As the Papers Told It

Little Bighorn · The full archive

April 1923

49 articles

The Milwaukee Leader · Milwaukee, Wis.

A 100-year-old Grand Junction, Colorado man, Civil War veteran 'Uncle Billy' Hildreth, celebrated his birthday with local Elks and G.A.R. members. The article notes he claimed to have been two miles from the scene when the Custer massacre took place.

The Milwaukee Leader · 1 April 1923 · page 4

OLDEST ELK HAS BIRTHDAY PARTY; COMPLETES CENTURY

Indian wars and suffered only one wound, a slight bayonet cut on the wrist. He was two mile's from the scene of the Custer massacre when if took place and with Gen. Howard helped stem the tide of Nespenhas Indians down through Yellowstone park.

See the clipping

The Seattle Star · Seattle, Wash.

A 1923 birthday feature on 'Uncle Billy' Hildreth, said to be the oldest living Elk and Civil War veteran, mentions he claimed to have been two miles from the scene of the Custer massacre when it occurred. The article also notes his later service helping General Howard during the Nez Perce conflict in Yellowstone.

The Seattle Star · 2 April 1923 · page 8

OLDEST ELK IS 100 - Local Lodge Gives Him a Birthday Party

Indian wars and suffered only one wound, a slight bayonet cut on the wrist o was two miles from the scene of the Custer massacre when {lt took place and with Gen. Howard { helped stem the tide of Nespenhas In dians down thru Yellowstone park. “Unele Billy*” is hale and hearty for his age, but makes no predictions ax to how many more birthdays he'll

See the clipping

The Laramie Republican · Laramie, Wyo.

The Interior Department approved a pension for Curley, a Crow Indian scout who served with Custer, settling a half-century dispute over whether anyone survived the Little Bighorn battle on the army side. The War Department account states he escaped death by mingling with the attacking Indians and rejoined U.S. forces five days later.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day. CorrectionThis set right an article from 17 days earlier.

Wrong

The Laramie Republican · 3 April 1923 · page 1

(By Associated Press.) < Washington, April 3—The contro versy for a half century as to whether there was a survivor of the Custer massacre on the IJttle Big Horn, in Montana in 1876, has been settled of ficially. The interior department to day approved the issuance of a pen sion certificate to ShuhShee-Ahsh. alias Curley, a Crow Indian, for his services in the Indian campaigns of 1876 and 1877, which included parti cipation in the famous battle. Cur ley, who was one of (’lister’s scouts, now lives on the Crow Indian reser vation in Montana. According to the war department, he escaped death by mingling with the attacking Indians and rejoined the government forces nearby five days later.

See the clipping

The Montgomery Advertiser · Montgomery, Ala.

The Interior Department approved a pension certificate for Curley, a Crow Indian scout, officially settling a nearly 50-year dispute over whether any survivor existed from Custer's command at Little Bighorn. The certificate credits him with participation in the 1876 campaign including the famous battle.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Montgomery Advertiser · 4 April 1923 · page 2

■ — I* WASHINGTON A.pri! 3.—A contro ls versy of almost half a century aa. to whether there was a survivor of the Custer massacre at Little Big Horn, Iff Montana, June 26, 1376, haa been set tled officially. /, The Interior department has sp iff proved the Issuance of a pension cer Wtiflcate to Shuh-Shee-Ahsh, alias Cur f ley. a crow Indian, for his services In i the Indian campaigns of 1876 and 1877,1 If which Included participation In the j famous battle which resulted In the obliteration of Custers cavalry. i

See the clipping

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

The Interior Department announced it had located Curly, a Crow Indian scout who served under Custer, and awarded him a pension after he proved his service record. He is described as the sole survivor of the Custer massacre at Little Bighorn.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

Evening Star · 4 April 1923 · page 36

INDIAN SCOUT, SOLE SURVIVOR OF CUSTER'S BAND, A PENSIONER

TRY VOUI HAND. The Interior Department has locat ed a survivor of the Custer massacre, June 25. it was announced today. The survivor is Shuh-shee-ahsh, alias Curly, a Crow Indian, now living on the Crow Indian reservation in Montana, and he is drawing a pension from the government for his services |

See the clipping

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

The passage recounts a War Department account of the Crow scout Curly, who allegedly stayed with Custer's command during the June 25 attack on the Sioux village and escaped by mingling with Sioux and Cheyenne warriors before rejoining his unit on June 30. It calls him 'the only survivor of the Custer massacre.'

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 8 days later. CorrectionThis set right an article from the day before.

Wrong

Evening Star · 4 April 1923 · page 36

TRY VOUI HAND. ed in the attack on the Sioux village in the valley of the Little Big Horn June 25. "The morning of the 26th." the War Department reports, "three of the scouts who had been with Col. Custer were found. The fourth Crow, who left the field of Custer's fight, named Curly, was actually with Custer throughout the battle. He escaped !by mingling with the Sioux and I Cheyennes and rejoined his detach ; merit June 30." ! Curly is the only survivor of the (Custer massacre, I •___

See the clipping

The Washington Daily News · Washington, D.C.

The Interior Department announced that Curly, a Crow Indian scout, is drawing a government pension as the sole survivor of Custer's command at Little Bighorn. The report says he survived by mingling with the Indians during the battle in which Custer's entire command was killed.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 7 days later.

Wrong

The Washington Daily News · 4 April 1923 · page 11

LONE CUSTER SURVIVOR

Recent investigation revealed that ' Curly fought throughout the battle , of the Little Big Horn in 1876 when I Gen. Custer’s entire conrmand was : NEW )ORk STATE sOCITY MEETIG, 8:30 j). m. 1th and Kenyon streets nw. EASTERN HIGH SCHOOL, IKILNDSHI club. picnic. 3 p. m Great Falls

See the clipping

The Omaha Morning Bee · Omaha, Neb.

The Interior Department announced it had located and pensioned Curley, a Crow scout who served with Custer, long believed to have been the only man to survive the Little Bighorn massacre. War Department records confirmed he escaped detection by mingling with Sioux and Cheyenne warriors and rejoined his unit four days later.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 7 days later.

Wrong

The Omaha Morning Bee · 4 April 1923 · page 9

Washington, April 3.—A survivor of the famous Custer massacre, in which it was believed everyone was killed, has been unearthed and pen sioned, the Department of the Interior announced today’. He Is Hhuh-Shee-Ahsh. alias Curley, a Crow Indian living on a reserva tion in Montana, lie has satiefied the government that he was a scout with Colonel Custer at the time every man in his command was voted by the tribes of northern Cheyenne and the Sioux. With three other Indian scouts, Shuh-Shee-Ahsli went with Custer Into the battle of the Little Big Horn on June 23, 1876.

See moreSee less

On the morning following the battle, when soldiers sent to the relief of Custer surveyed the scene, they were able to account for every man except one of the scouts. A search of War department records reveals that this man, who could not be accounted for, was the Crow Indian now claiming a pension. “The fourth scout who left the field of Custer’s fight, named Curley, was actually’ with Custer throughout

See the clipping

The Laramie Republican · Laramie, Wyo.

The Interior Department approved a pension for Shuh-Shee-Ahsh, alias Curley, a Crow Indian scout who served with Custer, officially settling a 50-year debate over whether any survivor existed from the battle. The War Department stated he survived by mingling with the attacking Indians and rejoined U.S. forces five days later.

The Laramie Republican · 4 April 1923 · page 1

One Survivor Of Custer Massacre Drawing Pension (By Associated Preas.) Washington, April 3.—The contro versy for a half century as to whether there was a survivor of the Custer massacre on the Little Big Horn, in Montana in 1876, has been settled of ficially. The Interior department to day approved the issuance of a pen sion certificate to Shuh-Shee-Ahsh, alias Curley, a Crow Indian, for his services in the Indian campaigns of 1876 and 1877, which included parti cipation in the famous battle. Cur ley, who was one of Custer’s scouts, now lives on the Crow Indian reser vation in Montana. According to the war department, he escaped death by mingling with the attacking Indians and rejoined tho government forces nearby five days later.

See the clipping

The Wrangell Sentinel · Wrangell, Alaska

A Crow scout named Scou, discovered by the Pension Department living on a Montana reservation, is identified as a survivor of the Custer Massacre. The brief news item appears among other world news snippets in the Wrangell Sentinel.

The Wrangell Sentinel · 5 April 1923 · page 1

WASHINGTON — Scou, a survivor of the Custer Massacre, has been un earthed by the Pension Department. He is a Shuhsheeas Crow living on a reservation in Montana.

See the clipping

Seward Daily Gateway · Seward, Alaska

The Department of the Interior announced it had located and pensioned a survivor of the Custer massacre, identified as Shuh Sheeahsh, a Crow Indian living on a reservation in Montana. The brief item appeared decades after the 1876 battle, amid routine local news from Seward, Alaska.

