As the Papers Told It

Little Bighorn · As the Papers Told It

Act Ten

Custer’s Last Fight

August 1893 – October 1905

Adolphus Busch gave the painting ‘Custer’s Last Fight’ to the Seventh Cavalry. A pay check made out to Custer on the day he died turned up in a Bismarck street. Six thousand Sioux kept the twentieth anniversary on the field. Comanche, years dead, went on living in newspaper paragraphs. The claimants kept coming, Custer’s ‘orderly’ among them, who was next heard of in 1904 under arrest after a quarrel over kidney stew. At Sheridan, Wyoming, fifteen hundred Crows and Cheyennes ‘annihilated’ 260 soldiers in a mock battle; a dying Sioux convert said he had killed Custer; and Rain-in-the-Face, ‘said to have personally killed General Custer,’ died in 1905.

A scout’s tribute: ‘a heart like a woman’s’

In South Berkeley, Josiah J. Rose, who says he scouted for Custer for nearly six years and is perhaps the only white man who saw the massacre, tells a San Francisco paper that the charges of cruelty were groundless. Custer was a strict disciplinarian, he says, but ‘a whole-souled man with a heart like a woman’s.’

Phillipsburg Herald · Phillipsburg, Kan. · and 5 other papers

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 5 days later. CorrectionThis set right an article from 6 days earlier.

Wrong

Phillipsburg Herald · 17 August 1893 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

A Scout's Tribute to Custer.

Living in comparative retirement in a neat cottage on Ashby avenue, in South Berkeley, is a man who enjoys the distinction of being, perhaps, the only white person who witnessed the massacre of General G. A. Custer and his little band of cavalrymen by hostile Sioux on the Little Big Horn River on June 25, 1876.

See moreSee less

Josiah J. Rose is the man. He spent nearly six years with General Custer as a scout, first entering the service in 1869, after Custer's restoration to his command. Custer was at that time suffering keen mental torture because of his suspension two years before for cruelty to his men and for having left his command without permission.

The charge of cruelty against Custer was, in Rose's opinion, absolutely groundless. This judgment is based upon his subsequent intercourse with the general in the Bad Lands of Dakota — a relationship which resulted in the discovery by Rose that Custer was "a whole-souled man with a heart like a woman's."

"I have often read, here and there, articles upon General Custer's character as a man and soldier," said the ex-scout to the writer. "Nearly all of these were incorrect, particularly those in which he was charged with being cruel and heartless towards his men, and all that sort of thing. Now I know he was a man with a big heart, kind and considerate. He was a strict disciplinarian, however, and this, no doubt, was the cause of the attacks upon him. But he was a thorough soldier, with a soldier's idea of duty and discipline. That cannot be regarded as a fault in a commanding officer on an expedition where the observance of all rules of army discipline is essential to safety and success."—San Francisco Chronicle.

See the clipping

A famous battle painting goes to Fort Riley

A Missouri paper reports that the oil painting ‘Custer’s Last Fight’ by Cassidy Adams is presented to the Seventh cavalry at Fort Riley as a gift from Adolphus Busch of St. Louis. Busch acquired it several years ago; it is the same canvas exhibited for about ten years in nearly all the large cities of the country.

Fair Play · Ste., Mo. · and 3 other papers

Fair Play · 6 April 1895 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

THE celebrated oil painting by Cassidy Adams, "Custer's Last Fight," was presented to the Seventh cavalry at Fort Riley, Kas., on the 28th, as a gift from Adolphus Busch, of St. Louis. The painting was acquired by Mr. Busch several years ago, and is the same that was exhibited for about ten years in nearly all the large cities of the country.

See the clipping

An unpaid $1,500 check to Custer

A Bismarck dispatch to the Chicago Record: a check for $1,500 to the order of Gen. George A. Custer, dated June 25 and signed by assistant paymaster B. L. Smith, is forwarded to Mrs. Custer. Michael Francis found it in the street last February, worn through at three creases and pasted together, never endorsed or presented, and still a valid claim.

