The Savannah Tribune · Savannah, Ga. · and 1 other paper
This account describes the Indian attack on Custer's position, with soldiers fighting a defensive battle as ammunition ran low and horses were stampeded. It recounts the discovery of Sergeant Butler's body between Custer and Reno's forces, suggesting a failed attempt to send a message, and notes the uncertainty soldiers felt about Reno's whereabouts as defeat loomed.
They fought on, therefore, coolly and resolutely, husbanding their ammunition and en deavoring to make every shot tell -on their galloping, yelling foemen. The Indians, In their accounts, speak of the cool, deliberate courage of num bers of the officers and fnen, whom they singled out for their bravery. Yet the troopers suffered great loss as the afternoon wore on. Their am munition began to run low, and the contracting, whirling circle of Indians drove them closer and closer together. The horses were at last stampeded, and with them went some of the re serve ammunition. It appears that at this time Custer must have endeavored to send a mes sage to Reno, foe the body of a solitary soldier, Sergeant Butler, was found after the battle at a point half way between Custer and Reno’s command. A little heap of cartridge shells lay near his body, evidencing that he had sold his life dearly. ^t was evident to all on the hill as the afternoon drew to Its close that they were doomed. It was hardly pos sible that a counter attack by Reno would save them now, and there were no evidences that he was anywhere In the vicinity. “Where In Gob’s name,” they must have asked them selves in their despair, “could Reno be?” One of the Crow scouts has said— although his account is generally dis believed—that he went at last to Cus ter, as yet unharmed, and told him that he thought he could get him away, and that Custer refused to leave the field. The Crow’ altered his ap pearance to look as much like a Sioux as possible, and in the confusion of the fight got away safely. He was the ohly human survivor of the field. What Occurred after is a matter of conjec ture, based upon the contradictory and Inadequate testimony of the Indians themselves.—Cyrus Townsend Brady, la Pearson’s.
East Providence Eagle · East Providence, R.I. · 12 November 1904
New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.
William Magee, arrested for fatally stabbing Frank Mitchell in a dispute over beef stew, claimed self-defense and said he had served as a cavalryman sent by Custer to fetch Reno for relief just before the Little Bighorn fight, where he was wounded. Mitchell died later that night at Bellevue Hospital.
New-York Tribune · 10 December 1904 · page 16
MURDER OVER BEEF STEW.
Prisoner Accused of Stabbing Says He Rode for Custer. William Magee, a magazine agent living at No. 20 Fast Fortv-first-st,, is alleped to have Killed
William McGee, who claims to be the sole white survivor of Custer's command at Little Bighorn, is arrested in New York for killing a man in a quarrel over cooking kidney stew. McGee claims Custer had sent him to carry a message to Major Reno just before the massacre.
Evening Times-Republican · 10 December 1904 · page 1
New York, Dec. 10.—William McGee, who claims to be the sole white'sur vivor of Custer's command In the fam ous battle of the Little Big Horn, Is under arrest here, charged with homi cide. Late Thursday night he got into an argument with Frank Mitchell, a sales man, over the proper method for cook ing a kidney stew. A quarrel followed and the men attacked-each other with kitchen knives. McGee declares Mitch ell attacked him first, and by practicing an old trick he felled his opponent, who received a, severe scalp wound, aiiictitell died twenty-fiftr ,&6Urs later. McGee declares he was detached by Custer just before the massacre to carry a message to Major Reno, who was to have made a joint attack with Custer's troops on the Indians^
William McGee, who claims to be the sole white survivor of Custer's command at Little Bighorn, is arrested in New York for the homicide of Frank Mitchell after a knife fight over cooking a kidney stew. McGee claims Custer detached him to carry a message to Major Reno before the massacre, and he bears many old scars as alleged proof of his frontier service.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 2 days later.
Wrong
The Minneapolis Journal · 10 December 1904 · page 2
Slayer. New York, Dec. 10.William McGee, *vho claims to be the sole white sur Vivor of Custer's command in the famous battle of the Little Big Horn, is under arrest here charged with homi cide. Late Thursday night he got into an argument with Frank Mitchell, a sales man, over the proper method for cook ing a kidney stew. A quarrel followed and the men attacked each othe'r with kitchen knives, the fracas having oc curred in Mitchell's flat. McGee, who Jived on the western frontier forty years, declares Mitchell attacked him first and, practicing an old trick, he felled his opponent, not, however', until he received a severe scalp wound.
See moreSee less
Mitchell did not appear badly off at the time, but he died twenty-four hours later. McGee was arrested meantime in a newspaper office, where he had gone to set the editor right regarding the story of the fight. In teliing of his service in the army, McGee declared he was detached by Custer just before the massacre, to car ry a message to Major Eeno, who was to have made a joint attack with Cus ter's troops on the Indians. McGee bears the scars of many wounds, which lie claims to have received before he reached Eeno's forces. Recently he came here from Texas and has been can vassing for a magazine. The Fashion Center. The great Plymouth Clothing House.
The Fargo Forum and Daily Republican · Fargo, N.D.
A man who claimed to be the only white survivor of the Custer Massacre was charged with murder after killing another man in a dispute over a kidney stew. The report treats his survivor claim as established fact.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 2 days later.
Wrong
The Fargo Forum and Daily Republican · 10 December 1904 · page 1
HISTORIC CHARACTER if CHARGED WITH MURDER The Man Who Claims to Be the Only White Survivor of the Custer Massacre, Killed Another ia a Row ever a Kidney Stew.- -4 KW. k' 10'.—-Wfttlcbn HtNew York, Dec. Gee, who claims to be the sole white survivor of the Custer massacre on the Little Big. Horn, is under arrest charg ed with killing Frank Mitchell. The men quarrelled over the proper meth od of cooking kidney stew and fought i with kitchen knives.
The Fargo Forum and Daily Republican · Fargo, N.D.
A man named Welcome McGee, who claims to be the sole white survivor of the Custer massacre at Little Big Horn, has been arrested for killing Frank Mitchell. The two men reportedly quarreled over how to cook kidney stew and fought with kitchen knives.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 2 days later.
Wrong
The Fargo Forum and Daily Republican · 10 December 1904 · page 1
William McGee, claiming to be the sole white survivor of Custer's command at Little Bighorn, is arrested in New York for killing Frank Mitchell during a knife fight over cooking methods. McGee claimed he was sent by Custer to deliver a message to Major Reno just before the massacre, explaining his survival.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Saint Paul Globe · 11 December 1904 · page 30
SURVIVOR OF CUSTER MASSACRE ARRESTED
NEW YORK, Dec. 10.—William McGee, who claims to be the sole white survivor of Custer's command in the famous-battle of the Little Big Horn, is under arrest here charged with homi cide. Late Thursday night he got into an argument with Frank Mitchell, a. salesman, over the proper method for cooking kidney stew. A quarrelfol lowed and the men attacked each other with kitchen knives, the Iracas having occurred in Mitchell's flat. McGee, who lived on the Western frontier forty years, declared Mitchell attacked him first and by practicing an old trick he felled his opponent, not, however, until he received a severe scalp wound.
See moreSee less
Mitchell did not appear badly off at the time, but he died twenty-four hours later. McGee was arrested meantime in a newspaper office where he had gone to set the editor right regarding the story of the light. In telling of his service in the army, McGee declared he was detached by Custer just before the massacre to carry a message to Maj. Reno, who was to have made a joint attack with Cus ter's troops on the Indians. McGe« bears the scars of many wounds which he claims to have receiver! before he reache # d Reno's forces. Recently he came 'from Texas and has been can vassing for a magazine.
William McGee, who claims to be the sole white survivor of Custer's command at Little Big Horn, was arrested in New York on a homicide charge after a fatal knife fight over cooking method. He claimed Custer had detached him to carry a message to Major Reno just before the battle.
