Capt. J. S. Lathrop is preparing an $80,000 claim against the government on behalf of Martin V. Boughton, stemming from Indian depredations around the time of the Custer massacre. Boughton lost 1,000 cattle and about 100 horses driven off from the Black Hills.
Grand Rapids Herald-Review · 1 November 1902 · page 2
WANTS EIGHTY THOUSAND.
Government. Sioux City, lowa, Oct. 29. —Capt. J. S Lathrop of this city is preparing an SBO,OOO claim growing out of the In dian depredations about the time of the Custer massacre, and will soon have the matter ready to present to the court of claims at Washington. The claimant is Martin V. Boughton, now a poor man, living at Great Falls, Mont. At the time of the Indian trouble Boughton owned 1,000 head of cattle and about 100 head of horses in the Black Hills, which were driven 'off by the Indians. <
A retired Seventh Cavalry quartermaster-sergeant, 'Tobe' Brummell, recalls serving under Reno at the Little Bighorn and describes Custer's force, casualties, and the Indian numbers. He claims it took four days for Reno's command to reach Custer's battlefield after being separated.
CHICKAMAUGA, Oct. 25.—The Seventh cavalry, at Chickamauga park, can boast of having the only survivor of the famous Custer massacre in the person of Canteen Steward BrummelL He is now on the retired list, having seen.- thirty years' experience in the army service. Twenty-three years were spent in the Seventh cavalry, and. during seventeen years of that time he served as quartermaster-sergeant. He is familiarly known as "Tobe." He served throughout the whole of the civil war. Six months after the battle of Big Horn he married the widow of Fred erick Hoemeyer, of the Seventh cav alry, who suffered the fate of the Cua-' ter party.
See moreSee less
At the battle of the Big Horn Corpo ral Brummell was in Reno's commaruL Reno's casualty list was 35. killed and GO wounded. Corporal Brummell state* that the strength of the Indian war riors was 7,000, while Custer's party amounted to about 700, and they were divided into two parties, commanded by Reno and Custer. Reno's party was separated from Custer's party, so that it was fouF days before they could reach the scene of the battle. Brummell says Ouster's orders were to reconnoiter and then report, but in stead he attacked the Indians as soon as discovered, with the result already known. "Tobe" will serve as canteen steward of the Seventh cavalry the remainder of his life, having been given a com mission by the government.
A 1902 article reports Rev. Philip Daloria, an Episcopal priest of Sioux heritage, revealing a supposed confession about how Custer died at Little Bighorn, claiming a brave named Appearing Elk struck him down with a tomahawk but could not scalp him because his head was shaved. The piece presents this 26-years-later account as correcting prior false reports.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
The St. Louis Republic · 2 November 1902 · page 10
MISSING CHAPTER IN HISTORY.
years Mr. Daloria has labored among his people In the capacities of helper, cate chlst and priest Mr. Daloria was an Intimate friend of Sitting Bull, but he could never persuade the old chieftain to change his mode of
An Indian missionary named Daloria recounts how a Sioux warrior named Appearing Elk, after converting to Christianity, confessed that he personally killed General Custer. Daloria also explains that Custer went unscalped because he had cut his hair short before the battle, making him unrecognizable to the Sioux.
The St. Louis Republic · 2 November 1902 · page 10
OLD WARRIOR'S CONFESSION
"There have been many tales purporting to come, from Sioux Indians about the man ner In which General Custer met his death, but I am convinced that everything I have read on the subject up to date Is false. The
Rev. Mr. Daloria recounts the story told by the late Appearing Elk, a Sioux warrior who claimed to have struck down and taken the pistol from a shaved-headed officer he believed was Custer during the battle. The account describes the chaos of the fight and Appearing Elk's claim to the honor of 'first feather.'
The St. Louis Republic · 2 November 1902 · page 10
TOOK CUSTER'S PISTOL.
ashamed to take a piece of skin. "I know oosltively." continued Mr. Dalo ria. "that the revolver taken by Apeparlng Elk was subsequently Identified as Custer's, and. so far as I have been able to learn from my people, and from what f tan read In your books he was the only man in the command who had his head shaved" Appearing Elk died last spring, and the Reverend Mr. Daloria was. the only man living at the time who knew his story.
