As the Papers Told It

The Hatfields and the McCoys · As the Papers Told It

Act Two

Another Kentucky War

January – February 1888

On the night of 1 January 1888 Randall McCoy’s house was set on fire; his daughter and his son Calvin were killed and his wife was beaten. A Pike County posse went after the raiders, killed old Jim Vance and brought West Virginians back to the Pike County jail. the envoy West Virginia’s governor sent to Logan county called it kidnapping, the prisoners were taken to Louisville for a hearing in the federal court, and the papers took sides: Wheeling blamed Kentucky, and the New York World told the Hatfield story while the Herald told the McCoys’.

Five years later, the McCoy house burns

A Catlettsburg dispatch brings the first report here of the New Year raid: the Hatfields set fire to Randall McCoy's house and shot his daughter Alfara, his son Calvin and his wife as each came out. The mother in fact survived, and she and her husband soon told their story to the Pittsburg Times. Later accounts say the father's shot hit Johns Hatfield in the shoulder, not Cap.

The Evening Bulletin · Maysville, Ky.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 4 days later.

Wrong

The Evening Bulletin · 9 January 1888 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image

ANOTHER KENTUCKY WAR.

An Old Feud Which Results in a Series of Murders.

See moreSee less

CATLETTSBURG, Ky., Jan. 9.—A crime growing out of an old feud has been committed on the Blackburr fork of Pond creek in Pike county. The work is of the notorious Hatfield gang. Five years ago in an election row three McCoy brothers fatally stabbed a Hatfield. The latter's relatives caught the three McCoys, tied them to a tree and shot them to death. The war has been kept up since, and the latest chapter has just been heard from. A few nights ago the Hatfields set fire to the house of Randall McCoy. His eldest daughter, Alfara, was the first to open the door, and by the light of her burning home the innocent young girl was shot dead. Her brother Calvin and her mother followed, only to perish in the same way.

The desperate and desolate father, Randall McCoy, reckless of his own fate after this slaughter of his innocent ones, dashed from their funeral pyre into the midst of the murderous gang, unhurt by their volley of bullets, and partially avenged his wrongs by killing one of the gang named Chambers by a well directed bullet, and shot Cap Hatfield in the shoulder. The rest of the cowardly assassins fled. Rewards aggregating $2,700 are offered by the state of Kentucky for the arrest of the Hatfields, but they are fortified in the wilds of West Virginia, and no one cares to risk his life in pursuing them. Already the blood of Mr. McCoy's wife, a fair young daughter and three sons has paid the penalty for that one death five years ago. Who can blame the half-crazed man if his future desolate life shall be devoted to avenging them.

See the clipping

Six captured, and rifles in demand

A Catlettsburg dispatch of 14 January says McCoy's posse has lodged Will Hatfield and five others in the Pike county jail, and reports one more death, Jeff Mickels. Pikeville would not be surprised by a Hatfield attack, and Winchester rifles ‘command good prices’. By mid-June West Virginia's governor had offered rewards for the posse's leader, Frank Phillips, and a long list of Pike county men.

The Stark County Democrat · Canton, Ohio

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

The Stark County Democrat · 19 January 1888 · page 6 · transcribed from the page image

WINCHESTER RIFLES

In Great Demand, and Commanding a Premium,

See moreSee less

At the Scene of the Hatfield-McCoy Feud on the West Virginia Border in Kentucky ---General News.

CATLETTSBURG, Ky., Jan. 14.—[Special.]—The latest intelligence from the seat of the Hatfield-McCoy war, is to the effect that McCoy's posse captured Will Hatfield and five others in the raid other night and landed them safely in the Pike county jail. One more man was killed who has not been reported, Jeff Mickels. The excitement in that section county is intense and beggars description. Everybody is up in arms, and the scenes surpass those of the late war. There is little sleeping done in Pikeville now, as all is expectancy, and citizens would not be surprised anyhow, to see the Hatfields swoop down upon them, extricate their members and burn the town, to say nothing of the people they would kill. The Hatfields are known to be well organized. Winchester rifles are in great demand, and command good prices. Captain Hatfield was dangerously wounded in the last encounter, but managed to make his escape. The Hatfield party had been badly worsted in the last two engagements, the McCoy party and authorities escaping unhurt. Music from that quarter may be heard now at any time.

