As the Papers Told It

Little Bighorn · As the Papers Told It

Act Four

The Only Survivor

August – October 1876

The regiment’s surviving soldiers asked that Reno and Benteen be promoted for saving them, and Reno’s official report was printed in full. The Crow scout Curly, ‘believed to be the only survivor,’ told how Custer fought and how he got away. Within weeks the papers had it ‘proved beyond dispute’ that Custer was neither scalped nor mutilated. In September President Grant called the battle a sacrifice of troops ‘brought on by Custer himself,’ and in October Buffalo Bill blamed Reno.

230 survivors ask promotion for Reno

General Sheridan has received a letter to the President and Congress signed by all 230 surviving non-commissioned officers and privates of the Seventh, asking that Reno, Benteen and others fill the regiment’s vacancies. Had the two taken position a hundred yards back from the brink, they say, the men would have been cut off from water and shot down. The Gazette doubts it will happen: promotions go by seniority in the whole branch of the service.

The Daily Gazette · Wilmington, Del.

The Daily Gazette · 1 August 1876 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

Reno's Soldiers Speak.

THE MEN HE SAVED ASK HIS PROMOTION.

See moreSee less

General Sheridan has received a letter addressed to the President and Congress, signed by all the 230 non-commissioned officers and privates of the Seventh Cavalry who survived the Custer massacre, earnestly requesting that the vacancies in the Regiment be filled by the promotion of Major Reno, Captain Benteen and other officers of the regiment, according to seniority, for their services in saving the remainder of the regiment from massacre. They state that although such promotion is against the rule, it would be deserved, for if Reno and Benteen had taken position one hundred yards back from the brink of the heights overlooking the river, the troops would have been cut off from water, entirely surrounded and shot down in detail from behind the heights, and not one would have escaped.

It is not likely that the request will be complied with. The promotions are always from the senior officers in the particular branch of the services to which a regiment belongs, and not from any particular regiment.

See the clipping

Reno’s report: ‘the whole outfit would support me’

The Sun reprints Major Reno’s official report. Ordered to charge with word ‘that the whole outfit would support me,’ he found that ‘the very earth seemed to grow Indians,’ at least 2,500 of them, and held the bluffs until Terry came. He blames Custer’s rapid marching, his daytime attack and his ‘unfortunate division of the regiment into three commands,’ and singles out Benteen.

The Sun · New York, N.Y.

The Sun · 5 August 1876 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image

GEN. CUSTER'S LAST FIGHT.

COL. RENO'S REPORT OF THE LITTLE BIG HORN BATTLE.

See moreSee less

How the Seventh Cavalry were Drawn into a Trap—Reno's Fight with the Indians—Custer's Mistake in Dividing his Forces.

From the Army and Navy Journal.

HEADQUARTERS, SEVENTH REG'T CAVALRY, CAMP ON YELLOWSTONE RIVER, July 5, 1876.

Capt. E. W. Smith, A. D. C. and A. A. A. G.

The command of the regiment having devolved upon me, as the senior surviving officer from the battle of June 25 and 26, between the Seventh Cavalry and Sitting Bull's band of hostile Sioux, on the Little Big Horn river, I have the honor to submit the following report of its operations from the time of leaving the main column until the command was united in the vicinity of the Indian village.

The regiment left the camp at the mouth of Rosebud river, after passing in review before the Department Commander, under the command of Brevet Major Gen. G. A. Custer, Lieutenant Colonel, on the afternoon of the 22d of June, and marched up the Rosebud twelve miles and encamped. 23d—Marched up the Rosebud, passing many old Indian camps, and following a very large lodge pole trail, but not fresh, making thirty-three miles. 24th—The march was continued up the Rosebud, the trail and signs freshening with every mile until we had made twenty-eight miles, and we then encamped and waited for information from the scouts. At 9:25 P. M., Custer called the officers together and informed us that beyond a doubt the village was in the valley of the Little Big Horn, and that to reach it it was necessary to cross the divide between Rosebud and Little Big Horn, and it would be impossible to do so in the day time without discovering our march to the Indians; that we would prepare to move at 11 P. M. This was done, the line of march turning from the Rosebud to the right, up one of its branches, which headed near the summit of the divide.

About 2 A. M. of the 25th, the scouts told him that he could not cross the divide before daylight. We then made coffee and rested for three hours, at the expiration of which time the march was resumed, the divide crossed, and about 8 A. M. the command was in the valley of one of the branches of the Little Big Horn. By this time Indians had been seen, and it was certain that we could not surprise them, and it was determined to move at once to the attack.

Previous to this no division of the regiment had been made since the order was issued, on the Yellowstone, annulling wing and battalion organizations. Gen. Custer informed me he would assign commands on the march. I was ordered by Lieut W. W. Cooke, Adjutant, to assume command of Companies M, A, and G; Capt. Benteen, of Companies H, D, and K; Custer retaining C, E, F, I, and L, under his immediate command, and Company B, Capt. McDougall, in rear of the pack train. I assumed command of the companies assigned to me, and without any definite orders moved forward with the rest of the column, and well to its left. I saw Benteen moving further to the left, and, as they passed, he told me he had orders to move well to the left, and sweep everything before him; I did not see him again until about 2:30 P. M. The command moved down the creek toward the Little Big Horn valley, Custer, with five companies on the right bank, myself and three companies on the left bank, and Benteen further to the left, and out of sight.

As we approached a deserted village, in which was standing one tepee, about 11 A. M., Custer motioned me to cross to him, which I did, and moved nearer to his column, until about 12:30 A. M., when Lieut. Cooke, Adjutant, came to me and said the village was only two miles ahead, and running away. To "move forward at as rapid a gait as I thought prudent, and to charge afterward, and that the whole outfit would support me;" I think those were his exact words. I at once took a fast trot, and moved down about two miles, when I came to a ford of the river. I crossed immediately, and halted about ten minutes or less to gather the battalion, sending word to Custer that I had everything in front of me, and that they were strong.

I deployed, and with the Ree scouts on my left charged down the valley, driving the Indians with great ease for about two and a half miles. I, however, soon saw that I was being drawn into some trap, as they certainly would fight harder, and especially as we were nearing their village, which was still standing; besides I could not see Custer or any other support, and at the same time the very earth seemed to grow Indians, and they were running toward me in swarms, and from all directions. I saw I must defend myself, and give up the attack mounted. This I did, taking possession of a point of woods, and which furnished, near its edge, a shelter for the horses; dismounted and fought them on foot, making headway through the wood. I soon found myself in the near vicinity of the village, saw that I was fighting odds of at least five to one, and that my only hope was to get out of the wood, where I would soon have been surrounded, and gain some high ground. I accomplished this by mounting and charging the Indians between me and the bluffs on the opposite side of the river. In this charge First Lieut. Donald McIntosh, Second Lieut. Ben. H. Hodgson, Seventh Cavalry, and Acting Assistant Surgeon J. M. DeWolf, were killed. I succeeded in reaching the top of the bluff, with a loss of the three officers and twenty-nine enlisted men killed, and seven men wounded. Almost at the same time I reached the top, mounted men were seen to be coming toward us, and it proved to be Col. Benteen's battalion, Companies H, D, and K; we joined forces, and in a short time the pack train came up. As senior, my command was then Companies A, B, D, G, H, K, and M, about 380 men, and the following officers: Capts. Benteen, Weir, French, and McDougall; First Lieuts. Godfrey, Mathey, and Gibson; Second Lieuts. Edgerly, Wallace, Varnum, and Hare; Acting Assistant Surgeon Porter. First Lieut. DeRudio was in the dismounted fight in the woods, but, having some trouble with his horse, did not join the command in the charge, and, hiding himself in the woods, joined the command after nightfall of the 26th.

