A report from raftsmen claims that 'Captain' Hatfield, a leading figure in the Hatfield-McCoy feud with a murder record second only to his brother 'Anse,' was killed in a quarrel over poker among men who had sworn friendship. The account is secondhand, relayed via raftsmen from the Tug Fork area to Louisville.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
The Morning Call · 6 April 1892 · page 1
"CAPTAIN" HATFIELD KILLED
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Providence News · Providence, R.I.
A wire dispatch claims that "Capt." Hatfield, a notorious figure in the feud second only to his brother "Anse," was shot twice through the heart and killed during a poker game gone wrong among fellow outlaws. The report states no arrests were made and suggests Anse may have been involved, also noting a $1,350 reward had been placed on Cap's head.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
The Providence News · 6 April 1892 · page 1
SHOT BY HIS OWN GANG.
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Olympia Tribune · Olympia, Wash.
Raftsmen reportedly brought news that a 'Captain Hatfield,' said to rank second only to 'Anse' in feud killings, was shot twice through the heart during a drunken poker dispute at his home. The report claims one of the Hatfield brothers, possibly Anse, and a companion named Bayson were involved, but no arrests had been made and witnesses were too terrified to identify the shooter.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
The Olympia Tribune · 6 April 1892 · page 1
KENTUCKY CIVILIZATION
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Paper unidentified
Raftsmen bring news that a 'Captain Hatfield,' said to rank second only to Anse Hatfield in feud killings, was shot dead during a drunken poker game dispute in Logan County, West Virginia. The killers are suspected to be among the Hatfield brothers themselves, with 'Anse' named as possibly involved, but no arrests have been made.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 7 days later.
Wrong
Paper unidentified · 7 April 1892 · page 2
A CAREER OF CRIME ENDED
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Seattle Post-Intelligencer · Seattle, Wash. Terr. Wash.
Raftsmen bring word that Captain Hatfield was killed during a drunken poker game gone wrong at his own house, shot twice through the heart. The report says it's unclear which Hatfield brother fired the fatal shots, though Anse's name is mentioned, and no arrests have been made.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 7 days later.
Wrong
The Seattle Post-Intelligencer · 7 April 1892 · page 3
"Cap" Hatfield, of Kentucky. Killed.
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Dalles Weekly Chronicle · the Dalles, Or. · and 1 other paper
A dispatch from Louisa, Ky. claims that Capt. Hatfield, a leading figure in the Hatfield-McCoy feud, was shot dead during a drunken poker game dispute at his home in Logan County, W. Va. The report alleges Bad Anse Hatfield was likely involved, though no arrests had been made and details remain uncertain.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 6 days later.
Wrong
The Dalles Weekly Chronicle · 8 April 1892 · page 7
A short news item reports that the Hatfield-McCoy feud has finally ended, stating that Captain Hatfield, leader of one faction, was shot and killed by members of his own gang after a quarrel. No further details or sources are given.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 6 days later.
Wrong
The Silver State · 8 April 1892 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
It is believed that the famous Hatfield-McCoy feud in Kentucky has been at last brought to an end. Captain Hatfield, the leader of one of the factions was shot and killed the other day by members of his own gang with whom he quarreled.
Passaic City Record · Passaic City, N.J. · and 2 other papers
Raftsmen reported that 'Captain' Hatfield, described as a leader in the Hatfield-McCoy feud, was killed in a quarrel over a card game among outlaws who had sworn friendship. The account came secondhand from rivermen on the Tug Fork of the Big Sandy River.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 12 days later.
Wrong
Passaic City Record · 9 April 1892 · page 7
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Also printed in 2 papers
Fisherman & Farmer · Edenton, N.C. · 15 April 1892
The Abbeville Press and Banner · Abbeville, S.C. · 20 April 1892
The World · Martinsburg, W. Va.
A dispatch relayed by the New York World claims that 'Cap' Hatfield, said to be second only to 'Bad Anse' in the feud's murder count, was killed in a quarrel over poker among outlaw associates in Logan County, West Virginia. The report details the bounties placed on Cap and other Hatfields by authorities.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 5 days later.
Wrong
The World · 9 April 1892 · page 3
"CAP" HATFIELD KILLED.
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Sun · New York, N.Y.
This article surveys eight major Kentucky feuds, including the Hatfield-McCoy feud, noting their scale, death tolls, and costs to the state. It frames the feuds as products of isolated mountain life and large family networks, contrasting past lawlessness with the state's increasingly firm legal response, exemplified by ongoing prosecutions in the Rowan County war.
The Sun · 10 April 1892 · page 25
SOME KENTUCKY FEUDS.
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Helena Independent · Helena, Mont.
The report claims outlaw Cap Hatfield was shot dead in a drunken poker game dispute at his home, allegedly by one of his own brothers possibly involving Anse Hatfield. It states no arrests have been made and that fear of the Hatfields makes it hard to determine exactly who was involved.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 3 days later.
