As the Papers Told It

Little Bighorn · The full archive

October 1902

27 articles

The San Francisco Call · San Francisco, Calif.

The San Francisco Call reports on a grand military review at the Presidio led by Lieutenant General Nelson A. Miles, noting his fame as an Indian fighter from the days of Custer and Sitting Bull. The article focuses on the pageantry of the troop inspection rather than the historical battle itself.

The San Francisco Call · 1 October 1902 · page 3

States army, was the \ hero of the, day. The veteran of many a hard-fought bat tle, an Indian fighter, who achieved fame and distinction in the days of Custer and Sitting Bull, a . dignified, stately, grim visaged warrior, who has passed through the turmoil and strife of many bloody campaigns, sat^-dignified and erect— tfie personification of all that one expects of a commanding general, reviewing the men in uniform as they swung by, in Imposing manner. - Flanked by General Hughes, command er of the Department , of J California, and his staff, Colonel Maus and officers and Colonel Rawles, commandant of the Fresidlo, General Miles sat on a hand some black charger, • dofHng his hat to the colors and saluting the various regimental officers as they passed by in parade.

See moreSee less

The

See the clipping

The Owosso Times · Owosso, Mich.

Veterans of the four Michigan cavalry regiments once led by General Custer gathered in Detroit for their thirteenth annual reunion. The article recounts the brigade's Civil War history and notes Custer's later death at Little Bighorn.

The Owosso Times · 17 October 1902 · page 2

200 OF THE OLD BOYS ON HAND

Little Big Horn mountains. Every veteran cavalryman among them Is a raconteur, and tire tales' they tell are only equaled by their de light in relating them. The famous Custer brigade, whose reunions bring together many, noted soldiers from throughout the state, is composed Vf four regiments, the First, Fifth, Sixth and Seventh Michigan cavalry regi ments, that fought through the many battles of the civil war under General George A. Custer. The brigade orig inally mustered 3,244 men. Of these, 1.515 lost their lives .in the Struggle. The reunions of later years muster only some 200 veterans, whose rants are thinning with increasing rapidity. For two days the picturesque Custer

See the clipping

The Holt County Sentinel · Oregon, Mo.

A 1902 local election article profiles Republican candidates for Holt County offices, including a county judge candidate who served in Custer's regiment, helped explore the Black Hills, and returned home just before the Custer massacre. The piece also covers candidates for probate judge and prosecuting attorney with brief biographical sketches.

The Holt County Sentinel · 17 October 1902 · page 1

JUDGE NORTHERN DISTRICT

He has been successful in the manage since by J. C. McKnight, Fannie Scott and others. He helped his father to erect the first school north of Mound City. He was a member of Custer's regiment. and assisted in exploring the Black Hills, and returned homejuBt prior to the Custer massacre. He is married, having married Frances, the youngest daughter of R. K. Ross, one of the pioneers of Northern Holt. He will make the people a strong, capable pre siding judge. PROBATE JUDGE.

See the clipping

The Minneapolis Journal · Minneapolis, Minn.

A Minnesota newspaper reports on National Guard promotions and discipline, noting that Captain W.S. Brisbin is the son of a Captain Brisbin who served in the First U.S. Cavalry and achieved fame at the time of the Custer massacre. The bulk of the item concerns guard administration, not Little Bighorn itself.

The Minneapolis Journal · 22 October 1902 · page 13

Captain Brlsbln is a son of the late Captain Brisbin of the First United States c a' airy, who achieved fame at the time ol the Custer massacre. H e served through the late war and was mustered out as second lieutenant.

See the clipping

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

An Episcopal clergyman, a former Sioux chief, recounts a confession from a dying convert named Appearing Elk, who claimed he personally killed Custer with a tomahawk during the battle. The story includes details like taking Custer's revolver but not scalping him due to his shaved head.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

Evening Star · 23 October 1902 · page 17

CLAIMS HE KILLED CUSTER

t CLAT H R ILLED CUSTE. "Appearing Elk" Yakes a Confessio to Sioux Clergyman. A dispatch to the New York World froi Philadelphia yesterday says: A forme Sioux chief, now an Episcopalian rector the Rev. Philip Daloria of Flora, S. D who is attending the council of the Protesl ant Episcopal Church here, said today: "It was only a year ago that I learne the true story of the death of Gen. Custer I had been the means of converting an 01 warrior named Appearing Elk. Unlike mos Indian braves, he was not much given t boasting of his exploits, but I knew that h had taken many scalps.