Omaha Daily Bee · 11 December 1904 · page 17
HOLD "LAST CUSTER SURVIVOR"
Blsr Horn. NEW YORK, Dec. 10. William McOoa, who claims to b tha cole whit survivor of Custer' command in the famous battle of the Little Big Horn, is under arrest here charged with homicide. Late Thursday night he got Into 44 argument with Frank Mitchell, a salesman, over the proper method for cooking a kidney stew. A quarrel followed and the men attacked each other with kitchen knives, the fracas having occurred in Mit chell's flat. McGee, who lived on the western frontier forty years, declared Mitchell atacked him first and by practicing an old trick ha felled his opponent, not, however, until h receive a severe scalp wound.
See moreSee less
Mitchell did not appear badly off at th time, but he died two hour later. McGe was arrested meantime In a newspaper office where he had gone to set th editor right regarding the story of the fight. In telling of his Service In the army, MoGee declared he waa detached by Custer, Just before the massacre, to carry a mes sage to Major Reno, who waa to hav made a Joint attack with Custer' troop on the Indians. McGee bears the scar of many wound which he claims to have received before he reached Reno's forces. Recently h came here from Texa and ho been can vassing for a magazine.
Abraham McGee, arrested in New York for fatally stabbing a man in a kitchen-stew argument, claims to be the sole white survivor of Custer's command at Little Bighorn. He says Custer sent him to carry a message to Major Reno just before the massacre, and he bears old wounds as proof.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Morning Astorian · 11 December 1904 · page 1
ONLY MAN LEFT AT BIG HORN
New York, Dec. 10. Abraham Mc Gee, who claims to be the sole white survivor of Custer's command In the famoua battle of Little Big Horn, la under arrest here, charged with homi cide. Last Thursday night he got Into an argument with Frank Mitchell, a salesman, over the proper method for cooking a kidney stew. A quarrel fol lowed and the men attacked each other with kitchen knlvea, the fracas having occurred In Mitchell's flat. McGee, who lived on the western frontier 40 years declares Mitchell attacked him first nd by practicing an old trick he felled his opponent, not, however, until he re ceived a severe scalp wound.
See moreSee less
Mitchell did not appear badly off at the time, but he died 24 hours later. McGee was arrested In the meantime In a newspaper otnee, wnere ne naa gone to set the editor right about the fight. In telling the story of the battle, Mc Gee declared he waa detached by Custer Just before the massacre to carry a message to Major Reno, who was to huve .made a Joint attack with Ciister'e troops on the Indians. McGee bears the scars of many wounds which he claims to huve receiv ed before he reached Reno's forces. Re cently he came here from Texas and has been canvassing for a mnguzlne.
Abraham McGee, who claims to be the sole white survivor of Custer's command at Little Bighorn, was arrested in New York for the death of Frank Mitchell following a kitchen knife fight over cooking methods. McGee claims he was sent by Custer to carry a message to Major Reno before the famous massacre and bears old wounds as evidence of his frontier service.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Salt Lake Tribune · 11 December 1904 · page 12
CHARGED WITH MURDER. Last White Survivor of Custer's Command at Little Big Horn.
NEW YORK, Dec. 10. Abraham McGco, who claims to bo tho hoIo whlto sur vivor of Custers command In tho fa mous battio of Llttlo Big Horn. Is under arrest here charged with homicide. Late Thursday night ho got Into an ar gument with Frank Mitchell, a salesman, over tho proper method for cooking a kid ney otew A quarrel followed and tho men attacked each other with ltltchen knives, tho fracas having occurred In Mitchell's flat. McGco, who lived on tho Western fron tier forty years, declares Mitchell at tacked him first and by practicing an old trick ho fulled his opponent, not, how ever, until ho received a severe 3calp wound.
See moreSee less
Mitchell did not appear badly off at the time, but ho died twonty-four hours later. McGoo wsa arrested meantime In a news paper office, whero ho had gono to act tho editor rb:ht about tho light. In tolling tho story of tho battio McGco declared ho was dotached by Custer Just boforo tho massacre to carry a mcssago to MaJ Reno, who was to havo mado a Joint attack with Custer's troops on tho Indiana McGee bears tho scars of many wounds which ho claims to have received beforo ho reached Reno's forces. Recently ho came hero from Texan and has boon can vassing for a magazine. Wireless Message. First received in Salt Lake. See page 14.
William McGee, who claims to be the sole survivor of Custer's command at Little Bighorn, is arrested in New York for the homicide of salesman Frank Mitchell. The two men fought with kitchen knives over cooking methods, and Mitchell died of his wounds a day later.
The Bemidji Daily Pioneer · 12 December 1904 · page 4
LAST OF CUSTER'S Sole Survivors of Custer's Command Charged With Homicide. New York, Dec. 12William Mc Gee, who claims io be the sole survivor of Custer's command the famous battle of the Little Big Horn, is under arrest here charged with homicide Late Thursday night he got into an argument with Frank.Mitchell, a sales man, ovei the proper method toi cook ing a kidney stew. A quarrel fol lowed and the men attacked each other with kitchen knives, the fracas having occurred in Mitchell's flat. McGee, who lived on the Western frontier forty years, declares Mitchell attacked him first and, by practicing an old trick, he felled his opponent, not, however, until he had received a severe scalp wound.
See moreSee less
Mitchell did not appear badly off at the time, but he died twenty-four hours later. McGee was arrested In telling of his service in the army McGee declared he was detached by Custer just before the massacre to carry a message to Major Reno, who was to have made a joint attack with Custer's troops on the Indians McGee bears the scars of many wounds, which he claims to have re ceived before he reached Reno's forces. Recently he came here fiom Texas and has been canvassing for a magazine
William McGee, who claims to be the sole white survivor of Custer's command at Little Bighorn, is arrested in New York for killing Frank Mitchell in a kitchen-knife fight over cooking methods. McGee was apprehended at a newspaper office where he had gone to correct the story about the altercation.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 6 days later.
Wrong
Bismarck Daily Tribune · 12 December 1904 · page 1
SURVIVOR TURNS UP AGAIN
Friend In a Friendly Discussion. New York, Dec. 12.—William McGee, who claims to be the sole white sur vivor of Custer's command in the famous battle of the Little Big Horn, is under arrest here charged with homicide. Late Thursday night he got into an argument with Frank Mitchell, a salesman, over the proper method for cooking kidney stew. A quarrel followed and the men attacked each other with kitchen knives, the fracas having occurred in Mitchell's flat. McGee, who lived on the West ern frontier forty years, declared Mitchell attacked1 'him first and by practicing an old trick he felled his opponent, not, however, until he re of the fight.
A man named McGee, arrested after a knife fight, claimed he had been the sole survivor of the Custer massacre, saying Custer had sent him to carry a message to Major Reno before the fighting began. He displayed scars he said came from wounds suffered while reaching Reno's forces, and was arrested while visiting a newspaper office to correct an earlier story about him.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 6 days later.
Wrong
Bismarck Daily Tribune · 12 December 1904 · page 1
SURVIVOR TURNS UP AGAIN
Friend In a Friendly Discussion. ceived a severe scalp wound. Mitchell did not appear badly off at the time but he died twenty-four hours later, McGee was arrested meantime in newspaper office where he had gone to set the editor right regarding the story of the fight. In telling of his service in the army McGee declared he was detached by Custer Just before the massacre to carry a message to Maj. Reno, who was to have made a joint attack with Custer's troops on the Indians. Mc Gee bears the scars of many wounds which he claims to have received be fore he reached1 Reno's forces.
