As the Papers Told It

Little Bighorn · As the Papers Told It

Act Twelve

Fifty Years After

June 1916 – January 1930

For the fortieth anniversary General Godfrey was to lead a re-enactment along Custer’s trail, and the organizers hoped to clear up old misunderstandings: Custer had worn his hair cut short that campaign, and the Seventh carried no sabres. The papers buried ‘the last surviving scout,’ took apart the story of Tom Custer’s heart, and argued over the word massacre. A New Jersey farmer said he had survived; the government settled Curly’s claim with a pension; a 1924 article said the only real survivor was a horse. A hundred thousand people came to the fiftieth anniversary. In 1927 a magazine said Custer killed himself, and in 1929 a paper explained how so many men had come to be last survivors. In 1930 an old man in Oklahoma said he had seen Custer fall.

Fortieth anniversary: a mimic battle planned

A Billings dispatch: for the fortieth anniversary General E. S. Godfrey, a survivor of the Seventh, is to lead veterans along the Custer trail toward a village of 150 tepees on the old Sioux camp site. The committees hope to clear up misunderstandings: Custer wore his hair short on the campaign, and ‘There were no sabres with the Seventh Cavalry on the expedition.’

Jamestown Weekly Alert · Jamestown, N.D. · and 2 other papers

Jamestown Weekly Alert · 29 June 1916 · page 7 · transcribed from the page image

FAMOUS CUSTER MASSACRE RE-ENACTED In Mimic Battle on Little Big Horn.

Billings, Mont., June 24.—Re-enactment of the crucial point in the Battle of the Little Big Horn, otherwise known as Custer's Massacre, by the Sioux Indians, is planned to be a feature of the fortieth anniversary celebration Sunday of the famous battle. The central figure in the event is to be General E. S. Godfrey, survivor of General Custer's famous Seventh Cavalry regiment. The observance of the anniversary is to take place on the battlefield itself and the re-enactment is to be as nearly a reproduction of the original event as possible.

See moreSee less

Arrangements for the observance have been completed by committees representing the citizens of Billings and Hardin, Montana, and Sheridan, Wyoming. Already thousands of visitors have arrived to view the event. Special trains from Billings and Sheridan are to take the visitors to the battlefields and thence to the Crow Indian reservation where Indian games were planned.

According to tne arrangements, the visitors, on reaching the battlefield are to find the scene arranged as it was a few hours before the famous battle with the Sioux in which Custer and many of his command lost their lives forty years ago. There is to be a village of 150 Indian tepees and between 2,000 and 3,000 Indians, pitched on the identical spot where the Sioux were encamped. General Godfrey, commanding a company of veterans is to traverse the historic Custer trail from the last camp on the Rosebud River and approach the Indian village as did General Custer.

During the mimic battle, General Godfrey will begin and carry out the historic retreat as General Custer retreated until the summit of the hill on which he made his "last stand" is reached. Here General Godfrey, in the midst of the graves of Custer's fallen, will deliver a brief address. He also is expected to read a message from Mrs. George A. Custer, of New York, who will be unable to be present. An Indian chieftain, selected by the Crow tribe, also will probably speak.

It is hoped by the committees of Billings and Hardin, Mont., and Sheridan, Wyo., who are in charge of the arrangements, that the re-enactment of the massacre will dispel many of the misunderstandings relative to the famous battle that have existed for many years. It has been pointed out that Custer really wore his hair cut short in his campaign against the Sioux, whereas invariably he is pictured by artists and described by writers as wearing long yellow locks. General Custer also is almost universally depicted as wearing a sabre. There were no sabres with the Seventh Cavalry on the expedition.

In the spring of 1876 the Sioux became restless and took up the war path. Their depredations led to sending an expedition, commanded by General Terry against them. He left Fort Abraham Lincoln, Dakota, May 17, 1876, with a command consisting of the Seventh Cavaltry, companies from the Sixth and Seventeenth regiments of infantry and a long wagon train. The command marched overland the entire distance the infantry and wagon train being left behind to form a supply camp at the mouth of the Powder River. The cavalry, with pack mules, continued.

At the mouth of the Rosebud on the Yellowstone, Terry's column met General Gibbon, who had come from the west with six companies of the Seventh and four troops of the Second Cavalry. From here, on June 22, Custer with six hundred men, was sent forward to the Little Big Horn to attack, should he deem advisable, a camp of Sioux. Custer covered the distance of one hundred miles in three days and learning that the Indians were ahead, prepared to attack, he divided his command, giving Reno three companies, Benteen three and retaining five himself. He detailed Captain McDougall, with one company, to act as rear guard.

Reno and Benteen went forward. The former almost immediately engaged the Indians in overwhelming numbers and retreated to the crest of Reno's Hill, four miles from the battlefield. Custer, instead of supporting Reno, as he had originally planned, passed around him on the east side of the stream and was furiously attacked by a large body of Sioux. He was surrounded on a ridge and his whole command was wiped out in less than two hours after the fight started. Reno and Benteen fought the Indians the rest of the day and until Terry and Gibbon arrived during the afternoon of the third day.

See the clipping

Veterans of five wars bury James Flanagan

At Mandan, N.D., the American Legion buries James Flanagan, eighty-four, called the last of Custer’s scouts. Three Grand Army survivors carry the colors he bore for years as color guard, and young World War veterans fire the volley. A Greenfield, Mass., native, he went to the California gold fields, served in the 11th Ohio Cavalry, then enlisted in the Seventh at Fort Lincoln.

Roanoke Rapids Herald · Roanoke Rapids, N.C. · and 12 other papers

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

Roanoke Rapids Herald · 24 June 1921 · page 6 · transcribed from the page image

LEGION MEN BURY PATRIOT

"Sargint" James Flanagan, Last of Custer Scouts, Laid to Rest in North Dakota.

See moreSee less

Indian fighter, veteran of the Civil war and ardent patriot, "Sargint" James Flanagan, eighty-four years old and actually the last surviving scout of General Custer's Seventh cavalry, massacred on the Lit[t]e Big Horn, was laid to rest by the American Legion in Mandan, N. D., in one of the most unique and impressive funeral ceremonies ever witnessed in the northwest.

Veterans of five wars participated in the ceremonies. A faltering but proud trio of Grand Army survivors carried at the head of the cortege the same colors which the old sergeant for years had borne as a color guard. Stalwart young veterans of the World war sent the funeral volley crashing over the patriot's grave.

"Sargint" Flanagan was a native of Greenfield, Mass. In the mid-fifties he joined the mad rush to the gold fields of California. He drifted back to Ohio and joined the 11th Regiment of Ohio Cavalry, serving through the Civil war. Later he enlisted in the Seventh cavalry at Fort Lincoln.

See the clipping

Watson on Rain-in-the-Face’s undeserved fame

Elmo Scott Watson says only Sitting Bull and Curley have drawn as much misinformation. The story that Rain-in-the-Face ate Tom Custer’s heart, asserted in Mrs. Custer’s Boots and Saddles, he denied to Dr. Charles A. Eastman, and Dr. Porter and General Benteen said the body was not so mutilated. Longfellow’s poem, Watson suggests, may have made him Custer’s slayer.

The Weekly Iberian · New Iberia, La. · and 3 other papers

The Weekly Iberian · 22 July 1922 · page 6 · transcribed from the page image

Stories of GREAT INDIANS By ELMO SCOTT WATSON Copyright, 1922, Western Newspaper Union.

CHIEF RAIN-IN-THE-FACE GOT UNDESERVED FAME

See moreSee less

WITH the possible exception of Sitting Bull and Curley, Custer's Crow scout, more misinformation has been written about Rain-In-The-Face (Itiomagaju) chief of the Hunkpapas than any other Indian who ever lived. When he died September 12, 1905, the word was flashed all over the country that "the Indian who killed General Custer is dead."

During the Stanley expedition up the Yellowstone in 1873, Rain-In-The-Face murdered two civilians who had strayed from Custer's command, a crime for which he was arrested by Capt. Tom Custer a year later and imprisoned at Fort Abraham Lincoln, N. D. He escaped and after joining the hostiles under Sitting Bull he is said to have sent word back to the fort that he would have his revenge on the whole Custer family and on Captain Tom in particular.

Out of this threat grew the story that Rain-In-The-Face after the battle of Little Big Horn had cut out Tom Custer's heart and eaten a piece of it. Mrs. Custer in her book "Boots and Saddles" makes such an assertion, but Rain-In-The-Face in telling his life story to Dr. Charles A. Eastman, the noted Sioux writer, denied any such deed and it is reasonable to believe that the Hunkpapa warrior would tell a member of his own race the truth. More than that, Dr. Porter and General Benteen, who found Tom Custer's body after the battle, have stated positively that he was not mutilated in this way.

In Longfellow's poem "The Revenge of Rain-In-The-Face," he repeats the story, although he makes Gen. George Custer the victim of the atrocity instead of Tom Custer. This may be the origin of the yarn that Rain-In-The-Face was the slayer of Custer.

The circumstances connected with his killing the two civilians from Custer's command showed that he was a ruthless, savage warrior. His bold attack on Fort Totten, N. D., in 1866 with two companions, an act of sheer bravado growing out of a dare, and his endurance of the worst tortures of the Sun Dance without a murmur proved that he was a man utterly indifferent to pain, danger or death.

After the Sioux wars were over Rain-In-The-Face settled on the Standing Rock reservation and in 1886 applied for admission to the Hampton school, an effort which inspired a second poem about him—this time from the pen of another great American poet, John G. Whittier. On the reservation Rain-In-The-Face became an Indian policeman.

See the clipping

A battle, not a massacre

Cyrus Townsend Brady, in the preface to Indian Fights and Fighters, objects to ‘The Custer Massacre’: Custer attacked and fought until all his men were killed, and that makes it a battle. Nobody, he says, ever heard of the ‘Massacre of Thermopylae.’

Farmers Independent · Bagley, Minn. · and 6 other papers

Farmers Independent · 28 December 1922 · page 6 · transcribed from the page image

OBJECTS TO TERM 'MASSACRE'

Author Insists That Custer's Last Fight Must Properly Be Described as a Battle.

See moreSee less

Cyrus Townsend Brady, LL.D., in the preface of a volume on "Indian Fights and Fighters," makes a marked distinction between the terms "massacre" and "battle." He says that every time a body of troops engaged in a fight with Indians and the troops were outnumbered or caught at a disadvantage, and the battle was continued until the troops were slaughtered, such an affair was popularly called a "massacre," as, for instance, "The Custer Massacre."

Mr. Brady believes this to be an unwarranted use of the term. Custer, the author points out, attacked the Indians and fought desperately until he and his men were all killed. He calls it a "battle" and not a "massacre." When an Indian war party raided a settlement or overwhelmed a train, or murdered women and children, that, he thinks, was a "massacre." The author says:

"I would like to ask if anyone ever heard of the 'Massacre of Thermopylae?' The Greeks fought there until all save one were killed. The results there were exactly the same as those of the battle of the Little Big Horn, but I have yet to read in history that the Persians 'massacred' the Greeks in that famous pass."