See moreSee less

"Appearing Elk became a fervent Chris tian and one day, after he had been bap tized and taken into the church, I aske him to tell me of his experiences in the bal tle of the Little Big Horn. Every Siou wants to know who killed Custer, and tha was my first question. I was surprise when the old man replied: 'I did.' "I felt pretty sure that Appearing El: told the truth. I drew his story from hir in detail, and this is what he said: "'We had surrounded the last cluster o soldiers when my pony was shot from un der me. When I got on my feet again discovered that I had been wounded. Sud denly a man in blue loomed up in front 0 me. "I knew he was a big chief. He wa swaying like a drunken man from exhaus tion and loss of blood because of many bul let and arrow wounds. I felled him witt my tomahawk and then eat on his body t be sure .that I should not be robbed of m; spoils. In order to make doubly sure I tool the revolver from the holster of the deac man and stuck it in my belt. " 'I didn't scalp the man, because his heat was shaved, and I was ashamed to takc a mere piece of skin.' "I know posittively," continued Mr. Dalo ria, "that the revolver taken by Appearing Elk was subsequently identified as Custer's and so far as I have been able to learn Custer was the only man in the comman< who had his head shaved." Appearing Elk died last spring.

See the clipping

Atlanta Semi-Weekly Journal · Atlanta, Ga.

A retired major recounts his military career, noting he narrowly avoided joining the 7th Cavalry under Custer due to a telegram mix-up, which spared him from dying at Little Bighorn. He also details the storied history of the Third battery, his original unit.

Atlanta Semi-Weekly Journal · 23 October 1902 · page 4

Harbor (May, 1564) it was attached to Custer’s division. Its new captain is a Georgia boy, the soldierly Captain Eli D. Hoyle, under whom it will lose none of its prestige. With regard to the Seventh cavalry I accepted a captaincy in the regiment in June, 1867, by telegram, and was very glad I was to ride with Custer, who was associated three years with me at West Point, Keough and a lot of other good cavalrymen, but a telegram from the war department informed me that it was the Tenth cavalry—" Buffalo” soldiers, as the Indians call negro soldiers.

See moreSee less

As my ac quaintance did not extend to the tawny Tenth I declined. Had I succeeded in my desire for the Seventh my bones very probably would be reposing with poor Custer’s on the mound overlooking the Little Big Horn. Looking at their tomb stones today in a picture of the battle field it occurred to me that "There s a Divinity which shapes our ends, etc.”

See the clipping

The Minneapolis Journal · Minneapolis, Minn.

An Episcopal minister and former Sioux chief, Rev. Philip Daloria, tells reporters that a warrior named Appearing Elk confessed on his deathbed to killing Custer with a tomahawk at Little Bighorn. The story describes Custer, bloodied and swaying from wounds, being struck down and then straddled by his killer who took his revolver but did not scalp him.

The Minneapolis Journal · 23 October 1902 · page 5

HE KILLED HIM

Indian Chief, Gives the Press an Interesting Story. Mmw Yfk Sim Samolml Sofvtem ' Philadelphia, Oct. 23.General Custer was slain by a Sioux warrior by the name of Appearing Elk, * according to Rev. Philip Daloria of Flora, S. D., formerly a Sioux chief, but now a minister attend ing the council of the Protestant Episco pal church in this city. Rev. Mr. Daloria gives the solution of the Little Bi g Horn mystery of 1876 in the words of Custer's slayer himself. Ap- ' pearing Elk died last spring after having told his story to the minister.

See moreSee less

"I was the means of converting an old warrior named Appearing Elk who was in the fight at Little Big Horn in which General Custer fell," said Mr. Daloria. "Appearing Elk gave me the following ac

See the clipping

The Times · Richmond, Va.

A former Sioux warrior, Appearing Elk, reportedly told a converted Episcopalian rector his account of personally tomahawking a shaved-headed officer he believed was Custer during the battle. The story is relayed secondhand, years after both the battle and the warrior's death.

The Times · 23 October 1902 · page 2

WHO SLEW CUSTER

The non-lrritating cathartic Pri-.# 25 centol all drugRlste or. hy mall a% C.LHuod_Co,I_>well. _!?__. - (Special Dispatch to The Times.) riiI_ADELPHIA, PA., October 22.? Rev. Philip Daloria,. of Flora, S. D., a former Sioux chief, now an Episcopalian rector, attending the..council of the Frot ostant Church' '.here, said to-day: "1 have beeh the means of convertlng ,an cld war'rior .lamcd Appearlng Klk, who was in the light at Little liig Horn. in which General Georgs A. Custer fell. Jle gavo me the .following account of tne massacre: " '.We had surrounded the last cluster of soldiers when I discovered that I my?

See moreSee less

self was wounded. Suddenly a man in biue loomed up in front of me. I knew that he was a chief, but} I did not know who he was. H? was swaying like a drunken man from cxhauptiou and loss of 'jiood from many bullet and arrow wounds. I fclled him with my tomahawk and then .???at on his body to bc ftare that I should not be robbed of my rights. *r'ln order to be doubly sure I took the revolver from the holster of the dead rnap,and stuck it in my belt. When there werLno more soldiers lol't alive the nois. cea?ed and the dust. liftedl I was still sitting on the body. I did not scalp the iran because his head was shaved and 1 '.sas ashamed to take a piece of skin.' 'So far as I have been able to le_.rn, Ceneral Custer was thc only man in the command who had hisi head sliaved." /..ipearlng Klk died last spring, and the Rev. Mr. Daloria was the only man liv? ing at the time who knew his story.

