As the Papers Told It

Wyatt Earp · As the Papers Told It

Act Five

Gun Fighter, Referee, Wanderer

March 1888 – July 1911

After Tombstone the papers keep finding him: as a chief of the ‘stage-robber faction’ in an old editor’s memoirs, as the referee who gave Sharkey the fight against Fitzsimmons and was called ‘one of those despicable assassins’ for it, as a saloon-keeper in Nome and Tonopah, and in 1911 as a man locked up in Los Angeles over a fake faro game. An old sheriff writes in to set the record straight, Warren Earp is shot dead at Willcox, and Virgil dies of pneumonia.

An old editor remembers it wrong

A former Tombstone city editor, writing seven years on, makes the Earps ‘the recognized chiefs of the stage-robber faction,’ puts Frank Stilwell among the dead in the corral fight, and has Warren Earp shot at a faro table. The papers had reported Stilwell killed at Tucson, and Warren lived until 1900.

Barbour County Index · Medicine Lodge, Kan. · and 7 other papers

Barbour County Index · 14 March 1888 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

SOME BORDER TALES.

Reminiscences of the Rustlers Who Once Made Tombstone Famous.

See moreSee less

According to a writer in the St. Louis Republican, Tombstone, a mining center in Southeastern Arizona, is the grave of more romance and adventure, hairbreadth escapes and deeds of daring than any other region in America perhaps. Tombstone is about sixteen miles from the Mexican boundary line, and for four or five years was the headquarters of all the leading desperadoes of the West. The four Earp brothers, toughs all, Doc Halliday, Frank and Jack Stillwell, Ike Clanton and his brother Billy, Jack McLowry and his brother Bob, Jack Ringo, Bill Dodge and several gentlemen known as Curly, Slim, Shorty, Texas, Buffalo and similar cognomens were frequently seen on the streets together. All had a reputation to sustain, and some were so eager to do themselves justice that they would not rely on the ordinary 44-caliber revolver, but had the barrels of shotguns cut off to about a foot in length, and thus abbreviated, that terrible engine of destruction, when properly loaded, became a part of their personal adornment. There were two factions in Southeastern Arizona in 1879, one being known as the stage-robbers and the other as the rustlers. The Earps and Doc Halliday were the recognized chiefs of the stage-robber faction, and Ike Clanton and Jack Ringo were the acknowledged bosses of the rustlers. The factions came into frequent conflict. One day the McLowrys and Frank Stillwell rode into town and put up their horses at a corral on Fremont street. Just as they emerged from the corral the Earps and Halliday confronted them, and in a minute the two McLowrys, Billy Clanton and Stillwell were dead. Word was sent to their friends, who were camped in the Huachua mountains, and they prepared to march to Tombstone in force to clean out the Earps. The Earps recruited and fortified in an adobe building in the west end of the town. The rustlers, thirty strong, under command of Ike Clanton and Jack Ringo, marched to town and took up headquarters in a corral at the extreme end of the town. Here were the honest people of Tombstone between the hostile camps of desperadoes, but Tombstone went right along about its business, and rather enjoyed the sensation. The saloons and gambling-houses did a thriving business twenty-four hours daily. The banks were open, and in the evenings four churches were jammed with devotees. The mines were operated by three thousand hard workmen and more than one thousand men and three hundred mules were engaged hauling ore from the mines to the reduction mills at Contention, eight miles distant. The stores were all open, the clerks all busy, and the only nervous people seemingly in the city were the reporters of the two morning papers, and they were only afraid of a scoop. The writer of this was the city editor of a Tombstone paper at the time, and he visited both the camps daily, and was made the medium of communication between the leaders. The rustlers circulated through the town, and the Earp, or stage-robber faction, confined themselves to their camp. Ike Clanton, the rustler leader, sent several messages to Wyatt Earp, the leader of that faction, daring him to come out and show his nose. Earp sent back invitations to Clanton to come and visit him. This thing continued for three days, and at last the Earps began to get tired—in fact, their liquor was exhausted and they were on the verge of a thirst famine. Warren Earp, one of the brothers, heeled himself properly with two revolvers and a shot-gun and walked up-town one evening about eight o'clock. He went into a saloon, took a drink at the bar and walked back to the faro department in the rear. He hadn't bucked the tiger in five days, and his appetite was whetted. He sat down in front of the dealer, pulled out a handful of twenty-dollar gold pieces and coppered the queen. Just as he did so a report was heard and Warren Earp fell off his stool dead. A bullet had penetrated his brain. When the report of his death reached his friends they rallied out in force. They were met by the Clanton party on Allen street and an exchange of shots took place. The casualties were meager—only three killed and two wounded. The Earps retreated and skipped the town. When they had left, and there was no hope of catching them, the sheriff of Cochise County became energetic. He organized posses to give pursuit that subsequently cost the tax-payers of the county seven thousand dollars. The Earps being absent, sympathy, of course, was against them, and they went to Colorado, where they remained for some time, and then went to California. The rustlers then had supreme command of the tough element of Tombstone, and they held it until the leaders quarreled and gradually killed each other.

