As the Papers Told It

Little Bighorn · As the Papers Told It

Act Three

The Dead

10–19 July 1876

The steamer Far West had carried the wounded down the rivers to Bismarck, and at Fort Lincoln the regiment’s wives learned who was dead. The Herald mourned its correspondent, Mark Kellogg. Flags raised for the Centennial came down to half-mast; a Kentucky man offered the President a regiment of ex-Confederates to avenge Custer; the House voted his widow a pension. From Sioux City came a story that Rain-in-the-Face had cut out Custer’s heart, and from Terry a confidential report, now in print, of the orders Custer had been given.

Kellogg, on a mule, half a mile behind

A Bismarck sketch of Mark Kellogg, the only professional correspondent with the troops: he once started a daily paper at Council Bluffs, worked as a railroad train despatcher, and drew for Harper’s Weekly. His horse having failed, he rode a mule, and fell half a mile behind Custer’s column, shot in the side. His body was plundered but not mutilated, perhaps, the writer suggests, because the Indians knew the Herald had exposed the agents’ frauds.

The New York Herald · New York, N.Y.

The New York Herald · 10 July 1876 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

OUR DEAD CORRESPONDENT.

SHORT SKETCH OF HIS LIFE BY ONE WHO KNEW HIM WELL—A CLEVER JOURNALIST AND A BRAVE MAN.

See moreSee less

BISMARCK, D. T., July 9, 1876.

Mr. Mark Kellogg, the HERALD correspondent who fell in the famous cavalry charge of Custer, was the only professional newspaper correspondent accompanying the troops engaged on the Big Horn. Kellogg gained a fine reputation for skill in his profession and was remarkable for courage and steadfastness. At one time he started a daily paper at Council Bluffs, Iowa, but this not proving remunerative he went to Minnesota, and finally to the North Pacific region, where, under J. Gregory Smith's administration, he was train despatcher on the North Pacific Railroad. He was one of the finest reporters in the land, and was among the first, if not the very first, sound telegraph operators in the country. For three years past he has been an occasional writer for the HERALD and other papers. He was also a capital sketcher, and furnished Harper's Weekly with some fine drawings illustrating Terry's march to Powder River from here. He sent the HERALD a connected description of the campaign under Terry up to that point, and had prepared a map in addition, which only waited the finishing touches to be put on by the result of Custer's twelve days' scout. In his last letter to your Bismarck correspondent he details so carefully the plan of the campaign, and alludes so understandingly to the conduct of Reno, who, on a former scout, so far exceeded his instructions as to seriously interfere with Terry's plan of campaign, that the conclusion was irresistible that in sending Kellogg your Bismarck correspondent had not made a mistake. Colonel Smith, aid-de-camp to General Terry, informs me that Kellogg was

ONE AMONG A THOUSAND.

He was ever on the alert, ever courteous, and took in the situation at a glance. Colonel Smith says General Terry afforded him every opportunity to gain information, as did all the other officers. He had the full run of headquarters, and the letter book of the commanders was open to him at all times, as they had full confidence in his discretion, and wished him to write understandingly. He was a favorite with General Custer, and always followed the Seventh cavalry in their operations. There was a great scarcity of horses and transportation, and General Terry could grant him no favors except transportation for his lead pencils, clothing, &c.; but as the horse he was outfitted with at Bismarck had failed he was mounted on a mule, as stated in your correspondence from the field of battle. Being poorly mounted, it is possible he fell behind, and did not go with Custer into the trap the Indians had prepared for him. He was shot in the side as if by an Indian in ambush, and fell about half a mile in the rear of Custer's column. Colonel Smith informs me that the battle field was searched by several officers, from one end to the other, to find the remains of poor Kellogg, till at last they were discovered by General Gibbon.

THE BODY

was plundered, but not stripped or in anywise mutilated. Now the HERALD is known to the dusky natives as a newspaper that has denounced and exposed the frauds perpetrated on them by thieving agents and dishonest traders, and, as his wrappings indicated his profession, it is possible, and, indeed, probable, that to this fact may be attributed his escape from mutilation or other indignity. Men always have friends; Kellogg had, and one who had a kind and full appreciation of the situation took up the work where Kellogg left it. As a result the HERALD had a full and comprehensive report of the disaster and the operations immediately preceding it, a report much fuller and more comprehensive than could have been obtained by any other newspaper. The report was delayed by the constant use of the single wire between Bismarck and St. Paul for official correspondence between General Terry's aid-de-camp and the District and Department headquarters.

MR. KELLOGG'S FAMILY.

Kellogg has a brother in Chicago, and has two daughters just budding into womanhood at Northfield College. His wife died some years ago, an event which cast a melancholy shadow over his life, and resulted in change of location and business. In conclusion, he was a man to whom was due the respect of all who knew him. The newspaper fraternity loses one of its most worthy members and the HERALD one of its most valuable correspondents.