See the clipping

Evening Times-Republican · Marshalltown, Iowa

A Philadelphia report from a church council has a former Sioux chief, now a reverend, recount a deathbed confession from a warrior named Appearing Elk, who claimed he tomahawked a wounded, swaying officer in blue during the Little Bighorn fight. The warrior later learned the man he killed was General Custer.

Evening Times-Republican · 24 October 1902 · page 1

Tragedy of Little Big Horn. Philadelphia, Oct. 24.—Rev. Philip Daloria of Flora, S. D., formerly a Sioux chief but now a minister attend ing the council of the Protestant Epis copal church in this city, explains the death of General Custer in the tragedy of the Little Big Horn in 1S7G. Rev. Mr. Daloria says a Sioux warrior named Appearing Elk, who died last summer, confessed before he passed away that he had slain Custer. Appearing Elk said that in the midst of the fray he himself was wounded, and that sudden ly a man in blue, chief of the white men, loomed up in front of him, sway ing from exhaustion and loss of blood from many wounds.

See moreSee less

The Indian slew him with his tomahawk, but did not silp him. He learned later that his victim was Custer.

See the clipping

Bismarck Daily Tribune · Bismarck, N.D.

A Philadelphia report recounts Rev. Philip Deloria's story, told to him by a Sioux man named Appearing Elk before his death, claiming he personally killed General Custer with a tomahawk at Little Bighorn. The account describes Appearing Elk striking down an exhausted, wounded officer in blue and taking his revolver, only later learning the man was the white chief.

Bismarck Daily Tribune · 24 October 1902 · page 1

TJ3RY CF THE SLAYER OF GEN­ ERAL CUSTER. Philadelphia,, Oct. 23--—General Cus­ ter was sllain by a Sioux warrior by the name of Appeaiting EJlk, according to Rev. Phfflip Datoria. of Flora* S. D., formerly a Sioux chief, but now a into ister attending tlia -c-ouincil of the Pro­ testant Episcopal church in t.hi« city. Rev. Mr. Dalca-ia giives ih© solution of the Little Big Horn mystery of 1876 in the words of Custer's slayer him­

See the clipping

Akron Daily Democrat · Akron, Ohio

A former Sioux chief, now an Episcopal rector named Rev. Philip Deloria of Pierre, South Dakota, reportedly told a story in which he identified 'Appearing Elk' as the man who killed General Custer. The account describes the warrior sitting on Custer's body to claim his kill as a trophy.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 2 days later.

Wrong

Akron Daily Democrat · 24 October 1902 · page 3

"I DID," Said an Old Sioux Chief / When Asked Who Killed Gen. Custer / Sat on the Body To Be Sure of His Spoil

Philadelphia, Pa., Oct. 24-Accord-lng to the story of n formerSloux chief, now an Episcopalian lector, the man who killed ttcn. Custer was Appearing Elk. Tho former Sioux Is P.cv. Philip Dalorla, of I'loro, South" Dakqtn. Ho suys that about a year ago no com ertcd the old chief Appearing !llt, arid knowing that tho warrior had been in the Little Big Horn battle, asked him who had killed Custer. "I did," he said. Tho story told to tho rector by the, old warrior follows: "Wo had surrounded tho last cluster of soldiers when iny pony was shot from under me.

See moreSee less

When I got on my feet again1 1 discovered tbd,t I had been wounded: Suddenly a man in blue loomed up in front of inq. "I kuov he was a big chief. Ho was swaying; llko u rtrnnkn man from exhaustion nnd Joss of blood because of many bfillct and' arrow

See the clipping

Akron Daily Democrat · Akron, Ohio

A newspaper recounts a story told by Rev. Philip Deloria, a former Sioux chief turned Episcopalian rector, about another chief named Appearing Elk who claimed to have killed Custer in battle. The account describes Appearing Elk striking down a wounded officer with a tomahawk, sitting on the body, and taking his revolver, which was later supposedly identified as Custer's.

Akron Daily Democrat · 24 October 1902 · page 3

His Spoil. Philadelphia, Pa., Oct. 24-Accord-lng to the story of n formerSloux chief, now an Episcopalian lector, the man who killed ttcn. Custer was Appearing Elk. Tho former Sioux Is P.cv. Philip Dalorla, of I'loro, South" Dakqtn. Ho suys that about a year ago no com ertcd the old chief Appearing !llt, arid knowing that tho warrior had been in the Little Big Horn battle, asked him who had killed Custer. "I did," he said. Tho story told to tho rector by the, old warrior follows: "Wo had surrounded tho last cluster of soldiers when iny pony was shot from under me.

See moreSee less

When I got on my feet again1 1 discovered tbd,t I had been wounded: Suddenly a man in blue loomed up in front of inq. "I kuov he was a big chief. Ho was swaying; llko u rtrnnkn man from exhaustion nnd Joss of blood because of many bfillct and' arrow

See the clipping

The Portland Daily Press · Portland, Me.

