcet. Hcllpves tlio

See the clipping

Der Westbote · Columbus, Ohio

The report states that since the murder of the Borden couple, no case has caused more sensation in Fall River than the arrest of Lizzie Borden, though suspicion against her seemed to be weakening among the public in recent days. It notes the arrest was carried out by the city marshal, who went to the Borden house.

Der Westbote · 18 August 1892 · page 2

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

See the clipping

Der Westbote · Columbus, Ohio

Lizzie Borden was brought before the district court and pleaded not guilty; Morse and Bridget Sullivan were held in custody as witnesses. The preliminary hearing was postponed until the 22nd, Borden's safe was broken open with its cash and papers taken into legal custody, and the report states there is actually no evidence against the arrested Lizzie Borden.

Der Westbote · 18 August 1892 · page 2

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

Pittsburg Dispatch · Pittsburg, Pa.

An anonymous police official reveals that Bridget Sullivan's testimony about seeing a hatchet and hearing Lizzie in the cellar was the key evidence leading to Lizzie Borden's arrest. The account claims Bridget saw the hatchet half-hidden in the sitting room after hearing Lizzie searching in the cellar.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

Pittsburg Dispatch · 18 August 1892 · page 6

A TELLTALE HATCHET

Sullivan. The arrest followed immediate ly alter her examination at the inquest. 1 he only intimation that has been made liublic was the remark credited to Bridget: "I am not surprised that they arrested Lizzie Borden." To-dav it was learned why she was not F'.trprWed. Tiie leak came through one of

See the clipping

Pittsburg Dispatch · Pittsburg, Pa.

The report describes Bridget Sullivan's account of seeing the hatchet and Lizzie near the cellar, which police use to link Lizzie to the murder weapon. It also details the police theory that no blood spattered on Lizzie's dress because of how the murders were committed, with officials leaning toward a murder charge rather than an insanity defense.

Pittsburg Dispatch · 18 August 1892 · page 6

SPECIAL TELEGRAM TO THE DISPATCH

If, however, she was an accessory, it will throw out an idea that the woman was in sane, and the police at present are strongly jiicuncu 10 inai tneory ratner inan oenere that this Christian girl, with so strong a reputation for piety and missionary labors, committed the heartless, cruel murder that they have shown the killing of Andrew and Abbey Borden to have been. That she could have cold-bloodedly devised such a crime with another person is almost beyond their credulity, although all police officials

See the clipping

Pittsburg Dispatch · Pittsburg, Pa.

This report describes in detail the location and small number of bloodstains found in the rooms where Andrew and Abbey Borden were killed, explaining why police believe the killer's clothing may not have been stained. It notes only a handful of blood drops were found on walls, baseboards, and pillow shams, supporting the theory that the murderer could have avoided heavy staining.

Pittsburg Dispatch · 18 August 1892 · page 6

out. Ufeblond Snaked All Around. "Where Mr. Borden's head rested on the pillow the liieblood that oozed from the wounds so.iked into the curtains, and run nine down on the floor, stained the carpets

See the clipping

Freeland Tribune · Freeland, Pa.

The report claims a blood-stained axe matching Mrs. Borden's hair was found in the cellar, along with washing evidence, and describes Lizzie Borden's calm demeanor at her formal commitment hearing. Her lawyer moved to dismiss the complaint on grounds the judge was biased from presiding at the inquest.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

Freeland Tribune · 18 August 1892 · page 4

Father ami Mother. I FALL RIVER, Mass., Aug. 13.—The ax with which Mrs. Borden wus killed has boeu ; found. That is the sensation of the day in the mysterious doublo murder ease. The formal commitment of Miss Lizzie as the ! assassin of her father and stepmother ranks I second in interest to the discovery of the j murderous weapon. It did not leak out till now that one of the I four hatchets found in the cellar of the Bor den homestead soon after the murdor was : the instrument with which the butchery I was committed.

See moreSee less

Under the microscope it I shows many spots of human blood. Tlint | it was carefully washed there is no doubt, I for a bucket of water was found near it, l and also three new towels, partially covered j with blood. The water had been splashed I over the cellar floor. The weapon also showed some long hairs, which matched , those in Mrs. Borden's head, j When court was opened Lizzie Borden j came in on the arm of Rev. A. E. Buck, the white haired missionary of Central church. She wore a tailor made gown of dark blue and a black hat trimmed with black polka , dot crape. She had no veil. She was more ! self possessed than at any previous time, and her steellike and almost painful sever ity of countenance betrayed no emotion. She was careless and indifferent to her sur | roundings and whispered leisurely to her counsel, A. J. Jennings. The latter filed a motion to dismiss the complaint upon the grounds that the judge, being the same per son who presided at the inquest, was not competent to p.-iss an unbiased opinion at the preliminary trial; further, that the in quest was still in session. I District Attorney Knowltou offered a de murrer, which was sustained, and then he asked that the prisoner bo called upon to j make her plea to the complaint. Her law

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

Charles H. Pinkham of Westport walked into Fall River police headquarters and confessed to murdering Andrew and Abby Borden, claiming he acted so Lizzie Borden would not suffer further. Police were skeptical of his detailed but unconvincing account, comparing it to a similar false confession case in New York.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

The Providence News · 18 August 1892 · page 1

FOR LIZZIE BORDEN'S SAKE

FALL RIVER, Mass., Aug. 18.—At 10:05 this morning, Charles H. Pinkham of Westport, walked into police headquar ters and gave himself into custody for the murder of Mr. and Mrs. Andrew J. Bor den. He asked for Marshal Hilliard, and upon being told that he was out inquired if Mr, Fleet was the next in charge. The latter replied in the aflirmative and in quired what the visitor wanted. He said, *My pame is Pinkham., I came from Westport, and I cannot bear tosee lizzie Borden suffer any more. I am the one who murdered her father and mother, and she is not accountable for the crime.” This was delivered in a clear voice and without any apparent excitement on the part of the visitor.

See moreSee less

Mr. Fleet could not believe his own ears. He inquirea of the man the time when he committed the crime, and the man answered that he did it two weeks ago to-day about noon, He said he had a good reason for doing it, which he did not state; he said he jumped over the fence in the rear of the house, entered by the side door into the kitehen, proceeded to kill Mrs. Borden, and afterwards her husband, Then the acknowledged assassin jumped over the fence and made his way through an adjoining street. “What clothes did you wear?’ asked Mr. Fleet. “These I have on,’”” was the reply. *“The first blow killed them both and stopped the heart’s action, for the clothes were not spofted with blood. I only struck the other blows as a precaution,” said Pinkham. The police think that, while Pinkham may be the murderer, his brain has be come unhinged by the excitement, So they are by no means sure the mystery is solved. Then Mr, Fleet asked further questions and the answers were given in a clear voice and with a readiness that indicated thorough familiarity with the details of the crime, Mr. Fleet then locked up the man until the city marshal could farther investi gate. Pinkham was taken to the cell room and searched. Nothing was found

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

A man named Charles H. Peckham (also called Pinkham) confessed to the Borden murders but police increasingly viewed him as an eccentric crank rather than the true killer, especially after his New Bedford record showed no insanity. The report also recalls a similar case of a wrongly self-accused man in the Maybee murders on Long Island.

The Providence News · 18 August 1892 · page 1

Mr. Fleet then locked up the man until the city marshal could farther investi gate. Pinkham was taken to the cell room and searched. Nothing was found but an old pocketbook 9ont.lnlng re coipts. The first thing after Pinkham was locked up Mr., Fleet telegraphed Mayor Kirby of New Budford for Pinkham's record. Mayor Kirby at onee recom mended the man as an eccentric. Mayor Kirby closed by stating he did not think him insane. There was a slight ripple of excitement around the station on the arrival of this customer, but no crowd was atiracted.

See moreSee less

Peckham looked as if he bhad imbibed bleood for centuries. Description of Peckham or Pinkham, FALL RIVER, Mass., Aug 18.—Charles H. Peckham, who gave himself up to the police this forenoon as the self-confessed murderer of the Bordens, is looked upon this afternoon as a crank, A A Heis 62 years old, five feet five inches

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

Private detectives chase a reward-driven clue across several cities while State Detective Seaver denies reports he implicated Lizzie Borden alongside accomplices. New details emerge about Andrew Borden's plan to make a will favoring his wife and daughters, strengthening the prosecution's case, while attorney Jennings moves to force officials to produce evidence in court.

The Providence News · 18 August 1892 · page 1

INTEREST NOT LESSENED

her wmother's residence to-night. üblished in the Taunton Gazette and rioown Post in which he is made to say that he believes several had a hand in the murder and that Miss Lizzie Borden was one of the guilty parties. He admits that he talked a short time with a representa tive of the two p:g:n. but maintains that he did not make fmportant statements be is allged to have made. The great intevest now centers in the fact that Mr. Borden, at the time of his death, was preparing a will, C. C, Cook, the business agent of Mr. Borden, in formed the city marshall that the mur dered man h‘J within three weeks before

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

A New Bedford Journal editorial argued that evidence against Lizzie Borden should not be concealed from an accused criminal. This paper mockingly questions calling her an "accused criminal" rather than an "accused innocent person," needling the Journal's phrasing.

The Providence News · 18 August 1892 · page 4

An accused criminal should be l’gnn every lposuible opportunity. Effo t© conceal the nature of the evidence against Lizzie Borden are all wrong in principle.-—New Bedford Journal, True enough, but why do you call Liz zie Borden ‘*an accused criminal”? Per haps she’s an accused innocent person. And why, oh, why do you say *‘should be given'? Le travailleur qui vote pour les Demo crats vote pour s’oter le pain de la bouche. -1 Esperance. The truth in one sentence; let the

See the clipping

The Pickens Sentinel · Pickens, S.C.

The report describes the discovery of Andrew and Abby Borden's mutilated bodies at their Fall River home, killed with an axe, cleaver, or razor. It notes police questioning of daughter Lizzie Borden and brother-in-law John Morse, and mentions a $5,000 reward offered for information.

The Pickens Sentinel · 18 August 1892 · page 1

A SAVAGE MURDER. THE HORRORS OF PARIS DUPLICATED IN NEW ENGLAND.

)een mutilated about the head and face ith an axe, cleaver or razor. Bor len lay on a sofa in a room on the top loor of the house. ils head had been ut and gashes from four to six inches ong were found on his face and neek. dra Borden was in her own chamber n the upper floor and the (ondition of ter face and head was the same as that of her husband. She lay face downard in the bed,which was a veritable pool )f blood. After a imost thorough and persistent, search no trace has beeti ound of the murderer.

See moreSee less

Four police nen are on guard at the house and iave been patrolling the neighborhood inDce the atfiir was made public. This morning State I)etective Seaver Ld City Marshal ililliard held a long -onsultation, and later on visited and nterrugated Miss Lizzie, daughter of MlIr. and Mrs Borden, at the house. The result of their investigation will not be cnown until an arrest or some kind

See the clipping

The Pickens Sentinel · Pickens, S.C.

Detectives questioned Lizzie Borden again and continued watching John Morse, while a $5,000 reward was offered for the killer's arrest and conviction. A rumored suspect—a nephew who had argued with the Bordens over property—was investigated but ruled out after it was found the quarrel occurred ten months earlier; police also theorized poison may have been used before or during the murders.

The Pickens Sentinel · 18 August 1892 · page 1

by the police at the present time. The following advertisement ap peared in to-night's local papers: "Five thousand dollars reward. Above re ward will be paid to anyone who may ,ecure the arrest and conviction of the person or persons who occasionett the :leath of Andrew .1. Borden and his wife. Emma .1. liorden, Lizzie J. Bor len." Late this afternoon it was reported it the police station that, a young man, isaid to be a nephew of Borden, was be

See the clipping

The Pickens Sentinel · Pickens, S.C.

This report details the autopsy process and describes wounds suggesting a struggle inconsistent with poisoning, yet notes that police are pursuing a poison theory. It reveals that a drug store clerk, Eli Bence, identified Lizzie Borden as having come into his shop seeking to purchase poison shortly before the murders.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

The Pickens Sentinel · 18 August 1892 · page 1

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

See the clipping

Hand County Press · Miller, S.D.

Lizzie Borden is placed under arrest in Fall River, Massachusetts, charged with murdering her father and stepmother. The report describes the arrest scene at attorney Andrew Jennings' home, noting her calm reaction compared to the visible distress of two women present.

Hand County Press · 18 August 1892 · page 2

LIZZIE BORDEN IS IN JAIL. Arrested on llie charge of hilling Her Father and Stepmother. Fa 1.1. River, Mass., Aug. PA — Miss Lizzie Borden is under arrest charged

See the clipping

Hand County Press · Miller, S.D.

Lizzie Borden appeared before Judge Blaisdell in Fall River district court, where her attorney entered a not-guilty plea on her behalf to charges of murdering her father and stepmother. The court was packed, and Borden, dressed in a dark-blue gown, stood to confirm her plea after an objection to the judge's dual role was overruled.