See the clipping

Custer declined the Gatling guns

Terry’s confidential dispatch to Sheridan, now given to the press, says Custer chose ‘his own regiment alone’ over Gibbon’s cavalry and declined the battery of Gatling guns, being ‘strong enough without it.’ Thinking the Indians were running, he attacked without getting all his men up, before Gibbon’s column, due at the mouth of the Little Big Horn on the 26th, could join him. Had he waited, Terry writes, ‘I cannot doubt but we should have been successful.’

River Falls Journal · River Falls, Wis. · and 1 other paper

River Falls Journal · 13 July 1876 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

CUSTER'S DISASTER.

An Explanation by General Terry and a Word From Sheridan.

See moreSee less

General Terry from his camp on the Yellow Stone sent a confidential dispatch to General Sheridan, which the latter has given to the press to throw some light on the lamentable masacre of Custer and his gallant troops. He says, "While at the mouth of the Rosebud I submitted my plan to Gen. Gibbon and Gen. Custer, and they approved it heartily. It was that Custer with his whole regiment should move up the Rosebud till he should meet a trail which Reno had discovered a few days before, but that he should not follow it directly to the mouth of the Little Big Horn, but that he should send scouts over it and keep his main force further to the south, so as to keep the Indian's from slipping in between himself and the mountains. He was also to examine the headwaters of Tulloch's Creek as he passed it, and send me word of what he found there.

"We calculated it would take Gibbons' column until the 26th to reach the mouth of the Little Big Horn, and that the wide sweep which I had proposed Custer should make would require so much time that Gibbons would be able to co-operate with him in attacking any Indians that might be found on the stream.

"I asked Custer how long his marches would be. He said they would be at first about thirty miles a day. Measurements were made and calculations based on that rate of progress. I talked with him about his strength and at one time suggested that perhaps it would be better for me to take Gibbons' cavalry and go with him.

"To this suggestion, he replied that he would prefer his own regiment alone. As much could be done with it as with the two combined. He epxressed the utmost confidence that he had all the force that he could need and I shared his confidence. The plan adopted was the only one which promised to bring the infantry into action and I desired to make a sure thing of getting up ever available man. I offered Custer the battery of Gatling guns, but he declined, saying that it might embarrass him and that he was strong enough without it.

"The movements proposed by Gen. Gibbon's column was carried out to the letter, and had the attack been deferred till it came up I cannot doubt but we should have been successful. The Indians had evidently nerved themselves for a stand.

"I learn from Capt. Benteen that on the 22d the cavalry marched 12 miles. On the 23rd, 35 miles from 5 A. M to 8 P. M. On the 24th, 45 miles, 10 miles further, then after resting, without unsaddling, 23 miles to the battle field.

"The proper route was not taken, but as soon as the trail was discovered it was followed. I cannot learn that any examination of Tulloch's creek was made.

"I do not tell you this to cast any reflection upon Custer for whatever errors he might have committed. He has paid the penalty, and you cannot regret his loss more than I do, but I feel that our plan must have been successful had it been carried out, and I desire you to know the facts in the action yourself.

"So far as I can make out, Custer acted under misapprehensions. He thought that the Indians were running, and for fear that they would get away, he attacked them without getting all his men up, and divided his command so that they were beaten in details.

"I do not at all propose to give the thing up here, but I think my troops require a little rest, and in view of the strength which the Indians have displayed I propose to bring up what little reinforcements I can get. I should be glad of any that you can send me. I can take two companies of infantry from Powder River, and there are a few recruits detailed whom I can get for the cavalry. I ought to have a larger mounted force than I now have, but this I fear cannot be obtained. I hear nothing from General Crook's operations. If I could hear, I should be able to form plans for the future much more intelligently."

WHAT SHERIDAN SAYS.

Gen. Sheridan, conversing with a reporter on the Custer massacre, said that the truth was the army was unable to carry out the purposes of the government in the Indian country by reason of its weakness. "I have," he said, "sent every man I could spare into that region, even taking troops from Laramie and Salt Lake. The government in its wisdom directs the doing of certain things in these regions. It directs an expedition like this of Terry's—an expedition necessary for the development of that country. We do the best we can with our material, but are in no condition to do the work required of us."

In answer to the question, what are the reasons for this campaign, Gen. Sheridan says: "We are doing this at the special request of the Indian Department. It does not originate with the War Department at all. Our purpose is to drive these Indians—who are of the very wildest and most savage sort known—on the reservations. You can say that we will do it now or exterminate them."

See the clipping

Sioux City’s story: Rain-in-the-Face and the heart

Indians arriving at Sioux City say Rain-in-the-Face shot Custer, cut out his heart and paraded it on a pole, the retreating bands halting to dance around ‘the heart of the great yellow-haired white chief.’ Military reports have said the body was not mutilated. The official casualty list accounts for only 260 of the 269 reported buried, with twenty-two men understood to be missing.

Worcester Daily Spy · Worcester, Mass.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

Worcester Daily Spy · 14 July 1876 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

The Indian Troubles.

