As the Papers Told It

The Hatfields and the McCoys · As the Papers Told It

Act Seven

Devil Anse Caught

January 1899 – December 1901

The Hatfield son captured in 1898 was sentenced to life in January 1899. In July his brother Elias shot dead the deputy who had arrested him, then gave himself up to the governor; he was convicted, and by 1901 was dying of consumption in prison. A dispatch of September 1899 had Devil Anse himself surrendering, though in 1901 the papers still described the clan as riding free.

Jones Hatfield gets life at Prestonburg

A short Kentucky item: at Prestonburg, Jones Hatfield has been sentenced to life imprisonment for killing two of Randolph McCoy’s children in the night attack on McCoy’s home. Other clippings call this son of Devil Anse Johnson, Johnse or Jonce. Dan Cunningham and Doc Ellis had captured him in the summer of 1898; five months after this sentence, his brother Elias killed Ellis for it.

The Spout Spring Times · Spout SpringS, Ky.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Spout Spring Times · 28 January 1899 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

At Prestonburg, Jones Hatfield has been sentenced to life imprisonment on a verdict of guilty of the killing of two children of Randolph McCoy, in a night battle at McCoy's home. This was one of the fights of the celebrated Hatfield-McCoy feud of Kentucky.

See the clipping

Devil Anse’s son kills the deputy at Grey

The Wheeling Register’s special report and an Associated Press dispatch: on 3 July 1899 Elias Hatfield, 18, a son of Devil Anse, shot Deputy Sheriff H. E. Ellis dead on a train platform at Grey, then crossed the Tug into Kentucky with a posse behind him. Ellis had captured his brother John S. Hatfield, and the AP says the old feud ‘broke out afresh to-day’.

Wheeling Register · Wheeling, W. Va.

Wheeling Register · 4 July 1899 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

MURDERED BY A HATFIELD.

H. E. Ellis, a Deputy Sheriff, Shot Dead at Grey, W. Va.,

See moreSee less

BY ELIAS HATFIELD, AN EIGHTEEN-YEAR-OLD SON OF "DEVIL ANS" HATFIELD—EACH HAD A WINCHESTER AND BOTH FIRED AT ONCE, BUT HATFIELD WAS THE BETTER MARKSMAN AND PUT A BULLET THROUGH ELLIS'S HEAD—MURDERER ESCAPED TO KENTUCKY—FEUD MAY BREAK OUT ANEW.

Special to the Register.

GREY, W. VA., July 3.—At noon today when No. 11 N. & W. passenger train pulled into the station here from the South on the rear platform of the train stood H. E. Ellis, deputy sheriff of Mingo county.

Elias Hatfield, an eighteen-year-old son of "Devil Anse" Hatfield, came walking up to the train with a Winchester on his shoulder. He began cursing the deputy sheriff for having arrested his brother, John S. Hatfield, a few years ago and raised his Winchester off his shoulder preparing to take aim at Ellis.

The deputy sheriff sprang inside the car and grabbed his own Winchester and a moment later faced the youthful, but already notorious Hatfield. Both raised their winchesters and fired at the same instant.

Hatfield had taken the better aim. The ball from his Winchester penetrated the deputy sheriff's skull and he fell to the car platform a corpse without uttering a word.

The bullet from the deputy's Winchester penetrated Hatfield's arm, making only a flesh wound. Hatfield ran to Tug river and crossed over into Kentucky. After reaching the Kentucky shore, he brandished his Winchester and yelled: "I have accomplished my aim at last."

It is said that the young murderer promised his aged mother years ago that he would kill Deputy Sheriff Ellis because it was he who captured his brother, John Hatfield, who is now serving a life sentence in state's prison.

A posse of twenty or more men was soon formed who are now scouring the hills of Kentucky for the young desperado. If he is captured, which he is not likely to be without bloodshed, all indications point to a lynching bee.

H. E. Ellis, the murdered deputy, was one of the influential citizens of Mingo county. He was a Mason and an Odd Fellow, and to-day's tragedy may cause an uprising in this county such as was never before witnessed.

The Hatfield clan will, of course use every effort to prevent the capture of Elias and that great trouble is just ahead is a foregone conclusion.

Sheriff N. J. Keadle, the most fearless officer in the State, is leading the posse in pursuit of Hatfield. With Keadle's posse is William Bevins, a man who knows no fear and who has brought to justice a number of both Hatfields and McCoys.

(By Asssociated Press.)

WILLIAMSON, W. VA., July 3.—The old Hatfield-McCoy feud, which has been slumbering for a few years, broke out afresh to-day when H. E. Ellis was killed by Elias Hatfield and the two factions are arming for a renewal of the old-time struggle.

A few years ago John S. Hatfield, one of the conspicuous leaders against the McCoys was captured by Ellis, and after trial sentenced to life imprisonment. At that time Elias Hatfield, brother of John, declared openly that he would some day kill Ellis.

The opportunity was offered to-day when Hatfield saw Ellis standing on the rear platform of a passenger train as it pulled into Grey station, a few miles south of here. Hatfield secured his Winchester and began abusing the deputy and said: "Now is as good a time as I will get to blow your brains out." Deputy Ellis, whose bravery had never been questioned, thrust his hand into his pocket, pulled a huge revolver and aimed at Hatfield. Both guns fired at the same instant, but young Hatfield had taken the better aim and Ellis fell to the car platform a corpse. He never uttered a word. Hatfield, the desperado, immediately fled across the river into Kentucky, and from blood spots visible along his trial, it is evident that the bullet from the dead officer's revolver had taken eect. Sheriff N. J. Keale lost no time in organizing a posse and started in pursuit. At sundown no capture had been effected, but to-night the baying of the bloodhound can be heard echoing in the mountains along the Tug river; and they are no doubt warm on the murderer's trail. Ellis, the murdered deputy, was one of the influential citizens of Southern West Virginia. His friends are thoroughly enraged and swear that Hatfield will never be brought back to this State alive. The Hatfields are on the alert. Word has been passed along the line, and they are organizing to protect Elias and if possible prevent his capture. Elias is a son of "Devil Ans" Hatfield and a brother of the notorious "Cap." He is but 18 years of age, but he has been implicated with his clan in a number of murders before. He fears no man, and will, no doubt, fight to the death before he will surrender. Ellis, who was kille, was a distant relatives of the McCoys and the entire Hatfield family always held a grudge against him.

See the clipping

Elias surrenders to the governor in person

A Louisville special to the Chicago Record says Elias Hatfield, after a week holding off a posse in the Kentucky mountains, sent word he would surrender only to Governor Atkinson of West Virginia, and on 11 July 1899 did so at Gray, shaking the governor’s hand. He looked for acquittal on the ground of self defense; in September a Williamson jury convicted him of second-degree murder.

Daily Press · Newport News, Va.

Daily Press · 12 July 1899 · page 8 · transcribed from the page image

"Devil Anse's" Son in Limbo.

(By Telegraph.)