Still hearing nothing of Custer, and with this reinforcement, I moved down the river in the direction of the village, keeping on the bluffs. We had heard firing in that direction, and knew it could only be Custer. I moved to the summit of the highest bluff, but seeing and hearing nothing, sent Capt. Weir with his company to open communication with the other command. He soon sent back word, by Lieut. Hare, that he could go no further, and that the Indians were getting around him. At this time he was keeping up a heavy fire from his skirmish line. I at once turned everything back to first the position I had taken on the bluff, and which seemed to me the best. I dismounted the men, had the horses and mules of the pack train driven together in a depression, put the men on the crests of the hills making the depression, and had hardly done so when I was furiously attacked. This was about 6 P. M. We held our ground with the loss of eighteen enlisted men killed and forty-six wounded until the attack ceased, about 9 P. M.

As I knew, by this time, their overwhelming numbers, and had given up any support from the portion of the regiment with Custer, I had the men dig rifle pits; barricaded with dead horses, mules, and boxes of hard bread, the opening of the depression toward the Indians in which the animals were herded, and made every exertion to be ready for what I saw would be a terrific assault the next day. All this night the men were busy, and the Indians holding a scalp dance underneath us in the bottom, and in our hearing. On the morning of the 26th, I felt confident that I could hold my own, and was ready as far as I could be, when, at daylight, about 2:30 A. M., I heard the crack of two rifles; this was the signal for the beginning of a fire that I have never seen equalled. Every rifle was handled by an expert and skilled marksman, and with a range that exceeded our carbine, and it was simply impossible to show any part of the body before it was struck. We could see, as the day brightened, countless hordes of them pouring up the valley from out the village, and scampering over the high points toward the places designated for them by their chiefs, and which entirely surrounded our position. They had sufficient numbers to completely encircle us, and men were struck on opposite sides of the lines, from where the shots were fired. I think we were fighting all the Sioux nation, and also all the desperadoes, renegades, half-breeds, and squaw men, between the Missouri and the Arkansas and east of the Rocky Mountains; they must have numbered at least 2,500 warriors. The fire did not slacken until about 9:30 A. M., and then we discovered that they were making a last desperate attempt, and which was directed against the line held by Companies H and M; in this attack they charged close enough to use their bows and arrows, and one man, lying dead within our lines, was touched by the "coup stick" of one of the foremost Indians. When I say the stick was only about ten or twelve feet long, some idea of the desperate and reckless fighting of these people may be understood. This charge of theirs was gallantly repulsed by the men on that line, led by Col. Benteen. They also came close enough to send their arrows into the line held by Companies D and K, but were driven away by a like charge of the line, which I accompanied. We now had many wounded, and the question of water was vital, as from 6 P. M. of the previous evening until now, 10 A. M. (about sixteen hours) we had been without.

A skirmish line was formed, under Col. Benteen, to protect the descent of volunteers down the hill in front of his position to reach the water. We succeeded in getting some canteens, although many of the men were hit in doing so; the fury of the attack was now over, and to my astonishment the Indians were seen going in parties toward the village. But two solutions occurred to us for this movement, that they were going for something to eat, more ammunition (as they had been throwing arrows), or that Custer was coming. We took advantage of this lull to fill all vessels with water, and soon had it by the camp kettle full; but they continued to withdraw, and all firing ceased, save occasional shots from sharpshooters sent to annoy us about the water. About 2 P. M. the grass in the bottom was set on fire, and followed up by Indians, who encouraged its burning, and it was evident it was done for a purpose, which purpose I discovered later on, to be the creation of a dense cloud of smoke, behind which they were packing and preparing to move their tepees.

It was between 6 and 7 P. M. that the village came out from behind the clouds of smoke and dust. We had a close and good view of them, as they fled away in the direction of Big Horn Mountains, moving in almost perfect military order; the length of the column was fully equal to that of a large division of the cavalry corps of the Army of the Potomac, as I have seen it on its march.

We now thought of Custer, of whom nothing had been seen and nothing heard since the firing in his direction about 6 P. M. on the eve of the 25th, and we concluded that the Indians had gotten between him and us, and driven him toward the boat, at the mouth of Little Big Horn river, the awful fate that did befall him never occurring to any of us as within the limits of possibilities. During the night I changed my position, in order to secure an unlimited supply of water, and was prepared for their return, feeling sure they would do so, as they were in such numbers. But early in the morning of the 27th, and while we were on the qui vive for Indians, I saw with my glass a dust some distance down the valley. There was no certainty for some time what they were, but finally I satisfied myself they were cavalry, and if so, could only be Custer, as it was ahead of the time that I understood that Gen. Terry could be expected.

Before this time, however, I had written a communication to Gen. Terry, and three volunteers were to try and reach him (I had no confidence in the Indians with me, and could not get them to do anything). If this dust were Indians, it was possible they would not expect any one to leave. The men started and were told to go as near as was safe to determine if the approaching column was white men, and to return at once in case they found it so; but, if they were Indians, to push on to Gen. Terry. In a short time we saw them returning over the high bluff already alluded to. They were accompanied by a scout who had a note from Terry to Custer, saying, "Crow scouts had come to camp saying he had been whipped, but that it was not believed." I think it was about 10:30 A. M. that Gen. Terry rode into my lines, and the fate of Custer and his brave men was soon determined by Capt. Benteen proceeding with his company to his battle ground, and where were recognized the following officers, who were surrounded by the dead bodies of many of their men: Gen. G. A. Custer; Col. W. W. Cooke, Adjutant; Capts. M. W. Keogh, G. W. Yates, and T. W. Custer; First Lieutenants, A. E. Smith, James Calhoun; Second Lieutenants W. V. Reilly of the Seventh Cavalry and J. J. Crittenden, Twentieth Infantry, temporarily attached to this regiment. The bodies of First Lieutenant J. E. Porter and Second Lieutenants H. M. Harrington and J. G. Sturgis, Seventh Cavalry, and Assistant Surgeon G. W. Lord, United States Army, were not recognized; but there is every reasonable probability they were killed. It was now certain that the column of five companies with Custer had been killed. The wounded in my lines were, during the afternoon and evening of the 27th, moved to the camp of Gen. Terry, and at 5 A. M. of the 28th I proceeded with the regiment to the battle ground of Custer, and buried 204 bodies, including the following named citizens: Mr. Boston Custer, Mr. Reed (a young nephew of Gen. Custer), and Mr. Kellogg, a correspondent of the New York Herald. The following named citizens and Indians who were with my command were also killed: Charles Reynolds (guide and hunter), Isaiah (colored), interpreter; Bloody Knife (who fell from immediately by my side); Bob Tailed Bull and Stab, of the Indian scouts.

