Der Deutsche Correspondent · Baltimore, Md. · and 1 other paper
A man named William McGee, who claimed to have fought under Custer at the Little Bighorn, got into a dispute with saloon-keeper Frank Mitchell over the best method of treating a kidney stone. The argument escalated to a knife fight in which Mitchell was fatally wounded and McGee was arrested for manslaughter.
Der Deutsche Correspondent · 1 January 1905 · page 7
Auch ein Streitobjekt. In einer Wirthschaft in New Uorl ent stand unlängst zwischen einem gewissen William McGee, welcher, seiner Be hauptung zufolge, unter Custer das blutige Gefecht am Little Big Horn mitmachte, und dem Verkäufer Frank
Nebraska Staats-Anzeiger Und Herold · Grand Island, Nebraska · 30 December 1904
Bismarck Daily Tribune · Bismarck, N.D.
A correspondent who served at Fort Lincoln disputes claims by a man named McGee who was posing in New York as a survivor of the Custer Massacre. He asserts the real messenger to Reno was Trumpeter Martin (an Italian named Maratene), and calls McGee a liar and fraud.
Medora, N. D., Dec. 29, 1904. The Tribune: I was surprised to see that The Tribune would print such slush, as it lately published, about one McGee, who has been posing in New York, lately, as the only true survivor of the Custer Massacre. It is a fact, which appears to me," should be welj known to The Tribune, that the man who carried the last order from Gen eral Custer to Major Reno, was Trumpeter Martin, or to use the Italian name of this man, for he was an Italian, Maratene.
See moreSee less
The writer was well acquainted with Trumpeter Martin. We were both stationed at Fort Abraham Lincoln twenty-six years ago. During the winter of 1878-9 there was a court of inquiry at Chicago, convened at the request of Major Reno, to investigate his actions during the battle of the Little Big Horn many of the officers at Fort Lincoln were ordered ibefore this court, to give testimony. Trum peter Martin was also ordered there but who ever heard of McGqe? McGee, qr ypsr account of him, makea him say thai he was vary yotmg at ill* time of-this battlef thwt he kfie* much about Indians that lie 'enlists
A review of a book collecting narratives of frontier military engagements, including a chapter on the Little Big Horn campaign and the death of Custer. The reviewer notes the book concludes Custer was to blame for the defeat due to disobedience and rashness, with Major Reno faring worst in the account.
The Salt Lake Tribune · 1 January 1905 · page 56
THE GLORY OF THE SOLDIER
I Further Discussion of tho Beaver rceK Affair," "Tho Battle of the Washita,' "Carr and Tail Bull at Summit Springs." This Is all a series of storle-s of discon nected fights, having no common purpose, though each Is glorious In itself, and blood-stirring In tho telling Then comes Part II.. which takes up apeciflcally "Tho War with tho Sioux," under tho titles, "With Crook's Advance." "Ex-Trooper Towno on tho Ro-ebud Fight," "Tho Grievance of Raln-ln-tho-Faee," "Tho Littlo Big Hern Campaign "Tho Lost of Custer," "Ono of the Last Men to Seo Custer Alive," "Tho Personal Story of Raln-ln-the-Face."
See moreSee less
"Two Inter esting Affairs," "The First Success," "A Decisive Blow," ' Mlles's Great Cam paign." "What They aro There for a Sketch of General Guy V. Henry, a Typ ical American Soldier," and two appon . dlxcs close the volume, which Is profuscl and spiritedly Illustrated Tho narratives are written with a vigor nnd absorbing stylo which make the read ing a puro delight. Every effort seems to havo been made to verify facts and claims, and to reconcile or present what ever varying shades of opinion may havo been held as to important matters. Among it all tho most momentous Is the lftlng of the blamo for tho defeat of Custer commonly but erroneously styled tho Cus ter massacre, for it was a fair, open fight. In tho pursuance of well-uetlned military movements on both sides. The conclu sion Is drawn, and It Is Irresistible from the facts and official orders as presented, that Custer himself wan to blame, for disulktuii'iici ui vrui'ra aim wiiiuuii rviMUsS-
The article profiles Charles M. Russell, the cowboy artist, reproducing his painting 'Custer's Last Stand' alongside an autobiographical sketch of his early life in Montana. Russell recounts working as a sheepherder, trapper, and cowboy before becoming famous for his Western art.
