Witnesses testify before the Reno Court of Inquiry about the retreat from the skirmish line into the woods, estimating over a thousand Indians attacking, and recount Custer's separation from Reno's command before his final charge. Trumpeter John Martin describes seeing the village and Custer's reaction upon viewing it from the ridge.
The New York Herald · 1 February 1879 · page 4
hai'lli firing by kkchvit8. Some of the recruits told witness that they hud fired sixty rounds; he had fired twenty-one rounds; there was no more than a necessary delay after the pack train came up in the movementof the command down stream; the firing heard by witness iu the direction of Ouster's positiou was at no time heavier than that which had been made by tbe skirmish Hue, uor was it so licsvy as to leave tbe impression that Ouster was having a more serious time than liad Major lteiio; on the night of the 2Sth the opinion was expressed that Custer's failure to join lleno was probably due to tbe fact that h<- had some wounded men and could not move; witness and Keno went to hunt for the body of
At the Reno Court of Inquiry in Chicago, trumpeter John Martin testified about the separation of Reno's and Custer's commands before the battle, describing Custer's apparent elation upon sighting the Indian village and his order to send for Benteen. Martin's testimony on timing was inconsistent, and the hearing adjourned before Benteen could be called to testify.
The New York Herald · 1 February 1879 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image
RENO AND CUSTER.
FURTHER TESTIMONY BEFORE THE CHICAGO COURT OF INQUIRY TENDING TO EXCULPATE RENO—THE RASH CHARGE ON THE INDIAN VILLAGE.
See moreSee less
[BY TELEGRAPH TO THE HERALD.]
CHICAGO, Jan. 31, 1879.
The Reno investigation was continued to-day. After the minutes of yesterday's session were read Lieutenant De Rudio was recalled by Mr. Gilbert, who asked him what conversation he had with the scout Girard respecting his being a non combatant. Girard had said that he had no business in the line as he was an interpreter, and consequently not expected to do duty. Sergeant Culbertson was then recalled for cross-examination by Mr. Gilbert. The witness said he heard an order given to Company G, when it moved down toward the timber, to keep cool and not get excited, as there was "likely to be hot work;" saw Major Reno only once, and he was then on the right of the skirmish line.
Mr. GILBERT—What, in your opinion, would have been the fate of the skirmish line if it had remained outside of the woods?
To this question the Recorder, who had drawn out opinions all along, objected.
The Court, however, permitted it to be answered.
The witness said that a continuance there of three minutes longer would have been fatal. Neither did he think the line could have remained in the woods more than a few minutes; he thought there were one thousand or one thousand two hundred Indians pressing around them.
RAPID FIRING BY RECRUITS.
Some of the recruits told witness that they had fired sixty rounds; he had fired twenty-one rounds; there was no more than a necessary delay after the pack train came up in the movement of the command down stream; the firing heard by witness in the direction of Custer's position was at no time heavier than that which had been made by the skirmish line, nor was it so heavy as to leave the impression that Custer was having a more serious time than had Major Reno; on the night of the 25th the opinion was expressed that Custer's failure to join Reno was probably due to the fact that he had some wounded men and could not move; witness and Reno went to hunt for the body of Lieutenant Hodgson; about five minutes after witness had heard firing down the river; witness did not hear any firing after that; so far as witness saw Major Reno was exercising command over his men on the afternoon of the 25th; Major Reno was frequently exposed to heavy firing, standing at points in the discharge of his duties where he was without protection, and in one instance where a man was just before killed; he did not avoid places of danger; after the firing ceased a picket was put out and the command laid down for rest; on the night of the 25th there was talk of sending a message to Custer, Lieutenant Varnum saying it was more than likely that he would be detailed to go; the feeling was that General Custer was all right and as able to take care of himself as was Reno.
CUSTER'S RASH CHARGE.
The next witness was John Martin, trumpeter, Company H, Seventh cavalry, now stationed at Fort Abraham Lincoln. He was orderly trumpeter for General Custer on the 25th of June. He said Major Reno separated from the command at the tepee so often referred to; they moved down opposite sides of the stream at a jump; when the separation was made prior to Reno's crossing the Little Big Horn, Custer started down the right and Reno went down the left on crossing; when Custer got upon the high ridge the Indian village was presented to view, the women and children being visible, but no warriors; Custer appeared glad, as it was supposed the Indians were sleeping; Reno's command was not in view; the Gray Horse company was in the centre of Custer's command; it was about an hour and a half after leaving the watering place that Custer got upon the bluff where the Indian village was made visible; witness saw the children running and playing around the tepees; the whole column passed over the ridge; witness could not see the river at that point.
"COURAGE, BOYS."
When Custer saw the Indian village he took off his hat and gave a yell, saying, "Courage, boys, we will get them and then go back to our station;" Custer appeared very glad; the command then passed down, but when it reached a ravine Custer called his orderly to send back word to Captain Benteen.
This witness was very wild in regard to the time, and made it appear after a time that it was two hours and a half from the time he left Custer to the time when Benteen came up; it might even have been three hours; it was about an hour anyhow after he delivered the despatch to Benteen to the time Benteen reached the hill.
The witness was excused and Benteen called, but as Benteen did not appear the Court adjourned until ten o'clock to-morrow.
The report notes that the Reno case inquiry is still ongoing in Chicago, with testimony generally favorable regarding Major Reno's conduct during the Custer massacre at Little Bighorn. This brief mention is part of a roundup of western news items.
Colored Citizen · 1 February 1879 · page 3
THE WEST. It is reported that Sitting Bull and his Sioux have left the British dominions and returned to the United States. The troubles between the roads East from Chicago, regarding the passenger business, still continue, and much uneasiness is evinced among railroad men lest the difficulties result in an open rupture.
The article reprints a letter from Frederick Whittaker to Congress alleging that Maj. Reno's cowardice and disobedience caused Custer's defeat at the Little Big Horn. This letter formed the basis for the official Reno Court of Inquiry then underway in Chicago.
Colored Citizen · 1 February 1879 · page 3
THE CUSTER MASSACRE.
Made Them, The following letter is the basis of the investigation now going on at Chicago into the conduct of Maj. Reno at the battle of the Little Big Horn: Mount Vernon, N. Y., May 18. 1878 The Hon. W. W. Corlett, M.C.: Dear S. 11 * —Having been called on to prepare the biography of the late Brev. Maj.-Gen George A. Custer, U. S. A., a great amount of evidence, oral and written came into my hands tending to prove that the sacriflc his life and the lives of his immediate command at the battle of the Little Big Horn was useless, and owing to the cowardice of his subordinates.
See moreSee less
I de sire, therefore, to ask your attention, and that of Congress through you, to the ne cessity of ordering an official investigation by a committee of your honorable body into the conduct of the United States troops engaged in the battie of the Little Big Horn, fought June 25, 1876, otherwise known as the Custer massacre, in which Lieut.-Col. Custer, Seventh U. S. Cav alry, perished, with five companies of the Seventh Cavalry, at the hands of the In dians. The reasons on which I found my request are as follows: I irst Information coming to me from participants in the battle, written and oral, is to the effect that gross cowardice was displayed therein by Maj. Marcus A. Reno, Seventh United States Cavalry, second in command that day; and that, owing to such cowardice, the orders of Lieut. Col. Custer, commanding officer to said Reno, to execute a certain attack, were not obeyed. That the failure of this movement, owing to his cowardice and disobedience, caused the defeat of the United States forces on the day in question; and that, had Custer’s orders been obeyed, the troops would probably have defeated the Indians. That after Major Reno’s, cowardly flight, he was joined by Capt. F. W. Benteen, Seventh United-States Cavalry, with re inforcements, which were placed under his order, and that he remained idle with his force while his superior officer was fighting against the whole force of tha In dians, the battle being within his knowl edge, the sound of firing audible from his position, and his forces out of immediate danger from the enemy. That the consequence of this second ex hibition of cowardice and incompetency was the massacre of Lieut. Col. Custer and five companies o< the Seventh United States Cavalry.
Lieutenant DeRudio gave testimony at the Reno Court of Inquiry that was described as more favorable to Major Reno than any previous witness. He stated that General Custer and two aides had reached a hilltop, seen Reno beset by Indians, cheered Reno's men, then rode away with his command instead of assisting, leaving Reno in a dangerous position.
New-York Tribune · 1 February 1879 · page 5
Chico, Jan. 30.—Lieutenant De Ladio thix niorning gave testiiuwuy mo. e decislve'y exeulof Major Reno than any yet wilduced His testimony was in brief that General Coster and two aids bad mented to the top ot a hill, had seen that Reno vas menacec py the Incians, had cheered on Reno's men as they cere nd vauciag on tho Indians, Lad idden away, les tion. Withess couls, uw ths, and thon with his command gz Reno In his precarions posiWy what Custer's idea was in mn ll —
The Reno Court of Inquiry continued with testimony from Sergeant Culbertson, Custer's trumpeter, regarding troop positions and the fighting in the timber. He testified about the volume of gunfire heard from Custer's direction and estimated how long Reno's command could have held the woods.
Chicago Daily Tribune · 1 February 1879 · page 3
Interpreter, nnd he was not expected to fight. RE ROT. P. A. CUI.RKRTSOJf. was then placed upon Hie stand, ami the cross examination was proceeded with by Mr. Gilbert. In answer to a question by Mr. Gilbert, wit* ness stated that lie did not see Maj. Ucno but once on the skinnish-linc; then he mid Adjt, Cook came out on the left of the line for a mo ment. Mr. Gilbert asked what would hare been the probable result of an attempt on the part of Maj. Kcno to hold the timber In face of the In dians.
See moreSee less
Witness slated Hint he did not think the com mand would hare lasted more than twenty min utes if It had remained in the woods. He heard some of the meu say they had tired sixty rounds. Ho fired mostly kneeling, himself, but most of the men were new, mid they fired at random. At the time ho heard the firing supimscd to he by Custer, while • Ucno was on top of the hill, he thought It did not sound as though the parties were baring any serious trouble,—any more than Reno’s command were baring. Hu was asked to state the circumstances con nected with Maj. Kcno going down to the pack train; whether he was In an exposed condition, and in a position of danger. 'Witness replied that ho was In a position of danger; a man was killed near him at the time. This was alxnit fi o’clock on the day In which the fight took place In the woods. He was also In an exposed po altlon on the skirmish-line. Witness beard Maj. Reno say something to Lluut. Dornum about going out to look for Cus ter and establish communication between the two commands. J.icut. Hamuiu replied I hat he did not know as ho would volunteer, hut he would go if he was detailed. The Idea seemed to he prevalent that Custer was as well able to take cure of himself as Reno was. and It was generally thought that Custer was In some tight place lu the hills, where he was not able to get to Kcno anv mure than Reno was to get to Custer. There was a disposition on the part of Hu* ofllccrs In Reno's command to find out the whereabouts of Gen. Custer. “Now,” paid Mr. Gilbert. “1 wish to ask you
A sergeant testifies about the dangerous retreat from the timber to the hill under heavy Indian fire, followed by trumpeter John Martin's account of riding as Custer's orderly during the approach to the village. Martin describes Custer's excitement upon sighting the camp, his order to water horses sparingly, and his final instructions before sending Martin with a message to Benteen.
Chicago Daily Tribune · 1 February 1879 · page 3
Court took a rcrvss of five minutes. TUUMI'BTRU. JOHN MARTIN, of Company H, of the Seventh Cavalry, was the uoxt witness called. He testified that h* was orderly trumpeter for (Jen. Custer on the 25th of June, 1878. lie was with Custer at the tepee on the riirht bank of the Little Dig Horn Itlver. lie described the circumstances ol the division of Custer’s command. Heno went down on the left aide of a little creek or ravine, und Custer on (lie right. 'l'lie latter stopped to water, und witness henid Ucn.
See moreSee less
Custer give orders to the company commander* not to let their horses drink too much, us the; had a good ways to go that day. lie was asked to state what he knew of Cub* tor’s lino of march from that time. He said Custer went along thcr'cht hank of the river in a direct line far ti while, und then turned o(T to the rigid. Altera time, they came to (he .river attain, und they saw the Indian village. Witness was at that time riding os nn otderly with Hen. Cuvier, and was quite vear to him. When Cus ter saw thu village he apjK-ared glad. Witness supposed hn thought the Indians were sleeping In the tepees, as they could see none around. On the way down they went at a little gallop all the way. He did not see anything of MsJ. Keuo on the wuy down, nor did lie hear onv firing. When he saw tlie village ho could svu children running and play* lug about, und ponies running around. Custer appeared glad; he took off Ids hut and swung it, and shouted to tho men, “Courage, bovs; we've got 'em 1 As soon us wo get through this jot) we will go hack to the station.” He gave orders to thu Adjutant to write a dispatch Ui Col. Henteen, and sold to witness, "Orderly. 1 want you to take this order to Co). Henteen ”; und he told him to hurry os last as ho could go with thu dispatch, und If he found hn could get buck without 100 much danger from the Indians to come buck to his command: If he could not get back, to rcuqrt to his own compsnv. The column of Custer turned off to the right immediately. Witness went buck ou the same trull that Cus ter had takcu down. Ho urged his horse as fust as ho could. When he got back upon a high bluff he looked down In the bottom and saw Hcno already engaged with the Indians. He met Capt. licntccn coming luck, und deliv ered Ida orders. Ho did nut tell Cant. Henteen that lluno was engaged, because Henteen did notask him. [A smile from the spectators.) Witness was not over three-quarters of an hour or au hour going back. Ho dlu not halt an Instant anywhere, nut even when bo saw Heno engaged, as Im knew the order be bad was Important,and he was expected to hurry. Upon delivering his order to C’epl. Henteen the latter dispatched him back to Copt. McDougall with orders to hurry up tho pack-train, and not let It get too far behind. Neither Capt. Henteen nor Capt.
The U.S. government will require Sitting Bull and his followers to surrender as prisoners of war or remain in Canada. Reports indicate his camp has crossed into American territory due to lack of buffalo, raising concern among military officials.
The Democratic Advocate · 1 February 1879 · page 3
trouble is feared. It is ascertained that the Government will | require Sitting Bull and his people to snrrcu der unconditionally as prisoners of war, or go back into Canada. General Sheridan is ad vised that Silting Bull’s “whole camp" is on this side of the line, and that “the British Assineboines are camped with the American Assiueboines." Tho reason given for the crossing of the border by the Canadian In dians, as well a* Sitting Bull’s force, is the lack of buffalo north ot the Missouri river.
A gossip item reports Captain French of the Seventh Cavalry claiming that General Reno hid himself during the height of the Little Bighorn battle. The brief item offers no corroboration or context for this serious accusation.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The News and Herald · 1 February 1879 · page 1
GE.NERIAL GOSSIP. Captain French, of the Seventh Cavalry, asserts that during the heat of the Custer massacre fight General Reno was hidden away somewhere. In his journey toward Tashkend the Amer is preceded by nine ele phants and two thousand horses, carrying his women, treasure and baggage. Governor Roberts, of Texas, wil not order an election to fill the va-. cancy in the Forty-fifth Congress, caused by the death of Gustav Schleichler. He thinks that the session is now too short. The German societies of New York are to receive the remains of Bayard Taylor on arrival with ap proprilte honors.
See moreSee less
The remains are to lie in state at the City R%ll and the societies are to sing a dirge over the body Bishop Chatard is annoyed by the rumor that he probably will succeed Archbishop Purcell, of Cincinati. He tolls the Indianapolis Evening News that in all likelihood Arch. bishop Purcell's tenure of office will expire with his life. A Cornell professor lecturing on the efiect of the wind in,some West orn forestq, remarked : "In travel" ing along tha road I even sometimes found the logs bound and twisted t o. gether to such an extent that -a mule couldn't climbover then, so I went around." General Longstreet's salary a postmaster of Gainesville, Ga., wil be $1,100 a year-a larger sum than he received as lieutenant general of the Confederate States. He thus gets more for licking postage stamps than for licking-as a rebel would say-than for licking Yan kees. Little Willie Anderson limped into the witness-box in the Louis ville Court on Thursday, and swore that he saw his father, Robert An, derson, kill his mother. Willie isa eleven years old, a small, lame, pale faced child, of such intelligence that. his testimony was admitted without. hesitation. There is talk and trouble in In-. dianapolis because wine was used and used freely at the Washington club house in the dinner given to celebrate the seventy-second birth day anniversary of Governor Wil liams. The temperance peopl'e throughout Indiana are - censurmg the once steady Blue Jeans. Edg ar Wyatt, who was the central figure in the story of "The Moon shine Mlan," published in Harper'* Weekly, killed William Pffanz, his passistant, in Hart county, Ky., the other day. Wyatt was United Statea Special Bailiff. He lost one eye in crusading against illicit distillers, and in real life, as well as fiction, is a character. The hand that rocks the cradle, is the hand that moves the earth. Dr; Bull's Baby Syrup is the best reme-. d y for all complaints children are sahjcct to, such as dysentery, diarrhcea, summer complaint, etc. Price 25 cents. * New Summer Cook. The Safety
Lieutenant Charles DeRudio testified at the Reno inquiry in Chicago that Reno was first to cross the river to attack the Indians, and that the retreat became a panic when men refused to obey orders. He also stated he saw nothing indicative of cowardice in Reno and believed more Indians attacked Reno than Custer.
Daily Press and Dakotaian · 1 February 1879 · page 2
THE AEN0 TRIAL Chicago, Jan 29.—Chas. DeKudio, first lieutenant of the Seventh cavalry, testified in the Keno case to-day that Keno was the first one to cross the river to attack the In dians. The retreat was like a panic, be cause the men refused to obey his orders to remain and he was cut off in the timber, where he heard a heavy volley firing down the river, which he believed was Custer. The Indians passed eo close tohim that he could hear their children crying. They fired the woods and moved away on the morning of the 26th, same being dresstd in the massacred soldiers clothes and one wore Captain Thomas Custer's garments.