Hand County Press · 18 August 1892 · page 2

WITHOUT BAIL. Lizzie Borden Held to Answer the Charge of Murdering Her Father and Stepmother.

C. borden was arraigned in the »*V‘*ni! district court before Judge J. c - »**“*• dell Friday morning charged with the killing of her father and stepmother. The courtroom w as crowded to suffoca tion. Miss Borden's friends at court were verv few in number. Mr. Morse. Bridget Sullivan, Miss Emma borden and City Missionary buck were present Misa Borden, the prisoner, was represented

See the clipping

The Daily Herald · Brownsville, Tex.

Fall River police are chasing down clues and testing statements from letters sent to the marshal while awaiting Professor Woods' analysis of blood evidence. Public opinion toward Lizzie Borden is reportedly softening, with attorney Jennings working to secure a full examination at the preliminary hearing set for August 25.

The Daily Herald · 18 August 1892 · page 1

The Borden Murders Fall River Mass Aug 14 The Borden murder is the great topic here yet At the Central Con gregational church of which the Borden family were members uuion services were held to day City Marshall Hilliard has heard nothing irom Professor Woods who is analyzing the stomachs of thf victims and comparing the spots of blood on the axe and carpet He says if ttiere is truth in the reports it would be discovered that the blood upon the axe and carpets is the same It is strange he has not Heard it officially The police to day have been engaged in chasing down clews and testing statements made in many letters sent to the marshal It is Lizzie Bordens side o tlm case that is now attracting the attention o the police It is not th < ughc the pielimiiiflry hearing set for the 25th will be uf long duration It has been the policy of Dibtrict Attorney Kuowlton in handling capital crimes to give as little evidence as possible until the trial takes place Attorney icuttings who beyond believe in the innocence ot Lizzie Borden will do everything iu Ids jiower to have a full exami nation at the earliest date IIi rturdj work at the time of arraign ment has done much m to change public opinion eoncernig the girl more particularly Ins position re lerring to a fair tiial by an im partial judge Although MiBs Borden is un er arrest charged with perhaps the most heinous crime committee in recent years there is little talk about the punishs meut that should be meted out to her She is finding supporters and friends in the most unexpected placces The talk is almost entire ly regarding her chances of proving her innocence This fact gives the police utho7itie6 reason to think much stronger evidence will have to be given before Attorney Jen nings will consent to an otder for holding his client until November It is an open secret in police circles that the government officer believes Miss Borden insane at the time of the murders if she com mitted them It is will know that Judge Blaisdell and Disttiet At torney Iviuiwlron were prejudiced in Miss Bordens favor ami they mut have the strongest pos ble reasons for ordering her arrest Some evidence relating to the private life of Miss Borden is now in he hands of the police and bears directly op this side of the case and btrengthens the opinion of the high authorities who have said that Miss Borden was not conscious of tbe deeds it she is implicated Rain on the Rio Grande A letter received by Atlee Mc

See the clipping

The Daily Herald · Brownsville, Tex.

The report describes shifting public opinion toward sympathy for Lizzie Borden after her arraignment, with her attorney Jennings pushing for a full examination. It also notes a police rumor that officials privately believe she may have been insane at the time of the murders, if she committed them.

The Daily Herald · 18 August 1892 · page 1

The words of this article are printed with the report it shares its clipping with. Read them there or in the clipping.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

The Austin Weekly Statesman · Austin, Tex.

Amid ongoing mystery in the Borden murders, a new theory surfaced suggesting that Mr. Borden and his wife were killed by sailors against whom they had testified in a mutiny case. Police were reported to be actively investigating this and other leads.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Austin Weekly Statesman · 18 August 1892 · page 2

TEE CASE STILL SUBBOUNDED BY THE DEEPEST MYSTERY. A new Theory Sprang, to the Effect that Borden and Wife were Murdered by Sailors Against Whom they Testi fied for Mutiny Police Active Lynn, Mass., Aug. 13. The Lynn Item today publishes a statement that Andrew Borden of Fall River gave the principal testimony which convicted the ringleaders of mutiny on the echooner Richard Borden while on a voyage from foreign porta to this country. That he and his wife were on the vessel; that his testimony in court was declared by the sailors to be false and exaggerated and that the men who suffered by it vowed ven geance against him.

See moreSee less

Most, if not all of them, have been released and it is submitted that several were in Fall River at the time of the murder.

See the clipping

The Austin Weekly Statesman · Austin, Tex.

A Fall River dispatch reports that public opinion has calmed since the frenzy of days earlier, with some now doubting Lizzie Borden's guilt and police surveillance of the Borden home relaxed. A separate item from the Lynn Item newspaper suggests Andrew Borden's damaging testimony in an old shipboard mutiny case may have made him enemies who sought revenge, with several of the convicted sailors reportedly in Fall River at the time of the murder.

The Austin Weekly Statesman · 18 August 1892 · page 2

AS VIEWED AT FALL RIVER. Fall River, Mass.. Auar. 13. A reaction in the Borden case has set in and today the popular feeling is noticeably quiet. There is very little save the event is being discussed on rue streets, and wnac lew cases seen were among business men. Three days ago it was the popular cry that aiiss lizzie was tne criminal and should be placed behind iron bars. I'oday although the district attorney ana tne judges nave passed opinions on the evidence, there are manv thoughtful and influential men who believe the trial will substantiate Miss Borden's plea of innocence. There is now but one policeman at the Borden homestead and he is doing patrol duty on the street to prevent

See the clipping

The Austin Weekly Statesman · Austin, Tex.

The report describes ongoing police re-investigation of Morse and Miss Sullivan, denial by the marshal that no search was made until after the funeral, and renewed inquiry into an old jewelry theft at the Borden home. It also recounts the story of the ship Jefferson Borden mutiny, suggesting surviving mutineers may have sworn revenge against Andrew J. Borden.

The Austin Weekly Statesman · 18 August 1892 · page 2

AS VIEWED AT FALL RIVER.

Borden home about a year ago. A lady's watch and several articles of jewelry were taken from tbe dressing uase iu one oi tne upper rooms and to this day the police have been unable to trace the thief. Some years ago the shin Jefferson Borden was bound from a foreign port

See the clipping

St. Johnsbury Caledonian · St. Johnsbury, Vt.

A roundup of weekly news items reports that Lizzie Borden was finally arrested on a charge of murdering her parents in Fall River, Massachusetts. The item appears as one line among many unrelated news briefs for the week.

St. Johnsbury Caledonian · 18 August 1892 · page 5

Lizzie Borden finally arrested on a charge of murdering her parents, at Fall

See the clipping

Eagle River Review · Eagle River, Wis.

The Lynn Item reports a new theory that Andrew Borden had testified against mutineers aboard a schooner, who vowed vengeance and may have murdered him. The report also notes that public opinion in Fall River has cooled from outright condemnation of Lizzie Borden toward more cautious, skeptical views.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

Eagle River Review · 18 August 1892 · page 6

A VICTIM OF MUTINEERS. New Theory in the Mysterious Borden Murder Case, Ly~xy, Mass.,, Aug. 13.—The Lynn Item will to-day print a statement that Andrew J. Borden, of Fall River, who was murdered two weeks ago, gave the principal testimony tbat convicted the ringleaders in the mutiny on the schooner Richard J. Borden, while on the voyage from a foreign port to this country; that he and his wife were on the vessel; that his tes. timony in the courts was declared by the sdilors to be false and exaggerat ed, and that the men who suffered by it vowed vengeance against him.

See moreSee less

Most, if not all, of them have been released, and it is submitted that several of them were in Fall River at the time of the murder. The reaction in the Borden case has set in, and to-day the popular feeling 18 noticeably quiet. There is very little violent discussion on the streets, and what cases were seen, were the qut ¢ owth of hard expressions against the imprisoned girl. Three days ago it was the popular cry that Miss Lizzie Borden was a criminal and should be placed behind prison

See the clipping

Eagle River Review · Eagle River, Wis.

Lizzie Borden, arrested the previous evening for the murder of her father and mother, was arraigned in Fall River and pleaded not guilty. The report notes no direct evidence against her, with the prosecution's theory being she killed her parents to inherit their fortune.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

Eagle River Review · 18 August 1892 · page 6

LIZZIE BORDEN IN COURT Pleads Not Guilty to the Charge of Murder

FarL River, Mass., Aug. 12.—Lig Borden, who was arrested last evelss on & charge of having murdered? father and mother on the 12th i hacking them to death "8 an axe, was arraigned {0 To the charge of mUEE she pleaded not guilty. There 151788 rect evidence against the youny W an, 8o far as known. The theoryd state is that she killed her parent order to speedily inherit the fortul several bundred thousand dollarF sessed by her father. s

See the clipping

River Falls Journal · River Falls, Wis.

Lizzie Borden was arraigned before Judge Blaisdell on charges of murdering her father and stepmother, with the courtroom packed but few supporters present. She pleaded not guilty after a procedural objection regarding the judge's dual role in the inquest was overruled.

River Falls Journal · 18 August 1892 · page 2

WITHOUT BAIL. I.lscle Horden Held to Answer the < barge of Murdering Her Father and Step mother. Fall River, Mass., Aug. 13.—Lizzie C. Borden was arraigned in the second district court before Judge J. C. Blais dell Friday morning charged with the i killing of her father and stepmother. The courtroom was crowded to suffoca tion. Miss Borden’s friends at court were very few in number. Mr. Morse, Bridget Sullivan, Miss Emma Borden and City Missionary Buck were present Miss Borden, the prisoner, was represented by Andrew J. Jennings. She was

See the clipping

The Iola Register · Iola, Kansas · and 1 other paper

Police describe a claw-hatchet found with bloodstains that may match Mrs. Borden's wounds, alongside bloody cloths from the cellar, as evidence against Lizzie Borden. Investigators also detail contradictions in her alibi about the barn loft and note the medical examiner's finding that Mrs. Borden died an hour before her husband, despite witnesses surrounding the house at the time.

CorrectionThis set right 6 earlier articles: Connecticut Western News, 18 August 1892, Barton County Democrat, 18 August 1892, The Sun, 18 August 1892, Pittsburg Dispatch, 18 August 1892, Freeland Tribune, 18 August 1892, The Pickens Sentinel, 18 August 1892.

The Iola Register · 19 August 1892 · page 8

custody they-.vonld neither admit nor it Tha' matter, with all other evidence, is now in control of District Attorncv Knowlton. The connec tion of the hatchet with a bloody deed of some kind is almost beyond doubt, as spots of blood have been found on the blade and handle. Certain cloths covered with blood found in the cellar where thcr.hate.hct was found are said to have an Important bearing on this part of the case. Last night Marshal Hilliard said that there was a great deal yet to be proven before' the crime could be finally fast ened upon Miss Borden.

See moreSee less

Much had been learned, but for all that he could see the trinl would bo long and tedious. Medical Examiner Dolan says that a great deal will depend upon the accu racy of the medical examination of the body and the analysis of the parts sent to Boston. Although the authorities refuse to make public their discoveries they are believed to have secured damaging evi dence against tho woman under arrest She has told tvro or three different stories, one of which is to the effect that at a few minutes past 11 o'clock on the morning of tho murders sho went to thebarn nnd climbed into the loft to get a piece of lead from a coil of lead pipe for a sinker. A detective, who climbed into the loft, found the floor covered with dust which retained impression of his feet There were no other foot prints' oh the floor. Moreover the coil ot lead pipe was found between the house and the barn and a mechanic who examined it declared that it had not been cut for two months. Medical Examiner Dolan S3ys that Mrs. Borden was killed an hour beforo her husband, a faet which shows that the murderer must hare remained in the house for soma time. It happens also that at the time Mr. Borden was killed the house was surroundod by per sons on all sides. Patrick McGownn was in the rear picking pears. Mrs. Chase wn6 on tho south side and saw McGowun, who in turn saw her. A young French boy was in the street, 'and Mrs. Buffiaton was on the north side of the hou3C, where is the entrance alleged to have been used by the murderer, John Dinnie, a laborer, was at work in the yard adjoining the Bordesi property and was within thirty feet of McGownn. Xono of these per sons saw anybody cither enter or leave the house. When Lizzie Borden found the body of her father she called Bridget Sulli van, the domestic, instead of her step mother. She explained af terward that the reason she did not call the latter was because she hud been summoned by a note to the bedhido of a sick friend earlierin the morning, and she sup posed her still absent Xo such note has been found, nor has the boy whom Lizzie Borden said delivered it made himself known. Moreover, none of the murdered woman's friends wsis sick. When Bridget Sullivan was examined she broke down so completely that the investigation had to bo adjourned until she could compose herself. Sho said to the officer who accompanied her to the police headquarters: "The murderer ought to clear mo." When sho was asked later what sho meant sho brok down and was unable to go on. A motive for the crime was furnished bv an official of one of tho Fall River j Iranks, who says that he knows that Mr. Borden was preparing to make a will and apportion his estate. He had gone so far, says this official, as to take a number of shares of stock in the Dur fee Safe Deposit Co. and in the Union - Xationul Lank and prepare to divide it UVk.trt'U HV V7I1G UUU UUJJLt;iUU .K ratio of twentv shares for his wifo and The men arc 1 one for eaeh of hi daughters. their future Hurt t n Oneer TImo. XoRmrTELD, Minn., Aug. 13. Burt Rivieit and Charlei Lemont, young men j living at Dundee, three miles from here are both in love with Miss LonKey, oi --"- " j .Swli Hxnar .pptMe(2. ciippii.K. j Enm;n Aug. i3. AU the facts in conben telegraphed here. The report is verv cenrallr nDuroTed, and the chief executive authority of Switzerland re gards the incident as closed. Anarchy on the Cono. Brussels, Aug. 13. The Independ ence Beige says that twenty agents of the Katanga company have been killed j or captured by Arabs on the Upper Congo river. The steamer Beernart, which wait taking goods up the river, "was saized and the facto ries closed. The Arabs northwestof Xyangwe have gone .down the Lualaba river and captured the station at Ribariba, killing the white employed there. The stations on the upper "Lomassi have al3o been destroved: The Arabs at Stanley i alls nd Isangij who have hitherto been 'loyalflajajshowing hostility.