See moreSee less
Re cently be came from Texas and has been canvassing for a magazine. brought it into a hurried roll as we ran from beneath it. It was nearing day light, and the birds were out on the dry railroad track, feeding. A man couldm't have heard that train more than 100 yards, and it seemed we jumped down on those birds. One big crow raised slowly in front of the engine and 'bang' he went into the headlight. A smaller bird, which I judged was a sparrow, plunked against the window paine in the cab. All along that run clear to Sedalia, we hit the birds. "When they took my 1,100 to the roundhouse we found several birds, ineluding the crow, lying on the engine. to knock its life out every time. Birds •through here don't fly a mile a minute, but these big engines do, and they often fly faster than that. A dove is the fastest of all the birds, and there are fewer of them killed. In the first place, a train rarely gets close to one. Missouri Pacific engineer them before they try to fly. blood spot of Tells the Finish." "Not long ago," said G. M. Jaques, 1 6 y*m -r^pp, V\'^€a 'X-$Mm 't '^4m 'j ^£«-a®
The piece satirically notes that another self-proclaimed 'only survivor of the Custer massacre' has been arrested in New York for a violent crime. It jokes that the true sole survivor was the horse Comanche, and that the ever-growing number of human 'survivors' now exceeds the men actually present at the battle.
Bismarck Daily Tribune · 12 December 1904 · page 2
THE WEEKLY TRIBUNE., Published every Friday eight pages, con taining a summary of the news of the week —local and foreign—particular attention being (.aid to state news. Sent to any address, postage paid, for $1 for one vear 50 cents for six months 25 cents for three months. The Bismarck Tribune is the oldest newspaper in tie state—established June 11, 1878. It has a wide circulation and is a desirable advertising medium. Being pub lished at the capital of the state it makes a feature of state news, of a semi-official char acter, and is therefore particularly interest ing to all who desire to keep the run of state affairs—political, social and business.
See moreSee less
We not* that another "only survivor of the Custer massacre" has been ar rested in New York tor exploring in the viscera of a comrade with a long knife or some other trivial offense, and we are constrained to observe, at the •risk -of becoming frivolous and fuM of levity in dealing with a. very melan choly subject, that the list of Custer survivora is growing to such an extent that the oldest Mason, the original compounder of the gin rickey, and other notable bands of famous men are being left far behind in the matter of numbers. Scarcely a week passes but the only survivor of the Custer massacre dies, or otherwise does something that earns him distinction ami newspaper reference more than usually extended. As we understand it orginally there was only one living thing that survived the Custer massa cre and that was Comanche, a horse belonging to one of the men of the un fortunate command. From that horse, however, seems to have sprung an innumerable line of survivors,—possi bly grotans who were afterward en gaged to care for him while he lived. This is the only reasonable explanatoin we can offer of the growing army of survivors, now numbering more man than were engaged in the action at the time of thie melancholy affair. A cigarette fiend! having been sen tenced to thie reform school from Cass county for some crime or otiher and the district judge having declared that in every case so far as he could recall where a minor had been sent to the reform school he was addicted to the use of cigarettes, thie states attorney of Cass county has caused' the anti cigaretite law to be published in the newspapers with his declaration that its provisions will be strictly enforced hereafter. The Grand) Forks Herald having de clared that a legislative session would seem incomplete without the never failing hospitality of the Bismarck Tribune, the Tribune will in turn de clare that the session would be in complete, indeed^ without the pleasant association of the courteous and able representatives always sent to Bis marck by the Heraldl Ex-President Mellon of the North ern Pacific, now president of the New York, New Haven arndi Hartford rail way, explodes that little senatorial boom let that was going the rounds by declaring that he would Mot serve if elected to the U. S. senate from Con necticut. Thie Grand Forks Herald declares that this lack of a candidate for chief clerk of the house is growing mo notonous and wants some one to fill the gap right away. C. E. Boydem, the new proprietor of the Lisbon Free Press says he is going to emulate the example of President Roosevelt ami give everybody a. square deal. Advertised List. The following Is the list of letters remaining uncalled for at the post office at Bismarck, N. D., lor the week ending Dec. 3, 1904: Bailey, Little. Brown, J. W. Brown, Chaa. Cooper, Jane H. Oanklin, Leo. (2) Clark, Geo. Dietrlck, Anthony GiUrup, Walter. Green, Wallace. Green, Mrs. F. Kennedy L. G. James, Henry. Jewell, Geo. May,Hattie. McKay, Robert Oaks, J. A. Pettis, John. Reamer, John. Shourds, Nina. for the above letters, please say "advertised," and give date of thlsnotiee. Lettefs wlll be held 14 days before being sent to the Dead a, Latter Office. Agatha Patterson,
William McGee, who claims to be the sole survivor of Custer's command at Little Bighorn, is arrested in New York for homicide after a fatal knife fight over cooking a kidney stew. McGee says he was sent by Custer to carry a message to Major Reno just before the massacre, and bears scars from wounds he claims to have received before reaching Reno's lines.
The Madison Daily Leader · 12 December 1904 · page 1
8ole Survivor of Custer's Command at the Little Big Horn. New York, Dec. 12.—William Mc Gee, who claims to be the sole survivor of Custer's lonunand in the famous battle of the Little Big Horn, is under arrest here charged with homicide. Late Thursday night he got into an argument with Frank Mitchell, a sales man, over the proper method for cook ing a kidney stew. A quarrel fol lowed and the men attacked each other with kitchen knives, the fiacus having occurred in Mitchell's flat. RlcGee, who lived on the Western frontier lorty years, declares Mitchell attacked him first and.
See moreSee less
by practicing an old trick, he felled his opponent, not, however, until he had received a severe scalp wound. Mitchell did not appear badly off at the time, but he died twenty-four hours later. McOee was arrested. In telling of his service in the army McOee declared he was detached by Custer just before the massacre to carry a message to Major Reno, who was to have made a joint attack with Custer's troops on the Indians. McGee bears the scars of many wounds, which he claims to have re ceived before he reached Reno's forces. Recently he came here from Texas and has been canvassing for a magazine.
William McGee, who claims to be the sole white survivor of Custer's command at Little Bighorn, is arrested in New York on a homicide charge after a fatal knife fight over cooking methods. McGee says Custer detached him to carry a message to Major Reno just before the battle, and that he bears scars from wounds received during his escape.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 6 days later.
Wrong
Palestine Daily Herald · 12 December 1904 · page 2
HOMICIDE CHARGED Sole White Survivor of Battle of Little Big Horn Under Arrest New York Dec 12 William McGee who claims to be the sole white sur vivor of Custers command In the fam ous battle of Little BIb Horn Is under arrest here charged with homicide Late Thursday nlsht he got Into an argu meln with Frank Mitchell a salesman oer the proper method for cooking kidney stew A quarrel followed and the men cttacked each other with kitchen knives the fracas havlnu oc curred In Mitchells Hat McGee de clares Mitchell attacked hltn first and by practicing an old trick he felled his opponent not however until he re ceived a severe scalp wound Mitchell did not appear badly off at the time but he died twentyfour hours later Mc Gee was arrested In the meantime in a newspaper ofllce where he had cone to set the editor right regarding the fight In telling of his service in the army McGee declared he was detached by Custer Just before the massacre to car ry a message to Major Reno who uaa to have made a Joint attack with Cus ters troops on the Indians McGee bfars the scars of many wounds which he claims to have received before he reached Renos forces Recently he came here from Texas and has been canvassing for a magazine
An article about artist C.M. Russell describes his life on the plains and his cowboy and Indian paintings, including one titled 'Custer's Last Stand.' The piece notes Russell's preference for the authentic western life over formal art school training in big cities.