See moreSee less
He saw nothing indicative of cowardice in Reno. He acted splendidly. He believed more Indians attacked Reno than' Custer. Edward Da yen, orderly to Reno, gave his testimony which was not vital.
A dispatch from the Reno Court of Inquiry reports testimony by scout George Herendeen describing the chaotic retreat of Reno's column after the skirmish line collapsed. He recounts soldiers fleeing in panic, the death of scout Bloody Knife, and men scrambling back to the timber under fire from pursuing warriors.
Public Ledger · 1 February 1879 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image
RENO'S RUN.
How He is Declared to Have Scampered From the Indians.
See moreSee less
A special dispatch from Chicago, dated the 27th, says:
The 13th day of the Reno trial opened with some fresh testimony,
George Hesendeen, an experienced scout, was placed on the stand. This witness said he was a scout and courier with General Custer on the 25th of June, 1876, accompanying Reno's column; he had been in several engagements with the redskins; concerning Custer's order to Reno the witness testified that as he overheard it it was in effect that Reno should lead out and Custer should follow him; they were not opposed by Indians as they went down the bottom; to estimate the distance of the Indians from them after the skirmish line was formed, the witness, Girard and another scout all took aim at one Indian, but the bullets fell short; he thought the Indians were from 700 to 900 yards away; just as the retreat was about to begin the witness rode up close to the major; a volley was fired by the hostiles; Bloody Knife, the Indian scout, some ten feet ahead, fell dead from his horse.
Major Reno had ordered the men to dismount; then, immediately, he ordered them to mount again, and everybody ran for his life; the retreat was just as fast as spurs would make an American horse go; witness followed the command as rapidly as he could; everybody was running for his life; the horse of witness fell, throwing him, and perhaps twenty Indians stumbled over him; witness then started back for the timber; as he did so the men were still coming out of the timber, and he heard an officer say, "Company A, halt; for God's sake do not run!" the halt was not effected; witness got back to the timber and found some men mounted and some dismounted; he advised these to turn back to the timber and try to lead the Indians off; they did so, and the party took up a position in the timber; they remained there two hours and were not molested by the Indians; the men had plenty of ammunition; they were scared at first, but got over it and proposed to fight.
Down the river he heard the sound of firing in volleys, in the direction of the Custer battle-field; that firing lasted an hour; over where Reno was, however, he heard during that time only scattering shots; probably Custer was half a mile beyond Reno's Hill when the major began his retreat; the Custer battle-field was about two miles from the same point; late in the afternoon the witness left the timber, and eleven soldiers, three of whom were wounded, and joined Reno; they left two men behind; in getting out they encountered five Indians, upon whom they fired, and the redskins ran; crossing the river (the water up to their necks) they saw the troops on the hill; Lieutenant Varnum came down to meet them; the only conversation he had with Major Reno was that evening, when he interpreted for Half Yellow Face, of whom Reno asked what the Indians appeared to be doing; the witness could not say who appeared to be exercising command; the witness estimated the number of fighting Indians at 3500; witness said emphatically that he did not believe that the Indians could have driven Reno from the timber had he remained there; he did not think that the Indians could have driven one hundred men with 5000 or 6000 rounds of ammunition out of the timber where Reno's command was.
Mr. Gilbert then examined the witness. The order which the witness saw delivered to Reno to cross the river and charge the Indians was given by General Custer in person; the witness did not see Colonel Cook, the adjutant, deliver any such order. After the witness had rehearsed the narrative of his adventures up to the time when he rode out into the glade and saw Major Reno's men mounted, he testified that Major Reno, after he gave the order for retreat, rode very fast through the timber; he saw nothing of Reno in the timber except when he gave the two orders in the glade.
When Mr. Gilbert had finished the cross-examination, Lieutenant Lee extracted a little more direct testimony, and Colonel Merritt asked the witness if he went over the battle field the next day after the massacre. The witness said he did not; he was quite positive that no fighting occurred at the place where Custer was supposed to have attempted so cross the river, for he would have heard the firing.
A witness describes Major Reno's chaotic retreat from the timber near the Little Bighorn, including the panicked mounting and dismounting, scattered gunfire, and later regrouping with wounded soldiers. He also recounts hearing volley fire from Custer's battle a few miles away and gives his opinion that Reno's men could have held the timber position.
Public Ledger · 1 February 1879 · page 4
Down the river he heard the sound of tiring in volleys, in the direction ot the Custer battle-field ; that firing lasted an hour; over where Keno was, however, he heard during that time only scattering shots ; probably Custer was half a mile beyond Reno's Hill when the major began his retreat; the Custer battle-field was about two miles
A witness testifies at the Reno Court of Inquiry that Custer personally ordered Reno to cross the river and charge the Indians, rather than the order coming through Adjutant Cooke. The witness also describes Reno's retreat through the timber and states he did not visit the battlefield until some time after the fight.
Public Ledger · 1 February 1879 · page 4
tune wncn he rode out into the glade and saw Major Reno s men mounted. ho testiued that Major lteno. atter he ' gave the order for retreat, mdo very last throucu the timber; he hnu - nothing of hem in tho timber cxccid extracted a htte more direct testimony, Cries of assent ana coionei .ucrnti askca tne witness it bo went over tho battle held the ; uoxt, uay alter tne massacre. J nc ' witness said ho did not; ho was quite tuiL ittt'A V n it f rrY I r rr aahii an4 k the place where Custer was supposed to have attempted so cross the river, for ho would have heard the firiug.
At the Reno investigation in Chicago, Capt. Frederick Benteen testified about the morning of June 25 at the Little Bighorn, describing Custer's dismissal of scout reports of nearby Indians and the orders given regarding ammunition and pack-train details. Benteen also recounted receiving orders to take his battalion of three companies to scout a line of bluffs to the left.
Chicago Daily Tribune · 2 February 1879 · page 16
FREDERICK WILLIAM BENTEEN. He was Captain in the Seventh Cavaliy, and a Brevet-Colonel in the United States army. He testified that on the morning of the 35th he was with Custer and Reno at the mouth of the Little Big Horn. He recited the circumstances of the scouts’ reporting to Gen. Custer that the Indians were close by, etc. Custer ex pressed belief that this was a mistake, as he had looked through his glass and could see no Indians. The company commanders were in structed that one non-commissioned ofiicer and six men from each company should go with the pack-train, and no more.
See moreSee less
Benteen, for formal ity’s sake, went to his First Sergeant and gave his directions, which also included that every man should have 100 rounds of cartridges in his belt and in bis saddle-bags. He reported to Custer that his oraers had been carried out. Witness received orders from, the General to take his column of three companies, which bad been apportioned to him in the division, and go away to the left to a line of bluffs. The Chief Trumpeter brought him instructions that if he found nothing at the first line of bluffs to ride to the second. He afterward received an order througn the Sergeant-Major to tile effect that be snould go to the first valley, if he found one, and If he found nothing therc ; to go on to the next vallcr, and take everything that he found in his way* He went off to the left, as directed, several miles; hot as he found no Indians and no valleys, he concluded that it was a mistake about there being Indians in that direction, as the country had no facilities for tin in. He had been ordered, also, by Gen. Custer, to send an officer and some men ahead of his column to take bearings, etc. These reported back, and staled that there was no change in the country for miles ahead, and witness thought it his duly to return to the main column, fic accordingly started back upon his trail, and shortly afterwards struck Lie trail of Custer. He came to a tepee in which he found a dead warrior. In due time
A witness testifies at the official inquiry about whether the timber position could have been held longer, and describes finding Custer's battlefield scattered with bodies showing no line formation, suggesting a rout. He also describes watching the Indian village moving away in organized fashion the next morning.
Chicago Daily Tribune · 2 February 1879 · page 16
THE POSITION IN THE WOODS,
BATTLEFIELD OF CUSTER, as it appeared to him afterward when he made au exammatioa.wich a view of finding out how the battle was fought: He said the ground was scattered about for a space of twenty-five or thirty vards with dead oodies. There was no appearance of a line anywhere. It was the same as if one was to take a handful of corn ami throw it upon the table or floor. The only ap pearance of a line there was, was four horses, which were arranged at regular distances, as though ou a skirmish line, with the bodies of the men who owned them lying just ahead of them, looking as though they were making for the point occupied by Custer.
See moreSee less
A thing that witness could not account for was that
At the Reno Court of Inquiry in Chicago, Colonel Benteen, third in command at Custer's battle, gave testimony highly favorable to Reno, praising his generalship and courage. Benteen now estimated Indian numbers at over 8,000, though he had earlier believed there were no more than 2,500.
The Cheyenne Daily Leader · 2 February 1879 · page 1
V ILLINOIS. ’ Good Testimony for Reno. Chicago, Feb. I.—ln the Reno in quiry, Col. Benteen, third officer in command at the Custer campaign, gave evidence which was the most favorable to Reno of any yet elicited. He com mended Reno’s generalship and cour age. lie estimated the Indians as numbering over 8,000, although at that time he had not believed them to ex ceed 2,500.
At the Reno Court of Inquiry in Chicago, Colonel Benteen, third in command during the Custer campaign, gave testimony most favorable to Major Reno yet heard, praising his generalship and courage. He estimated the Indian force at over 8,000, though at the time of the battle he had believed it numbered no more than 2,500.
New-York Tribune · 3 February 1879 · page 5
MAJOR RENO'Ss CONDUCT COMMENDED. Ciicaco, Feb, 2.—In the Reno inquiry yesterday, Co on | Be ton, tue third officer in comand in the Custer campaign, gave evidence which was the wo-t favorable to Major Beno of avy yet elicited. He commended Reno's generelalilp and courage. He esti wated the [uduns as numbering over 8,000, althoug. at that time he bad not believed tum to exceed 2,500, Waenever a head or set was shown it Grew a voley | from the ludiaus, ' rc t—
Witnesses at the Reno Court of Inquiry testified about Custer's conduct of the battle, with Col. Benteen reiterating his belief that Custer handled it badly due to poor organization. Lieutenant Edgerly testified that Reno appeared excited upon first sighting the Indians, and that Custer's gunfire was heard for forty-five minutes from Reno's position.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
Daily Los Angeles Herald · 4 February 1879 · page 2
Tbe neuo Court of Inquiry. Chicago, Feb. ;>.—Tho Reno case continued: Col. Hen teen reiterated his belief tbat Custercouducted the battle badly. The bodies of all his officers save four wore found lying together aud apart, from the private soldiers, showing bad organization. Dr. Loru and Lieutenants Sturgis, and Porter were not found and may he captives. Lieutenant W. 8. Edgerly, of the cavalry, testified that Reno's conduct was excited when he first saw the Indians. Cus ter's firing was distinctly heard from the Reno headquarters and lasted three-quarters of an hour. There waa no reason to believe that Custer and hisoffioers disgracefully abandoned their meu. root end EMnylsi Demi. Boston, Feb. 3J.—Rev. Henry Dana, poet and essayist, Is dead.
At the Reno Court of Inquiry in Chicago, Colonel Benteen testified about the vague orders he received from Custer before the battle, calling them a 'senseless' command to go 'valley hunting.' The Recorder pressed Benteen on his opinion of Custer, suspecting the testimony aimed to portray Custer as incompetent to exonerate Major Reno.
The New York Herald · 4 February 1879 · page 4
HOW THE SEVENTH DIED.
BF.NTEKN's FEKMMi TOWABD CCSTEK. The testimony of Colonel Benteen was so decidedly adverse to General Custer tliat the Heeorder asked witness if at the time of the fight lie entertained a good opinion of General Custer and was in accord with him. Colonel lienteeu made a rather evasive reply, remarking that lus opinion was as good as it ever bad been and he was as much in accord with Geueral Custer as he ever hud been. Mr. Gilbert objected to further interrogations of this kind. Uecurdcr Ime said that it appeared to
Testimony at the Reno Court of Inquiry addresses whether Custer's officers led charges or fought defensively, with Benteen stating there was no sustained charge and that the command tried to defend itself to the last. Lieutenant Edgerley then testified about troop movements and the arrival of trumpeter Martin with news of Custer's attack on the village.
The New York Herald · 4 February 1879 · page 4
DID CUSTER'S OFFICERS FIGHT ?
character. DID Ct'HTKB's OFFICERS FIOHT ? The cross-examination was continued and brought out the fart tint the departure to tho right was tho d.roelion in which Major lieno waa found. Tho whole idea of witness was that there would be a tight, ul.in., anil it waa his dill v to be where he could ifivo assistance. H<> liail pursued tho lino of his order far enough, he thought, though there wan no limitation except ue to valleys. The Indians remained iu tho bottom perhaps thirty to sixty minutes after witness name up, but ne dul not believe tho wholo of them left at all.
See moreSee less
He knew from Indian sources that tho Indians were prepared to ambush Keno if ho sought to come out to tho attack. WitnesH did not believe that the officers of Custer's command had ronght with their companies. There was do sustained resistance so far aa the evi- . deuce went. The bodies of tho officers were found with their companies. If there ho<l been a charge it was the duty of the officers to lead it. aud they would have died outside of enclosure like the men. The evidouco was that there hail been no charge, but that the command had tried to lefcud itself to the last. Four officers had never been toiiud, vis , l)r. Lord and Lieutenants Ktnrgia, Harrington and Porter, who it lsjpoaaibla
A witness testifies before the Reno Court of Inquiry about Major Reno's conduct during the battle and describes observations of the Custer battlefield, including signs of a defensive line and rapid collapse of Custer's command. The witness estimates Custer's men were killed within twenty to twenty-one minutes.
The New York Herald · 4 February 1879 · page 4
ItotV I'l'sTI'.ll LUKD. Wltno** detailed lit* observation on the Cnstrt battle Held, and, to his mind, then' were at dr*t evidences of a Una of defence. Cslhoiiti had borne the brunt of the engagement. The last of tlie commauil. however, was considerably scattered, I lie final lull where Custer was round m evidently a graul rallying point. The evUeMo was that tit* men had boon overcome by good odds. Knowing th<t soldiers, oh lie did, witness felt aunt there had been it hard light while it laetc<L lie thought Custer and his men boldly fought tint oilda against them.
See moreSee less
Witness thought much of tho firing oil the Custer battle field was duo to the raudoni shots of the Indians to show their Joy. Custer's command must have beeu killed within twenty or twenty-one minutes. The Court odjourned until ten oYlnck to-morrow.
At the Reno Court of Inquiry, Benteen finished his testimony about joining Reno's detachment and his opinion of Reno's conduct, followed by Lieutenant Edgerly taking the stand. Benteen described receiving orders from Custer, admitted he may have disobeyed them, and explained his reasoning based on the large number of Indians already known to be ahead.
Chicago Daily Tribune · 4 February 1879 · page 3
MAJ. RENO.
wter Martin, to burry up and bring the train 25 him, witness thought that Custer must : e been already dead, as it was about 3 o’clock In the afternoon. Witness supposed, of course, hti Custer expected each of tho columns to Inonort the others In case either found the InJiuir but there were no instructions given him further than that he should go on lo tho first ti Ist and, If he found nothing, to go on to tho .Mond These were his exact orders. There were not alley* there In a direct line for twenty miles, L consequently the orders of Custer could not be carried out without traveling in that di rection IndefinitelyIt might have been provl ilenilal, or accidental, or whatever they bad a mind to call It, his coming back at the time he did He could scarcely consider bis own ac tion* m a compliance with the orders of Gen.
See moreSee less
Caster; hi fact, It might have been a practical disobedience of orders. lie considered the or der of Custer directing him to go off valleyUnllDga senseless command then, and he did noir. They were already upon the trail of 8.000 or 10,000 Indians, and be Old notconridor it worth while hunting up a few more. Tho rca (on for his thinking that there was that nuro btrof Indians ahead of them was this: Gcu. trookhad fought with thoso same Indiansa ibort time before, and there were enough of item to influence Crook to let them alone. Aud then the tralllndlcaUd that there waa an im mense number. Witness was asked bis opinion as to what were the plans of Custer at tho time ho ordered Reno to charge upon the left bonk of the river, ilo replied that he presumed that It was Custer’s Intention to attack the further end of tho vil lage simultaneously with Rano, charging tho nearest point. Witness did not proceed down the river on his return on tiie left-hand ride, because there were about WO Indians over there, which fact offered a serious objection. At tho time ho received tho order from Trumpeter Martin, tho Pick-train was about seven mtlvs away. Wit ness rode a very fast walking horse, and tbo column had lo trot to keep up,—.Urn right of the line at a slow trot and tho left at a fast trot,—conscaucntly, thero was no occasion to (Tiro any command to trot to tho men, as thoy were already at that gait. Ho had not changed his opinion regarding that fight since It took place. Recorder Lee asked a series of questions as to
A witness at the 1879 Reno Court of Inquiry is questioned about his relationship with Custer and his views on the general's decisions during the Little Bighorn fight, including the division of the column and whether battle lines were formed. The defense objects to questions about personal relations with Custer, and the witness suggests Custer might have saved men by retreating after the first attack.
Chicago Daily Tribune · 4 February 1879 · page 3
AMICABILITY OR ANTAGONISM
AMICADILITT OB ANTAGONIST exiiUoe between witness uml Gen. Custer At that time socially* but to tbls Mr. Gilbert opJccted. He said tlmt MsJ. Reno was upon inves tigation, not Custer. • Lieut. Lee said that ho thought It was neces sary to show thu relations existing between any of the witnesses and Gen. Custer In order to ptsltlie motives, etc., uml It was desired to show to the Court whether or not M«J. Kono was guilty of the charges preferred against him. It had been the burden of the testimony to show that Custer was weak and Incompetent; Hut bo scot out bis column In divisions, Imper iling the safety of tbo men, whereby bo lost a large portion of his command, and was himself killed: The Court decided that the questions by the Recorder were not competent, out before tbls htd been done the witness bad answered tbe queitlons Indefinitely by stating that his rela tions with Custer were as amicable at that time u they ever bod belt).
