A military board of inquiry into Major Reno's conduct during the Battle of the Little Bighorn is set to convene in Chicago. An officer's report claims Reno was four miles from Custer's command when it was destroyed, and that the force opposing Reno consisted mainly of old men, squaws, and children, suggesting Reno could have advanced to rescue Custer.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 6 days later.
Wrong
Evening Star · 1 January 1879 · page 1
a no i>?r overflowing bouse, and t>ie ps'Iormaw was as complete as usual. with the we" organized M t ake sell company. To-night the o?-era c: Luc'a i-- to be ;>re.-?<ited. irfoducing the i.ew singer. Miss Maria 1 itra. who seems *o have created genuine sensation in musical clrc'es. . \ To Investigate tite keno Massacre.?A military board of inquiry to inquire into le coedut.tof Majo' l'eno r.s. \. aL t">e battle of .e I.'. tie iiijs Horn?the t uster massacre?wiii meet at Chicago on the oth insi. Mi oticer of tfce am:y.
See moreSee less
who was ~eiv to make an inspection nt" the bn'.tietleld and other matters connected TJ *-V,'Willi 'lith uji> "? iw?j\ft fn 1 lu> Wor rlo_ partnient. Ho submits therewith a plan of the firidcf battle, and says ttat Major Reno, ln? eadof beinr one mile from Custer when the lat! i s fomiiiand was annihilated, was. in fact, tout mil* - dl .ant. The iorce oppose 1 to Reno, and on account <?f I he presence of which h (lid no? uw\e, w a* composed of old iri'lLvis. squaws and children, if Renohad advanced and ouudthe true character of th s force, he coold have come to the rescue oi coster. T-'.e venkziei.an t\'-\aki?s.?1The Preside . must soon take action on the payment of the awards made o^.(ho Venezuelan commission, lie v.ill le iri/pe!led either to sanction the awards of the (lid commission, which areall<v;vd to hrrve been iiaudultnt, or to recommend the at-; ri:,urent of a new commi - slon to invest iicaf e t1 . ;':.st,' ^ateri-jan v\u,ens. ('.mure - on 1 10 liist n: rl-.t of the la-: session passed a bill repealing t#ie act ?4 IST3,which afflrmed the 'nitty of t be awards of the old commission.
The report describes a sworn statement Capt. Thomas B. Weir gave secretly to a New York Herald correspondent, not to be released until after his death, detailing his unauthorized movement to find Custer and his return after being told the attempt was useless. It also lists the officers of the Seventh Cavalry summoned to testify at the upcoming Chicago inquiry.
The Cheyenne Daily Leader · 3 January 1879 · page 1
Weir. Special to the Inter Ocean. Bismarck,* D. T., Dec. 30.—That sworn statement of Capt. Thomas B. Weir on the Custer fight was made to Okelly, of the New York Herald , in a tent on the banks of the Yellowstone. It was given under the seal of secrecy, ; not to be used until Weir was dead. !
The report describes a purported dying statement by Col. Thomas Weir accusing Maj. Reno of refusing to aid Custer despite hearing the battle nearby, which Reno publicly denounces as false. It notes Reno will soon face a military court of inquiry into his actions.
The Cheyenne Daily Leader · 3 January 1879 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
AS TO GEN. RENO. Proofs against Gen. Reno respecting the Custer massacre are clustering rapidly. The latest is a statement said to come from the late Col Thos. B. Weir, of the United States army, and which has been published. Weir said before his death, according to this report, that the sound of Custer's firing was distinctly heard by Reno's whole command; that Weir's company was sent out to reconnoiter, saw the fight in progress, reported to Reno, and urged that Custer be helped immediately; but that Reno refused to budge.
See moreSee less
Weir's dying statement, which was sworn to, added that the point from which he obtained a full view of Custer's fight for his life was not more than a mile and a half from Reno's position, so that there could have been no difficulty in going to the relief of Custer. To all of this Reno responds in a published card, pronouncing "every statement published as emanating from Col. Weir to be absolutely false." These are brave words, which might possibly be qualified if Weir were not in his grave. But Reno, who was not long ago court-martialed for another eccentricity, will in a few days have an opportunity to defend his failure to succor Custer before a military court, and in the meanwhile it is not fair to condemn him. The most competent witnesses as to his conduct on that fatal day would be some of the savages who fought under Sitting Bull, and who knew exactly where Reno was during the massacre; but this evidence can hardly be obtained.
The item reports that Maj. Marcus A. Reno is in Washington ahead of a court of inquiry meeting Monday in Chicago to examine his conduct at the battle where Gen. Custer was killed. It also lists several unrelated courts-martial convening at various forts for trial of prisoners.
The Cheyenne Daily Leader · 3 January 1879 · page 4
MILITARY MATTERS
southeast of Dead wood. MILHARY*MATTER&. \ I Maj. Marqus A. Reno, Seventh caval ry, who is ordered before a court of in quiry which meets Monday at Chicago, in regard to his conduct at the battle where Gen. Custer was killed, is in Washington. A court-martial for the trial of pris oners will convene on Monday next, at Fort Stanton, N. M. Detail for the court: Lieut. Col. Nathan A. M. Dud ley, Ninth cavalry, Capts. Henry Carroll, Ninth cavalry, and Casper H. Conrad, Fifteenth infantry, Lieuts. Eyron Daw son, Ninth cavalry, and Daniel M.
See moreSee less
Ap pel, assistant surgeon, and Lieut. Mil lard F. Goodwin, Ninth cavalry, Charles E. Garat, Fifteenth Infantry, and J. Hansel French, Ninth cavalry, with'Lieut. Geo. W. Smith, Ninth cav alry. as judge advocate. A court-martial for the trial of pris oners will convene Monday, January 6th, at St. Paul, Minn. Detail for the court: Lieut. Col. Pinkney Lugenbeel, First infantry* Maj. Robert E. A.
The report lists officers assigned to Major Reno's upcoming court-martial in Chicago and notes related courts-martial for Capt. French and Lieut. Jerome. It also announces Gen. Sheridan's renaming of frontier military posts to honor officers killed in action, including Fort Yates for Capt. George W. Yates, killed at Little Bighorn.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
The Cheyenne Daily Leader · 3 January 1879 · page 4
MILITARY MATTERS
Following are the officers detailed on the Reno court-martial: Capts. Ed. W. Smith, Eighteenth iufantry; F. W. Benteen, T. 11. French, Myles Moylan, T. M. McDougall, E. S. Godfrey, and E. G. Mathey, Seventh cavalry; Lieuts.
Indian scouts and families who surrendered after the Custer massacre in 1877 have been resettled at Fort Keogh, where they sold their war ponies to buy cattle and seed. Under supervision of a single soldier, they raised large quantities of potatoes, vegetables, and other crops, storing the harvest in root houses they built themselves.
The Cheyenne Daily Leader · 4 January 1879 · page 4
THE RED FARMERS AT FORT KEOGH
The words of this article could not be separated from the rest of its page. Read it in the clipping.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
Daily Globe · St. Paul, Minn.
Army officers are gathering in St. Paul and Chicago for Lieut. Jerome's court martial and the Court of Inquiry into Major Reno's conduct at the Little Bighorn. Reno faces widespread accusations of cowardice in allegedly sacrificing Custer during the battle.
Daily Globe · 6 January 1879 · page 2
MAJ. RENO'S TRIAL. THE COURT MARTIAL IN ST. PAUL AND CHICAGO.
Seventh United States cavalry, for alleged misconduct at the time of "the Custer massacre.'' That the pen is mightier than the sword has ample verification wheu an army officer
The report describes officers arriving in Chicago to testify before the court of inquiry into Major Reno's conduct at the Little Bighorn, noting they are non-committal but that army opinion considers his actions questionable. It also notes a sensation caused by the late Col. T. B. Weir's reported dying statement, which some believe was critical of Reno.
Daily Globe · 6 January 1879 · page 2
THE RENO COURT. Destined for Chicago as witnesses before the Reno inquiry, are Gapt. iid. S. Godfrey, Seventh United States cavalry,Standing Rock Agency, and Capt. E. G. Mathey, of the same regiment, stationed at Fort Totten. These will be followed in a few days by Capts. Benteen, McDougall and others of the regi ment. These officers, as stated above, are decid edly non-committal upon the matter. They reserve their testimony for the court, but as they were witnesses before Reno's court martial, in an iuciden tal way the in ference can be drawn as to their views.
See moreSee less
The GLOBE doesn't prejudge anyone. But enough is known to assert that Major Reno's con duct at the time Custer's whole command was sacrificed is considered in the army as decidedly reprehensible. The charitably inclined attribute his conduct to a mistake and an ill-judged appreciation of the situation. As remarked by an officer who came to the relief of Reno's besieged command: "Why, Reno should never have abandoned his position in the brush, the first taken. It was an egregious mistake to leave this natu ral stronghold, and seek safety in a precipi tous retreat. As an evidence of the mistake, all those wh were left in the brush escaped. The loss only occurred after he had taken to the hill. There many dead were tound by the side of mangled horses at every step. "How many did he lose," was asked. "I think the relief party buried nineteen or twenty."
An officer criticizes Reno for abandoning a defensible position in the brush and retreating to the hill, where most casualties occurred. The article also recounts the late Col. Weir's private statements blaming Reno's inadequate support for the disaster, and notes Reno's later court-martial and dismissal over an unrelated scandal.
Daily Globe · 6 January 1879 · page 1
COL. WEIE'S DYING ABBAIGNMENT. In a casual way it was learned that the dying statement of the late Brevet Lieut. Colonel, T. B. Weir, Seventh cavalry, has produced a profound sensation in military circles. While some are positive that he made no such confession m'the sense im plied by a conlession, the greater number of his former comrades are lully aware that the alleged statement is in accord with his ex pressed or implied views of the great tragedy Custer's massacre. Col. Weir died while OH
An officer sent to examine the Little Bighorn battlefield submitted his report with a diagram to the War Department, showing Reno's position was four miles from Custer's massacre site rather than one mile as previously believed. The report criticizes Reno for failing to make a diversionary demonstration against the weak force of old men, boys and squaws facing him, which might have aided Custer's men.
Boll-Dozing In Massachusetts. Those Republicans who haVe been fe licitating themselves over the possible fact that Judge Tburman pill bis foot into it when be offered an amendment to the Blaine resolutions extending the election inquiry to the' Northern, Ss well as the Southern Stales, have miscalcula ted the purpose in view and the real ob ject in offering it. It was thought by them that l hurra an would not be able to make good the assertion that there was intimidation at the North, and that an inquiry in that direction would only result in trouble for the pains.
See moreSee less
Within the past few days Senatoi Bailey, of Ten nessee, a Democratic member of the Teller Committee, has received a batch of affidavits from reputable witnesses, making hroartly the allegation that they were coerced to jrote agajnattueic. con victlons in the recent Gubernatorial elec tion in .Massachusetts.. Among these are affidavits from 4 fourteen, colored men Three of them 'set forth that they are employed in a shoe-factory at Lynn, snd that thev were giVen to understand by the Superintendent . of the factory that if they voted for Butler their s-rvi-ces would lie dispensed with Eight other colored men joined in an affidavit to' the effect that they are employed in a mill t Lowell ; that on the day of the election they were not only hounded and requested to vote the anti-Bmler ticket, hut that the Superintendent accompanied them to the polish and personally made it his business to see that they voted the ticket thpir employers desired they should One of them refused to-so vote, and was discharged the next day. Another affidavit is subscribed to by a colored man and an Irish employe of a bank They wrote in the statement that the President, who had never before spoken to either,' called each into the hank office the day preceding the elec tion, and told them that if they voted for General Butler it would be " directly aga;nst the interests of their employers, arid that the force of the bank would have to be reduced to the extent of dis pensing with their services In addition to these affidavits, which have been sent without request or restraint to Senator Bajley, J udgu Thurman is also receiving similar complaints : It is alleged that Ben Butler is active in furnishing this class of evidence, and that when all U;e testimony is forwarded the. fact will be demonstrated that even in .Boston, the hah of the universe and in Massachu setts, the great moral State, that a epe cies of in'imidatlon was practiced equal ly as forcible in accomplishing revolt as in. South Carolina, Louisiana and Georgia. f According to Comptroller Knox, Who would he out of emplo. ment it the National Banks were wiped out. of exis tence, all of them are ready to resume. He says many of tbem have reduced their circulation, and all of them have been gathering gold The amount of gold held bv them aggregates 640,000,- 000 ,'Tiiis amount, he says, would seem to be all that would be necessary to meet the demand for redemption . o their notes . Their circulation is so scattered around the whole country that a run would be . hardly possible. The ?40. OOfJ.OOrjf is amply sufficient to ;allay the go! I fever, and satisfy that class of peo ple who want to fill the traditional stock ing tfrith gold If it is not sufneieut, the banks can call on the Government to re deem the legal tender reserve which they have on hand,- and thus get more gold Each bank is required to keep in reserve a certain amount of United States legal tenders This amount varies according to the locality of the bank Ah am'Otfht equal to 25 per cent of its circulation is the lowest legal-tender reserve that any bank has on hand V The botes redeerfed by the Government' Will n-t.he" destroy ed. The act. of May, 1878, ' provides that "it shall not be lawful for the Sec retary of the Treasury, , or any officers under him, to cancel or retire any more of 'the United States legal-tender notes; and when any of said notes may he re deemed, or may be received in the Treas urv under any laws, and shall belong to the United States, they shall not be re tired.canceled or destroyed.but they sfi'aH be reiestied and paid out again and kept frf circulation." The notes redeemed will not tie destroyed, but will be paid out only for current expense atnl disburse ments of the Government. ' The New Army Bill. General Binning is confident that the Bill for the Ri irganization of the AStUV willpaas. This is, also the opinion of other membrs of the Joint Committee" which prepared it ' When it wss repor ted, on December 12ih, the opinion' was generally expressed that it would never get bavond a ; per.od of discussionbut that was before it had beerrexacfined by either civilians or military men, Sinee opportunity has bein given for fts exami nation, however, it has nftt wfib greater approval than its most bangafne4 friends expected. The very ; fact that it is in dorsd by a majority of the principal ar my officers gives it great strength. There will not be that occasion or opportunity for opposition which would have baen presented if it had been such a bill as would have brought out a de'ermined disapproval in army circles. When the bill was reported. General Biunrng and 'Genera? Biirnside had an, early day fixed for its consideration fb thetf respec tive Houses.- In tue Senate it was-made the special' order for January 8th,' and in the House tor January 9lb. Ii will thus be considered simultaneouslv in both Houses, and it is believed that K can be passed within a-week,witU stieb amendmenta as will make it more perfect. Gun eral Shermanand other arrift officers having treated the bill with great fairness which Will not Slterlhe general plan and scope of the bill. 'The Committee are disposed to make it conform to their re commendations. - ' - - Custer's Fatal Field. Wwh. Speoial toPittsburgh Com. Gkattte. 1 ae oraoer d ailed to make an ex amination of the battlefield of Little Big Horn has submitted his report to the War Department The report is accom panied by a careful diagram of the ground of the fight between Sitting Bull and Custer. From the diagram it ap pears that Reno, instead of being within one mile of the scene of the massacre of Custer and his men, . was four miles way. . X ne temporary defences . thrown up by Reno a men still remained to mark the spot The report reflects somewhat upon the failure of Reno to make a dem onstration, especially as the force on bis immediate front was composed of old men, boys and squaws. It ja believed that such action on the part of Reno would have created a. diversion which would have gone far toward - redeeming the fortunes of that fatal Held '
A Washington correspondent reports that military investigators measured distances and tested sound carrying at the Little Bighorn battlefield, finding results that contradict Major Reno's official claims about distance and inability to hear Custer's fighting. Several officers, including Benteen and others from the Seventh Cavalry, have been ordered to testify in Chicago regarding allegations against Reno.
Jamestown Alert · 9 January 1879 · page 1
THE BRIDGE. The Reno Court. In reference to the alleged statement of Col. Wier in regard to the misconduct of Col. Reno, a Washington correspondent of the New York Herald says: The statement was placed in the hands of the proper authorities last summer, after the war department had ordered an investigation, and was so startling that an examination was ordered into some of the allegation made. During the past summer a party of officers, including General Nelson A. Miles, colonel of the Fifth infantry, who was then command ing the Yellowstone district Colonel Edward W.
See moreSee less
Smith, aide-de-camp to Gen eral Terry, and Lieutenant Edward Ma guire, corps of engineers, chief engineer otT.cer on General Terry's staff, visited the Little Big Horn and made a series of ex periments and measurements, with results which seem fully to prove the assertions made by Colouel Wier and other surviv ing officers of the ill-fated regiment who were,present at the battle. The distance between the points where Reno retreated to and remained, and where Custer fought antf fell, was accurately measured, and is found to be much less than has always been claimed by Reno in his reports. It was also demonstrated, as refuting Reno's statement in his official report that the distance between the two commands was so great that he could not hear the firing of Custer's column, that a siugle shot from a carbine or pistol could be plainly heard from either point, in nearly every condition of the wind. The following named officers have been ordered to Chicago to testify in this case: Colonel E. W. Smith, aid-de camp, and Lieutenant Maguire, corps of engineer of General Terry's staff, and the following of the Seventh Cavalry: Colonel Frederic W. Benteen, Captain Thomas H. French, Myles Moylan, Edward S. Godfrey and G. Mathy, and First Lieutenant Charles C. de Rudio, George D. Wallace, Charles
Major Crofton and Capt. Mathey passed through Jamestown en route east, Crofton to sit on a court-martial in St. Paul and Mathey to testify in Chicago at the Reno court of inquiry. Mathey had commanded the pack train during the Custer fight.
Jamestown Alert · 9 January 1879 · page 4
Infantry, and Capt. E. Mathey, of Co. It, 7th Cavalry, arrived from Fort Totten last Friday, on their way east. Major Crofton was on his way to sit as one of a •wurtmartial at St. Paul. Capt. Mathey went to Chicago as one of the witnesses on the Reno courtmartial. or court of inquiry, he having been in charge of the pack train at the time of the Custer
An officer's report to the War Department, accompanied by a battlefield diagram, claims Reno was four miles from the Custer massacre site rather than one mile as previously thought. The report criticizes Reno for failing to make a diversionary demonstration against a weaker enemy force that might have aided Custer.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
Belmont Chronicle · 9 January 1879 · page 1
Custer's Fatal Field. W ash. Special to Pittsburgh Com. Gazette. The officer detailed to make an ex amination of tbe battlefield of Little Big Horn has submitted his report to the War Department. The report is accompanied by a careful diagram of the ground of the fight betwea Hitting Bull and Custer. From the diagram it . . a r a. appears that iieno, insteaa oi ueiug within one mile oi tne scene oi toe massacre of Custer and his men. was four miles away. The temporary de fence thrown up by Reno's men still remained to mark tbe spot.
See moreSee less
The report reflects somewhat upon tbe failure of Reno to make a demonstration, espe cially as the force on bis immediate front was compsed of olJ men, boys and sautwa. It is believed that such action on the part of Reno would bave created a diversion wnicn wouia nave gone far toward redeeming the fortunes ottbat latai neia.
Seventh Cavalry officers including Benteen, McDougall, Hare, Wallace, Varnum and Dr. Porter depart for Chicago to testify at the Reno inquiry, with expected conflicting views on whether Reno could have aided Custer. Interpreter Girard is reported ready to contradict parts of Reno's official report, including claims about Indian numbers and Custer's intentions before the attack.
The New York Herald · 11 January 1879 · page 7
THE RENO COURT OF INQUIRY. OFFICERS OF THE SEVENTH CAVALRY EN ROUTE FOR CHICAGO AS WITNESSES—CHARACTER OF THEIR TESTIMONY—WHAT AN INTERPRETER WILL SWEAR TO.
WILL 8WEAB TO. [BY TELEGRAPH TO THB HERALD.] Bumabck, D.T., Jan. 10, 1879. Colonel Benteen, Captain McDongal, Lieutenants Hare, Wallace and Varnnm, of the Seventh cavalry, and Dr. Porter, of Bismarck, departed to-day for Chicago to attend, as witnesses, the lleno inquiry. Colonel Benteen is the inan who it popularly credited with saving Bono's command. He is, however, no champion of Custer, and will testify that there wa*
Major Reno arrived in Chicago as the Court of Inquiry into his conduct at Little Bighorn prepared to convene, with testimony suggesting his river charge was an afterthought and that Custer was surprised Reno's command moved without his order. Separately, Captain French's court martial on drunkenness charges began at Fort Lincoln but was adjourned when he was too drunk to attend.
The New York Herald · 11 January 1879 · page 7
Bismarck, D. T., Jan. 10,1S79. The court martial for tho trial of Captain French, one of the heroes of tho Little Big Horn tight, commenced to-day at Fort Lincoln, and had to adjourn to Monday on aocount of the defendant being too drunk to attend. Tho charge Is drunkennoss.
The Court of Inquiry into Major Reno's conduct at Little Bighorn is set to convene Monday at the Palmer House, composed of Col. King, Col. Merritt, and Lt.-Col. Royall, with Lt. Lee as recorder. Reno himself requested the inquiry, expressing confidence it will clear his reputation of blame for Custer's death.
Chicago Daily Tribune · 11 January 1879 · page 8
called at the request of MaJ. Reno himself, who Is confident that hu cau refute ail charges and completely Justify his action during mu tlmo when Custer and Ids men were being butchered but a short distance from bis command. MaJ. Reno arrived In tbo city yestentav aftornoou, and expressed himself as conQdeut that the In quiry would result In clearing his reputation of Hie slur cast upon It after the Custer massacre. Thu olllcers at headquarters express the same belief as to the result. Bcmm/'BiiBniDAH. Tho reply of Hccrewry .St-luin, puhltstied In Tut: TmiiLNß of jealerdoy, was received in military circles with absolute satisfaction.
Several Seventh Cavalry officers, including Benteen, Varnum, McDougall, Wallace, Hare, and Dr. Porter, are en route to Chicago to testify before a military court of inquiry investigating charges of cowardice against Major Reno at Little Bighorn. Dr. Porter shares his view that Reno might have aided Custer but is uncertain whether this would have changed the outcome or caused further casualties.
Daily Globe · 12 January 1879 · page 8
OPINIONS DIFFER. A Squad of Witnesses for tho Reno Court of Inquiry Going Forward.The Views of Several of the Party.Reno is, Both. Gnilty and not Uuilty. Among the arrivals in St. Paul yesterday were a number of officers of the Seventh Cavalry, who are en route for Chicago to give evidence in the trial of Major Marcus A. Eeno by a court of inquiry for cowardice and treachery to Gen. Custer at the battle of Little Big Horn. The party is composed of Capt. T. W. Benteen, Capt. C. A. Varnum, Capt.
See moreSee less
T. M. MoDougall, Lieut. G. D. Wal lace, Lieut. Hare and Dr. H. K. Porter, of Bismarck, who, at the time of the battle, was acting assistant surgeon of the regment. The gentleman took quarters at the Metro politan, and were glad of a rest after their long journey from Fort Lincoln. They will leave for Chicago this evening at 7:40 o'clock.
Dr. Porter, a former army surgeon who was present at the battle, is interviewed about whether Reno could be proven a coward and whether his charge might have aided or doomed Custer. He states Benteen, not Reno, was the real leader of the troops and describes tensions between Custer, Reno, and Benteen.
Daily Globe · 12 January 1879 · page 8
DR. PORTER'S VIEWS
"Do you think the charge of cowardice will be pro\edV "Well, I can hardly tell. There is cer tainly ground for it." "What do you think of the published statement purporting to bo the death-bed statement o Col. Weir?"' "I do not believe he made that statement. He was frequently in a mental condition in which he made some extraordinary state ments, which he would afterward retract. He was sent forward by Major Keno to re connoiter, but was driven back by the In dians early in the day. While the Custer fight was in progress he was ordered for waid, Lieut.
See moreSee less
Hare carrying the dispatch, and what he saw on that reconnoissance I cannot tell. Nevertheless, although Reno was nominally in command, Capt. Btnteen was really the leaaer of the forces." "Do you think there was any jealousy be tween Gen. Custer and Capt. Benteen "I know they were not on friendly terms." "Was there not a jealousy between Custer and Reno?" "Undoubtedly." "How did it come that Benteen was the leader when Reno ranked him in command?" "Well, the soldiers recognized the stronger mind and followed it. It will always be thus." "Then I conclude that Reno did not cut much of a figure in the regiment?" "Reno was not a man to lead a regiment in such a time. Benteen took command nat urallyjust as strong men always do. It was not surprising." "What, your opinion, will be the out come of the court of inquiry?" "Of course I cannot tell. If the evidence adduced proves that Reno was guilty of cowardice, he would, in time of war, be shot. At any rate the present court will simply de termine whether it will be necessary to call a court maitial to decide on the charges preferred." Dr. Proctor is not now in the service, and while ho did not Jesiie the publication of his views, the GLOBE takes the liberty of giving them in substance, without asking his con sent.
Captain Benteen, en route to testify before the court of inquiry into Reno's conduct at Little Bighorn, tells a reporter he believes Reno was innocent of cowardice and that reinforcing Custer was a physical impossibility given the distance. He also recounts a separate conversation in which Dr. Proctor speculated that a guilty verdict could lead to a court martial and possible execution for Reno.
Daily Globe · 12 January 1879 · page 8
CAPT. BENTEEN. Tall stature. Well-proportion as to form. Erect and soldierly in bearing. A beardless, tawny-skmned face, the somewhat severe and perpendicular lines of which were softened by a pair of intelligent, keen, gray eyes. A luxunant head of crisp, early hair, prematurely gray, surmounted by a jauntv cap. Capt. F. W. Benteen, of the famous Seventh cavalry, as he conversed with a GLOBE representative at the Metropolitan hotel last midnight. "On your way East, I believe, captain," ventured the GLOBE man, after the ceremony of a self-introduction. "Yon are right," was the rejoinder, "if nothing transpnes to prevent, I shall leave for Chicago to-morrow evening."
See moreSee less
"If 1 am rightly informed you are sum moned aB a witness before the courtof inquiry that is to investigate Reno's alleged respon sibility for the Custer massacre?" "That is my object in going." "If agreeable, captain, the GLOBE would like to know your sentiments regarding the affair?" "As to Reno's responsibility for the mas sacre," remarked Capt. Benteen. "Exactly." "Well, sir, I can assure you that in express ing my private conviction, I have no hesi tation in saying that I believe Reno entirely innocent of the charge laid at his door. He behaved as any other man would have acted surrounded by the same circumstances. The fact is, that all the talk abeut Reno's being able to reinforce Custer is simply absurd. Considering the distance that separated them, it was a maiter of sheer impossibility." "You were in the subsequent engagement, were you not?" "Yes. We joined the detachment after the repulse." "You think, then, that the Little Big Horn massacre was due to the action of the la mented Custer himself "Most assuredly. In my opinion it was the result of Caster's own actions, and it is an injustice to attribnte the blame to some one else." The conversation was interrupted at this point by the entrance of several friends who claimed the attention of the captain, where upon, after thanking the veteran, the GLOBE man started home to turn in copy.
This report announces the start of a formal Court of Inquiry into charges that Major Marcus A. Reno acted cowardly during the Battle of the Little Big Horn, including accusations that he retreated and failed to aid Custer. It provides background on the 1876 battle and notes Reno himself requested the inquiry to clear his name.
Chicago Daily Tribune · 13 January 1879 · page 3
THE RENO INQUIRY.
On the 25th of June, 1870, tho Seventh Regi ment of Cavalry, U. 8. A., met and gave battle to n large body of Sioux Indiana at a point on the left bank of tho Little Gig Horn River, Da kota. Although nearly three years have elapsed since that memorable day, the one paramount result of that engagement is still fresh in the minds of the people of this nation;—tho com plete annihilation of five companies of troops, .together with tbo commander ot the regiment, Lleut.-Col. Georee A. Custer. To-dav o Court of Inquiry, composed of army officers, assembles la this city to investigate cer tain charges which havo from time to tima burn made against Maj.
See moreSee less
Marcus A. Reno, a .Major of the Seventh Cavalry, a participant in the Little Big Horn fight, as commanding officer of a de tachment ot three companies, and at present under sentence of snspension of pay for alleged improprieties towards the wife of a brother of ficer. It having been charged in the public press and elsewhere that Maj. Reno, at tho time of tho deplorable engagement with tho Sioux under Sluing Bull, was OCII.TT OP COWARDICE,
A Court of Inquiry has been convened at the Palmer House to examine charges that Major Reno acted out of cowardice by retreating and failing to aid Custer, contributing to the disaster at Little Bighorn. The report also reviews the background of the 1876 campaign, describing the planned pincer movement of Crook, Terry, and Gibbon against the Sioux.
Chicago Daily Tribune · 13 January 1879 · page 3
GUILTY OF COWARDICE
thorough and lengthy. WHAT LED TO TJI* VJOUT. While the fact that Custer and a portion of his regiment were on that memorable day cut down tu tho last man, may stood out clearly iu the minds of tho general public, the events
This 1879 retrospective recounts the 1876 campaign plan, with Crook and Terry advancing from different directions to trap the Sioux near the Big Horn Mountains. It details the Seventh Cavalry's departure from Fort Lincoln, their march along the Yellowstone, and Reno's reconnaissance mission up Powder River before Custer's own advance toward Tongue River.
Chicago Daily Tribune · 13 January 1879 · page 3
WHAT LED TO THE FIGHT
Geo. Terrv was advancing from Fort Abraham Lincoln, where the Seventh Cavalry bad been In •winter quarters. The departure from Fort Lincoln occurred on the ISllt of May, 1870, Gen. Terry having undur bis command twelve com panies ol the Seventh Cavalry, two pieces «»f artillery, and two companies of infantry. The march across the country was made over Stan ley’s trulls. Ou the Bth of Juno the command reached Powder River, twcnty-tlvu miles above tis mouth. On the following dav Gen. Terry, taking two companies of the Seventh Cavalry, went to tjiu confluence of Powder River wlth\
A military court of inquiry into Major Reno's responsibility for the Custer massacre opened in Chicago with doors open to the public, though reporters were barred from taking notes. The session's main action was deciding to summon Whittaker, who had made the original charges against Reno.
The Rock Island Argus · 13 January 1879 · page 1
Major Beno Again in Court. Oiitcago. Jan. 13. The military court of inquiry into the responsibility of Major Reno tor the Custer massacre, convened here to-dav with open doors, but reporters were not allowed to take notes ot the proceedinea. The only important action ot tho first session was a decision to summon Whittaker. who made the charges against Reno.
On the eve of his Chicago court of inquiry, Gen. Reno tells a reporter that his 112 men were vastly outnumbered by Sioux warriors who nearly encircled his position, and that pulling back saved his command from Custer's fate. He also claims Custer could see Reno's fight from a nearby height but did not come to his aid.
Daily Globe · 13 January 1879 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
FARED THE SAME FATE AS CUSTER'S.
RENO'S RACKET.
THE CHICAGO INQUIRY INTO THE CUSTER MASSACRE.
See moreSee less
Members of the Court Already Putting in Appearance—A "Globe" Reporter Meets and Interviews the Accused Officer—General Defense of His Conduct and Anxiety for a Thorough Investigation—Departure from St Paul of Important Witnesses.
[Special Telegram to the Globe.]
CHICAGO, Jan. 12.—Three or four of the court which is to meet to-morrow to inquire into the charges preferred against Major Reno, arrived in this city from the West this afternoon. A number of witnesses are also en route hither, but may not reach the city before Monday afternoon. Gen. Reno is at the Palmer House, and awaits the convening of the court. In conversation with the GLOBE reporter, Gen. Reno politely, but guardedly, answered a few questions put to him in a casual way. He was asked if he had formed any idea of the strength of the enemy at the time his command engaged them in battle.
He replied that the valley in front of him was swarming, and that his force of 112 men was overwhelmingly outnumbered.
NOT A MAN OF MY COMMAND WOULD HAVE SURVIVED,
said he, had we not changed position. The enemy was not only in front, but on our left and rear. They would have closed in on our right and completed a circle in five minutes more. Soldiers will not flinch from duty, so long as they can fight the enemy face to face, but place them in a position where they are as liable to be shot down from behind as fr[o]m in front, and they are at once disconcerted and unnerved, and cannot do effective fighting. I moved my command back where, like a man crowded into a corner, they could fight without being shot in the back, and but for that my men would have
FARED THE SAME FATE AS CUSTER'S.
In answer to the question whether Custer was aware of his (Reno's) engagement with the Indians, the general said:
He could see from the eminence from where he halted for a brief time, thas the Indians were fighting my command, but he did not come to my assistance, and had we not retreated just as we did we would have been wiped out.
In conclusion Gen. Reno said he was very willing to have the court develop all the facts in the case, and he would cheerfully abide by its decision, but of one thing he was quite certain, namely, that if he ever did his whole duty during his military career, it was at the battle of the Little Big Horn.
The "Globe's" Contribution.
All news in connection with the Reno trial, to commence to-day in Chicago, is of particular and peculiar interest to St. Paul. Reno's record of late years is pretty well known in this community, and has had a partial ventilation in our midst. The GLOBE, aware of this interest, has duly posted and gratified its readers with all events happening in regard to the affair. Yesterday St. Paul contributed a number of witnesses to the investigation in Chicago. They took the 7:40 train for Chicago, a jolly party, though bent on a mission to spoil or illumine American history.
The party were composed of Capts. Fred. W. Benteen, Thomas M. McDougall, Lieuts. Varnum and Wallace, Seventh U. S. cavalry; Dr. Porter, Bismarck, late assistant surgeon United States army; Frank Girard, scout. Col. Smith and Lieut. Maguire, of Gen. Terry's staff, were also of the party. These last a[r]e also parties to the issue at stake.
In looking over the crowd, the GLOBE ventures the assertion that there will be a stand-off in the testimony given "to make history" in this affair. Col. Benteen is anti-Custer; McDougall favorable to keeping Custer's gallant memory untarnished—the others are evenly balanced. The term anti-Custer is used advisedly. For no matter how the attempt may be concealed, the effort of Reno and friends will be directed in his vindication to tarnish the memory and deeds of the gallant, brave and unfortunate Custer. It will be the revival of an old and disgraceful army fight—for years confined to the Seventh regiment. So early and long ago as the organization of the Seventh cavalry, a feeling of enmity to Custer was entertained by many of his regiment; others were as warm in his admiration. The feeling of both parties was fostered, until the division in the regiment was marked and distinct. The bitterness of the controversy can not be understood except by those idle enough to cultivate it, and with nothing else to engage their attention. The thought is suggestive that a regiment divided by such a contention would be useless. The master spirit of Custer, in command, kept it in subjection.
The leader of the Custer opposition was, at first, Col. Wm. Thompson. He left the regiment. His mantel fell upon the shoulders of Col. Fred. W. Benteen.
The opposition to Custer were in Reno's command at the battle of the Little Big Horn, and survived; the supporters of Custer went gallantly to their death, with their commander fighting bravely and desperately at their head.
The Globe reports that a group of witnesses, including officers from the Seventh Cavalry like Benteen, McDougall, Varnum, and Wallace, left St. Paul for Chicago to testify at the Reno court of inquiry. The article discusses long-standing factional divisions within the regiment between pro- and anti-Custer officers, suggesting the testimony will revive this old rivalry.
Daily Globe · 13 January 1879 · page 1
The party were composed of Capts. Fred. W. Benteen. Thomas M. McDougall, Lieuts. Var num and Wallace, Seventh TJ. S. cavalry Dr. Porter, Bismarck, late assistant surgeon United States army Frank Girard, scout. Col. Smith and Lieut. Maguire, of Gen. Terry's staff, were also of the party. These last a e" also parties to the issue at stake. In looking over the crowd, the GLOBE ven tures the assertion that there will be a stand off in thrt testimony given "t make history" in this affair. Col."Benteen is anti-Custer Mc Dougall favorable to keeping Custer's gallant memory untarnishedthe others are evenly balanced.
See moreSee less
The term anti-Custer is used ad visedly. For no matter how the attempt may be concealed, the effort of Reno and friends will be directed in his vindication to tarnish the memoiy and deeds of the gallant, brave and unfortunHte Custer. I will be the revival of an old and disgraceful army fightfor years confined to the Seventh regiment. 8o early and long ago as ti organization of the Seventh cavalry, a feeling of enmity to Cutter was entertained by many of his regi ment others were as warm in his admiration. The feeling of both parties was fostered, until the division in the regiment was marked and distinct. The bitterness of the controversy can not be understood except by those idle enough to cultivate it, and with nothing else to engage their attention. The thought is sug gestive that a regiment divided by such a con tention would be useless The mastw spirit of Custer, in command, kept it in subjection. The leader of the Custer opposi'ioa was, at first, Col. Wm. Thompson. He left the regi ment. His mantel fell upon the shoulders of Col. Fred. W. Benteen.
The Globe reports that a group of St. Paul-based officers and witnesses—including Benteen, McDougall, Varnum, Wallace, Dr. Porter, and scout Girard—left for Chicago to testify in the Reno Court of Inquiry. The article frames the proceeding as a revival of old factional bitterness within the 7th Cavalry between pro- and anti-Custer officers, predicting Reno's defense will come at the expense of Custer's reputation.
Daily Globe · 13 January 1879 · page 3
The party were composed of Capts. Fred. W. Benteen. Thomas M. McDougall, Lieots. Var num and Wallace, Seventh D. S. cavalry Dr. Porter, Bismarck, late assistant surgeon United States army Frank Girard, 6cout. Col. Smith and Lieut. Maguire, of Gen. Terrv's staff, were alo of the partv. These last a e'also parties to the issue at stake. In looking over the crowd, the GLOBE ven tures the assertion that there will be a stand off th^- testimony given "to make history" in this affair. Col. Benteen is anti-Custer Mc Dougall favorable to keeping Custer's gallant memory untarnishedthe others are erenly balanced.
