Three men—Henry Chambers, John Knott, and Rutherford—were reportedly killed at Matewan, West Virginia by Capt. Hatfield, of Hatfield-McCoy fame, after an existing feud was reignited by politics. A reward has been offered for Hatfield, who fled to parts unknown.
Potosi Journal · 4 November 1896 · page 3
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Las Vegas Daily Optic · Las Vegas, N.M.
A dispatch from Williamson, West Virginia reports that Captain Hatfield, of Hatfield-McCoy feud fame, killed Henderson Chambers and John and Elliot Rutherford at Matewan during a political quarrel. Hatfield escaped the scene, and some 200 men were said to be in pursuit of him.
Las Vegas Daily Optic · 4 November 1896 · page 1
Murder Over Politics.
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The San Francisco Call · San Francisco, Calif.
A wire dispatch from Louisville claims a Hatfield feud survivor, Captain Hatfield, killed three men—Henderson Chambers and John and Elliott Rutherford—in a political quarrel near Williamson, West Virginia. It states he escaped and that 200 men organized a manhunt, with little chance he would be taken alive.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
The San Francisco Call · 5 November 1896 · page 3
FATAL POLITICAL FIGHT.
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Record-Union · Sacramento, Calif.
A brief dispatch reports a fatal fight in West Virginia on election day, in which three men were killed before the trouble ended. The notorious Captain Hatfield is said to have taken part in the battle.
The Record-Union · 5 November 1896 · page 1
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Record-Union · Sacramento, Calif.
A dispatch from Louisville says a political quarrel in Williamson, W. Va., led 'Captain Hatfield' to kill three men, then flee into the hills. Posses of 200 men were reportedly searching for him, with doubts he'd be taken alive.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
The Record-Union · 5 November 1896 · page 1
THREE MEN KILLED.
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Evening Times · Washington, D.C.
A brief news item reports that Capt. Hatfield, leader of the Hatfield-McCoy feud, killed two men and wounded others at Matewan, West Virginia. The report notes he remains at large.
The Evening Times · 5 November 1896 · page 4
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.
A dispatch reports that John and Elliot Rutherford, the latter an election officer, were shot dead at Matewan by Captain Hatfield of Hatfield-McCoy fame, with political tensions reigniting the old feud. A large reward was offered for Hatfield, who fled into the mountains with a posse of ten men pursuing him.
New-York Tribune · 5 November 1896 · page 12
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Daily Kennebec Journal · Augusta, Me.
A brief wire report states that three men, including an election officer named H. Chambers and John and Elliot Rutherford, were shot dead at Matewon, W. Va., by 'Capt. Hatfield of Hatfield-McCoy fame' during a political dispute tied to the ongoing feud. The dispatch notes a large reward was offered for the fugitive Hatfield, who fled to the mountains.
Daily Kennebec Journal · 5 November 1896 · page 2
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Portland Daily Press · Portland, Me.
The report states that Captain Hatfield, of the famous Hatfield-McCoy feud, killed three men—an election officer and two others named Rutherford—at Mattewan, West Virginia, after an existing feud was inflamed by politics. A reward was offered for Hatfield, who had fled to the mountains.
The Portland Daily Press · 5 November 1896 · page 2
At a polling place in Matewan, Virginia, Cap Hatfield of Hatfield-McCoy feud fame shot and killed Rutherford and fatally wounded Henderson Chambers before fleeing to the hills with his young son, later shooting young Rutherford who pursued him. The report says old grievances—an affair with Rutherford's wife and a prior killing—fueled the deadly election-day clash.
The Sun · 5 November 1896 · page 9 · transcribed from the page image
Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.
KILLED THREE MORE MEN.
ELECTION DAY CRIMES OF THE FAMOUS CAPT. HATFIELD.
See moreSee less
Shot His Victims Down at a Virginia Polling Place—Then He Fled to the Hills with a Posse in Pursuit—Leader in the Once Notorious Hatfield-McCoy Feud.
WILLIAMSON, Va., Nov. 4.—Capt. Hatfield, the notorious outlaw of Hatfield-McCoy fame, killed three men at Matewan in a row at that place yesterday afternoon. Some years ago Hatfield alienated the affections of Rutherford's wife, which afterward caused a divorce. Since that time a very bitter feeling has existed between the men, which was aggravated a year ago by the killing of a cousin of Hatfield by Rutherford.
Yesterday Hatfield, accompanied by his twelve-year-old son and carrying with him a double-barrel shotgun in addition to the repeating rifle which he always carries, came to S[t]a[t]en to vote. All passed off quietly until about 5 o'clock, when Hatfield and Rutherford got into an altercation and began firing at each other, Rutherford using a revolver and Hatfield his shotgun.
After emptying his shotgun, Hatfield seized his rifle and began pumping lead with lightning-like rapidity. At the fifth shot Rutherford fell dead.
In the mêlée Henderson Chambers, a brother-in-law of Rutherford, who was an election officer, was accidentally shot by Hatfield and mortally wounded, dying this afternoon.
Immediately after killing Rutherford Hatfield fled toward the woods, closely pursued by a nephew of Rutherford who emptied a revolver at him, wounding him slightly in the thigh. Hatfield suddenly stopped in his flight, shot young Rutherford through the heart, and taking his boy climbed a wooded mountain near by hotly pursued by a number of armed citizens.
The excitement which followed was intense, and the whole country is aroused, and in case of Hatfield's capture, which must surely occur, there is great danger of lynching. A reward of $1,000 has been offered for Hatfield by Rutherford's relatives, and it is believed that Gov. MacCorkle will renew the reward of $500 which he offered for his arrest a few years since.
Hatfield, who is a desperate man, was the leader of the Hatfield clan in the terrible Hatfield-McCoy feud of a few years ago. He knows every foot of ground and every stronghold in the mountains of Mingo and Logan counties. For this reason the task of capturing him is a dangerous one.
Sheriff Keadle and a posse of twenty-five men are now pursuing him, and although the chase will likely be a long one Hatfield will doubtless be captured at last. A part of Hatfield's relatives, owing to some trouble, have turned against him and are assisting the officers in their efforts to catch him. The excitement is intense, and the whole country is indignant over this recent outbreak by an old offender.
At 10 P. M. a report reached this place that a posse is in hot pursuit of the man, but he has not yet been seen. There is little danger of another outbreak of the Hatfield-McCoy feud, but serious trouble seems inevitable.