The Reported Mutilation of Gen. Custer's Body.

See moreSee less

NEW YORK, July 13.—The Sioux City special which says it was Rain-in-the-Face who shot Custer and then cut his heart out, which he placed on a pole and paraded through the camp, also says that when the Indians broke camp and retreated from the scene of slaughter they were greatly demoralized, but occasionally halted and had a dance around the bloody trophy, which they designated as the heart of the great yellow-haired white chief. Previous reports received through military sources have stated that Custer's remains were not mutilated, but the Indians who bring this report to Sioux City say emphatically that the above is true, and great satisfaction is felt in the fact that Rain-in-the-Face has fulfilled his threat against the great white chief who once humiliated him.

THE LIST OF CASUALTIES.

The official list of killed and wounded has been received at Sheridan's headquarters. The absence of all company records, and the loss of seven first sergeants, render it almost impossible to account for all the men at the present time. Two hundred and sixty-nine bodies were heretofore reported buried. This report accounts for 260 only. It is understood, unofficially, that there are twenty-two men missing. Some were undoubtedly buried, but not recognized.

See the clipping

Centennial flags lowered to half-mast

A Portland paper notes that the national flags run up to the masthead for Centennial day were dropped to half-mast on Thursday, at the news of ‘the wholesale butchery of General Custer and his command.’ It closes with a line of verse: ‘So swift treads sorrow on the heels of joy.’

The New Northwest · Portland, Or.

The New Northwest · 14 July 1876 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

The national flags which were drawn proudly to the masthead in honor of Centennial day, were dropped to half-mast on Thursday, in consequence of the sad news of the wholesale butchery of General Custer and his command by the Sioux Indians. "So swift treads sorrow on the heels of joy."

See the clipping

Twenty-nine widows at Fort Lincoln

A Chicago dispatch counts twenty-nine widows at Fort Abe Lincoln, seven of them officers’ wives. Mrs. Custer ‘is left without a blood relation,’ and Mrs. Porter believes her husband was taken alive and tortured. Beside it the paper prints an old portrait of Custer: golden locks, crimson cravat, ‘a wild dare-devil of a General.’

Burlington Weekly Free Press · Burlington, Vt.

Burlington Weekly Free Press · 14 July 1876 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

A Sad Sequal to the Indian Massacre. —A Chicago despatch says there are at Fort Abe Lincoln twenty-nine widows, made by the massacre of Custer and his regiment, seven of them officers' wives. Mrs. Custer is left without a blood relation. Mrs. Calhoun is very low from nervous exhaustion. Mrs. Custer bore up bravely at first, but now is almost in despair. Mrs. Porter refuses to see any one. She believes her husband fell alive into the hands of the Indians, and was tortured to death.

Col. Newhall, who wrote "With Sheridan in Lee's Last Campaign," thus describes Custer: "Custer of the golden locks, his broad sombrero turned up from his hard-bronzed face, the ends of his crimson cravat floating over his shoulders, gold galore spangling his jacket sleeves, a pistol in his boot, jangling spurs on his heels, and a ponderous claymore swinging at his side, a wild dare-devil of a General, and a prince of advance guards, quick to see and act."

See the clipping

Lieutenant Carland: seventeen shells by Custer’s side

Lieut. John Carland of the 6th Infantry writes that Custer charged into the centre of between 3000 and 4000 Sioux and fell almost first, though seventeen cartridge shells lay by his side. Custer was not disfigured, but Tom Custer’s heart was taken out. The Sioux carried new blankets branded for the Indian Department, and Carland, ‘as an eye witness of the whole battle,’ blames no one.

Worcester Daily Spy · Worcester, Mass. · and 2 other papers

Worcester Daily Spy · 15 July 1876 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

The Indian Campaign.

Further Particulars of Custer's Last Fight.

See moreSee less

NEW YORK, July 14.—The following new account of Custer's fight is from Lieut. John Carland of Co. B, 6th Infantry: He says Custer arranged for Reno to attack the Indians in the rear, while Custer fought them in front. This would have worked all right, as Reno had got in their rear, but Custer saw what he supposed was the front of the camp and made a charge on them, the Indians giving way and letting him right in the gap. The brave man rode in with his 300 men and would have killed the whole 2000 Sioux, I believe, if there had been no enemy behind him; but instead of charging the front, he was right in the centre of between 3000 and 4000 Sioux. Those that were behind him kept concealed until he was right in their midst, and then when it was too late he made a bold dash, trying to cut through them, but the enemy were too many. He fell about the first one, and the horses became unmanageble and the poor soldiers were cut down in less time than it takes to tell it. The Sioux then turned with all their force upon Major Reno. He charged them with one company and returned with only eleven men. He then retreated a short distance, placing his men on a bluff as before stated. Out of a whole regiment only 328 men are left, and forty of them are badly wounded.

