As the Papers Told It

Little Bighorn · The full archive

December 1878

19 articles

In the story →

Bismarck Tribune · Bismarck, N.D.

A Washington dispatch reports that President Hayes has ordered a court of inquiry, requested by Major Marcus Reno, to convene in Chicago in January to examine Reno's conduct at the Battle of the Little Bighorn in 1876. The report notes allegations that Reno was remiss in carrying out orders, and names the officers detailed to the court.

Bismarck Tribune · 2 December 1878 · page 5 · transcribed from the page image

A Washington special to the Pioneer Press observes: "By direction of the president, on the application of Major Marcus A. Reno, Seventh Cavalry, a court of inquiry is appointed, to assemble at Chicago, Ill., on the second Monday of January next, for the purpose of inquiring into Major Reno's conduct at the battle of Little Big Horn, on the 25th and 26th of June, 1876. This was the fight with the Indians in which Gen. Custer was killed. The court is to report its opinion and whether further action is deemed necessary.

See moreSee less

It has been charged that Maj. Reno was remiss in carrying out orders. The following is the detail of the court: Col. John H. Kink, Fifth Infantry; Col. Wesley Merrill, Fifth Cavalry, and Lieut. Col. W. B. Royal, Third cavalry, with Lieut. Nee, Ninth Infantry, as recorder."

See the clipping

Batesville Guard · Batesville, Ark.

On Major Reno's own application, a Court of Inquiry will convene in Chicago in January to examine his conduct at the Battle of the Little Big Horn, where General Custer was killed. The item appears amid a roundup of unrelated personal and political news briefs.

Batesville Guard · 5 December 1878 · page 1

PERSONAL AND POLITICAL.

On application of Major Reno, Seventh Cavalry, a Court of Inquiry is to assemble at Chicago the second Monday in Januarv, to inquire into the Major’s conduct at the battle of the Little Big Horn, when Gen. Custer was killed. Hancock (Democrat), defeated for Con-; gress in the Fifth Texas District by Jones (Greenbacker), it is said will contest the seat. The last of the Fenian prisoners, Michael Ahearne, was released from Millbank Pris on, London, on Nov. 7. He had been 11 years in confinement. O’Connor, the convicted Fenian confined at Spike Island, has been notified he will he released Immediately on condition he re- | side outside the Queen’s dominions.

See moreSee less

Kelly, another confined Fenian, will probably shortly be liberated on the same terms. Dr. Henry J. Livingstone, late agent at the Crow Creek Agency, has been arrested upon an indictment charging him with the forge ry of vouchers. Several clerks and traders are also under indictment for complicity in the alleged frauds. Dr. McCabe, Auxiliary Bishop of the Diocese of Dublin, succeeds Archbishop Cullen.

See the clipping

The Saline County Journal · Salina, Kan.

This short item reports that Major Reno's actions during the Custer massacre will soon be investigated by a board of military officers convening in Chicago to take testimony. It is included among various unrelated news items in a weekly roundup column.

The Saline County Journal · 5 December 1878 · page 3

The conduct of Maj. Reno upon the oc casion ef the massacre of Custer and his command is shortly to be made the sub ject of an investigation by a board of military officer who will organise and take testimony in 'Chicago. Heatt storms are reported on the New England coast. There is ground for the apprehension that these atmospheric dis turbances may have extended far enough seaward to baTe made it a very sick trans it for the Lome family. Mr. Sitekijas expects that the sub scriptions for the 4 per cent, bonds this year will amount to atleeast f 100,000,000, and that at least three times that sum will bt taken in 1879, when the bonds will be purchasable with common currren-

See the clipping

Bozeman Avant Courier · Bozeman, Mont.

A military court of inquiry is to convene in Chicago in January to examine Major Reno's conduct during the Battle of the Little Big Horn on June 25-26, 1876, where General Custer was killed. The inquiry was requested by Reno himself.

