As the Papers Told It

Little Bighorn · As the Papers Told It

Act Six

The Reno Court

January 1878 – November 1879

A visitor to the battlefield reported the reburial a sham, the bones mingled with the horses’. The army ordered honors for Comanche, the horse found wounded on the field. Reno, attacked in print, asked Congress for an inquiry, and President Hayes ordered a court. Before it met, a dying statement attributed to Captain Weir said Reno had refused to go to Custer. In Chicago the court heard the trumpeter who carried Custer’s last message and the scout Herendeen, and found no ground for a court-martial; an interpreter answered with an open letter. That August the field became a national cemetery, and in November Reno was court-martialed again, for drunkenness and insulting a woman.

Custer’s dead still unburied, a visitor says

A visitor fresh from the battlefield confirms the Leader’s charge that the burial party under Col. M. V. Sheridan, who barred correspondents, only heaped a little earth on the skeletons, which the first rain uncovered. The bones now lie ‘bleaching in the sun’ beside those of the horses, and the paper doubts the officers’ remains taken to the states were ever identified.

The Cheyenne Daily Leader · Cheyenne, Wyo.

The Cheyenne Daily Leader · 4 January 1878 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image

A STORY OF SHAME.

Which Should Cause Every True American to Blush and Hang His Head.

See moreSee less

A reputable gentleman who reached this city a few days ago, direct from the scene of the Custer massacre, confirms the stories heretofore told in these columns, of the disgraceful dereliction of duty on the part of the officers and men who were sent, at great expense, to that historic ground for the express purpose of burying the dead heroes in a civilized manner. It will be remembered that Col. M. V. Sheridan, the officer detailed to lead the burying party, refused to allow any correspondent to accompany him. This was a very suspicious circumstance, to say the least, occurring as it did, at the starting out. When he returned, his subalterns, both in and out of the ranks, were pledged to say nothing of the condition of the bodies or the manner in which they had been interred. One journal told a fishy story about sending a correspondent, disguised as a workman, but this was an attenuated yarn, and was not swallowed.

It is now known beyond the shadow of doubt, that the so-called burial consisted in piling up the dismembered skeletons, from which time and wild beasts had entirely removed the flesh, and heaping upon them a few shovelsful of the light powderish earth which is the soil of the battle-field. As a result, the first rain which fell after the work was done, washed away the light covering, and again the bones of the gallant dead were exposed to the elements.

When Gen. Sheridan visited the spot last Summer he found the field in this condition, and ordered the immediate burial of all the skeletons. A shovel brigade was sent out and another pretence of burial made.

To-day the bones of those heroes lie bleaching in the sun, among and almost indistinguishably mingled with those of their horses and other animals. There is no man living who can swear that the skeleton of the officers, which were taken to the states for burial, were or could be identified, and when Custer's stately monument shall rise we shall have no assurance that it does not tower over the grave of some obscure private. Truly, this is a story of shame, and the more so because it is true, every word of it.

See the clipping

Comanche never to be ridden again

The horse Comanche, called ‘the only survivor of the battle of the Little Big-Horn,’ was found grievously wounded two days after the fight and saved as Captain Keogh’s charger. General Sturgis now orders that he never be ridden or worked, have a special stall, and be paraded at ceremonies saddled, bridled and draped in mourning.

Orleans County Monitor · Barton, Vt.

Orleans County Monitor · 6 May 1878 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

The horse "Comanche," which is the only survivor of the battle of the Little Big-Horn, in which Custer met his death, has been made the subject of a general order. He was found on the battle-field grievously wounded, two days after the fight, and as he was the charger of Captain Keogh of the Seventeenth Cavalry, attempts were made to save him. He finally completely recovered, and now General Sturgis orders that the horse shall never be hereafter ridden, and shall do no work, but that a special stall shall be built for his accommodation; and that whenever the regiment parades on an occasion of ceremony, "Comanche," saddled, bridled and draped in mourning, and led by a mounted trooper, shall be paraded with the regiment.

See the clipping

Reno demands an investigation

A South Carolina paper reports that Major Reno, in command of troops stationed near Custer when he and his men were massacred, and whose conduct then ‘has been severely criticised,’ has written to the House committee on military affairs demanding an investigation.

The Abbeville Press and Banner · Abbeville, S.C.

