As the Papers Told It

The Hatfields and the McCoys · The full archive

January 1888

166 articles

Rock Island Daily Argus · Rock Island, Ill.

The report describes a nighttime arson attack by the Hatfield gang on Randall McCoy's house, in which his daughter Alifair and son Calvin were shot dead and his wife badly wounded. It recounts the feud's origin in an 1882 election-day killing and claims Randall McCoy killed one attacker and wounded Cap Hatfield while escaping.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 4 days later.

Wrong

Rock Island Daily Argus · 9 January 1888 · page 2

In Prosecuting a Feud One Party Sets Fire to the Enemy's Home and Shoots the Family, Male and Female, as They Appear

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

Clipping to come

Rock Island Daily Argus · Rock Island, Ill.

The report describes the Hatfield gang's attack on the McCoy home, claiming several family members including McCoy's wife and three sons were shot dead and the house burned. It also notes rewards offered by Kentucky for the Hatfields' arrest, though they remain protected in West Virginia.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 4 days later.

Wrong

Rock Island Daily Argus · 9 January 1888 · page 2

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

In the story →

The Evening Bulletin · Maysville, Ky.

A dispatch describes the Hatfield gang's New Year's attack on Randall McCoy's house, claiming his daughter, son, and wife were killed in the fire and shooting. It also claims McCoy himself killed a Hatfield gang member named Chambers and wounded Cap Hatfield before the rest fled.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 4 days later.

Wrong

The Evening Bulletin · 9 January 1888 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image

ANOTHER KENTUCKY WAR.

An Old Feud Which Results in a Series of Murders.

See moreSee less

CATLETTSBURG, Ky., Jan. 9.—A crime growing out of an old feud has been committed on the Blackburr fork of Pond creek in Pike county. The work is of the notorious Hatfield gang. Five years ago in an election row three McCoy brothers fatally stabbed a Hatfield. The latter's relatives caught the three McCoys, tied them to a tree and shot them to death. The war has been kept up since, and the latest chapter has just been heard from. A few nights ago the Hatfields set fire to the house of Randall McCoy. His eldest daughter, Alfara, was the first to open the door, and by the light of her burning home the innocent young girl was shot dead. Her brother Calvin and her mother followed, only to perish in the same way.

The desperate and desolate father, Randall McCoy, reckless of his own fate after this slaughter of his innocent ones, dashed from their funeral pyre into the midst of the murderous gang, unhurt by their volley of bullets, and partially avenged his wrongs by killing one of the gang named Chambers by a well directed bullet, and shot Cap Hatfield in the shoulder. The rest of the cowardly assassins fled. Rewards aggregating $2,700 are offered by the state of Kentucky for the arrest of the Hatfields, but they are fortified in the wilds of West Virginia, and no one cares to risk his life in pursuing them. Already the blood of Mr. McCoy's wife, a fair young daughter and three sons has paid the penalty for that one death five years ago. Who can blame the half-crazed man if his future desolate life shall be devoted to avenging them.

See the clipping

Weekly Courier-Journal · Louisville, Ky.

A letter to Senator Stewart describes a January 1 attack by the Hatfield party on Randolph McCoy's home in Pike County, Kentucky, claiming his wife and son were killed and the house burned, with McCoy and two daughters escaping. It also notes one gang member already jailed in Pikeville amid fears of a rescue attempt.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 4 days later.

Wrong

Weekly Courier-Journal · 9 January 1888 · page 1

'&&H. Kentacky-We»t Virginia Border. PITTSBCRO, Pa., Peb. 1.—The Times prints In detail the first true statement published of the famous Hatfleld-McCoy outrages that have been (or six years con tinued, without serious attempt being made to punish the outlaws. The story from stait to finish Is a tale of horrors rarely equaled, and has caused a blot on the names of the two great states of Ken* tucky and West Virginia. Charles Howell, of the Times'editorial staff, re turning from a personal investigation, reports to his paper that the Hatfleld MoCoy trouble threatens to develop into serious inter-state complications.

See moreSee less

Al though Governors Buckner, of Kentucky, •a and Wilson, of West Virginia, have or v: dered their militia to return to their :i, homes, It must not be understood that the troubles are ended. The Hatfleld McCoy war, divested of all sentiment with which the representatives of the two states have Invested it, is simply

Clipping to come

Telegram-Herald · Grand Rapids, Mich.

A dispatch describes the long-running Hatfield-McCoy feud's origins, including the 1882 killing of Ellison Hatfield and the retaliatory execution of three McCoy brothers, then reports a fresh attack: Hatfield partisans set fire to Randall McCoy's house and shot his daughter Alafair dead as she opened the door. It frames the new violence as the latest and most horrible chapter in an ongoing family war along the Kentucky-West Virginia border.

CorrectionThis set right 2 earlier articles: New-York Tribune, 7 March 1885, Der Westbote, 19 March 1885.

Telegram-Herald · 9 January 1888 · page 1

A TERRIBLE TRAGEDY IN KENTUCKY.

LIE IN BLOODY GBAVE8, •nd himself and family are wandering in the mountains, well-nigh penniless. In 1871 a warrant was issued for the arrest of Johnbon Hatfield, a son of Anderson, who eluded the officials for several months. Talbot McCoy was deputized to serve the warrant. McCoy captured Hatfield and started with him for. Pike court house, twenty miles distant. McCoy's two brothers acted as guards. A friend ap prised the Hatflelds of the arrest, and the elder Hatfield, accompanied by his allies, intercepted the McCoys, and rescind his son at the point.of the gun, and returned to West Virginia.

See moreSee less

A year later, at an election in Kentucky. Ellas and Ellison Hatfield engaged in a quarrel with Talbot McCoy, over an alleged debt, during which MoCoy stabbed Ellison Hatfield in the baok. Hatfield began pounding McCoy's head with a stone, whereupon McCoy's younger brother

Clipping to come

Telegram-Herald · Grand Rapids, Mich.

The report describes the Hatfield gang's attack on Randall McCoy's home, burning it and shooting dead his daughter Alifair and son Calvin, with his wife badly wounded. It claims rewards have been posted for the Hatfields' capture for murdering 'three of the McCoy boys' and a daughter, though they remain unapprehended in West Virginia.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

Telegram-Herald · 9 January 1888 · page 1

A TERRIBLE TRAGEDY IN KENTUCKY

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

Clipping to come

The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · Wheeling, W. Va.

A Cincinnati Enquirer dispatch from Catlettsburg, Ky. recounts the origin of the Hatfield-McCoy feud, including the 1882 election-day stabbing of Ellison Hatfield and the retaliatory killing of three McCoy brothers tied to a pawpaw bush. It then describes a recent night attack in which the Hatfield party burned Randall McCoy's house and shot his daughter Alifair as she emerged.

The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · 9 January 1888 · page 1

A FAMILY FEUD AND MURDER

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

Clipping to come

The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · Wheeling, W. Va.

The article describes a night raid by the Hatfield gang on Randall McCoy's home, in which his daughter Alafair was shot dead, his wife shot through the head, and his house burned, while McCoy himself escaped and fought back. It also notes rewards offered for the Hatfields' capture and claims three sons, a daughter, and the wife were killed or wounded in this and prior attacks.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · 9 January 1888 · page 1

SHOT THEN TO DEATH

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Semi-Weekly Interior Journal · Stanford, Ky.

The report describes a 1882 abduction of three McCoy boys by a Hatfield-led gang, followed by a January 1888 raid in which Hatfield's men allegedly killed Randolph McCoy's wife and son and burned his house. It notes a reward had been offered and one gang member was already jailed.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 3 days later. CorrectionThis set right an article from the day before.

Wrong

Semi-Weekly Interior Journal · 10 January 1888 · page 2

SATURDAY. FEBRUARY 4,1888. Col. IIobt. White, of Whaling, and Mr. F. M. Reynolds, of Kcyser were in town this week attending court. Parkersburg is in darkness. The contract of the city with the Gas Company has expired and the elec tric light contracted for, cannot be put into operation for three months. ,_— The troubles between certain citi zens of Logan county, W. Va., and Pike county, Ky.,bave about termi nated. It was a disgraceful affair andthecivil autboritiesof both .States should make an example of at least a few of the leading oflenders>» Gov ernor Wilson has issued a requisiVion upon the Governor of Kentucky for the return of nine citizens of \\ est Virginia, said to have been kidnap ped and taken to the Pike county jail__

Clipping to come

The Big Sandy News · Louisa, Ky.

This is a miscellaneous local news column from the Big Sandy News featuring community items, advertisements, and a brief mention that further news of the Hatfield feud is published that week. Most of the content concerns local social notes, business ads, and town government, with no substantive feud details given.

The Big Sandy News · 12 January 1888 · page 3

BIG SANDY NEWS

Transcript to come.

No clean clipping could be cut from this page

The Big Sandy News · Louisa, Ky.

An initial report claims Cap Hatfield was killed and John Hatfield badly wounded in an attack by Calvin McCoy and his father, with Calvin McCoy later killed himself; a 'Later' update then states Cap Hatfield was not actually killed, citing a newer letter from Pikeville. The piece also describes armed men mobilizing from Pikeville to pursue the Hatfield gang.

The Big Sandy News · 12 January 1888 · page 3

Gov. Buckner: "Have you any objection to the use ol your official correspondence couceininx the Hattfeld-McCoy leud.'" "I have no objection, whatever, to the use of my official correspondence. "I have seen it stated that Governor Knott, of Kentucky, during his term of office, made a requisition on me for the Hattields and others. Governor Kuott never made a requisition on me for the Hattields. I pou recent examination 1 Hod that Governor Knott's requisition wax for R. H. Casey, Wm. Mariou Mullett and Lafayette Boyd. I am satisfied that no requisition was ever made upon me by Governor Knott in the Hattield case, and therefore will omit the official correspon dence between us in reference to the above ca*e, when Governor Knott refused to comply with the statutes of our State in the manner of preparing bis requisition."

See moreSee less

THE WEST VIRGINIA LAW.

Clipping to come

The Big Sandy News · Louisa, Ky.

Armed parties from Pikeville pursued the Hatfield gang, and gunfire was heard from the area on Sunday. An initial report that Cap Hatfield was killed was corrected by a later letter stating that Jim Vance was killed in the skirmish while Hatfield escaped.

The Big Sandy News · 12 January 1888 · page 3

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Alexandria Gazette · Alexandria, D.C.

A dispatch from Cattlettsburg, Ky. claims McCoy posse members traveled to the Hatfield settlement in West Virginia seeking revenge and fought a pitched battle, killing three Hatfield men including Jim Vance. It states authorities are powerless to stop the ongoing feud.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

Alexandria Gazette · 12 January 1888 · page 2

War of Extermination.

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

Clipping to come

Waterbury Evening Democrat · Waterbury, Conn.

The report claims that after burying Mrs. McCoy and her sons, a McCoy posse attacked the Hatfield settlement and killed three men—Johnson Hatfield, Thomas Chambers, and James Vance—without losing any of their own. It frames this as part of an ongoing extermination war the authorities are powerless to stop.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out. CorrectionThis set right an article from 4 days earlier.

Waterbury Evening Democrat · 13 January 1888 · page 1

THE LAW SEEMS POWERLESS TO STOP THE FEUD.

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Waterbury Evening Democrat · Waterbury, Conn.

The report recounts the Hatfield-McCoy feud's origins from an 1882 election-day stabbing of Ellison Hatfield and the subsequent execution of three McCoy brothers, then describes the recent New Year's attack on Randall McCoy's home in which his children Alifair and Calvin were shot dead and his wife wounded. It notes rewards offered for the Hatfields' arrest and laments that authorities seem powerless to stop the ongoing violence.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

Waterbury Evening Democrat · 13 January 1888 · page 1

STOP THE FEUD.

; welcome rarely goes further than the echo ot tho ' J rifle that warned them ot their Imprudence too late. 1 TUT BCBNB OP T1IE WARFARE. I The County of Logan, W. Va., where tho Hat fields live, is one of the largest counties In that State In point ot territory. It lies at the southern most end of the State, and the boundary line ot Kentucky Is the Tug Fork of Sandy Itlver, a nar row, rough and unnavlgable stream be tween massive mountains crowned with timber. Logan County has a frontage on Tug Illvcr alone of almost eighty miles and Is nearly rectangular in shape.

See moreSee less

Logan Court-Uouse, the county seat, la tho only town. It Is situated on the Onyan Itlver, about trdity-flvo miles from what is known as the ' Hatfield Settlement on Tug." Logan Court-House has a population of not more than 400 people. The buildings, with the exception of the court-house and Jail and a few others, are the old-fashioned bouthern log cabins.

Clipping to come

Waterbury Evening Democrat · Waterbury, Conn.

The report describes the deadly attack on the McCoy home, including the killing of Calvin McCoy and Mrs. McCoy, the wounding of Randall McCoy, and his retaliatory shooting of one attacker. It notes the $2,700 in rewards offered by Kentucky for the Hatfields' capture, though none dare attempt it due to their fortified position in West Virginia.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day. CorrectionThis set right 3 earlier articles: Rock Island Daily Argus, 9 January 1888, The Evening Bulletin, 9 January 1888, Weekly Courier-Journal, 9 January 1888.

Wrong

Waterbury Evening Democrat · 13 January 1888 · page 1

STOP THE FEUD.

GIBSON CHOSEN By (i overnor WiUoii to KepreiteDt the .State in the Kentueky AlVitlr. ClIAUI-HsTON, W. Va., February 7.— Governor Wilson to-day commissi .ned ex CoDgressman Hon. Enstace Gibson to rep resent the State of West Virginia in the habeas corpus proceedings to be begun in the State of Kentucky for the return of the nine prisoners in the Pike eounty, Kentucky, jail, and who stand charged ! with having been implicated in the recent Hallield-McCoy vendetta. The case will be brought iu the United States District Conrt now in session at Louisville. Mr. Gibson left for I<ouisville this morning.

Clipping to come

The Morning News · Savannah, Ga.

A Chicago dispatch citing a Cattlesburg, Ky. special describes a posse of McCoys attacking the Hatfield settlement in West Virginia in retaliation for a recent 'butchery,' resulting in a pitched battle. The report claims three Hatfield men—Johnson Hatfield, Thomas Chambers, and James (Jim) Vance—were killed while no McCoys were harmed.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

The Morning News · 13 January 1888 · page 2

DOG EAT DOG.

The Hatfield-McCoy affairs have naturally be formed that there have hut fw worse feuds in the u.i.niu f,.nntrv . Such is not the case, as we who live near can testify

Clipping to come

The Indianapolis Journal · Indianapolis, Ind.

This dispatch from Catlettsburg, Ky. describes a feud escalation in which McCoys, after burying victims of a recent attack, organized a posse and raided the Hatfield settlement in West Virginia. It claims the Hatfields were badly beaten, with three men—Johnson Hatfield, Thomas Chambers, and James Vance—reported killed, while no McCoys were hurt.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

The Indianapolis Journal · 13 January 1888 · page 2

The War of the McCoys and Hatfield

Gov. Bucknkr having refused to release the nine West Virginians who j are in the Pike county (Ky-) jail j charged with being implicated in the i McCoy-Hatfield vendetta, the

Clipping to come

The Hazel Green Herald · Hazel Green, Ky.

A special dispatch recounts the long-running Hatfield-McCoy feud's origins and reports a recent night raid in which the Hatfield faction burned Randall McCoy's house, killing his daughter Alifair and son Calvin and shooting his wife through the head. It claims McCoy escaped and killed one attacker, with large rewards now offered by Kentucky.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out. CorrectionThis set right an article from 3 days earlier.

The Hazel Green Herald · 13 January 1888 · page 4

ARSON AND MURDER

To ZtKI.EASK THE WEST VIRGIN IANS.—GoV. Wilson h is issued a rc <|uiaitio'i upon Governor liuekner, of Kentucky, for tho safe delivery of Tom Chambers II. Nalnc , Selk'rk McCoy, L. l>. McCoy Mores Chris tiaus Davi) Mahon, D D Mahon, and Plaint Mahon, who are alleged to bate been implicated in the recent trouble, and who are citizens of Lr gan county, now confined in the jail • »f Pike county, Kentucky, awaiting trial. The petition further s'atea that the pallet* above noeulioncd, ns lio is infoi med and believes, wore taken from this State by the McCoy gang without any legal process what ever and iu violation of the laws of the Stale.

See moreSee less

This Hatfield-McCoy trouble die from the war\ in which the Hatfields fought on the Conicdera’o sido and the McCoy’s on the Union. The

Clipping to come

The Hazel Green Herald · Hazel Green, Ky.

The report describes Hatfield raiders burning Randall McCoy's house, shooting his daughter Alifair and son Calvin dead, and wounding his wife, while McCoy himself escaped and returned fire, killing one attacker. It notes large rewards offered by Kentucky for the Hatfields' capture, but says no one dares pursue them in their West Virginia stronghold.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

The Hazel Green Herald · 13 January 1888 · page 4

ARSON AND MURDER

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Evening Bulletin · Maysville, Ky.

The report claims a McCoy posse invaded West Virginia seeking revenge after the New Year's attack, encountering the Hatfield gang in the woods and killing three men including Johnson Hatfield, Thomas Chambers, and James Vance. It states the McCoys suffered no casualties and returned home satisfied, with authorities powerless to stop the ongoing feud.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

The Evening Bulletin · 13 January 1888 · page 1

A SECOND BATTLE.

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

Clipping to come

Daily Kennebec Journal · Augusta, Me.

The report claims an extermination war continues between the McCoys of Pike County and the Hatfields of Logan County, West Virginia, with a battle on Wednesday leaving the Hatfield side badly beaten and three of its men—Johnson Hatfield, Thomas Chambers, and James Vance—killed. It predicts the feud will continue until one side is wiped out.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

Daily Kennebec Journal · 13 January 1888 · page 1

York Herald each devoted aliout a iage of their recent issues to the Hat-lield-McCoy feud and describe graphi cally, not only the bloody battles and massacres, but-also the disorganized , state of society in the upper regions of the Big Sandy valley. Curiously enough, the two stories form "pendants" to each other. The New Tork World corres pondent has the Hatfield side of the story, the Herald man has the McCoy ' side. As travel through the region is entirely suspended by the decree of the murder ous gangs, as the United States mails have been interfered with and Kentucky county authorities have made several raids into West Virginia territory to cap ture members of the Hatfield gang, it is

Clipping to come

St. Paul Daily Globe · Saint Paul, Minn.

The report claims a McCoy posse attacked the Hatfield settlement in West Virginia, resulting in a battle that left three Hatfield men dead—Johnson Hatfield, Thomas Chambers, and James Vance—while no McCoys were harmed. It frames the feud as an ongoing war of extermination between Pike County, Kentucky and Logan County, West Virginia factions.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

St. Paul Daily Globe · 13 January 1888 · page 7

A DESPERATE FEUD

. character among these rude mountain eers. The attention of the outside world is occasionally called to these murders by a deed of unusual ferocity, as when three of the McCoy boys, one only four

Clipping to come

Richmond Dispatch · Richmond, Va.

A Chicago dispatch citing a Catlettsburg, Kentucky special reports that after a recent 'butchery,' the McCoys organized an armed posse and attacked the Hatfield settlement in West Virginia. The report claims the Hatfield gang was found, a fight ensued, and that several Hatfields including 'the Hatfield' were killed along with one McCoy.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

Richmond Dispatch · 13 January 1888 · page 3

PALATKA. FLA.. FEB. 11, 1888. ANAECHT OH TflE BIG SANDY. It Deems hardly credible that the scenes of centuries ago, the border forays with all the attendant scenes of murder and cruelly are reieated in our days within the borders of the Uni ted States. Yet the mountain country through which the line bet weed West Virginia and Kentucky runs is the seat of a most destructive warfare of families. These sanguinary feuds began during the war, In fact the war has never been over on Tug Fork of Big Sandy.

