As the Papers Told It

Little Bighorn · As the Papers Told It

Act Two

Custer Killed

6–8 July 1876

On 6 July a dispatch out of Montana, on the word of a scout named Muggins Taylor, said that Custer had found the Indian camp on the Little Horn, charged it, and been killed with every man of his detachment. General Sheridan called it a frontier story. General Sherman, found in a Philadelphia hotel with his coat and boots off, said it seemed almost too terrible to be true. Within a day Terry’s own dispatches confirmed it, the lists of the dead were printed, and a New York paper blamed the President, who had degraded Custer before the campaign: ‘Some one has blundered.’

Wilmington gets the news at press time

Just as it goes to press, the Wilmington paper has the Philadelphia Ledger’s summary: Custer, fifteen officers and all the men of five companies, about 300, killed by some 5000 Indians in a narrow ravine near the Little Horn. Dispatches from Montana add that his two brothers, his nephew and his brother-in-law died with him, that two hundred and seven men were buried in one place, and that the field ‘looked like a slaughter pen’.

Wilmington Daily Commercial · Wilmington, Del.

CorrectionThis set right 2 earlier articles: Helena Weekly Herald, 29 June 1876, Helena Weekly Herald, 29 June 1876.

Wilmington Daily Commercial · 6 July 1876 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

Tremendous Indian Battle.

RUMORED DEFEAT OF THE U. S. TROOPS AND KILLING OF GEN. CUSTER.

See moreSee less

The Philadelphia Ledger's news summary, this morning, says: Advices have been received from both Boseman and Stillwater, in Montana, of a battle on the 25th ult., between General Custer's force and about 5000 Indians, near the Little Horn river, in which Custer and fifteen officers and all the men of five companies of soldiers, about 300 in number, were killed. The fight occurred in a narrow ravine. The news is received just as we go to press.

DISPATCHES GIVING THE PARTICULARS.

SALT LAKE, July 5.—A special correspondent of the Helena, Mont., Herald writes from Stillwater, Montana, July 2: Muggins Taylor, scout for General Gibben, got here last night direct from Little Horn river. General Custer found an Indian camp of 2,000 lodges on Little Horn, and immediately attacked the camp. Custer took five companies and charged the thickest portion of the camp. Nothing is known of the operations of the detachment, only as they trace it by the dead. Major Reno commanded the other seven companies, and attacked the lower portion of the camp. The Indians poured in a murderous fire from all directions; besides, the greater portion fought on horseback. Custer, his two brothers, and nephew and brother-in-law were all killed, and not one of his detachment escaped. Two hundred and seven men were buried in one place, and the killed are estimated at 300 with only 31 wounded. The Indians surrounded Reno's command and held them one day in the hills cut off from water, until Gibbon's command came in sight, when they broke camp in the night and left.

SALT LAKE, UTAH, July 5.—A Times despatch from Boseman, Montana, July 3d, says: "Mr. Taylor, bearer of despatches from the Little Horn to Fort Ellis, arrived this evening, and reports the following:

The battle was fought on the 25th, thirty or forty miles below the Little Horn. Custer attacked the Indian village of from 2,500 to 4,000 warriors on one side, and Colonel Reno was to attack it on the other. Three companies were placed on a hill as a reserve. General Custer and fifteen officers and every man belonging to five companies were killed. Reno retreated under the protection of the reserve. The whole number killed was 315. General Gibbon joined Reno. The Indians left the battle ground which looked like a slaughter pen, as it really was, being in a narrow ravine. The dead were much mutilated.

See the clipping

‘The 7th fought like tigers’

The Tribune prints Muggins Taylor’s report as he told it, having been over the field: the whole Custer family ‘died at the head of their column,’ and seventeen commissioned officers fell, both adjutants among them. The Indians took all the dead soldiers’ arms, carried off and cached most of their own dead, and in places pulled men off their horses. Lieut. Crittenden, son of Gen. Crittenden, is among the killed.

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

New-York Tribune · 6 July 1876 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

FEARFUL MASSACRE BY INDIANS. GEN. CUSTER KILLED, HE CHARGES A LARGE CAMP OF INDIANS WITH COMPANIES OF CAVALRY—EVERY MAN KILLED, 315 IN NUMBER—RETREAT OF RENO. SALT LAKE, Utah, July 5.—The special correspondent of The Helena Montana Herald writes from Stillwater, Montana, under date of July 2, as follows: "Muggins Taylor, a scout for Gen. Gibbon, arrived here last night direct from Little Horn River, and reports that Gen. Custer found the Indian camp of 2,000 lodges on the Little Horn, and immediately attacked it. He charged t[h]e thickest portion of the camp with five companies; nothing is known of the operations of this detachment except their course as traced by the dead.

See moreSee less

Major Reno commanded the other seven companies, and attacked the lower portion of the camp. The Indians poured a murderous fire from all directions. Gen. Custer, his two brothers, his nephew, and brother-in-law, were all killed, and not one of his detachment escaped. Two hundred and seven men were buried in one place. The number of killed is estimated at 300, and the wounded at 31. The Indians surrounded Major Reno's command and held them one day in the hills cut off from water, until Gibbon's command came no's Gibbon's command came in sight, when they broke camp in the night and left. The 7th fought like tigers and were overcome by mere brute force. The Indian loss cannot be estimated, as they bore off and cached most of their killed. The remnant of the 7th Cavalry and Gibbon's command are returning to the mouth of the Little Horn, where a steamboat lies. The Indians got all the arms of the killed soldiers. There were seventeen commissioned officers killed. The whole Custer family died at the head of their column. The exact loss is not known as both Adjutants and the Sergeant-Major were killed. The Indian camp was from three to four miles long, and was twenty miles up the Little Horn from its mouth. The Indians actually pulled men off their horses in some instances. This report is given as Taylor told it, as he was over the field after the battle. The above is confirmed by other letters, which say Gen. Custer has met with a fearful disaster. The Times publishes a dispatch from Boseman, Montana Territory, dated July 3, 7 p. m., saying, that Mr. Taylor, bearer of dispatches from Little Horn to Fort Ellis, arrived this evening and reports the following: The battle was fought on the 25th of June, 30 or 40 miles below the Little Horn. Gen. Custer attacked an Indian village of from 2,500 to 4,000 warriors on one side and Col. Reno was to attack it on the other side. Three companies were placed on a hill as a reserve. Gen. Custer and 13 officers and every man belonging to the five companies were killed. Reno retreated under the protection of the reserve. The whole number killed was 315. Gen. Gibbon joined Reno. When the Indians left the battle-field looked like a slaughter-pen, as it really was, being in a narrow ravine. The dead were much mutilated. The situation now looks serious. Gen. Terry arrived at Gibbon's camp on a steamboat, and crossed the command over and accompanied it to join Custer, who knew it was coming before the fight occurred. Lieut. Crittenden, son of Gen. Crittenden, was among the killed.