The Frontier · O'Neill City, Neb. · and 2 other papers

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

The Frontier · 28 November 1895 · page 5 · transcribed from the page image

CHECK PAYABLE TO CUSTER.

Drawn the Day of the Massacre and Found at Bismarck, N. D.

See moreSee less

A recent dispatch to the Chicago Record from Bismarck, N. D., gives the following information: "The tragic death of Gen. Custer and his gallant men at the hands of the Sioux Indians in the massacre of the Little Big Horn, was recalled here this week by the forwarding to Mrs. Custer of a check for $1,500 drawn to the order of Gen. George A. Custer in 1876. The check is dated June 25, and signed by B. L. Smith, at that time assistant paymaster of the army. It was on June 25, 1876, that the massacre took place. The check is still unpaid, and soiled and tattered though it be, constitutes a valid claim against the government for the amount represented upon its face, which was no doubt intended as part payment of Gen. Custer's salary as an officer of the United States army. Where the check has been all these years no one knows, least of all Michael Francis, who found it in the street here last February, and who has retained it in his possession until now. When Francis picked up the bit of paper it was almost as legible as when it was drawn, but three heavy creases in it showed that it had been carried in a pocketbook until it had been worn through. The parts were joined together by narrow strips of paper pasted on the back, and the edges were somewhat soiled, as though the paper had at one time been dropped in the mud. No indorsement appears upon the back of the check, and the face shows the mark of no cancellation stamp, demonstrating that the check has never been presented for payment. The check was no doubt forwarded to the northwest before the news of the Custer massacre had reached Washington. Had it reached those in charge of the dead soldier's effects it would have been sent back at once in order that one payable to the heirs could have been sent on in its place. It has evidently been under shelter somewhere, and the chances are that it was mislaid last February and swept out into the street, where it was found by Mr. Francis."

See the clipping

Six thousand Sioux keep the anniversary

On the field itself, six thousand Sioux celebrate the twentieth anniversary of the destruction of Custer’s command, ‘the great event in their war history.’

Warren Sheaf · Warren, Minn. · and 5 other papers

CorrectionThis set right an article from 3 days earlier.

Warren Sheaf · 2 July 1896 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

Six thousand Sioux, the remnant of the most powerful fighters of the American Indians, celebrated at the scene of the massacre the great event in their war history—the 20th anniversary of the destruction of Custer's command on the Little Big Horn, June 25, 1876.

See the clipping

Comanche, dead since 1891, still in the papers

Paragraphs keep going round about Comanche, Custer’s horse, living out his days in a stall in South Dakota. The Detroit Free Press prints a letter from the chancellor of the University of Kansas to end them: Comanche died at Fort Riley in 1891, aged 31, and stands stuffed in the university museum. ‘Though dead, still liveth.’

Griggs Courier · Cooperstown, Dak. N.D. · and 3 other papers

Griggs Courier · 30 April 1897 · page 6 · transcribed from the page image

GEN. CUSTER'S HORSE.

Dead Several Years, But Items About Him Still Flourish.

See moreSee less

Almost every day newspaper readers see a paragraph telling how the government takes care of old Comanche, Custer's horse, the only survivor of the Custer massacre. The paragraph always tells how, by special order of the military authorities, Comanche is provided with a comfortable stall, fitted out especially for him, in South Dakota. No one, so the story goes, is allowed to ride him and he is not permitted to do any work whatever.

Then, as one writer put it feelingly a few days ago: "Riddled with bullets and scarred by saber wounds, his body speaks eloquently of the perilous duty once performed in his 22 years of service under the government. He will go down to history holding about as proud a place as that accorded to the gallant black charger that once carried Gen. Sheridan to the field in time to save the battle, 20 miles away."

