As the Papers Told It

The Hatfields and the McCoys · As the Papers Told It

Act Four

His Voluntary Statements

January 1889 – February 1890

In April 1889 the papers printed Ellison Mounts’s confession, made in jail: he named the men who had shot the three McCoys in 1882 and admitted shooting the girl at the New Year’s burning. In September Pliant and Doll Mayhorn were given life, Wall Hatfield and others were sent to the penitentiary, and Mounts was sentenced to hang. Stories of new battles that autumn turned out to be inventions, and on 18 February 1890 Mounts was hanged at Pikeville before thousands.

A Wheeling paper tires of feud tales

A New Year’s Day paragraph in the Wheeling Register wishes the reporters who write ‘thrilling stories of family feuds’ would travel the Hatfield-McCoy country themselves: ‘A skilful and industrious liar or two might get lost by the wayside’. By summer a Register correspondent had ridden through that country, and in November the Wheeling Sunday Register was hunting a faker of Hatfield-McCoy war news.

Wheeling Register · Wheeling, W. Va.

Wheeling Register · 1 January 1889 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

If a few of the enterprising journalists who spend the most of their waking hours in composing thrilling stories of family feuds and murders in the mountains of West Virginia, would take a trip through the Hatfield-McCoy country it would be a great relief to the West Virginia public. A skilful and industrious liar or two might get lost by the wayside, but there would be the consolation that they died in a good cause.

See the clipping

The confession of Ellison Mounts

Jailed at Pikeville, Ellison Mounts, son of the slain Ellison Hatfield, confesses before County Attorney J. Lee Ferguson. He names the men who shot the three McCoy brothers on 9 August 1882, says of a girl at the New Year 1888 house burning ‘I fired at her and she fell in the doorway’, and calls the alibis sent to Governor Wilson false. He was hanged for her murder on 18 February 1890.

The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · Wheeling, W. Va.

The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · 8 April 1889 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

Confession.

ELLISON HATFIELD'S STORY

See moreSee less

Of the Part He Took in the Famous Hatfield-McCoy Feud.

The Murders and Outrages in which He Participated.

HIS VOLUNTARY STATEMENTS

To the State's Attorney in Pike County, Kentucky, Jail.

The Intelligencer Correspondent Secures a Copy of the Document—The Principal Feature of It—How Governor Wilson was Deceived.

Special Correspondence of the Intelligencer.

PIKEVILLE, PIKE COUNTY, KY., April 6.—The great Hatfield-McCoy feud on the Kentucky border of this State, about which so much has been published in the newspapers during the past year, and the history of which is familiar to all newspaper readers, has been almost suppressed, and for several months there has been no word of any outrages being perpetrated by the outlaws on either side of the line. It will be remembered that a number of the Hatfields were arrested by the Kentucky authorities and placed in the Pike County jail, where they still languish awaiting trial for a long list of the most heinous murders and outrages chronicled in the criminal annals of this country. An ineffectual effort to gain posession of the prisoners was made by Governor Wilson, of West Virginia, the matter being finally decided in favor of the Kentucky authorities by the U. S. Supreme Court.

Since then the State's Attorney of Pike county has been unceasing in his efforts to obtain sufficient evidence against the West Virginia gang to convict them. He found it a difficult matter on account of the unwillingness of those in posession of any knowledge to give testimony.

Recently, however, Ellison Hatfield (alias Mounts) consented to make a confession, which he did in the presence of County Attorney J. Lee Ferguson, the Jailor, and five others, one of whom was J. M. York, a lawyer. Hatfield voluntarily told his story after being told that a confession would not in any manner lighten his sentence. His relation of the horrible acts, in which he was a principal actor, is of a thrilling character. The correspondent of the INTELLIGENCER has succeeded in obtaining a copy of it from the County Attorney. Following are the main features of

HATFIELD'S CONFESSION:

Ellison Hatfield in the presence of the above witnesses said, in substance:

I was present and participated in the murder of the three McCoy brothers, namely, Tolbert McCoy, Farmer McCoy, and Randolph McCoy. It was on the night of the 9th of August, 1882, at the mouth Blackberry creek, Pike county, Ky. The three brothers were taken from a log school house in Logan county, W. Va., where they had been guarded for a day and a night, and brought over the Tug river, which separates West Virginia from Kentucky. They were tied arm in arm with a plow line and led by one Charles Carpenter to the river and placed in a small boat, accompanied by Ans. Hatfield, Bill Hatfield, Tom Mitchell, Alex Musser, Dan White, Mose Christian, Sam Mahorn, Joe Murphy, Jeff Whitt and myself. We brought them to the Kentucky side and led them by the rope up the bank about fifty feet from the river. Carpenter tied them to a paw-paw bush and hung a lantern over their heads. Ans Hatfield then said to them: "Boys, if you have any peace to make with your Maker, you had better make it."

Tolbert and Randolph began praying but Farmer (we called him Dick) did not. However, before the boys had time to finish their prayers, John Hatfield shot Farmer dead. Ans. then gave the order to fire, and shot as he gave the word, killing Tolbert and then emptying the contents of the revolver into the dead body. Alex Musser then fired and killed Randolph McCoy. As soon as the first shots were fired the others followed suit, and all the bodies were riddled with bullets.

A TERRIBLE OATH.

The parties who were engaged in the shooting of the boys were Ans Hatfield, John Hatfield, Cap Hatfield, Bill Tom Hatfield, Alex Musser, Charlie Carpenter and Thomas Mitchell.

After the boys were killed we crossed the river back into Logan county, West Virginia, where we found Wall Hatfield and some others waiting for us. Wall then ordered us into line and administered an oath to all of us binding us to take the life of the first to divulge the name or names of any who were along, and to solemn secrecy, and wound up the oath by asking us if our feelings were not gratified. Ans, Cap and Johns Hatfield and Tom Mitchell said "yes." We then left. I went to Pat Hatfield's and stayed all night, and all the rest went to Elias Hatfield's and I went there next day. The corpse of Ellison Hatfield was at the house of Elias. Prior to our going into Kentucky with the McCoy boys we bound ourselves to have revenge for the death of Ellison Hatfield [the prisoner's father who had been shot by the McCoys] and to kill all the murderers.

[Wall Hatfield, who administered the above oath, was at that time a Justice of the Peace.]

BEATING HELPLESS WOMEN.

Cap. Hatfield told me that Tom Wallace and himself had gone to Pike county from West Virginia to the house of Bill Daniels, and found Daniels and his family in bed; that Tom presented his gun at Mr. Daniels and told him that if he moved he would kill him; that he (Cap) wrapped the hairy part of a cow's tail about his hand and beat Daniels' wife almost to death with the stub part of it in the presence of her husband. He then took the gun and held it to Daniels' head while Tom committed a similar assault on the old man's daughter. They then went back to West Virginia.

MURDER OF JEFF M'COY.

Cap. Hatfield told the deponent that he and Tom Wallace captured Jeff McCoy, tied him with a halter to their saddles and drove him down the road to William Ferrell's house, in Logan county, W. Va. Cap. went into the yard, and while he was there Jeff freed himself from the halter and ran across a field to Tug river. His late captors pursued him, firing several shots. He succeeded in swimaing [swimming] across the river without being hit, but as he was running up the bank on the Kentucky side, a shot aimed by Tom Wallace struck him, and he fell dead.

MURDER OF ELIFIRI M'COY.

On January 1, 1888, I was at work at my mother's house, on the Guian river, when John Hatfield and Tom Mitchell came after me and said that Cap Hatfield had sent for me. He told me that the Kentucky people had offered a reward of $500 for me—and that I had better stand in with them. So I went with them. We met Ans, Cap and Bob Hatfield at Dow Steel's, on Island Creek. We went from there to Henry Vance's, and from there to Floyd Hatfield's.

The prisoner described visits to all the Hatfields in turn and continued:

Finally, on Sunday morning we arrived at the house of Jim Vance, sr. We stayed there for quite a while, and Ans and Cap Hatfield and Vance went to one side and talked a while. They called me to them and said some of these Kentucky people must be killed, and that I must go along. Ans said he was sick and not able to go, and told Jim Vance to take command of the party. Before we started out Vance held up his hands and repeated three times:

"May hell be my heaven, I will kill the man that goes back on me to-night, if powder will burn."

Nine of the party left Vance's house and went up the river to Cap Hatfield's, arriving there about 4 or 5 o'clock p.m. Sunday, and got our supper there. We all stayed there until some time after dark, and all left together and went to the West Virginia side, to Amos Hatfield's house, opposite the mouth of Peter creek, in Pike county, Ky. We then went down to the river, pulled off our shoes and rolled up our pants and waded the river to the Kentucky side, to the mouth of Pounding Mill Branch, and up it and over to the Peter Fork of Blackberry, down to main Blackberry creek and up it to the mouth of Jerry Hatfield's branch, and up it and over to the Blackberry fork of Pond creek, and down it to near Randolph McCoy's house, where we made a halt. Cap Hatfield, John Hatfield and Jim Vance put on masks.

Jim Vance, Sr., directed each man where to go and what to do. He then directed Mitchell, Gillespie and Ellis to go to the lower of the big houses and told them to watch and not let any men come out dressed in woman's clothing. If they did to capture them. He then directed Elliott Hatfield and Bob Hatfield to go to the lower door of the kitchen. He told Cap Hatfield and me to go to the upper door of the kitchen, and he said that Johns Hatfield and himself would go to the upper door of the big house. We arrived at the house about half-past ten o'clock that night.

When we got very near the house we all slipped up very easy and made no noise. We all took our positions as directed by James Vance, Sr. Vance changed his voice and called to the McCoys to come out and surrender as prisoners of war. Cap Hatfield asked: "Are they coming out?" There was no response from inside the house and Cap said: "G—d d—n it, fire it! fire it!"

THE MURDERS.

We began shooting through the doors of what we called the big house in opposite directions. There was several shots fired from the inside of the house, and the shooting continued for some time from inside and out.

Calvin McCoy got upstairs and shot one of our party. Jim Vance, Sr., went to the house and found some cotton hanging against the side. He lit it with a match and placed a part of it in a joist hole, and the rest against the shutter of the door. Two shots were fired through the door from the inside of the house. We heard Calvin McCoy call to the girls (his sisters), who were in the kitchen, to go out and put out the fire. Vance said: "Boys, if they come out, d——n them, shoot them."

About this time a girl opened the door of the kitchen and Cap. and Johns both cried to me: 'D—n her, kill her.' I had a 32 calibre Winchester rifle, I fired at her and she fell in the doorway. I heard her sister ask her if she was hurt. She muttered something, but I could not understand it. I heard one of the girls say: "Farewell sister." Calvin McCoy called down stairs to know if anyone was killed and one of the girls said, "Yes, they have killed Alifari." The firing from both sides kept up for some time, until I was shot through the left arm by Calvin McCoy. The ball entered just above the wrist below the elbow. Cap and Johns Hatfield both told me afterward that they killed Calvin McCoy. They were both bragging about it, and each one claimed that he killed him. But I think from the position of the two that Cap killed Calvin McCoy. Three of our party was wounded. Tom Mitchel was shot in the right hand, shooting off three of his fingers and some of the shots went into his belt. Johns Hatfield was shot in the top of the right shoulder. He had on a heavy overcoat and the shots only entered the flesh very slightly. I saw the shots taken out. They were bird shot. We did not know that we had killed Calvin McCoy until the next day.

When we left the house it was in a good flame. The women were crying and begging for help to put out the fire. We returned to West Virginia by the same route that we came. I fainted on the way from loss of blood. We arrived at Cap Hatfield's about daylight and took breakfast.

DECEIVING GOV. WILSON.

The prisoner then detailed subsequent but unimportant events in which he bore a part, concluding as follows:

On the Thursday or Friday night after the house burning we all went together to Harve Duty's house, in Logan county. Joe Simpkins, a justice of the peace, was present, and each of us told where he was on the night of the burning of McCoy's house, and swore to it. This was done for the purpose of sending the affidavit to Gov. Wilson to keep him from honoring the requisition from the Governor of Kentucky. These affidavits were sent to Gov. Wilson and seemed to have the desired effect, but there was not a word of truth in them.

"The above and many like tricks were resorted to to keep Gov. Wilson from handing us over to the Kentucky authorities."

See the clipping

A Wheeling correspondent takes the Hatfield side

A Register correspondent rides the Tug river country and writes a long history kind to the Hatfields, ending at Anse Hatfield’s loop-holed fort on Island creek. It blames Carpenter, a stranger turned schoolteacher, for the killing of the McCoy boys while the older Hatfields were absent; Mounts’s April confession had Ans Hatfield giving the order to fire. It also dates the McCoy house burning to December 1887.

Wheeling Sunday Register · Wheeling, W. Va.

Wheeling Sunday Register · 30 June 1889 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

THE TUG RIVER COUNTRY

THE BORDER VENDETTA. Thrilling Story of the Hatfield McCoy Warfare.

FACTS WHICH SURPASS WILDEST FICTION

See moreSee less

Dozen Men Give Up Their Lives for a Family Feud.

THE FIRST FULL AND UNPREJUDICED HISTORY

Justice Done to the Members of the Hatfield Family.