See moreSee less

There have been enough men, women and children murdered in the feud between the Hat fields and the IfcCoys to have extin guiihed two ordinary families. But the cabin of the mountaineer swarms with children generally and ail the members of these fami ies know how to shoot, from the stripling to the old grandfather, or grandmother, for that matter. Sex . character among these rude mountain eers. The attention of the outside world is occasionally called to these murders by a deed of unusual ferocity, as when three of the McCoy boys, one only four teen years old, were caught by a gang of Hatfields, tied to bushes and tied hand to hand, then shot down in cold blo2i the child being killed last of all. ""TtnolherfroeTSus deed was committed a short time ago. A raid was made at midnight upon a family of the McCoys by a party of the Hatfields and a young girl, and a young man were shot dead while an old woman was brained by the lieht of their burning home, and an other girl went crazy by the corpse of er brother. Reporters of various Western and Eastern papers have taken their lives in their bands at various times and gone into these mountain wilds to got at the truth of these stories, to separate truth from rumor. They have had to face visible,- tangible danger to do so. Their rejiorts agree in one thing that there is a condition of affairs in those mountains which are a shame to American civiliza tion. Lying between such States as West Virginia and Kentucky, near Penn sylvania and Ohio, this state of anarchy, where the officers of law belong to either one gang or the other and justiee is laughed at, the scenes of barbarity de scribed in these corresjKindents' letters are set within the very heart of our long settled territory, not in Alaska or the wilds of the Rockies. The New York World and the New York Herald each devoted aliout a iage of their recent issues to the Hat-lield-McCoy feud and describe graphi cally, not only the bloody battles and massacres, but-also the disorganized , state of society in the upper regions of the Big Sandy valley. Curiously enough, the two stories form "pendants" to each other. The New Tork World corres pondent has the Hatfield side of the story, the Herald man has the McCoy ' side. As travel through the region is entirely suspended by the decree of the murder ous gangs, as the United States mails have been interfered with and Kentucky county authorities have made several raids into West Virginia territory to cap ture members of the Hatfield gang, it is possible that the National government will be called upon to restore order. The Kentucky State authorities have often -called out the militia to suppress these bloody murderers. Quiet reigns until the militia returns home, then the war breaks out again. It may be said, in passing, that no State has had more use for its militia during the last ten or twelve years than Kentucky. It might also be remarked that these troublesome mountaineers of Western and Southwes tern Kentucky are Republicans by a large majority. .West Virginia has done little to sup press this warfare. The present Ooy ernor of that State has done nothing, ex cept to endeavor to procure the custody of the prisoners captured by the authori ties of Pike County, Ky. If he intends that these gory-handed Hatfields shall be released after a mockery of a trial he is preparing a lasting disgrace for his State. But as a matter of law he is right the prisoners made in these raids into West Virginia are held without a shadow of right. The only hope for the wiping out of this disgrace to America is that the Gov ernors of the two States of Kentucky and West Virginia shall agree to declare themselves unable to put down this in surrection against all law and humanity itself and call for United States troops or that the National authorities shall take measures to protect the mails. Even then there is little hope of a permanent peace until drastic measures are taken. It will require wholesale hanging and the incarceration for life of every one connected with thesemurders, either as pnneijiuts or abettors and that means the conviction of a hundred or two of men and some women. Nor is the task of capturing these mountaineers, deserate men acquainted with all the fastnesses of the mountains, , a small task. The Big Sandy country is exceedingly broken and the move ments of even small bodies of troops difficult there. When Mr. McCreary, now in Congress, was Governor of Ken tucky, he sent several companies of militia into Breathitt County to sup press me venuetta mere, a lie moun taineers played hide-and-seek with the young men from the cities when sent out in squads to serve warrants on the ring- : leaders and sent them word of the many occasions on which they might have picked oil the unexperienced citizen soldiery. But when they heard that the Governor was organizing companies in the adjacent peaceable counties they came in and surrendered. They knew their chances were only equal with men who were acquainted with, the uiountains. Nothing will remove this dut. grace but the moat thorough measures which result in the punishment of eyery ) guilty man. The communication of Dr. Shaffranek on the benefits that would result from an' experimental garden on Palatka Hights, which we present in another column, opens views of a future that might be Palatka's if exertions could be made to that end. The amount of influ ence that such a garden would give this city in this section, and, indeed, through out the State, could not be measured by one or two years' results. The move ments which make cities large, rich and influential are built up from such small bptrimiinjrs. Such enterprises react on the public mind, liberalizing it and awakenincr a spirit not content with mere comfort and security. . The New York World says: "A num ber of League teams are going to Florida to play baseball. Florida is destined to become one of the leading States of the Union." The World was always notable for it wisdom and discernment. The champion oarsmen seem to have had fair weather at Punta Gorda, yester day, and made a gallant contest for supremacy, Teenier winning. A full report will be found in our telegraphic columns. - Everything is moving smoothly with the Gala Week Committee now and the outlook is fair for a great time next week.

Clipping to come

The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · Wheeling, W. Va.

A dispatch from Catlettsburg, Ky. claims a McCoy posse ambushed and killed three Hatfield men—Johnson Hatfield, Thomas Chambers, and James Vance—in West Virginia, suffering no losses themselves. It describes the feud as an ongoing 'war of extermination' that authorities are powerless to stop.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · 13 January 1888 · page 1

A FAMILY FEUD WHICH DISGRACES TWO STATES,

Iii Ptkt) Couuly. PlilLAbEM'BlA, February 12.—The Pre.<* to-day says Mr. Kn-se D. Morton, v.ho for tiiteen years has been a United States Marshal's oiticer in Kentucky*, patted through the city yesterday. Mr. Horton is from Car ter county, which is in the "mountain district" of the Bine (iras? State. His adventures among the outlaws, des peradoes and moonshiners ol the Sonth would make eolnmns of interesting read ing. "I know every man, woman aud thild in Pike county," he said, when questioned about the Hatfield-McCoy interstate war, "and I'm glad to bear that Judge Bir has granted a writ of habeas corpus in favor of the Hatfield's now iu jail at Pikeville.

See moreSee less

They couldu't possibly receive a fair trial in the State Courts, because the McCoy's, who are opposing them, are related to ev ery family in Pike county. No jury could be empaneled that would give a Hatfield a fair trial. This ease of feudal warfare has been givtn a national prominence, and yet it is no worse than hundreds of similar 'wars' that are always raging in Kentucky. The Underwood-Holbrook trouble in my coun ty, the Breathitt conntv war. the late Tol liver-Martin fend in Rowan county, are samples of the intenecine warfare that was born of the war between the States. They are always fighting in Kentucky. The newspapers only get hold of the more prominent cases. I know the McCoys and the Hatfields well. 'Bad' McCoy, who was killed during the raid npou the Hat fields, was undoubtedly the lrader of the Kentucky faction He was a fine-looking fellow, six feet and an inch in height, and was a regular mountain donkey. He could shoot 'at the drop of the hat,' and was considered a dangerous man.

Clipping to come

Ceredo Advance · Ceredo, W. Va.

A letter from a Pikeville official describes the Hatfield gang's raid on Randolph McCoy's home, in which his daughter Alifair and son Calvin were killed and his wife wounded, while McCoy himself fled into the woods. The report ties the attack to a longstanding reward for Hatfields wanted in earlier McCoy killings, framing it as an attempt to wipe out the family.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

Ceredo Advance · 13 January 1888 · page 3

The Hatfields Again Make Raid on the McCoys, with a Determination to Exterminate the Family.

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

A special report from Catlettsburg, Ky. states that the McCoy posse captured Will Hatfield and five others in a raid and jailed them in Pike County. It also reports that a man named Jeff Nicolls was killed and that the Hatfield party has been badly worsted in recent engagements.

CorrectionThis set right 2 earlier articles: The Evening Bulletin, 13 January 1888, Richmond Dispatch, 13 January 1888.

Evening Star · 14 January 1888 · page 5

Xieholasville to quarrel about which, has the greatest number of widows for Pike-ville, not a fourth as large as either of them, can discount, both. I' or particu lars read about the McCoy - Hatfield vendettilj cf ' JifoftK ItAiiu granted the writs of habeas corpus, in the case of the Hat fields and ,'tfiir prisoners are to he brought fronrPiko county to the court in at-' the-'expense, of West Virginia, .Argument iifthe eases is set for February 20th.

Clipping to come

The Portland Daily Press · Portland, Me.

A dispatch from Catlettsburg, Ky. claims a new battle broke out between the Hatfield and McCoy clans, killing three Hatfields after McCoys organized a posse in revenge for the earlier New Year's Night massacre. It also recounts that earlier raid, claiming the Hatfields burned the McCoy home and killed young McCoy, his sister, and his mother before old Randall McCoy escaped.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 4 days later.

Wrong

The Portland Daily Press · 14 January 1888 · page 1

KENTUCKY CIVILIZATION.

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Portland Daily Press · Portland, Me.

The report describes the burning of the McCoy home, old man McCoy's escape, and a subsequent McCoy posse raid into West Virginia that allegedly killed three Hatfield men without McCoy losses. It claims authorities are powerless and predicts the feud will continue until one side is exterminated.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Portland Daily Press · 14 January 1888 · page 1

KENTUCKY CIVILIZATION

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

Clipping to come

Narragansett Herald · Narragansett Pier, R.I.

The report describes a nighttime raid by the Hatfield gang on Randall McCoy's home, in which his daughter Alifair and son Calvin were shot dead and his wife was shot and expected to die. It also recounts the feud's origin from an 1882 election-day stabbing and lists rewards offered for the Hatfields' arrest.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 4 days later. CorrectionThis set right 4 earlier articles: Waterbury Evening Democrat, 13 January 1888, The Indianapolis Journal, 13 January 1888, The Hazel Green Herald, 13 January 1888, Ceredo Advance, 13 January 1888.

Wrong

Narragansett Herald · 14 January 1888 · page 4

A KENTUCKY FEUD.

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Narragansett Herald · Narragansett Pier, R.I.

The report describes the Hatfield gang's attack on Randall McCoy's home, claiming his son Calvin and Calvin's wife were shot, his house burned, and that McCoy killed an attacker named Chambers while wounding 'Captain Hatfield.' It also notes a $2,700 reward offered by Kentucky for the Hatfields' arrest.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 4 days later. CorrectionThis set right 2 earlier articles: Waterbury Evening Democrat, 13 January 1888, The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer, 13 January 1888.

Wrong

Narragansett Herald · 14 January 1888 · page 4

A KENTUCKY FEUD

Transcript to come.

No clean clipping could be cut from this page

San Antonio Daily Light · San Antonio, Tex.

A dispatch from Catlettsburg, Ky., reports that the McCoy posse captured Will Hatfield and five companions during a raid, securing them in the Pike County jail. It adds that one more man, Jeff Nickels, was killed, with excitement in the region described as intense.

CorrectionThis set right 2 earlier articles: The Morning News, 13 January 1888, St. Paul Daily Globe, 13 January 1888.

San Antonio Daily Light · 14 January 1888 · page 1

Piked Into Jail

WH uADr OF THE SCENY OF TPE TROUBLE. i NAP OF THE 3CEME OF 1T8E TROUBLE. Iu 1863 Capt. James Vance, a Hatfleld, an officer of the Confederate army, made a raid, during which he met one of his former friends, a MeCoy, whom he shot. This was in the Hatfield-McCoy war what tho firing on Sumter was to the nation. Some time after three McCoys lurked near Vance's house for the purpose of filling him with lead. | Vance's wife, however, pretended to look for er cow, spied out the enemy's camp and n formed her husband. Vance slipped out tho back door, got in the cnowy’s rear, killed two of them and put the third to fight.

Clipping to come

Alexandria Gazette · Alexandria, D.C.

A report from Catlettsburg, Kentucky describes the latest clashes in the Hatfield-McCoy feud, including the McCoy posse's capture of Will Hatfield and five others, jailed in Pike County, and the wounding of Cap Hatfield who escaped. It describes intense fear in Pikeville that the Hatfields might storm the town to free their captured kin, noting high demand for Winchester rifles.

CorrectionThis set right an article from the day before.

Alexandria Gazette · 14 January 1888 · page 2

two of them and put the third to fight. Then the McCoys met one Stratton, a Har. fleld, on a road in Pike county, and scored one for their eide by shooting kim. About five or six yours ago Johnson Hatfleld, a son of Capt. Auson Hatfield, met and wooed a McCoy girl. One night he ran ber of. He lived with ber till he becarce tired of her, and theu lat Ler go. By this time Winchester rifles became plentiful, and the warfare began to be prac ticed on a large scale One day after an election three {eCovs knocked down a Hat fleid and cut him up into mincemeat.

See moreSee less

Where upon Capt. Ans. Hatfield raided Pike county and carried off the three offending McCoys. These McCoye, one of whom was but 15 years old. they tied to trees aud amused themselves in pouring bullets ioto them till they were dead

Clipping to come

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

A dispatch from Catlettsburg, Kentucky reports that McCoy posses captured William Hatfield and five other men during a nighttime raid and placed them in the Pike jail. One man, identified as 'Jeff' Nicells, reportedly escaped during the encounter, and fears of a massacre at Pikeville are mentioned.

New-York Tribune · 15 January 1888 · page 9

FEARING A MASSACRE IN PIKEVILLE, KY.

AES VANCE, CaPI. VANCE. FRASK PILLIPS. CAPT. ANS HATFIELD. After a good many more murders, the state Kentucky concluding that if she did not t interfere there might be bloodshed, offercd beavy rewards for Ans Hatfield and sew ral of that gang Frank Phillips, a Mec Coy, was then deputy sheriff’ of Pike county, | Ky. Taking the warrants, be lad a gang into Logan county and captured tho stepfather of | a man for whom he had a warrant. Soon Sfter another raid was made into Logan unty, W. Va., resulting in the capture of | more prisoners.

See moreSee less

Then the Logan county “regulators” gave notice that if there was auy more “fooling” somebody might get turt. This kept the peace for a while, but uot long. On New Year's night about a dozen Hatflelds surrounded Randall McCoy's log cabin and called ou Lim to come cut and surrender. McCoy was naturally timid about obliging them, whereupon they set the bouse afire. All the occupants of the house xcept one, including aa old woman and a young girl, were shot down. The escaped man was Bepdall McCoy, whose wife, four «ons and & dauguter bave been killed. Capt. Vance, of the Hattields, was the next w tall. The McCoys went to his house when be was away and robbed it. An old woman, Mrs. Vance, Capt. Vance and Capt. Hatfleld, were returniug home, when they met the McCoys. Capt. Vauce rau down the mouu tain side he was descending at the time. As

Clipping to come

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

The report describes renewed violence in the Hatfield-McCoy feud, noting another man killed and panic gripping Pikeville as residents arm themselves with Winchester rifles. It claims Cap Hatfield was dangerously wounded and that the Hatfield party has been defeated in its last two engagements with the McCoys and authorities.

New-York Tribune · 15 January 1888 · page 9

Lornsni.iiE,' Ky., Feb. 17. The nine West Virginians known as the "Hatfields" arrived here last iflght ia. charge of a deputy United States marshal and th jailer of Pike county. The will appear before Judge Barr, of the United States District Court, oa Monday, when the habeas corpus application ot the Governor of West Virginia will be further heard. Valentine Hatfield, the "old man" of the gang, after stat ing that they bad been well treated while in the Pike county jail, gave the following account of the celebrated feud: ; "The whole trouble, so far as I know, began about six or eight years ago.

See moreSee less

I had five brothers Allison. Elias, Anderson, Smith and Patter on. Allison was the first one killed. Three of the McCoy boys cut him on Blackberry creek, on the Kentucky side, and he died the next day. The trouble, I believe, was started by one of the McCoys attempting to arrest Anderson Hat field's son Johnson, about eight years ago. There was a row then, bnt I do not remember exactly what it was. After Allison Hatfild was killed. Talbert. Richard and Farmer McCoy, all young men, were killed by a crowd supposed to Lave com from West Virginia. The killing was done on the bridge between Blackberry and Mates creek. The next Pike county grand jury Indicted a lot of people in West Virginia. - No one was arrested, however, and after that. Jeff McCoy, who is Bid Daniel's brotber-in law, bear! Daniel and Tom Wallace abusing the Hstfleid;. and a quarrel followed. McCoy at tempted to arr-st Wallace, and a fight took place. This resulted in Captain Hatfield, ar resting McCoy, and when McCoy tried to get away be was killed by the men who were guard ing him. It was said that Captaio Hatfield and Tom Wallace killed him. Some time after this a squad of men went to Randolph McCoy's bouse and killed one of h'.s sons and a daughter, and beat up hi old woman. This was charged to the Hat fields, but I never knew any thing about it until some ' time after the murders were committed. A short time after this, a company of Pike county men was formed to follow the Hatfie Ids and kill them. They eame into West Virginia and found Jim Vance and Captain Hatfield on a bridge near Hacker's ereek. They shot Vance to death and wounded Captain Hatfield. After that the Kentuckians eame in and captured us while we were at work on our farms. None of us resisted, and no injury was done us, but if there was any authority for confining us in jail, I never heard of it." County Attorney J. L. Ferguson, of Pike, was questioned concerning the claim of the pris oners that they were - innocent. He laughed at the idea, and said that while the worst of the Hatfield crowd had not been captured, the men

Clipping to come

Wichita Eagle · Wichita, Kan.

A dispatch from Catlettsburg, Kentucky describes the ongoing Hatfield-McCoy conflict, reporting that a McCoy posse captured Will Hatfield and five others and jailed them in Pikeville, and that Captain Hatfield was badly wounded in a recent clash. The report notes Pikeville residents are fearful of a Hatfield raid to free prisoners and burn the town, with Winchester rifles in high demand.

Wichita Eagle · 15 January 1888 · page 2

A WAR OF FACTIONS.

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

St. Paul Daily Globe · Saint Paul, Minn.

A dispatch from Catlettsburg, Ky. claims a McCoy posse captured Will Hatfield and five others and jailed them in Pike County, while also reporting another man, Jeff Nickels, killed. It describes general panic in Pikeville, high demand for rifles, and claims the Hatfield faction has been badly beaten in recent clashes.

St. Paul Daily Globe · 15 January 1888 · page 7

Virginia had b-eo retained with a fee of foOO to prevent Governor Wilson from recognizing the requisition issued by Governor Buckner. He charred, also, that the Hatfield crowd had brought other influences to near, and that the worst of "the gang were now to comparative se curity. Of the prisoners now in the Louisville jail, Mr. Ferguson says that Valentine Hatfield recently confessed to him that he had five living wives and thirty three living children. Nine of his children bave died. Mr. Ferguson states that Hatfield has peculiar ideas of polygamy, and does not marry his wives accord' ing to law, but takes them and apportions his time out between them.

Clipping to come

The Memphis Appeal · Memphis, Tenn.

A dispatch from Catlettsburg, Kentucky says a McCoy posse captured Will Hatfield and five others in a raid, killing one more man, amid intense excitement in Pikeville. It also reports Cap Hatfield was badly wounded but escaped, and that the Hatfields are expected to retaliate by attacking the town.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 4 days later.

Wrong

The Memphis Appeal · 15 January 1888 · page 10

HATFIELD-M'COY FEUD. THE VIBOINIA CONTINGENT IN THE LOUISVILLE JAIL. bid Man Valentin Hatfield Tells Straightforward Story About the Bloody War that Waged Botween the Families. Louisviixe, Ky., Feb. 17. Tlio nine West Virginians known as the "llatflolds" arrived here liwt night in charge of a lop uty United Stutos marshal and the jailer of Piko county. They will appear beforo Jn.lgo Burr, of the United States district court, Monday, hon tho habeas corpus application of tho Governor of West Vir ginia will bo further heard. Vulcntinc Hatfield, the "old niiin" of tho pinfr, after stating that they had 1een well treated w hile in tho Piko county jail, gnvo the fol lowing account of tho celebrated feud: "Thcwholo trouble, so fur as I know, be pan ulwut six or eight years ago.

