As the Papers Told It

Wyatt Earp · As the Papers Told It

Act Three

Thirty Shots in a Minute

October – December 1881

On the afternoon of 26 October 1881 the Earp brothers and Doc Holliday walk down Fremont street to disarm the Clantons and McLaurys, and about thirty shots later three men are dead. The first reports get names and wounds wrong; the papers agree only that it was over in under a minute. A justice hears the case, behind closed doors at first, and on its twenty-second day discharges them. Then the shooting starts again: the mayor’s stage is fired on, and in December Virgil Earp is cut down by shotguns in the street.

The street fight: the first report

Within hours the wire carries it from Tombstone: the Earp brothers and Holliday met four cowboys, ‘About thirty shots were fired rapidly,’ and two McLaurys and Bill Clanton lay dying. It names a ‘Jim’ McLaury and puts Ike Clanton in jail with a slight wound, and ‘Morgan Earp, after being wounded and fallen, struggled to his feet and continued the fight until he had emptied his revolver.’

Sacramento Daily Record-Union · Sacramento, Calif.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

Sacramento Daily Record-Union · 27 October 1881 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

ARIZONA.

Cowboys in Tombstone—Desperate Shooting Affray.

See moreSee less

TOMBSTONE, October 26th.—A sanguinary shooting affray occurred on Fremont street this afternoon. Four cowboys had been in town a few days past drinking heavily, and making themselves generally obnoxious by their boisterous conduct. This morning City Marshal V. W. Earp arrested one for disorderly conduct, and he was fined $25 and disarmed in the Justice's Court. He left swearing vengeance on the Sheriff and Marshal Earp and his brother. Morgan tried to induce them to leave town, but they were thirsting for gore and refused to be pacified. About 3 P. M. the Earp brothers and J. H. Halliday met the four, who drew upon them at once, when a lively fire commenced from the cowboys against the three citizens. About thirty shots were fired rapidly, and when the smoke of battle cleared away it was found that Jim and Frank McLoury were gasping in the agonies of death. Bill Clanton was mortally wounded and died shortly after. Morgan Earp was wounded in the shoulder. V. W. Earp received a flesh wound in the calf of the leg. Halliday escaped unhurt, but with several bullet holes in his clothing. The streets were immediately filled with resolute citizens, many of whom were armed with rifles and pistols. There was great excitement, but no further trouble is anticipated. Ike Clanton, of the cowboys, escaped with a slight wound, and is now in jail. The Sheriff's posse is now under arms. Morgan Earp, after being wounded and fallen, struggled to his feet and continued the fight until he had emptied his revolver. His wound is not thought to be serious. The citizens are determined to put down the riotous element at all hazards.

See the clipping

‘Boys, throw up your hands’

The fullest early account: the marshal calls out ‘Boys, throw up your hands; I want you to give up your shooters,’ Frank McLaury reaches for his pistol, Wyatt shoots him, and ‘the fight was over in less than a minute.’ It adds a rumour that ‘several thousand dollars were found on the bodies.’

Eureka Daily Sentinel · Eureka, Nev.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 3 days later. CorrectionThis set right 2 earlier articles: Arizona Weekly Enterprise, 29 October 1881, The Silver State, 29 October 1881.

Wrong

Eureka Daily Sentinel · 30 October 1881 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

THIRTY SHOTS IN A MINUTE.

COWBOYS KILLED.

The Liveliest Street Fight of the Season—Tombstone Officials Demonstrate That They Are Made of Good Stuff.

See moreSee less

The liveliest street battle that ever occurred in Tombstone took place last Thursday, resulting in the death of three persons and the wounding of two others, one probably fatally. For some time past several cowboys have been in town, and the fight was between City Marshal Virgil Earp, his two brothers, Morgan and Wyatt Earp, and Doc. Holliday on one side, and Ike and Billy Clanton and Frank and Tom McLowery on the other. The Clanton and McLowery brothers are known as cowboys, and Ike has been in town for the past week drinking pretty freely, and was arrested this morning for carrying concealed weapons, he having appeared on the street with a Winchester rifle and a six-shooter on. After paying his fine he is reported to have made threats against Marshal Earp and his brothers, and it is known that bad blood has existed between them for some time.

About 2:30 o'clock the Marshal requested his brothers, Morgan and Wyatt, and Doc. Holliday to accompany him to aid in disarming the cowboys, as trouble was feared in the evening. They started down towards the O. K. Corral on Fremont street, and a few doors below the Nugget office saw the two Clanton and McLowery brothers talking to Sheriff Behan, who had requested them to disarm. The Marshal called out, "Boys, throw up your hands; I want you to give up your shooters."

THIRTY SHOTS IN A MINUTE.

