As the Papers Told It

Wyatt Earp

As the Papers Told It

Eureka Daily Sentinel, 3 November 1881Barbour County Index, 14 March 1888Evening Star, 3 December 1896Arizona Republican, 3 March 1898

And the Gunfight at the O.K. Corral

April 1875 – December 193043 newspaper articles in the story, 1,586 in the full archive

In the 1870s Wyatt Earp was a policeman in Wichita and an assistant marshal in Dodge City, and the papers noticed him only now and then. On 26 October 1881, in Tombstone, Arizona, he walked down Fremont street with two of his brothers and Doc Holliday to disarm four cowboys, and about thirty shots later three men were dead. A hearing, an ambush, a murder and a ride of vengeance followed, and the papers never stopped writing about him after that.

They never agreed on what he was. They called him a marshal and ‘one of those despicable assassins,’ a chief of the ‘stage-robber faction’ and one of the ‘good citizens’ a new mining camp was glad to welcome, and they reported him killed in Arizona and shot at Nome. When he died in 1929, his obituary got the street fight wrong.

Here is how the papers told it, from the Wichita police to the Tombstone bookshelf.

The numbers

1,586newspaper articles
1,912printings
402newspapers
51states and territories
669months in the papers

Each article is counted once, however many papers ran it. Printings counts every paper that ran it, so an article reprinted in five papers is one article and five printings.

