Col. W. E. Mahan, sent by Governor Wilson to investigate the Hatfield-McCoy conflict, reported that the Hatfields are law-abiding citizens and that peace has been restored with both sides disbanded. His report also describes Kentucky men illegally entering West Virginia under false pretense of law to kidnap several men including Selkirk McCoy and Valentine Hatfield, and references a raid in which women and children were driven from their homes.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Waterbury Evening Democrat · 1 February 1888 · page 1
A FAMOUS FEUD FINISHED. THE OFFICIAL REPORT PRESENTED TO GOVERNOR WILSON.
Transcript to come.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
Waterbury Evening Democrat · Waterbury, Conn.
The report describes Kentucky-based posses, led by Frank Phillips and John Kite, raiding West Virginia to kidnap several Hatfield allies and kin, driving women and children before them, and killing James (Jim) Vance after Randal McCoy allegedly fired first. It also notes the broader context of resurrected indictments, rewards offered by Kentucky's governor, and growing alarm that lawless men are exploiting the feud for license to terrorize the region.
Waterbury Evening Democrat · 1 February 1888 · page 1
Entered at the Post Office for Transmission in the Mails at Second-Class Kates. Another Tnseott suspect has been ar rested. This timo he was in Berthold, fifty miles from Denver. Col., and was passing himself oiT for a young lady, wearing dresses and " mashing" the men generally. A party of lynchers burrounded the Lincoln county (W. Va.) jail last Fri day night, forced an entrance, and took two of the McCoy gang out and hanged them. Until the other members of the gang are dealt with in a like manner the McCoy-Hatfield feud, with its frequent outbreaks, will be the terror of that por tion of the country.
Clipping to come
Evening Star · Washington, D.C.
Col. W. L. Mahon reports to Gov. Wilson after investigating the Hatfield-McCoy vendetta in Logan County, calling the Hatfields law-abiding citizens and blaming Kentucky parties for illegally seizing several men under false pretenses. He states peace has been restored and no further trouble is anticipated, while also noting Frank Phillips's party had killed old man Vance and fired on a West Virginia constable's posse.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Evening Star · 1 February 1888 · page 4
A REPORT TO GOV. WILSON, OF WEST VIRGINIA.
WHO AN1> WHKRK I i THE " J AT FIKLD-M’UOY” FAKIR# For the pot three days the newspapers of the country have contained the most blood-chilling recita’- of the progress of the “Hatfield MeCcy war,” all bearing the stamp of falsehood on their face. The agent of the Associated Press at Chicago bee been deceived by the ingenuity with which the ”f»kn” has gotten them up, and in goed 'a th has stepped them over the ciicnit, witu the prefree, “A spscial from Milton, W. Vs., says.” It «• sel dom.
See moreSee less
indeed, tfcat the tg-nts of the Asso ciated Press, who are usually tre moet re sponsible journalists to be found, are de ceived by tbe.-a “fakir-,” but in such a case this, \v i.re the 1 tike is so inge niously coca!ruekd, and the eg*nt several handr*d miles from the ecene and nnac quaint 1 with the matter and ti e country, tbe (act of thedecep'ion is not -nrpribicg. To s'.art with, tho trouble in Lincoln conaiv has no connection ••hafevtr nitb the H \TKIEI.D XL COY affair, which isoon fined ;o Logan coouty, W. Va., and P e county. Ky., where tlrogsbave beeuqniet for over six months. The telegraph effio nearh ihe scene cf the alleged trouble ;s at llantirg'on, where the Reoisteb baf at a ion. d an alert nd teli ibis corres ponded, who ha* the best facilities in that neighborhood tor getting fhe nows, and has kept ns fatly informed of ill ,he facts in the Lincoln county affair. The Milton stories that have been foiled upon the Chicago agent cf *he Asset* ated Press do nut contain ooe iota cf tru b, as mrv be -eeu from the Register 9 spe* cial dispatch from Huntington, in •Bother column, which is authoritative. The latest production of tnis most accom plished newspaper * fakir,” is the follow ing * do .d-tnrdlin * tale, which was sent ont yesterday: Report' -f another bettV between tre Hat hc.ds a- .1 MeCovs have reached here La.'t utgiU a party of about thirty of the Me ( )i« came »n** a Brumfield camp in the woods, a I in cs fm . <ireen Shoal*. Both bauds were bound for the beadqUart-rs of thetr rv*peet ve factio as and were hea\ If armed. When the McCoy*discovod their euemits they seut out scouts and learued that there were al<out a wore In the camp Th?v crawled up through the dense uudort rush and pjurvd in h volley on their sleeping foe*. In an instant it was return"’. an>l the Hatfie!<ls. although takou I t surprise, were »0 tnueh better anted than the McCoys, havi.u repeating ritUs, that they soou put lliem to i ght The oue roller ' red b> the McCoys did tern b’.eexecution. Hall ado. omen werewounded and two were slain. Johu Brumfied. one of the leaders of thl' faction, was instantly killed. l!y his »ido lay K.dwtn Brown, the son of the woman who was shot in her term house at Fudge's creek. Two bullets lud gone through his body, cne pietc.ng the heart. By the way, this L» the third time that poor John Bbcmitki.d has been killed, and aleo the second member of the Brows family to meet a violent death at the hands of' this mercilese and bloody journalist. Tbe “fake” contirmee in the same cheerful vein: - \ other men were wruiuied, one of them, u*-i.se name iunknown, being fatally hurt. \ u r Jawu the HaiMl-1.1* bund two more dead men and four wouudtd men were captured. Some of the wounded Mc<' ys mutt have been carried o!' by their friends, for the trail of their feat through the wood' was marked by blood BtAi IIS. The prisoners oaptuu IwenOmM Ltaiwnn. !ohu Cain,-Cain and Pete McCoy. Ir.e names of the dead are unknown. The < am uhose first name was not learned was so badly Wfumled that his cupt‘»rs l€ft him to (lie wliens .ay, t.u-the other three were eompelled to march to the Hatfield 1 uarterAs soon as the 1 £> story of the attack and eanture was told a sort or 75 court martial was held. The pri,oners wire not allowed to sjamk in their own dtfc-nse.and, after 15 u snort lelti etaiion, a vote on their life or dtath 15 was taken by the entire Hattield party. The re sult was unauimou*. and the three men will be tied to trees and shot Joforc sundown this even ing. Nothin* can save them unlesthe Met oys -tu defeat the entire Hatfield party and ettecc a n vvue. Tb s is not likely, as tbev are outnum bered two to one and the Hatfields are better “The courier who b*onght this news was shot at twi-e from ambush while riding through I.in colti county. Now the questions are, who is this liar, and where is he locates? e do not be lieve he resides in this State, altbongn West Virginia is Hllicted with some very expert fakirs in this line. This bloody minded genius probibly resides in Cincin nati, and, posseting some knowledge of the Hatfield-McCoy matter, which he has confused wi‘h the Lincoln county foss, and the difficulties in the way of obtain ing new s, has resolved to make bis for tune by working h:s imagination and sail ing the result to the newspapers. The individual probably does not stop to consider the fact that he is obtaining money under fal»e preterses.
Col. W. H. Mahone reports to Gov. Wilson on his investigation into the Hatfield-McCoy feud, declaring the Hatfields law-abiding citizens victimized by a Kentucky posse led by Frank Phillips who illegally seized men and killed old man Vance without warning. He attributes the outbreak to Pike County parties reviving old indictments and acting without proper legal authority in West Virginia.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Morning News · 1 February 1888 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
CAUSE OF THE VENDETTA.
Col. Mahone Submits his Report to Gov. Wilson.
See moreSee less
CHARLESTON, W. VA., Jan. 31.—Col. W. L. Mahone, the emissary whom Gov. Wilson sent to Logan county a week ago to inquire into and report upon the now famous Hatfield-McCoy vendetta, made his report to Gov. Wilson to-day and it is as follows: "I visited all the Hatfields and found them to be good law-abiding citizens, who have the respect and confidence of every one in the neighborhood. While many depredations have been committed, and the whole surrounding country has been in a state of excitement and tumult bordering on a genuine young war, peace has again been restored, and the belligerent parties on both sides have disbanded, and no further trouble is anticipated. The strangest part of the whole affair is that that Hatfields and McCoys are related.
CAUSE OF THE OUTBREAK.
"The recent outbreak seems to have been caused by parties in Pike county, Kentucky, resurrecting old indictments against the Hatfields, which were found against them five years ago. The Pike county parties went to Frankfort, Ky., and had rewards offered for the Hatfields and came into West Virginia, under the guise of officers of the law, when in reality they had no requisition, and arrested (or rather kidnaped) Thomas Chambers, Andrew Varney, Shelkirk McCoy, D. D. McCoy, Moses Christian, Pliant Mahon, D. D. Mahon and Valentine Hatfield and took them over to Kentucky and placed them in jail, where they are still confined.
COLD-BLOODED MURDER.
"This party, headed by Frank Phillips, fired on and killed old man Vance, without as much as calling on him to surrender, and are the same parties who came over into this State and fired upon Constable Thompson and his posse, at which time Dolphy and another man were killed. Citizens of Logan county state that had any parties other than those sent been called upon to make the arrest no blood would have been shed, but the McCoys who came with Phillips to make the arrest, had sworn to kill the Hatfields and would have done so after they were disarmed. Peace has been temporarily declared, but it is feared by the law-abiding citizens of the two counties that hostilities will be renewed before a great while. The trouble began during the war. The Hatfields were in the Confederate army and the McCoys in the Union army."
Col. W. L. Eagan, sent by Governor Wilson to investigate the Hatfield-McCoy feud, reported that the Hatfields were law-abiding citizens and that peace had been restored with both sides disbanded. He attributed the recent violence to Kentucky parties illegally seizing men from West Virginia under false pretense of legal authority.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Indianapolis Journal · 1 February 1888 · page 1
Col. W.H. Mahon, sent by Governor Wilson to probe the Hatfield-McCoy feud, reports that the Hatfields are law-abiding citizens while accusing the McCoys of trumping up old indictments and attempting to kidnap Hatfields under guise of arrest. He claims the killing of 'old man Vance' was without cause and notes the men's divided Civil War loyalties, Hatfields Confederate and McCoys Union.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Rock Island Daily Argus · 1 February 1888 · page 2
Other Side of the Case.
Malvern sustained serious in juries by a storm Tuesday night of last week. Ed. Stewart, the supposed mur derer of C. Osborn, who was cap tured at Kingsland, last week, has made a confession. The Southern Iron Company, with a capital stock of $5,000,000, at Nashville, Tenn., has purchas ed the West Nashville Furnace Company’s interest for $150,000. The postoffice at Cromwell, Jackson county, Ark., was bro ken open last Friday night, aud robbed of all the money and pos tage stamps. The Hatfield and McCoy gangs had another fight, in West Virginia, Friday night, and the Hatfields were masters of the situation, and captured four prisoners.
See moreSee less
They were of course, put to death. The Jones-Glidwell case has been appealed to the Supreme Court. We see it stated that the brief embodies over 500 pages, and is the most voluminous docu ment ever presented to our
Clipping to come
Rock Island Daily Argus · Rock Island, Ill.
A Pittsburgh Times correspondent, Charles B. Howell, reports after personal investigation into the six-year Hatfield-McCoy conflict, calling it the first true published account of the feud's murders, arson, and assassinations. It describes the feud as a one-sided destruction of the smaller McCoy family by the larger Hatfield clan, centered on the Tug River near Pond Creek, Kentucky.
Rock Island Daily Argus · 1 February 1888 · page 2
“THAT IS HE, SITTING THfcRE.” Burke never changed color under this identification. Mr. Hynes recurred again to the condition of the cottage and furniture April 20. and asked Carlson if ne saw the carpet. Carlson replied that he did, and Identified a strip 7>T carpet (the same as identified by Hatfield) as being exactly like that on the floor of the cottage. The next time Carlson went to the cottage was on May 19. “We could find no key to “the door, and, finding a window shutter open, we got in the window next the stairs. The carpet was gone and paint had been
Clipping to come
Rock Island Daily Argus · Rock Island, Ill.
The report reviews years of Hatfield-McCoy violence, describing burned homes and multiple deaths, including the family of Randall McCoy. It recounts the 1880s warrant dispute, the election-day stabbing of Ellison Hatfield, and the subsequent revenge killing of three McCoy brothers by Hatfield partisans.
Rock Island Daily Argus · 1 February 1888 · page 2
nt of theil hundred re 125'revolvers and several ridges, and loading the n wagons, started for the feud. While at suppei ear the farm house of Mrs. , born Hatfield, the party t from an ambush. Tb urned the volley, but it could not see with whal Blumfield, their leader d, and after firing Mrs ound lying dead in he] through her neck t here is intense, anc will be asked to senc r be a hazardous under militiamen, ~however, t< the fastnesses of whiel -ng, and which are s( rri ' g factions. It is Ha fields and Blum m action at leasi
Clipping to come
The Climax · Richmond, Ky.
A brief news item among miscellaneous local notices reports that Governor Buckner has refused to send troops to Pike County to suppress the Hatfield-McCoy feud. This reflects the state's reluctance to intervene militarily in the ongoing conflict.
The Climax · 1 February 1888 · page 3
Lamibkin, John Cain and Peter McCoy The names of the dead are unknown Cain, whose first name was not known was so badly wounded that his corm rades left him to die where he lay, bul the other three were oompelled t< dHatfield headquarters whiehtthey reached about noon yester day. As soon is the story~ of the attacd and capture was told a sort of court martial was held. The prisoners werE not allowed to speak in their own de fense, and after a short deliberation vote on their life or death was taken The result was unanimious and thE three men will be tied to trees anc shot to-day.
See moreSee less
Nothing cars 1save then unless the McCoy's cart defeat tl.q entire Hatfield party arid effect a res cue. This is not likely as they are out numbered two to one, and the Hat field's are better armed. Thle co,urie: who brought this news was shot al twice from amkbah while ridinit through Lincoln coRunty.
Clipping to come
Der Deutsche Correspondent · Baltimore, Md.
Governor Wilson of West Virginia sent a commissioner to investigate the McCoy-Hatfield feud along the Kentucky-West Virginia border. The commissioner reported that both parties involved are very respectable people, a claim the paper mocks with a sarcastic "Naturally!"
Der Deutsche Correspondent · 1 February 1888 · page 1
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Abbeville Press and Banner · Abbeville, S.C.
A roundup of national news briefly notes that the ongoing feud between the Hatfield and McCoy families of Pike County, Kentucky, has resulted in ten murders. The item appears as one line among many unrelated national stories in a daily news summary.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
The Abbeville Press and Banner · 1 February 1888 · page 2
Transcript to come.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
Press and Daily Dakotaian · Yankton, S.D.
A representative sent by Governor Wilson returned from Logan county and reported that combatants on both sides of the Hatfield-McCoy feud had disbanded and the trouble was over. The governor subsequently countermanded his order calling out the militia.
Press and Daily Dakotaian · 1 February 1888 · page 3
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
Clipping to come
Richmond Dispatch · Richmond, Va.
Colonel Mahon reports to Governor Wilson after visiting Logan County, finding the Hatfields law-abiding and describing the feud's roots in an 1882 killing of Ellison Hatfield by McCoys, followed by Hatfield retaliation. It also recounts recent Kentucky-led raids and killings of West Virginians, including Vance and Dempsey, under dubious extradition claims.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
Richmond Dispatch · 1 February 1888 · page 4
TERRIBLE HATFIELD-McCOY FEUD
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
Clipping to come
Richmond Dispatch · Richmond, Va.
The report describes how Kentucky authorities revived old indictments, obtained a governor's backing and rewards, and sent men posing as law officers (without actual requisition) into West Virginia to arrest/kidnap several men including McCoys and a Hatfield, jailing them in Pike County. It also recounts earlier deadly raids by the same party, including killings of Vance and others, and notes the Hatfields are reportedly selling property to leave the state, suggesting the feud's end.
Richmond Dispatch · 1 February 1888 · page 4
A Fugitive Killed. Itob King was shot and instantly killed in Floyd county last week by n. Hatfield while resisting arrest. King was a bad character.. There was $Mt) reward for him for horse stealing in Pike county, and when killed 2ie was being arrested for shooting Constable Lewis Hatfield in this countv la-t year w liile the latter was attempting to arrest him.
Clipping to come
Richmond Dispatch · Richmond, Va.
A West Virginia governor's agent, Colonel Mahan, returned from Logan county and reported that peace had been restored between the Hatfields and McCoys. He recounted the feud's origin in an 1882 election-day killing of Ellison Hatfield by McCoys, followed by Hatfield relatives killing the McCoy brothers in revenge.
Richmond Dispatch · 1 February 1888 · page 4
FURTHER PARTICULARS OF THE TERRIBLE HATFIELD-McCOY FEUD
McCoy vendetta is to Kentucky. Bach might, perhaps, be said to act as a sort of mustard plaster on the body politic. People in the neighborhood don't suffer
Clipping to come
Richmond Dispatch · Richmond, Va.
This report retraces the origins of the Hatfield-McCoy feud from the 1882 killing of Ellison Hatfield and the subsequent killing of the McCoys, through recent Kentucky-led raids, kidnappings, and killings in West Virginia in early 1888. It notes that the Hatfields are now selling property and preparing to leave the state, suggesting the feud's end.
Richmond Dispatch · 1 February 1888 · page 4
REVENGE.
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Watertown Republican · Watertown, Wis.
After a clash between the McCoy and Hatfield factions left one McCoy wounded and Hatfield follower Will Dempsey shot after capture, Hatfields reportedly threatened to kill residents and burn Pikeville. County officials traveled to ask the governor for arms to protect the town, which was under guard.
Watertown Republican · 1 February 1888 · page 2
A CALL FOR TROOPS,
The Court of Appeals has affirm ed the dieision of the Pike county court in the Hat field McCoy cases Valentine Hatfield Ply ant May born go to the penitentiary for life for the murder of Tolbert Mc Coy Ellison Mounts will hang for the murder of the girl Alice McCoy sister of the murdered
Clipping to come
The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · Wheeling, W. Va.
A commissioner sent by West Virginia's governor reports that the Hatfield-McCoy feud has temporarily subsided after a tense standoff, noting that Kentucky parties had crossed into West Virginia to arrest Hatfields under dubious legal authority. He describes the Hatfields as law-abiding and notes several men were taken to a Kentucky jail.
The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · 1 February 1888 · page 1
THE COMMISSIONER'S REPORT
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · Wheeling, W. Va.
Pittsburgh police arrested a man named T.O. Wheeler believed to be wanted for a burglary at a store in Banetown, Pennsylvania. The robbers had stolen goods, cash, and stamps before being disturbed at the nearby home of Ellis Hatfield, unrelated to the famous feud family.
The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · 1 February 1888 · page 1
AN ALLEGED BURGLAR
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
The item notes that Governor Wilson of West Virginia will likely demand the release of nine West Virginians (Hatfields) seized by the McCoy-led posse and held in the Pike County, Kentucky jail. It briefly recaps that the feud originated during the Civil War, with Hatfields fighting Confederate and McCoys Union, and notes the families are said to be related.
Wheeling Register · 1 February 1888 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
Gov. Wilson will probably demand the release of the nine West Virginians kidnapped by the McCoy gang and now in the Pike county, Ky., jail. This Hatfield-McCoy trouble dates from the war, in which the Hatfields fought on the Confederate side and the McCoy's on the Union. The parties, it is said, are related.
