As the Papers Told It

The Hatfields and the McCoys · The full archive

April 1891

37 articles

Arizona Weekly Journal-Miner · Prescott, Ariz.

Captain Hatfield, a leader of the West Virginia faction, declares the twenty-year Hatfield-McCoy feud over through a general amnesty. His public letter expresses weariness with the conflict and a desire for peace, citing the loss of life and property.

Arizona Weekly Journal-Miner · 1 April 1891 · page 2

Hatfield-McCoy Feud

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Columbus Journal · Columbus, Neb.

A letter from Capt. Anse Hatfield to the Wayne News announces a general amnesty in the Hatfield-McCoy feud, prompted by the marriage of a Hatfield to a McCoy and a subsequent peace congress. The report claims the feud began in 1873 and has caused at least 100 deaths among participants.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 2 days later. CorrectionThis set right an article from 4 days earlier.

Wrong

The Columbus Journal · 1 April 1891 · page 1

HYMEN'S PEACE.

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Pittsburg Dispatch · Pittsburg, Pa.

The item is a miscellaneous editorial column touching on various topics, including a brief aside noting that the McCoy-Hatfield feud had been 'made up' (resolved), used as a comparison to the ongoing political feud between the New York Sun and an ex-President. It is not a direct report on the feud itself but a passing cultural reference.

Pittsburg Dispatch · 1 April 1891 · page 4

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Staunton Spectator · Staunton, Va.

The report compares the Hatfield-McCoy feud to Scottish clan wars, claiming it began thirty years ago over a marriage dispute and has cost some two hundred lives. It announces the feud is now ending with another marriage between the families.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 2 days later.

Wrong

Staunton Spectator · 1 April 1891 · page 1

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Staunton Spectator · Staunton, Va.

The report traces the Hatfield-McCoy feud's origin to a Hatfield killing a McCoy who had married a girl betrothed to the Hatfield, claiming some two hundred lives have been lost in the ensuing war between Kentucky and West Virginia. It announces an upcoming wedding between Aaron Hatfield and a McCoy daughter, intended to formally end the feud via a barbecue gathering, with Cap Hatfield declaring a general amnesty.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 2 days later.

Wrong

Staunton Spectator · 1 April 1891 · page 1

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Mexico Weekly Ledger · Mexico, Mo.

A local news item claims the Hatfield and McCoy families have settled their differences, with an upcoming marriage planned between a young man and woman from the two rival houses. The item notes fears had been widespread that the feud would otherwise end in disaster.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 2 days later.

Wrong

Mexico Weekly Ledger · 2 April 1891 · page 1

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Fergus County Argus · Lewistown, Mont.

The item reports that amnesty was declared between the Hatfield and McCoy clans of Kentucky, supposedly brought about by the marriage of a McCoy to a Hatfield. It closes with a jokey aside urging Kentuckians to propose more and shoot less.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 2 days later.

Wrong

Fergus County Argus · 2 April 1891 · page 2

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Passaic City Record · Passaic City, N.J.

A short news item among miscellaneous world notes claims the long-running Hatfield-McCoy feud in West Virginia is about to be settled through a marriage between the families. No names or details are given.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 2 days later.

Wrong

Passaic City Record · 2 April 1891 · page 1

NEWSY GLEANINGS.

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Sturgis Advertiser · Sturgis, S.D. · and 1 other paper

Devil Anse Hatfield writes to a newspaper declaring a general amnesty and the end of the feud, attributing the peace to a marriage between a Hatfield and a McCoy. The report claims the feud began in 1873 and has caused about 100 deaths.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day. CorrectionThis set right an article from 2 days earlier.

Wrong

Sturgis Advertiser · 2 April 1891 · page 2

HYMEN'S PEACE.

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Also printed in 1 paper
  • Wessington Springs Herald · Wessington Springs, S.D. · 3 April 1891

Brenham Weekly Banner · Brenham, Tex.

The item reports that the long and bloody Hatfield-McCoy feud of Kentucky, which claimed over a hundred lives, has finally ended. It credits the reconciliation to the love and marriage of two members from opposing sides, succeeding where legal efforts had failed.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 2 days later.