See the clipping

An early account blames Cap Hatfield

A Richmond Dispatch correspondent repeats what he heard near the scene: Cap Hatfield made the McCoy girl say his name, said ‘you will never know any one else’ and shot her, and Cap was later caught with his hand shot off. Later reports contradict both points. Ellison Mounts confessed to shooting her and was hanged for it, and Cap was not among the men held in Pike county.

Richmond Dispatch · Richmond, Va.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

Richmond Dispatch · 24 January 1888 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image

A TERRIBLE FEUD

ADDITIONAL PARTICULARS OF THE HATFIELD-McCOY AFFAIR.

See moreSee less

What a Dispatch Correspondent Learned—The Dead-Letter Crowd—Murder Trial

[Correspondence of the Richmond Dispatch.] LEBANON, VA., January 20, 1888.

I am just from the county of Buchanan and have seen and talked to a number of people who live near the place where the row between the Hatfields and McCoys took place, and the facts about the row are as follows: Hatfield, with his crowd went over to McCoy's, and they got all around the house and then set the house on fire and begun to halloo fire. When the McCoys waked up the house was in flames. Old man McCoy told his son that it was the Hatfields and advised him to run out of the front door and get behind the crib. The old man said he would go out at the back door and go to the stable and fire on the Hatfields from both points; that perhaps they might run them from the house. The old man made his escape, but the young man was shot and killed, and as the boy fell Mrs. McCoy attempted to make her escape and was shot. Captain Hatfield just at this time saw the old man running from the back of the house, and started through the house after him. When he entered the door Miss McCoy threw her arms around his neck and began to beg him not to shoot her father, and Hatfield said to her, "Do you know me?" and she said, "I do." He said to her, "What's my name?" and she said, "Captain Hatfield." He replied: "D—n you; you will never know any one else. He then put his pistol against her breast and shot her dead on the spot. There were two little children in the house, and Captain Hatfield took both of them in his arms and then took some covers off the bed and carried the children to a barn near by and put them in it and covered them up with the covers he got from the house. The children were the next day found, and had not been hurt. Mr. McCoy got a crowd of his neighbors and went after the Hatfield crowd. They caught them in a strip of woods near Yance Hatfield's house, where a regular battle took place. Three of Hatfield's crowd were killed—one of the Hatfields, a man named Vance, and one named Chambers. The civil officers caught two of the Hatfield crowd—Captain Hatfield and Thomas Chambers. Captain Hatfield had his hand shot off. Chambers and Hatfield are now in jail in Pike county, Ky., and it is rumored that the Hatfield gang will go down and take them out before the trial. He has a band of 151 men.

Near the Kentucky line, in Buchanan county, Va., a lot of outlaws have banded themselves together in the last week, and are now going around at night making men do whatever they want them to do by telling them if they refuse they will kill them. A few nights ago they went to a man's house by the name of Roy and carried with them a large bundle of withes. The crowd called Roy to the door and told him that Captain Hatfield expected to have come there that night and kill him and his family, but that they got him to let them come and get him to leave the county. And they told him they would give him thirty days to leave the county, and if he was not gone in that time they would kill him, if Captain Hatfield did not kill him sooner. This band goes by the name of the "Dead-Letter Crowd." It has just been organized, and has done nothing but make threats so far.

The trial of Mark Blankingship for the murder of his wife will begin this morning at Grundy, Va. His wife was sick in bed and he would not make her a fire or give her anything to eat. Dox.

See the clipping

A second massacre, reported from Parkersburg

A Parkersburg dispatch reports that the Hatfield gang raided the Wyoming County home of Simon McCoy, said to be a brother of the McCoy whose family had just been attacked, tied his wife to a tree and shot her, killed their young son, and fired on McCoy as he died in his burning house. It says the family ‘had no connection with the feud’. No later report gathered here mentions this attack.

Barton County Democrat · Great Bend, Kan.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

Barton County Democrat · 26 January 1888 · page 7 · transcribed from the page image

BRUTAL OUTRAGES. Another Shameful Chapter in the Hatfield-McCoy Troubles in West Virginia. An Inoffensive Woman Tied to a Tree and Riddled With Bullets—Her Husband Burned. Indiana Whitecaps Again Commit Outrages—Fatal Eviction Proceedings in California. PARKERSBURG, W. Va., Jan. 21.—Information reached here to-day of another outbreak in the Hatfield-McCoy troubles. Simon McCoy, a brother of the one whose family was murdered a few days ago, lives in Wyoming County. The Hatfield gang made a raid on his home and overpowered him and took Mrs. McCoy and her son, a mere boy, out to the woods.

