As the Papers Told It

The Hatfields and the McCoys · The full archive

March 1885

2 articles

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

The dispatch reports that a 'Montable Hatfield' has been moved to Mount Sterling, Ky., to avoid lynching after being arrested for a Pike County feud killing. It recounts that after a Hatfield was slain by a McCoy in a drunken quarrel, Hatfield relatives seized the McCoy man and his three brothers, took them to West Virginia, and killed all four by shooting.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 1,038 days later.

Wrong

New-York Tribune · 7 March 1885 · page 1

CAPTURING A KENTUCKY DESPERADO.

STUDENTS IN A BIG ROW. PROFESSORS APPEAR BUT ARE PUT TO FLIGHT. A Proposition to Put One of Them in the Bowl Made by the Boys -Medical Students Vanquish Both of the War ring Factions and Carry Off Their Trophy. Philadelphia. Jan. 31. —The “bowl fight" at the University "f Pennsylvania came off to-do n t :ih=tanding that it had been prohioited be the faculty, -t proved to 1* very exciting and its results may prove serious. The “light ’ has here tofore been between the freshmen and sophomores, but to-day while the conten tion was in progress the eries, cheers and shouts of the contestants could be heard for blocks.

See moreSee less

Spectators soon began to crowd in and fully 500 persons wre looking on. professors pi t to flight. The faculty also heard the noise and many of them hurried lo the ground, show ing evident displeasure nt finding that the boys had been too sharp for them and hud eluded all their vigilance. Their threats and orders fell like drops of water on hot iron, and when a body of students moved toward a demonstrative “professor" with cries of “Put him in the bow]!” they with drew en masse and watchod the baltle from a safer distance. new warriors on the field. After the fight had been in progress for some time a large party of medical studen’s made their appearance, and the light u->k an unexpected and unprecedented t urn. The “metis” were fresh, and outnumbered the former combatants combined by two to one. They finally secured possession of the bowl and landed it safely in the cellar of the medical hall. The fight l>etwoeu the “sophs” anti freshmen waa declared a draw, but another controversy will no doubt grow out of the battle. The members of the faculty cannot avoid taking the matter np, and in view of the disregard of the pos itive prohibition their action will, it is ex pected. lie of a summary and emphatic character. CAUSE OF THE VENDETTA. Col. Mabone Submits his Report to Gov. Wilson. Charleston, W. Va., Jan. 31.—C01. W. li. Mahone, the emissary whom Gov. Wilson sent to Itogan county a week ago to inquire into and report, upon the now famous Hat fleld-McCoy vendetta, made his report to Gov. Wilson to-day and it is as fol lows: “1 visited all tho Hatfields and found fhom to be good law-abiding citizens, who have the respect and confidence of every one in the neighborhood. While many depredations have boon committed, and the whole surrounding country has been in a state of excitement and tumult bordering on a genuine young war, [icace has again been restored, and the belligerent parties on both sides have disbanded, and no further trouble is anticipated. The st ranged part of the whole affair is that that Hat fields and McCoys are related. CAUSE OF THE OUTBREAK. “The recent outbreak seems to have been caused by parties in Pike county, Ken tucky, resurrecilng old indictments against the Hatfields, which were found against them five years ago. The Pike county par ties went to Frankfort, Ky., ami had rewards offered for the Hatfields and caiue into West Virginia, under tho guise of officers of the law, when in reality they had no requisition, and arrested (or rather kid nan id) Thomas Chambers, Andrew Var ney, Khelkirk McCoy, 1). I'. McCoy, Moses Christian, Pliant Mahon, D. I). Mahon and Valentine Hatfield and took them over to Kentucky and placed them in jail, where they are -fill confined. COLD-BLOODED MURDER. “This party, headed by Frank Phillips, fired on and killed old man \ anee, without as much as calling on him to surrender, and are the same parties who came over into this State and tired upon Constable Thomp son and hit posse, at which time Dolphy and another man were killed. Citizens <if I/igan county state that had nnv part ies other than those sent lieeu called upon to make the arrest no blood would have been shed, but the McCoys who came with Phillips to make the arrest, hail sworn to kill the Hatfields ami would have done so after they were disarmed, l't-a v has Ix-en temporarily declared, but it. is feared by the hnv-abi li.,g citizens of the two counties that hostilities will be renewed before a great while. Tho trouble began duriug the war. The Hatfields were in tee Confederate army and the McCoys in the Union army.”

Clipping to come

Der Westbote · Columbus, Ohio

The report describes a Hatfield being moved to Mt. Sterling, Kentucky to escape lynching after a notorious crime against the McCoys. It recounts how the Hatfields avenged a drunken stabbing by capturing four McCoy brothers, taking them across the river into West Virginia, tying them to trees, and shooting them in the back of the head.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 1,026 days later.

Wrong

Der Westbote · 19 March 1885 · page 1

CAUSE OF THE OUTBREAK. “The recent outbreak seems to have been caused by parties in Pike county, Ken tucky, resurrecilng old indictments against the Hatfields, which were found against them five years ago. The Pike county par ties went to Frankfort, Ky., ami had rewards offered for the Hatfields and caiue into West Virginia, under tho guise of officers of the law, when in reality they had no requisition, and arrested (or rather kid nan id) Thomas Chambers, Andrew Var ney, Khelkirk McCoy, 1). I'. McCoy, Moses Christian, Pliant Mahon, D. I). Mahon and Valentine Hatfield and took them over to Kentucky and placed them in jail, where they are -fill confined. COLD-BLOODED MURDER.

Clipping to come