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • Barton County Democrat · Great Bend, Kan. · 18 August 1892

The Hope Pioneer · Hope, N.D. · and 1 other paper

A brief news item reports that Lizzie Borden was arrested in Fall River, Massachusetts, charged with the murder of her father and stepmother. It appears among a roundup of short regional news items under the heading 'THE EAST.'

The Hope Pioneer · 19 August 1892 · page 2

JOHN EDWARDS' daughter and grand child and Ilarvey Edwards, a relative, were killed by lightning during a storm at Beaver Dam, N. J. AT Fall River, Mass., Miss Lizzie Borden was placed under arrest, chargpd with the murder of her father and stepmother. AT her home in Lawrence, N. Y-,

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • River Falls Journal · River Falls, Wis. · 18 August 1892

The Forrest City Times · Forrest City, Ark.

Lizzie Borden pleaded not guilty at Fall River to the murder of her father and mother. She was committed without bail and is now in jail.

CorrectionThis set right an article from the day before.

The Forrest City Times · 19 August 1892 · page 4

A Covington (Neb.) saloonmnn is, charged with burning down two towns j to rid lrimself of rivals. Sitting Bull’s daughter was married at Roundot, N.Y.. to an ex-soldier whose life she once saved. ■'Scare''crop reports had a marked bearish influence on Wall street specu lation, according to Bradstreet. Mnse Bradford of Marion. Ind., is 55 years old and a millionaire, and he offers 51000 for a young aud pretty wife. The Astor heirs have been paid 1507, 689.75 damages by the city of New York for property wrongfully appro priated in 1876.

See moreSee less

Gross mismanagement of the finan cial affairs of the order of the Iron IIall lias been admitted by Supreme Justice Somerbv. At Greensburg, Ind.. William Littell stabbed his brother Samuel to deat h in a dispute over a wash bill due Samuel's wife. Robert Brooks of Carmi assaulted Judge G. W. I’illow of Shawnetown. 111., in the diningroom of the Rose house at Elizabethtown, 111., Lizzie Borden was commited with out bail after pleading not guilty at Fall River of tne murder of her father and mother and is now in jail. Will Weatherly and Henry Dantzer of Whitehall, Ala., quarreled at a dance. Yesterday they met—Weath erly is dead aud Dantzler is wounded. For a general family cathartic we confidently recommend Hood’s Pill. They should be in every home medi cine chest. ------- At a picnic at Frisco Springs Friday

See the clipping

Morning Journal and Courier · New Haven, Conn.

Charles H. Peckham, a Westport farmer, walked ten miles to turn himself in claiming to have committed the Borden murders, having become unhinged after hearing about Lizzie Borden's arrest. He was later released as apparently sane, denied any knowledge of the crime, and was taken home by his wife and a constable.

CorrectionThis set right 3 earlier articles: The Evening World, 18 August 1892, The Evening World, 18 August 1892, The Providence News, 18 August 1892.

Morning Journal and Courier · 19 August 1892 · page 3

PECKHAM IS INSANE!

Committed tbe Boraea murders. FuxBirtK, Mass.. Aug. 8. Charles H. Peckham, the man who confessed to-day to having oommitted the Borden marders. lives two and a half miles south of Brow n ell's oorner in Westport, on a farm be purchased this spring. He was in thia olty last Friday and beard a great deal abont Lizzie Borden's arrest. He went home and slnoe then baa brooded so much over the affair that be became Insane. He left bis house between 6 and 7 o'clock this morning, despite the protestation, of his wife, and walked tan mile, to tne police station to give himself up.

See moreSee less

He ia a war veteran and haa been ancjeet to fits of In sanity for some years. He will be cared for by hi. menaa. xne police returned to-night from an nn.acce.ifoi search through Aaaonet woods after the mythical person who waa said to be in that vicinity. None of the officer, eoald locate the shadow. BXLKASVD FROM JAIU

See the clipping

The Willimantic Journal · Willimantic, Conn.

A brief opinion item suggests that Lizzie Borden's arrest for the murder of her father and stepmother was driven by the Fall River police feeling pressured to act rather than solid evidence. It appears amid a column of miscellaneous political and social one-liners.

The Willimantic Journal · 19 August 1892 · page 4

SLINGS AND ARROWS

It looks as if the arrest of Lizzie Borden for tbe murder of her father and step mother was the result of the Fall River police idea that they must do something. Up the Connecticut Valley where they raise tobaoco the crop is worth $300 per acre more than it was, because of the of Earl Rosebury, foreign secretary; Baron Hersohell, lord chancellor; Sir William Vernon Haroourt, chancellor of the ex ohnquer; Herbert H. Asquith, home sec retary; Henry H. Fowler, president of the local government board; H. Campbell, Bannerman, secretary of war; Earl Spen cer, first lord of the admiralty; John Mor ley, secretary of Ireland; Sir Charles Rus sell, attorney general; John Regby, solici tor general; Samuel Walker, lord chancel lor of Ireland, and J.

See moreSee less

B. Balfour, lord ad vocate. Lord Broughton will be vioeroy of Ireland.

See the clipping

The American Citizen · Topeka, Kan.

A short item buried in a miscellaneous news column reports that Lizzie Borden is charged with killing her father and stepmother in Fall River, Massachusetts. It claims she first poisoned them before hacking them to pieces.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

The American Citizen · 19 August 1892 · page 2

The Fayette Advertiser drops into the following bit of poetry: Keeping in the true, not th" false Have chance again to rob our valts. Keep In the true; trust not the Bads, Who cursed cur State and robbed our dads. If the people’s party in this county desiies to turn down a Negro who has been working on independent lines for years for a rank rabid Re publican they can do so but it will be darn poor politics and November will prove it. Crime is growing rampant Miss Lizzie Borden is charged with killing her gray haired father and step mother, she first poisons them and then literally hacks them to pieces.

See moreSee less

All this occurred in Fall River Mass. What is the world to see before the end of time?

See the clipping

The Iola Register · Iola, Kansas

The report states that Lizzie Borden has been arrested and charged with murdering her father and stepmother, following a third inquest session in Fall River behind closed doors. It details alleged motives, including long-standing family tension over money and Lizzie's refusal to eat with or speak to her stepmother.

The Iola Register · 19 August 1892 · page 2

LIZZIE BORDEN ARRESTED. Clinrgril IVlth tho .Murder of llor I"atlicr nntl Mrpmoliier. F.U.I. llivni!, Mass., Aug. 12. Miss Lizzie Uorden is under arrest charged with murdering her father and step mother last Thursday week.

See the clipping

The Iola Register · Iola, Kansas

A compressed national news digest reports that Miss Lizzie Borden has been arrested for the murder of her father and stepmother, a case that has startled eastern society. The item notes the prominence of all parties involved amid a long list of unrelated news briefs.

The Iola Register · 19 August 1892 · page 8

taper. Miss Lizzie Borden has been arrest .! ... T?nll T;t-, "Ticc frr t 1a Trmrdr! . . '""""' -J" ' . -f oi her latner anu stepmoincr, cnun. which has startled eastern society, all parties being prominent. Cruiser Xo. 11 was launched at Lor ing's ship yard, Boston, on the 11th. Judge Wallace, in the United States court at Utica, X. Y.. allowed the har row tooth trust the right to sue, not withstanding the plea that it was an illegal combination. TnE Pittsburgh Pest publishes a story of anarchists again plotting against the life of II. C. Frick.

See the clipping

The Iola Register · Iola, Kansas

Lizzie Borden was arraigned before Judge Blaisdell in Fall River and committed without bail on charges of murdering her father and stepmother. Police possess a peculiar claw-hatchet, matching the wounds, with blood found on it, though they would not confirm its custody to reporters.

CorrectionThis set right an article from the day before.

The Iola Register · 19 August 1892 · page 8

THE DAUGHTER ARRESTED. Banker Borden's Danjrhter Arrested" Charced With tho Murder of nerFatlier Hfanil Stepmother. Fall River, Mass., Aug. m lizzio Borden was arraigned in the Second district court before Judge J. G. Blais dell, charged with the killing-of her father and stepmother. The court room was crowded to suffocation, al though Miss Borden's friends at court were very few in number. After argument Misa Borden was com mitted without bait The police are in possession of a pe culiar hatchet and the rumor that this particular hatchet was used is greatly strengthened by the strong wording of City Marshal Hill iard'd complaint Xo hatchet like the one in custody can be found in the local hardware stores.

See moreSee less

Its greatest peculiarity is a claw on the side of the Tiead' nearest the handle.- The handle is about two and a half feet long and the top of the head is about one and a half by four inches. It is said that the head of the hatchet fits into the mur derous wounds in Mrs. Borden's head. The blade of the implement is repre sented as being very thin and very sharp, measuring about fivo and a half inches in the widest part It is what is known among farmers as an old fashioned thrash wood hatchet, except for the strange claw. When the police authorities were asked if such a hatchet was in their custody they-.vonld neither admit nor

See the clipping

People's Voice · Wellington, Kansas

Lizzie Borden has been arrested and charged with murdering her father and stepmother, with a preliminary hearing set for August 22. Public opinion is reportedly turning in her favor, aided by her attorney Jennings' efforts, with little talk of punishment and much speculation about her chances of proving innocence.

People's Voice · 19 August 1892 · page 6

It is Lizzie Borden's side of the case that is attracting the whole attention lizzie iioudkx. Attorney Jennings, who lwyond question believes in the innocence of Miss Borden, will do everything in his power to have a full examination at the earliest date. His sturdy work at the time of the arraignment has done much to change public opinion concerning the girl, more particularly that question referring to a fair trial by an impartial judge. Although Miss Borden is under arrest, charged with perhaps the most heinous crime committed in recent years, there is little talk about the pun ishment that should be meted out tc her.

See moreSee less

Friends are found in most unexpected places. The talk is almost entirely re garding her chances of proving her in nocence. This fact gives the police au thorities reason to think that much of the strongest evi dence will have to be given before At torney Jennings will consent to an order for holding his client until No vember. It is an open secret that the government officers mr bokdes. believe that Miss Borden was insane at . ----- u""iu aa iii.muc ui u.e time tne murders, if she committiH ttiAm mitted them. City Marshal Ililliard has heard noth ing from Prof. Wood, who is analyzing uie siomaens ot the victims and com paring the spots of blood on the ax and carpet Was It For Revenge? Lyxst, Mass., Aug. 14.- A number ol of the police. It is not thought now that the prelimin ary' hearing set down for the 2'2d inst will be of long duration. It has been the policy of District Attorney Knowlton in handling capital crimes to give as little evidence as possible until the trial takes place. 1 UQiy

See the clipping

People's Voice · Wellington, Kansas

The report describes a theory that two sailors, convicted in an unrelated ship murder and later pardoned, might actually be responsible for the Borden murders, based on the daughter's account of strangers near the house. It suggests that if these men can be placed near Fall River on the day of the crime, it could lead to Lizzie Borden's release.

People's Voice · 19 August 1892 · page 6

izations of the country and presented tc President Harrison and it is believed that the men were pardoned about eight months ago. If these men were released and the fact can be established that they or any of their comrades were in or about Fall River the day of the murder it may mean the release of Liz tie Borden,

See the clipping

Springfield Weekly Republican · Springfield, Mass.

The report describes Lizzie Borden's arrest for the murder of her father and stepmother following the conclusion of the inquest. It notes that John V. Morse was apparently cleared, while Bridget Sullivan remains a key witness under watch.

Springfield Weekly Republican · 19 August 1892 · page 7

CHARGED WITH AN AWFUL CRIME. POLICE ARREST LIZZIE BORDEN.

rn not l>i»clo**rd—Brid^ri Nullivuu an Important WitucM*. The authorities in charge of the Borden murder case at Fall River took definite ac tion last week Thursday and arrested Miss Lizzie Borden on a charge of having been concerned in the mur

See the clipping

Springfield Weekly Republican · Springfield, Mass.