See moreSee less

The woman was fastened to a tree by a member of tho party, the remainder staying at the McCoy house to prevent the escape of the others. After firing at their human target for a time the leader grew tired of mere sport, and gave the order for her to be killed. All the rifles were raised at once, and the poor woman's body was riddled with bullets. The boy who was taken out with her was also dispatched in a summary manner. By this time the other party had surrounded the McCoy house, having, in the meantime, placed various kinds of combustible material around it. It was concluded to fire the building and give McCoy a chance for his life, if he could run the gauntlet of their bullets. They expected he would leave the house as soon as it began to burn. In this they were disappointed. As soon as the flames shot up McCoy poked his head out of an upstairs window and begged for his life. He was answered with a volley of bullets and made no attempt to escape, but perished in the flames. The house was totally destroyed, and in the ruins was found his charred body. It is said two small children also were b[u]rned, but this is not confirmed. This family of the McCoys had no connection with the feud, and the attack upon them was unwarranted. The people are demanding that something be done by the Governor.

See the clipping

Wheeling says the blame lies in Kentucky

A Wheeling editorial insists the feud is no specimen of West Virginia lawlessness and belongs to Kentucky, citing a former Logan county man who calls the Kentucky desperadoes ‘the aggressors and barbarians’. In April 1889 the same paper printed Ellison Mounts' confession, which describes Hatfield parties crossing from West Virginia to kill in Kentucky, and false alibis sworn after the house burning and sent to Governor Wilson.

The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · Wheeling, W. Va.

The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · 27 January 1888 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

As APPEARS in another column of this morning's INTELLIGENCER, the Hatfield-McCoy feud is not a specimen of West Virginia lawlessness, but should properly be accredited to Kentucky. A very reliable gentleman, who was a citizen of Logan county, avers that Kentucky desperadoes are "the aggressors and barbarians," the sensational dispatches from unknown correspondents to the contrary notwithstanding.

See the clipping

West Virginia's envoy clears the Hatfields

Col. W. L. Mahone, sent by Governor Wilson to Logan county, reports that he found the Hatfields ‘good law-abiding citizens’ and blames Pike county men who, with no requisition, seized eight West Virginians and jailed them in Kentucky. Ellison Mounts later confessed that the New Year raiders had sworn false alibis before a justice so that Wilson would not honor Kentucky's requisition.

The Morning News · Savannah, Ga.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

The Morning News · 1 February 1888 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

CAUSE OF THE VENDETTA.

Col. Mahone Submits his Report to Gov. Wilson.

See moreSee less

CHARLESTON, W. VA., Jan. 31.—Col. W. L. Mahone, the emissary whom Gov. Wilson sent to Logan county a week ago to inquire into and report upon the now famous Hatfield-McCoy vendetta, made his report to Gov. Wilson to-day and it is as follows: "I visited all the Hatfields and found them to be good law-abiding citizens, who have the respect and confidence of every one in the neighborhood. While many depredations have been committed, and the whole surrounding country has been in a state of excitement and tumult bordering on a genuine young war, peace has again been restored, and the belligerent parties on both sides have disbanded, and no further trouble is anticipated. The strangest part of the whole affair is that that Hatfields and McCoys are related.

CAUSE OF THE OUTBREAK.

"The recent outbreak seems to have been caused by parties in Pike county, Kentucky, resurrecting old indictments against the Hatfields, which were found against them five years ago. The Pike county parties went to Frankfort, Ky., and had rewards offered for the Hatfields and came into West Virginia, under the guise of officers of the law, when in reality they had no requisition, and arrested (or rather kidnaped) Thomas Chambers, Andrew Varney, Shelkirk McCoy, D. D. McCoy, Moses Christian, Pliant Mahon, D. D. Mahon and Valentine Hatfield and took them over to Kentucky and placed them in jail, where they are still confined.

COLD-BLOODED MURDER.

