As the Papers Told It

Little Bighorn · As the Papers Told It

Act Eleven

The Statue

June 1906 – October 1913

John Mulvaney, who painted ‘Custer’s Last Stand,’ died poor. A novel that ended at the Little Bighorn ran in the papers as a serial. Another ‘only survivor’ died in Yonkers. In 1910 President Taft and Mrs. Custer unveiled an equestrian statue of Custer at Monroe, Michigan, with the scout Curly among the guests. In 1911 an old scout said Custer had shot himself; a destitute ‘Deadwood Dick’ said he had outrun the Sioux; and in 1913 Curley, now the only survivor, said he had held Custer’s head as he died.

Mulvaney’s canvas and the spirit of the fight

A Minnesota paper notes that John Mulvaney, known to thousands by his canvas ‘Custer’s Last Stand’, has died in poverty and neglect. A battle cannot really be depicted, the writer argues, but Mulvaney put spirit into a few faces, his picture ‘went home to the heart of the soldiers of the country’, and one day it may show Americans the spirit of the plains.

The Princeton Union · Princeton, Minn. · and 1 other paper

The Princeton Union · 14 June 1906 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

The Spirit of the Fight. Recently there died in poverty and neglect an artist known to but few personally, but known to thousands by his canvas "Custer's Last Stand." John Mulvaney had the longing which comes to many a novice to put into lines the spirit of a fight. This is not an easy thing to do—in fact, it is next to impossible, like that of putting Niagara within the limits of painting. Almost every American has seen in some form or other the Revolutionary piece "Spirit of '76." Shirt sleeve determination is the message the artist has given, and no one who cares for the message will be concerned about the art.

See moreSee less

Mulvaney put spirit into a few faces and figures in his picture, and it went home to the heart of the soldiers of the country. Some day, when Custer becomes a tradition and men, women and children want to see the spirit of the plains they may find it on Mulvaney's one famous canvas. A battle really cannot be depicted, but a face may be painted with the fervor of battle upon it, and this touch makes "Custer's Last Stand" eloquent as a souvenir of American warfare.

See the clipping

A novel ends in the Custer massacre

An Iowa paper announces a serial, Randall Parrish’s ‘Bob Hampton of Placer,’ whose hero, reinstated, falls with his old commander in a climax describing the Custer massacre. The critics it quotes promise suspense worthy of Sherlock Holmes.

Evening Times-Republican · Marshalltown, Iowa · and 5 other papers

Evening Times-Republican · 18 July 1907 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image

Bob Hampton of Placer

By RANDALL PARRISH,

See moreSee less

Author of "When Wilderness Was King," "A Sword of the Old Frontier," etc.

This remarkable story will be run serially in this paper. Read what the critics say of it:

St. Paul Dispatch—A compelling interest biases the reader in favor of this tale, which, with a wealth of dramatic power, reaches its climax in a description of the Custer massacre. Injustice makes men restless, and Bob Hampton was no mean specimen, but the love he bears his old commander, General Custer, like a magnet draws him with unfailing fatality, so that, with his old company, he, reinstated, falls with that gallant leader.

Houston Chronicle—The story is decidedly the best Mr. Parrish has written, and the popularity of his former volumes in connection with the excellence of this latest will make it one of the widely read novels of the day. In this story he has, perhaps, reached the summit of his art.

The Little Rock Gazette—This is one of the strongest, most virile stories of the year. The author has had several successes. This latest should eclipse them all.

The Portland Oregonian—Mr. Parrish can rest assured that in writing this military tale he has created a true American novel on rational lines.

Chicago Daily News—The best and strongest story in the line of succession from Mr. Parrish's pen. The story in complication and characterization is wonderfully clever, the elements of suspense remarkably sustained, while its atmosphere of mystery is as strong and its purpose as deep as any that ever entered the most subtle, calculating mood of Sherlock Holmes.

Philadelphia Press—"Bob Hampton of Placer" is another thrilling American novel by Randall Parrish. Like its predecessors, it commands attention from the start and holds the interest absorbed by its continuous action. Furthermore it is a notably well written story, exhibiting the author's rare sense of dramatic values.