Seward Daily Gateway · 5 April 1923 · page 1

WASHINGTON, Apr. 5.—A scout survivor of the Custer massacre has been unearthed and pensioned. The Department of the Interior, who was instrumental in securing his pension announces that he is Shuh Sheeahsh, a Crow Indian living on the reservation in Montana.

See the clipping

The Ronan Pioneer · Ronan, Mont.

This 1923 article profiles Colonel Gardner, an aging Montana scout who served with Custer, Reno, and later pursued Chief Joseph. He recounts frontier adventures including a nighttime escape from Fort Phil Kearny and the killing of a herder by Indians.

The Ronan Pioneer · 6 April 1923 · page 7

'the troops under Generals Sherman and Howard, in their pursuit of Chief Joseph through Yellowstone park at the time of Joseph's famous march j across Montana in the year following the Custer battle. He was a Reno and Custer Bcout. He is a personal friend of Daniel Beard, the national

See the clipping

South Bend News-Times · South Bend, Ind.

A newspaper retrospective column reminisces about events of 1876, noting that June 25, 1926 will mark the 50th anniversary of Custer's Last Fight at Little Bighorn. It claims the old controversy over survivors is settled, naming Crow scout Curly as the sole survivor of Custer's over-300-man force.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 2 days later. CorrectionThis set right 2 earlier articles: The Washington Daily News, 4 April 1923, The Omaha Morning Bee, 4 April 1923.

Wrong

South Bend News-Times · 11 April 1923 · page 6

BACK YONDER. Old-timers with good memories will look at the calendar .Tune 25. 1326, and say: "It’s Just 50 years since Custer's I>ast Fight took place on the Little Big Horn. Montana. Seems like yesterday.” The famous Custer Massacre is fading Into the long ago. But it lurks as the great dime-novel thrill of boyhood for millions of us. For nearly half a century a controversy has raged, whether there was a survivor of Custer's valiant cavalry. The controversy Is settled. Uncle Sam has found a survivor—Shuh-shee-ahsh. better known as Curly, a Crow Indian scout now on the pension list.

See moreSee less

More than 300 were wiped out on Custer's side. Curly, the only survivor, escaped by mingling with the attacking Indians until he was able to slip away. The Custer Massacre was Big Stuff 4 7 years ago. In the World war it would have attracted little attention. We do things on a bigger scale than our ancestors—everything, including killing. The leading events of 1 876 are interesting, by contrast, in 1 323. The Philadelphia Centennial took place that year. Pres’t Grant and Dom Perdo, visit ing emperor from Brazil, started the famous Corliss engine that set in motion the machinery of this world's fair with its 130 buildings. Other big events of 1 876: The first American cremation furnace was com ! pleted at Washington, Pa., body of Baron De Palm

See the clipping

The Carlisle Independent · Carlisle, Ark.

A syndicated humor piece from the Detroit News mocks the press habit of recycling superlative claims, noting how 'the sole survivor of the Custer massacre' periodically dies again. It lists this alongside other recurring false 'last of' and 'prettiest' claims as a harmless journalistic custom.

CorrectionThis set right an article from 8 days earlier.

The Carlisle Independent · 12 April 1923 · page 8

Few among us have achieved an obscurity in which we are not the youngest, the oldest, pretties'., tallest or smallest something or other some where. A few months ago Omaha picked her prettiest girl to represent her out of town, yet today we are informed that another lass of astonish’/ig beau ty has materialized and bee i dedg original little Eva died again a week ago, and now and then w« learn that the last of the captors of Jeff Davis has shuffled off once more. The last veteran of Scott’s Mexican expedition periodically passes on and the sole survivor of the Custer massacre g,Ves up the ghost. It is a pretty custom, and harmless. — Detroit News.

See the clipping

Springfield Weekly Republican · Springfield, Mass.

The U.S. Department of the Interior ruled that Curley, a Crow scout also known as Shuh-Shee Ahsh, was a survivor of Custer's Last Stand, settling a controversy nearly fifty years old. The finding was made official through approval of a pension certificate in his favor.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

Springfield Weekly Republican · 12 April 1923 · page 1

Custer massacre. Shuh-Shee Ahsh, alias Curley, a Crow Indian scout, the survivor, is still living and it is by the approval of the issue of a

See the clipping

Watauga Democrat · Boone, N.C.

The Department of the Interior's Pension Bureau has located Shuh-shee-ahsh, alias Curly, a Crow Indian scout, as the only surviving participant of Custer's final battle. He is now drawing a government pension after proving his service as an Indian scout under Custer during the 1876 campaign.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

Watauga Democrat · 12 April 1923 · page 6

last' SURVIVOR OF THE CUSTER MASSACRE FOUND. Washington, April 6. —The only survivor of the famous Custer Massacre has been found by the Department of the Interior through the Pension Bureau. He is Shuh-shee-ahsh, alias Cur ly, a Crow Indian now living on the Crow Indian Reservation in Mon tana, and he is drawing a pension I from the government for his serv -1 ices in the Indian campaigns of 1876 and 1877. Recent investigation of his case resulted in a pension certi ficate being issued in his favor after he presented proof that he was an Indian scout under Colonel Custer when he fought against the Northern Cheyenne and Sioux Indians.

See moreSee less

The official records of the War Department show that Shuh-shee ahsh, a Crow Indian, was enlisted as i a private April 10, 1876, at the Crow

See the clipping

Watauga Democrat · Boone, N.C.

This passage recounts the War Department's account of Curley, a Crow scout who allegedly stayed with Custer throughout the battle and escaped by disguising himself among the Sioux and Cheyenne. It notes he rejoined his unit on June 30, 1876, and is described as the only survivor of the 'Custer Massacre.'

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

Watauga Democrat · 12 April 1923 · page 6

RAINBOW CHASERS It is time to go a-fishing. So con sider the fisherman. There he is in his boat. Fish may be leaping out of the water behind him, but he will paddle to the far side of the stream or pond or lake before he throws in his lines. The fisherman always imagines the fishing must be better across the lake or farther upstream. Most of us are just like the fisher man. We are rainbow chasers, ob sessed with the idea that things must be much better at a distance.

See moreSee less

So the farm boy yearns for the city. And he city boy yearns for another town. An amateur wireless bug in New ark, N. J., writes to his local paper, and wants to know how he can pick up concerts from the Pacific Coast. On the Pacific Coast the wireless bug wants to pick up Newark. No matter how good may be the concerts that a radio bug hears from his own or nearby towns, he is for ever trying to pick up a concert from farther and farther away. After he gets everything in the United States, he wants to hear other countries’ sta tions. This craving for the distant is to some extent inherited from our nomadic ancestors who moved from place to place, seeking a location where they could live without workfamous long-tail coat carefully tailor-1 j ed in the height of fashion which j reigned in or around the Civil War times by Andrew Johnson, at the time ’ Governor of Tennessee, has been prej ' sented to the Tennessee Historical Commission, of which John Trot wood Moore is chairman for preserva tion. The hndsome coat, a gift to the State from W. W. Pepper, of Spring field, Tenn., was tailored by Johnson in 1852 and presented to Judge Pep per, Mr. Pepper’s father, then one of the Tennessee circuit judges, ac cording to Mr. Moore. Jackson’s career, which was con sidered most remarkable ranged from the tailor shop to the highest honor an American citizen can achieve, that of President of the United States, and afterwards serving as United States Senator from this state. Meanwhile ' his colleague rose from the anvil to the bench of justice. As the story goes, according to the historical records, when Johnson be came Governor, Judge Pepper laid aside his judical toga temporarily and reenterd the black smith shop, where he fashioned a shovel, poker and pair of tongs which he presented to the Chief Executive. Johnson not to be outdone, harked hack to his trade of old, selected a handsome piece of goods, and pat terned the fashionable coat in re ciprocation for the gift from the gen erous donor. .The coat, an heirloom in the Pep per family all these years, has been highly prized, and is said to be in a perfect state of preservation. It is double-breasted and handsomely built it is said. The little hut in which Andrew Johnson conducted his tailor business in Greeneville, Tenn., is still standing and a handsome museum building has been erected to shelter the little building and preserve it for all time. disturbances, six scouts were detach ed to accompany his command. They participated in the attack of the Sioux village in the valley of the Little Big Horn June 25. “On the morning of the 26th,” so the War Department reports, “three of the scouts who had been with Colonel Custer were found. The fourth Crow who> left the field of Custer’s fight, named Curley, was actually with Custer throughout the battle. He escaped by mingling with the Sioux and Cheyennes and re joined his detachment June 30." According to the records of the Crow Indian Agency, Montana, Curley was born in 1858, is married, served under Custer, and has the dis tinction of being the only survivor of the “Custer Massacre.”

