As the Papers Told It

The Hatfields and the McCoys · As the Papers Told It

Act Six

Eighteen Men Bite the Dust

March 1894 – December 1898

On election day in November 1896 Cap Hatfield and a boy shot two Rutherfords and a man named Chambers. Found asleep in a rock crevice on the Tug, Cap was jailed for the first time, convicted only of involuntary manslaughter, and broke out of the Williamson jail the next summer. In December 1896 the wedding of Aaron Hatfield and Mary McCoy was reported as the end of the feud, and in 1898 Johnse Hatfield was captured and confessed.

Bob Hatfield reported shot by Frank Phillips

A Parkersburg dispatch says the feud has broken out again in Logan county: Frank Phillips, once a McCoy leader, crossed from Kentucky with seven men, ambushed Bob Hatfield, son of Devil Anse, whom he blamed for nearly killing him, and mortally wounded Mose Christian. The death report appears to be wrong: in September 1899 a Providence paper has Devil Anse surrendering with his son Bob.

The Waco Evening News · Waco, Tex.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Waco Evening News · 23 March 1894 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

BOB HATFIELD KILLED.

Renewal of the Famous Hatfield-McCoy Feud Taking Active Steps.

See moreSee less

PARKERSBURG, W. Va., March 23.—The Hatfield-McCoy feud, which slumbered quietly for several years, has again broken out in Logan county, and affairs are beginning to assume a serious aspect. Bob Hatfield, son of "Devil Anse," and Mose Christian, both of the Hatfield faction, were killed by the ex-leader of the McCoys, Frank Phillips. Several men from that section, who arrived here as witnesses in the United States court, give the following account of the tragic affair:

Last Friday Frank Phillips, who was one of the most notorious leaders of the McCoy faction during the last feud, in which many lives on both sides were lost, came down from his headquarters in the mountains of Kentucky and crossed the boundary at St. Peter's creek, where he learned that Bob Hatfield, son of Anse Hatfield, was somewhere near. Phillips had always claimed that Bob Hatfield was the man who shot and came near killing him in the last feud, and he determined to kill him. He lay in ambush, and when Hatfield came along the road he shot and killed him. Mose Christian, a friend of Bob Hatfield, heard the firing and ran to his assistance and was also shot by Phillips and mortally wounded. Phillips had seven men with him at the time, and after shooting the men they escaped into Kentucky. The Hatfields are said to be collecting their forces to avenge the murder of Bob Hatfield and Christian.

See the clipping

Hatfields and McCoys guard the Kenova bridge

This roundup of the June 1894 strikes is mostly about miners firing on militia in Indiana and on railroad guards near Ironton, Ohio, with shorter reports from Kenova and McKeesport. The feud gets one line, at the end of the Ironton report: the Kenova bridge is safe, and ‘the McCoy and Hatfield tribe is guarding it’. The paper names the old enemies as a single band of guards.

The Jersey City News · Jersey City, N.J.

The Jersey City News · 7 June 1894 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image

MILITIA SURPRISED

Miners at Farmersburg Open Fire on the Outposts Without Warning.

See moreSee less

A BATTLE NEAR IRONTON.

Guards Positive a Number Of Miners Were Killed—No Dead Bodies Found.

Indianapolis, Ind., June 7, 1894.—The miners have attacked the militia at Farmersburg, in Sullivan county, and at this hour there is a battle raging. Several of the militia are reported wounded, but how seriously cannot be learned. Adjutant Parks has just wired that his pickets were surprised at one A. M. by a body of miners who slipped up under cover of darkness and opened fire without warning. The outposts returned the fire and retreated on the camp, where they rallied, and a charge was made on the assaulting party. The number of miners could not be learned. The first volley is said to have been at least fifty shots along the line. Word was sent to Shelburn and two companies are now marching to reinforce the attacked militia under Col. John W. Ebel of Terre Haute. The troops in the fight are of Company B from Terre Haute.

Later.—The report of a clash between the militia and miners at Farmersburg on the Evansville and Terre Haute road in Sullivan county, has been confirmed by a despatch received by Adj. General Robbins. About one o'clock this morning the miners opened fire on the militia picket line, which had been thrown out along the railroad. Fifty shots were exchanged, but no one was injured, so far as known.

Many Thought to Be Dead.

Ironton, O., June 7, 1894.—At midnight last night an attack was made upon the guards and track-walkers on the trestle running over Lyck Creek, five miles from Ironton, by a large number of miners. The track-walkers and guards were knocked down with stones and a volley of powder and balls. The guards were overpowered and their lanterns smashed to pieces. A freight train sidetracked its load and carried the Sheriff to the scene of the trouble. The guards saw a number of strangers hanging around the edge of the bridge trying to get on, and they opened fire upon them. The guards are positive some dead are lying around, but none have yet been found. There were between 50 and 100 shots fired last evening at this point. The guards expect another bloody attack this evening but will be supplied with Winchesters and a larger force of men. The Kenova bridge is all right and the McCoy and Hatfield tribe is guarding it.

Joined the Strikers.

Kenova, W.Va., June 7, 1894.—A telegram from George W. Jones, inspector of the Pocahontas Company at Dingess, W.Va., to W. P. Slaughter, the local representative of the company, states that the miners at that point today all joined the strikers. These men are all white, and were organized last Friday in the United Mine Workers by Local Organizer James Carter of the district of Northern Kentucky. This is the first strike on the line of the N. &. W. Railroad, and is the first step toward a determined effort to induce the men of the Pocahontas territory to come out.

Quiet at McKeesport.

McKeesport, Pa., June 7, 189s.—But few strikers are to be seen in the vicinity of the huge plant of the National Tube Works Company this morning. The continued excitement of the past forty-eight hours has exhausted the majority of the men and they have retired to their homes for rest. All night long the men guarded every entrance to the works for the purpose of intercepting deputies or outsiders who might be coming here to aid the tube works in starting up. This was unnecessary, however, as the company has not asked for deputies. A United Press reporter this morning called on Mr. Edwin C. Converse, vice president and general manager of the National Tube Works Company and asked him as to the future policy of the company. Mr. Converse said:—"The policy of the company at the present time is one of masterly inactivity. We are not going to try to start up the works at present. The men now guarding our works for the purpose of keeping deputies away, might as well buy lawn tennis bats and go enjoy themselves.

We will not bring deputies or outsiders here to run our plant. We do not want to cause terrorism in McKeesport. We have shown the men that the company could make no money if an advance in wages was granted. In fact, owing to the depressed condition of trade, there is as much money for us in the works lying idle as if they were running."

See the clipping

Devil Anse buys a farm, joins the church

A Huntington report to the Register, reprinted by the Webster Echo, says Devil Anse has bought a farm in McComas district and plans to move his family off the Tug river ground ‘where so many murders have taken place’. Now a Methodist said to pray ably, he claims all his shooting was in self defense. In September 1899 he surrendered to a Mingo county posse at the old Hatfield fort.

The Webster Echo · Addison, W. Va.

The Webster Echo · 23 August 1895 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

A Huntington special to the Register of recent date, says: "Devil" Anse Hatfield of Hatfield-McCoy fame, was in the city today. He purchased a fine farm in McComas district, this county, and intends moving his family here. He is now a very old man, and has lived his entire life on the banks of Tug river, formerly Logan, now Mingo county. He claims that he wishes to live a more refined life during his last days and that he wishes to move away from the grounds where so many murders have taken place.

See moreSee less

He is now a member of the Methodist Church, and it is said can deliver an able prayer. He claims that he was never the aggressor in a fight in his life, but says all his shooting was done in self defense.

See the clipping

Cap Hatfield kills three at the polls

The Sun says Cap Hatfield, whom a Kentucky paper had reported dead in 1893, shot three men at Matewan on election day: Rutherford, an old enemy; Henderson Chambers, an election officer, by accident; and a Rutherford nephew who chased and wounded him. He fled to the mountains with his twelve-year-old son. Later reports differ on the place, the boy and who fired.

The Sun · New York, N.Y.

The Sun · 5 November 1896 · page 9 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

KILLED THREE MORE MEN.

ELECTION DAY CRIMES OF THE FAMOUS CAPT. HATFIELD.

See moreSee less

Shot His Victims Down at a Virginia Polling Place—Then He Fled to the Hills with a Posse in Pursuit—Leader in the Once Notorious Hatfield-McCoy Feud.

WILLIAMSON, Va., Nov. 4.—Capt. Hatfield, the notorious outlaw of Hatfield-McCoy fame, killed three men at Matewan in a row at that place yesterday afternoon. Some years ago Hatfield alienated the affections of Rutherford's wife, which afterward caused a divorce. Since that time a very bitter feeling has existed between the men, which was aggravated a year ago by the killing of a cousin of Hatfield by Rutherford.