Grand Rapids Herald—The surpassing power of this new novel, "Bob Hampton of Placer," marks it not only as the best by Mr. Parrish but as probably the strongest in human interest of the season. Seldom has any novel exceeded it in virile strength and the quality that arouses the emotions.

See the clipping

Mrs. Custer plans a home for literary women

An Associated Press dispatch from New York: Mrs. Elizabeth Custer intends to build a home for aged literary women as a memorial to her husband, on sixteen lots she has bought in Bronxville, Westchester county. She has written several books, the dispatch notes, and has long been interested in literary women.

Los Angeles Herald · Los Angeles, Calif. · and 3 other papers

Los Angeles Herald · 14 January 1908 · page 12 · transcribed from the page image

GENERAL CUSTER'S WIDOW TO AID LITERARY WOMEN

Will Erect a Home for Aged Writers as a Memorial to Her Gallant Husband

See moreSee less

By Associated Press.

NEW YORK, Jan. 13.—Mrs. Elizabeth Custer, widow of Gen. Custer, who was killed in the Indian massacre in the west in 1876, intends to erect a home for aged literary women as a memorial to her husband.

She has purchased sixteen lots in Bronxville, Westchester county, and will erect the home there. Mrs. Custer has written several books and has long been interested in literary women.

See the clipping

‘Only survivor’ dies in Yonkers

Thomas J. Callan dies at Yonkers, described as the man Custer sent through the Indian lines for reinforcements, who led the relief back too late and won a medal from Congress for it. The headline calls him the ‘Only Survivor of the Custer Massacre.’

The Idaho Recorder · Salmon City, Idaho · and 2 other papers

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Idaho Recorder · 19 March 1908 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image

HERO GOES TO REST.

Only Survivor of the Custer Massacre Dies in New York.

See moreSee less

Yonkers, N. Y.—Thomas J. Callan, the man whom General Custer sent for reinforcements when his command was entrapped by Indians on the Little Big Horn river, in Montana, and who led a relief force back to the place where Custer and his men had been slaughtered, died at his home here Friday. Callan received a medal from congress in recognition of his bravery in making the dash for reinforcements for Custer. An overwhelming body of Indians had already surrounded Custer's troops when Callan was chosen to carry out the dispatch asking for help. He made his way through the Indian lines to the nearest military post, and then headed the relief party on the long ride back to the scene of battle. They arrived too late, however, the entire Custer command having been annihilated by the Indians. Callan left the army twenty-three years ago, and since that time has been engaged in business here.

See the clipping

Custer on horseback before the Monroe courthouse

With President Taft as orator, Mrs. Elizabeth B. Custer unveils Edward C. Potter’s equestrian statue, for which Michigan appropriated $25,000. Among the guests are Nevin J. Custer, the only surviving brother, and the scout Curly, called the only member of Custer’s command to escape. The statue shows a Civil War moment when Confederates held their fire, struck by Custer’s bravery and his horse’s beauty.

Newark Evening Star and Newark Advertiser · Newark, N.J. · and 3 other papers

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

Newark Evening Star and Newark Advertiser · 4 June 1910 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image

PRESIDENT SPEAKS AT UNVEILING OF STATUE OF CUSTER

Widow of Daring Cavalry Leader, Slain by Sitting Bull, Attends Michigan Ceremony.

See moreSee less

MONROE, Mich., June 4.—With President Taft in attendance as the orator of the occasion, the nation, state, city and adjacent farming district united here today in paying tribute to the memory of General Armstrong Custer, who, with 254 of his cavalrymen, was slain by Sitting Bull's band of Sioux Indians at the battle of the Little Big Horn in the "Bad Lands" of Montana, June 25, 1876.

A magnificent equestrian statue of General Custer, for which the Legislature of Michigan appropriated $25,000, was unveiled by the general's widow, Mrs. Elizabeth B. Custer, of New York, and among the other guests of honor was Nevin J. Custer, the cavalry leader's only surviving brother, who still resides on a farm near here in the neighborhood where the farmer and his military brothers passed their boyhood.