How much the papers printed

Month of 1 April 1875: 1 printingMonth of 1 March 1877: 1 printingMonth of 1 July 1877: 2 printingsMonth of 1 May 1878: 2 printingsMonth of 1 June 1878: 3 printingsMonth of 1 July 1878: 1 printingMonth of 1 August 1878: 1 printingMonth of 1 October 1878: 1 printingMonth of 1 April 1879: 1 printingMonth of 1 May 1879: 2 printingsMonth of 1 August 1879: 1 printingMonth of 1 September 1879: 1 printingMonth of 1 March 1880: 1 printingMonth of 1 August 1880: 1 printingMonth of 1 September 1880: 1 printingMonth of 1 November 1880: 1 printingMonth of 1 March 1881: 2 printingsMonth of 1 April 1881: 2 printingsMonth of 1 May 1881: 3 printingsMonth of 1 September 1881: 2 printingsMonth of 1 October 1881: 13 printingsMonth of 1 November 1881: 33 printingsMonth of 1 December 1881: 32 printingsMonth of 1 January 1882: 20 printingsMonth of 1 February 1882: 9 printingsMonth of 1 March 1882: 73 printingsMonth of 1 April 1882: 15 printingsMonth of 1 May 1882: 30 printingsMonth of 1 June 1882: 7 printingsMonth of 1 July 1882: 4 printingsMonth of 1 August 1882: 1 printingMonth of 1 September 1882: 2 printingsMonth of 1 October 1882: 1 printingMonth of 1 January 1883: 1 printingMonth of 1 May 1883: 4 printingsMonth of 1 June 1883: 1 printingMonth of 1 March 1884: 2 printingsMonth of 1 May 1884: 2 printingsMonth of 1 June 1884: 1 printingMonth of 1 October 1884: 2 printingsMonth of 1 November 1884: 1 printingMonth of 1 December 1884: 1 printingMonth of 1 March 1885: 2 printingsMonth of 1 July 1885: 1 printingMonth of 1 December 1885: 1 printingMonth of 1 January 1886: 1 printingMonth of 1 March 1886: 1 printingMonth of 1 June 1886: 10 printingsMonth of 1 July 1886: 1 printingMonth of 1 February 1887: 4 printingsMonth of 1 March 1887: 4 printingsMonth of 1 June 1887: 2 printingsMonth of 1 July 1887: 1 printingMonth of 1 August 1887: 3 printingsMonth of 1 September 1887: 4 printingsMonth of 1 November 1887: 4 printingsMonth of 1 December 1887: 2 printingsMonth of 1 January 1888: 5 printingsMonth of 1 February 1888: 3 printingsMonth of 1 March 1888: 5 printingsMonth of 1 April 1888: 9 printingsMonth of 1 May 1888: 4 printingsMonth of 1 July 1888: 10 printingsMonth of 1 August 1888: 3 printingsMonth of 1 December 1888: 1 printingMonth of 1 January 1889: 4 printingsMonth of 1 February 1889: 1 printingMonth of 1 March 1889: 1 printingMonth of 1 May 1889: 2 printingsMonth of 1 July 1889: 1 printingMonth of 1 August 1889: 7 printingsMonth of 1 September 1889: 2 printingsMonth of 1 October 1889: 2 printingsMonth of 1 December 1889: 1 printingMonth of 1 July 1890: 4 printingsMonth of 1 August 1890: 3 printingsMonth of 1 September 1890: 1 printingMonth of 1 October 1890: 1 printingMonth of 1 November 1890: 1 printingMonth of 1 December 1890: 1 printingMonth of 1 June 1891: 2 printingsMonth of 1 September 1891: 1 printingMonth of 1 November 1891: 2 printingsMonth of 1 December 1891: 2 printingsMonth of 1 January 1892: 2 printingsMonth of 1 March 1892: 1 printingMonth of 1 June 1892: 2 printingsMonth of 1 September 1892: 2 printingsMonth of 1 June 1893: 2 printingsMonth of 1 July 1893: 1 printingMonth of 1 August 1893: 1 printingMonth of 1 October 1893: 2 printingsMonth of 1 November 1893: 8 printingsMonth of 1 December 1893: 1 printingMonth of 1 January 1894: 1 printingMonth of 1 February 1894: 3 printingsMonth of 1 April 1894: 7 printingsMonth of 1 May 1894: 15 printingsMonth of 1 June 1894: 2 printingsMonth of 1 August 1894: 1 printingMonth of 1 November 1894: 4 printingsMonth of 1 April 1895: 10 printingsMonth of 1 June 1895: 1 printingMonth of 1 July 1895: 7 printingsMonth of 1 August 1895: 2 printingsMonth of 1 October 1895: 4 printingsMonth of 1 November 1895: 3 printingsMonth of 1 December 1895: 2 printingsMonth of 1 January 1896: 1 printingMonth of 1 February 1896: 2 printingsMonth of 1 April 1896: 4 printingsMonth of 1 May 1896: 1 printingMonth of 1 August 