See moreSee less
lie was asked what would have been tbe re sult. or how be would have been met In all probsbillty by the Indians, had he gone down into the bottom across the river when became up. He replied that bo thought tbo Indiana would have received them kindly, bad they gone down there, and would have mas sacred the whole lot. The officers wore Id quite as much clanger as their men. snd u was tbe duty of the officers to remain uml die with their men, If necessary, lie was asked whether, In his opinion, any lines of battle wero funned by Custer. Ho thought not: U they bad Hues, thu officers would have been killed upon those lines, lie (bought tbo men whose bodies were found In the ravlue were wounded and went there to hide, Hr. ullbcrt wished to make a statement. It was not the wish of the defense In this In vestigation to reflect In any manner upon Uie conduct yf (Jen. Custer In this engagement, or tu any particular from his heroism or In answer to a question by the Recorder as to ■het nr Cuater might not have fled with the fmaloder of Ida command after the llrst attack, and thus have saved a portion of the men from Qcftractioa, witness replied that he thought ho “Did, ami that in that instance discretion soula have been tho better part of valor, tbkb Urt toolc * receu 01 dre minutes, after LIEUT. WINFIELD S. BDOBBLT
At the Reno Court of Inquiry in Chicago, Colonel Benteen testified he believed Custer had conducted the battle badly, while Lieutenant Edgerly testified Reno appeared excited upon first sighting the Indians. Witnesses stated Custer's firing was heard from Reno's position for about three-quarters of an hour, and found no reason to believe Custer or his officers had disgracefully abandoned their men.
The Rock Island Argus · 4 February 1879 · page 1
The Xtang Cae, Chicago. Feb. 3.-rCoL Benteen testi fied that he believed Custer had conducted the tattle badly. Lieut. . S. Edgerlyot the ah cavalry. testified that Reno's conduct was excited when he first saw the Indians. Custer's firing was distinctly heard from the Reno headquarters and lasted three quarters of an hour. There was no reason to believe Custer and his of5cer9 disgraoetully abandoned their mea.
At the 1879 Reno Court of Inquiry in Chicago, Col. Benteen testified that Custer likely planned a rear attack while Reno hit the village from the front, and described which officers' bodies were found where. Lieut. Edgerly testified that Reno appeared highly excited and disheveled atop the hill but was not so impaired as to hurt his command's effectiveness.
The New Orleans Daily Democrat · 4 February 1879 · page 1
THE BLODGETT INVESTIGATION—RENO'S EXCITEMENT AT THE BATTLE OF THE LITTLE BIG HORN
citement at the Battle of the Little Big aorn. Cnicaoo, Feb 3--Notwithstanding the ab set ce of Mr. Lapham the investigation of the charge against Judge Blodg tt wer.t forward to-oay without interrupt:. n. It is understood that the investigation will be comple'ed by Messrs. Knott and Culbarson. Registrar Hlib bard was examined for the defense to-day on the eueppre-sed perjury indictment charge. His construction of the law In regard to returns was the same as Judge Blodgett's. He had con sultal other prominent lawyers, and they agreed with them. In the Beno tunrqvry to-day Col. Benteen said he believed Oen.Custer's plan was to attack THE .NEW ORLEANS DAILY DEMOCRAT,
At the Reno Court of Inquiry in Chicago, Col. Benteen testified that Custer had mismanaged the battle, noting most officers' bodies were found together apart from the men. Lieut. Edgerty countered that there was no reason to believe Custer's command had disgracefully abandoned its men, and speculated some missing officers might still be captives.
Daily Globe · 4 February 1879 · page 1
Edgerty Defends the Memory of the Fallen Brave. CHICAGO, Feb. 3.The Reno case was contin ued to-day, and Col. Benteen reiterated his be lief that Custer conducted the battle badly. The bodies of all his officers save four were found lying together and apart from the pri vate soldiers, showing bad organization. Dr. Lord and Lieuts. Sturgis, Harrington and Porter were not found, and may be captives to day. Lieut. W. S. Edgerty, Seventh cavalry, testi fied that Reno's conduct was excited when he first saw the Indians. Custer's firing was dis tinctly heard from the Reno headquarters, and lasted three-quarteis of an hour.
See moreSee less
There was no reason to believe Custer and his officers dis gracefully abandoned their men. The Pittsburgh Literary Loan exhibition was opened yesterday to crowded rooms. The dis play of fine arts, books, etc., is pronounced superior to anything ever before seen in this country. The proceeds are to be devoted to the Young Men's Mercantile library.
The court of inquiry into General Reno's conduct at the Custer massacre continues slowly, with Sergeant S. A. Culbertson of Fort Abraham Lincoln testifying. Culbertson stated that Reno had no choice but to retreat, as the overwhelming number of Indians would have quickly overrun his command.
Public Ledger · 4 February 1879 · page 2
! II 1 jail is cauea. Tho investigation of General Reno, as to his responsibility for tho Custer massacre is getting along slowly. The latest testimony, that of Sergeant S.
Testimony at the Reno Court of Inquiry in Chicago includes Colonel Benton's belief that Custer mismanaged the battle, noting officers' bodies found separated from soldiers. Lieutenant Edgerly testified Reno appeared excited upon first sighting Indians, and denied that Custer and his officers disgracefully abandoned their men.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
Memphis Daily Appeal · 4 February 1879 · page 1
The Reno Case Continued.
gis, Harrington and Porter were not found, and may bi captives to-day. Lieutenant W. S. Edgu-ly, S.'venth cavalry, testified that Reno's conduct 7a excited when he first nil iv the Indians. Custer" firing was dis tinctly lieyj from tlie ieno tead-iuarters
At the Reno Court of Inquiry in Chicago, Col. Benteen testified that Custer had mismanaged the battle, noting that most officers' bodies were found grouped together apart from enlisted men. Lt. Edgerly testified that Reno appeared excited upon first sighting the Indians, that Custer's gunfire was heard for forty-five minutes, and that there was no reason to believe Custer's officers had abandoned their men.
The Cheyenne Daily Leader · 4 February 1879 · page 1
Benteen on Custer—Edgerly on Reno.
Mswott S; lost 3. Uallaghar won 8; lost 3. Osrater won 3; lost 4. Bodolph won l; lost 8. Haiser won 1; lost S. diers, showing bad organization. Dr. Lord, and Lieuts. Sturgis, Harrington and Porter were not fouud, and may be captives to-day. Lieut. W. 8. Edgerly, Seventh cav alry, testified that Reno’s conduct was excited when he first saw the Indians. Custer’s firing was distinctly heard from the Reno headquarters and lasted three-quarters of au hour. There was no reason to believe that Custer and his officers disgracefully abandoned the men.
In House debate over army appropriations in February 1879, Representative Mills invokes the Custer massacre to criticize Democrats for cutting troop levels, claiming Custer and 300 men were killed by 2,000 Native Americans. The exchange veers into broader political sparring about Reconstruction-era troop deployments and the 1876 Electoral Commission.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
National Republican (Washington City) · 5 February 1879 · page 3
down tho army on a plea or economy to seruro their re-election, while tho borders wcro left un protected and Iho massacre of Custer and his Ihreo hundred men by two thousand savages permitted,
During House debate on the army appropriation bill, members argued over reducing troop levels, with several citing the Custer massacre and ongoing Rio Grande border troubles as reasons to maintain a larger army. Representative Mills of Texas controversially blamed Democratic budget cuts for contributing to Custer's death.
The Portland Daily Press · 5 February 1879 · page 2
HOUSE. The House went Into the committee of the whole on the army appropriation bill. An amendment re ducing tie army to 15,003 men was defeated by a large majority. Quite a stormy debate arose on the army appro priation bill on the amendment of Mr. Cox of New York to reduce the army to 17,500 men, in the course ot which Mills of Texas charged the Democrats with the responsibility of Custer’s death, because of their miserable economy. House reiected the amendment reducing the army to 19,000 men, and also reducing it to 20,000 meD, 66 ayes, US nays Several amendments were oflered, reducing the army to 20,ot0 men and Ie?s.
See moreSee less
Along and spirited discussion occurred between prominent members on both sides The Democrais also had a little side show, which was characterized by the Republicans as a family fight. Seveial spicy speeches were made retemng to -the Custer massacre and unsuppressed Rio Grande invasions as reasons for increasing the army; also the Baltimore and Pittsburg riots, which the militia were unable to control. Thioekmorton ot Texas opposed tho redaction. The people of his and bordering states have been and are still suffering because of this miserable economy which has cost his peop'e millions of money and millions of lives. Mr. Kiefer asserted that if it had not been for the few troops ga hered in Washington by President Grant two years ago, the decision of the electoral commission would have been overturned by violence and revolution, an t a man put into the Presidency who was not elected by the people. He was in favor ot a larger army than 25,0 0. Sir Cox ot New York said there was not a member on the floor who did not understand very well that out for a certain menace and but for the sendiDg out of orders for troops and artillery to come to Wash ington the electoral commission wonld never have been created. Timid citizens, money lords and bond-holders, (men constitutionally afraid of revolu tion and who would rather submit to fraud and wrong than to violence and revolution,) when that menace came from the chief executive, and when all arrangements had been made, (as they are being made now tor 1880,) had been frightened and that fright had been the procreative cause of the electoral commission. This menace had made some members of the House succomb to a power that was merely ph) sical, not moral. That was a part of the history of the country. The bill appropriated some $26 002, 000 for 25,600 soldiers. The same average had existed for the last ten years What good had it ever done? Had it settled the Indian question? No. Had it given protection on the Rio Grande? No. It had only eaten out ihe substance of the people. The amendments to reduce the army wore finally rej ected. The majority report from the House naval eommit ee charges that under Robeson’s administration the navy department was greatly mismanaged and calls the attention of the President to the fact and leaves further procedure to his discretion.
At the Reno Court of Inquiry in Chicago, Col. Benteen reiterated that Custer mismanaged the battle, noting most officers' bodies were found grouped apart from the men. Lt. Edgerly testified about Reno's agitation and that Custer's firing was heard for forty-five minutes, with speculation that Custer's command had become disgracefully separated.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Princeton Union · 5 February 1879 · page 5
Edgexty Defends the Memory the Fallen Brave. CHICAGO, Feb. 3.The Reno case was contin- -ued to-day, and Col. Benteen reiterated his belief that Custer conducted the battle badly. The bodies of all his officers save four were found lying together and apart from the private soldiers, showing bad organization. Dr. Lord and JJieuts. Sturgis, Harrington and Porter were not found, and may captives today. Lieut. W S Edgerty, Seventh cavalry, testi fied that Reno's conduct was excited when first saw the Indians. Custer's firing was dis tinctly heard from the Reno headquarters, and lasted three-quarters a hour. There was reason believe Custer and his officers dip gracefully abandoned their men.
A witness testifies at the Reno Court of Inquiry that Capt. Benteen seemed to be acting as commanding officer during the battle, and that many men believed Custer had been abandoned. A packer named John Frett also testifies that Reno, apparently drunk, cursed at and slapped him on the night of June 25th.
Chicago Daily Tribune · 6 February 1879 · page 3
ordered tho troops to charge was he was where Lecould see the Indians, and Ileno was where be could not; also that Heno went with the troops on the charge, nnd Hint was one act wbldi he saw Reno perform. Ho sold that. In his mind, a commanding officer In hesitating In receiving a suggestion from the officer next In command Indicated no fear necessarily, but rather deliberation and prudence. It appeared to be the general Impression among tho men that Custer had got Into some light place where be could not get to them, and that be had abandoned them.
See moreSee less
Ueu. Merritt asked witness If, when he moved down to the point occupied by Capt. Weir, he could see from there anything in thu direction of Custer’s battlefield. Witness replied that be could not. JOUH fRKTT
A witness testifies before the court of inquiry about Major Reno's conduct during the battle, describing a small flask of liquor Reno carried and stating he saw no evidence of drunkenness or cowardice. The witness also discusses assumptions about Custer's movements and Reno's exhausted command being unable to search for Custer after their own engagement.
Chicago Daily Tribune · 6 February 1879 · page 3
nothing In rrplv. In regard to Custer, witness said he did not know tvlut impression there whs among the officer* mid men almut his having gone uIT to Join Terry, and leaving Ileno nml Ids command, undid not have any such idea himself; Im did nut think Custer would do that. He thought at Mint time that Custer had become Hemmed In, und could not get to them with Ids wounded men. Reno's command was In no condition to. go out to hunt up Custer, iu his -Judgment, as they were pretty well exhausted when Ihctr own engagement was over, und went to steep.
See moreSee less
’ll>cy had all they could do to take care of themselves. In reply to questions by the Recorder, witness said he did not know as it was customary, but he knew that a great many officers did take a flask of liquor with them when they went out uu expeditious; he had done so himself. They usually got It filled, also, when it was empty, provided there was anything to till It with, lie saw no uvldcuccs of cowardice on tho part ol Maj. Heno.
During the Reno Court of Inquiry, Captain Moylan testified that Reno's decision to leave the timber was wise and necessary for the survival of his command. He stated he saw nothing cowardly in Reno's conduct, noting evidence of desperate fighting among Custer's dead and arguing that charging the Indians or remaining in the timber would have led to annihilation.
Bozeman Avant Courier · 6 February 1879 · page 2
The words of this article could not be separated from the rest of its page. Read it in the clipping.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
Daily Press and Dakotaian · Yankton, S.D.
At the Reno Court of Inquiry in Chicago, Col. Benteen testified he believed Custer handled the battle badly, noting officers' bodies were found grouped apart from the men. Lt. Edgerly testified Reno seemed excited and that Custer's firing was heard for three-quarters of an hour, with no evidence that officers had abandoned their men.
Daily Press and Dakotaian · 6 February 1879 · page 2
Chicago, Feb. 3.—The Reno case was continued. Col. Benteen reiterated his be lief that Custer conducted the battle badlv. The bodies of all his officers when found were found If ing together and apart from tlie private soldiers, showing had organize lion. Dr. Lord and Lieut's. Sturgis, Har rington and Porter were not found, and may be captives to-day. Lieutenant W. S. Edgerly.'of the Seventh cavalry, testified that Rent's conduct was excited. When he first saw the Indians Custer's firing was distinctly heard from the lieno headquar ters and lasted three quarter of an hour. Tbere was no reason to believe that Custer und bis ofiicers disgracefully abandoned their men.
A human-interest anecdote about a tramp who was fed and sheltered by a Dakota farmer, later returning in secret and anonymously gifting the family a fully equipped farm in gratitude. The farmer is identified as the brother-in-law of Kellogg, who died beside General Custer at the Little Big Horn.
The Kenosha Telegraph · 6 February 1879 · page 6
Joseph Poorgrass, “ feels his humble gratitude” for favors received, stands vindicated. Fours years ago, a Dakota farmer—a brother-in-law. by the way, of Kellogg, who fell beside General Custer, on the Little Big Horn—had finished his supper, when a dirty, ragged, foot sore tramp called at the house and
The Reno inquiry took a new turn as two witnesses on consecutive days swore under oath that Major Reno was drunk on the day of the Custer massacre. The report notes this direct testimony could place Reno in a very awkward position unless the witnesses are impeached.
The Cheyenne Daily Leader · 6 February 1879 · page 1
A new turn has been taken in the He no inquiry. Two witnesses on two consecutive days swore that Reno was drunk on the day of the Custer massa cre. The testimony we publish this morning is most direct, and unless the witness can be impeached, Reno will be placed in a very awkward poeition, to say the least. Smith M. Weed was before the Pot ter sub-committee yesterday. lie admitted the genuineness of the cipher telegrams printed in the New York Tribune. He further said that he ciphered some dispatches to Henry Havetnyer, in New York. This is at least interesting testimony, for Have myer wrote a card immediately after the cipher exposures emphatically de nying that he had ever sent or received a cipher telegram.
Captain McDougall testifies at the Reno inquiry, describing the pack train's march to join Reno on the hill and his limited observations of Reno's demeanor during the fighting. He states that every man there was brave, and the defence begins presenting Reno's official report.
The New York Herald · 7 February 1879 · page 5
MAJOR RENO'S TRIAL. CLOSE OF THE TESTIMONY FOR THE PROSECUTION—EVERY MAN THERE WAS BRAVE ON RENO'S HILL—OPENING OF THE DEFENCE—RENO'S OFFICIAL REPORT READ.
Chicago, Fob. 6,1879. The Bono inquiry opened this morning with Capi tain Thomas McDougall, of the Seventh cavalry, on the witness stand. The Captain certainly guve a more concise account of the Custer battle than has been given by any previous witness during tbe inquiry. He briefly and rapidly describod how he, being left in charge of the pack train, led it, along Willi a rear guard, on Custer's trail; how the mules got stuck in the morass; how the train came along at last to the "teepee" with a dead Indian in it, and how at last they all arrived on the hill where lteuo was; here he saw lteuo and reported to him that the pack train had come up; then lteuo told him he (McDougall) had lost his lieutenant; McDougall called Reno's attention to the dull sound of tiring down the river, and then went away to throw out a skirmish liue; the next evening he was walking with Reno, and Reno told him that he (ltcno) would have to make a
Witnesses testify at the Reno Court of Inquiry about Major Reno's composure and bravery during the battle, with Captain McDougall stating he saw no whiskey or drunkenness. Reno's official reports to the department and General Terry are then introduced, describing his decision to retreat to high ground after realizing his forces were being decoyed by Indians.
The New York Herald · 7 February 1879 · page 5
pretty thick, but be didn't seem to mind tbem. SAW NO WHiaKKY. Captain McDougall then gave a description of the Indian village and the Custer battle field; the general conclusions which he arrived at were in accordance
Springfield Weekly Republican · Springfield, Mass.
A roundup of Washington news notes that the Reno inquiry in Chicago this week produced testimony favorable to Major Reno. Colonel Benteen, third in command during the Custer campaign, praised Reno's generalship and courage.
