The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · 23 March 1891 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
OF THE HATFIELD-McCOY FEUD.
See moreSee less
Peace Declared by "Devil Anse," the Fearless Leader of the Hatfields.
THE FACTIONS AT PEACE AGAIN.
Resume of the History of the Bloody Vendetta From its Start to the Present.
As Told to the Intelligencer by "Devil Anse" Himself and in the Confession of Ellison Hatfield—Bloody Deeds Recalled—The State no Longer to Bear the Disgrace Under Which it Has Rested—A Thrilling Story Worth Repeating.
The famous Hatfield-McCoy-feud, the most noted family war in the history of American vendettas, has ended at last. Peace has been declared, hostilities have ceased and Captain Anse Hatfield, better known as "Devil Anse," the head of the West Virginia faction has graciously granted amnesty and announced that his war spirit has abated. The following letter, which appears in the Wayne News, tells an interesting story and explains itself:
Editor Wayne News:
I ask space in your valuable paper for these few lines. A general amnesty has been declared in the famous Hatfield and McCoy feud, and I wish to say something of the old and the new. I do not wish to keep the old feud alive and I suppose that everybody, like myself, is tired of the names of "Hatfield and McCoy," and the "Border Warfare" in time of peace. The war spirit in me has abated and I sincerely rejoice at the prospect of peace. I have devoted my life to arms. We have undergone a fearful loss of noble lives and valuable property in the struggle. We being, like Adam, not the first transgressors. Now I propose to rest in a spirit of peace,
Yours Respectfully.
Cap. Hatfield,
Logan County, W. Va., Feb. 24, '91.
THE FAMOUS VENDETTA.
In this connection a brief history of the great feud, which has been famous the country over for years and has caused so much bloodshed, will prove of interest. Though books have been written about the deeds of the Hatfields and McCoys upon the southern border of West Virginia, and a number of metropolitan newspapers have sent special correspondents into Logan county, W. Va., and Pike county, Ky., to obtain information upon which were based hair raising stories greatly exaggerated, the INTELLIGENCER is the only paper that has ever published an authentic history of the vendetta. This history was, on the 21st of November, 1889, obtained by the INTELLIGENCER from "Devil Anse" Hatfield himself, while on trial at Charleston for violation of the revenue laws, and published the following day.
"DEVIL ANSE'S" STORY.
From Anse's story the following facts are taken: Contrary to the general impression, which is that the feud dates back to the civil war, the first trouble occurred in 1873, when a difficulty rose between Floyd Hatfield, a cousin of Anse, and Randolph McCoy, who had married sisters, over a sow and pigs. A law suit followed,
"Some time subsequently my son Johnston and Rosanna McCoy, a daughter of Randolph McCoy, ran away from home to get married. The McCoys headed off the fleeing couple, and Rosanna, bare-footed, bare-headed, riding a bare-backed horse, made her way to the Hatfields under cover of darkness and informed them that Jonse Hatfield had been scooped in by the McCoys. The Hatfields formed an armed posse, headed by Anse who went a near way through the woods, caught up with the McCoys, overpowered them without a fight, and rescued Jonse, returning home with him. They were then happily married. In a few years, however, Rosanna deserted Jonse, and is now living with Phillips, the leader of the McCoy outlaws, in Pike county, Kentucky.
MURDER OF ELLISON HATFIELD.
"Some twelve months after the above occurrence, Tolbert Farmer and Randall and Floyd McCoy, who were still angered over the hog suit already described, and more so on account of the prosecution for the murder of Stratton, went to the election precinct where my brother Ellison voted and murdered him by cutting and shooting him literally to pieces.
"For this offense they were arrested, and when they were taken to the mouth of Blackberry creek for trial, by the Hatfields as guards for the officers, the McCoys gathered a posse to rescue them. They were taken across Tug river in a skiff to keep them from being rescued by the McCoy mob. Charles Carpenter, Alexander Messer, Daniel White and some others were the guards. To get them in a still safer place, they were taken to a point up Mate's creek, in Logan county. They were ordered by the Hatfields to take the prisoners to the Pike county jail, in Kentucky. After they got them across Tug river, while Charley Carpenter was bossing the job, on the Kentucky side of the river, three of the men were killed. Floyd was the only one who made his escape. Soon afterward Alex. Messer, Ellison Mounts, three of the Mahones, and Valentine Hatfield were arrested for the murders.