They Were Not the Authors of the War, and the Chief Responsibility Does not Rest With Them—A Sketch of the Country and People. A Refuge for Outlaws—Ellison Hatfield's Murder, and How It Was Avenged—Frank Phillips' Romance—The Flight of the Hatfields and Their New Home. ...ne part of the mountain districts of ...t Virginia has been an interesting ...e in the columns of every great daily America. Brilliant writers have in- ...d its glens, and talked with its inhab- America. Brilliant writers have [vis]ited inhabitants face to face. Scenic artists have [ca]ught its rugged hills and narrow valleys

[and] transferred them to living paper. Ev[ery] well-informed man has learned some[thin]g of the Hatfield country, and around [a] thousand firesides fair cheeks have [blan]ched at the tales of blood that came

[from] those dark mountain passes. For

[the] history of the Tug river country [reco]rds a family feud, whose bloody feroci[ty] appalled the civilized world. A few weeks ago business duties called [a] correspondent of the Register into [thi]s section of the State, and he made an [hon]est effort to learn the truth of the [re]gular train of crimes that caused so

[m]uch excitement a little over one year

[ag]o. Many fragmentary tales have been

[pu]blished, but he found that much yet

[re]mained untold, that would in some de[gr]ee explain the origin of the Hatfield-M[c]Coy feud, and extenuate if not excuse

[the] deeds of those who participated in it.

THE TUG RIVER COUNTRY.

From Catlettsburg your correspondent

[pro]ceeded by rail to Louisa C. H., and

[fro]m there a horseback ride of thirty miles

[ove]r a typical mountain road landed him

[at] Warfield, a little hamlet fifty-six miles

[fro]m the Ohio river. At Louisa Court

[Hou]se the Big Sandy forks, but the north

[fork continues] to be the dividing river

[bet]ween Kentucky and West Virginia.

[It] is a sluggish stream, flowing between [alluv]ial bottoms and fringed to the water's

[edg]e with thick growths of willows, beech

[and] sycamore. Steamers run regularly to

[War]field and many miles above there dur[ing] the spring floods. In the summer sea[son] it is easily fordable, and is practically

[no] barrier to the free intercourse of the [peop]le of the two States. [F]our miles northwest of Warfield the [boun]dary line of Wayne and Logan coun[ties], West Virginia, strikes Tug river. [Th]ence for sixty miles south east along the [rive]r's course lies Logan county, the home [of t]he Hatfields. Opposite it, but slightly [fur]ther to the south east is Pike county, [Ken]tucky. Pikeville, the county seat, is [twen]ty miles in the interior through a [woo]ded mountain country, impassable to [wag]on, and inhabited by hardy moun[ta]eer farmers. The mountain is the [divi]d[e] between the two forks of the Big [San]dy, and on the north east side Peter [Cre]ek collects the waters of a dozen smaller [stre]ams and empties them into Tug river, [twen]ty miles above Warfield. [L]ogan county's geography is even more [varie]d than its neighbors. Ten miles back [fro]m the Tug river a lofty range of hills [ris]e in a line parallel with that stream. [Th]is range is Guyan ridge, the back-bone of [Log]an county. On either side a dozen [mou]ntain rivulets flow down through nar[row] valleys to the Tug and the Twelve [Pol]e. Beyond Twelve Pole, on the north, [still] another range rises, and the travel[ler] finds himself in the valley of [the] Guyandotte. All three streams flow [nea]rly due northwest, and their parallel [vall]eys and intervening hills cover [the] entire face of the country. [Sou]thwest of Guyan Ridge the hills slope [awa]y until the Kentucky border is [rea]ched, and in this wild and thinly settled [neig]hborhood has been the scene of so [man]y bloody encounters. It is watered [by s]everal large streams tributary to the [Tug], Pigeon, Beach and Mate creeks being [the p]rincipal ones. The land is in many [respe]cts highly favored by nature. Rugged [mou]ntains rise steep to the skies; the [sides] are clothed in growths of mountain [tree]s, but nestling down among [them] are fertile farms whose richness is [co]nstantly [re]plenished from the land above, [who]se cultivated field follows the me[ander] [ing] waters in a thousand fantastic [turns.] [The] first settlements were made in Logan [county], in the early day of the century, [and t]he tide of immigration never more [b]rushed by its hills in the rush for [m]ore inviting lands of the West. The [settl]ers came from Virginia, and the [nam]es of these first families are still pre- served. Their descendants made up nine- [tenth]s of the native population, and they [s]o intermarried that the whole coun[try] [o]n both sides of the Tug river has be[come] [one] vast family organization. The [stro]ng honesty and hospitality of their [race] have descended in a great measure [to th]e present inhabitants. To-day in [West V]irginia or Kentucky there can not [be fo]und better men, or more peaceful [homes] than dozens of members of the [Varne]y, Rutherford, Mitchell, Clark, [Shephe]rd, Simkins, Hatfield, Duty, Far- [ley, C]hafin, Vance and McCoy families. [Th]eir first law is the law of hospitality. [The] stranger in their midst is certain of a [heart]y welcome from the most prosperous [farme]r of the valley to the humblest cabin [on th]e hillside. The guest in the house of [either] the Hatfields or McCoys, shares the [cabi]n bed and board. Many a story can [be tol]d to illustrate the almost chivalric [degre]e to which the spirit of hospitality is [carrie]d. The writer's brief stay in the [count]ry was full of such experiences. Be[nighted] [o]ne night on Pigeon creek, my com[panion] [rode a]nd myself rode up the mountain [road and we] called at a mere hovel. A faint [light] twinkling through a broken window [was th]e only sign of life. In response to our hello, the door opened and a man ap- peared, bare-headed and bare-footed. The rain was coming down in torrents and he took in our forlorn position at once.

A MOUNTAINEER'S HOSPITALITY.

"Light," "Light," he exclaimed, and hurried out to take care of the horses. The tired animals were surrendered to the man's care and the two travellers entered the house. It belonged to one of the Hatfields, and in the one room the family of man, wife and two children cooked, slept and ate. It was with a feeling of shame that we allowed ourselves to be entertained by the inmates, but nothing but this could be done. A coarse, supper of corn pone and bacon was smoking on the table, and the guests were invited to partake, the man and wife sitting with them, insisted on their eating heartily. After supper, the farmer engaged in conversation and talked intelligently and even entertainingly about his farm and crops, but when the Hatfield-McCoy feud was mentioned, he closed his lips, and a suspicious look betrayed his fear that his strange guests might have more than a friendly interest in him. At bed time the inevitable jug of mountain dew was brought out, and after a sip all around preparations were made to retire. There was but one bed in the house, and our generous host insisted that we occupy it. The wife spread out a small pallet by the fireside, and there the family of four people slept. In the morning the same hospitality was extended. When we were ready to depart the horses were saddled and brought to the door. Small presents were made to the little boy and girl—the father refused to accept anything for himself—and we rode away feeling that whatever were their faults, the Hatfield families of Logan county retained simple virtues which more cultivated communities had forgotten.

A prominent business man who has had important dealings through the Tug river country, told me that he had never passed the house of a Hatfield or McCoy with whom he was acquainted, without being asked to get off his horse and take dinner or stay all night. He had carried large sums about his person and it was well known to the people, yet never once had he had any reason to fear for his safety. The traveler may go unarmed on the darkest night, and up the loneliest valley, and no one will raise a hand to molest him. But their law is an eye for an eye and a tooth for a tooth, and the man who injures one of them takes his life in his own hands. "To-day" My informant said: "There are no better men in West Virginia than the Hatfields. They are brave and generous to a fault; peaceable when unmolested, and quick to revenge a wrong. As a rule they live to themselves, and although hospitable are slow to make friends with strangers, but once friends there are no truer friends on earth than they."

A CRIMINAL HAVEN.

A Hundred Desperadoes Along the Tug River.

But the sons and daughters of the hardy Virginia settlers do not constitute the entire population that has gathered in the valley of the Tug. For over fifty years this mountain country has been a refuge for outlaws from a dozen States. Its secluded valleys have furnished a safe retreat to fugitives from justice. Here came early in 1830 the remnants of a famous band of counterfeiters and moonshiners from North Carolina and Virginia. Criminals of every grade and class from the three border States and Ohio and Pennsylvania followed them. Within the last few years this influx of the criminal class has increased, and I am told by reliable citizens that over dozens strangers have come into the country in twenty years past, and no one ever learned their true name, or their past history. They built cabins and cultivated little farms. A brotherhood among them kept all well informed, and capture by the officers of the law was next to impossible.

AN OUTLAW'S FORT.

One of the oldest citizens of Logan county led me to a fort, which one of the refugees had constructed. It was on the Kentucky side and approached through a steep ravine. Clambering up the gorge for a hundred yards, we came to the outlaw's home. A log cabin nestled among the trees, that were then covered with the richest foliage, and was invisible to all but the keenest eyes. Twenty steps from the door an immense stone marked the boundary between Kentucky and the Old Dominion, and once across the line in either State the fugitive was safe from pursuit. For years a curious old man lived here. No one ever learned his history or dared to enquire it. He surrounded himself with dogs and made few acquaintances among the neighboring farmers. Even in his declining age he refused their aid, and continued to maintain himself by hunting and fishing. Numerous little gifts of food and clothing were sent him by the kind hearted people and thus he managed to live. One morning ten years ago he left his cabin to look at his snares on the Virginia side of the mountain. A few days later a son of one of the neighbors stumbled on a decomposing body in the woods. It was the mysterious old man. The remains were lifted, christian burial was given them, and then the secret of his life was revealed. A paper was found. It was carefully preserved, but creased with many years of folding. It enclosed a lock of golden brown hair, and on it was inscribed a few words, which re-

[Continued on Sixth Page.]

THE BORDER VENDETTA.

THE BORDER VENDETTA.

[Continued From First Page.]

vealed the story. James Arthur a prosperous North Carolina planter had killed his nearest friend in a moment of intense anger. He had fled to the mountains to hide his crime, and here deserted, save by his faithful dogs had surrendered up the blood stained life which he tried so long to hold.

CARPENTER'S CAREER.

While the natives usually avoided these men, a few had talents and ability which gave them positions of influence. To this class belonged Carpenter, who instigated and was the prime mover in the lynching of the McCoy boys. One afternoon in the spring of 1886, he arrived at the little village of Warfield, from the direction of Louisa Court House. He crossed into West Virginia, and located at the Mouth of Mate where he solicited and obtained employment. Carpenter was a man of magnificent physique, and entered heartily into all the sports of the mountain lads. Cap Hatfield was the only one of his competitors who could bring down a squirrel from a higher tree, or was a quicker shot than the handsome stranger. To these elements of popularity, Carpenter added others which seemed little less than miraculous to the people who surrounded him. He became a leader in every game and merry making. A party of young men clustered about him and their wild freaks of disipation in the succeeding winter and spring, were the subject of general comment. Carpenter taught school, and added to his influence, but not even to his nearest friends did he ever breathe a word as to his past life or his motive for seeking a home in the wilderness. Once a drunken companion attempted to question him before a crowd. Carpenter at first warded off his questions, and then a blow from the butt of his pistol quieted his tormenter, and left him scarred for life. Such was this man, when Ellison Hatfield was killed by the McCoys and his slayers were taken prisoners. They were kept on West Virginia soil for a few days, and one night were placed under guard, with Carpenter in command, and started for Pike county jail. When Tug river was crossed, Carpenter called a halt, and proposed that all three men be shot then and there.

The older members of the party insisted that their original design should be carried out, but they were out numbered. The hot blood of Carpenter's followers was heated to the boiling point, by the death of their kinsman, and the artful desperado had little trouble in leading them on to the slaughter. He carried the day. The men were tied together, led to a little bush, and a dozen shots fired into them. With his own hand Carpenter blew out the brains of the youngest McCoy, as he lay on the ground, dying from a dozen wounds.

CARPENTER'S FLIGHT.

The outrage awakened the vengeance of the whole McCoy family, and their wrath was primarily directed at Carpenter. Many of the relatives of the men he had slain lived on the West Virginia side of the Tug; hundreds of others were in striking distance in Kentucky. It was death to remain, and so within a month after the murder of his three defenseless prisoners, Carpenter fled, and his face has never since been seen on the banks of the little mountain stream. Whether he escaped or whether he fell victim to the vengeance of some McCoy will probably never be known.

JOE GLENN'S DEATH.

JOE GLENN'S DEATH.

Not a farmer's wife in the Valley of the Tug but could tell a dozen stories of the adventures of the lawless element that fled to the safe haven of the border community. Carpenter's case is not an isolated one. Joe Glenn was another of the refugees who became an influential citizen. Glenn arrived in 1879. He had plenty of money and was a shrewd business man. His store at the forks of Mate soon become the centre of the business and social life of the valley. The farmers came to it for their monthly supply of groceries, and learned what little was to be learned of the news from the great outside world. Glenn married, and became the head of a family, but he was still noted for his wild and reckless disposition. One day he became involved in a dispute with a man named Baker and shot him dead as he stood in his store. Baker had many friends, and Glenn went armed continually in expectation of attack. A week later he was shot dead from ambush as he walked from his store to his house.