The Billings Gazette · 3 January 1905 · page 6
FIRST WAS A SHEEP HERDER
Range Rider. Charles M. Russell of Great Falls, familiarly known as "the cowboy art ist," occupies a prominent place in the Christmas number of Outing. Three of his best-known pictures, "The Scout," "The Attack" and "Custer's
A New York newspaper reports a deadly bar fight between William McGee, who claimed to have fought under Custer at Little Bighorn, and salesman Frank Mitchell, sparked by a dispute over the best way to make kidney stew. Mitchell died of stab wounds, and McGee, covered in old scars he attributes to the battle, was arrested for manslaughter.
Indiana Tribüne · 4 January 1905 · page 1
Auch ein Streitobjekt
.William McGee. welcher, seiner Behauptung zufolge, unter Custer das blutige Gefecht am Little Big Horn Mitmachte, und dem Verkäufer Frank Mitchell ein Streit über die beste Methode ' der Herstellung eines Nieren stews. wobei sie sich derartig erhitzten, daß sie zu ihren Messern griffen und Mitchell schließlich den Kürzeren zog und kampfunfähig wurde. Kurze Zeit darauf erlag er den erhaltenen Ver letzungen. McGee, welcher wegen Todt schlags in Haft genommen wurde, hat viele warben an seinem Körper, die er sämmtlich in dem erwähnten Kampf erhalten haben will.
A reader writes to correct the claim that Comanche was the only survivor, asserting a horse named Mage, ridden by Lieut. Crittenton, also survived and was later shot by the government in 1877. The writer says he knew of this horse from Fort Abercrombie days.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
The Dickinson Press · 7 January 1905 · page 2
Beicegel, N. D., Dec. 30, 1904. Editor of the Press:—As I was look ing over the PRESS I noticed an item taken from the Bismarck Tribune say ing, as they understood it, Comanche was the only living thing that survived the Custer Massacre. I knew of one other, Mage, a black horse, ridden by Lieut. John J. Crittenton. I knew of this horse in 187? at Fort Abercrorr.bie. He was sent to Fort Lincoln for Lieut. Crittenton to ride on that expedition, and when the Indians were dismounted in 1877 he was brought into Standing Rock with a herd of Indian ponies. He was afterwards condemned by the government and shot. C. O. ARMSTRONG.
A letter writer identifies himself as a former soldier at Fort Abraham Lincoln who personally knew Trumpeter Martin, the real messenger who carried Custer's last order to Major Reno. He denounces a man named McGee who has been falsely claiming in New York to be the sole true survivor of the battle, calling him 'a liar and a fraud.'
The Dickinson Press · 7 January 1905 · page 2
No Stock in McGee. Medora, N. D., Dec. 29,1904. The Tribune: I was surprised to see that the Tribune would print such slush, as it lately published, about one McGee, who has been posing in New York lately, as the only true survivor ol the Custer Massacre. It is a fact, which appears to me should be well known to the Tribune, that the man who carried the last order from General Custer to Major Reno, was Trumpeter Mart-n, or, to use the Italian name of this man, for he was an Italian, Mara tene.
See moreSee less
The writer was well acquainted with Trumpeter Martin. We' were both stationed at Fort Abraham Lincoln twenty-six years ago. During the winter of 1878-9 there was a court of inquiry at Chicago, convened at the request of Major Reno, to investigate his actions during the battle of the Little Big Horn many of the officers at Fort Lincoln were ordered before this court to give testimony. Trumpeter Martin was also ordered there, but who ever heard of McGee? McGee, or your account of him. makes him say that he was very young at the time of' this battle that he knew much about Indians that he enlisted as a sort of civilian packer that he was a sort of orderly for General Custer, all ol which is, to an old soldier, nonsense. Perhaps the best account ever written of the battle of the 2^th of June, 1879, was written by Captain Godfrey, for merly of the 7th cavalry but he does not mention McGee. This man McGee is a liar and a fraud. I learn that Martin is now on the retired list of the armv.