See moreSee less

CHICAGO, July 11.—A special to the Record from Louisville, Ky., says: Elias Hatfield, the noted desperado and son of "Devil Anse" Hatfield, leader of the Hatfield-McCoy feud that cost 141 lives, surrendered to Governor Atkinson of West Virginia, in person today, at Gray. Hatfield shot Sheriff Ellis a week ago and has been holding off a posse in the Kentucky mountains. He sent word that he would surrender to Governor Atkinson only.

Governor Atkinson and guards arrived at Gray this morning. Hatfield immediately approached and shook hands with the governor. The prisoner left with the governor for Huntington. Hatfield looks for acquittal on the ground of self defense.

See the clipping

Devil Anse said to surrender at his fort

A Matewan dispatch says a Mingo County posse, armed with fifty Winchesters from the state capital, attacked the old Hatfield fort, and Devil Anse, his son Bob and son-in-law John Dingess surrendered; Cap escaped. It says Anse won his name leading the party that shot three McCoys and burned their bodies at a stake; earlier reports here have the three tied and shot, and none mentions burning.

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

The Providence News · 12 September 1899 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

"DEVIL ANSE" CAUGHT. With His Son and Son-in-Law He Surrendered After a Fight.

Fears That Elias Hatfield Will Be Lynched Before His Trial Ends.

See moreSee less

Matewan, W. Va., Sept. 12.—The long expected attack upon the old Hatfield fort by a posse of citizens of this (Mingo) county was made late last evening, and after a sharp fight in which many shots were fired "Devil Anse" Hatfield, his son Bob and his son-in-law, John Dingess, surrendered.

"Cap" Hatfield, the most notorious of the name, managed to escape, as did also half a dozen others, but a portion of the posse is still in pursuit, and it is believed that their capture will be effected today.

"Devil Anse" is the father of "Cap." rected He won his title when he led the party which shot three of the McCoys across the border into Kentucky and burned their bodies at a stake. "Devil Anse" was never before arrested. He has more than a score of times led his kin in battle against the authorities both of Kentucky and West Virginia.

The posse which made the raid yesterday was organized at the request of Judge Dolittle of this circuit, and fifty Winchester rifles were sent here from the state capital for the use of the posse.

Inside the old fort which has shielded the Hatfields for so many years were found ammunition and provisions enough to supply a company of troops.

"Devil Anse" wept bitterly when talking of his past life. His one plea is that he may not be taken to Kentucky.

The trial of Elias Hatfield for the murder of Deputy Sheriff Ellis is now in progress at Williamson, Mingo county, but it is feared that he will be lynched before the trial ends.

See the clipping

Elias convicted of second-degree murder

A Williamson dispatch of 18 September 1899: after deliberating more than 12 hours, the jury finds Elias Hatfield guilty of second-degree murder for killing H. E. Ellis, a verdict carrying five to 20 years. There was no lynching; in 1901 he was serving 12 years at Moundsville. A special grand jury has indicted more of the clan, two for complicity in Ellis’s death, and any acquitted go to Kentucky.

The Breckenridge News · Cloverport, Ky.

The Breckenridge News · 20 September 1899 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

SECOND DEGREE. Elias Hatfield Found Guilty of the Murder of Ellis. Indictments Retureed Against a Num ber of His Clan. Williamson, W. Va., Sept. 18,—Elias Hatfield, who on July 3 murdered H. E. Ellis, was found guilty of murder in the second degree. The jury reached this verdict after deliberating more than 12 hours. His sentence will not be less than five or more than 20 years in prison. The special grand jury has returned indictments against a number of the Hatfield clan, two of which were for complicity in the murder of H. E. Ellis. They will be given a speedy trial here, and if acquitted will be turned over to the Kentucky authorities to answer for murders committed some time ago.

See the clipping

The feud follows two soldiers to Angel Island

A long San Francisco feature retells the feud, then reports that two feuding soldiers of the Thirty-first Infantry, in smallpox quarantine on Angel Island, quarreled and one shot the other in the arm and the leg, crippling him. Its history is loose: it names Hutchinson, not Rutherford, as the man Cap Hatfield quarreled with at the polls in November 1896, and puts the New Year’s raid of 1888 six months after a siege that follows that election.

The San Francisco Call · San Francisco, Calif.

The San Francisco Call · 22 October 1899 · page 25 · transcribed from the page image

THE HATFIELD-M'COY FEUD REACHES CALIFORNIA

BUCKETS of blood does not commence to describe the sanguineous losses of the Hatfield and McCoy families in Kentucky. They shed it by the barrelful and they have plenty left. All over Eastern Kentucky and West Virginia Hatfields and McCoys have fought and bled. They do not know what it is to feel afraid. But their neighbors do, and so when a Hatfield shoots a McCoy or vice versa the jury is usually a unit of shyness about saying anything which might hurt the family feelings.

See moreSee less

For the family are very clannish, so much so that the cause of one is the fight of all. So the juries disagree or agree to dismiss or do anything rather than to make themselves a part of the family history of the Hatfields and McCoys.

These two noted families are now like the star of empire, coming West along with the wave of prosperity.

Just now our Uncle Samuel is looking down the line for the real thing in fighting men. The Hatfields and McCoys are looking for trouble, they have a liking for it, generally speaking. They have also a particular fondness for killing niggers. So it was no trouble for the spruce recruiting officer to secure the services of a Hatfield for his country when there were about eight million niggers, more or less, to be killed in the Philippines.

That was just about the size of his appetite for gore.

But he had not killed them yet, and the bait was still dangling when a partisan of the McCoy family jumped at the alluring tidbit.

"Eight millions of niggers to be killed." Gods, just think of it! And then not even having to buy your own cartridges. Whoop! Crack! Bang! What a time! Blood till the rivers run red and no disagreeably inquisitive court proceedings afterward to bother about it.

So it came that at Fort Thomas, Ky., were enlisted in the Thirty-first Infantry, United States Volunteers, two men whose education had been to kill each other.

It was not long before they met. They were thoroughbreds and like them did not spend any time in preliminaries, but started without delay to get a line on each other. The two men were seized and disarmed, one to nurse his slow wrath, the other to meditate sudden vengeance. Their officers gave them such a lecture on military duties as only West Pointers know how to give, and as the men of their company had particular reasons for not wishing to stop any United States magazine rifle bullets with their three-mile range, it was solemnly promised that there should be nothing but good behavior, with all bullets reserved for Filipinos.

It has been said that that the feud commenced when the first Hatfields and McCoys were born, but the first time it appears in authentic history was when citizens of Pike County, in the eastern part of Kentucky, asked the Governor of the State to provide them with arms and ammunition with which they might defend themselves from an expected attack upon the various members and friends of the McCoy family, which was to be made by an armed force consisting of nearly 100 of the Hatfield family and adherents, who were coming from West Virginia under the leadership of "Devil" Anse Hatfield and Cap Hatfield.

This contemplated expedition of the Hatfields lacked only Government sanction to give it the title of war, for there were as many men and as much method in their preparations as in many of the Government's military exploits during the early history of our country.

It was the culmination of an election fight that took place in Pike County in 1882, when a McCoy shot a Hatfield, but even back of this there seemed to be faint shadows of beautiful faces and bold hearts that loved not wisely, for like all of the sons of Mars they were no laggards in love.