These and many similar tales of blood make up the history of the country in the past few years. The majority of these crimes were committed or provoked by the criminals who had fled from justice in other lands. The world made no distinction between this criminal class and the native inhabitants, and the mountain territory became another dark and bloody ground. Reports of crime coming to the world were magnified in the passage, and so when finally the smouldering flames of the Hatfield-McCoy fend burst forth into a fire the public readily accepted exaggerated and prejudiced accounts of the events which resulted from it.

The story of the Hatfield-McCoy fend has often been told in fragments, but many a link has been left out of the completed tale. Just opposite the point where Peter creek empties its waters into Tug river, Anderson Hatfield, the central figure of the war, owned and cultivated a magnificent bottom farm. The house is now occupied by a tenant of the land speculator to whom Hatfield sold his property, when the repeated raids of the McCoys forced him to flee from his home, and take refuge in the interior. From its door the correspondent of the REGISTER could see in a dozen different directions little clearings that marked the homes of Anderson Hatfield's friends and relatives. The most of them are gone, but a few remain in the places where they were born and reared to manhood and womanhood. In the spring of 1882, five of Anderson Hatfield's ten children were grown. Johns and Cap, his oldest sons, were married, and lived on farms their father had sold them on Grape- vine creek, a few miles distant. A daugh- ter was married to French Ellis, a prosper- ous farmer whose land nearly adjoined his father-in-law's, and the remaining chil- dren lived at home and assisted their fath- er in the daily round of rural duties. Six miles away on Beach creek lived Wall Hatfield, Anderson's oldest brother, and a man of great wealth and influence. Wall was the justice of the peace, wrote deeds, solemnized marriages, and administered the laws with a firm and even hand throughout the community. He was one of the earliest victims of Phillips' raid, and to-day is lan- guishing in the Pike county jail. Ellison Hatfield lived on Mate creek, and Elias, the fourth brother, owned a farm on Tug, one mile below the mouth of Mate. Two miles from Cap Hatfield's house was the farm of Captain James Vance, another actor in the border warfare, and he and Cap Hat- field fought together in the battle which finally ended Vance's turbulent career.

THE SCENE OF OPERATIONS. It will be seen that the leaders in the fray on the West Virginia side were grouped together within a short distance of each other and close to the Kentucky border. The mouth of Mate creek was a central and natural rendezvous, and about this point gathers the greatest interest of the story. Not one of these men remains in his old home. Vance, Ellison and Johns Hatfield are dead; Wall Hatfield and Ellison Mounts are in prison, while Elias and Anderson Hatfield have been forced to abandon their farms and seek safety in the valley across Guyan ridge.

The McCoy family is probably spread as widely in West Virginia as in Kentucky, but with one branch of the Pike county members rests the chief responsibility for the slaughter of Ellison Hatfield, and the deeds of blood that followed his death. Up Tug river to the mouth of Blackberry creek, and thence through a sharp cleft in the Kentucky hills, the writer went to the ruins of Randall McCoy's cabin. Since the fatal night in December, 1887, when his roof was burned over his head, Randall McCoy has lived in Pikeville, and from there has directed and aided his friends. The house, or rather houses, which constituted the farmer's home, sat in a little bottom four or five miles back from the river. Blackberry fork of Pond ran within fifty yards of the door, and behind the double building the mountain rose steep to the height of five hundred feet. Laurel and pine clothe the sides and come down to within a few feet of the outbuildings behind the McCoy home. Here Randall lived with his family of six boys and three girls, and ruled with an iron hand over the rough and turbulent elements of the community. He and his sons were the leaders in every merry-making, church gathering and and shooting scrape alike. They were large men, brave as lions and experts at all mountain sports. Except when in drink they were peaceable and generally law abiding, but in numerous encounters had drawn and killed their men.

DEEDS OF BLOOD.

Even now the old women tell, with something like awe, how Bill McCoy, Randall's youngest brother, waylaid and shot three inoffensive Union sympathizers during the war; how at last he was compelled to flee the country, went west and there avenging Providence came in the lightning stroke, and cut short his life of crime. They tell how the bitter feud between the McCoy and Vance families sprang up and flourished until it was drowned in the blood of old Jim Vance; how Harmon McCoy went over into West Virginia and quarrelled with Richard Vance; how that night Vance was traveling slowly homeward, a shot rang out out from the mountain side, and he fell dead from his horse. Harmon McCoy was the slayer, but he was never captured or brought to justice.

A few years later a nephew of Randall McCoy shot a young man up in Wayne county, West Virginia, who had crossed him in a love affair. In the spring of 1882 another nephew of Randall McCoy met Wm. Staten in the road and shot him dead. Staten had had a law suit with Randall, and the fatal altercation arose concerning this. Nothing was done to the slayers in either of these cases. The McCoys retired to their homes. The Pike county authorities refused to arrest them. Their friends declared that they would not allow them to be taken, and their crimes went to swell the ever-increasing burden of hate among the people along the border.

Irritation continued to increase and parties on both sides were ready for an open out break, when the local elections were ties were held in the fall of 1884. One of Randall McCoy's friends was a candidate for Justice of the Peace, and a near relative of Ellison Hatfield opposed him. On election day, Ellison Hatfield, who was a skilful and active political worker, crossed over from his West Virginia home to take part in the contest. With him were his brothers, Anderson and Elias. The polls were held under some beech trees on the bank of Blackberry Creek, and the battle raged fiercely all day. In the afternoon the tide turned against the McCoys, and the situation soon became dangerous. Three of the McCoy boys had been drinking heavily and one of them came up to Ellison Hatfield and made a threatening gesture. "I have hell in me to-day," was his significant exclamation, but Ellison turned away and began talking to a friend. In a few minutes the McCoys returned and again accosted Hatfield. This time an altercation ensued, but no one heard what words were spoken.

ELLISON HATFIELD KILLED.

It ended by Ellison striking the younger man with his open hand, and immediately the brothers, who had gathered around him, made an assault. Their victim was taken by surprise, and it was but the work of a moment for the three strong men to use their knives with deadly effect. Elias Hatfield heard his brother's cry for aid and came riding up at a gallop. As he approached the two older McCoy boys seized their weapons and fled. The youngest, a mere lad of fifteen, stood his ground and never flinched when covered by Hatfield's pistol. He was disarmed, and the others who were too much frightened by the horrible results of their own act to make resistance, were easily captured and brought back. The quiet, rural election was broken up, and it was a question now as to the disposition of the three murderers. Elias Hatfield asked that they be taken to the sition Pike county jail, but old Randall McCoy swore that his boys should never be taken to Pikeville. A justice of the peace lived at the mouth of Blackberry, and after a brief consultation it was decided to take them to him for a trial. Guards were selected, and the party started, but in the meanwhile the alarm had spread throughout the whole country. Randall McCoy's friends were arming, and began to come in to protect their kinsmen. At the mouth of Blackberry a number of Hatfields were gathered, and they were equally determined that justice should be done. The law officers became frightened and refused to conduct the trial. The situation was becoming serious, the McCoys were hourly increasing in numbers, and it was plain that a rescue was intended. Then the Hatfields seized their prisoners, bound them together and marched them across Tug river to the West Virginia side. They were confined in a small school-house at the mouth of Mate creek, and held to await the result of Ellison Hatfield's wounds.

WHERE THE M'COYS WERE HELD.

The building which was thus made into a jail has been since moved one mile down Tug river to the farm of Elias Hatfield. It sits on a small level bottom within plain sight of the Kentucky hills. The correspondent of the REGISTER visited it. On the side of the little unpainted building there is a faint, almost illegible, scratch, which was decyphered into "B. J. M.," the initials of Ben McCoy, the youngest of the ill-fated prisoners.

About 8 or 9 o'clock in the evening on the day after the cutting, Ellison Hatfield died, and a council was immediately held by his friends and relatives to decide on the fate of his slayers. Finally it was determined to surrender them to the Kentucky authorities. The route to Pike C. H. was through a country full of Mc-

tucky McCoy sympathizers, and it was thought best to make the journey at night. It was bright moonlight, and at one o'clock in the morning, the little army consisting of Carpenter, Ellison, Mounts, an illegitimate son of Wall Hatfield, Johnson Hatfield, Henry Mitchell, and perhaps three or four others started with the prisoners in their midst. Carpenter was the captain. They crossed Tug river and reached the Kentucky share. It has been told how here, Carpenter began to urge their immediate slaughter; how, in the absence of the older Hatfields the young and hot blooded followers consented; how the men were lead to a pawpaw bush, and in a few minutes their crimes were expiated in death. The self appointed executioners fled and as they climbed the bank on the West Virginia side, they could plainly see three ghastly bodies shining in the moonlight. In the morning Randall McCoy gathered the remains of his children and gave them christian burial.

BLACKMAILING THE HATFIELDS.

The justice of the execution seems to have been generally recognized and no effort was made to avenge it. In the meanwhile, two of Randall McCoy's nephews each killed a man, but they were not apprehended or punished. Two years after the three McCoy boys were killed, a number of parties in Pike county determined to use the crime as a means of extorting money from the older Hatfields. Anderson, Eliss and Wall Hatfield were all men of wealth. Their farms were the finest in the valley and they were tempting objects to the would-be blackmailers. At any rate, after slumbering over twenty months the memory of the crime was stirred up, and indictments for it were returned indiscriminately. Men who were known to be many miles away when the McCoys were killed were branded with the same charge as their slayers. Carpenter, the leader in the slaughter, was not indicted at all. Application was made to Governor Buckner, and requisitions on the Governor of West Virginia were granted. Then Cline, Phillips and the rest of the Ken tucky conspirators were ready for open action. Offers were made that if the Hatfields would pay them certain sums of money the requisitions would be with drawn. The offer was accepted and the money paid, but the extortionists came back for more money, and again and again they unloosened the purse strings of their victims. Finally the West Virginians could endure no more, and word was sent to Pikeville that the authorities could do their wors’; no more money would be forthcoming.

In the meanwhile some of the most influ ential citizens of Logan county made rep resentations to Governor Wilson that the persons indicted in Pike county were en tire'y innocent, and he refused to issue ex tradition papers. The Pike county author ities then determined to arrest the men by invasion of West Virginia and deal with them in Kentucky as they saw fit.

FRANK PHILLIPS' CAREER.

They found a willing and acceptable tool for their work in Frank Phillips, an ex- Deputy Sheriff, and one of the most desperate men in the county. Phil lips hated the Hatfield family with all the intensity of a fierce and bloody na ture and there was reason for his hate. He had lived among the McCoys, and had courted and won the love of young Alvira McCoy, a niece of Randall McCoy, and the belle of the country side. Two hearts beat happily, two pledges were trothed and faith fully kept until young Johns Hatfield, the oldest son of Anderson Hatfield, appeared on the scene. It was the old story of wo man's fickleness. Alvira McCoy's love be gan to grow cold, and she looked with in man's fickleness. Alvira McCoy's love began increasing favor on the handsome stranger. Again and again Hatfield was drawn to the McCoy house, and finally there was an open rupture. After a stormy interview Phillips renounced all claim to the girl's hand, and a few weeks afterwards she was married to Johns Hatfield.

The old love had never died in Phillip's heart. It had burned into the marrow of his life, and from the ashes of his past happiness had sprung up a hatred of the Hatfields, which only one who had suffered such wrongs could feel.

When the Pike county conspirators, therefore, determined to invade West Virginia, and capture the men, who were under indictment, Frank Phillips gladly enlisted in the posse, and by his bravery and ferocity soon put himself at the head. A series of incursions across Tug river were begun, and a number of inoffensive citizens were kidnapped and hurried off to Pikeville jail. They were simple and law-abiding farmers and made no resistance when Phillips presented his forged authority, and ordered them to come with him. On one of these raids Frank Phillips left his party and proceeded in the night to the house of Johns Hatfield. Hatfield was away from home, and there the Kentucky leader met his old love. Again Alvira McCoy proved false. The fire of the old love was rekindled, and she assured Phillips that she was prepared to fly with him. ALVIBA HATFIELD'S FLIGHT. Phillips returned to his men and lead them across into Kentucky. While they rested on Blackberry creek their leader again stole away, this time accompanied by a friend. All preparations had been carefully made and they quietly took up their march to Johns Hatfield's house, ten miles away. At Tug river horses were secured, and these they rode to within a few yards of Hatfield's door and left them standing in the brush. The hoot-

in hooting of the owl was the signal agreed on, and late in the evening the familiar sounds split the night air. Johns Hatfield noticed it, and remarked to his wife that he would take his gun and shoot the bird. Much to his surprise she objected strenuously and he put up the weapon. A few minutes later the faithless wife made an excuse, slipped out bareheaded, and threw herself into her lover's arms. All knew the dangerous character of the man they had to deal with, and the flight to Kentucky was begun immediately. Johns Hatfield waited for his wife. She did not return, and when at last he became alarmed and started in search of her, it was too late to overtake the fugitives.