A Sioux-born Episcopal rector recounts a story told to him by a dying convert, Appearing Elk, who claimed to have killed a shaved-headed officer he believed was Custer during the Little Bighorn battle. The rector says the dead man's revolver was later identified as Custer's, offering this as proof of the claim.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

The Portland Daily Press · 25 October 1902 · page 13

THE BRAVE WHO KILLED CUSTER. Philadelphia, October 23.—A former Sioux chief, now an Episcopalian rec tor, the Rev. Phliip Daloria of Flora, S. D-, who attended the council of the Protestant Episcopal church here, said today: "It was oniy a year ago that I [earned the true story of the death of Gen. Custer. I had been the means of converting an oid warrior named Ap pearing Elk. Unlike most Indian braves, he was notmuch given to boast ing of his expiolts, but I knew that he had taken many scalps.

See moreSee less

"Appearing Elk became a fervent Christian and one day, after he had been baptized and taken Into church, I asked him to tell me of his experiences in the battle of the Little Big Horn. Every Sioux wants to know who killed Custer, and that'was my first question. I was surprised when the old man re plied, 'I did.' 'T felt pretty sure that Appearing Elk told the truth. I drew his story from him in detail, and this is what he said: " 'We had surrounded the last clus ter of soldiers when my pony was shot from under me. When I got on my feet again I discovered that I had been wounded. Suddenly a man in blue loomed up In front of me, '' I knew he was a big chief. He was swaying like a drunken (nan from exhaustion and loss of blood because' of many bullet and arrow wounds. I felled him with my tomahawk and then sat on his body to be sure that I should not be robbed of my spoiis. In order to make doubly sure I took the re volver from the holster of the dead man and stuck if in my belt. " T didn't scalp the man, because his head was shaved and I was ashamed to take a mere piece of skin.' " I know positively," continued Mr. Daloria, " that the revolver taken by Appearing Elk was subsequently iden tified as Custer's, and so far as I have been able to learn, Custer was the only man in the command who had his head shaved." Appearing Eik died last spring. i

See the clipping

Wheeling Register · Wheeling, W. Va.

A former Sioux chief turned Episcopal rector recounts how a dying warrior named Appearing Elk confessed to killing Custer in hand-to-hand combat during the Little Bighorn battle. The rector claims Custer's revolver was later identified as the one taken by Appearing Elk, and notes Custer was reportedly the only soldier with a shaved head.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

Wheeling Register · 25 October 1902 · page 6

TOOK. MANY SCALPS PHILADELPHIA, Oct 24.—A former Sioux chief, now an Episcopaiian rec tor, the Rev. Philip Daloria, of Flora,' S. D., who has been attending the Council of the Protestant Episcopal Church here, said to-day: “It was only a year ago that I learned the true story of the death of Gen. Custer. I had been the means of converting an old warior named Ap peaing Elk. Unlike most Indian braves, he was not much given to boasting of his exploits, but I knew that he had taken many scalps.

See moreSee less

“Appearing Elk became a frevent Christian and one day, after he had been baptized and taken into the church, I asked his to tell me of hia experiences in the battle of the'Little Big Horn. Every Sioux wants to know who killed Custer, and that was my first question. I was surprised when the old man replied: ‘I did.’ “I felt pretty sure that Appearing Elk told the truth. I drew his story from him in detail, and this is what he said: “ ‘We had surrounded the last eluster of soldiers when my pony was shot from under me. When I got on #ry feet again I discovered that I had been wounded. Suddenly a man in blue I loomed up in front of me. “I knew he was a big chief. ^He was swaying like a drunken man from ex haustion and loss of blood because of many bullet and arrow wounds. 1 felled with him my tomahawk and then sat on his body to be sure that I should not be robbed of my spoils. In order to make doubly sure I took the revolver from the holster of the dead man and stuck it in my belt. “ ‘I didn’t scalp the man, because hia, head was shaved, and I was ashamed to take a mere piece of skin.’ “I know positively,” continued Mr. Daloria, “that the revolvertaken by Appearing Elk was subsequently iden tified as Custer’s, and so far as I have been able to learn, Custer was the only man in the command who had his head shaved.” / Appearing Elk died last spring.

See the clipping

The Savannah Morning News · Savannah, Ga.

An Episcopalian rector, formerly a Sioux chief, recounts how a dying convert named Appearing Elk confessed to him that he was the one who killed General Custer at Little Bighorn. The story is presented decades after the battle as a personal recollection shared during a religious conversion.

The Savannah Morning News · 26 October 1902 · page 21

BRAVE WHO KILLED CUSTER.

Who Converted Him. From the New York World. Philadelphia, Oct. 22. —A former Sioux chief, now an Episcopalian rec tor, the Rev. Philip Daloria of Flora, S. D., who is attending the Council of the Protestant Episcopal Church here, said to-day: "It was only a year ago that I learn ed the true story of the death of Gen. Custer. I had been the means of con verting an old warrior named Appear ing Elk. Unlike most Indian braves, he was not much given to boasting of his exploits, but I knew that he had taken many scalps.