Fergus County Democrat · 13 December 1904 · page 3
Country Now Reproducing Draw ings of Gt. Falls Artist. The Christmas number of Outing contains an article that will be of es pecial interest to the people of Mon tana in general and of Great Falls in particular. The article is entitled, "Russell, the West's Cowboy Artist," and accompanies three pictures by Russell, all full page pictures and all in his best ■style. The first picture is "The Scout," one of Russell's liest; the second is "The Attack," showing a band of In dians ready to attack an emigrant train, and the third is "Custer's Last Stand."
The Frontier · O'Neill City, Neb. · and 1 other paper
William McGee, arrested in New York for killing Frank Mitchell in a knife fight over kidney stew, claims to be the sole white survivor of Custer's command at Little Bighorn. He states Custer sent him to carry a message to Major Reno just before the massacre.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 3 days later.
Wrong
The Frontier · 15 December 1904 · page 7 · transcribed from the page image
SCALPED HIS VICTIM.
"Sole White Survivor of Custer Massacre," Adopts Appropriate Method of Homicide.
See moreSee less
New York, Dec. 13.—William McGee, who claims to be the sole white survivor of Custer's command in the famous battle of the Little Big Horn, is under arrest here, charged with homicide. Late Thursday night he got into an argument with Frank Mitchell, a salesman, over the proper method for cooking kidney stew. A quarrel followed and the men attacked each other with kitchen knives. McGee declares Mitchell attacked him first, and that by practicing old tricks he felled his opponent, who received a severe scalp wound. Mitchell died twenty-four hours later. McGee declares he was detached by Custer just before the massacre to carry a message to Major Reno, who was to have made a joint attack with Custer's troops on the Indians.
The Kimball Graphic · Kimball, S.D. · 16 December 1904
Omaha Daily Bee · Omaha, Neb.
The obituary of General S. M. Whiteside, who fought at Wounded Knee in 1890, recalls how the Seventh Cavalry sought vengeance for the Custer massacre of 1876. It notes that many Sioux at Wounded Knee and many Seventh Cavalry soldiers had been survivors of the earlier 1876 battle, mistakenly naming it the 'Little Rosebud' rather than the Little Bighorn.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
Omaha Daily Bee · 17 December 1904 · page 7
MEMORY OF INDIAN FIGHTER Death of General Whiteside Recalls His Warfare a In Wonnded Knee Campaign. The death of General S. M. Whiteside will cause a pang of regret to a number of Nebraska people, and particularly the older members of the Nebraska National Guard with whom he Was closely asso ciated duringthe Wounded Knee campaign. It was General Whiteside who then, as major of the Seventh United Statea cav alry, opened up the fight against the ghost dancing Sioux, on that fated Slst day of December, 1S90. Or rather the fight was opened by the Indians directly against Major Whiteside's headquarters and bat talion, resulting In the loss of a score or more of the Seventh cavalry and the sub sequent slaughter of the Indians.
See moreSee less
The vengeance, of the Indians was specially directed against the Seventh cavalry, In memory of the Custer massacre of 1876, and ' the hatred of the Seventh cavalry against the Indiana was mutual. Many of the Sioux Indians who were In the Wounded Knee attack on the Seventh were survivors of the battle on the Little Rosebud and many of the old Seventh are still with the regiment who were with Major Reno In that affray of fourteen years before. It was a settling of old scores, and, as Major Whiteside remarked a week before the Wounded Knee affair: "The old Seventh has an old score to settle with that Crasy Horse and Sitting Bull gang and they only need the opportunity to settle It effectively."
A New York man arrested for assault claims to be the sole survivor of the Custer massacre, prompting the Bismarck Tribune to sarcastically note that such 'only survivors' keep multiplying, joking that the real sole survivor was the horse Comanche. The piece pokes fun at the growing number of men claiming survivor status, now exceeding the number who actually fought.
The Dickinson Press · 17 December 1904 · page 4
Bismarck Tribune remarks: "Scarcely a week passes but the only survivor of the Custer massacre dies, or otherwise does something that earns him distinction and newspaper refer ence more than_ usually extended. As we understand it originally there was only one living thing that survived the Custer massacre and that was Co manche, a horse belonging to one of the men of the unfortunate command. From that horse, however, seems to have_ sprung an innumerable line of survivors,—possibly grooms who were afterward engaged to care for him while he lived. This is the onlv reasonable explanation we can offer of the growing army of survivors, now numbering more men than were encaged in the action at the time of the melancholy affair.
The column states that a man named William McGee arrested in New York is not the 'sole white survivor' of Custer's last stand as he claimed, and may not have even fought in that battle. It reiterates the popular legend that the horse Comanche, belonging to Capt. Miles Keogh, was the true 'sole survivor' of the fight, quoting a poem in tribute.
The Savannah Morning News · 18 December 1904 · page 12
Corps will promote Capt. Laurence H. Moses to be major. He is a Georgian, from Columbus, I think, -and married a Bister of Samuel Spencer of the Southern Railway. * • * Con. M. Perkins, another Georgian, is already a major in the corps. * * * It is not generally known that the comman dant of the Marine Corps, who is Brig. Gen. George F. Elliott, is a native of Alabama, but all the colonels were born north of the Potomac river. * * * There are il4 cadets in the next June graduating class at West Point, but at present only about sixty vacant second lieutenancies in the army to be filled.
See moreSee less
Of course there will be some additional vacancies before June, but there seems to be a pros pect for a lot of brevet second lieu tenants about that time. * * * The William McGee arrested for an as sault in New York Is not, as claimed, the "sole white survivor” of the Custer massacre at Little Big Horn. He may have been a trooper, but he was not in that fight. The “sole survivor” of that terrible battle was “Old Comanche,” the horse of Capt. Miles W. Keogh, as I have before stated in these letters, and the government made this famous horse a pensioner upon its 'bounty. "Honor to old Comanche, The sole survivor he Of the fierce fight where Custer died With all his chivalry. Honor to Keogh’s charger! Only his flashing eye Saw the Three Hundred fighting— Saw the Three Hundred die!” S. M. Crothers, in the Atlantic Monthly, tells of his attendance upon the meetings of the recent Interna tional Peace Congress in Boston, and imagines that he there saw the secret of war. Nearly all of the speakers and listeners were middle-aged or old peo ple, so he infers that young men are the source of modern wars. Nothing could be more ridiculous than this idea. Why, take Savannah, for ex ample, how long would the old Guards’ Battalion, the Chatham Artillery, the Hussars, the First Regiment live if the old men, the exempt and honorary members and supporters were to hands off” and let the young men take care of themselves? And then the noble, patriotic old mothers of these sons, how they help to keep up these venerable organizations. I grant that young men are patriotic and heroic, but they would not be so If fathers and mothers were generally opposed to the military spirit. Why, even the Red Men and the Woodmen of the World are now following the Knights Templar and Knights of Pythias and other secret organizations into a mili tary branch. And the Catholic Knights, ns well as the students In Catholic schools, now have their mili tary organizations. Mr. Crothers ought to look elsewhere than In that peace congress to find out the reason why the military spirit prevails. He will find that middle-aged and old peo ple are behind the military spirit In all our church schools, agricultural colleges and even female colleges and Hunday-schools, not to speak of the famous boys’ battalions of the Boston, New York and Washington public schools. All this military spirit comes from the sanction, If not support, of the fsthers and mothers of the young peo ple concerned. For years past the military spirit has spread wonderfully Into our schools, our churches and our secret organisations, arid no peace movement, however strong and world wide. can check It, In Hyracuse. N. Y., they have a fine military company of young women, and In Atlanta, (la , the V. C. V. kave a uniformed com pany of young women. Out in Teaaa. as well as In acme other ctatee, female college# have girt companies Only a little while ago the young women of Troy, AJa, my homo he IM* 71 gave a public drill again#* the regular mIMUr) <-usspasty si the My auk m u*e Corps will promote Capt. Laurence H. Moses to be major. He is a Georgian, from Columbus, I think, -and married a Bister of Samuel Spencer of the Southern