The Epitaph mocks editor Purdy for contradicting himself about lawlessness in Cochise County, then reprints a Yuma Free Press item from January reporting Virgil Earp's wounding by assassins, Wyatt Earp's appointment as deputy U.S. marshal, and the anti-Earp ticket's election victory. The reprinted piece also recounts the October gunfight, claiming Wyatt's faction killed several men who had their hands up in surrender, though a magistrate ruled the killings justifiable.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
The Tombstone Epitaph · 1 May 1882 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
THE HOODLUM GOSPEL ACCORDING TO PURDY
Purdy speak for himself, and we ask that his utterances be given a careful perusal. The following is from the Yuma Free Press of January 7th: Three important items of news have reached this office from Tombstone. Virgil Earp has been dangerously wounded at the hands of assassins, his brother Wyatt Earp has been appointed deputy United States marshal in his stead, and the "people's ticket" has proven victorious at the city election. The latter was constituted as a rebuke to the Earp crowd, and its success determines the fact that the majority of the
This report narrates the Earp vendetta from its start four months earlier through a street gunfight in Tombstone, the later assassination of Morgan Earp during a card game, and the subsequent killing of suspect William Stilwell at the Tucson train station. It frames the events as an escalating cycle of frontier violence and revenge.
Daily Republican · 5 May 1882 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
AN ARIZONA VENDETTA. A NEW TALE OF WONDER—HOW THEY CONDUCT THEMSELVES.
engaged in the encounter.
The Earp vendetta which is attaining such bloody prominence at present begun four months ago. Morgan Earp, the city marshal of Tombstone, was called upon to interfere with the reckless and lawless amusement of a gang of cowboys, composed of the Clanton and Lowery brothers and some of their friends. The cowboys hungered for the fray and welcomed it when it came; Earp being backed by his two brothers and two other men. The sides were equal. Right in the main street of Tombstone the short triggered revolvers cracked like a blazing pack of firecrackers. Wounded men lay on the ground and shot till their breath left them. Everybody was wounded, and two of the Lowery gang were killed. Of the Earp crowd no one, fortunately, was fatally injured. After the fray the wounded were cared for, the dead buried, and Tombstone resumed the ordinary tenor of its way, pleasantly stirred by the little mortuary breeze.
See moreSee less
But the Clanton gang swore vengeance. Four months passed and though they laid for their man, his vigilance and coolness baffled them. However, a card party in a Tombstone saloon was interrupted. The interruption came in the shape of two pistol balls through the window, and Morgan Earp rolled out of his chair dead. His assassins disappeared unseen, and his brothers took charge of the body. They took him to Tucson the next day.
While the funeral party were at the station, one of the Clantons and William Stillwell, a member of their gang were observed a short distance away, They were suspected by the Earps of having committed the murder. Late that afternoon six rifle shots were heard down the railroad track. The next morning the dead body of Stillwell was found, riddled with bullets. And Stillwell was reputed to be one of the bravest desperadoes and quickest shots in all Arizona.
The two Earps and their four friends went back to Tombstone A coroner's jury branded them as the murders of Stillwell. They paid no attention to it beyond intimating to the Sheriff that they knew their own business best and did not propose to be interfered with. Heavily armed, they carelessly and gracefully rode out of the town, toward Denson. Rumor said they were hunting for Ike Clanton. Everybody knew what Clanton's fate would be if they found him. Then the sheriff and a
A brief dispatch from Tombstone states that the Epitaph newspaper has received information that Wyatt Earp has been killed, but no further details are available. The report is unconfirmed and lacks any specifics about the circumstances.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 7 days later.
Wrong
Eureka Daily Sentinel · 10 May 1882 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
Wyatt Earp Killed. TOMBSTONE, May 9.—The Epitaph has information of the killing of Wyatt Earp, but no details.
A roundup of miscellaneous regional news items includes a one-line mention that the Tombstone Epitaph has reported the killing of Wyatt Earp, though no details are given. The item sits amid unrelated local news about mining, fishing, and crime from across Nevada.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 6 days later.