Hatfield is a man of unusual intelligence, considering his environment, and possesses a wonderful amount of mountaineer shrewdness. He has lived a quiet and peaceable life since the suppression of the old feud, and this recent outbreak is quite a surprise to those who know him.
A newspaper recounts a violent altercation in which Hatfield shot Rutherford dead, accidentally killed a bystander, and then killed a pursuing nephew before fleeing into the mountains. The report notes a manhunt is underway, rewards offered, and recalls Hatfield's role as leader in the earlier Hatfield-McCoy feud.
The Sun · 5 November 1896 · page 9
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Marietta Daily Leader · Marietta, Ohio
A telegraph dispatch reports that Capt. Hatfield, of Hatfield-McCoy feud fame, killed Henderson Chambers and John and Elliott Rutherford near Matewan, W. Va., during a political dispute. Hatfield fled the scene and 200 men were reportedly pursuing him.
Marietta Daily Leader · 5 November 1896 · page 4
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Alexandria Gazette · Alexandria, D.C.
A brief dispatch reports that Captain Hatfield, called the notorious leader of the Hatfield-McCoy feud, killed two men and wounded others at Matewan, West Virginia, the previous day. The report notes that he remains at large and has not yet been captured.
Alexandria Gazette · 5 November 1896 · page 2
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Shepherdstown Register · Shepherdstown, Va. W. Va.
A brief news item states that Captain Hatfield, called the notorious leader in the Hatfield-McCoy feud, killed two men and wounded others at Matewan, and remains at large. The report gives no further detail on names, motive, or circumstances.
Shepherdstown Register · 5 November 1896 · page 2
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Evening Journal · Wilmington, Del.
At Matewan, W. Va., Captain Hatfield of the Hatfield-McCoy feud fame shot and killed Henry Chambers and John and Elliot Rutherford, one of whom was an election officer. The killings reportedly stemmed from an existing feud inflamed by local politics, and a posse with a reward offer set out in pursuit of Hatfield.
Evening Journal · 6 November 1896 · page 5
A Scoundrel Kills Three Men
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Morning Times · Washington, D.C.
The report claims the Hatfield-McCoy feud has been 'revived' after a Capt. Hatfield allegedly killed three men in an election-day shootout at Matewan, raising the death toll to nine McCoys. It recaps the supposed origins of the feud, including the 1891 marriage that patched things up and a McCoy's 1895 disappearance as a ninth victim.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Morning Times · 6 November 1896 · page 6
BLOODY FAMILY QUARREL
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Morning Times · Washington, D.C.
The report describes a Hatfield shooting Rutherford dead and fleeing to the mountains as a posse pursues him, then recaps the long Hatfield-McCoy feud's origin over a hog lawsuit and the execution of McCoy brothers tied to pawpaw trees. It claims a thirteen-year-old boy named Randolph McCoy witnessed his brothers' deaths and was later killed too.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Morning Times · 6 November 1896 · page 6
BLOODY FAMILY QUARREL
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Morning Times · Washington, D.C.
This retrospective account recounts the 1882 killing of three McCoy brothers tied to pawpaw trees by Hatfields, followed by the 1888 New Year's night raid on Randolph McCoy's house that killed his daughter and son. It also describes subsequent violence including the deaths of Jim Vance and a sheriff.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
The Morning Times · 6 November 1896 · page 6
HATFIELDS AS EXECUTIONERS.
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Abendblatt · Chicago, Ill.
A posse in the mountains along Tug River captured Capt. Hatfield and his 14-year-old son Glenn, accusing them of murdering John and Elliott Rutherford and H. Chambers on election day. The report identifies Hatfield as the leader of the Hatfields during the old family feud with the McCoys.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
Abendblatt · 6 November 1896 · page 1
MÖRDER EINGEFANGEN. Drei Personen von ihnen am Wahltage ermordet.
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Topeka State Journal · Topeka, Kansas
In Thacker, W. Va., a posse captured Captain Hatfield and his 14-year-old son Glenn in the mountains along Tug River. The two were accused of murdering John and Elliott Rutherford and Hance Chambers on election day, with the report noting Hatfield had once led the Hatfields in their feud with the McCoys.
The Topeka State Journal · 6 November 1896 · page 5
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Evening Bulletin · Maysville, Ky.
A dispatch from Williamson, W.Va. reports that a man called 'Captain Hatfield,' linked in the article to 'Hatfield-McCoy fame,' killed three men—Rutherford, Chambers, and a nephew—in a shootout at a polling place after a long-standing personal feud over an affair and a prior killing. Hatfield fled into the mountains with his young son, pursued by an armed posse and a sheriff, amid fears of lynching if captured.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Evening Bulletin · 6 November 1896 · page 1
THREE MEN LAY DEAD.
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Jersey City News · Jersey City, N.J.
A detective and deputy sheriff captured Captain Hatfield and his fourteen-year-old son in the mountains of Mingo County, charging them with the murders of John Rutherford, Elliot Rutherford, and Hanse Chambers on Election Day. Both father and son calmly confessed to the killings when interviewed at the jail, showing no remorse.
The Jersey City News · 6 November 1896 · page 4
Father and Son Murder Three Men on Election Day
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Sun · New York, N.Y.
Cap Hatfield, leader of the Hatfield clan, is reported cornered with about twenty kinsmen in an old stone fort in Logan County after a triple killing at Matewan. Sheriff Keadle has organized posses, tripled the reward, and guarded rail lines and mountain passes to prevent his escape into Kentucky.
The Sun · 6 November 1896 · page 3
CAP HATFIELD CORNERED
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Sun · New York, N.Y.
A sheriff's scout located the Hatfields' fortified stone hideout on a tributary of the Guyandotte River in Logan County, prompting Sheriff Keadle to assemble fifty armed men for an assault. The report describes the fort's defensible construction and warns that the Hatfields' skill with rifles makes any attack dangerous, with an assault expected by Friday daylight.
The Sun · 6 November 1896 · page 3
CAP HATFIELD CORNERED
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
San Antonio Daily Light · San Antonio, Tex.
A dispatch from Thacker, W. Va., reports that Captain Hatfield and his 14-year-old son Glenn were captured by a citizen posse for murdering John and Elliott Rutherford and Chance Chambers on election day. It identifies Hatfield as the leader of the Hatfield gang from its earlier war with the McCoys.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
San Antonio Daily Light · 6 November 1896 · page 1
HATFIELD CAPTURED.