Railway. * • * Con. M. Perkins, another Georgian, is already a major in the corps. * * * It is not generally known that the comman dant of the Marine Corps, who is Brig. Gen. George F. Elliott, is a native of Alabama, but all the colonels were born north of the Potomac river. * * * There are il4 cadets in the next June graduating class at West Point, but at present only about sixty vacant second lieutenancies in the army to be filled. Of course there will be some additional vacancies before June, but there seems to be a pros pect for a lot of brevet second lieu tenants about that time. * * * The William McGee arrested for an as sault in New York Is not, as claimed, the "sole white survivor” of the Custer massacre at Little Big Horn. He may have been a trooper, but he was not in that fight. The “sole survivor” of that terrible battle was “Old Comanche,” the horse of Capt. Miles W. Keogh, as I have before stated in these letters, and the government made this famous horse a pensioner upon its 'bounty. "Honor to old Comanche, The sole survivor he Of the fierce fight where Custer died With all his chivalry. Honor to Keogh’s charger! Only his flashing eye Saw the Three Hundred fighting— Saw the Three Hundred die!” S. M. Crothers, in the Atlantic Monthly, tells of his attendance upon the meetings of the recent Interna tional Peace Congress in Boston, and imagines that he there saw the secret of war. Nearly all of the speakers and listeners were middle-aged or old peo ple, so he infers that young men are the source of modern wars. Nothing could be more ridiculous than this idea. Why, take Savannah, for ex ample, how long would the old Guards’ Battalion, the Chatham Artillery, the Hussars, the First Regiment live if the old men, the exempt and honorary members and supporters were to hands off” and let the young men take care of themselves? And then the noble, patriotic old mothers of these sons, how they help to keep up these venerable organizations. I grant that young men are patriotic and heroic, but they would not be so If fathers and mothers were generally opposed to the military spirit. Why, even the Red Men and the Woodmen of the World are now following the Knights Templar and Knights of Pythias and other secret organizations into a mili tary branch. And the Catholic Knights, ns well as the students In Catholic schools, now have their mili tary organizations. Mr. Crothers ought to look elsewhere than In that peace congress to find out the reason why the military spirit prevails. He will find that middle-aged and old peo ple are behind the military spirit In all our church schools, agricultural colleges and even female colleges and Hunday-schools, not to speak of the famous boys’ battalions of the Boston, New York and Washington public schools. All this military spirit comes from the sanction, If not support, of the fsthers and mothers of the young peo ple concerned. For years past the military spirit has spread wonderfully Into our schools, our churches and our secret organisations, arid no peace movement, however strong and world wide. can check It, In Hyracuse. N. Y., they have a fine military company of young women, and In Atlanta, (la , the V. C. V. kave a uniformed com pany of young women. Out in Teaaa. as well as In acme other ctatee, female college# have girt companies Only a little while ago the young women of Troy, AJa, my homo he IM* 71 gave a public drill again#* the regular mIMUr) <-usspasty si the My auk m u*e
The report describes how the Crow Indians have reoccupied the site of old Fort Custer, building huts from dismantled barracks on the former parade ground. It notes the irony that the land taken from them by the U.S. military has reverted to their possession, near where Custer's forces once camped before his death.
Omaha Daily Bee · 18 December 1904 · page 11
Famons Post. Tha Crows have come Into their own again. What was once the site of old Fort Custer, one of the moat famous military posts of the northwest frontier, where the United States troops for a quarter of a century held In check the fierce red men of the mountains and plains, has reverted to the original owners of the lands, and the Crow Indians now gather to discuss the ancient glories of their tribe. Th9 parade ground has become an In dian village. The barracks have been dis mantled and hauled away, to be used In constructing Indian huts.
See moreSee less
The command ing general s fine residence Is now the domi cile of old Whlte-Earth-on-the-Forehead. who stables his favorite pony In the grand reception room where formerly gathered the military chieftains of the white army. Already more than 100 Indian shacks have been constructed from the materials taken from the old fort, and dally the tal men gather round the historic old ruins, fighting over some choice piece of timber.
William H. Davenport, a former vaudeville performer who had served with the Seventh Cavalry under Reno during the Custer massacre, died in Missoula of apoplexy. The report notes he was later commissioned a lieutenant for bravery before resigning after a decade to pursue a stage career.
Waterbury Evening Democrat · 19 December 1904 · page 5
I AUTIST IS DEAD . Missoula Mon, Dee 19. William II. Davenport, an old ; time, vaudeville artist" and former regular in the Unit ed States army. Is -dead here from apo plexy. Davenport was attached to the famous Seventh cavalry -as an en listed man and was with Reno at the time of the Custer massacre. On ac count of bravery ii that campaign he was appointed to -a lieutenancy, put resigned after holding his commission for ten yearsf to take up the theatri
The item reports that yet another man has falsely claimed to be a survivor of the Custer massacre, noting that such claims will likely multiply over time much like false Balaclava survivor stories. It asserts that in fact no white man who fought in the Battle of the Little Bighorn survived—all died—though some men had been sent away by Custer before the battle with messages.
The Hawaiian Star · 19 December 1904 · page 4
Wry to make banana brandy, as a means for making use of the bunches of bananas that are too small for ship ment. Another last survivor of the Custer massacre has been heard from. Before the last of this generation passes awny as many survivors of that bloody light will havo mado their appearance as last survivors of Ralaklava have. And that will be more than all the men en gaged In the Battle of the Little Big Horn, There Is every evldiiice that no white limn who took part In the battle Honpd alive, They died to a man. There were wine men eent twuy hy OiiKler before the Iwttl currying or di'a to Humi, TliMM vuim the iieureH It in wl U Imvtajf sy claim to
The Pacific Commercial Advertiser · Honolulu, Hawaiian Islands
A man named William McGee, who claims to be the sole white survivor of Custer's command at Little Bighorn, is arrested in New York for killing a man in a knife fight over cooking methods. McGee claims Custer sent him to deliver a message to Major Reno just before the massacre, and that he bears scars from wounds sustained during his escape.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
The Pacific Commercial Advertiser · 19 December 1904 · page 10
I ) THE LAST SURVIVOR OF THE CUSTER MASSACRE NEW YORK, Dec. 10. William McGee, who claims to be the sole vvhite survivor of Custer's command in the famous battle of Little Big Horn, is under arrest here charged with homicide. Late Thursday night he got into an argument with Frank Mit chell, a salesman, over the proper method for cooking a kidney stew. A quarrel followed and the men attacked each other with kitchen knives, the fracas having occurred in Mitchell's flat. McGee, who lived on the Western frontier forty years, declares Mitchell attacked him and by practicing an old trick he felled his opponent, not, however, until he received a severe scalp wound.
See moreSee less
Mitchell did not appear badly off at the time, but he died 24 hours later. McGee was arrested meantime in a newspaper office where he had gone to set the editor right regarding the story of the fight. . In telling of his service in the arnw, McGee declared he was detached by Custer, just before the massacre, to carry a message to Major Reno, who was to have made a joint attack with Custer's troops on the Indians. .ucuee Dears the scars of many wounds which he claims to. have received before he reached Reno's forces. Recently he came here irom xexas ana lias been canvassin g tor a magazine.
Will Davenport, a former Seventh Cavalry soldier and later vaudeville performer, died in Missoula, Montana of apoplexy. He had served with Reno during the Custer massacre and was promoted to lieutenant for bravery before resigning a decade later for the stage.
The Minneapolis Journal · 19 December 1904 · page 12
Regular and Vaudeville Artist. Missoula, Mont., Dec. 19.Will Davenport, an old-time vaudeville artist and ex-regular in the United States army, is dead here of apoplex y. was attached to the famous' Seventh cavalry, and was with Reno at the time of the Custer massacre. For bravery in that campaign he was appointed to a lieutenancy, but resigned after holding his commission for ten years to take up the theatrical profession.