Once this all might have been said with every indication of truth. The paragraph, however, with various additions and changes has made the grand rounds just as regularly as the good old sea serpent story. Still there must be an end to all things, and the Comanche paragraph ought to end after this letter:

"I mail you to-day picture of Comanche as he appeared in life. We do not possess any photograph of him as he appeared in his stall. He died from old age at Fort Riley, Kan., November 7, 1891, and was 31 years old. He belonged to the Seventh regiment of United States cavalry, and was cared for with great tenderness by the regiment. Upon his death he was skinned and mounted by Prof. Dyche, of this university, and placed in our museum.

"F. H. SNOW,

"Chancellor University of Kansas."

Thus it will be seen that, according to the newspapers, Comanche, though dead, still liveth. Perhaps it is because the man who writes the paragraph has not yet learned to distinguish between a stuffed and a live animal.—Detroit Free Press.

See the clipping

An orderly’s ride back to Reno

William H. McGee says he was Custer’s orderly, sent back to tell Reno ‘to wait 20 minutes more’; the trumpeter sent with him took a short cut and was riddled. His horse shot under him, he reached Reno, who said ‘Orderly, too late now.’ Half his story defends General Miles, whose ride under fire at the Bear Paw he saw.

The Manning Times · Manning, S.C. · and 1 other paper

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 6 days later.

Wrong

The Manning Times · 5 April 1899 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image

WITH MILES AND CUSTER.

An Orderly's Tale of Fighting Indians With the Two Famous Generals.

See moreSee less

IS THE ONLY SURVIVOR

Was With Custer the Day He Was Killed and Narrowly Missed His Command's Fate.

General Miles' Remarkable Bravery—Rode Across an Open Field Under the Fire of Eight Hundred Indians—A Sight Never to Be Forgotten—Resulted in His Promotion to a Brigadiership.

To a group of friends the other evening, William H. McGee, recalled some interesting reminiscences of the Custer massacre and of the fight in the Bear Paw, when General Miles captured the Nez Perces Indians under Chief Joseph.

Mr. McGee was General Custer's orderly on the day of the massacre and is the last man now living who saw that officer and is also the only survivor of the command with which Custer went forward, when he left Major Reno on that fateful morning of June 25, 1876.

"Yes," said he, "I was with Custer the day he was killed. I was his orderly that day and narrowly missed the tragic fate he and his command met at the hands of Sitting Bull and his horde of Indians. I am the only survivor of the command with which Custer started out that morning, and owe my life to the fact that just a few moments before the Sioux fell on him, he sent me back to Major Reno with orders to the latter.

About 9 o'clock one morning the command halted and Custer and Reno held a consultation. I was only a few feet away as they were talking, being Custer's orderly that day.

"They compared their watches, and a moment later Custer's command was on its way to the point where it met with annihilation. When we were, I should judge, about a mile from Reno, Custer turned to me and said:

"Orderly, do you think you can find the way back to Major Reno?"

"I replied: 'Yes, sir.'

"'Go as quickly as you can,' he said, 'to Major Reno; give him my compliments and tell him to wait 20 minutes more. He will understand that. I guess you will have to remain with him.'

"It was that order that saved me from a grave out in Montana.

"As I wheeled my horse to go back he recalled me, and calling up the regimental trumpeter, gave him practically the same instructions and further remarked to us, pointing in the direction of Reno's command, 'If you cut across there you may find it smoother going. If you prefer the trail, however, you may go that way, and use your own judgment.'

"We started, the trumpeter and myself. We had only gone 300 or 400 yards when he said to me: 'Mack, which way are you going?'

"'Back over the trail, of course,' I answered.

"He had gotten it into his head that Custer had told us to cut across, and I argued with him in vain that the route was left to our discretion. He wouldn't have it that way, and starting off alone, remarked: 'Good-by, Mack; we'll see who gets to Reno first.' The move cost him his life. He had gone only about 600 yards when I heard several shots in his direction. He had evidently run right into the Indians, and, as I afterwards learned, they had riddled him with bullets.