After following over his trail, it is evident to me that Custer intended to support me by moving further down the stream and attacking the village in flank; that he found the distance greater to the ford than he anticipated; that he did charge, but his march had taken so long, although his trail shows he moved rapidly, that they were ready for him; that Companies C and I, and perhaps part of Company E, crossed to the village or attempted it at the charge, and were met by a staggering fire, and that they fell back to secure a position from which to defend themselves; but they were followed too closely by the Indians to permit him to form any kind of a line. I think had the regiment gone in as a body, and from the woods in which I fought advanced on the village, that its destruction was certain, but he was fully confident they were running or he would not have turned from me. I think (after the great number of Indians there were in the village) that the following reasons obtained for the misfortune: His rapid marching for two days and one night before the fight, attacking in the daytime at 12 M., and when they were on the qui vive, instead of early in the morning, and lastly, his unfortunate division of the regiment into three commands.

During my fight with the Indians I had the heartiest support from officers and men, but the conspicuous services of Brevet Col. F. W. Benteen I desire to call attention to especially, for if ever a soldier deserved recognition by his Government for distinguished services, he certainly does.

I enclose herewith his report of the operations of his battalion from the time of leaving the regiment until we joined commands on the hill. I also enclose an accurate list of casualties as far as it can be made at the present time, separating them into two lists—"A," those killed in Gen. Custer's command; "B," those killed and wounded in the command I had.

The number of Indians killed can only be approximated until we hear through the agencies. I saw the bodies of eighteen, and Capt. Ball, Second Cavalry, who made a scout of thirteen miles over their trail, says that their graves were many along their line of march. It is simply impossible that numbers of them should not be hit, in the several charges they made so close to my lines. They made their approach through the deep gulches that led from the hilltop to the river; and when the jealous care with which the Indian guards the bodies of killed and wounded is considered, it is not astonishing that their bodies were not found. It is probable that the stores left by them, and destroyed the next two days, were to make room for many of them on their travois.

The harrowing sight of the dead bodies crowning the height on which Custer fell, and which will remain vividly in my memory until death, is too recent for me not to ask the good people of this country whether a policy that sets opposing parties in the field armed, clothed, and equipped by one and the same Government, should not be abolished. All of which is respectfully submitted.

M. A. RENO. Major Seventh Cavalry, Com'dg Regt.

See the clipping

Curly escapes in a Sioux blanket

The Crow scout Curly says Custer, finding a ford, was driven back to high ground and surrounded, and fought from about 2 o’clock almost until sundown. Shot in the left side, Custer ‘sat down, with his pistol in his hand’; a second shot felled him. Curly put on a Sioux blanket, mixed with the charging Sioux, and rode off on a fallen warrior’s pony.

The Milan Exchange · Milan, Tenn. · and 7 other papers

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Milan Exchange · 10 August 1876 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image

THE ONLY SURVIVOR. The Crow Indian Curly is believed to be the only survivor of the 250 men who went into action with Custer. He is very clear in his knowledge of the fight, and has made a statement. He says he went down with two other Crows and went into action with Custer. The General, he says, kept down the river on the north bank four miles, after Reno had crossed to the south side above. Custer's object was to cut off the Indians. He thought Reno would drive down the valley and at the same time attack the village on two sides, he believing Reno would take it at the upper end, while he (Custer) would go in at the lower end.

See moreSee less

Custer had to go further down the river and further away from Reno than he wished on account of the steep bank along the north side; but at last he found a ford and dashed for it. The Indians met him and poured in a heavy fire from across the narrow river. Custer dismounted to fight on foot, but could not get his skirmishers over the stream. Meantime hundreds of Indians, on foot and on ponies, poured over the river, which was only about three feet deep, and filled the ravines on each side of Custer's men. Custer then fell back to some high ground behind him, and seized the ravines in his immediate vicinity. The Indians completely surrounded Custer and poured in a terrible fire on all sides. They charged Custer on foot in vast numbers, but were again and again driven back. The fight began about 2 o'clock, and lasted, Curly says, almost until the sun went down over the hills. They fought desperately, and after the ammunition in their belts was exhausted, went to their saddlebags, got more, and continued the fight. Curly says more Indians were killed than Custer had men. He also says the big chief (Custer) lived until nearly all his men had been killed or wounded, and went about encouraging his soldiers to fight on. He got a shot in the left side and sat down, with his pistol in his hand. Another shot struck Custer in the breast and he fell over. The last officer killed was a man who rode a white horse (believed to be Lieutenant Cook, Adjutant of the Seventh, as Lieutenants Cook and Calhoun were the only officers who rode white horses, and Lieutenant Calhoun was found dead on the skirmish line near the ford, and probably fell early in the action). Curly says when he saw Custer was hopelessly surrounded he watched his opportunity, got a Sioux blanket, put it on and worked up a ravine, and when the Sioux charged he got among them and they did not know him from one of their own men. There were some mounted Sioux, and seeing one fall Curly ran to him, mounted his pony, and galloped down, as if going toward the white men, but went up a ravine and got away. He says as he rode off he saw, when nearly a mile from the battle-field, a dozen or more soldiers in a ravine fighting with Sioux all around them. He thinks all were killed, as they were outnumbered five to one and apparently dismounted. These men were no doubt part of the thirty-five missing men reported in the official dispatches of General Terry. Curly says he saw one cavalry soldier who had got away. He was well mounted, but shot through both hips, and Curly thinks he died of his wounds, starved to death in the bad lands, or more likely his trail was followed and he killed by the Sioux. Curly did not leave Custer until the battle was nearly over, and he describes it as desperate in the extreme. He is quite sure the Indians had more killed than Custer had white men with him, and says the soldiers fought on until the last man fell. The other Crow Indians in the battle were killed.

See the clipping

Custer unscalped; Buffalo Bill sends a scalp home

An Arkansas paper sets two facts side by side: Custer, it says, was not scalped, mutilated or stripped of his uniform by the Sioux, while Buffalo Bill, ‘white man and killer of Indians,’ has just sent friends in Rochester the scalp he cut from the Cheyenne brave Yellow Hand, with his blanket, head-dress and girdle.

The Osceola Times · Osceola, Ark. · and 1 other paper

CorrectionThis set right 2 earlier articles: The Interior Journal, 18 August 1876, The Herald and Mail, 18 August 1876.

The Osceola Times · 19 August 1876 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

It has now been proved beyond dispute that Gen. Custer was not scalped, that his body was not in any way mutilated and that his uniform was not stripped off by the Sioux. But it is a fact that Buffalo Bill, white man and killer of Indians, has just sent to his friends in Rochester the scalp which he cut from the head of the Cheyenne brave, Yellow Hand, after he had killed him, and the blanket, head-dress and girdle which he took from the body of Yellow Hand after death.

See the clipping

Benteen’s feint, and the camp kettles

A correspondent with Reno on the bluff reckoned they could last about ten hours. Then Benteen leapt his breastworks and charged a ravine where the Indians were massing, and later made a feint at the hills while men ran down another ravine with camp kettles to the river. Two were killed and six wounded, but scores of kettles came back full. That night the Indians held a scalp dance below while, he writes, people at home filled the churches.