See moreSee less

I had five brothers Kllison, Klias, Andemon, Smith und rutterson. Ellison was tho first one killed. Three of the McCoy boys shut and cut him on Uhickbcrry creek, on tho Kentucky side, and ho died tho next lay. Tho trouble, I believe, was Btartcd ly one of the Md'ojl attempting to arrest Andertwn lluttield's son JoliiiHon, iilxitit cilit years ago. Tlir was a row, but I don't remember exactly what it was. After KMihon Hatfield was killi'if, Talbert, hichavd and Fanner McCoy, all young men, wero killed by a crowd Hiipimned to liave come from Wtt Virginia. The kill ing was done on the bridge lK'twecn Brack borrv and Mutes crocks. "the next 1'iko rounly jrrnnil Jury in dicted a lot of H'ople in West Irginta. Ho one was amnteu. however, anil after that Jeff McCoy, who is Hill Daniel's brother-in-law, heard unicls and Tom AVallaro abusing the Huttields, and a nnnr itl followed. JlcCoy attempted to ufrest VuIlmi. and tight took place. This roBulted iu Cant, llatllcld arresting MeCov. nml when McCoy tried to got away he wiis killed by tho nx-n w ho were guiinliiie bun. Some, time after this a s)iiad of men went to Kandolph McCoy's house and killed one of his sons' and daughter, and beat up his old woman. This wus charged to the Hulllrlds, but I never knew any thing about it until some time after the murders wcro committed. "A short time after this, company of I'iko county men was lorruM to lullow tho Hattielils and kill them. They came into Went irginia and lound Jim, anee and Capt. llallleld on bridgo near Thacker's creek. They shot Vance to death and wounded Capt. Hatfield. After that tho Jventuckians came ra and captured us while, we were at work on our furins. None of us resisted and no injury was done us. but if there there was any authority for confining us in Jail, 1 never beard 01 1L County Attorney J. Lee , Ferguson, of Tike, was questioned concerning the claim of the prisoners that they were innocent He laughed at the idea, and said that while the worst of the liuttlcld crowd had not been captured, the men who are now in the Louisville tail are undoubtedly a Dart of the gang. Ho declared Uiat the prisoners bad not been unlawfully im prisoned, bnt alter having crossed the 1 (or der line between West V irginia and Ken tucky, bad been legally arrested and taken to jail by the proper otlicem. He did not deny that the N est Virginians had been forcibly taken from their homes, but held that the Kentnckians wore justified by the danger! threatening them in taking the matter into their own bands when the West Virginia authorities refused to asxist in restraining and punishing the outlaws, who bad only to cross a narrow etream to commit the most atrocious crimes and then cross hack again to safety from the law. Mr. Ferguson asserted positively that he had creditable information that a but official of West Virginia bod been re tained with a fee of I-hxj to prevent iiov. Wilson from recorcixins the reaoisition Lssued by Got. ltuckner. He charged also that the Hatfield crew had brought other influences to bear, and that the worst of the gang wen now in comparative ruritv. Of the prisoner now In the Louisville iitil, Mr. Ferguson says that Valentine lntfirl d recently confessed to him that he bad live living wives and thirtv-thrce liv ing children. Niua of his children have died. Mr. Ferguson states that Hatfield has peculiar ideas of polygamy and doea tint marry his wife according to law, bnt bikes them and apportions ins umo out between mem.

Clipping to come

Weekly Courier-Journal · Louisville, Ky.

The story claims that after burying their dead, the McCoys formed a posse and attacked the Hatfield settlement in West Virginia, resulting in a battle that killed three Hatfield men (Johnson Hatfield, Thomas Chambers, James Vance) with no McCoy casualties. It states authorities are powerless to stop the ongoing feud.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

Weekly Courier-Journal · 16 January 1888 · page 3

WAR OF EXTERMINATION

Louisviixe, Ky., Feb. 17. Tlio nine West Virginians known as the "llatflolds" arrived here liwt night in charge of a lop uty United Stutos marshal and the jailer of Piko county. They will appear beforo Jn.lgo Burr, of the United States district court, Monday, hon tho habeas corpus application of tho Governor of West Vir ginia will bo further heard. Vulcntinc Hatfield, the "old niiin" of tho pinfr, after stating that they had 1een well treated w hile in tho Piko county jail, gnvo the fol lowing account of tho celebrated feud: "Thcwholo trouble, so fur as I know, be pan ulwut six or eight years ago.

See moreSee less

I had five brothers Kllison, Klias, Andemon, Smith und rutterson. Ellison was tho first one killed. Three of the McCoy boys shut and cut him on Uhickbcrry creek, on tho Kentucky side, and ho died tho next lay. Tho trouble, I believe, was Btartcd ly one of the Md'ojl attempting to arrest Andertwn lluttield's son JoliiiHon, iilxitit cilit years ago. Tlir was a row, but I don't remember exactly what it was. After KMihon Hatfield was killi'if, Talbert, hichavd and Fanner McCoy, all young men, wero killed by a crowd Hiipimned to liave come from Wtt Virginia. The kill ing was done on the bridge lK'twecn Brack borrv and Mutes crocks. "the next 1'iko rounly jrrnnil Jury in dicted a lot of H'ople in West Irginta. Ho one was amnteu. however, anil after that Jeff McCoy, who is Hill Daniel's brother-in-law, heard unicls and Tom AVallaro abusing the Huttields, and a nnnr itl followed. JlcCoy attempted to ufrest VuIlmi. and tight took place. This roBulted iu Cant, llatllcld arresting MeCov. nml when McCoy tried to got away he wiis killed by tho nx-n w ho were guiinliiie bun. Some, time after this a s)iiad of men went to Kandolph McCoy's house and killed one of his sons' and daughter, and beat up his old woman. This wus charged to the Hulllrlds, but I never knew any thing about it until some time after the murders wcro committed. "A short time after this, company of I'iko county men was lorruM to lullow tho Hattielils and kill them. They came into Went irginia and lound Jim, anee and Capt. llallleld on bridgo near Thacker's creek. They shot Vance to death and wounded Capt. Hatfield. After that tho

Clipping to come

The Climax · Richmond, Ky.

The report describes a New Year's raid by the Hatfield gang on Randall McCoy's home in Pike County, Kentucky, in which his home was burned and his daughter Alifair, son Calvin, and wife were reportedly killed. It states Randall McCoy fought back, killing a gang member named Chambers and wounding Cap Hatfield before the attackers fled.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day. CorrectionThis set right 3 earlier articles: The Portland Daily Press, 14 January 1888, Narragansett Herald, 14 January 1888, Narragansett Herald, 14 January 1888.

Wrong

The Climax · 18 January 1888 · page 4

Wilson from recorcixins the reaoisition Lssued by Got. ltuckner. He charged also that the Hatfield crew had brought other influences to bear, and that the worst of the gang wen now in comparative ruritv. Of the prisoner now In the Louisville

Clipping to come

Paper unidentified

A Cattlettsburg, Kentucky dispatch reports that after a recent McCoy funeral, a McCoy posse raided the Hatfield settlement in West Virginia seeking revenge, resulting in a gun battle. The report claims three Hatfield men—Johnson Hatfield, Thomas Chambers, and James Vance—were killed while no McCoys were harmed.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

Paper unidentified · 18 January 1888 · page 1

A Virginia Vendetta

Transcript to come.

No clean clipping could be cut from this page

The Fairfield News and Herald · Winnsboro, S.C.

A dispatch from Cattlettsburg, Ky., reports that a McCoy posse attacked the Hatfield settlement after a recent killing, resulting in a pitched battle. It claims three Hatfield men—including Johnson Hatfield, Thomas Chambers, and James Vance—were killed, while no McCoys were hurt.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

The Fairfield News and Herald · 18 January 1888 · page 1

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Laurens Advertiser · Laurens, S.C.

A Chicago dispatch claims a McCoy posse attacked the Hatfield settlement in West Virginia after a funeral, resulting in a battle that killed three Hatfield men including Johnson Hatfield, Thomas Chambers, and James Vance, with no McCoy casualties. The report states authorities are powerless to stop the ongoing feud.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

The Laurens Advertiser · 18 January 1888 · page 1

A Virginia Vendetta

State about which correspondents of metrojKditan papers, sent out to 1 write up the McCoy—Hatfield troubles, lie; but Kentucky also is misrepresented by lying correspond ents. In order to give our readers an idea of the extent to which some of the unprincipled scamps go in their misrepresentations, we give an extract from a letter written to the New York Herald. about our J beautiful sister town, Catlcttsburg:

Clipping to come

The National Tribune · Washington, D.C.

The passage reports that the Hatfield faction set fire to the McCoy homestead in Logan County, W. Va., killing the mother, daughter, and a son by gunfire while the husband escaped. This brief account frames the attack as part of a long-standing family feud.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

The National Tribune · 19 January 1888 · page 8

CRIMES AND CASUALTIES.

OLD man Hatfield, one of Speaker Carlisle's constituents who has worked bard for the past eight years to kill ofl the McCoy family, is now in jail. He is a polygamist, too. REPRESENTATIVE BAKER of New York thinks the bouse will vote to divide Da kota that quite a number of Demoorats will vote with the Republicans to spite Springer, whom they do not like.

Clipping to come

The Washington Critic · Washington, D.C.

A dispatch from Charleston, W.Va. claims the Hatfield gang raided the home of Sim McCoy, tying Mrs. Randall to a tree and shooting her and her eldest son, then burning the house with McCoy and two younger children inside. The report describes this as retaliation following an earlier killing of part of Randall McCoy's family.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

The Washington Critic · 19 January 1888 · page 1

TERRIBLE OUTRAGE

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Rock Island Daily Argus · Rock Island, Ill.

A dispatch from Charleston, W. Va. claims the Hatfield gang raided the home of Sam McCoy, brother of Randall, tying his wife to a tree and shooting her and her son, then burning the house with McCoy and two young children inside. The account describes this as happening days after an earlier attack on Randall McCoy's family.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

Rock Island Daily Argus · 19 January 1888 · page 2

DEVILISH HATFIELD ATROCITY.

Transcript to come.

No clean clipping could be cut from this page

The Emporia Weekly News · Emporia, Kan.

The report says a McCoy posse captured Will Hatfield and five others, jailing them in Pike County, and that Jeff McCoy was killed in an unreported incident. It also notes Cap Hatfield was wounded, tensions are high in Pikeville, and residents fear a Hatfield raid to free the prisoners.

CorrectionThis set right an article from 4 days earlier.

The Emporia Weekly News · 19 January 1888 · page 3

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

Clipping to come

The Big Sandy News · Louisa, Ky.

The report describes a McCoy posse raiding the Hatfield settlement in West Virginia after the recent killings, resulting in a gunfight in which three Hatfield men—Johnson Hatfield, Thomas Chambers, and James Vance—were reportedly killed while no McCoys were hurt. It notes authorities are powerless to stop the feud and predicts it will continue until one side is exterminated.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

The Big Sandy News · 19 January 1888 · page 1

A SECOND BATTLE

HABEAS CORPUS WRITS DENIED. Applications for writs of habeas corpus were denied in the cases pf McCoy and others, the West Virginians who were kid naped into Kentucky by Kentucky deputy sheriffs (known as the McCoy-Hatfield vendetta case); McCoy and Bernhamer, of Indiana, now serving sentences for election tally sheet frauds, and Benson, who is awaiting extradition in New York for the Patti concert ticket swindle in the City of Mexico. A writ of habeas corpus was granted to the musicians convicted in the Washington Police Court for conspiracy to destroy the business of other musicians by boycotting them.

See moreSee less

The cases are known as the “Union musicians boycotting cases.” The members of the union had demanded trial by jury when the cases came before the Police Court, but this was denied them. Under to-day’s decision the prisoners were dis charged. RIGHTS OF STATES.

Clipping to come

The Big Sandy News · Louisa, Ky.

Amid a column of miscellaneous local items, the paper notes it received a communication from Pikeville this week concerning the Hatfield feud. No further details of the letter's content are given.

The Big Sandy News · 19 January 1888 · page 3

RIGHTS OF STATES. The court in its opinion refusing habeas corpus to Mahan, in the Hatfield-McCoy Vendetta cases, enunciates the following as its views with regard to the rights of States in these cases: “If the States of the Union

Clipping to come

The Big Sandy News · Louisa, Ky.

A reprinted Cincinnati Telegram dispatch claims the Hatfield gang raided the home of Sim McCoy in Wyoming County, West Virginia, shooting McCoy and his son and burning two young children to death after setting the house on fire. The report is paired with a separate review of the Pike County indictments and rewards offered for Hatfield suspects.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

The Big Sandy News · 19 January 1888 · page 3

Keeping It Up. The Work of Annihilation by the Hatfield Gang.

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Big Sandy News · Louisa, Ky.

The report details the burning of Randall McCoy's house and killing of two children, followed by a posse led by Frank Phillips raiding into West Virginia, killing James Vance and wounding Cap and Johnson Hatfield. It also describes the confused legal proceedings over Tom Chambers' custody and the Governor of West Virginia's refusal to honor extradition requests.

CorrectionThis set right 4 earlier articles: The Climax, 18 January 1888, Paper unidentified, 18 January 1888, The Fairfield News and Herald, 18 January 1888, The Laurens Advertiser, 18 January 1888.

The Big Sandy News · 19 January 1888 · page 3

Transcript to come.

No clean clipping could be cut from this page

Crawford Avalanche · Grayling, Mich.

A telegram claims the McCoys organized a posse that attacked the Hatfield settlement in West Virginia after a recent killing, resulting in a battle in which three Hatfield men—Johnson Hatfield, Thomas Chambers, and John Vance—were killed with no McCoy casualties. The report states authorities are powerless to stop the feud, which it predicts will continue until one side is exterminated.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

Crawford Avalanche · 19 January 1888 · page 4

Transcript to come.

No clean clipping could be cut from this page

The Frontier · O'Neill City, Neb.

A dispatch claims a McCoy posse invaded West Virginia to wipe out the Hatfields, resulting in a bloody battle that left three Hatfield men dead, including Johnson Hatfield, Thomas Chambers, and James Vance. The report describes ongoing extermination warfare between the two clans with authorities powerless to intervene.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

The Frontier · 19 January 1888 · page 3

KENTUCKY VS. WEST VIRGINIA

THE ELECTION FRAUD CASES The supreme court to-day rendered a de­ cision sustaining the decision of the court below in the case of Pliant Mahon, appel­ lant, vs. Abner Justice, jailor of Pike county, Ky. This is an application for writ of habeas corpus arising out of the 'Celebrated Hatfield-McCoy vendetta, brought here on appeal from the circuit court of the United States for the district of Kentucky which declined to grant writ. The court also rendered an opinion deny­ ing the application of Coy and Bemhamer for writ of habeas corpus. These cases are better known as Indiana tally sheet elec­ tion fraud cases. The supreme court to­ day adjourned until next term beginning in October.

Clipping to come

The News-Herald · Hillsboro, Ohio

The dispatch describes a McCoy posse crossing into West Virginia seeking revenge, clashing with the Hatfield gang in the woods, and claims three Hatfield associates were killed while no McCoys were hurt. It predicts the feud will continue until one side is exterminated, since authorities seem powerless to intervene.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

The News-Herald · 19 January 1888 · page 8

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

Clipping to come

Democratic Northwest · Napoleon, Ohio

The report claims a McCoy posse ambushed the Hatfields in West Virginia after a funeral, resulting in a battle in which three Hatfields—including Johnson Hatfield, Thomas Chambers, and James Vance—were killed while no McCoys were hurt. It portrays the feud as an ongoing war of extermination that authorities are powerless to stop.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

Democratic Northwest · 19 January 1888 · page 10

Transcript to come.

No clean clipping could be cut from this page

In the story →

The Stark County Democrat · Canton, Ohio

A dispatch from Catlettsburg, Ky. reports that a McCoy posse captured Will Hatfield and five others, jailing them in Pike County, while claiming another man, 'Jell Mickels,' was killed. It describes intense fear in Pikeville, rumors of an imminent Hatfield raid to free prisoners, high demand for Winchester rifles, and claims Captain Hatfield was wounded in a prior clash.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

The Stark County Democrat · 19 January 1888 · page 6 · transcribed from the page image

WINCHESTER RIFLES

In Great Demand, and Commanding a Premium,

See moreSee less

At the Scene of the Hatfield-McCoy Feud on the West Virginia Border in Kentucky ---General News.

CATLETTSBURG, Ky., Jan. 14.—[Special.]—The latest intelligence from the seat of the Hatfield-McCoy war, is to the effect that McCoy's posse captured Will Hatfield and five others in the raid other night and landed them safely in the Pike county jail. One more man was killed who has not been reported, Jeff Mickels. The excitement in that section county is intense and beggars description. Everybody is up in arms, and the scenes surpass those of the late war. There is little sleeping done in Pikeville now, as all is expectancy, and citizens would not be surprised anyhow, to see the Hatfields swoop down upon them, extricate their members and burn the town, to say nothing of the people they would kill. The Hatfields are known to be well organized. Winchester rifles are in great demand, and command good prices. Captain Hatfield was dangerously wounded in the last encounter, but managed to make his escape. The Hatfield party had been badly worsted in the last two engagements, the McCoy party and authorities escaping unhurt. Music from that quarter may be heard now at any time.

See the clipping

The Stark County Democrat · Canton, Ohio

A dispatch from Catlettsburg, Ky. claims the McCoys organized a posse and attacked the Hatfield settlement in a full battle, killing three Hatfields (named John Hatfield, Thomas Chambers, and James Nance) with no McCoy casualties. It predicts the feud will continue until one side is exterminated, noting authorities are powerless to stop it.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

The Stark County Democrat · 19 January 1888 · page 6

IN AMERICA, TOO!

THE recent decision of the United States Supreme Court in the case of disputed jurisdiction between West Virginia and Kentucky, growing out of the Hatfield-McCoy vendetta, affirms

Clipping to come

National Republican (Washington City) · D.C.

This report describes the Hatfields burning Randall McCoy's home on New Year's night, killing his wife, son, and daughter while he escaped to the woods. It further claims the McCoys organized a retaliatory raid that resulted in a pitched battle in which three Hatfields were killed and no McCoys were harmed.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 3 days later.

Wrong

National Republican (Washington City) · 20 January 1888 · page 1

TERMINATING THE FEUD OUTRAGES

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

National Republican (Washington City) · D.C.

The report describes the Hatfields burning Randall McCoy's home, killing his wife, son and daughter, with McCoy himself escaping into the woods. It also claims the McCoys retaliated with an armed raid that killed three Hatfields, followed by a separate account of a Hatfield attack on Sim McCoy's house.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 3 days later.

Wrong

National Republican (Washington City) · 20 January 1888 · page 1

TERMINATING THE FEUD

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

Clipping to come

The Palatka Daily News · Palatka, Fla.

A dispatch from Charleston, W. Va. claims the Hatfields staged a new raid, killing five members of Sim McCoy's family by shooting and burning their house. It also recaps an earlier supposed Hatfield massacre of Randall McCoy's household and a McCoy retaliatory raid.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 3 days later.

Wrong

The Palatka Daily News · 20 January 1888 · page 1

WHOLESALE MURDER.