Phillip's raids had resulted in the capture of many prominent West Virginians, and although done under a pretense of authority, it was plain that the purpose was to blackmail the inhabitants. As man after man was removed, the alarm among the quiet farmers of Mate, Beech and Pigeon creeks became intense, and at last they determined to protect themselves.

JIM VANCE'S RAID.

Randall McCoy's house had been made the headquarters for the raiders, and on the night of December 10, it was determined to break up their nest. Captain Jim Vance, whose brother had died at the hands of Harmon McCoy, was the leader of the West Virginians. They gathered at the mouth of Mate Creek and two men went to Anse Hatfield's house to induce him to join the party.

The sturdy old farmer refused, and on his bended knees begged Vance and his companion to give up their purpose. They were obdurate, and departed breathing vengeance on Randall McCoy. Then Mrs. Hatfield divining that the party would return by their house the next day, compelled her husband to leave, and go over to a neighbors in order to keep from learn-

pelled from learning the identity of the parties. It has never been learned who were the members of the Vance gang, and if any of them remain they have kept their secret well. They crossed Tug river, passed up the Blackberry in the darkness of the night, and soon reached the house of Randall McCoy. The succeeding events have been flashed over the wires, and published in every newspaper in the land. No one was in the mountaineer's house but Randall

McCoy, his son, wife and daughters, but they refused to be taken alive. The demand for their surrender was answered by a volley from the house, and in the battle that followed, Randall McCoy's wife and two children were killed, and his home burned before his eyes. The father escaped amid a shower of bullets, rushed up the mountain side, and from his concealment in the bushes saw the work of the avengers below.

The murder of the McCoy family fanned the embers of hate to a white heat, and the McCoys had double reason to seek revenge. Randall McCoy left his ruined home and called on his relatives for help. With Phillips' aid a posse of forty or fifty men was recruited, and preparations were begun for a sweeping raid into West Virginia. In the meanwhile the West Virginia authorities had not been idle. Reports of the lawlessness on the Kentucky border had come over the Guyan ridge, and the sheriff of Logan county summoned a body of deputies to resist the threatened ontslaught from Kentucky. The Kentuckians were first in the field, and in one raid captured Thomas Chambers, a well-known citizen of the West Virginia side, and held him a prisoner in the Pike county jail.

WM. DEMPSEY MURDERED.

On the seventeenth of April, 1888, the

Logan county officers set out from Logan C. H., and arrived on Grapevine creek. On the nineteenth they moved down Grapevine creek, and near Cap Hatfield's house encountered Phillips and a force of twenty-one men, who had just crossed Tug river. Cap Hatfield's wife was standing in the door and two shots were fired at her. In the fight that ensued the West Virginians were defeated and fled, leaving Wm. Dempsey, one of their number, seriously wounded on the ground. Dempsey crawled into a shuck pen, and the victors found him, slowly bleeding to death. To one of the McCoys he said: "I am wounded and I know you won't kill me." The McCoy turned away, and Phillips came up with his gun, put the muzzle to Dempsey's head and blew his brains out.

On the McCoy side, Bud, a nephew of Randall, was fatally shot. Phillips gathered his party together, and without waiting to commit further depredations, returned to Kentucky. On the way they passed French Ellis' house and shot at his wife, who was a daughter of Anderson Hatfield, but both bullets flew wide of their mark.

The country was now thoroughly alarmed, and every member of either family went prepared for fight. Men carried their guns to the fields with them, and women were constantly on the watch for an approaching foe. The efforts of the West Virginians were confined to defending their own borders and protecting themselves, while the Kentuckians were the assailants.

In a few days after the raid in which Dempsey was killed, the Phillips gang returned. They crossed Tug and stopped at the house of W. G. Ferrall. Ferrall and his son were both at home, and, although they had taken no part in the feud, Phillips compelled them to accompany him. The destination of the party was the house of Cap. Jim Vance, and they made no secret of their intention to kill him on sight. Vance lived on Thacker creek, one mile from the mouth, and his double log cabin was situated on a grassy knoll between two little streams, and easily accessible from all sides. The revengeful Kentuckians surrounded it and crept up stealthily, only to find it empty.

JIM VANCE SLAUGHTERED.

From Vance's cabin a mountain path leads over the divide to Mate creek, and up this precipitous ascent Phillips lead his men, expecting to capture and kill Cap Hatfield. Both Vance and Hatfield were over on Mate creek that day, and they started to return shortly before Phillips and his party left Vance's house. The hunted men took the same path, and sat down on the brow of the divide to rest a few minutes. Mrs. Vance, who accompanied them, walked on before. A hundred yards down the mountain she caught the gleam of light on a rifle barrel, and grasped the situation in a second.

"Jim, here they come," she cried, as she flew back to warn her husband and friend of their danger. Both men seized their rifles and dashed down the mountain yelling, "Charge," "Charge." A turn in the road brought them face to face with their enemies, and both opened fire. The battle was short, sharp and bloody. Hatfield and Vance were surrounded, but they made no effort to escape. At the first fire, Vance's left hip was shattered, and although he aimed repeated at the Kentucky leader, his bullets went wide of their mark. He fell pierced by a dozen balls, and Cap Hatfield, who had sheltered himself behind a tree, fled up the mountain side, turning to fire at his pursuers as he ran.

As Vance lay on the ground he emptied both revolvers at the Kentuckians, but his nerveless hand could do little more than pull the trigger. As his last shot was fired, Frank Phillips walked up to the dying man. Without a word he put his rifle to his head, pulled the trigger and scattered Vance's brains over the ground. Mary Vance stood by the side of her murdered husband. She had not flinched during the conflict, although her bonnet and dress had been shot through and through, and she did not beg for her husband's life as he lay bleeding on the ground, but when Frank Phillips turned to her after his fiendish deed her fury broke forth and her eyes flashed fire as she swore that she would have his life if she ever met him where she could be avenged

DIED FOR HIS SWEETHEART.

This was the last outrage of especial note committed by Kentuckians on West Virginia soil, but the cup of blood was not yet full. A few weeks later one of the McCoy boys ventured across Tug river to see his sweetheart. Cap Hatfield and others had knowledge of his coming and determined to arrest him. A party lay in wait for McCoy and he was taken by surprise, and Cap and Ellison Mounts started with him to the Logan county jail.

They came down Mate creek to its mouth, and as they passed along the path by the river bank the captive made a desperate effort to escape. His hands had been unloosened, and before Hatfield or Mounts fully realized his purpose he had sprung into Tug river and was diving and swimming toward the Kentucky shore. A merciless fusillade opened up from two Winchester rifles. Shot after shot struck the water about the hunted man, but he still swam on. The bank was just in his reach and he extended his hand to grasp the small bushes by the edge when the last shot was fired. It came from Mounts' gun, and as the smoke cleared away, nerveless hands released their holds on the Kentucky willows, and another victim of the Hatfield McCoy fend fell lifeless into the waters of the Tug River. HATFIELD'S HOME.

A Visit to the Refuge of Anse Hatfield's Family.

The capture and removal of nine of the Hatfields and their sympathizers to Kentucky, the death of Vance and the summary action of the West Virginia authorities, who prepared to send troops to the scene of the conflict, have brought comparative quiet to the Tug river valley. But the feeling of security has not yet come to the members of the Hatfield family. The State of Kentucky offers a reward for their arrest, and time and again alleged detectives have attempted to capture them. In order to avoid the fate of his brethren who were kidnapped by Phillips, Anderson Hatfield sold his farm on Tug river and purchased another on Island creek, a tributary of Guyan river, thus placing a steep and almost impenetrable mountain between him and his foes. Here his family and dependents followed him. After his battle with the Phillips party Cap Hatfield joined his father and came back to the Tug river, only two months ago, for his wife. Pres. Smith, Cap's father-in-law, also moved into the same neighborhood, and there the remnants of the family eke out a precarious and hunted existence.

ACROSS GUYAN RIDGE.

The correspondent of the REGISTER ascended Mate Creek to the divide between it and Pigeon, crossed over on to Island Creek by a narrow trail, which was all but impassable to the hardy mountain horses, and came down to Anderson Hat[field] Hatfield's home. A friend, who was acquainted with the family, acted as a guide, and his introduction was the open sesame to the old farmer's heart. Anderson Hatfield was sitting in the house as we rode up and made us welcome. Little children were playing about the door, and women were at work in the house. A gun was lying on a bench within a few feet of Hatfield's hands, and it was plain that he was on the alert for men who might come to take him prisoner.

A few gifts to the children opened the hearts of all alike, and for the next few hours we enjoyed hearty mountain hospitality. The old man is over six feet tall but bent with age and trouble. His full beard tinged with gray gives him a patriarchal appearance, which was enhanced by the awe and affection with which all seemed to regard him. The younger men were in the fields, and after a little persuasion he talked freely. His story of the origin and incidents of the difficulty was substantially the same as given above, but there was an evident desire to shield his sons, and put their actions in the best light possible.

There was a tinge of sadness in his voice as he spoke of his old home, and described his flight from it to his present abode, but he straightened up and his eyes flashed when the detectives were mentioned. "Those men have no right to arrest me or my sons," he said, "and they shall never do it. I have committed no crime. The Governor has granted no requisition papers, and they have no authority to touch us. They will do it at their peril." Hatfield then told of the several alleged detectives who had been in that section of the country, and laughed heartily as he described how his sons had turned on them, captured them and taken them to Logan C. H. THE HATFIELD FORT.

In the meanwhile a dinner of smoking bacon corn pone and milk was set upon the table and all were invited to set to and help themselves. The repast was a welcome tribute to appetites stimulated by the keen air, and the party ate as only mountaineers can.

After the meal was disposed of Anse volunteered to take us to the fort, which he had built for protection against the detectives who were stimulated to arrest him by offers of reward, and from there point out the shortest route to Logan C. H. He led the party back from the house to a narrow ravine, where the hills seemed to come together from above and almost shut out the light of day. At the head of the hollow a projecting eminence commanded every means of approach. A compact log house studded with loop holes stood on the extreme point. Within a hundred yards of it a voice ordered "halt." Anse went forward, spoke a few words and beckoned us to approach. Two men came out of the bushes and conducted the whole party to the fort. The little room contained a stock of arms and provisions. A barrel of flour and water were in one corner, and powder and balls were opposite them, while a number of guns hung around the walls. The logs were of solid hewn oak well put together, and every few feet loop holes at a convenient height let in the light of day.

The survey of the interior was made hastily, Anse explaining that his men did not like to reveal the location of the place to strangers and objected to an examination. The door was closed and our guide pointed out a route over the hills, which lead to Logan C. H. As we passed over the brow we looked back and saw the old man giving some instruction to his assistants. A rifle-barrel gleamed in the sunlight, as a last reminder of the Hatfield-McCoy feud.

See the clipping

The nine-year-old with the pocketknife

Reprinted from the New York Sun after Alexander Messer’s arrest, this story says nine-year-old Budd McCoy stabbed Deacon Ellison Hatfield’s legs in the 1882 election fight, and his brother Randolph, 13, was taken for him. After Talbot and Farmer were shot, Messer said ‘Dead men tell no tales’ and killed the boy. Budd, the Sun says, died of fever six months later. Messer was sentenced to life.

The Morning News · Savannah, Ga.

The Morning News · 18 July 1889 · page 5 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

A BOY'S DOINGS IN A FEUD

ONLY 9 YEARS OLD, BUT WELL ABLE TO USE A KNIFE.

See moreSee less

An Incident in the Hatfield-McCoy War in the Mountains of Kentucky—It Was a Serious Case of Mistaken Identity.

From the New York Sun.

The arrest and imprisonment of Alexander Messer, one of the Hatfield faction, not long ago, for a murder committed in the course of the Hatfield-McCoy feud, recalls the fact that the crime which Messer committed was due to a mistake made by mountain officers in arresting a boy of 13 for a deed done by a boy of 9. The part which this boy—Budd McCoy—took in the feud has never been told in print.

Budd McCoy was 9 years old at the time to which reference is made in this story, and his home was on the Blackberry branch of Pond creek, in Pike county, Kentucky. It ougt to be said now that this is a true story, for otherwise the reader might think that the writer, in an attempt to be sensational, had drawn the long bow.

The McCoy family was a large one. Budd had eight brothers and six sisters, all of whom were older than he, some of them being m rried and having children quite as old as their uncle Budd. Besides these brothers and sisters, Budd had so many cousins living in Pike county that he couldn't for the life of him remember half their names, thoug he generally saw them all from two to three times a year, when they all went to the outdoor church gatherings, which in the mountains of Kentucky and West Virginia are called associations.

Over the state line in West Virginia was a family that consisted of no end of brothers and sisters, with cousins, also, just like the McCoys, whose name was Hatfield. Anderson Hatfield was the name of the father of this family, and Randolph McCoy was the fater of Budd. Between the McCoys and the Hatfields there was a deadly feud. As they say down there, the two families were at war, and that means that whenever three or four McCoys caught a Hatfield out by himself, they would hide in the brush on the mountain side and shoot him in the back, while the Hatfields were just as anxious to kill McCoys, and just as cowardly in their way of doing it.