Springfield Weekly Republican · 7 February 1879 · page 1
In the Reno inquiry at Chicago this week con siderable testimony was given favorable to the major. Col Benteen, the third officer in com mand in the Custer campaign, highly commend ed his generalship and courage. Postmaster Snowdon of Philadelphia has had the offer of the late Dr Linderman’s position of director of the mint, but declines. Gen Sherman, after a brief visit at Savannah, is now sunning himself in Florida. The Washington branch of the Potter com mittee still keeps up the motions of the Louisiana investigation, but the heart has all gone out of it.
See moreSee less
The sub-committee of Teller’s men (Teller of Colorado, Cameron of Wisconsin, Kirkwood of lowa. McDonald of Indiana, and Randolph of New Jersey), who have been conducting the in vestigations in Louisiana and South Carolina, have returned to Washington and have been listening there to a continuation of the story of election rascalities from the lips of Mackey, O’Connor and Campbell.
Springfield Weekly Republican · Springfield, Mass.
The report states that Sitting Bull's main camp remains across the Canadian border and that he vows never to return to the United States, though many of his followers might return under acceptable terms. This reflects the ongoing aftermath of the Sioux conflict following Little Bighorn.
Springfield Weekly Republican · 7 February 1879 · page 1
years, was started Saturday. The latest news from Sitting Bull is that his main camp is still across the Canadian border and that be himself vows that he will not re turn to this country, although many of his braves would return If they could make satis factory terms.—The Nes I'erces offer to cede their lands in Idaho for 8250,(XX) to lie in the treasury and draw 4 per cent interest, and the secretary of the Interior will ask Congress to make the necsary appropriation, when the tribe will be located west of the Ponca reservation.
See moreSee less
The Theater Roni at Glasgow wa« burned last week. It bad a seating capacity of 4000 and the largest stage In the kingdom, aud cost $150,000. The surrogate of New York county resumed the hearing tn the Vanderbilt will case this week. Zenas C. Crane, division superin tendent of the New York Central milBcpwbKom.
Springfield Weekly Republican · Springfield, Mass.
This report covers congressional business, including the defeat of the army bill amid debate over reducing troop numbers, during which Mills of Texas accused Democrats of causing the Custer massacre through budget cuts. It also details other legislative matters including telegraph provisions, post-office appropriations, and the Mississippi levee bill.
Springfield Weekly Republican · 7 February 1879 · page 5
the democrats with being responsible for the Custer massacre through their miserable econ omy. The two features that killed the measure were the closing of the national armories and setting the general of the army over the secre tary of war. An appropriation of $250,000 was
Testimony at the Reno Court of Inquiry includes Col. Benton's belief that Custer mishandled the battle and that officers' bodies were found grouped separately from soldiers, suggesting poor organization. Lt. Edgerly testified Reno appeared excited upon first sighting Indians, but the inquiry found no reason to believe Custer and his officers had disgracefully abandoned their men.
The Corvallis Gazette · 7 February 1879 · page 2
While there is no hint ot any renection upon the integrity of the venerable Catholic dignatary, there is manifested among credit ors considerable im-atience at the delay to which they are subjected, and threats of suits are beginning to be heard. The Reno case was contained to day. Col. Benton reiterated his belief that Cus ter conducted the battle badly. The bodies of his officers, save four, were found lying together and apart from the private soldiers, showing bad organization. Dr. Lord, and Lieuts. Sturgis, Harrington and Porter were not found, and may be captives.
See moreSee less
Lieut. Y. S. Edgerly, 7th Cavalry, testi fied that Reno's conduct was excited' when he first saw the Indians. Custer's firing . was distinctly heard from Reno's hepdquarOI . 1 I . .. 1 1 ..... . on l.r.nr leiS, Jill l ) iv; i 1 1 (juai 110 "J ... '1 here was no reason to believe Ouster ana his officers disgracefully abandoned their men.
A Chicago dispatch reports testimony from John Felt, a civilian packer with Custer's column, given before the Reno Court of Inquiry. Felt testified that on the night of June 25th, Major Reno, while very drunk, slapped him for a trivial reason, spilling whisky on him.
Daily Press and Dakotaian · 7 February 1879 · page 1
John Felt of St, Paul, who was a citizen packer with Custer. He testified that on the night of the 25th Maj. Reno, for a tri fling cause, slapped hiin in tbe face, and that whisky from a bottle in Reno's bands flew all over him. He would say Reno was very drunk.
Colonel Benteen describes receiving orders from Custer to scout bluffs to the left with three companies before the battle, finding no Indians or valleys as expected. He recounts returning to the main trail, finding a dead warrior in a tepee, and receiving orders about the pack train.
Daily Press and Dakotaian · 7 February 1879 · page 2
Chicago Inter Ocean. Saturday the Reno investigation proceeded by the examination of Colonel Frederick William Benteen. On the morning of the 25th witness, who was third in command of the forces, was with Reno and Custer at the mouth of the Little Big Horn. While there the scouts reported the proximity of the In dian village, of which Custer expressed adoubt having failed to have discovered any In dians even with the use of a glass. Witness received orders from the General to take his column of three companies which had been appointed to him in the division,and go away to the left to a line of bluffs.
See moreSee less
The chief trum peter brought him instructions that if he found nothing at the first line of bluffifcto ride to the second. He afterward received an order from the Sargeant Major to the ef fect tbat he should go to the first valley, -if he found one, and if he found nothing thetd, to go to the next valley,and take everything that he found in his way. He went off to the left, as directed, several miles but as he found no Indians and no valleys, he con cluded that it was a mistake about there being Indians in that directiou, as the coun try had no facilities for them, He had been ordered, also by General Custer, to send sn officer and some men ahead of i&> col umn to take bearings, ete. These repotted back, and stated that there was no change in the country for miles ahead, and witness thought it bis duty to return to the main column. He accordingly started back up on his trail, and shortly afterward struck the trail of Custer. He came to a tepee in
Captain Benteen testifies about following Custer's trail, receiving orders, and finding Reno's command being overwhelmed by Indians before the retreat to the hilltop. He describes positioning companies defensively, estimates of Indian numbers, and exchanges about whether Reno could have moved toward the sound of firing.
Daily Press and Dakotaian · 7 February 1879 · page 2
When he got nearer be concluded tbe troops were being whipped, and pretty soon the retreat commenced. Witness was of the opinion tbat bis discovery of tbe In dians and^their cognizance of his presence were about simultaneous, and this bad the effect of checking tbe Indians in their pur suit. At their meeting witness asked Reno where Custer was, and Reno replied tbat fae did not know. Witness fixed the number of Indians at 900 or 1,000. He heard flr^g down the river, but not in volleys. After, Beoteen's command came up, Captain Weir sallied out without orders, for bravado as witness thought.
See moreSee less
Major Reno was coo) and collected at tbe meeting, tbougb a lit tle "blowed" from the exertion of coming up the hill. Lieutenant Lee—Do you not think that the command of Beno could have gone down in the direction in which you heard the firing? Witness (laconically)7#e could, bit we would all have been thsrefet. [Laughter.] The command oould not suoeassfally have
A witness testifies at the Reno Court of Inquiry about the confused, planless nature of the battle, estimating Indian numbers at 8,000-9,000 and defending Reno's conduct as cool under fire. The witness states officers believed Custer had abandoned them to join Terry, and a separate item reports Cheyenne prisoners being transferred from Fort Robinson to Leavenworth.
Daily Press and Dakotaian · 7 February 1879 · page 2
same. In reply to a question witness replied that the conduct of Major Reno at the time of the engagement was as cool as could be expect ed, and of a nature to inspire confidence among the men. Witness .admitted that be might havejoined Reno in the woods,but con sidered the coarse be took the most advisa ble. He said the position might have been held in the bottom perhaps four or five hours, perhaps all night but tbe Indians would bare Men reinforced in tbe morning, and tbe troops would have all been killed unless they bad been reinforced.
See moreSee less
If tbey could have intrenched themselves in tbe woods, be thought tbis would bave been a better position tban on tbe bill. Witness described tbe Custer battle field following tbe Same facts given by others. On tbe cross examination witness said be had seen no evidence of cowardice in M»jor Reno. The latter'several times stood in dangerously exposed positions togiveordws and witness hid cautioned him at one time for standing in front of tbe intrenebments against wbicb the volleys were coming. In reply to a question from Mr. Gilbert, witness stated tbat it was the ueceral belief of the officers on the bill that Custer had gone to Gen Terry, and bad abandoned them to tbeir fate. Witness said be was out "valley bunting" [laughter], and there was no plan of batt!e. ttewas sent out to find more Indians, there were no Indians, no tenees and no smoke in sight when be left. Reno bad no right to suppose be would come back to support him. Suppose he (witness) had found Indians, would Reno bave come to his assistance? Tbe distance was too great. Tbey would all have been wiped out before tbey could bave got together. There seemed lobe no plan of action. Shortly tbe cross examination concluded, and court ad journed until 10 o'clock this morning.
The item states that the ongoing Reno Court of Inquiry appears to show Reno was too far away to be held responsible for the massacre of Custer and his command. It frames this as an emerging conclusion from the investigation into Reno's conduct at Little Bighorn.
Colored Citizen · 8 February 1879 · page 3
■ The Reno investigation seems to |Row clearly that Reno was too far |Biay at the time to have been in the Hast responsible for the massacre of ■nster and Custer’s command.
Major Reno gives sworn testimony describing the regiment's movements on the morning of June 25th, including Custer's orders to Benteen and the advance toward the Indian village. He recounts crossing the stream, forming line, and sending word to Custer that strong Indian forces were ahead.
Chicago Daily Tribune · 8 February 1879 · page 3
MAJ. RENO
regiment waa then formed into companies. ,° clock the command moved again, anortly thereafter Lieut. Cook approached and said that Ueu. Custer bad ordered him to tako cummuml of Companies M, A, and 0. ,k l» that nil I 1 * and Lieut. Cook re c. yv? " Capi. licutecn had started up the wii, and Ucno asked him where ho waa going, and was answered that be (Ueutecn) was going ** drive 011 before him on the bill. Upt, llontccn had Companies H, D, and K, and weiu over to the leu.
See moreSee less
The other columns moved over to the other aide of the stream and •uvaneca as fur as the tepee, when the command ing oiikur beckoned with his bat to cross over, imre was some dllUculty in crosstug, so that wocttwuucu reached the other aide he waa to owu column and behind Custer, mre Lttut. Cook brought Ute cummaud to OTti° the front. When they got there there »i7.*i ,utuo ** tloo og the Indiana, and he coo iinucd to move on. Lieut Cook again brought t^. r ,ruHl Custer to move for a.L a wpid gait. Lleuta. Wallace ami Hudson were with witness at the time, i 1?.,; n . *"• command into a trot and moved Uiu * ral *’ cruaaed the stream, and formed o lonmauimi into line, keeping one in reE™ w* opposite aide of the stream. Ho In ,i'°. uvn V ed . l ‘‘ at C»c Indians were tbercaboula m "K m,m *>era. Thcrefora be sent »atk to Custer word that u * UtbUHa WXIiB in FKOMT IF STRONG fOKCI.
Major Reno describes ordering the retreat from the timber to the hilltop to save his men, and the subsequent fighting and fortification against Indian attacks. He states he had no suspicion that Custer's column had been destroyed during the engagement.
Chicago Daily Tribune · 8 February 1879 · page 3
men were crossing hurrledl? In some confusion. heavy Are was kept op all the time bjr theUl A iana, who were armed with Winchester rifles, ihe only/reason ho changed bis position from Ihc tlmocr to tin* hill on the other side ot the stream was that the men would have better chances lor their litres, and he (wit* ness) headed the column so Unit he might rally the men when they rcuc-licd the hill. AT THE ntLL he pnt the men in skirmish-line. He bad no reason to expect Capl. Rcntcen to aid him, tint he soon rode down to see Benteen, and he then moved hie men up to the hill.
See moreSee less
Witness was told about Hint time that Lieut. Hodgson had been shut. He went then ou foot down to the river where Hodgson lay, and left CoptBenteen in command ot the force on the hill. ♦Witness took from Hodgson's person a ring and a bunch of keys, nnd returned to the top of the hill. He had then lu his command ten wounded men. After the pack-train came in sight Hie force moved down the stream about it mile, and ny witness 1 command halted ami returned. After reaching the hill witness told Capt. Benteen to tsko care of one side of the hip. and witness looked after the oilier. Witness look D Com pany and placed It where the attack was ex pected. He remained there himself. The firing commenced as soon as the men were gotten into lino, mid continued till dark. At 9 o’clock In the eveulng witness moved some of ihe com panies ami told the company commomlcrs to pro tect themselves as best they might. There were but three spades ami a few axes in Hie com mand. As witness understood the plans, Gen. Terrv was supposed to be coming up the Little Big Horn Valley. Witness expected to be re lieved by clilicr Custer or Terry. He had MO SUSPICION TUAT CUSTER HAD RBBX DB-
This is a review of Frederick Whittaker's biography of General Custer, which argues that Reno and Benteen's failures, not Custer's errors, caused the Little Bighorn disaster. The reviewer notes the book will attract attention due to Whittaker's role in the ongoing Reno Court of Inquiry, while praising its accuracy regarding Custer's earlier career.
Chicago Daily Tribune · 8 February 1879 · page 16
OEN. COSTER'S I*IFK, “ A Popular Life of Ucu. George A. Custer, Major-General of Volunteers, Brevet MajorGeneral U. S. Army, and Lieutenant-Colonel Seventh U. S. Cavalry, by Frederick Whittaker, Brevet-Captain Sixth New' York Veteran Cav alry,” has been published by Bhcldou A Co., of New York, and can be obtained of A. O. Nct tlclou «& Co., 09 Uearlwm street, Chicago. Thu author of this biography, it is known, was the prime mover in tiiu Uuno Investigation, now being held In this city, lie believes, and in this book gives his reasons for believing, that if Ueno had fought us Custer fougnt, and if Ben teen hod obeyed Custer's orders, the battle of the Little Big Horn would have proved Custer's last aud greatest victory; and that.
See moreSee less
If Gen. Uraut. actuated by private revenge, liau not dis placed Custer from command of the Kurt Lincoln column, Custer would bo alive now and Iho Indian war settled. This biography will undoubtedly at tract special attention in consequence of Us relation to a topic of current diseussiou. Whatever may be thought of the author’s capac ity to Judge fairly of the unfortunate Little Big Horn ulToir, there will lm no dispute in re gard to the general accuracy of his account of Gen. Custer's previous career, which was, in some respects, the most romantic and stirring In the recent history of the United Stales army.
A sarcastic editorial mocks the ongoing Reno Court of Inquiry, joking that witnesses first proved Custer was dead and now seem bent on burying him figuratively forever. It also pokes fun at rival newspapers, local political appointments, and unrelated local gossip in the same miscellany column.
Bismarck Tribune · 8 February 1879 · page 4
AT first' the witnesses in the Reno en quiry were contented with demonstrating that Custer was dead. They have now gone beyond that, and having proved that he is "deader illa four horse.trip-ham raei\" are erigaged in burying him so deep in the blood stained prairie that the crack of doom won't reach him with a ten milo artesian auger. Great are army in vestigations and Seventh Cavalry "Colon els" are tlieir chief prophets!," ... IT is w?th feelings of profound gratitude that THE TBIBUNK notices a brief but re markable obituary on its editor, fulmina ted by the three ply jackass whom God.
This item is a sarcastic, joke-format synopsis of testimony from the Reno investigation, mocking witnesses for giving vague, contradictory, and nonsensical answers about their positions during the battle. It satirizes the unreliability of eyewitness accounts given at the inquiry into Reno's conduct at Little Bighorn.
Bismarck Tribune · 8 February 1879 · page 4
one respect Custer's death had a ben IH eficial effect, in that it reduced the num. ber of "Colonels" in the Seventh Cavalry to about six. IF thfe investigating board is really anx ious to get at the stern realities of that fa mous battle, it might be profitable to ex amine the tail of G-irurd's horse. As the Fargo Independent has not come to hand this week, we infer that it has busted, or that its editor has said some in fernally mean thing about THK TRIBUNE, of which he is very properly ashamed.
See moreSee less
IT will be highly gratifying to many of the constituents of the Hon. Ansley Gray, (of the Territorial House of Representa tives) to know that he has been appointed one of the committee on Banks and Bank ing. have received a letter from our fath WE
A satirical newspaper piece parodies the ongoing Reno investigation with absurd mock Q&A testimony, mocking witnesses' contradictory and nonsensical claims about Custer's and Reno's actions at the battle. The piece also contains unrelated sniping between rival Dakota Territory newspaper editors over political patronage jobs.
Bismarck Tribune · 8 February 1879 · page 4
SYNOPSIS of the testimony so far in the Reno investigation: Q. Where were you during the battle Witness. I was situated midway be tween any two given points where I could see without hearing on one side and hear without seeing on the other. Q. Which way were you looking? Witness. Toward the side on which I could hear. Q. Towwd which side were you list ening? Witness. The side on which I could see. Q. What did you hear? Witness. I heard Custer wave his hat. Q. Are you sure his hat was off?
See moreSee less
Witness. Yes it was a mile and a half off. Q. What did you see Witness. I saw Custer promise to sup port Reno. Q. Did he do it? Witness. No he ran away toward the Indians and left poor Reno in the lurch. Q. What did Reno do Witness. He couldn't do anything. Custer got between him and the Indians so there wasn't anything for him to do. Q. Are you prepared to swear that the action of Iieno made any difference in the result of the battle
A newspaper miscellany item notes that a Chicago paper's review of testimony from the Reno Court of Inquiry tends to clear General Custer of charges of rashness or bad judgment at Little Bighorn. The writer endorses this view, citing the reviewing paper's access to full inquiry testimony.