Yesterday Hatfield, accompanied by his twelve-year-old son and carrying with him a double-barrel shotgun in addition to the repeating rifle which he always carries, came to S[t]a[t]en to vote. All passed off quietly until about 5 o'clock, when Hatfield and Rutherford got into an altercation and began firing at each other, Rutherford using a revolver and Hatfield his shotgun.

After emptying his shotgun, Hatfield seized his rifle and began pumping lead with lightning-like rapidity. At the fifth shot Rutherford fell dead.

In the mêlée Henderson Chambers, a brother-in-law of Rutherford, who was an election officer, was accidentally shot by Hatfield and mortally wounded, dying this afternoon.

Immediately after killing Rutherford Hatfield fled toward the woods, closely pursued by a nephew of Rutherford who emptied a revolver at him, wounding him slightly in the thigh. Hatfield suddenly stopped in his flight, shot young Rutherford through the heart, and taking his boy climbed a wooded mountain near by hotly pursued by a number of armed citizens.

The excitement which followed was intense, and the whole country is aroused, and in case of Hatfield's capture, which must surely occur, there is great danger of lynching. A reward of $1,000 has been offered for Hatfield by Rutherford's relatives, and it is believed that Gov. MacCorkle will renew the reward of $500 which he offered for his arrest a few years since.

Hatfield, who is a desperate man, was the leader of the Hatfield clan in the terrible Hatfield-McCoy feud of a few years ago. He knows every foot of ground and every stronghold in the mountains of Mingo and Logan counties. For this reason the task of capturing him is a dangerous one.

Sheriff Keadle and a posse of twenty-five men are now pursuing him, and although the chase will likely be a long one Hatfield will doubtless be captured at last. A part of Hatfield's relatives, owing to some trouble, have turned against him and are assisting the officers in their efforts to catch him. The excitement is intense, and the whole country is indignant over this recent outbreak by an old offender.

At 10 P. M. a report reached this place that a posse is in hot pursuit of the man, but he has not yet been seen. There is little danger of another outbreak of the Hatfield-McCoy feud, but serious trouble seems inevitable.

Hatfield is a man of unusual intelligence, considering his environment, and possesses a wonderful amount of mountaineer shrewdness. He has lived a quiet and peaceable life since the suppression of the old feud, and this recent outbreak is quite a surprise to those who know him.

See the clipping

Cap Hatfield caught asleep in the rocks

Detective J. H. Clark and Dan Christian bring Cap Hatfield and his 14-year-old son to the Huntington jail, away from any mob, after officers found them asleep in a crevice of a rock cliff on Tug River. In jail the boy says ‘I killed both Elliott Rutherford and Mr. Chambers’, and his father admits killing John Rutherford. The Sun had put all three killings on Cap.

The Hocking Sentinel · Logan, Ohio

CorrectionThis set right an article from the day before.

The Hocking Sentinel · 12 November 1896 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

CAPTAIN HATFIELD And His 14-year-old Son Captured at Last.

A special from Huntington, W. Va., says: J. H. Clark, a famous detective and Deputy Sheriff of the Norfolk and Western, accompanied by Dan Christian, have arrived here with Capt. Hatfield and his 14-year-old son, who were captured in the mountains of Mingo County. They are charged with the murder of John Rutherford, Elliott Rutherford and Hanse Chambers on election day at Mattewan. Hatfield and son were interviewed at the jail and they seem not the least worried over the affair. The lad smiled and said: "I killed both Elliott Rutherford and Mr. Chambers," while the father acknowledged to killing John Rutherford.

See moreSee less

Hatfield and son were asleep in the crevice of a large rock cliff on Tug River when officers discovered them. They were brought here and placed in jail for fear of mob violence.

See the clipping

Eighteen killings laid to Cap Hatfield

A Baltimore American report, reprinted in Savannah, says Cap Hatfield, in his thirty-eighth year, is charged with eighteen killings and is behind bars for the first time. It names the boy as his stepson Joseph Glenn and puts the shooting at Thacker. Its feud history errs: it has Randolph McCoy killing ‘Jonce’ Hatfield in the 1888 raid, but Johnse was captured alive in 1898 and confessed to that raid.

The Morning News · Savannah, Ga.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 3 days later.

Wrong

The Morning News · 22 November 1896 · page 15 · transcribed from the page image

CAP HATFIELD'S VICTIMS.

HE HAS MADE EIGHTEEN MEN BITE THE DUST.

See moreSee less

Finally Captured by a Posse—The Outlaw and His Stepson Shot Down Three Men on Election Day at the Polls—The Chances Are He Will Swing—First Time He Has Ever Been Landed Behind the Bars. Story of the Hatfield-McCoy Feud.

from the Baltimore American.

Huntington, W. Va., Nov. 8.—The crime for which Capt. Hatfield and his stepson, Joseph Glenn, were hunted, and finally run down, was the murder of three men at an election precinct Tuesday afternoon. Hatfield went to the polls at Thacker, W. Va., to vote, and was accompanied by his stepson, Joseph Glenn, a lad who has just entered his 14th year. Both were carrying Winchesters on their shoulders, as well as revolvers of enormous caliber in their pockets. They had not been at the polls half a hour until they began to dispute with John and Elliott Rutherford, two natives of that section who "Cap" Hatfield claimed had more than ten years ago been on the side of the McCoys during a battle with his relatives. Trouble was imminent, and the Rutherfords started to leave the polls, when "Cap" raised his Winchester and fired a ball at John Rutherford, killing him instantly. Joe Glenn, the 14-year-old stepson, raised his Winchester and laid low Elliott Rutherford. Hance Chambers, a prominent citizen, rushed forward just as the lad fired. The boy, thinking he was a friend of the Rutherfords, turned his Winchester at him and killed him also. "Cap" and the boy then turned toward the mountains and walked off unconcerned. No one present attempted to arrest them, for the natives knew that it was useless, and would only result in more of their number being killed. Next morning a posse of 100 citizens, heavily armed, started in pursuit of the murderers, determined to effect their capture. No trail of them could be found, and the posse abandoned the search while on the top of a large mountain overhanging the Tug river.

J. H. Clark, the leader of the posse, accompanied by Daniel Christian, were returning to their home, and were passing near a large rock cliff on a hillside, when they discovered the forms of two persons in a large crevice of the rocks. Upon going near they discovered it was Cap and his stepson, both of whom were asleep. Their capture was easily made, and the prisoners were taken to the nearest railroad station, and were brought to Huntington and lodged in jail, arriving here early this morning. They were brought here for safe keeping, as it was feared they would be mobbed were they left in jail there.

Cap Hatfield has a record probably unexceled by any other living man. He is charged with killing eighteen men during his life, and is now only in the thirty-eighth year of his age. He is a man of ordinary intelligence, and does not look to be the desperado he is. It is feared that the citizens of Mingo county will form a mob and come here with the intention of lynching Hatfield and his son; but the authorities here are able to cope with any body which may attempt such proceedings.

During all the wild career of Hatfield this is the first time he was ever landed behind prison bars. Hatfield and stepson sat for a picture, and seemed to enjoy the notoriety which they were getting. The lad wore a suit made of homespun jeans, and is an innocent looking boy; but people of that section claim he is more daring and brave than any of his ancestors. Hatfield committed his first murder almost twenty years ago, when he was leader of the band which tied two of the McCoys to a pawpaw bush and assisted in shooting them to death. His deeds since that time have been numerous. The probabilities are now that he has killed his last victim, for the officials of West Virginia will likely see that justice is meted out for the many murders which have been committed in that wild and mountainous region.

The Hatfield-McCoy feud originated before the breaking out of the civil war. Its immediate cause was the ownership of two bony and bristly mountain hogs. Over these hogs Anse Hatfield and Randolph McCoy had a disagreement. They went to law, and Hatfield was beaten. The dispute was not settled, by any means. All the relatives of the families took sides, and the question was intensified. Shortly after the trial "Bill" Stayton, a nephew of Floyd Hatfield, a son of a witness in the case, was found dead, with a bullet in his person. Two of the numerous McCoy boys were tried for the murder and acquitted.

Soon afterward Jonce Hatfield became enamoured of Rosanna McCoy and kidnapped her. Matters went along with an occasional death on either side until 1882, when the hottest kind of hostilities began. "Cap" Hatfield became the leader of the Hatfields. Election day is always the favorite time for a gun fight among the Virginia mountaineers. In 1882 there was an election in Pike county. In the early afternoon the inevitable fight cropped out, this time between Ellison Hatfield and Talbot McCoy. When the spectators came out from behind the corner of the grocery store and from behind sundry trees from which they had been peeping, they found Ellison Hatfield lying on the ground dead. Several of the McCoys, including a 13-year-old boy, Randolph McCoy, were arrested and confined in the log school house over night.