A Philadelphia report retells a story from a former Sioux chief-turned-rector that an old warrior named Appearing Elk claimed to have killed General Custer with a tomahawk during the Little Bighorn battle. The warrior had since died, leaving no way to verify his account.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
Evening Times-Republican · 4 November 1902 · page 8
HOW CUSTER WAS SLAIN.
Philadelphia, Nov. 4.—According to a story told by a former Sioux chief, now an Episcopalian rector, the man who killed General Custer was Appearing Elk. The former Sioux is the Rev. Philip Daloria, of Flora, S. D. He says old Chief Appearing Elk, and knowing that about a year ago he converted the that the warrior had been in the Little Big Horn battle, asked him who had killed Custer. "I did," he said. The story as told to the rector by the o'd warrior fol lows "We had surrounded the last cluster of soldiers when my pony was shot from under me.
See moreSee less
When I got on my feet again I discovered that I had been wounded. Suddenly a man *ln blue loomed up in front of rne. "I knew he was a big chief. He was swaying like a drunken man from ex haustion and loss of blood because of many bullet and arrow wounds. I felled him with my tomahawk and then sat on his body to be sure that I should not be robbed of my spoils^ In order to make doubly sure I took the revolver from the holster of the dead man and stuck it in my belt." Appearing Elk died last spring.
Evening Times-Republican · Marshalltown, Iowa · 5 November 1902
The Topeka State Journal · Topeka, Kansas
The piece profiles Captain Jack Crawford, known as 'The Poet Scout,' detailing his literary works including poems, plays, and serials, one of which dramatizes events leading to the Custer massacre at Little Bighorn. It also recounts his travels, publishing successes in Britain, and a shipboard encounter with George Gould and singer Melba.
The Topeka State Journal · 4 November 1902 · page 4
New York to arrange for the staging of "Tat" this winter. It will be first produced in St. Louis. It is a play characteristic of the life of the man who buiit it: a iron tier story with cow-boys, an Indian girl and one of the most important scenes is that leading up to the Custer massacre of the Little Big Horn in the later seventies. "Pickles" is a serial story which will
A traveler describes a trip through Montana along the Bozeman Trail, visiting the Crow Indian agency and the site of the Custer massacre of June 25, 1876. He recounts finding old cartridges and a bullet near where Custer fell, and observes Indian life and reservation schools.
The Stark County Democrat · 4 November 1902 · page 4
west would not have been conquered. "Wo visited the Crow Indian agency and the sceno of tho Custer massacre, which occurred Juno 25, 187C. That was when Custer and his cntiro com
A former Sioux chief, now an Episcopal rector, recounts a converted warrior's deathbed-style confession naming himself as Custer's killer at the Little Bighorn. The account describes tomahawking an exhausted, wounded officer in blue and taking his revolver as a trophy.
Yorkville Enquirer · 5 November 1902 · page 1
Press and Banner. The Slayer op Custer.?A former Sioux chief, now an Episcopalian rector, the Rev. Philip Dalorla, of Flora, S. D., who Is attending the council of
The Anderson Intelligencer · Anderson Court House, S.C.
A newspaper miscellany item notes that horses rarely live past 30, then claims Custer's horse was the sole survivor of the Little Bighorn massacre and lived to age 45. This brief trivia note appears decades after the battle as part of general interest filler content.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
The Anderson Intelligencer · 5 November 1902 · page 6
Plain EngliKh Wanted. "There*a a physician ia my towu," j said a Cincinnati drummer, "who ha? ! a eon whom he is instructing io the rudiments of the profession, but just at present the young fellow is think ing of a great many things not down in the books. He has a lot of rapid young compaoions of the slangy sort, and be is master of them all. Indeed his language is at times so utterly modern as to be almost unintelligible to the old-fashioned people, who learn ed ?.heir language out of Webster's j dictionary.
