As the Papers Told It

The Hatfields and the McCoys · The full archive

December 1896

16 articles

Richmond Dispatch · Richmond, Va.

Sheriff N. J. Keadle of Mingo County tells a reporter that despite thirteen deaths in thirty days, the violence is unrelated to the old Hatfield-McCoy feud, which he says is over. He details the killings, including the shooting of Dr. Estep after he killed John Roberts in a dispute over chickens.

Richmond Dispatch · 8 December 1896 · page 3

THIRTEEN KILLED. INTERVIEW WITH THE SHERIFF OF MINGO COUNTY, W, VA.

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Richmond Dispatch · Richmond, Va.

The report describes a string of recent killings in the region, culminating in a chaotic election-day gunfight at Matewan involving Cap Hatfield, his stepson, and the Rutherford family. It recounts how a stray shot killed a bystander, a duel-like exchange occurred between Hatfield and Elliot Rutherford, and Hatfield and the boy fled to the mountains before escaping by train.

Richmond Dispatch · 8 December 1896 · page 3

THE HATFIELD

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Richmond Dispatch · Richmond, Va.

Sheriff N. J. Keadle of Mingo County, West Virginia, tells a reporter that despite thirteen recent killings in the county, these have nothing to do with the old Hatfield-McCoy feud, which he says is no longer active. He describes the Hatfields as respectable businessmen and recounts a separate recent killing involving Dr. Estep and the Roberts brothers that was mistakenly linked to the feud.

Richmond Dispatch · 8 December 1896 · page 3

INTERVIEW WITH THE SHERIFF OF MINGO COUNTY, W, VA.

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Kansas City Daily Journal · Kansas City, Mo.

The article reports that 'Old Cap' Hatfield shot and killed Rutherford and wounded Henderson Chambers in an election-day gunfight before being captured and arrested. It then begins recounting the origins of the Hatfield-McCoy feud, tracing it back to a dispute over hogs before the Civil War.

Kansas City Daily Journal · 9 December 1896 · page 2

FAMOUS MOUNTAIN DESPERADO NOW UNDER ARREST

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Kansas City Daily Journal · Kansas City, Mo.

The report describes 'Old Cap' Hatfield killing a man named Rutherford and wounding another in an election-day gun battle rooted in an old grudge, before being chased and finally captured. It then recounts the broader Hatfield-McCoy feud's origins, from a hog dispute through various killings up to the 1882 Ellison Hatfield slaying.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 11 days later.

Wrong

Kansas City Daily Journal · 9 December 1896 · page 2

FAMOUS MOUNTAIN DESPERADO NOW

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Kansas City Daily Journal · Kansas City, Mo.

This is a later newspaper retelling of the feud's history, describing the ambush and execution of McCoy prisoners by the Hatfields in the 1880s, followed by an account of the 1888 New Year's raid on Randolph McCoy's house. It frames the Hatfields as lawless and vengeful, culminating in the killing of Jeff McCoy and build-up to the 'awful massacre'.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 11 days later. CorrectionThis set right 2 earlier articles: Rock Island Argus, 27 November 1896, Rock Island Argus, 27 November 1896.

Wrong

Kansas City Daily Journal · 9 December 1896 · page 2

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The National Tribune · Washington, D.C.

A railroad detective, Capt. W. G. Baldwin, describes a fresh outbreak of the Hatfield-McCoy feud on election day near the Kentucky-West Virginia line, including a shootout involving a Hatfield son and a deadly clash between his deputies and feud participants. He frames the violence as part of the family's long, bloody legacy going back to 'Old Anse' Hatfield.

The National Tribune · 10 December 1896 · page 5

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Der Fortschritt · New Ulm, Minn.

This fragmentary, OCR-damaged German-language article recaps the Hatfield-McCoy feud, describing 'Old Cop' Hatfield as the decades-long leader of his clan's killings against the McCoys. It also mentions McCoys being arrested for murder but acquitted, and notes that despite the blood feud, Johnse Hatfield fell in love with a McCoy.

Der Fortschritt · 10 December 1896 · page 3

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Der Fortschritt · New Ulm, Minn.