Colonel W.S. Mahon, sent by Governor Wilson to investigate the feud, reported that the Hatfields were law-abiding citizens and that the violence stemmed from Pike County, Kentucky parties illegally kidnapping several men under false pretenses of law enforcement. The report also noted that Frank Phillips' party had killed an old man named Vance during the raids.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Wheeling Register · 1 February 1888 · page 1
MAHON'S REPORT.
Davit Aiihu llutMclri'* Story. The I.NTKLLIOKNCKR publishes thill morning "Devil Anso" Hatfield's own story of the famous llattleld-McOoy feud. It is a plain recital by a plain man and is unembelished by the sensa tional features that have accompauied tho numerous newspaper atones here tofore printed. It is probably the tirat true history of tho feud that has been published, aud will throw light upon much that has heretofore been mysterious. Whatovor may be tho char acter of tho other participauta in the feud, it ia pretty clearly ahown that "Devil Ansa" is not as black as ho has been painted by sensational newspaper jcporters, and that tho Ilatfields are not ulono responsible for the blood that has beeu shed.
Clipping to come
Wheeling Register · Wheeling, W. Va.
A dispatch describes the aftermath of a posse clash in which Dempsey and another man were killed, with Logan citizens blaming the McCoys for bloodshed since they had sworn to kill the Hatfields. The Kentucky side reports Governor Wilson's intervention, a near-fight between state representatives over jurisdiction, and continued arms shipments to Pikeville as tensions remain high.
Wheeling Register · 1 February 1888 · page 1
THE KENTUCKY SIDE.
Held* and Mei'oys Denied. Wheeling, W. W, Nov, 24. —Major Anderson, who has just returned from the scene of the alleged Lincoln county Hatfield-McCoy feud, blood-curdling sccouota of which have appeared in the papers for a month past, requests the press to givs an emphatic denial to all the atoriee that have been published. He says there ie no vendetta in existanca in that section. There have been no recent outbreaks of the Hatfield-McCoy feu 1, and the attempt of the sensational reporters to connect the Hatfields with the reported Lincoln county trouble is absurd, a« they live a hundred miles away.
Clipping to come
The Palatka Daily News · Palatka, Fla.
Governor Wilson of West Virginia issued a requisition to Kentucky's Governor Buckner demanding the return of several men accused in the Hatfield-McCoy feud, who are currently jailed in Pike County, Kentucky. The petition claims these Logan County citizens were illegally removed from West Virginia without proper legal process.
The Palatka Daily News · 2 February 1888 · page 1
HATFIELD-McCOY VENDETTA.
Transcript to come.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
The Morning News · Savannah, Ga.
West Virginia's governor issued a requisition to Kentucky's governor demanding the return of several men—including Selkirk McCoy and others—accused of unlawfully seizing Logan County citizens without legal process. The men are currently held in a Pike County, Kentucky jail awaiting trial, and a state agent will carry the extradition papers to Frankfort.
HatftVd Me-Coy. Baltimore. Nov. 21: A special to The Herald from Huntington, West Virginia, says: Big Al Bluru fleld and Heart Dinges, cousins of lit tle Al B'umfield, who with his wife was murdered by Wilt .Haley and Pete McCoy in the HatCeld-McCoy vendetta arrived at Bai hours ville yesterday. They are heavily armed and have war rents for the arrest of several members of the McCoy and Runyan families, alleged to be concerned in the killinu of old Mr. and Mrs. Paris Hatfield in Lincoln county last week. The war rants were issued by Justice of the Peace, Tom Blutniield, and he sas he is going to have "the men arrested if it takes all the Blumfields and Hat fields in Lincoln county to capture them.
See moreSee less
The McCoys will not give the men up, for it is certain that thev will be butch ered like Nathan A. Farmer, Kdwin and Peter McCoy, the two Cains and Charles Lnmhkiu were after the Blum fields caught them. This new move in the feud will reopen and a succes sion of bloody tragedies may be expec
Clipping to come
The Indianapolis Journal · Indianapolis, Ind.
Governor Wilson of West Virginia issued a requisition to Kentucky's governor demanding the return of eight men allegedly captured illegally and now held in Pike County jail awaiting trial. The petition claims these Logan County citizens were taken from West Virginia without legal process.
The Indianapolis Journal · 2 February 1888 · page 1
NEW PHASE OF THE HATFIELD-McCOY TROUBLES
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Wichita Eagle · Wichita, Kan.
This report describes the Hatfield-McCoy conflict as having escalated beyond a family affair into an interstate matter between West Virginia and Kentucky. It notes that local officials called for state assistance, with West Virginia's governor's envoy favoring intervention for his state's citizens, while Kentucky's governor declined to send militia but allegedly armed local citizen groups instead.
Wichita Eagle · 2 February 1888 · page 4
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
Clipping to come
The Big Sandy News · Louisa, Ky.
Governor Wilson of West Virginia ordered two companies of infantry to Logan County due to the raging Hatfield-McCoy feud, while Governor Buckner refused to send Kentucky troops to Pike County. The report also notes that Anderson Hatfield was reportedly arrested and jailed at Pikeville, supposedly the tenth gang member now in custody.
Governor Wilson of West Virginia issued a requisition to Kentucky's Governor Buckner demanding the return of eight men accused in the Hatfield-McCoy violence in Logan County, who were being held in Pike County jail. The petition claimed the men had been removed from West Virginia without legal process.
Daily Kennebec Journal · 2 February 1888 · page 1
HATFIELD-McCOY VENDETTA
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
Clipping to come
The Portland Daily Press · Portland, Me.
The report notes that civil authorities in West Virginia have formally taken up the Hatfield-McCoy feud. Governor Wilson has issued a requisition for feud participants currently held in jail in another state.
The Portland Daily Press · 2 February 1888 · page 1
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Kanabec County Times · Mora, MN
Logan County authorities asked West Virginia Governor Wilson on the 28th to send troops to suppress the ongoing Hatfield-McCoy feud violence. The brief item appears amid a roundup of unrelated national news stories.
The Kanabec County Times · 2 February 1888 · page 2
the and people up there have found It '?m7. profitable and pleasant to keep close ' months. Tho doclslon In the Hatfield case lit of I probably means more trouble. They are con
Clipping to come
St. Paul Daily Globe · Saint Paul, Minn.
West Virginia's Governor Wilson issued a requisition to Kentucky's Governor Buckner for the return of several men accused in the Hatfield-McCoy feud violence, including Selkirk McCoy and others, who are currently jailed in Pike County, Kentucky awaiting trial. The petition claims these men were illegally seized from West Virginia without proper legal process.
St. Paul Daily Globe · 2 February 1888 · page 5
Fleming the Governorship and per petuate Walker’s reign as Secretary of State.—Grafton Sentinel. “Devil Anse” Hatfield, one of the Hatfield McCoy faction of West Vir
Clipping to come
Omaha Daily Bee · Omaha, Neb.
West Virginia's Governor Wilson issued a requisition to Kentucky's Governor Buckner for the return of several Logan County men accused in the Hatfield-McCoy feud violence, who are being held in the Pike County, Kentucky jail. The report states these men were taken from West Virginia without legal process, violating state law.
Omaha Daily Bee · 2 February 1888 · page 2
THE HATFIELD-McCOY FEUD
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Beatrice Daily Express · Beatrice, Neb. · and 1 other paper
A Pittsburg Times reporter, after personal investigation, publishes what he calls the first true account of the six-year Hatfield-McCoy conflict, describing it as a series of cowardly murders and arson rather than a romanticized feud. The report notes that despite militia being withdrawn by the governors of Kentucky and West Virginia, the troubles are not truly over.
The Beatrice Daily Express · 2 February 1888 · page 2
DISCOUNTING ALL FICTION THE ORIGIN AND GROWTH OF THE HATFIELD-M'COY FEUD.
party were in the town. flip fnfia Xlf ECIDEXT OK THE FEUD. One evening an Eversole fired on a French man, who was standing near the court house. Both men were soon joined by others of their faction and a lively fight ensued, in which two Eversoles were killed. Then came a lull, af ter which B. F. French entered the town with re-enforcements. The nest morning at daybreak the fight was renowed from behind breastworks. After about an hour the Ever solo party retreated, leaving their dead on tho field.
See moreSee less
There were two Eversoles killed and several wounded. One French man was wounded. As the Eversole party occupied the court house the court vanished when the firing commenced. Tho Hatfield-McCoy vendetta, in West Vir ginia, and the French-Eversole vendetta, in
Clipping to come
Also printed in 1 paper
Press and Daily Dakotaian · Yankton, S.D. · 2 February 1888
Press and Daily Dakotaian · Yankton, S.D. · and 1 other paper
This report summarizes the Hatfield-McCoy feud as a series of murders and house-burnings, tracing it from an 1871 arrest warrant and rescue of Johnson Hatfield through the 1872 election-day stabbing and the subsequent execution of three McCoy brothers. It describes the McCoy family's devastation, with four sons and a daughter dead and Randall McCoy's family reduced to penniless wandering.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
Press and Daily Dakotaian · 2 February 1888 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
LIE IN BLOODY GRAVES
DISCOUNTING ALL FICTION
THE ORIGIN AND GROWTH OF THE HATFIELD-M'COY FEUD.
See moreSee less
Dime Novel Tales of Blood Are Fairy Stories in Comparison With the History of the Fiendish Murders on the Kentucky-West Virginia Border.
PITTSBURG, Pa., Feb. 1.—The Times prints in detail the first true statement published of the famous Hatfield-McCoy outrages that have been for six years continued, without serious attempt being made to punish the outlaws. The story from start to finish is a tale of horrors rarely equaled, and has caused a blot on the names of the two great states of Kentucky and West Virginia. Charles Howell, of the Times' editorial staff, returning from a personal investigation, reports to his paper that the Hatfield-McCoy trouble threatens to develop into serious inter-state complications. Although Governors Buckner, of Kentucky, and Wilson, of West Virginia, have ordered their militia to return to their homes, it must not be understood that the troubles are ended. The Hatfield-McCoy war, divested of all sentiment with which the representatives of the two states have invested it, is simply
A SUCCESSION OF COWARDLY MURDERS
by day and assassination and house-burning by night. All of the murders have been cruel, heartless and almost without the shadow of provocation. Given on one hand the family with its contingents of the same blood, allied and comented by a common desire to avenge an imaginary affront, and on the other a family, small in the matters of alliance and collateral sympathies, doomed to destruction by the larger, and the case is stated. The scene of nearly all of the murders and assassinations of the years named is the narrow bottom of Tug river, above and below the mouth of Pond creek, on the Kentucky side. Randall McCoy, with wife and thirteen children, six years ago lived in a log hut near the mouth of Pond creek. To-day his house is in ashes. Four of his sons and one daughter
LIE IN BLOODY GRAVES, and himself and family are wandering in the mountains, well-nigh penniless. In 1871 a warrant was issued for the arrest of Johnson Hatfield, a son of Anderson, who eluded the officials for several months. Talbot McCoy was deputized to serve the warrant. McCoy captured Hatfield and started with him for Pike court house, twenty miles distant. McCoy's two brothers acted as guards. A friend apprised the Hatfields of the arrest, and the elder Hatfield, accompanied by his allies, intercepted the McCoys, and rescued his son at the point of the gun, and returned to West Virginia. A year later, at an election in Kentucky, Elias and Ellison Hatfield engaged in a quarrel with Talbot McCoy, over an alleged debt, during which McCoy stabbed Ellison Hatfield in the back. Hatfield began pounding McCoy's head with a stone, whereupon McCoy's younger brother
STABBED AND SHOT HATFIELD, inflicting fatal wounds. All the parties were arrested. Thirty of Hatfield's friends promptly assembled and a compact was made to release the prisoner, which was done. They took the three McCoys with them, keeping them prisoners two days and a night, pending the result of Ellison Hatfield's injuries. They refused to allow a justice to give the McCoys a hearing, saying they would take care of both trial and punishment. The McCoys—father, mother, brothers and sisters, appeared on the scene and begged for the lives of the three boys, but were told to leave or they would be killed, too. That night Farmer and Talbot McCoy were taken into the timber and shot. Randall was tied to the dead bodies of his brothers, and the party started home. Once Hatfield said: "Boys, dead men tell no tales," and stepping near the boy, discharged both barrels of his shotgun into his head, bursting it open. The bodies remained tied to the bushes for hours, their friends fearing to remove them.
AN ABSOLUTE MONARCHY.
No concentrated effort was ever made to capture the perpetrators of the crime. Anderson Hatfield, Sr., styling himself "Devilance," purchased fire arms in large quantities, and organizing an absolute monarchy, himself taking command. Comparative quiet reigned for another year, when by mistake for Randall McCoy and one of his sons, John and Henderson Scott were waylaid and permanently crippled by a volley from the Hatfield Winchesters. Following this mistake came a period of "stock raising" by the Hatfield gang. About one year ago Jeff McCoy, cousin of the murdered man, was waylaid and shot by "Cap" Hatfield and Zim Wallace. The history of this crime has more elements of hellish fiendishness, if possible, than the first. The shots were fired while the victim's aged mother, grovelling at their feet, her arms entwined about their limbs,
SHRIEKED FOR PITY.
Spurning her with their boots, the fatal shots were fired. The old lady waded the stream to where her son lay dead, and fell in anguish upon his body. Jeff McCoy's father had, some years previously, been assassinated by the Hatfields within a few yards of where his son fell. Perry A. Cline, uncle of Jeff, an attorney, secured requisitions for the arrest of the band. At an election in August last, Louis Varney was beaten almost to death by "Cap" Hatfield. The Hatfields took possession of the polls and broke up the election. The crowning piece of deviltry was reserved for the night of Jan. 1, 1888, when thirteen of the Hatfield gang, headed by Jas. Vance, surrounded the Paul McCoy homestead, near the mouth of Pond creek, burned the house, with its contents,
KILLED HIS SON AND DAUGHTER, beat the mother over the head with the butt of a gun until they thought she was dead, and left the little children to die in the cold on the mountain side, among the bushes to which they had escaped in their night clothes. While the house was burning the father and husband fired two shots with telling effect. Three new-made graves are to be found on the Hatfield settlement, and a number are known to be wounded. After burying his dead, McCoy moved his family to Pike court house last week.
The story was obtained principally from Mr and Mrs McCoy, who show unmistakeable evidence of the intensity of their sufferings, and is fully corroborated by others. No one knows why the fiendish malignity should have been kept up. But once McCoy has attempted to retaliate, and that a few days ago. Even now no feeling of resentment is manifested. He spoke like a man who is bent and almost broken by the weight of his afflictions.
The killing of Callen and Alfred, on Jan. 1, became known the next day at the county court house. Measures were taken at once to capture, or kill, a portion of the Hatfield gang. Twenty or thirty men, under Deputy Sheriff Trask Phillips, crossed the Tug near Pond creek, in Pike county, Ky., on Jan. 6. When within thirty yards of the house, Mrs. Vance hailed Phillips with: "Who are you, and where are you going?"
"Who are you and where are you going?" was his rejoinder.
"I think they are after you, Pap," she shrieked, and a moment later old Vance arose from his concealment, thirty or forty yards behind her. During the shooting which followed Vance was killed. On the night of January 9, Phillips and posse arrested Valentine Hatfield, three Mayhorn brothers, Tom Chambers, Andrew Yancy, Selkirk McCoy and Moses Christian. Others of the Hatfields were captured in McDonald county, W. Va., about the same time and landed in Pike jail.
The Beatrice Daily Express · Beatrice, Neb. · 2 February 1888
The Beatrice Daily Express · Beatrice, Neb.
This report summarizes the feud's violent history, including the 1882 execution-style killing of the three McCoy brothers, later killings of Jeff McCoy and others, election violence, and the New Year's 1888 raid on Randall McCoy's home. It frames the Hatfields as an organized armed gang operating with impunity against law enforcement.
The Beatrice Daily Express · 2 February 1888 · page 2
Nevada newspapers on different portions of the window, but on the large front glass, where all could see, was his in scription: "Judicirus advertising made this for me. Try it and see what it will make for you." The famous Hatfield-McCoy feud and others who have been disgracing Ken tucky will probably come to an end now that the gallows has begun to claim the
Clipping to come
Jamestown Weekly Alert · Jamestown, N.D.
A report from Charleston, W.Va. states the Hatfield-McCoy vendetta has been settled for now, with both sides disbanding. Governor Wilson countermanded the militia call-out and notified Kentucky's governor accordingly.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Jamestown Weekly Alert · 2 February 1888 · page 1
AT PEACE AGAIN.
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Press and Daily Dakotaian · Yankton, S.D.
This report recounts the feud's violent history from the 1882 killing of the three McCoy brothers through later ambushes, the murder of Jeff McCoy, and the January 1888 burning of the McCoy homestead. It describes Devil Anse Hatfield's armed rule over the region and notes that no real effort was made to capture the killers until attorney Perry Cline sought arrest warrants.
Press and Daily Dakotaian · 2 February 1888 · page 2
AN ABSOLUTE MONARCHY.
Hatfleld-McCoy Row. Hcntioton, W. Va., Jan. 11. The Sheriff of Lincoln county was holdingt tbe jail at Ilalmia last night against an armed mob that
Clipping to come
Press and Daily Dakotaian · Yankton, S.D.
Col. W. L. Mahon reports to Gov. Wilson that he visited the Hatfields, found them law-abiding, and that peace has been restored after a period of violent unrest. He attributes the recent outbreak to Kentucky parties illegally seizing Hatfield relatives under false pretenses and killing an old man named Vance without demanding surrender.
Press and Daily Dakotaian · 2 February 1888 · page 3
The Hatfield-McCoy Feud
The farmer's body waa riddled with bulleta and life was extintt. The latter had a ghastly wound in the face from which she was rendered uoconcious. As the furniture was not disturbed ;and the wife could give no particnlsrs of the mystery sfter she regained consciousness, friends of the murdered man believe a gang of deaperadoes, for whom he had warrants for “moonshining" committed the awful deed. Others believe it is merely a continuation jjf the Hatfield* McCoy feud, as the victim was related to the former family. The wounde of the woman are believed to be fatal.
Clipping to come
Hand County Press · Miller, S.D.
The report describes the Hatfield gang invading the house of 'Simon McCoy' in Wyoming County, West Virginia, tying his wife and son to trees and shooting them before burning the house, allegedly killing McCoy and two small children. It also claims McCoy's brother's family was murdered by the same men.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Hand County Press · 2 February 1888 · page 1
Ellison Hatfield will be hnng at Piueville, Kentucky, to-day, for the murder of Randall McCoy's daughter. This is the first victim of the law from the famous Hatfield McCoy fued, which began twenty-seven years ago with the
Clipping to come
The Memphis Appeal · Memphis, Tenn.
West Virginia's Governor Wilson, acting on a petition from William Floyd, issued a requisition to Kentucky's Governor Buckner for the return of several men—including Tom Chambers, Andy Varney, Elkanah McCoy, and others—who were allegedly involved in the Hatfield-McCoy feud violence and are held in Pike County jail awaiting trial. The petition claims the men were illegally removed from West Virginia without due legal process. Colonel W.L. Mahon, who had assessed the feud situation for the governor, was to carry the papers to Frankfort the next day.
The Memphis Appeal · 2 February 1888 · page 1
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Salt Lake Herald · Salt Lake City, Utah
Governor Wilson of West Virginia issued requisitions to Governor Buckner of Kentucky for several men including Selkirk McCoy and L.D. McCoy, alleged to have been involved in the recent border feud. The men were residents of Logan County, West Virginia.
The Salt Lake Herald · 2 February 1888 · page 1
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
Clipping to come
Richmond Dispatch · Richmond, Va.