It makes one heartsick to look over the battle ground and see the poor fellows, some of them with their entrails cut out, others with their eyes dug out, and hearts laid across their face. They even stopped to cut their pockets to get their money and watches. Tne most fearful sight was Col. Cook. He was a splendid looking man, with long, dark whiskers. They dug his face all out so as to get his fine beard, it is supposed. They did not disfigure Gen. Custer in any way, but his brother, Tom Custer, was opened and his heart taken out.

It is estimated that the loss of the enemy is five hundred, though it is hard to tell how many were killed, as they carried most of them away. Some of ours claim that Sitting Bull was killed, as he is known by some, and an Indian answering his description was found dead, but no doubt this is false, as they would have tried to carry him along.

Gen. Terry and the remaining officers are feeling very badly. I was standing by Gen. Custer when Gen. Terry came up, and as he looked down upon the noble general the tears coursed down his face as he said, "The flower of the army is gone at last." Custer was supposed to be the first one who died, but though he fell first we found seventeen cartridge shells by his side, where he had kept them off until the last moment. There can no blame be attached to any one for this fearful slaughter. If Custer had had the whole regiment it would only have been more, as the Sioux were too many. Of course there will be some one blamed by the eastern papers, but as an eye witness of the whole battle I cannot censure any one. There is one poor Crow Indian on the boat who has five shots through him, yet he is happy because he has nine scalps by his side. This is a true statement of Gen. Custer's brave charge. These Sioux were all from some agency, as we found camp equipments that had never been used, also blankets that were new and branded "U. S. Indian Department."

See the clipping

A Fort Stevenson letter: Reno’s siege, Lincoln’s widows

From Fort Stevenson the Tribune’s correspondent tells how Custer, sure his regiment could whip every Indian on the plains, set out alone, and how Reno’s men held a hilltop for sixty hours while half-breeds jeered at them in English. Custer was found ‘his head on his hand,’ his hair untouched. At Fort Lincoln Mrs. Calhoun has lost a husband, three brothers and a nephew.

Chicago Daily Tribune · Chicago, Ill.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

Chicago Daily Tribune · 16 July 1876 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

BISMARCK.

RENO AND CUSTER. Special Correspondence of The Tribune.

FORT STEVENSON, July 7.—Gen. Terry's little army, by the 20th of June, found itself nearing the Indians, who were supposed to be in force on the Rosebud, near the mouth of the Little Horn. Scouting parties of the Seventh Cavalry, under Maj. Reno, had discovered fresh trails of unusual extent; and it was deemed advisable by Gen. Terry that they should be followed. The entire regiment was, therefore, detailed on this service, and Custer placed in command—his written instructions being of the most liberal character. It was doubtless Terry's idea to make a combined attack on the camp of the Indians about the 27th; but he did not calculate that Custer could or would move with the celerity that he did. On the 22d he started, rejecting the offer of a support of cavalry from Gibbon's force; he had so much faith in his gallant Seventh that he told Gen. Terry that, with such a regiment, he could

See moreSee less

WHIP ALL THE INDIANS ON THE PLAINS;

and no doubt the superior officer, knowing the experience of the subordinate, gave credence to the unfortunate confidence, and so permitted Custer to start alone. He was ordered, when he found the camp of the Indians, to report by courier to Terry, who expected by the 26th to be at the mouth of the Little Horn. On went Custer, elated as a schoolboy on a holiday,—dressed in a suit of buckskin, and bestriding a gallant horse, whose mettle was fit to match with that of his rider. We can imagine the thought, if not the shout, that animated himself and his men:

If you want to see the fun, Jine the cavalry.

As I have said, Custer left on the 22d. He traveled rapidly. On the afternoon of the 24th, his scouts reported a village recently deserted, when a halt was made. At 11 p. m. the march was resumed, and continued until daylight of the 25th, when the command was 15 miles from the main village, located on the Little Horn. After a lunch, "Boots and Saddles" was again sounded, and soon the Indians were discovered. Their movements throughout appear to have been directed by a skill and judgment superior to the ordinary tactics of Indians, and have led many to suppose that

WHITE MEN OF EXPERIENCE

were with Sitting Bull, and lent him their assistance. Their first movements indicated a retreat. Seventy-eight miles had been accomplished by Custer up to this time, without sleep. Here there was a pause, and a plan of battle was arranged, as it became manifest that the Indians were in force.

The disposition of the forces was as follows: Custer determined to attack with five companies,—C, E, F, I, and L,—making a detour, intending to take the rear of the village. Reno, with three companies, was to attack in front; and Benteen, with four companies, was left in reserve. In accordance with the arrangements, Reno crossed the river, and, throwing out a strong skirmish-line, advanced. His three companies were, however, speedily overpowered by the thousands of redskins surrounding them, and

NOTHING WAS LEFT BUT RETREAT,

which was accomplished by the right flank,—the command recrossing the river a mile or so farther up than where it crossed to attack, and, gaining a position on the top of a high butte or hill, in which was a hollow suitable for protection. This was some 300 feet high.