See the clipping

Charles Hayward’s twenty-four lost years

Charles Hayward, seventy, a farmer at McKee City, N.J., says he was a private in Company I who, wounded, ‘went half out of his mind’, so the Indians spared him and kept him in servitude until 1900, when his mind cleared at a spring and he escaped with the old headquarters flag. Representative Isaac Bacharach, who found a Charles Hayward on the rolls, will press his pension claim.

Worcester Democrat and the Ledger-Enterprise · Pocomoke City, Md. · and 4 other papers

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 17 days later.

Wrong

Worcester Democrat and the Ledger-Enterprise · 17 March 1923 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

SURVIVED CUSTER FIGHT, HE SAYS

Farmer Declares He Was Member of Famous Seventh Cavalry in Historic Massacre.

See moreSee less

MEMORY A BLANK 24 YEARS

Impaired Mentality, Due to Wound in Fight, Caused Indians to Spare His Life—Gets Aid for Pension Claim.

McKee City, N. J.—Charles Hayward, a seventy-year-old farmer who lives here, says he is a survivor of the Custer massacre, when General George A. Custer and his Seventh cavalry were slaughtered by the Ogalala Sioux at the Little Big Horn river June 25, 1876. The histories of the event have always stated that not a single white man survived Custer's impetuous attack against a force that outnumbered his ten to one. But Hayward's story is sufficiently credible to have impressed Representative Isaac Bacharach, who intends to lay before the authorities at Washington Hayward's claim for a pension based on his war services under Custer.

Private in Seventh Cavalry.

Hayward says he was a private in Company I of the Seventh cavalry when it was detatched by General Terry as one of three bodies of troopers ordered to attack what was supposed to be a small body of Indians near the confluence of the Big Horn and the Little Big Horn rivers. And Representative Bacharach has searched the records and found that there was in Company I of the Seventh cavalry during its Indian campaigns a private named Charles Hayward.

To continue Hayward's account. The main body of the Sioux suddenly appeared, and cut off from the white forces 264 men in Custer's command. The cavalrymen formed the customary circular barricade of slain horses and fought the Indians, who, according to Hayward, outnumbered them three to one, in contrast to the "ten to one" stated in the New International Encyclopaedia. Hayward, as he tells Representative Bacharach, was wounded "and went half out of his mind," the latter fact later saving his life. He climbed to the back of a wounded horse and started to flee. But not far from the barricade behind which Custer's men were rapidly being shot down his horse was shot again, falling and pinning its rider underneath.

Memory is Impaired.

Of what happened after that Hayward says he remembers nothing. Later he was told that he had been found by Indians, who spared his life because of his impaired mentality. They put him to work and kept him in servitude until 1900. In that year he was sent one day to fetch a bucket of water, and while bending over a bubbling spring his mind cleared suddenly and completely, as quickly as it had become clouded 24 years before. Then he made his escape, still carrying with him the old headquarters flag of the Seventh cavalry wound about his waist.

When a few years later, he moved to Atlantic county, N. J., he entered a claim with the pension office at Washington for an annuity. But on account of his previous lapse of memory he was unable satisfactorily to substantiate his assertions or to relate his record in detail. Therefore the officials refused to believe his story and his pension was disallowed.

Since then he has repeatedly petitioned the bureau chiefs at the capital for an audience, but has had none. Representative Bacharach, however, is going to examine thoroughly the old farmer's romantic story, and if he is entitled to a pension he will try to get it for him. Hayward bears upon his body scars, which he displays with pride, stating that they are the last vestiges of the wounds he received while fighting under Custer at the Little Big Horn.

See the clipping

Curly gets a pension

The Interior Department approves a pension for Shuh-Shee-Ahsh, ‘alias Curley,’ the Crow scout, for his service in 1876 and 1877, and the paper says the half-century argument over whether anyone survived Custer’s fight has been ‘settled officially.’ By the war department’s records, he escaped by mingling with the attacking Indians and rejoined the troops five days later.

The Browning Review · Browning, Mont. · and 2 other papers

CorrectionThis set right an article from 3 days earlier.

The Browning Review · 20 April 1923 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

CURLY'S PENSION BACKS CUSTER SURVIVAL TALE

Washington.—A controversy of almost half a century, as to whether there was a survivor of the Custer massacre at Little Big Horn, Mont., June 25, 1876, has been settled officially. The interior department has approved the issuance of a pension certificate to Shuh-Shee-Ahsh, alias Curley, a Crow Indian, for his services in the Indian campaigns in 1876 and 1877, which included participation in the famous battle which resulted in the obliteration of Custer's cavalry.

See moreSee less

Curly, who was one of Custer's scouts, now lives on the Crow Indian reservation in Montana. According to war department records he escaped death by mingling with the attacking Indians and rejoined government forces nearby, five days later.

See the clipping

Comanche, Keogh’s claybank sorrel

The Custer battle, the writer says, has produced more claimed last survivors than any event but the Charge of the Light Brigade, and the scout Curley may have the best right to the title. But of the last rally only a horse came out: Comanche, Captain Keogh’s sorrel, found by Lieut. Henry J. Nowlan with seven wounds, never ridden again, now mounted at the University of Kansas.

The Winslow Mail · Winslow, Ariz. · and 3 other papers

CorrectionThis set right 2 earlier articles: The Weekly Exponent, 13 December 1923, Evening Star, 27 December 1923.

The Winslow Mail · 1 February 1924 · page 8 · transcribed from the page image

THE ONLY REAL SURVIVOR O[F] CUSTER'S LAST RALLY

NEXT to the celebrated Charge of the Light Brigade, the Custer battle in Montana in 1876 probably has produced more "last survivors" than any other event in history and if all the claimants to that title had actually been there the wonder is that the Indians did not flee precipitately at the appearance of this overwhelming force. Perhaps Curley, the Indian scout who is still living on the Crow reservation, has the best right to the title, although that has been a matter of dispute for years. Curley went into the battle with the Seventh cavalry, but he escaped before the Sioux swept over the remnants of Custer's little band of heroes crouched on that barren hillside near the Little Big Horn.

See moreSee less

As for survivors of Custer's last rally, there was only one and that was a horse. He was a "claybank" sorrel named Comanche and he was ridden into the fight by Capt. Miles W. Keogh of Troop I of the Seventh. The horse was acquired by Captain Keogh and given the name Comanche during the Sully expedition to the sand hills of the Canadian in Oklahoma in 1868. He was wounded in one of the battles with the Indians and ever afterwards Keogh rode him on field expeditions.

Two days after the slaughter of Custer's men, Lieut. Henry J. Nowlan of Troop I, who escaped the fate of his captain because he was on detached service with General Terry at the time, while searching the battlefield for the dead found the horse standing in a ravine, suffering from seven bullet and arrow wounds and half dead from loss of blood. Nowlan recognized him as Keogh's charger and ordered that special efforts be made to save his life.

When the wounded of Reno's command started down the river on the steamer Far West for the long journey to Fort Abraham Lincoln, N. D., a stall bedded with the softest grass was provided for Comanche.

When Comanche recovered from his wounds, Colonel Sturgis, commander of the Seventh, issued an official order that no man should ever again sit on the horse's back. Furthermore, whenever the regiment appeared in any mounted ceremony Comanche, saddled, bridled, draped in mourning and led by a soldier of Troop I, was to parade with the regiment.

Comanche remained at Fort Lincoln until 1879, when he accompanied the Seventh to Fort Meade, S. D. In 1888 he marched overland from Meade to Fort Riley, Kan., where he died November 6, 1891. His skin was preserved and mounted and is now on exhibition in the Dyche museum at the University of Kansas.

See the clipping

Miles asks Congress for a battlefield memorial

After Mrs. Custer’s visit to Washington, Gen. Nelson A. Miles writes to Congress urging at least $40,000 for a memorial on the Custer battlefield; $15,000, he says, is not enough. Custer has been blamed, Miles says, but had all under him carried out his commands his sacrifice would have been needless. ‘He saved the frontiers of civilization.’

The Poplar Standard · Poplar, Mont. · and 1 other paper

The Poplar Standard · 22 February 1924 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

BUILD MEMORIAL IN HONOR CUSTER

NELSON A. MILES AIDS WIDOW OF FAMOUS CAVALRY CHIEF WHO DIED AT BIG HORN

See moreSee less

Agitation has been revived to erect a suitable memorial on the Custer Battlefield in honor of the cavalry chief who was slain there 48 years ago by the Sioux Indians and after whom the battlefield is named. This resulted from the recent visit of his widow to Washington.

During her visit, Mrs. Custer asked Gen. Nelson A. Miles, now a resident of Washington, and who was a fellow officer with General Custer, to aid in the project. General Miles has approved the plan and sent a letter to congress urging the appropriation of sufficient money to carry out the project. In his letter he suggested that at least $40,000 be appropriated.

"It is a shame nothing has been done in the way of putting up a memorial there before this time," General Miles said. 'Not a train across the state but what stops there, I have been told, and surely some lasting memorial should be put on such a spot, sacred to our country's progress.

"I recall well that campaign and how badly we felt at Fort Leavenworth when we received news of the death of Custer and his brave men. He has been blamed but if his commands had been carried out by all those under him his sacrifice would have been needless.

"It has been suggested that congress set aside say such a paltry sum as $15,000, but that is not enough. Why, not a day passes but what we hear of a monument to this or that cause not half as important as what Custer did for us. He saved the frontiers of civilization.

"Men who never even went overseas during the past war have had monuments erected to them and now it takes work to get money enough for such an important one as that deed which went down in history years ago on a Montana plain near the Little Big Horn river—a land then of desolation and raiding Indian tribes. Even the Indians admired Custer's bravery. Surely we can do no less than to see that his memory is kept sacred in fitting manner."

See the clipping

Nick Imo blames Custer, not Reno

Nick Imo, 76, of Spokane, a veteran of the campaign, says the massacre came from Custer’s disobedience and ‘poor judgment’, not from Reno’s failure: Terry’s orders set the battle for June 26, and Custer fought a day early. He recalls finding dead ponies and Indians, and hills that seemed covered with soldiers who proved to be Indians in uniforms stolen from the dead.

Daily Kennebec Journal · Augusta, Me. · and 1 other paper

CorrectionThis set right an article from 8 days earlier.

Daily Kennebec Journal · 3 August 1925 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

Gen. Reno Blameless Says Army Veteran

Spokane, Wash., Aug. 2—(AP)—Nick Imo, a veteran of the battle of Little Big Horn, June 25, 1876, holds that the massacre of Custer's command by Sioux Indians was due to disobedience of orders and "poor judgment" on the part of General Custer and not to the failure of General Reno to reach him in time with reinforcements.

See moreSee less

Mr. Imo, who served eight years in the United States army, is now 76 years of age and a resident of this city.

"Reno has been blamed for being lax, cowardly, dilatory and everything else," Mr. Imo said, "but it was impossible for Reno to reach the scene of conflict in time to participate. Custer himself was breaking an understanding that the pitched battle was to be June 26. He fought it a day earlier, before either the detachment of troops under Reno or Colonel Gibbons could come up, and lost.