1896: 5 printingsMonth of 1 October 1896: 1 printingMonth of 1 November 1896: 3 printingsMonth of 1 December 1896: 629 printingsMonth of 1 January 1897: 14 printingsMonth of 1 February 1897: 12 printingsMonth of 1 March 1897: 26 printingsMonth of 1 April 1897: 12 printingsMonth of 1 May 1897: 11 printingsMonth of 1 June 1897: 7 printingsMonth of 1 July 1897: 2 printingsMonth of 1 August 1897: 10 printingsMonth of 1 September 1897: 7 printingsMonth of 1 October 1897: 8 printingsMonth of 1 November 1897: 2 printingsMonth of 1 December 1897: 6 printingsMonth of 1 January 1898: 1 printingMonth of 1 February 1898: 9 printingsMonth of 1 March 1898: 6 printingsMonth of 1 May 1898: 3 printingsMonth of 1 June 1898: 3 printingsMonth of 1 July 1898: 2 printingsMonth of 1 August 1898: 1 printingMonth of 1 September 1898: 1 printingMonth of 1 October 1898: 1 printingMonth of 1 November 1898: 6 printingsMonth of 1 December 1898: 27 printingsMonth of 1 January 1899: 15 printingsMonth of 1 February 1899: 2 printingsMonth of 1 March 1899: 2 printingsMonth of 1 April 1899: 1 printingMonth of 1 May 1899: 1 printingMonth of 1 June 1899: 3 printingsMonth of 1 August 1899: 2 printingsMonth of 1 September 1899: 1 printingMonth of 1 October 1899: 2 printingsMonth of 1 November 1899: 5 printingsMonth of 1 December 1899: 4 printingsMonth of 1 January 1900: 3 printingsMonth of 1 February 1900: 5 printingsMonth of 1 March 1900: 7 printingsMonth of 1 April 1900: 3 printingsMonth of 1 May 1900: 5 printingsMonth of 1 June 1900: 2 printingsMonth of 1 July 1900: 38 printingsMonth of 1 August 1900: 23 printingsMonth of 1 September 1900: 15 printingsMonth of 1 October 1900: 5 printingsMonth of 1 January 1901: 1 printingMonth of 1 February 1901: 1 printingMonth of 1 March 1901: 2 printingsMonth of 1 April 1901: 1 printingMonth of 1 May 1901: 5 printingsMonth of 1 June 1901: 1 printingMonth of 1 July 1901: 6 printingsMonth of 1 August 1901: 6 printingsMonth of 1 September 1901: 4 printingsMonth of 1 October 1901: 1 printingMonth of 1 November 1901: 2 printingsMonth of 1 December 1901: 2 printingsMonth of 1 January 1902: 1 printingMonth of 1 February 1902: 10 printingsMonth of 1 March 1902: 7 printingsMonth of 1 April 1902: 4 printingsMonth of 1 May 1902: 3 printingsMonth of 1 June 1902: 4 printingsMonth of 1 July 1902: 3 printingsMonth of 1 August 1902: 1 printingMonth of 1 September 1902: 1 printingMonth of 1 October 1902: 1 printingMonth of 1 November 1902: 1 printingMonth of 1 January 1903: 1 printingMonth of 1 March 1903: 3 printingsMonth of 1 April 1903: 2 printingsMonth of 1 May 1903: 4 printingsMonth of 1 July 1903: 2 printingsMonth of 1 August 1903: 11 printingsMonth of 1 September 1903: 20 printingsMonth of 1 October 1903: 3 printingsMonth of 1 November 1903: 5 printingsMonth of 1 December 1903: 8 printingsMonth of 1 February 1904: 1 printingMonth of 1 March 1904: 1 printingMonth of 1 April 1904: 1 printingMonth of 1 July 1904: 1 printingMonth of 1 September 1904: 1 printingMonth of 1 November 1904: 4 printingsMonth of 1 December 1904: 3 printingsMonth of 1 February 1905: 2 printingsMonth of 1 April 1905: 2 printingsMonth of 1 June 1905: 2 printingsMonth of 1 August 1905: 2 printingsMonth of 1 September 1905: 7 printingsMonth of 1 October 1905: 8 printingsMonth of 1 November 1905: 12 printingsMonth of 1 December 1905: 3 printingsMonth of 1 February 1906: 6 printingsMonth of 1 March 1906: 14 printingsMonth of 1 April 1906: 2 printingsMonth of 1 May 1906: 3 printingsMonth of 1 June 1906: 1 printingMonth of 1 July 1906: 3 printingsMonth of 1 November 1906: 1 printingMonth of 1 January 1907: 3 printingsMonth of 1 February 1907: 3 printingsMonth of 1 March 1907: 2 printingsMonth of 1 April 1907: 2 printingsMonth of 1 May 1907: 1 printingMonth of 1 July 1907: 2 printingsMonth of 1 August 1907: 1 printingMonth of 1 December 1907: 3 printingsMonth of 1 January 1908: 1 printingMonth of 1 February 