Law was laxly administered in that wild mountain region, where the moonshiner defies even the Government's most wily secret service men and the power of the military combined, so the Hatfields, in order to prevent any miscarriage of justice and also to give a salutary warning to any other men who might be inclined to send bullets trespassing within their anatomies, captured four members of the McCoy family who had been concerned in the disturbance and forcibly carried them as prisoners to West Virginia. With the prisoners once in their power, however, it seemed to them that to execute them in West Virginia was a sort of "killing sheep too near home." Besides the laws of West Virginia were more actively enforced. So by secret mountain trails and through wild forest paths the unhappy prisoners were returned to their native State and shot by their captors.

The Governor of Kentucky thereupon made a requisition on the Governor of West Virginia for some Hatfields. The West Virginia Governor was evidently well acquainted with his citizens, and not desiring to suddenly leave his office vacant, firmly but politely refused the request. This unusual proceeding caused a storm of popular feeling. Large rewards were offered for the Hatfields, and the Sheriff of Pike County finally extended his strong arm and his jurisdiction into the State of West Virginia until it embraced three Hatfields.

The Hatfields now considered that not only their own honor and feelings were outraged, but also that their State had been insulted.

Another Hatfield foray was organized to raid the McCoy home in Pike County. Again the Hatfields crossed the border and succeeded in attacking and burning the McCoy house and killing while confined in the burning house McCoy's wife, daughter and son.

The elder McCoy escaped, persuaded thirty of his relatives and friends to join him, invaded Logan County, West Virginia, killed two Hatfields and captured six, whom they took back with them and turned over to the authorities of Pike County.

It was now the turn of the West Virginia Governor to plead for the return of his citizens, but the Governor of Kentucky not only refused but under the authority vested in him by law for the suppression of crime offered a reward of $5000 apiece for each and every one of the West Virginia Hatfields who had been engaged in trespasses on Kentucky soil.

The size of this reward made the Hatfields much-sought-after people, and, desiring to be somewhat more retiring and exclusive than formerly, like all who attain prominence, they withdrew themselves from active circulation in society. In order to secure their privacy they commenced the construction of an impregnable stone fortress on the top of a thin cliff or wall of rock known as "Devils Backbone," that jutted out into the valley of the Tug River above Huntington, W. Va. Here for seven years they defied law or McCoys to take them. The fortress was entirely of stone, even the roof being of that material.

It may seem strange that men could exist practically in a state of siege during that time, but it must be remembered that the friends and neighbors do not forget them, for there is always something attractive in assisting fugitives, and again there are many ways of profitable action open to those who have succeeded in placing themselves securely beyond the reach of the law.

But confinement and lack of exercise finally told upon the Hatfields and they longed for something more than a mere defensive existence.

In November, 1896, "Old Cap" Hatfield went down to Matewan to vote. Not that he cared particularly, but there is no nicer place to look for trouble than around the polls. It is a tradition of the race that leaders should be chosen by force and the old spirit still feebly shows when election day comes around.

It was not long before he was in a dispute with Hutchinson, one of the men whose family he had broken up in former years, and who was a member of the McCoy side of the feud.

Hatfield had to flee for his life, pursued by a nephew of Hutchinson, who fired at him repeatedly until "Cap" Hatfield turned and with his practiced aim dropped the young man in his tracks.

The whole of Mingo County was now stirred as no war had ever excited it before. Hatfield and twenty of his feudists retired to their fort on Tug River and one hundred more of his adherents prepared to go to the assistance of the stronghold on the Devils Backbone to prevent the arrest of Hatfield.

Something had to be done by the legal authorities if the power of the legal government was to be maintained. The fort could not be taken, for it was only to be reached by dizzy climbing single file. Artillery could not be brought in to those wild cliffs, so the Sheriff finally determined on blowing up the whole promontory with nitro-glycerin. Tons of the explosive were piled at its base in a spot sheltered by overhanging rocks from the fire of the fort. The slow match that was to fire the mine was necessarily very long in order to enable the Sheriff and his attacking forces to retire to a safe distance. After lighting it, in their haste to get away before the mountain fell, they exposed themselves to view of the Hatfields and three of the posse were shot.

The besieged force now looked for the cause of the close approach of the intruders. They saw the smoke from the burning fuses, recognized the peculiar tarry sulphurous smell and knew at once that some sort of an explosion was in store for them, and that instant escape only might save their lives. The remainder of the Sheriff's posse, having by this time placed themselves in ambush, began with their rifles to pick off the Hatfields as they clambered in wild frenzy down the cliff trail. Sure death awaited every one, so they determined to await the uncertain, rather than take the certain death, and returned to the top of the promontory to hurl vast stones below in vain attempts to strike and extinguish the torturingly slow fuses that sputtered out their dense folds of smoke.

Then came a burst of thunder sound, the air was filled with rocks, trees and blinding dust that filled the valley like a fog. Before it had cleared away and while the Sheriff was still looking for his game, a rifle shot was heard up the valley and another of the posse fell. That was Hatfield's farewell to the Sheriff. The invested forces had been missed by the force of the explosion and the dust of the explosion that was to have been his death concealed his escape until safe on the mountain above.

Hatfields and McCoys and their active partisans were now scattered far and wide, usually killing and seldom suffering any penalty.

About six months after the destruction of the fortress, Johnson Hatfield planned a grand coup, by which the McCoys were nearly exterminated. New Year's eve he fired a McCoy house. Hatfields had been posted all about the place. The McCoys, not suspecting the cause of the fire, were endeavoring to pack up and save some of their possessions.

Beautiful Allfair McCoy ran out of the house followed by her brother. Shots were fired. He fell, and as she stooped to lift him Johnson Hatfield shot her frail body through and through. The rage of McCoy made him like a demon, and in his fury the Hatfields, superior in numbers, were routed with loss. The trial of Johnson Hatfield did not occur until the beginning of this year, and the population of Prestonburg trembled at the assemblage of Hatfields, who were called out by their leaders but kept in submission by officers of the law.

For the present the feud is quiescent in the East. The stone fort is destroyed and the bodies of its defenders carry many bullets that pain and call forth curses as the moonshiner toils up stony mountain trails. The McCoys seek in far away lands to live in peace and escape the bloody death that waits them, but now under California's bright sun and over her summer parched hills the feudal bullets whistle and sing, for when the Thirty-first Infantry was discovered to be smallpox infected and sent into quarantine on Angel Island, the space became too small to hold the two belligerent soldiers, whose traditions did not allow them within forty miles of each other. The detention camp at Angel Island has been placed as remote as possible from civilization and far away from sight of human habitation. Surrounded by the great bay to the north and mountainous ridges, guarded along their crests by armed men on the southeast and west, this confinement became insupportable to the two feudatories used to the freedom of their mountain life, and they met in a furious quarrel before they had been long confined and were with difficulty separated. A solemn warning was given them—for the commanders of the regiment are mainly West Pointers and the discipline there is on the whole noticeably good.

The trouble still smoldered between the two men, and one day one of them fancied that his life was in danger if he did not protect it. With him forewarned was forearmed indeed. To his intent he rushed, and with malice aforethought secured his gun and came out to fire upon his fellow soldier.