Two other brothers, Thomas W. and Boston C. Custer, perished with the general on the fatal 25th of June, as did also Lieutenant James Calhoun, the husband of their sister Margaret.

Governor Fred M. Warner came today to give the State of Michigan official representation at the dedication, and veterans of the four Michigan cavalry regiments that comprised the Custer brigade in the Civil War acted as escort of honor to the President in the parade.

Indian Scout There.

One of the most interesting participants in today's celebration was "Curly," the Indian scout, who at the time of the battle was a young boy and was the only member of Custer's command to escape slaughter.

The statue unveiled today in front of the Monroe county Court House is the work of Edward C. Potter, of Greenwich, Conn. The sculptor submitted his model to General Custer's widow before compppeting it and received several suggestions from her, the result, it is said, being a remarkably life-like representation of the dashing cavalry leader. The statue represents an incident of General Custer's career in the Civil War. Riding ahead of his trooppps to survey the position of the enemy Custer suddenly found himself almost upon the Confederate lines.

Reining his mount up quickly, horse and rider stood a moment a bold target for the enemy while the officer examined the position of his opponents. So impressed were the Confederates by the bravery of the rider and the beauty of his steed that not a shot was fired, and Custer returned unharmed to his command.

Attitude of Statues.

The statue shows the general with his left hand lifted high as he reins up his mount, while his characteristic slouch hat is snatched from his curly hair to avoid all obstruction to his vision and hangs at arm's length in his right hand at his saddle.

Thousands of visitors came to Monroe today from near and distant towns to witness the dedication and listen to the address of President Taft, and there were many distinguished guests, including Mrs. John A. Logan, who is a friend of Mrs. Custer; United States Senator William Alden Smith and a number of General Custer's army comrades of the Civil War.

After the exercises here President Taft and his party went to Jackson Mich., to participate in the dedication of a tablet commemorating the organization of the Republican party "under the oaks" at Jackson in June, 1854.

See the clipping

Robert Jackson: powder burns on Custer’s head

Robert Jackson of Costilla, New Mexico, a scout and guide from 1874 to 1883, says he reached the field with the first company and that powder burns showed the fatal pistol was held against Custer’s head. The Indians, he says, wanted Custer alive and told him he put a gun to his head. Jackson, who says he killed and scalped Lame Deer, has no pension.

Audubon County Journal · Exira, Iowa · and 5 other papers

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 6 days later.

Wrong

Audubon County Journal · 4 May 1911 · page 7 · transcribed from the page image

CUSTER DIED BY OWN HAND

Robert Jackson, Old Indian Scout and Guide, Claims Great Fighter Shot Himself.

See moreSee less

That General Custer, the hero of Custer's massacre, believed to have been scalped and killed by the Sioux on the battlefield, was not murdered by the Indians, but died as the result of a gunshot wound fired by his own hand, is the somewhat startling addition offered to history by Robert Jackson of Costilla, Taos county, New Mexico.

Jackson was for nine and a half years a scout and guide for the United States soldiers, his service beginning in 1874 and ending in 1883. Jackson served under General Otis, General Reno, Colonel Benteen, General Miles, General Custer and General Hazen.

At the time of the battle in which General Custer met his death Jackson was serving on the Sixth United States infantry carrying dispatches to General Otis, then in command of the Twenty-second infantry. Jackson was with the first company to reach the battlefield after the massacre and gives in detail the scene as it presented itself to him. Jackson says that an examination of Custer's body showed that the wound which caused his death was fired at close range, the powder burns indicating plainly that the pistol was held against the head. Jackson was commanded by General Reno to talk with the Indians after they had been subdued by the United States troops in the hopes of finding out how Custer was killed. The Indians told Jackson that General Custer was the last man to fall in battle. They wanted to take him alive, believing that with him as a prisoner they could force the government to terms. Realizing this fact, Jackson says the Indians told him that Custer placed a gun to his head and fired.