General Gresham, when informed ' of lliurman'i nomination, said: “The best thing that could have, happened for Republican success in I Indiana. 1 his State is ours with out a doubt." And if General H.ir '"-on is nominated General Gresham will loyally support him. If G re>h-' am is nominated Harrison will sup port him as we!!. The countr-, expects Indiana Republicans to do1 their duty this year. Their State can be carried.— /£p. ----«<♦ - Governor Wilson has offered the following rewards for the parties rnK;,Ecd in killing James Vance and W. I>. Dempsey, in the recent Hatfield-McCoy vendetta, and who are indicted by the court of !.ogan county. The parties wanted are residentsof Hike county. Kentucky. Those for whom rewards are offered

Clipping to come

The Morning News · Savannah, Ga.

An early wire report claims Hatfields killed five McCoys in a new attack, conflating Randall McCoy's family with a supposed separate raid on 'Sim McCoy.' It describes Mrs. McCoy being tied to a tree and shot, and children burned alive in a house fire.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 3 days later.

Wrong

The Morning News · 20 January 1888 · page 1

M'COYS MASSACRED.

Governor Wilson of West Vir ginia, has offered a reward ot one handred dollars each for the arrest of twenty-seven men, five handred for another man and two hundred for still another, making thirty-four bandred in all. This 1s the latest move in the Hatfield-McCoy Dbus

Clipping to come

The Hazel Green Herald · Hazel Green, Ky.

The report states the McCoy faction captured Will Hatfield and five others during a raid and jailed them in Pike County, with one more man killed (unnamed, reported as Jeff Nickels). It describes intense excitement in the region, armed citizens, high demand for Winchester rifles, and claims Cap Hatfield was wounded but escaped after the Hatfields were 'badly worsted' in recent clashes.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 3 days later. CorrectionThis set right 2 earlier articles: The Big Sandy News, 19 January 1888, The Stark County Democrat, 19 January 1888.

Wrong

The Hazel Green Herald · 20 January 1888 · page 1

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Evening Bulletin · Maysville, Ky.

A dispatch from Charleston, W.Va. claims the Hatfield gang raided the home of Sim McCoy, brother of Randall, tying Mrs. Randall to a tree and shooting her and her eldest son, then burning the house with McCoy and two young children inside. This garbled account conflates names and details of the actual New Year's Day attack on Randall McCoy's own household.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Evening Bulletin · 20 January 1888 · page 1

CAPTAIN ALFRED W. BURNETT, a private detective, has succeeded in capt uring David Straton, one of the lead ers in the late feud in I^ogan and Pike counties, Ky., between the Hatfield*

Clipping to come

Fisherman & Farmer · Edenton, N.C.

The report describes a Hatfield gang raid on Randall McCoy's home, in which his daughter Alifair and son Calvin were shot dead, his wife was shot in the head, and McCoy himself escaped and allegedly killed one attacker named Chambers. It also recounts the feud's origin in an 1882 election-day killing and subsequent execution of three McCoy brothers.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out. CorrectionThis set right an article from the day before.

Fisherman & Farmer · 20 January 1888 · page 7

THE kENTM'kV VENDETTA. The llnlUriil-Hrinr Vend Renewed with Eat .I Hesnlta. LonrsviLLK, Ky.t Aug. 15. — Advices from Catletlsburg say the Hatfield-McCoy feud has broken out again. The troable was stirred up by the Sheriff, who went out to summon a w itness in the Hatfield case, and was attacked. This was fol lowed up by a meeting Sunday between the Hatfield and McCoy gangs, since which three of the former have been killed and several of the latter badly wounded.

Clipping to come

Fisherman & Farmer · Edenton, N.C.

An account describes the Hatfield gang raiding Randall McCoy's home in Pike County, Kentucky, killing his daughter Alifair and son Calvin and wounding his wife, while Randall escaped and fought back. It notes rewards offered for the Hatfields' arrest and claims they remain defiantly entrenched in West Virginia.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out. CorrectionThis set right 7 earlier articles: The Washington Critic, 19 January 1888, Rock Island Daily Argus, 19 January 1888, The Big Sandy News, 19 January 1888, Crawford Avalanche, 19 January 1888, The Frontier, 19 January 1888, The News-Herald, 19 January 1888, The Stark County Democrat, 19 January 1888.

Fisherman & Farmer · 20 January 1888 · page 7

WARRING KENTUCKY FACTIONS. The Hattield-McCoy Feud Resalts in More Bloodshed. Catlettsburg, Ky., Aug. 14. —There is trouble again in Pike County between the Hatfields and McCoys. Frank

Clipping to come

Shenandoah Herald · Woodstock, Va.

A dispatch from Catlettsburg, KY reports that a McCoy posse captured Will Hatfield and five others during a raid, lodging them in the Pike County jail, with one more man, Jeff Nicolls, reported killed. The report describes intense excitement and fear in Pikeville that the Hatfields might retaliate by attacking the town.

Shenandoah Herald · 20 January 1888 · page 2

THE HATFIELD-M'COY WAR

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Shenandoah Herald · Woodstock, Va.

This report describes a nighttime raid on the McCoy family home in Logan County, West Virginia, in which the house was set afire and family members were shot as they fled, with suspicion falling on the rival Hatfields. It also recounts background on the feud's origins, including an earlier killing and a lynching.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 3 days later.

Wrong

Shenandoah Herald · 20 January 1888 · page 1

FAMILY NEARLY ANNIHILATED IN ONE NIGHT MOTHER, SON AND DAUGHTER RUTHLESSLY SLAUGHTERED, AND THEIR HOUSE BURNED

TELEGRAPHIC. BLOODIER (ET. More Sore Spilled on the Dark and Bloody Uround. Catlettsbi'rc;, Ky., September 17.— Two men, Steele and Mr coatee, both diunk, hoarded a train atMt. Sterling yes terday afternoon, and fought all the way toStepstone, where the conductor, for the safety of the passengers, put the men off and told them to fight it out. They drew pistols and exchanged five shots each. The fifth shot from Steele's pis tol passed through Mackabee's brain, kill ins him instantly. They were cousins. After killing him Steele boarded the train and proceeded homeward, the train having waited until the duel was over.

See moreSee less

There was another pitched battle at Pawpaw Mountain on Friday between the McCoy and Hatfield factions, who had so often met before. Two McCoys were killed and two badly wounded. The McCoyj were driven off. Paducah, Ky., September 17.—An in cendiary fire this morning caused a loss of $200,000, insurance one-half. The chief losers are Kikopf & Co. saddlery, $70,000; Ellis & Ruddy, $50,000; J. L. AUard, $40,000; German National Bank, $25,000. Another Claimant of Distinction. Brussels, September 17. —Captain Van Gele, who has just returned from the Congo Country, states that he be lieves he himself is the man described as "The White Pasha," who is said to have been seen in the Bahrelguzeel dis trict. He says that at the beginning of the year he had a number of conflicts with natives in the direction of Bahrel gazeel.

Clipping to come

Shenandoah Herald · Woodstock, Va.

The report describes the aftermath of the New Year's Night attack on the McCoy home, including the mother being shot as she found her dead and dying children, and the father's escape into the woods. It then claims a McCoy posse invaded Hatfield territory in West Virginia and killed three Hatfields, including Johnson Hatfield, in a pitched battle with no McCoy casualties.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

Shenandoah Herald · 20 January 1888 · page 1

ANOTHER BATTLE BETWEEN THE MCCOYS AND HATFIELDS

More Sore Spilled on the Dark and Bloody Uround. Catlettsbi'rc;, Ky., September 17.— Two men, Steele and Mr coatee, both diunk, hoarded a train atMt. Sterling yes terday afternoon, and fought all the way toStepstone, where the conductor, for the safety of the passengers, put the men off and told them to fight it out. They drew pistols and exchanged five shots each. The fifth shot from Steele's pis tol passed through Mackabee's brain, kill ins him instantly. They were cousins. After killing him Steele boarded the train and proceeded homeward, the train having waited until the duel was over.

See moreSee less

There was another pitched battle at Pawpaw Mountain on Friday between the McCoy and Hatfield factions, who had so often met before. Two McCoys were killed and two badly wounded. The McCoyj were driven off. Paducah, Ky., September 17.—An in

Clipping to come

Alexandria Gazette · Alexandria, D.C.

The item reports a supposed new massacre, claiming Hatfields burned Randall McCoy's house killing his wife, son, and daughter, then claims a McCoy posse killed three Hatfields in a pitched battle. It also mentions a raid on Sim McCoy's house with the McCoys 'completely' something (text cut off).

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 3 days later.

Wrong

Alexandria Gazette · 20 January 1888 · page 2

Her People the Crime Laid at Her Door. The Chicago Dynamiters in Conrt, and Postponement Taken The HatfieldMcCoy Trouble Resumed by These Factions Other

Clipping to come

Alexandria Gazette · Alexandria, D.C.

The report describes a Hatfield raid on the McCoy home in which Mrs. McCoy was tied to a tree and shot, a son was riddled with bullets, and the house was burned with two children inside. It also claims an earlier pitched battle in West Virginia left three Hatfields dead with no McCoy casualties.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

Alexandria Gazette · 20 January 1888 · page 2

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Richmond Dispatch · Richmond, Va.

A New York dispatch recounts a 'bloody chapter' in the Hatfield-McCoy feud, describing a night raid on Randolph McCoy's home in which Mrs. McCoy was reportedly tied up and shot, a son was hanged and shot, and two children burned to death when the house was set afire. The account claims this followed earlier fighting in which several Hatfields were killed in the woods.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

Richmond Dispatch · 20 January 1888 · page 3

Some More Killing. Catti.etsbukg, Ky., Sept. 17.— Another raid was made by the McCoys on the Hatfield settlement Friday night last and, as usual, the Virginians were worsted. The McCoy crowd made a raid yesterday and attempted to arrest one of our innocent citizens, Richard Casey, a person who never had any thing to do with the trouble. They were stopped, however. Their action 60 enraged the neighborhood that nearly every man took his gun and went in pursuit. They came upon the West Virginia boys at Paw Paw moun tain. In the melee two of the West Virginians were killed and two more badly wounded. None of the Ken tucky boys were hurt.

Clipping to come

Richmond Dispatch · Richmond, Va.

A telegraphed dispatch claims the Hatfields struck again, this time wiping out the family of Sim McCoy, Randall McCoy's brother, in a brutal raid involving burning and shooting. It also recaps the earlier New Year's attack on Randall McCoy's own home, claiming his wife, son, and daughter were killed as he fled into the woods.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 3 days later.

Wrong

Richmond Dispatch · 20 January 1888 · page 3

THE M'COY-HATFIELD FEUD

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

West Virginia Democrat · Charles Town, W. Va.

A wire dispatch claims the Hatfields burned Randall McCoy's house, killing his wife and son and burning his family, with five McCoys dead total. It further claims the McCoys retaliated with a posse, resulting in a pitched battle in which three Hatfields were killed and no McCoys injured.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 3 days later.

Wrong

West Virginia Democrat · 20 January 1888 · page 3

THE McCOY-HATFIELD FEUD.

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

West Virginia Democrat · Charles Town, W. Va.

The report describes Hatfields burning McCoy's house and killing his wife, son and daughter while Randall McCoy escaped, then claims McCoys retaliated with a posse that killed three Hatfields. It also gives a separate, confused account of an attack on 'Sim McCoy,' whose wife and children were allegedly tied up, shot, and burned.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

West Virginia Democrat · 20 January 1888 · page 3

THE McCOY-HATFIELD FEUD.

Transcript to come.

No clean clipping could be cut from this page

Huntsville Gazette · Huntsville, Ala.

A dispatch from Charleston, W. Va., claims the Hatfield gang raided the home of Sim McCoy, tying Mrs. Randall McCoy to a tree and shooting her along with her eldest son, then burning the house with McCoy and two young children inside. The report presents this as a continuation of an earlier attack that killed part of Randall McCoy's family.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

Huntsville Gazette · 21 January 1888 · page 2

A Terrible Raid.

It is positively denied from Catletts "burg, Ky., that the principals in the McCoy-Hatfield vendetta have been acquitted. Their trials have not begun. TnE corner stone of the new Mason

Clipping to come

Der Deutsche Correspondent · Baltimore, Md.

A German-language U.S. newspaper derides the ongoing feud in southeastern Kentucky as a disgrace exceeding Apache cruelty, framing it as a counterpoint to nativist complaints about immigrant demoralization. It claims that after an earlier Hatfield defeat, the Hatfields attacked the McCoys the previous Saturday killing five, after which the McCoys rallied and killed three Hatfields in turn.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 2 days later.

Wrong

Der Deutsche Correspondent · 21 January 1888 · page 2

I t is positively denied from Catletts burg, Ky., that the principals in the McCoy-Hatfield vendetta have been acquitted. Their trials have not begun. The corner stone of the new Mason

Clipping to come

The Ohio Democrat · Logan, Ohio

A dispatch claims that after the recent killings, a McCoy posse attacked the Hatfield settlement in West Virginia and killed three Hatfield men, including James Vance, without losing any of their own. It predicts the feud will continue until one side is exterminated, as authorities seem unable or unwilling to intervene.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 2 days later. CorrectionThis set right an article from the day before.

Wrong

The Ohio Democrat · 21 January 1888 · page 2

A SECOND BATTLE

Hat field-McCoy Tronblw. CATLETS3URG, Ky., Sept. 19.—All busi ness in this region is paralyzed, and will be until the Hatfield-McCoy vendetta is raised. Non-participants in the troubles

Clipping to come

Custer Chronicle · Custer City, Black Hills, S.D.

A dispatch from Catlettsburg, Kentucky describes a bloody clash between the McCoy and Hatfield factions after McCoy organized a posse to attack the Hatfield settlement in West Virginia. It claims the Hatfield side was badly beaten, with three men—Johnson Hatfield, Thomas Chambers, and James Vance—reported killed.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 2 days later.

Wrong

Custer Chronicle · 21 January 1888 · page 3

KENTUCKY VS. WEST VIRGINIA

Joseph Cannon, an employe of Allen's mill, Birmingham, Conn., had both legs torn off from his hips by being caught in re volving machinery. Death was instantane ous. John Firth, of Rah way, N. J., and his brother Rimon, of Paterson, N. J. , who was visiting him, were both struck and instantly killed by the Chicago'limited express in Iiah way. Both had been drinking freely all day, and John had taken his brother to the station to see him start for home. A max named Iverson, who lived at Steiner s FJat, Northern California, shot and killed his wife and himself while in bed.

See moreSee less

"When found their babeH which was in ted with them, was covered with their blood. Hostilities have begun afresh between the Hatfield and McCoy factions in the Ken

Clipping to come

Wheeling Register · Wheeling, W. Va.

A detective interviewed at the McLure House describes the long-running Hatfield-McCoy feud in Logan County, explaining that the Hatfields live on one side of Tug Fork and the McCoys on the other. He notes the isolated, lawless nature of the region and predicts the feud will continue until one side is wiped out.

Wheeling Register · 21 January 1888 · page 4

The Feud Continued

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Wichita Eagle · Wichita, Kan.

A dispatch from Parkersburg, W. Va. describes a new 'outbreak' in which the Hatfield gang allegedly killed Simon McCoy's wife and son by firing squad and then burned McCoy alive in his house. The report admits some details, like two children also burned, are unconfirmed.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 2 days later. CorrectionThis set right an article from the day before.

Wrong

Wichita Eagle · 22 January 1888 · page 1

THE M'COY-HATFIELD FEUD

Transcript to come.

No clean clipping could be cut from this page

St. Paul Daily Globe · Saint Paul, Minn.

A dispatch from Catlettsburg, Ky. reports several unrelated murders occurring near the site of the Hatfield-McCoy feud, including an ax attack, a shooting, and a fatal knife fight. It also notes that a citizens' committee claims to have located the Hatfields' hideout and is pursuing them.

St. Paul Daily Globe · 22 January 1888 · page 6

The trouble nil began over two long-cosed, 1 razor-backed, olm-peelor hoe. Bondolph MoCoy, known nsOleRand'F. ia tho head of tie McCoy taction, nod Anderson Hatfield, com monly called Bad Anse, Is the head of the Hot fields. McCoy lived on the Blackberry Branch . of Pond Creek. In Plko county, and Anae on tho Logan county side of Tug IUvor. Bothmon had aiiumborof brothers, andevery one ot each family hnd just as many children as tho laws of nature would permit One of Ansa's brothers. Floyd by name, livod in Kentucky near Randolph McCoy. The McCoy boys say thnt Floyd Hatfield "took up" two hoes that belonged to their fathor, Ban-, dolph McCoy. The Hatflelds say that old Bandolph took up two belonging to Floyd

Clipping to come

The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · Wheeling, W. Va.

The report claims the McCoys, not the Hatfields, are the true aggressors in the ongoing feud, describing a vengeful posse that killed James Vance, an elderly Hatfield relative, and robbed his home. It also recounts lurid details of the posse's brutality and a threat by Randall McCoy to kill and eat part of Cap Hatfield.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day. CorrectionThis set right 12 earlier articles: National Republican (Washington City), 20 January 1888, National Republican (Washington City), 20 January 1888, The Palatka Daily News, 20 January 1888, The Morning News, 20 January 1888, The Hazel Green Herald, 20 January 1888, Shenandoah Herald, 20 January 1888, Alexandria Gazette, 20 January 1888, Richmond Dispatch, 20 January 1888, West Virginia Democrat, 20 January 1888, Der Deutsche Correspondent, 21 January 1888, The Ohio Democrat, 21 January 1888, Custer Chronicle, 21 January 1888.

Wrong

The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · 23 January 1888 · page 3

hoes, which were there present in court, tothSerod under a his beech tree near the house of the Justloe.' Randolph. McCoy could brine no witnesses, and, of course, lost his suit and was obllcod to pay cost?. Ho went home very much disgruntled, but did nothing worse than talk ing for a couplo of years. Ilowover. Randolph's talk eventually brought y on bloodshed.' Among the witnesses in the suit over tho hosa was old Bill Btayton. Bill ' was a brotherfOf Floyd Hatflcld'a wife. It hap- ' pencS one day that Floyd Hatfield, Deacon i Ellison Hatdold (Floyd's brother), youne Bill , Btayton.

See moreSee less

and .several other members of the ' Hatfield family were drawing n seine in Tug r Itlver for fish, 'when Randolph McCoy and two j cf his boys, qnmo alone Itnndolph cot to tnlklne nbout tho two hoes, and the ilnt- :. fields talked back, and in the end Ban. dolph said that old Bill Ktoyton had deliberj' atcly porjurcd himself at tho trial. At this i ll!l Stay ton. ., who won a boy of about 18 enrs, picked up a stone and threw It nt Bandolph with suehcopd aim that hi Itnookod tho u ld ruun down. Thi'teupon the McCoy boys ;umirtj on yourni Bill and would hoe mndo ' f tion work of him bad not Beacon EllUon Hat field interfered. Within six months young; Bill Staytonwas

Clipping to come

The Washington Critic · Washington, D.C.

A dispatch from Catlettsburg, KY reports that in a recent clash between the Hatfield gang in West Virginia and a party of pursuers, Bill Dempsey of the Hatfield gang was killed. It notes the gang is vowing vengeance and that the Governor has been telegraphed for aid.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

The Washington Critic · 24 January 1888 · page 1

The Hatfield-McCoy Feud.

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

Clipping to come

The Atlanta Constitution · Atlanta, Ga.

A dispatch from Charleston, W. Va. claims the Hatfields wiped out Randall McCoy's family by fire and gunfire, then days later slaughtered the family of his brother Simon McCoy, killing five more. The account describes Mrs. McCoy being tied to a tree and shot, and children burned alive.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out. CorrectionThis set right 2 earlier articles: Wichita Eagle, 22 January 1888, The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer, 23 January 1888.

The Atlanta Constitution · 24 January 1888 · page 12

The Feud Between the Hatfields and McCoys

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Alexandria Gazette · Alexandria, D.C.