The Abbeville Press and Banner · 3 July 1878 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image

Major Reno, who was in command of United States troops stationed near General Custer when the latter and his men were massacred, and whose conduct on that occasion has been severely criticised, has written a letter to the House committee on military affairs demanding an investigation.

See the clipping

The President orders a court for Reno

A Washington special says the President, on Reno’s own application, has appointed a court to meet at Chicago on the second Monday of January and inquire into his conduct at the Little Big Horn, where it has been charged he ‘was remiss in carrying out orders.’ Cols. Kink, Merrill and Royal will sit, with Lieut. Nee as recorder.

Bismarck Tribune · Bismarck, N.D.

Bismarck Tribune · 2 December 1878 · page 5 · transcribed from the page image

A Washington special to the Pioneer Press observes: "By direction of the president, on the application of Major Marcus A. Reno, Seventh Cavalry, a court of inquiry is appointed, to assemble at Chicago, Ill., on the second Monday of January next, for the purpose of inquiring into Major Reno's conduct at the battle of Little Big Horn, on the 25th and 26th of June, 1876. This was the fight with the Indians in which Gen. Custer was killed. The court is to report its opinion and whether further action is deemed necessary.

See moreSee less

It has been charged that Maj. Reno was remiss in carrying out orders. The following is the detail of the court: Col. John H. Kink, Fifth Infantry; Col. Wesley Merrill, Fifth Cavalry, and Lieut. Col. W. B. Royal, Third cavalry, with Lieut. Nee, Ninth Infantry, as recorder."

See the clipping

Weir’s dying statement against Reno

A statement said to be the sworn dying word of Col. Thos. B. Weir says Reno’s whole command heard Custer’s firing, that Weir saw the fight from a point not more than a mile and a half from Reno’s position and urged help, and that Reno ‘refused to budge.’ Reno calls it ‘absolutely false’; the Leader says he should not be condemned before his court.

The Cheyenne Daily Leader · Cheyenne, Wyo.

CorrectionThis set right an article from 6 days earlier.

The Cheyenne Daily Leader · 3 January 1879 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

AS TO GEN. RENO. Proofs against Gen. Reno respecting the Custer massacre are clustering rapidly. The latest is a statement said to come from the late Col Thos. B. Weir, of the United States army, and which has been published. Weir said before his death, according to this report, that the sound of Custer's firing was distinctly heard by Reno's whole command; that Weir's company was sent out to reconnoiter, saw the fight in progress, reported to Reno, and urged that Custer be helped immediately; but that Reno refused to budge.

See moreSee less

Weir's dying statement, which was sworn to, added that the point from which he obtained a full view of Custer's fight for his life was not more than a mile and a half from Reno's position, so that there could have been no difficulty in going to the relief of Custer. To all of this Reno responds in a published card, pronouncing "every statement published as emanating from Col. Weir to be absolutely false." These are brave words, which might possibly be qualified if Weir were not in his grave. But Reno, who was not long ago court-martialed for another eccentricity, will in a few days have an opportunity to defend his failure to succor Custer before a military court, and in the meanwhile it is not fair to condemn him. The most competent witnesses as to his conduct on that fatal day would be some of the savages who fought under Sitting Bull, and who knew exactly where Reno was during the massacre; but this evidence can hardly be obtained.

See the clipping

Reno at the Palmer House

On the eve of his inquiry Reno tells a Globe reporter in Chicago that his 112 men were overwhelmingly outnumbered and would have been encircled in five minutes more. He fell back so they could fight ‘like a man crowded into a corner’, while Custer, he says, saw the fight from a height and did not come. St. Paul’s witnesses, Benteen and McDougall among them, leave by train, ‘a jolly party’.

Daily Globe · St. Paul, Minn.

Daily Globe · 13 January 1879 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

FARED THE SAME FATE AS CUSTER'S.

RENO'S RACKET.

THE CHICAGO INQUIRY INTO THE CUSTER MASSACRE.

See moreSee less

Members of the Court Already Putting in Appearance—A "Globe" Reporter Meets and Interviews the Accused Officer—General Defense of His Conduct and Anxiety for a Thorough Investigation—Departure from St Paul of Important Witnesses.

[Special Telegram to the Globe.]