According to Jackson the Indians all loved Custer and called him "The Long Haired Chief."

Jackson is a picturesque character and although he was in long and dangerous service is not receiving a pension from the government, because he was not a regularly enlisted soldier. Friends in Taos county are interesting themselves in his behalf and hope to receive aid for him from the government to compensate him for valuable services rendered.

Jackson acted as a scout for General Otis when he went to the relief of General Miles, then being on a detail along the Yellowstone river. Jackson also scouted for General Miles when he was running down Lame Deer and his band. Jackson shot and killed Lame Deer, scalped him and afterwards gave the scalp to General Miles.

After the Indians had been driven into Canada, Jackson acted as a guide when General Miles burned over a large territory along the northern boundary of the United States and drove south the buffalo so that the Indians were forced to surrender the following winter.

See the clipping

Deadwood Dick in a Denver jail

Walter Richard Morrison, known in Denver as Deadwood Dick and jailed again for vagrancy, says he warned Custer the night before the massacre and escaped with Texas Jack by giving the Sioux war cry: ‘We were the only two who escaped.’ Almost 80, he lives by selling insect powder, prizes his waist-length hair, and writes verse in his cell.

Yorkville Enquirer · Yorkville, S.C. · and 1 other paper

Yorkville Enquirer · 23 June 1911 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image

DEADWOOD DICK AN OUTCAST.

Man Who Was With Custer at the Massacre at Little Big Horn Has Had Remarkable Career.

See moreSee less

"All the world's a stage, and all the men and women only players; They have their exits and their entrances."

And no one believes this more today than Walter Richard Morrison, at present an inmate of the county jail. As Deadwood Dick his entrance on the stage of the world was to play a leading part in one of the most exciting dramas the west has ever known. As Walter Richard Morrison his exit in the world is to play the lowest part on the stage of life as it is found in every large city in the country. Today he is a vagrant in the West Side jail.

From the honored place of scout to General Custer up to almost the very time when the fighting commander fell with his men on the bloody battlefield of the Little Big Horn, Morrison has fallen to become a figure well known to the police and jail officials of Denver.

His life history is one full of romance and pathos. In his younger days he was one of the men who aided in the making of the great west. Today he is an old man, past three score and ten, for whom life seemingly holds but little. But even in his present condition he is not disheartened. Although, to use an every-day expression, he is "down and out," he still finds something to live for, but his greatest joy and pleasure is in telling of the days when he was a scout with Custer.

Deadwood Dick has been a familiar sight in Denver for 15 years. He was at one time wealthy, and until seven years ago he was in comfortable circumstances. But since that time he has been eking out an existence by manufacturing and selling an insect powder. The old man is a pitiful sight as he sits in the jail. He has long, black hair that almost reaches his waist, and this he says is the pride of his life.

"I stood it all when I lost my money," he said, "but it would kill me if I should lose my hair. It is the only comfort I have."

Deadwood Dick tells a remarkable story of his experience with General Custer. "I was with him during all the trouble on the Little Big Horn," he said. "On the night before the massacre I told Custer that there was but one way to get away from the Indians. At that time we thought there was but 1,500 red men. But instead of that there were more than 3,000. Most of the men were under Sitting Bull. Custer told the men that there was no danger, and the best thing for us to do was to stay right where we were.

"A scout by the name of Texas Jack and myself left the camp to take a look about. This was on the day before Custer and his men were killed. Texas Jack and myself rode for some distance up the river. I felt sure we were about to be captured. So I told him I would give the Sioux war cry, for him to answer with the coyote yell, for by doing this all the Indians would go in the direction of their chief. It worked out just as I thought it would.

"All the Indians started in the direction of the chief and we started up the river, which was the only means of escape. We ran across one small group of Indians headed in the direction we were going. We made up our minds that the only thing to do was to shoot until our ammunition was gone and then run. We did this and managed to get through. On the next day the Indians, under Sitting Bull, killed Custer and his men. We were the only two who escaped. If General Custer had taken my advice Custer's last fight would never have taken place."

