‘Not in a fight’: Earp on Morgan’s murder
Deposed in a Boston will case, Earp, who ‘arrested pretty nearly every man that done any killing there,’ counts Tombstone’s killings on his fingers, and of his murdered brother says: ‘Not in a fight. He was assassinated—shot through the window.’
Douglas Daily Dispatch · Douglas, Ariz. · and 1 other paper
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
Douglas Daily Dispatch · 10 December 1926 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
TOMBSTONE IS DEFENDED BY AN OLD TIMER
BOSTON, Dec. 9.—(AP)—The good name of Tombstone, Ariz., was defended in a deposition read in Suffolk probate court today by the man who "arrested pretty nearly every man that done any killing there."
See moreSee less
The deponent was Myatt S. Earp of Los Angeles, deputy sheriff and United States marshal at Tombstone during the 80s, and his testimony was introduced in support of the contention of Mrs. Carlotta Cockburn of San Gabriel, Calif., that she was a niece of the late Lotta Crabtree and entitled to a share in the former actress' $4,000,000 estate.
Looking back on the days when he enforced law on the frontier, Earp declared that witnesses who have described Tombstone as a rough town were all wrong, and that "in its wildest days it wasn't half as bad as Los Angeles." In fact, he asserted he could count all the killings on his fingers.
"The first man killed was Mike Killeen," he began. "Then City Marshal White. He was killed by Curly Bill. I arrested him and took him to Tucson and put him in jail. Then the next man was killed by a man named Bradshaw. He killed his partner, McIntyre. Bradshaw had bought a kind of funny looking shirt, a red striped shirt, and he went out in the street, and everybody was making fun of it and saying, 'Where did you get that shirt,' and he got hot over it, and he says, 'The next man that kids about that shirt I am going to kill.'
"The next man he met was his partner, and of course he said to Bradshaw, 'Where did you get that shirt?' and Bradshaw jerked out his gun and killed him. That's three. The next man killed was Storms, and he was killed by Rufe Short. That is four, and that's all, except the Clanton-McLowry affair."
Earp said he remembered Jack Crabtree, but did not know that he was related to Lotta, the actress. He knew that Crabtree had a child, but (Continued on Page Eight)
Tombstone is Defended by an Old Timer
(Continued From Page One)
wasn't sure whether it was a boy or a girl.
Earp denied that "Doc" Halliday was a notorious character, "outside of this other faction trying to make him notorious," although "of course, he killed a man or two before he went there." There was another little fuss in which "Doc" wounded a man named Joyce and the latter's partner, Earp recalled, and then there was a fight in which Billy Clanton and two of the McLowry boys were killed and two of Earp's brothers and "Doc" were wounded.
"Wasn't one of your brothers killed?" Earp was asked.
"Not in a fight. He was assassinated—shot through the window."
A deposition by O. Gibson, mayor of Tombstone in 1925, was offered to explain common law marriage in Arizona, but was excluded on the ground that the court would take judicial notice of the laws of Arizona and that lawyers could file briefs on the question. Such parts of the deposition as referred to matters of fact were admitted. Gibson testified that assessors' records showed that Mary A. Crabtree, presumably Lotta's mother, was assessed for 14 lots of real estate in Tombstone in 1881.