As the Papers Told It

The Hatfields and the McCoys · As the Papers Told It

Act Five

Cupid Ends a Feud

April 1890 – July 1893

Both governors withdrew their rewards, and in February 1891 Cap Hatfield wrote that a general amnesty had been declared. Killings still came now and then, and in 1893 a Kentucky paper reported Cap Hatfield dead, wrongly. In 1893 one paper credited the end of the feud to the wedding of a Hatfield and a McCoy.

Jerry Hatfield reported killed at Logan

A dispatch with a damaged dateline reports Jerry Hatfield killed at Logan House by M. C. Lee, a man connected with the McCoys, whose weapon was ‘a Springfield of the army pattern’. A torn line seems to call Jerry a son of Devil Anse, but no later clipping in the set mentions this killing, and the list of sons Devil Anse gave the Wheeling Intelligencer names no Jerry.

The Beatrice Daily Express · Beatrice, Neb.

The Beatrice Daily Express · 3 April 1890 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

[-McCoy] Feud. [-], Va., April 3.—Intelligence [illegible] just been received here [that Sat]urday night Jerry Hatfield, [son o]f "Devil" Anse, and intimately [connected with t]o the Hatfields, who have been [engage]d in the well known feud along [B]ig Sandy, was killed at Logan House by a man named M. C. Lee, connected with the McCoys. The [shooting] occurred about 3 o'clock [a.m.], and Lee's weapon was a Springfield of the army pattern. Hatfield [was shot] through the body. There is a [great deal] of excitement over this fresh [murder a]nd it is probable there will [be furth]er trouble.

See the clipping

Peace talk, and a hundred indictments

A Pennsylvania paragraph passes on word that the feud is said to be settled, and that men who were shooting at each other a year ago have shaken hands. It wonders whether peace will dispose of the ‘hundred or so indictments for murder’ still hanging over them. It is the first of this act's many announcements that the feud is over.

The Somerset Herald · Somerset, Pa.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out. CorrectionThis set right 3 earlier articles: The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer, 4 September 1890, Daily Kennebec Journal, 8 September 1890, San Antonio Daily Light, 8 September 1890.

The Somerset Herald · 10 September 1890 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

The Hatfield-McCoy feud in West Virginia is said to have been settled, and those who a year ago were merrily shooting at each other have shaken hands and buried the hatchet. But will this end the hundred or so indictments for murder hanging over their heads?

See the clipping

A McCoy shot down by a McCoy

A Charleston dispatch confirms that on 30 October 1890 Bud McCoy, a deputy sheriff, was fired on from behind as he rode past Ples. McCoy and Bill Dyer in Pike county, his body riddled and his head pounded with a rock. The quarrel was not with the Hatfields: Ples. McCoy said Aaron Smith, whose sister Bud had eloped with and deserted, offered him a Winchester and a new revolver to fire first.

Richmond Dispatch · Richmond, Va.

Richmond Dispatch · 13 November 1890 · page 5 · transcribed from the page image

THE KILLING OF BUD M'COY.

Verification of the Report and Other Interesting Incidents of the Tragedy.

See moreSee less

[Special telegram to the Dispatch.]

Charleston, W. Va., November 12.—The rumored killing of Bud McCoy, one of the notorious Hatfield-McCoy party, has been verified and the particulars received here. It seems that on the 30th of October Bud McCoy, having eaten dinner with one John Goshom, in Pike county, Ky., started away from the house on horseback. A short distance away he met Ples. McCoy and Bill Dyer, who as soon as he had gotten by opened fire and put a number of bullets into him. He died instantly, but the pair continued their fire, riddling his body. They pounded his head with a rock to be sure he was dead.

ANOTHER FIGHT.

The pair then fled, but a posse was soon made up and started in pursuit. They were followed several days and overtaken in Buchanan county, Va. A fight ensued, in which McCoy was slightly wounded. He then surrendered, by Dyer escaped and is still at large, though a heavy reward is offered for him. From what can be learned it would seem that one Aaron Smith is at the bottom of the killing, and Ples. McCoy, after his arrest, even said that Smith had offered him a Winchester and a new revolver if he would fire the first shot.

ELOPED WITH HIS SISTER.

The murdered man eloped some time ago with Smith's sister and later deserted her. She then married Dyer. Smith escaped from the Pike county jail last summer, and Bud McCoy, as deputy sheriff, attempted to arrest him several times. Smith, enraged at this and at his sister's desertion by McCoy, is said to have been at the bottom of the murder, and is under arrest as an accomplice. Ples. McCoy, who is under arrest for the killing, is a mere boy, not over sixteen years of age.

See the clipping

Waiting on the railroad to bring peace

A Huntington letter to the New York Tribune, reprinted in Indianapolis, puts the dead at about thirty and says nobody has fallen in nearly two years, crediting the governors' withdrawal of rewards. Cap Hatfield is said to be ‘heartily sick of the vendetta’ and studying a borrowed law-book, and a branch of the Norfolk & Western railroad is expected to do more for peace than a dozen proclamations.

The Indianapolis Journal · Indianapolis, Ind.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out. CorrectionThis set right 3 earlier articles: Dodge City Times, 30 January 1891, Richmond Dispatch, 21 February 1891, New-York Tribune, 22 February 1891.

The Indianapolis Journal · 24 February 1891 · page 7 · transcribed from the page image

THE HATFIELD-M'COY FEUD

A Quarrel in Which Thirty Persons Have Been Killed in as Many Years.

See moreSee less

For Two Years Neither Side Has Been on a War Footing, and It Is Hoped the Coming of Railways Will Bring Permanent Peace.

Huntington (W. Va.) Letter in New York Tribune.

Dime novelists and sensational reporters have done much mischief by magnifying the bloody exploits on these borders of a few fighting families. In adjusting their little domestic difficulties, the Hatfields and McCoys have killed about thirty people and maimed and wounded as many more. The Adamses and Bromfields, and the Blaisders and Brewers have tried to imitate them, though on an unpretentious scale. But their crimes have been made a reproach to the whole population. Between the Guyandotte and the Big Sandy lie some of the finest hard-wood lands on the continent. Walnut grows nearly six feet thick, and there are noble poplars as tall and straight as church spires. The soil is spread over great sheets of coal, and the rivers afford good highways for commerce. Yet progress has been retarded and strangers frightened away by false charges of border ruffianism against worthy and peaceable communities.