The Fargo Forum and Daily Republican · Fargo, N.D.
A reader writing to the Dickinson Press challenges an earlier claim that Comanche was the only living survivor of the Custer massacre, recalling another horse named Mage ridden by Lieutenant Crittenton. The writer states this horse survived, was later captured with Indian ponies in 1877, and was eventually condemned and shot by the government.
The Fargo Forum and Daily Republican · 10 January 1905 · page 6
SURVIVOR
EQUINE :SURViVO&. C. O, Armstrong in The Dickin son Press: As I was looking Over The Press' I noticed an item taken from The Bismarck Tribune saying, as they understood it, Comanche was the only living thing that survived the Custer massacre. I knew of one other, Mage a black horse, ridden by Lieut. John J. Crittenion. I knew of this horse
A North Dakota collector acquired an old Winchester rifle said to date from 1860 and to have been carried by a Sioux warrior at the Little Bighorn in 1876. The gun was reportedly recovered from a Sioux refugee captured after returning from Canada in 1880.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 2 days later.
Wrong
The Miller Sun · 11 January 1905 · page 6
A VALUABLE RELIC. Winchester Rifle Carried by Indian in Custer Massacre. During a recent visit to North Dakota J. F. Waller, a resident of Brown Coun ty, became the possessor of a valuable relic. It is one of the first Winchester rifles ever manufactured, the date of its make being 1860. It went through the Custer massacre on the Little Big Horn River on June 25, 1876, and was carried by a Sioux Indian who had stolen or purchased it before that terrible event. The old weapon was in the possession of one of the Sioux refugees who were captured by United States cavalry in the Bad Lauds of what is now South Dako ta after their return in 1880 from Cana da, where they had taken refuge after the massacre of Custer and his com mand.
See moreSee less
The gun is indeed a curiosity, the workmanship being very crude as com pared with modern repeating rifles. Arrested at Last. S. J. Con£ was arrested at Minneapolis charged with the theft of a valuable w’ork team from John Stransky, of Puk wana. A little more than a month ago. Stransky and Conn, who was then his neighbor, had an altercation, and that night Stransky’s team was stolen and Conn was missing. He sold the team to an auctioneer in Minneapolis for S3OO and was engaged in spending the money County Seat War. The people of Selby, who wore defeat ed at the November election in their ef fort to secure the Walworth County seat from Bangor, drove to the latter town, thirty strong, Tuesday night, and took the records from the court house vaults. The raid surprised Bangor people, who knew nothing of it till Wednesday morn ing, when they found the records miss ing. More Than Expected. V. K. Stillwell and B. N.* Ward, of Alexandria, have taken an inventory of property owned by the late Rev. Dr. Kroeger. They report the value of us seta greater than was anticipated at the outset, and while unable at this time to give the exact figures place the sum at over SIOO,OOO. The business of the sani tarium and laboratory will be continued.
A North Dakota collector obtained a Winchester rifle said to have been carried by a Sioux warrior at the Little Bighorn in 1876. The gun reportedly was later found among Sioux refugees captured after their return from Canada in 1880.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Dakota Chief · 12 January 1905 · page 2
A VALUABLE RELIC. Winchester Rifle Carried by Indian in Cuater Massacre. During a recent visit to North Dakota O. F. Waller, a resident of'Brown Coun ty, became the possessor of a valuable relic. It is one of the first Winchester rifles ever manufactured, the date of its make being 1860. It went through the Custer massacre on the Little Big Horn River on .Tune IK, 1876, and was carried by a Sioux Indian who had stolen or purchased it before that terrible event. The old weapon was in the possession of one of the Sioux refugees who were raptured by T’nlted States cavalry in the Bad Lands of what is now South Dako ta after their return in 1880 from Cana da, where they had taken refuge after the massacre or Custer and his com mand.