Wrong

Brenham Weekly Banner · 2 April 1891 · page 4

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Ocala Banner · Ocala, Fla.

A short filler item states that a marriage intended to end the Hatfield-McCoy feud did not fail. It offers no names or details about which marriage is meant.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 6 days later.

Wrong

The Ocala Banner · 3 April 1891 · page 2

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Iola Register · Iola, Kansas

The article claims that after a twenty-year feud and the killing of one hundred men, the McCoys and Hatfields have made peace because a Miss McCoy married one of the Hatfield boys. It frames this romantically as 'Cupid disarming Mars.'

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 6 days later.

Wrong

The Iola Register · 3 April 1891 · page 6

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

In the story →

Springfield Weekly Republican · Springfield, Mass.

The article declares the Hatfield-McCoy feud over, citing a planned marriage between the families and a letter from Cap Hatfield announcing amnesty. It also claims the popular death toll of 200 is exaggerated, estimating the true number closer to 30.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 6 days later. CorrectionThis set right 3 earlier articles: The Columbus Journal, 1 April 1891, Staunton Spectator, 1 April 1891, Staunton Spectator, 1 April 1891.

Wrong

Springfield Weekly Republican · 3 April 1891 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

PEACE DECLARED ON THE BIG SANDY.

The greatest of American vendettas is at an end, for the Hatfields and McCoys have agreed to fight no more. Rumors of an impending settlement of this famous feud have been spread abroad of late, but have found little acceptance by a public that has been reading for years of sudden bereavements on the banks of the Big Sandy river. But there is no cause for further incredulity. The approaching marriage of the most beautiful and accomplished daughter of the house of McCoy to the most available youth with a whole skin remaining on the Hatfield side was announced several days ago. A monster barbecue will follow the wedding ceremony in a Wayne county (W. Va.) poplar grove, and it will be attended by all the Hatfields and McCoys alive. Such an event alone is sufficient to silence the most skeptical. As if to make doubly sure, however, "Cap" Hatfield, son of the old leader, "Devil 'Anse,' writes the following lines to the Wayne County News, under date of February 24:—

See moreSee less

I ask space in your valuable paper for these few lines. A general amnesty has been declared in the famous Hatfield-McCoy feud, and I wish to say something of the old and the new. I do not wish to keep the old feud alive, and I suppose that everybody, like myself, is tired of the names "Hatfield" and "McCoy," and the words "border warfare" in time of peace. The war spirit in me has abated, and I sincerely rejoice at the prospect of peace. I have devoted my life to arms. We have undergone a fearful loss of noble lives and valuable property in the struggle. Now I propose to rest in a spirit of peace.

The Hatfield-McCoy feud, which has made Wayne county in West Virginia and Pike county in Kentucky bloody ground for 30 years, had its rise in the hostilities of the civil war. Since then, according to the popular impression, some 200 lives have been sacrificed in family warfare; yet that impression is an exggerated one. Probably from first to last the list of dead does not number more than 30 people, although as many more have been wounded and much property has been burned or destroyed on both sides. The Hatfields, who for 100 years have lived. on the banks of the Big Sandy river on the West Virginia side, gave their support to the confederate cause; while the McCoys on the Kentucky side organized in defense of the North. During the war numerous McCoys were sacrificed by sundry Hatfields, and the McCoys could not forgive or forget even after the surrender at Appomattox. The McCoys waited until about 10 years ago for their blood revenge, and then one day three McCoy boys murdered Ellison Hatfield in an election brawl on the Kentucky side of the Tug fork of the Big Sandy. The Hatfields soon retaliated by tying those three McCoys to poplar trees and filling them with lead. Then the McCoys inaugurated a series of raids into West Virginia territory, which resulted in the incarceration of a lot of Hatfields in Kentucky jails. In retaliation for these outrages a band of Hatfields with their Logan county sympathizers, led by the notorious "Jim" Vance, crossed into Kentucky one New-year's night and burned the McCoy mansion to the ground, turning the inmates, men, women and children, out of doors without other covering than their night clothes. One McCoy was shot on this occasion and Alafray McCoy, the eldest daughter, was killed by a half-witted hanger-on in the Hatfield camp. The McCoys afterward hunted down "Jim" Vance and are said to have gravely shaken hands over his dead body.