The Abbeville Press and Banner · Abbeville, S.C. · and 2 other papers

The Abbeville Press and Banner · 30 August 1876 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

The Little Big Horn Battle.

A correspondent who was with Colonel Reno in his desperate resistance to the hostile Indians after their massacre of the gallant Custer, thus vividly tells us of the dangers and hardships of the brave band surrounded by savages, and who were so mercifully delivered from a terrible fate by the commands of Terry and Gibbons: Three o'clock came, and still the battle raged; many had fallen, and every hour added fearfully to the list of killed and wounded. At the present rate of mortality how long would we last? I made a mental calculation and said about ten hours; but when we became weak in numbers the savages would rush down in a body and finish us at one fell swoop. Oh, it was terrible, terrible; but the end would soon come. Already the Indians were massing in a ravine just in front and preparing in overwhelming numbers for a grand charge. Brave old Benteen saw it and determined not to wait for the onset; he sprung over his feeble breastworks, and calling on his company to follow him, dashed into the ravine.

See moreSee less

The Indians were taken completely by surprise and broke, but too late, for Benteen was upon them, and, before they could get away, he had killed ten and wounded as many more. The savages were evidently astonished, and no longer felt safe in the ravines. So far we had fought only on the defensive, and the Indians seemed to regard us as their certain victims. But Benteen's gallant conduct filled us all with a new courage and evidently alarmed the enemy. The day was hot and we had no water; many had not tasted a drop of water since the night before, and some not for thirty-six hours. The men's tongues were dry and swollen; few could speak plainly, and the wounded begged piteously for a drink of water. The narrow river ran at the foot of the bluffs scarcely two hundred yards distant, but the timber on the opposite side was lined with Indian sharpshooters guarding every drop of the precious fluid. Who could go down the side of that steep hill and come up alive? Not one.

A ravine was found leading down almost to the river, and again Benteen formed for a charge. He said he would make a feint against the hills, pour a few volleys into the woods below, and, while the Indians were confused, the men must run down the ravine, fill the camp kettles and get back under cover. The stratagem succeeded admirably; the Indians no longer trusted to a purely defensive policy on the part of the troops; and when the men sprung up, shouted and poured in volleys, there was excitement and confusion in the savage ranks everywhere, and even the men beyond the river thought the soldiers were coming down upon them. Under cover of the smoke and volleys the men with the camp kettles had reached the river and filled them, when the Indians discovered what was going on and rallied. They fired heavily, but it was too late; scores of kettles, containing many gallons of water, were on their way up the ravine, and an abundant supply for present use had been secured. Two men were killed and six wounded in this attempt to get water for their famishing comrades; but the loss was considered light compared with the service rendered. The Indians had taken every precaution to cut us off from water, and they no doubt felt greatly discouraged when they found we had beaten them. The water revived both our spirits and courage, and the men went at their work with a will. The battle lasted all day, and at night the Indians drew off to their village near by, leaving a strong cordon of pickets about our camp.

It was a horrible night, and we lay on our arms amid the dead and dying. The Indians were holding a grand scalp dance below us, and I could not help thinking, while these infernal fiends were holding their orgies on the plains, perhaps burning the bodies of scores of prisoners they had captured alive, the people at home were quietly filling the churches for evening worship.

I need not lengthen out the horrible recital. Suffice it to say that with the dawn of the morning the battle was ushered in again and raged until one o'clock in the afternoon, when the Indians drew off in great haste, and we knew relief was at hand. All evening we watched, but no one came, and we lay down to rest again in doubt. No Indians were about, however, and early the next morning General Gibbons' column was descried coming up the valley. Never was the grasp of brother's hand more welcome in a foreign land than the sight of those blue jackets. General Terry was with General Gibbons, and when he rode into our works many a gallant fellow did not feel ashamed to let his general see tears of heartfelt gratitude rolling down his cheeks for deliverance from a horrible death.

See the clipping

Grant: a sacrifice ‘wholly unnecessary’

In a Herald interview at Long Branch, reprinted in New Orleans, the President misses the word ‘Sioux’ and talks first of carrying Indiana. Asked again, he calls Custer’s massacre a sacrifice of troops ‘wholly unnecessary’: told to meet Terry and Gibbon on the twenty-sixth, Custer made a forced march of eighty-three miles in twenty-four hours and met the Indians alone on the twenty-fifth, ten to his one. Cold weather, Grant predicts, will starve the Sioux into surrender by spring.

New Orleans Republican · New Orleans, La · and 1 other paper

New Orleans Republican · 7 September 1876 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

CHAT WITH THE PRESIDENT He Talks Freely with a Herald Reporter. HIS VIEWS ON THE CAMPAIGN THE DEMOCRACY AND THE INDIANS His Opinion of Tilden, Sitting Bull and the Temporary Notables.

The following somewhat lengthy interview of the President by a reporter of the New York Herald was published in that paper of the second. The importance of the President's views and the freedom with which he pronounced them justify the republication of the article in full:

See moreSee less

LONG BRANCH, September 1, 1876.

President Grant has been wonderfully little interviewed since he entered the White House. This certainly appears strange, considering that this national process for extracting both news and views from great and distinguished men has been so widely adopted that there is scarcely a prominent man in the land who, some time or other, has not been subjected to it. The interviewing process was at first poohpoohed by the staid and slow newspapers of the effete monarchies of Europe, but since the Herald was enabled to enlighten them with the views of the German Crown Prince, Prince Bismarck, Don Carlos, the King of Sweden, Dom Pedro and other royal and semi-royal personages by publishing interviews with them, the European journals have learned its usefulness, and are gradually adopting it as far as the exclusive customs of Europe will allow them. The difficulty there, however, is that a European potentate is generally far more accessible to a Herald representative, as an American, than to a subject of his own realm.

To receive the representative of the Herald at once is only a recognition of the great power of the press, which, in this country, makes and unmakes presidents, generals, cabinet ministers and senators, as the mouthpiece of a sovereign people.

The President's cottage has been so frequently described that it is unnecessary to allude to it at any length. It is about fifteen minutes' walk from the West End Hotel, and is smaller and less pretentious than the cottages that surround it. When the Herald correspondent's coupe drove into the extensive grounds the President's famous four-in-hand was drawn up before the entrance. It has often been remarked that monarchies breed politeness and that republics promote rudeness. Hepworth Dixon said that the further east you went the politer were the people, the further west the ruder. There is much truth in this. At the departments in Washington, where the great shadow of the government falls over the smallest attendant, the least important usher feels his dignity and expresses it in the urbanity and courtesy of his manner. This is still more the case at the White House and at the President's villa at Long Branch. Here the servants are politeness personified.

"Is the President in ?" the correspondent asked a big, shapely, colored usher, all blazing with brass buttons.

"Yes, sir," he replied; "he is engaged now, but I will take in your card." He immediately came out and announced that the President was engaged with Secretary Morrill, but that the latter would presently leave for New York, and then the President would see your correspondent.

The President had been engaged, both with Secretary Morrill and Postmaster General Tyner, for the last two days, and it was this which prevented the interview from taking place sooner. Seated on one of the large rustic chairs on the porch, it was pleasant to look at the carefully trimmed shrubbery, the velvety grass and the beautiful plants that meet the gaze. On the porch lay an enormous sea shell, a most appropriate ornament for a seaside villa.