See the clipping

Sheridan doubts the story, then hears from Terry

In Philadelphia General Sheridan tells the Herald the story is ‘so incredible that he could not believe it.’ By afternoon a confidential dispatch from Terry confirms Custer’s death, though Sheridan reads its talk of stretchers for the wounded as proof there was no complete massacre. Terry’s impression is that Custer made a dash without waiting for support and had ‘thrown himself upon the main body of the Sioux.’

The New York Herald · New York, N.Y.

CorrectionThis set right an article from the day before.

The New York Herald · 7 July 1876 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

THE MASSACRE.

The Gallant Cavalry Leader's Death Officially Confirmed.

See moreSee less

AN INTERVIEW WITH GENERAL SHERIDAN.

“A Mistake, for Which He Paid the Penalty of His Life.”

PHILADELPHIA, July 6, 1876.

As soon as your correspondent heard of the disaster to our troops he visited Lieutenant General Philip H. Sheridan, who is here at the meeting of the Army of the Cumberland. The distinguished officer received the HERALD representative with great courtesy, and said he had read the painful narrative in the morning papers.

Your correspondent asked the General whether he had any news from the field, to which the General replied that he had no news at all. The whole thing was a surprise to him, a mystery, and so incredible that he could not believe it. He was the more surprised because the news came in such a roundabout way. Why were there no narratives in the New York papers from the special correspondents?

Your correspondent called attention to the full despatches that had appeared in the HERALD from the command of Crook, and said that, perhaps, some accident had happened to the scout.

Here another officer called attention to the name of the scout who was reported in the despatch as bringing in the news. His reputation was not such as would justify any one in accepting his story without reserve.

"More than that," said General Sheridan, "if you will analyze the despatch you will see that it comes without any of the marks of credence. It does not come to Headquarters. It does not come to the leading papers from special correspondents. It is not given to the press for telegraphing, but appears first in a Salt Lake and Montana paper. These scouts on the frontier have a way of spreading news, and all frontier stories, especially about Indian wars, are to be very carefully considered."

Your correspondent asked the General if he gave no credence to the news. The General answered that the story was so horrible that he could only accept it when it came officially. Anyhow, when the truth was known, even looking at it from the worst side, it would be found less alarming than is here printed.

Your correspondent asked the General whether his latest news from the expedition gave him any cause for apprehension.

AN INCREDIBLE FEATURE.

The General said that the march as described was the march General Custer intended to make, but even if Custer had fallen into an engagement there would not have been the slaughter here described. That is the incredible feature of the story, A fight was probable and a defeat possible, but no such defeat as is here described.

"When did you last hear from General Custer?" asked your correspondent.

The General said he last heard from Terry on June 21. Terry is in command of the expedition. He was then north of the Rosebud. He had discovered signs of a fresh Indian camp, showing that Indians were in that vicinity. It was his plan then to send General Custer, with his twelve companies of cavalry up the Rosebud and to cross from there over to the Little Horn. You will see from this despatch that the courier reports that it was on the Little Horn that the action is said to have taken place. While Custer was marching up the Rosebud to the Little Horn Terry went with a steamer to the junction of the Big Horn and Little Horn, and ferried General Gibbons' command to the south side of the Yellowstone. You see the Little Horn empties into the Big Horn, and that into the Yellowstone. It was then the purpose of Gibbons to march up the Big Horn and, meet Custer, who was coming down. All of this confirming certain features of the news, makes me regard the report with anxiety, but still I am in hopes that it is not true, and at the worst an exaggeration. If true the news should have come more directly.

The General then left to preside over the meeting of the Army of the Cumberland.

THE NEWS.

About three o'clock your correspondent called on the General again, and found him at his room in the Continental. Several officers were with him, and he was reading a long despatch from General Terry. After he had concluded he said, with much feeling, that his news from General Terry confirmed the reports to a certain extent, still they were imperfect despatches with allusions to a report of the details of the action that was on the way, and he had telegraphed for it. Until he received this he could not say what the disaster had been.

Your correspondent asked if this was an official despatch.

The General said it was not. Only a confidential despatch which it was his duty to send to General Sherman. It seems that there was an action, that Custer attacked the Indians, who outnumbered and defeated him, and he was killed.

Your correspondent asked if this despatch confirmed the death of Custer.

STRETCHERS FOR THE WOUNDED.

Yes; Terry says that in so many words. But he also speaks of sending up stretchers for the wounded, which, as I said this morning, shows that there were wounded, and, not as the despatch shows, a complete massacre. It shows that our troops were able to rescue their wounded and retreat with them. The Indian always kills. The fact that Terry speaks of caring for the wounded shows that there was no such complete destruction of the command of Custer. But beyond Custer's death I have no news nor names of the wounded, no details of the action. Those may come at any time.

THE RESPONSIBILITY.

Your correspondent ventured to inquire whether the General had any information as to the cause or the responsibility of the disaster.

The General said, with sorrowful feeling, that it was too soon to pass any judgment upon an action of this extent. It would be unfair to the memory of Custer or of any soldier who loses his life in battle to pass an opinion until the whole story was known. Custer was a gallant, daring man, who knew the Indian country well, who had served against various tribes, and who, in addition to his natural ability and courage, had special experience. The same could be said of General Crook, who was famous for his Indian knowledge.