See moreSee less

“Appearing Elk became a fervent j Christian and one day, after he had 1 been baptized and taken into the i church, I asked him to tell me of his experiences in the battle of the Little Big Horn. Every Sioux wants to know who killed Custer, and that was my first question. I was surprised when the old man replied: ‘I did.’ I

See the clipping

The Savannah Morning News · Savannah, Ga.

An 1902 article recounts Appearing Elk's claimed eyewitness story of killing a wounded, shaved-headed officer in blue with a tomahawk during the battle, then taking his revolver, which was later supposedly identified as Custer's. The narrator, Daloria, asserts this proves Appearing Elk killed Custer himself, since Custer was allegedly the only soldier with a shaved head.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 2 days later. CorrectionThis set right 3 earlier articles: Akron Daily Democrat, 24 October 1902, The Portland Daily Press, 25 October 1902, Wheeling Register, 25 October 1902.

Wrong

The Savannah Morning News · 26 October 1902 · page 21

Daloria, “that the revolver taken by Appearing Elk was subsequently Iden tified as Custer’s, and so far as I have been able to learn, Custer was the on ly man In the command who had his I head shaved.” Appearing Elk died last spring.

See the clipping

In the story →

Atlanta Semi-Weekly Journal · Atlanta, Ga. · and 1 other paper

An Episcopalian rector recounts a story told by a dying Sioux convert, Appearing Elk, who claimed to have personally killed Custer with a tomahawk at Little Bighorn. The rector says Custer's revolver was later identified among the warrior's spoils, and notes Custer was reportedly the only soldier with a shaved head.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

Atlanta Semi-Weekly Journal · 27 October 1902 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

STORY OF THE BRAVE WHO KILLED CUSTER

PHILADELPHIA, Oct. 21.—A former Sioux chief, now an Episcopalian rector, the Rev. Philip Daloria, of Flora, S. D., who it attending the council of tne Protestant Episcopal church here, said yesterday to a North American reporter:

See moreSee less

"It was only a year ago that I learned the true story of the death of General Custer. I had been the means of converting an old warrior named Appearing Elk. Unlike most Indian braves, he was not much given to boasting of his exploits, but I knew that he had taken many scalps.

"Appearing Elk became a fervent Christian and one day, after he had been baptized and taken into the church, I asked him to tell me of his experience in the battle of the Little Big Horn. Every Sioux wants to know who killed Custer, and that was my first question. I was surprised when the old man replied, 'I did.'

"I felt pretty sure that Appearing Elk told the truth. I drew his story from him in detail, and this is what he said:

"'We had surrounded the last cluster of soldiers when my pony was shot from under me. When I got on my feet again I discovered that I had been wounded. Suddenly a man in blue loomed up in front of me.

"'I knew he was a big chief. He was swaying like a drunken man from exhaustion and loss of blood because of many bullet and arrow wounds. I felled him with my tomahawk and then sat on his body to be sure that I should not be robbed of my spoils. In order to make doubly sure I took the revolver from the holster of the dead man and stuck it in my belt.

"'I didn't scalp the man, because his head was shaved, and I was ashamed to take a mere piece of skin.'

"I know postively," continued Mr. Daloria, "that the revolver taken by Appearing Elk was subsequently identified as Custer's, and so far as I have been able to learn, Custer was the only man in the command who had his head shaved."

Appearing Elk died last spring.

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • Yorkville Enquirer · Yorkville, S.C. · 5 November 1902

The Topeka State Journal · Topeka, Kansas

An Episcopalian rector recounts how a baptized Sioux warrior named Appearing Elk confided to him that he personally killed General Custer at the Little Big Horn. The rector says he only learned this story a year earlier after converting the old warrior to Christianity.

The Topeka State Journal · 28 October 1902 · page 5

HE KILLED CUSTER

Story "Appearing E" Told After He Became a Christian. Philadelphia, Oct. 2S. A formr Sioux chief, now an Episcopalian reotor, the Rev. Philip Daloria, of Flora, 3. ., who is attending the council of the Protestant Episcopal church here, said today: "It was only a year ago that I learned the true story of the death of Gen. Cus ter. I had been the means of converting an old warrior ' named Appearing Lik. Unlike most Indiarbraves, lie was not much given ta coasting ef his exploits, but I knew that he had taken many scalps.

See moreSee less

- "Appearing Elk became a fervent Chris tian End one day, after he had been bap tized and taken into the church, I asked him to tell me of his experience in the battle of the Little Big Horn. Every S!oux wants to know who killed Custer. and that was my first question. I was surprised when the old man replied: 'I did.' "I felt pretty sure that' Appearing Elk

See the clipping

The Topeka State Journal · Topeka, Kansas

A man named Daloria recounts the story told by Appearing Elk, a Sioux warrior who claimed to have killed a wounded officer at Little Bighorn with a tomahawk, identifying him as Custer by his shaved head and a revolver later identified as Custer's. Appearing Elk reportedly died earlier that year, 1902.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 5 days later. CorrectionThis set right 2 earlier articles: The Savannah Morning News, 26 October 1902, Atlanta Semi-Weekly Journal, 27 October 1902.