Wrong
The Silver State · 11 May 1882 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
SAGEBRUSH SCREENINGS.
The Tombstone Epitaph has information of the killing of Wyatt Earp, but has no details.
See moreSee less
John S. Mayhugh has been confirmed as Indian Agent for the Western
The Epitaph rebuts a Mr. Jackson's letter questioning the presidential proclamation and alleging vandalism in Cochise County, challenging him to specify who the 'vandals' are. The editorial accuses Jackson of political posturing and insists the paper will not take sides in the ongoing Earp-cowboy feud.
The Tombstone Epitaph · 13 May 1882 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
Epitaph sympathizes with the vandals? If Mr. Jackson will kindly inform us who these vandals are and where they live we will gladly answer his question. On his own confession he traveled, during the last twenty days, over four hundred miles of country, presumably hunting these vandals, and yet found nothing but grass and timber—not even a cowboy or an Earp. And yet Mr. Jackson is a gentleman who has always undoubtedly endeavored to do his duty. It seems to us that if these insurrectionary vandals are stampeding everybody out of the country
The Tombstone Epitaph editorializes that it will not take sides in the ongoing Earp-cowboy conflict, condemning lawbreakers on both sides while insisting it supports only law and order. A related item reports that negative press about Arizona's violence and Indian troubles has scared off a Chicago investor, which the paper calls exaggerated and harmful to the territory's reputation.
The Tombstone Epitaph · 13 May 1882 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
Earps, cowboys and county officials. Law-breakers are nothing but criminals, no matter what aroma you surround their conduct with. The county officials are county officials and nothing else. They represent no party, because they are only appointees, and we shall take no interest in them unless they are nominated by the Democratic party. The man who sustains the Earps is an accessory after the fact; the man who supports the lawless element of the cowboy fraternity condones crime. The Epitaph supports law and order, and he who takes issue with it upon that proposition deserves neither credence nor respect.
The item relays an unconfirmed rumor from the Tombstone Nugget that Wyatt Earp has likely been killed, after a falling out with Doc Holliday in Albuquerque. It speculates he was tracked down and killed by pursuers near Hooker's ranch.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Daily Los Angeles Herald · 13 May 1882 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.
Probably Killed.
It is probable that the rumor of the death of Wyatt Earp is true. It appears that while the Earp party were in Albuquerque Doc Holliday became intoxicated and indiscreet in his remarks, which offended Wyatt and caused the party to break up. Holliday went with Tipton, and it is said was with him when he was killed. Wyatt returned to Hooker's; of this there is no question, as a citizen of this place saw and talked with him there last week, and it was in that vicinity that he is reported to have been killed, presumably by parties who have been following him since he left this place.—Tombstone Nugget.
The Weekly Citizen comments on political and law-and-order issues in Cochise County, criticizing the Tombstone Star for suggesting that lawlessness ended with the Earp party's flight from the Territory. The piece argues the Earps' activities were only one small part of a larger pattern of lawlessness in the region.
Arizona Weekly Citizen · 14 May 1882 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
THE Star endeavors to create the impression that the only instance of lawlessness which has occurred in Cochise county was the exploit of the Earp party and their flight from the Territory and that with their flight all occasion for apprehension of disorder and violence ceased. The operations of the Earps have formed only one small chapter in the history of crime in Cochise county in support of which we refer the editor to his back files, particularly to the issue of March 30th of this year. The Sheriff led in his pursuit of the Earp crowd a band of desperadoes who would grace the train of a bandit chief, and the only man in Cochise county who had the nerve to properly characterize the party was H. C. Hooker, of the Sierra Bonita ranch. While that Sheriff's posse continues to pretend to administer law, there is not and there cannot be any safety either for life or property in Cochise county. The Nugget published Sheriff Behan's apology for the lawless character of that posse.