See moreSee less
The other day a patient ; was brought into the doctor's office j and the son happened to bc present. ? " 'Thc; man is suffering from mania I a potu,' said the doctor after a brief I examination. " 'What was that?' inquired thc i son, with an evident effort to catch the 1 meaning. ? "Mania a potu-delirium tremens." | " 'Oh,' commented the youngster, | 'you mean the jim jams, the d. t.'s, the delirious triuiD ings. the gorlmaj gius, io you,' I "''.pposo. I'll get next | to this medical racket before the finj ish, but until I do I wiab you would talk plain English for my benefit, | dad " - What is the sense of a woman having her dress ten inches longer ? third it ought to be and holding it up fifteen inches than is really necessary. - Horses rarely live to a greater age [ than thirty, and are not generally very j serviceable for Bpeed or hard work more than half that long. Custer's horse, which was the only thing to es cape when the Indians massacrfrtkCus ter and his soldiers on the Little Big Horn, lived to the age of forty-five. - There was enough "old corn" stored in granaries in Canaan co feed the whole body of invading Israelites for a year. They numbered 601,730 fighting men, their wives, and camp followers. ====================^
Twice-A-Week Plain Dealer · Cresco, Iowa · and 1 other paper
A claim case involving about $85,000 has been added to the U.S. Court of Claims, based on cattle losses from an Indian raid around the time of the Custer massacre. The dispute centers on whether the depredations occurred during the official Indian war, which would bar the claimant's recovery.
Twice-A-Week Plain Dealer · 7 November 1902 · page 4
Another Claim Caae. S. J. Lothrop, of Sioux City, who was instrumental in the recovery of a war claim amounting to $456,000, and which has been added to the United States court of claims in another case involving about $85,000, and which is based on a claiim for a raid committed by the Indians about the time uf the Custer massacre. Martin V. Boughton is the claimant. He was a cattle herder in 1877 and lost a large number through Indian depredaitions. The question appealed is whether the In dian war ended at tihe time shown by the proclamation of the government, or before. If the depredations were committed during the war Boughton cannot recover.
The Denison Review · Denison, Iowa · 7 November 1902
The Chanute Times · Chanute, Kan.
The item reports that the identity of the Indian who killed Custer at the Little Bighorn has finally been revealed: a man called 'Appearing Elk.' It adds that he has since died, passing to the afterlife without succumbing to modern vices like the 'Carnival craze.'
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 16 days later.
Wrong
The Chanute Times · 7 November 1902 · page 9
And are there no monsters to try their spears upon, no foeman worthy of their steel? There are men and , women whose lives are ground out of them by the pitiless heel of pov erty, there are human creatures who must forfeit their very souls for existence. W.hatisthe tyrant that compels it? I do not know. Call it social conditions, call it capital, call it greed, call it political cor ruption, call it what you please. But here certainly is a foe for the knight of to-day to be thinking about.
See moreSee less
There is another dragon whose power reaches to the remotest dis tnct. The liquor traffic wrecks every home in its domain, it breaks fathers' and mothers' hearts, it dark ens and blights children's lives, and tramples upon every holy thing, Could the knight of old meet a more brutal foe? l he Doys ot touay are the men of tomorrow, and it were well that they begin to think about the bat tles they will fight, to sharpen their weapons and toughen their muscles, for it will be a bitter fight. The Kansas Farmer. A portion of a gang of Filipino murderser got loose last week and killed a number of harmless breth ren who were guilty of friendly feel ing towards the Americans. Civiliza tion and Christianity are almost too much for a murderer, no matter of what nationality he may come from. Perhaps the savage of the far east will soon learn our home methods of Judge Lynch and then do busi ness in the reaPAmerican way. At last the nameqf the Indian who actually . killed -Custer in the great fight of the Little Big Horn has become known. He was an Elk "Appearing Elk," he was called.but since that memorable event he has made his appearance known in the land of the happy hunting grounds without first becoming addicted to the Carnival craze. What a won derful Elk! tr . . rwausas uas more u. a. K. men compared to population than any other state in the Union. Pretty good health record this and we cor dially extend an invitation to the balance to come to Chanute and live as loug as they want to. It is one of the few places worth moving to A preacher In a Kentucky church called for a letter for himself and wife when the congregation voted to