As the Papers Told It

The Hatfields and the McCoys

As the Papers Told It

The Evening Bulletin, 9 January 1888Press and Daily Dakotaian, 2 February 1888The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer, 15 May 1888Turner County Herald, 19 August 1897

Original newspaper accounts, 1882–1901

August 1882 – December 190162 newspaper articles in the story, 2,890 in the full archive

In August 1882 Ellison Hatfield was killed in an election-day fight at a precinct in Pike County, Kentucky, and his friends took the three McCoys held for it from the officers, tied them to a tree and shot them. On New Year’s night 1888 the house of Randall McCoy was burned and two of his children were killed. A Kentucky posse crossed into West Virginia, killed old Jim Vance and carried West Virginians back to the Pike County jail, and the case of the kidnapped men went to the Supreme Court.

For the next thirteen years the papers reported the feud ended and begun again: a confession and a hanging, a truce and an amnesty, weddings between the families, Cap Hatfield reported dead and then captured, and in 1899 a son of Devil Anse shooting the deputy who had arrested his brother.

The numbers

2,890newspaper articles
3,029printings
529newspapers
49states and territories
233months in the papers

Each article is counted once, however many papers ran it. Printings counts every paper that ran it, so an article reprinted in five papers is one article and five printings.

How much the papers printed

Month of 1 August 1882: 28 printingsMonth of 1 November 1883: 4 printingsMonth of 1 March 1885: 2 printingsMonth of 1 October 1885: 1 printingMonth of 1 June 1887: 1 printingMonth of 1 August 1887: 2 printingsMonth of 1 January 1888: 168 printingsMonth of 1 February 1888: 184 printingsMonth of 1 March 1888: 9 printingsMonth of 1 April 1888: 10 printingsMonth of 1 May 1888: 17 printingsMonth of 1 June 1888: 15 printingsMonth of 1 July 1888: 14 printingsMonth of 1 August 1888: 40 printingsMonth of 1 September 1888: 41 printingsMonth of 1 October 1888: 18 printingsMonth of 1 November 1888: 32 printingsMonth of 1 December 1888: 17 printingsMonth of 1 January 1889: 54 printingsMonth of 1 February 1889: 2 printingsMonth of 1 March 1889: 1 printingMonth of 1 April 1889: 61 printingsMonth of 1 May 1889: 2 printingsMonth of 1 June 1889: 8 printingsMonth of 1 July 1889: 20 printingsMonth of 1 August 1889: 2 printingsMonth of 1 September 1889: 81 printingsMonth of 1 October 1889: 145 printingsMonth of 1 November 1889: 154 printingsMonth of 1 December 1889: 27 printingsMonth of 1 January 1890: 42 printingsMonth of 1 February 1890: 45 printingsMonth of 1 March 1890: 20 printingsMonth of 1 April 1890: 56 printingsMonth of 1 May 1890: 35 printingsMonth of 1 June 1890: 9 printingsMonth of 1 July 1890: 10 printingsMonth of 1 August 1890: 3 printingsMonth of 1 September 1890: 27 printingsMonth of 1 October 1890: 3 printingsMonth of 1 November 1890: 65 printingsMonth of 1 December 1890: 1 printingMonth of 1 January 1891: 24 printingsMonth of 1 February 1891: 9 printingsMonth of 1 March 1891: 102 printingsMonth of 1 April 1891: 40 printingsMonth of 1 May 1891: 23 printingsMonth of 1 June 1891: 10 printingsMonth of 1 July 1891: 10 printingsMonth of 1 August 1891: 11 printingsMonth of 1 September 1891: 2 printingsMonth of 1 October 1891: 2 printingsMonth of 1 November 1891: 5 printingsMonth of 1 January 1892: 4 printingsMonth of 1 February 1892: 14 printingsMonth of 1 March 1892: 4 printingsMonth of 1 April 1892: 27 printingsMonth of 1 May 1892: 3 printingsMonth of 1 June 1892: 1 printingMonth of 1 July 1892: 2 printingsMonth of 1 August 1892: 9 printingsMonth of 1 October 1892: 25 printingsMonth of 1 November 1892: 22 printingsMonth of 1 December 1892: 4 printingsMonth of 1 January 1893: 2 printingsMonth of 1 February 1893: 5 printingsMonth of 1 March 1893: 2 printingsMonth of 1 April 1893: 1 printingMonth of 1 June 1893: 1 printingMonth of 1 July 1893: 6 printingsMonth