"I remember that we met Custer June 22, 1876, on the Yellowstone River, opposite the mouth of the Rosebud. We had just come from Fort Ellis and were camped on the north side when Custer, riding from Fort Lincoln, showed up on the south. That same day he received orders from General Terry to proceed up the Rosebud toward the Indian camp. The orders specified that the final engagement was to take place June 26, when all forces would concentrate on the camp.

"My detachment, under Colonel Gibbons, crossed the Yellowstone below the mouth of the Big Horn June 24, and camped on the east side of the Big Horn. L. Troop, under Captain Tyler, which was in advance of Gibbons' command, was fired upon by the redskins, and returned to report. We camped on the Little Big Horn June 25, just 10 miles from the Indian camp, all ready for the battle, scheduled for June 26.

"My troop, under Captain Ed Ball, was sent on in advance next day, with Captain Tyler on the right and Lieutenant Bradley on the left. To Bradley goes the distinction of first discovering the bodies of Custer and his slaughtered troops.

"I reconnoitered with Captain Ball and Bugler Kerney, about 50 yards in advance of the troops, and we came on 24 dead ponies and seven dead Indians, scattered about a couple of tepees. We also encountered a scouting party from Major Reno's detachment, out looking for Custer's band, and sent them on to Gibbon's camp to report our find. We returned to camp after a 10-mile scouting trip.

"There we learned of Custer's death. Immediately after that the hills around seemed covered with detachments of United States soldiers, marching in curious disarray. It was the Indians, wearing uniforms stolen from the bodies of their victims."

See the clipping

Fifty years on, the myths taken apart

Ahead of the fiftieth anniversary, when the Seventh Cavalry is to march Custer’s route from the Rosebud and meet the Sioux and Cheyennes on the field to bury the hatchet, Elmo Scott Watson sets out what the historians have established: it was a battle, not a massacre; the only real survivor was the horse Comanche; Gall, Crazy Horse and Two Moons led the Indians; Rain-in-the-Face denied cutting out Tom Custer’s heart; Reno was no coward; and ‘there was not a saber in the entire command.’

The Buffalo Bulletin · Buffalo, Wyo. · and 4 other papers

The Buffalo Bulletin · 3 June 1926 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

Custer's Last Fight

50th Anniversary of Most Famous Indian Battle to be Observed This Year

See moreSee less

By ELMO SCOTT WATSON

THIS year marks the fiftieth anniversary of the best known, most talked-about and most written-about Indian battle in all American history. Officially it is known as the Battle of the Little Big Horn river, Montana, but the picturesque figure of Gen. George Armstrong Custer, whose dashing career as a cavalry leader in the Civil war and as a successful Indian fighter on the western plains, has so caught the popular fancy and so dominates this engagement that it probably will never be known generally by any other name than Custer's Last Fight, or Custer's Last Rally or more commonly (albeit inaccurately) the Custer Massacre.

Plans for the semi-centennial celebration of this famous engagement are under the direction of the National Custer Memorial association, organized last year in Montana but including in its membership a score of persons nationally known who are prominent in the work of patriotic societies and perpetuation of historical spots. One of them is Gen. E. S. Godfrey, U. S. A., retired, who was a lieutenant in Custer's regiment, the Seventh cavalry, on that fateful day fifty years ago.

The program calls for participation in the celebration by the present personnel of the Seventh cavalry, now stationed at Fort Bliss, Texas, and Sioux and Cheyenne Indians, the sons and grandsons of the savage warriors who overwhelmed Custer's men on the Little Big Horn. The United States government is co-operating, $30,000 having been appropriated by congress recently for the transportation of the troops to and from the celebration. Congress has also passed a bill authorizing the secretary of the interior to acquire a tract of land of 160 acres on the site of the fight between the Indians and the detachments commanded by Major Reno and Captain Benteen, which was a part of the Custer battle, and to erect on it a suitable monument and historical tablet, the dedication of which will be a part of the celebration. But the most interesting part of it all will be the march of the Seventh under Colonel Lee from the mouth of the Rosebud river, beginning at noon on June 22 and following the route taken by Custer and his doomed men. They will arrive on the Custer battlefield, the property of the federal government upon which a monument was erected many years ago, on the morning of June 25. There they will be met by the Indians and a formal ceremony symbolical of the "burying of the hatchet" between red men and white will take place.

Thus, in a celebration which is attracting nation-wide attention, will be recalled a tragedy which shocked the entire nation a half century ago, echoes of which have been heard every year of the fifty that have intervened since America's "Six Hundred" rode into their "Valley of Death." The story of this battle is so well-known that it needs no repetition here. It has been told and retold so often that there seems to be little that is new to tell again. Over it has raged many a bitter controversy and around it has sprung up a great mass of tradition, myth, misinformation and sheer "bunk." Fortunately, however, it has had its historians who have worked industriously to "debunk" the story of the Custer battle and, although there still are many details over which there is, and always will be, a chance for disagreement, in the main certain facts which have been oftenest distorted have been established in their true light.

First of all, the Custer battle was not the "Custer Massacre," as it is so often called. Custer attacked the Indians and fought desperately until he and all of the 212 men in the five companies of the Seventh which accompanied him were killed. But there was no ambush, no slaughter of unarmed men, none of the other factors which would justify calling this battle a massacre.

One of the points over which there has been the most acrimonious debate is whether or not Custer disobeyed the orders of his superior officer, Gen. A. H. Terry, and by his disobedience brought disaster upon himself. In many respects this dispute resolves itself into an academic affair to which there can be no solution without a strict limitation, interpretation and definition of the terms used in the debate. Opinion on this matter is about equally divided. General Godfrey is the most eminent among those who believe that the disaster did not result from disobedience of orders and the general is probably as well qualified as anyone in the world to make a positive statement in this regard.

Next to the matter of responsibility for the disaster is the question of whether or not there were any survivors of the Custer battle. The center of the controversy over this point for many years was the Crow Indian scout, Curley, whose claim to the title of "survivor" depends entirely upon an interpretation of what that term means. Curley was with Custer after the general had separated his command and was with him when he first came into contact with the Indians. Just when he left Custer—at the order of the commander, by the way—is not known definitely, but it has been pretty well established that he was not with him when Custer made his last stand on the barren hillside over which the red wave of destruction swept to blot out five companies of the Seventh. The only genuine "survivor" of that last desperate struggle was not a human being, but a horse, Comanche, the claybank sorrel charger ridden by Capt. Myles Keogh of I Troop of the Seventh. Comanche was found after the battle, wounded in seven places but with tender care his life was saved and he lived to an honored old age.

Despite indisputable evidence that there was only one real survivor, a horse, and one human being who had a feint claim to being a survivor —Curley, the Crow— during the last half century there have come to light innumerable "survivors" whose claims have been easily exploded by competent authorities but who have succeeded in deceiving many persons not familiar with the Custer battle. In the same manner innumerable "Custer scouts" have gained wide publicity. They bob up at such regular intervals that the headline "Last of Custer Scouts Dies" has become a commonplace. Evidently every packer, wagoner or other civilian employee of the army, who ever had any remote connection with Custer's regiment, some time before he dies gets the idea—or his friends get it for him—that he was a "Custer scout" and either living or dying he enjoys a brief moment of fame. If all of the men who have claimed to be "survivors" or "Custer scouts" had been with Custer on the Little Big Horn on June 25, 1876, it is difficult to see how ten times the number of Indians who were there would have been able to have wiped out Custer's command!

One of the favorite pieces of fiction about the Little Big Horn battle is that the Indians were led by Sitting Bull and that Rain-in-the-Face personally killed Custer. While it has never been definitely established just how prominent a part Sitting Bull had in the battle (some authorities say that he was not even in the fight) it has been fully proved that the leaders who were principally responsible for maneuvers of the Indians on that day were Chief Gall of the Hunkpapa Sioux, Chief Crazy Horse of the Oglala Sioux and Chief Two Moons of the Cheyennes. As to Rain-in-the-Face's claim to distinction—it is true that there was a feud between him and Capt. Tom Custer, brother of the general, and that he had threatened to cut out Tom Custer's heart. It is also true that Tom Custer's body was found after the battle thus mutilated and, although Rain-in-the-Face is accused of having done this, in the closing years of his life he denied it. His denial was made to a man of his own race, Dr. Charles A. Eastman, and under all the circumstances it is reasonable to believe that he told Doctor Eastman the truth.

Within the last year there has been much dispute over the arms which Custer and his men carried into the battle. Many artists who have drawn pictures of the Custer battle have shown the soldiers using swords, when as a matter of fact there was not a saber in the entire command. The men of the Seventh were armed only with ancient single shot Springfield carbines and Colt revolvers and it was partly because of these ineffective single shot carbines that Custer's command perished.

Another favorite piece of misinformation lays part of the responsibility for the disaster upon the "cowardice" of Major Reno in not going to the support of Custer. E. A. Brininstool, a historian who has made a special study of this campaign and who has brought to light many important facts about it, has definitely disproved this imputation of cowardice on the part of Major Reno and has done much to show that the man who for so long was "the goat" in this unfortunate affair in reality was something of a hero.

It has remained for Prof. O. G. Libby of the department of history at the University of North Dakota to remove the stigma from the names of other brave men connected with the Custer battle. In addition to the Crow scouts who accompanied the Custer expedition there were also a number of Arikara or Ree Indian scouts. The manner of referring to their part in the battle by most historians is to say "the cowardly Rees fled at the first fire." Professor Libby's investigation among the surviving members of this group of scouts, published by the North Dakota Historical society under the title of "The Arikara Narrative," shows conclusively that the term "cowardly Rees" is utterly unfair and untruthful. When the Arikara scouts "fled," they did so expressly upon the orders of General Custer who told them that they were to guide him to the Indian village but were to take no part in the fighting.

But for all the disputes, controversies, charges and counter-charges connected with this battle to make it unique among Indian fights and for all that the general features of its story are well known to most Americans, there is much that is interesting and thrilling and inspiring which has never yet become widely known. There is the story of the narrow escape from death of Lieut. Charles C. De Rudio, Sergt. Thomas O'Neill, Scout Billy Jackson and Interpreter Fred Girard who became separated from Reno's detachment during the first days' fighting and, after numerous narrow escapes from death, managed to rejoin their command while it was beleaguered on the hills to which Reno was forced to retreat.

There is the story of the brave men in Reno's command who in the face of persistent Indian fire risked their lives to creep down to the river to get water for wounded and dying comrades. They received congressional medals of honor for their deeds, it is true, but they are almost unknown except to a few historians of the Custer battle and it is to be hoped that emblazoned high on the new monument will be their names. They were as follows: Neil Bancroft, Abram J. Brant, Thomas J. Callan, Frederick Deetline, Theodore W. Goldin, David W. Harris, William M. Harris, Rufus D. Hutchinson, James Pym, Stanislaus Roy, George Scott, Thomas W. Stevens, Frank Tolan, Peter Thompson, Charles H. Welch, George H. Geiger, Henry W. B. Mechling, Charles Windolph and Otto Voit. Along with their names should be those of Sergt. Richard P. Hanley, Sergt. Benjamin C. Criswell, Sergt. Thomas Murray, Corp. Charles Cunningham and Private Henry Holden, all of whom were awarded similar medals for various acts of gallantry during the two days of the battle and siege.