See the clipping

The Ely Miner · Ely, Minn.

The Interior Department approved a pension certificate for Shuh-Shee-Ahs, alias Curly, a Crow Indian scout, settling a nearly 50-year dispute over whether any survivor of Custer's command existed. Curly had served in the 1876-77 Indian campaigns, including the Little Bighorn battle that destroyed Custer's cavalry.

CorrectionThis set right an article from the day before.

The Ely Miner · 13 April 1923 · page 6

Busy Readers. Washington Washington—Secretary of Labor J. J. Davis predicts continuing period of prosperity. Washington—American Credit asso ciation head says United States must play part in solution of European prob lems. Washington—Brigadier General A. G. Fries of chemical warfare section assailed by Women’s Peace league for calling its pledge “treason” and by council for prevention of war for charging it with communism. Washington—President Harding ex pected to approve sending fleet of 50 naval, submarine chasers after rum fleet off Atlantic coast as part of an aggressive prohibition enforcement campaign soon to be inaugurated.

See moreSee less

Washington—Senator Reed Smoot (rep., Utah) accuses sugar refiners of responsibility for higher prices; says they seek to destroy American sugar industry by lowering tariff. Washington—Naval officers do not believe President Harding will hold modernization of fleet to be violation of Washington naval treaty; see 5-5-3 ratio farcial United States does not keep up with Great Britain and Japan in capital ships improvement. Washington—A controversy of al most half a century as to whether there was a survivor of the Custer massacre at Little Big Horn, Mont., June 25, 1876, has been settled offi cially. The Interior department has approved the issuance of a pension certificate to Shuh-Shee Ahs, alias Cur ly, a Crow Indian, for his services in the Indian campaigns of 1876 and 1877 which included participation in the famous battle which resulted in the obliteration of Custer’s cavalry. Domestic Chicago—The blacksmith shop of the Pullman company, manufacturers of railroad coaches, virtually was de stroyed by fire, at an estimated loss between $200,000 and $300,000. New Yo k —Smashing the window cf Silverstein’s jewelry store on up per Broadway, two well dressed young men seized worth of jewelry and escaped in a taxicab. Superior, Wis.—The new 2,100-foot steel ore dock at Allouez, the largest of its kind in the •world, will be ready for operation by June 1, according to Great Northern officials. The total cost is expected to be about $3,000,- 000. Hot Springs, Ark. —One man was dead, two were injured, more than 300 persons are deprived of their per sonal effects, and the site of the Ar lington hotel, was a smoking ruin as a result of fire which destroyed the hostelry, the oldest in Hot Springs, with a loss which approaches $1,500,-

See the clipping

The Ronan Pioneer · Ronan, Mont.

This 1923 article profiles frontier figure 'Butch' Sturges, detailing his career in cattle driving, hunting, and government service. It notes that in 1876 he was with Major Reno's command during the Sioux's defeat of Custer at the Little Bighorn.

CorrectionThis set right an article from 2 days earlier.

The Ronan Pioneer · 13 April 1923 · page 9

He Was With Reno Sturges did not confine himself to the cattle game. He served the gov ernment in different capacities. On that eventful day when the Sioux In dians massacred General Custer and

See the clipping

The Kadoka Press and Kadoka Reporter · Kadoka, S.D.

The Interior Department approved a pension certificate for Curly (Shuh-Shee-Aha), a Crow Indian scout, settling a decades-long dispute over whether anyone survived Custer's last stand. The certificate recognized his service in the 1876-77 Indian campaigns, including the Little Bighorn battle.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 4 days later.

Wrong

The Kadoka Press and Kadoka Reporter · 13 April 1923 · page 6

Washington —A controversy of al most half a century as to whether there was a survivor of the Custer massacre at Little Big Horn, Mont., June 25, 1876, has been settled offi* daily. The Interior department has approved the issuance of a pension certificate to Shuh*Shee Aha, alias Cur ly, a Crow Indian, for his services in the Indian campaigns of 1876 and 187 T which included participation in the famous battle which resulted in the Obliteration of Custer’s cavalry.

See the clipping

Peninsula Enterprise · Accomac, Va.

This article recounts how several of Custer's relatives died alongside him at Little Bighorn, including his brothers Tom and Boston, brother-in-law Calhoun, and nephew Autie Reed. It repeats the legend that Rain-in-the-Face cut out and ate Tom Custer's heart in revenge for a prior grievance.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

Peninsula Enterprise · 14 April 1923 · page 14

RELATIVES DIED WITH CUSTER

Miss Bobwig—Do you favor free love, Mr. Hardfax? Mr. Hardfax—Not absolutely. I j don't mind standing for an occasional show and a supper, but nix on the orchids and diamonds. ! the summer af 1876, and In which, i besides Gan. George A. Custer, every man In hla command lost his life, sev eral near relatives of Custer were among the killed. With Ouster In that memorable fight was his brother, Oapt. Tam Custer, tha ealy man In the United States army who held two medals for capturing two flags with his own hands la tha Civil war.

See moreSee less

After tha battle the Meux chief, Raln-tn-the Faee, made good a previous threat and accomplished a terrible revenge for an eld grievance agalnat Captain Custer by setting open tha breast of the brave young eoldler and sating bis heart. Calhoun, a brother-in-law ef the general, was among the slain, as was Boston Custer, another brattier of the general, who was civilian for age master ef the Seventh cavalry, and Antis Bead, the general'* nephew —a mere bey, who wonted to see something ef life In the West, and whs had wslcetned with joy this op portunity to make th* campaign. LnrriM Barbarism*. I The use ef Greek or Latin roots I from which to form new words, re i qulred by the advauce of scientific ! knowledge, la almost universal among { learned men. On the whole the prsc j tlce le useful, but.it can be carried to ' absurdity. Dr. Brudenell Carter, tho I English oculist, In one of his books, ' pretests against doctors who air their ! supposed acquirements by coining hor 1 rlble verbal compounds that are usu | ally Intended to express Tory simple i conditions. i I hays, ho writes, seen dacryocysto syrlngokataklolsis used te express ob struction ef the tear duct, and arnphl blestreicltla to express inflammation of the retina of the eye. I once met a country cabinetmaker who built wood I en frames, covered with needlework, i to protect polished fenders against the j feet. He sought a name for his con j trlvance from the local schoolmaster, I who furnished him with antitribospo I dethecidlon and with a literal transla ■ tlon—an against-frictlon-of-the-ashes i receptacle!—Youth’s Companion. Animal Sees Itself In Mirror. | A mirror is one of the toys which riums. j monkeys delight to play with. All i animals can • see a reflection in a i glass, if It is held In the right posi I tlon, that is, at an angle at which their eyes can focus upon It. Even then, however, it may not recognize the image. The reflection has, it Is true, form, but it lacks other charac teristics. such as smell, and many beasts will turn away bored from what looks something like an animal, but obviously isn’t. On the other hand, another nnimnl will recognize the Image ns one of Its kind, and will exhibit »every symptom of curiosity, fesr, or hate. But in no case does the animal appear to recognize the reflection as that <>f itself. In our stock you will find The New IRON Age Potato Planters John Deere Manure Spreaders Full Line Deere Machinery Disc Harrows, Riding and Walking Plows

See the clipping

The Washington Times · Washington, D.C.

A literary column lists newly published books, including 'Pay Gravel' by Hugh Pendexter, a historical novel about the Black Hills gold rush set just after the Custer massacre. The bulk of the passage covers unrelated book reviews and the O. Henry Memorial Prize Stories awards.

The Washington Times · 15 April 1923 · page 56

by the Society of Arte and Science*. PAY GRAVEL. Hugh Pendexter. In dianapolis: Bobbs Merrill. |2.00. Historical novel of the gold rush tn the Black Hills Jost after the Custer massacre. THE TAIL OF THM HEMISPHERE. Chile and Argentina. Frank G. Car

See the clipping

Perth Amboy Evening News · Perth Amboy, N.J.

This article looks ahead to the 50th anniversary of Little Bighorn in 1926 and reports that the U.S. government has confirmed Curly, a Crow scout, as the only survivor of Custer's command, who escaped by mingling with the attackers. It also reflects on other major events of 1876 for historical comparison.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out. CorrectionThis set right an article from 4 days earlier.

Perth Amboy Evening News · 17 April 1923 · page 6

' V* on the pension list. More than 300 were wiped out on Custer’s side. Curly the only survivor, escaped by mingling with the attacking In dians until he was able to slip away. The Custer Massacre was Big Stuff forty-seven years ago.