The Hatfield and McCoy feud dates from the civil war. The Hatfields, who live in West Virginia, were in the confederate army. The McCoys, in Kentucky, organized as "home guards" for the protection of Northern sympathizers. In the hostilities the Hatfields and their friends killed some of the McCoys, and there has been bad blood between them ever since. The first notable outbreak, however, was only about ten years ago, when Ellison Hatfield was murdered in an election brawl on the Kentucky side of the Tug fork of the Big Sandy river. His assailants, three McCoy boys, were seized by the Hatfields, tied to poplar bushes and riddled with bullets. The McCoys then began a series of raids into West Virginia, and succeeded in landing several of the Hatfields in Kentucky jails. In retaliation, "Jim" Vance and a gang of Hatfield sympathizers crossed into Kentucky one New Year's night, burned the McCoy house and shot one of the McCoys as he fled. Among the inmates were several women and children, who were driven out in their night-dresses. Alafray McCoy, the eldest daughter, was slain on the spot by a half-witted fellow named Mountz, who was afterward hanged in Kentucky. Meantime the Governors of the two States issued requisitions and offered rewards, and a swarm of detectives helped to make mischief. Vance, who was with the Hatfields in the confederate service, was finally killed one afternoon by the McCoys, who are said to have shaken hands over his dead body. Since then the Hatfields have moved back into the country from Tug river, the McCoys have done the same on the Kentucky side, and a truce has been called.

CHARACTER OF THE COMBATANTS.

This feud has never included more than the Hatfields and their immediate relatives, a few desperadoes in hiding in the mountains and some almost equally lawless detectives. The fighting has not spread beyond the banks of the Big Sandy, where the Hatfields have been hunting and raising corn since their ancestors came from the Valley of Virginia one-hundred years ago. Their neighbors are rude and sturdy backwoodsmen, narrowed by continual intermarriage and the lack of railroads, but without any passion for bloodshed. When the Tollivars were disporting themselves in Kentucky a few years ago a band of "Regulators" restored order by removing their chief, and if this affair had been confined to one State the leaders would have suffered long ago, but the situation is peculiar. The Hatfields at home are quiet and well behaved. Their excesses have all been committed on the Kentucky side, while in West Virginia the McCoys are the aggressors. Consequently the requisitions for arrest have always come from another State, and many innocent people have been indicted. Now, nobody cares to give up his friends to outsiders, with the chance of seeing them unjustly condemned, and this reluctance has shielded the true culprits. It is strenuously denied that the Hatfields terrorize their neighbors. Yet, instead of their meeting with open condemnation, the Governor has been asked to protect them. They are condoled with over the kidnaping of their allies; men slap them on the back and exchange jokes with them, as though murder were a humane and polite diversion, and they ride into town with their rifles slung over their shoulders and bargain in the stores and buy and sell bank stock like so many thrifty deacons. The disposition to regard them as a sort of cross between John Howard and Michael the Archangel, and the McCoys as a depraved combination of Judas Iscariot and Billy the Kid, is, however, dying out. It is seen that both sides are to blame, and some people are not afraid to say so.

The administration of the local courts in the past has not been what it should be. A single fearless editor or preacher could probably have stopped the trouble long ago. But the local sheets are timid, and at church the belligerents stack their arms and pray with one eye on the pastor and another on the door. Some of the magistrates to save expenses have actually hesitated to imprison criminals. The present circuit judge, however, will not be trifled with. At every term there is a string of convictions for carrying concealed weapons, and he inflicts in all cases the full penalty of fine and imprisonment without regard to anybody's brag or threats. The recent withdrawal of all rewards by the Governors of the two States seems to have worked well. Nobody has fallen in the fued for nearly two years, and the survivors are trying to live decently. "Cap" Hatfield, the son of "Bad Anse," is heartily sick of the vendetta, and realizes that under other circumstances he might have been something better than an outlaw. He taught himself to read and write, and for a man brought up in the mountains, is credited with a "right smart of business sense." He has read much history and "got in some pretty good snatches on medicine," and just now is wrestling with a borrowed law-book. He married the widow of a man killed in ambush, outside of the feud, and has a pretty daughter. It is due to his adroit management that the Hatfields have not been surrendered. His father, "Bad Anse" or "Devil Anse," as he is affectionally nicknamed, is the present Hatfield patriarch. He, too, is tired of sleeping on a Winchester, is declared to be inoffensive when no McCoys are about, and says he is willing to let the whole thing drop if they are. As an earnest, both men are laying down their rifles, though they wear a few revolvers "for protection," and the father has subscribed toward the building fund of a new Methodist church. The women, although "raised to it," are unconquerably averse to sudden bereavement. Vance's widow boasts that she can "bring down a squirrel from the highest treetop, every pop," but most of them shine better as house-keepers. Alafray McCoy was a religious woman, and when Mountz threatened her said she had prayed for her enemies for years.

THE RAILWAY AS A PEACE-MAKER.

The combatants now live thirty miles apart, and the railroad that will soon separate them will probably do more to promote peace than a dozen proclamations. In the border counties the hills are high, the forests thick, and the rivers swift and deep. There are no turnpikes and no telegraphs, and the sheriffs have to ride on horseback over blind trails and to ford dangerous currents. A train service will alter all that. By next summer the railroad, a branch of the Norfolk & Western, will be finished but for the piercing of a long tunnel. The inhabitants, in anticipation of fresh prosperity, are anxious to efface the stain fastened on them. "Of course," they say, "we have our faults, but we are as good as most backwoods communities. There has been only one arrest for theft in Logan county, and the charge was not proved. We have no locks on our doors, except at a few of the stores, and the keys of those are lost. The chickens roost on the fences and the apple trees, and are they ever stolen? The coverlets that our women weave are stored in our porches. The hams we cure hang outside in rows. Our corn-cribs are open to everybody, and are they ever pilfered? If you want to know what hospitality means, ride over and see us. You'd be safer with a pocketful of greenbacks in Logan county than in walking up and down Broadway in New York city. As to our intelligence, of course we have no Browning societies and circulating libraries. But we follow the news and get journals from New York and Cincinnati. We have two pretty good hotels. Next spring we shall have a bank, and we're building a stone church. Our children get four months' schooling. Several of our people are worth $50,000, and all of us keep the run of politics."

I have asked many of the best men who are trying to reform the district what guarantee they offer to strangers. Their reply is substantially: "Don't encourage people to come here who can't put up with a rough country and rough ways. Don't tell them we are models of virtue, or that our notions of social intercourse are all sound. But do say that we are not all cut-throats and thieves. Say that the feuds are strictly family affairs, and that neutrals are unmolested. We are not fond of swaggering and flourishing fire-arms, and the man who has killed the greatest number of people isn't the most looked up to. If we don't refuse to associate with the Hatfields, it isn't because we think they have done right. What we need is somebody to persuade us that the greatest virtue is not in being peaceable only when let alone. When we have learned that, you can trust us to behave."

See the clipping

Cap Hatfield announces a general amnesty

The Wheeling Intelligencer prints a letter to the Wayne News, signed Cap. Hatfield on 24 February 1891, announcing that ‘A general amnesty has been declared’, though the paper's headlines credit Devil Anse. It reprints parts of Anse's 1889 story, which traces the first trouble to a sow and pigs in 1873, and a statement Mounts made before his death: ‘I don't blame the McCoy's. The Hatfield's brought me to this.’