In 1882, the year that Budd was 9 years old, but one man had been actually killed in this way. His name was Bill Sayton, and he was one of the cousins of the Hatfields. He had been waylaid by two of Budd's cousins and shot to death because he had once thrown a stone at Budd's father and knocked him down, and thus openly arrayed himself with the Hatfields. Little Budd knew all about the feud from the time it began, when his father sued one of the Hatfields for the value of two longnosed hogs and got beaten. He had listened to his father and older brothers as they discussed the chances of meeting the Hatfields and shooting them and getting shot by them, and the one thing that worried him most was that his father said he was too young yet to learn to shoot, and so he must wait an awful ti e, it seemed to him—two whole years—before he could hope to kill a Hatfield. However, he got a chance at one of them much quicker than he anticipated, and the revenge taken for the blood that he helped to shed was horrifying.

On the first Monday in August, 1882, there was a general election in Pike county, and among other candidates before the people was an elderly cousin of Budd, who wanted to be justice of the peace. Now it happened t at this man, who e name was Thomas Stafford, had married one of the Hatfield girls, and so was considered a member of that family, also. He was a discreet man, who had kept friendly with both families, and the consequence was that not only Budd's father and older brothers turned out on election day to help Mr. Stafford get elected, but the Hatfields, who lived in West Virginia, and who could not, of course, vote in Ke tucky, also came ove to the polls to work for the same end. Little Budd and his next older brother, Randolph, Jr., a lad of 13, both went to the election ground to play with the other boys sure to be there.

Up there in the mountains the elections are held in the open air. This time the judges of election had a table placed on the grass under a big beech tree over on Blackberry creek (on the branch Budd lived on), and the ballot box stood on the table before them. With the two families there interested in obtaining a common end, what easier than for a discreet man like Stafford to get them together, to shake hands and become friends again. It was done. But unfortunately there was no law against selling whisky there then, and in their excess of good feeling the Hatfields and McCoys all drank heartily from the same jug of moonshine whisky. All whisky is bad, at such gatherings, but moonshine is the worst sort, and to make matters still worse, when the jug of corn whisky was empty a jug full of mountain-made applejack took its place. The mixture made the men ugly.

After emptying the jug of applejack Talbot McCoy, one of Budd's grown-up brothers, was anxious for more, but had no money to buy it. Then he met one of the Hatfields who had borrowed $1 75 of him a long while before. Talbot asked for the money, and the next thing anybody noticed was the two men fighting. Immediately there was a rush made by the men about the polls, and the fighters were separated and arrested by two constables.

But the fight was destained to go on. A

McCoy had hit a Hatfield, and all the ill feeling that had existed between the families was aroused once more, and the truce which Stafford had brought about was forgotten. Deacon Ellison Hatfield, a brother of Anderson Hatfield, chief of the Hatfield faction, was the one to pick up the fight for his side. The deacon, in spite of his church office, had taken too much moonshine whisky and was anxious for a fight.

Drawing a big pocket knife, he opened the blade, and with many hard words called

Talbot McCoy a coward for pitching into one of the smallest of the Hatfields. The more he talked the angrier he got, and so, too, did Talbot, until finally the constable, who was holding Talbot, saw that the deacon was going to cut Talbot anyhow, and so concluded to get out of the way and let the two men fight it out.

The instant he was released, Talbot sprang back two steps, and with a quick motion drew a pocket knife and opened the blade. Then both men stooped a bit and jumped for each other with murder in their hearts, while the ring of eager mountaineers about them swayed to and fro as each one strove to see every move made. Talbot, who was the younger and quicker, drove his knife into the deacon's left side, missing a fatal wound only because the point of the knife struck a rib and glanced off. The deacon's knife descended on Talbot's head, slashing through the soft black hat and clear across the top of his head, laying open the scalp to the skull for over five inches.

At this the two separated and then closed in with a bound. Neither uttered a word or cry, although the Deacon's knife closed on his hand, cutting it half way across, so that he had to drop the weapon, while Talbot plied his stabbing the deacon again and again with the agility of an Italian desperado. But the decon, although mortally wounded, was a man of great strength and pluck, and closed in on his younger opponent, intending to throw him. Thereafter he had the advantage, for Talbot could no longer use his knife so well.

As the two men struggled from side to side, swaying first against one part of the ring and then another, the men of both families began to draw their weapons—here a pistol, there a knife. Squeezed in between two full grown men, with his head stretched eagerly forward, watching every movement, stood little Budd McCoy, with an open pocketknife clutched in his right hand. After a little the two fighters in their struggle half stopped in front of him, and in an instant he had reached out and plunged his knife repeatedly into the legs of Deacon Hatfield. Two of the blows were below the knee, but one was in the hip, and it was a deep cut for so small a hand to make.

Again the men struggled away, and again they got back before the boy, who plied his knife as before. This time he was seen by one of the Hatfields, who called a neighbor's attention to the act. But before they could do anything toward seeing fair play the Deacon, by a last desperate effort, threw Talbot McCoy to the ground, and, picking up a stone, raised it aloft to crush the skull of his enemy.

Among the spectators was Farmer McCoy, another brother of Talbot. He had drawn his pistol, as he said, to see fair play. Now he could stand the sight no longer, and shot the Deacon in the back.

That ended the fight. The deacon fell to the ground dying, while Farmer McCoy fled up the road with a lot of bullets from a Hatfield pistol flying past him, while young Budd threw his knife into the creek and slipped away unseen.

At the same moment Randolph McCoy, Jr., the boy of 13, came running up from a spring some hundred yards below, where he had been playing with a companion. He had heard the shooting and arrived just in time to see his brother, Farmer, arrested and brought back, and Talbot also arrested. Then the Hatfield who had seen Budd stabbing the deacon's legs pointed out Randolph to the officers and accused him of the crime of which little Budd was really guilty. It was an awful mistake, but a natural one. People could not be expected to distinguish between two small brothers in a family of fifteen.

Young Randolph, made wild by an intuition of his coming fate, an intuition that did not yet oppress his older brothers, protested his innocence, but his eagerness and fear only convinced the officers that he was guilty.

The officers kept the three prisoners in a house near by over night and next morning started for Pikeville to put them in jail to await trial. But they never got there. Old Anderson Hatfield, Deacon Ellison's brother —Bad Anse, he was and still is called—with a great mob of relatives and friends, took the prisoners from the officers and carried them over Fog river to West Virginia, and put them in a school house, there to await the result of the deacon's wounds.

Tho deacon had been carried over the river also, and lay in the house of Anderson Ferr ld, at the mouth of Mate creek. The school house where the prisoners were kept was half a mile away. The surgeon who was summoned found twenty-seven wounds in the deacons' body, one of which split his left lung half in two, and several others were as deadly, but still the wounded man did not die until Wednesday afternoon at 3 o'clock.

Meantime the prisoners were kept lying on the school house floor, bound with a rope so securely that their arms swelled to double size, and it was impossible for hem to rest or sleep. Hatfields, armed with all sorts of weapons, stood guard and discussed with each other the parts of the bodies of the prisoners that would be most painful when "shot full of lead." The mother of the p isoners and Talbot's wife, with a baby 4 months old in her arms, came to see them. There were tears and pleadings, such as might have melted the he rt of any one but a savage. But they were vain. The women were even brutally taunted with the fate these boys were to suffer. At last the hour arrived when the deacon ceased to breathe. A messenger on a mule rode madly up to the school house with the news, and then with cries like wild beasts many of the younger Hatfields ran around the school house peering through the cracks in the hope of getting a shot at the prisoners without endangering their own friends. But Valentine Hatfield, another brother of the deacon and a justice of the peace withal, stopped that by telling them to wait till light and then they could have their revenge.

Worn out by their long sufferings, the prisoners broke down and wept, but Talbot, who was, after all, a manly sort of a fellow for a mountaineer, soon recovered his composure. Turning to old Bad Anse and to Valentine Hatfield, he said:

"Gentlemen, when you shoot me I want you to look me in the face." Then he pleaded for the lad, Randolph. It appears that at this time both Bad Anse and his brother Valentine had been convinced that they had got the wrong one of the two little boys, and had determined to spare Randolph's life, but to teach him a lesson they meant to make him witness the death of his older brothers.

As night came on the prisoners were taken out of the school and driven down the road toward Tug river, the dividing line between Kentucky and West Virginia. As they reached the river, Farmer McCoy, overcome by fear, fainted and fell on the sand, but water was sprinkled on his face in order that he might be revived and realize his fate. The three were driven then over into Kentucky, and there, on the edge of the woods, were tied to some paw-paw bushes.

Talbot, who had remained silent and proud, was tied with his back to his executioners. Farmer, who was half dead with fear, was tied facing them, and the lad, little Randolph, was tied kneeling and facing his older brothers. Then the gang formed in line a few feet away, with their arms pointed at the two older brothers. Old Bad Anse shouted to his brother Valentine, who stood over on the Virginia side:

"All ready."

"Take aim, fire!" shouted Valentine.

There was a roar of guns and rifles, and Talbot and Farmer were no more. Their bodies were shot full of bullets.

The boy on his knees could only gasp with horror at the awful scene. The men formed in line and marched down the path a few rods on their way back across the river. Then one of the gang, named Alexander Messer, thought of the possibility of the boy becoming a witness against them should they ever be brought to trial for what they had done. Speaking to Bad Anse, who commanded the gang, he said:

"Dead men tell no tales."

"Go, you," said Bad Anse.

He obeyed. Loading both barrels of his shotgun with heavy charges of powder and rifle bullets, he went back. The boy did not notice him till he was but a few feet away, and could only give one wailing cry for mercy, which was heard by an elder brother a quarter of a mile away, and then Messer fired both barrels of the gun. The whole of the boy's head was shot off, and a piece of the skull was afterward picked up ten feet from where he knelt. Young as was little Budd, he fully realized that it was his act that had caused the arrest and murder of his brother Randolph. Six months later he was attacked with a sort of fever common in the mountains. From the first, he told his mother that he should not get well, and he did not. Within seven days the disease had run its course, much sooner than usual, and he was dead. The last words he spoke were an incoherent reference to the murder of his brother Randolph.

Of course the feud has not been ended. The laws of the state are openly defied, the officers seem to care nothing about it, and one deed of violence has followed another. Probably many other murders are yet to come, and not until this wild country is opened up by railroads and settled by law-abiding citizens from other states will life and property become safe from bushwacking mob rule.

See the clipping

Life terms, and a death sentence for Mounts

A Pikeville dispatch gives the verdicts: Pliant and Doll Mayhorn, of the Hatfield gang, get life for the murder of the McCoy brothers and say old Ance Hatfield urged them on, and Ellison Mounts is sentenced to hang on 3 December for killing Elfora McCoy. A detective’s account in November gave the date as 8 December, and Mounts was hanged at Pikeville on 18 February 1890.

Evening Journal · Wilmington, Del.

Evening Journal · 16 September 1889 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image

Hatfield-McCoy Murderers Sentenced.

PIKEVILLE, Ky., Sept. 16.—At the trial of Pliant and Doll Mayhorn, two of the notorious Hatfield gang, they were convicted of the murder of the McCoy brothers and sentenced to imprisonment for life. They claimed that they were urged to the deed by old Ance Hatfield. Ellison Mounts was found guilty of the murder of Elfora McCoy and sentenced to be hanged Dec. 3.

See the clipping

A love affair blamed, and Devil Anse interviewed

An Examiner dispatch from Catlettsburg traces the 1882 outbreak to John Hatfield’s seizure of Rosanna McCoy and reports the murder of Julia Ann McCoy, her groom and the minister who married them, ‘if true’. A month later the Wheeling Sunday Register said the feud country had been quiet for over six months. In a recalled interview, Devil Anse jokes that he belongs to ‘the Devil's church’.

The Salt Lake Herald · Salt Lake City, Utah

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Salt Lake Herald · 8 October 1889 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

"IN MURDER LAND."

History of the Hatfield-McCoy Vendetta.

See moreSee less

A LOVE AFFAIR STARTS IT ALL.

How They "Take" All the Wives They Want To in Kentucky—Some of the Killings—An Interview.

[Special to THE HERALD--Examiner Dispatch.]

CATLETTSBURG, Ky., Oct. 6.—Aside from the killing of Herman McCoy in 1863 by Anse. or as he is better known, "Devil" Hatfield, the breaking out of the great mountain vendetta in 1882 can be directly traced to a love affair between John Hatfield and Rosanna McCoy. Since that time the boundary line between West Virginia and Kentucky on the Tug river has acquired a fearful notoriety as the home of desperate and shameless crime. "Murder Land" is now the ordinary and appropriate designation of these horror haunted mountains, where social condition, of an evil state of human nature are at once the cause and the results of the crimes which have rendered them accursed. The killing of poor Julia Ann McCoy. her young handsome John Hand and the minister that made them one Tuesday, if true, is but the logical sequal of a series of murders which have decimated the McCoy and Hatfield families. So far the Hatfields have had the best of it. It is not they but the McCoys who have mostly died in their boots.