The Cheyenne Daily Leader · 8 February 1879 · page 2
a Chicago paper of the testimony in the Reno inquiry, tending to clear the name dT Gen. Custer from all suspicion of rashness and bad judgment. The pa llet has Had the best facilities for ob
The article discusses the ongoing Reno Court of Inquiry, noting that evidence is slowly clarifying the facts of Custer's last battle and tends to exonerate Custer from charges of rashness. It argues the inquiry should also examine whether Custer disobeyed Terry's orders, asserting that existing orders show Custer was told to locate the Indian camp and then use his own judgment.
The Cheyenne Daily Leader · 8 February 1879 · page 3
RENO vs. CUSTER.
Chicago Times, Feb. 3. < It may be that Capt. Whittaker, the ' author of the “Life of Gen. G. A, Cus- « ter,” was engaged only in a shrewd es1 fort to advertise his book when he 1 made his charge against Reno. If so, 1 the public will forgive his efforts at a < speculation in view of the mass of in- ■ formation which has been developed in the investigation which has grown from Whittaker’s charges. Much that was unknown lias been learned; in oth er, false statements have been correctj { ed; and, finally, from out the mass of) 1 evidence—often vague and contradic- ■ tory It is true—thetruth underlying the !
See moreSee less
■ whole matter is being slowly evolved. ! It is scarcely necessary to say that this . truth is of a character that rights the 1 memory of Custer from the charges of ‘ rashness and bad judgment which have } been so freely circulated since the gali hint cavalryman’s last battle. How far, in righting his memory, the reputa- * tion of his brother officers may be im paired is a question now on trial by the 1 military commission. The alleged disobedience of orders t charged against Custer has not as yet j been touched upon in this examination ; except in a remote manner. This j comes from the fact that the scope of I
This report covers testimony at the Reno Court of Inquiry, arguing that Custer's orders allowed him discretion to attack once he found the Indian camp, contradicting claims he disobeyed Terry's orders. It also cites testimony that horses were not exhausted before battle and that Custer's plan of splitting forces was sound, aiming to exonerate Custer from charges of rashness and bad judgment.
The Cheyenne Daily Leader · 8 February 1879 · page 3
One thing has i>een gone into by the | commission which is of a similar 11aj ture—that is, as affecting both Custer and Reno. The latter, in his report, states as one of the reasons of the de feat the fact that the command made a rapid march of two days and one night 1 before making the attack. This has ' been characterized as rashness on the part of Custer. Now’, the testimony has been almost unanimous before the commission that the horses were not used up when the command reached the „ river.
See moreSee less
The interpreter, Girard, allow ed this, and so have others. These facts completely exonerate Custer from rashness, which has been one of the principal charges against him. Anoth1 er has been that he showed bad judgj ment in dividing his command; in fact, ! j Maj. Reno himself, in his official report j of fho occurrence, gives this as one of tin* reasons of the defeat. Here again the testimony before the commission I clean the memory of Custer from the 1 , charge of bad judgment. His plan wa ‘ ! that Reno should attack one end of the ! Indian village while he struck at its) centre or tin* other end. The evidence j is clear that the plan worked well as 1 far as it was carried out. When Ren > > crossed the river and*commenced mov- ]
The article argues that testimony before the Reno Court of Inquiry exonerates Custer of blame for rashness or poor judgment, instead blaming Reno's unexpected retreat for allowing Custer's command to be annihilated. It claims the evidence proves Custer's original attack plan was sound and would have succeeded had Reno carried out his assigned role.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Cheyenne Daily Leader · 8 February 1879 · page 3
ing down the left bank the Indians liej came panic-stricken and commenced a disorderly retreat. A few scores or perhaps hundreds of them circled al>out Reno's line of skirmishers, evidently for the sole purpose of covering the re1 treat of the main liody. Very natural ly, at the same time, they made a move ment to threaten his rear. These movements were successful, and after ten or fifteen minutes’ skirmishing the ! whole battalliou retreated in a disorder ly manner across the river. They did not display even the generalship of the Indians by making an effort to cover their retreat.
See moreSee less
Herein Custer's plan was broken, not only without his knowledge, but without any adequate reason, if the testimony which lias been given is of any value. Custer moved on down the river, siqqiosing, of course, that Reno was performing his share of the plan. There can now’ no longer lie reason for donbtiug the disgraceful conclusion that Custer was cut to pieces owing the unnecessary and un expected withdrawn! of Reno from the fight; and also 'that the two battalions under Reno lay quiet and undisturbed within sound of the battle while Custer was being annihilated by overwhelm ng odds. For an hour at least after D. O. TRAGY. P. O , Pm, Bluff Wyo. Range, Lodge Polo. r f bt ' «“• aw.Uuw-teH cut; left ear, split. Horse brands, same as cattle, on hip. Horses, same on left hip. A’ ItHEVI p. 0.. ' , 1 n wyo. Range, Pole Creek, and north of Laramie River. E* W. WHITCOMB. P. o. CherIteu.e lleei Cteek, O. P. GOODWIN. P. O.,Cheyenne Wyo. Range on Bear Creek, Lara mie Couney, Wyo. Branded as above on left shoulder side, rib or hip. Earmarks, half under-crop in eacb ear. Horses branded on left shoul der.
Major Reno, in a Chicago Times interview, says he will defend Custer's memory during the upcoming inquiry since Custer cannot speak for himself. The Bismarck Tribune mocks Reno's comment and attacks him over an alleged slight against officers' wives on the frontier.
The Cheyenne Daily Leader · 8 February 1879 · page 4
Hough on Reno. During a recent interview with a • Chicago Ttrues reporter, Reno is re1 ported to.luivn nsed this language: He (Custer) cannot speak for him self, and I shall use every effort during the progress of the inquiry to shield his memory. Whereupon the Bismarck 7Wfarte re sponds: If this bombastic warrior will be k{nd enough to let Custer’s reputa tion take care of Custer’s memory, he will confer a favor on Custer’s frienrtyi It will be more iu keeping if Major Reno will explain the nature of the ex perience from which he deduced the implication that the wives of officers on the frontier ate not entitled to the courtesy due ladies wherever they may be.
See moreSee less
It occurs to thinking men that in vestigation into iiis courage might well stop at his wholesale attack upon re spectable women.
Major Reno concludes his testimony before the court of inquiry, denying that liquor affected him or that cowardice motivated his retreat to the hill. He describes his movements during the battle, including disciplining a skulker near the pack train and his lack of awareness that Custer's command was in serious trouble.
The New York Herald · 9 February 1879 · page 9
MAJOR RENO'S CASE. CONCLUSION OF THE MAJOR'S TESTIMONY—HE WAS NOT AFFECTED BY LIQUOR—NO CONFIDENCE IN CUSTER AS A SOLDIER—THE DEFENCE RESTS AFTER SUBMITTING DOCUMENTARY MATTER.
to the hill ?" "No, sir," said witness, with emphasis, lie testified that he heard no firing down the river until alter the command began to move down, and then only a few scattering shots. He had no idea that there was a serious engagement, and at no time did it occur to liitu that General Custer was in serious trouble or dead. tifk majob's soiikikty. Mr. Gilbert?With regard to your sobriety, Major, I should like to have you state how much liquor you bad with you. Witness?Well, sir, I had some whiskey with me.
See moreSee less
I carried it in a small tlask in my coat pocket. I got the liquor at the Rosebud. It was a small fiask. I did not drink a drop of its contents until long after the firing ceased the first night on the hill, at about twelve o'clock. Mr. Gilbert?It becomes my duty to ask if you wero at any time affected by liquor? Witness?I was not. The whiskey in the fiask was used the morning of the :17th on the Custer buttle field, the stench being so severe that the officers used the liquor. I had several timet* been to tlic pack
Major Reno testifies about his positions during the battle, failed attempts to send communications to Terry and Custer, and his belief he would be supported. Under cross-examination he admits he had no confidence in Custer as a soldier despite expressing friendly feelings.
The New York Herald · 9 February 1879 · page 9
THE MAJOR'S MOVEMENTS.
most of the time. On the 'ititli he was with Sergeant Lacy down at a knoll shooting at Indians, as they galloped past them every now and then in troops of hulf a dozen. He saw no special reason for encouraging the men, for they appeared to be doing well. He saw Captain Godfrey sometimes, but some of the officers could not see him except when he went over where they were. Ho never received any communication from the interpreter, Girard, at the crossing "A." On the night of the '25th he tried to get communications to General Coster, but the men would not go.
See moreSee less
The Crow scouts talked about going, but would not do it. On the morning of the '27th he succeeded in sending a communication to General Terry. Witness then identified the communication which asked for aid and assistance. Mr. Gilbert?State whether it does not embody the sense of the communication you tried to send on the '2<>th. and whether that communication which you have nut now did not contain an assurance that you could hold your position? Witness?1 think it did, for I surely thought at the time that I could hold the position. When I went away from Custer 1 understood that I was to be supported and had a right to expect support from the
The passage records Major Reno's testimony before the court of inquiry into his conduct at the Little Bighorn, addressing the wounded left behind, the order to move to the hill, and allegations about a flask of whiskey. The defense then closed by submitting Sherman's report praising Reno's bravery and a War Department letter declining to promote him and Benteen.
The New York Herald · 9 February 1879 · page 9
THE WOUNDED MEN.
in& nninaj'.i rxana. Recorder?Iu regard to the whiskey. Colonel? I should not touch that had it not been that Mr. Gilbert had gone into it. Witness?No objections, sir. The witness testified that his orderly, Gaveru, did not hare charge of his flask either on the 26th or 26th. The witness carried it himself. Recotder?You hare stated. Colonel, that you thought subsequent events justified your conduct. Do you now think that yt>u made no mistake? Witness?If I bad to do ugain, I should do just what I did then, under tile circumstances and with the kuowledgo I had then.
See moreSee less
I think now that Custer's command was dead when I got on to the hill. I obeyed his orders, which sent lue into the timber. This concluded the testimony. cnoaixo thk cask con hkno. Mr. Gilbert concluded the defence by submitting
Major Reno completes his testimony at the Reno Investigation in Chicago, answering questions about his actions during the battle, including losing his hat but not his carbine, firing his pistol in the bottom, and his reasons for moving to the hill. He also addresses questions about his sobriety and an incident striking a man near the pack train on the night of June 25th.
Chicago Daily Tribune · 9 February 1879 · page 5
MAJ. lIENO reoccuoied the witness-chair, and Mr. Gilbert continued the examination. In answer to the necessary interrogatories, ho gave the following evidence: He wore a chip-straw hat on thedaj ol tlie battle, and lost it in the bottom. He did not lose his carbine in the bottom, and never told any one he did; did not fire his pistol from the top of tlie hill; he fired it at the Indians while crossing the bottom, and had no charges left. Mr. Gilbert asked the witness If it was coward ice that prompted him to leave the timber and go to the hill, and me witness replied emphatic ally that-it was not He knew they could not hold .that position in the bottom.
See moreSee less
He heard no firing down the river but a few scattering shots; he had then no idea that, there was a serious en gagement and if did not occur to him that Gen. Custer was in serious trouble or dead. Ue did not know nor did anv one tell him tiiat Custer
Testimony from the Reno Court of Inquiry details questions about alcohol use, troop positions, and communications during the battle. Reno denies drunkenness, explains his tactical decisions, and states he had no confidence in Custer as a soldier despite friendly feelings.
Chicago Daily Tribune · 9 February 1879 · page 5
MAJ. RENO
CONFIDENCE OU DISTRUST TOWARD GEN. CUST£R, and witness said 4, Ycs, sir.” The questioner asked for a prober answer, and the witness, after asking the Court if it insisted on an answer, and receiving an atiirmative reply, said he did not go into that fight with feelings of distrust in Custer; he had none but friendly feelings to ward him, but be had no confidence in him as a
Major Reno testifies before a military court of inquiry, defending his actions during the Little Bighorn battle and his relationship with Custer. He describes troop positions, denies certain accusations, and a petition from surviving officers requesting promotions is also read into record.
Chicago Daily Tribune · 9 February 1879 · page 5
CONFIDENCE OR DISTRUST TOWARD GEN. CUSTER
mand who could not mount their horses. Orderly Daverin did not make any report to him that he had lost his carbine; knew he did not; it was not a lime that he could be bothered t?Uh such reports. He was positive that he did not' lire a revolver about the time Bentecu’s command cameoip. The guidon was placed ou too of tiie hill for the reason that he thought it would attract attention sooner than anything else would. Orderly Daveriu had carried his flask, but did not have charge of it on the night ofthe2stb.
See moreSee less
It was customary to refill a flask if they had anything to refill it with. He wouid have listened to any communication from Girard, but would not nave believed him. He un derstood that Girard had been the basis of most of the information against him. He was quite os anxious to get Gen. Custer to aid him as the latter was to get bis (Reno’s) aid. The results of the battle bad justitied bim, he believed, in acting as be bad, and be would pursue the same course under similar circumstances. He found it impossiolc to charge the enemy, and, in reply to a question put by Lieut. Lee, said that ten men could charge a thousand, but their success was another thing. Witness gave some further testimony in regard to his positioo during the fight, and said he thought there were from COO to 900 Indians in his front during the battle. Mr. Gilbert said be would like to have the testimony closed that day, and he had but little more to offer. The witness continued: He certainly entered the fight with friendly feelings toward Gen. Custer, and felt then that he had done all he could to aid bim; he went “out of there” as much to aid Custer as to have the latter aid him. There was no communication to him from any one in the timber that Custer could be seen. He never thought at the time that the position he bad taken would have to be explained to his commanding officer; he then thought there would be uo Question about it.
The newspaper reports that the ongoing inquiry into Major Reno's conduct has shown Custer's own haste and disregard of orders caused the destruction of his command. It argues Custer sought glory through a reckless charge rather than following the campaign's plan to encircle and annihilate the Indians.
legislature, which is likely to be come a law, requiringtaxes to be paicT on church property. It is only a question of time when all states will have such a law on their statute books. Dennis Kearney does not want the bill to check Chinese immigra tion to become a la for the very moment that it does his stock in trade is, gone. With the Chinese gone, Kearney will be compelled to earn, an shonest livinpor irit. His whole capital has been the in "When that flux of the Chinese, ceases, then what?
See moreSee less
Slowly and stealthily, but surely and fearfully, the " black plague" is advancing westward! 1 - ; rrom eastern JMirope. iiu over southeastern Russia, it is carrying off the people by hundreds andi thousands. Russian and German sanitarv agents are doing all that science and money can do to stay its progress. In many districts the j mail service has been suspended, and railroading between many points is at a standstill. The inquiry into Maj. Reno's conduct has developed the fact, that the sacrifice of the brave and unfortunate Custer, and his three hundred followers, was due to his own haste and indiscretion. He neglected the orders of his superior officers, and expected to win the honors of the campaign by a head long dash, of which he was so fond and so noted. The plan of the campaign was to capture and an nihilate the Indians, and had Cus ter succeeded he would only have dispersed them. Admiration for his gallantry and sympathy for his misfortune should not blind the public to the facts in the case. It is a good deal like the mariner who navigates his ship over a dangerous shoal. If he gets across all safe he is a hero.
Major Reno testified again at his court of inquiry, denying cowardice in his retreat from the timber and explaining his use of whiskey after the battle. He admitted having no confidence in Custer as a soldier but said their relations were friendly, and the defense closed with document submissions, arguments to follow Monday.
The Cheyenne Daily Leader · 9 February 1879 · page 1
End of the Reno Inquiry.
him move from the timber on the hill. ! He had a flask of whiskey with him, j but didu’t drink a drop until the battle ! was over. He used it on the 25th on i the Custer battlo field, where the stench ' was so severe that the officers drank it. j lie was pressed as to an opiuion of Custer, and finally confessed that he )! 1 had no confidence in him as a soldier, but said his relations witli Custer were friendly. Had his own brother been ' with Custer he could not have doDe | matters, lest Pelton might compromise I the democratic general committee?
See moreSee less
j A.—l suppose they had full know ledge, and would be able to take care that nothing wrong should he done. The atmosphere at tiiat time was full of rumors of fraudulent returning | boards. I declare before God and my I country that the votes of Louisiana ' and Florida were bought (meaning by | republicans). 1 would scorn aud conI demn my righteous title if the demo cratic party had secured my scat by j fraud.
The item reports that Gen. Reno testified he had no confidence in Gen. Custer as a soldier, during the Reno Court of Inquiry. The paper adds sarcastic commentary noting Custer's wartime record against Confederate forces as a rebuttal to Reno's claim.
The Cheyenne Daily Leader · 9 February 1879 · page 1
GERMANY. Hostility to Denmark. Berlin, Feb. B.—lt is reported that the German minister at Copenhagen has been recalled. The people of North Schleswig propose to issue a protest, against the abrogation of tiie fifth ar ticle of the treaty of Prague. Should Germany prohibit such action, North Schleswig deputies will formally protest in the reichstag. Gen. Reno testified yesterday that lie had no confidence in Gen. Custer, as a soldier. The government must have been at fault then, in placing confi dence in Custer during the war. ne abused that confidence by abusing the rebels soundly on all occasions.
Major Reno testified in his own defense before the court of inquiry in Chicago, denying that cowardice caused him to retreat from the timber to the hill during the battle. He admitted he carried whisky but did not drink until after the fight, and stated he had no confidence in Custer as a soldier despite friendly personal relations, saying he would act the same way again given the same knowledge.
Evening Star · 10 February 1879 · page 1
Ma.ioh Reno, in testifying in his own i?ehalf xnore the court tit inquiry at Chicago, suturlay, stated emphatically that it was not cowirdice that caused him to move from the timber )n the hill in the battle or Little Big Horn, lie lad a flask of whisky with him. but did no: lrink a drop until after the battle. He was >ressed as to his opinion of Custer, and finally onfessed that he had no confidence in him 1 is a soldier, but his relations with Custer were i riendly. Had his own brother been with Cus1 erl e (Reno) could not have done differently.