The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · Wheeling, W. Va.

The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · 23 March 1891 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

The End

OF THE HATFIELD-McCOY FEUD.

See moreSee less

Peace Declared by "Devil Anse," the Fearless Leader of the Hatfields.

THE FACTIONS AT PEACE AGAIN.

Resume of the History of the Bloody Vendetta From its Start to the Present.

As Told to the Intelligencer by "Devil Anse" Himself and in the Confession of Ellison Hatfield—Bloody Deeds Recalled—The State no Longer to Bear the Disgrace Under Which it Has Rested—A Thrilling Story Worth Repeating.

The famous Hatfield-McCoy-feud, the most noted family war in the history of American vendettas, has ended at last. Peace has been declared, hostilities have ceased and Captain Anse Hatfield, better known as "Devil Anse," the head of the West Virginia faction has graciously granted amnesty and announced that his war spirit has abated. The following letter, which appears in the Wayne News, tells an interesting story and explains itself:

Editor Wayne News:

I ask space in your valuable paper for these few lines. A general amnesty has been declared in the famous Hatfield and McCoy feud, and I wish to say something of the old and the new. I do not wish to keep the old feud alive and I suppose that everybody, like myself, is tired of the names of "Hatfield and McCoy," and the "Border Warfare" in time of peace. The war spirit in me has abated and I sincerely rejoice at the prospect of peace. I have devoted my life to arms. We have undergone a fearful loss of noble lives and valuable property in the struggle. We being, like Adam, not the first transgressors. Now I propose to rest in a spirit of peace,

Yours Respectfully.

Cap. Hatfield,

Logan County, W. Va., Feb. 24, '91.

THE FAMOUS VENDETTA.

In this connection a brief history of the great feud, which has been famous the country over for years and has caused so much bloodshed, will prove of interest. Though books have been written about the deeds of the Hatfields and McCoys upon the southern border of West Virginia, and a number of metropolitan newspapers have sent special correspondents into Logan county, W. Va., and Pike county, Ky., to obtain information upon which were based hair raising stories greatly exaggerated, the INTELLIGENCER is the only paper that has ever published an authentic history of the vendetta. This history was, on the 21st of November, 1889, obtained by the INTELLIGENCER from "Devil Anse" Hatfield himself, while on trial at Charleston for violation of the revenue laws, and published the following day.

"DEVIL ANSE'S" STORY.

From Anse's story the following facts are taken: Contrary to the general impression, which is that the feud dates back to the civil war, the first trouble occurred in 1873, when a difficulty rose between Floyd Hatfield, a cousin of Anse, and Randolph McCoy, who had married sisters, over a sow and pigs. A law suit followed,

"Some time subsequently my son Johnston and Rosanna McCoy, a daughter of Randolph McCoy, ran away from home to get married. The McCoys headed off the fleeing couple, and Rosanna, bare-footed, bare-headed, riding a bare-backed horse, made her way to the Hatfields under cover of darkness and informed them that Jonse Hatfield had been scooped in by the McCoys. The Hatfields formed an armed posse, headed by Anse who went a near way through the woods, caught up with the McCoys, overpowered them without a fight, and rescued Jonse, returning home with him. They were then happily married. In a few years, however, Rosanna deserted Jonse, and is now living with Phillips, the leader of the McCoy outlaws, in Pike county, Kentucky.

MURDER OF ELLISON HATFIELD.

"Some twelve months after the above occurrence, Tolbert Farmer and Randall and Floyd McCoy, who were still angered over the hog suit already described, and more so on account of the prosecution for the murder of Stratton, went to the election precinct where my brother Ellison voted and murdered him by cutting and shooting him literally to pieces.

"For this offense they were arrested, and when they were taken to the mouth of Blackberry creek for trial, by the Hatfields as guards for the officers, the McCoys gathered a posse to rescue them. They were taken across Tug river in a skiff to keep them from being rescued by the McCoy mob. Charles Carpenter, Alexander Messer, Daniel White and some others were the guards. To get them in a still safer place, they were taken to a point up Mate's creek, in Logan county. They were ordered by the Hatfields to take the prisoners to the Pike county jail, in Kentucky. After they got them across Tug river, while Charley Carpenter was bossing the job, on the Kentucky side of the river, three of the men were killed. Floyd was the only one who made his escape. Soon afterward Alex. Messer, Ellison Mounts, three of the Mahones, and Valentine Hatfield were arrested for the murders.

"Mounts was tried and sentenced to be hung. Four others were sentenced to the penitentiary for life; among the number is Valentine Hatfield, who was absolutely not on the Kentucky side of the rivers when the murders were committed, but the McCoys swore him through.

KNEW NOTHING OF THE MURDERS.

"Seventeen other West Virginians have been indicted on the charge of being parties to that murder, myself and my sons Jonse and Cap being among the number, although as a matter of fact we knew nothing of the murders until several days after they had been committed.

"Nothing was done with these indictments for five years or more, until a lawyer named P. H. Cline, of Pike county, got up a petition, carried it to Governor Buckner, and induced him to offer a reward of $1,500 for the arrest of the Hatfields.

"Frank Phillips gathered up a posse of upwards of twenty men, armed to the teeth. They came across into West Virginia and killed an old man by the name of Vance, whom they claimed had killed Harmon M'Coy some time during the war. Deputy Sheriff Thompson

SUMMONED A POSSE

and started in pursuit. They met on Grape Vine creek, near the State line. The Phillips men refused to surrender, and opened fire on the officers. Little Bill Dempsey, one of the Sheriff's guards, was shot in the leg. McCoy was wounded in the shoulder. Dempsey crawled into a shuck pen with his broken limb, and way crying for water, when Dave Stratton, James McCoy, Sam Miller, Frank Phillips and two other men came up. The began to abuse the wounded man. He told them he was summoned by the Sheriff as a guard, and had to pursue them. Frank Phillips walked up close to where he was lying, drew his revolver and shot his brains out with one shot from his revolver. This is a straight statement of the feud up to this day (November 21, 1889). Every man in Logan county who knows me will tell you I am a peaceful, law-abiding man, and no man will say I ever told a fasehood. In this contest I have only defended myself, as any man would do under similar circumstances.

His

(Signed) ANDERSON X HATFIELD.

Mark.

With the subsequent events, newspaper readers are familiar—how an Inter-state complication grew out of the demand of Governor Wilson on the Governor of Kentucky for the surrender of the prisoners in the Pike county jail, referred to in Hatfield's story, and how the complications were settled by the U. S. Supreme court, sustaining the right of the Kentucky authorities to hold the prisoners. Ellison Mounts (or Hatfield) was afterward hanged in Kentucky. Before his death he made a statement, from which the following is an extract:

BEWAILING HIS FATE.