"Mounts was tried and sentenced to be hung. Four others were sentenced to the penitentiary for life; among the number is Valentine Hatfield, who was absolutely not on the Kentucky side of the rivers when the murders were committed, but the McCoys swore him through.
KNEW NOTHING OF THE MURDERS.
"Seventeen other West Virginians have been indicted on the charge of being parties to that murder, myself and my sons Jonse and Cap being among the number, although as a matter of fact we knew nothing of the murders until several days after they had been committed.
"Nothing was done with these indictments for five years or more, until a lawyer named P. H. Cline, of Pike county, got up a petition, carried it to Governor Buckner, and induced him to offer a reward of $1,500 for the arrest of the Hatfields.
"Frank Phillips gathered up a posse of upwards of twenty men, armed to the teeth. They came across into West Virginia and killed an old man by the name of Vance, whom they claimed had killed Harmon M'Coy some time during the war. Deputy Sheriff Thompson
SUMMONED A POSSE
and started in pursuit. They met on Grape Vine creek, near the State line. The Phillips men refused to surrender, and opened fire on the officers. Little Bill Dempsey, one of the Sheriff's guards, was shot in the leg. McCoy was wounded in the shoulder. Dempsey crawled into a shuck pen with his broken limb, and way crying for water, when Dave Stratton, James McCoy, Sam Miller, Frank Phillips and two other men came up. The began to abuse the wounded man. He told them he was summoned by the Sheriff as a guard, and had to pursue them. Frank Phillips walked up close to where he was lying, drew his revolver and shot his brains out with one shot from his revolver. This is a straight statement of the feud up to this day (November 21, 1889). Every man in Logan county who knows me will tell you I am a peaceful, law-abiding man, and no man will say I ever told a fasehood. In this contest I have only defended myself, as any man would do under similar circumstances.
His
(Signed) ANDERSON X HATFIELD.
Mark.
With the subsequent events, newspaper readers are familiar—how an Inter-state complication grew out of the demand of Governor Wilson on the Governor of Kentucky for the surrender of the prisoners in the Pike county jail, referred to in Hatfield's story, and how the complications were settled by the U. S. Supreme court, sustaining the right of the Kentucky authorities to hold the prisoners. Ellison Mounts (or Hatfield) was afterward hanged in Kentucky. Before his death he made a statement, from which the following is an extract:
BEWAILING HIS FATE.
"I don't blame the McCoy's. The Hatfield's brought me to this. I was forced to do as I did. Twice they came after me with guns, telling me to come on and take the lives of those who had killed my father. I saw his murderers shot, and I was at the burning of the cabin. I can't go into details. My guilt was not as great as Aleck Messer's or Wall Hatfield's or the White's, who turned State's evidence. Yet my life pays forfeit, while they are permitted to live.
"No, I do not look for a commutation of sentence. Nobody seems to be doing anything for me. My lawyers come here and talk to me; then go away and forget that I am alive."
BORN OUT OF WEDLOCK.
The doomed man's parents were both Hatfields—cousins, who loved not wisely but too well. After being discarded by her cousin lover, young Ellison's mother married a man named Mounts. Ellison was a mere boy at the time his father was killed, but at the time of the shooting of Aliferi McCoy, for which deed he suffered death, he had reached manhood and been married. His wife has died since his incarceration.
One of the outgrowths of the feud was the lynching, in October, 1889, of Green McCoy and Haley by a mob of Lincoln county citizens.
HISTORY OF THE HATFIELDS.
From the story given to the INTELLIGENCER by Devil Anse, the following interesting history of the Hatfields is taken:
"My grandfather, Valentine Hatfield, was born in Russell county, Va. My grandmother, Elizabeth Vance, was a native of the same county. Eight boys and three girls were born to them. My father was Ephraim Hatfield, who was born in Logan county, Virginia, in 1812. He married Nancy Vance, of Russell county, Virginia, in 1837, and to them were born eighteen children, eight of whom died when young. Six boys and four girls lived to manhood and womanhood. These six were Valentine, Anderson (they call me Anse), Ellison, Elias, Smith, Patterson, Martha, Elizabeth, Emma and Biddy.
