As the Papers Told It

Little Bighorn · As the Papers Told It

Act Five

Hunting Sitting Bull

December 1876 – November 1877

The army kept after the Sioux through the winter. Montana’s legislature voted to rename the Little Bighorn ‘Custer’s River.’ Red Horse, come in to the agency, told the story of the fight at ‘Greasy Grass creek’; Crazy Horse surrendered in the spring and was killed at Camp Robinson in September. In July soldiers gathered the officers’ bones, some already uncovered by wolves, and in October Custer was buried at West Point. In Canada Sitting Bull told a correspondent his version: ‘The fight was hell.’

Sherman’s report: nobody expected 3,000

In his annual report General Sherman says nothing official or private led any officer to expect more than 500 to 800 warriors. Reno, watching from his bluff, put them at 2,500 to 3,000: agency Indians had come out to join the fight. Custer’s five companies were ‘literally obliterated,’ and in all twelve officers, 247 men, five civilians and three scouts were killed.

Essex County Herald · Guildhall, Vt.

Essex County Herald · 9 December 1876 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image

The Custer Massacre.

Referring to the engagement between General Custer and the Sioux Indians, General Sherman, in his annual report, says that at the time the commands separated to meet at a certain point on a certain day there was nothing official or private to justify an officer to expect that any detachment could encounter more than 500, or, at the maximum, 800 warriors.

See moreSee less

In this engagement the five companies of the Seventh cavalry, led by Lieut.-Colonel Custer in person, viz.: "C," "E," "F" "I," and "L," were literally obliterated and the remaining seven companies saved by the brave and prudent conduct of Major Reno, and the timely arrival of Gen. Terry. The loss was twelve officers, 247 enlisted men, five civilians, and three Indian scouts killed, and two officers and fifty-one men wounded—a full list of names being on file. The loss by the Indians cannot be ascertained, but is variously estimated from forty to one hundred dead. Major Reno, from his bluff overlooking the valley of the Little Big Horn, saw the Indians break camp on the approach of General Terry's command, defile across the hills, and estimated the number of warriors at from 2,500 to 3,000, so that it amounted to a demonstration that the campaign had been planned on the wrong premises; that the troops were dealing with not only the hostiles, estimated at from 500 to 800, but with the available part of the agency Indians, who had gone out to help their friends in a fight, which was sure to result from preparations they themselves had witnessed.

See the clipping

The Little Big Horn to be Custer’s River

A Deer Lodge paper prints the resolution, introduced by Rotwitt from the committee on Indian Affairs, that the Little Big Horn ‘shall forever hereafter be known as Custer’s River.’ On W. F. Sanders’s motion the rules are suspended, the members rise to their feet to vote, and it passes unanimously.

The New North-West · Deer Lodge, Mont.

The New North-West · 2 February 1877 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

H. J. M. No. 1, was introduced by Rotwitt from committee on Indian Affairs.

WHEREAS, in the death of Colonel George A. Custer, who fell at the head of his column, the army of the United States lost one of its most valiant and dashing officers; and, whereas we have a due appreciation of the courage and valor displayed by the illustrious Colonel and his command while defending our borders against the incursions of remorseless savages; and, whereas, we cannot show our admiration for the gallant Colonel and command more appropriately than by identifying his name with the river on whose banks himself and command met their tragic fate, therefore be it

See moreSee less

Resolved, That, in commemoration of the dauntless courage, the disciplined valor and the heroic death of Col. George A. Custer and his men, of the Seventh Regiment of the United States Cavalry, who fell with him in the battle with the Sioux Indians on the Little Big Horn River, in the Territory of Montana, on the 25th day of June A. D. 1876, the name of said Little Big Horn shall be changed to Custer's River, and the same shall forever hereafter be known as Custer's River.

Read first and second times, and on motion of W. F. Sanders, the rules were suspended and the resolution read a third time and the clerk directed to call the roll and the members rise to their feet when voting. The resolution was then passed unanimously.

See the clipping

Red Horse and the white-footed horse

Red Horse, a Sioux sub-chief who surrendered at the Cheyenne agency, was gathering wild turnips when he saw the dust of the attack. He tells of an officer on a horse with four white feet, the bravest man the Indians ever met, said to have been killed by a Santee; of troopers who used very few of their cartridges; and of 136 Indians killed and 160 wounded. ‘I don’t like to talk about that fight,’ he says.

The Abbeville Press and Banner · Abbeville, S.C.

The Abbeville Press and Banner · 4 April 1877 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image

CUSTER'S BATTLE.

A Hostile Indian's Graphic Story of the Fight—What Red Horse Saw--Authentic Account of the Indian Losses.