This German-language report recounts the history of the Hatfield-McCoy feud, mentioning Jonce Hatfield falling in love despite the feud, an ambush killing, Old Cap Hatfield's leadership, and the bloodshed peaking in 1882. It also references Ellison Hatfield and Tolbert's fight, Anse Hatfield's demand for vengeance, and McCoys being arrested for murder but acquitted.

Der Fortschritt · 10 December 1896 · page 3

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Der Fortschritt · New Ulm, Minn.

This 1896 German-American newspaper article recounts the history of the feud, describing the killing of Ellison Hatfield by McCoy men, the subsequent capture and drowning-execution of Talbot and Farmer McCoy by Hatfield partisans, and the infamous New Year's Eve 1888 raid on Randolph McCoy's cabin. The text is garbled by OCR and appears interleaved with unrelated apple-crop market reports and a separate suicide story.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 10 days later.

Wrong

Der Fortschritt · 10 December 1896 · page 3

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

In the story →

New York Journal · New York, N.Y.

A long retrospective article recounts the forty-year Hatfield-McCoy feud, tracing its origin to an 1878 hog dispute and later killings, and reports that the feud has now been ended by a wedding uniting a Hatfield nephew with a McCoy daughter. It frames the marriage as a romantic reconciliation after decades of bloodshed and lawlessness.

New York Journal · 20 December 1896 · page 30 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

THE HATFIELD-M'COY VENDETTA ENDED BY THE GOD OF LOVE.

Here's a Romance of War and a Mountain Wooing That Has Suddenly Reconciled Two Families After Forty Years of Shooting at Sight and Defiance of the Law in the Bloodiest Feud in the History of the South.

See moreSee less

A NEIGHBORS' QUARREL ABOUT SOME HOGS, A LAWSUIT, MUTUAL HATRED AND THEN MURDER.

MARRIED--In Mingo County, W. Va., Aaron Hatfield, Nephew of "Cap" Hatfield, to Mary McCoy, Daughter of Rudolph McCoy.

A SECRET COURTSHIP WHOSE UNEXPECTED RESULT HAS BEEN RECEIVED WITH JOY ON BOTH SIDES.

A SIMPLE enough wedding notice that, but behind it and in it as romantic a tale of love and courtship as ever was penned—a tale of a mountain maid's wooing; she a McCoy, her lover one of the famous Hatfields, and the two families, for years avowed enemies, sworn to kill at sight, to hunt each other like wild animals; defying the law and the law's officers, and for forty years waging the bloodiest feud in the history of the South.

For forty years the Hatfield-McCoy vendetta has waged, and in those forty years forty coffins, marked by tombstones in the neighboring graveyards, tell of forty lives snuffed out by bullet and knife. Its origin was trivial. Way back in '56, when West Virginia was a new country, many parts of it unexplored and unsettled, two razor-back hogs strayed from the farm of Anse Hatfield. Where they went was the bone of contention. Hatfield claimed that they had wandered to the premises of Rudolph McCoy and were there being kept. This McCoy denied, and the matter finally came up in the shape of a suit for recovery in the country justice court. The case was decided for Hatfield.

During the trial warm words were passed and open hostilities were narrowly averted on several occasions. The relatives and friends of the two litigants crowded the rude court room, all armed and ready to take an active part if the impending battle broke out. But it was avoided, and nothing more than threats from the leaders of the McCoy faction occurred to give alarm. Thus the feud started, and for forty years it kept the country side in a state of excitement.

The McCoys made good their threats. One morning the body of Bill Stayton, a grandson of the plaintiff in the hog case, was found lying dead with a bullet hole in his head. Two of the numerous McCoy boys were arrested for the murder, and at the trial were acquitted. At this juncture the outbreaking of the civil war played a part. Though deadly enemies now and sworn to kill members of the opposing faction on sight, they united in their country's defense, and for the four years the war lasted a truce was declared.