A dispatch from Catlettsburg, Kentucky reports a violent confrontation between a 40-man posse and the Hatfield gang near Tug River, in which Bud McCoy was shot and wounded and Will Dempsey of the Hatfield gang was mortally wounded and then executed despite pleading for mercy. The Hatfields fled, and the posse, now joined by the Peter Creek Guards, continues pursuing them amid reports they were planning further raids.

Alexandria Gazette · 24 January 1888 · page 2

Virginia, still rages. Twelve men have been killed during its continuance. The trouble began five years ago, when one of the McCoy girls eloped with one of the Hatfield boys. Wheat growers who sold their prod duct early at 05 cents, instead of wait ing for the dollar, almost wish that the chinch bugs hud taken it. If people could see ahead as easily as rear ward, they might be happy— and again, they might not. The Cobden ciuo is one of the stale bugaboos of political campaigns. Tiie Chicago Tribune has the good sense to say that it has never spent a cent in this country, it is a begging institu tion, and it lis an insult to the intelli

Clipping to come

Alexandria Gazette · Alexandria, D.C.

A posse pursuing the Hatfields wounds and then executes a dying Will Dempsey despite his pleas for mercy, prompting one member to quit in disgust. The Hatfields are reportedly massing to raid Peter Creek and threaten to burn Pikeville and free jailed comrades, prompting county officials to seek state arms.

Alexandria Gazette · 24 January 1888 · page 2

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

In the story →

Richmond Dispatch · Richmond, Va.

A Richmond Dispatch correspondent reports details gathered from Buchanan County residents about the Hatfield raid on the McCoy home, describing the house being set afire, the killing of a McCoy son and his mother, and Captain Hatfield's execution of a McCoy daughter after a confrontation. The account also describes Hatfield rescuing two children from the burning house and a subsequent battle when McCoy neighbors pursued the attackers.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

Richmond Dispatch · 24 January 1888 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image

A TERRIBLE FEUD

ADDITIONAL PARTICULARS OF THE HATFIELD-McCOY AFFAIR.

See moreSee less

What a Dispatch Correspondent Learned—The Dead-Letter Crowd—Murder Trial

[Correspondence of the Richmond Dispatch.] LEBANON, VA., January 20, 1888.

I am just from the county of Buchanan and have seen and talked to a number of people who live near the place where the row between the Hatfields and McCoys took place, and the facts about the row are as follows: Hatfield, with his crowd went over to McCoy's, and they got all around the house and then set the house on fire and begun to halloo fire. When the McCoys waked up the house was in flames. Old man McCoy told his son that it was the Hatfields and advised him to run out of the front door and get behind the crib. The old man said he would go out at the back door and go to the stable and fire on the Hatfields from both points; that perhaps they might run them from the house. The old man made his escape, but the young man was shot and killed, and as the boy fell Mrs. McCoy attempted to make her escape and was shot. Captain Hatfield just at this time saw the old man running from the back of the house, and started through the house after him. When he entered the door Miss McCoy threw her arms around his neck and began to beg him not to shoot her father, and Hatfield said to her, "Do you know me?" and she said, "I do." He said to her, "What's my name?" and she said, "Captain Hatfield." He replied: "D—n you; you will never know any one else. He then put his pistol against her breast and shot her dead on the spot. There were two little children in the house, and Captain Hatfield took both of them in his arms and then took some covers off the bed and carried the children to a barn near by and put them in it and covered them up with the covers he got from the house. The children were the next day found, and had not been hurt. Mr. McCoy got a crowd of his neighbors and went after the Hatfield crowd. They caught them in a strip of woods near Yance Hatfield's house, where a regular battle took place. Three of Hatfield's crowd were killed—one of the Hatfields, a man named Vance, and one named Chambers. The civil officers caught two of the Hatfield crowd—Captain Hatfield and Thomas Chambers. Captain Hatfield had his hand shot off. Chambers and Hatfield are now in jail in Pike county, Ky., and it is rumored that the Hatfield gang will go down and take them out before the trial. He has a band of 151 men.

Near the Kentucky line, in Buchanan county, Va., a lot of outlaws have banded themselves together in the last week, and are now going around at night making men do whatever they want them to do by telling them if they refuse they will kill them. A few nights ago they went to a man's house by the name of Roy and carried with them a large bundle of withes. The crowd called Roy to the door and told him that Captain Hatfield expected to have come there that night and kill him and his family, but that they got him to let them come and get him to leave the county. And they told him they would give him thirty days to leave the county, and if he was not gone in that time they would kill him, if Captain Hatfield did not kill him sooner. This band goes by the name of the "Dead-Letter Crowd." It has just been organized, and has done nothing but make threats so far.

The trial of Mark Blankingship for the murder of his wife will begin this morning at Grundy, Va. His wife was sick in bed and he would not make her a fire or give her anything to eat. Dox.

See the clipping

Richmond Dispatch · Richmond, Va.

A correspondent describes the shooting of a young man and Mrs. McCoy, and Captain Hatfield's killing of McCoy's daughter after a tense exchange of words, followed by a retaliatory battle in the woods. It also reports vigilante threats spreading nearby and notes Hatfield and an accomplice are jailed awaiting trial.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

Richmond Dispatch · 24 January 1888 · page 4

HATFIELD-McCOY AFFAIR.

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

Clipping to come

Waterbury Evening Democrat · Waterbury, Conn.

A twenty-strong armed posse from Pike County, joined by Peter Creek guards, pursued the Hatfield faction and exchanged gunfire near Capt. Hatfield's house, wounding Bud McCoy and Will Dempsey. The report describes widespread panic, a guarded jail holding eleven captured Hatfield men, and ongoing pursuit of the Hatfields.

Waterbury Evening Democrat · 25 January 1888 · page 1

CITIZENS TAKE A HAND.

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

Clipping to come

National Republican (Washington City) · D.C.

A report says a 20-man posse pursuing the Hatfields from Pikeville was ambushed near Tug River, wounding Hud McCoy and fatally shooting Will Dempsey, who was then shot again at close range despite pleading for mercy. The dispatch claims the Hatfields are now planning a retaliatory raid to burn Pikeville and free jailed comrades.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

National Republican (Washington City) · 25 January 1888 · page 1

WAR OF EXTERMINATION

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

Clipping to come

The Indianapolis Journal · Indianapolis, Ind.

A dispatch from Catlettsburg, Ky. describes a clash between a Pikeville posse and the Hatfield gang on Tug River, in which Bud McCoy was wounded and Will Dempsey of the Hatfield side was mortally shot. It further claims that despite Dempsey's pleas for mercy, a posse member executed him, and that the Hatfields were reportedly planning another raid on Peter Creek.

The Indianapolis Journal · 25 January 1888 · page 1

THE HATFIELDS AND M'COYS

yottnft relative.' Thoro was a (lent. In which tho I Deacon lost his knlfo, and was then not only cut to pieces by Talbot McCoy's knlfo, but was tbot In tho back by 1'nrmer McCoy, Talbot's brother. Talbot nnd Farmor wore arrested, to Stther with a 13-yoar-old.brother of theirs named ltandolph, Jr., who was falsely accused of stabbing tho Deacon durliiR tho fight. It was proved noxt day to tho satisfaction of ovon old Dad Anso Hatfield, the loadorpf the faction. , that the boy was not near the placo when tho Unlit occurred.

See moreSee less

, . m., However, thoPeaoon was taken across Tub River Into Wont Virginia, to the house of Au ilorson Ferrall. at the mouth ol 31 ato Creel., where ho was Kept because ho could not stanil It to be carried furthor. Tho throe McCoy boys wero kept at u house on Hlackuerry Creole that nlKlit. nud artor breakfast ou Tuesday morning Ihe oUlcoraMartod for tho county seat to lotliro them In jalL Dcfore they had cone two miles they were overtaken by old Had Anse Hntlleld ,ind n gang of men from .Yost Virginia, who

Clipping to come

The Indianapolis Journal · Indianapolis, Ind.

During a pursuit, posse members fatally shoot Will Dempsey of the Hatfield gang as he begs for mercy, while the Hatfields retreat and plan further raids. Pike County officials seek state arms to defend against threatened Hatfield attacks on Pikeville.

The Indianapolis Journal · 25 January 1888 · page 1

THE HATFIELDS AND M'COYS.

mit ot Deacon Ellison Hntlleld's wounds. Tho Doacon lingered ulong until Wednesday afternoon at 3 o'clock, when he died, after tell ing his brothers to alto tho McCoy bovs tho "hencllt of tho civil law." That waaVxaotly what the Hatllelds had dooldod not to do.

Clipping to come

Wichita Eagle · Wichita, Kan.

A report describes a skirmish between a 20-man McCoy posse and the Hatfield gang near Tug River, in which Bud McCoy was wounded and Will Dempsey of the Hatfield side was shot. The dispatch claims Dempsey, while dying and begging for mercy, was shot through the head by one of the posse who had earlier killed Jim Vance.

Wichita Eagle · 25 January 1888 · page 1

ANOTHER BATTLE BETWEEN THE HATFIELDS AND McCOYS.

One of tlie Hatfield Desperadoes Boasts of His Career of Crime. CHARLESTON, W. Va,, Nov. 19.—The 'confession of Kilison Hatfield, alias Mounts,, who was arrested three weeks ago, implicates Alex MeSBer as one of •the murderers of the three McCoy boys, ,fWho were shot to death In August, 1882. in the Breathitt county trouble in Ken tucky, several years ago, he killed five or six men, and claims to have killed twenty-seven men since the war. Th* Kentucky authorities offered a reward of t850 for his capture, which was ef fected a fews days ago.

See moreSee less

He is now in jail at Cattlettsbrirg, Ky. Messer is about 51 years of age, and has a wife flna six childroa. He was ouce a deputy sheriff of Perry county, Ky. He is the Beventh of the Hatnel^-McCoy murder ess 'who Jiave been arrested. i__ A. Youthful PoUoncr.J 1

Clipping to come

Wichita Eagle · Wichita, Kan.

A posse pursuing the Hatfields after their New Year's raid caught and fatally shot Will Dempsey, then one man executed him at close range despite his pleas. The Hatfields are reported organizing further raids and threatening to burn Pikeville and free jailed comrades, prompting county officials to seek arms for protection.

CorrectionThis set right an article from the day before.

Wichita Eagle · 25 January 1888 · page 1

HATFIELDS AND McCOYS.

Transcript to come.

No clean clipping could be cut from this page

St. Paul Daily Globe · Saint Paul, Minn.

A report from Catlettsburg, Ky., describes a violent clash between a Pikeville posse and the Hatfield gang near Tug River, in which Bud McCoy was wounded and Will Dempsey of the Hatfields was shot and later killed by a posse member despite pleading for mercy. The dispatch also notes the Hatfields were reportedly organizing a new raid on Peter Creek, Kentucky, prompting reinforcements to join the pursuing posse.

St. Paul Daily Globe · 25 January 1888 · page 6

A REIGN OF TERROR.

Darance Vile. Special Teieçrc.m to 11\e Stouter. Charlestos, December 8,—Giorge Mc Coy, one of the no'orions Hatfield-McCoy desperadoes, who was arrested a few days rince, was brought to this city to-day by W. L. Yanhoro, Chief of Police of Ironton, Ohio, and J. C. Beaty, Marshal of Hunt ington, and lodged in jail far said keeping until ths authorities of Logan county can be beard from. He was heau'y ironed and is a bard looking fellow. He talks freely about the Hatfield-McCoy vendetta, and from what be said to parties seems to be familiar with incidents connected with the killing of Yanee.

Clipping to come

Morning Appeal · Carson City, Nev.

A dispatch from Catlettsburg, Kentucky claims a 20-man posse clashed with the Hatfield gang near Captain Hatfield's house, wounding Bud McCoy and killing Will Dempsey. It further reports the pursuing force has grown to forty men, with Pike County in an uproar over Hatfield threats to burn Pikeville and free jailed comrades.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

Morning Appeal · 25 January 1888 · page 3

THE WAR OF EXTERMINATION BETWEEN THE McCOYS AND HATFIELDS

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Springfield Daily Republic · Springfield, Ohio

A Kentucky posse of forty men pursuing the Hatfields reports a violent clash in which Hatfield gunman shot McCoy posse member Dempsey, who was then brutally finished off by a vengeful posse member. The Hatfields are said to be organizing further raids, prompting county officials to seek arms from the Governor to protect Pikeville.

Springfield Daily Republic · 25 January 1888 · page 3

LIKE KILKENNY CATS - The War Between the Hatfields and the McCoys Still Goes On

Southern Democrats. Ho>\ Henry G. Davis is said to be a candidate fur United States Sena tor from this State. Hon. Henry <r. Davis recently confessed that he did little or nothing for the success of his party in the last election. Now who does he expect to elect him to this high office? Another member of the Hatfield McCoy gang has been arrested, say the newspapers. Judging from the number of arrests and deaths report ed of thene famous people, we should think the country were now depopu lated, even though every tree on ev ery mountain were a Hatfield or Mc

Clipping to come

The Daily Morning Astorian · Astoria, Oregon

A special dispatch reports that a pursuing party of twenty clashed with the Hatfield gang near Captain Hatfield's house, wounding Bud McCoy and killing Will Dempsey. The pursuing force has grown to forty men amid fears the Hatfields will burn Pikeville and free jailed comrades.

The Daily Morning Astorian · 25 January 1888 · page 3

STILL KILLING EACH OTHER

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

Clipping to come

The Abbeville Press and Banner · Abbeville, S.C.

The report recounts the origins of the Hatfield-McCoy feud, including the 1882 election-day killing of three McCoy brothers, then describes a recent nighttime raid in which Hatfield partisans burned Randall McCoy's house, killing his daughter Alafair and son Calvin and allegedly shooting his wife. It also notes rewards offered by Kentucky for the Hatfields' capture.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Abbeville Press and Banner · 25 January 1888 · page 2

A KENTUCKY FEUD.

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Abbeville Press and Banner · Abbeville, S.C.

The report describes the Hatfield gang's night attack on Randall McCoy's home, in which his daughter, son, and wife were shot and the house burned. Randall McCoy fought back, killing one attacker and wounding another before the gang fled, with large rewards now offered for their capture.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

The Abbeville Press and Banner · 25 January 1888 · page 2

A KENTUCKY FEUD.

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

Clipping to come

Fort Worth Daily Gazette · Fort Worth, Tex.

A Pikeville posse of twenty crossed Tug River to capture the Hatfields, exchanging gunfire that wounded Bud McCoy and fatally shot Will Dempsey of the Hatfield gang. Despite Dempsey begging for mercy, a posse member executed him, while the Hatfields fled and were reportedly organizing a retaliatory raid on Peter Creek.

Fort Worth Daily Gazette · 25 January 1888 · page 4

WAR OF EXTERMINATION

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Fort Worth Daily Gazette · Fort Worth, Tex.

A posse chasing the Hatfields shoots Will Dempsey, who is left mortally wounded and then executed by a posse member despite pleading for mercy. The report describes the Hatfields regrouping for another raid on Peter Creek, Kentucky, and local officials seeking state arms to defend Pikeville amid threats of arson and violence.

Fort Worth Daily Gazette · 25 January 1888 · page 4

ORGANIZING FOR A RAID

The Hatfields and McCoys. New York, Dec. 31.—A Charleston, W. Va., special says: Still another 'member of the great Hatfield gang of murderers, has been slain by detec tives, who are prowling night and day over mountains of the wilderness, on the borders of Kentucky and West Virginia. David Strattan and Ken tucky Bill, have been hunting down Tom Wallace upon a requisition from Governor Buckner, of Ken tucky. They found tnem at at the Flat Top Mountain on the day before Christmas. Wallace is a dan gerous man. When the detectives or dered him to halt he whipped out a big revolver and opened fire.

See moreSee less

His first bullet passed through a portion of Stratton’s coat. The detectives re turned the fire and Wallace fell dead; as the dying desperado breathed his last he confessed that he and Capt. Hatfield, were paid $5O each, by the deputy sheriff of Buch anan county, Va., and others for kill ing Jeff McCoy about two years ago. The murder money was placed in the hands of J“Devil Auce” Hatfield, the father of the captain, and was paid to them when the bloody work was com pleted.

Clipping to come

The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · Wheeling, W. Va.

The editorial discusses the escalating 'war of extermination' between the Hatfields and McCoys spanning West Virginia and Pike County, Kentucky, suggesting authorities should intervene if reports of brutality are true. It also notes that exaggerated reports of feuds in West Virginia counties are damaging the state's reputation and calls for investigation to clear its name.

The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · 25 January 1888 · page 1

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

Clipping to come

The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · Wheeling, W. Va.

A report describes an armed posse of twenty men pursuing the Hatfields near Tug River, resulting in a shootout where Bud McCoy was wounded and Will Dempsey of the Hatfield gang was shot in the stomach. After the Hatfields retreated, a posse member executed the dying Dempsey by shooting him in the head, prompting another posse member to quit in disgust; the Hatfields were reportedly then organizing a retaliatory raid on Peter Creek.

The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · 25 January 1888 · page 1

THE HATFIELD AND M'COY FEUD

Jeff McCoy was in West Virpinia. when he was seized near the month of Thaeker creek by Tom Wallace and Cap Hattield, who tied him to a stake and pre pared to kill him. McCoy's mother waded across the river and heaped on her knees for the life of her son. She was kicked and forced back to Kentucky. Meanwhile Jetf M rugged free from tho cords that bound him. and, baning into the river, swam for his life. Wallace and Hattield stood on tho Weft Virginia bank and kept up a lire on their victim.

See moreSee less

McCoy had reached tho f Lore and was struggling ui the high bank. His old mother fell on her Knees in a trans port of gratitude for the life of her son. The young fellow had just seized a com ftaik to help him in the last upward bound, vrheji a bullet went through iiis head aud he fell on a tree stump below, stone dead.

Clipping to come

The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · Wheeling, W. Va.

A wounded member of the Hatfield gang, Dempsey, is killed execution-style by a posse member even as he begs for mercy, causing another posse member to quit in disgust. The report also describes Hatfield plans to raid Peter Creek, burn Pikeville, and free jailed comrades, prompting county officials to seek state arms for protection.

The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · 25 January 1888 · page 1

THE HATFIELD AND M'COY FEUD

Transcript to come.

No clean clipping could be cut from this page

Wheeling Register · Wheeling, W. Va.

The column reports a fresh, especially bloody chapter of the Hatfield-McCoy conflict occurring in Logan County, West Virginia. It states one man was shot through the bowels and another had his head blown off by a shotgun, and sarcastically urges state authorities to end the violence.

Wheeling Register · 25 January 1888 · page 1

Transcript to come.

No clean clipping could be cut from this page

Wheeling Register · Wheeling, W. Va.

A Cincinnati dispatch reports a bloody encounter between a 20-man posse pursuing the Hatfields and a Hatfield squad near Tug River, leaving Bud McCoy wounded and Will Dempsey fatally shot after being captured. The posse, reinforced to forty men by the Peter Creek Guards, continues pursuit as the Hatfields reportedly plan further raids into Kentucky.

Wheeling Register · 25 January 1888 · page 1

WAR TO THE DEATH. THE TERRIBLE FEUD RAGING BETWEEN THE HATFIELDS AND McCOYS.

The Emperor of the vast empire of China, who is eighteen years old, Lns just had two wives nd a sort of assistant wife set apart for him by the Hen press dowager, who is bossine the affairs of the nation. "Tom" Wallace, one of the most desperate of the notorious "Hatfield gang" of West Virginia, has been killed by officers of the law while resistine arrest. Before dying, al lace confesseJ that he and Capt Hatfield had been paid 150 each by a deputy sherifl' of Buchanan coun ty, W. Va.( for killing Jeff McCoy

Clipping to come

Wheeling Register · Wheeling, W. Va.