See moreSee less
The term anti-Custer is used ad visedly. For no matter how the attempt mav be concealed, the effort of Reno and friends will be directed in his vindication to tarnish the ruemo-iy and deeds of the gallant, brave and unfortunnte Custer. It will be the revival of an old and disgraceful army fightfor sears confined to the Seventh regiment. 8o early and long ago as tt organization of the Seventh cavalry, a feeling of enmity to Cutter was entertained by many of his regi ment others were as warm if*, his admiration. I'he feeling of both parties was fostered, until the division in the regiment was marked and distinct. The bitterness of the controversy can not be understood except by those idle enough to cultivate it, and with nothing else to engage their attention. Thf thought is sug gestive that a regiment divided by such a con tention would be use'ess The master spirit of Custer, in command, kept it in subjection. The leader of the Custer opposition was, at first, Col. Wm. Thompson. He lett the regi ment. His mantel fell upon the shoulders of Col. Fred. W. Bent*en.
A roundup of local arrivals and departures in Bismarck, including several officers traveling to Fort Lincoln to attend a court martial. The notices are brief social and travel updates with no narrative detail about the proceedings themselves.
Bismarck Tribune · 13 January 1879 · page 8
Fort Linoolu. Practical jokes are sometimes offensive tide Col. Baker and the demijohn of whis ky Of Benteen's. Sig tlauauer, the clothier, left for new York Friday morning where he will re main several weeks. Lieut. W. Manu and Lieut. T. S. Mc Comiiek of Ft. Yates, spent a few days in Bismarck last week. A. P. Farrar and S. H, Babcock, of the N. P. It. R., stayed over night at the Sher
This Bismarck local news column reports that several officers—including Lieut. Varnum, Capt. McDougall, Col. Benteen, Lieut. Hare, and Lieut. Wallace—departed for Chicago to attend the Reno investigation. It also notes other local figures traveling to Fort Lincoln for an unrelated court martial.
Bismarck Tribune · 13 January 1879 · page 8
Capt. Wheelan, of the Second Cavalry, and sister, of Fort Custer, arrived in tJ le city last week and departed for the .st this morning, where they will remain i\n til the opening of navigation. Madam Rumor reports that about two days ago certain two individuals at ort Beithold Indian Agency, sat up two whole
The military court of inquiry into Major Reno's responsibility for the Custer massacre opened in Chicago with open doors, though reporters were barred from taking notes. The court's main action was deciding to summon Whittaker, who had made the original charges against Reno.
Daily Press and Dakotaian · 13 January 1879 · page 1
THE RENO INQUIRY. Chicago, Jan 13.—The military court of inquiry into the responsibility of Major Reno, for the Custer massacre, convened here to-day with open doors, but reporters were not allowed to take notes of the pro' ceedings. The only important action of the first cession was a decision to summon Whittaker, who made the charges against Reno.
The Herald reprints its 1876 correspondent's dispatch detailing confidential officer accounts accusing Major Reno of inaction at Little Bighorn, which prompted the paper's original call for an investigation. It notes the inquiry was finally ordered in 1879, but laments that Colonel Weir, a key witness, had since died before testifying.
The New York Herald · 14 January 1879 · page 4
RENO'S STRANGE INACTION.
notice by the Herald, accompanied by a demand : for an official investigation, which should either relieve Major iteno from charges which must affect his character as a soldier or bring hint due punishment if found guilty. Action bus at last been taken iu this serious matter: but, unfortunately, not before the most important witness?the man who saw with his own eyes the lust sad scenes of the Custer massacrehad
This report argues that an investigation into Major Reno's actions should have been held sooner, before the death of key witness Colonel Weir, whose testimony might have settled the question of responsibility for the Custer disaster. It criticizes the official battle report as inaccurate and claims officers remain silent out of duty, loyalty, and fear of retaliation, calling for a sworn investigation to reveal the full truth.
The New York Herald · 14 January 1879 · page 4
THE LONG DELAYED INVESTIGATION
where the witnesses will have to answer under oatli. It such investigation should he held startling revelations may be looked for. The story of Custer's fight ami death is still unwritten. Your correspondent has gleaned some important tacts which must compel further investigation, but the officers of the regiment will give no information unless they are compelled to do so. From the day the Hkuald correspondent
The report argues that officers have stayed silent about the Little Bighorn disaster out of loyalty and fear of retaliation, but that fragments of truth have leaked out suggesting blundering or lack of support for Custer. It demands a full government investigation while witnesses are still alive to determine whether blame lies with Custer's rashness or his subordinates' failures.
The New York Herald · 14 January 1879 · page 4
RETICENCE OF OFFICERS AND WHY
merely echoed the official l.mguuge ! But little by little the truth came out; words spoken ut unguarded moments and dropped tu the hi at of argument, simple questions answered by officers and wcu, aud the whole joined together and connected has produced the conviction that there was blundering, want of soldierly sympathy?a failure ou the purt of men to do their duty, or lnkewarmuess in supporting (lenerai Custer?that might bo eallua by an ugly name. LICT t'S HAYK AN INVKMTIUAXION.
The Herald republishes its own 1876 correspondent's report alleging Reno and Benteen halted for two hours near Custer's position after receiving his order to advance, delaying aid. The paper says this evidence should be considered by the court now trying Reno in 1879.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
The New York Herald · 14 January 1879 · page 6
A Leaf from History
and delayed, and tho officers ot the Third It would please all our citizens to avenue line would have done well had they sec these two officers acting in cordiul added to their promises lor the luture the harmony for the .promotion of muuicioal then in the Indian Territory, in which he stated that there was good ground for believing that Major lleno and Captain Eoliteen had tailed in thoir duty to succor General Custer at tho Little Big Horn battle. Wo do this not to injure Major Bono, now on trial, or to prejudge his case, for wo believe him to
The Court of Inquiry requested by Major Reno into his conduct at the Little Bighorn convened at the Palmer House, composed of Colonels King and Merritt and Lt.-Col. Royall, with Lt. Lee as recorder. The session dealt largely with procedural matters, including whether reporters could remain, and Reno stated he had no objection to the court's composition.
Chicago Daily Tribune · 14 January 1879 · page 3
MAJ. RENO. The Investigation of His Conduct at the Custer Massacre.
ferred to, Is hereto attached. Very respectfully, Thn Recorder was about to read the loiter to Mr. Corlett, but Mb}. Reno objected, and ho desisted. Tim Recorder theu stated that there was a inau by thu uotno of M. A. Ukno. Major Seventh Cavalry. WUITAKBR.
The article describes the Court of Inquiry convened to investigate the Little Bighorn disaster, specifically to determine whether Major Reno was guilty of cowardice for failing to aid Custer. It outlines key unresolved questions, including whether Custer disobeyed orders and whether the regiment's fate might have been different with different troop movements.
Chicago Daily Tribune · 14 January 1879 · page 3
CUSTEE BATTIiE-FIEI/D, WHAT SHOULD 118 FOUND OUT. Tits TitinUNß yesterday gave a complete and succinct review of tho march of tho Seventh Cavalry from tho day of Its departure from Tort Lincoln, In May, IBTd, to the memorable 25th of June following, when it gave battle to the com bined Sioux forces under Sitting Bull on the banks of tbo Little Big Horn River. Tho Inci dents connected with that expedition under Gen. Terry, and tho final disaster which over whelmed five companies of tho Seventh Regi ment, have been recited in detail, but Itunques tlonably remains for a searching court of'lnqui ry, organized for the express purpose of eliciting all of the minutest facts, to determine tho right aud wrong of tbo movements which were then inado by tbe unfortunate commander of tbe regiment and tho officers to whom was given the duty of co-operating with him In that unfor tunate attack.
See moreSee less
Whether Custer disobeyed or ders. sad permitted his zeal and enthusiasm to run away with his Judgment: whether Reno willfully neglected to succor his commander in his hour of extreme peril; whether thu'dav might have been saved to the troops, or the entire regiment annihilated, had the seven com panies which made the final stand on Reno's hill gone farther and been surrounded by savages,— these are question# which the closest scrutiny and most caroial weighing of testimony must determine to the nubile mind. It Is enough to know that the disaster occurred: how it hap itened, or whether there was a display of coward ice, requires more than casual observation or tbo acceptance of mere hearsay evidence. It Is to determine the responsibility resting upon tho shoulders of Maj. itcuo—wno has been charged with cowardice lu that ho did not aid Custer— that tbe Court of Inquiry Is now sotting In ibis city. To give tho genera) reader a more comprehen sive idea of the battle-field wiicro Custer met Us fate, Tub Tiiiuunb presents this morning A MAP OP TUB LOCALITY,
The Military Court of Inquiry requested by Maj. Reno to investigate his conduct at the Battle of the Little Big Horn met but only settled procedural matters. The court decided to hold open hearings but barred reporters from taking notes, a rule the paper criticizes as impractical.
Chicago Daily Tribune · 14 January 1879 · page 4
gation Into his conduct at tho battle of the Little Big Horn, June 25, 1876, in which 00. currod the terrible massacre of Gen. Custer and his command, assembled yesterday, but beyond tbo decision of some points os to tbo mode of procedure, transacted no business.
The military court of inquiry into Major Reno's conduct at the Custer massacre resumed session, with Reno present in full uniform with his counsel. The first witness, engineer Edwin Maguire, described the topography of the battlefield site.
The Rock Island Argus · 14 January 1879 · page 1
ICilitary Co art. Chicago, Jan. 14 Thi military court of inquiry into Major Ueno s e .mduct at the Custer massacre resumed session this morninc. Major Iteno appeared in full uniform, accompanied by his counsellor. Lyman D. Gilbert, of liarrisburg. Pa. It was decided that the Recorder of the court should first bring his allegations and pres ent the case, to be followed by the accused with rebutting testimony, this is the re verse of the order which Major neno deHired should be observed. 1 he first wit ness called was Edwin Maguire, of the en gineering corps, which was on the ground the day succeeding the massacre. He simply cave a description of the topo graphy of the scene.
A military court of inquiry into Major Reno's responsibility for the Custer massacre convened in Illinois, with open doors but reporters barred from taking notes. The only significant action was a decision to summon Whittaker, who had originally brought the charges against Reno.
Daily Kennebec Journal · 14 January 1879 · page 3
ILLINOIS. The Charges Against Kcno. ..January 13. The military court of inquiry into the responsibility of Major Reno, for the Custer massacre, convened to day with open doors, but reporters were not allow ed to take notes of the proceedings. The only important action of the first session was a decision to summon Whittaker, who made the charges against Reno.
The military court of inquiry into Major Reno's conduct at the Custer massacre opened with doors open to the public, but reporters were barred from taking notes. The session's main action was deciding to summon Whitaker, who had made the original charges against Reno.
The Portland Daily Press · 14 January 1879 · page 2
CmcAGO, Jan, 13 —Tho military court of inquiry into the responsibility of Major Reno for tho Custer massacre, opened to day with open doors, hut re poners were not allowed to take notes of the pro ceedings. The only important action of the first ses sion was a decision to summon Whitaker who made the charges against Reno.
A military court of inquiry convened in Chicago to examine Major Reno's conduct at the Custer massacre, with doors open but reporters barred from taking notes. The court's main action was deciding to summon Frederick Whittaker, the man who had brought charges against Reno.
Daily Globe · 14 January 1879 · page 1
Whittaker to be huiumoned. CHICAGO, Jan. 13.The military court of in quiry into the responsibility of Major Reno tor the Custer massacre convened here to-day with open doors, but reporters were not allowed to take notes of the proceedings. Ti only important action of the first session was a de cision to summon Whittaker, who made the charges against Reno.
The military court of inquiry into Major Reno's conduct at the Custer massacre resumed session in Chicago, with Reno present in full uniform alongside his counsel. The recorder was to present allegations first, followed by rebuttal testimony, and the first witness, engineer Edwin Maguire, described the topography of the battle site.
Daily Press and Dakotaian · 14 January 1879 · page 1
aw.-AJ TELEGRAPHIC BREVITIES THE BEHO ISQtJIRY. Chicago, Jan. 14.—The military court of Inquiry into Major Reno'a conduct at the Custer massscte resumed its session tbis morning. Major Reno appeared in full uni form, accompanied by his counsel, Ly man D. Gilbert, of Barrisburg, Pa. It was decided tbst tbe recorder of tbe court should first bring bis allegations and present tbe case, to be followed by tbe accused with re butting testimony. This is tbe reverse of tbe order which Major Reno desired should be observed. The first witness called was Edwin Maguire, of the engineering corps which wss on tbe ground the day succeed ing the massacre. He simply gave a des cription of the topography of tbe scenes.
The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · Wheeling, W. Va.
The Military Court of Inquiry into Major Reno's responsibility for the Custer massacre convened in Chicago with open doors, though reporters were barred from taking notes. The only significant action was a decision to summon Whittaker, who had made charges against Reno.
The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · 14 January 1879 · page 4
The lteno Trial. CiucAGOy-January 13.?The Military Court of Injniry into the responsibility of Major Reno for tho Custer massacre, con1 vencd here to-day with open doors, but tho reporters woro not allowed to take
A military court of inquiry into Major Reno's responsibility for the Custer massacre convened in Chicago with open doors, though reporters were barred from taking notes. The court's main action was deciding to summon Whittaker, who had made the original charges against Reno.
The Cheyenne Daily Leader · 14 January 1879 · page 1
ILLINOIS. w The M»J. Reno Inquiry. Chicago, Jan. 13. The military court of inquiry into the responsibility of Maj. Reno for the Custer massacre, convened here to-day with open doors, but reporters were not allowed to take notes of the proceedings. The only important action of the first session was a decision to summon Wiiittaker, who made the charges against Reno.
Salt River Herald · Phoenix, Salt River Valley, Ariz.
A dispatch from Chicago reports that a military court of inquiry into Major Reno's conduct at the Custer massacre is now in session. The brief item gives no further detail on witnesses or proceedings.
Salt River Herald · 15 January 1879 · page 2
.Major Reno at the Custer massacre, is in session here. : Kai.kioii. X". C. January 14. Gov. Vance will qi; elected United States senator on the first ballot.
The Military Court of Inquiry into Major Reno's conduct at the Custer massacre resumed session in Chicago, with Reno present in full uniform alongside his counsel Lyman D. Gilbert. The court decided the Recorder would present allegations first, followed by rebuttal testimony, and the first witness, engineer Edwin Maguire, described the topography of the battlefield.
Daily Los Angeles Herald · 15 January 1879 · page 2
Hnrttiu Uantfert. PIIIDADELPHIA, Pa., Jan. 14.—A writ of error In the case of Bergin, the Molly Magulre, bas been re fused, and the execution took place as arranged. The Bhiio fjiiurc or laqnlry. Chicago, Jan. 14th.—The Mili tary Court of Inquiry into Major Reno's conduct at the Custer masBRCro, resumed its session this morning. Major Reno appeared iv full uniform, accompanied by his counsellor, Lyman D. .Gilbert, of Harrisburg, Pa. It was decided that the Recorder of tbo Court should first bring his allegations and present the case, to be followed by the accused witli rebutting tes timony.
See moreSee less
This is the reverse of Ihe ordir whioh Major Reno desired should be observed. The first wit ness called wbb Edwin Maguire, of the Engineer corps, which was on tiie ground tho day succeeding tho massacre, He simply gave a description of tlio topogripby of the scene.
The report criticizes the decision to close the court of inquiry into Major Reno's conduct at the Little Big Horn to press coverage, arguing that secrecy will harm either Reno or the court's credibility. It also questions why Captain French, a key witness, is simultaneously facing his own court-martial elsewhere.
The New York Herald · 15 January 1879 · page 6
Major Reno's friends, as well as his enemies, will regret that the press is denied the right to report the proceedings of the court of inquiry now in session at Chicago. If Reno is innocent of the terrible charge of negleoiing to obey orders and support Custer in the fatal fight on the Little Big Horn he is the most shockingly maligned man in America; if guilty, any attempt to withhold or obscure the testimony will ruin him and the members of the court also.
The Court of Inquiry into Major Reno's conduct at Little Bighorn began its formal proceedings in Chicago, with Recorder Lee reading prior correspondence including Frederick Whittaker's letter of accusations against Reno. Reno introduced his counsel, Lyman D. Gilbert, as the court prepared to hear witness testimony starting with Lieut. McGuire of the Engineer Corps.
Chicago Daily Tribune · 15 January 1879 · page 9
Engineer Corps. The Court of Inquiry In the rase of MaJ. Reno, Seventh Cavalry, were prompt In beginning their work yesterday forenoon In Room 14 Palmer House. At II o’clock the officers were
The report reproduces Frederick Whittaker's 1878 letter to Congress accusing Major Reno of cowardice and disobedience that doomed Custer, along with Captain Benteen of inaction, and recommending a formal investigation. It also notes the House Military Committee's recommendation and subsequent orders for a Court-Martial to be organized.
Chicago Daily Tribune · 15 January 1879 · page 9
Court-Martial. TUB DOCUMENT Is ns follows: Mount Vubnon. N. Y., May lit, 1878.— Th» Jloit, IP. JF. Cnrlett, M. G.—Dcau 8m: Hiring been called on to prooaro (he biourapby of the late Brevet Maj.-Gen. Heorgo A. Ouster, IT. 8. A., a crest amount of evidence, ors) and written, came into my hands tending to prove that the sacrifice of his life and the lives of his Immediate com mand at the battle of (ho Little Dig Horn was ussWe, and owing to (he cowardice of his sabordi mites. I desire, therefore, to ask your attention, ond that of C'omrre«s Hmmzh you.
See moreSee less
to the necessity of ordering an official invotligatton by a committee of vour honorable body into the conduct ot the Unhurt Stales troops onaißeu lu the battle of the Little IHg Horn, fought ■lnneg.'i. 1870, otherwise known as the Custer massacre. In which Lieut.- Col. Cuktcr. Seventh United Hlatrs Cavalry, per l«hcil, with flvn ciHDpAuios of the Suvunth Cavalry, nt toe hands of Hie Indians. The reasons on which 1 found mr request are as follows: /’■rAf—lnformation coming tome from partici pants In the b»‘.lte, written and oral, la to the effect that gro*s eowsrdlco was displayed therein by Maj. Marcus A. Heuo, Seventh United Slates Cavalry, second in command that dav; and that, ’ owing to such cowardice. Uie orders nf LleuU-Col. cu«ti‘r. commanding ofticur tusalalleuo, to exe cute a certain attack were not oboved. That tho inilnroof this movement, owing to his cowardice anil disobedience, caused the detest of 1 the United Mates forces on Hie day In question; and Hut, had Custer s orders been obeyed, the trooua would probably have defeated (he Indians, That alter MsJ. Reno's cowardly flight, he wss Joined hy Copt. F. W. Beuleon, Seventh United Hites Cavalry, with reinforcements which wore placed under Iff* order, and that he remained Idle with iff* force wnllu his superior offlcorwss fighting imniuit the whole force of thu Indians, thu battle being within Ids knowledge, the sound of firing audible from his position, and his forces out of imim-dlatu danger from Hie enemy. That me consequence of this second exhibition cd cowardice aim locoinpelcucy was tho massacre of Licnt.-Col. Custer and five companies of (be heieuth Untied States Cavalry.
The report reproduces a letter by Frederick Whittaker, read at the Reno Court of Inquiry, which denounces the official Army account of the Little Bighorn defeat as blaming Custer unfairly. Whittaker argues the true cause of the disaster was Major Reno's cowardice and willful refusal to engage the enemy, and demands a full investigation to clear Custer's name.
Chicago Daily Tribune · 15 January 1879 · page 9
THE DOCUMENT
The words of this article could not be separated from the rest of its page. Read it in the clipping.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
The Rock Island Argus · Rock Island, Ill.
Lieutenant George D. Wallace testified before the court of inquiry examining allegations by Whittaker that Major Reno showed cowardice and neglect of duty at Little Bighorn. Wallace described how Custer's forces were divided and said Reno's men were exhausted from swift marching before being overmatched by Indian forces.
The Rock Island Argus · 15 January 1879 · page 1
Uilitary Court. Chicago. Jan. 15 Tt 1Q rtsimA(l Vit? tha friends of Major Reno that yesterday's evidence was imnortant in that if tKo that Major Reno could not havn hearA tKo result of the noise of the skirniiahiog froai the position ne occupied wnen, as it will be attracted to prove by subsequent witnesses, he should have taken a hand in the fight. The allegations of Whittaker, six in number and summed up as being gross cowardice and neglect of duty, are before the court in ihe form of a letter Lieutonaut Geo.
See moreSee less
D. Wallace, ot the 7th cavalry, was the first witness to-day and was introduced by Recorder Lee. He de tailed the methods of dividing General Custer's forces; he said General Reno's ey came up,n the scene were exhausled through swift marching, and when they met the Indians, were over matched for the nine and compelled to retreat.
Charges of cowardice against Major Reno for his conduct at the Battle of the Little Big Horn, where Custer died, are being investigated by a board of army officers in Chicago. The report briefly notes the ongoing inquiry without further detail.
The Princeton Union · 15 January 1879 · page 1
THE charges of cowardice, preferred against Major Reno for his conduct at the battle of the Little Big Horn where the heroic Custer fellare be
A military court of inquiry into Major Reno's responsibility for the Custer massacre opened in Chicago with open doors, but reporters were barred from taking notes. The only notable action was a decision to summon Whittaker, who had made the original charges against Reno.
Morning Appeal · 15 January 1879 · page 2
necessary. - w M ! SC E L L A N EO I S TL L EG 1 1 A MS. Chicago. January The military court f inniry into the responsil-iiity of Major Reno for the Custer massacre convened here to day with open doors, but rep liters were nut allowed to take notes of the proceedings. Tlie only important action of the session was a decision to summon Whittaktr, who made the charge auainst Reno. .Boston, January l.'J. It is feared the uteanier Horner is lost. .She has not. been hoard from since leaving here, December 17, for Liverpool.
See moreSee less
New York, January l-'. A California colony, with a special view to fruit growing, is organizing to start out from lbitFalo. One of the national banks sold S17,000,000 of four per cents, to-day.
A newspaper recounts the checkered criminal career of a young man who had served as a soldier near the site of the Custer massacre, wandering the battlefield shortly afterward. It details his subsequent killing of a deputy sheriff, acquittal on self-defense grounds, and descent into a life of crime including joining a gang of train robbers.
Union County Courier · 15 January 1879 · page 4
He was near the scene of the Custer massacre, and wandered over the bloody field shortly after that terrible battle. Iu the eotirse of his service, his regiment
The court of inquiry investigating Major Reno's responsibility for the Custer massacre opened in Chicago on Monday with open doors. The court decided to summon Whittaker, Reno's accuser, to testify.
Green-Mountain Freeman · 15 January 1879 · page 2
Iho Connecticut legislature met last week and elected Mr. Andrews governor, together with other republican state officers. The court of inquiry into the responsi bility of Major Reno for the Custer mas
The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · Wheeling, W. Va.
The Chicago-based military Court of Inquiry into Major Reno's actions at the Custer massacre resumed session, with Reno present in full uniform alongside his counsel. The Recorder was to present allegations first, followed by Reno's rebuttal testimony, with engineer Edwin Maguire testifying about the battlefield's topography.
The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · 15 January 1879 · page 1
The Beno Investigation. Chicago, January 14.?The military j Court of Inquiry into Major Reno's con1 duct at the Custer massacre resumed its j session this morning. Major Reno at)- i pearedin full uniform accompanied by his 1 counsel, Lyman D.Gilbert, of Harrisburg.
The military court of inquiry into Major Reno's conduct during the Custer massacre reconvened in Chicago. Testimony began with the recorder presenting the case first, followed by rebuttal witnesses, starting with engineer Edwin Maguire describing the battlefield topography.
The Cheyenne Daily Leader · 15 January 1879 · page 1
ILLINOIS. * y The Reno Court of Inquiry. * Chicago, Jan. 14. The military court of inquiry into Maj. Reno’s con duct at the Custer massacre, reanmed its session this morning. Maj. Reno appeared in full uniform, accompanied by Lyman D. Gilbert, his counsellor, of Harrisburg, Pa. It was decided that therecorder of the court should first bring his allega tions and present the case, to be fol lowed hy the accused with rebutting testimony. This is the reverse of the order which Maj. Reno desired should be observed. The first witness called was Edwin Maguire, of the engineering corps, whicli was on the ground the day suc ceeding the massacre. He simply gave a description of the topography of the scene.
At the Reno Court of Inquiry, Lieutenant George D. Wallace testified about the division of the Seventh Cavalry into three commands under Reno, Benteen, and Custer before the battle. He recounted Custer's order to Reno to charge the Indian village with promised support, and described Reno's advance along the Little Bighorn.
The New York Herald · 16 January 1879 · page 7
stenographer aud some corrections made. TESTIMONY Of LIEUTENANT WALLACE. The Eecordcr called the second witness, lieorge I). Wallace, who stated thut he was second lieutenant of G company. Seventh cavalry, under Reno's command, at the time of the Little Big Horn campaign, and was now first lieutenant commanding, llis testimony was quite explicit throughout and presented a nearly consecutive narrative of facts, so fur us they were known to bint. He acted with the detachment of Major Keuo. wlio wus second in command in the campaign. In reference to the division of the troops " on the duy of the beginning of the battle, the witness said that three companies were placed under the command of Major Keuo, three under Colonel Benteen, aud live were directed by General Caster; Major lteuo's force numbered from one hundred and ten to one hundred ami thirteen men: Bent eon's was
Lieutenant Wallace testifies before the Recorder about Reno's retreat and the battle, describing the crossing, the skirmish line, and the chaotic fighting with Indians emerging from ravines. He states no formal charge order was given, describes Reno's men running low on ammunition, and recounts the retreat across the river under Indian pressure.
The New York Herald · 16 January 1879 · page 7
ANSWERING THE RECORDER,
T. W. Ritchie, W. h, Dlodgatt mint Auoa ltarues j to be comnletelv surrounded and it seemed only a were ulscted directors. With. they had proceeded in a gallop after crossing the stream, and that was the only thing that could be interpreted as such an order; at thu point when-they engaged the Indians the redskins could he seen coming up out of a ratine In numbers, the witness believed that they were rrom two hundred to threo hundred, which force continued to increase as long * asthe tight lasted. It wa* Lieutenant Wallace's belief that the Indians had known the position, force and intention of Grnoral Custer's command ever since noon on tho'Ad of June, for at that time the scouts of both the whiti s and redskins discovered
Lieutenant George D. Wallace testified before the Reno Court of Inquiry about the disposition of Custer's Seventh Cavalry companies on June 25 and the marching and condition of Reno's exhausted troops. Reno's supporters argued the testimony showed he could not have heard the sounds of fighting from his position, countering claims he should have joined the battle sooner.
National Republican (Washington City) · 16 January 1879 · page 1
Testimony ltolallug to tliu Custer -Maixucro. Chicago, Jan, 15. It is claimed by the friends of Major Reno that yesterday's evi dence beforo the court of Inquiry was impor tant, in lliat It shows that Major Reno could not have heard tho nolo of the skirmishing
A witness describes the layout of the Indian village and the Army's approach, including Major Reno's dismounting of troops and the subsequent skirmish with hundreds of warriors. The testimony details the retreat decision, made when ammunition ran low and the troops faced encirclement without natural defenses.
National Republican (Washington City) · 16 January 1879 · page 1
lage. All the nmmitttltiou was gotio from their saddles beforo ho retreat was com menced. Tlio retreat was ordered becauso they wcro lu danger of being surrounded ou all sides by Indians, nud had no natural de fenses, Ho did not scalRcno until uftcr they crossed tlio creek 011 llifl retreat. IIu last saw Custer after ho gavo the) order to move.
Testimony before the Reno Court of Inquiry in Chicago addresses whether Major Reno could have heard the sounds of fighting from his position, with claims of cowardice and neglect of duty raised in a letter from Whittaker. Lieutenant George D. Wallace testified about the division of Custer's forces and described Reno's troops as exhausted from hard marching before being overwhelmed by Indians and forced to retreat.
New-York Tribune · 16 January 1879 · page 8
TRIAL OF MAJOR RIENO, Citieaco, Jan, 15.=Tt is claimed by the Major Reno that vesterday's evidence before Hits ut fri iu that 1t shows | the Conrt of Inguiry was nuportant, {hat Major keno could not have heard the noise of the skirmitehing from the position wineh he occupied when, as it will be attempted to prove by subsequent wit. peskcs, he should bave taken part in the fight, Tue allegations of Whittaker, 8x fa nomber, and summed up a8 gross cowardice and neglect of duty are before the Convt mn the form of a letter.
See moreSee less
Lieutenant Geo, DD. Wallace, Tth Cavalry, was tae Hirst wWiiness today, and was introduced by Recordor Lee. He detmled the methods of dividing General Custer’s force. He card thet Major Reno's forces, When they came upon the scene, were exhausted throagh swift marching, and when they met the Indians, sere over-ateged for the time aud compelled to retreat.
The report covers testimony from the Reno Court of Inquiry in Chicago, where Reno's supporters argued he could not have heard sounds of Custer's fight from his position. Lieutenant George D. Wallace testified that Reno's exhausted troops were overmatched by Indians and forced to retreat.
Evening Star · 16 January 1879 · page 1
Lbe friends of Major Reno that Tuesday's evidence before the court of inquiry, at Chicago, showed that Reno could not have heard the notee of skirmishing in Custer's tight from the position which he occupied, when, as it will be attempted to prove, he should have taken a
This report covers the third day of the Reno Court of Inquiry at the Palmer House, describing procedural details such as the change of room and the reading back of previous testimony. It notes the court proceeded despite Reno's brief absence, and mentions testimony concerning the condition of the troops and the possibility of rejoining Custer.
Chicago Daily Tribune · 16 January 1879 · page 9
Condition of tlio Troops—Possibility of Unjoining Custer* The Reno Court of Inquiry commenced their third day’s labor* at 11 o’clock yesterday morn ing nt the rslmerHouse, Mr. Palmer haring al lowed them to change their quarters from the
The passage records courtroom testimony from Lieutenant George D. Wallace at the Reno Court of Inquiry, describing troop positions and Custer's division of the Seventh Cavalry into companies under Reno, Benteen, and himself on June 25, 1876. It details the march toward the Little Bighorn, the discovery of a tepee with dead Indians, and the order relayed to Reno to charge the enemy.
Chicago Daily Tribune · 16 January 1879 · page 9
LIEUT. GEORGE D. WALLACE,
declared to be In order, and LICDT. OKOUOR D. WALLACE, First-Lieutenant In the Seventh Cavalry, was culled In and placed in thcwitness-cliatr. ‘After staling his full name and position, and that ba was at present on duty nt Fort Abraham Lin* coin, Dakota, he was asked by the Recorder where be was on the 25th day of June, 187(1. Witness replied (hat he was witli his regiment In the Valley of the Little Big Horn, near its mouth. Llcut.-Col. Custer was in command, and Reno was. the second ollicer. The troops were alt together at that time.
See moreSee less
It was at about a quarter past 12 o’clock on that day when Custer divided no his command, widen consisted of twelve companies of the Seventh Cavalry, giv ing three companies to Hum and three com* panics to Bcnioen, while one coniuuny was left to guard the pack-train, and Custer took command of the remaining five companies. Cupt. Hentvon was sent to the left, with instruc tions to feel about iu that direction for the enemy. Reno bad about 115 men, Including Indian scouts; Benteen’s force was somethinglarger, and Custer’s command numbered In the neigh borhood of 225. After Uentcen bad gone oft to (lie lull, Custer and Reno started down on each side of a little stream toward the uurth. After they hud gone several miles, moving In parallel lines with each other, they came across a tepee llilcd witli the dead bodies of Indians. At this point TUB ADJUTANT CAME FROM CUSTER TO RENO,
A witness testifying at the Reno Court of Inquiry recounts how Custer's adjutant brought orders to Reno to charge the Indian village, describing troop strength, exhaustion, and the terrain. He also estimates the village's size after later passing over it.
Chicago Daily Tribune · 16 January 1879 · page 9
At this point TUB ADJUTANT CAME FROM CUSTER TO RENO, ami told him that the Indians were about two miles air, and ordered Kcuo to charge upon thciu, and he Would bo supported. In answer to a question by Lieut. Lee, wit* ness staled that tiiu llttlu stream spoken of by him was u tributary to tho Little Dig Horn. The first the witness saw of Uuno In person afDTCustcr'sordcr had been given to charge was while lighting on the sklrtnldidlnc. Tho last order he had heard given was this one to charge on the Indiana.
See moreSee less
The two columns were still moving In porallel directions up to that time, with their respective officers tu command. Custer went oil to the north, on the right of the Little Ulg Horn, and was lost sight of.
At the Reno Court of Inquiry in Chicago, Lieutenant George Wallace testified that Custer ordered Reno to charge and promised support, and that Reno's retreat to the hilltop position was militarily necessary given the Indians' numbers and the troops' exhaustion. The court ruled that the inquiry would cover the entire battle from June 25-26, not just Reno's own movements.
Daily Globe · 16 January 1879 · page 1
CUSTER'S CAUSE. INQUIRY IN DEFENSE OF THE GALLANT DEAD.
I Special Telegram to the Globe. CHICAGO. Jan. 15.In the Beno inquiry to day, Lieut. George D. Wallace, Seventh cav alrj, at Fort A. Lincoln, D. T., was called to the witness stand. He testified he was in the company of Maj. Reno on the 25th of June, 1876 that Custer ordered Beno to charge npon the Indians that he heard no order to that ef fect given by Reno to his troop, except when the retreat was made after the fresh engage ment. In the opinion of the witness it was abso lutely necessary for Reno to change his po sition fiom the skirmish line as a matter of safety for his troops, for the Indians had so worked in to their rear that tbey were almost completely surrounded.
See moreSee less
The only advanta geous point where a stand could be made was on the crest of the hill across the Little Big Horn river, where Reno eventually took up his position. The witness states that he heard Custer tell Reno to charge the Inians and we will sup port you." In his opinion, as a soldier, Beno did the most advisable thing he could when he changed his position. Reno, he said, made an attempt to move out where it was supposed Custer was, but not being able to keep the wounded np with the column, it became neces sary to fall back to the original position on the hill and there remain. When they went into the fight Reno's men were worn out and the animals fatigued, having made forced marohes and both going without regular food nearly a day. When a?ked if he saw anything during that engagement to reflect upon the military char acter of Major Reno, the witness replied that he had told what he knew about it. During the examination to day, the question was raised by Reno whether the inquiry should cover anything more than ,the movements of his command, and the court decided that everything connected with that battle from the 25th to the 26th of June, should be taken into consideration.
The court of inquiry into Major Reno's conduct at Little Bighorn heard testimony from Lieutenant George D. Wallace detailing the division of Custer's forces and Reno's march toward the Indian village. Wallace described Reno's exhausted troops, the skirmish line formed near the river bend, and the scale of the Indian encampment.
Daily Globe · 16 January 1879 · page 1
1 Western Associated Press. CHICAGO, Jan. 15.It is elaimed by the friends of Major Reno that yesterday's evidence before the court of inquiry was important in that it shows that Major Reno could not have heard th 3 noise of the skirmishing from the position which he occupied, when, as it will be attempted to prove by subsequent witnesses, he should have taken a hand in the fight. The allegations of Whittaker, 6ix in number, and summed as being gross cowardice and neglect of duty, are before the court in the form of a letter.
See moreSee less
Lieut. George D. Wallace, of the Seventh cavalry, was the first witness and was intro duced by Recorder Lee. He detailed the method of dividing Gen. Custer's rorces. He said Gen. Reno's forces, when they came npon the scene, were exhausted with swift marching, and. when thjpy jnet the Indiana^ were over matched for the the time and compelled to re treat. Lieut. Wallace testified that Custer's com mand, on the 25th of June, at Little Big Horn, consisted of twelve companies of the Seventh regiment, and were so disposed as to march down the right bank of the river. At about noon Col. Benteen had four companies, Major Reno three and Gen. Custer the rest. After the division of forces, Major Reno crossed to the left bank and the two columns, Reno's and Custer's, moved down a tributary to the Little Big Horn about twelve miles, on opposite
A witness testifies before the court about the Indian village's size, the troop movements, and Reno's actions during the engagement, including the retreat after ammunition ran out. The testimony details the sequence of events from the approach to the village through the chaotic retreat across the creek.
Daily Globe · 16 January 1879 · page 1
until after he crossed the creek on the retreat. He last saw Custer after he gave the order to move. The court decided to take all the testimony relative to the engageme it that was offered. Adjourned. CRIMES AND CASUALTIES.
A telegram from Yankton, Dakota Territory reports that runners from Sitting Bull's camp near the US-Canada border say the hostile bands are willing to surrender to agency rule if guaranteed government protection. The runners claim British American traders have discouraged surrender, and that they would have come in with General Terry earlier if not for this interference.
Stevens County Tribune · 16 January 1879 · page 3
SITTING BULL. A Yankton, Dakota Territory telegram of Jan. 11th savs a special to the Press and Dakotian from Cheyenne river agency, on the Missouri river, says: Two runners have just arrived from Sitting Bull's camp and make the following report Their camp is on Little river, near the Uuited States boundary. Twenty-flve days ago they had the largest council ever Id by the hostiles, and decided to send out twelve runners—five to Standing Rock, two to Cheyenne, three to Spotted Tail, and vo to Red Cloud—as representatives of the hostile bands which belong to these agencies.