At the first shot the victim was struck in the arm. The second struck him in the leg and crippled him hopelessly. No chance for him to win glory now in the wars. When his regiment sails he must sadly stay behind, and with the Thirty-first that is the saddest thing in life. Once, when they were Kentucky volunteers at Tampa, orders came for them to sail. Great was their glee when the transport steamed away for Cuba. But scarcely had she cleared the land when after her came a flying arrow of a torpedo boat to say that it was a mistake, and that they should return. The rage of the regiment could scarcely yield itself to discipline. To fight was their only ambition, and to be pulled back was worse to them than facing death.

Again, in San Francisco they were ordered on board the Grant; their baggage was discovered among the men, and away they went to Camp Detention, at Angel Island. But while they sail away happy and free to fight, the wounded man and his assailant will suffer more in being left behind than from the wound or the punishment inflicted for the crime.

But there will be an atonement. When the snow comes again at the old Kentucky home kind friends will redden it with the blood of his enemy's family, to make sorrowing women weep over a flowerless mound beneath the silent hemlocks. So the patient nurses his wounds and his wrath.

"Serious but not necessarily fatal" the surgeon said. Not fatal to the wounded man. But have a care, you innocent children, clambering on the barnyard gate back there in old Kentucky. Somewhere, somewhere there is a bullet long and slim like the stub of a lead pencil, and some day from an ambush will come a rifle crack and your golden curls will tumble in the dust, and ere your mother can wipe the blood from your whitening eyes her blood will be mixing with yours in the little pools in the hollows of the dust, and a tall, quite serious-faced man will throw another shell in his rifle, pass his hand over the handle of his pistol and walk away through the darkening forest.

TONS OF EXPLOSIVE WERE PILED AT THE BASE

THEY BEGAN TO PICK THEM OFF AS THEY CLAMBERED IN FRENZY DOWN THE HILL

JOHNSON HATFIELD SHOT HER THROUGH AND THROUGH

ON THE WARPATH.

See the clipping

Pardon urged for Elias, said to be dying

A Wheeling dispatch: the state board of pardons, sitting at the Moundsville penitentiary, decides to recommend a pardon for Elias Hatfield, less than two years into a 12 year sentence, because he is dying of consumption. The headline calls his victim Doc Ellis, the name under which an 1898 report describes Ellis helping Dan Cunningham capture Elias’s brother Johnse.

The Huntington Advertiser · Huntington, W. Va.

The Huntington Advertiser · 4 April 1901 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

HATFIELD TO BE PARDONED

THE SLAYER OF "DOC" ELLIS SAID TO BE DYING AT MOUNDSVILLE.

See moreSee less

WHEELING, W. Va, Apr. 4—The board of pardons which is in session at the Moundsville penitentiary this afternoon decided to recommend a pardon for Elias Hatfield, of Hatfield-McCoy feud fame, who is serving a 12 year sentence. They will give as a reason the fact that Hatfield is dying of consumption. Attorney Charles J. Schuck and Captain Ewing had Hatfield's case and pleaded for his pardon yesterday.

See the clipping

The marshal who hunts Hatfields

A Washington Evening Star feature on Deputy United States Marshal Daniel W. Cunningham, who it says has captured four of the clan and sent one to the gallows. That one, called here Ellison Hatfield, is the man earlier reports call Ellison Mounts, hanged at Pikeville in 1890. When Bud McCoy’s men wanted to ‘cut him up into inch pieces’, Cunningham raised his rifle and refused to give him up.

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

Evening Star · 6 April 1901 · page 24 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

HUNTING HATFIELDS

The Dangerous Pursuit of a Deputy United States Marshal.

See moreSee less

HAS CAPTURED FOUR OF THE CLAN

Deeds of Daring in the Mountains of West Virginia.

AT THE RIFLE'S POINT

Written for The Evening Star.

Throughout the northern spurs of the Alleghanies the name of Hatfield is a name of terror. Devil Anse and his clan have for years and almost with impunity ravaged the mountain region of four states—Virginia, West Virginia, Kentucky and Tennessee—with murder, arson and all other crimes of violence. The murders perpetrated by them in the Hatfield-McCoy feud are only a small part of their crimes. Nowhere in criminal annals is there another family with so bloody a record.

In their own home region of southern West Virginia their dominance is complete. There is a saying there, backed by a long and grim record, that to offend a Hatfield is the surest form of suicide. Even the officers of the law seldom interfere with them, and though the aggregate of indictments against the clan mounts up into the hundreds, its members, armed to the teeth, not only ride free in their own mountains, but even visit the cities unmolested when they choose. If they take a grudge against a man they hunt him to his death, and their list of victims was a long one before any man, except the McCoys, raiding in reprisal from across the border of Kentucky, dared interfere with them. But now they are being hunted in their own state by a man who has already captured four of them and sent one to the gallows. This is Deputy United States Marshal Daniel W. Cunningham of the district of West Virginia.

His First Capture.

Originally Cunningham was a partisan of the Hatfields. He had been a recipient of the surly and dangerous hospitality of Devil Anse and had heard his side of the Hatfield-McCoy history. Shortly after that he stayed at the house of Jim Vance, one of the Hatfield leaders, who had been killed while raiding in Kentucky, and heard from Vance's widow the story of the butchery of three defenseless McCoy children by a force of Hatfields, the first act in carrying out the declaration of extermination against the McCoys. Once convinced of the truth of this the marshal made a resolve to capture and turn over to justice every participant in that crime who should cross his path, and within a month he had made his first capture.

This was the taking of Charles Gillespie, who, after the murders, went to his aunt's home in Tazewell county, Virginia, just across the line. The house stands on a remote mountain, reached by a horse trail. Thither Cunningham made his way, pretending to be a friend of Gillespie's. At the house he learned that Gillespie spent his days in the mountain forest, coming in only at night. In a clearing of the woods he found the young desperado, carrying the inevitable rifle. Whistling a cheerful tune, the marshal walked along the trail until he met Gillespie, whose suspicions were disarmed, for he never supposed that a man hunter would be whistling on the trail. As they came face to face Cunningham caught the young fellow by the wrists. Gillespie struggled, but the marshal's muscles are scarcely less hard than the steel handcuffs which he snapped upon the desperado's wrists, ending the fight. Gillespie confessed to his part in the murders, substantiating the story told by Mrs. Vance. Cunningham took him to Kentucky, where he was tried and convicted, but afterward broke jail and escaped.

A Daring Enterprise.

While in Pike county, Kentucky, Cunningham learned of a plot to bushwhack and murder Frank Phillips, a partisan of the McCoy family. Ellison Hatfield, Black Elliott Hatfield and Tom Mitchell, murderers of the McCoy children, and also of Miss Allenham and Calvin McCoy in the attack Allaphare and Colvin McCoy, in the attack on old Randall McCoy's house, had planned to go from Jim Vance's house, which is a few miles within the West Virginia line, over the border into Pike county, and lay for Phillips there. Cunningham planned a counter ambush, in which he enlisted Bill Napper, an experienced hunter, and a young man named Gibson, of less experience, but equal gameness. The marshal knew that any one of the Hatfield gang would kill him on sight, but that if he killed any of them he must stand trial for it, as the state administration of West Virginia was, for reasons of its own, friendly to the Hatfields. It looked like a dubious proposition, for the three Hatfield men had Winchesters, but Cunningham determined to have a try at it. He picked out Ellison, the biggest and most dangerous of the trio, for himself, assigning Black Elliott to Napper and Mitchell to Gibson. Concealing themselves behind trees, they waited for their men near a creek bottom, along which the bushwhackers were sure to come.