CHICAGO, Jan. 12.—Three or four of the court which is to meet to-morrow to inquire into the charges preferred against Major Reno, arrived in this city from the West this afternoon. A number of witnesses are also en route hither, but may not reach the city before Monday afternoon. Gen. Reno is at the Palmer House, and awaits the convening of the court. In conversation with the GLOBE reporter, Gen. Reno politely, but guardedly, answered a few questions put to him in a casual way. He was asked if he had formed any idea of the strength of the enemy at the time his command engaged them in battle.

He replied that the valley in front of him was swarming, and that his force of 112 men was overwhelmingly outnumbered.

NOT A MAN OF MY COMMAND WOULD HAVE SURVIVED,

said he, had we not changed position. The enemy was not only in front, but on our left and rear. They would have closed in on our right and completed a circle in five minutes more. Soldiers will not flinch from duty, so long as they can fight the enemy face to face, but place them in a position where they are as liable to be shot down from behind as fr[o]m in front, and they are at once disconcerted and unnerved, and cannot do effective fighting. I moved my command back where, like a man crowded into a corner, they could fight without being shot in the back, and but for that my men would have

FARED THE SAME FATE AS CUSTER'S.

In answer to the question whether Custer was aware of his (Reno's) engagement with the Indians, the general said:

He could see from the eminence from where he halted for a brief time, thas the Indians were fighting my command, but he did not come to my assistance, and had we not retreated just as we did we would have been wiped out.

In conclusion Gen. Reno said he was very willing to have the court develop all the facts in the case, and he would cheerfully abide by its decision, but of one thing he was quite certain, namely, that if he ever did his whole duty during his military career, it was at the battle of the Little Big Horn.

The "Globe's" Contribution.

All news in connection with the Reno trial, to commence to-day in Chicago, is of particular and peculiar interest to St. Paul. Reno's record of late years is pretty well known in this community, and has had a partial ventilation in our midst. The GLOBE, aware of this interest, has duly posted and gratified its readers with all events happening in regard to the affair. Yesterday St. Paul contributed a number of witnesses to the investigation in Chicago. They took the 7:40 train for Chicago, a jolly party, though bent on a mission to spoil or illumine American history.

The party were composed of Capts. Fred. W. Benteen, Thomas M. McDougall, Lieuts. Varnum and Wallace, Seventh U. S. cavalry; Dr. Porter, Bismarck, late assistant surgeon United States army; Frank Girard, scout. Col. Smith and Lieut. Maguire, of Gen. Terry's staff, were also of the party. These last a[r]e also parties to the issue at stake.

In looking over the crowd, the GLOBE ventures the assertion that there will be a stand-off in the testimony given "to make history" in this affair. Col. Benteen is anti-Custer; McDougall favorable to keeping Custer's gallant memory untarnished—the others are evenly balanced. The term anti-Custer is used advisedly. For no matter how the attempt may be concealed, the effort of Reno and friends will be directed in his vindication to tarnish the memory and deeds of the gallant, brave and unfortunate Custer. It will be the revival of an old and disgraceful army fight—for years confined to the Seventh regiment. So early and long ago as the organization of the Seventh cavalry, a feeling of enmity to Custer was entertained by many of his regiment; others were as warm in his admiration. The feeling of both parties was fostered, until the division in the regiment was marked and distinct. The bitterness of the controversy can not be understood except by those idle enough to cultivate it, and with nothing else to engage their attention. The thought is suggestive that a regiment divided by such a contention would be useless. The master spirit of Custer, in command, kept it in subjection.

The leader of the Custer opposition was, at first, Col. Wm. Thompson. He left the regiment. His mantel fell upon the shoulders of Col. Fred. W. Benteen.

The opposition to Custer were in Reno's command at the battle of the Little Big Horn, and survived; the supporters of Custer went gallantly to their death, with their commander fighting bravely and desperately at their head.

See the clipping

‘Courage, boys’: the trumpeter testifies

At the Reno inquiry Sergeant Culbertson says three minutes more on the skirmish line would have been fatal, and that Reno did not avoid places of danger. Then John Martin, Custer’s orderly trumpeter, tells how Custer saw the village from a ridge, women and children in view but no warriors, took off his hat and yelled ‘Courage, boys, we will get them and then go back to our station.’ The Herald finds him ‘very wild in regard to the time’.

The New York Herald · New York, N.Y.

The New York Herald · 1 February 1879 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image

RENO AND CUSTER.

FURTHER TESTIMONY BEFORE THE CHICAGO COURT OF INQUIRY TENDING TO EXCULPATE RENO—THE RASH CHARGE ON THE INDIAN VILLAGE.

