Bloody Crimes Brought to an End by His Capture.
See moreSee less
A THRILLING ARREST
And Successful Because of the Bravery of DanCunningham
Who Afterward Escaped Killing at the Hands of the Famous "Doc" Hatfield by the Cool Bravery of Attorney General Rucker.
The blood blotted trail of "Johnse" Hatfield stops before prison bars.
Another of the desperate gang of murderers and outlaws that has infested the Kentucky border of the state has been coralled and is in the grip of the relentless, outraged law. In his human moments his eyes look out upon moving shapes of murdered men and murdered women, and murdered children. He sees a scaffold. In his human moments his ears ring with the groans of victims slaughtered, with curses and curiously uncouth prayers. He hears the swinging of the trap.
The facts leading up to the capture of this distinguished murderer are interesting. The story of his taking is thrilling. The characters in the episode are "Johnse" Hatfield, brother of the courtly criminal "Cap," and son of the paradoxical desperado "Devil Anso," his pal, "Awk" Damron—probably a contraction for awkward; Doc Ellis, a prominent timber man, worth about $15,000 with home at Gilbert, in Mingo county, and logging camp at the mouth of poplar branch just across the river in Kentucky; and lastly, though next to "Johnse," most interesting of the quartette, Deputy United States Marshal Dan W. Cunningham—that man of iron nerve and terror to evil-doers, who has been up against the Hatfield gang for many years and has brought a number of them to justice.
DAN SCENTS TROUBLE.
As may be readily supposed, Dan's name is on the Hatfield blacklist and he has been marked by the gang for slaughter. Dead men tell no tales. There is probably no man alive today who can give more valuable testimony against these picturesque pests in human form that this self made detective. Consequently when he received a letter from his friend Doc Ellis asking him to come to his camp at the mouth of Poplar creek, on urgent business, Dan's trained instinct scented trouble and his experience told him that the Hatfields were in it. But he took his life in his hands, as he has done so often in times past, and went. He was back in Charleston again last night carrying as trophies of his trip a 45-95 Winchester bullet, a 38 Smith & Wesson cartridge, a devilish-looking dirk, six-inches long and an inch wide, and a very bad headache. The three first articles he will present to the State Historical Society. The last he will keep—until he can get rid of it. It is a curiosity in the way of a headache, remarkable both for size and tenacity, but the society does not want it.
SWORN TO KILL HIM.
Cunningham had been up in Wyoming tracking a man wanted in Parkersburg for felony. He missed him there and came home. Here he heard that his man was in Mingo and Sunday he set out for that interesting little county. Not finding the game he was after he decided to go over to Ellis' camp, which decision he immediately acted upon. This was on Monday. There Doc Ellis told him that "Johnse" Hatfield had sworn to kill him and was preparing to follow up his unrighteous vow with immediate action. Now, how Doc Ellis came to be placed in this uncomfortable predicament the records do not show. It can not be said that the Hatfields had anything particular against Doc Ellis; it seems that he is one of a number of good citizens who do not love the gang, and they had it in for him, were going to give him a summer outing in eternity, as "Johnse" declared in other words. The citizens of Logan and Mingo counties, particular the latter, have grown terribly tired of these gangs of desperate men who roam the ranges attired principally in Winchesters, cartridges and dirks, and while they have nothing against the Hatfields or their friends who remain at home and attend to their business, or when they travel, go about as non combatants, the Mingolians have arrived at a sort of unwritten agreement that it is their opinion that the time has come when every Hatfield or member of the Hatfield gang or of any gang, going about the country armed to the teeth, must be dealt with according to the laws of civilized communities. So unanimous are the citizens on this point that the desire amounts to almost an organized effort.
At any rate, the name of Doc Ellis was on the fatal black list and he was feeling badly about it. He welcomed the detective with open arms, so to speak, and the two presently sat down to eat dinner. They had hardly begun their meal when they perceived steathily dodging in the woods on the other side of the river—Tug river—figures of armed men. Cunningham and Ellis had made up their minds to capture "Johnse" Hatfield or kill him. The time had come. This was their quarry. They slipped down to the river's edge and silently crossed over to the south end of Sand siding cut, where they took a position sheltered from observation. In a short time they saw "Johnse" put his Winchester to his shoulder and draw a dead aim on Ellis' shack on the other side of the river. He was waiting for Doc to come out. The other man, who was "Awk" Damron, was still down in the weeds. Ellis and Cunningham threw up their guns and covered the desperado, who had his Winchester trained on the headquarters of the Mingo man across the river. He turned his head for an instant and his murder-charged eyes looked down the barrels of two deadly rifles aimed at his head.