When they came Ellison was in the lead, walking along the bank. Cunningham stood close behind his tree with a rock in one hand and his rifle in the other. The other two Hatfields were a distance behind, while Cunningham's aids were farther up the bank. When Ellison was within a few yards of Cunningham, the marshal, moving slowly around his tree to keep out of sight, stepped on a crackling twig. Instantly the rifle of the desperado was leveled, but before he could fire the rock took him on the chin and he wavered for a second. In that second Cunningham was upon him. At the same moment Gibson opened fire and Mitchell and Black Elliott fled back along the creek bed, pursued by Cunningham's assistants, who left him in full confidence that he could handle Ellison.

A Fight for Life.

This proved to be a big contract, however. The marshal had wrenched away Ellison's gun, by which time the outlaw had recovered from his surprise and began to put up a furious fight. The rock had struck him only a glancing blow, and had not impaired his powers. He was as big a man as his antagonist and almost as strong. At the first wrench after they had clinched both went over the bank. In the rocky creek bed they struggled, now in the water, now out of it, never on their feet, the Hatfield tearing and biting at his captor like a wild beast, the marshal striving to get the handcuffs on his man. Endurance and condition won the battle. Moon- rance shine whisky is bad for the wind, and when Napper and Mitchell returned empty-handed Ellison was tied and handcuffed, while Cunningham was washing his bruised and bloody face in the creek. Cunningham took Ellison across the river to Kentucky, where they found Bud McCoy waiting with twelve men. The McCoys called on Cunningham to give up Ellison Hatfield to them, and at that Ellison broke down, cried and begged, and confessed the murder of Allaphare McCoy. Cunningham asked Bud McCoy what he intended to do with Ellison. "Kill him and cut him up into inch pieces." "Then you'll kill me first," said Cunningham, lifting his rifle. Gave Them Another Chance. After a consultation, McCoy promised to land Ellison Hatfield in jail without maltreatment, a promise which he kept. Ellison was tried, convicted and hanged. The Hatfields swore that they would have Cunningham's life if he ever again came into their country. Within a short time he gave them the chance, by going after Ellick Messer, another member of the child-mur-

dering expedition. Young Gibson went with him. They found Messer near the Hatfield settlement sitting on a log with his rifle across his knees, and captured him without a fight. At the station, where they took the train for Kentucky, they encountered a dozen of the Hatfield clan, fully armed, who had heard of the capture, and had liquored up and declared their intention of blowing Cunningham to bits. The worst they did after contemplating the obvious readiness of Cunningham's and Gibson's rifles was to curse compendiously, and assure the captive that they would derail the train and get him out. He was taken to Kentucky, confessed and got a life sentence. It was afterward discovered that before joining the Hatfield gang he had murdered the three children of a man against whom he had a grudge. Recovered the Boy. Thereafter whenever Cunningham was in the southwestern part of the state the Hatfields followed him. That they never succeeded in catching up to him would seem to indicate lack of zeal on their part, difficult to reconcile with the fervor of their threats. Three years ago the marshal gave them an excellent chance to get him, had they been on the alert. In a drunken revel, one night, they had instituted a little sport with a poor woodchopper named Duffy, which ended characteristically in their driving him into a pond, where he was drowned. His nine-year boy they took to bring up in their clan. The boy's uncle learned of it, and advertised a reward for the recovery of the child. Nobody came forward to apply for the job until a friend suggested that Mr. Duffy write to Dan Cunningham. That official took three days off, rode alone into the Hatfield settlement, found the boy at a house within half a mile of Devil Anse's homestead, grabbed him up on his horse, and galloped away. If the Hatfields followed, he did not know it. Thus was spoiled an outlaw in the making. In Gilbert, W. Va., lives Doc Ellis, a well-to-do timber owner. Against him the notorious Jonce Hatfield had sworn a grudge, for some fancied grievance, and sent word that he would kill him on sight. As it was a great detriment to Ellis' business to have a Hatfield gunning for him, he hired a crack shot named Hopkins to keep watch for Jonce and shoot first. Neither Hopkins nor Jonce had had any luck in their shooting, when Dan Cunningham came to Gilbert and put up at Ellis' house. Ellis told him of Jonce's threat. "I've got a little business with Jonce myself," said Cunningham. "Reckon I'll hang around for a few days." Two evenings later Hopkins came in and said that two men with Winchesters were lying out in a ragweed patch near the house. One of them, he thought, was Jonce Hatfield. "We'll go out and get them," said Cunningham. Hopkins was willing, and a lumberman who had dropped in volunteered to go

Daniel W. Cunningham, Deputy U. S. Marshal.

along. Counting in Ellis, the party was four strong, all around. But Jonce had a reputation as a dead shot, had killed a dozen men, and he and his companion had all the advantage of the position. Cunningham led his forces out of the house by a rear exit, and around by a gully to a spot near the ragweed patch. He had made a study of the ground about the house previously, and knew just how to go ahead. With Ellis close behind him, he crept up close to where Jonce crouched. The outlaw had his gun pointed at a lighted window of the Ellis house, waiting for a figure to show. The curtain was down. It always was in that house, for just such a reason.

"Don't reckon we'll get him tonight," the attacking party heard Jonce mutter to his companion.

"Shall I shoot the d—d murderer?" whispered Ellis.

"No," replied Cunningham. "I want him alive."

Then he broke cover and went straight for Jonce. Hatfield wheeled, but Cunningham's rifle pointed straight between his eyes. The other man dropped on all fours and scuttled away through the weeds. Jonce stood paralyzed.

"Hands up," commanded Cunningham.

The outlaw hesitated.

"Reach for the stars! Quick!" came the sharp order.

Threaten His Life.

The outlaw's rifle fell and his hands went up. Cunningham took from him a 44-caliber revolver and a fine English dirk, and left him in charge of Ellis while he went after the other man. The man was soon found and captured. He was Auk Dameron, and as Cunningham knew nothing at that time against him he was released. This proved to be an error, for it was afterward found that Dameron had broken jail under sentence of death for the murder of a deputy sheriff in Virginia. Cunningham took Jonce Hatfield to Kentucky, where he broke down and confessed. He is now serving a life sentence for the murder of the McCoy children. Naturally that made the Hatfields more savage than ever against Cunningham, and they redoubled their threats. Now, whenever he is in that country he gets warning that bands of mounted Hatfields are following him. But, as before, they don't catch up. He holds the clan in contempt.

"If they can get you foul they'll kill you," he says. "But in the open they're all cowards."