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Salt Lake Herald · Salt Lake City, Utah
A New York Sun dispatch claims 'Captain Hatfield, the notorious outlaw of Hatfield-McCoy fame,' killed three men in a gunfight at Matewan over an old grudge involving a wife's affections, then fled with his young son into the woods. A posse pursued him and lynching was feared, with a $1,000 reward offered.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Salt Lake Herald · 6 November 1896 · page 3
KILLS THREE MEN LATEST TRAGEDY CAUSED BY CAPTAIN HATFIELD
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Salt Lake Herald · Salt Lake City, Utah
A man named Hatfield shot and killed Rutherford and accidentally wounded his brother-in-law during an election dispute, then fled into the mountains after killing a pursuing nephew. Posses and a $1,000 reward were organized to capture him amid fears of a new outbreak of the old Hatfield-McCoy feud.
The Salt Lake Herald · 6 November 1896 · page 3
A GREAT LEADER
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Salt Lake Herald · Salt Lake City, Utah
In a satirical post-election roundup of political jabs and jokes, one line notes that 'The Hatfield McCoy feud has come forth in all its pristine glory.' No details are given about the specific incident prompting the remark.
The Salt Lake Herald · 6 November 1896 · page 4
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · Wheeling, W. Va.
A dispatch from Matewan, W.Va. recounts the decade-old killing of Ellison Hatfield and the retaliatory killing of three McCoy brothers, tied to bushes and shot dozens of times, as background to tensions in the area. It then reports that on Election Day 1896, despite heavy drinking and armed crowds, the day passed peacefully until the polls were closing, when an incident began involving 'Cap' Hatfield.
The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · 6 November 1896 · page 4
MURDER AT THE POLLS.
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Birmingham State Herald · Birmingham, Ala.
A detective and deputy sheriff captured Capt. Hatfield and his 14-year-old son asleep in a rock crevice near Tug River, charging them with the election-day murders of John Rotherford, Elliott Rotherford, and Hand Chambers at Mattewan. Both father and son reportedly admitted guilt smilingly, and were jailed in Huntington for fear of mob violence amid heavy armament and crowds seeking to view them.
Birmingham State Herald · 7 November 1896 · page 5
HATFIELDS IN HOCK. THE BLOODY FATHER AND SON ARE IN JAIL.
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Daily Morning Journal and Courier · New Haven, Conn.
Detectives captured Captain Hatfield and his fourteen-year-old son in Mingo County, West Virginia, asleep in a rock crevice along the Tug River. Both admitted involvement in the killings of John Rutherford, Elliott Rutherford, and Hanz Chambers at Matewan on election day.
The Daily Morning Journal and Courier · 7 November 1896 · page 1
THE HATFIELDS CAPTURED.
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The San Francisco Call · San Francisco, Calif.
Captain Hatfield, described as the notorious outlaw leader of the clan, and his son were captured and jailed near Huntington, West Virginia after a triple killing at Matewan. The report details a two-day manhunt that cornered roughly twenty Hatfield kinsmen in an old stone fort once used during the original feud with the McCoys.
The San Francisco Call · 7 November 1896 · page 2
OUTLAW HATFIELD JUGGED
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Evening Journal · Wilmington, Del.
Capt. Hatfield, a notorious West Virginia outlaw, has been jailed in Huntington after being captured by officers following the killing of McCoy friends on Election Day, reopening the long-dormant Hatfield-McCoy feud. His father Devil Anse and two brothers were also captured and jailed separately in Logan County, causing the clan to disperse.
Evening Journal · 7 November 1896 · page 3
KILLED THREE MEN ELECTION DAY
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Evening Journal · Wilmington, Del.
After three days and nights of trailing by about 100 men, Captain Hatfield, leader of the Hatfield clan and perpetrator of a triple killing at Matewan, has been captured and jailed in Cabell County. The report also recaps the feud's origins, including the hog dispute, earlier killings, and a peace-sealing marriage between the clans.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 4 days later.
Wrong
Evening Journal · 7 November 1896 · page 3
KILLED THREE MEN ELECTION DAY
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Morning News · Savannah, Ga.
Detective J. H. Clark and Daniel Christian captured Capt. Hatfield and his 14-year-old son hiding in a rock cliff on Tug River, Mingo County. The pair are accused of murdering John Rutherford, Elliott Rutherford, and Hans Chambers on election day, and both calmly admitted to the killings.
The Morning News · 7 November 1896 · page 1
HATFIELD AND HIS SON CAUGHT.
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Indianapolis Journal · Indianapolis, Ind.
A posse captured 'Cap' Hatfield and his 14-year-old son Glenn in the mountains along the Tug River, accusing them of murdering John and Elliott Rutherford and Hance Chambers on election day. The report notes Hatfield had led the Hatfields during their earlier feud battles with the McCoys.
The Indianapolis Journal · 7 November 1896 · page 2
The Hatfield Captured
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Wichita Daily Eagle · Wichita, Kan.
A posse in Thacker, W.Va. captured Captain Hatfield and his 11-year-old son in the mountains along the Tug River. The pair were accused of killing John and Elliott Rutherford on election day; the report notes Hatfield once led the Hatfield gang in its war with the McCoys.
The Wichita Daily Eagle · 7 November 1896 · page 1
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Evening Bulletin · Maysville, Ky.
Captain (Cap) Hatfield and his teenage son were captured hiding in a mountain rock fort in Mingo County, West Virginia, and charged with three murders from a separate 1896 election dispute at Matewan. The report recalls the earlier Hatfield-McCoy feud, calling Cap its leader and claiming he had killed 17 men over 20 years.
A dispatch from Huntington, W. Va. reports that 'Capt. Hatfield,' described as the notorious leader of the Hatfield clan in its war with the McCoys, has been captured asleep in a mountain rock fort along with his 14-year-old son. Both are charged with three murders in an election-day quarrel at Matewan, with the boy boasting of two killings and his father of a third.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 4 days later.
Wrong
Paper unidentified · 7 November 1896 · page 3
CAPT. HATFIELD.
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Daily Kennebec Journal · Augusta, Me.