Leaving Custer temporarily, I will confine myself to this party. Reno speedily found that, if not succored, not a man would escape; and, in response to his signals, Benteen came up with his four companies, making a slight detour, cut his way through, and formed a junction with Reno, and here they were in

A STATE OF SIEGE.

Thousands of screeching red devils surrounded them; the fierce June sun burned them up; water was in sight, but it was death to obtain it. The Indians, from another butte still higher than that occupied by Reno, commenced picking off the men; and it was soon discovered that the cavalry carbines could not, and did not, carry the distance that the Indians, with Winchester, Spencer, and needle-guns, could cover. So the hours passed until night. Stimulated by the groans of the dying and the sufferings of the living, several parties had volunteered to go to the river for water. But one man was successful; the remainder—and they were many—paid with their lives the penalty of their devotion. Now, however, under cover of night, the risk was not so great, and a sufficient supply of water was obtained. And so the brief hours of a calm summer-night wore away. Who shall tell of

THE TERRIBLE SUSPENSE

endured by officers and men? Where was Terry and Gibbons? Where Crook! Alas! they did not know that Crook had already suffered a check; but they did know that they had themselves outridden all hope of support from Terry or Gibbon for many hours. And what of their comrades under the gallant Custer? They knew what had become of them; and that, of the two parties, his had fared the worst. Day dawned, and with it came a repetition of all the horrors of the day previous. Ammunition became scarce, the heat was intense, and, to add to the chagrin of their position, half-breeds and others among the Indians jeered and gibed at them, calling out to them,

IN GOOD ENGLISH,

to come out and fight like men. So close did they come that they actually threw stones into the ranks of the soldiers. Officers fell fast. McIntosh and Hodgson, with Dr. DeWolf, fell at the ford when the retreat was made; and several of the best scouts had fought their last fight. Capt. Weir, with a band of brave volunteers, attempted a sally; but it was unsuccessful, and the retreat was made with great difficulty.

During the afternoon, the Indians received large reinforcements, which, of course, made them bolder. It was not until 10 o'clock that the fighting on this (the second) day closed. It would be simply a repetition to describe the morning of the third day. By noon, however, a movement was observed among the Indians, that speedily grew into a pronounced stampede, and ere long it was manifest that Terry, with reinforcements, was at hand. I will not attempt to describe the meeting. But one idea was manifest in the minds of all:

WHERE IS CUSTER?

None expected to see him again in life. All knew that, had he been alive, Reno would not have fought for sixty hours without hearing of or from him.

I must now return to where Custer left Reno. It will be a brief narrative, but a bloody one. Custer intended to have struck the end of the village; but it would appear that he attempted to cross the river about its centre, and failed. Finding the Indians too strong for him, he retreated, like Reno, to a butte; and here his body was found, surrounded by those of 150 of his men. They lay as they had fought, side by side. It seemed as though, being surrounded as they were, they had shot their horses, and made of the bodies of the animals a breastwork; for an irregular circle of dead horses were found, inside of which were the majority of the slain. But one man who was with the command is known to have escaped. This was a Crow scout, and he is wounded. Some of the bodies were frightfully mutilated,—too horrible, in fact, for description. This is attributed to the squaws. The General lay on his side; his head on his hand;

A SMILE ON HIS COUNTENANCE.

He was shot twice through the body, from side to side, and through the head. Singular to relate, his hair—of which he was so proud—was untouched, nor his body mutilated. Perhaps this was owing to his having no distinctive mark, not even a uniform. But his brother Tom was cut to pieces. Close by these two was the third brother, Boston, and Calhoun, a brother-in-law. The bodies of all were stripped. As soon as possible the dead were buried; the wounded of Reno's command removed to the River Yellowstone, and the rest of the troops, under Terry, moved to a base on that river, from which he can receive supplies and reinforcements.

THE RECEPTION OF THE NEWS AT BUFORD AND BISMARCK.

The news of this disaster was brought to Buford by the steamer Far West, of the Coulson Line. She had on board upwards of forty wounded men; and, as may be supposed, the grief and astonishment that ensued defy description. The steamer did not more than touch at Buford and Stevenson, and proceeded to Bismarck and Fort Lincoln, arriving at the former place at 11 p. m. of the 5th. The Town of Bismarck was speedily astir. It takes but the whistle of a steamboat to wake everybody up anyhow; and the news spread rapidly. Soon all the town was on the streets, and knots of men were discussing the situation until daylight. Such a disaster may bring on thoughts of perils to the little communities on this frontier; therefore it was with intense interest that the probabilities and possibilities were discussed. One sentiment prevailed over all others, however, and that was sympathy for

THE WIDOWED ONES AT LINCOLN.