"By this time I could hear constant firing, both in the direction of Custer and Reno. I was getting over the ground as fast as my horse could carry me, and I had a fine horse, too. Just as I got in sight of Reno's command I ran right into a bunch of red devils. They were not more than 30 yards away, and instantly I could hear the 'ping' and whistling of bullets all around me. I was probably within 120 yards of Reno's command. One ball struck my horse in the withers, and he went down. I fell over his head, but fortunately my arm slipped through the reins and left me holding the horse.

"He got up at once, and as I threw my right leg over the saddle another ball hit him, first passing through the calf of my right leg. It pierced my horse's lungs. He jumped forward and carried me within 60 yards of Major Reno, where he dropped dead. I jumped as he was falling and ran the rest of the way. There was a frightful din at this time, and as I saluted Major Reno he bent his head to hear my message. I repeated the orders of Custer, and he said:

"'Orderly, too late now. Take care of yourself.'

"Reno was then whipped and was being pressed back on the hill, where for three days the command was surrounded and endured suffering which is indescribable.

"The firing was hot and continuous. We did not know what had become of Custer, and were expecting he would come to our relief. Shortly after we got up on the hill we heard three volleys in his direction, a signal for aid, but we were powerless to respond, and could not go to him, although he was but little over a mile away.

"On the morning of the third day we saw a body of men in soldiers' uniforms in the distance. We mistook them for relief coming to us. Such a cheer and yell as went up from the imprisoned soldiers on that hill you never heard in your life. We soon learned that the uniforms were worn by Indians, and were those undoubtedly of Custer's men.

"This was our first knowledge of the fate which had overtaken him and his command. Our hearts again sank and hope almost deserted us. Soon, however, the Indians were seen to be leaving, and a few hours later General Terry came up with relief and re-enforcements. As Sitting Bull split up his followers into small bands, we could not follow them successfully.

"My next fight was under General Miles, then Colonel. This was in the fall of 1877, when we fought the Nez Perces under Chief Joseph in the Bear Paw Mountains. I speak of this because it has been said often of late that General Miles is only a dress parade and parlor soldier. The people who say this never made a greater mistake. General Miles is as brave and fearless a commander as ever lived. I don't believe he knows what fear is. Certainly if the people who make that charge against him could have seen him in that fight as I saw him their opinions would undergo a radical change.

"It was September 29, 1877, that the fight began. For five days we had been marching at night, going into camp about 4 o'clock each morning. We had camped but six or seven miles from the Nez Perces, although I am satisfied General Miles did not know it.

"After we had gone about four miles on the march we came in sight of the Nez Perces' camp. They must have known that we were coming, because they were fully prepared for us. We could not see them, but as we saw the camp we formed in line of battle.

"As I said, we could not see the Indians and did not, until we rode right into them, within 30 feet of them. They loomed up to view in an instant.

"Just think of it! There were fully 800 naked, painted savages, and, all told, our three companies did not number over 120 men.

"I will never forget the scene. Sergeant Wilde ran out a few feet in front of his horse. Corporal Delaney was next to him and I was next to Delaney. We were in the extreme front.

"In a moment Wilde was shot through the breast. Delaney wounded in the head and I shot in the right knee and side.

"For a time I was in a desperate situation, between the two fires. I thought my time had come, but our boys soon reached us. One fellow, named Stapleton, who was an ex-English soldier and a brave one, too, dragged me back beyond a little hill. Here I had a good view of the fight.

"General Miles came up to my company and pointing to a spot where several shots were coming from said:

"'Boys, I don't believe there are over a dozen of them over there. Charge them once.'

"We were so close that the Indians heard the order, and answered back jeeringly, 'Charge 'em.' It was a disastrous charge, and of the 14 men who leaped forward five dropped in an instant, and the remainder were compelled to fall back in a hurry.

"General Miles, telling the boys to remain where they were, said he would go back and send us re-enforcements. It was at this point that I saw him exhibit bravery and daring which have been seldom witnessed.

"He could have gone around the hills with perfect safety, but it would have required a little more time. Disdaining the secure route, he put his horse into a canter and rode across the open, the only real exposed place on the field.