The report speculates on what evidence led police to arrest Lizzie Borden, including medical testimony on time of death, blood on an axe and clothing, lack of footprints in the barn dust, and a story about her trying to buy poison. It notes much of the inquest evidence remains undisclosed and will only emerge at trial.

Springfield Weekly Republican · 19 August 1892 · page 7

POLICE ARREST LIZZIE BORDEN

The Evidence on which thiaMtepwaii Tak. rn not l>i»clo**rd—Brid^ri Nullivuu an Important WitucM*. The authorities in charge of the Borden murder case at Fall River took definite ac tion last week Thursday and arrested Miss Lizzie Borden on a charge of having been concerned in the mur der of her father ana her mother. It has been known that since the murder took place their strongest suspicions have been directed tow ard two members of the family, the younger daughter and the brother-in law, John V. Morse. The question was whether evidence enough could be found to warrant the arrest of either one.

See moreSee less

And to see w’hat the evidence was, the inquest was held which ended yesterday. At this inquest every person w r as examined who by any means could throw any light on rhe awful tragedy. What the exact evidence was, naturally enough, the police are un willing to say. That will be reserved till the time when the young woman w r ho has been arrested shall be called to trial. The action of the police, however, points to the conclusion that John V. Morse suc ceeded in proving to the satisfaction of the police that he was not in the house at the time of the crime and had no hand in it. Bridget Sullivan, who W’hile not sus pected of the crime, was suspected of knowing moie about it than she had told be. fore, will be carefully w’atched as a most im portant witness for the government. These things coupled with the arrest, make it quite certain that the inquest, developed important evidence which has not been made public. Until the trial takes place, the nature of this evidence must be largely a matter of sur mise. It is, though, quite safe to conclude that the evidence which induced the police to make the arrest consisted in part of these things.ln the first place the medical testimony is assumed to have proved that Mrs Borden died some time before her husband and that as according to the daughter's own state ment she was absent from the house not more than 30 minutes, she must have been in the house w’hen her mother fell. How hap pened, then, that she did not hear the noise which must have been made in falling, as Mrs Borden was a heavy woman. How hap pened it, too, that Bridget Sullivan heard nothing? It is rumored, too, that the stains on one of the axes and on some of the clothes found in the Borden house, Lave been decided to be human blood stains. If it can be proved that the capsules of these stains are identical with tboie found in blood known to be from the bodies of the victims, this will greatly strengthen the government case. Another point w’hich leads’ suspicion toward someone in the ^hotne is the fact that no trace which amounts to anything has been found of anyone leaving the house after the murders and before the alarm was given. The police have examined closely the parts of the barn where the daughter claims to have been, but no traces could be found in the thick dust on the floor of any visitor. The story that the daughter had tried to buy poison shortly before the murder, which the police still claim is true, is another link. Whether the stories of domestic trouble in the Borden family had any weight with the police or not, is not known. The great point to be discovered is, what the motive could have been. That w ill be for the government to discover. If they succeed, they w’ill be able, beyond a doubt, to make a strong case. As has been said, the servant-girl is an im portant witness for the government. It will be remembered that the story told all along has sent her to the third floor of the house to wash windows. She has claimed that this was at 9.30. As there w’ere 11 windows towash, it is safe to sav it took her at least an hour. Then she went upstairs to her room, certainly not before 10.30. Now’, as Mr Borden is supposed to have been killed about 11 o’clock, Mrs Borden from three-quarters of an hour to an hour before, this would bring her death during the time the servant was washing windows. If any one from the outside killed these two persons, how happened it bhat she saw nothing of him, as she commanded a view of the entrance to the house ? Of course these matters are largely con jecturejj, yet it is probable that the evidence of the government will be along these lines. Meanwhile the best legal ami detective talent will be engaged to clear Miss Lizzie Borden from the awful charge which has been brought against her. Miss Borden was taken to the second dis trict court-room about 3 o’clock Thursday afternoon, presumably to give farther evi dence at tiie inquest. Miss Borden was accompanied by her sister and Mrs Brigham. As was the case Wednes day all proceedings were conducted behind locked doors. No official an nouncement was made that would lead to any definite knowledge of the details of the inquest. Av hen Miss Lizzie returned frum the third inquiry she was a physical and mental wreck. She was conducted to the matron’s room and the inquest was ad journed about 4 o’clock, when Dis trict Attorney Knowlton and other officials went downstairs to the mar shal’s private office, where they remained closeted for two hours. Shortly alter 6 o’clock City Marshal Hilliard and District Attorney Knowlton drove to the home of Andre*’ Jennings, who has been attorney for the Borden family for some years. They returned about 7 o’clock and went upstairs into the matron's room, where Miss Borden was placed under arrest. The reading of the warrant was waived. Miss Borden took her arrest with surpris ing calmness, the two women with her being much more visibly affected than she. The excitement on the street, was very great just after the arrest, although some hours previous it was generally understood that Mius Borden would soon be arrested. Miss Borden was searched by Mrs Russell shortly after she was formally placed in cus tody. ' Other witnesses, who were examined at the inquest Thursday afternoon, were Eli Bence, the druggist who is supposed to have refused to sell poison to the prisoner; also his assistant, Fred Hart, and Frank Kilroy, who was in the store when Miss Borden is alleged to have made the request. Their testimony is said to have clinched the suspicions Qbeld by the police.

See the clipping

Springfield Weekly Republican · Springfield, Mass.

The report details police efforts to find physical evidence against Lizzie Borden, including her alleged poison purchase and inconsistencies in the maid's window-washing timeline relative to the murders. It also describes Lizzie's third day of inquest testimony, after which she appeared as a 'physical and mental wreck,' and officials' late-night meeting with the family's attorney.

Springfield Weekly Republican · 19 August 1892 · page 7

POLICE ARREST LIZZIE BORDEN.

The words of this article are printed with the report it shares its clipping with. Read them there or in the clipping.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

Der Deutsche Correspondent · Baltimore, Md.

A man named Charles H. Peckham walked into the Fall River police station and confessed to murdering Andrew and Abby Borden, claiming he climbed over the back fence and killed them 'just to see blood.' Police searched him, found only a pocketbook and official letters, and began investigating his background while noting he offered no clear motive.

Der Deutsche Correspondent · 19 August 1892 · page 1

Wahnsinniger bekennt sich als den Mörder der Borden'schen Eheleute

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

See the clipping

Der Deutsche Correspondent · Baltimore, Md.

The report describes Charles Peckham's rambling confession to the Borden killings, in which he claims the first blow was fatal so no blood splattered on him, with later blows struck only out of caution. Authorities, after consulting New Bedford's mayor, conclude Peckham is a war veteran with a history of mental illness who became obsessed with the case and is not a genuine suspect.

Der Deutsche Correspondent · 19 August 1892 · page 1

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

See the clipping

Daily Kennebec Journal · Augusta, Me.

Charles H. Peckham walked into the Fall River police station and confessed to killing Andrew and Abby Borden, describing how he entered and left the house, but authorities considered him insane. Marshal Hilliard separately gave his personal opinion that Lizzie Borden committed the murders during a temporary fit of insanity.

Daily Kennebec Journal · 19 August 1892 · page 4

HE SAYS HE DID IT.

tion this morning and said to Assistant Marshal Fleet ^ • Well, Mr. Marshal. I killed Mr. and Mrs. Andrew .1. Borden and . 1 have come from home to give myself up. I went over the hack fence a l through the rear door of the Burden honse. two weeks ago to-day, and 1 kille 1 both of these people out of pure love for blood, went out of the rear lour an ’ our the hack fence, and walked over the New Bedford road home. I'm the murderer and l want to lx !

See moreSee less

locked up." The marshal searched him and found a pocket hook with a few receipts in it. also : some official couuuunintlions from the Russian Bureau at Washington. lVckhani is ii. years of age. about five feet six inches tall and has a thin, gray board. He says he leases a farm from K hmiud Ihivis. City Marshal Hillard declares -It l.i/aie Borden i» guilty. 1 believe she com mitted the crime during a temporary tit of ! insanity. •Mark you. he continued. - I do not say she was insane; neither do l give that a* the idea of the government. It is merely j my personal opinion, based on what 1 know of the ease. • I think tiiiwoman may have, under certain circumstances, been so w rought up , that, for a lime, her reasons left hcr.aud in that time she w as led to commit those aw - ful crimes."

See the clipping

Daily Kennebec Journal · Augusta, Me.

A man named Charles H. Beckham confessed to the Borden murders after brooding over Lizzie Borden's arrest, but is described as insane and a war veteran subject to fits. City Marshal Hilliard also offers his personal opinion that Lizzie Borden is guilty, possibly having acted during temporary insanity.

Daily Kennebec Journal · 19 August 1892 · page 4

HE SAYS HE DID IT.

He Is Certainly Insane. Charles 11. Beckham, who confessed today to having committed the Borden murders, w as in this city Friday and heard a great ileal about Lizzie Borden’s arrest, lie went home and since then has brooded so much over the affair that he became insane. lie left the house between and 7 this morning, despite the protestations of his wife and walked ten miles to the police station to give himself up. —»J1 »* is a war veteran, and has been subject to fits ot insanity for some years. He will be cared for by friends.

See the clipping

In the story →

The Portland Daily Press · Portland, Me.

A man named Charles H. Peckham walked into the Fall River police station claiming he murdered Andrew and Abby Borden out of a love of blood, describing how he entered and left via the back fence. Police and acquaintances quickly determined he was mentally unstable and had become obsessed with the case after Lizzie Borden's arrest.

The Portland Daily Press · 19 August 1892 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

"I KILLED MR. BORDEN."

Startling Confession of a Supposed Crank.

See moreSee less

FALL RIVER, Mass., Aug. 18.—Charles H. Peckham, of Central Village, Westport, Mass., walked into the central police station this morning and said to Assistant Marshal Fleet; "Well, Mr. Marshal, I killed Mr. and Mrs. Andrew J. Borden and I have come from home to give myself up. I went over the back fence and through the rear door of the Borden house, two weeks ago today, and I killed both of these people out of pure love for blood, went out of the rear door and over the back fence and walked over the New Bedford road home. I'm the murderer and I walked to be locked up."

The marshal searched him and found a pocket book with a few receipts in it, also some official communications from the Pension Bureau at Washington.

Peckham is 62 years of age, about five feet six inches tall, and has a thin, gray beard. He says he leases a farm from Edmund Davis.

The police have started to hunt up his relatives or friends.

Peckham Crazy.

FALL RIVER, August 18.—The man Peckham, who gave himself up at the station this morning, is crazy beyond doubt. He begged several of the officers at the station to hang him. He formerly lived in Middletown, Ct., and, it is said, has had some trouble with his family. He was locked up.

Nelson Reed of Westport states that he knows Peckham very well, and says he has been crazy for some time.

Charles H. Peckham was in this city Friday and heard a great deal about Lizzie Borden's arrest. He went home and since then has been brooding so much over the affair that he became insane. He left home between 6 and 7 this morning, despite the protestations of his wife, and walked 10 miles to the police station to give himself up. He is a war veteran, subject to fits of insanity for some years He will be cared for by friends.

See the clipping

The Red Cloud Chief · Red Cloud, Neb.

Lizzie Borden was arrested in Fall River, Massachusetts, charged with murdering her father and stepmother the previous Thursday. She appeared before the district court for further inquest testimony behind closed doors, emerging as a 'physical and mental wreck,' while reports detailed her strained relationship with her stepmother over money matters.

The Red Cloud Chief · 19 August 1892 · page 3

LIZZIE BORDEN ARRESTED. Cliui-f-rd Willi the Murder of Her 1'iillier ii'iil Sti'piiuillier. Fai.i. Rivkii, Mass., Aug. 12. Miss Lizzie Ronton Is under arrest charged with murdering tier fattier and step

See the clipping

Fisherman & Farmer · Edenton, N.C.

The report describes the discovery of Andrew and Abby Borden's mutilated bodies at their Fall River home, with Andrew found in a downstairs room and Abby in an upstairs bedroom. It states that daughter Lizzie Borden found both bodies, that no weapon was located, and that a $5,000 reward was offered.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

Fisherman & Farmer · 19 August 1892 · page 6

A COUPLE KILLED.

A COUPLEjnLLED. Andrew J. Bordou and His Wife Found Mysteriously Murdered. A bloody double tragedy was enacted at Fall River, Mass., a few days ago. Andrew J. Borden and his wife were found dead at No. 92 Second street at 11 o'clock in the morning. Both had been frightfully mutilated about the head and face with an axe, cleaver or razor. Mr. Borden lay on a sofa in a room on the top floor of the house. His head had been cut, and gashes from four to six inches long were found on his face and neck.