Fort Lincoln—a post recently built—lies on the south bank of the Missouri, 4 miles below Bismarck, and has been made one of the most extensive and important in the department. This was the residence of Gen. Custer, and here were collected many of the wives, now widows, of the officers of his command. Here is Mrs. Calhoun, who loses a husband, three brothers, and a nephew. She was a Miss Custer. Like Queen Margaret of old, the griefs of all seem centered in her. Mrs. Custer, I understand, bears the loss with heroism; but, of course, the privileges of a correspondent could not, under the circumstances, be pressed so far as to seek any very definite information on such a subject. I visited the fort, but refrained from obtruding on such sorrow. The wounded are under the care of Dr. J. V. Middleton, who is doing all that experience can dictate for their comfort. As I left, a gentle shower was falling, and I thought that Nature was weeping. The grass was wet,

Dewy with Nature's tear-drops, Grieving, if aught inanimate e'er grieves, O'er the unreturning brave.

J. D. L.

See the clipping

An ex-Confederate offers a regiment

Representative Jones of Kentucky receives a letter from Wm. H. Rowan of Louisville offering the President, in this centennial year, ‘a full regiment, composed exclusively of ex-confederates’ to avenge Custer’s death. Rowan, once a soldier of the ‘Lost Cause,’ says he has crossed swords frequently with Custer’s command.

Worcester Daily Spy · Worcester, Mass.

Worcester Daily Spy · 17 July 1876 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

VOLUNTEERS FOR THE INDIAN WAR. Representative Jones of Kentucky has received the following letter, dated Louisville, July 9: Dear Sir: As this is the centennial year of American Independence, and I desire to let the world see that we, who were once soldiers of the "Lost Cause," are not deficient in patriotism, will you be kind enough to intimate to the president that I offer him the services of a full regiment, composed exclusively of ex-confederates, to avenge Custer's death? I have crossed swords frequently with his command in the past. You know me and know my ancestry, and this is the reason I apply to you for this favor. Believe me, very truly yours to command. (Signed) Wm. H. Rowan.

See the clipping

The House votes Mrs. Custer a pension

The House of Representatives votes on Saturday to pension Custer’s widow at $50 a month and to give $80 to his father and mother. A motion to make ‘the temporary generosity of the House’ available to the children of Custer’s soldiers provokes objection and fails.

Providence Morning Star · Providence, R.I.

Providence Morning Star · 18 July 1876 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

The House of Representatives decided, Saturday, to allow a pension of $50 a month to the widow of Gen. Custer and $80 to his father and mother. A motion to make the temporary generosity of the House available for pensions to the children of Custer's soldiers provoked objection and failed.

See the clipping

Terry’s plan, and a creek left unexamined

A connected account from the St. Paul Dispatch, with a map of the field. Terry gave Custer no precise orders, only his views: keep south toward the head of the Tongue before turning on the Little Big Horn, and examine Tullock’s creek, which it appears Custer passed without stopping. Expecting no more than fifteen hundred Indians, he met a village of 1,800 lodges by the count of Terry’s engineer, and ‘not less than two thousand and probably all of three thousand Sioux warriors’.

The Grange Advance · Red Wing, Minn. · and 2 other papers

The Grange Advance · 19 July 1876 · page 10 · transcribed from the page image

THE STORY TOLD.

A Connected Account of Custer's Disaster and Death.

See moreSee less

From the St. Paul Dispatch.

GEN. TERRY'S ORDERS.

From the information at hand it appears that on the 22d ult. Lt. Col. Custer started at noon from the mouth of the Rosebud river, a tributary of the Yellowstone, under orders from Gen. Terry, which required him to proceed up the Rosebud in pursuit of the Indians whose trail had been discovered a few days previous by Major Reno. Gen. Terry declined to give precise instructions for the movement, not wishing to hamper Custer's action when near the enemy and placing full confidence in his zeal, energy and ability. The General commanding (Terry) expressed, however his views of what Custer's action should be and desired him to conform to them unless he should see sufficient reason for departing from them. These were, that Custer should proceed up the Rosebud until he ascertained definitely the direction of the trail above spoken of. Should it be found, as appeared almost certain, to lead towards the Little Big Horn, the General thought Custer should still proceed southward as far, perhaps, as the headquarters of the Tongue river, which are directly southward, twenty-five miles, from the head of the Rosebud and about the same distance southeast from the locality on the Little Big Horn where Custer found and attacked the Indians. This route would have taken Custer (in a direct line) about one hundred miles southward from the mouth of the Rosebud. From the headwaters of the Tongue river the General advised that Custer should turn, westerly or northwesterly, towards the Little Big Horn, feeling constantly to his left so as to prevent the escape of the Indians to the south or southeast by passing around to Custer's left. Custer was informed by the General that the column of Col. Gibbon was then in motion and would move up the Big Horn to the parks at the mouth of the Little Big Horn, whence its movements would be controlled by circumstances. The hope was expressed that the Indians upon the Little Big Horn might be so nearly enclosed by the two columns that their escape would be impossible. Custer was desired, on his way up the Rosebud to thoroughly examine the upper part of Tullock's (Tinlock's) creek, (a stream rising on the divide between the Big Horn and Rosebud and emptying near the mouth of the Big Horn,) and to send a scout to Gibbon informing him of the result of this examination. Custer was further desired to report to Gen. Terry on the the supply steamer at the mouth of the Little Big Horn not later than the expiration of the time for which his command was rationed, or July 1st.