of 1 August 1893: 3 printingsMonth of 1 January 1894: 6 printingsMonth of 1 February 1894: 2 printingsMonth of 1 March 1894: 53 printingsMonth of 1 April 1894: 28 printingsMonth of 1 May 1894: 5 printingsMonth of 1 June 1894: 4 printingsMonth of 1 September 1894: 12 printingsMonth of 1 October 1894: 5 printingsMonth of 1 December 1894: 5 printingsMonth of 1 January 1895: 8 printingsMonth of 1 February 1895: 5 printingsMonth of 1 March 1895: 23 printingsMonth of 1 April 1895: 13 printingsMonth of 1 May 1895: 6 printingsMonth of 1 July 1895: 13 printingsMonth of 1 August 1895: 4 printingsMonth of 1 September 1895: 18 printingsMonth of 1 October 1895: 12 printingsMonth of 1 November 1895: 7 printingsMonth of 1 December 1895: 40 printingsMonth of 1 January 1896: 8 printingsMonth of 1 February 1896: 5 printingsMonth of 1 March 1896: 4 printingsMonth of 1 April 1896: 38 printingsMonth of 1 May 1896: 8 printingsMonth of 1 June 1896: 1 printingMonth of 1 September 1896: 1 printingMonth of 1 October 1896: 6 printingsMonth of 1 November 1896: 101 printingsMonth of 1 December 1896: 16 printingsMonth of 1 January 1897: 13 printingsMonth of 1 February 1897: 1 printingMonth of 1 March 1897: 3 printingsMonth of 1 April 1897: 24 printingsMonth of 1 May 1897: 11 printingsMonth of 1 June 1897: 8 printingsMonth of 1 July 1897: 7 printingsMonth of 1 August 1897: 63 printingsMonth of 1 September 1897: 13 printingsMonth of 1 October 1897: 21 printingsMonth of 1 November 1897: 11 printingsMonth of 1 December 1897: 4 printingsMonth of 1 January 1898: 8 printingsMonth of 1 February 1898: 9 printingsMonth of 1 March 1898: 1 printingMonth of 1 April 1898: 2 printingsMonth of 1 May 1898: 5 printingsMonth of 1 June 1898: 4 printingsMonth of 1 July 1898: 22 printingsMonth of 1 August 1898: 17 printingsMonth of 1 September 1898: 15 printingsMonth of 1 October 1898: 14 printingsMonth of 1 November 1898: 5 printingsMonth of 1 December 1898: 16 printingsMonth of 1 January 1899: 17 printingsMonth of 1 February 1899: 3 printingsMonth of 1 March 1899: 4 printingsMonth of 1 April 1899: 3 printingsMonth of 1 May 1899: 6 printingsMonth of 1 June 1899: 12 printingsMonth of 1 July 1899: 160 printingsMonth of 1 August 1899: 13 printingsMonth of 1 September 1899: 95 printingsMonth of 1 October 1899: 24 printingsMonth of 1 November 1899: 2 printingsMonth of 1 December 1899: 16 printingsMonth of 1 January 1900: 9 printingsMonth of 1 February 1900: 2 printingsMonth of 1 March 1900: 1 printingMonth of 1 May 1900: 1 printingMonth of 1 July 1900: 2 printingsMonth of 1 September 1900: 7 printingsMonth of 1 December 1900: 5 printingsMonth of 1 January 1901: 2 printingsMonth of 1 February 1901: 2 printingsMonth of 1 April 1901: 23 printingsMonth of 1 May 1901: 2 printingsMonth of 1 June 1901: 4 printingsMonth of 1 July 1901: 1 printingMonth of 1 September 1901: 2 printingsMonth of 1 October 1901: 2 printingsMonth of 1 November 1901: 1 printingMonth of 1 December 1901: 5 printings19 August 188230 August 18829 January 188819 January 188824 January 188826 January 188827 January 18881 February 18881 February 18882 February 188811 February 188818 February 188815 May 188815 June 188818 September 188820 September 18887 October 188831 December 18881 January 18898 April 188930 June 188918 July 188916 September 18898 October 188917 October 18893 November 18897 November 188923 November 188924 February 18903 April 189010 September 189013 November 189024 February 189123 March 18913 April 18912 June 18918 April 18927 October 189213 November 189219 July 189323 March 18947 June 189423 August 18955 November 189612 November 189622 November 189620 December 189612 April 189719 August 189727 July 189810 September 18984 December 189828 January 18994 July 189912 July 189912 September 189920 September 189922 October 18994 April 19016 April 190121 April 19013 December 190118821883188418851886188718881889189018911892189318941895189618971898189919001901184 printings in the month of 1 February 1888