After an exchange of gunfire, a posse captures and brutally kills the wounded Hatfield associate Dempsey despite his pleas for mercy. The report describes growing panic in Pike County as the Hatfields reportedly plan to burn Pikeville and free jailed comrades, prompting officials to seek state arms.

Wheeling Register · 25 January 1888 · page 1

THE HATFIELDS AND THE McCOYS

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Cheyenne Daily Leader · Cheyenne, Wyo.

A special dispatch from Catlettsburg, Ky. reports that a pursuing posse of Pike County men clashed with the Hatfield gang near Capt. Hatfield's house, wounding Bud McCoy and killing Will Dempsey. It claims the Hatfields have threatened to burn Pikeville and free jailed comrades, prompting heavy guarding of the jail.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

The Cheyenne Daily Leader · 25 January 1888 · page 1

Desperate Factions

The Detectives Trapped. Charleston, W. Va., January 15. —Word has reached here that “Bad Anse” and Capt. Hatfield, and a num ber of their friends who have become so notorious in the Hatfield-McCoy vendetta, laid a trap for the detectives who are after them, and last Friday captured Dan Cunningham, Evans and another detective, all of this city. The Hatfields procured a peace war rant and arrested the detectives and took them to Logan court house, where they are imprisoned, awaiting bonds for their release. They will be compelled to give bond to keep the peace.

Clipping to come

The Emporia Weekly News · Emporia, Kan.

The report claims the Hatfield gang raided Simon McCoy's home in Wyoming County, tying his wife to a tree and shooting her, killing her son, then burning the house with McCoy inside after he begged for his life. It notes unconfirmed rumors that two children also died, and says this McCoy family had no part in the feud.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day. CorrectionThis set right an article from the day before.

Wrong

The Emporia Weekly News · 26 January 1888 · page 1

MOST HORRIBLE OUTRAGES

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

Clipping to come

The Emporia Weekly News · Emporia, Kan.

A report describes an armed encounter between a Kentucky posse of twenty men and a squad of Hatfields near Tug River, resulting in Bud McCoy being wounded and Will Dempsey of the Hatfield side shot and then executed point-blank by a posse member. The account also notes the Hatfields were reportedly planning another raid on Peter Creek, prompting reinforcements to join the pursuit.

The Emporia Weekly News · 26 January 1888 · page 1

HATFIELD-McCOY FEUD

the Kentucky authorities by the IT. 8. Supremo Cairrt. hince then the State's Attoruoy of Pike county lias been unceasing in his efforts lu obtain sufficient evldenco against till* West Virginia gaug to convict Ultra. He (uumi it u difficult matter on account of the unwillingness of those In imwsiun of any knowledge to give testi mony. Recently, however, Klllson Hatfield llliiu .Mounts) consented to make a con feMioii, which he did in tlie presence of County Attorney J. !.ee Ferguson, the Jailor, and live others, one of whom was J.

See moreSee less

II. Vork, a lawyer, iiutllold volun tarily told his story after bolug told that ? confession would not In any manner lighten his sentence. His relation of the horrible acts, in which he was a princi pil actor, is of athrilliug character. The corresMudeut of the Iktkm<igknckk has lucceedod in obtaining a copv of it from Ihe County Attorney. Following aro theinain features of iiATmLti's co.vmastox: Ellison ltatlield in the piesenco of tho ?bore witnesses said, in substanco: I was present and participated in the murder of the three McCoy brothers, namely, lolbert McCoy, Farmer McCoy, ,. Randolph McCoy. It was on the tljlit of the t'th of August, 1882, at tho noulli Biuckberry creek, l'iko county, Ky. rile three brothers were taken fromalng school house in Logan county, "*>a., where they had boon guardui for a day and a night, and brought over tho Tut! nver, which separates West tioiinia from Kentucky. Thov were Bed arm in arm with a plow line and lod tiy one Charles Carpenter to the river tail placet]I in a small boat, accompanied

Clipping to come

The Emporia Weekly News · Emporia, Kan.

During a clash, Will Dempsey of the Hatfield gang was shot and mortally wounded, then executed despite pleading for mercy by a posse member who had also killed Jim Nance earlier. The Hatfields are reported regrouping for further raids on Peter Creek, prompting county officials to seek state arms to defend Pikeville.

CorrectionThis set right an article from the day before.

The Emporia Weekly News · 26 January 1888 · page 1

HATFIELD-McCOY FEUD

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

Clipping to come

In the story →

Barton County Democrat · Great Bend, Kan.

A report claims the Hatfield gang raided the home of Simon McCoy's family in Wyoming County, tied Mrs. McCoy to a tree and shot her along with her son, then burned the house with McCoy inside after he refused to flee. The report notes two children may also have died in the fire but this detail is unconfirmed.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

Barton County Democrat · 26 January 1888 · page 7 · transcribed from the page image

BRUTAL OUTRAGES. Another Shameful Chapter in the Hatfield-McCoy Troubles in West Virginia. An Inoffensive Woman Tied to a Tree and Riddled With Bullets—Her Husband Burned. Indiana Whitecaps Again Commit Outrages—Fatal Eviction Proceedings in California. PARKERSBURG, W. Va., Jan. 21.—Information reached here to-day of another outbreak in the Hatfield-McCoy troubles. Simon McCoy, a brother of the one whose family was murdered a few days ago, lives in Wyoming County. The Hatfield gang made a raid on his home and overpowered him and took Mrs. McCoy and her son, a mere boy, out to the woods.

See moreSee less

The woman was fastened to a tree by a member of tho party, the remainder staying at the McCoy house to prevent the escape of the others. After firing at their human target for a time the leader grew tired of mere sport, and gave the order for her to be killed. All the rifles were raised at once, and the poor woman's body was riddled with bullets. The boy who was taken out with her was also dispatched in a summary manner. By this time the other party had surrounded the McCoy house, having, in the meantime, placed various kinds of combustible material around it. It was concluded to fire the building and give McCoy a chance for his life, if he could run the gauntlet of their bullets. They expected he would leave the house as soon as it began to burn. In this they were disappointed. As soon as the flames shot up McCoy poked his head out of an upstairs window and begged for his life. He was answered with a volley of bullets and made no attempt to escape, but perished in the flames. The house was totally destroyed, and in the ruins was found his charred body. It is said two small children also were b[u]rned, but this is not confirmed. This family of the McCoys had no connection with the feud, and the attack upon them was unwarranted. The people are demanding that something be done by the Governor.

See the clipping

The Evening Bulletin · Maysville, Ky.

The report describes the feud between the Hatfield and McCoy factions in Pike County, Kentucky and Logan County, West Virginia, noting the remote, poorly connected location of the conflict. It details purchases of Winchester rifles and ammunition by both sides, plus officials seeking arms, suggesting imminent violence.

The Evening Bulletin · 26 January 1888 · page 1

PREPARING FOR BATTLE.

Talbert, Farley and Randolph. The Hattiolds captured them, led them to a tree and gave them time to say their prayers. Joho Hatfield then shot Far ley dead. Anse Hatfield killed Talbert, and Alexander Musser killed Randolph. All the others also emptied their weapons into the bodies of the victims. Then Wall Hatfield made all of the band swear to take the life of the first man who divulged the names of those who were along. Hatfield further said he and Tom Wallace killed Jeff McCoy, and gave the particulars of the brutal murder of Olifera and Alven McCoy in 1888. The Hatfield gang surrounded the house, fired it and shoe the girl while trying to extinguish the flames. Both Ellison and John Hatfield claimed to have shot Alven.

Clipping to come

The Kanabec County Times · Mora, MN · and 1 other paper

A news digest briefly reports that the Hatfield gang from Logan County attacked Sim McCoy's house in Pike County, Ky., tying his wife to a tree and shooting her along with her two eldest children, then burning McCoy and his two youngest children to death. This account, buried among unrelated domestic news items, garbles the victim's name and details of the New Year's Night Massacre.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Kanabec County Times · 26 January 1888 · page 2

Transcript to come.

No clean clipping could be cut from this page

Also printed in 1 paper
  • The Progress · White Earth, Minn. · 28 January 1888

The Beatrice Daily Express · Beatrice, Neb.

A report from Catlettsburg, Kentucky describes a violent encounter between a pursuing posse and the Hatfield gang near Tug River, claiming Bud McCoy was wounded and Will Dempsey of the Hatfields was shot and then executed while begging for his life. The account frames the feud as an ongoing 'war of extermination' between the two families.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

The Beatrice Daily Express · 26 January 1888 · page 1

WAR OF EXTERMINATION.

Deadly Feud. Viii:i:i.ixo, W. Va., April 10. Kllisnn Ifatlield, one of the jiarlicipaiits in the Mattield-McCoy feud now in jail ii) Ken tucky, has confessed to the fact of mur dering the three McCoy btothers.Talbert, j Farley and Randolph. Hat field secured them, tied them to a tree, gave them time to say prayers, and then shot them. Hatfield further said that he and Tom Wallace killed Jell' McCoy and (Hive the particulars of the nmnle'r of Alfra and Klven McCoy in 1888 bv the Hatfield ic K'tng.

Clipping to come

The Beatrice Daily Express · Beatrice, Neb.

A posse pursuing the Hatfields shot Will Dempsey through the bowels; despite his pleas for mercy, one of the posse executed him with a gunshot to the head, prompting another member to quit in disgust. The Hatfields are reportedly massing to attack Pikeville and free jailed comrades, prompting county officials to seek arms from the governor.

The Beatrice Daily Express · 26 January 1888 · page 1

WAR OF EXTERMINATION

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Independent Statesman · Concord, N.H.

A telegraphic dispatch claims Bud McCoy was badly wounded and Hatfield associate Will Dempsey shot through the chest, then finished off by a pursuer. It reports the Hatfields were allegedly organizing a raid on Peter Creek, Kentucky, while a 20-man posse called the Peter Creek Guards joined the chase.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

Independent Statesman · 26 January 1888 · page 8

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

Clipping to come

Richmond Dispatch · Richmond, Va.

A Charleston, W.Va. correspondent gives a defense of the Hatfields, saying they are wrongly portrayed as criminals, and traces the feud's renewal to an 1882 election-day killing of Ellison Hatfield by three McCoys, who were then killed by Hatfield relatives. It notes subsequent indictments in Pike County, Kentucky that were never pursued.

CorrectionThis set right 2 earlier articles: National Republican (Washington City), 25 January 1888, The Cheyenne Daily Leader, 25 January 1888.

Richmond Dispatch · 26 January 1888 · page 1

THE HATFIELDS AND McCOYS

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Richmond Dispatch · Richmond, Va.

The article recounts the 1882 killing of a Hatfield by McCoys and the retaliatory killing of the McCoys, followed by stalled indictments in Kentucky. It then describes how a lawyer named Cline revived old warrants for reward money, leading to renewed raids and the January 1 killing of Randall McCoy's son and daughter.

Richmond Dispatch · 26 January 1888 · page 1

MONEY REVIVES OLD GRUDGES.

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

Clipping to come

Richmond Dispatch · Richmond, Va.

The report claims bounty hunters working with Frank Phillips and Randall McCoy instigated violence to capture the Hatfields for reward money, and falsely blamed the Hatfields for burning McCoy's house and killing his children on January 1. It insists the Hatfields knew nothing of that attack, while also noting a telegram confirming continued conflict and a plea for state aid to Governor Wilson.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

Richmond Dispatch · 26 January 1888 · page 1

HOUSE BURNINGS AND KILLINGS

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

West Virginia Argus · Kingwood, W. Va.

A short news item reports that the ongoing feud between the Hatfield and McCoy families in Pike County, Kentucky, has resulted in the deaths of ten people. It appears as one item in a national roundup of miscellaneous news briefs.

West Virginia Argus · 26 January 1888 · page 1

GENERAL NEWS CONDENSED.

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

Clipping to come

Virginia Free Press · Charlestown, Va. W. Va.

A short digest item reports that another clash between the Hatfield and McCoy factions on the Kentucky-West Virginia border left five more McCoys dead. The note offers no further detail on when, where, or how the killings occurred.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

Virginia Free Press · 26 January 1888 · page 2

NEWSY NOTE

West Virginia and Kentucky. "About fifty feet from the river Carpenter tied them to a paw-paw bush and hung a lantern over their heads. Bad Anse Hatfield then said to them: 'Boys, if you have any peace to make with vour Maker you had better make it.' Talbot and Randolph began praying, but Farmer did not. However, before the boys had ima to finish tlipir nravors John Hatfield Bhot Farmer dead. Anse then gave the order to Are. and shot as he gave the word, killing Talbot and then emptying the contents of his revolver into the dead body. Alexander Masser fired

Clipping to come

Virginia Free Press · Charlestown, Va. W. Va.

This item is primarily about a political appointment of Marshall McDonald as Commissioner of Fish and Fisheries, with commentary on Senator Faulkner and Judge Hoge. It includes an aside comparing the bitter rivalry between Mahone and Riddleberger to the McCoy-Hatfield feud, suggesting the feud was already a well-known reference point for violent conflict.

Virginia Free Press · 26 January 1888 · page 2

part. Nine of tho Hatfield faction, on a Sunday night in January, 1SSS, crossed the river into Kentucky under the command of Jim Vance. "They surrounded the McCoy homestead, fired the house, and killed the girl as she stood in the door begging for her life. Cap and Jouce Hatfield both, asserted that they killed Calvin tion. McCoy, and bragged about it.

Clipping to come

Wheeling Register · Wheeling, W. Va.

A letter from Logan County, received by Senator J.B. Floyd from his brother who fought in the posse battle, corrects an earlier report that wrongly blamed the Hatfields for the fight. It clarifies that the McCoy gang was resisting arrest, and the conflict has escalated into open warfare, prompting a request for rifles and ammunition from the governor.

Wheeling Register · 26 January 1888 · page 1

BORDER VENDETTA. THE HATFIELD SIDE OF THE LOGAN COUNTY WAR.

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

Clipping to come

Wheeling Register · Wheeling, W. Va.

A letter from a posse member explains that the recent gunfight in Logan County was not the Hatfield gang fighting but a legally authorized posse attempting to arrest Kentucky men wanted for murdering James Vance. The account describes an ambush by about thirty armed men that left posse member William Dempsey dead and another wounded, prompting Governors of both states to communicate about preventing further cross-border conflict.

Wheeling Register · 26 January 1888 · page 1

INVADED WEST VIRGINIA SOIL

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

Clipping to come

Wheeling Register · Wheeling, W. Va.

A West Virginia letter-writer describes a fierce gun battle near Grapevine Creek between a Logan County posse and roughly thirty armed Kentuckians, claiming two men were killed and several horses shot. He pleads with the Governor to send Winchester rifles and reinforcements to stop the 'Kentucky desperadoes.'

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

Wheeling Register · 26 January 1888 · page 1

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Fisherman & Farmer · Edenton, N.C. · and 1 other paper

A one-line news digest entry notes the ongoing feud between the Hatfield and McCoy families of Pike County, Kentucky. It states that the feud has resulted in the murder of ten persons.

Fisherman & Farmer · 27 January 1888 · page 6

THE NEWS EPITOMIZED.

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

Clipping to come

Also printed in 1 paper
  • Narragansett Herald · Narragansett Pier, R.I. · 21 January 1888

Waterbury Evening Democrat · Waterbury, Conn.

Hon. John B. Floyd of Logan County says the conflict is between civil authorities and the murderers of Vance, for whom warrants have been issued, downplaying Hatfield involvement. He claims the McCoys are part of the gang of murderers, and the Governor has been asked for men or arms to bring the desperadoes to justice.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

Waterbury Evening Democrat · 27 January 1888 · page 1

Matsvtlle, Kr., July 14. Alexander Jlesser, one ot the Hatfield taction in the famous Hatfield-McCoy feud, is now in jail on a charge of murder. The crime which Cesser committed was due to a mistake made by mountain officers in arresting a boy of 13 for a deed done by a boy ot 9. The part which this boy Budd McCoy took in the feud has never been told in print. Budd McCoy was 9 years old at the time to which reference is made in this st6ry, and lis home was on the Blackberry branch of Pond creek, in Pike county, Ky.

See moreSee less

It ought to be said now that this is a trne story, for otherwise the reader might think that the writer, in an attempt to be sensational, had drawn the long bow. The McCoy family Was a large one. Budd had eight brothers and six sisters, all of whom were older than het some of them being married and having children quite as old as tneir Uncle Budd. Besides these brothers and sisters, Budd had so many cousins living in Pike county

Clipping to come

The Iola Register · Iola, Kansas

A dispatch from Parkersburg, WV claims the Hatfield gang raided the home of Simon McCoy, tied his wife to a tree and shot her, killed his young son, then burned McCoy alive in his house. The paper's own subhead flags the story as sounding doubtful.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out. CorrectionThis set right 2 earlier articles: The Emporia Weekly News, 26 January 1888, Barton County Democrat, 26 January 1888.

The Iola Register · 27 January 1888 · page 2

WORK OF RUFFIANS. A Story of West Virginia Diabolism That Sounds Doubtful.

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Semi-Weekly Interior Journal · Stanford, Ky.

The report notes that Kentucky Governor Buckner declined to send state troops into Pike County to suppress the ongoing Hatfield-McCoy feud. This brief mention appears amid a roundup of miscellaneous national news items.

Semi-Weekly Interior Journal · 27 January 1888 · page 2

the time it began, when his father sued one of the Hatfields lor the value of two long nosed hogs and got beaten. He had listened to his father and older brothers as they dis cussed the chances of meeting the Hatfields and shooting them and getting shot by them, and the one thing that worried him most was that his father said he was too young yet to learn to shoot, and so he must wait an awful time, it seemed to him two "whole years beiore he could hope to kill a Hatfield. However, lie got a chance at one ot tbem quicker than he anticipated, and the revenge taken for the blood that he helped to shed was horrifying.

Clipping to come

The Hazel Green Herald · Hazel Green, Ky.

A Pike County posse led by Deputy Sheriff Frank Phillips is reported hunting the Hatfield gang after the New Year's Day raid, with six Hatfield men already jailed and a count of three McCoys and four Hatfields killed, two wounded. The report also includes unrelated items on a severe Minnesota cold snap and a Kentucky farm shooting.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out. CorrectionThis set right an article from the day before.

The Hazel Green Herald · 27 January 1888 · page 1

A '. n t& e Mooitalne of Kentucky Case of Mistaken Weatlt from tie York Sun ' n . arreS t and murtsonment of Alexan a uAr one of tie Hatfield faction, not 4 ' r for a mu-der committed m the !CLg f the Hatfed-McCoy feud, recalls that the came which Messer com due t. a mistake made by arresting a boy of 13 ® oaE ' , doue b'a boy of 9. The part Irtltclfthis toy—Btdd McCoy—took in the i has never beet told in print. st id MeC .v wai 9 years old at the time ,o which reference is made in this story Ihis home "S'on the Blackberry branch , „ reek in Pike county, ken cf , P ° V oucifto tie said now that this is ,uk \'„ rv krotherwise the reader might V k that’the writer, in an attempt to be bad drawn the long bow &cO >v family "as a large one.