THE statements sent by the Tombstone associated press agent and the papers of that city to the effect that no lawlessness exists in Cochise county is simply presuming upon the ignorance of a public who have been treated for months to an almost daily dose of horrors from the same source. This is the way it strikes the San Francisco Exchange:
See moreSee less
"It is gratifying to know at last that Cochise county is 'in as peaceful a state as any section of the country.' What has become of all the cowboys there? Are they chasing up the Earps or out fighting Indians? And where are those other gentlemen who shoot holes through people's hats, knock cigars out of their mouths, and cut telegraph wires with bullets? And how about the stables and corrals of the honest yeomanry of Cochise county - are they not still locked at night? And it used to be a pleasant custom in Cochise county to enter a ball room, strip the ladies stark, and, with revolvers pointed at their heads, make them dance. It is pleasant to hear that these pastimes no longer exist in Cochise county, but we believe they do, all the same."
A Tucson gentleman reports meeting Virgil Earp in Colton, who claimed his brothers and Doc Holliday would soon return and surrender to Pima county authorities to stand trial in Tucson. This refers to the pending charges against Wyatt Earp and Holliday stemming from the vendetta killings.
The Sheriff of Arapahoe County, Colorado notified Sheriff Behan of Cochise County that Warren Earp, Wyatt Earp, and Doc Holliday had been arrested. Behan was to travel the next day to retrieve the prisoners, with an immediate trial considered likely.
Daily Los Angeles Herald · 17 May 1882 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
Major Tupper Congratulated—The Earps Arrested—Fire.
Tombstone, May 16.—Under instructions from the General of the Army, General Willcox, commanding the Department of Arizona, has officially congratulated Major Tupper on the result of his recent brilliant campaign.
See moreSee less
The Sheriff of Arrapahoe county, Colorado, has notified Sheriff Behan, of Cochise county, that Warren and Wyatt Earp and Doc Holladay have been arrested by him. Sheriff Behan will start to-morrow morning for the prisoners and the Court being in session an immediate trial is probable.
A fire this evening burned the block between Second and Third streets, on Toughnut. The buildings were mostly lodging houses and dwellings. Ten buildings were destroyed. Loss about $12,000.
A short news item reports that Warren and Wyatt Earp, along with Doc Holliday, have been arrested in Colorado and will be extradited to Arizona to stand trial. The item appears amid a list of miscellaneous national and international news briefs.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
Sacramento Daily Record-Union · 17 May 1882 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
General of the Army upon his work in the recent Indian campaign in Arizona and New Mexico.
Warren and Wyatt Earp and Doc Holliday have been arrested in Colorado, and will be taken to Arizona for trial.
See moreSee less
A fire at Tombstone, A. T., last night, destroyed ten buildings.
The May Musical Festival at Cincinnati was successfully opened last evening.
The remains of ex-Governor C. C. Washburne arrived at Chicago yesterday from Eureka Springs, Ark., en route to Milwaukee.
Upon the fourth page this morning will be found a portrait of George M. Chilcott, U. S. Senator from Colorado, together with the market report and several interesting news and other items.
A Tucson dispatch reports that the sheriff at Denver holds the Earp party, five men indicted there for the murder of Frank Stillwell, and that Sheriff Paul leaves for Denver with Governor Tritle’s requisition. It adds that Tipton, one of the party, met a violent death in New Mexico while attempting a robbery, and that Cochise county has been quiet since the Earps left.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 17 days later.
Wrong
Sacramento Daily Record-Union · 17 May 1882 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
Official Congratulation—The Earps Arrested—Fire.
The Capture of the Earps. Tucson, May 16th.—Sheriff Paul to day received a dispatch from the Sheriff at Denver, Col., that he had arrested and held in custody the Earp party, who are indicted in this county for the murder of Frank Stillwell. There are five men in the party. Tipton, one of the number, met a violent death in New Mexico two weeks ago, while attempting a robbery. Governor Tritle placed a requisition in the hands of Sheriff Paul, who leaves for Denver for the prisoners to-morrow morning. Perfect quiet has reigned in Cochise county since the Earp party left.