Wrong

The Topeka State Journal · 28 October 1902 · page 5

Manchester, Vt., Oct. 28. Robert T. Lin coln of Chicago, son of President Lincoln, scalps. - has purchased 2,500 acres of land here, which he purposes to transform into a country seat. The property overlooks the golf links of tre Ekwanok Country club and nl.if'in the summer places ofA. M. Gilbert and Edward S. Isham of Chicago. Mr. Lincoln, who for several years has made Manches ter his summer home, is to erect a hand did.' some residence during the winter. f';. A ." - " ''Ill ' f ,r ,t t .

See moreSee less

; II ' - -v3i ' , - - - . - - : r Horn buttons. told the truth. I drew his story from him in detail, and this is what he said:: " 'We had surrounded the last cluster of soldiers when my pony, was shot from the bodies: ' under me. When I got on my feet again I discovered that I had been wounded. Suddenly a man in blue loomed up in front of me. " 'I knew he was a big chief. He was swaying like a drunken man from exhaus tion and loss of blood because of many bullet and arrow wounds. I felled him with my tomahawk and then sat on his body to bo sure that 1 should not he rob bed of my spoils. In order to make dou bly sure I took the revolver from the hols ter of the dead man and stuck it in my belt. " 'I didn't scalp the men, because his head was shaved, and I was ashamed to take a mere piece of skin.' "I know positively," continued Air. Da loria. "that the revolver taken by Appear ing Elk was suhsequently identified as Cus ter's, and so far as I have been able to learn, Custer was the only man in the command who had his head shaved." Appearing Elk died last spring.

See the clipping

The Billings Gazette · Billings, Mont.

A minister, Rev. Philip Daloria, claims a dying Sioux convert named Appearing Elk confessed to personally killing Custer at Little Bighorn with a tomahawk. The account describes Appearing Elk sitting on Custer's body and taking his revolver, only learning afterward he was a chief.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 2 days later.

Wrong

The Billings Gazette · 28 October 1902 · page 2

INDIAN WHO SLEW CUSTER. FORMER CHIEF GIVES PRESS INTERESTING STORY. APPEARING ELK HIS NAME.

Philadelphia, Oct. 24.-General Cus ter was slain by a Sioux warrior by the name of Appearing Elk, according to Rev. Philip Daloria cf Flora, S. D., formerly a Sioux chief, but now a min ister attending the council of the Prostestant Episcopal church in this city. Rev. Mr. Daloiia gives the solution of the Little Big Horn mystery of 1870 in the words of Custer's :-:layer himself. Appearing Elk died last spring after having told his story to the minister. "I was tie means of converting an old warrior named Appearing Elk who was in the fight at Little Big Hlorn in which General Custer fell,' said Mr.

See moreSee less

Daloria. "Appearing Elk gave me the following account of the massaci e: "'We had surrounded the last clus ter of s:ldicrs. I discovered that I myself was wounded. Suddenly a man in blue loomed -up in front of me. I knew that he was a chief, but I did noct know who he was. He was sway ing like a drunken man from exhaus tion and loss of blood from many bul let and arrow wounds. I felled him with my tcmahawk and then sat on his body to be sure that I should not bh robbed of my rights. "'In order to make doubly sure I took the revolver from the holster of the dead man and stuck it in my belt. When there were no more soldiers left alive, the noise ceased and the ldust lifted. I was still sitting on the Soidy. I did not scalp the man. Af tr-ward I learned he was the chief of the white men.'"

See the clipping

The Tucson Citizen · Tucson, Ariz.

An Episcopal clergyman recounts how a dying Sioux convert, Appearing Elk, confessed to killing Custer at Little Bighorn with a tomahawk after his pony was shot. The priest claims the warrior's account was corroborated because he took a revolver later identified as Custer's from the body.

The Tucson Citizen · 29 October 1902 · page 1

Horn. Every Sioux w r ants to know who killed Custer, and that was my first question. I w r as surprised w’hen the old man replied: ‘I did.’ “I felt pretty sure that ppearing Elk told the truth. I drew his story from him in detail, and this is w r hat he said: “ ‘We had surrounded the last clus ter of soldiers when my pony was shot from under me. When I got on my feet again I discovered that I had been w'ounded. Suddenly a man in blue loomed up in front of me.

See the clipping

The Birmingham Age-Herald · Birmingham, Ala.

A state fair program lists a nighttime spectacle titled 'Custer's massacre' performed by cowboys, Indians, and local military as entertainment. The article also reports attendance figures of 8,000-9,000 visitors on Woman's Day, with band concerts and other amusements.