"DROP THAT GUN."
"Johnse" Hatfield is noted among other things, as a man of quick action. "Drop that gun and hold up your hands," shouted Cunningham. "Johnse" took another lightning glance at the rifles of his enemies and dropped his gun. He did not hesitate. Had he turned it an inch to the right he would have had two bullets in his head. Cunningham, Ellis covering "Johnse," walked over and standing on the desperado's rifle, proceeded to further disarm him by taking from his clothes a 38 Smith & Wesson and the six-inch dirk. He then handcuffed him and left him in charge of two men—Hopkins and Birchfield—who had just come up and he and Ellis followed "Awk" Damron, caught him, took from him a revolver and Winchester and brought him back to where they had left Hatfield. The latter's guards had taken him across the river and thither went Ellis and Cunningham with Damron. They kept him over night and next day, having nothing against him turned him loose and sent him home with his own and Hatfield's artillery. The dirk Cunningham bought from "Johnse," paying him a dollar for it; Ellis and Cunningham took their prisoner across the Kentucky mountains to the Pikeville jail, a long forty miles from camp. There they left him to face the thirty-nine Pike county indictments for murder pending against him.
SLAYER OF FIVE CHILDREN.
At the jail, who should visit the captured desperado, but Jim McCoy, brother of five children that "Johnse" Hatfield has helped to slaughter. It is characteristic of the situation, that McCoy went over and gravely shook hands with Hatfield, promising him the best treatment possible under the circumstances, and at the same time informing him that he proposed to prosecute him to the bitter end of the law.
It has even been characteristic, too, of the Hatfields, when caught, to confess, and the latest recruit for the gallows from their ranks was no exception to the rule. He confessed and asked for a life sentence. There is a possibility that he may get it, a probability that he may not.
The words "he confessed," to those unfamiliar with tragic incidents of the Hatfield-McCoy feud is a phrase ambiguous. Hatfield acknowledged his participation in at least two of the principal horrors of that deadly strife—that of 1882 and that of 1888.
HISTORY OF A FEUD.
In 1882, old man Randolph McCoy was engaged in a petty law suit with Bill Staten over a seventy-five cent shoat. Ellison Hatfield—or "Deacon", as he was known—he was a preacher before he became a corpse—was courting old man Staten's daughter and naturally sided with his prospective father-in-law. On election day in Pike county, as was their wont, the Hatfields crossed over the river and, at the behest of certain interested politicians as well as from a sheer desire for devilment, proceeded to terrorize the community and to run the election to suit themselves. The "Deacon" was at Black Fork Precinct with a squad of co-horts. "Devil Anse" was at Peter creek precinct, with another. Together, the Hatfields had twenty-nine men with them at these two precincts. Talbot McCoy approached the polls to vote. The "Deacon," the hog incident fresh in his mind, asked him how he was going to vote. "It's none of your business," said Talbot. "I'll make it my business," said the "Deacon." "I am hell on earth," declared Talbot. "So am I," asserted the "Deacon" emphatically, and the two men mixed. Knives were drawn and the battle was getting bloody, when "Farmer" McCoy, Talbot's brother, rushed up and shot the "Deacon." The two McCoys were arrested and several deputies started through to Pikeville with them. One of the "Deacon's" friends notified "Devil Anse," who with his posse headed off the deputies, took charge of the McCoys and brought them back to the scene of the fight, where they found little Randolph McCoy and the wounded "Deacon." They took the boy prisoner and carried all three of the McCoys over the river and held them in an old school house near what is now Matewan. A family of West Virginia McCoys, living on Mate creek, took the wounded man in. He died on the third evening after the fight. That same evening "Devil Anse" and fourteen other men took the three boys across the river into Kentucky and tied them to some pawpaw bushes, where a year before they had hanged three sheep killing dogs. They hung lanterns above the heads of the doomed McCoys and forming a squad fired below two of the lanterns. Forty five bullets entered the body of Talbot and forty-eight were pumped into the "Farmer." The little boy Randolph they had not fired at and started to leave him tied to the bushes. He was crying. "Dead men tell no tales," said Alex Messer, one of the gang, suggestively. "That's so," said Anse. Messer borrowed a shot gun, went back and fired both barrels at the boy's head, blowing the top of it completely off. Part of the skull as large as a man's hand was found seven feet away from where the poor little cold body lay, when discovered the next day.