A reunion of the survivors of the battle was held on the field in 1886, the tenth anniversary of the fight, and at that time Chief Gall of the Sioux and Chief Two Moons of the Cheyennes went over the field with officers of the Seventh and described the battle in detail as they remembered it.

Gall is long since dead, as are all the other Indian leaders on that fateful day. But their spirits may be there this June, not so much to rejoice again over one of the greatest victories the Indians ever won over the whites, as to rejoice when the "hatchet-burying" ceremony signalizes a final and lasting peace between red men and white.

See the clipping

Godfrey and White Bull meet at the monument

At Crow Agency the fiftieth anniversary draws crowds estimated at 100,000 over three days. The new Seventh rides over the ridge Custer is believed to have crossed, with General Godfrey and veterans of the battle, and meets Indian survivors led by White Bull, who gives his blanket for the general’s flag. An unknown trooper found by road builders is buried with full honors.

The Carbon County News · Red Lodge, Mont. · and 2 other papers

The Carbon County News · 1 July 1926 · page 6 · transcribed from the page image

SOLEMN RITES IN MEMORY OF CUSTER

WEST'S SADDEST MEMORIAL IS VIEWED BY THRONG

See moreSee less

VILLAGE MASS OF HUMANITY

People of All Part of United States Journey to Indian Agency in Tribute to the Slain

Crow Agency, Mont.—At no time in the history of the Northwest has a more solemn and impressive memorial event taken place than the ceremonies held at the Custer battlefield last Thursday, Friday and Saturday in commemoration of that famous conflict, which took place just fifty years ago.

Throughout the entire time, extending from Thursday morning until Saturday evening, this little Indian agency village and for miles around was teeming with humanity. Thousands came by automobiles and thousands by train. People were here from all sections of the country to pay tribute to the memory of General George Armstrong Custer and his five troops of America's bravest soldiers, 212 in all, who just 50 years ago were slain in combat with warring Sioux and Cheyenne Indians along the banks of the Little Big Horn river a few miles south of here. It is conservatively estimated that during the three days no less than 100,000 people visited the famous battlefield.

Flag Raising Opens Program

The program was ushered in Thursday afternoon by the raising of the American colors on a huge staff at the national cemetery, directly participated in by veterans of the old Seventh cavalry, when it was commanded by Custer, and aged Sioux and Cheyenne Indians who took part in the deadly war fifty years ago.

The veterans, after the flag raising, joined Gen. E. S. Godfrey, who, during the battle of the Little Big Horn, as first lieutenant, commanded Company K under Major Benteen, in a review of the new Seventh, consisting of 17 officers and 235 men under Col. Fitzhugh Lee, detailed here for the ceremony by order of the War department, from Ft. Bliss, Texas, 1,500 miles away. Opposite the reviewing stand in full war regalia stood a long line of Indian survivors of the battle, including four Cheyennes and seven Sioux, who were engaged against Custer. Following the troopers came a long line of Crows, trailed by their women, gaily bedecked horses, and all in their finery.

In General Godfrey's party on the reviewing stand were Mrs. Godfrey; their grandson, Edward S. Godfrey III; Col. Herbert J. Slocum, Col. Charles F. Bates, Col. J. M. T. Portello, retired, and Commanders Luther Barker and John H. Brandt of the Indian war veterans' organizations.

Thursday evening the veterans paid a formal visit to Colonel Lee's camp and were greeted by the commander who took much pleasure in contrasting their facilities with those at their disposal 50 years ago. They heard the band of the Seventh play "The Black Hills March," written by John Burri of Mandan, N. D., a trumpeter of the old Seventh, who was on hand for the reunion.

50,000 View Friday Spectacle

Officials of the Custer Memorial association, sponsors of the historical event, estimate that 50,000 people viewed the ceremonies at the battle ground Friday. Some conception may be had of the crowd by the fact that people stood 200 feet deep in the immediate vicinity of the monument which marks the last stand of General Custer and his troops. The multitude was so immense that thousands were unable to witness the services and had to be content to remain in their automobiles.

The climax to the memorable peagant came when the great crowd witnessed the marching of the Seventh cavalry over the same ridge to the south of the battle ground, whence Custer is believed to have come. In five troops they came—the same troops that Custer led, but a new generation of men, dropping over the brow of the hill under guidons to which were attached streamers bearing the names of Custer's commanders. Accompanying them was Gen. Godfrey. With him came seven troopers who were engaged in the battle under Reno and Benteen. They were Peter Thompson, Alzada, Mont.; Dan Newell, Sturgis, S. D.; Theodore W. Goldin, Dansman, Wis.; W. C. Slaper, Los Angeles; John C. Lockwood, Washington, D. C.; Fremont Kipp, Washington, D. C.

March to Dirge

Slowly they marched toward the National cemetery to the strains of a funeral dirge played by the band of the Seventh concealed in a nearby ravine. From the other side came in a far flung column the hundreds of Indians, led by the nearly 80 Sioux and Crow survivors of the battle headed by White Bull, who as a youth of 20 led a band of Sioux fighters under Rain-in-the-Face. Near the monument the two parties met. White Bull held up his hand making the sign of peace. General Godfrey replied by dropping his unsheathed sword into its scabbard as he rode forward to meet the Indians. They clasped hands, and to cement the friendship White Bull presented to the general a prized possession—his blanket—while the general gave to White Bull a large American flag.

Taps Sounded

Taps sounded from the cavalry bugles and the troopers fired a volley over the graves of Custer's veterans as the procession moved past the Custer monument led by the Indians. In passing White Bull and General Godfrey each placed on the shaft a floral wreath. Chanting their own funeral dirge, the Indians left the spot mourning the many warriors of their own race who fell before Custer's rifles.

Seventh in Battle Charge

Following the ceremonies at the battle ground the Seventh was again reviewed by General Godfrey and other Indian war veterans. As the troopers rode down the narrow street of the little agency town, they passed between two rows of veterans, the white men including many members of the old Seventh on one side and the Sioux and Cheyenne veterans in war paint and feathers on the other.

As a conclusion of its parade, the troop, for the benefit of the motion picture men, charged through the Little Big Horn river, just back of the town. The opposite bank was a little steep and slippery, with the result that several officers and men were dismounted when their horses toppled backward. None was hurt.

Indians Hold Campfire

Indian veterans of the battle had their innings Friday evening when they gathered around the campfire in the center of the plaza fronting the agency buildings and talked over their parts in the many campaigns in which most of them had participated, and pledged again their allegiance to the government.

Bury Unknown Trooper

As a final tribute to General Custer and his five squads of troopers the program was brought to a close Saturday with the burial with full military honors of the remains of one of the soldiers who fell with his commander. The first burial place of the trooper, on the bank of the river, was uncovered by men building a road across a part of the old battlefield. Identification was impossible, but buttons from an army uniform found there made it certain that the grave was that of a trooper with Custer.

Preceded by his riderless horse, saddled, bridled, bearing the boots and cavalry sabre, reversed, the casket containing the last mortal remains of the unknown trooper was borne to the site of a proposed monument as the Seventh cavalry band played a funeral dirge.

The funeral was distinguished by the fact that, in addition to active pallbearers from the new Seventh, eight members of Custer's Seventh, who were engaged in the battle where the trooper was killed, accompanied the casket to the grave.

Following the funeral, Gen. Godfrey presided over the dedication of a great slab of granite, which is to be a memorial to the unknown soldier.

To be placed within the crypt, White Buffalo, for the Sioux and Cheyenne warriors who came off the battlefield victors 50 years ago, offered his tomahawk, explaining through an interpreter, that he wished to show in that way that enmity between the red man and the white was at an end.

Crows and Sioux at Peace

Most significant is the fact that the commemoration of the Custer battle brought about a pledge of friendship between a Sioux and a Crow Indian, the first in history, so far as is known, and certainly the first in 50 years.

White Man Runs Him, Crow scout attached to Custer's regiment, and Little Wolf, Cheyenne warrior who helped annihilate the Seventh's leader and 212 members of his immediate command, in the manner of the white man, made known to each other that old enmities are forgotten, with a clasping of hands.

With Party of Survivors

Lone Wolf was at the head of a party of nine Cheyenne participants of the Custer fight. The others were Pine, a boy of 13 camped with the hostiles on the Little Big Horn when the fight occurred; Hollow Wood, 66 a young participant in the battle; Limpy, 70; Sun Bear, 80; Kills Night, 72; Fast Walker, 72; Dog Friend, 70, and Beaver Hart, 70, all participants in the battle. White Man Runs Him came here from his nearby ranch.

Among the distinguished Indian fighters who attended the Custer ceremonies include:

John C. Lockwood, a member of Troop M, who first came into contact with the Seventh at Yankton, Dakota territory, in 1863.

David P. Smith, a member of Troop K, commanded by Lieutenant E. S. Godfrey.

Dovelle Warner, 81, of Sunfield, Mich., a member of Company B, Eighteenth infantry.

Frank Cass, of Fresno, Cal., a member of Company H, Seventh cavalry, from 1880 to 1885.

C. Stierle, of Sidney, Mont., 62, a member of Company I, Sixth U. S. infantry, from 1875 to 1880. He participated in the Sitting Bull campaign in 1876-77.

W. H. White, 75, of Columbus, Mont., a member of Troop F, Second U. S. cavalry, from 1872 to 1877.

Major A. B. Ostrander, of Seattle, 81, a member of Company B, Eighteenth infantry, from 1864 to 1867.

Thomas McGirl, of Long Beach, Cal., 80, a member of Company T, Fifth mounted infantry, from 1864 to 1865.

Capt. John W. Pool, 78, of Spokane, a member of Company K, First Infantry, from 1877 to 1879. He is Washington commander of the National Indian War Veterans.

Col. J. M. T. Partello, 74, San Francisco, a member of the Fifth infantry, from 1876 to 1885.

Harley Crittenden, 76, of Los Angeles, a member of Company C, Ninth U. S. infantry, from 1872 to 1877.

John L. Talbot, 80, of Lake Bay, Wash., a member of Company G, Twenty-seventh infantry, from 1866 to 1869.

Henry G. Rice, 75, Bozeman, a member of Company H, Seventh infantry, from July 2, 1872 to July 2, 1877.

Willis Rowland, 65, scout, under General Miles.

See the clipping

Was Custer a suicide? The old scouts disagree

After the Cosmopolitan printed Chief Buffalo Child Long Lance’s story that Custer died by his own hand, Norfolk, Nebraska, sat six old plainsmen round a table to settle it: Deadwood Dick, Diamond Dick, Captain Luther North, Dr. W. F. Carver, Pawnee Bill and Idaho Bill. They talked past midnight and ended ‘a hung jury’: Carver thought Custer a suicide, North thought him foolhardy and Reno wise, and Deadwood Dick held that Custer died fighting and Reno was a coward.

The Poplar Standard · Poplar, Mont. · and 1 other paper

The Poplar Standard · 29 July 1927 · page 7 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

WAS BRAVE CUSTER A SUICIDE?