"There were fully, as I said, 800 Nez Perces within a short distance, and they opened fire on him at once. There must have been 2,000 shots fired at him as he rode across.

"It seemed certain death, actually courting it, but he dashed along utterly regardless of the rain of lead around him. It was a spectacle I shall never forget. When I hear General Miles called a parlor or a dress parade soldier I think of that ride and the scene it presented, and I feel like fighting myself.

"This was the hottest fighting for a time that I ever heard of, but we forced the Indians back, and although the fight lasted five days, the rest of it was tame compared with that first morning.

"After several parleys, Chief Joseph surrendered, and a few hours later General Howard, who was following the Nez Perces from Washington Territory, arrived.

"That fight was a great thing for General Miles. His success there and the opportunities it gave him resulted in his promotion to a Brigadiership and a big jump toward the position he now holds as commanding General of the Army."

See the clipping

Paints-Himself-Brown on Harrington’s last ride

The Fort Yates correspondent of the New York Herald hears from Paints-Himself-Brown how Lieutenant Henry M. Harrington, the one body never found on the field, broke through the Indian line. Six of his seven pursuers turned back, saying ‘Let the white man go.’ When his horse fell before the seventh he shot himself, and his body lay in a dry lake bed miles away.

Freeland Tribune · Freeland, Pa. · and 3 other papers

Freeland Tribune · 11 February 1901 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

TALES OF PLUCK AND ADVENTURE.

Fate of Custer's Last Officer.

See moreSee less

AGAIN have the awful particulars of the massacre of the Little Big Horn in 1876, which cost the lives of General Custer and his devoted followers, been told by one of the Indians who participated in the slaughter, writes the Fort Yates (N. D.) correspondent of the New York Herald. This time light is shed upon the fate of Lieutenant Henry M. Harrington, which has heretofore been shrouded with mystery.

Lieutenant Harrington's body was the only one not found on the battlefield, and for years there was a persistent rumor in existence that he was still alive, having been carried into captivity, in spite of the assertion made by the Indians that no white man who entered the Bad Lands with Custer survived the massacre. Lieutenant Harrington broke through the horde of redskins and raced for his life. Being pursued he sent a bullet through his head to escape capture and torture.

Paints-Himself-Brown, an Indian who fought under Sitting Bull and who was present at the death of Custer, has told a correspondent for the Herald the story of Lieutenant Harrington's desperate and almost successful fight and flight. He relates the circumstances with a minuteness of detail which would be convincing in itself. His reputation for veracity makes the story he tells more credible. This is how he described the campaign and massacre:

"General Custer was much feared by the Indians. His reckless bravery was known to them, and there was much rejoicing when it was seen that he was advancing into a trap which promised his death.

"General Terry held a long war council with General Custer and General Gibbons. This was reported by scouts sent out by Sitting Bull and Crazy Horse, who led the Indians. We saw Gibbons take the path to the northward, and we knew that Terry had gone to the south.

"General Custer, with about 400 braves, plunged into the Bad Lands. Sitting Bull had thousands of warriors ready for the attack which he knew Custer would make. It was to be a fight to the death, with no quarter.

"I have seen other brave men, but never saw any like Custer. He led his soldiers into our camp as though he would ride over us. There was a fight—a headlong battle for more than a mile. Sitting Bull wisely withdrew his Indians until the white men were completed surrounded.

"Custer and his men formed on a knoll and fought with desperation until the final charge of the Indians overwhelmed them. Then they were all dead—all but one.

"Just as we swung up the hill a young officer, well mounted, darted out from among his fellows and rode straight at us. His daring bewildered the Indians, and he had broken through our line before we realized that he was making a desperate dash to save his life. He escaped to the open prairie pursued by seven Indians. His mount was fresher than ours and he gained so rapidly that six of us turned back, saying:

" 'Let the white man go. It is well that one should escape to tell how the Indians fight for their land and their squaws.'