Next day the sheriff started through the lonely mountain woods with the prisoners for the Pike county jail. By this time the entire Hatfield clan had heard of the death of Ellison. They rallied immediately around "Anse," the patriarch, and "Cap," his son.

They ambushed the sheriff, who had the McCoy prisoners in charge, and took matters into their own hands. The sheriff was released, but the McCoys were taken to a lonely log house in the mountains, where they were tied so tightly with ropes that their limbs were practically paralyzed. On the following morning they were marched over the border into Kentucky, and tied in a kneeling position to some saplings near the margin of the boundary streams. There was no begging for mercy on the part of the McCoys. They knelt grimly, and sneeringly awaited their fate.

Wall Hatfield stood in plain sight on the Virginia side of the river.

"Are you ready?" he cried.

"Yes," said "Cap" and Anse and the other Hatfields.

"Take aim. Fire!"

There was a rattle of rifles, and two of the McCoys fell limp on their ropes. They were Talbot and Farmer McCoy. The young boy, Randolph, had not been hurt. He was there simply as a witness to the death of his brothers.

This shows the utter disregard in which the Hatfields have ever held the law. The boy was mounted in front of Wall Hatfield, and the party started back for their mountain haunts.

On the way "Cap" suddenly called a halt. "That boy must die," said he. "Anse" sat silent, thereby consenting. Wall Hatfield raised his voice in the boy's behalf. Some of the other Hatfields did likewise. It was no use. "Anse," the patriarch, and "Cap" ruled things with an iron hand. So the boy was killed and left lying by the side of the road. Of course, feeble attempts were made to capture the Hatfields, but without avail. Two years later Jeff McCoy was captured by the Hatfields and shot dead in the presence of his sister. It seemed to be evident that the Hatfields had fully determined upon the extermination of their enemies. No further murders took place, however, until 1888.

On New Year's night the Hatfields, feeling dull for want of something to do, determined to pay another visit to the McCoy's. Late at night the house of Randolph McCoy, the leader of the faction, was surroundered by a gang of Hatfields. In the house at the time were Randolph McCoy and his wife, his son, Calvin, three daughters (Allaphore, Addie and Fannie), Cora, the orphaned daughter of Talbot, and Melvin, the son of Rosanna McCoy. The Hatfields were headed by "Cap" and Jim Vance. They called on the McCoys to surrender or have the house burned over their heads. The McCoys refused. Then the heroism of border women cropped out.

The Hatfields built a fire against the house. Alaphore McCoy, a young woman 20 years old, heard the crackling of the flames. She grabbed a churn full of milk and walked calmly out of the house to pour it over the flames. She was shot dead before she could accomplish her object. The light blazed up and several Hatfields became visible. Old man McCoy shot Jonce Hatfield, killing him instantly. Then he ran for the woods, escaping without injury. Calvin McCoy rushed from the house and was shot through the brain. The other McCoys were not injured.

Throughout the entire feud "Cap" Hatfield has borne a charmed life. This later outbreak was in keeping with his former exploits.

The feud with the McCoys was settled in 1893 by the marriage of a McCoy to a Hatfield, and there is but little danger that it will break out again. Since that time "Cap" has lived a quiet and peaceful life, and his last exploit has caused no end of surprise.

See the clipping

Aaron Hatfield weds Mary McCoy

The New York Journal reports the Mingo County wedding of Aaron Hatfield, a nephew of Cap, and Mary McCoy after a secret courtship, and says it ends forty years and ‘forty coffins’ of feud. Its history is muddled, making Cap the family patriarch, a role other reports give Devil Anse. A Kentucky paper had said a Hatfield-McCoy marriage ended the feud in 1893 too.

New York Journal · New York, N.Y.

New York Journal · 20 December 1896 · page 30 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

THE HATFIELD-M'COY VENDETTA ENDED BY THE GOD OF LOVE.

Here's a Romance of War and a Mountain Wooing That Has Suddenly Reconciled Two Families After Forty Years of Shooting at Sight and Defiance of the Law in the Bloodiest Feud in the History of the South.

See moreSee less

A NEIGHBORS' QUARREL ABOUT SOME HOGS, A LAWSUIT, MUTUAL HATRED AND THEN MURDER.

MARRIED--In Mingo County, W. Va., Aaron Hatfield, Nephew of "Cap" Hatfield, to Mary McCoy, Daughter of Rudolph McCoy.

A SECRET COURTSHIP WHOSE UNEXPECTED RESULT HAS BEEN RECEIVED WITH JOY ON BOTH SIDES.

A SIMPLE enough wedding notice that, but behind it and in it as romantic a tale of love and courtship as ever was penned—a tale of a mountain maid's wooing; she a McCoy, her lover one of the famous Hatfields, and the two families, for years avowed enemies, sworn to kill at sight, to hunt each other like wild animals; defying the law and the law's officers, and for forty years waging the bloodiest feud in the history of the South.

For forty years the Hatfield-McCoy vendetta has waged, and in those forty years forty coffins, marked by tombstones in the neighboring graveyards, tell of forty lives snuffed out by bullet and knife. Its origin was trivial. Way back in '56, when West Virginia was a new country, many parts of it unexplored and unsettled, two razor-back hogs strayed from the farm of Anse Hatfield. Where they went was the bone of contention. Hatfield claimed that they had wandered to the premises of Rudolph McCoy and were there being kept. This McCoy denied, and the matter finally came up in the shape of a suit for recovery in the country justice court. The case was decided for Hatfield.

During the trial warm words were passed and open hostilities were narrowly averted on several occasions. The relatives and friends of the two litigants crowded the rude court room, all armed and ready to take an active part if the impending battle broke out. But it was avoided, and nothing more than threats from the leaders of the McCoy faction occurred to give alarm. Thus the feud started, and for forty years it kept the country side in a state of excitement.

The McCoys made good their threats. One morning the body of Bill Stayton, a grandson of the plaintiff in the hog case, was found lying dead with a bullet hole in his head. Two of the numerous McCoy boys were arrested for the murder, and at the trial were acquitted. At this juncture the outbreaking of the civil war played a part. Though deadly enemies now and sworn to kill members of the opposing faction on sight, they united in their country's defense, and for the four years the war lasted a truce was declared.

With the surrender of the Confederate forces came the renewal of the feudal hostilities. Old "Cap" Hatfield, the patriarch of the family, assumed the leadership. Jonce Hatfield soon after abducted Rosanna McCoy, and refused to right by marriage the wrong he had done her. For this he was arrested, but a daring rescue by the Hatfields prevented his trial for the charge. From this on to 1882 matters went along rather smoothly. Whenever members of the opposing factions would meet there was sure to be an exchange of shots, but, strange to say, no one was killed outright, though two of the McCoys died afterwards from wounds received in one of their battles.

But election day of 1882 marked the beginning of a series of fights, each one of which claimed one or more victims. A relative of both of the families was running for office, and members of the two factions agreed to suspend their differences and work for their kinsman's election. But before the day was over Talbot McCoy and Elias Hatfield became involved in a fight. At first it was merely a fisticuffs. McCoy threw his opponent, and was pummeling him severely when Deacon Ellison Hatfield and his brother Elias appeared on the scene, and several of the McCoy faction had gathered around their representative, ready to take a hand in the fight when the time came. Talbot McCoy and the deacon advanced on each other with open knives, and when within reach the slashing began. Hatfield's knife closed on his hand, and, throwing it away, he used his fists, while McCoy wielded his weapon with telling effect. The fight then became general, and when it was over, though no one was killed, several of the participants were carried away with injuries that afterward proved fatal. Ellison Hatfield died the following Wednesday. He had been cut twenty-seven times besides being shot. Three of the McCoys were arrested—Talbot, Randolph and Farmer.

The night of the fight the Hatfield clan gathered together seventy members, and, waylaying the deputy sheriff, who was taking the prisoners to the Pike county jail, captured the three McCoys. They were taken across the river to the West Virginia side, and there held to await the outcome of Deacon Ellison Hatfield's injuries. When news came of his death, the imprisoned McCoys were notified that they were to die. The following morning they were taken back to the Kentucky side, and, after being bound, were forced into a kneeling position on the river's brink.

At the word of command a dozen rifle shots barked in the crisp air, and Talbot and Farmer McCoy fell over dead. The thirteen-year-old boy, Randolph McCoy, had been a witness to the killing, and it was decided to kill him, too. One of the party was sent back to do the work, and two barrels from his shotgun riddled the boy's body.

The next move of the Hatfields was to try and kill Randolph McCoy, the head of the family. Two desperadoes of the clan waited in ambush one night near a road over which he would have to travel. Fortunately for the intended victim, a brother, Calvin McCoy, passed the concealed assassins before the man they had marked. In the darkness they mistook their man and fired at Calvin. He was not killed outright, but was maimed for life. Soon after this a Hatfield raid was betrayed to the McCoys, and they escaped. The mother-in-law of Bill Daniels, one of the Hatfield faction, were suspected of betraying the secret. For revenge "Cap" Hatfield and Tom Wallace went to Daniel's home one night, and, covering him with a shotgun, gave both of the women a brutal beating. The wife died from her injuries, and her mother had several ribs and bones broken by the force of the blows.