Governor Wilson of West Virginia issued a requisition to Kentucky's Governor Buckner demanding the return of several men—including Selkirk McCoy and others—accused in the Hatfield-McCoy feud violence, who are currently jailed in Pike County, Kentucky. The petition claims these Logan County citizens were illegally seized from West Virginia without proper legal process.
Richmond Dispatch · 2 February 1888 · page 3
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · Wheeling, W. Va.
A Pittsburgh Times correspondent, Charles B. Howell, publishes an extensive five-column account after spending time at the scene gathering facts, claiming to offer the first true statement of the feud. The report describes troop deployments by the governors of Kentucky and West Virginia along the Tug River and characterizes the conflict as a series of cowardly murders and assassinations against the smaller McCoy family.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · 2 February 1888 · page 1
NEW DEVELOPMENTS IN THE HATFIELD-M'COY FEUD
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
Clipping to come
The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · Wheeling, W. Va.
This report gives a detailed narrative of the January 1, 1888 attack on the Paul McCoy home, describing the burning of the house, the killing of a son and daughter, and the beating of the mother, based on interviews with Mr. and Mrs. McCoy. It also notes that a posse was organized the next day to capture or kill members of the Hatfield gang.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · 2 February 1888 · page 1
THE CROWNING PIECE OF DEVILTRY
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
Clipping to come
The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · Wheeling, W. Va.
The report describes the manhunt following the New Year's Night killings of Calvin and Alifair McCoy, detailing the posse's clashes with the Hatfields, including the deaths of old Vance and Jim Vance's companion Dunpany. It also describes the capture and jailing of several Hatfield associates, including Wall Hatfield, and notes he was not involved in the actual killings.
The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · 2 February 1888 · page 1
FULLY CORROBORATED
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
West Virginia Argus · Kingwood, W. Va.
A Charleston, W.Va. dispatch claims the Hatfield gang raided the home of Jim McCoy, shooting his wife and oldest son and burning McCoy and two young children alive. It states no arrests have been made and suggests the feud has ended with the extermination of the McCoys.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
West Virginia Argus · 2 February 1888 · page 1
MORE INHUMAN BUTCHERIES IN THE McCOY-HATFIELD FEUD
DEEDS OF liOTTETTAnr EAUDITTL BLUM MOUNTS ALIAS IIATTISXD (rrom a photograph taken In tha Jail) Pikeville Ky Feb 17-tSpaclaL)-SThls morning everything was as quiet in this little mountain city as could be ex pected considering that on to-morrow will take place the first lianging that lias occurred in this county for perhaps flirty years To-morrow a procession consisting of the guard officers and Ellison Mounts will leave the juil of Tike county for the scaffold wliich lias been erect ed - about half a mile from the jail and court-house where Ellison Mounts will be executed for the murder of Miss Allaphare McCoy on the night of January 1 1888 at tho humble Lome of her father Randolph McCoy en "Blackberry creek about thirty miles from this place The story of the crimes of the gang of which Ellison Mounts was a member would fill a volume The atrocities of the aboriginal savage with whom Boone and his contemporaries contended in these some mountains more than one hundred years ago do not surpass the crimes of " Devil Ansc" Hatfield and his gang Frequently the publio has been furnished with descriptions of the Mo-Coy-Hatfield fend and it is not necessary here to give a full detail of all the actions of this mountain banditti It will suffioe to give a brief history of the life and crimes of Ellison Mounts who is on to-morrow according to his statement Is going to change a state of sorrow and brief for one of unending joy in the Paradise of God On every afternoon for more than a week services have been held in the jaiL Rev J W Glover pastor of the jM E ehuieh South at this place and who is'also' the 3 ail physician is standing nobly by the condemned man and will aeoompany him to the scaffold and there will sing a song and offer prayer The other services consisting of the reading of a portion of the Scriptures and perhaps a short discourse by Dr Glover will be held at the jaiL Mounts says he is pre pared to die Mounts has been ill for several days lie refute to talk to anyone about his' ease or his past history although your correspondent has1 gained sufficient facts from reliable sources to warrant the fol lowing statement crrceming his life and cruxes: A man about six feet ox perhaps an inch over in height weighing when in health perhaps 185 pounds with very Sight hair and dull gray eyes Such is JSllison Mount as he appears to a casual observer Nothing very striking in his appearance is the first decision but on closer inspection of features you will find the traits of a very fiend plainly discernable A high narrow forehead' prominent cheek-bones broad vulgar mouth a nervous twlchlng chin all marks of a character bereft of the finer sensibilities Ellison Mounts Is now about twentyfive years of age and is the illegitimate son of the good Deacon Ellison IlatUeld whowas the first victim of the feud proper who was killed on August election day in 1882 Mounts' early boyhood was spent in the utual pursuit!
See moreSee less
of a rude unrully boy in fishing hunting roving about the neighborhood and en gaging with boon compunions la Sab bath-breaking petty pilfering and all the multifitrioua pursuits known to the average ungoveroed country boy His father was a " ilurd-shelP Baptist preacher Ills training in book-learn ing" was very limited lie can read and write a little which constitutes his stock of education His education in vice seems to have been very thorough and when at the age of seventeen he saw his father killed he was ripe for blood shed His first participation in murder was on the night following the death of Deacon JSlllson Hatfield his father who died from the effects of the wounds re ceived ori August election day 1 882 at the hands of Talbot Former and " Little liud" McCoy Immediately after the fight in which Deacon IJatflcld received his wounds tlie three McCoys were arrested— young Ifandolph McCoy however being taken for " Little Bud"— and early the next morning the guard with the prisoners ville a distance of about thirty miles They had not pro ceeded very far when they were intercepted by Old Devil Anee" Hatfield a brother of ' the wounded the guard— being accompanied by Ellison Mounts and " about ten others and took the McCoys back to West Vir ginia: to 'a place neat where ' the wounded man had' been tarriedOn: OAPT IIATraLD Wednesday aftemoop Ieacpn liatfleld died" and shortly after dusk " Devil Anee" with his crowdtook the three McCoy boys across to the Kentucky side tied them to paw-paw bushes and there In the darkness of night brutally murdered them - Mounts confesses that (he whs in the crowd and assisted in the shooting The 'next murder in which Mounts mrtieipated occurred in June 1884 It will le remembered that when the McCoy buys were murdered in 1882 Talbot McCoy was a man of some property and married Of course an administrator must be appointed and who so well-fitted to settle up the estate as his brother Calvin P In or der to do this work it was necessary to bring some suits and the cases were to be tried before a Justice of the Peace on tlie Tug river near the scenes of the bloody massacrce of 1882 The llatfickl gang of which Ellison Mounts was still an active member formed a plan to murder Kundolph McCoy the father of the murdered boys and Culvin tlie administrator as they should return from the trial By a mistake they fired on some innocent and un concerned parties slightly wounding one and seriously injuring the other The most lieinous crime of the series' And tlie one for which Mounts is to hang is the murdering in cold blood of a defenseless irirL On Mew Year's nicht of 1888 there were at Kandolph McCoy's house be sides himself und wife his son Calvin and Hose Ann's little boy Melvin all of whom 'were in the westerly end of tlie house In the other end were Aliaphar? Addle and Fanny McCoy daughters oi xtunuoipn ana young women grown besides little Cora the orphan daughter ox inioot Shortly after midnight they were awakened by a gang of Hattields who called on old IfantlT to surrender or they would burn his house over "his head The nana was headed bv Uncle Jim Vance who had hitherto kept out of the trouble and was got into it by a cucumstance wnicu illustrates tne morals of these mountaineers very weiL Uncle Jims sister was the wife of Had Ansc With Vance were Cap Hatfield' Jonoe IlatUeld liob Hatfield a younger son of Cap Elliott Hatfield son of Ellison Ellison Mounts French Ellis Tom Gil lespie and Tom Mitchell Gillespie and Elliott Hatliela were posted as sentinels up and down tie road The other seven attacked the house Old Hand'!' made no answer to the demand to surrender' and an effort was made to break in his door The door was barred Then the gang attacked the other end where tlie girls were and broke in tlvir door and jumped back lest a man should be inside and shoot out Allaphare the oldest girl went to the door and told them no man was in there "Stir a lights" ordered Jim Vance and Allaphare went to the fireplace and tried to build a fire But the coal was out and there was neither wood nor match to lighs a fire Allaphare returned to the door and told the men why she could make no fire The men broke out in a tor rent of profanity and Cap Hatfield ALiiAraARa if cot swore he would shoot her if she did not at once make a fire in the fireplace She recognized his voice and said holding up her hands and bursting into tears: "Cap I can't I would indeed' I would if I could You wouldn't shoot a woman who never did you any harm would you?" " What the hell are yon parleying with her for?" yelled Uncle Jim "God her make no more account of her than you would of a man Shoot her Cap raised his gun bat Ellison Mounts had nia gun already at his shoulder and shot the girl down as she stood there in her nightgown The hall entered just over roe leitoreastt ana one xeu oacjc dead with only a moan
Clipping to come
West Virginia Argus · Kingwood, W. Va.
The report describes Hatfield gang members raiding Randolph McCoy's home at night, tying up his wife and son and shooting them, then burning McCoy and two young children alive in their house. It also recaps the feud's origin in Ellison Hatfield's death and the paw-paw bush killings of three McCoy brothers.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
West Virginia Argus · 2 February 1888 · page 1
DEEDS OF liOTTETTAnr EAUDITTL BLUM MOUNTS ALIAS IIATTISXD (rrom a photograph taken In tha Jail) Pikeville Ky Feb 17-tSpaclaL)-SThls morning everything was as quiet in this little mountain city as could be ex pected considering that on to-morrow will take place the first lianging that lias occurred in this county for perhaps flirty years To-morrow a procession consisting of the guard officers and Ellison Mounts will leave the juil of Tike county for the scaffold wliich lias been erect ed - about half a mile from the jail and court-house where Ellison Mounts will be executed for the murder of Miss Allaphare McCoy on the night of January 1 1888 at tho humble Lome of her father Randolph McCoy en "Blackberry creek about thirty miles from this place The story of the crimes of the gang of which Ellison Mounts was a member would fill a volume The atrocities of the aboriginal savage with whom Boone and his contemporaries contended in these some mountains more than one hundred years ago do not surpass the crimes of " Devil Ansc" Hatfield and his gang Frequently the publio has been furnished with descriptions of the Mo-Coy-Hatfield
Clipping to come
The Hazel Green Herald · Hazel Green, Ky.
Anson Hatfield, leader of the West Virginia outlaws feuding with the McCoys, has been arrested and jailed in Pikeville, Kentucky. Ten Hatfields are now in custody with indictments pending against all of them, and the governors of Kentucky and West Virginia may be corresponding about the vendetta.
The Hazel Green Herald · 3 February 1888 · page 1
Deacon JSlllson Hatfield his father who died from the effects of the wounds re ceived ori August election day 1 882 at the hands of Talbot Former and " Little liud" McCoy Immediately after the fight in which Deacon IJatflcld received his wounds tlie three McCoys were arrested— young Ifandolph McCoy however being taken for " Little Bud"— and early the next morning the guard with the prisoners ' Started for Pike ville a distance of about thirty miles They had not pro ceeded very far when they were intercepted by Old Devil Anee" Hatfield a brother of ' the wounded : man who relieved the guard— being accompanied by Ellison Mounts and " about ten others and took the McCoys back to West Vir ginia: to 'a place neat where ' the wounded man had' been tarriedOn: OAPT IIATraLD died" and shortly after dusk " Devil Anee" with his crowdtook the three McCoy boys across to the Kentucky side tied them to paw-paw bushes and there In the darkness of night brutally murdered them - Mounts confesses that (he whs in the crowd and assisted in the shooting The 'next murder in which Mounts mrtieipated occurred in June 1884 It will le remembered that when the McCoy buys were murdered in 1882 Talbot McCoy was a man of some property and married Of course an administrator must be appointed and who so well-fitted to settle up the estate as his brother Calvin P In or der to do this work it was necessary to bring some suits and the cases were to be tried before a Justice of the Peace on tlie Tug river near the scenes of the bloody massacrce of 1882 The llatfickl gang of which Ellison Mounts was still an active member formed a plan to murder Kundolph McCoy the father of the murdered boys and Culvin tlie administrator as they should return from the trial By a mistake they fired on some innocent and un concerned parties slightly wounding one and seriously injuring the other The most lieinous crime of the series' And tlie one for which Mounts is to hang is the murdering in cold blood of a defenseless irirL On Mew Year's nicht of 1888 there were at Kandolph McCoy's house be sides himself und wife his son Calvin and Hose Ann's little boy Melvin all of whom 'were in the westerly end of tlie house In the other end were Aliaphar?
See moreSee less
Addle and Fanny McCoy daughters oi xtunuoipn ana young women grown besides little Cora the orphan daughter ox inioot Shortly after midnight they were awakened by a gang of Hattields who called on old IfantlT to surrender or they would burn his house over "his head The nana was headed bv Uncle Jim Vance who had hitherto kept out of the trouble and was got into it by a cucumstance wnicu illustrates tne morals of these mountaineers very weiL Uncle Jims sister was the wife of Had Ansc With Vance were Cap Hatfield' Jonoe IlatUeld liob Hatfield a younger son of Cap Elliott Hatfield son of Ellison Ellison Mounts French Ellis Tom Gil lespie and Tom Mitchell Gillespie and Elliott Hatliela were posted as sentinels up and down tie road The other seven attacked the house Old Hand'!' made no answer to the demand to surrender' and an effort was made to break in his door The door was barred Then the gang attacked the other end where tlie girls were and broke in tlvir door and jumped back lest a man should be inside and shoot out Allaphare the oldest girl went to the door and told them no man was in there "Stir a lights" ordered Jim Vance and Allaphare went to the fireplace and tried to build a fire But the coal was out and there was neither wood nor match to lighs a fire Allaphare returned to the door and told the men why she could make no fire The men broke out in a tor rent of profanity and Cap Hatfield ALiiAraARa if cot swore he would shoot her if she did not at once make a fire in the fireplace She recognized his voice and said holding up her hands and bursting into tears: "Cap I can't I would indeed' I would if I could You wouldn't shoot a woman who never did you any harm would you?" " What the hell are yon parleying with her for?" yelled Uncle Jim "God her make no more account of her than you would of a man Shoot her Cap raised his gun bat Ellison Mounts had nia gun already at his shoulder and shot the girl down as she stood there in her nightgown The hall entered just over roe leitoreastt ana one xeu oacjc dead with only a moan
Clipping to come
The Hazel Green Herald · Hazel Green, Ky.
The Lexington Company of State Guards stood ready to march to Pike County to help quell the Hatfield-McCoy feud, with Kentucky's governor expected to send troops. Meanwhile, officials in Logan County, West Virginia also requested troops to protect Hatfields from McCoys, while observers criticized local sheriffs for failing to arrest the feuding parties.
The Hazel Green Herald · 3 February 1888 · page 1
At a log rolling in Wayne Coun ty, on the 20th inst., Wade Thomp son, a notorious desperado, was struck and killed with a club by one Bam Pratt. The quarrel was over some trivial matter. Pratt was arrested, but escaped. Thomp son was one of the murderers of Alonzo McCoy, during the Hatfield McCoy troubles.
Clipping to come
The Hazel Green Herald · Hazel Green, Ky.
The paper reprints a Courier-Journal dispatch claiming the Hatfields and McCoys have disbanded their forces and that Governor Wilson ordered his militia to disperse. The report expresses hope that the news of peace is correct, suggesting uncertainty about its accuracy.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Hazel Green Herald · 3 February 1888 · page 1
Sheriff Piae. Emil Nenman, the Berlin music ian has been arrested for the mur der of his son. An English physician has disdiscovered that high collars are bad for the eyes. A Commission has been appoint ed to disccss the advisability of putting a railroad through Panama. The Hatfield-McCoy feud has
Clipping to come
Fisherman & Farmer · Edenton, N.C.
A Charleston dispatch reports that the Hatfield gang raided Sim McCoy's home, shooting his wife and eldest son and burning McCoy and two young children alive inside the house. The report claims this 'climax' has effectively exterminated the McCoy family, with the Hatfields now barricaded and unreachable by any posse.
On the 28th, Logan County authorities asked West Virginia Governor Wilson to send state troops to suppress the ongoing Hatfield-McCoy feud. This reflects escalating violence prompting official intervention.
Griggs Courier · 3 February 1888 · page 2
Chairman Senate Committee. Ellison ITatkif.ld Hanged.—A dispatch from l’iktvill**, Ky., of Thursday says: Eiii^on Mounts, or Hatfield, was hanged here yesterday for participa ting in the murder of Miss Alafsir McCoy and Lcr brother. He was cool to the last, and as the black cap was pulled ov.r his face, he declared that the Ila’field outlaw gang forced him to engage in tbc muidcr, the drop fell al 12 :37 o’clock. The ex ecution was practically public. The banging of Ha-field is the cul mination of the notorious Hatfield McCoy feud, which began between »he two fanni es in 1865.
See moreSee less
when Cap tain James Vance, oloeely related to the Haifields, and who was a confed erate t Ificer. met and murdered Ili* ram McCoy, a Union soldier, whom he had captured in a raid. The mur der of Miss McCoy, for which Hatfield was being tried, was a bru tal and cowatdly one. The killing recurred during a raid by tbo Hat fields on Devil McCoy's cabin. The girl was shot U rcugb the heart.
Clipping to come
The Warner Sun · Warner, S.D.
Colonel W.L. Mahon, dispatched by Governor Wilson to investigate the Hatfield-McCoy feud, filed a report entirely favorable to the Hatfields, describing them as law-abiding citizens acting only in self-defense against McCoy aggression. The report notes the feud began during the Civil War, with Hatfields serving the Confederacy and McCoys the Union.
A writer who worked as part of a U.S. government engineering survey party in 1883-84, guided often by Hatfield men through the mountains, disputes a January 25 Herald account as unfair to the Hatfield side. He claims the Hatfields were well-regarded by neighbors and that the feud stemmed from an outrageous murder attack on a Hatfield by Randall McCoy and sons at a Blackberry Creek election.
Richmond Dispatch · 3 February 1888 · page 2
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
Clipping to come
Richmond Dispatch · Richmond, Va.
A letter published in a Charleston newspaper, written by an engineer who had worked in the region in 1883-84, pushes back against sensationalized press accounts of the Hatfield-McCoy feud. The writer, who had been guided through the area by Hatfield family members during his survey work, argues that one newspaper account alone had fairly represented the Hatfields' side of the ongoing conflict.
Richmond Dispatch · 3 February 1888 · page 2
THE HATFIELDS - NOT SO BLACK AS THEY HAVE BEEN PAINTED
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Richmond Dispatch · Richmond, Va.
A government surveyor recounts his 1883-84 work among the Hatfields and McCoys, praising the Hatfields as peaceable, generous mountaineers. He claims the feud began when Randall McCoy and his sons made an unprovoked, murderous attack on a Hatfield brother at an election on Blackberry Creek.
Richmond Dispatch · 3 February 1888 · page 2
Transcript to come.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
South Branch Intelligencer · Romney, Va. W. Va.
State Senator J. B. Floyd of Charleston, who knew the Hatfields well, disputes newspaper portrayals of them as outlaws and offers his account of the feud's origin. He describes how in 1882 three McCoys killed Ellison Hatfield at a Kentucky election, and were themselves killed before escaping, leading to indictments in Pike County.
South Branch Intelligencer · 3 February 1888 · page 2
WHAT STARTED THE TROUBLE
To the disgrace of the great common wealth of Kentucky, the McCoy-Hat-field feud still continues, and midnight murder is almost of weekly occurrence. Sometimes it is tho young and strong
Clipping to come
South Branch Intelligencer · Romney, Va. W. Va.