buy an organ. That is genuine sanctity fy you. The President has been enjoying a turkey hunt in the mountains of Virginia ( and has also inspected some famous old battle fields of the late war. And are there no monsters to try their spears upon, no foeman worthy of their steel? There are men and , women whose lives are ground out of them by the pitiless heel of pov erty, there are human creatures who must forfeit their very souls for existence. W.hatisthe tyrant that compels it? I do not know. Call it social conditions, call it capital, call it greed, call it political cor ruption, call it what you please. But here certainly is a foe for the knight of to-day to be thinking about. There is another dragon whose power reaches to the remotest dis tnct. The liquor traffic wrecks every home in its domain, it breaks fathers' and mothers' hearts, it dark ens and blights children's lives, and tramples upon every holy thing, Could the knight of old meet a more brutal foe? l he Doys ot touay are the men of tomorrow, and it were well that they begin to think about the bat tles they will fight, to sharpen their weapons and toughen their muscles, for it will be a bitter fight. The Kansas Farmer. A portion of a gang of Filipino murderser got loose last week and killed a number of harmless breth ren who were guilty of friendly feel ing towards the Americans. Civiliza tion and Christianity are almost too much for a murderer, no matter of what nationality he may come from. Perhaps the savage of the far east will soon learn our home methods of Judge Lynch and then do busi ness in the reaPAmerican way. At last the nameqf the Indian who actually . killed -Custer in the great fight of the Little Big Horn has become known. He was an Elk "Appearing Elk," he was called.but since that memorable event he has made his appearance known in the land of the happy hunting grounds without first becoming addicted to the Carnival craze. What a won derful Elk! tr . . rwausas uas more u. a. K. men compared to population than any other state in the Union. Pretty good health record this and we cor dially extend an invitation to the balance to come to Chanute and live as loug as they want to. It is one of the few places worth moving to A preacher In a Kentucky church called for a letter for himself and wife when the congregation voted to buy an organ. That is genuine sanctity fy you. The President has been enjoying a turkey hunt in the mountains of Virginia ( and has also inspected some famous old battle fields of the late war.
A Philadelphia-sourced story claims Sioux warrior Appearing Elk confessed before his death to killing General Custer at Little Bighorn, describing how he tomahawked an exhausted officer in blue. The confession was reportedly given to Rev. Philip Deloria, a converted Sioux chief turned minister.
Red Lodge Picket · 7 November 1902 · page 7
"I KILLED CUSTER." This Is the Claim of Sioux Chief Now Dead. A story purporting to give the de tails of General Custer's death at the Indian massacre on the Little Big Horn in 1876 is sent out from Philadelphia. The confession of p pearing Elk. a Sioux warrior who went to the happy hunting grounds about a year ago, is said to have been
The Associated Press reports that Colonel Frederick W. Benteen's remains have been disinterred from Savannah, Georgia and will be reburied at Arlington National Cemetery with military honors. The report notes he served with General Custer in his Indian campaigns before retiring in 1888.
The Times · 14 November 1902 · page 8
COL. BtNTEEN'S REMAINS Ashes of Virginian to Be Reinterred at Arlington. (By Associated Pros??.) "WASHINGTON. Nov. 13.?The remains of Colonel Frederick W. Benteen, of Virginia, who died in June, 1S9S, Tiave been disinterred from the cemetery at Savannah, Ga., and will be reinterred in the National Cemetery at Arlington Saturday morning with military cere? monies. Colonel Benteen was a distin? guished cavalry officer and served with General Custer in his Indian campaigns. He was retired in July, 1SSS.
A Sioux man named John Threefingers, living in Oklahoma Territory among the Cheyenne and Arapaho by marriage, claims he ate part of General Custer's heart after the Little Bighorn massacre. His story surfaced while he was in court pursuing a damages suit against a railroad company over drained water on his land.
The Tucson Citizen · 18 November 1902 · page 8
Makes a Bold Boast GUTHRIE, O. T., Nov. 18.—A Sioux Indian, John Threefingers, lays claim to having eaten a portion of Gen. Custer’s heart after the massacre of that Gener al’s army at Little Big Horn. Threefingers is a resident of Okla homa, luviug. through marriage, been adopted into the tribes of the Cheyenne and Arapahoes. He gives a graphic de scription of the battle, w hen the entire army was wiped out of existence. I Recently Threefingers came into no t ce in Oklahoma as the first Indian to file a suit for damfeges again a t a railroad I company.