Jeff McCoy was the next to go. He was a brother of Daniel's wife and was looking for Tom Wallace, who, with "Cap" Hatfield, inflicted the injuries resulting in her death. "Bad Anse" Hatfield agreed to assist him in his search, but instead enticed him into an ambush, where he was killed.

In 1885 the Governor of Kentucky put a price on the head of "Anse" Hatfield and his brother "Cap," and called upon the Governor of West Virginia for their requisition. This was at first denied, but in the latter part of 1887 the officials of both States united in an effort to suppress the bloody feud. The McCoys had suffered so much that their spirit for revenge rarely showed, but they eagerly grasped at the proposition that they join the officers in search of the Hatfield leaders. Three of the gang were captured, and subsequently sent to State's prison.

The zeal of the McCoys in joining the officers aroused the ire of their enemies, and a raid was planned for New Year's night of 1888.

Nine of the Hatfields, led by Uncle Jim Vance, attacked the house of old Randolph McCoy, Two girls were in one end of the house, and one, Allaphare McCoy, opened the door when the gang demanded admission. She was immediately shot and killed by Ellison Mounts, at the command of Vance. Mrs. McCoy started from the door to go to her dead daughter, when Jim Vance broke two of her ribs with the butt of his gun, and stunned her with a blow from his pistol. Calvin McCoy was killed in the exchange of shots and the old man was wounded.

Strange as it may seem, the Hatfields repudiated the killing of the McCoy girl. With their characteristic brutality toward women it is hard to say what prompted it, but they delivered Ellison Mounts, who fired the shot, into the officers' hands, and on their testimony he was convicted and hanged.

From that time the feud, while it has been kept up, has not been as exciting as in former days. Now and then a Hatfield and McCoy exchange shots, but the last man killed met his fate two years ago. The persistent pursuit of the Hatfields by the deputies drove them into the mountain fastnesses and made the warfare before used impossible.

And now comes the reconciliation—the end of it all. Aaron Hatfield, a nephew of old "Cap" Hatfield, met and loved pretty Mary McCoy, daughter of the head of the family, Rudolph McCoy. Primitive in their habits, these mountain lovers knew nothing of what the social world terms conventionality in courtship. There was no one to say that they should do this or do that. They only knew that they loved each other, that it was the lasting, enduring love of years, and they were happy. The rugged, barren hillsides were their trysting places; there they met alone, and their secret was shared with none save one. And he was the trusted friend, who saw to it that neither family knew of what was transpiring until the time for the announcement was deemed ripe. For there was danger should the secret be known prematurely. The fires of the feud, though not blazing, were by no means out. One day Aaron told Mary that his brother would go to see her father the following day. The lovers were at the house of the friend. All day they waited to hear what the result had been. Mary at the window saw the stalwart form of her lover's brother striding toward the house. "It's all right," he said. And then came the joyful news that the wedding would end forever the forty-year feud.

Forty Coffins That Tell of Forty Hatfield and McCoy Victims.

See the clipping

Cap's verdict: involuntary manslaughter

From Williamson, the jury in Cap Hatfield's trial returns involuntary manslaughter, which under West Virginia law means no more than 90 days in jail; his stepson's trial is under way. The feud history that follows says Wall Hatfield was hanged, but other reports have Wall sent to prison and Ellison Mounts hanged in 1890. In July 1897 Cap broke out of the Williamson jail.

The Evening Bulletin · Maysville, Ky.

The Evening Bulletin · 12 April 1897 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

CAP HATFIELD GUILTY.

The Verdict Involuntary Manslaughter and the Sentence Will Be Light.

See moreSee less

WILLIAMSON, W. Va., April 12.—The jury in the "Cap" Hatfield trial, after being out all night, returned a verdict of involuntary manslaughter, which means only such fine and imprisonment as the judge may see proper to inflict. The jail sentence can not exceed 90 days in accordance with West Virginia law.

The trial of Hatfield's stepson is be[in]g heard this week.

The Hatfield-McCoy feud is probably the most famous of southern vendettas, and "Cap" Hatfield is the most prominent actor in its tragic scenes. The McCoys and Hatfields lived on Tug river, in Pike county, Ky. Their first trouble started over a hog, which a McCoy claimed a Hatfield had stolen.

After the first hostilities began scarcely a day passed that there was not a fight between some members of the factions. Bill Stayton was the first victim of the feud. He was killed by the McCoys. Up to August, 1882, the feud claimed three men.

The bloodiest fight of all took place in Matewan, on election day in that month.

The Hatfields, 25 strong, and the McCoys fought all afternoon. The results of that battle startled the country. When the smoke of battle had cleared away 10 Hatfields had been wounded. Deacon Ellison, who was the worst hurt, having 26 wounds. He had been half scalped by Talbot McCoy when rescued by friends.

Three McCoys, Talbot, Dick and Randolph, Jr., the last a boy of 13, who fought back to back with his brothers, were captured and held by the Hatfields to await the result of Ellison's injuries. Ellison died two days later. The three prisoners were taken to a secluded spot, tied to trees among some dead dogs, and shot one at a time.

Bushwhacking followed this battle for several years, a number of men being slain. Finally, in 1887, Governor Buckner of Kentucky placed a price on half a dozen Hatfields. Detectives hounded them through the mountains, but they were never caught.

The McCoys made a raid on the Hatfields in January, 1888, and captured 10 without much trouble. Wall Hatfield was hanged and four followers were sent to prison for life for the murder of the three McCoys after the election day fight.

The Hatfields then built their famous log and stone fort, which still remains on Island creek, Mingo county, W. Va., and which a few men can hold against an army. With this as a refuge to which to flee they made raid after raid upon the surrounding country, adding more murders to the list.

The battle of Grapevine creek occurred in 1890, when two Hatfields were killed and a number wounded. "Cap" Hatfield and Johnson Hatfield fled the country, going to Dakota, Washington and Manitoba, but finally returning to their native mountains.

Last election day at Matewan, on the West Virginia side of the river, "Cap" Hatfield's young stepson shot one of the Chambers gang, who were former Hatfield adherents. Hatfield himself killed Dr. Rutherford and his brother. For this, the latest crime in the feud, Hatfield and his son were arrested.

Altogether more than 40 men were murdered in the feud, and twice as many bear the scars of battle. Peace has probably been sealed by the marriage late last year of Aaron Hatfield to Mary McCoy. While their kinsmen fought, they had gone on loving each other for years.

See the clipping

Dynamite at the Devil's Backbone

A Huntington dispatch says Sheriff Keadle's posse blew up half of the Devil's Backbone, the Hatfields' rock fortress on Tug river, and drove Hatfield and his men from it. Three of his men were shot, but Hatfield, given no first name, escaped, and the paper expected his capture within a day. Cap had broken out of the Williamson jail the month before, and in September 1899 he escaped another posse.

Turner County Herald · Hurley, S.D. · and 1 other paper

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 7 days later.

Wrong

Turner County Herald · 19 August 1897 · page 7 · transcribed from the page image

BLOWN TO ATOMS HATFIELD'S ROCKY CREST IS NO LONGER A FORTRESS. The Sheriff and His Posse Use Dynamite to Dislodge the West Virginia Gang of Desperadoes—Hard Fig[ht] Which Three of Hatfields Men Are Fatally Shot—Hatfield's Capture Now Certain.

Huntington, W. Va., Aug. 16.—One-half of the Devil's Backbone, the rocky fortress of the Hatfields in the mountains on Tug river, was shattered by dynamite and Hatfield and his men were driven from their stronghold by Sheriff Keadle and his posse after a desperate battle. Several of the sheriff's men are badly wounded, but the Hatfields are still free. Only this has been accomplished: The rocky crest where the Hatfields have for years defied the law and from which they have carried out their bloody plans is no longer tenable.

See moreSee less

It was decided by the besieged force to dynamite the desperado and his gang. All day and night the closest watch was kept. In the morning the explosive was placed, the fuse was laid, the match was applied and the attacking force began to fall back. Until then the besieged men did not suspect what was being done, but with the flash of the chain that led to the dynamite they realized their predicament. They then rushed from cover and ran hither and thither in full view. Hatfield was seen to start for the path, heedless of a shower of bullets. A rush was made down the side of the mountain.

Three men dropped wounded. It was useless to try to escape by the well known path and the desperadoes returned to the top of their rocky fort, Hatfield directing them. Great bowlders were hurled over the rocks in hopes of breaking the fuse. Then came the explosion. Pieces of rock and trees flew in every direction. When the smoke cleared away Hatfield and his men seemed unharmed. Dan Lewis, Steve Stanley and Jake Monroe, who presumed in the excitement to leave shelter, were shot and are rot expected to live. Another charge of dynamite was trained, but under the cover of the explosion Hatfield and the rest of his men escaped. The chase was renewed. Hampered as he is by his wounds Hatfield's capture within twenty-four hours must follow.