Wrong
The Helena Independent · 11 April 1892 · page 2
CAP HATFIELD'S END.
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Helena Independent · Helena, Mont.
A brief news item reports that Cap Hatfield, described as one of the most brutal participants in the Hatfield-McCoy feud, was reportedly shot to death in a dispute over cards. The item editorializes that had he lived in Montana he would have been legally hanged years earlier.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 10 days later.
Wrong
The Helena Independent · 11 April 1892 · page 4
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The World · Martinsburg, W. Va.
A short editorial note announces the death of "pap" Hatfield, describing him as one of the mountain ruffians who ambushed the McCoys and shot them in the back. The piece declares his death a benefit to the country, Kentucky, and West Virginia.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 10 days later.
Wrong
The World · 11 April 1892 · page 2
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Western Sentinel · Winston-Salem, N.C.
A dispatch from Louisa, Ky. claims that a man known as 'Capt.' Hatfield, said to be second only to 'Anse' Hatfield in feud killings, was shot dead during a drunken poker game dispute at his own home. The report says it cannot be determined which Hatfield brother fired the fatal shots, though 'Anse's' name is mentioned, and no arrests have been made.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 7 days later.
Wrong
The Western Sentinel · 14 April 1892 · page 1
CAPTAIN HATFIELD KILLED.
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Logan County Banner · Logan, W. Va.
The Wayne County paper calls out a New York World article as a complete fabrication, which had claimed 'Cap' Hatfield was killed in a drunken poker game shootout among outlaws. The local editor states Cap Hatfield is actually alive, has been a church member, bedridden with illness for months, and notes the World even got basic facts wrong like his brother's name.
The report claims 'Capt.' Hatfield was shot twice through the heart during a drunken poker dispute with a Hatfield brother and a man named Bayson, with 'Anse' possibly involved and no arrests made. The piece ends by casting doubt on itself, suggesting it is 'the work of the Catlettsburg liar.'
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 7 days later.
Wrong
The Logan County Banner · 14 April 1892 · page 3
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Shenandoah Herald · Woodstock, Va.
Raftsmen report that a 'Captain' Hatfield, a leader in the Hatfield-McCoy feud, was killed in a poker game dispute among outlaws who had vowed friendship. The account is secondhand, relayed from the Tug Fork region of the Big Sandy River in Kentucky.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 6 days later.
Wrong
Shenandoah Herald · 15 April 1892 · page 1
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Richmond Dispatch · Richmond, Va.
A lawyer who recently traveled through the feud region reports that Cap Hatfield is alive but seriously ill with typhoid fever, contradicting earlier widely-published accounts of his violent death during a card game. The report also recounts background on the feud's origins and an attack on a disabled moonshiner, Ira Mullins.
"Cap" Hatfield Not Killed But Low with Typhoid Fever—A Moonshiner's Peril.
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Logan County Banner · Logan, W. Va.
A public notice warns against trespassing on Logan County lands owned by the Logan Coal & Timber Company, listing numerous tracts along Mate Creek, Grape Vine Creek, Tug River, and Beech Creek. Many of these parcels were previously sold to J. D. Sergeant by Anderson Hatfield, Elias Hatfield, and Valentine Hatfield between 1888 and 1890.
The Logan County Banner · 21 April 1892 · page 2
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Pocahontas Times · Huntersville, W. Va.
The article reports that outlaw 'Cap' Hatfield, second only to his brother 'Bad Anse' in the Hatfield-McCoy feud murders, was killed a few days earlier in a dispute over a poker game among fellow outlaws. It details the rewards offered for his and his relatives' capture, ranking him highest at $1,250.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 8 days later.
Wrong
Pocahontas Times · 21 April 1892 · page 3
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Paper unidentified
A Nashville dispatch claims 'Cap' Hatfield, said to rank second only to 'Anse' in murders during the feud, was shot twice through the heart and killed during a drunken poker game dispute at his home in Logan County, W. Va. The report notes it is impossible to determine which Hatfield brother was involved, despite 'stories to the contrary' already circulating.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 7 days later.
Wrong
Paper unidentified · 22 April 1892 · page 2
CAPT, HATFIELD DEAD.
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Paper unidentified
The item notes that Captain Hatfield, described as one of the 'stars' in the Hatfield-McCoy feud, has professed religion and is trying to live a better life. It frames the ongoing feud ironically as a theatrical production, calling participants 'tragedians.'
Paper unidentified · 26 April 1892 · page 1
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Busy Bee · Buckhannon, W. Va.
The report denies rumors that Cap Hatfield had been killed, claiming he is instead dying slowly from an old gunshot wound received eight years earlier. It also recounts a failed attempt by a detective named 'Wild Bill' Napper to capture Cap and other Hatfields.
The report recounts a shootout between Cap Hatfield and a man named Bill (Napper), who was wounded and cleverly hid inside a hollow log to escape pursuing Hatfields. It declares the feud over, claiming the McCoys are all dead or have fled, while the Hatfields remain entrenched and well-armed.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 36 days later.