1908: 3 printingsMonth of 1 March 1908: 1 printingMonth of 1 November 1908: 2 printingsMonth of 1 December 1908: 3 printingsMonth of 1 January 1909: 1 printingMonth of 1 May 1909: 1 printingMonth of 1 June 1909: 1 printingMonth of 1 July 1909: 6 printingsMonth of 1 October 1909: 1 printingMonth of 1 November 1909: 1 printingMonth of 1 December 1909: 1 printingMonth of 1 January 1910: 1 printingMonth of 1 March 1910: 3 printingsMonth of 1 April 1910: 2 printingsMonth of 1 May 1910: 1 printingMonth of 1 June 1910: 3 printingsMonth of 1 July 1910: 7 printingsMonth of 1 August 1910: 5 printingsMonth of 1 December 1910: 1 printingMonth of 1 July 1911: 15 printingsMonth of 1 August 1911: 2 printingsMonth of 1 September 1911: 1 printingMonth of 1 June 1912: 1 printingMonth of 1 September 1912: 3 printingsMonth of 1 November 1912: 1 printingMonth of 1 December 1912: 1 printingMonth of 1 January 1913: 1 printingMonth of 1 August 1913: 1 printingMonth of 1 February 1914: 2 printingsMonth of 1 December 1914: 1 printingMonth of 1 August 1915: 1 printingMonth of 1 December 1916: 3 printingsMonth of 1 March 1917: 1 printingMonth of 1 August 1917: 1 printingMonth of 1 September 1917: 1 printingMonth of 1 November 1917: 2 printingsMonth of 1 April 1918: 3 printingsMonth of 1 May 1918: 3 printingsMonth of 1 June 1918: 1 printingMonth of 1 October 1918: 2 printingsMonth of 1 December 1918: 2 printingsMonth of 1 October 1919: 1 printingMonth of 1 December 1919: 3 printingsMonth of 1 July 1920: 1 printingMonth of 1 August 1920: 1 printingMonth of 1 December 1920: 4 printingsMonth of 1 March 1921: 1 printingMonth of 1 April 1921: 3 printingsMonth of 1 September 1921: 1 printingMonth of 1 October 1921: 1 printingMonth of 1 November 1921: 2 printingsMonth of 1 November 1922: 2 printingsMonth of 1 July 1923: 2 printingsMonth of 1 September 1923: 1 printingMonth of 1 October 1923: 3 printingsMonth of 1 November 1923: 2 printingsMonth of 1 December 1923: 4 printingsMonth of 1 January 1924: 2 printingsMonth of 1 March 1924: 1 printingMonth of 1 April 1924: 6 printingsMonth of 1 September 1924: 1 printingMonth of 1 February 1925: 3 printingsMonth of 1 March 1925: 1 printingMonth of 1 May 1925: 1 printingMonth of 1 January 1926: 2 printingsMonth of 1 April 1926: 1 printingMonth of 1 November 1926: 1 printingMonth of 1 December 1926: 9 printingsMonth of 1 February 1927: 3 printingsMonth of 1 July 1927: 2 printingsMonth of 1 January 1928: 3 printingsMonth of 1 March 1928: 1 printingMonth of 1 April 1928: 1 printingMonth of 1 May 1928: 1 printingMonth of 1 January 1929: 25 printingsMonth of 1 February 1929: 2 printingsMonth of 1 March 1929: 3 printingsMonth of 1 April 1929: 1 printingMonth of 1 May 1929: 2 printingsMonth of 1 June 1929: 2 printingsMonth of 1 July 1929: 3 printingsMonth of 1 October 1929: 7 printingsMonth of 1 November 1929: 1 printingMonth of 1 December 1929: 1 printingMonth of 1 May 1930: 3 printingsMonth of 1 July 1930: 1 printingMonth of 1 September 1930: 6 printingsMonth of 1 October 1930: 9 printingsMonth of 1 December 1930: 1 printing29 April 187521 July 187716 May 187810 May 187922 August 187926 March 18803 September 188016 March 188131 March 18811 April 188128 May 188116 September 188130 September 188122 October 188127 October 188130 October 18813 November 188112 November 18811 December 18818 December 188117 December 188130 December 188121 March 188222 March 188226 March 18826 April 188210 May 188217 May 188219 May 188214 March 18883 December 189618 March 18973 March 189813 November 189915 July 190015 July 19001 February 19022 May 190328 October 190522 July 191110 December 192614 January 192924 May 193018751876187718781879188018811882188318841885188618871888188918901891189218931894189518961897189818991900190119021903190419051906190719081909191019111912191319141915191619171918191919201921192219231924192519261927192819291930629 printings in the month of 1 December 1896