See moreSee less

Lieutenant-General Sheridan has just received an important statement concerning the Custer massacre from Colonel Wood, commanding the Cheyenne agency post. It is no less than the story of Red Horse, a sub-chief of the Minneconjoux Sioux, who assisted at this memorable fight. The story comes from a source which the interpreter states may be depended upon as trustworthy. It appears that on the twenty-fifth of February 229 Sioux, belonging to the Minneconjoux, Sans Arcs and Two Kettles bands arrived at the Cheyenne agency from the main hostile camp on Tongue river and surrendered, giving up their arms and all their horses—some 300 in number. The principal men of this party were Red Horse, Spotted Elk and White Eagle. The former, upon coming in at the agency, told Colonel Wood that he and his people wanted to behave themselves in future, and then, upon close questioning, told what he knew of the battle wherein Custer's command was annihilated.

The following is his story of the battle of "Greasy Grass creek," Little Big Horn:

On Greasy Grass creek was the main camp of the hostiles. At that time I was one of the head councilmen in that camp. The Uncapapas, Yanktonnais and Santees were camped northeast of me, on the right, facing the battlefield.

The Minneconjoux, San Arcs, Two Kettles and Brules formed the center. On the left to the west were the Ogallallas and Cheyenne. On the morning of attack myself and several women were out about a mile from camp gathering wild turnips. Suddenly one of the women called my attention to a cloud of dust rising in the neighborhood of the camp. I soon discovered that troops were making an attack. We ran for the camp, and when I got there I was sent for at once to come to the council lodge. I found many of the councilmen already there when I arrived. We had no time to consult one another as to what action we should take. We gave directions immediately for every Indian to get his horse and arms; for women and children to mount their horses and get out of the way, and for young men to go and meet the troops. Among the latter was an officer who rode a horse with white feet.

The Indians have fought a great many tribes of people, and very brave ones, too, but they all say that this man was the bravest man they had ever met. I don't know whether this man was General Custer or not. Some say it was. I saw the man in the fight several times, but did not see his body. It is said he was killed by a Santee Indian, who still holds his horse. This officer wore a large brimmed hat and a buckskin coat. In speaking of him the Indians call him the man who rode the horse with four white feet. There were two men of his description, looking very much alike, both having long yellowish hair. [It is believed that General Custer's hair was cut comparatively short at the time of his death.]

Some time before this fight we were camped on the Rosebud; but we moved, crossed over and struck a tributary of Greasy Grass creek, following it down to its mouth. We then crossed Greasy Grass creek and went into camp on the west bank. An Indian started to go to Red Cloud agency that day, and when a few miles from camp he discovered dust rising. He turned back and reported that a large herd of buffalo was approaching camp.

The day was very warm, and a short time after he reported this the camp was attacked by troops who had followed our trail down the tributary and crossed Greasy Grass creek a little above where we did and above the mouth of this tributary. They attacked the upper end of the camp, where the Uncapapas were. The women and children fled immediately down Greasy Grass creek a little way and crossed over. The troops set fire to the lodges. All the warriors then rallied and attacked this command in an overwhelming force and drove them in confusion across the creek. They forced them over a place below where they first crossed. The creek was very high and swift and several of the troops were drowned.

After driving this party back the Indians corralled them on the top of a high hill and held them there until they saw that the women and children were in danger of being taken prisoners by another party of troops which just then made its appearance below. The word passed among the Indians like a whirlwind and they all started to attack this new party, leaving the troops on the hill. From this hill to the point where the troops were seen below it was open ground all the way with the exception of the small tributary I spoke of before.

As soon as we had finished this fight we all went back to massacre the troops on the hill. After skirmishing around awhile we saw the walking soldiers coming. These new troops making their appearance was the saving of the others.

The attack was made on the camp about noon. The troops, it appears, were divided, one party charging right into camp. We drove them across the creek. When we attacked the other party we swarmed down on them and drove them in confusion.

No prisoners were taken. All were killed. None were left alive, even for a few minutes. These troopers used very few of their cartridges. I took a gun and a couple of belts off two dead men. Out of one belt two cartridges were got; out of the other, five. It was with the captured ammunition and arms that we fought the other body of troops. If they had all remained together they would have hurt us very bad. The party we killed made five different stands. Once we charged right in until we scattered the whole of them, fighting among them hand to hand. One band of soldiers were right in the rear of us. When they charged we fell back and stood for one moment facing each other. Then the Indians got courage and started for them in a solid body. We went but a little distance when we spread out and encircled them. All the time I could see their officers riding in front and hear them, shouting to their men. It was in this charge that most of the Indians were killed.