It is not part of Cunningham's duty as a federal officer to hunt Hatfields. He does it as he would hunt rattlesnakes, and as his warrants for "moonshine" whisky distillers often take him to the Hatfield country, he is likely to get more of them. Cunningham is not the sort of man that one would care to have on his trail. He is more than six feet tall, broad in proportion, beautifully muscled, possessed of catlike agility and as swift as he is sure with a rifle or revolver, and in that country swiftness is a necessary accompaniment of sureness. He is always in the hardest of training, as he neither drinks, smokes nor chews. In manner and appearance he is quiet and unostentatious, and when going about the country is commonly taken for an itinerant clergyman. THE CAPTURE OF ELLISON HATFIELD. "REACH FOR THE STARS. QUICK!"

See the clipping

The ambush in the ragweed patch

Two weeks later the Omaha Bee prints the same feature under its own headlines. Its last scene is the 1898 capture of Jonce Hatfield in a ragweed patch, his gun pointed at a window of Doc Ellis’s house; when Ellis asked to shoot him, Cunningham said ‘I want him alive.’ The piece speaks of Ellis as living at Gilbert, though Elias Hatfield had killed him in 1899.

Omaha Daily Bee · Omaha, Neb.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

Omaha Daily Bee · 21 April 1901 · page 27 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

FINISH OF A BLOODY FEUD Hatfield Clan of Murderers Run to Cover and Captured.

DESPERATE TASK OF FEDERAL OFFICERS

See moreSee less

Killers Bagged in the Mountain Fastnesses of West Virginia—Worst Feared Ruffians in the Country.

Throughout the northern spurs of the Alleghanies the name of Hatfield is a name of terror. Devil Anse and his clan have for years and almost with impunity ravaged the mountain region of four states—Virginia, West Virginia, Kentucky and Tennessee—with murder, arson, and all other crimes of violence. The murders perpetrated by them in the Hatfield-McCoy feud are only a small part of their crimes.

petrated Nowhere in criminal annals is there another family with so foul and bloody a record.

In their own home region of southern West Virginia their dominance is complete. There is a saying there, backed by a long and grim record, that to offend a Hatfield is the surest form of suicide. Even the officers of the law seldom interfere with them and though the aggregate of indictments against the clan mounts up into the hundreds, its members, armed to the teeth, not only ride free in their own mountains, but even visit the cities unmolested when they choose. If they take a grudge against a man they hunt him to his death, and their list of victims was a long one before any man, except the McCoys, raiding in reprisal from across the border of Kentucky, dared interfere with them. But now they are being hunted in their own state by a man who has already captured four of them and sent one to the gallows. This is Deputy United States Marshal Daniel W. Cunningham of the district of West Virginia. Originally Cunningham was a partisan of the Hatfields. He had been a recipient of the surly and dangerous hospitality of Devil Anse and had heard his side of the Hatfield-McCoy history. Shortly after that he stayed at the house of Jim Vance, one of the Hatfield leaders, who had been killed while raiding in Kentucky, and heard from Vance's widow the story of the butchery of three defenseless McCoy children by a force of Hatfields, the first act in carrying out the declaration of extermination against the McCoys. Once convinced of the truth of this the marshal made a resolve to capture and turn over to justice every participant in that crime who should cross his path, and within a month he had made his first capture.

This was the taking of Charles Gillespie, who, after the murders, went to his aunt's home in Tazewell county, Virginia, just across the line. The house stands on a remote mountain, reached by a horse trail. Thither Cunningham made his way, pretending to be a friend of Gillespie's. At the house he learned that Gillespie spent his days in the mountain forest, coming in only at night. In a clearing of the woods he found the young desperado, carrying the inevitable rifle. Whistling a cheerful tune, the marshal walked along the trail until he met Gillespie, whose suspicions were disarmed, for he never supposed that a man hunter would be whistling on the trail. As they came face to face, Cunningham caught the young fellow by the wrists. Gillespie struggled, but the marshal's muscles are scarcely less hard than the steel handcuffs which he snapped upon the desperado's wrists, ending the fight. Gillespie confessed to his part in the murders, substantiating the story told by Mrs. Vance. Cunningham took him to Kentucky, where he was tried and convicted, but afterwards broke jail and escaped.

In the Haunts of the Clan.

While in Pike county, Kentucky, Cunningham learned of a plot to bushwhack and murder Frank Phillips, a partisan of the McCoy family. Ellison Hatfield, Black Elliot Hatfield and Tom Mitchell, murderers of the McCoy children and also of Miss Allaphare and Colvin McCoy, in the attack on old Randall McCoy's house, had planned to go from Jim Vance's house, which is a few miles within the West Virginia line, over the border into Pike county, and lay for Phillips there. Cunningham planned a counter ambush, in which he enlisted Bill Napper, an experienced hunter, and a young man named Gibson of less experience, but equal gameness. The marshal knew that any one of the Hatfield gang would kill him on sight, but that if he killed any of them he must stand trial for it, as the state administration of Virginia was, for reasons of its own, friendly to the Hatfields. It looked like a dubious proposition, for the three Hatfield men had Winchesters, but Cunningham determined to have a try at it. He picked out Ellison, the biggest and most dangerous of the trio, for himself, assigning Black Elliott to Napper and Mitchell to Gibson. Concealing themselves behind trees they waited for their men near a creek bottom, along which the bushwhackers were sure to come.

When they came Ellison was in the lead, walking along the bank. Cunningham stood close behind his tree, with a rock in one hand and his rifle in the other. The other two Hatfields were a distance behind, while Cunningham's aides were further up the bank. When Ellison was within a few yards of Cunningham the marshal moving slowly around his tree to keep out of sight, stepped on a crackling twig. Instantly the rifle of the desperado was leveled, but before he could fire the rock took him on the chin and he wavered for a second. In that second Cunningham was upon him. At the same moment Gibson opened fire and Mitchell and Black Elliott fled back along the creek bed, pursued by Cunningham's assistants, who left him in full confidence that he could handle Ellison.

This proved to be a big contract, however. The marshal had wrenched away Ellison's gun, by which time the outlaw had recovered from his surprise, and began to put up a furious fight. The rock had struck him only a glancing blow, and had not impaired his powers. He was as big a man as his antagonist, and almost as strong. At the first wrench, after they had clinched, both went over the bank. In the rocky creek bed they struggled, now in the water, now out of it; never on their feet; the Hatfield tearing and biting at his captor like a wild beast; the marshal striving to get the handcuffs on his man. Endurance and condition won the battle. Moonshine whisky is bad for the wind and when Napper and Mitchell returned, empty-handed, Ellison was tied and handcuffed while Cunningham was washing his bruised and bloody face in the creek. Cunningham took Ellison across the river to Kentucky, where they found Bud McCoy waiting with twelve men. The McCoys called on Cunningham to give up Ellison Hatfield to them; and at that Ellison broke down, cried and begged, and confessed the murder of Allaphare McCoy. Cunningham asked Bud McCoy what he intended to do with Ellison. "Kill him and cut him up into inch pieces."

"Then you'll kill me first," said Cunningham, lifting his rifle.

Again on the Trail.