These murderous deeds, of which the few herein mentioned were the most conspicuous, reached their culmination in a state of actual warfare about four years ago. The governors of the two states have issued requisitions without number; they have offered rewards for the capture of the outlaws, and many a sheriff has attempted to make a Hatfield or a McCoy his prize, but without much success. As each side did their butchering upon the soil of another state, the processes of law have been slow and uncertain. Moreover, each house in its own community has been as orderly and well-governed as any family in the county. Only at the objects of his hatred across the line has a McCoy or a Hatfield raised his rifle or aimed a blow. And thus the community surrounding each house has protected its members from the punishment of their atrocious deeds. The law has been baffled at almost every point, and the truth is that the cure has finally worked itself. The antagonists have heard from the outside world and have grown ashamed of themselves. For nearly two years past a truce has been maintained, and the withdrawal of the rewards for their capture seems to have stimulated the settlement that has come. The two families some time ago moved further back into their respective states, so that today 30 miles separate the trajectories of their rifles. "Cap" Hatfield is considerable of a man at bottom, and has managed to acquire a book education that is uncommon in those parts. "Cap" long since grew tired of sleeping on his rifle. And then, not long ago, old "Devil Anse," the Hatfield patriarch, joined the Methodist church. That was more than the feud could stand. It went to pieces like a string of beads suddenly left stringless. It will never rise again in the old form, because the iron horse, a great civilizer, is already snorting in the wilderness that lies about the Big Sandy river.

The civilization of Logan and Pike counties has been made to suffer more than it deserved because of this vendetta. Although, as in all backwoods communities, human life has not been held at its real value, in other respects the very extreme of virtue has been reached. In Logan county there has been recorded, it is said, but one case of theft and then the charge was not proved. A resident has said:—

We have no locks on our doors, except a few of the stores, and the keys of those are lost. The chickens roost on the fences and the apple-trees, and are they ever stolen? The coverlets that our women weave are stored in our porches. The hams we cure hang outside in rows. Our corn-cribs are open to everybody, and are they pilfered? If you want to know what hospitality means, ride over and see us. You'd be safer with a pocketful of greenbacks in Logan county than walking up and down Broadway in New York city.

The regret will be felt in contemplating the new civilization that is coming into that primitive community, that in the uplifting process extreme virtues as well as extreme vices will undergo modification. The slaughter of men and women will cease, but the days when chickens can roost upon the fences with impunity are numbered. Thievery will increase in Logan county, but on the whole the change will be for the better.

See the clipping

Springfield Weekly Republican · Springfield, Mass.

The article summarizes the thirty-year Hatfield-McCoy feud's origins in Civil War loyalties, recounting the Ellison Hatfield killing, the retaliatory execution of three McCoy brothers, and the New Year's raid burning the McCoy home. It notes that popular death tolls of 200 are exaggerated, estimating the true count closer to 30, and reports that peace has now been declared.

CorrectionThis set right an article from the day before.

Springfield Weekly Republican · 3 April 1891 · page 3

PEACE DECLARED ON THE BIG SANDY.

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Springfield Weekly Republican · Springfield, Mass.

A long retrospective piece recaps the feud's worst violence—the New Year's raid, the killing of Alifair McCoy, and the hunting down of Jim Vance—and claims a two-year truce has now effectively ended the vendetta. It credits 'Devil Anse' Hatfield's conversion to Methodism and the coming of the railroad as civilizing forces that finally broke the feud's hold.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 6 days later.

Wrong

Springfield Weekly Republican · 3 April 1891 · page 3

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Hope Pioneer · Hope, N.D. · and 1 other paper

The item reports that if 'Cap' Hatfield keeps his promise, the long-running feud between the Hatfields and McCoys will end in a wedding, just as it allegedly began with one. It states Aaron Hatfield is to marry a McCoy woman in early May as the occasion for a general reconciliation.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

The Hope Pioneer · 3 April 1891 · page 2

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Also printed in 1 paper
  • The Cape Girardeau Democrat · Cape Girardeau, Mo. · 4 April 1891

Paper unidentified

A short filler item reports that the long-running Hatfield-McCoy feud has once again been declared ended. The writer adds a hopeful aside that this time the peace will actually hold.