See moreSee less

BttiM , a eiUt brothers and six sisters, all f Wh m were older than he, some of Um bein' n Tried and having children lke n o ’d as their uncle Pudd. Besides T hr theis and sisters, Budd had so h Tv usins living in Pike county that he hint f r the life of him remember hall names, thong be generally siw them ii f,rm two to three tunes a year, when fl all went to tha outdoor church gs wnicli iu the mountains of Kentucky’and West Virginia are called line in West Virginia was aiarnt v that consisted of no end of broth er, atid’sisters, with cousins, “‘-o. just like t McCoV'. whoso name was Hatfield. Anders. l. Hatfield was the name of the father of this family, ami Randolph McCoy was the father CBud’.. Between the HcCovs id the Hatfields t tere was a he 'd V feud. As they say down there,the two far in - wenat war, and that means that whenever three or fur McCoys caught h Patfield eu‘ by himself, they would hide jiitue brush on the mountain side ami 6 boot him iu the back, while the Hatfields were jus: as mix; u - t > kill McCoys, and j u ,tas cowardlv m tlieir way of doi ig it. J In lSsf, the "year that Budd was 9 years old, hut one lima had been actually ktl-ed iu this w av. ilis name was Bill S ayton, ami he was one of the cousins of the Hat fields. lie ha 1 been waylaid by two of Rudd’s cousins ami shot to death because he hador.ee tin ow n a-tone at Bud l’s father ami knocked him down, and thus openly arrayed himseit with tiie Hatfields. Little Budil knew ail about t t.e feud from the time it began, when his lather sued one of the Hatfields f< r the value of two long nosed logs and got beaten. He ltd listened to Ins father and older brothers as they discussed the chances < f meeting the Hatfieldand shoo - ing p em and getting shot by them, ami the one thing that worried him most was that his (stiff sal-1 he was too young yet to learn to shoot, and so ho must watt an nwiul ti e, it seemed to him —two wtiole years— 'beforehe could hope to kill a Hatfield. How ever,Tie got a chance at one of them much quicker than he anticipated, and the revenge tasen for the blood tuat he helped to shed was horrifying. On use first Monday in August, 1882, there ;;sagi lieral election in Pike county, ami among other Candida es befoio the people was un elderly couia of budd, wh > wanted to be justice of the ] ea r e. Now it happened t at this man, who e name was Thomas Stafford, had married one of the liatli 1 i girls, and so was considered a member of that family, also. He was a discreet man, who had kept Iriendly with ho:;; families, and the consequence was that a t only Buuu’s fattier and ol letbrothers tamed oat on election day to help Mr. .-taf tefd get elected, but the Hatfields, who Bad m Wist Virginia, a-ul who could not, e£ course, vote i., Ko .lucky, also came ove ’.o tho polls to work for the same e id. Hitt e Budd and his in xt oilier brother, Jamtolph, Jr., a lad of 13, both went to the 'lection ground to play with tho other levs sure to be there. Up there in the m unrains the elections re in Id in tho open nir. This time tho pudgts of election had a table placed on the grass under a big beech tree over on idackterrv creek (no the branch Build iived wt). ad tile ballot box stood on the table Oi-lore them. With tuo tvvo families there si tires ed in obtaining a common end, what easier than for a discreet man like Stafford ‘•o got them together, to shake ha ils and become friends again. It was dote, hut unfortunately there was no law against so.ling whisky there then, and m Jlimr I*qce S of good feeling the Hatfields * 11 McCoys ail drank: heartily from the same jug of moonshine whisky. All whisky m had, at such gatherings, but moonshine ft Pie w, r t sort, anl to nuke matters sail worse, when the jug of c rn whisky "I 1 : empty a jug full of mountain-made ap plejack took its place. The mixture made ■to men ugly. After eni.fj'ins: the jug of applejack taibot McCoy, one of Budd’s grown-up orotaers, v.a anxious for more, hut hail no mony to buy u. Then he met one of the nathelds who 1 ad borrowed #1 To of him a "tile before. Talbot ;isked for the niey, anu the next thing anybody noticed K" tnu two men fighting. I<i.mediately intre was a rash made by the men about ■e pol.s, and the fighters were separated arrested by two constables, out ti.e light was destained to go on A JMb’yhaaniLa Hatfield, and all the ill seling that had existed between t,.e fatnil wHMal.aw U ?? onCon,, ' re > antl the truce r ,tnm &l n ffora \-, and brought no >ut uas to. - 5® n : Dca ?P' l Eilison Hatfield, a brother fac’d !n erbOI ‘ Hatfield, chief of the Hatfield Chun, was the one to pick up t Infight for oliicA a , J J T ac °n. i s l'ito of his church win t, . takoa to ° Hl <ich moonshine IWiL?', 1 - WaS - anli< 'us for a fight. Ha v ” f a S P UCKet knif ho operiedTtne Taibn. w d r. V,lttl ma °y ‘‘aril words called Onen f \’, lcCOya , OOWard fur Pt ching into ttore hi e ,r n if 1143 t of tho Hatfields The tW ii t-nM' 16 angrier he got, and sc, w!,’ ""t'l flaa'Jy the constable, c n L l ‘hng Talbot, saw that the deaCoßcludof!°t IgtU 5 Ut Talbot anyhow, and so tie t wo m tO - 8 ?* ° ;it o£ tha and let two men fight it out. Spranc lle was released, Talbot liiotii-m ,i r and two steps, ami with a quick blade TANARUS, '\ Docket knife and opened the jumo’-d for,' 111611 stooped a bit and Cts H e ?£ h oth6r witb murder . their “tout theri t the ,1 . 1 g ' f eager mountaineers Strove ayed t 0 and fro as each o e who was eVery move ,lm de. Talb >r, his knifi lnf L ? fl yo H nger aild quicker, drove a fatal >i e i deacon’.-, ieft side, missing knife stn cb' 1 00 y . because the point of the deacon’s knibY nud b'lat.ced off. The “lashtn * th rr ? i esc ? u<3ed ®" Talbot’s head, tlcar ”c S ro a nd. tb ® * ! 'lack hat and thi sea 1 f 5 tu p of his head, laying , pen Affc r kul ‘ *• over fivoiuch4 tn with ~ k ",, "° separated and tlieu closed Orerv Mit ** •* uttered a word 611^lld o cf ' f the - D ® acotl ’ s kmf.; closed that he iiad t, 11 !? U hu } f wa >’ a cru.-,s, so Taibot pl= e ,j i,is dr .°P lh ® weapon, w hile ‘ad whh Tubing the deacon again Hwado rt ßl “!i v 0t au Italian Dlc, rtaliy wonnitui th ° decOU - alt hough on Ti e ' was n m an of great yonder on„ P ,! UCi iand cloS6d hi on Ms tun. Therenf/ eUt I lUie,l ding to throw for Taibot ? I ,’ he had the advantage, *el!. Could no longer use his knife so Z n r Btr ? g K led from side to f n =Sand a"mr S e . US H°“ O part of t!,e Julies 1.-an “ ‘' er * v t! 0 men of both * pistol, th're r aw thelr " capons—here '* > f .11 erowT, , k fe ‘ . h< f Uo czed in between f “SO-ly forward 1 * 51 '’ 'VV'-‘‘ is head stretched 2*t/*id r; at fhtK every move ?P®a pocketkiiifn lV } cCo y. with an Und. AftolP, clutched in his right an iSsiant K Jp ? d 111 lroilt of hllf i. taut Le had reached out and plunged his knife repeatedly into the legs of Deacon Hatfield. Two of the blows jrere below the knee, but one was iu the hip, and it was a deep cut for so small a hand to make. Again the men struggled away, and again they got back before the boy, who plied his knife as before. This time be was seen by one of the Hatfields, who called a neigh bor’s attention to the act. But before they could do anything toward seeing fair play the Deacon,by a last desperate effort, threw T albot McCoy to the ground, and, picking up a stone, raised it aloft to crush the skull of his enemy. Among tne spectators was Farmer McCoy, another brother of Talbot. He had drawn his pistol, as he said, to see fair play. Now he could stand the sight no longer, and shut ih • Deacon in the back. Tuat ended the figlit. The deacon fell to the ground dying, while Farmer McCoy fled up the road with a lot if bullets from a Hatfield pistol flying past him, while young Budd threw his knife into the creek and slipped away unseen. lit the same mome it Randolph McCoy, Jr., the boy of 13, came running up from a spring some hundred yards below, where he had ben playing with a companion. He bad heard the shooting and arrived just in time to see his brother, Farmer, arrested and brought back, and Talbot also arrested. Then the Hatfield who had seen Budd stab bing the deacon’s legs pointed out Randolph to the officers and accused him of tho crime of which little Budd was really guilty. It was an awful mistake, but a natural one. Peop e could not be expected to distinguish between two small brothers in a family of fif teen. Young Randolph, made wild by an intui tion of his coming fate, an intuition that did not yet oppr s his older brothers, pro tested his innocence, but Ins eagerness and fear only convinced the officers that he was guilty. The officers kept the three prisoners m a house near by over night and next morning started for Pikeville to put them in jail to await trial. • utthey ever got there. Old Anderson Hatfield, Deacon Ellison’s brother —Bad Anse, he was and still is called—with a great mob of i elativvs and friends, took the p. isouers from the officers and carried them over Fog river to West Vir ginia, and put them in a school h'use, there to await the result of the deacon’s wounds. Tho deacon had been carried over the river also, and lay in the home of Anderson Ferr Id, at the mouth of Mute creek. The school house where the prisoners were kept was half a mile away. The surgeon who was summoned found twenty-seven wounds in the deacons’ - ody, one of which split his left lung half in two, and several others were as deadly, but still the wounded man did not die until Wednesday afternoon at 3 o’clock. Me mtime the prisoners were kept lying on the school house floor, bound with a rope so secut el v that their arms swelled to double size, and it was impossible for hern to rest nr sleep. Hatfields,, armed with all sorts of weapon--, stood guard and discussed with each other the parts of be bodies of the prisoners that would be most painful when “shot full of lead.” The mother of the p isoners and Talbot’s wife, with a baby 4 months old iii her arms, came to see them. There were tears and pleadings, such ns might have melted the he rt of anyone but a savage. But they were vain. The women were even brutally taunted with the fate these boys were to suffer. At last the hour arrived when the deacon ceased to i reatbe. A messenger on a mule rode madly up to the school house with the news, and then wit i cries like wild beasts many of tho younger Hatfields ran around tiie school bouse peering through the cracks in the hope of getting,a ybpt at the priso ners without endangering their own friends. But ValoigiJip Hatfield, another brother of t e and ,-aco 1 and a justice of tho peace wit ml, stopped that by telling them to wait till i igiit auu then they could have their revenge. Worn out by their long sufferings, the prisoners hr-ike down and wept, hut Talbot, who was, after all, a manly sort of a fellow for a mountaineer, soon recovered his com posure. Turning to old Bad Anse and to Valentine Hatfield, he said: “treutlemen, when you shoot me I want you to look me iu the face.” Then he pleaded for the lad. Randolph. It appears that at this time both Bad Anse anil his brother Valentine bad Been convinced that they had go. the wrong oneof the two little boys, and had determined to spare Ran dolph’s life, but to teach him a lesson they meant to make him Vdthess the death of his oilier brothers. As nig. t came on tho pd.o tiers were taken out of the -chool and sh iven down the road toward Tug river, the dividing line between Kentucky and West. Virginia. As they reached ilia river, Farmer McCoy, over c me by fear, fainted find fell on the sand,

Clipping to come

The Red Cloud Chief · Red Cloud, Neb.

A McCoy-led posse of twenty crossed the Tug River toward Captain Hatfield's home but was ambushed by eight Hatfield men, wounding Bud McCoy and leading to a shootout in which a Hatfield man named Dempsey was shot through the bowels. The Hatfields fled, abandoning gear, while the posse grew to forty with reinforcements and pursued them, and county officials sought state arms to protect against further raids.

CorrectionThis set right 3 earlier articles: The Beatrice Daily Express, 26 January 1888, Independent Statesman, 26 January 1888, Wheeling Register, 26 January 1888.

The Red Cloud Chief · 27 January 1888 · page 4

THE HATFIELD-M'COY FEUD. More Atrocious Murder Committed. The Last Raids.

it began, when his lather sued one of the Hatfields f< r the value of two long nosed logs and got beaten. He ltd listened to Ins father and older brothers as they discussed the chances < f meeting the Hatfieldand shoo - ing p em and getting shot by them, ami the one thing that worried him most was that his (stiff sal-1 he was too young yet to learn to shoot, and so ho must watt an nwiul ti e, it seemed to him —two wtiole years— 'beforehe could hope to kill a Hatfield.

Clipping to come

The Evening Telegram · Camden, N.J.

A dispatch from Charleston, West Virginia reports that Governor Wilson has been petitioned for state military aid to suppress the ongoing McCoy-Hatfield feud. The brief notice provides no further details on the request or the violence prompting it.

The Evening Telegram · 27 January 1888 · page 1

State Troops to Suppress a Feud

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Cambria Freeman · Ebensburg, Pa.

A dispatch from Charleston claims the Hatfields attacked Randall McCoy's home, burning it and killing his wife, son, and daughter, while McCoy escaped. It further asserts that McCoys later ambushed Hatfields in West Virginia, killing three without loss, and that five McCoys died in a subsequent raid on Sim McCoy's house.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out. CorrectionThis set right an article from the day before.

The Cambria Freeman · 27 January 1888 · page 2

Five Persons Murdered.

Frank Philips, who made a noto rious reputation during the Hatfield McCoy troublo in Pike county, mur dered a young Virginia attorney in cold blood one day last week. The

Clipping to come

The Cambria Freeman · Ebensburg, Pa.

This report describes the McCoys organizing a posse that clashed with the Hatfields in West Virginia, claiming three Hatfields killed with no McCoy casualties. It also recounts the Hatfield raid on Sim McCoy's house, describing Mrs. McCoy's death by shooting, a son's death by gunfire, and McCoy with two children burned alive.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Cambria Freeman · 27 January 1888 · page 2

it-ic w:w .igaiost him and he was sen ”ced to the peniteatiary for life. Next v Messer. He confessed to ki!lmg -mg Kandolph McCoy, who was only J. -ties vears of age. asked the mercy of Ta^f Kice, »nd receivtd a lifetime sen . , mt^ntiary. < and Fliant Mahon are now on trial. tvid?c< > is against them and there is BOthisg short of a lifetime sentence in the ,-a -ranary tor them. The trial of Eli*1 !. the man who. with Captain John, . . ^d “Bid Anse’’ Hatfield, Jim Vance, Mitchell and Frank Ellis, ^ w year’s night, 1*88, it is charged HMteioated the McCoy family, began t> jjy He was brought into Court and too:e*-ed that he killed Altari McCoy, and a^sed for the mercy of the Court.

See moreSee less

The said tfc? law had to have its coarse. K*a Mahon is not able for trial as he has bt*n sick tor sick months. Everything is awt and a deep interest seems to be mani m getting the last of these t irrible tngediee. _

Clipping to come

Shenandoah Herald · Woodstock, Va.

A dispatch from Charleston, W. Va. claims the Hatfield gang raided the home of Sim McCoy, tying Mrs. Randall McCoy to a tree and shooting her along with her eldest son, then burning the house with McCoy and two younger children inside. The report describes this as following an earlier attack in which Randall McCoy's house was burned and family members killed.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

Shenandoah Herald · 27 January 1888 · page 1

Awful West Virginia Tragedy

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Shenandoah Herald · Woodstock, Va.

Reports from Catlettsburg and Cincinnati describe a wave of violence near the Hatfield-McCoy war zone, including several unrelated killings. A twenty-man posse pursuing the Hatfields was ambushed, wounding a McCoy, before returning fire and mortally wounding Will Dempsey of the Hatfield gang, who begged for mercy as the Hatfields fled.

Shenandoah Herald · 27 January 1888 · page 2

THE DARK AND BLOODY GROUND

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

Clipping to come

In the story →

The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · Wheeling, W. Va.

An editorial column pushes back against a Pittsburgh paper's portrayal of West Virginia as lawless, insisting the Hatfield-McCoy feud originated in Kentucky rather than West Virginia. It cites an unnamed Logan County source claiming Kentucky 'desperadoes' are the aggressors, while also calling for state authorities to investigate alleged outrages in Logan County.

The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · 27 January 1888 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

As APPEARS in another column of this morning's INTELLIGENCER, the Hatfield-McCoy feud is not a specimen of West Virginia lawlessness, but should properly be accredited to Kentucky. A very reliable gentleman, who was a citizen of Logan county, avers that Kentucky desperadoes are "the aggressors and barbarians," the sensational dispatches from unknown correspondents to the contrary notwithstanding.

See the clipping

The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · Wheeling, W. Va.

A West Virginia newspaper complains that out-of-state press dispatches, mostly originating from Kentucky towns, unfairly blame West Virginia for the Hatfield-McCoy violence and show ignorance of state geography. It insists the feud began in Kentucky and that most crimes occurred there, also relaying a fresh dispatch about dueling sheriffs' posses crossing the state line.

The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · 27 January 1888 · page 1

THE VENDETTA OF PIKE COUNTY, KY., AND LOGAN COUNTY, W. VA. The Affair Worked to Bring Discredit on This State. Gross Ignorance of the Newspapers of Other States Concerning the Geography of West Virginia and Kentucky, Causes Them to Attribute the Lawlessness to This State. Thus is West Virginia Getting a Bad Reputation Abroad. Histories of the Feud as Told on Both Sides of the Line.

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

Clipping to come

The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · Wheeling, W. Va.

A West Virginia newspaper disputes a Pittsburgh Times editorial that blamed the feud entirely on "West Virginia Barbarians," clarifying that the conflict originated from an election dispute in Pike County, Kentucky, and that most crimes occurred there. The piece reprints the Pittsburgh Times editorial in full, mocking its ignorance of state geography and its suggestion of lynching to redeem West Virginia's reputation.

The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · 27 January 1888 · page 1

A SILLY EDITORIAL

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

Clipping to come

South Branch Intelligencer · Romney, Va. W. Va.

A dispatch claims the Hatfields burned Randall McCoy's house, killing his wife, son, and daughter, while McCoy escaped to the woods. It further claims the McCoys later ambushed the Hatfields, killing three with no McCoy losses.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

South Branch Intelligencer · 27 January 1888 · page 3

The Hatfield—McCoy Feud

Transcript to come.

No clean clipping could be cut from this page

South Branch Intelligencer · Romney, Va. W. Va.

This report describes the Hatfields burning Randall McCoy's house and killing his wife, son, and daughter, with McCoy escaping to the woods, followed by a supposed pitched battle in which three Hatfields were killed. It also recounts the McCoy posse's killing of Jim Vance in apparent retaliation.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

South Branch Intelligencer · 27 January 1888 · page 3

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

Clipping to come

Ceredo Advance · Ceredo, W. Va.

A dispatch from Catlettsburg, Kentucky claims the McCoys invaded Hatfield territory and were attacked, after which they mortally wounded 'Will Dempsey,' who was later killed by a shot to the head. Local officials are reported traveling to Frankfort to request state intervention amid fears the Hatfields will burn Pikeville.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

Ceredo Advance · 27 January 1888 · page 2

HATFIELD VS. McCOY: THE WAR OF EXTERMINATION CONTINUES - AID INVOKED FROM THE STATE

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Citizen · Chicago, Ill.

A dispatch from Oceana, W. Va. claims the Hatfield gang attacked the house of 'Sim McCoy' in Pike County, Kentucky, tying his wife to a tree and shooting her to death, killing the two eldest children, and burning McCoy and the two youngest children to death. This account of the New Year's Night raid on the Randolph McCoy home contains significant errors in names and details of what happened.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Citizen · 28 January 1888 · page 3

Awful Work of the Hatfield Gang.

Blocdy Vendetta Revived. Jamboree, Pike Co., Ky., (Via Paw Paw, W. Va.,)—Oct. 4.—The old Hatfield-McCoy feud has broken out again and at least three more lives have been sacrificed in the bloody vendetta which has new lasted over seven years. The shooting occurred at a marriage, at the farm house of Peter McCoy. His daughter was to become the wife of John Hand, a rela tive of the Hatfield gang and mem bers of both factions had sworn to prevent the union. Hand had never been connected with the disputes of the factions and refused to recognize the leaders.