Detectives captured the notorious Capt. Hatfield and his 14-year-old son hiding in a mountain rock crevice near Tug River, wanted for the election-day murders of three men at Mattawan, W. Va. Both father and son reportedly confessed to the killings without showing concern, and were moved to Huntington jail to avoid mob violence.
Daily Kennebec Journal · 7 November 1896 · page 1
NOT WORRIED
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Diamond Drill · Crystal Falls, Mich.
A brief news item reports that Capt. Hatfield, of Hatfield-McCoy fame, killed Henderson Chambers and John and Elliott Rutherford at Matewan, West Virginia, during a quarrel over hunting rights. Hatfield reportedly escaped after the shooting.
The Diamond Drill · 7 November 1896 · page 2
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The News Boy · Benton, Mo.
The report states that three men—Chambers, Elliott, and Rutherford—were killed at Matewan, W. Va., on the 3rd by Capt. Hatfield of Hatfield-McCoy fame. It notes the feud was reignited by local election politics, with a reward offered for the perpetrators.
The News Boy · 7 November 1896 · page 3
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Sun · New York, N.Y.
After three days and nights of trailing, a posse of about a hundred men captured Capt. Hatfield, leader of the Hatfield clan, following a triple killing at Matewan. He and his young son were found at a relative's house seeking food and were taken into custody, with the son's attempt to use a gun thwarted before being transported under heavy guard by rail.
The Sun · 7 November 1896 · page 1
CAPT. HATFIELD CAPTURED
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Sun · New York, N.Y.
A deputy's posse tracked down a Hatfield fugitive wanted for murder, surrounding a relative's house and capturing him after he surrendered at gunpoint. Separately, 'Devil Anse' Hatfield and two sons were captured by another posse, breaking up the clan's resistance; prisoners were taken by rail to jail in Huntington.
The Sun · 7 November 1896 · page 1
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Bryan Daily Eagle · Bryan, Tex.
Captain Hatfield and his 14-year-old son Glenn were captured in the mountains on Tug River by a citizens' posse. They were accused of murdering John and Elliott Rutherford and Hance Chambers on election day, and the report identifies Hatfield as leader of the Hatfield gang during its earlier battles with the McCoys.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 4 days later.
Wrong
The Bryan Daily Eagle · 7 November 1896 · page 4
HATFIELD CAUGHT.
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Wisconsin Vorwärts · Milwaukee, Wis.
A posse of citizens captured Capt. Hatfield and his 14-year-old son Glenn in the mountains along the Tug River, accusing them of murdering Elliott Rutherford and H. Chambers on election day. The report identifies Hatfield as the leader of the Hatfields during their feud with the McCoys years earlier.
Wisconsin Vorwärts · 7 November 1896 · page 4
Familienfehde.
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Guthrie Daily Leader · Guthrie, Okla.
Captain Hatfield and his 14-year-old son Cloinid were captured in the mountains along the Tug River on a charge of murder. They are accused of killing John and Elliott Rutherford and Nancy Chambers, in a case tied back to old Hatfield-McCoy enmity.
The Guthrie Daily Leader · 8 November 1896 · page 3
THE HATFIELDS IN FRESH TROUBLE
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Morris Tribune · Morris, Minn.
A brief dispatch states that 'Captain Hatfield' of Hatfield-McCoy fame and his 14-year-old son Glenn were captured by a citizens' posse. They are accused of murdering John and Elliott Rutherford and Hance Chambers on election day.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Morris Tribune · 11 November 1896 · page 8
CRIMINAL NEWS.
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Star · Reynoldsville, Pa.
A posse captured Cap Hatfield and his 14-year-old stepson in the mountains along Tug River, West Virginia, after they killed three men in a polling-day shootout at Matewan. The report recaps the long Hatfield-McCoy feud, noting nine McCoy deaths and the hog-lawsuit origin of the rivalry.
OUTLAWS CAPTURED. They Had Murdered Three Men on Election Day.
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Watertown Republican · Watertown, Wis.
Captain Hatfield and his 14-year-old son Glenn were captured in the mountains near Tug River by a citizen posse. They were accused of murdering John and Elliott Rutherford and Hance Chambers on election day, with the report noting Hatfield's earlier role in the feud with the McCoys.
Watertown Republican · 11 November 1896 · page 2
ONE OF THE HATFIELDS CAUGHT.
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Ceredo Advance · Ceredo, W. Va.
Deputy sheriff J. A. Clark captured Capt. Hatfield and his fourteen-year-old stepson, Joseph Glenn, after they fled to the mountains following the killing of three men at Thacker on election day. The pair were found hiding on a rock cliff above Tug River and surrendered without resistance, later being jailed and photographed.
Ceredo Advance · 11 November 1896 · page 1
"CAP" HATFIELD IS CAPTURED
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Ceredo Advance · Ceredo, W. Va.
Detectives captured Capt. Hatfield, called the most notorious outlaw in the West Virginia mountains, along with his teenage son, hiding in a rock fort once used during the Hatfield-McCoy feud. Both are charged with murdering three men in an election-day quarrel at Matewan, with the son admitting to two of the killings.
Ceredo Advance · 11 November 1896 · page 6
CAPT. HATFIELD.
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Delaware Gazette and State Journal · Wilmington, Del.
A posse on Tug River captured Cap Hatfield and his 14-year-old relative Glenn, accused of murdering John and Elliott Rutherford and Hance Chambers on election day. The report notes Hatfield was the leader of the Hatfields who feuded with the McCoys years earlier.
Delaware Gazette and State Journal · 12 November 1896 · page 3
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Canton Weekly Register · Canton, Ill.
The article describes the burning death of Cora Abbott in Lincoln County, West Virginia, allegedly set by outlaws connected to the Brumfield-McCoy feud. It notes this feud as similar in brutality to the Hatfield-McCoy conflict in the Tug River region.
Canton Weekly Register · 12 November 1896 · page 5
SOME WEST VIRGINIA SPECIMENS
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Evening Bulletin · Maysville, Ky.
This report describes a young woman named Cora Abbott burned to death in a house fire in Lincoln County, West Virginia, apparently in revenge related to the separate Brumfield-McCoy feud. The article explicitly compares this five-year conflict to the Hatfield-McCoy fight in the Tug River territory as a point of reference, not as part of that story itself.