CUSTER'S FORCE.

The command consisted of the Seventh Cavalry, about seven hundred and twenty strong and a detachment of scouts and guides, increasing the whole number of fighting men to near eight hundred.

CUSTER'S MOVEMENTS.

About twenty miles up the Rosebud, at about nine o'clock on the morning of the 23d, Custer struck a large lodge-pole trail, about ten days old, the same which Reno had before discovered in the Tongue river valley. This lodge-pole trail indicated the recent movement of an Indian village. It led up the Rosebud and Custer's command camped on it at night, 47 miles up the Rosebud or about east from the sources of Tinlock's creek, which it appears he did not stop to examine.

ABANDONED INDIAN CAMP.

The morning of the 24th, after proceeding six miles farther, the scouts reported the trail growing fresher, some ten miles ahead, and there was a consultation by Custer with his officers. At four in the afternoon, having rode that day 45 miles and being now about ninety-two miles from the mouth of the Rosebud, and at the forks of that river, about thirty miles north from the sources of the Tongue river and about thirty miles eastward from the Little Big Horn, the command was rested on the site of an Indian village which had evidently been moved away but a few days before.

A NIGHT MARCH.

At eleven o'clock on the night of the 24th, the command was again mounted and moved, the scouts leading, up a creek emptying into the Rosebud. About daylight there was a halt for rest and coffee Soon after the scouts brought word that they had seen an Indian village from the top of the divide. The command was then moved up near to the head of the creek, about three miles from the top of the divide, and halted in a ravine. The distance of this night march from the abandoned Indian camp on the Rosebud is estimated at 23 miles.

DISCOVERED BY THE SIOUX.

Custer and a few soldiers and guides rode forward to the top of the divide to look at the Indian camp. He could not see it but the Indian scouts insisted that they could see it, some ten to fifteen miles off. Custer returned to the ravine in about an hour. Meantime he was seen by Sioux scouts and others had discovered his command in the ravine.

FORWARD.

Custer again assembled his officers and then the command was arranged in fighting order and the forward movement resumed, the scouts leading and the regiment following at a walk. Over the divide the trail led down a little creek, a branch of the Little Big Horn. About six miles from the ravine where the command was halted at daylight a freshly abandoned Sioux camp was discovered in which one lodge had been left to shelter a dead Indian. From this point a park or level prairie surrounded by hills was visible over the Little Big Horn, the site of

THE INDIAN RENDEZVOUS,

as outlined in our map. The river was about three miles away. About two miles beyond it heavy clouds of dust were rising. Some thought the Indians were decamping and it is probable Custer thought the same. The subsequent discovery of a large fresh trail leading into the Sioux camp from the southeast would indicate, however, that this cloud of dust may have been caused by the arrival of heavy reinforcements for the Sioux. It is, indeed, certain that all the Indian forces were united just before the battle, but the dust may have been caused by the Indians assembling for the coming fight.

RENO'S ADVANCE.

Custer sent forward to Major Reno, who was leading with companies A, G and M to push the scouts rapidly forward and to head for the cloud of dust. A steady gallop of near three miles brought Reno to the mouth of the little creek and a natural ford over the Little Big Horn. The scouts warned him that the Sioux were coming in force, but he crossed and formed his companies and moved forward on the prairie about a mile, where he dismounted his men, sent the horses into the timber on the right and advanced a short distance on foot.

AFTER SKIRMISHING

a few minutes, under heavy fire, Reno fell back to his horses in the timber and, the Indians beginning to collect in force between him and the river, remounted. Just then the Indians opened fire from close range in the timber, and one soldier fell. The men were again dismounted for skirmishing, but being thought unequal to the contest, were again mounted and moved from the timber over the open prairie toward the ford. The Indians pressed them fiercely and soon forced

THE RETREAT

into a run for the ford. The Sioux on their ponies dashed along, firing at close range and meeting little resistance. At the ford and on the run towards it the companies engaged suffered nearly all their loss. Lieutenant McIntosh, Charley Reynolds, a scout, Dr. DeWolf, Bloody Knife, a scout, and others, were killed before reaching the river. Lieut. Hodgson and many others were killed while fording the river. A number of men, either cut off from the retreat or preferring the shelter of the timber, remained in the timber and subsequently joined Reno in safety as described below. Reno's retreat ended at the top of a bluff on the right bank of the river about a mile from the ford, where he intrenched himself as well as he could, and was joined by Capt. Benteen with companies D, H and K and subsequently by Capt. McDougall with company B and a train of pack mules, These four companies were about two miles in the rear when Reno forded the river on his advance.

THE MEN LEFT BEHIND.