A dispatch from Tombstone, Arizona reports on General Wilcox's Indian campaign, followed by a telegram from the Arapahoe County, Colorado sheriff stating that Warren and Wyatt Earp along with Doc Holliday have been arrested there. The item is brief and appears amid other unrelated telegraphic news items.
Washingtoner Journal · 18 May 1882 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
zu Charlton, Jowa, vertheidigte am Sonntag in einer Predigt die Mörder des Lord Cavendish.
Die Indianer=Unruhen in Arizona.
See moreSee less
San Francisco, 17. Mai. Eine Tombstone, Ariz., Depesche sagt Auf Befehl des General Sherman hat General Wilcox auf offiziellem Wege dem Mayor Tupper zu dem Resultat seiner kürzlichen brillanten Indianercampagne gratulirt. — Der Sheriff von Arapahoe County, Col., telegraphirt, daß Warren und Wyatt Earp und Doc Holliday daselbst verhaftet wurden.
A dispatch reports that the Sheriff of Arapahoe County, Colorado, telegraphed that Warren and Wyatt Earp and Doc Holliday had been arrested there. The report states they would be taken back to Arizona for trial.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
New-York Tribune · 18 May 1882 · page 1
TELEGRAPHIC NOTES. a — THE EARP BROTHERS ARRESTED. Ax FRra~CISCO, May 17.— he Sheriff of Arapahoe County, Col, has telegraphed here that Warren amd Wyatt Earp and ‘boc. Houlday have been arrested there. Tho
The report describes Sheriff Behan's hostility toward the Earp faction and his use of cowboy deputies, prompting citizens to petition the Governor for federal intervention. It notes competing petitions—one for a new marshal's posse, another urging the Earps' recall—reflecting divided local opinion on who could restore order.
Dodge City Times · 18 May 1882 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.
THE ARIZONA TROUBLES. To the Editor of the Dodge City Times.
TOMBSTONE, Arizona, May 7, 1882.
See moreSee less
The singular and anomalous condition of the law, its makers, breakers, and manipulators, deserve I think a space in your columns, more especially as the leading actors, the Earps and Dock Holliday, are well known in your famous city. The feud undoubtedly originated from the fact that the McLowrey and Clanton party were not permitted "to run the town," while Earp was Marshal; this culminated in the shooting of McLowrey and Clanton by the Earps, then came the assassination of Morgan Earp through a window, and the shooting one dark night of Virgil Earp from a vacant building; this was followed by the killing of one Stilwell a known stage robber and supposed murderer of Morgan. The Sheriff now turned all his energies toward avenging the death of the stage robber, and though five or six assassination of citizens known to be friendly to the Earps followed, among them the son of Judge Peel, the Sheriff with 18 or 20 cow-boy deputies, has turned all his official power toward the extermination of the Earps. Judge Peel declares the Sheriff has never spoken to him about the murder of his son. This peculiar conduct of the Sheriff was more than the citizens could swallow and on their appeal the Governor has now appointed thirty men under United States Marshal Thay, if possible, to apprehend the murderers. Another petition is being quietly circulated requesting the Governor to re-call the Earps, as the citizens claim they were the only ones who dared cope with the cattle thieves and stage robbers. I find the feeling is universal among the law and order party, that the Earp party are the only ones that can restore order and security of life and property. The enmity of the Sheriff toward Wyatt Earp and his brothers is well known to be caused mainly by the latter's success in the arrest and cleaning out of the thieves and highwaymen who infested this appropriately named city. The charge that Holliday or the Earps were in league with such men as Ed. Burns or Off Wheeler, all parties here disclaim, as the former were in fact the parties who drove these thugs out of the Territory.
A telegram from the sheriff of Arapahoe County, Colorado, reports that Wyatt Earp and Doc Holliday have been arrested there. The dispatch states they will be returned for trial.
Daily Kennebec Journal · 18 May 1882 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
Major Tupper Congratulated for His Successful Campaign.
Tombstone, Arizona, May 17.
See moreSee less
Under instructions from the General of the army. Gen. Wilcox officially congratulated Major Tupper on his recent brilliant campaign against the hostiles.