See the clipping

Seward Daily Gateway · Seward, Alaska

A man identified as Lone Star Hands, described as chief scout under General Phil Sheridan and official War Department investigator into the Custer massacre, died in Omaha after falling down an elevator shaft. The report notes he had killed twenty-nine men, mostly Indians, during his service.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

Seward Daily Gateway · 18 April 1923 · page 1

OMAHA, Apr. 18—Lone Star Hands, chief scout under General Phil Sher idan and official investigator for the War department of the facts sur rounding the Custer massacre, was killed here today by falling down an elevator shaft in the Omaha World Herald plant. He had killed twenty nine men mostly Indians, during his period of_service.

See the clipping

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

A 1923 feature recounts the exploits of an aging scout named Hans, claiming he served as official War Department investigator of the Custer massacre and tracked Sitting Bull 600 miles. The piece also credits him with numerous gunfights and kills, presented as frontier legend decades after the events.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

Evening Star · 18 April 1923 · page 1

By the Associated Press. PARIS, April 18 —The civil wedding of Mrs. Louise O’Hara Murray, for merly of Washington, D. C.. and Georges Masdusheil de Colange, a French manufacturer belonging to an ancient Norman family, took place today in the town hall of the Six teenth Arrondissement. The religi ous ceremony will be celebrated to morrow In the American Church of the Holy Trinity. Dean Richard Dobbs will officiate. The bride was formerly Miss Louise Putnam Nicholson and about thirty vears ago had a career In grand opera in Paris, Berlin, St.

See moreSee less

Petersburg and Vienna. , , On her mother s side she is a direct descendant of Daniel Boone and through her father is related to Gen. Nicholson of civil war fame. Her op eratic career was cut short by im pairment of her voice. bandits April 12, 1877, near Valentine, Neb. Shot five Indians In battle of Little Missouri, near Black Hills, August 21, 1877, saving the lives of a party of twenty prospectors. Killed eleven Indians with twelve shots, using both guns, hammer fan ning, In the battle of Wounded Knee, S. D.. In 1892. Killed bandit, Ainsworth, Neb., In 1878. Shot and killed bandit at Fremont. Neb., in 1897. Trailed Sitting Ball. Was official War Department In vestigator of Custer massacre, and followed Sitting Bull 600 miles on horseback, inducing him and his band to return to the reservation. Was present at Sitting Bull's death. 1 Was chief scoutmaster for Gen. Phil Sheridan for six years. Was chief special agent of the Northwestern railroad for years. In all, Hans was credited with hav ing killed eight white men and twenty Indians. “1 was never beaten on the draw,” he often declared. Until a month ago Hans wore a scalp lock eighteen inches long, which he kept curled under a skull cap as he sat around in the Herald editorial rooms at night, often displaying his skill with his two guns to reporters and visitors. "No ope is after It now," he ex plained when he ordered his lock cut oft.

See the clipping

The Bismarck Tribune · Bismarck, N.D.

This 1923 article reports the death of veteran plainsman 'Lone Star' Hans, killed in an elevator accident at the Omaha World-Herald building. It recounts his legendary exploits, including claims that he served as the official War Department investigator of Custer's massacre and tracked Sitting Bull for 600 miles.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

The Bismarck Tribune · 18 April 1923 · page 1

Hills, Aug. 21, 1877. Saving the lives of a party of 20 prospectors. Killed 11 Indians with 12 shots, using both guns, hammer-fanning in the Battle of Wounded Knee in South Dakota in 1800. At Sitting Bull’s Death. Killed bandit at Ainsworth, Neb raska, in 1878. Shot and killed u bandit at Fremont, Neb., in 1897. Was official War Department investiga tor of Custer's massacre and fol lowed Sitting Bull 600 miles on horse-back inducing him and his band to return to the reservation. Was present at Sitting Bull's death. Was chief scout master for Gen eral Phil Sheridan for several years.

See moreSee less

Was chief special agent for the Northwestern railroad for years. “I was never beaten on the draw," he often declared. Until a month ago Hans wore a scalp lock 18 inches long, which lie kept curled under a skull cap as he sat around in the Herald editorial rooms' at night, often displaying his skill with his two guns to reporters and visitors. “No one is pftcr it now/' he ex claimed when he order his lock cut off.

See the clipping

San Antonio Light · San Antonio, Tex.

The report recounts the death of Fred M. Hans, an elderly Omaha nightwatchman and former frontier gunfighter, who was crushed in an elevator shaft. It recalls his legendary exploits, including investigating the Custer massacre and witnessing Sitting Bull's death.

San Antonio Light · 18 April 1923 · page 17

THE SAN ANTONIO LIGHT. “LONE STAR” HANS, SLAYER OF 28, NEVER BEATEN AT DRAW, DIES WITH BOOTS ON Gray-haired Old Man Who Investigated Custer Mas sacre and Saw Sitting Bull Die Is Crushed to Death in Elevator Shaft —Once Saved Twenty Prospectors by Shooting Five Indians. vestigator of the Custer massacre, and By the Aaaoeiaied Omaha. Neb., April 18.—. ighting. followed Sitting Bull 600 miles on smiling, gray-haired old “Lone Star” horseback, inducing him and his band Fred M. Hans, Indian fighter, fron to return to the reservation. tier scout nnd the last of the real At Sitting Bull's Death.

See moreSee less

two-gun “cross-arm draw” experts, Was present at Sitting Bull's death. met death here last night with “bis Was chief scoutmaster for Gen. Phil boots on.” a? he hnd often desired. Sheridan for six years. But death did not come on the field Was chief special agent for the of battle, where he bad so often faced Northwestern railroad for four years. it, nor on the wings of a bullet. He In all. Hans wa» credited with hav was crushed to death in an elevator ing killed eight white men and twenty shaft of the Omaha World-Herald Indians. plant, where he was nightwatchman. “I was never beaten on the draw," “Lone Star” was caught by the ele he often declared. vator shaft when he attempted to Until a month ago, Hans wore a move the control lever from the out scalp lock eighteen inches long, which side. and the lift suddenly shot up he kept under a skull cap as he sat ward. The old veteran tried to leap aronnd in the Herald editorial rooms into it, but his feet, that so often at night, often displaying his skill had leaped on the backs of mustangs, with his two guns to reporters and had lost their old spring, and so "Lone visitors. Star” died with his boots on. IXt Home at 18. Screen Doors, Frames, Wire, Hard He developed the “cross-arm draw” ware Fixtures and Paint. ED until he was without a peer, and this STEVES A SONS. Lumber and Building Store, 710 E. Commerce St. skill he retained even in his old Phone Crockett 167. (Adv.) age. He never touched a trigger, but usc<phis thumb to revolve the hammer of his Colt single-action revolver. In a fan-like action. He often declared that he could fire his single-action Colt six times before any one armed with a modern automatic pistol could fire half that many shots. Lone Star broke into fame first in on the sea.

See the clipping

San Antonio Light · San Antonio, Tex.

The piece recounts the exaggerated exploits of gunfighter 'Lone Star' Hans, including claims he served as an official War Department investigator of the Custer massacre and tracked Sitting Bull. It lists numerous gunfights and killings attributed to him, mixing frontier legend with dubious historical claims.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

San Antonio Light · 18 April 1923 · page 17

THE SAN ANTONIO LIGHT. vestigator of the Custer massacre, and followed Sitting Bull 600 miles on horseback, inducing him and his band to return to the reservation. At Sitting Bull's Death. Was present at Sitting Bull's death. Was chief scoutmaster for Gen. Phil on the sea. Sheridan for six years. Was chief special agent for the Northwestern railroad for four years. In all. Hans wa» credited with hav ing killed eight white men and twenty Indians. “I was never beaten on the draw," he often declared. Until a month ago, Hans wore a scalp lock eighteen inches long, which he kept under a skull cap as he sat aronnd in the Herald editorial rooms at night, often displaying his skill with his two guns to reporters and visitors.

See moreSee less

Screen Doors, Frames, Wire, Hard ware Fixtures and Paint. ED STEVES A SONS. Lumber and Building Store, 710 E. Commerce St. Phone Crockett 167. (Adv.)

See the clipping

The Elkins Inter-Mountain · Elkins, W. Va.

A 1923 obituary describes an aging frontier scout who died as a night watchman, crushed in an elevator shaft, recounting his supposed exploits battling outlaws and Indians. It claims he served as the War Department's official investigator of the Custer massacre and tracked Sitting Bull for 800 miles.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

The Elkins Inter-Mountain · 18 April 1923 · page 1

broke into fame first in 1870 in I the "Hole in the Wall Country,” I Fonder Hirer, W'yo., when, sin gle handed, he shot and killed three bandits. Other high spots were: Simt and killed two bandits April I?. 1877. near Valentine, Neb. / Shot live Indians in battle of l.itlle Missouri near Itlurk Hills, August 21, 1877. saving lives of a party of 20 prospectors. Killed eleven Indians with twelve shots, using both guns, in i (lie battle of Wounded Knee, ‘ South Dakota, in 1802. * Killed bandit, Ainsworth, Ne >braska.