See moreSee less
He owns valuable land bor dering on the Choctaw railroad, and claims the company laid pipes which drained a necessary lake on his land, thus leaving his cattle without water. I While attending court in the inter. 8 jof this case his story regarding his par ticipation in the Custer massacre be -1 came known He is still a warrior of great strength and endurance, influen tial in his tribe.
A story circulating from Philadelphia claims a Sioux warrior named Appearing Elk confessed before his death to killing General Custer at Little Bighorn with a tomahawk. The confession was allegedly given to a Sioux-born minister, Rev. Phillip Daloria, who had converted the warrior to Christianity.
Fergus County Argus · 19 November 1902 · page 1
THE SLAYER OF CUSTER. Old Sioux Chief Claims to Have Slain the General. A story purporting to give the ne tails of General Custer's death at the Indian massacre on the I.ittle lig Horn in 1876 is sent out fron Phi'l a(delphia. The confession of Appear ing Elk, a Sioux warrior who went to the happy hunting grounds about a year ago, is said to have been made
At Sheridan, Wyoming on July 4, 1902, fifteen hundred Crow and Cheyenne Indians staged a mock battle reenacting the destruction of Custer's Seventh Cavalry, watched by thousands of spectators. The report calls it the most vivid depiction yet of the 1876 fight, since no U.S. soldier from Custer's command survived to describe the actual battle.
The Washburn Times · 20 November 1902 · page 3
Real Fight Years Ago. At SherbSin, Wyo., July 4, net far from the spot where Custer fell, twen ty-six years after the heroic Seventh cavalry was demolished by a ferocious and overpowering force of Indians, was enacted a mimic but fearfully lifelike imitation of that celebrated massacre, says the New York Times. Fifteen hundred Crows and Chey ennes, hideous in their war paint, swooped down upon 260 men from Fort McKenzie and surrounded, cut down and annihilated them in the presence of thousands of spectators, who then saw the first lifelike repro duction of the slaughter of Custer and
A 1902 article mixes a wool-shipping interview about the Big Horn country with reprinted local news snippets from decades earlier, under a header reflecting on 'twenty-one years ago today.' In passing, it references the region as the place 'where the famed Custer and his band of brave hearts were murdered in the cause of civilization.'
The Butte Inter Mountain · 21 November 1902 · page 4
WHAT HAPPENED TWENTY ONE YEARS AGO TODAY? Why Just Read These Extracts From the Files of the Inter Mountain of That Date and Be Made Wise.
prlt,hally the henlthie'st iin the worhl--for !lck if all kiits." lMr. I'pion lift tiday for the return trip inut i ill visit aill of the new towns that hate sprang it| like musihroom;s in the colntltry wr"re btl a few years ago the sullen tid sicomtitri, Sitting~ Bull, hehl full sway, aII whe.r"' the fan ed Custer and his h1a1n1 of brave Ihearts were mturdered
A Sioux minister recounts the deathbed confession of Appearing Elk, who claimed to have killed Custer with a tomahawk during the final stand at Little Bighorn. The account describes Custer swaying from wounds before being struck down, with Appearing Elk taking his revolver but not scalping him.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 2 days later.
Wrong
Perrysburg Journal · 21 November 1902 · page 9
ADMITS HE SLEW CUSTER
"I nave 'been the means of convert ing an old warrior named Appearing Elk who was in tho fight at Little Big Horn In which Gen. George A. Custer fell," said air. 'Dnlorla the other day. "Appearing Klk ga.vo tho following, account of iho massacre: 'We bad
A minister, Rev. Philip Daloria, relates the deathbed confession of Appearing Elk, a Sioux warrior who claimed to have struck down a swaying, exhausted officer with a tomahawk at Little Bighorn and later learned he was the white chief. The account describes taking the dead man's revolver and sitting on his body to guard against others claiming the kill.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
The Gazette · 22 November 1902 · page 4
ADMITS HE SLEW CUSTER.