A detective and deputy sheriff captured Capt. Hatfield and his 14-year-old son hiding in a rock cliff in Mingo County, wanted for the election-day murders of John Rutherford, Elliott Rutherford, and Hanse Chambers at Mattewan. Both father and son confessed to the killings when interviewed at the jail, showing no apparent remorse.
The Hocking Sentinel · 12 November 1896 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
CAPTAIN HATFIELD And His 14-year-old Son Captured at Last.
A special from Huntington, W. Va., says: J. H. Clark, a famous detective and Deputy Sheriff of the Norfolk and Western, accompanied by Dan Christian, have arrived here with Capt. Hatfield and his 14-year-old son, who were captured in the mountains of Mingo County. They are charged with the murder of John Rutherford, Elliott Rutherford and Hanse Chambers on election day at Mattewan. Hatfield and son were interviewed at the jail and they seem not the least worried over the affair. The lad smiled and said: "I killed both Elliott Rutherford and Mr. Chambers," while the father acknowledged to killing John Rutherford.
See moreSee less
Hatfield and son were asleep in the crevice of a large rock cliff on Tug River when officers discovered them. They were brought here and placed in jail for fear of mob violence.
Detective J.H. Clark and Dan Christian captured outlaw Cap Hatfield and his 14-year-old son after a two-day manhunt in Mingo County, West Virginia. Both are charged with murdering John Rutherford, Elliott Rutherford, and Hance Chambers during an election dispute at Matewan.
The News-Herald · 12 November 1896 · page 7
CAPT. HATFIELD.
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Pioneer Press · Miller, S.D.
A posse captured Capt. Hatfield and his 14-year-old son Bonn in the mountains along Tug River, West Virginia, accusing them of murdering John and Elliott Rutherford and Fiance Chambers on election day. The report identifies this Hatfield as the same man who led the Hatfields in their earlier feud with the McCoys.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
The Pioneer Press · 12 November 1896 · page 7
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Austin Weekly Statesman · Austin, Tex.
"Cap" Hatfield and his 14-year-old son Glenn were captured by a citizen posse in the mountains on Tug River. They were wanted for murdering John and Elliott Rutherford and Hance Chambers on election day; the report notes Hatfield led the Hatfields during their earlier war with the McCoys.
The Austin Weekly Statesman · 12 November 1896 · page 11
THE HATFIELDS CAPTURED.
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Eagle River Review · Eagle River, Wis.
A man identified as Capt. Hatfield, former leader of the Hatfields during their war with the McCoys, was captured with his 14-year-old son in the mountains along Tug River. The two were accused of murdering John and Elliott Rutherford and Hance Chambers on election day.
A news digest reports that Captain Hatfield, said to be of Hatfield-McCoy fame, killed Henderson Chambers and John Elliott Rutherford of Matewan, W. Va., during a quarrel over politics. The report states Hatfield escaped after the killings.
The Times · 13 November 1896 · page 3
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Also printed in 2 papers
The True Northerner · Paw Paw, Mich. · 11 November 1896
The Citizen · Chicago, Ill. · 14 November 1896
The Forrest City Times · Forrest City, Ark.
A special dispatch from Williamson, W. Va. claimed that Capt. Hatfield, called the notorious outlaw of the Hatfield-McCoy feud, killed three men in a row at Matewan on the 3rd. The report said excitement was intense and a $1,000 reward was offered for his arrest.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Forrest City Times · 13 November 1896 · page 4
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The State Ledger · Topeka, Kan.
Captain Hatfield, leader of the Hatfields in their old feud with the McCoys, and his 14-year-old son Glenn were captured in the mountains by a citizens' posse. They were accused of murdering John and Elliott Ruthford and Hance Chambers on election day.
The State Ledger · 13 November 1896 · page 2
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Kinsley Graphic · Kinsley, Kan.
A special dispatch from Williamson, W. Va. stated that Capt. Hatfield, called the notorious outlaw of the Hatfield-McCoy feud, killed three men in a row at Metawan on the 3rd. Intense excitement followed, and a $1,000 reward was offered for his arrest.
The Kinsley Graphic · 13 November 1896 · page 2
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Tensas Gazette · St. Joseph, La.
Capt. Hatfield and his 14-year-old son Glenn were captured by a posse near Thacker, W. Va., accused of murdering John and Elliott Rutherford and Vance Chambers on election day. The report identifies Hatfield as the leader of the Hatfields during their earlier feud with the McCoys.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 4 days later.
Wrong
Tensas Gazette · 13 November 1896 · page 4
THE HATFIELDS AGAIN
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Vermont Phœnix · Brattleboro, Vt.
Deputy sheriffs captured 'Cap' Hatfield and his 14-year-old son in the Mingo County, W.Va. mountains, charging them with the murders of John Rutherford, Elliot Rutherford, and Hanse Chambers on election day at Matewan. The son admitted to killing two of the victims while the father confessed to killing Rutherford.
Vermont Phœnix · 13 November 1896 · page 3
Notorious Outlaws In Jail
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Webster Echo · Addison, W. Va.
A newspaper recounts an election-day shooting in Mingo County in 1896, then recaps the decade-old feud history: Ellison Hatfield's killing by the McCoy faction and the subsequent revenge killing of three McCoy boys tied to bushes and shot. It also notes a prior 1895 shootout between Rutherford and Chafin, and reports that election day 1896 passed peacefully despite heavy drinking and armed factions present.
The Webster Echo · 13 November 1896 · page 1
MURDER AT THE POLLS.
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Webster Echo · Addison, W. Va.
This report describes a violent shootout at a Mingo County polling place on election day 1896, where Cap Hatfield killed John Rutherford and wounded Henson Chambers and Ex-U.S. Marshal White after a prior shooting contest between Rutherford and Chafin. Hatfield fled and roughly 200 men were reported in pursuit as the report notes seven men had been shot and killed in the county within 48 hours.
The Webster Echo · 13 November 1896 · page 1
MURDER AT THE POLLS.
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The L'anse Sentinel · L'anse, L.S., Mich. · and 2 other papers
The report states that Capt. Hatfield, of Hatfield-McCoy feud fame, killed Henderson Chambers and brothers John and Elliott Rutherford at Matewan, W. Va., during a dispute over politics. Hatfield reportedly escaped after the killings.