See moreSee less
They say we are willing to come surrender to agency rules, if we are guaranteed protection by the government The traders in Br tish America have used every measure te keep us there. If it had not been for them we would have come in with Gen. Terry. A council will be held by the agent.
Two runners from Sitting Bull's camp reported that a large council decided to send representatives to several agencies, offering to surrender horses and arms if guaranteed government protection. They blamed British American traders for discouraging earlier surrender with General Terry.
Helena Weekly Herald · 16 January 1879 · page 3
SITTING BUEE. He and His Hostile« Ready to Come in and Surrender If Guaranteed Protec tion. Yankton, January 11.—A special to the Press and Dakotian from Cheyenne river agency, on the Missouri river, says : Two runners from Sitting Bull's camp have just arrived and made the following report : Their camp is now on Little river, near the United States boundary. Twenty-five days ago they held the largest council ever held by the hos tiles, and decided to send out twelve runners, five to Standing Rock, two to Cheyenne, three to Spotted Tail and two to Red Cloud as rep resentatives of the hostile bands which be long to the agencies.
See moreSee less
They say: "We are willing to come in and surrender our horses and arms and submit to agency rales if we are guaranteed protection by the Government. The traders in British America have used every measure to keep us there. If it had not been for them we would have come in with Gen. Terry." A council will be held here to-morrow by the agent. Suicide.
The Military Court of Inquiry into Major Reno's responsibility for the Custer massacre convened in Chicago, with reporters barred from taking notes. The court decided the recorder would present allegations first, followed by Reno's rebuttal, and heard initial testimony describing the battlefield topography.
Helena Weekly Herald · 16 January 1879 · page 3
The Reno Court Martial. New York, January 13.—The Military Court of Inquiry into the responsibility of Major Reno for the Custer massacre, con vened here to-day with open doors, but re porters were not allowed to take notes of the proceedings. The only important action of the first session was a decision to summon Whittaker, who made the charges against Reno.
A military court of inquiry has assembled in Chicago to investigate charges against Major Reno concerning his conduct at the Battle of the Little Big Horn and the Custer massacre. The inquiry is reported as currently underway.
The Kenosha Telegraph · 16 January 1879 · page 2
there from Sitting Bull’s camp, with a message to the effect that S. B. and all the hostile Chey ennes w’ere anxious to come back and submit to the rules of the agency if they were assured of the protection of the Government The military court appointed to in vestigate the charges against Maj. Reno, in connection with the battle of the Little Big Horn and the Custer massacre, assembled in
The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · Wheeling, W. Va.
A Chicago dispatch reports on testimony given at the Reno Court of Inquiry, where Lieut. G.D. Wallace detailed how Custer divided his forces into columns under himself, Reno, and Benteen before the battle. The testimony described the march, the size and shape of the Indian village, and Reno's initial advance toward the enemy before his forces encountered overwhelming numbers.
The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · 16 January 1879 · page 1
THE RENO COURT MARTIAL
they were over matched for the time and 1 1 Itai-' that Ouster's v command, on the 25th, at Little Big Horn, d consisted of twelvo companies of the 7th regiment, and weje. so disposed as to 'march' do\yri tho ri?ht bank of the river at ~abo'ut noon. Col. Benton had c four rnmnnniw Momr ---- J"' "VUU IIIITO JIIIU 1
The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · Wheeling, W. Va.
A witness testifies at the Reno Court of Inquiry about the size of the Indian village, troop movements, and Reno's retreat across the creek during the Battle of Little Bighorn. The testimony recounts dismounting, skirmishing, and the chaotic retreat as soldiers ran low on ammunition.
The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · 16 January 1879 · page 1
they began the retreat from the village, s All the ammunitiou was gone from their \ saddles before the retreat began. The re- \ treat-wa?r0rderadt,J)pca^a0;thoy wero in I daiitet of being ;aum>unded by the Indian*1 with out natural defenses. Tie did not see Keno till after ho had crossed the creek in the retreat. He last saw Custer ? after he gave the order to move. , ' The Court dbclded to take all the testi- , mony relative to tho engagement that was , offered. Adjourned. - . 1
An officer from Major Reno's detachment gave testimony in the ongoing inquiry into his conduct during the Custer massacre. The report notes the testimony seemed to reflect poorly on Reno, though judgment should be suspended.
The Cheyenne Daily Leader · 16 January 1879 · page 1
dians by the troops at Fort Robinson. ; Perhaps the inquiry had better be exj tended into ascertaining the massacre ‘ of troops by the Indians since they took j to the bluff*. Soke important testimony in the j Reno inquiry was given by an officer in | the major’s detachment at the time of ( the Custer massacre. To a civilian it looks as if it added but little to Reno’s lustre. But we must suspend judg ment. The Germans seem to claim Bayard Taylor a* their own. On the arrival of the remains of the late poet at New York, the German societies will receive them with moat distinguished honor.
See moreSee less
Tiie body will also lie in state in the governor's room at the city ball. The Russo-Turkish treaty will be finally ratified to day. Russia accepts a reductiou in the indemnity claims of one hundred million roubles, and
The report describes testimony from Lieutenant George D. Wallace before the Court of Inquiry investigating Major Reno's conduct at Little Bighorn. He detailed the division of Custer's forces, the exhausted state of Reno's troops, and the retreat in the face of superior Indian numbers.
The Cheyenne Daily Leader · 16 January 1879 · page 1
ILLINOIS. Evidence as to Gen. Reno. Chicago, Jan. 15.—1 t Is claimed by the friends of MhJ. Reno that yester day’s evidence before tiie 'Court of in quiry was important in that it shows tliut Maj. Reno could not have heard the noise of the skirmishing from the position which lie occupied when (as it will be attempted to prove by subse quent witnesses) he should have taken a.hand in tiie fight. The allegations of Whittaker, six in number, and summed up as being gross cowardice and neglect of duty, are be fore the court in the form of a letter.
See moreSee less
Lient. Geo. D. Wallace, of tiie Sev enth cavalry, was the first witness to day, and was introduced by Recorder Lee. He detailed the method of divid ing Gen. Custer’s force. He said Gen. Reno’s forces, when they came upon the scene, were exhausted through swift marching, and wheu they met tiie Indians, were overmatched for the time and compelled to retreat. Lieut. Wallace testified that Custer’s commund, on the 25th of June, at Lit tle Big Horn, consisted of 12 companies of tiie Seventh regiment, aud were so di*iK)sed as to march down the right bank of tiie river at about noon. Col. Beuteen had four companies, Maj. Reno three, and Gen. Custer tiie rest. After the division of the forces Maj. Reno crossed to the left bank, and the two columns—Reno’* and Custer’*—moved
A witness describes the size of the Indian village, the skirmishing as troops approached, and Reno's actions before the retreat across the creek. The testimony notes ammunition was exhausted and the retreat was ordered due to fear of encirclement.
The Cheyenne Daily Leader · 16 January 1879 · page 1
danger of being surrounded on all side* | by the Indians, without any natural de fenses. He did not see Reno until after he crossed the creek on the retreat. He last saw Custer after he gave the order to move. Tiie court decided to take all the tes timony relative to the engagement that was offered. Adjourned.
Testimony before the Reno Court of Inquiry details Reno's conduct during the battle, including troop positions, Indian numbers, and the discovery of Custer's fate on the 27th. The Court also announces it will not investigate Benteen's conduct in connection with the matter.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
Daily Los Angeles Herald · 17 January 1879 · page 2
Sacramento, Jan. 16th.—Swing introduced a resolution, tbe pream ble of which recites the absence of Secretary Johnson without leave to visit the National Capital. The resolution dsclares his place vacant and appoints George A. Thornton Secretary for the remainder of the session. The resolution, on motion of MeCallum, was made tho special or der for uext Monday at 2 o'clock, so that iv the meantime Johnson may resign or explain. other. The Convention went into Com mittee of the Whole on city and county organizations. Section four was adopted without amendment.
See moreSee less
It provides that the Legislature shall establish a system of couuty governments which shall be uniform throughout the State and allow township organi zations thereunder. Section five was adopted without amendment. It provides for the election or appointment under gen eral laws of Supervisors, Sheriff,, Clerks, Distrist Attorneys and such other officers as the public convenience m*y require. Section six requires that the Leg islature shall pass a general law providing for the incorporation and classification, in proportion to pop ulation, of cities und towns. Adapted. aisction seven was parsed over and section eight stricken out. Section nine, relating to cities having a population of more than one hundred thousand, was passed temporarily and sections ten and eleven ware adopted. Stuart offered an amendment to section 12 requiring the Legislature to provide by law for the inspection of all distilisd liquors, wines and beer in order to prevent their adul teration, which was rejected. Section 12 was adopted. It gives a city or county power to enforce within its limits local police aud trail. sanitary regulations. Section 13 was read. The com mittee then rose and the Conven tion adjourned. miles north of here, on the old Deadwood stage road. It is report ed that the Cheyeunes were seen last nlgbt, six miles from Bluff station, on tho Cheyenne aud Deadwood stage road, about thirty miles northwest of Red Cloud. They are evidently making for tbe station to secure the hand of horses there b9louging to tho stage com pany. Tlie n.-ti«> tomtol luqn ry. Chicago, Jan. 16th.—Tho Reno Court of Inquiry to day decided that tho reporters' might take notes. Wallace was cross-examined by Major Ratio's counsel, Mr. Gilbert. The testimony was only a develop mout of tiiatgiven yesterday. He related how, after the division of Custer's cemniand, Col. Ronton weut to tho lefc, Major Reno cross ed tho stream and General Custer remained ou the right bauk; how thu two latter detachments tanned a j unci ion by Reno recrossing about 12 m les below, and how, tiually, the battle was fought. Some of Major Reno's command hid never ridden a horse until this campaign. The only ammunition in the hands ot Reno's force were the supplies at their saddles, and it was used up in half au hour. In his opinion it was a wise net of Major Reno to retreat, as to have remained would have been to Imperil tho lives of the whole body. Major Reuo's con duct was brave and praiseworthy, as, during the retreat, twenty-live men were killed and seven wound ed, and the time consumed was about an hour. Arrived on the top of the hill Benton's force camu up, but the pack train was three miles to tlie rear. Reno showed no signs of fear all this time, but was con spicuously bravo and fearless. No communication had bssn re ceived from Custer, but a trum peter stateil that he had gone back. The amiuunication was distributed and Company D fir.i met the In dians several thousand strong iv a ravine, where the men were properly posted by Reno. He had about two Hundred and eighty men under his command at that time. BUlle)S oame like hall until dark, about three hours, when for tifications were thrown up. Firing recommenced about 3 A. M. ou the 24th and continued until 10 o'clock, wheti it Blackened. There wero probably nine thousand Indian warriors iv the village that eve ning, it being two and a half or threo miles long. They first knew of Custer's fate on the 27th. They discovered the lino of battle per fectly evident from the dead horses and norpies. The position was not well chosen for defence. Around ouster was a file of msu. There had apparently been an attempt at es cape. The fight probably did not la«t over half an hour. Custer had 350 men when he separated from Reno. The Court decided this afternoon that il will not investigate the con duct of Beaton, whoso name has been associated with Reno in this matter. Adjourned. Tile Teller I-. vts c Xli >11 on. New Orleans, Jan. 16th—Be fore the Teller Committee A. J. Bryant, colored, Senator of Texsas, testified that no Republican ticket was nominated because of the throats of tho whites, who said they would consider such action a declaration of war. The uight be fore election a party of whites, in cluding Buokner and Hausboro, came to my iiouse, took me out in my night clothes, can e-d me a quarter of a mile and threatened me, saying I had sold out to the Bland party. I denied this and stated that I had not seeu any of tlie leaders of the Bland party. They let me go after promising that I wouldcome to tbe polls next day and vote the regular Democratic ticket. I complied with my promise. The party had a rope with them and said if they were satisfied I had sold out to the Bland party they would put me through. Qreitt 3,'>■!-. of NCoelt reirr<f — Legis lative Dcadlnak. Silver City, Idaho, Jan. 16th.— The heavy snow storms and unpre cedented cold weather create con siderable alarm among stock men, who have reason to fear that a large number of cattle will perish before milder weather sets in. There is much indignation among the people in consequence of tbe existing dead-lock iv tlie Idaho Legislature, occurriug in conse quence nf the parties Using so evenly divided. Tho feeliug is general that the members should go to work and strive to do some thing for the Territory, instead of frittering away the time In party squabbles, in which notbingof any consequence is to bs gained. Rlclmrds Heiltcuc.d to be It-«uirtd. Kearney, Neb., Jan. 10th.—The trial of 93. D. Riohards, the self confessed murderer of several per sons, was held at Miune yesterday. There were Indictment* against him for tlis murder of four persons. The obarge ou which he was tried was the murder of Peter Andersou, on December oth last. He pleaded notguily. Tlie jury received the ca«e in tlis afternoon, and returned a verdict of guilty, after two hours deliberation. Thereupon Judge Gaslin immediately pronounced sentence that he be hanged April 20th, just tbe one hnudred and oue days allowed by law. The prisoner was apparently the happiest man In the court room. Lynching is feared. European Cable News. fl tllrwHil Aoelili'UC lv Rn»*lii London, Jan. 10.—A St. Peters burg letter, dated January Hth, •aya a collisioa occurred ou the Warsaw Railway,thirty miles from St. Petersburg, 011 tbe 10th lust., by wbioh twenty persona were killed and tblrty-tWO injure:!, twenty-one daugerously. Crisis Immlueu* lv Frauutt. Pauis, Jan. 10.—In the Chamber of Deputies M. Uufaure yielded and assented to tho appointment uf Glen. Gresaeley. All peisona ac quainted with tho relatione between President MauMahon and General Gresseley are aware that the ap pointment la equivalent to a refusal to allow the Chambers to have proper constitutional control over tho office. Aa long aa Gen. Grease le;' is in office there will be no re form* aud no changes in the great military commands. Tlie Marshal claims that he holds control over the administration of the army, which tbe Chambers claim for themaelves and which they are de termined to have. Another Paris correspondent regards tbe situa tion as very critical. The over throw of the Cabinet, he says, miles north of here, on the old Deadwood stage road. It is report ed that the Cheyeunes were seen last nlgbt, six miles from Bluff station, on tho Cheyenne aud Deadwood stage road, about thirty miles northwest of Red Cloud. They are evidently making for tbe station to secure the hand of horses there b9louging to tho stage com pany. Tlie n.-ti«> tomtol luqn ry. Chicago, Jan. 16th.—Tho Reno Court of Inquiry to day decided that tho reporters' might take notes. Wallace was cross-examined by Major Ratio's counsel, Mr. Gilbert. The testimony was only a develop mout of tiiatgiven yesterday. He related how, after the division of Custer's cemniand, Col. Ronton Admirals. weut to tho lefc, Major Reno cross ed tho stream and General Custer remained ou the right bauk; how thu two latter detachments tanned a j unci ion by Reno recrossing about 12 m les below, and how, tiually, the battle was fought. Some of Major Reno's command hid never ridden a horse until this campaign. The only ammunition in the hands ot Reno's force were the supplies at their saddles, and it was used up in half au hour. In his opinion it was a wise net of Major Reno to retreat, as to have remained would have been to Imperil tho lives of the whole body. Major Reuo's con clemency. duct was brave and praiseworthy, as, during the retreat, twenty-live men were killed and seven wound ed, and the time consumed was about an hour. Arrived on the top of the hill Benton's force camu up, but the pack train was three miles to tlie rear. Reno showed no signs of fear all this time, but was con spicuously bravo and fearless. No communication had bssn re ceived from Custer, but a trum peter stateil that he had gone back. The amiuunication was distributed and Company D fir.i met the In dians several thousand strong iv a ravine, where the men were properly posted by Reno. He had about two Hundred and eighty men under his command at that time. BUlle)S oame like hall until dark, about three hours, when for tifications were thrown up. Firing recommenced about 3 A. M. ou the 24th and continued until 10 o'clock, wheti it Blackened. There wero probably nine thousand Indian warriors iv the village that eve ning, it being two and a half or threo miles long. They first knew of Custer's fate on the 27th. They discovered the lino of battle per fectly evident from the dead horses and norpies. The position was not well chosen for defence. Around ouster was a file of msu. There had apparently been an attempt at es cape. The fight probably did not la«t over half an hour. Custer had 350 men when he separated from Reno. The Court decided this afternoon that il will not investigate the con duct of Beaton, whoso name has been associated with Reno in this matter. Adjourned. Tile Teller I-. vts c Xli >11 on. New Orleans, Jan. 16th—Be fore the Teller Committee A. J. Bryant, colored, Senator of Texsas, ploy them. testified that no Republican ticket was nominated because of the throats of tho whites, who said they would consider such action a declaration of war. The uight be fore election a party of whites, in cluding Buokner and Hausboro, Court. came to my iiouse, took me out in my night clothes, can e-d me a quarter of a mile and threatened me, saying I had sold out to the Bland party. I denied this and stated that I had not seeu any of tlie leaders of the Bland party. They let me go after promising that I wouldcome to tbe polls next day and vote the regular Democratic ticket. I complied with my promise. The party had a rope with them and said if they were satisfied I had sold out to the Bland party they would put me through. Qreitt 3,'>■!-. of NCoelt reirr<f — Legis lative Dcadlnak. Silver City, Idaho, Jan. 16th.— wit: The heavy snow storms and unpre cedented cold weather create con siderable alarm among stock men, who have reason to fear that a lows, to wit: large number of cattle will perish before milder weather sets in. There is much indignation among the people in consequence of tbe existing dead-lock iv tlie Idaho Legislature, occurriug in conse quence nf the parties Using so evenly divided. Tho feeliug is general that the members should go to work and strive to do some thing for the Territory, instead of frittering away the time In party squabbles, in which notbingof any consequence is to bs gained. Rlclmrds Heiltcuc.d to be It-«uirtd. Kearney, Neb., Jan. 10th.—The trial of 93. D. Riohards, the self confessed murderer of several per sons, was held at Miune yesterday. There were Indictment* against him for tlis murder of four persons. The obarge ou which he was tried was the murder of Peter Andersou, on December oth last. He pleaded notguily. Tlie jury received the ca«e in tlis afternoon, and returned a verdict of guilty, after two hours deliberation. Thereupon Judge Gaslin immediately pronounced sentence that he be hanged April 20th, just tbe one hnudred and oue days allowed by law. The prisoner was apparently the happiest man In the court room. Lynching is feared. European Cable News. fl tllrwHil Aoelili'UC lv Rn»*lii London, Jan. 10.—A St. Peters burg letter, dated January Hth, •aya a collisioa occurred ou the Warsaw Railway,thirty miles from St. Petersburg, 011 tbe 10th lust., by wbioh twenty persona were killed and tblrty-tWO injure:!, twenty-one daugerously. Crisis Immlueu* lv Frauutt. Pauis, Jan. 10.—In the Chamber of Deputies M. Uufaure yielded and assented to tho appointment uf Glen. Gresaeley. All peisona ac quainted with tho relatione between President MauMahon and General Gresseley are aware that the ap pointment la equivalent to a refusal to allow the Chambers to have proper constitutional control over tho office. Aa long aa Gen. Grease le;' is in office there will be no re form* aud no changes in the great military commands. Tlie Marshal claims that he holds control over all times. the administration of the army, which tbe Chambers claim for themaelves and which they are de termined to have. Another Paris correspondent regards tbe situa city or county, tion as very critical. The over throw of the Cabinet, he says,
The report describes press access being granted to take notes during the Reno Court of Inquiry after earlier inaccurate accounts were published. Lieutenant Wallace's cross-examination details troop movements, Custer and Reno's division of companies, weapons carried, and conditions during the battle.
The New York Herald · 17 January 1879 · page 3
ANUARY 17, 1879.?TRIPLE tercet and were the basis of opinion, he thought it would ho advisable if the Court would afford the representatives of the press greater facilities for procuring an accurate reoort. Colonel King took the matter uuder consideration aud then said:?During the rest of the proceedings the reporters will be allowed to take notes. Immediately after this order was given the notebooks saw tlio light of day, and the cruss-exaiuinatiou of Lieutenant Wallace, who testified yesterday, was begun. Lieutenant Wallace said in substance tbat when tho division of tbo command was made Colonel llontoon took 1), II and K companies and moved off to tho left.
See moreSee less
Disappearing over a hill, he did not see him again until after Rcno'a retreat. Reno took A, <i and M companies, numbering about 11U to 113 men, and moved forward, at the order of Custer, to charge tho Indians, being the understanding, at least of the witness, that ho (Custer) would support him (ICeiio). He knew of no arrangement for the reuniting of the commands. Custer had C, F, I and L companies, numbering about 225 men. He moved down the right of the river, and Reno having crossed over moved down the left, witness rode to tho left of Reno, Lieutenant Uodgeson, who was killed, being between them. If there had been any orders to Reno from Custer other than to move
At the Reno Court of Inquiry, Lieutenant Wallace described the deployment and retreat of the skirmish line and defended Major Reno's decisions during the battle, stating he saw no cowardice and believed retreat was necessary to save the men. He also described finding Custer's body among about thirty others, with no signs of a prolonged struggle except near Captain Calhoun's position.
The New York Herald · 17 January 1879 · page 3
THE SKIRMISH LINE.
Major Iteuo gave the required orders. The body of General Custer was found with several men about mill, unit LI'ULII 111 1 Hill, I111U11J U. IO <Jl thirty bodies. There were uo indications uf a prolonged struggle. He did not think that General Custer had time to make an effective Htand; nor wan the ground adapted to it. He did not believe the struggle lia 1 continued more
Lieutenant Wallace testifies at the Reno Court of Inquiry about the fighting, water shortages, and conditions during the siege on the bluffs, and describes learning of Custer's death from General Terry on the 27th. The report also includes a reader's letter urging Congress to investigate the conduct of officers in the Little Bighorn disaster.
The New York Herald · 17 January 1879 · page 3
THE BATTLE OF THE LITTLE BIG HORN - REASONS WHY CONGRESS SHOULD INVESTIGATE THE CONDUCT OF THE ACTORS IN IT
position ne asked General Terry whero Custer was. He was told that the General and his men wero killed. This was the first intimation Lieutenant Wallace had received of General Custer's fate. It had been the opinion of the men with Major Reno that General Custer hail been dofoatcd and had retreated to meet General Terry and left them (Reno's men) to their fate. The cross-examination of the witness closed with the following question:? Mr. GtllMTt?.Search your memory thmngh and recall what you deem a cowardly action on tho part of Major Reno.
The piece discusses the Cheyenne escape from Fort Robinson, arguing they fled due to starvation and mistreatment, a grievance seemingly validated by General Sheridan's order to supply Comanches with beef rations. It calls for a reconstruction of US Indian policy, citing the Modoc war, Nez Perce war, the Custer massacre, and the Fort Robinson incident as evidence of systemic failure.
The New York Herald · 17 January 1879 · page 6
no more important subject which can engage tho attention of Congress. It evinces a lamentable lack of foresight that this great subject has been neglected while so many things have been occurring within the last lew years fitted to arouse indignation and disgust. The Modoc war, the Nez Perces war, the horrible Custer massacre, and now this bloody work at Fort Robinson are startling reminders, and the time has come when they must not longer be neglected. What are tho requisites of a truo Indian policy has become a question of the first magnitude and of the greatest I urgency. Tlie Herald is disposed to do its
The piece calls for Congress and military authorities to fully investigate the Battle of the Little Big Horn, noting that allegations made in 1876 were never challenged by participants. It argues the Reno court of inquiry alone is insufficient and a complete examination is needed to clear up the mystery and vindicate or condemn the officers involved.
The New York Herald · 17 January 1879 · page 6
of Congress. In September, 1876, the ILiuld correspondent in the Indiun Territory called attention to the unreliability of the official account of the Battle of the Little Big Horn, in which Custer lost his life, and made public in our columns a number of alleged facts of the most grave and serious nature, at the same time calling upon the government to investigate that sad event.
The editorial argues that a full and searching investigation into the Battle of the Little Big Horn is needed to satisfy public doubts about whether Custer's subordinates did their duty to aid him. It references testimony from the Chicago Court of Inquiry suggesting efforts to rescue Custer may have been inadequate, and urges the War Department or Congress to broaden the inquiry's scope.
The New York Herald · 17 January 1879 · page 6
the facts to light and satisfy the public conscience that every effort was made by Custer's subordinates to aid their chief in the hour of his need. The present impression is that such efforts were not made, and the evidence given by Lieutennnt Magnire before the Chicago Court of Inquiry tends to strengthen the belief that all was not done which might have been done to rescue Custer from the hands of his savage foes. As the Cliicugo court is only one of inquiry,
This report covers the Reno Court of Inquiry, noting a dispute over reporters' access to proceedings that was resolved to allow note-taking. It then details Lt. Wallace's testimony describing how Custer's regiment was divided into battalions under Reno, Benteen, and Custer, and their initial movements before the battle.
Chicago Daily Tribune · 17 January 1879 · page 6
plied, and every facility given. MBUT. WALLACE was first asked when hts regiment was broken Into battalions, to which ho replied that it was shortly after 13 o’clock, June 25. Before that it had moved as one battalion under tho com mand of Qcn. Custer, Reno acting os second in command, but having no spcclllc command. 'Witness heard MaJ. Reno say, the day ho left, that he was directed to perform the duties of Lieutenant-Colonel. One of tho newly-formed battalions was placed under the command of Reno, another under Benlcon.and another un der Custer.
See moreSee less
Tho first bad Companies A, G, and M, tho second, D, K, and 11, and Custer C, E, F, I, and L. Reno's men did not exceed 110 or 115, including scouts. Custer had about 225, and Dcntccn’s force, os witness could esti mate It, was a little larger thaa Custer's. With respect to the little tributary, the command at the tlmo It was broken up Into battalions was on tho western side or slope, Just before the little ravine commenced running In which formed the creek. It hadn't reached the creek, but was on that side of tho divide. Witness did not hear tho orders given to Ben icu» at the time tho division wasmade, but km||r that Bcutccn moved his battalion off to
A witness describes how Custer's and Reno's battalions moved in parallel columns after Benteen's command separated and disappeared from view. The testimony details Adjutant Cook's order relaying that Custer would support Reno's attack on the Indian village.
Chicago Daily Tribune · 17 January 1879 · page 6
AFTER BENTEEN DISAPPEARED
different battalions at unr given point. ArTEK lIBKTBBN PISAI’I’RAIIRO with ins three companies, Iteno ami Custer moved down the little stream, Reno on the left and Custer on the rlijht, from nine to twelve mites, neoo was called across with his three companies to the same point on which Custer was raovlntf,—thu right bank',—anil tho two battalions moved along In parallel columns for some distance. In colling blm across, Custer motioned him over, and, witness thought, an order came afterwards. Jlo did not remember that Custer’s command halted while Reno was crossing the creek.
See moreSee less
After crossing, tbo heads of tho two columns came together. Witness saw no communication between Custer and Reno at that time. They continued moving In parallel columns, both commands being on the right side of the creek, for nearly n mile. Witness rode at that time to the loft of Uono’s Adjutant, Hodgson, who was also at Reno's left. Alter moving along about u mile. Lieut. Cook, Adjutant of tin* regiment, came from Custer to Reno and said to him: “ Thu Indians are about two miles and a half
A witness at the Reno Court of Inquiry describes the cavalry's crossing of the Little Bighorn River and subsequent reorganization into formation. He details company commanders and armaments, but states he has no knowledge of whether messages were sent to Custer or if soldiers McIlargy and Mitchell were killed.
Chicago Daily Tribune · 17 January 1879 · page 6
lilt heeamoto tho crossing of tho Little Rig Horn, vrhoro they had to wait, the horses scut* tcrlug before thuv eouid he mudu to cross On lusting through and reaching the other aide, they hailed, closed up the column, ond funned a line. A Ikklv of i-uvaJr advancing towards u slieamot vapid gait was always throwu Into some little disorder, and remilred sonio lltilo reorgauliatlun. In fact, ho nan never known this to fail. Such disorder was no cvluencu of diiit|UiiUlleallun on the purl of a commanding otllcer, Inasmuch us it always occurred in spite of wiiatever pi ecautton one*might take, lie did nut know whether Reuu, at tho time of the halt, sunt buck any message to Custer, lie knew tho man Mcltlargy, und had heard of Mitchell,
The report describes Northern Cheyenne prisoners, resisting removal to Indian Territory, breaking out of confinement at Fort Robinson after chiefs Wild Hog and Old Crow were placed in irons. It claims between thirty and forty Indians were killed by pursuing soldiers, including leader Dull Knife, who was reportedly shot through the head.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
Fulton Journal · 17 January 1879 · page 2
the two leading chiefs, Old Crow and Wild Hog, in irons, and separate them from the common Indians. In carrying out this step there was a furious struggle be tween Wild Hog and the guards, in which one of the latter was dangerously stabbed. This affair caused the wildest excitement among the savages. Some of them commenced chanting a war song, and, at a given signal, the entire body made a dash through their prison windows, and, fir ing on the guard with revolvers which they had succeeded in concealing, all ran for the open prairie. The guard opened fire on the fleeing savages, shooting them down by dozens in the frozen snow, presenting a scene that discounts the Custer massacre. The cav
Springfield Weekly Republican · Springfield, Mass.
A military court of inquiry into Major Reno's conduct during the Custer massacre convened in Chicago this week, with open doors but no note-taking allowed by reporters. Whittaker, who brought the charges against Reno, is to be summoned to testify.
Springfield Weekly Republican · 17 January 1879 · page 1
The military court to inquire into the respon sibility of Maj Reno for the Custer massacre convened at Chicago this week, with open doors, but reporters were not allowed to take notes of the proceedings. Whittaker, who made the
A military court of inquiry convened in Chicago to investigate charges against Major Reno related to his actions during the battle of the Little Big Horn and the Custer massacre. The court is reported to be actively prosecuting the inquiry.
The True Northerner · 17 January 1879 · page 2
there from Sittiug Bull's camp, with a message to the effect that K B. and all tho hostile Chey enncs were anxious to come back and submit to the rules of the agency if they were assured of tho protection of the Government Tho military court appointed to in vestigate the charges against Maj. Ilono, in connection with the battle of tho Little Big Horn and the Custer massacre, assembled iu
At the Reno Court of Inquiry in Chicago, Lieut. George Wallace was cross-examined and gave a detailed account of the battle, testifying that Major Reno's retreat from the valley was the only way to save his command and that Reno showed bravery, not fear. He also described troop movements, casualties, and estimated a very large number of Indian warriors engaged.
Daily Globe · 17 January 1879 · page 1
upon his experience and knowledge asasoldier, Major Reno did the best thing that could have been done in letreatmg before the savages To have lemained there longer in the woods where his skirmish line rested would have been to court death for the entire three companies, rot a man could have got out alive had they remained there longer Neither theie nor later, when they had entrenched themselves on the hill did the witness see any signs of weakness or fear on the part of Major Reno. On the contrary, he displayed tJRAO AVD FORTITUDE.
See moreSee less
The command of Reno officers and men, ex pected Custer would support it, and there was a good deal oE feeling imfested ovei what was supposed to his direction of the commands of Reu and Benreen. It is thought th it he might have engaged the Indians, been re pulsed, and then instead of retreating as he should have pushed forward to join lent. The witness described the battle ground and the positions of Custer's men very minutely He heard no firing from the direction of Cus ter Witne th ugh there must have been 9 000 Indians engaged in the fight. [Western Associated Pi ess. CHICAGO Jan. 16.The Reno court of inquiry to day decided thai reporters might take notes Lieut Wallace was cross-examined by Major Reno's counsel, Mr. Gilbert. The testimony was only a development of that of yesterday. He lelated how atu the division oi Custei's emimind Col Benteen went to tfie left of Majoi Reno crossed tje stream, and Gen Cos tei remained on the ght bank, how the two lattei detai hments rme a jnn turn by Reno recrossing about twelve miles below, and how finally the battle was fought S of Major Rf no com nand hdd never ridden a horse till this campaign The only ammunition in the hands ot Reno's force was t^e supplies at their saddles It was used up in half an hour. In his opinion it wis a wise act of Major Reno to retirat and to have remained would nave been to imperil the lives of the whole body. Major Reno's conduct was
A witness cross-examined by Reno's counsel described the separation of Custer's command from Reno and Benteen, the retreat under fire, and the subsequent defense on the bluffs. The witness judged Reno's retreat a wise decision and called his conduct brave and praiseworthy, while noting the defensive position was poorly chosen and Custer's men were apparently overwhelmed.
Daily Globe · 17 January 1879 · page 1
BRAVE AJ.D PRAISEWORTHY. During the retreat twenty five men were killed and seven wounded, and the time con sumed about an hour. Arrived on top of the hill Benteen force came up, but the pack tram was thiee miles to the rear Rtnoshowed no signs of fcr all the time but was conspicu ously brave and fearless No communication had been received ftom Custer, bnt a trumpet er stated he had gone back The ammunition wis distributed, and Company hist met the Indians several thousand strong in a ravine of fine advan tigt a, where the men were properly posted by R"no. He had about 280 men under his command at the tini".
A military Court of Inquiry examining Major Reno's conduct and responsibility in the Custer massacre convened in Chicago on the 13th. The inquiry was formed to investigate accusations against Reno stemming from the Little Bighorn battle.
Perrysburg Journal · 17 January 1879 · page 1
Master, living at Murfreesboro, and D. C. Howell, of Chattanooga. They had already wrongfully collected $4,000, and were schem ing to swindle the Chicago Benevolent Society and the United Brotherhood of Pennsylvania out of $7,000. More developments are prom ised. The hostiles with Sitting Bull, now in the British Possessions, near the American line. held a council a short time ago, and decided to send runners to Standing Rock, Cheyenne. Spotted Tail and Red Cloud agencies to learn if arrangements can be made for their return to this country. They say that they are will ing to surrender their arms and horses, and submit to the agency rules, if they are guaran teed protection by the Government.
See moreSee less
Judge McConnell, of Nashville, Tenn., hav ing persisted in trying revenue officers in Ma con County, for alleged illegal arrest, has been ordered, by Judge Baxter, to appear be
A military tribunal in Chicago is investigating Major Reno's conduct at the Little Bighorn, where Custer's command was massacred. The inquiry aims to determine whether Reno's failure to support Custer stemmed from cowardice, misunderstanding, or inability to break through enemy forces.
Daily Press and Dakotaian · 17 January 1879 · page 2
Custer hud. just previous to his fatal charge directed Reno to a supporting position from whiih it might be supposed he cou reacb the rear of the Indian village on the opposite side of the river from Custei's por tion of the command Reno fell back bef'oie the enemy and crossed to the Custer sideol tiie river, where be remained, within sup porting disttnee, and failed to render any uid towards extricating Custer from the trap into which be bad fallen The investigation is made to ascertain wb tiler Reno's tailure to co-nper.te was the result of cowardice, or a misundersUnd lag, or whether be was unable to force bis way t) the relief of his superior officer.
See moreSee less
A large amount of testimony is being taken The presumption is that Reno can sustaiu himself, else he would not bave com ted an investigation wbicb would otherwise end in disgrace.
Lieutenant Wallace describes the Seventh Cavalry's movements on June 25 at Little Big Horn, detailing the division of forces among Custer, Reno, and Benteen, and Reno's charge toward the Indian village. He recounts the engagement, the exhaustion of the troops, the size of the Indian force, and the eventual retreat after ammunition ran low.
Daily Press and Dakotaian · 17 January 1879 · page 3
Tntliniiiiy of Llrutrnnnt Wallncr, of tli« Mrventli Cavalry. Chicago, Jan. 10.—Lieut. Wallace lehti fied that Cu«ler'n command on the 25ih of June, at Little liig Horn,conniHted of twelve companiea of the Seventh regiment, and were HO disposed as to inarcli down the right bank of the river at about noon. Col. Ben teen had four companiex, Maj. Reno tl ree, and Gen. Custer the rent. Alter the divis
Witness testimony before the court of inquiry recounts Major Reno's retreat, the defense on the hill, and the discovery of Custer's fate on the 27th. The witness describes troop numbers, Indian village size, ammunition shortages, and judges Reno's conduct as brave and his retreat a wise decision.
Memphis Daily Appeal · 17 January 1879 · page 1
Major Reno's command had never ridden a horse until this campaign; the only ammuni tion in the hands of Reno's force was the supply at their saddles; it was used up in half an hour; in his opinion, it was a wise act of Major Reno to retreat, aud to have re mained would have been to imperil the lives of the whole body; Major Reno s conduct was brave and praiseworthy; during the retreat twenty-five men were killed and seven wounded, and the time consumed was about an hour; arrived on top of the hill, Benticn's force came up, but the pack train was three miles to tho rear; R?no showed no signs of fear at this time, but was conspicuously brave and fearless; no communication had been re ceived from Custer, but a trumpeter stated that he had gone back; the ammunition wai distributed, and company D first met the Indians, several thonsand strong, in a ravine of tine advantage, where the men were properly posted by Reno; he had about two hundred and eighty men und-r his com mand at that time; the bullets came like hail until dark, about three hours, when forti fications were thrown up; firing recom menced about three o'clock in the morning, on the twenty-sixth, and continued until ten o'clock, when it slackened; there were prob ably nine thousand Indian warriors in the village that evening, it being two and a half or three miles long; they first knew of Cus ter's fate on the twenty-seventh; they dis covered the line of battle, perfectly evident from the dead horses and corpses; the position was not well chosen for defense; around Custer was a whole pile of men, there had apparently been an attempt at escape; the fight probably did not last over half an hour; Custer had three hundred and twenty five men when be separated from Reno.