With the surrender of the Confederate forces came the renewal of the feudal hostilities. Old "Cap" Hatfield, the patriarch of the family, assumed the leadership. Jonce Hatfield soon after abducted Rosanna McCoy, and refused to right by marriage the wrong he had done her. For this he was arrested, but a daring rescue by the Hatfields prevented his trial for the charge. From this on to 1882 matters went along rather smoothly. Whenever members of the opposing factions would meet there was sure to be an exchange of shots, but, strange to say, no one was killed outright, though two of the McCoys died afterwards from wounds received in one of their battles.

But election day of 1882 marked the beginning of a series of fights, each one of which claimed one or more victims. A relative of both of the families was running for office, and members of the two factions agreed to suspend their differences and work for their kinsman's election. But before the day was over Talbot McCoy and Elias Hatfield became involved in a fight. At first it was merely a fisticuffs. McCoy threw his opponent, and was pummeling him severely when Deacon Ellison Hatfield and his brother Elias appeared on the scene, and several of the McCoy faction had gathered around their representative, ready to take a hand in the fight when the time came. Talbot McCoy and the deacon advanced on each other with open knives, and when within reach the slashing began. Hatfield's knife closed on his hand, and, throwing it away, he used his fists, while McCoy wielded his weapon with telling effect. The fight then became general, and when it was over, though no one was killed, several of the participants were carried away with injuries that afterward proved fatal. Ellison Hatfield died the following Wednesday. He had been cut twenty-seven times besides being shot. Three of the McCoys were arrested—Talbot, Randolph and Farmer.

The night of the fight the Hatfield clan gathered together seventy members, and, waylaying the deputy sheriff, who was taking the prisoners to the Pike county jail, captured the three McCoys. They were taken across the river to the West Virginia side, and there held to await the outcome of Deacon Ellison Hatfield's injuries. When news came of his death, the imprisoned McCoys were notified that they were to die. The following morning they were taken back to the Kentucky side, and, after being bound, were forced into a kneeling position on the river's brink.

At the word of command a dozen rifle shots barked in the crisp air, and Talbot and Farmer McCoy fell over dead. The thirteen-year-old boy, Randolph McCoy, had been a witness to the killing, and it was decided to kill him, too. One of the party was sent back to do the work, and two barrels from his shotgun riddled the boy's body.

The next move of the Hatfields was to try and kill Randolph McCoy, the head of the family. Two desperadoes of the clan waited in ambush one night near a road over which he would have to travel. Fortunately for the intended victim, a brother, Calvin McCoy, passed the concealed assassins before the man they had marked. In the darkness they mistook their man and fired at Calvin. He was not killed outright, but was maimed for life. Soon after this a Hatfield raid was betrayed to the McCoys, and they escaped. The mother-in-law of Bill Daniels, one of the Hatfield faction, were suspected of betraying the secret. For revenge "Cap" Hatfield and Tom Wallace went to Daniel's home one night, and, covering him with a shotgun, gave both of the women a brutal beating. The wife died from her injuries, and her mother had several ribs and bones broken by the force of the blows.

Jeff McCoy was the next to go. He was a brother of Daniel's wife and was looking for Tom Wallace, who, with "Cap" Hatfield, inflicted the injuries resulting in her death. "Bad Anse" Hatfield agreed to assist him in his search, but instead enticed him into an ambush, where he was killed.

In 1885 the Governor of Kentucky put a price on the head of "Anse" Hatfield and his brother "Cap," and called upon the Governor of West Virginia for their requisition. This was at first denied, but in the latter part of 1887 the officials of both States united in an effort to suppress the bloody feud. The McCoys had suffered so much that their spirit for revenge rarely showed, but they eagerly grasped at the proposition that they join the officers in search of the Hatfield leaders. Three of the gang were captured, and subsequently sent to State's prison.

The zeal of the McCoys in joining the officers aroused the ire of their enemies, and a raid was planned for New Year's night of 1888.

Nine of the Hatfields, led by Uncle Jim Vance, attacked the house of old Randolph McCoy, Two girls were in one end of the house, and one, Allaphare McCoy, opened the door when the gang demanded admission. She was immediately shot and killed by Ellison Mounts, at the command of Vance. Mrs. McCoy started from the door to go to her dead daughter, when Jim Vance broke two of her ribs with the butt of his gun, and stunned her with a blow from his pistol. Calvin McCoy was killed in the exchange of shots and the old man was wounded.