"I don't blame the McCoy's. The Hatfield's brought me to this. I was forced to do as I did. Twice they came after me with guns, telling me to come on and take the lives of those who had killed my father. I saw his murderers shot, and I was at the burning of the cabin. I can't go into details. My guilt was not as great as Aleck Messer's or Wall Hatfield's or the White's, who turned State's evidence. Yet my life pays forfeit, while they are permitted to live.

"No, I do not look for a commutation of sentence. Nobody seems to be doing anything for me. My lawyers come here and talk to me; then go away and forget that I am alive."

BORN OUT OF WEDLOCK.

The doomed man's parents were both Hatfields—cousins, who loved not wisely but too well. After being discarded by her cousin lover, young Ellison's mother married a man named Mounts. Ellison was a mere boy at the time his father was killed, but at the time of the shooting of Aliferi McCoy, for which deed he suffered death, he had reached manhood and been married. His wife has died since his incarceration.

One of the outgrowths of the feud was the lynching, in October, 1889, of Green McCoy and Haley by a mob of Lincoln county citizens.

HISTORY OF THE HATFIELDS.

From the story given to the INTELLIGENCER by Devil Anse, the following interesting history of the Hatfields is taken:

"My grandfather, Valentine Hatfield, was born in Russell county, Va. My grandmother, Elizabeth Vance, was a native of the same county. Eight boys and three girls were born to them. My father was Ephraim Hatfield, who was born in Logan county, Virginia, in 1812. He married Nancy Vance, of Russell county, Virginia, in 1837, and to them were born eighteen children, eight of whom died when young. Six boys and four girls lived to manhood and womanhood. These six were Valentine, Anderson (they call me Anse), Ellison, Elias, Smith, Patterson, Martha, Elizabeth, Emma and Biddy.

"I was born September 9, 1838, and married Lavisa Chapin, April 18, 1861. Twelve children were born to us, vis: Johnson, William A., usually called 'Cap;' which nick name was given him when a small boy and has hung to him ever since; Robert E. Lee, Elliott, Elias, Detroit, Joseph, Willis Wilson. The daughters are Nancy B., who was captured by John T. Vance May 16, 1889—the only one of my family ever captured by anybody dead or alive (He meant she married Vance), Mary, Elizabeth and Rosada.

"I served in the militia in 1861, and regularly enlisted in 1862 in the Confederate army, as First Lieutenant in the Forty-fifth Virginia Infantry. I resigned in 1863, and then recruited a company which was kept in service in Wayne, Cabell and other border counties of West Virginia and Kentucky.

"Jonse, Marion and Tom McCoy (who are now trying to kill me), were members of my company during the war."

ELLISON'S CONFESSION.

During his confinement in the Pike county (Ky.) jail, awaiting his doom upon the scaffold, Ellison Hatfield sent to the INTELLIGENCER a long confession over his own signature. His statements were voluntary, were dictated by him to the prosecuting attorney and created a great sensation. Its most interesting features would make a long newspaper article, and as it is confirmatory of "Devil Anse's" story it is unnecessary to reproduce it. Among other things he described graphically the scene at the time the Hatfields and their followers, intrenched in the mountains of Logan county, took a terrible oath to revenge themselves on the McCoys. He then details the long list of bloody tragedies that followed, and tells minutely the story of the murders in which he was directly concerned. In the last massacre the McCoys suffered terrible loss in revenge for the murder of Ellison Hatfield, Sr. In that tragedy it was young Ellison's own hand that took the life of the girl Alifari. He thus describes the attack on the McCoy house on the Kentucky side of the line:

A THRILLING STORY.

We began shooting through the doors of what we called the big house in opposite directions. There were several shots fired from the inside of the house, and the shooting continued for some time from inside and out.

Calvin McCoy got upstairs and shot one of our party. Jim Vance, sr., went to the house and found some cotton hanging against the side. He lit it with a match and placed part of it in a joist hole, and the rest against the shutter of the door. Two shots were fired through the door from the inside of the house. We heard Calvin McCoy call to the girls (his sisters), who were in the kitchen, to go out and put out the fire. Vance said: "Boys, if they come out, d—d them, shoot them."

About this time a girl opened the door of the kitchen and Cap. and Johns both cried to me: 'D—n her, kill her.' I had a 32 calibre Winchester rifle, I fired at her and she fell in the doorway. I heard her sister ask her if she was hurt. She muttered something, but I could not understand it. I heard one of the girls say: "Farewell sister." Calvin McCoy called down stairs to know if any one was killed and one of the girls said, "Yes, they have killed Alifari." The firing from both sides kept up for some time, until I was shot through the left arm by Calvin McCoy. The ball entered just above the wrist below the elbow. Cap. and Johns Hatfield both told me afterward that they killed Calvin McCoy. They were both bragging about it, and each one claimed that he killed him. But I think from the position of the two that Cap killed Calvin McCoy. Three of our party was wounded. Tom Mitchel was shot in the right hand, shooting off three of his fingers and some of the shots went into his belt. Johns Hatfield was shot in the top of the right shoulder. He had on a heavy overcoat and the shots only entered the flesh very slightly, I saw the shots taken out. They were bird shot. We did not know that we had killed Calvin McCoy until the next day.

When we left the house it was in a good flame. The women were crying and begging for help to put out the fire. We returned to West Virginia by the same route that we came. I fainted on the way from loss of blood. We arrived at Cap Hatfield's about daylight and took breakfast.

THE HATFIELD CHARACTER.

Many things that have been printed about the vendetta are pure fabrications, and in most of them the Hatfields have had great injustice done them. It has been many months since there has been any trouble on the border between the families in the feud.

If Anse Hatfield and his friends had been left alone in peace by the Kentuckians it is safe to say that the public would have heard the last of hostilities long ago.

No more hospitable, honest or peacefully disposed people live than the Hatfields. Their enemies were the aggressors, and the blows they have struck have been in revenge for the unprovoked butchery of their nearest and best loved relatives.

Bad as the history of the feud is, it should be borne in mind that it was a family war and that the peace of no one else was disturbed. The quarrels and wholesale shedding of blood was solely in a revengeful warfare—no depredations were committed on the property of other people. They were at peace with all the world but themselves. Those who know them describe them as honest, thrifty, well-to-do citizens who would not harm a hair upon the head of anyone who had done them no injury.

See the clipping

Peace declared, and a wedding promised

The Springfield Republican declares the greatest of American vendettas at an end: an unnamed McCoy daughter is to marry an unnamed Hatfield youth, with a barbecue in a Wayne county poplar grove for every Hatfield and McCoy alive. It reprints Cap's letter, ‘The war spirit in me has abated’, puts the dead at probably not more than 30, not 200, and notes Devil Anse has joined the Methodist church.

Springfield Weekly Republican · Springfield, Mass.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 6 days later. CorrectionThis set right 3 earlier articles: The Columbus Journal, 1 April 1891, Staunton Spectator, 1 April 1891, Staunton Spectator, 1 April 1891.