See moreSee less
The gun is indeed a curiosity, the workmanship being very crude «« com pared with modern repeating rifles. Quite a Faintly Affair. At the time nf the , nomination of Speaker Browne for rr-elctiou to his old place Representatives Brown of Sanborn, and Brown of Brookings, seconded the nomination in the name of the Brown family. A note was hurriedly sent to the presiding officer suggesting that the three Browns on the floor, from Brook ings. Lincoln nd Sanborn Counties, be npfioint«’d a cortttrtlftce o/ r&ort. but the dote was slow in getting to the Officer, and the honor was conferred elsewhere. Won Icl Have Gam* Law* Changed. An enthusiastic meeting of the sports men of the Black Hills has been held at Lead (qr the purpose of haring the laws changed by the state legislature for the hunting of game. Tt is proposed to have the sentcui far deer hunting open a month earlier, Oct. IS, instead of Nov. Hl, and also make the limit two instead of three months for the killing of doer. * " - ■ Bede Fourche Man Mhot. •lames Rujodl, a young man of Belle Fourche, wns shot and dangerously wounded by Brnce Sebastian. Sebastian hl’ b-'tn pl-K—d under urrest, and con tends that the shooting waa done in iwlf
An Aberdeen man named O. F. Waller acquired an early Winchester rifle dated 1860 while visiting North Dakota, said to have been carried by a Sioux warrior at the Little Bighorn battle on June 25, 1876. The gun was reportedly taken from a Sioux refugee captured in 1880 after the group's return from exile in Canada following the battle.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Reporter and Farmer · 12 January 1905 · page 2
1 tU| either matter lies with having the roads ; perform their proper functions as j common carriers in a strictly busi nesslike and impartial manner and ■ do nothing else. Old Relic,One of the First of its Kind. During a recent visit to North Dakota, O. F. Waller an Aberdeen • *< man, became the possessor of a valu able relic. It is one of the first Winchester rifles ever manufactured, the date of its make being 1860. It went through the Custer massacre on the Little Big Horn river on June 25, 1876, and was carried by a Sioux ludian who undoubtedly had stolen or purchased it before that terrible event.
See moreSee less
The old weapon was in the pos session of one of the Sioux refugees who were captured by United States cavalry in the bad lands of what is now South Dakota after their return in 1880 from Canada, where they had taken refuge after the massacre of General Custer aud his command. The gun is indeed a curiousity, the workmanship being very crude as compared with modern repeating rifles. In its right side is the place where the cartridges were slid into the magazine. The bottom of the barrel is well worn by its constant contact with the pommel of the Indian’s saddle on the many long marches it must have been carried by its old-time redskinned owner. It is one of the most authentic and valuable relics of the sternuous times of the past on the Dakota and Montana frontiers, as it actually fig. ured in many battles waged by the warlike Sioux against the encroach ing palefaces. Father Kroeger’s Secret. Back of the life aud wonderful finan cial saooess of Father William Kroeger, the priest healer of Epiphany, who died on Deoember Bth, lies a story of dis grace borne bravely and restitution to the last iota. That this was the seoret of Fathers Kroeger’s desire to build up a mouey making basinets in Epiphany has not until now been generally known. One uight in Deoember, 1891, Father Kroeger, who had been pastor of the Oatholic parish at Elkhart, Ind., disappeared. He had bnilt far the par ish, which he had found practically penuiless, a ohnrch so handsome that it was termed a cathedral. The finance his plant for the parish he engaged iu numerous including stores, a dray line, a medicine factory and others. He simply became involved so deeply that he conld not extricate him self. In a moment of weakness he fled. Elkhart did not hear of Father Kroeger for six years and then cheoks began arriving. Slowly bnt conscientiously •very dollar of the principal and inter est of the heavy debt he had left in Elkhart was paid. This is why he bnilt at Epiphany a medieal business that readied almost from ooaat to ooast, bnilt the towns of Epiphany and Kroe ger, and incidently acquired a fortune of SBOO,OOO. It was for this mum reason that, he persisted when reprimanted by the church authorities for negleotiug his parish duties. He went to Rome aud explained and he was not oritiaed fnythML’ - Lease of Common School and Endow ment Lends. (Jan Utar) IJotkC* is hereby given that on March S ltW, all unleused common school and en dowment lands iu Day county will be offered for lease at public suction between the hours of lOoclock a. m. and » ociodk f* “' id* the door of the court house Doted at Plane, January Commissioner of School am! Public Lands ■ *<-. •< [■ 1 Pew Railroads Pail in 1904. THE FEET OF HORSES. Railroad insolvencies in 1904 were hflaeae* •( Ml on Sh«i» ■»< T»m (arc mt Hoof*. An English agricultural Journal says that the nature of the soli on which horses are bred and reared has a cer