"This party, headed by Frank Phillips, fired on and killed old man Vance, without as much as calling on him to surrender, and are the same parties who came over into this State and fired upon Constable Thompson and his posse, at which time Dolphy and another man were killed. Citizens of Logan county state that had any parties other than those sent been called upon to make the arrest no blood would have been shed, but the McCoys who came with Phillips to make the arrest, had sworn to kill the Hatfields and would have done so after they were disarmed. Peace has been temporarily declared, but it is feared by the law-abiding citizens of the two counties that hostilities will be renewed before a great while. The trouble began during the war. The Hatfields were in the Confederate army and the McCoys in the Union army."

See the clipping

West Virginia wants its men back

A Wheeling paper expects Governor Wilson to demand the release of the ‘nine West Virginians kidnapped by the McCoy gang’ and dates the feud from the war, Hatfields Confederate and McCoys Union. Devil Anse Hatfield's own story, as later printed in Wheeling, puts the first trouble in 1873, over a sow and pigs. Wilson pressed the case and lost in the Supreme Court in May 1888.

Wheeling Register · Wheeling, W. Va.

Wheeling Register · 1 February 1888 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

Gov. Wilson will probably demand the release of the nine West Virginians kidnapped by the McCoy gang and now in the Pike county, Ky., jail. This Hatfield-McCoy trouble dates from the war, in which the Hatfields fought on the Confederate side and the McCoy's on the Union. The parties, it is said, are related.

See the clipping

The McCoy side, told in Pittsburg

The Pittsburg Times prints the McCoy side, gathered by Charles Howell mainly from Randall McCoy and his wife: four sons and a daughter dead, the house burned, the family ‘well-nigh penniless’. It counts thirteen raiders on 1 January 1888, where Ellison Mounts later said nine, and sets the election stabbing a year after an 1871 arrest, though it says the outrages had run ‘for six years’.

Press and Daily Dakotaian · Yankton, S.D. · and 1 other paper

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

Press and Daily Dakotaian · 2 February 1888 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

LIE IN BLOODY GRAVES

DISCOUNTING ALL FICTION

THE ORIGIN AND GROWTH OF THE HATFIELD-M'COY FEUD.

See moreSee less

Dime Novel Tales of Blood Are Fairy Stories in Comparison With the History of the Fiendish Murders on the Kentucky-West Virginia Border.

PITTSBURG, Pa., Feb. 1.—The Times prints in detail the first true statement published of the famous Hatfield-McCoy outrages that have been for six years continued, without serious attempt being made to punish the outlaws. The story from start to finish is a tale of horrors rarely equaled, and has caused a blot on the names of the two great states of Kentucky and West Virginia. Charles Howell, of the Times' editorial staff, returning from a personal investigation, reports to his paper that the Hatfield-McCoy trouble threatens to develop into serious inter-state complications. Although Governors Buckner, of Kentucky, and Wilson, of West Virginia, have ordered their militia to return to their homes, it must not be understood that the troubles are ended. The Hatfield-McCoy war, divested of all sentiment with which the representatives of the two states have invested it, is simply

A SUCCESSION OF COWARDLY MURDERS

by day and assassination and house-burning by night. All of the murders have been cruel, heartless and almost without the shadow of provocation. Given on one hand the family with its contingents of the same blood, allied and comented by a common desire to avenge an imaginary affront, and on the other a family, small in the matters of alliance and collateral sympathies, doomed to destruction by the larger, and the case is stated. The scene of nearly all of the murders and assassinations of the years named is the narrow bottom of Tug river, above and below the mouth of Pond creek, on the Kentucky side. Randall McCoy, with wife and thirteen children, six years ago lived in a log hut near the mouth of Pond creek. To-day his house is in ashes. Four of his sons and one daughter

LIE IN BLOODY GRAVES, and himself and family are wandering in the mountains, well-nigh penniless. In 1871 a warrant was issued for the arrest of Johnson Hatfield, a son of Anderson, who eluded the officials for several months. Talbot McCoy was deputized to serve the warrant. McCoy captured Hatfield and started with him for Pike court house, twenty miles distant. McCoy's two brothers acted as guards. A friend apprised the Hatfields of the arrest, and the elder Hatfield, accompanied by his allies, intercepted the McCoys, and rescued his son at the point of the gun, and returned to West Virginia. A year later, at an election in Kentucky, Elias and Ellison Hatfield engaged in a quarrel with Talbot McCoy, over an alleged debt, during which McCoy stabbed Ellison Hatfield in the back. Hatfield began pounding McCoy's head with a stone, whereupon McCoy's younger brother