After a consultation, McCoy promised to land Ellison Hatfield in jail without maltreatment, a promise which he kept. Ellison was tried, convicted and hanged. The Hatfields swore that they would have Cunningham's life if he ever again came into their country. Within a short time he gave them the chance, by going after Ellick Messer, another member of the child-murdering expedition. Young Gibson went with him. They found Messer near the Hatfield settlement sitting on a log with his rifle across his knees, and captured him without a fight. At the station, where they took the train for Kentucky, they encountered a dozen of the Hatfield clan, fully armed, who had heard of the capture, and had liquored up and declared their intention of blowing Cunningham to bits. The worst they did after contemplating tention the obvious readiness of Cunningham's and Gibson's rifles, was to curse compendiously, and assure the captive that they would derail the train and get him out. He was taken to Kentucky, confessed and got a life sentence. It was afterward discovered that before joining the Hatfield gang he had murdered the three children of a man against whom he had a grudge.

Thereafter whenever Cunningham was in the southwestern part of the state the Hatfields followed him. That they never succeeded in catching up to him would seem to indicate lack of zeal on their part, difficult to reconcile with the fervor of their threats. Three years ago the marshal gave them an excellent chance to get him, had they been on the alert. In a drunken revel, one night, they had instituted a little sport with a poor woodchopper, named Duffy, which ended characteristically in their driving him into a pond, where he was drowned. His 9-year boy they took to bring up in their clan. The boy's uncle learned of it and advertised a reward for the recovery of the child. Nobody came forward to apply for the job until a friend suggested that Mr. Duffy write to Dan Cunningham. That official took three days off, rode alone into the Hatfield settlement, found the boy at a house within a half mile of Devil Anse's homestead, grabbed him up on his horse and galloped away. If the Hatfields followed he did not know it. Thus was spoiled an outlaw in the making.

In Gilbert, W. Va., lives Doc Ellis, a well-to-do timber owner. Against him the notorious Jonce Hatfield had sworn a grudge, for some fancied grievance, and sent word that he would kill him on sight. As it was a great detriment to Ellis' business to have a Hatfield gunning for him he hired a crack shot named Hopkins to keep watch for Jonce and shoot first. Neither Hopkins nor Jonce had any luck in their shooting when Dan Cunningham came to Gilbert and put up at Ellis' house. Ellis told him of Jonce's threat.

"I've got a little business with Jonce myself," said Cunningham. "Reckon I'll hang around for a few days."

Two evenings later Hopkins came in and said that two men with Winchesters were lying out in a ragweed patch near the house. One of them he thought was Jonce Hatfield.

"We'll go out and get them," said Cunningham.

Caught Red Handed.

Hopkins was willing and a lumberman who had dropped in volunteered to go along. Counting in Ellis the party was four strong, all armed. But Jonce had a reputation as a dead shot, had killed a dozen men, and he and his companion had all the advantage of the position. Cunningham led his forces out of the house by a rear exit, and around by a gully to a spot near the ragweed patch. He had made a study of the ground about the house, previously, and knew just how to go ahead. With Ellis close behind him he crept up close to where Jonce crouched. The outlaw had his gun pointed at a lighted window of the Ellis house, waiting for a figure to show. The curtain was down. It alawys was in that house, for just such a reason.

"Don't reckon we'll get him tonight," the attacking party heard Jonce mutter to his companion.

"Shall I shoot the d—n murderer?" whispered Ellis.

"No," replied Cunningham. "I want him alive."

Then he broke cover and went straight for Jonce. The Hatfield wheeled, but Cunningham's rifle pointed straight between his eyes. The other man dropped on all fours and scuttled away through the weeds. Jonce stood paralyzed.

"Hands up," commanded Cunningham.

The outlaw hesitated.

"Reach for the stars! Quick!" came the sharp order.

The outlaw's rifle fell and his hands went up. Cunningham took from him a forty-four caliber revolver and a fine English dirk and left him in charge of Ellis while he went after the other man. The man was soon found and captured. He was Auk Dameron and as Cunningham knew nothing at that time against him he was released. This proved to be an error, for it was afterward found that Dameron had broken jail under sentence of death for the murder of a deputy sheriff in Virginia. Cunningham took Jonce Hatfield to Kentucky, where he broke down and confessed. He is now serving a life sentence for the murder of the McCoy children. Naturally, that made the Hatfields more savage than ever against Cunningham and they redoubled their threats. Now whenever he is in that country he gets warnings that bands of mounted Hatfields are following him. But, as before, they don't catch up. He holds the clan in contempt.

"If they can get you foul they'll kill you," he says. "But in the open they're all cowards."

It is not part of Cunningham's duty as a federal officer to hunt Hatfields. He does it as he would hunt rattlesnakes and as his warrants for "moonshine" whisky distillers often take him to the Hatfield country he is likely to get more of them. Cunningham is not the sort of man that one would care to have on his trail. He is more than six feet tall, broad in proportion, beautifully muscled, possessed of catlike agility and as swift as he is sure with a rifle or revolver, and in that country swiftness is a necessary accompaniment of sureness. He is always in the hardest of training, as he neither drinks, smokes nor chews. In manner and appearance he is quiet and unostentatious and when going about the country is commonly taken for an itinerant clergyman.

See the clipping

Hatfields in an 800,000-acre land suit

The set closes with a land case. A Washington paper explains a Supreme Court appeal, ‘S. D. Hatfield and Nancy C. Rutherford vs. Henry C. King’, over title to about 800,000 acres. The two appellants, of the Hatfield family, swear they knew nothing of it until it was appealed; the State calls the suit fictitious and asks that King’s attorneys be disbarred.

The Evening Times · Washington, D.C.

The Evening Times · 3 December 1901 · page 5 · transcribed from the page image

SUIT INVOLVING 800,000 ACRES.

Important West Virginia Case Appealed.

See moreSee less

BITTERLY FOUGHT FOR MANY YEARS

Appellants Members of Notorious Hatfield Family — Attorneys Fired Upon, One Shot, and One Assailant Killed.

Under the title "S. D. Hatfield and Nancy C. Rutherford vs. Henry C. King," an appeal now pending before the Supreme Court of the United States, is concealed what in many respects is one of the most remarkable cases ever brought before that court for adjudication. The appellants in the case are members of the family made notorious by the Hatfield-McCoy feud.

Involved in it is not only the title to about 800,000 acres of valuable agricultural timber and mineral land in West Virginia, Kentucky, and Virginia, together with the constitutionality of the land laws of the State first named, but also the question of disbarring from practice before the Supreme Court of two attorneys against whom have been filed charges of fixing up a fictitious and fraudulent suit to be used for the purpose of obtaining a judgment against the 400 and odd settlers now in possession of that part of the land in West Virginia.

Old Morris and Clinton Tracts.

One tract of this land known as the Robert Morris survey, consisting of 500,000 acres, lying in the three States mentioned, was granted to Robert Morris, of Philadelphia, by the Commonwealth of Virginia, under patent dated June 23, 1795.

The other tract, embracing 142,000 acres, was granted by Virginia to DeWitt Clinton as assignee of William Duval, February 19, 1796. This lies entirely within the State of West Virginia, and it is claimed, overlaps in part the Morris grant.