"I was born September 9, 1838, and married Lavisa Chapin, April 18, 1861. Twelve children were born to us, vis: Johnson, William A., usually called 'Cap;' which nick name was given him when a small boy and has hung to him ever since; Robert E. Lee, Elliott, Elias, Detroit, Joseph, Willis Wilson. The daughters are Nancy B., who was captured by John T. Vance May 16, 1889—the only one of my family ever captured by anybody dead or alive (He meant she married Vance), Mary, Elizabeth and Rosada.
"I served in the militia in 1861, and regularly enlisted in 1862 in the Confederate army, as First Lieutenant in the Forty-fifth Virginia Infantry. I resigned in 1863, and then recruited a company which was kept in service in Wayne, Cabell and other border counties of West Virginia and Kentucky.
"Jonse, Marion and Tom McCoy (who are now trying to kill me), were members of my company during the war."
ELLISON'S CONFESSION.
During his confinement in the Pike county (Ky.) jail, awaiting his doom upon the scaffold, Ellison Hatfield sent to the INTELLIGENCER a long confession over his own signature. His statements were voluntary, were dictated by him to the prosecuting attorney and created a great sensation. Its most interesting features would make a long newspaper article, and as it is confirmatory of "Devil Anse's" story it is unnecessary to reproduce it. Among other things he described graphically the scene at the time the Hatfields and their followers, intrenched in the mountains of Logan county, took a terrible oath to revenge themselves on the McCoys. He then details the long list of bloody tragedies that followed, and tells minutely the story of the murders in which he was directly concerned. In the last massacre the McCoys suffered terrible loss in revenge for the murder of Ellison Hatfield, Sr. In that tragedy it was young Ellison's own hand that took the life of the girl Alifari. He thus describes the attack on the McCoy house on the Kentucky side of the line:
A THRILLING STORY.
We began shooting through the doors of what we called the big house in opposite directions. There were several shots fired from the inside of the house, and the shooting continued for some time from inside and out.
Calvin McCoy got upstairs and shot one of our party. Jim Vance, sr., went to the house and found some cotton hanging against the side. He lit it with a match and placed part of it in a joist hole, and the rest against the shutter of the door. Two shots were fired through the door from the inside of the house. We heard Calvin McCoy call to the girls (his sisters), who were in the kitchen, to go out and put out the fire. Vance said: "Boys, if they come out, d—d them, shoot them."
About this time a girl opened the door of the kitchen and Cap. and Johns both cried to me: 'D—n her, kill her.' I had a 32 calibre Winchester rifle, I fired at her and she fell in the doorway. I heard her sister ask her if she was hurt. She muttered something, but I could not understand it. I heard one of the girls say: "Farewell sister." Calvin McCoy called down stairs to know if any one was killed and one of the girls said, "Yes, they have killed Alifari." The firing from both sides kept up for some time, until I was shot through the left arm by Calvin McCoy. The ball entered just above the wrist below the elbow. Cap. and Johns Hatfield both told me afterward that they killed Calvin McCoy. They were both bragging about it, and each one claimed that he killed him. But I think from the position of the two that Cap killed Calvin McCoy. Three of our party was wounded. Tom Mitchel was shot in the right hand, shooting off three of his fingers and some of the shots went into his belt. Johns Hatfield was shot in the top of the right shoulder. He had on a heavy overcoat and the shots only entered the flesh very slightly, I saw the shots taken out. They were bird shot. We did not know that we had killed Calvin McCoy until the next day.
When we left the house it was in a good flame. The women were crying and begging for help to put out the fire. We returned to West Virginia by the same route that we came. I fainted on the way from loss of blood. We arrived at Cap Hatfield's about daylight and took breakfast.
THE HATFIELD CHARACTER.
Many things that have been printed about the vendetta are pure fabrications, and in most of them the Hatfields have had great injustice done them. It has been many months since there has been any trouble on the border between the families in the feud.
If Anse Hatfield and his friends had been left alone in peace by the Kentuckians it is safe to say that the public would have heard the last of hostilities long ago.
No more hospitable, honest or peacefully disposed people live than the Hatfields. Their enemies were the aggressors, and the blows they have struck have been in revenge for the unprovoked butchery of their nearest and best loved relatives.
Bad as the history of the feud is, it should be borne in mind that it was a family war and that the peace of no one else was disturbed. The quarrels and wholesale shedding of blood was solely in a revengeful warfare—no depredations were committed on the property of other people. They were at peace with all the world but themselves. Those who know them describe them as honest, thrifty, well-to-do citizens who would not harm a hair upon the head of anyone who had done them no injury.