See moreSee less

Mrs. Borden was in her own chamber on the upper floor, and the condition of her face and head was the same as that of her husband. She lay face down in the bed, which was a veritable pool of blood. The police were notified, and immediately an in vestigation was begun. No implements that could have been used in the commission of the crime have been found. The daughter of the unfortunate couple was the first to make the discovery. She went upstairs after finding the body of her father and saw that of her mother. She thought her mcther had fallen in a swoon, but on finding iiiat she, too, was murdered, the girl fled downstairs and fainted. The police have searched in vain for any clew to the murderer. Word was sent to Mrs. Borden thajt morning that a sick friend desired to see her, but she did not go out. It is said that the servant, Bridget Sullivan says she went into the room to make some inquiry of Mr. Borden about five minutes before Lizzie Borden gave the alarm. Ha was then sitting on the sofa reading a news paper. Mr. Borden was a wealthy real 3tate owner and mill man and was seen on the street half an hour before he was found dead. There is not even an apparent motive for the crime. A reward of $5000 has been of fered for the detection of the murderer. Twelve thousand men are laying the eastern section of the Trans-Siberian Rail way work, and it is expected that it will be completed next autumn. When the Prussian armv came back from their war they were receivad in 15-iat the gates of Benin, ani a choir stooi aoova the gates, and as the first regiment advanced and came to the gates the choir, in music, asked them what rigat they had to enter there. And then the first regiment, in song, replied, telling over the stories of their con flicts and victories. Tneri they marched in, and all the" city was full of gladness and triumph. But oh! the great joy wiitii the army with banners shall come up to the gates of our Kiug! It will be choir to choir, music to music, hosanna to hosanna, halleluiah to halleluiah. Lift up vour heads, ye everlasting gates, and let tnem come in. There w .11 be spread the banquet of eternal victory, and the un fallen ones of heaven will sit at it, and all the ransomed of earth will come in and cele brate the jubile? with unfading garlands on their brows telling of earthly conquests. All the walls ot that celestial mansion will be a-glitter with shields won in victorious battle and adorned with the banners of God that were carried in tront of the host. Harp shall tell to harp the heroism in which the conquerors won their palm, and the church that oay will sit queen at the banquet. Her wanderings over, her victories gained, Christ shall rise up to introduce her to all the nations of heaven, and as she pulls aside her veil and looks up into the face of her Lord the King, Christ shall exclaim, "This is she that looketh forth as the morning, fair as the moon, clear as the sun ani terrible as an army with banners I" obey orders.

See the clipping

Griggs Courier · Cooperstown, Dak. N.D.

Lizzie Borden appeared before Judge Blaisdell charged with killing her father and stepmother, represented by attorney Andrew J. Jennings. After an objection to the judge's dual role was overruled, she stood and pleaded not guilty in a voice that had to be repeated for the clerk to hear.

Griggs Courier · 19 August 1892 · page 2

,, W WITHOUT BAIL. Uwh Bwhs Held to Answer of XirdMiar Her Xtethararti Step mother. FALL RIVEB, Mass., Aug. IS.—Lizzie (X Borden was arraigned in the second district court before Judge J. C. Blais dell Friday morning charged with the killing of her father and stepmother. The courtroom was crowded to suffoca tion. Miss Borden's friends at court were very few in number. Mr. Morse, Bridget Sullivan, Miss Emma Borden and (Sty Missionary Buck were present. Miss Borden, the prisoner, was represented

See the clipping

Griggs Courier · Cooperstown, Dak. N.D.

At her arraignment, Lizzie Borden's counsel argued the inquest and trial should be separate matters, but the government's demurrer was sustained and a continuance granted until August 22. Borden was committed without bail and taken to Taunton jail, while John Morse and Bridget Sullivan were held as witnesses on $500 bail each.

Griggs Courier · 19 August 1892 · page 2

Miss Borden was asked to stand up and was committed without bail. She left the courtroom leaning on Mr. Buck's arm and was closely, followed by City Marshal Hilliard, who again placed her in charge of Matron RusselL Miss Borden was taken to Taunton jail later in the afternoon. Marshal Hilliard said that there was a great deal yet to be proven before the crime could be finally fastened upon

See the clipping

The Penn's Grove Record · Penn's Grove, N.J.

Lizzie Borden was formally arrested and charged with murdering her parents, showing no nervousness as Chief Hilliard read the warrant before her lawyer had her waive its full reading. The report also notes new witness testimony at the inquest, including a childhood acquaintance who confirmed unfriendliness between Lizzie and her parents.

The Penn's Grove Record · 19 August 1892 · page 1

Lizzie Borden Arrested as the Slayer of Her Parents. How She Met the Accusation. Her Remarkable Nerve Failed Not, and She Calmly Waived the Reading of the Warrant for Her Imprisonment.

reading of the warrant.” Chief Hilliard turned to Lizzie. ‘‘l)o ynu waive such leading?” he asked In surprise. Bite was silent tor a moment. Then she addressed her lawyer. “Aoswer him.” she commanded. “1 waive further read tug of that p iper She did not falter nor show a single sign of nervousness. For a second Bbe stood, her lips trembling; then her jaws shut firmly, and she sank hack Into her chair. Miss Emma Bjrdeo arose, faced her sister for an instant, ana hurriedly quit the room. As she shrunk before tbe great throng iu the street her eyes filled with tears Mrs.

See moreSee less

Josephine Tripp, of Westport, who has known Lizzie Borden from childhood, confirmed at the inquest the testimony that between Lizz'e and her parents there was uufriendliuesr, If not dislike. , , Other new witnesses testified duriug tbe day, and the polloe now declare that they have evidence ere ago where with to convict their prisoner. 6

See the clipping

The Evening Herald · Shenandoah, Pa.

Charles H. Peckham, a 62-year-old man from Westport, walked into the Fall River police station claiming he killed Andrew and Abby Borden out of love for blood. Medical examiners who interviewed him pronounced him insane, undermining his detailed but false confession.

The Evening Herald · 19 August 1892 · page 3

PECKHAM IS INSANE.

Wcstport, Mass. He walked into tho Central Police station yesterday, and said to Assistant Marshal Fleet: "Well, Mr. Marshal, I killed Mr. and Mrs. Andrew J. Borden and I have como from home to give myself up. 1 went over the back fence ami through the rear door of the Borden house two weeks ago, and I killed both of those people out of

See the clipping

The Evening Herald · Shenandoah, Pa.

Deputy Marshal Fleet questions a man named Peckham who confesses to a killing, explaining he struck extra blows 'as a precaution' after the first blow stopped the heart. The Mayor of New Bedford describes Peckham as eccentric, and the item connects to attorney Jennings, who represents Lizzie Borden.

The Evening Herald · 19 August 1892 · page 3

PECKHAM IS INSANE.

eccentric person, but was never SLjKta ' thou1'tJ? b A"3,""0,:, He said that Peckham leased a small farm from tho Davis estate in Westport, situated a few miles out of the city of New Bedford. Mr. Fleet also communi cated by telephone with Andrew J. Jen nings, attorney for Lizzie Borden.

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

Charles H. Peckham walked into the Fall River police station claiming he killed Andrew and Abby Borden out of a love of blood, describing how he entered and left the house. Police and reporters treat him as a crank, noting his history of eccentric behavior and a prior mysterious thirteen-year disappearance.

The Providence News · 19 August 1892 · page 1

:gr(;..“. brother now living as HartONLY A CRANK. Charles H. Peckham Thinks and Says He Killed the Bordens. FALL RIvER, Mass.,, Aug. 19.—Charles H. Peckham of Central Village, Westport, Mass., walked into the Central Police Station yesterday and askel for the city marshal. The latter had gone to the northern part of the city with a squad of officers to hunt down a suspect and Assistant Marshal Fieet answered his inquiries. “Well, Mr. Marshal,” said the man, “I

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

Charles H. Peckham of Westport walked into the Fall River police station claiming he killed Andrew and Abby Borden, describing how he entered and left through the rear. Police determined he was mentally unstable and not a genuine suspect, and he was released into his wife's care that night.

The Providence News · 19 August 1892 · page 1

Grinnell of Westport, took him home. Peckham was apparently sane and amused the crowd at the station by witty remarks. He denjed all lnowlod{: of the Borden murders and wanted to know why he had been locked up.

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

A newspaper opinion column mentions a man named Prokham whose mind was apparently unsettled by Lizzie Borden's story of suffering, calling him potentially dangerous but not credible. The piece defends Fall River police for refusing to believe his claims.

The Providence News · 19 August 1892 · page 4

. PROKHAM is evidently a crank, whose brain his been turned by the story of gzl Borden's sufferings. Such a man &y be dangerous, éven murderous, but @ Fall River police are hardly to be jlamed for refusing to credit his story. T conservative way in which the v York World handles the Buffalo strike shows vretty plainly that Home #tead cured its owners of all hankerings

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

An editorial criticizes recent newspaper commentary that disparages Andrew J. Borden's character, arguing that even if he had personal faults, this has no bearing on the legal case against his murderer. The piece suggests such criticism may be motivated by sympathy for Lizzie Borden.

The Providence News · 19 August 1892 · page 4

ANDREW J. BORDEN, Some of the recent reportorial com ments upon the character of Andrew J, Borden voice the sentiments and ap peal to the tastes of a small minority of

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

An editorial argues that attacks on the late Andrew Borden's character are unfair and irrelevant to determining guilt in the murders. It calls for public restraint, noting that pity for Lizzie Borden should not translate into vilifying her deceased father.

The Providence News · 19 August 1892 · page 4

Proof even that Mr. Borden wasa criminal himself would not have any bearing on the legal aspect of the case in hand, The simple fact exists that two people were murdered ; probably by the same person. Unless both acts can be attributed to self defense, punish ment must if possible be imposed upon the guilty one. This 1s the case, and no previous act or acts of Mrs, or Mr. Bor den can lessen the punishment which the guilty one deserves. It is undoubtedly true that some of the comments upon Mr.

See moreSee less

Borden's per sonal character are actuated by feelings of sympathy for Miss Lizzie Borden who has been unjustly, so far as public evi dence goes, accused of the murder, But charity is not a fixed quantity, It is not necessary that in proportion as pity may be extended to Miss Lizzie that feelings of the opposite kind should be entertained toward Mr, Borden. The contrary rather is true, The whole case appeals to the deepest sentiments in human nature. From the terrible crime itself each step in the de velopment of the evidence has been at tended by acts on the part of the author ities which called for the utmost for bearance toward the officials and claimed pity both for those who suffered as well as for the accused and the suspected. The demand upon pub lic charity has been great and constant ly increasing and is likely to continue su until the conviction of the guilty one. But the innocence or guilt of Miss Bor den does not depend upon the character of her father. Her case must rest on its merits and the public must not for get that the dead are defenceless and that to attack Mr. Borden's character now is neither honorable or just, It is pleasant to be able to record that this pitiless detraction of Mr. Borden and the passion for scandal which ac tuates it can only be charged to the few, But the spread of unclean and unkind rumors which is the result of such as sertions by the few is uufortunately much more general, Both the acts of the few and of the many are worthy of the severest censure, WAt warrant has the Woonsocket Call for spelling Henry Labouchere's “Henri 7" Henry is not a Frenchman, THERE seems to be otn the slightest ohjection to the request of the florists for a pound postal rate on seed catalogues. BrLLyY SHEEHAN'S partner plays rather an unenviable part in the troubles at Buffalo.

See the clipping

Daily Tobacco Leaf-Chronicle · Clarksville, Tenn.

Charles H. Peckham walked into the Fall River police station and confessed to killing Andrew and Abby Borden, claiming he entered through the back door and committed the murders out of 'pure love of blood.' He answered police questions about the crime in a coherent manner, and the report notes Lizzie Borden had previously been suspected and arrested for the murders.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

Daily Tobacco Leaf-Chronicle · 19 August 1892 · page 2

Now We Have the Man. And for That Reason He Killed an Aged Couple. The Fall River (Mass.) Mystery Finally Solved. Charles H. Peckham, of Central Village, Westport, Mass., Surrenders to the Fall River Authorities and Confesses the Double Murder of Mr. and Mrs. Borden. The Daughter Suspected.

Fall River, Aug. 19. Charles H. Peckham, of Central Villa, Westport, Mass., walked into Central police sta tion Thoreday morning and said to As sistant Marshal Fleet: , "Well, Mr. Marshal, I killed Mr. and Mrs. Andrew J. Borden, and I have come from home to give myself up. I went over the back fence and through thd rear door of the Borden house two weekSgo today and I killed both of those people out of pure love of blood. I went out of the rear door and over the back fence and walked over the New Bedford road home.