Every printing of every article, by the month it ran. The marks under the line are the articles in the story below; red ones were wrong.

Where it was printed

FewerMore

Printings in 51 states. Most: Arizona (302), California (266), Nevada (112). 71 printings could not be placed in a state.

How it unfolded

43 newspaper articles in 7 acts

The Setting

Silver and Cowboys

August 1879 – September 1881

In August 1879 a visiting professor found Tombstone a year old: where there had been a few miners’ huts of ocotillo stalks there was a town of adobe, a hotel, saloons and a mill pouring out silver. By the autumn of 1881 its mines were paying $175,000 a month, and the papers were full of ‘the cowboys.’ In March a stage carrying Wells, Fargo’s treasure was fired on near Contention and its driver killed, and in May the papers had Curly Bill, the cowboy who killed Tombstone’s marshal, shot by one of his own. This was the town the Earps came to keep in order.

Tombstone, a year old

A visiting professor finds that where a year before there were ‘only a few miners’ camps to be seen, made of ocotillo stalks,’ Tombstone is now ‘a flourishing place,’ with a hotel, saloons and a mill casting a silver bar every day. Within six months, he predicts, it will be ‘the liveliest camp in the Territory.’

Arizona Citizen · Tucson, Ariz.

Arizona Citizen · 22 August 1879 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

Professor Cox on Arizona—What he Sees and Says of the Mining Region.

(From the Los Angeles Commercial.)

See moreSee less

TUCSON, August 2, 1879.

Ed. COMMERCIAL:—It is now nearly one month since I left this city with Mr. H C. Hooker to take a look at his Sierra Bonita stock ranch and make an examination of some of the numerous mining camps now located in this highly favored county, so far as mines and mining is concerned. In the Dos Cabezas mountains there are several mineral ledges, the most conspicuous of which may be followed over abrupt mountain peaks for a mile or two, and is covered by locations. The ledge is claimed to carry $25-$40 in gold and a little in silver. Mr. Stewart, post trader at Camp Grant, and Capt. Madden of Camp Bowie, have a claim on this ledge, and have sunk a shaft forty to fifty feet. The ore from this shaft is piled up on the dump and makes a good showing. E. Martin Smith and Mr. Casey each have claims on this lode, the latter gentleman is working his ore in two arrastras, propelled by mules. The yield is said to be from $25 to $30 by this mode of treating them. Water is obtained from shallow wells in the pass of the mountains and the ore is brought down on the backs of mules in raw hide boxes. There is a silver camp in these mountains; but it was not convenient for me to visit it at this time, though it is said to be rich.

From Dos Cabezas we went to Dragoon mountains, where I made a hasty examination of a number of poorly prospected mines, said to be rich in gold and silver; saw one promising copper ledge. Water appears to be plenty here in wells, and by perseverance it is possible some paying mines may be opened.

From Dragoons we next stopped at Tombstone. It was nearly one year since my first visit to this district. Then there were only a few miners' camps to be seen, made of ocotillo stalks, and a small assay office made of plank owned by Richard Gird and the pioneer locators, Ed. and Al. Schieffelin. Now there are three small villages in sight and the slopes are covered with miners' camps. The new town of Tombstone is a flourishing place, contains quite a number of buildings, mostly of adobe, a hotel, a number of restaurants, saloons and a large store, owned by Gen. Allen. This kindhearted gentleman gave us an elegant room to occupy during our stay and would receive no pay. Indeed, I was treated with uniform kindness by every one at this hospitable camp. Richard Gird came up from the mill early the next morning with his bullion coach to take me down to the mill, but before leaving we descended the shaft on the Tough Nut mine. Here, at a depth of ninety feet, I saw a wonderful ledge of rich silver ore closely packed between well defined walls of metamorphic rock. Following the drift for more than a 100 feet I broke some ore from the ledge, and another sample about 90 feet this side. The first assayed $376 in silver and $51.20 in gold; the second, $245 in silver and $38.40 in gold. Up to the first of this month the mill has turned out $100,000 in bullion, and has never stopped an hour since set to going two months ago. I spent several days in the mill with Mr. Gird and witnessed the whole process of reduction, from the crushing of the ore to the emptying of the amalgam filters, distilling of the mercury, melting and casting the silver and gold into ingots worth from $2,500 to $2,800. One of these precious bars was made every twenty-four hours. When ten have been made they are taken in the bullion coach and strongly guarded on the journey of seventy miles to Tucson, where it is placed in charge of the express company and forwarded to Philadelphia.

The day before I left Tombstone Mr. Gage started up work on the Grand Central mine. Inside of six months there will be 55-stamps in operation in the Tombstone District, which will make it the liveliest camp in the Territory. The accommodation of such a vast business will necessitate the building of a considerable town on the San Pedro at the crossing of the Southern Pacific Railroad, twenty miles from Tombstone.