The sheriff of Arapahoe county, Col., telegraphed here that Wyatt Earp and Doc Holloway had been arrested there. They will be brought back for trial.
A brief item states the sheriff of Arapahoe County, Colorado, telegraphed that Warren and Wyatt Earp and Doc Holliday had been arrested and would be returned for trial. The report is part of a roundup of short national news dispatches.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Las Vegas Daily Gazette · 18 May 1882 · page 1
Tapper Congratulated. San Francisco, May 17. A Tomb stone dispatch says that under instruc tions from the general ot tlie army, General WUlcox has oiiicialiy congratu lated Major Tupper on the result of his recent brilliant campaign against tlie hostiles. Tho sheriff of Arrapaho county, Col., has telegraphed here that Warren and Wyatt Earp and Doc Holliday have been arrested there. They will bo brought back for trial. Immigration Report,
The item states that the Earp brothers and Doc Holliday have been captured and will be tried for their crimes in Arizona. It frames this as a chance for Arizonans to prove their commitment to law and order.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
Eureka Daily Sentinel · 18 May 1882 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
THE EARP'S CAPTURE
Earp brothers and Holliday have been captured and they will be tried for their crimes in Arizona. This will afford a first-rate opportunity to the people of
The report states that the Sheriff of Arapahoe County, Colorado, arrested Warren and Wyatt Earp along with Doc Holliday, and notified Sheriff Behan of Cochise County, Arizona. It claims Behan will travel to retrieve the prisoners and that an immediate trial is probable since court is in session.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
Eureka Daily Sentinel · 18 May 1882 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
Arrest of the Earp Brothers and Doc Holliday. TOMBSTONE, May 17.—Under instructions from the General of the Army, General Wilcox, commanding the Department of Arizona, has officially congratulated Major Tupper on the result of his recent brilliant campaign. The Sheriff of Arrapahoe County, Colorado, has notified Sheriff Behan of Cochise County that Warren and Wyatt Earp and Doc Holliday have been arrested by him. Sheriff Behan will start to-morrow morning for the prisoners, and the Court being in session, an immediate trial is probable. George Hearst Announces Himself for Governor.
The item reports that the Earp brothers have been captured and that Cochise County Sheriff John H. Behan has gone after them with an extradition requisition from Governor Tritle. The writer expresses regret, suggesting enough bloodshed and money has already been spent pursuing them.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
The Weekly Arizona Miner · 19 May 1882 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
Tombstone on the 15th, were—Hon. A. H. Stebbins, Hon. W. K. Meade, M. A. Smith, R. H. Cavil, James Viznia and Samuel Purdy.
The report states that Warren and Wyatt Earp along with Doc Holliday, described as desperados who killed three cowboys in Tombstone in October 1881, have been captured in Arapahoe County, Colorado. It frames them as fugitives finally apprehended by authorities.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 15 days later.
Wrong
Der Deutsche Correspondent · 19 May 1882 · page 1
Die Brüder Warren und Wyatt Earp und T> o c. Hallidav, welche als Desperados bekannt sind und im Oktober 1881 in Tombstone, Arizona, im Kampfe mit „Cow BoyS" drei der Letzteren erschossen, sind in Arapahoe-Connty, Cal., eingefangen worden. In Des MoineS, Ja., ist eine Sub skription eröffnet worden, um eine Beloh nung auf „die Entdeckung der irischen Guts besitzer auszusetzen, welche die Meuchelmör der des Lord Eavendish und des Hrn. Burke gedungen." Die Subskription hat soweit tz 23 eingebracht. Fred. L. Jeckson und die Gattin eines Hrn.
A report circulating that Wyatt Earp had been killed in Arizona is declared incorrect. The item notes that his attorneys appear to know nothing about any such incident.
A brief item states that the Sheriff of Arapahoe County, Colorado, notified Sheriff Behan of Cochise County that Warren and Wyatt Earp and Doc Holliday had been arrested. This came amid ongoing efforts to extradite the Earp party following the Vendetta Ride.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 15 days later.