See moreSee less
1 le would do the same again under similar clr- ] umstances with the knowledge he then hud. 1 arguments will be heard and thecaseelosed to- | lay. i ' 1 " C
A newspaper reports on Rev. W. H. Ryder's sermon about the Pope's encyclical letter against Communism and Socialism. In passing, the report notes that local newspapers have been preoccupied with the inquiry into whether a high army officer was responsible for the Custer massacre, rather than covering the Pope's letter.
Chicago Daily Tribune · 10 February 1879 · page 5
COMMUNISM. SERMON nr TUB REV. W. It. RYDER, The Hov. W. 11. Ryder delivered a most Inter esting discourse last evening In Bt. Haul's Unl versnllst Church on “TheHope’sKncycllcalLet ter uni Communism,” The official head of Iho Human Catholic Church, ho said, had recently Issued a letter to the faithful, which contained very many things of great and far-rcachtng Im portance, The newspapers of this city had failed, as yet, to bestow upon it the attention It so well deserved, probably for the press upon their time nud space involved in the Inquiry as to whether a high army officer was responsible for the massacre of Gen. Custer, and In the de termination of that other question of even
The Reno Court of Inquiry has concluded, finding insufficient grounds for a court-martial while leaving Reno's reputation damaged by conflicting testimony about cowardice versus tactical necessity. The report highlights how jealousy and factionalism within the Seventh Cavalry, particularly between Custer, Reno, and Benteen, contributed to the disastrous outcome at Little Bighorn.
Daily Globe · 10 February 1879 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image
THE RENO INQUIRY. The Reno inquiry has just concluded, and the main results are before the country. We hardly think, from a careful perusal of the testimony, that sufficient ground exists for the trial of Major Reno by court martial, but sufficient has been shown to prove that his conduct before, during and since the battle of the Little Big Horn, where Custer and his comrades fell, was not such as to increase the respect in which he has heretofore been held. The charge of cowardice was only half proved, and there appears to be an honest difference of opinion as to whether his failure to go to Custer's rescue was due to cowardice or to inability to do so by reason of the overwhelming force of the Indians in his front.
See moreSee less
His partisans are very emphatic in asserting that if he had carried out his instructions he would have sacrificed the lives of every man in his command besides his own, and that he was wise in pursuing the course he did. The partisans of Custer, however, are equally emphatic in declaring that, had Reno's force attacked the Indians simultaneously with Custer's, the result would have been the complete rout of the savages. All this testimony is mere speculation, however, and throws but little light on the subject. One fact, not at all complimentary to the discipline of the army, has been brought out in bold relief by this inquiry. It is that the regiment was distracted by jealousy and divided by contentions of all sorts. Reno was jealous of Custer, and so was Benteen, while Custer was jealous of his subordinates. So far had this disorganization progressed that every officer and private was openly arrayed on one side or the other. When Custer went into battle he had none but his own partisans with him, while Reno's command was composed wholly of the anti-Custer portion of the Seventh cavalry. It has been frequently hinted that the survivors of the regiment were so embittered by the feuds that had existed that they would not have taken the trouble to go to Custer's aid even had it been wholly practicable. Such a state of affairs must be prejudicial to the discipline of an army and greatly impair its efficiency, and we greatly suspect that the Seventh cavalry is not the only regiment that is similarly disorganized. Regiments in the army are generally close corporations, and the public knows but little of what is going on in camp or barracks. Thus it happened that none outside of army circles knew to what extent the bitterness in the Seventh cavalry had attained, and the public know next to nothing of the contentions in other regiments that may be in progress now, and possibly may lead to another Custer massacre. The war department should act decisively in the matter, for it cannot afford to imperil the efficiency of the forces through the toleration of these senseless contentions.
Attorney Gilbert argues that Reno's decisions to retreat from the timber and to the hill were justified, citing officer testimony praising his conduct over that of Herendeen and Dr. Porter. Lieutenant Lee, representing the opposing side, asks for a recess before replying to the arguments.
The New York Herald · 11 February 1879 · page 4
A CONTRAST IN RENO'S FAVOR
rkno's prurent action. Colonel Ben teen's testimony, which was atmngly in support of the disposition of the troops and the conduct of the conmi md on Reno's Hill, wna reviewed with minute detail to prove that Reno did the very best that conld he done in that position: and then It was shown that as Custer's command was probably dead at ati early hour
A military court in Chicago has spent two weeks investigating Major Reno's behavior during the Battle of Little Bighorn, where Custer and his men died. Reno, accused of cowardice for failing to support Custer, demanded the inquiry himself; witnesses are divided, and no verdict has yet been reached.
Luxemburger Gazette · 11 February 1879 · page 6
Mühle in einen Trümmerhaufen verwan— delt, vier Männer getödtet und ein gewis— ser Joseph Horn lebensgefährlich verletzt nueden. Die Veranlassung gab Fahrläs gkeit. Ein Kriegsgericht in Chicago untersucht seit zwei Wochen die Haltung des Majors Reno in ter Schlacht am Little Big Horn, wo der tapfere Custer mit sei nen braven Leuten den Tod fand. Reno war mit seiner Abtheilung Soldaten wäh—- rend des Gefechtes in Nähe gewesen und hatte keine Schritte zur Unterstützung von Custer gethan; er wurde seit der Zeit inund außerhalb der Armee der Feigheit be schuldigt und er hat sich deßhalb gezwungen esehen, selbst eine kriegsgerichtliche Unter—
The report states that Major Reno, who fought with Custer, is undergoing a court-martial in Chicago on charges of cowardice. It notes the proceedings have lasted four weeks and that testimony so far favors Reno.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Spirit of Democracy · 11 February 1879 · page 3
ITE.T1S. Bus su8peri8lona and failures are as frequent in England as they are in Amer ica. . , - -. ... The Free Methodists commenced, a protracted meeting at SucQmerUeld," No ble county, on the 2d inst. '' WorRme on the B it S W. railway are now engaged in putting np bridges at mouth of Rocky Fork and at Ander son's Run Betmont Chronicle The courts-martial at Chicago, before which Major Reno, who fought with Custer, is on trial for cowardice, has
The Reno Court of Inquiry concluded testimony and arguments, with Recorder Lieut. Lee arguing Reno's retreat to the timber and hilltop allowed Indians to overwhelm Custer's command. The court then cleared the room to deliberate a verdict, which will be sealed and sent through military channels to the President for review.
MAJ. ItlftTO. TUB INVRSTUMTION OVBtl. The Reno Investigation came to an end yester day morning, us far as thu taking of testimony uiul the hearing of arguments was concerned, and the Court ut Inquiry now has thu cheerful task of deciding upou thu conflicting testimony and formulating a report fur thu Secretary of War. The closing argument of Lieut. Lee, the Recorder, occupied about uu hour In Its delivery, the Lieutenant dwelling at length on Reno’s retreating to the timber and then lu the hilt, In stead of charging thu Indians and holding them In cheek according to Custer’s orders, .which retreat was thu means uf giving the Indians on opportunity to go back mid demolish Custer’s command.
See moreSee less
It had been shown, the Recorder claimed, that Reno knew uf the presence uf a heavy force ot Indians be tween himself and Custer, and that ilrlug was beard In the direction iu which Custer must have gone, and Reno's admission that he had no confluence In Custer os a soldier should ho taken into coualderatfou in connection with the fact that others than he had known Custer during the War and alterwsrds, ami held a very Ullfcr ent opinion on that subject. Lieut. Leo re ferred at length to the disorderly movement to thu hill, and remarked that It was but natural that sumo uf the survivors uf that fatal day should uuw believe tnui what Keuu ordered was fur the best. Thu question to be determined was, whether his conduct was such as should have been expected Irum an olllecr under the cir cumstances. Llcul. Lee also read certain extracts from Reno’s report, containing statements which varied somewhat from Reno’s statements at this day. At the conclusion of thu argument there was a brief recess, after which the room was cleared, uml the Court began Its inquiry as to what the verdict should bo. The (hiding of the Court will be sealed and transmitted to the AdJuUnt-Ueueral of the Army at Washington, who will place ft In the hands of Judgo-Advo cato-llenorul Dunne for review and revision. Thence It will bu sunt to thu President, aud pro mulgated by the Adjutsnt-Uenerul. It is the impression ttinunv many that the Court will attach' special weight to tho testi mony given by the packers relative to Ma|. He no's Intoxication, and will report that lu lliclr opinion sultldeot grounds exist for the prefer ring of cbtrges and his trial by a court-martial.
A humor/opinion column compares rumors that Zulu king Cetshwayo reads French and admires Napoleon to earlier false claims made about Sitting Bull following the Custer massacre. It mockingly suggests the press invents sophisticated traits for native leaders after major defeats.
Chicago Daily Tribune · 13 February 1879 · page 5
Wo shall soon hear from French sources that Cetbwato reads French, mid greatly admires Napolbon. ' That is what they told us about Sitting Bull niter tho Custer massacre. Tho Enquirer advises the Southern negroes to emigrate. Suppose they should move Into Ohio and Pennsylvania, and make those Slates solid ■for OaSSAu lo 1880. If anybody should bo killed for saying, “Never. Whatl Never! Scarcely ever," wo would consider It praiseworthy homicide. The next thing for tho Democrats is to slip In a little amendment to an anpropriatlou bill abolishing the Christian religion. Spite of the fact (hat ho returned the salary grab, Z. CnANUi.cti will bo elected United States Suuator from Michigan.
A Chicago telegram reports that Major Reno again took the stand on February 8th at his court of inquiry, denying cowardice and discussing his use of whiskey during and after the battle. He admitted having no confidence in Custer as a soldier but said he would have acted the same way again under the same circumstances.
The Worthington Advance · 13 February 1879 · page 1
E E N O CUSTER E N I ('iiicago telegram: Major Reno was again on the stand Feb. 8th, answering ques tioux, nplied emphatically that it was not cowardice that made him move from the timber on the hill, lie bad a flask of whisky with him, but didn't drink a drop until the battie was over. II used it on the 27th, hen on the Custer battle field, where the t-tench was so severe that officers drank it. He was pressed as to his opinion of Custer, and finally confessed that he had UD confidence in him as a soldier, but said his relations with Cu-ter were fiieudly.
See moreSee less
Had his own brother been with Custer he could not have done different ly, lie would do the same again under the same circumstances with the knowledge he then had. The long trial was closed by the defense submitting some documents. The arguments will be submitted Monday and the case closed.
At the Reno investigation in Chicago, Col. Benteen reiterated on Feb. 3 his belief that Custer mismanaged the battle, noting most officers' bodies were found grouped apart from the soldiers. The report also claims four officers—Dr. Lord and Lieutenants Sturgis, Harrington, and Porter—were not found among the dead and might still be captives.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
Stevens County Tribune · 13 February 1879 · page 2
Mr. Seward's life. In the Reno invtatigution time now in progress at Chicago, Col. Benteen, Feb. 3, re iterated his belief that Custer conducted the battle badly. The bodies of all his officers save four were found lying together and apart from the private soldiers, showing had organ ization. I)r. Lord and, Lieuts. Sbirgis, Hair rington and Porter Were not found, and may be captives to-day. John Danham of Minneapolis, charged with having taken improper liberties with young jfirls, and with having made infamous proposals to young ladies, met Joslah Town
The People and New Hampshire Patriot · Concord, N.H.
This editorial comment lists several current military investigations, including the charge of cowardice against Major Reno at the Battle of the Little Bighorn where Custer was killed. It's cited alongside other unrelated military misconduct cases as examples of congressional scrutiny of the army.
The People and New Hampshire Patriot · 13 February 1879 · page 2
Horn where Custer was killed, the charge of bigamy against Capt. Blair of the fif teenth infantry, the charge against Lieut. Tiffany for desertion induced by threatened
This report covers Senate and House proceedings in February 1879, including debates on Army appropriations and troop reductions. During the debate, Representative Mills of Texas charged that Democratic budget cuts were responsible for Custer's massacre, invoking the 1876 battle as a political argument years after the fact.
Belmont Chronicle · 13 February 1879 · page 2
CONGRESS.
the army to aeventeen tnousand men. Mr. Mills, of Texas, charged Demo cratic economy with being responsible for tbe massacre of Gen. Custer. All the propsitions for reduction were de feated. At tbe evening session the
A military court convened in Chicago to investigate Major Reno's conduct at the Little Bighorn has finished hearing testimony after three weeks and about two dozen witnesses. The testimony reportedly favors Reno, who stated under oath that while Custer was brave, he had no confidence in his military judgment.
The Kenosha Telegraph · 13 February 1879 · page 2
WASHINGTON NOTES. Canadian papers say there is no foundation for the story that Sitting Bull has returned to American soil The President has nominated Digby
A military court of inquiry convened in Chicago to examine Major Reno's conduct at the Battle of Little Bighorn has concluded testimony after three weeks and about two dozen witnesses. The testimony is reported as favorable to Reno, who stated under oath that while Custer was not lacking in bravery, he had no confidence in Custer's abilities as a soldier.
The True Northerner · 14 February 1879 · page 2
Big Horn, where Custer and his comrades met their sad fate, has concluded the testimony. The court sat for three weeks, and examined seme two dozen witnesses. Tho testimony is regarded as favorable to Maj. Reno. The lat ter made a sworn statement in his own behalf, ia which he said that, while he regardod Gen. Cuater as not lacking In bravery, he had no confidence whatever in his genius as a sol flor. Owing to the large bouses and popu lar en thueiadn with which the people of Chi cago have gr eted Alice Oates and her troupe, Manager Haverly h retained that company for another week tho present at which the attraction is the popular comic opera, "The Cbimej of Nonmudy .w
A newspaper item reports that roughly five hundred British soldiers and fifty officers were killed in a clash with Zulu forces, with large losses of stores and ammunition. The writer calls it "a Custer massacre in another land," invoking Little Bighorn as the public's instant shorthand for a shocking military disaster.
The Columbian · 14 February 1879 · page 2
WICKED PADDY
The words of this article could not be separated from the rest of its page. Read it in the clipping.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
Northern Ohio Journal · Painesville, Ohio
A military commission that had been sitting in Chicago investigating Major Reno's conduct during the battle in which Custer and his men were killed concluded its proceedings on the 11th. The report will be forwarded to Washington for public release.
Northern Ohio Journal · 15 February 1879 · page 1
000 pounds of cheese and 1,500,000 pounds of butter, of which $27,000,000 worth was ex ported. The military commission which has been sitting at Chicago for some time as a court of investigation into the conduct of Major Reno at the battle in which General Custer and his
This report describes a British military disaster in the Zulu War, where a column under Lord Chelmsford was annihilated by Zulu forces on January 21st. It opens by explicitly comparing this defeat to the earlier massacre of Custer's army by Sitting Bull and his warriors.
The News and Herald · 15 February 1879 · page 2
A Roar from the African Lion. - t The massacre of Custer's army by a Sitting Bull and his braves finds a I parallel in a recent British reverse in N
This report describes a British military disaster against Zulu forces, listing officer and soldier casualties and captured matériel including wagons, oxen, cannon, rifles, and ammunition. It estimates Zulu losses at five thousand and notes Lord Chelmsford's forced retreat, warning of a prolonged conflict.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 4 days later.
Wrong
The News and Herald · 15 February 1879 · page 2
previously thrown -in prison, was elevated to the throne under Rritish auspices. But Yakoob's transition from the dungeon to the palace threatens not to be permanent. Ilis subjects are quarreling among them selves; and when Yakoob Khan sent a cavalry regiment to Kokistan to I quell disturbances among the tribes there, both factions suspended hostili ties and attacked and routed the regiment. A Roar from the African Lion. - t The massacre of Custer's army by a Sitting Bull and his braves finds a I parallel in a recent British reverse in N Africa.
See moreSee less
To the northwest of Cape I Colony in Southern Africa and bori dering on the British possessions is a c territory of indefinite extent, and c known by the euphonious name of r "The Zulu Country." It is inhabic tated by a warlike race of savages who t. carne from further north a century c ago, and under the lead of a chief C named Chaka overran the country as far south as Natal. The Zulus at that time had a regular military ori ganization, consisting of regiments of , a thousand inen each, distinguished Ib by the color of their shields. In 1810 t they mustered forty thotisan,l warriors, i The Zulus have always been the most formidable barrierto British Cona qest. The .recent disposition of p Great Britain to annex Caflland, a the adjoining territory, filled the 11 Zulus with alarm, and under the t command of their chief, t:etywavo, t they commenced hostilities a year o ago.- The campaign languished last cl year and the British became over confident. On the 21st of January, c however, a British column undle' t .n Lord Chelmsf'ord, consisting of a ri battalion, a baittery, and six hundred ii native auxiliaries, was tterly annihiIl lated by a force of' Zulus, estirnated(e at twenty thousand; two majors, four d captains, twelve lieutenants and a e quartermaster, two captains of the fl 1toyal artillery, a colonel, captain, four lieutenants anId surgeoni maijor e of' engineers, besides twventy-one e other British officers conmmanding the t native levies, and five hundred ot' the ~ line being killed. The substantial ~ fruits of victory were a valuable convoy of 102 wagons, 1,000 oxen, ~ two cannon, 400 shot and shell,. 1,000 s rifles, 250,000 rounds of ammunition, d 60,000 p)ound(s weight of provisions" and the colors of the Twventy-fourth r regiment. Th~e ross of the Zulus Is 3 estimated at five thousand men, . though this is mere guesswork. The ~ savages are said to have been armed with breech loading firearms and to have shown great military skill. Lord Chelmsford, who was out re connoiteFing with a dlet achment at the time of the battle, has been forced to retreat, and the greatest alarm exists 'V In the Englieh colony,. This serious reverse will embolden all the native tribes andl render inevitable a pr~o longed and serious contest. The history of the world is one continued series of victories of civilization ever barbarism, but when a the savage happens to get in a blow he makes it tell. Sitting Bull and Cetywayo must be classed among the military suecesses of the nineteenth eentury, - A Little Mixed.. The Winnsboro NEa AND' UE,RALDY - says the Chzroniele blundered the ' other day when it said the Legisla ture of South Carolina consisted of one hundred and twenty-f'our memn bers, and that Senator Butler received sixty-five votes, or more than a ma jority,. It explains that the Carolina
A Chicago correspondent reports the Reno Court of Inquiry has concluded, speculating Reno will be censured not for the Custer massacre itself but for past personal conduct and his critical testimony about Custer's judgment. The piece also notes Custer biographer Whittaker is in Chicago seeking to vindicate Custer's reputation as a cautious, obedient soldier despite contrary opinions from Grant, Terry, Reno, and Benteen.