See moreSee less

Tuesday night, tne bridal party assembled in McCoy’s house, and just as young Hand and Miss McCoy stood before the minister, a volley was poured through a window, which killed both of them and fatally wounded the clergyman. Reports say that the farmers and mountaineers of the locality are hunt ing for the murderers, but no trace of them has been found.

Clipping to come

St. Landry Democrat · Opelousas, La.

A dispatch claims the Hatfield gang raided Simon McCoy's home, executed his wife and son in the woods, then burned McCoy alive in his house. The paper's own subheadline hints skepticism, comparing it to the fabrications of notorious hoaxer Joseph Mulhatton.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 3 days later. CorrectionThis set right an article from the day before.

Wrong

St. Landry Democrat · 28 January 1888 · page 1

WORK OF RUFFIANS. A Story of West Virginia Diabolism. Hint Sounds Mulhattanish.

SATURDAY, OCTOBER 5, lrtH9. Powdkri-y has gained another victory in St. Louis over the valiant Knights Pow who made charges against him. dtrly gains more victories than the Knights either in or out of the rank«. Thk Hatfield-McCoy feud has broken out again in the mountains of Kentucky.

Clipping to come

Macon Beacon · Macon, Miss.

A correspondent reports that both Pike County, Kentucky and Logan County, West Virginia factions are buying up Winchester rifles and ammunition, exhausting local hardware store supplies. Officials have gone to seek state arms, and the writer predicts open warfare is imminent.

Macon Beacon · 28 January 1888 · page 1

ARMING THEMSELVES.

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Macon Beacon · Macon, Miss.

A report describes an armed encounter between a twenty-man posse and the Hatfield gang near Tug River, in which Bud McCoy was wounded and Will Dempsey of the Hatfield side was shot through the bowels. The posse reportedly found the dying Dempsey begging for mercy as the Hatfields fled, abandoning blankets and coats.

CorrectionThis set right an article from the day before.

Macon Beacon · 28 January 1888 · page 1

WAR OF EXTERMINATION.

boundary line between West Virginia and Kentucky on theTug river has acquired a fearful notoriety as the home oJ desperate and shameless crime Murder Land is now the ordinary and appropriate designa tion of these horror haunted mountains where social condition of an evil state of human nature are at once the cause and the results of the crimes which have ren dered them accursed The killing of poor Julia Ann McCoy her young handsome John Hand and the minister that made them one Tuesday if true is but the logi cal sequal of a series of murders which have decimated the McCoy and Hatfield families So far the Hatfields have had the best of it It is not they but the McCoys who have mostly died in their boots Rosanna McCoy who was the daughter of Randolph chief of the McCoy clan lived with her father in Pike county Kentucky John Hatflelds domain was across tho state line in West Virginia His marriage I to Rosanna they call these little affairs marriages in West Virginia more resem I

Clipping to come

The Livingston Enterprise · Livingston, Mont.

A report describes an ongoing violent feud between the Hatfields and McCoys, noting a fight near Captain Hatfield's house where Bud McCoy was wounded and Will Dempsey killed. It also notes rising tension in Pike County as the Hatfields threaten to burn Pikeville and free jailed comrades.

The Livingston Enterprise · 28 January 1888 · page 2

War of Extermination.

A LOVE AFFAIR STARTS IT ALL ow They Pake All the WIve They Want f0W n sAn Interview i I To I Kentucky Some of the Kill Special t THE HERALD Examiner Dispatch OATLBTTsntwoKy Ky Oct GAside from the killing oc Herman McCoy in 1563 by Anse or as he is better known Devil Hatfleld tho breaking out of tho great mountain vendetta in 1SS2 can be directly traced t t love affair between John Hatfield and Rosanna McCoy Since that time the boundary line between West Virginia and Kentucky on theTug river has acquired a fearful notoriety as the home oJ desperate and shameless crime Murder Land is now the ordinary and appropriate designa tion of these horror haunted mountains where social condition of an evil state of human nature are at once the cause and the results of the crimes which have ren dered them accursed The killing of poor Julia Ann McCoy her young handsome John Hand and the minister that made them one Tuesday if true is but the logi cal sequal of a series of murders which have decimated the McCoy and Hatfield families So far the Hatfields have had the best of it It is not they but the McCoys who have mostly died in their boots Rosanna McCoy who was the daughter of Randolph chief of the McCoy clan lived with her father in Pike county Kentucky John Hatflelds domain was across tho state line in West Virginia His marriage I to Rosanna they call these little affairs marriages in West Virginia more resem I bled the rape of the Sabines In the ver nacular of the countyJohn took up with Rosanna who in 18b2 was a rosy faced girl of eighteen with regular features and straight lithe figure He had met her at un election gathering in Pike county whether she had ridden pillion fashion be hind one of her brothers The bold Hatfield became perfectly in fatuated with Miss McCoy and inflamed with liquor proposed tat she should elope I with him She objected He captured her b force and terrified her into compliance Towards the close of night he was seen by the McCoys crossing the river with Rosanna seated behind him on his strong black horse When John ran away with the pride of the McCoys he was already married but the Hatfields dont mind a little thing like that Justice of the Peace Valentine Hatfield when captured in 1SSS confessed t Attorney James Lee Fer guson of Pike county Kentucky that he had as many as five living wives and thirtythree living children The Hatfields have pecnliar ideas of polygamy They do iKiot marry their wives according to law 1ut > they take them and apportion their time between them Just like any Mormon elder or the grand Turk This is just what John did He took Rossaua home with I him presented her to his first wife and forced her to recognize this new leader as head of the house Rosanua remained in bondage till the end of the year when frightened by the threats of her family she returned to her own home John let her go but he did not for go the romantic luxury of visits to the Mc Coy homestead In one of the trips he was captured and led out as Rosanna believed t his death He was taken at 1 oclock in the morning After this arrest she crawled out of her bed unfastened a horse from her fathers stable and started off in the blackest of black nights t warn the Hatlields Old Anse immediately turned out his crowd They crossed the river and three of th m came up in time to beat off a party of nine wno were taking Jone t jail Tho Hatfields covered the McCoy3 with Winchesters and John was given up Apse was in favor of killing the McCoys then and there but was dissuaded by peace maker Elias Hatfield This quarrel led di rectly to the killing of Ellison Hatfield Ellison like Elias was arrested for beinga peacemaker He was a strong and square and resolute man always anxious to avoid a quarrel if he could He came to his death BJtause of his interference In a petty row between members of his family and one of the McCoys The ostensible cause of the 1 row was a quarrel over a ring Three of r Ellison and the McCoys closed upon Deacon Elson stabbed him with their knives He was cut in at least tventyfour different places and undoubtedly killed One ot these Me Covs was a mere boy of sixteen He did most of the cutting in the back The Hat iields led by a bad ugly coarse man im mediately retaliated They arrested the term Is not t be understood as used in any legal sense the three McCoys tied them t bushes and shot them to death Tablot Forge and Randolph McCoy jr thn net their fate Jeff m McCov next naid the penalty n w After killing a man named Woodford he paid CapHatfield a visit and shot one of his hired men in the hip It was no more than a flesh wound and no mountaineer lays up with anything short of a mortal wound Therefore the hired man did not design Jeffs death Wallace and Cap Hatfield f decided t arrest him and take him to k jail but when Jeff came to the river he attempted t escape and was shot at more than twenty times while crossing tho stream and finally killed by Cap Hat field just as he was escaping on the further bank bankhcre There now began a serie of raids be tween the states of Kentucky and West Virginia in which the McCoys were very active The respective governors of tho two states took u hand in the vendetta and only made matters worse The Hatfields exasperated by the state of war which reigned about their mountain lairs did not wait t be captured or killed but took time by the forelock planning and execut ing one of the most ghastly murders in history Ono night they surrounded the jJouse of Randolph McCoy where his f beautiful daughter had been stolen by John fired into the defenseless family A sharp II 5 Hatfield and who had ripened his violence by extraordinary love and devotion and volley was returned gjEIatfield seeing that they were likely to get a good as the could give set fire to the building and succeeded in driving the inmates mates out One of them was Miss Allaphan McCoy a young girl of sixteen As she stood pleading for mercy on the door step Ellison Mounts a low born son of the mur dered Ellison shot her dead Ah old lady was beaten about the head with a gun RO that her life was despaired of for several days and one of the sons of Calvin McCoy was killed The house was burned to the g jjund The Hatflelds concerned in this affair French Ellis Bob Hatfied Elliot Hatfield I were Cap Half d Tom Mitctell Charles Gillespie Ellis Mounts and Jim Vance This burning of the house and the atrocious murders in connection with it brought on another raid on the part of tho McCoys led by a man named Phillips who I Is said to have loved the beautiful Rosanna Phillips was an humble officer of the law 1 but was fired with the spirit of a fiend and his act was on a par with tha outlawry he was seeking to put down In this raid Jim Vance the leader of the house burning in jwhlch Anse Hatfield played so despicable a 4part was shot down by Phillips Vance I Vas I vindictive fighter and when Phillips aijind the trigger of his pistol trying with I even came up to the old fellow they found hinp with the right fore finger clasped itIsi last strength to shoot one more shot Phillips and his crowd after they had killed Vance like so many Indians robbed hIm of his personal effects A warrant was issued for Phillips and the sheriff summoned a posse of seven or oiht men to execute it Hut Phillips and his friends overpowered the posse and fatally tally wounded Bill Dempsay one of the number As Dempsey was expiring he begged that he might be left to die in peace but Phillips deliberately blew his brains out This was in lIST A dreadful pause of two years elapses Then comes the final chapterin this serial of blcod Already the triple murder of last Tuesday night has been fully tele

Clipping to come

The Ohio Democrat · Logan, Ohio

A dispatch from Charleston, W.Va. reports a nighttime raid by the Hatfield gang on the house of Sim McCoy, said to be Randall McCoy's brother, in which Mrs. Randall was tied to a tree and shot along with her eldest son, and the house burned with two younger children inside. This follows an earlier incident in which Randall's own house had reportedly been burned and family members killed.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 3 days later. CorrectionThis set right an article from the day before.

Wrong

The Ohio Democrat · 28 January 1888 · page 2

An Awful Deed

the blackest of black nights t warn the Hatlields Old Anse immediately turned out his crowd They crossed the river and three of th m came up in time to beat off a party of nine wno were taking Jone t jail Tho Hatfields covered the McCoy3 with Winchesters and John was given up Apse was in favor of killing the McCoys then and there but was dissuaded by peace maker Elias Hatfield This quarrel led di rectly to the killing of Ellison Hatfield Ellison like Elias was arrested for beinga

Clipping to come

Narragansett Herald · Narragansett Pier, R.I.

A Charleston dispatch reports that the Hatfield gang raided Sim McCoy's home, shooting his wife and eldest son and burning McCoy with two younger children alive in the house. The report claims the feud has reached its climax with the McCoy family virtually exterminated and no arrests made.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 3 days later.

Wrong

Narragansett Herald · 28 January 1888 · page 4

ALL DEAD BUT ONE.

The McCoy Hatfield savages on the Kentucky and West Virginia border, who have been waging a private war on the principle of alternate assassi nation, are again on the warpath. A rash relative of the Hatfields who proposed marriage with a McCoy was shot at the altar with his bride and the minister. One of the blood-thirsty ruffians belonging to the Hatfield

Clipping to come

Narragansett Herald · Narragansett Pier, R.I.

A lurid account claims Hatfield raiders bound McCoy's wife and eldest son to a tree and shot them, then burned the father and two youngest children alive in their home, wiping out the McCoy family. It also recaps the feud's origin, including the earlier killing of three McCoy brothers tied to a pawpaw bush after Ellison Hatfield's death.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

Narragansett Herald · 28 January 1888 · page 4

ALL DEAD BUT ONE.

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

Clipping to come

Martinsburg Herald · Martinsburg, W. Va.

Governor Buckner of Kentucky granted arms to the people of Pike County to defend themselves from an anticipated invasion by residents of Logan County, West Virginia. The conflict stemmed from the ongoing Hatfield-McCoy vendetta.

Martinsburg Herald · 28 January 1888 · page 2

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

Clipping to come

Martinsburg Herald · Martinsburg, W. Va.

A newspaper condemns the burning of Randall McCoy's house, the shooting of pinioned women, and the killing of family members as savage acts disgracing Kentucky and West Virginia. It also reports that a posse hunting the Hatfields killed James Vance, an elderly relative, allegedly without provocation, and robbed his home.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 2 days later.

Wrong

Martinsburg Herald · 28 January 1888 · page 2

THE DESPERADO AND THE TOUGH

Chicago Mail. 'Tu at unique Kentucky institution known as the Hatfield McCoy fued has broken out again, and under circumstances that indi cate a probability of its lasting until both families are utterly wiped out. According to the dispatches the little affair took place at Jamberre. a hamlet of Pike county. Ky. The daughter of Mr. Peter McCoy was

Clipping to come

Martinsburg Herald · Martinsburg, W. Va.

This editorial piece discusses the Hatfield-McCoy feud as an example of Kentucky's lawlessness, claiming new information suggests the McCoys were actually the aggressors who had spied on the Hatfields for months. It also describes a vengeance posse from Kentucky killing Hatfield relative James Vance and reports Randall McCoy's threat to kill and mutilate Cap Hatfield.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

Martinsburg Herald · 28 January 1888 · page 2

THE DESPERADO AND THE TOUGH

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

Clipping to come

St. Paul Daily Globe · Saint Paul, Minn.

This item is only a headline fragment within a multi-story roundup page, stating that citizens of Virginia want the Hatfield-McCoy vendetta stopped. No further details or body text about the feud appear in this extract; the surrounding content concerns an unrelated California murder confession.

St. Paul Daily Globe · 29 January 1888 · page 1

Citizens of Virginia Want the Hatfield-McCoy Vendetta Squelched

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

Clipping to come

St. Paul Daily Globe · Saint Paul, Minn.

Representatives from Logan County, West Virginia, met with Governor Wilson to request state assistance in suppressing the escalating Hatfield-McCoy feud. They described the conflict as originating after the Civil War, recently reignited, with the Pike County (McCoy) faction reportedly growing and threatening local citizens.

St. Paul Daily Globe · 29 January 1888 · page 1

ASKING STATE AID.

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

Clipping to come

Omaha Daily Bee · Omaha, Neb.

Messengers from Logan County, West Virginia asked Governor Wilson for state aid to suppress the Hatfield-McCoy feud, reporting that local civil officers could not control the armed parties. The governor was reportedly considering prompt measures to restore order after renewed killings on both sides.

Omaha Daily Bee · 29 January 1888 · page 2

TROOPS ASKED FOR

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

Clipping to come

Der Deutsche Correspondent · Baltimore, Md.

A German-language report from Charleston, W.Va. describes the ongoing vendetta between the McCoys of Pike County, Ky. and the Hatfields of Logan County, W.Va., noting it began shortly after the Civil War and has recently intensified with several deaths a month earlier. Logan County officials have appealed to Governor Wilson for militia assistance, as local authorities feel unable to control the violence.

CorrectionThis set right an article from 2 days earlier.

Der Deutsche Correspondent · 30 January 1888 · page 3

Die Hatfield-McCoy'sche Fehde.

and kihed in the continuance of the Hatfield-McCoy feud in West Virginia. Of these one was Miss Allaphare McCoy, shot pleading for mercy in her father’s doorway by Ellison Mounts. Another, the second woman killed, was Julia Ann McCoy, shot by her groom's side, together with the minis

Clipping to come

Daily Kennebec Journal · Augusta, Me.

Governor Wilson of West Virginia received word that Logan County mass meetings declared the Hatfield-McCoy feud too powerful for civil authorities to control, and called for troops from both Kentucky and West Virginia. He ordered militia to report and requested Kentucky's governor send soldiers as well, with local guard units also offering their services.

Daily Kennebec Journal · 31 January 1888 · page 1

KENTUCKY AND WEST VIRGINIA SEND TROOPS TO SUPPRESS THE HATFIELD-MCCOY VENDETTA

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

Clipping to come

The Portland Daily Press · Portland, Me.

A brief news item reports that militia forces have been ordered out to suppress the ongoing McCoy-Hatfield vendetta. No further details are given about the scale or location of deployment.

The Portland Daily Press · 31 January 1888 · page 1

GENERAL NEWS.

Hatfield-McCoy feud in West Virginia. Of these one was Miss Allaphare Mc Coy, shot pleading for mercy in her father's doorway by Ellison Mounts. Another, the sccond woman killed, was Julia Ann McCoy, shot by her groom's side, together with the minis ter in'fKe agt of uniting them.

Clipping to come

Omaha Daily Bee · Omaha, Neb.

West Virginia's Governor Wilson initially ordered militia to suppress the Hatfield-McCoy feud after confirming reports of trouble were not exaggerated. However, his representative returned from Logan county reporting both sides had disbanded, so the governor countermanded the militia order.

CorrectionThis set right 3 earlier articles: St. Landry Democrat, 28 January 1888, The Ohio Democrat, 28 January 1888, Narragansett Herald, 28 January 1888.

Omaha Daily Bee · 31 January 1888 · page 1

The Hatfield-McCoy Feud.

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Alexandria Gazette · Alexandria, D.C.

A short editorial item declares that the Hatfield and McCoy gangs of West Virginia and Kentucky have disbanded, quoting the phrase 'order reigns in Warsaw' to suggest peace has returned. The item treats the feud as a closed matter requiring no further comment.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

Alexandria Gazette · 31 January 1888 · page 2

EDITORIAL BRIEFS.

HaUield-McCoy feud in West Virginia. t)f these one was Miss Aliapha. e Mc Coy. shot, pleading for mercy in hoi father's doorway by Ellison Mounts. Another, Iho second woman killed, was Julia Ann McCoy, shot by he*

Clipping to come

Wheeling Register · Wheeling, W. Va.

A dispatch from Charleston, W. Va. reports that the Logan County War is said to have ended, with Governor Wilson rescinding an order sending militia to the border because their presence was deemed unnecessary. The article also disputes a rival newspaper's account, defending the Hatfields and correcting claims about the murdered Dempsey, who it says was a lawman, not a Hatfield gang member.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

Wheeling Register · 31 January 1888 · page 1

DISBANDED. The Logan County War Said to Be at an End. THE KENTUCKY GANG BREAKS UP, And it is Thought Peace Is Permanently Restored. TWO GOVERNORS' CORRESPONDENCE. The Report of Governor Wilson's Special Agent. ORDER FOR TROOPS RESCINDED. Their Presence on the Border Not Necessary—The Militia Respond Gallantly to the Call of the State—Romantic Story of the Trouble.

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Wheeling Register · Wheeling, W. Va.

Captain Mahon, sent by the Governor to investigate the border warfare, reports that the Phillips-McCoy gang has disbanded after killing an officer, and that the Hatfields have also disbanded and moved off. He conveys that law-abiding citizens of Logan County believe the Hatfields were wronged, while a letter from a prominent local man states that both sides have committed atrocious offenses.

Wheeling Register · 31 January 1888 · page 1

CAPTAIN MAHON'S REPORT

TWELVE persons have now been shot and killed in the continuance of the Hatfield-McCoy feud in West Virginia. Of these one was Miss Allaphare Mc­ Coy, shot pleading for mercy in her father's doorway by Ellison Mounts. Another, the second woman killed, was Julia Ann McCoy, shot by her

Clipping to come

Wheeling Register · Wheeling, W. Va.

West Virginia's Governor Wilson sends telegram thanks to Col. Fries and his troops for responding to the border crisis without violence, and explains his refusal of Kentucky's extradition requisition due to fears the accused would be killed if handed to Frank Phillips and the McCoys. The report also lists militia companies readied and dispatched to Charleston in response to the Governor's call.

Wheeling Register · 31 January 1888 · page 1

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come