Strange as it may seem, the Hatfields repudiated the killing of the McCoy girl. With their characteristic brutality toward women it is hard to say what prompted it, but they delivered Ellison Mounts, who fired the shot, into the officers' hands, and on their testimony he was convicted and hanged.

From that time the feud, while it has been kept up, has not been as exciting as in former days. Now and then a Hatfield and McCoy exchange shots, but the last man killed met his fate two years ago. The persistent pursuit of the Hatfields by the deputies drove them into the mountain fastnesses and made the warfare before used impossible.

And now comes the reconciliation—the end of it all. Aaron Hatfield, a nephew of old "Cap" Hatfield, met and loved pretty Mary McCoy, daughter of the head of the family, Rudolph McCoy. Primitive in their habits, these mountain lovers knew nothing of what the social world terms conventionality in courtship. There was no one to say that they should do this or do that. They only knew that they loved each other, that it was the lasting, enduring love of years, and they were happy. The rugged, barren hillsides were their trysting places; there they met alone, and their secret was shared with none save one. And he was the trusted friend, who saw to it that neither family knew of what was transpiring until the time for the announcement was deemed ripe. For there was danger should the secret be known prematurely. The fires of the feud, though not blazing, were by no means out. One day Aaron told Mary that his brother would go to see her father the following day. The lovers were at the house of the friend. All day they waited to hear what the result had been. Mary at the window saw the stalwart form of her lover's brother striding toward the house. "It's all right," he said. And then came the joyful news that the wedding would end forever the forty-year feud.

Forty Coffins That Tell of Forty Hatfield and McCoy Victims.

See the clipping

New York Journal · New York, N.Y.

This 1896 article retells the Hatfield-McCoy feud's origins and escalation, from the hog-case lawsuit through Bill Staton's killing, the Civil War truce, Johnse Hatfield's affair with Roseanna McCoy, and the fatal 1882 election-day brawl. It culminates in the stabbing of Ellison Hatfield, setting up the deadlier violence to follow.

CorrectionThis set right an article from 11 days earlier.

New York Journal · 20 December 1896 · page 30

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

New York Journal · New York, N.Y.

The article retells how a fistfight between Tolbert McCoy and Ellison Hatfield escalated into a knife fight, leading to Ellison's death and the Hatfields' capture and execution of three McCoy brothers. It also recounts subsequent revenge attempts, including the wounding of Calvin McCoy and plots against Randolph McCoy.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 12 days later. CorrectionThis set right 2 earlier articles: Kansas City Daily Journal, 9 December 1896, Der Fortschritt, 10 December 1896.

Wrong

New York Journal · 20 December 1896 · page 30

Forty Coffins That Tell a

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Hartford Herald · Hartford, Ky.

Maired Hatfield, self-confessed murderer of Jonas Trail, was hanged at Sneedville, Tennessee after collapsing and being unable to stand on the scaffold. A crowd of five thousand gathered to witness the execution, which came after weeks of anticipation across the mountain region.

The Hartford Herald · 23 December 1896 · page 1

HISTORY OF HIS BRUTAL CRIME

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Hartford Herald · Hartford, Ky.

A man named Hatfield was hanged in Hancock County for the 1896 murder of Jonas Trail, a crime involving robbery and brutal violence with a female accomplice. The report recounts his trial, failed appeal, denied clemency, and notes he was said to be a descendant of the Hatfields famed for their feud with the McCoys.

The Hartford Herald · 23 December 1896 · page 1

HISTORY OF HIS BRUTAL CRIME

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Weekly Courier-Journal · Louisville, Ky.

The article mocks a New York paper for reprinting the old, repeatedly recycled tale that the feud ended with a marriage between Cap Hatfield's nephew and Rudolph McCoy's daughter. It notes this story has circulated for years and is dismissed as discredited and stale in Kentucky.

Weekly Courier-Journal · 28 December 1896 · page 10

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come