The Birmingham Age-Herald · 30 October 1902 · page 5

BEAUTY PRIZE TO RE GIVEN Cowboys, Indians and Local Military Will Render Tonight an Illustra tion of Custer’s Massacre. The Plano Contests. V" *TODAY’S*PROGRAM*M*E ♦ ♦ -o

See the clipping

The Birmingham Age-Herald · Birmingham, Ala.

A county fair program for the evening includes a theatrical reenactment titled 'The Custer massacre,' performed by National Guard troops as Custer's men and local participants as Indians and cowboys. The passage also covers unrelated railway personnel news and other fair events like a piano contest and baby show.

The Birmingham Age-Herald · 30 October 1902 · page 5

Tonight’s Programme. The Custer massacre tonight at 9:80 o'clock In front of the grand stand will be a novel and entertaining exhibition In which all the Indians and cowboys will take part. It will be a presentation of the famous massacre of Custer’s band by the Sioux Indians. The Indians will be mounted as well as the cowboys and some Idea of their manner of fighting can be obtained. A company of the National Guard will represent Custer and his men. while the cowboys will take the part of scouts. Twenty contestants have been heard In the contest for the 9500 piano which was given by the E.

See moreSee less

E. Forbes Plano com pany to the fair management to offer as a prize. There are a number of other contestants to be heard and It will prob ably be next week before the result will be announced. The two Indian papooses who were en tered In the baby show were given their prizes of 92.50 each yesterday, the mothers taking it In charge for them.

See the clipping

Evening Times-Republican · Marshalltown, Iowa

Captain J. S. Lothrop is preparing an $80,000 claim for Martin V. Boughton, whose cattle and horses were taken by Indians around the time of the Custer massacre, for a new trial before the court of claims in Washington. The case hinges on whether the Indians involved were at peace or at war with the U.S., with testimony expected from General Nelson A. Miles about the war's actual end date.

Evening Times-Republican · 30 October 1902 · page 8

Sioux City, Oct. 29.—Captain J. S. Lothrop is at work upon an $80,000 claim growing out of the Indian depre dations about the time of the Custer massacre, and will soon have the mat ter ready to present to the court of claims at Washington. The case will be heard at Washing ton on a new trial granted as a result of the showing made in the presenta tion of the claim of John Hornick and the late Fred Evans, In which it was shown that while the government had cognizance of only one chief named "Crazy Horse" there were in reality

See the clipping

Turner County Herald · Hurley, S.D.

A Philadelphia news item reports that Rev. Philip Deloria, a minister and former Sioux chief, revealed the deathbed confession of Appearing Elk, who claimed he personally killed General Custer with a tomahawk at Little Bighorn. The account describes Appearing Elk striking down an exhausted, wounded officer in blue, sitting on the body, and taking his revolver, only later learning the man was the white chief.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 3 days later.

Wrong

Turner County Herald · 30 October 1902 · page 8

HE KILLED CUSTER. Appearing Elk, a Sioux Warrior Now Dead, Felled the General With His Tomahawk. 4 Philadelphia Oct. 23.—General Custer was slain by a Sioux War rior by the name of Appearing Elk, according to Rev. Philip Daloria of Flora, S. D., formerly a Sioux chief, bl}t iio\y a minister attending the council Of the Protestant Episcopal church in this city. Rev. Mr. Daloria gives the so lution of the Little Big Horn mystery of 1876 in tiie words of Custer's Slayer himself. Appear ing Elk died l^st spring after having told his Story to the min ister, "I was the means of convert ing an old warfior named Ap pearing El}£ who was in the fight' at Little Big Horn in Which Gen eral: Custer fell," said Mr.

See moreSee less

Daloria "Appearing Filk gave me the fol 16wing account of the'massacre: "We had surrounded the last cluster of soldiers. 1 discovered that I myself was wounded. Sud denly a man in bliie loomed up in front of me. I knew that he was a chief, but did tlot know who he was. He was swaying like a drunken man from exhaustion and loss of blood from many bul let and arrow wounds. I felled him with my tomahawk and then sat on his body to be Sure that I should not be robbed of my rights, "f/ptg "In ordet^o tiake doubly sure took the revolver from the hol ster Of the dead man and stuck it in my belt. When there were no mbre soldiers left alive, the noise ceased and the dust lifted I was still sitting on the body. $1 did not scalp the man. Afterward I learned that he was the chief of the white men." 11*1 -.vHave you seen that "Pock^ Atlas of the \Ybrld" we are giving to'aiub*

See the clipping

Northern Wisconsin Advertiser · Wabeno, Wis. · and 1 other paper

A minister recounts a deathbed confession from a Sioux man named Appearing Elk, who claimed to have personally struck down Custer with a tomahawk at Little Bighorn. The story, relayed secondhand 26 years after the battle, offers a dramatic but unverifiable solution to the enduring mystery of who killed Custer.

CorrectionThis set right an article from 2 days earlier.