Pawnee Bill, Deadwood Dick and Other Famous Old Plainsmen, at Recent Meeting Discuss This Rumor, Started by Story in a National Magazine; Heretofore Untold Incidents Come to Light

See moreSee less

ONE of the most interesting—and at the same time one of the most important—meeting of frontiersmen ever held in recent years was staged at Norfolk, Neb., a few days ago when "Deadwood Dick," "Diamond Dick," Capt. "Lute" North, Dr. W. F. Carver, once world's champion wingshot, "Pawnee Bill," and "Idaho Bill" were brought together to set history aright as regards the last stand of Gen. George A. Custer, who with all his men, was massacred by the Indians in 1876 at the Battle of the Big Horn in Montana.

Never before had there been such a meeting. And probably never again will there be another. For out of the past, reaching back half a century or more, there stepped forth into real life these six famous characters that every small boy a generation ago knew only in "Diamond Dick" and "The Boys with Buffalo Bill"—those exciting five-cent thrillers were bought on the sly and read hiding in the barn loft.

For half a century or more the battle has been refought by historians, no two of whom ever seemed to agree. Nor how could they agree as to what happened when there was none left to tell the story after the Indians slaughtered Custer and all his valiant men? Only the Indians themselves who made off into the wilderness actually could give eyewitness accounts of the fight, and their stories were at such wide variance nobody could rely upon them. But two months ago the Cosmopolitan magazine published a resume of the battle as told by an Indian, Chief Buffalo Child Long Lance, in which he stated that General Custer died by his own hand, a suicide, rather than to meet certain torture and death at the hands of the savage redskins.

Instantly the towns of the Northwest that had been on the old frontier began to buzz with controversies. How could anyone say the brave Custer died by his own hand? If there was any coward near that battle on the Little Big Horn was it not Major Reno, who failed to come to Custer's support as he had been ordered to do?

And who was this Chief Buffalo Child Long Lance, who said he had got the true story in a secret Indian conference in Canada where old leaders and chieftains told him they did not kill Custer because the general when a young man had befriended "Chief" Sitting Bull.

Was It All Fiction?

"Why, the story's all fiction," the old timers said. "Sitting Bull was never a chief, but a medicine man and philosopher for the Indian tribes."

But was it all fiction? Norfolk decided it would hear what such men as "Lute" North, "Deadwood Dick" and "Doc" Carver, all of whom had been Indian fighters and scouts at the time Custer made his fatal attack on outlawed Cheyennes and Sioux and Uncpapas, had to say about it. So one night late in June, after a parade and banquet in honor of the visiting delegates of the National Editors' association (stopping over on their way to the Black Hills), a powwow was arranged for the six pioneer plainsmen.

Behind closed doors in one of the smallest banquet rooms of the Hotel Norfolk, they sat around a big table and talked until well after midnight, while 30 leading citizens of Norfolk and a few chosen visitors listened, laughed and applauded. R. H. Beerman, secretary to Carl Gray, president of the Union Pacific railroad, took a verbatim report in shorthand of the unique hearing.

But before we go into the "powwow" with them let us see them as they rode in parade that afternoon through the streets of Norfolk.

Here they came, riding through the rain on decidedly spirited horses, while a crowd of 10,000 in that northeastern Nebraska city lined the sidewalks to cheer them and while every adjunct of the civilization for which the valiant plainsmen fought back the wilderness to advance now united to pay them homage. A big airplane soared back and forth overhead, roaring a welcome that echoed along the microphone of station WJAG, broadcasting from the roof of the Hotel Norfolk.

Now they came in sight far down the long avenue, riding two and two, while brass bands blared and the crowds cheered anew. Here were "Pawnee Bill," with his huge sombrero, and "Doc" Carver, an imposing figure on a bay charger that was almost covered by the huge buffalo coat Carver wore and which he has possessed for nearly 60 years. Next were "Idaho Bill," and "Lute" North, both riding as if they had been born in the saddle, and closely followed in train by "Deadwood Dick" and "Diamond Dick." What a sight—what a thrill—what a picture?

The into the hotel to rest awhile and have dinner with the editors, where it becomes opportune to introduce the famous frontiersmen.

Meeting "Deadwood Dick"

First, because he seemed to be one of the most lovable and picturesque of the pioneers, we will present in close-up "Deadwood Dick," whose legal name is Robert W. Clark. His home is at Deadwood, S. D., where he has lived since the wild and wooly days of the Black Hills country, a famous frontiersman, scout, guide, pony express rider and Indian fighter. Now 79 years old, he still remembers vividly the stirring days when the Indians, gamblers and hard-riding, quick shooting road agents constantly helped the Wild West to live up to its name.

Of course, the boys of a generation ago will remember that "Deadwood Dick" used to rage back and forth in the covers of "Beadle's Dime Library." And Edward L. Wheeler was the author who made him rage. Thirty or forty years ago nearly all the boys in America knew "Deadwood Dick" as a hero always on the side of the weak protecting it against the strong with a pistol that sent every shot unerringly to its mark. But most of the valiant deeds, as was this dare-devil character of Wheeler, were creatures of fiction. "Dick" Clark, in real life, was known to be quick on the draw and as good a shot as "Wild Bill" Hickok, "Calamity Jane," and others of the gold rush days in the Black Hills, but he never was in any sense a desperado. He could give a good account of himself in battle, but his fights were with Indians and bandits and road agents who used to try to hold up the stage-coaches he guarded with their treasures for the express companies. He saw "Wild Bill" killed by the cowardly "Jack" McCall as Hickok sat in a saloon in Deadwood with his back toward the door playing poker. He knew General Custer and his associates well and fed the ragged and starving troops of General Crook after they had been routed by the Indians in the campaign after the Battle of Little Big Horn and driven back to Deadwood.

But the wild days finally passed and "Deadwood Dick" seemed to pass out of the picture with them. The dime novels of Wheeler faded and were forgotten and every now and then came the report that "Dick" was dead. But he has been living on a ranch near Deadwood, after having retired from his peace-time job as watchman at the railroad station, and never asking for a pension from the government he served so well as an Indian scout on what finally became the munificent pay of $16.50 a month.

A lovable, genuine, picturesque character is "Deadwood Dick," with piercing black eyes and long dark hair, barely graying, held back from a high, classic forehead, by an improvished bandeau of buckskin on a head that is handsomely chiseled as that of Paderewski, whom "Dick" with his hat off closely resembles. His figure is erect and lithe and slenderly masculine ac thae.mcnww, and slenderly muscular; his face is powder scarred; his hands are twisted and gnarled like pine knots and his right index figure is missing—lost in a gun fight, but just when and how "Dick" will not say. One likes "Deadwood Dick" instantly. His disposition reminded us of the portrayal of "Jim Bridger" that we saw in the movie called "The Covered Wagon;" for "Dick's" bright eyes frequently send off glints of humor.

And Here is Dr. Carver

Now we are meeting Dr. W. F. Carver, 87 years old, but recalling the days when he was the champion rifle and pistol shot of the world as vividly as if they were yesterday. Carver was the first partner of Buffalo Bill, organizing First a Wild West show in 1883, while Col. W. F. Cody was appearing on the stage and then getting Cody to join him in that soon was to become the famous "Carver & Cody's Wild West." But longer before that "Doc" Carver had been an Indian fighter and killed not fewer than 30,000 buffalo on the plains. So deadly was his aim that the Indians called him "the Evil Spirit of the Plains." As a wingshot he knew no equal; being the greatest rifle shot from the back of a running horse he soon became known also throughout the world as the man who with either rifle or pistol could penetrate with a single shot any silver coin tossed in the air.

After defeating all the crack shots in America when shooting was shooting to boast of, he appeared in public exhibitions in 1879, and subsequently before the crowded heads of Europe, and today treasures royal gifts from the late Edward VII of England, ex-Kaiser Wilhelm and the late Franz Joseph, emperor of Austria.

Someone at Norfolk the other day asked "Doc" Carver's secretary, Charles R. Nordin of Omaha, how many notches Carver had in his gun. "He hasn't any," was the quick reply, "for he only notched 'em when he missed—and he never missed." "Doc" Carver still is a dominant figure in any assembly. He is 6 feet 2 inches in height and weighs 240 pounds. He says he was born in 1840, but one would easily mistake him for a man of 65.

If "Doc" Carver was Buffalo Bill's first partner, "Pawnee Bill" (Maj. Gordon W. Lillie) of Pawnee, Okla., was his last. The reunion between Carver and "Pawnee Bill" was happy indeed. "Gordon was just a rosy cheeked boy of 16 when Cody and I got him into our show," Carver said. "Now he is still rosy cheeked and boyish, even with some gray hairs from six raised with a wondrous $400 French siren horn. He borrowed for his driver the mayor of Pawnee, O. O. Mentzer. Major Lillie's story is well known. Retiring from the show business a few years ago, he established a large ranch in Oklahoma and keeps a herd of buffalo there.

Captain "Lute" North

Comes now—and really one of the most important figures in this unique conference—Capt. "Lute" North of Columbus, Neb. Almost everybody in the state knows Captain "Lute," and those who are familiar with the history of the West since the '60's should recall him instantly. Like "Deadwood Dick," Capt. Luther H. North was a veteran Indian fighter. He was a captain in the Pawnee Indian scouts, which he organized in 1864 to help put down the depredations of the warlike Sioux and Cheyennes. Later his company became a part of the battalion of four companies under his brother, the late Maj. Frank North. These men knew Cody long before he was "Buffalo Bill," and when he, too, was a leader of Pawnee scouts and helped fight the Indians.

"Lute" North knew General Terry and Custer and Crook. Also he lived among the Indians and became well acquainted with their language and knew intimately such chiefs as Gall, Crazy Horse and Rain-in-the-Face, and the medicine man, Sitting Bull. Captain North is 81 years old now, but, he, too, has the appearance and keen recollection of a man of 60.

"Idaho Bill" and "Diamond Dick"

"Idaho Bill," whose real name is Col. B. R. Pearson, was born in 1868 on the Oregon trail, either in Nebraska or Wyoming. His father was a railroad construction foreman. Nute Kay Pearson, who homesteaded in Adams county, Nebraska, in 1872, where "Idaho Bill's" sister, Mrs. H. E. Van Boening, still lives near the town of Hastings. In his younger days "Idaho Bill" was a scout and trapper of wild animals, and in 1908 roped wolves and took them to Chicago for an exhibition. He owns a large ranch in the Snake river valley of Idaho, where he has raised many hundreds of horses. At one time 1,500 head of horses ran on his ranges and today there still remain about 900. He acquired a competence selling horses to the British army during the Boer War, and before that time was a noted buffalo hunter.

Theodore Roosevelt visited Pearson's ranch of 20,000 acres near Weiser, Idaho, while president and there made his famous bear hunt. One of "Idaho Bill's" best tricks is to catch mountain lions and wolves alive by lassoing them. He is as picturesque as his photograph and still wears his hair long, almost to his waist, and a slender goatee that he says is nothing more than a wisp of mane.