STABBED AND SHOT HATFIELD, inflicting fatal wounds. All the parties were arrested. Thirty of Hatfield's friends promptly assembled and a compact was made to release the prisoner, which was done. They took the three McCoys with them, keeping them prisoners two days and a night, pending the result of Ellison Hatfield's injuries. They refused to allow a justice to give the McCoys a hearing, saying they would take care of both trial and punishment. The McCoys—father, mother, brothers and sisters, appeared on the scene and begged for the lives of the three boys, but were told to leave or they would be killed, too. That night Farmer and Talbot McCoy were taken into the timber and shot. Randall was tied to the dead bodies of his brothers, and the party started home. Once Hatfield said: "Boys, dead men tell no tales," and stepping near the boy, discharged both barrels of his shotgun into his head, bursting it open. The bodies remained tied to the bushes for hours, their friends fearing to remove them.

AN ABSOLUTE MONARCHY.

No concentrated effort was ever made to capture the perpetrators of the crime. Anderson Hatfield, Sr., styling himself "Devilance," purchased fire arms in large quantities, and organizing an absolute monarchy, himself taking command. Comparative quiet reigned for another year, when by mistake for Randall McCoy and one of his sons, John and Henderson Scott were waylaid and permanently crippled by a volley from the Hatfield Winchesters. Following this mistake came a period of "stock raising" by the Hatfield gang. About one year ago Jeff McCoy, cousin of the murdered man, was waylaid and shot by "Cap" Hatfield and Zim Wallace. The history of this crime has more elements of hellish fiendishness, if possible, than the first. The shots were fired while the victim's aged mother, grovelling at their feet, her arms entwined about their limbs,

SHRIEKED FOR PITY.

Spurning her with their boots, the fatal shots were fired. The old lady waded the stream to where her son lay dead, and fell in anguish upon his body. Jeff McCoy's father had, some years previously, been assassinated by the Hatfields within a few yards of where his son fell. Perry A. Cline, uncle of Jeff, an attorney, secured requisitions for the arrest of the band. At an election in August last, Louis Varney was beaten almost to death by "Cap" Hatfield. The Hatfields took possession of the polls and broke up the election. The crowning piece of deviltry was reserved for the night of Jan. 1, 1888, when thirteen of the Hatfield gang, headed by Jas. Vance, surrounded the Paul McCoy homestead, near the mouth of Pond creek, burned the house, with its contents,

KILLED HIS SON AND DAUGHTER, beat the mother over the head with the butt of a gun until they thought she was dead, and left the little children to die in the cold on the mountain side, among the bushes to which they had escaped in their night clothes. While the house was burning the father and husband fired two shots with telling effect. Three new-made graves are to be found on the Hatfield settlement, and a number are known to be wounded. After burying his dead, McCoy moved his family to Pike court house last week.

The story was obtained principally from Mr and Mrs McCoy, who show unmistakeable evidence of the intensity of their sufferings, and is fully corroborated by others. No one knows why the fiendish malignity should have been kept up. But once McCoy has attempted to retaliate, and that a few days ago. Even now no feeling of resentment is manifested. He spoke like a man who is bent and almost broken by the weight of his afflictions.

The killing of Callen and Alfred, on Jan. 1, became known the next day at the county court house. Measures were taken at once to capture, or kill, a portion of the Hatfield gang. Twenty or thirty men, under Deputy Sheriff Trask Phillips, crossed the Tug near Pond creek, in Pike county, Ky., on Jan. 6. When within thirty yards of the house, Mrs. Vance hailed Phillips with: "Who are you, and where are you going?"

"Who are you and where are you going?" was his rejoinder.

"I think they are after you, Pap," she shrieked, and a moment later old Vance arose from his concealment, thirty or forty yards behind her. During the shooting which followed Vance was killed. On the night of January 9, Phillips and posse arrested Valentine Hatfield, three Mayhorn brothers, Tom Chambers, Andrew Yancy, Selkirk McCoy and Moses Christian. Others of the Hatfields were captured in McDonald county, W. Va., about the same time and landed in Pike jail.

See the clipping

A Florida editor calls for troops

A Florida editorial says ‘the war has never been over’ on the Tug Fork, notes that the New York World told the Hatfield side and the Herald the McCoy side, and calls for federal troops and ‘wholesale hanging’. It grants that in law the seized West Virginians are held without right. In May 1888 the Supreme Court called the seizure lawless but let Kentucky keep them.

