The Indianapolis Journal · 24 February 1891 · page 7 · transcribed from the page image
A Quarrel in Which Thirty Persons Have Been Killed in as Many Years.
See moreSee less
For Two Years Neither Side Has Been on a War Footing, and It Is Hoped the Coming of Railways Will Bring Permanent Peace.
Huntington (W. Va.) Letter in New York Tribune.
Dime novelists and sensational reporters have done much mischief by magnifying the bloody exploits on these borders of a few fighting families. In adjusting their little domestic difficulties, the Hatfields and McCoys have killed about thirty people and maimed and wounded as many more. The Adamses and Bromfields, and the Blaisders and Brewers have tried to imitate them, though on an unpretentious scale. But their crimes have been made a reproach to the whole population. Between the Guyandotte and the Big Sandy lie some of the finest hard-wood lands on the continent. Walnut grows nearly six feet thick, and there are noble poplars as tall and straight as church spires. The soil is spread over great sheets of coal, and the rivers afford good highways for commerce. Yet progress has been retarded and strangers frightened away by false charges of border ruffianism against worthy and peaceable communities.
The Hatfield and McCoy feud dates from the civil war. The Hatfields, who live in West Virginia, were in the confederate army. The McCoys, in Kentucky, organized as "home guards" for the protection of Northern sympathizers. In the hostilities the Hatfields and their friends killed some of the McCoys, and there has been bad blood between them ever since. The first notable outbreak, however, was only about ten years ago, when Ellison Hatfield was murdered in an election brawl on the Kentucky side of the Tug fork of the Big Sandy river. His assailants, three McCoy boys, were seized by the Hatfields, tied to poplar bushes and riddled with bullets. The McCoys then began a series of raids into West Virginia, and succeeded in landing several of the Hatfields in Kentucky jails. In retaliation, "Jim" Vance and a gang of Hatfield sympathizers crossed into Kentucky one New Year's night, burned the McCoy house and shot one of the McCoys as he fled. Among the inmates were several women and children, who were driven out in their night-dresses. Alafray McCoy, the eldest daughter, was slain on the spot by a half-witted fellow named Mountz, who was afterward hanged in Kentucky. Meantime the Governors of the two States issued requisitions and offered rewards, and a swarm of detectives helped to make mischief. Vance, who was with the Hatfields in the confederate service, was finally killed one afternoon by the McCoys, who are said to have shaken hands over his dead body. Since then the Hatfields have moved back into the country from Tug river, the McCoys have done the same on the Kentucky side, and a truce has been called.
CHARACTER OF THE COMBATANTS.
This feud has never included more than the Hatfields and their immediate relatives, a few desperadoes in hiding in the mountains and some almost equally lawless detectives. The fighting has not spread beyond the banks of the Big Sandy, where the Hatfields have been hunting and raising corn since their ancestors came from the Valley of Virginia one-hundred years ago. Their neighbors are rude and sturdy backwoodsmen, narrowed by continual intermarriage and the lack of railroads, but without any passion for bloodshed. When the Tollivars were disporting themselves in Kentucky a few years ago a band of "Regulators" restored order by removing their chief, and if this affair had been confined to one State the leaders would have suffered long ago, but the situation is peculiar. The Hatfields at home are quiet and well behaved. Their excesses have all been committed on the Kentucky side, while in West Virginia the McCoys are the aggressors. Consequently the requisitions for arrest have always come from another State, and many innocent people have been indicted. Now, nobody cares to give up his friends to outsiders, with the chance of seeing them unjustly condemned, and this reluctance has shielded the true culprits. It is strenuously denied that the Hatfields terrorize their neighbors. Yet, instead of their meeting with open condemnation, the Governor has been asked to protect them. They are condoled with over the kidnaping of their allies; men slap them on the back and exchange jokes with them, as though murder were a humane and polite diversion, and they ride into town with their rifles slung over their shoulders and bargain in the stores and buy and sell bank stock like so many thrifty deacons. The disposition to regard them as a sort of cross between John Howard and Michael the Archangel, and the McCoys as a depraved combination of Judas Iscariot and Billy the Kid, is, however, dying out. It is seen that both sides are to blame, and some people are not afraid to say so.