At this Frank McLowery attempted to draw his pistol, when Wyatt Earp immediately shot him, the ball entering just about the waist. Doc. Holliday then let go at Tom McLowery with a shotgun, filling him full of buckshot under the right arm. Billy Clanton then blazed away at Marshal Earp, and Ike Clanton, who it is claimed was unarmed, started and ran off through the corral to Allen street. The firing then became general, and some 30 shots were fired, all in such rapid succession that the fight was over in less than a minute. When the smoke had cleared away it was found that Frank McLowery had been killed outright, with one ball through the intestines, one in the left breast and one in the right temple, the latter two wounds being received at the same instant. Tom McLowery lay dead around the corner of Third street, a few feet from Fremont, the load of buckshot fired by Holliday killing him almost instantly. Billy Clanton lay on the street with one shot in the wrist and another in the right side, near the waist, and the third in the left nipple. He was taken into a house and lived about half an hour in great agony.

INJURIES OF THE WOUNDED.

Morgan Earp was shot through both shoulders, the ball grazing the skin. Marshal Earp was shot through the fleshy part of the right leg. Wyatt Earp and Dock Holliday escaped unhurt. The shooting created great excitement, and the street was immediately filled with people. Ike Clanton was captured and taken to jail, where he now remains. The jail is guarded by a number of citizens to prevent lynching, of which there is no apparent danger. The three dead bodies were removed to the Morgue, where they now lie. It is reported that several thousand dollars were found on the bodies. The feeling of the better class of citizens is that the Marshal and his posse acted solely in the right in attempting to disarm the cowboys, and that it was a case of kill or get killed. Clanton's father was killed with four others a few months ago in New Mexico by the Mexicans while driving a band of cattle up to this market. The town is quiet and the authorities are fully able to maintain order.

See the clipping

A hearing behind closed doors

The Earps’ examination goes on behind closed doors, and the paper traces the whole trouble to ‘the attempted stage robbery and the killing of Budd Philpot last March.’ Marshal Earp wires the army for cavalry; Sheriff Behan wires that all is ‘quiet there.’

Eureka Daily Sentinel · Eureka, Nev. · and 1 other paper

Eureka Daily Sentinel · 3 November 1881 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

ARIZONA.

A Trial with Closed Doors in Tombstone—The Town Alarmed About the Cowboys—Railroad Surveys, Etc.

See moreSee less

TOMBSTONE, Nov. 2.—The examination of Morgan Earp, Doc Holiday et al., under arrest for killing the Lowery brothers and Clinton, on Wednesday last, is being held with closed doors under Justice Spicer, who made an order that any attorney who gave out information of the testimony would be held in contempt of court, therefore no information is to be had. This is made necessary from the fact that great excitement exists here. It is hoped no further trouble will occur. The friends of the deceased are determined to prosecute the case to the bitter end in the courts, and have retained in addition to Littleton Price and the District Attorney, the following attorneys: Goodrich & Goodrich, Colly & Smith, Smith, Earl, Campbell, Robinson and J. M. Murphy. For the defense appear Hon. Tom. Fitch, Howard & Street and J. J. Dram. The evidence is being reported by E. J. Risely, Territorial Reporter for this district. It will be a long and tedious case, and if it goes to the District Court a change of venue will have to be taken and the case tried elsewhere, as so much feeling is manifested on both sides here. The origin of the trouble dates back to the attempted stage robbery and the killing of Budd Philpot last March. It is said the lives of the Earps, Marshal Williams, Wells, Fargo & Co.'s agent and others who have been active after the stage robbers at different times have all been threatened.

The survey of the Atchison, Topeka & Santa Fe road from Benson is completed one mile from town. The locating engineers go to Sulphur Springs to begin the location from the east towards Tombstone. The main line from Deming comes through this place.

A Tucson dispatch of Nov. 2 says trouble is likely to arise from the recent shooting of the cowboys by Marshal Earp and posse at Tombstone. Earp to-day telegraphed General Wilcox to send a company of cavalry to protect the town from cowboys. Wilcox referred the matter to Acting Governor Gasper, and ordered a company of cavalry at Huachuca to be ready to march to Tombstone if required. Sheriff Behan telegraphs everything quiet there. The trial of the Marshal is going on with closed doors. A large amount of money has been raised to assist the prosecution by the friends of the cowboys.

See the clipping

Town against county

A Yuma paper borrows another paper’s one-sentence version of the feud: ‘The Earp faction have been running Tombstone and Johnny Behan’s party run the county of Cachise.’ That, it says, is the ‘kernal of the Earp-Clanton difficulty.’ No paper put it more plainly.

The Arizona Sentinel · Arizona City Yuma, Ariz.

The Arizona Sentinel · 12 November 1881 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

The kernal of the Earp-Clanton difficulty simmers itself down to this: The Earp faction have been running Tombstone and Johnny Behan's party run the county of Cachise. The is a clash between these two factions—hence the fight.—Demo

See the clipping

The Earps discharged

After twenty-two days Justice Spicer rules that the Earps and Holliday were ‘legally acting in their capacity as police officers’ and that the dead men ‘had threatened the lives of the Earps that day.’ He discharges them all.