Yours truly,

E. T. Cox.

See the clipping

The stage robbery

Robbers fire on the Benson stage near Contention, killing the driver, Eli Philpot, and mortally wounding a passenger; the Wells, Fargo messenger, R. H. Paul, empties both barrels at them, and the bolting horses save the treasure. Everything that followed in Tombstone, a paper would say that November, grew out of this night.

Sacramento Daily Record-Union · Sacramento, Calif.

Sacramento Daily Record-Union · 16 March 1881 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image

Stage Stopped and the Driver Killed. Tombstone, March 15th.—The regular mail and express line stage was fired into about two miles below Contention to-night. The driver, Eli Philpot, was killed, and one passenger, Peter Roering, mortally wounded. The stage was going up a small incline, when a man stepped out from the east side of the road and called "Halt!" and at the same instant fired. Then another man on the other side of the road fired. Wells, Fargo & Co.'s messenger, R. H. Paul, emptied two barrels at the robbers, and at the same time the driver fell forward and down between the wheelers, supposed to be killed.

See moreSee less

The horses jumped into a dead run on the first fire, the reins falling from the driver's hands, and ran nearly a mile before they could be stopped. This saved the stage from robbery, and saved Wells, Fargo & Co.'s treasure. Paul brought the stage on to Benson, with the wounded man, who will undoubtedly die. It is not known whether any of the robbers are shot or not. Paul starts at once for the scene of the robbery. There were eight or nine passengers on the stage, but none others were injured. Great praise is due to Paul for his coolness and bravery in saving the stage and passengers. The driver was found in the middle of the road dead.

See the clipping

‘The cowboys’

A California paper explains the new word in the Arizona news: the cowboys are ‘becoming famous, or infamous,’ like the desperadoes of the Plains before the railroad, and ‘In the end it will come to a matter of Winchester and Henry rifles, and the cowboys will have to succumb.’

Sacramento Daily Record-Union · Sacramento, Calif.

Sacramento Daily Record-Union · 1 April 1881 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

THE COWBOYS. The cowboys of Arizona are becoming famous, or infamous. Scarcely a day passes without its budget of news in which these wild, nomadic persons figure centrally. They seem to occupy much the same social and general position that was held by the desperadoes who infested the Plains before the Pacific Railroad was built, and who were accustomed occasionally to clean out stage stations and frontier villages. The exploits of the cowboys also remind one of the "flush" times of Boise City and Aurora, when the cheerful crack of the pistol was heard all day and night, and nobody's life was worth half an hour's purchase.

See moreSee less

It is evident that so extremely energetic and eccentric a class as these cowboys will have to be handled firmly. We fear that there is but one way of dealing with them. They are at feud with civilization, and civilization cannot suffer itself to be stopped by them or any other barbarians. In the end it will come to a matter of Winchester and Henry rifles, and the cowboys will have to succumb.

See the clipping

Curly Bill shot by one of his own

A Wisconsin paper passes on the Arizona news: Curly Bill, who ‘killed Marshal White, of Tombstone,’ and made a Charleston clergyman ‘dance before the congregation,’ has been shot and mortally wounded by one of his comrades. He recovered: the next spring the papers have him at the head of nine cowboys against the Earp party, and report him dead again.

The Superior Times · Superior, Wis. · and 2 other papers

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Superior Times · 28 May 1881 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

TRAGICAL TALES

Curly Bill, the Texas cow boy who killed Marshal White, of Tombstone, and recently captured a church at Charleston, with his gang, and made the clergyman dance before the congregation, and raided several towns in the vicinity at different times, was shot and mortally wounded at Galeyville, on the 19th, by Jim Wallace, one of his comrades. Wallace was released on the ground of self-defense.

See the clipping

$175,000 a month

Quoting the Tombstone Epitaph, a Dallas paper tots up what the silver is worth: the Contention, the Tombstone and the Grand Central together pay dividends that make ‘the dividends of Tombstone $175,000 per month.’

The Dallas Daily Herald · Dallas, Tex.