Presently Mrs. Grant came out, who bowed politely to your correspondent, and after her followed Secretary Morrill, his daughter and the President. The President, in an attitude of great gallantry, which showed how young he feels himself in spirit, bowed profoundly as he shook Miss Morrill's hand and keenly regretted that she could not stay longer at his cottage. She thanked him, evidently touched by his courtly bearing, and then Secretary Morrill and his daughter drove off in the President's four-in-hand. So unassuming and thoroughly polite was the first lady of the land that she would have run down the steps and handed Secretary Morrill his portemanteau, which he had evidently forgotten, if the writer had not promptly intercepted it. Secretary Morrill had been in great anxiety lest his two trunks would be left behind, but, luckily, the express wagon arrived at the last moment, and he drove off, he and his daughter waving their cordial adieus. Miss Morrill had, a few minutes before, declined the parting glass of wine which Mrs. Grant had hospitably offered her.

Scarcely had the equipage and baggage wagon disappeared when a mail wagon came rattling along, leaving a huge bag of letters for the President.

"Now I will see you," said the President, and he led your correspondent to the back piazza, which commands a beautiful view of the glorious sweep of ocean at Long Branch. There, seated in two large, easy, rustic chairs, the President and your correspondent had their cosy chat. But, before transcribing the substance of the conversation, a glimpse of the President and his lady may be welcome to the reader. To begin with Mrs. Grant. She looks as young and bright as she did seven years ago, when the writer first saw her. Her face, which is large and in harmony with her well rounded, luxurious figure, has an expression of exceeding good nature, and is decidedly prepossing in its open, frank lineaments. Mrs. Grant's stature and face both betray the evidences of generous living. Mrs. Grant wore a simple but elegant black silk, which was highly becoming to her matronly style and figure.

The President is undoubtedly what is called a good looking man. His face is not regular, it is true, but his appearance has many features of attraction. His solid, strong, broad figure, so expressive of sinew and muscle and backbone; his finely marked, rugged countenance, with its straight, clear, decisive nose, its strong, red, bright lips, its penetrating, open, blue eyes and rose fresh cheeks—all these form a decidedly pleasing picture. The President has not oldened in the last seven years either. His full beard is tinged with gray, but far more than his hair. There are many men of forty who do not look a day younger than the President does now at fifty-four. His face and his figure are more those of a man in the prime of his manhood than in the decline of his age. They repel instantly the frequent charges of dissipation that have been made against the President by unscrupulous enemies. A glance at his erect, splendid carriage and his ruddy, rugged fact shows that he is a man who has undoubtedly enjoyed the pleasures of the table, but who has taken eminently good care of himself.

The conversation opened with a rather ludicrous blunder, but which was luckily not noticed by the President. The writer naively began, after the usual social preliminaries, by asking what the President thought of the present aspect of the Sioux campaign.

The President evidently did not hear the word "Sioux," and immediately plunged into an exposition of the present aspect of the political contest. The correspondent, rather than interrupt him, allowed the mistake to go uncorrected.

"I think if we carry Indiana in October," said the President, speaking with great rapidity and fluency, and not bearing out at all the reputation for silence which the Empress of Brazil and other less distinguished visitors have given him, "there will be scarcely any contest at all."

Correspondent—But how does it look to you in Indiana, Mr. President?

The President (talking in the same rapid vein)—All the reports that I have received are very favorable. It looks to me as if we'll carry Indiana.

Correspondent—Has not the forced withdrawal of Orth, under charges of corruption, injured the prospects of the party, Mr. President?

The President (smiling)—No, I think it has greatly helped them. It shows that the Republican party will not run a candidate who even bears the semblance of wrong. Mr. Orth is a very good man, but as soon as his apparent shortcomings became known, the party withdrew him from the ticket.

The President pronounced the words "apparent shortcomings" with marked emphasis, as though he was by no means convinced of the truth of the charges against our ex-minister to Vienna.

Correspondent—You take a different view of the withdrawal of Mr. Orth from the Democratic papers.

The President—I am sure the course of the Republican party in this matter contrasts very favorably with that of the Democrats. We have withdrawn a gubernatorial candidate charged with having helped fraudulent claimants, but will they withdraw their presidential candidate in the face of the far more serious charges made against him?

The President smiled rather maliciously at this sally as though it would be no bad joke to see Mr. Tilden withdrawn from the Democratic ticket as Mr. Orth had been withdrawn from the Republican.

Correspondent—You allude to the charges against Mr. Tilden regarding his income, Mr. President?

The President—Yes, the Times makes a direct charge of perjury against Mr. Tilden. Now, I would not go so far as to make a charge of perjury; but here are the facts:—Mr. Tilden makes one affidavit as to his income, to the effect that it was only seven thousand and odd hundred dollars, and then he swears that in the same year he received one fee amounting alone to $20,000.

The President paused in his rapid delivery of this argument, smiled and shook his head, as if to say, "This is a queer business. I'd like to know how he can get out of it."

Correspondent—I think there is no probability that Mr. Tilden's name will be withdrawn.

The President—Well, that certainly shows that the Republican party is more scrupulous about the strict honor and integrity of its candidates than the Democratic.

Correspondent—Then I understand you, Mr. President, as saying that if the Republicans carry Indiana Hayes will be elected?

The President—Yes, that's what I meant to say. I suppose we have no chance in most of the Southern States, because the Democratic intimidation at the polls will prevent the negro from voting, and we can not have a fair election. But if we can check this intimidation we have a good chance of carrying North Carolina, South Carolina, West Virginia and Maryland.

Correspondent—Then you do not, like most Republicans, think that Louisiana and Florida may be won for Hayes and Wheeler?

The President—No; I don't despair of Hayes carrying Louisiana and Florida if we have a fair election, although I think they are more doubtful.

Correspondent—But will not the battle be really fought in the State of New York, as most Democrats and Republicans agree?

The President (answering quickly, as if anxious to remove an erroneous impression)—Oh, if we carry North Carolina, South Carolina and Louisiana we can afford to lose both New York and Indiana as well as Connecticut. I have not the figures at hand, and am not sure, but I think so.

Correspondent—Then you think it possible that the Republican party may be defeated in New York?

The President (rapidly and almost impulsively as before)—Oh, I don't think so. I think we'll carry all these three States, New York, Connecticut and Indiana, which are considered the pivotal States in the campaign.

Correspondent—What do you think of the nomination of Horatio Seymour by the Democrats at Saratoga?

The President—I think the nomination of Seymour shows that the Democrats are not confident of success in New York, for if they were they certainly would not have forced it upon a man who had positively declined.

Correspondent—But now that the nomination has been made, how does the contest in New York look to you, Mr. President? Has the nomination of Mr. Seymour secured the Empire State to Mr. Tilden?

The President—I think the move of nominating him is a very shrewd one, for there is no doubt that he is by far the ablest and the most popular of the Democrats, but even Seymour don't help them, I think.

Correspondent—Do you think that many who vote for Seymour won't vote for Tilden, Mr. President?