Morrison refers to many of the principal warrior chiefs.

While Sitting Bull was the big chief and the ruling spirit over all the Indians, Crow King, Black Moon, Low Dog and Crazy Horse, along with many others, were to be feared. These Indians which Morrison speaks of are all mentioned in the history of Custer's last fight.

Morrison, or Deadwood Dick, and Texas Jack stayed together for some time. They went into Mexico in a prairie schooner, which they obtained by trading their ponies. They got one horse and a mule with the schooner for their ponies.

"The mule was a fast one," said Deadwood Dick, "and I entered him in a race. There was considerable money up and when the mule came out in the lead I cleaned up a lot of money. Texas Jack left me soon after that and I don't know what became of him. He was much older than I was. I guess he must be dead.

"I started to travel after he left me and I have been all over the country. I went back to Montana and got a lot of sheep. I was wealthy twice, was almost a millionaire once, and the second time I was worth more than $300,000.

"I married and had one child, a daughter. My wife died about a year after we were married. After my daughter was married I did not see very much of her. She died and I have some grandchildren living in New York state.

"Then I went to Deadwood, S. D., where I went into the mining business. I married again and my wife and I worked in the mine. She was killed by falling rock. I was struck in the head by another rock and badly hurt. Since that time I have not been able to remember very well. I cannot remember the dates of Custer's last fight, or many other things that were very interesting to me. I have had two farms, one in Montana and one in Dakota. I sold both of them and everything else I had and started to follow the races.

"My travels took me down into Texas; I don't remember the name of the place. It was a little town. I went into a saloon to inquire the shortest trail to a certain place. The place was filled with cowboys. One of them, whom I recognized as a tenderfoot, stepped up to me and asked me to drink with him.

"I told him that I had some business to attend to and I could not take the time. He told me that if I did not drink with him he would fix me. I was without arms, and I told him that I did not want any trouble. As I talked with him I recognized him to be a man by the name of Dave Leahy. I had known him in the east, and I remembered whipping him.

"I recalled the incident, and told him if he would come outside until I got my gun I would repeat what I gave him in the east.

"By this time his brother stepped up and placed a gun at the back of my head. I told the two men that I would fight them a duel. We got on our horses and started. I killed Dave after the second shot had been fired. I don't remember the brother's name, but he shot me in the left hand and I had to have it amputated. I killed him with the next shot. Texas was a small place then. The boys took up a collection for me, and I had almost $500.

"I then bought two race horses. I took the horses to all the big meets in the east and made good money with them. I brought them to Denver from St. Louis. Then I took them up to Cheyenne. When I came back to Denver some one stole the horses from me. One of them was worth $8,000, and the other I was offered $12,000 for. After I lost the horses I was practically broke and have been ever since."

"Deadwood Dick" has been in the county jail once before. He was sentenced to thirty days on a vagrancy charge, and his time expired last Saturday. He was arrested again Sunday and started his new sentence yesterday.

When arrested before he received a letter from a man in Colorado City asking if he was one of the scouts under General Custer. The man said in the letter that if he were he would give him something to do and see that he never wanted for anything. "Deadwood Dick" never answered the letter. In referring to it yesterday he said: "I have always been able to take care of myself, and although I am almost 80 years old, I will not live off any one. When I can't work I'll go to the poorhouse."

"Deadwood Dick" is also quite a poet, and the last verse of a composition he wrote in the jail yesterday reads as follows:

"The truth is I am old and discouraged, My clothing is seedy and poor, And the merchant, God knows I don't blame him, Refuses to trust me for more, But I'll pay the last cent and be honest; No mortal on earth will I rob; Then toddle away to the poor farm, The John Smiths will give me a job."

—Chicago Inter-Ocean.

See the clipping

Curley: ‘We’ll fight to the end’

In St. Louis Curley, called a halfbreed Sioux scout and the only survivor, says the lithograph of Custer’s Last Stand errs only in showing mutilation: ‘There was no scalping and no mutilation.’ He says Reno refused to come, that he found Custer fighting alone with his saber, and that Custer spoke his last words to him before a Sioux’s son shot him through the heart.