Northern Wisconsin Advertiser · 30 October 1902 · page 3

HE KILLED CUSTER. Appearing Elk, a Sioux Warrior, Now Dead, Felled the General. Philadelphia, Oca. 25. —General Cus ter was slain by a Sioux warrior by the name of Appearing Elk, according to Rev. Philip Daloria of Flora, S. D., formerly a Sioux chief, but now a min ister attending the council of the Pro testant Episcopal church in this city. Rev. Mr. Daloria gives the solution of the Little Big Horn mystery of 1876 in the words of Custer’s slayer himself. Appearing Elk died last spring after having told his story to the minister.

See moreSee less

“I was the means of converting an old warrior named Appearing Elk who was in the fight at Little Big Horn in which General Custer fell,” said Mi. Daloria. Appearing Elk gave me the following account of the massacre: “ ‘We had surrounded the last cluster of soldiers. I discovered that I myself was wounded. Suddenly a man in blue loomed up in front of me. I know that he was a chief, but I did not know who he was. He was swaying like a drunken man from exhaustion ana loss of blood from many bullet and ar row’ wounds. I felled him with my tomahawk and then sat on his tody to be sure that I should not be robbed of my rights. ‘“ln order to make aoubly sure I took the revolver from the holster of the dead man and stuck it in my belt. When there were no more soldiers left alive, the noise ceased and the dust lifted. I was still sitting on the body. I did not scalp the man. Afterward I learned he was the chief of the white men.’ ’’ Some Delicious Dishes. Fig Puffs—One and one-half cups of flour, two teaspoons of baking powder, one-half teaspoon of salt, one tablet spoon of butter, one and one-quarter cups of milk, one egg thoroughly beaten with flour. Bake in moderate oven. Nut Bread—Set a sponge of one cup of entire wheat flour, one cup of white flour, one-half cake of compressed yeast, one cup of milk. When light add two tablespoons of brown sugar, one teaspoon of salt, one-quarter pound of shelled hickory nuts and enough entire wheat flour to make in pan, let rise for one hour and bake one hour. Prune Jelly—Soak one pound of prunes in one quart of water three hours, drain them and strain the water in which they have been soaked, to which add one pound of sugar. Put on stove and let come to boil. Now add prunes, which have had the stones removed and been picked up into smell pieces, and boil for about fifteen min utes. Stir into the boiling prunes one-half a box of gelatin, which has been soaked in a little cold water. Add the juice of one lemon and pour late a mold. Set away to harden, and serve with whipped cream. Heavenly Hash—Select twelve me dium-sized oranges of good shape and color. Cut a small circular piece from the stem end of each, and re move the pulp in small pieces with a spoon. To the pulp add one small can of pineapple (sliced), two ripe bananas, quartered and sliced, one quarter pound of seeded Malaga grapes. Sweeten to taste. Fill the orange shells and garnish with candied cherries. Egg Timbale —Six eggs beaten light ly, one level teaspoon of salt, one shake of pepper for each egg, one-half pepperspoon of red pepper, one and one-quarter cups of milk, a little onion juice. Put in small cups in dipper, and pour oiling water around. Bake from five to seven minutes in hot oven. Turn into shallow dish. Sauce —One-half can tomatoes, four saltspoons mixed pickle spice, one bunch of thyme, one block of sugar (loaf), one-half teaspoon of salt. Let cook until pulp of tomato is soft and will pour through a sieve. To this add one heaping tablespoon of flour and cook two minutes in a tablespoon of butter and a little lemon juice.

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • Vilas County News · Eagle River, Wis. · 3 November 1902

The Birmingham Age-Herald · Birmingham, Ala.

A newspaper lists the Alabama State Fair's daily events, including a Confederate Home Day speech, diving horses, and fireworks. It also describes the previous night's 'Custer Massacre' re-enactment, performed by National Guardsmen as Custer's command, cowboys as scouts, and Ponca Indians as the attacking Sioux.

The Birmingham Age-Herald · 31 October 1902 · page 5

TODAY'S PROGRAMME

Yesterday was one of the biggest days of the fair, probably the biggest with the exception of Wednesday, when so many school children were on the gi^unds. The grandstand was well filled the entire afternoon and last night. Ll beratl’s band and the Custer Massacre taxed its capacity. Two other strong drawing cards were the tournament and beauty show. The latter was won Ipy Miss Beatrice Boggan, and the tournament' was an easy victory for C. H. Alien, the Knight of Alabama, who caught every ring In the five heats. There were five heats of five rings each, each man having a try at twenty-five rings.

See moreSee less

The results were as follows: Knight of the Magic City, J. G. Wor sham, 15 rings. Black Knight of Mississippi, Dr. John Oliver, 22 rings. Knight of Oklahoma, George Elser, 12 rings. Knight of Alabama, C. H. Allen, 25 rings. The prizes were $100 to the best and $50 to the second. This was a novel entertainment and many went to the grounds to see it. There was a great deal of interest in the tournament, the ladies watching it eagerly.

See the clipping