Wrong

Springfield Weekly Republican · 3 April 1891 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

PEACE DECLARED ON THE BIG SANDY.

The greatest of American vendettas is at an end, for the Hatfields and McCoys have agreed to fight no more. Rumors of an impending settlement of this famous feud have been spread abroad of late, but have found little acceptance by a public that has been reading for years of sudden bereavements on the banks of the Big Sandy river. But there is no cause for further incredulity. The approaching marriage of the most beautiful and accomplished daughter of the house of McCoy to the most available youth with a whole skin remaining on the Hatfield side was announced several days ago. A monster barbecue will follow the wedding ceremony in a Wayne county (W. Va.) poplar grove, and it will be attended by all the Hatfields and McCoys alive. Such an event alone is sufficient to silence the most skeptical. As if to make doubly sure, however, "Cap" Hatfield, son of the old leader, "Devil 'Anse,' writes the following lines to the Wayne County News, under date of February 24:—

See moreSee less

I ask space in your valuable paper for these few lines. A general amnesty has been declared in the famous Hatfield-McCoy feud, and I wish to say something of the old and the new. I do not wish to keep the old feud alive, and I suppose that everybody, like myself, is tired of the names "Hatfield" and "McCoy," and the words "border warfare" in time of peace. The war spirit in me has abated, and I sincerely rejoice at the prospect of peace. I have devoted my life to arms. We have undergone a fearful loss of noble lives and valuable property in the struggle. Now I propose to rest in a spirit of peace.

The Hatfield-McCoy feud, which has made Wayne county in West Virginia and Pike county in Kentucky bloody ground for 30 years, had its rise in the hostilities of the civil war. Since then, according to the popular impression, some 200 lives have been sacrificed in family warfare; yet that impression is an exggerated one. Probably from first to last the list of dead does not number more than 30 people, although as many more have been wounded and much property has been burned or destroyed on both sides. The Hatfields, who for 100 years have lived. on the banks of the Big Sandy river on the West Virginia side, gave their support to the confederate cause; while the McCoys on the Kentucky side organized in defense of the North. During the war numerous McCoys were sacrificed by sundry Hatfields, and the McCoys could not forgive or forget even after the surrender at Appomattox. The McCoys waited until about 10 years ago for their blood revenge, and then one day three McCoy boys murdered Ellison Hatfield in an election brawl on the Kentucky side of the Tug fork of the Big Sandy. The Hatfields soon retaliated by tying those three McCoys to poplar trees and filling them with lead. Then the McCoys inaugurated a series of raids into West Virginia territory, which resulted in the incarceration of a lot of Hatfields in Kentucky jails. In retaliation for these outrages a band of Hatfields with their Logan county sympathizers, led by the notorious "Jim" Vance, crossed into Kentucky one New-year's night and burned the McCoy mansion to the ground, turning the inmates, men, women and children, out of doors without other covering than their night clothes. One McCoy was shot on this occasion and Alafray McCoy, the eldest daughter, was killed by a half-witted hanger-on in the Hatfield camp. The McCoys afterward hunted down "Jim" Vance and are said to have gravely shaken hands over his dead body.

These murderous deeds, of which the few herein mentioned were the most conspicuous, reached their culmination in a state of actual warfare about four years ago. The governors of the two states have issued requisitions without number; they have offered rewards for the capture of the outlaws, and many a sheriff has attempted to make a Hatfield or a McCoy his prize, but without much success. As each side did their butchering upon the soil of another state, the processes of law have been slow and uncertain. Moreover, each house in its own community has been as orderly and well-governed as any family in the county. Only at the objects of his hatred across the line has a McCoy or a Hatfield raised his rifle or aimed a blow. And thus the community surrounding each house has protected its members from the punishment of their atrocious deeds. The law has been baffled at almost every point, and the truth is that the cure has finally worked itself. The antagonists have heard from the outside world and have grown ashamed of themselves. For nearly two years past a truce has been maintained, and the withdrawal of the rewards for their capture seems to have stimulated the settlement that has come. The two families some time ago moved further back into their respective states, so that today 30 miles separate the trajectories of their rifles. "Cap" Hatfield is considerable of a man at bottom, and has managed to acquire a book education that is uncommon in those parts. "Cap" long since grew tired of sleeping on his rifle. And then, not long ago, old "Devil Anse," the Hatfield patriarch, joined the Methodist church. That was more than the feud could stand. It went to pieces like a string of beads suddenly left stringless. It will never rise again in the old form, because the iron horse, a great civilizer, is already snorting in the wilderness that lies about the Big Sandy river.

The civilization of Logan and Pike counties has been made to suffer more than it deserved because of this vendetta. Although, as in all backwoods communities, human life has not been held at its real value, in other respects the very extreme of virtue has been reached. In Logan county there has been recorded, it is said, but one case of theft and then the charge was not proved. A resident has said:—

We have no locks on our doors, except a few of the stores, and the keys of those are lost. The chickens roost on the fences and the apple-trees, and are they ever stolen? The coverlets that our women weave are stored in our porches. The hams we cure hang outside in rows. Our corn-cribs are open to everybody, and are they pilfered? If you want to know what hospitality means, ride over and see us. You'd be safer with a pocketful of greenbacks in Logan county than walking up and down Broadway in New York city.

The regret will be felt in contemplating the new civilization that is coming into that primitive community, that in the uplifting process extreme virtues as well as extreme vices will undergo modification. The slaughter of men and women will cease, but the days when chickens can roost upon the fences with impunity are numbered. Thievery will increase in Logan county, but on the whole the change will be for the better.

See the clipping

A warning from a Texas feud

Reprinted in Salem, Oregon, from the Chicago Tribune, this piece doubts the peace news: ‘The Hatfield-McCoy feud may be over, and it may not.’ Feuds end, it argues, only when one family dies out. Its proof is the Morton-Cummins feud in Texas, where the last Cummins and Dan Morton made up in a saloon, fell out again within half an hour, and Cummins was shot dead by the other Morton.

Paper unidentified

Paper unidentified · 2 June 1891 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image

THE END OF A FEUD.

It Usually Comes When There Are Not Enough Survivors to Take Sides.

See moreSee less

The Hatfield-McCoy feud may be over, and it may not. In all the cases ever known the feud died only when one of the families did the same. The Morton-Cummins feud in Texas belonged to this class.

The only man left of those two families now is Dan Morton. Three years ago he was dealing faro in El Paso. His face is like leather, and he is about as tough. Fear is a thing he does not know. He will probably die in his boots, because men of that sort are never pleasant to have about, and the community revolts occasionally.

But, to go back. How the thing started doesn't matter especially. Probably in the same way that it ended—in a saloon quarrel. This much is known: A Cummins shot a Morton; then the thing went on with deadly regularity until some six or seven had been killed on either side. Finally there were only two Mortons and one Cummins left. The latter had just killed one of his opponents and he lit out for other parts and kept away for a good many months.