The report recounts the McCoys' killing of Hatfield and their own deaths, old indictments in Pike County, and a jailer's reward offer that reignited violence. It describes a recent battle where Dud McCoy and Bud Dempsey were killed, with Dempsey allegedly begging for mercy before being brutally shot.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
South Branch Intelligencer · 3 February 1888 · page 2
A Kentucky Jailer Reopens the Fight
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Ketchum Keystone · Ketchum, Idaho
This passage is a local newspaper column reporting on school attendance honors, travel news, and winter ranching conditions in a Western town. It lists pupils named McCoy and Hatfield among many others on an honor roll, unrelated to the feud itself.
The Ketchum Keystone · 4 February 1888 · page 3
SCHOOL DEPARTMENT
There has been another murder among the McCoy-Hatfield outlaws in Kentucky. A corpse in the dead house of a Colum bus hospital was partially devoured by rats.
Clipping to come
Western Kansas World · Wakeeney, Kan.
Officials from Logan County, West Virginia, asked Governor Wilson for armed assistance to suppress the ongoing Hatfield-McCoy feud after renewed killings. The report notes the vendetta began after the Civil War and had recently flared up again despite earlier hopes of peace.
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
Clipping to come
Western Kansas World · Wakeeney, Kan.
An agent sent by Governor Wilson to investigate the Hatfield-McCoy vendetta returned to Charleston, West Virginia, reporting that both sides had disbanded and the trouble had ended, at least for the present. As a result, Governor Wilson rescinded his earlier order calling out the militia.
-NeCur Feud. Va., April 8.—In st been received here v night Jerry Hatfield. At” Devil" A nse, and intimately Jb the Hatfields, who have l»een P<1 in the well known end along tig Sandy, was killed at Logan (House by a man named M. C. lee, .connected with the McCoys. The f oc urred about 3 o'clock at hnd Lee’s weapon was a Spring of the army pattern. Hatfield
Clipping to come
The Diamond Drill · Crystal Falls, Mich.
The report states that Governor Wilson of West Virginia has been asked by Logan County authorities to send troops to suppress the ongoing McCoy-Hatfield feud. This reflects official concern over the escalating violence between the two families.
The Diamond Drill · 4 February 1888 · page 2
^cia! Dityatch lo trie Intelligencer, Charleston, W. Va., April 2.?Information has just reached this city stating that Jerry Hatfield, a couoin of Anse Hatfield, became engaged in a quarrel with M. C. Lee at Logan Court House on Saturday night, which resulted in Lee
Clipping to come
Narragansett Herald · Narragansett Pier, R.I.
Logan County citizens appealed to Governor Wilson for troops as fighting between the Hatfields and McCoys suspended local business. Wilson responded by dispatching two companies of infantry to suppress the warring factions.
Narragansett Herald · 4 February 1888 · page 4
a deputy sheriff of Tike county, Ky. The killing, if such it proves to be, was entirely the result of a personal altercation and is not to be attributed in any way to the famous Hatlield-McCoy feud.
Clipping to come
Martinsburg Herald · Martinsburg, W. Va.
Logan county, West Virginia officials asked Governor Wilson to send state militia to suppress the ongoing McCoy-Hatfield vendetta. The Governor of West Virginia also issued a requisition for the extradition of persons arrested in connection with the feud.
Martinsburg Herald · 4 February 1888 · page 2
the hospital and Lawtou is very low. a Woman at tli?? UottoUl f ii. Charleston, W. Ya.. April ?.^Mike Lee. who shot and kill .1 J rry llat field at Logan Court Bouse last week, was arrested Wednesday in a coal bank near the town. The. killing of Hatfield had nothing to do with the Hatfield? McCoy vendetta. There had ben a grudge between Lee aud Hatfield, and when Hatfield visited the pi: whore he was killed the keeper of the house ordered him away. Uatfi .k her and started away*. The woman called upon the men present to aveuge her. Lee responded and shot Liatfieid with an army musket just as be i .. pped out of tin1 house.
Clipping to come
Martinsburg Independent · Martinsburg, W. Va.
A brief notice reports that troubles between citizens of Logan County, W. Va., and Pike County, Ky., are nearly over, calling the affair disgraceful and urging punishment of leading offenders. It notes that Governor Wilson has demanded the Kentucky governor return nine West Virginia citizens allegedly kidnapped and jailed in Pike County.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 2 days later.
Wrong
Martinsburg Independent · 4 February 1888 · page 4
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
Clipping to come
Martinsburg Independent · Martinsburg, W. Va.
Col. W.L. Mahan reports to Governor Wilson that he investigated the Hatfield-McCoy feud and found the Hatfields to be law-abiding citizens, with peace temporarily restored after a violent outbreak. He details how Pike County men illegally kidnapped several McCoy allies and Hatfield relatives and killed 'old man Vance' without warning.
Martinsburg Independent · 4 February 1888 · page 4
MAY RESUME AT ANY MOMENT
ween here for some two or three weeks abstracting titles and at tending court, left Tuesday for hia home in Charleston, u 1,1 tbe ease of the State against M. (,’. Lee for the murder of Jerre Hatfield, the court refused to grant bail, and on motion of the prisoner he was sent to the jail at Charleston. The case of the State against James McConias was continued on Wednesday, and McKinney ad mitted to bail in the sum of one thousand dollars. The Daily Gazette, of Charles
Clipping to come
Wheeling Register · Wheeling, W. Va.
The report publishes for the first time official correspondence between the governors of West Virginia and Kentucky over the kidnapping of West Virginia citizens by Frank Phillips's gang. It includes a sworn petition and affidavit from W. P. Floyd detailing the illegal seizure of named men, now jailed in Pike County, Kentucky, as grounds for Governor Wilson's demand for their return.
Wheeling Register · 4 February 1888 · page 1
GOVERNOR WILSON'S ACTION Justified in Refusing to Render Up the Hatfields to be Lynched by Mob — Phillips and His Gang an Unfit Party to Receive the Prisoners.
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
Clipping to come
Wheeling Register · Wheeling, W. Va.
A sworn petition by W.P. Floyd details how nine West Virginia citizens were forcibly seized without legal process and taken to Pike County, Kentucky, where they remain jailed. The petition asks the Governor of West Virginia to demand their return from Kentucky's governor, followed by a letter testimonial from a New Yorker defending the Hatfields' character.
Wheeling Register · 4 February 1888 · page 1
THE PETITION AND AFFIDAVIT.
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Wheeling Register · Wheeling, W. Va.
A government surveyor who worked in the area in 1883-84, guided by Hatfield family members, writes defending the Hatfields as law-abiding, hard-working people. He claims local opinion uniformly blamed the McCoys as aggressors, citing an alleged unprovoked attack by Randall McCoy and sons on a Hatfield at a Blackberry Creek election.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
Wheeling Register · 4 February 1888 · page 1
AN INTERESTING LETTER
Transcript to come.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
Wheeling Register · Wheeling, W. Va.
Johnson Hatfield Sr. swears that attorney P.A. Cline agreed to use influence with Kentucky's Governor to halt pursuit of indicted Hatfields in exchange for $225, which was deposited with A.J. Auxier. The affidavit alleges Cline falsely claimed he had already spent $225 securing rewards and a requisition for the men's arrest in West Virginia.
Wheeling Register · 4 February 1888 · page 3
HATFIELD'S AFFIDAVIT
Mexico and Arizona. Tiie trunks of a jewelry salesman were broken open at Waverly, la., and $20,000 worm oi gooas stolen. Dave Stratton, who killed four men during the Hatfield-McCoy feud, was
Clipping to come
Wheeling Register · Wheeling, W. Va.
Sworn statements describe an arrangement where money was deposited to pay detective Cline if he could persuade Kentucky's governor to drop efforts to arrest Anderson Hatfield and others indicted for the McCoy murders. The affidavits allege Cline falsely claimed the money was spent on rewards and requisitions, and the passage also includes official correspondence between the governors of Kentucky and West Virginia regarding the extradition requisition.
Wheeling Register · 4 February 1888 · page 3
HATFIELD'S AFFIDAVIT.
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
Clipping to come
Wheeling Register · Wheeling, W. Va.
Kentucky's Governor Buckner presses West Virginia's Governor Wilson for extradition of Hatfield and others, citing new crimes and old indictments. Wilson responds detailing delays, exempting two suspects based on alibi evidence, and revealing information that the requisition process was being used to extort money rather than pursue justice.
Wheeling Register · 4 February 1888 · page 3
PERPETRATED OTHER CRIMES
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Morning News · Savannah, Ga.
Governor Buckner of Kentucky denied West Virginia's demand to surrender Hatfield gang members held in Pikeville jail, saying the courts must decide via habeas corpus proceedings. The special agent who investigated the feud believes bad men exist on both sides deserving punishment, but is skeptical of one-sided accounts.
The Morning News · 6 February 1888 · page 2
BAD MEN ON BOTH SIDES.
A !.u omotive, one of the greatest i f iiliing ageneits, has come to the i.ihf i f Kentucky and West Virginia ti..iu the llaUield - McCoy vendetta.
Clipping to come
The Indianapolis Journal · Indianapolis, Ind.
Kentucky Governor Buckner declined West Virginia's demand to surrender Hatfield gang members held at Pikeville, saying the matter must go through the courts via habeas corpus. The report also notes that special agent Mahan, who earlier advised against sending troops, believes bad men exist on both sides but is skeptical of either side's self-serving claims.
The Indianapolis Journal · 6 February 1888 · page 1
Buckner Will Not Surrender the Hatfields.
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Evening World · New York, N.Y.
The report says the Hatfield-McCoy feud has ended after much bloodshed, but a new jurisdictional fight has broken out between Kentucky and West Virginia over the Hatfield prisoners held at Pikeville. Kentucky's Governor Buckner refuses to surrender them to West Virginia, raising fears of renewed hostilities between the two states' factions.
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
Clipping to come
Alexandria Gazette · Alexandria, D.C.
Governor Buckner of Kentucky ruled that he lacks authority to surrender the Hatfield-McCoy combatants to West Virginia. He stated the matter must instead be settled by the courts.
Alexandria Gazette · 6 February 1888 · page 2
NEWS OF THE DAY.
Transcript to come.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
The Atlanta Constitution · Atlanta, Ga.
Colonel Mahon reports to Governor Wilson after investigating the Hatfield-McCoy vendetta, describing the Hatfields as law-abiding and blaming Pike County men for illegally kidnapping several individuals under false pretense of legal authority. The report also notes that Frank Phillips' party shot and killed 'old man Vance' without demanding surrender.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Atlanta Constitution · 7 February 1888 · page 5
Governor of Ohio in 1871, and in 1877 was sent to France as United Statss Minister. Frank I'. Schiffsaur, Mayor of Arkan sas City, Kan., has been arrested on a charge of embezzling $9847.63 of the city's money. Bob Shf.lton, colored, was hanged at Laurens, S. C, for the murder of William Rayford. The rope slipped on the first drop and a second attempt had to be made. The notorious feud between the Kentucky families of McCoy and Hatfield has come to an end, both sides agreeing to lay down their arms and live quiet lives.
See moreSee less
The feud has been in progress twenty years, and has cost at least twenty lives. Only one man "Cap" Hatfield was hanged. John Wolveklixe, a section fireman of the Northern Pacific Railroad, was knocked ilown by two drunken Indians near Spokane Falls, Washington, and scalped. At last ac counts ho was in a critical condition. A locomotive da?hed into an electric street-car at Cleveland, Ohio, killing one pas senger and injuring a dozen more in different degrees of severity. At a dance near Bivins, Ky., Ed and Tom Lancaster, aged fourteen and sixteen, killed James Higgms and fatally wounded Jesse
Clipping to come
The Atlanta Constitution · Atlanta, Ga.
The report describes how Kentucky officials, posing as lawmen but lacking proper warrants, seized several Hatfield-aligned men and jailed them in Pike County, sparking cross-border tension. It also notes that Governor Wilson of West Virginia has formally requested their return via requisition to Kentucky's governor.
The Atlanta Constitution · 7 February 1888 · page 5
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Alexandria Gazette · Alexandria, D.C.
Governor Wilson of West Virginia commissioned ex-Congressman Eustis Gibson to represent the state in habeas corpus proceedings in Kentucky, seeking the return of nine prisoners held in the Pike County jail. These men were charged with involvement in the Hatfield-McCoy vendetta, and the case was to be brought before the U.S. district court in Louisville.
Alexandria Gazette · 7 February 1888 · page 2
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
Clipping to come
Paper unidentified
Col. W. L. Mahon reports to Gov. Wilson after investigating the Hatfield-McCoy feud, describing the Hatfields as law-abiding citizens and stating peace has been restored. He attributes the recent violence to Kentucky parties illegally seizing Hatfield allies under false legal authority and killing 'old man Vance' without warning.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Paper unidentified · 7 February 1888 · page 2
The Hatfield--McCoy Vendetta.
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
Clipping to come
Paper unidentified
Armed men captured several Hatfield-aligned individuals and jailed them in Pike County, Kentucky; the report claims Frank Phillips's party killed 'old man' Vance without demanding surrender. West Virginia's governor sought extradition of the prisoners but Kentucky refused, prompting habeas corpus proceedings amid fears that violence could resume.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Paper unidentified · 7 February 1888 · page 2
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Arizona Weekly Journal-Miner · Prescott, Ariz.
The governor of Virginia ordered the state militia to intervene and stop the ongoing Hatfield-McCoy feud. This brief news item appeared amid a roundup of miscellaneous national news items.
Arizona Weekly Journal-Miner · 8 February 1888 · page 2
- A DESPERADO KILLED The Famous liud MuCoy Is Dropped by a Member of the Hatfield Gone Elkhorn W Va November 3 Bud McCoy leader of the notorious McCoy pong waa killed near Tennis Camp Logan county Friday evening by a man named Dcmpsey of tha Ilntfiold gang Eighteen bullets were found in Ins body Other parties are supposed to have assisted in the killing Tho county is u M with excitement and it is believed that Dempsoy and his associates will be found and tho death of McCoy avenged
Clipping to come
Arizona Weekly Journal-Miner · Prescott, Ariz.
A report states that the feud between the Hatfields of Logan County, West Virginia, and the McCoys of Pike County, Kentucky, has ended for now. Governor Wilson's agent reported both sides had disbanded, prompting the governor to cancel the militia call-up.
Arizona Weekly Journal-Miner · 8 February 1888 · page 2
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
National Republican (Washington City) · D.C.
Ex-Representative Eustis Gibson has been commissioned to represent West Virginia in habeas corpus proceedings seeking the return of nine prisoners from Kentucky connected to the Hatfield-McCoy vendetta. The report is brief, noting only the legal representation assigned to the case.
National Republican (Washington City) · 8 February 1888 · page 1
West Virginia After tho McCoys
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
Clipping to come
The Morning News · Savannah, Ga.
West Virginia's governor commissioned ex-Congressman Eustis Gibson to represent the state in habeas corpus proceedings in Kentucky, seeking the return of nine prisoners held in the Pike County jail. These men were charged with involvement in the Hatfield-McCoy vendetta, and the case would be heard in the U.S. District Court in Louisville.
The Morning News · 8 February 1888 · page 1
KENTUCKY'S PRISONERS.
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Indianapolis Journal · Indianapolis, Ind.
Governor Wilson commissioned ex-Congressman Eustace Gibson to represent West Virginia in habeas corpus proceedings in Kentucky, seeking the return of nine prisoners held in the Pike County jail. The prisoners were charged with involvement in the Hatfield-McCoy vendetta, and the case was to be heard in the U.S. District Court in Louisville.
The Indianapolis Journal · 8 February 1888 · page 1
Tho Hatfield Outlaws.
BUD MCCOY, the noted outlaw, was killed by members of the Hatfield gang at Tennis Camp, Logan County, Va. FIRE at San Francisco destroyed the
Clipping to come
The Climax · Richmond, Ky.
The report notes that Kentucky Governor Simon Bolivar Buckner has refused to dispatch state troops to Pike County to quell the ongoing Hatfield-McCoy feud. The item appears as a brief notice amid a page of local advertisements.
The Climax · 8 February 1888 · page 3
VBUU IN W'kst VIIUilNJA. [it May Result in Another WarSlmllnr to tho Hat Hehl-McCoy Strife. PARKKRSIilTRa. W. Va., Nov. IL? another feud has ended in the lower hart, of this State by the bullet. Some Lime ago Moses Napper, brother of tho Iioted Kentucky Hill Napper, whose >ody was reported to have been found fiddled by Hat ft old bullets, and Ander .on Walker, deputy sheriff of Wayne toiinty, fell out over a timber transac? tor.. Napper was arrested and put to con idcrablo trouble, and be swore thathe von Id avenge his wrongs.
See moreSee less
On Friday a arge crowd of people congregated at front's Hill, the county seat, to cele ?rato tho Democratic victory, and mong them were Napper and Walker, ['hero was considerable drinking, but io trouble arose until the two men met t a drinking resort. As soon as they one another each man reached for
Clipping to come
St. Paul Daily Globe · Saint Paul, Minn.
Governor Wilson of West Virginia commissioned ex-Congressman Eustice Gibson to represent the state in habeas corpus proceedings in Kentucky, seeking return of nine prisoners held in the Pike county jail. These men were charged with involvement in the Hatfield-McCoy vendetta, and the case would be heard in U.S. district court at Louisville.
St. Paul Daily Globe · 8 February 1888 · page 1
Time Something Was Done
I!ud McCoy, the noted outlaw, was k.llod by members of the Hatfield gang at Tennis Camp, Logan County, Va. I* irk at San Francisco destroyed the
Clipping to come
The Evening World · New York, N.Y.
A New York World correspondent traveled into the mountain territory of West Virginia and Kentucky to report on the decades-long feud between the Hatfields and McCoys. The report describes over twenty deaths, including the murder of Capt. Vance and three McCoys tied to a tree and shot, and portrays a lawless region where children are trained with rifles and residents pledge allegiance to one side or the other.
The passage describes the geography of Logan County, West Virginia, home of the Hatfields, detailing its size, terrain, and the Tug Fork river boundary with Kentucky. It also depicts the lawless, clannish culture of the mountaineers and the typical log cabin lifestyle, diet, and living conditions of the region's residents.
The Evening World · 8 February 1888 · page 1
THE SCENE OF THE WARFARE
30J. The Texas Farmer comes out -with a now head. If the condition of the order of which it is the offi cial journal is to be judged bj Bro. Shaw's paper it is obviously in a flourishing condition. THE.McCoy-Hatfield fund of West Virginia is still on. One of the ilc Coys who was known to have killed eight men has recently baen killed, by one of the Hat,fields, and it is generally believed that his death will be avenged by friends of the McCoy faction.
Clipping to come
The Evening World · New York, N.Y.
A reporter's party is stopped by a young armed picket on watch for McCoys or Hatfields while traveling through Pike County, Kentucky. The piece describes the isolated mountain settlements, their log houses, scarce trade with distant towns, and primitive way of life unchanged for a century.
The Evening World · 8 February 1888 · page 1
HALTED BY A YOUTHFUL PICKET.
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Somerset Herald · Somerset, Pa.