HOW IT LOOKS.

It now looks, at least that is the impression made upon the mind of General Terry, as if Custer found himself with his command in presence of the Sioux; that without waiting for reserves or reinforcements, or even for the co-operation of the other portions of the command, he made a dash. Instead of capturing and destroying a village, as he probably expected, he found that he had thrown himself upon the main body of the Sioux, 2,000 at least, if our information is accurate. Hence the disaster. This is what General Terry thinks from his information. I only repeat that to you as his opinion, not more. He has all the facts; I merely have his conclusions. That is the situation now. Custer is said to have made this mistake—and a mistake it was, all the more surprising in one who knew the Indian so well—but he pays the penalty with his life.

OUR INDIAN POLICY.

Beyond this general idea of the contents of the Terry despatch, the General would not go. He spoke of Custer with feeling and regard. The conversation then ran into our policy in dealing with the Indians. General Sheridan said that the truth was, the army was made to carry out the purposes of the government in the Indian country by reason of its weakness.

"I have," he said, "sent every man I could spare into that region, even taking troops from Laramie and Salt Lake. The government, in its wisdom, directs the doing of certain things in these regions. It directs an expedition like this of Terry, an expedition necessary for the development of that country. We do the best we can with our material, but we are in no condition to do the work required of us."

An officer present said with some fervor that this was one of the results of the policy of the democratic House, which invited Indian defeats by cutting down the army.

General Sheridan said that of course his business was with the army, not with politics, and he did not wish to be understood as criticising any branch of the government. It was a question which admitted of no political construction, a question of the peace, the efficiency and the growth of the country, and that should interest democrats as well as republicans, and so long as they had army work to do they should have an army to do it, otherwise there would be these disasters.

Your correspondent asked if Red Cloud and Spotted Tail were with these Sioux.

The General said "No." His last advices from these chiefs showed that they were on good terms with the whites. "It is not these chiefs," he continued, "who make these wars, but the young men of the tribe. When peace or war is the question the Bucks will always go forth if the old chiefs try to sway them from it, but they lose their authority."

The General had an engagement to meet the Society of the Army of the Cumberland, and promised to see your correspondent at midnight and give him any additional news.

See the clipping

Sherman is handed the confirmation mid-interview

General Sherman doubts the dispatch, believing there cannot be more than 1,000 Sioux in that country. As he explains why official word should have come first, a telegram from Sheridan arrives confirming Custer’s death. The campaign, he insists, is at the Indian Department’s request, to drive the Indians onto the reservation: ‘we will do it now, or exterminate them.’

The New York Herald · New York, N.Y.

The New York Herald · 7 July 1876 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

INTERVIEW WITH GENERAL SHERMAN.

Philadelphia, July 6, 1876.

See moreSee less

General Sherman was found taking his ease in his inn, at the Transcontinental Hotel, with coats and boots thrown aside, sitting in an easy-chair by the window-side, fanning himself. He received the Herald correspondent with his usual simple courtesy, and anticipated that gentleman's own words by asking.

"Is it true? What news have you got? What about Custer?"

The correspondent told him that nothing further had been received than had been published, and asked his opinion of the truth of the despatch.

"It seems almost too terrible to be entirely true. It must be exaggerated. I cannot believe that Custer and his whole command would be swept away. I don't think there were enough Indians there to do it like that. I'll bet,'" said the old warrior earnestly, "that if it is so there was a pile of dead on the Indian side. Custer's line of march, however, was to be just as the report says, and that tends to confirm it."

"What is the latest official information you have as to the situation there?"

"General Terry left Fort Abe Lincoln, striking for the Powder River and the valley of the Yellowstone. A boat was sent at the same time up through the Yellowstone with provisions and supplies. He encountered no Indians, and reported all well on the 21st of June, when he received a messenger from General Gibbon, informing him that Gibbon was on his way from Fort Ellis to meet him, but could not cross the Yellowstone, because the stream was too high to ford, and that Gibbon intended to send Custer up the Rosebud to its source with instructions to cross the country to the Little Horn, which he was to follow to where it joined the Big Horn, twenty miles from the Yellowstone. By way of this detour he was to come back to the Yellowstone, striking it at the Big Horn junction, which Gibbon could have reached by that time. This battle is reported just where Custer would have been likely to be. The steamboat would have gone up after Gibbon had used it to bring over his troops at the mouth of the Big Horn."

GENERAL SHERMAN'S EXPLANATION.

General Sherman explained that Terry started from Fort Lincoln with 1,500 men to march to the junction of the Big Horn with the Yellowstone (a distance of about 400 miles from Fort Buford), where he was to meet Gibbon, with 500 men, coming from Helena, by way of Ellis, the nearest post, Ellis being 200 miles from the Big Horn junction. Custer left Terry at the Rosebud river, with a full regiment of 1,200 men, to make a detour around by the Little Horn. It was near where the Little Horn empties into the Big Horn that he was surprised by the Indians and the massacre took place. This is only about twenty miles from the Yellowstone, where Gibbon and Terry were waiting for him to join them, so that they were a few hours' march of Custer's command when the massacre occurred. Where Crook's battle took place, described in to-day's Herald, cannot be much more than 100 miles from where Custer was killed, according to General Sherman's calculation.

"One reason why I think the account published is exaggerated," said the General, "is because we have yet received no official information. It would be the duty of the officer in command at Ellis, even if he were only a sergeant—for only a small garrison would be there, General Gibbon taking the cavalry at this post with him—I say the first duty of the officer left in command of this garrison would be to telegraph to Bozeman City, in Montana, 150 miles distant; thence to Montana City, 350 miles away. The despatch would be sent first to General Sheridan, who would forward it at once to me."

Even while the General was finishing this sentence there was a rap at the door, and a telegram was brought to him. It was from General Sheridan, announcing that the death of Custer was confirmed, but that no details were yet received. The despatch further stated that Terry was at the junction of the Big Horn, and was "all right." General Sherman inferred from the last assertion that Terry had Custer's wounded, and that in a very short time we shall have the full story of the battle from their lips.