See moreSee less

I'm the murderer and I want to be locked up." - The marshal took him to the cell room and searched him. He found a pocket book with a fewreceipts in it and also unearthed some official oor. munications from the Russian bureau at Washington. Peckham is sixty-two years of ago, about 5 ft. 6 in. tall, and has a thin gray beard. He sayS he leases a farm from Edmund Davis. The police have started to hunt up his relatives and friends. This is the mysterious double murder for which Miss Lizzie Borden, daughter of the murdered couple, was suspected and arrested. When asked why he committed the crime, Peckham said he had good reasons for doing it, which he did not care to state. Fleet asked him what clothes ho wore and he replied that he wore the same that he had on. He was asked if they were not spotted with blood and he re plied no, there were no spatters beawtii the nrst diow causea aeacu ana sioppei the heart's action. He , said he struck the other blows by way of precaution. . He then told the deputy marshal that he expected no sympathy and wanted to be held. He had borne the knowledge of the crime as long as he was able and now wanted relief. Mr. Fleet further questioned him re garding various particulars of; the tragedy and he answered in a coherent manner. Immediately after he was locked up, Mr. Fleet telephoned the mayor of New Bedford for particulars about Teckhaiu. The mayor replied that he knew hiin very well and that he was in some way an eccentric person, but was . never thought to be insane. He said that Peckham leased a small farm from the Davis estate in Westport, situated a. few miles out of the city of New Bedford. Mr. Fleet also communicated by tele phone with Andrew J. Jennings, at torney for Lizzie Borden. Mr. Jennings replied that he wished to see the pris oner. The Crime. Andrew J. Borden and his wife were found dead at their home, 03 Second street, Fall River at 11 o'clock Thursday tnnmini, A 11 rr A TtiA 1 1 i ti rr trnaa nn record as the most remarkable murderT New England haaever known. Both had been frightfully mutilated about the head and face with an ax, cleaver or razor. Mr. Borden lav on a sofa in a room on the floor of the house. His lit'; ul hr.il bt'en cut, and gashes from fonr to ; ix inches long were found on his face nnvl neck. Mrs. Borden was in her chamber, on tho upper floor, and the condition of her face and neck was the same as that of her husband. No implements that could have been used in the commission of the crime were found. . Borden was a weathy real estate owner and mill man, worth $500,000, and was seen on the street half an hour be fore he was fonnd dead. - It is said that the servant, Bridget Sullivan, says she went to his room to make some inquiry of Mr. Borden about five minutes before Lizzie Borden gave the alarm. He was then sitting on the sofa reading a newspaper. Mr. Borden was on the streets and in several of the banks as lata as 10 o'clock. Public indignation had reached such a fever heat that the police were neces sarily impelled to action. The fingor of suspicion pointed to Lizzie Borden, the seventeen-year-old daughter. She was accordingly arrest ed, and is now confined in the jaiL Two days after her incarceration, that changeable fnblio opinion onoe more changed in favor of the girl. Many believed that her arrest and im prisonment had nothing tangible as a basis and naught but the enormity of the crime, calling for speedy vengeance, bronght about her temporary disgrace. North . Savannah, Oa., Aug. 19. William R. Cole, formerly a Central mil road engineer, while under the in fluence of liquor Wednesday morning, shot his wifu and himself at their home on Walberg street. Both may die. Fiuaiu'ial trouble is the probable cause.

See the clipping

Daily Tobacco Leaf-Chronicle · Clarksville, Tenn.

A man named Peckham confesses in detail to the Borden murders to Deputy Marshal Fleet, describing the weapon blows and his lack of remorse; authorities check his background with the New Bedford mayor and notify Lizzie Borden's attorney. The report also recaps the original crime, describing the mutilated bodies of Andrew and Abby Borden and the arrest of Lizzie Borden.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

Daily Tobacco Leaf-Chronicle · 19 August 1892 · page 2

The words of this article are printed with the report it shares its clipping with. Read them there or in the clipping.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

Alexandria Gazette · Alexandria, D.C.

Charles H. Peckham became obsessed with reports of the Fall River Borden murders and turned himself in as the killer. He was later found to be delusional and sent home to his family instead of being charged.

Alexandria Gazette · 19 August 1892 · page 2

Under ? sure W. T. Baker has re? signed as president of the World's Co? lumbia Exposition Company, and H. N. Higginbotham has been chosen to suc? ceed bim, Charles II. Peckham, who had been crazed by reading the reports of the Borden murders at Fall River and gave

See the clipping

Essex County Herald · Guildhall, Vt.

Lizzie Borden was taken into custody by Fall River officers on suspicion of causing her parents' deaths and is held in Taunton jail awaiting further developments. A blood-stained hatchet was found in the cellar, along with other evidence suggesting her possible knowledge of the crime, though public opinion remains divided.

Essex County Herald · 19 August 1892 · page 4

THE BORDEN MURDER. The Daughter LI..lo In Custody for tbo ( rime. Lizzie Borden was taken In charge by Fall liiver nlllcers on suspicion of having caused the death of her parents, nnd in now In Taunton, Mass., jail awaiting further de velopments in the use, A hatchet with human Mood upon It wns found In the cellar of the Borden house, and this, together with other evidence pointing strongly to the daughter's having some knowledge of the deed nt least, were thought ulllrlent to hold her. Allsorts of theories nre being advanced.btit 'he public ho far see hut littlo evidence on w hich to bingo an opinion as to the guilt or Innocence of those suspected.

See the clipping

The Londonderry Sifter · South Londonderry, Vt.

The report states that nothing positive has yet developed in the Borden murder case at Fall River, though Lizzie Borden, daughter of the murdered man, was arrested a few days earlier. It adds that it is doubtful she can be held unless further evidence is found.

The Londonderry Sifter · 19 August 1892 · page 1

Uniform pitch Vote for Fuller to save Harrison. An effort will be made at the next session of the legislature to remove the county seat to Brattleboro. New fane will please take notice and be prepared to vote for the whole gang in order to save Harrison. Read the article in another column from the Hardwick Gazette, beaded ' "The Clamor of the Bosses." John G. Warwick, representative in Congress from the' 16th Ohio dis trict, died in Washington Sunday night. Nothing positive as yet developed in the Borden murder case at Fall River, Mass., though a few days ago Miss Lizzie Borden, daughter of the murdered man, was placed under arrest.

See moreSee less

It is very doubtful whether she can be held unless further evi dence is found. Part of the New York State Militia has been called to Buffalo to guard railroad property from striking switchmen. The strikers burned number of cars and otherwise injured property to a considerable amount.

See the clipping

The United Opinion · Bradford, Vt.

Lizzie Borden was arrested by City Marshal Hilliard and a state police officer, then quietly transferred to Taunton jail amid a curious crowd. She pleaded not guilty at her arraignment, and her counsel secured a continuance of proceedings until August 22.

The United Opinion · 19 August 1892 · page 1

LIZZIE A. BORDEN'S PRESENT HOME IS IN JAIL - She Pleads Not Guilty at the Opening of the Trial - Her Counsel Granted a Continuance Until Aug. 22

anrl George Seaver of the state ponce. FALL Rivei, Mrss., Aug. 13. Lizzie A. Borden is in Taunton jail. Her removal was effected quietly and with careful delicacy by City Marshal Milliard, who did everything in his power to make h r departure as quiet as possible. - In the early afternoon she was visited In the mation's room by her devoted friend, Mrs. Brigharn, who was soon after fol lowed by Dr. Bowen, Mr. Jennings; Miss Emma L. Eorden aud Rev. Edwin W.

See the clipping

The United Opinion · Bradford, Vt.

Lizzie Borden said tearful goodbyes to family and friends before being taken amid chaotic crowds to Taunton jail, where she was processed and placed in a cell. She was then arraigned before Judge Blaisdell on homicide charges for the killing of her father and stepmother.

The United Opinion · 19 August 1892 · page 1

LIZZIE'S IN JAIL

L. Borden, with Mr. Jennings and Dr. Bowen, bade Miss Lizzie A. Borden an af fectionate good-bye. The parting between the sisters was a sad one, but both ap peared buoyed up by a strong faith and great trust. At Tannton there was a tumultuous and simply (lisgraceful crowd of morbidly curious peo ple awaiting the aruvai or the train. They raced after the officers as soon as they alighted, and jostled their prisoner and her escort. Miss Borden was Hur ried as fast as the marshal could hurry her out through the ladies' room and into a hack.

See moreSee less

The mob fairly swarmed round the carriage and hemmed it in, many nar rowly escaping being run down when the coach rattled off toward the jail. The reporters' coaches were ready simul taneously, and in the same order as before the three hacks rattled off f r the jail. The carriage coiiV?ylng Lizzie Borden en tered the grounds and drew up on the west ern side. She quickly alighted, and, with Rev. Mr. Buck, preceded the marshal and District Officer Seaver into the building. In Jail.

See the clipping

The United Opinion · Bradford, Vt.

Lizzie Borden was committed to jail and placed in the fourth cell of the woman's wing after processing by the matron. At her arraignment before Judge Blaisdell, she pleaded not guilty in a firm voice, and the case was continued until August 22 pending the ongoing inquest, with Morse and Bridget Sullivan held as witnesses.

The United Opinion · 19 August 1892 · page 1

LIZZIE BORDEN IS IN JAIL

Blaisdell on charges of homicide arising from the killing of her father and step mother. She was somewhat nervous, but did not show feeling by either tears or trembling. The trial was begun by the entering of a plea (.igned and sworn to by the prisoner. This plea was overruled for the time be ing, and the judge asked for the reading of the complaint. The reading was waived aud Mr. Jennings said he would enter a plea of not guilty. District At torney Knowlton, who was conducting the government's case, insisted that Miss Borden plead herself.

See moreSee less

Augustus B. Leonard, clerk of the court, asked her to stand up, which she did firmly and without assistance. She was then asked to plead to charges of homicide and did so in a very weak voice at first saying, "Not guilty." The clerk did not hear her, and she raised her voice and said in quite a loud voice, "Not guilty, Dutting strong emphasis on the first word. Mr. Jennings then began to argue for the acceptance of his plea that his client should not be examined before the court where she had already been exam ined at an inquest District Attorney Moulton entered a demurrer against the plea. The government's demurrer was finally sustained, and Mr. Jennings filed an exception. He moved for a trial at once. District Attorney Knowlton ob jected, on the ground that an Inquest was still going on. He asked for a continu ance until Monday, Aug. 22, and it was

See the clipping

Iowa County Democrat · Mineral Point, Wis.

A brief item reports that Lizzie Borden has been placed under arrest, accused of murdering her father and stepmother in Fall River, Massachusetts. It appears amid a long list of unrelated condensed news items from around the country.

Iowa County Democrat · 19 August 1892 · page 2

Lizzie Borden has been placed under arrest accused of the murder of her father and step-mother at Fall River, Mass. Superintendent Byrnes discredits the story concerning an anarchistic plot to make a second attempt upon the life

See the clipping

Iowa County Democrat · Mineral Point, Wis.

Lizzie Borden, suspected in the murders of her father and stepmother in Fall River, Mass., has been arraigned in court. She entered a plea of not guilty.

Iowa County Democrat · 19 August 1892 · page 2

0(H). The British steamer Winnifred, re cently seized by the customs officers at Port Townsend, for violation of the navigation laws, has been lined $1,400 here. A sign of the anti-English feeling in Russia is that all Hindoos have been ordered to quit Turkestan witliiu six months. Many bankers and traders who have settled for generations in Bokhara. Samarcand and elsewhere have thus been virtually ruined. As no money to pay for repairs to St. Paul's stormdamaged streets is available, it is proposed to close the streets by fencing in the dangerous places. Miss Lizzie Borden, who is suspected

See the clipping

Perrysburg Journal · Perrysburg, Ohio · and 5 other papers

At her arraignment, Lizzie Borden's attorney challenged the propriety of a judge presiding over both the inquest and trial, but the objection was overruled. Borden personally pleaded not guilty to the homicide charges, and the case was continued to August 22, with Borden committed without bail and witnesses Morse and Bridget Sullivan held on $500 bail each.

Perrysburg Journal · 20 August 1892 · page 2

WITHOUT BAIL

The clerk did not hear her and sho raised her voice and said in quite a loud voice, "Not guilty," putting strong emphasis on the first word. Mr. Jennings then began to argue for the acceptance of his plea that his. client should not be examined at tho Inquest. The proceeding was contrary to all law and justice. He, as attorney for Lizzie Borden, had been refused permission to enter and guide his client while an inquiry was being made. It was not to be expected of human nature that the same judge could act

See the clipping

Also printed in 5 papers
  • Hand County Press · Miller, S.D. · 18 August 1892
  • The Redwood Gazette · Redwood Falls, Minn. · 18 August 1892
  • The Worthington Advance · Worthington, Minn. · 18 August 1892
  • River Falls Journal · River Falls, Wis. · 18 August 1892
  • Griggs Courier · Cooperstown, Dak. N.D. · 19 August 1892

Perrysburg Journal · Perrysburg, Ohio · and 1 other paper

A roundup of national news items includes a brief notice that Lizzie Borden was arrested in Fall River, Massachusetts, charged with murdering her father and stepmother. The item appears among dozens of unrelated domestic news briefs.

Perrysburg Journal · 20 August 1892 · page 2

DOMESTIC.