"One Indian, better mounted than the others, continued the chase. Lieutenant Harrington's horse finally began to falter and the Indian gained rapidly. Then the horse of the pursued man floundered and fell. Lieutenant Harrington raised his pistol to his head and sent a bullet through his brains. His body lay in the bed of a dry lake, several miles from the scene of the massacre, which accounts for the fact that it was not discovered by General Terry.

"General Custer died June 25, 1876. The Indians were blamed for the massacre, but we had to kill the white men or run away. They would not surrender, and they forced the battle. Of all the brave men who died that day none was more brave than Lieutenant Harrington, who rode through our lines."

See the clipping

A sham Custer massacre on the Fourth

At Sheridan, Wyo., on the Fourth of July, Crows and Cheyennes, more than 300 of whom were in the real fight, cut down a band of regulars before thousands. O. P. Hanna, once a scout with Custer, won the Crows over after ten years of refusals; Major Sanders plays Custer. The real fight left no surviving witness, so the paper calls this its most vivid picture.

The Washburn Times · Washburn, Wis. · and 2 other papers

CorrectionThis set right an article from 5 days earlier.

The Washburn Times · 24 July 1902 · page 6 · transcribed from the page image

VIVID MIMIC WARFARE.

First Lifelike Reproduction of the Custer Massacre.

See moreSee less

PLANNED BY SCOUT O. P. HANNA.

Fifteen Hundred Crow and Cheyenne Indians, With 260 Regulars, Fought a Sham Battle on the Little Big Horn's Historic Battleground. Three Hundred Indians Were In Real Fight Years Ago.

At Sheridan, Wyo., July 4, not far from the spot where Custer fell, twenty-six years after the heroic Seventh cavalry was demolished by a ferocious and overpowering force of Indians, was enacted a mimic but fearfully lifelike imitation of that celebrated massacre, says the New York Times. Fifteen hundred Crows and Cheyennes, hideous in their war paint, swooped down upon 260 men from Fort McKenzie and surrounded, cut down and annihilated them in the presence of thousands of spectators, who then saw the first lifelike reproduction of the slaughter of Custer and his band.

The fight of June 25, 1876, was without a surviving witness, and after the last horrible yell had died away in the Big Horn, after the last scalp had been lifted, there was no one of that gallant band of troopers left to tell the tale. The scene of carnage has been described only in the unwilling speech of the Indian victors and the imagination of the writers whom that speech and the graves of the silent dead inspired. So, after all, the most authentic and certainly the most vivid picture of that fight was the sham battle between Uncle Sam's men and the Crows and Cheyennes on the Fourth of July, 1902.

The recent reproduction of the Custer massacre is the result of many years of scheming. For ten years efforts had been made to persuade the Crows to take part in the mimic fight, but all overtures had been met with grunts of disapproval. It was not until after patient persistence and much canvassing that O. P. Hanna, once a scout with Custer, succeeded in interesting the reds in a sham battle. Through his long experience on the frontier and his personal acquaintance among the leading chiefs of the western Indians Hanna finally came out on top. They agreed to "put up" an exhibition if Hanna would do certain things, which Hanna readily promised.

The Crows are a very conservative tribe these days, and when once they were interested in the project they were ready to emigrate almost to a man to the field of the sham battle. So the Crow agency on the Fourth looked like a deserted village, while around the town of Sheridan were camped at least 3,000 Indians. Of the chiefs who took part in the sham battle the best known are Spotted Horse, Wolf-That-Lies-Down, Two Leggins, Old Crow, Plenty Cuss, Crazy Head, Red Tomahawk, Iron Thunder, Medicine Crow, Sparrow Hawk, Pretty Eagle and Bad Man.

Rehearsing 1,000 Indians for the sham battle was no small task and required diplomacy as well as executive ability. For days the spectacle was repeated until all the movements were thoroughly drilled into the red men's minds. In the band of Indians who fought on the Fourth more than 300 of them were in the battle of twenty-six years ago. Major Sanders was the Custer, and at the head of his little band, representing the detachment of the famous Seventh United States cavalry, he could be seen in the distance making a detour to surround a small cluster of Indians. The latter ran, and Sanders charged after them in full pursuit. The red men were real warriors in appearance, with their shining, naked limbs and features fantastically colored, and riding their mounts at top speed they presented a terrifying spectacle.