MANNER OF FIGHTING.

The Herald correspondent asked why Custer was ordered to make the detour up the Rosebud.

The General replied that it was frequently done in fighting Indians. "It is the best plan to divide so as to try and find their camp. The Indians rarely fight near their camps, where they leave their women and old men to guard their property. If you can surprise their camp and get the women and property out you soon get the men and bring them to terms. We conquered the Kiowas and the Comanches in the same way. We hemmed them in and caught them by finding their camps. There were good military reasons for Custer making this detour. He probably had his own good reasons for weakening his force by sending Major Reno around the Indian camp with seven companies. That was probably intended to cut off their retreat after the attack had been made."

"How many Sioux do you think there are in that country, and what kind of land is it, physically?"

"It is mauvaises terres, the worst kind of bad land. It is full of ravines, barren and water washed, poor soil, but with a little grass in the valleys. As to the numbers of Sioux there we have but little means of knowing, but, I think, there can't be more than 1,000."

REASONS FOR THE CAMPAIGN.

"What were the reasons for this campaign?"

"That is something I am very anxious you should say to the Herald, because I want it understood. We are doing this at the special request of the Indian Department. It does not originate with the War Department at all. You will see on my map where the Indian Reservation is. Our purpose is to drive these Indians, who are of the very wildest and most savage sort, down on the reservation. Montana," said the General, enthusiastically, "is the most promising of our Territories. It is settled by an intelligent people, among whom are many old soldiers, and it is the richest and most promising of our settlements. These Indians have been annoying the settlers, and we are to drive them down on the reservation. You can say that we will do it now, or exterminate them."

Speaking of the character of the soldiers the General said that the officers of Crook's, Terry's and Gibbons' armies are the best Indian fighters in the service. "General Crook has had thirty years' experience in Indian wars, and he suppressed the troubles in Arizona, Washington Territory and Idaho. The Herald is too severe in its criticism to-day."

See the clipping

The Herald lays Custer’s death at Grant’s door

A Herald editorial calls the Sioux campaign ‘a blunder and a muddle’ and blames President Grant, who it says degraded Custer for testifying against Belknap and so drove him to court a heroic death. Of Grant’s hands it says ‘they are red with the blood of Custer.’ It closes by asking whether Governor Hayes will break with the administration.

The New York Herald · New York, N.Y.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The New York Herald · 7 July 1876 · page 6 · transcribed from the page image

The Slaughter Near the Little Horn River—Death of General Custer.

The appalling news which reached this city at three o'clock yesterday morning and appeared in a later edition of the Herald, and of which we give fuller details to-day, is of a character to "give us pause" and raise the inquiry whether the present war against the Sioux was wisely undertaken and well planned. We had reason to expect something better under a President who is a great soldier and has himself had experience in the Indian country, and whose most important subordinate in connection with Indian affairs is the illustrious Sheridan, an old and successful fighter against the savages, charged with a general superintendence and direction of military affairs in the present theatre of hostilities. Matters have become so serious that it may be necessary for General Sheridan himself to go in person to the scene of action, for it is too evident that the campaign is a blunder and a muddle, if indeed it be not a disgrace. We cannot believe that General Sheridan is directly responsible for these shocking fiascos in his military department. He is a subordinate officer, and if he has committed any fault or is chargeable with any neglect it is in too implicit a deference to the wishes or orders of President Grant, the Commander-in-Chief of the Army. But it is unfortunate and deplorable that with an officer of General Sheridan's consummate ability and special experience in command of that department the country has not had the advantage of his skill and efficiency. "Some one has blundered," and there are strong grounds for ascribing the mismanagement to President Grant himself. In a fit of pique or spite he degraded General Custer, and we behold the result in the bloody massacre near the Little Horn which sends a thrill of horror through the country.

See moreSee less

The brave Custer, the best Indian fighter in the army next to Sheridan, may have been rash in the desperate encounter in which he and his three hundred comrades dared death and scalping and met their fate, but we must treat his memory with indulgence. Not the famous six hundred in the charge of the Light Brigade at Balaklava, when

Boldly they rode, and well, Into the jaws of death, Into the mouth of hell,

performed a more signal act of uncalculating heroism than the dashing Custer and his Seventh regiment of cavalry. The country will give him its admiration, its tears, its regrets; it will pardon his error, if he committed one, and inscribe his name in bright letters on the roll of fame. For the planning of this mismanaged, ill-starred campaign he was not responsible. It was at first intended that he should command it, and in that case the details would have been committed to his discretion and experience. But in an evil hour the President, acting on an unworthy impulse, displaced and degraded the brave Custer, putting him in so subordinate a position that the campaign lost the benefit of his counsels and direction. The result was a blundering and disjointed plan of operations; its first fruit the surprise, repulse and retreat of General Crook and his army; the second fruit is seen in the scalps of three hundred and fifteen fallen soldiers dripping with blood at the belts of Sioux warriors. Some one may have blundered at the Little Horn; but this was merely one consequence of the parent blunder perpetrated by President Grant when, in a fit of undignified wrath and petulance, he degraded General Custer after the latter had given his testimony in the matter of the post-traderships in obedience to the subpoena of a committee of Congress, and did not thereupon require General Sheridan to take immediate direction of the Indian campaign. But it would have been too great a compliment to Custer to assume that nobody but Sheridan could usefully replace him, and so the President committed the expedition to incompetent hands, with the result which we see.

