In March 1882 Morgan Earp is shot dead through a billiard-room door. Days later Frank Stilwell is killed at Tucson, and the Earp party, wanted for it, ride out of Tombstone past Sheriff Behan: they drew their guns on him, say the dispatches, while the Epitaph’s witnesses say no weapon was drawn. For two months the papers can hardly keep up: Curly Bill killed at Burleigh Springs, or the Earps beaten off by prospectors; Wyatt Earp killed, or not; and in May the party reported arrested at Denver, when only Holliday is held.
◆
Morgan Earp murdered
Morgan Earp is shot through the glass door of a saloon while playing billiards and dies at midnight; Wyatt, sitting near, is shot at and missed. ‘The tragedy was not unexpected,’ says the dispatch: the threats had never stopped since the street fight.
The Salt Lake Herald · Salt Lake City, Utah
The Salt Lake Herald · 21 March 1882 · page 6 · transcribed from the page image
San Francisco, 19.—Tombstone dispatch: Morgan Earp was assassinated while playing a game of billiards in a saloon to-night. The shot was fired through the glass door. His brother Wyatt, who was sitting near, was also shot at, but not hit. The assassin escaped. Earp died at midnight. There is great excitement. The tragedy was not unexpected, as since the fight between the Earp brothers and cowboys, last November, threats of assassination have been constant, and some attempts made.
Frank Stilwell has been killed at Tucson, a warrant is out for the Earp party, and when Sheriff Behan comes for them at the Cosmopolitan Hotel ‘they drew their guns on him and walked out of town.’ Sheriff Paul of Tucson sets out after them, and ‘bloodshed is expected.’
Sacramento Daily Record-Union · Sacramento, Calif. · and 1 other paper
Sacramento Daily Record-Union · 22 March 1882 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
The Tombstone Vendetta. TUCSON, March 21st.--A Star special from Tombstone, just received, says that the Earp party arrived in Tombstone at 1 P. M., went to the Cosmopolitan Hotel, stayed there until 7 this evening, until Sheriff Behan went to arrest them, when they drew their guns on him and walked out of town, mounted their horses and left for the hills. The feeling here in regard to the assassination of Stillwell is growing more intense hourly. The deceased was here in response to a subpena from the Court. It is now very generally believed that the bandits came down from Tombstone for the purpose of killing Ike Clanton, who has been here for two weeks.
See moreSee less
To-day, after a hearing before the Coroner's jury, a warrant was placed in the hands of Sheriff Paul for the arrest of the Earp party--Holliday, McMasters and others of the implicated parties. Learning that they had returned to and arrived at Tombstone this afternoon, Paul telegraphed Sheriff Behan, of Cochise county, at Tombstone, to arrest the parties. To-night Sheriff Behan telegraphed Paul that he had tried to make the arrest and was forcibly resisted by the party and a posse of their friends, and asked for assistance, and that the Earp party had fled to the hills. Sheriff Paul left to-night on a special for Tombstone, to make the arrests. There is no doubt but that he will take them, but bloodshed is expected.
A ‘reliable young man’ brings word from Burleigh Springs: nine cowboys under Curly Bill, ‘who killed Marshal White of Tombstone,’ ambushed six of the Earp party, and when the Earps charged the cowboys ran, ‘leaving Curly Bill dead upon the field.’
Las Vegas Daily Gazette · Las Vegas, N.M.
Las Vegas Daily Gazette · 26 March 1882 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
Bloody Conflict. San Francisco, March 25.—A Tombstone dispatch says a reliable young man, just from Burleigh Springs, eight miles south of this city, states that a desperate fight took place there last night between six men of the Earp party and nine cowboys, headed by the notorious Curley Bill, who killed Marshal White of Tombstone. The cowboys ambushed the Earps as they were approaching the Springs, and poured a deadly fire into them, wounding one man slightly and killing a horse. The Earps returned the fire, then charged upon the cowboys, who ran, leaving Curly Bill dead upon the field.
