An old editor remembers it wrong
A former Tombstone city editor, writing seven years on, makes the Earps ‘the recognized chiefs of the stage-robber faction,’ puts Frank Stilwell among the dead in the corral fight, and has Warren Earp shot at a faro table. The papers had reported Stilwell killed at Tucson, and Warren lived until 1900.
Barbour County Index · Medicine Lodge, Kan. · and 7 other papers
Barbour County Index · 14 March 1888 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
SOME BORDER TALES.
Reminiscences of the Rustlers Who Once Made Tombstone Famous.
See moreSee less
According to a writer in the St. Louis Republican, Tombstone, a mining center in Southeastern Arizona, is the grave of more romance and adventure, hairbreadth escapes and deeds of daring than any other region in America perhaps. Tombstone is about sixteen miles from the Mexican boundary line, and for four or five years was the headquarters of all the leading desperadoes of the West. The four Earp brothers, toughs all, Doc Halliday, Frank and Jack Stillwell, Ike Clanton and his brother Billy, Jack McLowry and his brother Bob, Jack Ringo, Bill Dodge and several gentlemen known as Curly, Slim, Shorty, Texas, Buffalo and similar cognomens were frequently seen on the streets together. All had a reputation to sustain, and some were so eager to do themselves justice that they would not rely on the ordinary 44-caliber revolver, but had the barrels of shotguns cut off to about a foot in length, and thus abbreviated, that terrible engine of destruction, when properly loaded, became a part of their personal adornment. There were two factions in Southeastern Arizona in 1879, one being known as the stage-robbers and the other as the rustlers. The Earps and Doc Halliday were the recognized chiefs of the stage-robber faction, and Ike Clanton and Jack Ringo were the acknowledged bosses of the rustlers. The factions came into frequent conflict. One day the McLowrys and Frank Stillwell rode into town and put up their horses at a corral on Fremont street. Just as they emerged from the corral the Earps and Halliday confronted them, and in a minute the two McLowrys, Billy Clanton and Stillwell were dead. Word was sent to their friends, who were camped in the Huachua mountains, and they prepared to march to Tombstone in force to clean out the Earps. The Earps recruited and fortified in an adobe building in the west end of the town. The rustlers, thirty strong, under command of Ike Clanton and Jack Ringo, marched to town and took up headquarters in a corral at the extreme end of the town. Here were the honest people of Tombstone between the hostile camps of desperadoes, but Tombstone went right along about its business, and rather enjoyed the sensation. The saloons and gambling-houses did a thriving business twenty-four hours daily. The banks were open, and in the evenings four churches were jammed with devotees. The mines were operated by three thousand hard workmen and more than one thousand men and three hundred mules were engaged hauling ore from the mines to the reduction mills at Contention, eight miles distant. The stores were all open, the clerks all busy, and the only nervous people seemingly in the city were the reporters of the two morning papers, and they were only afraid of a scoop. The writer of this was the city editor of a Tombstone paper at the time, and he visited both the camps daily, and was made the medium of communication between the leaders. The rustlers circulated through the town, and the Earp, or stage-robber faction, confined themselves to their camp. Ike Clanton, the rustler leader, sent several messages to Wyatt Earp, the leader of that faction, daring him to come out and show his nose. Earp sent back invitations to Clanton to come and visit him. This thing continued for three days, and at last the Earps began to get tired—in fact, their liquor was exhausted and they were on the verge of a thirst famine. Warren Earp, one of the brothers, heeled himself properly with two revolvers and a shot-gun and walked up-town one evening about eight o'clock. He went into a saloon, took a drink at the bar and walked back to the faro department in the rear. He hadn't bucked the tiger in five days, and his appetite was whetted. He sat down in front of the dealer, pulled out a handful of twenty-dollar gold pieces and coppered the queen. Just as he did so a report was heard and Warren Earp fell off his stool dead. A bullet had penetrated his brain. When the report of his death reached his friends they rallied out in force. They were met by the Clanton party on Allen street and an exchange of shots took place. The casualties were meager—only three killed and two wounded. The Earps retreated and skipped the town. When they had left, and there was no hope of catching them, the sheriff of Cochise County became energetic. He organized posses to give pursuit that subsequently cost the tax-payers of the county seven thousand dollars. The Earps being absent, sympathy, of course, was against them, and they went to Colorado, where they remained for some time, and then went to California. The rustlers then had supreme command of the tough element of Tombstone, and they held it until the leaders quarreled and gradually killed each other.