This was evidently a puzzle which President Grant did not feel inclined to solve just then. So he briefly and somewhat abruptly exclaimed—"I think we'll carry the State, sir."

Correspondent—And that you think is equivalent to Hayes' election?

The President—Yes, then there is no doubt of his election. Of course, if we carry New York we can afford to lose several of the Southern States which I have mentioned to you—probably three out of the six.

Correspondent—Has the result of the canvass thus far, in your opinion, vindicated the wisdom of Hayes' nomination at Cincinnati?

The President—Undoubtedly; Hayes is a man perfectly pure in his record—so pure that it is impossible to bring even a single charge against him. This can certainly not be said of Mr. Tilden, against whom charges are constantly being made.

Here the correspondent, seeing that the conversation had pretty well exhausted the field of politics, returned to the original charge at the beginning of the interview. But fearing that the word "Sioux" might again be misunderstood or overheard by the President, he put the question in this form:

"How do you view the present aspect of the Indian war, Mr. President?"

The President—I think our troops won't be able to do much now until the cold weather.

Correspondent—Most people regard the whole campaign as a failure.

The President—I think the whole war will be over next spring, and by that time the Sioux will have surrendered. You see, the cold weather will put them to great stress to find sustenance, and then they won't be able to do anything with their ponies, and will gladly come in and surrender to be saved from starvation.

Correspondent—Was not Custer's massacre a disgraceful defeat of our troops?

The President (with an expression of manifest and keenly felt regret)—I regard Custer's massacre as a sacrifice of troops, brought on by Custer himself, that was wholly unnecessary—wholly unnecessary.

Correspondent—How so, Mr. President?

The President—He was not to have made the attack before effecting the junction with Terry and Gibbon. He was notified to meet them on the twenty-sixth, but instead of marching slowly, as his orders required in order to effect the junction on the twenty-sixth, he enters upon a forced march of eighty-three miles in twenty-four hours, and thus he has to meet the Indians alone on the twenty-fifth.

Correspondent—Mr. President, do you share the general admiration for Sitting Bull as a tatician—as an Indian Napoleon?

The President—Oh, no! He is just as wily, as most of the Indians, who will never fight our troops unless they have them at a decided disadvantage.

Hitherto the President, who is decidedly nervous in his conversation, instead of being apathetic and lymphatic, as most people think, had amused himself by crumpling between his finger into every imaginable shape the card of your correspondent, but he now threw it away. It may as well be remarked here that the President's conversational powers, instead of being scant, according to general repute, are remarkably good. To be sure, when a topic is broached which he either does not particularly relish or upon which he does not wish to express himself, he has a striking habit of falling into a deep, gloomy silence; but when you open a subject that is agreeable to him his language pours forth free and unconstrained. It is very rarely that he stops for a word, and he expresses himself always clearly and tersely, with no circumlocution and no unnecessary verbiage.

Correspondent—Then your confidence in the present leaders of the campaign is unshaken, Mr. President.

The President—Entirely. General Crook is the best, wiliest Indian fighter in this country. He has had vast experience in Indian fighting. His campaign against the Idahoes and many other tribes show his brilliant talent as an Indian fighter.

Correspondent—But was he not badly repulsed by Sitting Bull?

The President—He is as wily as Sitting Bull in this respect, that when he finds himself outnumbered and taken at a disadvantage he prudently retreats. In Custer's case Sitting Bull had ten men to every one of Custer.

Correspondent—Is there to be a change in the Indian policy of the government?

The President—No; but the means we shall adopt will give us peace after the war is over. After next spring, when this Indians will have surrendered, we shall have no more Indian wars.

Correspondent—How is this to be accomplished?

The President—It is our present intention to put off the supplies from the Sioux by removing all the Indians from the reservations down to the Indian Territory, or, if they will not consent to that by treaty, down to the Missouri river, when a military barrier is to be placed between all these Indians and the hostile Sioux, so that all communication and all supplies will be cut off. Hitherto these hostile Indians have gone on the warpath, but when they can't get any food they come back, get food and take ponies and recruits along with them when they leave again for the warpath. All this play is to be stopped. We are taking up now all the hostile Indians that come to the reservations and disarming them.

Correspondent—It is indeed a comforting thought, Mr. President, that we shall have no more Indian wars after next spring.

The President—I firmly believe so (with a sign of qualification)—that is, we may have small troubles occasionally with some of the minor tribes, but there will not be, properly speaking, another Indian war.

Correspondent—What is to be done with the Sioux after they surrender for want of subsistence?

The President (with dry humor)—That we can determine after we have got them. Meanwhile, I have placed the Red Cloud and Spotted Tail agencies under military supervision. The agents remain there, but their functions are superseded for the present by the officers of the War Department. This was done on the same principle on which I would put a district of country in which military operations were carried on under martial law. Rest assured as soon as the Indians can not get any subsistence and any more supplies from the reservations, they will come in and surrender.

Correspondent—When was the order regarding the agencies alluded to given by you?

The President—About two months ago. I talked the matter over with the Secretary of War and General Sherman, and then gave a verbal order to the latter. That was all. My idea about disposing of the Indians is to disarm them and to set them all at work in the Indian Territory.

Correspondent—For what work do you deem them available?

The President—O, they can raise cattle and all that. That would be my idea.

The manner in which this was said left no doubt that President Grant considers the settlement of the troublesome Indian question as being beyond the range of his term of office, and is determined to leave it modestly to his successor. Whether our worthy friend, Sitting Bull, will therefore be ignominiously compelled to raise cattle instead of scalping white soldiers will probably depend either on Governor Hayes or Governor Tilden.

Leaving the subject of the Indian troubles, your correspondent asked the President whether the effect of the Democratic reductions had been yet felt by the government.

The President—You know they do not really go into effect until the tenth of October. It would, therefore, be premature to say how far the departments will be hampered.

Correspondent—You said in your message to the House in regard to the river and harbor bill—I suppose it might rather be called the river and harbor job—that you would not expend all the money. Have you arrived yet at a determination as to what improvements will be prosecuted, Mr. President?

The President—I can not give you the exact list, but it is sufficient to say that only works of national importance, such as Hell Gate and the like, will be prosecuted. (With an expression of great contempt.) I won't spend any of the people's money on little creeks in West Virginia or anywhere else. No new works of any kind will be begun anywhere.

Correspondent—How large a saving will you be able to effect?

The President—I think I shall be able to save from $3,000,000 to $3,500,000.

This the President said with an expression of as great delight, apparently, as though it was his own and not the people's money that he was about to save.

Correspondent—You read the House some severe lessons during the session on points of economy and propriety.

The President—They laid themselves open to it. I only did my duty in the course I adopted.

Correspondent—It was thought by some of the Democrats that you would be afraid of impeachment?

The President (rising and walking up and down a few steps on the piazza, with his hands in his pockets)—They didn't know anything to impeach me upon or which would reflect upon my character.

Correspondent—Mr. President, would you like to say something about the charges made in the Democratic journals that Hayes is responsible for Secretary Robeson, Babcock, Shepherd and others so prominently identified with your administration?