In 1894 the West Virginia authorities, acting under a State law providing for the forfeiture of lands not entered in the land registry or upon which taxes had not been paid for a period of five years, brought suit against that portion of the Morris tract within Wyoming, Logan, Mingo, and McDowell counties. The period in this instance was at least eleven years, and upon some parts of the tract it was shown that the holders themselves had paid the taxes for more than twenty years.

Origin of Present Litigation.

Acting upon a decree in its favor the State sold the lands to about four hundred individuals and corporations who are now in possession and against whom suits of ejectment have been filed by Henry C. King, of New York, who claims ownership of the entire tract under conveyance from Robert Morris.

This litigation for possession, instituted by King in 1895, has been going on ever since in the chancery, county, State, and United States circuit courts of West Virginia, and has previously been before the Supreme Court of the United States in one form or another on three or four occasions.

King, in addition to innumerable suits for ejectment, has sued out many injunctions to restrain the occupants of the lands claimed by him from disposing of the timber or coal thereon.

Attorneys Repeatedly Fired on.

The feeling against attorneys in that part of the State was so intense that they have been fired on repeatedly. One of them, Stiles, was wounded, and one of his assistants was killed.

In the original action King set up the claim that there had been no forfeiture of the lands, alleging a decree patenting the lands under the State law had been obtained by his predecessors in 1883, but he offered, if that decree were deemed invalid, to pay all back taxes due.

Before the chancery suit was decided, however, King brought an action in the United States Circuit Court to eject the various holders of the land, and from the adverse judgment of that court he appealed to the Supreme Court of the United States. Pending the hearing of this appeal an agreement was made by King's attorneys and filed in court that no action should be had in the chancery case or the proceedings before the commissioner of school lands in Wyoming county.

King's Alleged Breach of Faith.

Notwithstanding, and in violation of this agreement, King, it is alleged, obtained in 1897 a report from the commissioner, and, without notice to the parties concerned, they claim, obtained from the Circuit Court of Wyoming county a decree of redemption for that portion of the 500,000 acres in West Virginia.

The decree fixed the boundaries as claimed by King, a large part of the DeWitt Clinton tracts and other lands shown by other records to be outside the limits of the grant, being included.

King then paid the back taxes on the land together with interest and costs, and renewed proceedings in ejectment against the alleged "squatters." He was, however, enjoined from taking any advantage of the decree by an injunction, which also restrained the commissioner from paying out any of the money received from King. That injunction is still in force.

While the constitutionality of the law of West Virginia forfeiting title to lands for non-registry and non-payment of taxes during a period of five years, is the real basis of the appeal to the Supreme Court, and that State is represented in the case by special act of the West Virginia Legislature, which also appropriated $1,000 for prosecuting it, yet that question is not even touched upon in the motion filed by counsel for the Commonwealth.

Neither is it mentioned in the various petitions filed by the numerous parties interested.

Serious Charges Made.

Former Attorney General Rucker, of West Virginia, in his brief in behalf of the State, asks the Supreme Court first to declare null and void all proceedings in the case, both in this court and in the court below, for the reason that it is a fictitious proceeding, entirely under the control of Henry C. King and his counsel, feigned for the purpose of obtaining in the absence of any real opposition an opinion and decrees for use against the present holders of the lands in question, and that the pendency of the suit has so far as possible been concealed from the numerous persons whose interests it was intended should be affected by its result.

Second, that the decrees in the courts below be declared void on the ground of collusion, and, third, that Maynard F. Stiles and Henry C. Plesher, King's attorneys, be disbarred and proceeded against for contempt of court for bringing a ridiculous case before it and for other alleged unprofessional practices.

Grounds for the Action.

The grounds upon which this unusual action is based are set out at some length in the various petitions and affidavits presented on behalf of the appellants and those who ask the court for the privilege of intervening in the present action. Stuart Wood and thirty-five other holders of the land, including water, mining, and lumber companies, claiming bona fide ownership of the land, charge King, Flesher, and Stiles with bringing and carrying on this fictitious suit in the Circuit Court without the knowledge of the rural defendants; that it does not appear from the records of the Circuit Court that it was ever regularly and formally instituted; that no process was ever issued against either S. D. Hatfield or Nancy C. Rutherford; that the alleged orders and decrees made in that case were not entered in the order book of the court, and that no record of the pendency of this suit in that court is shown until application was made for a certification of the record for the purpose of appealing the case.

They further charge that S. D. Hatfield and Nancy Rutherford did not authorize Flesher to appear for them in the case or appeal it, and that neither of them knew of the suit until it had been appealed to the Supreme Court, their affidavits to that effect being attached.

Missing From the Records.

Flesher, it is also charged, filed, as attorney for Mrs. Hatfield, Mrs. Rutherford and William Claypool, a statement of fact in an ejectment suit against them, although all three of them in their affidavits deny signing it, which statement, it is alleged, has mysteriously disappeared from the court records.

The petition further avers that Flesher had been suspended from practice by the circuit court of Jackson county, for not paying over money collected as attorney.

As to Stiles, the petitioners charge him with falsely stating in the original bill that King was in possession of the lands of Mrs. Hatfield, as he had for years known of her occupancy. They also cite the record of the circuit court of Wyoming county showing Stiles' name stricken from the roll of attorneys before that court for unprofessional conduct in the King contest, although this action was afterward reversed by the higher court.

Family of Feud Fame.

It is also alleged that the name "Nancy C. Rutherford," one of the alleged appellants, is false, as she since 1895 has been Nancy C. Browning by reason of her marriage, and that that marriage was known to King's attorney.

Mrs. Browning, it appears from her affidavit, is the daughter of Sarah D. and Joseph Hatfield, and the granddaughter of Aby Hatfield, all members of the family concerned in the famous Hatfield-McCoy feud. Mrs. Hatfield claims unbroken possession of her land for thirty-two years, and a deed by Aby Hatfield to his daughter Martha Toler, dated 1861, shows the latter had since that date been in possession of that portion of the Hatfield tract.

The record of the latter deed in the clerk's office of Logan county has, however, been mutilated. Other affidavits show the land had been in possession of the Hatfields for at least since 1858.

Stiles' Alleged Promises.

Mrs. Hatfield deposes regarding the arrangement between her and Stiles regarding the suit that the latter had proposed to defend her title to the lands in an ejectment suit promising to pay all expenses and to reconvey her lands to her if King won the suit.

Her affidavit further declares that Stiles suggested Flesher, one of King's attorneys, to act for her, and consulting her own lawyer, H. K. Shumate, she had consented. Flesher afterward called on her, and she gave him power to act for her in the ejectment suit only.

Denies Alleged Agreement.

She denies all knowledge of the agreed statement of facts used in the present suit, and swears she never knew of the pendency of the suit until the appeal had been filed in the Supreme Court.

Holmes Conrad, formerly Solicitor General of the United States, heads the list of attorneys for the petitioners in their brief asking dismissal of the suit and disbarment of Stiles and Flesher. The latter have been given until Tuesday to file replies to the charges and the motions.

See the clipping

← Back to Act Six: Eighteen Men Bite the Dust