Bozeman Avant Courier · 5 December 1878 · page 2

Military Court of Inquiry

| Washington. November 25.-Onapplica1 1 ion of Msiinr l!i>un 7 th i»^ ., ! kft ; Uon of Major Reno. 7th Cavalry a | of inquiry is appointed to assemble a i cago on the second Monday hi January iu

See the clipping

Helena Weekly Herald · Helena, Mont.

A court of inquiry was appointed to meet in Chicago in January to examine Major Reno's conduct during the battle of the Little Big Horn on June 25-26, 1876, where General Custer was killed. The inquiry was requested by Reno himself.

Helena Weekly Herald · 5 December 1878 · page 4

Military Court or Inquiry. Washington, November 25.—On applica tion of Major Reno, 7th Cavalry, a court of inquiry is appointed to assemble at Chicago on the second Monday in January to inquire into the Major's conduct %t the battle of the Little Big Horn, on the 25th and 26th of June, 1876, when General Custer was killed.

See the clipping

Jamestown Alert · Jamestown, N.D.

The President approved Major Reno's request for a court of inquiry, to convene in Chicago in January, examining his conduct at the Little Big Horn battle where Custer was killed. The court will include Colonels King, Merritt, and Royall, with Lieutenant Lee as recorder, addressing charges that Reno was remiss in following orders.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 7 days later.

Wrong

Jamestown Alert · 5 December 1878 · page 1

THB RAILROAD QUESTION. The object of the company is to secure the extension to Yankton of the Milwau. kee and St Paul road, the Iowa division of which, under the name of the McGreg­ or Western road, is already approaching the Big Sioux at or in the vicinity of Beloit. To the north and west of us a heavy blow is being struck at Yankton by the Sioux Falls and Missouri river branch of the Sioux City and St. Paul road. Their line has already, as all are aware, been extended to Sioux Falls, and the road located to within a few miles of Firesteel.

See moreSee less

This company is aiming at two things, neither of which is for the benefit of Yankton. It aims first to open out an outlet for the magnificent wheat lands of the Jim river valley and its environs. For this purpose it enters the valley just below the mouth of Wolf creek, thirty five or forty miles from Yankton, and follows the stream to within a few miles of Firesteel, where it crosses, and thence takes an air line west for the Missouri, at Brule City. This outlet leads directly to the second aim, which is in reality a manifold aim: First, to compete with Yankton as a ship­ ping point second, to secure for its road and St. Paul all of the Black Hills trade not now enjoyed through Bismarck and the Northern Pacific road, and finally, doubtless, to tap the Union Pacific road by way of the Hills through Wyoming. Thus it will be jjeen that if Yankton sleeps while her enemies work, she will be gradually frozen out and her epitaph will be 'finished'. But we believe that the extension to Yankton can and will be secured. If so, this success will lead to further achieve­ ments The next thing in order will be connecting line from the Union Pacific road by way of Columbus, Neb., which will be shorter by nearly 150 miles than any other route to the great wheat markets of Milwaukee and Chicago. This will give us an outlet due south and bring to our merchants much Nebraska trade. But there is still another proposition which threatens Yankton. That is to make Springfield, or a point opposite Nio­ brara, the western outlet of the McGregor or Milwaukee and St. Paul road. That will make Niobrara the terminus of the future line from Columbus it will insure the extension of the Dakota Southern to Choteau Creek it will transfer our ship­ ping interests thither, and Yankton may hang her harps upon the willows. Hence it is that the extension of the Milwaukee road to Yankton becomes a question of lite and death to the people of Yankton and Yankton county. There are just two points which every citizen should keep constantly in view: First, that no legitimate stone be left unturued in our efforts to secure this connection second, that we do not allow our zeal to tempt us to shoulder more than we can carry. Some can carry one share of stock, some two, some five, some ten but let all do something in money, or labor, or right of way. The following eminent gentlemen were appointed at the Monday night meeting to visit Milwaukee tnd confer with the officers and directors of the Milwaukee company, to ascertain just what can be done, and to report at a future meeting, viz: Mayor Wynn, Secretary Hand, ex Governor Edmunds, Dr. Burleigh, Captain McVay, General Beadle and Judge Ben nett. Mayor Wynn will call the meeting on the return of the delegation and all should make it a point to attend. —The President, on the application of Maj. Reno, U. S. A., has ordered a court ot inquiry to convene at Chicago, 111 -, on the second Monday of January next to in­ quire into Maj. Reno's conduct at the battle of the Little Big Horn, June 15th and 26th, 1876. This was the fight with the Indians in which Custer was killed. The officers detailed for the court of in. quiry are Col. John H. King, 9th Infantry Col. Wesley Merritt, 5th Cavalry Col. W. B. Royall, 3rd Cavalry, with Lieut. Lee, 9th Infantry, as recorder. It has been charged that Maj. Reno was at the battle of the Little Big Horn, and was remiss in carrying out orders. tapping of the Missouri river by other railroads from the east will afford the basis of a more satisfactory compromise. But until then we had better keep quiet, unless we decide to work for division by the east and west line. We know it is hard for hungering souls to wait for Sen­ atorial honors, but let them not forget that the majority have rights."