The President was silent for a few moments, while an expression of the intensest disgust and contempt overspread his broad, rugged face. He seemed to be cogitating whether to answer or not. At last his doubts cleared, and looking brightly, he said:

"I don't see that there is anything against Robeson on which I could remove him, or on which he could be represented as a dishonest man or delinquent officer. I have read all the testimony against him with the utmost care, as I had heard of the charges that had been made against him for years, and was anxious to learn the results of the official inquiry. I found nothing in the slightest degree reflecting upon his character."

Correspondent—You regard the report of the Naval Committee as a piece of injustice?

The President—They published a great many lies about him. Take, for instance, the lies about his income. They got from the Internal Revenue Commissioner, Mr. Pratt, the amount of Mr. Robeson's income, and for certain years it appeared that he had paid no income tax at all. Now Mr. Robeson went before the committee and showed that in one of these years when, according to the statement, he paid no income tax at all, he actually did pay a tax on $75,000 income.

Correspondent—In what year was that, Mr. President?

The President—That was in the year when his father died and he came into a respectable fortune. This shows that he did even more than might have been done by many honest men—he returned his capital as his income, while Tilden (here the President smiled and looked jocose) regarded his income as his capital, and therefore would not return it.

Correspondent—How about the blackmailing of contractors by the Cattells, Mr. President?

The President—The Cattells have undoubtedly disgraced themselves. But I looked through all the testimony to find any proof that Robeson knew of their operations. I found none. They never had any conversation or communication with Robeson so that I could hold him responsible for what was done by the Cattells.

Correspondent—Was there not favoritism and violence of law in the contracts given out by the Secretary?

The President—On the contrary, I found upon an examination of the testimony that every head of a bureau testified that the Secretary never interfered in any manner in the awarding of contracts.

Correspondent—How about Robeson's deposits of nearly $500,000 while in office?

The President—If he deposited any such amounts then I'd like to know where. I'd like to know in what banks.

Correspondent—The figures in the report of the Naval Committee claim to show aggregate of deposits.

The President—I don't remember seeing that in the proof. However, it would be no evidence that the money deposited belonged to him; every business man knows that.

Correspondent—From what you have said about Secretary Robeson, Mr. President, I gather that the story started in Washington to the effect that before leaving for Rye Beach he handed you his resignation is untrue?

The President (curtly)—Entirely so; there is not a word of truth in it.

Correspondent—It has been stated that Mr. Bristow and Mr. Wilson have furnished some of these assaults upon you?

The President—Now, I have not the slightest doubt that Wilson did, and that Bristow was cognizant of his doings. I asked Bristow about this six months ago, and he denied it; but I know, nevertheless, that it is true.

Correspondent—Is it really true that the prosecution of the whisky ring had for its aim to make Mr. Bristow President.

The President (evidently not desiring to directly answer this question)—Well, they certainly have been villainously prosecuted.

Correspondent—As you look back upon your administration, Mr. President, are there many things which you would like to have done differently from what you did?

The President (ruminating)—With all the experience I have had in these eight years I don't know that I would do many things differently if I had to begin my term of office now. I might do some things differently in the way of appointments and that sort of thing, but as to the large measures of any importance I don't know that I would change any of them. One thing is certain, that no President can do anything important without finding many people who will differ with him as to the propriety or wisdom of the act.

Correspondent—You do not feel that the criticisms made upon you have injured you, Mr. President?

The President (laughing)—No; I regard them as compliments to me. If I had not done anything worth praising I would not have done anything worth criticising.

Correspondent—Have you read the criticisms upon Secretary Cameron's recent order as an attempt to dragoon the Southern people?

The President (still laughing)—Oh, I don't read criticisms. I don't pay any attention to them.

The President evidently did not deem it necessary to defend that order, and as the President had to see ex-Congressman Taylor, of Pennsylvania, on rather important business, the interview here closed. The correspondent thanked the President for the frank and full expression of his views and bade him goodby.

See the clipping

A captive trapper’s story of the fight

A Washington paper reprints a Minneapolis interview with Ridgely, an old trapper who says he was a prisoner in Sitting Bull’s camp from March and saw every movement of the troops. Custer saw twenty-five tepees, he says, but seventy-five more stood behind a bluff, and the fight lasted not more than fifty-five minutes. Six soldiers taken alive were tied to stakes and burned. Sitting Bull, he says, boasted of killing a general whose name he did not know.

National Republican (Washington City) · D.C. · and 3 other papers

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

National Republican (Washington City) · 9 September 1876 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

Custer's Last Fight.

The Minneapolis (Minn.) Times and Tribune publishes an interview with an old trapper, named Ridgely, who has been for a long time in the Yellowstone country and claims to have witnessed the Custer massacre, being a prisoner in Sitting Bull's camp and seeing every movement of the troops. He was taken prisoner last March and kept in the camp of the Indians ever since until the Custer massacre. He was kindly treated while there. He says Sitting Bull organized not to fight the whites, but to drive miners from the Hills. Previous to Custer's attack mounted couriers from Sitting Bull's camp had for eight days watched his forces, its division into small detachments being noted with manifestations of extreme delight.

See moreSee less

AMBUSCADES

were immediately prepared, and while the Indians stood ready for an attack many of them clambered up the hill overlooking Custer's line of march. The Indian camp was divided by a bluff, a point of which ran toward the Rosebud and in the direction of one of the available fords of the river to the Indian camp. By this ford Custer followed their trail down to the water's edge. There were but twenty-five teepes visible to Custer, but there were seventy-five double teepes behind the bluff not visible. Custer attacked the smaller village, and was immediately met by 1,500 or 2,000 Indians,

IN REGULAR ORDER OF BATTLE.

Every movement was made with military precision. Ridgely says he stood on the side of the hill, where he had a complete view of the battle, which was not more than a mile and a half distant. Custer began the fight in the ravine near the ford, and fully half of his command seemed to be unhorsed at the first fire. Then the soldiers retreated toward him in the rear, and were shot down with astonishing rapidity, the commanding officer falling from his horse in the middle of the engagement, which commenced at 11 a. m. and did not last more than fifty-five minutes.

AFTER THE MASSACRE

of Custer's forces the Indians returned to camp with six soldiers as prisoners, and delirious with joy over their success. Those six were tied to stakes at a woodpile in the village and burned to death. While the flames were torturing them to death the Indian boys fired red-hot arrows into their quivering flesh until they died. Sitting Bull was met after the fight and he exultantly remarked that he had killed many soldiers and one d--d general, but he did not know who he was. The squaws then armed themselves with knives, visited the battle-field and robbed and mutilated the bodies of the soldiers. While those

SOLDIERS WERE BEING BURIED

the Indians turned their attention to a force, evidently Reno's, attacking the lower end of the village. Ridgely says Custer's command had been slaughtered before a shot was fired by Reno's force, which attacked the lower end of the camp about 2 o'clock p. m. The Indians returned in the evening and said the men had fought like the devil, but Ridgely says they did not make a statement of their losses. They said the soldiers had been

DRIVEN BACK TWICE,

and they piled up stones, and the attack was unsuccessful. The prisoners were kept burning for an hour, but Ridgely was not permitted to speak with them, so we are unable to state who they were. One was noticeable from his small size and gray hair and whiskers. Reno killed more Indians than Custer. Two captains, believed to be Yates and Keogh, were the last to die.