We lost 136 killed and 160 wounded. We finished up this party right there in the ravine.

[General Sheridan is of opinion that "Red Horse" meant to say that 136 were killed and 160 were wounded during the entire engagement, and not in any one particular charge.]

The troops up the river made the first attack by skirmishing. A little while after the fight commenced with the other troops below the village. While the latter fight was going on we posted some Indians to prevent the other command from forming a junction. Some of the young men took the clothing off the dead and dressed themselves in it. There were several men among them who had citizen clothing. They then went up and attacked the other command in that way. Both banks of the river were very steep and difficult of ascent. Many of the troops were killed while crossing.

When they got on the hill they made some kind of fighting works and the fight was then carried on at a distance, the young men sometimes charging close up. The fight continued at long range until the walking soldiers came.

[This was the General Terry column, which arrived at a point near the battlefield on the night of the twenty-sixth of June.]

There are many little incidents connected with this fight, but I don't recollect them. I don't like to talk about that fight; if I hear any of my people talking about it I always move away.

See the clipping

Crazy Horse surrenders in silence

At Red Cloud Agency on 5 May, Crazy Horse comes in escorted by three hundred picked warriors, advances alone, sits down on the ground to wait for Lieut. W. P. Clark, and shakes his hand without a word. Red Cloud speaks for him: his people are not defeated, only surrendering as policy. Twenty-two hundred ponies come in but only 147 arms. Col. Mackenzie, chafing at the peaceable surrender of ‘Custer’s brutal butchers,’ would prescribe the guard house.

The Ouachita Telegraph · Monroe, La.

The Ouachita Telegraph · 1 June 1877 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

END OF THE SIOUX WAR. Ceremonies Attending the Surrender of Crazy Horse. [From the N. Y. Sun.] FORT LARAMIE, W. T., May 12.—Gen. Crook was not present at the surrender of Crazy Horse, which occurred at Red Cloud Agency on the 5th inst. He was represented by Lieut. W. P. Clark of the Second Cavalry, who has had charge of the Indians there and at Spotted Tail Agency during the past five months. He has managed the Sioux with the most consummate ability. Major Randall and Lieut. Bourke were also present to represent the Commanding General of the Department.

See moreSee less

The official ceremony of the surrender comprised a meeting between Lieut. Clark and the redoubtable chief himself. Crazy Horse was escorted by three hundred picked warriors, whose gaudy trappings and soldierly appearance recalled the splendid retinue of the old Barons of feudal times. Fully two hundred additional braves remained mounted and observant upon the neighboring bluffs. Immediately accompanying Crazy Horse were the chiefs Little Wolf, He Bear, and Little Big Man—his staff, so to speak. Indeed, no others among his adherents are permitted to familiarly address him or approach his person, and in this respect he is different from any Indian chief I have ever seen. He holds himself aloof from the common herd, and though greatly feared, is correspondingly respected. He is probably the ablest of their chiefs, not excepting Spotted Tail. Tall and about thirty-eight years of age he is not unlike other fine-looking and intelligent Sioux, though bearing himself with greater dignity than any of them. His eyes are exceedingly restless and impress the beholder fully as much as does his general demeanor. A bullet wound through his left cheek, obtained, it is said, in a personal feud which first gave him notoriety, disfigures his face and gives to the mouth a drawn and somewhat fierce or brutal expression. Crazy Horse advanced entirely alone to meet Lieut. Clark and after proceeding several rods, sat down upon the ground and awaited the coming of that young officer, who immediately followed his example. Crazy Horse then arose, and moving slowly over the distance which separated them, shook hands but said nothing. Subsequently a council was held, in which Red Cloud was chief spokesman for Crazy Horse, who continued to maintain his singular silence. The former stated for him that neither Crazy Horsy nor his warriors were defeated or cowed into submission, but that he deemed it best as a matter of policy to surrender, and that they acquiesed in this as they would have in any decision he made. From 1,000 to 1,500 bucks, squaws, and pahpoosses surrendered, 500 of which were warriors. Twenty-two hundred ponies, in fine order, were turned in, but only 147 arms were received, most of which were, however, first-rate sporting rifles or else Springfield carbines, caliber 45, the same as now issued to the United States troops. Beyond a doubt the remainder of their arms were chached in some secure retreat, where they can be readily obtained in an emergency. Crazy Horse had not been to an agency on foot for twelve years, his last visit to any settlement having been made to this post. His proud and almost contemptuous behavior chafes the impatient Col. Mackenzie, who ill brooks the peaceable surrender of Custer's brutal butchers. He thinks that Crazy Horse would be benefited by a dose of the Camp Robison guard house, and the exercise afforded by attending upon the post water wagon--and so expressed himself. The Indian villages, and particularly those of the Arrapahoes and Cheyennes, that were in the vicinity of Crazy Horse's camp, have marched further away through positive fear of that wily and moody chief. The Cheyennes, indeed, have borne the brunt of the war, and were in a perfectly destitute condition when they arrived at the agency. They say they have had enough fighting for the rest of their lives.