See the clipping

Chariton Courier · Keytesville, Mo. · and 1 other paper

At Major Reno's own request, a Court of Inquiry is to convene in Chicago on the second Monday of January to examine his conduct during the Battle of Little Big Horn, where General Custer was killed. The announcement appears amid a roundup of unrelated general and congressional news items.

Chariton Courier · 7 December 1878 · page 1

On application of Major Reno, Seventh Cavalry, a Court of Inquiry is appointed to assemble at Chicago on the second Monday in January, to inquire into the Major's con duct at the battle of Little Big Horn, when Gen. Custer was killed. Secretary Sherman's plan of resumption is briefly as follows: On New Year's Day greenbacks will be redeemed at the New York Sub-Treasury in gold or silver coin, at tbe option of the holder of notes, with out limitation. There will be no other point of unlimited redemption ex cept New York.

See moreSee less

though other sub-treasuries may redeem legal tender notes "within ordinary limits." Silver dollars will be exchanged for greenbacks or National Bank notes in .multiples of $1,000, and tbe expense of transportation w ill be paid by the United States Government. A specie issue of legal tenders of large denom lnatlons will take the place of gold certifi cates. Legal tenders will be receivable for customs dues. Robert Heller, the well known musician and magician, died suddenly at Philadelphia on the 27th, of pneumonia.

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • The Milan Exchange · Milan, Tenn. · 5 December 1878

The Iola Register · Iola, Kansas

Major Reno of the Seventh Cavalry has applied for a Court of Inquiry into his conduct at the Battle of Little Big Horn, where General Custer was killed. The inquiry is set to convene in Chicago on the second Monday in January.

The Iola Register · 7 December 1878 · page 4

' MINOR NOTES. About 70 temporary clerks, the majority women, have been discharged by the Treas ury Department, the appropriation being exhausted. On application of Major Reno, Seventh Cavalry, a Court of Inquiry is appointed to assemble at Chicago on the second Monday in January, to inquire into the Major's con duct at the battle or little Big Horn, when Gen. Custer was killed. Hancock (Democrat), defeated for Con gress In the Fifth Texas District by Jones (Ureenbacker), it is said will contest the seat. The last of the Fenian prisoners, Michael Ahearne, was released from Millbank Pris on, London, on Nov. 7. He had been 11 years in confinement.

See the clipping

The Lake County Star · Chase, Mich.

A court of inquiry into Major Reno's conduct at the Battle of the Little Big Horn will assemble in Chicago on the second Monday in January. The panel will include Colonels King, Merritt, and Royall, with Lieutenant Lee serving as recorder.

CorrectionThis set right an article from 7 days earlier.