See the clipping

Referee Earp gives Sharkey the fight

In San Francisco ‘Referee Wyatt E. Earp’ awards the fight to Sharkey on a foul and hands him a certified check for the purse, while Fitzsimmons’s backers talk of stopping it at the bank. Witnesses say ‘a foul blow was undoubtedly delivered, but many believe it was accidental.’

Evening Star · Washington, D.C. · and 1 other paper

Evening Star · 3 December 1896 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

SHARKEY GIVEN THE PURSE.

Fitzsimmons Men Talk of Enjoining Payment.

See moreSee less

SAN FRANCISCO, December 3.--A certified check for the amount of the purse was given to Sharkey by Referee Wyatt E. Earp for the fight last night. Some of Fitzsimmons' backers talk of enjoining the bank from paying the check, but it is not believed such action, if taken, would cause the bank to withhold payment to Sharkey.

It is claimed as the check was certified the bank has no option but to pay its holder. It is also declared that the decision of the referee is final, and no appeal to the courts is probable.

Physicians and newspaper men who participated in or witnessed the examination of Sharkey, after he was carried from the ring, say he was visibly wounded below the belt. Doctors say his condition is serious, but not dangerous, and have ordered him to remain in bed at least two or three days, stating that exercise, or any movement might aggravate his injuries.

Sharkey was seen in bed at this hotel this morning. He was resting easily, though suffering some pain and inconvenience.

Witnesses of the fight declared this morning that a foul blow was undoubtedly delivered, but many believe it was accidental.

See the clipping

‘A secure prison’ for the referee

The New-York Tribune is blunt: ‘Wyatt Earp stole the Sharkey fight from Fitzsimmons.’ He is one of ‘those despicable assassins who are called “gun fighters” in Western mining camps,’ and it puts him in Corbett’s corner at Carson City, where ‘His presence did not help Corbett.’ ‘A corner in a secure prison is the proper place for Earp for many years.’ Before the fight the papers had him at Carson to describe it for a newspaper.

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

New-York Tribune · 18 March 1897 · page 6 · transcribed from the page image

Wyatt Earp stole the Sharkey fight from Fitzsimmons. Earp is one of those despicable assassins who are called "gun fighters" in Western mining camps. Earp was in Corbett's corner in Carson City. His presence did not help Corbett. A corner in a secure prison is the proper place for Earp for many years.

See the clipping

Sheriff Paul sets the record straight

The man who held the warrant for Stilwell’s killing writes to the Tucson paper: Ike Clanton ‘ran away,’ Stilwell was shot at Tucson while ‘peeking in the window’ of Virgil’s railroad car, and when Behan said ‘Wyatt, I want to see you,’ Wyatt answered without stopping, ‘You might see me once too often.’

Arizona Republican · Phoenix, Ariz. · and 1 other paper

Arizona Republican · 3 March 1898 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image

STORY OF PHIN CLANTON. Ex-Sheriff Paul Sets the Press Right in Regard to the Feud.

R. H. Paul, ex-sheriff of Pima county, has written a letter to the Tucson Citizen in which he corroborates the substance of a story published in The Republican some time ago. He says:

See moreSee less

"Editor Citizen: I see in your issue of the 18th where you seek to correct the Phoenix Republican's biography of Phin Clanton, and in which you are a little off in some of your statements. Phin Clanton was not in the fight with the McLowries. There were only two McLowries in that fight, Tom and Frank. Ike and Billy Clanton were also there. The two McLowries and Billy Clanton were killed and Ike ran away into the back end of Montgomery's stable or corral. Ike was killed on the Little Colorado some time afterwards. Phin was convicted of cattle stealing and was sent to the Yuma prison. After his release he went to Globe and has made that vicinity his home since.