See moreSee less

in 1878. Shot and killed bandit at Free man!, Neb., in 1807. Was otficial War Department investigator of Custer massacre i and followed Sitting Hull 800 ■ miles on horseback inducing him | and his band to return to reser- ; vat ions. Was chief scoutmaster for (ien. Fliil Sheridan for six years. Was chief special agent of the Northwestern liailroad four years. In all Mans was credited with having killed eight while men and 20 Indians.

See the clipping

The Omaha Morning Bee · Omaha, Neb.

Fred Hans, known as 'Lone Star' and billed as a survivor of Custer's last stand, died after being crushed between floors by an elevator while working as a night watchman in Omaha. The obituary recounts his colorful frontier exploits, including gunfights with bandits and outlaws, and notes no inquest will be held.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day. CorrectionThis set right 2 earlier articles: The Bismarck Tribune, 18 April 1923, San Antonio Light, 18 April 1923.

Wrong

The Omaha Morning Bee · 19 April 1923 · page 3

Hero of Many Bandit Encounters Is Killed / "Lone Star" Fred Hans Dies in Lift Accident / Old Indian Fighter Crushed to Death by Elevator—No Inquest.

Hans was a night watchman and ■ elevator conductor in the building, | and lived in a shack in the vicinity j of 1504 South Sixty-second street. He i was divorced. Hans was one of the accredited survivors of the famous Custer ‘‘last j stand,” in Montana. lie appeared In Omaha police court more than a year ago to identify two bandits who held up "Dad's” place, on the West Q road. He had been a picturesque figure In the life of Sarpy county for years. 1 He had roamed the western plains ' since he was 16.

See moreSee less

Hans had a long line of desperate hand-to hand encounters w ith bandits and Indians to his credit, and al though slowed up a trifle by age, re cently demonstrated that he could "fan” a hammer six times faster than an automatic pistol can shoot. In 1877, in Cherry county, he shot and killed two stage bandits, both of whom had the draw on him, by a lightning "cross-arm” draw for which he was famous. The year previous he broke up a gang of bandits in the “Hole-ln-thc Wall” country near Powder River, Wyo.. single handed, and killed

See the clipping

The Bismarck Tribune · Bismarck, N.D.

This 1923 editorial reflects on the upcoming 50th anniversary of Custer's Last Stand, noting that the controversy over survivors has been settled with the pension listing of Crow scout Curly, said to be the only survivor who escaped by mingling with attacking Indians. It also surveys other notable events of 1876 for historical contrast.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day. CorrectionThis set right an article from the day before.

Wrong

The Bismarck Tribune · 19 April 1923 · page 4

HACK YONDER Old-timers with good memories will look at the calendar (une 25, 1926, and say: “It’s just 50 years since Custer’s East. Fight took place on the Little Big Horn, Montana, iccffis like vesterdav. ' The famous Custer Massacre is fading into the long ago. hit it lurks as the great dime-novel thrill of boyhood for nillions of us. For nearly half a century a controversy has raged, /.hother there was a survivor of Custer’s valiant cavalry. The controversy is settled. Uncle Sam has found a survivor - Shuh-shee-ahsh, better known as Curly, a Crow Indian :cout now on the pension list.

See moreSee less

More than 200 were wiped out on Custer’s side. Curly, the only survivor, escaped by mingling with the attacking Indians until he was able to slip away. The Custer Massacre was Big Stuff 'l7 years ago. In the World War it would have attracted little attention. We do things on a bigger scale than our ancestors —everything, including killing. The leading events of 1876 are interesting, by contrast, in 1922. The Philadelphia Centennial took place that year. President Grant and Don Pedro, visiting emperor from Bra zil, started the famous Corliss engine that set in motion the machinery of this world’s fair with its 190 buildings. Other big events of 1876 The first American cremation furnace was completed at Washington, Pa., body of Baron De Palm being the first “job.” Elections were actually taken seriously. Grant had to declare South Carolina in a state of insurrection and send “regulars” there to preserve the peace at the elections. Feeling generally ran so high that soldiers were distributed til through the south and in New York City and Washington, f). C. The Tilden-Hayes dispute. Over 200 were killed in the stampede at the lire in the Brooklyn G\ T . Y.) Theater during a performance of “The Two trphans.” Colorado was admitted to the Union The president’s secretary was placed on trial for com plicity in the great whisky frauds. Acquitted. The I>rohi hilion Reform Party held a convention in Cleveland, norni listing (ireen Clay Smith of Kentucky for president. President Grant vetoed a bill reducing his salary to .$25,000. Edward Duhufe’s celebrated painting, “The Prodigal Son,” valued at SIOO,OOO was destroyed at the burning of Melodeon Hall, Cincinnati. Any one of these lead events of 1876, occurring in 1023, would keep people talking for months. We’re still interested basically in the same old things, though we do the things in different ways.

See the clipping

The Elkins Inter-Mountain · Elkins, W. Va.

An aging plains scout and gunfighter died in an elevator accident at an Omaha newspaper plant, where he worked as night watchman. His obituary recounts a colorful, embellished career including claims of serving as an official War Department investigator of the Custer massacre and tracking Sitting Bull.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out. CorrectionThis set right an article from the day before.

The Elkins Inter-Mountain · 19 April 1923 · page 3

hrehe inlo fame llrsl in 1 H7(> in I he “Hole in Ilic’Wall Country,” 1‘owder Itlver, Wyn., when, sin gle handed, he shot and hilled three handils. Ollier high spols were: Shot and hilled two handils April I2, 1877. near Valentine, N’eh. Nliiil live Indians in liallle of l.iltlr Missouri near Iflack Hills, August 21, IK77, saving lives of a parly of 211 prospectors. Hilled eleven Indians with twelve shots, using liolh guns, in the liallle of Wounded linee, South Haliola, in 1893. Killed bandit, Ainsworth, Ne braska, in 1878. Shot and hilled bandit at I'ree inonl, Nch., in IK!>7.

See moreSee less

Was ollicial War Department investigator of Custer massacre and followed Silling Hull lift!) miles on horseback inducing him and his hand to return to reser vations. Was chief scoutmaster for lien. I’liil Sheridan for six yiucfs. Was chief special agent-tf the Northwestern Kailroapr four years. / III all linns was credited with Lhaviug killed eight (white men land 20 Indians, Statistics just given out show th along the 1.la7 prisoners admitted ing Sing last year, not one is a pr 'ssioiuii man. The Massaeliustees house has jeeted a hill to inutile motor Unit e gines.

See the clipping

In the story →

The Browning Review · Browning, Mont. · and 2 other papers

The Interior Department approved a pension certificate for Shuh-Shee-Ahsh, alias Curley, a Crow Indian scout who served in the 1876-77 Indian campaigns including the Battle of Little Bighorn. The article states he survived Custer's last stand by mingling with the attacking Indians and rejoining government forces five days later, settling a decades-old controversy about survivors of the massacre.

The Browning Review · 20 April 1923 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

CURLY'S PENSION BACKS CUSTER SURVIVAL TALE

Washington.—A controversy of almost half a century, as to whether there was a survivor of the Custer massacre at Little Big Horn, Mont., June 25, 1876, has been settled officially. The interior department has approved the issuance of a pension certificate to Shuh-Shee-Ahsh, alias Curley, a Crow Indian, for his services in the Indian campaigns in 1876 and 1877, which included participation in the famous battle which resulted in the obliteration of Custer's cavalry.

See moreSee less

Curly, who was one of Custer's scouts, now lives on the Crow Indian reservation in Montana. According to war department records he escaped death by mingling with the attacking Indians and rejoined government forces nearby, five days later.

See the clipping

Also printed in 2 papers
  • The Cody Enterprise · Cody, Wyo. · 11 April 1923
  • Belt Valley Times · Armington, Mont. · 12 April 1923

The Ronan Pioneer · Ronan, Mont.

The article recounts Henry Frith's frontier experiences, including an Indian raid near Huntley and his later army service. It notes he was rushed to Montana with his company when news of the Custer massacre arrived, and he took part in the subsequent campaign against the Indians.

CorrectionThis set right an article from the day before.

The Ronan Pioneer · 20 April 1923 · page 2

ROHAN PIONEER stock stolen on the raid. Though giving the settlers much alarm, the Indians confined their operations to stealing. It was also Mr. Frith’s last experience with war-like In dians, for soon thereafter he set tled down to farming and mercan tile pursuits. He spent many years as a mem ber of the United States army in its campaigns against the western In dians. He served in the field in 1873-74 under General McKenzie In 1875 he was under General Greeley of Arctic exploration fame, as a member of the Eleventh in fantry.