See the clipping

Johnse Hatfield captured, and he confesses

Deputy Marshal Dan Cunningham and timber man Doc Ellis catch Johnse Hatfield, son of Devil Anse, aiming his Winchester at Ellis's camp, and take him to the Pikeville jail to face ‘thirty-nine Pike county indictments for murder’. He confesses to the killings of 1882 and 1888 and asks for a life sentence. He got one, and in July 1899 his brother Elias shot Ellis dead for the arrest.

Paper unidentified

CorrectionThis set right an article from 4 days earlier.

Paper unidentified · 27 July 1898 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

"JOHNSE" HATFIELD'S

Bloody Crimes Brought to an End by His Capture.

See moreSee less

A THRILLING ARREST

And Successful Because of the Bravery of DanCunningham

Who Afterward Escaped Killing at the Hands of the Famous "Doc" Hatfield by the Cool Bravery of Attorney General Rucker.

The blood blotted trail of "Johnse" Hatfield stops before prison bars.

Another of the desperate gang of murderers and outlaws that has infested the Kentucky border of the state has been coralled and is in the grip of the relentless, outraged law. In his human moments his eyes look out upon moving shapes of murdered men and murdered women, and murdered children. He sees a scaffold. In his human moments his ears ring with the groans of victims slaughtered, with curses and curiously uncouth prayers. He hears the swinging of the trap.

The facts leading up to the capture of this distinguished murderer are interesting. The story of his taking is thrilling. The characters in the episode are "Johnse" Hatfield, brother of the courtly criminal "Cap," and son of the paradoxical desperado "Devil Anso," his pal, "Awk" Damron—probably a contraction for awkward; Doc Ellis, a prominent timber man, worth about $15,000 with home at Gilbert, in Mingo county, and logging camp at the mouth of poplar branch just across the river in Kentucky; and lastly, though next to "Johnse," most interesting of the quartette, Deputy United States Marshal Dan W. Cunningham—that man of iron nerve and terror to evil-doers, who has been up against the Hatfield gang for many years and has brought a number of them to justice.

DAN SCENTS TROUBLE.

As may be readily supposed, Dan's name is on the Hatfield blacklist and he has been marked by the gang for slaughter. Dead men tell no tales. There is probably no man alive today who can give more valuable testimony against these picturesque pests in human form that this self made detective. Consequently when he received a letter from his friend Doc Ellis asking him to come to his camp at the mouth of Poplar creek, on urgent business, Dan's trained instinct scented trouble and his experience told him that the Hatfields were in it. But he took his life in his hands, as he has done so often in times past, and went. He was back in Charleston again last night carrying as trophies of his trip a 45-95 Winchester bullet, a 38 Smith & Wesson cartridge, a devilish-looking dirk, six-inches long and an inch wide, and a very bad headache. The three first articles he will present to the State Historical Society. The last he will keep—until he can get rid of it. It is a curiosity in the way of a headache, remarkable both for size and tenacity, but the society does not want it.

SWORN TO KILL HIM.

Cunningham had been up in Wyoming tracking a man wanted in Parkersburg for felony. He missed him there and came home. Here he heard that his man was in Mingo and Sunday he set out for that interesting little county. Not finding the game he was after he decided to go over to Ellis' camp, which decision he immediately acted upon. This was on Monday. There Doc Ellis told him that "Johnse" Hatfield had sworn to kill him and was preparing to follow up his unrighteous vow with immediate action. Now, how Doc Ellis came to be placed in this uncomfortable predicament the records do not show. It can not be said that the Hatfields had anything particular against Doc Ellis; it seems that he is one of a number of good citizens who do not love the gang, and they had it in for him, were going to give him a summer outing in eternity, as "Johnse" declared in other words. The citizens of Logan and Mingo counties, particular the latter, have grown terribly tired of these gangs of desperate men who roam the ranges attired principally in Winchesters, cartridges and dirks, and while they have nothing against the Hatfields or their friends who remain at home and attend to their business, or when they travel, go about as non combatants, the Mingolians have arrived at a sort of unwritten agreement that it is their opinion that the time has come when every Hatfield or member of the Hatfield gang or of any gang, going about the country armed to the teeth, must be dealt with according to the laws of civilized communities. So unanimous are the citizens on this point that the desire amounts to almost an organized effort.

At any rate, the name of Doc Ellis was on the fatal black list and he was feeling badly about it. He welcomed the detective with open arms, so to speak, and the two presently sat down to eat dinner. They had hardly begun their meal when they perceived steathily dodging in the woods on the other side of the river—Tug river—figures of armed men. Cunningham and Ellis had made up their minds to capture "Johnse" Hatfield or kill him. The time had come. This was their quarry. They slipped down to the river's edge and silently crossed over to the south end of Sand siding cut, where they took a position sheltered from observation. In a short time they saw "Johnse" put his Winchester to his shoulder and draw a dead aim on Ellis' shack on the other side of the river. He was waiting for Doc to come out. The other man, who was "Awk" Damron, was still down in the weeds. Ellis and Cunningham threw up their guns and covered the desperado, who had his Winchester trained on the headquarters of the Mingo man across the river. He turned his head for an instant and his murder-charged eyes looked down the barrels of two deadly rifles aimed at his head.

"DROP THAT GUN."

"Johnse" Hatfield is noted among other things, as a man of quick action. "Drop that gun and hold up your hands," shouted Cunningham. "Johnse" took another lightning glance at the rifles of his enemies and dropped his gun. He did not hesitate. Had he turned it an inch to the right he would have had two bullets in his head. Cunningham, Ellis covering "Johnse," walked over and standing on the desperado's rifle, proceeded to further disarm him by taking from his clothes a 38 Smith & Wesson and the six-inch dirk. He then handcuffed him and left him in charge of two men—Hopkins and Birchfield—who had just come up and he and Ellis followed "Awk" Damron, caught him, took from him a revolver and Winchester and brought him back to where they had left Hatfield. The latter's guards had taken him across the river and thither went Ellis and Cunningham with Damron. They kept him over night and next day, having nothing against him turned him loose and sent him home with his own and Hatfield's artillery. The dirk Cunningham bought from "Johnse," paying him a dollar for it; Ellis and Cunningham took their prisoner across the Kentucky mountains to the Pikeville jail, a long forty miles from camp. There they left him to face the thirty-nine Pike county indictments for murder pending against him.

SLAYER OF FIVE CHILDREN.

At the jail, who should visit the captured desperado, but Jim McCoy, brother of five children that "Johnse" Hatfield has helped to slaughter. It is characteristic of the situation, that McCoy went over and gravely shook hands with Hatfield, promising him the best treatment possible under the circumstances, and at the same time informing him that he proposed to prosecute him to the bitter end of the law.

It has even been characteristic, too, of the Hatfields, when caught, to confess, and the latest recruit for the gallows from their ranks was no exception to the rule. He confessed and asked for a life sentence. There is a possibility that he may get it, a probability that he may not.

The words "he confessed," to those unfamiliar with tragic incidents of the Hatfield-McCoy feud is a phrase ambiguous. Hatfield acknowledged his participation in at least two of the principal horrors of that deadly strife—that of 1882 and that of 1888.

HISTORY OF A FEUD.

In 1882, old man Randolph McCoy was engaged in a petty law suit with Bill Staten over a seventy-five cent shoat. Ellison Hatfield—or "Deacon", as he was known—he was a preacher before he became a corpse—was courting old man Staten's daughter and naturally sided with his prospective father-in-law. On election day in Pike county, as was their wont, the Hatfields crossed over the river and, at the behest of certain interested politicians as well as from a sheer desire for devilment, proceeded to terrorize the community and to run the election to suit themselves. The "Deacon" was at Black Fork Precinct with a squad of co-horts. "Devil Anse" was at Peter creek precinct, with another. Together, the Hatfields had twenty-nine men with them at these two precincts. Talbot McCoy approached the polls to vote. The "Deacon," the hog incident fresh in his mind, asked him how he was going to vote. "It's none of your business," said Talbot. "I'll make it my business," said the "Deacon." "I am hell on earth," declared Talbot. "So am I," asserted the "Deacon" emphatically, and the two men mixed. Knives were drawn and the battle was getting bloody, when "Farmer" McCoy, Talbot's brother, rushed up and shot the "Deacon." The two McCoys were arrested and several deputies started through to Pikeville with them. One of the "Deacon's" friends notified "Devil Anse," who with his posse headed off the deputies, took charge of the McCoys and brought them back to the scene of the fight, where they found little Randolph McCoy and the wounded "Deacon." They took the boy prisoner and carried all three of the McCoys over the river and held them in an old school house near what is now Matewan. A family of West Virginia McCoys, living on Mate creek, took the wounded man in. He died on the third evening after the fight. That same evening "Devil Anse" and fourteen other men took the three boys across the river into Kentucky and tied them to some pawpaw bushes, where a year before they had hanged three sheep killing dogs. They hung lanterns above the heads of the doomed McCoys and forming a squad fired below two of the lanterns. Forty five bullets entered the body of Talbot and forty-eight were pumped into the "Farmer." The little boy Randolph they had not fired at and started to leave him tied to the bushes. He was crying. "Dead men tell no tales," said Alex Messer, one of the gang, suggestively. "That's so," said Anse. Messer borrowed a shot gun, went back and fired both barrels at the boy's head, blowing the top of it completely off. Part of the skull as large as a man's hand was found seven feet away from where the poor little cold body lay, when discovered the next day.

