As the Papers Told It

The Hatfields and the McCoys · The full archive

August 1887

2 articles

Daily Evening Bulletin · Maysville, Ky.

A jury in Portsmouth, Ohio found Alf McCoy not guilty of first-degree murder but guilty of second-degree murder in the killing of Dr. Northup at Haverhill, meaning life imprisonment. The jury had been deadlocked for over sixty hours before reaching the verdict, and some dissatisfaction with the outcome was reported.

Daily Evening Bulletin · 2 August 1887 · page 1

M'COY FOUND GUILTY OF MURDER.

Co., 109 and 111 South Illinois st. evr Fbeso of the Hatlleld-McCoy Troubles. Charleston, W. Va, Feb. 1. The civil authorities bar now taken bold of the rem

Clipping to come

The Stark County Democrat · Canton, Ohio

A jury in the Alf McCoy murder trial, after being locked up over sixty hours, returned a verdict of guilty of second-degree murder rather than first-degree, meaning life imprisonment. The report also recounts the May killing of Dr. Northup at Haverhill, allegedly carried out by Alfred McCoy, his brother James, and nephew Pierson over a quarrel about guinea fowls.

The Stark County Democrat · 4 August 1887 · page 1

M'COY FOUND GUILTY OF MURDER.

Co., 109 and 111 South Illinois st. evr Fbeso of the Hatlleld-McCoy Troubles. Charleston, W. Va, Feb. 1. The civil authorities bar now taken bold of the rem nants of the Hat field-McCoy feud, and upon a petition from William Floyd, a citizen of Logan eounty, this State, Gorernor Wilson to-day is sued a requisition upon Governor Buckner, of Kentucky, for the eafe delivery of Tom Cham bers, Andy Vadney. Selkirk McCoy, L. B. 3lc Coy, Moses Christian, David Mahon. D. D. Ma hon and Pliant Mahon, -who ara alleged to have been implicated in the recent troubles, and who are citizens of Logan eountr, now confined in the jail of Pike county, Kentucky, awaiting trial.

See moreSee less

The petition further states that the par ties above named, as he is informed and believes, were taiten from this State without any Jegal process whatever, and in violation of the laws of the State. Col. W. LMahan. of this city, who aoted as Governor Wilson's agent in ascer taining the Etatns of the Hatfleld-McCoy ven detta, last week, will leave for Frankfort, Ky., with the requisition papers, to-morrow morning.

Clipping to come