Rosanna McCoy, who was the daughter of Randolph, chief of the McCoy clan, lived with her father in Pike county, Kentucky. John Hatfield's domain was across the state line in West Virginia. His marriage to Rosanna, (they call these little affairs marriages in West Virginia), more resembled the rape of the Sabines. In the vernacular of the county, John "took up" with Rosanna, who, in 1882, was a rosy faced girl of eighteen with regular features and straight, lithe figure. He had met her at an election gathering in Pike county whether she had ridden pillion fashion behind one of her brothers.

The bold Hatfield became perfectly infatuated with Miss McCoy and inflamed with liquor proposed that she should elope with him. She objected. He captured her by force and terrified her into compliance. Towards the close of night he was seen by the McCoys crossing the river with Rosanna seated behind him on his strong black horse. When John ran away with the pride of the McCoys, he was already married, but the Hatfields don't mind a little thing like that Justice of the Peace Valentine Hatfield, when captured in 1888, confessed to Attorney James Lee Ferguson, of Pike county, Kentucky. that he had as many as five living wives and thirty-three living children. The Hatfields have peculiar ideas of polygamy. They do not marry their wives according to law, but they "take" them and apportion their time between them just like any Mormon elder or the grand Turk. This is just what John did. He "took" Rossana home with him. presented her to his first wife and forced her to recognize this new leader as head of the house.

Rosanna remained in bondage till the end of the year when, frightened by the threats of her family, she returned to her own home. John let her go, but he did not forgo the romantic luxury of visits to the McCoy homestead. In one of the trips he was captured and led out, as Rosanna believed, to his death. He was taken at 1 o'clock in the morning. After this "arrest" she crawled out of her bed, unfastened a horse from her father's stable and started off in the blackest of black nights to warn the Hatfields. Old Anse immediately turned out his crowd. They crossed the river and three of th[e]m came up in time to beat off a party of nine who were taking "Jone" to jail. The Hatfields covered the McCoys with Winchesters and John was given up. Anse was in favor of killing the McCoys then and there, but was dissuaded by peacemaker Elias Hatfield. This quarrel led directly to the killing of Ellison Hatfield. Ellison, like Elias, was arrested for being a peacemaker. He was a strong and square and resolute man, always anxious to avoid a quarrel if he could. He came to his death because of his interference in a petty row between members of his family and one of the McCoys. The ostensible cause of the row was a quarrel over a ring. Three of the McCoys closed upon Deacon Ellison and stabbed him with their knives. He was cut in at least twenty-four different places and undoubtedly killed. One of these McCoys was a mere boy of sixteen. He did most of the cutting in the back. The Hatfields, led by a bad, ugly. coarse man, immediately retaliated. They "arrested," the term is not to be understood as used in any legal sense, the three McCoys, tied them to bushes and shot them to death. Tablot, Farge and Randolph McCoy, jr., thus met their fate. Jeff McCoy next paid the penalty.

After killing a man named Woodford he paid "Cap." Hatfield a visit and shot one of his hired men in the hip. It was no more than a flesh wound and no mountaineer lays up with anything short of a mortal wound. Therefore the hired man did not design Jeff's death—Wallace and "Cap." Hatfield decided to "arrest" him and take him to jail, but when Jeff came to the river he attempted to escape and was shot at more than twenty times while crossing the stream and finally killed by "Cap." Hatfield just as he was escaping on the further bank.

There now began a series of raids between the states of Kentucky and West Virginia in which the McCoys were very active. The respective governors of the two states took a hand in the vendetta and only made matters worse. The Hatfields, exasperated by the state of war which reigned about their mountain lairs, did not wait to be captured or killed, but took time by the forelock, planning and executing one of the most ghastly murders in history. One night they surrounded the house of Randolph McCoy where his beautiful daughter had been stolen by John Hatfield, and who had ripened his violence by extraordinary love and devotion, and fired into the defenseless family. A sharp volley was returned.

Hatfield, seeing that they were likely to get as good as the could give, set fire to the building, and succeeded in driving the inmates out. One of them was Miss Allaphan McCoy. a young girl of sixteen. As she stood pleading for mercy on the door step, Ellison Mounts, a low born son of the murdered Ellison, shot her dead. An old lady was beaten about the head with a gun so that her life was despaired of for several days, and one of the sons of Calvin McCoy was killed. The house was burned to the ground.

The Hatfields concerned in this affair were "Cap" Hatfield, Tom Mitchell, French Ellis, Bob Hatfied, Elliot Hatfield, Charles Gillespie, Ellis Mounts and Jim Vance. This burning of the house and the atrocious murders in connection with it, brought on another raid on the part of the McCoys, led by a man named Phillips, who is said to have loved the beautiful Rosanna.

Phillips was an humble officer of the law, but was fired with the spirit of a fiend and his act was on a par with the outlawry he was seeking to put down. In this raid Jim Vance, the leader of the house burning, in which Anse Hatfield played so despicable a part, was shot down by Phillips. Vance was a vindictive fighter and when Phillips even came up to the old fellow, they found him with the right fore finger clasped around the trigger of his pistol trying with his last strength to shoot one more shot.

Phillips and his crowd, after they had killed Vance, like so many Indians, robbed him of his personal effects.

A warrant was issued for Phillips and the sheriff summoned a posse of seven or eight men to execute it. But Phillips and his friends overpowered the posse and fatally wounded Bill Dempsay, one of the number. As Dempsey was expiring he begged that he might be left to die in peace, but Phillips deliberately blew his brains out. This was in 1887.

A dreadful pause of two years elapses. Then comes the final chapter in this serial of blood. Already the triple murder of last Tuesday night has been fully telegraphed to the Examiner. When the end shall come, no one in "Murderland" pretends to know. Official interference hitherto has only aggravated the ills sought to be cured. In twenty-five years in bad Anse's territory there has not been one conviction for murder. The vendetta reopens supreme and will continue to reign until the last of the Hatfields and McCoys have passed away or until the light of some higher civilization shall have penetrated the gloom that hangs in the terrible mountains.

An Interview With "Devil Anse."

[Special to THE HERALD - Examiner Dispatch.]

NEW YORK, Oct. 7.—Shortly after the murder of Dempsey by Phillips, Mr. T. C. Crawford, a distinguished journalist of New York, visited "murder land" and obtained an interview with "Devil Anse" in his log fort on Tug river.

Bad Anse is described by Mr. Crawford as bearing a marked resemblance to Stonewall Jackson. He was of powerful frame with broad shoulders, deep chested but with a curve to his shoulders peculiar to the mountain type. Although fifty years of age, he had not a single gray hair in his thick brown hair, mustache and beard. His gray eyes eyes were set under the deepest of bushy eyebrows and his nose was such an enormous hook as to suggest the lines of a Turkish cimiter. When asked by Mr. Crawford if he had ever been personally present at any of the killings, he remarked candidly enough: "No man who was there would tell any one if he was."

Then Mr. Crawford boldly put this question to the great outlaw, "Mr. Hatfield, I want to ask you about your ideas about killing. There is no one in this community who has ever charged you with having killed anyone for the pleasure of it." Said Anse quickly: "I don't believe they have."

"But if they were to kill any member of your family in a fair fight, what would you do?"

"Well, I reckon," was the reply, "I should get away with them just about as soon as I could."

"That is your idea, then?"

"Yes, sir. Any man that wants to try it, he will find it out."

When asked why so many shots were fired during the vendetta without effect, when the men of both families were so handy at shooting at marks, Hatfield replied in this wise: "Human vermin is the most cooricus and most cunningest varmint that is. When he goes into a fight he turns his body sidewise, so that there is presented for the bullet only four inches space and even that doesn't hold up fair square. He just keeps a dodging and friskin about and so when bullets come along they don't find him. That's the only way I can account for it."

Anse did not admit being a religious man. "I belong to no church," said he, "unless you say that I belong to the one great church of the world. If you like, you can say it is the Devil's church that I belong to," and then he laughed as if he hugely enjoyed his joke.

The manners of the Hatfields are of the most primitive kind. Such an article as soap is absolutely unknown in the history of the family. Guests just before dinner are invited to wash in a passing stream about twenty feet from the house. Men, women and children and guards all sleep in the same room. The men are generally seated about the fire and ignore, according to the etiquette of the place, the retiring of the women to their pallets. The girls go to bed first and they are always up first in the morning. Each member of the happy family is divided off by Winchesters.

See the clipping

Twelve dead, by one Wisconsin count

A Wisconsin paragraph counts twelve people shot dead in the feud, among them Allaphare McCoy, killed by Ellison Mounts while ‘pleading for mercy in her father's doorway’, and a Julia Ann McCoy, said to have been shot beside her groom together with the minister marrying them. A Catlettsburg dispatch nine days earlier had hedged its report of the wedding killing, and no later clipping in the set confirms it.

River Falls Journal · River Falls, Wis.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 4 days later.

Wrong

River Falls Journal · 17 October 1889 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

Twelve persons have now been shot and killed in the continuance of the Hatfield-McCoy feud in West Virginia. Of these one was Miss Allaphare McCoy, shot pleading for mercy in her father's doorway by Ellison Mounts. Another, the second woman killed, was Julia Ann McCoy, shot by her groom's side, together with the minister in the act of uniting them.

See the clipping

A newspaper faker's war exposed

The Wheeling Sunday Register exposes three days of Associated Press stories from Milton, W. Va., describing pitched battles between Hatfields and McCoys. The Lincoln county trouble, it says, has nothing to do with the feud, which has been quiet in Logan and Pike for over six months, and of the faker's latest dead man it notes ‘this is the third time that poor JOHN BRUMFIELD has been killed’.

Wheeling Sunday Register · Wheeling, W. Va.

CorrectionThis set right 5 earlier articles: Evening Star, 2 November 1889, Evening Star, 2 November 1889, Wichita Eagle, 2 November 1889, Daily Kennebec Journal, 2 November 1889, St. Paul Daily Globe, 2 November 1889.

Wheeling Sunday Register · 3 November 1889 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image

WHO AND WHERE IS THE "HATFIELD-M'COY" FAKIR?

For the past three days the newspapers of the country have contained the most blood-chilling recitals of the progress of the "Hatfield-McCoy war," all bearing the stamp of falsehood on their face. The agent of the Associated Press at Chicago has been deceived by the ingenuity with which the "fakir" has gotten them up, and in good faith has shipped them over the circuit, with the preface, "A special from Milton, W. Va., says." It is seldom, indeed, that the agents of the Associated Press, who are usually the most responsible journalists to be found, are deceived by these "fakirs," but in such a case as this, where the "fake" is so ingeniously constructed, and the agent several hundred miles from the scene and unacquainted with the matter and the country, the fact of the deception is not surprising.

See moreSee less

To start with, the trouble in Lincoln county has no connection whatever with the HATFIELD-McCOY affair, which is confined to Logan county, W. Va., and Pike county, Ky., where things have been quiet for over six months. The telegraph office nearest the scene of the alleged trouble is at Huntington, where the REGISTER has stationed an alert and reliable correspondent, who has the best facilities in that neighborhood for getting the news, and has kept us fully informed of all the facts in the Lincoln county affair.

The Milton stories that have been foisted upon the Chicago agent of the Associated Press do not contain one iota of truth, as may be seen from the REGISTER'S special dispatch from Huntington, in another column, which is authoritative.

The latest production of this most accomplished newspaper "fakir," is the following blood-curdling tale, which was sent out yesterday:

Reports of another battle between the Hatfields and McCoys have reached here.

Last night a party of about thirty of the McCoys came across a Brumfield camp in the woods, about six miles from Green Shoals. Both bands were bound for the headquarters of their respective factions, and were heavily armed.

When the McCoys discovered their enemies they sent out scouts and learned that there were about a score in the camp. They crawled up through the dense underbrush and poured in a volley on their sleeping foes. In an instant it was returned, and the Hatfields, although taken by surprise, were so much better armed than the McCoys, having repeating rifles, that they soon put them to flight.

The one volley fired by the McCoys did terrible execution. Half a dozen men were wounded and two were slain. John Brumfield, one of the leaders of this faction, was instantly killed. By his side lay Edwin Brown, the son of the woman who was shot in her farm house at Fudgy's creek. Two bullets had gone through his body, one piercing the heart.

By the way, this is the third time that poor JOHN BRUMFIELD has been killed, and also the second member of the BROWN family to meet a violent death at the hands of this merciless and bloody journalist.

The "fake" continues in the same cheerful vein:

Six other men were wounded, one of them, whose name is unknown, being fatally hurt. After dawn the Hatfields found two more dead men and four wounded men were captured. Some of the wounded McCoys must have been carried off by their friends, for the trail of their retreat through the woods was marked by blood stains.

The prisoners captured were Charles Lambkin, John Cain, —— Cain and Pete McCoy. The names of the dead are unknown. The Cain whose first name was not learned was so badly wounded that his captors left him to die where he lay, but the other three were compelled to march to the Hatfield quarters. As soon as the story of the attack and capture was told a sort of court martial was held. The prisoners were not allowed to speak in their own defense, and, after a short deliberation, a vote on their life or death was taken by the entire Hatfield party. The result was unanimous, and the three men will be tied to trees and shot before sundown this evening. Nothing can save them unless the McCoys can defeat the entire Hatfield party and effect a rescue. This is not likely, as they are outnumbered two to one and the Hatfields are better armed.