The Indians were wild with delight, and many were drunk on whisky stolen from the whites. The squaws performed the duty of guards for the prisoners, and becoming drowsy, Ridgely and two companions escaped, securing ponies, and began their long journey homeward. They party ate game and laid in the woods four days to avoid the Indians. On the way his horse stumbled, breaking Ridgely's arm, but the party finally reached Fort Abercrombe, and thence Ridgely came here. He describes Sitting Bull as a half-breed, of large size, and very intelligent, with a peculiar gait to his walk.

See the clipping

Crook’s men recover the Seventh’s guidon

A courier from Crook’s command reports that Col. Mills, with 150 men on the best horses, surprised a Sioux village of forty-one lodges before daylight. Among the spoils is the Seventh Cavalry guidon ‘which Custer used in the Little Horn massacre,’ with clothing worn there. The chief American Horse is mortally wounded, and an afternoon attack by Crazy Horse’s band is driven off.

Northern Ohio Journal · Painesville, Ohio · and 2 other papers

Northern Ohio Journal · 23 September 1876 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

CHEYENNE, Sept. 16.

A courier who left Gen. Crook's command Sept. 10 brings the following news to Sept. 9: Since Gen. Crook's column turned south toward the Black Hills on the 5th inst. there has been considerable hardship through bad weather and living on bacon and hard bread, and there was a good deal of grumbling. On the 7th it was decided to send a portion of the pack train ahead, under escort of Col. Mills, with fourteen men on the best horses of each company of the Third Cavalry, making 150 in all. Lieuts. Von Lutwitz, Schulle and Crawford composed the subordidate officers, and Frank Gruard, Crook's chief scout, was to serve both as guide and scout. Yesterday evening he discovered through the rain and fog, without being himself observed, a hostile Sioux village, consisting of forty-one lodges, a band of several hundred ponies and a few American horses. Mills fell back a few miles, hid his command in a ravine, and at two o'clock this morning marched for the village, which was situated on a little creek, a tributary of Grand or Owl Creek. He formed on the north side before daylight and ordered Lieut. Schawka, of Company M, to charge through the village, while the rest of the force, dismounted, were to form a skirmish line on either side and pick off the Indians as they came out. The latter were completely surprised, and scattered out pell-mell, half naked, returning the fire to some extent. Their ponies were effectually stampeded, but owing to Mills' small force he only succeeded in securing the lodges and property therein, and about 140 ponies. There was an immense quantity of dried meat, berries, etc., all that Crook's whole pack train could carry, and sufficient to postpone the proposed purehase of supplies. There were wagon loads of robes and spoils of all kinds. The guidon of the Seventh Cavalry, which Custer used in the Little Horn massacre, and various other articles of wearing apparel worn on that occasion were also captured. A quantity of corn stored at the mouth of Powder River as late as Aug. 5, where Terry was fired on, was among the spoils. Lieut. Von Lutwitz, Company C, was seriously wounded in the knee. Privates Medburg and Charles Foster, of Company B, Augustus Dorn, of Company D, and Sergt. Glass, of Company E, were wounded, and Private Wenzel, of Company A, was killed in the action of the morning. About seven o'clock word reached Crook, fifteen miles back with the main column. He came forward with sections from the cavalry, reaching Mills at eleven o'clock. The latter had kept up a good picket fight during the forenoon. Crook was very much disappointed because Mills did not report the discovery last night, and there was plenty of time to have got up the entire command and so effectually surrounded the village that nothing could have escaped. But the General is also pleased, all things considered. About 100 yards from the village is a little ravine in which a band of seven warriors and fifteen women and children were safely lodged in caves in the rocks, and it was in trying to dislodge them that Mills lost his killed and wounded. Gen. Crook desired to save the women and children and, by means of guards interfering, a parley ensued. Three warriors came out, one Chief named American Horse being mortally wounded. Before this parley was effected, however, Frank White, a citizen, was shot through the heart, and Privates Kennedy and McKeenen, of Company C, Fifth Cavalry, were wounded. About 4:20 o'clock this afternoon a sudden picket firing sprung up, beginning on Col. Mason's front, resulting in the wounding of Sergt. Schreiber, of Company K, and Private Dorn, of Company F, Fifth Cavalry. It proved to be the result of reinforcements received from Crazy Horse's band, and a running attack all around the circle, but the troops were quickly thrown out and the enemy driven off in every direction. The latter got about a dozen horses which were too poor to get into camp. Back a mile, on the line of march, the village was thoroughly ransacked and the spoils divided around. Col. Mills and his men got the ponies. There were found passes to "Good Indians" from Indian-Agent Howard, of the Spotted Tail Agency, and an illicit trader there, named F. A. Boucher, dated respectively Jan. 14 and Feb. 18, 1876. Much ammunition and many guns were found in the lodges, and all the evidence is to the effect that these Indians were prepared for winter. There were probably 1,000 warriors connected with it and their Chief is Roman Nose, formerly of the Cheyenne Agency. It is regretted that other villages near by were not surprised and destroyed, but this affair demonstrates the good policy of a stern chase after the Indians, even with foot soldiers, who came in here to the relief of the cavalry, as their part in the play gives them renewed vigor and spirit.

See moreSee less

SEPT. 10.--There was a little picket firing last night and this morning, and after the command was on the march a number of Indians came down on the rear of the column, but met with a warm reception from Capt. Summers' battalion of the Fifth Cavalry, who covered the enemy in the ravines, killed several and disabled others. Privates Foster, of Company F, Madden, of Company M, and George Clantier, of Company D, were wounded. The command marched fifteen miles to-day toward the Hills, bringing the entire sick and wounded on twelve litters. Medical-Director Clements amputated the right leg of Lieut. Von Lutwitz last evening, and Private Kennedy died of his wounds. No other amputations or deaths are likely to occur. The wounded Chief American Horse died last night. Most of the captives were brought along, a few squaws being sent back with the General's advice to the hostile bands to go on to the agencies, behave themselves, and all will be well with them. Col. Mills and Lieut. Bubb and guard go through to the Hills to-morrow with a view to secure future supplies. Gen. Sheridan is now at Fort Laramie awaiting the arrival of Gen. Crook or advices from him as to what point he may meet him for council.

See the clipping

Buffalo Bill: ‘Reno is to blame’

Buffalo Bill tells the Philadelphia Press that Custer’s charge ‘was not mad or ill-timed’: properly supported, he would have won. Reno, he says, stood inactive with only a ridge between him and Custer, and Benteen wanted to go but was outranked. The officers in command are ‘too old,’ lacking the dash for such warfare.

Essex County Herald · Guildhall, Vt. · and 1 other paper

Essex County Herald · 14 October 1876 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

Buffalo Bill said recently to a reporter of the Philadelphia Press: "Custer's charge was not mad or ill-timed. Custer charged when, had he been supported as he ought to have been, he would have won a glorious victory. He was not supported. Reno stood inactive when only a ridge separated him from Custer when the latter was being butchered. Reno is to blame, and I told him so. Benteen wanted to go and support Custer, but Reno ranked him and he was powerless. The command was not in the hands of the proper men. They are too old, and lack the dash and vim and vigor for such a warfare."

See the clipping

← Back to Act Three: The Dead