TRAGEDY OF '88.
So much for the tragedy of '82. The tragedy of 1888, was, if possible, even more terrible. It was on New Year's night. A crowd of Hatfield's—nine in all—went over into Pike county to the house of old man Randolph McCoy, on Blackberry Fork of Pond Creek—a long house with doors at each end and windows. They surrounded the house, placing two men at each door. These men opened up a cross fire on the inmates. Old man McCoy ran up stairs. The women—his wife and daughter Alvira—climbed up on the head of the bedsteads. Tom Mitchell, one of Hatfield's crowd, began throwing lighted balls of cotton into the house which set it on fire. As he was doing this Randolph McCoy shot his hand off. He called Alvira to come up and put out the fire, which the two women had checked down stairs by putting milk on it. Alvira started up. She was shot in the breast and killed. Calvin McCoy, the old man's son, then started to make a break for the corn crib, intending to fire on the Hatfield gang while his father escaped from the building which by this time was in flames. He was shot through the head and died instantly. The old woman asked permission to bring her dead daughter out. She was caught, clubbed into insensibility and left for dead. Her own uncle, Jim Vance, did the deed.
The old man, roasted out from his garret, made a break for one of the doors, emptying a barrel of the shot into "Johnse" Hatfield's shoulder as he passed. He escaped.
"JOHNSE" GOES WEST.
"Johnse" Hatfield went west after this, but was rounded up at Seattle and driven from the country by Treeve Gibson, who had hunted him in the West Virginia hills. He came back to Mingo county and now figures before the public in an entirely new role—that of prisoner.
These are two of the crimes "Johnse" Hatfield confessed to participation in.
TRIES TO KILL DAN.
The murderer safely behind the bars, Deputy Cunningham started for Charleston, boarding the train yesterday morning at Sand Landing. When he got on he saw "Doc" Hatfield. With Doc were Bob Simpson and two other men. Half of this quartette was in the smoker and half in the other car. Attorney General E. P. Rucker was aboard the train also. Doc Hatfield saw Cunningham and went into the other car and spoke to Bob and his companion. They followed him into the rear car, and they crowded around Cunningham. Doc called Mr. Rucker aside and was talking to him. Suddenly he sprang up and said he was going to kill Cunningham. Rucker pulled him back but Doc reached over his shoulder and grabbed the detective by the collar. Conductor West and Brakeman Witt pulled him off. Ladies screamed and pandimonium reigned, but murder was averted. Doc and his companions got off at Thacker. They told Cunningham if he did not get off and be killed they would kill him in the train. The detective declined to get off, and the Hatfield crowd were hustled out. Cunningham came on to Charleston with his headache and souvenirs.
THE DETECTIVE'S RECORD.
Cunningham has made a record in the matter of arresting Hatfields. The first was Charles Gillespie, who confessed that he was in the gang that burned Ran. McCoy's house in 1888. He broke jail. He is now married and living in Virginia. There is a romance connected with this episode, but, as Kipling says, that is another story.
The detective's second victim was the younger Ellison Hatfield, whom he caught after a desperate struggle, on the head of Mate creek, in 1888. He confessed to participation in the crimes of '82 and '88, and was hanged. At the time he was caught, Ellison Hatfield, Tom Mitchell and Black Elliott Hatfield were going down to pay Frank Philips a polite call. The creek was swollen and they could not cross, so they put up at Josh Skeens, who is connected with the Counts of Jackson county—two sons of Richard Skeens, who went to Virginia from that county, were hanged in the Old Dominion the other day for killing a sheriff. Bill Napper and Treeve Gibson were with Cunningham on that occasion. Each picked out a man. Ellison fell to Cunningham, who, after a fight, handcuffed him to a Buckeye tree on the side of the creek. The other two got away. Frank Philips, whom the Hatfields were after, and who played an important part in the running of some of them to earth, was shot by his clerk twenty days ago and died Wednesday. Doc Hatfield attended him and amputated one of his legs. After he was buried, "Johnse" Hatfield and his friends crossed the river into Pike county, visited the grave at the mouth of Peter creek, fired a volly over it, preached the dead man's funeral and returned to West Virginia.
While returning from that trip, on which Ellison was captured, Cunningham ran across Aleck Messer, on Big Ugly, in Lincoln county—the man who shot little Ran's head off. He arrested him, took him to Pikeville, where he confessed and was sentenced to life imprisonment.