Paper unidentified · 3 April 1891 · page 2

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Shepherdstown Register · Shepherdstown, Va. W. Va.

The item reports that a Hatfield woman and a McCoy man are soon to marry, supposedly bridging the gulf between the two families. It declares that peace now reigns along the Big Sandy River.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 6 days later.

Wrong

Shepherdstown Register · 3 April 1891 · page 2

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Waterbury Evening Democrat · Waterbury, Conn.

The piece reflects on newspaper commentary praising a marriage that supposedly settled the Hatfield-McCoy feud in West Virginia, comparing young lovers from the feuding clans to Romeo and Juliet. It claims the feud produced 200 murders, including the shooting of an entire wedding party in a church.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 5 days later.

Wrong

Waterbury Evening Democrat · 4 April 1891 · page 2

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Morning Call · San Francisco, Calif.

A traveling salesman, Alexander Sharpnack, tells a reporter that the famous Hatfield-McCoy feud was invented by journalist Julian Ralph, who allegedly 'faked' a story out of a single reported murder, sparking a sensationalized newspaper rivalry. He claims the region is actually peaceful and the families have been unjustly maligned by this journalistic invention.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 5 days later. CorrectionThis set right 5 earlier articles: Mexico Weekly Ledger, 2 April 1891, Fergus County Argus, 2 April 1891, Passaic City Record, 2 April 1891, Brenham Weekly Banner, 2 April 1891, The Hope Pioneer, 3 April 1891.

Wrong

The Morning Call · 4 April 1891 · page 8

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Baxter Springs News · Baxter Springs, Kan.

The item claims that after a twenty-year feud and the killing of one hundred men, the McCoys and Hatfields have made peace following the marriage of a McCoy daughter to a Hatfield son. It frames this as love overcoming decades of violence.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 5 days later.

Wrong

Baxter Springs News · 4 April 1891 · page 2

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Kansas Agitator · Garnett, Kan.

The report claims that after twenty years and the deaths of one hundred men, the McCoys and Hatfields have made peace, attributing the reconciliation to the marriage of a McCoy daughter to a Hatfield son. It frames the end of the feud as a romantic resolution, with Cupid disarming Mars.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 2 days later.

Wrong

Kansas Agitator · 7 April 1891 · page 2

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Connecticut Western News · Salisbury, Conn.

A short filler item claims the 17-year-old Hatfield-McCoy feud, which began over a sow, has ended through a marriage and has caused 100 deaths. It appears amid a column of miscellaneous trivia and anecdotes.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

Connecticut Western News · 8 April 1891 · page 4

FROM VARIOUS SOURCES.

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Worthington Advance · Worthington, Minn.

The article claims that Cap Hatfield's promise and the upcoming marriage of Aaron Hatfield to a McCoy woman will bring a final reconciliation to the long-running feud between the two families, which began in the early 1860s with a wedding. It frames the conflict in dramatic terms, comparing it to the Montagues and Capulets and Corsican vendettas.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 11 days later.

Wrong

The Worthington Advance · 9 April 1891 · page 2

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Hand County Press · Miller, S.D.

The item claims the long-running Hatfield-McCoy feud, likened to the Montagues and Capulets, began with a wedding and will end with one when Aaron Hatfield marries a McCoy woman in May. It frames 'Cap' Hatfield's promise as the key to a final reconciliation between the families.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 11 days later.

Wrong

Hand County Press · 9 April 1891 · page 2

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

West Virginia Argus · Kingwood, W. Va.

A letter from Captain Hatfield of Logan County, West Virginia, announces that a general amnesty has been declared in the Hatfield-McCoy feud. He expresses weariness with the conflict and a desire for peace after great loss of life and property.

West Virginia Argus · 9 April 1891 · page 2

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Logan County Banner · Logan, W. Va.

The paper reports that romanticized stories of love and reconciliation between the Hatfields and McCoys, circulating in papers statewide, are a hoax. It notes the families have lived peacefully apart for two years, with no recent trouble, and that detectives who tried to stir up renewed conflict failed.