Daily Los Angeles Herald · Los Angeles, Calif.

Daily Los Angeles Herald · 1 December 1881 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

The Earp Brothers Discharged.

TOMBSTONE, Nov. 30th.—Yesterday closed the celebrated Earp-Holliday examination, being the twenty-second day. The case was submitted without argument. Judge Spicer took the case under advisement until to-day; when, at 2 o'clock P. M., he rendered a very exhaustive decision in writing, reviewing all the facts in the case. The testimony was voluminous, the review of which entailed great labor. He held that the defendants were legally acting in their capacity as police officers, and upon complaints duly made by several people. The evidence showed that the deceased had threatened the lives of the Earps that day. Therefore the defendants were justified in their acts. He discharged all the defendants.

See moreSee less

The weather is warm and pleasant, resembling Indian Summer in New England. The mines are all doing well, the hotels are full and the stages come in loaded every day.

See the clipping

Dodge City hears the verdict

Wyatt Earp’s old town prints the heart of the decision: the killings were ‘a necessary act, done in the discharge of an official duty.’

Dodge City Times · Dodge City, Kan.

Dodge City Times · 8 December 1881 · page 5 · transcribed from the page image

Wyatt Earp, fermerly a city marshal in this city, was recently under trial before a magistrate in Tombstone, Arizona, charged with hom cide. Great interest was taken in trial which lasted four weeks. From the voluminous testimony taken the Justice makes a long review of the case and discharges the defendant. The following is an extract from his decision: "In view of all the facts and circumstances of the case; considering the threats made, the character and position of the parties, and the tragical results accomplished, in manner and form as they were, with all surrounding influences bearing upon the res gestæ of the affair, I cannot resist the conclusion that the defendants were fully justified in committing these homicides; that it was a necessary act, done in the discharge of an official duty."

See the clipping

The mayor’s stage is fired on

Armed men fire on Mayor John Clum’s stage on the road to Tucson, wounding the driver and killing a horse; nothing is taken. Clum, the Earps, Holliday, Judge Spicer and others have all been threatened since ‘the recent cowboy tragedy.’

The Silver State · Unionville, Nev. · and 1 other paper

The Silver State · 17 December 1881 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

An unsuccessful attempt was made to assassinate John P. Clum, Mayor of Tombstone, last Wednesday night. A band of armed men fired on him while he was on the stage en route to Tucson. The driver was wounded and one of the horses killed. Mr. Clum escaped without injury. There was no attempt to rob the stage. The assault is supposed to be an outgrowth of the recent cowboy tragedy, since which threats have been made against the life of Clum, the Earp brothers and Holiday (who were engaged in the tragedy), Judge Spicer, City Marshal Williams and others. Parties are now in pursuit of the assailants.

See the clipping

Virgil Earp shot down

Three men with shotguns in an unfinished building fire five times at Deputy U.S. Marshal Earp as he crosses the street at night; the surgeons take bone from his arm and give him ‘four chances in five’ of dying. Wyatt Earp, Spicer, Williams and others are ‘in momentary danger of assassination.’

Sacramento Daily Record-Union · Sacramento, Calif.

Sacramento Daily Record-Union · 30 December 1881 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

ARIZONA.

Attempted Assassination.

See moreSee less

TOMBSTONE, December 29th.—Last night, about half-past 11, as United States Deputy Marshal Earp was crossing Fifth street, between the Oriental saloon and the Eagle Brewery, when in the middle of the street, he was fired upon with double-barreled shotguns, loaded with buckshot, by three men concealed in an unfinished building diagonally across on Allen street. Five shots were fired in rapid succession. Earp was wounded in the left arm just above the elbow, producing a longitudinal fracture of the bone. One shot struck him above the groin, coming out near the spine. The wounds are very dangerous, and possibly mortal. The men ran through the rear of the building, and escaped in the darkness back of the Vizina hoisting works. Nineteen shots struck the side of the Eagle Brewery, three going through the window, one shot passing about a foot over the men's heads who were standing by a faro table. Long ago the cowboy gang threatened the lives of Mayor Clum, Judge Spicer, Marshall Williams, agent of Wells, Fargo & Co., Earp and Holliday, and this is an attempt to carry the threats into execution. Intense feeling exists in the minds of all the better class of citizens at this dastardly attempt at assassination.

[SECOND DISPATCH.]

TOMBSTONE, December 29th.—The condition of United States Deputy Marshal Earp is critical. The surgeons this afternoon took out the fractured bone in the arm above the elbow. The shot penetrating the back, above the left hip, passed through the body and lodged near a point of the hip bone above the groin. The doctor says there are four chances in five that he will die. The local authorities are doing nothing to capture the assassins, so far as known. A telegram has been sent to United States Marshal Dake, at Prescott, of the state of affairs here. Judge Spicer, Marshall Williams, Wyatt, Earp, Rickabaugh and others are in momentary danger of assassination.

See the clipping

← Back to Act Two: The Earps in Tombstone