A Brown County, South Dakota resident named O. F. Waller acquired an old Winchester rifle, manufactured around 1866, that was reportedly carried by a Sioux warrior at the Battle of Little Bighorn in 1876. The gun had been found among Sioux refugees captured by U.S. cavalry after their return from Canada in 1880.
Hot Springs Weekly Star · 13 January 1905 · page 3
A VALUABLE RELIC. Winchester Ilille Curried by Indian in C'tister Massacre. During a recent visit to North Dakota O. F. Waller, a resident of Brown Coun *t.v, became tho possessor of a valuable relic. It is one of the first 'Winchester rifles ever manufactured, the date of its make being 18(a). It went through the Custer massacre on the Little Big Horn •River on June 25, 1S7!, and was earned by a Sioux Indian who had stolen or purchased it before that terrible event. The old weapon was in the possession of one of the Sioux refugees who were Scaptured by United States cavalry in the Bad l.ands of what is now South Dako ta after their return in 1SS0 from Cann- •da.
See moreSee less
where they had taken refuge after the massacre of Custer and his coin niand. i" The gun is indeed a curiosity, the 'workmanship being very crude as com pared with modern repeating rifles. A rrestoil at Lust. S. J. Conn was arrested at Minneapolis charged with the theft of a valuable work team from John Stransky, of Puk wana. A little more than a month ago, Stransky and Conn, who was then his ^neighbor, had an altercation, and that night Stransky's team was stolen and Conn was missing. He sold the team to an auctioneer in Minneapolis for $300 sand was engaged in spending the money County Seat War. •si The people of Selby. who were defeat ed at the November election in their cf .fort to secure the Walworth County seat from Bangor, drove to the latter town, thirty strong, Tuesday night, and took the records from the court house vaults. The raid surprised Bangor people, who knew nothing of it till Wednesday morn fng, when they found the records miss ing. Morn Than Kxpectert. V. IC. Stillwell and B. X. Ward, of Alexandria, have taken an inventory of property owned by the late Rev. Dr. •ifKroeger. They report the value of as sets greater than was anticipated at the soutset, aud while unable at this time to give the exact figures place the sum at -over $100,000. The business of the sani tarium and laboratory will be continued. New Register of Deeds. Albert llolton, register of deeds-elect, went to Sioux Falls Tuesday to take up the duties of the office to which he was elected last fall. He has appointed Will H. Hodge, of Dell ltapids, as depu ty register and P. I. Xeister, of Sioux Falls, as clerk. Caniarota'a Progress. During the year just closed extensive .public and private improvements will reach fully £20,000. Among the new tbusiness institutions is a farmer's eleva tor. THS REFORM SCHOOL. Snperindent Young Tells of tlte Con dition at the Reform School. S. E. Young, superintendent of the Pluukiiitou reform school states that it is in excellent condition. lie says that at the present time there arc lifty-seven inmates of the institution who reported daily. Besides these there are nine who are on parole, working in different places or at their homes. He says that hu heard from the parole pupils once a week or oftener and that all the reports were of the most encouraging nature. Of Mr. Young's family of fifty-seven there are fourteen girls. Tho superin tendent said that his family of children were not as bad as some people had been led to believe. Occasionally there was a truly incorrigible among the inmates but most of them were susceptible to kind treatment. Two-thirds of the inmates of the school are treated as trusties. That is they are not held down as prisoners. Among the inmates, however, are some who will bear watching. Moreover, tho tone of the school as a whole has been materially raised during the past few years. Most of the inmates of the in stil ut ion seem contented and it is rarely Tuesday. that one of them makes an attempt to run away.