See moreSee less

[BY TELEGRAPH TO THE HERALD.]

CHICAGO, Jan. 31, 1879.

The Reno investigation was continued to-day. After the minutes of yesterday's session were read Lieutenant De Rudio was recalled by Mr. Gilbert, who asked him what conversation he had with the scout Girard respecting his being a non combatant. Girard had said that he had no business in the line as he was an interpreter, and consequently not expected to do duty. Sergeant Culbertson was then recalled for cross-examination by Mr. Gilbert. The witness said he heard an order given to Company G, when it moved down toward the timber, to keep cool and not get excited, as there was "likely to be hot work;" saw Major Reno only once, and he was then on the right of the skirmish line.

Mr. GILBERT—What, in your opinion, would have been the fate of the skirmish line if it had remained outside of the woods?

To this question the Recorder, who had drawn out opinions all along, objected.

The Court, however, permitted it to be answered.

The witness said that a continuance there of three minutes longer would have been fatal. Neither did he think the line could have remained in the woods more than a few minutes; he thought there were one thousand or one thousand two hundred Indians pressing around them.

RAPID FIRING BY RECRUITS.

Some of the recruits told witness that they had fired sixty rounds; he had fired twenty-one rounds; there was no more than a necessary delay after the pack train came up in the movement of the command down stream; the firing heard by witness in the direction of Custer's position was at no time heavier than that which had been made by the skirmish line, nor was it so heavy as to leave the impression that Custer was having a more serious time than had Major Reno; on the night of the 25th the opinion was expressed that Custer's failure to join Reno was probably due to the fact that he had some wounded men and could not move; witness and Reno went to hunt for the body of Lieutenant Hodgson; about five minutes after witness had heard firing down the river; witness did not hear any firing after that; so far as witness saw Major Reno was exercising command over his men on the afternoon of the 25th; Major Reno was frequently exposed to heavy firing, standing at points in the discharge of his duties where he was without protection, and in one instance where a man was just before killed; he did not avoid places of danger; after the firing ceased a picket was put out and the command laid down for rest; on the night of the 25th there was talk of sending a message to Custer, Lieutenant Varnum saying it was more than likely that he would be detailed to go; the feeling was that General Custer was all right and as able to take care of himself as was Reno.

CUSTER'S RASH CHARGE.

The next witness was John Martin, trumpeter, Company H, Seventh cavalry, now stationed at Fort Abraham Lincoln. He was orderly trumpeter for General Custer on the 25th of June. He said Major Reno separated from the command at the tepee so often referred to; they moved down opposite sides of the stream at a jump; when the separation was made prior to Reno's crossing the Little Big Horn, Custer started down the right and Reno went down the left on crossing; when Custer got upon the high ridge the Indian village was presented to view, the women and children being visible, but no warriors; Custer appeared glad, as it was supposed the Indians were sleeping; Reno's command was not in view; the Gray Horse company was in the centre of Custer's command; it was about an hour and a half after leaving the watering place that Custer got upon the bluff where the Indian village was made visible; witness saw the children running and playing around the tepees; the whole column passed over the ridge; witness could not see the river at that point.

"COURAGE, BOYS."

When Custer saw the Indian village he took off his hat and gave a yell, saying, "Courage, boys, we will get them and then go back to our station;" Custer appeared very glad; the command then passed down, but when it reached a ravine Custer called his orderly to send back word to Captain Benteen.

This witness was very wild in regard to the time, and made it appear after a time that it was two hours and a half from the time he left Custer to the time when Benteen came up; it might even have been three hours; it was about an hour anyhow after he delivered the despatch to Benteen to the time Benteen reached the hill.

The witness was excused and Benteen called, but as Benteen did not appear the Court adjourned until ten o'clock to-morrow.

See the clipping

Herendeen: ‘everybody ran for his life’

At the Reno inquiry in Chicago the scout George Herendeen (the paper spells him Hesendeen) testifies that Reno dismounted his men, mounted them again at once, and led a retreat ‘as fast as spurs would make an American horse go.’ Thrown and left in the timber, he and a party of soldiers held it two hours without being molested, and he did not believe the Indians could have driven Reno out of it had he stayed.

Public Ledger · Memphis, Tenn.

Public Ledger · 1 February 1879 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image

RENO'S RUN.

How He is Declared to Have Scampered From the Indians.