This dispatch from Louisville recounts the long history of the Hatfield-McCoy feud, including the 1882 election fight, the killing of a McCoy constable's family members, and the New Year's Eve 1888 raid that killed two of McCoy's children and injured his wife. It also reports that Pike County officials have just asked Kentucky's governor for arms and ammunition to defend residents against further Hatfield attacks.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Somerset Herald · 8 February 1888 · page 2
The Bloody Vendetta
—— THE KILLING OF BUD M'COY. Yeritlention of the Report and Other In tere sting ne idents of the Tragedy. teresting Incidents of the Tragedy, TRS aE {Special telegram to the Dispateh.) \ Cirartrgroy, W, Va,, November 12, — Yhe rumored killing of Bud McCoy, vne of the notorions Hatfield-MeCoy | party, has been verified and the particn Jars received Liere, It seems that on the oth of October Bnd MeCoy, having caten dinner with one John Goshom, in Pike county ®Ky., started away from the house on horseback, A short dis tance away he met Ples, MeCoy and Bill Dyer, who as soon as he Lad gotten by | opened five and put a number of bullets into him.
See moreSee less
He died instantly, but the pair continued their fire, riddling his ody. ‘They pounded his head with a yock to be sure he was dead, ANOTHER FIGHT, The pair then fled, but a posse was goon made up and started in pursait. | They were followed several days and overtaken in Buchanan county, Va, A fight ensued, in which McCoy was shghtly wounded, He then surrendered, by Dyer escaped and is still at large, thongh a heavy reward is offered for | ] him, From what can be learned it would | geem that one Aaron Smith is at the bot tom of the killing, aud Ples, MeCoy after his arrest, even said that Smith bad | 1 offered him a Winchester and a new re | volver if ho would fire the first shot, ELOPED WITH HIS SISTER, | The murdered man eloped some time ago with Smith's sister and later deserted her, She then married Dyer. Smith | escaped from the Pike county jail last enmmer, and Pud MeCoy, as deputy sherifl, attempted to arrest him several | times. Smith, enraged at this and at his sister's desertion by MeCoy, 18 gaid to bave been at the bottom of the murder, nnd 18 under arrest as an accomplice, Ples. MeCoy, who is undor arrest for the Xilling, is & mere boy, not over sixteen Years of ace. -
Clipping to come
The Somerset Herald · Somerset, Pa.
The passage describes the Hatfield gang's New Year's Eve raid on the McCoy home, killing Alifair and Calvin McCoy and beating Sarah McCoy, followed by a Pike County posse's pursuit into West Virginia that killed two Hatfield associates and wounded others in a shootout. It notes West Virginia's refusal to honor extradition requests and warns of further Hatfield retaliation against Pikeville.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Somerset Herald · 8 February 1888 · page 2
ANOTHER FIGHT, The pair then fled, but a posse was goon made up and started in pursait. | They were followed several days and overtaken in Buchanan county, Va, A fight ensued, in which McCoy was shghtly wounded, He then surrendered, by Dyer escaped and is still at large, thongh a heavy reward is offered for | ] him, From what can be learned it would | | geem that one Aaron Smith is at the bot tom of the killing, aud Ples, MeCoy
Clipping to come
Wheeling Register · Wheeling, W. Va.
Governor Wilson of West Virginia appointed ex-Congressman Eustace Gibson to represent the state in habeas corpus proceedings seeking the return of nine prisoners held in the Pike County, Kentucky jail. These men were charged with involvement in the Hatfield-McCoy vendetta, and the case was to be heard in the U.S. District Court in Louisville.
Wheeling Register · 8 February 1888 · page 1
GIBSON CHOSEN
I , \ .ut id* prostrate I N-;it.*n ’i»a jelly with si' iV'‘ y,(.t ..lx ttiug this fearful ■d A purling v made tip and the a branch of Knox county, Virginia, o.rtaken and a short ... J“ , - McCoy received a ,h «i.und >*u the cheek and
Clipping to come
Wheeling Register · Wheeling, W. Va.
Kentucky's Adjutant General, Gen. Sam E. Hill, returns from the feud region and gives an account largely matching earlier reports, blaming the Hatfields as the original aggressors. He doubts the Hatfields will attempt to rescue their jailed members from the Pike County jail.
Wheeling Register · 8 February 1888 · page 1
Report of Gov. Buckner's Agent
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
Clipping to come
The Big Sandy News · Louisa, Ky.
The item comments that the Hatfield-McCoy affairs have been exaggerated and lied about by correspondents of newspapers, especially Cincinnati and Louisville papers. It states that such reports would give the impression the feud is among the worst in the country, but the editor who lives nearby claims this is not the case.
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
Clipping to come
The Big Sandy News · Louisa, Ky.
Kentucky Governor Buckner has refused to hand over a member of the Hatfield party currently jailed in Pikeville to West Virginia authorities. He states the matter is for the courts to decide, not the Executive, and suggests the Hatfields pursue habeas corpus writs for an early hearing.
The Big Sandy News · 9 February 1888 · page 2
BUD MCCOY, the noted outlaw, was killed by members of the Hatfield gang at Tennis Camp, Logan County, Va. FIRE at San Francisco destroyed the
Clipping to come
Crawford Avalanche · Grayling, Mich.
A Charleston, W. Va. special reports that the vendetta between the Hatfields of Logan County and the McCoys of Pike County has ended for now, with both sides disbanding after a state agent's visit. Governor Wilson reportedly countermanded his militia order, though the same brief also notes Logan County authorities had called on him to send troops to suppress the feud.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Crawford Avalanche · 9 February 1888 · page 4
Tho public school at this placi "ill close on Saturday evening Iteeembcr lath, with an exhibi tion. All are very cordially in ^ibr l to at.teud. whiskey, and thereby destroying the peace of onr community and leading our boys to rain. We be lieve that the officers are on the right track, and we know that they will “hew to the line, let the chips fall where they may.* The Logan County Temperance
Clipping to come
The Beatrice Daily Express · Beatrice, Neb.
West Virginia Governor Wilson commissioned ex-Congressman Gibson to represent the state in habeas corpus proceedings in Louisville. The proceedings concerned the return of nine prisoners held in the Pike County, Kentucky jail who were charged with involvement in the Hatfield-McCoy feud.
The Beatrice Daily Express · 9 February 1888 · page 1
The Hatfield-McCoy Feud
Floyd Buchanan,Gliarley Buch anan, Elias Hatfield and Green Ellis succeeded in killing two fine bears last week on Ruin Creek. Fonaajjears were started and they are now after the other two. For the next two months the ad dress of Maj. J. A Nighbert and wife is Plateau Hotel, Hot Springs, Arkansas. We hope they will have a niee time, and that they i
Clipping to come
Clarke Courier · Berryville, Va.
Governor Wilson of West Virginia sent an agent to Kentucky's Governor Buckner demanding release of West Virginia prisoners held on charges of involvement in the Hatfield-McCoy troubles. Buckner refused, and West Virginia authorities announced plans to pursue habeas corpus proceedings, claiming the arrests were illegal.
Clarke Courier · 9 February 1888 · page 2
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
Clipping to come
West Virginia Argus · Kingwood, W. Va.
The digest reports that Logan County citizens appealed to West Virginia's governor for militia to stop the Hatfield-McCoy fighting, that two companies of infantry were then dispatched, and finally that Governor Wilson declared the 'famous war' over with no need for troops. The three squibs, printed together, give contradictory snapshots of how serious the conflict actually was.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
West Virginia Argus · 9 February 1888 · page 1
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Fisherman & Farmer · Edenton, N.C. · and 1 other paper
West Virginia's Governor Wilson officially announced that the Hatfield-McCoy feud had ended, stating no militia would be needed to suppress it. The brief item appeared amid a roundup of unrelated national and international news items.
T11E HATFIELD-M'COY FEUD AQnarrel in Which Thirty Fersons Have Been Killed in as Man" Years, For Two lean Neither Side nas Been on a War Footing, and It Is Hoped the Coming of Kailwajs Will Bring Permanent Peace, ntuitlnirton (W.Ya.) Letter In New YoTk Tribune. Dime novelists and sensational reporters have dona much mischief by magnifying the bloody exploits on these borders of a few lighting families. In adjusting their Jittle domestic difficulties, the Hatfields and McCoys have killed about thirty peo ple and maimed and wounded as many more. The Adamses and Brum fields, and the Blaisders and, Brewers have tried to ixnitato them, though on an unpretentious scale.'
See moreSee less
Bat their crimes have been made a reproach to the whole population. Between the Guyandotte and the Big Sandy lie some of the tin est hard-wood lands on the conti nent. Walnut grows nearly six feet thick, and there are noble poplars as tall and straight as church spires. The soil is spread over great sheets of coal, and the rivers afford good highways for commerce. Yet progress has been retarded and strangers friehtened away by false charges of border , xutlianum against worthy and peaceable communities. The Hatfield and McCoy feud dates from the civil war. The Hatfields, who live in West Virginia, were in the confederate army. The McCoys, in Kentucky, organ ized as "home guards" for the protection of Northern sympaiaizejs. In the hostilities the Hatfields and their friends killed some of the McCoys, and there has been bad blood between them ever since. The first notable outbreak, however, was only about ten years ago, when Ellison Hatfield was murdered in an election brawl on the Kentacky side of the Tag fotk of the BigSandy river. His assailants, three Mctoy boys, were seized by the Hatfields, tied to poplar bushes and riddled with bullets. The Mc Coys then began a seties of raids into West Virginia, and succeed! in landing several of the Hatfields in Kentucky jails. In retaliation. "Jim" Vance and a gang of Hatfield sympathizers crossed into Kentucky oneNew Year's night, burned the McCoy house and shot one of the Mc Coys as he lied. Among the inmates were several women and children, who were driven out in their night-dresses. Alafray McCoy, the eldest daughter, was slain on the spot by a half-witted fellow named Mountz, who was afterward hanged in 'Kentucky. Meautime the Governors of the two States issned requisitions andoflered rewards, aud a swarm ofde- . tectives helped to make mischief. Vance, who was with the Hatfields in the confed erate service, was finally killed one after noon by the McCoys, who are said to have shaken hands over his dead body. Since then the Hatfields have moved Sack into Ihe country from Tug river, the McCoys have done the same on the Kentucky side, and a truce has been called. CHARACTER OF THE COMBATANTS. This feud has never included more than the Hatfields and their immediate rela tives, a few desperadoes in hiding in the mountains and some almost equally lawless . ietectives. The fighting has not spread beyond the banks of the Big Sandy, where the Hatfields have been hunting and rais ing corn since their ancestors -came from the Valley of Virginia one-hundred years ago. Their neighbors are rnde and sturdy backwoodsmen, narrowed by continual m . termarriage and the lack of railroads, but without any passion for bloodshed. When the Tollivars were disporting themselves in - Kentucky a few years ago a band of "Regu 1 lators'' , restored order by removing their chief, and if this affair had been confined to one State the leaders would have suf fered long ago, but the situation is peculiar. The Hatfields at home are quiet and well behaved. Their excesses have all been committed on the Kentucky side, while in Veat Virginia the McCoys are v tlie aggressors. Consequently the requisi tions for arrest have always come from, another State, and many innocent people have been iudicted, Now, nobody cares to give up his friends to outsiders, with the - chance of seeing them unjustly condemned, : and this reluctance has shielded the true culprits. It is strenuously denied that the Hatfields .terrorize their neighbors. Yet, instead of their meeting with open condem nation, the Governor has been asked to pro tect them. They are condoled with over, the kidnaping of their allies; men slap them on the back and exchange joke with them., as though murder were a humane and polite diversion, and they ride into town with their rifles slung over their shoulders and bargain in the stores and buy and.sell bank stock like so many thrifty dea-" cons. The disposition to regard them as a sort of cross between 'John Howard and. - Michael the Archangel, and the McCoys as a depraved combination of Judas Iscariot aud Billy the Kid, is, however, dying out. . It is seen that both sides are to blame, and some people are not afraid to say so.. The administration of the local courts in the past has not been what it should be. A single fearless editor or preacher conld probably have stopped the trouble long ago. But the local sheets are timid, and at church the belligerents, stack their arms - and pray with one eye on the pastor and another on the door, borne of the magis-. trates to save expenses have actually hesi tated to imprison criminals. The present circuit judge, however, will not be trilled .with. At every term there is a string of convictionsfor carrying concealed weapons, and he indicts in all cases the full penalty . ' of una and imprisonment without regard to anybody's brag or threats. The recent , withdrawal of all rewards by the Gov ernors of the two States seems to have worked well Nobody has fallen in the fued for nearly two years. and ;the survivors are trying to live decently. "Cap" Hatfield, the son of "Bad Anse." is heartily sick of the vendetta, and realizes that under other circumstances he might have been something better than an outlaw. He taught himself to read. and. write, and for a man brought up in the mountains, is credited with a "right smart of business sense." He has read much his tory and "got in some pretty good snatches on medicine." and, just now is wrestling with a borrowed law-book. He married the widow of a man killed in ambush, outside of the feud, and has a pretty daughter. It is due to hia adroit management that the Hatfields have not been surrendered. His father, -Bad Anse4" or "Devil Arise," as he is afieetinnally nicknamed, is the pres ent Hatfield patriarch. He, too, is tired' of sleeping on a Winchester, is declared to be inoffensive when no McCoys are about, and says he is wilimg to let the whole thing drop if they are. As an earnest, both men are laying down their ritles, though they wear a few reovlvers "for protection," and the father has subscribed toward the building fund of a new Metho dist church. The women, although "raised to it," are nnconquerably averse to sudden bereavement. Vance's widow boasts that she can "bring down a squirrel from the highest treetop, every pop." but most of them shine lietter as house-keepers. Ala' fray McCoy was a religions woman, and when Mocntz threatened her said she had prayed for her euc-mie for years. ' THE RAILWAY AS A PEACE-MAKKR. The combatants now live thirty miles apart, and the railroad that will soon sepa-' rate them, will probably do more to pro mote peace than a dozen proclamations. In the border counties the hills are high, the forests thick, and the rivers swift and deep. There are no turnpikes and no telegraphs, and the sherifls have to ride on horseback over blind trsils and to ford dangerous currents. A train service will alter all that. By next summer the rail road, a branch of the Norfolk & Western, will be finished but for the piercing of a long tunnel. The inhabitants, in anticipa tion of fresh prosperity, are anxious to effacethe stain fastened on them. "Of course," thejtsav, "we have our faults, but were as good as most backwoods commun ities. There has been only one arrest for theft in Logan county, and the charge was not proved. We have no locks on our doors, except at a few of the stores, and the keys of those are lost. The chickens roost on the fences and the apple trees, and are they ever stolen? The roverlets that our women weave are stored in our porches. The hams we cure hang outside in rows. Our corn-cribs are open to everybody, and are they ever pilfered! If you want to know rhat hospitality means, ride over and sea us. You'd be safer with a pocketful of greenbacks in Logan county than in walk ing up and down Broadway in New York city. As to our intelligence, of course wo have no Browning societies and circulating libraries. But we follow the news and get journals from New York aud Cincinnati. We have two pretty good hotels. Next spring we shall have a bank, and we're building a stone church. Our children get four months' schooling. Several of our people are worth $r),000f and all of us keep the run of politics." I have asked many of the best men who are trying to reform the district what guar antee they offer to strangers. Their reply is substantially: "Don't encourage people to come here who can't put np with a roach country and rough ways. Don't tell them we are models of virtue, or that ournotions of social intercourse are all sound. But do sar that we are not all cut-throats and thieves. Say that the feuds are strictly family affairs, and that neutrals are un molested. Wre are not fond of swaggering and flourishing tire-arms, and the man who has killed the greatest number of people isn't the most looked up to. If we don't re fuse to associate with the Hatfields, it isn't because we think they have done right. What we need is somebody to persuade us that the greatest virtue is not in being peaceable only when let alone. When we have learned that, you can trust us to be have." r
Clipping to come
Also printed in 1 paper
Narragansett Herald · Narragansett Pier, R.I. · 4 February 1888
Rock Island Daily Argus · Rock Island, Ill.
A New York Herald correspondent in Pike County, Kentucky reports on the causes and current state of the Hatfield-McCoy feud, describing terror in the region and the presence of troops needed to restore order rather than fight. The reporter himself was shot at from ambush while trying to reach the Hatfield stronghold and had to turn back without securing an interview.
Rock Island Daily Argus · 10 February 1888 · page 2
A BAD PLACE FOR REPORTERS
The Hatfield and McCoy feud dates from the civil war. The Hatfields, who live in West Virginia, were in the confederate army. The McCoys, in Kentucky, organ ized as "home guards" for the protection of Northern sympaiaizejs. In the hostilities the Hatfields and their friends killed some of the McCoys, and there has been bad blood between them ever since. The first notable outbreak, however, was only about ten years ago, when Ellison Hatfield was murdered in an election brawl on the Kentacky side of the Tag fotk of the BigSandy river.
See moreSee less
His assailants, three Mctoy boys, were seized by the Hatfields, tied to poplar bushes and riddled with bullets. The Mc Coys then began a seties of raids into West Virginia, and succeed! in landing several of the Hatfields in Kentucky jails. In retaliation. "Jim" Vance and a gang of Hatfield sympathizers crossed into Kentucky oneNew Year's night, burned the McCoy house and shot one of the Mc Coys as he lied. Among the inmates were several women and children, who were driven out in their night-dresses. Alafray McCoy, the eldest daughter, was slain on the spot by a half-witted fellow named Mountz, who was afterward hanged in 'Kentucky. Meautime the Governors of the two States issned requisitions andoflered rewards, aud a swarm ofde- . tectives helped to make mischief. Vance, who was with the Hatfields in the confed erate service, was finally killed one after noon by the McCoys, who are said to have shaken hands over his dead body. Since then the Hatfields have moved Sack into Ihe country from Tug river, the McCoys have done the same on the Kentucky side, and a truce has been called.
Clipping to come
The Evening Bulletin · Maysville, Ky.
A New York Herald dispatch from Pike County, Kentucky describes the terror surrounding the Hatfield-McCoy feud and the need for troops to restore confidence in law and order along Tug Fork. The correspondent himself was shot at from ambush while trying to reach the Hatfield stronghold and had to turn back without getting an interview.
The Evening Bulletin · 10 February 1888 · page 2
A Correspondent's Narrow Escape
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Der Deutsche Correspondent · Baltimore, Md.
Ex-Congressman Eustace Gibson arrived in Louisville on behalf of West Virginia's Governor Wilson to seek a federal court order extraditing nine Hatfields held in the Pike County, Kentucky jail to Logan County, West Virginia. Kentucky's Governor Buckner had refused the extradition request, and Gibson warned that if states could refuse to surrender such attackers, a formal 'border war' might result.
Der Deutsche Correspondent · 10 February 1888 · page 1
Die Hatfield-McCoy'sche Fehde
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
Clipping to come
Daily Kennebec Journal · Augusta, Me.
A brief dispatch reports that hostilities between the Hatfields and McCoys have flared up again. It claims that troops may be required to suppress the renewed disturbances.
Daily Kennebec Journal · 10 February 1888 · page 1
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
Clipping to come
The Evening World · New York, N.Y.
This item praises the New York World for sending an artist and writer to the Hatfield-McCoy feud scene to capture local color and detail. It frames the feud as a startling, almost unbelievable story for a modern era of railroads and telegraphs, comparing it to tales of wild border life in old Scotland and England.
The Evening World · 10 February 1888 · page 2
A Picture of Barbaric Wickedness
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Shenandoah Herald · Woodstock, Va.
West Virginia's governor sent an agent to demand release of West Virginians held in a Pike County, Kentucky jail on charges tied to the Hatfield-McCoy feud, but Kentucky's governor refused, saying only courts can decide via habeas corpus. West Virginia then commissioned a representative to pursue habeas corpus proceedings in federal court in Louisville.
Shenandoah Herald · 10 February 1888 · page 2
Kentucky Will Not Surrender Them.
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
Clipping to come
The Daily Times · Richmond, Va.