TRAGEDY OF '88.

So much for the tragedy of '82. The tragedy of 1888, was, if possible, even more terrible. It was on New Year's night. A crowd of Hatfield's—nine in all—went over into Pike county to the house of old man Randolph McCoy, on Blackberry Fork of Pond Creek—a long house with doors at each end and windows. They surrounded the house, placing two men at each door. These men opened up a cross fire on the inmates. Old man McCoy ran up stairs. The women—his wife and daughter Alvira—climbed up on the head of the bedsteads. Tom Mitchell, one of Hatfield's crowd, began throwing lighted balls of cotton into the house which set it on fire. As he was doing this Randolph McCoy shot his hand off. He called Alvira to come up and put out the fire, which the two women had checked down stairs by putting milk on it. Alvira started up. She was shot in the breast and killed. Calvin McCoy, the old man's son, then started to make a break for the corn crib, intending to fire on the Hatfield gang while his father escaped from the building which by this time was in flames. He was shot through the head and died instantly. The old woman asked permission to bring her dead daughter out. She was caught, clubbed into insensibility and left for dead. Her own uncle, Jim Vance, did the deed.

The old man, roasted out from his garret, made a break for one of the doors, emptying a barrel of the shot into "Johnse" Hatfield's shoulder as he passed. He escaped.

"JOHNSE" GOES WEST.

"Johnse" Hatfield went west after this, but was rounded up at Seattle and driven from the country by Treeve Gibson, who had hunted him in the West Virginia hills. He came back to Mingo county and now figures before the public in an entirely new role—that of prisoner.

These are two of the crimes "Johnse" Hatfield confessed to participation in.

TRIES TO KILL DAN.

The murderer safely behind the bars, Deputy Cunningham started for Charleston, boarding the train yesterday morning at Sand Landing. When he got on he saw "Doc" Hatfield. With Doc were Bob Simpson and two other men. Half of this quartette was in the smoker and half in the other car. Attorney General E. P. Rucker was aboard the train also. Doc Hatfield saw Cunningham and went into the other car and spoke to Bob and his companion. They followed him into the rear car, and they crowded around Cunningham. Doc called Mr. Rucker aside and was talking to him. Suddenly he sprang up and said he was going to kill Cunningham. Rucker pulled him back but Doc reached over his shoulder and grabbed the detective by the collar. Conductor West and Brakeman Witt pulled him off. Ladies screamed and pandimonium reigned, but murder was averted. Doc and his companions got off at Thacker. They told Cunningham if he did not get off and be killed they would kill him in the train. The detective declined to get off, and the Hatfield crowd were hustled out. Cunningham came on to Charleston with his headache and souvenirs.

THE DETECTIVE'S RECORD.

Cunningham has made a record in the matter of arresting Hatfields. The first was Charles Gillespie, who confessed that he was in the gang that burned Ran. McCoy's house in 1888. He broke jail. He is now married and living in Virginia. There is a romance connected with this episode, but, as Kipling says, that is another story.

The detective's second victim was the younger Ellison Hatfield, whom he caught after a desperate struggle, on the head of Mate creek, in 1888. He confessed to participation in the crimes of '82 and '88, and was hanged. At the time he was caught, Ellison Hatfield, Tom Mitchell and Black Elliott Hatfield were going down to pay Frank Philips a polite call. The creek was swollen and they could not cross, so they put up at Josh Skeens, who is connected with the Counts of Jackson county—two sons of Richard Skeens, who went to Virginia from that county, were hanged in the Old Dominion the other day for killing a sheriff. Bill Napper and Treeve Gibson were with Cunningham on that occasion. Each picked out a man. Ellison fell to Cunningham, who, after a fight, handcuffed him to a Buckeye tree on the side of the creek. The other two got away. Frank Philips, whom the Hatfields were after, and who played an important part in the running of some of them to earth, was shot by his clerk twenty days ago and died Wednesday. Doc Hatfield attended him and amputated one of his legs. After he was buried, "Johnse" Hatfield and his friends crossed the river into Pike county, visited the grave at the mouth of Peter creek, fired a volly over it, preached the dead man's funeral and returned to West Virginia.

While returning from that trip, on which Ellison was captured, Cunningham ran across Aleck Messer, on Big Ugly, in Lincoln county—the man who shot little Ran's head off. He arrested him, took him to Pikeville, where he confessed and was sentenced to life imprisonment.

See the clipping

Devil Anse as an unwilling host

In a New York Sun piece, engineer F. C. Albright recalls the Tug river country. Two railroad detectives, warned of a Hatfield ambush, rode straight to Devil Anse's fortified house on Island Creek and were fed before he got home, so he had to host them, and he sent them off by a back way with a guide. Ambush, he says, is the mountaineer's way: ‘taking a bush to a man’.

El Paso Daily Herald · El Paso, Tex.

El Paso Daily Herald · 10 September 1898 · page 8 · transcribed from the page image

THE HATFIELDS AT HOME.

A Land Where Human Life is Cheap and the Marksmanship is Poor.

See moreSee less

"When I went with a surveying party into the Tug river country, in West Virginia, several years ago, there was doubt as to whether the natives would let us stay," said F. C. Albright, a civil engineer. "In general it was taken for granted by the mountaineers that any stranger who crossed the dead line, where the mountain district begins, was an enemy, a revenue officer or sheriff, whom it was their duty to pot for the public safety. But shortly before our coming the United States marshals had made some impression on the district and inspired a respect for government. The mountaineers regarded our surveys and railroad building as part of the government, and accordingly did not molest us.

"All are hospitable, and, like the Arab, the mountaineer regards the stranger who has eaten his salt as being under his protection. This brings me to a story of Devil Anse Hatfield and two of our railroad detectives. Devil Anse, as you probably have heard, is the patriarch and leader of the Hatfield clan. He lives in his fortified house on Island Creek with six or seven armed men always there as guard. Somehow the two detectives had got the ill will of the Hatfields, and an ambush was laid for them. The detectives got wind of it. They knew the country and the people and decided on the only thing that they could do. Leaving the road, they made a detour behind the men in ambush, and rode straight to the house of Devil Anse Hatfield. As luck would have it the old man was away, perhaps superintending the ambush, and they got to the house and within the door without being fired at. They set their rifles in a corner, hung their belts and pistols against the wall, sat down and asked for something to eat. When Devil Anse came back the woman had fed the detectives, and as they had eaten bread beneath his roof there was nothing for the old man to do but to play host with the best grace he could show. He made the best of the matter and gave the men the best supper and breakfast that the house afforded, and fed their horses. The next morning he sent them with a guide by an out-of-the-way part of the country.

"'He'll see you safe,' said Devil Anse at parting. 'If you took the main trail you'd likely meet some of my folks and I reckon they'd turn their guns loose without stopping to ask where you've been.'

"With all their readiness to shoot I found that in this country, where every man is supposed to carry a revolver and a Winchester rifle, the men are not good marksmen with either of these weapons. With the old-fashioned, long-barrelled squirrel rifle, using a rest, the mountaineer can draw a fine bead and bark a squirrel on a high limb with a great deal of certainty. But using a Winchester in a mix-up, such as is apt to occur when hostile factions come together on court days, he pumps away a great deal of ammunition for every man that falls. When he starts deliberately out to kill a man he always plans to shoot him from an ambuscade. This he calls taking a bush to a man. Not to be a partisan in one of the border feuds -- there are half a dozen along the line, some more inveterate and bloody than the Hatfield-McCoy vendetta -- is to be a man of small consideration in the community. The very young men are the worst. One of these is apt to think that he is of no account until he has got his man. He kills somebody of another clan to establish his reputation, and so keeps alive the feud.