The Palatka Daily News · Palatka, Fla.

The Palatka Daily News · 11 February 1888 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

ANARCHY ON THE BIG SANDY.

It seems hardly credible that the scenes of centuries ago, the border forays with all the attendant scenes of murder and cruelty are repeated in our days within the borders of the United States. Yet the mountain country through which the line betweed West Virginia and Kentucky runs is the seat of a most destructive warfare of families. These sanguinary feuds began during the war. In fact the war has never been over on Tug Fork of Big Sandy. There have been enough men, women and children murdered in the feud between the Hatfields and the McCoys to have extinguished two ordinary families. But the cabin of the mountaineer swarms with children generally and ail the members of these fami ies know how to shoot, from the stripling to the old grandfather, or grandmother, for that matter. Sex makes but little shade of difference in character among these rude mountaineers.

See moreSee less

The attention of the outside world is occasionally called to these murders by a deed of unusual ferocity, as when three of the McCoy boys, one only fourteen years old, were caught by a gang of Hatfields, tied to bushes and tied hand to hand, then shot down in cold blood the child being killed last of all. Another atrocious deed was committed a short time ago. A raid was made at midnight upon a family of the McCoys by a party of the Hatfields and a young girl, and a young man were shot dead while an old woman was brained by the light of their burning home, and another girl went crazy by the corpse of her brother.

Reporters of various Western and Eastern papers have taken their lives in their hands at various times and gone into these mountain wilds to get at the truth of these stories, to separate truth from rumor. They have had to face visible, tangible danger to do so. Their reports agree in one thing—that there is a condition of affairs in those mountains which are a shame to American civilization. Lying between such States as West Virginia and Kentucky, near Pennsylvania and Ohio, this state of anarchy, where the officers of law belong to either one gang or the other and justice is laughed at, the scenes of barbarity described in these correspondents' letters are set within the very heart of our long settled territory, not in Alaska or the wilds of the Rockies.

The New York World and the New York Herald each devoted about a page of their recent issues to the Hatfield-McCoy feud and describe graphically, not only the bloody battles and massacres, but also the disorganized state of society in the upper regions of the Big Sandy valley. Curiously enough, the two stories form "pendants" to each other. The New York World correspondent has the Hatfield side of the story, the Herald man has the McCoy side.

As travel through the region is entirely suspended by the decree of the murderous gangs, as the United States mails have been interfered with and Kentucky county authorities have made several raids into West Virginia territory to capture members of the Hatfield gang, it is possible that the National government will be called upon to restore order. The Kentucky State authorities have often called out the militia to suppress these bloody murderers. Quiet reigns until the militia returns home, then the war breaks out again. It may be said, in passing, that no State has had more use for its militia during the last ten or twelve years than Kentucky. It might also be remarked that these troublesome mountaineers of Western and Southwestern Kentucky are Republicans by a large majority.

West Virginia has done little to suppress this warfare. The present Governor of that State has done nothing, except to endeavor to procure the custody of the prisoners captured by the authorities of Pike County, Ky. If he intends that these gory-handed Hatfields shall be released after a mockery of a trial he is preparing a lasting disgrace for his State. But as a matter of law he is right—the prisoners made in these raids into West Virginia are held without a shadow of right.

The only hope for the wiping out of this disgrace to America is that the Governors of the two States of Kentucky and West Virginia shall agree to declare themselves unable to put down this insurrection against all law and humanity itself and call for United States troops or that the National authorities shall take measures to protect the mails. Even then there is little hope of a permanent peace until drastic measures are taken. It will require wholesale hanging and the incarceration for life of every one connected with these murders, either as principals or abettors—and that means the conviction of a hundred or two of men and some women.

Nor is the task of capturing these mountaineers, desperate men acquainted with all the fastnesses of the mountains, a small task. The Big Sandy country is exceedingly broken and the movements of even small bodies of troops difficult there. When Mr. McCreary, now in Congress, was Governor of Kentucky, he sent several companies of militia into Breathitt County to suppress the vendetta there. The mountaineers played hide-and-seek with the young men from the cities when sent out in squads to serve warrants on the ringleaders and sent them word of the many occasions on which they might have picked off the unexperienced citizen soldiery. But when they heard that the Governor was organizing companies in the adjacent peaceable counties they came in and surrendered. They knew their chances were only equal with men who were acquainted with the mountains. Nothing will remove this disgrace but the most thorough measures which result in the punishment of every guilty man.