One day Cummins came back. Everybody was offering bets that Dan Morton would shoot him on sight. Cummins thought so, too, but he had come back to try and settle the thing peaceably if he could, otherwise if it had to be. The two met in the natural course of events, and both started to reach for their guns. Cummins said his say, though, before the other got the cinch on him.

"Dan," he said, "this thing's gone far enough, an' I reckon we might as well quit. There's only me left, an' you too. Now what's the use of it, anyway?"

It struck Dan sort of reasonably, and he put up his gun.

"Believe ye're about right," he said. With that the two went into the Red Front saloon, and in another ten minutes the two were patting each other on the back, and telling each other what a pity it was they hadn't known before what good fellows they both were. They kept feeling better and better.

"An' none of it need hev happened," said Morton, "ef your Tom hadn't shot Morton."

"He didn't do it," said Cummins.

"He did."

The denial was too much for Cummins.

"You lie!" he hissed, and then in a minute all the sworn friendship of the last half hour went to the four winds and forgetfulness, and those two closed in a deadly struggle. Each was trying to reach for the other's gun. They surged all over the saloon. No one interfered for a while.

Then the other Morton, who had not trusted the newly made reconciliation, and had kept close by, stepped up to the two, and putting his pistol to Cummins' head, literally shot his head all to pieces.

And that ended the feud. The other Morton was killed shortly afterward in an ordinary quarrel, and Dan is now the only one left.—Chicago Tribune.

See the clipping

Captain Hatfield reported killed by his men

A Nevada paper reports it is believed the feud has at last ended, because ‘Captain Hatfield, the leader of one of the factions’ has been shot and killed by members of his own gang after a quarrel. The report was wrong. Cap Hatfield was captured in November 1896, charged with three election-day killings at Matewan, and Devil Anse, whom a Wheeling paper had called Captain Anse Hatfield, surrendered to a posse in 1899.

The Silver State · Unionville, Nev.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 6 days later.

Wrong

The Silver State · 8 April 1892 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

It is believed that the famous Hatfield-McCoy feud in Kentucky has been at last brought to an end. Captain Hatfield, the leader of one of the factions was shot and killed the other day by members of his own gang with whom he quarreled.

See the clipping

A life sentence for Pleasant McCoy

A Bristol special relayed from Louisville reports that on 6 October 1892 Pleasant McCoy, of the McCoy faction, was convicted of murder in Pike county and sentenced to life imprisonment for killing his cousin, named here as Bird McCoy. The Richmond Dispatch had told the story in November 1890 as the killing of Bud McCoy by Ples. McCoy, then a boy not over sixteen.

The Morning News · Savannah, Ga.

The Morning News · 7 October 1892 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

Pleasant McCoy Convicted. Louisville, Ky., Oct. 6.—A special to the Times from Bristol, Tenn., says: "Pleasant McCoy, a member of the McCoy faction of the famous Hatfield-McCoy feud, was to-day convicted of murder in Pike county, Kentucky, and sentenced to life imprisonment. He was convicted of the murder of his cousin, Bird McCoy."

See the clipping

Kentucky's mountain feuds called finished

A Los Angeles Herald survey counts eight eastern Kentucky feuds since the war and says the Hatfield-McCoy feud ended when the state captured its participants: ‘Wils Jennings and the Hatfields are in the penitentiary.’ Most of it concerns the Tollivers of Rowan county and Pennsylvania's Cooley gang. Wall Hatfield had gone to prison in 1889, but Cap Hatfield was free in November 1896, when he was charged with three killings at Matewan.

Los Angeles Herald · Los Angeles, Calif.

Los Angeles Herald · 13 November 1892 · page 10 · transcribed from the page image

PASSING OF THE FEUDS.

Last of the Tollivers, Cooleys, Hatfields and Their Kind.

See moreSee less

ALL EAST KENTUCKY IS AT PEACE.

Why the Mountainous Regions of the South Produced So Many Family Wars. The Topography Attracted That Sort of People and the War Demoralized Them.

THE Cooley gang is no more. The dispatch which gave this interesting information added this significant sentence: "People of this section [about Uniontown, Pa.] are breathing more freely now." In the Middle Ages in Italy, in the days of Saxon and Norman in England, or Gael and Saxon in Scotland, or Saxon and Celt in Ireland, this would have sounded natural enough. But why should there be a "gang" in peaceful Pennsylvania? Why feuds in Kentucky?

Well, it isn't easy to explain to a foreigner or even to an Atlantic coast Yankee, yet it is a fact that here and there in all the states which have mountainous regions, and in all the new states, a few feuds linger on in civilization's track as reminders of the barbarism of our distant forefathers. They are unique now and worthy of the newspaper reader's especial attention because of their rarity, though there was a time when they were so common that except where the station of the participants was high, as in the case of the Marmion-Douglas row, or where there was some frill of romance attached, as in the Montague-Capulet quarrel, the gossiping chroniclers of the day made no more mention of them than a newspaper nowadays does of a plain murder.

The general rule is that these feuds continue till all the desperate men on both sides are killed, or the state government comes in with overwhelming force and captures all the participants, or some peculiarly horrible tragedy creates such widespread disgust and rage that the parties to the feud abandon it and the country in a general panic. The Sutton-Taylor feud of Texas, probably the worst ever known in America, terminated in the first named way. Every man in it was killed (about a hundred in all) except John Wesley Hardin, and the state hanged him. The Hatfield-McCoy feud of Kentucky and West Virginia terminated by the second method. And the long feud in Kemper county, Miss., ended in a massacre of the Chisholm family and its supporters, which left nobody to keep up that side of the controversy.

No census has ever been taken of the feuds in eastern Kentucky. Those since the war, sufficient to interest the nation, have been eight in number. They were the Turner-Sizemore feud, in Knott county; the Strong and the Little feuds, in Breathitt county; the Martin-Tolliver war, in Rowan county; the Turner-Sowders feud, in Bell county; the Turner-Howard quarrel, in Hardin county; the Hatfield-McCoy feud, on the West Virginia border, in Pike county, and the French-Eversole war, in Perry county. They were no ten cent affairs. There was no pulling of pistols for show. The participators meant business every time. They terrorized entire counties, slew scores of people, drove hundreds more from home, broke up local courts, stood off the militia and cost the state hundreds of thousands of dollars before they were finally suppressed.

But the job was thoroughly done. There is peace through all the once disturbed region, and a recently published roll of the present condition of the survivors has about it a flavor of comedy. But the famous dead are many. Craig Tolliver is dead. Boone Logan and the Youngs are practicing law. Andy Johnson is a capitalist. The Yellow Creekers have become land speculators or gone west. Wils Jennings and the Hatfields are in the penitentiary. Joe Eversole has been killed. A saw log dispatched Jerry Little. "General" Sowders is a quiet citizen, and his old enemy, Alvis Turner, is slain. Wils Howard and Joe Henderson are awaiting trial. Talt Hall has been executed, and B. Fulton French is living quietly at Winchester, doing all that in him lies to provide legal defenses for his many old retainers who are under indictment.