"Few men that take part in the feuds have any idea how the quarrel started and what were the rights and wrongs in the matter. That a man is named McCoy or Hatfield is reason enough in the minds of any partisan opponent for killing him if a good chance offers. It is probable that some of the feuds date back to the end of the last century when the whites first settled in the mountains. They were pirates and outlaws generally, the tradition runs, who, after the revolutionary war, found the settled part of Virginia too warm for them and were forced westward until, entering the mountains by way of Cumberland Gap, they found a region where they could remain. They are not a religious people. In summer or autumn an open-air meeting is sometimes held in a meadow or in a grove. It is well attended -- too well, indeed, for almost invariably it ends in a fight, with shooting and somebody hurt. Mormons are active in this region and have made many proselytes. They do not preach nor do the converts adopt the polygamous features of the faith.

"The primitiveness of some of the people in the Tug river region is almost beyond belief. During the building of the Norfolk and Northern railroad the engineer of a passing construction train was hailed by a native, who asked him to stop and take him aboard. As the train continued on the fellow looked surprised and then indignant.

"'I'll teach you manners,' he said, and opened fire on the engineer with his Winchester. The engineer threw open the throttle, and he and the fireman dodged between the locomotive and tender, where they stayed until the train got out of range. Such happenings, repeated in one or another form, lent variety and excitement to railroad construction in this country, where the missionary had not arrived and the school master was not abroad."

-- New York Sun.

See the clipping

The photograph Devil Anse tried to destroy

The Sun prints what it calls the only group picture of the Hatfields taken with their consent, made at Devil Anse's Tug River cabin after Cap broke out of the Williamson jail in July 1897. Devil Anse and three younger sons destroyed the plate and smashed the photographer's cameras, but one proof survived and reached the McCoys. The Sun dates the wedding peace to April 1897 and hears talk it is over.

The Sun · New York, N.Y.

The Sun · 4 December 1898 · page 17 · transcribed from the page image

ONLY HATFIELD PICTURE.

PHOTOGRAPH OF THE FAMOUS WEST VIRGINIA OUTLAWS.

See moreSee less

In a Careless Moment Devil Anse Allowed It to Be Taken—The Hatfields Wrecked the Photographer's Establishment the Next Day, and Only One Proof Was Saved.

When the famous feud between the Hatfield and McCoy families, which cost many lives in the mountain country of West Virginia and Kentucky, was declared at an end in April, 1897, the families of old Randolph McCoy and the descendants of old Deacon Ellison Hatfield, led by the notorious Devil Anse, gathered on the banks of the Big Sandy River to sanction the wedding of Mary McCoy and young Aaron Hatfield. There are rumors now that this peace protocol is over and talk of a fresh outbreak. Whether there is any ground for the belief that the feud is to be reopened it is hard to tell, for fighting, not talking, is what both families engage in when the ill-feeling comes to the top and there are scores to be settled.

Four times the Hatfields and the McCoys gathered to declare off the feud that has been passed down through three generations, and three times out of the four blood was shed before the negotiations were concluded. Moonshine whiskey, which both families make and drink in large quantities, has been responsible mainly for the breaking of these compacts, and if the families go at each other again it will probably be because of the evil effects of the product of the illicit distilleries in the West Virginia mountains. It is almost incredible that such a feud could start up again and continue with the same freedom that it did twenty years ago, but it is possible, for the authorities of that State are as powerless to stop it to-day as they were years ago, when Parish and Sam McCoy shot and killed young Bill Stayton from ambush, thereby shedding the first blood of the feud.

The picture that accompanies this story is particularly interesting for two reasons. First, it is the only group picture ever taken of the Hatfields and the only picture ever taken of any of the leaders of that family with their consent. Secondly, having been taken in times of peace, it illustrates the caution with which these outlaws are observing the truce. There are four revolvers and four rifles in sight. How many small weapons there are in concealment it is impossible to tell, but the reader can be pretty certain that Mrs. Devil Anse and Mrs. Cap, in the background, and the two youngsters in the foreground are as well prepared for emergencies as their relatives. It was only a short time after this picture was taken that one of these youngsters tried to murder a deputy sheriff who had cornered his father, Cap Hatfield, who was a fugitive from justice, having escaped from the jail at Williamson. The youngster came pretty near succeeding in his purpose.

After Cap Hatfield escaped from jail in July, 1897, he made for Devil Anse's old home on Tug River, near the mouth of Peter Creek, where he was joined by the others who are shown in the picture. Some fifteen miles away, at a small settlement, a photographer had set up an establishment and he drove out to the Tug River cabin to get a picture of the Hatfields. The Hatfields received him decently enough, but refused to allow him to take a picture at first. Cap was particularly vehement in his objections, but Devil Anse was good-natured about the matter. He knew that he and Cap and other members of the family had had cameras snapped at them during visits to West Virginia towns time and again, and he finally got the whole crowd together and told the photographer to fire away.

The result was the picture here shown. The photographer took the plate away, promising to send back a set of the pictures. The next day Cap Hatfield was in an ugly mood. He cursed Devil Anse, himself and everybody else for sitting for a photograph, particularly at a time when officers were on his track, and, armed to the teeth, he set out for the settlement to do things to the photographer and his outfit. Now, of all the Hatfields, Cap is the most reckless and murderous. He, more than any other member of the family, with the possible exception of Ellison Mounts, is responsible for the killing and maltreating of women in the feud now supposed to be closed, and he is a scoundrel without morals or mercy. Killing is his pleasure, and there is no doubt in the world that he would have murdered that photographer if he'd ever caught him.

But Devil Anse looked out for that. With Elias, Trav and Joe he headed Cap off and sent him back to the cabin. All Hatfields have a way of doing what Devil Anse tells them to do, and even the bloodthirsty Cap is subservient to him. The old man told Cap that he'd see that none of the pictures were printed, and with his three younger sons he set out to keep his word.

The photographer declared on his solemn oath that he had sent the plate away to be developed. He was lying when he said it, and it was a good thing for him that it was Devil Anse and not Cap that he tried to fool. Anse and his boys found the plate and destroyed it. Then, as a lesson to the photographer, they smashed his cameras and wrecked his entire establishment. Then they went back to the cabin on Tug River.

But the photographer had struck off a proof before Devil Anse arrived. He toned this proof and made the picture shown here. It fell into the hands of the McCoys and one of them gave it to a travelling man who went through that region a short time ago. The cabin which is the background of the picture is deserted now and was practically deserted then. It was being used when the picture was taken as a hiding place for the fugitive Cap. It is over the fireplace in this cabin that the following, done in gaudy colors, has hung for years:

THERE IS NO PLACE LIKE OUR HOME.

Under this motto some wag wrote some years ago:

"Leastwise, not this side of hell."

Although the McCoys shed the first blood in the famous feud, the history of the affair shows no such atrocities credited to them as to the Hatfields. Anything more horrible than the revenge of Devil Anse and his sons for the murder of old Deacon Ellison Hatfield could not be imagined. The murder of Miss Allaphare McCoy by Ellison Mounts, who only committed the deed because he was quicker with his gun than Cap Hatfield, was the most dastardly crime of the whole feud and roused the whole country at the time. The McCoys have shot and killed, too, but there are no such terrible crimes against them as against the Hatfields, unless it be the murder of Deacon Ellison Hatfield, who was stabbed twenty-seven times in a claspknife duel with Talbot McCoy, and was beating his man when Farmer McCoy shot him in the back. And these two bewhiskered individuals in the picture, who would look like peaceful mountain farmers if it wasn't for their weapons, have been the chief actors in the crimes of the Hatfields. Deacon Ellison was always a peacemaker up to the time of that fight with Talbot McCoy.

In the language of a writer who has compiled some interesting facts about the feud, "the trouble all began over two long-nosed, razorbacked, elm-peeler hogs." Old Randolph McCoy lived on Pond Creek, in Pike county, Ky., and Deacon Ellison, Devil Anse and the rest of the Hatfields on the Logan county side of Tug River, West Virginia. Floyd Hatfield, a brother of Devil Anse, lived in Kentucky near Randolph McCoy. The McCoys accused Floyd Hatfield of stealing these two hogs, and the case came up for trial before Matthew Hatfield, who was a Justice of the Peace. Floyd Hatfield won the case and the hogs because he had the best witnesses.

Floyd's principal witness was old Bill Stayton, his brother-in-law. Stayton, with his son, young Bill, and several of the Hatfields were fishing in Tug River shortly after the trial when Randolph McCoy and two of his sons came along. Randolph opened up the hog question and finally called old man Stayton a perjurer, whereupon young Bill, who was only 18 years old, hit Randolph on the head with a stone. A few months later Parish and Sam McCoy murdered young Bill from ambush, but they were acquitted in a Kentucky court. The Hatfields were getting ready to do some killing themselves, when election day rolled around and the two families, being interested in the same candidate, patched up a peace which was kept for several years.