The L'anse Sentinel · 14 November 1896 · page 2
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Also printed in 2 papers
The Ely Miner · Ely, Minn. · 11 November 1896
The Worthington Advance · Worthington, Minn. · 12 November 1896
Perrysburg Journal · Perrysburg, Ohio
A short news item reports that Cap Hatfield, of Hatfield-McCoy feud fame, killed Henderson Chambers and John and Elliott Rutherford during a political quarrel at Matewan, West Virginia. Hatfield reportedly escaped after the shooting.
Perrysburg Journal · 14 November 1896 · page 2
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The New Dominion · Morgantown, W. Va.
The report describes Cap Hatfield shooting and killing three men on Election Day 1896 in Mingo County, with the killer fleeing and a manhunt underway. It also recaps the feud's history, including the 1880s killing of Ellison Hatfield and the retaliatory execution of three McCoy brothers.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 6 days later.
Wrong
The New Dominion · 14 November 1896 · page 2
KILLS THREE MEN.
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The New Dominion · Morgantown, W. Va.
On election day 1896 in Matewan, a feud-related gunfight broke out at the polling place between Cap Hatfield and John Rutherford, leaving Rutherford dead and others wounded, including election officer Henson Chambers and ex-Marshal H. S. White. The report also recounts an earlier 1895 shooting duel between Rutherford and John Chatin that ended in acquittal.
Near Huntington, W. Va., Captain Hatfield of the Hatfield-McCoy feud killed three men in a political quarrel and initially escaped. A posse later captured Hatfield along with his 14-year-old son.
Decorah Public Opinion · 17 November 1896 · page 2
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Calhoun Chronicle · Grantsville, W. Va.
The article reports that the capture of Cap Hatfield is expected to end the long-running Hatfield-McCoy feud, then recounts the feud's origins from the 1878 election-day killing of Ellison Hatfield through the brutal execution of the three McCoy brothers. It frames the capture as a culminating event in an eighteen-year cycle of violence between Kentucky and West Virginia families.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 3 days later.
Wrong
The Calhoun Chronicle · 17 November 1896 · page 2
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Calhoun Chronicle · Grantsville, W. Va.
This 1896 article recaps the feud's origins and major violent episodes, from Ellison Hatfield's killing by three McCoy sons through the retaliatory executions, the burning of Randall McCoy's home, and years of deadly clashes. It closes by noting Cap Hatfield's jailhouse interview about the feud's crimes.
This article recounts the Hatfield-McCoy feud's history, describing various killings including Charles McCoy, James Vance, Harry Hatfield, and Bill Dempsey, and claims over 70 people died during the feud. It also reports the recent election-day murders of the Rutherford brothers and Benson Chambers, allegedly by Cap Hatfield and his stepson.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 3 days later.
Wrong
The Calhoun Chronicle · 17 November 1896 · page 2
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Randolph Enterprise · Beverly, W. Va.
The report describes a violent altercation at Matewan on election day in which 'Cap' Hatfield, tied to the Hatfield-McCoy feud, killed Rutherford, Chambers, and a nephew after a dispute over an affair with Rutherford's wife. Hatfield fled with his young son into the mountains but was captured days later by armed citizens.
Randolph Enterprise · 18 November 1896 · page 1
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Evening Journal · Wilmington, Del.
After a clash in which officers were shot, a posse of about a score of armed men pursued the fleeing culprits, with a relative of the victims offering $500 rewards for the arrest of the men, including one named Clark. The community was reported as wildly excited and divided, some condemning the officers' actions and others defending them, amid fears of further bloodshed if the pursuers caught up with them.
Evening Journal · 19 November 1896 · page 3
RELATIVE OF THE HATFIELDS
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Barbour Democrat · Philippi, W. Va.
The report states that 'Cap' Hatfield, infamous from the Hatfield-McCoy feud, killed three men including Rutherford at Matewan after a dispute over a woman's affections, fleeing with his young son before being captured days later. It describes the shootout, the killing of Rutherford's relatives, and Hatfield's pursuit and capture by armed citizens.
The Barbour Democrat · 19 November 1896 · page 1
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Wheeling Register · Wheeling, W. Va.
A detective attempting to arrest Anderson Mounts killed him and mortally wounded his father after mistakenly trying to arrest a man already in custody, then fled with his partner. Armed gangs reportedly gathered along the railroad, with one man beaten to death, before the detectives wired their surrender to a Kentucky sheriff.
Wheeling Register · 20 November 1896 · page 1
THE DETECTIVES FLED.
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Clarksburg Telegram · Clarksburg, W. Va.
This retrospective article summarizes the Hatfield-McCoy feud, tracing it back to the 1882 election-day killing of Ellison Hatfield by three McCoy brothers, who were then abducted and brutally executed by Hatfield partisans. It frames a recent 1896 triple killing as part of the same long-running vendetta.
The Clarksburg Telegram · 20 November 1896 · page 2
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Clarksburg Telegram · Clarksburg, W. Va.
This long after-the-fact newspaper account retells the whole feud saga, from Ellison Hatfield's killing and the McCoys' retaliatory lynching to the New Year's raid on Randall McCoy's home. It compresses years of events into a single dramatic narrative for readers unfamiliar with the story.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 2 days later.
Wrong
The Clarksburg Telegram · 20 November 1896 · page 2
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Clarksburg Telegram · Clarksburg, W. Va.
This 1896 report recounts the five-year Hatfield-McCoy feud's history, noting over 70 deaths and only one Hatfield ever hanged. It details a recent election-day triple murder for which Cap Hatfield and his teenage son were arrested, while patriarch 'Devil Anse' Hatfield mysteriously escaped jail.
The Clarksburg Telegram · 20 November 1896 · page 2
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Wichita Daily Eagle · Wichita, Kan.
Detective J. H. Clark, who killed Anderson Mounts, is jailed alongside captured Cap Hatfield in Williamson, W. Va. The Mountses and McCoys are threatening to lynch both the detectives and Hatfield, while the Hatfields vow to defend the jail.
The Wichita Daily Eagle · 21 November 1896 · page 6
A BADLY MIXED-UP FEUD.
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Bryan Daily Eagle · Bryan, Tex.
The report describes Detective J. H. Clark being jailed after capturing 'Cap' Hatfield and killing a friend of Anderson Mounts, with the Mounts and McCoy factions now uniting to threaten a lynching of both the detective and Hatfield. The Hatfields are said to be preparing to defend the jail if such an attempt is made.