To write a full and philosophical history of these feuds in the highland south would require a Buckle. The Appalachians send down a great tongue in a south southwest direction, forming a central mountain nucleus from Maryland to Alabama, from which the affluents of the Potomac and Ohio, of the Mississippi and all the streams which flow into the gulf and south Atlantic run rapidly down their rocky beds to every point of the compass. The result

THE HATFIELDS AT BAY.

is topographically a region about 400 miles wide and 800 miles long, destined by nature to be the last to be redeemed from nature's wilderness, and yet in the end to be the seat of a far more diversified industry than is possible to the lowlands.

To the region through all the century of 1760-1860 fled the criminals and the unfortunates of the more fertile lowlands. The worst class of Tories fled there after the revolution. Fraudulent and absconding debtors found refuge there. Hardy and honest hunters found their paradise there. Invalids and good men of daring natures found health and romance in the valleys. The result was a singularly varied population, and in no long time a sort of dumb war in politics and otherwise with the lowlanders. As slavery was strengthened on the fertile lands the mountaineers tended toward abolitionist views. On all economic issues they habitually opposed the lowland sentiment. And finally when the lowlands were almost unanimous for secession the mountaineers became almost unanimous for the Union.

The war "brought the thing to a head," as the local phrase goes, but the mountaineers had a few little matters of their own to settle. And they have settled them—very thoroughly for the most part. The participants, too, are settled—"planted" in fact. They made good soldiers, but didn't know when to quit fighting. From sire to son the passion for tumult and bloodshed was transmitted, and some of the most dangerous outlaws in the mountains have been boys under twenty, while most of the leaders in the greatest of the feuds have been under thirty years of age.

The Rowan county feud was the last and probably worst. It begun in an election quarrel between the Tollivers and Martins. Craig Tolliver, a blue eyed giant, led the Tolliver faction. The Martins had friends, but lacked leadership, and were almost exterminated. The Youngs were drawn into the quarrel as friends of the Tollivers, and the Logans were marked for destruction as friends of the Martins. That was Craig Tolliver's blunder, and led to his overthrow. As usual the forms of law assisted rather than hindered the crimes. Craig Tolliver had himself elected town marshal of Morehead, the county seat, and was afterward police judge. His canvass and election to the latter office show the character of the man. He made up his mind to become a candidate the day before the election, and at once notified his opponents of the fact. He also intimated that he wanted the office and intended to have it. The opposition took the hint and withdrew. Election day Tolliver took charge of the polls himself. When he closed the books in the afternoon fifty votes had been cast. Tolliver's election, it is hardly necessary to say, was unanimous. He could now issue warrants and make arrests at will. Crime followed crime with increasing brutality. The county was at Tolliver's mercy.

The state was compelled to interfere. Governor Knott invited the leaders to a conference at Louisville and a truce was effected. Down to that time the people of the rest of the state had been philosophically inclined to "let 'em fight it out among themselves;" but facts came to light which outraged the Kentuckian love of fair play and set the state in a rage. It was shown that there was no chivalry in it. Most of the killing was done from ambush. All sorts of treachery was practiced. Open fights rarely occurred, unless one side had big odds and the other side couldn't get away. Human life simply had no value, and there were hundreds of men in the mountains ready to accept employment as retainers for any man who was able to pay them for committing murder and to put up money to protect them afterward. Recently, in a trial of a murderer, one witness admitted that he had been offered $150 to kill another, but as the destined victim was "a big man in the neighborhood" he stood out for $250.

STANDING OFF A POSSE.

In 1887 Craig Tolliver had the two Logan boys assassinated by his posse. Then the county rose on him. Sheriff Hogg and Boone Logan, a cousin of the victims, led the volunteers who hunted him down and killed him and several of his followers. Now there is peace. Railroads run through Bell, Breathitt and Rowan counties. The mineral land syndicate has invaded every mountain nook. There are newspapers in Breathitt and Harlan, and three of them in Bell. The sale of whisky is forbidden by vote of the people themselves in most of the counties where feuds raged. The law is more respected, since violation of it means speedy arrest and severe punishment.

About the Pennsylvania gang there never was the slightest flavor of romance. The Cooley boys were outlaws pure and simple. They began by stealing hogs and chickens, went on to manufacture and sell illicit whisky, then fought to avoid arrest and next for revenge, and finally graduated as murderers. One by one they were killed or captured and imprisoned, till only Frank Cooley remained at large, with his pal, one Ramsey. Sheriff McCormick organized a picked posse to fight them to a finish. They got Frank surrounded and he sent five shots from his Winchester at the sheriff, but missed, though once he came so near that the wind of the ball knocked the sheriff down.

At length a bullet glanced from a stump near the outlaw and pierced his heart. Cooley staggered, and the sheriff rushed upon him and found him clinging to a sapling. In the final struggle, before he went down, Cooley discharged his Winchester twice; the bullets tore up the ground near his feet and the weapon fell out of his hands. As he lay upon the ground Sheriff McCormick spoke to him and said that he was sorry Cooley had to be killed, but that it was his own fault. The outlaw replied, "You did your duty," and a moment later he was dead. Ramsey was captured next day. A touch of comedy ended the play. On the person of Frank Cooley was found a letter from a well known dentist, which contained a request for Cooley's surrender. The dentist promised that if Cooley would surrender himself and permit himself to be delivered over to the sheriff he would get $1,200 of the reward, which he could use in defending himself in court. All the dentist asked for his trouble was $300.

See the clipping

A schoolhouse wedding, and peace again

A Kentucky paper reports the feud ‘permanently settled’ by the marriage of Frank Hatfield and Hattie McCoy, who had written to each other in secret for two years. It names Cap Hatfield, shot the past Christmas week, as the feud's last victim. That was wrong: Cap was captured in November 1896, charged with three killings at Matewan, and a month later a New York paper credited another wedding with ending the feud.

The Breckenridge News · Cloverport, Ky.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Breckenridge News · 19 July 1893 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

END OF THE GREAT FUED. HATFIELDS AND M'COYS MADE FRIENDS BY A MARRIAGE.

The True Story of the Quarrel is Herewith Given in Detail.

See moreSee less

The Execution of Ellison Mounts in Kentucky.

The McCoy-Hatfield fued, which for years has drenched the mountains of Kentucky and West Virginia with blood, has been permanently settled. Several times during the existence of the terrible strife reports of a similar nature have been circulated, only to be followed by outbreaks more bitter than before, until each faction has looked upon advances of friendly character as merely a part of a concerted plan to secure an advantage in the mountain war. Peace was the result of the marriage of Frank Hatfield and Hattie McCoy, representatives of the younger element of both factions. They met in a log schoolhouse in the wilds of the Kentucky mountains several weeks ago. The place was selected owing to its isolated location and because it was an equal distance removed from the homes of the two factions. About a dozen representatives of both families were present. For two years the young couple had been corresponding without the knowledge of their families and through their advances and the efforts of mutual friends the mountain fued is ended forever.