Hartford City, Ind. Mi6S Lizzie Borden was placed under arrest at Fall River, Mass., charged with the murder of her father und step mother. By the burning of the large planing

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • The Kanabec County Times · Mora, MN · 18 August 1892

Baxter Springs News · Baxter Springs, Kan. · and 1 other paper

The report discusses District Attorney Knowlton's cautious approach to evidence and Attorney Jennings' efforts to prove Lizzie Borden's innocence, noting that government officials privately suspect insanity if she committed the murders. It also includes an unrelated historical account of a shipboard mutiny and murder aboard the Jefferson Borden, seemingly included for its coincidental name connection.

Baxter Springs News · 20 August 1892 · page 3

Attorney Jennings, UZZIC BOBDEN. who beyond question believes in the Innocence of Miss Borden, will do everything in his power to have at full examination at the earliest date. His sturdy work at the time of the arraignment has done much to change public opinion concerning the girl, more particularly that question referring to a fair trial by an impartial judge. Although Miss Borden is undo arrest, charged with perhaps the most heinous crime committed in recent years, there is little talk about the pun ishment that should be meted out to her.

See moreSee less

Friends are found in most unexpected places. The talk is almost entirely re garding her chances of proving her in nocence. This fact gives the police au thorities reason to think that much of the strongest evi dence will have to be given before At torney Jennings will consent to an order for holding his client until No

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • People's Voice · Wellington, Kansas · 19 August 1892

Huntsville Gazette · Huntsville, Ala.

A roundup of crime news notes that Lizzie Borden was arrested at Fall River, Mass., on the evening of the 11th, charged with murdering her father and mother. It claims the victims were found horribly butchered with an ax or hatchet, having previously been poisoned.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out. CorrectionThis set right 2 earlier articles: The American Citizen, 19 August 1892, Fisherman & Farmer, 19 August 1892.

Huntsville Gazette · 20 August 1892 · page 1

CRIMES AND CASUALTIES. On the 11th the Iowa state institute for the deaf and dumb, located three miles southeast of Council Bluffs, was destroyed by fire. There were but few' pupils in the school at the time, and all escaped without harm. The loss was estimated at $15,000. On the morning of the 11th Bender Bros/ planing mill at Hamilton, O., was burned, throwing 700 men out of work. The loss is nearly $100,000. Incendiar ism is suspected. On the 11th seven soldiers w'ere drowned at Neisse, Prussian Silesia, while practicing in the military swim ming school. Miss Lizzie Borden was arrested at

See the clipping

Los Angeles Herald · Los Angeles, Calif.

The New Bedford Standard reports that Andrew Borden had complained of discomfort living with Lizzie, who allegedly refused to eat at the same table as him. It also claims Lizzie told her father she hoped he would come home a corpse shortly before the murders.

Los Angeles Herald · 20 August 1892 · page 2

THB BOBDKH MUKDBRS. Circumstantial Evidence Strongly Im plicate* Lizzie Borden. New Bedford, Mass., Aug. 19.—The Standard this afternoon prints a story regarding the Borden murders, in which

See the clipping

The Record-Union · Sacramento, Calif.

Charles H. Peckham surrendered to police claiming he killed Andrew and Abby Borden, but was released after denying any knowledge of the crime. Police maintain evidence points to a woman, specifically Lizzie Borden, as the killer, citing family financial disputes as motive.

CorrectionThis set right an article from the day before.

The Record-Union · 20 August 1892 · page 1

BORDEN MUKDEIt. No Credit Given to the Confession Made by l'eckham. Fall River (Mass.), Aug. I.*.—Charles 11. Peckham of Central Village, who sur rendered to the police, declaring that he killed Mr. and Mrs. Andrew J. Borden, was released from the (station last night at !> o'clock and his wife took him home. Peckham is apparently save, and amused ii crowd at the station by his witty re j marks, lie denied ail knowledge of the I Boruen murder, and wanted to know why he had been locked up. The police insist that the evidence will show that a woman and not a man, com mitted the murders, and financial trou bles in the family and consequent bicker ings are recited to show they led to the tragedy, which the officials chum was caused by Miss Lizzie Borden.

See moreSee less

lizzik's wish; New Bedford (Mass.), Aug. 18.—The Standard this afternoon prints a story regarding the Borden murders, in which it is said that not Long since old Mr. I'.or den remarked that Ue did not take much comfort at home with Lizzie; thai she would not eat at the samo table with him, and only that morning when he acci dentally went into a room where she was ing she left the room. Borden is said to further remarked that when he left the \ noose Lizzie told him she hoped he would come home a corpse, and wouid probably be thai before Long.

See the clipping

Evening Journal · Wilmington, Del.

A man named Peckham who falsely confessed to the Borden murders was released after being deemed sane and ignorant of the crime. The report also circulates rumors of insanity in Lizzie Borden's maternal family and claims Andrew Borden's estate was worth nearly a million dollars.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out. CorrectionThis set right an article from the day before.

Evening Journal · 20 August 1892 · page 2

LIZZIE EOHDEN MAY BE INSANE. Wat Tainted—A It I« Said Hit Mulla« Story of a ( diivpinuMo». Fall River,.M aa»., Aug. 20.—Charles F. Perkham, the man who surrendered to the police, wiving that lie was the murderer ol Mr. uml Mrs. Borden, has been released. Him wife and Constable Grinoell, Of West port, took him home. Pcckham was ap parently sane, and amused the crowd at the station by bis witty remarks. Ho denied all knowledge of the Borden murder and wanted to know w hy lie had been locked up.

See moreSee less

An examination of the late Andrew J. Borden's papers discloses the fact that be was worth nearer a million thun a half mil lion dollars. His property holdings are all gilt edged and would soil at ranch more than their face value. The daughters' in bentance will be greater than was autlcl pated by the public and probably by them selves. The report is circulated hero that, thn presence of iusauit.v in the family of Lizzie Borden's own mother bos been discovered. It Is further added that no member of the Morse family, from which she came, es raped the reputation of being odd and ec centric. Friend* of Lizzie Borden say that the take* after the Morses and that her po uulimities are almost identical with thosi of her maternal ancestors. A friend of Andrew J. Borden, at New Bedford, relates u conversation which tool: place between himself and Mr. Borden a few weeks before the murders. Mr. Borden appeared very much disturbed. Upon being questioned, he remarked that lie did not take much comfort at home with Lizzie. Hint she would not cat nt the same table with him, and that only that morning when he went into tho room where she was eat ing she got up from the table und left the room. - This gentleman also Baid that Mr. Bordeu told him this with tears in hiseyeg, and fur ther remarked that when he left tho house Lizzie told him she hoped he would cotnu home a corps", und that probably he would before long.

See the clipping

The Washington Bee · Washington, D.C.

Lizzie Borden has been arrested by Marshal Hillyard after detectives investigating the Fall River murders concluded she was guilty. The chief detective explains his reasoning, including suspicions about her story of fetching a sinker from the barn, and mentions a second autopsy yielding new evidence.

The Washington Bee · 20 August 1892 · page 2

LIZZIE BORDEN IN JAIL CHARGED WITH THE MURDER OF HER FATHER AND STEPMOTHER.

The detectives claim to have discov ered undoubted evidence that Lizzie, the youngest member of the family, was guilty of tl.e horrible crime. The chief detective gives the following statement of the conclusions leading to the arrest. "From thavery first day I believed that Lizzie Borden had a hand in the mur ders. It was a hard thing to charge a

See the clipping

The Washington Bee · Washington, D.C.

An investigator details physical evidence—an undisturbed box, a lead pipe untouched for a week—casting doubt on Lizzie Borden's account of events. The report argues the house's acoustics make her claimed ignorance of the murders implausible, and that no stranger could have entered or left unnoticed.

The Washington Bee · 20 August 1892 · page 2

Borden was killed when her husband waadowriOTr2,!,Szi9sBSrI?h -ssrP-the house when it was done, but Bridget Sullivan was out, so she says. 'Lizzie had sent her into the yard for something. It is most remarkable that Lizzie did not hear her mother's body fall on the floor. Any sound in that house can b plainly heard in any part of it. It n made of weatherboarding and the inside plaster is thin. I stood at the edge of the barn the other day while an officer went upstairs and dropped a package weighing ten pounds on the floor in the room where the old lady was killed.

See moreSee less

I beam the sound distinctly. Mrs. Borden weighed over tw o hundred pounds, and when s e fell under the first blow sha dropped as so much lead. "As to the killing of Mr. Borden by some one who escaDed out of the back door while Lizzie was in the loft of the barn, the contradictions are equally 3trong. Lizzie would have heard th person escaping if he had shoes on. An officer walked down the steps while I was in the loft and I heard the footf -db plainly. But that is all nonsense. II

See the clipping

The Washington Bee · Washington, D.C.

A commentator argues against theories of an outside killer, citing sound tests and neighborhood visibility to claim no stranger could have escaped unseen. The report also notes Lizzie Borden's calm demeanor, her not-guilty plea, her confinement in Taunton jail, and claims about a distinctive hatchet allegedly used in the murders.

The Washington Bee · 20 August 1892 · page 2

this fictitious murderer had been bare footed he would have been observed by the people in the streets all tiie more readily. There were people at the wi dows of all the houses in the neighbor hood. No stranger went into the Borden house nor left it that morning untees he had wings and flew down the chimney and made his exit the same way. Lrezia would have been arrested Ion; ago if ' were not for her family connections and the Borden wealth. To show you how strong a pull is being exercised in her favor I will tell you that the persons who told us certain things a few days ago nov want to modify their statements or ttk tnem back entirely.

See moreSee less

" Lizzie Borden took her arrest very coolly, and showed no signs of breaking down. She plead not guilty to tha charge of murder, and was confined in Taunton jail pending the completion of the inquest. It is said the authorities have secured the hatchet with which tl murder was committed. No hatchet like the one in custody can be found i" the local hardware stores. Its greatest peculiarity is a claw on the side of th head nearest the'handle.

See the clipping

Dziennik Chicagoski · Chicago, Ill.

No certain facts have yet been found regarding the murder of the Borden spouses, and suspicion still rests on the jailed Lizzie Borden. A traveling salesman named Hathaway reported that the elder Borden had complained of his daughter's heartless behavior, saying she wished he would soon be dead and refused to eat with him.

Dziennik Chicagoski · 20 August 1892 · page 1

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

See the clipping

Baxter Springs News · Baxter Springs, Kan.

The article describes growing sympathy for Lizzie Borden in Fall River as her preliminary hearing approaches on August 22. It notes that Attorney Jennings has worked to improve public perception of her chances for a fair trial, while District Attorney Knowlton plans to withhold evidence until the actual trial.

Baxter Springs News · 20 August 1892 · page 3

The words of this article are printed with the report it shares its clipping with. Read them there or in the clipping.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

Baxter Springs News · Baxter Springs, Kan.

The report speculates that Andrew Borden was murdered in revenge by former mutineers he had once wronged as a ship owner, suggesting two strangers seen near the house that day could be linked to this plot. It notes a labor leader's efforts to free two imprisoned men connected to the mutiny, implying their release could exonerate Lizzie Borden.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

Baxter Springs News · 20 August 1892 · page 3

In or about Fall Hirer the day of the murder it may mean the release If Lis sie Borden.

See the clipping

Macon Beacon · Macon, Miss.

Lizzie Borden was arrested and charged with murdering her father and stepmother, with the warrant read to her at the matron's room after a third day of inquest testimony. Witnesses including a druggist and his assistant testified about an alleged attempt by Borden to purchase poison before the killings.

Macon Beacon · 20 August 1892 · page 1

LIZZIE BORDEN Charged With Murdering Her Father and step-Mother Wurrnnt Issued For IIr Arrest nnil She Is l'laced In I'rlson. Fall Rivkh, Mass., Aug. IS. Miss Lis.le ltorden is under arrest charged

See the clipping

The Grenada Sentinel · Grenada, Miss.

A brief news item reports that Lizzie Borden has been arrested at Fall River, Massachusetts, for the murder of her father and stepmother. It notes the crime has shocked eastern society due to the prominence of those involved.

The Grenada Sentinel · 20 August 1892 · page 2

878. _ _ THE EAST. Lieut. -Gov. Sheehan has been chosen chairman of the New York state campaign committee. The Cramps, of Philadelphia, secured the contract to build the ocean grey hounds that are to beat the records of the City of New York and the City of T'aris. The works of the Lancaster, Pa., Chemical Ca burned. Loss, 270,000; in surance, 220,000. James Faulkner, the bank wrecker of Dansville, N. Y., has been released on a pardon by the president Ballard Smith, editor of the New York World, has withdrawn from that paper.

See moreSee less

Miss Lizzie Borden has been arrest ed at Fall River, Mass., for the murder of her father and stepmother, a crime which has startled eastern society, nil parties being prominent Cruiser No. 11 was launched at Lor ing's ship yard, Boston, on the 11th. The Pittsburgh Post publishes a story of anarchists again plotting against the life of H. C. Frick.

See the clipping

The Grenada Sentinel · Grenada, Miss.

Lizzie Borden was arraigned before Judge Blaisdell on charges of killing her father and stepmother and held without bail. Police reportedly possess a peculiar claw-headed hatchet believed to match the wounds, along with bloodstained cloths from the cellar, though officials would not confirm its existence.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 2 days later.