General Custer's desperate hardihood in riding "into the jaws of death, into the mouth of hell," was a natural consequence of the treatment he had received from the President. The honor of a soldier is "the immediate jewel of his heart." When his honor is impugned, when a stigma is publicly set upon him, in the face of the whole country, by his commander-in-chief, he is subjected to a torture such as only a soldier or a man of extreme moral sensitiveness who "feels a stain like a wound" can fully understand. Civilians are sometimes tempted to smile at the excessive punctiliousness of army officers about questions of precedence and relative standing; but it must be considered that honor and estimation are the chief reward of the military class, and that it is to their eager craving for distinction that the world is indebted for the illustrious acts of heroism which emblazon the pages of history. If the intense, excruciating smart of soldiers under disgrace be a fault it is a "failing which leans to virtue's side." General Custer was a man whose mental organization made him peculiarly vulnerable to the sting of disgrace. It is only an impetuous man of quick and almost boiling sensibilities that can make such a bold, dashing cavalry officer as General Custer had shown himself to be. It is in the nature of such a man to be elated by marks of honor and appreciation, and to be plunged into desperation and despair by a public stigma fixed upon him by a superior whose acts it is not permitted him to question. General Custer went into the campaign, from the expected command of which he had been harshly degraded, with his heart torn by a keen sense of injustice and with an apparent determination to retrieve his standing by some splendid act of successful daring or die the kind of death which hallows the memory of a soldier in the hearts of his countrymen. Had he been in command of the campaign a sense of responsibility would have restrained and tempered his impetuosity. But this brave soldier had been rendered desperate by ill usage, and when "death was set in one eye and honor in the other" he courted a heroic death rather than endure the disgrace which the cold malignity of the President had attempted to put upon him. It would be hardly too severe to say to President Grant, "Behold your hands! they are red with the blood of Custer and his brave three hundred."

The sun of General Grant's administration seems to be going down in an eclipse. Alike in its earlier and in its later stages, it is an expression of the personal humors of the President; but his earlier humors were more amiable and kindly. So long as he remained the chief object of popular favor he had a hearty enjoyment of his position, and it seemed to be his wish to make every creature connected with him by blood, marriage or friendship the sharer of his good fortune. This showed an inadequate sense of his great public trust, but if it was selfish it was an amiable selfishness. Since the disappointment of his cherished hopes of a third nomination his temper has undergone a change. The spirit of indulgent nepotism has been supplanted by a fell spirit of revenge, and his chief delight seems to be in punishing all who have been in any way instrumental in thwarting his hopes. He degraded poor Custer because Custer testified to the truth of the charges against Belknap. He insisted on the dismissal of Yaryan because Yaryan was active in ferreting out the whiskey frauds which came so near lodging Babcock in a penitentiary. He is taking steps for the dismissal of other officers who assisted ex-Secretary Bristow in his successful efforts to expose and punish official peculation and thereby made it impossible for Grant to lay his hands for a third time on the coveted prize. Whether in good humor or in bad humor President Grant is equally selfish and equally oblivious to the obligations of his public trust; but his good-natured nepotism was not so discreditable as his ill-natured spleen and petulance against all who have obstructed the path of his ambition. His kindness to the Dents seems better than his relentless malignity toward a valuable and truthful officer like Custer.

President Grant is ending in a worse spirit than he began, and the country, accordingly, awaits with deep interest the letter of acceptance of Mr. Hayes. Will he indorse this administration, or will he boldly wash his hands of it? The citizens of this Republic are anxious to learn whether Grantism will end with the retirement of Grant, or whether Governor Hayes, if elected President, will sail the ship by the same compass and the same political chart. The country will stand anything rather than a prolonged reign of Grantism. On this point Governor Hayes must leave the people in no doubt. If he lacks the courage or the sagacity or the independence to tell the country unequivocally that he will put the administration on a new course he will miss that "tide in the affairs of men" which leads on to fortune.

See the clipping

Washington waits, then Chicago confirms

The report struck Washington with ‘almost nervous amazement’, the National Republican says: neither the War Department nor the Indian office had any word, and Secretary Cameron and Generals Sherman and Sheridan were away in Philadelphia. Late in the afternoon a telegram from R. C. Drum in Chicago reached the chief clerk, H. D. Crosby: General Terry’s dispatches of July 2 confirmed the fight and Custer’s death. The Indians, the paper concludes, show a boldness and discipline that may well surprise.

National Republican (Washington City) · D.C.

National Republican (Washington City) · 7 July 1876 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

The Custer Slaughter.

The very startling report of Custer's repulse and the entire destruction of his gallant cavalry force by Indians, printed in The Republican yesterday, caused a profound sensation in all quarters throughout this city yesterday. The War Department as well as the Indian office was without advices indicating a possible event of this character, and so sudden came the news of the terrible disaster that it struck every one with almost nervous amazement. Inquiries were anxiously made at the War Department for further particulars, but as none had been received by the authorities here, of course none could be given.

See moreSee less

Secretary Cameron, General Sherman and Lieutenant General Sheridan were in Philadelphia, in attendance upon the meeting of the Army of the Cumberland, and, as it was believed that dispatches received at Gen. Sheridan's headquarters in St. Louis would be forwarded to him in Philadelphia, and probably might not reach this city, yesterday a telegram asking for particulars was sent by Adjutant General Townsend and also by Mr. Crosby, the chief clerk of the War Department. Throughout the day it was hoped that the reports were idle, or else that they were vastly exaggerated, but dispatches late in the afternoon put an end to such aspirations, and rendered vain the impression that the scout's story may have been the result of too vivid an imagination mixed with a wholesome scare. The sad message that gave confirmation to the reports came to Mr. Crosby late in the afternoon, and is as follows:

Chicago, July 6, 1876.

H. D. Crosby, War Department, Washington:

Dispatches from General Terry, dated at his camp, mouth of Big Horn. July 2, confirm the newspaper reports of a fight on the 25th of June on the Little Big Horn, and of Custer's death. Terry has fallen back to his present camp. I have sent full dispatches to the Lieutenant General, who will probably communicate them. I have not yet received General Terry's report of the action, nor a list of the casualties.

R. C. Drum, A. A. G.

Full dispatches are, of course, awaited with the utmost anxiety, and every one is wondering to what extent the Indian war will go. They seem well prepared in every particular, and upon their native heath evince a savage boldness, organisation and discipline that well may be taken as a source of surprise.

See the clipping

Smoke on the horizon, taken for victory

A dispatch from the mouth of the Big Horn tells how three badly frightened Crow scouts brought word of the battle and were not believed. All day Terry’s men watched a cloud of smoke to the south, hailed as Custer firing the village. Next morning they found funeral lodges holding nine dead chiefs, Reno’s men cheering them from their bluff, and Custer on the highest point of the ridge, his brothers, nephew and officers within a few yards of him.