See moreSee less

With his company he was rushed to Montana when news of the Custer massacre was received, and he took an active part in the campaign against the Indians that followed that catastrophe. He was at Standing Rock agency in the winter of 1876-77. His regiment participated in the disarming of the Sioux and in 1877 moved to the Yellowstone valley and established Forts Keogh and Custer, the latter long ago aban doned. He,participated in the battle with - We guarantee you for all eggs received by us up to and in cluding April 31, 1923, unless countermanded— Why not ship your next can of cream to us and compare our returns? We say every cream pro ducer, no matter how small, should become a dir ect shipper. Don’t sell your cream to cream sta tions. Ship direct and get the benefit of the sta tion commission and overhead expense. months hence. o time of the year.”

See the clipping

The Ronan Pioneer · Ronan, Mont.

A pioneer named Fontaine, writing to a friend in 1923, recounts his days as a government packer during the Sioux campaigns, describing an 1875 peace commission involving Red Cloud, Spotted Tail, Sitting Bull, and Crazy Horse. He also defends Major Reno, saying the major's conduct during the Little Bighorn fight was misunderstood by critics.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Ronan Pioneer · 20 April 1923 · page 9

the same fate as Custer and his men had not the officer possessed the wisdom of withdrawing before retreat was impossible. The recollec tions of this pioneer credit Reno with having accomplished some hard fighting and moreover, that the major had been made the victim of mis understandings concerning his conduct while the fight was in progress. Mr. Fontaine recounts the days of< Indian campaigning in a letter to Wil liard R. Booth of Fort Benton, an old friend of the writer. The experi ences of Mr. Fontaine as related by him follows: When the United States was having trouble with the Sioux Indians, 1 was a t Walla Walla.

See moreSee less

Washington, working for the railroad company. The government wanted to hire pack ers and I went to Wyoming and hired to the government, I started from the Dalles, Oregon, going to Umatilla, there taking the stage, traveling day and night for seven days until I land ed at Kelton, Utah. We slept on the stage. From Kelton, went to Chey enne by train. I left the latter part of August, 1875. They had a peace commission to try to settle this trouble between the Sioux Indians and the United States. It was held at Red Cloud agency, Dakota or Camp Brown. Sitting Bull at this time had never been in a pow wow with the whites. At this time he came in to have a pow wow. There were Red Cloud, Spotted Tail, Ameri can Horse, Sitting Bull and CrazyHorse. I never blamed the Sioux Indians for not wanting to give up their country, it was their “happy hunting ground"—buffalo, antelope, deer and elk in the mountains in great quan tities and trout in the streams. I will tell you something about the circumstances: Frank Gurard was captured on the Missouri river and was held prisoner for 12 years. At the time he was captured, he was car rying mail for the government. When Sitting Bull came into the peace com mission, he brought Frank Gurard with him. While they were in this pow wow, Gurard was sent out with the horses. He came to the conclu sion that he would take three of the best horses that Sitting Bull had and come to Fort Laramie. He told them who he was. At this time the peace commission was in session, and they probably didn't miss Gurard until he was in Fort Laramie. Had it not been for Red Cloud, some people think the Indians would have massacred the peace commis sion. Red Cloud was a friend of the whites and wanted the Indians to settle their troubles at this time. The peace commission induced Sitting Red Cloud, Sioux Chieftain Bull to send some of his warriors to Washington, D. C., to talk with the “Big Father.” A few of them went. When they got there they were tak en around and entertained in hopes

See the clipping

The Ronan Pioneer · Ronan, Mont.

A veteran recounts pre-war history: Frank Grouard's capture and escape from Sitting Bull, the peace commission's failed negotiations, and General Crook's winter 1875-76 preparations for the campaign. The account blends personal memory with Indian oral testimony about the delegation's trip to Washington.

The Ronan Pioneer · 20 April 1923 · page 9

try, it was their “happy hunting ground"—buffalo, antelope, deer and elk in the mountains in great quan tities and trout in the streams. I will tell you something about the circumstances: Frank Gurard was captured on the Missouri river and was held prisoner for 12 years. At the time he was captured, he was car rying mail for the government. When Sitting Bull came into the peace com mission, he brought Frank Gurard with him. While they were in this pow wow, Gurard was sent out with the horses. He came to the conclu sion that he would take three of the best horses that Sitting Bull had and come to Fort Laramie.

See moreSee less

He told them who he was. At this time the peace commission was in session, and they probably didn't miss Gurard until he was in Fort Laramie. Had it not been for Red Cloud, some people think the Indians would have massacred the peace commis sion. Red Cloud was a friend of the whites and wanted the Indians to settle their troubles at this time. The peace commission induced Sitting Red Cloud, Sioux Chieftain Bull to send some of his warriors to Washington, D. C., to talk with the “Big Father.” A few of them went. When they got there they were tak en around and entertained in hopes that there would be some way of making peace. When they returned, they reported to Sitting Bull. They sain: “White people cannot fight.” They said: “Hi-U-Boston —they can’t fight—they haven't any guns.” Consequently their visit to Washing ton did not do any good. In the meantime General Crook was fixing aparajos and getting ready for the Indian war. They were fixing these riggins and getting materials together at Camp Carling that winter, the winter of '75-'76. AH winter we packed provisions and forage to Fort Laramie at the same time we were breaking the mules and getting ready for that campaign. It was a very rough winter and we lived on the road. In the spring of '76, in March, we started out with the pack train and 300 wagons. We left Fort Fetterman somewhere about the first of March, the weather being fine. We traveled several days and came to old Fort Reno on Powder river. The first evening we were attacked by the In dians. This is the first time I ever heard a bullet whistle over my head. The Indians tried to stampede our mules, but failed. There is one little incident that I will tell you about. There was an of ficer who was shot in the cheek, the bullet going in one cheek and coming out the other and never touching a tooth. Outside of that, there was no casualties. Traveled at Night We went on from there, getting to Wind river mountains and went into Old Fort Phil Kearney—this was an abandoned fort. We traveled north until we came to a camp near the Wind river mountains on Trout creek. The Indians had been follow ing us all the time, trying to stam pede our stock, so General Crook made up his mind to leave the wagons and try to get away from the Indians. We left the wagons and went out in the night, dumbing the bells and went out very quietly and got away from the Indians.

See the clipping

Rock Springs Miner · Rock Springs, Wyo.

The Interior Department approved a pension for Curley, a Crow Indian scout, settling a half-century debate over whether anyone survived Custer's final stand at Little Bighorn. The report claims he escaped death by disguising himself among the attacking Sioux and Cheyenne before rejoining army forces five days later.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 6 days later. CorrectionThis set right an article from the day before.

Wrong

Rock Springs Miner · 20 April 1923 · page 6

♦ ONB SURVIVOR OF CUBTBR MABBACRB DRAWING PBNSION The controversy tor a halt century as to whether there was a survivor ot ths Custer massacre on the Little Big Horn, tn Montana in 1878, has been nettled officially. The Interior de partment has approved the teeuace ot a penaton certificate to Bhuh-BbeeAbeh, alias Curley, a Crow Indian, tor his services In the Indian cam paigns ot 187* and 1177, which in cluded participation In the famous battle. Curley, who wa. one ot Cus ter’s scouts, now lives on the Crow Indian reoervaMon in Montana. Ac cording to the war department, ho eocapod odnth iby mingtlng with the attaching Indiana and rejoined the government force. neadby five days later. * PATS FOBTT-FIVB CBNTB

See the clipping

The Nenana News · Nenana, Alaska

The report announces the death of Fred "Lone Star" Hans, a former chief scout for General Sheridan, who died in an elevator accident in Omaha. It claims he was the official war department investigator of the Custer massacre and had killed 14 Indians among a score of men in gunfights.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Nenana News · 21 April 1923 · page 2

OLD SCOUT PASSES

the last of “two pun arm®draw” ex perts, died here night before last as the result of being crushed be neath an elevator at the plant where he was employed as watchman. He had never been beaten in the “draw” and was credited with kill ing a score of men, of whom 14 were Indians. He was official in vestigator of the Custer massacre for the war department.

See the clipping

Atlanta Tri-Weekly Journal · Atlanta, Ga.

The article recounts the colorful career of an old scout nicknamed 'Lone Star' or 'Hans,' claiming he served as official war department investigator of the Custer massacre and tracked Sitting Bull 600 miles to the reservation. It lists his supposed gunfights, killings, and presence at Sitting Bull's death, framing him as a legendary Old West figure.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

Atlanta Tri-Weekly Journal · 21 April 1923 · page 3

AUGUSTA, Ga., April 18.—Dr. R. D. J. Griffith, of New York City, is in Augusta to organize a local club in the “Ford for President” league. Similar clubs have been formed in Macon, Savannah and Charleston, and Dr. Griffith will go from here to Charotte, N. C., to orgnaize a club in that city. hammer fanning that won the un equal fight. The Indians dubbed him WeChach-Pe-Wan-Ge-La, which, trans lated, means “Lone Star.” Hans was official war department investigator of the Custer massacre, and followed Sitting Bull six hun dred miles on horseback, inducing him and his band to return to the reservation.