See moreSee less

A special dispatch from Chicago, dated the 27th, says:

The 13th day of the Reno trial opened with some fresh testimony,

George Hesendeen, an experienced scout, was placed on the stand. This witness said he was a scout and courier with General Custer on the 25th of June, 1876, accompanying Reno's column; he had been in several engagements with the redskins; concerning Custer's order to Reno the witness testified that as he overheard it it was in effect that Reno should lead out and Custer should follow him; they were not opposed by Indians as they went down the bottom; to estimate the distance of the Indians from them after the skirmish line was formed, the witness, Girard and another scout all took aim at one Indian, but the bullets fell short; he thought the Indians were from 700 to 900 yards away; just as the retreat was about to begin the witness rode up close to the major; a volley was fired by the hostiles; Bloody Knife, the Indian scout, some ten feet ahead, fell dead from his horse.

Major Reno had ordered the men to dismount; then, immediately, he ordered them to mount again, and everybody ran for his life; the retreat was just as fast as spurs would make an American horse go; witness followed the command as rapidly as he could; everybody was running for his life; the horse of witness fell, throwing him, and perhaps twenty Indians stumbled over him; witness then started back for the timber; as he did so the men were still coming out of the timber, and he heard an officer say, "Company A, halt; for God's sake do not run!" the halt was not effected; witness got back to the timber and found some men mounted and some dismounted; he advised these to turn back to the timber and try to lead the Indians off; they did so, and the party took up a position in the timber; they remained there two hours and were not molested by the Indians; the men had plenty of ammunition; they were scared at first, but got over it and proposed to fight.

Down the river he heard the sound of firing in volleys, in the direction of the Custer battle-field; that firing lasted an hour; over where Reno was, however, he heard during that time only scattering shots; probably Custer was half a mile beyond Reno's Hill when the major began his retreat; the Custer battle-field was about two miles from the same point; late in the afternoon the witness left the timber, and eleven soldiers, three of whom were wounded, and joined Reno; they left two men behind; in getting out they encountered five Indians, upon whom they fired, and the redskins ran; crossing the river (the water up to their necks) they saw the troops on the hill; Lieutenant Varnum came down to meet them; the only conversation he had with Major Reno was that evening, when he interpreted for Half Yellow Face, of whom Reno asked what the Indians appeared to be doing; the witness could not say who appeared to be exercising command; the witness estimated the number of fighting Indians at 3500; witness said emphatically that he did not believe that the Indians could have driven Reno from the timber had he remained there; he did not think that the Indians could have driven one hundred men with 5000 or 6000 rounds of ammunition out of the timber where Reno's command was.

Mr. Gilbert then examined the witness. The order which the witness saw delivered to Reno to cross the river and charge the Indians was given by General Custer in person; the witness did not see Colonel Cook, the adjutant, deliver any such order. After the witness had rehearsed the narrative of his adventures up to the time when he rode out into the glade and saw Major Reno's men mounted, he testified that Major Reno, after he gave the order for retreat, rode very fast through the timber; he saw nothing of Reno in the timber except when he gave the two orders in the glade.

When Mr. Gilbert had finished the cross-examination, Lieutenant Lee extracted a little more direct testimony, and Colonel Merritt asked the witness if he went over the battle field the next day after the massacre. The witness said he did not; he was quite positive that no fighting occurred at the place where Custer was supposed to have attempted so cross the river, for he would have heard the firing.

See the clipping

A regiment ‘distracted by jealousy’

As the Reno inquiry closes, the Globe sees no ground for a court martial, though it finds the charge of cowardice ‘only half proved’ and Reno’s standing no better for it. Its real finding is a Seventh Cavalry split into factions: Reno and Benteen jealous of Custer, Custer of them, and Reno’s command made up wholly of the anti-Custer side.

Daily Globe · St. Paul, Minn.

CorrectionThis set right an article from the day before.

Daily Globe · 10 February 1879 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image

THE RENO INQUIRY. The Reno inquiry has just concluded, and the main results are before the country. We hardly think, from a careful perusal of the testimony, that sufficient ground exists for the trial of Major Reno by court martial, but sufficient has been shown to prove that his conduct before, during and since the battle of the Little Big Horn, where Custer and his comrades fell, was not such as to increase the respect in which he has heretofore been held. The charge of cowardice was only half proved, and there appears to be an honest difference of opinion as to whether his failure to go to Custer's rescue was due to cowardice or to inability to do so by reason of the overwhelming force of the Indians in his front.