Every printing of every article, by the month it ran. The marks under the line are the articles in the story below; red ones were wrong.

Where it was printed

FewerMore

Printings in 49 states. Most: West Virginia (582), Virginia (171), Kentucky (140). 105 printings could not be placed in a state.

How it unfolded

62 newspaper articles in 7 acts

Act One

Blackberry Precinct

19–30 August 1882

The first reports, in August 1882, told of an election-day killing in Pike County, Kentucky. Ellis Hatfield had died of wounds from knives and pistols in a fight with three McCoys at the Blackberry precinct, and before the McCoys could be tried some fifty of his friends took them from custody, tied them to a tree and shot them. None of the mob had been arrested, and the papers expected more bloodshed.

An election brawl, and three McCoys shot

The earliest notice here comes from a Michigan paper: at an election in Pike county, Ky., a Hatfield was fatally hurt, and his friends caught three McCoys, ‘tied them to a stake and shot them dead’. In 1889 Ellison Mounts, one of the party, confessed that the brothers were tied to a paw-paw bush and shot on the night of 9 August 1882.

Northern Tribune · Cheboygan, Mich.

Northern Tribune · 19 August 1882 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

At an election in Pike county, Ky., the other day, an affray occurred between the McCoy and Hatfield families, in which one of the latter was shot and otherwise injured so that he died. His friends united, caught three of the McCoys, tied them to a stake and shot them dead, and it is believed that more bloodshed will follow, as the families are numerous and revengeful.

See the clipping

Taken from custody and shot in the woods

A Parkersburg paper reprints the Kentucky Democrat's account: on election day at the Blackberry precinct, Ellis Hatfield was fatally cut and shot in a fight with Talbert, Randolph and Bud McCoy. About 50 of his friends took the arrested McCoys into the woods and ‘literally riddled their bodies with bullets’. Later reports name the Hatfield as Ellison and the dead McCoys as Tolbert, Farmer and Randolph.

West Virginia Freeman · Parkersburg, W. Va.

West Virginia Freeman · 30 August 1882 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

The Kentucky Democrat of last week says: "On election day a difficulty arose in the Blackberry precinct in Pike county, between Ellis Hatfield on one side and Talbert, Randolph and Bud McCoy on the other, in which Hatfield received wounds inflicted with knives and pistols, from which he died. The McCoys were arrested, and before an examination trial was had the friends of Hatfield, about 50 in number, took the prisoners from the custody of the law, carried them into the woods, tied them to to a tree and literally riddled their bodies with bullets.

See moreSee less

We are informed that the double murder has caused great excitement in that vicinity, and it is thought further bloodshed will follow. Our latest report says that none of the mob who killed the McCoys, have been arrested.

See the clipping

About these pages

Every clipping here was printed in an American newspaper at the time. The text on each card was read from the page by machine and lightly repaired; where it disagrees with the clipping, the clipping is right. Where the scan of an old page was too damaged to read, the text was transcribed again from the page image and is marked so; letters in [square brackets] were supplied where the printing itself is damaged, and the paper’s own misspellings are kept. The dates, papers, headlines and text are the papers’. The notes on why each article matters, and the one-line summaries, are ours.