BUT THE FRIENDLY

arrangements came after years of fierce warfare, in which many lives have been sacrificed by both factions in order that their peculiar ideas of family honor might be maintained with becoming dignity. The first quarrel between the families was about two hogs. This was amicably settled after only one man had been killed. The second trouble was caused by a wayward girl. Pretty Rose Ann McCoy, daughter of old Rand'l, loved stalwart Johnson Hatfield, a son of Bad Anse. They did not bother with a marriage ceremony. "Jonce" was an outlaw in Kentucky. He had at that time been indicted twenty-seven times. The crimes, however, were not venal in Kentucky or West Virginia eyes He had merely made a practice of bringing moonshine whisky across the border. Talbot McCoy, Rose's brother, was made a deputy and set out to catch Jonce. He captured him by following his sister on one of her visits to her lover. She slipped away and gave the alarm. Then Bad Anse Hatfield gathered a posse and rescued the prisoner. After that Rose Ann lived with her lover at war with her family, until the lover kicked her out and her family took her back. In 1882 a political rally made the two factions friends again until too much whisky got into the politics. Deacon Ellison Hatfield and Talbot McCoy fought a duel with knives. It was

A HORRIBLE AFFAIR.

Claims of foul play were made by both sides. Finally a McCoy onlooker shot and badly wounded Ellison Hatfield during the duel. Three McCoys were arrested. The Hatfields took them away from the officers and carried them (among the prisoners was a little boy) into West Virginia. Bad Anse Hatfield led the gang. Talbot McCoy's young wife, with a baby in her arms, went on her knees to Anse to plead for her husband's life; but the Hatfield leader could not be moved. He sat with his revolver in his hand waiting for news from Ellison. If Ellison died then he would kill the McCoys. Ellison died the next day. The McCoys were taken into the woods and tied to trees by their throats. Then the two men were shot down. The little boy was at first spared. Afterward a Hatfield went back and killed him. While the McCoy faction was in a way cowed by the triple murder the Hatfields appear to have been incited to further deeds of violence.

A SUCCESSION OF MURDERS.

Until 1884 no one was killed. Then Anse Hatfield planned a surprise on three McCoys whom he knew would pass along a certain road about dusk. Three men appeared, and they were fired on, one being killed and two badly hurt, but they were not the McCoys. Anse was angry at having been deceiven into killing the wrong men. He thought that a Mrs. Daniel and her daughter had warned the McCoys- Several nights later, Bad Anse Hatfield and Tom Wallace suddenly ter. [illegible] the Daniels cabin. Bill Dan compelled to[o]k into a cocked Winches[ter] dragged by their [s]leep quiet. He was their night clothes and b[a]nd daughter sible. The beating was done beds in bone end of a cow's tail, which Cap [illegible] cut from the animal in the stable of his victims. A year later "one of the women" died from the terrible beating, and the other is a cripple for life. After that

Bill Daniels joined Rand'l's men in revenge. A brother of Mrs. Daniels was tied with a rope to a saddle a few days afterward, and driven like a hog down

Grapevine creek toward the Daniels home

[whe]re he was to be killed in sight of his [door]. As they neared the point the

[th]ought he saw a chance to slip [a rope] around his neck. The Hat[field learned] great satisfaction, that [the] [illegible]an. [illegible]OOK [illegible]g, plunged [h]igh into shore. Then the Hatfields kneeled down and deliberately began firing with their Winchesters at his head. The fugitive was permitted to reach the opposite bank. Just as he thought himself safe, Anse cried, "Now." The next moment the fugitive dropped back into the river with three Winchester balls in his head. The Hatfields had been playing with him. They could have killed him the first fire, but there was more fun in waiting. This is one of the stories much enjoyed to this day in Hatfield circles. Then some Hatfield sympathizers were captured and taken to the Pike county (Ky.) jail. This made the Hatfields "right mad" and incited that faction to a sort of revenge that horrified the people of both states. On the New Year's night following there were at Randolph McCoy's home besides himself and wife their son, Calvin and Rosa Ann's seven-year-old boy, Melvin, and Allaphare, Addie and Fanny McCoy, Old Rand'l's daughters. About midnight the inmates were roused by a

GANG OF HATFIELDS.

Old Rand'l made no reply to the Hatfields' order to surrender. The door was first shot full of holes, then five men of the Hatfield gang used a log as a battering ram and tore the door from its hinges. Miss Allaphare, hearing Cap Hatfield's voice, and remembering that they had been sweethearts once, sprang to the door in her night clothes to appeal to him. As the girl appeared, Cap, from behind a tree ten yards distant, raised his rifle to fire. "You wouldn't shoot me, Cap," observed the girl calmly, but without attempting to retreat. Then Ellison Mounts shot the girl down while she continued to plead for her mother and sisters. In the meantime the house has been fired in several places, and the women told to run out and try to escape to the woods. Mrs. McCoy was shot ten feet from the house. As she was supposed to be dead she was not shot again. An effort was made to have the perpetrators of this out- rage extradited. It failed, and a proba- bly illegal posse crossed the border in search of them. They killed old Uncle Jim Vance; captured Wall Hatfield and Doc and Sam Mayhorn; killed Andy Var- ney and Bill Dempsey, and finally cap- tured Ellison Mounts. THE EXECUTION OF ELLISON MOUNTS.

The prisoners were taken into Kentucky and lodged in the Pike county jail. All went to the penitentiary for long terms except Ellison Mounts. He was convicted of the murder of the McCoy girl. Feb- 18, 1890, was the date fixed for the exe- cution. The Hatfields swore that Mounts should never hang. One hundred of the McCoy faction assembled and escorted the prisoner to a small valley surrounded by mountain peaks near the scene of his crime. A desperate fight was expected, and, with cocked rifle in the hands of his executioners, Ellison Mounts was swung off. Bad Anse explained that the proposed rescue failed because the boys were kinder tired of killing McCoys, "and if I could just shoot that —— Phillip and Ole Rand'l, I'd go to the gallows just as peert as I ever went to dinner," he observed.

A year ago Frank Philip was shot at a dozen times by the Hatfields while he was on West Virginia soil in one of his daring attempts to arrest members of the gang single-handed. The last victim of the fued was Cap Hatfield. The circumstances surrounding his death have never been made clear. He was shot during last Christmas week, near Tug river. Anse says it was the result of a quarrel with some of his friends over a game of cards, but others assert that the murder was indirectly due to the terrible mountain fued.

See the clipping

← Back to Act Four: His Voluntary Statements