The courier who brought this news was shot at twice from ambush while riding through Lincoln county.

Now the questions are, who is this liar, and where is he located? We do not believe he resides in this State, although West Virginia is afflicted with some very expert fakirs in this line. This bloody-minded genius probably resides in Cincinnati, and, possessing some knowledge of the Hatfield-McCoy matter, which he has confused with the Lincoln county fuss, and the difficulties in the way of obtaining news, has resolved to make his fortune by working his imagination and selling the result to the newspapers.

The individual probably does not stop to consider the fact that he is obtaining money under false pretenses.

See the clipping

A Kentucky detective hunts Jonce out west

In the Spokane Falls Review, T. M. Gibson, a detective hired by Kentucky, tells how he helped take Ellison Mounts and caught Alexander Messer by posing as a pension agent. He says Jonce Hatfield has lived near Spokane for over a year ‘going by the name of James Jacobs’ and got away in a box car. By 1901 the Washington Evening Star had Jonce taken by Cunningham and serving a life sentence.

Spokane Falls Review · Spokane Falls, Wash.

Spokane Falls Review · 7 November 1889 · page 8 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

A GREAT FEUD. One of the Cruel Hatfields in This State.

HE HAS BEEN IN SPOKANE.

See moreSee less

A Remarkable but Straightforward Statement.

A DETECTIVE SENT FROM KENTUCKY.

The Fugitive Aided and Abetted by Men in the Government Employ.

The Review this morning is enabled to lay before its readers another interesting page in the history of a famous vendetta. From this statement it appears that one of the murderous Hatfields is even now in this state. The following story has been written by a detective now here from the state of Kentucky, who makes it over his own signature and vouches for its correctness. To the Review reporters he exhibited many confirmatory facts whose publication at this juncture would not be prudential. His story is as follows:

After reading the interesting account of the Hatfield-McCoy warfare given in the Review of October 30, I would like to add a few facts which may be of interest to the readers of your valuable paper. Having been employed by the state of Kentucky to help "run down" and prosecute the gang of desperadoes led by "Devil Anse" Hatfield, I am very familiar with every detail of the case. It would be difficult to give a more accu- rate account, or fuller details of the atro- cious crimes that have been committed since this feud began, than that already published. But as my name has been mentioned in connection with the arrest of Ellison Mounts and others of the Hatfield outlaws, I will endeavor to give a full account of these arrests.

I shall never forget the morning we arrested Mounts. I say "we," because there were with me Dan Cunningham, as brave a man and true-hearted gentle- man as you will often see, and Bill Knapper, "Kentucky Bill" we always called him, with his wily ways and the cunning of a fox. We made a strong team, and the Hatfields dreaded us and consequently they kept close to their "fort" on Island creek. There were eight of them there, and they each had a brace of revolvers and trusty Winchester rifle in reach all the time. While eating their Winchesters were in their laps, and sleeping they were under their pillows. And besides posting one of them as a sentinel while the others slept they kept a keen-scented, well-trained greyhound and an enormous bulldog lying outside the "fort." They were too well guarded for us to hope for any success in an attack on the "fort," our only chance being to maneuver carefully and surprise them.

We had some warm friends in the neighborhood, who kept us concealed for days until the Hatfields, not hearing of us, thought we had left for "parts unknown," and then they ventured out.

TRACKED TO THEIR HOME.

Tom Mitchell and Ellison Mounts thinking the coast was clear crossed the mountains to Mate valley to visit their families. This was our chance. We followed through the woods, arriving only a few hours later than they. Sitting on a hillside about half a mile from the house we waited for nightfall to make the attack. But just at dusk we saw them leaving the house with their blankets, being afraid to sleep in the house, they were going to the woods. We couldn't get up with them from where we were, so we decided to "lay" for them as they came to breakfast the following morning.

Early in the morning, the ground covered with frost, we stood, chilled and numb, having staid out without fire or blankets by the mountain trail, hidden by two large poplar trees, waiting for the villains to come along. Presently, peering out from our hiding place, I saw them coming. Mounts was some thirty yards in front of Mitchell, and carried the same Winchester with which he so brutally murdered Miss Alaphare McCoy and which he afterwards presented to me. Mitchell carried a large Winchester and a pair of heavy revolvers in his belt.

As Mounts approached, Cunningham stepped out and with his gun in Mount's face told him to surrender. Mounts had always said he would not be arrested alive and thinking to carry out his resolution, he started his gun from his shoulder to shooting position, but before he could use it, I sprang forward, pushing Cunningham aside, and dealt him a heavy blow with a billy. When he recovered he was handcuffed.

Meanwhile Mitchell, seeing Mounts confronted, turned and ran. He had gore about 100 yards when I started in pursuit. My gain was so apparent that he turned and fired four shots at me, wounding me slightly in the leg, while I emptied my pistol, shooting off his left forefinger and wounding him in the side.

A few more steps took him to a thicket that covered his retreat, and I was unable to get sight of him again.

Mounts begged us to allow us to kill himself, saying he would rather commit suicide than be hanged for killing a McCoy. At his trial in September last he was sentenced to hang December 8.

RANDOLPH M'COY'S MURDERER.

Alexander Messer, who shot young Randolph McCoy, and was sentenced to the penitentiary for life, was one of the most desperate of the gang. A perfect "dare-devil," he left the "fort" at his pleasure and defied the officers of the law.

On learning that he had left the gang to visit his family some ten miles distant. I thought that my time to follow him Knowing that he had for some time been trying to get a pension for wounds alleged to have been received in the war, I went boldly into his neighborhood and representing myself to be a pension agent called to see him. He soon became very much interested, so much so in fact that he laid his gun in the "rack," and turning to the corner, reached up to pull down a little smoky, dusty box which contained his letters. Turning to me he said "I'll show ——" But the sentence was never finished, I had him "covered" and told him to "hold up," which he did without a work. I landed Messer in jail the following day, where he has remained until his trial with the above result.

Charles Gillispie another of the Hatfield gang, who is indicted for the murder of Calvin McCoy and his sister Alaphare, was arrested by Cunningham and myself while in hiding with his uncle. He lay in the woods in daytime, and came in at night. We got "on to" him and lay for him one evening, and as he was riding in we stepped out, stopped his horse and handcuffed him. He is now awaiting trial at Pheville, Ky. He confesses he was with the gang when Calvin and Alaphare McCoy were murdered.

HATFIELD IN SPOKANE.

The people of Spokane Falls will perhaps be surprised to learn that Jonce Hatfield, one of the worst of the "gang," [has] been here, or near here, for more than a year past, going by the name of

James Jacobs, and associating with a special timber agent and a timber agent, both of whom knew him to be a murderer and a fugitive from justice.

When I learned that Jonce had left, and from information believed him to be here, I came at once to this place, and, finding no clue to his whereabouts, I went boldly to the timber agent and offered him a bribe for his information concerning the whereabouts of Hatfield. He didn't get insulted at my offer, but said he guessed Hatfield was in Gunnison, Colo., by that time, as he had started to that point some time before. But I found out some days later, instead of being in Colorado he had been cutting government timber on the Little Spokane river and selling it at Dart's mill. He was spirited away as soon as I was known to be here.

Some time after I met the special timber agent, and made him the same offer I had made his associate, except that I raised it 50 per cent. He gave me so much encouragement that I followed him to Yakima when he left, and on meeting him there, he said he was willing to set me right; that Hatfield had gone to Los Angeles, Cal., and my only show was to follow him there.

But I didn't think so, and keeping a weather-eye on him after he left me, I saw him go to the telegraph office. When he left, I had business there, and by a little "ruse" I found these telegrams were on file in the office:

C—— B——, Clealum, W. T.: Gibson is here; goes to Clealum to-night sure.

W. B——, Clealum, W. T.: Gibson is here; goes to Clealum to-night sure.

The B—— to whom the first message was sent was a man who, under another name, took up a claim on the Little Spokane river, cut the timber and then left with Hatfield, going to Clealum, where each took up a coal claim, Hatfield using the alias of James Henderson. William B—— is another coal claim jumper, and does just as the special directs.

I countermanded the telegrams and took the first train, arriving twelve hours later, only to find that Hatfield had that much the start of me in a box car, which I didn't learn until three days later.

Where he is now I am unable to say. He is somewhere among Washington's kind-hearted, indulgent people, just where we hope to tell you later. T. M. GIBSON.

See the clipping

Devil Anse tells his own story

The Wheeling Intelligencer introduces Devil Anse Hatfield's own story of the feud, ‘a plain recital by a plain man’, and judges that he is not as black as reporters have painted him. Printing extracts from it in March 1891, the paper said Anse gave the story while on trial at Charleston for violating the revenue laws; it traces the first trouble to a quarrel over a sow and pigs in 1873.

The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · Wheeling, W. Va.

The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · 23 November 1889 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

Devil Anse Hatfield's Story.

The Intelligencer publishes this morning "Devil Anse" Hatfield's own story of the famous Hatfield-McCoy feud. It is a plain recital by a plain man and is unembelished by the sensational features that have accompanied the numerous newspaper stories heretofore printed. It is probably the first true history of the feud that has been published, and will throw light upon much that has heretofore been mysterious. Whatever may be the character of the other participants in the feud, it is pretty clearly shown that "Devil Anse" is not as black as he has been painted by sensational newspaper reporters, and that the Hatfields are not alone responsible for the blood that has been shed.

See the clipping

Ellison Mounts on the gallows

The Weekly Courier-Journal of Louisville carries two dispatches. From Pikeville on 17 February 1890 it profiles Ellison Mounts, condemned for killing Allaphare McCoy, on the eve of the county's first hanging in perhaps forty years, and recalls his words at sentencing: ‘Judge, I was forced to go and do them crimes.’ From Louisa it reports him hanged the next day before a crowd put at four to eight thousand.

Weekly Courier-Journal · Louisville, Ky.

Weekly Courier-Journal · 24 February 1890 · page 8 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

DEATH BY LAW.

The Murder of Alla-phare McCoy To Be Expiated.

See moreSee less

A Dramatic Story of a Midnight Raid and the Slaughter of a De-fenseless Girl.

DEEDS OF MOUNTAIN BANDITTI.

ELLISON MOUNTS, ALIAS HATFIELD. (From a photograph taken in the jail.) Pikeville, Ky., Feb. 17.--(Special.)--This morning everything was as quiet in this little mountain city as could be expected, considering that on to-morrow will take place the first hanging that has occurred in this county for perhaps forty years.

To-morrow a procession consisting of the guard, officers and Ellison Mounts will leave the jail of Pike county for the scaffold, which has been erected about half a mile from the jail and court-house where Ellison Mounts will be executed for the murder of Miss Allaphare McCoy, on the night of January 1, 1888, at the humble home of her father, Randolph McCoy, on Blackberry creek, about thirty miles from this place.

The story of the crimes of the gang of which Ellison Mounts was a member would fill a volume. The atrocities of the aboriginal savage, with whom Boone and his contemporaries contended in these same mountains more than one hundred years ago, do not surpass the crimes of "Devil Anse" Hatfield and his gang. Frequently the public has been furnished with descriptions of the McCoy-Hatfield feud, and it is not necessary here to give a full detail of all the actions of this mountain banditti. It will suffice to give a brief history of the life and crimes of Ellison Mounts, who is on to-morrow, according to his statement, is going to change a state of sorrow and grief for one of unending joy in the Paradise of God.

On every afternoon for more than a week services have been held in the jail. Rev. J. W. Glover, pastor of the M. E. church, South, at this place, and who is also the jail physician, is standing nobly by the condemned man, and will accompany him to the scaffold and there will sing a song and offer prayer. The other services, consisting of the reading of a portion of the Scriptures and perhaps a short discourse by Dr. Glover, will be held at the jail. Mounts says he is prepared to die.

Mounts has been ill for several days. He refuses to talk to anyone about his case or his past history, although your correspondent has gained sufficient facts from reliable sources to warrant the following statement concerning his life and crimes:

A man about six feet, or perhaps an inch over in height, weighing when in health, perhaps 185 pounds; with very light hair and dull gray eyes. Such is Ellison Mounts as he appears to a casual observer. Nothing very striking in his appearance, is the first decision; but on closer inspection of features you will find the traits of a very fiend plainly discernable. A high, narrow forehead, prominent cheek-bones, broad, vulgar mouth, a nervous, twiching chin, all marks of a character bereft of the finer sensibilities.