"Diamond Dick," who in private life is Dr. Richard J. Tanner, is Norfolk's local celebrity. Dr. Tanner freely admits there were other men known as "Diamond Dick," but says he has used the name since he was 16 years old, at which time he adopted it and went into a show as a crack shot and rider. His chief claim to fame came with his ride on his horse, Gyp, covering 5,500 miles in nine months—from March 15 to November 19, 1893. He came to Norfolk unassumingly more than a dozen years ago after getting his degree in a medical college and has been a practicing physician here under his real name since.

The "Powwow" Begins

The six famous frontiersmen sat around a large table. C. E. Burnham, president of the Norfolk National Bank, became chairman of the informal meeting and announced its purpose. To set aright some disputed history concerning what happened at the Battle of the Little Big Horn. Was General Custer a suicide, as a recent magazine article had stated? There follows a word-for-word report of the "powwow."

Mr. Burnham—In our discussion of the Custer fight yesterday I asked if you gentlemen had read the article in the Cosmopolitan stating that Custer had committed suicide, and before I got the words out of my mouth Deadwood Dick said, "That's a damn lie."

Deadwood Dick—And I still say it.

Mr. Burnham—Doctor Carver, you were familiar with the circumstances there, the orders that were given to Reno, and the fact that he did not obey them. I think Lute disagrees with you on Reno not obeying orders.

Deadwood Dick—I disagree with him.

Mr. Burnham—Dr. Carver says that Reno absolutely disobeyed orders.

Dr. Carver—What do you boys want to know?

Mr. Burnham—They want the real story of the Custer fight. What happened from beginning to end.

Dr. Carver—The white men killed the buffalo off for five years to get the Indians on the reservations. Crazy Horse was one of the bravest Indians that ever lived. When they took the Black Hills away from him it broke his heart. He met a white man in a field one day, armed with a Winchester. Crazy Horse had only a quirt, but instead of running away, Crazy Horse, who didn't know what fear was, faced the man and the Winchester and chased that man clear in to Deadwood.

The Indians used to go into battle with no means of transportation and they whipped the white men with their bows and arrows. Terry, Gibbon and Godfrey couldn't whip the Indians. I am an Indian at heart, and have no love for palefaces. The whites rode into the camps and chased them out, the Ogallalas, Uncpapas, Brules and Cheyennes—they never whipped the Sioux in their lives. The Sioux have never been whipped.

How the Indians Whipped Crook

Now they go out with all the great generals—they had it all fixed and were going to eat the Indians up. General Crook was the best friend I ever had. He was going to fix the Indians, but when they woke up the Indians were scrapping and they stopped him, whipped him right. Crook hung around like a whipped pup, and then he went into Deadwood, ragged, dirty, and hungry. All they had to eat was the horses they killed. Crook was supposed to follow the Indians and they cut off his supply trains. Then they whipped him, the best soldiers, best cavalry that ever was.

After the Indians whipped Crook, comes Custer with a lot of soldiers with the old Sharp's carbine, that you can't shoot with, because they kick up. Shooting on horseback they had to hold the reins with one hand and shoot with the other, and you can't hit anything. Down came Custer, down the bluff alongside of the Indian village. Reno was going down and come in behind them and drive them up this way, and they'd clean them up.

Dear old Reno—it took them three minutes to give him a trimming—he mounted and dismounted his men three times—and then told them, "Every man for himself and get into the bluffs." Reno got up on the bluffs, dug some holes there and a lot of kids and squaws kept him there.

Custer came down off the bluff and there was a ravine—he dismounted his soldiers and started down the side of the bluff. Here were the Indians on the other side of the ravine—he got 100 feet, threw out a skirmish line and in three minutes the skirmish line was gone and in the next ten minutes all of his men would have been dead.

Deadwood Dick Speaks

Deadwood Dick—When Custer was called to Washington, he was called in on the Kansas City, Kan., deal and any man that served in the service knows that the articles of war read that a deserter in the front of the enemy is to be killed. When they surrounded Antelope's band in Kansas, there were two men in that company who, instead of staying with the colors, just turned their horses and left the fight. After the scrap was over, they were to tell him that if he burned any more settlements they would clean them out. They followed the deserters. Here is where the call to Washington came in. The men were brought back—they couldn't go from here to there and they were caught and they had to shoot them. There was a court-martial held and Custer wasn't in it. They pick the court like a jury. They were the men who condemned them to death. The men were shot. After a little while Custer was called in on that very question.

That was when they cut us (scout's pay) from $125 to $16.50 and we quit in a body at Fort Totten—the 21st infantry—we quit in a body and we came down. Word came if the white men won't, the Indians will. They did. The expedition started in the spring—the Indian agent said there were only about 1,500 off the reservation. There were close on to 15,000 Indians.

Dr. Carver—Those Indians had fought all their lives with muzzle loaders and bows and arrows and I traded a lot of weapons for them. When Custer came up against 1,000 Winchesters—that amounts to 16,000 Indians with muzzle loaders—Custer's men were killed before they knew what happened.

Thompson is one of the fellows that claims he got lost from the command and hid in the hills and got out—the only man that got out of the fight was Curley and he was on a bluff watching it. Comanche is the only living thing that came out of that fight; he died at Riley later. A horse.

"Lute" North's Version

Captain North—Reno had just 112 men when he went into the fight. Suppose Reno came in on the flank—he lost 30 men before he was in there two minutes.

Dr. Carver—He had 29 men killed when he crossed the creek.

Deadwood Dick—Before we go any further with Reno. Plem, nothing but a buck private—they wanted water, they didn't have any and Plem took canteens—16 of them—and went down the bluff, filled them and came back. When he came back Reno was going to have him court-martialed.

Dr. Carver—That man came back without being hit—you might go through a hail storm and not get hit.

Deadwood Dick—That is what he did. Reno was going to have him court-martialed for disobeying orders. When the thing was all over—Reno got a little bronze medal—Reno didn't. When Plem was discharged from Ft. Meade—before he started riding with the Northwestern Stage company, we named a butte for him—Plem Butte, which was a stage station. The day Plem got his discharge, Plem turned around and asked if he was again a citizen—he could say what he pleased and he said "Reno, you are a dirty, cowardly son of a dog"—and Reno stood it. Right there is what Plem done and Reno ducked his head and walked to his quarters. I can prove every word I am saying. Plem got a bronze cross, what we fight for. Reno was cashiered on half pay and Plem got the medal.

Dr. Carver—One man went for water and got shot in the leg—they had to cut his leg off and before they did it they gave him a drink of whisky.

Deadwood Dick—And he said to give another drink and cut the other one off!

Captain North—I am just as much a friend of Custer as either of you. I think Custer was one of the very best men that ever went out as an Indian fighter. He wasn't afraid of anything. He had the right idea of fighting Indians, go to them when you can find them; don't wait. Custer was that kind of a man, and I am a friend of his as much as you are. I am going back years before this. You probably know,—will remembered about the Belknap scandal in the Grant cabinet. Custer knew about that and he knew what was being done. He knew that these tradershipts were being traded in through politics and knew that the forage and rations that went out to the different posts weren't up to standard at all. He went to Washington voluntarily to go before the senate investigating committee that investigated Belknap. There was where he got in bad. Sherman was at the head of the army—Phil Sherman was in command of the department—he would do anything they told him to do. I was with Custer in '74 when Custer went into the Black Hills. After that he went before the testimony, and after he gave his testimony, whatever it was, he didn't come back to his regiment. His regiment was at Ft. Abe. Lincoln. Custer was sent home ostensibly on furlough, but he was just sent there. He was home a year, wasn't even in charge of the regiment, let alone the division. He didn't come back until '76. When the expedition was outfitted in '76, Custer was brought back and given command of the regiment. They put Terry in charge of the expedition.

Dr. Carver—Custer was sent on the expedition with only an hour's time—no chance to arrange things.

"Custer Wanted All the Glory"

Captain North—Custer started out with his regiment to locate the Indians. He didn't go five miles before he drew up the men in a line and told them that if they located the Indians the 7th cavalry was to have all the glory. He said then that he would disobey orders.

He divided his regiment into three columns. He gave Reno—and Reno may be a coward—he gave him three companies and he took the five companies himself. In the last order that Custer gave in his life, he said "Go to the river and when you find the village attack it." Reno did, with 112 men he attacked the village of 4,000 warriors. He was licked in two minutes, lost 29 men. He lost his head, the soldiers lost their heads and the Indians say when the men turned they staggered across the river; they seemed drunk; the Indians knocked them off their horses with the butts of their guns. Reno took his men onto the ridge. Reno was to attack the upper end of the village. Benteen was to come in further down. Custer turned back of the ridge, I guess, and rode down—this is guess work—Custer rode down there to head them off.

Dr. Carver—Custer went to the lower end of the village—the Cheyennes were there—White Shield, Spread Nose, Yellow Belly, Bobbed Tailed Horse, they were in the village when Custer got there and the Indians didn't know he was there till he was down the hill.

Captain North—You said they were all killed in a short distance. Some of them went clean down to the river. Bobbed Tailed Horse told me so.

Dr. Carver—Bobbed Tailed Horse is another.

Captain North—They were divided into seven units, the Indians said, instead of five troops. Two of them must have been divided, for there were seven units. The Indians fighting Reno jumped off their horses, ran up the ravine, and this fight that we imagine was fought on horseback was nearly all fought on foot, Indians and soldiers. Bobbed Tailed Horse told me he was crawling up this gully. Every fourth man was holding the horses—the horses broke loose and ran over toward the Indians. The saddlebags were full of ammunition. He had a gun that Crazy Horse captured on the Rosebud, and this ammunition fitted these guns. "If we hadn't got this ammunition out of the saddlebags we couldn't have killed them so quick," he told me. It was over while you could light a pipe.

Custer's Last Message

Deadwood Dick—Major Reno was in command of the right wing. French and Benteen were under Reno—they had to do what he said with their troops. What he said went—he was in command. They had to take their men up where Reno was. The men were lost crossing the river. Reno was in command, and he would not let a man out of that place. Gibbon couldn't get there; he had infantry. Terry could have come, but he didn't. The Far West came up the Yellowstone, and he stayed there at the mouth of the Big Horn. I have talked with Green Grass, and I talked with Crazy Thunder—last Seventy-six celebration day we were talking about this thing. Crazy Grass told me if they had waited another two hours the trumpeter that carried Custer's last dispatch, that was torn out of a—a leaf out of his book, reading, "Send me reinforcements—hurry"—and Reno didn't send the reinforcements, and that is the last man that saw Custer alive.

Dr. Carver—General Custer had 205 men when he went into the fight. Charley Reynolds—Hamilton was his name, he shot a sentry down in Lexington, Ky., before he came out here. The Indians called him Charley the Fox, and they said he shot 30 Indians fighting in front of Custer.

Deadwood Dick—There were three Custers killed in the fight, George, Tom and Boston.

Captain North—The first question that Reno asked of Terry and Gibbon was where Custer was. He thought he had gone back to Terry.

Dr. Carver—They whipped Crook, cleaned out Custer, and now comes Terry. They pulled down their tepees. Sitting Bull took his Uncpapas into Canada and the rest of them marched right around between Reno and Terry and went to their reservation.

Mr. Burnham—The Cosmopolitan story about Custer committing suicide—is it fact or fiction?

A Hung Jury

Captain North—The story is fiction, pure and simple.