The New York Herald · New York, N.Y.

The New York Herald · 8 July 1876 · page 5 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

CUSTER IN DEATH

ANOTHER ACCOUNT OF THE MASSACRE. Chicago, July 7, 1876. The following account of the Custer massacre has been received here:— Sioux Expedition, Mouth of the Big Horn, July 1, Via Bismarck, D. T., July 6, 1876. Long before the arrival of this despatch you will have heard of the tragedy which has been enacted here. The ghastly detail would seem to court oblivion, if it were in the nature of things possible to forget or cloak them up. At noon on the 22d day of June, General Custer, at the head of his fine regiment of twelve veteran companies, left camp at the mouth of the Rosebud to follow the trail of a very large band of hostile Sioux leading up the river and westward in the direction of the Big Horn.

See moreSee less

The signs indicated that the Indians were making for the western branch of the last named river, marked on the map as the Little Big Horn. At the same time General Terry, with Gibbon's command of five companies of infantry, four of cavalry and the Gatlin battery, started to ascend the Big Horn, aiming to assail the enemy in the rear. The march of the two columns was so planned as to bring Gibbon's forces within co-operating distance of the anticipated scene of action by the evening of the 26th. In this way only could the infantry be made available, as it would not do to encumber Custer's march with foot soldiers. On the evening of the 24th Gibbon's command was landed on the south bank of the Yellowstone, near the mouth of the Big Horn, and on the 25th was pushed twenty-three miles over a country so rugged that the endurance of the men was tasked to the uttermost. The infantry then halted for the night, but the Department Commander, with the cavalry, advanced twelve miles further to the mouth of the Little Big Horn, marching until midnight, in the hope of opening communication with Custer. NEWS OF CUSTER'S FIGHT. The morning of the 26th brought the intelligence, communicated by three badly frightened Crow scouts, of the battle of the previous day and its results. The story was not credited, because it was not expected that an attack would be made earlier than the 27th, and chiefly because no one could believe that a force such as Custer commanded could have met with disaster. Still the report was in no way disregarded. All day long the toilsome march was plied, and every eye bent upon a cloud of smoke resting over the southern horizon, which was hailed as a sign that Custer was successful and had fired the village. It was only when night was falling that the weary troops lay down upon their arms. The infantry had marched twenty-nine miles. The march of the next morning revealed at every step some evidence of the conflict which had taken place two days before. ON THE BATTLE GROUND. At an early hour the head of the column entered a plain half a mile wide, bordering the left bank of the Little Big Horn, where had recently been an immense Indian village extending three miles along the stream, and where were still standing funeral lodges with horses slaughtered around them, and containing the bodies of nine chiefs. The ground was strewn everywhere with carcasses of horses, cavalry equipments, besides buffalo robes, packages of dried meat and weapons and utensils belonging to the Indians. On this part of the field was found the clothing of Lieutenants Sturges and Porter, pierced with bullets, and a bloodstained gauntlet belonging to Colonel Yates. Further on were found bodies of men, among whom were recognized Lieutenant McIntosh, the interpreter from Fort Rice, and Reynolds, the guide. RENO DISCOVERED. Just then a breathless scout arrived with the intelligence that Colonel Reno, with a remnant of the Seventh Cavalry, was intrenched on a bluff near by, waiting for ence bluff near by, waiting for relief. The command pushed rapidly on and soon came in sight of a group surrounding a cavalry guard upon a lofty eminence on the right bank of the river. General Terry forded the stream, accompanied by a small party, and rode to the spot. All the way the slopes were dotted with the bodies of men and horses. The General approached and the men swarmed out of the works and greeted him with hearty and repeated cheers. Within was found Reno with the remains of seven companies of the regiment, with the following named officers, all of whom are unhurt:— OFFICERS WITH RENO. Colonel Benteen. Colonel Weir. Captain Felix. Captain Maylan. Captain McDougal. Lieutenant Godfrey. Lieutenant Mathey. Lieutenant Gibson. Lieutenant Dernded. Lieutenant Edgerly. Lieutenant Wallace. Lieutenant Varnum. Lieutenant Hare. In the centre of the enclosure was a depression in the surface, in which the wounded were sheltered, covered with canvas. Reno's command had been fighting from Sunday noon, the 25th, until the night of the 26th, when Terry's arrival caused the Indians to retire. Up to this time Reno and those with him were in complete ignorance of the fate of the other five companies, which had been separated from them on the 25th to make an attack under Custer on the village at another point. ON CUSTER'S TRAIL. While preparations were being made for the removal of the wounded a party was sent on Custer's trail to look for traces of his command. They found awaiting them a sight fit to appal the stoutest heart. At a point about three miles down the right bank of the stream Custer had evidently attempted to ford and attack the village from the ford. The trail was found to lead back up to the bluffs and to the northward, as if the troops had been repulsed and compelled to retreat and at the same time had been cut off from regaining the forces under Reno. The bluffs along the right bank come sharply down to the water and are interspersed by numerous ravines all along the slopes and ridges, and in the ravines, lying as they had fought, line behind line, showing where defensive positions had been successively taken up and held till none were left to fight, there, huddled in a narrow compass, horses and men were piled promiscuously. CUSTER IN DEATH. At the highest point of the ridge lay Custer, surrounded by a chosen band. Here were his two brothers and his nephew, Mr. Reed; Colonels Yates and Cooke, and Captain Smith, all lying in a circle of a few yards, their horses beside them. Here, behind Yates' company, the last stand had been made, and here, one after another, these last survivors of Custer's five companies had met their death. The companies had successively thrown themselves across the path of the advancing enemy and had been annihilated. Not a man has escaped to tell the tale, but it was inscribed on the surface of the barren hills in a language more eloquent than words. Two hundred and sixty-one bodies have been buried from Custer's and Reno's commands. The last one found was that of Mr. Kellogg, correspondent of the New York Herald. The following are the names of the officers whose remains are recognized:— THE DEAD. General Custer. Colonel Keogh. Colonel Yates. Colonel Custer. Colonel Cooke. Captain Smith. Lieutenant McIntosh. Lieutenant Calhoun. Lieutenant Hodgson. Lieutenant Reilly. All of these belonged to the Seventh cavalry. Lieutenant Crittenden, of the Twentieth infantry, was serving temporarily with the regiment. MISSING. Lieutenants Porter, Sturges and Harrington, and Assistant Surgeon Lord, are reported missing, as their remains were not recognized, but there is small ground to hope that any of them survived, as it is obvious that the troops were completely surrounded by a force of ten times their number. ALL THAT IS KNOWN. The history of Reno's operations comprises all that is now known of this sanguinary affair. It seems that Custer, with eight companies, reached the river in the forenoon of the 25th, having marched continuously all the previous day and night. Seeing the upper or southern extremity of the village, and probably underestimating its extent, he ordered Reno to ford the river and charge the village with three companies, while he, with five companies, moved down the right bank and estimating three companies, while he, with five companies, moved down the right bank and behind the bluff to make a similar attack at the other end. Reno made his charge, but finding that he was dealing with a force many times his own numbers dismounted his men and sought shelter in the timber which fringed the river bank. The position appearing to him untenable, he remounted and cut his way to the river, forded under a murderous fire, and gained the bluff, where he was subsequently found. Here he was afterward joined by Colonel Benteen with the three companies, which had just reached the field, and by Captain McDougall, with his company and the pack mules. The position was immediately after completely invested by the Indians, who, for more than twenty-four hours, allowed the garrison no rest and inflicted severe loss. But for the timely arrival of relief the command would have been cut off to a man. The number saved with Reno was 329, including fifty-one wounded. LOSS OF THE INDIANS. The loss among the Indians was probably considerable, as bodies have been found in every direction, and they left behind only a small portion of their dead. We remained nearly two days on the scene of this disaster to bury the dead and prepare for transporting the wounded to a place of safety. The neighboring country was still full of scattering bands of Indians watching our movements, and doubtless prepared to take advantage of any want of vigilance to add to the number of their victims. REMOVING THE WOUNDED. A species of rude horse litter was constructed of poles and strips of hide, and on these the disabled were carried twenty miles to the fork of the Big Horn, where they were placed board on the steamer, and last night they were brought down to the junction with the Yellowstone. To-morrow the steamer will convey the poor fellows to Fort Lincoln. In closing my hasty narrative of this affair, in certain respects the most remarkable in modern history, I purposely refrain from comment. The naked facts, so far as they are known, must guide your readers to a conclusion as to the causes of the calamity. STRENGTH OF THE INDIANS. Information derived from many sources, including, of course, the observations of officers engaged in the battle, leads to the conclusion that 2,500 or 3,000 Indians composed the fighting force arrayed against Custer and his 600. Still, these were odds which any officer of the Seventh cavalry would have unhesitatingly accepted for his regiment under any ordinary circumstances of Indian warfare, warfare. TERRY'S OPERATIONS. The force under General Terry's immediate command was designed not only to cut off the retreat of the Indians but to afford support to Custer if needed. Its march was made in accurate accordance with the plan communicated to each of the subordinate leaders before the movement commenced. It reached the point where the battle was expected at the time proposed, and had not the action been precipitated, for reasons which are as yet unknown, a force would have been present on the field sufficient to retrieve any repulse of the attacking column. GIBBON'S MOVEMENT. General Gibbon's cavalry followed the Indians for about ten miles, and ascertained that they had moved to the south and west by several trails. A good deal of property had been thrown away by them to lighten their march, and was found scattered for many miles over the prairies. Many of their dead were also discovered secreted in ravines a long distance from the battle field. Among them were Arapahoes and Cheyennes as well as Sioux.