The administration of the local courts in the past has not been what it should be. A single fearless editor or preacher could probably have stopped the trouble long ago. But the local sheets are timid, and at church the belligerents stack their arms and pray with one eye on the pastor and another on the door. Some of the magistrates to save expenses have actually hesitated to imprison criminals. The present circuit judge, however, will not be trifled with. At every term there is a string of convictions for carrying concealed weapons, and he inflicts in all cases the full penalty of fine and imprisonment without regard to anybody's brag or threats. The recent withdrawal of all rewards by the Governors of the two States seems to have worked well. Nobody has fallen in the fued for nearly two years, and the survivors are trying to live decently. "Cap" Hatfield, the son of "Bad Anse," is heartily sick of the vendetta, and realizes that under other circumstances he might have been something better than an outlaw. He taught himself to read and write, and for a man brought up in the mountains, is credited with a "right smart of business sense." He has read much history and "got in some pretty good snatches on medicine," and just now is wrestling with a borrowed law-book. He married the widow of a man killed in ambush, outside of the feud, and has a pretty daughter. It is due to his adroit management that the Hatfields have not been surrendered. His father, "Bad Anse" or "Devil Anse," as he is affectionally nicknamed, is the present Hatfield patriarch. He, too, is tired of sleeping on a Winchester, is declared to be inoffensive when no McCoys are about, and says he is willing to let the whole thing drop if they are. As an earnest, both men are laying down their rifles, though they wear a few revolvers "for protection," and the father has subscribed toward the building fund of a new Methodist church. The women, although "raised to it," are unconquerably averse to sudden bereavement. Vance's widow boasts that she can "bring down a squirrel from the highest treetop, every pop," but most of them shine better as house-keepers. Alafray McCoy was a religious woman, and when Mountz threatened her said she had prayed for her enemies for years.
THE RAILWAY AS A PEACE-MAKER.
The combatants now live thirty miles apart, and the railroad that will soon separate them will probably do more to promote peace than a dozen proclamations. In the border counties the hills are high, the forests thick, and the rivers swift and deep. There are no turnpikes and no telegraphs, and the sheriffs have to ride on horseback over blind trails and to ford dangerous currents. A train service will alter all that. By next summer the railroad, a branch of the Norfolk & Western, will be finished but for the piercing of a long tunnel. The inhabitants, in anticipation of fresh prosperity, are anxious to efface the stain fastened on them. "Of course," they say, "we have our faults, but we are as good as most backwoods communities. There has been only one arrest for theft in Logan county, and the charge was not proved. We have no locks on our doors, except at a few of the stores, and the keys of those are lost. The chickens roost on the fences and the apple trees, and are they ever stolen? The coverlets that our women weave are stored in our porches. The hams we cure hang outside in rows. Our corn-cribs are open to everybody, and are they ever pilfered? If you want to know what hospitality means, ride over and see us. You'd be safer with a pocketful of greenbacks in Logan county than in walking up and down Broadway in New York city. As to our intelligence, of course we have no Browning societies and circulating libraries. But we follow the news and get journals from New York and Cincinnati. We have two pretty good hotels. Next spring we shall have a bank, and we're building a stone church. Our children get four months' schooling. Several of our people are worth $50,000, and all of us keep the run of politics."
I have asked many of the best men who are trying to reform the district what guarantee they offer to strangers. Their reply is substantially: "Don't encourage people to come here who can't put up with a rough country and rough ways. Don't tell them we are models of virtue, or that our notions of social intercourse are all sound. But do say that we are not all cut-throats and thieves. Say that the feuds are strictly family affairs, and that neutrals are unmolested. We are not fond of swaggering and flourishing fire-arms, and the man who has killed the greatest number of people isn't the most looked up to. If we don't refuse to associate with the Hatfields, it isn't because we think they have done right. What we need is somebody to persuade us that the greatest virtue is not in being peaceable only when let alone. When we have learned that, you can trust us to behave."