"Wyatt Earp did not follow Stilwell to Tucson. Ike Clanton and Frank Stilwell came to Tucson and about two weeks later the Earps came on the train as an escort to Virgil Earp, who had been shot, as you say, on Allen street and was on his way to Colton where his father and mother lived, for medical treatment. While the train was standing in Tucson, Frank Stilwell was seen standing on a gravel car peeking in the window of the car that Virgil Earp was in. Wyatt Earp and the balance of the escort started after him, overtook him and killed him as you say. The train pulled out before the shooting was over. The Earps then started on foot for Benson, where they left their horses. A freight train overtook them about eight miles from Tucson. They made signals and the train stopped and took them to Benson, where they got tehir horses and were in Tombstone before daylight.

"The next morning a warrant was sworn out and placed in my hands (I was then sheriff), and Judge Alex Campbell was district attorney. We went to the telegraph office together and wired the warrant to Behan, and when Behan received the message all of the Earp party that were in the killing of Stilwell were upstairs in Billike's hotel. As soon as they heard that Behan had a warrant for them they sent to Montgomery's stable in the block below where their horses were, to have them saddled, which was immediately done. When informed that their horses were ready they walked to the stable, mounted and rode out of town.

"Behan had collected all his deputies and Dave Nagle, who afterwards killed Judge Terry, was city marshal, and Behan had Nagle and all the police at the door of the hotel as the Earps passed out. Behan said: 'Wyatt, I want to see you,' and Wyatt without stopping, said, 'You might see me once too often.' There was no further attempt made to arrest them.

"The next day I started for Tombstone and met Behan and his posse about five miles this side of town. One of Behan's deputies gave me his horse and I went with the posse. We went to Contention that night, and next day we went to Tombstone. As I had had no sleep since leaving Tucson I went to sleep in the express office and told Behan where I could be found. He agreed to call me if he heard where the Earps were, as I wished to go with him. He got his posse of rustlers and brought up at Hooker's ranch, where the Earp party had been. They told Hooker where they were going to camp and that if Behan and posse came where there looking for them to tell them where they were, as they intended to remain there four or five days. When the Behan posse arrived at the Hooker ranch Hooker told them where the Earp party was, but Behand did not want them.

"I had a horse engaged to go with Behan and he agreed to call me if he started out again, but he did not do it and I returned to Tucson. If I were in Tucson I would give you some 'reminiscences,' as I have the published accounts of them. I had nothing to do today and thought I would set you straight.

"Yours respectfully, "R. H. PAUL. "Solomonville. Feb. 27, 1898."

See the clipping

Rich in Nome

Back in Seattle from Alaska, Earp calls Cape Nome the greatest camp he has ever seen; his saloon, clubroom and hotel there are making money ‘perhaps faster than he ever made it before.’

The Seattle Post-Intelligencer · Seattle, Wash. Terr. Wash.

CorrectionThis set right an article from 33 days earlier.

The Seattle Post-Intelligencer · 13 November 1899 · page 6 · transcribed from the page image

WYATT EARP ON CAPE NOME.

Says It Is the Greatest Camp He Has Ever Lived in.

See moreSee less

Wyatt, Earp, sporting man and frontiersman, came unheralded from Nome, arriving on thesteamship Cleveland Saturday. He is accompanied by Mrs. Earp. Since his return Mr. Earp has been much about the city in company with local sporting men, with every one of whom he is personally well acquainted. Indeed, none of the fraternity, not even "Bat" Masterson, is better known than Wyatt Earp, more than thirty years of whose life has been spent in frontier mining camps. And in all that time he declares that he has never found the equal of Cape Nome. In short, he expresses himself as believing it the greatest both as to richness and extent he has ever seen.

Earp has in Nome a combination saloon, clubroom and hotel. He is making money perhaps faster than he ever made it before, and has told his friends, if business runs with him next summer as it did after his arrival in the camp from Rampart, several months ago, he will be able to retire with all the money he desires.