See moreSee less

In all, Hans was credited with having killed eight white men and twenty Indians. Other high spots of Hans’ life were: Shot and killed two stage coach bandits April 12, 1877, near Valen tine, Neb. • Shot five Indians in a battle at Little Missouri, near Blackhills, Au gust 21, 1877, saving the lives of a party of twenty prospectors. Killed eleven Indians with twelve shots, using both guns, hammer fanning, in the battle of Wounded Knee, S. D., 1892. Killed bandit at Fremont, Neb., in 1897. Probed Custer Massacre Was official war department In vestigator of Custer massacre, and followed Sitting Bull 600 miles on horseback, inducing him and his band to return to the reservation. Was present at Sitting Bull’s death. Was chief scoutmaster for Gen eral Phil Sheridan for six years. Was chief special agent of the Northwestern railroad for years. “It was never beaten on the draw,” he often declared. Until a month ago Hans wore a scalp lock 18 inches long, -which he kept curled under a skull c?rp as he sat around in the Herald edi torial rooms at night, often display ing his skill with his two guns to reporters and visitors. “No one is after it now,” he ex plained when he ordered his lock cut off.

See the clipping

The Omaha Morning Bee · Omaha, Neb.

The funeral of Fred 'Lone Star' Hans, a former Indian scout killed by an elevator accident, included a eulogy noting he was among the first to reach the Custer massacre site. The minister repeated Hans' claim that Custer committed suicide rather than being killed by Indians, reasoning that Indians did not mutilate the bodies of suicides.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 5 days later.

Wrong

The Omaha Morning Bee · 21 April 1923 · page 2

er lor 18 years. ’ Itev. Mr. Savidge declared that j Hans was one of the first men to come upon the scene of the Custer massacre, and said It was Hans' opinion that Custer was pot killed by tha Indians, but that he committed suicide, for the reason that his body I was not mutilated The Indians, he said, never mutilated the body of a man who committed suicide Mrs C. K. Brinkman sang ' Some where the Sun Is Shining ' and at the closing of the services, "Nearer. My Ood, to Thee ." Burial was In West I.*wn cemetery.

See the clipping

Yorkville Enquirer · Yorkville, S.C.

This article recounts the life of frontier gunfighter Hans, listing killings of bandits and Indians across decades, and claims he was official war department investigator of the Custer massacre. It describes his pursuit of Sitting Bull and presence at his death, alongside tales of gunfighting prowess.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 4 days later.

Wrong

Yorkville Enquirer · 24 April 1923 · page 7

Shot - and killed bandit at Fremont, -Neb., in 1897. s- . • ■ ; Was; official war -department inves tigator. of Custer massacre, and fol lowed Sitting Bull six hundred miles on liorsfe-back, inducing him and his band to return to the reservation. Was present at Sitting' Bull’s death. Was chief scout master for General Phil Sheridan for six years. Was chief special agent of the Northwestern Railroad for years. In all,’ Hans was credited with, hav ing killed eight whtto men and twenty Indians. "I was never beaten -on the draw/’ lie often declared.

See moreSee less

Until a month' ago Hans wore a scalp-lock eighteen inches long which he.kept curled under-a skull cap as he sat-around in the Herald editorial, rooms at.. night, often displaying ,liia skill with his twp guns to reporters and visitors. • , \ ‘‘No one is after fJt flow,”; he ex-; plained, when he .ordered-his lock cut off. -jV ‘f-Only half the number of babies to day die after the first month, compared with infant mortality 16 or 20 . years ago. During the first month four per cent, of all infants die, just as they, did ,ln ‘ years past. Life insurance statis tics show that it is easier to survive, a year at the age of 65 than for a new "Some time ago, I was very irregular," writes Mrs. Cora Roble, of Pikeville, Ky, “l suffered a great deal, and knew. I must do something for this condition, 1 suffered mostly back and a weakness in 1 would have dread* leadaches. 1 had hot flashes and very queer feelings, and Oh. how my head hurt! 1 read of

See the clipping

The Seattle Star · Seattle, Wash.

A 'Those Days Back Yonder' column anticipates the 50th anniversary of Custer's Last Stand and claims a long-standing controversy over survivors has been settled by the discovery of Curly, a Crow scout, as the lone survivor. The piece also lists other notable events of 1876 for historical contrast.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 2 days later.

Wrong

The Seattle Star · 24 April 1923 · page 8

8 Published Dally by The Star Publishing Ce. PFhone Maln 0800 New paper Bnterprise Association and United Press Bervice. Ny mall, sut of wity, 800 per month: 3 menths 11 50; & months, §1.00; year, $l5B. Wy Marrier, oity, e a menth Gllman, Nieoil A Ruthman, #pecial Representatives. Ban Francisce of fioe, Monadnock bidg.: Chicage office, Tribune bidg . New York eoffios, Dasadian Pacific bidg.: Bostoa eoffice. Trewent dldg : Those Days Back Yonder ~ Old-timers with good memories will look at the calen ‘dar June 25, 1926, and say: “It's just 50 years since Custer's last fight took place on the Little Big Horn, ‘Montana.

See moreSee less

Seems like yesterday.” ~ The famous Custer massacre is fading into the long ago. But it works as the great dime-novel thrill of boy ‘hood for millions of us. ~ For nearly half a century a controversy has raged, }}"hether there was a survivor of Custer's valiant cavalry. ‘The controversy is settled. Uncle Sam has found a sur —Shuh-shee-ahsh, better known as Curly, a Crow In scout now on the pension list, _ More than 300 were wiped out on Custer's side. Curly, ‘the only survivor, escaped by mingling with the attacking ‘lndians until he was able to slip away. " The leading events of 1876 are interesting, by contrast, ‘in 1923. The Philadelphia Centennial took place that year, ‘President Grant and Dom Pedro, visiting emperor from ‘Brazil, started the famous Corliss engine that set in “motion the machinery of this world's fair with its 190 buildings ~ Other big events of 1876: ~ The first American cremation furnace was completed

See the clipping

The Frontier · O'Neill City, Neb.

The report describes the death of "Lone Star," a night watchman crushed in an elevator shaft, and recounts a string of legendary gunfights and heroics attributed to him. Among the claims is that he served as an official War Department investigator of the Custer massacre and personally tracked Sitting Bull for 600 miles.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 2 days later.

Wrong

The Frontier · 26 April 1923 · page 6

FAMOUS OLD INDIAN FIGHTER DIES IN ACCIDENT Omaha, Neb., April . '—-Fighting, smiling, gray haired old "Lone Star,” 'Fred M.) Hans, Indian fighter, fron tier scout met death here last night with his "boots on" as he had often desired. But death did not come to him on the field of battle, where he had so often faced it, nor on the wings of a bullet. He was crushed to death in an elevator shaft at the Omaha World-Herald plant, where he was night watchman. "Lone Star" was caught by the elevator when he attempted to move the control lever from the outside, and the lift suddenly shot upward.

See moreSee less

The old veteran tried to leap into it but his feet had lost their old spring, and so "Lone Star" died with his boots on. uoiie jsiar orose into rame nr.st in 1876, In "the hole in the wall" country, Powder River, Wyo„ when he single handed shot and killed "Shacknasty" Jim and his two fel low bandits. It was "Lone Star’s" hammer fanning tha* won the un equal fight. Other high spots of his life are: Shot and killed two stage coach bandits, April 12, 1877, near Valen tine, Neb. Shot five Indians in battle of little Missouri, near Black Hills, August 21, 1877, saving the lives of a party of 20 prospectors. Killed 11 Indians with 12 shots In the battle of Wounded Knee, in 1S92. Killed bandit, Ainsworth, Neb., in 1878. Shot and killed bandit at Fremont, Neb., in 1897. Was official war department in vestigator of Custer massacre and followed Sitting Bull 600 miles orf horseback, inducing him and his bqnd to return to the reservation. Was present at Sitting Bull’s death.

See the clipping

The Bismarck Tribune · Bismarck, N.D.

A Bismarck man writes to refute an AP wire story claiming Crow scout Curly was a survivor of Custer's command at Little Bighorn. He asserts there were no survivors among Custer's men, and that Curly was never actually in the fight but watched from a ravine before escaping to report the news.

CorrectionThis set right 2 earlier articles: The Omaha Morning Bee, 21 April 1923, The Seattle Star, 24 April 1923.