Public Ledger · 15 February 1879 · page 2
TR0M CHICAGO. Correspondence of the Ledger.l " Chicago, February 12. It was a natural coincidence that the conclu sion of the Reno investigation should closely follow that of the Judge Blod gett "inquiry," which drew to a finale last Friday. Yesterday the lleno matter reached a climax, and ere this reaches you all the military men of tho noted court will be back, or on their way to the Western camps. It is next to impossible to tell how the inquiry will effect General lleno; but, by way of speculation, one might say that it is quite likely the general will be censured.
See moreSee less
I think this will be brought about not so much by the Custer massacre matter, but by the little affair of 1877 with tho wife of Lieutenant King. You will remem ber that he was then charged with insulting Mrs. King. This taken to gether with his assertion while on the stand in his own defense, that he had no confidence in General Custer's mil itary judgment, will have more weight with the court iu making up his re port than anything directly connected with the massacre matter. The sym pathy ot the country is most certainly, and with just causo,. with General Custer as a grand monument of the knightly soldier. Consequently it mar ne presumed tuat tne court will teach General iteno a lesson in thus arraying himself against tho country's verdict of applause for tho many dariog deeds of a model soldier and gentleman the Muratoftho American military school. Of course the court's action will not be made known like that of the Blodgett findings until after the'officials at j ashington have passed upon it. llichardson and Schmidt, the grand jurors unaer investigation lor perjury and taking bribes, have been honora bly" released. Mr. F. Whittaker, the biographer of General Custer, is in the city. He says he cares little for Reno, but his object is to vindicate the char acter of the late lamented Custer as a brave soldier. He claims that Gen eral Custer was not a rash, but a very cautious soldier; and that as to him being a " disobedient" officer, such a charge is utterly without foundation, notwithstanding the opinion of Gen erals Grant, Terry, Reno, and Colonel Benteen to the contrary. It might be well here to mention that it was a fact that General Grant, as well as General Terry, did not like the gallant Custer, and when his death was announced to the country it was the general remark that Grant's treatment of the fearless warrior had driven him to do deeds of reckless and fatal dariiur. that the ma. . . 1. - ' . nunu unpui. sue ue as nui airam to
The report discusses the ongoing Reno Court of Inquiry, noting public sentiment favors Custer as a model soldier while Reno faces scrutiny. Custer biographer Whittaker is quoted defending Custer against charges of recklessness and disobedience, with the article also repeating the rumor that Grant's dislike of Custer drove him to reckless, fatal daring.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 5 days later.
Wrong
Public Ledger · 15 February 1879 · page 2
Chicago, February 12. It was a natural coincidence that the conclu sion of the Reno investigation should closely follow that of the Judge Blod gett "inquiry," which drew to a finale last Friday. Yesterday the lleno matter reached a climax, and ere this reaches you all the military men of tho noted court will be back, or on their way to the Western camps. It is next to impossible to tell how the inquiry will effect General lleno; but, by way of speculation, one might say that it is quite likely the general will be censured.
See moreSee less
I think this will be brought about not so much by the Custer massacre matter, but by the little affair of 1877 with tho wife of Lieutenant King. You will remem ber that he was then charged with insulting Mrs. King. This taken to gether with his assertion while on the stand in his own defense, that he had no confidence in General Custer's mil itary judgment, will have more weight with the court iu making up his re port than anything directly connected with the massacre matter. The sym pathy ot the country is most certainly, and with just causo,. with General Custer as a grand monument of the knightly soldier. Consequently it mar ne presumed tuat tne court will teach General iteno a lesson in thus arraying himself against tho country's verdict of applause for tho many dariog deeds of a model soldier and gentleman the Muratoftho American military school. Of course the court's action will not be made known like that of the Blodgett findings until after the'officials at j ashington have passed upon it. llichardson and Schmidt, the grand jurors unaer investigation lor perjury and taking bribes, have been honora bly" released. Mr. F. Whittaker, the biographer of General Custer, is in the city. He says he cares little for Reno, but his object is to vindicate the char acter of the late lamented Custer as a brave soldier. He claims that Gen eral Custer was not a rash, but a very cautious soldier; and that as to him being a " disobedient" officer, such a charge is utterly without foundation, notwithstanding the opinion of Gen erals Grant, Terry, Reno, and Colonel Benteen to the contrary. It might be well here to mention that it was a fact that General Grant, as well as General Terry, did not like the gallant Custer, and when his death was announced to the country it was the general remark that Grant's treatment of the fearless warrior had driven him to do deeds of reckless and fatal dariiur. that the ma. . . 1. - ' . nunu unpui. sue ue as nui airam to
The Herald interviews Dr. V.T. McGillycuddy, the newly appointed agent at Red Cloud Agency, about his background with the army and the Sioux. He recounts his service on surveys, with Crook's Big Horn expedition, and as physician to the Red Cloud Indians, including attending Crazy Horse when he died.
The New York Herald · 16 February 1879 · page 12
IDEAS OF AN INDIAN AGENT.
tween Montana and British America, passing through the country where Sitting Bull now is. During that j year, and more particularly since that time, circumstances have brought me a great ileal in direct contact with the Indians, among whom I have found many friends as sincere as a man ever finds. 1 be: lieve I know something >>f the needs of the Indian, of his nature, of the wrongs which he has suffered aud of the difficulties which stand in the way of the Agent. 1 have taken a deep interest in the subject mid have much sympathy for the Indian or I should not have accepted this appointment.
See moreSee less
Correspondent?You attended Crazy Horse after lie was shot, I am told? Dr. McOilucdddt?I was with the old chief when lie died, and had a valuable experience with his band. My experience, in brief, to complete my answer to your first question, was that in the winter following
Frederick Whittaker, Custer's biographer, writes to the Chicago Times after the Reno Court of Inquiry concludes, noting he was barred as a technicality from acting as accuser despite having instigated the inquiry through his congressional letter. He states he remained a silent spectator throughout and now intends to speak now that Reno and the Recorder have given their statements.
The New York Herald · 16 February 1879 · page 12
through the country where Sitting Bull lias taken up Ills abode that northern herd of butfulo seemed inexhaustible. The e.oiut y was lull of bull do, and these herds were boundless, stretching away to the horizon's edge. Sitting Bull has no occasion to come south fur game, and certainly he would come fur nothing else.
Captain Frederick Whittaker, Custer's biographer, writes to the Chicago Times defending Custer as a soldier following the Reno Court of Inquiry, which he says proves Custer was prudent and was abandoned by subordinates rather than defeated by the enemy. He states the charge of disobedience against Custer remains to be refuted before Congress at a future date.
The New York Herald · 16 February 1879 · page 12
CARD FROM CUSTER'S HISTORIAN.
rightful position of accuser or prosecutor in the in ijuiry, on the narrowest technical grounds. I, then tore, had no opportunity to suy one word in Canter's or my own behalf in court, and wan obliged to remain a Rilent and powerless spectator of event a in which 1 had ?o keen an interest. Now that the trial in over, anil that Keno and tho liecorder have said their say, it become* my duty, um the biographer of the late General Custer, to apeak, if only lor a luouieut, and put the poHition of finder an well a* my own in its proper light, to prevent future misunderstandings.
See moreSee less
I came to Chieago for two purpose*?to vindicate CiiHtcr us a soldier and myaclf ax a man of truth. The character <>t lleno wax a mere incident in which I had no special interest, though this trial and the courtmurtial of 1X77 in the case of Hell against heno have revialed it pretty fully. As far as Ileuo is concerned, if the army can endure him, after the double exposures of 1x17
A letter to the editor responds to a prior correspondent's praise of Custer, instead branding him a coward at Little Bighorn and demanding that Congress investigate the massacre, noting the ongoing Chicago inquiry (the Reno Court of Inquiry) has not yet revealed the full truth. The writer frames doubts about Custer's courage as tied to testimony before a court of inquiry examining the battle.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 3 days later.
Wrong
National Republican (Washington City) · 17 February 1879 · page 2
LET CONGRESS INVESTIGATE THE BATTLE OF LITTLE BIG HORN
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
As the Reno Court of Inquiry concludes, observers note shifting sentiment against full exoneration based on Recorder Lee's summation and the panel's deliberation time. A knowledgeable source guesses the verdict will find Reno's retreat unwise but not cowardly, and that he had no duty to aid Custer absent an official call.
Daily Press and Dakotaian · 17 February 1879 · page 2
whether at his order or not, the command did make a reasonable effort to reach Custer that, having acted, in the first place, upon an order embracing the promise of support* and being hotly engaged by the euetuy him aelll it wa» not Reno's duty to go to the aid of Custer, supiNwing him to be advised as to the latter'* whereabout, except upon an offi cial call for aid."
This item presents a sarcastic, exaggerated parody of witness testimony at the Reno Court of Inquiry into Major Reno's conduct at Little Bighorn. It mocks the contradictory and physically impossible claims made by witnesses, suggesting Custer promised support but abandoned Reno.
Daily Press and Dakotaian · 17 February 1879 · page 2
THE RENO INVESTIGATION
COLONIZING THE NEGROES. Bismarck, D. T., Feb. 12.—General T. S, Rosser, chief engineer of the Northern Pa cific railroad, and the Custer of the late confederate army, heartily indorses Senator Windom's scheme of colonizing the south ern negroes. In an interview to day he re garded the questions rai.itd by Mr. Windom as eminently business-like and practicable, speaking as a southern man and a warm friend of the negro, and Rosser thought the scheme was the best that had yet been ad vanced for their amelioration. He looked upon Dakota as one of the best fields for their location, aud the extension of the Northern Pacific as an inducement.
See moreSee less
He considers negroes first-class railroad build ers, and if the quota of 2,000 for this sum mer's work on the North Pacific could be filled by black men it wjuld be lucky for the construction company. He consider* the Dakota climate and soil as very faror able.
Juniata Sentinel and Republican · Mifflintown, Pa.
This miscellaneous news column cites the Custer-Reno contrast while criticizing a British general defeated by the Zulus. It notes that Reno is criticized for retreating with part of his command, while Custer is praised for not withdrawing and dying with his men.
Juniata Sentinel and Republican · 19 February 1879 · page 2
Tub English General, Lord Chelms ford, is. severely criticised for being defeated bv tbe Zulu. iue best wav - . ! a fir a general to do, if be does not WlSbl. unfavorable criticism, is to defeat tbe enemy or be killed, as was Custer. For illustration, take the case of Kenor cd Custer. Reno, for escaping with part of bis command, is severely criti cised, and Custer is mourned over and
A former cavalry soldier writes to defend Major Marcus Reno against charges of cowardice, arguing Reno was brave but not rash while Custer was both. He claims Custer's impatience and ambition, not Reno's actions, caused the Little Bighorn disaster by not waiting for the other columns to join him.
National Republican (Washington City) · 20 February 1879 · page 2
pomattox Coiirt-llouse In ISM. My estimate of Reno nud Custer is this: Tho former was brave, but not rash, and Custer was both. Through rash ness Custer ami tho "Third Cavalry Division" got surrounded aiTrovilllan Station In lbOl, anil It was a brave, but not n rah man who cut him out. I mean Wesley Merrill, ho commanded thu FlrH
The Highland Weekly News · Hillsborough Hillsboro, Ohio
The article describes Major Reno, who served under Custer at the Little Bighorn, as on trial before a military court in Chicago for allegedly disobeying an order to charge simultaneously with Custer, leaving Custer unsupported and leading to his death. Reno's defense is that obeying would have destroyed his own command, and the report questions his bravery compared to Lord Cardigan's charge at Balaklava.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 5 days later.
Wrong
The Highland Weekly News · 20 February 1879 · page 1
A Military Trial. Major Reno, who held a subordi nate command nnder Gen. Custer daring tbe Eig Horn fight, where Gen. C. and Lis immediate troops
Idaho Semi-Weekly World · Idaho City, Idaho Territory
A brief aside compares the Custer massacre, a revolt in New Caledonia, and Zulu attacks on British troops as examples of savage power and valor. It is a passing reference within a miscellany column, not a direct report on the event itself.
Idaho Semi-Weekly World · 21 February 1879 · page 3
Young, Centerville; Jas. Parker, Durby shire,England; Neil AlcCaron, Placer ville ; Jas. Magee, Philadelphia. Bret Harte, who has not been pros pering for a year or two, has achieved great success in the London lecture field. His diplomatic post is not a very profitable one, but its convenient proximity to English audiences will enable him to reap considerable profit. Thf. Custer massacre, the revolt oi the native tribes of New Caledonia, and the recent slaughter of British troops by tlie /.ulus forcibly cxh.l'i excessive contempt fin t io fel y of savage valor aud power.
Springfield Weekly Republican · Springfield, Mass.
The report states that testimony-taking in the Reno Court of Inquiry has ended, with witnesses sharply divided on whether Reno could have held his position at the Little Big Horn. It speculates that Reno's jealousy of Custer's fame made him reluctant to support him, implying this caused Custer's defeat.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 4 days later.
Wrong
Springfield Weekly Republican · 21 February 1879 · page 1
Big Horn, while just as many have sworn just as positively that he could not, so it is probable that the accused will have the benefit of a technical acquittal. While the court declined to admit testimony relating to the personal rela tions between Gen Caster and his subordinate, it allowed Reno to testify that he had no con fidence in Custer’s military judgment—a confes sion that will not help his case with the public. Gen Custer’s Indian campaigns have been warmly commended by Gen Sheridan and Gen Sturgis, and his exploits on the Wachita and the Yellowstone have yet to be rivaled by those of any Indian fighter.
See moreSee less
Disinterested spectators will naturally conclude, in the face of these facts, that Reno’s jealousy of his superior’s re nown made him lukewarm in the execution of his superior’s orders, and that to this unfortu nate lack of zeal was due the fatality which left Custer to an unaided struggle with his gavage foes.
A military commission investigating Major Reno's conduct at the battle where Custer and his men were killed finished its work on the 11th. Its report will be sent to Washington for public release.
Perrysburg Journal · 21 February 1879 · page 1
The military commission which has been sitting at Chicago tor soma time as a court of investigation into the conduct of Major Reno at the battle in which General Custer and his
A brief news item reports that Major Reno, testifying at a court of inquiry in Chicago, admitted he had no confidence in Custer as a soldier. This appears amid a roundup of unrelated political and personal notes.
Colored Citizen · 22 February 1879 · page 2
PERSONAL AND POLITICAL,. Senator Jones, of Nevada, pays $17,000 rent for his Washington redidenco. Maj. Reno, in his testimony at Chica go on Saturday, confessed that he had no con fidence in Custer as a soldier. Judge W. B. Fleming, nominated to succeed the late Julian Hartridge, of Georgia, in Congress, is in his 74th year.
A roundup of global news items reports that England has suffered its own 'Custer massacre' in South Africa, with a reconnoitering force left unable to repel attackers. The item calls the British disaster even worse than Little Bighorn, citing 49 officers and 500 men killed.
Colored Citizen · 22 February 1879 · page 2
GENERAL FOREIGN NOTES.
is a prominent and acceptable candidate for the Governorship of Algeria. Dispatches from the Star and Herald, of Panama, say a serious revolution has broken out in Antioquia. The French Chambers, it is rumored, after a few more sittings will adjourn till March 1, when they will discuss urgent bills, and then adjourn until May. England has had a Custer massacre in South Africa. A reconnoitering expeditioe that left a force in camp unable to keep off thn enemy was an amazing blunder. The disaster to the English army, moreover, was far greater than that which our troops met at the Little Big Horn. A list of forty-nine officers and 500 men killed is appalling.
Scout Fred Girard publishes a scathing letter to Major Reno, recounting his 1876 dismissal and reinstatement as post interpreter and accusing Reno of cowardice and tyranny at the Little Bighorn. The letter references the upcoming court of inquiry into Reno's conduct during the battle, which Girard says was long overdue.
Bismarck Tribune · 22 February 1879 · page 1
DISCHARGING Ajjf INTERPRETER, as you probably foresaw that there would be no occasion for one so far as your rela, tions with the Indians were concerned. Gen. Caster, contrary to your plans and expectations, returned and assumed com mand, and after hearing your reason for my discharge, from yourself, restored me to my position on 'the 12th of the sanle month. Why did you not malce official com plaint to your superior or institute pro ceedings yourself tfga'inst me? The fact is, you displayed another trait of charac ter always associated'with that which dis tinguished you at tliie battle of the Little Big Horn—petty tyranny.
See moreSee less
Custer you could not harm,' biilj you could his hum ble friends, so you discharged Girard. Major, what evil genius tempted you to suggest comparison bf character between you and me you, whom a too geinerous country educated and trained for an hon orable profession,vto^ see you conspicuous only for a meanne|8| ancl unmanliness in your capacity of $p,\ma,iiding officer at Abercrombie, whetij^ab^. ,.
A telegraph dispatch from Pittsburgh reports that Major Reno, tried at Chicago for conduct unbecoming an officer related to the Custer massacre, has been acquitted. The finding of the court-martial still awaits presidential approval.
The Cincinnati Daily Star · 24 February 1879 · page 1
Acquitted By tho Court-martial. (Special to Hie Star. Pittsburg, Feb. 24. The Telegraph this afternoon has private informa tion of the acquittal of Major Reno, who was recently tried at Chicago for conduct unbecoming an officer in con nection with t lie Custer massacre. The finding of the court-martial has not yet been approved by the President.