A farmers' convention program for the Rock County Pomona Grange includes a Wednesday evening talk titled 'The Custer Massacre' by Hon. Theo. W. Golden, described as one of the two survivors. The rest of the clipping covers unrelated local news and convention schedule items.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
The Wisconsin Tobacco Reporter · 13 January 1905 · page 2
Necessity of Cleanliness in Milk Production | Jas. G. Moore, Madison. Recitation—Miss Laura North, Milton Junc tion. Agriculture and Etymology—Wm. C. Daland, Milton. 7:30 p. m. The Custer Massacre—Kon. Theo. W. Golden, Janesville (one of the two survivors). Thursday. 8:00 a. m. Music under direction of Mrs. F. C. Binne weis. Prayer—Rev. A. L. McClelland, Milton, Reminiscences of a Granger—Rev. Milton Wells, Footville.
A riverboat captain, Grant Marsh, praises the character and prosperity of Arickaree Indians at an agency, noting many former Seventh Cavalry soldiers settled nearby as farmers, some survivors of the Little Bighorn. He then recounts an 1873 anecdote about a banker who lost mules to Indians near Fort Lincoln and wrote to General Custer asking about recovering them via a chattel mortgage.
The Washburn Leader · 21 January 1905 · page 4
While there, 1 met a great many farmers who had been soldiers long ago. Usually when their time with the government had expired, they secured a good tract of land and remained in the country. Conse quently they are now prosperous farmers. A great many of these were in the Seventh Cavalry, and some are survivors of the Battle of Big Horn, where Custer lost his life. It might not be amiss to relate here an incident of 1873, In the spring of the year General Custer moved with the Seventh Cavalry
A 1905 review discusses a history book covering the Plains Indian Wars, praising its balanced treatment of both soldiers and Indian leaders like Crazy Horse and Sitting Bull. It highlights earlier engagements such as the Fetterman fight, the Wagon Box fight, and Custer's Washita battle as background to the broader conflict.
New-York Tribune · 25 January 1905 · page 10
Fece and Crazy Horse he especially singles out as foemen worthy of the steel of our best and Sravest leaders, the last named in particular exhibiting a capacity for generalship, coupled with personal courage, that is nowise dimmed by his ultimate inevitable defeat. The author | also pays a tribuie to the strategy of Sitting Bull, which enabled that astute medicine man to maintain his chieftaincy over fighting men despite his reluctance to engage in actual com bat. Beginning with the Powder River expedition under General Henry B. Carrington, in 18686, which led to the establishment of Fort Phil Kearny, the first part of the book carries the reader through the Fetterman tragedy, the wagon box fight, Forsyth's defence of Beech ers Island, Carpenter's fight on Beaver Creek, Custer's battle of the Washita and Carr's en
A newspaper book review discusses Cyrus Townsend Brady's history of Indian wars, covering the 1876 Sioux campaign including Custer's 'disastrous' Little Big Horn campaign and subsequent battles. It notes the author's extensive appendix debating whether Custer disobeyed General Terry's orders, concluding he was not justified in acting independently.
New-York Tribune · 25 January 1905 · page 10
divided, the Indians swinging themselves to the #ltes of their horses as they swept down the length of the island. . . . It was & most magnificent charge, and one which for splendid daring and reckless heroism would have done credit to the best avape of any nation in the world. And m iA cently had it been met. Powell's defence of the corral on Piney Island was a remarkable achieve ment, but it was not to be compared to the fighting of these scouts on the little open, unprotected heap of sana and grave!