The Lake County Star · 12 December 1878 · page 2

TOPICS OP THE TIMES. , Eleven out of twelve women Been In a Memphis street car a few days ago were In mourning. , CoL Ingersoll, after rending . the country with his lectures on Moses and Hell, proposes to pause In Washington and Indulge in the practice of the law. Idol making Is an extensive and profitable industry among the English manufacturers. The heathen prefer ... . ' . i i . . a - in em to nome-maue guus uu uccuum ui their excellent and artistic workman ship,'; . ' " The court to inquire into the conduct of Maj. Reno at the battle of the Little Big Horn, at which the Custer massacre

See the clipping

Public Ledger · Memphis, Tenn.

Corporal Noonan of the Seventh Cavalry, formerly Custer's command, killed himself after it was revealed that his 'wife,' who had recently died, was actually a man. The scandal and his comrades' scorn reportedly drove him to despair and suicide at the Bismarck garrison.

Public Ledger · 16 December 1878 · page 1

AN ASTOUNDING STORY

The Husband of the Man Midwife of 6eneral Custer's Old "Command" Commits Suicide. j Biaraarck (D. T.) Tribunal Corporal Noonan, of the Seventh Cavalry, whose "wife" died some

See the clipping

Helena Weekly Herald · Helena, Mont. · and 1 other paper

The article profiles Captain Grant Marsh, pilot of the steamer Far West who transported wounded soldiers from the Little Big Horn battle to Bismarck. It recounts an anecdote about Mark Twain and details Marsh's career, reputation, and praise from Generals Terry and Miles.

Helena Weekly Herald · 19 December 1878 · page 2

Capt. Grant Marsh, the father of Yellow stone navigation and the man who brought the Custer wounded on the steamer Far West from the mouth of the Little Big Horn to

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • Memphis Daily Appeal · Memphis, Tenn. · 5 August 1881

The New York Herald · New York, N.Y.

The report previews the upcoming Reno Court of Inquiry, claiming explosive testimony will emerge from a sworn ante-mortem statement by the late Colonel Thomas B. Weir. Weir allegedly stated he heard and saw signs of Custer's fight and urged Reno to advance, but that Reno refused, prompting accusations of cowardice from his own officers.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The New York Herald · 28 December 1878 · page 3

THE RENO COURT OF INQUIRY FACTS PROMISED WHICH WILL STARTLE THE COUNTRY ANTE-MORTEM STATEMENT OF AN OFFICER OF THE SEVENTH CAVALRY CHARGES OF COWARDICE AGAINST CUSTER'S SECOND IN COMMAND

leged misconduct of Major Marcus A. Reno at the battle of the Little llig Horn, June 25, 1870, when General Custer and Ave companies of the gallant Seventh cavalry lost their lives, will meet at Chicago January 0, when, it is alleged by oflicers who claim | to know, the facts connected with Major Reno's con duct at that battle will startle the country. AN OFFit'Eli's ANTE-MORTEM STATEMENT.

See the clipping

The New York Herald · New York, N.Y.

An investigation was launched based on Colonel Weir's sworn statement, leading officers including General Miles to visit the Little Big Horn battlefield to measure distances and test sound carrying. Their findings reportedly contradicted Reno's official report claims about distance from Custer's position and inability to hear gunfire. Multiple officers were ordered to Chicago to testify in the matter.

The New York Herald · 28 December 1878 · page 3

A VISIT TO THE LITTLE DIG HORN. The statement was placed in the hands of the proper authorities last summer, after the War De partment had ordered au investigation, and was so startling that an examination was ordered into some of the allegations made. During the past summer a party of officers, including Gen eral Nelson A. Miles, colonel of the Fifth infantry, who was then commanding the Yellow stone district; Colonel Edward W. Smith, aide-de camp to General Terry, and Lieutenant Edward Ma guiro, corps of engineers, chief engineer officer on General Terry's staff, visited tho Little Big Horn and made a series of experiments aud measurements, with results which seem fully to prove the assertions made by Colonel Weir and other surviving officers of tho ill-fated regiment who were present at the battle.