The Baltimore American recounts how Cap Hatfield and his teenage stepson Joseph Glenn shot three men dead at a Thacker, WV election precinct after a dispute, then fled to the mountains unopposed. The article frames this as part of a long pattern, claiming Hatfield has now caused eighteen deaths total, with a posse's pursuit proving fruitless.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 3 days later.
Wrong
The Morning News · 22 November 1896 · page 15 · transcribed from the page image
CAP HATFIELD'S VICTIMS.
HE HAS MADE EIGHTEEN MEN BITE THE DUST.
See moreSee less
Finally Captured by a Posse—The Outlaw and His Stepson Shot Down Three Men on Election Day at the Polls—The Chances Are He Will Swing—First Time He Has Ever Been Landed Behind the Bars. Story of the Hatfield-McCoy Feud.
from the Baltimore American.
Huntington, W. Va., Nov. 8.—The crime for which Capt. Hatfield and his stepson, Joseph Glenn, were hunted, and finally run down, was the murder of three men at an election precinct Tuesday afternoon. Hatfield went to the polls at Thacker, W. Va., to vote, and was accompanied by his stepson, Joseph Glenn, a lad who has just entered his 14th year. Both were carrying Winchesters on their shoulders, as well as revolvers of enormous caliber in their pockets. They had not been at the polls half a hour until they began to dispute with John and Elliott Rutherford, two natives of that section who "Cap" Hatfield claimed had more than ten years ago been on the side of the McCoys during a battle with his relatives. Trouble was imminent, and the Rutherfords started to leave the polls, when "Cap" raised his Winchester and fired a ball at John Rutherford, killing him instantly. Joe Glenn, the 14-year-old stepson, raised his Winchester and laid low Elliott Rutherford. Hance Chambers, a prominent citizen, rushed forward just as the lad fired. The boy, thinking he was a friend of the Rutherfords, turned his Winchester at him and killed him also. "Cap" and the boy then turned toward the mountains and walked off unconcerned. No one present attempted to arrest them, for the natives knew that it was useless, and would only result in more of their number being killed. Next morning a posse of 100 citizens, heavily armed, started in pursuit of the murderers, determined to effect their capture. No trail of them could be found, and the posse abandoned the search while on the top of a large mountain overhanging the Tug river.
J. H. Clark, the leader of the posse, accompanied by Daniel Christian, were returning to their home, and were passing near a large rock cliff on a hillside, when they discovered the forms of two persons in a large crevice of the rocks. Upon going near they discovered it was Cap and his stepson, both of whom were asleep. Their capture was easily made, and the prisoners were taken to the nearest railroad station, and were brought to Huntington and lodged in jail, arriving here early this morning. They were brought here for safe keeping, as it was feared they would be mobbed were they left in jail there.
Cap Hatfield has a record probably unexceled by any other living man. He is charged with killing eighteen men during his life, and is now only in the thirty-eighth year of his age. He is a man of ordinary intelligence, and does not look to be the desperado he is. It is feared that the citizens of Mingo county will form a mob and come here with the intention of lynching Hatfield and his son; but the authorities here are able to cope with any body which may attempt such proceedings.
During all the wild career of Hatfield this is the first time he was ever landed behind prison bars. Hatfield and stepson sat for a picture, and seemed to enjoy the notoriety which they were getting. The lad wore a suit made of homespun jeans, and is an innocent looking boy; but people of that section claim he is more daring and brave than any of his ancestors. Hatfield committed his first murder almost twenty years ago, when he was leader of the band which tied two of the McCoys to a pawpaw bush and assisted in shooting them to death. His deeds since that time have been numerous. The probabilities are now that he has killed his last victim, for the officials of West Virginia will likely see that justice is meted out for the many murders which have been committed in that wild and mountainous region.
The Hatfield-McCoy feud originated before the breaking out of the civil war. Its immediate cause was the ownership of two bony and bristly mountain hogs. Over these hogs Anse Hatfield and Randolph McCoy had a disagreement. They went to law, and Hatfield was beaten. The dispute was not settled, by any means. All the relatives of the families took sides, and the question was intensified. Shortly after the trial "Bill" Stayton, a nephew of Floyd Hatfield, a son of a witness in the case, was found dead, with a bullet in his person. Two of the numerous McCoy boys were tried for the murder and acquitted.
Soon afterward Jonce Hatfield became enamoured of Rosanna McCoy and kidnapped her. Matters went along with an occasional death on either side until 1882, when the hottest kind of hostilities began. "Cap" Hatfield became the leader of the Hatfields. Election day is always the favorite time for a gun fight among the Virginia mountaineers. In 1882 there was an election in Pike county. In the early afternoon the inevitable fight cropped out, this time between Ellison Hatfield and Talbot McCoy. When the spectators came out from behind the corner of the grocery store and from behind sundry trees from which they had been peeping, they found Ellison Hatfield lying on the ground dead. Several of the McCoys, including a 13-year-old boy, Randolph McCoy, were arrested and confined in the log school house over night.
Next day the sheriff started through the lonely mountain woods with the prisoners for the Pike county jail. By this time the entire Hatfield clan had heard of the death of Ellison. They rallied immediately around "Anse," the patriarch, and "Cap," his son.
They ambushed the sheriff, who had the McCoy prisoners in charge, and took matters into their own hands. The sheriff was released, but the McCoys were taken to a lonely log house in the mountains, where they were tied so tightly with ropes that their limbs were practically paralyzed. On the following morning they were marched over the border into Kentucky, and tied in a kneeling position to some saplings near the margin of the boundary streams. There was no begging for mercy on the part of the McCoys. They knelt grimly, and sneeringly awaited their fate.
Wall Hatfield stood in plain sight on the Virginia side of the river.
"Are you ready?" he cried.
"Yes," said "Cap" and Anse and the other Hatfields.
"Take aim. Fire!"
There was a rattle of rifles, and two of the McCoys fell limp on their ropes. They were Talbot and Farmer McCoy. The young boy, Randolph, had not been hurt. He was there simply as a witness to the death of his brothers.
This shows the utter disregard in which the Hatfields have ever held the law. The boy was mounted in front of Wall Hatfield, and the party started back for their mountain haunts.