Ellison Mounts is now about twenty-five years of age, and is the illegitimate son of the good Deacon Ellison Hatfield, who was the first victim of the feud proper, who was killed on August election day in 1882. Mounts' early boyhood was spent in the usual pursuits of a rude, unrully boy, in fishing, hunting, roving about the neighborhood and engaging with boon companions in Sabbath-breaking, petty pilfering, and all the multifarious pursuits known to the average ungoverned country boy. His father was a "Hard-shell" Baptist preacher. His training in "book-learning" was very limited. He can read, and write a little, which constitutes his stock of education. His education in vice seems to have been very thorough; and when at the age of seventeen he saw his father killed he was ripe for bloodshed. His first participation in murder was on the night following the death of Deacon Ellison Hatfield, his father, who died from the effects of the wounds received on August election day, 1882, at the hands of Talbot, Farmer and "Little Bud" McCoy. Immediately after the fight in which Deacon Hatfield received his wounds, the three McCoys were arrested—young Randolph McCoy, however, being taken for "Little Bud"—and, early the next morning, the guard with the prisoners started for Pikeville, a distance of about thirty miles. They had not proceeded very far, when they were intercepted by "Old Devil Ance" Hatfield, a brother of the wounded man, who relieved the guard—being accompanied by Ellison Mounts and about ten others—and took the McCoys back to West Virginia, to a place near where the wounded man had been carried. On Wednesday afternoon, Deacon Hatfield

CAPT. HATFIELD.

died, and, shortly after dusk, "Devil Ance," with his crowd, took the three McCoy boys across to the Kentucky side, tied them to paw-paw bushes and there, in the darkness of night, brutally murdered them. Mounts confesses that he was in the crowd, and assisted in the shooting.

The next murder in which Mounts participated occurred in June, 1884. It will be remembered that when the McCoy boys were murdered in 1882, Talbot McCoy was a man of some property, and married. Of course, an administrator must be appointed, and who so well-fitted to settle up the estate as his brother Calvin? In order to do this work it was necessary to bring some suits, and the cases were der were to be tried before a Justice of the Peace on the Tug river, near the scenes of the bloody massacree of 1882. The Hatfield gang, of which Ellison Mounts was still an active member, formed a plan to murder Randolph McCoy, the father of the murdered boys, and Calvin, the administrator, as they should return from the trial. By a mistake they fired on some innocent and unconcerned parties, slightly wounding one and seriously injuring the other.

The most heinous crime of the series, and the one for which Mounts is to hang, is the murdering in cold blood of a defenseless girl.

On New Year's night of 1888 there were at Randolph McCoy's house, besides himself and wife, his son Calvin and Rose Ann's little boy Melvin, all of whom were in the westerly end of the house. In the other end were Allaphare, Addie and Fanny McCoy, daughters of Randolph, and young women grown, besides little Cora, the orphan daughter of Talbot.

Shortly after midnight they were awakened by a gang of Hatfields, who called on old Rand'l' to surrender or they would burn his house over his head. The gang was headed by Uncle Jim Vance, who had hitherto kept out of the trouble and was got into it by a circumstance which illustrates the morals of these mountaineers very well. Uncle Jim's sister was the wife of Bad Anse.

With Vance were Cap Hatfield, Jonce Hatfield, Bob Hatfield, a younger son of Cap; Elliott Hatfield, son of Ellison; Ellison Mounts, French Ellis, Tom Gillespie and Tom Mitchell.

Gillespie and Elliott Hatfield were posted as sentinels up and down the road. The other seven attacked the house.

Old Rand'l' made no answer to the demand to surrender, and an effort was made to break in his door. The door was barred. Then the gang attacked the other end, where the girls were, and broke in their door, and jumped back lest a man should be inside and shoot out.

Allaphare, the oldest girl, went to the door and told them no man was in there.

"Stir a light," ordered Jim Vance, and Allaphare went to the fireplace and tried to build a fire. But the coal was out, and there was neither wood nor match to light a fire. Allaphare returned the men why she could make no fire. The men broke out in a tor- rent of profanity, and Cap Hatfield

ALLAPHARE M'COY. swore he would shoot her if she did not at once make a fire in the fireplace. She recognized his voice, and said, holding up her hands and bursting into tears: "Cap, I can't; I would, indeed, I would, if I could. You wouldn't shoot a woman who never did you any harm, would you?" "What the hell are you parleying with her for?" yelled Uncle Jim. "God—— her, make no more account of her than you would of a man. Shoot her, —— her." Cap raised his gun, but Ellison Mounts had his gun already at his shoulder, and shot the girl down as she stood there in her nightgown. The ball entered just over the left breast, and she fell back dead with only a moan.

JUDGE RICE. Then one of the gang, who had found a bag of cotton between the two houses, brought a handful of it, set it on fire and threw it into the room. By its light they could see that no man was concealed in the room, and they were, therefore, safe to put all their forces on the other end.

A part of them had already been engaged there. They had shot the southerly door to pieces, so that a determined rush would have broken it open, but a rush of that sort was what no Hatfield has the courage to make.

One of the gang, however, brought burning cotton and piled it against the door, but Mrs. McCoy had been churning the night before and had four gallons of buttermilk in churn. The old man took a tin cup and sitting down near the door dipped milk on the fire with one hand and held a revolver ready to shoot with the other.

Then they tried to fire the roof. Tom Mitchell climbed up the logs, and with one hand over the top log held a blazing torch against the clapboards. The old man saw the hand and, putting his revolver as close to it as possible, shot all four fingers off close to the knuckle. Cap tells gleefully to this day how Tom "cried like a baby over the loss of his fingers."

Calvin had not been idle all this time. He had mounted to the attic, and, kicking off the gable boards, and here and there a clapboard from the roof, had opened port holes through which he got several shots at the gang. One ball passed lengthwise through Ellison Mount's left forearm, soon after he had killed Allaphare, but it was from a thirty-two-caliber rifle, and did not make a permanent injury. However, Calvin drove the gang under the porch on the south side of his end of the building and between the buildings, and there they were secure. Calvin kicked off roof boards and strove to remove a part of the roof of the porch, but in vain. From their retreat under the porch the gang kept up a fire on the door, and, at the same time, kept applying torches to the house roof, while one or two others fired the roof successfully at the end where the girls were, and it began to get very warm for Calvin.

While the men were fighting, the old mother of the murdered girl had taken advantage of a lull in the shooting to slip out of the door facing the road to go around where the girls were. She had heard the other girls scream that Allaphare had been shot. As she went out the door Jonce Hatfield fired at a form on the bed, and the bullet cut the quilt over his own son. This story is told by the Hatfield crowd as one of the jokes of the feud. It would have been a good one on Jonce, Cap says, if he'd killed his own bastard.

CALVIN M'COY.

Mrs. McCoy started around to the door of the other part of the house. As she passed the space between the houses Jim Vance ordered her back with an oath and raised his gun with a threat to shoot her.

"I saw it was wrong end to for that," Mrs. McCoy said, when telling of it, "and kept on. But he struck me in the side with it and knocked me down. It broke two ribs. Pretty soon I got on my hands and knees. I felt so weak I couldn't get up, and so crawled on. Some one with a pistol got before me. 'For the Lord's sake, let me go to my girl,' I said. 'Go back, damn you, or I'll kill you,' he said. 'Oh,' I said, 'she's dead. For the love of the Lord, let me go to her,' and then I put out my hand. I could almost touch her feet as she lay there, and I could see her blood where it had run out of the door. Oh, my God! my God!"

In her grief in telling of the horrors of that night, the mother forgets what happened to herself as she put out her hand. The man who stopped her was Jonce Hatfield, and he struck her a blow with his revolver on the head that drove the hammer to the skull and left her senseless. They supposed she was dead.

It was not long after this before the fire drove Calvin from the attic. He said to the old man that he should strive to reach a corn crib about one hundred yards away across the yard to the northwest. From that point he could cover the retreat of of the old man, and both might then cross the fork and reach the woods. MR. AND MRS. RANDOLPH M'COY.

while they did not notice him. He With a box of cartridges in one hand and his rifle in the other Calvin leaped from the door and ran across the yard. As he cleared the corner of the house where the gang could see him they opened fire. It was a regular roar, and it roused the old man to action, and he followed. Calvin was by this time twenty-five yards away, in the shadow of some trees, and almost safe, but a bullet pierced his brain and he fell dead, unknown even to those who shot him.

The gang had spread out from their retreat at the west end of the house, where they had gone as Calvin came down the ladder, and as the old man sprang out he saw them before him, leveled a double-barreled shot gun at Jonce Hatfield and shot him in the right shoulder, and Jonce fell. Then he saw Tom Mitchell before him and fired. The shot pierced Tom's cartridge belt and entered the flesh of the abdomen, but the wounds, on account of the thickness of the belt, were of little account.

Then the firing at the old man began, and he ran the best he could and escaped untouched. He reached the corn crib, and from thence passed on up the mountain on the other side of the fork to JONCE HATFIELD AND HIS WIFE.

the woods. He was dressed in shirt and drawers only, and it was a very cold night. Had he not been lucky enough to find some hogs sleeping against some hay in an old barn on the next farm, he would probably have died from exposure. He routed the hogs out, and got into the bed they had left.

After the men left the house and the firing ceased the girls Addie and Fanny, finding the roof falling in, ventured to leave the house. They saw the gang just turning a point of the mountain on the road to Tug river. Then they picked up their dead sister, and, followed by the little orphan Cora, they dragged the body to the edge of the woods to the southwest of the house, and there built a fire and cowered down by it. Their mother had by this time revived enough to crawl after them as they drew the body of Allaphare away from the burning building. Little Melvin ran out at the time his grandfather did, and was clutching the old man's leg, but he tripped and fell at the door, and then crawled away around another corner of the house and was unnoticed. The women remained by the fire until morning without clothes or assistance.

On the morning of January 2, the family was cared for and sent to Pikeville. The old man and Jim and Sam came on ahead. The neighbors prepared Allaphare and Calvin for the grave, and buried them on the mountain side with their dead brothers. The graves are plainly seen from the road. They are surrounded by an old rail fence after the fashion of the country, and shaded by a peach tree that will not live to bear fruit another year.

The old farm is let to a tenant, and is rapidly going to ruin.

Such was the life of Ellison Mounts—that is, these were the capital crimes in which he participated before he was twenty-three years of age. Numerous minor crimes and misdemeanors he ha[s] been known to commit, and God only knowns the amount of sin and crime and wrong-doing he has engaged in that has never been brought to light.

A leading spirit in all these murders was Valentine Hatfield, a Justice of the Peace in Logan county, West Virginia, and a man of considerable local influence at the time the feud burst forth. He was a brother to Deacon Ellison Hatfield, who was the first victim of tho feud. At any time during the whole reign of terror he could have stopped the matter. But he was not built that way. He was director general of all the murders which the gang engaged in. When, in last September, he was sentenced to the penitentiary he informed the court that he "had been euchred out of his life and liberty."

The scene in the court when "Wall" Hatfield, Alex Messur, Doc and Plyant Mayhorn were sentenced to the penitentiary, was ridiculous and pitiful.. The Mayhorn boys merely maintained their innocence. "Wall" Hatfield censured the prosecuting attorneys, the witnesses, the jury and every influence. that aided in his conviction. When the court came' to that part of the sentence "confined at hard labor for the period of your natural life," in sentencing Alex Messur, he interrupted the Judge, saying: "It's mighty little work I can do, Judge, hain't bin able to work none of any 'count for several years."

When Ellison Mounts was brought into court, Judge Rice's countenance was most solemn. Judge Rice, it will be remembered, presided at the trial of, and passed sentence upon, Wm. Neal and Ellis Craft. of the Ashland horror. In sentencing Mounts his manner was very gentle, his language kind and his tones pitying; while the very spirit of compassion beamed from his countenance. More than once while pronouncing sentence did the Judge pause in order to regain control of his emotion. Outwardly Mounts was unmoved, and only said: "Judge, I was forced to go and do them crimes."

While W. H. Maynard is Sheriff of the county, the execution will be directed by Deputy Sheriff Harry Widdington, of Pikeville. At present everything points to a very orderly execution.

Louisa, Ky., Feb. 19.—(Special.)—Advice from Pikeville state that the execution of Ellis Mounts for the murder of vice Alafair McCoy was done according to law and without any interference from any source whatever.

For some days previous to the hanging the Sheriff had on duty a guard of fifty men, armed with Winchester rifles, in addition to about twenty special deputies appointed for the occasion. There was no particular reason to anticipate interference from Mounts' friends, but the Sheriff took the necessary caution to meet and repel any effort that might be made to prevent his execution.

From all accounts there was assembled the largest crowd that such an occasion ever brought together in the State, the throng of visitors being estimated by careful observers at from four to eight thousand.

About two miles from the Court-house, at the base of a low hill, the scaffold, from which Ellis Mounts was to take his last view of the sunlight, was erected. The great throng moved rapidly and soon covered the hill-top which afforded a magnificent view of the place where the last work was to be done.

A few moments after 12 o'clock the Sheriff appeared at the jail with the death warrant, which was read to the condemned man in a low, coarse voice, who seemed to listen to it without any apparent emotion. Religious services were conducted by the Rev. Dr. Glover, of the M. E. Church South.

The prisoner said, in a strong, firm voice, that he had no speech to make, but that he was ready to die, and he hoped that all of his friends would be good men and women, and meet him in heaven.

At six minutes to 1 o'clock the black cap was adjusted, the trap was sprung and the last of Ellis Mounts was dangling between heaven and earth, and was a sight that caused a shriek to go up from all parts of the crowd, which indicated that many were painfully affected.

After hanging ten minutes, the attending physician pronounced him dead, and the body was cut down and subsequently viewed by hundreds of curious people, and then turned over to his friends.

See the clipping

← Back to Act Three: Rights of States