A Court of Inquiry convened at Reno's own request examined charges that he was guilty of cowardice and dereliction of duty at the Battle of Little Big Horn. The report finds insufficient evidence to warrant a court martial against him.
It is understood that the Court of Inquiry convened t the request of Major Marcus A. Reno, of the Seventh cavalry, to inquire into the chargoe that Major IUjio had, at the battle of Little Big Horn (the Custer massacre), been guilty of cowardice and remissness
A correspondent describes how testimony from Col. Benteen at the Reno Inquiry gave a Maine woman false hope that her secret fiancé, Dr. Lord, missing at Little Bighorn, might still be alive among the Indians. Major Walsh and Canadian police searches have found no evidence of survivors, and the correspondent concludes such hope is as improbable as a Jules Verne fantasy.
Chicago Daily Tribune · 25 February 1879 · page 12
BISMARCK, D. T.
IUSJIARCK, l). T. A Romnnen of llio Custer Massacre-LookIn? for ilor Uoml I.ovor—Ccii. llusscr on Wlnrfom’s Negro Scheme—A Wonl-of Ap proval—l.ogUlutlvo Skullduggery. Special Corrfrpomlfucf of The Tribune, Bismaiick, I). T. f Feb. IS.—Col. Bcntecn, of the Seventh Cavalry, loft the Impression In his testimony In the Ueno Inquiry Unit Dr. Lord und Lieut. Sturgis, who wera with Custer, and whose bodies were nut found, might ho still alive mid with the Indians. Awn? down In Maine this ray of hope full upon the heart of a youmr lady who is in reality hut not in im.no one of the widows of that fatal dash far vindi cation.
See moreSee less
There was more la the Colonel’s words to her than ho Intended. Tor the fifteenth time ehu wrote to Bismarck pitifully Inquiring if there was any possible hope that Denteen’s intimation was founded upon fact. Her friend hero answered “No.” If Dr. Lord was nllvo and In Sitting Bull’s camp the Canadian mount ed police would havo found it out long before this. MoJ. Walsh, who Is on the best pf terms with the bostltcs, und Is with them u great dual, has made every effort to discover u survivor. Ho is n great admirer of the dead Custer, and his personal lecllmrs have been heartily unlist ed in the vain search. All that ho has found has been one of the horses of the while-horse company. Dr. Lord may be nllve, but it is ns improbable as Jules Verne’s elahtv-aay tfip around the world. The lady in Maine, however, lias an intuitive belief that bo Is still alive und she will yet see him. She reproaches herself for some little thing she did, thinking It sent him oB with Custer, and that he was Indifferent as to tliu consequences.
A correspondent describes the Palmer House in Chicago being used for the court of inquiry into Major Reno's conduct at the Little Bighorn, alongside a separate judicial investigation of Judge Blodgett. Public opinion largely blames Reno for not going to Custer's aid, though military witnesses defend him while scouts and civilians suggest cowardice or drunkenness.
The Hillsdale Standard · 25 February 1879 · page 1
CniOAOo, Feb. 19, 1879. : For weeks the 1'almer Honne baa as eumed quite the air of conrt of jus tice, a iarlor ami dioiog-room being tranafurmed into halls for martial and judicial inresti'Kation, while its corridors Lar been thronged with generals aud judges, aoldcim, law yers and ciriliaci; and the common Ulk in street cars and restaurant, has bexrn of Major lie no and Judge Ulod gett. The Major is called to explain his action, or rather lack of action, in tho memorable Custer battle on the
Former officers of Custer's Third Cavalry Division are reported outraged at Major Reno's testimony before the Chicago court of inquiry, in which he claimed no confidence in Custer as a soldier. A Washington dispatch quotes them calling the charge cowardly and unjustifiable, insisting Custer's reputation was unassailable.
Public Ledger · 25 February 1879 · page 1
German home, which was granted, j A REAL telegraph has been invented , by an English mechanical engineer. A writer in London moves his pen, and simultaneously at Brighton an ' other pen Is moved in precisely simi '; lar curves and motions. Tho writer writes in London, tho ink, marks in . Brighton. The pon at the receiving ' end has all the appearance of being ' guided by a spirit hand. The appa ratus is shortly to be mado public ' before' the Society of Telegraph En gineers. ' ' ' j ' S6me of the officers of the old Third ; Cavalry Division, which performed ;many heroic deeds under Goneral Custer, are indignant at the reported statement in the testimony of Major ' Reno before the court at Chicago, ; that ho had no confidence in General "Custer as a soldier.
See moreSee less
A Washington ".Bpeeial says : " These gentlemen char. ucicrize mo cnarge as cowardly and unjustifiable, as General Custer's rep
A court of inquiry convened at Major Reno's own request examined charges of cowardice against him related to the Custer massacre at Little Bighorn. The court concluded that the evidence did not warrant proceeding to a court martial.
Alexandria Gazette · 25 February 1879 · page 2
? is given for tho assassination. Angcll, th? defaulting treasurer of tho Pal!. mac Dftlaes Car Coinpaoy, who arrived at i Philadelphia yesterday from Lisbon, Portugal, waived all formalities under tho S:ato extradi1 tioc laws, and was ecnt ca to Chicago under charge of tho detective who came over with i him. The court el inquiry convc-i ed nt tho request t of Major Keao to investigate the charges of cowardice brought og iir..-: hina in connection with the Custer massacre, has reported that the evidenco does not warrant a trial by court . martial. r Some of the Mississippi papers are urging , Jefferson Davis ee tho successor of Bruce, col ored, in the United States Senate. Others, again, oppose it, charging its advooues as J guilty of BourboDism.
The Pittsburgh Telegraph reported that Major Reno, who had been court-martialed in Chicago to answer for his conduct during the Custer battle, was acquitted. The brief note appeared among a roundup of various news items from around the country and abroad.
Washingtoner Journal · 26 February 1879 · page 2
Major Reno, welcher vor ein Kriegs gericht in Chicago gestellt worden war, um sich für sein Benehmen während der Custer - Schlacht zu verantworten, sei freigesprochen worden.
This report reconstructs the Little Bighorn battle, describing Custer's division of forces among Reno, Benteen, and himself, with specific orders given through Adjutant Cooke and others. It details Reno's advance, his sudden halt and retreat to timber as Sioux warriors rallied, and Custer's separate movement toward the village before turning to attack from the rear, as witnessed by Lieutenant DeRudio.
The Sun · 26 February 1879 · page 4
jj j wltt tba whole outub 1 I Those ord. rs k'lV' ii. Custer and Reno Is.th ad3 it yanood at a last tr..t or gallop Reno diyorjtlBB I i (i th" left and oraaallUI the I.dilo Itur ll-.rt.. J I while Custer kept mi the riaht hank, tollowiua I the are of which Robo had tbeehord. Tbey j l urnved in sik'ht of the Indian vllliu,'" almost ai I tim same time, the Indiana rOOBlptf from be-
This report recounts the battle action at the Little Horn, describing how Reno's troops took cover in timber, then suddenly retreated across the river under Indian attack, during which the scout Bloody Knife was killed beside Reno. It also describes Custer waving his hat to cheer Reno's men before turning to attack Indians to the rear, and the subsequent arrival of Benteen's column to join Reno on the bluff.
The Sun · 26 February 1879 · page 4
I tim same time, the Indiana rOOBlptf from beII I turn lleno in a eliiud of dust, oauaed oy drlvla in the lo rds ol pooteawltb which tin y h id I ii aurprisd in toe valley, and by a panic which bail seized them. Within athouaiiBd vanlsol tin-viihik'e RB0 luddanly halted, dismounted II bis men, ami sent his liorsen into a patch ol f timteT on tim left hank of th" it ream, where a j i perfeot aatural fortlfioatlon existed. All around ! I , was hii open prairie, and iba timber waa sunk ' I b.'low Hie prairie, bordered hy a steep hank.
See moreSee less
As soon as tinIndians saw Reno hull they took i b.-art. and bnaaB to eoBia back to defend their Women and children. Thatroopaope I inm the prairie a wild, aimless lire, in which Haioi ij ) ', Iojuo BlmaoU joined w ith a curl ui". the ortl1 porB paylnii v rv little attention b reatiilnt Irir the iixpotnliture of ammUBitioa, Allei I a'.oul ten in unites, we nn". ol a sudden full back to tho liuii.er. Win n the line llrsl opaoed I Urn Custer heard them mi Hie right hank of th" ' riv.'r, I' ll his, iilumu Hlmit; with Adiutant Oooko. i gallo,..,i lothe ediro ot the hlalTs. looked down i ! Bud waved his hat to cheer thorn mi in the fight. II then went book to his eolumu to attack llm In 1 I dinnt in r"iir. He was sen hy on" offlo-r in ! the lltihl. Lieut de HUdlO. From ttlHUou the I 1;,. the gl .and hid ouch eolumu fioin Hi, i j' oilier. Custer hud hardly I n gone Ih-mln I utea whOB Reno suddenly made up Inn m ud to f I I retreat, and ao, ordnik'ly ordered his men to I tin ir horses. While this was doing the Hi" ol Il l tli" iroopa oaaaed, and the Indium oarne near j 1 tiio tirnber. When all Wore moulded in column ol ' fours, lieu, led away lr, en tho village, it lew tn- ! diauswho i.ai sneaked clour around thucol IJ ,1 J umn ijuring tho lull in Hie a In u. auddi'Bi) I 1 1 Bred, kniiiik' Cualer'a favorite In i nn scout, II i ' "Bloodi Knife, who on that day was attendiBg I 'I i Reno. Tiiuacout'abraina wore apattored over I ) Bano, who Imiuadiabily relied out, " Die I I Biouiit! "and tin in " Mount"' Ai the same (no J I. i, a ohilar shout d: ".My (iod.boya, I've
The report recounts testimony from the Reno Court of Inquiry in Chicago, criticizing Major Reno's conduct during the Little Bighorn battle, including his delay in supporting Custer and an incident where he abused a packer. It notes that Custer's firing was heard by witnesses but Reno took no action, and describes Capt. Weir's unauthorized advance toward Custer's position.
The Sun · 26 February 1879 · page 4
but went down the bluff to look nt the deed I bealy nf one of hja ofTlcnra, AHtho Indians had h ft his front and had uonc to Oust r. and still 1 lie remained nutet At last Capt. Thomaa I!. . Weir, who ImuI I n fretting Mid fuii'itur. start ed ofT alOBBtO JOjn Custer, iitul wns followed by his emnpnny without orders. When they hnd Kmi" about a mile BnBO h t th" rest go after. Ity thut time tlie flrnik' down the river tin, I ceased, and they mot tin' Indiana rcturnink. In an other hour they wore attacked themselves, ami Reno prartleallf diaappwar id from the icepe, having the actual
This report discusses British and American handling of Indian tribes in Alaska and British Columbia, prompted by disturbances at Sitka. In passing, it claims Sitting Bull and Chief Joseph sent emissaries to incite British Columbia tribes to violence before the Custer massacre.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
The New York Herald · 27 February 1879 · page 5
most salutary effect iu the preservation of the peace. It is not at all unnatural to suppose that in view of the reported disturbances at Hitka the English commander should deem it incumbent upou himself at once to proceed to the scene and ascertaiu it the trouble would extend to tho tribes In British territory. The Alaska Indians and those in British Columbia are in constant communication with,each other, and once iet tho ball open and there is no telling where it will stop. It is a well known fact that Hitting Bull, seconded by Joseph, the Noz Perce chief, before the massacre of Custer scut runners and emissaries among the Indians of British Columbia to endeavor to incite them to deeds of blood, and a great deal of uneasiness was felt at the time, but owing to the fur superior policy of Indian control as exercised by the British government tluiy dared not uttemi>t u revolt.
The report states that Major Reno of the Seventh Cavalry, on trial before a court of inquiry for cowardice at the Battle of Little Big Horn, will likely be found not guilty. It notes the evidence against him is not clear enough to warrant a court-martial.
Centre Democrat · 27 February 1879 · page 1
IT is understood that Maj. Keno, of the Seventh cavalry, on trial by a court of inquiry for cowardice in the battle of Little Big Horu, which re sulted so disastrously in the massacre of Custer aud bis command, will ra
Officers from Custer's old Third Cavalry Division reacted angrily to reports that Major Reno testified at the Chicago court of inquiry that he had no confidence in Custer as a soldier. They called the charge cowardly and unjustifiable, insisting Custer's reputation was unassailable.
The Kenosha Telegraph · 27 February 1879 · page 4
'General Custer’s Friends Indio j NANT. Washington, February 16. —Some of the officers of the old Third Caval ry Division, which performed many ! heroic deeds under command of Gen eral Custer, are indignant at the re ported statements in the testimony of Major Reno before the court at Chica go, that iie had no confidence in Gener al Custer as a soldier. These gentle men characterize the charge as coward ly and unjustifiable, as General Cus ter’s reputation was perfectly estab lished and could not be injured by one on trial on the charge of cowardice.
See moreSee less
Surgeon General Woodworth, of the United States Marine Hospital Service, is of the opinion that precautions should be taken by Congress to prevent tiie plague from being landed on our shores. He advises that $12,000 be appropriated to pay the expenses of two medical men to be stationed in Europe, and notify tiie authorities here of ports that should be quaran tined against. Rupture of an Artery in the right arm. Tried the most prominent sur geons in this city without benefit. By accident heard of Dr. Giles’ Liniment lodide Ammonia. It acted like magic. Am now well. W. Berge, Music Director, Organist Church of St. Francis Xavier,
The passage describes the Reno Court of Inquiry, focusing on witness Benteen's testimony attacking Custer's decisions and character while no rebuttal was permitted. It accuses the court of bias, claiming only anti-Custer testimony was allowed while Reno himself was being investigated, calling the whole proceeding a mockery of justice.
Chicago Daily Tribune · 28 February 1879 · page 8
who cstno to hear the great Indian-fighter testify. IN. 11.— .Most of these ladles came from Sheridan's headquarters,] Ana yet what was the testimony of this vaunted Bcntcenf It is enough to say that before ho had loft tho stand he had convinced ovory one In tho room except Keno and Gammon that ho could nut bo trusted, ills slntomcnls were cundnud to a series of malignant sneers at bis dead com mander, Custer; to an expression of opinion that Custer had given “senseless" orders; that bo had blundered into a trap; that ho bud been killed in a * * panic "; that bis dubt bad only lusted ten min utes, and so on, in uplpt of the firing beard lur two long hours on Reno’s Tilll by ovory ono else.
See moreSee less
And here comes tho true Inwardness of the Reno in quiry. Every witness who wanted to Blander Custer was allowed to do so, but no won! was al lowed on the other aide, because It was Reno, not Custer, who was to bo investigated. Gen. Sheridan sent In his brother, tbo Colonel, belter Known in Cklcaso us “Alike Sher idan." to swear down Castor, and Mike, who never was in action, was permitted to oQor his military Judgment on tnu probable fate of Custer, though he only visited tho held In 18T7. Pour Alike, by-tlio-by, was sullcring front a recent wound contracted by bumping his head against tho tup of an ambulance while campaigning after imag inary Indians; so wo must not he severe on him. lie gave bis evidence like a little mum Reno himself was allowed to sneer at Custer for hln Civil War record, an appeal to too old rivalry oetwcou Custer and .Merritt, now ono of tbo Court, nml nut without clfcct. Renteon was allowed to sneer at Custer, but u question us (o his relations toward Castor was ruled out. Rontccn, tuo, was not on trial. In short, by the rulings of the Court and lho terms of the order under which they acted, the whole proceeding became at lust the merest mockery of Justice, despite of the honesty of Cols. King and Royull, mm tho energy of Recorder Leo. All that could bo done was to accumulate facts; and, thunk* to the Recorder, enough facts wore established to sink Reno ten times over, it was proven that Custer went into action on that fatal day with two subordinates who hated and distrust
Former post interpreter Girard publishes a scathing personal letter to Major Reno, recounting his dismissal and reinstatement by Custer and attacking Reno's character, including his conduct at Little Bighorn and an earlier dismissal from the army. The letter mocks Reno's request for a court of inquiry, implying cowardice during the battle.
The Cheyenne Daily Leader · 28 February 1879 · page 2
MAJOR RENO AND THE SCOUT GIRARD
with the ludians were concerned. Gen. Ouster, contrary to your plans and ex pectations, returned and assumed com mand, and, after hearing your reason for my discharge from yourself, restor ed me to my position on the 12th of the same month. Why did you not make official complaint to your superior, or institute proceedings yourself against me? The fact is, you displayed anoth er trait of character always associated with that which distinguished you at the battle of the Little Big Horn—petty tyranny. Custer you could not harm, but you could Ids humble friends. So
Scout F.F. Girard publishes a bitter, sarcastic letter mocking Major Reno's conduct at Little Bighorn and his recent testimony before the Court of Inquiry. Girard accuses Reno of cowardice, vanity, and dishonesty, referencing Reno's doubt of Girard's reports during the battle and his criticism of Custer.
The Cheyenne Daily Leader · 28 February 1879 · page 2
MAJOR RENO AND THE SCOUT GIRARD
are not my ideal representative of the American officer. 1 cannot recall ;tny illustrious person in our military histo ry to whom you bear any resemblance, and yet I am informed you sometimes assume Napoleonic attitudes; but they are only attitudes and are not signifi cant of anything warlike. Major, among the other amusing elements of your statement before the court was your attempt to cristicise Custer’s mill1 tary abilities. What must his com rades, especially Gen. Merritt, have thought as you, with your limited ca pacity and narrow, beclouded horizon, attempted to criticise a soldier whose life is a challenge to yonr own dead level and whose death you will never emulate?
See moreSee less
In answer to a question by Recorder Lee you state that you heard I was at Little Big Horn. Was this the source of your information?