See moreSee less
The court decided this afternoon that it will not investigate the conduct of Bentien, whose name has been associated with that of Reno in this matter. Adjourned.
At the Reno Court of Inquiry in Chicago, Lieut. Wallace testified under cross-examination about the division of Custer's command, Reno's retreat, and the ensuing fight with Indian warriors. He praised Reno's conduct as brave and his decision to retreat as wise, while describing casualties, ammunition shortages, and the eventual siege until relief arrived.
The Cheyenne Daily Leader · 17 January 1879 · page 1
(Chicago, Jan. 16.—The Reno court of inquiry to-day decided that report ers might take notes. Lieut. Wallace j j was cross-examined by Major Reno's i counsel (Mr. Gilbert). The testimony ; i was only a development of that given * I yesterday. He related how, after the ! I ' division of Custer's command, CoL i Ben teen went to the left, Maj. Reno : crossed tiie stream and Geu. Custer re- ' mained on the right bank ; how the ' j two latter detachments formed a June
Testimony describes Major Reno's retreat to the hilltop, the arrival of Benteen's force, and the ensuing siege by thousands of Indian warriors. It also notes the court's decision not to investigate Benteen's conduct and states Custer had 325 men when he separated from Reno.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Cheyenne Daily Leader · 17 January 1879 · page 1
on tiie 20th, and continued until 10 o'clock, when it slackened. There j j were probably 6,000 Indian warriors in j ' tbe village that evening, it being two 1 and 'a-half or three miles long. They j first knew of Custer's fate on the 27th, j They discovered the line of battle, { perfectly evident from the dead horses ( and corpses. The position was not well chosen for a defense. Around ( Custer was a whole pile of men, there had apparently been no attempt to esj cape. The fight probably didn't last , over half an hour.
See moreSee less
Custer had 325 men when he separated from Reno. The court decided this afternoon I that it will not investigate the coni duct of Ben teen whose name has been i associated with Reno in this matter. < Adjourned. 1
The scout Frank Girard testified at the Reno Court of Inquiry about the timing of Custer's movements and his order to charge, estimating Cook delivered the charge order around 2:15pm and that Reno and Benteen's commands joined about ninety minutes later. He stated Custer was likely fighting when Reno and Benteen met, and discussed ammunition, troop positions, and discipline during the battle.
The New York Herald · 18 January 1879 · page 3
was that tho question should be allowed. CUSTKB'S OBDKH. In reply to the Recorder, the witness said that the time ot day at which Lieutenant Cook gave General Custer's order to charge the Indians was, he believed, a quarter after two o'clock in the afternoon; the commands of Major Uono and Captain Denteen joined at tho hill an hour and a halt later; the time Lieutenant Cook delivered the order from General Custer wus the last the witness saw of the General's column; General Custer was probably fighting when Reno and Renteen met; the amonnt of ammunition Reno's men had when he began his retreat across the river he was unable to state;
Lieutenant Wallace testified about the retreat casualties and estimated Indian force size, based on lodge counts suggesting thousands of warriors. Scout Girard then described Custer's final movements and orders before the battle, including Custer's instruction to Reno to 'pursue and charge' the Indians with promised support.
five or six warriors to each lodge, besides many wieka-ups; lie was unable to give an estimate of the number of the women and children. This finished Lieutenant Wallace's testimony. scout c.ruAiio's stout. After a recess of a few minutes Lieutenant Lee next called Oirard. the famous Indian seont. lie is quite an ordinary looking man, in a plain looking pepper and salt colored suit. Uis hair was sborl and stiff, no falcon eye "Hashed be utaiu tiuia ra-munn, , auu um > WU0 IK'llur'r weather beaten nor sunburnt. Tinwitness said that on the morning of the :15th ho wan serving under tho Immediate orders of General Custer: that the General ordered liiu to join Major Reno, with hi* scouts; indications that tho Indians were in the vicinity the interpreter had discovered that morning, and had so iuformed General Cnster by hallooing to him from a hill, "Here are Crow Indians ruiiniug like devil*!"
See moreSee less
About eleven o'clock on the evening of the 24th General Custer called the witness to iiim and told hint to take two Indian scouts. Half Yellow Kare and Bloody Knife, with him and ride with General Custer at tho head of the column: in conversation
At the Reno Court of Inquiry, defense counsel Gilbert questions Lieut. Wallace further about Reno's movements and the defensibility of his chosen position near the river. The Recorder objects when Gilbert tries to ask Wallace's opinion on Custer's decision to split the regiment, ruling Custer's conduct outside the inquiry's scope.
Chicago Daily Tribune · 18 January 1879 · page 3
tbe purpose of putting a few more questions to LI BUT. WALLACE. The request was granted, and Mr. Gilbert pro ceeded to ask tbe witness whether MaJ. Ueno had lost any time In moving from the hlll-top In the direction in which Lieut.-Col. Custer—Mr. Gilbert never nays Gen. Custer—was found, after the pack-train had come ud.
During the Reno Court of Inquiry, counsel Gilbert questions whether Lieut. Wallace's opinion on Custer's decision to divide the regiment is relevant, while Lieut. Lee argues Custer's conduct is outside the inquiry's scope. The court rules the Whittaker letter will only be considered insofar as it falls within the court's original mandate, disallowing the question.
Chicago Daily Tribune · 18 January 1879 · page 3
LIEUT. WALLACE.
Gen. Custer’s conduct on that occasion. CUSTBIU Mr. Gilbert said ho would bo glad to bo re lieved from tlmt branch of tho question. This loiter was nut in tho form that charges and spcclik-ations should be, but abounded in a good deal of rhetorical declamation. There was one thing to which be Invited attention, viz.: tbo third statement, tu the effect that the only old cfal report of tho battle was MaJ. Reno’s, which was In the mam false, and libelous to tho mem ory of thu late X.teut.-Col. Custer, in that it rep resented the dclcat on that occasion to have been owing to tho division by Custer of Ids force Into threo battalions, mid to tbo over matching of Ids force, and to Ids ignorance of tho cncmv’s force,—all of widen, according to the letter, were serious charges against Custer’s capacity as an officer.
A witness testifies at the Reno Court of Inquiry about the timing of Custer's movements, the order to charge, and the condition of ammunition during the battle. He discusses the positions of Reno, Benteen, and Custer's command and expresses uncertainty about exact troop movements and support plans.
Chicago Daily Tribune · 18 January 1879 · page 3
haw much the meu on the skiruiisli-tine had. 1 buy were supposed to hare hod 1W) rounds apiece, but some, owing to the Irregular firing, had expended more than others. There ought certainly to have boon 11,800 rounds, and there was probably more, lie did not hear any com plaint about ammunition, except that In many of the wen's belts It was all gone when the re treat was made, lie did not know where Cook and Keough turned around, alter Cook had given the order, but lie saw them within hall a mile ol the ford.
See moreSee less
Custer must have been to Juno’s rear thuu. lu reply to a question as to whether a command going into battle couldn’t be practically supported In Its attack to some other way than by having a 'tolurnu Immediately behind It, witness said he guested It could, ilo thought, at the time the uroer to ehuruu was given, that Rontocn was to the left, but wbat the orders were, or what Ron-' teen was going tudo,he couldn’t tell. He did uot expect much assistance from that direction, lu reply to a question as to whether the sup port spoken of lu Custer’s order could not have referred to Renlceu’s column, witness said he md nut know as to that, but he Imagined, from wuat was said, that Ibu support was coming Jruin Custer. That was simply his idea—that w>n»lng Irom Custer. Kudo's route, w.mje °°t the most direct, waa the most prae
This report primarily describes the Fort Robinson Cheyenne breakout and subsequent killings, with an editorial blaming government mismanagement. It lists the Custer massacre two years earlier as one of several calamities caused by the same corrupt Indian policy.
The Ottawa Free Trader · 18 January 1879 · page 4
The same causes precisely which led to this massacre are responsible for the calamities in western Kansas and Nebraska last summer, for the ISannock war a year ago hist summer, and for the Custer massacre two years ago.
A scout's testimony is reported describing how he rode with Custer's column, saw over 2,500 Indians, and recounted the order given to Reno to advance and charge the Indians. He also described the terrain and movements of the various columns during the battle.
The Rock Island Argus · 18 January 1879 · page 1
F. F. Girard, who was with Reno at the time ot tbe massacre, tie testined tnat the two scouts Half lellow Face and Blood Knife, he rode at the head of Gen. Custer's column to the top of a knoll and saw not less than 2,500 Indians; the order civen Reno was: "Uo forward, and when you meet Ihe Indians charge them and I will support you " He ioined the Reno force: he described at some length the character of tbe ground and tbe direc tions taken by the various columns. Adjourned.
At the Reno Court of Inquiry in Chicago, scout and interpreter F. F. Girard testified that on June 24 he saw at least 2,500 Indians from a knoll while riding with Custer's column. He described Custer's order for Reno to advance and charge, with Custer promising to support him, and detailed the terrain and troop movements.
The Portland Daily Press · 18 January 1879 · page 2
The Reno Inquiry. Chicago, Jan. 17.—In the Reno court to-day t.ho noted Indian scout and intrepreter, F. F. Girard, who was with Reno at the time of the massacre, te3 tified that on the evening of the 24th of June, with two scouts he rode at the head of Custer’s column to the top of a knoll and saw not less than 2500 Indians. The order given Reno was to go forward and when you meet the Indians, charge, and J will support you. He joined the Reno force. Ho described at length the character of the ground and the direction taken by various columns. Adjourned.
The Reno Court of Inquiry in Chicago continued hearing testimony, with Lieut. Wallace cross-examined about the distance between Reno's separation point and where Custer's first casualties were found. Scout F. F. Girard testified he saw over 2,500 Indians from a knoll and described Custer's order to Reno to charge and promised support.
Daily Globe · 18 January 1879 · page 1
CUSTER'S LAST RIDE.
LSpecial Telegram to the Globe. CHICAGO, Jan. 17.At the opening of the Reno inquiry to-day, Maj. Reno's counsel asked Lieut. Wallace, who was still on the wit ness stand, what was the wisdom of separating the Seventh regiment into the different bat talions before the attack on the Indians was made. The recorder objected on the ground that an opinion as to Gen. Custer's conduct was not within the scope of the inquiry. The court decided to not admit the evidence on this point. Col. Merritt, one of the members of the court, desired to know the distance from the point where the Reno column separated to the point where Custer's first horse or man killed or wounded was found, and was answered by Lieut.
See moreSee less
Wallace that it was fully six miles. The next witness was T. F. Girard, a scout who was attached to Custer's command and was with Reno in the fight. Nothing of par ticular interest was elicited from him, when the court adjourned. His examination will be continued to-monow. [Western Associated Press.]
A Military Court of Inquiry into Major Reno's responsibility for the Custer massacre convened in Chicago on the 13th. The brief item is part of a roundup of miscellaneous news from around the country.
Northern Ohio Journal · 18 January 1879 · page 1
A severe shock pf earthquake was felt at Jacksonville, Fla., on the night of the 12th. It lasted about thirty seconds. , Buildings were violently shaken, crockery rattled, and doors thrown open: - The -shock was also felt at. jtu Augustine ana aown the uuu coast from Puif ta Russa to St. - Mark's, as well as &ver the interior portion of the State. . . .The Military Court of Inquiry into the repotlSibillty of Major Reno for the Custer mas
A military commission is examining charges of cowardice against Major Reno, alleging he stayed with several hundred men within hearing of the battle and allowed Custer and his men to be massacred by Indians. Reno claims he can fully refute the charges against him.
The News and Herald · 18 January 1879 · page 2
J"O. A. R.MNOLDis ASMIm 9DRos. OPPONE14rS o Senator 1ill claim that he Is in the same boat with Murphy, because he. while United States Senator, tried to do for a fee what Murphy succeeded in doing. It is charged, also, that he ol'ered to compromise with Murphy, and say nothing for half the fee. If so this makes Murphy no better, but Senator 1Il1 worse. A MILITARY comtilssion is Investi gating charges of cowardice preferred against Major Reno who, it is alleged, stood with several hundred men with!n hearing of' the battle and allowed Custer and all his men to be
This report details Lieutenant Wallace's cross-examined testimony before the Reno Court of Inquiry in Chicago, describing the division of Custer's command, the battle sequence, and Reno's conduct during the retreat. It recounts troop movements, casualties, ammunition shortages, and estimates of Indian warrior numbers, noting Custer's fate was not known until the 27th.
Daily Press and Dakotaian · 18 January 1879 · page 3
MAJ.KNO'tCASE C'onllnuatlon mt' Lieutenant WilUet*! TrilUmii}' ••rare the Canrt. Chicago, Jan. 16.—The Reno court ot in quiry wjijr decided that reporter* might take note*. Lieut. Wallace was croH-examnied by Mij, Reno's conncii, Mr. Gilbert. The tes timony w«* only a development of that giv en yeaterday. He related how, after the di vision of Custer** command, Col. Ben teen went to the left, Maj. Reno erased the stream and Oen. Custer remained on the right bank how the two latter detachments formed a junction by Reno recroiaing about twelve'mile* below, and how finally the bat tle was fought.
See moreSee less
Some of Maj. Reno'* com mand had never ridden a horse until this campaign. The only ammunition in the hann* of Reno'* force wan the supply *t their saddle*. It was u-ed up in naif an hour. In hie opinion it was a wise act of Maj. Reno to retreat and to have remained would have imperilled the live* of the whole body. Maj. Reno's conduct was brave and praiseworthy. During the retreat twenty-five men w»#o killed and seventeen wounded, and the time consumed was about an hour. When we arrived on tbe top of the hiil Benteen'a force came, but the pack train was three mile* to the rear. Reno showed no signs of fear at this time, but was conspicuously brave and fear less. No communication had been received from Custer, but a trumpeter stated that he had gone back. The ammunition was dis tributed, and company first met the In dians, seven thousand strong, in a ravine of fine advantage* where the men were proper ly posted by Reno. He had about 280 men under his command at that time. Bullets came like hail until dark, about three hours, when fortificationa were thrown up. Firinp recommenced about 3 a. m. on the 26th, am continued until 10 o'clock, when it slack ened. There were probably 9,000 Indian warriors in the village that evening, it being two and a half or three miles long. They first knew of Custer's fate on the 27th. The line of battlewas perfectly evident from the dead hot sea and corpses. The position was not well chosen for defense. Around Custer was a whole pile of men. There had appa rently been an attempt to esrape. The fight probably did not last over an hour. Custer nad 325 men when he separated from Reno. The court decided this afternoon that it will not investigate the conduct of Benteen, whose name has been associated with that of Reno's in this matter. Adjourned.
Witness testimony recounts Reno's retreat, casualties, and defensive stand on the bluffs, estimating thousands of Indian warriors in the village. The court also announces it will not investigate Benteen's conduct alongside Reno's.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Daily Press and Dakotaian · 18 January 1879 · page 3
Chicago, Jan. 16.—The Reno court ot in quiry wjijr decided that reporter* might take note*. Lieut. Wallace was croH-examnied by Mij, Reno's conncii, Mr. Gilbert. The tes timony w«* only a development of that giv en yeaterday. He related how, after the di vision of Custer** command, Col. Ben teen went to the left, Maj. Reno erased the stream and Oen. Custer remained on the right bank how the two latter detachments formed a junction by Reno recroiaing about twelve'mile* below, and how finally the bat tle was fought. Some of Maj.
See moreSee less
Reno'* com mand had never ridden a horse until this campaign. The only ammunition in the hann* of Reno'* force wan the supply *t their saddle*. It was u-ed up in naif an hour. In hie opinion it was a wise act of Maj. Reno to retreat and to have remained would have imperilled the live* of the whole body. Maj. Reno's conduct was brave and praiseworthy. During the retreat twenty-five men w»#o killed and seventeen wounded, and the time consumed was about an hour. When we arrived on tbe top of the hiil Benteen'a force came, but the pack train was three mile* to the rear. Reno showed no signs of fear at this time, but was conspicuously brave and fear less. No communication had been received from Custer, but a trumpeter stated that he had gone back. The ammunition was dis tributed, and company first met the In dians, seven thousand strong, in a ravine of fine advantage* where the men were proper ly posted by Reno. He had about 280 men under his command at that time. Bullets came like hail until dark, about three hours, when fortificationa were thrown up. Firinp recommenced about 3 a. m. on the 26th, am continued until 10 o'clock, when it slack ened. There were probably 9,000 Indian warriors in the village that evening, it being two and a half or three miles long. They first knew of Custer's fate on the 27th. The line of battlewas perfectly evident from the dead hot sea and corpses. The position was not well chosen for defense. Around Custer was a whole pile of men. There had appa rently been an attempt to esrape. The fight probably did not last over an hour. Custer nad 325 men when he separated from Reno. The court decided this afternoon that it will not investigate the conduct of Benteen, whose name has been associated with that of Reno's in this matter. Adjourned.
A Chicago dispatch reports testimony given at the Reno Court of Inquiry by a Scout Guard describing troop movements on the day of the Custer massacre. The witness estimated Indian warrior strength at 2,500-3,000 and described hearing volleys of gunfire before Reno's force moved and later saw what he believed was Custer's command.
Daily Los Angeles Herald · 19 January 1879 · page 2
New York, Jan. 18th.—S. M. Mills & Co., siid to be brokers for Jay Gould and other well kuown operators, have suspended, owing to Northwest having advanced too rapidly for the bears. I lie Kflsn t'OHrt Of li.QIIIrj. Chicago, Jan. istii.—The Scout Guard who testified to-day iv the Reno inquiry gave a lengthy ac count of the movements of the troops on the day of the Custer massacre. He described the condi tion and situation of the bitllo fio'd aud mentioned the various orders given. The witness believed the lighting force of the ludiuns was 2 ,-500 to 3,000 warriors.
See moreSee less
They heard several volleys of from Ilfiy to ono hundred shots each on the other side of tbe village at übout the time the order was given, "livery man tv Ills horae." Reno's force at that word left the wood where they were stationed aud in ten or fifteen min utes they saw Custer's command, or what he believed to bo that com mand. Ho thought the force of 150 men ought tn have held the Indians In cheek some time. Wltuess's furtliei's testlmouy related to the finding of bodies, etc. Ie ftl'iruc itruheu lIiCHMONU; Jan. 18.—The steam er Wyaudke forced a passage through the ico gorge at 11 o'clock to-day, occupying over three days. The short gorge, near Verina, was broken up by the steamers Wy audke ami Old Dominion, working from eucli end. The ice at that | point was twelve feet thick.
Interpreter F.F. Girard resumed testimony describing the chaotic retreat of Reno's command from the skirmish line into the timber and back to the river. He noted the lack of order, with troops anxious to leave and no concerted movement during the withdrawal.
Chicago Daily Tribune · 19 January 1879 · page 7
MAJ. RENO.
a pivot. THE INDIAN VILLAGE ans a mile and a half or two miles from the liac, down the left bank of the Little Big Horn. The command did not remain on the skirmisli
A witness at the Reno Court of Inquiry describes the Indian village, estimating 2,500-3,000 warriors, and recounts seeing what he believed was Custer's column moving downstream before losing sight of it. He speculates that Indians abandoned fighting Reno to intercept Custer's force, and testifies about ammunition usage during the fighting.
a pivot. THE INDIAN VILLAGE ans a mile and a half or two miles from the liac, down the left bank of the Little Big Horn. The command did not remain on the skirmisli llae over ten minutes before it swung around. Witness was asked to describe the timber where the right oi the line was drawn up, aim did so at some length, giving distances. The com mand did not stay in the timber, after leaving the skirmish-line, over ten minutes, aud went off in a diagonal direction towards the river.
See moreSee less
The troops in the timber seemed anxious to get oat. Every man was for bimsclt, and there was nothing like order or a concerted movement. After he heard the order “To horse,” the men withdrew from the line, got their horses, and an officer told him they were going to charge. Witness and Remolds were in the timber, and concluded that the orders weren’t intended for them, that the troops would return after the charge, and that they needn’t bother themselves to join them, as they would be iu the way. While in tbe timber he saw De Rudio and a scout named Jackson. He pulled out his watch—a good timekeeper—aud it was 1 o’clock. When they left tne woods it was twi light, and the watch indicated that it was 9 . o’clock. The command, wiiile in the timber, was iu a sheltered position, so that they could load and fire under shelter. Witness* heard firing, while in the timber, to the left of the village. De Radio slapped his baud ou his thigh, and said, very excitedly: “By , iuehu’s ccster; let s go and join uim,” Witness, however, told him to wait; that there would be time enough for that. Witness heard continuous firing ail the way down the banks to tbe place known as Custer’s battle-field. At first the shots were scattering, and then in vol leys. When they went down afterwards to bury the soldiers they found a gray horse, wounded, on the lelt bank of the river, at a ford further down the stream than the point “B.” The general tiring, on what was known as Custer’s battle-field, lasted about two hours, imdindiealcd ageueral engagement. After leav ing the timber, witness rejoined Reno’s command about 11:30 tbe night of the 26th. Immediately after leaving the limber, however, on the 25th, witness crossed the river at the point where Reno had crossed, aod saw the moving Indian village, lie estimates their fighting men at between 2,500 and 3,000. Witness described the . downward course of the river, spoke of the trails, the fords, etc., and otherwise showed his familiarity with the situa tion. There were only three fords,—where Reno crossed in his advance, where he crossed on his retreat to the lull, aud where the gray horse was found. From the latter point, witness conln sec where the lodges bad been. A large portion of the village was below the ford. The lodges be first saw, while at the ford, were not quite tothe centre of the village. It was about ten or fifteen minutes before Reno left the timber that witness last saw Custer’s column.—at least he supposed it was Custer’s, for he, knew noth ing of tbe division into three battalions. The column apocared to be moving very fast down tile stream. He found out afterwards that it was actually Custer’s com mand, because Reno and Bentecn joined on the hill, and, Knowing where tbe tiring lurtber down had taken biaec, he was satisfied that it was between the Indians and Custer, since the latter’s column was the only one that could have been there. When on'the little knoll, referred to in Friday’s testimony, the vaiiey seemed alive with Indians. Afterwards there were comparatively few, and witness con cluded they had discovered Custer, and had prob atily moved down in the direction of the point “B ” with the design of CUTTING OFF CUSTER
Custer's scout F.F. Girard testified before the Reno Court of Inquiry in Chicago, describing being cut off from Reno's forces and witnessing Custer's troops moving along the bluffs before the main Indian force turned to pursue Custer. He estimated Indian numbers at 2,500-3,000 and suggested Reno should have held his position against lesser opposition.
The New Orleans Daily Democrat · 19 January 1879 · page 1
The Rene Court of Inquiry-Severe Cold In Nebraska. CHIAoo,. Jan. 18.-The testimony of F. F. Girard. Custer's scour, was continued before the Beno Court of Inquiry to-day. He was with Reno's forces, but was cut off from them and remained in the woods over night with another scour Lieut. De Budio and Private O'Netl. Be fore Ieno retreated the witness saw Oauster's troops passing on the bluffs to the right of the river. The main body of the Indians left Beno and went after Ouster. He did not think there were more than 160 op posingr eno.
See moreSee less
When his troops began the retreat, every man was for himself. He heard vollles of heavy firing, which wasthe only indl cation of Custer's line. De Budio wanted to go and join Custer. but Girard wouldn't venture. He believed there were in all from 250oo to s000 Indians, and the main body went after Custer tc protect the village from him, and that Reno should have held his ground against the small odds of his enemies. The court adjourned till Monday. Reports in private letters from Nebraska and Western Kansas tell of deep snows.cold weather. much suffering and considerable loss of cattle, owing to the scarcity of hay and lack of shelter.
Scout Frank Girard testified before the Reno inquiry in Chicago, estimating Indian fighting force at 2,500-3,000 warriors and stating Reno's command should have held out longer. He described troop movements, the battlefield, and the discovery of bodies before the court adjourned until Monday.
Daily Globe · 19 January 1879 · page 1
RENO'S RAID. Frank Girard Examined as to the Battle of the tattle Big Horn. [Special Telegram to the Globe. CHICAGO, Jan. 18.The scout Girard was fur ther examined to-day in the Reno inquiry. He thought the fighting force of the Indians was about 3,000. He further thought that Reno's force ought to have held out a good deal longer than it did, and that the greater portion of the savages were af er Custer instead of Reno. The witness was examined very exhaustively, but the foregoing are the salient points of his tes timony. The court adjourned until Monday. I Webtern Associated Press.
At the Reno Court of Inquiry in Chicago, scout Girard described troop movements and the battlefield on the day of Custer's defeat, estimating Indian warrior strength at 2,500-3,000. He recounted hearing volleys of gunfire, the order for Reno's men to mount up, and his view of what became of Custer's command.
Eureka Daily Sentinel · 19 January 1879 · page 2
Teatlaaewy of the Beau*. Girard. Chicago, January 18. The scout, Girard, who testified to-day in the Beno inquiry, gave a lengthy account of the movements of the troops on the day of the Custer massacre. He described the condition and situation of the battle-field, and mentioned the various orders given. The witness believed the fighting force of tbs Indians was 2,500 to 3,000 warriors. They heard several volleys of from 50 to 100 shots each, on the other side of the village, at about the time the order Was given, “ Every man to his horses !” lteno’s force, at that order, left the woods where they were stationed, and in 10 or 15 min utes they saw Custer’s command, or what he believed to be that command.
Scout Girard testified at the Reno inquiry into the Custer massacre, describing troop movements, battlefield conditions, and orders given during the fight. He estimated Indian warrior strength at 2,500-3,000 and recounted the sequence of events including Reno's withdrawal and sighting of what he believed was Custer's command.
The Cheyenne Daily Leader · 19 January 1879 · page 1
Progress of the Reno Inquiry. Chicago, Jan. 18. —The scout Girard, who testified to day in the Reno inqui ry, gave a lengthy account of the move | ments of the troops on the day of the ! Custer massacre. He described the i condition and situation of the battle | field, and mentioned the various orders given. Tiie witness believed the fight ling force of the Indians was 2,5U0 to 3,000 warriors. They heard several volleys of from fifty to one hundred shots each, on the other side of the village.
See moreSee less
At about the time the order was given: “Everyman to his horse,” Reno’s force at that word, left the wood where they were stationed and in ten or fifteen minutes they saw Custer’s i command, or what he believed to be | that command. lie thought the force ; of 150 meu ought to have held the In i dians in check some time. The wit ness’ further testimony related to the . finding of the bodies, etc. Adjourned.
A Chicago reader writes to the Tribune about testimony given by scout Girard (Grouard) at the Reno Court of Inquiry, suggesting Reno could have held the timber position and gone to Custer's aid. The letter urges the examining attorney to cross-examine Girard about his own conduct, implying Girard abandoned comrades DeRudio and O'Neill during the retreat.
Chicago Daily Tribune · 20 January 1879 · page 3
The Itmw Cano. TW MW Editor »t Th* Triton*. Chicago, Jan. 10.—1 would Ilka to ask a question. 1 have read with caro the proceed ings of the Reno Court of Inquiry now sitting In this city, and been much Interested in the testimony of the several witnesses,—Maguire, Wallace, and Girard, or Grouard. The latter la, or was, * scout, and at thu time of the Cus ter fight was attached to the Seventh Cavalry In this caoscllv. Ho accompanied MaJ. Reno when thu latter made Ids attack upon the Indians, and.
See moreSee less
not getting out of thu timber with the cav alrymen when tbev fell back to the hill ou the coat hank of the river, no doubt had n lively ex perience, eventually, running the gauntlet of savages. In the opinion of this roan Girard, as 1 road hla testimony, MaJ. Reno might have made a protracted stand In the timber and saved many of hla men who were subsequently killed; might have coped successfully with the savage foe without retreating; nml ought to have gone to Custer's aid, for “ heavy and continuous tiring ” la that, direction could bo distinctly heard. Furthermore, Girard appears to think Reno kept himself hidden, personally, In (ho timber, fur ho did not see him. I wish Mr. fillbert would ask a few questions of Girard, to llic following died: 4 * Wliero were you and Lleul. DcUudto, and
The Reno Court of Inquiry continued with cross-examination of scout F.F. Girard, whose testimony suggested a worse case against Reno. Girard described the disorganized retreat from the timber, the distance to the Indian village, and hearing continuous firing toward Custer's battlefield while separated from the main command.
Chicago Daily Tribune · 20 January 1879 · page 7
a pivot. Til* INDIAN VIM.AOB was a mile and a half or two miles from the Hue, down the left bank of the Little Big Horn. The command diet nut remain on the skirmish line over ten minutes before it swung around.
A witness recounts testimony about troop movements near the timber, timing by watch, and sighting Custer's column before it disappeared toward the village. He also describes the river fords, the scale of the Indian village, and estimates of enemy fighting strength between 2,500 and 3,000.
Chicago Daily Tribune · 20 January 1879 · page 7
THE INDIAN VILLAGE
there's cuftTßit; i.gr* no and join him.” Witness, however, told him tu wait; that there would bu time enough fi.r that. Witness heard continuous firing nil the wav down the banks to thu plme known as Custer’s battlu-lleld. At first the shots went scattering, mid then in vol leys. When they went down afterwards to bury the soldiers thev found a gray horse, wounded, on tho Iclt bank of the river, at a font further down tlm hi ream than the point “B.” Thu general tiring, on what was known as Custer’s battle-field, lasted about two hours, and Indicated a general engagement. Afierleav-
A witness at the Reno Court of Inquiry describes the three fords of the Little Bighorn, the sighting of Custer's column moving downstream, and the apparent shift of Indians from Reno's position to intercept Custer. He also recounts ammunition use, dead bodies near the village, and the location where Custer's body was found.
Chicago Daily Tribune · 20 January 1879 · page 7
THE INDIAN VILLAGE
2,600 mid 3,030. Witness described the downward course of the river, sooko of the trails, thu fonts, etc., and otherwise showed ids (ondllarltv with the >liua tlou. There were only three fords,—where Reno crossed in Ids advance, where ho crushed on hU retreat to the hill, nnd where tlm gray horse was found. From the latter point, witness could see where the lodges had been. A large portion of tho village was below the ford. Tho lodges bw first saw, while at the ford, wetc not quite to the centre of tho village, it was about ten or fifteen minutes before Runo left tbs Umber that witness lest saw Custer’s column,—at least ho supposed It was Custer's, for he knew noth ing of the division Into .three,battalions.
See moreSee less
The column opocarcd to bu,t(uovios.' very Jaot down tho stream. Ho found out afterwards that It was actually Custer's com mand. because Reno nnd Benton joined 011 tho hill, and, Knowing where the firing further down had token olnco. he was lothllcd that It was between the Indians .and Cutter, alueo the latter’s column was thu only one that could have been there. When,on thu lliilo knoll, referred to in Friday’s tcsthmmv, the volley seemed alive with Indians. Afterwards there were comparatively few. und witness con cludsd they had discovered Custer, nnd had prob ably moved down In the direction of the point
At the Reno Inquiry in Chicago, scout Girard testified about troop movements on the day of the Custer massacre, describing the battlefield and estimating Indian warrior strength at 2,500-3,000. He recounted hearing volleys of gunfire, Reno's force leaving the woods, sighting what he believed was Custer's command, and his opinion that 150 men could have held off the Indians.
The Portland Daily Press · 20 January 1879 · page 2
The Reno Inquiry. Chicago, Jan. 18.—The scout Girard, who testi fied to-day in the Reno inquiry, gave a len thy ac count of the movement of the troops on the day of the Caster massacre, described the condition and sit. uation oi the battlefield, and mentioned the various orders given. Witness believed the fighting force of the Indians to be 2500 or 3000 warriorB. They heard several volleys ot from fifty to one hundred shots each on the other side oi the village about the time order, "Every man to his horse,” was given.
See moreSee less
Reno’s force then leit the wood, and in ten or fifteen min uteB saw Custer’s command, or what he believed to be that command. He thougbt a force of 150 men ought to have held the IndianB in check some time. Adjourned. The Iiieut. Governor of Florida Indicted
In a letter to the editor, Col. William Thompson disputes a prior report naming him as a leader of anti-Custer sentiment among officers, insisting he always admired Custer and Benteen and never considered Reno or his officers cowardly. He attributes the disaster to an underestimate of Indian numbers rather than to any individual's fault.
Daily Globe · 20 January 1879 · page 1
Col. TJtonipson Blames Xo One. To the Editor of the Globe. BISMABCK, D. T., Jan. 15, 1879.In your number 364, of the 13th inst., in the column "Reno's Racket," and under the heading "The GLOBE'S Contribution," I find the following surprising paragraph, to-wit: "The leader of the Custer opposition was, at first, Col. Wm. Thompson. He left the regi ment. His mantle fell upon the shoulders of Col. Fred. W. Benteen." Now. the truth is, I have ever been a friend and admirer of Gen. Custer, and have never taken any part with any opposition to him. I have always regarded him as a superior man and splendid officer. I think the same of Col. Benteen, and have
Daily Press and Dakotaian · Yankton, S.D. · and 1 other paper
An army officer in Washington warns that Cheyenne prisoners in Indian Territory may break out and head to the northwest in spring, claiming they are desperate and would rather die fighting. He also references the Cheyenne role at the Little Bighorn and debates within the Indian Commission over transferring Sioux and Cheyenne oversight to the military.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
Daily Press and Dakotaian · 20 January 1879 · page 2
NOTES FBOM THE CAPITAL. Washington, Jan. 16.—An officer of the army who has had long experience with the Indians of the northwest, now temporarily in this city, says that in his judgment there is serious danger of the Cheyennes, now in Indian territory, breaking away in the spring and making their way across Kansss and Nebraska to the northwest hunting grounds. The Cheyennes, he says, are the finest Indians physically now alive. The men are brave, strong and desperate fight era, and. the women are chaste. The Cheyenne warriors did the most of the fighting during the lata Sioux war, and at the massacre of Custer it was the Cheyenne bucks that played the most havoc in this disastrous campaign, The Cheyenne warriors now in Indian ter ritory, are desperate.
See moreSee less
They say they cannot and willnot stay there.. It is death anyhow, and they (Uight as well be killed lighting in the field as die like dogs in their present imprisonment, for that is. all it is. There are about two thousand Cheyenne bricks who are determined to breakaway. There am but two courses to pursue with them. Thej must either be disarmed, and then all their ponies token away and a sufficiently strong force placed about them, or else they must be taken back to the northwest and allowed to affiliate with the Sioux. If the latter course is pursued it will be less difficult and less expensive to maintain control of them than if they are retained in Indian territo ry. The plan of the officer above referred to is to gather all the Sioux and Cheyennes in the northwest and draw a cordon of troops about tliem, and let the responsibility for their management be turned over to' the military. THE INDIAN COMMISSION.
Scout Frank Girard testified before the Reno inquiry in Chicago about troop movements during the Custer battle, estimating Indian warrior strength at 2,500-3,000 and stating most warriors pursued Custer rather than Reno. He described hearing volleys of gunfire, the order to mount up, and the subsequent sighting of what was believed to be Custer's command.
Daily Globe · 20 January 1879 · page 3
RENO'S RAID.
timony. Th court adjourned until Monday. I Western Associated Press. CHICAGO. Jan 18.The scout Girard, who testified to-day in the Reno inquiry, gave a lengthy account of the movements of the tioops on the day of the Custer massacre, described the condition and situation of the battle-field, and mentioned the various orders given. Th witness believed the fighting force of the In dians was 2,500 to 3,000 warriors. They heard several volleys of from fifty to one hundred shots each on the other side" of the village at about the time the order was given, "Hvery man to his horse."
See moreSee less
Reno's force at that word left the woods where they were stationed, and in ten or fifteen minutes they saw Custer's comman d, or what he believed to be that co m mand. thoug ht the force of 150 men ought to have held the Indians in check some time. Witness further testified relating to the finding of the bodies, etc. Adjourned.
At the Reno Court of Inquiry in Chicago, Lt. George D. Wallace testified that Custer ordered Reno to charge the Indians with a promise of support, and that Reno's retreat to the hilltop position was a necessary and advisable military decision given the overwhelming Indian numbers and exhausted troops. The court also ruled that the inquiry would cover the entire battle timeline, not just Reno's movements, amid allegations of cowardice and neglect of duty raised in a letter by Whittaker.
Bismarck Tribune · 20 January 1879 · page 2
INQUIRY IN DEFENSE OF THE GALLANT DEAD
his position. The witness states that he heard Custer tell Reno to charge the [mans and "we will sup port you." In bis inion, as a soldier, Reno did the most advisai le thing be could when he changed his posit n. Reno, he said, made an attempt to move lit where it was supposed Custer was, but being able to keep the wounded up with th column, it became neces sary to fall back to le original position on the 1 hill and there remaii, When they went into the fight Reno's me were worn out and the animals fatigued, ht ring made forced marches and both going with ut regular food nearly a day.
See moreSee less
When asked if saw anything during that engagement to refle upon the military char acter of Maior Reri the witness replied that he had told what hcj chew about it. During the examn ition to-day, the question was raised by Reno het-her the inquiry should cover anything m« than the movements of his command, and. the court decided that evervthing connecte with that battle from the 25th~to the 26th of tine, should be taken into consideration, "If
The Reno Court of Inquiry continues, with the scope of investigation expanded to cover the entire battle from June 25-26, not just Reno's movements. Lieutenant George D. Wallace testifies in detail about troop positions, the Indian village, and the chaotic retreat, while Reno's supporters argue evidence shows he could not have heard the sounds of fighting from his position.
Bismarck Tribune · 20 January 1879 · page 2
until after he crossed the creek on the retreat. He last saw Custer after he gave the order to move. The court decided to take all the testimony relative to the engagement that was offered. Adjourned.?