A New York Herald dispatch from Pike County, Kentucky reviews the causes and current state of the Hatfield-McCoy feud, describing widespread terror and the need for troops on both sides of Tug Fork to restore order. The correspondent reports being shot at from ambush while trying to reach the Hatfield stronghold, preventing him from getting an interview.
The Daily Times · 10 February 1888 · page 1
TIIX FAMOUS VKNDKTTA. In this connection a brief history of ( tbe (treat feud, which has been famous the country over for years and has caused bo much bloodshed, will prove of inter- , oat. Though books have been written . about the deeds of the Hatfieldsand 1 .McCoys upon tho southern border of ( West Virginia, and a number of metro* politan newspapers have sent special ' correspondents into Logan county, W. 1 Va., and Pike county, Ky., to obtain in- ' formation upon which were based hair I raising stories greatly exaggerated, tbe J Intklligencku js the only paper that ] has ever publiahed an authentic history ' of the vendetta.
See moreSee less
This history was. on < the 21st of November, 1689, obtained by 1 the 1 ntki LiGKNCKit from "Devil Anse" ' Iiatlield hiuiaelf, while on trial at J fiharleaton for violation of the revenue I Jaws, and published the following day. j
Clipping to come
Shepherdstown Register · Shepherdstown, Va. W. Va.
Governor Buckner declined to release nine West Virginians jailed in Pike County, Kentucky, on charges of involvement in the Hatfield-McCoy feud. West Virginia authorities, through Governor Wilson's appointed representative Eustace Gibson, planned habeas corpus proceedings claiming the men were illegally abducted into Kentucky.
Shepherdstown Register · 10 February 1888 · page 2
living with Phillips, the leader of the ( McCoy outlaws, in Pike county, Kentucky. mubdkrof ellison iiatfikld. "Some twelve months after the above tj.*currecce, Tolbert Farmer and Randall ana Floyd McCoy, who were still anger#t' over the hog suit already described, and more so on account of the
Clipping to come
South Branch Intelligencer · Romney, Va. W. Va.
West Virginia's Governor Wilson issued a requisition to Kentucky's Governor Buckner demanding the return of several men implicated in the Hatfield-McCoy trouble who are currently jailed in Pike County, Kentucky. The petition claims these men, citizens of Logan County, West Virginia, were taken across state lines by the McCoy group without legal process.
South Branch Intelligencer · 10 February 1888 · page 2
TO RELEASE THE WEST VIRGINIANS
Tux news that the famous Hatfield UcOoy feud has ended?stopped short never to go again?will be bailed will dslight throughout the State. Oar nam and fame as a quiet law-abiding pcOpli have suffered immensely by theixag Iterated reports that have been sent ou regarding the vendetta, and now tha unconditional peace has been declarec and an amicable adjustment of all differ ences has been made, a stain npon Wes Virginia's name has been wiped out Thus ends a feud of thirty years dura tlon, and one of the most remarkable, 1 not the bloodiest, vendettas.in the bii tory of this country.
See moreSee less
Wjbt Virginia people have been th subjects of many misrepresentation abroad. None of the sensational storle have been worse and more untrnthfu than the recent tale about "whit -1-?-llonnfl iiTiaf nmnno wfnil BlU VU1 J IIIIC^LU w ? ? -?
Clipping to come
South Branch Intelligencer · Romney, Va. W. Va.
Kentucky's Governor Buckner refuses to surrender the West Virginia men imprisoned at Pikeville, saying the courts alone can decide the matter, while West Virginia's Governor Wilson plans habeas corpus proceedings to free the Hatfields. The state has also hired Hon. Eustace Gibson to help secure release of eight Logan County men allegedly kidnapped by Kentucky parties and jailed in Pike County.
South Branch Intelligencer · 10 February 1888 · page 2
NEWS OF THE WEEK
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Ceredo Advance · Ceredo, W. Va.
A reprinted editorial calls the Hatfield-McCoy feud deaths 'murders' born of 'semi-barbarism' needing education reform, claiming roughly a score of lives lost. The item also reports Governor Wilson hiring Eustace Gibson to secure release of eight Logan county men kidnapped by Kentuckians and jailed in Pike County, threatening legal action if Kentucky's governor does not free them.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 3 days later.
Wrong
Ceredo Advance · 10 February 1888 · page 2
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
Clipping to come
The Palatka Daily News · Palatka, Fla.
The article recounts the long-running Hatfield-McCoy feud along the Tug Fork, describing the infamous 1882 killing of three McCoy brothers and a recent nighttime raid in which a girl and young man were shot and a woman burned alive. It notes that major Eastern papers like the New York World and Herald have sent reporters into the mountains at great risk to verify these stories and found a region in a state of lawless anarchy.
The article reviews recent New York World and Herald reports on the Hatfield-McCoy feud, noting one covered the Hatfield side and the other the McCoy side. It criticizes the breakdown of law in the Big Sandy region, questions the legality of Kentucky's raids into West Virginia to capture prisoners, and calls for state or federal intervention to restore order.
The Palatka Daily News · 11 February 1888 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
ANARCHY ON THE BIG SANDY.
It seems hardly credible that the scenes of centuries ago, the border forays with all the attendant scenes of murder and cruelty are repeated in our days within the borders of the United States. Yet the mountain country through which the line betweed West Virginia and Kentucky runs is the seat of a most destructive warfare of families. These sanguinary feuds began during the war. In fact the war has never been over on Tug Fork of Big Sandy. There have been enough men, women and children murdered in the feud between the Hatfields and the McCoys to have extinguished two ordinary families. But the cabin of the mountaineer swarms with children generally and ail the members of these fami ies know how to shoot, from the stripling to the old grandfather, or grandmother, for that matter. Sex makes but little shade of difference in character among these rude mountaineers.
See moreSee less
The attention of the outside world is occasionally called to these murders by a deed of unusual ferocity, as when three of the McCoy boys, one only fourteen years old, were caught by a gang of Hatfields, tied to bushes and tied hand to hand, then shot down in cold blood the child being killed last of all. Another atrocious deed was committed a short time ago. A raid was made at midnight upon a family of the McCoys by a party of the Hatfields and a young girl, and a young man were shot dead while an old woman was brained by the light of their burning home, and another girl went crazy by the corpse of her brother.
Reporters of various Western and Eastern papers have taken their lives in their hands at various times and gone into these mountain wilds to get at the truth of these stories, to separate truth from rumor. They have had to face visible, tangible danger to do so. Their reports agree in one thing—that there is a condition of affairs in those mountains which are a shame to American civilization. Lying between such States as West Virginia and Kentucky, near Pennsylvania and Ohio, this state of anarchy, where the officers of law belong to either one gang or the other and justice is laughed at, the scenes of barbarity described in these correspondents' letters are set within the very heart of our long settled territory, not in Alaska or the wilds of the Rockies.
The New York World and the New York Herald each devoted about a page of their recent issues to the Hatfield-McCoy feud and describe graphically, not only the bloody battles and massacres, but also the disorganized state of society in the upper regions of the Big Sandy valley. Curiously enough, the two stories form "pendants" to each other. The New York World correspondent has the Hatfield side of the story, the Herald man has the McCoy side.
As travel through the region is entirely suspended by the decree of the murderous gangs, as the United States mails have been interfered with and Kentucky county authorities have made several raids into West Virginia territory to capture members of the Hatfield gang, it is possible that the National government will be called upon to restore order. The Kentucky State authorities have often called out the militia to suppress these bloody murderers. Quiet reigns until the militia returns home, then the war breaks out again. It may be said, in passing, that no State has had more use for its militia during the last ten or twelve years than Kentucky. It might also be remarked that these troublesome mountaineers of Western and Southwestern Kentucky are Republicans by a large majority.
West Virginia has done little to suppress this warfare. The present Governor of that State has done nothing, except to endeavor to procure the custody of the prisoners captured by the authorities of Pike County, Ky. If he intends that these gory-handed Hatfields shall be released after a mockery of a trial he is preparing a lasting disgrace for his State. But as a matter of law he is right—the prisoners made in these raids into West Virginia are held without a shadow of right.
The only hope for the wiping out of this disgrace to America is that the Governors of the two States of Kentucky and West Virginia shall agree to declare themselves unable to put down this insurrection against all law and humanity itself and call for United States troops or that the National authorities shall take measures to protect the mails. Even then there is little hope of a permanent peace until drastic measures are taken. It will require wholesale hanging and the incarceration for life of every one connected with these murders, either as principals or abettors—and that means the conviction of a hundred or two of men and some women.
Nor is the task of capturing these mountaineers, desperate men acquainted with all the fastnesses of the mountains, a small task. The Big Sandy country is exceedingly broken and the movements of even small bodies of troops difficult there. When Mr. McCreary, now in Congress, was Governor of Kentucky, he sent several companies of militia into Breathitt County to suppress the vendetta there. The mountaineers played hide-and-seek with the young men from the cities when sent out in squads to serve warrants on the ringleaders and sent them word of the many occasions on which they might have picked off the unexperienced citizen soldiery. But when they heard that the Governor was organizing companies in the adjacent peaceable counties they came in and surrendered. They knew their chances were only equal with men who were acquainted with the mountains. Nothing will remove this disgrace but the most thorough measures which result in the punishment of every guilty man.
A habeas corpus motion was filed in U.S. Court on behalf of West Virginia regarding the Hatfield prisoners, with lawyers representing both West Virginia and Kentucky's interests. The petition claimed Selkirk McCoy was illegally captured by armed Kentucky invaders and faced danger of assassination while jailed, with the matter now entangled between the two states' governors.
Kentucky officials and attorneys argued over the legality of the West Virginia McCoys' capture and imprisonment, with petitions citing a pending extradition requisition from West Virginia's governor. Adjutant General Hill, investigating the feud for Governor Buckner, reported it began not in Civil War times but from an 1882 bailiff incident, and described finding injured elderly Mrs. McCoy after the New Year's massacre.
The Evening Telegram · 11 February 1888 · page 1
THAT FAMILY FEUD.
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
Clipping to come
Martinsburg Independent · Martinsburg, W. Va.
Governor Wilson of West Virginia commissioned Congressman Eustis Gibson to represent the state in habeas corpus proceedings in Kentucky concerning nine prisoners jailed in Pike County, charged with involvement in the Hatfield-McCoy feud. The case was to be heard in the United States District Court in Louisville, Kentucky.
Martinsburg Independent · 11 February 1888 · page 1
An Inter-State Affair.
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Martinsburg Independent · Martinsburg, W. Va.
Governor Wilson's agent traveled to demand the release of West Virginians held by Kentucky authorities in connection with the Hatfield-McCoy troubles. The agent reported back that Kentucky's governor refused to surrender the prisoners.
Martinsburg Independent · 11 February 1888 · page 5
In a letter sent to the editor of the Wayne News by Captain! Anse Hatfield (Devil Anse)hel bays that general amnesty has been declared in the famous Hat- ’ Hjtld-McCoy feud, that the war < saint in him has abated and he 1 tjgjoices at the prospects of peace. < This letter will serve to quell all I jffaturbance as far as the Hatfield > jgiie is concerned, and it is 1 tfroiyht that a like letter hasbeenje •'publi’Sed in Kentucky. This / state of affairs is the result of the e marriage of one of the Hatfield’s I e to Miss McCoy, and a truce and d peace congress was held shortly t after.
See moreSee less
This sued has been in ex-; I 1 istence since 1873, and there has 1; been no less than one hundred 1 deaths among the participants. I On March. 22nd, at Huron, S. D. the jury in the Hendley . murder case returned a verdict of . manslaughter in the first degree against Fred Hendley, who killed his father last June. Hendley was the leading democratic editor of the state and chairman of the ’ state committee. An order has been received by Colonel Sumner, in command at. Ft. Meade, from the secretary of war to deliver to the civil authori ties Tasunkaota, alias Plenty Horses, indicted at the last term of the United States court held in Deadwood for the murder of Lieu ’ tenat Casey, and Weihpeya, in ' dieted at the same time for the 1 murder of Ranchman Miller dur ' ing the recent Indian outbreak. The two Indians arc now in the . Fort Meade guard house, the niilI itary having refused to surrender them to the civil authorities until an order to do so was made by ! the secretary of war. United ■ States Marshal Frye, has taken ■ the prisoners to Sioux Falls, ■' where they will be tried before . the next term of the United States court convening there April 10.
Clipping to come
Der Deutsche Correspondent · Baltimore, Md.
This German-language commentary criticizes sensationalist press coverage of the Hatfield-McCoy feud, comparing the exaggerated 'anarchy' narrative to similar lawlessness in Rowan County, Kentucky. It cites testimony from a Rowan County investigation showing 20 murders in three years with almost no convictions, illustrating widespread impunity in feud violence.
Der Deutsche Correspondent · 13 February 1888 · page 2
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Wheeling Register · Wheeling, W. Va.
A longtime U.S. Marshal from Kentucky, passing through Philadelphia, discusses the Hatfield-McCoy feud and notes that a judge has granted a writ of habeas corpus for Hatfields jailed in Pikeville, arguing they could not get a fair trial there due to McCoy family ties. He also compares the feud to other Kentucky mountain wars and describes 'Bad' McCoy as the Kentucky faction's leader, killed during a raid on the Hatfields.
Wheeling Register · 13 February 1888 · page 1
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
Clipping to come
Wheeling Register · Wheeling, W. Va.
A telegram reveals Judge Barr granted a writ of habeas corpus for the West Virginia men (Hatfields) held in the Pike County Jail. The report warns that if released, they would likely be lynched by local residents.
Wheeling Register · 13 February 1888 · page 1
HATFIELDS IN DANGER.
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Wheeling Register · Wheeling, W. Va.
West Virginia Governor Wilson told a reporter that newspaper accounts of the Hatfield-McCoy trouble were greatly exaggerated and denied any rift with Kentucky's Governor Buckner. The same dispatch reports Wilson issuing a requisition to Buckner for 28 men charged in the killing of William Dempsey during a Hatfield-McCoy clash in Logan County.
GOVERNOR WILSON Declines to Discuss the Scandalous Stories of a Sensational Newspaper
The feud between the llatfields of West Virginia, and the McCoys, of Kentucky, has been settiefl by the mar riage of Hiss McCoy to one of the
Clipping to come
Semi-Weekly Interior Journal · Stanford, Ky.
A court has granted writs of habeas corpus in the case of the Hatfields, with prisoners to be brought from Pike County to court at West Virginia's expense. Arguments in the case are scheduled for February 20th.
Semi-Weekly Interior Journal · 14 February 1888 · page 2
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
Clipping to come
The Climax · Richmond, Ky.
The report states that Governor Buckner has refused to send state troops into Pike County to suppress the ongoing Hatfield-McCoy feud. It appears as a brief item amid unrelated local news and advertisements.
The Climax · 15 February 1888 · page 3
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
Clipping to come
Omaha Daily Bee · Omaha, Neb.
The article describes the deep-rooted culture of violence among illiterate mountain families along the Tug Fork, comparing the feud to Scottish Highland vendettas like Glencoe. It also recounts how Major Merriman's Civil War regiment included both McCoys and Farleys, bitter enemies who nonetheless fought loyally for the Union.
Omaha Daily Bee · 15 February 1888 · page 6
THE M'COY AND HATFIELD'S FEUD.
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Omaha Daily Bee · Omaha, Neb.
The passage recounts a melodramatic Civil War story of Sergeant Markham's execution for killing a man named Farley, tying his dying words to the Hatfield-McCoy feud. It then offers an origin legend claiming the feud began when a dancing master married and deserted a McCoy daughter, prompting Hatfield retaliation for insults to her.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 2 days later.
Wrong
Omaha Daily Bee · 15 February 1888 · page 6
WILL DEVELOP INTO A VENDETTA. Both sides have since resolved themselves into factions, and the shooting will be kept up indefinitely, both factions swearing vengeance. The sheriff of Holmes county was apprised of the affair, and upon arriv ing at the scene failed to get •! iller, who in the meantime ran oyer into Walton county. The ill feeling between Miller and Aar n originated five years ago, and has been kept alive ever since until the friends of botn parties are involved. Another HatfleldMcCoy feud is imminent. A MOONSHINERS’ STRONGHOLD.
Clipping to come
The Abbeville Press and Banner · Abbeville, S.C.
Citizens of Logan County, West Virginia appealed to Governor Wilson to send militia to disperse the warring Hatfield and McCoy factions, as business had been suspended. Governor Wilson responded by sending two companies of infantry to suppress the feuding factions.
The Abbeville Press and Banner · 15 February 1888 · page 2
About the time the grippe loosens its clutche3, the spring fever will come along and there we are. President Harrison declares that he cannot appoint a World s Fair com missioner because there is no vacancy. But he does not explain why he for got the 8,000,000 negroes in making up the list in the first place. The eolobrated Hatfield-McCoy
Clipping to come
San Antonio Daily Light · San Antonio, Tex.
A U.S. Marshal's deputy reported that he and the Pike County jailor brought a Hatfield prisoner to Catlettsburg and were awaiting further orders. No demonstration or excitement occurred among the McCoys during the removal, and nine more prisoners were expected to follow with guards the next night.
San Antonio Daily Light · 15 February 1888 · page 1
Effected Without Trouble
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Weekly Register · Point Pleasant, Va. W. Va.
The Wheeling Register condemns New York and Pittsburgh newspapers for sensationalized and allegedly false reporting on the Hatfield-McCoy feud, arguing it unfairly damages West Virginia's reputation. The report also notes that Judge Barr of the U.S. Federal Court granted a writ of habeas corpus for Hatfield family members, ruling they had been unlawfully imprisoned in Pike County jail after being seized by the McCoys.
The Weekly Register · 15 February 1888 · page 2
TJie IlutlleldH aud MeCoya. We suggest that our versatile friend Ex'Congreesman Atkinson, who has rc cently written an epic poem about th "Maid of the Cumberland," the scene i which was laid in the Tennessee mou: tains, should now come nearer home an utlliiQ the wealth of material tht abounds on tho banks of the classl stream that divides West Virginia froi Kentucky. Wo refer to the formal end ing of the long and bloody feud betwee tfie two noted families of Hatfield an McCoy. The feud has ended in the wa that all border wars should end, in Iot
Clipping to come
The Weekly Register · Point Pleasant, Va. W. Va.
Governor Wilson of West Virginia commissioned attorney Gibson to represent the state in habeas corpus proceedings in Kentucky, seeking the return of nine prisoners held in the Pike County jail. The men were charged with involvement in the Hatfield-McCoy vendetta, and the case was to be heard in U.S. District Court in Louisville.
The Weekly Register · 15 February 1888 · page 2
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
Clipping to come
The Indianapolis Journal · Indianapolis, Ind.
U.S. Marshal Gross received word that Deputy Marshal McDonald and the Pike County jailer brought the Hatfield prisoners to Catlettsburg, with no demonstration from the McCoys and no excitement in the county. Gross will allow the nine prisoners and their two guards to be brought to Louisville the following night.
The Indianapolis Journal · 16 February 1888 · page 2
Bringing the Hatfields to Louisville
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Wichita Eagle · Wichita, Kan.
The Hatfield prisoners, in custody of a Deputy Marshal and the jailer of Pike county, were brought to Catlettsburg, Kentucky, and were awaiting further orders. The report notes there was no demonstration from the McCoys at the removal, and no excitement in the county, with nine prisoners and two guards expected the next night.
Wichita Eagle · 16 February 1888 · page 1
THE HATFIELDS REMOVED.
Amnesty has been declared between the McCoy and Hatfield factions of Kentucky. Peace was restored by the marriage of a McCoy to a Hatfield. Kentuckians should pop the question more and their guns less. An exchange says twenty-seven Amverican girls have married Chinese within the last five years. With the noble red men and foreign counts as auxiliaries, American girls ought to be able to secure husbands. John T. Murphy has been nominated for mayor of Helena hy the I)enmo crats. While it has the appearance of being a citizens' movement, regardless of party.