The Dallas Daily Herald · 30 September 1881 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

WHAT CONSTITUTES A MINE. Sensible Advice to Mineral Hunters and Investors. Tombstone (Arizona) Epitaph. This is a question seemingly easy to answer and one upon which there ought to be no diversity of opinion. Notwithstanding the apparant easy solution of the question there is diversity of opinion among those engaged in mining and probably but few would be found to agree were they called upon to examine and report upon the thousands of prospects by courtesy denominated mines. The discovery of a lode or deposit that shows rich ore, we think all will agree, does not constitute a mine.

See moreSee less

They are but the foundation or groundwork of a mine. The work following upon the discovery determines the fact of whether there is that abundance of paying ore to make the mine, or whether the discovery is to remain a prospect. The fact of there being some rich ore in pockets or strata, is not the point that the owners are working to est[abl]ish. There are rather the leaders to the o[b]ject of the search. The paramount object [in] mining operations is to find large bodies of ore that can be easily mined and milled, yielding a moderate profit over and above the cost of extraction and reduction. Such bodies of ore, by their size, allow of extensive operations, and by the quantity handled give large monthly profits to the owners. We see the above statement verified in the gold mines of the Black Hills, that on an average give a gross yield of from $6 to $8 per ton. Notwithstanding this apparently low yield, by the large quantities handled they are among the best properties in the United States. In California there are notable examples. Take the Idaho, of Grass Valley, that has paid $3,024,000 in 145 consecutive monthly dividends from ore that on the whole, has not probably paid over $15 or $18 per ton. Here, again, quantity and ease of mining and milling have been the chief factors in constituting it a mine and not a prospect. The Keystone, of Amador county, California, is another instance. From ore that averages but $10 there arises a net profit monthly of at least $15,000. Changing from gold to silver, we have the celebrated Eureka mines of Nevada the ores of which run about $56 per ton exclusive of the lead. The value of a ton of crude bollion as it comes from the furnaces is given as $249 23 and the cost to manufacture $207 62 per ton. Here it is the quantity that again saves the mines and makes them among the most profitable investments of the day. We will now come to our own mines at Tombstone and see how the case stands. Take Western (Contention) for instance and we think no man will say it is not a great mine The average value of the ore is not largely in advance of the Eureka mines judging by the amount crushed monthly and the bullion output. However this may be, the large body of ore exposed in the vein, and the ease and cheapness with which it is extracted and reduced the profits are largely enhanced over those of the Eureka or California mines. With 25 stamps the bullion output exceeds $130,000 per month from which the owners are enabled to pay dividends of $75,000 per month with a supplimentary dividend about New Yeras's of a like amount, or a total for the year of $975,000. In addition to the Western ther is a Tombstone and Grand Central with massive bodies of ore and a monthly output of bullion from which they pay dividends of $50,000 each to their shareholders. This mak[e]s the dividends of Tombstone $175,000 p[e]r month. In addition to these we have the Vizina a large and steady bullion producer, and the Girard with its 2,000 tons of ore on the dump, awaiting the completion of the mill, ground for which was broken yesterday, and which is to be complete by the 1st day of December; the Ingersoll with its 1,500 tons on the dump, and $1,000,000 worth in sight in the mine: Flora Morrison, Sulphuret and Stonewall, all showing large bodies of ore. It is safe to say that the aforementioned may be classed as mines. In other parts of the territory we may mention the Copper Queen, Total Wreck, Silver King and Tip Top. Outside of these are large numbers of prospect rapidly developing into mines that at no distant day will make Arizona the leading producer of silver and copper in the world. From the foregoing it will be seen that it is more in the quantity of ore than in quality that constitutes a mine, i. e., when the ore is sufficiently enriched to yield a margin over and above cost of extraction and reduction.

See the clipping

About these pages

Every clipping here was printed in an American newspaper at the time. The text on each card was read from the page by machine and lightly repaired; where it disagrees with the clipping, the clipping is right. Where the scan of an old page was too damaged to read, the text was transcribed again from the page image and is marked so; letters in [square brackets] were supplied where the printing itself is damaged, and the paper’s own misspellings are kept. The dates, papers, headlines and text are the papers’. The notes on why each article matters, and the one-line summaries, are ours.