Northern Cheyenne held captive at Fort Robinson since October, told they would be forced back to Indian Territory, broke through windows at night and fled armed with concealed revolvers, wounding guards. Pursuing cavalry reportedly shot and killed over forty of the fleeing Cheyenne on the frozen prairie as the chase continued.
Bismarck Tribune · 20 January 1879 · page 2
THE CAPTIVE CHEYENNES ON THE WAR PATH
until after he crossed the creek on the retreat. He last saw Custer after he gave the order to move. The court decided to take all the testimony relative to the engagement that was offered. Adjourned.?
The piece sarcastically notes that despite all the contradictory witness accounts of the Little Big Horn fight, one fact can be deduced: Custer is indeed dead. It mocks the unreliability of competing narratives surrounding the battle.
Bismarck Tribune · 20 January 1879 · page 4
FROM the conflicting accounts of the witnesses in the Little Big Horn fight, one fact is at least deducible, and that is that Ouster is really dead. WE are tempted to ask: "Who ever knew an editor to lie when there was nothing in it?—' Fargo Independent.
At the Reno Court of Inquiry in Chicago, scout Girard described troop movements on the day of the Custer massacre, estimating Indian fighting strength at 2,500-3,000 warriors. He recounted hearing volleys of gunfire and believed a force of 150 men could have held off the Indians for some time.
The Daily Dispatch · 20 January 1879 · page 3
The Echo Court of HiUHtirj. Cijicago, January 18.? Scout Girard, in the Reno inquiry to-day, gave a long ac count of the movements of the troops on the day of the Custer massacre, a-ad the sit uation of the battle-fields, and Mentioned the various orders given, lie believed the lighting force of t he Indians to have been 2,500 to 3.000. lie heard several volleys of from 50 to 100 shots each on the other. side of the village ab&ut the time the order was given, Every man to his horse."' Reno's force, at that command., left the wood-where they were stationed, and in ten or fifteen minutes he saw Custer's command.. He thought a force of 150 men ought t-0 have held the Indians in cheek for some time.
Scout F.F. Girard testified before the Reno Court of Inquiry in Chicago, describing Custer's order to Reno to charge the Indians and the sequence of events during the attack and retreat. Girard also corrected his earlier testimony about the timing of the retreat, shifting it by an hour to explain Reno's delay in reaching Custer.
Daily Los Angeles Herald · 21 January 1879 · page 2
Tbe Reuo Inquiry. C'HiCAfio, Jan. 20.—m the Reno inquiry to-day Major Reuo and his counsel asked leave to subpeoua two more witnesses, making twen ty-six in all, namely, J. Scott Payne and Sergeant Delesey, of Company I, Seventh Cavalry. The latter was present on tho battle field under Reuo at the time of the massacre. The Court reserved its decision. The scout, F. F. Glrard, continued his testimony and was cross-examined by Recorder Lee. The principal point made was that Custer gave Reno the followiog or der, when standing within a few feet of him: "Major Reno, you will advance and try to overtake the In lilaus and when you do so, charge them.
See moreSee less
Take the scouts with you." This contradicts the testimony of Lieut. Wallace, that the order was delivered by Col. Cook. When the advance was made and the Indians began to troop up to meet Reao, the latter checked his horse and his command did the same. Wit ness then rode off to tell Custer about the approach of the ludians. Witness was closely questioned on this point aud said, after telling Col. Cook, whom he met, to bear this news to Custer, he rode back to Reno's command and advanced with them, but In the rear of tbe enlumr.. When he caught up the skirmish Hue was formed and the horses were in the timber in charge of the horse holders. The men advanced at once and fighting be gan about ten minutes later. The retreat began with the order "Men to their horses; the ludians are in our rear." One of the Captains gave the order aud in a minute the men were ou their way across the river. Glrard made a correction iv his testimony as to the time when tbe command began the retreat. Saturday he said ten minutes after 1; he now said teu minutes after 2. This explains Reno's delay of au hour in getting to Custer. Girard was closely interrogated concern
The Reno Court of Inquiry reconvened in Chicago to hear testimony from scout Girard, who corrected earlier estimates of Indian numbers and clarified details of the retreat. Girard asserted that Custer personally ordered Reno to charge immediately, a statement that caused a stir in the courtroom.
The New York Herald · 21 January 1879 · page 3
THE RENO TROUBLE. CLOSE OF THE EXAMINATION OF THE SCOUT GIRARD--IMPORTANT TESTIMONY AS TO CUSTER'S ORDERS AND THE RETREAT OF RENO--THE STORY OF SWINGING AROUND THE SKIRMISH LINE.
Chicago, Jan. 20, 1879. At eleven o'clock this morning the Court of Inqury in the case of Major Reno reconvened at the Palmer House. The usual large crowd attended. In the reading of his testimony on Friday and Saturday several objections were made by Glrard, most of them being corrections in his statements rather than in the transcription; for instance, ho said that his corrected estimate of the number of Indians ahead of Reno when he first left Custer was 1,500 or '2,000 instead of 2,500. He also said that not the killed scout, Charley Reynolds, but ho himself cried out on the order to retreat, "What damned fool Is this?"
See moreSee less
He also corrected his opinion as to the time of the day when Reno's command crossed the stream toward the hill, stating that bis second estimate made it about an hour later. Assisted by tlie clear and pointed questions of Mr. Gilbert tlie scout's testimony to-day seemed
At the Reno Court of Inquiry, scout Girard testified that Custer personally ordered Major Reno to charge the Indians, promising support, contradicting Lieutenant Wallace's account that the order came only through Adjutant Cook. Additional witnesses were subpoenaed and Girard detailed the advance of Reno's column toward the river under Indian approach.
The New York Herald · 21 January 1879 · page 3
ID several nu i-anirwumuiia i*r tun testimony of Lieutenant Wallace, and notably in tbe aasertion 01 the witness that Custer personally and in the hearing of witness ordered Reno to make an immediate charge. This statement caused a decided flutter. The witness repeated his former narrative without any change up to the time of Reno's receiving his orders from Custer to Join
The scout Girard gives detailed testimony about the orders Custer gave Reno, the advance toward the river, and the approach of Indians before the retreat began. Cross-examination by Mr. Gilbert probes contradictions with Lieutenant Wallace's earlier account of how orders were transmitted.
The New York Herald · 21 January 1879 · page 3
CUSTER'S ORDERS
A*- /1;?I?TT.i ctnvfr.,1 immor1iatr.lv The witness next told of the advance of Reno's command across the river into the timber*. When lteno got to the river the witness colled his attention to the fact that the Indians were coming up to the river to meet tliem. Reno gave the order to advance, llcno'tt horse was moving, but witness had halted his horse when he told Reno about the Indians. The remembrance of witness was that lteno checked his horse when thix was told him. The command were all close upon ltuuo and they checked their horses when he did so.
See moreSee less
Witness then went back to tell General Custer about the approach of the Indians. He had no orders to do so, but he thought it was s fact of sufticiont importance ami that Custer should know it.
At the Reno Inquiry in Chicago, scout F.F. Girard testified that Custer personally ordered Reno to advance and charge the Indians, contradicting Lieutenant Wallace's earlier testimony that the order came via Colonel Cooke. Girard also revised his account of the time the retreat from the timber began, from 1:10 to 2:10, explaining the delay in getting word to Custer.
National Republican (Washington City) · 21 January 1879 · page 1
THE RENO INQUIRY. Testimony of the Scout Continued.
Olr.nd mado a collection in his testlmmiyas totliollmu wliun tlio command begin to ro llout. On Saturday bo said it w.i. 1:10 o'clock, nut to-iiiy biatcu unit it was 2:111. nils ex plained lh'im'rf delay of ail hour in leschiuij Custer. Girard was simply iniuirog.ited con cerning this change of testimony, and said til it ho itfieslud hie memory )istunlay by reading old cnricspuuduiico on Hut point. Ho hel lived ins mcuioiy Unit not lulltd 1111 other point j. llo said it was not 1111 net of cowuidlie tor Ruuo s troujn to movu out of tho tlmbui, but ho bclicud they would have lu oil safer bail they remaiued thcie. Adjuuiuid. III I'iuui' nl tlio Ti-M-t riitlllu Haul,
At the Reno Court of Inquiry in Chicago, scout F. F. Gerard testified about the order Custer gave Reno to advance and charge the Indians, a account that contradicted Lieutenant Wallace's version naming Colonel Cook as the messenger. Gerard also corrected his own earlier testimony about the exact timing of Reno's retreat from the timber.
New-York Tribune · 21 January 1879 · page 2
TESTIMONY OF F. F. GERARD, THE SCOUT, BEFORE THE RENO COURT OF INQUIRY. Cnicaco, Jan, 20.—In the Reno inquiry to-day, Major Revo and bis counsel asked leave to subpeta (Wo ore WHOesscs, waking twenty-six in all, namely, J. Scott Payne and Sergeant Delescy, of Com, pany I, 7: Cavalry. The latter was present on the battle-tield under Keno ot the time of the massacre. The request was granted. The seout Fu 1 Gerard eontinued his testimony, and was cross-examnned by Recorder Lee. Tae principal point wade was that Custer gave Reno the folowing order when standing within a few feet of Lim: “Major Reno, you will advance and try to overtake the Indians, and when von do so charge them.
See moreSee less
Take the scouts with, yon,” This contradicts the testimony of Lieutenant Wallace that the order was delivered by Colonel! Cook, Wren the advance wus made aud the jadigns began to troop vp to met Reno, the latter checked his horee and his command did the same. The witness then rode off to tell Caster about the approach of the Indians, The witness was closely questioned en Lis pond, and sad that after telling Colonel Cook, whom he met, to bear this news to Custer, be rode back
At the Reno Court of Inquiry, interpreter Girard corrected several points from his prior testimony, including the number of Indians he estimated, who shouted a famous exclamation during the retreat, and the timing of river crossings. Custer's early morning orders to halt, make coffee, and remain saddled before advancing were also detailed.
Chicago Daily Tribune · 21 January 1879 · page 3
The Reno Investigation was resumed yester day morning with tho usual large audience of Interested outsiders, In standing and neck-cran ia attitudes and otherwise uncomfortable pos tures, In flUendnme. In reading over Interpret er Girard’s testimony certain corrections be came necessary, owing to misstatements by Gir ard on the stand, or. as some are Inclined to think, to a desire on that person’s part to alter or modify certain statements ho had made for the purpose, as It Is scientifically known, of „ crftW fislilng.” For Instance, in his testimony He stated he had told Custer ho would have not less than 2,300 Indians to deal with. Yesterday
A witness (Girard) testifies before the Reno Court of Inquiry about the orders Custer gave at dawn on June 25, including halting to make coffee and later taking scouts to a lookout point. He also discusses troop positions and discrepancies with Lt. Maguire's map, including the spot where he and Charley Reynolds stopped for whiskey.
Chicago Daily Tribune · 21 January 1879 · page 3
Recorder asked witness as to WUiT ORDERS CUSTBU HAD GIVEN AT EARLY DAWN, on tbe morning of June 35, in regard to halting, caving, etc. before witness replied, Mr. Gilbert asked that Capl. J, Bruit Pavuo, of tbo Filth Cavalry, who had gone over the battle-ground since the occurrence nnd made a map of It, and Beret. Lacy, who wits with McDougnll and tho pack train, be sitbpamacd as witnesses. Tho applica tion was lokoa under advisement. Tho witness, In answer to tho Recorder’s question, told what ortldrs Custer gave ou that morning.
See moreSee less
Tho command was halted nnd orders gtvon to make coffee at small fires, which were to he put out ua soon as tho coffee was made, the riarnca to remain saddled, and to mnvo after daylight, Witness had orders to communicate with two or three scouts who had come up with Kent. Varnnm. When tho coffee was made ho lay duwu alongside of his horse, slept awhile, and was awakened by Custer, who told him to tike Hie scouts and accompany him. A* ho bad his lack turned to Custer, either Cuok or Tom Custer came up nod asked whether tho command would follow. Custer said, “No, you will remotn hero until I return.” Witnoi, Custer, and the scouts then mounted, rode to-the foot of tho little mountain, dis mounted, and walked to tho top. When Custer left tho command to go to tho divide, Reno re mained lo charge, witness thought. On return ing from the mountain, tbu troops were about three miles tram whore they left them lo the morning, although witness was satisfied no orders were sent bsek to move out the com mand. When Reno engaged tbo Indians on tho leitbonk of the river, witness did not notice that the horses were In any way fatigued. Ho had been riding, be thought, more than snv other man In tlio command, nnd wouldn’t have hesitated to have ridden forty or fifty miles with his burse the next day. POSITIONS.
Witness Girard is questioned by Mr. Gilbert about the exact locations of Reno's command, Custer's column, and where Indians were first sighted, with distances estimated between various marked points on a map. The testimony includes a sardonic exchange about marking a spot where whiskey was drunk during the campaign.
Chicago Daily Tribune · 21 January 1879 · page 3
his burse the next day. POSITIONS. This closed tho direct, and Mr. Gilbert, mov ing up nearer to tbe witness, put thu following to him: “ You don’t agree precisely with the man of Lieut. Maguire. 1 wish you to give your understanding of these position*,and I wool run to locate the plac-u where you and Cnnrloy Reynold* stopped for thu drink of whlskvi” The Recorder's ula was called In to explain the position, and translated Girard’s answer bv saying that the point was at t lie loft ot tho skir mish line and a little hack of It.
See moreSee less
The Court suggested marking it by a letter. MaJ. Reno (solo vow) suggifllcd that “W" would bo tbc appropriate letter, considering that It was there that tliu drink of whisky was taken. M.autrlitcr.l Mr. Gilbert ashed Girard If ho could give any idea ns to where ho llrst saw the Jmilans at tliu time he communicated that fact to Custer. Thu witness replied that the map didn’t ruu up far enough fur that. The point would bo south* wist (mm whom Reno crossed at “A." Ho had Parsed from (he point where Reno’s command was on the night of the S3tb to the point •* A ” <-n the night of the Siith ut 10 oHlock, passim; between tint point and the point where the Judge with the dead Indians was standing, and following the trail up to the point where lie Joined Ileuu’s command on the hill. He thought he must have passed to the right of the knoll seventy live yards or so, and then continued Upon the trull. The distance from “A,” where Reno crossed under Custer's order, to the point where Reno was on the night of thotlSthwos about a mile or a mile and a quarter, and the dutnneo beiwced “A” and “E,” where the dead bodies were sup|Kjscd to liavo been found, was between four and live miles, according lo Ids estimate. The distance between tbo point where Ucno was on the night of the tSUh and the point “E”was “nigh onto four miles.” Mr. Gilbert tried to get witness to llx the point where he last saw the column under Custer, and, from the map, witness said it was nusr the letter d” lu the words “Reno’s command,” us> u to murk thrlr position on tho blit, after the tight in tho timber, lu other words, it was i>» the right bank ul tho river, cast and north of the point “ A " when Reno crossed on his way towards the village. The place WIIEUB WITNESS riHST SAW TUB INDIANS,
At the Reno Court of Inquiry in Chicago, scout Girard corrected his earlier testimony, saying new letters showed Reno's command left the timber at 2:10 p.m., not 1:10 p.m., which removes the appearance of a delay in reaching Custer. Girard also testified on Custer's direct order to Reno to advance and charge the Indians, contradicting Lieutenant Wallace's earlier account that the order came via Lieutenant Cooke.
Daily Globe · 21 January 1879 · page 1
Scout Girard Continues His Story of Cus ter's Last ChargeImportant Correction of Previous Testimony to Reno's Advan tageCuster'g Orders to Reno, Etc. ISpecial Telegram to the Globe.J CHICAGO, Jan. 20.At the Reno inquiry to day during the reading of Saturday's testi mony, Girard, the scout, made an important correction, saying that from letters now in his possession, which he did not have last Satur day, he had ascertained that it was 10 minutes after 2, instead of 10 minutes after 1 o'clock, when Reno'R command left the timber on their retreat across the river.
See moreSee less
The significance of this charge is that it relieves Major Reno of explaining an hour's delay in going to Custer's relief. The examination of this witness was then continned. Reno's position was about four miles from the point where Custer was found. Custer's order to Reno when the two separated was, "Major Reno, you will advance and try and overtake the Indians and when you do so charge them." Reno turned away and after he had gone but ten feet, Custer said, "And take the scouts with you." This order was given, G'rard said, direct from Custer to Reno. It will be remembered that" Lieut. Wal lace testified that the order was brought to Reno by the regimental quartermaster, Lieut. Cook. The witness said it was not an act of cowardice for Reno's troops to have moved out of the timber when they did. His judgment was, however, that for safety's sake they ought to have remained in the timber.
At the Reno Court of Inquiry in Chicago, scout P.F. Girard testified about Custer's order to Reno and the sequence of the retreat from the timber, while correcting his earlier testimony on the time the retreat began from 1:10 to 2:10. Witnesses disagreed on details such as who delivered Custer's order, and Girard stated the retreat was not cowardly but that remaining in the timber would have been safer.
Daily Globe · 21 January 1879 · page 1
INVESTIGATION
I Western Associated Press. CHICAGO, Jan. 20.In the Reno inquiry to day Maj. Reno and his counsel asked leave to subpoena two more witnesses, making twenty six in all, namely: J. Scott Paine and Sergeant Delesey, of Co. "E," Seventh cavalry. The latter was present on the battle-field under Reno at the time of the massacre. The court reserved decision. The scout, P. F. Girard, continued his testi mony, and was cross-examined by Recorder Lee. The principal point made was, Custer gave Reno the following order when standing within a few feet of him"Major Reno, you will advance and try to overtake the Indians, and when you do, charge them.
See moreSee less
Take the scouts with you." This contradicts the testi mony of Lieut. Wallace, that the order was de livered by Col. Crook. When the advance was made and the Indians began to troop up to meet Reno, the latter checked his horse, and his command did the same. Witness then rode off to tell Custer about the approach of the Indians. Witness was closely questioned on this point, and after telling Col. Crook, whom he met, to bear the news to Custer, he rode back to Reno's command and advanced with them. but in rear of the column. When he caught up a skirmish line was formed and the horses were in the timber in charge of the horseholder. The men advanced at once and the fighting be* gan about ten minutes later. The retreat be gan with the order, "Men to their horses, the Indians are in our rear." One of the captains gave the order, and in a minute the men were on their way across the river. Girard made a correction in his testimony as to the time when the command began the re treat. Saturday he said ten minates after 1. He now said ten minutes after 2. This ex plained Reno's delay of an hour in getting to Custer. Girard was sharply interrogated con cerning this change of testimony, and said he had yesterday refreshed his memory by reading old correspondence on the point. He believed his memory had not failed him on other points. It was not an act of cowardice for Reno's troops to move out of the timber, but he believed they would have been safer to remain. Court here adjourned, it being announced that Major Reno might summon the two wit nesses he desired.
The scout Girad testified about troop movements on the day of the Custer massacre, describing the battlefield and estimating Indian warrior strength at 2,500 to 3,000. He recounted hearing volleys of gunfire, the order for Reno's men to mount up, and the subsequent sighting of what was believed to be Custer's command.
Daily Press and Dakotaian · 21 January 1879 · page 2
THE RENO TRIAL Chicago, Jan. 17.—The scout, Girad, who testified to day in the Reno inquiry gave a lengthy account of tbe movemsclt of the troops on the day of the Custer massacre. He described tbe condition and situation ot the battle field and mentioned tbe various orders given. The witness believed the fighting force of tbe Indians was 2,500 to 3,000 warriors. They beard several volleys of from 50 to 100 shots each on the other side of tbe village at about the time the order was given '"every man to bis horse."
See moreSee less
Reno's force at that word left tbe wood where they were stationed, and in ten or fifteen minutes they saw Custer's command, or what be be lieved to be that command. He thought the force of 150 men ought to have held tbe In dians in check some time. Witness' furth er testimony related to the finding of tbe bodies, etc.
At the commission investigating Major Reno's conduct during the Custer massacre, scout F.F. Girard testified that he heard Custer order Reno to overtake and charge the Indians. The report speculates that Reno's failure to obey this order was likely the cause of the disastrous battle outcome.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Memphis Daily Appeal · 21 January 1879 · page 1
THE on the currency question, take this ground, favoring a continued issue of treasury aoU as a part of the paper currency, but requiring that they be deprived of their legal tender quality. Gk.skkal Shkrmaii, in a letter to General Sheridin, published yesterday, says he thinks the controversy with Secretary Scburz, as to tne control aud management of Indiau affairs, shuutd end where it is. And so thinks Secretary M'Crary. Tuk New York World publishes a state ment to the effect tbat many ex-Con federates in Washington have declared for Grant tor President.
See moreSee less
If this is true, they only speak for themselves. The Democrats of the south generally, will stand by the nominee of the party. F. F. Girard, the scout, testified before the commission investigating, in Chicago, General Reno's conduct at the Custer massa cre, that he heard General Custer order Gen eral Reno, on that occasion, to overtake and charge the Indians if possible. General Reno's failure to obey orders, it will probally be developed, was the cause of the disas trous results in that battle. The UTobe-Democrat, in a series of very ornamental headlines, in it's issue of Sun day, pronounces Bret II arte a prophetic poet, and calls attention to the fact that his "Spelling Bee" no longer rests on fiction, and it publishes in proof the following counter part of that story in verse, from real life, as it is known in Fostoria, Ohio: "John Schrech, a young Fostoria blood, with a number of companions, attended a spelling-school, three miles north of Fostoria, on Saturday night. While there they became involved in a fight with the country boys, during which young Scbrech drew a revolver and shot one of the latter, named Panherst, in the side, from the iffrctsof which, according to ths latest re ports, he .cannot recover. Scbrech and his companions have been placed under arrest." Sf.sator Wisdom i3 an as?. He has seri ously piopused to the senate that a committee appointed by that body thall device means for the removal of the negroes from those parts of the south whera they are refused or deuied their rights to other parts of the country. As the New York Herald truth fully as promptly states, " hundreds of thou sands of negroes have emigrated from south eastern to southwestern States ia tho last halt dozen years, and it would probably amaze Senator Windom to know that Arkan sas, Louisiana and Mississippi have been fa vorite States with industrious colored men seeking now homes, and that in 1375, at the Vdry time when' Senator Morton was vainly trying to persuade the northern public tbat no negro's life was safe in Mississippi, hun dreds of negro families removed thither tiom North Carolina, Georgia and Tennessee, at tracted by the rich lands of the Yazoo bot tom, and laughing at the ridiculous stories of murder and intimidation, which they knew from the reports of their friends who had pre ceded them were false' More than usual importance ia attached to the report of the senate committee award ing to Corbia the seat now held by Butler, from the fact that on the South Carolina sen atorsbip may depend the partisan complexion of the senate in 1881. "If the senate," says the Washington correspondent of the New Orleans ricayune, "sustains the report of the committee on privileges and elections, the senate will stand, after the fourth of March nest, forty-one Democrats, thirty-four Re publicans, and one Independent. Of vacan cies occurring on March 4, 1881, five are those made by retiring Democrat, from the States of New York, New Jersey, Connecticut, Ohio and Pennsylvania, all ot which at preseut nosKPsa ReDubhcan leeiti'iitureH. As these five Stabs will cot improbably have Repubi i.i . i, .f 1 , . , i en
A witness named Girard testified before the Reno inquiry, describing troop movements on the day of the Custer massacre and estimating Indian warrior strength at 2,500 to 3,000. He also described hearing gunfire and the discovery of bodies on the battlefield.
Memphis Daily Appeal · 21 January 1879 · page 1
Chicago, January 2Q. Tae sout Girard, who testified to-day in the Reno inquiry, gave a lengthy account of the movements of the troops on the day of the Custer massacre, d scribing the condition and situation of the battlefield and mentioned the various orders given. The witness b-lieved the fighting force of the Indians were from twenty-five hundred to three thousand warriors. They heard several volleys of from fifty to a hun dred shots each on the other side of the val ley at about the time the order was given, " every man to his horse."
See moreSee less
Reno's force, at that word, left the woods where they were stationed and in ten or fifteen minutes they 6a w Custer's command, or what he believed to be tbat command. He thought this force of one hundred and fifty men ought to have held the Indians in check some time. The witness's further testimony iclated to the finding of bodies, etc. Adjourned. The Case of Lteatenant-Uoveraor Hall,
The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · Wheeling, W. Va.
Scout F.F. Girard testified that Custer personally ordered Reno to advance and charge the Indians, contradicting Lieutenant Wallace's earlier testimony that the order came via Colonel Cook. Girard also corrected his earlier testimony about the exact time Reno's command began its retreat.
The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · 21 January 1879 · page 1
The Reno Trial. li Chicago, January 20.?In the Reno in8j luiry to-day, Maj. Reno and his counsel * isked leave to subpmna two more witn jesses, making twenty-six, viz: J. Scott T Jayno and Sergeant Delezey, of Company B Seventh Cavalry. The latter was presb >n on the battle-field under Reno at the w ime of the massacre. The Court reserved I-i he decision. tl The scout, F. F. Girard, continued his e< estiinony, and was cross examined by u Recorder Lee. The principal point made w vaa that Custer gave Reno the following ei trder when standing within a few feet n if him: si "Major Reno, you will advance and try o overtake the Indians, and when you do \* o, charge them.
See moreSee less
Take the seouU with S rou." ri This contradicts the testimony of Lientl enant Wallace, that the order was deliva (red by Colonel Cook. When the advance t\ vas made and the Indians began to troop <1 ipto meet Reno, theJatter checked his I: lorso and his command did the same, tl Witness then rode off to tell Custer about k ho approach of the Indians.' u Witness was closely questioned on this tl >oint and said after telling Col. Cook, tl vhom he met to bear this news to Custer, o 10 rode back to Reno's command and ado
At the Reno inquiry in Chicago, scout F.F. Girard testified under cross-examination about Custer's order to Reno and the sequence of events at Little Bighorn, contradicting Lt. Wallace's earlier testimony about who delivered the order. Girard also corrected his own prior testimony on timing, pushing back the start of the retreat by an hour, which was questioned sharply by the court.
The Cheyenne Daily Leader · 21 January 1879 · page 1
M Scout Girard's Testimony. Chicago, Jan. 20.—1 n the Reno in quiry to-day Maj. Reno and his coun sel asked leave to subpoena two more witnesses, making twenty-six in all, namely, J. Scott Payne, and Sergt. Deelsey of company I, Seventh cav alry. The latter was present on the ! battle field under Reno at tho time of the massacre. Court reserved its dei cision. The scout, F. F. Girard, continued his testimony and was cross-examined by Recorder Lee. Tho principal }H>int made was that Custer gave Reno the following order when standing within a few feet of him : “ Maj.
See moreSee less
Reno, you will advance and try to overtake the Indians, and wheu you do so charge them take the scouts with you.” This contradicts tho testimony of Lieut. Wallace, that the order was de livered by Col. Cook. When the ad vance was made and the Indians be gan to troop up to meet Reno, the lat ter checked his horse and his command l did the same. The same witness then rode off to tell Custer about the ap proach of the Indians. The witness was closely questioned on this point and said after telling Col. Cook, whom he met, to bear this news to Custer, he rode back to Reno’s command and ad vanced with them, but in the rear of the column. When he caught up the skirmish line was formed and the horses were in the timber in charge of the horse-holder. The men advanced at once and fighting began. About ten minutes later the retreat began, with the order, “ Men to their horses ! Tho Indians are in our rear I ” One of the captains gave the order and in a min ute the.men were ou thqir way across the rivei\ Girard made a correction in his tes timony as to the time when the comj mand began the retreat. Saturday he ! said ten minutes after 1 o’clock, no j now said ten minutes after 2. This j explained Reno’s delay of an hour in ! getting to Custer. Girard was sharply 1 interrogated concerning this change of ; ! testimony, and said he had yesterday i j refreshed his memory by reading old
Salt River Herald · Phoenix, Salt River Valley, Ariz.
A scout named Seward testified before the Reno inquiry, describing troop movements on the day of the Custer massacre and the battlefield conditions. He estimated Indian warrior strength at 2,500-3,000 and suggested a force of 150 men should have been able to hold them off for some time.
Salt River Herald · 22 January 1879 · page 4
The scout Seward, who testified to day . in the Reno inquiry, gave a lengthy account of the movements of the troops on the day of the Custer massacre. Hedescribed the condi tion and situation of the battle-field, and mentioned the various orders given. The witness believed the lighting force of the Indians was 2,500 to 3,000 warriors. They heard several volleys of from fifty to a hundred shots each on the other side of the village at alxnit the time the order was given, -'Every man to his horse. Reno's force at that word left the woods where they were stationed, and in ten or fifteen min utes they saw Custer's command, or what he believed to lc tliat command, lie thought that a force of 150 men onght to hare held the Indians in check some time.
See moreSee less
The witness' fur ther testimony related to the finding r the bodies, etc.
At the Reno Court of Inquiry in Chicago, witnesses Girard and Lieutenant Varnum testified about the battle of June 25-26, 1876, including Custer's reported shout questioning Reno's retreat from the timber. Varnum described the overwhelming Indian numbers and the exhausted, demoralized state of the troops during their retreat.
Daily Los Angeles Herald · 22 January 1879 · page 2
Journal. This is a defeat of exCollector Arthur. 'Tbe Beno inquiry. Chicago, Jan. 21st.—In the Rono Inquiry to-day, some time was con sumed iv debate between counsel as to whether the witness Glrard had Indian children and whether his testimony, on that account, was admissible. The latter issue was decided in tbe negative. Wit ness testified that Custer, on seeing Reno move away from the timber, shouted, "Who the mischief or dered out your command?" Lieutenaut Cavarnum, Qirter master of the Seventh Cavalry: On the 25th and 26th of June, 1876, he was a Second Lieutenant in com mand of tbe party of scouts under Custer.
See moreSee less
On the 26th he was de tached from tbe main body of troops, being away with the soouts. He did net know what troops were assigned to Reno, but he had about 120 men. He desoribed the uu neuvres of tbe forces. The Indians were in greater numbers than he had ever before seen. He recounted the advance and retreat of Reno much as Glrard had done. He said that the horses and men were greatly fatigued and the troops were badly demoralized on their retreat. Adjourned.
At the Reno Court of Inquiry in Chicago, interpreter Girard corrected earlier testimony about an Indian wife, then answered further cross-examination detailing where scout Charley Reynolds was killed and the distances marched by the Seventh Cavalry before the battle. Lieutenant Lee then began redirect examination on the command's movements that morning.
Chicago Daily Tribune · 22 January 1879 · page 3
A FEW MORE CROSS-QUESTIONS
Mr. Gilbert discovered that bo had a FBW MORE C11099-QOBSTION9 to put to the witness, ami In response to them Girard told Just where Charley Reynolds was killed. It wss at a point a little to the right of ami below *‘C,”thc right end of tho sklr misti-line, and Reynolds was killed In trying to Join Reno’s com mand on the retreat. Tbe mountain top to which Custer ascended on the morning of theSSlhwas about twelve or thirteen miles from the ford “ A.” The command moved up, while Custer was on the mountain top, but at whoso order witness did not know.
See moreSee less
He thought, when be went bacic to give Information about the Indians coming up the volley, that his com munication would have tho effect of hurrying Custer up and change his plans, If ho had any. Witness admitted having said that he expected Custer to come down nnd support Reno’s com msml. 110 might have said so, but he did not think he had done so very often; might have isld so to Col. E. W. Smith, of Geo. Terry’s staff. Mr. Gilbert asked tho witness If be had any Indian children. The Recorder objected to the question as be ing Intended to degrade the witness to public estimation, nnd as wholly Irrelevant. Mr. Gilbert gracefully withdrew the question, adding that ho simply wished to ascertain just b-jw Intimate the witness was with the Indians, In whoso country, according to Ids testimony, be had lived thirty-one years. [Smiles.] The witness slated. In response further to questions from Mr. Gilbert, Uic distance march ed by the Seventh Cavalry on the 22d, 23d, 34th. 25tb, and night of tho 25tb of June. Alto gether, from the point where they started on the 22d to tho ford “A,” the distance waa 107 miles. Witness admitted that bis horse, which he had testlflcd was fresh when the retreat was made from the Umber, was rather better thau the rust, and bad enjoyed better grazing. L.IBUT. LED
This report records courtroom testimony from the Reno Court of Inquiry, where interpreter Girard is cross-examined and redirected about troop movements, firing sounds, and distances during the June 1876 Little Bighorn campaign. Details include Custer's reaction to the command moving out and the timing and direction of gunfire near Reno's position.
Chicago Daily Tribune · 22 January 1879 · page 3
the rust, and bad enjoyed better grazing. L.IBUT. LED entered upon the redirect, asking Girard In ref erence to the command moving out that morn ing. The witness was Anally allowed to answer the question to which Mr. Gilbert had objected, end staled that when Custer was coming down the mountain, and saw the command moving out, he said: "Who the mischief moved out that command!" Meeting Tom Custer, the General asked him who had moved it out, and the reply was, "I don't Know. Orders were to match, and wo marched."
See moreSee less
When ho (witness) thought that Custer might recoil Keno, on re ceipt o! Information as to the Indiana coming no the vnllev, that was merely his supposition. The firing on tlho right bank, before Reno re-v treated, was scattering (or Alteon, twenty, or twenty-live minutes, when It became general, and continued so lor about two hour*. The sound of this firing came (rum down the river. In a northeasterly direc tion. Tho firing censed about dark, und before the general tiring around Reno's position began. The wind blow from the battle-field towards him, und bo remembered the circumstance from the fact that thu Indians had kindled a Are In the timber on the left hank.and the smoke came over in his direction. . . Witness was asked to state If be knoy why ho had been discharged from the position of Inter preter at Fort A. Lincoln by Maj. Keno.
At the Reno Court of Inquiry, scout Girard is questioned about whether a ford near the battlefield was crossable, and he describes the terrain as miry and unsuitable. Lieutenant Charles Varnum then begins testifying about troop movements and the separation of Reno's battalion from Custer's command on June 25, 1876.
Chicago Daily Tribune · 22 January 1879 · page 3
termaster CUAKLIS A. VAKMUM, of Uie Seventh Cavalry, serving at Fort A. Lin coln, D. T. On thu 23th and Sdlh of June, 1870, he testified, he was Second Lieutenant of Uie Seventh Cavalry, lu command of a detachment of Indian scouts, with the Seventh under Geo. Custer, In Uiu vicinity of the Little Big Horn. The command embraced twelve companies of the Seventh Cavalry and thu detachment of In dian scouts. Msj. Itcno was second lu com mand, uud thu operations were sgslust the hos tile Sioux. Witness was not with the com mand exactly on the morning of Uie 2!*th, hut was detached, scouting, and, from what the scouts said und the dust-clouds down the valley, bu saw what he supposed lu be me Indian village.
See moreSee less
He was not present when *the division of the command was made, and did not know the particulars except (rum what ap peared afterwards. Maj. Reno bad command of s separate battalion on the 85th. Just what command It was lie didn't know. He had, how ever, three companies, averaging about forty men each. Hu heard no orders given by Custer, or his Adjutant, to Reno that day, fur thu rru siin that lie passed nearly all the lime scouting with the Indians. Reno's battalion was passing Custer's when witness reported to Custer, at shouts mllo from the ford "A." Thu Reno huttttllun started on aiieud, aud be (ell lu with Uas it went uu, und Jollied thu head aa it funned uu the other side of the river. Ucui. Lee asked thu witness to describe tus UOVBUBMTB OB TUB TUKBB COMFAVIBS
At the official inquiry into Major Reno's conduct at Little Bighorn, Lieutenant C. A. Varnum testified about the positions of Custer and Reno during the battle. He described the advance and retreat, noting the horses and men were greatly fatigued and the troops demoralized during the retreat.
Chicago, Jan. 21. In the Reno inqui ry to-day, Lieut. C. A. Varnum, testified to the position of Custer and Reno on the day of the fight. He recounted the ad vance and retreat of Reno, much the same
Lieutenant Varnum testified that Reno took the best defensive position available after leaving the woods, though he lacked enough men to hold it fully. Varnum described seeing Custer's company moving along the bluffs around the time Reno's skirmish line formed, and recalled hearing distant firing downstream.
The Rock Island Argus · 22 January 1879 · page 1
retaries of legation. Dropped. lX.t.lK013 CniCAOO. Jan. 24. in the Ixeno mhavplauiry to-dav Lieut. Varnum, who was re called, testified he thought iieno toot the best possible position after he left the woods with his command, but there were hardly enough men to hold it. Heno, how ever, created a diversion in the Indian vil laee. The Indians must have attacked Custer about the time Ileno left the woods, . i . ..i. . . i t. . : o i out toe wuut3 niuuKiii iiiu luaiu iiuiiug force ot tne vniage was opposigg neno.
See moreSee less
tie saw uusters lirsy Horse company moving along the bluffs down lhe river, at about the time the bkermisn c formed; it was three quarters 1 1 i. I..... ii..i R..n.nnn ;..;nnri SWHy. nu uuui mici vn. ucmocii iuv;u Keno over the hill, and aoout the same time witness heard firing away down the 1 1 V .
A witness recounts hearing cavalry and seeing 'Grey Horse' troops, initially unsure if they were Custer's command or Indians near the village. The account reflects testimony likely from the Reno Court of Inquiry into the Little Bighorn disaster, held in early 1879.