See the clipping

Rough boxes and ox carts

A Herald editorial says the removal of the remains from the Little Big Horn had no special solemnities but was not done without reverence, and none too soon: in a few years more no one could have said where they lay. The relics went into rough boxes for ox carts, Custer’s likely bound for West Point and the other officers’ for Fort Leavenworth. The men still on the field, it says, are not forgotten.

The New York Herald · New York, N.Y.

The New York Herald · 15 July 1877 · page 8 · transcribed from the page image

The Remains of Custer and his Comrades. The removal of the remains of Custer and his comrades, as described by our correspondent who accompanied the expedition to Little Big Horn Creek, was not attended by any special solemnities. There was the lonely mountain pass where the massacre took place in all unchanged, except that instead of the yells of the savages, the echo of the deadly rifles from the heights and the shouts of defiance, there were only a few cavalrymen searching for the bodies of our heroes. It was a simple and almost a rude duty, but one not performed, we think, without reverence.

See moreSee less

The facts given by our correspondent show that the removal of the remains was not begun too soon. In a few years more they would have been beyond identification, and those who honor bravery and devotion could only have pointed to the fatal valley and have said, "Here somewhere they lie, but in what spot no one knows." The work of destruction had begun already when Colonel Sheridan and his command reached the Little Big Horn. Some of the bones lay bleaching upon the surface of the ground, and several graves had been molested by the wolves. These relics were carefully gathered and placed in rough boxes to be conveyed in ox carts to their destination. The remains of Custer will be, no doubt, interred at West Point, which he often desired should be chosen as his last resting place, while those of the other officers, it is thought, will be buried in the soldiers' cemetery at Fort Leavenworth. But others still remain on the battle field. Although they have not received the tribute paid to the leaders of the ill-fated expedition they are not forgotten by the country, and their memories will have due honors in fitting time.

See the clipping

Crazy Horse is dead

A Washington paper reports that Crazy Horse, ‘the fighting chief’ of Sitting Bull’s band at the Custer battle, will not be coming east with the Sioux delegation. Being disarmed at Camp Robinson, he drew a knife, cut Little Big Man, and was stabbed in the side; by whom, the telegram does not say. He was twenty-six.

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 6 days later.

Wrong

Evening Star · 7 September 1877 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

It is now safe to say that Crazy Horse will not come to Washington this month with the Sioux delegation. His spirit has been wafted to the happy hunting grounds or to some other indefinite locality, and the places which knew him will know him no more forever. The telegraph has thus far failed to place us in possession of the exact circumstances of his death, but the natural inference would be that he was killed by a Sioux Chief named Little Big Man, since a dispatch says that while being disarmed at Camp Robinson he drew a knife and cut Little Big Man severely in the arm, whereupon he was fatally stabbed in the side, but by whom the telegram fails to state.

See moreSee less

The defunct redskin, although a young man of but twenty-six years of age, distinguished himself as "the fighting chief" of Sitting Bull's band, and in that capacity served at the Custer massacre. A few months later he came into the agency with a portion of the hostile band. They were all disarmed and dispossessed of their ponies, and since that time Crazy Horse has been chafing under his helpless condition, and lately made a break for liberty, which ended in his death.

See the clipping

Custer buried at West Point

The remains are brought from Poughkeepsie on the steamer Mary Powell for a funeral at West Point, a brief Episcopal service with responses sung by cadets. Custer’s hat and sword lie on the flag-covered coffin; his widow and his father attend. A horse with a vacant saddle follows the caisson to a grave ‘not far from Gen. Scott’s sepulchre.’

The Weston Democrat · Weston, W. Va.

The Weston Democrat · 20 October 1877 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

Burial of General Custer.