See moreSee less
it was only a shrewd scheme to catch votes, and it may win. New York being too niggardly to complete Gen. Grant's monument by subscriptions, will ask the state legis lature to appropriate for that purpose $500,000 of the state direct tax re cently refunded to the state by the
Clipping to come
The Big Sandy News · Louisa, Ky.
This miscellany column mixes political commentary on Cleveland and Tilden with wry jokes about the Hatfield-McCoy feud, suggesting West Virginia take Pike County and the feuding families off Kentucky's hands. It also references a habeas corpus legal battle between the two states involving lawyers Proctor Knott and Eustace Gibson, likening it to the feud itself.
The Big Sandy News · 16 February 1888 · page 2
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Big Sandy News · Louisa, Ky.
The article criticizes a New York Herald reporter for writing an exaggerated, mocking account of the Hatfield-McCoy troubles, mocking his depiction of Catlettsburg, Kentucky as squalid and its residents as slovenly. The editor condemns the Herald piece as scurrilous lies and regrets that any newspaper would publish such material.
The Big Sandy News · 16 February 1888 · page 3
GIVE US JUSTICE.
i "III Ti ie Hatfield McCoy feud of Ken tuc'iy, has been ended after years of ex';ermination during which time ni.ore than a hundred lives have teen lost. Love and marriage of
Clipping to come
The Big Sandy News · Louisa, Ky.
This piece criticizes an unnamed journalist for publishing an exaggerated, sensationalized account of the Hatfield-McCoy troubles after supposedly overhearing gossip on a train. The writer accuses such reporters of unfairly maligning eastern Kentucky by highlighting only negative, embellished details while omitting any commendable facts about the region.
The Big Sandy News · 16 February 1888 · page 3
The marriage that put an end to the Hatfield-McCoy fend was not a failure. Illinois and Wisconsin have counties m which the English language is never used,
Clipping to come
The Daily Times · Richmond, Va. · and 2 other papers
The report narrates the feud's history from early slayings through the Hatfield raid that captured and executed three McCoy brothers, and describes the New Year's night attack on Randall McCoy's cabin. It also recounts a shootout in which Capt. Vance of the Hatfields was apparently mortally wounded while his wife stood exposed to gunfire.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Daily Times · 17 February 1888 · page 3
Misses McCoy has married one of the Hatfield boys. Thus does Cupid dis arm Mars. CHICAGO property holders are in a flurry over the claim set up by the Herrington family of Crawford county, Pa., to one hundred and sixty acres of land in the center of that city. It seems that an old deed has been over looked and the title to the present possessors is not perfect. It is sad that the heirs will vigorously push the claim and will employ Col. Bob Inger soll to aid them. A little rebellion against the mother country is threatened in New foundland.
See moreSee less
The people there are .wild over certain measures proposed by the government in the British parliament respecting the fisheries question. In the event that the British government h persists in what the Newfoundlanders consider an unjust and outrageous course the latter will make formal application to become a state of our re
Clipping to come
Also printed in 2 papers
The Beatrice Daily Express · Beatrice, Neb. · 22 February 1888
The New North-West · Deer Lodge, Mont. · 24 February 1888
The Daily Times · Richmond, Va.
This 1888 article recaps the twenty-year history of violence between the Hatfield family of Logan County, W. Va., and the McCoy family of Pike County, Ky., beginning with a Civil War-era shooting by Capt. James Vance. It recounts subsequent killings, an ambush, Johnson Hatfield's elopement with a McCoy girl, and an election-day mutilation that escalated the feud into open warfare.
HATFIELDS AND McCOYS. THE WARRING FAMILIES OF PIKE AND LOGAN COUNTIES.
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Daily Times · Richmond, Va.
The report describes how McCoys ambushed and killed Capt. Vance Hatfield after robbing his home, with Mrs. Vance standing bravely amid gunfire. It speculates the attack was motivated by a desire for his rifle rather than feud honor, and predicts the violence will continue for years.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Daily Times · 17 February 1888 · page 3
FRANK PHILLIPS. CAPT. VANCE HATFIELD.
Lord Bosebery. PEACE DECLARED ON THE BIG SANDY. The greatest of American vendettas is at an end, for the Hatfields and McCoys have agreed to fight no more. Burners of an im pending settlement of this famous feud have been spread abroad of late, but have found little acceptance by a public that has been reading for years of sudden bereavements on the banks of the Big Sandy river. But there Is no cause for further incredulity. The approaching marriage of the most beautiful and accomplished daughter of the house of McCoy to the most available youth with a whole skin remaining on the Hatfield side was announced several days ago.
See moreSee less
A mon ster barbecue will follow the wedding cere mony in a Wayue county (W. Va.) poplar grove, and it will be attended by all the Hat fields and McCoys alive. Such an event alone is sufficient to silence the most skep tical. As if to make doubly sure, however, "Cap” Hatfield, son of the old leader, "Devil ‘Anse,’’ writes the following lines to the "Wayne County News, under date of Febru ary 24 :— 1 ask space in your valuable paper for these few lines. A general amnesty has been declared in the famous Hatfield-McCoy feud, and I wish to say something of the old and tile new. Ido not wish to keep the old feud alive, and I suppose that everybody, like myself, is tired of the names ‘‘Hatfield” and "McCoy,” and the words "border warfare” iu lime of peace. The war spirit in we has abated, and I sincerely rejoice at the prospect of peace. I have devoted my life to arms. "We have undergone a fearful loss of noble lives and valuaole property in the struggle. Now I propose to rest in a spirit of peace. The Hatfield-McCoy feud, which has made "Wayne county in West Virginia and Pike county in Kentucky bloody ground for 30 years, had its rise in the hostilities of the civil war. Since then, accord ing io the popular impression, some 200 lives have been sacrificed in family warlare; yet that impression is an exgger ated one. Probably from first to last the list of dead does not number more than 30 peo ple, although as many more have been wounded and much property has been burned or destroyed on both sides. The Hat fields, who for 100 years have lived on the banks of the Big Sandy river on the West Virginia side, gave their support to the con federate cause; while the McCoys ou the Kentucky side organized in defense of the North. During the war numerous McCoys were sacrificed by sundry Hatfields, and the McCoys could not forgive or forget even after the surrender at Appomattox. The McCoys waited until about 10 years ago for their blood revenge, and then one day three McCoy boys murdered Ellison Hatfield in au election brawl on the Kentucky side of the Tug fork ot the Big Sandy. The Hatfields soon re taliated by tying those three McCoys to pop lar trees and filling them with lead. Then the McCoys inaugurated a series of raids into West Virginia territory, which resulted in the incarceration of a lot of Hatfields in Kentucky jails. In retaliation for these out rages a band of Hatfields with their Logan county sympathizers, led by tne notorious "Jim” Vance, crossed into Kentucky one New-year’s night and burned the McCoy mansion to the ground, turning the inmates, men, women and childreu, out of doors with out other covering than their night clothes. One McCoy was shot on this occasion and Alatray McCoy, the eldest daughter, was killed by a half-witted hanger-on in the Hat field camp. The McCoys afterward hunted down “Jim” Vance and are said to have gravely shaken hands over his dead body. These murderous deeds, of which the tew herein mentioned were the most conspicu ous. reached their culmination in a state of actual warfare about four years ago. The governors of the two states have issued requisitions without number; they have offered rewards for the capture of the out laws, and many a sheriff has attempted to make a Hatfield or a McCoy bis prize, but without much success. As each side did their butchering upon the soil of another state, the processes of law have been slow and uncertain. Moreover, each house*u its own community lias beeu as orderly aud well-governed as any family in the county. Only at the objects of ilia hatred across the line has a McCoy or a Hatfield raised bis rifle or aimed a blow. Aud MUS community surrounding each house has protected Its members from the punishment of their atrocious deeds. The law has been baffled at almost every point, and the truth is that the cure has finally worked itself. The antagonists have heard from the outside world and have grown ashamed of them selves. For nearly two years past a truce lias been maintained, ana the withdrawal of the rewards for their capture seems to have stimulated the settlement that has come. The two families some lime ago moved further back into their respective states, so that to day 30 miles separate the trajectories of their rifles. "Cap” Hatfield is considerable ot a man at bottom, and has managed to acquire a book education that is uncommon in those parts. “Cap” long since grew tired of sleep ing on his rifle. And then, not long ago, old “Devil Anse,” the Hatfield patriarch, joined the Methodist church. Thal was more than the feud could stand. It went to pieces like a string of beads suddenly left stringless. It will never rise again in the old form, because the iron horse, a great civilizer, is already snorting in the wilderness that lies about the Big Sandy river. The civilization of Logan and Pike coun ties has beeu made to suffer more than it deserved because of this vendetta. Although, as in all backwoods communities, human life has not been held at its real value, in other respects the very extreme of virtue has been reached. In Logan county there has been recorded, it is said, but one case of theft and then the charge was not proved. A resident has said; — We have no locks on our doors, except a few ot the stores, and the keys of those are lost. Ibe chickens roost on the fences and the apple-trees, and are they ever stolen / The coverlets that our women weave are stored in our porches. The hams we cure hanfi outside in rows. Our corn-cribs are open to everybody, and are they pilfered? if you want to know" what hospitality means, ride over and see us. You’d be safer with a pocketful of greenbacks in Logan county than walking up aud down Broadway in New York city. The regret will be felt in contemplating the new civilization that is coming into that primitive community, that in the uplifting process extreme virtues as well as extreme vices will undergo modification. The slaughter of men and women will cease, but the days when chickens can roost upon the fences with impunity are numbered. Thievery will increase in Logan county, but on the whole the change will be for the bet ter.
Clipping to come
National Republican (Washington City) · D.C.
The nine Hatfields, held under federal marshal and Pike County jailer custody, await a habeas corpus hearing before Judge Jackson. Valentine Hatfield, calling himself well-treated in jail, narrates his version of the feud's history, including Ellison Hatfield's killing, subsequent revenge killings, and his own capture.
National Republican (Washington City) · 18 February 1888 · page 1
THE HATFIELDS IN JAIL
Lord Bosebery. PEACE DECLARED ON THE BIG SANDY. The greatest of American vendettas is at an end, for the Hatfields and McCoys have agreed to fight no more. Burners of an im pending settlement of this famous feud have been spread abroad of late, but have found little acceptance by a public that has been reading for years of sudden bereavements on the banks of the Big Sandy river. But there Is no cause for further incredulity. The approaching marriage of the most beautiful and accomplished daughter of the house of McCoy to the most available youth with a whole skin remaining on the Hatfield side was announced several days ago.
See moreSee less
A mon ster barbecue will follow the wedding cere mony in a Wayue county (W. Va.) poplar grove, and it will be attended by all the Hat fields and McCoys alive. Such an event alone is sufficient to silence the most skep tical. As if to make doubly sure, however, "Cap” Hatfield, son of the old leader, "Devil ‘Anse,’’ writes the following lines to the "Wayne County News, under date of Febru ary 24 :— 1 ask space in your valuable paper for these few lines. A general amnesty has been declared in the famous Hatfield-McCoy feud, and I wish to say something of the old and tile new. Ido not wish to keep the old feud alive, and I suppose that everybody, like myself, is tired of the names ‘‘Hatfield” and "McCoy,” and the words "border warfare” iu lime of peace. The war spirit in we has abated, and I sincerely rejoice at the prospect of peace. I have devoted my life to arms. "We have undergone a fearful loss of noble lives and valuaole property in the struggle. Now I propose to rest in a spirit of peace. The Hatfield-McCoy feud, which has made
Clipping to come
The Indianapolis Journal · Indianapolis, Ind.
The nine Hatfield men arrive in Louisville in custody ahead of a Monday habeas corpus hearing on West Virginia's extradition request. Valentine 'Old Man' Hatfield gives reporters his own long account of how the feud began and escalated through a series of killings.
The Indianapolis Journal · 18 February 1888 · page 1
THE WEST VIRGINIA MURDERERS.
IP "Cap" Hatfield keeps his promise, a family feud more fatal than the fa mous strife between the Montagues and the Capulets and more savage than any Corsican vendetta has come to a final end. "Cap" is the present head of the house of Hatfield, between whom and the McCoys a deadly war has existed since the early sixties. The hostilities have kept the borders of Kentucky and West Virginia in bloody turmoil. They began with a wedding and are to end as they began, in a wedding. Aaron Hatfield is to marry a McCoy maiden
Clipping to come
The Indianapolis Journal · Indianapolis, Ind.
A Hatfield prisoner in the Pike county jail gives his version of the feud's history, from Ellison Hatfield's killing through the deaths of the McCoy brothers, Jeff McCoy, and the Alifair McCoy killing, claiming his own innocence. County Attorney Ferguson disputes the prisoners' claims of unlawful arrest, defending the Kentuckians' cross-border seizure of the West Virginians.
The Indianapolis Journal · 18 February 1888 · page 1
THE WEST VIRGINIA MURDERERS.
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
Clipping to come
The Indianapolis Journal · Indianapolis, Ind.
A spokesman defends the Kentucky posse's cross-border seizure of Hatfield suspects, arguing they were legally arrested after crossing into Kentucky and that West Virginia officials had been bribed to block extradition. He also relays an unverified claim that prisoner Valentine Hatfield confessed to having five wives and thirty-three children.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Indianapolis Journal · 18 February 1888 · page 1
THE WEST VIRGINIA MURDERERS.
It is said that James G. Bleine will not make a fight for the Presidency next year. Mr. McKinley will, however, try to win the prize, regardless of President Harrison's desires in the same line. Thk great gulf that has divided the Hatflelds and McCoys is to be bridged by matrimony, for a Hatfield maiden and a McCoy youtli are to be married in a few days. Peace reigns at last on
Clipping to come
Der Deutsche Correspondent · Baltimore, Md.
Nine West Virginia men belonging to the Hatfield gang, held in Pike County, Kentucky, arrived in Louisville in custody of a deputy U.S. marshal and are to appear before Judge Barr regarding a habeas corpus petition filed by West Virginia's governor. Valentine Hatfield recounts the feud's origin six years earlier, while Pike County attorney Ferguson calls the Hatfields dangerous and notes Valentine's polygamous household.
Der Deutsche Correspondent · 18 February 1888 · page 1
Die Hatfield-McCoy'sche Fehde
After a twenty years foud and the killing of one hundred men the McCoys and Hatfields of West Vir ginia ard Kentucky have made peace. They have shaken hands across the bloody cham and agreed to kill c;b other no more becauee one of the Misses McCoy has married one of the Hatfield boys. Thus does Cupid dis
Clipping to come
Narragansett Herald · Narragansett Pier, R.I.
Judge Barr of the U.S. Court in Louisville issued a writ of habeas corpus demanding that Hatfields, described as desperadoes tied to the McCoy-Hatfield feud who had been kidnapped from West Virginia, be brought before his court. Separately, Governor Wilson of West Virginia requested that Kentucky's governor extradite twenty-three members of the warring Hatfield-McCoy factions.
Narragansett Herald · 18 February 1888 · page 4
There were three bad breaks in the Mississippi levees occasioned by the re ' cent high water. The one in St. James' parish La., has just been closed but the waters are still flowing through the other two to the great damage of the surrounding country. After a-twenty years feud and the killing of one hundred men the McCoys and Hatfields of West Vir ginia and Kentucky have made peace. They have shaken hands across the bloody cham and agreed to kill each other no more becauee one of the Misses McCoy has married one of the Hatfield boys. Thus does Cupid dis
Clipping to come
The Memphis Appeal · Memphis, Tenn.
Nine Hatfields jailed in Louisville await a habeas corpus hearing before Judge Barr on Monday. The eldest, Valentine Hatfield, recounts the feud's beginnings, including the killing of his brother Ellison by McCoy men and the subsequent killing of three McCoy brothers.
The Memphis Appeal · 18 February 1888 · page 3
HATFIELD-McCOY FEUD. THE VIRGINIA CONTINGENT IN THE LOUISVILLE JAIL.
A Hatfield family member narrates the feud's origins, from Ellison Hatfield's killing by the McCoys through the killing of Tolbert, Pharmer, and 'Richard' McCoy, Jeff McCoy's death, the New Year's raid on Randolph McCoy's family, and the cross-border capture of Hatfield men now jailed in Louisville. Pike County Attorney Ferguson is quoted insisting the captured men are legitimate feud members legally arrested after crossing into Kentucky, despite admitting they were forcibly taken from West Virginia.
The Memphis Appeal · 18 February 1888 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
HATFIELD-M'COY FEUD.
THE VIRGINIA CONTINGENT IN THE LOUISVILLE JAIL.
See moreSee less
Old Man Valentine Hatfield Tells a Straightforward Story About the Bloody War that Waged Between the Families.
LOUISVILLE, Ky., Feb. 17.—The nine West Virginians known as the "Hatfields" arrived here last night in charge of a deputy United States marshal and the jailer of Pike county. They will appear before Judge Barr, of the United States district court, Monday, when the habeas corpus application of the Governor of West Virginia will be further heard. Valentine Hatfield, the "old man" of the gang, after stating that they had been well treated while in the Pike county jail, gave the following account of the celebrated feud:
"The whole trouble, so far as I know, began about six or eight years ago. I had five brothers—Ellison, Elias, Anderson, Smith and Patterson. Ellison was the first one killed. Three of the McCoy boys shot and cut him on Blackberry creek, on the Kentucky side, and he died the next day. The trouble, I believe, was started by one of the McCoys attempting to arrest Anderson Hatfield's son Johnson, about eight years ago. There was a row, but I don't remember exactly what it was. After Ellison Hatfield was killed, Talbert, Richard and Farmer McCoy, all young men, were killed by a crowd supposed to have come from West Virginia. The killing was done on the bridge between Blackberry and Mates creeks.
"The next Pike county grand jury indicted a lot of people in West Virginia. No one was arrested, however, and after that Jeff McCoy, who is Bill Daniel's brother-in-law, heard Daniels and Tom Wallace abusing the Hatfields, and a quarrel followed. McCoy attempted to arrest Wallace, and a fight took place. This resulted in Capt. Hatfield arresting McCoy, and when McCoy tried to get away he was killed by the men who were guarding him. Some time after this a squad of men went to Randolph McCoy's house and killed one of his sons and a daughter, and beat up his old woman. This was charged to the Hatfields, but I never knew anything about it until some time after the murders were committed.
"A short time after this, a company of Pike county men was formed to follow the Hatfields and kill them. They came into West Virginia and found Jim, Vance and Capt. Hatfield on a bridge near Thacker's creek. They shot Vance to death and wounded Capt. Hatfield. After that the Kentuckians came in and captured us while we were at work on our farms. None of us resisted and no injury was done us, but if there there was any authority for confining us in jail, I never heard of it."
County Attorney J. Lee, Ferguson, of Pike, was questioned concerning the claim of the prisoners that they were innocent. He laughed at the idea, and said that while the worst of the Hatfield crowd had not been captured, the men who are now in the Louisville jail are undoubtedly a part of the gang. He declared that the prisoners had not been unlawfully imprisoned, but after having crossed the border line between West Virginia and Kentucky, had been legally arrested and taken to jail by the proper officers. He did not deny that the West Virginians had been forcibly taken from their homes, but held that the Kentuckians were justified by the dangers threatening them in taking the matter into their own hands when the West Virginia authorities refused to assist in restraining and punishing the outlaws, who had only to cross a narrow stream to commit the most atrocious crimes and then cross back again to safety from the law. Mr. Ferguson asserted positively that he had creditable information that a State official of West Virginia had been retained with a fee of $500 to prevent Gov. Wilson from recognizing the requisition issued by Gov. Buckner. He charged also that the Hatfield crew had brought other influences to bear, and that the worst of the gang were now in comparative security.