Johnson Hatfield, known as Jonce, was an outlaw in Kentucky at this time, and he opened up the bad feeling again by ruining Rose Ann McCoy, a daughter of Randolph McCoy. Then when Talbot and Farmer McCoy took advantage of their sister's intimacy with Jonce Hatfield to follow her to the outlaw's lair and arrest him in order to get the rewards offered for his capture, there was more trouble. Devil Anse, Cap, and the rest of the Hatfields, warned by Rose Ann, rescued Jonce from the McCoys, but the feeling was not allayed, and there would have been a heap of killing but for another election in which both families happened to be interested in the same candidate. The candidate was Thomas Stafford, a blood relation of the Hatfields and related by marriage to the McCoys, and on that election day the families declared peace once more, and sent down for buckets of moonshine in which to seal the compact.

It was on that day that Deacon Ellison was murdered, and only a few days later that Devil Anse and his sons took their revenge, that revenge being the most fearful tragedy of the feud. The McCoys and Hatfields drank moonshine to each other until they got to feeling ugly. Then Talbot McCoy remembered that young Elias, who is No. 2 in the picture, had once borrowed $1.75 from him and had failed to return it. Elias, who was a mere boy then, called Talbot a liar, and Talbot started to beat him. The sight of great, burly Talbot McCoy beating little Elias Hatfield was more than peaceful Deacon Ellison could stand. He drew a revolver and with Elias Hatfield, the youngster's uncle, went for Talbot. Farmer McCoy drew a pistol, and two constables, seeing trouble ahead, arrested Talbot and young Elias for fighting. All might have been well but for Deacon Ellison Hatfield. Too frequent indulgence in moonshine had changed him from a peacemaker to a troublemaker, and he denounced all the McCoys as scoundrels for pretending to make peace when they were really looking for fight. He called Talbot McCoy a coward for pitching into a boy and made a lunge at him with his knife. The constable who was holding McCoy let him go, and Talbot drew a knife, while the members of both families made a ring for the two men to fight it out.

Talbot McCoy sprang at the Deacon and plunged his knife into his side. The Deacon cut open his opponent's head and then the men fell apart. Ellison accidentally cut his own hand and dropping his knife he sailed into McCoy with his fists. Talbot stabbed him twenty-six times and then slipped and fell, with Deacon Ellison on top of him. The Deacon grabbed a heavy stone and in another moment would have crushed McCoy's head to a jelly, but at that moment Farmer McCoy shot him in the back, and then dropping his revolver ran up the road.

Then the constables asserted themselves, placing Farmer, who had been captured by Elias Hatfield and Talbot, under arrest. They also arrested Randolph McCoy, Jr., a mere boy, who was accused of stabbing Deacon Ellison in the legs during the fight. The prisoners were taken to John Hatfield's house, while the wounded man was taken care of by a neighbor. The news of the shooting of Deacon Hatfield brought a dozen Hatfields to John Hatfield's house, but the McCoys disappeared and made no attempt to rescue the prisoners.

The next day, while the constables were taking the prisoners to the Pikesville jail, they were met by Devil Anse and a lot of other Hatfields, who ordered the constables to take the prisoners to Blackberry Creek. On the way there Devil Anse took the prisoners away from the constables, tied them together with ropes, and drove them into West Virginia, where they were placed in a schoolhouse for safekeeping.

There Devil Anse told the prisoners that if Deacon Ellison died of his injuries they would be put to death. A lot of the McCoy women folks came and pleaded for mercy, but Devil Anse drove them all away. The prisoners suffered torture while in the schoolhouse, for the ropes that bound them were on so tight that the blood could not circulate.

When the news of Deacon Hatfield's death was brought to Devil Anse he conveyed it to the prisoners, and they broke down and wept. That night the Hatfields drove them down the road, still bound with ropes, and over the line into Kentucky. Farmer McCoy, who had fainted, was restored to consciousness, and then the march was resumed until the spot selected by Devil Anse was reached. Here the prisoners were thrown to the ground, then raised on their knees and tied in that position to some bushes. Talbot McCoy, who had asked to be allowed to face his executioners, was turned the other way, while Farmer was made to look into the weapons of his murderers. The boy Randolph was tied facing the others, and then Devil Anse yelled to Wall Hatfield that all was ready and that he was to give the word when to fire.

"Take aim. Fire!" yelled Wall, and every man discharged his weapon. Talbot and Farmer were killed instantly. No shot was fired at the boy. His punishment was to see his relatives die.

After the shooting the Hatfields started back for West Virginia, but they hadn't gone far when one of them objected to leaving the boy Randolph alive. It was dangerous, he said, as the boy knew every one of them and might send them all to the gallows.

"Go back, then," said Devil Anse, and this man went back and blew the top of the lad's head off with a shotgun. Back in West Virginia Devil Anse gathered his men around him and made them all swear a solemn oath never to reveal the night's doings under penalty of death.

It was some time after this that Cap Hatfield and Tom Wallace went to the cabin of Bill Daniels and horsewhipped Mrs. Daniels and her daughter, who was Wallace's wife, until they were insensible because they suspected them of having informed the McCoys of an intended raid into Kentucky. Mrs. Daniels died some time after as the result of this beating. Mrs. Wallace recovered. There were a number of killings between this affair and the murder of Allaphare McCoy, the most notable one being the murder of Jeff McCoy, one of the most peaceable of the McCoys, who was lured to his death by Devil Anse through base treachery.

The McCoys made a determined effort to bring some of the Hatfields to justice for their crimes and came pretty near succeeding. This infuriated the Hatfields and their revenge was the raid in which Allaphare McCoy was so brutally murdered. It was on a New Year's night that the Hatfields went to old Randolph McCoy's house and called upon him to surrender. In the house were Randolph and his wife, his son Calvin, Rose Ann, Cap Hatfield's former mistress and her little boy Melvin, of whom Cap was the father. They were in the west end of the house. In the east end were Allaphare, Addie and Fanny McCoy, daughters of Randolph, and Cora McCoy, the orphan daughter of Talbot.

Failing to get any response from Randolph, Cap Hatfield, Ellison Mounts and some of the others broke open the door at the other end of the house. Allaphare McCoy came out in her night dress and protested that there were no men in that part of the house.

"Light the fire or I'll shoot you," yelled Cap.

"Cap, I can't," cried the girl, putting her hands to her face. "I have no light. Don't kill me, Cap, I never done you any harm."

"Kill her," said Jim Vance, Devil Anse's brother-in-law.

Cap raised his gun, but before he could shoot Ellison Mounts fired, and the girl fell dead with a bullet in her heart. In the fight that followed a few minutes later Calvin McCoy was killed and all of the McCoy women were injured. Old Randolph escaped, however.

There were raids innumerable after that, some by the McCoys, some by officers of the law, but most of them by the Hatfields. The feud went on despite the efforts of the authorities to stop it, until March 1891, when it was declared off. Peace lasted until February, 1895, when a Hatfield adherent named Culler killed Henry Chafflin of the McCoy clan with a chunk of coal. That reopened the feud, and it raged up to the time of the wedding of Mary McCoy and Aaron Hatfield.

The last big row occurred on election day, 1896. Cap Hatfield came into Matewan with a rifle, a shotgun, and two pistols. He cast his vote, imbibed a lot of moonshine whiskey, then went out in the street, and, running across Rutherford McCoy, shot him dead. Walking up the street he ran across Henderson Chambers, a McCoy man, and mortally wounded him. Then with his 12-year-old boy he cleared out, closely pursued by Rutherford McCoy, Jr. The latter took a shot at Cap as he ran, and the bullet grazed Hatfield's hand. Wheeling around, Cap dropped to his knee, took careful aim, and put a bullet through young Rutherford's heart.

Cap was captured a few days later and put in the Williamson jail. He was convicted of manslaughter and served three months. Then he escaped from the jail and is to-day a free man. The most remarkable thing about the feud as it stands to-day is the unwillingness of the West Virginia authorities to punish any of the Hatfields for their crimes. They are afraid of reopening the feud. For just as sure as a Hatfield is arrested and prosecuted the rest of the Hatfields will blame it on the McCoys and a raid will follow. The McCoys have repeatedly sought for revenge through the courts, while the Hatfields have always settled differences with their guns. The Hatfields always regard the McCoys with suspicion, and if there is fresh trouble it will be because some of the McCoys are caught trying to set the machinery of justice going.

1. —— Dameron, a relative of the Hatfields and an "outlaw." 2. Elias Hatfield, son of "Devil Anse." 3. Son of "Cap" Hatfield. 4. Troy Hatfield, son of "Devil Anse." 5. "Devil Anse" Hatfield. 6. Mrs. "Devil Anse." 7. Mrs. "Cap" Hatfield. 8. Joe Hatfield, son of "Devil Anse." 9. Son of "Cap" Hatfield. 10. "Cap" Hatfield. 11. Supposed to be Ellison Mounts.

See the clipping

← Back to Act Five: Cupid Ends a Feud