The Rock Island Argus · 22 January 1879 · page 1
ha resumed work. I resiaent hnt thoucrhtit mieht be the Indians in the colliery U'HIVIJ a. V I McGowan promises the men their Piovem - village. When be saw the bray Horse caval ber and December wages in two weeitc, ry be thought Custer was making a and steady work for the remainder of the detour to strike the other end of the Indian winter. . . .village ihwramn. Jan. 22 A convention of foe Senator is
Testimony continued in the Reno inquiry in Chicago, with scout Girard concluding his account and Lieutenant Varnum describing the battle's chaotic retreat. Witnesses described being heavily outnumbered by Indians, demoralized troops, and Custer's reaction upon seeing Reno's command withdraw from the timber.
Daily Globe · 22 January 1879 · page 4
further examined to-morrow. I Western Associated Press. CHICAGO, Jan. 21.-In the Reno inquiry, to day, some time was consumed in debate be tween counsel as to whether the witness Girard had Indian ohildren, and whether testimony on that point was admissable. Th latter issue was decided in the negative. Witness testified that Custer, on seeing Reno mo ve away from the timber, shouted, "Who the mischief ordered out that command?" Lieut. 0 A. Varnum, quartermaster of the cavalry, testified that on the 25th and 26th of June, 1876, he was a second lieutenant in com mand of a party of scouts under Custer.
See moreSee less
On the 26th he was detached from the main troops. Bei ng away with the scouts he did not know what troops were assigned to Reno, but he had about 120 men. described the manceuvers of the forces. Th Indians were in greater numbers than he had ever before seen. re counted the advance and retreat of Reno much as Girard had done. Said the horses and men were greatly fatigned and the troops were bad ly demoralized on their retreat. Adjourned.
Lieutenant Varnum testifies at the Reno Court of Inquiry in Chicago, describing Reno's defensive position and the timing of the Indian attack on Custer's command. He recounts seeing Custer's gray horse company moving along the bluffs and hearing distant firing that he initially did not attribute to Custer's engagement.
Daily Press and Dakotaian · 22 January 1879 · page 1
THE RENO INQUIRY. LIEUT. VAKNUM's TESTIMONY. Chicago, Jan. 12—In the Reno inquiry, Lieut. Varnum testified that he thought Reno took the best possible position after he left the woods with his commaud, but there were hardly euoutih nun to hold it. Reno, however, created a diversion in the Indian village. The Indians must have attacked Custer about the time Reno left the wooda, hut witners thought the main fighting force of the village was opposing Reno. He saw Custer's gray horse company moving along the bluffs dawn the river at about tbe lime the skirmish line was formed. It was three-quarters of a mile away. An hour later Col. Utnlecn joined Reno over tbe bill, and at about the MOM time witae**
At the Reno Court of Inquiry in Chicago, scout F.F. Girard testified that Custer personally ordered Reno to advance and charge the Indians, contradicting Lieutenant Wallace's account that Colonel Cook delivered the order. Girard also corrected his earlier testimony on the retreat's timing, shifting it from 1:10 p.m. to 2:10 p.m. after reviewing old correspondence, which helped explain Reno's delay in reaching Custer.
Daily Press and Dakotaian · 22 January 1879 · page 2
THE RENO INVESTIGATION. Girard, the Scout, Continue* Hb Testi mony and Corrects a Former Statement. Chicago, Jan. 20.—In the Reno inquiry to-day, Major Reno and his counsel askeel leave to subpoena two more witnesses, ma king 26 in all, namely J. Scott Payne and Sergeant Delesey of company I,"Seventh cavalry. The latter was present on the bat tlefield under Reno at the time of the mas sacre. The court reserved decision. The scout F. F. Girard continued his tes timony,and was cross-examined by Recorder Lee. The principal point made was that Gen.
See moreSee less
Custer gave Bens the following order when standing within a few feet of him "Major Reno, you will advance and try to overtake the Indians, and when you do so charge them. Take the scouts with you.' This contradicts the testimony of Lieut. Wallace, that the order was delivered by
At the Reno inquiry in Chicago, witness Girard testified that Custer shouted in anger upon seeing Reno's command retreat from the timber. Lieutenant Varnum, who had been detached with scouts, described the overwhelming Indian numbers and the exhausted, demoralized state of the troops during Reno's retreat.
Memphis Daily Appeal · 22 January 1879 · page 1
The Custer Massacre Investigation. CniCAOo, January 19. In the Reno in quiry to day some time waa consumed in debate between counsel as to whether the witness Girard had Indian children, and whether testimony on that point was admisst ble. The latter issue was decided in the negative. Witness testified that Custer, on seeing Reno moving away from the timber. shouted: "Who the mischief ordered that command V Lieutenant C. A. Yarnum, quartermaster of the Seventh cavalry, testi fied that on the twentv-fifth and twentv-sixth of June, lTt), he was second lieutenant in command ol a party of scouts under Luster.
See moreSee less
On the twenty-sixth he wa3 detached from the mam body of troops. Being away with the scout?, he did not know what troops were assigned to Reno, but he had about one hun dred and twenty men. He described the maneuvers of the forces. Tne Indians were in greater numbers than he had ever before seen. He recounted tbe advance and retreat of Rano much as Gilbert had dene, and said the horses and men were grettiy fatitrued. The troops wera badly demoralized on their retreat. Adjourned.
Vermont Watchman and State Journal · Montpelier, Vt.
The editorial discusses the Cheyenne outbreak at Fort Robinson, attributing it to fear of removal to Indian Territory, and calls for reform of federal Indian policy. It references the Modoc War, Nez Perce War, and the Custer massacre as prior warnings that were ignored.
Vermont Watchman and State Journal · 22 January 1879 · page 2
Ulsgust. The llodoo war, the Ncz PerceJi war, the liorrible Custer massacre, and now this bloody work at Fort Hobinson are start llng rerainders, and the tlme has come when
The Chicago inquiry into Major Reno's conduct at Little Bighorn heard witness Girard recount Custer shouting at Reno's retreating command, and Lieutenant Varnum describe the battle's chaotic troop movements. Varnum testified the Indian forces were larger than any he had seen, and that Reno's men and horses were exhausted and demoralized during their retreat.
The Cheyenne Daily Leader · 22 January 1879 · page 1
ILLINOIS. Additional Testimony in the Reno Case Chicago, Jan. 21.—1 n the Reno in quiry to-day some time was consumed in a debate between counsel as to whether the witness Girard had Indian children, and whether the testimony on that was admissable. The latter issue was decided in the negative. The witness testified that Custer, on seeing Reno moving away from the timber, shouted “Who the mischief or dered out that command?” Lieut. C. A. Varnum, quartermaster of the Seventh cavalry, testified that on the 25th and 26th of June, 1876, he was a second lieutenant in the com mand of a party of scouts under Cus ter.
See moreSee less
On the 26th he was detach*! from the main troops, being away with the scouts. He didn’t know what troops were assigned to Reno, but he had about 120 men. He described the manoeuvres of the forces. The In dians were in greater numbers than he had ever before seen. He recounted the advance and retreat of Reno, much as Gilbert nad done, said the horses and men were greatly fatigued and the troops were badly demoralized on their retreat. Adjourned.
Lieutenant Vernum testified before the Reno inquiry that Reno took the best defensive position available after leaving the woods, though lacking sufficient men to hold it, and that his movement created a diversion in the Indian village. Vernum described seeing Custer's gray horse company moving along the bluffs about three-quarters of a mile away and hearing distant gunfire, though he could not be certain at the time it came from Custer's command.
Daily Los Angeles Herald · 23 January 1879 · page 1
Tbe Keno Inquiry. Chicago, Jan. 22.—1n the llano inquiry Lieutenant Vernum testi fied that he thought Reno took tbe best possible position after he left the woods with his command, but there wore hardly enough men to hold it. Reno, however, created a diversion iv the Indian village. The ludians must have attacked Custer abeul the time Reno left the woods, but witness thought the main lighting force of the vil lage was opposing Reno. He saw Custei'a gray horse company moving ulong the hind's down the river at about the timo tbe skir mish lineformed.
See moreSee less
It was throe quarters of a mile away. An hour later Col. Benton joined Reno over tbe hill and, at about the same time, witness heard firing away down the stream, but it was a crash—did not sound like a continuous engagement. At that time he did not think It came trom Custer, but thought it might he the Indians in tho village. When ho saw the gray horse cavalry he thought Custer was making a detour to strike tlie other end of the vil lage. Robbed ami .Ylnrdtircil hr Ui'l£ttu<lri. Belgrade, Jau. 22.—C01. Qola, station member of the Servian Boundary Commission, was robbed and murdered by Turkish brigands near Plevna. The Austrian aud Hungarian Government!) have arrived at an understanding in regard tn taking precautious against tho plague. Ilrnuta from n Poiaouou* Nitrliiir mid Uied.
Lieutenant Varnum testified that Reno's men faced fierce fighting and feared the Indian village might overwhelm them, with no clear sense of Custer's fate at the time. He stated Reno showed no remarkable bravery or cowardice, but there was confusion and haste as the command retreated from the woods.
Daily Los Angeles Herald · 23 January 1879 · page 2
The Rene Inquiry. Caicauo, Jan. 21. —Testimony of Lieut. Vemum continued: There was some pretty warm work about Reno's quarters, and for a time It seemed as if the whole Indian vil lage were about to advanceon him. Reno did not exhibit any remarka ble conduct either for bravery or coolness. There was considerable speculation among the Reno com mand regarding tlie whereabouts of Custer and whether he was In a predicament, too. Witness at that time had no idea that Custer had been slaughtered, but believed tbe Indians had driven him oil and were coming back on Reno.
See moreSee less
Had Reno gone forward with his com mand to assist Custer, he would have been obliged to go through tbe Indiau village, and witness did not believe that could have been done by either oommand. He did not care to answer the question as to whether tbe conduct of Reno at this battle was such as to inspire his men with courage, but finally said there was no cowardice In it. There was some little demoraliza tion and great haste in the method of Reno's force in getting out of the wood. Mother auti Child lteroseued.
The House Committee on Military Affairs received a War Department report showing that transportation costs for building Forts Keogh and Custer on the Little Big Horn River exceeded the original appropriation by $149,000. The committee plans to alert the Appropriations Committee and is preparing a report criticizing the excess disbursement.
The New York Herald · 23 January 1879 · page 3
EXPENDtTTOE FOR TRANSPORTATION. The IIouso Committee on Militiry Affairs has received an answer from tho War Department to the request for information is to the cost of building Forts Keogh and Custer, on tho Little Big Horn River. The original appropriation was $'J<N>,000, and the cost of transporting the supplies purchased was $149,000
This is testimony from the Reno Court of Inquiry, with Lieutenant Varnum describing Reno's retreat to the hilltop position and the timber fight, and recounting hearing heavy firing downstream believed to be Custer engaged with the Indians. He states soldiers had no idea Custer's men were wiped out, only suspecting he might be hemmed in.
The New York Herald · 23 January 1879 · page 10
Varnnm 'li<l not think, however, that when Itcno was on the liill his men wero in a condition to make an attack upon the Inliav.s that would divajt their attention. Die lest timo the witness saw Custer's -otnmand was when he caught sipht of the Gray dorse company which was with the General near the hill to which Reno had subsequently retreated. ' louerul Custer's eolutnu then seemed to ho moving '
A witness describes hearing heavy firing believed to be Custer's engagement, the long wait before Reno's main fight began, and the Indian attacks on Reno's position through the following day. He also recounts searching for and burying Custer's dead near Reno Hill before being questioned about Reno's leadership and courage under fire.
The New York Herald · 23 January 1879 · page 10
Wallace at the time; witness said to Wallace, "Just hear that!" The heavy volleys evidently came from where General Custer was, and then the witness believed the General was having a pretty warm time of it. This fir lug did not last a great while. The Lieutenant did not know personally whether there had been arranged a plan of a co-operation of the different divisions, but ho supposed such had been the case. From the time Major Reno first reached his position on tho hill two hours probably passed before his general ' ngiigement began with the wliolo force of the Indians.
See moreSee less
Reno was giving commands during the t.mc, as devolved upon the chief officer. The witness, when asked what was the solicitude of tho itfi'U lor Custer, replied that he himself ..JuuJ, .jjio _ ldoa that the Geueml. and. hiafmcn wet* cut Tn pieces. He thought, perhaps, that Caster might he hemmed in, as they were, or , had gone off to meet General Terry. This was the general opinion ot the men at the time. Kven after the Indians returned to them the thought did not oe tir to him that Custer was killed. THE INDIANS OJC THE OFFENSIVE.
Lieutenant Varnum testified at the Reno Court of Inquiry about the positions taken by Reno's command and the timing of firing heard toward Custer's position. He described seeing Custer's gray horse company moving along the bluffs and stated that Reno's conduct showed neither remarkable bravery nor coolness.
Evening Star · 23 January 1879 · page 1
In tdk Reno Inquiry yesterday Lieutenant Varnum testined that he thought Reno too* the best possible position after he left the w oods with his command, but there were hardly enough men to hold It. Reno, however, created a diversion In the Indian village. The Indians must have attacked Custer about the time Reno left the woods, but witness thought the main lighting force of the village was opposing Reno. He saw Custer's gray horse company moving alGng the bluffs down the rear about the time
A witness describes Reno's position in the timber, the movement of Custer's gray-horse column along the bluffs, and later finding dead bodies near a watering place. He also recounts hearing heavy, non-volley firing downstream after Benteen's arrival, suggesting Custer's fight was already underway.
Chicago Daily Tribune · 23 January 1879 · page 3
THE MAIN FIGHTING FORCE WAS THERE
the Reno Investigation was resumed yestcr a»y morning nt 11 o’clock, mid, otter the usual reidlne-over of Hie previous day’s testimony, Lieut. Vnrnum’o direct examination was iroln taken up, Lleal. Lee asking him to dcScribe Itcno's position on the hill, which he did , Bome length. The command, he sold, stopped when about half way up the hill, but ot whose enter he could not tell. When thu command stopped, MaJ. Reno—so witness thought— ■aid “This Is no place to form; better go to the too of the hill.” Being asked his opinion, as •n officer, with regard to Keno’a position * the left bank.—ln the Umber,— witness said be thought It was as rood as any on that side, but the three compa nies didn’t seem to ho able to cover (he entire oositlon that they must necessarily hold in order to keen the Indians out of Oie timber.
See moreSee less
In other words It didn’t seem to him that Reno had •nouc’h men In that position to hold the entire circle of the bottoms. Almdyof men like that would of course threaten any village so situated u was the Indian village In this coic, and a cer tain diversion on the part of the Indians was •err natural. He did not think the entire In dian force was attacking the command, clUicr In the timber or on the hill, but ho judged TUB MAtX FIOHTISO FORCB WAS TUBUS. ’ From Die top of the hill, the village was out of range, and no diversion could bo created as against the village for that reason. Being by Ucul. Leo If he had seen Custer’s column niter the division of the com mand, witness recollected that, when ho and Lieut, flair joined Reno’s skirmish-line, he turned his hcod over his shoulder, looked to the right, and saw on the edge of the blurts, on the opposite side ot the river, the “grav-horse ” (Custer’s)columu, moving down the stream. Ho last caught sight ot a portion of this column, but he could see them moving at a trot, Custer’s bone probably keeping up his well-known fast walk. The point where Custer’* column last wss, when ho saw It, must have been about tbrcc-ouartcrsof a mile from where Reno’s com mand then was on the aklrmlsh-Unc. In other words, It was near-hut a little further down ’ stream—to thepolntwhcrc Reno’seommand first rested on gaining the bluffs on thn opposite side after Ihe retreat. At the time Reno and Ben teen united on the hill, Custer must have been engaged In his fight. Witness was next asued as to finding the bodies, and told about having struck what ho supposed to be Custer’s trail, stopping at a watering-place to water his horse, seeing some bodies near by, and then being called awor bv Reno to put out the scouts. This point, where he saw the dead bodies, was about two miles from Reno’s position on the hill, two or three of the Intervening points being higher than the latter position. Shortly after Benlccn enmo up witness heard firing away down the stream, nml spoke of It to Lieut. Wallace. The firing was not like a volley. It was u heavy lire, “a sonr op a crash, crash, crash,” and yet not In the lorm ot a volley. Ho heard it only a few moments. It evidently came from the vicinity of the oilier end of the village where Cusler’a men were afterwards found, but whether It came from Custer's command or from the In dians he could not say. Ills Impression at the lime was that Custer was having a pretty hard time ot It down there. When ho saw the “gray horse” command going along the blurts, ho Iro meillatcly supposed that U was going down to attack the oUut end of the village, but, having arrived from Ids scouting tour justat the time ol the separation of Reno from Custer, ho heard no orders, nml could only imagine what the plans M-erc. From the titnc tunt. Reno got up on the hill until the tvhulu body of Indians, os It ao pmml, attacked Idm in that position, and a general engagement e nsued, might have been on hour and a half or two hours, but on points of time tie wouldn’t pretend to bo accurate. Witness was In position to hear Rcuo give or ders on the hill only once, uml that was when Inand Weir returned from the far point where Weir had been lighting the Indians. As they came up, Reno said he hail selected a site' further up the river to make a stand on. W li ners was riding around a good deal, mid must have seen Reno more or leas, without being particularly drawn towards him. Lieut. Leo asked II there was any feel ing of uneasiness among Reno’s nml lienteen’s commands os to Custer's late, and the reply was that both commands wondered where he was, hut nobody supposed that ho had been used up. The Idea of Custer nml his command being killed never entered hla mind at all, and when the Indians returned ho thought that they had driven Custer oil at the other end of the village nml had come back to give Rcuo another dose. In other words, he didn't think (here was any doubt hut that the mass of Indians who had attacked Rcuo on the skirmish-lino ulterward went up to thu village, engaged In the light with Custer, drove him off, and then turned buck to attack Reno on the hill, flo heard no orders given by Reno on Ihcnlchtof the iltluuml wont to bed about U o’clock thoroughly exhausted. The next morn ing witness went over and lay in the trench with Cant. French, where they kept up a “give and take” fire for some time. In the afternoon he tried to eel a dispatch out of the lines, and Reno, nt ms request, wrote out four notes to be taken out, out the Indians didn’t get beyond U *At to the wounded on the night of the 25th, witness couldn’t say. The command that night
At a military court in Chicago, Lieut. Varnum testified about the Custer massacre, stating that Custer must have known Reno's command was engaged with a large force of 4,000-5,000 Indians. Varnum stated he believed Reno was justified in using his own judgment to withdraw given the overwhelming odds.
The Rock Island Argus · 23 January 1879 · page 1
Military Conrt. Chicago, Jan. 23. Lieut. Varnum was cross examined this morning regarding the Custer massacre and testified that the Gray Horse cavalrv. which he had men tioned, must have seen that Reno's corn mand was entering an engagement with the Indians, and Custer must also have known that they were at bay. Tn witness judgment any careful commander would have inquired into the situation of the troops irora which he expected support. There was no misunderstanding between Custer and Reno previous to this time. The ndians were probably not less than four or bye thousand stmnonrl i-ulf tht force was too great for half the whole com mand. U5 thought Reno wan riohf in using his own judgment in getting out of IUC wuuus. Fires.
This report details cross-examination testimony from Lieutenant Wallace before the Reno Court of Inquiry investigating Major Reno's conduct at the Little Bighorn. It covers troop movements, the retreat, casualties, and the eventual discovery of Custer's fate on the 27th.
The Leavenworth Weekly Times · 23 January 1879 · page 6
LIEUT. WALLACE WAS CROl EXAMINED) by Major Reno's conn-sel, Mr. Gilbert. The testimony was only a development of that given yesterday. He related how. after the division of Cu-ttr's command, Col. Bentien went to the left. Major Reno crossed the stream and General Custer remained on the right bank; how the two latter detach mcnU formed a junction by Reno recn-ving about twelve miles below and how finally the battle was fought. Some of Majir lteno's commind hail n-ver ridden a horse until this cimpaign. ihe only ammuni tion in tie hands of Reno's force was the supply at their saddles. It Has u-ed tin in halt an hour. In his opinion it wis a ii-e act of Major Reno to retreat and to have remained would have been to
Testimony before the 1879 Reno Court of Inquiry describes how Reno's besieged troops first learned of Custer's fate on June 27, after discovering the battle line and the pile of dead around Custer's position. The court also ruled it would not investigate Benteen's conduct in the affair.
The Leavenworth Weekly Times · 23 January 1879 · page 6
THEY FIRST KNEW OF CUSTEIi's FATE on the 27lh. The discovered the line of battle, jierftctly iviilent from the dead horses and cnrines. The position was not well chosen fur defence. Around Custer wis a whole pile of men. There had p parently been an attempt at escape. The tight prolnbly lid not last over hilf an hour. Cu-ter had three hundred and twen ty five men when he sepirated frcm Keno.
A witness (Varnum) testifies at the Reno Court of Inquiry about the chaotic fighting near Reno's position and uncertainty over Custer's fate during the battle. He states he saw no cowardice in Reno's conduct, though there was haste and some disorder as the command retreated from the woods.
Daily Globe · 23 January 1879 · page 1
VARNUM'S VOICE
Witness said there was some pretty warm work about Reno's quarters, and for a time it seemed as though the whole Indian village were about to advance on him. Reno did not exhibit any remaiKable conduct either for bravery or coolness. There was considerable speculation among the Reno command regard ing the whereabouts of Custer and whether he was in a predicament, too. Witness at that time had no idea that Custer had been slaughtered, but believed the Indians had driven him off and were coming back on Reno. Had Reno gone forward with his com mand to assist Custer, he would have been cfllUged to go through the village, and witness did not be ieve that could have been done by either command.
See moreSee less
He did not care to answer the question whether the conduct of Reno at the battle was such as to inspire his men with courage, but finally said there was no cowardice in it. There was some little demoralization and great haste in the method of Reno's force in getting out of the woods. Adjourned.
Lieutenant Varnum testified before the Reno inquiry that Custer must have been engaged with Indians when Benteen joined Reno's forces on the hill, and that firing from Custer's direction was heard around that time. Varnum stated he did not initially believe Custer's command had been wiped out, and that Reno's command could not have reached Custer without passing through the Indian village.
Daily Globe · 23 January 1879 · page 1
Declare Reno a Brave and Wise CommanderSome New Light Poured in Upon the Little Big Horn Massacre. [Special Telegram to the Globe. CHICAGO, Jan. 22.Some of the most inter esting testimony in the Reno inquiry was elicited to-day from Lieut. C. A. Varnum, of the Seventn cavalry. In his opinion Custer must have been at the point where he engaged the Indians when Benteen joined Reno on the hill. It was not until this time that firing was heard down tho stream in Custer's direction. He was impressed that Custer must have been having a pretty warm time of it.
See moreSee less
The recorder of the court pressed the witness pretty closely as to Major Reno's deportment, asking whether he appeared to be commanding his men as though in lhe presence of great dan ger, or how. The witness replied that Major Reno certainly was commanding his men, out re garding his conduct the witness did not know as there was anything rn it that especially attracted his attention so that he should remember it, nor was there any uneasiness in the command regarding the whereabouts of Custer. The witness r'plied that there was of course won dering as to where he was, whether he had got into a predicament too. Regarding his own impressions the witi ess said that it never en tered his mind that Custer had been slaughter ed. notion was when the Indians began to come up stream that now having driven Custer off they were coming back to tackle Reno's command. If Reno had gone forward to assist Custer his command uld have had to go through the village and this the witness did not believe either command could have done. There was quite a large force, probably several hundred Indians, within 500 yards of Reno's command when it retreated from the timber. Now stae to the court, said the recorder, what was the conduct of Major Reno at the battle ot the Little Big Horn? Was it such as to inspire his men with couiage or the reverse? The witness intimated that he did not care to answer the question. He was informed he would have to answer the question, and no ob jection being made by either Reno or the court, the witness said that so far as his observation went theie was nothing in Reno's conduct that day that indicated cowardice, When asked what was the feeling in Reno's command on reaching the hill after the re treat, the witness replied he could only speak for himself. He felt as though he had been pretty badly licked. [Western Associated Press.]
The Reno Court of Inquiry in Chicago heard testimony from Lieutenant George D. Wallace defending Major Reno's conduct at Little Bighorn, including details on the division of Custer's command and the subsequent battle. Wallace testified that Reno's retreat was a wise and necessary decision, and that Reno behaved bravely throughout the engagement.
Helena Weekly Herald · 23 January 1879 · page 5
Custer's forces. He says General Reno's forces, when they came upon the scene, were exhausted through swift marching, and when they met the Indians were overmatched for the time and compelled to retreat.
The report details testimony from the Reno Court of Inquiry, describing Reno's retreat, the defensive stand on the hilltop, and the eventual discovery of Custer's fate on the 27th. It also includes an unrelated note about a new Army bill being drafted by Gen. Garfield.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
Helena Weekly Herald · 23 January 1879 · page 5
Chicago, January 16.—The Reno court of of in inquiry to-day decided that the reporters might take notes. Lieut. Wallace was cross-examined by Maj. Reno's counsel, Mr. Gilbert. The testimony was only a development of that given yester day. He related how, after the division of Custer's command, Col. Benteen, to the left of Major Reno, crossed the stream and General Caster remained on the right bank ; how the two latter detachments formed a junction by Reno recrossing about 12 miles below, and how, finally, the battle was fought. Some of Major Reno's command had never ridden a horse until this campaign.
See moreSee less
The only ammu nition in the hands of Reno's force was the supplies at their saddles. It was used up in half an hour. In his opinion it was a wise act of Major Reno to retreat, and to have re mained would have been to imperil the lives of the whole body. Major Reno's conduct was brave and praiseworthy. During the retreat 25 men were killed and 7 wounded, and the time consumed was about an hour. When he arrived on lop of the hill Benteen's force came up, but the pack train was three miles to the rear. Reno showed no signs of fear all this time, but was conspicuously brave and fearless. No communication had been received from Custer, but a trumpeter 6tated that he (Custer) had gone back. The ammunition was distributed, and company D first met the Indians, several thousand strong, in a ravine of fine advantages, where the men were properly posted by Reno. He had about 280 men under his command at that time. Bullets came like hail until dark, about three hours, when fortifications were thrown up. up. Firing was recommenced about 3 a. m. on on the 26th and continued until 10 o'clock, when it slackened. There were probably nine thousand Indian warriors in the village that evening, it being 2£ or 3 miles long. They first knew of Custer's fate on the 27th, and discovered the line of battle, perfectly evident from the dead horses and corpses. The position was not well chosen for defense. Around Custer was a whole pile of men, and there apparently had been an attempt at es es cape. The fight probably did not last over half an hour. Custer had 325 men when he he separated from Reno. The court decided this afternoon that it it will not investigate the conduct of Benteen, whose name has been associated with Reno in this matter. Adjourned. Chicago, January 17.—More testimony favorable to Major Reno was given this morning by Lieut. Wallace, and by the tarn ous scout, Grouard. Th« New Army Bill Chicago, January 17. —The Tribune's Washington special says: Gen. Garfield has prepared a substitute for the Army bill which has received the approval of officers repre senting the several branches of the service. It has merits of brevity, containing only six sections : The substance of these is as fol lows: 1st. Directions of the Secretary of War to the army shall be deemed to be orders of the President and shall be respected and obeyed accordingly. 2nd. The General commanding the army shall have the assistance of all the staff corps of the army to enable him to be informed at all times of materials and supplies on baud and the condition of appropriations for various military purposes. 3rd. The President shall perfect a plan by which all officers of the line below Major except the medical corps shall be transferred from one arm of the service to another, so that every officer shall have experience in each branch, the promotion in all cases to be* by seniority, except where a board pronoun ces an officer unfit lor advancement. 4th. The army to consist of 25,000 men of 34 regiments—20 infantry, 10 cavalry and 4 artillery—and the President is authorized to distribute men to complete the organization. 5th. All officers who by long and faithful service are entitled to be retired may elect to leave the army absolutely, taking one year's pay of their grade for every five years ser vice, or they may be retired as at present. The sixth section is the repealing of con flicting laws. T he bill does not reduce either
Scout F.F. Girard testifies at the Reno Court of Inquiry in Chicago about troop movements and orders on the day of Custer's last battle, estimating Indian forces at 2,500-3,000 warriors. His account of Custer's order to Reno conflicts with Lieutenant Wallace's earlier testimony about who delivered the command.
Helena Weekly Herald · 23 January 1879 · page 7
THE RENO INQUIRY.
The words of this article could not be separated from the rest of its page. Read it in the clipping.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
Helena Weekly Herald · Helena, Mont.
At the Reno Court of Inquiry in Chicago, scout F. F. Girard testified that Custer personally ordered Reno to advance and charge the Indians, contradicting Lieutenant Wallace's earlier testimony that the order came via Col. Cook. Girard also revised his earlier timeline of the retreat from the timber by an hour, and further witnesses including Lieut. Varnum were called to testify.
Helena Weekly Herald · 23 January 1879 · page 7
Custer gave Reno the following order when standing within a few feet of him : "Major Reno will advance and try to overtake the Indians, and when you do so charge them. Take the scouts with you.", This contradicts the testimony of Lieut. Wallace—that the order was delivered by Col. Cook. When the advance was made and the Indians began to troop up to meet Reno, the latter checked his horse and his command did the same. Witness then rode to tell Custer about the ap proach of tbe Indians. Witness was closely questioned on this point, and said, after tell ing Col.
See moreSee less
Cook, whom he met, to bear thi9 news to Custer, he rode back to Reno's com mand and advanced with them, but in the rear of the column. When he caught up the skirmish line was formed and the horses were in the timber in charge of the horse-holders. The men advanced at once and the fighting began. About ten minutes later the retreat began, with the order, "Men to their horses; the Indians are in our rear." One of the Captains gave the order, and iu a minute the men were on their way across the river Girard made a correction in his testimony as to the time when the command began the re treat. On Saturday he said ten minutes after 1. He now said ten minutes after 2. This explains Reno's delay of an hour in getting to Custer. Girard was sharply interrogated concerning this change of testimony, and said he had yesterday refreshed his memory by reading an old correspondence on tbe point. He believed his memory had not failed on the other points. It was not an act of cow ardice for Reno's troops to move out of the timber, but he believed they would have been safer to remain. The court here adjourned, it being announ ced that Major Reno might summons tbe two witnesses he desired.
The report states that Gen. Reno's conduct during the Custer massacre is being investigated by a military court, and based on testimony, the writer concludes Reno did not show cowardice. The piece attributes the fatal error to Custer himself for dividing his command and underestimating the enemy's strength.
Nebraska Advertiser · 23 January 1879 · page 2
Gen. Reno's conduct at the time of the Custer massacre is now being In vestigated by a military court. From reading the testimony we do not think the General showed cowardice. It was all he could do to save bis com mand from a like fate. The fatal mis take made at that battle was made by General Custer himself, in dividing hta command, an over estimate of the prowess of himself and men, and a lack of knowledge of the strength of the enemy. On the 17th inst. the Republicans of the Illinois legislature nominated Gen.
See moreSee less
John A. Logan for United States pnator, and theRepublicans of ev ery Stats rejoiced at the good news. His vote was 80 while Senator Ogiesby received 26. Now nothingbut the direst treason in the Republican ranks
At the Reno Court of Inquiry in Chicago, witness Varnum testified about troop positions during the Little Bighorn battle, describing Reno's retreat to high ground and uncertain sounds of gunfire downstream. Varnum stated he believed the main Indian force opposed Reno rather than Custer, and initially thought Custer might be flanking the village rather than engaging in heavy combat.
Morning Appeal · 23 January 1879 · page 2
Chicago, Jan. 22. Iu the Reno inquiry last night vYarnum testified that after Reno left the woods with his command he took the best possible position he could, but there were hardly enough to hold of it. The Indians attacked Custer as Reno left the woods, but witness thought the main fighting force of the village was opposing Reno. An hour later Benteen joined Reno over the hill, and at the same time witness heard firing away down the stream, but it didn't sound like a continuous engagement. He didn t think it was Custer, but the Indians at the village.
See moreSee less
When he saw the cavalry he thought Custer was making a detour to strike the other end of the village. Kingston, Unt. , Jan. 22. 1 nomas John son's bakery and dwelling burned to-day. His two little daughters perished. The Tybo Sun, says that "some of tha pa pers, pretending to De interested in Air. Chartz's behalf, are using him for a handle to attack the Sentinel, when they should be con scious that they are doing him a thousand times more injury than if they let him alone. It's a mighty poor way to get a man out of State s prison abusing everybody who thinks differently. Just yon cheese your racket, some of you.
Lieutenant Charles De Rudio of the Seventh Cavalry, known to be hostile to Custer, is reported to have said Major Reno made a fatal mistake retreating from the woods during the Custer massacre. De Rudio claimed he saw Custer look down at Reno's position moments before Reno's retreat, then vanish behind the bluffs toward the lower village, suggesting Custer expected Reno to hold his ground.
Eureka Daily Sentinel · 23 January 1879 · page 2
#»y» hostile to' General Custer, recently expressed the opinion that Major Iteno shade a fatal' mistake when he retreated from the wood, at the Cnster massacre. Jnat alow minutes betore Iteno stampeded, De Radio saw Custer look down on him ahd then disappear behind the bluffs for the lower village. He says Custer must
Witness Varnum testified that Reno took a reasonable defensive position after leaving the woods, though his force was too small to hold it well, and that Reno's stand diverted a major portion of the Indian force. Varnum said he saw what he believed was Custer's gray horse company moving along the bluffs, heard distant firing he did not recognize as sustained combat, and did not realize at the time that Custer's command had been destroyed.
Eureka Daily Sentinel · 23 January 1879 · page 2
The Testimony of Mr. Vnrnum. Chicago, January 22. In the Reuo inquiry last night, Mr. Varnnm testified that he thought Reno took the best possible position after he left the woods with his command, but there were hardly enough men to hold it. Reno, however, created a division in the Indian village. The Indians must have attacked Custer about the time Reno left the woods, but the witness thought the main fighting force of, the village was opposing Re«*o. He saw Custer’s gray horse company mov ing along the bluffs down the river at about the time the skirmishing line was formed.
See moreSee less
It was three fourths of a mile away an hour later. Colonel Renton joined Reno over the likU, and at about the same time witness heard firing away down the Stream, but it was a trash, and did not not sound like a continuous engagement. At that time he did not think it came from j Custer, but thought it might bo the In-, j diaus in the village. When he aaw the gray horse eavalry he thought Custer was making a detour to strike the other end of the village. Witness said there was some pretty warm work about Reno’s quarters, and for a time it seemed as though the whole Indian village were about to advance on him. Reno did not exhibit any re markable conduct either for bravery or coolness. There was considerable specula tion among the Reno command Regarding the whereabouts of Custer, and whether he was in a predicament too. Witness at that time had no idea that Custer had been slaughtered, but believed the Indians hail driven him off, and were coming back on Reno. Had Reno gone forward with his command to assist Custer, he would have been obliged to go through the Indian vil lage, and witness did not believe that it could have been done by either command. He did not care to answer the question whether the conduct of Reno, at this bat tle, was such as to inspire his men with courage, but finally said there was no cow ardice ih it. There was some little de moralization and great haste in the men and that of Reno’s force in getting out of the woods. Adjourned.
Scout Girard testified before the Reno Inquiry about troop movements on the day of the Custer massacre, describing the battlefield and orders given. He estimated the Indian force at 2,500 to 3,000 warriors and recounted hearing volleys of gunfire before Reno's men saw what they believed was Custer's command.
The Stark County Democrat · 23 January 1879 · page 1
The scout, GIrard, testified on Saturday before tbe Reno Inquiry, giving a lengthy account of tbe movements of troops on the day of the Custer massacre, describing tbe condition and situation or the battle field and mentioning tbe various or ders given. The witness believed the fighting force of the Indians was 2.600 to 8,000 warriors. They heard several volleys of from 50 to a lot) shout each on ihe other side of the village at about the time tbe order was given, "Every man to bis horse I" Reno's force at that word left the wood where tbey were stationed, and In 10 or 15 min utes they saw Custer's command, or what he be lieved to be that command.
See moreSee less
He thought the force of 160 men ongbt to have held the Indians In check some time. The new steel works at .Swansea. Kntluiif will be lighted with theelectrlo light. The principal street in Poole, Esgland, has been satisfactorily lighted with It, NEWS OF THE WEEK. Norwich, Conn,, Jan, 17. Mrs. Cobb, adjudged a guilty or poisoning her husband, has been sen fenced to Imprisonment for life.
Lieutenant Varnum was cross-examined at the Reno inquiry about the Custer massacre, testifying that Custer should have known Reno's command was engaged with a large force of 4,000-5,000 Indians. He stated there was no misunderstanding between Custer and Reno beforehand, and defended Reno's decision to retreat to the woods.
Daily Press and Dakotaian · 23 January 1879 · page 1
THE RENO INQUIRY. VAUNUM'8 STATEMENT. Chicago, Jan. 23.—IA Veiuum w&scross examined ill's morning regarding the Cus ter ma!3acre, nnd testified that the gray hor-se cavalry which he had mentioned muet bave Been that Reno's command wat entering engagement with the Indians, and Custer must also have known J.hat they were at bay, and in wilneu' judgment any careful commander would have inquire-1 in to the situation of the troops from which he expected support. There wes no misun derstanding between Custer and Reno pre vious to this time. The Indians were prob ably not less than 4,000 to 5,000 Blrong and half of that force wan too great for half the whole command. He thought Reno was right in using his own judgment in getting to the woods.
Lieutenant Varnum described Reno's defensive position after leaving the timber, noting it was undermanned but created a diversion. He recounted seeing what he believed was Custer's gray horse on the bluffs, hearing distant firing he didn't initially attribute to Custer, and stated there was no cowardice in Reno's conduct despite declining to say it inspired courage.