See the clipping

Reno’s fight told, the dead listed by company

A dispatch from Little Horn, via Bismarck, says Custer’s body was not mutilated: ‘his face calm and a smile upon it.’ It tells of Reno’s retreat across the river, his men thirty-six hours without water, and says Sitting Bull commanded in person. From Chicago comes the official list of the dead, company by company: 14 officers, an acting surgeon, 237 enlisted men, five civilians and three Indian scouts.

The Cincinnati Daily Star · Cincinnati, Ohio

The Cincinnati Daily Star · 8 July 1876 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

THE INDIAN WAR.

Bodies of General Custer and His Comrades.

See moreSee less

A Thrilling Account of Reno's Fight.

Hand to Hand Conflict With Four or Five Indians to Every Soldier.

A Wild Scramble For Life Graphically Described.

Official List of the Killed

By American Press Association to the STAR.

NEW YORK, July 8.—No details regarding the Indian massacre have been received farther than are already published.

A special dispatch from Little Horn, via Bismarck, says: Custer's body was not mutilated when found, although the others were.

He lay as though asleep; his face calm and a smile upon it. Reno and his remnant of the Seventh Cavalry must also have fallen had not Gibbon appeared and rescued them. Nothing is known of the battle in which Custer and his comrades perished except what can be surmised from the appearances of the field.

Reno says he advanced upon the Indian village with his command and encountered but little resistance. He deployed on a plain between the bluff and the river. The first intimation of danger was the appearance of masses of Indians on the bluff on the left.

The Indians opened a heavy fire from the bluff and at the same time charged in front. The troops behaved gallantly, driving the Indians back, but the fire from the bluff was so severe that Reno's men were forced to ford the river.

He ordered them into the timber, where they dismounted to fight on foot. The Indians tried several times to dislodge them, but ineffectually. They charged back on ponies and on foot, and tried to work round to the rear, but Reno charged them through the timber.

The Indians pressed so hard and were so numerous that Reno ordered his men to mount and cut their way through. A wild scramble for life followed. It was every man for himself. The Indians charged on foot and made tremendous efforts to route the soldiers.

The fight was desperate and hand to hand. The Indians finally retired. The fighting continued at intervals till at night the troops were completely surrounded. At daylight on the 26th the battle was renewed, the Indians numbering two thousand to four thousand; Reno's command, barely four hundred.