The reds were then re-enforced and beat back the soldiers, the firing broke into a sullen roar, and the soldiers were seen again advancing. The soldiers divided into two columns, one taking one side and the other the opposite of the ascent up the ravine. Then Spotted Horse, who acted Gall, brought up more Indians. The troopers tried to form a junction of their two slender columns, but the enemy, scores and scores of flying, yelling fiends, remained ever between them.

There was no escape. Gall was an omnipresent fiend and seemed to possess a charmed life as he charged at the head of his hordes, yelling, encouraging, calling on the Great Spirit as they rode over their own dead to reach the little band of the Seventh. First the cavalry horses fell as their riders dropped behind them, shooting desperately on every side at an enemy that seemed to encircle each one of them, so numerous were the reds.

A final charge, and both sides were down save a few plucky bunches of men who stood side by side in the last encounter. Then the carnage began, and scalps were lifted in high glee. Custer alone, with half a dozen men, was making his last stand.

Then Custer remained alone for a moment, finally falling, pierced by numerous bullets and lying undisturbed among that yelling horde, which regarded him with awe as some powerful agency of the evil spirit. There he lay, even as did the Custer of a quarter of a century ago, his yellow locks undisturbed, his face marred only by the battle smoke and his sword in his hand even in death.

Such was the mimic battle given at Sheridan on the Fourth, at once the first and the most lifelike attempt to reproduce the Custer massacre.

See the clipping

A Sioux convert: ‘I did’

The Rev. Philip Daloria, a former Sioux chief now an Episcopalian rector, tells a Philadelphia reporter that the old warrior Appearing Elk, whom he had converted, said he killed Custer: he felled a swaying ‘big chief’ with his tomahawk, took his revolver, and did not scalp him because his head was shaved. Daloria says the revolver was later identified as Custer’s. Appearing Elk died last spring.

Atlanta Semi-Weekly Journal · Atlanta, Ga. · and 1 other paper

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

Atlanta Semi-Weekly Journal · 27 October 1902 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

STORY OF THE BRAVE WHO KILLED CUSTER

PHILADELPHIA, Oct. 21.—A former Sioux chief, now an Episcopalian rector, the Rev. Philip Daloria, of Flora, S. D., who it attending the council of tne Protestant Episcopal church here, said yesterday to a North American reporter:

See moreSee less

"It was only a year ago that I learned the true story of the death of General Custer. I had been the means of converting an old warrior named Appearing Elk. Unlike most Indian braves, he was not much given to boasting of his exploits, but I knew that he had taken many scalps.

"Appearing Elk became a fervent Christian and one day, after he had been baptized and taken into the church, I asked him to tell me of his experience in the battle of the Little Big Horn. Every Sioux wants to know who killed Custer, and that was my first question. I was surprised when the old man replied, 'I did.'

"I felt pretty sure that Appearing Elk told the truth. I drew his story from him in detail, and this is what he said:

"'We had surrounded the last cluster of soldiers when my pony was shot from under me. When I got on my feet again I discovered that I had been wounded. Suddenly a man in blue loomed up in front of me.

"'I knew he was a big chief. He was swaying like a drunken man from exhaustion and loss of blood because of many bullet and arrow wounds. I felled him with my tomahawk and then sat on his body to be sure that I should not be robbed of my spoils. In order to make doubly sure I took the revolver from the holster of the dead man and stuck it in my belt.

"'I didn't scalp the man, because his head was shaved, and I was ashamed to take a mere piece of skin.'

"I know postively," continued Mr. Daloria, "that the revolver taken by Appearing Elk was subsequently identified as Custer's, and so far as I have been able to learn, Custer was the only man in the command who had his head shaved."

Appearing Elk died last spring.