See moreSee less

The distance between the points where lUtno rotreatod to and remained, aud where Custer fought and fell, was accurately measured, and is found to bo much less than has always been claimed by Reno in his reports. It was also demonstrated, as refuting Reno's statement in his official report that the distance between tho two commands was so great that he could not hear the firing of Cnater's column, that a single shot from a carbine or pistol could be plainly heard front either point, in nearly every oon dition of the wimi ORDERED TO CHICAGO,

See the clipping

Daily Globe · St. Paul, Minn.

A Washington dispatch reports that the late Col. Thomas Weir had declared before his death that Reno refused to advance to help Custer despite hearing gunfire and being urged to do so, and that officers accused Reno of cowardice at the time. Major Reno, awaiting the upcoming Chicago court of inquiry, denounces the statement as false and vows to disprove it before the court.

Daily Globe · 30 December 1878 · page 1

GEN. CUSTER'S FALL.

Before the Chicago Inquiry. I Special Telegram to the Globe.J HABBISBUBG, Pa., Dec. 29.A Washington correspondent of a New Tork paper tele graphed yesterday that Col. Thos. B. Weir, one of the officers commanding a company under Major Iieno on the day of the disaster to Caster, had declared before his death last December that he was in full view of the fight when he was sent out to reconnoiter daring the action, and that he reported to Reno and said that help would be given their comrades. The dying officer is said also to have asserted that Reno flatly refused to make the movement aa urged, and was openly accused at the time of cowardice by hia own officers.

See moreSee less

Col. Weir's statement alleges that when he moved out with hia company sound of firing from the Custer column was distinctly heard by the whole command, and that point from which he ob tained a view of the battle was not more than a mile and a half from where Reno's command lay, This sworn statement was placed before Col. Weir's death in the hands of a well known New York ex-officer of volunteers, who is widely known as en admirer and bi ographer of the late Gen. Custer, and who solemnly promised Col. Weir not to rest un til the matter was officially investigated, and not to let the contents of the statement be come publicly known until an investigation was ordered. Major Reno, who is here, in a card says the publication of the slander on him is an evi dent attempt to. manufactuxepublio opinion in regard to the Little Bif*Hern battle in view of an official investigation, the court for which is to convene in Chicago soon. He concludes as follows: "I pronounce every statement published as eminating from Col. Weir, to be absolutely false and shall so prove to the court of inquiry." Major Rono expresses great confidence in his ability to explode all charges of coward ice and other misconduct.

See the clipping

Daily Globe · St. Paul, Minn.

A Washington correspondent reports that the late Col. Thomas B. Weir left a dying statement accusing Major Reno of refusing to advance toward Custer's sound of gunfire despite urging, and of being accused of cowardice by his own officers. Major Reno publicly denounces the account as false and vows to disprove it before the upcoming Chicago court of inquiry.

Daily Globe · 30 December 1878 · page 2

GEN. CUSTER'S FALL.

ISefore tho Chicago Inquiry. I Special Telegram to the Globe.J HAEJSXSEUJSG, JPa,., Deo. 29.A "Washington correspondent of a New York paper tele graphed yesterday that Col. Taoa. B. Weir, ono of the officers commanding a company under Major Keno on the day of the disaster to Custer, had declared before bis death last December that he was in full view of the fight when he was sent out to reconnoiter during the action, and that he reported to Reno and said that help would be given their comrades. The dying officer is said also to have asserted that Reno flatly refused to make the movement as urged, and was openly accused at the time of cowardice by his own officers.

See moreSee less

Col. Weir's statement allege* that when he moved out with his company sound of firing from tha Custer column was distinctly hoard by the whole command, and that point from which he ob tained a view of tho battle was not more than a mile and a half from where Reno's command lay. This sworn statement was placed before Cul. Weir's death in the hands of a well known New York ex-officer of volunteers, who is widely known as ?n admirer and bi ographer of the late Gen. Custer, and who solemnly promised Col. Weir not to rest un til the matter was officially investigated, and not to let the contents of the statement be come publicly known until an investigation was ordered. Major Reno, who is here, in a card says the Tut licution of tiae slander onhim 13 an evi dent attempt to. manufacture public opinion in regard to the Little Bif%em battle in view of an official investigation, tho court for which is to convene in Chicago soon. He concludes as follows: I pronounce every statement published as emulating from Col. Weir, to be absolutely false and shall so prove to the court of inquiry." Major Reno expresses great confidence in his ability to explode all charges of coward ice and other misconduct.