Will K. Davenport, a former Seventh Cavalry lieutenant and later vaudeville performer, died suddenly in Missoula, Montana. He had served under Reno during the Custer massacre and was commissioned for bravery before leaving the army for the stage.
The Salt Lake Tribune · 19 December 1904 · page 2
Vaudeville Artist Dead. MISSOULA. Mont.. Dec. IS. Will K. Davenport, an old-time vaudeville artist and cx-lloutenant In the regular United States army, died suddenly today of ap oplexy. Davenport was attached to tho famous Seventh cavalry as an enlisted man and was with P.ono at the lime of the Custer massacre. On account of bravery in that campaign he was np pclntodvto a lieutenancy but resigned af--ter holding hia commission, for ten years, to take 'lip the theatrical profession. He was widely known throughout the West At one time ho conducted a theater In Wallace, Ida., and was on the Northwest circuit
A Missoula, Montana obituary reports the death of Will H. Davenport, a former vaudeville performer and Seventh Cavalry veteran who served under Reno during the Custer massacre. It notes he was promoted to lieutenant for bravery in that campaign before later pursuing a theatrical career.
The Saint Paul Globe · 20 December 1904 · page 9
DEATHS OF THE DAY
MISSOULA, Mont.. Dec. 19—Will H Davenport, an old time vaudeville artist and ex-regular in the United States army is dead here of apoplexy. He was at tached to the famous Seventh cavalry as an enlisted man and was with^Renb at the time of the Custer massacrer On ac count of bravery in that campaign he vas appointed to a lieutenancy but reBigned after holding his commission ten years to take up the theatrical profes sion. Machen Gets a Stay
The Fargo Forum and Daily Republican · Fargo, N.D.
A Missoula dispatch reports the death of Will H. Davenport, a former Fargo vaudeville stage manager and ex-U.S. Army officer, who died of apoplexy. The notice recalls that he served with Reno's command during the Custer massacre and was later promoted to lieutenant for bravery before leaving the army for the theater.
The Fargo Forum and Daily Republican · 20 December 1904 · page 7
OLD-TIME FARGOAN IS DEAD IN MONTANA
In the early eighties, Davenport was well known in Fargo. He was stage .manager of the variety theatre con ducted by McCauley & Reynolds on the corner of N. P. Avenue. At that time John Guerin was the star per former in the concert halls and the plays in which the favorite was fea tured were put on under the direction of Davenport, who left here in 1&87 to go to Montana. Davenport was a great favorite with old timers and many now living in the city remember him well. He first came to Fargo in 1880. not long after the Custer massacre.
Will H. Davenport, a former vaudeville performer and ex-U.S. Army regular, died of apoplexy in Missoula, Montana. He had served as an enlisted man in the Seventh Cavalry and was with Reno's command at the time of the Custer massacre.
The Madison Daily Leader · 20 December 1904 · page 4
United States army, is dead at Mis soula. Mont., of apoplexy. Davenport was attaihi»| the famous Seventh cavalry as an enlisted man and was with Reno at the time of the Custer massacre.
Will H. Davenport, a former vaudeville performer and ex-army lieutenant, died suddenly of apoplexy. The report notes he had been an enlisted man in the Seventh Cavalry and was with Reno's command during the Custer massacre.
The Western News · 21 December 1904 · page 2
MONTANA NEWS.
cure bail. Will H. Davenport, an old time vau deville artist and ex-lieutenant in the regular United States army, died sud denly Sunday of apoplexy. Davenport was attached to the famous Seventh cavalry as an enlisted man, and was with Reo at the time of the Custer massacre.
The report announces the death of Will H. Davenport, a former vaudeville performer and ex-U.S. Army soldier, who had served with Reno's command at the time of the Custer massacre. It claims he was later commissioned a lieutenant for bravery before resigning after ten years to pursue theater.
The Bee · 22 December 1904 · page 1
000 to 350000 I Seelbach Realty Company + of Louisville increasing its capital stock from 500000 tc 050000 Survivor of Custer Massacre Dies tisso luMont Dec 10 Will H DavenporC an old ti me vaudeville artist and ex regular in the United States army is dead here of apoplexy Daven pprt was attached to the famous Seventh cavalry as an enlisted E man and was with Reno at the time Of the Custer massacre On account of b avery in that cam o paign he was appointed to a lieutenancy but resigned after I
A 1904 Hood River newspaper notes that G. W. Halloway, a former Indian scout under General Miles, is visiting the town. The piece recalls his service in the Big Horn country shortly after the Custer massacre, chasing Sioux in freezing conditions.
The Hood River Glacier · 22 December 1904 · page 7
the Big Horn country shortly; after the Custer massacre, is in Hood River, tlalloway is o2 years old, and while no one won Id take him to be that old, he says he is beginning to feel theeffects of the hardships of his youth, and hit joints are not so limber as they were when he chased the festive Sionx in the Rockies with the mercury 40 below zero. The old scout can relate many interesting ex periencea of his narrow escapes from the red skins.
George Knapp reports receiving a letter from his brother Ezra C. Knapp, who had been missing and presumed dead for about 26-28 years after supposedly dying in the Custer massacre. Ezra is actually alive and well, living in Carson City, Nevada, and sends greetings to old acquaintances.
The Bennington Evening Banner · 22 December 1904 · page 4
Carson City, Nevada. Is enjoying good health and sends best wishes to any who may remember him and wish to know of him. His brother George living here in speaking of it. said that they supposed that his brother lost his life in the Custer massacre.
The report describes how the abandoned Fort Custer, built near the Little Bighorn battlefield to subdue the Crow and other tribes, has been dismantled and its site reoccupied by Indians building shacks from the old timber. It recounts the fort's 1877 founding on the former Crow village site following Custer's death, framing the current reversal as an irony of history.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
Omaha Daily Bee · 25 December 1904 · page 4
Which Thj Wert DrivM ii '78. . VILLAGE FORMED ON PARADE GROUND Old Chief White Earth Hits the Pipe la the Commaaalsar - OAeer's Quarters History of a Famous Post. Tbe Crows have come Into their own again. What was once the site of old Fort Custer, one of the most famous military posts of the northwest frontier, where the I'nlted States troops for a quarter of a century held In check the fierce red men of the mountains and plains, hasreverted to the original owners of the lands, and the Crow Indians now gather to discuss the ancient glories of their tribe.