CorrectionThis set right 10 earlier articles: The Ocala Banner, 3 April 1891, The Iola Register, 3 April 1891, Springfield Weekly Republican, 3 April 1891, Springfield Weekly Republican, 3 April 1891, Shepherdstown Register, 3 April 1891, Waterbury Evening Democrat, 4 April 1891, The Morning Call, 4 April 1891, Baxter Springs News, 4 April 1891, Kansas Agitator, 7 April 1891, Connecticut Western News, 8 April 1891.

The Logan County Banner · 9 April 1891 · page 3

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Corvallis Gazette · Corvallis, Or.

A short filler item reports that the expected spring round of violence in the Hatfield-McCoy feud has been called off for now. It offers no further detail or explanation.

The Corvallis Gazette · 10 April 1891 · page 2

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Lebanon Express · Lebanon, Or.

The report states that Cap Hatfield has announced the Hatfield-McCoy feud, said to have lasted thirty years and cost 200 lives in Wayne County, W. Va., is now at an end. This brief item appears among a list of unrelated news paragraphs.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 10 days later.

Wrong

The Lebanon Express · 10 April 1891 · page 1

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Busy Bee · Buckhannon, W. Va.

The item states that the famous Hatfield-McCoy feud is over, based on a letter from Capt. Hatfield published in the Wayne News. It offers no further detail on the letter's contents or the reasons for the supposed reconciliation.

Busy Bee · 10 April 1891 · page 3

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Silver State · Unionville, Nev.

This miscellany column of local Nevada news notes that 'The Hatfield-McCoy Combination' will soon perform a new drama called 'At Outs Again.' The mention shows the feud had already become fodder for popular theatrical entertainment far from Kentucky and West Virginia.

The Silver State · 14 April 1891 · page 3

BREVITIES.

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Wheeling Register · Wheeling, W. Va.

The Logan County Banner newspaper dismisses widely circulated romantic stories of love and marriage reconciling the Hatfields and McCoys as a fabricated joke. It states both families have lived peacefully and separately for two years with no contact, contradicting the sensationalized accounts being printed elsewhere.

CorrectionThis set right 3 earlier articles: The Worthington Advance, 9 April 1891, Hand County Press, 9 April 1891, The Lebanon Express, 10 April 1891.

Wheeling Register · 20 April 1891 · page 4

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Logan County Banner · Logan, W. Va.

A notice lists numerous tracts of land on Tug River, Beech Creek, Mate Creek, and Grapevine purchased from various parties including members of the Hatfield family, warning against trespass. The surrounding page consists of unrelated business advertisements for hotels, banks, and grocers in West Virginia.

The Logan County Banner · 23 April 1891 · page 3

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Evening Journal · Wilmington, Del.

The item reports that a son of the Hatfields was to marry a daughter of the McCoys the next day, framing it as a new way of carrying on the famous feud. It treats the planned wedding as an actual, imminent event ending hostilities.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 9 days later.

Wrong

Evening Journal · 27 April 1891 · page 2

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Daily Tobacco Leaf-Chronicle · Clarksville, Tenn.

Logan County sources deny reports of a marriage alliance and settlement between the Hatfield and McCoy families. They say the families are living peacefully apart, but tension remains since the leaders have avoided each other for two years.

Daily Tobacco Leaf-Chronicle · 27 April 1891 · page 1

HATFIELDS AND McCOYS YET OUT.

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Wheeling Register · Wheeling, W. Va.

The article speculates whether the Hatfield-McCoy feud has truly ended, noting that historically such feuds only end when one family is wiped out. It illustrates this with the story of the Morton-Cummins feud in Texas, which ended when the last two survivors agreed to stop fighting.

Wheeling Register · 28 April 1891 · page 2

THE END OF A FEUD

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Brookhaven Leader · Brookhaven, Miss.

A brief notice claims that a marriage between the two feuding families successfully ended the Hatfield-McCoy feud. It is presented as good news amid a roundup of miscellaneous marriage-related items.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 6 days later.

Wrong

The Brookhaven Leader · 30 April 1891 · page 4

A WOMAN IN IT.

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come