Of the prisoners now in the Louisville jail, Mr. Ferguson says that Valentine Hatfield recently confessed to him that he had five living wives and thirty-three living children. Nine of his children have died. Mr. Ferguson states that Hatfield has peculiar ideas of polygamy and does not marry his wife according to law, but takes them and apportions his time out between them.
An official named Ferguson defends the legality of the Hatfield crew's arrest, claiming they were lawfully taken after crossing into Kentucky, while admitting West Virginians were forcibly seized. He also makes sensational claims about bribery to block extradition and about Valentine Hatfield having five wives and thirty-three children.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Memphis Appeal · 18 February 1888 · page 3
LOUISVILLE JAIL.
If “Cap' Hatfield keeps Ids promise, • family feud more fatal than the fa mous strife between the Montagues and the Capulet* and more savage titan any Corsican vendetta has come to a final •nd. “Cap" is the present head of the house of Hatfield, lietw-een whom and the McCoys a deadly war lias existed since the early sixties The hostilities have kept the torders of Kentucky ami West Virginia in bloody turmoil. They began with a wedding and are to end as they begau, in a wedding. Aaron Hatfield is to marry a McCoy maiden
Clipping to come
Fort Worth Daily Gazette · Fort Worth, Tex.
Nine Hatfields, held in Louisville en route to a federal habeas corpus hearing, are described, with elder Valentine Hatfield giving his version of how the feud began and progressed through several killings. He traces the violence from Ellison Hatfield's death through the killings of Talbert, Richards, Farmer McCoy, and Jeff McCoy, and the attack on Randolph McCoy's family.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 4 days later.
Wrong
Fort Worth Daily Gazette · 18 February 1888 · page 1
Transcript to come.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
Fort Worth Daily Gazette · Fort Worth, Tex.
The article reviews the chain of killings in the Hatfield-McCoy feud, including Jeff McCoy's death and the earlier New Year's raid on Randolph McCoy's home, leading to a Pike County posse capturing Hatfields in West Virginia. County Attorney J. Lee Ferguson defends the arrests as lawful despite cross-border seizures, alleging West Virginia officials were bribed to block extradition.
Fort Worth Daily Gazette · 18 February 1888 · page 1
Transcript to come.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
Fort Worth Daily Gazette · Fort Worth, Tex.
A witness named Ferguson testified that Kentucky authorities justified seizing West Virginia men due to lack of cooperation from West Virginia officials, and claimed a state officer was bribed with $500 to block the governor's recovery of a requisition. The report also notes that jailed Hatfield family member Valentine confessed to having five wives and thirty-three children, nine of whom had died.
Fort Worth Daily Gazette · 18 February 1888 · page 1
A “Noted Leader” Gone. Frank Phillips, the leader of the McCoy faction, made famous by the HatfieldMcCoy feud, was killed on Tug River, in
Clipping to come
The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · Wheeling, W. Va.
Anderson Hatfield, held with eight other West Virginians awaiting a habeas corpus hearing in Louisville, gives reporters his account of how the feud began roughly six to eight years earlier, starting with the killing of his brother Ellison by McCoy men. He traces subsequent killings on both sides, including the deaths of three McCoy brothers, Jeff McCoy, and an attack on Randolph McCoy's family, attributing much of the violence to misunderstandings and retaliation.
The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · 18 February 1888 · page 1
THE STORY OF THE FAMOUS FEUD
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
Clipping to come
The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · Wheeling, W. Va.
This report reviews the feud's key killings—including the New Year's attack, Jeff McCoy's death, and the Thacker Creek shootout—before detailing the capture of West Virginia men by Kentuckians. It also covers County Attorney Ferguson's defense of the arrests as legal and his accusation that a West Virginia official was bribed to block extradition.
The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · 18 February 1888 · page 1
THE STORY OF THE FAMOUS FEUD
Transcript to come.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · Wheeling, W. Va.
An attorney for the Hatfields argued the West Virginians' abduction was a legal arrest once they crossed into Kentucky, justified by the McCoy allies' inaction. He also claimed a West Virginia official was bribed to block extradition, and cited a confession that Valentine Hatfield had five wives and thirty-three children.
The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · 18 February 1888 · page 1
KiioiieIi Survivors to Take Side. Tho Ilatflcld-McCoy feud may bo oyer, and It may not. In all tho cases aver known tho feud died only when
Clipping to come
Wheeling Register · Wheeling, W. Va.
The nine West Virginia Hatfields, having arrived safely in Louisville under guard, await a Monday hearing before Judge Barr on the Governor's habeas corpus application. Valentine Hatfield, the clan's patriarch, gives reporters his own version of how the feud began and escalated through a series of killings.
Wheeling Register · 18 February 1888 · page 1
THE HATFIELDS SAFE. THE NINE HATFIELDS LODGED IN LOUISVILLE JAIL.
Transcript to come.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
Wheeling Register · Wheeling, W. Va.
A captured man recounts the feud's events—Jeff McCoy's killing, the raid on Randolph McCoy's home, and the shootout at Thacker Creek where Jim Vance died—while denying wrongdoing. Pike County Attorney J. Lee Ferguson defends the legality of the prisoners' capture, arguing Kentuckians were justified since West Virginia authorities refused to act against the Hatfields.
Wheeling Register · 18 February 1888 · page 1
The Pennylvania -papers will now probably give us a rest on the Ilat field-McCoy feud and devote the space to giving accounts of the officers who are too cowardly to at
Clipping to come
Wheeling Register · Wheeling, W. Va.
A brief note reports that the habeas corpus hearing in the Hatfield-McCoy case, scheduled for Monday at Louisville, has been postponed until February 25th at the request of Kentucky's Attorney General. The item appears among miscellaneous local news briefs of the day.
Wheeling Register · 18 February 1888 · page 4
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Richmond Dispatch · Richmond, Va.
Captured West Virginia Hatfields, held pending a habeas corpus hearing, gave their account of the feud to a reporter. The elder Hatfield recounted the killing of his brother Ellison, the revenge killings of three McCoy brothers, and subsequent raids and captures, while a county attorney dismissed their claims of innocence.
Richmond Dispatch · 19 February 1888 · page 8
OLD MAN HATFIELD'S STORY
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
Clipping to come
Richmond Dispatch · Richmond, Va.
The report recaps the killing of McCoy by his guards, Hatfield reprisals, and the capture of West Virginia men by a Pike County posse, who killed Jim Vance and wounded Captain Hatfield. County Attorney Ferguson defends the legality of the arrests, alleges bribery to block extradition, and relays Valentine Hatfield's claim of five wives and thirty-three children.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 5 days later.
Wrong
Richmond Dispatch · 19 February 1888 · page 8
OLD NAB HATFIELD'S STORY
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
Clipping to come
Richmond Dispatch · Richmond, Va.
Valentine 'Old Man' Hatfield, held with eight other West Virginians awaiting a habeas corpus hearing in Louisville, gives his version of how the feud began roughly six to eight years earlier. He describes the killing of his brother Ellison by McCoy brothers, the retaliatory killing of three young McCoys, subsequent indictments, the killing of Jeff McCoy, and an attack on Randolph McCoy's family.
A purported Hatfield figure recaps the feud's violent escalation, from the bridge killings to the New Year's Day raid on Randolph McCoy's home, while denying personal guilt. A Pike County prosecutor disputes claims of unlawful imprisonment and alleges bribery to block extradition of the Hatfields.
Richmond Dispatch · 19 February 1888 · page 8
OLD MAN HATFIELD'S STORY
field, with a history of the once! j familiar Hatfield and McCdy feud. Get a copy of the paper. Address Advance Thought^ Pulit zer Building, New, York City.
Clipping to come
Richmond Dispatch · Richmond, Va.
Mr. Ferguson argued that the Kentuckians were legally justified in capturing the West Virginia defendants once they crossed into Kentucky, framing it as lawful arrest rather than kidnapping. He also claimed a West Virginia official was bribed to block extradition, and relayed Valentine Hatfield's claim of having five wives and thirty-three children.
Richmond Dispatch · 19 February 1888 · page 8
Transcript to come.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
The Beatrice Daily Express · Beatrice, Neb.
This report recounts a 25-year history of violence between the Hatfield family of Logan County, WV, and the McCoy family of Pike County, KY, beginning with a Civil War-era killing by Capt. James Vance. It describes subsequent killings, an elopement, and an election-day beating that escalated tensions between the two clans.
The Beatrice Daily Express · 22 February 1888 · page 2
HATFIELDS AND McCOYS. THE WARRING FAMILIES OF PIKE AND LOGAN COUNTIES.
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Beatrice Daily Express · Beatrice, Neb.
The report describes an ambush in which the McCoys opened fire on Capt. Vance, Mrs. Vance, and Capt. Hatfield as they returned home, with Mrs. Vance refusing to flee despite gunfire. It speculates that the killing was motivated by a desire for Vance's rifle rather than feud honor, and predicts the violence will continue indefinitely.
The Beatrice Daily Express · 22 February 1888 · page 2
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Wheeling Register · Wheeling, W. Va.
In a letter about promoting West Virginia's resources and schools, Representative W. L. Wilson complains that exaggerated stories of the Hatfield and McCoy feud have damaged the state's reputation among potential settlers. He argues for better publicity and education reform to counter this negative image.
Wheeling Register · 22 February 1888 · page 4
REPRESENTATIVE W. L. WILSON
Freda Ward's Murderess. 1'l.XKVli.LE, Ky., Jan. 30. A factional feud that promises to rival in bloodshed ding the famous Hat field-McCoy, or any of the other deserate factional wars which have made this section of Kentucky notorious, has broken out in the southern part of this county. The scene is a wild mountainous locality known as South America, and is about eighteen miles from this, the nearest railroad point. Owing to the inaccessibility of the place particulars of the fight are hard to obtain. Three men have been killed since last Saturday.
See moreSee less
Their names are Manuel Parton, l,ee Davis and Will Jones. The fight is between lierry Turner, a notorious outlaw and murderer, who lias killed more men than any other one man w ho has ever terrorized this section, with a strong gang, and the Part on faction.
Clipping to come
West Virginia Argus · Kingwood, W. Va.
Governor Wilson of West Virginia has made a formal requisition to the Governor of Kentucky for twenty-three members of the warring Hatfield-McCoy factions. The request seeks their extradition to face justice for feud-related crimes.
West Virginia Argus · 23 February 1888 · page 1
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Hazel Green Herald · Hazel Green, Ky.
The report lists members of the Hatfield gang, including Valentine Hatfield and several McCoys and others, who were taken to the Louisville Jail the prior Thursday. A hearing before Judge Barr of the U.S. Court was set for the following Monday.
The Hazel Green Herald · 24 February 1888 · page 1
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
Clipping to come
The New North-West · Deer Lodge, Mont.
This report traces the feud back twenty-five years to an 1863 Confederate raid in which Hatfield ally Capt. James Vance killed a McCoy, and recounts retaliatory killings and an abduction that escalated the violence. It frames the conflict as a long-running, deadly scandal spanning Pike County, Kentucky, and Logan County, West Virginia.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 7 days later.
Wrong
The New North-West · 24 February 1888 · page 1
HATFIELDS AND McCOYS. THE WARRING FAMILIES OF PIKE AND LOGAN COUNTIES.
Next followed the Hatfield-McCoy feud between two border families of Kentucky end West Virginia; the principals to this feud have been hanged or imprisoned or
Clipping to come
The New North-West · Deer Lodge, Mont.
The report describes an armed encounter in which the McCoys ambushed Capt. Vance while he traveled with Mrs. Vance and Capt. Hatfield, exchanging gunfire until Vance was apparently mortally wounded. Mrs. Vance bravely stood her ground amid the shooting, and the writer speculates the attack was meant to seize Vance's rifle rather than continue the feud's original cause.
The New North-West · 24 February 1888 · page 1
MRS. VANCE AND CAPT. HATFIELD
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Fisherman & Farmer · Edenton, N.C.
A federal judge in Louisville ordered that Hatfield gang members, who had been kidnapped from West Virginia, be brought before his court via writ of habeas corpus. Separately, West Virginia's governor formally requested Kentucky's governor extradite twenty-three members of the feuding Hatfield-McCoy factions.
Fisherman & Farmer · 24 February 1888 · page 6
Andrew Carnegie is said to be worth about $35,000,000 all of which he intends to dispose of in charitable work before his death. It is believed that the famous Hatfield-McCoy feud in Kentucky has been at last brought to an end. Captain Hatfield, the leader of one of the factions was shot and killed the other day by members of his own gang with whom he quarreled. A peculiar ease, involving the paternity of a boy baity, has just been decided at Portland. Mrs. J. T. Hag gin and Mrs. Minnie R.
See moreSee less
Willis both claimed to be the mother. The court concluded that both could not have given birth to the child, and as Mrs. Haggin presented the strongest claim it was awarded to her. The silver movement in Nevada is beginning to assume a definite shape. The voters of the State are commenc ing to realize that they must place their own interests first, and if neces sary force party affiliations to the rear of the procession. It is said that “God helps those who help them selves.” We can lose nothing by giv ing the motto a fair test. A call for the organization of a silver club is published in another column. The organization of these clubs is the first step toward intelli gent organization to fight for the cause of silver at the coming election. Winnemucca has thus taken the lead and set an example which should be generally followed by the towns throughout the State. Are you with us or against us? It is interesting to observe how universal is the financial assistance tendered to Hebrew fugitives from Russia. Five thousand dollars comes from Sydney, Australia, with an equal sum from South Africa. Bom bay has sent two contributions. Rus sia is irritated about the widespread attempt to interfere with the op pressed subjects of the Czar, and is not otic ring any facilities to Ameri cans or anybody else desirous of aid ing the starving peasants. An organized silver and irrigation movement has l>een started in Lyon county. A call signed by a large number of the best citizens of the county, Republican and Democratic, [ has been issued for a meeting to nn/rtni'/r* Jinil <1rouiim eimli raarvln. tion.s as they deem l>est for their in terests. The call declares that the signers will stand upon a platform of free silver coinage and irrigation legislation and act independently of any party that does not support their interests. The last report of the United States Civil Service Commission shows that in the examinations for Government positions women aro are much more successful than men. In the exam ination for copyists’ positions only one woman in six failed, while only half the men were successful. In the more difficult examinations one-third of the men failed and only one-fourth of the women, while, in the very difficult,examination for pomological clerk, the four men who were ex- ' amined failed, while three out of the four women were successful. Tuken all in all, the women did more than twice as well as the men. MAKE IT A POLITICAL ISSUE. If the free coinage question is not a political one now and never has been, the silver men can make it so almighty sudden by organizing silver
Clipping to come
Ceredo Advance · Ceredo, W. Va.
The article discusses how correspondents from metropolitan papers sent to cover the McCoy-Hatfield troubles are misrepresenting both West Virginia and Kentucky with exaggerated, disparaging accounts. It quotes a New York Herald letter that paints an unflattering, insulting portrait of Catlettsburg, Kentucky as evidence of this journalistic dishonesty.
It is believed that the famous Hatfield-McCoy feud in Kentucky has been at last brought to an end. Captain Hatfield, the leader of one of
Clipping to come
Devils Lake Inter-Ocean · Devils Lake, N.D.
The item reports that 'old man Hatfield,' described as a constituent of Speaker Carlisle who had spent eight years trying to wipe out the McCoy family, has been jailed. It adds, seemingly as an aside, that he is also a polygamist.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 3 days later.
Wrong
Devils Lake Inter-Ocean · 25 February 1888 · page 4
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
Clipping to come
The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · Wheeling, W. Va.
A dispatch from Charleston, W.Va. reports a shooting at Hamlin between Paris Blumfield of Lincoln County and a man named McCoy of Wayne County, said to be reviving an old feud. McCoy's revolver misfired, but Blumfield's shot missed McCoy and wounded a bystander, Rufus Stowers, in the leg; the McCoy involved is said to be a relative of the Kentucky McCoys.
The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · 25 February 1888 · page 1
RELATIVE OF THE KENTUCKY McCOYS CONCERNED
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
Clipping to come
The Salt Lake Herald · Salt Lake City, Utah
The report notes that West Virginia prisoners, including Valentine Hatfield, await trial in Louisville and that Valentine protests his innocence. Randolph McCoy, father of several victims, gives a detailed account of the New Year's night attack on his home, including the shooting and the burning of his daughter's house.
The Salt Lake Herald · 26 February 1888 · page 10
NOT BRAVE BUT COWARDS
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Salt Lake Herald · Salt Lake City, Utah
Randall McCoy describes how a Hatfield mob burned his house, fatally shot his daughter Alifair and son Calvin, and names Cap Hatfield and others as the shooters. He also insists Valentine Hatfield organized the raiders and expresses confidence a trial, not mob violence, awaits the jailed suspects.
The Salt Lake Herald · 26 February 1888 · page 10
THE SON KILLED
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
Clipping to come
The Salt Lake Herald · Salt Lake City, Utah
A source describes how Valentine Hatfield organized the raiding band and swore members to an oath to avenge Ellis Hatfield's death, though he admits he cannot say for certain who was present at the shooting. He also denies rumors of mob violence against the captured Hatfields, saying sentiment is strong but no lynching was ever planned, and separately reports that Valentine Hatfield has confessed to having five wives and thirty-three children.
The Salt Lake Herald · 26 February 1888 · page 10
NOT IN DANGER FROM A MOB
—“Cap’’ Hatfield, the uotorious outlaw is reported to have been killed a few days ago in a row over a game of poker in his house among outlaws, who had solemnly vowed perpetual friendship. In the moan I tains of Logan county, West Vir | ginia, near the secluded retreat of j the notorious “Bad Ause” Hatfield, ! was the house of “Gap” Hatfield, whose record for murders lu the Hatfield McCoy fued stands second only to that of his brother “Ause.” “Cap” Hatfield, was regarded as the worst member of the Hatfield gang, though lie had not, perhaps, killed as many people as his broth er, “Bad Arise.” When the au thorities announced the rewards for the capture of this family of criminals, “Cap” headed the list at $1,250.
See moreSee less
“Bad Anse” and “Jonce’’ Hatfield were each valued at $700, which would show that “Cap” was looked upon as about equal to two of the most, famous criminals West Virginia has ever produced. “Cap” Hatfield was charged with a num ber of cold-blooded murders.
Clipping to come
Paper unidentified
A public letter about 'booming' West Virginia argues that exaggerated press coverage of the Hatfield-McCoy feud has unfairly damaged outside perceptions of the state's social stability. The writer proposes educational and economic reforms to counter this negative image rather than addressing the feud's facts directly.
A federal judge in Louisville ordered that the Hatfield men, seized from West Virginia, be brought before his court on a writ of habeas corpus. Separately, West Virginia's governor requested Kentucky's governor extradite twenty-three members of the feuding Hatfield-McCoy factions.
The Abbeville Press and Banner · 29 February 1888 · page 2
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
Clipping to come
Wheeling Register · Wheeling, W. Va.
This report covers a West Virginia development convention where various businessmen and politicians advocate for more railroads to spur the state's growth. One speaker, discussing Kentucky's rail network, offhandedly references the Hatfield-McCoy feud as tied to Kentucky's 'unsettled condition.'
Wheeling Register · 29 February 1888 · page 4
WHAT THEY THINK
Tug river fishing, and using that all destructive explosive called dynamite. They came In crowds, with Winchesters, calling themselves the Hatfield gang. One day last week, while their work of destroying the fish