WEST POINT, N. Y., October 10.—The funeral of General Custer to day was attended by a large concourse of people. The remains were conveyed here this morning from Poughkeepsie on the Steamer Mary Powell and deposited in the chapel where they were left under guard. Services at the chapel commenced at 1:15, and were conducted by Rev. John Forsyth, D. D., post chaplain, consisting only of reading of a portion of the Episcopal burial service, with responses sung by a choir of cadets. The coffin was covered by the national flag, crape and a profusion of choice floral decorations. Custer's hat and sword were also placed on it. General Custer's widow was also present at the services, attended by Major General Schofield; also E. H. Custer, father of the hero of the Little Big Horn; Mrs. Nettie B. Smith, sister, and Mrs. Lawrence Barrett. Mrs. Gen. Alfred Gibbs and Miss Cora Bean, friends. Lieut. Braden, of the Seventh Cavalry, who fought under Custer, and has been several times wounded, was also in attendance. At the conclusion of the brief services at chapel the line was formed, and the procession set out for the cemetery in the following order: Major General Thos. H. Neil with escort, consisting of detachment of cavalry, commanded by Col. Beaumont; cadet battalion of artillery, Col. Piper; West Point Band and cadet battalion of infantry, with arms reversed and colors draped; a carriage with clergymen; caisson bearing the body; horse with vacant saddle and covered by a blanket; Brevet Major Gen. J. B. Fry; Brevet Major Gen. R. B. Marcy; Brevet Brig. Gen. J. B. Kiddoo; Gen. T. C. Devins; Adjutant Gen. Forsyth; Col. Stephen C. Lyford; Col. Ludlow and Col. Mitchel; pall bearers; carriages containing mourners and friends; officers of the Military Academy; naval and army officers; Loyal Legion; the veteran organization of New York, commanded by Gen. Geo. H. Sharpe; volunteer and milita officers; detachment Twenty-first Regiment and Bald Eagle battery of Poughkeepsie; delegation of the Society of the first Connecticut Volunteers and citizens.

See moreSee less

The procession moved slowly to the cemetery, the band playing a funeral march. At the grave the balance of the burial service was read and the infantry salute fired, three rounds. The grave is near the cemetery entrance, to the left gate, not far from Gen. Scott's sepulchre. The ceremonies concluded and procession was dismissed at 4 P. M.

See the clipping

Sitting Bull: Custer ‘stood like a sheaf of corn’

Sitting Bull tells a correspondent that Custer’s men rode up on tired horses and ‘swayed to and fro’ yet fought at once, falling back across gullies to make fresh stands. Custer, he says, killed a man as he fell and laughed; he rose on his hands to fire again, but his pistol would not go off. Only squaws, old men and children held Reno on the bluff.

The True Northerner · Paw Paw, Mich. · and 4 other papers

The True Northerner · 23 November 1877 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

THE CUSTER MASSACRE.

Graphic Account of the Fight as Told by Sitting Bull—How the Brave Custer Met His Death.

See moreSee less

Sitting Bull has been talking with a correspondent and telling the story of the Custer massacre. He says: "The fight was hell. A thousand devils—the squaws—were like flying birds; the bullets like humming-bees. We thought we were whipped; not at first, but by and by. Afterward no. Your people were killed. I tell no lies about dead men. These men who came with the Long Hair (Custer) were as good men as ever fought. When they rode up their horses were tired and they were tired. When they got off their horses they could not stand firmly on their feet. They swayed to and fro, so my young men have told me, like limbs of cypresses in a great wind. Some of them staggered under the weight of their guns, but they began to fight at once. But by this time our camps were aroused, and there were plenty of warriors to meet them. They fired with needle guns. We replied with magazine guns—repeating rifles." Sitting Bull illustrated by patting his palms together with the rapidity of a fusilade. "Our young men rained lead across the river and drove the white braves back, and then rushed across themselves, and then they found that they had a good deal to do. The trouble was with the soldiers. They were so exhausted, and their horses bothered them so much, they could not take good aim. Some of their horses broke away from them, and left them to stand, and drop and die. All the men fell back, fighting and dropping. They could not fire fast enough, though. They kept in pretty good order. They would fall back across a gully and make a fresh stand beyond, on higher ground. There were a great many brave men in that fight, and from time to time, while it was going on, they were shot down like pigs. They could not help themselves. One of the officers fell where the last fight took place, where the last stand was made. The Long Hair stood like a sheaf of corn with all the ears fallen around him."

"Not wounded?"

"No."

"How many stood by him?"

"A few."

"When did he fall?"

"He killed a man when he fell. He laughed."

"You mean he cried out?"

"No; he laughed. He had fired his last shot."

"From a carbine?"

"No; a pistol."

"Did he stand up after he first fell?"

"He rose up on his hands and tried another shot, but his pistol would not go off."

"Was any one else standing up when he fell down?"

"One man was kneeling—that was all; but he died before the Long Hair."

Sitting Bull says there were only squaws, old men, and little children in front of Reno, keeping him in his strong position on the bluff and preventing him giving aid to Custer.

See the clipping

← Back to Act Four: The Only Survivor