On the way "Cap" suddenly called a halt. "That boy must die," said he. "Anse" sat silent, thereby consenting. Wall Hatfield raised his voice in the boy's behalf. Some of the other Hatfields did likewise. It was no use. "Anse," the patriarch, and "Cap" ruled things with an iron hand. So the boy was killed and left lying by the side of the road. Of course, feeble attempts were made to capture the Hatfields, but without avail. Two years later Jeff McCoy was captured by the Hatfields and shot dead in the presence of his sister. It seemed to be evident that the Hatfields had fully determined upon the extermination of their enemies. No further murders took place, however, until 1888.
On New Year's night the Hatfields, feeling dull for want of something to do, determined to pay another visit to the McCoy's. Late at night the house of Randolph McCoy, the leader of the faction, was surroundered by a gang of Hatfields. In the house at the time were Randolph McCoy and his wife, his son, Calvin, three daughters (Allaphore, Addie and Fannie), Cora, the orphaned daughter of Talbot, and Melvin, the son of Rosanna McCoy. The Hatfields were headed by "Cap" and Jim Vance. They called on the McCoys to surrender or have the house burned over their heads. The McCoys refused. Then the heroism of border women cropped out.
The Hatfields built a fire against the house. Alaphore McCoy, a young woman 20 years old, heard the crackling of the flames. She grabbed a churn full of milk and walked calmly out of the house to pour it over the flames. She was shot dead before she could accomplish her object. The light blazed up and several Hatfields became visible. Old man McCoy shot Jonce Hatfield, killing him instantly. Then he ran for the woods, escaping without injury. Calvin McCoy rushed from the house and was shot through the brain. The other McCoys were not injured.
Throughout the entire feud "Cap" Hatfield has borne a charmed life. This later outbreak was in keeping with his former exploits.
The feud with the McCoys was settled in 1893 by the marriage of a McCoy to a Hatfield, and there is but little danger that it will break out again. Since that time "Cap" has lived a quiet and peaceful life, and his last exploit has caused no end of surprise.
A posse of 100 armed citizens pursued Cap Hatfield and his stepson after they walked off unmolested from a killing; they were later found asleep in a rock crevice and captured. The report recounts Cap Hatfield's violent history, including the feud's origin over a hog dispute and his role in tying McCoys to a pawpaw bush to be shot.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 5 days later.
Wrong
The Morning News · 22 November 1896 · page 15
HE HAS MADE EIGHTEEN MEN BITE
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Morning News · Savannah, Ga.
The report sketches the feud's background, from the 1878 hog dispute between Hatfield and McCoy through early killings and Roseanna McCoy's elopement, up to the 1882 election-day killing of Ellison Hatfield and the McCoy brothers' deaths at Hatfield hands. It frames these events as context for a recent arrest of a young Hatfield now drawing public notoriety.
The report describes a fresh election-day shooting by 'Old Cap' Hatfield that killed Rutherford and young Rutherford, then recaps the origins of the Hatfield-McCoy feud. It traces the feud's start to a hog ownership dispute and subsequent killings, framing Cap Hatfield as the feud's violent leader.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 5 days later.
Wrong
The Indianapolis Journal · 22 November 1896 · page 5
ANOTHER BLOODY KILLING BY "OLD CAP," THE FAMOUS OUTLAW.
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Indianapolis Journal · Indianapolis, Ind.
The report traces the feud back to a hog-ownership dispute and early killings, then describes the 1882 election-day killing of Ellison Hatfield and the retaliatory capture and execution of McCoy brothers by the Hatfields. It claims only two McCoys, Talbert and Farmer, were shot dead while young Randolph McCoy survived merely as a witness.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 5 days later.
Wrong
The Indianapolis Journal · 22 November 1896 · page 5
"OLD CAP" THE LEADER
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Indianapolis Journal · Indianapolis, Ind.
This retelling describes the Hatfields capturing three McCoy prisoners, executing two by gunfire while sparing a young boy who was later killed separately on the road home. It continues with the New Year's 1883 attack on Randolph McCoy's house, where the family was surrounded and threatened with burning.
The Indianapolis Journal · 22 November 1896 · page 5
"OLD CAP" THE LEADER
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · Wheeling, W. Va.
Sheriff N.J. Keadle of Mingo County tells a reporter that despite thirteen recent killings in the county, these are unrelated to the old Hatfield-McCoy feud, which he says has ended. He describes the Hatfields as law-abiding timber operators living peacefully apart from the McCoys.
The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · 25 November 1896 · page 1
WAS ELECTED SHERIFF IN MINGO
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · Wheeling, W. Va.
The sheriff of Mingo County denies newspaper claims that thirteen recent killings are connected to the old Hatfield-McCoy feud, insisting the Hatfields are peaceable, successful citizens. He details several unrelated homicides, including the Estep shooting and the Evans-Vance killing, before beginning to describe the Hatfield-Rutherford shooting on election day.
The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · 25 November 1896 · page 1
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · Wheeling, W. Va.
The report details a string of killings in Mingo County around election time, culminating in a violent clash between Cap Hatfield, his stepson Joe Glenn, and the Rutherford family at Matewan. John Rutherford, Elliott Rutherford, and bystander Hense Chambers were killed, and Hatfield and the boy fled to the mountains before being helped to Williamson via train.
The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · 25 November 1896 · page 1
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Rock Island Argus · Rock Island, Ill.
The article reports on Cap Hatfield's recent election-day shooting at Matewan, W. Va., which killed three men, and uses it as an occasion to recap the long history of the Hatfield-McCoy feud. It traces the feud's roots to a pre-Civil War hog ownership dispute between Anse Hatfield and Randolph McCoy, followed by subsequent killings and the kidnapping of Rosanna McCoy by Johnse Hatfield.
Rock Island Argus · 27 November 1896 · page 3
Manslaughter a Favorite Pastime With Old 'Cap' Hatfield / Famous Hatfield-McCoy Feud
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Rock Island Argus · Rock Island, Ill.
This report traces the feud from a pre-Civil War dispute over hogs through escalating violence, the killing of Ellison Hatfield, and the capture and execution of McCoy brothers by the Hatfield clan. It dramatizes the ambush and shooting of two McCoy brothers while claiming a third, young Randolph, was spared as a witness.
This retelling describes the execution of two McCoy brothers while a third, young Randolph, was spared as a witness before being killed later on the road. It recounts further killings over the years, including Jeff McCoy, Calvin McCoy, and Jonce Hatfield, before claiming the feud ended with a 1933 marriage uniting the families.