See the clipping

Bismarck Tribune · Bismarck, N.D.

A report claims Capt. Thomas Weir gave a sworn statement, now held by Custer's biographer Whittaker, saying Reno refused to aid Custer's command despite urging from Weir and was accused of cowardice by his own officers. Maj. Reno denounces the story as a slander meant to influence the upcoming inquiry.

Bismarck Tribune · 30 December 1878 · page 1

RENO AND CUSTER. ST PACT-, Dec. 30.—The statement is made that Capt. Thomas B. Weir, previ­ ous to his death, made a sworn statement which is in tho hands of Capt. WhitaUer, Custer's biographer. It is to the efifcet that on the day of the fight he was seDt by '.' Reno 10 rcconnoiter and'had full view of n. »the fight. He returned to Reno and urged him to help his comrades, which Reno refused to do, and was openly accused of cowardice at the time by his own officers. K^Maj. Rtno declares the rcpart a slander -instigated to influence the coming in "vestigation.

See the clipping

Bismarck Tribune · Bismarck, N.D.

Dr. H.R. Porter, the surgeon who accompanied Reno's battalion at Little Bighorn, has been subpoenaed to testify before the court of inquiry examining Reno's conduct. The report notes the standing charge that Reno failed to go to Custer's aid, and emphasizes Porter's testimony will be unbiased since he has left the army.

Bismarck Tribune · 30 December 1878 · page 1

if Little Big Horn fight. It has been the !'/,*t*iidin? charge that Reno neglected or reftased to go to the Assistance' of General

See the clipping

Bismarck Tribune · Bismarck, N.D.

The report recounts the colorful life of Lieutenant Harry Tiffany, a wealthy Baltimore scapegrace who enlisted in the army and rose to officer rank at Fort Custer near the Little Bighorn battlefield. It details his romance with Miss Barrett, whose family opposed the match and tried to keep them apart during her visit to Bismarck.

Bismarck Tribune · 30 December 1878 · page 5

A OALLAXT OFFICER from the far off Fort Custer, in the valley of.the Little Big Horn and the historical battle-llcid where the flttwer of the Seventh Cavalry died. He was a knight and lus handsome person seemed the embodiment of thrilling romance. In Baltimore he met one'more interest­ ing than even his fond parents. They had been children together, and the elegant Miss Barrett was-as much interested in the Don C.-X'sar I)e Bazan as she had been in the young rake. Later she came oi't to Fort Custer to visit a sister, the wife®!'one of the bravest captains in the service.

See moreSee less

The sixth of September she arrived in Bismarck with a military party on the steamer Gen. Sherman. Here an uncle from New York City met her. The uncle was commissicned to protect, her trom the #miles and meetings of Har ry Tiffany, and he came all tlie way to Bismarck to see that it was effectually done. Her relatives were opposed to their iutimacy and natu­ rally feared the marital climax. Here liss B. plead with the "dear uncle" for one

See the clipping

Daily Globe · St. Paul, Minn.

The report details a dying affidavit by Col. Thomas B. Weir alleging that Reno refused to move to help Custer's command despite hearing gunfire and being urged to act, and that officers accused Reno of cowardice at the time. Reno denies the claims and asks the public to withhold judgment until a military commission hears the case in Chicago.

Daily Globe · 31 December 1878 · page 2

GEN. RENO'S CASE. Another chapter involving Gen. Reno in responsibility for the Custer massacre was furnished by the GLOBE yesterday in the form of the dying affidavit of Col. Thomas B. Weir, who commanded a detaohment un der Reno at the time of the battle of the Little Big Horn. Col. Weir declared before

See the clipping