See the clipping

McGee held after a kitchen-knife fight

In New York William McGee, who claims to be the sole white survivor of Custer’s command, is held for homicide. He and Frank Mitchell, a salesman, quarrelled over ‘the proper method for cooking kidney stew’ and fought with kitchen knives; McGee says old tricks let him fell Mitchell, who died of a scalp wound. He repeats that Custer sent him with a message to Reno.

The Frontier · O'Neill City, Neb. · and 1 other paper

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 3 days later.

Wrong

The Frontier · 15 December 1904 · page 7 · transcribed from the page image

SCALPED HIS VICTIM.

"Sole White Survivor of Custer Massacre," Adopts Appropriate Method of Homicide.

See moreSee less

New York, Dec. 13.—William McGee, who claims to be the sole white survivor of Custer's command in the famous battle of the Little Big Horn, is under arrest here, charged with homicide. Late Thursday night he got into an argument with Frank Mitchell, a salesman, over the proper method for cooking kidney stew. A quarrel followed and the men attacked each other with kitchen knives. McGee declares Mitchell attacked him first, and that by practicing old tricks he felled his opponent, who received a severe scalp wound. Mitchell died twenty-four hours later. McGee declares he was detached by Custer just before the massacre to carry a message to Major Reno, who was to have made a joint attack with Custer's troops on the Indians.

See the clipping

Rain-in-the-Face dies untamed at Standing Rock

An Oregon paper marks the death, aged 62, of Rain-in-the-Face, last of the great Sioux chiefs of the seventies, who escaped after Tom Custer arrested him for murdering an army surgeon and a trader, leaving the threat ‘I will kill you all.’ The claim that he personally killed Custer is ‘not so sure, the evidence being very conflicting’, and few doubted he murdered his last wife.

Heppner Gazette · Heppner, Or. · and 6 other papers

Heppner Gazette · 19 October 1905 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

RAIN-IN-THE-FACE.

Indian Who Led in Custer Massacre Dies Untamed.

See moreSee less

Rain-in-the-Face, who was one of the leading chiefs in the Custer massacre and is said to have personally killed General Custer, died recently at the Standing Rock reservation, aged 62. He was the last of the great Sioux chiefs who fought the United States troops in the middle 70's, and was in character and disposition the cruel, relentless, unforgiving Indian which tradition paints. Though in his later years he wore the uniform of the Indian police, he never lost his hatred of the white man.

Born in 1843, a pure-blooded Sioux, Rain-in-the-Face lived the active life of the redskins of his age, but it was not until he was 30 years old that his criminal capacities came directly to the attention of the army authorities, the occasion being the murder of an army surgeon and a trader. He was arrested by Col. "Tom" Custer on orders from Gen. George A. Custer, his brother.

The next day after his arrest the Indian confessed and General Custer reported the case to Washington.

After being imprisoned about three months he escaped and joined Sitting Bull on the Rosebud and Big Horn rivers, but he left behind him the threat for Tom Custer and the whole Custer family: "I will kill you all."

Months of desultory warfare led up to the battle of the Little Big Horn, on June 26, 1876, when General Custer's command was annihilated.

That Rain-in-the-Face distinguished himself in this fight by his reckless bravery seems certain, but the claim of his personally killing Custer in a last desperate charge is not so sure, the evidence being very conflicting.

Rain-in-the-Face, who was wounded in two places during the battle, fled with the other chiefs to Canada. He returned to the United States and surrendered to General Miles in 1880 and 1881, being the last to yield. He has spent most of the time since on the reservation, peaceful from compulsion but unreconciled.

His power as a leader lay in his splendid physique, indomitable spirit and mental alertness. Sitting Bull had no more kindred nature among his fighters than Rain-in-the-Face, whose ability for trouble making in general, horse-stealing and murder made him famous throughout the far Western States.

Rain-in-the-Face had seven wives, none of whom lived happily with him. His last wife was found in her tepee with her throat cut. Few doubted that Rain-in-the-Face had murdered her, but there was no legal proof of his guilt.

See the clipping

← Back to Act Nine: Gall Tells It