See the clipping

Warren Earp killed at Willcox

Warren Earp, of ‘the widely known Earp family of Tombstone fame,’ is shot dead in a Willcox saloon by a cattleman, John Boyett. It is said Earp ‘became abusive and told Boyett to get his gun,’ then came at him with a pocket knife ‘at same time saying he was unarmed’; the coroner’s jury exonerates Boyett.

Tombstone Epitaph · Tombstone, Ariz.

CorrectionThis set right an article from 4 days earlier.

Tombstone Epitaph · 15 July 1900 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

WARREN EARP KILLED

John Boyett Exhonorated by the Coroners Jury

See moreSee less

Word was received here today that John Boyett who killed Warren Earp at Wilcox on Friday night has been exhonerated by the coroner's jury. Earp was a member of the widely known Earp family of Tombstone fame. Boyett is a wellknown cattleman. It is understood the two men have not been on friendly terms for some time. At the time of the killing both met at a saloon in Wilcox and it is said Earp became abusive and told Boyett to get his gun. The latter did so and returning found Earp in bad mood. Earp started for Boyett with a pocket knife in his hand, at same time saying he was unarmed. Boyett warned Earp to stop as he would take no chances and ordered him not to proceed farther on pain of being killed. The deceased paid no attention to the warning and in advancing received the fatal shot. It was latter found that Earp was unarmed save the pocket knife. This is in effect the report of killing as reached here. The verdict of the coroners jury has not yet been officially received here.

See the clipping

Shot at Nome, says a letter

The same week a letter from Nome has Wyatt himself shot through the arm by a customer in his saloon and jailed by the army, after making himself ‘the terror of the town.’

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 26 days later.

Wrong

New-York Tribune · 15 July 1900 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

WYATT EARP SHOT AT NOME.

THE ARIZONA "BAD MAN" NOT QUICK ENOUGH WITH HIS GUN.

See moreSee less

San Francisco, July 14 (Special).—In a letter received from ex-Coroner Hill, of San Francisco, now at Nome, comes news that Wyatt Earp, the notorious Arizona gun fighter and bad man, was shot in the arm by a man on whom he started to pull a gun in his saloon. Earp was badly wounded, and before he recovers he will have received intelligence of the death of his youngest brother, Warren, who last week was shot at Willcox, Ariz.

According to Hill, Wyatt Earp, who keeps a saloon and gambling house in Nome, has been the terror of the town because of his reputation as a dead shot. He bullied every one, and he was particularly offensive in his own place after he had had a little liquor. On June 30 Earp quarrelled with a customer, and, being greatly enraged, reached for his gun, which was behind the counter. The customer, who had a large navy revolver, didn't wait for the bad man to heel himself, but opened fire, and put a bullet through Earp's right arm. This ended the fight, for Earp's arm was rendered useless, and he lost much blood.

The military authorities investigated the affair and lodged Earp in jail. His followers swore vengeance, but there were too many troops for them to do anything. Wyatt Earp gained notoriety here at the time he gave the decision against Fitzsimmons and in favor of Sharkey. Before he entered the ring as the referee the police made him deliver up his big revolver, and after the fight he went around heeled with two guns and dared any one to hint that he had made a crooked decision.

See the clipping

Welcome to Tonopah

Earp arrives in the new Nevada camp of Tonopah with his wife, a partner and ‘a big wagon loaded down with soft hardware’ for a saloon, and the local paper is glad to have him: ‘They are good citizens and we welcome them to Tonopah.’

Tonopah Bonanza · Butler, Nev. · and 1 other paper

Tonopah Bonanza · 1 February 1902 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

Wyatt Earp and wife and H. Martin arrived from Los Angeles Tuesday. Mr. Earp has just returned from Nome and comes to Tonopah to engage in the saloon business. He has a big wagon loaded down with soft hardware and as soon as he and his partner Mr. Martin secure a location they will be home to all. They are good citizens and we welcome them to Tonopah.

See the clipping

The fight retold, twenty-two years on

A Tombstone paper retells the street fight almost line for line from the first reports, down to the thirty shots, but makes the marshal ‘Bob Earp.’

The Williams News · Williams, Ariz.