Wood County Reporter · Wisconsin Rapids, Wis. · and 5 other papers

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out. CorrectionThis set right an article from 5 days earlier.

Wood County Reporter · 16 October 1913 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

IN CUSTER BATTLE

"Curley the Crow" Tells How He Caught Heroic Soldier.

See moreSee less

Halfbreed Sioux Scout, Only Survivor of Massacre, Relates How Famous General Fell Dead in His Arms.

St. Louis.—Curley ("Curley the Crow"), the halfbreed Sioux scout, now in his seventy-second year, is the only survivor of the Custer massacre. At the Planters' hotel here he gave some interesting details, some of them new, of the battle of the Little Big Horn on June 24, 1876, in which Custer and practically all of his command perished.

A large lithograph of "Custer's Last Stand" represents the scene truly in all respects but one, Curley says.

"The artist should not have shown scalped and mutilated American soldiers on the battle field," Curley remarked. "There was no scalping and no mutilation. Four hundred and seventy-three soldiers were killed and not a mark was found on them that was not made by bullets.

"I was General Custer's scout. He and the other white men knew me as Curley. By some of the Indians I was called Bloody Knife. Though I was a scout for the army, I was in no danger from the Indians except the danger of being accidentally shot in battle. The Indians never purposely killed a scout. Spies they would kill, but not scouts. They respected scouts who could speak the Indians' language, too. I knew eleven Indian languages, and I could go from the white soldiers' camp to the Indians' and smoke the pipe with the chiefs.

"On the evening before the battle I ate with Rain-in-the-Face. He was my uncle, brother of my mother, who was a full-blooded Sioux. I knew Sitting Bull, but I ddi not see him just at that time. He was the high priest of the Sioux, not their leader in battle. He told me there would be a battle, and said I must keep out of it. I said I would stay with General Custer, no matter what the danger was.

"That night I was sent by Custer to summon Colonel Reno and Captain Bentine, with their commands, to reinforce him.

"I reached Reno first and he refused to go, saying he and his men could not get across the river. Had he started at that time he might have saved Custer. I afterward testified at the courtmartial which dismissed him from the service.

"I went on to Captain Bentine and he started his command at once. They crossed the same stream which Reno had been afraid to try and came in the morning to where a high hill separated them from Custer's men. I took one way over the hill and Bentine took what he thought was a shorter way. He did not reach the place, but his men, under subordinate officers, got there in time to perish with Custer's men.

"As I got on the other side of the hill I was in range of the Indians' guns. While I was still a long way off my horse was shot under me, and I got down and ran until I came into the thick of the fighting.

"As I got there I saw the soldiers were lying dead right and left. Those 473 had been surrounded by 6,000 Sioux. I saw Custer fighting with his saber, and I thought he was the last man alive there, but I soon saw that his brother, Lieut. "Tom" Custer, was fighting beside him. He fell and General Custer stood alone.

"The Indians could have killed him easily before that, but the purpose was to take him alive. The reason for that purpose is known to me, and I shall tell of it in a story I am going to write. Fourteen Indians whom he slashed and gashed with his saber lay near him, most of them dead or dying.

"Then I saw Rain-in-the-Face. He said harshly: 'Curley, I told you to keep out.'

"'I couldn't get away,' I replied; my horse was shot.'

"I called to General Custer, meaning to tell him of Reno's refusal to come, and he said: 'You here, Curley? We'll fight to the end.'

"Those were his last words. A big Sioux seized his arm and Custer turned on him and dealt a terrific saber stroke that half cut his head off. As he did this the son of the Sioux fired his rifle at Custer and the bullet went through his heart.

"In the familiar picture there is an Indian seen pushing his way through toward Custer as he fell. That man was myself. I held his head as he sank back dead."

See the clipping

← Back to Act Ten: Custer’s Last Fight