See moreSee less

His partisans are very emphatic in asserting that if he had carried out his instructions he would have sacrificed the lives of every man in his command besides his own, and that he was wise in pursuing the course he did. The partisans of Custer, however, are equally emphatic in declaring that, had Reno's force attacked the Indians simultaneously with Custer's, the result would have been the complete rout of the savages. All this testimony is mere speculation, however, and throws but little light on the subject. One fact, not at all complimentary to the discipline of the army, has been brought out in bold relief by this inquiry. It is that the regiment was distracted by jealousy and divided by contentions of all sorts. Reno was jealous of Custer, and so was Benteen, while Custer was jealous of his subordinates. So far had this disorganization progressed that every officer and private was openly arrayed on one side or the other. When Custer went into battle he had none but his own partisans with him, while Reno's command was composed wholly of the anti-Custer portion of the Seventh cavalry. It has been frequently hinted that the survivors of the regiment were so embittered by the feuds that had existed that they would not have taken the trouble to go to Custer's aid even had it been wholly practicable. Such a state of affairs must be prejudicial to the discipline of an army and greatly impair its efficiency, and we greatly suspect that the Seventh cavalry is not the only regiment that is similarly disorganized. Regiments in the army are generally close corporations, and the public knows but little of what is going on in camp or barracks. Thus it happened that none outside of army circles knew to what extent the bitterness in the Seventh cavalry had attained, and the public know next to nothing of the contentions in other regiments that may be in progress now, and possibly may lead to another Custer massacre. The war department should act decisively in the matter, for it cannot afford to imperil the efficiency of the forces through the toleration of these senseless contentions.

See the clipping

The interpreter’s open letter to Reno

The Globe reprints from the Bismarck Tribune an open letter by the interpreter F. F. Girard, answering Reno’s testimony that he was discharged in 1875 for stealing. Reno fired him on 6 May 1876, Girard says, because his salary would pay three teamsters, and Custer restored him on the 12th. He calls it ‘petty tyranny,’ mocks Reno’s ‘feat of horsemanship’ and his refuge behind the barricades on the hill, and grants him only the Scotch verdict, ‘Not proved.’

Daily Globe · St. Paul, Minn. · and 1 other paper

Daily Globe · 2 March 1879 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

WHEN BEHIND THE BARRICADE ON THE HILL

RENO.

Post-Interpreter Girard Writes an Open Letter to the Major—He Indicates Considerable Contempt for the Person He Addresses—Cowardice, Mendacity, Vanity and Vulgarity Among Girard's Innuendoes.

See moreSee less

The following open letter to Maj. Reno appears in the Bismarck Tribune:

"To Maj. Marcus A. Reno—Major: In the issue of the Chicago Times of Jan. 9 you are represented as testifying, in your effort to acquit yourself of the charge of cowardice, that you discharged Girard from the government service in the latter part of 1875 because you believed him to be guilty of stealing. Those who do not know you, sir, may not make due allowonce for you, and may do me injustice to place absolute confidence in your veracity. To guard against such an error, I take the liberty of confronting you with your worst enemy,—a statement of fact. You did discharge me as post-interpreter May 6, 1876, assigning as a reason that you expected to go out of command of the Lincoln colunm, that you must economize, and that you could employ three teamsters for my salary.

I CAN NOW UNDERSTAND THE ECONOMY.

in discharging an interpreter, as you probably foresaw that there would be no occasion for one, so far as your relations with the Indians were concerned.

"Gen. Custer, contrary to your plans and expectations, returned and assumed command, and, after hearing your reason for my discharge, restored me my position on the 12th of the same month. Why did you not make official complaint to your superior or institute proceedings yourself against me? The fact is, you displayed another trait of character always associated with that which distinguished you at the battle of the Little Big Horn—petty tyranny. Custer you could not harm, but you could his humble friends, so you discharged Girard. Major, what evil genius tempted you to suggest a comparison of character between you and me? You, whom a too generous country educated and trained for an honorable profession—to see you conspicuous only for a meanness and unmanliness in your capacity of commanding officer at Abercrombie, where your insults and prosecutions of a brother officer's wife aroused