See moreSee less
The parade ground has become an In dian village. The barracks have been dis mantled and hauleu away, to be used In constructing Indian huts. The command ing general's fine residence Is now the domi cile of old White-Earth-on-the-Forehead, who stables his favorite pony In the grand reception room where formerly gathered the military chieftains of the white army. Already more than ICO Indian shacks have been constructed from the materials taken from the old fort, and dally the tel men gather round the historic old ruins, fighting over some choice piece of timber. Iroay of Circumstances. It Is the Irony of fate that the site of the old fort, wrested from the Indians by force of arms, should In time return to the keeping of the Identical band of In dians from whom It was taken, and who today are making their campflres Just where their tepees stood before General Custer was massacred and before the per manent invasion of the "Crow country" by the white soldiers. After Sitting Bull and Raln-ln-the-Face and their 6.0UO Sioux and Cheyenne war riors had exterminated Custer and his lit tle band of 20 soldiers of the Seventh on the brown hills -of the Crow country, the government war officials determined to build a stronghold which would overawe tho natives of the northern plains. An expedition was sent out to find a suit Able place, In tho very heart of the new post. JuHt two years after Custer died a fort bearing his name was built about ten miles down the Little Big Horn river from where the monument stands which marks the resting place und bears the names of the gallant soldiers who rode with Yellow Hair to a frightful and glorious death. At the confluence of the Big Horn and the Little Big Horn rivers, on a high bluff which commands the country In all direc tions, waa the chief village of the Crow In dians. In the spring of 1878 long wagon trails and large bodies of American troops came up the Big Horn Valley, and soon small flat-bottomed steamboats pushed up the Yellowstone and thence into the Big Horn, coming to anchor at the Crow vil lage. Most Extensive Post in West. With scant ceremony the IndUns were driven from the traditional home of their great chiefs, anj before the snow fell that winter Fort Custer was well und.r way. In time tho new post became the most ex tensive in the entire northwest, and many expeditions went from the Bhelter of Its barracks in Wyoming, Montana and other states. The stream of settlers that po ire into the great northwest owed Its protec tion from the Indians more to old tort Custer than to any other army post along its line of travel. That which the Indians failed to accom plish with tho bow and arrow and scalping knife they have effected with the plow share, and by accepting to a. certuln ex tent the civilization of the white man have rendered unnecessary the close proximity to their homes of an army post. When the call to arms came In the spring of 1888 the soldiers at Fort Custer were sent to Cuba, and the post Itself waa abandoned. A small guard was stationed there for some years, and last summer the work of dismantling was begun. When the post was abandoned the build ings reverted to the original owne.s of the ground, and so the Crow Indian tribe became the proprietor of the old fort. The Indian agent, Colonel S. Q. Reynolds, has been distributing the building materials contained in the different structures to those Indians living in the vicinity, and as a result many old bucks who have lived In tepees all their lives will this winter for the first time spend the cold mouths within a small shack, the walls of which were formerly some part of the barracks or even "officers' row." One House Steading. Over on "officers' row:' there is Just one house standing. Years ago the com manding officer of the post lived thera and many military functions took i lace within its walls. But now the new owner, White-Earth-on-the-Forehead, proudly passes his red plpestone calumet around the circle which he and his friends have formed within the large dlnlngroom, while the favorite "calico" pony of the old In dian stamps his feet and eata his hay In the big reception room and watches his reflection In the French plate mlrrora which line the walls. Just within the confines of the post, off toward the south, is still to be seen, the old stage coach and the station at Which the vehicle ended ita long Journey from Chey enne, 600 miles away. Both the stage and the station are in a dilapidate condition, but the former will be renoved to the agency and preserved as a "memento of the early pioneer days. In Its palmy days the old fort boasted of a haunted house, and every stick of timber In that building remains on the original site. Not a brave on the reservation will accept a piece of the house which waa formerly "bad medicine" to them, and the Indian agent says he can do nothing ex cept burn the debrla of the structure. Remains of the waterworks system are on every hand, the Iron hydranta lifting their heads even among the tepees of the Indian village on the parade ground. But no water can be drswn from the pines and the supply tube to the standplpe la dry and twlated. Even the carriage of the old cannon which commanded and protected the pump ing atatlon in the river valley waa left In position when the troops started for Cuba. One wheel is broken and the Iron tires have fallen from the felloes, but the ammuni tion box Is yet intact. v The magazine ia being torn down by the Crows and the bricks are being removed to soma of the new Indian houses, where they will be used to build chimneys, tbe very first tbe Crows have ever used. Establish a Cemetery. ml' above the old fort the Indians have founded one of the above-ground cemeteries, the dead being wrapped In blankets and depoalted on high scaffolds. There was g time when the Crows burled their dead with the weapons and trinkets owned while alive. But when the erase for elk teeth aroat the Indians climbed the scaffolds, un wrapped the bodlea and . secured the elk teeth, which they sold at good prices. No snore teeth are burled with the dead now. The old fort and the new Indian village stand on the dividing line between that part of the Crow reserve which will be opened to the white man next year for settlement and the portion which the Indiana reserve to themselves. Of the former there are bout 1. 000. 000 acres. Before the tepee ot the chiefs, as tf as the eye can see, both
This 1904 report describes the Crow Indians reoccupying the site of old Fort Custer, dismantling abandoned barracks to build their own village on the former parade ground. It reflects on the irony that the land taken from the Crow by the army has now reverted to them.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Arrested in New York for stabbing a man in a quarrel, William McGee claims he was present at Little Bighorn as a civilian packer and Custer's messenger. He describes being sent to carry word to Reno before the fatal charge, and repeats the tale that Curley the scout survived by disguising himself in a war bonnet.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 6 days later.
Wrong
Bismarck Daily Tribune · 26 December 1904 · page 1
Custer Massacre. In a Washington paper sent the Tribune by Charley Gurley, is the fol lowing regarding Wm. McGee, the al leged Custer "survivor" recently ar rested on a charge of stabbing a com panion in a quarrel at a restaurant: *J,While waiting for his hearing be fore Magistrate Pool, in the Yorkville police court, McGee told the story of hiq part in the Custer fight. It has been told before in the west. Of the doomed three hundred who were in that fatal and glorious charge, only one came out alive.
See moreSee less
That was Curley, a who disguised himself in a Bcout, war bonnet and sneaked away. This man McGee was of the detachment, but not in the charge he had been sent back not ten minutes before to carry a message of Maj. Reno. He is a queer figure in a New York court. The experienced eye would spot him anywhere for the old plains man and gun fighter. Small, erect, alert, iron gray, all his movements have a catlike ease and precision. His step is quick, fiatfooted, silent. His feet point straight forward as he walks. Under his brows are the straight glancing, blue-gray eyes which go with straight shooting. He said. "I was only a kid then, but strong. I enlisted as civilian packer for the Little Big Horn expedition, and before we got up to the buttes I was a kind of order ly for Custer—scurrying 'round carry ing messages—because I was light and rode fast.' "Custer had set his watch with Reno's and they were to charge from opposite sides of the village at the same time. They agreed to that when they split forces. But Custer couldn't make it as fast as he wanted. He was his own detachment got up. He called me and Wagner, his trumpeter. He said: Fatal Error of His Companion. 'Stienie,'—that was my nickname— 'get over to Maj. Reno and tell him to hold in for twenty minutes.' He salt? the same to Wagner. He sent two or us to make sure the message would get there, I guess.' 'And keep out of sight,' he said. "Now, I knew Injuns and how to keep out of sight, but Wagner was a Farmers Lose Money. Most of the successes in agriculture are. only partial. Farmers as a rule do not realize maximum returns for their work and time. They lose mon ey through lack of technical informa tion. Technical knowledge, coupled with industry and prudence, compels success. The Breeder's Gazette is a 60-page illustrated live stock and 48 to most reliable information along these basic lines. It tells him how, why and when. It teaches economy through improved methods and better live stock. It helps the farmer to solve all the problems which beset him in his work. Its regular persual will enable him to convert losses into profits. With Its profusion of beautiful pic tures of live stock and farm scenes, and its columns of practical informa tion, to stimulates larger interest in and love for the country, indicating its pecuniary possibilities and emphasiz ing the wholesomeness and independ ence of rural life. The Christmas number of The Gazette, just from the press, contains 84 pages, and is replete I with illustrations, many of them suit able for farming, and artistically illus grated articles, which are thrilling, in structive and enlivening, written by writers of national repute. This great Mln* new your subscription, it will be dia-
A veteran recalls the day of the battle, describing Custer as a 'hardheaded, swell-headed Dutchman' who insisted on cutting across the hills despite warnings, leading to his isolation. He also describes arriving at a ridge to see Reno's troops surrounded by Indians riding in circles and firing.
Bismarck Daily Tribune · 26 December 1904 · page 1
Custer Massacre. In a Washington paper sent the Tribune by Charley Gurley, is the fol lowing regarding Wm. McGee, the al leged Custer "survivor" recently ar rested on a charge of stabbing a com panion in a quarrel at a restaurant: *J,While waiting for his hearing be fore Magistrate Pool, in the Yorkville police court, McGee told the story of hiq part in the Custer fight. It has been told before in the west. Of the doomed three hundred who were in that fatal and glorious charge, only one came out alive.