Dr. Carver—Part of it is fiction and part is very true.

Deadwood Dick—It is fiction, the whole thing right through, all the way through.

And so it went far into the night, refighting the renowned fight on the Little Big Horn. Yet each of these three old Indian fighters is positive his own version is the true one—just as the Indians related it. Still the three, Carver, "Deadwood Dick," and "Lute" North, cannot agree. Carver believes Custer was a suicide. North believes he was foolhardy and allowed himself to be ambushed and that Reno used wisdom in not taking his command into certain death. While "Deadwood Dick" believes that Custer died fighting and that Reno was a coward. There you have it—a hung jury.

While the argument became heated at times it was generally agreed that the Indians were poor witnesses and that their testimony could not be entirely depended upon, so there was an occasional outburst of good natured laughter.

So it was not all stern fighting that the old plainsmen recounted. Finally when the ends of their cigars had begun to burn low, like the embers of a dying campfire, they said goodnight, and goodby, perhaps with just a little pathos after holding each rough hand, for now there was separating the men who never before had met together and perhaps never would meet again. For true men are these; something more than a band of boisterous gun-fighters with vainglorious tales of outlawry. Rather they must be regarded sturdy heroes and onetime soldiers who went forth valiantly to ride, to shoot and if need be to die to push back the Wild West before our advancing civilization.

MAJOR MARCUS A. RENO, who was cashiered from the army because he did not send a handful of men against thousands of well armed Indian warriors.

CURLEY. Crow scout, who witnessed part of the Custer fight and got away.

GENERAL GEORGE A. CUSTER, most famous figure of our Indian wars, who, according to a recent magazine article, committed suicide, when his command was decimated and a wave of red warriors was sweeping over him. Old Indian fighters say the story is without foundation of fact.

See the clipping

Watson sorts the Sitting Bull legends

Marking American Indian Day and a South Dakota poetry contest on Sitting Bull, Elmo Scott Watson lists five tales he calls ‘sheer bunk’: that he was a half-breed, a West Point man, a Mason, the battle’s commander in chief, and Custer’s blood brother. There was no commander, he writes; Gall, Crazy Horse and Two Moons led. The Custer suicide story, he adds, has been repeatedly disproved. His verdict: ‘From the white man’s point of view he was a malcontent; from the Indian’s, a patriot.’

The St. Johns Herald · St. Johns, Ariz. · and 5 other papers

The St. Johns Herald · 15 September 1927 · page 6 · transcribed from the page image

TATANKA YOTANKA Sitting Bull

By ELMO SCOTT WATSON

See moreSee less

AMERICAN INDIAN DAY, which is observed on the third Friday in September in many states, has an added touch of interest this year because of the announced plan for honoring a great leader in a new way. Sitting Bull, the Sioux, is to be made the subject of a poetry contest to be conducted by Pasque Petals, South Dakota poetry magazine. C. N. Herried of Aberdeen has offered a cash prize for the best 40-line poem on Sitting Bull, to be submitted to the magazine before December 1 of this year. "From my viewpoint, Sitting Bull was one of the truly great among the many notable Sioux of the Dakotas, in spite of the fact that he has been misunderstood and maligned," Mr. Herried has declared.

There are many students of history who will confirm Mr. Herried's estimate. So far history's verdict on Sitting Bull has been handed down mainly by white men who saw in him only a troublemaker, irreconcilable to the fate imposed upon his race by the white men under the name of civilization. If ever the red man is called upon to hand down a verdict, he will probably find in the fact that Sitting Bull was irreconcilable a kind of racial patriotism that can only be admired, misguided though it may have been.

It is doubtful if the name of any other Indian is so well known to the average American as is the name of this warrior and tribal leader of the Hunkpapa Teton division of the great Sioux or Dakota confederacy. And a corollary to that statement is that it is also doubtful if there have ever been told about any other Indian so many wild tales, and if there has ever been included in them so much sheer bunk as have been told and written about Tatanka Yotanka (Tatanka—Buffalo Bull; Yotanka—Sitting). Here are a few of the choice bits of misinformation that have at one time or another been given out as fact, and as such have been accepted by some so-called historians:

(1) Sitting Bull was a half-breed, and after receiving a good education from French-Canadian priests, returned to his people and "went back to the blanket."

(2) Sitting Bull was a graduate of West Point, who gradually drifted back into savage life. He had various solid acquirements, could speak French like a Parisian, was a close student of Napoleon's campaigns, etc., etc.

(3) Sitting Bull was a Mason, knew the Masonic ritual and lodge work as well as the emblems and on at least two occasions saved the lives of white men, captured by his warriors, because they wore Masonic emblems.

(4) Sitting Bull was commander in chief of all the Indians at the Battle of the Little Big Horn where Custer was killed, and he gave to a missionary who had been adopted into his tribe a complete account of how he planned the battle which ended so disastrously for the soldiers. This involved placing dummy figures in front of the lodges in the village to deceive the soldiers. After thus setting the stage he retired to the hills with his warriors, having first sent the women and children to a place of safety. Before the soldiers could recover from the surprise at finding the village deserted, Sitting Bull fell upon them from the rear and destroyed most of them.

(5) Sitting Bull visited West Point in 1859, there met Cadet Custer, and such a warm friendship sprang up between the red man and white that Sitting Bull made Custer his "blood brother." Accordingly, the day before the Battle of the Little Big Horn, Sitting Bull called a council, told his warriors that they were to fight Custer the next day, but that since Custer was his "blood brother," they were not to harm him. And then the cavalry leader foiled the Indian's kind purpose by committing suicide when he saw that all was lost!

From the most authoritative sources of information available, the patent absurdities of these statements can be disposed of as follows:

(1) Sitting Bull was a full-blood Sioux, born on the Grand river, S. D., about 1834, the son of a subchief of the Hunkpapa, named Four Horns, who changed his name to Sitting Bull when he "made medicine" in 1857. As a boy Sitting Bull (the younger) was first known as Jumping Badger. When he was fourteen he accompanied his father on the warpath against the Crows and counted his first coup on the body of a fallen enemy. On the return of the party his father made a feast, gave away many horses and announced that his son had won the right to be known by his name.

(2) This statement is too ridiculous on the face of it to warrant denial. As for his ability to speak French, it is possible that he picked up some words and phrases from French Candian traders and others with whom the Sioux came into contact, but more than that the story of his linguistic ability is undoubtedly fictitious.

(3) Possible but highly improbable. Neither of the two cases are sufficiently authenticated to be accepted seriously. It may have been mere coincidence that two men whose lives he spared were Masons. There is said to be a similarity between some of the secret signs of Masonry and some of the Indian sign language in universal use among the Plains tribes and a similarity between some of the Masonic ceremonies and certain Indian ceremonials. These similarities may have been one of the origins of this yarn.

(4) The part of Sitting Bull at the Custer battle is at best an equivocal one. Although his being the son of a subchief would give him some hereditary right to leadership, he had risen to prominence among the Sioux as a medicine man and a councillor because he possessed "accuracy of judgment, knowledge of men, a student-like disposition to observe natural phenomena, and a deep insight into affairs among Indians and such white people as he came into contact with." Before the Custer battle he had predicted a great victory for the Indians, and at the opening of the fight he retired to the hills some distance away and was there during the engagement. But there was no especial disgrace attached to Sitting Bull, the medicine man, doing this. Diplomats and statesmen of other nations who bring about wars are usually far from the firing line.

As for "commander in chief of the Indian forces" there was none in that battle. An Indian chief's authority over his followers was only nominal, and of all the thousands of Sioux (Oglala, Hunkpapa, Brule, Minlconjou, Sans Arc and Sihasapa) and Northern Cheyennes on the Little Big Horn that day, few, except possibly the members of Sitting Bull's immediate band of Hunkpapa, would have acknowledged his authority. The Indian leaders who were principally responsible for the tactics which resulted in the defeat of the Seventh cavalry, were first and foremost, Gall of the Hunkpapas, and then Crazy Horse of the Oglalas and Two Moons of the Northern Cheyennes.

(5) So far as there is any authentic record, the first visit Sitting Bull ever paid to the East was in 1868 when he, Red Cloud of the Oglalas and Spotted Tail of the Brules went to Washington, where they were received by President Grant. If he visited Custer at West Point or ever had any contact with that officer, it is indeed curious that Custer himself in his writings, Mrs. Custer in hers (notably her books, "Boots and Saddles," "Following the Guidon" and "Tenting on the Plains," or any of the accurate and painstaking biographers of the leader of the Seventh, never have mentioned the fact. So this incident can be dismissed as pure fiction, as can Sitting Bull's instructions that Custer's life should be spared. The "Custer suicide" story has been repeatedly disproved by men who saw his body soon after the battle.

In stating that Sitting Bull was more noted as a medicine man than a war leader, it should not be supposed that he was lacking in ability as the latter, even though there has been some dispute on this point. Col. James McLaughlin, agent on the Standing Rock reservation where Sitting Bull spent his last years, has always maintained that he was a physical coward, and others have pointed to his actions at the Custer battle as evidence of that fact. Dr. Charles A. Eastman, the noted Sioux author, as the result of his investigations among his own race, has recorded several incidents of Sitting Bull's valor in battle, and it is reasonable to suppose that Doctor Eastman could come nearer getting the truth about Sitting Bull than any white man.

So a final summing up of Tatanka Yotanka—and perhaps some of the entrants in the South Dakota poetry contest may voice it in their verse—would write him down as a brave warrior in his youth, at a later period the most sagacious and powerful medicine man the Sioux ever had and an embittered "caged eagle" in his last years. From the white man's point of view he was a malcontent; from the Indian's, a patriot. These were the words of Sitting Bull once when he was being questioned by an importunate American newspaper man: "I am," said he, crossing both hands upon his chest, slightly nodding, and smiling satirically, "a man!"

See the clipping

‘Last survivors’ traced down

Writing after the death of Peter Thompson of Ekalaka, who said a lame horse kept him out of Custer’s last fight, W. H. Banfill goes through the men who claimed to have survived it: a man named Finkle who said his horse carried him out blinded and wounded, Sebastian Best who said he watched it as a captive of the Sioux, a man who watched through a spyglass from a hill. Traced down, the headline says, they were usually with Reno or Benteen; ‘there have been sole survivors enough to equal Custer’s command.’

The Kevin Review · Kevin, Mont. · and 1 other paper

CorrectionThis set right 2 earlier articles: St. Croix Avis, 20 December 1928, The Buffalo Bulletin, 20 December 1928.

The Kevin Review · 3 January 1929 · page 7 · transcribed from the page image

"Last Survivors"

Of Custer Battle on the Little Big Horn Have Died With Astonishing Regularity During Recent Years, But Traced Down It Usually

See moreSee less

Develops that They Were Really With Reno or Benteen on the Day of that Disastrous Fight

(By W. H. BANFILL)

THE recent death of Peter Thompson of Ekalaka, who claimed that he missed the fate of Custer and his command only by reason that his horse became lame on the march, brings to mind that scores of men since the day of the tragic battle of the Little Big Horn, have posed as survivors of the fight or the last to see Custer alive. Thompson's record in this respect is far more substantial than most of those who have aspired to the limelight or who have been thrust into it by some unusual association with Custer. Thompson, according to the account he gave at Hardin in 1921 when a commemorative stone was unveiled on the 45th anniversary of the battle, was a member of one of the troops that was under Custer's immediate command when he rode away from the detachments under Reno and Benteen.

