As the Papers Told It

Wyatt Earp · As the Papers Told It

Act Two

The Earps in Tombstone

March 1880 – October 1881

By 1880 the Earps are in Tombstone wearing badges: Virgil a deputy United States marshal, and a Deputy Sheriff Earp arresting a lawyer and a judge out of the same courtroom brawl. In March 1881 Wyatt rides with the posse after the stage robbers; in September he and Morgan bring in one of Sheriff Behan’s own deputies for robbing another. A month later Behan and Marshal Earp are still riding together after Apaches.

An Earp wears a badge in Tombstone

A deputy United States marshal, ‘V. P. Earp,’ arrests a man named C. S. Hogan at Tombstone for counterfeiting trade dollars. Hogan is held to bail in $5,000 but escapes from the Tombstone prison, and ‘The plates and dies were found with the prisoner.’

The Weekly Arizona Miner · Prescott, Ariz

The Weekly Arizona Miner · 26 March 1880 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

Deputy U. S. Marshal V. P. Earp arrested a man by the name of C. S. Hogan at Tombstone, a few days since, for counterfeiting trade dollars. He was examined, held to bail in $5,000, but escaped from the Tombstone prison. The plates and dies were found with the prisoner.

See the clipping

A judge, a lawyer and Deputy Sheriff Earp

When a Tombstone justice grabs a lawyer by the throat and the lawyer hits ‘His Honor in the eye,’ Deputy Sheriff Earp separates them and arrests both. ‘To-day they’ll go at it again.’

The Silver State · Unionville, Nev.

The Silver State · 3 September 1880 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

AN ARIZONA COURT.

How a Disciple of Blackstone Pasted His Honor in the Eye.

See moreSee less

[From the Arizona Star of August 19th.]

This is the way they keep the judicial pot a boiling in Tombstone : Owing to some private difficulty between Mr. Harry B. Jones, counselor-at-law, and Justice of the Peace James Reilly, the latter ordered the former out of Court unless he apologized to him when he came to take his seat as counsel for Perrine, who is charged with murder. Mr. Jones took no notice and sat down beside his client. This incensed Judge Reilly to such a degree that he came from behind his judicial desk, grasped Jones by the throat and attempted to throw him out. Jones then hit His Honor in the eye. Deputy Sheriff Earp, who was in another part of the Court, as soon as possible separated them and arrested Jones, telling the Justice to consider himself also under arrest. Jones was taken before Justice Gray, and his case was to come up for examination yesterday, as also Justice Reilly's, for whose arrest Deputy Sheriff Earp had in the meantime procured a warrant. As soon as Mr. Jones reappeared in Justice Reilly's Court His Honor fined him $25 and one day's imprisonment. He was brought down Tuesday night from Tombstone in charge of Earp, and came up on a writ of habeas corpus before Probate Judge Woods yesterday at one o'clock. The order of commitment proving defective, and the punishment imposed for the contempt greater than a Justice can inflict, the prisoner was at once discharged from custody on motion of the District Attorney. To-day they'll go at it again.

See the clipping

After the stage robbers

Wyatt Earp and Marshall Williams come back from the hunt for the stage robbers, leaving Virgil Earp’s party on the trail, and three of the robbers are named: ‘Billy Leonard, James Crane and Harry Head,’ with $3,600 offered for them.

Eureka Daily Sentinel · Eureka, Nev.

Eureka Daily Sentinel · 31 March 1881 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

Who They Are. Tombstone Epitaph : Wyatt Earp and Marshall Williams have returned from the hunt for the robbers, having left the pursuing party at Helm's ranch. Mr. Earp states that the robbers have separated, there now being but two in advance of the party who are headed for New Mexico. They have gained considerably on Virgil Earp and his companions, owing to the fact that they procured fresh horses at Redfield's ranch on the San Pedro, while the horses of the pursuing party were jaded and almost broken down, until a fresh supply arrived from this city.

See moreSee less

It is now known definitely that three of the stage robbers are Billy Leonard, James Crane and Harry Head. Their ultimate capture is certain, as, aside from the fact that the shrewdest and most determined men in the Territory are on their track, Wells, Fargo & Co. are sending detailed descriptions all over the country, and a reward of $3,600 all told is offered for their apprehension.

See the clipping

The sheriff’s own deputy arrested

Wyatt and Morgan Earp bring in Deputy Sheriff Stilwell and another man for robbing the Bisbee stage, on the evidence of his boot heels. If it proves true, says the Epitaph, ‘it would seem to be in order for Sheriff Behan to appoint another deputy.’

Daily Los Angeles Herald · Los Angeles, Calif.

Daily Los Angeles Herald · 16 September 1881 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

IMPORTANT CAPTURE.

A Deputy Sheriff Arrested on a Charge of Robbing the Bisbee Stage.

See moreSee less

[Tombstone Epitaph, Sept. 13.]

Wyatt and Morgan Earp, Marshal Williams and Deputy Sheriff Breakenridge, who went to Bisbee to arrest the stage robbers, on Sunday evening brought in Deputy Sheriff T. C. Stillwell and P. Spencer, whom the evidence strongly points out as the robbers. They were examined before Wells Spicer, Esq., yesterday, and were admitted to bail in the sum of $7,000 each—$5,000 for robbing the mail and $2,000 for robbing D. B. Rea. The evidence against Deputy Sheriff Stillwell is circumstantial, and rests principally upon the tracks made by his boot heels in the mud, which corresponded with those which he had removed by a shoemaker upon his return to Bisbee. The Epitaph has no desire to prejudge the case, but if it turns out as now anticipated, that the officers of the law are implicated in this nefarious business, it would seem to be in order for Sheriff Behan to appoint another deputy.

See the clipping

Behan and Earp ride together

An Arizona paper mocks an army officer who could not move for soft ground while ‘a squad of Tombstoners, under Sheriff Behan and Marshal Earp, crossed the valley twice’ after Indians. Within weeks the papers would call the two men rival factions.

Eureka Daily Sentinel · Eureka, Nev.

Eureka Daily Sentinel · 22 October 1881 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

A Comment on Indian Fighting. The press of Arizona has no very high opinion of the efficiency of the officers and troops of the regular army in their operations against the hostile redskins. Officers who are without experience in Indian fighting, it is urged, defer too much to the discipline of the training camp, which is very different from what the rapid movements and long marches of the troops should be on the frontier. The Tombstone (Arizona) Nugget speaks of one of the officers of the troops having command in that region as follows: While camped at Soldiers' Holes, he telegraphed: "The rain has softened the trail badly, and I cannot move without leaving the animals;" but a squad of Tombstoners, under Sheriff Behan and Marshal Earp, crossed the valley twice during that particular day, and were not obliged to leave their animals; but they were looking for Indians, and in that respect differed from the command encamped at Soldiers' Holes.

See moreSee less

It must also be borne in mind that the retreating savages did not find "the trail" too soft in going over the same ground with their ponies and stolen stock, and they were but six hours ahead of the troops when the troops went into camp and remained there for 48 hours.

See the clipping

← Back to Act One: The Cow-Town Policeman