Memphis Daily Appeal · 23 January 1879 · page 1
More of the Reno Investigation. CercAoo, January 22. In the Rno in vestivation Lieutenant Varoum testified that he thought Reno took the best possible posi tion alter he left the wood with his com mand, but there were hardly enough mn to hold it. Reno, however, created a diversion in the Indian village. The Indians mutt have attacked Custer about the time li?no left the woods, but witness thought that the main fightinsr force of the village was oppos ing Reno. He saw Custer's gray horse mov ing along the bluffs down the river at about the time tb skirmish linn was foimed.
See moreSee less
it was three-quarters of a mile away. An hour later Colonel Benton joined Reno over the bill, and at about tbe same time witness heard firing away down the stream, but it was a crash and didn't sound like a continu ous engagement. At that time he didn't think it came from Custer, but thousrht it might be the Indians in the village. When he saw the gray horse of tbe cavalry he thought Custer was making a detour to strike the other end of the village. The witness said there was ome pretty warm work about R?no's quarters, and for some time it seemed as though the whole In dian village was about to advance on Lim; Reno did not exhibit any remarkable con duct either for bravery or coolness; there was considerable speculation among the Reno command regarding the whereabouts of Cus ter, and whether he was in a predicament too; witness at that time had no idea that Custer had been slaughtered, but believed the Indi ans had driven him off, and were coming back on Reno; had Reno gone forward with his command to assist Custer he would have been obliged to go through the Indian vil lage, and witness does not believe that could have been done by either command. He did not care to answer the question as to waetber the conduct of Reno at this battle was suc'a as to inspire his men with courage, but finally said there was no cowardice in it; there was some little demoralization and great haste in the method of Reno's force in getting out of the woods. Adjourned.
Lieutenant Varnum testified before the Reno inquiry that Major Reno took the best available position but lacked sufficient men to hold it, and that Reno's diversion in the village may have drawn Indian forces while Custer was attacked separately. Varnum described uncertainty among Reno's men about Custer's fate and said Reno's conduct showed neither remarkable bravery nor cowardice.
The Cheyenne Daily Leader · 23 January 1879 · page 1
V ILLINOISV I More Reno Testimony. f Chicago, Jan. 22.—1 n the Reno int inquiry Lieut. Varnum testified that \ he thought Maj. Reno took the best i possible position, after ho left i the woods with his command, but there t were hardly enough men to hold it. ; t Reno, however, created a diversion in i the Indian village. The Indians must c have attacked Custer about the time f Reno left the woods, but the witness f thought the main fighting force of the a village was opposing Reno.
See moreSee less
He saw t Custer’s gray horse company moving i along the bluffs down the river at about t the time the skirmish line was formed. \ It was three-quarters of a mile away, i An hour later Col. Benteen joined t Reno over the hill* and at about the same time the witness heard firing a away down the stream, but it was a c crash; did not sound like a continuous ! J engagement; at that time he did j ] not think it came from Custer, but C thought it might be the Indians in the £ village. When he saw the gray horse ( cavalry he thought Custer was making a detour to strike the other end of the Indian village. Witness said there was i some pretty warm work about Reno’s [ quarters, and for a time it seemed as ] though the whole Indian village was about to advance on him. Reno did not exhibit any remarkable conduct either for bravery or coolness. There was considerable speculation among the Reno command regarding the wheret about sos Custer, and whether he was , in a predicament too. Witness at that * time had no idea that Custer had been , slaughtered, but believed the Indians had driven him off and were coming back on Reno. Had Reno gone for ward with his command to assist Cus ter he would have been obliged to go through the Indian village, and the witness did not believe that could have been done by either command. lie did not care to answer the question whether the conduct of Reno at this battle was such as to inspire his men with cour age, but finally said there was no cow ardice in it. There was some little de moralization and great haste in the method of Reno’s force in getting out of the woods. Adjourned.
The True Northerner · Paw Paw, Mich. · and 1 other paper
A correspondent at Omaha recounts how the Black Hills were invaded and treaties broken, leading to the Sioux War in which Custer and much of the Seventh Cavalry were killed. The report then traces how Sitting Bull's captured followers and other Sioux and Cheyenne were sent to Fort Reno, where unmet government promises of rations and farming aid set the stage for desperation.
The True Northerner · 24 January 1879 · page 6
Bull resisted this demand, and the bloody war that followed cost us Custer and the flower of the Seventh cavalry. A part of Sitting Bull's band, captured
The Kenosha Telegraph · Kenosha, Wis. · 23 January 1879
The New York Herald · New York, N.Y.
Lieutenant Charles Varnum testified before the Reno Inquiry in Chicago, describing troop positions, timing, and his belief that Custer could have seen Reno's men under attack. He argued the lack of bodies near the ford suggested no major fight occurred there.
The New York Herald · 24 January 1879 · page 3
RENO'S RETREAT.
appear to him to be accurate, and he could only ap. proximate it. Ho next repeated tho time, place and circumstances under which he last saw General Custer, all of which is familiar to the readers of the Herald, and once more traversed the banks of the river to point out the place where he saw the famous gray horse company. He thought it would tako about half au hour for Ouster's column to go from the point where ho Haw the gray horse coin jmuy 10 iuf watering piaco ?, iuu puiui.
See moreSee less
nudi^ Custer attempted to cross to the Indian village. He thought that as it was about halt an hour from the deploying of IU'tio'a skirmish line to the time when the retreat began Custer must have had time to gut to the ford and become engaged with the Iudiaus in the interval. Ho believed Custer must have known, for he must have seen what lleno'a men wuro doing; at least, the gray horse company woe in a position to see what llcno's ineu in the timber were doing.
Lieutenant Varnum testifies about Reno's force being too small to hold the timber position and uncertainty about Custer's fate, followed by Dr. Porter's testimony on Reno receiving Custer's order to charge. The testimony examines command communications and whether reinforcements were expected during the battle.
The New York Herald · 24 January 1879 · page 3
had on this score, but he himself knew that General Terry was then probably on his way down the Yellowstone oifup the Little liig Horn; ho had no conception at the time that General Custer's men had ull been killed; ho could not say what the rest of the command might have thought, but it was his idea at the time that cither Custer's men had bcenfoorrallcd like Keno's, or had gotten down to.ward General Terry. KKKO'S LETTER TO TKRBY.
A resolution by Delegate Corlett to have the House Military Committee investigate the Custer massacre will be favorably reported, but there is not enough time left in the session to conduct the investigation. The report notes a separate, more limited inquiry—the Reno court of inquiry—is already underway in Chicago.
The New York Herald · 24 January 1879 · page 4
THE CUSTER MASSACRE—A CONTEMPLATED INVESTIGATION PREVENTED BY THE PRESS OF BUSINESS.
The resolution offered by Delegate Corlett at the ' > last session, instructing the House Military Committee to investigate the Custer massacre, aud which was
At the Newsboy's Lodging House, Major Philip Schuyler described his time near Laramie Peak and Sioux customs, including the valuation of women by ponies and burial practices. He exhibited Indian weapons and moccasins, some said to have been used in the Custer massacre.
New-York Tribune · 24 January 1879 · page 8
INDIAN LIFE AND CUSTOMS
on fu se fold, but always wrap them in a green blanket, Major Schavier exhibited Indian weapons, some of which were used in the Custer massacre, ana also articles of domest.e nse, Meocasons belonging to the Sioux,
Lieutenant Varnum testifies about troop positions and timing during the Little Bighorn battle, under cross-examination by Reno's counsel. He describes the skirmish line location, his sighting of Custer's column, and estimates of movement timing relative to the ford.
Chicago Daily Tribune · 24 January 1879 · page 3
Mr. Gilbert, MaJ. Reno's counsel, set out upon THE CROSS-EXAMINATION, first asking that witness as to the exact location of the skirmish-lino on the map. Lieut. Var num replied that bo didn't believe the map to bo absolutely correct, but, on tbe assumption that It represented the open space In the timber correctly, the point on the skirmish-line where tho men deployed was about opposite the cen tre of that open space. According to this, tho sklrmisb-Uue woula bo perpendicular to tho open space, and nearer the Indian village than Ills represented on the map.
See moreSee less
It was from this point on the skfrmtsh-llne that witness saw tbe “ gray-horse " column. Being asked to fix the point where Custer’s column was when he caught that glimpse of it, the wit ness said It was on the other side, In tho direc tion of the skirmish-lino prolonged, and about a quarter of a mile below the point where Reno struck the bluffs after bis retreat. The column was moving, bo thought, at a trot, Custer's lost-walking horse leading tho rest and keeping them (a a trot. During the fight witness did not tell Reno that he had seen the " gray horse " column on the opposite side. The fact that Reno used a gun in the fight In the timber was nothing to bo wondered at, as none of the officers went into that fight with satires. Being asked as to the probable time required for the " gray-borse ” column to pass from tbe point oo the bluffs to tbe lower ford " B,” wit ness replied that, assuming Ids distances ami the column's rate of speed as correct.lt must have taken In tho neighborhood of thirty-five minutes.' While tho banks were steep it “B,” and crossing was not verv pleasant, yet a col umn could get down, and It could ascend the opposite bank about as easily. Mr. Gilbert—Before the Indians commenced to leave Reno, tho column uuder Lteut.-Col. Custer would nave bad time to reach thu ford “ B,” would It not! Lieut. Varnum—l think those are about the relative positions. Continuing, witness said Custer was moving down on the right bank, and might have seen Reno's men for a lime. Al thu time Reno's command were dismounted Caster must have been lo a position to BSE WHAT TUET WIRE DOING.
Lieutenant Varnum testifies at the Reno Court of Inquiry about troop movements, timing, and distances near ford 'B', stating Custer likely saw Reno's command from the bluffs before the fighting intensified. He discusses the lack of communication between Reno and Custer, the absence of evidence of a determined crossing attempt at the ford, and his own failure to inform Reno when he heard firing from Custer's direction.
Chicago Daily Tribune · 24 January 1879 · page 3
SEE WHAT THEY WERE DOING
been lo a position to BSE WHAT TUET WIRE DOING. Ab far as bo knew, there was no communica tion between Reno and Custer at the time. Cuslcr, bo thought, must Imvo reached tho ford “ b,” jf ho attempted to cross at all* with the belief that Reno was nut charging, but standing there at bay before these Indians. He thought Custer would have been watching the proceed ings oi the fight from the point on the bluff. If Custer saw Reno’s men from this point,—and witness had no doubt ol It,—that must have been the last information Custer got concern ing Reno’s command.
See moreSee less
If there had been any evidences of a determined effort to cross at “ B."—lf there hid been much of a light,—there would have been dead bodies and horses left there, whereas tho bodies were found some distance oft. In answer to a question as to whether the Indians were not sulUcicnt to copo with both commands sepa rately, witness said ho wouldn’t like to take halt the Indian warriors and light them with Reno’s command. iLaughlcr.J He did not notice any evidences on the part of Custer’s column of an attempted return from “B” to the iiointou the blulli. Reno was Ignorant of Bentren’s and McDougall’s orders, didn’t know they were coining up, and bad to rely, of course, on his own Judgment as to leaving for some other place, when outnumbered in the timber, that ho could hold. Witness was asked as to GAIT. WElll’s BAI.LT, and again went over at considerable length the particulars connected with that subject. When he beard the bring In the direction of the place whore Custer was found, be did not inform Reno. Witness had heard Terry and Custer talking together of their plans, and bad an Idea at this time that Terry was op the Hip-Horn. As to whether the olllcura generally had any idea that Terry was coming up with a force to relievo Reno, he could not say. When he beard this firlug In the direction whore Custer was artcrwsrds found, hu had no Idea that Custer was cut to pieces or anything of the kind, al though he thought there bad been a repulse, lie could not say that It was a belief among Uie ofliccrs that Custer’s command was as well able to take core of itself as wus iteno’s to take care of itself. Ills own opinion sc the time was that Custer, having been attacked down the river, had either been conaled, or, having broken away, had gone uu in the direction in which Terry was for the purpose of joining him. Using asked as to the CONTBNTB OP TfIB LETTER
A special correspondence piece profiles Monroe, Michigan, noting its fame as the home of the slain General Custer and the site of the 1812-13 River Raisin Massacre. It describes the town's historical significance and interviews survivors of the earlier massacre, while referencing Custer's 1876 death and a local rowing crew's 1878 trip to England.
Chicago Daily Tribune · 24 January 1879 · page 9
Hlf'ompniituna-in-Anns. Kpeeiat Corretpon-Unte of The Tribune. Mo.snoE, Mich., .fan 22.—At two different periods within the past two years the name of lids beautiful little city on the west shore of Lake Krlo has perhaps been oftenor upon Hie lips of the people of this country than Hint of almost any other within Its wide domain.—ln July, IHTO, when the overwhelming and crush ing shock came of the massacre of our gallant (len. Custer, when the name of Monroe as the homo of the valiant soldier was associated with that tragic mid mournful event; mid again In July, 1878, when our “phenomenal ” but repre sentative crew of amateur oarsmen,the plnrky, wiry, and enthusiastic Bho-Woc-Cnc-Mettcs, crossed the big herring pond to measure oars with (hdr aquatic brethren on the Thames.
See moreSee less
The name of Monroe »« on a million longues I which perhaps have not since spoken It. Yet thu place tins on historic Interest and importance which will not quiteallow It to be dropped from thu page of history, even If It should be for gotten ns the former home of Custer. Its Inti mate connection with the early settlement of
A Military Court of Inquiry, requested by Major Reno, has convened in Chicago to investigate his conduct at the Battle of the Little Big Horn on June 25, 1876, where Custer and his command were massacred. The inquiry is currently in session.
Fulton Journal · 24 January 1879 · page 2
Advices from the Cheyinno River Indian Agency report that runners had arrived there from Sitting Bull's camp with a message to the effect that S. B. and all the hostile Cheyennes wore anxious to come back and submit to the rules of tiie agency if th y were assured of the protection of the Government The Military Court of Inquiry, appointed at - request of Maj. Reno, for an investigation into his conduct at the battle of the Little Big 1 Horn, June 25,187ft, in which occurred the ter
Lieutenant Varnum and Dr. Porter testify before the Reno Court of Inquiry about Reno's actions during the Battle of Little Bighorn, including estimates of Indian numbers and confused scenes during the retreat to the hill. Testimony is inconclusive on whether Reno's conduct was justified in not reinforcing Custer.
The New Orleans Daily Democrat · 24 January 1879 · page 1
THE RENO INQUIRY. Why lene Did Not Go to the Assistance of Custer-The Number of the lndUan Opposee to Ilm. CHICAGO. Jan. 23.-Lieut. Varnum's testimony in the Beno court of inauiry was completed to
Springfield Weekly Republican · Springfield, Mass.
The Reno inquiry is still underway in Chicago, with witnesses giving various conflicting accounts of Custer's fight with the Native Americans at Little Bighorn. The testimony remains inconsistent as the inquiry proceeds.
Springfield Weekly Republican · 24 January 1879 · page 1
The Maj Reno inquiry Is still proceeding at Chicago with various conflicting testimony concerning Custer’s ill-fated fight with the sav ages. The Teller election Investigating committee transferred its operations from New Orleans to Charleston, 8. C„ last week and got ample te timony corroborating the use of tissne ballots in that state at the last election. The Brevard county (Fla.) canviMing board were found guilty Wednesday of making false re turns at the late congressional election, the sheriff and justice of the peace being recoin mended to the mercy of the court. Ex-Lieut Gov Hull, whose election to Congress hinged upon this ease, is also indicted tor conspiracy. Official confirmations by the Semite the past week Include: Cyrus Harris at Providence, K.
Lieutenant Varnum and Dr. H.R. Porter testified before the Reno Court of Inquiry in Chicago about whether Custer knew Reno's men were under attack and expected to support him. Both witnesses indicated Custer was expected to reinforce Reno, with Porter recounting the order to charge the Indians and Varnum noting Reno acted reasonably given the overwhelming Indian force.
Daily Globe · 24 January 1879 · page 3
DR. R. n. PORTER, who was acting assistant surgeon under Caster, and who was with Reno's battalion, was put on the stand. From his evidence it seems that he also understood that Custer was expected to support Reno. The adjutant had told Reno that Custer was coming along when Benteen was seen approaching. After Reno got to the hill the men supposed at first it was Custer coming to their relief. [Western Associated Press. I CHICAGO, Jan. 28.Liet. Varnum was crosB examined this morning regarding the Custer massaore, and testified that the Gray Horse cavalry which he had mentioned mat have seen that Reno's command was entering into an engagement with the Indians, and Custer must also have known they were at bay, and in witness' judgment any 'careful commander would have inquired into thesituation of the troops from which he expectecnupport.
See moreSee less
There was a misunderstanding between Custer and Reno previous to this time. The Indians were probably not less than four or five thousand strong, and half that force was too great for half the whole command. He thought Reno was right in using his own judgment in getting out ot the woods. Dr. H. R. Porter, of Bismarck, acting assist ant surgeon under Ouster, with Reno's batal lion, testified he heard the adjutant deliver to Reno the command to cioss the ford and then charge the Indians. The adjutant told witness Custer would support Reno. Reno obeyed the order, and the fight progressed with the Indians for a while, but finally the Indians made the charge, and not the troops, a fact which sur prised witness.
Lieutenant Varnum testified that Custer should have known Reno was engaged with a large force of Indians and that a careful commander would have checked on the troops he expected to support. Dr. H. R. Porter testified that Reno was ordered to cross the ford and charge, with assurance that Custer would support him, but was surprised when the Indians charged first.
Daily Globe · 24 January 1879 · page 1
DR. H. R. PORTER,
[Western Associated Press. CHICAGO, Jan. 23.Liet. Varnum was cross examined this morning regarding the Cu3ter massacre, and testified 1 hat the Gray Horse cavalry which he hadmentioned mu-t have seen that Reno's command was entering into an engagement with the Indians, and Custer must also have known they were*t bay, and in witness' judgment any "careful commander would have inquired into the situation of the troops from which he expected support. There was a misunderstanding between Custer and Reno previous to this time. The Indians were probably not less than four or five thousand strong, and half that force was too great for half the whole command.
See moreSee less
He thought Reno was right in using his own judgment in getting out ot the woods. Dr. H. R. Porter, of Bismarck, acting assist ant surgeon under Custer, with Reno's batal lion, testified he heard the adjutant deliver to Reno the command to cross the ford and then charge the Indians. The adjutant told witness Custer would support Reno. Reno obeyed the order, and the fight progressed with the Indians for a while, but finally the Indiana made the charge, and not the troops, a fact which sur prised witness.
Frederick Whittaker, who accused Major Reno of cowardice at Little Bighorn, arrived in Chicago to testify before the Reno Court of Inquiry but called its scope too narrow, seeking a fuller Senate investigation. He also publicly retracted his earlier charge that Benteen disobeyed orders, now stating Benteen was blameless for the disaster.
Daily Globe · 24 January 1879 · page 2
CUSTER'S CHAMPION.
vestigation Asked forHis Charges Against Bentecn Retracted. [Special Telegram to the Globe.! CHICAGO, Jan. 23.Frederick Whittaker, of Mount Vernon, N. Y., who makes the charges of cowardice against Reno, which are now being investigated, arrived here last night to give in his testimony. He says be has come to Chica go "safely in the hope of securing justice for the memory of Custer by bringing to light the whole truth about the battle of the Little Big Horn, and the campaign in which the General met with his death. Since I have been here I have became satisfied that the scope ef the present inquiry, and the orders by which the court is limited, are too narrow to insure the revelation of all the facts bearing on the question of who is responsible for the Custer disaster.
See moreSee less
I have therefore made application for a farther and fuller investigation in the highest tribunal of the country, the Senate of the United States, and private letters from Washington assure me that the application will in all probability be granted." Mr. Whittaker has heretofore publicly charged Mr. Benteen with a disobedience cf orders on that day in that he did not ride more quickly to Custer'B suppor!, as ordered. He now says he is satisfied that Benteen is wholly blameless for the disaster of the Little Big Horn. He mak8 this correction in justice to the living and dead.
During the Reno Court of Inquiry in Chicago, witness Girard testified about Custer's reaction to Reno's retreat from the timber, and Lieut. Vroom described troop movements and the overwhelming Indian numbers on June 25-26, 1876. The testimony detailed the chaotic, demoralized retreat of Reno's forces.
The New North-West · 24 January 1879 · page 2
The Reno Trial. CHICAGO, Jan. 21.-In the Reno Court of Inquiry to-day some time was consumed in the debate between the counsel as to whether the witness Girard had Indian children and whether the testimony on that ground was admissible. The latter issue was decided in the negative. The witness testified that Custer on seeing Reno moving away from the timber shouted "who in the mischief ordered out that conmmand ? Lieut. C. A. Vroom, Quartermaster, Seventh Cavalry, testified that on the 25th and 26th of June 1876 he was Second Lieutenantin command of a party of scouts under Custer.
See moreSee less
On the 26th he was detached from the main troops being away with the scouts. He did not know what troops were assigned to Reno but he had about 120 men. He described the movements of the forces. The Indians were in greater numbers than he had ever before seen. He recounted the advance and retreat of the horses and men were greatly fatigued. The troops were badly demoralized on their retreat. Adjourned.
Lieutenant Varnum testified that the gray horse cavalry should have shown Custer that Reno's command was engaged with the Indians, and that any careful commander would have checked on the troops he expected to support him. He stated there was no prior misunderstanding between Custer and Reno, estimated Indian strength at 4,000-5,000, and said Reno was right to retreat from the timber.
Memphis Daily Appeal · 24 January 1879 · page 1
Beno. Chicago, January 23. Lieutenant Var nuui was cross-examined this morning re garding the Custer massacre, and testified that the gray horse cavalry which he had mentioned must have seen that Reno's com mand was entering an engagement with the Indians, and Custer must also have known that they were at bay. and in the witness's judgment, any careful commander would nave loquired into the situation ot tha troops trom which be expected support, there was no misunderstanding between Custer and Reno previous to this time: the Indians were probub'y not less than four to five thousand strong, and half that force was too great for bait ot the whole command.
See moreSee less
He thought Reno was right in using his own judgment in getting out of the woods. A Cheyenne special says that tnoso killed in the recent encounter are Sergeant Tag gart, Farrier Brown and Private Nelson, of company L, Third cavalry. Sergeant Am brose, ot company E, and the Indian scout Womans Dress were wounded severely, and
The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · Wheeling, W. Va.
Lieutenant Varnum testified that Reno faced an overwhelming Indian force of 4,000-5,000 and was right to retreat from the woods, noting Custer should have checked on Reno's situation. Dr. Henry Porter testified that Reno was ordered to charge and was told Custer would support him, but the Indians counter-charged first, surprising the troops.
The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · 24 January 1879 · page 1
The Beno Court Martial. j tore Chicago, January 23.?Lieutenant Varnum was cross-examined this morning re- < garding the Custer massacre, and testified J that the Gray Horse Cavalry, which he | hud mentioned must have been that of t Reno's command, was entering an en* gogement with the Indians, and Caster must have known that they were at bay;
Lieut. Varnum testified that Custer should have known Reno's men were engaged and at bay, estimated Indian strength at 4,000-5,000, and said Reno was right to retreat. Dr. H.R. Porter corroborated that Reno was ordered to charge and told Custer would support him, and was surprised when the Indians rather than the troops made the charge.
The Cheyenne Daily Leader · 24 January 1879 · page 1
Nl ILLINOIS, Varnum Thinks Reno Did Right. Chicago, Jan. 23.—Lieut. Varnum was cross-examined regarding the Cus ter massacre and testified that the gray horse cavalry which he had mentioned must have seen that Reno’s command was entering the engagement with the Indians, and Custer must also have known that they wore at bay, and in witness’ judgment any carefal com mander would have inquired into the situation of the troops from which he expected support. There was no mis understanding between Custer and :
Salt River Herald · Phoenix, Salt River Valley, Ariz.
Chicago dispatch reports testimony from Lieut. Varnum in the official inquiry into Major Reno's conduct at Little Bighorn. Varnum stated Reno took the best defensive position available with insufficient men, that Custer was likely attacked around the time Reno withdrew from the woods, and that advancing to aid Custer would have required passing through the Indian village, which he believed was impossible for either command.
Salt River Herald · 25 January 1879 · page 1
TELEGRAPH
were hardly enough men t" hold it. Reno, however, created a diversion in the Indian village. The Indians must have attacked Custer about the time Reno left the woods, but witness thought tbe main fighting force of the village was opposing him. Had Reno gone forward with his com mand to assist Custer he would bare been obliged to go through the In dian village, and witness did not be lieve it could have been done by either command. He did not care to answer the question whether the con duct of Reno was such as to inspire his men with courage, but finally said there was no cowaadice in it.
See moreSee less
There was some little demoralization aud great haste in the method of Reno's force in getting out of the woods.
The report describes the newly opened Reno Court of Inquiry, prompted by Reno's own request after controversy over an alleged statement by Capt. Weir. It details a battlefield survey by Col. Miles and others, accompanied by Sioux participants, suggesting Reno could have heard and possibly seen Custer's fight, and that his delay allowed warriors to rally.
The Sun · 25 January 1879 · page 3
THE SCENE CUSTER'S DEATH AND RENO'S INACTIVITY.
correspondent expressly disclaims Rnydenlrei r Intuition to " maiiufai-tiire evnlen io " In the cose. The names id the , ffl-'crs who c ini.e-e the court ' 'I. John King. Ninth Iufnutrv: ('..I. W.-sley M erritt. Fifth i'nvnlry. end Uent Col. William U. BopnlL Third t'nralry-gimran-tee a fair and laborious hearing and an Impartial rcpirt. It will he remembered Uiat Delegate Corliett of Wyoming once mtr, da. 1 a Mil for the investigate n now pending upon Major It no's own application: and it is sup posed that t'.ipt. Wbltaker. Custer's biographer, was Influential In procuring such action, the Oceoaion therefor being certain now and start ling evidence.
See moreSee less
The character of these developments other thnn the statement ol Capt, Wler, referred lo nliova, was surmised last sunnncr. when Oot Nelson A Miles. Filth infantry, and l.ieut. Ed ward Uagnlre. Oorpn of Kngineere, and otbev officers vis ted nud made an accurate survey of the battleBald. Tin y were aeoompanled by several Kiotix chlefi who pnrti. Ipated in the maaaacra, and. it is sai l, aaeera tallied by actual measurement that not only could the firing 111 Ihe engagement between the ludiniis and Custer's individual command have been dlatlnctly heard nt Banoa intrenched po RiUon, but that certain phases of III" eOgBM must have Is en visible from that point. It Ie further Mat"'l that their savage com panions admitted tho perfect surprise of the village, nnd Maerted that they were preparing to abandon everything, aeeklng pen n il -aw in Bight, when Bono hali.d I Is column, dismounted, and ib-ployed It in li n of skirmishers five hundred yards from the exterior ftpU, Tills UnaoOOUBtable delay enabled them to rally the y oinig lai'-ks, and to Roc rata their women and chlldr'-n. hubaeguently they ntoyed out ami attneked i.-no. forcing his pi sit ii.ii and driving him aeroM tba Itream to aoek shelter upon nn elcvati ,1 km II. Il Is said t tut t it was not more than a mile end n half from this point to where Custer and hit five com pun h-h fell. The fa. t that tbcRS ofB 'Ort liRvo been sum moned by the Coin t Would hC'lll to beennllrm ntory of tins rumor. If f..lso It will, doubtleaa, bo easily disproved by tho dfftntti Uut tho public is entitled to know nil the alrenmataneee attending tho revival of tins muoh-diacuaaad anaetion. It would seem that the whole matte! resolves Itself into this Inquiry: Wag or was not Major ltno nwara of the ib-apcrate fiBOOUnter pro gressing ks'tween Custer nnd the common eii"-
This report discusses whether Major Reno should have attempted to rescue Custer's forces, arguing that separation may have left him unable to comprehend the battle situation. It also criticizes Custer's decision to divide his forces before attacking, comparing it unfavorably to Napoleonic tactics, and notes that General Sheridan may be called as a defense witness regarding Reno's conduct in the ongoing inquiry.
The Sun · 25 January 1879 · page 3
Il has been assert", I that Cant. It iBteen urged Beno to permit him to go to the rescue, nml was peremptorily refueed i but his alive, and can sponk for himself. What alBOtWOUld have u-en produced had li m. cut his way through the cordon of Indians In bis Immediate front nnd attacked Custer's assailants la tin-1! ink or rear, it la dlfl nit to any : but the battle of the I.lttio llig Horu might have terminated different!! outi therband, Reno mny have been too remote to hear tho firing or see any part of the eoBfllat IB short, to have comprehended the situation; nml ba mny have had his hands full.
See moreSee less
Whether he obeyed or or disobeyed or ders la not of miih eonoeo.uenee, except us n matter of justioo to Custer's mem ory. A subordinate eoiumbndcr, wiun eeiiarated from his superior, must be his own guide ill the CMgell s that arise, unless they p iong nnd be fnreorderedl and. ordi narily, wo enn oBlyaaeriba to him luck ui or an error In ludgmonl, . , , And just her" BWOrd for Custer s plana, so uu jnstiy criticised. Hla mnvemeBla after ha had
Dr. Henry Porter, assistant surgeon under Custer with Reno's battalion, testified that he heard the adjutant order Reno to cross the ford and charge, with assurance that Custer would support him. Reno obeyed, but the Indians ultimately charged the troops rather than being charged, surprising witnesses.
Daily Press and Dakotaian · 25 January 1879 · page 2
that Custer would aupport Reno. Reno tbe order and tbe fight progressed obeyed with tbe Indiana for a wblle.bat finally tbe Indians made the ibargeaaad not tbe troopa a fact which surprised wMaese. RWICH orinzuRE.
A Chicago correspondent notes that the Custer massacre commission is still in session investigating General Reno's conduct, with the writer speculating that evidence looks unfavorable to Reno regarding charges resembling cowardice. The correspondent personally speculates that Reno's retreat was likely the only way to save his command given the overwhelming number of warriors between his position and Custer's.
Public Ledger · 25 January 1879 · page 1
FROM CHICAGO.
The Custer massacre commission is still in session, with the prosect of a long session be! ore it. I p to date things look a little against General Reno, who is on trial, charged with something liko cowardice. " Jiut it looks as though his command was generally demoralized. And no won der, when tho red devils were so nu merous between licno and Custer. I do not bcliovo anything was left llono to do but save his men by a retreat. If he had remained, he and his com mand, from all appearances, would now bo with tho bravo Custer and his gallant meu.
See moreSee less
Her Majesty's Opera Troupe is set ting fashiouable Chicago wild. Its success is immense. Most certainly it is a splendid gathering together of first-class talent, and deserves the pat ronage it is attracting. 1 1 Business is very dull here, owing to the very severe weather. Such a cold snap as commenood Now Year's night, and continued for twelve days there after, was never known before in this region. It was simply horriblo. But it is moderating now, and business may look up. I hope the Ledsf.R folks and all its readers spont a " happy New Year."
At the Reno Court of Inquiry in Chicago, Captain Moylan testified that Reno's decision to retreat was wise and necessary to preserve his command. He stated he saw nothing cowardly in Reno's conduct, arguing that charging the Indians or staying in the timber would have led to annihilation.
Daily Los Angeles Herald · 26 January 1879 · page 2
The Reno inquiry.
Companies A, B, D, I and M, Seventh Cavalry, uuder Captain Ferris, arrived to day and leave Iv the morning for the Sand Hills, where Little Wolf and a band of 200 Cheyennes are reported to be. Companies A, F, E aud L, Third Cavalry, leave for their respective stations early next week, leaving two companies at this post.
A witness testifies before the Reno Court of Inquiry about the condition of Major Reno's command after reaching the hilltop, describing the skirmish line and eventual sounds of firing later identified as Custer's fight. The witness also recounts identifying Captain Calhoun's body and the arrangement of dead soldiers, giving his assessment of Reno's self-possession during the retreat.
The New York Herald · 26 January 1879 · page 6
MORALE OF THE COMMAND
CUHTEH's EIGHT HE A HI). About au hour after reaching the top of the hill, where Reno took up his position, the witness tor the tirst time heard firiBg in the direction of what was afterward ascertained to be Custer's battlefield, and called Captain MrDnngall's attention to it, asking nini what he supposed it to be; he replied he supposed it was General CusMr fighting at the end of the village, down the bottom; the flriug was very faint, though it wus evidently volley tiring. Speaking of the evidences of desperate tightitig on the part of Custer's men, the witness said that the body of Captain Calhoun, his brother-in-law, having
A witness describes the reunion of Reno's and Benteen's commands on the hill, the condition of the troops, and evidence found later on the battlefield including Calhoun's body and cartridge shells. He is then asked to give his opinion on Major Reno's conduct during the battle regarding coolness, efficiency, and courage.
Chicago Daily Tribune · 26 January 1879 · page 5
THE PART OF WISDOM TO LEAVE THE TIMBER.
skirmish line a few minutes after arriving there. His impression was that quite a number of the men must have crossed before Reno did. from the fact that when he saw Reno, after crossing, he was standing on the right bank, while a number of men were some little distance up the bill. The timber was lower than the village, so that Reno would have overshot the village from his position in the timber, and could really have done it no harm. He had no reason to doubt the Indians’ statements that tire village was one of 1,800 lodges and 400 wickiups—wigwams occupied by men without families.
See moreSee less
The village, from Reno’s position on the hill, was out of range. He had understood that Custer was to have supported Reno, and his own opinion was that Custer’s column was on the trail in the rear of Reno’s column and was coming up to support him. After reaching the top of the hill—about an hour afterwards—he heard firing in the direc tion of wnat was afterwards ascertained to he Caster’s battlefield. He called Capt. JlcDougal’s attention to it, and the latter replied that be thought it was Custer attacking the Indians at the other end of the village. It was volley firing, but evidently very faint. It was about an hour from the time of separating from Custer until the union of Reno and Bcntecn ou the lull. Bcuteen could have gotten across the river to Reuo in the timber, if his force was sufficient. The first dead bodies witness found in the vicinity of the watering-plaee “B ” were about half a mile off from that point. He saw very little evidences ot fighting near the river, but farther hack the evidences were con clusive. The body of Col. Calhoun, bis nrother-in-law, was’one of a company of those who had fallen together in regu lar line. Around one of these bodies he observed twentv-eigtt cartridge-shells. Some of the soldiers Had evidently vainly tried to cross the river, for their finger-marks and boot marks were seen on the bank. There were no evidences ol fighting ot the watering-place “ B,” although mere were evidences that a lot of pomes had recently crossed. “Now,” said Lieut. Lee, “please state your opinion as to THE CONDUCT OF MAJ. RENO
Capt. Moylan testifies at the Reno Court of Inquiry about Major Reno's conduct during the Little Bighorn battle, describing him as calm and giving orders coolly, with no signs of cowardice. Cross-examination covers troop movements, the crossing at ford A, and testimony about Dr. Porter's fear during the fighting.
Chicago Daily Tribune · 26 January 1879 · page 5
THE CONDUCT OF MAJ. RENO
This closed rne direct. Mr. Gilbert then entered upon the cross-ex amination, asking witness to describe the move ments after receiving the order from Custer up to the time of crossing at ford “A.” He did so, pretty much as he did on the direct, and in response to further questions said that Reno was always at the head of the column, and he (the witness) riding near him. He did not remember seeing Girard or anybody else speaking to Reno just before crossing. After crossing,, they moved on at the same gait. There was a man in ms (Moyian’s) company whose horse was very restive. Reno told him to hold his horse in, as he would give him work enough after awhile. Witness knew
A witness (Capt. Moylan) testifies at the Reno Court of Inquiry about the retreat from the timber to the hilltop, praising Benteen's conduct as 'superb' and noting Reno commended him. He also describes finding evidence of organized resistance by Calhoun's company, comparable only to Custer's position, and commends Dr. Porter's performance under fire.
Chicago Daily Tribune · 26 January 1879 · page 5
COL. BENTEEN'S COLUMN
the bravery, or want of bravery, of his men. On the hill he saw more of . Bcuteen than any body else, mid Benteen’s conduct was simply superb. Nothing short of that would ex press it. “AudMaj. Reno made special mention of it, did he uotf” asked Mr. Gilbert. “ Yes, sir,” was the reply. “ And deservedly?” “I think so.” “Stale whether, from the indications as you saw them of
A newspaper miscellany column reports that Capt. French of the Seventh Cavalry asserted Maj. Reno was 'hidden away somewhere' during the height of the Custer massacre. The item is one of many unrelated gossip snippets printed together.
The New Orleans Daily Democrat · 26 January 1879 · page 7
Grant," has been elected doorkeeper of the Texas Senate. The chapter mottoes in George Ellot's later works are understood to Mr. Lewis' running commentary on her work. Caleb Cashing hated dusters. He never would allow a servant to dust his room. If any attempted it, Caleb would himself get up and dust. Capt. French, of the Seventh Cavalry, as serte that during the heat of the Custer mas sacre light Gen.Reno was hidden away some where. Ton armed men overpowered the guard at the Mexican fortress of Collmathe other day and rescued ex-G(ov. Filomeno Bravo from a dungeon. Congressman S. 8. Cox sometimes carries his humor too far. In his address on Prof. Henry the other night he alluded to "the 1 skeleton hand of God."
At the Reno Court of Inquiry in Chicago, witnesses including Capt. Moylan testified that Reno's decision to leave the timber and retreat was a wise and necessary move to preserve the command, as remaining would have led to annihilation. Testimony also described hearing faint gunfire later identified as Custer's battle, and defended Reno's personal conduct as not cowardly.
Daily Globe · 26 January 1879 · page 1
RENO'S RETREAT.