See moreSee less
in the Arickaree. The story of the subsequent defence of the | island and its relief is scarcely less sensational, and is told with fine appreciation. | The second part of the volume is devoted to the war with the Sioux in 1876, which, begin ning with Reynolds's fiasco on Powder River, the battle of the Rosebud, a wallantly fought but inconclusive engagement, and Custer’'s dis | asirous Little Big Horn campaign, was finally brought to a successful termination by Crooks and Milis’s fighting at Slim Buttes, followed by Mackenzie's winter battle with Dull Knife in the Big Horn Mountains and Miles's crushing defeat of Sitting Bull at Clear Creek and of | Crazy Horse at Wolf Mountain. In addition to & full account of Custer's last campaign, the author devotes nearly fifty pages of the appen dix to & further discussion of the dashing cav alry leader's course, printing e great variety of communications from those who approve, as | well as from those who condemn, it. While Dr. Brady admits that the question whether Gen eral Custer was actually guilty of disobedience | EE TT RD TONERS TRE
In 1905, Custer's widow publicly clashed with historian Cyrus Townsend Brady over his assertion that General Custer brought about his own defeat at Little Big Horn by disobeying orders. Brady countered that the charge was not his invention but had been raised earlier by Major General Robert P. Hughes in a 1896 military journal.
Fergus County Argus · 25 January 1905 · page 2
ter disobeyed orders on that occasion. "That charge has been made many times," he declares, "and most prom inently by Major General Robert P. Hughes in the Journal of the Mili tary Service Institution for January, 1896, volume 18. No. 79. This publi cation was brought to the notice ot Mrs. Custer at the time, and she issued a pamphlet concerning it." The story that Custer was guilty of virtual disobedience of orders in striking out on his own hook is not new to the ephemeral literature of that tragic episode in Indian warfare, yet in a formal history which will be read by posterity the statement, if made, should be fortified by official authority. The public will be satisfi ed to leave the matter where Custer's superiors left it.
A travel writer describes a journey through the Badlands toward Montana, passing near Billings and the Little Bighorn River, site of Custer's famous defeat by Sitting Bull's Sioux forces. The piece is a touristic reminiscence noting the government-maintained battlefield, grave markers, and monument, before continuing on to describe Livingston and the approach to Yellowstone Park.
Oxford Eagle · 26 January 1905 · page 2
We now come into a section made famous in history as the section where roamed the savage and terrible Sioux Indians. It was just South of Billings and near tho Little Big Horn River that the heroic Gen. Custer and
The Birmingham Age-Herald · Birmingham, Ala. · and 4 other papers
A 1905 sermon by Rev. Frank De Witt Talmage argues that courage without proper equipment is insufficient, citing historical examples including Custer's defeat at Little Bighorn, attributed to exhausted ammunition. The passage also discusses Bunker Hill, Khartoum, and David versus Goliath as parallel examples.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 7 days later.
Wrong
The Birmingham Age-Herald · 29 January 1905 · page 15
mere food for powder. Bunker Hill had to be evacuated by the American troops not because they would not fight. The Revolutionists’ sup ply of ammunition ran out. Twice did the charging British lines break and fall back before the withering tornado of shot i pouring Into their ranks, but at the third charge the American soldiers had to turn and flee. Their powder wras gone. They were helpless then before the attacks of the advancing enemy. It has been said that Custer and his brave band were over powered at Little Big Horn river, Mon tana, by the Sioux Indians because their ammunition was exhausted.
See moreSee less
The fall of Khartum under “Chinese” Gordon was largely due to the same lack of powder and bullets. A soldier without effective weapons In his hand Is as helpless be fore the attack of his enemies as Is the lamb In the slaughter house when the butcher Is about to cut open the animal's throat with the keen edge of the knife.