THE INDIGNATION OF THE WHOLE COUNTRY,

and culminated in your dismissal from the military service, for conduct unbecoming an officer and a gentleman—you, I say, do yourself an injustice in contrasting yourself with an humble interpreter, whose simple ambition never arose before the humble discharge of his humble duty. Your name, since this fiasco, has secured to itself some prominence by its association with a chief whom you betrayed, and this has ended in an inquiry into your conduct at the Little Big Horn. I commend your prudence in this course, if not in others, as more than two years and a half elapsed before your wounded honor asserted itself, and asked for a court of inquiry, the coveted regime. You are safe at last, sir, and safety is the goal you have been striving for most of your life; but, remember, major, you once secured a certain kind of safety; was it worth the price? Your modesty would not allow you to imagine that your feat of horsemanship on that occasion would excite such profound interest in the minds of your countrymen, nor did you believe,

WHEN BEHIND THE BARRICADES ON THE HILL,

where you so strategetically eluded the sight of your command and the fire of the Indians, that you would be exposed and pilloried as you have been in Chicago. Pity for you prevented your comrades from charging you with a quality of which the public verdict convicts you. I too commisserate your condition, and gladly award you all the benefit of the doubt implied by the Scotch verdict, "Not proved." You are not my ideal of the representative American officer. I cannot recall any illustrious person in our military history to whom you bear any resemblance. And yet I am informed you sometimes assume Napoleonic attitudes, but they are only attitudes, and are not significant of anything warlike. Major, among the other amusing elements of your statement before the court was your attempt to criticise Custer's military abilities. What must his comrades, especially Gen. Merritt, have thought, as you, with your limited capacity and narrow, beclouded horizon, attempted to criticise a soldier whose life is a challenge to your own dead level, and whose death you will never emulate? In answer to a question by Recorder Lee, you state that you heard I was then at Little Big Horn.

WAS THIS THE SOURCE OF YOUR INFORMATION?

Perhaps so. It is in keeping with your recollections of the memorable 25th of June, 1876, and you swore you would not beleive any report brought to you by me on that occasion. Major, the question will naturally suggest itself, Upon what have you been feeding that you have grown so great in your own esteem? You forget, Major, that you were

NOT BEING TRIED BY SNOBS,

but by an American constituency who will place a just estimate on your snobbish assumptions of superiority, and with that constituency I leave the question as to who did his duty, you or I, on the occasion referred to. In leaving you, Major, let me correct any impression you may have that I am arguing with you on points of facts, or matching my veracity against yours. My respect for myself and my friends will not permit me to do my reputation such injustice. I merely call your atention to a few naked truths with which you are perhaps already familiar, but which, with characteristic modesty wherever the truth is concerned, you would leave for some one else to push forward.

F. F. GIRARD.

See the clipping

A national cemetery of the fourth class

The Herald prints a War Department order from Washington, 4 August: the ground known as the Custer battlefield, on the Little Big Horn River in Montana Territory, is announced as ‘a national cemetery of the fourth class.’ Its boundaries will be given in general orders from the headquarters of the Department of Dakota once the site is surveyed and the President has proclaimed it a military reservation.

The New York Herald · New York, N.Y.

The New York Herald · 5 August 1879 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

ARMY INTELLIGENCE.

THE CUSTER BATTLEFIELD MADE A NATIONAL CEMETERY.

See moreSee less

WASHINGTON, August 4, 1879.

The following orders have been issued by the War Department:—

First—The ground known as the Custer battlefield, on the Little Big Horn River, Montana Territory, is announced as a national cemetery of the fourth class.

Second—Upon the completion of the survey of the site and after the order of the President of the United States has been obtained declaring and proclaiming the same a military reservation, the boundaries thereof will be announced in general orders from the headquarters of the Department of Dakota.

See the clipping

Reno faces a court martial at Fort Mead

A Minnesota paper reports that a court martial has been instituted at Fort Mead, Dakota, to try Major Reno, ‘of Custer massacre notoriety,’ for ‘conduct unbecoming an officer and a gentleman’: the specifications are drunkenness and insult to a woman.

Stevens County Tribune · Morris, Minn. · and 3 other papers

Stevens County Tribune · 13 November 1879 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

A court martial has been instituted at Fort Mead, Dakota, Territory, to try Major Reno, of Custer massacre notoriety, for "conduct unbecoming an officer and a gentleman" the specifications being drunkenness and insult to a woman.

See the clipping

← Back to Act Five: Hunting Sitting Bull