The Williams News · 2 May 1903 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

FAMOUS EARP DUEL RECALLED

One of the Nerviest Battles Ever Occurring in Tombstone or Anywhere Else.

See moreSee less

The following account of a bloody fight, which occurred in Tombstone in the early days, will no doubt be remembered by many of our readers, and probably some of them were in the old camp when the battle took place. Here is the way the Tombstone American tells the story:

In 1880 and 1881 Tombstone was the rendezvous for all the cowboys and the mecca of the "bad men" of those years, who flocked into the city of almost sacred name, there to enjoy in their own way the scenes in which they reveled, namely, of loading up with active firewater, shooting out the lights and making the "tenderfeet" dance at their sweet will and pleasure.

Bob Earp was marshal of the town, a man well-known as desperate when called upon to face a danger.

It was on the 26th day of October, 1881, that Tombstone was visited by a band of occasional visitors who came periodically to have what was known as a hell-roaring time.

Heavily armed with 45s and Winchesters, they had given evidence that before the shades of evening fell on that day there would be "something doing" in town that night.

Marshal Earp recognized this fact, and calling up his brothers, Morgan and Wyatt, and Dock Halliday to assist him, determined to disarm the steer-ropers.

These latter were assembled in and around the O. K. corral, but a short distance from the present office of the American, on Tremont street, and thither Marshal Earp, his brothers and Halliday proceeded, bent on overpowering the intended peace disturbers.

Just as they passed the old Nugget office, formerly the place of publication of the paper of that name, they saw Sheriff Behan in conversation with the Clantons and the McLowrey brothers, and requesting them to disarm.

Bob Earp called out, "Boys, throw up your hands and give up your sixshooters."

No sooner had the command been given than Frank McLowrey attempted to draw his revolver, and Wyatt Earp, who had his pistol in hand, immediately shot him.

Dock Halliday had drawn a bead on Tom McLowrey, and blazed away with a shotgun, filling Tom with buckshot under the right arm. Billy Clanton then took up the fight from the cowboys' side and fired on Marshal Earp, while his brother Ike shot out through the corral to Allen street.

At this point there was a perfect fusilade of shots exchanging between the desperate men on both sides, some thirty shots being fired, and so swift was the work that the fight lasted but little over a minute.

When the firing ceased and the "smoke of battle had cleared away" it was found that Frank McLowrey had been killed. Tom McLowrey, wounded, had still life sufficient to walk around the corner of Third street, where he was found dead from gunshot wounds. Billy Clanton lay upon the street mortally wounded, from the effects of which he died later. Morgan Earp was shot through both shoulders and his brother, Marshal Earp carried a painful wound in the leg.

Strange to say, neither Wyatt Earp or Dock Halliday received a scratch.

This was one of the nerviest battles ever occurring in Tombstone.

See the clipping

Virgil Earp dies

Virgil Earp, who was ‘shot through the arm, losing the use of that member entirely’ in one of the Tombstone battles, dies of pneumonia at Goldfield, where the new gold had drawn him from his farm near Prescott.

Mohave County Miner · Mineral Park, Ariz.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 4 days later. CorrectionThis set right an article from 8 days earlier.

Wrong

Mohave County Miner · 28 October 1905 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

Virgil Earp, one of the Earp brothers, died at Goldffeld last Thursday morning of pneumonia. Virgil was at Tombstone during the stormy period of the early eighties and was in several of the battles with his brother Wyatt Earp, who was deputy U. S. marshall, and in one of which he was shot through the arm, losing the use of that member entirely. Several years ago he purchased a farm near Prescott and settled down to a pastoral life, but the excitement of the recently discovered riches of gold field attracted him, and there death ended his career.

See the clipping

Jailed in Los Angeles

‘Wyatt Earp, the noted gunman of Nevada and referee of the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight’ is locked up with two others, charged with trying to bunco a real estate dealer in a fake faro game.

East Oregonian : E.O · Pendleton, Or.

East Oregonian : E.O · 22 July 1911 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

Noted Sportsman Jailed. Los Angeles, July 22.--Charged with having attempted to "bunco" J. Y. Peterson, a local real estate dealer, in a game of fake faro bank. Wyatt Earp, the noted gunman of Nevada and referee of the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight, was locked up here today with two accomplices.

See the clipping

← Back to Act Four: The Vendetta