Wrong

The Grenada Sentinel · 20 August 1892 · page 2

thk daughter arrested. CtargeA With the MerAer ef Her rather Fall Ritih, ht», Aug. Il-IA*** Bordta waa arraignad In the Saeond diitrict court before Judge J. C Blais dell, eharged with the killing of her father and stejtnothsr. The court ed to euffoeetloa, eh though Him Borden's friends at court were very few ia number. argument Mitt Borden wee com* After without bail. milled The police are la possession of a pe culiar batches and the rumor that particular hntadiet this by the 1* greatly atrsngtihtnsd strong weeding of City Marshal Hill iard's complaint No hatchet Uka the in custody can be found ia the one local hardware stores It* greatest peculiarity ia a claw on the aide of the head nea r est the, handle.

See moreSee less

The handle ia about two and a half test long and the top of the head ia about oae and a half by four laches It It said that the head of the hatchet fits iato the mur derous. wounds in Mrs Borden's head. The blade of the implement Is repre sented as being very thin and very sharp, measuring about five and a half inches in the widest part It ia what is known among farmers as an old fashioned thrash wood hatchet except for the strange elaw. When the police authorities were asked If auch a hatchet was In their custody they would neither admit nor deny it The matter, with all other evidence, is now in control of District The connec Attorney Knowlton. tion of the hatchet with a bloody deed of some kind is almost beyond doubt, as spots of blood have been found on the blade and handle. Certain cloths covered with blood found in the cellar where the hatchet waa found are said to have an important bearing on this part of the ease Last night Marshal Hilliard said that there was a great deal yet to be proven before the crime could be finally fast ened upon Miss Borden. Much had been learned, but for all that he could see the trial would be long and tedious Medieal Examiner Dolan says that a great deal will depend upon the accu racy of the medical examination of the body and the analysis of the parts sent to Bottom Although the authorities refuse to make public their discoveries they are believed to have secured damaging evi dence against the woman under arrest She has told two or three different stories, one of which is to the effect that at a few minutes past 11 o'clock on the morning of the murder* she went to the barn and climbed into the loft to get a piece of lead from a coil of lead pipe a for a sinker. A detective, who climbed into the loft found the floor covered with dust which retained impression of his feet There were no other foot prints on the floor. Moreover the coll of lead pipe was found between the house and the barn and a mechanic who examined it declared that it had not been cut for two months Medical Examiner Dolan says that Mrs Borden waa killed an hour before her husband, a fact which shows that the murderer must have remained in the house for some time. It happens alto that at the time Mr. Borden was killed the house was surrounded by per sons on all aides Patrick McGowan was in the rear picking pears Mrs Chase was on the south side and saw McGowan, who in turn saw her. A young French boy was in the street, and Mrs Bnffinton was on the north side of the house, where is the entrance alleged to have been used by the murderer, John Dinnie, a laborer, was at work in the yard adjoining the Borden property and was within thirty feet of McGowan. None of these per sons saw anybody either enter or leave the house. When Lizzie Borden found the body of her father the called Bridget Sulli van, the domestic, instead of her step mother. She explained afterward that the reason she did not call the latter waa because she had been summoned by a note to the bedside of aalek friend earlier in the morning, and she sup posed her still absent No such note has been found, nor baa the boy whom Lizzie Borden said delivered it made himself known. Moreover, none of the murdered woman's friends waa sick. When Bridget Sullivan waa examined she broke down so completely that the investigation had to be adjourned until she could compose herself. She said to the officer who accompanied her to the police headquarten: "The murderer ought to clear me." When she was asked later what she meant the broke down and was unable to go on. A motive for the crime waa furnished by an official of one of the Fall River tranks, who says that he knows that Mr. Borden was preparing to makes will and apportion his estate. He had gone so far, saya this official, as to take a number of shares of stock in the Dur fee Safe Deposit Co. and in the Union National bank and prepare to divide it between his wife and daughters on the ratio of twenty shares for bis wife and one for each of his daughters Hart at a Quser Tims. Nortiifield, Minn., Aug. 18.—Burt Rivler and Charles Lemon t, young men living at Dundee, three miles from here, are both In love with Mis* Lonkey, of their town. They made an agreement to rattle the matter by a light in the presence of the young woman. Miss Lonkey vrat watching the encounter from n boggy when the horse took fright and ran away, throwing her ont It te thoug ht she ia fatally hu rt Swiss Honor Apposaed. Berne, Aug. 13— Atl the facts in con nection with the arrest at Bay Riagc, Maryland, of Dr. George, attache of the Swiss legation at Washington, who waa charged with appropriating the pnrae of a Mrs. Horde of Baltimore, have been laid before the government. The re port of Gov. Brown of Maryland, regretting the incident m a blunder on the part of the deputy sheriff who made the arrest and stating tbit he had bran dismissed from his position, has also been telegraphed here. The report is very generally approved, and the chief executive authority of Switzerland re gnrda the incident as sloasd.

See the clipping

The Grenada Sentinel · Grenada, Miss.

The report describes mounting circumstantial evidence against Lizzie Borden, including her contradictory account of visiting the barn loft, the discovery that the lead pipe hadn't been cut recently, and testimony that multiple witnesses surrounded the house yet saw no one enter or leave. It also notes Bridget Sullivan's emotional breakdown during questioning and references an unverified note Lizzie claimed to have received.

The Grenada Sentinel · 20 August 1892 · page 2

Medical Examiner Dolan says that Mrs Borden waa killed an hour before her husband, a fact which shows that the murderer must have remained in the house for some time. It happens alto that at the time Mr. Borden was killed the house was surrounded by per sons on all aides Patrick McGowan was in the rear picking pears Mrs Chase was on the south side and saw McGowan, who in turn saw her. A young French boy was in the street, and Mrs Bnffinton was on the north side of the house, where is the entrance alleged to have been used by the murderer, John Dinnie, a laborer, was at work in the yard adjoining the Borden property and was within thirty feet of McGowan.

See moreSee less

None of these per sons saw anybody either enter or leave the house. When Lizzie Borden found the body of her father the called Bridget Sulli van, the domestic, instead of her step mother. She explained afterward that the reason she did not call the latter waa because she had been summoned by a note to the bedside of aalek friend earlier in the morning, and she sup posed her still absent No such note has been found, nor baa the boy whom Lizzie Borden said delivered it made himself known. Moreover, none of the murdered woman's friends waa sick. When Bridget Sullivan waa examined she broke down so completely that the investigation had to be adjourned until she could compose herself. She said to the officer who accompanied her to the police headquarten: "The murderer ought to clear me." When she was asked later what she meant the broke down and was unable to go on. A motive for the crime waa furnished by an official of one of the Fall River tranks, who says that he knows that Mr. Borden was preparing to makes will and apportion his estate. He had gone so far, saya this official, as to take a number of shares of stock in the Dur fee Safe Deposit Co. and in the Union National bank and prepare to divide it between his wife and daughters on the ratio of twenty shares for bis wife and one for each of his daughters

See the clipping

The Weekly Tribune · Great Falls, Mont.

The Lynn Examiner reports that Andrew J. Borden's testimony once helped convict mutineers from the schooner Richard J. Borden, and that the sailors vowed vengeance against him. It notes several of those men were later released and some were reportedly in the area at the time of his murder.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Weekly Tribune · 20 August 1892 · page 6

The Iorden Murder. Less, Mass., August 13.-The Iynn Examiner will today publish the state ment that Andrew J. Borden of Fall River gave the principal testimony that convicted the ring-leaders in the mutiny on the schooner Richard J. Borden while on her voyage froun a foreign port to this country; that he and his wife were on the vessel, and his testimony in the courts was declared by the salors to be false and e erated and that the men who suffered by t vowed veonesncw against him. Mast, if not all ofthem have been relewsd and it is sub.t.sd that severl of them were n all ver ati t me of the murder.

See moreSee less

Miles, the important duties they had be fore Mr. Proctor broke up the divisions. Oen. Schotleld has always opposed this change made by Mr. Proctor. He con siders that divislon organization will be essential in time of war and argues that v the system should be the same in time of peace if efficient service is to be ex pected in time of emergency. Even those who advocate the abolition of divis ion commands are not pleased with the manner in which Mr. Proctor arranged the department commands, for as it is t now, some of the brigadier-generals have

See the clipping

The Weekly Tribune · Great Falls, Mont.

Servant Bridget Sullivan said she wasn't surprised Lizzie Borden was arrested, a statement that unsettled the defense since she is a key government witness. Lizzie's lawyer could not learn what evidence was presented at the inquest, and the prosecution reportedly plans to withhold key evidence at the preliminary hearing.

The Weekly Tribune · 20 August 1892 · page 6

The Nttate Evidently Has a Strong Case Against Lisale BHorlen. F.tia,. RInV:L, Mase., August 13.-The most noticeable feature in the Borden case today was the expression made by Bridget Sullivan during an interview this afternoon, she remarked: "Well, I don't wonder that they arrested Lizzie Borden." As Miss Sullivan is the most important government witness her state ment has startled the friends of the im prisoned girl. Her remark undoubtedly represents the servant's view of the case. A. J. Jennings, counsel for Miss Borden, has been able to get no inkling the testimony elicited at the inquest.

See moreSee less

A great many people feel that the govern ment should have acquainted Mr. Jennings with its side of the ease. The district attorney would not talk on the case beyond dropping an occasional hint as to its legal aspect. It is known the government is indifferent as to the opinions of the people regarding the justice of the arrest of Miss Borden. It is reported the prosecution will present but little of its case at the preliminary hearing, keeping back, If possible, the most important evidence.

See the clipping

Passaic City Record · Passaic City, N.J.

A sixty-two-year-old man named Charles B. Peckham walked into the Fall River police station and claimed he had killed Mr. and Mrs. Borden, for whose murder Lizzie Borden had been arrested. The report notes he was evidently insane and that little credence was given to his story.

Passaic City Record · 20 August 1892 · page 1

River, Maas., and declared that he had killed Mr. and Mrs. Borden, for whose mys terious murder Miss Lizzie Borden has been arrested. Pack ham was evidently insane, »nit little stock was taken in his story. How. Whitxlaw Run spoke at the Con vention of the Illinois League of Republican

See the clipping

The Evening World · New York, N.Y.

This is a promotional item advertising an upcoming Sunday World feature in which crime novelist Anna Katherine Green offers her theory on the Lizzie Borden murder case, comparing it to her own detective novel 'The Leavenworth Case.' It notes she has concluded that the accused woman is not guilty, alongside other announcements for the paper's upcoming Sunday edition.

The Evening World · 20 August 1892 · page 1

ANNA KATHERINE GREEN ON THE BORDEN MURDER MYSTERY

DEN MURDER MYSTERY. Every one who reaas the papers and cares about creepy things, or things lull ot dark and deadly gloom, has followed the re markable murder case that has developed In Fall River, Mass. There la a strange New England woman, accused ot murder, acting as calmly, and displaying as little emotion as though she were playing a part in amateur theatrloals. It she Is guilty she Is a wonderful criminal, and it not she Is a woman with such strength ot character as all men must respect espe cially bachelors.

See moreSee less

That murder case Is strangely like the hypothetical case set forth In the clever detective story "The Leavenworth case." Anna Xatherlne Green, who wrote that story, has followed with deep Interest the devel opments In the Borden murder case, and baa decided that the accused woman Is not guilty. Ot course Ins World has arranged to publish her theory ot the case. It will be found mighty interesting reading, specially to women who want to believe their accused tellow-woman in nocent. What a chance It would be for Mary WUklns, who can dig out the char acter ot a New England woman as no one else ever thought of doing, to become a regular reporter or going to Vail Hirer and working on the case ot Lizzie Borden I

See the clipping

Perrysburg Journal · Perrysburg, Ohio

Lizzie Borden was arraigned in Fall River district court before Judge Blaisdell on charges of murdering her father and stepmother. After her attorney's procedural objection was overruled, she stood and firmly pleaded not guilty.

Perrysburg Journal · 20 August 1892 · page 2

WITHOUT BAIL

rest being, and tho judge asked for tho rcadlng of the complaint The reading was waived and Mr. Jennings said ho would enter a plea of not guilty. Dis trict Attorney Knowlton. who was con ducting the prosecution, inslbtcd that Miss Borden plead herself.

See the clipping

Pittsburg Dispatch · Pittsburg, Pa.

The New Bedford Standard reports a secondhand story from traveling agent George Hathaway, relayed via Captain Orrick Smalley, claiming Andrew Borden tearfully complained that Lizzie refused to eat with him and had wished him dead. The account is presented as newly credible gossip circulating among those discussing the case.

Pittsburg Dispatch · 20 August 1892 · page 7

LIZZIE HATED HER FATHER. A New Story Barring on the Fall Ztlver Tragedy Mr. Borden Complained That His Daughter "Wouldn't Est at the Same Table With Him.

See the clipping