Wrong
The Silver State · 19 May 1882 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
on Sunday evening, fell and broke both the bones of her leg.
The Sheriff of Arraphoe county, Colorado, has notified Sheriff Behan, of Cochise county, that Warren and Wyatt Earp and Doc. Holliday have been arrested by him.
This editorial criticizes a rival newspaper, the Star, for editorializing in favor of the Earps' guilt and execution before their trial has occurred, violating the presumption of innocence. It notes the Earps are indicted for the murder of Frank Stilwell but states nothing beyond the bare fact of the killing is absolutely known.
Arizona Weekly Citizen · 21 May 1882 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
Earps stand indicted by the grand jury of Pima county for the crime of murder. Notwithstanding such indictment they are for the purposes of their trial clothed
This editorial criticizes the Tombstone Star for assuming the Earp party's guilt in the killing of Frank Stilwell and clamoring for their execution before trial. It argues this is improper journalism that could prejudice the jury pool and increase trial costs, while expressing confidence that Arizona justice will prevail fairly regardless.
Arizona Weekly Citizen · 21 May 1882 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
What then is to be said of a newspaper, aspiring to be a leading party organ, a newspaper published in the chief city of this Territory, published in a law-abiding and law enforcing community, which daily fills its editorial columns with paragraphs assuming the guilt, and clamoring for the execution of men whose trial is yet to be had? Beyond the bare fact that Frank Stilwell was shot and killed in this city last April and probably by the Earp party, nothing is absolutely known. If the Earps have any defence it will be the duty of their counsel to present it at the trial.
See moreSee less
If we knew of their defence it would be almost as improper for us to present it here and demand their discharge, as it is improper for the Star to assume their guilt and editorially clamor for a "necktie sociable." We conjecture that the editorials of the Star will greatly add to the cost and difficulty of a trial, for the Star is not without circulation, and among unthinking men pungent editorial paragraphs prejuding the case of the Earps will not be without influence. Doubtless a consumption of several weeks of time and several thousand dollars of county money will be the consequence of the efforts of the Star to make the hanging of Wyatt Earp a Democratic party measure. But we have faith enough in the ultimate fairness and good sense of the mass of the Arizona Democracy to believe that increased expense to the county will be the only result of the present course of the Star, and that the Earps will be
A brief notice states that the Sheriff of Arapahoe County, Colorado, has informed Sheriff Behan of Cochise County that Warren and Wyatt Earp and Doc Holliday have been arrested. The item appears amid a miscellany of unrelated local news snippets.
The Weekly Elko Independent · 21 May 1882 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
Cochise county, that Warren and Wyatt Earp and Doc. Holliday have been arrested by him.
The much and long needed improvement in the way of a new sidewalk in front of the Post office was completed
A Democrat-leaning letter, printed by the newspaper, argues that Tombstone's law-abiding citizens regard the Earps favorably despite their arrest for killing Frank Stilwell. It accuses Sheriff Behan of corruption and complicity with cowboys, suggesting the Earps' vendetta killings were justified revenge for Morgan Earp's murder.
The Arizona Sentinel · 27 May 1882 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
The thing desired found at last. Ask druggists for "Rough on Rats." It clears out rats, mice. roaches, flies, bed-bugs. 15 cent boxes.
A Democrat's Opinion of the Earps.
See moreSee less
As the Earps have been arrested and will be brought to this country and put upon trial for the murder of the noted desperado, Frank Stilwell, it may not be uninteresting to our readers to know how these so-called Republican outlaws are regarded by decent, law abiding people in Tomstone, regardless of politics. We are permitted to make ex-
Virgil Earp, one of the Earp brothers from Tombstone known for clashes with cowboys, arrived in San Francisco to receive surgical treatment for his left arm. He was shot in his last encounter with the cowboys, with about six inches of bone carried away.
Sacramento Daily Record-Union · 30 May 1882 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image
Virgil Earp, one of the Earp boys of Tombstone, A. T., who have recently come prominently before the public by reason of their contests with the cowboys, arrived in San Francisco last Thursday to receive