See moreSee less
That was Curley, a who disguised himself in a Bcout, war bonnet and sneaked away. This man McGee was of the detachment, but not in the charge he had been sent back not ten minutes before to carry a message of Maj. Reno. He is a queer figure in a New York court. The experienced eye would spot him anywhere for the old plains man and gun fighter. Small, erect, alert, iron gray, all his movements have a catlike ease and precision. His step is quick, fiatfooted, silent. His feet point straight forward as he walks. Under his brows are the straight glancing, blue-gray eyes which go with straight shooting. He said. "I was only a kid then, but strong. I enlisted as civilian packer for the Little Big Horn expedition, and before we got up to the buttes I was a kind of order ly for Custer—scurrying 'round carry ing messages—because I was light and rode fast.' "Custer had set his watch with Reno's and they were to charge from opposite sides of the village at the same time. They agreed to that when they split forces. But Custer couldn't make it as fast as he wanted. He was afraid that Reno would charge before bunch of men in blue army uniforms his own detachment got up. He called me and Wagner, his trumpeter. He said: Fatal Error of His Companion. 'Stienie,'—that was my nickname— 'get over to Maj. Reno and tell him to hold in for twenty minutes.' He salt? the same to Wagner. He sent two or us to make sure the message would get there, I guess.' 'And keep out of sight,' he said. "Now, I knew Injuns and how to keep out of sight, but Wagner was a hardheaded, swell-headed Dutchman, ure it out that he'd tried to get away He wanted to cut straight across we' and the Injuns had caught him on the buttes so's to get there qulCK. run. That's rot. as I've told vou. I've "The Injuns'll see you, you blame! always figured that Custer "would 'a' fool,' says I. I knew there was plenty' stood a heap better chance if that of time to go back and make it by folDutchman hadn't got original." Farmers Lose Money. lowing up the trail. I bet he argued half a mile and at he said he'd go laBt anyhow. I let him go. He lived about three minutes. B'l-1-1 the rifles went^' just like that. There w§re fourteen .• holes in his body when they found it. I always belteved that he. gave Sitting Bull's band the first notice that Custer was coming—got 'em prepared to meet the charge the way they did. "For in a minute there was shooting all along the Horn. I rode to the fork and took the trail for Reno's command. 1 You know they caught Aster on a hillside, and he made. a running fight backward up the hill. "When I came out on the summit, there they were—the troops blazing away in a bunch, and the valley filled with Indians as far as you* could see, riding in circles and' blazing away, as they rode. How Reno would ever make it out alive I couldn't see, but It was my business to get down to him, so I spurred my horse and rode like hell. Wounded, but Reached Reno. "I was half way down before the In dians saw me coming, all alone, and turned loose on me. I was thirty yards away from our rear when I felt my horse cave in and drop. He had got it through the flank. I jumped up to run for it—and I got it—square through the thigh. Somehow I made it into the line and up beside Reno. Of course, the message was too damn late. "Well, it was simple hell, a whole day of it. We laid out, thirsty and done up, and the men fighting and everybody expecting Custer. 1 can't remember much. I was too sick. 1 just remember this: Four hours be fore we were relieved, the boys see a come riding down the river. They jumped out of the trenches and cheered ana threw up their hats, because they thought it was the relief. The met in blue uniforms turned and fired on us. They were the Sioux, dressed in the clothes they'd taken off Custer's men, getting out because their scouts had said that Cook was coming. "You'll remember that it says in all the histories how Wagner's body was found three-quarters of a mile from the bunch of Custer's men. They fig-
A veteran recalls riding alone through gunfire to reach Reno's besieged troops after being sent from Custer's column, getting wounded along the way. He describes the desperate four-day siege, including the cruel moment when soldiers mistook Sioux warriors wearing captured cavalry uniforms for rescuers.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 6 days later.
Wrong
Bismarck Daily Tribune · 26 December 1904 · page 1
w# jyT cum. PRICE Five lowing up the trail. I bet he argued half a mile and at he said he'd go laBt anyhow. I let him go. He lived about three minutes. B'l-1-1 the rifles went^' just like that. There w§re fourteen .• holes in his body when they found it. I always belteved that he. gave Sitting Bull's band the first notice that Custer was coming—got 'em prepared to meet the charge the way they did. "For in a minute there was shooting all along the Horn. I rode to the fork and took the trail for Reno's command.
See moreSee less
1 You know they caught Aster on a hillside, and he made. a running fight backward up the hill. "When I came out on the summit, there they were—the troops blazing away in a bunch, and the valley filled with Indians as far as you* could see, riding in circles and' blazing away, as they rode. How Reno would ever make it out alive I couldn't see, but It was my business to get down to him, so I spurred my horse and rode like hell. Wounded, but Reached Reno. "I was half way down before the In dians saw me coming, all alone, and turned loose on me. I was thirty yards away from our rear when I felt my horse cave in and drop. He had got it through the flank. I jumped up to run for it—and I got it—square through the thigh. Somehow I made it into the line and up beside Reno. Of course, the message was too damn late. "Well, it was simple hell, a whole day of it. We laid out, thirsty and done up, and the men fighting and everybody expecting Custer. 1 can't remember much. I was too sick. 1 just remember this: Four hours be fore we were relieved, the boys see a come riding down the river. They jumped out of the trenches and cheered ana threw up their hats, because they thought it was the relief. The met in blue uniforms turned and fired on us. They were the Sioux, dressed in the clothes they'd taken off Custer's men, getting out because their scouts had said that Cook was coming. "You'll remember that it says in all the histories how Wagner's body was found three-quarters of a mile from the bunch of Custer's men. They fig-
This piece revisits the controversy over Major Reno's actions during the Little Bighorn battle, noting that the Court of Inquiry he demanded declined to recommend further action against him, though many officers still held him culpable. It cites a newly published narrative by Cyrus Townsend Brady concluding that Reno lost his head during the crisis.
The Salt Lake Herald · 27 December 1904 · page 7
WHY RENO FAILED CUSTER
The words of this article could not be separated from the rest of its page. Read it in the clipping.
A temperance advocate publication quotes a claim that Major Reno privately confessed to the late Rev. Dr. Arthur Edwards that his erratic conduct at the Little Bighorn was due to being drunk. The report frames this confession as explaining Reno's actions and his later dismissal from the army for drunken misconduct.
The Salt Lake Herald · 27 December 1904 · page 7
knew him well ell and continued d his alto faithful altoful I wag as drunk To Arthur Edwards who whoknew ful friend Major 3jor Rend often unbur unburdened unburdened dened his heart and on one occasion in indeep indeep deep sorro sorrow said that hIs strangI a atrnns < I Ilions lions were due to drink His action at atthe atthe the batt or the LIttle Big Born waS waSdttd wascited cited 85 one instance instanceMajor InatanceMajor Major Rc Reno o was as di dismissed nIssed from the the1rmy thermy 1rmy rmy ftYr tur years after the Custer dis disaster disaster aster for getting drunk publicly ns nsltaulthtg asieaulting ltaulthtg a fellow officer and otherwise otherwisebeh1nl otherwisebehaving behaving scandalous It Is t trtain trtainthat rtain rtainthat that his use 01 IIqu 11400r r blought this 50 50dlers sotilers
Will H. Davenport, a former vaudeville performer and ex-lieutenant in the U.S. Army, died suddenly of apoplexy in Missoula, Montana. He had served as an enlisted man in the Seventh Cavalry and was with Reno's command during the Custer massacre.
Shoshone Journal · 30 December 1904 · page 6
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.