See the clipping

Valentine Hatfield talks in Louisville jail

The nine West Virginians reach the Louisville jail for a federal hearing on Governor Wilson's habeas corpus plea. Valentine Hatfield, called the old man of the gang, says he knew nothing of the New Year raid until afterward; Pike's county attorney calls the men part of the gang. Ellison Mounts later confessed that Valentine, known as Wall, swore the 1882 killers to secrecy, and Wall was sentenced to life.

The Memphis Appeal · Memphis, Tenn.

The Memphis Appeal · 18 February 1888 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

HATFIELD-M'COY FEUD.

THE VIRGINIA CONTINGENT IN THE LOUISVILLE JAIL.

See moreSee less

Old Man Valentine Hatfield Tells a Straightforward Story About the Bloody War that Waged Between the Families.

LOUISVILLE, Ky., Feb. 17.—The nine West Virginians known as the "Hatfields" arrived here last night in charge of a deputy United States marshal and the jailer of Pike county. They will appear before Judge Barr, of the United States district court, Monday, when the habeas corpus application of the Governor of West Virginia will be further heard. Valentine Hatfield, the "old man" of the gang, after stating that they had been well treated while in the Pike county jail, gave the following account of the celebrated feud:

"The whole trouble, so far as I know, began about six or eight years ago. I had five brothers—Ellison, Elias, Anderson, Smith and Patterson. Ellison was the first one killed. Three of the McCoy boys shot and cut him on Blackberry creek, on the Kentucky side, and he died the next day. The trouble, I believe, was started by one of the McCoys attempting to arrest Anderson Hatfield's son Johnson, about eight years ago. There was a row, but I don't remember exactly what it was. After Ellison Hatfield was killed, Talbert, Richard and Farmer McCoy, all young men, were killed by a crowd supposed to have come from West Virginia. The killing was done on the bridge between Blackberry and Mates creeks.

"The next Pike county grand jury indicted a lot of people in West Virginia. No one was arrested, however, and after that Jeff McCoy, who is Bill Daniel's brother-in-law, heard Daniels and Tom Wallace abusing the Hatfields, and a quarrel followed. McCoy attempted to arrest Wallace, and a fight took place. This resulted in Capt. Hatfield arresting McCoy, and when McCoy tried to get away he was killed by the men who were guarding him. Some time after this a squad of men went to Randolph McCoy's house and killed one of his sons and a daughter, and beat up his old woman. This was charged to the Hatfields, but I never knew anything about it until some time after the murders were committed.

"A short time after this, a company of Pike county men was formed to follow the Hatfields and kill them. They came into West Virginia and found Jim, Vance and Capt. Hatfield on a bridge near Thacker's creek. They shot Vance to death and wounded Capt. Hatfield. After that the Kentuckians came in and captured us while we were at work on our farms. None of us resisted and no injury was done us, but if there there was any authority for confining us in jail, I never heard of it."

County Attorney J. Lee, Ferguson, of Pike, was questioned concerning the claim of the prisoners that they were innocent. He laughed at the idea, and said that while the worst of the Hatfield crowd had not been captured, the men who are now in the Louisville jail are undoubtedly a part of the gang. He declared that the prisoners had not been unlawfully imprisoned, but after having crossed the border line between West Virginia and Kentucky, had been legally arrested and taken to jail by the proper officers. He did not deny that the West Virginians had been forcibly taken from their homes, but held that the Kentuckians were justified by the dangers threatening them in taking the matter into their own hands when the West Virginia authorities refused to assist in restraining and punishing the outlaws, who had only to cross a narrow stream to commit the most atrocious crimes and then cross back again to safety from the law. Mr. Ferguson asserted positively that he had creditable information that a State official of West Virginia had been retained with a fee of $500 to prevent Gov. Wilson from recognizing the requisition issued by Gov. Buckner. He charged also that the Hatfield crew had brought other influences to bear, and that the worst of the gang were now in comparative security.

Of the prisoners now in the Louisville jail, Mr. Ferguson says that Valentine Hatfield recently confessed to him that he had five living wives and thirty-three living children. Nine of his children have died. Mr. Ferguson states that Hatfield has peculiar ideas of polygamy and does not marry his wife according to law, but takes them and apportions his time out between them.

See the clipping

← Back to Act One: Blackberry Precinct