The Bismarck Tribune · 26 April 1923 · page 2

NO SURVIVORS OF CUSTER MASSACRE, SAYS BISMARCK MAN, REFUTING STORY

TRIBUNE Editor Tribune: .In recent numbers of the Fargo Forum and the Bismarck Tribune, the following appeared in the Asso ciated Pres reports of said papers. “For nearly half a century a con troversy has raged, whether there was a survivor of Custer’s valiant cavalry. The controversy is settled. Uncle Sam has found a survivorRhuli-shce-ahsh, better known as Cuilv, a Crow Indian scout now on the pension list. “More than MOO were wiped out on Custer’s side. Curly, the only sur vivor, escaped by mingling with the attacking Indians until he was able to slip away.” There were no survivors of the Custer tragedy, except a horse found on the battle field two days later by Captain Nowlan who recognized the horse as Camanche, owned by Capt.

See moreSee less

Keogh who was killed with Custer's batallion. Curly was never in the fight, he hid in a ravine and watch ed the fight until the soldiers were all killed. He stole away after dark, and two days later on the morning of June ‘27th he found the steamer Far West at the mouth of the Little

See the clipping

The Bismarck Tribune · Bismarck, N.D.

This report debunks the long-circulated story that Crow scout Curly helped Custer try to escape by disguising him with a blanket during the battle. It notes Sioux warriors fought nearly naked that day, Curly never knew Custer before the battle, and cites Curly's own 1916 account contradicting the earlier tale.

The Bismarck Tribune · 26 April 1923 · page 2

SAYS BISMARCK MAN, REFUTING STORY

Big Horn River, and by means of tlie sign language lie told the men on board The Far West of the dis aster which befell Custer and bis batallion. Later when an interpret er was procured Curly told a cock and bull story about picking up two Sioux blankets during the fight that he went to Custer ann told hirtn to throw one of the blankets over his head and that lie would help him to escape. This : lory of Curly’s was published over Hi years ago in (ieneral Custers memoirs, published

See the clipping

The Bismarck Tribune · Bismarck, N.D.

The report uses testimony from Crow scout Hairy Moccasin and Curly's own 1916 statement to show Curly left Custer's column miles before the battle and never witnessed the fight. It argues that self-proclaimed 'sole survivors' of Custer's command have long spread misinformation accepted as historical fact.

CorrectionThis set right an article from 6 days earlier.

The Bismarck Tribune · 26 April 1923 · page 2

his'A. M. degree from the University of Minnesota in June. published in the June 1916 number of the Teepee Book, published at Sheri dan, Wyoming. Curly says! in this statement “1 was a young fellow, I was only sixteen or seventeen and didn’t know mueh about fighting at that time. If I had been older when tiny had the war I might have done something, and if 1 had been older I wouldn’t huge off. After I got off the high hill, I rode wherfe the steamboat was.” Before Custer left the mouth of the Rosebud River on June 22, 1876, Lieutenant Bradley who had charge of the Crow Indians scouts, selected six of his Crow scouts and turned them over to General Custer.

See moreSee less

Hairy Moccasin one of the < row scouts afterwards made a statement which was pub lished in the Teepee Book. He said. “Custer said you go and find that village. I went to a butte on the head of Reno Creek from where f could see the village. I went and reported the Camp to. Custer. He asked if any were running away from the Camp. I said no* When we separated Half Yellow Face and White Swan, were ordered to go with Reno, Goes-ahead, White Man, Runs him, Curly and myself, were or dered with Custer. From the high point north of where Reno later en trenched we could see the village and could see Reno lighting. We •four sAuts turned and charged THURSDAY, APRIL 26,1923 published in the June 1916 number of north to where Custer was headed the Teepee Book, published at Sheri for, and we saw no more of Curly af dan, Wyoming. Curly says! in this ter that. I dont know where he went. statement “1 was a young fellow, I Custer told Mitch Bouyer, the was only sixteen or seventeen and guide, to tell us to go back to the didn’t know mueh about fighting at pack train which we did." From that time. If I had been older when where the Crow scouts left Custer tiny had the war I might have done and to the point where Custer was something, and if 1 had been older killed was over three miles. As I wouldn’t huge off. After I got stated Curly never went into the off the high hill, I rode wherfe the battle, and he was no more of a steamboat was.” Before Custer left survivor than the other three ( row the mouth of the Rosebud River on scouts who were nearer the j* Utlo June 22, 1876, Lieutenant Bradley field than Curly was, and tnose who had charge of the Crow Indians three scouts have never claimed to scouts, selected six of his Crow be aXirvivor* of the Custer battle. scouts and turned them over to As one writer aptly states it. “It is General Custer. Hairy Moccasin the accounts of .-ole survive.:.! of one of the < row scouts afterwards Custer’s command that have given made a statement which was pub writers the greater amount of mis lished in the Teepee Book. He said. information subsequently published “Custer said you go and find that as historical truths. Sole survivors have been plentiful, they have crop village. I went to a butte on the head of Reno Creek from where f ped up in every portion of the coun could see the village. I went and try, lived for a time as the hero of the hour, and have inevitably passed reported the Camp to. Custer. He into oblivion”. Curly no doubt re asked if any were running away from the Camp. I said no* When ceived his pension for being a scout we separated Half Yellow Face and for the government duiing the years White Swan, were ordered to go with 1876 and 1877, and not on account of being an alleged sole survivor of the Reno, Goes-ahead, White Man, Runs Custer Battle. him, Curly and myself, were or dered with Custer. From the high Yours truly, point north of where Reno later en W. A. FALCONER

See the clipping

Evening Capital · Annapolis, Md.

The Pension Bureau has identified Shuh-shee-ahsh, a Crow Indian living on the Crow reservation in Montana, as another survivor of the Custer Massacre. He reportedly escaped by mingling with the Sioux and Cheyenne and is now receiving a pension for his service in the 1876-77 Indian campaigns.

Evening Capital · 28 April 1923 · page 1

CUSTER ilploUND (Bt Th<* Amorlalrd Prru.l WASHINGTON. Apr. 28.—One more j survivor of the Custer Massacre has been unearthed hy the Pension ! Bureau.. j He is Shuh—shce-ahsh, a Crown ! Indian, now living on the Crow reser

See the clipping

The West Virginia News · Ronceverte, W. Va.

The report is an obituary for a plainsman known as 'Lone Star,' who died in an elevator accident in Omaha, listing a fantastical résumé of gunfights, Indian battles, and frontier exploits. Among the claims is that he served as the War Department's official investigator of the Custer massacre and personally persuaded Sitting Bull to return to the reservation.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out. CorrectionThis set right 2 earlier articles: Yorkville Enquirer, 24 April 1923, The Frontier, 26 April 1923.

The West Virginia News · 28 April 1923 · page 1

LAST GREAT GUN-FIGHTER DEAD. Fighting snuHng, gray-haired old Lone Star” Fred M. Hans, Indian fighter, frontier scout and possilily the last of the real two gun “cross arm draw” experts, met death at Omaha, Nebraska, on April 18 “with his boots on.” But death did not come on the field of battle, where he had so often faced it, nor on the wings of a bullet. He was crushed to death in an elevator shaft at the Omaha World-Herald plant, at his work as night watchman. Lone Star” began his career as a plainsman at the age of six teen, when he left home to search for a brother kidnapped by Sioux Indians.

See moreSee less

He broke into fame first in 1876 in the “Hole in the Wall” country on Powder river in Wy oming, when single-handed he shot and killed three bandits. Other high spots in his life Shot and killed two stage coach bandits April 12, 1877, near Val entine, Nebraska. Shot five Indians in battle of Little Missouri, near the Black Hills on August 21, 1877, saving the lives of a party of twenty prospectors; Killed eleven Indians with 12 shots, using both gun* in the bat tle of Wounded Knee, South Da kota, in 1892. Killed bandit at Ainsworth, Nebraska, in 1878. Shot and killed bandit at Free mont, Nebraska, in 1879. Was official War department investigator of the Custer mas sacre and followed Sitting Bull on horseback 800 miles and in duced him and his band to re turn to the reservation. Was chief scoutmaster for Phil Sher idan for six years. Was chief special agent of the Northwestern railroad for four years. In all, Hans was credited with having killed eight white men and twenty Indians.

See the clipping

The Laramie Republican · Laramie, Wyo.

The U.S. pension bureau identified Shu-shee-ahsh, a Crow Indian living on the Crow reservation in Montana, as another survivor of the Custer massacre. He reportedly escaped death by mingling with the Sioux and Cheyenne and is now drawing a pension for his service in the 1876-77 Indian campaigns.

The Laramie Republican · 30 April 1923 · page 5

Latest Survivor Custer Massacre Is Crow Indian (Ry Associated Press.) Washington, April 30.—One more survivor of the Custer massacre has been unearthed by the pension bu reau. He is Shu-shee-ahsh, a Crow

See the clipping