According to Thompson, while on the trail after the separation, his horse cast a shoe and became lame and he was unable to keep up with the band. With the heat, he became exhausted and finding he would be unable to overtake his comrades, he joined two other stragglers and they made their way back to McDougall's pack train and finally joined Reno's command, entrenched in the hills.

During the siege of Reno and Benteen by the Indians, he was slightly wounded. In spite of his wounds, however, he went for water for his comrades, a venture of great danger, as the Indians endeavored to cut the force off from water, to compel them to abandon their entrenched positions.

Thompson was the proud possessor of a congressional medal, given for his heroism on July 25 and 26, 1876. Whether or not he could justly lay claim to having been the last white man to see Custer of those who lived to tell the tale, is another question.

As far as his being a survivor of the battle is concerned, his title is perhaps somewhat better than that of a former resident of Huntley who died several years ago. He also might have met his death along with Custer but he was placed in the guardhouse at Fort Abraham Lincoln for being drunk or some other misconduct before the expedition started and was left behind. His troop was one that was annihilated.

For many years there lived at Billings, an old, taciturn man, John Burkman, who for many years had charge of General Custer's horses and dogs and who saddled his horse Victor, the morning of the fatal charge. Burkman had been interviewed and queried so often about Custer and the circumstances of his defeat that the mere mention of Custer's name was sufficient for him to shut up like a clam and only a few who had known him long could get him to talk on the subject at all. Burkman lived to be nearly 90 and then, threatened with blindness, committed suicide.

Custer Changed Horses

On the morning of the fatal day, Custer, who had been riding his favorite horse, Dandy, in an early hour scouting trip to locate the Indian village, returned to camp and after deciding on the plans for the attack with his officers, changed to Victor, the Kentucky thoroughbred, who shared with him the fate of the battlefield. Burkman was at least one of the last men left behind to whom Custer spoke.

Burkman had been with Custer since the reconstruction days in Kentucky and Tennessee where breaking up moonshine distilleries and suppressing the Ku Klux Klan were the principal tasks. His service under the general continued through the four years at Fort Abraham Lincoln, including the Stanley expedition and the Black hill episodes until the final tragedy.

Scattered through Montana and here and there in other states as well, are still a handful of men who can boast of some close connection with Custer's last battle; men who were besieged on the hills with Reno and Benteen and fought desperately to ward off a similar fate; soldiers in Gibbon's command who were the first to see the awful carnage field; men who were with the steamer Far West which bore back Reno's wounded soldiers and the cruel news of disaster. And as these men pass on one by one, the story of Custer's last stand, with all its dramatic elements, will be made new again.

News dispatches not so long ago carried an account of the death of a certain "last survivor" of Custer's command. As new survivors spring up with a fair regularity, the supply must still be large in spite of occasional deaths. Although with the exception of perhaps Curley, the Crow scout, historians of the battle remain firm in the belief that none escaped, there have been sole survivors enough to equal Custer's command.

Used Poor Judgment

Seven or eight years ago while on a newspaper staff at Walla Walla, I interviewed a man named Finkle who posed as the only survivor of the battle. He claimed that he enlisted under the name of Frank Hall although his account would have been better if he had stuck to his own name, as there was a man named Finkle killed with Custer, although the first name was not the same. On the other hand, no Hall was on the muster roll.

Although the old gentleman had rather a hazy conception of directions, his account of his escape was thrilling enough to make up for other deficiencies. In the early part of the battle he was wounded in the foot while another bullet was imbedded in the flesh of the muscles above his hips. His horse was wounded in the flank and another bullet cut one of the bridle reins. Still another bullet hit the iron of his gun and a splinter struck him between the eyes, causing the blood to spurt over his face, blinding him so that he was unable to see. His horse bolted for the hills and with only one line, he was unable to control it. He remembered hearing bullets whistle above his head but could not recall going through the Indian lines.

For some time he rode, dazed and almost unconscious, with a hazy idea of getting back to the other troops but with no idea of direction. Finally he got off his horse and picketed him and slept awhile. On the second day, he saw some mountains at a distance and started for them. On the third day, he reached the cabin of some trappers, where he found two men, one of whom was sick with the mountain fever, from which he died a few days later. Here Finkle remained for four months, the surviving trapper nursing him back to health.

Near Fort Benton

When he came to leave, Bill, the only name the trapper gave, told him he was about two days' journey from Fort Benton and showed him the route to take. When the attention of Finkle was called to the necessity of crossing the Yellowstone river to get from Custer's battlefield to Fort Benton, he said, "My horse must have carried me across, one of those times when I didn't know much of what was happening." As the Yellowstone is commonly a raging torrent in the latter part of June, his explanation, to say the least, did not sound plausible.

At Fort Benton, Finkle said that he heard for the first time of the complete annihilation of Custer's men. He told no one of his part in the fight, merely saying that he had been wounded in a scrap with some Indians. A boat was going down the river and Finkle after being refused a job on it because of his crippled condition, hid on board until it started and finally induced the captain to carry him as far as Sioux City. Finkle said that he had never made any effort to obtain an army discharge or to gain official recognition; he had lost all his papers, the officers that he knew had all been killed and he "wasn't going to chase all over the country to find some one to discharge me."

An article which recounted Finkle's claim to fame, brought several letters in reply from various people who have made a "hobby" of Custer battle memorabilia, including E. A. Brininstool, the author of "A Trooper With Custer," and other books on frontier wars. Mr. Brininstool said that the woods were full of Custer survivors and that he had a friend in Chicago who was acquainted with 14 men who claimed to be survivors.

Some Annoyed Mrs. Custer

Brininstool told of one man who claimed that he laid on a hill half a mile from the battlefield and watched the fight through a spyglass. The man described the battle in great detail and was able to clear up all the controverted points about the battle which have always been a matter of speculation. Some of these imposters have even been bold enough to endeavor to get an audience with Mrs. Custer herself in the hope that they could gain her help in furthering their recognition, and she has been given no little annoyance by their efforts.

The first "survivor" to seek and gain notoriety was one Sebastian Best, whose story went the rounds of the national press as early as 1881 or 1882. Best's claim, however, was rather that of an eye-witness as he avowed that he was a captive among the Sioux Indians at the time of the battle.

According to Best, he was a captive among the Sioux for six years until he was regarded as almost one of them. He said that the Sioux built a decoy camp, placing billets of wood covered with blankets around the camp fires to represent seated Indians. When Custer rode down and opened fire on the "faked" camp, 3,000 Sioux warriors rode down off the mountain sides and surrounded him. Custer with his sabre left many a ragged edge cross as a trademark on the redskins' faces but finally fell, pierced with seven bullets.

Best claimed that he saw the intrepid officer die and that when his foes closed in at last and he saw there was no escape, he exclaimed, "I am all alone. I have done my best. The boys are all gone and I go with them." Best finally escaped from the Indians after traveling for a long distance with a fleeing band and made his way back to a frontier town. Like many of the other survivors, Best waited, however, until he had returned east to give his tale to a credulous world.

Indians Saw One Escape

Although historians of the battle are agreed that there were no survivors of the battle with the possible exception of Curley, the Crow scout, it is of interest to note that several of the battle chiefs of the Sioux and Cheyennes in the account which they gave of the fight years afterward, said that one trooper severely wounded got through their lines. Perhaps they had heard of one of the many "sole survivors" and thought they might as well leave him a loop-hole of escape.

The soldiers who were sent in the next year to complete the hasty job of burial which Gibbons' men had done, were able to account for all of the squadron but two. Later the skeletons of two men were found at some distance from the scene of conflict so that avenue of escape would seem to be closed. The soldier whom the chiefs thought escaped might have been one of these men who got away from the main body only to perish a little way on. Mistakes are made in counting up the deal on a battlefield, however, and one of Reno's dead might have got mixed in by mistake.

If there is any element of doubt, however, it is very small indeed. And even if the chance of one survivor were conceded, the historian would have a herculean job in discovering the true survivor from the army of imposters. Probably like the "Man in the Iron Mask," the "Lost Dauphin" and the Czar's daughter, Anastasia, the sole survivor of the Custer fight will continue to bob up in the field of speculation in spite of all the historians can do to bury him under the facts, and we doubtless haven't heard the last of him yet.

Commanche, the horse ridden into the battle of the Little Big Horn by Captain Keogh of Custer's command and which was the only horse of the troop left alive after the fight was over. Commanche was "pensioned" by the government and lived for many years.

Curley, the Crow Scout, the only man of Custer's immediate command who escaped alive from the Little Big Horn battle. He died on the Crow reservation several years ago.

See the clipping

An old scout comes home to Lawton

W. B. (Curley) Hicks, 89, who says his real name is McAlpin, returns to his birthplace at Lawton, Okla., and tells the United Press he witnessed the massacre; other claimants, he says, are fakes. Sitting Bull was eight miles away, he says, and Gall led the raid. Custer gave him a message for ‘General Terrey’, and fifty paces off he turned and saw Custer fall.

The Indianapolis Times · Indianapolis, Ind.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 8 days later.

Wrong

The Indianapolis Times · 2 January 1930 · page 7 · transcribed from the page image

CUSTER'S LAST STAND RETOLD BY OLD SCOUT

Declares He Has Proof of His Statements About Famous Battles.

See moreSee less

By United Press

LAWTON, Okla., Jan. 2.—An old Indian scout, who claims to have witnessed the massacre of General Custer and to trace his ancestry to the famous McAlpin famliy of the east, came to Lawton to visit once again, before his death, the place of his birth.

W. B. (Curley) Hicks has followed the trail of adventure for more than four score years and now the trail has led back home.

"I know I have been failing the past year and so I came back to visit my birthplace," said the old timer when he arrived here.

Tells Thrilling Story

Hicks, who claims his real name is McAlpin and that he is the son of the late George McAlpin, founder of the Philadelphia Masonic lodge, tells a story as thrilling and as adventurous as those of the Diamond Dick novels of generations ago.

With his long, silvery hair hanging to his shoulders, the pioneer, who stands erect and walks with a firm step despite his age of 89 years, recites minute details of Custer's last stand in Wyoming. Other persons claim they are survivors of Custer's last stand, but they are "fakes," declares Hicks.

Has the Proof

"Why should I say I have had these experiences if there is no truth behind my statements?" the old scout asks. "I have been traveling about fifty years and proof of my adventures are in the historical societies' records.

Curley said Custer was a lieutenant colonel, not a general. He said Custer's widow lives in New York and that Sitting Bull was eight miles away when Custer and his men were killed. He said Chief Gall conducted the raid against Custer.

Custer saw he was outnumbered and motioned for Hicks to come to him. He gave the scout a message to be delivered to General Terrey. Hicks claimed that when about fifty paces away he turned and saw Custer place his hand to his head and side and fall, mortally wounded.

See the clipping

← Back to Act Eleven: The Statue