His men were without water thirty-six hours and were desperate. The horses and the wounded men perishing for thirst, and water only two hundred yards off, but the ground was full of Indian sharpshooters on both sides of the river. Reno determined to get water at all hazards.

It was a hand to hand fight, one soldier having sometimes as many as five Indians upon him. The troops used their revolvers at short range. They dashed through the timber, crossed the river, and ascended the high bank opposite the Indians, meanwhile maintaining a deadly fire.

The slaughter near the ford was terrible; horses and men were shot and rolled down the bank into the river. Indians charged the high bank but were repulsed. They then began to draw off. It was evident that the large mass of Indians were somewhere else.

Reno then became more anxious about Custer, but his attention was soon occupied by a large body of Indians which was preparing to attack him.

It is believed some of the troops have been captured alive and tortured.

Hordes of squaws and old gray haired Indians were roaming over the battle field after the fight, killing and robbing the wounded. Six squaws were killed by the Reese Indian allies.

The Indians are estimated at three thousand. They fought Reno first, then finished Custer, then came back to finish Reno, but were frightened off by Gibbon's approach. Sitting Bull commanded in person. The chiefs carried the flags.

It is not believed that one of Custer's men escaped. They were surrounded by at least twenty-five hundred Indians. The list of casualties is as follows: Commissioned officers, 14; Acting Assistant Surgeon, 1; enlisted men, 238; Captains, 5; Indian scouts, 30; wounded, 42; besides many missing.

CHICAGO, July 8.—The official list of killed and wounded in the recent battles with the Sioux is as follows, of Field, Staff and Non-commissioned Officers:

Staff—G. A. Custer, Brevet Major General; W. W. Cooke, Brevet Lieutenant Colonel; — Lord, Assistant Sergeant; J. N. De Wolf, Acting Assistant Sergeant; W. H. Sharrow, Sergeant Major; Henry Boss, Chief Trumpeter.

Company A—Corporals Dolans and King; privates Armstrong, Drinaw, Moody, Rawlins, McDonal, Sullivan and Switzer.

Company B—Lieut. Hodgson; privates Dowan and Moss.

Company C—Capt. I. W. Custer, Lieut. H. W. Harrington; 1st sergeant, Failey; corporals French, Foley and Ryan; Privates—Allen, Crindle, King, Bucknall, Risnan, Engle, Right, Field, Taband, Griffin, Hornet, Hattisdall, Kingsautts, Loomis, Mayer, Phillips, Russell, Rix, Ranty, Short, Shea, Shode, Stuart, St. John, Sanellan, Thodix, Warren, Wishdhan, Wright.

Company D—Capt. Vincent Farrier; privates, Patrick, Golden, Edwards and Hansen.

Company E—Capt. A. E. Smith; Lieut. Sturgis; Sergeants Kohneyer, Edger and James; Corporal Hagen; privates, Miller, Tweed, Veller, Coshan, Keifer, Andrews, Cristield, Harrington, Pougge, Kavanagh, Labaring, Mahoney, Schmidt, Lemon, Hermanson, Riebold, O'Connelly, Butler, Warren, Harrison, Gilbert, Ziller, Wash, Ashley, Burk, Chever, McGuire, McCarthy, Logan, Maxwell, Scott, Babcock, Perkins, Tarbox, Dye, Tessier, Galvin, Graham, Hamilton, Snow, Hughes.

Company K—First Sergeant Winny, Sergeant Hughes, Corporal Callahan, Trumpeter Helene, Private Ed. St. Clair.

Company D—Captain S. N. Heagh, Lieutenant J. E. Porter, First Sergeant Varden, Sergeant Bustard, Corporal Wilde, Morris and Staples. Interpeters D. McGraeer, J. Pardan; Blacksmith Henry Bailey. Privates—Brand, Thurst, Barry, Connon, Downing, Mason, Blarn, Meyer. Trumpeters—McElroy and Mooney. Privates—Baker, Doyle, Bath, Conner, Daring, Farrell, Hilley, Haber, Hime, Henderson. First Lieutenant Henderson; Second Lieutenant Henderson. Privates—O'Connor, Rood, Smith, Stellar, Stafford, Schoob, Smallwood, Tarr, Vangant, Walker, Bragen, Knight.

Company F—Captain G. W. Yates, Lieutenant Bulley; First Sergeant Kenner; Sergeants Mysey, Viebarg, Wilkinson; Corporals Coleman, Freeman, Farriers, Broidy, Brandson, Licksmith, Manning; Private Atchinson: First Lieutenant, Brown; Second Lieutenant, Bruce. Privates, Brady, Burnham, Colter, Carney, Doran, Donnelly, Gardner, Hammond, Kline, Kryanth Lumar, Loose, Milton, Madison, Monroe, Ridden, Ometting, Sycioz, Saunders, Wanew, May, Lerock, Kelley, Driscoll, Giliat, Gross, Holcomb, Hoen, Hittisden, Fred. Lehman, Henry Lehman, Lloyd, Maccharge, Mitchell, Noshanny, O'Brien, Parker, Pitten, Post, Quinn, Reed, Rossburg, Symons, Troy, Van Bramer and Whalley.

Company G—Captain, Daniel McIntosh; Sergeants, Ba ziel and Colsidina; Corporals, Martin, Hagman, Wells, Farrey, Henry, Dopee; Trumpeters, Crawford and Lalley; Privates, Rogers, Monroe, McGinnis, Stanley, Stufferman, Pappe.

Company H—Privates Jones and Meady.

Company M—Sergeant C. Harris; Corporals Scottie and Stringer; privates Gordon, Klotzbursher, French, Myer, Smith, Sollys, Tanny, Tenley, Voight.

Lieut. John J. Crittenden; Civilians—Boston Custer, Arthur Reed, Mark Kellogg, Chas. Reynolds and Frank. C. Mann.

Indian scouts, Bloody Knife, Bobtailed Bull and Stab. Recapitulation—Commissioned officers killed, 14; acting surgeons, 1; enlisted men, 237; civilians, 5; Indian scouts, 3.

See the clipping

← Back to Act One: Up the Rosebud