George Hernedon, a scout, tells that thirteen cavalrymen, three of whom were wounded, (two so badly they could not use their arms,) remained with him in the timber where Reno placed his horses when he advanced his skirmish line into the Indian village. They remained there about three hours and meantime saw that nearly all the Indians went from the upper end of the valley down the river, and from there they heard heavy firing which lasted about one hour and then began to die away. Then Hernedon persuaded eleven of the soldiers to go with him and escape. They met on their way to the ford five Indians who were driven off by pistol shots and the twelve (including the three wounded soldiers above mentioned) waded the river and proceeded to Reno's position without opposition.

RENO ATTACKED.

Indian skirmishers had meantime surrounded Reno's position and kept up a scattering fire from commanding positions, but inflicted little if any loss. The wounded had been placed in the center, and the dead horses and mules were piled in front of such rifle pits as the men could dig. Soon after the firing below ceased, the Indians came up the river in great force, and Reno's skirmishers retired to his entrenched position, which he strengthened during the succeeding night. The evening attack lasted about an hour and covered the Indian chiefs getting their warriors in position.

Early next morning the Sioux renewed the attack and several times charged close up. These attacks ended about ten o'clock with a sortie led by Benteen, which dispersed a large body gathered in front for another charge. Desultory firing was kept up, however, all day, and one notable event was the procuring of water from the river at the foot of the bluff, by a volunteer detachment of soldiers, one of whom was killed and several wounded in this service. At the time, the suffering for want of water, especially among the wounded, had become terrible.

THE INDIANS WITHDRAW.

During the afternoon the Indians began to withdraw, and near dark the firing ceased altogether. In the morning not an Indian was to be seen, and about ten o'clock runners sent out by Reno brought intelligence of the approach of Gen. Terry with Gibbon's cavalry, the infantry and the Gatling guns.

CUSTER'S FATE.

So far as known not one except a Crow scout whose knowledge is extremely limited, is left alive to tell the story of Custer's movements and the loss of all his command. From such traces as are left he appears to have moved with companies C, E, F, I and L on the right side of the bluffs on the right bank of the river something over two miles and there to have met the Indians in force near the river, where he perhaps attempted to cross. Here, either then, or later in the action, Captain Smith's company fell. Among the bluffs there were numerous evidences of a desperate defense against overwhelming numbers and indications of repeated defeats of attempts to reach the river or to break through the encircling savages. A mile below the remains of Smith's company were found the bodies of a number of men and horses, indicating an attempt to cross the river at that point. Three-quarters of a mile back were found the remains of Custer and the last of his gallant comrades. On the lines of advance and retreat indicated on the map were found the dead singly as if they had fallen during flight or attack, and also lines of soldiers and horses where unavailing stands had been made. One company after another was annihilated. The Indians were ten to one and the fight was at last at close quarters, when there was nothing left for the survivors but to sell their lives as dearly as possible.

All accounts are agreed that Custer's fight lasted about an hour, during which the firing was very heavy. It began about the time that Reno was reforming his routed troops and providing for his wounded after his retreat to the bluffs where Benteen joined him, and while it lasted the main body of the Indians went down the river and engaged in it, returning afterwards to renew the attack upon Reno.

What reason Custer had for dividing his force and why he attacked at all may be explained by Reno and Benteen, but does not appear in any of the reports yet published. We can only presume that, having followed a fresh trail, indicating a movement of the Indians in retreat and, not being well informed by his scouts of the actual position, he imagined that the Indians in the Little Big Horn valley were breaking up their village and were likely to get away from him in the very direction he had been cautioned by Gen. Terry against permitting their flight. This thought that the Indians were retreating explains his closely following their trail and his rapid march; and the fact that the Indian force he had followed was estimated by Reno, Gen. Terry and himself at not over fifteen hundred, all told, accounts for the confidence with which he sent Reno forward to the attack with less than two hundred men while he proceeded to make a flank attack with less than three hundred men. Instead of fifteen hundred men, women and children, he had to meet alone not less than two thousand and probably all of three thousand Sioux warriors. He was overwhelmed by numbers far beyond the anticipations of himself and Gen. Terry. Reno and Benteen estimated the Indian force which they engaged at 2,500. The number of lodges which were in the village is estimated by Gen. Terry's engineer at 1,800. This would indicate a total population of 8,000, while it is known there were comparatively few women and children, so that the whole fighting force of the Sioux could not have been less than 5,000 and may have been a thousand more.

[Map: CUSTER'S LAST BATTLE FIELD. Labeled features: Custer Fell and 5 Companies; Smith's Co. Killed; Benteen's March; Reno's Intrenchment; Reno's Crossing; Skirmishers; Little Big Horn R.; Indian Village, 1800 Lodges; Scale 1 in. to mile; T. Robinson Co., St. Paul, Minn.]

CUSTER'S LAST BATTLE FIELD.

See the clipping

← Back to Act Two: Custer Killed