The ConfeMlon of Appearing Elk. a Sioux Warrior, Clears l'p IHyetery of Many Yean. Gen. Custer was slain by a Sioux warrior by the naine of Appearing Elk, according to Rev. Philip Daloria, of Flora, S. D., formerly a Sioux chief, but now a minister. Rev. Mr. Daloria gives the solution of the Lit tle Big (Horn mystery of 1876 in the words of Custer’s slayer himself. Ap pearing Elk died last spring after having told his story to the minister: “I have been the means of convert ing an old warrior named Appearing Elk who was in the fignt at Little Big Horn in which Gen. George A. Custer
A dispatch reports that John Threefingers, a Sioux Indian connected to Oklahoma tribes, claimed in court testimony that he ate a piece of General Custer's heart after the battle. The newspaper expresses hope that this is mere boastful exaggeration rather than a true account.
San Antonio Daily Light · 23 November 1902 · page 11
Is This True? The Dallas Times-Herald, in a dis patch from Oklahoma, says: “John Threefingers. a 3!<-ux Indian, related in the Cheyenne-Arapahoe tribes through marriage made a statement at El Reno that he ate a piece of General Custer’s htait after the battle when Custers army was massacred. “Threefingers suddenly came into prominence recently by being the first Indian to sue a railroad company for damages. While attending court he made this confession.” We hope this is a mere piece of braggadocio on the part of the Indian, if not he is not worthy ot a place among men get some service fur which It Is paying good money.” There is considerable complaint of the "examinations” and charges of "fixing" that cotild be avoided.
See moreSee less
The civil service is nothing unless It lie <iuite independent and conducted in a thoroughly Impartial way. Many re forms. discovered by working, arc needed am! should be made.
The obituary of Captain John Ferral McBlain, who died in Houston of diseases contracted during the Spanish-American War, recounts his earlier frontier army career. It claims his company was among those that tried to save Custer during the 1876 massacre by Sitting Bull's forces.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
The San Francisco Call · 27 November 1902 · page 14
HERO OF CHARGE ON SAN JUAN HILL, WHO DIED AT HOUSTON, TEX., OF DISEASES CONTRACTED IN THE SERVICE OF HIS COUNTRY ON CUBAN BATTLEFIELDS.
TRY ON CUBAN BATTLEFIELDS. THE remains of Captain John Fer ral McBlain. who .died at Hous ton, Tex., Saturday, last, have been sent to Washington,- where they will be burled in Arlington Cemetery. ' ' ; : ' ¦ ' • ' / " Captain McBlain was born in. Philadel phia, Pa., but came to San Francisco in early manhood and was for a time em ployed as a bookkeeper In the office of Scott & Robinson, . stock ' brokers, on Montgomery street. Something over twenty years ago he en listed as a private soldier in 'the regular army and soon afterward went .- to the frontier and entered upon a longcareer of active service against the Indians.
See moreSee less
His company was among: those that endeav cred to save ' the ' gallant • Custer at . the time of the massacre by. Sitting Bull. By degrees ybung • McBlain : rose from the ranks and was the first: officer to obtain a commission, under the act of Congress permitting enlisted men to , apply for ex amination: --- . . . .. . .... When the warwith Spain opened McBlain went, with 'his regiment, the Ninth Cavalry (colored), as .captain; of Troop D, and served with distinction at Santi ago. He was among the foremost in the bloody charge 8n San Juan Hill, taking up with his . fighting blacks a , number of the ' , Rough
This 1902 essay on Irish music and its global influence claims that General Custer died at Little Bighorn with the tune 'Garryowen' still echoing in his ears. It uses this as an example of Irish music's stirring power across the world's armies.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
The Chicago Citizen · 29 November 1902 · page 4
Uoultlesi many of the noblest of the original Irish airs are lost forever, but enough survive, preserved by patriotic tradition through ages of persecution, to thrill all maukind. The veriest pbysioai coward can be moved to deeds of daring by such Irish battle-marches as ‘Let Erin Kemember” and ‘‘O’Don nell Aboo." The glorious American general. Custer, died at the Little Big