[Special Telegram to the Globe.l CHICAGO, Jan. 25.Qapt. Moylan, who is perhaps one of the most entertaining of the witnesses thus far examined in the Reno case, was again on the stand to-day. Amongst the questions asked bim were whether the command of Reno could have been so formed when the at tack was first made as to protect itself. He did not think it could have been so disposed as to hold the position and protect itself under the circumstances. The object of getting out of the timber was, in his opinion, to save the command.
See moreSee less
The witness believed that in view of the uncertainty regarding support, the re treat was less injurious than it would have been to remain in the timber, for he did not believe the command could have remained there thirty minutes longer without looping many more men than it did, of course pursued. He thought further that if the Indians had fol lowed up the troops, and closed in upon them on the hill, the command could not have held out against them until relief came, for its ammunition would have given out. He did not know how many men were killed at the river crossing, and did not think the crossing was covered bya organized body of men to protect the rest in getting over. It was about an hour after Reno got into position on the hill that the witness heard firing in the direction of what afterwards proved to be Custer's bat tlefield. The firing was faint, and Captain McDougall, whose attention was called to it, said he supposed it was Custer fighting at the end of the village, down the bottom. As to Reno's conduct in the bottom, whether brave or cowardly, the witness said: "At times Major Reno rode at the head of the column, at other times at the center, and again at the rear. I all the orders which he gave to witness he man ifested as much self-possession as any man would under the circumstances, and he saw nothing in Major Reno's conduct indicative of cowardice. I his opinion, had the command remained in the timber it would have b.een annihilated. TWestern Associated Press.] CHICAGO, Jan. 25.In the Reno inquiry to
At the Reno Court of Inquiry in Chicago, Captain Moylan testified that Reno's decision to leave the timber was wise and necessary to preserve his command. He stated that evidence of desperate fighting was found among Custer's dead, and that charging or remaining in the timber would have led to annihilation of Reno's force.
New-York Tribune · 27 January 1879 · page 8
CONDUCT DEFENDED
i ONDUCT DLFENDED, MAJOR RENO'S ( CHicaco, Jan, 26.—1u the Reno inquiry yesterday Caption Moylan testified that he beheved it was a wise wove for Reno to leave the timber, and necessary for the preservation of his command, Iu picking up the dead bodies of Custer's men after the massa re evi dences appeared of desperate fighting. He saw nothing cowardly ju Major Keno's conduct, Had he eharged on the Iudisns or remained iu the tuubes kis force would Lave been annihilated,
During the Reno inquiry in Chicago, Captain Moylan testified that Reno's decision to leave the timber was wise and necessary to preserve the command. He stated that evidence of desperate fighting was found among Custer's dead, and that Reno would have been annihilated had he charged or stayed in the timber.
Daily Globe · 27 January 1879 · page 3
tion to continue the same therefore the loss is total. Camp liobiuson Notes. Four EOBTNSON, Neb Jan. 25.Private Spiowl, ambulance driver, started to drive to the old camp, cne mile distant, this afternoon. To-night hew as found lying in the load, and his skull fiactnred. I is not known whether the wound was caused bj a gun shot or by fall ing from the ambulance. His condition is ci itical. The wound cannot be examined to night. Wednesday night a trumpeter arrived from the old camp and reported being fired at by a party come'iled in the ravine.
See moreSee less
I is believed that either Indians or bad white men are in the bluffs. Reno. CHICAGO. Jan. 25.In the Eeno inquiry to day Capt. Moylan testified he believed it was a wise move for Reno to leave the timber, and nccessaiy for the preservation of the command. In picking up the dead bodies of Custer's men after the massacre evidences appeared of des perate fighting. He saw nothing cowardly in Major Reno's conduct. Had he charged on the Indians or remained in the timber he would have been annihilated. Adjourned. Washington Item*, WASHINGTON, Jan. 25.The President has signed the arrears of pension bill. FOUR PEE CENTb. Subscriptions to the four per cent, loan since yesterday's ieport, $14,028,700. SILVER DOLLARS. The demand for silver dollars to-day amount ed to $25,000 for the month $497,000. Chosen to Congress. ASHLAND, Va.. Jan. 25.R. L. Beal, Conserva tive, elected to the Forty-sixth Congress, has been chosen to fill the vacancy caused by the death of Representative Douglas. The vote was small. ALL AKOl'SD THE GLOB E. Mrs. Elizabeth Hancock, mother of Maj. Gen. Hanc ck died at Norristown, Pa., yester day, aged 78.
At the Reno Court of Inquiry in St. Paul, Dr. Porter testified that Reno appeared frightened during the battle and confirmed that Custer had promised to support Reno's charge. Reno's counsel objected to the doctor's opinion on his client's demeanor, but the objection was overruled.
Bismarck Tribune · 27 January 1879 · page 1
KENO'S TBI Alt. ST. PACT,, Jan. 25.—The testimony of Dr. Porter before the Reno court contin ued yesterday. On reading the steno |t«]Iier't review, Reno tried to confine the doctor by getting close to him and staring «t him, but the doctor was im periurable. To the question as to how Reno's conduct impressed, him, Gilbert, the Major's counsel, objected, stating that fciaobjection was to a medical man's opin ion. The objection was over-ruled. The doctor thought Reno was frightened him self. He confirmed the previous testimony -that Custer said be would support Reno in charge. Capt. Moylan was the next witness, but added nothing new.
A Standing Rock report describes Sitting Bull sending runners with a surrender message, likening it to Chief Joseph's famous words of defeat. A Tribune correspondent also interviews one of the runners, who gives a detailed account of the Custer battle, describing Reno's early retreat, the annihilation of Custer's command, and the Sioux's claim that Terry's arrival prevented a second massacre of Reno's men.
Bismarck Tribune · 27 January 1879 · page 1
SITTING BULL.
MA88ACBK BIS COMMAKB, also, and the Indians believe they wbudd have done so but for the timely arrival of Gen. Terry. When: Ternr made hisap. puarance tiiey all left. The Indians be lieve that therc wonld have been no bat tle had. Custer not .divided iiia command id h#d iiGU^ iiot hec^ae demo leve^tlkitii wouW have heia aj^ssartie. Hki fright gave them heart, tlwh ttie old men wha went off with the squaws returned, and joined in the whaiping itnd yelling which contributed so much to the terroi of the troops. Twelve and fifteen year old boys, if armed, fought beside middle aged men^ and if not armed they joined in whoopingSc(4t waa hell brolte loose. ',
The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · Wheeling, W. Va.
At the Reno inquiry in Chicago, Captain Moylan testified that Reno was right to leave the timber, as it was necessary for the command's survival. He stated that evidence from the dead showed desperate fighting and that Reno's conduct was not cowardly.
The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · 27 January 1879 · page 1
CHICAGO. g, the reno inql'ily. Chicago, January 25.?Ill tho Reno inh luiry to^iny Captain Maylan testified that le believed it waia vise more (or Reno o leavo the tirabor, and necessary [or tho w >resorvation ol the command. In picking ki ip the dead bodies of Custer's men after be massacre, evidence appearod ol des- ~ urate fighting. Mo saw nothing cowarda] y in Reno's conduct. Had he charged on hi lie Indians or remained in the timber, he pi rould have been annihilated. Adjourned. M u'khxoh i co. . hi The Application lor an injunction to re2 itrain Tappan McKillop & Co.
See moreSee less
Irom Isiu- , ng their January book ol ratings, was H vithdrawn this morning by complainant J. ?eIore a hearing could be obtained in h Joint. The Agency had a good reputation K lore a>u| the suit has been regarded with K lonslderaklo iutorest. Thp rating book lias .
The item notes that if Sitting Bull surrenders in time, he could testify before the military commission in Chicago investigating Major Reno's conduct at the Little Big Horn. It claims he knows more about the twin battles against Custer and Reno than all white witnesses combined.
Washingtoner Journal · 28 January 1879 · page 2
Editorielle Notizen. In einem bder Biergärten auf Conty Island bei New York soll im nächsten Sommer eine lünstliche Kah aufgestellt werden, in deren Innerem ein mit Milch gesüllter Eisschrank ange bracht sein wird. Eine Schenlmomsell in bänerischer Tracht soll das „künstliche Vieh“ mellen zuS Cents sür's Olas! Die Kuh soll $2500 kosten. Wenn Sitting Bull recht zeitig kapitulirt, so kann er hier in Chicago vor der Militärcommission, welche das Verhalten des Major Reno am Litile Big Horn untersucht, noch als Zeuge vernommen werden. Er weiß über den Verlauf der an jenem Flusse von den Indianern gelieferten Doppel schlacht gegen Custer und gegen Reno Mehr als alle weißen Zeugen zusammen genommen.
See moreSee less
(dn. Stozig.) Frankreich will den Zoll auf Peiroleum herabsetzen. Fur die Einfuhr von 100 Kilos werden jetzt doit 37 Francs gezahlt. Die Octroisteuer in Paris ist 27 Franes mehr, oder 64 Francs per 100 Kilos, also etwa drei mal so viel als der Kostpreis des Petro leums. Der Finanzminister hat jetzt eine Reduciion der Zolle und des Ociroi
Scout George Herendeen testified at the Reno Court of Inquiry that Reno's retreat from the valley fight was a chaotic rout, with soldiers fleeing for their lives and officers unable to halt the panic. He described Bloody Knife's death, the failed attempt to estimate Indian distance, and his own fall from his horse amid the retreat to the timber.
The New York Herald · 28 January 1879 · page 3
RENO'S RUN. HOW HE IS DECLARED TO HAVE SCAMPERED FROM THE INDIANS—"EVERYBODY RAN FOR HIS LIFE"—"COMPANY A, HALT! FOR GOD'S SAKE DON'T RUN!"
scout and courier with General Custer on the 2">tk of June, 187(1, accompanying Reno's column; he had been in several engagements with tho redskins; concerning Custer's order to Reno tho witness testified that as he overheard it it was in effect that Reno should lead out and Custer
A witness testifies about Major Reno's chaotic retreat from the valley, describing men fleeing for their lives on horseback and later regrouping in timber before rejoining Reno's hilltop position. He also recounts hearing volley fire from the direction of Custer's battlefield and estimates the number of hostile warriors at 2,500-3,500.
The New York Herald · 28 January 1879 · page 3
fight. RENO 1* COMPARATIVELY SAFE QUARTERS, Down the river he heard the sound of firing in volleys, in the direction of the Custer battlefield; that firing lasted an hoar; over where Reno was, however, he heard during that time only scattering shots; probably Custer was halt a mile beyond lk-no's hill
Witnesses testify before the Reno Court of Inquiry about the Little Bighorn battle, including details on Custer's orders, troop movements, and the battlefield's terrain. Officers describe the timing, numbers of Indians, and the lack of defensible positions for Custer's command.
The New York Herald · 28 January 1879 · page 3
RENO IN COMPARATIVELY SAFE QUARTERS,
river, for he would hxvu heard the firing. I'APTAUI rax Nit's KVIDKXCK. Captain 4. S. Payne, of the Filth cavalry, was called. He said that he was over tho field last August; the distance tictween tho place w hero Custer was killed
The Reno Court of Inquiry continued with testimony from scouts Payne and George Herendeen about the topography and events preceding the battle. Herendeen described scouting activity, the discovery of Sioux warriors, and Custer's order for Reno to advance while Custer would follow.
Chicago Daily Tribune · 28 January 1879 · page 3
tried CAPI. MOTLAK if be recollected having a conversation with Lieut. Wallace about sending back word to Culler. The witness replied that the conversa tion was with regard to tbo number of hostile lodimi. Witness ssked o half-breed boy If bo rtuld get h acl{ 40 Custer and tell him as to thu force, hut the half-breed replied, pointing to ,bc Indians working around to tbo left, that it vis impossible. GBORQK IIBIIHDBBH
A witness testifies before the Reno Court of Inquiry about the chaotic retreat to the timber, an officer's desperate plea not to be left behind, and hearing volley fire later believed to be Custer's command engaging the enemy. He also describes conditions on the bluff, the state of the river crossing, and uncertain observations about Indian movements and troop strength.
Chicago Daily Tribune · 28 January 1879 · page 3
“CONFAHT A, HALT; let’s nonTTIIEM. DON’T, FOR GOD’S SAKE. HUM.’ 1 . Ouenwti, coming out of the timber, saw he »»i left behind, uml threw his gun away. Witmen In the timber, and at his wvice they stayed there. No Indians were In tnc Umber then, and they were not molested by *i D -. f n * w bllo there. Everybody was a good oesi frightened when ho got In there, but thev rerailoed two hours, and had time to cool off, clean their guor, and get ready for further muleeM, if there was to he any.
See moreSee less
Having been « about half on hour, be beard firing flown the stream, In volleys, fronrthe direction in which Coster was afterwords found. This fir ing might have lasted nn hour During Urn time, he did not hear any firing across tho stream. When ho beard this firing down the •'*»» Impression was that It was Custer, ana that Impression had since been confirmed. AV't* lß l!lnte Reno left the timber, Custer must nive been obout half way from where be started
A witness testifies before the Reno Court of Inquiry about events in the timber during the Little Bighorn battle, describing troop movements, firing heard, and confusion over Reno's and Custer's positions. The witness recounts not seeing certain officers and uncertainty about troop numbers and the village's size.
Chicago Daily Tribune · 28 January 1879 · page 3
tiling <,ld ~ot l, 'l«k the Indians could have Swaffn UOUtof Uwr#if *l“Tbid had food Tu!f ,hc direct examination. Ukln* ii^*-' 1 ! XBlnl , l l atl ‘' n I>ec*n by Mr. Hilbert •a the m,? *,* ne ‘‘ llwasn’t rather exhausted lLrenh?L n,u ¥ uf . U»« aslh without bis coffee. 18 inot?m. n oe Caitv«. The column was cri, “?, WDc u Cutter gave Reno the order m hear L’u!*.. ‘dvaure, amt the witness down ?««!*'“» nut I* r I rom Keno. On riding au A M 0 AUJr. Cook deliver any wli °» M lu °rd*r was Irom Custer him with Itj-i, e L.- I d !d h* *«« Ucut. Wallace riding
Scout George Herendeen testified about the position of Reno's men during the battle, while Capt. E. S. Payne gave measured distance figures between Custer's death site and Reno's hilltop entrenchment. The hearing was part of the official inquiry into Major Reno's conduct at Little Bighorn.
The Rock Island Argus · 28 January 1879 · page 1
The Seno Inquiry. Chicago, Jan. 27. In the Reno inves tigation to-day George Herendean. a seou with Custer, testified in regard to the posi tion of Keno's men. Capt. E. S. Payne, part that 5th cavalry, testified that the exact dis tance by measurement, from the plac where Custer was killed toRcco's entrench ment on the hit . was tour miles ana one hnndred and sixty yards.
At the Reno inquiry in Chicago, scout George Herendeen testified about Reno's retreat into timber under Indian fire and estimated the Indian village's fighting force at 3,500. Capt. E.S. Payne testified to measuring the distance between Custer's death site and Reno's hilltop entrenchment at four miles and 160 yards.
Daily Globe · 28 January 1879 · page 1
Scout Eereudeen and Capt. ifi. S. Payne Tell Their Stories. CHICAGO, Jan. 27.In Eeno"s investigation to-clay Oieo. Herendeen, of Bozemau, scout with Custer, testified he was with Reno in the woods when the firing began. The Indians were at first out of range, but later advanced into the woods and when Reno withdrew they followed, firing. The eoldiers seemed considerably frightened. He heard firing which ho then believed was Custera suspicion since con firmed. He estimates the fightiug force of the In dian village at 3,500. I believe the Indians could not have driven 300 soldiers from the timber provided the latter had plenty of ammunition.
See moreSee less
Capt, E. S. Payne, Fifth cavalry, testified the exact instance by measurement from the place whero Cus ter was killed to Reno's iutrenehment on the hill, and it was four raiies and 1G0 yards.
Witness Varnum describes Reno's positioning after leaving the woods and the subsequent diversion in the Indian village. He recounts seeing Custer's gray horse company on the bluffs and hearing distant firing, though he did not initially believe it came from Custer's command.
The Spirit of Democracy · 28 January 1879 · page 2
Major Reno's Trial. Chicago, Jan. 22. Ia the Inquiry Court Yarnum testified that he thought Reno took the best position after he left tbe woods with his command, but there were hardly enough men to hold it. Re no, however, createda diversion in tbe Indian village. The Indians must have attacked Custer about the time Rsno left the woods, but witness thought the main fighting force of tbe village was oppo sing Reno. He saw Custer's gray horse company moving along the bluffs down the river at about tbe time the skirmish line was formed.
See moreSee less
. It was three quarters of a mile away. An hour later Colonel Benteen joined Reno over tbe bill, and at about the same time witness heard firing away down the stream, but it was a crash, and did not sound like a continu ous engagement At that lime he didn't think it came from Custer, but thought it might be the Indians in tbe village, When he saw tbe gray horse cavalry he thought Custer was making a detour to strike the other end of tbe Indian village from the east.
A Washington dispatch reports that roughly 5,000 lodges, or nearly 15,000 people, are with Sitting Bull, prompting attention from the President and War and Interior Departments. Officials are seeking more information, noting reports that Sitting Bull's intentions are peaceable but uncertain given unsettled Indian affairs.
The Spirit of Democracy · 28 January 1879 · page 2
Sitting Bull. Washington, January 21. It is re ported that some five thousand lodges, or nearly fifteen thousand people are with Sitting Bull. The subject will re ceive the immediate attention of tbe
This general news digest reports that Sitting Bull claims his 'spirit is broken' and proposes unconditional surrender, while noting that Sand Hill Cheyennes remain the only active hostiles. The item suggests increasing army strength even if Sitting Bull is granted a reservation.
The Cheyenne Daily Leader · 28 January 1879 · page 1
Sitting Bull proposes uncondi tional surrender. His “spirit is broken” .he claims pathetically. Well, if he is granted an agency and a reservation it would not be eut of place to increase
George Herendeen, a scout with Custer at Bozeman, Montana, testified in the Reno inquiry that he heard Custer order Reno to advance with scouts while Custer would follow. He described firing on Indians from a buffalo trail and seeing Major Reno near the scout Bloody Knife shortly before Bloody Knife was killed by a volley.
The Cheyenne Daily Leader · 28 January 1879 · page 1
The Very Humble Sitting Bull. ’Fort Lincoln, Jan. 27.—Runners from Sitting Bull have arrived at Standing Rock agency bearing a distinct propo sition from the chief to surrender his
The article analyzes Lieut. Wallace's testimony before the Reno investigation, which claims Reno was attacked by overwhelming Indian forces and nearly out of ammunition before recrossing the river, implying Custer was already wiped out by then. It notes a weak point: Reno's later advance down the river along Custer's trail seems inconsistent with the claim of being surrounded by vast numbers of Indians.
The Cheyenne Daily Leader · 28 January 1879 · page 3
From the Chicago Times. The Reno investigation increases in interest as it progresses and as the facts connected witli the Little Big Horn fight are coming out. It was stated by the Times in a late review of the evi dence that, unless Lieut. Wallace’s testimony was contradicted, a very clear defence would be established for Maj. Reno. According to his testi mony, Reno crossed the river was at tacked by several thousand Indians, and. after fighting desperately until his ammunition was about exhausted, and the Indians had gained his rear, he charged through them, recrossing the river, where he intrenched himself on the heights.
See moreSee less
He placed the time of re croesing at from 3:30 to 4 o’clock; so that according to his statement, Custer had been attacked and annihilated be fore Reno had obtained his position on the hill. Os course, such a state of things would constitute a complete de fense for Reno, because it obliges a con clusion that Reno fought until reduced to the alternative of retreat or annihi lation, and that, as a good officer, he could only elect to take the former. The same theory kept him engaged un til after Custer had been wiped out, and thereafter he had all he could do to de fend himself until the arrival of Gen. Terry. The limes lias pointed out the strength of this theory, although in viting attention to one weak point in it. This was that, after Reno had taken up his position on the heights, he ordered an advance down the right bank of the river, which would admit two inferences: (1) That there were no great number of Indians about him; and (2) that he knew the direction Custer had taken, because it was along Cu9ter’s trail that the advance was or dered made. It hardly seems logical that Reno expected Custer to come and support him.in view of the fact that he, Reno, ordered this move toward the position of Custer. The Times also iutimated, at the conclusion of Lieut.
Scout Girard testifies that Reno's force panicked and fled across the river despite facing only a small number of Indians, while the bulk of warriors moved to overwhelm Custer's column. His account, which blames Reno for an unnecessary retreat, is contrasted with Lieut. Wallace's more favorable testimony, leaving the inquiry's outcome dependent on which version is believed.
The Cheyenne Daily Leader · 28 January 1879 · page 3
says that the Indians, at first, on the | left bank were in great force; but that, finding that their village was endanger ed by Custer’s advance along the right bank, all of them, save a couple of lundred, went over and finished up uuster, after which they gave their at tention to Reno and Benteen. He tlnuks there was'no reason why lieno shiuld have retreated from the timber on Uie left bank; and.that the retreat wasVa rout in which “devil take the
Salt River Herald · Phoenix, Salt River Valley, Ariz.
A scout named George Herendeen testified at the Reno Court of Inquiry in Chicago that Custer had ordered Reno to advance and take the scouts, promising to follow. The witness also described taking a position during Reno's fight in the valley.
Salt River Herald · 29 January 1879 · page 2
per month; now he gets $72. The ' scout with Gen. Custer, testified that Miiisiiou nit u u.e case o. a tota.iy . ,,e ,., Custer ordor Reno to move disabled new pensioner is whether he ; out and lake the scouts, and he would shall be paid arrearages at the rate of follow. During Reno's fight in the 72 or S per month. The Conimisj yo,Uwitness took a position in a iMiuaitriinii nun iiivu iu itic jtiiuiuiis. sioner of Pensions will a.-k Cou-rrcss
At the Reno Court of Inquiry in Chicago, scout George Herendeen testified that he heard Custer order Reno to advance with the scouts. He described the chaotic fighting in the woods, the death of scout Bloody Knife, and Reno's confused commands before the retreat began.
Daily Los Angeles Herald · 29 January 1879 · page 1
Tbe Riaau ■ uvratlgatleu. CHICAGO, Jan. 28th.—In tbe Reno enquiry to-day Geo. Hern teen, of Bozeman, Mont., who was a scout with Custer, testified that he heard Custer order Reno to move out and take the scouts and be would follow. During Reno's fight In the wood witness took a po sition in a buffalo trail and tired on the Indians. When he left bis rifle pit became upon Reno sitting on bis horse In an opening. Tbe D 'fan scout Bloody Knife sat on bis horse within ten feet of Reuo.
See moreSee less
At this instant, a volley fired by the Indians killed Bloody Knife and wounded one man In the com mand which was drawn up near 'by. He heard Reno give a com mand which he thought was dis mount and immediately afterward he cried mount ami the retreat began. Tbe Uaiiee rassee tbe Antl-L'hlui SB Meeaure.
Testimony at the Reno investigation was reported as largely favorable to the accused officer. Lieutenant Hare argued it was impossible for Reno to have assisted Custer and credited him with saving his command, while scout Herendeen suggested Reno had been hasty in retreating.
The New York Herald · 29 January 1879 · page 7
The Testimony in the Rcuo investigation ycst< rday was on the whole iavorublc to the accused oilicer. Lieutenant Haro thought it im|>osHible for Reno to have assisted Custer, and that credit was duo hiui for having saved his
Scout Herendeen testifies that Reno's sudden retreat from the woods was prompted by panic after Bloody Knife's death, but says he saw no evidence of cowardice. Lieutenant Hare also testifies, describing the pack train's arrival, Reno's tactical decisions, and his own belief that Reno's retreat across the river saved the command.
The New York Herald · 29 January 1879 · page 8
ANSWERING CAPTAIN WHITAKER'S QUESTIONS
vote. Lieutenant Hare was thou recalled, who detailed tlio incident* of the coming up of the pack train, lie having come down iu order to Join Xicno. Just before ho left on thin mission ho heard two distinct volleys tired from where Custer was supposed to be; Major lteuo might, with Captaiu Benteen, have then gone to the assistance ot Custer, leaving his wounded with the pack tralu under Captuiu McDougal. The wituess believed that if lteuo had remained iu the
A witness testifies at the Reno Court of Inquiry about Major Reno's conduct during the Little Bighorn battle, stating he saw no cowardice and praising Reno's decision to retreat across the river as having saved the command. Cross-examination by Mr. Gilbert explores whether Reno could have advanced further or created a diversion to aid Custer, with the witness arguing such moves would have been fatal given the terrain full of Indians.
The New York Herald · 29 January 1879 · page 8
ASKING CAPTAIN WHITAKER'S QUESTIONS
one, since he brought his command out alive. A UOOl) WOItn foil lit NO. The examination concluded with a description of what tho witness saw while burying the dead on the Custer battlefield, and then Mr. Gilbert commenced tho croBs-exsmiuutioji. Witness believed that if Major Reno's command hud gone moitutcd J00 yards farther down tho bottom not a man would ever have gut out alive, and tho command would not have lived more than Ave minutes; ho thought the movement back across the river was the only thing that saved i tho command; it would have been impracticable I for* Reno's command to have continued down the bottom to create u diversion in favor of Custer's I command attacking the Indians at another point, I aiiu luujrvvaiu ikiuu ?
See moreSee less
niniumim iiimii iiui nave moved down the river front the liill where it was enticnched, for the whole country in front wan filled with Indiana. Tho name of Captain Pe Rndio was then called, but as that officer Via sot immediately forth coining it wuii decided to begin the examination to-morrow with Dp liudio's testimony. The court adjourned until eleven o'clock to-morrow.
Testimony continues at the Reno Court of Inquiry, with questioning about why Reno's command abandoned the timber and the killing of an Indian scout. Lieutenant Hare describes the subsequent movements to the hilltop position, the aborted advance toward Custer under Weir, and the belief that Custer would support Reno's attack.
Chicago Daily Tribune · 29 January 1879 · page 3
Instant.” I.IRUT. HAIR was called, and his direct examination resumed, lie thought Uie command might hare remained In Uus timber, with the remaining fifty rounds, by a coo) ami careful use of their ammunition, as long as an hour, although this would depend upon Uin movement of the Indians. It was about an hour and a half from the lime Reno left Custer until Bcnlecn came up. Witness was then ordered by Reno to get the pack-train upas soon as possible. Returning from the pack-train, he was Uliccled to tell Weir to open up communication with Custer, and that Reno would Join them soou.
See moreSee less
The order was execut ed, and Weir set out. The command followed, but the attack upon Wclr by the Indians stmwcil Reno that It wonld be necessary to re turn to the original position. On going back, tbe command was placed around tbe hill In thu form of an ellipse, and in this form received the Indians’ attack. The supposition had been that Custer would support! Reno, mid, ss he had not dnuc so, It was thought that ho must ho somewhere on the line . of advance. Witness also heard tiring In the di rection Custer was supposed to have pursued, lie beard this firing just before lie started for tbe pack-train. The reason the advance move ment was abandoned was that Weir’s position, m llano said, was not a good one for a stand. It wss seen that they must fight for it, and it was Important that a good position should be selected. There was no belief that Custer would send Reno against iho Indians and remain out of the fight himself. As far os bo knew, no Information was received by Reno that Custer was not going to support him. As the result of the battle showed. Custer's flank movement on the Tillage was no support at all. The witness said no heard Bcntccn say that the posltlou last selected on the hill was the best position to make Uie stand, and MaJ. Reno said bo thought so too. The natty young Lieutenant was examined at conslderable’lonuth as lo the geography of thu country In und around the village und the hill and along the river banks. Heno's command, he stated, threatened Hie village, but It did not, as im thought, bold the bulk of the Indians In the village. He did not believe there were more than 1,000 Indians lo the village while Reno was In the timber. THE POSITION IN TUB TIMBER
A witness describes the positions held by Reno's command in the timber and on the hill, estimating Indian strength and discussing whether retreat was necessary. He defends Reno's conduct as cool and his tactics as sound, while describing Custer's presumed movements toward the ford and final positions.
Chicago Daily Tribune · 29 January 1879 · page 3
while Reno was In the timber. THE POSITION IN TUB TIMBER was a good one for defense, lleniccn might have joined Bono, but witness did not think MeDougall, with the paek-truln, etAild. In fact, twenty Indians could have kept McDougnll from getting down the blutfs; they could cither have done that or gotten all bis puck-mutcs. He thought all hope of support from Custer, from the rear, had vanished when Ucno left the tim
A witness testifies before the Reno Court of Inquiry, reconstructing the sequence of Custer's fight and Reno's retreat from the timber, describing troop positions and the fate of the gray-horse column. The witness defends Reno's conduct, arguing his retreat decision saved the command and that cowardice was not evident.
Chicago Daily Tribune · 29 January 1879 · page 3
THE POSITION IN THE TIMBER
been the esse bad Hie men been demoralized. Weir ceased hi* advance movement In the direc tion of Custer’s column because there was a force of 1,500 Indians in sight of his front, und probably mure,who were concealed In the woods. The selection of the tins! stand was the result of the brief consultation between Ucno and Ben teen, the commanding officer ami the second In command. Thu witness was then Interrogated os to the character of the country about ” II,” ami in the course uf his replies said ho regarded the ford ‘•B” as about os good as the ford U A.” Fur ther doa'ii from >r ß,” a number of men were found who were shot in the back, Indicating Unit the Indians had erupt up from behind,—as they could easily do,—and then fireduponthem.
See moreSee less
The position of thu bodies indicated that ihu men were In sklrmlsh-llue. lit hm opinion, Cus ter and Ids men could hardly have lasted oyer three-quarters of an hour. IN RENO'S CONDUCT ON THE HILL,
Witnesses testify at the Reno Court of Inquiry about his battalion's retreat, with conflicting estimates of Indian warrior numbers (6,000 vs. 1,000) and details of the chaotic flight. Lieutenant Varnum's testimony corroborates timing of Custer's movements and confirms Reno personally led the retreat amid disorder.
The Sun · 29 January 1879 · page 3
Th geiitlemm was I a'.owcd by (ierarl.nn Interpreter, WnO had been In th Indian conn try thirty yar. and who "atlninTi'd th" Ind iana at i ion men, perhaps less. This witness wis left ia th tlmts'rby Reno , whn,th but t n' n nl rented lo ttiu rb"r and he saw tii" lore which otrponad It. lie natimntad Ihntnnt o"r on or IWO bundnd Indians. nt theoiitnide, thnntaned Reno when ho rwtnutnd.nnd t'lll"d that ha saw lust re colunm wning down on the rntthnt bnnk ot tba momoht Reno w'-ui tuto netirit, ii, s teetlinony wnn tho flni that was nonflji 'd to mot of time nnd pin Nl, nnd I showed unit Custer must nave seen Reno going into a iton in the vulhir met fa the alters
The piece debates whether Major Reno was aware of Custer's desperate fight and failed to act, suggesting he should face the extreme penalty if so. It weighs conflicting possibilities, including Captain Benteen's alleged request to go to Custer's aid being refused, and considers whether Reno simply lacked knowledge of the battle's full scope.
Public Ledger · 29 January 1879 · page 4
The responsibility of the Custer Mas sacre. Chicago Special. It would seem that the whole mat ter resolves itself into this inquiry as or was not Major Reno aware of the desperate encounter progressing between Custer and the common enemy? If answered affirmatively, he should suffer the extreme penalty ef the law. Not even the most positive assurance that he and his cpmmand would share the impending fa to of their comrades can excuse his making no effort to save them. 1 n the exer cise of a soldier's profession, if he do not seek, at least lie should not fear danger; and how much greater the ob turation if Liu l,.,,tli,.,..j ; i .
See moreSee less
'"vuihd in aims are OCmg overwhelmed ! Better had the entire Seventh Cavalry perished in a common and united effort for victory, than that one-half, by becoming inac tive and impassive spectators should survive the destruction of the others It has been asserted that Captain Lcnteen urged Beno to permit hint to go to the rescue, and was peremptorily relused ; but he is alive, and can speak for himself. What effect would have been produced had Ilentt cut his way through the cordon of Indians in his immediate front and attacked Custer's assailants in the flank or rear, it is difficult to say; but thc battle ot tho Little llig Horn might have termina ted ditlerently. On thc other hand, Keno may have been too remote to hear the tiring or sec any part of the conflict in !, i,. to have comprehended the situation ; and he may have had his hands full. bother he obeyed or disobeyed or ders is not of - much consequence, ex cept as a matter of justice to Custer's, memory. A subordinate commander, when separated from his superior' must be his own guide in the exigen cies that arise, unless they be foreseen and be foreordered ; and, ordinarily we can only ascribe to him lack of or an error in judgment. And just here a word for Custer'
At the Reno court of inquiry in Chicago, scout George Herndon testified about the fighting near the timber and his belief that he heard firing from Custer's doomed command. Captain E. S. Payne also gave testimony establishing the precise distance between Custer's death site and Reno's hilltop entrenchment.
Memphis Daily Appeal · 29 January 1879 · page 2
Hie Iteso In vesttlKatloa. CiiicAuo, January 27. In the Reno inves tigation to-day, George Herndon, of Bosa roan, a scout with Custer, testified that he was with Reno, in the woods, when the fir ing began. The ludians were at first out of range, but the latteradvanced into the weeds aud when Reno withdrew they followed fir ing; the soldiers seemed considerably flightcued, tie heard hung which he then be 1 it: ved was Custer, a suspicion since confirmed Ho stated the fitihting force of the Indian village at thirty-five hundred; didn't believe that the Indians could have driven oue hun dred soldiers from the timber, provided that the latter had plenty of ammunition.
See moreSee less
Captain E. S. Payne, of the Fifth cavalry, testified that the exact distance by measure ment, from the place where Custer was killed to tho Reao entrenchments ou tho hill, was lour miles one hundred and sixty yards.
The report clarifies that Girard, the interpreter who testified at Major Reno's court of inquiry, is not the same person as Frank Gruard, General Crook's scout. It details Gruard's biography as a Sandwich Islander who lived among Sitting Bull's Sioux for years.
The Cheyenne Daily Leader · 29 January 1879 · page 2
From Uie Inter Ocean. There seems to be some misunder standing in the minds of a number who iiave read in our columns thqjull and accurate reports of the inquiry into Maj. Reno's conduct as to wliO Girard, the interpreter, is. It is thought by some that he is the snmb man who was with Gen. Crook in the campaigns of 1870. Girard, the interpreter, who was serving under Gen. Custer at the time of the battle of the Little Big Horn, should not be confounded with
The article recounts frontier scout Frank Gruard's feats during the 1876 campaign, including a dangerous mission to recruit Crow warriors and his role in saving Lieutenant Sibley's scouting party from Sioux and Cheyenne warriors near the Little Bighorn battlefield. It also notes public confusion between Gruard the scout and a separate interpreter named Girard.
The Cheyenne Daily Leader · 29 January 1879 · page 2
tiie season. Another act of Gruard's was the sav ing of the scouting party of twenty five men under Lieut. Sibley. The hos tiles surrounded Sibley's command, and would have wiped them out had not the detachment been dismounted, tho horses left as a target for White Ante lope’s warriors, and the soldiers guided out from among the Indians, who, a short time before, had met Gen. Custer and his brave boys on the Little Big Horn. The party was saved, and got back to Gen. Crook’s camp in tiie most approved “walk-a-heap," i.
See moreSee less
o. infantry style, by footing i£. These aro a few out of many inci dents that might he given of tiie yet short but eyentful life of Gruard. It is but natural that the public should think Girard, the interpreter, and Frank Gruard, tho scout and guide, are one and the same persons.
On the fifteenth day of the Reno Court of Inquiry in Chicago, Lieutenant Charles De Rudio testified about Reno's river crossing, the deployment of the skirmish line, and the chaotic retreat into the timber. De Rudio also described being left behind and hiding from Indians who set fire to the woods, rejoining Reno's command only on the morning of the 27th.
The New York Herald · 30 January 1879 · page 3
MAJOR RENO'S CASE. FIFTEENTH DAY OF THE PROCEEDINGS
TELL WHAT THEY KNOW OF THE MATTER. [BY TELEGRAPH TO THE HERALD.] Chicago, Jmn. 20, 1870. The fifteenth tlay of the lteuo trial opened with ? larger uinuber of spectators than mom!. A number of ladies, who occupied seats immediately behind tho judges, appeared to enter into the spirit of tha proceedings witii as luurh interest p* old soldier*. Lieutenant Charles C. I>e Rndio was the first wit. ness called. Ho is a small man, with florid com. Flexion, wavy iron gray hair, mustache and imperial. He spoke with a marked Italian accent.
See moreSee less
He testified that he was First Lieutenant of the Seventh cavalry, now serving at Fort Meade; he recounted the well known faets regarding, the division of Custer's forces, and 1* -no's orders to advance upon tha Indians; ho described the crossing of the river, saying that lie well'remembero I that lteuo was tha
A witness testifies before the Reno Court of Inquiry about hiding near the Little Bighorn river, observing Reno's skirmish line, and estimating thousands of Indians near the village. He describes a near-fatal mistake when he called out to a mounted figure wearing Captain Tom Custer's clothing, who turned out to be an Indian wearing clothing taken from a massacred soldier.
The New York Herald · 30 January 1879 · page 3
A HAIRBREADTH ESCAPE
A HAIllBHEAPTH KSCPAE. On the morning of the ytlth at break of day tho witness heard a party of mounted men, Indians, crossing the river; he could lmar the splashing of tin-water and the rattling of the ponies'hoofs on the stones; they filed up 011 the bluff; some of them wore soldiers' clothes, and iu the darkness he mistook them for troops; one of them was dressed so mneli like Captain Thomas Custer that