A Tucson paper has a deputy sheriff’s account: the Earps fired on four prospectors cooking their dinner, ‘instead of cow-boys, as reported,’ were ‘ingloriously repulsed,’ and Wyatt Earp took ‘a couple of ugly flesh wounds.’ Which account was true, the papers that spring never settled.
Daily Los Angeles Herald · Los Angeles, Calif.
Daily Los Angeles Herald · 6 April 1882 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
BURLEIGH SPRINGS FIGHT.
The Earps Attack a Party of Prospectors and Get More Than They Bargained For.
See moreSee less
A reliable gentleman who returned to this city last evening from Tombstone, informs us that a Deputy Sheriff of Cochise county returned to that city shortly before our informant's departure and recited an exciting account of the battle of Burleigh Springs. It seems that the Earp party attacked a party of prospectors on that occasion, instead of cow-boys, as reported, and were ingloriously repulsed. The Deputy Sheriff above referred to states that four prospectors were encamped temporarily in the cañon and in the act of preparing their noonday meal, when a shower of lead in their midst naturally attracted their attention and a like compliment in return. The prospectors, when the first shock was over, grasped their guns and glancing in the direction of their assailants were surprised to see instead of a party of Apaches, as they expected, eight white men on horseback, blazing away as fast as Winchesters could pump lead. The prospectors, who were under the lead of a party named Dan Murphy, turned their shotguns loose, and the so-called defenders of law and order beat a retreat, one of them, who flourishes under the classic appellation of Texas Jack, leaving his steed dead on the ground. Now comes the interesting part of the business.
The Deputy Sheriff was a quiet spectator of this exciting battle, and whether from knowledge or the intuition of genius we are unable to determine, made up his mind that if his official body became visible there would be a vacancy thereafter in his family circle. So, without much ceremony, he made his way quietly to a neighboring ranch; but ere he had the pespiration dry on his brow after entering was horrified to see the enemy approach at double quick. He wanted to make his will but hadn't time; so, doing the next best thing, he secreted himself, putting up a job with the proprietor to keep mum. The party entered and ordered dinner, and while the meal was in process of preparation they talked over the battle. The Sheriff's officer, with his shotgun at a "ready," was an interested listener. It seems that Texas Jack had his horse killed by the first volley and that Wyatt Earp received a couple of ugly flesh wounds in the region of the breast and shoulders; McMasters also coming in for a dose in the back as he turned to retreat. After regaling themselves at the farmer's expense they departed further into the mountains and the representative of the executive authority of Cochise county made his way to the county capital.
In spite of rumors to the contrary, it is the general opinion of Tombstone people that the Earps are still lurking around the mountains in the vicinity of the town. The Sheriff and City Marshal are keeping a close look-out for them, and it is to be hoped that they will soon be brought face to face with the law they have so grossly outraged.—Tucson Star.
The sheriff at Denver wires that he holds the Earp party, five men indicted at Tucson for the murder of Frank Stilwell, and Sheriff Paul sets off to bring them back. ‘Perfect quiet has reigned in Cochise county since the Earp party left.’ By 3 June Paul is telegraphing from Denver that Holliday is the only one of the party under arrest.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 17 days later.
Wrong
Sacramento Daily Record-Union · 17 May 1882 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
Official Congratulation—The Earps Arrested—Fire.
The Capture of the Earps. Tucson, May 16th.—Sheriff Paul to day received a dispatch from the Sheriff at Denver, Col., that he had arrested and held in custody the Earp party, who are indicted in this county for the murder of Frank Stillwell. There are five men in the party. Tipton, one of the number, met a violent death in New Mexico two weeks ago, while attempting a robbery. Governor Tritle placed a requisition in the hands of Sheriff Paul, who leaves for Denver for the prisoners to-morrow morning. Perfect quiet has reigned in Cochise county since the Earp party left.
Nine days after the report of his death, a New Mexico paper sets it straight: ‘The statement going the rounds that Wyatt Earp had been killed in Arizona is not correct.’